Meeting The Needs of Children With Autism Spectrum Disorder: Early Intervention Experiences of Filipino Parents

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

MEETING THE NEEDS OF CHILDREN WITH

AUTISM SPECTRUM DISORDER: EARLY


INTERVENTION EXPERIENCES OF
FILIPINO PARENTS

PSYCHOLOGY AND EDUCATION: A MULTIDISCIPLINARY JOURNAL


2023
Volume: 11
Pages: 334-340
Document ID: 2023PEMJ965
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.8191312
Manuscript Accepted: 2023-26-7
Psych Educ, 2023, 11: 334-340, Document ID:2023 PEMJ965, doi:10.5281/zenodo.8191312, ISSN 2822-4353
Research Article

Meeting the Needs of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder:


Early Intervention Experiences of Filipino Parents
Louise Leosala*
For affiliations and correspondence, see the last page.
Abstract
Many studies have described family experiences on raising a child with Autism Spectrum Disorder
(ASD) for most of the population; however, there is less emphasis on the impact of autism in
culturally diverse families, specifically in the Philippine setting. This phenomenological study
explored the lived experiences of Filipino parents on meeting the needs of children with ASD and
how they cope with its demands. Using a semi-structured interview, data were gathered from 10
Filipino parents of children ages 3 to 8 years with ASD who are receiving early childhood
intervention. Interviews were transcribed and data were analyzed which resulted in 10 major themes
(a) Meeting the Child’s Needs, (b) My Unique Child, (c) Sense of Fulfilment, (d) A Challenging
Task, (e) Supportive Service Delivery, (f) Barriers on Service Delivery, (g) Changing Family
Dynamics, (h) Seeking for Information, (i) Getting Involved, and (j) Move from Denial to
Acceptance which were categorized into textural and structural descriptions of the phenomenon. This
study concluded that the parents lived through unique experiences and adapted coping mechanisms
which were distinct to each family as every child with ASD presented with unique needs.

Keywords: children with autism spectrum disorder, early intervention, filipino parents, lived experiences

Introduction After the diagnosis of ASD is confirmed, appropriate


treatment and evidence-based interventions need to be
determined which may include a variety of approaches
Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) refers to a broad such as occupational therapy, speech therapy, physical
range of conditions typically characterized by deficits therapy, special education, and vocational training,
in social interaction, communication, and by restricted, among other nonpharmacologic interventions (Persico
repetitive, and stereotyped patterns of behavior et al., 2019). In addition, it would be necessary to
(Yochum, 2016). This spectrum of deficits which establish supports within the home and community for
appears in early childhood may range from very mild the child and the family to gain additional help and
to severe. Two children with the same diagnosis of care. As each child with Autism presents with different
ASD may behave differently and may have vastly strengths, needs, and behavioral issues; therefore, each
different skills, levels of cognition, and sensory or family has their own specific requirements that need to
medical needs. Some children exhibit relatively mild be met to provide for their child.
symptoms that are present in individuals with high-
functioning autism. while others display severe Early childhood are important years in any child's life.
inability to communicate, have cognitive impairments, During the first years of schooling, children are still
and challenging behaviors. totally dependent on their families specifically their
parents to safeguard them. Parents are most probably
In the past, Autism was a relatively rare disorder, the first people who are closely involved with their
occurring in 4 to 5 cases per 10,000 in the 1940s and child’s education throughout their entire school years.
increasing to 10 per 10,000 in the 1990s. By 2022, They are likely to be the most affected by the
approximately one out of 100 children are diagnosed outcomes of any schooling decisions (Mitchell, 2013).
with autism spectrum disorder around the world. Many Even if children are in the care of the teachers for
studies have outlined the increasing number of many hours, they always return to their family, where
children diagnosed with ASD over time within and much of the learning and development happen. When
across sociodemographic groups (Fombonne, 2018; teachers work with families and support them in their
Zeidan et al., 2022). With the rise in ASD diagnoses goals, a huge impact is made on the lives of the
and its lifelong duration, early intervention is children. It is important to provide for children with
important. It has been discussed by Maksimović ASD a sense of continuity between home and school
(2023) that early treatment is a key to improving experiences, which can be ensured through
communication, social skills, and decreasing partnerships between the early intervention service
challenging behaviors for children with ASD. providers and the parents (Darling-Hammond, 2020).

