Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1industrial Safety Management 23108
1industrial Safety Management 23108
13. Initiative :- Henri Fayol argued that with this management principle employees
should be allowed to express new ideas. This encourages interest and involvement and
creates added value for the company. Employee initiatives are a source of strength for
the organization according to Henri Fayol. This encourages the employees to be
involved and interested.
14. Esprit de Corps:- The management principle ‘esprit de corps’ of the 14 principles
of management stands for striving for the involvement and unity of the employees.
Managers are responsible for the development of morale in the workplace; individually
and in the area of communication. Esprit de corps contributes to the development of
the culture and creates an atmosphere of mutual trust and understanding.
Advantages Disadvantages
1. Relief to line managers Line-staff conflicts
2. Expert advice (specialization) 3. Better Confusion in relationships
decisions Staff becomes ineffective or irresponsible
4. Training of personnel Expensive for small units
5. Flexibility – opportunity for
advancement
SPAN OF MANAGEMENT
Definition: The Span of Management refers to the number of subordinates who can be
managed efficiently by a superior. Simply, the manager having the group of
subordinates who report him directly is called as the span of management.
Both these organizational structures have their advantages and the disadvantages.
But however the tall organizational structure imposes more
more challenges:
Since the span is narrow, which means less number of subordinates under one
superior, requires more managers to be employed in the organization. Thus, it
would be very expensive in terms of the salaries to be paid to each senior.
With more levels in the hierarchy, the communication suffers drastically. It takes a
lot of time to reach the appropriate points, and hence the actions get delayed.
Lack of coordination and control because the operating staff is far away from the
top management.
Delegation of Authority :-
:
All activities are not performed by one person. Authority should be provided to the
subordinates too. Process of transferring authority and creation of responsibility
between superior and subordinates to accomplish a certain task is called delegation of
authority.
Some of the main principle of delegation are mentioned below:
Principle of absoluteness of responsibility– according to it, responsibility can’t
be delegated. Only authority can be delegated. The person who delegates
authority is himself responsible for his seniors.
Principle of unity of command– according to it, subordinates must be
commanded by one superior, they should take their task from one superior and
should be accountable fro their responsibility toward the superior level of
operation
Principle of functional definition of authority and responsibility– as per this
principle. Duties and task assigned by the superior and the authority given to
fulfill the task should be clearly explained and decided. Bt this subordinates can
know about the limit of one’s right, duties and responsibility.
The scalar chain– according to it, authority flows from top to bottom. So that
scalar chain is the basis of relationship between the superior and subordinates. It
emphasizes the relation between superior and subordinates by which delegation
will be easier.
Principle of parity of authority and responsibility– parity of authority and
responsibility is one of the important principles of delegation of authority. There
is equality in assigned task and power to do the work. Authority to the
subordinates is given by the superior on the basis of assigned task. So Authority
to the subordinates is given nether more or less than the task otherwise their can
be improper utilization of authority and mismanagement of task.
Planning
The core concept of MBO is planning, which means that an organization and its
members are not merely reacting to events and problems but are instead being
proactive. MBO requires that employees set measurable personal goals based upon the
organizational goals. For example, a goal for a civil engineer may be to complete the
infrastructure of a housing division within the next twelve months. The personal goal
aligns with the organizational goal of completing the subdivision.
MBO is a supervised and managed activity so that all of the individual goals can
be coordinated to work towards the overall organizational goal. You can think of an
individual, personal goal as one piece of a puzzle that must fit together with all of the
other pieces to form the complete puzzle: the organizational goal. Goals are set down
in writing annually and are continually monitored by managers to check progress.
Rewards are based upon goal achievement.
Safety Policy is statutorily required u/s 7A(3) and 41B(2) of the Factories Act, 1948
and its details arc prescribed u/r 12-C and 68-0 of the Gujarat Factories Rules, 1963.
Definition:-
It refers an activity, process or function of management i.e. organizing.
It is used in a dynamic way referring to process by which the structure is
created, maintained and used.
Chester Barnard-It is a system of co-operative activities
McFarland-It is an identifiable group of people contributing their efforts
towards the attainment of goals. of two or more persons.
Joseph L. Massie- Organization is defined as the structure and process by
which co-operative group of human beings allocates its tasks among its
members, identifies relationship and integrates its activities towards common
objectives.
John Pfeiffer- It is essentially a matter of relationship of man to man, job to job
and departmentto department.
Planning is the brain of a business unit while organization is its physical structure.
All managerial
Functions like planning, directing, co-ordinating, controlling, budgeting, staffing
etc. are performed· through the medium of organisation.
The Company Board decides the safety policy and objectives and
monitors its implementation. Managing Director is reportable to the Board for
implementation of safety policy. Safety executive or safety department reports to
MD. Managers are answerable to the Safety Department or Executive for
application of the safety arrangements. Supervisors are reportable to the
Managers for shop floor extension and application of safety policy, rules and
procedures. Workers are responsible to their supervisors for effectively carrying
out the safety rules and precautions. Safety Representatives selected from
workers and supervisors advise and assist to Safety Committee for promoting
health and safety.
Safety Committee advises on all matters of safety and health to the Managers and
the Managing Director.
Staffing : It includes personnel function of recruitment and training the staff and
maintainingsafe and favourable conditions of work through personnel.
Directing : It is a continuous task of taking decisions, ordering, instructing,
guiding and advisingon all maters of safety.
Controlling : It includes performing, evaluating and correcting the performance
according to
objectives, procedures and plans. It is concerned with quality, times, uses and cost
in safety matters.
Co-ordinating : It includes interrelating and synchronising the different
activities for achievingsafety goals
Definition:-
Urwick and Brech - Directing is the guidance, the inspiration, the leadership of
those men andwomen that constitute the real core of the responsibility of
management.
J. L. Massie - Directing concerns the total manner in which a manager
influences the actions ofsubordinates. It is the final action of a manager in
getting others to act after all preparations havebeen completed.
