Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BieblQuerner TransportationofWoodBoringBeetles StudiesinConservation 2020
BieblQuerner TransportationofWoodBoringBeetles StudiesinConservation 2020
BieblQuerner TransportationofWoodBoringBeetles StudiesinConservation 2020
net/publication/342063463
CITATION READS
1 425
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Webbing clothes moth(Tineola bisselliella) monitoring in the carpet museum of Tehran,Iran View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Stephan Biebl on 20 November 2020.
To cite this article: Stephan Biebl & Pascal Querner (2020): Transportation of Wood Boring
Beetles in Wooden Transport Boxes, Wooden Pallets, and Newly Bought Wood in Museums,
Studies in Conservation, DOI: 10.1080/00393630.2020.1756126
1
Ingenieurbüro für Holzschutz, Benediktbeuern, Germany; 2Department of Integrated Biology and Biodiversity Research, Institute of
Zoology, University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences, Vienna, Austria; 3Institute of Conservation, University of Applied Arts Vienna,
Vienna, Austria
CONTACT Pascal Querner pascal.querner@boku.ac.at Department of Integrated Biology and Biodiversity Research, Institute of Zoology, University of
Natural Resources and Life Sciences, Gregor-Mendel-Straße 33, A-1180 Vienna, Austria; Institute of Conservation, University of Applied Arts Vienna, Expositur
Salzgries, A-1010 Vienna, Austria
© The International Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works 2020
2 S. BIEBL AND P. QUERNER
increasing risk of spreading infestation from one for pictures or delicate objects, or one-way crates,
museum to another. which differ in material composition and size. Depend-
ing on the object-specific requirements such as
climate stability, watertight insulation, lining of the
Biology and food requirements of sapwood
interior, double seal, and water-repellent paintwork,
beetles
the costs for transport crates vary greatly. More
More than 20 different species of sapwood infesting expensive crates are often custom-built in the
beetles (Coleoptera, Bostrichidae, Lyctinae) are globally museum’s own carpentry shop or by art transport
found infesting wood; about 10 are also found in companies.
Germany and Austria. In addition to the native In the museum industry, mainly wooden materials
species Lyctus linearis and L. pubescens, two neobiotic made of plywood, the so-called ‘carpentry panels’, are
(introduced) species have also become established used for transport crates. Carpentry panels consist of
outdoors. The most frequent introduced species in a middle layer with parallel wooden rods and a deck
central Europe are Lyctus brunneus, L. cavicollis, or barrier veneer glued transversely thereto on both
L. planicollis, L. africanus, and L. hipposiderus (Bußler sides. These standardized wood panels are also stable
2009; Geis 2012; Pospischil 2017). They are normally under fluctuating climatic conditions; they are flexible
found only in buildings and cannot survive a winter and have a good reputation. Due to its low weight,
outside in most parts of central Europe. wood as a material is ideal for transporting high-
The wood-destroying larvae are limited to starch- quality museum objects such as paintings or sculp-
and protein-rich food, which they find in the tures. Furthermore, carpentry plates are also used for
sapwood of hardwood (deciduous) trees. The attacked exhibition construction, shipbuilding, vehicles, or
tree species include maple, abachi, bamboo, oak, ash, caravan construction (where damage is also caused
illomba, chestnut, limba, meranti, walnut, poplar, by Lyctus sp. beetles).
ramin, rattan, false acacia, elm, willow, walnut, and Since the packaging of high-quality art objects also
occasionally cherry. Some hardwood tree species has an aesthetic dimension for many customers, the
cannot be affected due to the low nutrient content of material selection must also take into account the
the wood cells. Beech is also described as immune in external appearance. In the case of carpentry panels
the literature due to vascular cells. The infested wood the top layer is usually made of homogeneous hard-
can be very dry (10–8% wood moisture) at the wood veneer, such as beech, poplar, or tropical wood
surface so that infestation is recognized only after an (e.g. Gaboon or Okoumé), and the middle layer of con-
extended period of feeding. ifers. To improve robustness during transportation,
Since the nutrient content of the wood decreases solid wood of spruce or MDF material is used for
with time, the risk of an attack is reduced with increasing reinforcement.
