Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

Empowering Teenagers Through

Built Environment Education While 34


Experimenting (In)The Public Space

Oana Paval, Muresanu Monica,


and Mina Sava

Abstract tion channels and to reduce the generational


distances, we started a fellowship program for
Teenagers may not be the most obvious
students in different study fields connected to
left-out category of people, but in the design the built environment (multidisciplinary
and use of public spaces they are often left teams), in order to bring teenagers and young
out. Public space belongs to everyone, yet
adults together. The students became mentors
teenagers seem not to have the means to make for the high school students, in workshops
their voices heard when it comes to demand- they co-designed, aiming to engage them in
ing their own space, which represents their
better understanding and using public spaces.
identities and offers a creative and comfortable It is our belief that the more aware and
environment in which they can socialise and involved teenagers are today, the more active
evolve. De-a Arhitectura Association began to
and responsible citizens they will be
develop the Urban Up educational program in tomorrow.
2016, as a starting point in diversifying its
portfolio with another age group, that of Keywords
teenagers, aiming to be inclusive of all
categories and backgrounds. Throughout the 
Teenagers Built Environment  Education 
past years, Urban Up tried to come before 
Public Space Inclusivity
their need to be more involved and heard,
regarding their wishes and expectations from
the built environment and the public spaces
they use, through different hands-on activities 34.1 Intro—Urban Up in De-a
(extracurricular) and with a design thinking Arhitectura’s Portfolio—The
methodology for improving their schools. Beginning
Trying to constantly find better communica-
Through its activity, De-a Arhitectura Associa-
tion aims to introduce architecture and built
environment education for children and teenagers
O. Paval (&)  M. Monica in the school curricula, as well as to encourage
De-A Arhitectura Association, U.A.U.I.M, and guide teachers to use the built environment
Bucharest, Romania
and architecture as learning resources for other
e-mail: sooana.paval@gmail.com
subjects. It promotes architecture and built
M. Sava
environment education for children, teenagers
De-A Arhitectura, Bucharest, Romania

© The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2023 469
M. Mostafa et al. (eds.), Design for Inclusivity, Sustainable Development Goals Series,
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-36302-3_34
470 O. Paval et al.

and teachers in schools, and it involves profes- new things though not yet corrupted by the
sionals of the built environment in all these monotony and responsibilities of adult life that
processes. The idea of the quality of the built tends to make us become idle to problems that
environment as a civic responsibility is a core we don’t perceive as our own. As adults, we
value of the organisation. De-a Arhitectura has a seem to lose the awareness regarding the impact
large network of built environment professionals the built environment has upon us, we take
who enjoy sharing knowledge with children and everything as a given and we only focus on our
teenagers involved in our programs regarding day-to-day routines. We also become less intro-
elementary notions of architecture and urbanism, spective than teenagers and easily ignore how
through direct observation and analysis of the our own behaviours impact the built environ-
built environment we live in and also apply these ment, public spaces, nature and other people.
notions in a common creative process, to benefit For teens, “there are simply more things
from the results of their work and communicate happening than at any other time—a teenager is
them. The teaching and learning methods are neither a child nor an adult, but a complex
experiential and rely on creativity, curiosity, mixture of both. These years are not a gap—
communication skills and team spirit. rather they are a wonderfully exciting collision
Another purpose of De-a Arhitectura is to when all the different strands of our life get
increase the visibility of the architects' profession tangled together in a way that will never happen
in society, starting with the school environment again.” (Bainbridge 2010). This amazing com-
and also by continuously training architecture bination of emotions and experiences leads to a
and built environment professionals to better perspective that can contribute to improving the
communicate with a broader audience. environment and space in an inspired and con-
De-a Arhitectura Association started as a structive way, in understanding things in a cre-
working group in 2011, when the six founding ative way.
members wrote the “De-a Arhitectura [Playing Considering all of the above and based on our
architecture] in my city” course, for children in previous experiences and conclusions, in the fifth
the 3rd and 4th grades. The NGO was legally year of activity, 2017, the De-a Arhitectura
formed in 2013, and it had the optional class Association launched a new project, Urban Up!
“De-a Arhitectura [Playing architecture] in my Built Environment for High-School Students.
city” approved, after the pilot year, 2012. In the Through this new project, the activities portfolio
following years, the portfolio of De-a Arhitectura gained another age group, that of high-school
Association diversified with a new course for students. The idea of the project that led to the
first years of school—De-a Arhitectura Mini, birth of the Urban Up program arose because of
many club activities, more cities, schools and the little knowledge teenagers have about the way
professionals involved in the programs, but the environment we live in is altered.
mainly targeting children between 6 and 12 years
old. Before the Urban Up program, over 3600
school children, 135 volunteer architects and 140 34.2 Urban Up! Built Environment
teachers were reached. for High-School Students—
Reducing discrepancies between the way Outcomes
professionals understand the built environment
and the way the broad public does is the key to a The intention of the project was to bring knowl-
better built environment. After the first years of edge and shape attitudes about the values of the
activity, it became more and more obvious that built environment, sustainable development and
there is a particular category of users we can the role of young people in the processes of
address, the most present ones in the public transformation that affect their cities. The curric-
space, the teenagers. They are specific users that ula and workshop activities were designed to help
are still passionate, curious and willing to learn the high school students acquire skills to learn
34 Empowering Teenagers Through Built Environment Education While Experimenting … 471

