oi.uchicago.

edu

!"#$$#%&'#()'#*+)&,)%-+)(#,!.#!+*))
/0)%-+)$&11(+)+#*%)#,1)+."/2+
 oi.uchicago.edu

The University of Chicago Center in Paris. Photo by Dan Dry

 oi.uchicago.edu

!"#$$#%&'#()'#*+)&,)%-+)(#,!.#!+*))
/0)%-+)$&11(+)+#*%)#,1)+."/2+
!"#$%&'%#()%*+#),+!#*&+!-%"&--&./*/0
1!,*!#*&+$2%"&+"/,,)+")%)#%)1&-/#*&+%3)$%"!$% %
3!+$%3*1),$%3&0!*+)$%-*+4/*$#*./)$
567892%:;<%!=78>%:??@

!"#$!"%&'
0*"(A-)%',/B#
0*"()-%0!C&B),
()"
3)++*$%5!,3))%

678',(6,1$1&,(1725,(17$/&,9,/,=$7,21೏‡೏180%(5
#()% &,*)+#!-% *+$#*#/#)% &'% #()% /+*1),$*#B% &'% "(*"!4&
&+,&$*2೏‡೏,//,12,6
 oi.uchicago.edu

-8D767E%FG%"FHI7J99%"FHK7F>%+LMDJ7N%:?OOPQQORP
,6%1
,6%1
,661

*+!%,-#!)$(.%/)0$#$1$!2%3+#4(56

‹೓E\7KH8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR$OOULJKWVUHVHUYHG
3XEOLVKHG3ULQWHGLQWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVRI$PHULFD

678',(6,1$1&,(1725,(17$/&,9,/,=$7,21೏‡೏180%(5
7KH2ULHQWDO,QVWLWXWHRIWKH8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR

7!-#!0%8"#$6-0
/HVOLH6FKUDPHU
()"
7KRPDV*8UEDQ
9#$+%$+!%(00#0$()4!%6:%
5HEHFFD&DLQ

7!-#!0%8"#$6-0;%<4=)69.!"5>!)$0

-HVVHQ2·%ULHQDQG)HOLFLD:KLWFRPEDVVLVWHGLQWKHSURGXFWLRQRIWKLVYROXPH

36?!-%/>(5!

56UHFWR5HIHUUHGWRLQILJXUHVDQG%
3KRWRE\WKH3KR7e2SURMHFWRIWKH0LVVLRQGH5DV6KDPUD

@-#)$!"%&'%A4B(15+$6)%C%D1))2%7(.#)!2%A#4+#5()

7KHSDSHUXVHGLQWKLVSXEOLFDWLRQPHHWVWKHPLQLPXPUHTXLUHPHQWVRI$PHUL
FDQ1DWLRQDO6WDQGDUGIRU,QIRUPDWLRQ6HUYLFHV³3HUPDQHQFHRI3DSHUIRU
3ULQWHG/LEUDU\0DWHULDOV$16,=
 oi.uchicago.edu

%#3(+)/0)'/,%+,%*

3UHIDFHA#4+E.!%F-1'$2%A#4+!.%A(G6'!-2%DQG%H!))#0%@(-"!!                                                       YLL

  &DVHWDQDO\VHHQPRUSKqPHVS%3+-#0$#()%*61-($#!-                                                     % O
  7KH&RQMXJDWLRQ3UHIL[HVWKH'DWLYH&DVHDQGWKH(PSDWK\+LHUDUFK\LQ6XPHULDQ3+-#0$6I+!-%J66"0       % OO
  $JHQW6XEMHFW3DWLHQWDQG%HQHILFLDU\*UDPPDWLFDO5ROHVLQ+XUULDQH!))#0%KL%AL%3(>I&!..               % :O%
  'HVFDVHQpODPLWHS%F.6-!)4!%A(.&-()MN(&($                                                            % <@
  eYROXWLRQGHVFDVGDQVOHVpPLWLTXHDUFKDwTXHODFRQWULEXWLRQGHO·pEODwWH@!.#6%F-6)G(-6.#                  % R@
  $RPH&DVH3UREOHPVLQ8JDULWLFK6&!-$%O(9.!'                                                         
  (DUO\&DQDDQLWHDQG2OG$UDPDLF&DVHLQWKH/LJKWRI/DQJXDJH7\SRORJ\K!&!44(%O(00!.&(4+                % O?O
  9HVWLJHVGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOHQWUHOHQRPHWOHSURQRPVXIIL[HHQKpEUHXELEOLTXHH!))#0%@(-"!!             % OOQ
  *HQqVHHWpYROXWLRQGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOLQGRHXURSpHQTXHVWLRQVHWK\SRWKqVHVP!()%O(1"-'                % O:Q
  $OODWLYHLQ,QGR(XURSHDQF6.=!%P60!I+06)                                                             % O<Q
  $QRPDOLHVJUDPPDWLFDOHVj%ҸVRWࡃQ%QL%@#-(-$% ORO
  7KH3UREOHPRIWKH(UJDWLYH&DVHLQ+LWWLWH%3-(#5%A!.4+!-$                                               
  $SURSRVGHO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHOHVWDWLTXHHWOHG\QDPLTXHHQKLWWLWHA#4+!.%A(G6'!-                       
  6XUO·pYROXWLRQGXORFDWLIHQDUPpQLHQA($$+#(0%F-#$G                                                   % O@Q
  eQLJPHVDXWRXUGXGDWLIHWGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOF-()R6#0!%S("!-                                            % O@P
  /HVPDUTXHVFDVXHOOHVGDQVOHVGRFXPHQWVSDOpRVDEHOOLTXHVHWODPRUSKRORJLHGXJpQLWLISOXULHO%
VXGSLFpQLHQT#)4!)$%A(-$G.6::                                                                       
  )RUPDWLRQHWYDULDWLRQVGDQVOHVV\VWqPHVIOH[LRQQHOVGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVHQWUHV\QFKURQLH%
HWGLDFKURQLH@(6.6%@644!$$#                                                                         % :O@
  &DVHWpYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHHQODWLQA#4+E.!%F-1'$                                                    % :QR
  /DFDVXDOLWpODWLQHHQYDULDWLRQGLDVWUDWLTXHGXSDUOHUSRSXODLUHjODGLFWLRQSRpWLTXH3(-6.!%F-'            % :R@
  /HIORWWHPHQWHQWUHOHVFDVHQODWLQWDUGLID!-"%TL%AL%O(?!-.#)5                                           % :@R
  &DVH0DUNLQJRI&RUH$UJXPHQWVDQG$OLJQPHQWLQ/DWH/DWLQA#4+!.(%3!))(>6                           % :P@
  &DVJUDPPDWLFDX[HWFDVORFDX[HQJRWLTXHOHVPRGqOHVFDVXHOVHQJRWLTXH<)"-U%K6100!(1                 % QOR
  5HPDUTXHVVXUOHGDWLIHQLVODQGDLVPRGHUQH@($-#4=%D1!.I(                                            % Q:@
  0pFDQLVPHVGHUpDIIHFWDWLRQGpVLQHQWLHOOHHWKLpUDUFKLHGHVRSSRVLWLRQVFDVXHOOHVHQVODYH3.(#-!%N!%F!1?-!   % Q<R
  3RXUTXRLGHX[JpQLWLIVHWGHX[ORFDWLIVHQUXVVHSRXUFHUWDLQVVXEVWDQWLIV"(WDWDFWXHOGHVSDUDGLJPHVHW%
DVSHFWVGLDFKURQLTXHV7!-51!V%7(=+)6                                                                % QRP
  5HJDUGVVXUOHVFDVGDQVOHVODQJXHVRXUDOLHQQHVP!()%@!--6$W                                            % Q@Q
  6XUO·KLVWRLUHGHVFDVHQWRNKDULHQD!6-5!0MP!()%@#)(1.$                                                  
  $FFRUGVXUOHGpVDFFRUGTXHOTXHVUpIOH[LRQVVXUOHVUDSSRUWVHQWUHPRUSKqPHVFDVXHOVHWDGSRVLWLRQV%
HQpWUXVTXHDL%?()%O!!>0                                                                           % QPP
  6\QWKqVH7KH'\QDPLFVRI&DVH³5HFDSLWXODWLRQDQG)XWXUH'LUHFWLRQVD!)!%D-(55                       % <O@

Y
 oi.uchicago.edu

The University of Chicago Center in Paris. Photo by Dan Dry

 oi.uchicago.edu

2"+0#'+
A#4+E.!%F-1'$2%A#4+!.%A(G6'!-2%H!))#0%@(-"!!

&HWRXYUDJHUHSUpVHQWHOHVDFWHVGXFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOLQWLWXOp´T(-#($#6)02%46)41--!)4!%!$%U?6.1$#6)%"!0%4(0%
"()0%"#?!-0%"6>(#)!0%.#)51#0$#X1!02µTXLV·HVWWHQXGXDXDYULOj3DULVjO·,QVWLWXWFDWKROLTXHGH3DULV UXH
G·$VVDV²3DULV OHVHWDYULOSXLVGDQVOHVORFDX[GHO·8QLYHUVLWpGH&KLFDJRj3DULV UXH7KRPDV0DQQ
²3DULV OHDYULO
/HFROORTXHUpVXOWHG·XQHRUJDQLVDWLRQFRQMRLQWHHWWUDQVDWODQWLTXHHQWUHOHVXQLYHUVLWpVGH&KLFDJR3DULV,HW
3DULV,9DXWUDYHUVGHFROODERUDWLRQVVFLHQWLILTXHVGHORQJXHGDWHTXLOLDLHQW'HQQLV3DUGHH 8QLYHUVLWpGH&KLFDJR 
HW0LFKHO0D]R\HU 8QLYHUVLWpGH3DULV, G·XQHSDUW0LFKHO0D]R\HUHW0LFKqOH)UX\W 8QLYHUVLWpGH3DULV,9 
G·DXWUHSDUW/HVVXEYHQWLRQVDFFRUGpHVSDUO·8QLYHUVLWpGH&KLFDJR 2ULHQWDO,QVWLWXWH SDUO·8QLYHUVLWpGH3DULV
,96RUERQQH ($&HQWUH$OIUHG(UQRXWGHOLQJXLVWLTXHODWLQHO HWOH&156 *'5´/LQJXLVWLTXHODWLQHµJ%
VHFWLRQ6+6 SHUPLUHQWG·DVVXUHUO·HVVHQWLHOGHO·RUJDQLVDWLRQPDWpULHOOHjTXRLV·DMRXWqUHQWXQHVXEYHQWLRQGH
O·8QLYHUVLWpGH/LPRJHVHWXQHDLGHSUpFLHXVHGHO·,QVWLWXWFDWKROLTXHGH3DULV:DLQVLTXHGX&HQWUHGHO·8QLYHUVLWp
GH&KLFDJRj3DULVQTXLPLUHQWGHVVDOOHVjODGLVSRVLWLRQGHVRUJDQLVDWHXUV
3RXUODSDUWLHVFLHQWLILTXH'HQQLV3DUGHH VSpFLDOLVWHG·KpEUHXHWG·RXJDULWLTXH %IXWFKDUJpGHVFRQWDFWVDYHF
OHVVDYDQWVDPpULFDLQVGDQVOHVGRPDLQHVGHOD0pGLWHUUDQpHRULHQWDOHDQFLHQQH ODQJXHVVpPLWLTXHVDNNDGLHQ
pEODwWHRXJDULWLTXHDUDEHFDQDQpHQDUDPpHQKpEUHXDXWUHVODQJXHVVXPpULHQKRXUULWHpODPLWH 0LFKqOH
)UX\W VSpFLDOLVWHGHOLQJXLVWLTXHODWLQH HW0LFKHO0D]R\HU VSpFLDOLVWHGHKLWWLWH UpXQLUHQWGHVVSpFLDOLVWHVGH
ODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV WRNKDULHQKLWWLWHJUHFODWLQODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVLVODQGDLVUXVVHODQJXHVEDOWLTXHV 
GHODQJXHVQRQLQGRHXURSpHQQHVGHO·,WDOLHDQFLHQQH pWUXVTXH GHODQJXHVILQQRRXJULHQQHVDLQVLTXHGHODTXHV
WLRQGHVFDVHQOLQJXLVWLTXHJpQpUDOH3DUWLFLSqUHQWDXFROORTXHSDURUGUHG·LQWHUYHQWLRQ&7RXUDWLHU&:RRGV3
)URQ]DUROL)0DOEUDQ/DEDW5+DZOH\5+DVVHOEDFK'3DUGHH:+HLQULFKV$5RXVVHDX(3LUDUW-+DXGU\)
-RVHSKVRQ00D]R\HU&0HOFKHUW,.ORFN)RQWDQLOOH5/HEUXQ,<DNXERYLFK0)ULW])%DGHU/,VHEDHUW0
)UX\W0&HQQDPR*+DYHUOLQJ&)U\90DUW]ORII33RFFHWWL/$JRVWLQLDQL*9DQ+HHPV'50&DPSEHOO
*-3LQDXOW'3HWLW66DNKQR&%/H)HXYUH3*XHOSD-3HUURW**UDJJ/DSUpVHQWHSXEOLFDWLRQUHJURXSHODSOX
SDUWGHFHVFRPPXQLFDWLRQV
/DILQDOLWpGHFHWUDYDLOFROOHFWLIHVWGHFRQIURQWHUOHVVLWXDWLRQVRIIHUWHVSDUGHVODQJXHVUHOHYDQWGHGLIIpUHQWV
GRPDLQHVOLQJXLVWLTXHVHWHQSDUWLFXOLHUG·H[DPLQHUOHVGLYHUVHVTXHVWLRQVSRVpHVSDUOHVYDULDWLRQVV\QFKUR
QLTXHVOHVFRQFXUUHQFHVHQWUHOHVFDVG·XQHPrPHODQJXHHW³FRQVpTXHQFHGHFHWWHVLWXDWLRQGHYDULDWLRQ³OHXUV
pYROXWLRQVGLDFKURQLTXHV
6LFHWWHYDVWHWKpPDWLTXHDUHWHQXO·DWWHQWLRQGHVRUJDQLVDWHXUVF·HVWTXHOHVFDVFRQVWLWXHQWO·XQGHVGR
PDLQHVHVVHQWLHOVGHODV\QWD[HGHVODQJXHVGDQVOHVODQJXHVRLOVH[LVWHQWLOVVRQWFRQFHUQpVSDUWRXVOHVpQRQ
FpVPrPHOHVSOXVFRXUWV,OVUHSUpVHQWHQWO·DUPDWXUHGHODV\QWD[HGHODSKUDVHVLPSOHHWGHODSURSRVLWLRQOHU{OH
PRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHGHVGpVLQHQFHVQRPLQDOHVpWDQWHVVHQWLHOGDQVO·pODERUDWLRQGHWRXWpQRQFpHWO·XQGHVSLOLHUV
GXV\VWqPHJUDPPDWLFDOG·XQHODQJXHGRQQpH2UOHVFDVVRQWVRXPLVFRPPHWRXVOHVSKpQRPqQHVOLQJXLVWLTXHVj
GHVSKpQRPqQHVGHYDULDWLRQHQV\QFKURQLHHWG·pYROXWLRQHQGLDFKURQLH&HVSKpQRPqQHVSHXYHQWPHWWUHHQMHX
O·HQVHPEOHGXV\VWqPHPRUSKRORJLTXHG·XQHODQJXHHWO·DIIDLEOLVVHPHQWGXPDUTXDJHFDVXHOSHXWPrPHPHQDFHU
WRXWOHV\VWqPHGHODODQJXH/HVpYROXWLRQVVHPDQLIHVWHQWWDQW{WSDUO·DSSDULWLRQGHQRXYHOOHVFDWpJRULHVFDVXHOOHV

O
%4XHVRLHQWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWUHPHUFLpVDXWLWUHGHO·8QLYHUVLWpGH Q
%4XHVRLHQWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWUHPHUFLpVDXWLWUHGX&HQWUHGHO·8QLYHU
3DULV,96RUERQQH2OLYLHU3LFDUG'LUHFWHXUGHO·(FROHGRFWRUDOH,HW VLWpGH&KLFDJRj3DULV3KLOLSSH'HVDQ'LUHFWHXUHW6pEDVWLHQ*UHSSR
OH&RQVHLOVFLHQWLϮTXH 5HVSRQVDEOHDGPLQLVWUDWLI
:
%4XHVRLWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWUHPHUFLpHDXWLWUHGHO·,QVWLWXWFDWKROLTXH
GH 3DULV )ORUHQFH 0DOEUDQ/DEDW 5HVSRQVDEOH GX GpSDUWHPHQW GHV
ODQJXHVDQFLHQQHV

YLL
 oi.uchicago.edu

YLLL% @K8F<38

RXGHQRXYHOOHVIRQFWLRQVSRXUXQPrPHFDVSUpH[LVWDQWWDQW{WDXFRQWUDLUHSDUODUpJUHVVLRQRXODGLVSDULWLRQGH
FDWpJRULHVFDVXHOOHVHWGHVIRQFWLRQVGHFHUWDLQVFDV
/DSUREOpPDWLTXHSUpVHQWpHLFLFRQFHUQHQRQVHXOHPHQWO·pYROXWLRQGHSOXVLHXUVFDVRXELHQGHWRXWXQV\V
WqPHFDVXHOjO·LQWpULHXUG·XQHPrPHODQJXHPDLVDXVVLGHVpWXGHVFRQWUDVWLYHVHWFRPSDUDWLYHVSRUWDQWVXUOHV
GLIIpUHQFHVHWOHVpYROXWLRQVG·XQPrPHFDVGDQVGHVODQJXHVDSSDUHQWpHV&HUWDLQHVpYROXWLRQVWUDQVLWRLUHVWUD
YHUVHQWGHVSKDVHVVXFFHVVLYHVTXLPpULWHQWG·rWUHGpFULWHVXQHODQJXHD\DQWjVDGLVSRVLWLRQSOXVLHXUVPR\HQV
G·H[SUHVVLRQSRXUGpQRWHUGHVUHODWLRQVVSDWLDOHVWHPSRUHOOHVRXQRWLRQQHOOHVSHXWQ·HQUHWHQLUTX·XQVHXOSHQ
GDQWXQHFHUWDLQHSpULRGHSXLVO·DEDQGRQQHUSRXUXQQRXYHDXUHQRXYHOOHPHQWHWUpHQFRGDJHPRUSKRORJLTXH
/·pYROXWLRQGHVV\VWqPHVFDVXHOVFRQFHUQHDXVVLO·RULJLQHOHGHYHQLUHWOHVWDWXWOLQJXLVWLTXHGHVPRUSKqPHV
GpVLQHQWLHOV&HWWHWKpPDWLTXHWRXFKHDXVVLjODFUpDWLRQGHFHUWDLQHVGpVLQHQFHVQRPLQDOHV SDUH[HPSOHSDU
JUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQG·DQFLHQVOH[qPHVHWSOXVSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWG·DQFLHQQHVSDUWLFXOHV jOHXUpYHQWXHOOHH[WHQ
VLRQYHUVG·DXWUHVSRVLWLRQVGHODIOH[LRQHWSDUIRLVPrPHjOHXUJpQpUDOLVDWLRQRXELHQDXFRQWUDLUHjOHXUGLVSDUL
WLRQ/HVFRQGLWLRQVGDQVOHVTXHOOHVDSSDUDLVVHQWOHVSKpQRPqQHVGH´V\QFUpWLVPHGHVFDVµIRQWpJDOHPHQWSDUWLH
LQWpJUDQWHGHVSUpVHQWHVUpIOH[LRQVVXUOHVFDV
1RXVHVSpURQVSDUFHWWHSXEOLFDWLRQHWSDUOHFROORTXHTXLHQIXWODVRXUFHSDUWLFLSHUDXFRXUDQWVFLHQWLILTXH
FRQWHPSRUDLQGHVpWXGHVWUDQVOLQJXLVWLTXHV

0LFKqOH)UX\W0LFKHO0D]R\HU'HQQLV3DUGHH

7ZRDGGLWLRQDOUHPDUNVDUHLQRUGHUIURPWKHRUJDQL]HUUHVSRQVLEOHSUDFWLFDOO\IRUWKH&KLFDJRVLGHRIWKH
SURJUDPDQGVFLHQWLILFDOO\IRUWKH6HPLWLFVLGH)LUVWLWZDVRZLQJWRWKHJHQHURVLW\RIWKH2ULHQWDO,QVWLWXWHDQG
LWV'LUHFWRU*LO6WHLQDVZHOODVWRWKH'LUHFWRURIWKH8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR&HQWHULQ3DULV3KLOLSSH'HVDQDQG
LWV$GPLQLVWUDWLYH'LUHFWRU6pEDVWLHQ*UHSSRWKDWWKLVXQLYHUVLW\ZDVVRZHOOUHSUHVHQWHGDWWKHFRQIHUHQFH DWR
WDORIVHYHQVSHDNHUVLQFOXGLQJRQHDOXPQXV DQGWKDWWKHWKLUGGD\RIWKHFRQIHUHQFHKHOGDWWKH&HQWHUZDVVR
VXFFHVVIXO6HFRQGSODQVKDGEHHQPDGHIRUUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRIWZRRIWKHPRUHLPSRUWDQWRIWKH6HPLWLFODQJXDJH
JURXSV$UDELDQ$UDELFDQG$NNDGLDQEXWXQIRUWXQDWHFLUFXPVWDQFHVUHJUHWWDEO\UHPRYHGWKHVHFRQWULEXWLRQV
IURPWKHPL[

'HQQLV3DUGHH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%<B<NY78%8B%A,K@OZA87[% O

!
"#$%&'%#(#)*$&%&(%+,-./0+&$1

3+-#0$#()%*61-($#!-2%\)#?!-0#$U%";<#]M!)M@-6?!)4!%^<#]MA(-0!#..!%_`

71>>(-'&DVHVDUHQRWPRUSKHPHVWKDWLVPLQLPDOPHDQLQJIXOXQLWVEXWRQO\PRUSKRORJLFDOXQLWVWKDW
LVVHWVRIPLQLPDOVHJPHQWVLQFRPSOHPHQWDU\GLVWULEXWLRQ7KHVHPRUSKRORJLFDOXQLWVDUHXVHGDORQHRU
VHYHUDOWRJHWKHUWRIRUPWKHVLJQLILHURIPRUSKHPHV)RULQVWDQFHXVHGDORQHWKH/DWLQDEODWLYHUHSUHVHQWV
DQLQVWUXPHQWDOPRUSKHPH :!-#-!%5.("#6 DVXEMHFWPRUSKHPH I(-$#&10%:(4$#0 RUDQREMHFWPRUSKHPH (.#X1(%
-!%1$# FRPELQHGZLWKDSUHSRVLWLRQVXFKDV#)LWLVDORFDWLYHGLVFRQWLQXRXVPRUSKHPH (>&1.($%#)%+6-$6 
RUVXFKDV41>LWLVDGLVFRQWLQXRXVPRUSKHPHVLJQLI\LQJ´ZLWKµ 41>%(>#46%4!)(&(> 7KHVRFDOOHGFDVH
V\VWHPLVQRWKLQJEXWLQIOHFWLRQ

3RXUGpFULUHOHVFDVRXFRPPHHOOHVOHGLVHQWSDUIRLVOHV\VWqPHGHVFDVG·XQHODQJXHGRQQpHOHVJUDPPDLUHV
FRPPHQFHQWSDULGHQWLIHUHWpQXPpUHUOHVGLIIpUHQWVFDVGHODODQJXHHQTXHVWLRQ3XLVHOOHVUHFHQVHQWHWFODVVHQW
OHVGLIIpUHQWVHPSORLVTX·LOFRQYLHQWGHUHFRQQDvWUHjFKDFXQG·HQWUHHX[(OOHVV·HIIRUFHQWSDUIRLVG·XQLILHUOH
FODVVHPHQWGHFHVGLIIpUHQWVHPSORLVHWGHSURSRVHUODYDOHXUIRQGDPHQWDOHjODTXHOOHFHVGLIIpUHQWHVYDOHXUV
SDUWLFXOLqUHVSHXYHQWSOXVRXPRLQVrWUHUDWWDFKpHV'HVOLQJXLVWHVFRPPH+MHOPVOHY-DNREVRQRX.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]
RQWHVVD\pGHV\VWpPDWLVHUHWWKpRULVHUFHVWHQWDWLYHVG·XQLILFDWLRQjXQPRPHQWRFHUWHVODQRWLRQGHVLJQH
OLQJXLVWLTXHHWSDUFRQVpTXHQWFHOOHGHVLJQHOLQJXLVWLTXHPLQLPDORXPRUSKqPHDYDLWpWpSURSRVpHPDLVROHV
OLQJXLVWHVDPpULFDLQVQ·DYDLHQWSDVHQFRUHYUDLPHQWGpYHORSSpODSUDWLTXHHWOHVWHFKQLTXHVG·DQDO\VHHQPRU
SKqPHV0DLQWHQDQWTXDQGRQYHXWIDLUHODJUDPPDLUHG·XQHODQJXHLOQ·HVWSOXVSRVVLEOHGHQHSDVFRPPHQFHU
SDUHQIDLUHXQHDXWKHQWLTXHDQDO\VHHQPRUSKqPHVSRXULGHQWLILHUFHTXLIRQFWLRQQHHWFHTXLQHIRQFWLRQQHSDV
FRPPHXQLWpVLJQLILFDWLYHPLQLPDOHHWSDUFRQVpTXHQWFHTX·LOHVWOpJLWLPHGHFRQVLGpUHUFRPPHGHVPRUSKqPHV
GHFHWWHODQJXH
7UDGLWLRQQHOOHPHQWOHVJUDPPDLUHVVDQVWRXMRXUVELHQSUpFLVHUOHVVHJPHQWVFRQFHUQpVDGPHWWHQWXQFHU
WDLQQRPEUHGHYDULDWLRQVGHVIRUPHVQRPLQDOHVTX·HOOHVDSSHOOHQWOHVGLIIpUHQWVFDVGXQRP$LQVLOHODWLQDXUDLW
FDVOHJUHFDQFLHQO·DOOHPDQGOHUXVVHO·DQFLHQIUDQoDLVVLRQVHOLPLWHDX[ODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV
PDLVVLO·RQYDSOXVORLQOHFKLQRLVO·DUDEHOHILQQRLVHWF&HUWHVFHVFDVMRXHQWXQU{OHGDQVODFRQVWUXF
WLRQGXVHQVGHVPHVVDJHVTXLOHVPHWWHQW¬HQ±XYUHLOVVHPEOHQWGRQFFRQWULEXHUjOHXUVLJQLIFDWLRQHWjOHXU
DFFHSWDELOLWp0DLVVRQWLOVSRXUDXWDQWGHVPRUSKqPHVF·HVWjGLUHGHVXQLWpVLJQLILFDWLYHVPLQLPDOHV"(WVL
RXLFKDTXHFDVUHSUpVHQWHWLOXQHWXQVHXOPRUSKqPH"/HVJUDPPDLUHVVHUDLHQWWHQWpHVGHUpSRQGUHSOXVRX
PRLQVSRVLWLYHPHQWVLO·RQVHUDSSHOOHFHTXHODD-(>>(#-!%"!%.;(..!>()"%GH-HDQ)RXUTXHW  HQVHLJQDLW
DYHFWRXWHIRLVXQHFHUWDLQHSUXGHQFH

/·HPSORLOHSOXVFDUDFWpULVWLTXH PDLVQRQOHVHXO FRUUHVSRQGDQWjFKDTXHFDVSHXWrWUHUHSUpVHQWp

68H98N
1RPLQDWLI ೏6XMHWG·XQYHUEH
$FFXVDWLI ೏2EMHWG·XQYHUEHWUDQVLWLI
'DWLI ೏&RPSOpPHQW´G·DWWULEXWLRQµ DSSHOpDXVVLREMHWLQGLUHFWRXVHFRQGDLUH 
*pQLWLI ೏&RPSOpPHQWGpWHUPLQDWLIG·XQVXEVWDQWLI
([DPSOH೏H#!%F-(1%"!0%Sa4=!-0%5#&$%"!)%b#)"!-)%!#)!)%b14+!)
ODIHPPHGXERXODQJHUGRQQHDX[HQIDQWVXQJkWHDX
1RPLQDWLI *pQLWLI 'DWLI $FFXVDWLI

3RXUPHQHUjELHQO·DQDO\VHHQPRUSKqPHVG·XQHODQJXHGRQQpHRQXWLOLVHFHUWHVOHVFRQFHSWVFODVVLTXHV
GHPRUSKqPH XQLWpPLQLPDOHDVVRFLDQWXQVLJQLILpHWXQVLJQLILDQW GHYDULDQWHVRXDOORPRUSKHV IRUPHVGLIIp
UHQWHVVXLYDQWOHVFRQWH[WHVRXOHVVLWXDWLRQVpQRQFLDWLYHVGXVLJQLILDQWG·XQPrPHPRUSKqPH GHPRUSKqPH
jVLJQLILDQWGLVFRQWLQX DVVRFLDWLRQG·XQVHXOVLJQLILpDYHFXQVLJQLILDQWIRUPpGHGHX[RXSOXVLHXUVVHJPHQWV

O
 oi.uchicago.edu

:% 3OK/7*/<B%*,\K<*/8K

IRUPHOVQRQFRQWLJXV G·DPDOJDPH DVVRFLDWLRQG·XQVHXOVLJQLILDQWDYHFOHVLJQLILpGHGHX[RXSOXVLHXUVPRU

SKqPHV HWGHV\QWKqPHV FRPELQDLVRQSOXVRXPRLQVILJpHGHGHX[RXSOXVLHXUVPRUSKqPHV 0DLVLOFRQYLHQW
G·DMRXWHUFRPPHQRXVO·DYRQVPRQWUpjSOXVLHXUVUHSULVHVOHVGHX[FRQFHSWVGHVHJPHQWPRUSKRORJLTXHHW
G·XQLWpPRUSKRORJLTXHGRQWODGpILQLWLRQHVWUHSULVHj+DUULVPDLVGRQWODSRUWpHHVWGLIIpUHQWH1RXVDSSHORQV
HQHIIHWVHJPHQWPRUSKRORJLTXHWRXWH´VXLWHGHSKRQqPHV HQHQWHQGDQWSDUVXLWHGHSKRQqPHVDXVVLELHQXQ
VHXOSKRQqPHTXHSOXVLHXUVSKRQqPHV LQGpSHQGDQWHGHVRQHQYLURQQHPHQWF·HVWjGLUHTXLSHXWFRPPXWHUGDQV
O·HQYLURQQHPHQWRHOOHVHWURXYHHWGRQWO·HQYLURQQHPHQWSHXWpJDOHPHQWFRPPXWHUµ 7RXUDWLHUE/,9 %
FHTXH+DUULVDSSHODLW%>6-I+!>#4%0!5>!)$ +DUULV $LQVLSRXUUHSUHQGUHXQH[HPSOHGH+DUULVOXLPrPH
OHYHUEHDQJODLVI!-4!#?!FRQWLHQWGHX[VHJPHQWVPRUSKRORJLTXHV&DU4!#?!>VLY@HVWLQGpSHQGDQWGHI!->S͇@
FRPPHOHPRQWUHO·H[LVWHQFHGHVYHUEHV
I!-0#0$>S͇·VLVW@I!-c1-!>¶S͇G=͇@
JK%I!-HVWLQGpSHQGDQWGH4!#?!FRPPHOHPRQWUHQWOHVYHUEHV
-!4!#?!%>UL·VLY@"!4!#?!>GL·VLY@
FI+DUULV (WQRXVDSSHORQVXQLWpPRUSKRORJLTXHXQHFODVVHGHVHJPHQWVPRUSKRORJLTXHVHQGLV
WULEXWLRQFRPSOpPHQWDLUH³TXH+DUULVDSSHODLWjWRUWjQRWUHDYLVPRUSKqPH$LQVL4!#?!HW4!IVRQWGHX[
VHJPHQWVPRUSKRORJLTXHVHQGLVWULEXWLRQFRPSOpPHQWDLUHFDUOHQRPTXLFRUUHVSRQGjFHVGHX[GHUQLHUVYHUEHV
HTJ9K%=69%U-!4!#?$#6)%JK%U"!4!#?$#6)2%M689%-!4!I$#6)%JK%"!4!I$#6),OV·DJLWGRQFG·XQHVHXOHHWPrPHXQLWpPRUSKROR
JLTXH+DUULVDSSHODLW>6-I+!>!0OHVGHX[XQLWpVPRUSKRORJLTXHVGHI!-4!#?!2%-!4!#?!2%FL%"!4!#?!0DLVFHOOHVFLQH
FRUUHVSRQGHQWSDVjGHX[XQLWpVVLJQLILFDWLYHVPLQLPDOHVFHTXLHVWQRWUHGpILQLWLRQGXPRUSKqPH&DURQHVW
ELHQREOLJpGHFRQVLGpUHUTXHOHVLJQLILDQWS͇·VLYHVWDVVRFLpDXVLJQLILp´V·DSHUFHYRLUµOHVLJQLILDQWUL·VLYDX
VLJQLILp´UHFHYRLUµHWOHVLJQLILDQWGL·VLYDXVLJQLILp´GpFHYRLUµSXLVTX·LOHVWLPSRVVLEOHGHWURXYHUXQpOpPHQW
GHVLJQLILFDWLRQFRPPXQjFHVWURLVYHUEHVTXLVHUDLWDVVRFLDEOHDXVHJPHQWPRUSKRORJLTXH4!#?!2QYRLWDLQVL
TXHOHVXQLWpVPRUSKRORJLTXHVVRQWGHVFODVVHVG·XQLWpVIRUPHOOHVTXHODODQJXHXWLOLVHVHXOHVRXjSOXVLHXUVSRXU
IRUPHUOHVLJQLILDQWGHVHVPRUSKqPHV
,OVHUDLWIDFLOHGHPRQWUHUTX·HQODWLQSDUH[HPSOHOHVFDVVRQWGHVXQLWpVPRUSKRORJLTXHVFRQVWLWXpHVGHVHJ
PHQWVPRUSKRORJLTXHVHQGLVWULEXWLRQFRPSOpPHQWDLUHOHVTXHOVVHJPHQWVPRUSKRORJLTXHVFRUUHVSRQGHQWDX[
FLQTGpFOLQDLVRQVGHQRVJUDPPDLUHV3DUH[HPSOHO·XQLWpPRUSKRORJLTXHGHQRPLQDWLIFRUUHVSRQGDX[VHJPHQWV
PRUSKRORJLTXHV
M( GHODqUHGpFOLQDLVRQ M10%JK%M1> GHODqPHGpFOLQDLVRQ M#02%M02%̒V GHODqPHGpFOLQDLVRQ M0 GHODqPH%
GpFOLQDLVRQ HWM10 GHODqPHGpFOLQDLVRQ 
O·XQLWpPRUSKRORJLTXHGHJpQLWLIDX[VHJPHQWVPRUSKRORJLTXHV
M(! GHODqUHGpFOLQDLVRQ Ҹ GHODqPHGpFOLQDLVRQ M#0 GHODqPHGpFOLQDLVRQ Ҹ GHODqPHGpFOLQDLVRQ 
JK%ࡃV GHODqPHGpFOLQDLVRQ 
O·XQLWpPRUSKRORJLTXHGHGDWLIHWF5HVWHjVDYRLUVLFHVXQLWpVPRUSKRORJLTXHVVRQWWRXMRXUVjHOOHVVHXOHVOH
VLJQLILDQWG·XQPRUSKqPHHWTXLSOXVHVWWRXMRXUVGXPrPHPRUSKqPH

