gl (cognitive paradigm) Qual! 255450 I de GIS La yal Janay ta gles Lal J, aL lalla Sc Zl be 6S Se ahd SE LI pHs Clegagl in peling Je uy Stig naan Lyaaig lade ads ala quit patlate i haan! Cl! tol ty! tage! Gaal) abaly Je Ja] Paes. -tT| il 8 Ud Bioly SEL 5 LI ell ae age Rng Sy spy) ag alll iH olsen GanLANGOUN ntl Jas ga5 nc 5 as La gas ga | oo | i ie uals Fey Al |W pty 1s (eit pos kegel Soll algal 28 to ABN SET “ | S| eis ual oi yas Io al ga Bal CAD Ld Cah ho ane y ky Boley aids Gall Lau Nn Ja GS Bd gla S Eyhy OLD ge lly a 8 Bill pose fled GegyacnNS Col Uae kp gil ColN Bla] Shas pe UG Sool 0 gar ola g8 le ole pale Stegall cegisdl Jai |) MI 3 oe atl iz Le @ —iiiiinmy LJ Get Lia Healy CAALIN Sly Jl galas ta nang Zell by IV Sal gel anne By Saye Stele ob 9 Seal th ot BBW El IM Ged oo a yet Canby laa gag Sat gl ed ew et be Ayal Any Cheb ame Se Haha Lai Cle yz Jas Al Skat pnely a) Sh La SASL SN iat i Byatt ey BOLAb29 eC Aas SE bys sy She Sy Lawton Ctl Aaa Ul ley tia ga Ola iyalt Jud (ta Segdieisasari ip(ele ere. plat JuciY Gilad saatichgai¥ legal tal Sagi Bug Oa Crea ail shadnn &B sept ye OES Bifold GEA MILAN GUI Gl gS AM estat ge eS : pole at ott 2021 gaa ASU LS gl Jail 2b 978 - 9938 - 942 -53-8 :4.¢.3.3 Aes AW pe BI ee ao ehagh i pal Nang J USI © idl yo ib aL hopcais Gretelpea 9 edaglgatis| SL] GldLey pled G3 gaye Gall Gib zg Yo oe Seg HALE sod ily lel lad gasps ULE GS gd 118 2 (1973) galge Ge «Sag yeSte 751 Blally Sala! Lnghy Blow Lagh suogs gS ade xcesall pl Go i a yale 30 go 2002) Sy Syl eal Ll ques glasdl dsygal UYAN fy BB gual acid OMe ng dB yall Layo 5 Boumcall gall! Cowl! Banqaall Synally Syl gaily Clee Ul Last Gy ogi! DY cla Jy Zelda yeally Bla uslatedl pile dabasitly pSdsll A SElL sg gael Goins LS) yoS Cyn i] agg! yall gley 275 o (2002) Saisiepene) Uy GLAD appl op Re ye ta Se | OLS o» OBS Ur dF Se sl IV sete ans ath alll J ay GY yee gard 1 alt! ase tobe qa gl Lia Jf jelly Lola) oles dE ye abet sepa cael fo tpl) dat ge Cah all + OS eye sll jee J Je BUI 390 Cigneb) abs Lagle CailST ol pe op glad B ye ge be I Of gbL Lis age y WHE We Lb ae Fall (BILAL 5 dele dud l ee pelos Gale etal lest fo Last wesls Lee eg hl clef Lin hy Lad Heel UI gi en Jp ely pe gle Lab olaaial Bhi clash opal dng sly Sp aig tee ASI sib GJ ey Minas gor Bele Keds clglalss I ULatl of Fa gl gl paar ASU gee ye (tly SLAY 9 ge oye paral OL ely gy ol I pl ly dey AS gpa AlN UL eng shin ilyBi y cal ¢ ple Lends spl ¢lall $US Sly O] UH OT Ey gh lng pee Ql al Lali WLadly 6 Gils sm al AT ls pple Win oT (1992) pedgaen9Ss 8 LET LS eget by de ll Gall ye oe eee 9S GU gael Ae NES hy Ge ANI Dd Lis gj (naturalism) ab ik ys SEY aay Le hy gl pa si ¢ hal vahe pl Jo pall tol te LALA yey lal OSM tery Fo par Ses cp gall ae IS tLe hel She dt phy Gilg Joeléll J gb gas Bald ellis ccgl ya yas y ality CALE a leg ab ple gt Le ple pplall JS Hlgesity Males OSU ey Al img pf Leb! ew J] BLS] pled! golall Gell aii ety sla .2iee Bunge (2011) ge dg [S cle plally pA ae Se ables sd Sam Sle gle 23 gill -LYIUT ig 9 Ga go aiid y te Ly pl flo AT OS J] BLS] POS phy ALE cay goodly SNL Lely tel ee pal ay ae Gel a 1 AUS gay geenlly OLY Heel ppl ee ye JS GALLS ge Gti apa DEY LS obs lary bt & Al ll tly Jae Lad JAH Vl shee bes golll 9 Spall GLY Lal eee eee. G2l gral Ugetel i) edhe 6] Dep le cLpe aL Gaal LSA Js O} hyde Ey US Dd GabWI-LA, Gal ob SU Jes, ade, Sea ga Del oe ge Lei gl pill FAI a dal 8SAN asl a ls 2 alll Ladle ale ge pads Yoke obs S72) gl MoM dale ge Vy cally Gl Ab Ll JAB Gale ge Vy Mabe Biny pole Alb JS Lyi 1S pall gy otal pants ll (guably rae ly ye Rb AE IF ce leet ons J gy ISIE IS Jy ay eat any oa JS el Le a hae ele Ole oye WOU ey BD gata OLSY pyle Dole y | SUBD p sla esl py fale] Le BIL Ny pay le Ue pS A lf eo pad Cl; Le ll Gal pyle Webel ce yay op slal Oy prball Jradll tl |S dajalis 5 nl oe Some § 61992 dee Sperber nw HS ad s1 (S cde Gill ogg SEs a pall Spor Gs tld eS el oe eg kets pple ole Ube Of dae GLU oe 05S Gl aA pl Gp whe oS ybl es, US Obl ae Mga, Sa ANI, AE yy LIS alas y ole pd ye selaslly AAU LST Lede at UD LEVY Gad oI cl aly AS nb A ol glly deal y «piltlly «0 glally cdiailly Bjeee abel BH ILE see pW KY Key pall 6 ne ds So Bye TSB goleal po yet Leg iz dal ‘Ebel fps aN LAR ow Ne Hell La NN all LT le Le yall BN go Ys AAR GS ye a el coal Cal ll Lay SOUS y La J [gard ye