Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Modernism - Reference
Modernism - Reference
Syed Amanuddin
To cite this article: Syed Amanuddin (1976) Modernism in Indian Poetry in English, South Asian
Review, 1:sup1, 1-17, DOI: 10.1080/02759527.1976.11932189
Syed Amanuddin
Morris College, Sumter SC
former British dominions and colonies has both imported and indigenous
elements. The Indo-Anglian writer uses a medium which is now being used
writer worth the name writing in English could afford to ignore all the
his own country and region. He is influenced by the stress of the social
attitude to life.
teristic of modern times." G.S. Fraser in his The Modern Writer and His
in the works of the nineteenth century poets, Walt Whitman, Emily Dickin-
consideration, we may say modernism began during the First World War.
Literary historians may prefer to begin with the year 1917, the year T.S.
Eliot's Prufrock and Other Observations was first published. Eliot was
hailed as a modern poet because his poetry avoided the debased "romantic
Aspects of Modern Poetry, pre-modern poetry in English was "flat and thin,
more on the self-contained poem than on the poet. T.S. Eliot declared,
"Honest criticism and sensitive appreciation are directed not upon the poet
but upon the poetry."4 Modern poets were not preoccupied merely with
technique, they also expressed social and spiritual concerns of the modern
and American poetry was a result of several forces including the literary
climate and the stress of social change. We cannot simply relocate these
Modern age in Indian life probably began with the First War of Independence
in 1857 which manifested signs of Indian nationalism and united the people
of India. It was also the year when the first modern universities were
as Raja Ram Mohan Roy for the introduction of modern education in India.
The English system of education had its impact on every aspect of Indian
~ife which led to the final struggle for independence. When independence
PAGE 3
Modernism in Indian Poetry in English
was finally achieved in 1947, it was a moment of joy and despair for the
murders, refugee problems, and bitter memories for several years to come,
and later even the murder of the great Indian leader who preached the
gospel of love and peace. Independence years were also the years of
freedom did not necessarily mean freedom from the problems of hunger,
The Indo-Anglian writers like the other Indian writers have lived
in their poetry should look at these changes and their impact on the Indo-
Anglian poetry. At the same time, we should remember that the Indian
writer in English is using the medium used in various regions of the world
for creative expression. While not forgetting his s~iritual and cultural
kinship with Kalidasa, Kabir, Ghalib, and other masters of Indian literature,
the Indian writer in English cannot help remembering, because of the medium
Anglian writers - their roots are both Indian and alien and so are their
poets, and piously imitating their themes and moods, the Indo-Anglian
8
poets recollected their emotions almost in futility." Most poets
manifest even to this day among Indian critics who get excited about an
scene only after the Indian independence, the time when rapid social
in the poetry of those regions and replaced modernism with certain other
and published in 1959. Like a true avant-garde, Lal attacks the kind
of poetry that interested the Indian readers of the period. He uses poetic
treated in concrete terms as the Irish poet AE does in his poetry would
there is nothing to hang on to. When the eyes are focused to catch a
ground,' the picture blurs and slithers off like some theosophical
so much the poetry of Aurobindo as the kind of poetry that was written
forties and the fifties: "this kind of slushy verse is the dangerous
feared his own future as well as the future of poets like him if public
poets, the anthology does not have much to offer - "rambling sentences
din and hubbub, the confusion and indecision, the flashes of beauty and
ists; 8) in an age of mass approval and hysteria, the need for the private
voice must be emphasized; the lyric form is best suited for the capsule-
12
minded reading public.
speech, but to employ always the exact word, not merely decorative word;
between the two manifestos are clear. Both groups were reacting to
pleasingly." The problem with poets such as Tagore and Naidu is that
they are too very pleasingly poetical and Lal's group is against their
in his"Unhappily Married"?
poets such as Sri Aurobindo and Sarojini Naidu enjoy some pages in the
anthology. It is interesting to see Naidu's "If You Call Me" with its
Krishna Mehrotra and dull versifiers like Yamini Krishnamurthy on whom the
Modernism in Indian Poetry in English PAGE 8
anthology and the title is misleading. More poets have been added to
problem in the present anthology is not so much clearing the way for
himself and his kind of poets, as with the survival of the Indian writing
The new anthology concentrates chiefly on one problem: why does the
of English and American Poets edited by Stephen Spender and Donald Hall.
every possible poet writing in English even though some of the "poets"
Three significant poets emerged from this movement: P. Lal, Nissim Ezekiel,
the most significant of these three poets is Dom Moraes who is more
He uses the conversational style and does not try to be merely "pleasingly
poetical," and his effective images prevent his poetry from degenerating
I am ashamed of myself
Since I was ashamed of you.
