Paper 10

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 11

Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Materials Today: Proceedings


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/matpr

Challenges on friction stir welding of magnesium alloys in automotives


M.A. Unnikrishnan a, J. Edwin Raja Dhas b, K. Anton Savio Lewise c,⇑, John C. Varghese b, M. Ganesh d
a
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Vidya Academy of Science and Technology Technical Campus, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala 695602, India
b
Department of Automobile Engineering, Noorul Islam Centre for Higher Education, Kumaracoil, Tamilnadu 629180, India
c
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Karunya Institute of Technology and Sciences, Coimbatore, Tamilnadu 641114, India
d
Department of Aeronautical Engineering, MLR Institute of Technology, Hyderabad, Telangana, India

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: The most important advancement in metal joining during the last few decades is the Friction Stir Welding
Available online xxxx (FSW) process. When welding magnesium or light weight alloys, FSW offers several benefits. Due to its
advantages in lightweight construction, friction stir welding of magnesium alloys are widely used in
Keywords: the aerospace, marine, transport sector, particularly in automobiles and trucks, where they may signifi-
FSW cantly increase fuel economy and reduce emissions. Research and development in the area of FSW and
Mg alloy related technologies have recently been advancing quickly on a global scale. The fundamentals of friction
Thermal analysis
stir welding and a number of characteristics of friction stir welded magnesium alloys have been discussed
Light weight alloys
Automobile applications
in this article. Furthermore, this review reports the summary of the present status of friction stir welding
of magnesium alloys with automotive applications. In addition to that, the properties, structure, flamma-
bility and wear behavior of magnesium alloys have been described.
Copyright Ó 2023 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the International Confer-
ence on Advancements in Materials and Manufacturing.

1. Introduction chemical cleaning is required. The easiest methods for fusion weld-
ing use procedures that use an inert shielding environment of
Transportation industry is still facing challenges today though argon or helium gas. There is a great deal of misunderstanding
the technology has been developed so far. The major concerning out there about the fire risk while manufacturing magnesium
factor is the environmental impact which includes the CO2 emis- alloys. It is true that magnesium alloys are very flammable when
sions which must be reduced and is directly linked with the fuel they are broken down into small pieces, like powder or tiny chips,
efficiency and overall weight of the vehicle. Therefore, the automo- and this danger should never be disregarded. To prevent burning
bile manufacturers are in a constant urge of reducing the weight of beyond 427 °C, a non-combustible, oxygen-free environment is
the components as it will substantially influence the fuel efficiency necessary. The non-combustible magnesium alloy AMCa602 is cre-
of the vehicle. This demand for light weight structures has put ated by adding 2% calcium by weight to the magnesium alloy
focus on many alloys rather than metals as alloys possess wider AM60. Since stable RE-Mg intermetallic compounds may form at
properties than metals. Magnesium (Mg) alloys contains signifi- both low and high temperatures, rare earths can enhance the
cant material properties such as, low density, light weight, excel- mechanical characteristics of materials based on magnesium. Nev-
lent corrosion resistance and good mechanical properties at high ertheless, the low strength and poor wear resistance of magnesium
temperature. Also it includes, manganese, silicon, copper, rare alloys restricts their use in structural and anti-friction applications.
earths, zirconium and other metals. The hexagonal lattice structure According to prior research, Mg matrix composites made by mixing
of magnesium alloys has an impact on their basic characteristics secondary particles with Mg may greatly slow down corrosion and
[1]. decomposition rates. This increases strength and corrosion
Mg alloys may be spot-welded almost as readily as aluminium, resistance.
however prior to the weld being created, scratch brushing or Kulekci [2] reviewed that proper selection of alloys will consid-
erably reduce the overall payload and thereby achieving the
marked performance. The weight reduction criterion has so many
⇑ Corresponding author. advantages such as better performance levels, low emissions, bet-
E-mail address: kaslewise@gmail.com (K. Anton Savio Lewise).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2023.03.789
2214-7853/Copyright Ó 2023 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the International Conference on Advancements in Materials and Manufacturing.

Please cite this article as: M.A. Unnikrishnan, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise et al., Challenges on friction stir welding of magnesium alloys in
automotives, Materials Today: Proceedings, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2023.03.789
M.A. Unnikrishnan, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise et al. Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx

ter fuel efficiency etc. Almost all industries are highly concerned widely used. AZ91B has been used in various applications owing
with environmental conservation and automobile industry is no to its good cast ability, mechanical strength, impact toughness
different. The major part of automobile weight is concentrated etc. The letter A and Z denotes Al and Zn whereas number 9
on chassis, engine components, power train components etc. Some denotes the percentage of aluminium and 1 denotes the percent-
research statistics shows that around 30% of weight is related to age of Zinc in the alloy grade composition and the alphabet
chassis and same to powertrain components. Constant research denotes the second stage of development of the alloy. As the per-
has been going on for proper substitute materials with better dura- centage content of aluminium is more the structural properties,
bility, impact strength etc. This demand has resulted in the selec- strength etc. gets improved and thus it’s suitable for lightweight
tion of Mg alloys for automotive components since the properties structural parts. Among the wrought alloys Mg-Al-Zn Alloys series
of Mg alloys are similar to that of Aluminium alloys. Easton has been widely used. They are heat treatable and may be
et al., [3] reported about various applications of Mg alloys in a vari- strengthened by precipitation hardening. Among the wrought
ety of automotive parts such as in chassis components like Brake alloys AZ31B is finding more applications due to its good strength,
bracket, brake/clutch pedal bracket, air bag housings, engine descent weld ability etc. Liu et al., [7] mentioned that the AZ31B
cradle/subframe, Seat base, console bracket, instrument panel grade is finding applications in luggage racks of high speed trains
cross car beam, Antilock Braking System (ABS) housing, steering due to a weight reduction of 33% and Dziubinska et al., [8] quoted
wheel armature, steering column bracket band hub, jacket assem- the applications in aircraft brackets.
bly and housings, lock housing, actuator housing and retainer,
exterior components like Sunroof cover/cap assembly, outside mir- 1.1. Friction stir welding process
ror armature, roof frame, powertrain components such as Alterna-
tor A/C bracket, alternator bracket, alternator/idler bracket, valve FSW which is a solid state welding technique having a rotating
cover, cam cover, EGR valve plate, clutch housing, oil pan, cam tool with a pin inserted into the weld line until the tool shoulder
cover, power steering pump bracket etc. touches the upper surface of the plates being welded. Unnikrish-
Davies [4] described about Mg and its basic properties. Mg with nan and Raja [9] detailed that plates are welded due to the fric-
a density of 1.74 g/cm3 is the lightest of all engineering metals. Mg tional heat developed between the tool shoulder and the plates.
is the eighth most abundant element in the earth’s crust. Mg is 35% The side of the weld, where the traversing direction and tool direc-
lighter than Aluminium (Al) (2.7 g/cm3) and almost four times tion are the same is called as the Advancing Side (AS), whereas the
lighter than steel (7.86 g/cm3). Mg has a HCP crystal structure. It side where the traversing direction is against the tool direction is
is having a Hexagonal Close Packed (HCP) crystal structure which called as the Retreating Side (RS). The temperature is increased
makes it difficult to deform at room temperature. Mg is having up to the recrystallization temperature and the rotating tool will
good strength to weight ratio, formability properties, better damp- cause the intermixing of plasticize material and leads to solid state
ing characteristics, fluidity, hot formability, good machinability welding. The weld zones can be classified into Nugget Zone (NZ)
and low temperature properties which are very important from where the intermixing takes place, Thermo-Mechanically Affected
structural application point of view. They have better manufac- Zone (TMAZ) where maximum deformation takes place and Heat
turability, longer die life and faster solidification. Affected Zone (HAZ) where temperature variation can be noted
Taub and Luo [5] quoted that the Mg alloys are contributing without much influence on deformation. Friction stir welding has
around 50–60 % weight reduction in automotive structures. many advantages over other conventional welding techniques
Though pure Mg is abundantly available from the application side such as Metal Inert Gas (MIG) welding, Tungsten Inert Gas (TIG)
Mg alloys are widely used. They are easily machinable and are hav- welding etc. Also, it has been mentioned about some of the advan-
ing high damping resistance. Sankaran and Mishra [6] quoted tages are smaller HAZ [10], high weld strength [11], low distortion
about the alloying of Mg and the classification of Mg alloys based [12], less defects due to solidification, no consumables being used,
on manufacturing route is shown in Fig. 1.1. The most commonly cleaner and environmentally friendly process etc. Also many prob-
used alloying element is Al. In addition of Al will significantly lems such as porosity, solidification cracking, shrinkage etc. which
improve the strength, corrosion resistance etc. Another major are common in other welding techniques can be avoided to a great
alloying element is Zinc (Zn) which increases strength but may extent. Another important characteristic is FSW can be used for
have some negative impact on corrosion resistance properties. It joining dissimilar alloys. And it has been found that welding
mainly depends upon the percentage composition of the alloy parameters play a key role in final weld quality and some of the
being made. Manganese (Mn) is another element which is used major welding process parameters in FSW are Tool rotational
for alloying Mg and yield strength can be made better with Mn speed, Tool travel speed or welding speed, tool tilt angle, plunge
addition. Other alloying elements are Silicon (Si), Zirconium (Zr), depth, effect of forces in the , y, z axes and most importantly
Tin (Sn), Copper (Cu), Lead (Pb) etc. the tool which is used for welding [13]. Grujicic et al., [14] pre-
The Mg alloys can be broadly classified in to cast alloys and sented the schematic diagram of FSW process and the different
wrought alloys. Among the cast alloys Mg-Al-Zn series has been metallurgical process zones is shown in Fig. 1.2.(a) and (b).
The FSW process is carried out through these steps. Firstly, the
plates to be welded are clamped firmly on the back plate by means
of fixtures. Then a rotating tool is plunged into the abutting edge
until the shoulder of the tool touches the upper surface of the
material. Sufficient downward axial force is needed to keep the
contact. The rotating tool is held at its initial position for some time
to achieve enough temperature for plastic flow. The tool is then
allowed to traverse along the line of joint till the end of the weld.
After reaching the end of the line the tool gets withdrawn from the
work piece. Some of the applications of FSW in automotive indus-
try are center tunnels, camshafts, pistons, tailor welded blanks etc.
Some of the reasons for increasing acceptance of FSW are operating
costs are low, its capability in joining dissimilar metals, high con-
Fig. 1.1. Classification of Mg alloys based on manufacturing route. sistency and most importantly it’s environmentally friendly.
2
M.A. Unnikrishnan, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise et al. Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx

Annamalai et al., [18] had done a detailed review on Mg alloys


especially its strength, physical properties, biocompatibility etc.
Riaz et al., [19] had done research on various applications of Mg
alloys in biomedical and related streams. Though the usual focus
is on automotive, aerospace and transportation Mg alloys are also
finding application in biomedical fields.
Yang et al., [20] briefed about the recent advances in Mg and its
alloys worldwide. Apart from microstructural and corrosive prop-
erties Mg ion batteries, hydrogen storage Mg materials and bio-
Mg alloys are the future areas of concern. Kawajiri et al., [21]
focussed on the impact of light weighting on greenhouse gases
emissions. The influence of various structural materials on emis-
sion rate has been analysed. High strength steel, aluminium, car-
bon fiber reinforced polymer and Mg were chosen for analysis.
Fong et al., [22] discussed about the possibilities of Mg alloys in
light weighting applications. The improvement of formability char-
acteristics, reduction in grain size thereby increasing its applica-
tion status has been described.
Muttana and Aggarwal [23] reviewed about the various collab-
orations worldwide related to Mg research and development espe-
cially in the automotive world. The various organizations such as
United States Automotive Materials Partnership (USAMP) which
focuses on various casting and joining techniques of Mg alloys in
automobile sector, Collaborative Research Laboratories (CRLs) of
Fig. 1.2. (a) typical FSW process; (b) zones formed during FSW. General motors which researches on light weighting techniques,
Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization
(CSIRO) and Department of Energy (DOE) which focuses on new
techniques in Mg alloy productions.
2. Applications of magnesium alloys Magliaro and Altenhof [24] studied about the energy absorbing
capability of Mg alloys and its impact resistance characteristics.
Mg alloys have been a prime choice for all automobile manufac- Demirci and Yildiz [25] researched about crash performance of
turers, aerospace industries, bicycle manufacturers etc. owing to its Mg, Aluminium and advanced High Strength Steel which has been
light weight, low density yet good strength to weight ratio. As the used for vehicle thin walled energy absorbers. AM60 and AZ31 Mg
automotive and transportation industries are in a constant urge of alloys was chosen. Some of the crash performance parameters such
weight reduction a lot of research have been done and still going as total energy absorption, reaction forces and crush force efficien-
on in the field of Mg alloys. Though many other competitors are cies were compared and analysed using Finite Element method.
there like carbon fibre, composites etc. yet the availability of Mg The impact energy absorption capability of Mg alloys was found
alloys is a favoring factor and the cost is comparatively low when to better. Jayasathya kawin et al., [26] briefed about the basic prop-
compared to the above mentioned materials. erties of Mg, its advantages over other alloys in terms of applica-
Powell et al., [15] researched on the application of Mg alloys for tions, corrosion and mechanical properties.
lightweight powertrains and automotive structures. The basics of
Mg and its alloying details have been mentioned. The survey
details of Mg demand for a period of 18 years and difference 3. Friction stir welding of magnesium alloys
between cast Mg alloys and wrought Mg alloys have been plotted.
A detailed study about various casting methods, forming processes, Due to the wide variety of applications the need for a reliable
extrusion methods and their respective applications in various joining technique is always necessary. Though so many welding
fields. techniques are used, owing to the chemical properties of Mg alloys
Luo and Sachdev [16] discuss about the various applications of many of the normal welding techniques may not be completely
Mg alloys in automotive engineering. The authors focussed on the reliable. Tungsten-arc Inert Gas (TIG), Metal-arc Inert Gas (MIG),
properties and potential characteristics of Mg alloys and its com- Plasma arc, Electron beam, Laser,
parison with various competitors like mild steel, advanced high Ultrasonic, Spot welding etc. are some of the common welding
strength steels, aluminium, and polymer composites. Various man- techniques in use. In Laser beam welding, though the welding
ufacturing methods, alloy developmental stages had been summa- technique is precise and have many advantages when it comes to
rized. The main concentration was on the application of wrought Mg alloys, the material properties influence the welding efficiency
Mg alloys and its applications. The major concern was on the tech- to a great extent. Also, few other literatures explain the basic
nical challenges in the Mg production and processing by constant advantages and disadvantages of various welding methods for
research and collaboration among various countries, industries. Mg alloys. The oxidising tendency, low absorptivity of laser beams,
Gialanella and Malandruccolo [17] researched about the various wide solidification temperature range etc. are some of the factors
alloys used in aerospace applications. Various electrolytic pro- that are preventing the laser beam welding to be used for joining
cesses used for the production of Mg alloys have been discussed. Mg alloys. The tensile strength may get reduce due to the stress
The weight of Mg used for various aircraft models had been dis- concentration around porosities and may lead to micro cracks for-
cussed. ASTM designations of various grades, chemical composi- mation. Another factor is solidification cracking. The alloys with
tions and alloying behaviour had been presented. The authors less than 6% Al content and Zn content up to 1% possess good weld
focussed on the factors corrosion resistance, high temperature ability and the increase in percentage of Al more than 6% and up to
creep resistance, strength and elongation characteristics in the 1% Zn are moderately crack sensitive. Eventhough there are some
aerospace application viewpoint. concerning factors proper selection of welding parameters, joint
3
M.A. Unnikrishnan, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise et al. Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx

composition, joint design etc. will help in obtaining a stable joint.


In the case of resistance spot welding the welding current has
direct influence on the nugget region and it may lead to formation
of cracks. Though there are many advantages for resistance spot
welding some of the cons are, high equipment cost, requirement
of high vacuum, time consumption, precise arrangement of work
piece etc. In all the conventional welding techniques oxidation
occurs because of melting of the work piece. Surface preparation,
filler materials [27], preparation of the material are some of the
other requirements. In the case of solid state welding the chances
of oxidation are low and the need for shield gas, consuming mate-
rials can be avoided. Apart from friction welding were the heat
generated from the rotating surfaces itself is used for joining, in
FSW a rotating tool is introduced between the joining work pieces,
the tool shoulder produces the frictional heat and stirring is done
by the pin. The combined effect of these with axial pressure causes
the materials to be joined. Due to these advantages FSW has been
used in joining Mg and other lightweight alloys. FSW can be used Fig. 3.1. TMAZ micrograph of retreating side.
for joining dissimilar alloys in particular owing to the benefits such
as a thin HAZ region, better joint quality while comparing with
conventional fusion welding techniques. The selected Mg alloys Li et al., [31] studied about the improvement of microstructural
AZ31B and AZ91B are having similar thermal properties such as and tensile properties of AZ31B using stationary shoulder FSW. The
latent heat of fusion, their melting point range, specific heat capac- tool was having a concave shoulder with threaded pin and an
ity, thermal conductivity and thermal expansion. Proper selection external stationary shoulder was used for welding purpose. The
of welding parameters can resolve most of the problems related tool rpm, welding speed and tool tilt angle were the selected pro-
to dissimilar alloy welding such as tunnelling defect, cracks, voids cess parameters. The arc corrugation was eliminated at a higher
etc. Therefore, FSW can produce good quality welds even though tool rpm. Similar to normal FSW BM, NZ, HAZ and TMAZ regions
the alloys are different. were obtained. The stir zone showed a decrease in Vickers hard-
Czerwinski [28] reviewed about the various joining techniques ness and the advancing side of TMAZ/SZ region showed the mini-
for Mg alloys. Various fusion welding techniques and solid state mum value. The hardness distribution pattern is shown in
welding techniques with their advantages and disadvantages were Fig. 3.2. An increase in width of the stir zone with respect to the
listed. The solid state welding techniques especially FSW was increase in tool rpm has been noted and that can be due to plastic
found to be the most suitable for joining Mg alloys owing to its bet- strain owing to higher heat input.
ter joint strength and quality. A lot of work has been done on FSW Mysliwiec and Sliwa [32] studied about the tensile strength,
of Mg alloys. Though many alloy grades are there our consideration micro hardness and forces acting during FSW of AZ31B.Tungsten
is limited to FSW of AZ31 grade and AZ91 grade. carbide cylindrical tool with cylindrical pin was used for welding.
Gulati et al., [29] had done a detailed microstructural analysis The process parameters include tool rpm, welding speed with
on FS welded Mg alloy AZ31B-H24. The welding was done using dwell time of 20 s for all joints. Ultimate tensile strength (UTS),
the central composite design in response surface methodology. Yield strength (YS) and percentage elongation were calculated
The chosen process parameters were tool rpm, welding speed and welded joints showed around 80% efficiency in an average.
and plunge depth using a truncated conical profiled tool. Three The author finds that in almost all the joints the failure occurred
zones were identified dynamically recrystallized zone, TMAZ and in between the SZ and TMAZ region and was on the AS. The
base material region. Very fine grains were obtained at the nugget microstructural analysis showed better results and proper recrys-
region and sufficient recrystallization has been observed and the tallization has been occurred by the presence of equiaxed grains
influencing factors be plastic deformation along with frictional in the HAZ and TMAZ regions. An important factor influencing
heat. Onion ring formation was also observed. The TMAZ region the joint efficiency is the amount of force that has been exerted
shows clear variation in grain sizes as compared to nugget zone.
The grain size observed to be larger in the advancing side than
the retreating side as shown in Fig. 3.1. The maximum micro hard-
ness was obtained at the NZ and goes on decreasing towards the
TMAZ side. The maximum hardness value was 84 Hv which was
almost 16% higher than base material value.
Wang et al., [30] studied about flat friction spot welding of
AZ31B Mg alloy and the microstructural and mechanical properties
has been studied. The welding was done using double side adjusta-
ble tools made of tool steel JIS-SKD61 grade and was having two
sets of shoulder and probe one on the upper side and one on the
lower side respectively. The upper and lower shoulder/probe set
rotates clockwise/counter clockwise. For microstructural examina-
tion Optical microscopy, Field Emission Scanning Electron Micro-
scopy and Electron Back Scatter Diffraction (EBSD) measurements
were taken. The probe plunge depth of 1.5 mm or above yielded
better joints. Three fracture zones was identified namely interface
fracture, partial plug fracture and plug fracture. The un-bonded
surface created due to improper temperature was found to be a
starting point for crack formation. Fig. 3.2. Vickers hardness distribution pattern along mid thickness.

