REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES

COURT OF TAX APPEALS

QUEZON CITY

THIRD DIVISION

COURT CALENDAR FOR THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 14, 2023 at 9:00 A.M.

PRESENT:

HON. CATHERINE T. MANAHAN Associate Justice / Chairperson

HON. MARIAN IVY F. REYES-FAJARDO Associate Justice / Member

ATTY. CHRISTINE C. MAZA-GUARIN Executive Clerk of Court III

MS. KEITH GWYNETH R. MANUEL Court Stenographer III
MS. RAMONNE DJ. BALOR Interpreter II

I. CIVIL CASES

1. TRIUMPH INTERNATIONAL (PHILIPPINES),

INC.

- versus - CTA CASE NO. 11240

COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE

(For petitioner’s Urgent Motion to Suspend Tax Collection)

*With petitioner’s Urgent Motion to Suspend Tax Collection (with prayer for the Issuance of Status Quo Ante
Order and or Writ of Preliminary Injuction) filed on August 2, 2023

- With attached Judicial Affidavit of Mary Rose H. Lara executed and filed on August 2, 2023

*With respondent’s Motion to Admit attached Comment/Opposition [Re: Petitioner's Urgent Motion to
Suspend Tax Collection (with prayer for the Issuance of Status Quo Ante Order and or Writ of Preliminary
Injuction) filed on September 6, 2023

CP: Atty. Johnsen H. Alejandro CR: Atty. Niki Beryl B. Dela Cruz
Atty. Jericho D. Valencia (notified)
Atty. A.J. John M. Carbonell
Atty. Gene Paolo S. Guevara
Atty. Ferdinand Elbert D. Jomilla, Jr.
Atty. Moachi C. Siansen
Atty. Brigitte Anne A. Mupas
(notified)
3rd Division Calendar
September 14, 2023
Page 2 of 4

2. THE CAMBRIDGE VILLAGE

CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC.

- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10955

COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE

(For Pre-Trial Conference)

*With petitioner’s Secretary’s Certificate attached to the Petition for Review filed on August 12, 2022

*With petitioner’s Pre-Trial Brief filed on September 6, 2023

- With the Judicial Affidavit of Juanito N. Angeles executed on January 5, 2022 and attached to
the Amended Petition for Review filed on January 10, 2023

- With the Judicial Affidavit of Sharon Relos executed on January 5, 2022 and attached to the
Amended Petition for Review filed on January 10, 2023

*With respondent’s Pre-Trial Brief filed through accredited courier service provider on September 8,
2023 and received by the Court on September 11, 2023

- With the Judicial Affidavits (J.A.) of the following witnesses attached to the respondent’s Pre-
Trial Brief filed through accredited courier service provider on September 8, 2023 and
received by the Court on September 11, 2023

1. J.A. of Nathaniel Sayson executed on September 8, 2023

2. J.A. of Princess Eve Palabrica executed on September 8, 2023
3. J.A. of Ernie C. Dimzon executed on September 8, 2023

*No Special Power of Attorney filed by respondent

*With both parties’ Joint Stipulation of Facts and Issues filed on September 6, 2023

CP: Atty. Winston P.L. Esguerra CR: Atty. Rose Ann O. Tolentino
Atty. John Philipps M. Reposo (notified)
Atty. Alfonso Miguel C. Lopez
(notified)
3rd Division Calendar
September 14, 2023
Page 3 of 4

3. HC CONSUMER FINANCE PHILIPPINES, INC.

- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10757
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE

(For the presentation of evidence for petitioner, for the testimony of Remelyn Lumabao and the
Commissioning of Independent Certified Public Accountant)

*With the Judicial Affidavit of Remelyn Lumabao executed on January 6, 2022 and attached to the Pre-
Trial Brief filed on February 7, 2023
*With petitioner’s “Urgent Motion to Admit the Amended Judicial Affidavit of. Ms. Remelyn
Lumabao” filed on September 8, 2023
- With attached Amended Judicial Affidavit of Remelyn Lumabao executed and filed on
September 8, 2023
*With petitioner’s Motion for the Commissioning of an Independent Certified Public Accountant filed on
August 11, 2023
- With attached Judicial Affidavit of Glenn Ian D. Villanueva executed on August 10, 2023 and
filed on August 11, 2023

CP: Atty. Kevin John B. Lumbre CR: Atty. Francis Gideon G. Naputo
Atty. Princess Rexille V. Liboon Atty. Aprilyn T. Pobar
(notified) (notified)

4. STEFANINI PHILIPPINES INC.

- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10920
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE

(For the presentation of evidence for respondent, for the testimony of Revenue Officer Jelly Anne T.
Mateo)

*With the Judicial Affidavit of Revenue Officer Jelly Anne T. Mateo executed and filed on January 9,
2023

CP: Atty. Jonathan A. Mangundayao CR: Atty. Bryan C. Diego

(notified) (notified)

5. MD NABUNTURAN AGRI-VENTURES, INC.

- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10989
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE

(For the presentation of evidence for petitioner, for the testimonies of Regine Agcito and ICPA, Peter
Raymond T. Santos)

*With the Judicial Affidavit of Regine Agcito executed on July 7, 2023 and filed on July 11, 2023
*With the Judicial Affidavit of Peter Raymond T. Santos executed on September 7, 2023 and filed on
September 11, 2023
- With ICPA Report and 1 USB filed on August 29, 2023

CP: Atty. Atty. Ruth V. Ricardo CR: Atty. Mark Joey S. Lucero
(notified) Atty. Ayesha Hania B. Guiling-Matanog
(notified)
 3rd Division Calendar
September 14, 2023
Page 4 of 4

COMMISSIONER’S HEARING FOR THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 14, 2023

(GROUND FLOOR, OFFICE OF THE DIVISION CLERK OF COURT, CTA BUILDING II)

1. SIRAWAI PLYWOOD AND LUMBER

CORPORATION

- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10810

(Respondent)
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE

(Before Atty. Amelia Dolores B. Castillo-Esquivel, Clerk of Court II, at 1:30 p.m.)

2. MISNET EDUCATION INC.

- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10802

(Petitioner)
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE

(Before Atty. Amelia Dolores B. Castillo-Esquivel, Clerk of Court II, at 2:00 to 2:30 p.m.)

3. MISNET EDUCATION INC.

- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10802

(Respondent)
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE

(Before Atty. Amelia Dolores B. Castillo-Esquivel, Clerk of Court II, at 2:30 to 3:00 p.m.)

4. NOVARTIS HEALTHCARE PHILIPPINES, INC.

- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10900

(Petitioner)
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE

(Before Atty. Amelia Dolores B. Castillo-Esquivel, Clerk of Court II, at 3:00 to 3:30 p.m.)

-end-