Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Evolution of CES Chapter 19 Bioelectromagnetic and Subtle Energy Medicine

    Uploaded by

    Ana Maria Amanaturalis
    12 views28 pages
    This 3-sentence summary provides the key details about the document: The document appears to be information from a book about bioelectromagnetics and subtle energy medicine, as it includes the book's international standard book number and publication details. While attempting to publish reliable data, the publishers make no guarantees about errors and disclaim responsibility for views expressed by individual editors or contributors. Readers are urged to independently verify any medical information or advice due to rapid advances in the field.

    Original Description:

    Evolution of CES Chapter 19 Bioelectromagnetic and Subtle Energy Medicine

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    This 3-sentence summary provides the key details about the document: The document appears to be information from a book about bioelectromagnetics and subtle energy medicine, as it includes the book's international standard book number and publication details. While attempting to publish reliable data, the publishers make no guarantees about errors and disclaim responsibility for views expressed by individual editors or contributors. Readers are urged to independently verify any medical information or advice due to rapid advances in the field.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as pdf or txt
    12 views28 pages

    Evolution of CES Chapter 19 Bioelectromagnetic and Subtle Energy Medicine

    Uploaded by

    Ana Maria Amanaturalis
    This 3-sentence summary provides the key details about the document: The document appears to be information from a book about bioelectromagnetics and subtle energy medicine, as it includes the book's international standard book number and publication details. While attempting to publish reliable data, the publishers make no guarantees about errors and disclaim responsibility for views expressed by individual editors or contributors. Readers are urged to independently verify any medical information or advice due to rapid advances in the field.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 28

    BIOELECTROMAGt

    サETIC
    ANDSUBTLE
    ENERGYMEDICINE
    CRCP r
    ess
    T

    1
    a
    y

    3
    0
    1
    υr& F
    6000R
    C<
    1R
    rn
    k
    lt
    <
    e
    o
    r
    l
    andsGr
    ollp
    lSoundParkwayN X
    n，FL:n4
    府7-2742
    !，日u
    it 、
    e300

    ⑥20151
    >)
    '1叫 l
    or& F
    ranc
    isGrol
    lp，LLC
    CRCPrcs
    sisal
    limp
    rintofT
    aylr& F
    o r
    anc
    isGroup，anl
    nform<
    lbusi
    nes
    s

    Noc
    lai
    mtn(
    Iri
    gin
    alU
    .S.Go
    v出 nmentworks

    Pri nl cd0 11adr


    l・f
    reepap
    ct
    Ve l".~íon Dat
    e:2(
    )1411
    07

    I
    nte
    fll
    ati
    ona
    lSt
    anc
    hl
    L"(1sookNumber
    -13
    :97純一1
    -4822-
    331
    9-3(
    Har
    db-
    ack
    )

    rhi sbo ok山 nt ainsi nf ormat i


    onobt ain
    ed( rlm a
    ( uthcnticandhi ghlyre~<Hrle d SOl!rc
    es.Whi leal
    lr easona blee ffmtsh .
    oveb cenma det opllbli
    shreli
    ablゼ
    da t
    aand川 f ormation，n eith ertbcauthor
    [slnort hcpub li
    shcrGl naじにc ptanyI cgalr eSpOtl則 bil
    it)
    'orl iab
    ili t
    yf (Jranycrl"Orsoronl issinnst hatmaybema de
    Thepubi lshersw i
    sht omakt :dc arthatany円 ewsoropi nio
    llsexpr esse din山内 bonkb }
    'i ndividualedi tor s
    ，温u tl旧 日 01":
    contr
    ibll t s.
    υr on'.pcrsol
    laltothcm
    anddonotn e
    c ess
    ar il
    yr cf
    lc ctthevi山 ¥
    's
    /opinionso fthep u
    blishers，Th ein"
    tormat ion01'g ll
    id ancccon tai ncdi nthisbookI si ntendedf oru島ebymedic< ，
    ll
    scientif
    i:υrh
    < e
    ..
    llt
    h-car cp rofe日 io
    nalsandi sp r
    ovidcds t
    rict
    lyasas l lp p
    lcmcntt ot hel ll
    edicalo ro t
    h crp rofes s
    iunal'sQwnj l l
    ds ement， t hei
    rknowl cdgcof
    thcp aticn s1l1c
    t' di
    calh i stor y，rc
    lc¥'a
    ntmanufactur el馬 Inst
    ruct
    iollSalldt 1
    1(
    'a ppropr iateb es
    tp rac
    t i
    c egui dc!incs.Bc 仏.lUseofth cr apida dvancesinmcdi
    cal sdence， anyi n
    foflll<ltiono radvicc01
    1dosag s，
    e procedures01"d i
    a.
    g nosess houldbei ndepen dentlyvcri fi
    ed .Ther e aderisstr onglyu rgedt oconsullthc
    relevantn atiunaldrugr url1lulary<1dt
    lt h
    cdrugcompani es'
    printcdins t r
    u<ti
    : ons，andt hcirwe bsites，b巴fO'lea dminis te rin
    ganylJft hedrllgsrecommendcd
    11t
    1 h¥5book.T hisb()のkdoc sn川 i ndicat
    ewhet herapa r
    ti山 lartre;
    lt mcnli sappr o pr
    ia t
    e01 "s ui
    tablef o
    rap articulari nd
    ividlla.lUl ti
    lla
    1 tdyi tisthc501e
    ¥
    "l'
    spons ib
    ilil)
    'οft hemedicalp rof
    ession
    alt omak eh i
    so rhCl"nwnp r ofcssion
    alj u dgemen ls，s oa stoa dvi se;ln dtrea
    tp at
    ienlsappl υpr
    i atel
    y，Thea uthors
    an dpub! ishcJ
    'sh avea ls oa ttcm pt
    edt otracet hecoprrightholderso fa lmater i
    l.lr eprod u
    c cdi nt hispuh lic:a
    . ti
    ollandapol ogizet oc opy r
    ighth o
    ldersif
    p叩 l l
    issinnt npubi1shi nt hisfonnh asnotbecno bta
    i ne
    d.l fa
    nyωp )'l"i
    ghtm山 ! ri
    alh a
    sn otbeena cknowledge dplea問 、v r
    itcandl et凶 knows owema y
    rectif}'
    ιnanyt "It
    l urer epr int

    E
    x仁e ptilSpermit t
    cdunderU.S
    .Copyrig
    htLaw，nop af
    t{)
    fthisbookmayben
    :
    !print
    cd，r
    e pr
    oducゼd，lransm
    itte
    d，()
    rut
    il
    i1
    .edi
    nanyformby< lnye
    leιt
    roni
    ，
    :
    .c
    mι~c.: han iζ. 1 ， υ r o
    thcrmeans.nowknownυrhe reaf
    teri
    n¥
    '('
    ntcd，in
    dll
    din
    gphoto
    c o
    pying，mit
    .
    :rof
    i[ming，il
    ndrcc
    ordi
    ng，ori
    nanyinf
    Ul'lna
    tionsto
    ragc01'
    l
    "'
    tlri引 唱 1 sys t cm， wit
    houtwrit
    tenper
    misslOlf
    rり mthepuhl
    ishers

    Forpcrmi s
    siontop hotoc
    opyOru sema t
    er ll
    i. ピl
    ecl
    roni
    t;a
    . ly[[
    "1m t
    { hiswor k，
    pJ剖問 acce問、I!¥¥Iw.copyr
    ight
    .com(http:/
    /ww¥¥I.
    copyr
    ight.
    c010/
    )orcontact
    thcCopyrightC1earanceCcnt
    er，In仁 (CCC)，222Ru日 wnodDri 四 .Danvers，M A01
    923，978-7 50.8400
    .CCCi sanot-f
    or-pr
    ol i
    tor胆n i.
    za
    tionthatpr
    ovides
    li
    ccnscsandr c
    gistnuit
    川 fo
    rav a
    rictyofus('
    rs.F
    ororganizat
    ionst h
    atha vcbccngr
    antedapho tocυpyli
    cen同 hyteCCC，
    h l
    is epara
    t cs
    ystem ofp
    a}'ment
    hasbeena r
    ran.
    gcd

    rrademarkNoti
    ce:Pwduclt
    lrc
    orp
    ora
    tenamc
    sm叫 bct
    rademar
    kstH. r
    egiは er
    edt
    radcmarks，andi
    l
    reusedon
    l'
    )fO
    iid
    ，叫 t
    if
    ic
    ati
    onande
    xplana
    tion
    wi
    thoulint
    enttlin
    fri
    nge
    V
    isi
    tt heTny
    lor& FmncisWehsi
    tea
    t
    h
    ttp:
    //www.t町'
    lorandfr
    anc
    is.
    com
    andtheCI
    ミCPreSS、X
    'cbsi
    tca
    t
    htt
    p:/
    /www.c
    n:.
    pte
    ss.c。
    剛
    1
    9 TheE
    Stimu
    l
    v
    a
    o
    l
    ti
    u
    t
    o
    io
    nf
    nofC
    o
    rania
    rAnxiety
    lEle仁trotherapy
    ，Insomnia，
    Depression，andPainandI ts
    Pot
    entialforOtherI nd
    i c
    ations
    OanielL
    .Kirsch業 andJ
    eff
    reyA
    .Marksberry

    CONTENTS
    NaluralEl cc t
    rici
    ty:ThcD iscovcryo faP eculiarP r np!r
    ltyo fFish...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..........._............・..............1 89
    TheMoue r
    nE ra..
    ..
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ......................................、。 190
    CESComest oAmeri ca....
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    .. 今 ・・ 0 .•••• ••.••.••••. ....
    ..
    ...
    .1
    91
    E山 IyE lccl roenじeph alo
    gr aphyRc ぉcarchandt heSub叫 quentExp a
    ns i
    oni n
    t othcT reat m
    ento fMoodDi sor der s. .. ... ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    .191
    Mechanisms0 1Aじ1
    ' 10n...
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    .・ .•••. ・
    ・ ・.
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ....
    .
    ...
    .
    .....
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    .....・ 1
    92 、 今

    Mo reE lcclr oencepha log


    r aphicS ludie
    s.・ ・..................・..........，.・
    0 ・.
    ...
    .
    e..
    .... ... ..... ......
    ...
    ..
    ...193
    TheC lillicalR ole0'1CES. ..
    ..
    ....
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    . ー...
    ...
    ....
    ... ーー . .
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ...... .............
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..194
    Clin
    ic alS tudi e
    s...
    ..
    ..
    .. ・・ ・ ・・
    0 0 .
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    0.
    .........
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    .....
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ...... .............
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..194
    Summar yofThreeSu rvc ys(n=5 91 7
    ).
    ...
    .・ . .... .
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    .，
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ... ・ ..
    ..
    .
    ..
    ・ ・ .0.
    .
    ..
    .
    ..
    ，. .
    ..
    . ・・ 0 .
    ・.
    .
    0.
    ..
    ..195
    Mo de r
    nRcscan .
    :h. . . ・ .
    ..
    ..
    .
    .. .
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ...... .............
    ..
    ....
    .
    ..195
    Anxie ty1コ isorder
    s・. 0 ・…...・ ・ ・ 0 .
    ......・
    0 ・ ・.
    0 .
    .
    0..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ...... .............
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..195
    Dcpr cssiveD is or
    der s..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ......
    .. .
    ..
    ..
    ......
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..・ ・ .
    ....
    ..
    0...
    ....
    ...
    ..・.
    .....
    . .. .. .. .. ... ..
    ..・
    ....199
    In附 mnia.... ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..........
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ..
    .....
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ... ... .............
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..199
    Pain... .
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    .. .
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ....
    ..
    .. .
    ..
    ..
    .
    ... .
    ..
    ...... .
    ..
    ..
    ...
    .. .
    .
    ..
    ...
    .
    .....
    ..
    ....................ー . .
    ...2
    01
    Olhc rPOl entialAp pl i
    ca
    ti ons.
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ...
    ..... .
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    .. ・ 0 ・...・ .205
    Tinnitu討 ー -一 ..
    ..
    ...
    .
    ....
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...... .............
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..205
    Canct!r
    : .
    ......
    ....
    ......
    .......
    ...
    . .
    ....
    .・..
    ....
    ...... .. .
    .....
    ....
    ....
    .....
    . .
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ...... ..... ........
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    20
    6
    A1z hcimcr・ sD isease，Par kinson'
    5D is
    case，Autism，PT SD. ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ... ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ..
    .. ......・. .. ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    207
    Clinica
    lCons i
    ueratiunsa ndG uidclincs
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ....... .
    .. .
    ...
    ...
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ...
    ...
    .一一 一 一 .
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ... ........ .......
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    207
    Duri ngP sy chotherapyS essi
    ons
    ...
    ..
    .....
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ...
    ...
    .... 白 .
    ....
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ....
    ..
    .. ...... ..........
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    20
    7
    COI1C山 r!
    .!
    ntP harm
    aco ther
    a py..... ・ .
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ...
    ..... .
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ....
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    .・ ・..
    .0.... .... .........
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    20
    7
    Self-Direc tedH01n~ Trcatmen t.. .
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    .........
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ....
    .
    .....
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ........ .............
    .
    ..
    ..
    .....
    207
    Evaluatin gI mmediatea ndLong- TermE ffe
    cl s........
    .. .
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    .....
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ....
    . 会 会 208
    Co ntra
    i n
    di cations.P rccnutionsa ndA c
    tvcrscE ffc ct s....
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    .
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ......
    ..
    ..
    ..
    . ・ ・ ・ . 0 .
    02
    08
    Con cJusion. ...
    .
    ..
    ..
    ... .
    ..
    ..
    ......
    ..
    ，
    ....
    ......
    .
    ..
    ..
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ..
    .....
    .. ...、 .....
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    .... ....... .........
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    209
    Refcr c11
    ces... .
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    .....
    ..
    ..，..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    .，
    ....
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ....
    ...
    ..
    ...... .
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ・ .
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ...
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...
    ..
    .. ...
    . .. ..........
    ..
    ..
    ..
    ...209

    NATURAlElECTRICITY:THEDISCOVERY the1 orp edofishstu nso rnumbsユI nf acl，thcword" narco


    tir
    .
    :"
    OFAPE仁UlIARPROPERTYOFFISH 叫 cmメ f r omn arke， whichi stheGr ee kwordf orthe
    set ypeぉof
    eleC1ricr ayl.s
    i h
    An ci
    c
    lllwr i
    ti
    ngぉ01
    1p ap
    yriinfonnu sIh<
    llelectr
    iじc at
    fishin Pe
    r ha p
    ぉt h efi
    rs tknownus eofwha t日 now悶 f e
    rredt o品
    theNileR iverwereused【or e
    lievepainb yt heEgypt ians cr ani
    ale l
    ect ro
    ther apys timlllat
    ion!CES)waswh cnc le
    ctrト
    4700y ea
    rぉa go
    .Thea ncic
    ntG rcc
    ksu sedthcl1110numbr hc califs hwer eappl iedtot hes kull10r elieveh eaua
    cheb ythe
    pai
    llnfじll
    ildbi
    rlhandsurgic
    alp roc
    edurcs.
    'I nhis380B. C Or cckph ysicianC la
    udiusO a len，whoh a
    以l
    dm凹もoreofan川1
    In
    】i
    日lu
    di叫ogueMeno.P Ja
    toa c
    cusedS o
    cratcsof“お t
    unnin gpeopl
    e't eI
    I
    目叩】C
    印e0叩n】 Wc山stcr
    n】a ndA I川
    ‘ぬ
    a
    l
    巾bi
    叫cM cω
    diC
    山
    口山1
    日
    川1
    児
    J
    lc1
    叩 山h叩 u n
    1
    叩町
    守yo
    川Ihe
    町r川 d出1一
    withhispu z
    zlingql
    lcst
    ionsinamanners imilarl'O t
    hcway v
    引iduω.
    a 1Oa 叫t
    le1Wi
    目叩 .
    出l
    sc
    凶 alled
    Ages ピ
    .‘a shi 2
    お、w “
    or dwasc ons
    引idcrcdg o spcla ndh凶 h umoral
    C
    anh
    ere
    :
    lch
    cda
    lJ、
    lll
    @cp
    ii.
    com th coryo fd iseasel as
    tedw elli ntothen ineteent
    hc e
    nt ury
    .He

    1
    89
    1
    90 B
    ioel
    ect
    rom
    agn
    eti
    candSu
    btleEnergyMedicine

    wasthen 叫 t
    r odescribem
    igraine.whic
    :hi
    . sderi
    vcdfromt h
    e tr
    an信じれ111旧 Il
    yt hr
    o u
    ghel ectro dcs.Thcb rainfu ncti
    o nse lectro-
    Greckwordhemikrania(ha
    lft h
    eh ea
    d).A
    fterinv
    eメtl
    galmg chemicall yandi tc anr eadi
    l yb emodulatedbyel ec
    t r
    icali nteI
    th
    ea nci
    enttrca
    tmen
    to fheadachewithtorp
    edofih，Gal
    s e
    n vent
    ion.U n likcp cri
    ph eralc le c
    tr omedi cine，CESh asb eenl ess
    、
    .vr
    otc frequ
    entl yc i
    t edinolder.h i
    s toriclit er
    a t
    ure.Kruegeri sp crh ap討
    then rs
    lp e円 ont om c nliont hisu日， n otingi n1 743t ha
    tl he
    Tht
    !v.'
    hol
    el orpedo‘md1mt
    、 :anthe 町 a ~ lorpedo 山川 id h y expcr
    Imcmals clιapplicationo felc ctricc ur
    re n
    ta l low edtIim
    sometoc ur
    ch e 出 1
    町 hea ndp r
    olapsus削 l Iwhena ppl
    icd.1 tosleepb e t
    ter.7A ld
    in iw rot ei nd e ptha b outils1I泊 m men-
    In
    ueedtrI
    eubo t
    hu ft
    h、 cl
    心 hin 、a
    臣 ndf oun ul 'l
    1tihertuh cI rue
    la
    ld is
    ea sei 11
    l 802.KManud 出 crib edt hea ppl
    i c
    ationo fstrong
    Therc
    fo問 I l
    h ougllllh
    cl orpedos houl
    db ca ppli
    cda li
    v c1 0
    curren臼a crosst h
    eh ca dth瓜 p roduc cdconvuI s i
    o1
    1ぉ."T hescl at
    -
    th
    ep er
    sonwhoh asthch ead:lch
    c.a ndi tl '
    ( 川 I
    Jh ct hatI h
    i日
    remed
    yjぉ<lnody nca ndc¥】ul
    df r
    cl' l
    h巳 p 川 I wtIro1ll p
    a1ll as te
    rsludie~ミ werc apr~ctlrsor t othedevelopmento fe l
    ec t此 co n-
    ot
    herrC01
    cdieぉw hi:hnumDt
    l he只cn討es:Thω[found1Ob じs o vulsi
    ves hockt reatment(ECT )i nt hc1 93 .1
    0s O

    AndIthinkthath ewh ufirs


    lt r
    icd巾 1ぉd i d叩 f ort hea bov e- Ori
    gi nallyr cf
    errcd1 0出 凶e lcじI roslecp:'th ei n
    t end edp ur-
    mCl
    llIon
    cdreasol1"l poseo fe arlyCESde viccぉh adb el!nt oi nduces leept hrou gh
    theappli cationo fs mallamounts0 1e
    ' lec1r
    icals timula tiont o
    G川はle
    目 n'scn
    町叩(
    吋d印
    ors
    盟c口ml
    刊C
    引訂n
    2 lmadet 山h
    i討t
    凶 リh
    阻etr
    l
    陀'
    ea
    l
    五
    叫tmcn
    川1ofch o
    印JC
    叫d or恥h
    1
    官en
    叫d- Iheb r
    ai na sap ri maryo ra djuncti vem od alityo ft he‘ slccp
    a
    i
    以ch ca叩1
    げ
    川nd0山 1
    h e【p 山 n 討 B cure"w i uelyempl oyed i np sychiatr yt hroughoutt hee arly
    、
    以 町

    a
    川ndsomewhous e d泊 t
    r口ide
    白1
    川1
    t
    叫 ‘
    at
    ω
    ( hreep rongcdm etals pear)!u r partoft het we nti
    ethc c ntury
    fishi ngc la imc dt hはI t
    hcs hockt hattravcle
    dupt hem ctals pear In1 90 2，th eFrcnc hphy si ologistS tcphcllLeducp r oduc cd
    rclic vcdt heira rthril
    Icp ai ns
    .Rccommendationsf ora pplying sleepinr abbi t
    sb yt hcl rans c
    r山口 0 1d eli v
    cryo f3 5vol ts，a t
    l
    iv et o rped o品s hl orh ca dac heandj ointpainpers s
    .
    itedt hro
    llgh- 110H7 .H
    . eat阻 mptedt oex tc n
    dh iss uccesses1 0hims elfwi th
    ou1m e dicv alEuropeandwerea dvocatcdb ylcad i
    ngMus lim HlOHzd ircctc urrc
    llts(OClo f3-1 2m illia mpcrc討 (mA)o f
    phy sic ianss u ch出 A vi cenna( lb nS in辻
    .)a ndA vc ro己si nt he a¥0%d uratio n
    .Whileheremainedc onsCIotls，hec ou ldn ot
    tenth山 1 de leve nthc enl u
    rieぉ， [nt he1 500s.Oawud‘ l
    l-Antak i， movco rs pcak，andexper i encedb lun t
    eJs ensalionso fpain
    IhcramousS yr ianp hysici anandp hilosopherdccl a
    r c
    dt ilOb e Usinghims elfasat e
    sts ubject.Leducu t tacheda nc lec-
    effe じれ vei n<.陀 l ie v
    ingじh ronich ead ache，unil
    ateralhe adach c trodet oh isf orehcadanda n
    oth ere lectroden eart heb ase
    (mi g raine)
    .andv e rti
    go.c v enind esperateじases叫 ofh i
    ss pine.H issen sationsa ft
    era d ministeringas erieso f
    Thcmo stp ow erfuls ou配 eo felectric
    itycamcfromt he 50-vol
    tpul sesi nI hcm illi am percr an gewcres imilart o‘ a
    hugeSout hAmcriconc c
    l(EI 出:Iroplwrusel eC
    lrictts)wh ich， drcamb utIwascon~ciou メ of t hca bぉenceofpowcrt omovc
    des pit citsname，日Illo rcc loselyr el
    atedt oag ian1c alhぉh anda ni nabilitytocommunicatew it hmyc olle‘
    19ues ;1f cl
    t
    Ad ul tsa ret yp ically6o r7f ee
    tl ongandc nngenerawe 1e ct
    ric thec o
    nl aCI，t hep inchcs，s tri k
    ingo fp insi nmyf o rca nn，b ut
    sho ck ぉ0 1u
    ' p1 0600v ollst hrough24f e
    clo fw ater，which thes ens ations wer ed ull
    e d叶'口 O espit eLeduc' sr e po
    r ted
    a l
    l o wsIhcmt of eed011o th e
    rn shand只m a
    llmarnmals .When ぉuccessw ilhcl ectr
    oa nalgesi a，thes eJ in
    ding sf a
    iledt oa ro use
    I h
    c ywereb r ou ghtt oEuropei n1 750，p eoplc1 10ckcdt ob e signif
    ica ntin tcr
    c叫 amongc li n
    icalp r
    a cti
    l i
    oncrso u
    lsiclco rt he
    tre atedw ithi ts‘・n‘ t1
    uralc lcctr
    icity，"cspccial
    lyt hoses ulT
    cl fo r
    merS ovietUnionandF ra nce
    ingf rol1la rthritis 111 91 4，Loui seRobino vitchd is linguishcdhetweenc lec-
    lric
    allyi ndl
    lc eds lcepanda n algcsi a，p roducinge lec
    l fics leep
    IIp
    I at
    te ntsぉl Iffe
    ringfrominsomniabya ppl yingan egalIve
    THEMODERNERA
    electrodct ol heforchcadandapo s il
    i v
    ee leclrodetot h ehand
    Thep rac ticeo fu 旧日 gclcctric
    alt ishe ve nll
    lulyd iminis heu Sher e
    p ortcd t hatp aticntsf c
    lla sleepw ithi nt h
    c 1ht rca t
    -
    follow
    ingt h
    ca dvento fth eLeydcnj arandV olta'sprimit iv
    e mentper ioda nclc ont inuedt os l eepa ftert hec urre ntw凶 ，
    ba
    ttcry
    .Thcぉewercmuchmorea c
    ces sibles ourcesofe lec
    - discont
    in lled.U
    lr
    ic
    ityi nd osagc討 tha
    tc ouldb ccOlHrolku (
    .) Thcworko fG ily arovs ky‘ mda s叩 じiatesi nt hef orm cl
    Atth ctumo fthel a
    stc enlUry，Ed日 0 1
    1andTe ぉl
    a'scJeclri
    tic
    ationo fNcwYorkandbeyond陀 p lac eJc andlcsandg a
    s
    I
    ightin
    g .l Ishe
    ringi nt h
    emodcrne raandb ringi
    ngp陀 v io usl
    y
    unimagi nahlet cchnolo
    gic s1ut h
    cp atcllto ffic
    candt hcnt hc
    market. During t hist ime，many phys icians and sciellli
    st
    s
    cxpcrim en tedw ith ar n
    u l
    titud
    eo fe lcctfOm edI
    c ald cvi ccs lnhos pl
    t ‘lst hep r occ dur eip
    討 cr f onncdi nh cd.Thcp at
    il!n
    .t
    andt hcira pplicmions
    .Thcsei n
    cl l
    ldedt hcmanyv a
    riatioll
    s undrl
    .山C
    ! 詩 a ndlic ~、 ùo\.v n a吋 t ho u ghforh i
    sn i
    ght'
    ss lccp
    oft r
    anscu t
    aneollsel ec
    tricはIn e
    rv cぉtim ulators(TENS)t ha
    l UsuaJIyc lcc(r
    icぉl ccpi ぉa dmil 】is lc
    rcd州 l lu1 tan
    col
    lsly1 0a
    continue st oev olvct od
    ayf o
    rIlll m
    er ousp a
    il1andnon -p ai
    n groupo rp atienlsinas cp aral!h
    l
    . a l f- d
    arken cdw ar
    d.G r
    a d
    ually
    lh
    cS CI刊誌 t i
    ollofh cavi nl!s
    . s0 1I
    ' hel id
    s.i ucaso f' go
    i n
    gor f'
    rc
    latcdc on di
    tions，a longw itht hcp utali vcme じh a
    niおrn sto
    explain叫 I chphenomena
    乱ppcar、 気o l
    TIctimesam il ddiz zi n ~日 oc curs ， a
    ndad ru、
    /
    -'
    .sy
    st
    ateぉu pe rνcncs.wh ic hgr adual ly< Ic
    . epen込 1 0l h
    cd cgrec1)
    1
    Whilee le
    ctrici
    lyh 出 his t
    or
    icalybecn1I児 dt hernpeu
    ti cally physio
    l(lgi c
    als leep .Th cp al
    It:
    l1l i
    si naぃ山 n陀 l axt
    :dp o則-
    ona l
    la rc a
    so fl hehndy ，c ra
    nialel ectroth c
    日 pys '
    ti
    mulat inn， ti
    on.uS Lla l
    lyo nh i討 s itlc
    . :t hcr c spir
    ationbecome d
    沿 ccpc'l
    orCES.i sa行p e
    citict ermdenot inge1e ctrica
    ls timula
    tio nt o slo
    w cr•.
    Lldl
    I TIor
    cr cg ul.r
    :
    l : th
    cp uJ叫 芯1 0川 U pb yscvcr
    alh cals
    thebrail1.CESi nvolvesdc v
    icesthatd eliverc l
    cc町 ic
    alcurr entぉ arnl
    llutじ "
    TheEvol
    uti
    ono
    fCr
    ani
    alE
    lec
    tro
    the
    rap
    ySt
    imu
    lat
    ion 1
    91

