Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Loss and Rediscovery of The Vizier Iuu at Abydos
The Loss and Rediscovery of The Vizier Iuu at Abydos
The Loss and Rediscovery of The Vizier Iuu at Abydos
In his groundbreaking work at Tel el-Dabca, Manfred In celebration of the contributions Manfred
Bietak has provided a prominent example both of Bietak has made and continues to make to the
the importance of considering whole archaeological understanding of ancient Egyptian landscapes and
landscapes in the reconstruction of pivotal periods of their relationship to the writing of history, there-
ancient Egyptian history, and indeed of integrating fore, we offer in this essay an example of how the
the full scope of archaeological, textual and pictorial changing research questions and methodologies of
data in discussions of historical events and historical the late 20th and early 21st centuries can help to
process. His research questions and excavation illuminate more clearly historical problems and
methodologies, therefore, stand in sharp contrast to individuals originally identified in the often haphaz-
the very different goals and techniques prevailing in ard atmosphere of 19th century archaeology in
the 19th century during the formative years of Egyp- Egypt. In particular, we shall focus on the problem
tology as a discipline; and the kind of history that he of the Middle Cemetery at the site of Abydos in
now writes for the Hyksos period and its broader southern Egypt (Fig. 1), where the goals and exca-
chronological context is almost immeasurably richer vation techniques of its earliest excavators shaped
than early scholarly reactions to this phenomenon. the writing of late Old Kingdom ‘history’. The con-
With the incorporation of recently developed and ditions these antiquarians and scholars created on
powerful techniques of geophysical prospection such the ground continue to pose challenges to modern
as magnetic survey, the ability to build a comprehen- excavators seeking to piece together a comprehen-
sive understanding of the spatial dimensions of the sive view of the cemetery landscape and the impli-
Tell el Dabca landscape has increased exponentially. cations of that provincial necropolis within the later
Old Kingdom, including the role and context of European auctions of Abydos stelae of the late 1820s
ancient individuals whose graves were found and and 1830s (SIMPSON 1974: 5–6). LEPSIUS himself was
then “lost” during those early campaigns. interested not in archaeology but in inscriptions and
‘significant’ monuments; his failure to describe Iuu’s
THE VIZIER IUU AND EARLY CAMPAIGNS
or any other tomb structures in the Middle Cemetery
IN THEMIDDLE CEMETERY may well have reflected a disdainful attitude regard-
In his detailed survey of the known inscriptions of ing mud brick architecture, and also the possibility
the late Old Kingdom from Abydos, Brovarski dis- that most of the Old Kingdom remains still lay
cussed the problem of a vizier Iuu, whose tomb was meters below the surface. His description and associ-
“probably located in the Middle Cemetery at Abydos ated map of Abydos site map conveyed a sense of a
… found by Lepsius … in the course of the Prussian vast and jumbled landscape of bricks and mummy
Expedition to Egypt and Nubia in 1842–1845” pieces and With the work of Mariette from
(BROVARSKI 1994b: 24). Because of the paucity of 1858–1876, the ‘face’ of the Middle Cemetery was
contextual information provided by LEPSIUS apart irrevocably altered. Employing hundreds of work-
from a sketch plan and section of Iuu’s shaft and men, Mariette and his deputies initiated a system of
burial chamber (“a square shaft and subterranean deep trenching wherever significant architectural fea-
brickwork burial chamber roofed over with a barrel tures could be discerned, in search of museum-wor-
vault of six courses of mudbrick” [BROVARSKI 1994b: thy objects and inscriptions. This methodology left in
24]), Brovarski concluded that “(e)vidently, no trace its wake massive spoil heaps, one of which apparent-
of a superstructure was found” (BROVARSKI 1994b: ly covered completely the tomb of Iuu. From work in
25). Other than the fact that this Iuu seems to have ‘la necropole du centre,’ which Mariette characterized
been the grandfather of a woman Mezenet, whose as a “high hill,” there emerged a series of inscriptions
stela was found by Mariette more than twenty years for important central government officials of the 5th
after Lepsius’ visit to the site (MARIETTE 1880b: 94), and 6th dynasties (MARIETTE 1880b: 33, 83–95,
little more could be said about his place in the social 507–11; KEMP 1975: 28–41; BROVARSKI 1994a,b),
history of the 5th and 6th dynasties. The dates pro- including the lengthy biography of the 6th dynasty
posed for his vizierate by various scholars have Governor of Upper Egypt Weni the Elder. Mariette’s
ranged from the 5th dynasty to the end of the 6th lack of interest in context resulted in a merely curso-
dynasty, based on his title sequences, the occurrence ry description of the tomb in which Weni’s biogra-
of a similar shaft and chamber type of grave at phy was originally placed (MARIETTE 1880b: 84), and
Saqqara, and the deliberate mutilation of certain an even less informative description of the character
hieroglyphic signs in Iuu’s burial chamber (BROVARS- of the cemetery as a whole (MARIETTE 1880a: 40–41).
