Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ESG Impact 2022 Report
ESG Impact 2022 Report
Marta Muñoz
Stephen Elliot
Senior Research Director and Lead
Group Vice President, I&O, Cloud
Technology & Sustainability Practice,
Operations, and DevOps, IDC
IDC EMEA
Dan Versace
Randy Perry
Research Analyst, Environmental,
Vice President, Sales Enablement
Social, and Governance (ESG)
Practice, IDC
Business Services, IDC
Table of Contents
Click on titles or page numbers to navigate to each section.
Executive Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
Metrics Matter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
Conclusion. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
Methodology. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
Executive Summary
In September 2021, IDC conducted a global survey, sponsored by ServiceNow, with For further firmographics
senior executives to gather insight into their current ESG strategies and business of who was surveyed,
priorities leading into 2022. The results of this research provide critical executive please see the
insights into what is shaping ESG leadership, investments in enabling technologies, methodology section at
and intended outcomes. the end of this paper.
These include:
Worldwide, ESG has become a very or extremely important business priority
for 72% of organizations with 500+ employees. It is crucial for 98% of companies
with 5,000+ employees.
ESG drivers have become more linked to business value. While cost savings
through energy management was the top driver stated by 37% of respondents,
product innovation also surfaced as a leading driver by 34% of senior leaders.
Still, organizations face ongoing challenges, 74% state they lack ESG expertise/
capability, 61% say they lack the right IT tools to report and measure and 59% say
they donʼt have the necessary operational technologies.
While ESG strategy is a multifunction responsibility, 97% say that CIOs play an
important or major role in the delivery of ESG outcomes.
N 2
LA CHNOLOGY .
TE
1. P
AC
T
ESG
FOUNDATION
PROC
LE
4. I M
OP
SE
ES
PE
CK
S
OV HE
PR
E 3. C
An ESG Foundation enables executives and teams to align ESG initiatives with the
business strategy and planning cycle, enabling companies to operationalize ESG into
their operating fabric. It also enables people to think differently about ESG; assessing
risks, opportunities and their unique role in planning, acting, checking, and improving
their organizationʼs ability to deliver ESG impact and ultimately tangible business value.
The terms sustainability and ESG are often used interchangeably, as both address
key challenges the world is currently facing. The individual ESG elements are
interconnected and important to define.
Social refers to topics such as employee attraction and retention; equitable labor
relations; diversity, equity, and inclusion practices, and community engagement.
IDCʼs survey results indicate that the importance of ESG increases as the size of an
organization increases: It is crucial for 98% of companies with 5,000 employees or
more compared to 45% of companies with 500 to 999 employees. This is often tied
to business and technology leadership teams that recognize the value creation from
ESG investments and their impact on stakeholders. From a purely financial impact
perspective, leadership teams are increasingly measuring ESG impact in terms
of top-line growth, cost reduction and containment, trust enablement, improved
transparency, risk mitigation, improvements in culture/mission alignment, and
employee engagement. These strategic imperatives should be at the forefront of
every C-suite executive decision-making process for new ESG opportunities for
long term value creation. Slowly, these objectives are also permeating into smaller
organizations who are often suppliers of the larger ones and therefore asked to
adhere to certain sustainability values.
Organizations often cite their number one benefit from ESG investments as driving down
costs (derived from energy efficiencies). While cost implications are still an important driver,
they are closely followed by the need to establish a positive impact on brand reputation — in
other words, trust. This has considerable implications for C-level executives who are sending
the right — and credible — signals to a customer base that is increasingly discerning about
ESG intentions and execution. ESG strategies need to be strongly aligned and integrated into
business criteria and objectives to ensure continued investments and scalability, reducing
the risk of greenwashing claims and enabling brand reputation and trust.
FIGURE 1
ESG Drivers Vary by Region
(% of respondents)
Q: What are the main drivers for your organization investing in sustainability?
Encouragingly, the ability to generate new product innovation is cited as the third
most important driver for organizations worldwide. This is often a consequence of
adapting design processes and production cycles to incorporate more sustainable
materials, to enable repair and remanufacture practices, and to create new business
models based on circular economy principles and “as a service” models.
In addition, investments in digital ESG tools often enable better governance structures
and processes, and improved data collection and tracking across teams for board,
C-suite, customer, regulatory, and investment reporting capabilities.
63 %
50 %
Education and Regulatory Executive management
Government requirements mandate
Finance
40 % Customer
demand 40 % New product
innovation
Manufacturing
46% Cost
41% Regulatory
requirements
Healthcare
52 % Cost
43 % New product
innovation
Retail
42% Customer
demand 42% Brand/image
60% 50%
Transport, Shift in corporate Customer
Communications, Utilities purpose demand
While a growing number of organizations are incorporating ESG principles into their
strategy and vision, an important gap remains between these corporate commitments
and the execution and operationalization of ESG objectives within the company.
