T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER

02 - VAC - PODIUM & BASEMENT

IMPACT ON PROCUREMENT

PRIORITY / KEY ISSUES / CLIENT AGREEMENT Wasl comments on milestone Wasl comments on milestone
REF NO DISCIPLINE ISSUE DESCRIPTION RESOLUTION PROPOSAL/COMMENT COMMENT CATEGORY PURPOSE CLIENT REMARKS DOCUMENTS IMPACTED: IMPACT LEVEL INTERNAL STATUS
CRITICAL STAUS submission 2023/07/20 submission 05/08/2023

HVAC COMMENTS

Extract fan from dirty spaces such as grease trap room and toilet area are Open. Grease trap room fans are Updated on drawings Reference MEC-
HVAC Extract ducts from dirty spaces to be kept at negative pressure and Extract fan to R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-
1 HVAC installed at same space beginning of extract duct which will lead to positive Extract fan to be installed at end of extract air duct close to discharge point. MEDIUM TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION
be located close to discharge point
LEVEL 1 closed located near to room and not close to B01- 1211
pressure inside extract duct. ELECT. POWER 1211,1213,1214 discharge point MEC- B01-1212 , MEC-B01-1213, 1214

R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-
1211,1212,1213,1214 B02-MEC-1201
HVAC CLIENT CLOSED, IN
2 HVAC Install FSMD at supply and return ducts serving electrical rooms. Only FD can be installed and acceptable to DCD.
ELECT. POWER
MEDIUM
PROGRESS
COORDINATION MSFD shall be provided for all rooms protected with clean agent system. 1202 LEVEL 1 closed Closed
GFL-MEC-1221,1224
L01-MEC-1233,1234

R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC- Fan rooms closed. However, masonry

tunnel to be verified. Also, ESP
3 HVAC Using the extract fan rooms and makeup air fan rooms as plenum space. Fans to be ducted and connected to masonry shafts or plenum space. HVAC HIGH TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST Masonary fan rooms shall not be used as plenum. All fans shall be ducted. 1211,1212,1213,1214 LEVEL 2 closed calculations for all fans to be submitted
ESP calculations Submitted
L01-MEC-1233,1234 for review.

R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-MEC- Pipe sizes as per DBC, chilled water

layouts attacehed Refer R1029-02-IBA-
1601,1602,1603,1604,1605,B01-MEC- DWG-B02-MEC-
No change in pipe size. IBA to verify and
Main chilled water pipe size is 900 mm dia while the loop is sized to be 800mm CLIENT CLOSED, IN Chilled water pipe sizing shall be based on Dubai Building Code. The velocity and 1610,1611,1612,1613,1614,1615,GFL- 1601,1602,1603,1604,1605,B01-MEC-
4 HVAC
dia.
Pipes shall be sized as per DBC. HVAC HIGH
PROGRESS
COORDINATION & COST
friction limits mentioned in Dubai building code shall be followed
LEVEL 3 closed confirm the pipe sizes as per the
1610,1611,1612,1613,1614,1615,GFL-
MEC- requirment of dubai building code
MEC-
1620,1621,1622,1623,1624,1625,1626, 1620,1621,1622,1623,1624,1625,1626,
L01-MEC-1631 to1634 L01-MEC-1631 to1634

The exhaust fans and ducting shall be

Car park exhaust fans shall be designed based on UAE fire code. The exhaust fans sized for 10 ACH in fire scenario on the Submit calculations for verification.
Car park extract and makeup air fans serving two levels are sized based on 10 HVAC CLIENT CLOSED, IN
5 HVAC
ACH (fire scenario) in one floor only.
Fans to be resized to achieve 6 ACH for both floors.
ELECT. POWER
HIGH
PROGRESS
COORDINATION & COST and ducting shall be sized for 10 ACH in fire scenario on the other floor and 6ACH other floor and 6ACH high CO LEVEL 3 closed Also, find attached commented Car park Fan calculations submitted
high CO condition for both floors. equipment (Fan) schedule.
condition for both floors. Calculation
rechecked and confrimed

CLIENT CLOSED, NO Sand trap not required for car park area make up air. All other make up air shall Louver/intake mesh sizing calculations louver free area calculation submitted
6 HVAC No sand trap is provided for makeup air system of parking area. Sand trap can be provided at makeup air inlet point. HVAC LOW
ACTION
COORDINATION & COST
be with sand trap louvers. Comment closed by WASL N/A closed to be submitted for verification. along with car park fan calculations

Total m2 required

Treated fresh air not required for unoccupied rooms as per ASHRAE 62.1
CLIENT CLOSED, IN R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-1210 Schedule of individual space ventilation
7 HVAC Fresh air is provided for IDF and electrical rooms. ASHRAE standard to be followed. HVAC LOW
PROGRESS
COORDINATION However the same shall be provided for rooms opening to ambient air to LEVEL 1 closed to be submitted for review.
Ventilation schedule submitted
maintain positive pressure. GFL-MEC-1221,1224

R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-1210 Closed. However, air balance sheet to

8 HVAC Pantry is provided with fresh air only. Extract air to be provided. HVAC LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST Exhaust to be provided as per ASHRAE 62.1 requirements LEVEL 1 closed be submitted for review
Refer to B02 - MEC-1202
B02-MEC-1201

Drivers Female and Male WCs are to be Updated Reference R1029-08-IBA-

9 HVAC Toilet area is not ventilated. Extract air to be provided. HVAC LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST Exhaust to be provided as per ASHRAE 62.1 requirements R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-1210 LEVEL 1 closed ventilated in drawing ref. 02-1201 DWG-B02-MEC-1198

Some of BOH areas such as security control room, landscape Asst. Manager are R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-1210 Closed. However, air balance sheet to
10 HVAC
not provided with fresh air.
Fresh air to be provided. HVAC LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST Ventilation to be provided as per ASHRAE 62.1 requirements LEVEL 1 closed be submitted for review
Ventilation schedule submitted
B02-MEC-1201

Page 1 of 15
# Classification: Shared - Confidential
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
Exhaust provided. However, air balance
Lifting station is provided with fan coil unit for air conditioning purpose without HVAC CLIENT CLOSED, IN Ventilation to be provided with duty/standby fans. Exhaust to be Discharged at R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-1210 Lifiting station ventilation calculation
11 HVAC
ventilation system.
Ventilation system to be provided. MEDIUM
PROGRESS
COORDINATION & COST
roof top.
LEVEL 1 closed sheet and sequence of FCU operation to
attacehd
ELECT. POWER B02-MEC-1201 be submitted for review.

Parallel arrangement noted. However,

IBA to provide ventilation Calculations for electrical substation as per DEWA
R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC- ventilation Calculations as per DEWA
12 HVAC Two fans are installed in series to ventilate entertainment elect. Substation. Fans to be installed in parallel. Series fans arrangement is not acceptable. HVAC LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION requirement and indicate required Fans in parallel arrangement with required LEVEL 1 closed requirement to be submitted to verify
Substation fans calculation attached
ESP 1211,1212,1213,1214
equipment flow rate.

Open. UPS rooms near B2 security

server room P-B02-415, Aria P-B02-798,
HVAC central entertainment P-B02-797 and
Standby unit to be provided to ensure continuation of service in power Dx Stand by units provided Refer to
13 HVAC One duty fan coil unit is provided for UPS room. (No standby unit).
interruption scenario. ELECT. POWER
MEDIUM TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST Agree. DX standby unit to be provided. R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-1210 LEVEL 1 closed B1 Aria P-B01-230, MGM2 P-B01-207 &
basement 2 and 1 drawings
P-B01-231 are not provided with stand
by DX unit. Please check all UPS rooms
and clarify.

