Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Michel Solien Variance Requests To Hubbard County Planning Commission
Michel Solien Variance Requests To Hubbard County Planning Commission
g
.2.
'
. . .
~ Variance Coilntyp??ronme
A Iication
HUBB_A_R9 Hubbard Services
ntal
am rggtirv um. V-5Ci"l4 Mtl '64 -'’i
\' _ ' A/I3
‘ -
Phone we r -,2 Wir.
vvww co hiibbairl US’(J‘;‘pr”lnlCHl</9l'\‘./I!’/7lVl’lE'r7l3l_S@(’J nrlw (mp
‘
rnii ta:
l am requesting a variance in regard to Hubbard County Shoreland Management Ordinance No. 17,
Amendment 20, Section 402. Special Provisions, Item 7, D. and any other related ordinances which
requires one centralized sewage system to service a proposed campground and allow to multiple
systems be installed at my proposed campground and property at the recommendation of an advance
septic system designer and septic system installer / contractor for the most environmental friendly and
efficient system to service the campground. Campground /property layout with septic and mound
system design is attached.
i neeoy swim am UK: we we owl'\&' of the abovodesclibod property or he authorized agent lheleol an-:1 agreu to In 5 avptica! 5; = 31.) wd"di'l
(Pal I . .is.~...i- ll'.J' l AF“ as-1-i :96 :w
.,v.«;it-,v my to 695'’; ‘or :re ..-ii arm r. question By timing this applimlion lmraby canily mat lhe inloinnaliorvcontained ill rm; gppl ,3
~. r_ 4 ran: 10! .e'r rig mo ycposcr: variance application lhereby state and affirm that any and an ape! riiticns sketches son:-»_.s and :
it .117] at me information providod by me in this implication is later louno oi daterrrii
'
*
'41: l _i.g.;.i=i;,i-q i«.,;:
._ _.,,
A ,3, my. 6 94 -,4 1 ,r.ar~.oes I cerlily and agree that I will comply with any and all conditions imposed in can
¢,d[)f'llf audit and ;xur.e'1y r.‘.esaipl.orii Sxopevly surveys silo plm building plans or omerinformation as deem-2 I i\<:~ce>s:iry Fly the imxiviiy tor “lC‘i'V. :
Signature of applicant(s):
For Office Use
Application date:
"
A lication
u
*
Variance CountypEEronm
u n
Hubbard Services
.
\
~ . I
W ,
vwvw
.
co hubbarri
.A
._
inn
ental
H01Court/Xve Park Rapids MN 544 1'1
Phone 718 I27 win
us."lopattrrientstenvimrirnenta|__serv=ms’ir'l°I
. , .. ;_.J,,c._
, _ ._., _ .
r.i'*n
Note: Place an X’ by each item below that applies to your request Then. fill out only the applicable
following sectiomsl that apply, as directed. If a section does not apply to your request, leave it blank.
What is the reason(s) for applying for the variance? Place an “X" by each applicable item.
536Setback issues complete Section 1
,7 Land or vegetative alteration: complete Section 2
if Lot size not in compliance with minimum Ordinance standards. complete Section 3
if Alteration to nonconforming structure: complete Section 4
LE Other attach separate sheet explaining variance request
i Section 1
Check the item(s) from which you are requesting a variance and fill in the proposed setback distance
’
Setbacks are measured to the nearest point on a structure which can be the eave overhang or an attached
deck/platform.
13.7Ordinary High Water Mark (OHWM) Proposed Setback ‘O0 ft
I Lot line Proposed Setback ft
I Road Right of Way Twp Co State Proposed Setback ft
2 Crest of bluff Proposed Setback ft
2 Septic system components (new SSTS site design must accompany variance application)
Section 2
What is your land alteration’? Check all categories that apply.
I Vegetative alteration
Ci Grading/filling
c; Other (Attach separate sheet explaining the land alteration)
Note: An additional cross-section sketch showing L, W, and H dimensions and an itemized list showing
volume (cubic yds.) of all proposed grading/filling must accompany application.
Section 3
When was your lot created (month/day/year)? (This information can be found in your abstract
of title A copy of either this first deed or page in the abstract must be included in your application.)
Note: An ISTS site design showing your proposed building site, well location. a primary drainfield site, and
an alternate drainfield site must be included in your application for a lot size variance
Section 4
Note: A sketch showing L, W, and H dimensions of all portions of the existing and proposed structure(s)
and addition(s) must be included in your application.
Circle all that apply and fill in requested information:
Existing structure Proposed addition(s)
Foundation: basement. crawlspace. slab on grade Foundation" basement, crawlspace. slab on grade
Stories above ground ground level, 1 ‘/2.two Stories above ground ground level. 1 ‘/2.two
Existing structure height‘ _ ft Proposed addition(s) height‘ _ ft
Existing # bedrooms __ Final it bedrooms after remodel __
Updated 0 i 301/2122
I" I I I I I I I I I I I I I I N
I/ dcfg/Kggyg?
farm?
5”‘7L%
4’.//Ia’?0/6’/CU/‘/I4/L715
I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
You must include all structures and additions, welI(s). and septic system(s) existing and proposed. on your property
and label them You must also include all dimensions (including height) of the structures as well as all setbacks to
property lines. lakes or rivers, roads, and any other pertinent setbacks See reverse side of “Site Plan" for example sketch
. »
_v ~ Click the "Submit Form" button to the left to submit the application and a new email message will open with the
completed application attached. Please attach the site drawing, the ground-level color photographs, and any
other necessary paperwork to this e-mail before submitting
"
Click the "Reset Form" button to the left to clear all Information from the form
_ Updated 01/01/2022
.
iav?ans13,‘ "
--—(o.
Page 682 of 785
O 1N3W39VN\1W NOIDHMSNOD 0 NOll3]dSN|'|VJ.N3WNOMIl\N3 D S33lI\lBS3N|Ed|d 0
atsssi eamauum tram"-H1,490: me ‘on; 1
E8029 |N\ ‘NV/OAOSHI-IS NMOHS SV
:zuz/ no/so u3A03 'a:sx ‘nuoua NV'|d :I'lL3S Java
ZLL#avoa JKEITIVA rzozl nc/Lo M1530 SNIGHIOnus
HHHLVEH 5082 QZOZ/E/BIJLVO 3N3SN3LS'V IAE G3>133H3 :zaz/ VZ/LO A?0AV‘I Olh?s 01 saanwo
rxanos 13H3Iw {ZOZ/E/9 BLVG EJNVISW 5A8 ONIGVEIO
SZOZ/OZ/L0
szoz/o I/LO
::3=r—z‘a~a'.4aa
10¢
an uzxum Hid
40
SIJNVHQ DIVW
aaxuvwuse szarm-«:3 zxm
{Z02/E/9 i31vG N3OWS?HAN')1 TAEINMVEICI
0 9NI13?OW?'E 0 DNINNVJSISESVICPE 0 9NIddVWA.L|'||J.? 0 NO|J.V30'|A.LHIJ.? 0 NO|Ld|EICJSI-IO
380i G3EiVd3&Id
I-U.d3(] NI TIVLS Q l D!
ESVHVD O3H3V13G 'I'IVLS’E _____
/,
L .
"’40o’ watt DISTANCE(wu\
\
arvnaiv03SDdD¢‘Jd
« «
, armorva3soI.-load
» »
R « «
K
\“ M"
» »
mm aysodaad
« «
\
?is?iz“
xoveu “
‘
—
\
\\______4
\ 3 EIN\'/‘I
»‘V9V513\S
\ \
mm 30199?»9; T§’z\
'§'sv';;«§s‘
“‘~(ans
Page 683 of 785
E NOLMIIJSIG um3’esnpiu'MMM ;qaM
— LDEIZ‘ON DH
,
NVNHZNJ M133].
1,}
3‘“'3"ld
96Zl‘LVS‘9LZ
seossIM ’ue5I<oq9us
ZLL# 'Pl‘-’°HKane/\
/
/’If \ J9'~4199H
608E
/
‘VIDSINNIW£0
EHJ.HSGNH IDA!/M05 GNV1 OESNSDTI
3.LVJ.SEH110 SMV1
ATHCIV WVI .l.VH.l
uauosa>|1w
AVE) 5U°!3E|"‘3lE3 we uau pvv CINVN0lS|I\H3d|'\S JJEHICIAW HZCINH30 EN AB Gik?dilld
SVM lM0d3H ED NV'ld 'I\3I\H?S §lH1 IVHJ. MIDI!) A3/\?:|?S :10 E|.LVC)|:i|.LHED
AEENEH I
Page 684 of 785
0 LNBWSSIVNVWNOIDHHLSNOD 0 NOUJ3dSNl1VJ.N3WNOU|l\N3 0 S33!/RES 3NI1]dld 0
L909?
1
g?ifi zjeoaa-inn
ma $9099 wx‘NVOAOEEIHS "ON mjroac: as/vw
ZLL#avoa x311v/\
EHHLVHH 6089
ccoz/9z/90 33iVG 9Nv1s‘w rxa C]3)D3H3 tzuz/oz/to an aaxuvu mad szuuvna JIM
Na?os73H3nw a3ar—t‘o~¢‘.4au
{zoz/9z/90 3EliVO N3OWSr1HAN'>I we NMVEJCI czoz/on/to Add an OJIUWI 81¢ szsmma zxvw
0 9Nl130OWl]'E 0 9NlNNVJSN35V‘lG‘E 0 9N|ddVWA.L|1lln 0 N0|i\7301ALl1un D NOlLd|?5I)S3G
580.-I G38Vd38d
Page 685 of 785
Transfer Entered On 2[14[2022 A000422273
HUBBARD COUNTY, MINNESOTA
( X )eCRV ( )N/A
CERTIFIED, FILED, AND] OR
( X)NoDelinquentTaxes ( )N/A RECORDED ON
( )CurrentTaxes Paid In Full (X)N/A 2/14/2022 1:37:45 PM
Lauren Anderson, Hubbard County Recorder LAUREN ANDERSON
HUBBARD COUNTY RECORDER
BY RLB DeP”tV av TK Dep PAGEs: 3
Parcel N°' 16'08'0°710
wELL DISCL RECD
MTG REG TAX PD 0.00 s
DEED TAx PD 1; 876.15
TAx EXEMPT
DOCUMENT RECORDED ELECTRONICALLY
eCRVnumber: il _ M
DATE: )
IWTMMI-'i'l
FORVALUABLE
CONSIDERATION. strata Trust Company.CustodianFBOBurtonPalmerFosse, Jr., IRA11201416361
(insertnameofsranlorj
{lnsonnamaareachGrantee)
(‘Grantee’).
as
E] renams
incommon. (Innate thanoneGrameeis namedabovaandeimsrnabox ‘Gcheckedorbatnboxasare checked,
lCv‘|9'=*00lY0?'-'
901-} .. rhisoorwaysncairmadelolllenauredsmlees oslunanfslncomnm.)
8 joint tenants.
SEEATTACHED
EXHl8lT
"A"
togetherwithallhereditaments
and appurtenances belongingthereto.subjaci to the following
exceptions:
Page 1 of 3
Checkapplicable
box: Grantor
E TheSellercerti?esthatthe Sellerdoes not knowof any wellson State Trust Company,CustodianFBOBurton PalmerFuses, Jr.. IRA
thedescribed
realproperty. l20141B361
D A welldisclosure
certi?cateaccompaniesthis documentor has """"‘°'°
?led.(ifelectmnicaily
beenelectronically ?led,insertWDC
3,.
