Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Leadership Challenge 1
Leadership Challenge 1
Currently, I am the Deputy Principal at St Alipius Parish School and have been in this role
since 2021. Prior to this, I was a lead teacher at another Catholic primary school in Ballarat.
I came to St Alipius after successfully applying for the advertised Deputy Principal position
which I saw as a great opportunity to develop my educational leadership skills.
The current enrolment of St Alipius sits at 242 primary school students (September, 2023).
The student population is relatively diverse, with a significant number of families, from both
Aboriginal and Indian backgrounds. We also welcome families from a diversity of
socio-economic backgrounds, with the recent Index of Community Socio-educational
Advantage (ICSEA) quartiles being reflective of this diversity.
(https://www.myschool.edu.au/school/45636).
Over the past 10 years, St Alipius has invested a significant amount of time and resources
into bolstering wellbeing and child safety - in part influenced by the Royal Commission into
Institutional Sexual Abuse. Whilst this intense focus has been beneficial for the social,
emotional and psychological safety of the students, it has come at the expense of academic
performance and growth. Past standardised testing scores are an example of this impact
as they show low performance, despite having an ICSEA profile that suggests potential for
greater academic success. See below for examples of National Assessment Program -
Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN) data from the MySchool website which are evidence of
this:
2017
2018
This academic languishing was also picked up in the 2020 External School Review,
conducted as part of a Five-Year School Improvement Cycle. This review was very
complimentary of the school’s inclusive and contemporary approach to schooling that
prioritised the wellbeing of both staff and students. However, the report also recommended
a more stringent approach towards teaching and learning, with an emphasis on improving
teacher capability - particularly in being able to use data. The review report also
recommended that the school embed a feedback culture to encourage continual
improvement practices.
2
Consequently, after much research and discernment by the school leadership team, the
decision was made to engage Corwin Australia in order to adopt a Visible Learning
pedagogy at St Alipius. A three year partnership (2021-2023) was formed between the
school and Corwin, who would provide both ‘job-embedded’ professional development for
staff, as well as access to Corwin consultant Shane Crawford, who would give support and
guidance in the role of ‘critical friend’.
Given that my employment came after the formation of the partnership with Corwin, these
events would ultimately frame much of my role as Deputy Principal at St Alipius. In turn, this
has also shaped my leadership challenge for the Brown Collective program, which is “to
systematically embed a Visible Learning pedagogy at St Alipius”.
Additionally, taking on Visible Learning as part of my leadership challenge would assist the
school in addressing some of the recommendations from the aforementioned 2020 External
School Review. The Review identified the following key priorities to be the focus on the
2021-2025 school strategic plan:
For me as a leader:
This challenge is significant for me, as an aspiring principal, as it provides an opportunity to
develop and refine leadership skills, as specified by the Australian Institute for Teaching and
School Leadership (AITSL) Principal standards. These include:
- Articulate a clear vision;
- Develop and draw upon knowledge and understanding of researched-based
educational pedagogy to improve student outcomes;
- Lead teaching and learning through a positive culture of challenge and support;
- Build a professional learning community that seeks and responds to feedback;
- Lead improvement, innovation and change;
- Leading the management of the school;
3
- Engaging with the wider community to promote lifelong learning.
For a more comprehensive overview of change outcomes, their purpose and their impact,
please refer to the Appendix at the end of this document.
Success in addressing the Visible Learning challenge can be measured through both
quantitative and qualitative data. Quantitatively, improvements in student achievement data,
such as increased test scores and reduced achievement gaps, serve as tangible indicators
of success. Qualitatively, observations of enhanced classroom practices, greater teacher
collaboration, and increased student motivation provide deeper insights.
