Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Transforaminal Debridement With A Posterior Only.62
Transforaminal Debridement With A Posterior Only.62
OPEN
Abstract
The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical and imaging results of transforaminal debridement with a posterior-only approach
involving placement of an interbody bone graft combined with diseased vertebral fixation for the treatment of thoracic and lumbar
tuberculosis (TB) with a minimum 5-year follow-up.
Sixty-five patients who presented with active thoracic and lumbar TB between October 2006 and August 2013 were
retrospectively analyzed: 20 were thoracic TB (group A), 17 were thoracolumbar TB (group B), and 28 were lumbar TB (group C). The
patient data, operating time, blood loss, Visual Analog Scale score, Oswestry Disability Index score, correction of kyphosis, recovery
of neurological function, and complications were recorded and analyzed.
The patients were followed for 68.7 ± 17.8 months. The preoperative average Cobb angles of kyphosis in patients in groups A, B,
and C significantly decreased from 28.2 ± 11.9°, 30.5 ± 16.9°, and 10.9 ± 8.8° before surgery to 8.0 ± 5.4°, 5.0 ± 4.1°, and –4.4 ± 1.6°
(– indicates lordosis) after surgery, respectively. At the final follow-up time, the Cobb angles were 9.2 ± 6.1°, 6.8 ± 10.0°, and -3.7 ±
2.0°, respectively. The postoperative Cobb angles of kyphosis were significantly improved in all groups (P < .05). The correction loss
angles were larger in groups A and B than in group C (P > .05). The operating time, blood loss, and complications were not
significantly different between the groups (P > .05). Three (4.6%) patients developed unhealed TB during postoperative anti-TB
treatment, and 6 patients (9.2%) with TB relapsed after healing from surgery.
The posterior-only approach for the surgical treatment of thoracic and lumbar TB achieved satisfactory outcomes over long-term
follow-up. The implantation of pedicle screws in diseased vertebrae reduced the range of fixation, but patients with thoracic and
thoracolumbar TB should undergo fixation to at least 1 adjacent normal segment. There were some cases of recurrence after TB
healed, and long-term follow-up is therefore necessary.
Abbreviations: CRP = C-reactive protein, ESR = erythrocyte sedimentation rate, MRI = magnetic resonance imaging, ODI =
Oswestry Disability Index, PO = per os, TB = tuberculosis, VAS = Visual Analog Scale.
Keywords: diseased vertebral fixation, long-term follow-up, posterior approach, spinal tuberculosis
1
Zhao et al. Medicine (2020) 99:22 Medicine
2
Zhao et al. Medicine (2020) 99:22 www.md-journal.com
(ODI) score, kyphosis angle, neurofunctional improvement, and and C (32.1%) than in group A (5%). There was no significant
complications were recorded. The kyphosis angle was measured difference in age, sex or neurological impairment among the
by the Cobb angle, and we defined kyphosis as a lumbar angle groups.
>0° and thoracic and thoracolumbar angles >10°. Neural At the final postoperative follow-up, VAS and ODI scores had
function was assessed based on the American Spinal Injury significantly improved in all 3 groups. There was no significant
Association impairment scale. difference in operating time, blood loss, VAS score, or ODI score
The data were analyzed using IBM SPSS Statistics Version 19. among the 3 groups. The detailed clinical outcomes are shown in
Operating time, blood loss, VAS score, ODI score, and kyphosis Table 2.
angle were analyzed and compared using analysis of variance. The average Cobb angles of the patients with kyphosis in
Patient characteristics and complications were analyzed using the groups A, B, and C were 28.2 ± 11.9°, 30.5 ± 16.9°, and 10.9 ±
Chi-squared test. 8.8°, respectively. The preoperative Cobb angle of kyphosis was
larger in groups A and B than in group C and significantly
decreased postoperatively to 8.0 ± 5.4°, 5.0 ± 4.1°, and –4.4 ± 1.6°
3. Results
(the negative number indicates lordosis), respectively. At the final
The mean follow-up time was 68.7 ± 17.8 months (range 60–130 follow-up time, the Cobb angles were 9.2 ± 6.1°, 6.8 ± 10.0°, and
months). The patient data are shown in Table 1. Multiple –3.7 ± 2.0°, respectively. The correction loss angle was larger in
segments (more than 1 segment) and kyphosis were more likely to groups A and B than in group C. The correction of kyphosis is
be involved in patients in group A (35%, 75%) and group B shown in Table 3.
