Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 s2.0 S0143749610000679 Main
1 s2.0 S0143749610000679 Main
a r t i c l e in fo abstract
Article history: This paper describes the pre-treatment of the wrought aluminium alloy AW 6016, which is mainly
Accepted 25 May 2010 employed in automotive car body manufacturing to reduce the weight. The major focus is on surface
Available online 9 June 2010 pre-treatment using laser to examine the influence of selected pre-treatment parameters on the
Keywords: strength and aging resistance of the bonded joint. The laser procedure presented is compared with
Epoxy/epoxides surface pre-treatments on the basis of the wet-chemical deposition of a TiZr oxide layer and
Aluminium and alloys atmospheric pressure plasma (AP-plasma) treatment. The pre-treated surfaces were characterised using
Surface treatment SEM–EDX, FTIR spectroscopy and XPS methods. Laser pre-treatment helped improve cleaning the
Laser surfaces and modify the oxide layer at the same time. The improvements resulted in better tensile shear
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy
strength of the bonded joint before and after aging.
Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy
& 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy
0143-7496/$ - see front matter & 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.ijadhadh.2010.05.009
596 R. Rechner et al. / International Journal of Adhesion & Adhesives 30 (2010) 595–601
ablation of aluminium, the metal surface is subjected to short- varied on the specimen surface with full power and a fixed
time melting and immediate cooling, which produces a dendritic average scan speed (Table 1).
structure of the metal surface [21]. XPS testing of the aluminium For the sake of comparison, atmospheric pressure plasma
surface confirms the reduction of the magnesium content and the pre-treatment tests using an AP-plasma system by Plasmatreat
carbohydrate compounds in the boundary layer [22]. All com- were conducted. A single nozzle was used for selective
mercial laser systems, ultraviolet to infrared, are suitable for laser pre-treatment. All tests were carried out for maximum system
treatment [17,23,24]. For the parallel removal of organic layers output. The gas medium used was pressurised air and the specific
and inhomogeneous oxide layers Q-switched Nd:YAG lasers are air flow rate (up to 2000 l/h) depends on the plasma nozzle. The
recommended. The optional beam guidance through flexible glass tests used different nozzle heads (standing, rotating) at varied
fibres additionally offers the chance to combine pre-treatment movement speeds (1–20 mm/min), nozzle–substrate distances
and automatic adhesive deposition [25,26]. (3–10 mm) and pre-treatment widths (1–5 mm). Best results
In former investigations it was already proved that the laser could be achieved with a standing nozzle at a movement speed of
pre-treatment represents an effective procedure for the prepara- 1 mm/min, a nozzle–substrate distance of 6 mm and a
tion of bonding surfaces. However, the interaction between laser pre-treatment width of 3 mm. These parameters were used for
irradiation and material surface was analysed so far only the pre-treatment of the plasma specimen shown in Fig. 11.
inadequately. This interaction will be analysed more closely in
this paper. First of all suitable laser parameters are selected for
2.2. Materials selection
the cleaning of oiled aluminium sheets and studied in terms of
their effect. Then the influence on the topography and chemical
The wrought aluminium alloy AW 6016 has been chosen for
composition of the aluminium surface is analysed. The concluding
experimentation (Table 2). The tensile shear specimens had the
tensile shear strength investigations show the effect of the laser
dimensions (w h d) 100 25 1.6 mm3 and thus were in
pre-treatment on the component strength of bonded aluminium
accordance with ISO standard 4587. For reference bondings
sheets (AW 6016). The procedure is directly compared with
(variant A), the TiZr coating Gardobonds X 4591 was applied to
conventional pre-treatment and atmospheric pressure plasma
the specimens, before the corrosion inhibitor oil Anticorit RP 4107
pre-treatment. The tensile shear strength investigation is carried
RV (by Fuchs) was deposited on top. The TiZr coating is not
out before and after various aging procedures.
applied on the specimens with laser and plasma pre-treatment,
the coating is replaced by the chosen laser or plasma process
(variant B).
2. Experimental
2.3. Analytical techniques
2.1. Pre-treatment techniques
XPS, FTIR spectroscopy and SEM–EDX methods were used to
In the laser tests, an Nd:YAG (l ¼1064 nm) laser of the type characterise the surface.
CLA 050 manufactured by Clean-Lasersysteme GmbH was used. It XPS tests were conducted at a take-off angle of 451 using
has a mean output power of 0–120 W (pulsed or cw) and a non-monochromatized Al Ka radiation on a ESCA 5700 (Physical
continuous frequency range of 8–40 kHz. Owing to the short pulse Electronics). With a calibrated (SiO2/Ta2O5) sputtering rate the
duration of few nanoseconds, a pulse maximum power of 120 kW surface was removed at about a rate of 1 nm/min using Ar ions to
can be attained. be able to analyse deeper layers. For the final interpretation of the
The laser power is coupled into a glass fibre immediately after measured values, the spectra were normalised to the contamina-
the resonator. The fibre ensures the quasi-lossless transmission of tion carbon peak at 285.0 eV. For the XPS analysis a specimen
the laser power even over long distances until it reaches the (50 25 1.6 mm3) with small fields of about 10 mm2 for each
workpiece [27]. At the place of processing, the laser beam is laser parameter and reference was prepared and measured
decoupled from the fibre and projected onto the surface through a shortly after laser pre-treatment.
