Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RIT Design Recommendations
RIT Design Recommendations
IAC-04-S.4.04
DEVELOPMENT OF RIT-MICROTRHUSTERS
Horst W. Loeb, K.-H. Schartner, St. Weis, D. Feili, and B.K. Meyer
1st Institute of Physics, Giessen University, Germany
Davar.Feili@exp1.physik.uni-giessen.de
Karl-Heinz.Schartner@exp1.physik.uni-giessen.de
ABSTRACT
The electric propulsion activities of Giessen University were focussed first on a 10-cm rf-ion thruster RIT-10
and lateron on scaled-up engines with 15, 20, 22, 26, and 35 cm of ionizer diameter.
Downloaded by RYERSON UNIVERSITY on January 29, 2018 | http://arc.aiaa.org | DOI: 10.2514/6.IAC-04-S.4.04
As recent secondary propulsion applications need EP-thrust levels of less than 1 mN, Giessen University
started a scaling-down program of its RIT-family towards 1 to 4 cm diameter aggregates.
In this procedure all design parameters and materials of the larger engines were adopted. This holds for the
ionizer/xenon-injection system, the neutralizer, and especially to the grid system which is unchanged with
respect to the material (carbon composite), the grid thicknesses and the interspace, the beamlet holes
(1.9 and 1.2 mm of diameters), and the grid voltages (+1.2 kV and -300 V).
The optimization concentrates on the geometry of the rf-ionizer and its working parameters. Established
scaling laws suggest that the rf-frequency and the discharge pressure should increase inversely proportional
to the ionizer radius R. The optimum ionizer length scales with (2R)0.66. Due to the increasing surface-to-
volume-ratio of the discharge vessel, the scaling down will require increased ion production costs and
specific power data.
Based on the well-known RIT-10 performance data and the scaling laws, the scheduled data of RIT-1, RIT-2,
RIT-3, and RIT-4 are presented.
For verification, a 4-cm diam rf-thruster has been designed and built and is now under testing in a new
2.2 m3 vacuum facility which is equipped with a 12,000 ltr/s cryopump (Xenon). A thrusting range of 250 µN
to 2,5 mN is envisaged at 33 W/mN, 67 % of power efficiency, and 73 % of propellant efficiency. As the
second scaling-down step, a 2.3-cm diam microthruster (with 100 µN to 1 mN of thrust) is just being
manufactured at Giessen University.
The new Giessen effort will benefit from the fact that among the class of gas-discharge ion microthrusters,
the rf-type seems to be most favourable because no discharge electrodes, magnetic pole shoes, etc. must
be installed inside the ionizer vessel and especially because of its excellent controllability by regulating gas
flow, rf-power, and voltage separately.
1
55th International Astronautical Congress 2004 - Vancouver, Canada
engines with less than 100 µN up to only a few technique enable the design of promising
micronewtons. Attractive applications of this microengines with ionizer diameters between 1
mission class are accurate drag-free operations, and 4 cm.
the fine-pointing attitude control, and the For testing, a new EP-vaccum facility wit 2.2 m3
controlled formation flying of spacecraft fleets. of chamber volume has been put in operation.
Several coming ESA missions like GOCE, At present similar acitivities at the Pennsylvania
SMART-2, MICROSCOPE, GAIA, LISA, and State University are reported.6
IRSI-Darwin will benefit from EP-microthrusters.1
Additional EP-applications could be spacecraft 2. Characteristics and Potentialities
discharging, changing of spin rate, East-West- of Rf-Microthrusters
Stationkeeping, etc.
The advantages of miniature EP-thrusters over 2.1. RIT Components
the competitive chemical systems are their
excellent controllability and mass savings at long- RIT-type engines have been repeatedly
term missions owing to the higher specific described (see e.g. Ref. 7 and 8) and will be
Downloaded by RYERSON UNIVERSITY on January 29, 2018 | http://arc.aiaa.org | DOI: 10.2514/6.IAC-04-S.4.04
2
55th International Astronautical Congress 2004 - Vancouver, Canada
2.2. RIT Advantages Fig.1: View of the holder grids of some rf-
microthrusters. Each of the N beamlet holes
Within the class of gas-discharge electric is 1.9 mm in diam. Assuming a constant ion
thrusters, the rf-type seems to be the most current density per hole and a constant
suitable for scaling-down, because it works voltage U = +1.2 kV, the thrust F can be
without any discharge electrodes, magnetic pole calculated.
shoes, etc. inside the ionizer.