"23%4564738987::;<3
1RXVDYRQVGpMjPRQWUpTXHOHVFDVGLWVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOVF·HVWjGLUHOHVFDVTXHSUpVHQWHQWOHVQRPVRXOHV
V\QWDJPHVQRPLQDX[TXLVHFRPELQHQWDYHFXQHSUpSRVLWLRQ QRVJUDPPDLUHVGLVHQWOHVFDVUpJLVSDUFHVSUpSR
VLWLRQV IRUPDLHQWDYHFFHVSUpSRVLWLRQVOHVLJQLILDQWGLVFRQWLQXG·XQVHXOPRUSKqPH&HODHVWpYLGHQWORUVTXHOD
SUpSRVLWLRQHVWWRXMRXUVVXLYLHGXPrPHFDVFRPPHHQODWLQ41>dDEODWLI GHVLJQLILp´DYHFµ RXI!-«DFFXVD
WLI GHVLJQLILp´jWUDYHUVµ HQDOOHPDQG1>«DFFXVDWLI GHVLJQLILp´DXWRXUµ FRPPHWRXWHVOHVSUpSRVLWLRQV
GXJUHFPRGHUQHHWO·DFFXVDWLIRXWRXWHVOHVSUpSRVLWLRQVDUDEHVHWOHJpQLWLI.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]O·DIRUWELHQYXTXDQG
jSURSRVGXV\QWDJPHODWLQIRUPpG·XQHSUpSRVLWLRQHWG·XQPRWjO·DFFXVDWXI!]$-(%1-&!>LOHVWLPDLWTXH

ODELSDUWLWRQFRUUHFWHHVW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%<B<NY78%8B%A,K@OZA87[% Q

,OV·HQVXLW TXHODIRUPHFDVXHOOHQHVHODLVVHSDVGpJDJHUGXWRXUSUpSRVLWLRQQHOLOQ·HVWGRQFSRLQWSHUPLV
GHWUDLWHUFHWWHIRUPHFDVXHOOHVXUOHPrPHSODQTXHODIRUPHFDVXHOOHOLEUHRXUpJLHGpSHQGDQWGXYHUEH
VDQVO·LQWHUPpGLDLUHG·XQHSUpSRVLWLRQ TXHODSUpSRVLWLRQQ·HVWSDVOH-!5!)0GHODIRUPHFDVXHOOHPDLV
TX·HOOHHVWXQVRXVPRUSKqPHELHQTXHSULQFLSDOGXPRUSKqPHFRPSRVp,, FRQVLVWDQWHQSUpSRVLWLRQ
GpVLQHQFHFDVXHOOH  .XU\‫ן‬RZLF]² 

1RXVDYRQVPRQWUpTXHPDOJUpOHVDSSDUHQFHVF·HVWH[DFWHPHQWODPrPHFKRVHTXDQGOHVSUpSRVLWLRQVVRQW
GLWHVPL[WHVSDUOHVJUDPPDLUHVDOOHPDQGHVRXODWLQHVF·HVWjGLUHTXDQGOHVSUpSRVLWLRQVSHXYHQWVHFRQVWUXLUH
DYHFGHX[FDVGLIIpUHQWV2QDXUDLWG·DSUqVOHVJUDPPDLUHVOHFKRL[HQWUHGHX[FDVFKRL[HQWUHO·DFFXVDWLIHW
O·DEODWLIHQODWLQRXHQWUHO·DFFXVDWLIHWODGDWLIHQDOOHPDQGDSUqVODSUpSRVLWLRQ#)´GDQVµ&HUWHVRQGLWSDU
H[HPSOHHQODWLQHWHQDOOHPDQG
% #$% #)% 1-&!>%´LOYDGDQVODYLOOHµ
% #%M%$% #)% 1-&M!>%
 DOOHULOGDQVYLOOHDFFXVDWLI
% !-%5!+M$% #)% "M#!%7$("$%´LOYDGDQVODYLOOHµ
 LODOOHU3GDQVODDFFXVDWLIYLOOH
JK
% .(&6-($% #)% 1-&!%´LOWUDYDLOOHGDQVODYLOOHµ
% .(&6-(M$% #)% 1-&M!
 WUDYDLOOHULOGDQVYLOOHDEODWLI
% !-%(-&!#$M!$% #)%"M!-%7$("$%´LOWUDYDLOOHGDQVODYLOOHµ
 LOWUDYDLOOHU3GDQVODGDWLIYLOOH
0DLVOHORFXWHXUQ·DDXFXQFKRL[$SUqVOHYHUEH#-! 5!+!)´DOOHUµ LOQHSHXWSDVPHWWUHDXWUHFKRVHTXH#)DFFX
VDWLIHWDSUqVOHYHUEH.(&6-(-! (-&!#$!)´WUDYDLOOHUµ LOHVWREOLJpGHPHWWUH#)DEODWLI GDWLI ,OOXLHVWLPSRVVLEOH
GHPHWWUH#)DFFXVDWLI/DSUpSRVLWLRQHWOHFDVUHSUpVHQWHQWGRQFGDQVFHVGLIIpUHQWVpQRQFpVXQPRUSKqPHj
VLJQLILDQWGLVFRQWLQX0DLVIDXWLODGPHWWUHTX·LO\DDORUVGDQVFKDFXQHGHFHVODQJXHVGHX[PRUSKqPHVjVLJQL
ILDQWGLVFRQWLQXSDUWLHOOHPHQWKRPRQ\PHVTXLPHWWHQWHQ±XYUHOHPrPHVHJPHQWPRUSKRORJLTXH#)",OHVWFODLU
TXHQRQFDUHQWUHOHVGHX[pYHQWXHOVPRUSKqPHVjVLJQLILDQWGLVFRQWLQX#)«DFFXVDWLIHW#)«DEODWLI RX#)V%
GDWLIHQDOOHPDQG LO\DGLVWULEXWLRQFRPSOpPHQWDLUH/HVJUDPPDLUHVVFRODLUHVOHVLJQDOHQWH[SUHVVVpPHQWDX
FKDSLWUHGHFHTX·HOOHVDSSHOOHQWOHVTXHVWLRQVGHOLHX(OOHVRSSRVHQWQHWWHPHQWODTXHVWLRQGHOLHX1&# DOOHPDQG
96´R"µ SRXUOHOLHXRO·RQHVWjODTXHVWLRQGHOLHXX16 DOOHPDQG96+#)´R"µ SRXUOHOLHXRO·RQYD&HVRQW
HQHIIHWOHVYHUEHVTXLVLJQLILHQWQRQSDVVHXOHPHQWXQGpSODFHPHQWPDLVXQFKDQJHPHQWGHOLHXTXLH[LJHQW
W#)«DFFXVDWLI6DQVFHWWHSDUWLFXODULWpVpPDQWLTXHGXYHUEHLQWURGXFWHXURQQHSHXWPHWWUHTXH#)«DEODWLI RX
HQDOOHPDQG#)«GDWLI &HODYHXWGLUHTXHOHVLJQLILDQW#)«DFFXVDWLIQ·HVWTX·XQDOORPRUSKHGH#)«DEODWLI
2QSRVWXOHUDGRQFXQVHXOHWPrPHPRUSKqPHGHVLJQLILp´GDQVµHWGHVLJQLILDQW#)«DEODWLI HQDOOHPDQG#)V%
GDWLI (WO·RQGLUDTXH#)«DFFXVDWLIQ·HVWTX·XQHYDULDQWHFRPELQDWRLUHGHFHPRUSKqPHGHVLJQLILDQW#)V%
DEODWLI HQDOOHPDQG#)«GDWLI &HWWHGHVFULSWLRQUHMRLQWXQHDXWUHLQWXLWLRQIRUWMXVWHGH.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]TXLj
SURSRVGHFHVWRXUVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOVGLIIpUHQWVGHODTXHVWLRQ1&# DOO96 HWGHODTXHVWLRQX16 DOO96+#) GLVDLW

'DQVFHVH[HPSOHVODYDOHXUGHODSUpSRVLWLRQUHVWHWRXMRXUVODPrPHPDLVOHYHUEHGHPRXYHPHQW\DMRXWH
ODQXDQFHDGGLWLRQQHOOHGX&1$GHVRUWHTXHSH[GDQVOHODWLQ#)%1-&!>%#-!%>J%KFL7%#)%1-&!RODGpVLQHQFH
GHO·DEODWLIGpSHQGGH#)VXELWO·DVVLPLODWLRQVpPDQWLTXHGHODSDUWGXYHUEHGHPRXYHPHQWG·R#-!%#)%1-&!%
X%#-!%#)%1-&!> .XU\‫ן‬RZLF] 

2QUHSURFKHUDWRXWHIRLVjFHWWHIRUPXODWLRQGHVFKRVHVGHUpLQWURGXLUHVXEUHSWLFHPHQWOHFRQFHSWWUDGLWLRQQHOGH
FDVGDQVODGHVFULSWLRQGXFDVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOSRXUWDQWUHFRQQXFRPPHGLIIpUHQWGXFDVVHXOHOOHDGPHWHQHIIHW
XQHFHUWDLQHYDOHXUjO·DFFXVDWLIRXjODSUpSRVLWLRQGXWRXU#)%1-&!>SDUODQWG·XQH´QXDQFHDGGLWLRQQHOOHGH&1$µ
/HVFRQFHSWVGHO·DQDO\VHHQPRUSKqPHVSHUPHWWHQWXQHSUpVHQWDWLRQGHVFKRVHVSOXVWUDQFKpHHWSOXVFODLUHLOV
IRQWGH#)%1-&!>XQHYDULDQWH VDQVDMRXWGHVLJQLILFDWLRQ GH#)%1-&!%GDQVOHFRQWH[WHGHYHUEHVGHFKDQJHPHQWGH
OLHXFRPPH#-!VLELHQTXH%#)%1-&!>DSUqV#-!DSSRUWHjO·pQRQFpRLOVHWURXYHOHPrPHVHQVTXH#)%1-&!SXLVTXH
>J9%9EHK6IMJ9%#)%1-&!>%JK%#)%1-&!%FRQWLHQQHQWOHPrPHOH[qPH1-&´YLOOHµHWOHPrPHPRUSKqPH´GDQVµGRQW
OHVLJQLILDQWHVWGDQVXQFDV#)«DFFXVDWLIHWGDQVO·DXWUH#)«DEODWLI&HQ·HVWGRQFSDV´ODYDOHXUGHODSUp
SRVLWLRQµPDLVOHVLJQLILpGXPRUSKqPHGHVLJQLILDQW#)«DFFXVDWLITXL´UHVWHWRXMRXUVODPrPHµ(WO·DFFXVDWLI
Q·DSSRUWHSDUFRQVpTXHQWDXFXQH´QXDQFHDGGLWLRQQHOOHGH&1$µRXG·DXWUHFKRVH0DLVO·LQWpULHXUGHODYLOOHF·HVW
 oi.uchicago.edu

<% 3OK/7*/<B%*,\K<*/8K

jGLUHOH#)%1-&!HVWOHVHFRQGDFWDQWGXYHUEHGXGpSODFHPHQW#-!HWGRQFOHWHUPHGHFHGpSODFHPHQW&·HVWOjOD
YpULWDEOHFDXVHHWQRQO·DFFXVDWLITXLIDLWTXH´GDQVODYLOOHµHVWXQEXWGDQVOHV\QWDJPHYHUEDO 69 #-!%#)%1-&!>

.57=<>?;%@;%<298:%!"#$%!&'%A2<<;?2:@%()!*+'&',B
,OQHIDXWSDVFURLUHVRXVSUpWH[WHTX·jF{WpGH/)%1-&!%(>&1.($%´LOVHSURPqQHGDQVODYLOOHµ FIO·H[HPSOH
VFRODLUH<>&1.($%#)%+6-$6´LOVHSURPqQHGDQVVRQMDUGLQµ RQSRXUUDLWWURXYHU/)%1-&!>%(>&1.($TXHODJUDPPDLUH
VWUXFWXUDOHGH5LFKDUG2·%ULHQOWUDGXLWIRUWMXVWHPHQWSDU
´+HZDONVWRZDUGWKHFLW\µ
DSUqVDYRLUSURSRVpQRQPRLQVMXVWHPHQWODWUDGXFWLRQ
´+HZDONVLQWKHFLW\µ
=FL7%/)%1-&!%(>&1.($TXHO·DFFXVDWLIVHXOSHXWSDUIRLVFRPPXWHUDYHFO·DEODWLIVHXOHWVHPEOHUrWUHOHVLJQLILDQW
G·XQPRUSKqPHGLVRQVGH´EXWµ&DUVLDXVHXOQLYHDXV\QWDJPDWLTXHGHO·RUGUHVpTXHQWLHOGHVPRWVLOVHPEOH
\DYRLUXQHFRPPXWDWLRQTXLSRXUUDLWFHUWHVrWUHLQWHUSUpWpHFRPPHODFRPPXWDWLRQG·XQDFFXVDWLIDYHFXQ
DEODWLIPDLVDXVVLGXUHVWHFRPPHODFRPPXWDWLRQG·XQPRUSKqPHGLVFRQWLQX#)«DEODWLIDYHFXQPRUSKqPH
pJDOHPHQWGLVFRQWLQX#)«DFFXVDWLILOQ·\DHQIDLWDXSRLQWGHYXHV\QWD[LTXHDXFXQHFRPPXWDWLRQ/HV\Q
K6IMJ%#)%1-&!%UHPSOLWHQHIIHWODIRQFWLRQGHFLUFRQVWDQWF·HVWjGLUHGHFRQVWLWXDQWLPPpGLDWQRQYHUEDOG·XQ69
HQGRFHQWULTXH RXFHTXLUHYLHQWDXPrPHG·H[SDQVLRQG·XQ69jO·LQWpULHXUG·XQDXWUH69 OHYHUEHLQWUDQVLWLI
(>&1.(-!FRPPHWRXVOHVYHUEHVGLWVWUDGLWLRQQHOOHPHQWLQWUDQVLWLIVDSSDUWHQDQWHIIHFWLYHPHQWDXSDUDGLJPH
QRQSDVGH9PDLVGH693DUFRQWUHOHV\QWDJPH#)%1-&!>HVWXQFRPSOpPHQWGHYHUEHELHQTXHQRQDSSHOpSDU
ODYDOHQFHGXYHUEH(>&1.(-!TXLHVWPRQRYDOHQWOHYHUEHpWDQWDORUVHPSOR\pWUDQVLWLYHPHQW8QHWHOOHWUDQVL
WLYDWLRQDMRXWHDXVpPqPHGXYHUEH(>&1.(-!O·DUFKLVpPqPHGHVYHUEHVGRQWLODSULVODFRQVWUXFWLRQjVDYRLU#-!2%
HWOXLGRQQHDLQVLO·HIIHWGHVHQVGH´DOOHUHQVHSURPHQDQWYHUVODYLOOHµ3XLVTXHOHV\QWDJPHFKDQJHGHIRQFWLRQ
V\QWD[LTXHRQQHSHXWSDVGLUHTXHOHVGHX[WRXUVSUpSRVLWLRQHOVDSSDUWLHQQHQWDXPrPHSDUDGLJPHFHTXH
PRQWUHFODLUHPHQWODILJXUH,OQ·\DGRQFSDVVLPSOHFRPPXWDWLRQHQWUH#)%1-&!%JK%#)%1-&!>SXLVTX·LOQ·\DSDV
FKRL[jO·LQWpULHXUG·XQPrPHSDUDGLJPH

)LJXUH&LUFRQVWDQWHWFRPSOpPHQWGH9HUEH

O
%2·%ULHQ,OQHIDXGUDLWSDVFURLUHTX·LOV·DJLWOjG·XQVROp
FLVPHGXODWLQFKUpWLHQFDURQWURXYHFKH]3ODXWXV <>I+#$-'6) 
e16%(>&1.(0[MXVWHPHQWWUDGXLWSDU´2YDVWX"Y6LFHWRXUQ·pWDLW
SDVDWWHVWpLOIDXGUDLWELHQHQIDLUHO·K\SRWKqVHSRXUH[SOLTXHUTXH
(>&1.(-!%´9J%=7FMJHJ7YDLWSXGRQQHUXQHGHVYDULDQWHVGXOH[qPH
IUDQoDLV(..!- jSDUWLUGH(>Z&1@·OčUHDYHFV\QFRSHGHODV\OODEHSUp
WRQLTXHHQYR\HOOHIHUPpH 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%<B<NY78%8B%A,K@OZA87[% R

2QSRXUUDLWSHXWrWUHSURSRVHUXQHDXWUHDQDO\VHHWGLUHTX·DXPRUSKqPHORFDOLVDQW#)«DEODWLIV·DMRXWHOH
PRUSKqPHGHFRPSOpPHQWGHYHUEHGRQWOHVLJQLILDQWOHSOXVXVXHOHVWO·DFFXVDWLI&·HVWGHFHWWHIDoRQTXH3DXO
9DOHQWLQDYRXOXH[SOLTXHUHQDOOHPDQGO·DFFXVDWLIGHODTXHVWLRQGHOLHX96+#)5DSSURFKDQWOHVGHX[H[HPSOHV
% 8-% :a..M$% 1)$!-% "M!)% *#04+%
 OXLWRPEHU3VRXVOHDFFXVDWLIWDEOH´,OWRPEHVRXVODWDEOHµ
% 8-% $-a5M$% "M!)% *#04+
 OXLSRUWHU3OHDFFXVDWLIWDEOH´,OSRUWHODWDEOHµ
LOIDLWODUHPDUTXHVXLYDQWH

,OQ·HVWjWRXWOHPRLQVSDVFRQWUDLUHjO·LQWXLWLRQGHGLUHTXH:(..!)HVWWUDQVLWLISDUUDSSRUWj1)$!-%"M%*#04+%
GHODPrPHPDQLqUHTXH$-(5!)O·HVWSDUUDSSRUWj"M%*#04+OHJURXSHSUpSRVLWLRQQHOpYRTXHO·´REMHWµDIIHFWp
SDUODFKXWHHWOHJURXSHQRPLQDOO·´REMHWµDIIHFWpSDUOHWUDQVSRUW 9DOHQWLQ 

,OUHSUpVHQWHDORUVOHVVLJQLILpVGHVGHX[V\QWDJPHVYHUEDX[SDUOHVVFKpPDVGHODILJXUHRPDQLIHVWHPHQW
OHVLJQLILp´WUDQVLWLYLWpµFRUUHVSRQGDXVLJQLILDQWDFFXVDWLI1RXVDYRQVREMHFWpjFHWWHGHVFULSWLRQIRUWDVWX
FLHXVHTXHFHQ·HVWSDVODWUDQVLWLYLWpRXODWUDQVLWLYDWLRQTXLHQWUDvQHO·DSSDULWLRQGXVLJQLILDQW#)«DFFXVDWLI
SXLVTXHOHFRPSOpPHQWGHYHUEHVELYDOHQWV

)LJXUH$FFXVDWLI ´&RPSOpPHQWGHYHUEHµ

FRPPH´KDELWHUµRX´UHVWHUµQHSUpVHQWHQLHQDOOHPDQGQLHQODWLQOHVLJQLILDQW#)«DFFXVDWLI
% 8-% 96+)M$% #)% "M!-% 7$("$
 OXLKDELWHU3GDQVOHGDWLIYLOOH´LOKDELWHGDQVODYLOOHµ
% O(&#$(M$% #)% 1-&M!
 KDELWHUOXLGDQVYLOOHDEODWLI´LOKDELWHGDQVODYLOOHµ
% 8-% &.!#&M$% #)% "M!-% 7$("$
 OXLUHVWHU3GDQVOHGDWLIYLOOH´,OUHVWHGDQVODYLOOHµ
% A()!M$% #)% 1-&M!
 UHVWHUOXLGDQVYLOOHDEODWLI´,OUHVWHGDQVODYLOOHµ FI7RXUDWLHU 
2QSHXWFRQFOXUHTXHOHFDVTXLV·DMRXWHjXQHSUpSRVLWLRQQ·HVWMDPDLVOHVLJQLILDQWG·XQPRUSKqPH&HQ·HVWTX·XQ
GHVpOpPHQWVGXVLJQLILDQWGLVFRQWLQXG·XQPRUSKqPH

&:%C5;D%2:D8;:
6LO·RQVHWRXUQHPDLQWHQDQWGXF{WpGXJUHFDQFLHQQRXVDYRQVPRQWUpTXHODVLWXDWLRQGHVFDVSUpSRVLWLRQ
QHOVTXLHVWSOXVFRPSOH[HTXHGDQVG·DXWUHVODQJXHVHVWILQDOHPHQWODPrPHOHFDVQ·DMDPDLVFRQWUDLUHPHQW
jFHTXHVRXKDLWHUDLHQWOHVJUDPPDLUHVXQVHQVSURSUH&·HVWXQpOpPHQWGXVLJQLILDQWGLVFRQWLQXTXHIRUPHQW
ODSUpSRVLWLRQHWOHFDVTX·HOOHHVWFHQVpHUpJLU,O\DGHVSUpSRVLWLRQVTXLQHVHFRPELQHQWTX·DYHFXQVHXOFDV

/HVSUpSRVLWLRQVරဎࠗໆ´DXOLHXGHµර›཭´jSDUWLUGHµ์৓´KRUVGHµ›‫´ཬݰ‬GHYDQWµVHFRPELQHQWWRXMRXUVDYHF
OHJpQLWLIOHVSUpSRVLWLRQVරဎඦ´HQUHPRQWDQWGHµ͘໑ߥ´YHUVµHWරࢆ‫ݵ‬ໆ´DXWRXUµWRXMRXUVO·DFFXVDWLIHWOHV
SUpSRVLWLRQV์ဎ´GDQVµۭ࿱ဎ´DYHFµWRXMRXUVDYHFOHGDWLI 7RXUDWLHUD 

HWIRUPHQWGRQFDYHFFHFDVOHVLJQILDQWGLVFRQWLQXG·XQPRUSKqPH,O\DDXVVLOHVWRXUVDYHFGHVSUpSRVLWLRQV
FRPPH›Ǔ‫ݰ‬ඥ´DXSUqVµ࿽›ཬ´VRXVµRX์›໅¬´VXUµTXLjODTXHVWLRQ›‫່ڗ‬GXOLHXRO·RQYDUHPSODFHQWOHGDWLISDUXQ
DFFXVDWLIHWFRUUHVSRQGHQWGRQFFRPPHHQODWLQRXHQDOOHPDQGjXQHYDULDQWHDYHFDFFXVDWLIGDQVOHFRQWH[WH
G·XQYHUEHGHFKDQJHPHQWGHOLHXGHPRUSKqPHVjVLJQLILDQWGLVFRQWLQXIRUPpG·XQHSUpSRVLWLRQHWG·XQGDWLI
0DLVOHVFKRVHVVHFRPSOLTXHQWDYHFFHVSUpSRVLWLRQVGXIDLWTX·HOOHVSHXYHQWDXVVLVHFRPELQHUDYHFXQQRPDX
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3OK/7*/<B%*,\K<*/8K

JpQLWLI0DLVO·DSSDULWLRQGHFHJpQLWLIQ·DSDVOHVPrPHVFRQVpTXHQFHVSRXUFKDFXQHGHVFHVWURLVSUpSRVLWLRQV
$YHF์›໅LOV·DJLWG·XQHYDULDQWHVXSSOpPHQWDLUH TXLHVWSRpWLTXH GH์›໅«GDWLIWDQGLVTX·DYHF›Ǔ‫ݰ‬ඥHW࿽›ཬLO
V·DJLWG·XQPRUSKqPHjVLJQLILDQWGLVFRQWLQXVXSSOpPHQWDLUHTXLFRUUHVSRQGUHVSHFWLYHPHQWDXVLJQLILp´G·DXSUqV
GHµHW´GHVRXVµTXHOHVJUDPPDLUHVVFRODLUHVUDWWDFKHQWKDELWXHOOHPHQWjODTXHVWLRQ›ཬ۟͘ဎGXOLHXG·RO·RQ
YLHQW0DOJUpODSUR[LPLWpVpPDQWLTXHLOQHV·DJLWSDVGHVPrPHVPRUSKqPHVTXH›Ǔ‫ݰ‬ඥ«GDWLIHW࿽›ཬ«
GDWLIWRXWFRPPHHQIUDQoDLV";(1I-E0%JK%"!%0610%QHVRQWSDVODPrPHFKRVHTXHOHVPRUSKqPHV(1I-E0%JK%0610L%
$XWUHVFDVGHILJXUHODSUpSRVLWLRQࢆࠗ͘ඥGRQQHOLHXjGHX[DOORPRUSKHVGXPrPHPRUSKqPHGHVLJQLILp
´SDUPLµDYHFOHGDWLIHWOHJpQLWLIPDLVjXQVHFRQGPRUSKqPHSDUWLHOOHPHQWKRPRQ\PHGHVLJQLILp´DSUqVµDYHF
O·DFFXVDWLI3DUFRQWUHODSUpSRVLWLRQ›͘‫ݰ‬ໆHQWUHGDQVODFRQVWLWXWLRQG·XQVHXOHWPrPHPRUSKqPHGHVLJQLILp
´DXWRXUµjWURLVDOORPRUSKHV´DSSOLTXpDXGRPDLQHVSDWLDOFHVLJQLILpDODYDOHXUORFDOHGH¶DXWRXU· ¶DXWRXUGH
7URLHDX[HQYLURQVGH7URLH· DSSOLTXpDXGRPDLQHWHPSRUHOODYDOHXUG·XQHDSSUR[LPDWLRQWHPSRUHOOH ¶YHUV
OHPLOLHXGHODQXLW·›͘‫ۭ็ࢆ໇ݰ‬Ǔߥဎ࿲໵ࠗǓߥ HWDSSOLTXpDXGRPDLQHQRWLRQQHOODYDOHXUGH¶DXVXMHWGHjSURSRV
GH·µ 7RXUDWLHU² (WODSURVHGHODODQJXHFODVVLTXHDODSDUWLFXODULWpGHOLPLWHUFHWWHYDULDWLRQHQSUL
YLOpJLDQWO·DOORPRUSKH›͘‫«໇ݰ‬JpQLWLISRXUODYDOHXUQRWLRQQHOOHFHTXLQ·HVWSDVOHFDVGHODSRpVLHKRPpULTXH
SDUH[HPSOH
3RXUWHUPLQHUDYHFOHJUHFRQSHXWGLUHjODIRLVTXHOHVGLIIpUHQFHVGHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHVWURLVFDVSUpSR
VLWLRQQHOVGDWLIDFFXVDWLIHWJpQLWLIHPSrFKHQWGHWURXYHUXQVLJQLILpXQLTXHDXTXHOUDWWDFKHUFKDFXQGHOHXUV
HPSORLVHWTXHOHXUVUHVVHPEODQFHVGHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWHPSrFKHQWGHWURXYHUSRXUFKDFXQGHFHVFDVXQVLJQLILp
SURSUHTXLVRLWGLIIpUHQWGHFHOXLGHVGHX[DXWUHVFDV(QJUHFFRPPHGDQVOHVDXWUHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV
OHVFDVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOVQHVDXUDLHQWGRQFrWUHGHVPRUSKqPHV&HQHVRQWTXHGHVVHJPHQWVPRUSKRORJLTXHVTXL
V·XQLVVHQWjFHTXHOHVJUDPPDLUHVDSSHOOHQWGHVSUpSRVLWLRQVSRXUIRUPHUOHVLJQILDQWGLVFRQWLQXG·XQPRUSKqPH

"23%:7:%4564738987::;<3%2<9;5:2:9%2E;D%D23%4564738987::;<3
6L.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]DHXUDLVRQG·H[FOXUHOHVFDVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOVGHFHTX·LODSSHODLWjODVXLWHG·XQHFHUWDLQH
WUDGLWLRQOHVV\VWqPHGHVFDVLOIDXWpJDOHPHQWHQH[FOXUHWRXVOHVFDVVHXOVTXLQHVRQWTXHGHVYDULDQWHVG·XQ
PRUSKqPHDYHFFDVSUpSRVLWLRQQHO-HDQ3HUURWHVWOHSUHPLHUjQRWUHFRQQDLVVDQFHjO·DYRLUGLW

/·DFFXVDWLIFRUUHVSRQGDQWDXWHUPHGXPRXYHPHQWQHIRQFWLRQQHSDVFRPPHO·DFFXVDWLIGHO·REMHWSDUFH
TXHODQRUPHFRPSRUWHO·HPSORLG·XQHSUpSRVLWLRQWHOOHTXH%#)%FL%("O·DEVHQFHGHSUpSRVLWLRQREpLWjXQ
FHUWDLQFRQGLWLRQQHPHQWHOOHHVWOLpHVRLWjGHVH[SUHVVLRQVGHFDUDFWqUHIRUPXODLUHILJp >(.(>%4-14!>%#-!2%
#):#$#(0%#-!HWF VRLWjODGpVLJQDWLRQGHFHUWDLQHVUpDOLWpVJpRJUDSKLTXHV QRPVGHORFDOLWpVRXGHWHUULWRLUHV
UHVWUHLQWV &HV´H[FHSWLRQVµQHVRQWTXHGHVYDULDQWHVJUDYLWDQWDXWRXUGHODQRUPHHWOLpHVWRXMRXUVjGHV
FRQGLWLRQVGpILQLVVDEOHV/HVPrPHVREVHUYDWLRQVYDXGUDLHQWSRXUO·DEODWLIGHSRLQWGHGpSDUWRXGHORFDOL
VDWLRQSDUH[HPSOHHPSOR\pVVDQVSUpSRVLWLRQ 3HUURW 

&HFLUHMRLQWPDLVGHIDoRQEHDXFRXSSOXVVDWLVIDLVDQWHQRXVVHPEOHWLODXSRLQWGHYXHWKpRULTXHO·DQDO\VH
GH.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]TXLGLVWLQJXDLWSRXUFKDTXHFDVXQHIRQFWLRQSULPDLUHHWGHVIRQFWLRQVVHFRQGDLUHVHWUDQJHDLW
SDUPLOHVIRQFWLRQVVHFRQGDLUHVWRXVOHVHPSORLVTXH-HDQ3HUURWGLW´FRQGLWLRQQpVµRX´OLpVjGHVFRQGLWLRQV
GpILQLVVDEOHVµ

3UHQRQVGLVDLW.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]O·H[HPSOHGHO·DFFXVDWLI LQGRHXURSpHQ $XSUqVG!HVYHUEHVWUDQVLWLIVRLO

GpVLJQHO·REMHWH[WHUQHRXLQWHUQH (::!4$1>%FL%!::!4$1> VDGpVLQHQFHHVWVDQVDXFXQHYDOHXUVpPDQWLTXH
HOOHHVWSXUHPHQWOHVLJQHV\QWD[LTXHGHODVXERUGLQDWLRQGXQRPDXYHUEH0DLVHQRXWUHLO\DjWLWUH
G·HPSORLVVSpFLDX[XQDFFXVDWLIGXEXWGHO·H[WHQVLRQVSDWLDOHRXWHPSRUHOOHGXSUL[HWF&KDFXQHGHFHV
YDOHXUVQ·HVWSURSUHTX·jXQJURXSHGHYHUEHVGpWHUPLQpDXSRLQWGHYXHVpPDQWLTXH .XU\‫ן‬RZLF]
² 

(WLOFRQFOXDLW

2QSHXWGRQFSDUOHUG·XQHIRQFWLRQSULPDLUHGHO·DFFXVDWLIODTXHOOHHVWFHOOHGHUpJLPHGLUHFWHWG·XQH
VpULHGHIRQFWLRQVVHFRQGDLUHVDFFXVDWLIGXEXW )(5(-(>%5(44+($#2%K6>(>%#-! GHO·H[WHQVLRQGXSUL[HWF
/HVFRQGLWLRQVGHO·HPSORLHQIRQFWLRQVHFRQGDLUHVRQWWRXMRXUVGpILQLVVDEOHVHWG·XQHPDQLqUHSRVLWLYH
.XU\‫ן‬RZLF] 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%<B<NY78%8B%A,K@OZA87[% @

