Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Condition of Salvation - For Jews and Gentiles in This Age - Kesher Journal
The Condition of Salvation - For Jews and Gentiles in This Age - Kesher Journal
LO G I N ( / l o g i n / ) S U B S C R I B E ( / s u b s c r i b e / )
(/)
The purpose of this article is to answer the question, “Exactly what must one do to be saved?” According to the
Scriptures, what is it that a person must do to be saved?
The key point as emphasized by the Brit Chadashah is that faith is the one and only condition for salvation. In
more than 200 cases where a condition is given for salvation, faith or belief is stated to be the only condition.
One example is John 1:12: but as many received him, to them gave he the right to become children of God,
even to them that believe on his name. This verse states that the ones who become the children of God are
those who received him. What does it mean to receive the Messiah? The second part of the verse explains that
to receive the Messiah means to believe on His name, to believe he really is the Jewish Messiah. Simply by
believing what one must believe, one receives salvation. That is the way one becomes a child of God, and
believing is the only condition mentioned here.
Another example is Acts 16:30-31: and brought them out and said, Sirs, what must I do to be saved? And they
said, Believe on the Lord Jesus, and you shall be saved, you and your house. In verse 30 the question is asked:
what must I do to be saved? The Apostle answers in verse 31, the only condition is to believe on the Lord
Jesus. If they believe on the Lord Yeshua, then they will receive salvation.
Now what exactly must one believe on the Lord Yeshua? Paul spells out the full content of faith in I
Corinthians 15:1-4. In verse one he reminds them that he had spelled out the gospel to them, and in verse two
he reminds them that it is by believing the gospel that they are saved. Then in verses three and four he goes
on to spell out the full content of the gospel that involves three basic points: first, Messiah died for our sins;
second, he was buried (the evidence of his death); and, third, he rose again from the dead. Thus, that is the
content of the gospel one must believe for salvation, and it applies equally both for Jews and Gentiles.
And in none other is there salvation: for neither is there any other name under heaven, that is
given among men, wherein we must be saved.
Peter clearly declares to the Sanhedrin that there is no other name given under Heaven by which one could be
saved than Yeshua, and therefore, they must put their faith in that person for their salvation. It should be
noted that he is speaking to Jews and not Gentiles, and furthermore, he is speaking to religious Jews and not
secular Jews. Thus, even the most religious Orthodox Jew who claims to believe in the God of Israel, who does
not also believe in the Messiahship of Yeshua and Messiah’s death for his sin, is just as lost as any pagan
Gentile. Hence, in Acts 2-9, the gospel is consistently declared to those who are Jews or those who are
proselytes to Judaism who would certainly affirm their belief in the God of the Hebrew Bible, yet apart from
Yeshua they had no salvation.
Is it true that while the Bible affirms that those who believe in Yeshua are clearly saved, it leaves silent the
question of those Jews (and Gentiles) who do not believe? Here again, the opposite fact is true. In John
chapter three he does affirm several times that only those who believe have eternal life. Is he silent about
those who do not believe? Not at all. Therefore the one who believes not has already been judged because he
did not believe on the name of the only begotten Son of God (John 3:18). Therefore, the one who fails to
believe simply has the wrath of God abiding on him (John 3:36). Here again, he is addressing Jews and not
Gentiles.
The same truth is taught in many other passages. John the Immerser declared that those who believe in the
one he identifies as the Messiah, will be baptized by the Spirit; but those who do not believe will be baptized
into unquenchable fire (Matthew 3:11-12).
In John 5, clearly identifying himself both as the Son of God and the Son of Man, Yeshua points out it is those
who believe on this Son of God and Son of Man who will undergo the resurrection of life and those who have
not done so will undergo the resurrection of judgment (John 5: 25-29). Furthermore, their failure to recognize
him as the Messiah was their failure to believe what Moses actually wrote, because had they truly believed
Moses, they would also have recognized who He is and what He teaches is truth (John 5: 46-47). It should be
noted that he is addressing a Jewish audience and not a Gentile audience in this context.