Leadership:-
It is an indivisible part of the process of directing as explained in earlier part. It is a
tool or meanswhich makes direction effective. Dr. Terry says that managers have to
manage business which means thatthey have to provide leadership. They have to instil
in them desire to achieve the goals, a desire toimprove their performance and a sense
of co-operation. If the managers fail to provide such 'leadershipthe employees will
search the leadership outside which may lead to conflict or distraction.
Koontz and. O'Donnell - Leadership is influencing people to follow in the
achievement ofcommon goal.
Terry - It is the ability of influencing people to strive willingly for natural
objectives.
R. T. Livingston - It is the ability to awaken in others the desire to follow a
common objective.
An Attribute of leader:-
1. Attributes of a Leader : Certain qualities are necessary for leadership but they
must be applied atthe correct place and time. Dr. Terry mentioned following
qualities of a leader -
2. Energy - Physical and mental fitness to work by self and to guide for a longer
time.
3. Teaching ability - He should be a good teacher.
4. Emotional stability- should be free from bias and anger and not emotional.
5. Empathy - It means the ability to understand other's viewpoint. He should
have respect for othersand their beliefs.
6. Objectivity -He should be objective to others and should find out reasons for
requests or refusal byhis subordinates.
7. Enthusiasm - is required in leader. He should be self motivated and capable
of motivating others.
8. Knowledge of HR - Leader has to deal with human beings and therefore he
should possesknowledge of human resources.
9. Communicative skill - He should be effective in his speech, talk and forceful
impression.
10. Social skill - He should mix with his followers freely and socially. He should
appreciate others'opinion and work with close co-operation.
11. Technical competence - Doubtlessly he must be technically more competent
so that he cansuccessfully teach technical aspects.
Channels Media
Formal Informal
Downward
Upward
Horizontal
Diagonal
A communication channel is a route through which messages flow from the
sender to the receiver.
Barriers to Communication:
Adjusted Information
Understanding
Communication and group dynamics.
Keith Davisdefines "Group Dynamics" as the social process by which people interact
face toface in small groups.
Group dynamics is the study of forces operating within a group. It is the study of field
that dealswith
(1) Interactions and forces between group members in a social situation
(2) The nature and development of small groups
(3) Interactions among members and inter group behavior
(4) How a group should be organized and operated and (5) Nature, Structure and
processes of a group, and their influence on the behavior and performance of group
members.
Team building
The groups perform four functions of
(1) Socialising the new employees
(2) Getting the work Done
(3) Decision making and
(4) Control measures.
2. Roles - Depending on position, the members perform three types of roles : expected
role,perceived role and enacted role.
3. Norms - mean prescriptions for acceptable behaviour determined by the group.
4. Informal managerial roles - Managers can perform three types of roles
(1) Interpersonal 'roles as a figurehead, leader and liaison officer.
(2) Informational roles as disseminator, monitorand spokesperson.
(3) Decisional roles as entrepreneur, disturbance handler, resource allocator and
negotiator (Henry Mintzberg).
5. Informal communication system - or grapevine communications in all directions
should beutilised to attain objectives.
Supervisors' good behaviour with their workers, informal relations and taking interest
in theirpersonal matters and paying constant attention for their individual growth, give
desired results. Such behaviour is much more useful to make the workers safety
Oriented. Sympathetic and fatherly behavior is the best form of communication. Group
dynamics should not disintegrate the organisation, rather it should strengthen
integration. Art of communication should be developed for this purpose by giving
special training to the superiors.
The Constitution of India provide detailed provisions for the rights of the citizens and
also lays down the Directive Principles of State Policy which set an aim to which the
activities of the state are to be guided.
OBJECTIVES:
The policy seeks to bring the national objectives into focus as a step towards
improvement in safety, health and environment at workplace. The objectives are to
achieve:-
a) Continuous reduction in the incidence of work related injuries, fatalities, diseases,
disasters and loss of national assets.
b) Improved coverage of work related injuries, fatalities and diseases and provide for a
more comprehensive data base for facilitating better performance and monitoring.
c) Continuous enhancement of community awareness regarding safety, health and
environment at workplace related areas.
d) Continually increasing community expectation of workplace health and safety
standards.
e) Improving safety, health and environment at workplace by creation of “green jobs”
contributing to sustainable enterprise development.
ACTION PROGRAMME:
Enforcement:
1 by providing an effective enforcement machinery as well as suitable provisions for
compensation and rehabilitation of affected persons;
2 by effectively enforcing all applicable laws and regulations concerning safety, health
and environment at workplaces in all economic activities through an adequate and
effective labour inspection system;
3 By establishing suitable schemes for subsidy and provision of loans to enable
effective implementation of the policy;
4 by ensuring that employers, employees and others have separate but complementary
responsibilities and rights with respect to achieving safe and healthy working
conditions.
National Standards:
1 by developing appropriate standards, codes of practices and manuals on safety,
health and environment for uniformity at the national level in all economic activities
consistent with international standards and implementation by the stake holders in true
spirit
2 by ensuring stakeholders awareness of and accessibility to applicable policy,
documents, codes, regulations and standards
Compliance:
Awareness:
Any training programme should be designed for its specific purpose. Design and
development of safety training programme need systematic job safety or risk analysis.
For steps (detail) of such analysis Following general points are useful in designing and
developing any training programme.
1. Motivation should be the first condition of any type of training.
2. Number of lessons and content to teach should be well designed beforehand. Steps
or sequence of topics should be decided.
3. The amount to be taught in an unit (period) should not be too large or too small.
4. An objective of the training should be decided and the training process should move
toward it. The training procedure should be developed.' A list of training aids should be
prepared.
5. The task to be performed should not be described only but it should be demonstrated
in actual or simulated conditions. "Doing" is important than mere "Hearing" or
"Seeing". Practice makes man perfect.
6. The demonstration (by teacher) should be followed by the learner (trainee) as soon
as possible before' he forgets it. The teacher should be given feedback or knowledge of
results.
7. Questions of learners should be properly replied and discussed at all stages (steps).
8. Ample practice opportunity should be provided and practice encouraged.
9. Frequent and accurate knowledge with examples, pictures, practical etc., speeds up
learning rate and motivation.