”“"‘”°'- -) (mm)
D I am familiarwiththe propertydescribedIn thisinstrumentand I
certifythatthe status and numberof wellson the described
reat 353WW9 9° ‘"3951 W’
propertyhave not changed since melast previously?led welt M‘°""'-"°‘*Y}
disdosurecerti?cate.
By:
(5"P?3‘|l|‘l’}1
Its:
{W9‘WWW
StateofTexas,Countyof
Thisinstrument
wasacknowledgedbeforeme on
mead
W/titm
cotrmm
(name of authorized
sinner)
(Sbmp)
(ssgnuumuorurnr
CFHSSY D. FORE-TESTER
Notary Public, State or Texas “"9 (W 33"”:
a
-
2&5Comm.Expires 07-31-2022
13°‘ Notary ID 124533253
THtSINSTRUMENT WASDRAETED
BY: TAXSTATEMENTS
FORTHEREALPROPERTY
DESCRIBED
INTHIS
(insertname and addmssi INSTRUMENT
SHOULDBESENTTO:
(ins:-1toga!name md residendaterttuslness addressof Grantee)
HubbardCountyAhstract 8.Closing,Inc. MichelSolienand MihaelaSolienmarriedto each other
$16 West ThirdStreet +-H-1-Meedowhraek-Br'ive
Park Rapids, MN56470 Mf
FileNumber21-8584 go 0‘ ?o1*H
7-
_
oxiga/\WI 53 0&3
Six?io
EXHlBlT
“A”
Commencingat a 2 and one-heii inch diameteraluminumcapped ironmonumentat the southwestcornerat said GovernmentLot3 as
describedin that Certi?cateof Locationof Governmentcorner on fileand of record as DocumentNo.A000382662 in the Officeof the
Recorderin and for said county, and state:thence south 88°48'11" East, hearingsbased uponthe Hubbardcounty CoordinateSystem
(NAD83-1998 adjustment),alongthe southlineof saidGovernmentLot3 and Government Lot4.a distanceof 2648.15feet to a 3 inch
squarealuminumcappedironmonumentat the southeast comer of said GovernmentLot 4 described in that Certificateof Locationof
GovernmentCorneron ?le and of record as DocumentNo.AD00368466 insaid Oflice;thence returningNorth83°48'11" West, along said
south line,1154.69feetto a one-haltinchdiameteriron rehar monumentwithplasticcap stamped “LINDOW 47924‘and the POINT OF
BEG|NhllNG of the llnetobe described;thenceNorth41°37'44' ‘East623.25feet to a one-halfinchdiameteriron rebar monumentwith
plasticcap stamped 'LlNDOW 47924";thence continuing North41°37'44' East 47 feet, moreor lac. to the shoreline of PlckerelLake and
said linethere tenninating.
Subjectto, and together with,a 33 foot wideeasement as describedin Book100of Deeds, page 348 on file and of recordin said Office.
HUBBARD
COUNTY,
MINNESOTA
ABSTRACT
PROPERTY
25848 Holly Rd
Park Rapids MN 56470
E911 Address:
25848 Holly Rd
Park Rapids MN 56470
SOLIEN RV PARK
PID 16.08.00710
—
7/17/2023
FLOW CALCULATIONS: FULL HOOK UP RV SITE 100GPD, REMOTE SITE 50GPD. TANKS SIZED
AT 3 DAYS FLOW RETENTION. DRAINFIELDS AT EACH SITE WILL BE DIVIDED INTO EQUAL
PARTS TO IMPROVE REST TIMES, REDUCE GROUND WATER MOUNDING AND
ENVIRONMENTAL RISK.
A NEW 5” DEEP WELL WILL BE INSTALLED WITH A WATER METER TO TRACK DAILY FLOWS.
TIME DOSE CONTROL PANELS WILL BE INSTALLED ON EACH LIFT STATION.
COLLECTION LINES WILL BE PLUMBED FROM SITE 1-15 AND THE SHOWER HOUSE WITH 4”
SCH 40 TO A 3200GAL +2250GAL + 2250GAL SEPTIC TANK WITH EFFLUENT FILTER AND ALARM.
2250GAL LIFT TANK WITH DUAL PUMPS, SWITCHING VALVE, TIME DOSE CONTROL PUMPING
TO 3- 10X69.5 PRESSURE MOUNDS WITH 20” LIFT, PRESSURE CLEANOUTS AND ACCESS BOXES.
COLLECTION LINES WILL BE PLUMBED FROM SITE 15-23 WITH 4” SCH40 TO 3-2250GAL SEPTIC
TANKS WITH EFFLUENT FILTER & ALARM, 225OGAL LIFT TANK WITH DUAL PUMPS, TIME
DOSE CONTROL PUMPING TO 2—10X77.1PRESSURE MOUNDS WITH 20” LIFT, PRESSURE
CLEANOUTS AND ACCESS BOXES.
CONSIDERED TO BE REDUNDANT WITH THE FLOWS FROM THE SHOWER HOUSE THEREFORE
THE DUMP STATION IS BASED ON THE FOLLOWING CALCULATION: 10 SITES X SOGPD X 5
TIMES DAILY FLOW = 2500. INSTALL A 3200 GALLON HOLDING TANK WITH ALARM. REMOTE
CAMP SITE FLOWS TO THE HOLDING TANK ARE EXPECTED TO BE MUCH LOWER AS FLOWS
WILL BE SPLIT BETWEEN THE HOLDING TANK DUMPING AND THE SHOWER HOUSE.
Provertv°wner=
Site Address:
— We
_
PID: 16~08.00710
wvvw.SepticResource.com (vers 22.2)
I)
-bedroom Type '2 Residential System
2) GPDdesign flow 1850COMBINED
3) Garbage disposal or pumped to septic _j 5: V’
“
‘ 5.; :_
4) 5550 Gal Septic tank (code minimum) 6750 Gal Septic tank (design size / LUGreq'd)
Tank options: none
5)
-GPD/ftzmound sand loading rate contour loading rate of req's a min ft. long rockbed
6)
ft rockbed width ft rockbed length
7)
ft lateral spacing ft perforation spacing (maximum of 3 for both)
manifold connection
8)
laterals feet long perfs / lateral perfs total
9)
10)
3/ 16 inch perfs at [:lfeet residual head
for this perf size & spacing, & pipe size on line 12, max perfs/lateral
I2)
inch diameter laterals must be used to meet "4x pipe volume" requirement
)3)
-feet of inch supply line leads to gallons of drainback volume
(Tip: "top feed" manifold to control the drainback)
14) gallons TOTAL pump out volume (treatment + drainback)
17) 1850 gal Dose tank (code minimum) 2250 gal Dose tank (design size / LUGreq'd) at gpi
leads to a; Optional Time dosing of:
)3)
inch swing on Demand float, (this delivers Average flow, =70%of Peak design flow)
1229 gallons reserve capacity (after High Level Alarm is activated«demand dosed)
25) -inches, or ft. to Redox or other limiting condition (need at least 12" to be a Type I)
Treatment zone containsl:|inches
of 0% soil credit, and Einches of 50% soil credit. Giving a:
26) inch, or ft. Sand Lift Mound CRITICALFOR FUTURECERTIFICATIONS!!!
—————— --
Limiting Condition
Note:
For 0 to 1% slopes, Absorption W/'0’:/7is measured from the Bed equally in both directions.
For slopes >1%, Absorption Width is measured downhill from the upslope edge of the Bed.
36) Topsoil:
ft. by ft. 6" deep, plus 20% gives Yd’ OF *1-4= 151 ton
ompleted this work in accordance with all applicable ordinances, rules and laws.
Note;
For 0 to 1% slopes, Absorption H/id:/7is measured from the Bed equally in both directions.
For slopes >196, Absorption W/cf.-f/2
is measured downhill from the upslope edge of the Bed
Sewer line & tank connection (no hard 90's, long sweep 90 or 2-45's, slope minimum 1" in 8' = 1%)
(no depth req's, clean out every 100', Sch 40 pipe)
Septic tank and risers (water tight risers, baffles, insulated, proper depth, existing verified by pumping)
mfg 6750 gallons none
Riser over outlet, riser over inlet or center, and 6"+ inspection pipe over any remaining baffles.
No effluent filter & alarm
Dose tank, risers and piping (water tight risers, insulated, proper depth, drainback)
mfg 2250 gallons
Optional Time dosing of:
dose pump 33 gpm 17 head VERIFYPUMPCURVE 5.7 min ON 3.4 hr OFF
verify that installed "vertical lift from pump to lateraIs" is no more than design value of 11 feet
float setting drop 3.3 inches at gpi "DESIGNED" 2.7 inches approx float tether length
188.0 gal dose divided by gpi "|NSTALLED" = inches float drop (field corrected
LABEL pump requirements and drawdown on riser or panel
Cam lock reachable from grade 30" max. J-hook weep hole. Supply line access (no hard 90's)
—
2.0 inch supply pipe: Sch40, sloped 1/ 8"+, supported by 4" sch40 sleeve or compacted, and buried 6"+.
splice box / control panel / electrical connections / Hi Level Alarm
flow measurement: CT, ETM, time dosed, home water meter
mound absorption area rough up
mound rock dimensions 10.0 X 77.1
Sand lift depth 20 inches. (Jar test : 2" sand leaves < 1/8" silt after 30 min)
Air inlet at end of laterals, and at top feed manifold if necessary. VERIFY
clean outs (no hard 90's)
4" inspection pipe to bottom of rock, anchored VERIFY
Owner Information
Date 7/14/2023 Sec / Twp / Rng 8/141/34
Parcel ID 16-08.00710 LUG (county, city, township) HUBBARD
Property Owner: SOLIEN RV PARK Owners address (if different)
Existing & proposed lot Yes No Well casing depth NEW DEEP
improvements located (see site map)
Utilities located & identi?ed Yes N0 Buried water supply pipe Yes No
(gopher state one call) w/in 50' of system
Soil treatment area protected Yes No Site map prepared with J Yes No
previous items included
Construction related issues SEE COMMENTARYPAGE AND SURVEY
_...j_.
Evidenceof site:
Cut Yes J No
Filled Yes 2 No
Compacted Yes 7 No
Disturbed Yes “ N0
I hereby certg?zthis evaluaz“ eted in accordance with MN 7080 and any local req’s.
NORTHLAND 549
Designer Signature Company License #
Parent mat1's: ‘
Soil Log #1
30mg J Pit Elevation 98.57 Depth to SHWT
Depth (in) Texture fragment % matrix color redox color consistence grade shape
Commentsz
IOYR3/2
<35
35 50
:9:
‘a '3
loose
weak
single grain
granular blocky
prismatic platy
—
moderate
>50 massive
strong
0-3
Designer Signature
‘z// NORTHLAND
Company
549
License #
I hereby certij?zthis work wa 0 n accordance with MN 7080 and any local req '5.
NORTHLAND 549
Designer Signature Company License #
Keep this Management Plan with your Septic System Owner’s Guide. The Septic System Owner’s Guide
includes a folder to hold maintenance records including pumping, inspection and evaluation reports. Ask
your septic professional to also:
0 Attach permit information, designer drawings and as-built of your system, if they are available.
0 Keep copies of all pumping records and other maintenance and repair invoices with this document.
0 Review this document with your maintenance professional at each visit; discuss any changes in product
use, activities, or water-use appliances.