    l
    ni t
    scOJ 1tempor
    ar yform，CESi sade sccndal
    lLn tL
    " he 【04000h ertz( Hz )andcur renti ntensit
    yup1 08mi lli amper es
    aforeme
    nt旧 ned i nvesti
    gations
    . l n t he clectr
    oconvulsi
    ve (mA)，wh ilemor er ec
    e nld evic e
    su til
    iz ef requenciesa sl ow
    ぉhockparadigm，1 20v ol
    tsal60Hzand500mAwasa pp
    licd as0 .
    5Hzandc urrentl、
    it ensilya slowa s1 00m icroa、np erc s
    in 0.
    2sbu rsts
    . From t h
    ise l
    ectroan出 thc
    ぉia was dcri
    ved. (μAJ円 0' 1c our叫 a llI he措 v ariahl出Ille al
    】l tha
    tt her e sults
    whichu scdar educedc ur
    rc n
    tl ev
    clo f2v olt
    sa t700Hzand from diffcmmCESd cvicesv a ri
    c da swell，a n dthisr em山IlS
    30mAg ivcnf orthedurati 1o
    ol fJn，o
    り rsurg
    cry.A t i
    naldcr
    i- truewi t
    ht hede vicescommcr じia
    llya vailablct oday
    vati
    on10c lcじtros
    leepw出 p r
    oduc edb y700Hza t1v ol
    tand Thee vollli
    1 ono fe lectrodep lac emcJ1sw
    1 asp山 t i c
    ular ly
    5mA.Today' sCESd ev
    ic凶 t ypica
    llyd eliv
    crar a
    ngefrom notable
    .Ast het reatmcn ta rrivedi 1t
    l heU .S.f r omEurope，
    0.
    51 015，000Hzfroma9v o l
    to r1
    .5v oltAAo rAAAba llc
    ry devicesメu cha st hcE Icctroぉo neuぉeds alineぉa turatedga uzc
    souτcesuppl
    y ingfrom50microampere討 (μA)t o4mA pa d
    swrappedaroundme t
    alp la t
    esp l
    ac edo vere achc 10sed
    eyelidc onnec tedt oe lcctrodesp l
    n cedo vert he1 1剖 l
    1 oids.At
    thet imei twast h oug
    h tt hatt heeyωweret h
    eb e
    st，i fn ot
    CESCOMESTOAMERICA
    theonl y
    _p lacewheree leclricityじo ulde ntert hebrain.Lat er.
    Thc altc
    n Ino
    t、
    ( fp sy
    chiat
    ristぉ ande x
    perim
    entalpsychol
    o- be c
    au s
    eo ft hed iscomfor tf rom I hep re臼u reont hcey Ji
    c ds
    g日 制 i
    nlhcUnilc
    dStalc
    s¥ ¥
    'a
    sh ei
    g h
    tenedbycli
    nica
    lrc日a r
    ch andt c日 d
    h ee ff
    c ctofb lurrcdvi sionlastinga pproxi matel y
    conductcdinEuropei nvol
    vinge lcc
    tros
    leepth
    ata ppe
    a r
    cd 1 5-45min imn 】ediat
    e l
    yf o llowingt re川m ent，r e
    se arche r討
    inE ngli
    shl a
    ngungc journ
    als d u
    ringt helut
    e1 9
    60s.1
    元自b
    be gant op lacet hef rontale lectrodesj l
    ls la bovee ache y c-
    Pr
    ofe出 i
    onalinl e
    rcおlcoupledwi t
    hpopul arnoti
    olls0
    1 "
    、 inSl
    ant browwhi l
    et hcr carelectrUllcsr cmaillcdo verthema叫 o i d気
    s
    leep"achievcdI hroughte.
    chno-wizardryprompt edin depelト Suhs eq
    llcntly，thef r
    ontalc1ec trode話，v
    、 e
    悶Jlo longeru 時d ，wit h
    d
    cntc on
    su l
    taJ1l山 l
    db usiness
    ma n.ArsenJ wanovsky.1 0m山 - electrodeso nlyp laccdont h em剖 t oi
    dp ro cessesjustbeh in d
    k
    etadcvi ceh en amcdt heElcctroぉone50，a sAmcr ica'sifl叫 ca c
    hc ar.s ot hatt h
    cc urrcntwcntl a
    tcralya crosst hehcad
    p
    ortah
    lc.h attery-opcrat
    edc ranioelect
    ricalsleepg ene r
    ator inslcadofa nterio r-po日criorly.Thi sc ausedv e
    rtigo:the refore，
    aro
    uml1 973.17 Pri
    Oft othed e
    v i
    ce'sd ebut‘lwanovskyp llb
    - thee le
    ct rodeswerene xtmovedt ot het emp l
    es.Thel ypic al
    l
    ishedthcb as
    icc ircui
    ts chcmati
    cso ftheu ni
    tf ortheh enef
    it clcctrodcp la ccm cntu同 dl ouaycmpl oysc nrc lipc leclrod cs
    o
    fbiomedi c
    alf C同 archer
    sande xpe
    rim e
    nters.l e1ippedt oe ac he arl obe ，nlthoughsomed e v
    i c
    e凶 Sli
    lld i
    re ct
    Accord ingt op rom o
    t i
    o n
    alm at
    e r
    ialst hはtaccompanicd thec urre
    n ta crosst het cmples.15
    theue vice，l
    )(theE le ctrosonc50was山 口1f or“A制 I
    S1n
    t g1 1
    1
    thelid d
    so fr c l
    ax a
    tionanus leep
    ..r A
    Iv eryweak，p uls
    ating
    cle
    ctricalc urr~nt produc e
    dan dcontroll
    edi nthi
    sinstrumcnt EARLYELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHYRESEARCH
    passe
    st hro ught hep a t
    ient'
    sb r
    ainbymc.::ans0'1foure1ec ANDTHESUBSEQUENTEXPANSIONINTO
    lro
    u(ー l
    出 woa rcp lacedonl hec10seueyclid
    sandi ntheb ack01
    THETREATMENTOFM O O DDISORDERS
    Ihene ck(oc cipi
    talar e
    a):-Thes l
    eekandcompactE lcc
    tro拍 ne
    repr
    es cn
    tcdac Ollsiderabl
    ei mpro vcmento vcrthch u
    ll札口e問 Whcnat re
    atmc ntst r
    ategythmwoul dr eli
    ablyi nduce討Jec p
    。fGily ar
    o vsky"
    メo riginaldcsignduet otheu nit
    'sdependel
    1cc cou l
    dn otb e" tound.c 1e ctlひe ncep halogr aphy(EEG) s ll
    ld
    onV aCUUJl1t ubetechnol ogyfromt he1 9
    50s m
    .: 1C討 werei nitia
    t cdt oexumi net hepo ssi b
    len cu
    rop hys
    i o
    logic
    Wh叩 CESw品 。 円 t1 I1i
    lizc
    dinI hcUSA，p sychoph出 ma cventst hato ccu rrcd wh c nc urrcntwasa ppli
    eda crosst hc
    じe
    uti
    cal
    tre
    atm
    ent
    swerel
    e日 wel
    lknowl 1l h礼I1lheyarct oday head.Thef i
    rsts tudywasde si邑l edtos eei fther
    ewer eany
    見oi n
    tensei n
    terestwasg e ne
    ratedbyt hepo日 i bi
    1iti
    cs【halthis chan gcメ Int hcEEG r e
    l evantt os lccp.The l in
    " dings were
    llCWmcthodo ffcrcdf ort r
    eati
    ngd i
    ficu1
    f tp sych
    iatri
    cc a
    s e
    s inconc l
    usivea ssomepU L
    icnt ss lcptwhe ni nthet r
    catment
    Studieswer ec o
    nd u
    c tedi nunIve
    rsit
    yl aboratori出 10idc n
    lify condi ti
    on.s omes Ieptint hec ont r
    olc ondition，whileo thers
    themc じhanismso fa Cliont h
    atp ut
    ativelywcrer espol1s
    ible ncv c
    rs lcptduri nganyph aseo ft hcs t
    lldy.10
    fortheC I川 叫 1fl::
    SpOI
    lSCSb cginningtobco bscl刊 d.Morc An otherEEG叫 udyf o undt h a
    ton e30mine leじtr o
    sIccp
    deviccscameont hema rketw i
    thnamess u ch出 An酎 t heJec， treatm en
    tp erda yf or5d a ysp r oduc eds lowerEEGf requen
    Diastim，E lectrodorn，E lectr
    oson，Neurometer ，N eurotone. cicsw ithi ncrea sedampl itlldei nt hef ronto-tcmporala rc出

    Neurotransmi t
    terM odula tor
    ，RelaxPak，andSomleιamong ina l
    lo ft h
    ep alic n
    ts.Mostp atientsa lsoshowcdi ncreased
    others円 quulityandq uantityo ftheEEGa lphar hythmwit hi ncreas
    ed
    Thec 1inic
    alintentwast h
    ate l
    ectro
    sle e
    pt reatments hould am plitudeint hco ccipita
    l- par i
    e tallcads.21
    induccs lccpi mmediatelywhenl hec urrcntwasappl i e
    dt o Wci日 c ondllc t
    edane arlyEEGs ludyi nas l
    ecpl abora
    thep川 I e
    nt'shead，andt h a
    tt hepati
    ents hou ldremaina slecp tory，inwh ichp aticnlswhoha dbeend i agnosedw ithinsom-
    natur
    ally.onceI hcs l
    eepwasi n
    duced.Thald idnoto c
    c ur， niawcrca llow edt oslecpi nt h
    c i
    ru su alwayi 1lheu ni
    v c
    rsity
    however ，eVClt houg hmanyoft hecarliestd inica
    ls t u
    dics labora t
    orywh ileh av i
    ngt h e
    irEEGm onitor ed
    .F ivepa ti
    ents
    inthcUSAf ocuscdond iscov
    eringthewave 'ormt
    l ha
    twould wereg ivens l
    lbs enぉorye lectr oslecpt reat m
    e nt
    s30mind aiJy
    successfulyi nduces leepYR es
    earchersu sedav a
    riel
    yo ff r
    e- for1 0d a
    ys.andt ivewcreg ivenshaml reatmcnts.S ub
    sc quent
    qUCll
    CIC 人c ur
    rcntlevcI人 andwaveform ぉaswcl凶 c lectrodc mo nitoringo ft heirEEG討 Jcc pr 叫t ern見 showedt hatpa t
    ients
    configurat
    ions. Unf or
    tun a
    tely，notallr e
    p receiv i
    nga ctualt reatmcnt、 .
    v e
    n t10s le
    e pf asle
    r，メ p
    entr no
    l 志

    ti mei ns la
    gclVs leepd urin gt hcn ight，hadf ew e
    rn o
    ctur
    naJa 削 kening s，wenthac kt os leeps oonc rwhcnt heyd id
    1
    92 日i
    oel
    ect
    rom
    agn
    eticandS
    ubt
    leEne
    rgyMedicine

    awakeni nI hen ig ht，andr eporteds ig


    ni ti
    cantlyl 1Q
    l r cft !Slfu
    J MECHANISMSOFACT
    lO N
    and叩 s tor
    a tivesl eepuponawakeningt hen e
    xtl 110rn in gI han
    d idt hcs hamg rou p.!2 Allt hcsechan gesw erem aint a in edat Themcchani smso f‘Lctiono fCES h a ven otbeenc 1 car lv
    a2 -yea rfo llow_Up .
    l.l idcl 山M cd、howevcr ，s cv cral m乱 ・h anismsha vcb e cnp os tu-
    5001 1t hcre;
    tf
    . ter ，agrowingl 1u mbero fr esearche rsuem- la t
    e d.Mostcommonl y ，CES同 t hough tl obeder iv edfroma
    01 lstralcdt hatCESn oto nlyen suredsound，r cstfuls l
    e epf o
    r di rectmodeo fa ction，andt hus，undert heCun 官n tparadigm
    p atientss uf ferin
    gfromI nsomni a ‘bUlwasa ne ff cじIv
    l Ct reat
    - o ft houg .CESh
    ht asbeend e
    scribcul a rgclyf roman e ur o-
    l1lenlf ors tress-
    re latecl symptom sa sw ell，a sd et err nined b iologicals tandp o
    i ntr eg4 1
    r dingitぉ effect0 11e lect
    ricalh ra in
    t h r
    oughth~ l Ise0 1v
    ' ariousp sychologicala 臼C 州Illcnt日 a lcぉ01 a ct
    i vity，n eurotra nsmitte rs， andh orr non cs
    u n xietyandd e pr
    e s sion( c，.，H
    g amiJ tonA nxiet yS cal e‘S tate
    l Animals tu
    dic si ndica【edthmCESmi ghth‘IveOJ1e0 1two
    '
    Tr aitA n xiet y1 nve ntory，ZungDeprcs 臼01
    1Scal e，P ro fileo f p ossi h
    l ee ffect
    s: postsyn aptich yperpolar iヌa ti
    oJ1ora Jteratio ns
    MoodS tates.e tc
    .).Morei mportantly，itwa 民ω nfirmcdt ha
    t 111n e u
    r otran sm
    it terぉ 1 ne itherc usc‘ eurlyr e
    s earchr ev eal ed
    lu
    I merouspsychophy引 ol o gi
    cm e
    a sures，i ncludin gs leepp at ar e su
    l tanti n
    cr easei nt hcd egr ceo fi nhibitoryp roce sse s
    Ic rns，improvedr e gardles sofwhctherl hep atients lept du ring r esultingi na nalgesiaands lee
    p.IO
    .
    '..
    1
    'Subsequentr esear chi n
    th el realme nto rno. tIL2o CESf ocu sedont hec hang 白 l nn curo tranS ml
    t terc oncclltr a-
    Asa1 出 ult，t het erl1
    1・'electr
    osJ ec
    吟p W山 dr oppedi nt he Lo
    t ns .l na ne arlys tudy，p syじh ia
    tricp aticntぉandじo ntr obt h at
    USAal thou ghitr c maIn sinu 日 1 1pmt ぉ0 1E
    ' urop e.l nstead， lなじ ei ved5day ぉo fCESs howcdi ncrea sedu rin ar
    yl f日 ec a t-
    e ch olam inesb u
    tnoc h angci n1 7・ket osteroids.32Nonnaland
    Amcri じanr c search crお じl leditbys evcralnamcs ，inc lu ding
    ‘lranscrul
    li alel !c
    l trost
    il 1u
    1 l
    ation J
    呼 n1 978，t he Neurol ogy d cpr cssedぉu bjcctsr ccc ivingCESh atli ncr easedb loodcon
    P anelo ft he Food and Drug A d ministratioIl( FOA) s ug- c ent rationso fser otoninan dc holi n
    e sterasea fterone20min
    E山 t cdthmi thec alleu‘ ιn
    l川 ale lcctrolhemp y."TheFDA se s
    si o
    nandf ol
    1owing2 wcekso fd aily20mins c日 ions.3 J
    ag r eed，butadded【h eword‘s timulation"tot hep h ra se，a s Ac l
    d ilional ly，s uhs Hn
    l ce n bu scs ub jcct謁 r ccciving 30t11i n
    th eywer en oty etconvi ncedt hatitwast he
    rapeutit:
    .TheFDA se s
    si onso fCESf or4weck討 hadi ncr eaぉedb Joodc onc en-
    al sod c termi nedt hntCESwouldhco n lya vailablcbyp r
    e- tr a
    t ionso fm onoami llcoxi daseーBa ndgal1l町l Haminob u tyri c
    sc ription
    .m 41kingt h
    eUSAt heo nl yco untryi nt hew or l d問 ac id(GAB A)t ha tal叩 c orr espon dcdwi thani mp rovemcnt
    、
    .vh ichan0 1叫e rfr nl11al i cens
    edh ealthc arep ractitionc rmust ins yr npt omsi nc ontra stt ot heC Ol
    l t
    roJg roup.However ，1 10
    bco bta inedf orilメu se，nr estricl
    ioncomInueut hrou ght o day c han ges weren o ledi n concentration.~ o fs erotonin.do pa -
    CES 1 10Wh asa f ound 41
    tiono fmoret han 50y e ar so f m ine .o rb ct a-c
    n dorph ini nthmstlldy. '~
    rc 封印 Irchandc li
    nic alH S Ci nt heUSAfromwhichp ro o fof A ぉmal s tudy o fv olu n【eersr cveal cd an i n creasei n
    sa felye ln
    def fecti venessh avebecnw clle stabi
    l討hedf ort hc cc r
    e bralぉp inalf t
    uidc onc en trar
    ionso fs erotoninandb eta-
    no nhi山 c d田 vl :w
    t er cn do rphinf ol
    lo wing20mino fCES.Thea vcra g
    ei nじre a日

    、IJ山.;r
    ala hcommented0 1
    1ps ych ial
    ry'sf uture.p r edi cting forb
    山 b jec
    e
    t a-endo
    thada21
    rphilJ was 50% from ba;
    9lkI ncr ease. J
    5Thc 日 d
    予

    at
    el
    .s
    int
    h
    !a
    ou l
    lt
    hou
    dbevi
    ghont
    ewed
    !

    tha t‘n eurosli1lu


    1 lati onf orb ra
    inr cpair"wason eo fthet o p引 x
    tr endsi nd in icalp ract
    i じe.H Hec it edr ep
    etit
    iv et rans cra nial wi thc uutio na ぉt hes ma lls amples izei n じludede xecuti ves
    mu 芭netic山 I nulatio n(rTMS) ，vaga lncrv cstimula t
    ion(VN 針 0'1aCESm anuf actu re r
    .However，t hoscpo 出 ibJechemi cal
    。nddcepb ra in叫 i mulatioll(OBS)，a l
    lo fwhi chn rei llva sive ch
    IO
    a
    c
    r
    n gesa
    c制 c dn
    rec
    eu
    o
    r
    nsistentw
    otnmsmi t
    i
    t
    thd
    erc
    i
    o
    n
    n
    c
    i
    e
    calf
    ntra
    i
    t
    n
    io
    d
    n
    ingsぉu
    smayb
    gge
    s
    ci
    tingthm
    nvolv ed
    andc ostlymedicalp roce uures.CESI s4 1ls
    on euros tim ula tion
    forb r
    a inre pairandi nc ontrastisaロlOr ec o
    st-effectiv e.1 10
    n- int hes edativee ff
    e c
    tso fCESw ithr eg ardt oGABAand
    in vasivct ypco fdc v icet hatca nb es af
    elyu scdbyp ati cl1lsat be ta、cn do rphinぉa tt heGABAundmuo pio idrcc ep
    t orsit出."(，
    ho rne.Itcanbeus eda sa na djut
    1ctt om edicationo rp s y じho- B cca useGABAs ervcsa sam ajori nhibitoryn eurotra nsrnIt -
    th crapyo rlISas t山 l d-alonct rcatmen.tTheo n
    lycontraindic~ト teri
    可 n
    cr e
    4 1sedじo ncentr ati onso fGABAmayr esu
    lti na n x-
    tio ns10CESa rep r egnu nc yandh a vingapaccmakero ro the iolysis.L ikewi s
    e.s cdati oni son er e州 lt0 1muo
    ' pioidr cccpt or
    st imul ation.S eve r
    als tu dicsr ep
    ortd e じreaメedo pioidr equ irc-
    mC I
    TheE
    vol
    uti
    ono
    iCr
    ani
    alE
    lec
    tro
    the
    rap
    yStimul
    ati
    on 1
    93

    neur ot日 n Sl1littcrr el c出 e d and a vail、a


    tl ew ith ini ls
    . yn a psc opiatcusea ndgi v
    ene ithera lphamethyldopa( adopamine
    al:-
    ;oa ffe ClSt hca 、
    ctil ityandc he mistr yo f、p roxln aten ClIr onぉ andn orepinephr i
    ner e upta keb locker
    )01 'C ES: sHer oIna ct s
    川 l hc1 ，淀川 e nvironmcnl . Aぉ av aricty0' 1d rllgsc an込f fcCl 01endogenol 1sopioid1'ece ptorおint heb r
    a in，d ow n~rcg ulatin g
    lhe 討eme cha ni日 n s .t he yc ana lsob e1I品目ja src~、ea rc h t ool s tht
    !p rodl
    1cti
    ol1o fe ndo r
    ph in.andt hus，d is t
    u rbi ngnO' e
    lpi
    lh<lt
    . atle rhr ainc he mi stryandt huぉ behav iorsundo thc rpメy - nep h
    rineprodu じti
    oni nl hel o c
    usc er11
    1e us.Whenh croini s
    むh iatrice ffcct s
    . discontinud叫 n日 l
    c i乏ctlo p io
    idr ec e
    pt ors0 11n or c p
    ine phrin e
    Poz os 'g r ou pi nc reaぉc dt heamounto fdopi 1l
    1 l
    inei nt he ne uro
    ns evoke 込n1 11linhi bi
    tedr el
    e凶 eo fn o rep inephri ne 町

    brain:-;o fexpe riment al dogsb y‘ ldmi nist erin gt hedrugr e se


    r - 、
    .vhichactsata drenergi cr ec!pw
    t rso fthec entra la ndp eriph -
    p1l1C、号ν hk .
    :bi nd u ccsar ohus lrel easco fdopaminel h rou gh oul uraln crvou
    ss ystcm討 t op roduccc hはrac t
    e n
    s t
    lじ wi thdrawa l
    theb r ain.Dopaminec olltrolsav ariet y0 1b
    ' e hav io問、 r nost signsandsymptoms
    no ta bl yr nov em c ntandcl1lo tionals tatus.Pozo ゲ r c叫 r j1lle
    1 Int hestud y
    .h alft hep a
    tienl話 rcce山 臥JC ES w hi let h e
    tr cat eddogsJc v cl op cdm ild1 1l0ve mcnta b nor ma li'
    li山 ( e.g
    .， othcrhalfwereg
    司 ivena lphamc thyldopat ob loc kt hcpo stsyn -
    tr cmo r )‘ lSar 出 u lto fc lop amined eplet ionand1 0日 0 '1I1c ural apticnorepine p
    h ri
    n er ecep to
    rs.Thosep a ticl
    1tst hath以 1been
    口r cul白 川 t hcmotora rca ぉ1nt heb raint hata re山 mula ted t
    r cated wit
    ht hun orc pine phrine nwptake b lo
    ..
    :k c
    rd idn o t
    byt hen eu('
    (予t r
    <ln 引n 1tlera じetyl cholinc.Thcd cc rcaseddopa- showp rof
    oundw i】
    1tdrawalc ffec
    lsbl 1tt hcya 1
    Ic xper icnce d
    min ci nt her即時 rpine ~ trca ted d o gsl edt oa ni mha laI1l:co f reboundd epre s
    sion.1 1
    1c Olltr
    ast，CESt reatm:
    tn tr esultedi n
    ace t y lch()lin e~in du cc d mo lOrs t i
    m ul川 i on.l nte restingl y，CES palient
    sbccomingh c
    r oinab叫 i nentwi thol
    lla nywi thdr awa l
    pr n duc cdt hcぉanl ec f rec
    la sres erpine ， soi1wash ypot h cs izcd 01'd叩r css
    ives igns01 's ymploms .Manymorc叫 u dieswcrc
    thatek じ訂正1.11 s tirnul a t
    iono ft heh rai nwasc apahl en fa l
    te ring condu ct
    ed01s ubstancca buぉep opu l
    ation sandt henmood
    th er e lea seo fn cu rol r a
    ns milters disordersbcc amct hcf oc uso fmodcrnr l!scar ch'
    . 気

    Tocxami ncf u rrhe rt her olco fCESonnじlr otranS 1


    l11th.
    :r
    見y stems ，ther c討c arc h e
    rぉι liscontin uedt hea d min istrat io nof
    MOREE
    lECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHICSTUDIES
    凶1 d r ug 諸 山l dI ct ha lfo f
    th edogsr estw il ht he i
    ru日 m lalotmen t
    off ooda ndw a le.rThe yf ou ndl hatt hes ea n ima lぉr Clun1c dt o Aboul20EEG叫 u diesh avea ppc arc di nt heCESI it crat
    u rc
    ana pp ar cnl lyn o rma ls tatew i thi n3~5 days .Anotherg r ou p beginn ings hortlyafte rCESa じh ieve upopul arityi nE astcr n
    hadt hed ru g漏出 s con t
    i nucdbuい 刊 山 g ive nCESt re at me nt Eu roped uringt hel a
    l ee山 I y1 960s.U i， ngc nhanccdEEG
    Thct h cor ywast ha tifCESs timulat edt hed own- rcg ul atc d lechnol ogy.U. S
    .r c日 a rchc rぉc ontinu cl hi治 typeo fi nvestiga-
    dop はm lneぉyメtem，t h ca ni mal討 woulc 1r ctl1r nt on o rrnalmore tiontot hisday
    qUlじ k l y
    .The dogsgi vcn CES r elur n山 1t on o rnwl w i thi n Rcs earcht od atch品 shownt ha tCESt rcat mcntuvok e s
    3-7h，whichwascompa rablet or cじOもe rys eenf o
    11owingt h c ac han gei nlheEEGp attcrnofc vcr yp c日 ont owhomi ti s
    au rni n ist ra
    t ion0 1l
    ' hct Io
    . paminep rccu rぉ0 'L
    1 -do pa.Thi お 討ug - applied. CES i nducc 討 おignif i
    ca ntc ha ng e
    si nt he EEG a s
    g e叫 st hatCESa pp e arst o引 i mu1alet hedopamines ys tem. showni nt hcb rainmapi nF igu re1 9.1.l ti n crcas csal p ha
    a lt ho ug hI lisn otknowli ft h
    ise f fe
    c ti お札lirccto rI ndirc cl (8-12Hz )r clati
    vepo wer . andd cc rcas csr clativep oweri n
    PO χ osa ls os t uui cdI heb io chemi cald fec tsofECTand thed elt a(0-3. 5Hz ) and b et‘
    1( 12.5- 30Hz )f 陀 quenci es.+1
    foundIhemt ob es imila rt oCES.Hes ur m isedt hatt r eat lncreas cda l
    p hac orre l
    ate sw it hi m pr ovedr cla xation and
    Ilc
    1 ntwi lhCESwoul d叫 c omp l i
    s ht hesamec ff eclsa sECT， 1I
    1cre出 edme nt
    ala lertncsso rc1a r
    ity.Dccr e‘I
    s cdddti lw
    . av es
    bu to v ert heCOlHメeo fsc vcralwec ksi ns tcado fm illise conds. ind山 atear eductioni nf atigue.B et awaver ed uction sfrom
    Convcr sely，1 l 0ne o ft he n c
    g ative 日 de c ffec l
    sf rom ECT 20-3 0Hzc orrclatcw ithd ecre ase si na nxiuty 、ruminative
    s h oul dbc(:nωun tc 町 di nt hep roc凶討 lh ou
    ght s‘andob 問、 sivc/co mpul sivc-likeb ehav ior s
    Inn na tt emp tt ode termineap ossibl ec ellu lnrme ch a nism Low】 山 O I
    U t
    iOI1el ectr omagne tictomography( LORETA)
    o fCES.S i cgc slIlu ndandh isc ow orke rsexamincdwh c thcr andf u nctionalm agnet icr esoniln
    . c eima ging(fMRI )s tud
    i 剖

    de ct rica ls l im u lm iona Hc ctedt hcq uan tity01 'q ua lityofne ll- showedt ha
    tCESr cac hcda l
    1c ortic alandS 1b
    l cOfli cala r
    c as
    rotran~‘mitter r ele ase日 Neul'Ot ransm i
    t tersa res torc
    tli nv 臥ト oft hcb rain.p roducingc h ange討 s imila rt ot hos ei nt luc
    edby
    cleλP‘ Ic klS，，1
    e ι hcm i calst hatu pons timu lali ona rer el ea sed anxiolyt i
    cm ed ic
    a tions羽 .6 Man ys ymptomss ee ni np s
    y chi-
    inl Os yn a p
    ti cs pa ce1 0e xcn ana ctio n.S igi smund' 討さ r ou p atricc o n
    dition人 s Ic
    l h辻s mx ， lety，1I1SOml1lユ. anda t
    lc nLIon
    f o un dt hatel ect r
    i じa l叫 i l
    111l
    l ation0 1t
    ' hcb ra int cndedt of Olじe detkitd i
    sordersa ret hough tl obee xace rb川e db ye x cessC OI
    t hep rl!ぉy
    - na pli cv e sic
    le只 p reSCl1t(Q r ekasct heI1 じo n tcl刊誌 t
    i calact iv
    alion，4
    7AsAnfMRIs t udyi na na nxi 目 yp op ulation
    inlOt he showedt hatCESc al1sc討じ o rticalb rainu e activa t
    i oni nt he
    mi dlinef rontalandp arietalr eg iols0 '1theb rail】 af t
    erjllS t
    on c20mintreatmen t.~~ An othc rfMRIs tudywasc onduc t
    ed
    asp arto f"randomlycon tr o
    llcdd oub lc-blindl rial( RCT)
    inap ai npopulationt hatr evcale dg r e
    a terd ecr ease si na ver-
    a gepai nl evds(p=0 . 023)t h ant hos elIS】ngashamd eviじem

    re C
    CIV11lgu おualc arew ith outCES.4 り Thca ctiveCESd e v
    i じe

    wass hown1 0d ecreasea ctivationo fpai np r仁じ c s


    slIlgr e
    glOn s
    o ftheb rain，sllchast hec ingula tugyr us ，insulaandprdron-
    ta1c o
    r tex，comparcd1 0thes hamd evic c
    1
    94 s
    ioel
    ect
    romagnel
    icandSubl
    teEnergyMedicine

    D
    eJt
    a(1
    .0-3
    .
    5Hz
    ) A
    lph
    a18
    .0-1
    2.
    0Hz
    ) B
    eta(
    12.
    5-2
    5.0H
    z)

    .~、

    • •• ，

    0
    .00 0
    .03 0.
    06 0
    .00 0
    .03 0
    .06 。 0
    .03 0
    .06 0
    .00 0
    .03 0
    .0
    6

    B
    eta1(
    12.
    0-1
    5.
    0Hz
    ) B
    eta2(
    15.
    0-1
    7.5H
    z) B
    eta3(
    18
    .0-2
    5.0H
    z)

    。 。 。
    。。
    .。
    .
    0
    .00 0
    .03 0
    .06 。
    。 0
    .03 0
    .06 0
    .0
    0 0
    .0
    3 0
    .06 0
    .0
    0 0
    .03 0
    .0
    6

    FIGURE 19.1 ( Sceo ol


    ori n実e
    rt.)Rclai
    lv
    cpowcrp .v
    alucl o
    pogra
    phi:a
    ll mapf o
    r0. 5Hlc rani
    alcle c
    tro
    [hc r
    apy汎 imul
    atio
    ll(CE
    S)
    St
    at
    i山 calys i
    gni
    ti仁antchang
    じs '<O
    (
    1 .OSorhcl
    tl!
    rJaf
    lcra引 ngk0.5H又 CESおじ州川n山 ' ci ndj仁川じ dhycolOl‘ whit
    ci m
    Jiじa
    tcsno則 gn
    ilk
    ant
    ch
    ung.Thじ a
    c r
    ro
    ¥'
    .'i、nt
    lic
    atcthcd
    irccl
    iol
    1ofじhan
    gc.Star
    iぉti
    cnl
    lysig
    niti
    ca
    ntdeじn:
    :a
    sc芯 W 白 ℃ 叫 山 1i
    ndcl
    ta: mdh c
    t;
    ，twit
    hs t
    ati
    sti
    ca1
    lyμgn
    if
    i
    (a
    nlinc
    r c
    aおじメ i
    ni
    ll p
    ha

