Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 11

Women's Studies International Forum 35 (2012) 343–353

Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect

Women's Studies International Forum


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/wsif

Water and waste management in the Moroccan tourism industry: The case
of three women entrepreneurs
María del Mar Alonso-Almeida
Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Facultad de Económicas y Administración de Empresas, Módulo E-VIII: Departamento de Organización de Empresas,
28049 Madrid, Spain

a r t i c l e i n f o s y n o p s i s

Available online 20 July 2012 Water is a key resource for the tourism industry, especially in countries lacking in drinking
water and water infrastructures, such as Morocco. This case study analyzes women's degree of
empowerment for making significant decisions regarding water management, and their
contribution to the community through the companies they establish in the tourism sector.
Through the tourism industry, the Moroccan women have managed to enter the labor force in
the formal economy, thus gaining independence and social recognition. The study shows that
women can have a positive role in promoting practices designed to protect the environment in
view of managing the available water resources, thus helping to increase the wealth of the
local community.
© 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Introduction innovative ways (Veuthey & Gerber, 2011). Finally, from a


perspective of feminist “liberation theology”, women who play a
According to the World Water Assessment Programme key role in the management of natural resources can then
(2009), in developing countries women are habitually respon- contribute to the empowerment of other women, thus
sible for the management of water destined for household use, improving the latter's quality of life (Rocheleau, 1997). For all
while men take the decisions concerning the overall manage- these reasons, the empowerment of women in water manage-
ment and development of water resources. This situation is ment is a key issue that can provide positive benefits for the
especially difficult in countries with low levels of water community. Moreover, as Schein (2007, 6) states, “improving
availability such as Morocco. In this type of country, and women's participation in leadership roles is part of the struggle
particularly in rural areas, women are responsible for collecting to enhance the rights, freedoms, and opportunities of all women
water from different sources such as ditches, drains and globally.”
streams. This activity consumes a large amount of time, during The travel and tourism sector is very important for the
which women could otherwise have been involved in other economic welfare of developing countries. As UNWTO (2010,
activities to generate income. Moreover, previous research 2) stated, “tourism can make a significant contribution to
linking environmentalist and feminist strategies has found that address economic climate and poverty imperatives. Tourism
women working in the tourism sector are more sensitive to represents up to 45% of the exports of services of developing
environmental issues than their male counterparts for three countries and it is often one of the few entry possibilities into
main reasons. The first of these, viewed in terms of basic the job market”. Consequently, tourism promotes economic
patterns of human behavior, can be explained by women's progress by enhancing infrastructures and increasing phys-
natural temperament and inclinations (Mellor, 1997). Second- ical capital (Lee & Chang, 2008).
ly, women enjoying “masculine” positions of power in terms of However, a debate exists about the impact of the travel
access to property, credit and education have the opportunity to and tourism sector on the environment. On the one hand,
use such positions to make economic growth compatible with tourism is one of the main sources of wealth for numerous
environmental conservation, by applying technical advances in destinations, particularly in developing countries in Africa

0277-5395/$ – see front matter © 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.wsif.2012.06.002
344 M. del Mar Alonso-Almeida / Women's Studies International Forum 35 (2012) 343–353

(UNWTO, 2011). On the other hand, it is also pointed out that of women in Morocco and their current role in terms of
tourism consumes energy and water, produces waste and business initiatives and entrepreneurship. The study's ap-
damages the environment. It is clear that, as in the case of other proach to methodology and data analysis are then explained,
countries with dry climates in North Africa and elsewhere, including the presentation and analysis of case studies and of
Morocco's increased level of tourist activity, while representing the study's results. Finally, the study's conclusions are pre-
a continuing source of economic growth, also inevitably places sented, together with a discussion of its limitations and
increasing strain on water supplies, resulting in a problem of suggestions for possible future lines of research.
scarcity of water that can be especially acute during the
summer months. Thus, quite apart from more general consid- Overview of tourism in Morocco
erations about the impact of tourism, the lack of water may also
act as a direct barrier to its further development. The Moroccan government is committed to working to
Regarding the situation of women, Morocco is one of the decrease poverty and improve the environment. Tourism is one
Arab countries in which the role of women in society has most of the main instruments through which it aims to achieve these
changed in recent years. Al Maaitah, Al Maaitah, Olaimat, and goals, being the second largest contributor to Morocco's Gross
Gharaeibeh (2010) affirmed that Morocco has adopted policies Domestic Product (GDP) and to the creation of employment in
to integrate women into both the labor market and the political the country. With this in mind, the Moroccan government
life of the country. In spite of these efforts, the presence of created the Ministry of Tourism for the purpose of speeding up
women in such activities continues to be quite low compared the development of the tourism sector. As a consequence,
with that in other developing countries, especially in entrepre- Morocco has experienced a significant growth in its number of
neurship (Gray & Finley-Hervey, 2005; Metcalfe, 2008). In this tourist arrivals, which has more than doubled in the last
situation, tourism can play a significant role in the achievement decade, increasing from 4,333,900 in 1999 to 9,213,700 in 2010
of the Millennium Development Goals (MDG), specifically in (Observatoire du turisme, 2010).
the case of MDG1 (eradication of poverty), MGD 3 (gender Furthermore, UNWTO (2011) forecasts that by 2020, the
equality) and MGD 7 (environmental sustainability) (see number of tourist arrivals in the African continent will total
UNWTO, 2010). 77 million, accounting for 5% of the total market share.
There is, however, a lack of research into the question of Table 1 provides a breakdown of tourist arrivals in
female entrepreneurs' empowerment to take significant Morocco by nationality. The largest single group is repre-
decisions concerning water management in the tourism sented by Moroccan citizens living abroad, followed by
industry in developing countries, especially in relation to Europeans, particularly the French and the Spanish. As can
countries where such information is very difficult to obtain, be seen in Table 1, Moroccan citizens living abroad represent
as is the case in Morocco (Eurostat, 2009). For these reasons, 50% of the total tourist arrivals in Morocco. Their number
Al Maaitah et al. (2010) called for qualitative studies to be increased constantly during the period 2001–2008, while
carried out in order to gain insights into women's experi- during the same period the numbers of French tourists
ences in Arab countries in this respect. To our knowledge, increased by almost 50%. France and Morocco have a
this study is the first to examine the relationship between common history because a large part of Moroccan territory
female entrepreneurs and water management practices in was a French protectorate during the period up to 1956 and
the tourist industry in any country. Some previous research the two countries have always maintained very strong
has focused on the relationship between water issues and commercial and social links.
gender with regard to agriculture, but to date no such study Moreover, the tourist industry's capacity increased by 57.66%
has analyzed this relationship in the tourist industry. between 2001 and 2008, due to the Moroccan government's
With the aim of exploring this relationship, this work will prioritization of the sector (see Table 2). Nevertheless, the
analyze the challenges faced by three female entrepreneurs in occupancy rate in hotels has remained relatively constant at just
their businesses in the tourism industry and their contribution below 50%. The occupancy rate is the average occupancy of
to attaining the above-mentioned MDGs, placing particular rooms reported by hotels during a given period (over the period
emphasis on water management and an examination of best of a year in this case). In spite of this rise in capacity the
practices in water provision in female-managed tourist occupancy rate actually decreased in 2008, most probably as a
businesses. result of the global financial crisis, since the vast majority of
This paper contributes to previous literature in environ- tourists visiting Morocco come from Europe (see Table 1). These
mental management and gender-related issues in a number of figures could therefore lead us to anticipate an increase in both
ways. First, it provides empirical material for understanding the number of tourists and the occupancy rate in future years.
how women manage a natural resource such as water when it The overall growth in tourism has had a positive influence
is a crucial aspect of their commercial activity. Second, it on society in terms of poverty reduction, social inclusion,
highlights ways to explain how women who assume an education, empowerment of women and improved water
entrepreneurial role help to promote the empowerment of consumption patterns, among other criteria (UNWTO, 2010).
other women. Finally, this paper could provide practical advice
about the importance of best water management practices in Water consumption in Morocco
the tourism sector.
For these purposes the remainder of the paper is organized Today, water scarcity is affecting the entire Maghreb area
as follows. An overview of the tourist industry in Morocco and of North Africa, which includes Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia,
its impact on water consumption is now presented below. The Libya and Mauritania. Water scarcity has been defined by
following section discusses the social and professional situation noting that “when an individual does not have access to safe
M. del Mar Alonso-Almeida / Women's Studies International Forum 35 (2012) 343–353 345

