Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1961 4 Eng
1961 4 Eng
COMMENT
ROYAL CANADIAN AIR FORCE
DFS LIBRARY
EDITORIAL LIBRARY COPY-th ;s
pub must be retatrned,
TAXIINO
2 3
I~IIIIII SIIIIII -~'
base an experienced pilot will carefully assess cate the method of approach . The water char-
its suitability for the subsequent take-off . acteristics of aircraft will affect the technique
Having selected the landing run, surface con- to be used . The combination of forethought,
ditions may suggest a special landing technique . good searnanship and a well trained crew
properlybriefedfor the manoeuvre is essential.
, .
LANDING IN ROUGH WATER Having secured the aircraft, responsibility fo~
its safety rnust be established by the captain .
Landings may be made in water much too Highwinda and waves mustbe anticipated and it
rough for a take-off if the power-stall is used . ia often necessary to leave a crew aboard a
The power-stall landing consista of putting the flying boat at moorings . Aircraft left at docks
aeroplane in the proper attitude for a landing should not be without a guard and regular pilot
at some distance above the w~ater and main- inspection of securing ropes and bridles is
taining, by the use of the engine, just enough e s sential to a good seaplane and boat operation.
speed to allow a gradual rate of sink . Care
must be taken not to let the speed get too low, CONCLUSIONS
as the usual consequences of a atail wi11 re sult .
In the past few years the emphasis in the
LANDING IN GLASSY WATER RCAF has been primarily on jet flying . We
still have, however, a requirement for a rel-
The most hazardous condition frequently atively small number of skilled water-borne
encountered by sea-plane and boat pilots in pilots . Although somewhat less spectacular,
Canada is that due to glassy water . The con- the occupation has rnany advantages asaociated
dition is well known and all qualified water-
borne pilots will have had instruction on the
as it is with advanced base operations . There LAC J .P . MURPHY
is a greater freedom of action which in turn
technique to be employed . The problern then permita a pilot to exercise more initiative .
is to determine when the condition exists . His responsibilities are increased and must
Should there be doubt, assume glassy water and be accepted if unnecessary accidents are to be
approach accordingly . Difficulty frequently avoided . Additional and continuous training
arises under marginal conditions when the pilot in seamanship is required . Some sail-boat
thinks that he can see the surface and changes t :me, whichmakes one conscious of submerged
to a normal landing technique . That's where and floating obstacles and the peculiarities of
the trouble starts . At best, one eacapes with wind and current, is time well spent in the
a violent reminder that all is not well with the training of a seaplane pilot . In conclusion,
landing technique . Alternatively, survivors let us keep our summer free of watercraft
may have sorr~e unpleasant under-water ex- accidents . Watch out for that glassy water
periences to relate to the board of inquiry . surface . When in doubt assume the condition
exists . Remember all water is suapect until
SECURING your inspection provea otherwise . Check for LAC F .M . PELLEY
submerged rocks and sand-bars . Watch for
Unlike flying from a land base where a floating logs and dead-heads . Carefully pre-
smooth landing to all intents completes an plan your docking, beaching, or mooring, be-
operation, the seaplane or boat pilot has an cause through failing to do so, you might find LAC Murphy ACOp, while on duty in Rivera after the pilot was heard to request an imme-
additional and sometimes tricky c}iore to secure tower monitored a transmission from an air- diate descent to Minimum Enroute Altitude .
yourself up the well known creek, Maintain a
his aircraft . The type of dock, the beach or craft to Broadview radio . The pilot was ex- ATC were unable to clear the aircraft below
well trained crew and keep them briefed on
buoy, in relation to the currer~t wind will indi- your plan . periencing difficulty with icing while flying at 6000 feet because of conflicting traffic . Rivers
9000 feet and was requesting information from established radar contact and passed the
ATC regarding icing in the lower levels . necessary separation information to ATC for
Realizing he might be able to help, LAC emergency descent . Fortunately the aircraft
Murphy contacted LAC Pelley Met/Obs who was in difficulty broke out between layera of cloud
on duty in the met section and then alerted the and was able to proceed to Winnipeg .
DFCO . LAC Pelley consulted the area fore- The alertness, and quick recognition of the
caster and advised ATC of the correct course problem displayed by LAC Murphy and LAC
of action while the DFCO alerted GCA and pro- Pelley and their subsequent actions, along with
ceeded to the tower in the event the aircraft the staff of RCAF Rivers are highly commend-
might have to land at Rivers . able and are deserving of a Good Show from
Listening watch was maintained and shortly Flight Comment .