Louise Leosala 334/340


Psych Educ, 2023, 11: 334-340, Document ID:2023 PEMJ965, doi:10.5281/zenodo.8191312, ISSN 2822-4353
Research Article

Participants of the Study


This home-school collaboration is critical in making
intervention decisions for the child. The participants in this study were selected because
they have lived the experiences being investigated and
Many studies have described family experiences on were willing to share their thoughts about their
raising a child with ASD for most of the population; experiences. Ten Filipino parents were chosen as
however, there is less emphasis on the impact of participants using purposive sampling. The following
autism in culturally diverse families, specifically in the were the inclusion criteria for the participants: (a)
Philippine setting and how the parents specifically Filipino couple, (b) Parent of a child with a diagnosis
adapt to raising a child with autism. At present, the of or at risk for ASD, between the ages of 3 years and
continuous increase of the prevalence of ASD creates a 8 years, (c) Parent’s child had a diagnosis of ASD for
need for educational professionals to understand and at least 6 months; (d) Parent’s child is receiving any of
provide responsive services that meet the unique needs the early childhood intervention such as Special
of each family, who often face personal, financial, and Education, Occupational Therapy, Speech Therapy,
emotional challenges.The researcher aims to contribute Physical Therapy, during the time of research data
to Psychology and Education by exploring what collection.
Filipino parents experience in having a child with ASD
in the early years of intervention through this Instrumentation and Validation of the Instrument
phenomenological research. By understanding how
Filipino parents experience life with their child with Three sources of data were utilized in data gathering
ASD and gain services for their child, professionals which were (a) parent interviews, (b) observations
can provide individualized services and improve through field notes, and (c) documents. A semi-
structured interview guide was used for the parent
supports that are relevant and responsive to the unique
needs of each family. interviews. Observations were recorded as field notes.
Field notes were detailed written descriptions of what
Research Questions was observed during the interview process. As much
detail as possible were recorded including direct
This study specifically sought to answer the following quotes and non-verbal responses of the participants.
questions: Documents were also used to support the data obtained
from interviews and observations. Accepted
1. What is the lived experience of Filipino parents of documents include a referral from the developmental
children with Autism Spectrum Disorder in the early pediatrician, Individualized Education Plan (IEP),
years of intervention? Initial Evaluation reports, and Progress Reports. The
2. How do parents cope with the demands of having a use of multiple data sources parent interviews,
child with Autism Spectrum Disorder in the early observations through field notes, and documents
years of intervention? provided for triangulation of the data.

Pilot tests were performed prior to data collection to


Methodology ascertain that the interview questions align with the
research questions and to locate any problems with the
interview procedures. The pilot study also provided an
A qualitative research methodology specifically opportunity to become familiar with the use of the
phenomenology was used in capturing the experiences recording equipment and interview procedures. To
of participants and facilitating an open dialogue with
verify the efficacy of the interview questions, the
Filipino parents of children with ASD. The purpose of questions were presented in English and Filipino to 2
conducting a phenomenological study is to describe
bilingual parents to assure that questions are clear in
and interpret the experiences of participants to
both languages. Revisions on the questions were made
understand the meaning of the experience. The basis of after the pilot tests.
phenomenology is that there are multiple ways of
interpreting the same experience or event, and that the Revised interview questions were subjected to
meaning of the experience to each participant is what validation of experts in the field of qualitative
is used as primary data. A phenomenological study research, neurodevelopmental disorders specifically
focuses more on the consciousness of human ASD, special educators, and therapists in the early
experiences (Neubauer et al., 2019). intervention setting. These experts provided feedback
and recommendations for validity and reliability. The