Ley £05] a U alld iS AAS abe ph des Y $i gl ow 5 ol gl ll gs oli AS Mys LK! Regd Se oll Ohad 5 UI UW yey DWE BEL ayet By shail 9sige le ed ele a Ly eee Ab die G ll # bo! Ny pall Ole Spaat Alls a2 Ut Wgdecyb AUREL UW Jha ly egcerean 1dyle bebe he sie I al ijee gj Seal Cod ine Ve pag DALI 1O.g AS ad Le CI te enc oS Sas Jo eget 9A Ny Qa dey BY ces Bl Je pid Gaited! gall Gi UT Lada stall es Mla ey 4 SbF LOLY igeley Gale dgrly sovelerl Cater ly Oe Yo ey Lele all oll pat gh ole J BG SEM LY! EB gl yg pall Ie JL gaby ge Uy alse agAll ao ell ple she gl Gl ak ga Gla galll lI Wingy hae alg al ill gl Jb pte elena gil eel Je ples 43a O92 beler Vi ULSI ne gs es gh ee da ge 5H al Ogu gS) apes PLAN O99 Kell BST Ul LLL S pljail Leas ge SIL ot ES Ge AB A Be gl Seals ety a eh tll OL chap pal toll Lng oye palestl Cs Gall GL oo Elba jglesd JN ob cals alle lel ans cand Leh ty SeaaBl jal fl aad Jo — sll dally GLIA fal U5 EL) Gil Ll U,S5 [S agalll grasll Veayry SK] S5! psi Ue Gola Wy GLY) Cee La Leb GE TS all ppl eS Coed lng ay aT Segall Gall LY ad Of gpl J aT Sey le aL ara chs OVE fom oy eM Jed cyt tas J HAN OLS aS all Stl fed 10AS a ghtiy pS ple ole lo pba) ise It Lalall ISLA Jos cy ist poball idee Jat gy pal SUbY! gee Hall HLYI Me J) jbl ee Wi ye is Last ae ele» (cognitive paradigm) Li pas Led sail gla ty BA pl tas SSF hbk 5S tte 9 Bere, (new naturalism) layer PS asl pyle G pg Vol pay eet da all LLL gs ace wo Be loll OA ge Saye Aad) Gall nb Gale JS Od \s ‘ee OS J GAD Neurath Obi shsl ge Fs HL Gals ii hl 50 onal 5 gt Leal ace atl Sain Be JS leh Sin ee Bye ctl spall al By Ble, sf eLaSY) aie i508 ge aN ole oy eectane dee gee coat tll G8 Weel ol po 5S Se yo BY petted Ol po gets Gldall Jo Ise Vie oad phe gg Le ae cy USES Ly Ri peeps dys AIL hey LLU ye LAE el ll gabe ll Uy glee peg wobec ghey 45s sels i all will poss) alee sda CB pH Deer ell fo DVM Vite (oa aly dy gla, pithy spall tle gooll gbliy| Je dat gay LeU Vie Co nl Bally Ba Gall gM Goi dat yo WAZ LS eda clu! i Jo SYS DY 4 by gl cok gill gg fel byl els en CAS fed all 2 eM tole LE GIS AI silo ete DS) pall See YoY Sy tats GS TAL Sy UN Ob el ye 20 pl Healyo VY] 0955 AT Sag V Ugeel yo OF ory dd aad 25, eb Jo ULL OS iy 1Vy dapes Ld a8 Gee bed SUI Si V GNF yo Leased dolce 312015) ISS Sp lS ey pra DV Bd SEM oladl bebe ot le Bae Jo pee J gl AL ele Wy lee all da Jo 555 weg 5 All pl tie pe EB pobal 1D sal ¢ ge bengal Lal 5) pane OUST Le Js 03] Ke uA G cond IE gy SLAY) Lele Vlg gba sD gal egles Gna ange Mey 2grey, Dsl ad I Sally Ga ds sgl ell ee poled ae Lys CLAY yee cigall lel Ue pala dry pg Ula dst S Nh 3, py ASLAM yo Deal CLI Wa fo SV gel ceed UST Ul yewets oly! BE g ULaall ela platy cp olsal MLS lel Ml fe IY» cep clas G UjaF tery egy Ua odes «pel pl 2 pall Ula lel YA ally Ene AI DVL gle J) BS) gy» Gls ae ys GA lege ll gall Ge yf fhe Woe op po yh lly Ui DU Gb ge Le gL) eB Ose ys sel asl gill gLAHM ell GIS Gee Aker ne AS el ge il gall a ana (ig ye nahh omy Je OS: pS dle gy ese yy ISU] LL T ay ogi JOlde a pa late oped lia sp Va pr sSh Si fob dey yes gail golall ell o+ isle besly Old jb Bln UAE oye Lge Ly V Low J dead SGM pall Hele pala G ell ie Bla oy |S ee LE AL A nen: pad plat ol Jo outs I pla G Gls We GLY Oy ge gap V Lasher Eb lated See ols op ancl pls ge oe LAY Belarc gall gel ODE 2AEA Shel ASI Ell EY Sly Seal Geb as Al ge J BONUS eh pe pale I oy Lal aes all Egil OU! a ble, i gale gl Ol od lS pl SRS cine Us ely I HE Aone JRA a ll by ale] G salad le clea US cat od pay bd ssl ll gal edad dad cpantny Gall cB 0! J slab gy GU aad GUI OL LT esl On Whe g ine gather UNI alll GF etyi pad By Sh] Fy ple page oe UI ab Jes al le aU pgles Alege deny ls gabe pling co plait canes Ae pl pit eo ol pately UpSUS 2107 ag pel Fy yall el oy Spal (Se Tae pyle ley sgl USA al pl Lil 5 rel GS etsy Copal ey ge aK he gay EB all pghall G UHL! Bu! oll ne Gad aig Lgl Lee Ley te gf ULES Sal Wb] Jy Ge Sarda pgball J Goel Lite qette toly Gai J ale yl dais Gols AS ghilly Lele Vy Helly Fe get anal IIE oe chy ia J OLLI cll fo Jue |S Ve std lal on Ue, BAU po Al ype Seed Gael oh oH GSE OLE ay tl ple 2a aI DY dey ay mee Geel gall ge yl pad HU Joaiy dally Wgeity UY obs 3 all, paily US1291 GLY) ibs, BUSY Aare danly JI DY ASW DYo 9 5 pall ALsYl SLT UES] ode Jats y Gale olaley pe lel paty BUI Le go pred sloth paige st misldl leg