For a copy of the Septic System Owner '3 Guide, visit www.bookstores.umn.edu and search for the word
“septic” or call 800-322-8642.
'
Crosrsec?on ofnmnd
= V
-
lnspeclionpipr
'
‘
Number of bedrooms:
Dwelling Type Well Construction
Well depth (ft): NEW DEEP
!
System capacity/ design flow (gpd): 1350 El Cased well Casing depth:
Anticipated average daily flow (gpd): 600 D Other (specify):
CommentsCAMPGROUND Distance from septic (ft):
Business? : ©Y ON What type? Is the well on the design drawing? i SY5 N
Septic Tank
Cl First tank Tank volume: 2250 gallons CI Pump Tank 2250 gallons
0
Does tank have two compartments?
Second tank Tank volume: 2250
OY@ N CI Effluent Pump make/model:Z0E'-LER152
gall0ns+3?'0 Pump capacity 33 GPM
Cl Tank is constructed of CONCRETE TDH 17 Feet of head
Y O N Alarm @Y
D
Effluentscreen:® O N El Alarm location CONTROL PANEL
-45 ft x __107 ft
9 "‘
Rock bed size (width x length): 10 ft x 77-1 ft Inspection ports Cleanouts
Location of additional STA: ADJACENT
;‘
Your toilet is not a garbage can. Do not ?ush anything besides human waste and toilet paper. No wet
wipes, cigarette butts, disposal diapers, used medicine, feminine products or other trash!
Your service provider or pumper/maintainer should evaluate if your tank needs to be pumped more or less
often.
Seasonally or several times per year
Leaks. Check (listen, look) for leaks in toilets and dripping faucets. Repair leaks promptly.
Soil treatment area. Regularly check for wet or spongy soil around your soil treatment area. If
surfaced sewage or strong odors are not corrected by pumping the tank or ?xing broken caps and
leaks, call your service professional. Untreated sewage may make humans and animals sick. Keep
bikes, snowmobiles and other traffic off and control borrowing animals.
Alarms. Alarms signal when there is a problem; contact your service professional any time the
alarm signals.
Lint?lter.If you have a lint ?lter, check for lint buildup and clean when necessary. If you do not
have one, consider adding one after washing machine.
Ef?uent screen. If you do not have one, consider having one installed the next time the tank is
cleaned along with an alarm.
Annually
Water usage rate. A water meter or another device can be used to monitor your average daily water
use. Compare your water usage rate to the design ?ow of your system (listed on the next page).
Contact your septic professional if your average daily ?ow over the course of a month exceeds 70%
of the design flow for your system.
Caps. Make sure that all caps and lids are intact and in place. Inspect for damaged caps at least
every fall. Fix or replace damaged caps before winter to help prevent freezing issues.
Water conditioning devices. See Page 5 for a list of devices. When possible, program the recharge
frequency based on water demand (gallons) rather than time (days). Recharging too frequently
may negatively impact your septic system. Consider updating to demand operation if your system
currently uses time,
Reviewyottr water usage rate. Review the Water Use Appliance chart on Page 5. Discuss any major
changes with your service provider or pumper/maintainer.
-3-
Pump and controls. Check to make sure the pump and controls are operating correctly.
Pump vault. Check to make sure it is in place; clean per manufacturer recommendations.
Alarm. Verify that the alami works.
Drainback. Check to make sure it is draining properly.
Event counter or elapsed time meter. Check to see if there is an event counter or elapsed
time
meter for the pump. If there is one or both, calculate the water usage rate
and compare to the
anticipated use listed on Design and Page 2. Dose Volume: 138 gallons: Pump run time:
57 Minutes
o Finely-ground solids may not settle. e To prevent solids from exiting the tank, have your
spread your
laundry loads throughout the week.
i
- Powdered and/or high-phosphorus o Use gel detergents. Powdered detergents may add
detergents can negatively impact the solids to the tank.
Perfmmahcc °f)’°U1'l3hk and 50” - Use detergents that are low or no-phosphorus.
Dishwasher
treatment area‘ - Wash only full loads.
.
' New models promote _n° S°ra_pm.g ‘
- Scrape your dishes anyways to keep undigested
They have a garbagedisposal inside. Solids out Ofyour septic System.
i a Finely-ground solids may not settle. o Expand septic tank capacity by a factor of 1.5.
Grmde‘ Pump 0“ Unsettled 30hd5_Cah exit the tank - Include pump monitoring in your maintenance
home) and enter the S011f1‘€'<1tmentaFea- schedule to ensure that it is working properly.
o Add an effluent screen.
- Large volume of water may - Avoid using other water-use appliances at the same
Large bathtub overload your system. time. For example, don’t wash clothes and take a
(whiripoon - Heavy use of bath oils and soaps can bath at the Same hm‘?-
impact biological activity in your o Use oils, soaps, and cleaners in the bath or shower
H1gh'ef?ClehCY - Drip may result in frozen pipes o Re-route water directly out of the house. Do not
furnace during cold weather. route furnace discharge to your septic system.
Water softener - Salt in reehar 3e water ma Y affect o These sources produce water _ that is not sewa 3e and
_
Iron ?lm. system performance. should not go into your septic system.
Reverse Osmosis - Recharge water may hydraulically o Reroute water from these sources to another outlet,
Surface drainage
. overload the system.
Water from these sources will
overload the system and is
such as a dry well, draintile or old drainfield.
- When replacing, consider using a demand-based
recharge vs. a time-based recharge.
F°°hh8 draihs pfohibif?d from entering Septic - Check valves to ensure proper operation; have unit
system. serviced per manufacturer directions
- 5 -
H5.‘
‘ in
Hill-3 :4-;yn:5)n!1\$§u v!
..'\
‘ x »
. m
»
IHJ“ .
o :1,’
‘ .\.‘
xi
Provertv°wner= — °ate= —
Site Address: PID: 16.08.00710
Gal Septic tank (code minimum) Gal Septic tank (design size / LUG req'd)
Tank options: none
-GPD/ftzmound sand loading rate contour loading rate of req's a min ft. long rockbed
3/ 16 inch perfs at feet residual head gives gpm flow rate per perforation
for this perf size & spacing, & pipe size on line 12, max perfs/lateral = , line #3 must be [e55 "> OK
inch diameter laterals must be used to meet "4x pipe volume" requirement
Sfeet feet
29
vertical lift from pump to mound‘laterals, leads to a:
GPM @ of head, Pump requirement (note: >50gpm
may require an extra 3-6‘ of head)
lgalDose tank (code minimum) 2250 gal Dose tank (design size / LUGreq'd) at gpi
[eads to 3; Optional Time dosing of:
3.0 Iinch swing on Demand float, (this delivers Average flow, =70% of Peak design flow)
-—:IlA/.lE—_DOS%“ "
15 inches from bottom of tank to "Pump ON" float inches to "Timer ON" ?oat
18 inches from bottom of tank to “Hi Level" float inches t0 "Hi LeVei"fi0at
1229 gallons reserve capacity (after High Level Alarm is activated-demand dosed)
7)
ft.Total ABSORPTION
width (with sand beyond rockbed as follows:)
23)
ft. upslope and sideslope
ft. Downslope
Individual slope ratios give BERMwidths (topsoil beyond rockbed) of:
upslope ratio ft. upslope berm
. sideslope ft. sideslope berms
31) downslope ft. downslope berm
32) Overall Dimensions: 10.0 ft. wide by ft. long Rock bed
40 ft. wide by ft. long Mound footprint
Depth to Limiting
L1'm“itin‘§7fo-naingn l
“
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ , _
_
W
‘
Absortion Width
'FoTCJi"to
1% slopes, Absorption W/‘aw:is measured from the Bedequally in both directions.
For slopes >195, Absorption W/'0’!/7is measured downhill from the upslope edge of the Bea’.
33) Rock Bed:
ft. by ft. by l:linches under pipe, plus 20% gives Yd’ or *1.4=
ton
34) Mound Sand: (note: volume is based on 3:1/4:1 slope from top of rockbed, Exchange sand for loamy cap if desired)
up + downslope +
ends +
under rock = yd‘ 0|’ *1-4= ton
plus 20%
35) Loamy Cap:
ft. by ft. 6" deep, plus 20% gives
Yd’ OF *1-4= ton
36) Topsoil:
ft. by ft. 6" deep, plus 20% gives yd‘ or *1-4=
ton
GPM @
ft. of head, Pump required
inch swing on Demand float which translates to roughly inches of float tether length
minutes ON
inches from bottom of tank to "pump ON" float, or 1.6 hours OFF
inches from bottom of tank to "Hi Level Alarm" or inches to "timer ON"float
inches to "Hi level" float
20 ft. of inch supply line with manifold connection
(Tip: "top feed" manifold to control drainback)
20 inch, or it. Sand Lift Mound
10.0 ft. wide by
3 laterals inch diameter ft. long ft. lateral spacing
3/16 inch perfs ft. perforation spacing
twin; teams;
i
~ -
?9_te_:._
For 0 to 1% stopes, Absorption Width is measured from the Bea’ equally in both directions.
For slopes >1%, Absorption W/‘dtfzis measured downhill from the upslope edge of the Bed.
Sewer line & tank connection (no hard 90's, long sweep 90 or 2—45's,slope minimum 1" in 8' =
1%)
(no depth req's, clean out every 100', Sch 40 pipe)
3
Septic tank and risers (water tight risers, baffles, insulated, proper depth, existing
verified by pumping)
mfg 3200 gallons none
.___
}
Riser over outlet, riser over inlet or center, and 6"+ inspection pipe over any remaining baffles.
No effluent filter & alarm
Dose tank, risers and piping (water tight risers, insulated, proper depth, drainback)
mfg 2250 gallons
Optional Time dosing of:
3 dose pump
verify that installed
float setting drop 3.0 inches
29
"vertic-a—llifTfrbm
gpm
gpi
VERIFYPUMPCURVE 5.9 min ON
is no more than design value of
"DESIGNED"
gpi "INSTALLED"=
9
1.6 hr OFF
feet
2.5 inches approx float tether length
inches float drop (field corrected
1
LABEL pump requirements and drawdown on riser or panel
Cam lock reachable from grade 30" max. J—hookweep hole. Supply line access (no hard 90's)
-
2.0 inch supply pipe: Sch40, sloped 1/8"+, supported by 4" sch40 sleeve or compacted, and
buried 6"+.
splice box / control panel / electrical connections / Hi Level Alarm
flow measurement: CT, ETM,time dosed, home water meter
mound absorption area rough up
mound rock dimensions 10.0 X 69.5
Sand lift depth 20 inches. (Jar test : 2" sand leaves < 1/ 8" silt after 30 min)
S
Bermed topsoil beyond rockbed 10 upslope 11 sideslope 20 downslope
a 3/16
3.0
inch perforations
ft perforation spacing
E
Abandonexisting system
monitoring plan and type
well abandonment form
—
-
if necessary
if necessary
|:|Re-use existing tank certification
SYSTEM1
-
3 10X69.5 MOUNDS
P3 P5 FILTER
M |__J;"H__‘Jl
2250
LIFT
2250's 3200
I
K
Preliminary & Field Evaluation Form
Owner Information
Date 7/14/2023 Sec / Twp / Rng 8/141 /34
Parcel ID 16.08.00710 LUG (county, city, township) HUBBARD
Property Owner: SOLIEN RV PARK Owners address (if different)
Site Information
Existing & proposed lot “ Yes N0 Well casing depth NEW DEEP
improvements located (see site map)
Req'd setbacks determined J V95 N0 Site w/in an inner wellhead Ye-5 '
Y N0
(see site map) mgmt zone (CWSfNTNCWS)
Utilities located & identi?ed Y95 J N0 Buried water supply pipe Yes “ N0
(gopher state one call) w/in 50' of system
Soil treatment area protected J Yes No Site map prepared with J YES NO
previous items included
Constructionrelated issues TREES TO BE REMOVED, ACCESS ROUTE FOR DRAIN FIELD
AND MAINTENANCETO BE PROVIDED
Depth (in) Texture fragment % matrix color redox color consistence grade shape
I OYR4/4
IOYR6/4
single grain
granular blocky
prismatic platy
massive
PIT 7
Boring ¢ Pit Elevation 99.79 Depth to SHWT
fragment % matrix color redox color consistence grade shape
war
rigid
V
/ I
I hereby certi?zthis eted in accordance with MN 7080 and any local req’s.
