Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bonini 2021
Bonini 2021
review-article2021
EJO0010.1177/11206721211024827European Journal of OphthalmologyBonini
EJO European
Journal of
Ophthalmology
Review
Stefano Bonini
Abstract
The red eye is one of the most common cause encountered in ophthalmic practice but a red eye is not always related
to eye diseases, instead, it may be a clinical sign of several systemic diseases which may the alarmin signal of sight-
threatening or life-threatening condition. Frequently, GPs, pediatricians, immunologists, and rheumatologists are the
first landing of patients with a “red eye.” This paper is addressed to non-ophthalmic specialists who may be faced with
patients having a red eye. Inspection of the external eye under standard office lighting or with a bright light can be easily
and accurately made by a general practitioner. Three major caveats should alert the GPs to promptly refer the patient
to the ophthalmologist: the presence of pain; the loss of the natural corneal transparency and specular reflex; and any
patient-described reduction of visual acuity. In most cases, a red eye is due to occasional and mild ocular surface reaction
as consequence of exposure of the external eye to irritants and naturally occurring environmental agents. In these
cases washing the eye with a tear lubricant may help in relief of symptoms. If this treatment fails within a few days, a
consultation with an ophthalmologist is suggested. The role of the general physician is crucial in the decision making to
judge the severity of the ocular condition. Managing a red eye often requires the support of other specialists. Our goal
is not only to preserve vision but to globally cure the patient health.
Keywords
Acanthamoeba keratitis, bacterial keratitis, cornea stem cell, diseases of the ocular surface, diseases of the ocular
surface: exposure keratopathy, immune disease of the cornea, immune disease of conjunctiva, viral keratitis, tear
deficiency states
cases, a foreign body may be present, and this can be read- bulbar conjunctivas. In these cases, washing the eye with
ily detected by inspection with the aid of a bright light. a lubricant or, after topical anesthesia, removal of any for-
In other cases, a red eye may be the alarming sign of eign body has an immediate effect in the relief of all signs
more severe and sight-threatening conditions.6 The diag- and symptoms.
nosis to identify the several etiologic factors that can be The presence of a partial or massive subconjunctival
responsible for the red eye requires a brief but targeted hemorrhage may alarm the patient to promptly consult the
systematic approach to determine the timing of onset, uni- ophthalmologist. These subconjunctival lesions are gener-
lateral or bilateral involvement, acute or chronic/relapsing ally limited in size, well circumscribed, do not affect the
onset, and the presence of other symptoms such as pain cornea, and they do not cause a reduction of the visual
or photophobia. The previous or concomitant use of other function (Table 1). Natural and occasional subconjunc-
topical or systemic medications and the ocular response tival hemorrhages may follow any Valsalva maneuver,
to previous ocular treatment may be helpful to clarify for example, coughing, vomiting, or strenuous exercise.
the diagnostic dilemma. In contrast, the presence of pain, Repeated and non-traumatic subconjunctival hemorrhage
blurred vision, and corneal opacities may indicate the pres- should be considered as a sign of systemic hypertension,
ence of a more severe sight-threating disease (Table 1). vascular diseases such as diabetes, or the effects of antico-
agulative agents.
Acute red eye due to ocular surface Exposure to solar radiation may affect the conjunctiva
and the cornea, causing a painful superficial punctate kera-
disease titis (SPK), that can also occur in cases with high reflection
Although every clinical disease of the external eye is still from surfaces like snow (Table 1). SPK is also common
named with the anatomical tissue most affected, for exam- in occupational eye injuries that can occur in unprotected
ple, conjunctivitis, keratitis, etc., it is now well accepted workers exposed to artificial UV light. Topical lubricants
that in every external eye disease all of the anatomical may alleviate symptoms that can persist for few days until
components of the ocular surface, that is, the cornea, the complete corneal healing occurs.