KI 1994b: 24, 26–32). Brovarski’s evaluation of these Thus Weni’s inscription, along with others recovered
various lines of evidence led him to summarize that by Mariette, also entered into the writing of Egypt-
Iuu “may have held the vizierate at the end of Pepy ian history stripped of the implications of their orig-
I’s reign but may also have served Merenre as vizier.” inal physical emplacements.
Brovarski concluded, however, that this designation Such was the havoc wrought in the Middle Ceme-
could remain tentative only (1994b: 33). tery by Mariette’s careless methodology that in near-
The decontextualization of an individual’s ly fifty years of further work in North Abydos by a
inscription, the “loss” of his tomb, and thus our abil- variety of British missions, none of these later exca-
ity to situate that particular individual productively vators (with the possible exception of Henri Frank-
within a broader social and political landscape, was a fort [FRANKFORT 1930]) attempted to excavate the
not uncommon by-product of early work in the Aby- part of the Middle Cemetery which had been the
dos Middle Cemetery. Entering Abydos in 1799, focus of his work, describing it as having been rav-
Napoleon’s savants described a vast cemetery land- aged by Mariette’s men (PEET 1914: xiii). They tar-
scape filled with a multitude of ruined brick con- geted instead the northeastern ridge, a now disap-
structions (Antiquités descriptionnés XI: 8–9), an peared prominence of the Middle Cemetery plateau.
impression reflected in the map ultimately published Apparently ignored by Mariette because this ridge
in la Description de l’Egypte (I: 35). By the time of contained no superstructures (and was therefore
Lepsius’ visit to Abydos nearly 40 years later, howev- probably thought unlikely to yield inscriptions), it
er, this ‘built’ landscape had already altered consid- proved to be the location of thousands of simple
erably due to the more or less systematic plundering graves of the later Old Kingdom (GARSTANG 1909;
of the cemetery landscape that resulted in the great PEET and LOAT 1913; LOAT 1923). Working also
The Loss and Rediscovery of the Vizier Iuu at Abydos: Magnetic Survey in the Middle Cemetery 143
Fig. 2 Abydos, the Middle Cemetery. Mastabas in the “high hill” area, excavated in 1999 and 2001. The cross indicates the find spot
of the Iuu door jamb; the number 1 indicates the paving slabs outside the local north wall of the Idi/Nekhty enclosure; the number
2 indicates the possible original emplacement of Mezenet stela (CGC 1567). Map: G. Compton, Abydos Middle Cemetery Project
beyond Mariette’s “high hill” further west on the hundred years after its inception. Excavations there
level portion of the Middle Cemetery plateau, the in 1999 and 2001 confirmed these suspicions, relocat-
excavators discovered hundreds more of these simple ed the ‘lost’ and massive mastaba, shaft and burial
graves of the period in an area they called Cemetery chamber of Weni the Elder (RICHARDS 2001, 2002 a,
E (NAVILLE 1914: 1–11; PEET 1914: 17–29). b, c; 2003), other late Old Kingdom elite complexes,
three examples of what was clearly a series of sub-
FROM 1995: ‘LOST’ TOMBS ARE ‘FOUND ’
sidiary mastabas laid out in carefully planned rows
Thus, between 1876 and 1995, when the University of south of Weni’s tomb, and numerous simple surface
Michigan initiated a field project in the Middle Ceme- burials carefully situated in proximity to these more
