Professional Documents
Culture Documents
An High Sensitivity Optical Sensor For Chloroform
An High Sensitivity Optical Sensor For Chloroform
An High Sensitivity Optical Sensor For Chloroform
Received 23 April 2004; received in revised form 31 July 2004; accepted 9 September 2004
Abstract
A film of syndiotactic polystyrene (sPS) in the nanoporous crystalline δ form has been used for the detection of chloroform in the vapor
phase at very low concentration The variation of the refractive index due to the chloroform sorption within the polymer has been used as
transduction property. Reflectivity measurements by a fiber optic refractometer, coated with a nanometric (73 nm) film has been performed at
very low pressure of chloroform (between 0.2 and 5 Torr) at three different temperatures (35, 49 and 56 ◦ C). Mass sorption experiments have
been concurrently performed with an electronic microbalance operating in the same conditions of the optical sensor. Major result from the
gravimetric tests is that the analyte is mainly adsorbed into the nanoporous phase where the penetrant molecules can be hosted with a certain
selectivity based on both size exclusion and host guest interactions. The quantitative correlation between the mass of analyte sorbed within
the polymer layer and the refractive index variation has been observed to be temperature independent. A phenomenological equation based
on the Lorentz–Lorenz law has been proposed to describe the effect of the chloroform uptake including both concentration and polarizability
changes on the refractive index of the sensible layer.
© 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
0925-4005/$ – see front matter © 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.snb.2004.09.038
M. Giordano et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 107 (2005) 140–147 141
compounds, but also a broad range of selectivity. Calixarenes ous environment. The aim of the present work was not only to
[4], instead, exhibit a good selectivity and a good complexing investigate the suitability of the sensor for the detection of the
ability, as they have a an intermolecular cavity chemically sta- analyte in the vapor phase, but also to have quantitative infor-
ble and of tunable size and a coordination selectivity. Specific mation about the correlation between the chloroform uptake
host–guest interactions can, then, be enhanced by opportune within the polymer sensible layer and the corresponding vari-
designing of the molecule. ation of the optical property. Measures of reflectance at very
However, beside low molecular weight materials also small pressures of chloroform (down to 0.2 Torr) were, then,
many polymers comply to many of the requirements listed carried out at three different temperatures (35, 49 and 56 ◦ C)
above, resulting to be suitable materials to employ in sen- and the sorption isotherm curves obtained with the optoelec-
soric. Furthermore they can be deposited on several substrates tronic sensor were properly compared with those obtained
with easy processing techniques, and are low cost. In general from sorption tests by gravimetric analysis made with an elec-
amorphous materials are used (in the form of elastomers or tronic microbalance (CHAN 200) operating in the same con-
glasses) as the crystalline phase [5,6], being too compact, is ditions of temperature and pressures. The correlation between
usually impervious to penetrant. the sorbed mass and the variation of the polymer refractive in-
Nevertheless an interesting exception is represented by the dex and the external pressure of chloroform was obtained and
syndiotactic Polystyrene (sPS) in the semicrystalline δ form interpreted on the basis of the Lorentz–Lorenz law. A full de-
which is able to absorb also in the crystalline domains. This scription of the analysis and of the results is presented along
polymer is, in fact, characterized by a nanoporous crystalline discussion.
phase with a regularly spaced array of nanocavities of well
defined size and shape, where penetrant molecules can be
hosted with a certain selectivity based on both size exclu- 2. Materials and methods
sion and host guest interactions, and exhibits high sorption
capacity and an improved selectivity towards low molecular 2.1. δ Form SPS layer as vapor sensitive element
weight organic substances, mainly chlorinated and aromatic
[13–15]. Syndiotactic polystyrene is a polymorph semi-crystalline
The natural step following the selective recognition of an polymer exhibiting four different crystalline forms: α and
analyte, from the sensitive layer, is the signal transduction and β characterized by a transplanar conformation of the chains
thus the choice of the opportune technique to read the physi- and two others δ and γ consisting of s(2/1)2 TTGG heli-
cal changes occurring at the sensing part. In last years several cal chains [8]. Among these crystalline structures the δ form
sensor technologies have been developed for the chemical va- raises particular interest, as it is nanoporous [9]. It can be
por detection, where usually the transducer converts a vapor obtained when the polymer is cast from solution, in fact, sPS
induced change in the physical property of the sensing layer can clathrate the used solvent molecules housing them be-
into an optical or electronic signal. Widely used are the mass tween helical chains. Over extraction of the host molecules
