Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gynecologic Tumor Markers: Tumor Marker Overview
Gynecologic Tumor Markers: Tumor Marker Overview
Normalization of tumor marker values may indicate cure despite radiographic evidence of
persistent disease. In this situation, residual tumor is frequently nonviable. Sometimes, tumor
marker values may rise after effective treatment (due to cell lysis), but the increase may not
portend treatment failure. A consistent increase in a tumor marker value, combined with lack of
clinical improvement, may indicate treatment failure. Residual elevation after definitive treatment
usually indicates persistent disease.
Many new tumor markers have been discovered since the development of monoclonal
antibodies, and most tumor markers are now detected with them. No marker is completely
specific. Therefore, diagnostic immunohistochemistry must be used in conjunction with
morphologic and clinical findings. [2]
Ovarian cancer, uterine cervical cancer, endometrial cancer, and trophoblastic neoplasms are
gynecologic malignancies for which tumor markers are in clinical use. The following are
important gynecologic tumor markers:
Inhibin
Estradiol
Topoisomerase II
Ferritin
Lysophosphatidic acid
L1 (CAM)
Mesothelin [3]
Osteopontin
Interleukin 8 (IL-8)
Cyclin E
OVX1
CA-15-3, CA-19-9
Clinical usefulness of tumor markers
The usefulness of a tumor marker is in its sensitivity and specificity, as well as its influence on
patient management decisions. Because pathologic diagnosis of ovarian cancer is difficult
without laparotomy, tumor markers such as CA-125, in addition to diagnostic imaging, are useful
in preoperative evaluation for ovarian cancer.
No tumor markers with high sensitivity and high specificity for endometrial cancer are known at
present, although CA-125 is often used in clinical practice. However, in a retrospective analysis
(2008-2011) evaluating the utility of preoperative tumor markers in predicting prognostic
parameters in women with pure endometrioid type endometrial cancer who underwent adjuvant
therapy, investigators noted elevated levels of CA-125 was significantly able to predict for the
following [4] :
Extrauterine disease
Positive cytology
In addition, mean levels of CA-15-3 and CA-19-9 were significantly higher in women who
required adjuvant therapy, and levels of CA-19-9 were also predictive of deep myometrial
invasion, cervical involvement. [4] CEA and AFP levels were inadequately able to predict any of
the evaluated poor prognostic parameters and requirements for adjuvant treatment. [4]
SCC antigen is useful in the clinical management of advanced cervical cancer. Beta-hCG and
alpha-fetoprotein have proved to be useful markers for ovarian germ cell tumors. In addition,
beta-hCG serves as an ideal tumor marker for monitoring gestational trophoblastic disease and
has set the standard with which other assays must be compared.
Studies aimed at improving the detection of epithelial ovarian cancers, especially at an early
stage, have identified several new candidates for markers. These include lysophosphatidic acid
(a lipid found in serum and ascitic fluid), mesothelin, HE4, osteopontin, VEGF, IL-8, M-CSF, and
different kallikreins.
Among these potential markers, HE4 has sensitivity similar to CA-125 in detecting late-stage
disease and greater specificity than CA-125 in detecting early ovarian cancer. Validation of HE4
as a diagnostic biomarker for early-stage ovarian cancer is ongoing. New approaches to
facilitate identification of novel markers that may be altered early in disease include high-
throughput techniques using microarray technology and proteomic screening.
To distinguish porocarcinoma from squamous cell carcinoma, cytokeratin 19 can be a helpful
marker. A study by Mahalingam et al found diagnostic sensitivity and specificity to be improved
using a selected panel of immunohistochemical stains that includes cytokeratin 7, cytokeratin
19, and nestin. [5]
Since its discovery in the early 1980s, CA-125 has proven to be a useful first-generation marker
for monitoring ovarian cancer and triaging patients with pelvic masses, despite limitations in
sensitivity and specificity. False-positive results may derive from several conditions, especially
those associated with peritoneal inflammation, such as endometriosis, adenomyosis, pelvic
inflammatory disease, menstruation, uterine fibroids, or benign cysts.