4
M.A. Unnikrishnan, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise et al. Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx

during welding and these forces both in X axis and Y axis has been ing. The pin length and tool tilt angle was kept constant at 5.45 mm
measured using a high sensitive piezoelectric dynamometer. Four and 3°. The tool rotational speed and traverse speed selected for
different FSW stages namely tool plunging, tool dwelling, welding cylindrical tool and truncated conical tool were 1500 rpm-
and tool pulling out was recognized. The tool feed rate was most 1800 rpm and 100 mm/min to 120 mm/min respectively. Among
influential than rotational speed. the two different tool profiles used the truncated tool produced
Khan et al., [33] researched on the mechanical properties and better defect free joints rather than cylindrical tool as the contact
characterization of AZ31B Mg alloy which was processed by FSW area for cylindrical pin profile is more it may have led to defect for-
and Tungsten arc welding. The tool was of H13 tool steel with a mation and the area of detection was parallel along the weld line.
conical tip having a diameter ratio of 2:4. Tool rpm, welding speed, Gupta et al., [35] studied about the tunnel defect formation dur-
tool tilt angle and axial force were the chosen process parameters. ing FS processing of AZ31B and the effect of tool rpm and feed rate
UTS, YS, percentage elongation and weld efficiency were calcu- on it.The chosen process parameters were tool rpm which was kept
lated. While comparing to TAW, FSW joints showed better results constant at 2000 rpm, feed rate of 40 mm/min, 50 mm/min and the
for UTS. Also the fatigue strength of FSW joints were more, both welding was done using H13 tool steel with cylindrical as well as
metallographic and fractographic analysis favour FSW as per the truncated conical pin profiles. The results shows that cylindrical
results. Though this is a comparison between two welding tech- pin produced much tunnel defect and the orientation of defect
niques more emphasis has been put on to FSW and the results was inclined towards the retreating side. At a feed rate of
showed that FSW was more beneficial. The microstructure of the 50 mm/min excessive flash was observed while using the cylindri-
weld is shown in Fig. 3.3. cal tool. The tunnel defect was low while using truncated conical
Gulati et al., [34] analysed about the defect formation during tool.
FSW of AZ31B alloy. A truncated conical pin profiled and cylindri- Rao and Naik [36] researched the effect of welding parameters
cal pin profiled tool made up of H13 tool steel was used for weld- on microstructural and mechanical properties of AZ31B.A cylindri-

Fig. 3.3. Microstructure of (a) base metal (b) SZ of FS weld zone (c) TMAZ of FS weld (d) GTA weld zone.

Fig. 3.4. Optical microstructure of (a) TMAZ (b) HAZ at 1600 rpm and 24 mm/min.

5
M.A. Unnikrishnan, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise et al. Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx

min produced high quality joints. Sufficient recrystallization and


grain growth has been observed in the TMAZ and SZ zones as per
the microstructural analysis. The stir zone showed smaller grains
at lower feed and higher tool rotational speed. The optical
microstructural image of TMAZ and HAZ regions has been shown
in Fig. 3.4.
Mironov et al., [37] analysed the tensile behaviour of AZ31 Mg
alloy after FSW using EBSD and digital image correlation. The FS
welding tool was made up of tool steel with concave shoulder
diameter 15 mm, an M5 threaded cylindrical pin of 3.7 mm in
length. The angle of tilt of the tool was at 3°. A sample size EBSD
map was obtained for detailed examination of texture distribution
and the results showed that the basal slip was favoured at retreat-
ing and advancing sides. In the stir zone region, a strain gradient
was observed lengthways. The stain was larger on the front face
than the back side.
Naik et al., [38] researched on the microstructural and fatigue
properties of FS lap welded Mg alloy AZ31B-H24.H13 tool steel
was used for welding. The tool tilt angle was maintained at 0.5°.
The welding speed was maintained at 10 mm/min and tool rota-
Fig. 3.5. Microstructure of SZ at 1000 rpm and 20 mm/min. tional speed at 1000 rpm and 1500 rpm. The results showed an
equiaxial grain structure with dynamic recrystallization at SZ and
TMAZ regions.
cal tool with conical probe having a length of 3 mm and pin length The microstructure of SZ at 1000 rpm and 20 mm/min is shown
3 mm made of H13 tool steel was employed. Tool rotational speed in Fig. 3.5. The hardness pattern showed an increase with respect
ranging from 1200 rpm to 1600 rpm, feed rate ranging from to lower heat input at the SZ region. The welding parameters have
24 mm/min to 28 mm/min and tool tilt angle of 1°were the chosen been found to be influencing hook height and fatigue life. Padman-
process parameters in which the combination of 1600 rpm/24 mm/ aban and Balasubramanian [39] focussed on the selection of tool

