Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hierarchical Coordinated Control of DC Microgrid With Wind Turbines
Hierarchical Coordinated Control of DC Microgrid With Wind Turbines
! PDC_L
voltage and, thus, the DC voltage increases. Consequently,
the wind turbines generation power should be reduced
initially by using the W-VSC and then the pitch control
mechanism of the wind turbine system.
3548
control methods.The proposed hierarchical control refers to a voltage source control strategy based on AC voltage d-q
multilevel coordination control according to the DC voltage components regulation. Because there is no power source
variation range (LlVdc) of each DC terminal as shown in Fig. 2, voltage for vector orientation, from Fig. 3(d), the voltage
which consists of three control levels. Under each control phase angle Bs used for reference frame transformation is
level, at least one converter is responsible for DC voltage achieved by integrating a constant frequency ill; rather than
control. Each DC terminal works independently and each using conventional phase-locked-loops.
converter switches its control method by monitoring its
B. The Second Control Level
own DC voltage instead of using other communication
The second control level happens during O.OS::S; III Vdcl<O. 1,
links. The three control levels and the control strategies for
corresponding to the situation that the G-VSC is not enable to
each converter under different control levels are described as
control the DC voltage under grid integration-controlled
following.
mode and islanding mode.
A. The First Control Level Under this level, the W-VSC operates at MPPT mode, the
The first control level happens during ILlVdcl<O.OS (in per G-VSC switches from DC voltage control mode to current
unit), corresponding to grid integration-uncontrolled mode. limit operation, and the BES unit must control the DC voltage
The W-VSC operates atMPPT mode. Using the stator flux within a certain level. It can be seen from Fig. 4, a hysteresis
oriented control, the decoupling control of the stator active band is used to avoid unnecessary repetitive control mode
and reactive power is achieved by regulating the q- and d-axis switching during operation. Once the DC voltage at the BES
rotor currents respectively [8]. Fig. 3(a) shows the dual unit terminal exceeds its normal variation band (±O.OS), the
closed-loop control strategy. The inner-loop regulates the BES unit regulates the charging/discharging current in order
stator current, and the outer-loop generates the active power to maintain a constant DC voltage. The DC voltage controller
reference p*opt or the active power current reference tq is also designed using a dual close-loop structure. V*deB is set
according to MPPT control which depends on the rotating at l.OS p.u. or 0.9S p.u. for DC overvoltage or undervoltage
speed Wr ofPMSG.The reactive power current reference td is conditions, respectively, as shown in Fig. 2.
set at zero in stator flux oriented reference frame.
C. The Third Control Level
The G-VSC controls the DC voltage constant. Using the
The third control level happens during 0.1 qLlvdcl<O.IS,
grid voltage oriented control, the decoupling control of the
two conditions can be considered. 0.1 ::S; LlVdc<O.IS
active and reactive power is achieved by regulating the d- and
corresponds to the situation that the battery charging power
q-axis grid currents, respectively [9]. The outer-loop DC
exceeds its rating PB_max or the SOC reaches 80% in grid
voltage controller generates the active power current
reference signal for the inner-loop current regulation as
shown in Fig. 3(b). The reactive power current reference is in
generally set at zero according to the unity power factor
(a)
control.The DC voltage reference V*deG is 1 p.u..
The BES unit is charged with constant current. State of
charge (SOC) refers to energy storage capacity, defined as the
percentage of the rest storage capacity in the rate capacity. In
order to prolong the battery life, the battery energy
management system should limit energy storage and voltage
within a certain range [10-11].The SOC is set at 40%-80% in
this paper. When the SOC reaches 80%, the charging current
is set at zero. The charging control is achieved by regulating
the duty cycle of the Bi-DCIDC as shown in Fig. 3(c).
