Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Final Paper
Final Paper
Quantitative Research
presented to
By
Jianne N. Jimenez
October 2021
i
HOW PESTICIDE AFFECTS THE FINANCIAL INSTABILITY AND
HEALTH OF FARMERS AMID THE PANDEMIC
By
Jianne N. Jimenez
October 2021
ii
ABSTRACT
The use of chemical inputs like pesticides has increased agriculture production
and productivity. With the use of Pesticides, it can control different harmful
organisms on the farm. This chemical/s is used by farmers in the cultivation of crops.
However, there was also an increase in negative externalities resulting from such use.
In this paper, the study sought to identify the cause and effect of pesticide use
in the financial instability and health of farmers. Researchers used correlational
research design to determine the extent of relationship between the control and
experiment group. This study examines the paradox and shows how pesticides
influence farmers' financial instability and health during this pandemic.
iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
iv
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
Over the past few years, Corona virus disease or COVID-19 has experienced
rapid growth in the Philippines. The occurrence of this event became most felt by
those who engaged in agriculture. Most farmers use pesticides to kill harmful
organisms so the farmstead can grow. But using this chemical substances to destroy or
kill pest can be beneficial but at the same time it can be very disadvantageous not only
to the health of people who use it but it can also affect the financial instability of
someone who is using pesticide, along with the environment. The pesticide is
natural materials that are not expensive. There are many types of pesticides, but the
most common pesticides that farmers use are organophosphates, carbamates, and
provided it's done through chemicals. In Philippines small farms only use pesticides
that are made from natural materials, some natural materials they used to make
pesticide is from animals, plants and the most common is the bacteria which is kind of
problematic when it comes to health. The continued use of pesticides has resulted in
One evidence that was related to this topic was the study of Antle and Pingali
who conducted a health study consist of two groups of farmers in the Philippines
where they have been using pesticides for over two decades. They found five health
issues in their research. These are eye problems, dermal problems, respiratory
1 1
problems, Neurological problems and lastly Kidney problems.
research study on the effects of pesticide use, people, particularly farmers, who are
overly exposed to this chemical substance can develop serious health problems, which
can have a financial impact owing to medication costs. To summarize, pesticides will
output, but they will have both a positive and negative impact on the people who are
exposed to pesticides. With this issue at hand, this research paper can help future
STABILITY
To better grasp the matter, using pesticide is a smart decision because it can
eliminate pests in the farm. However, too much exposure to pesticide can be quite
dangerous and have a negative impact on one's health, which can also lead to financial
problems. Aktar, Sengupta, and Chowdhury (2019) all agree that pesticides are
generally regarded a quick, easy, and is an economical approach for controlling weeds
and insect pests in the urban landscape, according to their research. Using it can be
simple and effective in growing crops, and it is inexpensive, but being overly exposed
to pesticides can be very costly during this pandemic due to medicine demands if
2
There may be challenges, such as the risks to human health posed by
pesticides. Due to financial constraints, some Farmers do not seek immediate medical
attention if they experience symptoms, especially given the current state of affairs.