Besides the standard cylindrical vessel, the rf- Compared with the actual microthrusters like
ionizer can even be shaped with a rectangular FEEP, the possibility to utilize the inert gas
cross-section if desired (see Fig. 1). Xenon, the operation at voltages around 1 kV and
Corresponding R & D work with hydrogen the insensitivity to backstreaming electrons are
sources proved the successful operation.9Another favourable.
advantage of the rf-discharge with inductive
coupling is the high electron temperature Te near
the discharge vessel walls being the
consequence of the induction law, i.e. the
induced electrical field strength Eind(r) (see Fig.
2).8 Together with the plasma density n, which
decreases towards the walls due to the ambipolar
diffusion, the extractable ion current profile
ji ( r ) ~ n Te is rather flat. This enables to drill
the beamlet holes in the grid system close to the
ionizer walls.
Experiments should show whether more, i.e. also
peripheral extraction holes could be used than
considered conservatively in Fig. 1 for the RIT-
microthrusters.)
Other advantages of the rf-type are its excellent Fig. 2: Experimental discharge parameters of a
regulation by varying gas flow, rf-power, and 10-cm rf-ion source in their radial variation.
extraction voltages independently and the long The n- and Te-data have been obtained by
lifetime due to the absence of discharge double Langmuir probes averaged over many
electrodes. test runs.8
3
55th International Astronautical Congress 2004 - Vancouver, Canada
3. Optimization of the Ionizer i.e. lopt, increases with decreasing atomic weight
of RF-Microthrusters of the propellant.8*)
On the other hand, the discharge vessel length
3.1. Discharge Parameters should be as short as possible to minimize the
plasma recombination losses on the ionizer wall.
The induced electric field Eind (see Fig. 2) is not
strong enough to accelerate the discharge Fig. 3 shows the three optimum discharge
electrons during a single half rf-period up to parameters (lopt, νopt, popt) calculated by Equs. 1
energies which enable them to ionize. However, if and 2 with the carefully investigated RIT-10
the electrons suffer elastic collisions with ionizer as the reference.
(approximately) 180-deg. turns just when the E-
field direction reverses, an energy accumulation
takes place.
The related statistics can be affected in a
favourable manner if the discharge vessel radius
Downloaded by RYERSON UNIVERSITY on January 29, 2018 | http://arc.aiaa.org | DOI: 10.2514/6.IAC-04-S.4.04
p ~ ν ~ 1/ R (1)
4
55th International Astronautical Congress 2004 - Vancouver, Canada
4.1. Thrust
F = η d ⋅ J 2m(U + Vp ) / q (3)
Assuming a divergence efficiency ηd = 0.98, a Fig. 4: Nominal thrust with throttling range and
typical positive high voltage U = 1.2 kV, a plasma ion production costs of 6 rf-engines vs. the
potential Vp = 30 V, a mean ion mass m = 131.3 extraction area diameter. The values of the
amu, and a mean ion charge q = 1.02 e (at 1 % of three larger thrusters have been measured.
Xe++ ions). The J/F-ratio becomes 17.8 mA/mN.
The multiplication of the ion production costs w
4.2. Ion Production Costs and Power with the ion beam current J yields the necessary
Consumption rf-discharge power. Together with the beam
power J(U+Vp) and the drain losses on the accel
In the double-logarithmic graph of Fig. 4, the
grid 0.02⋅J⋅Uex we get the thruster power input P
measured ion production costs of the three larger
(without neutralizer; see Fig. 5):
rf-engines are placed on a straight line. This
allows us to estimate the ion production costs for
the microthrusters by extrapolation. P = J(U + Vp ) + wJ + 0.02 J ⋅ U ex =
(5)
The reason why the costs w increase when J(U + Vp + w + 0.02 U ex )
scaling down the thruster is based on the
increasing ionizer wall surfaces S (where the
We use a conventional drain current percentage
plasma losses occur) relative to the discharge
of 2 % of the beam current and an extraction
volume V (where the ions are generated); we get
voltage of 1.5 kV, i.e. a negative high voltage of
for a cylinder:
300 V.
The quotient of the beam power over the thruster
power input gives the power efficiency ηe =
J(U+Vp)/P; the power-to-thrust-ratio P/F is usually
*)
Note that the numbers in the marking of the RIT- called specific power Psp. ηe decreases and Psp
microthrusters give not always the exact ionizer increases by scaling down the RIT-motor (see
diameter (in centimeters), contrary to the larger
Fig. 6), following the increasing ion production
engines. This is caused by the discontinuous radius of
the outer hole circles which becomes relevant for a costs.
decreasing number of beamlets.
5
55th International Astronautical Congress 2004 - Vancouver, Canada
RIT-1 RIT-2 RIT-3 RIT-4 RIT-10 V& = V& i + V& o , V& i = 14.0 sccm ⋅ J / A and
(6)
800 8 V& o = 6.10 ⋅ 10 − 4 sccm ⋅ N ⋅ (p opt 4 ⋅ 10 − 4 Torr )
600 6
500 5 The propellant efficiency η m = V& i V& decreases
400 4 when scaling down the engine size (see Fig. 6)
caused by the increasing discharge pressure.
300 3
The same belongs to the specific impulse Isp; with
the ion velocity vi = 42.8 km/s (at U = 1.2 kV) and
200 2 go as the gravity acceleration of the Earth, we get:
I sp = 42.8 km / s ⋅ η m g o (7)
100
thruster power input, W
1
80 0.8
60 0.6
50 0.5
40 0.4
30 0.3
20 0.2
.
V P
10 0.1
8 0.08
6 0.06
5 0.05
4 0.04
1 2 3 4 5 6 8 10
ionizer diameter, cm
6
55th International Astronautical Congress 2004 - Vancouver, Canada
Table 1: Scheduled data of small rf-ion engines calculated on the basis of scaling laws with the measured
RIT-10 performance data as reference. The grid geometry and voltages have been kept unchanged.
Figs. 7 and 8 show a drawing true to scale and a 5.2. Test Facility Big Mac
photo of the RIT-4 engine, respectively. In Fig. 1,
the arrangement of the 151 beamlet holes in the For testing the RIT-4 and other rf-microthrusters,
first grid is depicted. a 2.2-m3 high vacuum test stand, formerly used for
The 4-cm ionizer-diameter thruster has been spacecraft charging experiments by electrons, has
conventionally designed. been refurbished and adapted for operation of
The relatively large isolator/gas-injector system Xenon-ion microthrusters.
and the grid-supports are made of Macor or Figs. 9 and 10 show a drawing true to scale and a
Stenan. The discharge vessel is manufactured photo of the test facility which is named "Big Mac"
from quartz. Two rf-coils with 9 and 6 turns are due to its shape.
available, respectively. The pumping system consists of a 500 ltr/s-
The first grid is 0.3 mm thick; its borings are 1.9 turbopump and an additionally installed cryogenic
mm in diam. The second grid is 1.2 mm thick with pump with 12,000 ltr/s for Xenon. At full-power
borings of 1.2 mm in diam. The interspace operation of RIT-4, a background vacuum of
between the grids is 0.6 mm. The grounded 2⋅10-6 Torr can be maintained.
7
55th International Astronautical Congress 2004 - Vancouver, Canada
Downloaded by RYERSON UNIVERSITY on January 29, 2018 | http://arc.aiaa.org | DOI: 10.2514/6.IAC-04-S.4.04
Fig. 7: Drawing true to scale of the RIT-4 Fig. 8: Photo of the disassembled RIT-4
microthruster. microthruster
Fig. 9: Drawing true to scale of the new 2.2 m3 EP-test facility "Big Mac" of Giessen University.
8
55th International Astronautical Congress 2004 - Vancouver, Canada
Fig. 10: Photo the new 2.2-m3 EP-test facility "Big 6. M. Micci, V. Mistoco, and S. Bilen:
Mac" of Giessen University. "Development and Chamber Testing of a
Miniature Radio-Frequency Ion Thruster for
Microspacecraft", 4th Intern. Spacecraft Prop.
Conf., Sardinia, June 2004