0DLVDYRQVQRXVMDGLVREMHFWp´DORUVTXH.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]UHFRQQDvWIRUWMXVWHPHQWDXQLYHDXGHODWKpRULHJpQpUDOH
TXHODIRQFWLRQSULPDLUHHWOHVIRQFWLRQVVHFRQGDLUHVG·XQHXQLWpOLQJXLVWLTXHQHVRQWTXHGHVUpDOLVDWLRQVGDQVOH
GLVFRXUVGHODIRQFWLRQIRQGDPHQWDOHGHODGLWHXQLWpIRQFWLRQIRQGDPHQWDOHTXLFRPPHLOOHGLWH[SUHVVpPHQW
VHGpWHUPLQHGDQVOHV\VWqPHLOQHQRXVGLWULHQVXUODIRQFWLRQIRQGDPHQWDOHGHO·DFFXVDWLIHWQHSUpFLVHSDV
GHTXHOOHYDOHXUGDQVOHV\VWqPHGHVFDVLQGRHXURSpHQVODIRQFWLRQSULPDLUHHWOHVIRQFWLRQVVHFRQGDLUHVGH
O·DFFXVDWLISHXYHQWrWUHFRQVLGpUpHVFRPPHGHVUpDOLVDWLRQVSDUWLFXOLqUHVµ 7RXUDWLHU ,OIDXWWRXWHIRLV
UHFRQQDvWUHTXHFHODVHPEOHLPSRVVLEOHHWOHSRLQWGHYXHGH-HDQ3HUURWSHUPHWGHOHFRPSUHQGUH&·HVWSDUFH
TXHOHVDFFXVDWLIVGHVSUpWHQGXHVIRQFWLRQVVHFRQGDLUHVVRQWGHVDOORPRUSKHVG·XQPRUSKqPHjVLJQLILDQWGLV
FRQWLQXIRUPpG·XQHSUpSRVLWLRQHWG·XQDFFXVDWLITX·RQQHSHXWULHQOHXUWURXYHUGHFRPPXQDYHFODYDOHXUGH
O·DFFXVDWLITXLQ·HVWMDPDLVSUpSRVLWLRQQHO/HVDFFXVDWLIVYDULDQWHVG·DFFXVDWLIVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOVHWOHVDFFXVDWLIV
VHXOVQHUHSUpVHQWHQWGRQFSDVGXWRXWOHVPrPHVPRUSKqPHV

"23%F2?283%4564738987::;<3
6LRQV·LQWpUHVVHPDLQWHQDQWDX[FDVMDPDLVDFFRPSDJQpVGHSUpSRVLWLRQVF·HVWjGLUHjFHTXH.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]
FRQVLGpUDLWFRPPHODIRQFWLRQSULPDLUHGHVFDVULHQQHSURXYHTXHWRXWHVOHXUVRFFXUUHQFHVUHSUpVHQWHQWXQ
VHXOHWPrPHPRUSKqPH1RXVDYRQVHQHIIHWSXPRQWUHUGDQVQRWUHDUWLFOHGHTXHO·DEODWLIWRXMRXUVVHXO
TXLDIIHFWHXQFRQVWLWXDQWQRPLQDOGH69SHXWrWUHOHVLJQLILDQWG·XQPRUSKqPHUHODWLRQQHO F·HVWjGLUHG·XQ
PRUSKqPHJUDPPDWLFDOD\DQWXQFHUWDLQFRQWHQXVpPDQWLTXH GRQWOHVLJQLILpHVW´DYHFDXPR\HQGHµHWTXH
OHVJUDPPDLUHVFRODLUHVLOOXVWUHQWSDUO·H[HPSOH
:!-#-!%5.("#6´IUDSSHUDYHFXQHpSpHµ
PDLVTX·LOSHXWDXVVLrWUHOHVLJQLILDQWG·XQPRUSKqPHIRQFWLRQQHOD\DQWFRPPHO·DFFXVDWLIGLWG·REMHWODYDOHXU
V\QWD[LTXHGH´&RPSOpPHQWGHYHUEHµ&·HVWFHOXLTXHO·RQWURXYHGDQVOHV69
(.#X1(%-!%1$#´VHVHUYLUGHTTFKµ
FL
(&1)"($%"#1#$##0f%)1..(%-!%4(-!$%´LOUHJRUJHGHULFKHVVHVLOQHPDQTXHGHULHQµ
ROHVJUDPPDLUHVKLVWRULTXHVDLPHQWWDQWjUHWURXYHUXQLQVWUXPHQWDOFHTXLDO·LQFRQYpQLHQWG·DVVRXSOLUOD
QRWLRQG·´LQVWUXPHQWDOµMXVTX·jODUHQGUHLQFRQVLVWDQWHHWIORXH0DLVHQGHKRUVGX69O·DEODWLISHXWDXVVLrWUH
XQDOORPRUSKHGXQRPLQDWLID\DQWODYDOHXUV\QWD[LTXHGHVXMHWGDQVODSURSRVLWLRQVXERUGRQQpHSDUWLFLSLDOH
TXHOHVJUDPPDLUHVVFRODLUHVDSSHOOHQW´O·DEODWLIDEVROXµ
@(-$#&10%:(4$#02%1!-&(%:!4#$%.!6%´OHVSDUWVD\DQWpWpIDLWHVOHOLRQSDUODµ
/·DEODWLIVHXOUHSUpVHQWHGRQFDXPRLQVWURLVPRUSKqPHVGLIIpUHQWVTX·LOHVWLPSRVVLEOHGHUDPHQHUjO·XQLWpTXH
FHOOHFLVRLWVpPDQWLTXHRXV\QWD[LTXH,OHVWHQHIIHWDXVVLLPSRVVLEOHGHWURXYHUXQHFDUDFWpULVWLTXHV\QWD[LTXH
FRPPXQHDX[WURLVIRQFWLRQVGH&LUFRQVWDQW&RPSOpPHQWGHYHUEHHW6XMHWTXHGHYRLUGDQVWRXVFHVHPSORLV
GLIIpUHQWVXQIDLWGHSRO\VpPLH,OV·DJLWGRQFG·XQHKRPRQ\PLH
/DVLWXDWLRQHVWODPrPHSRXUO·DFFXVDWLI&HUWHVF·HVWOHFDVSDUH[FHOOHQFHGXFRPSOpPHQWGHYHUEHTXH
FHOXLFLVRLWOHGHX[LqPHDFWDQWG·XQYHUEHTXHOHVJUDPPDLUHVVFRODLUHVTXDOLILHQWGHWUDQVLWLIFRPPHGDQV
<>6%I($-!>´M·DLPHPRQSqUHµ"64!6%I1!-60%5-(>>($#4(>´M·HQVHLJQHODJUDPPDLUHDX[HQIDQWVµ
RXTX·LOVRLWDMRXWpVDQVQpFHVVLWpVpPDQWLTXHjODFRQVWUXFWLRQG·XQYHUEHPRQRYDOHQWFRPPHGDQVODWUDQVL
WLYDWLRQTXHOHVJUDPPDLUHVVFRODLUHVDSSHOOHQW´O·DFFXVDWLIG·REMHWLQWHUQHµ
1#1!-!%1#$(>%&!($(>%´YLYUH PHQHU XQHYLHKHXUHXVHµ
0DLVOHPRUSKqPHIRQFWLRQQHOGH´&RPSOpPHQWGHYHUEHµFRQQDvWG·DXWUHVDOORPRUSKHV¬FRPPHO·DEODWLIGDQV
(.#X1(%-!%1$6-%´MHPHVHUVGHTTFKµOHJpQLWLIGDQV>!>#)#%>6-$16-1>´MHPHVRXYLHQVGHVPRUWVµRXOHGDWLIGDQV
0$1"!6%5-(>>($#4(!´M·pWXGLHODJUDPPDLUHµ(WO·DFFXVDWLIOXLPrPHSHXWrWUHXQDOORPRUSKHG·DXWUHVPRUSKqPHV
SDUH[HPSOHGXPRUSKqPHGHVXMHWGDQVOHVVXERUGRQQpHVGLWHVFRPSOpWLYHV
74#6%1#$(>%!00!%&-!1!>%´MHVDLVTXHODYLHHVWFRXUWHµ"#41)$%O6>!-1>%4(!41>%:1#00!´RQGLWTX·+RPqUHDpWp
DYHXJOHµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3OK/7*/<B%*,\K<*/8K

&RPPHQWSDUH[HPSOHQHSDVSDUOHUG·KRPRQ\PLHGHYDQW
(">6)!)$%>!%1!)#-!%´LOVP·HQJDJHQWjYHQLUµ
RO·DFFXVDWLI>!HVWOHFRPSOpPHQWGH(">6)!)$2%JK%
(">6)#$10%!0$%>!%1!)#-!%´LOIXWDYHUWLTXHMHYHQDLVµ
RO·DFFXVDWLI>!QHSHXWTX·rWUHTXHOHVXMHWGH1!)#-!

0rPHOHQRPLQDWLITXLHVWOHVLJQLILDQWQRQPDUTXpGXVXMHWHWTXLDGHVDOORPRUSKHVQRXVYHQRQVGHOHYRLU
FRPPHO·DFFXVDWLIHWO·DEODWLISHXWPDUTXHUG·DXWUHVIRQFWLRQVTXHO·RQV·HIIRUFHGHUDWWDFKHUDXPRLQVYHUEDOH
PHQWjODIRQFWLRQGHVXMHW,OPDUTXHXQDWWULEXWGXVXMHWTXHFHOXLFLVRLWXQDGMHFWLIRXXQQRP
7#4#.#(%>(5)(%#)01.(%!0$´OD6LFLOHHVWXQHJUDQGHvOHµ:#.#10%(%I($-!%e1#)$10%164($1-´OHILOVHVWDSSHOp4XLQWXV
SDUVRQSqUHµ
&HUWHVLO\DXQHUHODWLRQVpPDQWLTXHHQWUHFHWDWWULEXWHWOHVXMHWGHODSKUDVHSXLVTX·LOGpVLJQHOHPrPH
LQGLYLGXTXHOXL0DLVDXSRLQWGHYXHV\QWD[LTXHTX·HVWFHTX·XQDWWULEXWGXVXMHW"&·HVWWRXWVLPSOHPHQWOH
FRPSOpPHQWG·XQHFODVVHSDUWLFXOLqUHGHYHUEHVjVDYRLUOHVYHUEHVTXLVLJQLILHQWXQpWDW/HQRPLQDWLIHVWSDU
FRQVpTXHQWLFLOHVLJQLILDQWGXPRUSKqPHGHFRPSOpPHQWGHYHUEHTXLHVWXQHIRQFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHTXHO·RQD
O·KDELWXGHG·RSSRVHUjODIRQFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHGHVXMHW0DLVOHQRPLQDWLISHXWDXVVLrWUHFHTXHOHVJUDPPDLUHV
DSSHOOHQWSXGLTXHPHQWXQ´)6>#)($#110%I!)"!)0µFRPPHGDQV
F!>#)(!%X1(!%)6)%+(&!)$%1#-602%.#4!$%!#0%)1&!-!% $XJXVWLQH7!->6)0 ´/HVIHPPHVTXLQ·RQWSDVGHPDUL
LOOHXUHVWSRVVLEOHGHVHPDULHUµ
0DLVFHQ·HVWSDVSDUFHTXHODJUDPPDLUHWUDGLWLRQQHOOHQ·DSDVYXTXHOH61DXQRPLQDWLIUHPSOLVVDLWXQHIRQF
WLRQV\QWD[LTXHRULJLQDOH³TXHO·RQSHXWDSSHOHUO·H[WUDSRVLWLRQHWGpILQLUFRPPHOHIDLWG·rWUHXQFRQVWLWXDQW
LPPpGLDWGH3TXLHVWDXVVLH[SDQVLRQGH3³TXHO·RQQHUHFRQQDvWUDSDVjFHQRPLQDWLIG·LQGLTXHUFHWWHIRQF
WLRQV\QWD[LTXHG·H[WUDSRVLWLRQ2QSRXUUDLWrWUHWHQWpGHSDUOHUDORUVQRQSDVG·XQHIRQFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHPDLV
G·XQHIRQFWLRQLQIRUPDWLYHRXSUDJPDWLTXHGHWKqPHGHO·pQRQFpFHTXLHVWGXUHVWHOHU{OHVpPDQWLTXHDXTXHO
FRUUHVSRQGVHORQQRXVODIRQFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHG·H[WUDSRVLWLRQ0DLVTXDQGRQYRLWTX·XQDFFXVDWLISHXWUHPSOLU
ODPrPHIRQFWLRQHWLQIRUPDWLYHHWV\QWD[LTXHSDUH[HPSOHGDQV
/..60%X1#%"()$%!60%"!-#"!0f%X1#%"!.1"1)$%"!I!-#0 3ODXWXV<0#)(-#( ´4!1]TXLQRXVSDLHQWWXW·HQPRTXHV
FHX[TXLQRXVEHUQHQWWX!)%J9%GF>>JY%
LOGHYLHQWSUpIpUDEOHGHGLUHTXHHWOHQRPLQDWLIHWO·DFFXVDWLIVRQWGHVDOORPRUSKHVGXPRUSKqPHG·H[WUDSRVLWLRQ
(WO·RQGRLWHQFRQFOXUHTX·DXFXQGHVFDVHPSOR\pVVHXOVHWVDQVDOWHUQDQFHSRVVLEOHDYHFXQWRXUSUpSRVLWLRQQHO
QHFRUUHVSRQGTX·jXQHVHXOHYDOHXUHWQ·HVWGRQFOHVLJQLILDQWG·XQVHXOPRUSKqPH
&HFLYHXWGLUHHQFRQFOXVLRQTXHOHVFDVHQHX[PrPHVQHVRQWSDVGHVPRUSKqPHVPDLVVHXOHPHQWGHV
XQLWpVPRUSKRORJLTXHVHWTXHOHV\VWqPHGHVFDVQ·HVWULHQGHSOXVTXHOHV\VWqPHPRUSKRORJLTXHDSSHOpWUDGL
WLRQQHOOHPHQWODGpFOLQDLVRQGRQWRQSHXWGRQQHUODGpILQLWLRQVXLYDQWH8QHGpFOLQDLVRQHVWXQHQVHPEOHRUJDQLVp
G·XQLWpVPRUSKRORJLTXHV F·HVWjGLUHGHFODVVHVGHVHJPHQWVPRUSKRORJLTXHVHQGLVWULEXWLRQFRPSOpPHQWDLUH 
TXLGDQVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVV·DMRXWHQWjGHVOH[qPHVPDLVDLOOHXUVSDUH[HPSOHHQMDSRQDLVjGHV
V\QWDJPHV RXFRPELQDLVRQVGHOH[qPHV (QODWLQSDUH[HPSOHODGpFOLQDLVRQHVWFRQVWLWXpHGHGHX[VpULHV
SDUDOOqOHVG·XQLWpVPRUSKRORJLTXHVTXLUHoRLYHQWWUDGLWLRQQHOOHPHQWOHQRPGHVLQJXOLHUHWGHSOXULHO&KDFXQH
GHFHVGHX[VpULHVG·XQLWpVPRUSKRORJLTXHVFRPSUHQGVL[XQLWpVPRUSKRORJLTXHVDSSHOpHVWUDGLWLRQQHOOHPHQW
GHVFDVHWGRQWOHVQRPVUHVSHFWLIVVRQWQRPLQDWLIYRFDWLIDFFXVDWLIJpQLWLIGDWLIHWDEODWLI
'DQVODPHVXUHRODGpFOLQDLVRQODWLQHFRQWLHQWGHX[IRLVVL[FDVHOOHHVWSOXVFRPSOLTXpHTXHODGpFOLQDL
VRQJUHFTXHFRQVWLWXpHGHVHXOHPHQWGHX[IRLVFLQTFDVjVDYRLUOHQRPLQDWLIOHYRFDWLIO·DFFXVDWLIOHJpQLWLI
HWOHGDWLIRXTXHODGpFOLQDLVRQDOOHPDQGHFRQVWLWXpHGHVHXOHPHQWGHX[IRLVTXDWUHFDVjVDYRLUOHQRPLQDWLI
O·DFFXVDWLIOHJpQLWLIHWOHGDWLI0DLVHOOHHVWPRLQVFRPSOLTXpHTXHODGpFOLQDLVRQILQQRLVHTXLHVWFRQVWLWXpHG·DX
PRLQVGHX[IRLVRQ]HFDVjVDYRLUOHQRPLQDWLIOHJpQLWLIOHSDUWLWLIO·LQHVVLIO·pODWLIO·LOODWLIO·DGHVVLIO·DEODWLI
O·DOODWLIO·HVVLIHWOHWUDQVODWLI
7RXWHIRLVOHODWLQDMRXWHXQHDXWUHIRUPHGHFRPSOLFDWLRQTXLHVWSUHVTXHLJQRUpHGXILQQRLVSDUH[HPSOH(Q
ILQQRLVHQHIIHWOHVGLIIpUHQWVFDVFRUUHVSRQGHQWODSOXSDUWGXWHPSVjXQVHXOHWPrPHVHJPHQWPRUSKRORJLTXH
HWSDUIRLVVHXOHPHQWjGHX[VHJPHQWVPRUSKRORJLTXHVGLIIpUHQWV(QODWLQOHVXQLWpVPRUSKRORJLTXHVGHFKDFXQH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%<B<NY78%8B%A,K@OZA87[% P

GHFHVGHX[VpULHVGHFDVUpXQLVVHQWWRXWHVDXPRLQVFLQTVHJPHQWVPRUSKRORJLTXHVTXLFRQVWLWXHQWFHTXHOHV
JUDPPDLUHVODWLQHVRQWO·KDELWXGHG·DSSHOHUOHVFLQTGpFOLQDLVRQVGXODWLQ
6LQRWUHDQDO\VHGHVFDVHVWMXVWHLOQHIDXWSDVFKHUFKHUjWRXWSUL[jUDWWDFKHUFKDTXHFDVjXQHHWXQHVHXOH
YDOHXU&DUFHODUHYLHQGUDLWjSUpWHQGUHUpVRXGUHXQSUREOqPHFRPSDUDEOHjFHOXLGHODTXDGUDWXUHGXFHUFOH

G8=<87C524H8;
)RXUTXHW-HDQ
% OPR:% D-(>>(#-!%"!%.;(..!>()"3DULV+DFKHWWH
+DUULV=HOOLJ6
% OPRO% 7$-14$1-(.%N#)51#0$#40&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVV
.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]-HU]\
  ´/HSUREOqPHGXFODVVHPHQWGHVFDVµ'DQV80X1#00!0%.#)51#0$#X1!0pGLWpVSDU-HU]\.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]SS
²3ROVND$NDGHPLD1DXN3UDFHM̯]\NR]QDZF]H%UHVODX=DNODG1DUROGRZ\3UHPLqUHSXEOL
FDWLRQHQGDQVS#1.!$')%@60=#!56%*69(-'0$9(%P!G'=6G)(94G!56 %XOOHWLQGHOD6RFLpWp3RORQDLVHGH
/LQJXLVWLTXH ²
  *+!%/):.!4$#6)(.%3($!56-#!0%6:%/)"6M81-6I!()+HLGHOEHUJ&DUO:LQWHU
2·%ULHQ5LFKDUG-
  <%H!04-#I$#?!%D-(>>(-%6:%844.!0#(0$#4(.%N($#)%S(0!"%6)%A6"!-)%7$-14$1-(.%<)(.'0#0&KLFDJR/R\ROD8QL
YHUVLW\3UHVV
5J77FK2%[J6H
  ´/HIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGXV\VWqPHGHVFDVHQODWLQµK!?1!%"!%I+#.6.65#!²
7RXUDWLHU&KULVWLDQ
  ´4XHOTXHVSULQFLSHVSRXUO·pWXGHGHVFDV DYHFDSSOLFDWLRQjO·DEODWLIODWLQ µN()5(5!0²
  ´$FFXVDWLIHWDQDO\VHHQPRUSKqPHVµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%N#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
 D ´&DVSUpSRVLWLRQVHWDQDO\VHHQPRUSKqPHVHQJUHFDQFLHQµ'DQV3(0%!$%I-UI60#$#6)0%!)%5-!4%()4#!)%
$FWHVGXFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOGH6DLQWeWLHQQH²MXLQ pGLWpSDU%-DFTXLQRGSS
²6DLQWeWLHQQH3XEOLFDWLRQVGHO·8QLYHUVLWpGH6DLQWeWLHQQH
% OPP<D% 7')$(]!%.($#)!%LEOLRWKqTXHGHV&DKLHUVGHO·,QVWLWXWGH/LQJXLVWLTXHGH/RXYDLQ/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV%
% OPPR% ´/HFDVHVWLOXQHXQLWpIRQFWLRQQHOOHOHJpQLWLIODWLQµ'DQVH8%T7Tg%U$1"!0%"!%0')$(]!%.($#)!%6::!-$!0%!)%
+6>>(5!%h%A(-#10%N(?!)4'pGLWpSDU'/RQJUpHSS²%LEOLRWKqTXHGHV&DKLHUVGHO·,QVWLWXWGH
/LQJXLVWLTXHGH/RXYDLQ/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
16>JHK8H2%56L>
  ´/HJURXSHSUpSRVLWLRQQHODOOHPDQGHQJUDPPDLUHGXVLJQLILpµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%N#)51#0$#X1!%"!%
@(-#0²
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% *O8%3,BP\D<*/,B%@K8F/i872%*O8%H<*/T8%3<782%<BH%*O8%8A@<*OY%O/8K<K3OY%/B%7\A8K/<B% OO

!
"#$%&'()*+,"-'(%./$0-1$23%"#$%4,"-5$%&,2$3%%
,(4%"#$%$6.,"#7%#-$/,/&#7%-(%2*6$/-,(

3+-#0$6I+!-%J66"02%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%3+#4(56j

,QWKHVWXG\RI6XPHULDQJUDPPDUWKHUHLVQRWRSLFRYHUZKLFKPRUHLQNKDVEHHQVSLOOHGWKDQWKHFRQMXJDWLRQ
SUHIL[HV&HUWDLQO\WKHODQJXDJHNHHSVLWVVHFUHWVLQRWKHUDUHDVEXWLQQRQHKDVLWEHHQOHVVIRUWKFRPLQJWKDQ
LQWKHGRPDLQRIWKHSUHIL[HV7KHSUREOHPRZHVLWVSULGHRISODFHDPRQJWKHP\VWHULHVRIWKHODQJXDJHWRWKH
VLPSOHIDFWWKDW³DWOHDVWIRUWKHQRQPRGDOIRUPVRIWKHYHUE³WKHFRQMXJDWLRQSUHIL[HVFRQVWLWXWHDQREOLJDWRU\
HOHPHQWRI6XPHULDQYHUEDOPRUSKRORJ\7KHLURQ\FDQKDUGO\HVFDSHXVWKDWRXULQDELOLW\WRDGHTXDWHO\H[SODLQ
WKHVHPRUSKHPHVLVHSLWRPL]HGE\WKHYHU\QDPHZHFRQWLQXHWRJLYHWKHPDVWKHVHPRUSKHPHV³ZHNQRZWKLV
PXFKDWOHDVW³KDYHQRWKLQJWRGRZLWKYHUEDOFRQMXJDWLRQ:HUHWDLQWKHWUDGLWLRQDOODEHOQRWVRPXFKIRUODFN
RIDEHWWHUWHUPDVIRUODFNRIDQDFFXUDWHGHVFULSWLRQRIWKHLUIXQFWLRQVWKDWZRXOGVXJJHVWRQH,QWKLVSDSHU,
GHVFULEHWKHEDVLFLFRQLFLW\WKDWXQGHUOLHVDQGGULYHVWKHFRQMXJDWLRQSUHIL[V\VWHPDQGKRZLWPDQLIHVWVLWVHOILQ
RQHRILWVEDVLFXVHVQDPHO\WKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQLQGLYLGXDOSUHIL[HVDQGWKHVHPDQWLFUROHVRI%(1(),&,$5<
DQG5(&,3,(17DVUHQGHUHGLQWKH6XPHULDQFDVHV\VWHPE\WKHGDWLYHFDVH O,WVKRXOGEHQRWHGDWWKHRXWVHW
WKDWDOWKRXJK,GHVFULEHWKLVXVHDVEDVLFLWLVQRWWKHSULPDU\IXQFWLRQRIWKHSUHIL[V\VWHPEXWRQHWKDWVSHDNV
SDUWLFXODUO\FOHDUO\WRWKHLFRQLFLW\WKDWXQGHUOLHVWKHV\VWHPDVDZKROH
%HIRUHWXUQLQJWRWKHGDWLYH,ILUVWRXWOLQHZKDW,XQGHUVWDQGWREHWKHSULPDU\IXQFWLRQRIWKHV\VWHPWKH
RQHWKDWLVH[WHQGHGWRLQFRUSRUDWHRWKHUIXQFWLRQV)URPWKHSHUVSHFWLYHRIIXQFWLRQDQGPHDQLQJ,FRQVLGHUWKH
SULPDU\FRQMXJDWLRQSUHIL[HVWREH>1#>>(&(DQG#$QGIURPWKHSHUVSHFWLYHRIERWKIXQFWLRQDQGPHDQLQJ
WKHVHSUHIL[HVFRQVWLWXWHDV\VWHPRIJUDPPDWLFDOYRLFH:LWKRXWJLYLQJGHWDLOHGHYLGHQFHIRULWKHUH VHH:RRGV
 WKLVFODLPLVEDVHGXSRQWKHVLPSOHEXWQRQHWKHOHVVHVVHQWLDO³DQGRGGO\UDUHO\PDGH³REVHUYDWLRQ
WKDWLQGLYLGXDOSUHIL[HVWHQGWRRFFXUZLWKFHUWDLQVHPDQWLFFODVVHVRIYHUEVDQGLQFHUWDLQSUDJPDWLFFRQWH[WV
PRUHWKDQRWKHUV%URDGO\VSHDNLQJJUDPPDWLFDOYRLFHV\VWHPVSURYLGHVSHDNHUVZLWKDVHULHVRIOLQJXLVWLFRS
WLRQVIRUH[SUHVVLQJDOWHUQDWLYHFRQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQVRIH[SHULHQFHDQGUHDOLW\9RLFHLQ6XPHULDQLVDVHPDQWLFDOO\
EDVHGV\VWHPEXWRQHZLWKDVWURQJRIWHQRYHUULGLQJSUDJPDWLFFRPSRQHQWDIDFWWKDWDFFRXQWVIRUPXFKRIWKH
SHUFHLYHGLGLRV\QFUDV\LQWKHV\VWHP7KHXOWLPDWHFKRLFHRIDSUHIL[LQPDQ\FDVHVLVDWWKHGLVFUHWLRQRIWKH
VSHDNHUDQGLVEDVHGXSRQKLVRUKHUSDUWLFXODUGLVFRXUVHUHTXLUHPHQWV
,QWHUPVRIWKHWUDGLWLRQDOODEHOV#>>(DQG&(DUHPLGGOHYRLFHPDUNHUV³RUEHWWHUPHGLRSDVVLYHPDUNHUV
>1UHSUHVHQWVWKHDFWLYHRUEHWWHUWKHPDUNHGDFWLYHYRLFHDGHVLJQDWLRQWKDWGLVWLQJXLVKHVLWIURP#ZKLFKLV
QHXWUDOZLWKUHJDUGWRYRLFHGLVWLQFWLRQVEXWZKLFKPD\EHVDLGWRUHSUHVHQWWKHXQPDUNHGRUEDVLFDFWLYHYRLFH
ZKHQXVHGLQWKHVHVDPHFRQWH[WV

7KLVSDSHUUHSUHVHQWVLQSDUWDV\QRSVLVDQGLQSDUWDIXUWKHU
GHYHORSPHQWRIVHYHUDODUJXPHQWVSUHVHQWHGLQP\ERRN*+!%D-(>M
>(-%6:%@!-0I!4$#?!g%*+!%71>!-#()%36)c15($#6)%@-!:#]!0%(0%(%7'0$!>%6:%T6#4!%
%ULOO 7KHDEEUHYLDWLRQVXVHGLQWKLVSDSHUDUHWKRVHRIWKH
3+#4(56%<00'-#()%H#4$#6)(-'RIWKH2ULHQWDO,QVWLWXWHRIWKH8QLYHU
VLW\RI&KLFDJRDQG*+!%71>!-#()%H#4$#6)(-'%6:%$+!%\)#?!-0#$'%A10!1>%
6:%$+!%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%@!))0'.?()#(ZLWKWKHIROORZLQJDGGLWLRQV&$N 
&XUVHRI$NDGH,Q*XG ,QDQDDQG*XGDP/J% /XJDOEDQGDLQWKH
0RXQWDLQ&DYH1* )DONHQVWHLQD!-#4+$01-=1)"!)5&8 5R\DO&RU
UHVSRQGHQFHRI8U8U1LQ& 8U1LQXUWD&<1 \HDUQDPH&LWDWLRQV
RI3UH6DUJRQLFUR\DOLQVFULSWLRQVDUHWKRVHRI)UD\QHFLWDWLRQV
RIOLWHUDU\WH[WVDUHWKRVHRIWKH(OHFWURQLF7H[W&RUSXVRI6XPHULDQ
/LWHUDWXUH %ODFNHWDO² 
O
6HPDQWLFUROHVDUHLGHDOL]DWLRQVRIFDVHDVLQWXLWLYHO\SHUFHLYHGLQ
H[SHULHQFHDQGODQJXDJHIRULQVWDQFH5(&,3,(17(;3(5,(1&(5/2
&$7,21DQGVRRQ³LGHDOVWKDWQRODQJXDJHDFWXDOO\JUDPPDWLFDO
L]HVEXWXSRQZKLFKDVPDQ\OLQJXLVWVEHOLHYHDOOODQJXDJHVVWUXF
WXUHJUDPPDWLFDOFDVH VHH%ODNH²&URIW²
/DQJDFNHUDQG3DOPHU² 

OO
 oi.uchicago.edu

O:% 3OK/7*,@O8K%J,,H7

$Q\DFWLRQRUVWDWHH[SUHVVHGE\DYHUEZKDWZHPD\UHIHUWRDVDQ!?!)$2:PD\EHFRQFHSWXDOL]HGLQWHUPVRI
DVWDUWLQJSRLQWUHSUHVHQWHGE\DQ,QLWLDWRUPDFURUROHQ%J99JHK86>>E%6%"6!-%F7%(4$6-ZKREULQJVDERXWDQGFRQWUROV
WKHDFWLRQDQGDQ(QGSRLQWPDFURUROHDQHQWLW\WKDWLVXOWLPDWHO\DIIHFWHGE\WKHDFWLRQDQHQWLW\WRZKLFKWKH
HIIHFWVRIWKHDFWLRQDFFUXH7KHDFWLYHYRLFHLQGLFDWHVWKDWVRPHHQWLW\GLVWLQFWIURPWKHVXEMHFW³WKH2EMHFW
LQWUDQVLWLYHFODXVHV³LVDIIHFWHGE\WKHDFWLRQ,QWKHLQWUDQVLWLYHFODXVHWKHDFWLYHPD\VLJQDOWKDWWKHVXEMHFW
FRQWUROVWKHDFWLRQDQGLVDYROLWLRQDOSDUWLFLSDQWLQLWWKDWWKHHIIHFWVRIWKHDFWLRQDUHSHUFHLYHGDVDFFUXLQJ
EH\RQGWKHVSKHUHRIWKHVXEMHFW,QFRQWUDVWWKHPLGGOHYRLFHLQGLFDWHVWKDWLWLVWKHVXEMHFWRUKLVLQWHUHVWV
WKDWLVXOWLPDWHO\DIIHFWHGE\WKHDFWLRQ&RQVLGHUWKHIROORZLQJVHQWHQFHV
>@ $FWLYH /%6I!)!"%$+!%"66-L%
% % /%-6..!"%$+!%&(..%6::%$+!%$(&.!L
 3DVVLYH *+!%"66-%9(0%6I!)!"L%
% % *+!%&(..%9(0%-6..!"%6::%$+!%$(&.!L%
 0LGGOH *+!%"66-%6I!)!"L%
% % *+!%&(..%-6..!"%6::%$+!%$(&.!L
,QWKHDFWLYHWKHVXEMHFWLVWKH,QLWLDWRURIWKHDFWLRQDVLQ/%6I!)!"%$+!%"66-%F7%/%-6..!"%$+!%&(..%6::%$+!%$(&.!2%
EXWLWLVQRWUHJDUGHGDVDIIHFWHGE\WKHDFWLRQIURPWKHVSHDNHU·VSHUVSHFWLYH7KHVXEMHFWLVQRWWKH(QGSRLQW
&RQYHUVHO\LQWKHSDVVLYHWKHVXEMHFWLVWKH(QGSRLQWRIWKHHYHQW³*+!%"66-%9(0%6I!)!"2%*+!%&(..%9(0%-6..!"%6::%
$+!%$(&.!³EXWQRWWKH,QLWLDWRUWKH$JHQWRIWKHDFWLRQKDVEHHQRPLWWHGIURPWKHFODXVHEHLQJSHUKDSVFRQ
WH[WXDOO\XQLPSRUWDQWRUXQNQRZQ+RZHYHULQWKHPLGGOHYRLFH³*+!%"66-%6I!)!"%F7%*+!%&(..%-6..!"%6::%$+!%$(&.!%
³WKHVXEMHFWLVWKH,QLWLDWRURIWKHDFWLRQWKH"6!-RIWKHDFWLRQDQGPRUHVDOLHQWO\WKH(QGSRLQWRIDFWLRQWKH
DIIHFWHGHQWLW\9RLFHDVWKHVHVHQWHQFHVVXJJHVWUHSUHVHQWVDOWHUQDWLYHSHUVSHFWLYHVRUZD\VRIORRNLQJDWDQ
HYHQW7KHDFWLYHYRLFHYLHZVWKHHYHQWIURPWKHSHUVSHFWLYHRIWKH,QLWLDWRUWKHPLGGOHDQGSDVVLYHYRLFHVIURP
WKHSHUVSHFWLYHRIWKH(QGSRLQW&RQVLGHUWKHFDVHRIWKHWUDQVLWLYHHYHQWWKHDFWLYHVHHVWKHDFWLRQGHVFULEHGE\
WKHSUHGLFDWHIURPWKHSRLQWRIYLHZRIWKH$JHQWZKLOHWKHSDVVLYHVHHVLWIURPWKHYDQWDJHSRLQWRIWKH2EMHFW
&OHDUO\WKH$JHQWLVWKH,QLWLDWRUDQGWKH2EMHFWLVWKH(QGSRLQW
%XWWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ,QLWLDWRUDQG(QGSRLQWLVQRWOLPLWHGWR$JHQWVDQG2EMHFWVEXWVXEVXPHVWKH
SURSHUWLHVWKDWW\SLI\HDFKWKHVHPDQWLFSDUDPHWHUVXSRQZKLFKWUDQVLWLYLW\LWVHOIGHSHQGV7KHVHLQFOXGHWKH
YROLWLRQDOLW\DQGDJHQF\RIWKH$JHQWWKHDIIHFWHGQHVVRIWKH2EMHFWDQGWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVZLWKZKLFKWKHDFWLRQ
LVWUDQVPLWWHGIURP$JHQWWR2EMHFW VHH+RSSHUDQG7KRPSVRQ ,QWKHSURWRW\SLFDOWUDQVLWLYHHYHQWDV
UHSUHVHQWHGVFKHPDWLFDOO\LQILJXUHDQ$JHQW³DYROLWLRQDOHQWLW\WKDWFRQWUROVWKHDFWLRQ³DFWVXSRQDQG
FRPSOHWHO\DIIHFWVDQ2EMHFWDQRQYROLWLRQDODQGQRQFRQWUROOLQJHQWLW\IRUH[DPSOHP1"'%&-6=!%$+!%"#0+2%7(>%
=#..!"%$+!%&15DQGS6&&'%&1#.$%$+!%+610!&RQFHLYHGLQWKHVHWHUPVWKHUHLVDPHWDSKRULFDOPRYHPHQWDQGGLUHF
WLRQDOLW\WRWKHSURWRW\SLFDOWUDQVLWLYHHYHQW:HFDQVSHDNRILWLQWHUPVRIDSRVLWLYHYHFWRUWKDWH[WHQGVIURP
$JHQWWR2EMHFWRUDWUDQVIHURIHQHUJ\IURP$JHQWWR2EMHFWVXFKDVWDNHVSODFHLQWKHFROOLVLRQRIWZRELOOLDUG
EDOOV /DQJDFNHU 