Farmers are important because they ensure crop cultivation. Farmers can adapt
quickly due to their agricultural expertise; they know what to do when the weather
seems to be unpredictable. The more time they devote to agriculture, the more
knowledge they gain in this field, but agricultural knowledge and chemical knowledge
Boric Acid, Diazinon, Dursban, Malathion,), and it is obvious that it is not in its
purest form. It is dangerous and expensive, and only a few people have in-depth
knowledge of chemical substances. The thing about here is that when it comes to
persistence in the environment. (Bernardes, Pazin, Pereira and Dorta. 2015). Farmers
work very hard that they are extremely productive in the field. There is evidence that
Philippine farmers do not use pesticides efficiently or safely, which may result in a
health problem. A related study was also conducted as part of a United Nations
Economies. Kim J. (2020) led and carried out the research stated that pesticides and
fertilizers contain toxic content that can harm the environment and human health. Not
3
to mention that the price of crops sold in the Philippines is lower than it was before
the pandemic. The value of agricultural production at constant 2018 prices fell by -3.8
percent in the fourth quarter of 2020. Crops, which accounted for 57.9% of total
agricultural output, contracted by -0.4%. Production of palay and corn fell by -1.4
percent and -0.3 percent, respectively. He also stated that the value of agricultural
production at current prices was PhP 503.8 billion, which was 5.0 percent higher than
the previous year's level (Mapa, 2021). According to their research, the price of the
crops they sell is dropping rapidly during the pandemic, which has a direct impact on
the farmers' earnings. He mentions that the decreasing rate occurred in the fourth
quarter of 2020. Adjusting is easy for farmers, but keeping up during this pandemic
that is affecting not only their health but also their financial earning is decreasing to
endangered species, from pests, according to Damalas. Farms are where fruits,
vegetables, and crops are grown. Farms dealing with bugs, insects, and other pests.
Pesticides are not only harmful to the environment, but they are also harmful to
one's health. (Jakuboski, 2011). Furthermore, pesticides have an impact not only on
human health but also on the environment. There are numerous theories about
they also have negative effects on the environment, including water, soil, and air
4
Eleftherohorinos , 2011).
There are numerous benefits to using pesticides, but there is also a higher risk
severe, people must all consider the greatest risk of something. Despite ongoing
disagreements about the level of risk posed by pesticides, it appears that public
concern about pesticide and other agrichemical use has grown in recent years. When
used incorrectly, all pesticides have the potential to be harmful to humans, animals,
other living organisms, and the environment. (E.S Lorenz. 2017). Despite all of these
increasing rate.
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
This study was conducted to determine how pesticides affect farmers' financial
The framework depicted below shows how the independent variable, pesticide
use, affects the dependent variables, which are financial instability and health of
Financial instability of
farmers
Use of Pesticides
Health of the farmers
Figure 1.0
Research Paradigm
5
STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
This study aims to know how pesticide use affects financial instability,
whether it decreases or increases during the pandemic, as well as the health of farmers
who are overly exposed to pesticides. To be more specific, this study seeks to answer
the following questions:
RESEARCH HYPOTHESIS
This study sought to learn how pesticide use affects farmers' financial instability
during the pandemic, as well as the health of farmers who are overly exposed to
pesticides, which led to the following hypothesis:
Ho: The financial instability of the farmers remain the same during this pandemic
Hµ: The financial instability of the farmers will become unstable during this
pandemic.
Ho: The effect of frequent usage of pesticides to the health of farmers, can have no
effect to their health.
Hµ: The effect of frequent usage of pesticides to the health of farmers, can lead them
to have minor or major health problems.
6
Ho: There is no significant effect between the frequent use of pesticides to the
financial instability of the farmers
Hµ: .There is a significant effect between the frequent use of pesticides to the
financial instability of the farmers.
Ho: There is no significant effect between the frequent use of pesticides to the
financial instability of the farmers.
Hµ: There is a significant effect between the frequent use of pesticides to the financial
instability of the farmers
This study can help broaden the comprehension of the effects of using
pesticides. A farmer’s contribution into one’s society is greatly important, it is stated
by IMPOFF(2020), that farmers are the backbone of the agriculture system, thus
making them an important asset to the country. Knowing this effects may bring the
people some form of protection or financial help to keep them afloat. The
generalization of this study would be a great contribution to the vast knowledge in
relation to the following:
To the Farmers
This raises awareness towards their line of work. They can have a great
benefit in learning this study, as to it can help protect their crops, health as well as
finances.
7
their understanding of the world of agriculture. Students who are studying
agriculture can learn about this research and may as well add into it.