    Thc ahove mecha川 町ns providee vidence that CES f


    r omCES.ma ya lsof u
    el01 'enhancet h
    isp ro
    cess.Con s
    ciolls
    changcsthebra
    ini nawaythmr educcsal1xicty，de
    pressi
    on， dircじtin，i
    o ntcntionalilyo
    司 rmindfulnc 州 ぉhownt o込IterEEG
    andp a
    in.Ital
    sohc lp
    ぉp eopl
    ef斗1a
    : slecph yi oducingrc
    lax- patternscouJdp rovi de s imi
    larb enel
    ltst o陀 s to
    renormal
    at
    ionw hi
    lede
    -crea
    singcompulsivet houg
    hts fuoctionwhenho me osta s
    i sist h
    reatened
    Thcrc arei ndividuals wi thout any obviousぉi gnifi
    cul
    lt
    phy si
    ca.
    llTIe
    nt al，o rcmotionalproblemsbu tmallyar en 01
    THE仁L1NICALROLEOFCES
    functionin
    g01'p erf ormi ngo p
    timally.Ina dd
    itioI
    l.then umcr-
    CESmayb cs ccn， th
    e n，l10tu sat n:
    : a
    tmcntf oras p eci1icd is- O
    ll討 psycho叩 cialp res sureso fmod ernl i
    fcplaccani nc
    reas-
    order，butu 舗は b ioelcctrica
    li nterv
    e n
    t io
    nt 1a
    l ta ctst h
    rol lgh inga llo
    sta
    ticl oadt hatc 札口 contri
    butct oav arict
    yo fs l
    re山

    mc じhanisl
    1lsk nowl t obec onsistcmw i
    tl 】 thef u nctionso f rel
    atedc ompl山 n tsandd is order
    s.CESma yh el
    p1 0p rcv
    ent.
    varIousphy siolog icalf unctio日sundt hee f feCLぉ 0'
    1d rugst h川 lesscn
    .o rale viateI hesei nane xt
    remcl y泊 fe出 ldv eryco蕊l

    叩::rrcqu回 t lyp rcscri hc


    df o
    rt hesamci ndi cmio n吋 el1eじtiv
    efashio n
    Whilet hee xactmech叩 i smo fCESr emぬi nsu llclear，t he
    samcI st r
    ucf orpharma colog ic
    ali ntcrvcnt i 1su
    ol s edt ot n::a
    t
    仁L1NICALSTUDIES
    mooddi sorder 丸 山l di ts ecmsl ikel
    yt ha
    tbOL hha veぉi mil ar
    Cfr
    e c
    lsO l
    lll.
    C::uro
    transm It
    te rsoro t he
    rr elevantn 】ech anislls
    1 Atp resent.ther
    ei saweal t
    hofda ta011CESf romo vcr50
    Mostp ractilIon crs1 nt hef astgrowi ngf ieldso fcomple- ycars0 1r
    ' esca
    rch.As w Itht hec hemical compo 別t i
    on0 '
    1
    mcn tar
    y.i ntegr a
    t ive.andはI tcrnativcmc d icineassumct hat drugs.e achCESdc vicehasad i
    fferen
    twaveforms oc1in
    i-
    thebodyw ilhe ali ls
    elfifith山 t hen ecess aryb uildi ngb loc ks cianssh ould10tg eneral
    izcther es
    ear c
    ht o‘1genencc a
    te-
    (c.
    g.，p ropcrI lll
    trition and トi uf
    ficicntc x crcise.)R eparaLiv e gory0 1CESa
    ' sr e
    sultsfr
    omt h
    cv arioustcchnolo
    giesd if
    fer
    processcsr equir een e rgyf rom ATP .¥ vhichi sp r odlcedby widely
    .I nI hc1 970swhenCESwasncw1 0I heU.S..mo 幻
    oxidativephos pho ryl
    a ti
    oni 1t
    l heelectront rans portchai n.I t oft h
    er cscarchwasdonew it
    ht heNeUl'OLOnede v
    ice，whi ch
    柑 emsp la
    u日 hl ct hatanc l
    ectricalbo ost，whctheri tbef rom 日c
    1
    I d1 00Hzi na20%d utycycIewithamaxIl1lu rnc urrc
    nt
    ekじ trou~upunc lure， elec
    tri叫 I
    L01'c¥cctromagnet icstimul 川1 0
    11 l
    evelofI .Sm il
    l i
    amp e
    re只 Thc山 町 earchmethodolo gyu sed
    TheE
    vol
    uti
    ono
    fCr
    ani
    alE
    lec
    tro
    the
    rap
    ySt
    imu
    lat
    ion 1
    95

    AI
    pha
    -S
    tim¥lA
    IDw
    ave
    for
    m 3000p at i
    ents凶 却 [n川 o thersurveyo f152S erviceMembers
    300
    undv eleranscon duct
    e dforFDAi n201 Jt heoutcomes.wh il
    e
    三2∞ t川 町 gn
    s it
    icam，、、r
    札 cn olquileasr obusta sp r
    iorsurvcys0'1
    刷
    v ci
    vilians.幻 However ，at hir
    ds U'v
    I e
    yc on ductedin2013 o f
    邑1
    00 2861S er vic
    eMembers.v eteran
    s，andc i
    vilianswasc10scr10
    E
    。 theorigi na
    ls urvcyo rcivili
    al刊 T hisconl innsthco bsc
    rva-
    』
    出 tio
    nt hatS erviceMembersandv cteran
    swhou seCESmost
    E
    S-1
    00 li
    kelys uffe
    r from more e .
    xtrcm et rauma， and.t her
    efo陀，
    H

    E cxpenencc討l i
    ghtly]essc fli
    cacyt hanac ivil
    ian-onl
    yc ohort
    5-
    200 Never
    t heless.ther e
    sl
    tlts問n1aJn日邑 n incant(， 50%)a
    ;
    0 ndthey
    u
    .
    tF
    ∞

    shouldb econsidcredasc l
    in
    icallyr el
    evan igurc19.3p r
    o 叩

    2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1
    0
    vi
    clcsad cta1
    ied日 lmmaryo fallt hrcco ft hcpOSImarket -
    T
    ime
    (s) ingsu rveysc o
    n ductedforFDAt ota
    lingne ar
    ly6000S er
    vice
    Members， v
    eteran，andc ivil
    ianse l
    f.re
    porl当
    FIGURE 1
    9.2 ThcA
    lph
    a-S
    tim w
    avc
    for
    msh
    owno
    vcra 1
    0s
    p口io
    d
    仁H
    MODERNRESEAR
    AsCESh a
    sbecnc e肝 edb
    l ytheFDAf o
    rl helr
    catmentof
    wascon sisl cn
    tw itht hes t:lndar dso ft hed a y.b l
    ltf a
    llwc1 l
    bcl 、
    ovmo dc rnst a
    nd ards.Dcpcndi ngont hed e v l ce.thcq u al・
    a
    m
    n
    a
    X
    r
    Jc
    .

    il
    t，lnsOmnta‘ andd
    y
    yforthesci ndica
    ti
    c
    p
    o
    r
    n
    s
    c回 l0nS
    .Aぉ ar
    l
    ll
    e
    s
    じc1
    llJ
    78，i
    9
    r，ther
    li
    su
    ear
    s
    cdp rト
    enumer-
    it
    yo ft hcr es
    (ふ1C
    1
    " l
    1p rotoco l，i nclu dingt hcb 1
    in d ingmethod，
    ouss u
    pport
    ives t
    ud iesandpubliじat
    iol
    lSb u
    to nlyrc
    ccntone見
    int hos ee arlys tudiese xhib itcdI11 ix~ù 問slllts. ! ~ Whilet h erc
    th
    atcomplyw itht hemorer i
    gidcurr c
    nls ta
    ndar
    usw il
    lbc
    arcc op icso fthcNcu roton ewa 、
    .
    reforms oldu n d crt hcb ran d
    describe
    dinthis日 C 1
    10
    11.
    namcso fCES U llraandH ea lthP ax，s cvcralo lh
    crp riv atc
    Jabe le
    uv e日i on
    so ft heset h ata rcs t
    illont hemarke t山 宮 p ro
    dl1ccdh y只m allcomp anicsw ith1 10r esearchs t udic
    s1 0山 l ト
    ANXIETYDISORDERS
    portt he i
    rじl aims
    Mo 叫 r c ccn
    tCESs tudie su sc山 l ia
    hlcandv alido ut
    ，(O J
    llじ Anxi etyd isor dersar~ cha r
    a ct 即 日 以1byami じi pat
    i onofaf u tu
    re
    I
    11ca sur emc nts c
    all沿 T
    ! het n.日orityo ft h
    e s
    eh av cbccnC OJ1- thr
    ea t，c xce州 i vcf ca
    r，andr cla
    tcdh eha vior ald istu rban ces
    du cledw it ht heAlpha-SlimCESd evice，whichh川 b ecn Fcari s削 討 ociat euwit ht he山 町 お r espons c，o r日 lrgc討 ofsym.
    pr o
    grcs siv clyr c
    f i
    nedo vcrt hep a s
    tt hreed cc a d es.Itl l
    SC日 a pathetica rou salS CCI1inngh lo rO ight問 符 p ons es‘t hou ghts
    comp lexi lndp atcntcdb ip olar出 ymmetricwavcf ormc on - ofimmcd iarcd ang er，andc s capeh ehaviors .Anx icty日 a l
    so
    si
    s '
    li
    ngo Fm ultiplef re ql
    le nciesa ta5 0cad l lt y ιycleh aving oncna ssoじi ateJ¥-¥' hi
    叶 ncre as edmus dct c
    n sionIln
    . uv igi l an
    ce
    av aria ラJ
    l cp uls
    ew id thwi thamaximumd ur ati ollo f0.5Hz inpr eparationf orf utur
    ed a ηg eralon gw ithc au
    ti 1s
    ol ora v oid
    (2ゆ p rovi dedo vcra1 0st imef r am ew it
    hr and oll
    lf actorst o antb eha
    v io
    r s.A n xietyp a ticntst ypical l
    yo vere s
    ti matet he
    av o
    i dh abit uati
    onbyt hen er vouss ystcm.ThemaxImumcu r - dang crins Itu atIonst hcyfe aro ravoid.A n xic tyIsabou tt，、Vl
    ce
    rcntl evelo fthcd cvicci s600microampereぉ Thcimpe d an cc asp revalcnti 、
    nνome nロ
    ra nιew it hinwh icht hewavcformp ar山n etersr cmaInv alidi s Thck eyf eatureso fgC l1c nda nxietyd isordero rGADa re
    fro1
    111 00Q t o1 0KQ.Thcwavcformi sb ala nc ed10a chic vc pcrぉistcntande xccssivci l nxiet
    yundw o rry.whichi mp airs
    ol1etcurrentincitherdircctionasshownioFigure19.2 worko rs cho olp erform an cct h川 t hei ndividua lf indsd if
    -
    Randomly c o n
    tro lledd ouble- blindt rials0 1 CES c
    ' a n tic
    ultt oc ont roLI na ddition，a ffectedp alicntメ e xpcnence
    bca じC O!II
    T ヲlish
    cdt o dayi l
    lt hcぉamem‘iOl1C rl 1s cd10c v alu一 phys icalsymptoms，i ncludingr cslc州 n e州 o rf e e
    l i
    n gkcycd
    川ep ha rmac eUlicals.Asd o sag ecanbep ortr a y edasc urr ent Upo roned 呂e ，b einge asil
    yf atigued.d i
    H h.:ul
    Lycon cent ra ti
    ng
    inuirect l
    yp ro
    portiona lt ot ime，d ouhle -h
    l ind in gi s以 ;hie ved ormindg oin gb l ank，irritability，1lU
    1 気じlet ensi
    o n.a nds le
    ep
    hyr edl1c川 gt h
    ec urr c1lt
    1 oas ubs ensory1 00m icroamp crc s distur banccs史
    whl iei 即 日 制l n日 theu ぉual20mint reatme1 1lt imcl oaf u1l An xietyd isord erぉuffect40m illionAmericuna d ult
    sa ged
    ho ur.Thef ollowingi sasummaryo ft hiぉl110d ernl e
    velo f 18a ndo ldcr，o rab out1 8
    .1 %o ft hepopuJ alion
    .A nxi ctyd is
    RCT山 l d
    ie s.opcnc linicalt r
    ials，a nds ci
    cntiiica l lyc o n
    d uct ed ordersf r eq
    u entl yC O-Qじc u
    rw ithd cprcssi v!d
    l
    . isor d
    e rso rs ub-
    sur vey日 叫a nc ea bl
    1scandmos tp eo plcwhoa red iagnose t
    lwi thone
    typeo fanxi etyd i sordcrof tend evelopo t hcr sY
    Ta blc1 9
    .1l itぉ n
    s inerandomi泊三dcOl lt
    roJledt rias(RCT)，
    l
    SUMMARYOFTHREESURVEYS(
    N=5917)
    cighto fwhicha red ouble- blindHIH .01
    l lCt hati品 川v estlg ato
    r-
    P
    eer-re
    vicw
    edoutcomescondu
    ctedOntheAlpha-
    Stimbrand blindw it hs 1m
    l mari出 o ft her csearchOlltcome 市b asc d011t hc
    o
    fCESf orFDAfrom2500p at
    icn
    lsurv
    cysp u
    bli
    shcdin2001 measurements c 川e su scd.T ablc1 9.2showsf ouroJlc n- lab
    cl
    c
    orre
    late
    dwellwith47p hy
    sic
    ian
    s'repor
    tぉo n500pal
    icl
    lts studiesandf ouru問 rs urv cys1I1V出 tiga tingt hee f
    f i
    c a
    c y01
    T
    hi長 da
    tareve
    aledthata日 gn
    ifl
    can
    teffcctofatle
    ast25% t
    r e
    ati nga nxi etyw ithCES.T able1 9.3以lmmanze ぉt he且nd -
    tm
    provem
    clltwaぉ r
    cport
    cdbyn i
    ncout0'1tc
    ninagroupo f ingso ftwom C la-a nal
    y ぉeso fCESs tud ieso fa n
    x i
    c l
    y .The
    9&
    1 Bi
    oelect
    romagnet
    icandSubll
    e EnergyMedici
    ne

    S
    elfr
    epo
    rtso
    fimprov
    ementfromAlpha-5tImu
    ser
    s
    compar
    ing20
    01.20
    11.and2013s u刊 e
    ys
    S
    igni向c
    ant注
    ( 25%)
    。% 20% 40
    % 60
    % 80
    % 100怖 I
    mprovement

    2日01C 25.
    79も 6
    7.0% 1 92.， N=679
    7%
    Ao剖 et
    y 2
    0115MV 2
    0.2% 46.6% 66.
    7， N=11
    % 4
    20135MVI亡 23.4% 59
    .5% 82.
    9崎， N=714

    2001C 28.8% 6
    5.明色 93.8%，N=163
    Insomni
    a 20115MV
    20135MV/仁
    20
    .
    20
    4
    .
    4
    %
    %
    4
    4.8
    %
    57.
    5拍 .
    - 65
    77
    .2%，N=88
    ‘6%，N=230

    200
    1C 21併も
    36
    .0拍
    o
    'l
    も 3 54
    9%，N=31
    87.
    .0%，N=89
    8
    Depr
    ess
    ion 20115MV 1
    8.0
    9も
    201l5MV/C 20.
    0'
    lも 5
    9.7目 79.
    79" N=4
    令 66

    200
    1仁 3
    2.0'
    lも 6
    1.1抽 93.0% ，
    N=1，
    949
    P
    ain 20115MV 1
    5.1% 30明る 45.
    1帖I ，
    N:73
    201l5MV/C 2
    3.2怖 57.
    7
    'る 80.9， N=730
    軸

    He
    adache 20115MV 1
    8.5% 前ゐ 58.
    5， N=70
    %

    201
    15MV 2
    3.9% 38.6% 62.
    5， N=88
    %
    PT5D 20135MV 26.0怖 63.
    7拍 3 89.
    7， N=146
    %

    TotaIN=S，
    917
    ロImproved25-49明 白Improv
    ed2
    :50%
    C=C i
    vi
    1ian
    SMV=ServiceMembersandVet
    erans
    5MV/C=5e刊に eMembers，Ve
    担r asandC
    n iv
    ili
    ans

    F
    lGURE19.
    3 S山 lTn:lr
    yoft
    hret:山 r
    vey fcr
    ani
    ale
    lect。
    泊
    rotherapystimul
    ati
    unu
    ser討 (
    0=5
    917
    )

    TABLE19.
    1
    仁ranialEl mulation(
    ectrotherapySti 仁 ES)RandomizedControlledStudy(RCT)Anxi
    etyStudies

    P
    rincipal
    I
    nvestig
    ator T
    olaln Su
    bjec
    ts 5tud
    yTy
    pe M四 s
    urementSca
    les
    /Oul
    come
    s
    sarday 11
    5 An且 i
    elvP
    ali
    cl
    l!s RCT
    .DB Hami l
    tonAnx i
    ctyR; u
    in gSc al c(HAM-A):l nt hcact
    ivl
    !tr!a
    l tmcnfgru l1 p、 R .\ Ç~ h~u a
    Cla.q
    l Jc crc出co r;
    ?:
    5(
    )，，i
    k
    1 ns corcsf rornh ast
    :l
    . in
    ctl)cnJpoi
    ntonI hcHAMι A(p<O1 .川1).
    Thcrcwa sa羽目l il
    icantu ifre r，巴nじ巴 b~lw~en groups(p<0. 001.l=(
    t )り
    - 1 -)f r o m
    has ei
    1nctocnJ[lointu f叫 UU)ιT hc1¥
    )，コmd
    ( ccrc出じ いnt h
    cHAM- Ai nt h ct n ::a unenl
    grnltpof32 .
    H':
    .
    r(1 9.1
    :1
    9t u1 3..' ¥7)山I Smn 回 t h
    ant h
    rel
    !(月)t im
    cst heme andC erea!
    -
    .c
    り 1l1
    1cHAM- Af o rthc" h川 1 g rul
    1p¥)1'
    り.1f
    1t
    .(21.98to19.9削 frollh
    1 a:. c
    1ine1 0
    cnupoi n
    roft hc刈 utly
    .
    Lc
    c‘叫 o
    可 Pr
    じop
    cra
    tiv
    eP江
    Ilc
    nt百 RCT L
    ike
    ltAnxi
    etyS t
    ak:CESgro
    uph、l
    .sig nilie~ntly l
    l o¥Vc
    rS(
    'o
    ・ resf romhas
    cli
    ncnn
    しikcr
    lanxid
    y，-:C
    llk
    .th
    att
    hcc
    ont
    rolgroup，whichg o
    tl h
    cl l.~ua l c
    are(
    jJ=0.01
    6)
    Thcr
    ewa 且 砧l
    sor
    cJu
    cti
    oni
    nwit
    hdr
    awals
    cor
    csf
    orpmkntsuu
    rin
    gin
    jed
    ion
    s
    (
    /1=OJJ4t
    ))
    .
    K
    irnc
    ta..
    l. 60 Pr
    Cl
    I!X九百 l
    iv
    じ， Pa
    ticn
    Ls R(
    T.旧 UkcnAnx
    ictySC<
    lk:
    'CESgrn
    uphadsi
    gnii
    lcam
    lylo¥
    ¥'
    crs;u
    t r
    cs"‘'
    romh a
    叫 l
    in
    con
    L
    ikcI
    1an
    xict
    y:-
    .
    ca1cth
    anc
    onl
    rolg
    mllpatendpoi
    nt0'
    1swdy(1'<( )
    .05.d=- [ U~S).
    Strèntzsch ~7 )
    H C
    hro
    nic
    alyMcnta!
    l lyI
    I
    I RC
    T.、DB S
    I、ie
    lherg erS t
    atcTnutAnxi
    ctyTnv
    enlo
    ry(STAI :CESgr
    ) ouphads
    ign
    itk
    :an
    tly
    Pa
    ti
    cnts lowcr出 仁 川 c
    sfron
    lh a
    scl
    inc005AI(in
    Jic机 t
    ingl
    csss
    t:
    ¥t
    c:ln
    xic
    tyJth
    an!'
    hamgroup
    .
    l
    telllJ
    p ointnfMU uy(p=OJ 日.d=一り斗1).
    Che
    nct:
    lL旬
    . {
    心 C
    h il
    J刊 nwithMixcJ RCT.1
    s ZungAnxict
    yS~~lc (
    5 A5):T h~ ANQVA' !hnweJtha
    to nSA5、t helUa i
    nc ll
    'el
    t
    .
    ^nxicl ln
    Y< dDcpr
    c同 i
    vc hctwc
    cnCESgmup祖 n ds ham comp:.i
    fat
    orgroupw出 s ign
    ilic
    ant( F=8 3.21
    Dis
    (l
    J'Je
    r( MAD) '<
    1 0.01)Changc
    咽 si
    nEEG0 1O .
    : c
    ipi
    ta
    咽 lLnhcsviahrainelec
    tricalaClivi
    l)
    'mappi n
    g
    (BEAM):o nl
    c't:
    1 mdrightα1r CVCl
    i!
    cdlhcma i
    ncffcc¥orgro u
    pwass i g
    nilica
    nt
    (F=5.98.
    ]1<0 .
    05;F=6 .3り.f
    I<0 .0
    5):Ol
    llef
    t~nd r
    it
    :h la2 thema incf可fcctof
    gro
    upW l
    lSals
    us i
    gnii
    lcant([0=7 54.JI<O. o
    !:F=6 .72‘p<( ).
    05).
    Cor
    kcla
    .!
    l 1 74 Fi
    hfl
    lmy
    algi
    aPa
    tIcn
    ts RCT.Ds Pn巾 k0' 1Mo odSta
    lcs(POMS)f oranxic
    ly:CESg rouphadsign
    il
    icanll
    yll
    lWCI
    OL ~corcs fro
    mh a.
    .
    cli
    nc011POMSf i
    ndil
    '
    atingt
    essanxIct
    y)thanshamg r
    oupatend
    j
    lOilt
    l01'stu
    uy(1<O
    ( J)1
    ).Opcnl u
    bclCE5g ro
    tlphaJ:-.i
    gn
    il
    ican
    tl
    yluwcrscor
    cson
    POMSa tposトt
    c叫 f
    r口mh a
    :世 l
    inc叫 or
    c:
    -
    .(p<0 .
    (旧1).
    TheEvol
    utionofCranialElectrotherapySt
    imul
    ati
    on 197

    TABlE19.
    1 (continued)
    lectrotherapy Stimulation(
    CranialE 仁 ES)RandomizedControlledStudy(RCT)AnxietyStudies
    P
    rinci
    pal
    I
    nvest
    igat
    or T
    ota
    ln Subje
    cts SludyType MeasuremenlS日 l
    es/
    Oulcome
    s
    L
    il'
    ll
    tb
    rl
    lU
    O'
    ，
    i' 。
    () F
    ihr
    omy
    alg
    iaPa
    tic
    nb lH
    RCT.L P
    rofilc¥)
    fMooJS tal出 入 n x
    ictySuhs 山IcI POMS- AJ :CESg roUJ lh ad幻 g nitic
    anlly
    OL lowC
    'rSCOl山 0 1
    1POMS-A( in di山 川 区 lcs~ l In xi c ly )f f( ‘
    )m haeJ il l ct han.~ha m gr
    ollp
    Tc
    a ndpυ1111川 山 l dy( p=;; 0
    . 02. d= ベ)印).T hc悶 Wぷ 1 11 ~igni Ji canl d
    ( iff
    c印 n cc10
    0作: 11Lah e1じr o州 刑' c
    rgr 山 p' 1 romp r Clcslt op o s t- t e stonPOMS-A( 1
    '>0 . 0
    5)
    、
    ，
    yjnkk' リ n D
    enl
    alP
    ali
    enl
    s RCT
    .DB V
    istla
    lAn al o gS calc(VA針 。I n verseL ik crtS c a lc CESg
    ふ 山 lIPl l
    <1d i
    ち gn
    ilk:a nll
    y
    I
    mv crscúrc~ fromh asd inc.i n JicatingI c
    附 anxh ::ty .OnI hcVAS(p<0. 02，
    d=-0 .(1)a n dhighe rs core話。 nL ik crtS c a l e.i n Jk a li ngl essanxktyI p<υ ()1)
    t
    ha nshumg r P‘
    山 ' t
    lcnu似) inl olぉt t
    ldy
    V
    ori負 制 1
    05 Pおう!
    chi
    at
    ricPa
    tIc
    ntsw
    ith RC
    T.口B S
    tatc^ nxi
    c tyI nv
    c ntory( S AJ
    ):CESgr ol1phaJ討i g n i l ka ntly[ o wc r叫 O 叫 ミ ( 川dicat
    ing
    Anxiel
    y 1
    <怜i l
    nxI
    elY )O l
    lSA(I hant hes ha1l
    l< 1
    IlUc o n t ro [g r o u p 沿 a
    tcndp o i ulnfぽ u Jy
    (p=o 叫)() I. d~ ー l 副}). C[ Sg r
    oupha J.~ i g: nili l';H1 l l y hig hcrl i n g c
    rt ernp:印刷出
    ど荷 刷出{Jl=0 α)1.f/=0 .5t
    l).1I1d討i gnilit a
    n t l yl u w c rEMG叫 o r引 ( 1'=0似川 l
    d=-1 .0お).i n
    diピ臼 l
    ingl c蛸 a n xi cl
    )
    ' .Ih:
    .
    1 1、 h: H nCE .f)a ndc u n
    lrl lg代川 p ミ

    1
    B:i
    nvc
    :
    -.
    lig
    ulol
    'hli
    nd:Ds:
    Jou
    blcb
    lid:01
    n .:opc
    nla
    ょ:
    t
    l
    . 11=51
    >5f
    : ora
    nxi
    ctyRCi SwJics

    TABLE19.2
    CESOpenLabelandSurveyAnxietyStudies

    P
    rin
    c i
    pal
    l
    nvestig
    ato
    r T
    ota
    Jn S
    uhj
    ect
    s StudyType MeasuremenlScales/Outcomcs
    Pr Íl'c~ 1 1
    46 Servi
    'cMcmb
    l
    . !
    ¥l
    '
    、 S
    ur¥
    'cy 7-p¥lin
    lL i k
    c rt礼: alc.Ofthet ot
    alg fl叩 63.rkr
    l cpl1r1c Jf e
    W ¥!f1寸 SDs ymplom 持 a
    nddini c
    al
    andVet
    era
    n馬，¥
    、 '
    i
    th 11] '0'
    1
    1 、 elllcnto f ;日0ψ(l 1n、
    町
    p : C11
    1C11l{ )
    fs uh stanl ia
    ld i nicali111 ~xl rt anc l! cat
    eg nry
    .Dworkin
    PTSD " 川 町 wh ilc2 6
    . 01fl陀戸川叫 c lini，，"
    a linljl
    nlVCm 山 1 1 0 1I
    ' 可 S口叩lIl]lt Oll1S hcl wccn2円 < 1nd
    49時(Im pro vcl l
    l cnto f1l10ucm l
    cd i nk ali mp ortan c c ).[ 1
    1t hc1 0
    t: I
    1g rotl p .89. 71
    h:叶
    陀 ~ pom 1c nl s rc似 川c dき2 5 t
    kf ewerJYrSD~y mp tom ぉ川 dd iniα\1 i m p rtl¥'C mCn lwi thI he
    州日~or il y o fI hc~c rC~ 戸川 dcnt ミ "'P(市川 19 2: 50 切 impmVC IIlC11 1 i nPT SD
    P
    rI'e
    l l
    !
    . 714 Ci'
    ¥i
    lian
    !九5

    Memhc円 <
    ピ円i

    ¥n
    u
    c
    e Stlrv~y 7-似)
    刊 l
    il
    p
    1l

    ro¥
    L
    '
    iJ
    c
    .
    .
    m
    crt討cal
    c川 o
    c
    .0'
    f250 ;
    t
    1I
    を(
    heI
    imp
    ・
    {talg
    l山t
    r
    roUJ
    cm心n
    .5
    l
    lnfs
    9.SIi
    !
    Uhs
    :r
    li
    e
    1n
    p
    l
    u
    ia
    r te J1
    lI，."
    li
    剖語 a

    nica
    n
    l1川.
    x.i !
    Xl
    l ya
    rl
    :
    n
    Jm :
    ddi
    cC:l
    ni
    l
    e
    c
    g
    a
    l
    ory
    Vetera
    nswiL
    h Dw υ『 k川
    比 in
    ，じ叫E泊川1 州).wh 、lie23ι
    l
    己 モr
    ℃ ピp
    陀 ο
    叫a
    口1 e
    dC叶
    え汁i
    [
    ;，
    川'
    "仁a li ，
    川叫
    En pr ov e c
    引'"児 n10'
    川 1
    ，
    I
    I1X1Ct
    y a u"49 ~t ο"(川川
    nn戸pm v C
    引I
    llC
    引11
    10叶f n
    川B叫l
    α 忙c問 t edi 川IKαal川河川 rtan~c). I nl hcl olulg rolp.H2
    l ， lJtk0'1
    t
    訓
    山
    川E
    "
    叫“
    刈
    叫 引、
    町宅 旬 凶
    目
    "に
    山叫
    _
    .
    ‘
    仁辺
    ‘
    r目 p ond ent 品 問p orted225係 kssa l1.x ic
    t ，
    山
    y dじl in in ¥!l mp ro vcl11c 川 wi t hth巴 mj
    ‘
    to rityof
    thc scr c sp川 d cn tsr cport i
    n g:?SO鴨 川 1 pro
    、
    刊 川町 "