)LJXUH7KHSURWRW\SLFDOWUDQVLWLYHHYHQW%
DIWHU/DQJDFNHUDQG$OODQ

:
)ROORZLQJRWKHUIXQFWLRQDOWUHDWPHQWVRIYRLFHWKHWHUP!?!)$%89%
XVHGWKURXJKRXWWKLVSDSHUWRUHIHUWRWKHDFWLYLW\VWDWHRUSURFHVV
WKDWLVGHQRWHGE\DYHUE,QHVVHQFHWKHWHUPLVWDNHQDVWKH´FRQ
FHSWXDOFRUUHODWHRIDYHUEµ .HPPHUVHHDOVR$OODQ 
Q
0DFURUROHVDUHHVVHQWLDOO\XPEUHOODVHPDQWLFUROHVWKDWVXEVXPH
LQGLYLGXDO VHPDQWLF UROHV DQG KDYH UHOHYDQFH IRU LQWUDQVLWLYH DV
ZHOODVWUDQVLWLYHHYHQWV VHH)DUUHOO².HPPHU
)ROH\DQG9DQ9DOLQ²9DQ9DOLQDQG:LONLQV 7KH
,QLWLDWRUUROHHQFRPSDVVHV1I0$-!(>VHPDQWLFUROHVVXFKDV$*(17
(;3(5,(1&(5DQG6285&(DVHDFKUHSUHVHQWVWKHVWDUWLQJSRLQWRI
LWVHYHQWHDFKLVWKHLQLWLDOVRXUFHRIHQHUJ\WKDWVHWVWKHHYHQWLQ
PRWLRQ7KH(QGSRLQWUROHLQFOXGHVWKRVHVHPDQWLFUROHVWKDWUHS
UHVHQWWKHWHUPLQDOSRLQWVRIWKHLUUHVSHFWLYHDFWLRQFKDLQV7KHVH
"69)0$-!(>VHPDQWLFUROHVLQFOXGH3$7,(17%(1(),&,$5<5(&,3,
(17DQG*2$/ FI.HPPHU 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% *O8%3,BP\D<*/,B%@K8F/i872%*O8%H<*/T8%3<782%<BH%*O8%8A@<*OY%O/8K<K3OY%/B%7\A8K/<B% OQ

7KHQRWLRQWKDW$JHQWVDUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKFRQWURODQG2EMHFWVZLWKDIIHFWHGQHVVFDQEHWUDFHGLQPRGHUQ
VFKRODUVKLSEDFNWR6LOYHUVWHLQ  ZKRGHPRQVWUDWHGWKDWVRPHQRXQVEDVHGRQWKHLULQKHUHQWOH[LFDOVHPDQ
WLFVDUHPRUH$JHQWOLNH³DUHPRUHOLNHO\WRFRQWURODQDFWLRQ³WKDQRWKHUVDQGWKDWDVFDOHRIDOOSRVVLEOHQRXQ
W\SHVFRXOGEHHVWDEOLVKHG7KLVVFDOHNQRZQDVWKH$QLPDF\RU1RPLQDO+LHUDUFK\ ILJ UDQJHVIURPQRXQV
KDYLQJSURWRW\SLFDOO\RUVWDWLVWLFDOO\WKHJUHDWHVWSRWHQWLDOIRUVHUYLQJDV$JHQWVWRWKRVHKDYLQJWKHJUHDWHVW
SRWHQWLDOIRUVHUYLQJDV2EMHFWV,WGHVFULEHVWKHFRQWLQXXPRIQRPLQDOVLQODQJXDJHZKLFKLVERXQGHGDWRQH
HQGE\WKHILUVWDQGVHFRQGSHUVRQVWKHSURWRW\SLFDO$JHQWVDQGRQWKHRWKHUHQGE\WKHLQDQLPDWHFRPPRQ
QRXQVWKHSURWRW\SLFDO2EMHFWV
)URP\HWDQRWKHUSHUVSHFWLYHWKHQDWXUDORUGHULQJRI13VLVDQ!>I($+'KLHUDUFK\UHSUHVHQWLQJWKHGHJUHH
WRZKLFKVSHDNHUVEHLQJKXPDQDQGDQLPDWHLGHQWLI\RUVKDUHFRPPRQFRQFHUQVZLWKWKHSHRSOHDQGWKLQJV
XQGHUGLVFXVVLRQ .XQR.XQRDQG.DEXUDNLVHHDOVR'H/DQFH\/DQJDFNHU² 
7KHVSHDNHUQDWXUDOO\HPSDWKL]HVPRVWZLWKKLPVHOI+HLVFRQFHUQHGDQGLGHQWLILHVPRVWZLWKKLPVHOIDQG
VHFRQGDULO\ZLWKWKHDGGUHVVHHKLVSDUWQHULQGLVFRXUVH7KHVSHDNHUGLVSOD\VSURJUHVVLYHO\OHVVHPSDWK\IRU
XQLQYROYHGWKLUGSHUVRQVFROOHFWLYHVDQGILQDOO\LQDQLPDWHV,QRWKHUZRUGVHPSDWK\UHIOHFWVWKHGHJUHHWR
ZKLFKWKHVSHDNHULGHQWLILHVZLWKDQRWKHUFODXVDOSDUWLFLSDQWFKRRVLQJWRWDNHRUQRWWRWDNHWKDWSDUWLFLSDQW·V
SHUVSHFWLYHRQWKHHYHQW(PSDWK\WRXVH/DQJDFNHU·VIHOLFLWRXVGHVFULSWLRQ´UHIOHFWVDQHJRFHQWULFDVVHVVPHQW
RIWKHYDULRXVVRUWVRIHQWLWLHVWKDWSRSXODWHWKHZRUOGµ ² ,QGHHGLWLVWKHHJRFHQWULFQDWXUHRIODQ
JXDJHWKDWLVDWWKHURRWRIILJXUHDVDKLHUDUFK\RIERWKDJHQF\DQGHPSDWK\

)LJXUH7KH1RPLQDO+LHUDUFK\ DIWHU'L[RQ

2XUFRJQLWLYHPRGHOWKHQZKLFKHQYLVLRQVWKHHYHQWLQWHUPVRI,QLWLDWRUDQG(QGSRLQWPDFURUROHVFDQEH
HODERUDWHGWRDFFRXQWIRUWKRVHVFDODUSURSHUWLHVWKDWDUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHFDQRQLFDO$JHQWVDQG2EMHFWV7KH
,QLWLDWRUDQG(QGSRLQWVRIWKHHYHQWVXEVXPHDKRVWRISDUDOOHORULFRQLFVWUXFWXUHVWKDWWHQGWRFOXVWHUWRJHWKHU
DQGDUHGHVFULEHGLQILJXUH VHH'H/DQFH\ 

)LJXUH&RLQFLGHQWVWUXFWXUHVUHODWLQJWRWKHSURWRW\SLFDOWUDQVLWLYHHYHQW
 oi.uchicago.edu

O<% 3OK/7*,@O8K%J,,H7

6SHFLILFDOO\WKH,QLWLDWRUUROHLVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKKLJKDJHQF\DQGDQLPDF\DVZHOODVZLWKYROLWLRQDQGFRQWURO
FKDUDFWHULVWLFVWKDWDUHHPERGLHGE\WKH$JHQWVSDUH[FHOOHQFHWKHPRVWVDOLHQWDQGHPSDWK\JDUQHULQJ13V³
WKH6SHHFK$FW3DUWLFLSDQWVZKLFKDUHE\GHILQLWLRQ+!-!DWWKHSODFHRIGLVFRXUVH&RQYHUVHO\WKH(QGSRLQWRI
WKHHYHQWLVFKDUDFWHUL]HGE\DIIHFWHGQHVVORZDQLPDF\DQGDODFNRIFRQWURODQGYROLWLRQRYHUWKHHYHQW7KHVH
DUHSURSHUWLHVDIILOLDWHGZLWKWKHFDQRQLFDO2EMHFWV³$+#)50ZKLFKDUHORZLQVDOLHQFHZLWKZKLFKVSHDNHUVVKDUH
OLWWOHHPSDWK\DQGZKLFKDUHREYLRXVO\XQLQYROYHGLQWKHGLVFRXUVHDQGPHWDSKRULFDOO\DUHXQGHUVWRRGWREH
$+!-!$QGDVWKH,QLWLDWRUUROHLVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHRQVHWDQGXQIROGLQJRIWKHHYHQWWKH(QGSRLQWUROHUHODWHV
WRLWVFRPSOHWLRQDQGUHVXOWLQJHIIHFWV
:LWKUHVSHFWWRRXUSUHIL[HV>1LVDQ,QLWLDWRURULHQWHGQRWLRQZKLOH#>>(DQG&(³EXWSDUWLFXODUO\&(³
DUH(QGSRLQWRULHQWHGQRWLRQV>1FRUUHODWHVZLWKLQFUHDVHGWUDQVLWLYLW\DQLPDF\DQGFRQWURORYHUWKHHYHQW
ZKLOH&(DQG#>>(FRUUHODWHZLWKGHFUHDVHGWUDQVLWLYLW\LQDQLPDF\DQGDIIHFWHGQHVVE\WKHHYHQW,QWHUPVRI
YRLFHDWWKHFHQWHURIWKHVHPDQWLFUDQJHRIWKHSUHIL[>1³LWVFDQRQLFDOXVDJH³LVWKHSURWRW\SLFDORUKLJKO\
WUDQVLWLYHHYHQW)RUWKHSUHIL[HV#>>(DQG&(LQFRQWUDVWWKHSURWRW\SLFDOXVDJHVDUHYDULRXVPLGGOHYRLFH
HYHQWV
!"#DQGSURWRW\SLFDOWUDQVLWLYHHYHQWVIRUH[DPSOH!"$"%2%!"$&#%&!´GHVWUR\VWKµ>@!""'!´NLOOVWKµ
>@²>@ FI&(1k:´GLHµ>@ !"(&)´NLOOFUXVKVWKµ>@DQG!"*"8´EXLOGVWKµ>@ FI>@>@ %\H[WHQ
VLRQZLWKLQWUDQVLWLYHVWKHSUHIL[VXJJHVWVWKDWWKHVXEMHFWH[HUFLVHVVRPHFRQWURORYHUWKHHYHQWIRUH[DPSOH
!")"´NQRZVWKµ>@²>@LQWKHVHQVHRIWRKDYHDVNLOORUPDVWHU\RYHUVRPHNQRZOHGJH,QDOOFDVHVVXEMHFW
DIIHFWHGQHVVLVQHXWUDOL]HG
>@ 8UXD]NL%9:;<:=%JH98:EL9:;:>!0LߖLPHNL%9:;<:=$UX:DNL%9:;<?;=?9´ (DQDWXP GHVWUR\HG8UXD]
DQGNLOOHGLWVUXOHUKHGHVWUR\HG0LVKLPHDQGDQQLKLODWHG$UXDµ (DQDWXPLY²(DQDWXPLY²Y


>@ *XGGDPHHVLU:%/HLINLJDNH<ߖDU:UD9:;@A;A@;B?CߖDU:UDJLߖWXNXODQD9:;@A;A@;:BD´*XGDPFUXVKHG
DPXOWLWXGHRQWKHVWUHHWVRI8UXNKHNLOOHGDPXOWLWXGHZLWKKLVPDFHµ ,Q*XG&² 1RWHWKDW15@%89%
WKHSOXUDOURRWRI1k:´GLHNLOOµ

>@ 8UG1DQߖH«H:%G1DQߖH9:;E:8HߖQ%487:VX9:;E:8,EJDO9:;E:8.LQLU9:;E:8%):GDP9:;E:8%DJDUD:%
9:;E:8$E]XHJ:%9:;E:8´8U1DQVKH«EXLOWWKHWHPSOHRI1DQVKHEXLOWWKHVDQFWXDU\RI*LUVXEXLOW
WKH,EJDOEXLOWWKH.LQLUEXLOWWKH(GDPEXLOWWKH%DJDUDDQGEXLOW$E]XHJµ 8U1DQߖH 

>@ VLSDG]LG*XQGH:DJDO9:;C:%I6>%8QJDWXP:PX´7KHWUXHVKHSKHUG*XGHDLVYHU\ZLVHDQGYHU\DF
FRPSOLVKHGDVZHOO OLWJUHDWO\NQRZLQJDQGJUHDWDVZHOOLQWKHFDUU\LQJRXW µ *XGHD&\O$[[Y² 

>@ HߖEDUGXJ<JDQLNLELߖHQ%I6:JD:GLGLEL9:;F;C:´ 1LQXUWD \RXXQGHUVWDQGKRZWRHVWDEOLVKDQGFDUU\

RXWWKHGHFLVLRQVILUPO\SURQRXQFHG E\(QOLO µ 8U1LQ& 
+&#DQGPLGGOHHYHQWVWKDWLVWKRVHLQZKLFK´WKH¶DFWLRQ·RU¶VWDWH·DIIHFWVWKHVXEMHFWRIWKHYHUERUKLVLQWHUHVWVµ
/\RQV IRUH[DPSOH+&"'!´GLHµ>@ FI>11k:´NLOOµ>@²>@ +&!"!´JURZµ>@,-!G+&./´IHDUµ
0"G+&)-(8´KDYHJRRVHEXPSVEHWHUULILHGµ>@ FI>@ '"G+&.-´UHFHLYHµ>@DQG+&("+´VWDQGµ>@&(LV
DOVRXVHGWRH[SUHVVWKHSDVVLYHIRUH[DPSOH+&*"8´VWKLVEXLOWµ>@,QDOOFDVHVWKHSUHIL[HVHPSKDVL]HVWKH
VXEMHFW·VUROHDVSDWLHQWRU1)"!-56!-WKHSURWRW\SLFDOHQYLURQPHQWIRUWKHSUHIL[LVUHSUHVHQWHGE\WKRVHHYHQWV
LQZKLFKVXEMHFWDIIHFWHGQHVVLVPD[LPDODQGLQZKLFKDJHQF\³VSHFLILFDOO\FRQWURODQGYROLWLRQ³LVPLQLPDO
>@ PX/X:JLJXQ<QDߖHߖ.XOLJXGX<%H?;:>!%8QEL:ODQXXQWXNXDߖHQ´%HFDXVH/XJLJXQDWKHEURWKHURI.XOL
WKH51"1SULHVWKDVGLHGZLWKRXWDQKHLUµ 1*² 

>@ >X:DQL@UH?;?98;9:!ߖXPXH?;?98;9:!>ED@GQELX:JLG:GDH?;?98;9:!´/DPHQWDWLRQJUDVVVSURXWHG
DOIDOIDJUDVVVSURXWHG³E\WKHZDOOVJUDVVJUHZORQJµ 1LVDED%² 

>@ QXNDU:NDU:%6I6QXV:OXJDOJD:NH<%JLߖEDQߖXUPXLQEDODDߖHQ%@A!%H?;E?;IF%J:%H?;E?;CAB8´$OWKRXJK,KDG
JLYHQQRLQVXOWWKHERG\JXDUGVRIP\NLQJRYHUWXUQHGP\WDEOH³,EHFDPHWHUULILHGP\IOHVKFUHSWµ
5&8² 

>@ QLJ:ߖDP:%I6H6:NDP>:%H?;IA´ 7KHVHOOHUV UHFHLYHGWKHSXUFKDVHSULFHRIWKHILHOGµ *HOE.XGXUUXV

L² 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% *O8%3,BP\D<*/,B%@K8F/i872%*O8%H<*/T8%3<782%<BH%*O8%8A@<*OY%O/8K<K3OY%/B%7\A8K/<B% OR

>@ G
%DX:QDPߖLWD8UXLQLPJLQDNDNH<%H?;B:HPXEL´¶%DXVWDQGVDWWKHSUD\HUVRI8UXLQLPJLQD·LV WKLV
REMHFW·V QDPHµ 8UXLQLPJLQDV> )$268NJ@ 

>@ PXEDGQPDGDNL%H?;E:8´7KH\HDUWKHZDOORIWKHODQGZDVEXLOWµaPX G߰XOJLOXJDOHEDGQPDGDNL%9:;

E:8´7KH\HDU6KXOJLWKHNLQJEXLOWWKHZDOORIWKHODQGµ ߰XOJL<1 
-!!&#DQGPLGGOHHYHQWV7KHSUHIL[KDVPXFKRIWKHVDPHIXQFWLRQDOUDQJHDV&(DQGVLPLODUO\IXQFWLRQVDVD
PLGGOHPDUNHU+RZHYHULQFRQWUDVWWR&(WKHVXEMHFWRIWKH#>>(SUHIL[HGYHUEWHQGVWRH[HUFLVHJUHDWHUFRQWURO
DQGDJHQF\RYHUWKHDFWLRQ WKDWLVWKHVXEMHFWLVOHVV3$7,(17OLNH &RQVHTXHQWO\WKHHYHQWH[SUHVVHGZLWK#>>(
LVRIWHQRIJUHDWHULQWHQVLW\ FI'"1-!!&.-´JUDEVHL]Hµ>@ZLWK'"1+&.-´JHWUHFHLYHµ>@ RUFRPSOH[LW\ FI
98HIL>67%+&("+´VWDQGµ>@ZLWKFROOHFWLYH-!!&("+´VWDQGµLQ>@ WKDQWKDWH[SUHVVHGZLWKLWVFRXQWHUSDUW
&(,QWKLVZD\#>>(UHSUHVHQWVDOHVVH[WUHPHPDQLIHVWDWLRQRI(QGSRLQWIRFXVWKDQGRHV&(³QRWH>1"1Q%
´EXLOGVWKµ>@#>>("1Q´EXLOGVWKIRURVµ>@EXW&("1Q´VWKLVEXLOWµ>@
>@ 8OPDߖNLD@A!%A9;9?;@A;A@;IF YDUXPPDGDDQWH ´,Q8OPDVK ,QDQD EHFDPHIHDUIXOµ &$N 

>@ H:HHQH?;B:HODJDOH?;B:HPHHߖXVLLPPDVD:% G$QXQQDXQGLGHQ%A9;9?;>:K;>:K;BF;F>!´7KH!)

SULHVWVWDQGVEHIRUHWKHWHPSOHDQGWKH.(5(.SULHVWVWDQGV EHIRUHWKHWHPSOH ³WRJHWKHUWKH\GRHY
HU\WKLQJWRSHUIHFWLRQ7KH$QXQDNLVWDQGWRJHWKHULQDVWRQLVKPHQWµ *XGHD&\O$[[² 1RWHWKDW
k1<Mk1< 5 LVWKHSOXUDOURRWRI51&´VWDQGµ

>@ XGED,O:%96HI6%C6D6>6MNLNDP*LU:VXNLWD8PPDNLߖHQ%I67QGDUUDDHJHQ,O:OHQDPHQVL:%/MM6NLD>:%
F;9?;IA´$WWKDWWLPH,OZKRZDVWKHWHPSOHHVWDWHDGPLQLVWUDWRUDW=DEDODPPDUFKHGLQUHWUHDWIURP
*LUVXWR8PPDDQGVHL]HGWKHUXOHUVKLSRI8PPDIRUKLPVHOI µ (QPHWHQDLLL² 

>@ XGEDHߖQ$NDQGHQNLNXJG,QDQDNH<%6M6RPDKDQLߖHQ%A9;9?;?@;E:8;E:8´$WWKDWWLPHKRO\,QDQDEXLOW
KHUVHOIWKHVDQFWXDU\RI$NDGHDVKHUPDJQLILFHQWZRPDQ·VGRPDLQµ &$N² 
7KHFRQMXJDWLRQSUHIL[HVDUHQRWOLPLWHGWRWKHH[SUHVVLRQRIJUDPPDWLFDOYRLFHEXWH[SUHVVDQXPEHURI
JUDPPDWLFDOFDWHJRULHVWKDWDUHHLWKHUGLUHFWO\UHODWHGWRYRLFHRULFRQLFDOO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWKYRLFHE\YLUWXHRI
VKDULQJDVLPLODUVWUXFWXUH$VDJHQHUDOEXWE\QRPHDQVDEVROXWHUXOHWKHJUDPPDWLFDOYRLFHIRUFHRIWKHSUH
IL[HVLVDWLWVPRVWSRWHQWWKHFORVHUWKHSUHIL[LVWRWKHYHUEDOURRW:KHQGLPHQVLRQDOLQIL[HVLQWHUYHQHEHWZHHQ
WKHSUHIL[DQGWKHURRWLWLVRIWHQWKHTXDOLW\RIWKHLUUHIHUHQWVWKDWGHWHUPLQHVWKHFKRLFHRISUHIL[$V%\EHH
 VWUHVVHVOLQJXLVWLFSUR[LPLW\DVUHIOHFWHGLQWKHOLQHDURUGHULQJRIPRUSKHPHVLVLFRQLFZLWKSUR[LPLW\
LQWHUPVRIPHDQLQJ,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHSRWHQWLDORIDSUHIL[WRPRGLI\WKHVHPDQWLFVRIWKHYHUE³YRLFHRI
FRXUVHDVDYHUEDOFDWHJRU\LVRQHPHDQVRIDOWHULQJWKHPHDQLQJRIWKHYHUE³LQFUHDVHVWKHFORVHUWKHSUHIL[
LVWRWKHYHUEDOURRW
7KLVEULQJVXVWRWKHSUHIL[HV·FRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKHGDWLYHWRZKLFK,GHYRWHWKHUHPDLQGHURIWKLVSDSHU7KH
GDWLYHLQIL[LVRQHRIWKHYHUEDOHOHPHQWVWKDWPD\LQWHUYHQHEHWZHHQWKHSUHIL[DQGWKHYHUEDOURRWVHSDUDWLQJ
WKHWZRLQWHUPVRIERWKWKHRUGHULQJRIPRUSKHPHVDQGPHDQLQJ$OWKRXJKWKHFRUUHODWLRQVWKDW,GHVFULEHDOVR
DSSO\EURDGO\WRWKHRWKHULQIL[HVWKH\DUHPRVWFRQVSLFXRXVO\GLVSOD\HGLQWKHFDVHRIWKHGDWLYHWKHRQHFDVH
WKDWKDVLQGHSHQGHQWIRUPVIRUHDFKSHUVRQ,QDFFRUGZLWKWKHLFRQLFLW\EHWZHHQIRUPDQGPHDQLQJZKHQD
YHUEDOIRUPLQFOXGHVDGDWLYHLQIL[WKHSUHIL[WHQGVWRUHIOHFWWKHVHPDQWLFVRIWKHUHIHUHQWRIWKHGDWLYHUDWKHU
WKDQWRPRGLI\WKHYRLFHRIWKHYHUE$VJLYHQEHORZWKHYHUE01>´JLYHµLVSDUDGLJPDWLFRIDYHUEWKDWW\SLFDOO\
LQFOXGHVD5(&,3,(17RU%(1(),&,$5<DVSDUWRILWVOH[LFDOIUDPH VHH(G]DUG*UDJJ 
>@ VW >1REOLJDWRU\ >(01>´JLYHWRPHµ  >@

 QG >1RYHUZKHOPLQJO\IUHTXHQW >1M-(M01>  >@

 UG DQLPDWH  >1YV#DSUDJPDWLFRSWLRQGHSHQGHQW%
FH%!>I($+' >1l#M)(01>  >@²>@
 UG LQDQLPDWH  &(RYHUZKHOPLQJO\IUHTXHQW%
&(‘01>´JLYHWRLWWKHPDZD\µ  >@²>@

([DPSOHVLQFOXGHWKHIROORZLQJ
>@ ߖDJ<JXGPD>ߖ:@9?;?@;J:9´7KHR[GULYHUJDYHPHJRDWVµ 7&6² 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3OK/7*,@O8K%J,,H7

>@ QDPOXJDODQQD]DUD9:;L?;?@;J:9´ (QOLO KDVJLYHQWR\RXWKHNLQJVKLSRIKHDYHQµ 1DQQD$ 

>@ G
6XHQH≠J7:±QDߖXEDDQߖLLQWLQDPWLOQ%9:;@?;?@;J:9´6XHQDFFHSWHGKLVWHDUVDQGJDYH /XJDOEDQGD 
OLIHµ /J%$ 

>@ PD:KXQJD:Dߖ$WXH$:WDA@;@?;?@;J:9´$WXJDYH$WDRQHERDWDVDUHQWDOµ 1*² 

>@ H:H«OXJDO G(QNLNH<HߖEDUNLQH?;?@;J:9´.LQJ(QNLJDYHRUDFXODUGHFLVLRQVWRWKHWHPSOHµ *XGHD

&\O%LY² 

>@ OXJDO≠ML±%9L7[ ᅵወᅵቨ: H<?;H?;?H;J:9;9:´0\ORUGVKRXOGJLYH WKHILHOG WRWKHZRUNWURRSµ )$26¬

*LUUHY ² 

>@ NLEDODKXOJLJ G1DQQD]DNH<Hߖ$QQH:%<?;H?;?H;J:9;9:´0D\$QFDVWRII OLWJLYHDZD\ WKHUHEHO

ODQGDVLWLVKDWHIXOWR\RXU1DQQDµ ,QDQD% 
$OWKRXJKWKHSUHIL[HVJHQHUDOO\GRQRWPDUNIRUJUDPPDWLFDOYRLFHLQGDWLYHHYHQWVWKHLUDSSHDUDQFHLQWKHVH
FRQWH[WVLVQHYHUWKHOHVVJRYHUQHGE\WKHVDPHVHPDQWLFSURSHUWLHVWKDWXQGHUOLHWKHLUYRLFHDQGWUDQVLWLYLW\
IXQFWLRQV7KDWLVOLNHWKHYRLFHXVHVWKHFRUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQWKHSUHIL[HVDQGWKHUHIHUHQWVRIWKHGDWLYHFDVH
FDQEHH[SODLQHGLQWHUPVRIWKH1RPLQDO+LHUDUFK\SDUWLFXODUO\WKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ>1DQGKLJKDQLPDF\
DQGWKDWEHWZHHQ&(DQGORZDQLPDF\6SHFLILFDOO\WKHFRUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQWKHSUHIL[HVDQGWKHGDWLYHFDVHDUH
H[SODLQDEOHLQWHUPVRIWKH1RPLQDO+LHUDUFK\ZKHQLWLVXQGHUVWRRGDVDQHPSDWK\KLHUDUFK\
&RQVLGHULQJWKHFRUUHODWLRQRI>1ZLWKWKHGDWLYHDOORPRUSKVLWLVLPPHGLDWHO\DSSDUHQWWKDWWKLVGLVWULEX
WLRQIRUPVDFRQWLQXXPWKDWPLUURUVWKH1RPLQDO+LHUDUFK\,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHIUHTXHQF\ZLWKZKLFK>1RFFXUV
ZLWKWKHGDWLYHFDVHLVGLUHFWO\SURSRUWLRQDOWRLWVUHIHUHQW·VSRVLWLRQRQWKH1RPLQDO+LHUDUFK\>1LVREOLJD
WRU\ZLWKWKHILUVWSHUVRQ SUHVXPDEO\>(>1(>ILUVWSHUVRQGDWLYH@ DQGQHDUO\VRZLWKWKHVHFRQGSHUVRQ
ZLWKWKHWKLUGSHUVRQ>1LVDIUHTXHQWO\XVHGSUDJPDWLFRSWLRQH[HUFLVHGZKHQWKHVSHDNHUHPSDWKL]HVZLWK
LWVUHIHUHQW7KDWLVE\FKRRVLQJ>1WKHVSHDNHUH[WHQGVWKHHPSDWK\PDUNWKDWLVPRVWFORVHO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWK
KLPVHOIDQGWKHDGGUHVVHHWRWKDWWKLUGSHUVRQ7KLVLVDSHUVRQLQZKRPWKHVSHDNHUKDVDSDUWLFXODULQWHUHVW
ZLWKZKRPKHLGHQWLILHVDSHUVRQKHGHHPVWREHRQVRPHOHYHOOLNHKLPVHOI8QGHUWKLVEURDGODEHORIHPSDWK\
IDOOIRULQVWDQFHWKHPDQ\HYHQWVLQZKLFKDUXOHUGRHVVRPHWKLQJIRUWKHEHQHILWRIDGHLW\VRRIWHQH[SUHVVHG
DE%>1M)(9(5%
>1VLJQDOVWKHLQFOXVLRQRIDKLJKO\DQLPDWHSDUWLFLSDQWLQWKHFODXVH³DSDUWLFLSDQWZKRLVVHPDQWLFDOO\
$*(17OLNHEXWQRWKLPVHOIWKH$*(17RIWKHHYHQW7KHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ>1DQGWKHGDWLYHVWDQGVLQFRPSOH
PHQWDU\GLVWULEXWLRQWRWKDWRIWKHQHXWUDOSUHIL[#ZKLFKLVQDWXUDOO\LQFRPSDWLEOHZLWKWKHILUVWSHUVRQLQIUH
TXHQWZLWKWKHVHFRQGEXWOLNHZLVHFRPPRQZLWKWKHWKLUG%\RSWLQJWRXVH#ZLWKWKHWKLUGSHUVRQWKHVSHDNHU
LQGLFDWHVWKDWHLWKHUKHGRHVQRWHPSDWKL]HRULGHQWLI\ZLWKWKLVSHUVRQZKRLVE\GHILQLWLRQXQLQYROYHGLQWKH
GLVFRXUVHRUDOWHUQDWLYHO\IRUSUDJPDWLFRUVW\OLVWLFUHDVRQVWKHVSHDNHUFKRRVHVQRWWRH[SUHVVWKLVLGHQWLW\$V
LWLVZLWKUHVSHFWWRRWKHUSURSHUWLHV#LVQHXWUDOZLWKUHVSHFWWRHPSDWK\&RQVLGHU>@DQG>@JLYHQDERYHLQ
WKHIRUPHUWKHSURWDJRQLVWRIWKHVWRU\/XJDOEDQGDLVDIIRUGHGWKHKLJKHPSDWK\PDUN>1ZKHUHDVLQWKHODW
WHU³DFODXVHIURPDQDGPLQLVWUDWLYHWH[WDJHQUHWKDWH[KLELWVDVWULSSHGGRZQUHJLVWHURIWKHODQJXDJHZKLFK
VWULYHVDWDGHWDFKHGIDFWVRQO\UHSRUWLQJRIHYHQWV³WKHHPSDWK\QHXWUDO#LVXVHG7KDWWKHFKRLFHWRH[SUHVV
HPSDWK\LVLQWKHHQGDSUDJPDWLFRQHGHSHQGHQWRQWKHVSHDNHU·VGLVFRXUVHUHTXLUHPHQWVLVGHPRQVWUDWHGE\
>@DQG>@LQZKLFKWZRSDUDOOHODQGRWKHUZLVHLGHQWLFDOFODXVHVGLIIHUVLJQLILFDQWO\RQO\ZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKH
DSSHDUDQFHRI>1YHUVXV#
>@ XG G1DQߖHQDPOXJDO/DJDߖ NLVD9:;@?;J:9;9?;?´:KHQ1DQVKHJDYHWR (QPHWHQD WKHNLQJVKLSRI
/DJDVKµ (QPHWHQD²VLPLODUO\(QDQDWXP,LL²LLLLL²LLL 

>@ XG G1LQJLU:VXXUVDJ G(QOLO:OD:NH<8UXLQLPJLQDUDQDPOXJDO/DJDߖNL%F;@?;J:9;9?;?´:KHQ1LQ

JLUVXZDUULRURI(QOLOJDYHWR 8UXLQLPJLQD WKHNLQJVKLSRI/DJDVKµ 8UXLQLPJLQDYLL²YLLLVLPL
ODUO\/XJDO]DJHVLL² 
7KHFRQWHQWLRQWKDWHPSDWK\LVDWLVVXH³UDWKHUWKDQVRPHRWKHUSDUDPHWHURUIUHHYDULDWLRQ³ILQGVPRUH
FRQYLQFLQJVXSSRUWLQWKHSDUDOOHOSDVVDJHVRI57&>@²>@D3UH6DUJRQLFDGPLQLVWUDWLYHWH[WWKDWKDVEHHQ
FLWHGE\DOOFRPPHQWDWRUVVLQFH7KXUHDX'DQJLQ  LQFRQQHFWLRQZLWKWKHDOWHUQDWLRQEHWZHHQ>1DQG#M
57&GHDOVZLWKWZRH[FKDQJHVRIGLSORPDWLFJLIWVEHWZHHQWKHZLYHVRIWKHUXOHUVRI$GDEDQG/DJDVK7KH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% *O8%3,BP\D<*/,B%@K8F/i872%*O8%H<*/T8%3<782%<BH%*O8%8A@<*OY%O/8K<K3OY%/B%7\A8K/<B% O@