how to learn, to communicate and to be part of a interests, how to design, imagine and present
team, meanwhile becoming citizens aware of the those places, how accessible certain areas are, in
built environment, as well as promoters of posi- their city, etc. (Fig 34.1).
tive changes in their cities. The project was
Workshop B—A project for my city & City tour
implemented between April and December 2017.
The 54 workshops took place in 7 cities in The main idea that the participants synthesised
Romania—Bucharest, Braşov, Sibiu, Cluj- after this workshop was that the space of the city
Napoca, Timişoara, Iaşi and Constanţa, and they is something concrete that influences each of
reached 1025 high school students. A total of 26 them, just as they can also influence the city,
built environment professionals (architects, city even though not as much as they get to have an
planners, engineers, anthropologists) were train- impact on their own space at home. The first part
ers of the 4 workshops briefly described below. of the workshop was a role-playing game where
some of the characters were those who decide
Workshop A: Monument, who are you? & Anti-
how to spend public money for new projects in
boredom map
the city. They found out how our cities transform
Through interactive exercises, the participants and how decisions are made on projects regard-
better understood how cities are transformed, ing the city. The second part of the workshop
why they should care about the quality of the was wrapped as a challenge to brand their city
built environment, why heritage matters, which and explain it to others as such, through a guided
are the relevant and exciting places to spend time tour for anyone who would like to better know
together with other citizens who have similar the places they like best.

Fig 34.1 Anti-boredom map exercise in Bucharest at Galateca Gallery, November 2017
472 O. Paval et al.