10. The training should be taken to the point of goal and not be left unfinished.
11. Effectiveness of the training should be evaluated and conclusion be drawn to revise
(improve) the training programme and it should be followed in the next cycle.
1. Lecture Method : Oldest and most basic method. Well planned lectures can cover a
large amount of information in a short time. More useful when participants are more,
or their involvement is less required.
2. Discussion Method : Useful with small number of people in a group. The trainer
acts in a limited way as a scene setter or referee encouraging participants to speak out.
The two way communication moves toward objectives. Participants are more attentive,
active and don't feel boredom.
3. Case-study Method : Accident case study is presented explaining how an actual
accident happened or an imaginary accident can happen. Causation analysis and
remedial measures can be discussed by questions and answers. Good pictures are more
useful to explain the situation effectively.
4.Role playing method : It is a form of learning by doing but in a simulated situation.
Trainees are given 'a situation like in case-study method but instead of just discussing
it they resolve the problem by acting out the roles of the people involved. Here
extrovert trainees show their skill but introvert or shy trainees unused to such situation
get embarrassed.
5. Business Games Method: More useful for business people and skill required for
safety attitude or inspection in buying/selling items which are more safe or with the
details of safety.
6. Sending at training Centres : Institutes, seminars, workshops, special courses etc.
utilizes external resources for required training.
7. Job instruction training: Useful to train supervisors who in turn train the
employees. Job instruction training (JTT) involves four steps.
Training to Supervisors:
Training to supervisors is most important because safety and production control
are associated with supervisory functions and it is their main duty to prevent accidents.
Objectives of safety training to supervisors include
1. To explain them their principal responsibilities of establishing work methods, giving
job instruction, assigning people to job, supervising people at work and maintaining
good housekeeping, plant and equipment.
2. To acquaint them with the company's safety policy, rules and practices.
3. To emphasise that accident investigation work is solely for prevention purpose and
not for fixing blame.
4. To establish their status of a key-man for safety and production.
5. Ways and means to maintain safe conditions and actions.
6. Special information on accident causes and methods of prevention, particularly in
their areas "of work. Case studies of actual accidents.
7. Job instructions for safely, supervising for safety, accident reporting, investigation
and. Record writing, job safety and risk analysis and group meetings for safety etc.
8. Ways and means of job training to workers and training aids.
9. How to participate in planning of safety programme and safety committee.
10. Solving of supervisory problems. The steps are :
(a) Identify the problems.
(b) Find and verify the reason for the existence of the problem.
(c) Select the appropriate remedy and apply the remedy.
3. Additional Problems:
1. Direct refusal or insubordination
2. Assumption of unwanted authority
3. Loose talk
4. Ridicule of criticism of the company
5. Creating disturbance, noise etc.
4. Personal Problems:
1. Dissatisfaction, wages, treatment, unhappiness
2. Chronic tardiness –or absence
3. Outside, home, social situations
4. Demands for premature promotion
5. Trivial tale bearing.
Remedies:
(1) Engineering or process revision
(2) Persuasion and appeal
(3) Personnel adjustment (Placing and medical treatment
(4) Psychological treatment and (5) Discipline.
CHAPTER: 3
Employees are the major work force working under hazards. Some know the
hazards and some do not It is of great importance that they must realise that they would
be the first victim of any accident, their safety awareness and all accident prevention
work is in their interest and therefore their active participation in showing hazards and
helping in removing them by the joint efforts of management and all employees is
most desirable.
Section 41G of the Factories Act speaks worker's participation in safety
management. A method of safety committee is suggested. Right of workers to warn
about imminent danger is also created by sections 41 H 111A of the Act. Display of the
Extract of the Act and Rules (Section 108(1), Rule 106 and Form No. 23) is for the
same purpose of making workers aware and to call for their participation. Some areas
and methods of participation are discussed below:
Areas of Participation :
General areas of participation are as under :
1. To set safety goals and training programmes.
2. To design and improve standard operating procedures (SOPs) and methods of
operation.
3. Appraisal of progress towards goals.
4. To give, collect and discuss safety suggestions and to implement which are
necessary. Rewards for good suggestions boost up motivation for participation. '
McGregor's theory states that participation management has a basic belief in the
competence and abilities of individual employees regardless their status in
organisation.
Employees' and supervisory participation is essential for success of any safety
programme. When workers are taken into confidence in designing any .safety
programme or goal they feel themselves responsible for its success. This element of
involvement and joint responsibility is most fundamental to employee participation.
As per factories act 1948, section 41G it's mandatory to form safety committee
and the details as follows:
(1) The occupier shall, in every factory where a hazardous process takes place, or
where hazardous substances are used or handled, set up a Safety Committee
consisting of equal number of preventatives of workers and management to
promote cooperation between the workers and the management in maintaining
proper safety and health at work and to review periodically the measures taken in
that behalf:
Provided that the State Government may, by order in writing and for reasons to be
recorded, exempt the occupier of any factory or class of factories from setting up
such Committee.
(2) The composition of the Safety Committee, the tenure of office of its members
and their rights and duties shall be such as may be prescribed.
(c) which carries on 'hazardous process' as defined under section 2(cb) of the Act
and employs more than 50 workers, there shall be a Safety Committee.
(a) A senior official, who by his position in the organization can contribute
effectively to the functioning of the Committee, shall be the Chairman;
(b) A Safety Officer and Factory Medical Officer, wherever available and the
Safety Officer in such a case shall be the Secretary of the Committee;
(3) The workers' representatives on this Committee shall be elected by the workers.
(5) Safety Committee shall meet as often as necessary but at least once in every
quarter. The minutes of the meeting shall be recorded and produced to the Inspector
on demand.
(a) ask for necessary information concerning health and safety of the workers;
(b) seek any relevant information concerning health and safety of the workers.
