Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Maternity Leave Laws
Maternity Leave Laws
Maternity Leave Laws
© 2012 Business Management Daily, a division of Capitol Information Group, Inc. All rights reserved.
Substantial duplication of this report is prohibited. However, we encourage you to excerpt from this report as
long as you include a hyperlink back to www.businessmanagementdaily.com/MaternityLeaveLaws. The
hyperlink must be included on every usage of the report title. Alternatively, you may simply link to the
aforementioned page on our site. Any reproduction in print form requires advance permission by contacting
the publisher at (800) 543-2055 or customer@BusinessManagementDaily.com. Any violation is subject to
legal action.
This content is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information regarding the subject matter
covered. It is provided with the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering legal service. If
you require legal advice, please seek the services of an attorney.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Maternity Leave Laws
It’s important to know what you must do—and what you can’t do (or say)—under
federal anti-discrimination and leave laws. Plus, it’s vital to double-check state
maternity leave statutes, which may provide more liberal leave benefits for
pregnant women and new parents.
While no federal law requires you to provide paid maternity leave, most
employers must comply with the Pregnancy Discrimination Act (PDA) and the
FMLA. And even the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) may come into play
if pregnancy complications rise to the level of substantially limiting a major life
activity.
Here’s how best to comply with those laws, plus a sample maternity leave policy
you can adapt for your own organization.
The PDA prohibits discrimination against employees and applicants on the basis
of “pregnancy, childbirth and related medical conditions.” Any employer that’s
subject to Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (i.e., has 15 or more
employees) must comply with the PDA.
Under the law, you can’t deny a woman a job or a promotion merely because she’s
pregnant or has had an abortion. Nor can you fire her because of her condition or
force her to go on leave as long as she’s physically capable of performing her job.
In short, the law requires you to treat pregnant employees the same as other
employees on the basis of their ability or inability to work. That means you must
provide the same accommodations for an expectant worker that you do for any
employees unable to perform their regular duties. For example, if you provide
other work for an employee who can’t lift heavy boxes because of a bad back, you
must make similar arrangements for a pregnant employee.
In addition, the PDA requires you to provide sick leave and disability benefits on
the same basis or conditions that apply to other employees who are granted leave
for a temporary disability. Women who take maternity leave must be reinstated
under the same conditions as employees returning from disability leave.
At the same time, you’re allowed to apply the same requirements that you impose
on other employees. So, if you usually require employees to obtain a doctor’s note
before allowing them to take sick leave and collect benefits, you can impose the
same rule on pregnant employees.
Note: The Affordable Care Act—the health care reform law that was enacted in
2010—prohibits health insurance companies from denying insurance based on
pregnancy as a “pre-existing condition” (i.e., a condition that existed when the
insured worker’s coverage took effect). This is the case even if the woman had no
prior coverage before enrolling in her employer’s plan.
Singling out pregnant employees for any reason can lead to a lawsuit. If
supervisors make little jokes about pregnancy and childbirth, rein them in.
In one case, when a top performer received an award at a luncheon, she was taken
aback when her boss casually said, “You’re not gonna get pregnant now, are
you?” In fact, she did become pregnant the following month. Then her boss began
calling her “Prego” and soon was criticizing her work. She complained to HR, but
the company didn’t investigate.
She sued, and the court concluded calling her “Prego” and making comments
about pregnancy amounted to a hostile environment. (Zisumbo v. McLeodUSA
Telecom, 10th Cir.)
When an employee becomes pregnant, her employer must also consider her right
to take leave under the federal FMLA. Eligible employees can take up to 12 weeks
of unpaid, job-protected FMLA leave for the birth, adoption or foster care of a
child; caring for a child, spouse or parent with a serious health condition; or
convalescence after an employee’s own serious health condition.
To qualify for FMLA leave, an employee must have worked for the same
employer for at least 12 months (not necessarily continuously) and clocked at least
1,250 hours of service (slightly more than 24 hours per week) during the 12
months leading up to FMLA leave.
New parents—both mothers and fathers—can take FMLA leave any time in the
first 12 months after a child’s arrival. But employees must conclude their leave
before the 12-month period ends. Presumably, the idea is that if a working mother
takes her 12 weeks and then returns to work, the father can care for the child for
the next 12 weeks.
What if both parents work for the same company? They’re entitled to a combined
total of 12 weeks’ leave after the birth or adoption. In this case, each parent would
have the difference between 12 weeks and the amount of leave they took for the
child to use for any other legitimate FMLA reason in that year.