pail Geis pHi ab gy pad 2 yb apr y lp lLSI LAS Lay chagdall O1ALl) Ad fe ans dopa spe Gales g ll ee a 13AIG Gy pull be gy WIE Ul ot lpr de Jo Bally pad badly AS HH fiat Shel Ola ye Lad EIN Jel Jas Nabe panda aly) all GLUT jaa ol es oy Aas eb gl gb SUN Lobe y cla Sa ghey al dy pat Iriel fo lade legs Gabe ad ay HOlyhl ge Slag sly SAU asl pny ba BU il UT Sak pl dell Steal em dey apa go Ade ne Je ps Rap clingy inna eo ALS Winget ald pada tat / 2 sea QaNU aah Jas lea lle aD lang Be] Gpesal Sez ANS all Spal paw cits rail J sty NB che peat Rell Gla Yay Layee ly pall CS Li] Jo all Jig Ae Seb aT aL Usleuis $ Joel sh of Len, AS gate 52,8 lb A KER AS ge CU ey pel ANd I FF GA AE I peal alle ALB i ge hay ell EY BGY Lat Jes gil aS All DEY a pal gen Sous 62 jSlag sill Ol fo pis gill Atl aad HS FAM Lolly Sle ole, fo 5 pre La cel per dem fe Leal By pall ag all Jol gl gen cash AST ll all ee de as gt Ll ge A Is all all ds Jelisd ALE by pay E12] polar ge G21) begat ow de J Ob okie oye jp eo Sng gl go yy pal ST AE ey 5 ge bps ee ALB gt Ub Ne lS 2 cap BUM Sate lew lb set Ald (arly 5SU ESL pY-L pall GLAT J] KK GL pat aid gl 9 Jal ABTY cop AS JS Lad ny Mp Lal Zale JI OGD! 14SAN lalasiny GLIVI ola OUR ool dale J Ui jall pba GLE Saks Jail SLU ¢ gla CL oye jae gl gg stl Ele [opal Hd adall cays iar Ue Laglsel SpVI Gaal dled Il) GU paved INI bail Ged sd od all ed Gebel Je DVI VL nl cy (Gi Sad cigs GB pll be Uggs Al 61S cleat MA Real AG Es Dall G3 pV G yg he ps ys) we Lele AN fea YP US Ley Lack YJ 04S oT yee Y egal plo Lia oly J fell all SL Lg cad al galls (poetics) nA guliall pla Uke ISS pl dilly SAU Ll Le ee pail SLALBY oe OF le belay UII din 6S bbe ds all OLLI YL, bee bday Gell Gaal Gaidll pley Gi pll SLU oly BASH ET PIe MoM Ey peal SLEAT HS OT Eyal p gla Le oye 3 nS Lae EWols & Sl ps de BLY pall Lela gl G yadiny das ye el Uy dB pds aa Gall tl phe gil Gam aT Je Gite) rail G due FIN BL a ge bey pal onal che gl AG pl g AI) gs USES 59 NI ae eae Ula y ee pall UU a belt a Cpe i ppd, A lt hy ll Glad pie Bots ol ail es IB pall ga te ogg Stns lb alll ol yah a ll PN bens Soles) ol yl pd lo Saadll spuall Le De Bly Lt Ma oly Real Gand GLE ake] JE ye (Spo pall SL Wate gil o(metarepresentation) tell LF 5] e cai fall solves ost GS Le UL Ala sl teins past olan pally Gol depll te J 15tg ASL ng cheb Sas oye BT obit ff LUD Gye le ple ech By CMs deal Seta Ae sly Ke garly Boe slat osty J cag shene pI he 19S teal Shee We Leh 2 cae OI ay cy dled TGs gay tele Gite NAL AAS tangs tele) OLY, Ogally GUUS Ob de SS ange Ua righ ye inte co ye 3S UE 3 pt etal Jo 2 Killy Atel ly Ge etl oh elas aT LW Lda GIP Sudll JS Spy BSE Ab ge sel oF aul is Woe dae so plilal aL opie atl 0 153] ya Ls glemtsll, eds qayry sg ale dats ELI iy ine tal ey pe tly egetarell geal Ltd LA Udtealy eptall dats ISS poli dss flay ope galery qgarlill ddey whie aly agate piel wey Bees sain gull Che ay yt He hey fle tat egal Said Gaal egal ele dnt ype datly bs dees subg SH ae palin ey poeta Gartily or 53F J cui Js Sls gel asl spall Job tale othe J Jat Le obyel sn oe lt Ga peat welts 2019-9-30 3g cbt Jt 16Sails dio gg cgitall agi 9?9! Jaa cptball eagieadl yquctd cy AS po GM gos Bl cule oe y bh LaLa Sell g Chall Ul g2h Garb gabe eel oF fant sod ats 13] (1) Chel dS ap bey Veale Hdl pul eal UY thse golll Gell sf cLele Lengie Of seal tel ls 13] (2) Sal Haale tgs Cid] gE Y LA ALT hall al 265 061973) py SIS Masel LASlisl Lis «Popper almost alone, and alone in ous century, has claimed that criti- cism belongs not to the hors oeuvre, but to the main dish». Agassi, 3.4968), p.317. eel eel ge AN Lag eyo 5 lal GD eal ye pal SIE} Min ey ge cli ps OK ob epgin He pal Calas tin pty ey sy ogra shyly ey ely Lal op A8U Of op pall Gel ke G ool bly eel 19eet bia of sold ity J 2B sl eid Se el Gale aa gl pte Ober the tT ag Lane Oly c gill oo lege Gels eel Adal cpt lb nb Bae a Sly 5g 2 ae ol pe ned Lay Le WE abe Jing Led a See ge sh ey Bo OLAS pale oo Gell LLAS recall gallina LU a Jp tle Jo ULI LT Medawar yoda ptf le ac LAS Ly HY pl Leake ale yay SIS 1] Go pater ple § Sal fo gyatins Ip dal OF indy alll ode dal ole, Si han iets tall gop go Ue peat ge Mle Sle) Lengel! Cob) pte SV ibe Ny SALUT olay SU 89 he Ny GAH 0 ch Mi es gl pale gif AS Sola 0 Cola, SID aeghyge De Mecpre ely Mh cael fe yt Bale Oy tS ge gy el 0 EU ye pate