(11.8%, 58.8%) than in those in group C (7.1%, 14.3%). Psoas The complications that occurred in each group are shown in
or iliac abscesses were more likely to occur in groups B (35.3%) Table 4. Three (4.6%) of the 65 patients developed unhealed TB
during postoperative anti-TB treatment, and the other patients
achieved bony fusion. Six patients (9.2%) experienced TB relapse
Table 1 after healing. Two of 3 patients with unhealed TB were cured
Patient data. with a posterior-only reoperation, and the other was cured with
conservative treatment. In group A, 1 patient experienced TB
Group A Group B Group C
relapse 72 months after surgery. In group B, 2 patients with TB
Patients (no.) 20 17 28 relapsed 59 and 63 months after surgery. In group C, 3 patients
Sex (male/female) 11/9 9/8 11/17 with TB relapsed 23, 35, and 48 months after surgery. The
Age (Y/O) 35.6 ± 11.1 33.9 ± 12.5 39.5 ± 12.3 patient in group C who experienced TB relapse at 23 months was
∗
Multiple segments (no.) 7 (35%) 2 (11.8%) 2 (7.1%)
cured with a posterior-only reoperation, while the others were
Psoas or iliac abscess (no.)† 1 (5%) 6 (35.3%) 9 (32.1%)
Neurological impairment (no.) 9 (45%) 6 (35.3%) 15 (53.6%)
cured with conservative treatment. In group C, the lumbar artery
Kyphosis (no.)‡ 15 (75%) 10 (58.8%) 4 (14.3%) was injured during the operation in 1 case but was cured after
∗
embolization. All other complications were cured after conser-
Comparison of groups A and B (P > .05), B and C (P < .05) and A and C (P < .05). vative treatment. There was no significant difference in the
†
Comparison of groups A and B (P < .05), B and C (P > .05) and A and C (P > .05).
‡
Comparison of groups A and B (P > .05), B and C (P < .05) and A and C (P < .05).
incidence of complications among the 3 groups Figs. 1 and 2.
Table 2
Clinical outcomes.
VAS ODI
∗
Group Pre FFU Pre FFU† Operating time (min) Blood loss (mL)
A 3.3 ± 1.2 0.7 ± 0.7 28.3 ± 20.6% 5.2% ± 6.0% 281.3 ± 101.3 910.0 ± 594.6
B 3.9 ± 1.1 0.8 ± 0.6 23.0 ± 12.8% 7.5% ± 7.8% 310.2 ± 149.1 705.9 ± 908.6
C 3.6 ± 0.8 0.7 ± 0.9 21.1 ± 11.5% 4.9% ± 10.3% 277.0 ± 160.0 748.2 ± 1146.2
FFU = final follow-up; Pre = preoperative.
∗
Comparison of FFU VAS and Pre VAS, P < .05.
†
Comparison of FFU ODI and Pre ODI, P < .05.
Table 3
Correction of kyphosis (Cobb angle).
∗
Group Pre Post† FFU‡ Correction Lossx
A 28.2 ± 11.9° 8.0 ± 5.4° 9.2 ± 6.1° 20.2° 1.2°
B 30.5 ± 16.9° 5.0 ± 4.1° 6.8 ± 10.0° 25.5° 1.8°
C 10.9 ± 8.8° 4.4 ± 1.6° 3.7 ± 2.0° 15.3° 0.7°
FFU = final follow-up; Post = postoperative; Pre = preoperative.
Correction = correction angle; Loss = correction loss angle; “–“ indicates lordosis.
∗
Comparison of groups A and B (P > .05), B and C (P < .05) and A and C (P < .05).
†
Comparison of post- and pre-Cobb angles, P < .05.
‡
Comparison of FFU and post-Cobb angle, P > .05.
x
Comparison of groups A and B (P > .05), B and C (P > .05) and A and C (P > .05).