    日r
    acl
    'ia
    nnω 2 V
    ct¥!
    ran
    swi
    th 01
    . 口a i
    l ySym刊の m Sci cril)
    lR< lling:-.- Tre a
    tn lCnlLog( ()-1 (
    ))d CCI山 町 dfmmab ascl inc
    PTSD me: mu f61 0(l post-tcstmふ1Il0' 12(p<0 .05.d=[ . 6
    1 ).PT SDSymptomS 仁川cI n lcr
    view
    (PSS- I)wI Sr cdu ccJr r om 34
    - 10 [
    :
    1anJ29t o 10 川 t h cr e 叩 C'
    : I W p au c nt只a nd
    ‘
    日- e.
    xpel 'i
    e ncingde crc出 c df r um71 02an d1}t o2 . 八 、叩i da lKCJιreas edf rom 1 5t o7ιmd
    ゆt n，5
    ，: ln dI nc氏、よ、cda 代、u 只alJc c r
    C
    i l.
    '、cdf rom1 21 l>4 11 nd1 1( 0可
    By~( ri l ~ ky f> 1 1
    2 G
    c nc
    ralAnxie
    ty OL Ha r
    n ilt
    ll lR atingS cu!cr orA nxi ety( HAM-A).F u u rDim e川 i on alA nx i e tya 1dD
    ! cpr 白羽o n
    Disor
    dcrPal
    icn
    ls Sca le(FDADS):A nxi c
    t y，;c
    l or山 d e c
    r e山 cu~ig l1 jli む antly onHA M- Af rom ba~e Jî ne t
    o
    Cn d[lOi n lοfs tu d
    y( p=0 .01，11=--1 .52 ).AnれClys c or c対 wcrcs i
    g n i l
    i cn nlyl o w
    cr( 11
    l主)ADSaJ山1 11p oinl0 1叫 I IJ
    yr romh a岨Iill じ( p<0 . 0 39. d=- O. 7 5 )
    Lue
    lal
    .M 32 ChilJ
    renwilh OL Zung^nxiet ySca le( SAS ):Fromh a 、
    )e l
    inco f5!UO土 1 1.5010j>¥減 I -
    IC叫 4 5.9 1土 1 0.36
    Emntional (">0. 01);1 3ピ祖先Cぉ h ad則 gni f
    icantcl .i
    'dt4 1%) .1 7ca柑ぉ hJdcff
    cct153~話)， andthc
    Disurucs erfetw‘ 悼 川 V
    c ‘
    li
    ld川 【"，1)l'a同ぉ {61i
    f
    -) :th
    cl('
    I¥n
    lc ffccli
    vera
    te¥V山り4ち も_Ski ntemperatu
    re
    (Anxiιl
    yl ' 叫 I
    0 p<ll.Ol) 叩叫 u li
    chl oodpr cおお ur
    cdropped川 dI hcpulcl
    s o
    w ιJdownaf !crthe
    ‘
    t r
    CJtmcn.
    t:1ndI hcJin'c1引にι swcr es igni
    ficJ f
    1
    I(1'<0 .05).2
    6c 剖 C只follo wcdtP(
    l 81%)
    (1fwhich24C <l世話 hJtllon g1山 t
    ing dlicaι)
    'wi lhftょli
    evc
    dorel i
    mi na
    t ed詩ymptom句、 and
    2c ns山 had悶 l apscof討ymptomwhcrct l
    ru.
    g sv.'
    cren ccdc
    d1り 仁ont
    rol thc
    i r尽ymptoms
    口
    、ic
    n:a
    shl
    '
    ‘ 1
    97 A
    nxietyDis
    nrJ
    er OL (ト](附 N u
    meric;1 1R ati
    ngS c alc(NRS ):SutJjec
    l沿f:1lingofanxic
    lyW3 Ss ig
    n i
    il.
    cant
    lyl e
    ss
    P‘t
    Ii
    cnlぉ f rom1川 崎linct I
    J1削 I-L t(p<(
    cs ).05).S uhj
    e c¥
    ピp hy si
    nlo
    gica
    lmca .
    "u
    r 出 υ fanxicty-
    EMG、EDRa nt
    lTC1llト-changcds ignitic
    antlyfmmb ase
    lin
    c1 lo
    0! st-testindi
    catingIc
    ss
    a n
    xicly(p<0 .0 5)
    {
    ('(
    llI l
    inu
    ed)
    198 Bi
    oel
    ect
    romagne
    ticandSubtleEnergyMedi
    cine

    TABLE19.2 (continued)
    CESOpenlabelandSurveyAnxietyStudies

    P
    rinc
    ipal
    I
    nvest
    iga
    tor T
    o 11
    l< n S
    ubj
    ecl
    s S
    tud
    yType M旧 suremenlScal
    es/Ol
    l
    t印 mes
    K
    irM.
    :h 202 ScrvI(
    '!
    ¥MC 1 11bt!四 Sur
    吋 y 7
    - po
    inlL ikert~ a k : An' ¥i
    cty( 1=1 1.
    .1).Of th巳 t otalg rou[l.4 6弓 安 問 戸 川 e dleおお a n x ie ly and
    clal叫 jm
    ; JVch.:m l1~ ¥¥11
    th dinic礼，imp 仰向Illc IIIOf注50 1
    ffwhi k:: W.2 ;
    rfJ 'c pO 1c
    r Jd in iじ，1川 l p rov
    cmc ntl l
    fa n xicl)'
    an x;
    ctyl in du d出 hetwe en25 (，毛山叫~l)~争 ln 1 heI ma!g roup.6 fi .7をi
    '刊 誌p o.叫 e nt
    sr じp o口od之2 5%
    pηTS口 川
    口mp即 vcm c
    泌 n
    附川1川in
    decre
    ふa
    剖i
    均c
    凶 d品川'"制I:l
    l
    .
    ' y‘山
    l1dc
    I i
    1niじu川1 1
    l
    川llp
    r代
    叩υ、1
    《】
    凶 (
    '11
    1ピ引川
    n1
    η
    tοf注5 0
    ι A
    .w
    ル hi!c1 5.
    4
    宅，f r cportcdιl i ni c
    al
    improvcm c nl( ¥
    rill足i
    l cl
    yI x: tw cen25 弘 a nd49Q.l nt hct otalgr ou p.66.7号 同 叩 印l
    月 dcnl 倍

    rcpo
    r lcd;'
    :25 め'
    rh nprnvcl1lcn ti na n.
    xi cty.I nt h cCESo n[ ygr oup( nomcdkati on ，s1
    57.
    7各 r cportc dd叫 r ca同 d川 l :
    :i
    l
    ¥ dya nddi nic alimpr o町 me nlnr2:5 OCkwh ile1 5.4%
    rcport cddi n k.llimp ro町 制 c n to fa n則 c tvhClw ccn2宅待 a nl49r kf orat 刷、lIof7 J.IS 手o f
    '0叩o nd enl swt lor eporlc lk !> sanx i clyandcl i
    nkali mpr o
    v cm..
    :nl: ?:
    25守 1 1Ih cCES
    日ndmcukationsgmup.4~ . 2ιk o fre .
    >
    :pon dじI H'r
    !c p叫 【 山 1uu:r c
    u:>.cdanx icty礼n ddinkal
    川 lprovernl!nt<:
    !5()ψwhi e2.
    l 16役 目 pOr l
    eudc cr ..
    :used川 XI <:ly2 5保 49C jri mpr o v 印刷"

    te
    )rHt oti
    llo f6 4.Xr
    /o
    " fI'csp on u叩 tswho山 p川 I ..:
    ddc c rca scdanxi ct
    ylil叫 dini c al
    impr ov cmc nt.<
    :1 jtI
    r，
    PT5D( 1
    1=忠 則 orI h
    ..
    :t olalg r oup.J8.6ti ;r C[l()r!c dl e問 ‘mXIじt y・ mddini じuli m
    p r o vclIll:m
    of2:5ut kwhl ic2 -
    '.9句 r cp orlc dclini ca llm rro v cm cll I( )
    fnnxi clyhclwccn2 5~ル nnd 49弘
    10Ihc1 011
    01g ro up.62.りをr
    5 espom lenl s陀 p or lc d. <
    :2 5/完 I np rovc r
    n entina nλicty
    .1 0I hc
    CESo nlyg r ou]l(noI lC
    l d[
    ('aIIon叫 5 0. 0毎 日 p orl..:dd c c陀 a日 da n'，
    .ピt
    j yan dc i
    1ni c al
    impro vcll
    l cllIo f:
    ?50'
    -:twh
    - il
    c2 2
    .2<.
    1:r cportc d¥ '.linI'a
    L limprovcmel ll01山 政 i e
    lyh c tw el!n

    25係 ‘mJ4l )l.f


    ，
    f ora1 川 a lof7 2.2句 o fr c
    s pon d cn tswhun ::p
    o rtcJl c日 anxicty<tn ddi niじ，1
    Improvcmじn t2 :25tk.I n! hcCE可白川 dmc d
    i cati l)1Jぉ gro up 、35 .7係 o fr e
    spor吋 enlsr cpo 川e d
    d山 山 肌 叫 川 x icly;Imldinkalimp ro 刊 '"じn l2 :5 U係 w hi lc24. 3
    '+rcport~d J~~: n.: as~d
    '
    an.
    xiety2 5係 -49 (Ajmpruv~mènl f oral o
    talof60. t問 。f 附 pondcn tswho陀j10r lc d
    d己cre出 ..:
    :
    da n:"icIY山¥(.1di nI cali mp r o刊 mcnl; ;
    :
    - 2 5切
    A l p h ~・- S li m 679 Pu
    t ，'
    kms、 i
    lh S
    ur¥
    'cy 4-poi川Lik crtSc ak: Anx icly(i1lon c)凶 = 1 28.0' 1thi '
    !~roup. 6 7.1 9ふ
    'r
    i epo ncJI c
    時

    U~c r :
    JI
    lJU
    ":
    :ly 出lXiel)
    'an dcli nk: lIimp rnvc mc nt0 '
    12'50筑 a tteru ~i ll g Al pha-Sl im.whi l
    e1 2.66ちゅ
    Surve
    v. rClo
    J nc dlt:
    :
    日・t 川 i ctya ll
    di lllprovcl l
    lcl lh叫 w ce n25 鴨 川 d 49写会ミ t ot
    alo r1 :
    N.8'
    "% o f
    1995- theseT山 ponclen ls同 por led<:!15~f. i mp ro
    ¥'em.
    .:nti na n x it !t
    y
    199日刊 '
    ，¥
    n.xidy(Wi lhu lh crt:ondit I
    o¥， n=J
    l
    ) 70 .0'1lhi
    ..
    .gr lJujl，68. 1 1 'ii日戸川 ~J 1cぬ品 n xiclyall d
    clin
    icalimp ro vclTlcnl()fo:50( ka ftcrlIs i
    ngA lph !
    ¥-S I
    II l
    l，w hile2.2. 97'hr
    " el
    川 円 以1 I
    css
    川 目ictyandi 川 p rnvcmCl I1belwc~n 1 5q‘ md-49t k.At Ql
    alof91 .0忠弘 o f1 1山 C
    r!.
    l-:
    pondcntsr c pufl cd:
    ?2 弓係 1 I11r
    ] o官
    、mC1 li
    1 1J
    l n'
    <ic
    . ty . An xic t
    y( wil hu cprc州 市 川 n=弓 お
    Of th附 group. 62. 07匂 rcp orl coI c~s a n
    xiely‘II1dCI川 ' C川 I mpr n、C
    円 J
    llClllof主計 )'ka f
    lcr
    山 川g /
    ¥lpha-SlItn，wh l
    ic32 .767 .
    .r c刊 岡 山1 .Icssi ln
    x i
    cl y~lO ù i
    mp r ov cmcnllx 'lwccn25 ~是
    anl-49与 を Al o tal of9
    "'. 83t
    ;{，oft hesc町 、[l(.ndcnl.
    .n: po r
    tcd;
    ;日間 I Inprov 創n cnl
    lll
    anx;cly
    .5 1陀 同 N=1 2 ~. O fl hisg rullp.7 0.73% r c po r tl!dlc出 anx iclylIndc li
    nic:¥
    1
    imp rovcmen t0 1詮弓O俳 誌r tcr1刈 ng八I p
    ha・Stil1.w
    l h
    i l e2 4 .39切 r epol1eJl ，.sun刈 etya!ld
    c
    imp rovemen th ct wccn2 50 ，
    iω d斗 9C ，Al
    f. utal01 円 12%o rthc同 r cs pond c
    nlぉ r!p
    l l
    l山 d
    ;
    >
    :150;
    :i m proVt!menli na nxict y

    OL:ll
    penlat
    x
    .
    'l:PTSD:pll~Hrallm ;I(i l" ~tre日 dì sord c r: PSS-
    I:PTSDメymptom刈 .
    l
    lcI
    1
    It
    t"V陀 W、 n=1
    '
    l 984f
    (l
    rli
    lX.i
    clyn
    pCI
    Ilahe
    Jω叫 メ u
    rvc
    ys l([ d i c~ 百1.1
    0
    n=257りti
    xa lCESa
    J nxi
    ctvはu dic s

    t
    Olalnumberofsubjccts(
    n)f
    oral
    1anxiety刈udicswas4819 ThcJ
    'c have bcen lwo s
    urvcys and onc open l
    ahelcasc
    wilh595fromRC丁
    、 S
    じnc沿t
    oevaluatetheer
    rcct
    soft
    reatingpos
    ttraumaticsl
    rcs
    s
    TherearenineRCTsshowingt
    hatCESha
    sprov
    ent
    obea d;
    sordcr(PTSD)wilhCES.Thecases
    eri
    es1
    山 l
    edfor4weeks
    sar
    candc
    ffc
    cti
    vct
    rca
    ltn
    Cntf
    oranxiclywithe
    ffc
    cts
    ize呉 rang- 川 l
    dpro
    vidcdaver
    ylar
    gec
    ffe
    c ze(d;1
    lsi .61)Ni
    lh叫at
    ist
    ica
    l 、
    i d=
    ng from medium ( ー0.41) 10 very large (d;一1.60)日 附 pく 0.05)日 Twop
    signitkance ( ati
    entぉ rcported ぬ 38 %and
    Thr
    eeoft
    hest
    udiesl
    ookcda
    tacuteanxi
    ety
    .suchasprcoper
    - 34% reduct
    ion. r
    espcctivel
    y.;
    1
    1I SD Sympl
    hc PT Om Sc"le
    a
    tiv
    canxi
    e pく 0.
    ty( 05
    .d=
    =-0.88).includinganxietypriort
    o I
    nter
    vic¥V.Thecas
    l!ser
    iesr
    t
    :!s s
    ul
    t.werefurtherslIpportcdby
    dcn
    tal procedure民 (
    1'; 0.02.1';-0.61
    )
    . Anothcrl
    halmoni- the sur
    vcy datat
    hat誌howed64% and 39% ofr
    espondents
    toredchang
    esi
    nEEGmappingfcvcaledsigni
    f
    lcan
    tchanges reponingc
    1inicalimprovcmcnl0'
    1~5 09;-' .fol When lookinga
    t
    ductoCESont hckftandr
    ights
    idcofthebr
    aini
    nthcal provcmcn.
    clinkalim t lhe highcstcalegory i
    s ‘日 t
    bst
    anl
    ial
    and0
    :2rC立1
    011品 川 知 子J c
    lini iじhi
    calimportancc" wh inedas~50IÆ.I 削
    sdet
    TheE
    vol
    uti
    ono
    fCr
    ania
    lEl
    ect
    rot
    her
    apySt
    imu
    lat
    ion 1
    99

    TABlE19.
    3
    ルlet
    a-A
    nalys
    eso
    f仁E
    SSl
    udi
    eso
    fAnxiety
    p
    rin
    cip
    al
    In vesti~ator T
    ot
    aln Subje cts S
    ludyType F
    indi ngs
    K i r~t' h 山 ld 2
    04リ 41s lud陀~ I.'xa1
    1lI
    nc d MCla
    - Thc川 川 l ysis01r
    ' cm Jcrcdd 川:
    .tunIh 'd
    l
    . kcl ofCESo n羽n .x
    ict yyÎdd~J 泊 n dkus iz
    c
    Gi l llla<~' t
    hcd f
    c('to fCES a
    nal
    y川 lf
    ( r =0 .
    57:ab rgcc fkct~ilC i
    s副 知 W八 n alvs
    is川 l hc~ lU dicぉ Ih :11 1l叫d onlya
    U
    l
    la nxle!y uOtlbl c
    -bindmcl h山 Ipro JL
    にc dand r
    ...c
    lI Ct
    叫 u
    rCESU la
    I nxi ctyりr r =0 .53
    .S l
    u uI
    !s
    t
    that u~cd cx
    trancou st nc
    an reso
    ，
    > f:1l
    t x
    iCl
    yw e印 陀 刊ov cd3 1叫 o nly叫l ldi出 fo rsta
    tc01
    tr
    aita n
    xictylha
    lU 日 d Ih
    (
    'S pic
    l h
    cr:
    g crSt
    ate バn d
    tInvcllt!町w c n
    ::川 a !y7.l'
    u.T hじ
    cffccl 川 C ES
    υns tal
    c札口 x
    iClyw asr =0引}川l .
    !Intit
    :l1x
    I ictyw r 悩 =O .6
    H. W hcnt he
    ほお ultお o
    fu n‘t
    [、
    y刈w品 c orrcclc
    df nrt h
    cl111 mDcrur州 l、I
    j
    CL't
    si nc a.
    .:hs ludy.s ta
    tc
    l
    11tlcty、川凶 r=0 .5 9a nulr
    ait<ln
    xicty、va
    . sr =0.60.T hcc O'cじt SIZ
    C.
    < 巳f l
    lrt h
    c~ [
    ぉw di出 i nthi
    sm cta -a
    n aly
    .
    ¥isr a
    ngeuf r
    omh igh.)伽 tol ow6 恥

    Kl
    a鴨川 n..¥
    .
    y 2
    41 日R CT .DB. CES MCla Thepi凶 [ eur c
    叫 t
    lf orl hccigh ts
    tu
    di出 i n
    clll1Ji
    ng2 4[!oUhj
    cC
    l..
    ...a na lYl .i n
    gI hcc ff
    cl:l0'
    1
    c
    t:
    .
    1.1>7 s
    tud ic
    st h 日【 L
    ‘J
    Ia
    l
    y則 ‘ CF.ちI
    ! f
    C川m en
    t01
    1;1I1民 l
    clyWぷ i nf a
    VtlfufCESo vcrぉh:una t a叫川 l ポi cally
    c
    xa mInedI hee t
    fc ct 川g nih c川 Ilc
    '、
    .e
    llc IT
    CL't叫lec !
    oI
    tmatcr =- 0 .
    5泌潟
    、 f 1<1 1.
    (5)、 Vh
    ， CI
    IIhrcc ぉ fu dîe~
    f仁E
    u Su na n
    xi刷 、 w c山 J WI、
    [
    l r
    Jh c‘
    c “ I
    "!I
    l hcyp ro、
    idc dOlc Ol l
    vinc
    in gs
    . じn s
    at lon柿 I hl !I rh
    民 al
    l1

    p rO
    f
    ()I..
    '
    ol
    .t h
    c同 州 I t i
    nfavoro fCESr cm川 吋 . .
    i
    gnii
    f山 '
    "

    ThcI
    hre
    eanXi
    !l
    L
    . yぉp
    eci
    fi
    csu
    rve
    ysr
    cpo
    rlc
    dsIb
    l s
    lan
    tia
    l disor de
    rsi 討 ヲ 2a n dt hcs
    ea re 討ccn ll10r ef re qucnt lyi n
    じl
    ini
    calimpo
    rtan n47
    じei Cc
    (.60%.and6
    7% o
    fres
    ponde
    nts
    . woment hanl1l ell. ~"
    asshowni nFig u
    re1 9.
    3.Inthetwoa n
    xietyme t
    a-ana
    lys
    es. Ta bl
    e1 9.4i n cl u d csc ig
    hthum l
    t ns tu diesi nvestigatingt he
    Ol
    1Cc ombiningt h
    crc討ul
    tぉof41a nx
    i c
    tys t
    udi
    esa n
    dt hcot
    her cffectso fCES f orL hct rca t
    m cnL ofd c prc
    ssion.Thct nblc
    usin
    gei ghtsclect
    edRCT~ふ botb con品rmcdt h
    ccffect
    iven
    ess inc
    Ju dest h
    recRCTs( twod ou b
    le -
    blindl. twoo pe nlab e
    lt rial
    s.
    ofCESi nt 印 a
    tinganxiet
    ywithc o
    nsistc
    ntlyla
    rgeeffe
    ctsi
    zcs andt h
    reeu sers ur v e y s
    .I nadd i
    ti on.the rei sam eta- analysiso f
    (d= 0.57‘d= 0.59)
    6(，
    .
    r7
    ， 20CESs tudicso fd eprc州 101
    1s um m 山 i z cdinT abl e1 9.5.The
    tot
    alnf orthee i gh ts tudieswas1 113w i th1 96f r omRCT: 、
    Thet hreeRCT sぉhowcds ignificantlyd ccre a日 dd epres-
    DEPRESSIVED1S0RDERS
    日o ns c
    orcsr l'<0 . 001.l'<0 . 01
    .a ndl '<0 .
    (1)u ぉingt hn:
    :c
    The C Oll1mon f e
    atu r
    eo fa ld
    1 epre日 Ivcd is
    ordclメ ist he dif
    f erentぉc alest om ea sureu epressi on (HAM-DI 7‘ B cck
    pr c
    scn cco f拍 d，cmply .ori rr
    ita
    blemoodaccompan iedb y Dcp ressionI nve nt o r ya ndZun gD epre s sionS cale).
    5.15
    K刷
    somaL icHn uじυgni iv
    t ec hangest h
    atぉi gni
    fican
    tlyilff
    cctt hc Thetwoo p e nl abclt ria
    lss howeus ign
    if
    ic untimp rovc-
    individu al'お じapac
    ilyt of u
    nc t
    ion.M句。rd epre
    日i vedisorder me ll
    lsu swel w 噌ithones tu
    dyr e
    portin game diumc ffc('
    1s i
    ze
    rcprcs cn
    lぉ t hed assi cconditionint hisg roupofdi メordcrs (d=-0. 41)an dt heo thcrat otale ffectiv er at
    eo f94 %.6'."
    おi!
    l('
    1!itr eqllirc
    sc l!a
    l r-c
    utc hangesina f
    fect.cognit
    ion，and Uponf oll
    ow- upo f26c ascぉ 2 4hadl ongl as
    tin gc f
    t icacy01 '
    ne u
    r ovcgc t
    a tivefunc t
    ion
    s.Diagno はi ccrt
    icriainclud
    et i
    veo r relievedo re lim i na t eds ympt oI1l沿 Lua lsome 川 ure dp hysi
    J10
    1 reo fIhef ollo
    win gsymptomsp r
    e sentina2 -weckp eriod ologicalc hange sd u ringa llda f t
    ert rc ut mcntwi ths ignif i
    c a
    nt
    wi t
    ha tJ casl oncbei ngei
    thcrd ep
    rcssc dmoodo rl o
    sso rin
    Ler- cha ngc対 sccnins k i nt cm pcralur c，syst oilcb loodp re同 u reand
    Cぉto rp lcasu re日 puls e('<0
    1 .
    0 5)削
    Thet hr
    ce日 p ar a teus ers ur vcy式 rca che d叫 b stantialc1i n
    i-
    Dc pr
    cs scdmood cali mportan cei n66q :
    ，
    .58%， a nd36%o fde pressi o
    np atic
    n t爪
    Dimini shedi n
    teres
    t witht h
    el owcsts co r er e po
    rte db yS ervi ceMe mbe rsa n dv e
    t
    Signi
    ticnntw eightloss erans.Them eta - an a lysisf o
    rd c prcssio ni ncl
    ud ed937p aticnts
    Inぉomni aO rhypa メomma acl'OSS20s epar at es tudie sandr e
    port edal ar
    gcC f f
    CC Is i
    ze0 1
    Psy:
    chomotora gi
    tatio
    n 0.05 0(Tab 1
    e1 9.5 ).' "
    FaL
    igu c lnad ouble- bl in dRCT，H2%o ft hea ClIverrcuu nentg roup
    Fccl
    illgso fwon hle同 日e
    ss repo rled~50 % r~uuction i ndcp 印 刷 。 ns cores
    .Th esca ctive
    Oimi nisheda b
    ili
    lyt othIn
    k0'1c
    once
    nlr
    ate t
    r eat mentgr oupr es ultsw cre1 2l imesh igherI ha nt hes ham
    Recurr e
    ntt hou!htsofdeath treatm entgrou p.Thc町 wass omei niL ialt r
    an討t entI m prove-
    mcnti nt hea nx ict ys corcsamongr h cs hamgr ouph u
    tno
    Thea bo
    v esymptomsm l
    lstc a
    usedistr
    e阿 川 n onnalsocil，
    a challgei nthcird c p r essions c:o
    . r c
    対向

    occlIp
    ationu.
    l0'
    1othcrim
    p o
    rtantar
    e a
    只o ffunc
    rioning
    Majordcp rs日 v
    c edisorde
    ri st
    hel eadi
    ngc nus eofdis-
    INSOMNIA
    abi
    Ii t
    yinL hcU.S.forageぉ 1
    5-44，affcct
    ingap p
    r ox
    imはtcly
    14
    .8l 1l
    i
    IlionAmeri ca
    lladult
    so ra
    b ou
    t6. 7%of thepopula- I
    nsomniai
    ぉco
    nsidercdasl
    eep-N
    aked
    isorde
    .l
    r tsdi、
    a
    gno
    sti
    c
    tio
    ni nflg
    . iv
    cny ear
    .Themcanagca lo n
    sctfordcp re
    ぉSIVC c
    rit
    eri
    aisaprcdominantc
    ompla
    into
    fc l
    i
    ssat
    isr
    act
    ionwit
    h
    200 Bi
    oel
    ect
    romagnet
    icandSubtl
    e Ener
    gyM edi
    cine

    TABLE19.
    4
    CraniaJEJectrotherapyStimulation(
    仁 ES)DepressionStudies
    P
    rincipal
    I
    nvcstigat
    or n Su
    bject
    s Sl
    udyT
    ype Me
    asur
    emen
    tSc
    ale
    s/Outcome
    s
    Oa
    rda
    y('
    ¥al
    叫 J1
    5 AnxI
    'l
    l yP
    川Icnl
    s Rιマ"
    DB H
    il
    ll
    lil
    tonD、p陀 ss
    iol
    1 Ral
    IngScalc1 7(H八M-DI 71
    :I nt
    heac
    tiv
    cIr
    c川 mcnt
    gr山 '
    p，K2φha dauccrcaseof~き50 % 川 町or，引 from ba
    同Jin
    e10!ndpoi
    nt01
    t
    hcHA M-
    [}(p<t
    l.
    OOI
    )
    .Thc
    n!w岬 品 川gni
    i
    lc川1td
    iff
    cn:
    :nc
    cbc
    れ 叩cng r~lU ps
    t
    (p<O.)
    (
    l d=0
    ]. .7則。 1t
    hcHAM-
    D17f
    m mhasdine10endpo
    inl
    llf~(U(ly
    Thcmca
    ndC
    <'
    :1山 日 開 t
    hcHA M-
    DI7i
    nIhcI
    rl
    'l
    iLm
    じntgroupu
    f31. ( 64
    9%り
    tn6.
    47)w出 J llu"
    !
    CIh叩 twclvc(J2
    )li
    mc誌 t
    hcmeandc crea
    同 υnthe
    HAtvl
    -D17f ort h
    cshι1mgroU[
    Juf2.h%(10
    .22←りり 6
    )from ha
    :.d
    inc10
    じodp
    oinlofぉt udy
    P
    rieM
    ι 466 O¥'il
    山 首 Ser
    vic
    cMc ml河内 Su刊 c
    y 7
    -似)iolLikenscal
    c.Ofthctul
    algroup.5り 7~~ト rep0l1cd le田 Jcp即 断 i
    onam
    l
    川 、IVr
    Ic
    .
    ! r
    an、
    語vilhdcpt
    'es
    川on CI川 i
    Cl1
    : imp
    rovcmentn
    f::
    ;'
    :
    50% (
    improvcmenlo rs ubsti
    .
    lluialcl
    ini
    じ，1

    1Il 1~川 rt a nピc c


    ate
    gor
    y.Dworki
    nt! lll l."~ ) ， whi
    le20.
    0
    <:
    :-
    (
    'repnl
    1cdc
    lin
    ica
    l
    impmvcmC
    ll1(
    ¥rdc oobetw凶 n2
    r山 川 i 51
    kand4リ切 (improvcnwnlo
    l
    lm
    I Jcr
    atccl
    ini
    c:
    lli
    mpI)Jt叩山). I
    nIh
    clnT
    nIgr
    oup，7
    9.7係 0"1f
    cspond
    cnい
    rcp(1rt
    cd::
    ;
    '
    :25'kle日 dじP陀 閉 山 nanddin
    il.alimpm' cmenlwit 、
    hlh ~ J
    l
    1.り
    刊l¥y
    0'1I
    h 出 G陀 sp¥ln
    dcntぉrc
    porting:;
    .
    :5
    ()(
    i
    f;llp
    I rov menti 、
    ndq、同 日 !
    on
    Kげ出 h~I al
    ;¥
    1 別 恥r
    v ピ
    ，
    t Mω巾 Cl:' a
    nd柚 t
    cr;
    .l
    n.
    ' S
    urv
    cy 7
    -pn
    intLi
    .
    lcr
    t:-
    .
    cal
    c
    :36'
    Hof
    thct gr
    川川 ， o
    up日 p
    I)r
    kudc口 C
    山 c
    JJcp問 時 i
    onanu
    wi
    thDcprc.~sîun di
    nk"l1
    ;
    川1f
    {lV
    ell
    ll'凶101差別 }旬 、¥
    'il
    hL'I S~ 陀 porlcd di
    ni'a
    l limp
    川 ，、'
    cmCn
    l0'
    1
    hct
    dcp rc~sio n wl-'Cn25~託川 049税 54 .f1J. 0'
    1Ih
    cI nt
    algro叩 問 問 r
    lcd~2 Y"Æ>
    impr(WCl
    Il'
    lI
    II;1
    Id ep目 s
    si
    Clr
    l.I
    nlhcCESonl ygm up(nomcdica
    tion
    s).JR. 5C0
    r
    cpo
    rtc
    d申 込 印 刷cddcpr
    cs
    :-
    .i
    ol
    1<tn
    . dc
    lini
    c.t
    limpr o町 mじnt0' 0% whi¥
    1ミ5 c
    2
    3.1
    併 rcp
    (川 eddinic
    alimpro同 men
    t( )
    fdcp
    rcs
    :-.ionbetwc叩 25%川 d49
    Sf
    r~)f a1
    叫u1 υr61.
    60/
    ，.01r
    ' espOl礼Icnl
    swhor
    epo
    rt.
    :ddc
    crca:
    -.
    e
    dc t
    cpr
    c出 I
    υnand
    clink:ali
    llp
    1 ro
    日 m cnt2
    :2 う(k.l日I h
    !
    .Cι可andmedi
    ca
    til
    )l
    lsgroup，l5.
    5g n
    f
    仇:~pùndc n l:-. r
    ピpor
    tedd!.
    !nca
    :-.
    c Jdcprじ州 l
    unal
    叫< .
    :
    li
    ni
    <
    .
    :alimprovemcnl;
    :
    ?
    :50
    C{
    whi k1 7. lf Nr cp
    nrlcddcacω;i，!ddc
    prcssiunt
    x
    !lwcen25%an d-'1
    }持
    Hn
    川川、p
    刊
    刊
    ，、
    州
    '刷
    0