2D scan head with built-in F-theta lens (f ¼100 mm). The range of For the FTIR measurements, an IRspecXL (Fraunhofer IWS) at
processing speeds is 0–4000 mm/s. The beam profile, after having grazing incidence (y ¼731) with p-polarised light in a wavenum-
passed through the fibre, follows the continuous uniform ber range of 6000–500 cm 1 and for a fixed measuring dot size of
distribution that is also called top hat distribution. The beam 0.8 mm 1.5 mm was used. The spectra were recorded in
section is round and the beam size in the focus is 357 mm. The specular reflection mode with a DTGS-detector. An Au-mirror
pulse frequencies and thus the resulting laser intensities were was used for the reference signal.
Table 1
Laser parameter (LP) for fibre-coupled laser processing.
pulse intensity (W/m2) 1.73 1011 2.10 1011 2.66 1011 3.48 1011 4.42 1011
Table 2
Choice of materials.
A JSM 6400 with LaB6 cathode (by Jeol) was used for the 3. Results and discussion
SEM–EDX measurements. The images were made at an accelera-
tion voltage of 10 kV by scanning the surface with variable 3.1. Surface analysis
resolutions (3–500 mm). The secondary electron contrast (surface
topography) and the back scattered electron contrast (material Fig. 1 shows the results of an X-ray spectroscopy (XPS)
contrast) were used to image the sample surface. The element conducted with the aluminium alloy AW 6016. The normalised
composition was assessed using additional X-ray analysis for representation of the spectra between 0 and 1100 eV shows – on
selected magnifications (100:1, 500:1, 1000:1). the basis of the reference value – the modified composition of the
For the bonding tests, the hot-curing epoxy adhesive Betamate elements carbon, oxygen and aluminium after the laser pre-
1496 (Dow Automotive, lot no. 279844) a commonly used treatment. Table 3 gives a quantitative elemental analysis for the
adhesive in car body construction was chosen. The preheated investigated parameters. Carbon contamination decreases with
adhesive (50 1C) was applied with a spatula from both sides onto increasing laser intensity, while the measured oxygen content
the surfaces of the preheated samples (50 1C). Due to the increases. Only small amounts of aluminium can be detected on
unpredictable influence of spacers (e.g. in aging) the reproduci- the reference surface due to the heavy contamination. The related
bility of the bondline thickness was controlled by the amount of peaks for aluminium can be located on the laser pre-treated
the applied adhesive and a defined contact pressure using clamps. specimen surfaces. A change of intensity between the individual
The specimens were fixed after the joining process and then cured parameters cannot be measured. However, the quantitative
at 180 1C for 30 min. To ensure statistical reliability, a series of 5 elemental analysis shows an increase from 10.3% to 18.7%.
specimens was bonded for each parameter. Before the test cycle The additional layer removal by 5 nm through an Argon ion
was continued, all samples were conditioned at room tempera- sputtering process and the subsequent measurement (Fig. 2,
ture for 24 h and at 40 75% relative humidity. Table 4) of the exposed layers further show that the reference
Following ISO 9227, the specimens were subjected to aging in specimen surface is considerably contaminated by the deposited
the salt spray test for selected periods of time (1000 and 2000 h). corrosion inhibitor oil which in all probabilities immediately
A salt spray chamber of the type SC/KWT 450 (Weiss Umwelt- diffuses over the exposed area because of the low viscosity. The
technik GmbH) was used for the tests. The specimens were measured carbon content of the laser pre-treated specimens is
arranged in the chamber at an angle of 201 to the perpendicular. negligible. However, the presence of aluminium and oxygen on
After aging, the specimens were temporarily stored at room the specimen surface increases. The intensity detected remains
temperature and at 40 75% relative humidity for 24 h to ensure a nearly constant. Differences between the laser parameters cannot
comparable initial state without a full re-drying. be measured.
Before the lab aging process, some of the specimen series were The XPS results are confirmed by FTIR spectroscopy (Fourier
completely sealed in an electrophoretic deposition process (EPD) transform infrared spectroscopy) measurements. Fig. 3 shows the
to model the typical bonding and paintwork on bonded mid-infrared spectrum of 2700–3000 cm 1. The extent to which
components in the automobile industry. A dualscope MP40/probe
ED10 (Fischer) was used to determine the thickness of the
Table 3
deposited varnish layer in the eddy current mode and was found
Quantitative elemental analysis.
to be 24 mm.
The specimens were tested in a testing machine of the type Specimen Elements (at%)
Zwick/Roell Z050 to determine the tensile shear strength. The test
C O Al O/Al
speed was 10 mm/min. The load cell KAP-TC employed is suitable
for forces of up to 20 kN. The specimens were arranged Reference 84.1 12.1 1.3 9.1
symmetrically between the grips. The minimum distance LP1 52.8 28.8 10.3 2.8
between the grip and the nearest edge of the single lap joint LP2 43.0 34.0 14.3 2.4
was 50 mm according to ISO 4587. LP3 41.0 37.6 14.1 2.7
LP4 35.2 40.5 16.8 2.4
LP5 30.1 42.7 18.7 2.3
Fig. 1. XPS measurement of AW 6016. Fig. 2. XPS measurement of AW 6016 after sputtering of 5 nm.
598 R. Rechner et al. / International Journal of Adhesion & Adhesives 30 (2010) 595–601
Table 4
Quantitative elemental analysis after 5 nm argon sputtering.
C O Al O/Al
Fig. 6. Untreated and laser pre-treated (LP5) surface in secondary electron Fig. 8. EDX analysis of LP5 pre-treated surface.
contrast.