Louise Leosala 335/340


Psych Educ, 2023, 11: 334-340, Document ID:2023 PEMJ965, doi:10.5281/zenodo.8191312, ISSN 2822-4353
Research Article

interview with the participants commenced after the


interview questions were validated by experts.To
ensure validity of the participant’s responses in the
interviews, the researcher utilized member checking
after each interview. The researcher asked the
participants to review interview responses as repeated
by the researcher, and the participants confirmed. The
researcher summarized notes at the end of the contained an introduction about the researcher,
interview to check whether the notes accurately reflect background information with the purpose of the study,
the point of view of the participants. procedures, risks and benefits, statement of
confidentiality, voluntary nature of the study, and a
Procedures of the Study statement of consent. The researcher also obtained the
permission of the participants regarding audio and
The p articip an t s were r ecru ited thro ugh video recording of the one-on-one interview for
recommendations from selected private schools with accurate transcription of the responses. All audio
an early intervention program for children with ASD. records of the research interviews were coded to
Initial contact was done through online messaging to ensure anonymity and confidentiality of the
arrange a meeting with the participants and to explain participants’ data.
the details of the study. When the parents expressed
their willingness to take part in the study, the one-on-
Results and Discussion
one interview sessions were arranged at a location and
time agreed upon by the parent and the researcher.
Bracketing, the initial stage in the phenomenological
Before the interview, the consent form was explained analysis, was done by reporting of the researcher’s
to each participant. Two separate interviews were personal experiences in the clinical and special
conducted with each lasting approximately 30-45 education settings in relation to the phenomenon being
minutes per participant. The interviews were spaced at studied. Prior to presenting the data gathered, the
an interval of three days. This process allowed the researcher provided a full description of her personal
researcher to establish a more authentic relationship experiences to set them aside to ensure a fresh
with the participants and allowed the participants to perspective of the phenomenon and to direct the focus
fully explore the experience more. Each of the two to the participants and the phenomenon that they have
interviews had a specific focus: (a) details of the experienced.
experience of having a child with ASD and (b)
interactions with early intervention service providers. Horizontalization was done by presenting a list of
Observation through field notes were used to help significant statements from the interviews which were
describe the environment and the reactions of the noteworthy in answering the central questions of the
parents. The researcher took time immediately after study. These statements were treated of equal value in
the interview to write the observations in the field describing the participants’ experiences of the
notes. All interviews were transcribed. phenomenon. Theme clustering was done by
analyzing, outlining, and grouping the significant
Qualitative Analysis statements into larger units of information called
themes. After a detailed examination of the significant
Moustakas’s (1994) seven-step phenomenological data
statements and the entirety of the verbatim responses
analyzing procedure was utilized for the treatment and
shared by the participants, the researcher was able to
analysis of data in this study. The goal of the analysis
identify 10 theme clusters which were divided into
was to discover patterns in the participant responses.
textural themes and structural themes to answer the
Specific data elements were organized and synthesized
central questions of the study.
to derive the patterns and ideas that will form the basis
of the conclusions.

Ethical Considerations

Ethical standards were maintained throughout the


course of this study. An informed consent form was
obtained from all the participants. The consent form

Louise Leosala 336/340


Psych Educ, 2023, 11: 334-340, Document ID:2023 PEMJ965, doi:10.5281/zenodo.8191312, ISSN 2822-4353
Research Article

Textural Themes: As to what parents of children


with Autism Spectrum Disorder experienced in
Early Intervention

Theme 1: Meeting the Child’s Needs

After the diagnosis of ASD is confirmed by the


parents, it was a necessity to meet the child’s needs by
first establishing support within the home, as the
parents are the closest social system of the child. As
each child with ASD presented with different strengths
and needs, so as each of the parents had their own
ways of becoming involved to meet the needs of their
child with ASD. Some of the participants provided the
necessary care for their children by becoming full-time
parents while the others met their child’s needs
primarily by working. The division of roles of mother
and father on single-income families was also evident
from the responses in the study, where fathers were
geared towards being providers and mothers were
inclined to being hands-on parents.

Theme 2: My Unique Child

Parents have described their child both positively and


negatively, as each child with ASD presented with
unique characteristics. Parents have positively
described their child with ASD by recounting their
personal strengths and abilities. The parents also
described their child with ASD through the range of
Theme clustering was done by analyzing, outlining, impairments associated with the diagnosis which is
and grouping the significant statements into larger characterized by impairments in reciprocal social
units of information called themes. After a detailed interaction and communication and the presence of
examination of the significant statements and the stereotyped behaviors, restricted interests, and
entirety of the verbatim responses shared by the activities.
participants, the researcher was able to identify 10
theme clusters which were divided into textural themes Theme 3: A Sense of Fulfilment
and structural themes to answer the central questions
of the study. Early intervention services and supports made a
positive difference in the lives of children with ASD
and their families as reported by their parents. The
interview responses have revealed the improvements
of the child with ASD which were regarded as happy
and fulfilling experiences by their parents. The parents
also felt a sense of fulfilment when they taught and
implemented the strategies at home for their child with
ASD, and when they were able to provide for their
child’s needs financially.