Workshop C—Not in the mood today & The 34.3 Follow-Up—The City and The
claimed city Professions of the Built
One topic of this workshop was to identify the
Environment
links between the built environment and the
physical and emotional state of those who use it. The purpose of the city and the professions of the
The participants presented their own personal built environment project was to raise interest
opinions and observations regarding the aspects and attract the attention of high school students
that influence the quality of life in their cities. towards the city, and also to offer teaching and
They analysed the existing facilities in some learning methods, already tested in 2017. The
areas of their cities and determined if they are methods could also be used by teachers, NGOs
sufficient for the inhabitants. They got to com- and public local authorities, since the built
pare and contrast places they like and places they environment can really be a fruitful research and
don’t and to find arguments why some places are reflection topic. This follow-up project was also a
appreciated by others, but not by them, using a means to reiterate the intention of our approach
space analysis criterion that the built environ- towards projects for teenagers and young adults.
ment professionals use. Also, besides objective It was a way to raise awareness that the teen-
criteria, the participants had to pay attention to agers' perspective on the built environment
the way that perception influences us differently, should matter. The project was carried out by the
based on each person’s sensitivity and personal De-a Arhitectura Association in 2018, under the
experience, learning to be more empathic with Urban Up! umbrella, in partnership with
those that don’t share their perceptions and Bucharest City Hall through the Center for
opinions. Educational and Sports Projects (PROEDUS)
Workshop D—Wheeled access & Defendant city and “Ion Mincu” University of Architecture and
Urban Planning (UAUIM).
After this workshop, the participants might have Why another project for high school students?
become more interested in influencing the deci-
sions made for the harmonious and inclusive Because we considered that it was important to
development of the city, because they better continue to cultivate their knowledge about how
understood how the city influences our everyday our living environment is changing, it was an
life, even if we are not typical users. First, the opportunity to create contexts for teenagers to
city was either accused by a prosecutor’s team of meet active and passionate professionals of the
diminishing the quality of life of its inhabitants built environment who are examples of social
engagement. It was meant to be a framework for
or defended by a team of lawyers. The best
argued side was decided by a jury which gave the them to practice and develop their social and
verdict in the end. During the second part of the civic skills, and critical analysis, while demon-
strating social integration behaviours. One
workshop, the students followed an itinerary
through an urban area nearby either pushing a objective was to empower teenagers to have a
stroller, in a wheelchair or pulling luggage. So, proactive attitude and take their own educational
path into their own hands.
the participants got to experience a certain area in
terms of accessibility and gained more experi- The participants, over 100 high school stu-
ence in analysing the city. dents from 20 high schools in Bucharest, expe-
rienced one or more workshops and were very
34 Empowering Teenagers Through Built Environment Education While Experimenting … 473

enthusiastic to interact with the students from continue in Sibiu, after winning a competition on
“Ion Mincu” University of Architecture and the Social Agenda of the Sibiu City Hall and
Urban Planning, on their grounds, in the uni- being shortlisted in another competition, but the
versity studios. For the teaching staff of the formal request they both had did not align with
university and the architects who took part in the our objectives enough, so we decided to put
project, meeting the high school students was a things on hold. Meanwhile, focusing towards a
chance to ``feel'' the pulse of the young genera- new target age group, that of young adults,
tion, soon to be active in the fields of the built became an objective on the agenda of De-a
environment, either as future professionals or as Arhitectura Association and after a general
beneficiaries or users of urban spaces. assembly in 2020 a dedicated work group was
formed. We already had a strong identity and the
Urban Up! platform, so it became obvious that
34.4 The Need for Urban Up Urban Up! needed to grow up, bringing youths
to Grow Up (With a Fellowship side by side with teenagers in our educational
for University Students) projects.
The first priority was to upgrade the age
“Teenagers have a language of their own” as De group, so we decided to also address students.
Bruce J. Gevirtzman says, and this language and They are closer in age with teenagers who usu-
their preferences make them into these exuberant ally look up to them, and their knowledge and
personas that have the energy to change and interest in the city can be a relevant means to
colour the world with fantabulous ideas. More share knowledge. The idea of a fellowship was
so, when teenagers become involved in a the one through which to best bring together
movement or project, they engage both younger teenagers and students, and it was also the best
and older people in their lives in the immersive approach to empower the students into taking
story they create, often surprised by their fresh action. The aim of this particular fellowship was
angle or perspective on things. to engage the students in a co-design process of
Since 2018, Royal Institute of British Archi- new urban pedagogy educational scenarios for
tects (RIBA) has started an extensive national high school students’ workshops. The call for
program to educate children about the built participants was launched in April 2022. It was
environment in British schools, something that not only dedicated to students from fields related
the De-a Arhitectura Association has been doing, to built environment and urban studies but also
with the support of architects, for quite some connected study fields, aiming for a diverse,
time. Any educational program and project about interdisciplinary group of fellows. 30 students
the city and the built environment is a plus in the with different backgrounds applied (urban plan-
education of young people, regardless of the ning, architecture, psychology, educational sci-
profession they will choose in the future, because ences, anthropology) and following a selection
they will be either our colleagues or the benefi- process, 26 fellows were selected. Some of our
ciaries of the proposed projects by us and in both selection criteria were their motivation regarding
situations, they must be able to make informed interdisciplinary and participatory processes,
decisions. their interest in the life of the city, their civic
The excitement of the 2017 project and the involvement or the potential to do so and their
feedback we received from over 1000 high willingness to pass on the concept of active cit-
school students that took part in the workshops, izenship to high school students.
as well as the energy we received from them and The Urban Up Fellowship was structured in
their creative and honest outcomes, made it clear three modules: module 1—Inspiration and
that Urban Up! has to become an umbrella for forming teams based on common interests,
diverse projects dedicated to teenagers and module 2—Co-creation of the educational sce-
youths. In 2019, we had some attempts to narios, and module 3: test and pilot in workshops
474 O. Paval et al.