CA-125 values may also be elevated in a number of gynecologic (eg, endometrium, fallopian
tube) and nongynecologic (eg, pancreas, breast, colon, lung) cancers. However, the most
marked elevations (>1500 U/mL) are generally seen with ovarian cancer.
Early detection of ovarian cancer through the measurement of CA-125, usually in combination
with other modalities (eg, bimanual pelvic examination, transvaginal ultrasonography), is the
most promising application of this tumor marker, permitting effective triage of patients for primary
surgery. [7]
An algorithm has been developed that estimates the risk of ovarian cancer based on the level
and trend of CA-125 values. In addition, several trials are ongoing to determine the potential of
CA-125 in combination with other markers to increase earlier detection of occult ovarian cancer.
Detection of recurrence and progression of ovarian cancer
The predominant use of CA-125 is in monitoring the status of patients with known ovarian
cancer. Persistent elevation of serum CA-125 has generally reflected persistence of disease at
second-look surveillance procedures. However, residual disease can be found at laparoscopy or
laparotomy, despite a serum CA-125 value that has returned to within normal limits.
An increase in the serum CA-125 value during or after treatment is a strong predictor of future
disease progression. A rapid decrease in the CA-125 value during initial treatment correlates
with longer progression-free intervals and survival. A serum CA-125 value of less than 15 U/mL
after a standard 6-course treatment generally correlates with longer progression-free intervals,
although it does not predict whether microscopic disease is present. A CA-125 value greater
than 35 U/mL after a standard 6-course chemotherapy treatment predicts the presence of
disease. Disease may also progress when CA-125 values are stable.
The Gynecologic Cancer Intergroup uses the Rustin definition to define a rise in CA-125. If the
CA-125 value becomes normal after surgery, a subsequent level twice the upper limit of normal
is consistent with progression. If the CA-125 value is not normal after surgery, then a
subsequent level twice the patient's nadir value indicates progressive disease.
Kang et al found that the nadir level of CA-125 is an independent prognostic factor in patients
with advanced epithelial ovarian cancer. In a retrospective review of 153 patients, the median
progression-free survival was 32.4 months in patients with nadir CA-125 values of less than or
equal to 10 U/mL versus 16.8 months in those with a nadir of 0-35 U/mL (P = .0001). The
authors note that whether maximal surgical debulking can affect nadir CA-125 levels remains
unclear. [8]
Standardized CA-125 values have the potential to complement or, in some cases, replace
current therapeutic response criteria in a cost-effective way. Rising CA-125 values may precede
clinical detection of recurrent disease by at least 3 months. Given the modest efficacy of salvage
chemotherapy, this information has not yet influenced survival rates. Rising CA-125 levels during
subsequent chemotherapy is associated with progressive disease in at least 90% of cases. CA-
125 may serve as an effective surrogate marker for clinical response in clinical trials of new
drugs.
Currently, ovarian cancer screening is not recommended for women with no risk factors (relative
risk [RR] ≤3). For women at increased risk (RR = 3-6 times), after evaluating risks and benefits,
ovarian cancer screening with CA-125 measurement and/or transvaginal ultrasonography may
be considered, usually by way of a clinical trial. [9]
Women at high risk (RR >6 times), such as those with mutations in ovarian cancer susceptibility
genes, should be screened by a combination of transvaginal ultrasonography and CA-125
measurement. [7, 10] For patients with mutations in BRCA1 or the mismatch repair genes, MLH1,
MSH2, and MSH6, screening should begin around age 30-35 years. For patients with mutations
in BRCA2, ovarian cancer screening should be performed beginning around age 35-40 years.
Early-stage ovarian cancer has an excellent prognosis after definitive therapy. Therefore, early
detection is vital in reducing mortality due to this disease. However, no general screening
program for ovarian cancer has achieved this goal. Several studies have been launched to
identify the best strategy for detecting early stage disease and reducing mortality by using either
CA-125 or ultrasonography as the primary screening test.