tery, there had been no systematic investigation of substantial structures (Fig. 2). It became clear that
the seemingly largely destroyed “high hill” of Mari- this “high hill” was the central part of a complex
ette. Returning to the site in 1995 with very different planned cemetery, established here on previously
goals and methodologies, we sought to understand the restricted ground by officials of the central govern-
character of the late Old Kingdom cemetery as a ment, while the majority of the local population were
whole, and the place of the ‘lost’ individuals of 19th buried off the plateau on the northeastern ridge and
century campaigns within it. The results of a pro- later, on the level plateau local west of the hill. Such a
gram of surface survey of topography, architecture, deliberate partitioning in the use of mortuary space
and ceramic material in the mid 1990s seemed to sug- indicated an idealized, two tiered view of provincial
gest that much remained to be found in Mariette’s society, with literate officials perched for eternity high
area, and that this core area of Old Kingdom elite above the majority of the population, whose simple
graves remained intriguingly sacrosanct for several graves contained no inscriptions (RICHARDS 2002c).
144 Tomasz Herbich and Janet Richards
Fig. 5 Abydos, the Middle Cemetery. Topographic conditions in the “high hill” area. Photography: T. HERBICH, Institute
of Archaeology and Ethnology, Polish Academy of Sciences, for the Abydos Middle Cemetery Project
ly stretching between these four structures, setting out tization that would culminate during the Middle
the cornerstones of the burial ground of two promi- Kingdom hundreds of years later, visible here in the
nent families possessing both material and spiritual encroachment of simpler graves over several genera-
power. The identity of this complex’s owner remains tions into previously rigorously controlled sacred
an open question; but it is quite likely that he was space. This sprawling pattern yields a foreshadowing
related by blood or by marriage to Iuu’s line. Also doc- of the far less partitioned character of the North
umented in alignment with these monumental com- Cemetery at Abydos, which became the primary bur-
pounds were several rows of subsidiary mastabas, with ial ground from the 11th dynasty onward, and in
groups ranged to the south of Iuu and Weni respec- which access to funerary inscriptions spread far
tively, the graves of individuals related to their family beyond the rarefied reaches of ancient high society.
network either by kin ties or by professional affiliation. The blueprint for future research provided by the
Perhaps more compelling was the evidence compelling marriage of new research questions and
revealed by the survey for thousands of shaft and exciting new methodologies such as magnetometry
surface graves, both with and without associated sur- allows us to track the activities not only of previous-
face chapel architecture, spreading outward from this ly ‘lost’ officials such as Iuu and the prominent fam-
central core. This phenomenally vast continuation of ilies to whom his own was linked, but that of the mid-
the lower order cemetery, of which Peet discovered dle and lower class individuals who shared with them
only a very small part in his Cemetery E, was the a total social and political landscape.