DFS LIBRARY
ARE YOU SURE OF YOUR ALTITUDE?
You have the following discussion with the
weather forecaster : LIBRARY COPY -thia
pub must he returned.
PIL~T : Iintend to file for 10, 000 feet,
which is the standard height of
the 700 millibar surface .
It is inconceivable that a c apable, exper- will discuss a new approach to an old subject, Is the height of the 700 milli-
ienced pilot would deliberately fly below the it would be best to begin completely fresh with bar pressure surface above
tops of prominent terrain features, particularly no preconceived ideas . To illustrate, here are or below normal and by what
under instrument conditions . Nevertheless, a few statements almost universally accepted, amount?
accidents of this type occur all too frequently . yet they are not true .
The queation then arises, "Was he off his 1 . The pressure altimeter reads approxi- FORECASTER : According to the latest charts,
altitude?" or "Didn't he have the current alti- mate true altitude if the current setting the height of the 700 millibar
meter setting?" is maintained, surface will be about normal
2. A high altimeter setting (high surface ( here at McChord, but will be
DID YOU KNOW THIS TYPE OF ACCIDENT pressure) means that the aircraft is about 800 feet below normal
higher than indicated . over the Rockies .
CAN OCCUR EVEN IF YOU ARE INDICATING
3. True altitude may be computed inflight
THE PROPER ALTITUDE AND DO HAVE THE by correcting for flight-level tempera- PILC>T : Well, that will put me 800 feet
CURRENT ALTIMETER SETTING? ture, lower than indicated to begin
with . What are the altimeter
Most pilots confidently expect that the cur- THE ABOVE STATEMENTS ARE FALSE . settings along this route?
rent altimeter setting will compensate for
FORECASTER : The altimeter setting is
irregularities in atmospheric pressure . Un- What determines the indications of the pres- standard here at McChord and
fortunately, this is not always true . In fact, sure altimeter? There are only three (3) inc rea s e s to a maximum of
under some conditio~ns, the correct altimeter variables . . . . . . .
~ut~~ue
30,6L inches near the Rockies .
setting will actually aggravate errors in alti- 1 . The atmospheric pressure which the What effect does that have?
tude, We expect far too much from the altimeter instrument is rr~easuring .
setting . After all, it is only a correction for L. The mechanicaL displacement of the in- PIL~T : Because a high setting in-
non-standard atmospheric conditions from the dicatorneedles . . .thealtimeter setting,
2
creases the altimeter scale
surface down to sea level, It makes no attempt 3 . Instrument error, (This is largely an indications, I will naturally
to correct from the surface up . unknown but may be expected to be within lower the aircraft to maintain
The pressure altimeter, correctly set, is plus or minus 3% of the reading . ) desired indicated altitude .
good for flight-level separation because any Aside from the possible instrument error, In this case, the difference
atmospheric error is common to all aircraft in it is easy to anticipate the effects of the other will be . . .
the area, It is also useful for landing, at which two variables . The basic information is readilv
point possible atmospheric error diminishes to Actual setting 30 .62
available in the weather station . B Y askin g for Standard setting L9 .92
zero . BUT, TI~iE PRESSURE ALTIMETER two specific iterns of information during the -~~x 1000 = 700 feet
WILL NOT TELL YOU HOW HIGEi YUU ARE preflight weather briefing, you can at once Fati gue is a difficult thing to define, des-
WHEN IN FLIGHT r determine if you will be higher or lower than F~RECASTER : How high will you actually be ? cribe, or explain . We all know it exists and
What can you do to anticipate a large dis- indicated and by what amount . have experienced it in many ways and degrees,
crepancy between indicated altitude and true As an example, consider a flight from PILOT: Add the two effects , r . Perhaps the simplest way to think of it is as a
altitude? First, 1et's review this instrument McChord AFB, Washington to Great Falls, temporary loss of ability to cope with a task,
from a slightly different angle . Because we Montana on the afternoon of Z4 March 1955 . Variation of 700 millibar i .e ., a loss of fitness . The factors producing
surface from standard -800 feet it may not be associated with the task . The
Effect of high altimeter active, physical fatigue which is due to activity
Path vl airtreft maintainin,
the torrett altimrter seftlngc
e~
B,000' S,ODO-
1500 feet below my indicated altitude of are subjectto a form of mental or ekill fatigue
10, 000 feet, The terrain is about 8000 feet which can occur even in idleness . It is related
just to the west of my destination, so I'11 to the concentration, reaponsibility, and appre-
A1 Ihis point yous al4meter
Indltatr< 10,000 leel, whith is
s,ooo 6,Opp'
hension of flying or waiting to fly . It has been
an apparenl 1,000 foot trrrain
drarenta Attually, yow ah- file for 1L, 000 instead - just to be on the
vall rs only 500 Imr alovr ihe
l,OpO foot pw1.
