UTMOSTIMPORTANCEFACILITATINGTHEMOVE CONTEMPORARYREALITIESTHECHALLENGE 'AMES4-.OP )MAGINE

INTOCHALLENGINGTHEMATICOBSERVATIONAL RESTSWITHRESEARCHERSARTISTSDESIGNERS 0UBLISHING
ANDHISTORICALMODES ANDDEVELOPERSTOCHALLENGEESTABLISHED 4HEODORE3 @4HE2EAL7ORLD
PERCEPTIONSOFTHEVIDEOGAMEFORMAND THE5PSAND$OWNSOF5SING2EAL 7ORLD
Conclusion CONlDENTLYFOLLOWINTHEFOOTSTEPSOF 2EFERENCE-ATERIAL'AME$EVELOPER6OL
'AME$EVELOPER
'AME$EVELOPER6OL
!SDISCUSSEDTHEMEDIACANATTIMESBE ARTISTSSUCHAS3PIEGELMANWHOWAS .OP 5"-
IRRESPONSIBLEOFITSCOVERAGEOFEMERGENT MOTIVATEDBYTHENOTIONTHAThHISTORY ""#.EWS @#ATHEDRALROWOVER
INTERACTIVEFORMSTHUSNEGATIVELY WASFARTOOIMPORTANTTOLEAVESOLELYTO VIDEOWARGAME""#.EWS/NLINETH
SHAPINGTHEPERCEPTIONANDAWARENESS HISTORIANSv;= *UNE!VAILABLEFROMNEWSBBCCOUK
OFPOTENTIALAUDIENCES%XISTINGREALITY HIENGLANDMANCHESTERSTM
BASEDORINDEED@DOCUMENTARYGAMES Notes "ROPHY 7ARREN* @)RAQTHE
HAVEBEENSHOWNTOPOSSESSASUBJECTIVE 2OHDE--4OSCHLOG-! 6IDEOGAME7ARISHELL3HOULDITBEA
RE INTERPRETATIONOFEVENTSWHICH @4OWARDTHE&USIONOF3ERIOUS3IMULATION GAME4HE7ALL3TREET*OURNALTH!PRIL
HAVEOFTENBEENPOORLYCONSIDERED AND6IDEO'AMESIN0ROCEEDINGSOFTHE !VAILABLEFROMONLINEWSJCOM
ANDDEFENDEDINRESPONSETOEXTERNAL 3PRING3IMULATION-ULTICONFERENCE ARTICLE3"HTML
SCRUTINY.EVERTHELESSTHEREISAGREAT 3OCIETYFOR#OMPUTER3IMULATION ,AUGHLIN! @3IX$AYSIN&ALLUJAH
POTENTIALWITHINTHEINTERACTIVEFORM )NTERNATIONAL3AN$IEGO#!!RTICLE @DElNITELYNOTCANCELLED$IGITAL3PY
$IGITAL3PY
$IGITAL3PY
TOSUCCESSFULLYANDSENSITIVELYDELIVER (UGHES3 @2EALLESSONS !VAILABLEFROMWWWDIGITALSPYCOUK
ANAPPROPRIATEFACTUALEXPERIENCE4HE FROMVIRTUALBATTLE""#.EWS/NLINE GAMINGNEWSASIX DAYS IN
FACTTHATTHEMAJORITYOFVIDEOGAME TH!UGUST!VAILABLEFROM FALLUJAH DElNITELY NOT CANCELLEDHTML
DEVELOPMENTEXISTSHIDDENBEHIND.ON NEWSBBCCOUKHIUKSTM !NTONIADES4 IN@!N!UDIENCE
$ISCLOSURE!GREEMENTSIMPACTSONTHE "OYD# @$ARFURACTIVISMMEETS 7ITH.INJA4HEORY%DGE.O0
TRANSPARENCYOFAPRODUCTIONWITHTHE VIDEOGAMING""#.EWS/NLINETH*ULY &UTURE0UBLISHING
PUBLICANDPRESSUNABLETOBEPRESENTED !VAILABLEFROMNEWSBBCCOUKGO 3PIEGELMAN! 4HE#OMPLETE
WITHARATIONALANDSATISFYINGOVERVIEWOF PRFR HITECHNOLOGYSTM -AUS,ONDON0ENGUIN
THEDEVELOPMENTPROCESS)FCONTROVERSIAL 'EARBOX3OFTWARE @0RESS 3TONE/ @3TONEON3TONES
THEMESORCONTENTISBEINGTACKLED 2ELEASE"ROTHERSIN!RMS(ISTORY
"ROTHERSIN!RMS
"ROTHERSIN!RMS(ISTORY )MAGE!S0RESENTEDBY3OME(ISTORIANS 
THEGAMEDEVELOPERHASTOBEABLETO #HANNEL3PECIAL!VAILABLEFROM )N"RENT4OPLIN2ED /LIVER3TONES
RESPONDWITHAJUSTIlCATIONOFTHEIR WWWGEARBOXSOFTWARECOMABOUTPRESS 53!&ILM(ISTORYAND#ONTROVERSY
53!&ILM(ISTORYAND#ONTROVERSY53!
METHODSINTENTIONSANDANAWARENESS BROTHERS IN ARMS HISTORY CHANNEL 5NIVERSITY0RESSOF+ANSAS
OFTHEISSUESSURROUNDINGAPRODUCTION SPECIAL 3PIEGELMAN! -ETA-AUS
&ORVIDEOGAMESTOBEAPOWERFULFORMOF 'AMES4- "REAKING.EWS ,ONDON0ENGUINP
COMMUNICATIONHANDLINGHISTORICALAND

Why Bridge the Uncanny Valley?