In John 6:40 it is those who believe on the Son that have eternal life and they are the ones that will be
resurrected into the immortal and glorified state. This promise simply does not apply to those who do not
believe on him.
In John 10, still addressing a Jewish audience, he declares, I am the door of the sheep. Those who enter
through him are the ones who are saved and those who come in may have life, may have it abundantly. But
those who do not enter by that door are the ones who do not have this life (John 10: 7-18). Luke 10:16
declares that those who reject Yeshua also reject God the Father who sent Yeshua; again, that is still strictly a
Jewish context.
In John 10:22-39, the Jews who believe in him are the ones who are his sheep and therefore, only they have
eternal life and therefore they shall never perish. The promise is simply not applied to that part of the Jewish
audience who did not believe on him. In John 11:26, Yeshua declared that those who believe on him, even
though they die physically, they have the promise of the resurrection.
The above examples of course could be multiplied many times over, but I chose to limit our discussion within
the gospels (even then it is not exhaustive) to keep it within the Jewish context. For example, Paul writes in
Galatians 2:21, …For if righteousness is through the law, then Messiah died for nothing. The fact remains,
whether one is a Jew or a Gentile, without faith in the person of the Messiah who died for our sins, there is no
salvation, there is no eternal life.
False Additions to Salvation
The second major category concerning the condition of salvation consists of various false additions, which
have been added throughout Church history. We will discuss five false additions.
Repentance
The first false addition to salvation is repentance. Some groups make a distinction between repentance and
faith and claim that not only does a person have to believe on the Messiah and trust Him for one’s salvation,
but that one must also repent. Usually what they mean by repentance is that “they must truly be sorry for their
sins.”
{josquote}the actual meaning of the Greek word for “repentance” simply means, “to change one’s
mind.”{/josquote}
First, the actual meaning of the Greek word for “repentance” simply means, “to change one’s mind.” That is all
that biblical repentance means. Repentance does not mean, “to feel sorry for one’s sins.” Second, when it is
used as a synonym for believe, then yes, it is a condition for salvation. For example, one has to change one’s
mind about who the Messiah is in order to be saved. If repentance is meant as a synonym for belief and faith,
then yes, repentance is necessary for salvation. Third, it becomes a false addition when it is taken to mean
“sorrow.” If by repentance one means “sorrow” and, therefore, one has to feel sorry for the sins to be saved, then
it is a false addition to salvation. Fourth, the reason for this is that if repentance in the sense of being sorry for
one’s sins is necessary, salvation then becomes two things. First, salvation is now placed on the basis of works,
and secondly, salvation is based upon feeling, not upon the facts and promises of Scripture. Fifth, in salvation
repentance is never a separate act from faith or believing.
Belief as a condition to salvation appears about two hundred times; repentance as a synonym for believing
appears thirty‑five times. Repentance is a synonym for believing and only as a synonym for believing is it a
condition for salvation. But if one redefines repentance as “being sorry for one’s sins,” then it is a false
addition.
The New Testament uses the word “repentance” four different ways. First, it is used as a synonym for believing,
and means nothing different than believing in Yeshua the Messiah. (Lk. 24:47; Acts 17:30; Rom. 2:4;
II Tim. 2:25; II Pet. 3:9). Second, repentance simply means to “change one’s mind.” (Acts 8:22; 11:18; 20:21;
26:20; Heb. 6:1, 6; 12:17; Rev. 9:20). It never carries the sense of feeling sorry. Sorrow may accompany
repentance, but the word itself does not mean “sorrow.” It simply means, “to change one’s mind” Third, the word
“repentance” is used is in reference to Israel when speaking of Israel’s need to repent, that is, Israel’s need to
change its mind about Jesus. Here again, it merely means “a change of mind concerning who the Messiah is.”
(Acts 2:38; 3:19; 5:31) Fourth, the word is used is as a reference to John’s baptism, which was called a “baptism
of repentance.” In this sense, it is simply a part of God’s covenantal relationship with Israel (Acts 13:24; 19:4).