safe side, said that pilots are either bored to death,
a,ooa This example was an actual weather situation worked to death, or scared to death! All of
~,ooo
and is neither unusual nor outstanding . Com- these are mentally and physically exhausting
bined errors of this type may reach as much and may accumulate day by day to a chronic
2,000 ~ z,ouo as L, 000 feet . If you are one who relies upon atate known as "pilot fatigue" unless relieved
the current altimeter setting when flying at by frequent rest, recreation, or leave from
minimum altitudes, you had better think again . duty .
.
Modern ~'e t a ir c r at
f h a v e been known as But safety measures are not complete when
supersonic fighters, high speed interceptors the pilot reaches terra firma . Part of the
and, lately, missiles with men in them . And equipment strapped to him is an ingenious seat
as long as there are men in them, andthe per- pack which serves as a cushion during the flight .
formance factor continues to rise, there will Spirited into this canvas pack little more than
be an increased requirement for the utmost in a foot square and only five-and-one-half inches
air safety . deep are such items as a sleeping bag, oxygen
While aircrews are drilled in air safety bail-outbottle, insect repellent and netting,
measures from their first aviation class, it is whistle, l5 feet of snare wire, survival in-
the aircraft that contain the life-preserving struction booklets, a search and rescue anc?
equipm ent . homing (SARAH) radio unit with battery pack
Perhaps the moat important item to the jet and homing beacon ; fishing kit, compass, first
pilot ie his oxygen gear, for at high altitudes aid kit, rations and a generous supply of wool
he cannot survive without it . Most modern stockings and mittens .
systems include a set of storage bottles, made In short, it contains enough equipment to
of shatter-proof metal, and a circuit of plumbing sustain a man alrnost indefinitely when com-
which leads to a regulator in the cockpit . The bined with a knowledge of bush lore . For air-
regulator controls the amount vf oxygPn mixed craft flying over large bodies of water, the
into the air according to the height at which the contents vary slightly . The sleeping bag is THE BIG BLOW .
aircraft is flying . This equipment is inspected replaced by a dinghy and the pilot is required to
by technicians at regular intervals with close wear a Mae West, self-inflating life jacket over
attention being paid to the length of time a his immersion suit . On a routine flight from Quebec to Ottawa, a
regulator is in service . Also, the oxygen While every precaution has been taken to Dakota aircraft was cleared to land off a right
supply ia replenisiled immediately after each provide equipment for survival in the event of hand base behind a DC8 which was on a long final
flight, with precautions taken against the pre- an emergency, the use of the equipment is in for r/w 3l at Uplands . The DC8 was on an
sence of dirt, grease or fuel . the hands of the aircrew . If' you don't know all unknowm frequency and the Dakota was on 126 . 2 .
A 'bail-out bottle' is installed in the cockpit about the emergency equipment, see your Safety The DC8 was given landing clearance by the
for uae in case of an emergency in the main Equipment section and get the informationfirst tower and unknowm to the pilot of the Dakota,
system . It supplies sufficient oxygen for a hand . Your emergency pack is not a surprise was on a touch and go procedure . The Dakota
fast descent to safe altitude or for use in case package, know what's in it, and how to use it . was from 1-1 /Z to Z miles behind the DC8 when (This particular case was investigated and
of an emergency ejection at high altitudes . approaching the end of the runway for round the tape recording of the tower transmission
If an emergency should occur inthe air, the was played back . The actual transmission from
out . Turbulence was anticipated and the dis-
seat in which the pilot spends his airborne the tower to the llC8 was as follows : quote
tance allowed was considered ample for safety .