There is an implied protest in the poem. Unlike other poets of this group,
Dom Moraes treats sexual themes with boldness which indicates his kinship
with later modern Indo-Anglian poets. One way of classifying the twentieth
Nizamat Jung are romantic idealists, Lal and Ezekiel are inhibitists, and
romantic realists. 18 Lal and Ezekiel would talk about love but rarely
The above lines from Ezekiel's poem "Marriage" should be read in the
context of Lal's second principle in the manifesto: "We think that poetry
must deal in concrete terms with concrete experience. That experience may
'the wide and open sky'." The early moderns in their search for
blood", the awkward rhyme "blood" and "good", and the clumsy line without
one wonder if the poets of Lal-Ezekiel group were really serious about their
Naidu has her lyricism - the early moderns could offer mostly the "bare-
Pound, Yeats and others, but never very well. My own voice has often been
a better translator than a poet probably because he spends all his creative
scious or not, writes so differently from Lal-Ezekiel group that one would
call him a bridge between the early moderns and later moderns, and probably
would produce better poetry in the seventies along with later moderns.
Modernism in Indian Poetry in English PAGE 11
One would have thought that the early moderns who started writing under the
influence of the spirit of free India would have felt liberated in the use
of language and theme, but they seem to write their poetry under some strange
Ramanjuan, Syed Amanuddin, G.S. Sharat Chandra, Kamala Das, Shiv K. Kumar,
Arvind Krishna Mehrotra, Pritish Nandy, and H.B. Kulkarni belong to another
group of modern poets who may be called later moderns. V.K. Gokak may like
ally share with the early moderns and interest in the lucid and the clear,
they have a greater love of irony and verbal play and they tend to explore
complex range of human ex9erience which is often the experience of the poets
themselves. They are not over enthusiastic about the exact word (what does
that mean anyway?) , but they do pay attention to the choice of words and
imagery. One should remember, however, this group is not bound by any
single manifesto, and each voice is an independent voice. One of the signi-
ficant poets of this group is A.K. Ramanujan. He writes in his poem "Self-
Portrait":
I resemble everyone
but myself, and sometimes see
in shop-windows,
despite the well-known laws of optics
the portrait of a stranger,
date unknown,
often signed in a corner
Modernism in Indian Poetry in English PAGE 12
by my father. 23
Poor bladders
and bad weather and steam
from urinators
colour the dream.
B.J. Daruwala is essentially a quester and the problems of self and truth
interest him more than the dirt and filth around him in Indian streets,
dictions of human personality and discovers Rama and Ravana within his own
Indo-Anglian poet: "Indian poets in English are drawing room poets who
have never gone out into the streets to find out things for themselves.
sponsored readings. They cannot write major poetry."29 However, with some
major weakness of their poetry is that they are conscious academics. One
critic said, "Most of the poets of the thirties, forties, fifties and six-
ties take in the 'revolution' of the poetry written in Europe and elsewhere.
this critic seems to imply such an imitation of the models from abroad to
Most Indo-Anglian poets have been better imitators than original creators.
We cannot speak of a major poet unless his voice is distinct enough to make
him a model for poets both from India and abroad. It seems most Indo-Anglian
dominated by the academics. But the academics should come out of their study
in order to experience life in all its rawness, in its boredom and beauty,
its mire and misery, and fun and fury in the streets and ghettos, in the
marketplace and stinking public urinals, on the city pavements and in the
PAGE 14
Modernism in Indian Poetry in English
ness of the Indian countryside. They must also stop swearing by the text-
books of grammar and poetics, and also stop imitating poets, both Indian
and foreign, consciously. They should stop writing for other poets,
While the poets who are academics should try to be less academic in
because of the Western interest in this genre (and this interest is often
more sociological than literary) , but very few Indian academics have
statement, "the time is not yet propitious to take a stand on their (Indo-
which has advanced beyond the initial stages of experimentation and promise,"21
may be true of the poets of the fifties and sixties, but the seventies have
produced distinct voices who deserve better attention from the academics.