In determining the success of the challenge, the following data tools will be used as impact
measures:
- Visible Learning Mind Frames surveys
- Visible Learning Capability Assessments
- The Tell Them From Me (TTFM) survey (staff, students and parents)
- Standardised testing results - eg. NAPLAN, PAT
- Essential Assessment pre and post test data
In order to successfully lead and achieve these change outcomes, it will be important to:
- Work collaboratively with the principal and leadership team to oversee strategic
directions and to develop a concise Annual Action Plan;
- Facilitate opportunities for staff professional development and goal setting;
- Promote a data-driven approach, supporting educators to regularly assess the impact
of their teaching strategies using data;
- Foster a collaborative environment that encourages educators to share best
practices and learn from one another;
- Work collaboratively with staff to develop collective teacher efficacy;
- Lead a team of impact coaches to embed a feedback culture;
- Develop the impact coach capacity and distribute leadership;
- Develop clear policies, procedures and guidelines to bring clarity and consistency for
staff around Visible Learning;
- Develop a meeting schedule that prioritises Visible Learning for whole staff;
- Develop and implement strong structures to provide a ‘system’ (eg Master schedule);
- Establish mechanisms for monitoring the process and impact of the Visible Learning
implementation;
- Provide support and resources to teachers to successfully implement Visible
Learning into classrooms.
Leadership Link
Evidence of aligning ‘the challenge’ outcomes to the Strategic Plan and Review
outcomes
As mentioned previously, there is a clear and direct link with my leadership challenge to the
2020 School Review. In turn, this has then fed into the school’s Strategic Plan and Annual
Action Plans. These documents clearly outline adopting a school-wide Visible Learning
pedagogy as a key strategy for addressing the key priorities of the School Review.
Additionally, my leadership challenge also addresses the broader priorities of the Ballarat
Catholic diocese, namely:
- Empowering all to flourish
- Building inclusive Catholic learning communities
5
- Achieving best practice
- Fostering inspiring leadership
- Enhancing family engagement, governance and stewardship.
This alignment between my leadership challenge, the School Review and the broader
priorities of the Ballarat Catholic diocese reinforces the strategic coherence and collective
commitment between the school and its governor.
John Hattie's Visible Learning research underscores the vital importance of relationships in
education. Through his extensive analysis, Hattie recognizes that positive teacher-student
relationships are a critical factor in enhancing student achievement. When students feel
valued, supported, and connected to their teachers, they are more likely to engage in the
learning process, take risks, and persevere through challenges. These relationships foster
trust and create an environment where students are comfortable seeking help and feedback,
ultimately leading to improved learning outcomes. Hattie's research serves as a powerful
reminder that beyond instructional strategies, the human connections formed within
classrooms significantly impact the educational journey and contribute to the holistic
development of students.
The emphasis on the importance of relationships in John Hattie's Visible Learning research
directly resonates with the core values and goals of the Brown Collective program, which
places a significant emphasis on relationships in educational leadership. Hattie's research
underscores the pivotal role that positive teacher-student relationships play in student
achievement. In a similar vein, the Brown Collective program recognizes that strong
relationships within the educational community are essential for effective leadership.
Educational leaders who prioritise relationships build trust, foster collaboration, and create a
supportive atmosphere where teachers and staff feel valued and motivated.
6
References:
1. Hattie, J. (2008). Visible learning. Routledge.
2. Fullan, M. (2006). Change theory: A force for school improvement. Center for Strategic
Education,
What leadership strengths and capabilities do you have to respond to this challenge?
- Having a strong vision about education that includes a balance between academic
achievement and prosperous wellbeing for all;
- Effective communications skills (both spoken and written);
- An ability to adapt to changing circumstances and make informed decisions in
dynamic situations (especially those requiring a calm, considered manner);
- Strong problem solving skills and an ability to analyse complex issues, identify
solutions and make decisions for the greater good of the team/school/community;
- Capacity to be creative, innovative and solution-focused.
As a leader, I have had lots of experience at leading smaller teams that come with a deeper,
more intimate connection and deeper understanding of each other. I have always worked
well in paired situations and small groups. Whilst the skills of leadership may be similar, I
recognise that leading the whole staff team presents a different level of challenge. I cannot
help but feel a bit nervous about the prospect of stepping into this larger leadership role. The
dynamic of a larger team is undoubtedly more complex, and the responsibility feels greater.