(a) assisting and co-operating with the management in achieving the aims and
objectives outlined in the 'Health and Safety Policy' of the occupier;
(b) dealing with all matters concerning health, safety and environment and to arrive
at practicable solutions to problems encountered;
(c) creating safety awareness amongst all workers;
(d) undertaking educational, training and promotional activities;
(e) deliberating on reports of safety, environmental and occupational health surveys,
emergency plans safety audits, risk assessment and implementation of the
recommendations made in the reports;
(f) carrying out health and safety surveys and identify causes of accidents;
(g) looking into any complaint made on the likelihood of an imminent danger to the
safety and health of the workers and suggest corrective measures; and
(h) reviewing the implementation of the recommendations made by it.
8. Where owing to the size of the factory, or any other reason, the functions referred
to in sub-rule (7) cannot be effectively carried out by the Safety Committee, it may
establish sub-committee as may be required, to assist it.
Applicability:
1. Factories employing workers more than 250.
2. Factories carrying dangerous operations u/s 87.
3. Factories listed in the First Schedule.
Toolbox Talks:
Toolbox talks are a way to ensure all workers are participating in safety activities, and
have an opportunity to discuss hazards/controls, incidents and accidents.
As part of the Health and Safety at Work Act, employers must provide employees the
opportunity to regularly engage in health and safety discussions.
If you are a Site Safe Member, you can access Site Safe Toolbox Talks to help guide
you through relevant and beneficial health and safety discussions. Sign in to the
members area (/Portal/login)to gain access to your members only Toolbox Talks.
There's a wide range of topics to choose from so you can tailor these discussions
specifically to your project.
Topics to discuss:
SAFETY KAIZEN:
Kaizen was first introduced in the Toyota manufacturing plant in Japan in the early
1950s and it has since become one of the main reasons for the country’s success. In
Japan, kaizen is a way of life in the workplace, from the office of the CEO all the way
down to shop apprentice. The Japanese take it very seriously, and for good reason.
Kaizen Concepts Management
PDCA Cycle The PDCA cycle is a system used to ensure the continuation contin of the
kaizen principles. It is a vital part of the process. Plan refers to establishing a target and
a strategy for improvement. This is a must. Without a target, how do you know if you
have achieved success? Do refers to the implementation of your plan. Check is when
you determine if your plan actually improved the process. Act is the process of
standardizing the improved procedure so that it can be continued and so that the
problem will not return. By following the PDCA cycle, you will ensure that your
process improves and does not degrade.
Quality First Quality is always the highest priority in a kaizen system. But quality does
not only refer to the finished product, it also refers to the processes and standards that
create the product. It runs through all phases of company activity: design, production,
management, sales, and service. It is both the goal and the method of the production
cycle.
5S
The heart and soul of visual management is 5S. It is systematic approach to workplace
organization and cleaning that will transform a disorganized workplace into an
efficiently running machine. 5S creates a strong foundation that allows businesses to
employ additional lean manufacturing tools such as kaizen. When the work
environment is orderly, people can more easily identify opportunities for improvement.
1. Sort (Seiri) - The first step in 5S is to eliminate all the things in the workspace that
are not being used and store them away. If a tool or material is not used on a daily
basis, eliminate it from the workstation.
2. Set in Order (Seiton) -The second step is to arrange the items used on a daily basis
so that they can be easily accessed and quickly stored. Your goal is to eliminate any
unnecessary movements and actions by the worker to make the process as efficient as
possible.
3. Shine (Seiso) - Next is to get everything cleaned and functioning properly. The goal
is to remove all the dirt and grime and to keep it that way on daily basis. You want to
get it clean and keep it clean.
4. Standardize (Seiketsu) -The fourth step is to develop a routine for sorting, setting,
and shining. Standardize creates a system of tasks and procedures that will ensure that
the principles of 5S are performed on a daily basis.
5. Sustain (Shitsuke) - In the last step, you want to create a culture that will follow the
steps on a daily basis. The chief objective of sustain is to give your staff the
commitment and motivation to follow each step, day in and day out.
Safety campaigns:-
The Healthy Workplaces Campaigns are our flagship awareness-raising activity.
They are the main way of getting our message to workplaces .in this employees are
involved in safety campaign arranged for a week, or year month on different activities
such as PPE use, good housekeeping etc. such cam[aligns keep the employees attentive
and also create awareness that helps to promote safety in the organization
Safety Competitions:
This is another method of workers' participation in safety. Competitions
(contests) are of two types:
(1) Individual comparison - where individual worker takes part in competition
and award is given by comparing individual performance. Examples are safety speech
or quiz, essay, poem or slogan writing, posters or cartoons etc.
(2) Group comparison - where groups take part in competition and award is
given by comparing group versus group. Examples are department wise housekeeping
competition.
Audio-Visual Publicity :
As we saw in foregoing Part 10.7 of this Chapter, a trainee tends to remember
50% of what he sees and hears and 70% of what he sees and talks. This is possible by
audio visual aid only. Television and video effectively reproduce actual happening.
Therefore safety education and training by safety films on TV is the most powerful
method. Only difficulty is in getting safely films or safety video cassette easily and
frequently. This should be made possible if we wish to utilise its full role in increasing
safety. used to die extent possible to hold the picture to discuss and understand it in
details which is not possible with a moving film.
Modern media is a closed circuit television. Travelling units are complete
television studios in themselves and have up-to-date equipment with the control room
housed in a single vehicle. There are fixed and moving cameras, telecine equipment, a
video tap recorder and monitor screens which can be installed up to 500 meter away
from the studio. Using both inside and outside cameras, extensive safety programmes
can be broadcast through the closed network. Such unit can be hired also.
Behavior Based Safety (BBS): “focuses on what people do, analyses why they do it,
and then applies a research- supported intervention strategy to improve what people do.
Observation of unsafe act and conditions, their reporting and taking action is
key while maintaining safety standards within the working environment.