NORTHALND 549
Designer Signature Company License #
LUG soil verify Signature + LUG media elev/depth Signature = Soil Separation Report
NORTHALND 549
Designer Signature Company License #
Evidenceof site:
Cut
Filled
Compacted
Disturbed
Original soils
I hereby certi?zthis evalu pleted in accordance with MN 7080 and any local req’s.
NORTHALND 549
Designer Signature Company License #
Parent mat1‘s; ‘
IOYR3/2
22-27 IOYR6/4
Service Provider/Maintainer
NORTHLAND Contact Info 218-237-5276
Keep this Management Plan with your Septic System Owner’s Guide. The Septic System Owner’s Guide
includes a folder to hold maintenance records including pumping, inspection and evaluation reports. Ask
your septic professional to also:
0 Attach permit information, designer drawings and as-built of your system, if they are available.
0 Keep copies of all pumping records and other maintenance and repair invoices with this document.
0 Review this document with your maintenance professional at each visit; discuss any changes in product
use, activities, or water-use appliances.
. . Cris-suction
‘
mound
'
inspectionpipe-
Topsail_ . .
Frnm y\mI1|vuI\l:‘
Septic Tank
El First tank Tank volume: 3200 gallons D Pump Tank 2250 gallons
Does tank have two compartments‘?
Second tank Tank volume: 2250
OY @ N D Effluent Pump make/model: ZOEU-ER 93
CI gallons Pump capacity 29 GPM
D Tank is constructed of CONCRETE TDH 15 Feet of head
Cl Effluent scrccn:@
Y O N Alarm @Y O N D Alarm location CONTROL PANEL
Your toilet is not a garbage can. Do not flush anything besides human waste and toilet paper. No wet
wipes, cigarette butts, disposal diapers, used medicine, feminine products or other trash!
Your service provider or pumper/maintainer should evaluate if your tank needs to be pumped more or less
often.
Seasonally or several times per year
Leaks. Check (listen, look) for leaks in toilets and dripping faucets. Repair leaks promptly.
Soil treatment area. Regularly check for wet or spongy soil around your soil treatment area. If
surfaced sewage or strong odors are not corrected by pumping the tank or ?xing broken caps and
leaks, call your service professional. Untreated sewage may make humans and animals sick. Keep
bikes, snowmobiles and other traffic off and control borrowing animals.
Alarms. Alarms signal when there is a problem; Contact your service professional any time the
alarm signals.
Lint?lter.If you have a lint ?lter, check for lint buildup and clean when necessary. If you do not
have one, consider adding one after washing machine.
Ef?uent screen. If you do not have one, consider having one installed the next time the tank is
cleaned along with an alarm.
Annually
Water usage rate. A water meter or another device can be used to monitor your average daily water
use. Compare your water usage rate to the design ?ow of your system (listed on the next page).
Contact your septic professional if your average daily flow over the course of a month exceeds 70%
of the design ?ow for your system.
Caps. Make sure that all caps and lids are intact and in place. Inspect for damaged caps at least
every fall. Fix or replace damaged caps before winter to help prevent freezing issues.
Water conditioning devices. See Page 5 for a list of devices. When possible, program the recharge
frequency based on water demand (gallons) rather than time (days). Recharging too frequently
may negatively impact your septic system. Consider updating to demand operation if your system
currently uses time,
Review your water usage rate. Review the Water Use Appliance chart on Page 5. Discuss any major
changes with your service provider or pumper/maintainer.
-3-
Plumbing/Source of Wastewater
Review the Water Use Appliance Chart on Page 5 with homeowner.
Discuss any changes in water use and the impact those changes may have on the septic system.
Review water usage rates (if available) with homeowner.
Pump and controls. Check to make sure the pump and controls are operating correctly.
Pump vault. Check to make sure it is in place; clean per manufacturer recommendations.
Alarm. Verify that the alarm works.
Drainback. Check to make sure it is draining properly.
Event counter or elapsed time meter. Check to see if there is an event counter or elapsed time
meter for the pump. If there is one or both, calculate the water usage rate and
compare to the
anticipated use listed on Design and Page 2. Dose Volume: gallons: Pump run time:
Minutes
o Drip may result in Frozen pipes - Re-route water directly out of the house. Do not
furnace during cold weather. route furnace discharge to your septic system.
J. .
- Salt in recharge water may affect - These sourceslproduce that is not sewage and
Water So?ener
system performance.
water
should not go into your septic system.
Iron ?lter
Reverse osmosis o Recharge water may hydraulically - Reroute water from these sources to another outlet,
overload the system. such as a dry well, draintile or old drain?eld.
A
-7 - Water from these sources will o When replacing, consider using a demand-based
Shrfeee drainage
F°°t‘”g dmms
overload
the system and is
.
recharge vs. a time-based recharge.
Prehrbttedfrom ehterlrtg Septle - Check valves to ensure proper operation; have unit
S)/Sterrr serviced per manufacturer directions
_ 5 -
H.111 I. K nn;g;H in :1
(-a|(Lk. r-~,M! 31
i";..:fY1-'H 1,‘
.xi
Pr°Pertv°wner= — Date-*=‘
SiteAddress: — PIo:16-oa-00710
instructions: 2 = site specific input [:1 = adjust if desired I: = self~calculated (DO NOT ADJUST)
Lift station to holding tank (lift basket < 100 gal treat as sewer line, > 100 gal treat as tank)
/
completed this work in accordance with all applicable ordinances, rules and laws.
D Sewer line & tank connection (no hard 90's, long sweep 90 or 2- 45's, slope minimum 1" in 8‘ = 1% )
(no depth req's, clean out every 100', Sch 40 pipe)
C] No Lift station to Holding tank (lift basket < 100 gallons treat as sewer line, >100 gal treat as tank)
D Holding tank and risers (water tight risers, insulated, proper depth, existing verified by
pumping)
mfg 3200 gallons
C] High Level Alarm (set at 75% capacity) (electrical or mechanical) Q inches from bottom of tank
"
uzv -'\ri~.‘~.*:.=.
* *
v »\.I~ w ‘-1-~\'w.;.u::i nun? um :1Iun.+m‘;-2 \.‘,'|I 9:‘-mrw! 1v"‘/frs“»-'.1 ‘7"’»Ii'
—
~. -
L xv -:~'\<w'.« oi yaw =.\.av-.:_m1nrm (ha-Ir lormmn Ntms H 9, Cesng? -.!-r—»
‘
V‘ ‘
V-‘A 53-',‘\‘!9r:L)aww's <_§m<.1L¥'xr~ .1sale*m;n;-'
‘
‘
fur I11i:xr+’:ree.‘»':re:«'*.r..r:
'
. ~ ~ - 0' MN at 1-8()f)-5'/‘£v'~86'%i:
JMJ LJ'."I|‘/'37‘>|'\‘,‘
" '
2 ‘T fq>a.:~ Edi‘ ;~,;:»:m-y rt-,‘LjLnrv; cagrub:-asiona: H rC5;)i>!':~I!»9 ‘-"J
.,V
.-:-.:».'neo'.vner Tasks
- f.!:‘- -. 5:: co-‘.s~i!r-wn, ».-.'a:=:=r
- ’
Profc-ssionai Tasks
my re.~3pC4vs:bm!y$3 ‘. “(em
';1.;~.(mg 9.7/25:! ,‘ ci:7c/er;s!e;:r:‘; 1: :5 ;’)I’«‘v/).£a1'/y
5/-
;: '<'
Z" 2 .
Q n
..
V
A 1' «
.:.:w.7
n
\.‘/mt 1.-',-u::i.'.r:.nr..,. in. .
%~,~
‘
‘r"' ‘\.iIE’s:‘-’H‘x‘¢I¢r - \
’:’~‘ . E‘ I; ‘xi ‘.i‘.J:~\ “O-.('i v'\<..I<liu\ §'<?|'i{a')\. II); N \il‘x\-‘ix \H«’.‘\ E’ 3 ‘.~ ? ~
H w“ x» 1 \..\~-.‘‘. \1| ~.i ‘: wJ.'~ HVJH \ R1) l“T\£'\‘?\ I<=\i'li}.‘\. \1‘=~. 13H =;‘i".“\
‘\"'l‘=\\i}§.,: I'~.‘5-'1
? \\'I «i ‘.'x l‘H ¥-".i.\U'\ ‘\I U} Hui I-\\1'\ ('1'>‘~~"‘\H\. ’§3"ii'>i‘ii ii‘ { $1 MW‘
-.;“\ A‘ \ ‘aw \;J,.,
.4’ '
:
- .
.«
. , "_/K
~ - :4:
V K
/” {MM
-—,-"
«
z,-
1
j)
.
I
I
4
1
GOV-‘T I 0'!’ 3
<33‘: :-,
3} ~‘
*4»,
IJSCLAIMER: Infonna?on available an or accessed horn Hubbard County's GIS maps is urcm'dedfor
hfrzrmath nal and reference purposes any and has not been prepared forand may not be suitdvle for Iegl,
myneering, or sumeying purposes. Hubbard County makes no yzantee as In the accunacy, currency.
sullabilltv, performance, merdwanlabililv, rellabiity, or flness ofthis data md informaion for zuypanicular Parcel Viewer
purpose. Htbbard County shdl not be llable for any incidents or conseq uenthl damages. losses, at third
panv dalms that might arise from the use of maps or the Information thevcontah, even 3 Hubbzd County
has been advised of the pussibilny af such potentid loss or damage. This daa may not be used in
'pn'sd "nth ns tha do notallowthe exchsion or linitatbn of incidental or consequential damges.
Hubbard County - 301 Court Ave, Park Rapids, MN 56470
Map Unit Description: Steamboat-Two inlets-Seelyevillecomplex, pitted, 0 to 15 percent
slopes—-Hubbard County, Minnesota
Typical profile
Oa1,0a2 0 to 18 inches: muck
-
Minor Components
Potatolake and similar soils
Percent of map unit: 5 percent
Hydric soil rating: No
Egglake and similar soils
Percent of map unit: 4 percent
Landform: Swales
Hydric soil rating: Yes
Water
Percent of map unit: 1 percent
DISCLAIMER: Information axmilable on or accessed from Hubbard County's GIS maps is provided for
‘nformational and reference purposes only and has not been prepared for and may not be suitable for
legal, engineering, or surveying purposes. Hubbard County makes no guarantee as to the accuracy,
currency, suitabiity, performance, merchantability, re|iability,orfitness of this data and information forany
particular purpose. Hubbard County shall not be ?able for any inctiemal or consequential damages,
30-V-23 Solien
losses, or third party claims that might arise from the use of maps or the information they contain, even if
Hubbard County has been advised ofthe possibility of such potential loss or damage. This data may not be
used injurisdictions that do notallow the exclusion or limitation ofincidental or consequentiaidamages.