    J
    cpr
    ，
    陀
    じ引:
    ‘
    “S
    l“
    ‘
    川‘
    刊na
    削 川n
    ‘
    山
    ' u，
    凶 叶I
    i
    川n
    刷κ
    '
    C .
    川
    ‘Ii
    “mp0
    刊附
    、
    Bw
    、¥
    '
    、CIll
    叫cn
    川1;主芝日 必
    25~句
    恥kl
    υn
    l"' 2
    1 J
    ai
    Dcpn:~~cJlSccur
    i!y:
    l
    Ild RCT‘日日 RcckDcp r
    c山 i
    OI
    lIIl¥
    'c
    nlor
    y(BDIJ日ri
    cfSymplomI nvc1Ho
    ryDè prcs~ i on
    P
    alr
    olQ
    niccrs Suh叫 ;
    I
    k (8S1-D
    ):ThcCESg ro
    tlphadれ g
    nit
    ica
    ntl
    yl osdcprc~sion f rom
    b山 e
    lin
    cth
    anshu
    lllgnmp込1cndp
    oinl
    υfぉt
    udy1
    1
    Il BD1(p<0
    .01
    ):mc
    ¥nn
    、
    ‘r

    BSI-D(p<0.
    (5)
    y

    y
    k
    uu
    メ

    1
    2 GcncralLadAnxi
    ctyDisn
    rdi
    .
    '1
    " OL H‘l
    l1
    1i
    ll
    ol
    1Dcprc
    :
    柑iO
    llScak1 7.Dc pr
    es見1
    (
    !1Iscore
    swe町 民 i
    gniJ
    ica
    ntl
    yIc.~ おり n
    Cla 1.~パ Patc!Hsw
    i it
    hDcprcs
    sion HA M-D打，1
    1Cldp
    J <川 1of.~ I ud y f
    romhil
    :
    -.
    cl川 c(p-=O
    .OI.t
    1- =
    イ1.41
    )
    Ch
    ClC
    la l .\-~ 60 1
    Chidr
    enwi
    thMi
    ;
    .;
    eJAnx
    ic
    l)
    ' RCT.I
    B Zun
    gDcp
    陀 柿i
    OI
    lSc
    .lk(
    SDS
    ):TheANOVA.
    -
    :howedt
    hat0
    11SDS.
    thclll ~ in
    Dc prc ~s i \'c Dis
    urJ
    er(MAD} dli
    :
    t:1bet
    W<!C1
    ICESgruupandぉhamωmpamlo'
    lgr
    oupwa
    おお i
    gnihc
    ant
    (F=)6.5へ1'<υ01 )
    t.
    Luc .
    1
    .
    ''
    '
    ' 32 C
    hil t
    ln:nwi l
    hEmol ion:
    l OL Z
    IU】gD
    cpr
    css
    ionS
    cal
    c(SDS)
    ;rrOllb
    a
    :-
    .c
    ¥in
    cυ'
    10.
    6 Ol
    4士n.!lnpO~ l -t出t
    D i~unlc rs (De
    prC同 i
    o・n
    ) 0
    .52土 O.
    !(
    ){p>O.
    Ol) 1
    )山 守 将巧 ha
    d延i
    gni
    ti
    cant
    clT
    cct(
    41Ck)，1
    7c~ お町 had
    clTcct( 5ミ切)， a nJIhcef
    fcl
    じ1wa品 I
    nvll
    < i
    dint
    woじas
    c討 (6C;{);l
    hcto
    talcff
    c.:
    :l
    ivi，!
    ratc 、.v a~ り4';}. SJ
    .i
    ，
    ; nt
    ell
    lpc
    rat
    un!roS
    ¥!(I<0
    } .01
    ):-
    .y
    stoli
    chl句 o
    otlp山 川 ほ
    d
    roppcdandlhcpu¥
    seslo
    wcddOWl‘f
    L
    lcrlhct閃 almenLanuthcdif
    fcr
    em.:品

    、
    刊rc則 gnl
    伯印 刷 (p<01
    .)
    5).2
    6叫 s
    C:
    -
    .foll
    向，¥
    'dup刊 1
    c ¥01ωfwh;ch24C:出 、
    気

    ha
    dlungl ;l ~l ill g c
    nic
    acyw
    ilhf
    clkv
    edO
    fcl
    imi
    nat
    cd只ymptom
    山 川 .
    u1情
    。
    凶叫ぉ hadr
    cl
    ar
    :-
    .cof:
    -.y
    mpt
    oslWh'
    ll
    Cd
    " r
    u.
    gswcrcn
    凶 dedt
    oco
    nll11lt
    h山
    :
    -.y
    mpl
    om 、
    Al
    ph:
    I-S
    tim Jl8 Dcpn
    !
    .日c tk
    JPa :n
    tぉ S
    urv
    cν Fnurp川 nlL
    ikcr
    lScalc:Dcpn:
    :州 i
    on‘(don¥!
    l
    .n'"53 口fthi
    s割引 up.
    66 Wi
    .( :-
    U叫 rSurvcy f
    Cp 円以 Ik凶 depr
    e同 ionl
    inJdink<lli1
    llp
    rovel
    Il¥
    !J
    l fミ50仏 wh
    ¥o i
    lc2U.75S手
    1
    りり5-
    . 19り8 r
    cpo
    rtc
    JI c凶 dcp陀 ~sl on at
    叫 impr
    ovcl
    1lc
    ntb
    ctw
    ¥!n2
    e c
    5kand4引 r
    . 1
    00a
    ]0'
    1 ^
    86.79 りその f rh c::柑 re~IX)fl d\! n tぉ rcpo l'lcd ;
    :?
    :2
    Skimprovem
    C 引l
    tind叩"阿 1川
    0，、 prl's~ icm (
    ¥
    ¥'i
    lhn
    lhcrl
    :on
    dit
    io川 n=265
    .Ofl
    hiぉg
    roup
    .66
    .0司法陀 poncl
    t
    l :
    c
    白話 d pr
    心掛 i
    . Ol uc
    lan 1i
    nica
    lil
    ll
    provcmenlor
    ;
    :?
    :50"
    k .
    ' v
    hie2
    l 3
    .02
    CJn'
    por
    lι
    叫 、 ，
    andimprovcmc川 hclW
    Ics~ dcp四日 Î~1fl 勺(;n25%品nJ499
    f.Al olalof持9
    .06'
    1
    oft
    h剖 cr
    e対pondenl
    srep
    oI1ed2
    :
    .25を
    i
    1 lmprov
    emc川 indep阿 川 川 n

    RCT:T<m
    dom
    I/.じ dc
    ont
    rol
    kdI
    ri
    ul 口s
    :douh¥
    chl s:i nvc~tigat úrh li n d ~ OL
    ind、I :upcn1
    Jb
    : c.
    lTO
    laln
    ;
    ;;
    ;111
    3fra1
    o lCESdepr
    css
    ion叫 u
    Jic
    s
    TheEvol
    uti
    ono
    fCr
    ani
    alE
    lec
    tro
    the
    rap
    ySt
    imu
    lat
    ion 201

    TABLE19.5
    Mela-Analysi
    sofCESS
    lud
    ies01Depression
    P
    rincipal
    I
    nve sti
    gat
    or T
    ota
    ln S
    ubj
    ect
    s S
    lud
    yTy
    pe F
    ind
    ing
    s
    K
    ir可ピ han
    d 937 :
    !)S
    ( t
    udi
    oth
    ati
    ndu
    dl'd Ml
    ::
    Iト 2
    0山 ldieswhkhi n du dcd937p a
    i
    l c l 刊誌、v ithd e p r:s
    l .
    " ionwc 陀 a naJyzt!d10
    Gil uJ
    a'
    u d
    epre同 cdp a
    ti
    en t
    san
    d ¥
    n:dy
    !>j
    ぉ dcterm
    i ncl h
    ed t
    ec to fCES0 11t c1
    1 刊を s s
    i，)nan dp roduιe d3.1e 汀ect誌i zenf
    i
    nve
    si
    t g
    :n
    .edt hじ r:0 .5
    0d /i
    c Tじd
    l asah lrgcclTect:-
    i山 ( p.115
    ). ""N (l(e :A Co c hr
    an e
    仔ι
    c じ"刊 n e
    s snfCESon SystcmalkR cvi ewb yM oncri cff山 d町、l1e agu出(20 04)山 川 1 thec f f
    ccto
    f
    o
    epre
    s 詩<0" anli
    d lr
    cJ c崎 山 い o nd ep山 川 i
    onI halj m: l udc
    dn In cl
    吋 udi出 i n vohing7 51
    pa川!C
    lp an
    t ぉp roduc cdap o o
    k dc st i m‘t
    ¥ c01c
    ' ff :c
    l to fr:(U9s tandan l
    dcv
    ia
    til ぉ(
    ll
    1 0.2410 0.5 4
    )i1f av
    . oru ft h eanli d c prc活 ~allt mCil.~U日 d by
    l11
    1p
    ro叫
    v:lll
    Cn
    凶t nmo xd.Onc気対叫川
    l
    t
    u d
    yW 邸~札附、 t h
    c
    叩n 叩 m ov c d山 1 tW 、t

    “
    l ，
    川 代
    <>刈
    山
    吋 時 、

    “
    し
    侭
    ‘

    戸'
    附詩
    "山I
    lv
    eI na叫
    1.5 e S
    引"悩l山"，
    叫"げyal
    la
    叫I ys
    剖"‘泊B叫l白叫h~ r omi
    l
    川t
    山tln gよth
    itト
    誌
    占 r
    ial陀r'
    eJ山
    "，
    比山
    、
    Lcdt h
    陀 e
    poo[eJd f
    c clt orニ0 . 1
    7(0 .
    001 00. 34)

    s
    leep叫u
    antl
    ly.a
    おおO
    C1込t
    edwi
    thone(
    ormo
    rc)o
    flh
    cro
    llowing rcsultscomingi nt heopcnl ab
    elpha sewhcnp at
    icn l倍
    、.vere
    s
    ymptom沿 al lowedt ocon trolthccu rrent，duratio
    n.andt imeofda yt he
    t
    r eat l
    llc
    nttookpl a
    ct.21
    :
    : l

    Difl
    icultyinit
    iat
    ingsle
    ep Thc S cr
    vi ce Member and v e
    te.
    ran s urve
    yd ividedt hc
    Diff
    icultymaintain
    ingslee
    p patie n
    tsupi ntos ubgroupsdepending0 1
    1m edicationu ぉe;
    Early-morningawakeningwit
    hin
    abi
    lil
    ytor
    etu
    rnt
    o 40. 3%ofp atients uおi n
    gCES i n じombin込tionw ith slcep
    sl
    ecp ingm edications陀 p ort cd主50%impro vement，w hile6 5.2併
    0'
    1p ati
    entお usingCESwilhoUfm edication只 r
    eporred2 :
    50 号
    も
    Slc opd i
    ぉt ur banccsc auscc l
    ini caI
    lys ig
    nificantdi日 r e
    sso r 川 l provement
    .Thistrendwasconsiおt cnt山 not
    1ge achc ate-
    impainnenti ns o
    c i
    a l，o ccupatio nal，e ducational， 出 ademic. go ryt hatw，-日付 t
    u died( an
    xicly.PTSD，i nsomnia，de p
    rcssion，
    b e havio ral，o ro theri mpo rt
    a nta rcaso ff u
    nc tio川 ng.The pain .andh eada che)a ss e
    CI】 i
    nF igure1 9り免l
    ぉIccpd iflic
    ult ymustoccura tl e
    a 川 t hreenightsaweekf ora '
    t
    h::~a.
    .
    .
    ;t3m o nthsι lespit eadequateo pportunityf o
    r討l e
    c p
    .5!
    PAIN
    As tudydonebyt heN ationallnst ituteぉofHe althi n2005
    、
    ct imutcd' h
    I
    完1
    a
    la ppro xim ately1 0%o fAmericanおお u 1Tcrfrom Chronicp ainaff
    cclsal mo 叫 100m i
    lliol
    lAmericanswi t
    ha
    II1S 0mn1i .
    l to
    talannualco 叫 toh ealthc arerangingfrom$560h ill
    ion
    Tabl e
    s1 9
    . 6-19.8 i nclude 剖 x human s t
    udi剖 and one to$635b il
    1ionin2010.Chronicp aina1soh a stheg reate
    sr
    c quincs tudyi nvc叫 i gatingth ce ffcct討 ofCESf orr hot roat- ccononlCImp江c
    l tduet od i叫 bi
    li
    tyday詩 andl ostwagesand
    mentofi nsomn i
    a. Thet ablesi n
    c ludct hrceRCT s
    .( a
    lld oubl e- product
    ivi
    ty
    hl i nclt
    ，
    ) h reeus ers ur veys，andame ta-analys
    is.Thent ort hc Anest i
    matcd20Coo
    ; fAmericana d
    u l
    ts(42m il l
    ionp e
    ople)
    si xhumans l
    u diest ot a
    led654 ‘wit h1 63fromRCT 、 : repo
    rlt ha
    lp aindisruptst he
    irs l
    cepatl ea
    stafcwn igh
    tsa
    Whencompar ingd atafromt h et hreeRCTs tudie仇 weh ave weck.Evenw iththeop lio
    n swehaveavai labh~ forpainman-
    () n es malldfects ize( d~ - 0.03.l'~ 0 .00
    1)andonemouium agementnow ，morethanh alfofaIJho叩 i
    talizedpa ti
    entsexpe-
    c!1c cts ize (J~ 0 .54.p~ 0 .02)."訓 Thct hi
    rd RCT d idn ot n叩 cedp aininthelastdayso fthc
    irilveswith50%ー75%of
    r cp ortc ffects izcsb utd ids ees igni.
    i
    f cantimprovementu tday pati
    cntsdyingofc a
    ncc rreponingmoderatet o時 v erepは)n
    .74
    1( 1
    '~ 0 .04)andday4( I=0
    f .03)d uringr hes t
    u dy.Thes tu dy Tabl e1 9.
    9i ncfudess evend ou b1e- b
    1i n
    dRCT s
    .oncopen-
    d e signc a ll
    e df or5c o nsecutivcday so fCESt r eatmen tinun labcl，and t wo u scrs ur
    vc y話 inve stigatingl hce fticac
    y of
    a t temp ttoimprov es lee pamonga ctived utyServi ccMembers treatingc hron icpa i
    nw ithCES.Thct ota!nfromt hispain
    A f ter5day日 o ftre atm e
    nt，t hes u
    b jectお intheacti v
    egroup以 IW rcseare his1 7 1
    2w ith366fromd oub1 e-blindRCTs
    an品 、: r
    agc0' 143morcm inut山 0 1s
    ' leeppe rnightcomparcdt o ThcRCTsi ncludcdp川 Icntss u
    f fcringwi l
    hf ibror
    nyalgi
    a.
    19mi n1esss leepoverr hosc5da yぉ int hes hamt re川e dg roup .1
    J Par kinぉon's，ands pinalcor dinjuri出 A 11reportcde rFectsiz
    es
    Thel hrees eparateus crsUfve ysr ea chedsub 叫a lHialclini- weremeasureda sl a
    r gew ithp- val uesra n
    g ingf romp=0 .03
    ca limportancci n65%，58%.and45%o finsomniap aticl1ts rop<0 .001. Mosto fr h
    ed oublc-b 1inds tudiesaddcda nopen-
    Thc1 0wcr叫 : or eo f45%i sfroma刊 r v
    eygi vent oS erviじC label arma tt h
    ecndoft hed o ublc -
    bl indp ortionins ham
    Membersandv etera ns
    .wh icha ret ypical
    lyamo r
    eu i
    fficult treated叩 b jec ts$0t hatallp arti c
    i panrshadano pp
    or tu
    nity
    p o pul ationt ot re
    a .T
    1 hcm cta-a nal ysisgroup ed t her e民u1tぉ tor cceivct re atm
    ent.l neach仁a s e， 州防 e ctsi ntheopen- Iab
    el
    from20insomnias tudi出 .e ncompassing 1 087p叫 l ent吋 anct plta児 alぉoa c hieveds ign
    ificantp ainr elief( s
    eeT ablc1 9
    .9)
    repor tcdalarg~ c ffe cts iz
    c0'1O .64.('
    t
    l Ther e
    sultsf rorntwod ifferen
    ts ur v
    eysi nc
    ludeds u
    bstanti
    al
    A RCTf oc ll
    singon t hes leepin gh abit
    soff ibromyal gia clinic
    alimportance( ミ 50%i mprov山 1 1Cn
    t)i npaticntswithpain
    p at lcntぉ showcd s igni
    tiじa ntc linical improv ementd uri ng (30%).headaeheち ( 4
    0 %).rcf
    le xs ympa rheticd ysrrophy( 5
    3係)，
    ther igiddouble -blindp ortiono ft hes t
    udy.l henevenheHe f Hbr or
    ny al
    g ia(54~)， andm igrainch叫 da ehes( 5
    7%).'‘Asw ith
    202 Bioelectromagnet
    icandSubt
    leEner
    gyM edi
    cine

    TABlE19.
    6
    CranialElectrotherapyStimulalion(
    仁 ES)InsomniaStudies
    P
    rinc
    ipal
    I
    nve
    stig
    ator n Su
    bje
    cts St
    udyTypc MeasurementS臼 l
    es/
    Outcomcs
    Pr
    I:e
    l
    . /
    1
    ， 130 S
    Ci vi li a l\ ~.c
    r ¥
    'ke Su
    rve
    y 7
    - p
    o;1I1Lik !r
    l ts c"l
    e.Ofl ht!1()lal.
    g roup. 57
    .5後 陀 pim eJI 出 品 川 岬 mn 凶 anucli
    nic al
    M ctllbc:: r~ and 川lpro v巴 menl(Jfミ50野 ( I
    Inp r ov'm叩 1
    t
    . orsubslani
    l川仁 lini:
    .a
    ¥imp u刊 誌nccc:
    lIcgo可
    VI
    !l
    . C ranSwi th Dwor bnd礼 !“) .whi l
    c20. 4tkr cpOlt cJc l
    inka limprov cm じn
    l0' 1Insomniahe twccn
    l
    ns omnw 2刊 : lnd4 917
    0( impr o ¥'cmcnlo fm ode r ateclini山 1i
    mpl.
    .lrW恥 :
    c).IIt heIOta
    lg roup.
    77H .{
    /
    r )f山)<， pomkntsn :
    :por teJ2: 25c
    kl c出 川 崎 mniaa ndc l
    iniealimpruv cm叩 tw i
    thth
    e
    maj
    or it :5
    yofth csc 同 .~ po ndè nts 問 porlÎ ng :
    2 (
    Yki mpro¥
    ' cmentini n
    s omn
    ia
    Lundea
    仁i
    ragn
    a
    u
    n
    d
    i
    η
    57

    I
    n同 I
    I
    DUl

    I
    nt!
    :
    yS
    c
    A ~ l i v\!
    McmbcrswI
    t
    r
    h
    vI
    ce RCT.Ds P
    i

    ト
    (
    ;
    u沿b
    4
    lep
    u
    3min
    rg1 r1 ~ ú l1l ni ;l Ra
    )f
    .Thcui
    t
    r utl
    o" c
    、
    lhaci
    陀
    I l I:
    .
    ln
    Cb
    t
    ingSca
    ct
    el
    ha
    we
    nt
    lc
    :Th
    h
    ent
    cs
    eact
    hamCE
    hea、
    ct
    i'
    、
    ivcCESg
    !g
    eCESa
    '山 I

    n
    r
    oupha
    pwhoa
    dSh
    ‘
    v
    da1
    !r
    amCESg
    a
    g
    0ng
    e1
    r
    crt
    9mi
    oup品a
    ota
    ltimc沿J
    nk阿 t
    円lr
    ot
    oil¥:h
    e
    pt
    alt
    eu
    irn
    c

    -
    ;igni t
    i
    ca n c e(p三('-079) .A. gcnu口 dit
    Tc陀 I
    1"C¥
    l ¥
    ';附 o(
    )lc
    d.Mc nwhocompl c
    tcdi l'
    ¥c
    ‘cs点目。nおり rCESh "dおign ilkan
    ti mprovcmen ti ntolll
    < tim
    es kpぺarterIh 、
    e針rICES
    tr
    catmcn t(p=0. 0 4
    )a nJ01da y4
    -(1'=0.U3) .Mc ninthc;H
    .
    :tiv
    eCESg rnup可1 刊日 n
    ，
    avct:
    .lge(1f5~ O1i nmo rct 山 11times
    leptaftctthei lrs
    tCESt r
    eatmenta ndn n川 口 a ge
    61minmurct叫 ult il
    ll
    .'SkPl山 】 day4COOl川、r
    I c dlOt hcshamCES: gr
    oLip.The rcwcrc
    nos igniti c a ntc h an gc鈴 i
    nt ota
    lt im
    c寸e ptam lln.
    gt hcfcmaksi n山 es tudy
    Ta
    yJo
    rct品[
    .
    '1 46 ドihmll
    y:
    l.
    igi
    a 民CT.D
    tl Gen er
    alSle巴PD 、
    itu
    rhanピf'Scal
    e(GSDS):CEミg rlU
    ( pha u訓 gniti
    cant
    lylo
    wc l刈 I
    ) r
    cson
    P:
    ni
    cnls GSDS( i
    ndkatiogIいおお kc pJi
    泊urha町 c)t
    h川 ぉhamfrom ha seli
    ncatcnJpoinl(lf
    ‘tudy(p=O. O
    OI( 1=-0. 30)a
    可 ndcomplelc
    Jtheぉt
    udyw ilh!oc
    ' nre
    shelowthcr'
    ，mg.
    .
    ::of
    1
    1lS0nmJa
    Lidl
    lhr
    oUI
    1 (
    バ) Fihrumya
    lgi
    a RCT.D日、 0-10Nu m
    ..
    ::r
    ic
    alRlti
    ngおじ:.ll ，
    c(NRS) :CESgmuphaJ"
    Sig
    nil
    ica
    ntlyh
    igh
    cf語以 '刊 誌 川 1t
    h:
    .
    c
    taL'ト Pai
    tcnls OL qual
    ityofsle
    cpontc
    :om
    . emè a~叩 re t
    hant
    hl
    !s
    . h
    arna
    ndじ制1Imlgroup
    satcndpoil1tof
    当tuu
    y(p=O. r2，d=0.
    J 54
    )
    K
    irs
    dlc
    t川 " 98 Scr vi
    c t 'Me mbcrs Sur
    vcv Lik
    7 ~po î nl .
    .:
    :rtsc:.
    ¥l
    c:~)f l 1
    lcl o
    lalg mu .4
    p 4.8ck閃 portcJl e揺ら m叩 mn iaa ndd inica l
    Jn
    : dVcl er a
    nswith improv e ll1c ntI)f~5 0' 令 whi le 20. 4f
    Ar cportl
    !dd inω
    :..
    1i rnp 、
    roemen to fi l詩o
    1 mr la
    In~引 l tlln li\ 以::t
    we .n2Sf
    : 万lin J49( j.1
    f ¥I
    1 hcl ol algruup.6弓2 i
    1砂川 町 甲 山u l
    eJll 品目 似J r
    ted2 :
    2 ミ句
    unp rn\'e m..:川川川 ~o lll l\ i a . InthcCESon lyg r oup(1
    ¥0Illcdi cat ion吋 .62( 手 r
    j ep 1
    0l cd
    decre:
    <脳c di nswnni 品 川 Jc li nI
    .:a
    li mpmv cmcnllfお O係 whi k23. 8寝 間 p urtcdC I山 山1
    il
    l1provcmc l
    ll¥lfi1s
    l omni abdwccll2 弓鴨 川 d4 )'
    1 kforat ota lo fg5日係 υr"，只 p on JCl
    l
    ts
    whor c po川 c Jlc州 m詩O sl ni aan dc link alImpnweme l2
    l
    ¥ :25%.I nI heCES) ;nd
    mcdicatinm， gmup、- HJ.JC ふu frc)p
    ，
    < ondcntsr Clo
    [ rlcddecrc a叫 di n討o mniaa ndcl i
    nIl
    .:
    al
    rm pro刊 m創刊 当日9 ('wh ile1 9汚c;r CJ
    10rt
    ピdd 叩 ，.出 edi n込o mnia25弘 -4 9(，
    Yoil
    l1provemen
    t
    forat ul alof5 Y.8c
    A : υrr cぉpu nuen tswhnn :
    :purtcJuc c
    r c
    山 c Ji n ~olll n ia :
    lndιilni cal
    imp rl
    lVC mC lI
    J ~25 (;砕

    A
    1ph仕 Slil
    l
    l 1
    63 I
    nsomni
    aPat
    ;cnl
    S Sur
    ve)
    ' -poimL
    4 ikcl1S C:l
    le: oft h
    時 grollJ
    l. 65. 0.
    Vk日 p(lr
    ' leJI c l
    l
    ls “
    offima山 ddi nkal
    U叫 rSurn:y
    . imrrovemcnto f 之 50~f ， whi1
    c' 28民 .¥tifrcpor
    tcdI c 山 川sOl
    llnIaa ndImpro何c
    、 l
    ll
    cnl
    199汚-1998 hCl¥v
    ee
    -n2 5 ~f :
    tnd4 ~リ%八 l ot alo r 9 3.H7得。 ft he討e r山仰 ndenls r
    epurl
    cu詮2 5ck
    nnpro山 mc n tin1附 O !
    ll
    lll
    <J

    RCT
    'ra
    nd(
    )IlI
    l z
    edc
    ont
    rolc
    us h1
    wuy:DB:dυu ch
    lind OL
    :opc
    nIL
    ‘ h
    cl
    :n=6句4f~)r ali
    守 川 t
    川lIli
    ast
    udi
    c誌

    TABlE19.7
    Meta-AnalysisofCESStudiesofInsomnia
    P
    rincip
    allnvest
    ig a
    tor n Subjects StudyTyp
    e Mea
    surcmentS
    cal
    es/
    Fin
    din
    gs
    ;附 cha
    K nJGilul
    a仙 1
    087 20Stu
    dばお lhatexaminc
    d Mcta~anal y 叫 is Twcl l
    ty( 20)は u di
    cs.whi chIncJudcJ1 08 7pati
    ent兵 wc陀 an
    alY 7eJ10
    t
    hceffe
    ctofCESon dc t
    enni nct hee fιc
    l
    f tofCE! 'o
    i ninso
    llmI aprouκ
    ue danclTe
    ct語版 eo f
    msのmm a r=0. 64J eli n eda.
    sal :
    ugcc ITcl
    .'
    1siz
    c( p.11計 約 N叫 己 ^mc ta
    ‘lIla
    ly川 byHuc do-Mc uina:U
    l dω l
    Ie a
    ，
    -t
    '1I
    CS(2012)川 theelfc.
    .
    :t01
    100- 淀 川z
    1 n di a zcpinehypn 州 国 t h
    atindu le
    t
    . d円 吋 ud叫 invll
    C ving
    -1 17 民 ~ u hjc c! s pro
    du ccdn“誌i gnil
    ica
    nt. hut忌malltomcdium
    d;町ι陀 nc c
    '.0 11s ub
    jc!
    ':l
    ivc討lccpl a
    tency( -0.33)and
    poly
    somnn
    grap
    hicぉ1
    ccp1at
    ClC
    YclTc
    ctt
    -0.
    3刷 i
    nfa
    Vl
    l"
    ioft
    hc
    Ir
    catm
    entve目ust
    hecOl
    1tr
    oJgwup
    TheEvol
    uti
    ono
    fCrani
    a
    lEl
    ect
    rol
    herapyS
    tim
    ula
    tion 203

    TABlE19.
    8
    CES5tudyofInsomniai
    nHorses
    P
    rin口 p
    aJl
    nve
    sti
    gat
    or n Su
    hje
    cts S
    ludyT
    ypc Measureme nlS caJes /Outcome s
    C e.
    lilf.
    l t;
    : ¥
    1
    .7; 持 ( )Hor..e~. 1Mω2 OL Thじ p Hl p Ol1ioll0 '
    11ime~penl s lalHl ing! tu zin glhr ough oUIth ef o urtr
    Iu l p
    h出 じ 討
    :
    .
    l
    I1d5Gddi
    n;:
    見 W: I
    メI lJ
    I I
    Fc d .11r h山 e th陀c.v a lu c ぉa 'e
    l h i
    g h
    c '0
    l 'c
    1 l)
    凶<11t
    ut hc柄。 lucsin酬 は同
    町l e
    .AP 山町t.l lI
    - oln unp aringI hem: c anV Jl u
    ピS duin
    r gI h
    e 心 p
    、 h a
    seso n
    e. md
    【hrcc~ ug gω I s l hedi I
    Tcre nc
    ci i
    気持 gni li
    <:anl( t=- 2ふ. J.p<O .
    U 町 I np h国 efo ur
    Ihe刊 met r
    el 叫1 おお ccnw ithc achh 刊 誌C 、 刊l u
    eh igher( n=o)01 'cqu i
    l
    l( n
    ::
    :2 )
    1ll
    !
    ， h，11i np h出 co ne.Ap a
    ircdt - l è ~1 ι onlirm~ lhじ見 i g
    niliじa 1ι
    l eu fl
    hi>
    !t.li
    lTe
    renじC
    (
    1=-1 .29. 1<0 .0訂
    Thcp r o p o ri
    t山l ofli mcぉp cnl河川以l ingd 山lIlg 配 r o日 t hep h 山出 w asa l
    sof ou nd
    10h :
    :Wept)~i tî vc c orrcla Io
    l nw itht rialp ha 同 (rニ n .
    220 .p=り山.1) .t i
    llc只pcnt
    wi t
    hl te 附 rlirr c l
    a xeJ( r:0 .62 0 、ρ< 0，(則1).l im cS pClltwi 山 l o weril p
    q u
    ivcr i n g(1'= 0.48 4
    .P<(J.(川 1 ). I hcI Imc. :pc
    nt witht h eIc
    f.e
    l tr
    ; had .
    れ =0 .2 6ミ ρ=f U)0 2) Imc見
    1 pt:n lwi thI Ic
    l ri
    ghle arh ack(1'= 0 .26呂、ρ:::O.
    (Jf日).
    an dh c a d、'，o hhli ngI士r0 ..
    15 3.'<り(x)1
    1 .)Timじ ~rcnl ~land i ll g l
    to/ingaじrosお
    thel ri
    alp ha丸山町l~ a hof ounJt oh ~1 吋 a n e.
    galivec orr el山川 w ithtirnesp目立