Table 1
Tourist arrivals by nationality (2001–2008).
Source: Tourism of Morocco (2011).

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

MNRAa 2,130,328 2,230,993 2,537,396 2,769,132 2,787,825 2,986,372 3,376,719 3,666,784


France 840,230 877,465 916,147 1,167,088 1,337,204 1,481,610 1,605,503 1,707,055
Spain 200,519 201,258 231,156 317,119 367,811 467,956 540,186 595,279
Other European 539,981 515,855 443,463 510,192 584,597 707,386 822,918 790,118
Other countries 668,932 627,689 633,109 713,182 765,940 915,009 1,062,291 1,119,403
Total 4,379,990 4,453,260 4,761,271 5,476,713 5,843,377 6,558,333 7,407,617 7,878,639
a
MNRA: Moroccan Nationals Resident Abroad.

and affordable water to satisfy her or his needs for drinking, from a severe lack of water, given that rainfall varies from
washing or their livelihoods we call that person water 1800 mm per year in the north to less than 200 mm per year
insecure. When a large number of people in an area are in the south. Thus, in addition to the fact that the supply of
water insecure for a significant period of time, then we can water in dry areas is low, demand for it from the tourism
call that area water scarce” (Rijsberman, 2006, 6). Morocco's sector is increasing (Doukkali, 2005).
main problem is the so-called economic water scarcity. In Moreover, several chronic problems affect water quality.
other words, in addition to water scarcity there is a lack of In particular, the sanitation infrastructure is inadequate;
infrastructures to make water resources available to the there is a significant level of water loss in the distribution
entire population (Rijsberman, 2006). systems (between 30% and 50%), and only a limited fraction
According to Ait Kadi (2004), Morocco has made some of the country's potable water is available to the rural
efforts to maximize the capture of the country's surface water population. as already mentioned above.
resources and to provide for their optimal use for the The country's supplies of potable water are stored in a
purposes of irrigation in agriculture, the provision of potable network of eight river basins. When required, inter-basin
water supplies, industrial consumption and energy genera- water transfers are undertaken, with the result is that the
tion during the last three decades. But water management surpluses in certain basins cover the deficits in others. Thanks
has been only considered as a national priority during the last to this mechanism of inter-basin transfers a regional water
decade. During this period, the country has invested signifi- balance is achieved. The main problems have been posed by
cantly in the essential infrastructures required to control the management of the basins and the need to develop a
surface water flows, and also in a number of wastewater strategic water plan. To summarize the observations made by
treatment plants for recycling water (Choukr-Allah, 2011). The Doukkali (2005), the Moroccan Government, as a first step to
results of these efforts in terms of drinkable water are uneven. developing an Integrated Water Resources Management
Thus, Euromonitor reports that 100% of the urban population (IWRM) program, passed the Water Law of 1995 so as to
has had access to supplies of improved-quality water since integrate the allocation and management of all water resources
2006, while the rural population with access to an improved through a single, but decentralized, system of River Basin
water source has remained at a level of 58% since 1990 Agencies (RBAs), with one agency for each basin. These RBAs
(Euromonitor, 2011), mainly due to the depopulation of rural have responsibility for the overall water supply, water quality
areas. Despite these important achievements, Morocco faces a and maintenance facilities for each basin. On the one hand they
number of constraints concerning the availability of water monitor and regulate water use and quality. On the other hand,
resources and a rapid deterioration in water quality. Ait Kadi they plan and organize flood controls and provisions for
(2004) asserts that water availability is 20billion cubic meters emergencies in their basin. Moreover, they are also responsible
(BCM) per year, consisting of 16 BCM of surface water and for developing a Water Master Plan for each basin once every
4 BCM of groundwater. In the Moroccan context, “surface five years, which includes the strategies for water supply,
water” is understood to be the water collected by the storage exploitation and allocation within the basin with a view to
in dams of water originating from precipitation, while ensuring that all necessary modifications and improvements are
“groundwater” refers to water that is extracted from deep or made so as to adapt to changing conditions.
shallow inventoried aquifers. This Law also led to a significant change in the water
Agriculture, however, consumes 92% of Morocco's fresh administration system, in that water issues were transferred
water resources (Doukkali, 2005, quoted by the World Bank, to the Ministry of Environment in order to signal a national
1995). The main problem is that water is unequally commitment to water quality. The Law also promoted public
distributed. The south of the country has already suffered and private partnerships, resulting in the granting of operating

Table 2
Capacity and room occupancy rate in Morocco (2001–2008).
Source: Tourism of Morocco (2011).

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Hotel capacity (in beds) 97,001 102,097 109,615 119,248 124,270 133,230 143,269 152,936
Room occupancy rate 48 42 39 43 47 49 48 45
346 M. del Mar Alonso-Almeida / Women's Studies International Forum 35 (2012) 343–353