Open. Drawing R1029-01-BSB-DWG-L02-

Louver location to be recoordinated with Architect to ensure compliance with HVAC Louver location to be recoordinated with Architect to ensure compliance with ARC-4451_J and R1029-03-IBA-DWG- Updated as per ARCH 4451 R1029-02-
14 HVAC Car park area extract air is discharged to outside via louvers located at L02 level.
DM regulation. ARCHITECTURAL
MEDIUM OPEN COORDINATION
DM regulation. R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-1240 LEVEL 3 closed L02-MEC-1240 are not matching for air CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-1240
intake and exhaust

Mentioned on drawings Refernce : MEC

B01 - 1211,12,11,12,13,1214,1215
VCDs are installed at extract and makeup-up air duct used for smoke VCD used in smoke management system shall be specified as fire rated for two Not Done. The same shall be mentioned
15 HVAC
management system. hours at 400°C.
HVAC MEDIUM OPEN COORDINATION & COST VCDs shall comply to UAE fire code 2018. Overall spectification will be updated LEVEL 3 closed on the drawings.
Mec- B02- 1201,1202,1203,1204
MEC GFL : 1221,1222,1223,1224
MEC L01, MEC L02

HVAC Condensate drain piping for all types of AHUs, FCUs to be indicated in drainage R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-DRA-1210 Closed. Revision in Drainage layouts 02-
16 HVAC Condensate drain for HVAC equipment (PHE) not shown on the drawings Condensate drain to be implemented. LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION
layout
LEVEL 1 closed 1210, 02-1190 noted..
closed
DRAINAGE R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1190

CLIENT CLOSED, IN Stair Pressurization fans located inside enclosed floor space to be fire rated as closed. However, revision cloud with
17 HVAC Pressurization fan installed within an enclosed space is not fire rated. Staircase pressurization fan installed in an enclosed space to be fire rated. HVAC MEDIUM
PROGRESS
COORDINATION & COST
per UAE FLS code Fan schedule fire rating updated LEVEL 3 closed tracker reference to be provided
R1029-02-IBA-DWG-ALL-MEC-9208

Total m2 required

No Separate smoke zone

Smoke zones / compartment is basement floor is not shown or clear on design HVAC No Separate compartment provided
18 HVAC
drawings.
Compartment for smoke control to be indicated on the drawings. HIGH TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION Smoke zones shall be as per UAE fire code and agreed with the FLS consultant. LEVEL 3 closed Not Done. compartments provided
ARCHITECTURAL Confrimed by FLS
Confrimed by FLS specialist

1.Centrifugal fans converted to axial fans.

2.Increasing No. of fans. Refer to 02-ARC-37 for impacetd
3.Fan rooms shall be provided with proper acous c treatment due to using axial fan. drawing details of Architecture.
- Ll Plantroom absorption onto slab/soffit and available walls shall be equivalent to
50mm thick black woven mat faced glass wool insulation with perforated aluminum ARCH
Current specfied Fans - Centrifugal fans need Fan room sizes to be increased.
sheet facing having nominal 22% open areas. Alternatively, 50mm thick polyester MEP CLIENT CLOSED, IN MEP IMPACTED DRAWING : R1029-02-
19 HVAC This increase in size of rooms and relocation of shaft are causing to lose 29 nos
panel having NRC 0.85 shall be installed. ACOUSTIC PROGRESS LEVEL 3 closed
parking spaces which is unacceptable to Client - Adequate sound attenuators for Air terminals
CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-1211,1213,1214
- Acoustic Louvers where required GFL-MEC-1221 ,
- Fans Vibration isolation
- Doors to be min. RW 35db
GFL-MEC-1223,1224,-L01-MEC-1234

Page 2 of 15
# Classification: Shared - Confidential
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
Stage -4

R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-MEC-
1211,1212,1213,1214,1215, B02-mec-
1202,1203,1204,1205
GFL-MEC-1221 1223,1224, L01-MEC-
CLIENT CLOSED, IN 1233,-L01-MEC-1234
20 HVAC Hap calculations to be submitted For review Revised Hap calculation submitted to be submitted HVAC COORDINATION LEVEL 3 closed
PROGRESS

R1029-09-IBA-DWG-ALL-MEC-9001
R1029-09-IBA-DWG-ALL-MEC-9202,
DPCV , DRV to be provided on chilled water drawings and CLIENT CLOSED, IN COORDINATION & R1029-16-IBA-DWG-ALL-MEC-9001
21 HVAC Chilled water drawings to be segregated HVAC level 3 closed
drawings to be segregated PROGRESS COST

A Revit walkthrough shall be carried out for the basement

and all car park areas to ensure that the current MEP
services coordination is carried out to ensure That the
current MEP services coordination is carried out to ensure CLIENT CLOSED, IN Updated on revit model screenshots
22 HVAC Car park clearnce to be maintained HVAC COORDINATION level -1 closed
that minimum clearances (especially within the drive PROGRESS attached.
ways) are achieved. More over, ensure that access to
equipment can be achieved with the current MEP services
arrangement

Total m2 required

Page 3 of 15
# Classification: Shared - Confidential
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
02 - FPR - PODIUM & BASEMENT
IMPACT ON PROCUREMENT

PRIORITY / KEY ISSUES / CLIENT AGREEMENT Wasl comments on milestone Reply of Wasl comments on milestone
REF NO DISCIPLINE ISSUE DESCRIPTION RESOLUTION PROPOSAL/COMMENT DISCIPLINES IMPACTED PURPOSE CLIENT REMARKS DOCUMENTS IMPACTED: IMPACT LEVEL INTERNAL STATUS
CRITICAL STAUS submission 2023/07/20 submission 2023/08/05

FIRE FIGHTING COMMENTS

CDP from OAHUs and MAHUs which are at higher levels to be connected to Ø150 Test pipe from Fire Pump up to Mentioned drawing attached
Irrigation tank. Any shortfall to be filled from TSE water from DM. In case TSE Condensate collection tank is noted in (02-FPR-6724)
water is not available, DEWA water to be filled. Fire pump test line and pressure drawing ref. 02-FPR-1214. However,
relief line to be connected to Irrigation tank to facilitate testing and pressure Drawing 01-FPR-6724 not found in this
The filling strategy of the irrigation tank from the fire water tank shall be
Provision of 200 dia pipe from diesel engine discharge to the irrigation Tank relief, as the fire tank is combined with domestic water tank submission to verify pressure relief line.
defined.
1 FIRE FIGHTING Provision of 150 dia pipe from elec. And Diesel engines discharge line to the Fire, Irrigation LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST R1029-01-CKR-DWG-B02-FPR-6724-PDF [G] LEVEL 1 CLOSED
We recommend including the 20 minutes of the fire pump operation within the
irrigation line
irrigation water tank, which shall be coordinated with the landscape consultant.