cS PN Rae op op gSy Heteale LD pe SI HL HLS sel OVE Make + M95, OT gan ley og 9 ne ai Ob ool gad Yt ol ae yl By Leb le Se hey OS be Sars thant d pees il teh us i BB ey Se gd Spice celica Lal LES aed Lengle OS aatl o nd sSMEY Ye SB 2) gg Lell sta pe plaltol Lal Su ato ot age Lat tee Lal eae Yoo MS alae Ul, J AB ELT len Of ou Ogeg hs U Li gS oI a pt Lkieg fogiptlo Cl Ye il pel pled il AL SVT gag y Halal regal § bpp Si nal rel dogg] 2-1 pu Nola nd Sankey (2007) iLeg Vig 80 yoi(1984) hae at (1) 20LN Ae 6 FALUN 5g [pa gilSV] dog ol AS yt ed Lin Jt Opal Saba 52 NeW aga Ue lip ST lll ye Iyngdy A phne ee Goole OB NAN clad ayy 18 tly St Katie egal of [ee 5S ANU Gor SI Labs oa Jae ches padi Bo TIS Pedal yy Oe the scl sas gill Sich Sh ly tle pada ye Ghee gy egal ad OLS UH 5 os LS cash JS JS ets py plaly Ged pS WIS ASI ile pha! eb sd GLAS, lege eM a dem Se Ley pall gee aso oy, polall GAD! LE Eodol Ges (2013 f salall als § doles) bbs dn ye GUY Gy Lal Sle Ud Leas s gale gl pathos jo) an (bs gill fy) Lraill a GU yb Sey pat pata (ately DLIYI) gaily Gna) SU ple Gang AR IS spat yo pabl ony Le LST lal HDG TEDL, oLall 5 (1994-1902) Karl Popper Lael 5 pall ell yd ade $91 JIS BLL ess sie a gall A oD sayy 12 tlt 62.0 Lakatos (1978) gts (1) BONS Ceol AI I oe Kutcher 5 Cb Ue ke (Ld 5 2) PIE Le aDAN LaS ejet Ot cy Mica ll yo pied all Uy ol AS RGA SNS, SLES galing galls ded LAIN ALAS et 385 5 y0s(2002) 3.ye4(2007), $595 (2) 5 go Gower 1997) tb (3) Siell Jol M ada a gille4-2 pans Hoymingen-Huene(2013) sigh yjtinyn sl (4) See eh alll ital Sal at aSpiny dale (Lad 1 LNGLY Je pr Slt Sef OL Guess gobal elle wsdl atl gpa Jnolis By pally al pLeL ng cy) ayadt EAN Lia OY seb gl aye pos pil Ell Cg pgp te ole gall PAB s ANG a YL ts ae gab hee OE Bylo alall [de OST ope ob ary pale Silly poll fe es tll SA) ashi Ue ta gl Say Y pball OF le yay, daeel 4B geet OLS pl dal sth pha] yp Rta lal bela pal Lay med Ld op al BAN pole JSG Gees Gus dear eae page ype gay ell a aA rgabll alla ge au ty Gap thl Se pay gay dered! ly ll GUS Hab eg Y- Ber hepa dhe ed ial asl on wpa JU eee fae isl te Sfedabe 5 Saeco ge AST OF GLa gs Gina py gaye LiKe Vy — NT ys LN) opt inasl pay gag LeSey Vy ~ sdopee SST fatal oye sede Ls de tak ag 3 OT Sas LEY cane aes HE pd ga Lh ae OIF GUIS rg sUatl oye pbedl ce Jobe yy a es 5 Hee a 3 ol yp asts at =, age aKrngh (20120 81,55$100 4161990) sha a BCD) Bee Marvel (2017) pp St Jot ily 313 01962 jy, (2D 22splaall de Lasts Lisle 153 tad ay cua Ley te bell O95 Lig ISI ALY OSG Vy To gh Lo ULES [Bla O45 Cnn 1g SUSE BLE skal! bl fp sted Cited 1865 yg Gay LT BL eggs JRA y gabe ASN LOGAN pall sy Li eo il Si De tell ey i She eyed pleat ty ie lal SY MEAD ggAEN ppl ay AST jill gece Aa Elrel Uo ail Ug last Ue fbbyiell lye ole Eas bal py cany Lelie, Oy eI fe tb tsllna gis t8) a del LO bya N gras il gry poole gb pill ut fo abt fy tds O52 UA AI WLLas pany Hal cialis bE pl! Un 3] ane BADIA oldall pe try G polall plallad biog alit Layo pales PLM ym LHI gL talin oll ace 95 yget JS fe Pasals ye Peter Godfiey- (2016) tamu ig 352 pla] Byuld Jyh [Stale BILSON gy Ae lal) Gil ol jel jaw (AES y A pet gill Smith pate 244 Ae gale eel y pla LG Ulead ol patel So Ill tol pe Vin ad Gay Para (6 8 gh ome gt aleVin Elst gu gill (Eliminative Inference) gstlaad Y SV YE 6258) AVY Gad oF Leleny tsa! olay oldest pet d pad gla] glad) SVL [1] 4 y yll all Gani (2009) até 1 (1) 160 Boland (1994), (2) 2 yed2019) 615 2) 104 e201) ings (4) 106 out (3) 23Last gh be Ws ptalll ob bl asl eh Sly phe Was ye SLU Lae MI ga Ung ala Sask oe fat lag Lo! howe A J Lap cs ge se 3 Hood Sf EAT gt dale Clb Hal yy MIT ge Comers doe Ute Giles EM DLA Cad Ug ality SIH Fpolall plu! Hab G AA ea lgeay Js S Gla ode Jol srs AMG a 2 ida)! SLL, PL feels ay hesle in IY ja La heel eM Wid > Si) Ce pale sD pate Bi Ene pe NIG LIST ay clay de pel parlabing Il al el cy Bang DI 2003 hare quantum theory) S014 js) 5] pS el jd HG Lat clan coli J SINS tgoley asl dll yaw ole G5 IS GL dell gotta jab wel a5 yy LIS Gti of gue ge Gla pS gee DUS IOS AB aghe Ee lp eS blll S23} eel Late cag dill e Hbitelly Shiels Bp SINE EB Jeakny ALU a fps Glbe taal GAS teh AN] 9 gab ge enol (2019) gle os ee pS By yA go SL My pl Sill kia J -agie ue Jo SLA par 5! sat 202 de eral pg Les pl SE ABD oy pI al al cat el pS els p> DAL a co ae Bt a Uohs 