Castro, Vincent Charles P.

BSED English 3D

Qualitative Miscue Analysis Summary Sheet

Grade 6

The Life Cycle of Frogs

Text Miscue Semantically Syntactically Self- Beginnin Middl Endin Graphic-Sound

Acceptable Acceptable Corrections g e g Summary
frog prog yes yes ü some
yolk yow no no ü some
become becomes yes yes ü ü high
lives li yes yes yes ü some
As A no yes yes ü some
gradually gradua yes yes yes ü ü ü high
pairs pair yes yes yes ü some
frog prog yes yes ü some
Percentage of semantically acceptable miscues = (6/8) x 100% = 0.75 x 100% = 75%
Percentage of syntactically acceptable miscues = (7/8) x 100% = 0.875 x 100% = 87.5%
Percentage of successful self-correction = (4/4) x 100% = 1 x 100% = 100%
Percentage of miscues with high graphic-sound similarity = (2/8) x 100% = 0.25 x 100% = 25%
Percentage of miscues with some graphic-sound similarity = (6/8) x 100% = 0.75 x 100% = 75%

Extent to which reader reads for meaning = (6+4)/8 = 1.25 x 100% = 125%
 Grade 4

In Search for Peace and Freedom

Text Miscue Semantically Syntactically Self- Beginnin Middl Endin Graphic-Sound

Acceptable Acceptable Corrections g e g Summary
In none
Search none
for none
Peace none
and none
Freedom none
lived livid no no  some
Let Let's yes yes  some
a none
readily readly no no  some
Panay Pa-nay yes yes   high
fearless fearlessand no yes   high
undisturbe undistur- yes yes   high
d bed
bought but no no none
nipa nipay no yes  some
Malay's mala no no yes   high
peacefully and none
Percentage of semantically acceptable miscues = (3/17) x 100% = 0.1764 x 100% = 17.64%
Percentage of syntactically acceptable miscues = (5/17) x 100% = 0.2941 x 100% = 29.41
Percentage of successful self-correction = (1/1) x 100% = 1 x 100% = 100%
Percentage of miscues with high graphic-sound similarity = (4/17) x 100% = 0.2352 x 100% = 23.52%
Percentage of miscues with some graphic-sound similarity = (5/17) x 100% = 0.2941 x 100% = 29.41%

Extent to which reader reads for meaning = (3+1)/17 = 0.2352 x 100% = 23.52%