    は andi l1 g 川 ~rl (
    1'= -0.94汚 ρ<0 . 0 01)、¥IJn c話pcnle 山 n gb cd di ng1 "=
    1 ーイ 1
    .205 、

    p:0 .
    ( 5 ).a ndt i mcメp CJll叫 li
    ngf or agl!(r= --0.3 31.1 1<r u則1 )

    theanxiety，inおomniat lnddcpre附 101


    1s urveyぉc onduct e
    dw ith groupwnse xpcric
    ncingIcssp ain He fi
    :rnanwasablet
    t 判 o
    Scrvic ‘
    、
    cMcmbcr l ndVcteransach ieve
    dl e
    ssp ainrdid 5
    1This
    . measure山】 di d
    enli
    fyEEGpa ltc
    rn s0'
    1patientswi l
    hp ainand
    i
    sbdi c
    v山I t
    ohcthe，出 u ltoft h
    eI ypeo rinjuryanda s叩 c ia
    ted wast h c
    nabl e10normalizcthep attc
    rncx じlusivclywilhI he
    p山 1i nc
    ur redbySt!rvI
    :eMcmbcrsi
    l nlheatersofwar U河 o ftheAlpha-StimCESd evicc，butnott heo therclev
    ices
    Thcmostr cce n
    tt ibromyalgiaRCTusedf unctionalMRJ het es
    ted?
    '<
    叫u die
    st odt:t
    ; crmincl hピ areasoft heb raint h
    a larcr cspon 予 Unfortuna
    tely，the FDA isa r bi
    trar
    yi l n
    dc apric
    iousi n
    見ibl
    ef o
    rproc essingpail1duringal ihromyalgiuf l
    are-up. Oncc performingitsduti
    csi nregul
    atingmedicaluev ices.]nf act
    ，
    thcsckcya 印刷 h adbCCI1idel
    1li
    fied.p叫 ien
    tslIsinga c
    t ivcCES theyhavcaut hori
    zedt h
    emarkcti ngo fCESde vic
    ::swithno ‘
    ands hun】 CES、叩 r ccxami ned，rewali ngthatconsi slcntwith rcぉearchalallbyallowingthcmt ous esl
    lllic
    l おじ onducledon
    allothcrf actorsmcas urcd，o nlyI hcu ct
    iveCES t r e
    a tme
    nt otherd evi
    ccs
    .witlwidelydiffer
    in gwaveforn】 charact
    erist
    icお

    ECES+Med
    c
    王
    〈子
    TG
    0
    %

    2
    0.2
    %
    21
    .6崎
    2
    0Qも

    4
    6
    4
    3
    40 ~ 。

    .
    .
    5
    %
    2
    %
    6加も

    ，
    ~肌，
    6
    6.%川 =7
    7 6
    8
    0帖

    N=5
    7
    1
    00怖

    C
    E5 1
    5.4
    % I 5
    7.7
    % I73
    .1
    軸， N=
    19
    7

    •
    2
    3.9% 3
    8.1
    6
    拍 • 6
    2仇 N=55
    T
    G
    2
    4.3
    % 3
    5.7% 60
    .0%
    ，N=4
    2
    ロ
    巴
    ロ
    司 CES+Med
    C
    E5 2
    2.略￨
    2 5
    0.0
    '
    l色 I72.2%，N=13
    T
    2
    0.4
    % 4
    4.8
    % • 6
    5.2
    %，N=臼
    E
    C
    c
    EEES+MTed
    例
    帆 G 1
    9.5
    % .
    4O3 d台 .59.8
    %，N=4
    6

    仁E
    5 2
    3.8
    % 6
    2.0
    叫 I85.
    8帖.
    N=1
    8

    1
    8.0
    % 3
    6.0% 5
    4.0
    %，Nニ 4
    8

    E
    ω
    v
    C
    E
    口、
    L C
    ES+
    MTe
    G
    d 1
    7.
    1% 3
    5.5% -
    526%
    ，NZ4
    40

    仁E
    5 2
    3.0% 3
    7.8
    % I60.8%，N=8
    口I
    mpr
    ove
    d25-
    49% 口I
    mpr
    ove
    d之5
    01も

    T
    G=T
    ota
    lgr
    oup，C
    ES+Me
    d=仁日 n
    ial
    ele
    ctr
    othe
    rap
    yst
    imu
    lat
    ionpl
    usmedi
    ca
    tlo
    n

    lGURE1
    F 9.4 S目
    erv
    川1ω
    じ oM山I
    己m
    口 h
    由児
    、C
    町r
    aωn
    dVe
    叫 剖I
    c
    町ra
    n沿以川I
    I
    r
    円v心yc
    omp
    a山1
    川ng出
    1
    hcm、
    Co
    心 fC
    f
    江r
    山u
    刷i
    川
    l a
    1c
    I叫 Je
    clr
    o
    叫【h
    cra
    py誌~吋‘刊t i mu l ation (
    CES)"川お t
    :
    ;~、山、
    me
    出1
    1
    】1tοCESwi
    th川nc
    "児dicat
    io nぉ
    204 Bioelectromagneti(and Subtle EnergyMedi口 ne

    TABLE1
    9.9
    CranialElectrotherapyStimulation(
    仁 ES)RandomizedControlledStudy (RCT) ，
    SurveysandO pen-LabelStudiesofPain

    P
    rin
    cip
    all
    nves
    tigal
    or n Sub
    jec
    ts Design Mcasurement$cal
    cs/Ou
    tcomes
    Tayl
    orC
    I<ll.~吋 4" Fihwmyalgia RCT
    .日8 0-¥0N¥{S
    :Thoぽ in
    Jivi
    ou;
    ¥lぉusingthca
    Cli
    veCESc kviceh:ld，
    ¥signi
    fi
    can
    t
    Pati
    c!
    l{s JCC
    fca
    scin山 cr
    agcp川 1(p=O JJ23
    )whcncumpared1 0th出 ci nd
    ivio
    uals
    Uおi
    ngthcshamdc、i
    ccorthosじ r
    cco、
    :J
    . 1
    1
    lgu討u;11car
    calonc(Jvcrtim
    c
    。持fthcBP1
    Ta1
    lc¥~p同 1
    05 かl
    il
    C
    on
    i
    t
    l
    l
    a
    n
    r
    y，S
    j
    ur
    p
    y
    in
    al
    。
    Rι:T.D日
    L
    唱 {ー1
    ト
    a
    0NRS:P
    ainJ
    n
    山 町 CESg
    te
    nsi
    tvan
    dPa
    i
    .r
    nJ
    o
    n
    u
    te
    r
    pr
    f
    cn
    :
    cp
    :l
    o
    比:

    r
    cSuhsc:
    t ，
    吋 ai
    dc
    gni
    tica
    n t
    lyg r
    calc川 町 四 euccr
    四日 m
    :The
    p
    ;:1l1l
    p rc1 0po 式t daliyt
    r:a
    l lmcn!ぉ Ih
    ant h
    es h¥
    '
    :1
    T1gr J(P<(
    ou[ ).0
    5).Thea c
    ti¥'
    eCES
    g r oupぉh叫 cdl arg
    erp r
    e -10po仲 l日 山llcntd町出品山 i npainin
    terlCrcm:e
    thant h 、c hamg roupd id(JI<0.0
    1.d=0. 59)
    .Thじ;ぽtivcCESgwuph ada
    ~ igniti t: ant m cal
    1p川 11J¥t
    叫 訓 yJccr
    ea:-eo f0.
    601川 i
    ntsunthc
    :(ト1 0おじ a
    le
    (1'<0 . 0 01.d= =0.7
    3 )
    R
    inl川，
    ¥ct泊 1" 1
    3 VCI
    C 日 n!
    '
    . RCT.DB 0
    -11
    1NRS:SubjCCbr
    ecc
    ivin
    gcti
    w CESh
    od，on 川 ('ra~ょc. a1
    l 泊 .
    14戸
    、Jl1
    !

    Pi
    ¥rkin且0"冶 dじ じ 問 削C川 p
    a¥Oκom1旧 日 dwi
    lhaO
    .23
    -pいi
    ntdc..:rCil ~e f
    ort
    hos
    c向 山 lvmg
    Di ~eal気C 気hamCES(p= =0.(28)
    Ta
    l
    lcla.
    l'
    " 38 Mili
    lar
    y.Spin
    al RCT.DB u.
    .JONRS:A ctIvcCESgmuph山 1s igni恥 川t l
    ylc同 pmnt rll
    Cnslly，pn
    .'( Upo叫
    CurdJnj
    uη OL CES刈 判 l on.comp a 陀 d10sh all
    lg ro up(JI=0.03.d=0. 76)
    .At :1仇'cCES
    吾川町、 r cpol
    1cds i
    g n
    if i
    cantl
    ydcc印 刷c dpninintc
    rfcr'
    llt:じむ1=0α旧、
    d=Oミ0 ).prev er
    .;u謁 postinl cr
    vcntinn.w hi
    le1 h
    erew出 anon誌i gnitic
    alll
    dcc日 出ei np a
    ini ntcrfcrcn
    cl"i
    . nth巴 対 hamCESg roup、旬r cvc r見Uお pO~I­
    l
    I1t
    c円 enlIon
    .OpenL abclg!'(lUphad討 i gn
    llh
    :antl
    yl e品 pam1 n【 叩 叫y片山n
    ha叫 l
    inc1 υcndpointo fs tuuy(p=0 .(3)
    Cork い 74 ドi
    hrn
    rnva
    l1
    !ia RCT.DB. 0
    寸 NRS:A cti 刊 C ESg rυuphad気i gnit
    ica
    nllylc持活 p
    .1I1Hll
    I c
    l川 tycomp 川
    -cd
    Pat
    ien
    ls OL 0~ha m gr
    1 oupa le n
    upninl0'1stl
    1dy(p<0 .(
    1).NRS，0-1 0:Activ eCES
    grouph出 l owerlc l叫crp Oln
    l叫 O刊誌 compJfcd1 0品 川 1group(p=0 .0
    1)
    McGil:No詩i
    l g
    nitic
    antu iff
    crenceinpaInぉCO'
    lCSh e
    tw(!cl
    1A C
    li v
    eCES剖1<1
    Shamgrnup~. ( ト5NRS:Op '
    .
    lnLa hc
    lg rouphad訓忌 n i
    liピ
    D.l1
    11
    yd t，(!出 l
    SCjl
    .l
    l
    rl
    f'
    ll
    ll
    l
    lh:lsc
    lin c10emlp llin
    tIlf)，Ud
    l y(p<0 .
    1川 11.M正G ill
    :O pcllL油 dg rouJ
    l
    h川 叫g.llIf
    ll
    'i1川 1'
    )dlXre山 cdPilinrr
    mnb a
    珂 li
    neltI帥dい> 1
    1
    11u f剖 m ly
    (
    1'< り0 (1)
    Li c hfhrou n :~ “ Fihmmya l
    gia マ DIl.ト lUNRS:-
    R( nl
    cU C【iv
    cCESgr uuph ad...i
    gn
    ili
    c川 Ilyl o¥V:rp
    t
    : ain" co刊 お
    Pat
    icn
    tぉ OLρ ~ O.(X】2.d = ベ16訂 l uwc r I cndcrpoi川 町 山' ¥'
    S(p= =0 .01.tl=0. 36】 hi ghcr
    qualilyor符kcp真cur e
    s(p=0 .01.1=り 4町 h igh crr cel川g
    ...orwcll - bcing
    則。町語 I p=n同) 5，d=0 .7 31
    .h i
    g hcr吋uali
    ly川 i lfc封 印 rい ρ{: .{). 0
    3
    d=0 .97)，lowcrf3ligu
    c討c orcst p=0 .0
    3.d=. .
    ..
    0.72)andl tl
    wernng clぽ 何 引
    ('=0
    1 .04.d=- {
    ).60)Ihant hes hama nuco n
    lrυ!日 山 円 The0 戸 nl ah c
    1
    gr oupha Jsign
    ificantga川、 o nt nt
    c 1c
    rpo in
    ls corcs( 1'<0 .0(1)‘l1lUdc cn
    .::as
    cu
    pa i
    n(jl<O .n(5)fromb as dine1 0eni
    Lpoill
    lofsHlu y.Tht:l<cl
    ivl
    'CESg r o
    up
    anu叶 淀 川 clini
    calCESg ro ph叫 a1
    u 7('
    /
    t:n::d
    lh
    .:1
    ill1i
    l n世 lf-ra
    lct
    lp ai
    n当仁川出
    mula2 8Li
    ふd e口四時 i nl ent
    1erpo intsco
    n :ぉ
    Alpha-S
    limU同 rSur
    vcy
    . 67
    X RSD.Fihrom yal
    gia SU' !y
    lVl
    . 5
    - poin tL ikcnScalc:RビJlc xS ympath clicDy‘ Iwphy(RSDJ ，n=5 5
    19
    95.
    ..
    .1J9
    1 .
    l
    !1
    完 川 dMi
    !!
    .l'.lIn
    c Rωpnndemsreponedi mprvじmcnlofpain出「叫 I
    o mv， .
    ;日 7Yk町 poncd
    .
    pa
    tie
    nts painr cilc'Jor2 :S{)
    Ck.29.09切 r e
    p ortcdp ainr c1icfhclwccn2弓 <rund49<:LA
    .
    !
    lot
    alu fRI .R2%( )
    fr cぉponuentぉi'ep刷 .te
    dp aillr clicfa ~ ;
    ::
    :2
    5切 刊わr omyalg i
    ‘l
    (alon c).1=1 41.Rc ぉp o
    mlc
    nl:
    ->r cpo rlcdi mpr o v山 ncn
    t llfp ail
    l:.f
    1
    :
    - ol [nw : -.
    5~.52% ' le port cdιl
    pi 11rei
    lcfnf;:::50~. 37.nl 'hr epor
    t edp :l
    inr dicfh et wecn
    25;
    ti .i1n J4¥1偽^1 0la1(
    11明)匁 5
    ' I
    J.01 陀s
    ' pO ndc llbrcponcdpa i
    nr d i cfa s
    ミ25' 1十F i br omy alg川 ( w
    ilhulhe r山 ndl ijoll
    ).11=' .63
    .RC' -
    :I
    附 ""聞い陀(1 I
    )r
    l吋
    lmprov~m叩 t 0 'pa in出 f olo¥
    ¥' 5 、4.S2'k叫抽l1e dpai nr c
    licf01 J
    、
    1 '2: 弓却
    O ~'Í'

    6.0 りり%刊 r己p ο刊 cdP 川


    ‘
    川"
    川nrelicrhc
    引IWι0
    刊℃
    巳叩n25切a 創t仙
    悦d斗9句係
    川
    " 浄 ' ¥1
    川01:
    110'
    140引 "必~ o f
    '
    r
    陀es
    持
    叩p同"m"
    叩
    】 配￠叩n
    lω対 『陀
    C
    叩l
    ''
    阿
    、0“
    '
    1
    印川
    ' e
    吋dp
    ι
    r
    叶仲
    陀 p
    加υ
    3州刊巾 cdi1
    川 m
    叩
    】p印 V
    叩 町cl
    口
    川
    引山ne
    叩n川1れ
    ぱf仰川1
    口
    川na s
    活'o
    Il l
    tl帆 56. 7x
    ，
    .tfrcp or
    tl'dp ainr c liefo f
    ~5 0 'K .4 1.5Yiゐ repo円以.1 painr dic"th t、
    c 旬
    、
    、 n2Yieand49; -
    "十八t 川社 I {
    )f
    )l
    l :U1 ， o
    '
    /
    ( fr es刊河川 c nい rc
    pl川e Jp a inrclîcf 出 ~25%
    TheE
    vol
    uti
    ono
    fCr
    ani
    alE
    lect
    rot
    her
    apySt
    imu
    lat
    ion 205

    TABlE19.9 (
    εon
    tin
    ued
    )
    CranialE
    lec
    tro
    therapyStimu
    lat
    ion(
    CES
    )Randomized仁o
    ntr
    oll
    edS
    t ，
    udy(RCT)
    SurveysandOpen-labelS
    tud
    ieso
    fPain
    pr
    inc
    ipa
    lI n v e
    slI
    gat
    or n S
    ubj
    ect
    s De
    sig
    n M四 s
    ure
    men
    tSc
    ale
    s/O
    utc
    ome
    s
    Ki
    rsc
    hcta l. ~ 1 1
    43 P
    ainPalkn
    ls S
    urw
    )' 7
    - p nInlL ikcl1町 . .I
    c:P ain( 0=.1 ¥:
    : J3 0'
    1 ，uf t
    hc1 01<11 gruupr cp oI1 '
    l
    ，
    .dd cじ 陀ι、 ¥
    !d
    Scrv
    iccMI.!川札!
    r
    s p alll川 叫 c lin kali mp ro¥! emcn tof~日 OfÆ wh l
    ie円 I <krep ot
    r edd i nli'
    al
    andVl己r
    ¥
    ! an
    沿 i m pl'¥J¥!cm elt
    ! hct柄、¥ !n25( 'ka nd4 9
    (''，
    .
    4 ¥l
    ; ot
    alo f 45，J Ko
    t ft otal gro up
    I
    X 11
    l h': lpa
    ntsu 山n .
    gCESn .:p on¥ !
    d2 :2 5
    'kc l inic3.1 i l
    l1pro、ωl1cn.tJ nl h
    ¥!CES
    i Jl1l
    yg roup( nom cdi cati ons)的1 .6
    ('A
    .u fr cp
    持 on de n tsr epo rl
    edd 叫 陀 出c Jp a i
    n
    a n J< :1川 出l li m刊n vcml !n
    .t2 : 25係 (46. 2"'
    /(~50~;'t> . 1 5A~{ h
    ' ctれ川cen2 5 t
    ;ユn
    ，
    十 d
    4 9 匂 i lllpr
    o¥'C 1
    1lenf)w hil
    c4 1.
    7 (
    4u ft hcC~雪 and Illed i catíon ~ g roupr e p
    or t
    ed
    J e 口 同 誌c p削 1 a ndd i nka li mpro v
    ¥!llIcnt三2 SCi
    ル( 26.74 '
    #.:
    ;5 0り I
    長 Ykh cl刊、c c
    n
    2 5%i1n J4 9;rfi mp l"u¥!erne
    nt .Hl !ad ache( n=7 0) :4 0%o f lhel 01 al group
    刊似)rtc dd c
    n.
    . :
    :出 c up ain川 ddi n ka lI1
    l1p rovcr nc nl or;:
    :50 1
    h:w hi1 cl H.6~
    r
    e 側、r l cJc1ini<:
    alimpm 刊 m cnl h et WCCI12 5'
    (fa
    ， n d4 -9c.0
    k 1I
    ' hc1 0 la
    lg roup
    58 .6 '(
    4-o fparti口 p antsr Cp ¥
    lJ'lc
    J2 :2 ベ%じIin ic礼1 im 、
    p r o1じm cu1.InI hcCESo nly
    gm u p( 10Illl!d
    1 il!u
    . tinns)，](附 ' ko f陀 s p川 l dentr
    見 cp o円c dd ccrclI!位以1 p
    : In‘
    1 lnd
    にl in
    i山l 川¥1'山町 n tc nt~25% ( 64，7 %2 :50' k.35司 7rh etwec n2 5 弘a nd4 }C
    l イ
    lll l
    pr、Ci
    1 Clll
    cnt)w hilじ 45.Jf'A0 1I
    ' h cCESa n dm c di catinn詩 gmupr ¥
    ![ Il
    > r
    tcd
    "Cピ' e 出ピ p ain3.n ddi nicali mp ro vemc nt主 ユ5 係 ( 32 .1 K:
    ' ;5 0%p a i
    nr clief3.nd
    1.¥'.2 'k陀p ort c
    dTcl w山 n1 月 '*a n dt.9 俗 l lnpro 問問。l¥
    H
    lll
    ub
    !¥
    じ 7 2
    号 弓 P
    ainP
    ‘山 じn
    lS OL 1-1 0NRS弓2 弓(;0肉付￠じ UtlV じP 山 n pa l
    lc川 s inap a inma na gcm cnld i niじw c r
    c
    a d m in iぉI crl
    'd2 0m in0 1C
    ' ESt 問 a t me川 O rt ho~ピ 261 wcr eg iv enas ccorul
    tr cat m c n
    talt hci
    rn c刻 、 isti，1 6
    0¥ vcrcg i同 nt hrl 'Ctrl'ut
    m cnt人莞 7I VC陀 g w cn
    f ou rt reatmen ts.a n d2 6w c rc別、l entiv et rcatm e nt s.T he7 9，81~託、、 ho
    rcs po n dcd¥1 1thct ir
    sttr ca l mcntI!x pcricl1(，:edι 14 2.4 0%r c d
    u ctiul 1in
    持じl f -r aleJp ain.w i thラ 1 4%of th ep a tk n bd ecl a ri ngIh己yw cr cp ailf re
    e
    C u m ul a tivcr cs
    ult 弘、刊刊 日' (1:Im
    . ongIhúsc 持 uh~、cqucmly m' al cJ. T hcn!w a
    :.
    a7 0，il叫後 r edu ctIu
    lli np 川n a
    ftcr 、
    it.'
    cI 同 al I1lCJlI.~. includ
    i ng1 弓3 " 告。 f thc
    n ! mUlI1l sgp 陀aln lsr epol111gm lr ωn
    H
    ctk
    rn、聞 齢す 3
    0 C
    hronicPa
    il
    l RCT
    ，DB 5
    -p '
    川 HL ik cr
    tP a i
    nS calc: Th..
    ::a c[ivcA II、 ha -
    Sl i mCESg r ou
    話ph r
    ainwa vc
    Patk
    :n
    t可 p al ¥cr nじh an gedf ["
    (lm;
    ' mu n ¥
    ! ve
    n .j aw- to othp al l crnc Ol
    ls
    i剣山t lw i[ hp ain[ 0a
    、州u (
    )lh: -.
    pe
    c l
    r 川p a H l
    !1
    "lc
    I o n州諸[I!nlw ithap ain!- h:cp al
    tr:r
    . n，T h ca じh、'cCES
    g rol1p h.d
    3 吋g l11片い川 t l
    yI 日p
    c :
    l
    ln，凶1I1C u
    出 reL
    Ih yt hc、1Cp
    i oi1¥1 .i
    l kcrtp ぬ"
    '
    ~\，"Hlc t hanth cL issCES n砧 u(，;onlrol JじV¥じじ g ro u p s(p<0 .
    011

    [C
    ミ T:
    ran
    L
    Iomi
    zc
    dco
    n[
    ro
    lt
    ri
    al;
    DB:d
    ouh
    kh1m
    i . OL
    守
    i :l)
    凹 nl
    ahc
    l:N
    RS:n
    Ull1c
    ri
    ea
    lra
    tI
    ngぉc
    al
    c:n'=3
    66'
    }
    ¥
    I rRCT
    s:1'= 1
    341OLa
    nd叩 r
    叩 yお[
    ud
    i山 l
    ol
    al
    n= 1
    712f
    ora
    l
    lCESp
    :li
    l対 u
    dic 話

    whilea lsoallowing甲 山 I O
    U S‘CESd eviccs
    "t h
    utn ev
    crrcgi
    s- Overt hepωt d~(;ade . thaeh asbeenI n cre削 cdI ntl2r e s l
    tere
    dwi lhFDAt o1四 日oldo penlythroughmagazinea dsund ul
    Idl l umcrou
    s以 lv‘tn
    ce si nt heu seo fthisa pp ro:
    .c
    J h，n o
    tonly
    webs
    i tes.Co nvcr
    sely，FDAa ppli
    esa dvers
    ee v
    cnls.however with陀 s pe
    ctt orTMSb uta ls ov agalnc rv
    est irnlll ation ， xo - ~B
    mill
    o r，cquallytoallCESd ev
    icesthatじomplyw iththcFDA Pl
    Ilsed日 g nalt hcrapy( PS T).w i dclyusedf ort hct rc叫 mcnt
    def
    init Io
    n‘ and lim
    its whut de vi
    cem anufactur
    e r
    s andd i
    s ofo st
    c oart
    hrit
    isi nEurope.hasa lsobeenf o un dt ob ee f fe c-
    lr
    iburOI"smay泊 ya bollteffec
    lsfromt h
    cirIeg
    allymarkcted li
    ve，a nd.a lth
    ougha v
    ai l
    a blei n20o therc ountr ies.l iiso n l y
    devices，evenwhens Ic
    l hs tatcme
    nts山 ea ccur
    uteandt rut
    h- approvcdi ntheUSAf o
    rv eterinaryu 日 制

    fu
    lr at herthanmis leadin
    g.Theseando therproblemswith At t h
    e V ctcrans A dm inist ration Medical C en teri n
    the Centcr "orDevi
    1 じC ぉa ndR adiologi
    calHeaHh (CDRH) Clevel and，OH，USA，r h c 1I問 o fAlpha-Slim t c chno l o g y
    approvalp rocessIsdiscussedi nChaptcr49. toIrea ttinnI
    tuswase val uatedi natwoa ft1l expcr i
    m e n t a l
    叫u dy.!5Th
    l et i
    rstarmc o nsiste dofs cv en mulesandt hr e e
    femalc~、 from 23t o69 y e ar
    so ld(meano f43 y c ars)hav
    lAlAPPL
    OTHER POTENT lCAT
    lONS [ngt tnn[t
    l日 inat otalof1 8c ars.O to
    l ogica1anda udiol og i -
    ('
    a1e val u
    atio
    nsr evcaleda lls ubjeclse xceptonehadv ar yi ng
    TI
    NNITUS
    d!
    .grceso fscnsoryh eari ngl oss， Betweenoncand 1 7t r ea t -
    Aぉ indica
    tedinth!
    .
    !f ir
    ste di
    tiono fB iοel
    eClrom a
    gnelIc mcntsof50μAAlpha-Stimぉt im u
    l a
    tioJ1 W出 g ive na t1 3s it e s
    Mιl i
    cin
    e.v a
    rio
    us formぉ 01
    'crania
    le le
    ctri
    cal ぉtimula
    tio
    r】 uroundI hecaff or24st o2m in.Thet inni
    t uswasmatchcd
    havebeenuscdtot
    rca
    tt i
    nnit
    us1'
    0"o
    1 ¥'c
    r200y ea
    rs.7<
    J aflcrc acht reat
    ment、、lit
    hs imul 込tcdsoundsfromaNorwe討t
    206 Bioelectromagnet
    icandSub
    tleEnergyMedi口 ne