GLVWULEXWLRQRI>1DQG#FRQIRUPVWRZKDWWKHHPSDWK\KLHUDUFK\SUHGLFWV7KHZULWHUZKRLVIURP/DJDVK³DV
WKLVLVD*LUVXWH[W³QDWXUDOO\KDVJUHDWHUHPSDWK\IRUWKRVHSDUWLFLSDQWVZKRFDOO/DJDVKKRPHWKDQIRUWKRVH
IURP$GDE&RQVHTXHQWO\>1LVXVHGZLWKWKRVHLQGLYLGXDOVIURP/DJDVKDQGQHXWUDO#ZLWKWKRVHIURP$GDE
>@ YDULRXVJLIWV 1LQJLߖNLPWLOQGDPHQVL:$GDENLNDNH<%DUDJQDPWDUUDGDP/XJDO$QGDHQVL:/DJDߖNL
NDUDNDPPDND>:%9:;@?;I?M?K$QHGDQXPHDOX:QL0DDOJDVXGGD9:;E?;BF@;@?;?%9:;EFN%
JDUPHQW 1LQJLߖNLPWLOQH0DDOJD9:;@?;J:9´:LWKWKHVHFRQGGHOLYHU\1LQJLVKNLPWLOWKHZLIHRI
WKHUXOHURI$GDEVHQW YDULRXVJLIWV WR%DUDJQDPWDUDZLIHRI/XJDO$QGDUXOHURI/DJDVK$QHGDQXPHD
KHUVHUYDQWZKRFDPHZLWK0DOJDVXGGHOLYHUHGWKHP1LQJLVKNLPWLOJDYH RQHJDUPHQW WR0DOJD VXG µ
57&LL²LY 

>@ PHWDOV %DUDJQDPWDUUDGDP/XJDO$QGDHQVL:/DJDߖNLNDNH<NDPPDND1LQJLߖNLPWLOQGDPHQVL:%

$GDENLNDUD>:%F;@?;I?M?K0DDOJDF;E?;BF@ JDUPHQWVDQGVFHQWHGRLO %DUDJQDPWDUUD$QHGD
QXPHDF;@?;J:9´:LWKWKHVHFRQG GHOLYHU\ %DUDJQDPWDUDZLIHRI/XJDO$QGDUXOHURI/DJDVKVHQW
PHWDOV WR1LQJLVKNLPWLOZLIHRIWKHUXOHURI$GDE0DOJD VXG FDPHZLWK $QHGDQXPHD %DUDJQDPWDUD
JDYH JDUPHQWVDQGVFHQWHGRLO WR$QHGDQXPHDµ 57&Y²YLL 
$VGHVFULEHGLQ>@&(FRPSOHPHQWV>1DQGFRPSOHWHVWKHVSHFWUXPWKDW>1EHJLQVUHSUHVHQWLQJLWVORZ
HQG&(DSSHDUVW\SLFDOO\ZKHQWKHGDWLYHDUJXPHQWEHORQJVWRWKHFODVVRI)6)MI!-06)0RULVVHPDQWLFDOO\VLPLODU
KF%)6)MI!-06)0ZKHQLWLVFROOHFWLYHRULQGHILQLWHRUZKHQLWLVDEVHQWDOWRJHWKHUEXWFDQRQLFDOO\H[SHFWHGDVLQ
´JLYH(9('µ+XPDQVGRQRWHPSDWKL]HZLWKWKLQJVFROOHFWLYHVDUHRIWHQJUDPPDWLFDOO\UHJDUGHGDV$+#)5OLNH
$QGKXPDQVQDWXUDOO\GRQRWHPSDWKL]HZLWKHQWLWLHVWKDWDUHQRQH[LVWHQW,QWKHSDUDOOHOFODXVHVJLYHQLQ>@
&(GRHVQRWFURVVUHIHUHQFHWKHLQDQLPDWHUHFLSLHQWWKHGRQNH\DVVRPHKDYHVXJJHVWHG&RUUHVSRQGLQJWRWKH
FURVVOLQJXLVWLFDOO\REVHUYHGWHQGHQF\IRUOHVVDQLPDWHREMHFWVWREHOHVVPDUNHGWKHGDWLYHFDVHLQIL[IRULQDQL
PDWHVLVVLPSO\]HURWKDWLV‫ۦ‬
>@ DQDJQDJ@:;@?;J:9;9:DQߖHDQDJQDJ@:;H?;J:9;9:´ 7KH0+1&.15(. ZRXOGQRWJLYH DQ#5#)1"1 
ZDWHUWRGULQN³KHZRXOGQRWHYHQJLYHDGRQNH\ZDWHUWRGULQNµ 8UXLQLPJLQDLL ² 
7KHFRUUHODWLRQRI>1ZLWKI!-06)0DQG&(ZLWK)6)MI!-06)0H[WHQGVEH\RQGWKHGDWLYHWRWKHRWKHUFDVH
LQÀ[HVRIWKHYHUE$VZLWKWKHGDWLYHWKHSUHÀ[RIWHQUHÁHFWVWKHGHJUHHRIDQLPDF\RIWKHSHULSKHUDODUJXPHQW
DVUHSUHVHQWHGE\WKHLPPHGLDWHO\IROORZLQJLQÀ[7KXVZKHQ(QOLOORRNVXSRQ1LQJLUVXDI!-06)ZLWKZKRPKH
HPSDWKL]HVWKHSUHÀ[LV>1>@EXWZKHQ*XGHDORRNVXSRQDFOD\SLWWKHSUHÀ[LV&(>@
>@ G
(QOLO:HHQ G1LQJLU:VX:ߖHQ%ABA]LG9:;>A;H?L´(QOLOORRNHGIDYRUDEO\XSRQWKHORUG1LQJLUVXµ *XGHD
&\O$L 

>@ NDDOELߖHQ%ABA]LGH?;>A;H?L´ *XGHD ORRNHGIDYRUDEO\XSRQWKHFOD\SLWµ *XGHD&\O$[LLL 

$OORIWKLVEULQJVXVEDFNWRWKHFRPPRQEDVLVIRUWKHIDUIOXQJXVHVRIWKHSUHIL[HVWKHIRUHPRVWEHLQJWKH
H[SUHVVLRQRIYRLFHDQGLQFOXGHVWKHVLJQDOLQJRIWKHDQLPDF\RI5(&,3,(176DQG%(1(),&,$5,(6:KHQMRLQHG
ZLWKSHULSKHUDODUJXPHQWV>1W\SLFDOO\VLJQDOVWKHLQFOXVLRQRIDKLJKO\DQLPDWHSDUWLFLSDQWLQWKHFODXVH³D
SDUWLFLSDQWZKRLVVHPDQWLFDOO\$*(17OLNHEXWQRWKLPVHOIWKH$*(17RIWKHHYHQW,QWKLVZD\DPRUSKHPH
WKDWLVFORVHO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWKDJHQF\LVH[WHQGHGIXQFWLRQDOO\WRPDUNWKHUHIHUHQWRIDQRWKHUDUJXPHQWZKLFK
LVVHPDQWLFDOO\LGHQWLFDORUQHDUO\VRWRWKH$*(173URWRW\SLFDOO\5(&,3,(176DQG%(1(),&,$5,(6DUHDQLPDWH
DVSURWRW\SLFDOO\LWLVDQLPDWHVWKDWUHJLVWHUWKHUHFHLSWVDQGEHQHÀWVRIDQHYHQW9LHZHGIURPWKLVSHUVSHFWLYH
&(VLJQDOVDVHYHUHGRZQJUDGLQJRIWKHSURWRW\SLFDOGDWLYHUHIHUHQWPXFKDVLWGRHVZLWKWKHDJHQWLQLWVGH
WUDQVLWLYL]LQJIXQFWLRQ,QGHHGWKLVGHJUDGDWLRQLVWKHFRPPRQJURXQGIRUWKHYRLFHDQGGDWLYHIXQFWLRQVRIWKH
SUHÀ[0RUHRYHU³DQGWKHSRLQWLVDQLPSRUWDQWRQH³ZLWKYHUEVWKDWDUHQDWXUDOO\PLGGOHOLNH51Qm"!:´DGGUHVV
VSHDNFDOOµWKHWZRIXQFWLRQVFDQEHVHHQDVFROODSVLQJWRJHWKHU$EVHQWDVDOLHQW(QGSRLQW³DQDQLPDWH5(&,3,
(17RU%(1(),&,$5<WKDWFDQUHJLVWHUWKHFRQVHTXHQFHVRIWKHDFWLRQ³WKHVXEMHFWKLPVHOIPD\EHSHUFHLYHGDV
WKH(QGSRLQWRIWKHHYHQWWKDWLVDVWKHORFXVRIWKHDFWLRQ·VSULQFLSDOHIIHFWVIRUH[DPSOH51Q³&("!:%MJ6H8HI%
´FDOORXWFDOOWRVWKµ$QGZLWKWKHSUHÀ[SUR[LPDOWRWKHYHUEDOURRWWKHOLNHOLKRRGWKDWLWZLOOLQWHUDFWGLUHFWO\
ZLWKWKHYHUEDOPHDQLQJVSHFLILFDOO\IXQFWLRQLQJDVDYRLFHPDUNHULVLQFUHDVHG7KHQRWLRQWKDWDQLPDWHWKDW
LVVHQWLHQW5(&,3,(176DQG%(1(),&,$5,(6DUHPRUHOLNHO\WRDEVRUEWKHHIIHFWVRIWKHDFWLRQWKDQLQDQLPDWHV
SDUDOOHOV³LQGHHGPD\EHVHHQDVDQH[WHQVLRQRI³WKHFULWLFDOGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQWKHDFWLYHDQGWKHPLGGOH
SDVVLYHYRLFHV,QWKHDFWLYH >1 DQ,QLWLDWRURULHQWHGQRWLRQWKHDIIHFWHGHQWLW\LVSURWRW\SLFDOO\GLVWLQFWIURP
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3OK/7*,@O8K%J,,H7

WKHVXEMHFWQDPHO\$6%"6%:6-%()6$+!-³LQWKHPLGGOHDQGSDVVLYH #>>(&( (QGSRLQWRULHQWHGQRWLRQVWKHDI

IHFWHGHQWLW\LVWKHVXEMHFWQDPHO\$6%"6%:6-%6)!0!.:,QWKLVZD\WKHHPSDWK\DQGYRLFHIXQFWLRQVRIWKHFRQMXJDWLRQ
SUHIL[HVILQGVWUXFWXUHZLWKLQWKHIUDPHZRUNRIWKHOLPLWVRIWKHHYHQWDVGHVFULEHGE\WKH,QLWLDWRUDQG(QGSRLQW
UROHV ILJ DQGLQWKHYDOXHVRIDJHQF\DQLPDF\FRQWURODQGVSDWLDOUHIHUHQFHWKDWDUHLFRQLFZLWKHDFK

OAH=APBL?Q<R
$OODQ5XWJHU-
% :??Q% *+!%A#"".!%T6#4!%#)%<)4#!)$%D-!!=g%<%7$1"'%#)%@6.'0!>'L$PVWHUGDP6WXGLHVLQ&ODVVLFDO3KLORORJ\
$PVWHUGDP-&*LHEHQ
%ODFN-HUHP\HWDO
 ² *+!%8.!4$-6)#4%*!]$%36-I10%6:%71>!-#()%N#$!-($1-! KWWSZZZHWFVORULHQWR[DFXN 2[IRUG2[
IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
%ODNH%DUU\-
% OPP<% 3(0!&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
%\EHH-RDQ/
  A6-I+6.65'g%<%7$1"'%6:%$+!%K!.($#6)%S!$9!!)%A!()#)5%()"%F6->L7\SRORJLFDO6WXGLHVLQ/DQJXDJH$P
VWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
&URIW:LOOLDP
% OPPO% 7')$(4$#4%3($!56-#!0%()"%D-(>>($#4(.%K!.($#6)0g%*+!%365)#$#?!%,-5()#G($#6)%6:%/):6->($#6)&KLFDJR8QL
YHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVV
'H/DQFH\6FRWW
  ´$Q,QWHUSUHWDWLRQRI6SOLW(UJDWLYLW\DQG5HODWHG3DWWHUQVµN()51(5!²
  ´$VSHFW7UDQVLWLYLW\DQG9LHZSRLQWµ,Q*!)0!M<0I!4$g%&!$9!!)%7!>()$#40%()"%@-(5>($#40HGLWHGE\3
-+RSSHUSS²7\SRORJLFDO6WXGLHVLQ/DQJXDJH$PVWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
'L[RQ5REHUW0:
% OPP<% 8-5($#?#$'L&DPEULGJH6WXGLHVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
(G]DUG'LHW]2WWR
  ´¶'XKDVWPLUJHJHEHQ·¶LFKKDEHGLUJHJHEHQ·hEHUGDVVXPHULVFKH9HUEXPVXPµ%H#!%J!.$%"!0%,-#M
!)$0²
)DUUHOO3DWULFN
% :??R% D-(>>($#4(.%K!.($#6)02[IRUG6XUYH\VLQ6\QWD[DQG0RUSKRORJ\2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
)ROH\:LOOLDP$DQG5REHUW'9DQ9DOLQ-U
  F1)4$#6)(.%7')$(]%()"%\)#?!-0(.%D-(>>(-L&DPEULGJH6WXGLHVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH
8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
)UD\QH'RXJODV5
  @-!0(-56)#4%@!-#6"%^noppqnrsp%SL3L`L5R\DO,QVFULSWLRQVRI0HVRSRWDPLD(DUO\3HULRGV7RURQWR8QL
YHUVLW\RI7RURQWR3UHVV
*UDJJ*HQH%
  ´/LQJXLVWLFV0HWKRGDQG([WLQFW/DQJXDJHV7KH&DVHRI6XPHULDQµ,-#!)$(.#(QV%²
+RSSHU3DXO-DQG6DQGUD$7KRPSVRQ
  ´7UDQVLWLYLW\LQ*UDPPDUDQG'LVFRXUVHµN()51(5!²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% *O8%3,BP\D<*/,B%@K8F/i872%*O8%H<*/T8%3<782%<BH%*O8%8A@<*OY%O/8K<K3OY%/B%7\A8K/<B% OP

.HPPHU6X]DQQH
% OPPQ% *+!%A#"".!%T6#4!L7\SRORJLFDO6WXGLHVLQ/DQJXDJH$PVWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
.XQR6XVXPX
  ´6XEMHFW7KHPHDQG6SHDNHU·V(PSDWK\³$5HH[DPLQDWLRQRI5HODWLYL]DWLRQ3KHQRPHQDµ,Q71&M
c!4$%()"%*6I#4HGLWHGE\&1/LSS²1HZ<RUN$FDGHPLF3UHVV
  F1)4$#6)(.%7')$(]g%<)(I+6-(2%H#0461-0!2%()"%8>I($+'&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVV
.XQR6XVXPXDQG(WVXNR.DEXUDNL
  ´(PSDWK\DQG6\QWD[µN#)51#0$#4%/)X1#-'²
/DQJDFNHU5RQDOG:
% OPPO% F61)"($#6)0%6:%365)#$#?!%D-(>>(-2%1F>LMJ%:N%H!04-#I$#?!%<II.#4($#6)6WDQIRUG6WDQIRUG8QLYHUVLW\
3UHVV
/\RQV-RKQ
  /)$-6"14$#6)%$6%*+!6-!$#4(.%N#)51#0$#40&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
3DOPHU)5
% OPP<% D-(>>($#4(.%K6.!0%()"%K!.($#6)0&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
6LOYHUVWHLQ0LFKDHO
  ´+LHUDUFK\RI)HDWXUHVDQG(UJDWLYLW\µ,QD-(>>($#4(.%3($!56-#!0%#)%<10$-(.#()%N()51(5!0HGLWHGE\5
0:'L[RQSS²/LQJXLVWLF6HULHV$WODQWLF+LJKODQGV+XPDQLWLHV3UHVV
7KXUHDX'DQJLQ)UDQoRLV
  ´6XUOHVSUpIL[HVGXYHUEHVXPpULHQµt!#$04+-#:$%:u-%<00'-#6.65#!²
9DQ9DOLQ5REHUW'-UDQG'DYLG3:LONLQV
  ´7KH&DVHIRU¶(IIHFWRU·&DVH5ROHV$JHQWVDQG$JHQF\5HYLVLWHGµ,QD-(>>($#4(.%36)0$-14$#6)0g%
*+!#-%F6->%()"%A!()#)5HGLWHGE\06KLEDWDQLDQG6$7KRPSVRQSS²2[IRUG2[IRUG
8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
:RRGV&KULVWRSKHU
  *+!%D-(>>(-%6:%@!-0I!4$#?!g%*+!%71>!-#()%36)c15($#6)%@-!:#]!0%(0%(%7'0$!>%6:%T6#4!L%"LHJ8GF7M%0FHF
JUDSKV/HLGHQ%ULOO
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% :O

!
"#$%&'()*+,$-&'(."&/$%&'("%0(+$%$1/-/"234((
#2"55"&/-"6(276$)(/%(8*22/"%

H!))#0%KL%AL%3(>I&!..2%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%3+#4(56

+XUULDQLVRQHRIWKHQRQ,QGR(XURSHDQDQGQRQ6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVRIWKHDQFLHQW1HDU(DVWSUHVHUYHGLQ
ZULWWHQIRUPIURPDSSUR[LPDWHO\WR%&O,WLVDKLJKO\DJJOXWLQDWLYHHUJDWLYHODQJXDJHZLWKDULFKV\V
WHPRIFDVHPRUSKRORJ\:$WSUHVHQWWKLUWHHQRUIRXUWHHQFDVHVKDYHEHHQGLVWLQJXLVKHGDOWKRXJKWKLVQXPEHU
LQFOXGHVDSSDUHQWH[DPSOHVRIFRPSRXQGFDVHVQ2IWKHVHFDVHVWKHPDMRULW\DUHREOLTXHRULQKHUHQWW\SLFDOO\
LQGLFDWLQJVSDWLDOGHL[HV<,QWKLVSDSHU,OLPLWP\VWXG\WRWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVDQGWKHLUFRUUHVSRQGLQJPRU
SKRORJ\ LHFDVH ZKLFKILJXUHDVWKHFRUHV\QWDFWLFDUJXPHQWVRIDFODXVH $JHQW6XEMHFWDQG3DWLHQW 7KLV
LQFOXGHVWKHVWXG\RIWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVDPRQJWKHVHUROHV,WZLOOEHGHPRQVWUDWHGWKDW+XUULDQDOORZV
DFHUWDLQDPRXQWRIYDULDELOLW\LQWKHPRUSKRORJLFDOUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRIJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVLQRUGHUWRILOOFHUWDLQ
V\QWDFWLFDQGRUSUDJPDWLFQHHGV
7KHUHLVDFHUWDLQDPRXQWRIDPELJXLW\ZLWKLQOLQJXLVWLFOLWHUDWXUHEHWZHHQQRWLRQDORUVHPDQWLFUROHVJUDP
PDWLFDOUROHVJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVDQGFDVH1RXQVLQDQ\ODQJXDJHKDYHRQHRIDQXPEHURIQRWLRQDORUVH
PDQWLFUROHVGHSHQGLQJXSRQWKHLUVWDWXVLQDFODXVH$QRXQWKDWLVWKHVXEMHFWRIDWUDQVLWLYHYHUELVRIWHQFDOOHG
DQDJHQW\HWZLWKYDULRXVYHUEVLWGRHVQRWKDYHWKHDFWXDOQRWLRQDOUROHRIDJHQWEXWLVSHUKDSVDQH[SHULHQFHU
SHUFHLYHUHIIHFWRURUDQ\RQHRIDQXPEHURIGLIIHUHQWUROHVR7KHVLWXDWLRQLVMXVWDVFRPSOH[ZLWKQRXQVLQSD
WLHQWSRVLWLRQZKHUHWKH\PD\EHSDWLHQWH[SHULHQFHGSHUFHLYHGFRQWUROOHGDQGVRRQ*UDPPDWLFDOUROHVDUH
PRUHOLPLWHGLQQXPEHUEHLQJGHWHUPLQHGE\WKHJUDPPDWLFDOIRUPVLQDSDUWLFXODUODQJXDJH7KH\DUHWKHUHIRUH
ODQJXDJHVSHFLILFZKLOHQRWLRQDOUROHVDUHXQLYHUVDO)XUWKHUPRUHQRWLRQDOUROHVDUH´H[SRQHQWVµRIJUDPPDWL
FDOUROHVDQGWKHUHLVDOPRVWQHYHUDRQHWRRQHFRUUHVSRQGHQFHEHWZHHQJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVDQGQRWLRQDOUROHV
WKHUHW\SLFDOO\EHLQJDQXPEHURIQRWLRQDOUROHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDQ\RQHJUDPPDWLFDOUROH7KHUHLVRIWHQDGH
JUHHRIRYHUODSEHWZHHQJUDPPDWLFDODQGQRWLRQDOUROHV)RUH[DPSOHWKHQRWLRQDOUROHVRIDJHQWDQGSDWLHQWDUH
WKHSURWRW\SLFDOIXQFWLRQVRIWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHV$JHQWDQG3DWLHQW,QRUGHUWRHOLPLQDWHSRVVLEOHFRQIXVLRQ

O
7KHOLQJXLVWLFDIILOLDWLRQRI+XUULDQLVDORQJGHEDWHGLVVXH7KH
PRVWFRPPRQWKHRU\LVWKDW+XUULDQ DQGLWVVLVWHUODQJXDJH8UDU
WLDQ LVVRPHKRZUHODWHGWRWKH&DXFDVLDQODQJXDJHV 'LDNRQRIIDQG
6WDURVWLQ:HJQHU² 2QWKHHDUO\KLVWRU\RIWKH+XU
ULDQVLQWKHDQFLHQW1HDU(DVWVHH6DOYLQL6WHLQNHOOHU
:LOKHOP²
7KH IROORZLQJ DEEUHYLDWLRQV DUH XVHG LQ WKLV SDSHU $%/
,167 DEODWLYHLQVWUXPHQWDO  $%6 DEVROXWLYH  $%67 DEVWUDFW 
$&7 DFWLYH  $'9 DGYHUELDO  $* DJHQW  $*5 DJUHHPHQW  $3
DQWLSDVVLYH &20 FRPLWDWLYH '$7 GDWLYH ',5 GLUHFWLYH '1
GLYLQH QDPH  (1&/ HQFOLWLF  (3(17+ HSHQWKHWLF YRZHO  (5*
HUJDWLYH  (66 HVVLYH  *(1 JHQLWLYH  ,03 LPSHUDWLYH  ,1'
LQGLFDWLYH  ,175$1 LQWUDQVLWLYH  -866 MXVVLYH  02' PRGDO 
1(* QHJDWLYH 237 RSWDWLYH 3$7 SDWLHQWLYH 3(5) SHUIHFW 3/
SOXUDO 31 SHUVRQDOQDPH 3266 SRVVHVVLYH 327 SRWHQWLDO 
35(7 SUHWHULWH  5(/ UHODWLYH  5(/$7 UHODWRU  6* VLQJXODU 
67$7 VWDWLYH 75$1 WUDQVLWLYH $OORWKHUDEEUHYLDWLRQVIROORZWKH
FRQYHQWLRQVRIWKH3+#4(56%O#$$#$!%H#4$#6)(-'
:
+XUULDQKDVORQJUHFHLYHGDWOHDVWSDVVLQJLQWHUHVWIURPVFKRODUVRI
WKHDQFLHQW1HDU(DVW:RUNRQGHFLSKHULQJWKLVODQJXDJHEHJDQRYHU
RQHKXQGUHG\HDUVDJR 0HVVHUVFKPLGW DQGJUDPPDUVZHUH
VRRQSXEOLVKHG )ULHGULFK6SHLVHU%XVK)ULHGULFK
 6LQFHWKHSXEOLFDWLRQRIWKH+XUUR+LWWLWHELOLQJXDOGLVFRYHUHG
DWWKH+LWWLWHFDSLWDORI+DWWXVDLQWKHV HG1HX VHYHUDO
QHZJUDPPDUVKDYHDSSHDUHG *LRUJLHUL:HJQHU:LOKHOP
+D]HQERV:HJQHU 2QFDVHPRUSKRORJ\LQ+XUULDQ
VHHDOVR*LRUJLHUL
Q
)RUH[DPSOHWKHDEODWLYH–"()PD\EHDFRPSRXQGRIWKHGLUHFWLYH
–"(DEODWLYHLQVWUXPHQWDO–) # 6HH*LRUJLHUL:HJQHU
²2QHUJDWLYLW\LQJHQHUDOVHH'L[RQ
<
$IHZFDVHVKDYHFRPSDUDWLYHIXQFWLRQV7KHHVVLYHLVRQHRIWKH
PRVWYDULDEOHFDVHVLQ+XUULDQFRYHULQJDYDULHW\RIJUDPPDWLFDO
UROHV$ORQJZLWKLQGLFDWLQJPRYHPHQWLQWRLWIXQFWLRQVDVDFRP
SDUDWLYH HJPDJčQQZ#@–(´OLNHDJLIWµ>0LWWLLL@*LRUJLHUL
² 7KHHQGLQJ–Rঈ RUSHUKDSV–6–ঈDVSHU*LRUJLHUL 
IXQFWLRQVDVDQHTXDWLYHNčঈ # –‫گ‬ঈ´OLNHDFXSµ .%RL 7KH
HQGLQJV–(!DQG–))#DQG–)) # –(DOVRKDYHDGYHUELDOIXQFWLRQV
*LRUJLHUL²:HJQHU:LOKHOP 
R
3DOPHU²9DQ9DOLQDQG/D3ROOD²

7KLVLVWKHGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVDQGQRWLRQDO
UROHVPDGHE\3DOPHU ² ,IROORZWKLVPRGHOWKURXJKRXW
WKLVDUWLFOH

:O
 oi.uchicago.edu

::% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

EHWZHHQWKHWZRJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVDUHH[SUHVVHGE\HLWKHUFDSLWDOOHWWHUVRUVLQJOHFDSLWDOOHWWHUDEEUHYLDWLRQV
VHHEHORZ ZKLOHQRWLRQDOUROHVDUHVSHOOHGRXWLQORZHUFDVH
&DVHLVWKHPRUSKRORJLFDOPDUNLQJRQDQRXQWKDWGHILQHVLWVUHODWLRQVKLSWRLWVKHDGW\SLFDOO\DSUHGLFDWH@%
7KHFRUUHVSRQGHQFHEHWZHHQJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVDQGFDVHLVFRPSOH[*UDPPDWLFDOUROHVDUHQRWXVXDOO\OLPLWHG
WRDQ\RQHFDVHEXWFDQPRYHEHWZHHQFDVHVDVUHTXLUHGE\V\QWD[DQGRUGLVFRXUVH7DNHIRUH[DPSOHWKH
JUDPPDWLFDOUROHRI3DWLHQW,QDQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHODQJXDJHWKH3DWLHQWLVW\SLFDOO\LQWKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVH
7KURXJKSDVVLYL]DWLRQKRZHYHUWKHJUDPPDWLFDO3DWLHQWLVSURPRWHGWRWKHVXEMHFWSRVLWLRQDQGLVSODFHGLQWKH
QRPLQDWLYHFDVH$OWKRXJKWKH1RXQ3KUDVH 13 KDVFKDQJHGFDVHVLWVJUDPPDWLFDOUROHUHPDLQVWKDWRI3DWLHQW
,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHFKDQJHRIFDVHLVQRWDFFRPSDQLHGE\DFRUUHVSRQGLQJFKDQJHLQJUDPPDWLFDOUROHV7KHVLWX
DWLRQLVQRGLIIHUHQWLQ+XUULDQZKHUHDVLWZLOOEHVKRZQWKHUHLVDGHJUHHRIIOH[LELOLW\EHWZHHQJUDPPDWLFDO
UROHVDQGWKHFDVHVXVHGWRH[SUHVVWKHP VHHWDEOHDQGH[DPSOH>@EHORZ 
'L[RQLQKLVVHPLQDOZRUNRQHUJDWLYLW\SURSRVHGDV\VWHPRIWKUHHSULPLWLYHVDPRQJWKHZRUOG·VODQJXDJHV
$JHQW $ 6XEMHFW 6 RIDQLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEPDQG3DWLHQW 3 O?7KHVHSULPLWLYHVDUHLGHQWLFDOWRWKHEDVLFJUDP
PDWLFDOUROHVIRXQGLQDOOODQJXDJHV'L[RQ·VPRGHOVKRXOGKRZHYHUSHUKDSVEHH[SDQGHG7KH613FDQDFWXDOO\
EHGLYLGHGEHWZHHQWKRVH13VZKLFKDUHPRUHDJHQWOLNHYHUVXVWKRVHZKLFKDUHPRUHSDWLHQWOLNHOO)RUWKLVUHD
VRQDIXUWKHUGLVWLQFWLRQRI6!DQG65FDQDQGSHUKDSVVKRXOGEHPDGHO:%'F7%MF9K%>6HIL6IJ92%$!DQG65DUHWUHDWHG
WKHVDPHDQGFDQVLPSO\EHUHIHUUHGWRDV6 LH6! 65 6RPHODQJXDJHVKRZHYHUGRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHWZHHQWKH
WZR7KHVHODQJXDJHVDUHGHILQHGDVHLWKHU6SOLWRU)OXLG6ODQJXDJHVOQRUDFWLYHODQJXDJHVO<,Q+XUULDQERWK6!%
DQG65DUHLQWKH–‘DEVROXWLYHFDVHPHDQLQJWKDWRQHFDQVLPSO\VSHDNRI6LQWKLVODQJXDJH+XUULDQGRHVKRZ
HYHUDSSHDUWRGLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQDFWLYHLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVDQGWKRVHZKLFKDUHSDWLHQWLYHRUVWDWLYH VHHEHORZ 
$VPHQWLRQHG+XUULDQLVDKLJKO\HUJDWLYHODQJXDJH,QEULHIHUJDWLYLW\UHTXLUHVWKDW613VEHWUHDWHGOLNH3
13VZKLOH$13VDUHWUHDWHGGLIIHUHQWO\OR,Q+XUULDQWKLVLVGLVWLQJXLVKHGWKURXJKFDVHPRUSKRORJ\ZLWKERWK6
DQG3EHLQJPDUNHGE\WKH–‘DEVROXWLYH SOXUDO–)( DQG$E\WKHHUJDWLYHFDVH–ঈ7KHVHDUHWKHWZRSULPDU\
FDVHVIRUWKHWZRFRUHDUJXPHQWVVXEMHFWDQGGLUHFWREMHFW ZLWKVXEMHFWEHLQJVXEGLYLGHGLQWR$JHQWDQG6XEMHFW
HDFKZLWKGLIIHUHQWFDVH 7KHDEVROXWLYHFDVHZKLOHFRQVLVWHQWO\XVHGIRU6LVQRWWKHRQO\FDVHIRU313V'H
SHQGLQJRQYRLFHRURWKHUV\QWDFWLFSUDJPDWLFUHTXLUHPHQWVWKH3DWLHQWFDQDOWHUQDWHO\EHRPLWWHGRUGHPRWHG
WRWKHHVVLYHFDVH –( O@7KHDEVROXWLYHFDQDOVREHXVHGWRPDUN$LQFHUWDLQVLWXDWLRQV
7KHUROHRIWKH'DWLYH%HQHILFLDU\ % KDVUHFHLYHGOLWWOHIRFXVLQSDVWVWXGLHVRI+XUULDQ:KLOHWKHGDWLYH
–?(W–9( DQGGLUHFWLYH –"( FDVHVDUHW\SLFDOO\XVHGWRLQGLFDWHWKHVSDWLDOJRDORIDQDFWLRQWKH\SOD\DIDU
PRUHLPSRUWDQWUROHLQ+XUULDQWKDQGRWKHRWKHUREOLTXHFDVHVOP,WLVVKRZQEHORZWKDWLQYDULRXVFLUFXPVWDQFHV
WKH13LQWKHUROHRI%FDQEHSURPRWHGWRWKHDEVROXWLYHWKURXJKGDWLYHVKLIWLQGLFDWLQJWKDWLWVUROHLVFORVHU
WRWKDWRIDFRUHDUJXPHQWWKDQDSHULSKHUDORQH:?7KLVSURPRWLRQWRDEVROXWLYHGRHVQRWRFFXUZLWKDQ\RWKHU
REOLTXHFDVHV

@
%ODNH OR
2QHUJDWLYLW\LQJHQHUDOVHH'L[RQ

7DNHWKHIROORZLQJ*HUPDQVHQWHQFH´'HU0DQQW|WHWGHQ:ROIµ 
(UJDWLYLW\LQ+XUULDQLVDOVRLQGLFDWHGWKURXJKYHUEDODJUHHPHQW
7KH3DWLHQW´GHQ:ROIµLVLQWKHDFFXVDWLYHDVLQGLFDWHGE\WKH VWUDWHJLHV,QWKHWUDQVLWLYHWKHYHUEDJUHHVZLWK$E\XVLQJPRU
PDVFXOLQHDFFXVDWLYHDUWLFOH"!),QWKHSDVVLYH3LVPRYHGWRVXEMHFW SKRORJ\WKDWLVXQLTXHWR$DJUHHPHQW VHHEHORZ 7KHUHLVQR6
SRVLWLRQDQGLVLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGWKHDJHQWLVHLWKHUREOLTXHRU DJUHHPHQWZLWKLQWUDQVLWLYHRUDQWLSDVVLYHYHUEV7KHILQDO–&LQ2OG
RPLWWHG´'HU:ROIZXUGH YRP0DQQ JHW|WHWµ +XUULDQLVQRWDQDJUHHPHQWPDUNHU FRQWUD:HJQHU²
P
3DOPHUVXJJHVWVWKDW6VKRXOGSHUKDSVVWDQGIRU6LQJOHDUJXPHQW :LOKHOPD:LOKHOP ,WLVIRXQGZLWKDOOSHUVRQV
RIDQLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUELQRUGHUWRDYRLGFRQIXVLRQVLQFH´VXEMHFWµLV DQGPXVWKDYHDGLIIHUHQWIXQFWLRQ &DPSEHOOEWKHUH,DUJXH
RIWHQXVHGIRUERWK6DQG$HVSHFLDOO\ZLWKQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYH WKDWLWLVDJUDPPDWLFDOL]HGDJUHHPHQWPDUNHUWKDWDJUHHVZLWKDOO
ODQJXDJHV  :KLOHWKLVZRXOGEHLGHDO6LVW\SLFDOO\WDNHQ SHUVRQVDQGQXPEHUVDQGWKLVIXQFWLRQLVQRWOLNHO\WREHFRUUHFW
DV6XEMHFWLQOLQJXLVWLFOLWHUDWXUH VHHQRWHEHORZ 
O?
'L[RQ
O@
2QWKHHVVLYHVHH+DDVDQG:LOKHOP²DQG:HJQHU
OO
1RWHWKHEDVLFGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKH613VRI´-RKQZHQWµDQG IRUIXUWKHUELEOLRJUDSK\
´-RKQJUHZµRU´-RKQZDVVDGµ,QWKHILUVWH[DPSOHWKH613LVWKH