This study focuses on the effects of pesticides on the financial status and
health of selected farmers amid the pandemic. Data will be collected from selected
participants in Manicahan, Zamboanga City. This study will not cover any other
issues that are not considered as a result of the selected farmers' financial situation
and health. The study would be carried out by distributing questionnaires to
participants as a survey and reference tool. The researchers will discover the benefits
and drawbacks of pesticides on the financial status and health of the selected farmers
during the pandemic.
DEFINITION OF TERMS
To deeply scrutinize this research, the following terms are rationally defined:
Pesticide - This refers to the a substance used for destroying insects or other
organisms harmful to cultivated plants or to animals.
Agriculture - This refers to the art and science of cultivating the soil, growing
crops and raising livestock.
8
CHAPTER II
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This chapter describes the research flow, which includes the research design,
RESEARCH DESIGN
This research made use of correlational research design to grasp on the variables
of How Pesticides affect the Financial Instability and Health of Farmers Amid the
Pandemic, presented and produced under the institution of Claret School of
Zamboanga City. The purpose of this correlational research design is to establish and
determine the extent of relationship between the independent and dependent variables
that will be used in this research study. To summarize, a correlational research design
attempts to determine the extent of relationship between two or more variables.
To form this study, the research went through the following steps: Elucidating
Questionnaire, Analysis and Interpretation of Data. Figure 2.0 shows the work
Figure 2.0
A Work Flowchart for the Study
9
REASEARCH INSTRUMENT
information from the Farmers. The researchers created significant questions for the
respondents to fill out in order to collect the necessary information for conducting the
POPULATION SAMPLING
RESEARCH LOCALE
because Internet access would be difficult in the Mountains area, but rest assured that
all of the researchers are fully vaccinated. For this study, the respondents are farmers
who use pesticides and want to share their personal perspectives on how pesticides
The researchers asked permission to conduct this study to the Senior High
School Unit Research Adviser Of Claret School Of Zamboanga City. After the
approval, the researchers had scheduled an appointment with the selected farmers
from Manicahan in Zamboanga City, for the distribution of the survey questionnaires.
The survey questionnaires was personally distributed by the researchers, after all the
10
farmers are done answering, the researchers were to analyze and interpret the results.
accumulated from the survey was interpreted and analyzed through the use of
hypothetical testing. The researchers have collected the results of the survey and
collected data from the questionnaire that was interpreted and correlated.
Table 1.0
Summary of Statistical Tools used in the Study
11
Hµ:The effect of
frequent usage of
pesticides to the health
of farmers, can lead
them to have minor or
major health problems.
Hµ: There is a
significant effect that
can alter the health and
financial instability in
the coming future.
Hµ: There is a
significant effect
between the frequent
use of pesticides to the
financial instability of
12
the farmers.
STATISTICAL TREATMENT
The new data gathered from the questionnaire were calculated and arranged
using the statistical tool which is the hypothetical testing and was inferential
statistical treatment. SPSS was used for the hypothetical testing to see if there are was
Columns and tables were used in data organization and summarization. The
researchers composed an interpretation based on the SPSS results for the hypothetical
testing.
CHAPTER III
This chapter presents the gathered data regarding on how pesticide affects the
financial instability and health of farmers. In this chapter, the researchers will present
the included figures, charts, tables and other tools to present the results of the study.
RESPONDENTS PROFILE
briefly explained on the subject matter by the researchers and was interviewed
formed with the participants who used synthetically-made pesticides, while Group
B(controlled group) was formed with participants who used organically made
pesticides.
13
Table 2.0
Respondents Profile
Group Farmers
Group A 10
Group B 10
Total 20
Shown in Table 2.0 is the profile of the respondents. All participants are Farmers from
USING EXPERIENCE
the survey questionnaire which is based on the two choices of using organic pesticides
and synthetically- made pesticides. It is revealed that 50% (10) of the participants use
synthetically-made pesticide(Group A), claiming to have bought it. The other 50%
made themselves.