Decision makers and senior executives refer to the following operational and
structural challenges when trying to act on their ESG objectives:
Operational Challenges
The lack of ESG expertise/capability is perceived as a top challenge for organizations, Almost all (99%) of
especially those trying to establish sustainability strategies and conduct materiality respondents would
assessments that require proficiencies outside the core competencies of traditional like an integrated
staff. In addition, the lack of IT tools to report and measure the companyʼs sustainability solution
sustainability policy impact — and that of their supply chain — is identified as the with 85% saying it would
second most important challenge. While a number of tools are beginning to emerge be highly valuable or
(carbon calculators, for example) many of these provide segmented information on a game changer.
specific emission drivers (such as cloud services, IT hardware, and employee travel)
and are mostly focused on the environmental aspects.
The availability of an integrated solution that can guide organizations through the
various stages of documenting material topics, setting goals and targets, defining
metrics, collecting metric-driven data from across the organization and generating
needed disclosures would simplify what can be today a resource- and time-intensive
process. Furthermore, there is a need for tools to incorporate regulatory aspects and
ensure auditable data across the different projects and initiatives, in order to facilitate
risk mitigation. A technology platform that can enable streamlined communications
and collaboration across teams and managerial layers will play a key role.
Although some of the necessary technology to avert a portion of the past and current
challenges is yet to be invented or needs to be more scalable, IT providers have made
considerable progress in creating solutions that provide transparency and control over
the initial step of measuring the current and future impact across all operations and the
wider supply chain.
FIGURE 2
Which department currently has the ESG budget?
(% of respondents)
Q: What department has the highest share of your organizationʼs sustainability budget?
IT 27%
Operations 12%
Finance 10%
Marketing/Sales 7%
Human resources 6%
That said, the technology foundation enables an enterprise-wide view of how The ability to digitize
the longer-term strategy is being operationalized, what the key challenges and processes and make
opportunities might be within environmental, social or governance focus areas, and work possible from
how initiatives and outcomes intersect. Leadership teams must understand their level anywhere is the most
of ESG maturity and the existence (or lack thereof) of governance structures within the important environmental
organization to support their ESG progress. impact of IT products
and services. This is
There is often an opportunity to integrate ESG practices and procedures into
closely followed by the
existing governance activities across business functions, in areas such as planning
ability to rightsize and
and strategy, reporting and dashboarding, human resources (HR) hiring practices,
run environmentally
hardware consolidation, asset management, energy management, procurement, and
efficient IT operations,
other business functions. In the case of governance, risk, and compliance (GRC), ESG
applications, and
has become an integral part for many organizations, which has led to the emergence
infrastructure and the
of integrated ESG/GRC risk-management solutions.
capacity to reuse, repair,
Therefore, technology as an enabler and the CIO as a sustainability champion play refurbish, and recycle IT
critical roles in the deployment and success of ESG initiatives. hardware assets.
By adopting a technology platform that empowers business (procurement, finance, One-third (32%) of
HR, etc.) and technology teams (development, customer support, operations, security, organizations intended
etc.) to manage and execute ESG projects, CIOs are at the center of enabling and to spend between
operationalizing ESG success. 10% to 30% of their IT
budgets in ESG-related
products and services
in 2021, and firms
have an expectation
to increase the share
of their IT budget
towards sustainability
by 3.7% in 2022.
Metrics Matter
As discussed earlier, ESG can feel daunting for practitioners to put into practice.
It is clear however that “you cannot manage what you donʼt measure”, so IDC asked
companies what their key performance metrics were — both from an environmental
angle as well as from social and governance perspectives. Not surprisingly, on the
environmental side, energy-management and risk-management metrics surfaced to
the top. From social and governance views, employee health and safety and data
security were key metrics being tracked.
FIGURE 3
Metrics that Matter
(% of respondents)
Q: With the current focus on climate change, for which Q: Besides environmental metrics, what other social or
of the following environmental metrics is your governance metrics is your organization currently
organization currently tracking its performance? tracking?
For the purpose of illustrating tangible steps of turning strategy into action, we will
dedicate the remainder of this paper to laying out a blueprint to integrating ESG into
business operations and showing how technology solutions can directly impact the
triple bottom line by accelerating business value creation.
C-SUITE VIEW:
Creating an ESG Action Plan
IDC outlines a four-step blueprint for leveraging technologies with workflows across teams
to deliver ESG outcomes (See Figure 4). It enables people to think differently about ESG by
continuously assessing both risks and opportunities. Importantly, it creates an integrated ESG
foundation that can help an organization overcome some of the operational and structural
challenges outlined earlier in this paper.
FIGURE 4
A C-Suite Approach to Building an ESG Strategy Through People, Process and Technology
AC
ESG foundation
to build trust and
transparency with
4. I M
Phase 1: Plan
To drive integrated processes and procedures, the importance of planning cannot
be understated. Planning and integrating ESG initiatives across the organizational
constructs, leadership teams, and operational staff effectively drive the collection,
sharing, and contextualization of data. This enables executives to gauge progress and
prioritize ESG projects and investments alongside or as part of other business plans
and operations. For global organizations, planning becomes paramount as regulatory
models differ by region and therefore create differing demands for reporting.