These feelings of nervousness also seem to trigger a sense of Imposter Syndrome within
me. I find myself questioning whether I truly have what it takes to lead a larger team
effectively, despite my previous successes with smaller groups. It is almost as if I fear that
my past accomplishments were a stroke of luck, and that I might be exposed as an imposter
in this new, more significant role. However, I remind myself that Imposter Syndrome is a
common experience for many leaders, especially when transitioning to larger
responsibilities. It is important to acknowledge these feelings, but also to remember that my
7
skills and experiences have prepared me for this challenge. By embracing this discomfort
and continuing to learn and grow, I can overcome these doubts and lead the staff team with
confidence and authenticity.
Fortunately, the support I've found within my Brown Collective syndicate group has been
instrumental in alleviating the Imposter Syndrome that sometimes creeps in. Sharing my
feelings of self-doubt and vulnerability with my syndicate members has been a reassuring
experience. It turns out that many of my peers have faced similar doubts at various points in
their leadership journeys, and their insights and encouragement have been invaluable. The
sense of camaraderie and the opportunity to learn from one another's experiences has not
only normalised these feelings but has also provided practical strategies and a supportive
network to help combat them. Through this collective support, I've come to realise that
leadership growth often involves embracing moments of self-doubt and that it's okay to ask
for help and guidance from those who understand the challenges firsthand.
In addition to the support from my syndicate group, the opportunities for coaching within the
Brown Collective program have been instrumental in my journey to combat Imposter
Syndrome and grow as a leader. Working closely with coaches, like Sam and Amanda, has
been incredibly helpful. Their guidance, expertise, and personalised feedback have provided
me with a clear roadmap for self-improvement. Sam's deep understanding of leadership
dynamics and Amanda's insights into building confidence have been enlightening. Together,
they've not only validated my strengths but also helped me address specific areas where I
can enhance my leadership abilities. Their unwavering support and belief in my potential
have given me the confidence to face the challenges of leading a larger team with a
renewed sense of purpose and self-assurance.
In completing this leadership challenge, I am drawing upon John Hattie's Visible Learning
and Michael Fullan's change theory, which share a common commitment to enhancing
education through evidence-based practices and meaningful transformation. Hattie's
research emphasises the importance of identifying high-impact teaching strategies and
continuously assessing their effectiveness to drive student achievement. Fullan's change
theory, on the other hand, focuses on the complexities of implementing educational change
and highlights the significance of strong leadership, collaborative cultures, and a deep
understanding of the change process. These two perspectives intersect when considering
that Visible Learning can serve as a valuable tool within Fullan's change framework. Hattie's
research can inform leaders about which instructional practices are most likely to drive
positive change, while Fullan's theory provides the framework for implementing those
practices effectively and sustainably, fostering a holistic approach to educational
improvement.
Central to Michael Fullan's change theory is the recognition that teachers are pivotal change
agents within schools. They are the individuals who directly interact with students on a daily
basis, and their instructional practices have a profound impact on student learning
outcomes. Empowering teachers to embrace and drive change is essential for the
successful implementation of any educational reform. When teachers are engaged,
motivated, and equipped with the necessary support and resources, they become
8
enthusiastic advocates for change. Their expertise, insights, and buy-in are instrumental in
shaping the culture and practices of a school. Moreover, teachers serve as role models for
students, showcasing the importance of adaptability and lifelong learning. By acknowledging
and harnessing the potential of teachers as change agents, educational leaders can foster a
culture of continuous improvement and innovation that ultimately benefits both educators
and students alike.
To lead change effectively, I will adopt a multifaceted approach that combines the insights
from Visible Learning and Fullan's change theory. First and foremost, I will prioritise open
and transparent communication with all stakeholders, ensuring that they understand the
rationale behind the proposed changes and feel included in the decision-making process.