sensors like those usually referred as piezoelectric sensors, by suitable solvent treatment a metastabile nanoporous struc-
(SAW, BAW, QCM), which act also like balances by measur- ture is obtained [10–12] (see Fig. 1). In this form sPS can
ing the shift in the resonance frequency of the piezo crystal adsorb reversibly certain analytes, whose size and shape well
due to the sorption of analyte within the sensing element, fit the nanocavities establishing specific host guest interac-
that is directly related to the sorbed mass. Another interest- tions, when exposed to vapor or liquid environment where
ing class of sensor of large application is represented by the these compounds are present even in traces. The nanoporous
impedance type sensors which are based on the changes in structure of the δ sPS is responsible of its higher sorption
resistivity or permittivity of conducting or insulating sensing capability in respect with other semi-crystalline polymers as
layers, deposited between contact lines, upon sorption of a it allows the penetration not only in the amorphous phase but
sample analyte. also within the crystalline domains that usually are more com-
Beside these, the fiber optic sensors represent another class pact and then impervious to penetrants. However a previous
of sensors of recent fast growing interest. Several advan- study [13,14] showed that, for low concentration of analyte,
tages are in fact associated to fiber optic like the absence δ form sPS exhibits sorption levels in the amorphous phase
of electrical interference that allows the remote real-time much lower than that of the crystalline phase; thus, when ex-
sensing, the possibility to use them in harsh environments posed to very low concentration of analyte it can be safely
as they are not subjected to corrosion and the possibility assumed that the sorption occurs almost completely in the
to serve both as sensing data transportation system and as sole crystalline phase where only those molecules of proper
transducer. dimensions and which are able to establish host guest inter-
In a earlier work, Authors [7] reported the successful per- action with the nanocavities, like low molecular chlorinated
formance of an optoelectronic sensing system for the measure or aromatic compounds, are admitted to pass. This allows δ
of refractive index, based on the sorption properties of a film sPS to be successfully used as polymeric coating for chemi-
of δ form syndiotactic polystyrene, for the detection of traces cal sensing as well as for application in chemical separation
of chloroform and toluene down to 5 ppm (ml/ml) in a aque- and water purification in membrane feature [15].
142 M. Giordano et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 107 (2005) 140–147
Fig. 1. Chain conformation in the sPS δ crystalline form. When the sensing film is cast from chloroform solution, ac planes corresponding to rows of parallel
helices with minimum interchain distances, are parallel to the film plan (uniplanar configuration). The grey shaded form represent the hosting cavity.
The sPS used for this work was supplied by Dow Chemical
Co. (Questra 101) presents a tacticity up to 98%, average
molecular weight (GPC) Mw = 320,000, polydispersity index
Mw/Mn = 3.9. The atactic PS was purchased by Aldrich with
an average molecular weight of 230,000 g/mol (GPC) and
specific density 1.04.
The fiber optic sensor probe was prepared by dip-coating
a sPS film from a chloroform solution of the polymer (1.5%
b.w.) onto the tip of a standard silica optical fiber 125 m
diameter and of 9 m core, which was previously perfectly
polished from the acrylic protection and cleaved with a preci-
sion cleaver in order to obtain a smooth and plane surface. The
clathrate thus formed was finally exposed to acetone vapors in
order to extract the solvent and obtain the empty nanoporous
δ form semi-crystalline sPS. The crystalline fraction of the
δ form obtained by a casting from a chloroform solution is
about the 50% by volume [12] and presents a strongly uni-
planar orientation, in other words the ac planes are parallel to
the sensor surface [16]. A schematic view of the basic sensor
design is reported in Fig. 2.
Reflectance measurements have been performed by light-
ing the sensing fiber with a broadband light source. To this
aim a superluminescent diode (40 nm bandwidth) centered at
1310 nm was used. A 2 × 2 in fiber coupler provides the nec-
essary connections between light source, sensing interface
and two receiving channel: one for reflected signal detection
and the other one for power monitoring in order to obtain well
compensated intensity measurements. More detailed descrip-
tion of the system set up can be found elsewhere [7]. Fig. 2. Scheme of the probe of the film refractometer and SEM image of the
The sensor head was, then, inserted in to a water-jacketed fiber coated tip.
stainless steel vacuum-tight cell by a special feed through
M. Giordano et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 107 (2005) 140–147 143
[17]. The pressure of the analyte vapor into the test cell is mea-
sured by a pressure transducer with a resolution of 0.01 Torr
while a turbomolecular pump allows the evacuation of the
test cell down to 10−3 Torr. Refractometric measurements
consisted in recording the sensor output as the sorption of the
analyte in the nanocavities promotes a change of the polymer
layer refractive index.