Sprinkler coverage to be ensured for all required areas as per UAE FLS code and Closed.
NFPA 13 requirement

Sprinkler distribution of the Maintenance storage and landscape storage room

2 FIRE FIGHTING The drawing shall be updated Fire Fighting LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-FPR-1211-PDF [I] LEVEL 3 CLOSED
is not matched with the architectural background

Sprinklers shall not be provided for electrical rooms. All electrical rooms above Closed. However, schedule of Clean Clean Agent schedule will be seperately
10 sqm shall be protected with clean agent system. agent systems to be included in submitted.
drawings

The electrical room is partially protected with a sprinkler system and clean agent The drawing shall be updated. The sprinkler head shall be omitted from the
3 FIRE FIGHTING Fire Fighting LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-FPR-1211-PDF [I] LEVEL 3 CLOSED
system electrical room

Drawings to be revised as per UAE FLS code and FHC locations to be coordinated Closed.
with architect.

The drawing shall be updated. The FHC shall be provided as per the UAE Fire
4 FIRE FIGHTING 3 Nos. FHC located nearby each other. Fire Fighting MEDIUM TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-FPR-1211-PDF [I] LEVEL 3 CLOSED
code.

Drawing to be revised by providing wet raiser pipe connection to FHC Not found in refered drawing Refer to DWG No: R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-
FPR-1211. DWG No mentioned in the
tracker comment number is wrong. As the
drawing mentioned in the tracker is from
Ground floor with Basement 01 tag.

5 FIRE FIGHTING No pipe connection to FHC Wet riser pipe connection shall be provided. Fire Fighting LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-FPR-1223-PDF [I] LEVEL 3 CLOSED

Drawing to be revised by providing connection to sprinklers from zone sprinkler Closed.

network

6 FIRE FIGHTING No pipe connection for sprinkler. Pipe distribution for sprinkler with pipe size shall be provided. Fire Fighting LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-FPR-1223-PDF [I] LEVEL 3 CLOSED

Drawing to be corrected in coordination with latest architectural layout Closed.

Total m2 required

7 FIRE FIGHTING Fire extinguishers are located in the middle of the room and parking area. The drawing shall be updated. Fire Fighting LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-FPR-1223-PDF [I] LEVEL 3 CLOSED

Clean agent shall be deleted for all electrical/ GSM room less than 10 sqm as per Implimented in MGM 1 drawing ref.07- Already implemented, drawings attached
the UAE fire code 2018. 1199

CLIENT CLOSED, IN
8 FIRE FIGHTING Clean agent system is provided for electrical room P-B01-145 of area 8 sqm. The clean agent system shall be omitted. Fire Fighting MEDIUM VALUE ENGINEERING R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-FPR-1234-PDF [I] N/A CLOSED
PROGRESS

Drawings to be revised and FHC location to be coordinated with architect. Closed.

9 FIRE FIGHTING FHC location is not correct. The FHC shall be relocated as per the architectural background. Fire Fighting LOW TECHNICALLY APPROVED COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-CKR-DWG-B01-FPR-1234-PDF [I] LEVEL 1 CLOSED

Page 4 of 15
# Classification: Shared - Confidential
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
02 - LPG - PODIUM & BASEMENT
IMPACT ON PROCUREMENT

PRIORITY / KEY ISSUES / Wasl comments on milestone Reply of Wasl comments on milestone
REF NO DISCIPLINE ISSUE DESCRIPTION RESOLUTION PROPOSAL/COMMENT DISCIPLINES IMPACTED PURPOSE CLIENT REMARKS DOCUMENTS IMPACTED: SPECIFICATION REFERENCES: IMPACT LEVEL INTERNAL STATUS
CRITICAL submission 2023/07/20 submission 2023/08/05

LPG COMMENTS
Location of LPG yard and related piping Drawings attached, requested for latest
route, accessories to be updated as per landscape architecture
latest master plan

1 LPG The LPG pipe corssing the road without RCC enacasmet RCC pipe encasment to be provided LPG/Structural MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-01-CKR-DWG-ALL-GAS-1001- PDF [A] .pdf LEVEL 3 ISSUED TO IMPLEMENT

RCC pipe encasement shall

be provided as per UAE
fire code.
Location of LPG yard and related piping Drawings attached, requested for latest
route, accessories to be updated as per landscape architecture
latest master plan
Coordination with
Infra/architect/landscape
LPG / Landscape / consultant. Second stage
2 LPG LPG 2nd stage PRDP is located within the landscape area Coordination with Infra/architect/landscape consultant is required HIGH COORDINATION & COST R1029-01-CKR-DWG-ALL-GAS-1001- PDF [A] .pdf LEVEL 3 ISSUED TO IMPLEMENT
Architectural regulators shall be
provided before entering
the basement area for all
LPG pipes to maintian
pressure requirement as
per UAE fire code.

3 LPG The LPG pipe riser inside the F&B area are exposed Coordination with architect consultant is required LPG/Architectural HIGH COORDINATION & COST R1029-07-CKR-DWG-B01-GAS-1199-PDF [H] LEVEL 3 ISSUED TO IMPLEMENT
LPG pipe routing shall be
as per UAE fire code and
the location shall be
coordinated with ID/
Archtiect.

Total m2 required

Page 5 of 15
# Classification: Shared - Confidential
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
02 - PHW - PODIUM & BASEMENT
IMPACT ON PROCUREMENT

PRIORITY / KEY ISSUES / Wasl comments on milestone IBA REPLY ON WASL COMMENTS-
REF NO DISCIPLINE ISSUE DESCRIPTION RESOLUTION PROPOSAL/COMMENT DISCIPLINES IMPACTED PURPOSE CLIENT REMARKS DOCUMENTS IMPACTED: SPECIFICATION REFERENCES: IMPACT LEVEL INTERNAL STATUS
CRITICAL submission 2023/07/20 02-08-23

PUBLIC HEALTH WATER COMMENTS

Water supply and drainage Hot water return for Admin Exec Noted and included in as part of
network to be completed Toilets to be confirmed latest submission
considering latest
architectural, ID and
kitchen layouts
To be updated providing missing connections and network based on latest
1 Public Health-Water Administration offices wet areas are not connected into water supply network. Water MEDIUM COORDINATION R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-WAT-1212 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
layout and to be Coordinated with ID, applicable for entire building.

CCU humidifiers to be Not Done. Example security server Noted and included in as part of
provided with water room CCU not provided with water latest submission, refer item no 19
connection connection. Please check all CCU units 2. water distribution for server room
locations for water connection. in aria building will be part of aria
submission refer drawing no:R1029-
04-IBA-DWG-B02-WAT-1198
2 Public Health-Water No water supply provision considered for server rooms CCU. To add water supply provision for each electrical room provided with CCU Water MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-IBA-B02-WAT-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED

Water supply and drainage Water distribution for toilet is part of confirm that water distribution is
network to be completed Aria 04-L02-WAT-1202 part of Aria 04-L02-WAT-1202
considering latest
architectural, ID and
kitchen layouts
3 Public Health-Water Public toilets water supply distribution is not provided. To provide all missing wet areas with water supply service distribution Water MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-IBA-L02-WAT-1244 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED

Water supply and drainage Open. All drawings related to plaza plaza Public health design
network to be completed area to be coordinated with architect coordination is work in progress as
considering latest and landscape designer per email dated 25th july
architectural, ID and
kitchen layouts
To update the design as per latest arch and verify areas provision requirement
Plaza area and surrounding water supply network to be coordinated with latest
4 Public Health-Water for events. Also to be checked with the Main Consultant for the type of each Water MEDIUM COORDINATION R1029-02-IBA-L02-WAT-1244 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
arch.
retail.