Building trust and fostering a collaborative culture within the educational community will be
paramount.
I'll also focus on providing the necessary support and resources to teachers, recognizing
their pivotal role as change agents. This includes professional development opportunities
tailored to the specific needs identified through Visible Learning research, which emphasises
evidence-based practices. I'll encourage continuous reflection and assessment of our
strategies, using data-driven insights to refine and adapt our approach.
We will closely monitor the progress of our initiatives by tracking key performance indicators,
such as improvements in student achievement, teacher engagement, and stakeholder
satisfaction. Both quantitative and qualitative tools of measurement have been mentioned
previously in this document.
9
What has happened?
For students:
The adoption of a more rigorous and explicit approach to teaching and learning yielded
significant improvements in student academic results. By emphasising clear learning
objectives, structured lesson plans, and a systematic delivery of content, educators have
created a more focused and efficient learning environment. Students were also explicitly
taught how to self- assess against success criteria, how to use test results to set specific
learning goals, and how to give, receive and act upon feedback. Consequently, students
were empowered in the learning process and developed into ‘assessment capable learners’
- a key element of the Visible Learning pedagogy.
For teachers:
For teachers participating in the Visible Learning challenge, this transformation in student
outcomes went hand in hand with a profound shift in their own roles and practices. Teachers
became more efficient and confident with using data to inform the next steps in learning.
Collegial conversations shifted to include discussions around data-driven insights and
improvement strategies. Teachers demonstrated a newfound openness to feedback, both
from their peers and from students, fostering an environment where constructive critique was
welcomed as a catalyst for growth. Vulnerable conversations about areas of improvement
became commonplace as educators recognized that these discussions were essential for
their own professional development.
Throughout this transformative journey, I too have grown as a leader. Witnessing the positive
impact of these changes on both students and teachers has reinforced my belief in the
power of evidence-based leadership, as well as the importance of strong, supportive
relationships. I've become more adept at facilitating open, data-driven discussions, fostering
collaboration, and creating a culture of trust and vulnerability. Embracing the role of a
learning leader, I have recognized the importance of adaptability and resilience in the face of
challenges. This experience has shaped me into a more reflective, responsive, and impactful
leader, who is committed to the ongoing pursuit of excellence in education and the
empowerment of both educators and students.
As mentioned earlier in this document, a range of qualitative and quantitative measures were
10
used to determine the success and effectiveness of my leadership challenge. An overview
of some of these measures is included below as evidence of this success:
The blue line on the graph indicates the most recent Capability Assessment, compared with
previous reports. The graph shows significant growth, particularly from 2021 to 2022.
Naplan results
Following the introduction of Visible Learning principles into our educational approach, we
witnessed a rapid and remarkable transformation in our NAPLAN results. This can largely
be attributed to a more stringent, co-ordinated and explicit approach towards teaching and
learning.
11
NAPLAN - 2017
NAPLAN - 2018
NAPLAN - 2019
NAPLAN - 2022
Please note: 2023 data is currently not available, but is further improved on the 2022 data.
12
Essential Assessment
Similar to the story of NAPLAN, a more explicit approach in classrooms had a significant
positive impact on Essential Assessment results. By implementing clear learning objectives,
structured lesson plans, and data-driven insights, students exhibited notable improvements
in their Essential Assessment scores.
The charts below outline the improvements in student achievement, in both Numeracy and
Literacy. The first chart is helpful in determining a pre-challenge start point, with the second
chart showing the impact of the leadership challenge.
13
Tell Them From Me survey
In 2023, St Alipius engaged with the Learning Bar to implement the ‘Tell Them From Me’
surveys. This gave an opportunity to gather feedback from teachers, students and families
through three separate surveys. It also provided both qualitative and quantitative data that
could be used to gauge the success of the leadership challenge.
Below is a sample written feedback from teachers in response to “What brings you joy at St
Alipius?’
At the start of 2023, Impact Coaches were discussing implementing a peer-coaching model.