with high school students. The first and second feedback sessions, the students translated the
modules took place in May 2022, at the begin- presented ideas into clearly structured workshop
ning and at the end of the month, so that the third scenarios which were afterwards tested through
module that meant to test and pilot the co- role-play and each team got to facilitate parts of
designed workshops could take place during the their scenarios, while the other teams got to
summer. impersonate high school students. The fellows
The first module took place at and mentors went through the rights and obli-
ExpoHUB OARB (headquarters of the Bucharest gations of citizenship, imagined that they had
Territorial Branch of the Romanian Order of their own political party and took it upon them-
Architects) and was meant to inspire the fellows selves to solve some problems in the city, dis-
and to expose them to diverse intertwined con- cussed mobility by wearing the hats of different
texts and initiators with interdisciplinary stakeholders, looked for social and spatial land-
approaches in their fields of work. The 14 guests marks as starting points for conversations about
from different organisations presented some of heritage and walked around the area and felt the
their initiatives that changed the life of the city city at their feet looking for subjective details that
for the better. The main topics our fellows got in bring it to life. The simulations were followed by
touch with were inclusive design, empathy and another feedback session, so that the workshop
vulnerable users (AMAis, Active Watch), quality scenarios could be finalised while integrating the
of the built environment and good design (the useful feedback.
Order of Romanian Architects, Dizainăr), The third module took place during the sum-
bottom-up initiatives (the Cișmigiu Civic Initia- mer. It started in June, with a workshop led by
tive Group, the Legacy Bucharest community the Sustainable Mobility Team in a city centre
centre), documenting urban experiences (Vira park, in Bucharest, where 12 high school stu-
Association) and sustainable mobility (Bate dents from 3 different schools participated. In
Șaua, Hai cu Bicla). After their presentations, our August, all 5 teams of fellows got the chance to
guests were divided in three, covering the fol- test their workshop scenarios in Năvodari, a
lowing large sustainable development topics: small town by the Black Sea, in a high school
social, economic and environmental. The fellows students' summer camp. Representatives from all
got to have informal conversations regarding the teams were there to pilot their scenarios, and
their own interests on these topics in a world cafe they had the chance to receive constant feedback
format. The world cafe format, in which the from the same group of 20 teenagers of different
participants have the opportunity to visit each ages and from different places in Romania. The 5
table, ensures an informal, dynamic and interac- workshops were the people of the city—aiming
tive relationship, a two-way exchange of ideas to create a frame for understanding how the city
and a networking opportunity. influences the quality of life of its inhabitants; the
The team-forming process was also a partici- heritage of the city—aiming to encourage teen-
patory result meant to create an organic option agers to appropriate the concept of heritage by
for the fellows, based on their areas of interest understanding it in a personal key; the nature in
aligned with the 5 previously defined subtopics: the city—aiming to overlay the sensorial per-
heritage conservation, ecology, sustainable ception of the urban space on the presence or
mobility, inclusivity and good governance. absence of nature and how this impacts each of
Between the first and second modules, the us; city governance—aiming to contribute to the
fellows, guided by each team’s mentors, turned civic involvement of young people, with the
their ideas into workshop scenario drafts, as a concept of common interest at its core, being a
work base for the second module. During the very relatable concept in relation to the built
second module, the fellows presented their ideas environment; sustainable mobility in the city—
and received feedback both from the mentors of developed around the importance of inclusive
all 5 teams and their peers. Following the design and a city for all.
34 Empowering Teenagers Through Built Environment Education While Experimenting … 475