very social fabric of Iuu and Weni’s life and times, Yet another aspect of magnetic research worthy of
reflecting the whole regional population of which note is the assistance the method provides in re-local-
they were a part. The magnetometry map reflects izing excavation trenches from a hundred years ago
even more vividly than do previously known data the and in verifying and revising errors and omissions in
sharp increase in local population at Abydos begin- the documentation made at the time. There is every
ning in the later Old Kingdom. It also materializes reason, for instance, to believe that further magnetic
the early stage of a trend towards funerary democra- prospection in a southerly direction will allow us to
The Loss and Rediscovery of the Vizier Iuu at Abydos: Magnetic Survey in the Middle Cemetery 147
Fig. 6 Abydos, the Middle Cemetery. Magnetic map. A – Weni complex; B – Idi/ Nekhty complex; C – the structure that is most
likely the tomb of Iuu; D – the possible remains of a previously unknown Old Kingdom mastaba complex; E – graves appearing
in semicircular arrangement, reminiscent of PEET’s “Cemetery E” map. Map: T. HERBICH, Institute of Archaeology and Ethnol-
ogy, Polish Academy of Sciences, for the Abydos Middle Cemetery Project
pinpoint the exact location of Peet’s Cemetery E ing of the ancient Egyptian landscape during the
excavations: the graves appearing in semicircular later Old Kingdom. Beyond the provincial phenom-
arrangement at the southwestern edge of the mag- enon of the Abydos Middle Cemetery, magnetome-
netic map, marked as E on Fig. 6, are reminiscent of try has facilitated the discovery (or re-discovery) of
Peet’s “Cemetery E” map (PEET 1914: 17)). In anoth- the tombs of the highest officials from the Fifth and
er part of Abydos, that is, in Abydos South, magnet- Sixth Dynasties at Saqqara West, for instance. Geo-
ic survey results have already helped to establish the physical prospection provided the basis for situating
actual size of the temenos of Senwosret III in relation excavation trenches and for locating structures
to the neighboring Middle Kingdom mastabas (see (MYÐLIWIEC, HERBICH and NIWI¼SKI 1995, HERBICH
HERBICH and WEGNER 2003). 2003). Excavating theses structures led to the dis-
covery of the tomb of Meref-nebef, an unknown
CONCLUSION vizier of the same epoch (MYÐLIWIEC 1998).
In the past few years geophysical research – a rela- Undoubtedly, many monuments from this same
tively new tool in the instrumentarium of Egyptolo- period of the Old Kingdom are to be found amidst
gists – has assisted in building a better understand- the dozens of tombs and mastabas discovered in the
148 Tomasz Herbich and Janet Richards
Fig. 7 Abydos, the Middle Cemetery. Reconstruction of the components of Weni the Elder’s tomb showing surface
enclosure and chapel, and subterranean shaft and chamber. Reconstruction: G. Compton, Abydos Middle Cemetery Project
course of magnetic prospecting in other regions of Research Center in Egypt. In Sohag we are grateful
Saqqara and Abusir South (MATHIESON et al. 2002, to Mr. Zein El Abdin Zaki, General Director, Sohag
KÌIVÁNEK and BÁRTA 2003). Governorate; Mr. Mohammed Abdel Aziz, then Chief
The ensemble of these recent discoveries suggests Inspector, El-Balyana, and Mr. Ashraf Abdel Aall
that there is still much to discover about the archae- Okasha, Inspector of Sohag, who acted as Inspector
ology of political and social processes during the late for the Project. Crew members Krzystztof Stawarz
Old Kingdom, and that new research questions and and Geoffrey Compton contributed greatly to the
new techniques of prospection including magnetom- success of the season; and as always Ahmet Rageb
etry will help us to decipher this historical puzzle and the staff of the Pennsylvania-Yale-Institute of
more completely. Fine Arts dig house ensured a comfortable living
environment.
Acknowledgements One of the FM instruments used for the magnet-
The authors would like to thank Dr. Zahi Hawass, ic survey was provided by the Programa de Estudios
Secretary General, Supreme Council of Antiquities, de Egiptologia (Consejo Nacional de Investigaciónes
and members of the Permanent Committee of the Cientíicas y Técnicas) in Buenos Aires on the
SCA for their gracious permission to conduct this grounds of a cooperation agreement with the Polish
work. In Cairo we would also like to thank Mme. Center of Mediterranean Archaeology of Warsaw
Amira Khattab and the staff of the American University in Cairo.
The Loss and Rediscovery of the Vizier Iuu at Abydos: Magnetic Survey in the Middle Cemetery 149
Bibliography