3DOPHU²
FRQWUROOHURIWKHDFWLRQDQGWKHUHIRUHPRUHDJHQWOLNHZKLOHLQWKH OP
7KHGDWLYH –9l?( DQGGLUHFWLYH –"( DUHFOHDUO\PRUSKRORJLFDOO\
ODWWHUWZRLWLVDQXQGHUJRHUWKDWHLWKHULVLQDVWDWHRUFKDQJHVRQH GLVWLQFWFDVHVEXWWKHUHLVD SRVVLEO\KLJK GHJUHHRIRYHUODSLQIXQF
DQGLVWKHUHIRUHSDWLHQWOLNH WLRQEHWZHHQWKHWZR7KLVLVDVXEMHFWWKDWUHTXLUHVIXUWKHUVWXG\
O:
0DQQLQJ² :?
$OUHDG\LQ:LOKHOPQRWHGVRPHH[DPSOHVRIDSRVVLEOHGDWLYH
OQ
'L[RQ² VKLIWZLWKRXWH[SODLQLQJWKHPHFKDQLVPVIRUWKLVSURFHVV  
O<
0LWKXQ 0RUHRQWKLVLVJLYHQEHORZ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% :Q

7KHVLWXDWLRQLQ+XUULDQFDQEULHIO\EHVXPPDUL]HGDVIROORZV7KHFRUHDUJXPHQWVRI$6DQG3KDYHWKH
SULPDU\FDVHPDUNLQJVRIHUJDWLYHDQGDEVROXWLYH7KHHUJDWLYHFDVHLVOLPLWHGWRWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHRI$JHQW
EXWWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHRI$JHQWLVQRWOLPLWHGWRWKHHUJDWLYHFDVH7KHDEVROXWLYHFRYHUVDEURDGHUVSHFWUXP
GHSHQGLQJXSRQYRLFHRUSUDJPDWLFVDQGFDQPDUN$63RU%7KHREOLTXHHVVLYHZKLOHW\SLFDOO\LQGLFDWLQJ
HLWKHUPRYHPHQWLQRUIXQFWLRQLQJDVDFRPSDUDWLYHLVWKHFDVHWRZKLFKWKHSDWLHQWLVGHPRWHGWKURXJKHLWKHU
WKHGHWUDQVLWLYL]DWLRQRIWKHYHUERUGDWLYHVKLIW7KH%HQHILFLDU\LVXVXDOO\IRXQGLQWKHGDWLYHRUGLUHFWLYHFDVH
EXWFDQXQGHUFHUWDLQFLUFXPVWDQFHVEHSURPRWHGWRGLUHFWREMHFWSRVLWLRQ7KHUHODWLRQDPRQJJUDPPDWLFDO
UROHVFDVHDQGQRWLRQDOUROHVLVJLYHQLQWDEOH

7DEOH*UDPPDWLFDOUROHVDQGPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHLQ+XUULDQ

6
7KHGDWLYHDQGGLUHFWLYHDOVRKDYHWKHIXQFWLRQRILQGLFDWLQJPRWLRQWRZDUGDSODFH%
,QWKLVXVHWKH13LQWKHGDWLYHFDQQRWEHSURPRWHG

7KHFRPSOH[LQWHUDFWLRQDPRQJFDVHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVDQGQRWLRQDOUROHVLVDOWHUQDWLYHO\LOOXVWUDWHGLQ>@
EHORZ7KHVROLGOLQHVEHWZHHQFDVHDQGJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVLQGLFDWHWKHSULPDU\FDVHIRUHDFKUROHZKLOHGDVKHG
OLQHVDUHXVHGWRLQGLFDWHWKHFDVHVWRZKLFKDJUDPPDWLFDOUROHFDQEHSURPRWHGRUGHPRWHG$VDPSOLQJRIYDULRXV
QRWLRQDOUROHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVRI$6 GLYLGHGKHUHLQWRLWVWZRFRQVWLWXHQWSDUWV6!DQG
$5 3DQG%LVDOVRJLYHQ´*UROHVµVWDQGVIRU´JUDPPDWLFDOUROHVµDQG´1UROHVµIRU´QRWLRQDOUROHVµ7KHH[DFW
FRUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQFDVHVDQGJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVDVLQGLFDWHGE\WDEOHDQG>@DUHH[SORUHGLQGHWDLOEHORZ

*UDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVGHWHUPLQHWKHZD\LQZKLFKYDULRXVJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVLQWHUDFW,QDQRPLQDWLYH
DFFXVDWLYHODQJXDJH$DQG6DUHERWKLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHZKLOH3LVLQWKHDFFXVDWLYH,WFDQWKHUHIRUHEHVDLGWKDW
WKHSULPDU\JUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQLVEHWZHHQ$DQG6 RUWKDW$ 6 DQG3LVDVHFRQGDU\UHODWLRQ:O7KHVLWXDWLRQ
LVGLIIHUHQWLQHUJDWLYHODQJXDJHVZKHUH6DQG3DUHWUHDWHGDVWKHVDPHDQG$LVGLIIHUHQW7KHUHIRUHLQHUJDWLYH
ODQJXDJHVZHILQGWKDWWKHSULPDU\UHODWLRQLV6 3ZKLOH$LVWKHVHFRQGDU\UHODWLRQ
&HUWDLQV\QWDFWLFWUDQVIRUPDWLRQVDOORZWKHVHFRQGDU\UHODWLRQWREHPDGHHTXLYDOHQWWRWKHSULPDU\RQHV::%
7ZRRIWKHPRVWFRPPRQPHFKDQLVPVUHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKLVVKLIWRIUHODWLRQVDUHWKHSDVVLYHDQGWKHDQWLSDVVLYH

3DOPHU²
:O
EHDFFRPSOLVKHGWKURXJKZRUGRUGHU,QODQJXDJHVWKDWXVHFDVHPRU
7KLVFDQEHGRQHWKURXJKDYDULHW\RIPHFKDQLVPVGHSHQGLQJ
:: SKRORJ\WKHVHFRQGDU\UHODWLRQLVSODFHGLQWKHVDPHFDVHWKDWLV
XSRQWKHODQJXDJH)RUODQJXDJHVZLWKRXWFDVHPRUSKRORJ\WKLVFDQ W\SLFDOO\XVHGE\WKHSULPDU\RQHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

:<% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

,QWKHIRUPHU3LVSODFHGLQVXEMHFWSRVLWLRQDQGLVLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHFDVH LQFDVHPDUNLQJODQJXDJHV ,QWKH

DQWLSDVVLYH$LVLQWKHDEVROXWLYHDQGQRWLQWKHHUJDWLYHDQGLVWKXVDGHULYHGSULPDU\UHODWLRQ7KLVPRYHPHQWRI
WKHVHFRQGDU\UHODWLRQWRDSULPDU\RQHLVFRQVLGHUHGWREHSURPRWLRQ&RQYHUVHO\WKHPRYHPHQWRXWRIDSULPDU\
UHODWLRQ HLWKHULQWRDQREOLTXHRQHRURPLWWHG LVWREHWDNHQDVGHPRWLRQ,QWKHSDVVLYHZHILQGSURPRWLRQRI3
WRDSULPDU\UHODWLRQDQGWKHVXEVHTXHQWGHPRWLRQRI$WRDQREOLTXH RUFRPSOHWHRPLVVLRQ ,QWKHDQWLSDVVLYH
$LVSURPRWHGWRDSULPDU\UHODWLRQDQG3LVGHPRWHG:Q7KHEDVLFJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVLQQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYH
DQGHUJDWLYHODQJXDJHVDUHJLYHQLQ>D@DQGWKHSDVVLYHDQWLSDVVLYHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQVLQ>E@

>@ D QRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYH $ 63

 HUJDWLYH 6 3$
 E SDVVLYH 6 3$
 DQWLSDVVLYH $ 63

1RHUJDWLYHODQJXDJHLVHQWLUHO\HUJDWLYHLQPRUSKRORJ\RUV\QWD[,QDOONQRZQHUJDWLYHODQJXDJHVWKHUH
LVDVSOLWZKHUHWKHODQJXDJHQRORQJHUIXQFWLRQVDVDQHUJDWLYHODQJXDJH :<7KLV´VSOLWµHUJDWLYLW\PHDQVWKDW
GHSHQGLQJXSRQWKHFODXVHDQHUJDWLYHODQJXDJHGLVSOD\VWZRVHWVRIJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQV$VDKLJKO\HUJD
WLYHODQJXDJH+XUULDQODUJHO\RSHUDWHVZLWKWKHVHWRIUHODWLRQV6 3$LQWKHLQGLFDWLYH:KLOHSULPDULO\DOVR
IXQFWLRQLQJDORQJHUJDWLYHOLQHVLQWKHPRGDOV\VWHPWKHUHLVFOHDUHYLGHQFHIRUDVSOLWLQFHUWDLQQRQLQGLFDWLYH
IRUPV,QWKHVHPRRGVZHILQGDQHZVHWRIUHODWLRQVZKHUH$ 6 3DQGDOODUHLQWKHDEVROXWLYHFDVH,WLVVKRZQ
EHORZWKDWGHVSLWHWKHIDFWWKDWDOOWKUHHUROHVDUHLQWKHDEVROXWLYH3LVWUHDWHGVRPHZKDWGLIIHUHQWO\DQGLWPD\
EHWKDWWKHSULPDU\UHODWLRQLV$ 6DQG3LVDFWXDOO\DVHFRQGDU\UHODWLRQ7KHYDULRXVJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVLQ
+XUULDQLQFOXGLQJDOWHUQDWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVWKDWPRGLI\WKHVHUHODWLRQVDUHJLYHQLQWDEOH

7DEOH*UDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVLQ+XUULDQ

T!-&%*'I! @-#>(-'%K!.($#6) 7!46)"(-'%K!.($#6) <.$!-)($#?!

$6 %3!HVVLYH
,QGLFDWLYHVRPHPRGDOIRUPV 6 3 DEVROXWLYH $ HUJDWLYH
$QWLSDVVLYH$!‘3!HVVLYH
6HYHUDOPRGDOIRUPV $ 6 3  DEVROXWLYH SHUKDSV3 $ DEVROXWLYH 3!HVVLYH

$VGHPRQVWUDWHGLQWDEOHDOWHUQDWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVWRWKRVHLQWKHSULPDU\UHODWLRQFROXPQVH[LVWLQ
+XUULDQ,QWKHLQGLFDWLYHWKHDQWLSDVVLYHYRLFHSURPRWHVWKHHUJDWLYH$13WRWKHDEVROXWLYHZKLOHGHPRWLQJ3
E\HLWKHURPLWWLQJLWRUSODFLQJLWLQWKHREOLTXHHVVLYH+XUULDQDOVRH[KLELWVGDWLYHVKLIWZKHUH% W\SLFDOO\DQ
DQLPDWH13LQWKHGDWLYHRUGLUHFWLYHFDVH LVSURPRWHGWRWKHDEVROXWLYH7KLVSURPRWLRQRI%WRDEVROXWLYHUHVXOWV
LQWKHGHPRWLRQRI3WRWKHHVVLYH VHHEHORZ 

"9:;<
,Q+XUULDQ$13VFRUUHVSRQGWRWKRVHQRXQVPDUNHGE\WKHHUJDWLYHLQDFWLYHWUDQVLWLYHFODXVHVDQGE\WKH
DEVROXWLYHLQDQWLSDVVLYHDQGFHUWDLQPRGDOFRQVWUXFWLRQV7KHSULPDU\QRWLRQDOUROHDWWULEXWHGWR$LVWKDWRI
DJHQWEXWWKLVLVE\QRPHDQVWKHRQO\RQH)RUH[DPSOH$FDQDOVREHDSHUFHLYHUZLWKYHUEVRISHUFHSWLRQVXFK
DVZLWKWKHYHUE:6-´WRVHHµDPRQJRWKHUQRWLRQDOUROHV7KH$13LVRIWHQWKHLQLWLDWRURIDQDFWLRQEHLWSK\VL
FDOVXFKDVZLWK$()´WRPDNHµDQGI(kk´WRVHQGµRUPHQWDOPHWDSK\VLFDOVXFKDVI(.´WRNQRZµ1-´WRGHVLUHµ
DQG+઄Dঈ´WRKHDUµ$FRPPRQWKHPHDPRQJWKHQRWLRQDOUROHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKH$JHQWLVWKDWRIFDXVDWLRQ:R%
7KLVOLQNZLWKFDXVDWLRQLVVXSSRUWHGE\WKHIDFWWKDW$13VDUHODUJHO\OLPLWHGWRDQLPDWHRUDQWKURSRPRUSKL]HG

:Q
,EHOLHYHWKDW:HJQHUJRHVWRRIDULQVHSDUDWLQJRXWWKRVHDQWLSDV WKHFODXVHLWLVGHOHWHG7KLVLVQRGLIIHUHQWIURPWKHGHPRWLRQRI$
VLYHYHUEVZLWKH[SUHVVHGDQGGHPRWHG3IURPWKRVHZLWKRPLWWHG LQSDVVLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
3LQ+XUULDQ7KHVHDUHQRWWZRVHSDUDWHDQWLSDVVLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQV :<
'L[RQ
3LVH[SUHVVHG DOEHLWLQWKHHVVLYHFDVH ZKHQLWLVQHFHVVDU\IRU :R
3DOPHU
GLVFRXUVH,QWKRVHFDVHVZKHUH3LVVHHQDVYHU\XQLPSRUWDQWIRU
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% :R

LQDQLPDWH13V7KHODWWHUDUHSULPDULO\IRXQGLQWKHSDUDEOHWH[WV.%RDQG.%RRIWKH+XUUR+LWWLWH
ELOLQJXDODQG+XUULDQP\WKLFDOWH[WVIURP%RОD]NDOH
$VPHQWLRQHGWKHPRVWFRPPRQUHDOL]DWLRQRIWKH$JHQWLVDVWKHHUJDWLYHFDVH –ঈ 13RIDQDFWLYHLQGLFDWLYH
YHUE,QPRVWODQJXDJHVWKDWKDYHDQHUJDWLYHFDVHLWQRWRQO\PDUNVWKH$13EXWDOVRKDVDQREOLTXHIXQFWLRQ
VXFKDVLQVWUXPHQWDORUJHQLWLYH:@7KHUHLVDVRI\HWQRFOHDUHYLGHQFHIRUVXFKDQREOLTXHIXQFWLRQIRUWKH+XU
ULDQHUJDWLYHDOWKRXJKLWLVSRVVLEOHLIQRWOLNHO\WKDWVXFKDXVHIRUWKLVFDVHZLOOEHGLVFRYHUHG
,QWKHLQGLFDWLYH+XUULDQVWULFWO\FRQIRUPVWRHUJDWLYHPRUSKRORJ\7KDWLVWKH$13RIDGL RUWUL YDOHQW
YHUEUHJDUGOHVVRIERWKLWVSODFHLQWKHQRPLQDOKLHUDUFK\DQGWKHWHQVHDVSHFWRIWKHYHUEPXVWEHLQWKHHUJD
WLYH7KHUHLVQRHYLGHQFHIRUGDWLYHRURWKHUFDVH$13VLQ+XUULDQ:P
7KHUHLVDFRQVLGHUDEOHGLIIHUHQFHLQYHUEPRUSKRORJ\EHWZHHQ2OG+XUULDQDQG0LWWDQL+XUULDQQ?%&HJ%FG%
WKHPDLQGLVVLPLODULWLHVEHWZHHQWKHWZRLVLQWHQVHDVSHFWPDUNLQJ0LWWDQL+XUULDQGLVWLQJXLVKHVDPRQJWKUHH
WHQVHVXQPDUNHGSUHVHQWIXWXUHLQ–!"DQGSUHWHULWLQ–RঈQO2OG+XUULDQGRHVQRWGLVWLQJXLVKWHQVHVOLNH0LWWDQL
+XUULDQ7KHV\VWHPLVXQFOHDUEXWPD\EHDVSHFWXDOQ:$OWKRXJKPRUHZRUNLVUHTXLUHG,SUHIHUWRWHQWDWLYHO\
ODEHOWKH2OG+XUULDQIRUPVLQ–6 – DQG–‘–%F7%–#–DVSHUIHFWLYHDQGLPSHUIHFWLYHUHVSHFWLYHO\
'HVSLWHWKHVHGLIIHUHQFHVLQYHUEDOPRUSKRORJ\EHWZHHQ2OGDQG0LWWDQL+XUULDQERWKVKDUHWKHFRPPRQ
FKDUDFWHULVWLFRIPDUNLQJDJUHHPHQWZLWK$DQGQRWZLWK3RQWKHYHUE,QWKH2OG+XUULDQSHUIHFWLYHWKLUGVLQ
JXODU$13VDUHFURVVUHIHUHQFHGRQWKHYHUEWKURXJKWKHPRUSKHPH–>DIWHUWKHYDOHQFHPDUNHU–6 – QQ%!I7JJ
PHQWZLWKSOXUDO$13VLVPDUNHGE\WKHPRUSKHPH–#"–,ZKLFKRFFXUVLPPHGLDWHO\EHIRUHWKH–6PRUSKHPHQ<%


(GLWHGE\1HX  7KHXVHRIDQWKURSRPRUSKL]HGLQDQLPDWHV SUHVHUYHG+XUULDQWH[WVEXWZKHQLWGRHVRFFXULWGRHVQRWKDYH
DV$13VFDQDOVREHIRXQGLQWKH+XUULDQP\WKRORJLFDOWH[WVIRXQG WKHPRUSKHPH–#–7KHELOLQJXDOWH[W.%RH[KLELWVYHU\ROG
DWWKH+LWWLWHFDSLWDORI+DWWXVD)RUWUDQVFULSWLRQVRIWKHVHWH[WVVHH IHDWXUHV SHUIHFWLYHVLQ–6Z–@WKHXVHRI–&ZLWKLQWUDQVLWLYHDQGDQ
6DOYLQLDQG:HJQHU WLSDVVLYHYHUEV ,PSHUIHFWLYHWKLUGVLQJXODUIRUPVLQFOXGHk#"–čU–(%
:@
%ODNH 8H%Ҹk–Gߖ̒GRLOLDQH–ঈ%k#"–čU–DQčO # –.! v)! –ঈ´ZK\LVWKH:($$!)!"GHHU

7KHWZRPRVWFRPPRQDUHDVZKHUHVSOLWVDUHIRXQGLQHUJDWLYHODQ FXUVLQJPH"µ .%RL² ([DPSOHVRIWUDQVLWLYHIRUPVLQ
JXDJHVDUHLQQRPLQDOKLHUDUFK\DQGWHQVHDVSHFW,QVRPHHUJDWLYH –‘–ZKLOHLQIUHTXHQWDUHIRXQGWKURXJKRXWWKH+XUULDQWH[WVIURP
ODQJXDJHVZKHQWKH$JHQWLVILUVW DQGLQVRPHFDVHVVHFRQG SHU %RОD]N|\ VHH&DPSEHOODDQGQ*LRUJLHUL &RXOG
VRQWKHODQJXDJHRSHUDWHVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYH LWEHWKDW–#–ZDVQRWLQWURGXFHGLQWRWKHWUDQVLWLYHSDUDGLJPXQWLOD
V\VWHP HJ'\LUEDO ,QRWKHUODQJXDJHVHUJDWLYLW\LVDVVRFLDWHG ODWHUSRLQW DSRWHQWLDOH[SODQDWLRQIRUWKHIDFWWKDWLWLVRQO\IRXQG
ZLWKSDVWWHQVH RUSHUIHFWLYH HYHQWVZKLOHWKHSUHVHQWIXWXUH RU ZLWKWKLUGDQGVHFRQGSHUVRQYHUEV DQGWKDWLWPD\EHUHODWHGWR
LPSHUIHFWLYH LVQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYH WKHDQWLSDVVLYHPDUNHU–#S
0RUHFRPSOLFDWHGLVWKHXVHRI–&ZLWKLQWUDQVLWLYHDQGDQWL
:P
2QVXEMHFWVLQWKHGDWLYHFDVHVHH3DOPHU²
SDVVLYHYHUEV:KLOH–&LVW\SLFDOO\UHVHUYHGIRUFRPSOHWHGDFWLRQV
Q?
7KLVLVVXHRIGLDOHFWVLQ+XUULDQLVSUREOHPDWLF .KDɥLNMDQ
DQGWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ–‘IRUSUHVHQWIXWXUH WKHUHDUHH[DPSOHV
:HJQHU² 7KHSULPDU\VRXUFHPDWHULDOWKDWLVRIXVHIRU
RIYHUEVLQ–&WKDWFDQQRWEHSDVWWHQVH7KLVLVPRVWQRWDEOHLQWKH
WKLVVWXG\FDQEHGLYLGHGEHWZHHQWKH0LWWDQL/HWWHUDQGWKHWH[WV
=6996IJ%=(kk(? #S –(S–GLODUčU̒Z–)#%(k$# –( @:#-:#-–#k$–#–E´:HUHOHDVH
IURP%RОD]N|\7KH+XUULDQRIWKH0LWWDQL/HWWHUUHSUHVHQWVDODWHU
>WKHZRPDQIURP@VRUFHU\DWLQWKHJDWHµ &K6,UHY ² 
GLDOHFW DQG FDQ EH FDOOHG 0LWWDQL +XUULDQ 7KH +XUULDQ IRXQG DW
&H%=(kk(?(VHH:LOKHOPQ*LYHQWKHULWXDOQDWXUHRI
%RОD]N|\LVPXFKPRUHSUREOHPDWLF7KHODQJXDJHRIPDQ\RIWKH
WKLVWH[WWKHYHUEFDQQRWEHWDNHQDVDSUHWHULWH!"#$%&#'%(&)*+,%(*#
WH[WVUHIOHFWVDQROGHUSHULRGWKDWLVVLPLODUWRWKHROGHVWNQRZQ+XU
-&)"&.+/0&#,*#/%(/.,+/%1#+2,+#,%#,.+/$%#/*#0/&3&(#,*#,#*/%14&#32$4&5#
ULDQWH[WWKH7LߖDWDOLQVFULSWLRQ RQWKLVWH[WVHH:LOKHOP 
+2&#,.+#$"#)&4&,*/%15#*/%.&#/+#/*#,#+&4/.#,.+/$%5#/*#.$6-4&+&(#,+#+2&#6$7
7KRVHWH[WVZLWKHOHPHQWVRIWKLVROGHUGLDOHFWDUHFDOOHGKHUH2OG
6&%+#$"#'++&),%.&8,QWKLVFDVHWKHSHUIHFWLYHLVQRWXVHGIRUDSDVW
+XUULDQ$PDMRUSUREOHPRIWKHWH[WVIURP%RОD]N|\LVWKDWRQHFDQ
DFWLRQEXWIRUDSUHVHQWRQH
WUDFHDQXPEHURIGHYHORSPHQWVOHDGLQJIURP2OG+XUULDQWR0LWWDQL QQ
:HJQHU²$YDULHW\RIRWKHUWKHRULHVKDYHEHHQSRVLWHG
+XUULDQ7KLVGHYHORSPHQWLVDVXEMHFWWKDW,SODQRQSXUVXLQJLQD
GF7%–>6RPHKDYHWDNHQLWDVDSRO\SHUVRQDORUELSRODUPRUSKHPH
VHSDUDWHZRUN
PDUNLQJWKLUGVLQJXODU$2DJUHHPHQW :LOKHOPD*LRUJLHUL
QO
:HJQHU:LOKHOP
² RUSDWLHQWDJUHHPHQW &DPSEHOOE 7KHHYLGHQFH
Q:
:LOKHOP7KLVLVQRWWKHSODFHIRUDGHWDLOHGGLVFXVVLRQ DOEHLWOLPLWHGWRWKLUGSHUVRQ$JHQWVVSHDNVLQIDYRURIDQDO\]LQJWKLV
RIWHQVHDVSHFWLQ2OG+XUULDQEXWVRPHREVHUYDWLRQVFDQEHPDGH –>PRUSKHPHDVDQ$DJUHHPHQWPDUNHU VHHEHORZ 
8QOLNH0LWWDQL+XUULDQZKLFKXVHV–‘–2%–Rঈ–DQG–!"–WRPDUN Q<
,QKLVDUWLFOHRQ+XUULDQPRUSKRV\QWD[3ODQNJLYHVWKHH[SHFWHG
WHQVH2OG+XUULDQPDNHVDGLVWLQFWLRQDPRQJWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVEH
RUGHURIYDOHQFHWHQVHDQGDJUHHPHQWPRUSKHPHVRQWKH+XUULDQ
WZHHQ–6 – DQG–‘– DQGSHUKDSV–#– DQGDPRQJLQWUDQVLWLYHDQG
YHUEDVWHQVHPRRGQXPEHUSHUVRQ 3ODQN(G879K%=7F
DQWLSDVVLYHYHUEVSRVVLEO\EHWZHHQ–‘DQG–E7KHSULPDU\VRXUFH
SRVHGLQ6SHLVHUDQGIROORZHGE\:HJQHU²DQG
GF7%GF7M9%8H%–6–LVWKH+XUUR+LWWLWHELOLQJXDOIURP%RОD]N|\,Q
:HJQHU 7KLVSUHVFULSWHGRUGHULQJGRHVQRWKROGIRUHYHU\
WKHVHWH[WVYHUEVLQ–6 – FRUUHVSRQGWR+LWWLWHYHUEVLQWKHSUHW
IRUP7KHUHLVOLWWOHGRXEWWKDW–#"–LQWKH2OG+XUULDQWUDQVLWLYH
HULWH$OOH[DPSOHVRILQGLFDWLYHYHUEVLQ–6–LQGLFDWHWRWKHEHVWRI
IRUPV LHLQWKHIRUP–#"–6 FOHDUO\PDUNVDJUHHPHQWZLWKWKHWKLUG
P\NQRZOHGJHFRPSOHWHGDFWLRQ7UDQVLWLYHYHUEVLQ–‘– RU–#– 
SOXUDODJHQW6LQFH–6LVWKHWUDQVLWLYHPDUNHUSHUIHFWLYHYDOHQFH
GHFOLQHGLIIHUHQWO\WKDQGRWKHLUFRXQWHUSDUWVLQ–6 – DQGFDQEH
PRUSKHPHLWFDQRQO\EHVDLGWKDWWKHDJUHHPHQWPDUNHUFRPHV
VHHQDVLQGLFDWLQJLQFRPSOHWHRUIXWXUHDFWLRQDQGPD\SRVVLEO\EH
EHIRUHWKHYDOHQFHPRUSKHPHHYHQWKRXJKWKLVYLRODWHVWKHRUGHU
LPSHUIHFWLYH7KHTXHVWLRQLVZKHWKHUZHKDYHDQXQPDUNHGLPSHU
SUHGLFWHGE\3ODQN
IHFWLYHRULILWLVPDUNHGE\–#–7KHLPSHUIHFWLYHLVUDUHLQWKHROGHVW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

3DJUHHPHQWLVRSWLRQDOO\LQGLFDWHGE\DIUHHHQFOLWLFSURQRXQ1RWHWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV $DJUHHPHQWLVLQ
EROG 

>@ QčOL% V%:(&() # –)!–ঈ%% >!.–(+઄+઄–6–!

 GHHU‘$%6«PRXQWDLQ6*5(/$7(5*H[SHO(+઄+઄75$13(5)$*$*5
 ´7KHPRXQWDLQH[SHOOHGWKHGHHU IURPLWVERG\ µ .%RL²

>@ DYLТDU # –)!–?!–)!–..(%% 1- # –#–. .(

 D6*5(/$7*(1$%/,1673/(1&/IRRW6*3266‘$%63/(1&/
% (")#–Q̒ NHO – #–5!.–!k$–6–!
 IRRWVWRRO$%/,167UDLVH!k$75$13(5)$*$*5
 ´+H 7HߖߖRE UDLVHGKLVIHHWXSRQDIRRWVWRRORIDQDYLТDUL PHDVXUHLQVL]H µ .%R¬L² QR

>@ :(&() # –) ( –Dঈ–Xঈ ߖҸH–) ( –Dঈ–Xঈ HঈH–)!–k–k( v))(

 PRXQWDLQ3/5(/$73/(5*ZDWHU3/5(/$73/(5*(DUWK6*5(/$7(5*6*(1&/
% V%#$=–"#–6
 «SXULI\3/$*$*575$13(5)
 ´7KHPRXQWDLQVWKHZDWHUVWKHHDUWK«SXULILHGLWµ &K6,LL² 

7KH0LWWDQL6\VWHPZKLFKPD\GHULYHIURPWKH2OG+XUULDQLPSHUIHFWLYHDOVRUHTXLUHVDJUHHPHQWZLWK$Q@%
8QOLNHWKHROGHUGLDOHFWDFRPSOHWHSDUDGLJPLVNQRZQIRUWKHWUDQVLWLYH0LWWDQLYHUE,QWKH0LWWDQL/HWWHULWVHOI
KHUHDEEUHYLDWHG´0LWWµ DWUDQVLWLYHYDOHQFHPRUSKHPH–#–LVIRXQGZLWKVHFRQGDQGWKLUGSHUVRQVLQJXODU
DJHQWV FI>@DQG>@ DQGDOOWUDQVLWLYHQHJDWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQV RXWVLGHRIWKH0LWWDQL/HWWHU–#–LVDOVRIRXQG
ZLWKVHFRQGSOXUDODJHQWV 

>@ >LQࡃ@–P̒–QҸQ%% +઄HQQLߖ̒Q ( –LIIH LঈD–ঈ%% WöG–$%

 DV6*(1&/)#)QRZ EURWKHU6*3266‘$%66*(5*ORYH6*$*$*5
 ´>$V@QRZ,ORYHP\EURWKHU«µ 0LWWL

6LQFHWKHSHUIHFWLYHWUDQVLWLYH–#"–6LQ2OG+XUULDQ´YLRODWHVµ =>L76>%GF7M9N%)(==–#"–!)´/HW WKHJRGV IUHH XV µ 0LWWLY DQG

SUHGLFWHG ZRUG RUGHU LW VWDQGV WKDW WKLV ´RUGHUµ LV QRW XQLYHU
VDOLQ+XUULDQDQGWKDWRWKHU´H[FHSWLRQVµPLJKWH[LVW(YHU\RQH
DJUHHVWKDW–#"!)LVWREHDQDO\]HGDVWKHFRPELQDWLRQ–#"–!) 3/
$*$*5-866 ZKLFKLVFOHDUO\QXPEHUSHUVRQPRRG *LRUJLHUL
:HJQHU :HJQHU·VSULPDU\DUJXPHQWVDJDLQVW
WDNLQJWKHSOXUDOMXVVLYHDV–#"–!)LVWKDWVXFKDQDQDO\VLV´KlWWH
GDUEHUKLQDXVIUGHQ$Q]HLJHUGHV1XPHUXVGHU3HUVRQ #" GLH
QLFKW]XHUZDUWHQGH2UGQXQJVSRVLWLRQGDGLHVHUGDQQQlPOLFKZXU
]HOQlKHUDOVGDVYHUPHLQWOLFKH0RGDOHOHPHQW ! RGHU !) DQJH
RUGQHWZlUHµ :HJQHU :HJQHU·VLVVXHVZLWKWDNLQJ–#"%69%
WKHSOXUDODJHQWPDUNHUZLWKWKHMXVVLYHVWHPVWRKHUSRVLWLRQWKDW
WKH–#–LQWKHVLQJXODUMXVVLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQ–#–!)FDQQRWEHWUDQVL
WLYHDQGPXVWLQVWHDGEHPRGDO :HJQHU +HUDUJXPHQW
LVODUJHO\EDVHGRQWKHIDFWWKDWWKHIRUP#$$#"!)LQ0LWWLLLLQKHU
RSLQLRQFDQRQO\EHWDNHQDVLQWUDQVLWLYH%DVHGRQWKHFRQWH[WRI
WKLVSDVVDJHKRZHYHU,EHOLHYHWKDWLWLVPXFKPRUHOLNHO\WKDW#$$
´WRJRµLVWREHVHHQDVODELOHRUSRO\YDOHQWDQGKDVWKHFRUUHVSRQG
LQJWUDQVLWLYHPHDQLQJRI´WREULQJIRUWKµ &DPSEHOOD² 
7KHPRUSKHPH–#–LQWKHVLQJXODUMXVVLYHLVQRWWREHWDNHQDVHLWKHU
WUDQVLWLYHRUPRGDOEXWUDWKHUDVDQDFWLYHYRLFHPDUNHU VHHEHORZ
DQGQRWH &RPSDUHWKHIRUPV+઄ (–#–!)´/HW WKHELUGRI!KHDYHQ 
WDNH HYLO µ &K6,REY DQG=!&–čQ–6–!) 0LWWLLL DQG
WKHQHJDWLYH+઄ # 0–ࡃТ–#–Zč–!)´0D\ P\EURWKHU QRWGLVWUHVV P\
KHDUW µ 0LWWLLL DQG+઄#0–ࡃТ–6.–6–9 ( –!)´0D\ P\EURWKHU QRW
EHGLVWUHVVHGµ 0LWWL ,QERWKH[DPSOHVZHILQGWKDWWKHPRU
SKHPHV–#–DQG–6–DSSHDULQWKHVDPHSRVLWLRQ WKHUHDVRQIRUWKH
HOLVLRQRIWKH(RIWKHQHJDWLYHPRUSKHPHZKHQSUHFHGHGE\–6–%89%
XQFOHDU :LWKWKLVLQPLQGFRPSDUHWKHIROORZLQJWZRWKLUGSHUVRQ
)(==–#"–‫–گ‬9 ( –!)´OHW WKHJRGV QRWIUHH 0L6LW%0L$+L µ 0LWWLL 
ZKHUHLWLVOLNHO\WKDWZLWKWKHODWWHUIRUPWKH–6–SODFHVHPSKDVLV
RQWKHSDWLHQW*LYHQWKLV,ZRXOGSRVWXODWHWKDWZLWKMXVVLYHVLQ
–#–,ZHKDYH–#–!) WKLUGVLQJXODU DQG–#"–!) WKLUGSOXUDO ZKLOH
WKRVHLQ–6– 67J%–6–!) WKLUGVLQJXODU DQG–#"–6–!) WKLUGSOXUDO 
7KHUHDVRQIRUWKHORVVRI–#– 8H%–#"–!)LVQRWFOHDUEXWPD\KDYH
VRPHWKLQJWRGRZLWKWKHIDFWWKDW–#"–LVH[FOXVLYHO\DSOXUDODJHQW
PDUNHUDQGWKHUHIRUHFDUULHVZLWKLWDKLJKGHJUHHRIWUDQVLWLYLW\DQG
E\H[WHQVLRQDFWLYHQHVV
QR
,ZRXOGOLNHWRWKDQN0DXUR*LRUJLHULIRUWKLVFLWDWLRQ7KHUHKDV
WUDGLWLRQDOO\EHHQDZLGHGLYHUJHQFHRIRSLQLRQVRQKRZWKH2OG+XU
ULDQDJUHHPHQWPDUNHU–>LVWREHXQGHUVWRRG9,*&(RQWKHDERYH
H[DPSOHDQGRWKHUVZKHUHDWUDQVLWLYHYHUEZLWKVLQJXODUDJHQWDQG
=>L76>%=6K8JHK%89%8H%–6–>2ZHKDYHFRQYLQFLQJHYLGHQFHWKDW–>%89%
QRWELSRODU :LOKHOPD:LOKHOP*LRUJLHUL
²  RU SDWLHQW PDUNLQJ &DPSEHOO E  EXW UDWKHU PDUNV
DJUHHPHQWZLWK$ VHHDOUHDG\.KDɥLNMDQ:HJQHU
 3UREOHPDWLFZLWKERWK.KDɥLNMDQ·VDQG:HJQHU·VDUJXPHQWVLV
WKDWWKH\FRPSDUHWKHDJUHHPHQWPDUNHU–>ZLWKWKH–&IRXQGRQ
ROGHULQWUDQVLWLYHDQGDQWLSDVVLYHYHUEV7KLV–&PRUSKHPHLVQHX
WUDODVWRERWKSHUVRQDQGQXPEHUZKLOH–>DSSHDUVWREHDVSHFLILF
WKLUGSHUVRQVLQJXODU DJHQW PDUNHU &DPSEHOOE 