Photorealism vs Suspension of Disbelief in Animation

Robin Sloan

) NRECENTYEARSTHE5NCANNY6ALLEY
THEORYHASBEENUSEDTOFRAMECRITICAL
ANALYSISOFHYPER
REALCHARACTERANIMATION
CONCERNEDWITHWOWINGTHEIRAUDIENCES
WITHPHOTOREALISTICCHARACTERAPPEARANCE
INBOTHlLMANDCOMPUTERGAMES4HE
ANDMOVEMENTOTHERCHARACTERANIMATORS
The uncanny valley and the quest
for photorealism
4HENOTIONOF@REALISMINCOMPUTER
AREMORECONCERNEDWITHEXPLORINGWHAT GENERATEDIMAGERY#') HASLONGBEEN
THEORYPREDICTSTHATASCHARACTERSBECOME ITMEANSTOBEHUMAN)NDEEDITCANBE ASSOCIATEDWITHPHOTOREALISM!S$ARLEY;=
MOREHUMAN
LIKEINAPPEARANCETHEY ARGUEDTHATIMAGINEDCHARACTERSTHATARE NOTESTHEAESTHETICSOF#')HINGEON
RUNTHERISKOFBECOMINGUNSETTLINGTO UNNATURALINAPPEARANCEANDMOVEMENT THEhRESEMBLANCEOFANIMAGETOTHE
AUDIENCES4HISDIPINACCEPTABILITYISTHE CANINFACTBEMOREBELIEVABLYHUMANTHAN PHENOMENALEVERYDAYWORLDTHATWE
5NCANNY6ALLEYANDONTHEOTHERSIDE THOSETHATFOCUSONVISUALMIMICRY4HIS PERCEIVEANDEXPERIENCEPARTIALLY THROUGH
OFTHISVALLEYARETHETHEORETICALHUMAN ARTICLEMAKESACASEFORANALTERNATIVE SIGHTvP 4HEREALISMMOVEMENTINART
SIMULANTSnCHARACTERSSOCONVINCING APPROACHTOTHE5NCANNY6ALLEYFORJUDGING SUPPORTSTHISSTANCETOADEGREE2EALIST
THATTHEYAREUNDISTINGUISHABLEFROMREAL THEAESTHETICSOFHUMAN
LIKEANIMATION ARTISTSHAVESINCETHENINETEENTHCENTURY
HUMANS(OWEVERTHETHEORYnWHICHHAS WITHSPECIlCFOCUSONTHEINTENTIONSOF AIMEDTODEPICTTHEWORLDASITEXISTS
ITSORIGINSINROBOTICSnCANDISTRACTUS THEANIMATORINPRESENTINGCHARACTERS EMPIRICALLY.OTABLYHOWEVERREALISTARTIS
FROMONEOFTHEPRIMARYAIMSOFANIMATION THATREmECTHUMANEXPERIENCERATHERTHAN NOTCONlNEDTOTHEPURSUITOFPHOTOREALISM
7HILESOMECHARACTERDESIGNERSMIGHTBE REPLICATEHUMANAPPEARANCE (OWTHEARTISTAPPROACHESANDREPRESENTS