Fig. 3.6. Effect of various tool pin profiles on stir zone microstructure.

6
M.A. Unnikrishnan, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise et al. Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx

material, shoulder diameter and tool pin profile during FSW of The SEM images of different zones during one pass FSP is shown
AZ31B Mg alloy. The effect of various pin profiles on microstruc- in Fig. 3.9.
ture has been shown in Fig. 3.6. The microstructure was refined more during second pass. The
Among the five tool materials and pin profiles high carbon steel UTS,micro hardness in the stir zone region and elongation all
tool with threaded pin profile with a shoulder diameter of 18 mm increased. Sufficient breakup of a-phase and proper refinement
showed better tensile properties. Sahu et al., [40] assessed the of b-phase was observed as results.
effect of self-retracting Bobbin Tool (BT) FSW of AZ31 Mg alloy at Farzami et al., [49] focussed on the properties of AZ91 Mg alloy
an inert gas environment.H13 tool was used with tool rpm and during FSW with and without the addition of SiC nano particles.
welding speed as selected parameters Ugender et al., [41] Kadigithala and Vanitha [50] researched on the effects of welding
researched on the effect of tool rotational speed and tool material speeds during FSW on mechanical and microstructural properties
during FSW of AZ31B Mg alloy. Tool rotational speeds of 900 rpm, of Mg alloy AZ91D. H13 tool steel with tapered cylindrical pin
1120 rpm and 1400 rpm and welding speed from 25 to 75 mm/min was used. Kouadri-Henni and Barrallier [51] analysed the mechan-
were used. Three tool materials namely Stainless steel, HSS and ical, microstructure and crystallographic properties during FSW of
H13 tool steel were used. AZ91-D Mg alloy.
Singh et al., [42] studied about the effect of parameters on FSW Patel et al., [52] researched on the influence of tool pin profile
of AZ31B-O Mg alloy. A high strength joint was obtained at a weld and welding parameters during FSW of AZ91 Mg alloy on mechan-
pitch of 0.050 mm/rev. The area between SZ and TMAZ towards the ical properties. Three different tool pin designs were selected
advancing side was the fracture location for most of the samples. namely threaded straight cylindrical, tapered cylindrical and
The grain size after welding was found to be inversely proportional straight cylindrical. The welding process was designed according
to weld pitch. to Taguchi’s L9 orthogonal array with three tool pin profiles, tool
Yang et al., [43] studied about the effect of probe less FSW on rotational speed from 710 rpm to 1400 rpm and welding speed
AZ31 Mg alloy. Tool was made up of H13 tool steel. TMAZ and from 28 mm/min to 56 mm/min as the process parameters.
HAZ were observed with fine and partially deformed grains. Three Suhin et al., [53] had predicted the process parameters during
fracture modes namely interfacial shear, mixed mode and pull out FSW of similar and dissimilar alloy. Four different process param-
fracture were observed. Mirzaei et al., [44] had studied the effect of eters are optimized by regression analysis to get a high strength
tool pin profile on the material flow during FSW of AZ91 Mg alloy. welded joint.
Fashami et al., [45] researched about the mechanical properties of Sunil et al., [54] researched on the microstructural aspects dur-
AZ91 Mg alloy during multi-pass FS processing. The optical micro- ing FSW of dissimilar Mg alloys AZ31 and AZ91. The specimens
scopic images of the grain distribution in stir zone up and stir zone
down regions and the corresponding SEM image of the distribution
of b-phase is shown in Fig. 3.7.
Asadi et al., [46] had simulated the dynamic recrystallization
process during FSW of Mg alloy grade AZ91. Tool rotational speeds
of 710 rpm, 1400 rpm and traverse speeds of 25 mm/min, 50 mm/
min were used. The tool was of 2344 hot working steel with square
pin profile. The tilt angle of the tool was fixed at 3°. The process
was finite element modelled and a combination of cellular automa-
tion and laasraoui-jonas model has been used. A comparison has
been made between the simulated and experimental results. The
results showed that the proposed model can simulate the disloca-
tion accumulation map, nucleation and grain growth stages.
Baradarani et al., [47] studied the effect of Ultra Sonic assisted
FSW (USFSW) of AZ91-C Mg alloy and its microstructural and
mechanical properties. The hardness profile during two processes
has been shown in Fig. 3.8.
Chai et al., [48] worked on the microstructural and mechanical
aspects during multipass FS processing of AZ91 Mg alloys. The
material was subjected to one pass and two pass FSP with a tool
rotational speed of 800 rpm and traverse speed of 60 mm/min. Fig. 3.8. Hardness profiles of US FSW and FSW joints.

Fig. 3.7. (a) SEM Image of Grains and Distribution of b-Phase (b) OM Image of the Stirred Zone-Down (c) OM Image of the Stirred Zone-up.