The aim of the L-VSC is to ensure the output voltage
amplitude and frequency constant. The L-VSC uses the
Fig. 3. Vector control diagrams under the first control level (a) W-VSC (b)
Vdc
G-VSC (c) Bi-DC/DC (d) L-VSC
1.15
Level 3 Wind turbines
1.1
Level 2 BES unit
1.05
1 --Level 1--- G-VSC (a)
0.95
Level 2 BES unit
0.9
Level 3 Load
0.85
(b)
Fig. 2. Hierarchical coordinated control strategy for DC microgrid Fig. 4. Vector control diagrams for Bi-DC/DC under the second control
3549
integration-controlled and islanding modes. Under this Simulation studies are carried out according to different
situation, the wind turbines generation power should be operation conditions under three operation modes, adopting
reduced. -0.15<LlVdc::S; -0.1 corresponds to the situation that the proposed control strategies for this DC microgrid system.
the battery discharging power exceeds its rating in grid In order to simulate the conditions of SOC reaching limitation
integration-controlled and islanding modes, and load (40% and 80%), during the simulation, the charging rate and
shedding should be implemented. Moreover, the SOC discharging rate of the battery are set at 1200 times the actual
reaching 40% also need appropriate load shedding. rate. In the simulation results, the voltage and rotating speed
Load shedding flowchart is shown in Fig. 5, taking four are given using per unit value, DC bus voltage and rated
loads as an example. When discharging power exceeds its rotating speed ofPMSG are selected as base values.
power rating, the BES unit operates at current limit and load
A. Simulation in Grid Integration-uncontrolled Mode
shedding is implemented based on the load terminal DC
As shown in Fig. 7, when the simulation starts, the wind
voltage VdeL. When VdeL is below 0.85 p.u., the load with
speed (v) is 8 m/s. The wind turbines rotor speed (cor) is
lowest priority is tripped immediately. When the SOC
around 0.92 p.u. and the wind turbines generate
becomes lower than 40%, V*dc_B decreases to 0.9 p.u. and
approximately 20 kW (PWT)' Ll and L3 are switched in, the
remains at this value for a certain period. Subsequently, when
total load is about 30 kW (Pd. The initial SOC is 55%, the
VdeL is below 0.9 p.u., the load with lower priority is tripped.
battery is charged with constant power about 9 kW (PB), so
After a certain period, if the SOC is still below 40%, another
the SOC increases accordingly. As the system is grid
load shedding becomes needed as well. V*deB can go back to
connected, the G-VSC outputs power 19 kW (PG) to
the original value 0.95 p.u. if no further load shedding is
compensate the energy deficits. The DC voltage Vdc_G is
required. A hysteresis band is also used to avoid unnecessary
controlled by the G-VSC at 1 p.u.
repetitive switching of the load shedding.
At 6s, the wind speed changes to 11 mls and PWT increases
The details of the generation curtailment control, using the
to 46 kW which is more than loads and battery demand, so
W-VSC and the pitch control mechanism to protect the
the surplus power 7 kW flows to the AC grid as shown in Fig.
system from overvoltage, will be reported in the future.
7(e). L2 and L4 are switched in at 8 s and 12 s, respectively.
IV. SIMULATION STUDIES But the wind speed reduces to 9 mls at 14 s and L3 is
In order to validate the proposed hierarchical control switched out at 16 s. It can be seen clearly from Fig. 7(e) that
strategy, simulation system has been built using the G-VSC adjusts its power output accordingly to maintain a
MATLAB/Simulink shown in Fig. 6. ThePMSG-based wind constant DC voltage of 1 p.u.. At about 12 s, the SOC reaches
turbines are rated at 60 kW. A 60 kW W-VSC and a 40 kW 80%, the charging power changes to 0, i.e., the charging is
G-VSC are used.The common DC voltage is set at 400 V. Ll stopped as predefmed. Through the effective control to each
and L2 are constant power type AC loads both rated at 15 kW, unit, the DC bus voltage Vdc_G is controlled at about Ip.u, and
while L3 and L4 are constant resistance type DC loads both the DC voltage regulation is less than 2%.
set at 10.6 n. The priorities of Ll-L4 decrease in turn. Ll is B. Simulation in Grid Integration-controlled Mode
the most important load and cannot be switched out during As shown in Fig. 8, the operation performances when the
operation.The BES unit consists of a 120 VIlOOO A'h nickel simulation starts are the same as that in the grid integration
metal hydride battery and a 30 kW Bi-DCIDC. uncontrolled mode. But at 6 s, a 500 ms three-phase AC fault
results in a large AC voltage dip as shown in Fig. 8(c). This
reduces the exported power by the G-VSC to almost 0 and
causes the DC voltage to drop immediately. As shown in Fig.