—
Hubbard County 301 Court Ave, Park Rapids, MN 56470
Page 734 of 785
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT:
NEW BUSINESS
Variance Application 30-V-23 by Michel Solien: Part of Gov't Lot 3 and 4, Section 8, Township 141, Range
34, Lake Emma Township on Pickerel Lake, a recreational development lake. Parcel 16.08.00710. Applicant is
requesting Part 1: a variance from the requirement in Section 402, Item 7.D of the Shoreland Management
Ordinance (SMO) that a recreational vehicle campground must have a centralized subsurface sewage
treatment system and Part 2: a variance from the 150’ ordinary high water mark drainfield setback requirement
in Sections 502.2, 801.3, and 1013.7.A of the SMO.
Enclosed Document(s):
30-V-23 application
2020 aerial imagery w/2’ elevation contours overlain
The two parts to this application are septic system-related and for a proposed 47 RV campground for which a
conditional use permit is planned to be requested in the next month or two. The SMO requires that all the sites
in an RV campground be serviced by a single SSTS. Part 1 of the application requests a variance from this
requirement as the applicant’s SSTS designer proposes using two separate SSTS to service the proposed RV
campground. Part 2 of the application seeks a variance from the 150’ OHW setback for one of the proposed two
drainfield mound locations. Each drainfield is proposed to be made up of three separate mounds that would be
dosed through a time-dosage system to allow each mound to have a resting period.
Staff is supportive of the Part 1 request as having two systems vs one means that one system is still operational
if the other goes down rather than having the entire campground be affected if a single system would ever have
an issue. Staff is not supportive of Part 2 as the property is 26.5 ac., ~1100’ wide on average, ~700’ deep on
average, and the topography and soils allow ample room meeting setbacks where a drainfield can be placed. It
is the proposed RV campground layout that is driving the need for the OHW setback variance.
Part 1
1. Is the variance in harmony with the general purposes and intent of the official controls?
Yes ( X ) No ( )
Why or why not? Having two SSTS rather than one allows part of the campground to remain operational if
one of the SSTS has issues vs. having the entire campground being affected if there is an issue with a
single SSTS being used. Having two drainfield sites also disperses the effluent and allows the soil loading
to be distributed and the volume of effluent handled by a given drainfield to be lessened. This reduces the
potential for the effluent to enter the groundwater before being effectively treated.
2. Is the property owner proposing to use the property in a reasonable manner not permitted by an official
control?
Yes ( X ) No ( )
Why or why not? Not putting all one’s eggs into a single basket in terms of having two drainfields vs. one is
a reasonable proposal that offers a higher likelihood of environmental protection. There will still be only two
SSTS servicing the RV sites that will have water/sewer hook-ups so the ordinance’s objective of
centralized SSTS is still being met.
3. Is the need for a variance due to circumstances unique to the property and not created by the current or
prior property owners?
Yes ( X ) No ( )
Why or why not? The topography of the property is rolling hills, valleys, and swales which lends itself to
separate SSTS making more sense to install as that keeps the system designs as simple as possible and
simple designs are less susceptible to having issues that affect performance than more complicated systems
with more moving parts.
4. Will the issuance of the variance maintain the essential character of the locality?
Yes ( X ) No ( )
Why or why not? Whether the proposed RV campground has one or two septic systems will not harm the
locality’s character as a septic system is a standard accessory component to any commercial or residential
use that generates sewage. If anything, splitting the required septic system sizing into two systems will
mean that the proposed mound drainfields will be smaller in size and thus less aesthetically obtrusive than
one large single drainfield.
5. Does the stated practical difficulty involve more than just economic considerations?
Yes ( X ) No ( )
Why or why not? Economics are not cited in the application as a practical difficulty.
Part 2
1. Is the variance in harmony with the general purposes and intent of the official controls?
Yes ( ) No ( X )
Why or why not? The lot is 26.5 ac. in size and an average of 1100’ wide x 700’ deep. There are no
topographic or soils constraints that prevent a drainfield from meeting the 150’ OHW setback. When
permittable options exist, no practical difficulty exists and thus granting a variance from the 150’ OHW
setback would not be in harmony with the ordinance’s intent.
2. Is the property owner proposing to use the property in a reasonable manner not permitted by an official
control?
Yes ( ) No ( X )
Why or why not? Given the lot size, dimensions, topography, and soils conditions mentioned in the answer
to question 1, seeking relief from the 150’ OHW setback when there is ample room on the property to meet
the setback is not a reasonable request.
3. Is the need for a variance due to circumstances unique to the property and not created by the current or
prior property owners?
Yes ( ) No ( X )
Why or why not? The property is 26.5 ac. in size and averages 1100’ in width and at least 700’ in depth.
There are no topographic or soils constraints preventing all needed SSTS drainfields from meeting the 150’
OHW setback. The need for the variance is due to how the applicant would like to lay out the proposed RV
campground.
4. Will the issuance of the variance maintain the essential character of the locality?
Yes ( X ) No ( )
Why or why not? The proposed drainfield site that will not meet the 150’ OHW setback will be at least 100’
from the ordinary high water mark and surrounded by a mature Norway Pine plantation so it will not be
visible from the lake, Holly Road, or nearby properties.
5. Does the stated practical difficulty involve more than just economic considerations?
Yes ( X ) No ( )
Why or why not? Economics are not cited in the application as a practical difficulty.
Legal Description: Part of Gov't Lot 3 and 4, Section 8, Township 141, Range 34
Parcel ID #: 16.08.00710
Lot Viewal Date: Thursday, August 24, 2023 at approximately 9:45 a.m. (Please allow at least
± 30 minutes of scheduled time.)
Place: Hubbard County Government Center, 3rd Floor Board Room # 324.
Purpose: Applicant is requesting Part 1: a variance from the requirement in Section 402,
Item 7.D of the Shoreland Management Ordinance (SMO) that a recreational
vehicle campground must have a centralized subsurface sewage treatment
system and Part 2: a variance from the 150’ ordinary high water mark drainfield
setback requirement in Sections 502.2, 801.3, and 1013.7.A of the SMO.
Above please find a Public Hearing Notice for your information. An effort has been made to notify all the
property owners within 500 feet of the premises concerned. To ensure that everyone has been notified,
please share this notice with any interested property owners that may have not been notified by mail.
Should you have any further questions, please contact the Environmental Services Office at 218-732-
3890.
Planning Commission/Board of Adjustment (PC/BOA) hearing/meeting agenda items (i.e. applications and
related documents), composition and duties, meeting procedure, and findings of fact may be viewed on
the Hubbard County website (www.co.hubbard.mn.us) by clicking on the homepage “Agendas,
Summaries & Minutes” link and then on the “Meetings” link on the subsequent webpage that opens.
Eric Buitenwerf, Env. Services Director Bryan Haugen, Asst. Env. Services Director Staci Lee, Admin. Asst.
Env. Specialists: Aaron Anderson, Demey DeJong, Kal Larson GIS Supervisor: Jack Bovee
Phyllis Breezee
270 Cardinal Circle
Chaska, MN. 55318
I am a property owner on Pickerel Lake and I am concerned about having an RV park on the lake.
Forty seven lots seems like it would draw a lot of extra road traffic and Holly Road is in bad shape
as it is. In other words, the road is NOT being taken care of properly. Also, I’m concerned about
all the boats on the lake and the extra pollution they will cause. The lake is too small to
accommodate that much boat traffic.
I am requesting that this variance be denied because of road traffic on a road that is NOT being
taken care of. Extra boat traffic on a small lake and the sewage system that’s being requested.
Thank You,
Phyllis J. Breezee
We have recently been noti?ed that there is an RV park proposal consisting of 46 units
to be built at the west end of Pickerel Lake.
We have been homeowners on this lake for 55 years. We have been tax payers on this
lake for 55 years. This is a small, quiet lake. There is not room for 46 more boats,
people, campers, etc. There is a public landing that anyone can use.
The area of the lake where the proposal is being made has a lot of loon habitat and a
large eagle nest that has an eagle family in it each time you drive around the lake.
I'm also concerned about the amount of wake boards that may enter the lake. We can
handle a few, but they can cause so much damage to the lake shore.
I would also assume that in order for this to happen, there would be hundreds of trees
cut down destroying more habitat.
What gets destroyed can not come back.
Sincerely,
Gerry and Nancy Fladeboe
3675 113"‘Ave NE
Spicer, Mn 56288
I have owned property on the lake for almost 8 years. The lake is very
clean. Not only are my concerns about the septic variance, I am also
concerned about the lakes shoreland development. The lake is roughly
310 acres and the shoreline for the proposed RV site is only 3 foot deep. It
has lots of lily pads and vegetation for the fish. Basically, this will destroy
the natural shoreline. I'm sure they will want to make a swimming beach,
boat and parking docks. They will have to use chemicals to remove
weeds, herbicides for tick control, there will be run off from the sites,
etc. RV's have a lot of sewer usage.
Also, if you add another 47 boats on the lake, this lake will be overfished
and the loons and eagles will leave. That's probably a DNR issue.
Tammi Soehl
2712 S Glendale Ave
Sioux Falls SD 57105
Please be advised that we strongly oppose the proposed development of a campground by Michel Solien
on Parcel 16.08.00710 on Pickeral Lake.Accordingly, we oppose the granting of any variances that would
further his efforts to develop the proposed campground.
We have owned property on the south shore of Pickeral Lake since 2003. Pickeral Lake is a small (311
acres), shallow lake that cannot possibly handle the stress that will be introduced by the proposed
campground. As stated in Section 201 of the Hubbard County Shoreland Management Ordinance No. 17
("Ordinance”), Pickeral Lake is a Recreational Development Lake. As you know, Section 302, Paragraph 2
of the Ordinance stipulates criteria to protect Recreational Development Lakes from development that
would be unsuitable. We believe that the proposed development of a campground on Parcel
16.08.00710 would be highly unsuitable and therefore violates the Ordinance. In particular, the
proposed development is not consistent with other existing development and use. Further, it would not
promote the bene?cial use of public water to the general public as an excellent public access already
exists for that purpose. Furthermore, that portion of the lake is not suitable for the launching of
watercraft. Finally,a campground would adversely affect the bene?cial use of Pickeral Lake by existing
riparian owners. We riparian owners would expect our quiet enjoyment of small Pickeral Lake, as well as
our property values, to be adversely affected if this unsuitable development proceeds.
We are highly concerned about any variances to the Ordinance provisions for septic systems that would
harm the surface water quality of Pickeral Lake. Accordingly,we request that you not approve Variance
Application 30-V-23 that would lessen such requirements for Parcel 16.08.00710. Such a proposed
variance would con?ict with the law and spirit of the Ordinance.
Please do not grant any variances or conditional use permits that would allow this proposed unsuitable
development to proceed.
Sincerely,
Mailing address:
Johnmccormick299@gmail.com
Lisamccorm23@gmail.com
We are submitting a written objection for the proposed Septic Variance for a 47—unitcampground
being proposed on the west end of Pickerel Lake.