Haze machines to be Please check details of proposed haze plaza public health design
provided with potable machines and their requirements. coordination is work in progress as
water supply. Scope to be Incorporate services accordingly. per email dated 1st of august
coordinated by kling
R1029-02-IBA-B01-WAT-1210,
This part to be shifted to irrigation design not under water supply as part of
Part of the design drawings include site irrigation provisions for landscape areas GFL-WAT-1220,
5 Public Health-Water coordination and design verification in coordination with the Landscape Water MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
and events Haze machines locations L01-WAT-1230,
Consultant. Haze machines shall be supplied with DEWA water.
L02-WAT-1240,

Bib taps with lock shield
key to be provided in
public accessible car park
areas. All mechanical plant
rooms to be provided with
Bib taps to be provided where missing in basement car parking and plant room water supply (bib tap) and
6 Public Health-Water Shortage for car parking and plant rooms Bib taps Water MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST
such as TSE plant. floor drain
Noted bib taps addition in 02-1200, 02- Noted and included in as part of
1210. However same to be latest submission
coordinated with architect as
proposed locations are clasing with car
parks. Refer to drainage layout where
600*600 catch pit indicated for
R1029-02-IBA-B01-WAT-1210, B02-WAT-1200, LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED

Total m2 required

Water supply and drainage Not Done. No revision noted on 02- Noted and included in as part of
network to be completed 1210 with this tracker reference. latest submission
considering latest
architectural, ID and
kitchen layouts
To review the network and update where required including to remove pipe
7 Public Health-Water Pipe connection at basement without connection for identification. Water MEDIUM COORDINATION R1029-02-IBA-B01-WAT-1210 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
that are having no connection to use.

Minimum flow Decoupler Boiler circuit delta T to be 20 Deg C. Noted and included in as part of
line shall be provided to Flow rates to be revised accordingly. latest submission
ensure flow in the primary Also, boiler closed circuit to have
circuit. expansion vessels. Each boiler burner
to be provided with separate LPG
Boiler provided with variable primary flow circulating pump without bypass pressure regulator
8 Public Health-Water To provide minimum flow by pass pipe connection. Water MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-WAT-6723 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
connection for minimum flow

The boiler circulation Motorized control valve to be provided Noted and included in as part of
system between boilers for each boiler latest submission
and calorifiers shall be
based on variable primary
pumping system.
Boiler variable primary flow circulating pump is controlled via differential R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-WAT-6723,
9 Public Health-Water boiler operation updated considering constant flow . Water MEDIUM COORDINATION LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
Temperature R1029-01-IBA-DWG-B02-WAT-6708,

Solar panel with overheat To be considered in MGM, Aria, After reviewing the solar system
protection to be specified Bellagio submissions specification, it can be conformed
and safety relief valves to that emergency cooler will not be
be provided required due to:
The solar panels specified are
powder coated dark blue aluminum
10 Public Health-Water For solar no overheating protection is used Built-in over heating protection is required other than radiation type. Water MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-08-IBA-DWG-ALL-WAT-9303 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
frame with thermal switching
absorber layer with phase change
temperature dependent shutdown
properties consisting of crystalline
structure and thermochrom coating
i.e. when the solar collector reach

Page 6 of 15
# Classification: Shared - Confidential
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
IBA to prepare and submit Calculations to be attached along with Noted and included in as part of
water demand this submission latest submission
calculations for review.
The total domestic water
storage shall be 2 days as
Calculation domestic To be removed for daily water demand calculation only but shall be maintained per DEWA requirement.
11 Calculation include 10% safety on demand Water MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-IBA-CAL-WAT-9003 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
daily demand for equipment calculation.

IBA to prepare and submit Water piping material to be clarified Refer updated reply.
GRE PN20 shall be used for domestic hot water pipe material based on
hydraulic calculations
following:
determining pump head
-Hot water guest room & public toilet(hws/hwr) with calorifier water
for review. Riser piping
temperature 60c if the water network pressure higher than 12.1 BAR,the
material shall be suitable
pressure
The design pressure for hot water system is reaching 13 to 16 bar and the pipe for 1.5 times the design
12 Public Health-Water limit (12.1 bar) shall be based on ppr manufacture approved material. Water HIGH COORDINATION & COST ALL LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
material is PPR PN20. pressure.
-Hot water kitchen & laundry(khws/khwr) with calorifier water temprature 70c
if the water network pressure higher than 8.1 BAR,the pressure
limit (8.1 bar) shall be based on ppr manufacture approved material.

The water disinfection Closed

shall be automatic
chlorine dosing system as
per DM requirement.
Minimum ppm level sof
Recommend using copper silver ionization instead of the Chlorine dioxide for chlorine shall be
13 Public Health-Water Chlorine dioxide water treatment is provided for legionella prevention. Water MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-04-IBA-DWG-ALL-WAT-9301 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
water treatment maintained.

The remote point residual Calculations to be attached along with Noted and included in as part of
pressure to be considered this submission latest submission
for domestic water
calculation shall be 3 bar.
Each guestroom fixture shall have pressure between 30 to 75 PSI (2.0 to 5.0 bar) However pressure at
The pressure range used for domestic water pumps head calculation for sanitary as per MGM brand standards. fixture shall be between 2
14 Public Health-Water Water/Power HIGH COORDINATION & COST LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
fixtures residual pressure was between 2.5 – 4.0 Bar. As agreed with WASL, 3.0bar will be used for each guest room fixture to verify to 5 bar as per MGM
the domestic water pump head calculation. standards.

Part of pipe sizes on the drawing are not complying with the nominal pipe sizes
list such as
15 Public Health-Water - 75 mm needs to be 80 mm. Pipe sizes on the drawings to be reviewed following the nominal pipe size list. Water HIGH COORDINATION & COST All Drawing LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
- 110 mm needs to be 125 mm.
- 160 mm needs to be 150 mm.

To add the missing contractor work requirement points in the standard general
16 Public Health-Water Typical general notes does not cover all needed contractor work requirement. Water LOW COORDINATION All Drawing LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
notes.

To provide details including note,calculation,section and layout for the tank

level control requirement for storage.
Irrigation tank for condensate drain collection and municipality domestic water R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-WAT-1214,
17 Public Health-Water Water MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
is missing water storage arrangement and control requirement. Also, a note was added for TSE tank having planter drain and TSE filling to R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-WAT-1201,
confirm similar control and storage to be applied as per condensate and
domestic filling irrigation tank.
Total m2 required

18 Public Health-Water Updation in equipment schedule. Equipment schedule upadated based on the current design Water LOW COORDINATION R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-WAT-9001& 9002 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED

To update plumbing water services incooperating the new archtectural including

19 New archtecturer changes including wet area water services Water HIGH COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-WAT-1210,B02-WAT-1200,GFL-WAT-1220 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
wet areas

missing control valve for cooled cold water heat exchanger to allow for control
20 To add heat exchanger conyrol valve as per cooled cold sequence of operation Water LOW COORDINATION & COST R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-WAT-6703 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
requirement as per sequence of operation

To update the desgn for softner to be specified as duplex softener also to

21 softner not provided as duplex also no stand by is considered Water MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-WAT-6714,B02-WAT-6707 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
provide stand by duplex softner to have duty stand by

Page 7 of 15
# Classification: Shared - Confidential
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
DRAINAGE AND STORM WATER COMMENTS
Lifting shall be based Schedule revised except one set. 1. for drainage revised schedule
based on 1 duty and 1 Please correct all equipment. Lift pit refer item no 13
assist pumps. drain pump discharge to be connected 2. For Lift pit drainage pump into
to nearest Car park lifting station. nearest car parking lifting station
To modify the design to have all basement lifting pumps sequence ( duty + 1 Control panels location to be refer item no 20
1 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN The current all basement lifting pumps sequence ( duty + 1 standby) Drainage MEDIUM COORDINATION R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-DRA-6705 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
backup). reviewed. Missing grease trap and 3. The same shown in electrical
Sewage lifting station equipment to be drawing refer power layout.
incorporated 4.For grease trap & sewerage lifting
station equipment refer item no 20