At this point, we felt that there was some hesitation/push back from staff about observations
and feedback. The Tell Them From Me survey was used at the end of Term 2, 2023, and the
response (below) to “What could make our school even better” showed readiness to engage
in feedback cycles. This was also indicative of the emergence of a feedback culture at St
Alipius - evidence of success!
14
Personal satisfaction - an internal measure of success
Additionally, having a profound sense of pride in the positive changes and outcomes
resulting from my leadership challenge served as a deeply meaningful and personal
measure of success. This emotional connection to the impact of my efforts reinforces the
value of the journey and the sense of accomplishment in contributing to the betterment of
teaching and learning at St Alipius.
In conclusion
Ultimately, the success of my leadership challenge is evident not only through data and
indicators, but also in the positive impact felt by students, teachers, and the entire school
community. This journey has reaffirmed my commitment to educational excellence and the
holistic development of individuals within the learning environment, making me even more
passionate and dedicated as an educational leader.
15
Appendix 1: AN OVERVIEW OF CHANGE OUTCOMES 2021-2023
PRIORITY Change outcomes & Success Indicators Intended impact
strategies to achieve
Priority One: All staff will use pre-test This will be reflected in Staff will become more
In order to data to plan impactful planning documents and in skilled in analyzing and
improve teaching and learning meeting agendas. interpreting data. In turn,
student cycles for all students at this will ensure students are
** It is anticipated there will
growth and point of need. Post data will be a paradigm shift in the being taught at their point of
achievement, then be used to determine way data is spoken about by need.
engaging and success/impact. teachers **
challenging
students at All staff will participate in Observable change in Focus on skill, will and thrill
their point of Visible Learning Professional planning to reflect surface, (connected to surface, deep
Development to understand deep and transfer learning. and transfer) will ensure that
need
Teachers selecting
pedagogy students are engaged and
strategies based on effect
This size knowledge challenged.
addresses
AITSL Impact Coaches will ICs will meet Fridays to Teams meeting every Friday
Standard 1: participate in additional PD to share progress in learning allows support and
skill up coaching and communities. connection for ICs
Know
Students and mentoring skill sets (leadership and
Walkthrough documents will
How They - these staff members will reflect non-negotiables in attendance).
Learn work within their teams to plan (as per meeting This also doubles as an
implement VL into schedule document) accountability measure.
Standard 2: classrooms.
Know the
Teachers will educate Students will be able to Students will have a deeper
content and
students on data in order to articulate their growth and understanding of success,
how to teach achievement in Essential
become ‘assessment capable achievement and growth,
it Assessment.
learners’ using data to set goals, and
(Videos to be taken to
document progress) LISC to determine steps in
Standard 3
the learning process.
Staff will commit to using Planning documents will Essential Assessment data
Essential Assessment (EA) reflect student grouping will drive teaching and
(particularly in Maths) and according to EA data. learning in Maths - this will
Students are provided with
using pre-testing to determine provide a common platform
learning that is at the point
points of need for each child. of need identified in EA. and common language to
discuss data.
16
PRIORITY Change outcomes & Success Indicators Intended impact
strategies to achieve
Priority Two: Students to be empowered Students will be able to set Students become
Empowering to take goals, give and receive assessment capable
students to ownership/responsibility for feedback, and use LISC to learners who are able to
inform next steps in learning
have agency their learning (and take ownership over their
in their world subsequently to have own learning (therefore
agency in their world) having agency)
17
PRIORITY Change outcomes & Success Indicators Intended impact
strategies to achieve (What does success look
like?
Priority Staff will be provided with Staff show a change in Developing deeper
Three: opportunities for teaching practice that knowledge and
Staff see professional development indicates a willingness to understanding in staff that
take on new learning
themselves through Corwin and ReLate, informs better decisions
as learners on and will participate in around teaching and
a journey of feedback cycles to improve learning
continuous professional practice
improvement.