tear film, the lacrimal glands, the lids, and the commensal A red eye can be a typical sign of infectious and
flora, participate at the same time in response to any infec- non-infectious conjunctivitis that each requires differ-
tious or inflammatory process. Other systems, such as the ent therapeutic approaches once the etiology has been
neuro-immune-endocrine systems, may be influenced as defined (Figure 1). Permission to publish their images
well at a site distant from the ocular response.7,8 was obtained from each patient. Infective conjunctivitis,
An acute unilateral red eye may be the result of occa- either bacterial or viral, may have an acute onset starting
sional irritating external agents such as dust, wind, or the quite often as a unilateral disease but generally involving
presence of a foreign body (Table 1). Inspection of the the contralateral eye later. Viral infections are generally
external eye under standard office lighting or with a bright more aggressive than bacterial infection, presenting with
light can be easily and accurately made by a general prac- a more intense redness, edema of the lids, ptosis, and the
titioner. It requires only the eversion of the upper lid and presence of enlarged pre-auricular lymph nodes.9 Topical
pulling down of the lower lid to check the palpebral and antibiotics are effective in hastening the resolution of
Bonini 3
Figure 1. Aspects of different types of red eyes. Acute red eye may be the result of bacterial conjunctivitis (top left) or the
expression of scleritis (top right). Red eye can be associated with the initial steps of a chronic autoimmune disease such as
pemphigoid (bottom left). It presents with corneal neovessels and fornix foreshortening (black arrow). Red eye, appearing as a pink
eye, can be an indicator of mucosal non-Hodgkin lymphoma (bottom right). Permission to publish their images was obtained from
each patient.
bacterial conjunctivitis (Figure 1, top left), a self-limited containing preservatives, antibiotics, steroids, other immu-
disease without functional complications. No effective nosuppressive agents, or other medications may be helpful
therapy exists for viral conjunctivitis, but topical steroids in relieving red eye, and other symptoms. However, the
may reduce the intense inflammation. Viral conjunctivitis persistence of symptoms or the development of new symp-
may be complicated by the development of sub-epithelial toms suggest that a more complex clinical scenario exists.
corneal infiltrates that can be responsible for blurred vision For instance, the preservatives in tear substitutes and other
and may persist for months or years. topically applied solutions can be toxic to the corneal epi-
Severe ocular inflammation of the cornea and the inter- thelial cells,10,11 and topically applied steroids can induce
nal eye may be associated with a red and painful eye. glaucoma.12 Thus the aggressive and indiscriminate use of
Almost any loss of corneal transparency can be seen in eyedrops may cause a toxic reaction in the external eye or
standard office lighting or with a bright light. Any corneal the whole eye and could be a misleading factor for clinical
lesion, either traumatic or possibly of infectious origin, diagnosis of the red eye that was initially presented. Under
should be promptly referred to an emergency ophthalmic these conditions, consultation with an ophthalmologist is
center. Corneal abrasions are generally traumatic and may needed.
follow occasional injury such as those caused by fingers Corneal epithelial lesions, due to herpes simplex virus
of a baby touching the parent’s cornea. These lesions are or herpes zoster are responsible for typical dendrites or
painful and associated with intense photophobia, but gen- geographic epithelial damages. These patients have an
erally they subside in few days. Antibiotic eyedrops and inflamed conjunctiva with lid edema, photophobia, and
topical lubricants are generally prescribed to avoid infec- blurred vision.13 Topical antivirals, following microbio-
tions of the damaged ocular surface. logic laboratory confirmation, may heal the epithelium in
As suggested above, the application of topical lubri- 1 week. However, in the worst cases, the virus or immune
cants and antibiotic eyedrops is often the most appropri- reaction caused by the virus itself may damage the under-
ate and simplest way to treat red eye. However, a short lying corneal stroma.