Some of the opinions voiced by the high interaction of children and young people with
school students through the anonymous feedback cultural heritage and archaeological sites and to
form they filled are “I gained a different image enrich architectural education with informal
regarding the city and its buildings, the green practices.
spaces, etc”, another student said: “I'm glad that I Also, in 2021 two of the members of the De-a
managed to better observe the things that sur- Arhitectura team (authors of the current essay)
round me. Although some notions were repeated submitted a project to ARCUB (a public cultural
more, this helped us to better understand them” institution in Bucharest) through which they
(targeting the content). A student commented proposed to initiate a participatory planning
about the activities: “They put us in motion, and process for public spaces, with and for teenagers.
it wasn't something boring where it only included In 2022, it was selected to be funded and it was
theory. It's easier to learn through practice.” One implemented in November and December. The
of their colleagues mentioned: “We managed to call addressed Bucharest high school students
get out of the visual sphere and differently per- and 15 spots were available, but in the end, we
ceive the world we live in.” On the collaboration had the pleasure to meet 19 participants. The
with the fellows, the teenagers said: “It was a project brought teenagers, students and profes-
pleasure to meet them and exchange knowledge. sionals together for 3 days of hackathon, where
One of the coolest parts of the camp” as well as both high school and university students assisted
“Super nice. I love their enthusiasm and dedi- to presentations of the guests on topics such as
cation to what they study.” urban acupuncture and micro interventions in the
public space, inclusive design, recovered places
and spaces through versatile design proposals,
34.5 Still Growing Up—Recent democracy of the public space, social vulnera-
Projects bility, the 15 minutes neighbourhood and cities
for happy people.
The fellows that facilitated the workshops during The TU_act project involved 10 Urban Up
the Năvodari summer camp manifested their fellows in different stages: 8 as mentors and
interest and availability for continuing to facili- ``translators'' of the high school participants’
tate their workshops from now on and also to be ideas in concrete proposals, 1 in the team of
a part of other Urban Up! projects we have on the authors for the contest brief and 1 in the jury
agenda. All 5 student-developed scenario pro- team.
posals are creative and have the potential to grow The nineteen students were organized in five
into lasting programs, not just single workshops. different teams. In the week that followed the
The 5 teams will have the opportunity to coor- hackathon they submitted a proposal that illus-
dinate the workshops in different contexts: in trated their vision on the urban acupuncture
high schools, at cultural events, at local com- intervention for a public space, of their choice.
munity events, etc. We also want to implement The main focus of the proposal was on the needs
the educational scenarios during the Different of their specific group and the needs of their
School Week program, starting with the 2022- peers, in relation to the chosen urban space.
2023 school year. Teenagers like to use the urban space as a vessel
Another growing direction for Urban Up is for their creative ideas, and they should be
through an international Erasmus+ project— encouraged to explore and shape the space as they
Palimpsest Cities, in which 2 fellows that already see fit for their use and different types of activi-
have a bachelor's degree joined our team. Some ties. The five proposals were team 1—Urban
of the project objectives are to raise awareness Glade, team 2—modulOM, team 3—Hangout,
about local cultural values at a higher education team 4—Take a Break Here and team 5—Our
level by focusing on future architects, conserva- Spot. The 3 projects awarded by the jury were as
tors and interior architects, to increase the follows: 1st prize was won by team 5 (Fig. 34.2),
476 O. Paval et al.

Fig 34.2 Extract from the contest proposal of theme 5—our spot (Spotu' nostru)

2nd prize was won by team 1 and 3rd prize was spaces, separate together. Our proposal amplifies
won by team 2. many perspectives gathered in the same place.
The teenagers in team 5 described their We felt like bringing a direct path to a gate
approach as follows: “Once we found our chosen unopened yet, to link to existing trails. Through
spot, we started to interact with it and we dis- the created portal we turn a simple crossing over
covered its potential to be valued. We aimed to from one side to another to an event. We felt that
bring the invisible layers forward, the ones that this place is intimate but open. There, you feel
not every person passing by notices. The wall surrounded by people but alone, with yourself.
(there since the 70’s when there was a building Through modular urban furniture (adaptable and
site here) is both a limit and a link between two multifunctional) we preserve this character. The
34 Empowering Teenagers Through Built Environment Education While Experimenting … 477