Water supply and drainage Gym wet area and office wet area work in progress, accordingly to
network to be completed drainage piping in 08-1198 indicated current design seperation for wet
considering latest with note for pipe in pipe (which is area above kitchen is required this
architectural, ID and running in high level of B2 kitchen). update is in incoordination with
kitchen layouts Please check and revise. architect so that to be implemented
2 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Wet areas not connected into drain network To connect all missing wet areas into the drainage network Drainage MEDIUM COORDINATION R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-DRA-1212 & B02-DRA-1194 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED

car parking area drains to please provide calculation for basis of please note carparking drain points
be provided as per DM aditional drains in 02-1190, 02-1200, where provided where drain way
drainage requirement 02-1210.. Also, back flow preventers found to be not provided with the
locations to be reviewed. same
The car parking provided drain points are not enough to cover the complete To add where required car parking drain points to cover the complete car R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-DRA-1210, R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1190, carparking drain considering not to
3 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Drainage MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
parking areas. parking areas. R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1200, exceed distance 30m b/w two
carparkig drains.
For back preventor refer item no 25

To be coordinated with Refered drawing not included in this Noted and included in as part of
structural Drawings and submission for review. Drainge latest submission
shall not pass through drawing for Ground Floor, L01 & L02
shear wall. are missing in this submission.
Current design to be coordinated with structure, and to avoid the crossing Drainage /
4 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Drainage pipes crossing structural shear wall. MEDIUM COORDINATION R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1205, B02-DRA-1200 & B01-DRA-1215 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
where possible. Structure

Drain grating to be Open. Not incorporated. included also updated foul tank
provided with seal sewage pump calculation included
trap/gully with revised discharge pipe size
Drainage /
Update the design for Foul pump & TSE pump room to provide grating for drain
5 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Foul pump & TSE pump room missing drainage grating. Structure / MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1191 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
and connect into drainage system.
Architectural

Coordinate with Refered drawing not included in this Noted and included in as part of
Landscape consultants and submission for review. Drainge latest submission, please note this
provide all required drain drawing for Ground Floor, L01 & L02 item work was inprogress as per our
To update the site planter drains to be connected through network into TSE points and drain network are missing in this submission. email dated 25th july 2023
Site planter drain are shown without connection into drainage network, and
Tank and to provide planter drains for the missing green areas incoordination to be completed R1029-03-IBA-DWG-GFL-DRA-1201, GFL-DRA-1220
6 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN part of the landscape areas are missing the planter drain, also Geo. Textile Drainage MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
with landscape designer, also to include Geo. Textile membrane and gravel with R1029-03-IBA-DWG-L02-DRA-1240, L02-DRA-1243 & L03-DRA-1254
membrane and gravel are not used for the planter detail.
planter drain detail.

Drain to be considered for Basement 2 high level Part drawings Provided Refer latest submission
CCUs not availble for review.

R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1200
7 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN No drain provision considered for server rooms CCU. To add drain provision for each electrical room provided with CCU Drainage MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
and R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-DRA-1210

Coordinate with Refered drawing not included in this Noted and included in as part of
Landscape consultants and submission for review latest submission, please note this
provide all required drain item work was inprogress as per our
points and drain network email dated 25th july 2023
Podium irrigation drainage network to be completed and collected for re-use
Podium planter irrigation drain network is incomplete, also planter drain to be completed
8 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN into TSE tank also the additional lifting pump is cancelled as yhe planter drain Drainage MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-DRA-6710- LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
provided with additional pump which is not required
network is provided by gravity

Total m2 required

Reroute / rearrange Drain Part drawings not availble for review included part plan, refer latest
pipe with out cross submission
substation and electrical
rooms as per DEWA
Drainage pipes shall be rerouted. Otherwise, attic slab to be provided at Drainage / R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1190
requirements
9 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Drainage pipes crossing substation and electrical rooms electrical rooms H/L as per DM. This to be coordinated with arch. And Structure / MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
structure, to be specified where applicable for entire building Architectural R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-DRA-1210

Revision (02-DRA-12) noted in 02-DRA- this comment is not applicable for this
1200. Please include in tracker podium and basement submission this
comment is related to building storm
To modify the design to have the roof rain water collection with network free Agreed, however, the water & emergency free discharge
Rain water riser continuity not reflected in floor plan same as schematic. discharge at site surrounding areas. building permit condition R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-DRA-1210 which covers under building podium &
10 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Roof rain water outlets coordination with architect. For car parking drainage to be connected into drainage lifting station through Drainage HIGH NEW ITEM on storm water design to R1029-03-IBA-DWG-GFL-DRA-1220 NOT APPLICABLE IMPLEMENTED basement drawings, accordingly for
sand trap. be complied and agreed R1029-03-IBA-DWG-L02-DRA-1240 this podium and basement submission
Also rain water roof outlets to be coordinated with architect layout with DM this comment is not valid.

Revision (02-DRA-12) noted in 02-DRA- This comment was implemented refer

1200. Please include in tracker drawing no-R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-
The ground and upper floors drainage connected by gravity into basement H/L, DRA-6709,
To change the gravity drainage coming from ground and upper levels to be
then diverted into central foul tank from which drainage will be discharged by R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1191,
connected into site external manholes and to delete the basement H/L network
lifting pumps into project infrastructural drainage system.
as well the central foul tank and their pumps. R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-DRA-6709,
11 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Kitchen and basement drainage are connected into basement grease DRAINAGE / Architect HIGH NEW ITEM NOT APPLICABLE IMPLEMENTED
Kitchen and basement drainage will remain to be connected into basement R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1191,
interceptor and lifting pump then into basement central foul tank from which
grease interceptor and lifting pump but the discharge of the lifting pump will be
drainage will be discharged by lifting pumps into project infrastructural drainage
connected into the site external new manhole network.
system.

Revision (02-DRA-12) noted in 02-DRA- This comment was implemented refer

1200. Please include in tracker drawing no R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-
DRA-6710, R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-
DRA-1210,
To seperate all pressure pipes coming from the lifting station including sewage R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1200
R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-DRA-6710, R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-DRA-1210,
12 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Seperation of pressure pipe coming from all lifting pump lifting station,car park lifting station,drive way lifting station,lift pit lifting pump Drainage HIGH NEW ITEM LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1200,
to foul tank with dedicated pipes for each.

Drawing Ref. 01-DRA-6711 to be drawing reference 6711 is the

To update the design based on sewerage lifting stations, accordingly, to revise clarified. Also, drawing reference to be schemetic for condesate drain the
Sewerage lifting pumps were designed considering the pit as holding tank. the calculation and pits requirements. provided for location of indicated same is updated in latest submission
condensate lift pumps including deleting nrv & the note
R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-DRA-6710, R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-DRA-6712, mentioned for each tower pressurized
Also F&B, kitchen, retails & wet areas calculation were not consistent and has To update F&B, kitchen, retails & wet areas calculation as per latest retails list
13 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Drainage HIGH COORDINATION & COST R1029-18-IBA-DWG-GFL-UTI-INF-60006, LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED cindensation drain, instead schematic
many missing. requirement and to coordinate the calculation reference and basis.
R1029-18-IBA-DWG-GFL-UTI-INF-60501, showing gravity line, refer item no 19

Lifting pumps were designed without conserving sprinkler drain condition Where applicable to update the lifting pumps flow rate considering sparkler
drain condition.