hours enables him to escape safely at high At about Z00-300 feet severe turbulence was "802--cleared to land 3Z--gear down and
speeds . The seat is ejected by a cartridge- encountered and the Dakota was thrown about locked--touch and go" unquote . The pilot of the
operated gun which lifts both seat and pilot violently making control extremely difficult . Dakota heard the "clear to land" and then ig-
clear of the aircraft, An automatic mechanism Flaps and undercarriage were retracted by the nored the balance of the message .
separates them and opens the parachute for a co-pilot and emergency power was applied by This happens too often . When we are anti-
safe descent . Provision is made for automatic the captain . There was no need to pull off the cipating a transmission and we know what is
operation of radio equipment on ejection . side of the turbulence as the turbulence literally coming up we hear the first part of the message
The parachute, which has carried thousands threw the aircraft violently in this direction . and then close our ears to the rest of it . This
of aviators to safety, has been developed into The Dakota completed the overshoot without is a natural action w~hen wre are busy in the
an efficient, compact unit . It is issued to air- further complications . cockpit preparing to land . But natural or not
crews as part of their personal flying gear,
ln the form of recommendation it is con- we must guard against this tendency .
and it must be turned in to the Safety Equip- s idered that the distance allowed behind a large (The problem of turbulence be}iind a multi-
ment section periodically . jet aircraft in the landing pattern should be in- jet engine aircraft on full power is a serious
Everytwo months the chute is released from creased commensurate with safety to allowfor one . In this case at 1-1/L to 2 miles the tur-
the pack for inspection and hung in a three- the jetwash and airframe turbulence causedby bulence was sufficient to throw the aircraft
story drying room from the apex until all these aircraft . out of the wake of the jet engines of the aircraft.
creases have fallen out . The drying usually It is also considered that the controlling If you are following a jet in the landing pattern
takes from ll to Z4 hours . Then, deft handa agency should inform the No .2 aircraft on keep your eyes and your ears open, and if you
fold the billowing yards of silk into a compact landing of the intentions of the jet aircraft, when are in doubt about the intentions of the jet pilot
unit ready to open in an instant should it ever the two aircraft are on different frequencies . confirm with the tower . -ED)
be needed .
r
the person's hearing mechanism . muffs, fitted with liquid-filled ear seals, must
Studies made on the hearing acuity of several be handled carefully . These earmuffs, unlike
groups of aircraft maintenance workers have previously used kapok-filled ear buns, are
shown a slgnificant number of marked per- designed to provide ear protection and at the
manent hearing losses . Similarly, significant same time make possible better perception of
il
MAINTENANCE
i ~~~
1
Par aph rasmg an old refram, " why is it so " sonnel gamed experience on the new types . as serviceable-and then fastens an inspection
that the maintenance errors which cause flying F3ut this has not proved to be t}te case . The panel so poorly that it is torn off on the next
accidents follow the same pattern month after complexity of the new equipment has not been flight . (Depending on her humor that day,
month? responsible for the increase in the number of Lady Luck may write off not just a panel, but
In the past fe~c years ne~~ and complex maintenance caused accidents . Themain error an aircraft and cre«~ as well . )
aircraft in increasing numbers have been today is the same type of error that was made Accidents of this type would not happen if
introduced into the service . It would be under- in the days of the Tiger Moth . the technicians responsible paid more attention
standable, if not excusable, if it could be said There }~as also been a rapid expansion of the to the little things . As they say in the popular
that unfamiliarity with this equipment was the RCAF itself, combined ~a~ith an increased flying song, "Little Things Mean a Lot"-particularly
major cause of maintenance type accidents . commitment, both of which have necessitated a when applied to aircraft accidents . As a matter
We could then anticipate a reduction in the shortening of the training program for trades- of fact they mean the difference between a main-
number of these accidents as technical per- men and a reduction in the number of exper- tenance accident rate which we now consider
ienced personnel allocated to each of the flights . too high and one which could be reduced, with
From a flight safety point of view such a con- a little care, to a negligible level .
dition is most undesirable and it was expected That the problem is a serious one we all
thatan increase inmaintenance accidents would agree ; but at present we are at a loss as to the
be the unfortunate result . Again this was not solution . Perhaps the cause is lack of super-
the case, and we think it only appropriate that vision ; but «~hether this is due to an insufficient
credit should be given to the tremendous job number of supervisory personnel or to a super-
done by maintenance personnel since, in any fluitv. of PPa er work ~,vhich kee P s them desk-
program of expansion, it is they who carry the bound, we do notknow. Whatever the immediate
major burden . cause, the end result is the same . That direct
Why, then, do we say that these facts have supervision of work which ensures that the little
not contributed to the increasing maintenance things will not be neglected, is lost .