6p SI SIR Gy lA J fratll paar GES tl as Uskeel, AUS BI xa asl abl yy LA ye pot paw 227 EYL AS ion gy gla! peel es pal Sage (pols 1934 deal 110 yo s(2016) comers axe (1) 105 uecaeds (2) 24WU ed a NS te op SII ISL 1 OUI olen S pol JoDbal ca. Lal ce Ble aT yada ool gos ST bad Gall ga [oT ay lS (2004) oye Ca Ele cbs ot ld AES peed gol A obeat Sbl PepSUIESISLSB se Ob MyTelly Lee ge all DLW oly al pall O15 ay i able S asl Clot ele alle gl yas pS Gall stale ASE yay) abr be SIG DeVry de ye poly Sle JU ne eleal Os 21s gutetal wai AEST Voy Wily oe eo p SISAL LV jal Leth 3 oS Ele S asl ed patel lng OLY OIE ype slg Ah ol Ay pel Gell 5.5 ai (uncertainty principle) yaZSUt pe cals ab esl ghily Lee Cth lS he Gye Cals Le (Peiee] Ogd ba ge UTS fy cell pall ples § oval dl sail ole ale G clos YT pty YEE J ash Uy clevaisll old rolall Jadll LLG oy JIS) Aulaly als ye (Ui Aas I Leeda Slyally LEME YI Ghd aly el sf dll obaale Gt JS ley Jbl oy pli bs shee SB he STV JS hed Alli ysl Opal bem d ZY GSA py yh ghee OL Nell ow ees dy ts Spe Jil) Sp GIG) Nee toe gill (2 . ge Stokes and Shearmur «2016 byes TS ap A ols ily 1 go 2019) ge ng 1678 ye 2008) 56 (1) he J) SM gel J GAM a be bg al ely pS Ke ie Tg a9 2012) tly (2017) heey 2019 1 ge Shields (2012) gather (2) 25Bpatandiy all go a BCI LS] etn Jd peel sl bey io ge ey 89 past ode gall Jaa! pay (2008) 25, bpny by oy addcats pata sls of Wala VU aT [S land 3 pacbll oly ay oe Ba as cee T Cale DLN cay spe ie aiongy galall gel Be TG phll aces Il Gall oe AS ye det tie Se a EL pi el ea 5S sat pelie ae ost AgaiNyeabieal Oy -2 Hegel Lad Jylss G basally LIV Jl gos GWE SII OLA go Bylall we I GILSYy ele Vy Secdall ple Geel lee yo patel jel ey A pall gill) alles > pall J GS fe Se) obs oy jak Cf OLR en AUS op ey Halt Vy TE OL Bl Oy 4 Dele] Jo ds (laren dae ctor eS oe bas dott Sale gan gay Ge Lo (pple go ine 3) ple JS Robs Le MAN aA gt ls eld el Jo lil lane das Ving (Scientific Metbed) Lae lmgieisle games Le pny ¢ le lal 3] a RAS Lad co pads 1G gill pay Lyx eit le ga JU eldree (eons tebllpgle Gass slgelliuny ele copy SBI oles Gy BIL Gl pl HDG OL LAL dl cay let Richard Rudner 242,08, 8512] sCeechniques) ot CAM pplall ge Loe dalee Lol Vip gla b tll SLM pent pple heyhey I A ln led gad alls gen A OY 17 se sPasemore (1948) jy (1) 26Long] Sbly Lag iy dale ye Mil Ab pe Lis bowel at le Sg Lye om fo dighy alias ops jl blot tMark Blaug f pl le ,L2] anny has hp Spall gil Le gpa ged pontll Cat pd pal hed Sole a8 OSI cine done Gh fell hele M bled he plyapee By Ny pall § Co fo fot be Lge al YY) celia culleal Uf 51 Gl p> Colle) ang gall Ming Le & pt pe pK) dale Wes allly pola dali fo oles tobatV ple Leagly2yied poaill Loy Migs ober boge elas ph (aS LAL lel aM oye el el ol dl pt Sela ob BN foleglhy eto) 45 i ly I Gabel folded! oe gl ole SUl cisLan Yl ally nll Gb bd ola del yy Wy dpe! KPballl p pails J pill pally pgrbly UALS de Wolly pilly ll sl ole G LAY Ball, 055 ol Se: toe slit ple J dpeliy tot inky bs SL Wey eel esl ds este bobs pe U cord agit JM dalIl tele My esol) $e S33 sale! eogilll GA yey LLM obs Gy hlasry atlengy 4 Wyle Sb sly cll Old ll Ble ale 5 sll g ayhl LY ALA ple sD) (Methodology) Le so gall canis Upaiy of Uy bane Gp Boas Ul ge ULE NN gly 6 gall Lye Gala! Galella ll lal Sa4 20 (1988) 355) (1) HAV (199 Eyb_@) pie genie pt pain le Ly 13 pace Nola and Sankey(2007) Sis ily (3) obll easel ois 27Lie ya [Bas ANI AIS Bly Sp pbl JSS dels ole apie Sa fo shail Ue ola ell gin ns Spal pats G gall pe patente gl dbs feel OB ae Lace ol Lad ead af lala GAT gl (1948) syne plat Spell Ge dale ie BE Il SI LANL HS he J dzally ell Gy Gall Kin gala LT oT cad -galall GeslAl fll He cep LLad Bee Ayal LL fle gala Stale jee! gl ll pi b-SLe (mmethodotogist) gagale fenh diey gl ely Wy aad 96 BSL fail AAS bee ULL ib le capt alae Oy JL peels gl Sot Sell SL jak ge Ly pad sEaae Robt Sead Gall atl gibt Ges fel fle sl ange JS Glad Re lwe gh GUN ST cpg olathe A bc ple JS Of Sing V [dba be Let 0% OT phat aale gy Ly ged oS alg SUL dada fall ate ay ( oes gig [Sle JOIN ce ge bal a Hage JSLb> SAU ple eLer] Jo WED tee? cline pune Oi] alee Ele LE IS Hae tng gel po gale Coe ple Ghats gl e golell Godt hal ad ply Ub tle Js thal plall $b JI yest ole al Je Lal - egal lis 3 yo Miele! gall olay - gala ial paid 3 pied ilgle poh LIM dell Obsetl J AA pylall cals