nf − n n − next 2πnd
r12 = ; r23 = ; δ= ;
nf + n n + next λ
where the constant Kn contains the optical coupling factor 2.4. Gravimetric analysis
α and the actual thickness d of the film [18]. Fig. 3a shows
the reflectance R as function of the refractive index of the For gravimetric analysis, powder particles of 10 nm aver-
polymer film for different film thickness (refractive indexes age diameter were used. The sPS samples were prepared by
of the fiber nf as been set to 1.46 and of the external medium milling films of the polymer, cast from chloroform solution,
next unity, respectively). exposed to CS2 vapors, boiled in acetone and then vacuum
Few useful considerations can be made on the expected dried at 60 ◦ C. The aPS, powders were obtained milling poly-
performance of the optical sensor. In particular, the sensor mer pellets without any previous treatment.
sensitivity ∂I/∂n and the response time θ ∝ d2 /D are both in- The apparatus for the gravimetric analysis consists in a
creasing function of the film thickness. Fig. 3b shows the sen- controlled atmosphere (chloroform vapor pressure at a con-
sor sensitivity, as theoretically evaluated from Eq. (1), and the trolled temperature) electronic microbalance, CAHN D200,
response time, both normalized to the value they attained for with a sensitivity equal to 0.1 g. The chloroform pressure
a 50 nm thick layer. Obviously, the proper compromise be- was measured using a MKS Baratron pressure transducer
tween high sensitivity and fast response of the sensor involves with a full scale reading of 10 Torr, a sensitivity of 10−3 Torr
primarily the choice of the polymer thickness. and an accuracy of 0.15% of the readout. The full detailed
144 M. Giordano et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 107 (2005) 140–147
description of the device is reported in a previous work [19]. amorphous phase in the semicrystalline polymer is equivalent
The equipment was used to determine the mass gain of the to that of atactic polystyrene, from the curves in Fig. 4, it can
powder samples due to sorption when exposed to chloroform be inferred that the sorption amount in the amorphous phase
vapors. Gravimetric measurements were carried out on pow- of δ sPS is negligible with respect to that in the crystalline
der samples of δ form sPS and aPS at the same temperatures phase.
and in the same range of chloroform pressures of the refrac-
tometric analysis. 3.2. Fiber optic refractometer experiments
Fig. 4. Sorption isotherms of chloroform at different temperatures for sPS Fig. 5. Ratios of the spectra of sPS films and nude fiber at 25 ◦ C (continuous
and aPS (continuous lines are only guides for the eyes). lines are the best fit).
M. Giordano et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 107 (2005) 140–147 145
Table 1
Refractive index of sPS at different temperatures and thermo optic coefficient
◦
T ( C) 25 35 49 56 dn/dT, K−1
n 1.5781 1.5741 1.5684 1.5656 4.03 × 10−4
Such finding, based on the evidence that a class of penetrant [8] G. Guerra, V.M. Vitagliano, C. De Rosa, V. Petraccone, P. Corradini,
molecules can be hosted within the crystal cavities only due Polymorphism in melt crystallized syndiotactic polystyrene samples,
Macromolecules 23 (5) (1990) 1539–1544.
to both size exclusion and host guest interactions, guaranties a
[9] V. Petraccone, F. Auriemma, F. Dal Poggetto, C. De Rosa, G.
certain selectivity towards the chloroform (even if a quantita- Guerra, P. Corradini, On the structure of the mesomorphic form of
tive evaluation of the polymer selectivity shall involve further syndiotactic polystyrene, Makromolekulare Chemie 194 (5) (1993)
work). 1335–1345.
Sensor calibration enabled to retrieve the effective changes [10] C. Manfredi, C. De Rosa, G. Guerra, M. Rapacciuolo, F. Auriemma,
of refractive index due to the analyte sorption within the P. Corradini, Structural changes induced by thermal treatments on
emptied and filled clathrates of syndiotactic polystyrene, Macromol.
polymer layer and permitted a quantitative correlation be- Chem. Phys. 196 (9) (1995) 2795–2808.
tween the concentration of sorbed chloroform, the variation [11] G. Milano, V. Venditto, G. Guerra, L. Cavallo, P. Ciambelli, D.
of the polymer refractive index and the external pressure of Sannino, Shape and volume of cavities in thermoplastic molecular
chloroform. As matter of fact, the sorption of chloroform sieves based on syndiotactic polystyrene, Chem. Mater. 13 (2001)
induces stronger changes in refractive index, approximately 506–1511.
[12] C. De Rosa, G. Guerra, V. Petraccone, B. Pirozzi, Crystal struc-
∂n/∂C ≈ 2 × 10−3 , if compared with the thermo-optic coef- ture of emptied clathrate form (␦e form) of syndiotactic polystyrene,
ficient of sPS, ∂n/∂T = 4 × 10−4 K−1 ; as a consequence the Macromolecules 30 (1997) 4147–4152.
dependence of refractive index on the concentration of sorbed [13] G. Guerra, C. Manfredi, P. Musto, S. Tavone, Guest conformation
chloroform results non linear and poorly dependent on tem- and diffusion into amorphous and emptied clathrate phases of syn-
perature. In addition, an empirical equation has been pro- diotactic polystyrene, Macromolecules 31 (4) (1998) 1329–1334.