accident rate? The reason is that the major A certain amount of paper work is a neces-
cause of maintenance accidents has been and sary adjunct to administration in a modernAir
continues to be commission of those basic Force ; however, we feel that, for junior super-
errors which a tradesman is taught to avoid in visors particularly, it must be reduced to the
his very first lessons at technical training bare minimum . Personnel should spend a
school : over-torquing of bolts ; failure to maximum amount of time on the floor-super-
properly secure a connection ; failure to cor- vising . Paper work will increase from floor
11 13
"
DFS LIBRARY
UBRARY COPY-this
A uh rnust be returned .
NOSEWHEEL COLLAPSE
14
IN OTHER WORDS
HANDLE WITH CARE
Irrii~als
power vs hurnidity and power vs ingested rain may become intolerable because of their drag After a walk-around check and a normal
for various breeds of engines, The piston jobs effect which, as you know, increases as the flight the aircraft was landed at St Hubert,
really lose out with either an increase in hum- square of the speed, where itwas discovered thatthe centre section
idity or rain . The turbo jet and prop jet on the The amount of drag produced by a small flap jack had passed through the flap at the
~ind
other hand get a real kick out of moisture, projection or dent is yix timey greater at 500 rear trunnion, There were no L14 entries to
mph than it is at 200 mph, Increa~ed drag indicate that the flap had been lowered since
Graphs by Mr, Sydney Berman, requireti proportional increasey in thrust, the last PI, and the case was assessed against
DFSR Norton A.F .B . therefore, increased fuel consumption and maintenance, unit unknown,
decreased range,
Dcpartu~~es
As an interesting sidelight to this case,
It willbe essential thatall door gapy, 5eals, some circumstantial E:vidence came to light in
air leakages, aerodynamic ~moothers, drain the nature of a conversation overheard in
tubes, and cowling fits be maintained 5trictly Bagotvillf:, An airman was heard to be ad-
in accordance withthc~ best aerodynamic stand- monished for not lowerin g the batter Y of a
~OW~R VS HUMIDITY
i ards, Allowina drag build-up to continue particular CF 100, He claimed he had per-
i i unchecked wi11 inerea~e operating eo~t .~ signi-
i i i formed the duty but was advised he had done it
I~ Iw ficantly, to the wrong CF100, The CF100 that suffered
TURBINE
Im USN: Approach
100 ~~ I N~~~~~~~
the accident wati at Bagotville when this ha -
i p
i~ i~ pened,
IQ I"
a I~ IQ Fortunately, DFS doe~n't assess cases on
I~
~ 95 i] hc~arsay evidence, therefore, it remains rnain-
d 1 ~ R ix
a
I `~ ~ W tenance, unit unknown,
c
I a IF
I ~
~a
PRACTICE IFR
9U _. . __
i z ja ~a
a I ~~
I ~ I ~~ I
I~ I° I
i Follow IFR Procedures Even When Operat-
oi oz 03 ing VFR-You don't have to follow IFR pro-
HUMIDITY i~BS LBS AIR
POWER VS INGESTED RAIN cedure5 if you are conducting VFR operationy,
but you cannot maintain instrument proficiency
without practicing at every opportunity, Use
all the navigational aids available and make
accurate position report_-,
USN : Approach
16
17
seizing was most likely to be an internal fail-
ure of the crank shaft, or some other internal F.O . D .
failure that stopped the crank shaftfrom turning
A Dakota was being air tested after a star-
very suddenly, When an engine fails there is a
~~,^';,; ~'. .a _ ~ ir tremendous force acting on the propeller that
board engine change, The engine checked OK
,~L, , on ground run, butafter takeoff vibrated badly,
keeps the engine wind-milling, When the pro-
A check of the ignition analyser revealed that
peller comes to a yudden stop and does not
the No,3 cylinder rear spark plug was not
wind-mill it follow5 that there is a tremendous
firing, Power was reduced but the vibration
force acting on the crank shaft to prevent the
persisted, The engine was heard to back-fire
propeller from turning,
and the aircraft was returned to base .