contracts to foreign private water companies in the largest cities. The situation of women in Morocco
Thus, water quality improvement and environmental manage-
ment techniques were implemented through foreign invest- The International Research Centre (2010), 108) noted that
ment and the introduction of international expertise of a kind “Morocco is a lower-middle-income country with a popula-
that was sorely lacking in Morocco at the time. As a result, the tion of 31 million and 2009 GDP per capita of about US$4700.
Law has accomplished its main goals and the overall perfor- It has embraced the principle of a market-based economy
mance of both urban water supplies and national irrigation and has been implementing economic liberalization policies
systems is increasingly effective. In short, “Morocco has now a since the 1980s”, including some related to women's
solid institutional foundation for promoting an economically empowerment.
responsive, user-oriented and allocation-based water sector” Surprisingly, a dichotomy has formed in society regarding
(Doukkali, 2005, 87). These efforts to improve overall water the role of women. On the one hand, among Arab countries,
access, thanks to the effects of the introduction of the above law, Morocco has one of the highest percentages of women in
may have contributed to improving women's living conditions in paid employment, and the second-highest percentage of
the cities by freeing them from responsibilities related to water female university students and of women exercising power
collection and giving them more time for self-development. at the executive level of government. On the other hand, it
With regard to tourism, Eurostat (2009) has stated that has the highest percentage of illiterate women, while fewer
the Mediterranean region is one of the world's top mass than 5% of the country's municipal councilors are women
tourism destinations. Therefore, tourism-related activities (International Research Centre, 2010; Metcalfe, 2008; United
engender two types of environmental impact. While some Nations, 2010).
environmental impacts are linked to the movement of According to Metcalfe (2008), in general female partici-
tourists around the country, other effects are related to the pation in the workforce tends to be higher in countries with
totality of tourist and leisure facilities created to meet the abundant labor and relatively few resources like Morocco.
tourists' needs. The situation of women within the Moroccan workforce is
The increase in tourist activities puts pressure on water summarized in Table 4.
resources through the presence of the tourists and of the golf As can be seen in Table 4, women have a high rate of
courses, swimming pools and other aquatic facilities they use. employment in agriculture, the most important sector of
Although the level of water consumption in the tourism economic activity in the country, followed in second place by
industry is relatively low compared to other sectors such as the service sector. The majority of women work in subsis-
agriculture, the expected trend is for a rapid increase in such tence agriculture, where their commercial activity is limited
consumption in accordance with the growth in tourist traffic to selling their surplus production (Dana & Dana, 2008). As
(Eurostat, 2009; UNWTO, 2011). the International Research Centre affirms, economic growth
Levels of water consumption by category of accommoda- in Morocco is heavily dependent on the agricultural sector,
tion in Morocco are shown in Table 3. which is highly influenced by the amount of annual rainfall
Water consumption in hotels is divided into six main (International Research Centre, 2010). The situation is thus
categories of use: for guests' rooms, kitchens, laundry, air potentially negative for the continued enhancement of
conditioning, swimming pools, and gardens. Trung and women's participation in economic activity.
Kumar (2005) found that in the Vietnamese hotel industry Moreover, as some authors have explained, in Morocco
the highest consumption of water is for guests' rooms, the widespread expectation is still that women should stay at
followed by outdoor activities and, finally, the kitchens. The home. They are dominated and considered to be of lower
situation in Vietnam with regard to water consumption in the status than men. In rural areas women's activity is limited to
hospitality sector is similar to that in Morocco. Choukr-Allah domestic and reproductive roles and to agricultural work.
(2011) stated that the potential for the treatment of These cultural barriers inhibit entrepreneurship (Goby &
wastewater for reuse is still underexploited in Morocco. The Erogul, 2011; Gray & Finley-Hervey, 2005; Itani, Sidani, &
most frequently used technology for water recycling is a sand Baalbaki, 2011; Metcalfe, 2008).
filter system. In the north of Morocco water reuse involving
this system is used in both golf courses and sanitary Female entrepreneurship in Morocco
installations. These figures give an idea of the importance of
managing this resource carefully. An analysis of the data relating to employment status (see
Table 4) shows that only 0.6% of women are employers and
9.8% are self-employed. Both are very low rates in compar-
ison with the proportion of men involved in entrepreneurial
activity, which is over 33%.
Table 3
To illustrate the above comments, according to the
Levels of water consumption by category of accommodation in Morocco.
Source: Own elaboration. Data source: Eurostat (2009).
International Research Centre (2010), 5.8 million adults in
Morocco are involved in entrepreneurial activities, and fewer
Tourist company Water consumption standards than 0.6 million of these are women. These lower levels of
Luxury 5-star hotel 600 l/bed-night entrepreneurial activity among women are influenced by
5-star hotel/riad 500 l/bed-night cultural aspects which lead to women being largely excluded
4-star hotel or equivalent 400 l/bed-night from the public and economic sphere. According to Al
3-star hotel or equivalent 300 l/bed-night
Maaitah et al. (2010), Arab women suffer from a thick wall
(18-hole golf course) (3500 m3-day)
that prevents them from entering a public sphere that is
M. del Mar Alonso-Almeida / Women's Studies International Forum 35 (2012) 343–353 347

Table 4 reason for this is that tourist industry subsectors such as


Employment situation of women in Morocco. hospitality or restaurants involve accommodation, cooking
Source: own elaboration. Data source: United Nations (2010).
and cleaning, activities that are considered as domestic work,
Adult (15+) labor force participation 1990 Women 24 and, therefore, appropriate for women (Faulkenberry,
rate (%) Men 80 Coggeshall, Backman, & Backman, 2000; Kattara, 2005).
2010 Women 25
Tourism has thus provided a good opportunity for women
Men 82
Adult (15+) unemployment rate 2006–2007 (%) Women 10 to enter the formal economy. This sector presents a variety of
Men 10 opportunities for women, given that working in tourism is
Distribution of the employed population Women Agriculture 61 perceived as an extension of domestic work, and for that
by economic sector 2004–2007 (%) Industry 15
reason is acceptable in countries in which outside work for
Services 24
Men Agriculture 37
women is not as a general rule considered favorably, or in
Industry 22 which women have few employment options, or even none
Services 41 at all. Following this line of reasoning, Dhaliwal (1998) found
Distribution of the employed population Women Employees 33.4 that many women in developing countries choose entrepre-
by status of employment Employers 0.6
neurial activities that are an extension of their roles as wives
2004–2007 (%) Own 9.8
account in order to avoid cultural problems.
workers
Contributing 55.3 Data collection and methodology of study
family
workers
Men Employees 46.8
Case studies have frequently been used in the relevant
Employers 3.3 literature to explain various specific aspects of the adoption
Own 29.9 and implementation of environmental practices (Casadesús,
account Marimon, & Alonso-Almeida, 2010; Fresner & Engelhardt,
workers
2004; Ghisellini & Thurston, 2005), and the practice of female
Contributing 17
family entrepreneurship in general (Dana & Dana, 2008; Gray &
workers Finley-Hervey, 2005; Ndemo & Maina, 2007). Case studies
Share of women legislators, senior officials and managers 13 provide insights into a management situation when the area
2004–2008 (%) of research is new, the research has little control over events
Share of women office clerks 2004–2008 (%) 24
Share of women in parliament 2009 (%) Lower or 11
or it is difficult to study the situation outside its natural
single house setting (Yin, 1994), as in the present case.
Upper house 1 In the present study, ten extensive interviews were con-
Share of women among ministers 2009 (%) 19 ducted with hotel managers in Tetouan in northern Morocco
during the summer of 2010 (specifically in July and August).
Priority was given to cases involving women entrepreneurs with
dominated by men. Women are thus involved in “informal” a view to obtaining an in-depth analysis of their approach to
economic employment, particularly in agriculture, where water management, while hotel managers with other profiles,
their activity has limited visibility. As a consequence, women such as male managers, employed managers or managers
are not seen to form part of economic life. When some working for hotel chains, were excluded because they were not
women try to follow a different path, they may face rejection owners of the hotels concerned, and therefore did not take this
from society (Gray & Finley-Hervey, 2005). Thus, the family is type of decisions. We thus finally focused on three companies
the biggest barrier to women's advancement in the Arab which were managed and owned by women.
countries (Itani et al., 2011; McElwee & Al-Riyami, 2003). Two main sources of information were used: i) primary
This situation continues even when Moroccan women go to sources (used for direct observation through a combination
live in developed countries (Essers, 2007). of in-depth personal interviews and informal visits); and ii)
Apart from cultural barriers, a number of factors suggest secondary sources (such as bibliographical analyses, press
that the business environment does not seem to be very articles, reports and websites).
favorable for women in Morocco. On the one hand, women This area of Morocco was studied because of its growth
suffer from a lack of economic independence and difficulties thanks to its tourism activities and because of its economic links
in obtaining access to financial resources (Muravyev, with Spain, since it was a Spanish protectorate for 44 years.
Talavera, & Schäfer, 2009). This lack of financial resources Since the author is Spanish, it was therefore easier for her to
makes them dependent on their families and restricts their conduct her research and to establish a rapport with the
capacity to make independent decisions (Ndemo & Maina, interviewees thanks to the residual Spanish influence in this
2007). On the other hand, there are persistent bureaucratic territory.
barriers, as the Ease of Doing Business 2010 Index noted A structured survey was conducted on a one-to-one basis.
(World Bank, 2009). The interviews were carried out in Spanish and French, and
Previous research in Arab countries (Ndemo & Maina, lasted for between 60 and 90 min.
2007) found that women who start up businesses usually do Adapting an interview previously developed in another
so in the service sector. Tourism constitutes a good area of language requires validation through the application of a
activity in which women can open up a business in order to specific procedure. Not only the basic linguistic issues, but
gain independence and obtain a salary (Itani et al., 2011; also technical and conceptual ones need to be taken into
Javadian & Singh, 2012; McKenzie Gentry, 2007). The main consideration when undertaking the translation (Ferrer et al.,
348 M. del Mar Alonso-Almeida / Women's Studies International Forum 35 (2012) 343–353