life. Nevertheless, wood which is older than 10 years can In principle, packaging materials or transport crates
still be affected if stored at low humidity and constant must not contain any chemically reactive pollutants
temperature (Pospischil 2012). Due to the hidden ovi- from the conservation viewpoint and must be free of
position up to 8 mm deep in vascular cells, an initial plasticizers and solvents as they can react with
attack is difficult to detect. The eggs themselves are different materials of art objects over a longer period
only about 1 mm long and 0.15–0.175 mm thick. The of time. Natural tannins, which occur in oak, false
beetles can penetrate surfaces with paint, varnish, or acacia, and elm tree or acetic acid from wood compo-
thin films, and easily exit through extraneous materials site materials (MDF) are regarded as dangerous in the
(e.g. MDF boards or paper) during hatching. The lifespan case of transport boxes and long-term storage. The
of most species is 12 months, under ideal conditions problem of possible infestation of transport crates by
even less, making the Lyctus species some of the powderpost beetles and other species has also been
fastest developing wood pests. Beetles can also fly described by Krehan (2007) and Zahid, Grgurinovic,
very well and spread inside an infested room. and Walsh (2008).
Public attention was attracted for example to the Several cases are known to the authors after many
incident at the Bodemuseum in Berlin, which was years of working in museums, in which pests (pow-
affected in 2008 by an infestation with the southern derpost beetles or other species) have been trans-
lyctus beetle (Lyctus planicollis) and the newly-laid ported through transport boxes or wooden pallets,
parquet floor had to be treated with great effort and introduced with new picture frames or parquet
(Unger, Steinbach, and Buczynski 2008). floors.
problem in Germany and Austria between 2003 and one case in Austria and one case in Germany), the fur-
2019. niture beetle (A. punctatum, one case in Austria), and
the Anobiid Oligomerus ptilinoides were all found in
infested wooden pallets inside museum stores (two
Results cases in Austria; see also Querner 2007; Querner,
We found different species of wood pests in a number Morelli, and Kimmel 2013; Landsberger 2015 for more
of museums in Germany and Austria. Infested museum details) (Figures 5–7).
objects are not listed. The results are discussed as three
groups: transport boxes, new picture frames, and Discussion
wooden pallets.
The following can be counted as direct damage to
works of art or room equipment (parquet floors, door
Infested transport boxes leaves / frames, edge frames, picture frames, work
tables, etc.) from susceptible hardwood. Follow-up
Not only the native Lyctus linearis, but also the intro-
costs result from measures such as checks, pest
duced L. brunneus, L. cavicollis, and L. africanus can be
control, repairs, cleaning, disposal, and remediation of
found in transport boxes. We found nine reported
transport boxes. Figures 1–3 illustrate infestation in
cases from Germany between 2003 and 2015 (Figures
transport crates. Usually only the veneer of the 1–
1 and 2; see also Biebl 2014 for a more detailed
2 mm thick outer layer is infested because the soft-
description).
wood in the middle layer is resistant to powderpost
beetles. A static impairment is not present and thus
Infested wooden picture frames leads to partial damage to the transport crate. The
more crates and additionally endangered objects of
Three cases of new picture frames (Figure 3) bought by art in a storage space that become affected the
different museums for exhibitions were found to be higher are the costs of rehabilitation, which are
infested by Lyctus sp. in Austria between 2010 and funded either by the owner or, in the most favorable
2015. Also wood, sold to the museum carpenters case, by art insurance. Therefore, pest infestation
(Figure 4) for making of new picture frames and should be prevented in the best possible way.
stretchers, were found to be infested (two cases in
Austria). In two cases from Germany, the newly-laid
parquet floor was infested by powder post beetles Wooden pallets
(one is the well-known example of the Bodemuseum Wooden pallets (Europool pallets, usually according to
in Berlin; Unger, Steinbach, and Buczynski 2008). DIN EN 13698-1) are very often used in museums to
store large and mostly heavy stone or metal objects.
Infested wooden pallets Usually, spruce is used for this purpose. New wooden
pallets should be pretreated with heat (30 min at a
We found a total of five cases of infested wooden core temperature of 56 °C) in accordance with the
pallets used for museum storage. Also, the species of ISPM 15 standard. In many museums, these pallets
pest varied: The house longhorn beetle (H. bajulus, are used in long-term storage facilities. In one
German art storage room and four Viennese
museums, an active infestation of house longhorn
beetle (Hylotrupes bajulus), the common furniture
beetle (Anobium punctatum), and Oligomerus ptilinoides
has been found in recent years. The origin of the infes-
tation in all cases could not be clarified. Furthermore, in
Berlin an attack by the house longhorn beetle (Hylo-
trupes bajulus) in a single wooden pallet in the
musical instrument museum was also discovered in
recent years (Landsberger 2015). The pallet had
already been stored there for at least six years before
a house longhorn beetle emerged and frass and
holes were noticed. Savoldelli and Regalin (2009) also
describe the infestation of wooden pallets in Italy
with the species Sinoxylon unidentatum, introduced in
Figure 1. Signs near a wooden transport box infested by Lyctus wood from Sri Lanka. Downes et al. (2020) discuss the
brunneus in Germany: dead beetles and frass (Image: Stephan outbreak of the furniture beetle Anobium punctatum
Biebl). in wooden storage pallets in the UK.