After suffering an engine failure under these
On inspection, the ~park plug and pi5ton of
conditions ar~d being fortunate enough to get the
WHAT PRICE CO-OPERATION? engineto feather, itis extremely poor airman- the No,3 cylinder were found to be damaged
apparently by a piece of metal (foreign object)
CIVILIAN CONTRACTOR
ship to try to re7tart the engine, '
of undetermined size and origin which had After a Functional Flight Test by the con-
An expeditor became completely encased in It must be realized that an internal failure
been c-jected through the exhaust port of No,3 tractor and while on the landing run, one engine
ice from freezing rain following an over-night sufficient to cau5e an engine seizure is apt to
cylinder before the subsequent dismantling, was Seen to be smoking badly, After shutdown
stop at a civilian airfield . break oil lines and cause a complete los5 of
Because of a loo5e spark plug insert on it was discovered that the power recovery tur-
During the de-icing operation, prior to de- oil, Because the engine would feather in the
No,9 cylinder, thi~ engine had been UCR~d bine had failed, Further investigation revealed
parture, the supply of de-icing fluid was first place doe5 not mean that it would feather
on receipt from the manufacturer, and No,9 a bag of moisture ab5orbing material had been
exhau~ted, The crew re5orted to manually a second time, If the second attemptat feather-
cylinder was replaced before the engine was left in the cooling ducts and had been drawn
chipping off the ice, They were assisted in ing was not successful the drag cau5ed by the
installed on the aircraft, into the PRT,
this operation by a USAF crew from a C47, unfeathered P ropeller is ~ufficient to make an
How a foreign object could get into the No,3 Apparently the contractor has been placing
The captain of the Expeditor departed from Expeditor unflyable on a single engine, This
cylinder, or for that matter any cylinder, of these bags in the PRT hood and cooling ducts
the scene briefly to try and locate a Herman crew was extrernely lucky,
a newly overhauled engine, is hard to under- for years, removing them before fhght, this
Nelson heater to de-ice the g1a5 .5 surfaces .
stand, The fact remain~, however, that it was one, however, wa~ mi~~ed on preflight ins-
On return he found several windows cracked
the _re, pe ction,
and broken due to one of the USAF crew chip-
A contributory factor, (and this might sound
ping at the ice on the glatis with a rubber en-
familiar to some) was the ab5ence of streamers
cased aluminum pipe,
or strings on this particular bag, Suffice to
The total cost of the repair 5 nece ~ 5ary,
~ay, that an amendment to their Functional
including~ixreplacementwindows, was roughly
,~-~_~, Flight Test Procedure appeared almo5t im-
$475 .00 .
mediately following the incident,
w +
propeller had unfeathered it did not move, ~o was maintained and a slow turn was made back
he tried to crank the engine with the starter, to the airfield whc~re a succes~,fu1 single-en-
The propeller still did not move so the engine gined landing was carried out,
wa~ refeathered, The aircraft was landed This engine failure, suspected to be a CSU
yafely . failure, oecurred at a most critical point
This case is worth a second look, It is during takeoff, but by knowing and applying
obvious that the pilot of the aircraft did not the correct procedures the pilot turned an
recognize the fact that when the propeller emergency into a routine single-engined land-
stopped before feathering action was taken ing_
that the engine had seized . The temperature Could you cope under similar conditions?
and pres5ure5 werc~ indicating normal before How would you make out if it happened on your
seizing, therefore, the reason for the engine next takeoff?