MEDIAEDUCATIONJOURNAL


OBJECTIVEREALITYCANVARYINVISUALSTYLEAND OFHUMANREALISM%FFECTIVELYTHEREARE

PRESENTATIONSEE-ALPAS;= 4HEAESTHETICS MINORmAWSINAPPEARANCEORMOVEMENT
OFREALISTARTMAYTHEREFOREBECONSIDERED THATLEADUSTODOUBTTHATTHEANDROIDIS
INTERMSOFTHEBEAUTYINHERENTINTHE WHATITPRETENDSTOBE)TISNOTHUMAN
SKILFULANDARTISTICREPRESENTATIONOFREALITY ANDOURRESPONSEISONEOFFEARDISGUST
RATHERTHANITSPHOTOGRAPHICACCURACY7E ANDSUSPICION)NOTHERWORDSTHEOBJECT
NEEDNOTBEFOOLEDINTOTHINKINGTHATWHAT APPEARSUNCANNY
WEAREOBSERVINGISREALITYITSELF!NDYET 4HE0OLAR%XPRESS;=¥7ARNER"ROTHERS
INRECENTYEARSINCREASINGCRITICALAPPRAISAL !NIMATEDCHARACTERSTHATAREMOREOR
OF#')HASCENTREDONTHENOTIONOF@THE LESSHUMAN LIKEINAPPEARANCECANBE WEREFEDINTOTHECHARACTERANIMATION
UNCANNY INPARTICULARUSINGADAPTED CRITIQUEDUSINGTHE5NCANNY6ALLEYTHEORY PIPELINE4HERESULTINGCHARACTERSWERE
VERSIONSOF-ASAHIRO-ORIS5NCANNY6ALLEY &IGSHOWSTHE5NCANNY6ALLEYPLOTTING ALMOSTUNIVERSALLYMETWITHDISDAIN;=
THEORY;=ASATOOLFORANALYSINGANIMATED HUMAN LIKENESSVERSUSPERCEIVEDFAMILIARITY nTHEDIRECTORSINTENTIONWASTOPRESENT
CHARACTERS"EFOREWECANPROPERLYEXAMINE THECOMMONMEASUREUSEDTODENOTE CHARACTERSTHATWEREREALISTICALLYHUMAN
THETHEORYANDEVALUATEITSTRUEVALUE OURFEELINGSTOWARDSANANDROID )NTHIS LIKEINAPPEARANCEANDTHERESULTWAS
TOANIMATIONITISIMPORTANTTHATWE EXAMPLEASERIESOF#')FEATURElLMSHAVE ANIMATIONTHATFELLINTOTHE5NCANNY6ALLEY
lRSTCONSIDERTHEORIGINOFTHEUNCANNY BEENPLACEDALONGTHEGRAPHBYTHEAUTHOR 3INCETHENACOMMONARGUMENTHASBEEN
AESTHETIC (EREWECANSEETHATAS#')CHARACTERS THATFURTHERADVANCEMENTINMOTION
BECOMEMOREEMPIRICALLYREALISTICAND CAPTUREANDRENDERINGTECHNOLOGYWOULD
3IGMUND&REUD;=RAISEDTHENOTIONOF HUMAN LIKEINAPPEARANCETHEYRUNTHE ALLOWTHE5NCANNY6ALLEYTOBEBRIDGED
THEUNCANNYINHISESSAY@$AS RISKOFFALLINGINTOTHE5NCANNY6ALLEY (OWEVERWHILESUBSEQUENTMOTION
5NHEIMLICHEINWHICHHEDISCUSSEDTHE !CCORDINGTOTHETHEORYIFANIMATORS CAPTUREDANIMATIONSSUCHAS"EOWULF
"EOWULF;=AND
EXPERIENCEWITHREFERENCETOEXAMPLES CANSUCCESSFULLYMIMICREALHUMANSTOA -ARS.EEDS-OMS MADEUSEOFADVANCED
;=

FROMLITERATURE&REUDSTATEDTHATTHE SUFlCIENTDEGREETHENTHE5NCANNY6ALLEY TECHNOLOGIESANDTECHNIQUESCRITICSSTILL