Example: Bob and Linda Jones have a child and work for the same employer. Bob
takes four weeks’ leave, and Linda takes eight weeks’ leave for their child’s
arrival. Bob still has eight weeks of leave to use in that year for any other FMLA
purpose; Linda has four remaining weeks.
Employees can also use their allowable FMLA leave if they suffer complications
during pregnancy or prenatal care that constitute a “serious health condition.” (The
FMLA defines a “serious health condition” as “an illness, injury, impairment or
any physical or mental condition that requires inpatient medical care or continuing
treatment by a health care provider.”)
Case in point: Cindy Hiemer said her chronic lung problem was exacerbated by
her pregnancy. She asked her employer, Anthem Insurance, for FMLA leave.
After she was fired for failing to call in sick, she sued the company, alleging
interference with her right to FMLA leave. But Anthem Insurance said her
absence wasn’t a serious health condition—Hiemer had testified she couldn’t
come to work because she felt nauseous and lightheaded. The company said
FMLA didn’t cover that sort of problem. The court disagreed, concluding that—
since FMLA regulations say anything related to pregnancy automatically qualifies
as a serious health condition—nausea and lightheadedness might be enough. The
case could proceed to trial, giving Hiemer the opportunity to convince a jury that
her absence was indeed pregnancy-related. (Hiemer v. Anthem Insurance, SD OH)
Advice: When it comes to a pregnancy, follow the safest path: Approve any
absences that are even remotely related to the pregnancy as FMLA-covered leave.
A normal pregnancy is not considered a disability under the ADA. The law defines
a disability as “a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or
more major life activities.”
Example: If a new mother is still unable to return to work after exhausting her 12
weeks of FMLA leave, you should evaluate her condition under the ADA to
determine whether additional time off is a reasonable accommodation for her.
(Also, be sure to check your state law because some states provide more than 12
weeks of parental leave.)
All employers that have 15 or more employees must comply with the ADA.
Several states mandate more generous maternity and family leave than the FMLA
(and some state laws apply to smaller employers). Here are a few examples:
Tennessee: Public and private employers that have eight or more workers
must grant female employees 16 weeks’ leave for childbirth.
Tip: You can find more information on state maternity leave laws, at the National
Conference on State Legislatures’ website: http://www.ncsl.org.
Not many employers choose to offer paid maternity leave aside from what’s
covered in their short-term disability policies. In a 2011 Employee Benefits
Research Report by the Society for Human Resource Management, about 70% of
HR professionals polled said their organizations offer short-term disability
benefits. But only 16% said they have a separate, paid maternity leave policy
(compared to 12% in 2006). Only 16% said they provide paid paternity leave
(versus 13% in 2006).
Here’s sample policy language that you may want to adapt to your
organization’s needs, subject to review by your attorney:
Paid leave may be substituted for unpaid maternity leave in accordance with [your
organization’s] paid-leave substitution provisions of [your organization’s] FMLA
policy.
Pregnant employees may continue to work until they are certified as unable to work by
their physician. At that point, pregnant employees are entitled to receive benefits
according to [your organization’s] short-term disability insurance plan.
When the employee returns to work, she is entitled to return to the same or equivalent
job with no loss of service or other rights or privileges. Should the employee not return
to work when released by her physician, she will be considered to have voluntarily
terminated her employment with [your organization].
It’s also up to each employer to decide how many weeks of paid leave to offer. For
example, one accounting firm with an 80-person staff provides new moms and
dads who are full-time employees 30 days’ paid leave and an additional 60 days’
unpaid leave upon the birth or adoption of a child. By contrast, a large
broadcasting corporation gives moms with one year of service eight weeks of paid
maternity leave on top of two weeks of paid pre-maternity leave, while new dads
get two weeks’ fully paid leave.
The SHRM survey showed that larger organizations are significantly more likely
to offer paid leave benefits than smaller organizations (whether they are for-profit
or non-profit). Also, government organizations are more likely to offer paid
benefits.
The EEOC has developed a series of questions and answers that clear up most of
the ambiguities in the Pregnancy Discrimination Act of 1978. The law requires
that companies (with 15 or more workers) cover maternity benefits if they cover
other health benefits.
A. That depends on the type of accommodation you usually make for other
employees who are unable to perform their usual jobs. For example, if you provide
other work for an employee who cannot do any lifting because of a bad back, you
must make similar arrangements for a pregnant employee.