digression and an important caveat is warranted here Similarly, corneal ulcers due either to Acanthamoeba
regarding the use of topically applied medicines. Eyedrops species and Pseudomonas aeruginosa are associated with
4 European Journal of Ophthalmology 00(0)
a red painful eye (Table 1).14 These corneal ulcers are reactions primarily affecting the skin, but involving other
mostly seen in contact lens wearers. The patients present mucosal tissues as well. Acute ocular involvement with
with a red eye, loss of corneal transparency, pain, intense loss of visual function, neovascularization of the cornea,
photophobia, and a massive edema of the lids that makes and scarring of the ocular surface warrant a prompt refer-
the clinical examination difficult to perform. Referral to an ral to an emergency department.22
emergency ophthalmic center is mandatory, and a diagno- Acute and more intense red eye follows most chemical
sis should be established to promptly start the appropriate burns (Table 1).23,24 Prompt referral to an emergency oph-
treatment.15–18 thalmic center is needed but a prolonged washing of the
Acute non-infective red eye may be the consequence of eye is suggested as a first approach.
an allergic reaction of the external eye (Table 1). A mul-
titude of substances such as occasional contact with irri-
tants, local or systemic medication, or allergy to nickel or Relapsing or chronic red eye
food may cause a red eye. These allergies can be difficult Dry eye and ocular allergy (Table 1) represent the most
to diagnose, but they are generally self-limited and disap- common causes of relapsing or chronic red eye with a
pear in few days, even without treatment. However, if the prevalence ranging from 5% to 50% and 20% to 30%,
symptoms do not quickly subside, a definitive diagnosis is respectively.25 Dry eye is a multifactorial disease with
required, and the treatment is typically easy to achieve and ocular symptoms, tear film instability, tear hyperosmolar-
relief from the symptoms soon follows. ity, ocular surface inflammation and damage, and neuro-
sensory abnormalities.26 Keratoconjunctivitis sicca is also
Acute red eye mimicking ocular a term to indicate dry eye and frequent corneal involve-
ment in the inflammatory process. Complete and exhaust-
surface diseases ing diagnostic and treatment guidelines have been recently
A red eye may also be the result of internal eye disease published by the Tear Film and Ocular Surface Society
or the manifestation of a systemic disease that targets the (TFOS).27
external eye. These conditions are generally associated Mild to very severe and symptomatic diseases are
with mild to severe pain, blurred or marked reduction of grouped together in dry eye. In the mildest forms of dry
vision, and evident loss of the corneal transparency, all of eye and blepharitis, the use of tear substitutes together with
which require prompt referral to an ophthalmic emergency lid hygiene may be useful to relieve symptoms. Dry eye is
center. also one of the main criteria to diagnose other systemic
Inflammation of the anterior uvea (Table 1), the inter- diseases such as Sjogren syndrome (Table 1) and other
nal membrane of the eye, and more specifically of the iris autoimmune diseases associated with red eye.28,29 These
and ciliary body, may be caused by a variety of ocular and conditions represent a more symptomatic and disabling
systemic diseases. In these patients, the painful red eye is disease for the patients and require a more aggressive and
accompanied by visual blurring and photophobia. Clinical multi-disciplinary treatment with topical or systemic ster-
inflammation of the anterior chamber, which lies posterior oids and immunosuppressive agents.27 Acute allergic con-
to the corneal endothelium, requires examination by slit- junctivitis (Table 1), either seasonal or perennial, causes a
lamp microscopy. However with a bright light, the physi- recurrent or chronic red eye following contact with a sen-
cian can see a pupillary restriction (miosis), which is an sitizing allergen.30 In these cases, the seasonal recurrences
expression of inflammation of the anterior uvea. or the history of previous or concomitant allergic diseases
Acute glaucoma (Table 1) due to a sudden increase such as asthma, rhinitis, or atopic dermatitis may help in
of the intraocular pressure also causes a red and pain- the differential diagnosis. Artificial tears or antiallergy
ful eye. The intraocular pressure, which normally ranges eyedrops may control the clinical symptoms.