7
M.A. Unnikrishnan, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise et al. Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx

were friction stir welded with three different feeds and speeds to be larger than at AZ31 side. The optimum results were obtained
ranging from 1400 to 1800 rpm and 25 to 100 mm/min. After at 580 rpm and 45 mm/min.
welding the joints were subjected to micro hardness measurement, Lee et al., [56] carried out FSW of dissimilar Mg alloys AZ31 and
tensile test and microstructural analysis. Fig. 3.10 shows the opti- AZ91. AZ31B-H24 and as cast AZ91D Mg alloys were used with tool
cal microstructure of the weld zone. Kumar Singh and Kumar rotational speed from 1250 to 3600 rpm, welding speed from 22 to
Dubey [55] studied about the joining performance of dissimilar 87 mm/min, pin inserting depth from 3.92 to 3.95 mm and fixed
Mg alloys AZ31 and AZ91. Tool rotational speed ranging from tool to work piece angle of 3°as process parameters. The
440 to 1160 rpm, welding speed ranging from 45 to 55 mm/min microstructure of TMAZ region of AZ91 and stir zone is shown in
and heat input ratio from 8 to 25.77 x/v. Fig. 3.11.
The welded specimens were undergone for tensile test, micro- Sound welds were obtained at 3600 rpm and 41 mm/min with
hardness test and the surface roughness was calculated. The proper dynamic recrystallization occurance.The base material
microstructural analysis includes SEM and XRD. The surface rough- region showed more hardness than the weld zone. Fig. 3.12 shows
ness results show that the smoothness increased with respect to the hardness distribution pattern during higher welding speed of
increase in heat input. The grain size in AZ91 side was observed 3600 rpm.

Fig. 3.9. SEM microstructure at (a) SZ (b) TMAZ (c) HAZ.

Fig. 3.10. Optical Microscope Images of (a) AZ91 BM (b) AZ31 BM (c) NZ and BM Interface at the AZ31 Side (d) Corresponding Magnified Image (e) NZ and BM Interface at the
AZ91 Side (f) Corresponding Magnified Image.

8
M.A. Unnikrishnan, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise et al. Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx

Fig. 3.11. (a) TMAZ Region of AZ91 (b) Stir Zone Region.

4. Conclusions

The current research reviews recent developments of process-


ing welding conditions’ effects on FSW joining magnesium alloys
and their applications in the automobile sectors. The application
of Mg alloys, latest trends, FSW of Mg alloys comprising of both
similar and dissimilar alloys and its advantages, temperature mea-
surement and its distribution, thermal analysis, various optimiza-
tion techniques and prediction techniques, corrosion testing and
thermal stability analysis has been carried out. The literatures pro-
vide ample information for the proposed title and experimenta-
tion. In addition, difficulties with friction stir welding of
magnesium alloys for automotive applications are highlighted.

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Fig. 3.12. Hardness Distribution Pattern During Two Welding Speeds.


M.A. Unnikrishnan: . J. Edwin Raja Dhas: Supervision. K.
Anton Savio Lewise: Supervision. John C. Varghese: Supervision.
M. Ganesh: Supervision.
Mohamed and Alias [57] focussed the tensile and microstruc-
tural properties of AZ31 and AZ91 Mg alloys during FSW. H13 tool Data availability
steel was selected as the tool material. Welding speed ranging
from 60 to 100 mm/min, tool rotational speed from 800 to The data that has been used is confidential.
1200 rpm were the selected process parameters.
TAMZ region of AZ31 and AZ91 is shown in Fig. 3.13. (a) and (b) Declaration of Competing Interest
respectively. The stir zone was observed with fine grains with
equiaxed structure. The grain distribution shows that sufficient The authors declare that they have no known competing finan-
dynamic recrystallization had taken place. Yin et al., [58] observed cial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared
the metallurgical and mechanical properties of FS welded dissimi- to influence the work reported in this paper.
lar Mg alloys AZ31 and AZ91. The welding was carried out using
threaded, three-flat threaded and three-flat no thread tools. Tool References
rotational speeds from 1000 to 3000 rpm with 2.5 mm/s plunge
[1] B.C. Pai, U.T.S. Pillai, P. Manikandan, A. Srinivasan, Modification of AZ91 Mg
rate and dwell time of 1 s. Microscopic and SEM images were taken alloys for high temperature applications, Trans. Indian Inst. Met. 65 (2012)
for detailed analysis. Intermingled AZ91 and AZ31 lamellae had 601–606, https://doi.org/10.1007/s12666-012-0166-1.
been formed when three-flat no thread tool. Highest failure load [2] M.K. Kulekci, Magnesium and its Alloys Applications in Automotive Industry,
The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 39 (9–10)
properties were observed in joints welded using threaded tool. (2008) 851–865.

Fig. 3.13. (a) TMAZ Region of AZ31 (b) TMAZ Region of AZ91.

9
M.A. Unnikrishnan, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise et al. Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx

[3] M. Easton, M. Gibson, A. Beer, M. Barnett, C. Davies, Y. Durandet, S. Blacket, X. [30] X. Wang, Y. Morisada, H. Fujii, Flat Friction Stir Spot Welding of AZ31B
Chen, N. Birbilis, T. Abbott, The Application of Magnesium Alloys to the Light Magnesium Alloy Using Double Side Adjustable Tools: Microstructure and
Weighting of Automotive Structures, In Sustainable Automotive Technologies, Mechanical Properties, Science and Technology of Welding and Joining 25 (8)
Springer, 2012, 17–23. (2020) 644–652.
[4] G. Davies, Materials for Automobile Bodies, Butterworth-Heinemann, 2012, pp. [31] W. Li, P. Niu, S. Yan, V. Patel, Q. Wen, Improving Microstructural and Tensile
3–9. Properties of AZ31B Magnesium Alloy Joints by Stationary Shoulder Friction
[5] A.I. Taub, A.A. Luo, Advanced Lightweight Materials and Manufacturing Stir Welding, Journal of Manufacturing Processes 37 (2019) 159–167.
Processes for Automotive Applications, Mrs Bulletin 40 (12) (2015) 1045– [32] P. Mysliwiec, R. Sliwa, Friction Stir Welding of Thin Sheets of Magnesium Alloy
1054. AZ31B, Archives of Metallurgy and Materials 63 (1) (2018) 45–54.
[6] K.K. Sankaran, R.S. Mishra, Metallurgy and Design of Alloys with Hierarchical [33] M.Y. Khan, N.A. Anjum, R.A. Pasha, S. Ahmad, A. Batool, J. Shafique, Mechanical
Microstructures, Elsevier, 2017, 7.. Characterization of Magnesium Alloy AZ31B Processed by Friction Stir
[7] J.Z. Liu, Y.H. Zhao, L. Song, Z.X. Xiang, Study on the AZ31B Magnesium Alloy in Welding and Gas Tungsten Arc Welding, Technical Journal 24 (4) (2019) 23–
the Application on High-Speed Trains, In Advanced Materials Research, volume 29.
535, Trans Tech Publications (2012) 875–879. [34] P. Gulati, D.K. Shukla, A. Gupta, Defect Formation Analysis of Friction Stir
[8] A. Dziubinska, A. Gontarz, K. Horzelska, P. Piesko, The Microstructure and Welded Magnesium AZ31B Alloy, Materials Today: Proceedings 4 (2) (2017)
Mechanical Properties of AZ31 Magnesium Alloy Aircraft Brackets Produced by 1005–1012.
a New Forging Technology, Procedia Manufacturing 2 (2015) 337–341. [35] A. Gupta, P. Singh, P. Gulati, D.K. Shukla, Effect of Tool Rotation Speed and Feed
[9] M. Unnikrishnan, D.J.E. Raja, A Survey on Friction Stir Welding of Dissimilar Rate on the Formation of Tunnel Defect in Friction Stir Processing of AZ31
Magnesium Alloys, IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, Magnesium alloy, Materials Today: Proceedings 2 (4–5) (2015) 3463–3470.
volume 247, IOP Publishing, 2017, p. 012009. [36] G.S.P. Rao, B.B. Naik, Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Friction Stir
[10] K. Anton Savio Lewise, J.E. Raja Dhas, R. Pandiyarajan, Optimising aluminium Welded AZ31B Magnesium Alloy, International Journal of Ethics in
2024/7075 friction stir welded joints, Adv. Mater. Process. Technol. 00 (2022) Engineering & Management Education 2 (6) (2015) 11–14.
1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/2374068X.2022.2079226. [37] S. Mironov, T. Onuma, Y. Sato, S. Yoneyama, H. Kokawa, Tensile Behaviour of
[11] K. Anton Savio Lewise, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, FSSW process parameter Friction-Stir Welded AZ31 Magnesium Alloy, Materials Science and
optimization for AA2024 and AA7075 alloy, Mater. Manuf. Process. 37 Engineering: A 679 (2017) 272–281.
(2022) 34–42. https://doi.org/10.1080/10426914.2021.1962532. [38] B. Naik, D. Chen, X. Cao, P. Wanjara, Microstructure and Fatigue Properties of a
[12] K. Anton Savio Lewise, E.R.D. J, R. Pandiyarajan, Microstructure and mechanical Friction Stir Lap Welded Magnesium Alloy, Metallurgical and Materials
properties of friction stir spot welded dissimilar aluminum alloys, J. Chinese Transactions A 44 (8) (2013) 3732–3746.
Inst. Eng. Trans. Chinese Inst. Eng. A. 45 (2022) 453–464. https://doi.org/ [39] G. Padmanaban, V. Balasubramanian, Selection of FSW Tool Pin Profile,
10.1080/02533839.2022.2061603. Shoulder Diameter and Material for Joining AZ31B Magnesium Alloy–an
[13] V. Haribalaji, S. Boopathi, M.M. Asif, M. Jeyakumar, R. Subbiah, K.A.S. Lewise, Experimental Approach, Materials & Design 30 (7) (2009) 2647–2656.
Influences of Friction stir tool parameters for joining two similar AZ61A alloy [40] P.K. Sahu, N.P. Vasudevan, B. Das, S. Pal, Assessment of Self-Reacting Bobbin
plates, Mater. Today Proc. 50 (2021) 2547–2553, https://doi.org/10.1016/ Tool Friction Stir Welding for Joining AZ31 Magnesium Alloy at Inert Gas
j.matpr.2021.12.074. Environment, Journal of Magnesium and Alloys 7 (4) (2019) 661–671.
[14] M. Grujicic, G. Arakere, H. Yalavarthy, T. He, C.-F. Yen, B. Cheeseman, Modeling [41] S. Ugender, A. Kumar, A.S. Reddy, Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of
of AA5083 Material-Microstructure Evolution During Butt Friction-Stir AZ31B Magnesium Alloy by Friction Stir Welding, Procedia materials science 6
Welding, Journal of Materials Engineering and Performance 19 (5) (2010) (2014) 1600–1609.
672–684. [42] I. Singh, G.S. Cheema, A.S. Kang, An Experimental Approach to Study the Effect
[15] B. Powell, P. Krajewski, A. Luo, Magnesium Alloys for Lightweight Powertrains of Welding Parameters on Similar Friction Stir Welded Joints of AZ31B-O Mg
and Automotive Structures, In Materials, Design and Manufacturing for Alloy, Procedia Engineering 97 (2014) 837–846.
Lightweight Vehicles, 4, Elsevier, 2021, 125–186. [43] X.-W. Yang, W.-Y. Feng, W.-Y. Li, X.-R. Dong, Y.-X. Xu, C. Qiang, S.-T. Yao,
[16] A. Luo, A. Sachdev, Applications of Magnesium Alloys in Automotive Microstructure and Properties of Probeless Friction Stir Spot Welding of AZ31
Engineering, Advances in Wrought Magnesium Alloys, 12, Elsevier, 2012, pp. Magnesium Alloy Joints, Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China 29
393–426. (11) (2019) 2300–2309.
[17] S. Gialanella, A. Malandruccolo, Alloys for Aircraft Structures, Aerospace Alloys, [44] M.H. Mirzaei, P. Asadi, A. Fazli, Effect of Tool Pin Profile on Material Flow in