Theme 4: A Challenging Task

Parents reported as being stressed which was attributed


to the child's lack of reciprocity to their parents and the

Louise Leosala 337/340


Psych Educ, 2023, 11: 334-340, Document ID:2023 PEMJ965, doi:10.5281/zenodo.8191312, ISSN 2822-4353
Research Article

child's disruptive or embarrassing acts, especially in demands of everyday living in raising their children
public places. These behaviors placed restrictions on with ASD.
family activities and interactions with others. The
parents have shared notable experiences on their Theme 7: Changing Family Dynamics
child’s socially inappropriate behaviors in public
places. Unanimous responses from the parents also Change in family dynamics is a coping mechanism for
showed their difficulty in managing their child’s parents with a child with ASD. Some of the parents
behavior. The parents’ efforts to meet the needs of wanted to provide the necessary care for their children
their child with ASD also affected the families’ with ASD by becoming full-time parents; while others
finances. Parents have reported having debts and wanted to provide the needs of their children by trying
difficulty to sustain the early intervention programs to earn additional income. Parents tried to meet the
because of the hefty amount of money exhausted for child’s needs by moving from employment to being
acquiring the early intervention services needed by hands-on parents, from being one-income to becoming
their child with ASD. dual-earner families, and by lessening the time they
spent for leisure activities outside of home.
Theme 5: Supportive Service Delivery
Theme 8: Seeking for Information
Parents benefitted from on-going communication with
service providers because they remained up to date Families needed the support of professionals to be able
about their child’s development and school progress to adjust to the emotional demands of caring for a
and it increased the opportunities for them to seek the child with ASD. Parents expressed that they seek
guidance of trained service providers to assist them information from professionals such as doctors,
with concerns related to their child’s care and therapists, and teachers. They also engaged in self-
education. The parents also described the service initiated learning by reading on studies about handling
providers as supportive, knowledgeable, and children with ASD and by attending relevant talks and
competent in providing the services for their child. seminars which they could learn from. Parents also
They have expressed their satisfaction on the approach benefitted from informal, non-structured interaction
of service providers, specifically the teachers, and the with the school-based community such as with co-
therapists. Developmental trajectories have also been parents of children with ASD.
reported by parents when they sent their child with
ASD to early intervention programs. The responses Theme 9: Getting Involved
from the participants considered on-going
communication, positive approach of the service Collaboration was deemed necessary to ensure that the
providers, and developmental gains as manifestations service providers that work with the child with ASD
of a supportive service delivery. and the family agree on the goals and strategies for the
child. Parent-teacher collaboration were evident in the
Theme 6: Barriers in Service Delivery responses of the participants. Parents were also
involved in home follow-up interventions for their
Parents reported that their lack of knowledge about the children with the help of professionals.
services and management techniques for their child
with ASD and their lack of time to participate in the Theme 10: The Move from Denial to Acceptance
interventions were barriers in acquiring the services
for their child. Among the concerns of parents in the Coping strategies of parents involved efforts to face
service delivery is the lack of information and the the stressful situations being experienced. Parents
parents’ lack time to coordinate and implement initially experienced a feeling of denial when they first
services for their child. learned about their child’s diagnosis of ASD. The
feeling of anxiety also became apparent through the
Structural Themes: As to how parents coped with similar responses of the parent’s desperation and
the demands of having children with Autism expectation of immediate recovery of the child from
Spectrum Disorder in the early years of the diagnosis of ASD. Despite undergoing feelings of
intervention denial and anxiety, the parents still found ways to cope
from the feelings of distress. They have shared
Having a child with ASD often placed the parents in a optimistic realizations to positively deal with their
stressful condition. Parental stress therefore demanded child’s condition, needs, and demands. Parents also
extra effort from the parents in dealing with the looked upon having children with ASD in a spiritual