1996). These requirements were met by the authors in the main water consumption areas in a hotel. We ourselves clean
following manner. First, the interviews were sent to women the sheets and tablecloths and dry them on the terrace. In the
managers in the original languages so as to guarantee that guestrooms, water-saving sanitary equipment has been
the topics and responses had been transcribed correctly. installed and housekeepers are responsible for checking for
Second, the interviews were translated by the author into leaks when travelers leave the rooms. Our customers are
English (the first version) and, finally, this translated version mainly European guests and they are very aware about
was then revised by colleagues who translated them back environmental care, although this is unusual in the accom-
into Spanish and French and compared them with the modation sector in Morocco. These types of environmental
original versions written in both languages (Lee, Lim, & practices are only implemented in the highest category
Pathak, 2011). hotels”.
They focused on the main drivers under investigation as Regarding the hotel's decoration she explained: “Plants
motivations for their ventures, the application of water are used for decoration instead of fresh flowers, and drip
management in their businesses, and the extent of their irrigation systems have been installed to save water.” With
social contribution (especially in relation to other women). regard to the workforce she explained that “we try to employ
All the interviews were transcribed word for word, and the women, but sometimes it is difficult because when they are
information acquired was subsequently coded by topic. married their husbands want them to stay at home”.
The preparation of food is the main source of revenue in this
Case studies hotel, and is therefore the main cause of water consumption and
waste generation. Water is a scarce and expensive commodity
In the following three case studies, the profiles of three in Morocco. Hence, education in water consumption is
women entrepreneurs are developed. These women are necessary. To achieve this goal, this female owner trains her
representative of the middle and upper-middle class social employees in environmental matters. Some best practices (in
strata in Morocco and have the profiles of women entrepre- terms of the specific requirements of the kitchen) have been
neurs, as identified previously by Gray and Finley-Hervey written down to ensure they are followed by all employees. By
(2005) and by Weeks (2009). All of them have a university taking these measures the hotel has saved a considerable
degree. Two of the women are hotel owners, and the other is amount of money and its water consumption is currently below
a restaurant owner. The number of employees they have the average for the hotel's category, according to the manager.
working for them ranges from seven to sixteen. Their The hotel buys all the food for the restaurant in the local market
companies have been active for between two and eight from local farmers, “from other women preferably”.
years, and they all operate in the formal economy. The two
hotels are located in the vicinity of the city of Tetouan, and Case 2 boutique hotel BBB
the restaurant is located in a rural area outside the city.
The second case study concerns a hotel near Tetouan, in
Case 1 riad hotel AAA marina coastal area, which focuses on a client profile of
high-level businesspersons. The hotel has seven rooms and
The first case study concerns a riad, a traditional type of one suite, and is staffed by 16 women employees, including
Moroccan hotel, usually located in the medinas (the old the manager.
districts of the cities). The riad hotel in question has five The female business owner is 38 years old, single and has
rooms and one of the most famous restaurants in the city, a degree in law. The hotel was opened one year ago. Its owner
and is housed in a historic palace. Its woman owner is is a well-known female lawyer who is working for equal
41 years old, married and has an arts degree. When she opportunities and women's rights. The hotel was created to
purchased and opened the hotel she was single. She had help other women to obtain work outside the home. She used
worked previously as a teacher and confided: “(I) wanted to her savings and external financing to buy and decorate the
have something for myself.” hotel. “My father is happy that I help to improve economic
Her project was financed using her own savings, because health in our country,” she commented, adding: “The idea is
“it is very difficult to find financial support from local banks”. to open another boutique hotel in the short-term with the
She added the following comment: “The bureaucracy is very profits, and following the same strategy.” She stated: “I am
hard and we took a long time to have all licenses ready”. The happy because I can help other women to achieve objectives
hotel was opened in 2002 and it has ten employees, four men in their lives to feel more valuable”.
and six women. The owner studied in Europe, and she has maintained her
The hotel targets business clients with a commercial business contacts. She hired a European construction company
strategy of offering good quality at an affordable price. More to redesign the hotel, installing the latest environmental
than 75% of the customers are foreigners, mainly Spanish and innovations for the reduction of energy use and water
French. 30% of the hotel's revenue is earned from accommo- consumption. With regard to water management, each guest-
dation, and 70% from food and drink. room's bathroom has a faucet timer and a water-saving W.C.
With regard to the hotel's advanced, environmentally Also, water use and towel reuse instructions are posted on the
respectful practices, she explained that “the redecoration of door. The manager commented: “The ownership favored these
the palace lasted more than one year and (we) took the practices because 85% of our customers are foreigners and they
opportunity to introduce some environmental practices and are familiar to them. … Our customers demand environmental
tools in the kitchen and in the guestrooms. For example we care and we cannot disappoint them. … Moreover, these
have neither gardens nor green areas nor swimming pool, the instructions enable quick and practical learning, and facilitate
M. del Mar Alonso-Almeida / Women's Studies International Forum 35 (2012) 343–353 349