18 19
equipment, with a total weight of 30 pounds, the main entrance on the port side, forward of
into a C119, The three airmen loaded the six the propeller, This Order had been issued
boxes on the fork lift and proceeded tothe air- because aircraft were bc~ing damaged by fork
craft that was parked on the tarmac where the lif t s working in the cramped area between the
pallet was loaded through the port paratroop booms and the fuselage, Inthis case the Order
door, A~ the tran~ tech group 3 started to tie was contravened,
down the boxes of freight, he noticed that he During the investigation the driver of the
was going to run outof tie down material so he fork lift was asked if he had a DND 404, He
a~ked one of the airrl~t n, who was on useful 5aid that he did not have one and prior to the
MAINTENANCE SUPERVISION FORK TROUBLE duty, to get somc rY~ore, We don't know how
rnuch tie down equipment i5 required for 30
accident did not know that such a thing existed,
When que~tioned a~ to how he had learned to
During a pre takeoff runup in a Neptune air- pound~ of freight but surely sufficient equip- drive the vehicle, he said that he had learned
Inthe lastyear, eight ground accidents were
craft the I~ilot noticcd a puff of ~~hite ~moke ment could have been taken to the aircraft to to drive on his own while at AIV1U, From this
caused by loading vehicles being driven into
emit from undc~r the inboard cowl flap of the finish thc job in the first place, it would appear that this airman and possibly
aircraft, The pattern has been consistent, The
port engine, The timoke persi~ted and a visual upper frame of a fork lift or similar vehicle The airman left the aircraft, climbed on others were allowed to drive the fork lift on
the fork lift which was parked by the port para- many previous occasiony,
inspection revealed a considerable oil li:ak, comes incontact with atail assembly, the wing
The enginc was shut down and the aircraft re- or the fuselage, However, something new has troop door, and backed up to the rear, He The investigation revealed a lack of proper
turnE:d to the ramp, stopped and shifted into forward gear and briefing to airn-~en who were usefully employed
been added, Recently a fork lift way driven
5tarted ahead, keeping to the port side of the at t}re unit, It also revealed lack of proper
Investigation revealed a rocker box hou5ing into the propeller of a C119,
aircraft outboard of the boom, He lowered direction and 5upervi~ion on the part of the
cover nut found directly behind No,6 cylinder Let us examine. the events that led up to this
the fork lift and was keeping a sharp lookout supervi5ory staff,
rocker box lrou5ing, The rocker box cover on accident, A loading crew were on duty at an
on the port side for a fire extingui5her which It i~ unfortunate that, inmany cases it takes
No,6 cylinder ex}rau5t rocker box hou~ing had Aw1U with an airr~~an, Trans Tech, group 2,
wa5 located at the port wing tip, The vehicle an accident to revea.l the deficiencies inan org-
fractured, and a half inch hole was found, designated as airman in charge of the crew,
collided with the port propeller, an ization, It behoove s all of us to take a long
Record .ti indicated that No,6 cylinder had Included inthe crew weretwo airmenwho were
A local Ordcr had been issued by thi5 unit searching look at our own organization to 5ee
been changed 37 flying hours prior to the in- employed onuseful dutie5 pending course . The
that all C 119 aircraft must be loaded through if herhap5 we couldn't be caught the same way,
cident and new glands had bec:n in~talled in board of investigation into thi5 accident indi-
this cylinder two days before the nut wa~ found, cated that one of the TranS TechS in the crew
It was determined that on the st~cond occa~ion was a group 3 technician, Why a group Z tech-
when the nut could have dropped behind the nician was put in eharge of a group 3 technician
cylinder, a crew change had taken place before wa~ not explained,
the work wa~ com 1~leted, This means tEiat The group 3 technician and the two air~~~t n
there «~a :~ a period of thrce hours when the were in~tructed to load six boxe ~ of AOG
work ~;~a5 left unattcnded and a rocker box
houying was r~ot covered, in othc>r words, one LIFTLESS
crew removed the rocker arm cover and
another crew reinstalled it, Major W, de Kitkat-Watney's Nieuport Scout
Since this incident, a crew is required to was extensively damaged when it failed to be-
stay onthc job until the workis completed, and come airborne .
if this is not fea5ible, the new crew iy given an ~1 The original Court of Inquiry found that the
primary cause of the accident was carelessness
overlap period of one hour, The purpose of this
_ and E~oor airmanship on the part of a very exper -
procedurc is to en~ure thatany job will not re-
- ienced pilot .
main unattended andthat n:i~understanding5 do
..~ ti ~ ~. 'I'he Commandant C~eneral, not being wholly
not arise with regard to the work remaining,
\ convinced that Major W, de K-Watney could be
il guilty of so culpable a mistake, ordered that
lll
. . . ; : . . .- . . . . " ~ . . ~ . ;- .- . . . _ _ , 1SP the Court should be reconvened,
. . .. . . . . . . . . : .: After extensive inquiries and lengthy dis-
.