modules can be moved around considering the in their cities. They are not simple users of the
activities there, and so we create a diversity of urban layout and have their own vision and
experiences. (...) This is how we ended up with a benefits out of the interactions in (with) the urban
simple result, but complex at the same time, with space, individualised to the various activities
many hidden messages and interpretable they carry out in the city.
symbols.” Throughout our projects in the Urban Up
The jury, formed of 3 built environment pro- program, we aim to continue to bring teenagers,
fessionals and an urbanism student and Urban Up students and professionals together and to offer
fellow, considered that Our Spot proposal con- high school and university students a platform to
vinces primarily through the choice of place: a express their needs and ideas with regard to their
non-place, located next to the traffic flow of the inclusion in public space and in society while
area, a space neither public, nor private or part of they are young and not necessarily yet taxpayers
the park, enhanced with multipliable, flexible and or voters.
relatively readily available means.
All five proposals were very brave and cre-
ative and all 8 mentors, students in architecture, Bibliography
interior architecture and urbanism, considered
that they also had a lot to learn from the teams of Bainbridge D (2010) Teenagers: a natural history. Porto-
teenagers they guided and supported throughout bello Books Ltd.
Brice Heath S (1999) Rethinking youth transitions
a week of developing ideas. Some of the mentors everyday courage: the lives and stories of urban
said that they were really impressed by their teenagers by Niobe Way. Human Dev 42(6):376–382
initiative and determination and also by their Bugarič, B (2018) Urban acupuncture treatment: Imple-
awareness regarding important themes of today’s menting communication tools with youth in Ljubljana
suburbs. Urbani Izziv 29(Special Issue: Public Spaces
society, like social justice and equity, climate For Local Life):95–108
change, gender studies, and even politics and Coleman J (2021) The teacher and the teenage brain.
civic engagement, and they do not remember to Routledge
have been so aware as teenagers. De a Arhitectura (2018) Mediul construit—material
didactic şi experienţe educaţionale
The scenario of the Teens Urban Acupuncture De a Arhitectura (2017) Jurnal urban up, 2017 retrieved
project that consists of a hackathon followed by January 12, 2023, from Jurnal Urban Up!—de-a
an ideas contest is designed to be repeated in the arhitectura (de-a-arhitectura.ro)
years to come and even in other cities in De a Arhitectura (2022) School projects, retrieved
October 10, 2022, from de-a arhitectura—toghether
Romania perhaps, in other countries. we bring architecture to schools! (de-a-arhitectura.ro)
Feinstein S (2009) Secrets of the teenage brain: research-
based strategies for reaching and teaching today′s
34.6 Conclusions adolescents. Corwin Press
Gevirtzman B (2008) An intimate understanding of
America’s teenagers: shaking hands with aliens. BC-
All in all, teenagers are part of the local com- CLIO
munity, and communities shape and adapt space Jensen FE, Nutt AE (2015) The teenage brain: a
to their own needs. By understanding how local neuroscientist’s survival guide to raising adolescents
and young adults. Harper Collins
development happens, youths will become more Lawson L, McNally M (1995) Putting teens at the center:
aware of what they can do in the future and will maximizing public utility of urban space through
be able to have an impact on improving their youth involvement in planning and employment.
cities, according to their creative demands and Child Environ 12(2):209–221. Children's Gardens
and Children in Farming
expectations. In the future, we aim to contribute Moshman D (2011) Adolescents and their teenage brains.
to engaging high school students in the decision- Human Dev 54(4):201–203
making processes related to urban development Palfrey J, Gasser U (2016) Born digital. Basic Books
478 O. Paval et al.

Simpson B (1997) Towards the Participation of Children Way N (1998) Everyday courage: the lives and stories of
and Young People in Urban Planning and Design. Urban teenagers. NYU Press
Urban Stud 34(5/6):907–925 White R (1993) Youth and the conflict over Urban Space
Verovšek Š, Juvančič M (2009) Identifying spatial values in in children’s. Environments 10(1):85–93
the opinions of teenagers. Urbani Izziv 20(1):164–174

You might also like