Safe Behaviour Observation Program-BBS
Cycle of BBS:
Benefits of BBS for the company:
Enhanced reporting
Increased hazard recognition
Share recognized hazards
Data gathered is used to develop trends
Trended data can be used to improve overall safety for employees
Employees have greater sense of ownership of the HSE program
Incentives may be tied to best quality observations
Increased employee retention
1. Leadership
2. Engagement
3. Coaching
4. Communication
5. Recognition
6. Measurement
Impact of control
▷ People tolerate substantially more risk when they engage in voluntary behavior
▷ Related to a sense of controllability: less risk is perceived in situations that are
under personal control
▷ Phenomenon of illusion of control
• the risk of winning the lottery is perceived to be higher if we pick the numbers
ourselves [Langer 1975]
• a person who sees themselves as being in control (driving the car vs being a
passenger) perceives the risk to be smaller [McKenna 1993]
Theory X – Theory Y
Management Theory
Theory Y
Supervisors
You are directly responsible for the safety and health of employees and other workers
that you direct or supervise. Here are your roles and responsibilities:
Ensure the health and safety of all workers under your direct supervision
Know the WorkSafe safety requirements that apply to the work being supervised
and ensure they are followed
Ensure workers under your supervision are aware of all known or reasonably
foreseeable health and safety hazards where they work
Provide orientation and training to new and existing workers at your workplace
Consult and cooperate with the Joint Occupational Health and Safety
Committee members or worker representatives, and cooperate with others
carrying out occupational health and safety duties, including WorkSafeofficers
Ensure that the appropriate personal protective equipment and clothing are
available, worn when required, and inspected and maintained
Investigate unsafe conditions reported to you, and ensure that corrective action is
taken without delay
Learn more about accident prevention and investigation.
All workers have safety roles and responsibilities. Follow safe work procedures, report
unsafe conditions or incidents and be prepared to respond in the event of a workplace
injury or emergency. Whether you are a supervisor or front-line staff, be sure to
Conflict is…
• a normal, inescapable part of life
• a periodic occurrence in any relationship
• an opportunity to understand opposing preferences and values
• Disagreement about ideas and approaches
• Issue focused, not personal
• Characteristic of high performing groups
• Personal blame fueled by differences of opinion
• Destructive to group performance and goal
There should be effective MIS between Safety Department and the top
management of the company to appraise the work being done by the Department.
Similarly it should also be developed/extended for bottom line management and the
outside authorities to provide quick and tabulated information in wide areas of safety,
health & environment.
Application of MIS from book:-
Accident Prevention:
Accident prevention is both science and art. It represents, above all other things,
control i.e. thecontrol of human performance, machine or equipment
performance and physical environment.
The word ‘control’ connotes prevention as well as correction of unsafe
conditions and actions.Prevention is the first step of control.
To control unsafe human actions, knowledge of psychology, philosophy and
management arenecessary. To control unsafe conditions, knowledge of
engineering, health effects, industrial hygiene,ergonomics etc. are necessary.
Accident prevention requires five steps organisation, fact-finding analysis if the
facts found,selection of remedy and application of the remedy. Sixth step of
monitoring should be considered. Itincludes measurement of result, assessment
i.e. comparing with legal criteria or standard, feedback andfurther improvement.
Incident:
An incident is any observable human activity sufficiently complete in itself to
permit referencesand predictions to be made about the persons performing the
act viz. cleaning an unguarded machine,failing to wear PPE, using compressed
air on body, raising pressure or temperature unnecessarily.It may result in
accident or a near miss.
Incident for accident is defined as, 'an unplanned event or series of events that
has or could have,caused injury to people and / or damage to assets and / or
damage to the environment and / or loss ofreputation.
Injury:
Injury (occupational) means an injury that result in death, loss of consciousness
andadministration of medical treatment, temporary assignment to other duties and
transfer to another job, orinability to perform all duties on any day after the injury.
Work injury: -is defined as an injury suffered by a person, which arises out of and in
the course of his employment. It isan external damage to human body; disturbance or
dysfunction resulted from an accident. By because itmay be mechanical, thermal,
chemical, radiated or combined.
Injuryis physical harm or damage to the body resulting from an exchange of (usually
acute,mechanical, chemical, thermal or other environmental) energy that exceeds the
body's tolerance.
Source of injuryis the principal object such as tool, machine, chemical vessel or
equipmentinvolved in the accident and is usually the object inflicting injury or property
damage. Also called agencyor agent.
Dangerous Occurrences:
Dangerous occurrences are mentioned u/s 88-A, of the Factories Act 1948 and
u/r 103 of theMaharashtra Factories Rules 1963. They' include:
1. Bursting of a steam plant under pressure.
2. Collapse or failure of lifting appliances or overturning of a crane.
3. Fire, explosion, escape of molten metal, hot liquor, gas etc.
4. Explosion of a pressure vessel.
5. Collapse or subsidence of a structure. For Dangerous Chemical Reaction
Emergency Plan:
Emergency plan is a formal written plan, which on the basis of identified
potential hazards at theinstallation together with their consequences, describes how
such hazards and their consequences shouldbe handled either on-site or off-site
Error:
Errors are of different types, viz. human error, design error; planning,
production, operation andmaintenance error etc.
Human error can be defined as a human's action, which differs from or is
inconsistent withprescribed or established behaviours or procedures. It may be
of two types: predictable or random.
Predictable error occurs under similar conditions and can be foreseen because it
has occurredmore than once.
Random error is non-predictable and unique in nature. For example, all of a
sudden a fly or insectenters in eye due to which a worker may throw away a tool
or lose his balance and cause error. But ifflies become common phenomena i.e.
predictable, the error becomes predictable one and remedialmeasures are
required.
Hazards Analysis:
In simple term, hazard analysis means classification of hazards, eg. chemical
hazards, mechanicalhazards, electrical hazards, fall hazards, day and night wise
hazards etc. in this way it is qualitativeanalysis.
Hazard Analysis is
(i) Analysis of mechanism of hazard occurrence and
(ii) Analysis of terminalconsequences of hazards which may include number of injury,
fatality, property damage and other loses.
HAZOP:
Hazop (Hazard & operability) study is carried out by application of guidewords to
identify allpossible deviations from design intent having undesirable effects on safety
or operability, with the aim ofidentifying potential hazards.