volume 1, Springer, 2020, pp. 41–127. Double Shoulder Friction Stir Welding of AZ91 Magnesium Alloy, International
[18] S. Annamalai, S. Periyakgoundar, S. Gunasekaran, Magnesium Alloys: A Review Journal of Mechanical Sciences 183 (2020).
of Applications Magnezijeve Zlitine: Pregled Uporabe, Material in Technologies [45] H.A.A. Fashami, N.B.M. Arab, M.H. Gollo, B. Nami, Effect of Multi-Pass Friction
53 (6) (2019) 881–890. Stir Processing on Thermal Distribution and Mechanical Properties of AZ91,
[19] U. Riaz, I. Shabib, W. Haider, The Current Trends of Mg Alloys in Biomedical Mechanics & Industry 21 (4) (2020) 411.
Applications—A Review, Journal of Biomedical Materials Research Part B: [46] P. Asadi, M.K.B. Givi, M. Akbari, Simulation of Dynamic Recrystallization
Applied, Biomaterials 107 (6) (2019) 1970–1996. Process During Friction Stir Welding of AZ91 Magnesium Alloy, The
[20] Y. Yang, X. Xiong, J. Chen, X. Peng, D. Chen, F. Pan, Research Advances in International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 83 (1–4)
Magnesium and Magnesium Alloys Worldwide in 2020, Journal of Magnesium (2016) 301–311.
and Alloys. (2021). [47] F. Baradarani, A. Mostafapour, M. Shalvandi, Effect of ultrasonic Assisted
[21] K. Kawajiri, M. Kobayashi, K. Sakamoto, Lightweight Materials Equal Friction Stir Welding on Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of AZ91- C
Lightweight Greenhouse Gas Emissions?: A Historical Analysis of Magnesium Alloy, Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China 29 (12)
Greenhouse Gases of Vehicle Material Substitution, Journal of Cleaner (2019) 2514–2522.
Production 253 (2020). [48] F. Chai, F. Yan, W. Wang, Q. Lu, X. Fang, Microstructures and Mechanical
[22] K.S. Fong, M.J. Tan, B.W. Chua, D. Atsushi, Enabling Wider Use of Magnesium Properties of AZ91 Alloys Prepared by Multi-Pass Friction Stir Processing,
Alloys for Lightweight Applications by Improving the Formability by Groove Journal of Materials Research 33 (12) (2018) 1789–1796.
Pressing, Procedia CIRP 26 (2015) 449–454. [49] M. Farzami, M. Farahani, D. Akbari, M. Tabasi, Friction Stir Weld of AZ91
[23] S.B. Muttana, D. Aggarwal, Prospects of Magnesium for Automotive Light Magnesium Alloy with and Without Nano-SiC Particle, JOM 71 (11) (2019)
Weighting Applications—Part II, Auto Tech Review 4 (4) (2015) 18–23. 4171–4179.
[24] V. Haribalaji, S. Boopathi, M. Mohammed Asif, T. Yuvaraj, D. Velmurugan, K. [50] N.K. Kadigithala, C. Vanitha, Effects of Welding Speeds on the Microstructural
Anton Savio Lewise, S. Sudhagar, P. Suresh, Influences of Mg-Cr filler materials and Mechanical Properties of AZ91D Mg Alloy by Friction Stir Welding,
in Friction Stir Process of Aluminium-based dissimilar alloys, Mater. Today International Journal of Structural Integrity 11 (6) (2020) 769–782.
Proc. 66 (2022) 948–954. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2022.04.668. [51] A. Kouadri-Henni, L. Barrallier, Mechanical Properties, Microstructure and
[25] E. Demirci, A.R. Yildiz, An Investigation of the Crash Performance of Crystallographic Texture of Magnesium AZ91-D Alloy Welded by Friction Stir
Magnesium, Aluminium and Advanced High Strength Steels and Different Welding (FSW), Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A 45 (11) (2014)
Cross-Sections for Vehicle Thin-Walled Energy Absorbers, Materials Testing 60 4983–4996.
(7–8) (2018) 661–668. [52] N. Patel, K. Bhatt, V. Mehta, Influence of Tool Pin Profile and Welding
[26] S. Jayasathya kawin, M. Ravichandran, N. Baskar, C.A. Chairman, R. Parameter on Tensile Strength of Magnesium Alloy AZ91 During FSW, Procedia
Balasundaram, (2020), Mechanical Properties and Applications of Technology 23 (2016) 558–565.
Magnesium Alloy–Review, Materials Today: Proceedings, 27(2), 909–913. [53] S. Suhin, S. Robin Divahar, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise, M.
[27] P. Asadi, K. Kazemi-Choobi, A. Elhami, Welding of Magnesium Alloys, New Satyanarayana Gupta, Optimizing FSW process parameters using RSM and
Features on Magnesium Alloys, Dr. Waldemar a. Monteiro, InTech 5772 (6) regression analysis for similar and dissimilar aluminium materials, Mater.
(2012) 121–158. Today Proc. 64 (2022) 368–373. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2022.04.707.
[28] F. Czerwinski, Magnesium Alloys: Design, Processing and Properties. 2011. [54] B.R. Sunil, G.P.K. Reddy, A. Mounika, P.N. Sree, P.R. Pinneswari, I. Ambica, R.A.
[29] P. Gulati, D.K. Shukla, A. Gupta, M. Singh, R. Kumar, J.P. Singh, Microstructural Babu, P. Amarnadh, Joining of AZ31 and AZ91 Mg Alloys by Friction Stir
Analysis of Friction Stir Welded Mg AZ31 Alloy, Materials Today: Proceedings Welding, Journal of Magnesium and Alloys 3 (4) (2015) 330–334.
26 (2020) 1145–1150.

10
M.A. Unnikrishnan, J. Edwin Raja Dhas, K. Anton Savio Lewise et al. Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx

[55] Kumar Singh U. and Kumar Dubey A., (2020), Study of Joining Performance [57] N. Mohamed, J. Alias, The influence of Friction Stir Welding of Dissimilar AZ31
of Dissimilar Mg Alloys in Friction Stir Welding, Proceedings of the and AZ91 Magnesium Alloys on the Microstructure and Tensile Properties,
Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C: Journal of Mechanical International Journal of Automotive and Mechanical Engineering 16 (2) (2019)
Engineering Science, 1–9. 6675–6683.
[56] C.Y. Lee, W.B. Lee, Y.M. Yeon, S.B. Jung, Friction Stir Welding of Dissimilar [58] Y. Yin, N. Sun, T. North, S. Hu, Microstructures and Mechanical Properties in
Formed Mg Alloys (AZ31/AZ91), In Materials Science Forum, volume 486, Dissimilar AZ91/AZ31 Spot Welds, Materials Characterization 61 (10) (2010)
Trans Tech Publications (2005) 249–252. 1018–1028.

11

You might also like