between 10 and 21 mmHg, may rise to 70 mmHg with In contrast to acute allergic conjunctivitis, ocular aller-
this condition.19 The patients may also have pupillary gies with seasonal relapses or chronic progression, such
dilation (mydriasis) in the affected eye, and nausea and as vernal kerato-conjunctivitis (VKC) and atopic kerato-
vomiting may be associated with diffuse but intense pain conjunctivitis (AKC), represent a major challenge for oph-
in the periorbital area. thalmologists. VKC (Table 1) is an allergic inflammation
An eye that has a red-to-purple appearance along of the ocular surface generally affecting young boys in
with pain and visual blurring may be the sign of a scleri- their first decade of life. All of the anatomical structures
tis (Table 1; Figure 1, top right). These ocular conditions of the ocular surface participate in this allergic inflam-
need prompt referral because scleritis may be prodromic or mation. The conjunctiva becomes red and chemotic, the
associated with a systemic or lethal disease, for example, cornea develops a superficial punctate keratitis or even
rheumatoid arthritis or Wegener’s granulomatosis.20,21 corneal ulcer, the palpebral conjunctiva of the upper lid
Stevens-Johnson syndrome and Lyell syndrome acquires a characteristic cobblestone appearance, and the
(Table 1) are severe, acute, and dramatic adverse drug tear film has increased levels of inflammatory mediators
Bonini 5
and cytokines. The disease subsides after puberty, gener- that is unresponsive to topical therapy (Figure 1, bottom
ally without ocular consequences. However, it may require left).40–42 Aggressive systemic immunosuppressive agents
aggressive treatment for the relief of symptoms and atten- can prevent the progression of these potentially blinding
tion to avoid complications for prolonged use of topical diseases.43
steroids.31,32 Any chronic or acute red eye requires attention by a
AKC (Table 1) is generally associated with atopic general practitioner and/or pediatrician because the eye
dermatitis and occurs in the first years of life or in adults may be the target of mucosal lymphoma (Table 1; Figure
50 years of age or older.33 In AKC, similar to VKC, cor- 1, bottom right). The presence of an asymptomatic,
neal complications may cause permanent reduction of chronic pink-to-red eye with conjunctival hyperplasia and
the visual function. Topical tear substitutes or antiallergic that is unresponsive to conventional eyedrops should alert
nonsteroidal eyedrops may control the intense itching and the physician of a potentially serious condition associated
photophobia. However, both VKC and AKC often require with the mucosal-associated lymphoid tissue (MALT).44 A
the use of topical steroids or immunosuppressive agents, brief but specific history should be requested before any
for example, cyclosporine or tacrolimus, during the severe other action is taken. In addition to the presence of a red or
recrudescence of the disease.33–35 pink eye and information gained through the patient his-
Mild to severe red eye can be difficult to diagnose tory, the loss of the natural corneal transparency and spec-
because it may be related to a multitude of constitutional ular reflex, the presence of pain, and any patient-described
and mechanical factors that require careful anamnestic reduction of visual acuity suggests a more complicated
investigations. For instance, a unilateral red eye that is etiology and indicates that a prompt referral to an ophthal-
unresponsive to medical treatments is often due to floppy mologist is necessary.