bf poe GAB qe as AN bee ge dels ple ale gee G Sat lel 946 «po Hatfield (2005) alice $303 .» Ladyman (2007) a5 ksh (1) 1721948) syne @D 158 yo Verdugo (2009) 53,5 (2)Le eels 28 lel ghd Geb oe Halal Bp JI geod le se IS Chat bedangyall pal gll JSLbe Ld ool Bly eS\tly ols AS (Sal Sis Lasyk Uh poy 95> JS Hepple ceil a Hypothetico-) blow V9 il eel aul) Haw OLS geil Lhe elle peel bea lea Y— ele ee py (Deductive Method 212 JIS iby OF IS tlre do te ply Ob jell OLY Whey Ob fell Ad Sd aL Dal a gh Gad eh hal PY cadly 5 ST eit pat Lp py Ls ell eka phall sl Gd LEVI 5 il cell Lin ple L ey (Inductive Method) 1 | feel LL) pilé sp WS Cole (1626-1561) Bacon 3 55h (peo d col AB Uphill GLSY Ghee ge ay J 1620 de Ly cach G yoleall wud fea indo) ABM le atl AS pla dl deka a Sh Joo Al gly ei ll ily pach in jap et yb Cp Be a agen Ga Aas Elec a sols tae Vell pa Lill FAS s1 Kala LLaal ops LG ote gh Sad) Leth of bs All allel! Lat 5S Coe sl opel Ley «fils (positivists) d yond ol AST, . (universal) A gel gL A grey pel bin (1857-1798) Auguste Comte tile atat lend Set SON YaST Scag gl mens j cy Hie dL Salt as eB fly 170.2 2007) Seg V5 ily 56-54 pre (2002) pe (1) ides Wheel a 3 ghoul ea iy bh Al ell pate 8 gel oh asl 16 01987) Ske (2) 29GU UNG oy Sf Cl Jos Raed Sy Ue fa 10,551 WN US) ha gl ll Og spoke IS aly elt JOS Laas pl ollie Ml Eat teal La] 5a b ge (universality) LISI yj OU gene Sl la 2 Ad aly Rnd Uae 6 AS ys nl ene el er I AEM pa be Naya ocd] «pated ode Jet sale Shenk, Gk Dae oye y al al do datas apt yay heal Baad iB peal Lie ja appl pall p AS ne Oy Bae shalday Lolly Wale pe pe eer ep tle LS op pall jeaed Sl ite gal a andy ig ual 3 gad Hae rll Ll Yo le pl ede aia yoy Glens cae po By & rl Jo Lets Gl fl ale eee Glee ; pial sh cot ky pte Gta Habe Uglte ll (logical positivism) iil yaad lh 22 Yb kt Obs] of oe) ai ge pl opal HL hag the a gall Oat U3] Y] poe SIME Y Le Sly REN Ally oll or ge Girl da sy OBB pada ya la yas dls UE cl yg Loe ny) pla BAB Gea 3 OL gl of YY Cell Hi be gle Al gail Sl fo Se (8, aslo olen sls fill VWs SAI OU fo abd ols ll adj, glll gL ie 25 ae Bowverese (1981) ad (1) 1998) pil 666-47 mr Malherbe (198 Do hay s17 yoe(1987) AL) sien getsMalas de glo yey pte Gy ol Hume (1776-171 Dp ein Soe iy Wacko Ad AI OY ote O15 Lge g galll Js 0 Sm eal a Gio Uae ead UF Hs YUL oye ae GY Say Vd ll ad Joy AS 2p AS pond OD Adin, pst OS Ley SI ope ia gl gl ieee 4 LY COAL fe tne G55 Jo cake sb 1 SH gay Ly atl Lily principle of9) «Jo yocIl Lie? goull Tall yoy dyIS G gulailly ddl cil Lal gre Shall § ere ya le ole thle Guay epi "(transference Lal fil glee Gs ALB eG peel pil play ntl gle L BEY ig J Sle oT ey Lt gle Lal gh cLdlate pale ob Lely UL] Lee, Vy «tCalsifiability) JU Gverifiability) O31 OS yom ttl Lleel ya ld Gans of Oty) aad L Op LaLa ait IS 3 Hehe BUH 1 dome ye Gi OF Say V LiL (Lge 4) Why] glad Bp DNS pl acl ge een J STU lge LS Le sabe lle oe AML SV Els Rabel 8 all J obs pl GUS YI La sy pba! Qo} Sb pl ya Sia de slash ila sh JS I tly kp pia Gi 45-1 (1866-1794) Whewell 35 palsy dpi |S eDLSYI Oly Cayperbesis) Ale By em Lhe eshiel ool ae ily Ub Uae bid Jy dab ded yay CM GLAU Dh [slo gat elt Cty yannti o+ UML 28 ot ae OT Ser Y gull al Kepler 1.5 GLEst at wid Je Jy 4 Jail 29-26 yw (2007 /1748)¢ J (1) 3 ua? yo Sl yall ph ps tCustom or Hadi (2) 6101972) py 3) 4.2958 ay (4) 443 od MoAlC1867) dd 31JS Uplate hag V 605) co al Of «5 II Las 3S BSI Slade hn 50 Ol ected yh [S&B Sap 3] pall bane On Gi po late IE hy gag BB J] el ow go Lb Sls od 9S) dy pl Lge fags fol Seal Lag tS ele Ley 99d 1.3 cn Deal 2 8 SU ge AST cyah ot Lee ell Sle Ol gle Olay celety Le VU pity LALA GLSY ol] call 1978) 1973) gel ate Bolt icipd yt Lee ys ete Joel pd pla Oba Lily palld (Halle 1975 la tee LIL J jae a alat jly gts liags lal (contingent pane) g2 Pls allt AA ame etal ell a os eas oboe y ll an Sey gl gat lh Uepey WLEs asLeeb pha) (ULel adall oy) SLbll pLul acl ple Le Leng ell ie yard Jo el gill oe ge of os Ley Ls jet Feyerabend ub, Ne psig 8 fp coll yard eel ose! Oda JB pan se Stal ggg sstldbel it tow gill la st aeSE dels Wel dle Cals i] ae abe yg al sel gg Glas SZ, ants he pla EAD ge 95 ae Le ty |S SLES plo Le Sy iL gay a gala Al Load Luabit cLole kts og ny Ja S dy BE We aha aggt St eam Hay, 80 pall jalle saad JEM, (61999) leg Joel 221975) gga 3) (2) 89 .9301978) a, el (2) 