Page 8 of 15
# Classification: Shared - Confidential
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
Drawing Ref. 01-DRA-6710 to be noted and incooperated, refer item no
revised with dicharge of lift pit pumps 20&21
to nearest car park lifting station. Also
notes regarding SCADA system to be
To add the missing contractor work requirement points in the standard general revised
14 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Typical general notes does not cover all needed contractor work requirement. Drainage HIGH COORDINATION & COST ALL LEVEL 2 IMPLEMENTED
notes.

Drawing Ref. 01-DRA-6709 Overall Site Noted and included in as part of latest
Gravity Drainage Schematic to be submission
revised by mentioning the Manhole
Not applicable for
referance of external drainage
drainage.
Irrigation tank using condensate drain collection and municipality domestic To provide details including note,calculation,section and layout for the tank leve R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B01-DRA-1214, network.
15 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Drainage HIGH COORDINATION & COST This was included in
water is missing lcontrol requirement for storage. R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1201,
water, refer above water
item 17.

Drawing Ref. 01-DRA-6706 Typical please refer drwaing no-R1029-01-IBA-

Details - Drainage Sheet-5 indicates DWG-ALL-DRA-6704 &R1029-01-IBA-
details of SLS 1, 2 & 3. Please clarify DWG-ALL-DRA-6706
where details of SLS 4,5 and 6 are
incorporated.
16 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Updation in equipment schedule. Equipment schedule upadated based on the current design Drainage LOW COORDINATION R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-DRA-9001& 9002 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED

To update plumbing drainage services incooperating the new archtectural

17 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN New archtecturer changes including wet area drainage services Drainage HIGH COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1190,B01-DRA-1210,GFL-DRA-1220 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
including wet areas

plant rooms having calorifiers are using floor drains which will required complecated
18 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN To use channel grating close to calorifiers instead of flpoor drains for the plant rooms Drainage MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1190 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
and additional drain piping from the equipment

schmatic for condensate drain collectted from ac equipoment including comment and To updated the schematic the note and nrv so that to confirm that the network
19 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Drainage HIGH COORDINATION & COST R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-DRA-6711 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
nrv for pressurized network were as the network is having gravity design working by gravity

to update the design considering lift pit discharge pipe to be connected into nearest
20 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Lift pits discharge pipe connected into foul tank including additional piping Drainage MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1190,B01-DRA-1210 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
car parking pit as more effective design with less piping requirement

SCADA is used for basement for sewerage lifting stations control due to the reson SCADA is not required instead all the sewerage lifiting pump control wiil be through
that operation to be not allowing for more than one pump to be WORKING TO BMS as cost effective this is appplicable after updating the drainage design for
21 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Drainage MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-DRA-6710- LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
DISCHARGE INTO FOUL TANK, as the discharge line is common for all sewerage lifting sewerage lifting considering each station to have separate discharge line connected
pumps into the fouil tank

Total m2 required

to updated the design with providing for each ventilation tunnels with gerneral
22 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN car parking mechanical ventilation tunnles are not provided with general drain points Drainage MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST R1029-03-IBA-DWG-L02-DRA-1240,GFL-DRA-1220,B01-DRA-1210 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
drainage points.

R1029-03-IBA-DWG-L02-DRA-1240,L01-DRA-1230,GFL-DRA-1220,B01-DRA-
23 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN missing drainage for staircase open to outside to prvide the missing drainage in open to outside staircases Drainage MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
1210,

Current Slopes for horizontal runs drainage pipes requirement provided on design To change the horizontal runs drainage pipes slopes requirement to comply with DM
24 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN drawings: requirement as follow: Drainage MEDIUM ALL LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
100 MM - 1:90, 150 MM - 1:120 and 200 MM - 1:150 100 MM - 1:60, 150 MM - 1:90 and 200 MM - 1:120

basement 02 drainage back flow preventor require manhole for accesibility to confirm that that all basement drainage network with back flow preventor to be
25 PUBLIC HEALTH DRAIN Drainage MEDIUM R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-DRA-1191,-B02-DRA-1192,-B02-DRA-1194
(maintanance and replacement) installed for manhole for accesibility.

Page 9 of 15
# Classification: Shared - Confidential
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
02 - ELE - PODIUM & BASEMENT
IMPACT ON PROCUREMENT

PRIORITY / KEY ISSUES

REF NO DISCIPLINE ISSUE DESCRIPTION RESOLUTION PROPOSAL/COMMENT COMMENT CATEGORY PURPOSE CLIENT REMARKS AUTHORITY IMPACT DOCUMENTS IMPACTED: SPECIFICATION REFERENCES: IMPACT LEVEL INTERNAL STATUS
/ CRITICAL

ELECTRICAL COMMENTS
A - AUTHORITY /
Proceed to comply with
1 ELECTRICAL TX's transportation routes to be identified from GF, B1 and B2. Approval shall be obtained from Dewa OPERATOR MEDIUM COORDINATION NO R1029-02-IBA-DWG-ALL-ELE-6605 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
authority requirement
COMPLIANCE

Proceed to apply correct

diversity factor complying
with DEWA standard
High demand factors are indicated e.g. 0.85 for 0.85 lighting and small power Reduced demand factor shall be considered. (from final DB up to MDB R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9001,
2 ELECTRICAL O - OPTIMISATION (VE) MEDIUM COORDINATION YES LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
etc. level) and consider only R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9002
realistic spare
loads/spaces and optimize
overall TCL and LV panels.

A - AUTHORITY /
Proceed to comply with TO BE SUBMITTED FOR
3 ELECTRICAL Dewa approval is not obtained for transformer and RMU room arrangements Dewa HV approval shall be obtained OPERATOR MEDIUM COORDINATION YES LEVEL 3
authority requirement AUTHORITY APPROVAL
COMPLIANCE

Fire shutters are currently not required by DEWA. However, drawings to be

submitted for DEWA approval.
Proceed to comply with
4 ELECTRICAL Fire shutter is shown in the basement floors O - OPTIMISATION (VE) MEDIUM COORDINATION YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-ELP-1200 LEVEL 3 CLOSED
authority requirement
( As per latest discussion with Dewa, fire shutters are accepted for the
substation)

A - AUTHORITY / R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-ELE-6606,
DEWA external Mobile Generator Trucks to be coordinated with Archi and Proceed to coordinate
5 ELECTRICAL Mobile generator transportation not indicated OPERATOR MEDIUM COORDINATION YES R1029-03-IBA-DWG-ALL-ELE-6607 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
structural Engineers, as the weight of DEWA Gen Truck around 30 Tons. with Kling
COMPLIANCE

Proceed to obtain DEWA

A - AUTHORITY / approval on current
Mobile generator connection is provided so that one LV panel in each LV room
6 ELECTRICAL Mobile generator shall be provided for all LV panels OPERATOR MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST mobile generator YES R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-ELE-6610 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
will be connected to mobile generator at a time.
COMPLIANCE strategy, Client will
Total m2 required
support for the same

Routings for standby generators busbar from L02/GF to B2 is not properly The busbar route and structural opening shall be properly coordinated with T- TECHNICAL
7 ELECTRICAL MEDIUM COORDINATION Proceed to coordinate with Kling NO R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-ELE-6615 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
indicated in the layouts structure engineer CORRECTNESS

A - AUTHORITY /
All MV cables to be coordinated with ducts space form at least one side as per Proceed to comply with
8 ELECTRICAL MV cable routing is not coordinated with other MEP services OPERATOR LOW COORDINATION YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-ALL-ELE-6613 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
DEWA. authority requirement
COMPLIANCE

A - AUTHORITY /
Directional exit signs shall be provided as per DCD requirements. Proceed to comply with
9 ELECTRICAL Directional exit signs are not provided in most of the areas OPERATOR LOW COORDINATION & COST YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-EML-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
UAE FLS requirement
COMPLIANCE

Proceed to comply with

A - AUTHORITY / latest authority
Relocate the CBS panel and FA risers away from the electrical room as per DEWA
10 ELECTRICAL CBS panel/FA risers are located in electrical rooms. OPERATOR MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST requirement. Fire alarm YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-EML-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
requirements. Separate rooms for CBs to be considered at basement level.
COMPLIANCE cables shall be moved to
IDF rooms.