Insofar as repentance is concerned, there are two things to note. If repentance is used merely as a synonym for
believing in the Messiah¾the way the Bible uses it¾only in that sense is it truly a condition for salvation. But
if¾as some groups use it¾repentance means, “to feel sorry for one’s sins,” then it indeed becomes a false
addition to salvation.
Every one therefore who shall confess me before men, him will I also confess before my Father
who is in heaven.
Based upon these two passages of Scripture, some groups have made a false addition to salvation and teach
that there must be a public, verbal confession for a person to be saved. The answer is that in both of these
passages, confession is not a separate act from faith. In the case of Matthew 10:32, the context is dealing with
Israel’s having rejected the Messiah, and those individual Jews who want salvation must confess the Messiah,
meaning that they must confess that Yeshua is the Messiah. But in this case, the word “confession” is simply
part of the act of faith; it is not a separate act in any way. As far as the Romans 10:9‑10 passage is concerned,
Paul uses a Hebraic poetical form known as “inversion.” Paul interchanges the terms “confession” and
“believing” to show that both these terms are used synonymously. For example, in verse 9, he first spoke of
confession: with your mouth [the Lord Jesus], and then secondly: believe in the heart that God raised him from
the dead. So in verse 9, there was confession followed by believing. Then in verse 10, he reversed the terms. In
verse 10, he first spoke of believing: for with the heart man believes unto righteousness, then he spoke of
confession: with the mouth confession is made unto salvation. This inversion of confession and believing and
the interchangeableness of the two terms show that he used them synonymously. Confession in this verse
equals calling upon the name of the Lord. Calling upon the name of the Lord is simply exercising faith in Him.
Confession is not a separate act from faith.
There are three problems with this false addition of confession for salvation. The first problem is that
confession is omitted in all passages that speak of a condition of salvation with these two exceptions. In the
other two hundred‑plus cases where the condition is given for salvation, confession is not one of them. Even
in these two cases, confession is used only synonymously with believing in the Messiah. The second problem
is that if a public confession is necessary for salvation, then salvation is on the basis of works. Salvation would
be based upon works if a person must actually publicly confess the Messiah. The third problem is that the
circumstances for many people who are saved preclude a public confession. Many people are saved merely by
reading a gospel tract or by reading a New Testament. They believe on Yeshua the Messiah and they indeed
experience salvation without having any opportunity to make a public confession right then and there. A
public confession is not part of salvation, and those who teach it make it a false addition to the condition of
salvation.
Confession of Sin
The third false addition is confession of sin. The verse, which is used, is I John 1:9:
If we confess our sins, he is faithful and righteous to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us
from all unrighteousness.
People sometimes use this verse and make it a condition of salvation: you must confess your sins before you
can be saved.
First of all, I John 1:9 is not a salvation verse. In fact, the writer is writing to those who already are believers;
they have already been saved. Notice the pronouns: If we confess our sins. The pronouns we and our include
the Apostle John and his readers. Both John and his readers were already saved. Again-this is not a salvation
verse-it is simply a verse, which deals with the sins committed by people who already are believers. Second, if
the confession of sin were a necessary addition to the condition of salvation, how many people remember
every sin they commit? It would literally be impossible to remember every sin that one has committed. If this
condition were true, it would mean that unless one has confessed every single sin ever committed, then one
cannot be saved! Since this is impossible, no one would have hope of salvation.
Imploring God for Salvation
The fourth false addition which some teach is that one must implore God to save him or her, and without such
salvation does not occur. The picture is that God is somewhat reluctant to impart salvation and, therefore, one
must implore Him as a precedent for receiving it.
Two main passages are used to teach this. First is Isaiah 55:6:
Seek ye Jehovah while he may be found; call ye upon him while he is near: . . .
The admonition to seek ye Jehovah is interpreted as “imploring God to save.” While the admonition is to seek
the Lord, they ignore the fact that Romans 3:11 teaches that no one seeks God on his own. If this were a
condition of salvation, it would mean that no one would be saved since no one will ever seek God on his
own! Another passage used is Luke 18:13, which speaks of praying for salvation. What is ignored here is that
this passage does not actually say that one must implore God to be saved, nor does it teach that one must
seek God and seek God and seek God until one finds Him. The passage is dealing with the believer’s prayer-
life, not with salvation. Luke 19:10 states that it is the Messiah who actually does the seeking.