UNCANNYISAFEELINGOFFEARTRIGGEREDBY CANBEBRIDGEDANDTHEENDRESULTWILLBE DISCUSSEDTHEUNCANNYFEELINGTHESElLMS
SOMETHINGUNFAMILIARnNOTABLYTHEFEELING ACHARACTERTHATISAESTHETICALLYSUPERIOR GENERATED;=)TISCLEARTHATIMPROVEMENT
THATANAPPARENTLYANIMATEOBJECTAPPEARS TOALLOTHERDESIGNS!UDIENCESWILLSEE INTECHNOLOGYDIDNOTELIMINATETHE
UNREAL&REUDPROVIDEDTHEEXAMPLEOF THECHARACTERASBEINGINDISTINGUISHABLE AUDIENCESCAPACITYTOIDENTIFYUNCANNY
REALISTICALLYCRAFTEDDOLLSTOILLUSTRATETHE FROMAREALHUMANWHICHACCORDINGTO ARTEFACTSWITHINTHEANIMATIONOFHUMAN
POINT4HEDOLLSWEREINTENTIONALLYDESIGNED THISTHEORYISTHEAESTHETICIDEAL4HISIS LIKECHARACTERS%VENWHENlLMSFEATURED
TOFOOLPEOPLEINTOBELIEVINGTHATTHEY MOREDIFlCULTTOACHIEVETHANITSOUNDS CHARACTERSTHATWERECLEARLYNOTHUMAN
WERE@REALANDTHENEGATIVEEMOTIONAL HOWEVERAND ASWESHALLDISCUSSSHORTLY SUCHAS!VATAR AUDIENCESDEMONSTRATED
!VATAR
!VATAR AUDIENCESDEMONSTRATED
RESPONSETOTHISMIMICKEDREALITYWASTHE POTENTIALLYmAWEDASAMEANSOFJUDGING THATTHEYCOULDCONTINUETOlNDCHARACTERS
UNCANNYFEELING)TWASLARGELYFROMTHIS THEAESTHETICOFANANIMATEDCHARACTER UNSETTLINGWHENTHElLMMAKERSINTENTION
PREMISETHAT-ORIDEVELOPEDTHE5NCANNY WASTOSITUATETHECHARACTERSWITHIN
6ALLEYTHEORYASAMEANSOFEVALUATINGTHE /NEOFTHECLASSICEXAMPLESOFUNCANNY EMPIRICALREALITY)NOTHERWORDSTHE.AVI
REALISMOFHUMANOIDROBOTSORANDROIDS  ANIMATEDCHARACTERSOFTCITEDINTHE OF!VATARHADREALISTICMOVEMENTCAPTURED
4HECONNECTIONBETWEENTHEREALISTICALLY ANIMATIONSTUDIESLITERATUREIS&INAL FROMACTORS ANDREALISTICFORMANDTEXTURE
CRAFTEDDOLLSDISCUSSEDBY&REUDANDTHE &ANTASYTHE3PIRITS7ITHIN;=4HISATTEMPT WHICHBROUGHTTHEMCLOSERTOEMPIRICAL
ANDROIDSOF-ORIISCLEARnBOTHARTEFACTS ATPHOTOREALISTICHUMANSWASWIDELY REALITYANDPROVIDEDAUDIENCESWITHREASONS
SEEKTOFOOLTHESPECTATORINTOACCEPTING PANNEDBYCRITICSPRIMARILYDUETOITS TOlNDFAULTINTHEIRPRESENTATION
THEMASAUTHENTIC4HE@VALLEYOFTHE UNCANNYCHARACTERS4HREEYEARSLATERMORE
5NCANNY6ALLEYTHEORY-ORIPREDICTEDWAS ADVANCEDTECHNOLOGIESANDTECHNIQUES
THEPOINTATWHICHANANDROIDBECOMES UNDERPINNEDTHEPRODUCTIONOF4HE0OLAR
HIGHLYHUMAN LIKEINAPPEARANCEBUT %XPRESS;=(ERETHEMOTION CAPTURED
LACKSSOMESUBTLEYETCRUCIAL ELEMENTS PERFORMANCESOFACTORSSUCHAS4OM(ANKS