Page 10 of 15
Classification: Shared - Confidential
#
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER

A - AUTHORITY /
Proceed to comply with
11 ELECTRICAL Normal Lighting switches are provided in wet areas Weather proof switches shall be provided for wet areas OPERATOR LOW COORDINATION & COST YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-ELT-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
DEWA standard
COMPLIANCE

12 ELECTRICAL Building reference not provided for earth pits Revise the drawings to provide the earth pits reference. C - COMPLETENESS LOW COORDINATION Proceed to correct the drawings NO R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-ELE-1200 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED

13 ELECTRICAL Two numbers of earth pits provided for LV Panels One earth pit can be provided for LV panels with all earth bars linked. O - OPTIMISATION (VE) LOW VALUE ENGINEERING Proceed to comply with DEWA Regulations NO N/A OPEN

Proceed to obtain DEWA

Mobile generator connection is provided for secondary LV rooms/panels: approval on current
14 ELECTRICAL busbar is provided from Bellagio generator room to secondary LV rom which is Mobile generator connection to be provided for the main ACB panels O - OPTIMISATION (VE) LOW VALUE ENGINEERING mobile generator NO N/A OPEN
around 150m away. strategy, Client will
support for the same

Proceed to coordinate
The 3rd generator for MGM02 is located at ground floor of central Generator room to be provided near MGM or building in coordination with
15 ELECTRICAL O - OPTIMISATION (VE) LOW COORDINATION with Kling (Space palnning NO N/A OPEN
entertainment which is around 170m away from MGM02 room. Architect
required)

ECC room shall be located and easily accessible from outside. The same to be
A - AUTHORITY /
coordinated with FLS. Proceed to comply with
16 ELECTRICAL ECC rooms are located inside the building and opening to service corridors OPERATOR LOW COORDINATION YES R1029-03-IBA-DWG-L02-FAS-1240 LEVEL 3 CLOSED
UAE FLS requirement
COMPLIANCE
The ECC room location is acceptable as confirmed by the FLS.

RMU rooms to be located at plot limit unless DEWA approval is obtained by Proceed to obtain DEWA
A - AUTHORITY /
infra team in the current proposed location. approval on current
17 ELECTRICAL RMU incoming cables are passing through the basement floor OPERATOR MEDIUM COORDINATION YES R1029-01-IBA-DWG-B02-ELE-1001 LEVEL 3 OPEN
design, Client will support
COMPLIANCE
(To be submitted for Dewa for the approval) for the same

A - AUTHORITY /
FFL for main LV rooms is the same FFL of the driveway. The trench depth in the Raise the FFL by 100mm. The trench shall be of same depth as the transformer Proceed to coordinate
18 ELECTRICAL OPERATOR LOW COORDINATION YES R1029-02-KCD-DWG-B02-ARC-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
LV room is 850mm. room of 950mm. with Kling
COMPLIANCE

Total m2 required
A - AUTHORITY /
R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9001,
19 ELECTRICAL Normal isolators are provided for fire life safety equipment Fire rated isolators to be provided for FLS equipment. OPERATOR MEDIUM COORDINATION & COST Proceed to comply with authority requirementNO LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9002
COMPLIANCE

R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9001,
20 ELECTRICAL 65KA breaking capacity are considered for the incoming breakers. Breaking capacity of main incoming breaker can be reduced to 50KA. O - OPTIMISATION (VE) LOW COORDINATION Proceed to comply with DEWA standard NO LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9002

Fuel tank capacity inside generator room is 3000Lit which is exceeding UAE code
A - AUTHORITY / Proceed with 3000 lit and
requirement (2498 L) with UAE code. As indicated in the received close out TO BE SUBMITTED FOR
21 ELECTRICAL DCD official approval is required to be obtained for 3000 L per tank. OPERATOR MEDIUM COORDINATION coordinate with FLS to YES R1029-03-IBA-DWG-GFL-ELP-1220 LEVEL 3
report, the amount of 3000L per tank inside the generator room has been AUTHORITY APPROVAL
COMPLIANCE obtain DCD approval.
agreed with Dubai Civil Defence.

Proceed to correct the

drawings. Proceed to
22 ELECTRICAL VE Speaker is provided for each staircase level One VE speaker could be provided for each alternative floor. O - OPTIMISATION (VE) MEDIUM COORDINATION NO R1029-02-IBA-DWG-ALL-FAS-9001 N/A OPEN
comply with UAE FLS
requirement

Proceed to obtain DEWA

A - AUTHORITY /
The transformer rooms are proposed at basement-2 level which requires DEWA approval on current TO BE SUBMITTED FOR
23 ELECTRICAL DEWA HV approval shall be obtained for the same. OPERATOR MEDIUM COORDINATION YES LEVEL 3
special approval. design, Client will support AUTHORITY APPROVAL
COMPLIANCE
for the same

Page 11 of 15
Classification: Shared - Confidential
#
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
Proceed to corect the
A - AUTHORITY /
drawings as per revised DESIGN CHANGE UNDER
24 ELECTRICAL Incoming power cables for RMU are not matching with the updated infra design. Incoming cables to RMUs to be coordinated with the updated infra design. OPERATOR MEDIUM COORDINATION YES LEVEL 3
infra design in PROCESS
COMPLIANCE
coordination with Kling.

A - AUTHORITY /
Proceed to comply with R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9001,
25 ELECTRICAL Some equipment are not provided with Earth leakage breaker/ relay. Earth leakage protection/ sensor to be indicated for all equipment OPERATOR LOW COORDINATION & COST YES LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
authority requirement R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9002
COMPLIANCE

Industrial equipment are provided with 30mA ELCB.