    SG- IT innil usS yn lhesi尻 町 l lsingana sc cndi ngp roc e du re.Six As igni白c antnumbero fs u
    bje ctsreponedimprovemen ti n
    01l h et en叩 b j e
    ct sr epor teda tl eas ta60% improv emcnti n he a
    ringa ctivi
    tyh utI h
    i前 couldn otbev er
    ifiedb yob jective
    山g hl0" 1t he1 8e ars‘心 011!"
    irmedbyt innitusmat ching.Thrce cvalualioJ1.Thea u th
    orsc oncludc dt h叫 t he82%s ucce日 r ate
    addi tionals ub jectsw e n!u nd ecid edw het h c r improvement inimprovementi ntinni
    tusi mpli es込 f easi
    blet re
    atmentp ro
    hado c curre d.Thcpcrm川 e nじeo fi mp rovcl l
    lcn tl as lcuf roITI cc d
    u rci nl h
    iぉo ftendevaslutin
    gd isorde rthatc anp re
    d ispos e
    Xht o2 .mon l hs(Iastconl Hc Lwil ht hee xper im enl cr) tos ci
    UJ dality
    I nl hese cond山 111.20s u~j ec ts W口I'Cd ivide dI lltotwog roups ， Ina n others malp ilots tu
    dyo fi
    fv epat ientst r
    ealed、 .
    vith
    lna
    i
    . ctiveandac ontrolg roup.i nas ingleb J indp ro to coJ
    .Al I Alpha- StilTIinau niversi
    ty-basc dn e urotherapyc lin
    iじ tlllnI-
    川 bj ectsw e r cmah :
    :，wi lhc ithernormalh ClIr
    . ingo rs ensor y lusha nd ica pandt innit
    uss~\'eri 旬、 as well‘ IS EEGp rcand
    hcar in 呂Jos s‘1l10stha vingi di opathico rn o
    is eexpo ぉu rctmllI- postm cas ures，were Llscd forb aseline and t re
    atmento ut-
    tus.Eachs ubje c
    tr eceive dab aselinea u d
    iol og ica le v al ua
    t ion comcs .Ther ese
    archersr e
    po r
    tedt hat40%oft hep art
    i ci
    p ants
    utili z
    i n
    gs la ndardequipmc nlr efcr cncc dtoANSIs tan dard s (lhoscw ilhu nil
    aleralt i
    nnItusRuc t u
    at ingini nt
    ensi
    t y)e vi-
    01山 rc ond ucti oll，s p eechr ec eption thre~、 hold ， 11l0 stCOIn- dencedapp陀 ci a
    bleimpr ovemen ts川 t hcirtinnitussymptom誌
    fortabl eI Olld nessl evel.s pee chd is cri min
    a lion(W -
    22word andt hatr eぉpOnSlVCI
    1C同 tot r
    ea t me
    n ti nthiss ubgr oupmay
    i
    l叫 札 a ndwheni ndicn ted，bonecondu ion，i
    ct n】peda nc cb at oc curase ar
    lya ぉt h
    et i
    rsttr
    catmcn ts eお1
    お 0
    11終偽
    tery
    .andt on ede c a
    y .Thet re atmen tw出 i de nti calt ot heitrst A coじh learim planllh川 c anbe山 : l iv
    atedwi t
    hl owr
    れ ate
    annc xccpl lh ccu rren lwasa t50o r100μA.andt hes t imuluメ clcctri
    cs timul川 io
    n"was a tt!.! m
    pted and appeared t o bc
    Jura ti o
    nwase ilher1 2o r24sa tt he1 3s I
    les.A rt cre ‘.
    H.
    ::
    ht 陀 はt- ve ryc1 Tcctivcf orJe辻fp atientsw ithl in
    n i
    tu討 buti sp res-
    ment .t hct innituお W出 a gaina naly zc dlIsingt h esamep r
    o to- cntlycon traindi
    catedi nothclぉ bccauseofaぉs ocialedn e r
    v e
    co.lThecon trolgrouphnd[ h eide nticalp ro ce durer epeate d daamm
    aag
    ge灯
    lwic c ，thcn rs tti mcwi thoutト; timul atiol，r ollowcdbya ctllal
    叫川1ll!a tiOI1. Of1 7e a rst reatedi nt heexper ime n
    t alg roup .
    仁
    A、KE
    r R
    onlyones ubj ecl( bO lh出げの wcrep erceiv c da snOl h avin g
    unpr 、
    cvcdbys limul川 iOI1. Thus .n inco rt cn日 I hje cls( 90%) Thc ra hion icn onin vas ivc1 0¥V c nergye miss iont he rapy
    corr eぉp ond in g1 01 5o f1 7即 日 ( 8R' i
    b)r epor t edimprovement (LEET). a no therf orrno fc ra n
    i ale lectrother apys ti mula
    int h cirt i
    n nitus .Thcdcc rca~也 in t innitusf r eq uenc y[ ort he t
    10n、h asbc enf ou nd1 0bct hemoste ffectivet rcalmentf or
    subj cctivcimprovcmentr angedfrom48%i nones uh jectt o hep atoccl lularc arc Inorn aはn dhasおhownpromi別 ngr es uぉ
    t
    1
    cOl1lpleteremi s
    sion( none)i nI hc別 xe a r
    scombi nedf orf oul 川 c crti.l
    JnI T
    I elastatK m川 i i ‘
    gnunc it
    :s.There a re noa d v crse
    subje clS.One s uhjcctd idn ot1 児 rc目v ea 1 9% dt .!c rcasca s sidcc ffecl s.andt hcd ailyt hree Ihs c持おionsc an bes el
    t
    hcin .
    gs igni rican .
    t111t hecon trolgroupo r15c ars.i no nlyone ad mi nist ereJa thOl Icwh
    T ilct hcp atic
    nli src a
    d in go rwal ch-
    eard idas ub jec tbelit!vet hcrchadbeena nychange ， andmea ingt cl!
    .
    !vis ion附 句1
    叫 r c mcnl長 i nd ic"le d"1 3係 d ecr eas einf r
    e q ue nじy.Thcr a nge Nnvocur et UITI
    ort ant ingf iel
    ds(TTF)hasbCc !na
    . pp r oved
    01c
    ' hungef ort he1 5e arswasfrom+1 6‘(lf tcrs hams l Im
    u la- byt heFDAf ortreatingg li ob
    l aslOmam ultifo rmcandc ¥i n i
    cal
    tion，f requ enc ywasmcusured川 h ig h
    e r)1 0-2 20AI
    .Oncer he tri
    a l白山じ i np rogres s1 0c x tcn dthiぉ tol ungじan じerandmeta
    cOlllrol gro uphada じl ualsti l
    l1
    l1lation.S O f
    C:，n
    . :pO rl以 jI mpro ve- staticb rai nles ions
    . '
    1
    2TTFt he rapyi sdeliveredu則 ngnonl1lv a
    me nli na ll e‘目tonec 山 Th emcnsurcdde cr cas ei nt innitus 引v c，i ns ulatcdt rans duce ra rraysp l
    accdd ircctlyonrh~ s kin
    l印刷 c ncyr an gedfrom28% 1 0compl eler en 川 s i
    on( none )i n arc as urr oundi ngt hctumori namannc rr h
    ata llow ぉp alJentぉ
    fOUI日I bjeはお tomai ntai nt heirnormuldai lya crivit
    ieswh ilct reatingth~ir
    Bccau話cb o thg ro up sint hcs ec onJarmha da ct uals tim u- di同 制c .WhilcI lh a sht ;cl
    l日 f c
    rr ed10山 “ 24 /7 CES， "TTF
    lation.I hed ataw出 p oole d.O vcr a
    l limprovementw川 82%川 the ra pydoc sn otd e livera n yel ec t
    ricc urr
    e nt1 0l hetiS Sll
    C.
    repo rtedby20s ubjecls( 2
    7o f3 3e ars). Inte nc asc只. t herewas sti mulatt!n
    . erv es.o rhea ttISS1IC
    .R ather，i
    tc reate sa na ltcr n
    at-
    じomp lc
    ter e ingc lec
    :t
    . ricl ieldthmi nterr cn:ぉ wi thmitosiぉ andc cld iv ision
    wi lhint het l1mo .Theon
    r lys idee ff
    cctsa r
    eocca sionalぉk in
    irritatiol
    ¥a tthet rans du ce rar rays ites
    WhC1I 】crFDAc 1e arc dCESd cviceち mayhav ca n
    tit uJnOl
    effe ctsisn otyetknown.ai thoughan~cdota l r eport品，山 cha s
    onep ubli shedi nth~ formo fabookbyMargar ctWa ddin gton.
    MD.は r etiredn euro logi s
    lw ithI ymphati じl eukemia‘s ug gcst
    lhiお p ossibility.Hero ncol ogislg aveh eramaximum2 - ycm
    pr ogno stぉi fs here fu日 dc hel l
    lo lher込py.Ast hisbookg o e sto
    prin li l
    l川、 b eenove r20yea r ssinc cDr.Wadding tolr cf usud
    ch emol he rap yandr eliedonel ect ri
    call her
    apyf o rhe ra pop-
    tos ist reat mcnl.Y cts hei s叫 illa bll210liveal oneandcon ti nuc
    hav ingap roductiv elif~ w h iler unn inga! Oラa c r
    cmaplet ree
    f ar mi 1Vennont同
    P，官l im in礼r ystl1uie討 a1 sos upp ortt heu s
    eo fCESi nca n
    :c
    r
    . rp atien ts1 0r e
    d uc eI h cs c quel aeo fradiationt herap yf or
    TheE
    vol
    uti
    ono
    fCrani
    a
    lEl
    ect
    rot
    her
    apyS
    tim
    ula
    tio
    n 207

    canc er
    .l no nes tu
    dy.t hea u t
    hOiぉ c onclude dIhatI h
    ec lini ca l inc a
    c hi ndi
    vi d
    ua.
    lA ftert h
    ei n
    iti
    alt ri
    al，pati en
    t scanb epre-
    tmpa同 i o
    na tM.D.A nd erso llCancerC enteri sthatAlpha scribedaCESd evicet ousea thomeg i
    vingthemi llcre
    ased
    Sti mt herapyiss i
    milart oh y p
    e rba ricoxygena ndb ot ho f controlo vcrt hcmanagemento ft hetrs ymp to ms.I na ddi-
    Ihcsemoda J
    ities制 定 achi evingad e greeo ftissuerep aira n d t io
    nt o:1r egul山 20-60mint rea t
    me ntdaily0 1e veryol h町

    rcv山 山l ia
    rizati
    o nofthei rr込di atedn el
    d.Al t
    houghi li ss lIlI day，p at
    i e
    ntsc a
    11addt reatm entsa sn eede
    d .Somt !c1i nic
    ians
    undcarw hat日 s pec
    ilicallyo ccur ringp hysiologic
    allya ndh i s- tin
    di tusefult Oscl upaCES l oungewhcrcp atientscan
    tological
    ly，thci rr
    adiat
    e dぉo fttissu eち appeartobecomcr ev. 山 comei nf o
    ru n
    attended1 0、
    ;vc ostt reatment 呉 whcnc vert hey
    culari四 d.Iti sa p
    parel1tt hattl日比 m odalitieぉh aver el ie v ed f ee
    ls t
    ressed.Thisc onceptwass tu d
    ieda 【l heM ich aelE
    diぉco m
    fort.cnhancedh calingo fi rr adiut
    edh arda nds oftt is- DcBakeyV ctcransAffairsM edicalC cnteri nH ousto n，TX，
    sue丸 a ndi mprovcdt h
    eq u alityo ft h eirraJiate
    ds o
    ftli おお ue s.<)~ USA.A fterb einglminedt o"s etived i
    ffele nll yp
    eso fs tre
    ss
    A 6 1
    -year-old mak v etcmn r eceiving 6000 r adso f relievin
    gd evicesataw alk -inp ainc li
    n ， v
    iじ c ter an
    sp ref e
    rred
    radia t
    iont herapyb yam e gav oltc obalt1in cara cc
    e lc rat o r Alph a-StimCES73%o ft het ime.Theb e ne
    f i
    lso b sclvcd
    forT2NIMOs quumousc ellc arcin omHo fther ightt Oll日一 included improv 凶 叫t enda nce: 1ndv eteran s'i 1v
    l ol vement
    lara reaatt heCl e
    velan dVAM cd icalCent crwasgi vcna i ng ro up-basedt he
    rapies，r educ【iOl1sinr e portedp a Inand
    maximumo f30minofAlpha-Stiml herapyo f50-500μA a nxicty‘i mproveds J
    ecp.unda ni ncr
    easeds enseo femo-
    al0 .5H玄 immedi .
    itt
    dyf ol lowin ge a chradiationt r
    e at me n t tio
    n a
    lw e ll-
    be i
    ngi nthep ar
    t icipa
    n t
    s.D ecre a sesont he0-1 0
    Thef ollowinga dvers
    er eactio n
    st or adi川iOI1weree x pe ct e d Num ericalR a t
    ingS caleo fp ailli n
    t e
    nsityd uringt hes tudy
    irrcvcrsib
    lex crostomiil b
    . eca usea llt hcs alivar
    yg lan J s pcriodweres tati
    stica
    lly日 g0 1l
    Icanta tpく 0 .001.はn dr e
    p r
    e-
    we re induded i nt h
    er acliat
    ion l ie
    1d.l emporar yd yぉg e u - sentedal ar
    gee ff
    cctsi尻e0 10
    ' .93刊
    sia
    .t hro
    atp a in，possi b
    lemuじO SltlS andr
    司 adiat
    i o
    ndcrma
    tI
    tIs
    .F ollowingl heCESt r
    e alrnent s
    .a l
    la dvcrscre‘ IctlOns
    were r e
    du cedd r山c
    a ally and x cr oslomia and dy sg cu s i a DURINGPSYCHOTHERAPYSESSIONS
    werec liminated.Thcp a tientr e qu irednor egimeno fp a i n CESmaya lsobeuぉe ddllringp sy c
    h otherapy括 州 o ns.Using
    me dicationb cc a
    llscCES r edu ce dt hcI cvclo fp ai ne a c h CESd uringat al
    kt hcrapys essiond ecrci
    ls
    . eぉ un xi
    e tyand
    dayf ollowingr adia
    tion:h eshowednos ign
    so fIllu co s
    i t i s usuallyi mpr
    o vest hep a
    tient"sd esireanda b
    ilityt os hare
    orr a d
    iationdc rmat
    itisa tanyt i mewhichi sh ighlyl In usu al p ro blems，c o
    n cernsandworr ieswi ththet herapist
    .a sw ell
    a気 持 omcd egre e()
    fx er osto miaandr nuco日tisisa nt
    i ci pat ed a ぉl or c s
    pondl ot het h
    crapist'sq ucstionsmo rce ff
    e c
    tively
    .
    ina lls uchi rradia
    tedp ati cnts.Thea ut
    ho raddedt hat日 v - Ane cdotalr epo
    rts from p syじhiatr
    i s
    ts. p討y cho logist
    メ a nd
    eraIp alicn
    tsh avcb ccn日 e na lI heC leve landVAMedical o lherm e n
    talh ealthprofessionalsont heus co fCESd uring
    Ccl1tcrf o
    rAl pha-Stimt reatm entf o
    rpos t r
    adiationd r y nc州 ，
    、v
    it he qu
    allygoodr esults.
    ' )
    :
    ;
    t
    h
    h
    y
    c
    p
    r
    n
    a
    o
    p
    t
    ye
    i
    U芯 じons
    crelaxeds
    i
    s
    t
    t
    a
    cn
    t
    t
    l
    eo
    ye n thusias
    ti
    fmindandbodyt
    c. CES i
    ha ti
    nducesap
    scomplemen-
    r
    c

    toryw it htalk.biofeedback.c yemovemer 】t dcscnsi t


    izati
    on
    AlZHEIMER ' SDISEASE， PARKINSON'S and rcplocessing (EMD R). hypnoth erapy， a nd l
    Ilany o
    thel
    DISEASE， AUTISM， PTSD intervention
    s.

    TI
    cr
    陀'
    ea胞
    tce1出
    et
    じt
    二 山
    f C
    1凶 al じha
    肌n 邑
    侠es旧n
    I
    I】t h
    eb r
    ain.As叫 su eh】，はtc
    1 anb cc on CON仁URRENTPHARMACOTHERAPY
    引i
    s d
    cr
    凹 c 、
    d辻山t】川ndil'陀e仁t自O
    印1mu fCES.B I
    山ar
    i
    日nsw a
    y 'sp a
    叫tel
    lle
    陪 dDEEP
    CESc anbeu sedwithpharmacologicthe
    rapywith
    outcon-
    TMSt 阻echno ωlo g ydl
    出
    【if
    白l
    er円Sf
    !
    ‘
    'l
    J
    "附omo
    H
    (】 therl rans cran ialm agne t ic
    じer
    na bou
    tp otc
    ntia
    l polyphannacy in
    ter
    aじt
    ion
    s.Howcvcr，
    sti
    mlllationa pp roac hcsb yl lsi
    ngs cvcral DeepT防I Sc oils
    i
    tisimporta
    nttoi nf
    onl
    lt h
    ep ι
    lti
    enttha
    tCESmayd ecre
    ase
    (tcrmedH c oil
    s )r a
    t h
    ert h anas inglef oc
    als t imulati on.T his
    l
    hcn eedfo1
    'medica
    lion
    .Ast hcpatic
    nt川 lp
    roVC
    S，b o
    thlhe
    i
    sd esig nedt os timuluted ee pe
    rb r
    ainI esionsw ithou ti ncr eas-
    cl
    inic
    ianandp a
    tiet山 o
    n uIdbeal e
    rtforsymptomぉtha
    tmay
    Ingthee lectricu lH cldi ntcnsityofぉupe r
    licialc orticalr egi ons
    山 1i
    cat
    can eedforadosageadjustmcn
    t
    ore xcc日 iv elys ti mulatingf a
    cialncr vcs.T yp ic a
    lt rcatl1lent
    prolocolじo ns i
    s t s0 11
    ' 5-20s essio
    ns，e<lchl astin g1 5-20min，
    overac o urseo f3 -4w ee ks.DEEPTMSwasa p prov edb yI he
    SElF-DIRECTEDHOMETREATMENT
    FDAi n2 013f ort hctr eatm entofm aj o
    rd epr essived iso rder
    ori np atientswhod i
    ct1 10
    lr espon
    dt oa nti dep ressan td r ugs Mostindivi
    dualsarccnp a
    bleofdoingscl
    f -
    dirc
    ctc
    dCESt her-
    Int eEuropcanEconomicArca，i
    h talぉoh a只 CEmarkingf or "pyathome.TheUSA山 t heonlycounlryinthew o
    rldt ha
    t
    Al
    P
    l
    a
    zh
    rki
    e
    n
    i
    s
    hcUSAa
    me
    o
    r'
    n'
    r
    sd i s eae，a
    s
    sdisc~目 e ， a
    ep l a nned
    n
    u t
    ism .b
    dPTSD:a
    i
    pol
    p
    p
    a
    r
    rd
    ov
    is
    or
    ，
    c
    altr
    ler.c
    r烏omco
    hro n
    f
    i
    t
    cp
    h
    c
    ai
    日 1
    n
    1
    1
    r

    b
    qUJl出 CESd
    e
    alicens
    cdoned
    e
    dh
    ai
    l
    ca
    yd
    e
    l
    t
    v
    h
    u
    i
    c
    r
    i
    c
    a
    n
    e
    r
    sl
    cp
    gt
    ob
    ra
    c
    het
    es
    t
    i
    i
    t
    r
    s
    i
    o
    l
    o
    do
    n
    e
    tIt
    r
    nl
    .T
    o3o
    yb
    r
    ea
    y
    t
    ，0
    me
    1o
    nt
    nlheo
    smayn
    r4weeks，t h
    e
    r

    nt
    d
    e
    e
    ro
    eut
    wot
    f
    o
    o
    ，

    thr
    eet i
    m出 p e
    rwee kd uringamai nte
    nancep h
    asc.Thei ndi
    vid
    ualcana ls
    ou scCESaぉ o r
    tcnasn cc
    u cu，a詩thc
    rea r
    cno
    Cl
    INICAl仁ONSIDERATIONSANDGUIDE
    lINES
    si
    dee f
    fect
    sfrome xt
    en deduse.This目 白 peci
    alyb en
    etic
    ial
    Toint
    egr
    ateCESi1
    1toc
    1in
    icn
    lprac
    ticcwerccommendatr
    ia
    l fo
    rl ho
    seI nd
    ividu
    alsd iagnosedwithPTSD川 I do t
    herswho
    日 r
    ic
    softrca
    tme
    ntsInacJi
    nIco
    rofli
    cctoev
    alua
    tcr山 p
    onseぉ expe
    riencepanicattac
    k討り7
    206 B
    ioel
    ectromagnei
    tcandSu
    btl
    eEnergyMedi口 ne

    EVAlUATINGIMMEDIATEAND 仁ONTRAINDICATION5 PRECAUTlON5 ，


    LONG-TERMEFFECT5 ANDADVERSEEFFE仁T5
    Feelingse xperi c
    n cedd uringaCESt reat menta re由 Qwnm Therea renoknownc o ntraindi cationsto1 heu seo fCES.The
    Figurc1 9.
    5.I ft hep aticntfcclsh ea vy，g rog gy，o re up horica l onl yp reca u
    tion目 r e gar dingus cd ur ingpregnanc y
    .Aぉt u dyo f
    theendo fthea llottedt ime.i
    tisi mportanrt oc o nLinuet he[ r
    cat- pot enl ia
    lt e
    rato genice ffeclsfromCESwasCUIl(J uじtedon844
    mcn l日 間 io
    nu n tillhep at
    icntf cds・'l
    ight
    : 'Att h ecndo faCES S pra que- Dawl e yf et a
    lr a
    ts叫 Thet reatedr atswered i vided
    おC為sion，thcm ajority0 1p
    ' a
    tientswi l
    lfeclmorcr elax cdwhil c Intot h r
    c cg roup sandg ivc nCES 1hd ailyt h
    r oughou lt hcir
    rc mainingalert，andh av cal
    li llcreas
    eds ens eo f、、le1
    l-b eing p reg na ncya tc i ther1 0，1 0 0，o r 1000Hz，w h ilet heparam-
    CESi sd emonst rablye f
    f e
    ctiveb yb otht h ep alientr ecei ving eters0" 1 1v olt、0， 1 25m i
    ll iamI可 re，a ta0 .22t n
    i c
    rosec onds
    trcalmcnt剖 1dt hoseobs cr vi
    ngi tsrcJaxationando th crbcn dits， pll
    l叫 w idl hrcm 山 n edcon ぉtan【 Onday 1 8ofp rcgnan cy_th c
    whicha reぉometimcsc videnta fte
    rt hcfirs
    tt 1ι ltment damswerek illc dandc e s
    ar cans cct io
    nwasp e rforme dimme-
    Acc o
    rding ly，e v川u ati n
    gas i n
    gl e20-40mint ri
    alo fCES diately .A ftcrt h oro ug he xter n
    a lex aminatio n
    .a urops
    iesc val
    -
    ll aじl
    I i
    nicoro flIC
    -cw ilhcl pi dcnt if
    yt h osei ndivid u
    alswho u alcJL hcp a l
    at c.h ea rt.majorv cs sel
    s，I ungs，Iivcr.k idn eys，
    Hrel ike
    ly tor espond r apidly t ot r
    eat me n.
    tHowev er，CES ure ter s.an c
    lb l add e.
    rExuminationsu nclerlightmicr os copy
    efl!c
    I tsarec umu lat i
    ve5 0t ho長ewhodon otr espo ndi n
    i t
    ial
    1y 同 v ca led00n eura lt ubed e f
    ects ，1
    imbr eductiood e
    formiti e
    s.
    muyh cnefi
    twhen g ivcnc i
    ailyt re瓜m ents( 2 0-60m in )f or ora ot criorabdominalw al
    labnormal it
    icぉ int hcc ontrols.O r
    Imontho rl o nger 2
    1
    .177 T
    . hisi sp a rt
    icula rlyt fU
    Ci nd e pres- il1u n yo ft hc1 r eat mcIlt grou p
    s .Skcl etals urveyso ft hef eta
    l
    SLOI
    la ndt ibrom y
    a lgiawhichmayt ak
    es evera lt r
    Ci¥t
    . men ts1 0 ratst oundnov e rtebra lc o lum n.r ib
    .o rl ongboned e formi-
    in duccap r
    eilminaryef tect ties.Comparisonbetwccng roupsr evcal
    e dmorcp rcgnan cy
    A d inici<l
    .
    1l who ¥Vo uldI iket o do じu menl t rca tmenl re公o rp tlolsぬndf ewc ro ffsprin gina llt r
    ea tmentg roupscom-
    progr es
    si nCESp‘ ll
    ientsI la
    l yc ho ose1 0U ぉct hc Hami l
    ton p are d{Qt hec om ro lg r oup.wi l
    l】thed iffe
    r cnceon lyrea ching
    Anxi ctyR atin gScal e(HARS)， S tate
    - TraitAnx ietyI nd
    c x s i
    gn iJic: mcci n1 he 1000Hzt reatmentg roup .A verag ef el
    al
    (STAI)，HamiltonD eprcs sionR ati ngSca le(HAM-DI 7)a nd/ wel 且h ts附 r emver叫 I yp ro ponion alt of requem :yandwere
    Or8e ckDep 町民自 iOI1I nventor y，th cPittsb urgS le epQ u ality s igni fic aml
    yd ifferentamongg r oups.F e
    talb r
    a inw eightf ol-
    In dcx(PSQIJ， Numerica lR at ing(NRS)， Visu alAnalogS c"lc lowedas i m
    i larpはt te
    r no fr cdu cti
    o n，cxceptt hatw eightsw er c
    (VAS)，o rLik ertS oale，all0 1w
    ' hichh av ep r ovenus efuli n nots ignif i
    cantlyd ifti
    じ rt!n
    tbetw eent hemediumandh igh e
    s t
    eval u
    ating CES o utcomes . Thc a nxiclyt c stings hould be fre 叫u e ncyt rea1 men tg roups
    込d minisLCf
    cdb c forcandimmcdi atelyafte rlh eH r叫t rcatment. Inl hcird iscllssion，t her es 0archcrぉ statedt hatwh ilet hc
    anda f
    ter3weeksand6weekso fd ailyus c.F ord epr ession 11
    1 じid cnc eo fcon g enitala llom ai
    leswasz ero，ther easonp re
    g -
    an dinsomnia，whicht ypicallyr cs pondmor es lowly.p atients n nnc y回 s o
    rp t
    i onswerc i ncre asedmay beduet otheCES
    sh oulJbct estc db crorc.b Ul1 10timmcdiat ely‘ d"tert hcf i
    rst t rcare dratsb cin gmorccomplaccnt'.T heirbch‘ lviorresemblcd
    treatrne
    nt.Measur ementsa t3-4weeksandt hen峰 山 na t6-8 theじ品 l m inge ffectso fCESi nhumans.Thet reatedratsw er e
    wccksp rovidel lsefu
    la S
    S CS
    Sll1cntso fpatie ntp r o
    g ress I10ta sa ctivea st hcc ontrols.A c cordingly，iti spo ssiblet hat

    F
    eel
    ing
    sexpeT
    ienceddu
    rin
    gCES
    tr
    ear
    me n
    ts t
    age
    s
    D
    osa
    geeq
    ualst
    imei
    nver
    sel
    ypr
    opo
    rti
    ona
    ltocur
    re
    ntle
    vel
    (
    .
    ie
    .，J
    ec
    u
    日rr
    entr
    equi
    resl
    ong
    ertr
    eat
    men
    ttimepe
    rsess
    ion
    )

    A
    le
    rt E
    ner
    get
    icn
    ，o"br
    a i
    nfo
    g"，
    V山o
    niscl
    ea
    r，a
    sifth
    e
    ，
    / p
    ati
    en
    tsle
    pta
    llnig
    ht

    ，穴
    ， 、
    、
    、 Ugh
    t
    、、
    ，/
    f
    e e
    l
    ing
    、、
    、
    、
    、
    ー
    干ーー
    ---
    He
    avy
    /gr
    oggyo
    ，reu
    pho
    ricf
    ee
    lin
    g
    (
    Nev
    ersto
    pher
    e!
    )
    S
    lee
    py
    S
    ta
    rt E
    nd
    2
    0mi
    nute
    sto
    ，
    o
    rmoreho
    urs

    FIGURE1
    9.5 C
    rani
    alckclro lh ~rapy s
    tim
    ul叫 i
    ond
    o叫 r
    出 p
    ons
    ccu
    rve
    TheE
    vol
    uti
    ono
    fC日 n
    ialE
    lec
    tro
    the
    rap
    ySt
    imu
    lat
    ion 209

    fo odi ntakewaιloweredi nthet r


    eatmentgroup，ar easona
    ble 7.K rat zcnstci n，CG.S chrei benv 川 d
    t ellN
    1 ut，zm d erEf町 tri citll
    t
    im plicationgiv~n t her ed
    u c
    tioni nfctalw cight
    s.Theyc on- 川 d e rArz.l1 ei~\川町J1S{'!U所 Halle: 1 745
    cl udedt hatCESmaybcc mbryolclhalinl hev erycarlyslag
    cお 討 A ldin iJ.Pr r
    !(刊 d esE叩 白 川 T entl
    lls Irl
    l eC a !v
    凶1 Ism
    e .P ‘IfIS

    0'
    1p rcgnancyi nthemtandmightc ausesomem isca
    rriages t8 03
    9.MωaIJP.M山 ，川 印 刷 l 'EiectlU'i
    f!
    tl Je
    v dica le.Pa
    ris:1 78 4
    espec iallyat 1000Hz，b u
    tt hereisnoc vi d
    e n
    c eof己自totOXI
    C
    1
    0.K al i nowsk yL .E lcじtric-collvulsi
    ont hcrapyi nぽ hi70p
    . b rc ni a
    eff~cts. Thcr clevanccofthcsctindin
    gs10humはIlSi sunknown [
    ..
    ll
    l1Ci'f19 3り2 :1232
    Advcrsee ffec
    tso fCESi nhumansoccuri nle山 than1% 11
    .Ledl 1c S .La n an仁 川e c 1cc t
    rique.Z t
    scll rjitrE iectJυt he!
    ofc a sesandt heyaremildands el
    f-limi
    ting.Thesei nclu
    dc 1903 ;1 1(1): 37 ι削 403-1 0，
    vcrtigo.s kini rri
    tatio
    na te l
    cctrode引 t e
    s，and hcadaches 1
    2.LeducS，RouxeauA .I nl1uじI1CCd ur ythmee td cl ape r
    io d持UI
    Headaches and v e
    rtigoa re u叫 l
    all
    ye xp erienced when thc lapn叫 u c
    ri O lld c1 ・inh
    i hitionp arIcsc oun
    : mい】川口 m ittcnt sd e
    curr enti ss ett ooh ighf orap art
    iculari ndividu . Thesc
    al has日 t en
    si o n.CRSt'tl llcesSocB io!1 903、55(VIl- X):899-9 0 1
    1
    3.R oh i n川 '
    [
    1じh LG. E leclrica
    l A l1al鼎~s;a， S leep， 川，，1
    ~ffccts rcsolv~ whent hccurrentisredllc~d orwuhinminute討
    Res us【i t
    ali o n.A ncsthes;a.NcwY ork:A pp1 eton;1 914
    toh o ursf ollo wi
    ngt reatmcnt
    .I rr
    itat
    iona tt hee le
    ctrode日 t
    c 1
    4.G ily arov北 Y VA， L i四 nt 記 vI M‘ ScgalYY 、Kiri1
    lo vaZA
    canbca voide dbyr n
    ovinge lectrode
    sarounds ligh
    tlyd u
    r- Elel'lmsoll: Klu
    li:o
    J
    . -Fiz;%gIch 出 koye /ss ledovl/J1Iy e
    11g 1
    l rc叫m cnts.Nos cri
    ousa dversee ffec
    t shavec vc
    rbeen (E!ec lr
    ICS lcep: A C/i nical-Physiυlogi口If! t
    ll
    '('Suxati ol/)
    re
    目
    no rtedfromu
    〕
    s
    inf!CES.I
    句 Moscow:1 9 58
    1
    5.K irs ch DL .J 11
    t.S ci enceb eh ind Cnmia! Electmrhcm/ ハ
    Sri
    lll ul
    alioJ1. 2ndc d
    .E dm onl on:M edi calS copePuhl i sh in g
    CONCLUSION
    2似た
    CESじ辻 nimprovet hes afctyandc ffective
    nessoft reatmen t 16
    . D川 j gc CH. E lcc
    tl'os
    l cc
    p， c cc
    J lroancぉIh出 ia， a nu c l cc-
    foran xicty，i nsom
    n iil，は ndd epres日iona sw e
    lla sc ontribut e tron
    eur a
    ld iagnosticsa ndt hcrapeuti山 Forei gn 品 IBI lIl
    1967ゴ(3) :4ι64
    tot h
    emanagemento fpa inando thcrd i
    sorder
    s.Whenp rc -
    17
    .I wtlnovぉkyA .Dod :
    gcCH.E l c
    ctroぉI ccpa nde lじct roancs thc民Ja
    scribedf o
    rhomeu se，p atie
    nts山 ' eempowercdt or cgul叫 e
    Theory山 l dc1ini
    c a
    lp rac
    tice.F orei gnS iBul
    c !1 9
    6 8:4(2);1 - 64
    thc
    ir0¥¥'11moods，1 0overcomet heirsleepproblcmぉ.andman U~. lwanvo skyA .T r
    a n
    scr an
    i a
    le Jeじtro therapya nde le cl
    ro an出 t he
    aget heirownp ain，t huscnhancingoutcom出 Comparedt o si
    a;Newa r
    .山 I
    S0 1b
    ' io medicalc ngin eering.IEEEC υnvenlwl I
    othern euerost i
    mul ationt echniquesf orb ra
    inr epair，CESi s Virg
    inia:C harlotte.
    sviUe;April，1 9 71
    noninvasi v
    e.l e日 e x
    p ensive，andcanbel lscdsafel
    yi lndcon 19.C ollccredp cr
    s o
    n alp apcrぉo fA刊 c nT w ano v討ky .Acce ぉs mn
    venientlybyp atie
    n t
    s川 homc.I tisu scf
    lllbotha sana djunc t Numher g 4.2
    .A r
    tifacts
    .D a taba 日 Thc 8akkcn Mu日 um
    tomcd icationo rp sycho thcrapyora 品 astand-alo
    net reatme nt Lihr
    ary.M in neapolis，MN，USA.
    20.Magora F ， Bd 1crA .A la d
    j emo ff し Ma goraA c ta l
    Whilet hecf 1
    icacyofCESi nc ancerando lherseriol
    lsd i
    s-
    Ohservation民 o ne le c
    lrica
    llyi nd uced 叫e e pi nm an. BrJ
    eases￥vi thpoorr espot】sestoc onventionalt reatmen1 i
    只 C l
    1r-
    Anesrh1 CJ65;37:4g0，49J
    ren
    tly叫 I pportedo nlybya necdotalr eport
    s.s uchpatientぉc an 21.McKenzi eRE.R osenthalSH，D r icssnerJ S.Somcp巳y c ho
    ccrta
    i nlyb enc
    t i
    tfromi t
    sa l
    羽1 i
    ty【oimprovcmoodands lecp phyぉiologice rf
    ectsn fc lcctri
    calt ranscra川礼l只t i mLllat inn
    出 w e
    l la srelicvingp ain. (cl
    cctl 叫c ep).AmeriC
    、
    'l1 (
    ll Psychill trù メhsocia fioll 品 it.'IIf~fù
    1