!VATAR;=¥4WENTIETH#ENTURY&OX
4HEIMPORTANTPOINTHEREISTHESITUATION
OFTHE#')CHARACTERSWITHINANAPPARENT
EMPIRICALREALITY4OCOMEBACKTO&REUDIT
ISCLEARTHATCONTEXTCANNOTBEDETACHED
FROMOURAESTHETICEXPERIENCEOFTHE
UNCANNY&REUDTELLSUSTHATWElNDOBJECTS
UNCANNYONLYINRELATIONTOTHEREALITYIN
WHICHTHEYEXIST)NTHISSENSEOBJECTS
WITHINIMAGINEDWORLDSARENOTNECESSARILY
METWITHTHEUNCANNYRESPONSETHATIS
MUCHMORELIKELYTOOCCURWHENOBJECTSARE
PLACEDWITHINOUREMPIRICALREALITYAS&REUD
EXPLAINS
&IG0OTENTIALPLACEMENTOFANIMATEDFEATURESALONGTHEPATHTO5NCANNY6ALLEY

MEDIAEDUCATIONJOURNAL
 

h!MONGTHEMANYLIBERTIESTHATTHE HASSHOWNTHATNON HUMANAPPEARANCE ANEXAMPLE4HEANIMATORSHERECLEARLY

CREATIVEWRITERCANALLOWHIMSELFIS
THATOFCHOOSINGWHETHERTOPRESENT
AWORLDTHATCONFORMSWITHTHE
READERSFAMILIARREALITYORONETHAT
HUMANAPPEARANCEWITHTHEABILITY
ISMOREAPPEALING3CHNEIDERETAL;=
ARGUEDTHATTHEhSAFESTCOMBINATIONFORA
CHARACTERDESIGNERSEEMSTOBEACLEARLY
NON
MOVEMENTOFTHECHARACTERSCAPTUREDFROM
DIDNOTAIMFORPHOTOREALISM4HESTYLE
ISADESCENDENTOFTHETRADITIONAL$ISNEY
CELANIMATIONAESTHETIC.EITHERISTHE
INSOMEWAYDEVIATESFROMIT7E TOEMOTELIKEAHUMANv4HISIMPLIESA REALITY/NTOPOFTHISTHECHARACTERSARE
ACCEPTHISCHOICEINEVERYCASE4HE CONSCIOUSEFFORTONTHEPARTOFCHARACTER CLEARLYNOTMEANTTOBEHUMANBEINGSBUT
WORLDOFTHEFAIRYTALEFOREXAMPLE ANIMATORSTOAIMFORANEFFECTIVEDESIGNFOR ANTHROPOMORPHISEDANIMALS!NDYETTHESE
ABANDONSTHEBASISOFREALITYRIGHT THECHARACTERRATHERTHANAPHOTOREALISTIC CHARACTERSAREMOREBELIEVABLYHUMANIN
FROMTHESTARTANDOPENLYCOMMITS APPEARANCE4HEPOSITIVEIMPACTOFGOOD THEIREMOTIONSINTERACTIONSANDSTORIES
ITSELFTOTHEACCEPTANCEOFANIMISTIC DESIGNRATHERTHANREALISM ONPERCEPTION THANlLMSSUCHAS&INAL&ANTASYTHE3PIRITS
BELIEFSvP HASBEENDEMONSTRATED&ORINSTANCEONE 7ITHINOR"EOWULF4HEAUDIENCEOF4HE
"EOWULF
"EOWULF4HEAUDIENCEOF4HE
STUDYSHOWEDTHATTOYROBOTSWERERECEIVED ,ION+ING
,ION+INGNEVERQUESTIONEDTHEVISUAL
)TISTHISIDEAnTHATTHEINTENTIONOFTHE ASMORELIKEABLETHANPHOTOGRAPHSOFREAL REALISMOFTHECHARACTERSnTHEYWILFULLY
DIRECTORCANMANIPULATEWHETHERANOBJECT PEOPLE;=)NTHISEXAMPLETHECONCEPT SUSPENDEDTHEIRDISBELIEFANDACCEPTED
APPEARSUNCANNYORNOTnTHATLEADSUSTO OFAN5NCANNY6ALLEYWASCONFRONTED THECHARACTERSASTHEYWERE)TTHEREFORE
ANOTHERWAYOFTHINKINGABOUTTHEDESIGN WITHTHEARGUMENTTHATWHATMAYEXIST SEEMSABITSTRANGETHATACCORDINGTOTHE
OFANIMATEDCHARACTERS7HENTHEDIRECTORS ISINFACTAN5NCANNY#LIFFWITHTHEMOST 5NCANNY6ALLEYTHEORYSEE&IG 4HE,ION
INTENTIONISTOBRIDGETHE5NCANNY6ALLEY LIKEABLECHARACTERSBEINGTHOSEWHICHWE +ING
+INGWOULDSOMEHOWBECONSIDEREDLESS
THEEMPHASISISONAWORLDTHATALIGNSWITH lNDAPPEALINGRATHERTHANTHOSEWHICHARE @HUMAN
LIKETHAN4HE0OLAR%XPRESSOR
0OLAR%XPRESS
0OLAR%XPRESSOR
OUREMPIRICALREALITY"UTMOSTANIMATION MOREHUMAN
LIKEINAPPEARANCE!NOTHER !VATAR
!VATAR
ISUNCONCERNEDWITHEMPIRICALREALITY PROPOSEDCONCEPTISTHE5NCANNY7ALL;=
INSTEADHAVINGANEMPHASISONIMAGINED )NTHISALTERNATETHEORYTHE5NCANNY
REALITYGRANTINGANIMATORSTHEFREEDOMTO 6ALLEYCANNEVERBEBRIDGEDBECAUSEAS
EXPLOREHUMANEXPERIENCEWITHOUTBEING TECHNOLOGYADVANCESANDALLOWSEVERMORE
OVERLYFOCUSEDONVISUALREPRESENTATION HUMAN
LIKEAPPEARANCESANDMOVEMENTS
ANDACCURACY7ITHTHELATTERAPPROACH THEABILITYOFOBSERVERSTODETECTEVER

THEINTENTIONISTOSUSPENDAUDIENCE SMALLERDIFFERENCESBETWEENREALANDVIRTUAL
DISBELIEFTHROUGHTHEDESIGNOFENGAGING HUMANSADVANCESALSO7EENCOUNTERED
ANIMATEDCHARACTERSTHATTRIGGEREMOTIONAL THISNOTIONEARLIERWHENDISCUSSINGTHE 4HE,ION+ING;=¥$ISNEY
RESPONSESRATHERTHAN@FOOLANAUDIENCE CONTINUEDUNCANNYRESPONSESTOMOTION