the training of our new and temporary employees.” She According to the woman manager, “Most of our clients are
continued: “Our main customers are mainly European, they executives of foreign companies who are looking for a good
want to feel like they are in Europe and sometimes it is difficult meal to celebrate success in their businesses. Other cus-
in Morocco”. tomers are foreigners with high purchasing power who come
In the case of the gardens, she explained: “We water the to enjoy quality cuisine while on their holidays. We cannot
gardens at night with timed spray irrigation. In areas such as lower the quality of our service due to lack of water.” In
the inner courtyard or roof terrace we have a mist spray relation to the restaurant's water consumption, she com-
installed. This system pulverizes the water with high mented: “Our water consumption is high but we are seeking
pressure in drops of 10 microns. These drops remain for a solutions to reduce it because the kitchen is a big consumer”.
while in suspension before they evaporate into the air, She added: “We are always concerned about economizing
thereby reducing the temperature to 12 degrees without a our water consumption. For this reason, we are thinking
significant increase of humidity. Thus, water consumption is about acquiring a new low water consumption dishwater.”
quite low.” The manager asserted that “systems like these are
not very usual in Morocco. We are helping our employees to Discussion of case studies
understand the importance of using water wisely and
effectively.” Moreover, the manager noted: “Environmental All the cases examined show that the women concerned are
regulations do not exist in Morocco yet, but water is very aware of water management. In line with previous research,
important in this business and country and it is necessary to these women consider water as a key resource and try to make
make people aware of the water shortage.” their business sustainable by optimizing its use (Veuthey &
Gerber, 2011). Moreover they have used their businesses as
Case 3 restaurant in a rural area vehicles for the empowerment of other women. Therefore it can
The third case concerns a restaurant in a rural area near be confirmed that the women studied are contributing to
Tetouan. This restaurant specializes in Mediterranean and economic growth and water management in Moroccan society
modern Moroccan cuisine. The restaurant has a capacity for as a means of reducing poverty, of giving opportunities to other
60 people. It was opened five years ago and has seven women and of helping the local community through the tourism
employees (two men and five women), including the woman industry.
business owner herself. With regard to the role of women in entrepreneurship, Gray
The restaurant is a family business; to all external and Gray (2007) asserted that women in Morocco can be
appearances, it is managed by a woman, but the father is described as a minority in a society dominated by men, and that
the head of the family at home and is asked for his opinion, it is not therefore usually expected that they will be able to
“as a signal of respect”. The family are agricultural land- contribute much to commercial and industrial activity. This
owners and they have been working the land for more than situation continues when women are outside Morocco, so that
fifty years, or three generations. For more than twenty years the family acts a barrier that obliges women to remain in the
the women of the family worked the land, and the vegetables private sphere (Essers, 2007). Given, however, that this situation
and fruit from their land that were left over after supplying is changing (Goby & Erogul, 2011; Gray & Gray, 2007), and that
the family's needs were subsequently sold by them at women are now entering the workforce at all levels in other
Tetouan market, to restaurants and at the roadside. This Arab countries (Al-Dajani, 2010; Goby & Erogul, 2011), it is to be
was the origin of the present-day restaurant. expected that this trend will continue to develop in the near
This situation was negative for the women members of future, even if only slowly, and the cases studied are examples of
the family, however, because this work was considered as this tendency. Nevertheless, social changes – regarding both
part of their domestic tasks and they thus obtained from it women themselves and their role within the family – and
neither a formal salary nor any degree of social recognition. government support are both clearly needed.
As they did not always sell all their remaining fruit, the The cases presented are relevant because these women
mother started to cook and to sell meals in the market and in are operating in the formal economy, and are therefore
the street. This was the origin of the present-day restaurant. contributing to creating wealth both for the country and for
Having first started to serve meals in an informal way, once other women, by engaging them in formalized employment,
they had a certain level of savings they opened a restaurant, thus reducing the risk of falling back into poverty (Blanchet,
with the mother as manager. As the women explained, “we 2010; Chen, Datt, & Ravallion, 1994; Chen & Ravallion, 2004).
wanted to improve our economic situation and with the Sadly, they are a minority (Gray & Gray, 2007), and their
increase of foreign investments and companies in this area situation is uncommon in Morocco in terms of both their
we saw the opportunity to open our own business. Our social personal and their financial status. These findings suggest that
situation has changed we are not only small farmers, we are a more Moroccan women need to be engaged in the formal
business family. Now we give employment to six people. It is economy, given that the rate of women working within their
a source of pride for us”. She further added: “We know all the families without any external visibility is very high, at 55.3%.
farmers in the area, and where we can buy the best meat and This situation involves a greater possibility that women will fall
fish for our restaurant”. back into poverty, given that such a risk is higher in the informal
Regarding water management practices, the restaurant economy (Al-Dajani, 2010). The government should work as a
strictly restricts the use of potable water to cooking purposes facilitator, and encourage a labor environment that is friendly to
only. It has a well, and water from this is used to clean women (Itani et al., 2011; Javadian & Singh, 2012). Women
table-linen and dishcloths. The restaurant also has a number entrepreneurs are succeeding in achieving a number of goals,
of water tanks to collect rainfall. such as improving their degree of economic independence
350 M. del Mar Alonso-Almeida / Women's Studies International Forum 35 (2012) 343–353