At the start of Term One, staff Professional learning plans Development of collective
complete a Professional show goals that are aligned teacher efficacy - united
Development Plan that to the AAP - teachers efforts to drive towards
indicate interest and
specifies a SMART goal same goals
commitment to helping the
related to our Annual Action school achieve its strategic
Plan. plan goals
Staff participate in Visible Staff are observed engaging Improving practice through
Learning professional in robust conversations collective teacher efficacy
development (whole school during the VL PD, and then and a culture of
can be seen taking key
closures) collaboration and trust
learnings and implementing
in the classrooms (eg.
through walkthroughs)
Impact coach to participate in Impact coaches will engage Developing capacity of staff
further professional in feedback cycles, members to distribute
development to develop observing their peers and leadership across the staff
providing feedback in order
coaching skills
to improve practice
Impact coaches are
confident in their role and
use skills developed through
PD opportunities
Meeting schedule to reflect Meeting schedule show Providing whole staff time
opportunities for teaching and teaching and learning and for teaching and learning as
learning, sharing of ideas and reflection are prioritised for a priority
staff
to provide feedback Keeping Visible Learning
visible and in focus
18
Appendix 2: AN OVERVIEW OF AITSL AND CHECS
Standard 1: Know students and how they learn
Standards ● 1.1: Physical, social and intellectual development and characteristics of students
addressed ● 1.2: Understand how students learn
● 1.3: Students with diverse, linguistic, cultural, religious and socioeconomic backgrounds
Australian ● 1.4: Strategies for teaching Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students
Institute for ● 1.5: Differentiate teaching to meet the specific learning needs of students across the full range of
Teaching and abilities
School ● 1.6: Strategies to support full participation of students with disability
Leadership As part of Visible Learning, we explored how students learn, SOLO Taxonomy, surface/deep/transfer, LISC -
(AITSL) teachers were able to implement this into their practice.
Standard 7: Engage professionally with colleagues, parents/carers and the wider community
● 7.1: Meet professional ethics and responsibilities
● 7.3: Engage with the parents/carers
● 7.4: Engage with professional teaching networks and broader communities
As part of our strategy, there were multiple opportunities to engage with families. We were also in a
‘learning cluster’ (network) with St Brigid’s, Ballan and St Michael’s, Daylesford.
19
Aspects 2. Community Engagement
addressed ● 2.1: Partnering with Families
● 2.2: Community Partnerships
Characteristics
Some of the observable practices that indicate we were addressed this component:
of a ● Promotion of home-school partnerships
Highly ● There are open and effective communication strategies, policies and practices on student
Effective learning
Catholic ● School documents reflect Tier 1- Tier 3 supports and interventions (these are developed with
School consultation from families)
(CHECS) ● The school builds the capacity of staff and families to work collaboratively for school
document improvement and improved student learning
● The school has extensive knowledge of students and their families, including support
requirements
● The school systematically plans for the collective, analysis and use of data and feedback to
improve family engagement
● The school has arrangements in place for communicating student learning and growth to
parents and caregivers.
Some of the observable practices that indicate we were addressed this component:
● Teams meetings every Friday with Impact Coaches - distributed leadership practices
● Professional development to build staff capacity around Visible Learning
● The school has in place practices to engage staff in coaching/mentoring and feedback (impact
cycles)
● Development of staff capacity to give, receive and respond to feedback (from colleagues,
students and also families/carers
● Use of data (and clear processes/protocoles around collection) to improve teaching
effectiveness (guided by Maths and Literacy Leaders)
5. Wellbeing
● Quality Relationships
● Wellbeing practice
● Safe Learning Environment
Some of the observable practices that indicate we were addressed this component:
● Social Emotional needs are also part of the teaching/learning program
● Wellbeing is incorporated into every classroom’s daily schedule
● Growth and achievement are celebrated
● Each learning space is welcoming and provides for every child’s point-of-need
● Staff and students are engaged in the learning process and motivated to learn
● The school supports the diversity of needs of all learners
20
21