For the above stated concerns and questions, we respectfully request that this variance is not
granted. Thank you for considering this request.
éfwégd/W
SINCERELY,
MARK HETRICK
Kevin Sharkey
17800 Happy Drive
Park Rapids, MN 56470
This is in regard to the proposed variance application 30-V-23. This variance is for the
sewage treatment and drain?eld on Pickerel Lake.
Speaking for the homeowners on and around Pickerel we are vehemently opposed to
the variance as well as the campground. There is no reason for the variance other than
to add more space for more campsites. There is no possible upside for the environment
by granting this variance.
The potential for sewage leaks into the environment is there, it is impossible to believe
a breach of some sore won’t happen. This is a very shallow part of the lake and the
environment needs to be protected at all costs. The eagle nest on this part of the lake
will most likely be negatively affected as well as other wildlife and the environment in
general.
The additional boat and vehicle traffic generated by this campground with be a further
detriment to the environment. Giving a variance for a sewage treatment system so close
to the lake is unnecessary and will eventually impact the surrounding environment.
My family has been on Pickerel Lake since the early 1970’s and have been good
stewards of the land. I am asking you to do the same. Additionally, I would request an
Environmental Impact Study be initiated for the whole project as well as the proposed
septic variance.
I plan on being at the Board of Adjustment walk thru on August 24th and look forward
to hearing the rationale for even considering granting the variance request.
Sincerely yours,
"Moth,
glxovz
Kevin Sharkey
Re: Hubbard County Planning Commission I Board of Adjustment Monday, August 28, 2023
Variance Application 30-V-23 by Michel Solien: Part of Govt Lot 3 and 4, Section 8, Township 141, Range 34, Lake
Emma Township on Pickerel Lake, a recreational development lake. Parcel 16.08.00710. Applicant is requesting Part 1: a
variance from the requirement in Section 402, Item 7.D of the Shoreland Management Ordinance (SMO) that a recreational
vehicle campground must have a centralized subsurface sewage treatment system and Part 2: a variance from the 150’
ordinary high water mark drainfield setback requirement in Sections 502.2, 801.3, and 1013.7.A of the SMO.
lam opposed to the variance requested. It appears to be done for economic gain and the land in
question has sufficient suitable area for reasonable septic needs. The applicant is maximizing
development economic potential at the expense of the balance of parcels on Pickerel Lake. I am not
opposed to reasonable development, and expected the 7 or 8 parcels that were previously laid out and
signed for lots to develop into future cabins.
Other than the applicant property, there are approximately 80 lake access parcels on Pickerel. The
application proposal is for over one—halfagain as many sites as exist. The septic treatment needs will
increase proportionately having unknown detrimental effects.
The increased use of boat traffic from the proposed pier will result in degradation of the existing public
landing. The proposed pier will not be able to accommodate the potential boating needs for the number
of RV sites. This will lead to unwanted beaching for restroom breaks or using the lake inappropriately.
The existing landing already has no restroom facilities. Perhaps the applicant should provide their own
launch area and porta—potties as needed.
The proposed septic system is sized for campground use. The rules are antiquated for the potential year-
round use of todays modern RVs. Modern RVs are being manufactured as Tiny Homes and for four
season living. Many have dishwashers, full laundry, multiple baths and accommodate large groups of
people. This is far from the tent and old RV the septic rules of the past were designed for.
I feel the County should address the non—septic issues this application will create with a conditional use
permit. I have a hard time equating the number of cabins that would be presently allowed with this
proposal for over 47 RV/cabins. A moratorium on these RV campgrounds is in order to study this issue.
Sincerely,
John Griebler
8-16-23
Joyce and I have enjoyed the Park Rapids area most of our lives, as visitors, campers, seasonal RV site owners and
?nally a Pickerel Lakeresidence for the past 16 years.
We were saddened to hear about the Decision HillsCampground Proposal to construct a 40+ unit RV Park on the
SW shore of PickerelLake. Pickerel Lake, a 310—acre lake, simply cannot sustain a project of this magnitude.
As a small-town business owner for nearly 40 years, I know and understand the economics of bringing more people
to the Park Rapids area. With the recent boom in campground’s usage, it is evident that more areas are needed to
accommodate these visitors. HOWEVER,Pickerel Lake is not a good fit for a 40+ unit RV site, a larger lake
perhaps.
Mr. Buitenwert, we want to thank you in advance for your DENYINGMr. Solien’s variance re uest.
Park Rapids
MN 55470
As a property owner on Pickerel Lake near Emmaville, MN, it has come to our attention that
another property owner on this lake is requesting Part 1: a variance from the requirement in
Section 402, Item 7.D of the Shoreland Management Ordinance (SMO) that a recreational
vehicle campground must have a centralized subsurface sewage treatment system and Part 2: a
variance from the 150’ ordinary high water mark drain?eld setback requirement in Sections
502.2, 801.3, and 1013.7.A of the SMO.
We wish to let it be known that we are adamantly opposed to approving these variance
requests. Subsurface sewage treatment system and drainfield regulations have been thoroughly
researched by experts and applied by county officials to protect the environmental integrity and
preservation of our natural resources and public health. To grant an individual any variance
fromthese regulations is not in the best interest of the public locally or regionally.
i
btherHubbard County rural and lake property owners have spent and will continue to spend
many thousands of dollars to create and maintain compliant subsurface sewage treatment
systems. Any further development in the county should be obligated to follow the regulations
currently in place.
We are con?dent the Hubbard County officials responsible for a decision on this matter will
make the right decision to protect our natural resources and public health by declining the
requests for variances on the centralized subsurface sewage treatment system and drain?eld
setback requirements at 25848 Holly Road, Park Rapids, MN legally described as Part of Gov’t
Lot 3 and 4, Section 8, Township 141, Range 34, parcel ID if 16.08.00710.
Respectfully Submitted:
Mk
Gary and Phyllis Leraas
Qnsaugzmw
17906 Happy Dr.
Park Rapids, MN 56470
Mailing Address:506 4"‘St. SE, Hillsboro, ND 58045
TO: Hubbard Country Environmental Services, 301 Court Ave, Park Rapid, MN 56470
FROM: Annette Palmgren, 18207 Ithaca Dr, Pickerel Lake, Park Rapids, MN. Permanent Address:
712 Reeves Drive, Grand Forks, ND 58201. 701-610-1620. apa|mgren@gra.midco.net
RE: Michael Solien’s Request for Variances at 25848 HollyRoad, Park Rapids, Part of Gov’t Lot 3
and 4 Section 8, Township 141, Range 34, Parcel 16.08.00710
I am strongly opposed to these Variances for numerous reasons. This is a small and shallow
lake, becoming more shallow. There is a very delicate balance of the natural ecosystem Pickerel
Lake that I have observed over the many years of living there. Shoreland destruction, increased
boat and RVtraffic including their pollutants are only a couple of the adverse environmental
impacts.
/egard s,
R
Annette Palmgren —
Contact information is listed above
Hubbard County
Environmental Services
301 Court Avenue
Park Rapids, MN 56470
Please find my comments to the BOA regarding the Variance Application 30-V-23.
I have been a property owner on Pickerel Lakefor the past 50 years. Over time I have transitioned my
cabin into my home at 17659 Ivy Drive.
Pickerel Lake is a small, relatively quiet lake and a home for much wildlife including Bald Eagles and
families of Loons. The west end of the lake is very shallow.
The proposed RV park for the west end of the lake will impact this lake, the natural environment and the
wildlife.
It is your responsibility to assess the applicant's request for variance from requirements of the Shoreland
Management Ordinance and ensure that the decision protects the habitat and water quality and
—
Overall, I am very concerned about the impact I see to our lake from the proposed RV park.
0 Changes to the natural shoreland
0 Risk of Sewage problems
0 increased traffic on the roads
0 Increased boat traf?c
Reino Anderson
17659 lvy Drive
Park Rapids, MN 56470
Vessey
17856 happy dr
Park rapids rnn
(732 5040
no_rep1y@exan1p|e.com
Aug 21 2021
Hubbard county planning commision
301 Court Ave
Park rapids 56470
Efiiq/M3
X ‘Threereason... <
k|eentank.com
D
it!” Here are three reasons
why:
Potentialhealthrisks
Some tank additives feature
formaldehyde, what the EPS
says is ”a probable carcinogen;
moderately toxic to humans.”
OSHA adds that formaldehyde
causes known health hazards
when touched, swallowed, or
breathed. In 2004, the
National Cancer Institute
reports the International
Agency for Research on
Cancer (IARC) reevaluated the
existing data that '1
’
- formaldehyde is a probable
human carcinogen and
reclassified it as a known a
human carcinogen
Eric Buitenwerf
Environmental Services Director
Hubbard County Environmental Services
301 Court Ave.
Park Rapids, MN 56470
We are respectively writing in regards to Variance Application 30-V-23 by applicant: Michel Solien at property address:
25848 Holly Road, Park Rapids, MN 56470. He is proposing to build a 47 site RV park with a marina. As permanent residents
on Pickerel Lake, our concerns are as follows:
Q1
0 Sewage: We are in absolute agreement with the staff study findings to deny the request for a variance to 150
feet for sewage set back requirement. What safeguards will be in place to prevent lake contamination if the
system fails? What water level is being used to determine the setback distance starting point? Twenty years ago,
the water was 6-7 feet higher than the current level.
0 Environmental Disturbance: Heavy machinery used in the construction process will compact the soil, making it
difficult for water absorption that supports plant life. The proposed plans for the RV park will necessitate the
removal of vegetation and wildlife habitat. This will lead to erosion and sedimentation which will have a direct
impact on aquatic species and the swans and loons that have nested on that part of the lake for decades.
The high demand for water for 47 RV sites will also put a strain on groundwater sources. By adding these sites,
you are essentially increasing the number of residents on the lake by 50%.
0 Increased Road[Boat Traffic: Who will take on the responsibility of upgrading or maintaining the roads when a
new development goes in? The RV traffic will cause damage to gravel roads that were not built for heavy vehicle
traffic, thus a heavier road to be built. This would include Happy Drive, Hoff Trail and Hannah Lane which are
privately maintained gravel roads that lead to the public access.
Additionally, the public access is only minimally maintained, cannot be expanded and its size is not suitable for
an increased load. Has there been an environmental study done to determine if a lake the size of Pickerel can
sustain this level of traffic following the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources guidelines of 20 acres per
boat with high—speed watercraft? The increase of transient boat traffic will also greatly increase the likelihood
of the introduction of Aquatic Invasive Species to a lake that is currently free of them.
0 Noise Pollution: Will Mr. Solien be living onsite to implement and enforce noise regulations? Prolonged
exposure to noise can harm reproductive success and stress levels of local wildlife.
Sincerely,
Access to the land via Holly Road, so many docks on a small lake, future control over proper use and upkeep of the land
are all concerns of ours. We are battling invasive species staying out of our lakes as it is, Blue Lake will be an easy stop
for these campers to boat at and we fear Pickerel Lake along with Blue Lake will have negative impacts for the lakes
themselves and existing property owners.
There is the new park going in on county road 4, the old ski lodge, and ManTrap's RV park, this is enough for the area.
We do not feel opening up so much lakeshore on a small lake for a campground is necessary for the community and the
other Pickerel Lake shore owners.
Thank you,
William McDermott and Kristyn Bettin
24825 Harebell Drive
Park Rapids, MN 56470
Application #30-V-23
Parcel ID .16.08.0710
I have interest in property on Pickerel Lake in Hubbard County. I am concerned that the proposed development
would be detrimental to the lake.