However, the tendency to imitate the English models persisted during the
first phase of modernism which lasted from the fifties to the early sixties.
During the late sixties and early seventies have emerged many new voices,
nique, who are gradually taking over the Indo-Anglian poetry scene and who
loyalties both to the Indian culture which started as "a wagon hitched to
the engine of English poetry," is now not only running on its own independ-
4
T. s. Eliot, Selected Essays (New York: Harcourt Brace and Co., 1950), p. 7.
5
Syed Amanuddin, "Citizen of the Universe," Lightning and Love (Sumter,
South Carolina: Poetry Eastwest, 1973), p. 9.
6
v. K. Gokak, ed., The Golden Treasury of Indo-Anglian Poetry, 1828-1965
(New Delhi: Sahitya Akademi, 1970), p. xxii.
7
C.D. Narasinhaiah, The Swan and the Eagle (Simla: Indian Institute of
Advanced Study, 1969), p. ix.
8
John B. Alphonso-Karkala, Indo-English Literature in the Nineteenth Century
(Mysore: The Literary Half-Yearly, University of Mysore, 1970), p. 34.
9
See this writer's essay, "Avant- Gardism in American Poetry," Creative Moment,
II (Spring, 1973).
10
P. Lal and K. Raghavendra Rao, eds., Modern Indo-Anglian Poetry (New Delhi:
Kavita, 1959), p. ii.
11
Ibid., pp. ii-iii.
12
Ibid., pp. xi-xiii.
13
Michael Roberts, ed. "Introduction," The Faber Book of Modern Verse (London:
Faber and Faber, 1936), p. 15.
14
Nissim Ezekiel, "Unhappily Married," Modern Indo-Anglian Poetry, p. 26.
15
Dom Moraes, "Shyness," Poems 1955-1965 (New York: McMillan Company, 1966),
p. 11.
16
"Autobiography," Poems 1955-1965, p. 29.
17
"·Letter to My Mother," Poems 1955-1965, p. 80.
18
See this writer's essay, "Love and Sex in Indo-English Poetry,"
Creative Moment, III (Fall, 1974), p. 15.
19
Modern Indo-Anglian Poetry, p. vi.
20
"Suresh Kohli Interviews Nissim Ezekiel," Mahfil - A Quarterly of South
Asian Literature, VIII (Winter, 1972), pp. 9-10.
21
Ibid.
22
Gokak, p. xxv.
23
A. K, Ramanujan, The Striders (New York: Oxford University Press, 1966), p. 21.
2
ibid., p. 1.
25
See this writer's review of Lawrence Bantleman's Man's Fall and Woman's
Fallout (1964) and Kanchanjanga: A Sornbolical Poem (1967) in Mahfil,
VI (1970), pp. 149-150.
26
See this writer's review of B. J. Daruwala's The Wheel of Fire and Other
Poems (1966) in Mahfil, VI(l970), pp. 150-151
27
"Ulcers," Poems of Protest (Sumter, South Carolina: Poetry Eastwest, 1972),
p. 15. Also see "When I Look into the Mirror," and "Nirvana," The
Children of Hiroshima (Mysore: Kavyalaya, 1970).
28
"Bharatmata - A Prayer," Mahfil, VI (1970) , p. 1.
29
"Suresh Kohli Interviews Pritish Nandy," Mahfil, VII (Winter, 1972), p. 13.
30
H. H. Anniah Gowda, "Contemporary Indian Verse in English," Indian Literature
of the Past Fifty Years, ed. C. D. Narasimhaiah (Mysore: University of
Mysore, 1970), p. 825.
31
The Swan and the Eagle, p. 36.
32
G. s. Balarama Gupta, "Some Reflections on Indian Writing in English," Essays
on Indian Writing in English (Gulbarga: JI\iE Publications, 1975), pp.4-8.