14
Figure 3.0 Viewing of the Preference Product of the Farmers
experimental groups are based off the scores of the respondent in the survey
questionnaire. The total result will determine to reject or support the hypothesis and
15
Figure 4.0 Result of the Survey questionnaire
In Figure 4.0 is the result of the survey questionnaire that was answered by the
farmers from Manicahan Zamboanga City. The figure shows that The result of the
control group, 100% (10) participants manage to present the same range scale of 3,
has very similar answers in which it conveyed a stagnant slope of data. The
Experimental group on the other hand, had a more noticeable different set of opinion
in which the data can be seen being slightly more diverse. 60% (6) manage to get the
scale range of 3.07, 20% (2) manage to get the scale range of 3, and last 20% (2)
16
Group No. Of Mean Standard df T-Test Sig.
Participants Score Deviation (n,n-l) (t- Value
Value) (p-
Value)
Experimenta 10 3.09 0.07
l
18 0.002 0.005
Controlled 10 3 0
The mean scores are compared and analyzed using independent sample t-test
using the significant level of 0.05. The mean score of the controlled group
(organically made pesticide) of x=3 is near from the mean score of experimental
groups (synthetically made pesticide) x=3.09 presented in Table 3.0. Using this result,
the number of farmers in controlled group and experimental group is equal white
difference between the controlled and experimental group with p=0.005 where the
significant value is lower than the critical value set at 0.05. With this information, the
null hypothesis (Ho) of problem one, two, three and four are all rejected hence
accepted the alternative hypothesis (Hµ). These result were also evident in the studies
of a global enterprise named Bayer (2022), stated in their articles that consumers are
buying less fresh produce and more processed and canned items with longer shelf life,
following initial strong sales during panic buying waves that will affect the driving
down agricultural market prices; therefore rejecting the null hypothesis (Ho) of the
first problem and accepting its alternative hypothesis (Hµ) indicating that the financial
instability of the farmers will become unstable during this pandemic. In the study of
P.N Stamati, Maipas, Kotampasi, P Stamatis and Hens (2016), it was stated there that
The need for pest control is self-evident, and its origins can be traced back to
antiquity, when both organic and chemical substances were used as pesticides and
17
there was a major effect or impact in the health of people. Hence, rejecting the null
hypothesis (Ho) of the second problem and accepting its alternative hypothesis (Hµ)
indicating that the effect of frequent usage of pesticides to the health of farmers, can
lead them to have minor or major health problems. For the third problem, rejecting the
null hypothesis (Ho) and accepting alternative hypothesis (Hµ) indicating that there is
a significant effect that can alter the health and financial instability in the coming
future. This was also evident in the studies of Hughes (2021), he indicated that using
pesticides have been shown to have negative effects on the environment. Furthermore,
there is mounting evidence of harm to human health. Since the critical value is set at
0.5, with p=0.005, seen in Table 3.0, therefore rejecting the null hypothesis( Ho) of
the fourth problem and accepting its alternative hypothesis that indicates that there is
a significant effect between the frequent use of pesticides to the financial instability of
the farmers.
18
CHAPTER IV
researchers from the analyzed data and recommendations necessary for the
improvement in determining how pesticides effects the financial instability and health
of the farmers amid the pandemic that was tested through survey questionnaire.
SUMMARY
instability and health of the farmers amid the pandemic. The purpose of this study is
to determine the relationship between how pesticides affects the financial instability
and health of the farmers. The needed data for this study, with the use of a controlled
group along with the experimental group is conducted in the surrounding areas from
participate within this study as they were split into 2 groups— namely Group A which
presenting the control group which uses organically-made pesticides, each group has
10 participants that has answered our survey questionnaire.After the test scores are
collected and tallied, inferential statistical treatments are used to determine the
difference between the survey scores of the controlled and experimental groups such
Based from the acquired results, the control group, 100% (10) participants
manage to present the same range scale of 3, has very similar answers in which it
19
conveyed a stagnant slope of data. The Experimental group on the other hand, had a
more noticeable different set of experience in which the data can be seen being
slightly more diverse. 60% (6) manage to get the scale range of 3.07, 20% (2) manage
to get the scale range of 3, and last 20% (2) managed to get the scale range of 3.21.