    HistoricallyCEShasbeenl Iseda sal a


    st配 sor
    twhenmed- Pnweedingsすummm 1 971
    ica
    t i
    onsando theri nterventi
    onsf ai
    lo ra rcnotwclIt olc悶 te d 22.W cissMF.TheI reat m
    cnt01川 叫 m n iat hroug hlISC0 '1cl cct ro-
    slc
    ep:A llEEGs tudy.j N刊 '
    vMemD is1 973; 157( 2):108-20
    becal
    l scofa dvcrses idcc f
    fect
    s.CESo ftenp rov
    idc shenefit s
    23.C arlwl'ig
    ht RD，Wei同 MF . Thee JTcct
    so fe 1c clnド;lc e
    po n
    Inぉ uch“ tre
    atment-rcsist山 l
    f'p ati
    e n
    ts.and becausei ti ss o
    I
    n川口1I1l a【cvIs
    ited.JNen叩 t dMe lD is1 975‘1 61(2):1 34←7
    -
    司
    J l1
    safeandc ostcffecti
    v e.shouldbec ons i
    dcredatir
    - stlinet r
    e at- 24.NasI'allah HA: P syc
    h iatry
    'sf utur eish e
    re. CurrPsych川 f
    mentf ora nxiety，i nsomnia，d e
    pre s
    si o
    n.p ain，andpo附 i b l
    y 2009;8(2)
    somco ft heotherd isordersn oteda bove. 25.C ran
    i a
    lc l
    cc t
    rothcrapystimulat
    or.じ: odeザ F 出 leralR egl l/a l umゐ
    20日号T itl
    e2 1，v o.8
    1 :Scc.88 2.580 0
    REFE且EN仁ES 26.L iじhthro u
    nAS，R aicerMC，S mi th RB. The t reatmc r】tn f
    tibromyalgiaw ithc raniale lectmt herapyはi mulation.J Cli n
    1.BullockTH，HopkinsCD.Por 甲山 A N.FayR.El cc trol庇 町 山 011 ?hewllowl2001、
    l 7
    (2)・72 -8
    Spr
    inger.NcwY ork:20 05 27，CorkRC WoodP
    句 .MingN，S hc ph crdCc ta lThcc
    . tle d0' 1
    2
    .D ialogl
    じ b
    1 el weenMenoa ndS ocr
    ales
    .Wi J
    .山"Jt/J'c
    : e.A va
    ilah lc crama
    onl
    incf r o
    m hup: /
    len.wik
    isourcc.
    or:
    g/wiki
    /M cI 1o (a山 巳 出 cd
    JanuI
    ‘ry2 8，20 14
    )
    3
    .K ellawayPK .X II.365.Quotedi nlhepar
    tp lay edh yclcctric
    fl
    shint h
    ee a r
    lyh isto
    ryo fbioclcc
    tri
    cit
    y.BlIlJ HUToryMed
    19462町0:1 3
    0 ーl
    4
    .S t
    illing
    sD .A s urvcyo fthchi汚lor
    yo fele
    ctri
    c a ls limulation
    1
    ''p
    0
    1 ainw 1 9 肌Uvl円 llnsTmmI り75:9
    :255-9
    5
    .S che
    c trDC
    e .O rigin.
    sofc1ccl
    rothcrap
    yPan1 .NewY rwkS tate
    /
    ルl ed1 97 t
    ;71:1 02-8
    6
    .R、仏c hP J.Bra in刈 iml
    1lat
    ionandmindm a
    nipulat iontor e
    pla cc
    dru
    gs.Pωt1 :E
    1 lectr
    iじalぉtimu
    lat i
    on;:
    If
    te
    r1 800. HI叩 lt
    hS tress
    20t4、26(1 )
    :4
    --21
    210 Bioel
    ectromagneticandSubtleEnergyMedicine

    3.PozosRS、R
    1 ichard叩 1A W ，K apla n H M.Modc0' 1pn 叫llC 50
    .S mi thRB .J sm i
    c r ocurrcnts timulutionc ffc c tiv ci np 山 nm an
    liona nJ1 0じIIぉ o
    fa c! i
    ul1()fc lc
    c troane s thc只iai nd ogs.A llcsrhe .
    a gcment? An a dd itionalp c日 pCClivc.AmJ P ail “
    l M nαg ど

    Al1a(ge1 9 69:48(川 342 -5 2 ω1 :1 1(2 ):6 2-6


    32
    .s rione誌 D，FR osenth alSH.Changcsi nu rin川 yr rccc atecho
    l 51
    .K in-c hD， LP r
    i c
    eLR.N i cholぉ F
    .恥 1a
    " rkぉhcrηJA，P latoniKT .
    amincs a nd 1 7-ke lOslcro id ぉ w i t
    hc erchra lc [c ctrolhera
    p y EH ic aじYo fcraniale lcclrulher a
    pys timu lat
    ionf ora nxiet
    y.PTSD，
    (c
    1e ctr
    oslcc p).DisNav5¥sI 97 3:34(1 ):57 -8 IIIれ )mm 人 a ndd 叩r c出 ion:U. S.Milita rySc r v i ccMcmbersand
    33.ShcalyCN.CadyRK .WiJkieRG.CoxRH.L i
    s:
    -.S.C lo出 o nW V c[cr ansS clfR cpor ts.ArmyMedDeptJI np rc臼， 2 014
    ela lD
    . cprcs日i on
    :Ad iagnos ticn curo c hem iじ31p rof1
    lca ndl h巳ト 52
    .Amcriじa nPぉy chia lricA ssoci at
    ion.Dia~ l1() .\.tÎC (llIdSraris
    fu.αl
    apyw i
    t hc ranialclピc troth cr a
    py叫 i mu lati on.JNeu仰 IOrt Jop
    ! Mal1l1a JofM出 I talD isorder s.5 the d.A rl i n gto n :American
    M山 I Sl
    lrg1989: 10(1): 319ー- 21 P sy chi atri
    cA ssoc ia t
    io n:2013
    34
    .K rup itskyEM.BurakovA M，K ar an d ash ovaG， FK atsnc 川1
    J 53.N ati onalI nsl
    itllLeso fHe alt h
    .TheNumhersCount :M cntal
    JS，LebcdcvV P.G ri nenk oAJ .a ndB o rod ki n1S，Thcadmin D is ord c
    r si nA mc ric a.R ctricvc d from h ttp ://www.nimh
    i
    st r
    ationo ft ransじrani a
    lc lc c tri
    ct n.'a tmcnlf o raffcctiv
    ed i叫Ul'- ni h. govI h calt h
    / p ub1 i
    catiùns/thc ~ n 1mb cr s- COl 1n t
    "meOla1 _
    banc cst hcra pyina co
    J holiじ p aticnts.DrugAlcol JofDepclld di s ordcrs-in- a
    m cric al
    in dex泊 tml#WHORcportBurdcn on
    19 91;27(1):1-6 Novembcr.5 th2013
    35
    .L i日 S .L iおも B .Phys iol
    o gi ca la ndt h cra peuticc ffcct
    so fh igh 54.Ba 日l ayTH.B ar cl ayRD.A じl inic
    alt r
    ia
    lo fc r aniale lec
    tro
    frcqllcncyc lec
    tricalP l
    llse 只 lJ1legrP hysIo l andBehav 抗 t t hcr apys t imulalio nf ora nxi c
    lyandd cpres芯i OIlr datcdd i
    sor-
    1 996‘31(2): 88-94 d白 s .P (/Je
    f rpresemed( /
    (Amer iCUl
    lP s:rc
    h(J! o g ic
    .αI ASS
    ()Cult
    ioll
    36
    .S hca ly亡、Cady札 Cul vcr~ V cc ho ffD .CoxRC la 1
    .C cr eh
    ra l N ar Io/lufCm ザe rcl1ιe.H onolu lu.Jllly2 013.JA J Te ctDis οrd.ln
    討pinalt l
    u i
    da ndplasman c ur ochc mi c al:Rcsp、
    s nsct oc ranial p rocc ss.20141 町 6 4: 171-7
    electro
    stimul ati
    on.JN .
    山 r o/Or 的ο ，'Med.
    f )"，
    .1998;18(2):94-7. ラ5.LccS .E ffc じt
    s0 '1c ranialc lectrothera pysti ml 1la l
    I on011p reop-
    37
    .MignoJl A .LaudcnbachV，Gui叫 h ar dFc taLT ra nscutancou s c ratIvca n xicty
    .p ai na ndc nd ocrincr cponぉc
    泊 .JI II(tv
    l目i Rese
    cranialc lectrica
    ls tImulat io n(Limoge、 ， c
    ，
    . u rre
    nts)d c c陀 a問、 1
    11P rc日 2014
    carlyb llprcn o叩h inca na lg出 i cr e qui rc mcnt sa ft
    era hdn日l inal 56. KimHJ， KimWY.LeeYS， ChangMctal. Th e ef f e ctofcranial
    surgery.AI1t'sthAna/~ 1996: 83( 4
    ) :771 -5 c lcctro t
    hel叩 y山 m ula tiononp rcopc rativca nxi c tya ndhcmo-
    3K StanleyTH.C azala aJA，A ti
    n aultA e ta LTnm出 u tanc叫 凶 dynamicr csponses .K .川 町m J Aneslh出 i of2008;55:657 6 ← 1
    じranialclc c
    t ric
    als timlllati o nd ccr caお じ sn arcotic日 q Ulrc mc
    nt s 57.S tr entzsch‘ J A. An e xamin ationo fc rani a le k C1I
    'otherapy
    durin gn curo lepta n cslhes i aa ndo p eratiollI n man.A llesrJ
    r 叫i mul ation(CES) on a lph a-amylas cI cv d s，c o n。
    i見Ilevc 1s

    1
    Ana!xI
    り Sl
    じr
    a
    a
    n
    n
    l
    i
    e
    alc
    開 2刷(10):8ω4
    vTH
    lcじt
    ‘C
    ri
    c.
    a
    1
    z
    ts
    al
    t
    a
    i
    a1A.L
    mulali o
    imogcA c
    ni llcrcas est
    ta
    hcp
    LT
    ot
    r
    c
    a
    n
    n
    c
    sc
    yo
    ut
    fn
    an
    i
    e
    t
    o
    r
    l
    o
    ls
    uぉ
    ands
    D
    Tc
    oc lo
    t
    r
    x出 .P
    at
    a
    e-lrai
    ta
    ld】山口 l
    sy ch o
    l
    n

    o
    u
    g
    x
    t
    i
    i
    e
    o
    n
    tys
    ;S
    c
    a
    o
    i
    r
    n
    c芯 inl
    tMary U
    yDcpartmcnt
    、
    hじ c

    .200X
    h
    n
    i
    r
    v
    o
    e
    n
    r
    i
    s
    c
    i、
    a1ym
    l en
    t al
    町 SanAntonio，
    l
    yi l
    I

    OXid cinhuman込 i ¥n esr


    h cs i olo gv1 9R2 :5 7(4) :
    293-7 58.C hel lY， YuL、Zh‘ mgJ .LiLc ta. lRe su
    lt沿 υ fc r anialcl c
    ctro-
    40
    .K icferF.HorntrichM，JahnH，WicdcmannK .lswuhdrawal t hc rapys tImlllationt oc hil
    drc l
    lw ithmixcda n x ic tya ndd cprcs-
    in d
    u ccda nx cityi n akholism b ase d on B ~ l'ndorphill dじjト Mνcd isord白 S!rang! Ja;A η hPsychiat2 007 ;1 9 (4 ):203 -
    5
    clcnじy1Pり chο 'p!
    w rm(/{
    ."o !ogy.2 002;1 62 :43 3-7 59. Winick .RL .C nmiald cctrot h
    じ 叫 甲 山m ulat I on( CES):A叫 f e
    41
    . Pows RS. S track LE， Whitc RK. R iじhards on 生W andじf f
    cc tivcl owc os tmeans0" 1a nxictyconl roli n~ d ent.
    a1
    ElectroslcepVel 汎 ISc lc
    ctJ'Oc onvul siv ct hcrapy.J n:Rcynol Js， p raclic .GcnDcmist1
    c 999;4 7(1):50-5
    DY .S j
    orlc 、
    rg .AEEd話 NClm )
    ピ e
    lt>ctru :R e.w才r
    “ c
    h.S pringliclJ 60.V ori sM D，GoodS .T rcatil1g同 日m lo ffcn d c円lIs in
    gc r
    anial
    ，
    マ

    Charl c
    sThom出;1 971.p .221 -5 c1c ct rothcr apys ti mulation.MedS '叩 eMOI1 1996、 3(11):1ι8
    42.Sicgesmund KA，S UllCC.'i A，L ars o nS 1.Thc 勾7 ι“ 吋 61.P ric弘 LR. 2013 AlphaS ゃ lim Uscr E ffe c t目 白 淀 川 S urvcy
    Eft
    >ctricafC u rre
    llts()Jl Sy no pti cV{.
    '.
    ，，'
    idesi nMonkc .vC orle x Abs tracti nt hc2013SlIp pl cmcntl nformati ont ot h
    eCDRH
    NewY o rk:Exc白 l )taMcdicuF o un dat i on;1 967 forA l pha- StimCES，Auguぉt5 lh，2 01 3.Availabko nlincfrom
    斗3.GoldMS.P o tta
    shALC，S lc rnh a
    c hH .8arbahanJc la.lA ntI w\vw.alpha ~ 討 tim . com/wp - content / uploads/FDA -A UGUST
    with druwalc ffec
    t日 o fu lp h am ct hyl dopaU l
    lUc ranialc lec- 5-2013-5
    15ト S
    Upp
    lCf
    llCI
    lt.
    pJf(a
    ccc問 c
    dNo. 'c
    mbr11
    c .2013) 、
    lrothc口中 y.P rescnle u.1
    1t hcSo 】e
    じ Lyf orN c uroscicncc.1 21h 6
    2.Bracci
    anoAG‘ChangW，Ko kc
    shS‘M art
    inzAe
    c talC
    . r
    ani
    al
    Anfl/w[M出 t in.M
    g in ncapo l i s.M i nnc so ta.O ctobcr，1 98 2 dcct
    rolhcra
    py
    4
    TheEvol
    uti
    onofCranialEl
    ectrotherapySt
    imulati
    on 2
    11

    68.Dworkin RH， Tu rk DC， Wyrwich K W， B eato n0 c la l 自4


    .Ra
    inc
    rB 山
    .Mad1IR
    .Neuro日 旧f
    omi
    sch
    esP
    ost
    lll
    aL，
    .:u
    rGenese
    In【山-pr eli ngt hじc 1ini c
    ali mpoロ an ceof【r catme nlo utcomcs1 11 VOf
    lT i
    llli
    l Lu!
    i ( N.的 r
    目 oall afO川 ist Po sl!/la
    resl heG e llesis of
    chron i cp a inc !I nIc alt ri
    al
    s:I ル1 MPACTr ccommendal ions.J 7il
    lniLus).2003:Ka dcn
    Pail
    l2008、 9:05-12 85
    .E ngcl bcrgM.Baue rW.T ra nscuta neo u selectrica
    ls ti mulati oT
    l
    69
    . Mcll cnRR.MackeyW.Rcduci ngS hcriff' sO rticers'symp- forti n
    n i
    tus.Lar yngos co pe1 9 85:95 :1 1 67-72
    IOI1S o
    l rctcpression using cranialelectrotherapy s ti mul a 86
    .J ohnsonM.Bodcnhame r~D av i s E .B ai leyL.Neurof 1
    .じd
    ! back，
    lion( C ES) :A c on trolc xpc rime nt a
    ls tud y.C orrectlP s:rcho l cranialel ec
    trotherapys t i mulat
    iona ndm icrocur r
    e ntel eじtrical
    ∞
    2 9 : 41 (1) :9- 15 s
    timul ation10t reattinni lus:Ac< lses eries.Po stcrp r esen teda t
    70
    .K Irs ch DL. G il ula M. Cr anial e lectr otherap ys limul a He lpingt heBr ainHe lpU s.r h
    e1 8 1hA wlltalmel !lingofI he
    tioni nt hct r ea tmen tofd c p
    r cssi on.P r
    a ct icalPa iflMα nαg e Inlem alionalSoc ielyfo rNeurolhempyαndR e sear ch.Denver 守

    2007: 7(4):33-41 Col orado，Scptember29-0ctohcr~. 2010


    71
    . LandcRG.Gra g nan iC .Eflicacy0' 1cran ialc l
    cctr i
    じ s l
    i mula- 87.Z cngFG、TangQ.QingT，Dim itrijcv icA e ta lT
    . inn ituss up-
    i
    tonf orI hct rea lme nt0'1i nsomnia :A r andomi zcdp il
    ots tud y prcssionbylow~ ratc c l cctrics t
    im ulat ionandi lse l eclro ph
    y si-
    白 川1 '/Th era pMed2 013:2 1(1 ):8 -13 ologicalmecha n
    is ms.He arin gRes2011 :277:61-6 6
    7.Tay
    2 lorAG.AndersonJ G.R陀 d c lSL .LewisJ Eeta. lCrani al 88
    .B ar bau!tA， CostaF P.BougerB.MundenRFc ta.lAmp litude
    elcctricals t
    im ul ati oni mpro vessymptomsandF unctional5 1鉱 山 modul a tcdelectro m
    ag ne t ict iel
    dsf ort het reatmento fc a nce r
    inind ivi dual swi 1hf ibr omyalgia.Pa il
    lMwwgeNurs2 011 :e pub Dis coveryoftumor -
    sp eci ticf requ enc ie sanda sscss me ntofa
    ishcd ahead 0'
    ¥ 1p rint h
    句 tt p: //w ww.pain m an agemcntn ur sing novelt h
    crapcutica ppr oa ch.JExpC lurRes2 00 9;2 8べl
    org!ani clc/S1 52 4-9042(1 1)∞ 1 3 6.6/ful
    lt削 89
    .C ostaF P. CosmcdeO li veiraA，M山 r cllcsJ rR Machado
    句

    73
    .Cl ar kN. Mi llsD.Mar chantJ .E valu
    at ionoft ht!p otenlial MCCc ta.lT real mentofa dv ance dhep atoc
    cl lularc a rcinoma
    efticac yort h cAl pha- StimSCSi nt hch or sc.Pa pc rp rcsc nlcd withv e rylowl evelso famplitudc-modul atedel e
    c trom a gnet ic
    alth~ DcMontforr Univc円 i tyE【j uestr
    i anCent reand F ield !e
    i lds.Br. lCan ζe r201 1 ; 105 :640-8
    Slatio n.L i nc oln shirじ. Unite dKingdom，J a nu ar
    y2α)0 90
    . ZimmermanJ .P:tnnis o nM.Br cwvichLY iN e ta lCancer
    .
    74
    .Th eC oη lIniueeonAdvancingPai nRes e arc h.Re fie
    villgH α川 ce1
    lp roli
    rera
    tioni si nhi bi tedbys p eci tkm肌 1 ulalionf re quen
    υ11¥川 e ri
    c a.A 8 1u el川川f or' 目rals formIlIgP reve
    lll i
    oll，Care ， cie
    s.BrJCancer20!21 町 06:3 07-1 3
    Edu c ariol
    landRe search.2011 .A vailahlじo ni
    lnef omhup:
    r l l . Blackman CF
    91 . 丁目 at ingc an cer wi lh a m p
    l itude-modul aled

    75
    h川 ks
    . Ri
    usi
    n
    n
    ta
    .n
    l
    gc
    a

    r
    p
    aDH.
    an
    .

    i
    e

    a
    du
    Ta
    le
    /

    l
    op

    ect
    、
    enb
    nG. N
    ro
    ook.
    il
    thc
    ls
    r
    php
    o
    a
    nP
    p ys
    ?r

    l
    c

    i
    co

    mu
    r

    l
    d

    a
    _i
    .BryamMSe
    ti
    d=13172&page=1

    o
    nf
    ta
    01
    "p
    .
    1Fe
    aini
    asit
    np
    ラi
    l
    e
    i
    r
    t
    y(
    son
    )f
    s 92.S
    cl

    t
    c

    u
    ct
    JCα n
    p
    ro
    ce
    ma
    r2
    gn
    0
    e
    1
    pR，WongE
    l
    2
    icf
    ;1 0
    T
    i
    6
    c
    l
    :
    d
    2
    s:A pO
    4
    .Kann
    1 -2
    e
    le

    rAA.S
    n
    ti l1
    :

    te
    paradigms

    in bcrg0eta.
    hi fta
    . g

    lNovoT
    ain?8 1

    寸 F-
    wIlhP arkin son '只 d isease.Hαr kinsoll'sDi s2 010:1 -8 looA v ersusp hysician 'schoi cechcmOlher apy i nr c cu何 cnt
    76
    .TanG.Ri ntalaDH.Thor nbyJ .YangJc ta. lUsi ngcr ani al gliohlasloma:A r and omis e dp has el I
    tt r
    ialo fano velt 日a t
    !c
    c ctr other apys t
    im ulation10t r
    e atpai n拍 S OCI創 出J wi t
    hs pinal me ntmodai lty.El/rJC C/lJcer201 2: 48: 2192-202
    cordi njury.JR e ha hilRe seDev2 006:41( 4) :461-74 91. Waddington M， The 8 y l叩 ¥1. Edmonton: Medic al Scop c
    77
    . Hn !u be cJ T. Cumul ai
    tv cr じs pon sef romc r anialdeじ【 r ot h
    cr Puhlish ing;2008.A vai la bleo n
    li nefromwww.thehyway，o rg
    apys t imul atio n(CES)f orc hron icp ai.P
    n ra clAα川 Mal/a ge (acce s
    s edJanuar y31.2 0 14)
    2009 : 9(9) : 8
    0 - 83 94. King GE 目 aJ . E lt!c trot herapy and h ype rbaric oxygcn
    78
    . He ffer nanM.Theef fcct0' 1v ari ah
    lemi cr o curr
    en tsonEEG Prom ising t r
    eat mcnls f or po str adi a
    tion compl ications
    spcct ruma ndp aincomro. lC α"JC /i"Med1 997:4( 10):4 ー11 ，
    Jp叩 h etDe n
    t1 98 9:6 2( 3) :
    3 31-4
    79
    . Ro sch PJ .Re pet itivcI ra
    ns crania lm agn ct ics timulation f or 95.Bos we!l.NS.Neurocl c ctr ict herapyel irninat
    esx cro sl
    omi ad ur-
    tinnilius.s ioe l由、 l romaglMed .CRCP r
    e ss.NewYor k:2004 ingr adiothcrapy- Ac as eh i
    story.MedE le
    ctr1 9 8
    9 :1 15:1 05-7
    p
    .313-20 96.l anG、DaoTK、Smit hDL .Robi nsonA e ta ll
    . n cor por a
    li ng
    80
    . FolmerRL.C arro llJ R .RahimA e ta lE'
    . 1fects0'1r epetitiv c compl e mentarya nda ltcr native medici nc(CAM)The rapies
    I
    r ansc悶 ni almagnct ics l
    il
    llul atIon( rTMS )onchr on i
    ct inn it
    u s toe xpa ndps ycho logic als erv;ccs1 0v !l
    t eranss uf fcringfrom
    AC/lI O LOlar)' Ig
    l o12 006:1 26 :9ι1 01 chronicp an.Ps
    i )'ch
    olS e r v2010: 7(3):1 4
    ←8 61
    81
    . Kh己d rE .R ot hw ellJ .EI ・Ata rA. Onc-yじa rf o Io¥V up 0
    l '
    1 97， SmithR日 、 S hiromotoFN .Thcu s eo fc ran
    ialc 1c ct rot he
    r apy
    patlcn t詰 wi thc h ro nict innitust reat c
    dw ithl efttemp o
    ro par同日 l はi mu l
    a tio
    nt obloc kf earp ercepitoni nphobi cp atie nts.]C l ln
    rTMS.EurJN印 r ， o
    /2 009:1 6:4 04-8 The川 pRes1 992 ;51(2 ):2 49- 53
    82
    .M ul le rN.Lor enz1 .LangguthB. Wci日 N，rTMSi nducc dtin- 98.L
    nitusr c
    lic fi sr elat edt oan山 : re
    FIGURE18.2 fMRIdcmons【r a
    testhesecondarybrainerfe
    ctso fprefr
    ontaltransc
    rani
    alma gneti
    cstimul at
    ion(TMS).Showni ncoJ
    orarc
    thebrainr cgi
    o n語 t
    hatarcsignincan
    tlyaCliva
    tedcomparedt or est(p<0. 01、extcntp<0.05)ins i
    xa dul
    tsw ithc linic
    aid ep
    ressi
    ond ur
    ing
    Jef
    tp r
    erronta
    lTMSa t1s.Thed iff
    crenc
    esar epJ吋 e
    <
    .'t
    edOnaC Omff
    i()nbrain( T
    alai
    rach
    ).Thcarrowd epictstheTMSc o
    ilp os
    It
    ion.which
    folow句 thealgor i
    thmdcv el
    opedIn1994f orprobabili
    sti
    calylinding【hcprd r
    onlalcor
    lexba日 donr cl
    ati
    v edistancefroml hemolorcortcx
    TMSw出 o rig
    i nall
    yuscdQv erIhcprcfro
    ma lcor
    tcx10treatdcpressi
    onb ccauseofthepmemi alforac
    tiva
    tin gco 山c al-
    limbicloo
    ps.Jmaging
    studi
    es5 uchast hisoncshowt halthisassumptionwasl ikdycorrectandt hatthcprefr
    ont
    alC O
    rlexisawindowt os timu
    l u
    tingsubcor
    tica
    l
    andl imh
    ics it
    es.F ULU
    reworki snccdedt odet e
    rminetheoptimumcor t
    ica
    ls i
    tesformaximalc l
    inic
    alc f
    f e
    ctivencss.andw hetherthe
    reare
    genera
    lr ulesforl i
    ndingth
    isa c
    ro日 indi
    vidualsorshouldheindividual
    lygui dedbasedons t
    ructu
    ralorf unctio
    n alimagingヨ剛 (FromMUSC
    BrainSlimula l
    ionL abora
    loryandCen【e r"orAdv
    t ancedIm<lgi
    ngRc scar
    ch.D.rL i)
    .

    O
    elt
    a(1
    .0-3
    .5Hz
    ) T
    het
    a(4
    .0-7
    .5Hz
    ) Al
    pha(
    8
    .0-1
    2.0Hz
    ) B
    eta(
    12.
    5-2
    5.0Hz
    )

    •
    •
    0
    .00 0
    .03 o回 0
    .00 0
    .03 0
    .06 0
    .00 0
    .03 0
    .06 0.
    00 0
    .03 0.
    06

    H
    igh8
    eta(
    25.
    5-3
    0.0H
    z) B
    eta1(
    12.
    0-1
    S.0H
    z) B
    eta2(
    15. 7.
    0-15Hz
    ) 8
    eta3(
    18.
    0-2
    5.0Hz
    )

    •
    • •
    •
    0
    .00 0.
    03 0.
    06 0.
    00 0.
    03 0
    .06 0
    .0一
    0 0
    .03 一 0.
    06

    FIGURE19.1 Rel31
    iveP'】wcrp-val
    uet o
    pographi
    calmap"o
    Jr0 .
    5Hzc raniale l
    ect
    ro【h
    erapystimul
    ation(CES).Stat
    istic
    all
    ys i
    gnii
    !cant
    change
    s(p<0.05orbet
    tcr
    )a ftc
    ras ing
    lc0.5HzCES日 s s
    iona reindicatcdbycol o
    r;whiteindi
    catc
    snos ig
    nific
    antchange.Thじ am刊"IS
    indi
    cat
    cth
    edir
    ecli
    onofcha
    n gc
    .Sl a
    t叫 ic
    all
    ysigni
    i
    fcantd
    ecr
    cas c
    s、 同 日 目 印 叩 ddlaandhctawil
    hs t
    at
    isti
    call
    ys i
    gni
    ficam in
    creas
    csinalpha

    You might also like