Industrial equipment will be provided with 100ma/300mA as per DEWA in order T- TECHNICAL Proceed to comply with R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9001,
26 ELECTRICAL LOW COORDINATION NO LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
to avoid possible trip CORRECTNESS authority requirement R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9002

Proceed to correct the

Wall mounted speakers are provided in the staircases while wall mounted drawings. Proceed to
27 ELECTRICAL Wall mounted speaker to be provided. C - COMPLETENESS LOW COORDINATION NO R1029-02-IBA-DWG-ALL-FAS-9001 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
speakers with flashers are provided for staircases in the fire alarm schematic. comply with UAE FLS
requirement

Proceed to correct the

VE - VALUE drawings and comply with
28 ELECTRICAL VE Speaker is provided for each staircase level One VE speaker could be provided for each alternative floor. LOW VALUE ENGINEERING NO N/A ISSUED TO IMPLEMENT
ENGINEERING UAE FLS
requirement. Stairs shal

A - AUTHORITY /
Proceed to comply with R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9001,
29 ELECTRICAL Spare breaker of 100A are provided in the LV panels Spare breaker less than 160A breaker shall be moved to SMDBs OPERATOR MEDIUM COORDINATION YES LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
authority requirement R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9002
COMPLIANCE

Proceed to comply with R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9001,

30 ELECTRICAL No of ways and the outgoing reference number is missing In the electrical panels Feeder number shall be indicated in the SLD C - COMPLETENESS MEDIUM COORDINATION NO LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
authority requirement R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9002

A - AUTHORITY /
Different loads are considered for EV charging stations( 7kw, 11kw,17kw and Proceed to comply with
31 ELECTRICAL One value of electrical load (advisalbe 22 kW) to be considered for EV charger. OPERATOR LOW COORDINATION YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-ELP-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
22kw) authority requirement
COMPLIANCE

Total m2 required

One lighting fixture can be provided for each staircase landing to achieve the Proceed to comply with
32 ELECTRICAL 2 lighting fixtures are provided for each staircase landing. O - OPTIMISATION (VE) LOW VALUE ENGINEERING NO N/A ISSUED TO IMPLEMENT
required lux level. authority requirement

Proceed to correct the

R1029-01-IBA-DWG-ALL-ELE-6606,
T- TECHNICAL drawings and comply with
33 ELECTRICAL Mobile generator parking location not indicated in the layout The mobile generator location to be shown in the layout LOW COORDINATION YES R1029-03-IBA-DWG-ALL-ELE-6607 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
CORRECTNESS UAE FLS
requirement. Stairs shal

Proceed to comply with

Modifications of electrical requirments for other disciplines (Mech, IT/AV, Implementing the modified electrical requirements of other desciplines (Mech, T- TECHNICAL
34 ELECTRICAL LOW COORDINATION & COST electrical good practice NO R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-ELP-1200 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
security, VT, pools, Façade Lighting etc.) IT/AV, security, VT, pools,Façade Lighting etc.) CORRECTNESS
and DEWA standard

Proceed to correct the

A - AUTHORITY / R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-ELT-1200,
drawing and comply with
35 ELECTRICAL Change lighiting fixtures in all toilets to IP-55 In all toilets provide lights to IP-55 (as per DEWA) OPERATOR LOW COORDINATION & COST YES R1029-03-IBA-DWG-GFL-ELT-1220 , LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
project
COMPLIANCE R1029-03-IBA-DWG-L01-ELT-1230
requirement.

Page 12 of 15
Classification: Shared - Confidential
#
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
A - AUTHORITY /
Electrical room are very congested. Panels are not properly sized especially for Actual panel size shall be considered and additional space shall be provided
36 ELECTRICAL OPERATOR LOW NEW ITEM YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-ELP-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
the MCC panels inside the electrical room
COMPLIANCE

A - AUTHORITY /
37 ELECTRICAL Electrical room/ IDF room are provided with smoke detector with sounder base Electrical/IDF room shall be provided with smokde detector OPERATOR LOW NEW ITEM YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-FAS-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

A - AUTHORITY /
38 ELECTRICAL Plant rooms are provided with heat detector Combined smoke and heat detector shall be provided for plant rooms OPERATOR LOW NEW ITEM YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-FAS-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

A - AUTHORITY /
39 ELECTRICAL Detectors are not provided in service rooms All Service room shall be provided with fire alarm detectors OPERATOR LOW NEW ITEM YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-FAS-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

T- TECHNICAL R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9001,
40 ELECTRICAL The indicated power Cables types are not indicated correctly. Cables types to be indicated correctly (CU/XLPE/SWA/LSZH, CY/LSZH(Y/G) LOW NEW ITEM NO LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
CORRECTNESS R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9002

A - AUTHORITY /
41 ELECTRICAL Detectors/Emergency light arrangements are not as per FLS requirements Emergency lights shall be provided as per FLS requirements OPERATOR LOW NEW ITEM YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-EML-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

A - AUTHORITY /
Directional exit light shall be provided by coordinating with FLS layout
42 ELECTRICAL Directional exit lights are missing OPERATOR LOW NEW ITEM YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-EML-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

Total m2 required

Electrical panels and naming shall be provided matching with SLD and load T- TECHNICAL
43 ELECTRICAL Electrical panels are missing or the annotations are wrong LOW NEW ITEM NO R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-ELP-1200 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
schedules CORRECTNESS

Exit light is provided without exit door. Revisit.

A - AUTHORITY /
44 ELECTRICAL Exit lights shall be re-arranged OPERATOR LOW STAGE 4 COMMENTS YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-EML-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

Provide exit light in all exit to staircase.

A - AUTHORITY /
45 ELECTRICAL Exit light shall be added OPERATOR LOW STAGE 4 COMMENTS YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-EML-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

Revisit the exit lights in driveway.

A - AUTHORITY /
46 ELECTRICAL Exit lights shall be re-arranged as per FLS OPERATOR LOW STAGE 4 COMMENTS YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-EML-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

Page 13 of 15
Classification: Shared - Confidential
#
 T H E I S L A N D - VALIDATION TRACKER
Level-01 (R1029-03-CKR-DWG-L01-EML-1230)

27)Change in direction provide exit light. Typical comment

A - AUTHORITY /
Directional exit light shall be provided asper FLS
47 ELECTRICAL OPERATOR LOW STAGE 4 COMMENTS YES R1029-03-IBA-DWG-L01-EML-1230 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

Battery room ventilation shall comply with UAE FLS chapter 6 Table 6.2 item
3.
Flame detector and Hydrogen detector shall be provided in battery rooms in
addition to heat detector (refer UAE FLS Chapter 8 Section 5 Table 8.14).
A - AUTHORITY /
48 ELECTRICAL Flame detector and hydrogen detector shall be provided in battery rooms OPERATOR LOW STAGE 4 COMMENTS YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-FAS-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

Detectors are missing in boiler room.

A - AUTHORITY /
49 ELECTRICAL Detectors shall be added in boiler room OPERATOR LOW STAGE 4 COMMENTS YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-FAS-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

Justify requirement of Heat detector and multisensory with of detectors in

electrical room. Provide smoke detector.

A - AUTHORITY /
50 ELECTRICAL Only Smoke detector shall be provided in electrical room OPERATOR LOW STAGE 4 COMMENTS YES R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-FAS-1200 LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
COMPLIANCE

Switches to be provided based on the number of doors. If multiple doors exists, provide
two way switches. Many room entrance are not provided with a switch. Verify and
provide the switches in coordination with architectural drawing. General comment

T- TECHNICAL
51 ELECTRICAL Two way switches are provided for multiple doors LOW STAGE 4 COMMENTS NO R1029-02-IBA-DWG-B02-ELT-1200 LEVEL 1 IMPLEMENTED
CORRECTNESS

Oversize cables are provided for feeders with respect to load. Provide voltage 2!.._ S.9
calculations to justify oversize feeders.

A - AUTHORITY /
R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9001,
52 ELECTRICAL Cables shall be revised asper the current rating OPERATOR LOW STAGE 4 COMMENTS YES LEVEL 3 IMPLEMENTED
R1029-02-CKR-DWG-ALL-ELE-9002
COMPLIANCE

Total m2 required

Page 14 of 15
Classification: Shared - Confidential
#