Hazop study is normally undertaken at an advanced stage of project implementation
when thedesign criteria are well established. The study can be used for both new and
working plants. They have tobe carried out by multidisciplinary teams of experienced
technical personnel having detailed knowledgeof both the design ,and operation of a
plant.
A preliminary Hazop study is intended to review the general parameters of
materials processed,unit operations and layout of individual units and plant sub-units.
A detailed Hazop study is required afterthe finalization of the designs to identify the
potentially hazardous situations and to arrive at agreeableoptions to rectify design
deviations and anomalies.
Mistake:
Mistake, in the sense of safety, can be defined as an act of wrong opinion,
judgement about athing or situation which results in hazard or harm to a person,
property or environment. It means to havewrong, perception about danger or to
understand it wrongly so that it may cause hazard.
Near miss:
It means any unplanned, sudden event that could have caused injury to man,
materials (plant) orenvironment or could have involved a loss of containment possibly
giving rise to adverse effect but notresulted in such accident.
If near miss is detected and prevented, possible accident due to that near miss can be
avoided orprevented. If causes of near miss are not removed, they can result in
accident. Therefore importance toidentify and control near miss is more than that of
controlling accident.
Since they essentially mean an accident didn’t happen, why is it so important to report
near misses? They motivate us to be more proactive in our safety measures. By
knowing something could happen, we can then put policies and procedures in place to
prevent them from happening.NSC and OSHA offer these best practices when creating
a near miss reporting system:
Oversight:
Oversight means overlooking of something, error or supervision. When there are
more switchesside by side and looking identical, an operator may operate a wrong
switch by oversight. While countingmany things, by oversight, someone may make
mistake. Thus oversight denotes a state of mind by whicherror or mistake is possible
due to lack of concentration or attention. Result of oversight is mistake orerror.
Oversight leads to unsafe action and that may result in accident.The words -
error, mistake and oversight - have thin difference, all leading to the causation ofhazard
or accident and concern with the state of mind or human behaviour.
Probability:
It means the likelihood, chance or frequency that a considered (predetermined)
occurrence maytake place.
Probability includes possible frequency of hazard occurrence or possible frequency of
effects dueto any particular hazard.
Probability and severity (effect or consequence) are two ingredients of a risk. R = P x S
Costs of Accidents:-Many employers believe that the insurer will pick up the costs of
an accident, and that's why they pay their insurance. However the costs of an accident
can be broken down into the direct costs and indirect (uninsured) costs.
Direct costs are those costs that are accrued directly from the accident. They are
quite easy to calculate, and include the medical costs incurred and the compensation
payments made to the injured workers. Direct costs are usually insurable by
businesses.Accidents are more expensive than most people realize because of the
hidden costs. Some costs are obvious — for example, Workers' Compensation claims
which cover medical costs and indemnity payments for an injured or ill worker. These
are the direct costs of accidents.
Heinrich's Theory:
H.W. Heinrich, a pioneer in safety philosophy, first published his work. Industrial
Accident
Prevention, in 1931. Many of his principles and basic philosophy of accident causation
and preventionare confirmed by time and application, but, some are also questioned
and criticised. His philosophy isbased on his 10 axioms (self evident-truths) as follows.
Ten Axioms of Industrial Safety:
1. The occurrence of an injury invariably results from a completed sequence of factors
- the last oneof these being the accident itself. The accident in turn is invariably caused
or permitted directly bythe unsafe act of a person and/or a mechanical or physical
hazard.
2. The unsafe acts of persons are responsible for a majority of accidents.
3. The person who suffers a disabling injury caused by an unsafe act, in the average
case has hadover 300 narrow escapes from serious injury as a result of committing the
very same unsafe actLikewise, persons are exposed to mechanical hazards hundreds of
times before theysuffer injury.
4. The severity of an injury is largely fortuitous the occurrence of the accident that
results in injury islargely preventable.
5. The four basic motives or reasons for the occurrence of unsafe acts provide a guide
to theselection of appropriate corrective measures. These are: Improper attitude. Lack
of knowledge orskill, Physical unsuitability and Improper mechanical or physical
environment.
6. Four basic methods are available for preventing accidents. These are Engineering
revision,Persuasion and appeal. Personnel adjustment and Discipline.
Methods of most value in accident prevention are analogous with the methods required
for thecontrol of the 'quality, cost and quantity of production.
8. Management has the best opportunity and ability to initiate the work of prevention,
therefore itshould assume the responsibility.
9. The supervisor or foreman is the key man in individual accident prevention. His
application of theart of supervision for the control of work performance is the factor of
greatest influence insuccessful accident prevention. It can be expressed and taught as a
simple four step formula -Identify the problem, find and verify the reason for the
existence of the problem, select theappropriate remedy and apply the remedy. The
humanitarian incentive for preventing accidentalinjury is supplemented by two
powerful economic factors:
(1) The safe establishment isefficiently productive and the unsafe establishment is
inefficient
(2) The direct employer's cost ofindustrial injuries for compensation claims and for
medical treatment is about one-fifth of the total(direct plus indirect) cost which the
employer must pay.
These axioms were the first set of principles or guidelines ever set before in
industrial safety andit has guided all safety activity till today. During the passage of 75
years, some of his axioms arequestioned and disbelieved as truths, but, most of them
are still true and deal with the important areas of safety, viz. accident causation and
prevention, reasons of unsafe acts and conditions, management control functions,
responsibility of organisation, costs of accident, safety and productivity etc.
Accident Sequence: The five factors .in accident occurrence series in chronological
order are:
1. Ancestry and social environment.
2. Fault of person.
3. Unsafe act and/or mechanical or physical hazard.
4. Accident and
5. Injury
One factor is dependent on another and one follows because of another, thus
constituting asequence that may be compared with a row of dominoes placed on end
and in such alignment in relation to one another that the fall of the first domino
precipitates the fall of the entire row. An accident is merely one factor in the sequence.