4 S. BIEBL AND P. QUERNER
Figure 2. Detail of the outer surface of wooden transport box infested by Lyctus brunneus (photograph by Stephan Biebl).
Figure 3. New picture frame infested by Lyctus brunneus in Austria (photograph by Pascal Querner).
The infestation of wooden pallets is probably a rare by a visual inspection. New pallets should be heat-
phenomenon. It can happen when they are stored treated before entering the museum, or plastic pallets
outside the museum buildings or together with other can be an alternative to avoid this source of contami-
infested material. Usually, it can easily be determined nation (Figure 8).
Figure 4. Wood, newly bought to build or repair picture frames, infested by Lyctus brunneus in Austria (photograph by Pascal
Querner).
TRANSPORTATION OF WOOD BORING BEETLES INTO MUSEUMS 5
Figure 5. A wooden pallet infested by Anobium punctatum in Austria (photograph by Pascal Querner).
Figure 6. Frass from a wooden pallet infested by Hylotrupes bajulus in Austria (photograph by Pascal Querner).
Prevention by selecting the right wood a good price-performance ratio. However, it should
also be considered in economic terms whether it is
At this point, the authors would like to make practical
worthwhile to reduce the risk of pest infestation by
suggestions to museums or transport companies in
using more resistant wood (softwood instead of
order to look for resistant or alternative materials in
sapwood).
the selection of transport crates. Carpentry panels, at
In addition to carpentry panels with hardwood
present frequently used, have good properties with
veneer (density 450 kg/m3), so-called ESB boards
Figure 7. Wooden pallet infested by Oligomerus ptilinoides in Austria (photograph by Pascal Querner).
6 S. BIEBL AND P. QUERNER
containers; in-situ generated nitrogen is banned at the 21–23 May 2019, edited by L. Nilsen, and M. Rossipal,
moment, but countries like Austria have applied for a 244–253. http://raa.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1389
derogation. See for more information: https://icom. 000/FULLTEXT01.pdf
museum/en/news/icom-icomos-unite-in-call-to-allow- Geis, K.-U. 2012. "Eine neozoische Splintholzkäferart unter
the-use-of-nitrogen-for-the-protection-of-cultural- Einfluß der Klimaerwärmung: Erster Nachweis
heritage/; and http://www.icom-cc.org/379/-icom-cc- mehrjähriger Überwinterungen von Lyctus brunneus
documents/european-restriction-on-use-of-nitrogen- (Steph.) in einem naturnahen Habitat
for-disinfestation/#.XtbLkENCSX0. Südwestdeutschlands (Coleoptera: Bostrichidae: Lyctinae)
Freiburg i.Brsg." May 2. Accessed February 11, 2020.
http://kaeferklaus.de/fileadmin/kaeferklaus.de/Fachaufsae
Acknowledgements tze/Subtropische_Splintholzkaefer_unter_Einfluss_der_Kli
maerwaermung_Suedwestdeutschland_Coleoptera_Bostri
The authors would like to thank all museums that support an
chidae.pdf.
IPM program and colleagues who have shared their experi-
Hickin, N. E. 1975. The Insect Factor in Wood Decay. East
ences with us.
Grinstead: The Rentokil Library, Rentokil Group PLC.
Krehan, H. 2007. “Verpackungsholz-Kontrollen in Österreich
notwendiger denn je.” Forstschutz Aktuell 41: 1–4.
Disclosure statement Landsberger, B. 2015. Fakultativ materialschädigende und inva-
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s). sive Schadinsekten in den Sammlungen der Staatlichen
Museen zu Berlin. In Berliner Beiträge zur Archäometrie,
Kunsttechnologie und Konservierungswissenschaft Bd. 23 vols,
ORCID 119–125.
Noldt, U. 2000. Holzzerstörende Insekten – Fälle von
Pascal Querner http://orcid.org/0000-0002-3537-0699 gestern, Forschung von heute, Gefahren von morgen.
