The document provides a rubric for evaluating strategic management presentations with criteria including content, objectives, analysis, strategies, implementation, presentation skills, visual aids, and question and answer engagement. Presentations will be evaluated on a scale of 21-100 and assessed as poor, fair, good, or excellent based on demonstrating understanding of concepts and developing well-supported strategies aligned with organizational goals.
The document provides a rubric for evaluating strategic management presentations with criteria including content, objectives, analysis, strategies, implementation, presentation skills, visual aids, and question and answer engagement. Presentations will be evaluated on a scale of 21-100 and assessed as poor, fair, good, or excellent based on demonstrating understanding of concepts and developing well-supported strategies aligned with organizational goals.
The document provides a rubric for evaluating strategic management presentations with criteria including content, objectives, analysis, strategies, implementation, presentation skills, visual aids, and question and answer engagement. Presentations will be evaluated on a scale of 21-100 and assessed as poor, fair, good, or excellent based on demonstrating understanding of concepts and developing well-supported strategies aligned with organizational goals.
MBA M001 – STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT Instructor: Janice D. Castillo
RUBRICS
CRITERIA Poor Fair Good Excellent
21-40 41-60 61-80 81-100 Content The presentation The presentation The presentation The presentation demonstrates a demonstrates a demonstrates a demonstrates a limited basic solid deep understanding of understanding of understanding of understanding of strategic strategic strategic strategic management management management management concepts, models, concepts, concepts, models, concepts, models, and frameworks. models, and and frameworks. and frameworks. frameworks. Objective The presentation The presentation The presentation The presentation lacks a clear or articulates the clearly articulates clearly articulates defined objective(s) and the objective(s) the objectives(s) objective(s) and purpose of the and purpose of and purpose of purpose. presentation. the presentation. the presentation. Analysis The presentation The presentation The presentation The presentation provides a poor provides a fair provides a good provides a analysis of the analysis of the analysis of the thorough analysis internal and internal and internal and of the internal external external external and external environment, environment environment environment including a SWOT including a including a including a analysis and lacks a SWOT analysis SWOT analysis SWOT analysis Swot analysis of and and identification and identification fails to identify key identification of of key strategic of key strategic strategic issues and some strategic issues and issues and challenges. issues and challenges. challenges. challenges and challenges. Strategies The presentation The presentation The presentation The presentation proposes weak or proposes some proposes adequate proposes well- vague strategies strategies that strategies that are developed and that lack relevance may not be fully relevant to the insightful or alignment with aligned with the organization’s strategies that the organization’s organization’s goals and address the key goals and goals and objectives and strategic issues objectives. objectives. have a clear and challenges. implementation plan. Implementation The presentation The presentation The presentation The presentation lacks a detailed outlines a outlines a outlines a implementation somewhat comprehensive detailed outlines plan or fails to incomplete plan plan for and provide a clear and for implementing the comprehensive Page 1 measurable plan for implementing proposed plan for implementing the the proposed strategies, but implementing the proposed strategies. strategies, with may lack some proposed limited details, details or clear strategies, timelines, and timelines, including resource responsibilities, or timelines, allocation. resource responsibilities, allocation. and resource allocation. Presentation The presenter The presenter The presenter The presenter Skills demonstrates demonstrates demonstrates demonstrates presentation skills, satisfactory good presentation exceptional making it difficult skills but may skills, engaging presentation to understand and lack polish or the audience and skills, engaging follow the confidence. conveying the audience and presentation. complex ideas conveying with clarity. complex ideas with clarity and confidence. Visual Aids The presentation The presentation The presentation The presentation lacks visual aids or utilizes visual effectively effectively the ones used are aids, but they utilizes visual utilizes visual irrelevant or are not aids, such as aids, such as confusing, consistently charts, graphs, charts, graphs, hindering used to support and diagrams, to and diagrams, to comprehension. key concepts support and enhance and data. illustrate key understanding of points. key concepts and data. Q&A and The struggles to The presenter The presenter The presenter Engagement engage the engages the engages the engages the audience or does audience audience through audience through not facilitate active through limited A&A sessions effective Q&A participation or A&A and encourages sessions, actively encouragement. interaction. A audience listening and limited effort to participation. responding to encourage questions.