eyelid syndrome.36 This condition is generally unilateral The diagnosis of a red eye is generally clinical but a
and has been described in obese people that lose body careful history together with an accurate slit lamp exami-
weight too quickly. The physical contact of the upper lid nation is required to understand the etiology of this clinical
with the pillow while sleeping may evert the lid, leav- sign. In addition, and mainly for scientific purposes, grad-
ing open the inferior part of the ocular surface. As con- ing scales of ocular hyperemia or its digital version, may
sequence, the external eye, that is, the conjunctiva and be helpful to quantify the intensity of clinical redness, to
cornea, are exposed at night. Thus, conjunctival redness, share a common language among clinical scientists and in
corneal epithelial damage, and tearing are the typical signs monitoring the progression of ocular surface changes.45,46
when these patients wake up in the morning. Closing the In summary, managing a red eye can be a difficult task,
eye with a tape for few days may confirm the diagnosis and even for ophthalmologists. The role of the general physi-
reduce the intensity of the ocular surface inflammation. cian is crucial in the decision making to judge the severity
Hormonal imbalance and the presence of polycystic of the ocular condition. If the patient refers pain or reduc-
ovary syndrome in young women may cause red eye and tion of visual acuity, a consultation with an eye doctor is
symptoms that can be confused with dry eye and/or ocular suggested. In cases of mild and occasional occurrence of
allergy.37 Filaments of mucus and intolerance to contact red eye, additional information may indicate to the phy-
lenses are common findings. Although the pathogenesis is sician if the nature of the red eye is infective, allergic,
still not defined, the treatment of any hormonal imbalances or related to dry eye. In these cases, temporary relief of
may help in the resolution of the disease. symptoms may be achieved with antibiotic eyedrops, mild
Mild but persistent conjunctival infection, for example, antiallergics, or ocular lubricants. If this treatment fails
chlamydia and others, can be unresponsive to topical treat- within a few days, a consultation with an ophthalmologist
ment and can be responsible for red eye.38 Specific micro- is suggested. Diagnosing and managing a chronic and/or
biologic tests are suggested for resistant and symptomatic recurring red eye can be especially challenging and often
young patients that require systemic antibiotic treatment. requires the support of other specialists such as rheumatol-
A chronic red eye may also be the result of anti-glau- ogists, dermatologists, immunologists, and pediatricians.
coma medication or the effects of preservatives in topi- We should always be reminded that our goal is not only to
cal treatments applied to the ocular surface.11 Alternative cure the eye, but also the patient.
treatment or the suspension of any topical therapy some-
times improves the redness of the eye. Unpreserved eye- Acknowledgement
drops should always be used when available. The author thanks Dr. Britt Bromberg at Xenofile Editing (https://
Any long standing ocular surface inflammation may xenofileediting.com) for his skillful editorial assistance
cause fibrosis and evolve to cicatricial conjunctivitis with
complete anatomical and functional alteration of the ocu- Declaration of conflicting interests
lar surface.39 This is particularly evident in some ocular The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with
autoimmune diseases such as ocular cicatricial pemphi- respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this
goid (Table 1) or corneal ulcer of autoimmune origin article.
6 European Journal of Ophthalmology 00(0)
39. Ong HS, Minassian D, Rauz S, et al. Validation of a clini- 43. Queisi MM, Zein M, Lamba N, et al. Update on ocular
cal assessment tool for cicatrising conjunctivitis. Ocul Surf cicatricial pemphigoid and emerging treatments. Surv
2020; 18: 121–129. Ophthalmol 2016; 61: 314–317.
40. Ong HS, Setterfield JF, Minassian DC, et al.; Mucous 44. Hindso TG, Esmaeli B, Holm F, et al. International mul-
Membrane Pemphigoid Study Group. Mucous membrane ticentre retrospective cohort study of ocular adnexal mar-
pemphigoid with ocular involvement: the clinical pheno- ginal zone B-cell lymphoma. Br J Ophthalmol 2020; 104:
type and its relationship to direct immunofluorescence find- 357–362.
ings. Ophthalmology 2018; 125: 496–504. 45. Vianya-Estopa M, Nagra M, Cochrane A, et al. Optimising
41. Ahmed M, Zein G, Khawaja F, et al. Ocular cicatricial pem- subjective anterior eye grading precision. Cont Lens
phigoid: pathogenesis, diagnosis and treatment. Prog Retin Anterior Eye 2020; 43(5): 489–492.
Eye Res 2004; 23: 579–592. 46. Efron N, Morgan PB and Jagpal R. Validation of computer
42. Dart JK. The 2016 Bowman Lecture Conjunctival curses: scar- morphs for grading contact lens complications. Ophthalmic
ring conjunctivitis 30 years on. Eye (Lond) 2017; 31: 301–332. Physiol Opt 2002; 22(4): 341–349.