INTOBELIEVINGTHATTHEANIMATEDCHARACTER CAPTUREDlLMDESPITERAPIDIMPROVEMENTS 3URELYANOTHERMEANSOFJUDGINGTHE
EXISTSINOURREALITY INTECHNOLOGY AESTHETICSOFANIMATEDCHARACTERSIS
THEREFOREREQUIRED7HYSHOULD4HE,ION
The uncanny and suspension of )NCREASINGLYTHENDESIGNKNOWLEDGEHAS +INGBECONSIDERED@LESSAMBITIOUSTHAN
disbelief INFORMEDASHIFTAWAYFROMTHEORIGINAL lLMSTHATTRYTOMIMICEMPIRICALREALITY
)NANIMATIONSTUDIESITHASBEENARGUED 5NCANNY6ALLEYTHEORYFORROBOTS;=AND WHENINFACTTHEAMBITIONOFCAPTURING
THATTHEORIGINAL5NCANNY6ALLEYTHEORY CHARACTERS;=TOEMPHASIZETHENEEDTO WHATITMEANSTOBEHUMANISMUCHMORE
nWHICHCOMPARESPERCEIVEDFAMILIARITY MAKEAESTHETICALLYPLEASINGCHARACTERS DARING)N&IGANALTERNATIVEAPPROACH
WITHHUMAN
LIKENESSnCANBEBETTER RATHERTHANCONVINCINGREPLICATIONS ISPROPOSEDINORDERTOUNDERSTANDTHE
UNDERSTOODIFFAMILIARITYISREPLACEDWITH 5LTIMATELYWECANMAKETWOOBSERVATIONS AESTHETICQUALITYOFANIMATION)TIS
THEIDEAOFAESTHETICENGAGEMENT;=4HIS THATSTRIVINGFORPHOTOREALISMWILLNOT SUGGESTEDTHATHUMAN
LIKENESSASA
ALIGNSWITHTHECONCEPTOFSUSPENSIONOF NECESSARILYLEADTOCHARACTERSTHAT MEASUREOFAMBITIONBEREPLACEDWITH
DISBELIEFWHICHMAYBEMOREAPPROPRIATELY VIEWERSWILLlNDMOREAPPEALINGAND DEPICTIONOFHUMANITYnTHEEXTENTTO
USEDTODESCRIBEHOWAPPEALINGACHARACTER THATBELIEVABLECHARACTERSAREINFACT WHICHTHEANIMATORSHAVESUCCEEDEDIN
ISBASEDONTHEIRHUMAN
LIKEEMOTIONSAND THEPRODUCTOFDELIBERATEDESIGNRATHER CAPTURINGTHEHUMANCONDITIONWITHIN
BEHAVIOURSRATHERTHANTHEIRPHOTOREALISTIC THANREPLICATION2EGARDLESSOFWHETHER THEIRlLMS!SWECANSEEASCHARACTERS
APPEARANCE)NANIMATIONTHEREFORE THE5NCANNY6ALLEYCANBEBRIDGEDOR BECOMEMOREBELIEVABLYHUMANTHE
THEAESTHETICSOFCHARACTERSAREBETTER NOTPROPONENTSOFTHEPUSHTOWARDS AESTHETICEXPERIENCEOFTHEAUDIENCE
UNDERSTOODTHROUGHCHARACTERAPPEALAND PHOTOREALISMARESOMEWHATMISSINGTHE IMPROVES4HEREISNOVALLEYHEREnTHIS
BELIEVABILITYRATHERTHANVISUALAPPEARANCE POINT2ECALLTHESTUDYTHATDEMONSTRATED GRAPHSIMPLESHOWSTHATBYFOLLOWINGTHE
ANDFAMILIARITY)NDISCUSSINGAESTHETIC AGREATERAPPEALOFTOYROBOTSTHANREAL DESIGNPRINCIPLESFORANIMATIONINORDER
ENGAGEMENT"UTLERAND*OSCHKO;= USED HUMANS!UDIENCESLIKECHARACTERSTHAT TOPRODUCECHARACTERSTHATAREBELIEVABLY
ACASESTUDYOFTHE)NCREDIBLES;=AND AREDESIGNEDTOGRABOURATTENTION4HEY HUMANTHEAUDIENCEEXPERIENCEWILLBE
&INAL&ANTASYTHE3PIRITS7ITHINWITH ENJOYEXAGGERATIONnTHEMETHODOF ENHANCEDAPPROPRIATELY)NPARTICULAR
THEFORMERlLMBEINGPOSITEDASAMORE CARICATURETHAT7ALT$ISNEYDESCRIBEDASA NOTETHATAMIXOFDIFFERENTlLMSCOULD
POSITIVEAESTHETICEXPERIENCEDESPITETHE FORMOFHYPERREALISM;='RAPHICSEXPERTS POTENTIALLYBEPLOTTEDALONGTHISGRAPH
LESSPHOTOREALISTICAPPEARANCEOFTHE MAYALLOWANIMATORSTOCROSSTHEVALLEY 4HOSETHATAIMTOACHIEVEEMPIRICALREALISM
CHARACTERS BUTALLTHATWEWOULDENDUPWITHARE ARENOTNECESSARILYWEIGHTEDTOTHELOWER
CHARACTERSTHATAREMERELYSIMULATIONSOF ENDOFTHEGRAPH4HEMAKERSOF!VATAR
!VATAR
!VATAR
&URTHERCRITIQUEOFTHEORIGINAL5NCANNY HUMANBEINGS7HENDESIGNEDACCORDING FORINSTANCEAIMEDFOREMPIRICALREALISM
6ALLEYTHEORYISPREVALENTINTHELITERATURE TODESIGNPRINCIPLESANIMATEDCHARACTERS ANDTECHNOLOGICALACCOMPLISHMENTASWELL
&OREXAMPLEINVESTIGATIONINTOTHE CANBEMUCHMOREHUMAN4AKEANOTHER ASHUMANSTORYANDRELATIONSHIPS!SA
UNCANNYAPPEARANCEOFGAMECHARACTERS $ISNEYANIMATIONn4HE,ION+ING;=nAS RESULTITCANBECONSIDEREDANAESTHETICALLY