Forschungsreport 1, 24–28. Accessed February 11,
2020. http://literatur.vti.bund.de/digbib_extern/dk040
References 522.pdf.
Auer, J., and A. Kassel. 2014. “Braconid Wasps: A Biological Pinniger, D. B. 2015. Integrated Pest Management in Cultural
Control Method.” In Proceedings of the 8th International Heritage. London: Archetype Publications.
Conference on Urban Pests, edited by G. Müller, R. Pospischil, R. 2012. Der Braune Splintholzkäfer - ein Update.
Pospischil, and W. H. Robinson, 335–340. Zürich: OOK- Der praktische Schädlingsbekämpfer 7–8, 14–15.
Press Kft. Pospischil, R. 2017. “Lyctus (Coleoptera: Bostrychidae): A
Berry, R. W., R. G. Lea, and D. Higham. 1993. “The status of Never Ending Story.” In Proceedings of the 9th
Anobium punctatum and Hylorupes bajulus in buildings in International Conference on Urban Pests, edited by M. P.
the United Kingdom.” Paper presented to 24th Davies, C. Pfeiffer, and H. W. Robinson, 377–380.
Conference of the International Research Group on Birmingham: Pureprint Group.
Wood Preservation. Querner, P. 2007. “Befall von Holzpaletten in Depots durch
Biebl, S. 2014. “Holzschädlinge in Transportkisten, Praktische zwei Holzschädlinge (Gemeiner Nagekäfer Anobium pucta-
Erfahrungen mit Splintholzkäfern in Depoträumen.” tum und Hausbockkäfer Hylotrupes bajulus).” Restauro 3:
Restauro 3: 22–25. 188–190.
Biebl, S., and J. Auer. 2017. “The Practical use of Braconid Querner, P. 2015. “Insect Pests and Integrated Pest
Wasps for Control of the Furniture Beetle (Coleoptera: Management in Museums, Libraries and Historic
Anobiidae).” In Proceedings of the 9th International Buildings.” Insects, Special Issue on Integrated Pest
Conference on Urban Pests, July 2017 in Birmingham, Management 6 (2): 595–607.
edited by M. P. Davies, C. Pfeiffer, and W. H. Robinson, Querner, P., M. Morelli, and T. Kimmel. 2013. “Transport von
367–375. Birmingham: Pureprint Group. Schädlingen mit Kunstobjekten – ein unterschätztes
Bußler, H. 2009. “Teures Leben im Parkett. Eingeschleppte Problem.” Kunst unterwegs - Tagungsband der
Splintholzkäfer zählen zu den bedeutensten Schädlingen Österreichischen Restauratoren 14: 86–92.
von Holzprodukten.” LWF aktuell 73: 18–19. Ridout, B., 2012. Timber. English Heritage.
Child, R., and D. Pinnniger. 2014. “Current Status and Savoldelli, S., and R. Regalin. 2009. “Infestation of Wood
Treatments for Anobium punctatum.” In Proceedings of Pallets by Sinoxylon unidentatum (Fabricius) (Coleoptera
the 8th International Conference on Urban Pests, edited by Bostrichidae) in Italy.” Bollettino di Zoologia agraria e di
G. Müller, R. Pospischil, and W. H. Robinson, 329–333. Bachicoltura, Ser. II, 41 (3): 235–238.
Zürich: OOK-Press Kft. Unger, A., S. Steinbach, and B. Buczynski. 2008. “Mikrowellen
Creffield, J. W. 1991. Wood Destroying Insects: Wood Borers and zur Bekämpfung eines Splintholzkäferbefalls im Parkett
Termites. East Melbourne: CSIRO Australia. des Bodemuseums Berlin.” In Bauphysik und
Downes, S., P. Lankester, S. Lambarth, C. Rawson, D. Thickett, Altbausanierung, Forum Altbausanierung, edited by H.
A. Xavier-Rowe, and D. Pinniger. 2020. “Beetles Behaving Venzmer, 3 vols, 111–112. Stuttgart: Fraunhofer IRB Verlag.
Badly – Control of Furniture Beetle Anobium punctatum Zahid, M. I., C. A. Grgurinovic, and D. J. Walsh. 2008.
Outbreak in Wooden Storage Pallets.” In Integrated Pest “Quarantine Risks Associated with Solid Wood Packing
Management (IPM) for Cultural Heritage. Proceedings from Materials Received ISPM 15 Treatment.” Australian
the 4th International Conference in Stockholm, Sweden, Forestry 71 (4): 287–293.