,WLVWHPSWLQJWRWUDQVODWHWKLVSDVVDJHDVDIXWXUH´WKH\ZLOOSX
ULI\µEXWWKLVLVFRQWUDU\WRWKHQDWXUHRI–6DVDPDUNHURIWKHSHU
IHFWLYHDVSHFW3HUKDSVLWLVEHWWHUDV´WKH\SXULI\µ"
Q@
.KDɥLNMDQVHHVWKHYHUEDOV\VWHPLQ2OG+XUULDQDVDWZRWHQVH
V\VWHPZLWK–#–XVHGIRUWKHSUHVHQWIXWXUHDQG–6 – IRUWKHSDVW
 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% :@

>@ (#%&'–"–(% =#-!)G#

 LIGHVLUH75$16*$*$*5UHOHDVLQJ‘$%6
 ´,I\RXGHVLUHDUHOHDVLQJµ .%RLY 

>@ SčOL–PčQ XUТ ! –(%% )&*–"–+–)

 OLH‘$%6PDQWUXWK(66VSHDN75$16*$*$*5Q
 ´+HVSHDNVWKH.#!DVWKHWUXWKµ 0LWWLL

,DPVRPHZKDWKHVLWDQWLQGHFODULQJWKHDQWLTXLW\RIWKLV–#–PRUSKHPHLQ+XUULDQ7KHUHDUHVHYHUDOIRUPVIURP
%RОD]N|\WKDWGRQRWLQFOXGHWKHH[SHFWHG–#–YDOHQFHPRUSKHPHQP7KHUHLVVRPHHYLGHQFHWKDWWKHRULJLQDO
LPSHUIHFWLYHPD\KDYHEHHQXQPDUNHGIRUYDOHQFHDVSHFWDQGMXVWPDUNHGIRUDJUHHPHQW<?,QERWKGLDOHFWVWKH
SDWLHQWLVRSWLRQDOO\FURVVUHIHUHQFHGRQWKHYHUEE\DQHQFOLWLFSURQRXQ
7KHFDVHPRUSKRORJ\RI$13VLQWKHQRQLQGLFDWLYHLVFRQGLWLRQHGE\WKHPRGDOIRUP&HUWDLQPRGDOIRUPV
UHTXLUHWKH$13WREHLQWKHDEVROXWLYHZKLOHZLWKRWKHUVLWLVLQWKHHUJDWLYH<O+XUULDQKDVVHYHUDOQRQLQGLFDWLYH
IRUPVDQGWKH\FDQEHGLYLGHGLQWRWZREURDGSDUDGLJPVWKHLPSHUDWLYHDQGDOORWKHUPRGDOIRUPV7KHLPSHUD
WLYHLVDPRUSKRORJLFDOO\PLQLPDOIRUPWKDWGLVWLQJXLVKHVEHWZHHQWUDQVLWLYHDQGLQWUDQVLWLYH <:7KHRWKHUPRRGV
GRQRWPDNHWKLVVDPHGLVWLQFWLRQUDWKHUIXQFWLRQLQJDORQJDFWLYH –#– RUSDWLHQWLYH –6– OLQHV<Q
,QWKHLPSHUDWLYHWKH$13LVDOZD\VLQWKHDEVROXWLYH7KHUHVXOWRIWKLVLVWKDWWKH$13RIWKHWUDQVLWLYH
LPSHUDWLYHDQGWKH613RIWKHLQWUDQVLWLYHDUHERWKLQWKHVDPHFDVH7KLVPHDQVWKDWLQWKHLPSHUDWLYH+XUULDQ
RSHUDWHVZLWKWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQRI$ 6ZKLFKLVQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHDQGQRWHUJDWLYH<<1RWHWKHIRO
ORZLQJWZRH[DPSOHV

>@ IDঈ–(–IID SDUТL–"Z(@

 HQWHU,175$1,033/(1&/FRXUW\DUG',5
 ´(QWHULQWRWKHFRXUW\DUGµ &K6,UHY <R

>@ ()(>>#–$$(%% +઄čঈ–#–>>(%% *("6MO઄ !&(–$$(

 VR6*(1&/KHDU75$1,036*(1&/31‘$%66*(1&/
 ´6RKHDUPH7DGR҅HEDµ &K6,LLL


&RPSDUHWKLVVHFRQGSHUVRQIRUPLQ–#–6WRWKHQRPLQDOL]HGUHOD
WLYHDQčТLGL–)!–ঈ%WčG–6–kk!–)!–ঈ´7KH(ZKLFK\RXORYH«µ &K6
,L %DVHGRQWKH0LWWDQL+XUULDQSDUDGLJPZHZRXOGH[SHFW
UWčG–#–6–kk!
QP
&DPSEHOODDQGQ*LRUJLHUL
<?
7KHUHDUHVHYHUDOH[DPSOHVRIWKLUGSHUVRQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVZLWK
RXWWKHXVXDO–#–W\SLFDORIWKH0LWWDQL+XUULDQGLDOHFW VHH&DPSEHOO
D*LRUJLHUL $OOWKHVHH[DPSOHVFRPHIURP%RОD]N|\
DQGPD\EHUHSUHVHQWDWLYHRIDQHDUO\VWDJHZKHUHWUDQVLWLYH LP
SHUIHFWLYH" YHUEVKDG‘PDUNLQJZLWKRQO\DJHQWDJUHHPHQWEHLQJ
LQGLFDWHGRQWKHYHUE
<O
7KLVLVH[SODLQHGLQGHWDLOLQP\GLVVHUWDWLRQ &DPSEHOOD 
<:
7KHLPSHUDWLYHKDVEHHQDQDO\]HGLQDYDULHW\RIZD\V0RVWJUDP
PDUVRI+XUULDQVHHWKHLPSHUDWLYHDVDFRPSOH[V\VWHPFRQVLVWLQJ
RIDYDULHW\RIPRGDOIRUPVWKDWDUHIRXQGZLWKDOOSHUVRQVDQGQXP
EHUV,QP\GLVVHUWDWLRQ,GHWHUPLQHGWKDWWKHUHZDVDWUXHLPSHUD
WLYHWKDWLVDPRUSKRORJLFDOO\PLQLPDOVHFRQGSHUVRQFRPPDQG
IRUPLQ+XUULDQ &DPSEHOOD² ,WLVP\RSLQLRQWKDWWKH
LPSHUDWLYHLVPRUSKRORJLFDOO\DQGV\QWDFWLFDOO\GLVWLQFWIURPWKH
RWKHUPRRGVLQ+XUULDQ)RURWKHULQWHUSUHWDWLRQVRIWKHLPSHUDWLYH
VHHQRWHEHORZ
<Q
$YDULHW\RIYLHZVH[LVWRQWKHIRUPVDQGIXQFWLRQVRIWKHPRGDO
HQGLQJVLQ+XUULDQ,QWKHSURFHVVRIUHVHDUFKLQJP\GLVVHUWDWLRQ,
QRWLFHGDSDWWHUQEHWZHHQPRGDOIRUPVSUHFHGHGE\DPRUSKHPH–#–%
DQGWKRVHSUHFHGHGE\–6– &DPSEHOOD $VDUHVXOWRIP\VWXG\
RIWKHVHIRUPV,FRQFOXGHGWKDWWKHVHPRUSKHPHVIRFXVHGWKHYHUE
RQHLWKHUWKH$JHQWRUWKH3DWLHQW DQGLQFDVHVRIGDWLYHVKLIWWKH
%HQHILFLDU\ ZLWK–#–IXQFWLRQLQJDVDQDJHQWLYHPDUNHUDQG–6– 69%
DSDWLHQWLYHRQH)RUGLIIHULQJYLHZVRQWKH+XUULDQPRGDOV\VWHPVHH
LQSDUWLFXODU*LRUJLHUL²+D]HQERV+D]HQERV
²:LOKHOP²:HJQHU²
<<
(YHQWKRXJKWKHDSSDUHQWUHODWLRQLQWKHLPSHUDWLYHLV$ 6 3
3LVWREHGLIIHUHQWLDWHGIURPWKHRWKHUWZRJUDPPDWLFDOUROHV VHH
EHORZ 
<R
6RPHSUHIHUWRDQDO\]HIDঈDIID%69%IDঈ²D # –::(ZLWKDVKLIWRIWKH
LPSHUDWLYHIURP–#%X%–(WKURXJKYRZHOKDUPRQ\ZLWKWKHHQFOLWLF
=7FHFLH%–::( :HJQHU  6XFKDQDQDO\VLVGRHVQRWWDNH
LQWRDFFRXQWWKHLQWUDQVLWLYHLPSHUDWLYHIRUPV1)–(–>>(´FRPHµ
&K6¬,L QH[WWRWKHWUDQVLWLYHLPSHUDWLYH1)–#–.´EULQJWKHPµ
&K6¬,REY VHHDOVR+઄ čঈ–#–>>(LQH[DPSOH>@DERYH:LWK
WKHWUDQVLWLYH1)–#–.WKHUHLVQRVKLIWRI–#%X%–(HYHQWKRXJKWKH
HQFOLWLFSURQRXQ–. .( LVDSSHQGHGWRLW1RWHWRRWKHIRUPV15–6.–(%
DQG1"-–()–( 56² 2QߖDOТ–6.–(DVLQWUDQVLWLYHVHH&DPS
EHOOD²
$IXUWKHUSUREOHPLVWKDWWKHSOXUDOIRUPLQ–::(FRQIOLFWVZLWK
WKHVRFDOOHGSOXUDOLPSHUDWLYHIRUPLQ–!–kWKDWLVSRVWXODWHGE\
VRPH IRU–!–kDVDSOXUDOLPSHUDWLYHVHH:HJQHUDPRQJ
RWKHUV 6LQFHPRGDOIRUPVLQ–#W–(DUHOLPLWHGWRVLQJXODUSOXUDO
VHFRQGSHUVRQVXEMHFWVZKLOH–#WHঈLVIRXQGZLWKPXOWLSOHSHUVRQV
DQGQXPEHUV,SUHIHUWRWDNHWKLVODWWHUIRUPDVDGLIIHUHQWPRRG
IURPWKHLPSHUDWLYH &DPSEHOOD² ,IHHOWKDWLWLVKLJKO\
XQOLNHO\WKDWWKHUHZRXOGEHWZRGLIIHUHQWHQGLQJVIXQFWLRQLQJDV
VHFRQGSOXUDOLPSHUDWLYHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

:KLOHWKHVXEMHFW 6RU$ LVXVXDOO\RPLWWHGLQ+XUULDQLPSHUDWLYHVLWLVPDGHH[SOLFLWLQERWK>@DQG>@WKURXJK

WKHXVHRIWKHHQFOLWLFSURQRXQV–::( VHFRQGSOXUDO DQG–>>( VHFRQGVLQJXODU UHVSHFWLYHO\(QFOLWLFSURQRXQV
DUHRQO\DEVROXWLYHLQ+XUULDQIXUWKHUVXSSRUWLQJWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQ6 $LQWKHLPSHUDWLYH
:LWKWKHQRQLPSHUDWLYHQRQLQGLFDWLYHPRGDOIRUPV$13VDUHW\SLFDOO\LQWKHHUJDWLYHFDVHUHJDUGOHVVRI
ZKHWKHUWKHYHUELVDFWLYHRUSDWLHQWLYH:LWKWKHVHPRRGV+XUULDQIXQFWLRQVDFFRUGLQJWKHHUJDWLYHV\VWHPRI
6 3$,QWZRPRRGVKRZHYHUWKHDFWLYHIRUPIXQFWLRQVDVQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHZKLOHWKHSDWLHQWLYHLVHUJD
WLYH7KLVLVW\SLILHGE\WKHRSWDWLYHPRRG –Hঈ IRUZKLFKDQXPEHURIH[DPSOHVRIERWKDFWLYHDQGSDWLHQWLYH
DUHNQRZQ<@$IHZH[DPSOHVZLOOVXIILFHWRGHPRQVWUDWHWKHSRLQW

>@ =(kk(? # < –(–Z"@#.% (-(-!–)#%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%(k$!%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%:#-:#-–#k$–#– ! ঈ

 JDWH(663/(1&/VRUFHU\$%/,167ZRPDQ‘$%6UHOHDVH#k$$&7237
 ´0D\ZHUHOHDVHWKHZRPDQIURPVRUFHU\LQDWWKHJDWHµ &K6,REY

>@ #-"#–E XUТ # –D WҸ ! –(%% =("–#–.–̒ঈ

 WRQJXH6*3266‘$%6WUXH<P(66ZRUG(66VSHDN$&7.237
 ´0D\\RXUWRQJXHVSHDNWUXHZRUG V µ &K6,LLL

>@ ߖ̒Q ( –LII̒–Q WčG–XJčU–#– ! ঈ ߖ€–-(%

 EURWKHU6*3266‘$%66*(1&/ " ORYH5(&,3$&72376*&20
 ´0D\P\EURWKHUVKDUHORYHZLWKPHµ 0LWWLL

,QWKHWKUHHH[DPSOHVMXVWJLYHQWKH$13VRI>@DQG>@DUHERWKLQWKHDEVROXWLYH –"#.DQG#-"#–&UHVSHFWLYHO\ 
ZKLOHWKH613RI>@LVLQWKHVDPHFDVHR?$VZLWKWKHLPSHUDWLYHZLWKWKHDFWLYHRSWDWLYHZHILQGDV\VWHP
RI$ 6ZKLFKLVQRWHUJDWLYH,QIDFWWKHW\SLFDOVLWXDWLRQLV$ 6 3ZKHUHDOODUHLQWKHDEVROXWLYH H[DPSOH
>@DERYH DOWKRXJKDOWHUQDWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVZLWK3GHPRWHGWRWKHHVVLYHDUHDOVRIRXQG >@DERYH RO,QWKH
SDWLHQWLYHRSWDWLYHWKHDJHQWZKHQH[SOLFLWWKH$13LVLQWKHHUJDWLYH

>@ !) # –) ( –čঈ–Xঈ WDOčYRঈL–) ( –čঈ–Xঈ DߖW–6–+઄+઄#–) ( –čঈ–XঈV

 JRG3/5(/$73/(5*PLJKW\3/5(/$73/(5*ZRPDQ$%673/5(/$73/(5*«
% ߖ̒Т–(.–#)"–6– ! ঈLWN–#)"–6– ! ঈ
 PDNHSXUH (. 3/$*$*5 "" 3$7237SXULI\3/$*$*5 "" 3$7237
 ´0D\WKHPLJKW\IHPDOHJRGGHVVHV«PDNHSXUHDQGSXULILHG WKHI(kk# µ &K6,LL² R:


$FFRUGLQJWR'L[RQWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQRI$ 6LQWKHLP
SHUDWLYHLVXQLYHUVDODFURVVODQJXDJHV6LQFHWKHLPSHUDWLYHLVDFRP
PDQGZKHUHE\WKHVSHDNHUWHOOVWKHOLVWHQHUWRSHUIRUPVRPHDFWLRQ
LWUHTXLUHVWKDW$DQG6EHWUHDWHGLGHQWLFDOO\DQGLVWKHUHIRUH6 $LV
DEDVLFFKDUDFWHULVWLFRIDOOODQJXDJHVEHWKH\QRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYH
RUHUJDWLYH 'L[RQ² 
<@
,QKHUJUDPPDURI+XUULDQ:HJQHUSUHIHUVWRVHHWZRGLIIHUHQW
PRGDOHQGLQJVLQ–HঈRQHEHLQJDVHFRQGSOXUDOLPSHUDWLYHIRUP
DQGWKHRWKHUEHLQJVHJPHQWHGDV–!–kRILQGHWHUPLQDWHIXQFWLRQ
 *LRUJLHULDOVRVHHVWZRKRPRSKRQRXVIRUPVDJDLQ
DVHFRQGSOXUDOLPSHUDWLYHDQGWKHRWKHUDVDQRSWDWLYH 
²WKHVDPHSRVLWLRQLVKHOGLQ:LOKHOP 6LQFHVHF
RQGSOXUDOLPSHUDWLYHVDUHFOHDUO\IRUPHGE\DFRPELQDWLRQRIWKH
YDOHQFHPRUSKHPH –#%F7%–( DQGWKHRSWLRQDOVHFRQGSOXUDOHQFOLWLF
SURQRXQ VHHH[DPSOHDERYH LWVHHPVXQOLNHO\WKDWLWZRXOGKDYH
6H%6>KJ7H6KJ%GF7M%8H%–#–ঈ,SUHIHUWRVHHDOOIRUPVLQ–!k DQG–6k DV
EHORQJLQJWRRQHPRGDOIRUPWKHRSWDWLYH–Hঈ DVHJPHQWDWLRQ–!–ঈ%
LVSRVVLEOHEXWVLQFH–ঈKDVQRGHWHUPLQDEOHIXQFWLRQDQGLVDOZD\V
IRXQGZLWKWKLVPRRG,SUHIHUWRVHHWKHPDVRQHHQGLQJ&DPSEHOO
D² 

6HH:LOKHOPQ
<P
% (J7J% XUТD ´WUXWKµ FI >@ DERYH  LV EHLQJ XVHG DWWULEXWLYHO\ WR
PRGLI\$#!´ZRUGµDQGVR,KDYHWUDQVODWHGLWDVWKHDGMHFWLYH´WUXHµ
R?
7KHVDPHVLWXDWLRQKROGVIRUWKHSRWHQWLDOLV–!?( RQZKLFKVHH
&DPSEHOOD² 1RWHWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOH
()(>>#–$$(–PDQߖ̒Q ( –#::1–9(%V
VR6*(1&/PDQEURWKHU6*3266'$7«
V%=!&–čQ–6. –#l6 –.–̒YD–$$ ( –čQ
«VHQG () 6. $&73$7 O3276*(1&/()
´6RZRXOG,VHQG WKHP WRP\EURWKHUµ 0LWWLLL²
7KHYHUE=!&–čQ´WRVHQGµLVFRQVLVWHQWO\WUDQVLWLYHLQ+XUULDQ7KH
!%+52%–$$(LVLQWKHDEVROXWLYHDQG)6$WKHHUJDWLYH%DVHGRQWKLVLW
LVOLNHO\WKDWWKHHQGLQJV–ROO̒YDDUHWREHDQDO\]HGDV–6. –# –.–̒YD2%
ZLWKWKHDJHQWLYH–#–
RO
 7KLV LV LQ VRPH ZD\V VLPLODU WR VSOLW HUJDWLYLW\ LQ %XUXVKDVNL
3DNLVWDQ ,Q%XUXVKDVNL$13VDUHW\SLFDOO\LQWKHHUJDWLYHH[
FHSWZLWKFHUWDLQFDVHV,QWKHIXWXUH$LVLQWKHDEVROXWLYHZKHQ
LWLVWKHILUVWSHUVRQDQGVRPHWLPHVZKHQLWLVVHFRQGSHUVRQ 7LI
IRXDQG0RULQ &RPSDUHWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHVw)! (5* 
#) $%6  PXF~ɥiD 35(6  ´\RX PDUU\ KHUµ YHUVXV 1) $%6  #) $%6 
PXF~ɥXPD )87 ´\RXZLOOPDUU\KHUµ 7LIIRXDQG0RULQ 
R:
$OWKRXJK,DQDO\]HWKHPRUSKHPH–6–DVSDWLHQWLYHWKLVGRHVQRW
PHDQWKDWWKHSDVVDJHQHHGVWREHWUDQVODWHGDVSDVVLYH,QIDFWWKHVH
IRUPVDUHQRWVWULFWO\VSHDNLQJSDVVLYHV3DVVLYHVUHTXLUHERWKWKH
SURPRWLRQRI3WR6 LHDVKLIWIURPJUDPPDWLFDOSDWLHQWWRJUDP
PDWLFDOVXEMHFW DQGWKHFRQFXUUHQWGHPRWLRQRI$WRDQREOLTXHFDVH
RULWLVRPLWWHG 'L[RQ :LWK+XUULDQPRGDOIRUPVLQ–6–2%
WKH$13ZKHQH[SOLFLWLVLQWKHHUJDWLYHFDVHWKDWLVWKHVXEMHFW
FDVHLQHUJDWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQV7KLVODFNRIGHPRWLRQRI$LQGLFDWHV
WKDWSDVVDJHVVXFKDV>@DUH)6$SDVVLYHV6LQFHWKLVPRUSKHPHIR
FXVHVWKHFODXVHRQWKH313LWLVRIWHQWKRXJKQRWDOZD\VQHFHVVDU\
WRWUDQVODWHWKHVHSDVVDJHVDVSDVVLYHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% :P

+XUULDQDOVRKDVDQDQWLSDVVLYHYRLFH7KHDQWLSDVVLYHDVPHQWLRQHGDERYHLVDPHFKDQLVPIRUSURPRWLQJWKH
$13IURPWKHHUJDWLYHWRWKHDEVROXWLYH,WSODFHVWKHVHFRQGDU\UHODWLRQ$LQWRWKHSULPDU\UHODWLRQW\SLFDOO\KHOG
E\6DQG37KHUHVXOWRIWKHDQWLSDVVLYHLVWKDWDVHPDQWLFDOO\WUDQVLWLYHYHUELVFRQVWUXHGOLNHDVLQJOHDUJXPHQW
LQWUDQVLWLYH7KHSURPRWLRQRI$WRWKHDEVROXWLYHUHTXLUHVWKDW3EHHLWKHUFRPSOHWHO\RPLWWHGRUGHPRWHGWR
WKHREOLTXHHVVLYHFDVH VHHEHORZ RQ

>@ DFWLYHWUDQVLWLYH$),4%5$%6%1#,!+
 DQWLSDVVLYH$$%6 3)$$ 9!+#*5!$$*1)

7KHDQWLSDVVLYHKDVWZRSULQFLSDOIXQFWLRQVLQ+XUULDQ2QHRIWKHSULPDU\XVHVRIWKHDQWLSDVVLYHLVWRGH
WUDQVLWLYL]HWKHYHUER<7KHPRWLYDWLRQVIRUWKLVFDQEHPDQLIROG,QPDQ\FDVHVLWLVGXHWRWKHIDFWWKDWWKHSDWLHQW
LVQRQWRSLFDORUXQLPSRUWDQWWRWKHGLVFRXUVH,WLVDOVRXVHGWRUHPRYHHPSKDVLVIURPWKH313HLWKHURQWR$
RURQWRWKHDFWLRQRIWKHSUHGLFDWHLWVHOI7KHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHFRPHVIURPWKHILUVWOLQHRIDQHZSDUDJUDSKLQ
WKH0LWWDQL/HWWHU

>@ 1)"6–PčQߖ̒Q ( –LII̒–)% I(kk–ZRঈ–# RR

 QRZ>()EURWKHU6*3266‘$%6)VHQG35(775$1
 ´1RZP\EURWKHUKDVVHQW DPHVVHQJHU µ 0LWWLL

7KHIRFXVLVQRWXSRQZKRLVVHQW³WKDWLQIRUPDWLRQLVJLYHQLQWKHLPPHGLDWHO\IROORZLQJOLQH³EXWXSRQWKHDFW
RIVHQGLQJLWVHOI:KDWLVWRSLFDOKHUHLVWKHIDFWWKDWWKHSKDUDRK7XߖUDWWD·VV\PEROLF´EURWKHUµKDVSHUIRUPHG
DQDFWRIVHQGLQJ,QDQRWKHUSDVVDJHWKH313LVH[SOLFLW

>@ !. # –D IDТU–6–ঈ ! –D WčQ–"–#–E QHJUL HঈH–)!–?!

 IHDVW(66ERXQWHRXV 6ঈH (66PDNH"$3$*5EROW‘$%6HDUWK6*5(/$7*(1
% G
ǴOOčQL
 '1‘$%6
 ´ǴOOčQLWKHEROWRIWKHHDUWKSUHSDUHGDERXQWHRXVIHDVWµ .%RL²

7KHDQWLSDVVLYHLVUHTXLUHGLQ>@EHFDXVHWKH´ERXQWHRXVIHDVWµLVDJHQHUDOWRSLFWKHSDUWVRIZKLFKDUHHQX
PHUDWHGLQWKHLPPHGLDWHO\IROORZLQJOLQHV7KHVSHFLILFDFWLRQVXQGHUO\LQJWKHSURFHVVRISUHSDULQJWKLVIHDVW
DUHDOODFWLYHWUDQVLWLYHDFWLRQVZLWK$LQWKHHUJDWLYHDQG3LQWKHDEVROXWLYH
7KHDQWLSDVVLYHDOVRKDVDV\QWDFWLFIXQFWLRQLQ+XUULDQ7KH$13LVUHVWULFWHGDVWRWKHW\SHRILQWHUFODXVDO
V\QWDFWLFRSHUDWLRQVLQZKLFKLWFDQRFFXU)RUH[DPSOHUHODWLYL]DWLRQLQ+XUULDQLVOLPLWHGWRDEVROXWLYHDUJX
PHQWV7KHKHDGQRXQPXVWEHLQWKHDEVROXWLYHDQGLWFDQQRWEHLQWKHHUJDWLYH$WWKHVDPHWLPHWKHWDUJHW13
LQWKHPDLQFODXVHLVXVXDOO\LQWKHDEVROXWLYH LHWKH6RU313RIWKHPDLQFODXVH DOWKRXJKZLWKQRPLQDOL]HG
UHODWLYHVLQ–kk!WKHWDUJHWFDQEHREOLTXHDQGLQRQHFDVHHUJDWLYH7KLVPHDQVWKDWUHODWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVDUH
ODUJHO\OLPLWHGWR6DQG313V7KLVLVGHSLFWHGLQ>@

>@ 5(/  $),4 ೏5W$$%6%1%75$1,175$15(/ $),4 5W$$%6%1%#,!+W*+#,!+R@

% %

RQ
7KH+XUULDQDQWLSDVVLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQZDVILUVWVWXGLHGLQGHWDLO
E\*LUEDO  2WKHUVWXGLHVKDYHVRXJKWWRIXUWKHUFODULI\WKH
IXQFWLRQRIWKHDQWLSDVVLYH :HJQHU²² ,FDQQRW
KRZHYHUFRPSOHWHO\DJUHHZLWK:HJQHU·VGHVFULSWLRQRIWKHDQWL
SDVVLYH,QKHUGHVFULSWLRQVKHVHHNVWRVHSDUDWHRXWDQWLSDVVLYHV
ZLWKRXWH[SUHVVHGSDWLHQWVIURPWKRVHZLWKWKHP7KHDQWLSDVVLYH
PXFKOLNHWKHSDVVLYHLQYROYHVWKHSURPRWLRQRIRQHDUJXPHQW $
DQG3UHVSHFWLYHO\ DQGWKHFRQFXUUHQWGHPRWLRQRIWKHRWKHU 3
DQG$UHVSHFWLYHO\ (LWKHUWKHGHPRWHGDUJXPHQWDSSHDUVLQDQ
REOLTXHFDVHRUWKLVGHPRWLRQLVVRFRPSOHWHWKDWWKHDUJXPHQWLV
FRPSOHWHO\RPLWWHG7KHVHDUH)6$GLIIHUHQWSDVVLYHVDQGDQWLSDV
VLYHVEXWUDWKHUGLIIHUHQWGHJUHHVRIGHPRWLRQ)XUWKHUPRUH:HJQHU
GRHVQRWGHPRQVWUDWHWKHXVHRIWKHDQWLSDVVLYHWRDOORZWKH$13WR
IXQFWLRQLQV\QWDFWLFSLYRWV VHHH[DPSOHV>@DQG>@EHORZ )RU
PRUHRQWKHVHFRQVWUXFWLRQVVHHDOVR:LOKHOP
R<
3DOPHU²
RR
7KHUHVWRUDWLRQKHUHLVDEVROXWHO\FHUWDLQ

,QWKHSDVVDJH>DQč@ТLG̒–)!–ঈWčG–‫–گ‬kk!–)!–ঈN̒O–6W1´0D\WKH
>PH@DWRIIHULQJWKDW\RXORYHPDNH'61ZHOOµ &K6,L ZH
KDYHDQHUJDWLYHFDVHQRPLQDOL]HGUHODWLYHWčG–6–kk!–)!–ঈ7KHKHDG
RIWKHUHODWLYHDQčТLGLLVWKH313RIWKHUHODWLYH UHFRQVWUXFWHGDV
DQDТLGLWDG–6´\RXORYHWKH(RIIHULQJµ EXWLVWKH$13RIWKHPDLQ
FODXVH
R@
,Q(QJOLVKWKHFRQVWUXFWLRQ´-RKQVDZWKHPDQDQGOHIWµFDQRQO\
EHLQWHUSUHWHGDV´-RKQVDZWKHPDQDQG>-RKQ@OHIWµ IXOOEUDFNHWV
DUHXVHGWRLQGLFDWHWKHGHOHWHGDUJXPHQW 7KLVLVDQH[DPSOHRI
DQ$6SLYRW$ODQJXDJHZLWKHUJDWLYHV\QWD[RSHUDWHVZLWKDQ62
SLYRW7KHFRPSDUDEOHHUJDWLYHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRI´-RKQVDZWKHPDQ
DQGOHIWµZRXOGEH ´-RKQVDZWKHPDQDQG>WKHPDQ@OHIWµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q?% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

7KHUHDUHQXPHURXVH[DPSOHVRIUHODWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVLQ+XUULDQDQGWKH\DOOFRQIRUPWRWKHHUJDWLYHV\V
WHP5HODWLYHVFDQEHIRUPHGE\HLWKHUDQLQWURGXFWRU\SDUWLFOH#'(– ROGHU!– WKHQRPLQDOL]DWLRQRIDFRQMXJDWHG
YHUEZLWKWKHPRUSKHPH–kk!RUDFRPELQDWLRQRIWKHWZR1RWHWKHH[DPSOHVJLYHQKHUH

>@ L\č–.–DQ WčQ–(?%% x. # –.( )( DY̒ߖߖL–..(–>()

 5(/3/(1&/()PDNH$*$*5RWKHU3/$%6ZKHUH3/(1&/>()
 ´7KHRWKHU WKLQJV ZKLFK,PDGHZKHUHDUHWKH\"µ 0LWWLL

>@ ࡃU–(?–ঈ–č–kk!–Qč–PčQ WLYH–QD IDТU–6–))#–)

 GHVLUH$*$*53/(3(17+5(/3/$%6>()WKLQJ3/$%6JRRG$'9)
% #k$() # –#::1–ঈ–(%% (==1–ঈ DJX–9(%% !" # –y–GD WčQ–(k$–#–!)
 EHWZHHQ32663/(66RQH(5*RQH'$7VHOI3266',5PDNH(k$$&7-866
% QҸU–6–ঈ # –(!%$#kk()
 VZLIWO\ YHU\
 ´7KRVHWKLQJVZKLFKZHGHVLUHLQDEHDXWLIXOZD\EHWZHHQXVPD\RQHGRIRUWKHRWKHUH[FHHGLQJO\
VZLIWO\µ 0LWWL²

7KURXJKWKHDQWLSDVVLYH+XUULDQDOORZVIRUWKHUHODWLYL]DWLRQRIDQ$13%\SURPRWLQJ$IURPWKHHUJDWLYH
WRWKHDEVROXWLYH LHIURPDVHFRQGDU\WRDSULPDU\UHODWLRQ WKHDQWLSDVVLYHDOORZV$WRIXQFWLRQDVWKHKHDGRI
DUHODWLYH,NQRZRIWZRFOHDUH[DPSOHVRIWKLVXVHRIWKHDQWLSDVVLYHWRDOORZWKHUHODWLYL]DWLRQRI$RP

>@ !–>!–)# )  $(kI–L ·čOOL%GN1&("(5(–ঈWDߖS–6–!)