MEDIAEDUCATIONJOURNAL


#HANG* "EOWULF;ONLINE=

"EOWULF
"EOWULF;ONLINE=
!VAILABLEFROMWWWVARIETYCOMREVIEW
6%REFCATID;!CCESSED
3EPTEMBERTH=
+IM*-ARSNEEDSMOMSAND
THEUNCANNYVALLEY;ONLINE=!VAILABLE
FROMHTTPWWWHUFlNGTONPOSTCOM
JONATHAN
KIMMARS
NEEDS
MOMS

UCANNY
VALLEY?B?HTML;!CCESSED
3EPTEMBERTH=
7ARNER"ROTHERS4HE0OLAR%XPRESS53
4HE0OLAR%XPRESS
4HE0OLAR%XPRESS53
 ;ONLINE=!VAILABLEFROMIMDBCOM
MEDIARMTT
&IG0OTENTIALPLACEMENTOFANIMATEDFEATURESWHENTHEHUMANREALISMOFTHE ;!CCESSED!UGUSTTH=
CHARACTERSISCONSIDEREDAGAINSTTHEAESTHETICEXPERIENCEOFTHElLM 4WENTIETH#ENTURY&OX!VATAR53
!VATAR
!VATAR53
 ;ONLINE=!VAILABLEFROMIMDBCOM
ENGAGINGlLMINTERMSOFTHEHUMAN
LIKE AREBYTHEVISUALAPPEARANCEOFTHEWORLD MEDIARMTT
EMOTIONSANDEXPERIENCESDEPICTEDDESPITE NOTHOWCONVINCEDWEAREBYTHEDEPTH ;!CCESSED!UGUSTTH=
ITSPOTENTIALUNCANNYCHARACTERS0ERHAPS ANDQUALITYOFHUMANEMOTIONIMITATEDBY "UTLER-AND*OSCHKO, @&INAL
MOSTIMPORTANTLYTHOUGHlLMSSUCHAS 0IXARSVIRTUALPUPPETS7HILEITISINDEED &ANTASY 4HE)NCREDIBLESULTRA
REALISTIC
&ANTASYOR
4HE,ION+ING
4HE,ION+INGAND 4OY3TORY
4OY3TORYnTWOOFTHE LEGITIMATETOLOOKAT#')WITHACRITICALEYE ANIMATIONAESTHETICENGAGEMENTANDTHE
MOSTHIGHLYPRAISEDANIMATEDFEATURElLMS TOWARDSITSSUCCESSATACHIEVINGEMPIRICAL UNCANNYVALLEYIN!NIMATION3TUDIES
OFALLTIMEnCANBECLEARLYHIGHLIGHTEDAS

SUCHONTHISGRAPH4HESElLMSAREAMONG
REALITYTHESEPARATIONOF#')FROMOTHER PP
FORMSOFANIMATIONPUTS#')ANIMATORSAT 4HE)NCREDIBLES53 DIR""IRD
4HE)NCREDIBLES
4HE)NCREDIBLES53 DIR""IRD
THEVERYBESTATREmECTINGHUMANITYIN ADISTINCTANDUNFAIRDISADVANTAGE&ILMS 3CHNEIDER%ETAL @%XPLORINGTHE
THEIRCHARACTERPERFORMANCES7OULDITNOT SUCHAS4OY3TORY;=SEE&IG SHOULD UNCANNYVALLEYWITH*APANESEVIDEOGAME
THEREFOREBEAPPROPRIATETOSEECHARACTERS INSTEADBEEXAMINEDINTERMSOFTHEQUALITY CHARACTERSIN0ROCEEDINGSOFTHE$I'2!
SUCHASTHESEASTHEAESTHETICIDEALRATHER OFTHEHUMANPERFORMANCESEXHIBITEDBY #ONFERENCEPP

THANTHEHYPOTHETICALHUMANSIMULANTOF THEIRCHARACTERSRATHERTHANVISUALlDELITY "ARTNECK#ETAL @)STHE
THE5NCANNY6ALLEY6ISUALAPPEARANCEIS OFTHERENDERINGORINTHECASEOFANIMATED UNCANNYVALLEYANUNCANNYCLIFFINTH
NOTASRELEVANTnVARIATIONINVISUALSTYLE FEATURESTHATMAKEUSEOFMOTION
CAPTURE )%%%)NTERNATIONAL#ONFERENCEON2OBOT
ANDANIMATIONMETHODISALLOWEDBECAUSE THEACCURACYOFTHEREPLICATIONOF@REAL (UMAN)NTERACTIVE#OMMUNICATION2/

THEIDEALANIMATEDCHARACTERISONETHAT HUMANMOVEMENT -!.*EJU3OUTH+OREAPP

ENCOURAGESTHEAUDIENCETOWILFULLY 4INWELL!AND'RIMSHAW-
SUSPENDTHEIRDISBELIEF @"RIDGINGTHEUNCANNYANIMPOSSIBLE
TRAVERSE-INDTREKPP