3
Zhao et al. Medicine (2020) 99:22 Medicine
Figure 1. Case I: A 31-year-old male patient with T8–9 tuberculosis in group A. A–D show the preoperative X-ray, computed tomography (CT), and magnetic
resonance imaging scans. Screws were implanted in the bilateral pedicles of diseased vertebrae, and the remaining vertebrae were >50% maintained; thus, the
range of fixation was from 1 upper to 1 lower normal segment. E and F show the 1-year postoperative X-ray and CT scans, respectively. G–J show the 4-year
postoperative X-ray, CT, and magnetic resonance imaging scans, as indicated.
At the final follow-up time, all patients with neurological can easily occur during posterior surgery but does not cause
impairment had improved by at least 1 level on the American serious consequences, such as TB meningitis. Performing the
Spinal Injury Association impairment scale. Each patient with operation under a non-direct view may result in damage to the
grade B and C impairment in group A improved to grade D, while anterior vessels, and the relationship between vessels and lesions
the other patients in the 3 groups improved to grade E. should therefore be observed with MRI before surgery.
Spinal TB destroys the anterior column in most cases, and the
collapse of the anterior column causes kyphosis.[12] Kyphosis
4. Discussion
correction and spinal stability are important factors in spinal TB
Transforaminal debridement with a posterior-only approach and surgery. A meta-analysis reported that posterior surgery was
placement of an interbody bone graft combined with fixation is a better than anterior surgery for correcting kyphosis.[13] Our
new surgical method for thoracic and lumbar TB. There is some study demonstrates that posterior surgery can correct kyphosis
controversy regarding whether posterior-only surgery can be and restore lumbar lordosis. The pedicle screw system used in
used to effectively debride TB lesions as the operation involves a posterior surgery can provide spinal 3-column stability. Anterior
non-direct view and destabilization of the spine with destruction column support combined with posterior column compression
of the posterior spinal column. and osteotomy can, when necessary, effectively correct kyphosis.
Debridement methods with a posterior-only approach mainly To improve the stability of the spine, most surgeons adopt a
include transpedicular and transforaminal approaches. Zhang fixation strategy involving fixation to 1 or 2 adjacent normal
et al reported that debridement with a posterior transpedicular segments to treat thoracic and lumbar TB.[4,11,14,15] However,
approach combined with placement of a bone graft and fixation this strategy sacrifices normal spinal motion. Some studies have
could heal TB and improve neurological function.[11] Wang et al reported that pedicles can provide approximately 70% of the
resected the spinous process and unilateral facet joint to debride holding force, and the implantation of pedicle screws in fractured
TB lesions at 270°.[6] In this study, we debrided TB lesions using a vertebrae can reduce screw stress while increasing the axial load
transforaminal approach, and more than 95% of the patients and providing anti-flexion and anti-rotation abilities to the entire
were cured. Debridement with a bilateral transforaminal internal fixation system.[16,17] In many cases, TB destroys the
approach could remove TB lesions effectively at 360°, even vertebral body but not the pedicle, providing conditions allowing
though some operations were performed with a non-direct view. the implantation of screws. We believe that pedicle screws can
This method is convenient for spinal canal decompression and provide great stability when they are implanted in the bilateral
allows spinous processes and ligaments to be maintained. In pedicles of diseased vertebrae and in cases where >50% of the
addition, preservation of the pedicle provides a condition vertebrae remain, thus appropriately reducing the range of
allowing the implantation of screws. Cerebrospinal fluid leakage fixation. This study shows that this fixation strategy can
4
Zhao et al. Medicine (2020) 99:22 www.md-journal.com
Figure 2. Case II: A 24-year-old female patient with L3–4 tuberculosis (TB) in group C. A and B show the preoperative X-ray and magnetic resonance imaging
scans, respectively. Screws were implanted in the bilateral pedicles of diseased vertebrae, and the remaining vertebrae were >50% maintained; therefore, the
range of fixation was only the lesion segment. C–E show that TB was cured 1 year after surgery. F and G show TB relapse 3 years after surgery. H–J show that TB
was cured by anti-TB treatment again at 5 years after surgery.
effectively stabilize the spine. The correction loss angle was only immunity is low. Therefore, long-term follow-up is necessary in
0.7° to 1.8°. patients with thoracic and lumbar TB.