High specificity is important in screening strategies for ovarian cancer, because a positive test
result generally requires definitive surgical assessment. Given the relatively low prevalence of
ovarian cancer, a test with 95% specificity would result in 50 surgical procedures for every
ovarian cancer detected.
Einhorn and colleagues screened 5550 women with CA-125 alone and found an unacceptable
rate of 29 surgeries for every cancer detected. [11]
Another major limitation of CA-125 screening is that serum levels are elevated in only
approximately 50% of patients with stage I disease.
Because other conditions can elevate CA-125 values, combination test strategies have been
attempted to improve the predictive value of CA-125.
Jacobs et al were able to show a median survival benefit to the use of a combination of CA-125
levels and ultrasonographic imaging for the detection of ovarian cancer. The investigators
randomized 22,000 postmenopausal women to screening with 3 annual CA-125 measurements
or no screening. [12]
Patients in the screened group who had a CA-125 value higher than 30 U/mL underwent
transvaginal ultrasonography. Twenty-nine women were referred for surgical exploration, and 6
women were diagnosed as having ovarian cancer (3 of whom had stage I disease). The positive
predictive value was 20.7%. Ten additional women in the screening arm developed ovarian
cancer during follow-up. Twenty women in the control arm developed ovarian cancer. The
investigators were able to show a median survival benefit to screening (72.9 mo in the screened
arm vs 41.8 mo in the control group). [12]
In a British cohort study by Funston et al of 50,780 women who underwent CA-125 testing in a
primary care setting, 456 (0.9%) received a diagnosis of ovarian cancer and 1321 (2.6%)
received a diagnosis of nonovarian cancer. Of the women who had a CA-125 level at or above
the conventional cutoff of 35 U/mL, 3.4% of those aged younger than 50 years and 15.2% of
those aged 50 years and older had ovarian cancer. [13]
Elevations in beta-hCG are also found in patients with choriocarcinoma of the uterus, embryonal
carcinomas, polyembryomas, mixed cell tumors, and, less commonly, dysgerminomas.
Beta-hCG and human placental lactogen (hPL) are the most useful markers for trophoblastic
disease and can be localized in syncytiotrophoblasts of partial and complete hydatidiform moles.
The intensity and pattern of immunoreactivity for these antigens differ in partial and complete
moles. Gestational choriocarcinomas demonstrate variable, but positive, staining for beta-hCG
and hPL. The hPL immunostaining differentiates placental-site trophoblastic tumors from
choriocarcinomas. The use of beta-hCG is not limited to trophoblastic diseases; it has been
found in a wide array of nontrophoblastic gynecologic neoplasms.
The following diagnostic criteria are commonly used for malignant gestational trophoblastic
disease:
Ten percent or greater rise in beta-hCG for 3 or more values over at least 2 weeks
Patients who have undergone molar pregnancy evacuation should have weekly beta-hCG
monitoring until normal levels are achieved, then monthly monitoring until 6-12 months of normal
values have been achieved. Approximately 20% of patients undergoing evacuation of molar
pregnancy develop postmolar gestational trophoblastic disease, usually manifesting as failure to
normalize the postevacuation beta-hCG levels. A 10% rise in beta-hCG over 3 or more weekly
titers or a beta-hCG titer of 40,000 mIU/L 4-5 months after uterine evacuation constitutes a
serological diagnosis of postmolar trophoblastic disease.
Alpha-Fetoprotein
Alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) is a normal fetal serum protein synthesized by the liver, yolk sac, and
gastrointestinal tract. It shares sequence homology with albumin. AFP is a major component of
fetal plasma, reaching a peak concentration of 3 mg/mL at 12 weeks of gestation. Following
birth, AFP rapidly clears from the circulation, because its half-life is 3.5 days. AFP concentration
in adult serum is less than 20 ng/mL.