Conclusion (ANSON$ %XPLORINGTHE
/URACCEPTANCEOFTHEWORLDTHATSURROUNDS AESTHETICRANGEFORHUMANOIDROBOTSIN
ANANIMATEDCHARACTERISKEYTOOUR 0ROCEEDINGSOFTHE)##3#OG3CI
,ONG
ABILITYTOSUSPENDDISBELIEFANDRECEIVE 3YMPOSIUM4OWARD3OCIAL-ECHANISMSOF
THECHARACTERPERFORMANCEASSOMETHING !NDROID3CIENCEPPn
FAMILIARTOUS7ITH4OY3TORY
4OY3TORYFOR 4OY3TORY;=¥$ISNEY0IXAR 3LOAN2*3ETAL@#HOREOGRAPHING
INSTANCE$ARLEY PROPOSEDTHATITCOULDBE

EMOTIONALFACIALEXPRESSIONS#OMPUTER
CONSIDEREDASTEPTOWARDSPHOTOREALISM Notes !NIMATIONAND6IRTUAL7ORLDS
 
WHENCOMPAREDWITHPREVIOUS$ISNEY $ARLEY! 6ISUAL$IGITAL#ULTURE PP

ANIMATIONSBUTTHATULTIMATELYITIS 3URFACE0LAYAND3PECTACLEIN.EW-EDIA 4HOMAS&AND*OHNSTON/ 4HE
STILLJUSTACARTOON(EGOESONTOSTATE 'ENRES2OUTLEDGE.EW9ORK )LLUSIONOF,IFE$ISNEY!NIMATION.EW9ORK
THATTHESTORIESOF0IXARlLMSAREhRATHER -ALPAS* 2EALISM-OVEMENTSIN $ISNEY%DITIONS
UNEXCEPTIONALPARTICULARLYTOTHOSEWHO -ODERN!RT ,ONDON4ATE0UBLISHING 4HE,ION+ING53 DIR2!LLERS
4HE,ION+ING
4HE,ION+ING53 DIR2!LLERS
AREFAMILIARWITH$ISNEYCARTOONSvBUTTHAT -ORI- @"UKIMINOTANI%NERGY
%NERGY
%NERGY AND2-INKOFF7ALT$ISNEY0ICTURES
THEhIMAGESTHEMSELVESARENOTvP !S  PPn $ISNEY%NTERPRISES)NC4HE
THISANALYSISINCLUDES4OY3TORYSTILLONE
4OY3TORY
4OY3TORYSTILLONE &REUD3;= 4HE5NCANNY
4HE5NCANNY
4HE5NCANNY ,ION+ING
,ION+ING53 ;ONLINE=!VAILABLE
OFTHEMOSTHIGHLYREGARDEDFEATURElLMS ,ONDON0ENGUIN FROMIMDBCOMMEDIARM
OFALLTIMELISTEDASINTHE)-$BTOP &INAL&ANTASYTHE3PIRITS7ITHIN53 TT;!CCESSED!UGUSTTH=
ATTHETIMEOFWRITING ITAPPEARS *APAN DIR(3AKAGUCHIAND- 4OY3TORY53 DIR*,ASSITER
4OY3TORY
4OY3TORY53 DIR*,ASSITER
RATHERUNFAIRLYDISMISSIVEOFTHEQUALITY
OFTHECHARACTERPERFORMANCESWHICHDO
OWEMUCHTO$ISNEY WHILEEMPHASISING
3AKAKIBARA )-$"COM)NC)-$B#HARTS
4HE0OLAR%XPRESS53 DIR2
4HE0OLAR%XPRESS
4HE0OLAR%XPRESS53 DIR2 )-$B4OP;ONLINE=!VAILABLEFROM
:EMECKIS IMDBCOMCHARTTOP;!CCESSED!UGUST
THEIMPORTANCEOFTHE#')RENDERING !LDRED* @&ROMSYNTHESPIANTO TH=
QUALITY)NOTHERWORDSBECAUSETHElLM AVATARRE
FRAMINGTHEDIGITALHUMANIN 4OY3TORY53 DIR,5NKRICH
ISAFULLY$#')FEATUREPHOTOREALISM &INAL&ANTASY
&INAL&ANTASYAND 4HE0OLAR%XPRESSIN $ISNEY0IXAR4OY3TORY 
4OY3TORY
4OY3TORY 
BECOMESANASSUMEDBENCHMARKFOR -EDIASCAPE7INTER ;ONLINE=!VAILABLEFROMIMDBCOMMEDIA
QUALITY!CCORDINGTO$ARLEYSUSPENSION
OFDISBELIEFRESTSONHOWCONVINCEDWE
"EOWULF53 DIR2:EMECKIS
"EOWULF
"EOWULF53 DIR2:EMECKIS RMTT;!CCESSED
-ARS.EEDS-OMS53 DIR37ELLS
-ARS.EEDS-OMS
-ARS.EEDS-OMS53 DIR37ELLS !UGUSTTH=
MEDIAEDUCATIONJOURNAL