(Goby & Erogul, 2011; Madrid & Lovell, 2007; Ndemo & Maina, national culture of their country and to human rights (UNWTO,
2007), but this is not enough. The gender gap continues to be 2010).
very wide, and some challenges need to be tackled urgently, Finally, this research confirms that such working women
such as the need to combat the stereotypical image of women are not only motivated by self achievement or by a desire for
that is perpetuated by cultural factors, to address the problem independence and to earn more money (Sadi & Al-Ghazali,
of women's low level of self-confidence, and to create women's 2010; Woldie & Adersua, 2004), but that in addition they “are
organizations and establish women empowerment programs motivated by the social contribution their business can make
so as to help other women (Al Maaitah et al., 2010). to society” (Orhan & Scott, 2001, 237).
Regarding the importance of the tourism sector for
developing countries, it has clearly become a regular source Conclusion
of opportunities for women to enter the formal economy. For
example in Belize, McKenzie Gentry (2007) pointed out that To sum up, this work has tried to shed light on the key
women have found a wide range of employment opportuni- role that women in tourism companies can play, particularly
ties in tourism. in terms of poverty reduction, the empowerment of women,
It can therefore be concluded that tourism could contribute achieving effective water management and contributing to
to increasing the wealth of the local community overall, and of the overall well-being of the community in tourism destina-
women in particular. Following this argument, it can be asserted tions. In addition, a number of recommendations are made
that tourism is a good tool for helping to eradicate poverty, for concerning possible political initiatives and feminist or other
advancing towards gender equality and for achieving environ- strategies to help improve women's social and economic
mental sustainability in accordance with the MDGs (Gray & position in such contexts.
Finley-Hervey, 2005; McKenzie Gentry, 2007). In Arab countries First, given that tourism seems to be an aid to the country's
today, however, social status plays a significant role in development, the international agencies should develop a more
determining career course and success in economic life. This active role and place more emphasis on the changes needed to
means that the women examined in our case studies are not the achieve the MDGs. As UNWTO (2010) noted, the collaboration
majority, but rather the exception, as is shown by the available between the public and private sectors and other independent
statistical data (see the Ease of Doing Business 2010 Index). associations can provide funding and knowledge to improve
Nevertheless, they could serve as examples to other women and both the skills of the workforce and customers' wellbeing. In the
service companies. case of tourism, all the key players should be involved, namely
The companies studied above have developed a number national and local government, community representatives, the
of water management measures, and some of them are even accommodation sector, airlines, tour operators and any other
very advanced by the standards of their country and of other appropriate participants such as international agencies like
developing countries. For instance, in the hospitality sector in UNWTO, or other non-governmental organizations. For exam-
Vietnam water consumption measures have been taken in ple, UNWTO is currently involved in 90 projects in 31 countries.
certain hotels, but in general they are not widely used (Trung Morocco should use its location in the Maghreb area and its
& Kumar, 2005). foreign relations to improve its competitive position by attract-
A number of studies have found that other characteristics of ing investment to develop infrastructures and to obtain a greater
a hotel, e.g. whether or not it is part of a chain, its level of level of commitment from internationally active hotel chains
international activity or its category, could constitute the main and airlines. Both could generate income and employment for
reasons for complying with environmental management the community, and particularly for women.
(Alonso-Almeida & Rodriguez-Antón, 2011; Rodriguez-Antón, Second, the cases studied have shown that women can be
Alonso-Almeida, Celemín, & Rubio, 2012). “agents of change rather than […] passive vessels of develop-
This seems to be the situation in the hotels studied. Their ment assistance” (Jennissen & Lundy, 2001, 183). Therefore, the
guests are mainly European, and their female owners want to Moroccan government should strengthen its efforts to democ-
build an image of modernity with a service similar to that ratize the country with regard to women's rights and equal
found in Europe, but combined with Moroccan culture. These opportunities (Huq & Moyeen, 2011). It should improve access
results suggest that if more foreign tourists travel to Morocco, to organized markets, formal credit institutions and training
more hotels will improve their environmental management facilities (Goby & Erogul, 2011; International Research Centre,
in the medium term. 2010; Landig, 2011). But first of all, the Moroccan government
From a managerial perspective it is necessary to dissem- should produce a plan to decrease the illiteracy rate among
inate best practices in the accommodation and restaurant women, as a first step toward giving them their economic
industry. Trung and Kumar (2005) considered that hotels independence. This is particularly important in rural areas,
should introduce a number of inexpensive water and waste where more primary and secondary schools should be created.
management measures. In the case of water, certain measures As the International Research Centre (2010), 116) stated, “there
could be introduced, such as adjusting the level of the float in is still a gender gap in the level of confidence women have in
the water in the lavatory cistern, placing water saving notices their abilities to start a business. To strengthen the role of
in guestroom bathrooms and toilets, and regularly monitoring women in entrepreneurial activities, dedicated efforts to
water usage in the kitchens, guestrooms and in relation to promote entrepreneurship and impart the required knowledge
outdoor activities. Furthermore, Moroccan tourist companies and skills should be considered”.
should develop a corporate social responsibility plan to Third, the government should strengthen the regulatory
increase their competitiveness by reassuring their customers environmental framework to protect natural resources, and
that the company is committed to the environment, to the water in particular. Given that water is a vital resource for life
M. del Mar Alonso-Almeida / Women's Studies International Forum 35 (2012) 343–353 351

and prosperity, it is a priority to continue investing in water and in household duties with a view to removing social
technologies. In this respect, another action needs to be taken barriers to women's progress.
urgently: to provide access to improved water supply facilities Fifth, feminist theories state that men and women are
for the rural population. The proportion of the rural population essentially equal, but that women work at a disadvantage due
currently enjoying such access is 58%, a figure which has not to a lack of assistance, of financial resources or of access to
improved in the last 20years. This situation is damaging for power networks, and because the prevailing culture favors
women, given that they are made responsible for supplying this masculine stereotypes (Morris, Miyasaki, Watters, & Coombes,
resource, a task that prevents them from seeking involvement in 2006). However, not only are there differences between
other activities to improve their lives. Consequently, the individuals, but also differences in terms of social structure,
Government should develop a training program at all educa- economic power, class structure and political loyalties (Orser,
tional levels to sensitize young people to the importance of Riding, & Manley, 2006). Therefore, the more women are able
safeguarding water supplies. For the adult population, special to obtain a certain level of education and of personal resources,
advertising campaigns about water and the best practices for its the greater will be their potential to wield a larger influence
use could also be created for educational purposes. These types both at home and outside the home, and thus to break down
of educational campaigns are very popular in Europe for gender stereotypes (Landig, 2011). In general, women entre-
ensuring the widespread dissemination of information concern- preneurs in Arab countries may not desire a rapid radical
ing particular regulations or recommendations. change in social structures. On the contrary, they may prefer to
Fourth, women and their families should make some respect the existing social rules and traditions, while working
changes in their personal and group behavior. In most Arab towards a modern interpretation that will facilitate their
countries the tradition of arranged marriages at an early age is careers and their visibility as economic agents (Itani et al.,
still maintained. In this situation women have few opportunities 2011). Thus, the most difficult challenge in Morocco will be to
to receive an education, have large numbers of children and do achieve the recognition of the multiple roles that women can
not normally work outside the home (Henry, 2011). play as individuals, wives, workers and citizens (World Bank,
Women need to increase their own self-confidence and 2004).
personal effectiveness in order to progress and to overcome From an eco-feminist perspective this exploratory work
the challenges that they face (Itani et al., 2011; Javadian & confirms that women entrepreneurs can act to make
Singh, 2012). In this respect, there is a social need to break economic growth compatible with environmental conserva-
the traditional gender paradigms based on different social tion, by applying technical advances in innovative ways, and
functions and family responsibilities designated by sex that they can contribute to improving their families' lives and
(World Bank, 2004). Thus, women should seek paths to to the empowerment of other women. Beyond economic
redefine and expand their opportunities (Jabre, Underwood, issues, the responsible use of scant natural resources such as
& Goodsmith, 1997). Women should seek family support to water in Morocco has a crucial significance, given that, as
study, and to be allowed to marry men that they have chosen with the provision of any other product or service, the use of
themselves or who support their ideas. When such a different approaches will inevitably produce different results
situation is not possible and family tensions arise, women (Perkins & Kuiper, 2005). It therefore seems clear that an
should seek to achieve their goals – whether in education or increased participation of women in the labor force would
in terms of employment – and at the same time to ensure a increase the effects of every investment in women's potential
balance with other family members by gaining their respect, throughout the economy, resulting in higher levels of per
something which the success of a number of women capita income and faster economic growth.
entrepreneurs in Arab countries has shown to be possible Finally, a number of limitations have been identified in
(Jabre et al., 1997). relation to this study, and additional lines of research are
Another path for women could be to become involved suggested below in the following section.
with external associations which keep women informed This study is limited by the fact that it is difficult to obtain
about their rights and help them with regard to critical issues the data or information required in Morocco. Efforts have
such as reproductive methods, child care, education, work been made to mitigate these shortcomings by accessing other
and networking with other women (Goby & Erogul, 2011; sources of data. Given this situation, exploratory case studies
Jabre et al., 1997; Landig, 2011). are the best method of studying social events. Another
Regarding the family-related aspects of such proposed limitation may arise from the fact that the interviews were
changes, Landig asserted that “men must be made aware of carried out in a single specific area, so that the findings may
women's rights and appreciate women's worth in the social, be difficult to extrapolate to other areas. Nonetheless, as the
economic, and political sphere” (Landig, 2011, 216). Today area can be regarded as being representative of the country
many Arab men recognize the need for both the husband and studied and of the sector concerned, this may provide an
the wife to earn a salary in order for a couple to improve their indication of the situation in the country as a whole. Finally,
standard of living. Thus, married men should support and data collection via interviews is yet another limitation,
encourage women's initiatives to work outside the home and inasmuch as this method may introduce subjectivity or bias,
ignore gossip from their family and their neighbors (Jabre et but these objections could be diluted by the quantity of
al., 1997). The challenge is to combine and balance work interviews held. It is therefore proposed to increase the
outside the family with family responsibilities by respecting number of interviews conducted for future research.
social rules so as to avoid arousing antagonistic attitudes Finally, more research is needed to understand the role of
(Itani et al., 2011; World Bank, 2004). A big step forward is for women in environmental care and management in general,
husbands to become involved in their children's education and particularly in water management. The proposals for the
352 M. del Mar Alonso-Almeida / Women's Studies International Forum 35 (2012) 343–353