Q. What procedures can you use to force a pregnant employee to take a leave
A. The EEOC says emphatically that you cannot single out pregnant employees
for special procedures to determine their ability to continue work. However, you
can apply the same requirements that you impose on other employees. Thus, if you
usually require employees to obtain a doctor’s note before allowing them to take
sick leave and collect benefits, you can impose the same rule on pregnant
employees.
Q. Can you bar a woman from returning to work for a predetermined period
after she gives birth?
A. No. You cannot have a rule, for instance, that a woman must wait a month
following childbirth before returning to work.
Q. If a pregnant employee goes on maternity leave because she’s ill and then
feels better and wants to return to work, can you require her to stay on leave
until she gives birth?
A. No. An employee can return to work anytime during her pregnancy as long as
she can perform her job.
Q. Must you keep the job of a pregnant employee open until she’s ready to
return to work following the birth of her child?
A. Generally, yes. Unless you are informed that she will not return to work, you
must keep the job open on the same basis as positions that are held open for
employees on sick leave or disability leave for other reasons.
Q. Are you required to hire a woman who, because of her pregnancy, can’t
perform only one of a job’s necessary functions?
A. You can’t refuse to hire a pregnant woman who is capable of performing most
major job functions. Furthermore, you can’t refuse to hire her just because co-
workers, clients or customers prefer that the job not be filled by a pregnant worker.
A. No, according to a decision by a U.S. Appeals Court. The decision singles out
two pitfalls for companies in regard to pregnant employees:
A. Yes. You must provide benefits for pregnancy if you offer benefits for other
medical conditions.
A. No. Single women who become pregnant also must be covered under your
disability plan.
Q. How long are you required to pay disability benefits for pregnancy if you
provide income maintenance benefits for other temporary disabilities?
A. Generally, you must provide benefits for as long as a pregnant woman is unable
to work for medical reasons; however, you may set certain time limits if you
impose them on other temporary disabilities.
Q. If you comply with a state law that requires disability insurance for a
specific period before and after childbirth, are you automatically in
compliance with the federal pregnancy law?
A. Not necessarily. Under federal law, you must treat employees who are
temporarily disabled due to pregnancy in the same manner as you would
employees temporarily disabled by other conditions.
A. Yes, but only if you have the same requirements for employees absent for other
types of disabilities or illnesses. You should state this in your FMLA policy.
A. No. You may not tack on an additional deductible or increase the usual
deductible for coverage of pregnancy, either as a condition for inclusion of
pregnancy costs or for the payment of costs when incurred.
A. Again, the rule is that expenses arising from pregnancy must be reimbursed on
the same basis as expenses for other medical conditions.
Abortion policies
Q. Can you refuse to hire, discharge or in any other way discriminate against
a woman for the sole reason that she’s had an abortion?
A. No. A woman who has had an abortion must be treated the same as other
employees.
A. Your plan must pay costs arising from complications resulting from an
abortion—but not necessarily for the abortion itself.
Q. Can you decide to have your insurance program cover abortion, even if
it’s not required?
A. The Pregnancy Discrimination Act specifically says that employers can provide
insurance for abortion, either directly or through a collective bargaining
agreement. However, employers are warned that if they do include abortion in
their health insurance plan, they must do so in the same manner as they cover
other medical conditions.
However, the debate surrounding the Affordable Care Act of 2010 revived the
debate over abortion coverage, which has led to many states passing new laws
limiting abortion coverage. You should check the law of your particular state for
limits on abortion coverage. By mid-2011, five states had passed laws banning
abortion coverage in the private insurance market (Idaho, Ky., Mo., N.D., Okla.).
In all, some 20 states now prohibit insurance plans for public and/or private
employees and/or private-sector individuals from covering abortion services.
You can find more information at the National Conference on State Legislatures’
website. Visit http://www.ncsl.org and search for “abortion insurance.”
Final tip: Keep in mind that a pregnancy discrimination claim can’t succeed if
there’s no evidence that the employer had knowledge of the pregnancy. (Prebilich-
Holland v. Gaylord, 6th Cir.)
Learn how to conduct positive, valuable assessments that lead to maximizing staff performance and helping your
employees achieve their professional goals and your organization’s objectives. Use Business Management Daily's
practical advice for writing employee reviews and conducting performance evaluations. Don’t forget to reference our
sample performance review and employee evaluation forms for your own staff assessments.
http://www.businessmanagementdaily.com/EffectivePerformanceReview
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/WorkplaceConflictResolution
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/MaternityLeaveLaws
The Office Organizer: 10 tips on file organizing, clutter control, document
management, business shredding policy, record retention guidelines and how to
organize office emails
Learn how to keep your office operations running smoothly—and ward off chaos and legal trouble—with practical
document management techniques for administrative professionals, office managers and HR professionals.