26. got 32ot ene Dod Jbl EUS pple celerl fab ALE Opty slo Eakby CLINI hale AN ye daly dele CE psd Mal AM ge by oll Wks ashsely lal lym dda [St payaall plat] Linen Vly dpa Agi ples ole one Jobs GLESY) OS UpLeY a3he Lele slays CEs Ob BI Mle cage gy ng ee ISNT LL) Lent} Opes gl We Ops apa OF Nhe all la ay ealally ally aL SI, AN el Ls oT dee oe Cay wee I UD Bh ld SLA com coals tis (Wthematie planed) tg yall g gealld ily oil lal (PaaS JSLaL tal Ile 6 a db GiLyll oy Spe and Sh gall S.A (thematic presuppositionst) 1% youll le ATV spans Sgt gay cS all ne gl lil ad gall falling 38 sll ga a Wey Ul Ys OLIN ALG ge pad ry AHS ol Lely edn, gs te tally bLdly KIS gale ots) Malte oad Ua le SSN Ble ea al ges ge olla Seka ins dl ges BIE poydl Jas alld LI oll Jeol ud Les yy ofA ges) el wallh eet ee le fo Lal egy CMRI gb nobild EB SLES 6 ol bles NE bel de IST AS Joss gil 100. yoiC1978) ga) se Shy Atte words) EN All op yy dey bl ea iby WNT LSID pty (2) NU ST ll ole all fle VT IS! BSN OLS I Algal je of gt by eS LISA My gical oN Jog SIN fle LU Il 61972) ay, Mica My ally Hae NI Raley SH Le pl Ae Sly Ul 4 dd Jo aap ea UKE hall aay Apne gay LIM ancy ype COE JL sc bl $1.00(1973) cele (3) 9901978) 30 (4) 32 oul 968) py (5) 33Gee Syl HH a ory mel seaketl ol a Vg Eg Uso SASL OLD ola J gg gal Gash dye Vt cme al bb 2 Udy Dsbll sd os 3 Aha, Cue y G50 Nall ew oe Bisley Se GSH Spall fle GALLE ols Ley peach je IB] play 84 ye gl Lede lay\yodey fox gill tly i Fie ce dad ot gt ten We al Uf Oi] GLESY Gopate ral e Oly Hida! ob Galate oly sale] [ad ge] sl agar 18d] de Solas dae WL Of LH gy So bs pall ely J] egogll Ld! ole SL yelp ISLE ye Lega Sy Calan UY oye BLAM OSS Voy sles Pb peal SY Bhi gp shine pelt gil flit egal Clglad 2.3 pe tae Al Gaal ob prea ppl Held pd! oly gall 5 1 ad Led oges dey dpi dae Wold Be] Le lal! ela J yall Soll fo ily gl ada ently ake ba oly gos oul in ge pres ee Dab ob ball de fo adh een gee gla gey pe wil ow GAN Ye de cra Akay Ge pl sae Gaby Salad Shelling 18 32 1979 ga BO Ba Yj pla Sle Supa at 1872 pb 18 Maurice La Cte 389 Hal pa tp ghana A SgmalgtAY eNSEY sp il ted a 9 go 1989) S511 JAN ASIL1875-18721 MY Roy 33 cg AD ail 135, y2e(1961) a9 @) (4985) ag ily $258 9 661973Dy 146.0 lt 96295 132 yo al1966) yy sl (3) 343-340 ao Beade 15.2018), (9)ela Le gol) GLE UT ge Col de ad clnaie plea! ok cre Bagh, Je Sy ~Utke > la Slee Sill obs pill yh, hee alan lla Jo seal alee ol Lag ol ly La te Bea ake fo a ol lee V & oT WS cps] Ile Eel as Head) yall ebad yeSe tary classat OT ySer gy lays gf Game US ola Jb Oly cde lage C8 | Al ge BUI Obl frais ol gs Sas aquted taal (SL All ery dade LES ole pla ytd LS by aN POL Oba SM lene LS spay Ke 915 all Off ULI os role 92 alae Agi 2 ae 52 eo lr Leb iyo LS de clase Bll pa ony GaN gas cle Bek slots Gio Ly Lge slg V tow oy dda 9 pla Se gs gay Ways KY dl tla RelaYl erole G LL 505 & pall Sl oe gl anes AS 04S GB Ley Gg Hily Hague Yad Sa op pee cr BEY) AINE (Bb ht & ill le lc SE OP Mae Ba ee YY dae NU asad V4 lye Gl [Uy apa Lae nob ill] > 3! 1B pall oj ell aE y pall BEY HSU lO (31) Mae Slaall stuey USM JS [ils alle U2, Age Le alae YF yp ISS BI Ho Ba 5 yt Sas (tld lt BASU) by Af ye yaad Wye syty Pd Sally espe clad fll 11-10 poe sC1981) pay sl C1) 57 011973) 391 3 (2) 35Patterns of 1.958) Hanson gadla Joe gh say tit ¢ glall did G Lege Win dh hl og glall Gy ge Bodate tad ID oye 5g ll Discovery Pla, Glan of tle gl ite Slat in ay Es i Mae De JSG Kjell ya cals gh came UNS (ge danny 72 Shea! [slo Skee fp OR key eg ll banal) Coke res G08] aS Y Lalall Bll aye OL del ad GV SBM Oped lly OS ISI Ope ell lie JE LS Rep taghg Aly abt en hd [Sobs ADEs olYlobs Eyl Saeco Weld aU iy og all Lol le jylee l ad Kall S pall» Dues Qoblede jf Jol TG Tol Ge iy deel gill BLM il ell Gaby oF Mill cial Gadi ay JIS gS ob kl Pussiiy flee hh gdsil eel Lh yah lybdt lel oSaxy AJL @ McA bony ly ode WS Sadan DL aly (1p) JsLL LNT I aya 549 (0) Lp Riis ol 05 gy SLAM ade Jor gL Seles Lebel Le ls eles pel cdl Uy ew ou fill Sly spall Site (Si lp AS ashy 58-55 ee (18S) SIe Lely (1) Becmy Wola ball ALAN dy J aalall OAL pW wha 65 Jl BM el op si aighes U Had SR Jo igs V bal ASLAM Bai he Ngo gel lal de JS Ling NI fs aad BEI 2 pat S201) AB iy pp DIS ad Mask oS SU gl Aspe ge A131 e196 gy De RTA BLN gs gl allan nel hey (2) 3620) oa) shall Gash ce TEI Lad ot all