Louise Leosala 338/340


Psych Educ, 2023, 11: 334-340, Document ID:2023 PEMJ965, doi:10.5281/zenodo.8191312, ISSN 2822-4353
Research Article

approach by regarding their child as a divine for their child's interventions and parents participating
providence. The responses also showed the parent’s less in recreational activities outside home to give
emotional shift from feelings of denial and anxiety more time for the child’s needs. Personal involvement
towards positive insights on their move to adjustment of parents with their children is considered as the most
in having a child with ASD. important coping which is supported by the cultural
practice of the Filipinos where the family is regarded
Textural Description as the most important social group. Parents also cope
with the demands through seeking employment
The six theme clusters answering the first central primarily because of the economic necessity to sustain
question, what is the lived experience of parents of the needs of the child with ASD. Parents also
children with ASD in the early years of intervention, identified seeking medical and educational help from
presented the contrasting forms of parent involvement professionals who are experts with children with
on a child with ASD. Despite opposing forms of parent neurodevelopmental disabilities. Interpretation of data
involvement and division of roles of a mother and also revealed that parents tend to rely on self-learning
father in single earner families, both full-time parents due to lack of information and knowledge about
and working parents shared the same goal of providing managing their child with ASD (Hosseinpour et al.,
for the child’s various needs and demands. All the 2022). Parents have also benefitted from informal,
parents described their child with ASD both positively non-structured interaction with the school-based
by their unique strengths and negatively by the range community. In addition to dealing with the common
of impairments and unique needs brought by the multifaceted aspects of parenting, families of children
condition, which the parents have lived through. with ASD also cope with emotional strains (Al-Oran et
Consequently, parents have shared both positive and al., 2022). There is an emotional move from feelings
negative experiences in living with their child with of denial and anxiety towards adjustment which was
ASD. Positive experiences brought them feelings of expressed in the positive insights of the parents.
fulfillment which generally included witnessing the
improvements on their child, teaching the child Essence
effectively, and financing the child’s needs. On the
other hand, the negative experiences of parents which Through the scrupulous attention to details covered in
they considered challenging and difficult were the the structural and textural descriptions, the researcher
child’s socially inappropriate behaviors in public in search for universality in the target phenomenon
places, managing behavior and financial demands of came across with similar views. The participant’s
the child. Providing the financial need of the child with shared experiences eventually led the researcher to
ASD was deemed as both a fulfillment and a challenge fortify the notion that each child with autism presents
for the families. Analysis of the parent’s experiences with different strengths, impairments, and behavioral
with the service providers showed that a supportive issues; therefore, each family has their own coping
service delivery consisted of on-going communication mechanisms and specific requirements that need to be
between home and school, responsive service met to provide for their child. Parents of children with
providers (Coogle & Hanline, 2016), and ASD find it challenging to cope with the demands and
developmental gains for the child with ASD (Factor et needs of their child which requires home-school
al., 2012). Barriers in service delivery were the collaboration, follow-up interventions, seeking and
parents’ lack of knowledge in handling the child’s applying of knowledge regarding the diagnosis, and
behaviors and the lack of time to implement the sustaining financial needs. Parents of children with
intervention for their child at home (Hosseinpour et al., ASD, though confronted with the demands of their
2022). child, still hold positive insights from their experience.
They hope to provide and support the needs of their
Structural Description child as much as they can and overcome the challenges
through ways that could best help their child with
The remaining four theme clusters answering the ASD.
second central question, how do parents cope with the
demands of having children with ASD in the early Verification
years of intervention, enumerated the different coping
mechanisms of parents faced with the everyday The researcher got in touch with the participants
challenges and demands in raising their children with through personally revisiting them and through
ASD. Parents took various adjustments to meet their electronic mailing. A hard and soft copy of the
child’s needs such as halting work duties to give way interview’s verbatim transcription was given to each

Louise Leosala 339/340


Psych Educ, 2023, 11: 334-340, Document ID:2023 PEMJ965, doi:10.5281/zenodo.8191312, ISSN 2822-4353
Research Article

participant for verification. Their corrections were Linda Darling-Hammond, Lisa Flook, Channa Cook-Harvey, Brigid
Barron & David Osher (2020) Implications for educational practice
equally considered to assure accuracy and reliability of
of the science of learning and development, Applied Developmental
qualitative data. Science, 24:2, 97-140, DOI: 10.1080/10888691.2018.1537791