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/OfficeOrganizer
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/LeadershipTeamManagement
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/BackgroundCheckGuidelines
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/SalaryNegotiating101
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/FMLAIntermittentLeave
Employers, beware: The Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division reports that wage-and-hour labor litigation
continues to increase exponentially. Federal class actions brought under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
outnumber all other types of private class actions in employment-related cases. Use this special report, Overtime Labor
Law: 6 compliance tips to avoid overtime lawsuits, wage-and-hour Labor audits and FLSA exemption mistakes, to
review your overtime pay policy and double-check your FLSA exempt employees’ status. Expecting a visit from a DOL
auditor? Get prepared by taking the self-audit at the end of this report.
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/OvertimeLaborLaw
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/OfficeCommunicationToolkit
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/WorkplaceViolencePrevention
For organizations and employees alike, recognizing the critical link between business protocol and profit is key to your
success. Learn how to confidently interact with colleagues in ways that make you and your whole organization shine.
Discover best practices on making proper introductions; cubicle etiquette; “casual dress” rules; handshake protocol;
guest etiquette; workplace behavior faux pas; business dining etiquette, office wedding invites and other co-worker
special occasions; business letter and email protocol—and even how your office decorations may affect your
professional image.
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/BusinessEtiquette101
If you’ve had to cut pay and staff and now expect more from those who remain, it’s vital to revamp your employee
recognition and rewards program. Employers can double their rewards and recognition efforts in innovative, cost-
efficient ways with employee-of-the-month awards, employee incentive pay, employee appreciation luncheons, more
time off, shopping sprees, wellness incentive contests, plus employee rewards customized to motivate Millennials, Gen
Xers, Baby Boomers and the Matures. Now is the time to get clever with your employee recognition programs. This
report shows you how with great ideas offered up from our Business Management Daily readers.
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/EmployeeBenefitsProgram
The Case in Point Yearbook: Real-Life Employment Law Advice … from Mindy
Chapman’s Case in Point blog
Mindy Chapman, Esq., has been providing sound employment law advice in her Case in Point blog since 2007. In her
trademark entertaining style, she dissects an important employment law court ruling and provides essential
employment law advice via three "Lessons Learned." Topics include: ADA guidelines, age discrimination cases, sexual
harassment laws, EEOC cases, FMLA requirements and more.
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/CIPYearbook
The Bully Boss Strikes Again! How to deal with bosses who make crazy
requests
And you thought your boss was unreasonable? Bet he never asked you to perform oral surgery or fill in for the bomb
squad. Talk about “other duties as assigned!” Even if your direct supervisor swamps you with petty tasks and doesn’t
appreciate all you do, you can always “manage up” to make sure the boss’s boss knows your worth. This report
includes practical advice on how to manage a toxic boss along with dozens of outrageous stories about bully bosses.
http://www.businessmanagementdaily.com/BullyBoss
We all use Outlook. It’s easy. You can answer email, keep your appointments and your calendar, and save your files in
various folders. But are you using it to manage your entire workflow? You can. Melissa P. Esquibel combines her 25+
years of experience in information technology with a background in training, technical writing and business risk
analysis to move beyond email and help you understand Outlook’s amazing workflow benefits. You’ll discover how to
get more out of Outlook than you ever dreamed possible with this hands-on road map to Outlook that can send your
productivity skyrocketing.
http://www.businessmanagementdaily.com/MicrosoftEmailOutlook
17 Team Building Ideas: The team building kit for managers with team
building exercises, activities and games to build winning teams today!
With employees still reeling from workplace budget cuts, now’s a great time for new team building ideas. No, you don’t
need an expensive round of paintball to gain the benefits of team building exercises, but you do need to squeeze the
most out of them. This report provides teamwork examples, exercises and tips for leading winning teams. Go from
being a manager who oversees people to a leader who molds them into winning teams with these 17 team building
ideas.
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/TeamBuildingIdeas
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/TimeManagementTips
.
Our Free Email Newsletters, Print Newsletters, Free Special Reports and Webinars,
Podcasts, Audio Conferences & CDs help provide business professionals with the news,
skills and strategies they need to grow their business, avoid legal pitfalls and advance
their careers.