I have read the staff report for the variance application and agree with their ?ndings.
Mark Gengler
3064 Oak Ave
Slayton, MN 56172
507-456-0340
Hubbard County Environmental Services 301 Court Ave. Hubbard County Environmental
Services
301 Court Ave S
Park Rapids MN 56470
I am writing to express my strong concerns and objections regarding the proposed RV campground
park development within our community. While I understand the importance of progress and
growth, I firmly believe that allowing such a development would have significant negative impacts on
our neighborhood and the surrounding environment.
1. Traffic Congestion: The construction of an RV campground park will lead to increased traffic
congestion. This could result in safety hazards to those that want to enjoy the lake. And will
also contribute to noise pollution.
2. Environmental Concerns: The establishment of an RV campground park on a lake that is only
310 acres would lead to environmental degradation, particularly if it is not designed with
sustainable practices in mind. Increased waste generation, potential harm to local wildlife,
and alteration of natural habitats could have lasting negative effects on our ecosystem.
3. Quality of Life:Our community is known for its tranquility and peaceful atmosphere. The
introduction of an RV campground park, with its potential for noise from RV generators,
increased foot traffic, and other associated activities, could compromise the quality of life
that residents have come to cherish Pickeral Lake.
4. Property Values: The presence of a campground park could potentially lead to a decrease in
property values for residents in the vicinity. The sight of an RV park and the potential for
increased traffic may not align with the desires of potential homebuyers.
My family has owned property/Cabin for over 50 years on Pickeral Lake, being a little girl at only 1
the memories and enjoyment that I have experienced can never be replaced. Knowing that, my
grandchildren, nieces, and nephews are also learning to appreciate the beauty and tranquility of the
lake. I urge you to carefully consider these concerns before deciding on whether to approve the
development of the RV campground park. I believe that it is essential for our community's wel|—
and |ong»term sustainability that we prioritize thoughtful development that aligns with the being
values
and needs of our residents. I kindly request that you consider the voices of the residents who will be
directly impacted by this decision. Thank you for your time and consideration. I hope that you will
Sincerely
This letter is to provide comment for the Public Hearing for Variance, Application 30—V—23.My wife and
1, Amy and Chris Jackson, are property owners on Piekerel Lake. Our property is located at l7929 Ivy
Drive.
We were very recently made aware of the referenced hearing. We propose to voice our strong opposition
togranting the requested variances listed as Parts I and 2 under the Purpose section ofthe llearing
Notice.
EPA regulations regarding septic system setbacks from water bodies were set in place for obvious
reasons. An RV Park of this proposed size will generate a large volume of sewage. When the system does
fail, as it eventually will at some point, the resulting leakage will make its way to the Lake. lfthe setback
is allowed to be less than I50’ there will be less response time, creating the potential for a larger spill. /\
non—eentralizedsystem places the bulk ofthe storage closer to the lake as well. ljndetected leakage would
have easy access to shallower groundwater, and being closer to the lake, and the scale ofthe resulting
contamination could be devastating to the lake's eco-systems. Not only are septic system failures
dangerous to the surrounding eco-system, but spills are also a direct health hazard to anyone, or any
animal exposed to it. Spills can also contaminate groundwater, wells, and surface waters. Mitigation
would also have cost impacts on public and private entities. All these negative impacts can be easily
avoided by denying the requested variances. We strongly implore the Board to deny both requested
variances, not only for the welfare of current Piekerel Lake residents and property owners, but also
anyone who uses the lake.
In addition to denial of the requests, we would respectfully ask the Board to consider denial ofthe RV
park in total. The reasons for this request are many:
I Pickerel Lake is a small lake; it cannot reasonably nor safely sustain a high volume ofadditional
boating traffic. The additional personal watercraft and boat traffic will increase the risk of
accidents and loss.
I Additional lake traffic will also increase the amount ofshoreline erosion due to increased wake
activity.
0 The park would most likely require some sort of deck facilities for the guests. Given the shallow
depth of that end of the lake, a large portion of vegetation would need to be removed. Chemical
treatment for these lake weeds would be the most effective method of control but could very
realistically have a detrimental effect on aquatic life as well.
0 Precipitation run off from the paved areas ofthe park will wash contaminants into the lake over
For these reasons, we are humblysubmittingour opposition to the requested variances and respectfully
ask that the Board deny requests regarding this application.
We currently live in Lincoln, Nebraska, but regularly visit our property on the lake. If you have questions
regarding the above points, please let us know. We can be reached at 308-238- I749, or
chrisi14l 2@g,mail.com.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
%;,
CIIns&Amy .Iuk.-on
Eric Buitenwerf
Environmental Services Director
Hubbard County Environmental Services
301 Court Ave
Park Rapids, MN 56470
We are respectively writing in regards to Variance Application 30—V—23 by applicant: Michel Solien at property
address: 25848 Holly Road, Park Rapids, MN 56470. He is proposing to build a 47 site RV park with a marina.
As a property owner on Pickerel Lake, our concerns are as follows:
Sewage: We are in absolute agreement with the staff study ?ndings to deny the request for a
variance to 150 feet for sewage setback requirement. What safeguards will be in place to
prevent lake contamination if the system fails? What water level is being used to determine the setback distance
starting point? Twenty years ago, the water was 6-7 feet higher than the current level.
We have many other concerns about the campground in general but those will be addressed in a letter in the
near future after the CUP meeting is scheduled.
Thank you,
Home:
Dave and Teri Olson
3254 Bent Tree Drive
St Cloud, MN 56301
320-980-5281
o1yo1959@gmail.com
Cabin (which is 1500 feet plus or minus from this proposed campground):
17742 Happy Drive
Park Rapids, MN 56470
I have a lake home on Pickerel Lake for the past 45 years. l choice to avoid the over populated, dirty, crowded lakes
near Detroit Lakes and area to its south. i choice Pickerel because it was less coveted than other lakes in the area. It
was less attractive and more natural and less spoiled. large areas of the lake were native wetlands which were likely
never to be develop because of the shallow swampy shoreline.
Now were have a developer (the second in as many decades) who knew the development they planned was not
allowed by the zoning regulations. In this case the land was zoned for 5 lots for possible lake homes allowing limit
changes to the shoreline, due to it being a protected wetland. The developer now has plans for ten times that number
homes with nearly concrete RV pads. Fifty RV pads will have ten times the impacted on the lake's character and its the
native wetland. The developer is asking to change the the land usage from 5 single residential homes to fifty "smalls
homes" and they will be homes, not a campground! As "Small Homes" the county must taxed at a higher rate as
required by law. It is not going to be a campground. individual pads with individual year around sewage and water are
not characteristics of camp grounds, but housing development.
Hubbard County needs to stop granting variance to developers who know the rules before making their investing.
Pleading for a variance to do zoning laws may be business as usual for developers, but but for the zoning board to grant
makes a mockery of Hubbard County rules and regulation.
Keith Hilber
18327 Ithaca Drive
Park Rapids
Mary Griebler
18593 Ithaca Dr
Park Rapids, MN 56470
To Hubbard County,
I would oppose granting a septic variance for this application. It makes no sense to allow a variance for a
commercial enterprise when the variance is only being requested as a means to increase pro?ts.
Variances should be reserved for situations where there are no reasonable alternatives. This situation has
alternatives.
Before this proposed park proceeds, I would like to see data showing what impact lakeside RV parks have on
different lake classes. At what ratio of sites to lake acreage do these parks become problematic?
The number of sites proposed seems more suited to a 5000 acre lake than to one of 300 acres. The current
plan has the potential to have this property's guests outnumber the existing lake residents on any given day.
Such a sudden and substantial addition to the number of neighbors who would share our lake is going to have a
major impact on what we see, hear, and how we experience life at the lake.
Sincerely,
Mary Griebler
As a property owner on Pickerel Lake, I am very concerned about the possible pollution from the
proposed RV Park. I support the Environmental Services staff recommendation not to allow a sewage
setback closer than 150 feet, as called for in current ordinance.
Thank you,
Curt Soehl
This letter is to address the concerns raised with the application submitted for a variance from the
requirement in Section 402, Item 7.D of Shoreland Management Ordinance (SMO) that a recreational
vehicle campground must have a centralized subsurface sewage treatment system and Part 2: a variance
from the 150’ ordinary high water mark drain?eld setback requirement in Sections 502.2, 801.3, and
1013.7.A of the SMO for the property address of 25848 Holly Road, Park rapids, MN 56470 (legal
description: Pat of Gov't Lot 3 and 4, Section 8, Township 141, Range 34) parcel ID 16.08.00710. The
concerns are with granting permission to develop the fore-mentioned property this type of access for
development are as follows:
1. Nutrient Pollution: Subsurface sewage treatment systems, if not properly managed, can contribute to
nutrient pollution. Nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorus from treated wastewater can leach into the
groundwater and ?nd their way into the lake. Excessive nutrient levels can lead to algal blooms, oxygen
depletion, and eutrophication in the lake, disrupting the natural balance of the aquatic ecosystem.
3. Habitat Disruption: Construction and maintenance activities associated with subsurface sewage
systems can disrupt terrestrial habitats near the lake. Clearing land, digging trenches, and installing
infrastructure can disturb soil, vegetation, and wildlife habitats, potentially leading to habitat loss and
fragmentation.
4. Erosion and Sedimentation: Improperly managed construction and maintenance activities can
contribute to soil erosion and sedimentation. Sediments can be carried into the lake, leading to
increased turbidity and reduced water clarity. This can impact aquatic plants, ?sh spawning areas, and
other aquatic organisms that rely on clear water conditions.
5. Invasive Species: Human activity related to sewage system installation and maintenance can
inadvertently introduce invasive plant species to the area. Invasive species can outcompete native
vegetation and disrupt the balance of the local ecosystem, affecting both terrestrial and aquatic habitats.
6. Wetland Impact: Lakes are often interconnected with wetlands, which provide essential ecosystems
services like water ?ltration and ?ood control. If subsurface sewage are allowed too close to wetland
areas, there's a risk of wetland degradation or loss, which can have cascading effects on the lake's water
quality and biodiversity.
7. Climate Change Vulnerability: Climate change can exacerbate the risks associated with subsurface
sewage systems. Increased precipitation, ?ooding, and storm surges can overwhelm sewage systems,
8. Public Health Concerns: Inadequate sewage treatment can pose risks to public health, especially if
pathogens and contaminants make their way into the lake. Swimming, ?shing, and other recreational
activities could be impacted, affecting both residents and visitors.
9. Long-Term Sustainability: While setback requirements aim to reduce immediate risks, the |ong—term
sustainability of subsurface sewage systems must be considered. As the population grows and land use
patterns change, the cumulative impact of multiple impact of multiple systems in the area could still lead
to environmental degradation over time.
Placing an RV campground with septic facilities near a quiet small lake can have signi?cant negative
impacts on the tranquility and overall ambience of the area. Here's how such a development could
potentially disrupt the peacefulness of the lake environment:
1. Noise and activity: RV campgrounds tend to attract a higher volume of visitors compared to
natural, undeveloped areas. Increased human activity, including loud conversations, vehicle
traf?c, generators, and recreational activities, can create a constant background noise that
contrasts with the serene and tranquil sounds of nature typically associated with a quiet lake.