future lines of research to be explored in this regard include Fresner, J., & Engelhardt, G. (2004). Experiences with integrated manage-
ment systems for two small companies in Austria. Journal of Cleaner
an increased number of interviews in both the same and Production, 12(6), 623–631.
other areas of Morocco, an analysis of the differences in Ghisellini, Alessia, & Thurston, Deborah L. (2005). Decisions traps in ISO 14000
environmental management depending on the sector con- implementation processes: Case study results from Illinois certified
companies. Journal of Cleaner Production., 13(8), 763–777.
cerned, particularly in the case of those sectors with a high Goby, Valerie Priscilla, & Erogul, Murat Sakir (2011). Female entrepreneur-
level of women's participation such as agriculture, and the ship in the United Arab Emirates: Legislative encouragements and
impact of water management policies on the well-being of cultural constraints. Women's Studies International Forum, 34, 329–334.
Gray, Kenneth R., & Finley-Hervey, Joycelyn (2005). Women and entrepre-
the country's population as a whole. neurship in Morocco: Debunking stereotypes and discerning strategies.
International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal, 1, 203–217.
Acknowledgments Gray, Kennet R., & Gray, Doris H. (2007). Women entrepreneurs in Morocco:
Vanguards of change in the Muslim world. In Mirjana Radovic (Ed.), The
perspective of women's entrepreneurship in the age of globalization. United
The author would like to thank Professor Kerstin Bremser States: Information Age Publishing Inc.
for reading this work and offering valuable comments. The Henry, Hami M. (2011). Egyptian women and empowerment: A cultural
perspective. Women's Studies International Forum, 34, 251–259.
author would also like to express her gratitude to the two Huq, Afreen, & Moyeen, Abdul (2011). Gender integration in enterprise
anonymous reviewers of this text. development programmes. Women's Studies International Forum, 34(4),
320–328.
International Research Centre (2010). Global entrepreneurship monitor:
References GEM-MENA regional report 2009 (Middle East & North Africa). December
2010.
Ait Kadi, Mohamed (2004). From water scarcity to water security in the Itani, Hanifa, Sidani, Yusuf M., & Baalbaki, Imad (2011). United Arab Emirates
Maghreb Region: The Moroccan case. In Antonio Markina (Ed.), female entrepreneurs: Motivations and frustrations. Equality, Diversity
Environmental challenges in the Mediterranean 2000–2050. NATO Science and Inclusion: An International Journal, 30(5), 409–424.
Series. IV Earth and Environmental Sciences, 37. (pp. 175–186). Jabre, Bushra, Underwood, Carol, & Goodsmith Lauren (1997). Arab women
Al Maaitah, Rowaida, Al Maaitah, Hadeel, Olaimat, Hmoud, & Gharaeibeh, speak out: Profiles of self-empowerment. Johns Hopkins School of
Muntaha (2010). Arab women and political development. Journal of Public Health, Center for Communication Programs, Baltimore, Mary-
International Women's Studies, 12(3), 7–26. land and the Center of Arab Women for Training and Research, Tunis,
Al-Dajani, Haya (2010). Diversity and inequality among women in employ- Tunisia, November.
ment in the Arab Middle East region: A new research agenda. In Mustafa Javadian, Golshan, & Singh, Robert P. (2012). Examining successful Iranian
F. Ozbilqin, & Jawad Syed (Eds.), Diversity management in Asia: A research women entrepreneurs: An exploratory study. Gender in Management: An
companion. UK: Glos: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited. International Journal, 27(3), 148–164.
Alonso-Almeida, María del Mar, & Rodriguez-Antón, José Miguel (2011). Jennissen, Therese, & Lundy, Colleen (2001). Women in Cuba and the move
Organizational behaviour and strategies in the adoption of certified to a private market economy. Women's Studies International Forum,
management systems. An analysis of the Spanish hotel industry. Journal 24(2), 181–198.
of Cleaner Production, 19(1), 1455–1463. Kattara, Hanan (2005). Career challenges for female managers in Egyptian
Blanchet, Thérèse (2010). Migration to the bars of Bombay: Women, village hotels. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management,
religion and sustainability. Women's Studies International Forum, 33(4), 17(3), 238–251.
345–353. Landig, Jennifer M. (2011). Bringing women to the table: European Union
Casadesús, Marti, Marimon, Frederic, & Alonso-Almeida, María del Mar funding for women's empowerment projects in Turkey. Women's Studies
(2010). The future of standardised quality management in tourism: International Forum, 34, 206–219.
Evidence from the Spanish tourist sector. Services Industries Journal, Lee, Chien-Chiang, & Chang, Chun-Ping (2008). Tourism development and
30(14), 2457–2474. economic growth: A closer look at panels. Tourism Management, 29,
Chen, Shaohua, Datt, Gaurav, & Ravallion, Martin (1994). Poverty increasing in 180–192.
the developing world? Review Income Wealth, 47(3), 283–300. Lee, Sang M., Lim, Seong-bae, & Pathak, Raghuvar D. (2011). Culture and
Chen, Shaohua, & Ravallion, Martin (2004). How have the world's poorest entrepreneurial orientation: A multi-country study. International Entre-
fared since the early 1980s? World Bank Research Observer, 19, 141–169. preneurship and Management Journal, 7(1), 1–15.
Choukr-Allah, Redouane (2011). Innovative wastewater treatments and Madrid, Gilma, & Lovell, Terry (2007). Working with flowers in Colombia:
reuse technologies adapted to southern Mediterranean countries. In The ‘lucky chance’? Women's Studies International Forum, 30(3), 217–227.
Damiá Barcelo, & Mira Petrovic (Eds.), Waste water treatment and reuse McElwee, Gerard, & Al-Riyami, Rahma (2003). Women entrepreneurs in
in the Mediterranean region. The handbook of environmental chemistry. Oman; some barriers to success. Career Development International, 8(7),
Berlin–Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag. 339–346.
Dana, Leo Paul, & Dana, Theresa E. (2008). Ethnicity and entrepreneurship in McKenzie Gentry, Kristine (2007). Belizean women and tourism work:
Morocco: A photo-ethnographic study. International Journal of Business Opportunity or impediment? Annals Tourism Research, 34(2), 477–496.
Global, 2(3), 209–226. Mellor, Mary (1997). Women, nature and the social construction of the
Dhaliwal, Spinder (1998). Silent contributors — Asian female entrepreneurs and “economic man”. Ecological Economics, 20, 129–140.
women in business. Women's Studies International Forum, 21(5), 463–474. Metcalfe, Beverly Dawn (2008). Women, management and globalization in
Doukkali, Mohammed Rachid (2005). Water institutional reforms in Morocco. the Middle East. Journal of Business Ethics, 83, 85–100.
Water Policy, 7, 71–88. Morris, Michael H., Miyasaki, Nola N., Watters, Craig E., & Coombes, Susan M.
Essers, Caroline (2007). Entrepreneurship on the public–private divide: (2006). The dilemma of growth: Understanding venture size choices of
Businesswomen of Turkish and Moroccan descent playing family ties. women entrepreneur. Journal of Small Business Management, 44(2),
Paper presented at Reconnecting diversity to critical organization and gender 221–244.
studies critical management studies conference, Manchester, July 11–13, 2007 Muravyev, Alexander, Talavera, Oleksandr, & Schäfer, Dorothea (2009). Entre-
Available on: http://www.mngt.waikato.ac.nz/ejrot/cmsconference/2007/ preneurs' gender and financial constraints: Evidence from international data.
proceedings/reconnectingdiversity/essers.pdf. (Accessed in April, 10, 2012) Journal of Comparative Economics, 37, 270–286.
Euromonitor (2011). Morocco macro data. Euromonitor data base Accessed Ndemo, Bitange, & Maina, Fides Wanjiku (2007). Women entrepreneurs and
in February, 23, 2011. strategic decision making. Management Decision, 45(1), 118–130.
Eurostat (2009). MEDSTAT II: “Water and tourism” pilot study 2009 edition. Observatoire du turisme (2010). Lettre trimestrielle de l'Observatoire du
Eurostat methodologies and working papers. Available in http://ec. Tourisme,18 — décembre 2010 (pp. 1–16).
europa.eu/eurostat. Accessed in March, 28, 2011 Orhan, Muriel, & Scott, Don (2001). Why women enter into entrepreneur-
Faulkenberry, Lisa V., Coggeshall, John M., Backman, Kenneth, & Backman, ship: An explorative model. Women Management Review, 16(5),
Sheila (2000). A culture of servitude: The impact of tourism and 232–247.
development on South Carolina's coast. Human Organization, 59, 86–95. Orser, Barbara J., Riding, Allan L., & Manley, Kathryn (2006). Women entrepre-
Ferrer, M., Alonso, J., Prieto, L., Plaza, V., Monso, E., Marrades, R., et al. (1996). neurs and financial capital. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 30(5),
Validity and reliability of the St George's Respiratory Questionnaire after 643–645.
adaptation to a different language and culture: The Spanish example. Perkins, Ellie., & Kuiper, Edith (2005). Exploration: Feminist ecological
European Respiratory Journal, 9, 1160–1166. economics. Feminism Ecologics, 11, 107–150.
M. del Mar Alonso-Almeida / Women's Studies International Forum 35 (2012) 343–353 353