[14] G. Mensitieri, V. Venditto, G. Guerra, Polymeric sensing films ab-
posed on the basis of the Lorentz–Lorenz law accounting for sorbing organic guests into a nanoporous host crystalline phase, Sens.
density and polarizability dependence of refractive index on Actuators, B: Chem. B92 (3) (2003) 255–261.
the mass of chloroform adsorbed. [15] G. Guerra, G. Mensitieri, V. Venditto, Method for the detection of
In conclusion, the proposed sensor system, together with organic pollutants using syndiotactic polystyrene polymers as sensing
the derived correlation between the concentration of sorbed elements, US Pat. Appl. Publ. (2002) 7.
[16] P. Rizzo, M. Lamberti, A.R. Albunia, O. Ruiz de Ballesteros, G.
chloroform and the variation of the polymer refractive index Guerra, Cristalline orientation in syndiotactic polystyrene cast films,
permits the quantitative monitoring of the vapor chloroform Macromolecules 35 (2002) 5854–5860.
composition at very low chemical activities levels. [17] E.R.I. Araham, E.A. Cornell, Teflon Feedthrough for coupling optical
fibers into ultrahigh vacuum systems, Appl. Opt. 370 (10) (1998)
1762–1763.
[18] A. Cusano, G.V. Persiano, M. Russo, M. Giordano, Novel optoelec-
References tronic sensing system for thin polymer films glass transition inves-
tigation, IEEE Sens. J. (in press).
[1] J.W. Grate, M.H. Abraham, Solubility interaction and design of [19] C. Manfredi, A.M. Del Nobile, G. Mensitieri, G. Guerra, M. Rapac-
chemically selective sorbent coatings for chemical sensor and ar- ciuolo, Vapor sorption in emptied clathrate samples of syndiotactic
rays, Sens. Actuators, B 3 (1991) 85–111. polystyrene, J. Polym. Sci., Part B: Polym. Phys. 35 (1) (1997)
[2] C. Di Natale, D. Salimbeni, R. Paolesse, A. Macagnano, A. 133–140.
D’Amico, Porphyrins-based opto-electronic nose for volatile com- [20] A. Cusano, A. Cutolo, M. Giordano, L. Nicolais, Optoelectronic
pounds detection, Sens. Actuators, B 65 (2000) 220–226. refractive index measurements: application to smart processing, IEEE
[3] H.B. Lin, J.S. Shih, Fullerene C60-cryptand coated surface acoustic Sens. J. 3 (6) (2003) 781–787.
wave quartz crystal sensor for organic vapors, Sens. Actuators 92 [21] P. Rizzo, A. Costabile, G. Guerra, Perpendicular orientation of host
(2003) 243–254. polymer chains in clathrate thick films, Macromolecules 37 (8)
[4] S.K. Matè, G. Nagy, L. Collar, Investigation of the interaction of (2004) 3071–3076.
calixarenes (host) and neutral benzotrifluoride (guest) conmparisn [22] P. Musto, G. Mensitieri, S. Cotugno, G. Guerra, V. Venditto, Prob-
of luminescence characteristic of calixarenes with results of model ing by time-resolved FTIR spectroscopy mass transport, molec-
calculation relating to complex formation, Sens. Actuators, B 76 ular interactions, and conformational ordering in the system
(2001) 545–550. chloroform–syndiotactic polystyrene, Macromolecules 35 (6) (2002)
[5] A.S. Michaels, H.J. Bixler, Flow of gases through polyethylene [and 2296–2304.
rubbery polymers], J. Polym. Sci. 50 (1961) 413–439. [23] J. Crank, The Mathematics of Diffusion, second ed., Clarendon
[6] C.E. Rodgers, Permeation of gas and vapors in polymers, in: J. Press, Oxford, 1975.
Comyn (Ed.), Polymer Permeability, Elsevier, New York, 1985, Ch. [24] G. Milano, G. Gaetano, F. Mueller-Plathe, Anisotropic diffusion
2. of small penetrants in the δ crystalline phase of syndiotactic
[7] M. Giordano, M. Russo, A. Cusano, G. Mensitieri, G. Guerra, Syn- polystyrene: a molecular dynamics simulation study, Chem. Mater.
diotactic polystyrene thin film as sensitive layer for an optoelectronic 14 (7) (2002) 2977–2982.
chemical sensing device, Sens. Actuators B (in press).