Maksimović, S., Marisavljević, M., Stanojević, N., Ćirović, M.,


Conclusion Punišić, S., Adamović, T., Đorđević, J., Krgović, I., & Subotić, M.
(2023). Importance of Early Intervention in Reducing Autistic
Symptoms and Speech-Language Deficits in Children with Autism
Spectrum Disorder. Children (Basel, Switzerland), 10(1), 122.
Based on the findings of the study, the following https://doi.org/10.3390/children10010122
conclusions were drawn: (1) The parents of children
with ASD experienced both positive and negative Mitchell, D. (2013). What Really Works in Special and Inclusive
experiences which are unique to each family as every Education: Using evidence-based teaching strategies (2nd ed.).
Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203105313
child with ASD presented with unique strengths and Moustakas, C. (1994). Phenomenological research methods.
needs. (2) The parents used various coping Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
mechanisms to meet the unique needs of their child
Neubauer, B. E., Witkop, C. T., & Varpio, L. (2019). How
with ASD and to positively adjust despite the phenomenology can help us learn from the experiences of
challenges and demands experienced in the early years others. Perspectives on medical education, 8(2), 90–97.
of intervention. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40037-019-0509-2

Oono, I. P., Honey, E. J., & McConachie, H. (2013). Parent-


References mediated early intervention for young children with autism spectrum
disorders (ASD). The Cochrane database of systematic reviews, (4),
CD009774. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD009774.pub2
Al-Oran, H., Khuan, L., Ying, L. P., & Hassouneh, O. (2022).
Coping Mechanism among Parents of Children with Autism Persico, A. M., Ricciardello, A., & Cucinotta, F. (2018). Chapter 24
Spectrum Disorder: A Review. Iranian journal of child - The psychopharmacology of autism spectrum disorder and Rett
neurology, 16(1), 9–17. https://doi.org/10.22037/ijcn.v16i2.31518 syndrome. Handbook of Clinical Neurology, 165, 391.
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-444-64012-3.00024-1
Coogle, C. G., and Hanline, M. F. (2016) An exploratory study of
family-centred help-giving practices in early intervention: families Yochum A. (2016). Autism Spectrum/Pervasive Developmental
of young children with autism spectrum disorder. Child & Family Disorder. Primary care, 43(2),
Social Work, 21: 249– 260. doi: 10.1111/cfs.12148. 2 85 –3 00 .h tt p s: / /do i .o rg /10 . 101 6/ j .p op .2 01 6. 01 .0 10

Factor, R. S., Rea, H. M., Dahiya, A. V., Albright, J., Ollendick, T. Zeidan, J., Fombonne, E., Scorah, J., Ibrahim, A., Durkin, M. S.,
H., Laugeson, E. A., & Scarpa, A. (2022). An Initial Pilot Study Saxena, S., Yusuf, A., Shih, A., & Elsabbagh, M. (2022). Global
Examining Child Social Skills, Caregiver Styles, and Family prevalence of autism: A systematic review update. Autism research:
Functioning in the PEERS® for Preschoolers Program for Young official journal of the International Society for Autism
Autistic Children and their Caregivers. Research in developmental Research, 15(5), 778–790. https://doi.org/10.1002/aur.2696
disabilities, 121, 104152.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ridd.2021.104152

Fombonne, E. (2018), Editorial: The rising prevalence of autism. J Affiliations and Corresponding Information
Child Psychol Psychiatr, 59:
7 1 7 - 720. ht tp s : // do i. o rg / 10 .11 11 /j c pp .1 294 1 .
Louise Leosala
De La Salle Medical and
Hosseinpour, A., Younesi, S. J., Azkhosh, M., Safi, M. H., & Health Sciences Institute - Philippines
Biglarian, A. (2022). Exploring Challenges and Needs of Parents
Providing Care to Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders: A
Qualitative Study. Iran J Psychiatry Behav Sci, 16(3).
https://doi.org/10.5812/ijpbs-127300

Louise Leosala 340/340

You might also like