The problem with the teaching is that in the two hundred‑plus places where the condition for salvation is
discussed, imploring God is not a condition for salvation. It is never written that one must implore, seek, and
pray for God for salvation before God will impart it. Furthermore, this is salvation by works. Salvation is
emphasized as being by grace through faith. The salvation, which God offers, is simply received by faith; one
does not have to implore God in order to be the recipient of salvation. God is more than ready to save.
But Peter said, Not so, Lord; for I have never eaten anything that is common and unclean.
In this verse, Peter called Jesus Lord, and yet he said to the Lord, Not so, Lord. Peter proceeded to rebuke the
Lord. In fact, one can accept the Lordship of Messiah like Peter did, and yet immediately act contrary to
something that this Lord commands. Acts 19:8‑19 will also bear out this same point.
Baptism
“Is baptism necessary for salvation?” In this study, we will address this topic in a brief, three-part comment on
the passages, which people use to teach that baptism is necessary for salvation.
Mark 16:15‑16
Mark 16:15-16 does not say that one who is not baptized will be lost, nor does it teach that one who believes,
but is not baptized, will be lost. The negative is not stated. It simply says to believe and be baptized. In those
days, baptism immediately followed salvation. Furthermore, this verse is not even found in the best and oldest
Greek manuscripts of the Gospel of Mark.
Acts 2:38
The second passage used is Acts 2:38, which states: Repent ye and be baptized… [for] the remission your of
sins. The Greek word here is eis, which can also mean “because of” or “on account of,” as is its meaning in
Matthew 12:41. Therefore, Acts 2:38 simply states: “repent and be baptized on the basis of the remission of
sins” or “because you have been saved, therefore you should be baptized.”
Acts 22:16
The last passage is Acts 22:16, which, in the Greek text, contains two imperatives and two participles, and
literally reads: “arise, having been baptized, wash away your sins, having called upon the name of the Lord.”
What this verse is saying is that baptism follows the arising just as the forgiveness of sins follows the calling
upon the name of the Lord. The two parts of the verse must be kept distinct. Just as after calling upon the
name of the Lord, one is then saved; having been saved, one should arise, and be baptized.
Conclusion
If it is possible to be saved in any other way, especially if one provides a way of salvation for Orthodox Jews
who do not accept the Messiahship of Yeshua, then we, Messianic Jews, have no special message to give. In a
different context Paul writes that if we do not believe in the resurrection, then we are chosen to believe for
nothing. The same applies specifically to us as Messianic Jews: those of us who have chosen to believe in the
Messiahship of Yeshua, chosen to be rejected by members of our family, by the Jewish society, especially by
Orthodox Jews, have believed for nothing. The whole reason for establishing Jewish ministries is that there is
only one way of salvation for both Jews and Gentiles-faith in Messiah Yeshua. This is a message that simply
cannot be compromised.
Arnold Fruchtenbaum is founder and director of Ariel Ministries. Before receiving his doctorate from New York
University in 1989, Dr. Fruchtenbaum earned his Th.M. from Dallas Theological Seminary. His graduate work
also includes studies at the Jewish Theological Seminary in New York City and The Hebrew University of
Jerusalem.
About Kesher
Kesher is a journal of Messianic Judaism, published
by the Messianic Jewish Theological Institute
(https://mjti.org). Its purpose is to provide a forum
for scholars, professionals and laity to address issues
that impact contemporary Messianic Judaism.
Read More... (/contact/)
Subscriptions
Subscribe Now (/subscribe/)
Account Login (/login/)
Kesher Issues (/past-issues/)
Advanced Search (/advanced-search/)
Privacy Policy (/contact/)
Terms & Conditions (/contact/)
Contact
Question or comment? Write to us or use our online
Contact Form link below.
Kesher
P.O. Box 928004
San Diego, CA 92192
CO N TACT F O R M
(/contact/)
( / CO N TACT / )