Most endodermal sinus tumors of the ovary express AFP. It is present in the cytoplasm of tumor
cells and in the characteristic hyalin globules observed in the endodermal sinus tumor. AFP is
also expressed by ovarian embryonal cell carcinoma, immature teratomas, and polyembryomas.
AFP and beta-hCG play crucial roles in the management of patients with nonseminomatous
germ cell tumors. AFP or beta-hCG is elevated in 85% of patients with these tumors but in only
20% of patients with stage I disease. Hence, these markers have no role in screening.
In patients with extragonadal disease or metastasis at the time of diagnosis, highly elevated AFP
or beta-hCG values can be used in place of biopsy to establish a diagnosis of nonseminomatous
germ cell tumor.
AFP values in excess of 10,000 ng/mL or beta-hCG levels greater than 50,000 mIU/mL at initial
diagnosis portend a poor prognosis, with a 5-year survival rate of 50%. Similarly staged patients
with lower AFP and beta-hCG levels have a cure rate of greater than 90%.
Following AFP and beta-hCG levels is imperative in monitoring response to treatment in patients
who have nonseminomatous germ cell tumors. Patients with AFP and beta-hCG levels that do
not decline as expected after treatment have a significantly worse prognosis, and changes in
therapy should be considered. Because curative salvage therapy is possible, the tumor markers
are followed every 1-2 months for 1 year after treatment, then quarterly for 1 year, and less
frequently thereafter.
AFP or beta-hCG elevation is frequently the first evidence of germ cell tumor recurrence; a
confirmed elevation should prompt reinstitution of therapy.
In spite of complete clinical response after chemotherapy, almost 50% of patients with stage
III/IV disease have residual tumor. Among patients with persistent elevation of CA-125,
approximately 90-95% have residual tumor. The beta-hCG level is used for monitoring response
to therapy and detecting early relapse. Testing for beta-hCG is an integral part of diagnosis,
management, and response to treatment for gestational trophoblastic disease and in selected
patients with epithelial carcinomas of the ovary.
Combined AFP and beta-hCG testing is an essential adjunct in the evaluation and treatment of
nonseminomatous germ cell tumors, and in monitoring the response to therapy. AFP and beta-
hCG may also be useful in evaluating potential origins of poorly differentiated metastatic cancer.
[14]
Inhibin
Inhibin is a peptide hormone normally produced by ovarian granulosa cells. It inhibits the
secretion of follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) by the anterior pituitary gland. It reaches a peak
of 772 ± 38 U/L in the follicular phase of the menstrual cycle; it usually becomes nondetectable
after menopause. Certain ovarian tumors, mostly mucinous epithelial ovarian carcinomas and
granulosa cell tumors, also produce inhibin, and its serum levels reflect the tumor burden.
Although most commercial laboratories provide assays for inhibin A only, serum levels of inhibin
B seem to be elevated more frequently. Whenever available, assays to detect both isoforms are
recommended. The free alpha subunit can also be measured.
The availability of markers of ovarian stroma, including melan-A and inhibin-alpha, has provided
a means for the positive identification of ovarian stromal tumors, which can manifest myriad
histological appearances.
Estradiol was one of the first markers identified in the serum of patients with granulosa cell
tumors. In general, estradiol is not a sensitive marker for granulosa cell tumors. Approximately
30% of tumors do not produce estradiol, because they lack theca cells, which produce
androstenedione, a necessary precursor for estradiol synthesis. However, monitoring serum
estradiol postoperatively may be useful for detecting recurrence of an estradiol-secreting tumor.
Carcinoembryonic antigen
Most vulvar tumors of sweat gland origin, including malignant tumors, stain positively for
carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA). In most instances, staining for CEA occurs in cells that line
cysts, form glands, or are arranged around a lumen. The reaction for CEA does not differentiate
eccrine from apocrine adnexal tumors.