Using the right technologies (and workflows) can drive consistency and
standardization across key ESG areas such as stakeholder (and shareholder)
transparency and reporting, workforce diversity, emissions controls, regulator data
requirements, and workforce health, among other areas.
Determine which ESG issues the company has already been managing without a
formal ESG strategy and celebrate progress in those areas.
Define goals and targets (ESG key performance indicators) across the relevant
teams.
Integrate ESG with day to day business ops and company culture.
EXAMPLE
Planning and integrating hardware asset management technology and processes can enable the proper
tracking of energy usage, the reuse, remanufacturing and responsible recycling of used and depreciated
IT hardware, and a sustainability connection between the employee and their environmental impact.
This information (energy and asset use, recycling) becomes critical for sustainability objectives and
empowers IT to work with procurement, workplace services, and sustainability offices to align objectives,
map outcomes, and reuse data for environmental- and regulatory-specific requirements.
Phase 2: Act
Use the technology platform and processes to refine ESG metrics and outcomes that
are aligned to organizationsʼ overall strategies. ESG metrics should not be considered
a “tax” on doing business but rather an enabler to drive business value. That said,
defining metrics is critical for achieving ESG goals, but having too many metrics can
cause confusion and lack of focus. In addition to metrics, identify the key workflows (and
associated stakeholders and teams) that drive desired outcomes to promote real change.
Match relevant data with the workflows that can operationalize the collection and
dashboarding of ESG metrics.
EXAMPLE
Social and diversity requirements are often supported through HR technologies that collect information
from across the organization and enable a positive and productive employee experience. Recent
examples include the ability to have a safe return to the workplace for employees, and the broader theme
of employee health and safety. This use case requires connecting people, systems, and functions across
an organization to deliver outcomes and create opportunities for advancements.
Phase 3: Check
Consider data disclosure and its related requirements for effective data collection,
analysis and processing. The data can be HR and IT management sourced as well as
from third-party streams such as ratings orgs or supply chain partners. For example,
the ability to implement changes that drive successful environmental outcomes can
exist across a core set of energy, regulatory, waste generation, and carbon emissions
initiatives. Pinpointing data and performance gaps across teams becomes paramount to
checking progress and establishing improvement opportunities.
Increase data quality and accuracy for measuring ESG success and progress.
Enhance ESG data reporting and access with streamlined data collection and
contextual dashboards.
Give the sustainability frontline team easy access to insights and tasks via mobile
apps, reporting, and dashboards.
Ensure that the ESG data gets to the right people via an auditable and
transparent process.
EXAMPLE
Phase 4: Improve
Executives should focus on creating policies and procedures that interlock ESG
initiatives with their associated business risks as well as the opportunity for product
innovation. Monitoring, measuring, and reporting on ESG key performance indicators
requires quality data and solid communications across teams and with executive
stakeholders. This phase presents an opportunity to train or retrain stakeholders
towards new behaviors, adoption of new processes, adapting to changing regulatory
requirements, and use of new technologies to deliver ESG improvements.
Automate the data collection process used to support ESG initiatives, policies,
and governance guardrails; identify new data sources and stakeholders if required.
Reuse some of the data captured in the discovery and inventory processes, and
data stores, for ESG reporting, analysis, and disclosures.
EXAMPLE
The use of integrated risk-management technology can enable the move away from manual,
spreadsheet-based data collection to automated processes. Creating an ESG data platform that
enables teams to collect and analyze ESG data from different functional teams on an ongoing basis
drives transparency and increased confidence in the accuracy of trending and performance statistics.
It also provides a foundation for data-driven discussions that can lead to improvement opportunities
across ESG initiatives.
Conclusion
The time for action is now, as many CEOs now consider their technology architecture to
be their business architecture. Now, more than ever, technology is enabling ESG success,
delivering data collection and access, collaboration, reporting, and baselining capabilities
across ESG metrics and processes, empowering business and technology teams to
deliver powerful, transformational information, fast and at scale.
Methodology
Region
Technology 18%
Finance 15%
18% 41% 41%
500 – 999 1,000 – 4,999 > 5,000
Business or professional
services
15%
Process manufacturing 7%
30% 24% 20%
Discrete manufacturing 6% SVP/VP/Director SVP/VP/Director SVP/VP/Director
Operations IT Sales/Marketing
Healthcare 5%
Message from
the Sponsor
ServiceNow believes that together we can workflow a more sustainable,
equitable, and ethical world. ServiceNow can be your platform for ESG
impact, connecting environmental, social, and governance use cases with
an operational control tower that helps you efficiently plan, manage, govern,
and report on ESG. Workflow with us to mobilize your ESG strategy, build
transparency and trust, and deliver long-term value and impact.
© 2022 IDC Research, Inc. IDC materials are licensed for external use, and in no way does the use or publication
of IDC research indicate IDCʼs endorsement of the sponsorʼs or licenseeʼs products or strategies.
Privacy Policy | CCPA