Rijsberman, Frank R. (2006). Water scarcity: Fact or fiction? Agricultural Veuthey, Sandra, & Gerber, Julien-François (2011). Logging conflicts in
Water Management, 80, 5–22. Southern Cameroon: A feminist ecological economics perspective.
Rocheleau, Dianne (1997). Women, men and trees: Gender, power and property Ecological Economics, 70, 70–177.
in forest and agrarian landscape. World Development, 25, 1351–1371. Weeks, Julie R. (2009). Women business owners in the Middle East and
Rodriguez-Antón, José Miguel, Alonso-Almeida, María del Mar, Celemín, North Africa: A five-country research study. International Journal of
Marisol, & Rubio, Luis (2012). Use of different sustainability manage- Gender Entrepreneurship, 1(1), 77–85.
ment systems in the hospitality industry. The case of Spanish hotels. Woldie, Atsede, & Adersua, Adebimpe (2004). Female entrepreneurs in a
Journal of Cleaner Production, 22(1), 76–84. transitional economy: Businesswomen in Nigeria. International Journal Social
Sadi, Muhammad Asad, & Al-Ghazali, Basheer Mohammad (2010). Doing Economics, 31(1/2), 78–93.
business with impudence: A focus on women entrepreneurship in Saudi World Bank (1995). Water sector in Morocco. Report No: 12649-MOR.
Arabia. African Journal of Business Management, 4(1), 1–011. Washington, DC.
Schein, Virginia E. (2007). Women in management: Reflections and World Bank (2004). MENA development report. Gender and development in
projections. Women in Management Review, 22(1), 6–18. the Middle East and North Africa. Women in the public sphere.
Trung, Do Nam, & Kumar, S. (2005). Resource use waste management in Washington, D.C.: Publication of The World Bank and the International
Vietnam hotel industry. Journal of Cleaner Production, 13(2), 109–116. Finance Corporation.
United Nations (2010). The world's women 2010. New York: Trends and World Bank (2009). Doing business 2010 Morocco comparing regulation in
Statistics. United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. 183 economies. Washington D.C: A copublication of The World Bank and
UNWTO (2010). Tourism and millennium development goals. Available in the International Finance Corporation.
http://www.unwto.org/tourism&mdgsezine/ Accessed on March 8, World Water Assessment Programme (2009). The United Nations world
2011 water development report 3: Water in a changing world. Paris: UNESCO,
UNWTO (2011). International Tourism 2010: Multi-speed recovery. Available in and London: Earthscan.
http://85.62.13.114/media/news/en/press_det.php?id=7331&idioma=E in Yin, Robert K. (1994). Case study research (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA:
www.untwo.org. Accessed in March,11, 2011. Sage.

You might also like