If this series is interrupted by the elimination or withdrawal of even one of the five
factors that comprise it, the injury can possibly be prevented. See Fig
In above dominos, social environment includes family and surrounding atmosphere in
which aperson is born and brought up. This is the origin or root cause of behavioural
development as per H. W.Heinrich.
Undesirable traits include unsafe behaviour, negligence, lack of knowledge,
violent temper,
nervousness, recklessness etc.
Unsafe act or conditions are the results of undesirable traits.
Accident is caused because of unsafe act or condition 6r both.
Injury is the result of accident.
This suggests the steps of management controls as under:
suggests the steps of management controls as under:
Controls
Human Failure
Knowledge – Attitude – Fitness – Ability
Inference of this 1-10-30-600 ratio is that 630 no injury accidents, with 10 minor and I
major(serious) injury accidents, provide a much larger basis for many opportunities to
prevent any injuryaccident. Out of total 641 events, only 10 may result in minor
injuries and only 1 in major injury. But this can happen at any time not necessarily at
the end.
7.3 Hepburn's Theory
H.A. Hepburn amplified the above Heinrich's theory and arrived at the principle that an
injuryaccident is the result of the convergence at the same point of time of 4 factors
Unsafe actionable
Unsafe conditional
Proximate casual and
Personal.
Unsafe Actionable
Proximate casual
Here unsafe actionable and conditional factors are as usual Personal factor means
person injuredor likely to be injured by an accident and die person causing the
accident. The proximate factor is that immediate causative factor such as failure of a
brake, sudden exposure to gas etc., which by its reaction causes a sudden closing
together or convenience of all the four factors to cause an injury accident He
emphasises that lie four factors are complementary to one another m causation of any
injury-accident such that, if any one or more can be withdrawn by any means during or
just before convergence, an injury accident can be prevented. The event of an accident
will not be prevented by efforts to control any one of the factors to the exclusion of the
others. Remedial measures must be adopted for each of the factors. Like Heinrich he
also suggested planning and organizing to prevent unsafe actions and remove unsafe
mechanical or physical conditions.
Characteristics of –
1. Man includes- age, sex, height, skill level, training, motivation etc.
2. Machine includes- size, weight, speed, shape, material of constriction, energy etc.
3. Media includes- pressure, temperature, content, contaminants, obstruction on road
etc.
4. Management includes- structure, style, policy,procedure, communication etc.
Simple example of this theory is a man slipping due to walking on a banana skin lying
on .theroad. Here main contributing factors are as under:
Man - A man walking on the road. Machine or object or vehicle - Slipprery banana
skin.
Media - Hard road.
All above causes are interacting with each other to lead to the accident. Absence of any
one causecan avoid the accident This indicates that slippery banana skin should be
removed from the road or manshould be more attentive for not walking on it or the
road should not be so hard to cause slipping.
Let us take another example of a worker falling from a ladder. As per the
domino theory aninvestigation is as under :
The unsafe Act Climbing the defective ladder
The unsafe condition The defective ladder
The remedial measure Remove or repair the defective ladder and train that worker
As per the multiple causation theory some of the contributing factors surrounding
this accidentcan be found out by asking :
Why was the defect in ladder not found in normal (past) inspections?
2. Why did the supervisor allow its use? Why did he not get it repaired urgently?
3. Didn't the injured worker know he shouldn't use it?
4. Was he properly trained or not?
5. Was he reminded or cautioned?
6. Did and do the supervisor examine the job first?
The answers to these and similar questions would suggest the following measures:
1. An improved inspection procedure.
2. Repairing the ladder (machine-tool, job etc.) immediately i.e. not waiting for an
accident.
3. Improved training and supervision.
4. Better fixation of responsibilities.
5. Pre job planning and checking by supervisors.
Man Unsuccessful
task
feedback
Machine Stressors
Decisions
Risks
Accident
Environment Task
This necessitates the introduction of feedback system (as shown in diagram) to
find out the faults/causes in man, machinery and environment. The information that the
man possesses can be strengthened through training. The stressors can be precedent in
the following form –
Psychological stressors . Anxiety, aggressiveness, fatigue.
Overload Human
Error
Accidents
Outcomes
Casual Chain
This theory states that accidents are the result of a casual chain (as in multiple
causation theory),one or more of the causes being human error, which is in turn caused
by three situations - overload,incompatibility and improper activities. Factors affecting
these three situations are as follows
This theory adapts Ferrell’s human factors of overload and (also Heinrich's domino
theory and states that causes of accident/incident are human error and/or system
failure. Human error is due to overload, traps and decision to err. Human error may
directly cause accident or may cause system failure which may cause accident resulting
in injury or loss as shown below:
Traps
Decision to err Accident or
Incident
Factors causing overload are much the same in Ferrell's model. Traps are due to
defective workstation, design and incompatible displays or control. Decision to err are
caused by illogical decision under situation, unconscious desire to err and perceived
low probability.System failure is due to error in policy, responsibility, authority,
accountability, measurement, inspection, correction, investigation, orientation, training,
selection, safe operating procedure, standards.
Epidemiological Theory:
Suchman stated epidemiological definition of accident as "An unexpected;
unavoidable,unintentional act resulting from the interaction of host (accident victim),
agent (injury deliverer) and environmental factors within situations which involve risk
taking and perception of danger". His model is shown below:
Damage -- Unavoidable
--
Unintentional
Identifying the Hazard - involves recognizing things which may cause injury or harm
to the health of a person, for instance, flammable material, ignition sources or
unguarded machinery.
Assessing the Risk - involves looking at the possibility of injury or harm occurring to
a person if exposed to a hazard.
It is important to regularly review the steps, especially if there are changes in the
work environment, new techn ology is introduced, or standards are changed
Hazard identification
A hazard in relation to a person is "anything that may result in injury to a person
or harm to the health of a person".
There are a number of ways of identifying potential sources of injury or disease.