ode pase Bade (Slt § Ir de dandy GLE dala!) LoL deat O53 3 GS Halal ll Lae 955 at oy 9) wWSay (26) OD (od Cp) AE pola eel HLT Joes ol ol pad abe Uf Ginas of Eas FEMS Em ll poli deaball 3 yall gai $2p)9 19) cay J A Saad ges GEL gla pa os oe eb Rae Nal ly Mall ob dill ye buf eae gkay Ye SPALL LAR Ld 5 lpm ot Lge eLSL Tbe ta oll fe a pil Ue Jo halal allo Gy bapa lian Jay AdghS 3.3 caked Slat oe pte OT ae egg NN pa al gl cabal og og cD LU p spd all tite |S Male Las yl yc gS il gle ade bi A IS ey cel LBS Role yl hl ine ul oe Patel UE aS JS els Oo A SL LEVI of Lie Gy ll CN ae a ay 529 OVE Se ee be Flee oye Gy th BA Vy elle yl ara gy dt oT ns ys wll gp Ue ds py C9 pth Lal fil Ub LA is aba ind ple Ly 2g JS LS PN BIB Kins cd LU cm lpg the Von op Cale te dat Ce ae eb i ol a 3 1 2s AM Ob sll oe aedall ge salad Gal ge aS al AUS ay analy by Meals yey S 01999) i838 30 1981) spe dy Js) 246 11962) py (2) 37gala) ty pl) Shas IU YN LLU ON Jo ¢ yet yp Jy tls fo ey LH oprah Oil ao LEE end DEA rls ter 5 pe BU ge JS JB Al lal ep ase oe ered Sasa sl oe AL so opt Sgtlny pe Add ty be JS dae 98 Dy grt SU} pS JSLell Ly AALP SLO By HL c+ ual 4 BT als ad al ope polb Ay ES joy Se BS J I eo Leb glad i Je ccs lei pal play JTobal fest ss lng ol Bell gs tall OT S| Bronowski Sud yy 2311 HepSle Nine Sle Sing hy Sap A eS agen ar] bag ey AH oll “panei |S (eoreberation®) tll SD LEY Je Pll Uys tase of get oF AS 4 SU OLE fo bye atey ANU ggell its (Sead sheath aly § JAF Yaa jay Lad Oe a Cee pr LSI AY pele VI Gilat ges pail ball JLo NT fs Gd le J oF als ys 5 Lal of Lb ay Thomas Kuhn (1970) 08 les bees gl EE Ey ly ab Wheel 2805 poe i GRAY 3 GUN AY Dyn Oslalas BBLS] ill BL eN pgs Jo BUI GO nk 2 bate epteleal le ee J} (normal science) Kagalall plait elyy gel kal JU Gad Sep tad gay gs ge an ll TAs fo age a UT Sy 20 cllaae ail ie Sf Le ty Me Al ola A JY ae eee EY pasting BAHT SUSLAD Yeas og all ash J ns He J ipl 8 edgy La SY dled Quy Vy alll is Jo J Sal fps gh ages pe coe ual «gph! lle] pSow Lait Endl LadUdl ol gee ee Labeda pst go lances Bis al Sw SAbY! de op HE Bia ny ae i gall Ol JS TAS HR BLS ytd cp FN pola bse halla ope ples LY clay Be SS go O 0 algo Boa? 38GWU 5 hs Lead] paling PULL! Alb AUS Gy Yb ge gos ld rags JULI ob yes bey ST Co Jere BY ai all ya Ho VLBI J] pts dell al ye OEY eb » Ay ebb byte Le Gill ge Ray WAS eo ar a leles EL La A Le lve heme Ue Ua GH te gas BUI lyr es all JUHI clas OL aS, cot ele 32 AGN Busts sh call lh Jed SO Le lod Say Jp SEL Ta yey MALL SL, Leal pla 6142 0 11968 ey AS GD peal BOLI OT gle dee Les pi Bs Sle ALG gy Ay Nagas 6003] «JU Y! IS 15] Lelne Salty ed LO as ip sede wld enV a ol pba ad oo lege I a Ullal god Ce IS al gy Le WE phe DU! cys pall jeetd [phew SUI aalrenly ULM abe BW jel Y ol estes y GIVI be Leal al 25) 01 Y] AUIS eens ll plea VI oT delay 18 0 61973 ay hog Y SISO 2a Wl 5) By ae yyel egal OIE gelall Could pat Bled ab Sella Glow GOghany clad Mile Gj LLL O yoad gl cpp ar pat 1S Ah yee ee oe et Da led SY lalla pt ole chen gS gy be Lajtes shiel) Ul pga Shy LIVI LEW lye 3p JE age BAU Ce pall lead 52 96) ler! ye lal ral (peice LsY! ¢ seil eM sos 8 159d LN GA lS ALL ead gl SI CO sLl Ls IS des Ree Le Nelsen dest $0 LS SOT 8 ge he sh cad y Jedd pall agar 9 t6olee oll a baile ash Leta pe atl ee pate DVI Say ibe sh BW oy 5s dl A Dot heer gy Gabe 186.9401973) 4 (1) 39YN ger ell fo jt LDS cy BB ya pr ISMN LI Le JLT py seats $US AEST Le las 5 FledasL> oS I POS ja Ua AAG Le ga ode Deals pled Sy cea INN Hp el ha a gel all aa gs ll pha > 0 AST ge he ole, pane GMAT HEIL AE Sal pal Si el pe ysl UE oo gt Jae 1974) Shs Jad GLESY | lat NS G Pe IY pat Jhdlae wad coben slo cll fe Loe jl ey 5 ALMA pt ang 961934 See UL 4b gl pall! ASM plead J) JUapy oll shall fe wats oo Ve et ye 5 ol SY OLS 1 SL a MI YS J esl fo Sai ia Stns jes jell Ele) Uh ist oye Aas oye cs gS tly HLasl AULis JU Of « cy alg GE Ve tl alr Uy UN ad MeL od bs slats So Olely Ob ash Uf PML be aha oe: phrase eg en Sons Dy pe alle cmd ST py Licey thee ob Vaal gay oh tl clad Wal sya al ply DSU Lalas ts (Gaya & alll gl) Le a fill Ly ols ade bb ply Dall, edtalle AY GUL alls Gay Ob U Sy Uy ll Bagaee ISLS JS oT a Ry pill} pee 3145417 962) 15 ll SNS] Gopal es dle Epics Balad SUT BE) Jer WAL y S65 of ale 355-354. ya01985) 44 (1) 162395816. yo 197 S34 (D 619 oud (3) 241 yollt962) gy