The loss angle was larger in groups A and B than in group C. Thoracic, thoracolumbar and lumbar TB have different
Pedicle screws placed in the lumbar region provide strong characteristics due to anatomical and biomechanical differences.
stability because of the large pedicles and vertebral bodies. Thus, Lumbar TB can compensate for some kyphotic deformities due to
the lumbar cases were fixed only at the lesion segment to allow physiologic lordosis and large discs.[21] The results of this study
more spinal motion when possible. However, the pedicles and also show that the angle and incidence of kyphosis were
vertebral bodies of the thoracic and thoracolumbar regions are significantly lower in group C than in groups A and B. The lesions
small, and the thoracolumbar region is the site of stress easily spread through the interspace of the psoas major and
concentration; thus, the range of fixation requires at least 1 formed gravitation abscesses in thoracolumbar and lumbar TB.
adjacent normal segment. The screws should be implanted on the Debridement with an anterior extraperitoneal approach was
anterior edge of the vertebral body in an upper or lower direction required if the gravitation abscess could not be removed with
to avoid the bone defect area and increase the holding force. posterior-only surgery.
Unhealed or relapsing spinal TB is a serious complication. Wang Of course, this study has some limitations, such as a single-
et al reported that the postoperative recurrence rate of spinal TB center retrospective study and the inadequacy number of cases
was 3.2%, while that of complex TB was as high as 24.1%.[18] Ren studied. The results of this study need to be further confirmed by
et al reported an unhealed or relapse rate of 10.3% in a 28.7-month studies with multi-center, prospective and more cases.
follow-up study.[19] Many short-term follow-up studies have
reported satisfactory outcomes and a low recurrence rate following
5. Conclusions
posterior surgical treatment of spinal TB.[3,15,20] However, few
reports have included long-term follow-up results. In this study, The surgical treatment of thoracic and lumbar TB with a
4.6% of patients developed unhealed TB during postoperative posterior-only approach can achieve satisfactory outcomes over
anti-TB treatment, while 9.2% of patients developed relapse after long-term follow-up. Transforaminal debridement can preserve
healing, with the latest case occurring 72 months after surgery. the pedicles, and the implantation of pedicle screws in diseased
Postoperative unhealed TB may be related to incomplete removal vertebrae can reduce the range of fixation. However, patients
of lesions, nonstandard chemotherapy, drug resistance, hypo- with thoracic and thoracolumbar TB should undergo fixation to
immunity, and so on. TB relapse after healing may be associated at least 1 adjacent normal segment. Cases of recurrence may still
with resting-stage mycobacterium TB recurrence when patient occur after TB healing, and long-term follow-up is necessary.
5
Zhao et al. Medicine (2020) 99:22 Medicine
Author contributions spinal tuberculosis: a retrospective case series. J Spinal Disord Tech
2006;19:595–602.
Conceptualization: Xiaobing Pu, Qiang Zhou. [8] Ukunda UNF, Lukhele MM. The posterior-only surgical approach in the
Data curation: Chen Zhao, Liehua Liu, Pei Li, Lichuan Liang, Fei treatment of tuberculosis of the spine. Bone Joint J 2018;100-B:1208–13.
Luo, Tianyong Hou, Fei Dai, Jianzhong Xu, Qiang Zhou. [9] Jain A, Jain RK, Kiyawat V. Evaluation of outcome of transpedicular
decompression and instrumented fusion in thoracic and thoracolumbar
Formal analysis: Chen Zhao, Liehua Liu, Qiang Zhou. tuberculosis. Asian Spine J 2017;11:31–6.
Investigation: Chen Zhao, Lei Luo, Xiaobing Pu, Liehua Liu, Pei [10] Sun L, Song Y, Liu L, et al. One-stage posterior surgical treatment for
Li, Lichuan Liang, Fei Luo, Tianyong Hou, Fei Dai, Jianzhong lumbosacral tuberculosis with major vertebral body loss and kyphosis.
Xu, Qiang Zhou. Orthopedics 2013;36:e1082–90.