In patients with vaginal adenosis, surface columnar epithelium and glands may show focal
cytoplasmic membrane staining for CEA. As the columnar cells are gradually replaced by the
process of squamous metaplasia, CEA positivity may be observed in the cytoplasm of
metaplastic cells.
CEA levels are elevated in up to 35% of patients with endometrial cancer. CEA
immunohistochemistry cannot distinguish between benign and malignant glandular proliferations
of the uterine cervix; therefore, CEA staining is of no value in the differential diagnosis of
endocervical and endometrial adenocarcinomas.
Most epithelial neoplasms of the ovary also express CEA. The neoplasms include, with
decreasing intensity and frequency, Brenner, endometrioid, clear cell, and serous tumors.
CEA is frequently present in patients with cancer that has metastasized to the ovary; that is
because the primary cancer is generally mammary or gastrointestinal in origin, and such tumors
frequently contain CEA.
Squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) antigen may be increased in patients with epidermoid
carcinoma of the cervix, benign tumors of epithelial origin, and benign skin disorders. SCC
antigen may be helpful in assessing response to chemotherapy and in determining relapse
when monitoring patients with complete remission.
Müllerian inhibiting substance (MIS) is produced by granulosa cells in developing follicles. It has
emerged as a potential tumor marker for granulosa cell tumors. As with inhibin, MIS is typically
undetectable in postmenopausal women. An elevated MIS value is highly specific for ovarian
granulosa cell tumors; however, this test is not commercially available for clinical use.
Topoisomerase II
Serum carbohydrate antigen 19-9 is elevated in up to 35% of patients with endometrial cancer
and can be used in the follow-up evaluation of patients with mucinous borderline ovarian tumors.
Measurement of serum tumor markers in the follow-up care of these patients may lead to earlier
detection of recurrence in only a very small proportion of patients; the clinical value of earlier
detection of recurrence remains to be established. Carbohydrate antigen is not specific for
ovarian cancer.
Elevated cancer antigen 27-29 levels are associated with cancers of the colon, stomach, kidney,
lung, ovary, pancreas, uterus, and liver. First-trimester pregnancy, endometriosis, ovarian cysts,
benign breast disease, kidney disease, and liver disease are noncancerous conditions that are
also associated with increased cancer antigen 27-29.
Human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT) is a novel biomarker for patients with ovarian
and uterine cancers. The hTERT mRNA level has a significant correlation with CA-125 and with
histologic findings in ovarian cancer. [15]
Serum hTERT mRNA is useful for diagnosing gynecologic cancer and is superior to
conventional tumor markers. Up-regulation of hTERT may play an important role in the
development of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) and cervical cancer; hTERT could be
used as an early diagnostic biomarker for cervical cancer in the future.
Lysophosphatidic acid
Lysophosphatidic acid stimulates cancer cell proliferation, intracellular calcium release, and
tyrosine phosphorylation, including mitogen-activated protein kinase activation.
Lysophosphatidic acid has been shown to be a multifunctional signaling molecule in fibroblasts
and other cells. It has been found in the ascitic fluid of patients with ovarian cancer and is
associated with ovarian cancer cell proliferation. Further studies are needed to determine the
role of this marker.
MIB1-determined tumor growth fraction has been studied as an additional tool to aid decisions
on adjuvant therapy in patients whose ovarian carcinoma is in a very early stage. In one study,
MIB1 predicted tumor recurrences in 84% of the ovarian cancers. [16]
L1 (CAM)
According to Daponte et al, immunoreactivity to L1 (CAM) correlates with stage and grade of
ovarian cancer. Immunoreactivity increases progressively and significantly from benign tumors
to early carcinomas and to advanced stage carcinomas. [17]
5-Protein Signature (Ova1) consists of 5 different proteins (CA-125, B2M, ApoA1, transthyretin,
transferrin). It is found in the blood of ovarian cancer patients.
Human Epididymis Protein 4 (HE4) is detected in the blood of ovarian cancer patients. HE4 can
be used to determine the disease progressions and recurrence.