2. Visual disturbance: RVs, tense and campground infrastructure can disrupt the visual harmony of
the lake and its surroundings. The natural beauty of the area could be marred by the presence of
structures, vehicles, and arti?cial lighting. These visual disruptions can detract from the peaceful
and calming experience that visitors seek in such tranquil environments.
3. Light pollution: RV campgrounds often require lighting for safety and convenience. However,
these arti?cial lighting can lead to light pollution, which not only affects the view of the night sky
but also can disrupt the natural nocturnal behaviors of wildlife and disturb the tranquil ambiance
that quiet lake environment should provide.
4. Increased traffic and congestion: The establishment of an RV campground could lead to
increased traf?c and congestion in the surrounding area. This not only affects the visual and
auditory aspects of the lake environment but also introduces potential safety concerns and
reduces the overall sense of solitude that many visitors seek.
5. Water and air pollution: septic systems used by the campground could pose a risk of nutrient
pollution and potential leaks, which may affect the lakes’ water quality and aquatic ecosystem.
Improperly maintained or failing septic systems could lead to unpleasant odors and
contamination of the surrounding area, further diminishing the tranquil atmosphere.
6. Wildlife disturbance: the increased human presence and activities associated with RV
campground can disrupt the natural behavior of wildlife that depend on the lake and its
surroundings. Nesting birds, for instance, could be driven away by noise and disturbance,
impacting the delicate ecological balance of the area.
7. Recreational pressure: an in?ux of visitors from the RV campground could lead to overuse of the
lake and its resources. Increased boating, ?shing, swimming, and other recreational activities can
place stress on the lakes ecosystem and diminish the sense of tranquility that comes from
experiencing a less frequented natural environment.
8. Loss of privacy: for nearby residents and property owners the presence of an RV campground
could compromise their sense of privacy and seclusion. Views of the lake and peaceful natural
In conclusion, introducing an RV campground of this size to a lake less than 400 acres will
ju—|-1j|—|.-.——|--2-I
.I—-I-u--u-Q3-II-I--nu
signi?cantly devalue the existing properties and cause overuse ofZu—-uulup--I
the habitat and disrupt the very
quali?es that make the lake environment tranquil and serene. A lake of this size cannot support the
—|-—1—Tj:1-T-
an-—-._
increased human activity n- that-u a campground
.-g--uaul-\.--In -In-|-—lIu-u
would bring to this lake. The ul-.
increased human activity,
visual
—jZ —ZjITdisturbances, noise, and potential environmental impacts associated with such a development
Pl‘-'I?'-n‘l-Ful1'n'i"Il'-iI'—?1
can erode the sense of natural beauty and peacefulness that draws people to these quiet lakeside
settings. It is for these reasons my husband (Darren T. Christenson) and I had purchased property on
hj?iuihlLake located north of Park Rapids, Minnesota and do not
Pickerel I?iendorse the application for a
variance
jjj-:—— from the requirement in Section 402, Item 7.D-—ofIj Shoreland Management Ordinance (SMO)
---u-jinn:-—IuI-Iu—&u:I-1|-u-—
that a recreational vehicle campground must have a centralized subsurface sewage treatment
and Part 2: a variance from the 150' ordinary high water mark drain?eld setback requirement
-1.-----.--pqyzr.-_1:—.-—-.-.2
system
in—Im of the SMO for the property address of 25848 Holly Road,
Sections 502.2, 801.3, and 1013.7.Aj??jjnjj
Park rapids, MN 56470 (legal description: Pat of Gov’t Lot 3 and 4, Section 8, Township 141, Range
—1I—I-I-1I—--I--II---I-—I--II|- II-
34)
jinn; parcel ID 16.08.00710.
IrI—-I r-1
Jeff Packer
401 Pinewood Lane
Duluth, MN 55804
8/20/2023
Eric Buitenwerf
Environmental Services Director
Hubbard County
301 Court Ave
Park Rapids, MN 56470
Dear Mr Buitenwerf.
My family has owned property on Pickerel Lake in Hubbard County for over 50 years. My mom
and dad, Arvin and Mary Packer have been excellent stewards of their land having great respect
for the undeveloped lakeshore that they own and the crystal clear water. It is their and my
concern regarding the proposed variance for a drainfield setback on a proposed campground with
up to 40 some units that I am writing to voice my opposition.
I was kayaking with my wife just a few weeks ago on Pickerel and I commentedthat the lake has
been so clean and clear since the first time I swam in the lake as a kid some 50 years ago. My
own kids were swimming in the lake just yesterday. It is beyond my comprehension how
anyone would even propose a drainfield closer to the water than allowed. What would happen if
it were to fail? Would the lake be tainted for years? Who would be responsiblefor cleanup
costs.
Sincerely, ,
\
Jeffrey E. Pa ker
218-340-7458
Eric,
I am writing you to let you know that I support the staff recommendation to leave the septic set back at 150 feet.
Please share my letter with the board.
Thank you!
Alison Bailey
2701 S. Glendale Ave
Sioux Falls, SD 57105
My Family And I have a cabin on Pickerel Lake sense 1965 , we have heard of this camp ground trying to be built
on Pickerel Lake near us,
I would like to start out by saying that I am very much not in favor of this hole camp ground idea. I think the lake is to
small for this kind of boat traffic.
I also wanted the board to be aware of the Eagle nest in the trees at east end of this project. I do know there are some
rules about building close to them and would like that checked out.
I know this meeting is for septic concerns at this time for Application # 30—V—32 Parcel ID 1608007810 , the idea that
they are putting a mound system at the front of the building slte,which is on the lake side is bad enough, but trying to put
it closer to the like than normally allowed seems to me to be a bad idea , after reading the staff reports ,I have to agree
with them and would like to see it denied.
Tnak you for listing to my concerns
John Bungert
1175 W55th StW
Northfield ,MN 55057
612-578-4148
I support the staff recommendation to leave the septic set back at 150 feet. Please
pass my letter on to the board.
Thank you,
Tammi Soehl
2712 S Glendale Ave
Sioux Falls SD 57105
I am totally against this variance. First of all this is a quote: "Variances should be rare and for reasons of exceptional
circumstance.“ The burden of proof that a variance is warranted lies with the applicant, not the board, planning
commission, or staff.
People buy their properties with rules and regulations established before they purchase the property. Just because you
want to put a 47 spot RV park plus 10 campsites does not mean you should get tojust apply for a variance and be able to
put that large ofa septic system in.
I bought on this lake because ofthe up north feeling. I do not want this lake to have the feeling ofa city lake or
overpopulated.
(4. Will the issuance of the variance maintain the essential character of the locality
The proposed drain?eld site that will not meet the 150’ OHW setback will be at least 100’ from the ordinary high water
mark and surrounded by a mature Norway Pine plantation so it will not be visible from the lake, Holly Road, or nearby
properties.)
Just because something is not visible does not mean it will not change the essential character.
The septic location for the intended use will destroy the natural resource of the land. A septic system this large will have
drainage pipes routed to all 47 spots for RV use. These RV pads are probably going to be concrete. so an impervious
surface which will cause all water to drain into the lake. You start cementing to much ofyour ground. you disrupt the
natural ?ow of rain and where the run of goes.
RV‘s today have a lot of sewer usage. The new ones all have washers and dryers, dishwashers and l to 3 bathrooms, some
with jacuzzi tubs. Really they use much than a house.
Most RV’s today are made for the winter months.so this will not be a seasonal park.
Just because there aren't policies to protect this from happening now is no reason to not start now and make them an
example.
Thank You,
Theresa Zolninger
I, Michael Eichenauer, have been a resident on Pickerel Lake since 1972 and I have seen this lake
change from small boats to large pontoon/recreational boats operating on this small 340-acre lake. I
am opposed to the variance application of 30—V—23
on the southwest corner of Pickerel Lake. If
approved, it will bring much more boat traffic along with a larger chance of incoming invasive species.
Secondly, the public access road is small and mostly maintained by the south shore lake
association not by the DNRor township. There is little parking available and wouldn't
accommodate the volume of vehicles and trailers that would possibly use the launch.
Thirdly, there is an established eagle nest on the lake front of the property. Per my research, the
MN DNRguide states that you can only be between 330-600 feet away from the eagle nest. No
construction can occur within 330 feet unless the contractorhas permits to override this law.
The proposed variance would allow the developer to build directly on top of this nest zone which
is totally unacceptable.
Fourth, the section of lakeshore is all cattails, weeds and lily pads with a base of muck and mud. I
am sure this would not be ideal for those families looking to use the beach for swimming. If this
application would be approved, I could see a dramatic negative change to the flora and fauna in
and around our lake.
Lastly, within 5 miles from our lake there are at least a dozen RV camps (the larger
being...Vagabond Village, Breeze Campgrounds, Hoosier Beach Resort, Mantrap Lake
Campground, Sleeping Fawn Resort, Whippoorwill Resort and Pine Park Resort). This area does
not need more.
We are a second—generation family here on the lake and hope that the natural beauty and peace
of the lake will still be there for our children and grandchildren when they inherit our property in
the future.
My name is Tim Olson and I am writing from my permanent address: 816 Fairview Ave
N, Saint Paul, MN 55164. I am a trustee of 17742 Happy Dr, Park Rapids, MN 56476.
which has endured in my view as my real home for all 30 years of my life and part
of my family tradition since 1968.
I believe this septic system setback poses a high risk to altering the background
pH and natural chemical balance of the lake. In my view this variance and waste
treatment proposal has a negative recreational and environmental impact which
runs counter to the projects stated goals.
It is my hope that the Hubbard County Planning Commission agrees with these
environmental findings and moves to deny the variance as proposed.
Eric Buitenwerf
EnvironmentalServices Director
Hubbard County EnvironmentalServices
301 Court Avenue
Park Rapids, MN 56470
The Lot Viewal Date for Variance application 30-V-23 is scheduled for Thursday, August 24, 2023
at 9:45 am and the Hearing before the Planning Commission/Board of Adjustment is scheduled
for Monday, August 28,2023 at 6:00 p.m.
permit
I agree with the staff report (30-V-23 Solien variance app staff rpt) regarding Part2 of the
application. A variance to reduce the setback requirement for the drain?eld should NOT be
granted.
The project is a large one apparently involving 47 RV sites, a 1000 sq ft cabin and a 1500 sq ft
home. It apparently is near the size requiring an EnvironmentalReview so I urge you to take this
into consideration.
In addition, I have concerns about the potential for erosion, pollution, and wetland issues
so
please take these into account during the lot viewal.
Sincerely,
David R. Nelson
Address of Residence:
17942 Happy Drive
Park Rapids, MN 56470
RECEIVED
AUG
23 2023
I was surprised and concerned to learn of the proposal for an RV park on the north end of Pickerel Lake.
My family and l are strongly against this proposal for a number of reasons.
We have been on this lake for 30+ years and one of the main reasons we decided to make this our
second home was because ofthe quiet, serene nature of this small gem of a lake. The addition of 47 RV
sites would drastically change the nature of this small lake, increasing boat traffic, jet skis and fishing
pressure. I can't fathom a development of this size on a lake as small as Pickerel.
Pickerel Lake has maintained a very natural shoreline with residents taking pride in the health of our
lakeshore and water quality. We are good stewards of this lake and are very concerned that this
development will change the lake we know and love.
Sincerely,
Q We Mir
Diane Wiseheart
Pickerel Lake
25886 Hoff Trail
Park Rapids, MN 56470
#~3cs..V~—c>?.3
/é,&J’.C?07/O