According to the statistical analysis of the results from the survey questionnaire, the
a>0.05, where p=0.05 which means that there is a significant difference since the
mean scores of both classes have 0.9 difference from each other. The significant
difference is from using paired sample t – test and provides a clear distinction and
difference between controlled group and experimental group scores. This shows that
the financial instability and health of the farmers amid the pandemic.
CONCLUSION
The researchers have concluded that pesticide use has a substantial impact on
farmers' health and financial stability during the pandemic. This can be based on the
results of the survey questionnaire given to the farmers, which showed that the
experimental group had a greater result than the controlled group. Having to use the
statistical analysis using independent t-test, statistical result show that there is a small
significant difference between the controlled and experimental group where the
critical value of 0.05 is greater than the significant value at p=0.005. This result to the
acceptance of the alternative hypotheses of problem one, two, three and four,
indicating that using pesticide do bear significant effect to the health and financial
20
RECOMMENDATION
affect the financial instability and health of farmers amid the pandemic, the
21
REFERENCES
Antle, J.M., Pingali, P.L. (n.d.). Pesticides, Productivity, and Farmer Health: A
Philippine Case Study. Retrieved from
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.2307/1243654
Stamati, P.N., Maipas, S., Kotampasi, C., Stamatis, P., Hens, L. (2016). Chemical
Pesticides and Human Health: The Urgent Need for a New Concept in Agriculture.
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2016.00148/full
Aktar, Md. W., Senguota, D., Chowdhurry, A. (2009). Impact of pesticides use in
agriculture: their benefits and hazards. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21217838/
Bernardes, M.F.F., Pazin, M., Pereira, L.C., Dorta , D.J. (2014). Impact of Pesticides
on Environmental and Human Health. https://www.intechopen.com/chapters/48406
Damalas, C.A., Eleftherohorinos, L.G. (2011). Pesticide Exposure, Safety Issues, and
Risk Assessment Indicators. https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/8/5/1402/htm
Hughess, D., Jordan, S., Turnbull, N. (2021). Health impacts of pesticides use.
https://www.researchgate.net/project/Health-impacts-of-pesticides-use
22
McCoy, T.(2020).Organic vs. Conventional (Synthetic) Pesticides: Advantages and
Disadvantages. Virginia Cooperative Extension.
https://www.pubs.ext.vt.edu/content/dam/pubs_ext_vt_edu/ENTO/ento-384/ENTO-
384.pdf
Journals. https://academicjournals.org/article/article1380540217_Damalas.pdf
23
Pimentel, D.(2015).Environmental and Economic Costs of the Application of
Pesticides Primarily in the United States.SpringerLink.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10668-005-7314-2
Bastian, C., Coatney, K., Mealor, R., and etc.(2014).Priority of nature versus finances
in land management attitudes of rural exurban landowners.Landscape and Urban
Planning. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0169204614000838
24
APPENDIX A:Letter for Respondents
25
APPENDIX B:Permission Letter
26
A P P E N D I X C: Survey Questions
9. Pesticides causes an
reaction/irritation when in contact
or when exposed .
27
12. Pesticides is certainly not a
factor in my health
issues/problems.
28
APPENDIX D: Acceptance Letter
29
CURRICULUM VITAE
Personal Profile:
Nickname: Cass
Zamboanga City
Alfred B. Abalos
Educational Background:
2018-2022
2010-2016
30
CURRICULUM VITAE
Personal Profile:
Nickname: Trixie
Educational Background:
2016-2022
2010-2016
31
CURRICULUM VITAE
Personal Profile:
Nickname: Ji or Jay
Joey O. Jimenez
Educational Background:
2017-2022
2010-2016
32