Selection of the appropriate procedure will depend on the type of work processes and
hazards involved. Procedures may range from a simple checklist for a specific piece of
equipment or substance, to a more open-ended appraisal of a group of related work
processes. Systematic inspections and audits can be used to detect changes away from
the designed or designated conditions. Such programmes can be scheduled on time,
fault or random regimes. Importantly the results should be utilised and form part of an
on-going base of data for the workplace. A combination of methods may provide the
most effective results. Methods of identifying workplace hazards include:
examining and considering material safety data sheets and product labels; and
Some hazards are inherent in the work process, such as mechanical hazards,
noise, or the toxic properties of substances. Other hazards result from equipment
or machine failures and misuse, control or power system failures, chemical
spills, and structural failures.
Hazards may be grouped into three categories - physical, mental and biological.
Within each category, there are further hazard groups or types. It is useful to
consider these hazard types (see below) when identifying work related hazards
to ensure that a wide range of potential hazards is considered. The most common
hazards in terms of bodily injury or disease are those which result in:
Assessing these three factors will indicate the probability or likelihood of injury or
harm to workers involved in a particular work process. It also indicates the likely
severity of this harm. Incomplete data or incomplete information regarding hazards of
a work process may complicate the task. Risk assessment requires good judgment and
awareness of the potential risks of a work process. Any person undertaking the risk
assessment must have knowledge and experience of the work process.
An assessment of the risk will help determine the consequences (potential injury or
disease) and assist to identify methods to reduce the risk. Risk assessment should
include:
8. examining procedures for an emergency (eg: accident, fire and rescue); and
In some cases it may be necessary to break down the activity or process into a series of
parts and assess each part separately.
The final step is to determine the control measures that need to be taken. In some
instances, a combination of control measures may be appropriate. Control measures
should be designed to:
eliminate or reduce the risks of a hazardous work process and to minimise the
effects of injury or disease; and reduce the risk of exposure to a hazardous substance.
Controls involve implementing measures that reduce the hazard and risk in the
workplace. The control of occupational injury and disease risks should preferably be
dealt with in a preferred order or hierarchy. The control measures range from the most
effective to the least effective. The Hierarchy or Preferred Order of Control is:
Elimination - removing the hazard or hazardous work practice from the
workplace. This is the most effective control measure.
Substitution - substituting or replacing a hazard or hazardous work practice
with a less hazardous one.
Isolation - isolating or separating the hazard or hazardous work practice from
people not involved in the work or the general work areas, for example, by
marking off hazardous areas, installing screens or barriers.
Engineering Control - if the hazard cannot be eliminated, substituted or
isolated, an engineering control is the next preferred measure. This may include
modifications to tools or equipment, providing guarding to machinery or
equipment.
Administrative Control - includes introducing work practices that reduce the
risk. This could include limiting the amount of time a person is exposed to a
particular hazard.
Personal Protective Equipment - should be considered only when other control
measures are not practicable or to increase protection.Control measures are not
mutually exclusive. That is, there may be circumstances where more than one
control measure should be used to reduce exposure to hazards. The higher level
controls generally eliminate, reduce or minimise risk in a more reliable manner
than personal protective equipment which is at the bottom of the priority
schedule.
2. Organisation:-
The safety organisation, management or at least the planned procedure, which it
represents, is the
vehicle, the mechanism by means of which interest is kept alive and the safety
programme is designed, directed and controlled . Safety is not only a staff
function but it is a line function also The actual work of prevention is done by
safety director or manager, safety officer and the line and staff supervisors with
the active support of top management.
4. Analysing
Twelve steps (safety officer's procedure) to analyse the causes of accidents are
as follows :
Obtain the supervisor's report of the accident containing the details
given above.
Obtain statutory accident report form.
Obtain the injured person's report.
Obtain the reports of witnesses if any.
Obtain the doctor's report on injury. .
Investigate the accident.
Record all evidences and facts.
Tabulate the essential facts of the accident together with the similar
past accidents.
Study all the facts.
Analyse accident causes in details. Such analysis will classify causes
as defective or no guard,
poor lighting, poor ventilation, no safety devices, no use of PPE,
accidents - fatal or nonfatal,
male or female wise, day or night wise, age wise etc.
Arrange the causes in order of importance or priority of compliance.
Find and record reasons of existence of those causes.
Selection of Remedy:
When it is analysed to indicate, which is the proximate or main cause that needs
to be corrected then it suggests the fourth step of selection of remedy for the
named (analysed) hazards. Four basic remedies 'are as under:
Four Basic Remedies:
a. Engineering Controls : Guarding of machine and tools, isolation of
hazards, revision of procedures and processes, good illumination,
ventilation, colour and colour contrast, substitution of safer materials and
tools, replacement, reduction, repair and a variety of mechanical, physical
and chemical remedial measures for which the most of the chapters of this
book are developed.
b. Instruction, Training, Persuasion and Appeal: Regular training as well
as instruction, reinstruction, persuasion, appeal, notice, posters,
supervision and motivation.
c. Personnel adjustment: Selection and placement with regard to the
requirement of the job and thephysical and mental suitability of the
worker, medical examination, treatment, advice and PPE.
d. Discipline: Mild admonition, expression of disappointment, fair
insistence, statement of past record, transfer to other work and penalties.
1)As far as reasonably practicable the health safety &welfare of all workers while they
are at work.
2)Maintain the plant & system of work in the factory safe and risk-free.
3)The arrangement in the factory in a such way that it is safe and risk free for
chemicals handling, storage & import.
4)To provide information, instruction, training & supervision to employees.
5)The maintenance of all work place that is safe and risk free.
6)To monitor the plant and worksites.
7)To disclose the information to the authorities, employees, workers and surrounding.
8)Make sure employees have and use safe tools and equipment’s& properly maintain
equipment
9)Use color codes,poster’s,labels or signs to warn employees.
10)Establish SOP & communicate workers that they understand.
11)Provide medical examinations and training when required by OSHA std.
12)Examine workplace condition to make sure they confirm osha standard.
13)Provide workplace free from hazard.
14)Keep record of work related injuries and illness.
15)Provide medical record & exposure record to employees
16) To give imminent danger information to the workers.
Role Of workmen’s