8(g-h), once the undervoltage value 0.95 p.u. is detected by
the BES unit controller, its operation mode is automatically
switched to DC voltage control from charging mode and it is
discharged to compensate the power loss caused by the G
VSC.The DC voltage Vdc_B is maintained at about 0.95 p.u..
At 6.5 s, the AC fault is cleared and the AC voltage quickly
recovers.This causes a rapid increase of the G-VSC exported
power and the DC voltage, as shown in Fig. 8(d-e).
Consequently, the BES unit switches back to charging mode
and the G-VSC regains DC voltage control, Vdc_G is
controlled at Ip.u. again.
At 8 s, the generated power of wind turbines decreases and
L2 and L4 are switched in at 10 s. The G-VSC increases its
power export to balance the extra power demand. However,
the G-VSC rapidly reaches its power limit of 40 kW and can
Fig. 5. Control flowchart for load shedding
no longer control the DC voltage, thus, the DC voltage droops.
3550
- �t- - 61
Grid
m �: �
Z, Z
PW"I j)G
2
11
+ l(
I
dc.... ---l t---.
2 ...-+-{
� � � B B3
t-----r- -,--------+-
I_V�k_WT --- ----I-V.
I _ -;-I
...-·-
-
11 kV
Wind turbines W-VSC G-VSC
60 kW 60kW 40kW
-
m
Fe
� : : :
+
Z 2
FL
I_V"'-R
I-----.... I--I•3 1--+-{I
120V IOOOkh
--;-
--.------
--'- -l
B i-DODC VdCL_I
30kW L-VSC
Fig. 6. The simulated system schematic diagram of the DC microgrid with wind turbines
Subsequently, the BES unit switches to DC voltage control As shown in Fig. 9, when the simulation starts, the loads
upon the detection of the low voltage value 0.95 p.u .. Vdc_B is L l-L4 are all switched in, PL is about 60 kW, and the wind
again kept at 0.95 p.u.. L4 and L3 are switched out at 14 s and turbine generates approximately 46 kW. The BES unit is
16 s respectively, which results in the total imported power to discharged to compensate energy deficits and controls VdcB
the DC microgrid being greater than the loads demand and at 0.95 p.u.. At 6 s, PWT drops, so the BES unit increases its
the DC voltage rises. Accordingly, the G-VSC and BES unit power output. At around 6.1 s, PB reaches the power limit of
switch back to DC voltage control mode and charging mode, 30 kW and cannot increase further. As PWT still decreases, the
respectively. DC voltage starts to drop due to the power imbalance. Once
the load terminal DC voltage Vdc_L drops to 0.85 p.u. at
C. Simulation in Islanding Mode
around 6.5 s, L4 is tripped immediately.This ensures that the
� : : tiiN! ! .! ! ..
� : t 1!=kill!lj
� : fi � iiii! 11
0'
I� :: f!
" 1 1
R i i � i·
,I �y1 l---,-1----
1
�: [ � TT l
"[i'
�
o I
:;:;: 0.95
,�
2 4 6 10 12
Time (s)
14 16 18 20
�]. �i! II f 12 4 6 8 10
Time (s)
12 14 16 18
�
20
Fig. 7. System operation performances during grid integration-uncontrolled Fig. 8. System operation performances during grid integration-controlled
mode mode
3551
mode and islanding mode, are described. A hierarchical
t :: flEl+1111 1
coordinated control strategy according to DC voltage
variation range is investigated in order to maintain a constant
DC voltage under different operation conditions. AC grid
connected converter (G-VSC) is responsible for DC voltage
! :: tiki! ;! !f 1 control and power balance under the first control level. The
battery energy storage (BES) unit replaces the G-VSC to
regulate DC voltage under the second control level.
� i::flvllcplll j
Appropriate load shedding and generation curtailment are
required under the third control level. Moreover, the control
method for each power electronic converter is analyzed,
� :� f� • · · · ·.) 1< s
especially the control method switching when DC voltage is
! .:fitIIHLirll
DC microgrid. Under various operating conditions, such as
variations of wind speed and load, grid AC faults, and
·
islanding, the system shows the satisfactory operation
performances, thereby improving DC microgrid stability and
3552