[11] Zhang P, Peng W, Wang X, et al. Minimum 5-year follow-up outcomes
Methodology: Chen Zhao, Lei Luo, Xiaobing Pu, Qiang Zhou.
for single-stage transpedicular debridement, posterior instrumentation
Project administration: Lei Luo, Xiaobing Pu, Qiang Zhou. and fusion in the management of thoracic and thoracolumbar spinal
Software: Chen Zhao. tuberculosis in adults. Br J Neurosurg 2016;30:666–71.
Supervision: Qiang Zhou. [12] Huang J, Zhang H, Zeng K, et al. The clinical outcomes of surgical
Writing – original draft: Chen Zhao. treatment of noncontiguous spinal tuberculosis: a retrospective study in
23 cases. PloS One 2014;9:e93648.
Writing – review & editing: Chen Zhao, Liehua Liu, Pei Li, Qiang [13] Yang P, Zang Q, Kang J, et al. Comparison of clinical efficacy and safety
Zhou. among three surgical approaches for the treatment of spinal tuberculosis:
a meta-analysis. Eur Spine J 2016;25:3862–74.
[14] Garg B, Kandwal P, Nagaraja UB, et al. Anterior versus posterior
References
procedure for surgical treatment of thoracolumbar tuberculosis: a
[1] Organization WH. Global tuberculosis report. World Health Organiza- retrospective analysis. Indian J Orthop 2012;46:165–70.
tion; 2018; Available from: http://www.who.int/tb/publications/global_ [15] Zhang H, Sheng B, Tang M, et al. One-stage surgical treatment for upper
report/GraphicExecutiveSummary. thoracic spinal tuberculosis by internal fixation, debridement, and
[2] Wang B, Lv G, Liu W, et al. Anterior radical debridement and combined interbody and posterior fusion via posterior-only approach.
reconstruction using titanium mesh cage for the surgical treatment of Eur Spine J 2013;22:616–23.
thoracic and thoracolumbar spinal tuberculosis: minimum five-year [16] Anekstein Y, Brosh T, Mirovsky Y. Intermediate screws in short segment
follow-up. Turk Neurosurg 2011;21:575–81. pedicular fixation for thoracic and lumbar fractures: a biomechanical
[3] Liu P, Sun M, Li S, et al. A retrospective controlled study of three different study. J Spinal Disord Tech 2007;20:72–7.
operative approaches for the treatment of thoracic and lumbar spinal [17] Mahar A, Kim C, Wedemeyer M, et al. Short-segment fixation of lumbar
tuberculosis: three years of follow-up. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 2015;128: burst fractures using pedicle fixation at the level of the fracture. Spine
25–34. 2007;32:1503–7.
[4] Liang Q, Wang Q, Sun G, et al. Five-year outcomes of posterior affected- [18] Wang B, Kong L, Zhu Z, et al. Recurrent complex spinal tuberculosis
vertebrae fixation in lumbar tuberculosis patients. J Orthop Surg Res accompanied by sinus tract formation: causes of recurrence and clinical
2018;13:210. treatments. Sci Rep 2018;8:6933.
[5] Liu J, Wan L, Long X, et al. Efficacy and safety of posterior versus [19] Ren HL, Jiang JM, Wang JX, et al. Is duration of preoperative anti-
combined posterior and anterior approach for the treatment of spinal tuberculosis treatment a risk factor for postoperative relapse or non-
tuberculosis: a meta-analysis. World Neurosurg 2015;83:1157–65. healing of spinal tuberculosis? Eur Spine J 2016;25:3875–83.
[6] Wang LJ, Zhang HQ, Tang MX, et al. Comparison of three surgical [20] Pu X, Zhou Q, He Q, et al. A posterior versus anterior surgical approach in
approaches for thoracic spinal tuberculosis in adult: minimum 5-year combination with debridement, interbody autografting and instrumenta-
follow up. Spine 2017;42:808–17. tion for thoracic and lumbar tuberculosis. Int Orthop 2012;36:307–13.
[7] Lee SH, Sung JK, Park YM. Single-stage transpedicular decompression and [21] Rajasekaran S. Natural history of Pott’s kyphosis. Eur Spine J 2013;22
posterior instrumentation in treatment of thoracic and thoracolumbar (Suppl. 4):634–40.