cussions with the Meteorological Officc:r and
. . ._., :, ., , " ~ . . : . . . : :,~i~-
9 ~~u Astronomer Royal, the court carne to the
conclusion that the pilot unfortunately was
authorized to fly his aircraft on a day when
REDUCE COMMUNICATIONS t.here was absolutely no liftinthe air and could
not be held responsible for the accicient,
~,,l~r,, We extend our congratulations to Major
Tower Controllers (in this instance, at
W, de Kitkat-Watney on his reprieve and also
C hicago Midway Airport~ report that pilots
on his engagementtothe CommandantGeneral's
can help reduce communicationti on approach
daughter which was announced shortly before
control by advi~ing on th~ir initial contact,
the accident,-Flight Safety, RAAF, Refer-
that ti~ey have wind and runway data, (Some
ence Summary of Aircraft Accidents July 1917,
refer to these as "the numbers" ,either is
okay,~ This procedure would be appreciated
by tower operators in all high-den~ity area .~,
USN ; Approach
20
21
D F S LIBR ARY was moving, The pilot instantly assumed a
forward movement and selected some reverse
LIBRARY COPY " thi~ thrust, A quick visual check revealed that the
22 23
BIRD WRTCNERS'CORNEB
FLIGHT
COMMENT
ISSUED BY
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR D1REC1'OR :1TE Uh PI,IGII'1' S :1FFT~'
R .C .A .F . HEADQUARTERS " OTTAWA " CANADA
Dear Sir
luly " August 1961
Your photograph on the inside cover of the
Mar-Ahr 61 issue of Flight Comment is mo~t
eye catching and timely . Editorial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
flowever, it i .ti to be trusted that readers
Are You Taking to The Water? . . . . . . . . 2
r~~
will not be lulled into a false sense of security
that the mere in :~ertion of double chocks will Good Show . . . . . . 5
miraculously preclude aircraft movement .
Ithas oeen long recognized that our aircraft Are You Sure Of Your Altitude? . . . . . 6
chocks do not grip firmly, if at all, on con-
crete or ice sur£aces, In fact "biting" of the All The Help You Need . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
i ;.
;ei,w~
tire on the inner edge of the chock iy a must
to ensure ~etting of the chock points into the Near Miss . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
terrain or surface .
Instance5 canbe cited withinthe pa5t couple Protection From Noise . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
of years where aireraft, double chocked as
Maintenance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
your photo shows, have rolled con~iderable
distance~ pu~,hing the chock, with the wheels, 14
Nosewheel Collapse . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
When double chocking against climatic con-
ditions it is mo5t e~~ential that the chock5 be Arrivals and Departures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
properly placed and firmly la~hed together, on
either ~ide of the wheels, in a manner which Thrust 'n' Parry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , , 24
~i~ ~
will reduce wheel rotation and the accompany-
ing chock 5kidding to the minimum, Ediior-in-Chief Squ3dron Leader G . L . Sheahan
i~
OFFICIAL INFORMATION-The printinq of this pub-
BLACK ALERT lication has baen approved by the Minister, Department of
National Defence . Contributions are weleome, as are comment
and criticism . Address all correspondence to the Editor, Flight
THE
An unusual incident recently occurred in Comment, Directoraie of Flighi Safety, ftCAF Headquarters,
Otiawa 9, Ontario . The Editor reserves the riqht to make any
which a ~tarling flew into a hangar with a chanqes in the manuscript which he believes will improve the
lighted cigarette butt in it~ beak, then droppE:d material without alterinq the intended meaninq . Service oryani-
zations may reprihl articles irom Flight Comment withoul further
THRESKIORNI~ ~
the lighted butt on the hangar floor (no doubt authorization . Non-Service organizations must obtain official
in writing from ACAF Headquarters before re-
startled by the no-tirnoking signs), pennission
priniinq any of the contents of this publicalion . The opinioris
Thiti incident could have been ~erious, had expressed in Flight Comment are the personal views of con-
AETHIOPICA
tributing writers ; they do not necessarily reflect the official
the lighted cigarc:tte fallen into something
opinion of the Aoyal Canadian Air Force . Unless otherwise
flammable . All personr.el of the 5quadron stated, contents should not be construed as requlations, orders or
concerned have been rebriefed on the import- di-rectives .
RoceR DVHA~L, F.R .S .(' ., Queen's Printer and Controller of Stationery, Ottawa, 1961 OHECKTHEEOCARRYOUTA2JCHECKTHEEOCARRYOUTA2J
tUK SAFETY'S SAKE LOCK YOUR
PARACHUTE Q .R. BOX I DFS LIB RARY
LIBRARY COPY-this
Pub must be returned .
INSERT POSITION
jo
"
TO UNLOCK