 5(/6*(1&/)#)GHVWUR\$36*'1(5* GHVWUR\75$1-866
 ´7KHRQHZKRGHVWUR\V WKHWHPSOHRI1HUJDO PD\/XEDGDJDGHVWUR\WKDWRQHµ 7LߖDWDO²

>@ (-) # –(–)%I(.–#–==#–kk!%% !)#–"(% (-–Rঈ–6.–(–>Z>@(

 VLQ(66)NQRZ$31(*5(/JRG',5UXVKRঈ6.,175$1>>(
 ´7KHRQHZKRGRHVQRWNQRZVLQUXVKHVWRWKHJRGµ 56

:KLOHWKHSDWLHQWLQ>@LVRPLWWHGLWLVFHUWDLQO\WKHWHPSOHRI1HUJDOZKLFKLVWKHWRSLFRIWKHHQWLUHLQVFULSWLRQ
$VVXFKWKHOLVWHQHU RUUHDGHU ZRXOGFHUWDLQO\KDYHXQGHUVWRRGWKDWLWZDVWKHWHPSOHWKDWZDVWKHSDWLHQWRI
WKHYHUE$(kI´WRGHVWUR\µ7KHDEVROXWLYHWKLUGVLQJXODUHQFOLWLF–>!–FDQRQO\VWDQGIRUWKHRQHGRLQJWKHDFWRI
GHVWUR\LQJ,Q>@WKLVFRPSOH[VHQWHQFHLQWURGXFHVDQHZVHFWLRQRIWKHWH[W)RUWKLVUHDVRQWKHSDWLHQW(-)#2%
ZKLFKLVQHZLQIRUPDWLRQLVH[SOLFLW,QRUGHUIRUWKH$13VRIERWKUHODWLYHFODXVHVLQ>@DQG>@WRIXQFWLRQ
DVWKHKHDGVWKH\DUHSURPRWHGWRWKHDEVROXWLYHWKURXJKXVHRIWKHDQWLSDVVLYHYRLFH
,QVXPPDU\WKHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHRI$LQ+XUULDQLVDVHFRQGDU\UHODWLRQ,WLVUHSUHVHQWHGE\WKHHUJDWLYH
FDVHLQLQGLFDWLYHWUDQVLWLYHFODXVHVDQGLQPRVWPRGDOFRQVWUXFWLRQV,QWKHLQGLFDWLYH$FDQEHSURPRWHGWRWKH
DEVROXWLYHFDVH LHWRDSULPDU\UHODWLRQ ZKHQWKHYHUELVLQWKHDQWLSDVVLYH,QVRPHPRGDOIRUPVHVSHFLDOO\
WKHLPSHUDWLYHDQGDJHQWLYHIRUPVRIWKHRSWDWLYH+XUULDQGRHVQRWRSHUDWHDVDQHUJDWLYHODQJXDJHDQGZHILQG
WKHUHODWLRQ$ 6ZKHUHERWKDUHLQWKHDEVROXWLYHFDVH

)=>?:@<
7KHVLQJOHDUJXPHQWRU613RIDQLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUELVDOZD\VLQWKHDEVROXWLYH,QIDFWWKHUHDUHQRH[DPSOHV
RI613VRFFXUULQJLQDQ\FDVHRWKHUWKDQWKHDEVROXWLYH7KHUHDUHQRFRQVWUXFWLRQVZLWKGDWLYHVXEMHFWVRIWKH
KE=J%80%5!+$%>#-%51$%IRXQGLQ*HUPDQDQGPDQ\RWKHUODQJXDJHV
+XUULDQGRHVQRWGLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQDJHQWLYHDQGSDWLHQWLYH613VWKURXJKFDVHPRUSKRORJ\7KDWLVWR
96E2%8H%(L7786H%$! 65DUHERWKLQWKH–‘DEVROXWLYH$GLVWLQFWLRQLVPDGHDPRQJDFWLYHSDWLHQWLYHDQGVWDWLYH
VLQJOHDUJXPHQWYHUEVWKURXJKYHUEDOPRUSKRORJ\7KUHHGLVWLQFWPRUSKHPHVDUHIRXQGZLWKPRQRYDOHQWQRQ


*LRUJLHUL²:HJQHU² IRUFHRIWKHPDLQFODXVHLV´PD\/XEDGDJDGHVWUR\+#>µZLWKHPSKD
RP
7KLVSRVLWLRQLVVKDUHGE\*LRUJLHUL² VLVRQWKHSDWLHQWDQGQRWWKHDJHQW

,WLVSRVVLEOHWKDW–6–LQWKHHDUOLHVWWH[WVGLGQRW\HWKDYHWKH
IXQFWLRQRIDSDWLHQWLYHPDUNHU,ILWLVWREHWDNHQDVVXFKWKHQWKH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% QO

DQWLSDVVLYHYHUEVLQ+XUULDQ–(2%–12%–!:KLOHWKHH[DFWIXQFWLRQVRIWKHVHPRUSKHPHVHVSHFLDOO\–1DQG–!2%
KDYH\HWWREHGHWHUPLQHGFHUWDLQFKDUDFWHULVWLFVFDQEHREVHUYHG
7KHPRUSKHPH–(LVXVHGZKHQWKHVXEMHFWH[KLELWVFRQWURORYHUWKHDFWLRQDQGLVWKHUHIRUHDJHQWOLNH

>@ LQQč–Pč–QҸQ XQ–̒W–$–(

 ZKHQ6*(1&/)#)FRPH)87$,175$1
 ´:KHQVKHFRPHVµ 0LWWLLL

>@ G
*!kk6&% V%=!k+઄#–)#%% )(+઄+઄–(–&
 '1‘$%6«WKURQH$%/,167VLW,175$13(5)"
 ´7HߖߖREVDWGRZQRQWKHWKURQH«µ .%RL

,QERWKH[DPSOHVWKH613LVDJHQWOLNH LH6 ! 9LUWXDOO\HYHU\H[DPSOHRIDQLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUELQ–(FDQEH

WDNHQDVDFWLYH
,QFRQWUDVWWRIRUPVLQ–(LQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVLQ–1DQG–!DUHXVHGZKHQWKH613LVDQXQGHUJRHURUGRHVQRW
RUVHHPVQRWWR FRQWUROWKHDFWLRQ6LVWKHUHIRUHFORVHUWRDSDWLHQW LH63 ZKHQWKHVHPRUSKHPHVDUHXVHG
7KHPRUSKHPH–!LVRIWHQXVHGZLWKH[LVWHQWLDOYHUEVRUYHUEVRIVWDWH

>@ PčQQ–H WDUঈXZčQL

 LV67$7SHUVRQKXPDQ‘$%6
 ´ ,W LVDSHUVRQµ .%RL

7KHPRUSKHPH–1LVRIWHQXVHGZKHQWKHVXEMHFWKDVQRFRQWURORYHUWKHDFWLRQDQGLVXVXDOO\DIIHFWHGE\WKH
SUHGLFDWH7KLVLVFOHDUZLWKWKHXVHRIWKLVPRUSKHPHZLWKWKHYHUE:(-–´WREH FRPH VLFNµ

>@ IDEčQL «IčU–1%% #k$() # –Ҹ–"(

 PRXQWDLQ‘$%6«VLFN,175$1LQVLGH6*3266',5
 ´7KHPRXQWDLQ XSRQKHDULQJDERXWWKHFXUVH EHFDPHVLFNZLWKLQKLPVHOI µ .%RL

,WLVQRWDOZD\VVRHDV\WRGHWHUPLQHWKHIXQFWLRQRIWKLVPRUSKHPH–17KHUHDUHH[DPSOHVLQZKLFKYHUEV
8H%–1DUHFOHDUO\FRQWUDVWHGWRHLWKHUWKHVDPHYHUERUDWOHDVWDVHPDQWLFDOO\VLPLODURQHLQ–(%*K%89%=F998D>J2%
LIQRWOLNHO\WKDWWKLVPRUSKHPHDOVRKDVDGHWUDQVLWLYL]LQJIXQFWLRQDQGPD\KDYHVRPHSURSHUWLHVRIDPLGGOH
YRLFHPDUNHU)XUWKHUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ–1DQG–!%G7FM%–(LVWKDWWKHIRUPHUWZRPRUSKHPHVGRQRWDSSHDUZLWK
WKHWHQVHPDUNHUV–Rঈ–%F7%–!"–
7KHGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQDJHQWLYHDQGSDWLHQWLYHLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVLVDOVRIRXQGLQWKHPRGDOV\VWHP$VQRWHG
DERYHWKHLPSHUDWLYHGLVWLQJXLVKHVEHWZHHQWUDQVLWLYHDQGLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEV VHH>@DERYH ZKLOHRWKHUPRRGV
VKRZDVSOLWEHWZHHQDJHQWLYHDQGSDWLHQWLYHRQHV,QWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVLQWKHDJHQWLYHYRLFHEHKDYHLGHQWLFDOO\WR
WUDQVLWLYHRQHVLQWKHLUXVHRIWKHPRUSKHPH–#–N


*LRUJLHUL²:HJQHU:LOKHOPD:LO
KHOP GRHVQRWLQFOXGH–1LQKLVWUHDWPHQWRI+XUULDQ 

*LRUJLHULFDWHJRUL]HVYHUEVLQ–(DV´LQWUDQVLWLYHGLPRYLPHQWRµ
² 7KLVLVDOLWWOHPLVOHDGLQJLQWKDWQRWDOOYHUEVLQ–(%
DUHYHUEVRIPRYHPHQWVXFKDV)(+઄ +઄ ´WRVLWµ VHHH[DPSOH>@ 

,QKHUJUDPPDU:HJQHU  QRWHVWKDW$1IIZKLOHQRU
PDOO\WDNLQJ–!LQWKHLQGLFDWLYHKDVWKHIRUP$1II–(–kk!–)(%8H%6%
UHODWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQ 0LWWLLL ,WLVXQFOHDUZK\WKHPRUSKHPH
–(LVXVHGKHUHLQVWHDGRI–!,VLWDUHIOHFWLRQRIWKHSKRQHWLFVWDWXV
FG%–!%69%W̾RUGRHVLWDFWXDOO\UHSUHVHQWVRPHGLIIHUHQFHLQJUDPPDU
EHWZHHQ%$1II–!DQG$1II–(–kk!S

*LRUJLHULODEHOVYHUEVLQ–!DVVWDWLYH ² EXWFODVVL
G8J9%–1DV´LQYHUELDSSDUHQWHPHQWHLQWUDQVLWLYHEHQFKpODIXQ]LRQH
HVDWWDGLTXHVWRPRUIHPDVLDDQFRUDSRFRFKLDUDµ  :HJQHU
GRHVQRWDWWHPSWWRGHILQHDIXQFWLRQIRUHLWKHUPRUSKHPH 
O?O%Z–#W!@>–1@ .KDɥLNMDQFDOOVIRUPVLQ–1´VWDWLYHµ  
:LOKHOPXVHVWKHWHUPVWDWLYHIRUYHUEVLQ–#W!  

2USHUKDSVVLPSO\WKHWKLUGVLQJXODUSURQRXQ"

,Q.%RZHILQGWKHIROORZLQJWZRFODXVHVIURPZLWKLQWKH
96MJ%=6996IJN%čL%+઄ !))#%G*!kk6&%+઄ !)G–čG–1%V%+઄ !)G–DLঈRТQ # –(#%G*!kk6&%
.%RL ² 7ZRGLIIHUHQWXVHVRIWKHYHUE+઄ !)GDUHXVHGKHUH
WKHILUVWLQ–1 ZLWKWKHGHULYDWLRQDOPRUSKHPH–čG– ZKLOHWKH
VHFRQGLVDURRWIRUPZLWKWKH DFWLYH LQWUDQVLWLYHPRUSKHPH–(
,QDQRWKHUWH[WRIWKH+XUUR+LWWLWHELOLQJXDOZHILQGWKHIROORZLQJ
*!kk6&%:(-–Lঈ–(–))(% GǴOOčQL–YDߖHТO–1%Z+઄ @(#=(. # –.# )#  .%RL
² ,QWKLVSDVVDJHZHKDYHWZRDSSDUHQWYHUEVRIPRWLRQ WKH:(-–%
KHUHLVOLNHO\DKRPRQ\PWRWKH:(-–´WREH>FRPH@VLFNµ ,QP\WDON
´9RLFHDQG9DOHQFHLQ+XUULDQµDWWKHJ5HQFRQWUH$VV\ULRORJLTXH
,QWHUQDWLRQDOH0RVFRZ6W3HWHUVEXUJ-XO\²,SURSRVHG
WKDW–1PD\IXQFWLRQOLNHDPLGGOHYRLFHPDUNHUHLWKHULQGLFDWLQJ
WKDWWKH613KDVOLWWOHWRQRFRQWURORYHUWKHDFWLRQRUWRSODFHWKH
IRFXVRIWKHFODXVHRQWKHDFWLRQDQGQRWLWVHQGSRLQW SDUWLFXODUO\
ZLWKYHUEVRIPRWLRQ 0XFKPRUHZRUNQHHGVWREHFRQGXFWHGRQ
WKLVWRSLF

:HJQHU:LOKHOPD
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q:% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

>@ 1)–#– ! ঈ ߖ‫گ‬YL I‫گ‬UL

 FRPH$&7237HYLO‘$%6H\H‘$%6
 ´0D\WKHHYLOH\HFRPHµ &K6,L 

>@ ߖ̒Q ( –LII̒–Q WčG–XJčU–#– ! ঈ ߖ€–-(

 EURWKHU6*3266)ORYH5(&,3$&72376*&20
 ´0D\P\EURWKHUVKDUHORYHZLWKPHµ 0LWWLL

7KH613LVWKHFRQWUROOHURIWKHDFWLRQLQERWK>@DQG>@DQGWKHYHUEVDUHWKHUHIRUHLGHQWLFDOWRWUDQVLWLYH
FRQVWUXFWLRQVLQ–#–,WFDQEHVWDWHGWKDWPRGDOYHUEVLQ–#– 9–#–02' DUHIRXQGRQO\ZLWK$DQG6$13V
7KHSDWLHQWLYHPRUSKHPH–6–LVXVHGZLWKLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVZKHUHWKHVXEMHFWHLWKHUXQGHUJRHVDFKDQJH
LQVWDWHRUGRHVQRWFRQWUROWKHDFWLRQ FIH[DPSOH>@ 7KHIROORZLQJSDVVDJHIURPWKH0LWWDQL/HWWHUW\SLILHV
WKHXVHRI–6–ZLWKPRQRYDOHQWYHUEV

>@ LQQč–PPDPDQߖ̒Q ( –#::1–9!%% $Z6@-1&#% 1-–‫)!–(?–گ‬

 LI>>(>() EURWKHU6*3266*(1HQHP\‘$%6H[LVW3$71(*-866
 ´,IRQO\WKHHQHP\RIP\EURWKHUGLGQRWH[LVWµ 0LWWLLL²

:KLOHWKHH[DFWSDUVLQJRIXU‫گ‬YDHQLVGHEDWDEOHLWLVFHUWDLQO\DSDWLHQWLYHPRGDOIRUP
&RPSDUHWKHSDVVDJHLQ>@ZLWKWKHIROORZLQJWUDQVLWLYHMXVVLYHIRUPLQ–6–IURPWKHVDPHWH[W

>@ +઄#(-–6–+઄+઄ # –č–$$ ( –čQ WH‫گ‬Q # –D ߖ̒Q ( –#::1–ঈ

 JROG 6+઄+઄# (666*(1&/()PXFK(66EURWKHU6*3266(5*
% =!&–čQ–6–!)
 SURYLGH () 3$7-866
 ´0D\P\EURWKHUSURYLGH>!ZLWKPXFKJROGµ 0LWWLLL² @?

,Q>@WKHMXVVLYHYHUELVLQ–6–!)LQVWHDGRIWKHW\SLFDO–#–!)7KHVHPDQWLFSDWLHQW+઄#(-6+઄+઄(%WH‫گ‬QDLVLQWKHHV
VLYHZKLOHWKHUHFLSLHQWWKHILUVWSHUVRQ–$$(LVLQWKHDEVROXWLYH@O,Q>@–6–LVXVHGEHFDXVHWKHYHUE1-´WR
H[LVWµLQGLFDWHVWKDWWKH613LVLQDSDUWLFXODUVWDWH,Q>@ZHKDYHDGLIIHUHQWXVHRIWKHPRUSKHPH–6–,QWKLV
H[DPSOHLWLVXVHGZLWKDWUDQVLWLYHYHUEWRLQGLFDWHWKDWWKHDEVROXWLYH13 KHUHWKHVHPDQWLFUHFLSLHQW LVPRUH
WRSLFDOWKDQWKH3DWLHQW7KHVHH[DPSOHVVXSSRUWWKHWKHRU\WKDWWKLV–6–PRUSKHPHLVUHODWHGWRQRQDJHQWV
LHSDWLHQWV>365@DQGDEVROXWLYHUHFLSLHQWV>%‘@UHVSHFWLYHO\ 7KLVWRSLFLVUHYLVLWHGEHORZ
7KHGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQDFWLYHDQGSDWLHQWLYHVWDWLYHLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVLVQHXWUDOL]HGLQWKHQHJDWLYH$OO
LQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVDUHQHJDWHGE\WKHFRPELQDWLRQRIPRUSKHPHV–6==6IRUZKLFKWKHH[DFWSDUVLQJLVXQFHUWDLQ
7ZRFRPSHWLQJDQDO\VHVRIWKHQHJDWLYHLQWUDQVLWLYHGRPLQDWHWKHVFKRODUO\OLWHUDWXUHRQ+XUULDQ$FFRUGLQJWR
:HJQHUWKHILUVW6LVWREHVHHQDVDQDOORPRUSKRIWKHLQWUDQVLWLYH(ZKLOH–==–LVWKHDFWXDOQHJDWLYHPRUSKHPH@:%
6KHGRHVQRWRIIHUDQH[SODQDWLRQIRUWKHIXQFWLRQRIWKHILQDO6H[FHSWWRQRWHWKDWLWJRHVWR(ZKHQIROORZHGE\
DQHQFOLWLFSURQRXQ LH–(>6@–(1&/ 
!%MF7J%=7JGJ76D>J%6H6>E989%FG%–6==6LVDYDLODEOHLIZHLQFOXGHWKHQHJDWLYHDQWLSDVVLYHIRUPLQWKHGLVFXVVLRQ
7KHQHJDWLYHDQWLSDVVLYHLVIRUPHGLQDPDQQHUVLPLODUWRWKHLQWUDQVLWLYH:KLOHWKHQHJDWLYHLQWUDQVLWLYHLVLQ
–6==6WKHQHJDWLYHDQWLSDVVLYHLVLQ –#==#7KLVVLPLODULW\KDVOHGVRPHWRWKHRUL]HWKDWWKHQHJDWLYHPRUSKHPH
89%–==9ZKHUH9LVGHWHUPLQHGE\WKHYDOHQFH–1W6ZLWKLQWUDQVLWLYHVDQG–#ZLWKDQWLSDVVLYHV@Q7KHILQDOYRZHO
H[KLELWVDVKLIWRI9!(ZKHQIROORZHGE\DQHQFOLWLFSURQRXQ LH –#W6–==#W6–)+"-%X% –#W6–==(–(1&/ ,IWKLV


,WLVSRVVLEOHWRUHDGk1–1–&#KHUHDVDILUVWSHUVRQJHQLWLYHߖ‫–گ‬9!% FDXVH–1l6–RFFXUVLQWKHVDPHSRVLWLRQDVWKHLQWUDQVLWLYH–(GRHV
´P\ H\H µ QRWPHDQWKDWWKH\DUHDOORPRUSKV6LQFHDOOPRQRYDOHQWYHUEVEH

:HJQHURIIHUVWKHDOWHUQDWHDQDO\VLVRIWKLVIRUPDVDMXVVLYHLQ WKH\LQ–(2%–!2%F7%–1LQWKHSRVLWLYHDUH–1W6–LQWKHQHJDWLYHWKHUH
1-–69!)  7KLVLVXQOLNHO\EDVHGRQWKHIRUPNHEčQRHQ VHH DSSHDUVWREHDQHXWUDOL]DWLRQRIWKHVHGLIIHUHQWHQGLQJV VHHWDEOH
H[DPSOH>@   7RFDOO–1W6– DQDOORPRUSKRI–(GRHVQRWH[SODLQKRZ–!DQG
@?
)RUPRUHRQWKLVSDVVDJHVHHEHORZ –1DUHDIIHFWHGLQWKHQHJDWLYH,WLVWKHUHIRUHKLJKO\XQOLNHO\WKDW
–1W6–LVDQDOORPRUSKRI–(2%–#DQG–1
@O
)RUWKHVKLIWRIWKHLQGLUHFWREMHFWIURPWKHREOLTXHGDWLYHGLUHF
WLYHWRWKHDEVROXWLYHVHHEHORZ
@Q
*LRUJLHUL:LOKHOPD:LOKHOP
@:
:HJQHU,QP\RSLQLRQZHVKRXOGQRWEHRYHUO\KDVW\
DWFDOOLQJDSDUWLFXODUPRUSKHPHDQDOORPRUSKRIDQRWKHU-XVWEH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% QQ

DQDO\VLVRIWKHQHJDWLYHZLWKPRQRYDOHQWYHUEVDV–==9LVFRUUHFWWKHQZHDUHOHIWZLWKWKHDQWLSDVVLYHPRUSKHPH
–#–DQGDPRUSKHPH–1W6–ZLWKLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEV7KLVPHDQVWKDWLQWUDQVLWLYHVLQ–(2%–!DQG–1DUHQHXWUDOL]HG
LQWKHQHJDWLYHZLWKDOORIWKHPPDUNHGDV–1W6–@<,ZRQGHULIWKLV–1W6–PRUSKHPHRIWKHQHJDWLYHLVUHODWHGWR
WKH–1PRUSKHPHPHQWLRQHGDERYH@R
7KHIROORZLQJWZRH[DPSOHVGHPRQVWUDWHWKHFRQVROLGDWLRQRIDFWLYHDQGSDWLHQWLYHLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVLQWR
RQHIRUPLQWKHQHJDWLYH,QWKHILUVWH[DPSOHZHILQGWKHDFWLYHLQWUDQVLWLYH1)6==6 FRPSDUHZLWKWKHSRVLWLYH
IRUPLQ>@ DQGWKHSDWLHQWLYH$1II6==6LQ>@,QWKHSRVLWLYHWKHIRUPHULVLQ –(ZKLOHWKHODWWHULVLQ –!,Q
ERWKFDVHVWKH613LVLQWKHDEVROXWLYH

>@ DQGL ࡃQ–6–==( v6 –.–()

 WKLV‘$%6FRPH,175$11(*3/(1&/()
 ´7KHVH PDOLFLRXVVSHDNHUVZRUGV" GRQRWFRPH EHIRUHDJUHDWNLQJ µ 0LWWLY

>@ (y–)%d%$1II # –#–Dঈ WXSS–6–==6

 LI)«WDEOHW32663/‘$%6DYDLODEOH,175$11(*
 ´,IWKHLUWDEOHWV WKRVHRIWKHGRZULHVRIP\IHPDOHUHODWLYHV DUHQRWDYDLODEOH«µ 0LWWLLL² 

7DEOHLQGLFDWHVWKHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQSRVLWLYHPRQRYDOHQWYHUEVDQGQHJDWLYHRQHV

7DEOH3RVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYHLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEDOPRUSKRORJ\

@60#$#?! B!5($#?!

$FWLYH 1–(
1–6–==6
3DWLHQWLYH 1–12%1–!

$IXUWKHUQHJDWLYHPRUSKHPH–6&W?1- SHUKDSV–6–&W?1- LVIRXQGLQWKH+XUUR+LWWLWHELOLQJXDO,QWKHSDU

DEOHWH[W.%RLWLVFRQVLVWHQWO\IRXQGLQWKHLQWURGXFWLRQWRWKHDSRGRVLVRIWKHSDUDEOHVLQWKHIRUPXOD;
>())–6–&W?1-%>())–HWDUঈXZDQL´LWLVQRW;LWLVDSHUVRQµZKHUH;LVWKHWRSLFRIWKHSURWDVLVRIWKHSDUDEOH
2XWVLGHRIWKLVWH[WRQHRWKHUH[DPSOH=1.–"–6 – &W?1- &K6,LLL LVNQRZQ@@,WLVXQFOHDUKRZWKLV
QHJDWLYHPRUSKHPHIXQFWLRQV
'DWDRQUHIOH[LYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVLQ+XUULDQDUHODUJHO\ODFNLQJ7KHUHLVVRPHOLPLWHGHYLGHQFHWKDW+XUULDQ
XVHVLQWUDQVLWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVLQRUGHUWRFUHDWHUHIOH[LYHVRIWUDQVLWLYHYHUEV7KHUHLVRQHFOHDUH[DPSOHRI
ZKLFK,DPDZDUHRIDFHUWDLQUHIOH[LYHFRQVWUXFWLRQ7KLVH[DPSOHLQYROYHVWKHWUDQVLWLYHYHUE1"-´WRSURWHFWµ
,WGRHVQRWKRZHYHUGHFOLQHDVDWUDQVLWLYHYHUELQWKLVH[DPSOHEXWUDWKHUDVDQLQWUDQVLWLYH
7KHXVHRILQWUDQVLWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVIRUWUDQVLWLYHUHIOH[LYHYHUEVLVQRWZLWKRXWSDUDOOHOV,Q:HVW*UHHQ
ODQGLFZKHQWKHVXEMHFWLV FRQVFLRXVO\ GRLQJVRPHWKLQJWRKLPVHOIWKLVDFWLRQLVH[SUHVVHGWKURXJKDGHULYHG
LQWUDQVLWLYHDQG)6$WKURXJKDWUDQVLWLYH@P1RWHWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV

>@ />>#M)1$%% $1X1IMI1X

 KLPVHOI'$7NLOO,1'6*
 ´+HNLOOHGKLPVHOI µ

@<
6HH.KDɥLNMDQ PHVVHQJHUV DUH SUHVHQWµ 0LWW LL ²  ,QWHUHVWLQJO\ DOWKRXJK
@R
2QHSRVVLEOHH[SODQDWLRQIRUWKLVLVWKDWWKHQHJDWLYHLQWUDQVLWLYH $1IIVHHPVWRSULPDULO\WDNH–!LQWKHSRVLWLYHLQGLFDWLYHZKHQ
YHUEVDUHVWDWLYHOLNHHYHQZLWKDJHQWLYHYHUEV,QWKHFODXVH´WKH LWLVUHODWLYL]HGWKHPRUSKHPH–(LVXVHG HJ$1II–(–kk!–)(´DOO
SULQFHVVLVQRWFRPLQJµWKHVXEMHFWKDVQRFRQWURORYHUWKHDFWLRQ WKRVH>WKLQJV@ZKLFKDUHSUHVHQWDVVHPEOHGµ>0LWWLL@ 
SDUWLFXODUO\VLQFHWKHDFWLRQLVQRWRFFXUULQJ)RUWKLVUHDVRQLWPD\ @@
:HJQHU
EHWKDWDOOPRQRYDOHQWYHUEVEHWKH\DJHQWLYHRUVWDWLYHSDWLHQWLYH 
&DPSEHOOD²
DUHWUHDWHGDVSDWLHQWLYHLQWKHQHJDWLYH7KLVFRXOGH[SODLQZK\DF @P
'L[RQ
WLYHLQWUDQVLWLYHVDUHQRWQHJDWHGE\DPRUSKHPH –(–==( 
%RN%HQQHPD D 

$QH[DPSOHRI$1IILQWKHSRVLWLYHLVx. # –. ()( –čQ‫گ‬PҸQ # –
QDSDߖߖҸW+઄ ! –QDߖࡃD–..(–>()%$1II–!´WKHRWKHUODQGV DQG DOOWKH
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q<% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

>@ <)51$% #>>#M)1$%% $(=1M?1X

 PDQ$%6KLPVHOI'$7VHH,1'6*
 ´7KHPDQVHHVKLPVHOI µ

7KHWUDQVLWLYHYHUE$1X1ILVWUDQVLWLYHDQGLQLQGLFDWLYHFODXVHVIXQFWLRQVDVVXFKZLWKDQHUJDWLYH$JHQWDQGDQ
DEVROXWLYH3DWLHQW,Q>@WKH313LVWKHUHIOH[LYH#>>#DQGLWLVQRWLQWKHDEVROXWLYHEXWUDWKHULQWKHGDWLYH
FDVH,Q>@ZHVHHWKDWWKH$JHQWZKHQH[SUHVVHGLVLQWKHDEVROXWLYHDQGFDQEHXQGHUVWRRGDVDGHULYHG613
$VPHQWLRQHG,NQRZRIRQO\RQHFOHDUH[DPSOHRIDUHIOH[LYHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQ+XUULDQ,WLVWKHUHIRUHIDU
IURPFHUWDLQWKDW+XUULDQGRHVLQGHHGXVHGHULYHGLQWUDQVLWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVWRH[SUHVVWUDQVLWLYHUHIOH[LYHV7KH
H[DPSOHRIDWUDQVLWLYHUHIOH[LYHLVIRXQGLQWKH+XUUR$NNDGLDQELOLQJXDOIURP8JDULW

>@ #"#–I–I(–)% 1"-–()–(

 VHOI6*3266'$7)SURWHFW () ,03,175$1
 ´3URWHFW\RXUVHOIµ 56

7KLVLVWUDQVODWHGLQWR$NNDGLDQDV

>@ I(5(-=(%k1..#>
 ´3URWHFW\RXUVHOIµ 56

7KHUHIOH[LYHLQ$NNDGLDQLVH[SUHVVHGE\WKHXVHRIWKHI(5-1´ERG\VHOIµDQGLWFRUUHVSRQGVWRWKHGDWLYH ZLWK
VHFRQGVLQJXODUSRVVLYH–& #"#–I–I(LQWKH+XUULDQ7KH$NNDGLDQFRQVWUXFWLRQLVWUDQVLWLYHEXWWKH+XUULDQLV
LQWUDQVLWLYHDVLQGLFDWHGE\WKHPRUSKHPH–(RQWKHYHUE%1"-–()–(8QWLOPRUHHYLGHQFHLVIRXQGIRUUHIOH[LYH
FRQVWUXFWLRQVLQ+XUULDQWKLVDQDO\VLVRI>@ZLOOKDYHWRUHPDLQWHQWDWLYH$VLWVWDQGVKRZHYHUWKLVH[DPSOH
GRHVVHHPWRVSHDNLQIDYRURILW

.A<B:;<
7KHJUDPPDWLFDOUROH3XVXDOO\FRUUHODWHVWRWKHQRWLRQDOUROHRISDWLHQWWKDWLVWRVD\WKHDIIHFWHGRUFRQ
WUROOHG13RIDWUDQVLWLYHYHUE$VZLWKPRVW LIQRWDOO ODQJXDJHVWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHRI3LQ+XUULDQFRYHUVD
UDQJHRIQRWLRQDOUROHV)RUH[DPSOH3LVXVHGWRLQGLFDWHWKH´H[SHULHQFHGµZLWKYHUEVRIVHQVHVXFKDV:6-´WR
VHHµ

>@ QLТčUL–PčQNXUR ߖ̒Q ( –#::1–ঈ IRU–z"–(

 GRZU\PčQIXUWKHUPRUHEURWKHU6*3266(5*VHH)876*$*$*5
 ´)XUWKHUPRUHP\EURWKHUZLOOVHHWKHGRZU\µ 0LWWLLL

,QWKHDERYHH[DPSOHWKH313QLТčULLVQRWDWUXHVHPDQWLFSDWLHQW,WLVQRWDIIHFWHGLQDQ\ZD\E\WKHDFWRI
VHHLQJ'HVSLWHWKLVODFNRIDIIHFWHGQHVVRURIEHLQJFRQWUROOHGLWLVVWLOOWKHGLUHFWREMHFWRIWKHYHUE:6-DQGLV
WKHUHIRUHWREHFRQVLGHUHGD3DWLHQW
7KH313LVW\SLFDOO\LQWKH‘DEVROXWLYH7KHUHDUHVLWXDWLRQVKRZHYHUZKHUHLWLVGHPRWHGWRWKHREOLTXH
HVVLYHFDVH7KLVLVDW\SLFDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFRIDQWLSDVVLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVZLWKH[SUHVVHGSDWLHQW$VDOUHDG\PHQ
WLRQHG+XUULDQRQO\DOORZVIRUGRXEOHDEVROXWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVLQFHUWDLQOLPLWHGQRQHUJDWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
6LQFHWKHDQWLSDVVLYHLVDIHDWXUHRIHUJDWLYLW\WKHSURPRWLRQRIWKHDJHQWIURPWKHHUJDWLYHWRWKHDEVROXWLYH
LQWKLVFRQVWUXFWLRQPHDQVWKDWVORWLQWKHFODXVHILOOHGE\DQDEVROXWLYH13 DQGW\SLFDOO\UHVHUYHGIRU313V LV
ILOOHGE\WKH$137KHDQWLSDVVLYHVKLIWVIRFXVDZD\IURPWKHSDWLHQWDQGRQWRHLWKHUWKHYHUERUWKHDJHQWDQG
VRLWLVWKHUHIRUHQRWVXUSULVLQJWKDWWKH313ZKHQSUHVHQWZRXOGEHSODFHGLQDQREOLTXHFDVH7KLVLVPXFKWKH
VDPHDVWKHXVHRIDQREOLTXHFDVHWRPDUNWKHDJHQWLQSDVVLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQV

%RN%HQQHPD F 
 
%3+#4(56%<00'-#()%H#4$#6)(-'%5%I(5-1PQJ
,WLVW\SLFDOO\DVVXPHGWKDWWKH$NNDGLDQLVWKHRULJLQDO´9RUODJHµ
 
%'F7%MF7J%FH%1"-VHH:LOKHOP
DQGWKH+XUULDQLVDWUDQVODWLRQRILW 'LMNVWUD 7KLVLVQRW
WKHSODFHWRGHOYHLQWRWKHUHGDFWLRQDOKLVWRU\RI56¬EXW,
ZRXOGOLNHWRPDNHDQREVHUYDWLRQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% QR

,QWKRVHPRGDOIRUPVLQ–#–ZKLFKUHTXLUHWKH$WREHLQWKHDEVROXWLYH VHHDERYH WKHSDWLHQWLVDOVRW\SL

FDOO\LQWKHDEVROXWLYH$VPHQWLRQHGWKLVUHVXOWVLQDVZLWFKIURPWKHHUJDWLYHV\VWHPWRDQRQHUJDWLYHRQH%
,QIDFWZLWKWKHVHIRUPVLWPD\EHVDLGWKDW+XUULDQRSHUDWHVXQGHUDQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHV\VWHP7KHVLWXD
WLRQLVWKHXVXDOVHWRIUHODWLRQV$ 6 3ZKHUHDOODUHLQWKH‘DEVROXWLYH:KLOHFHUWDLQO\QRWHUJDWLYHWKHUHLV
QRWKLQJDERXWWKLVVHWRIUHODWLRQVWKDWLPPHGLDWHO\VSHDNVIRUDQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHRQH,QFHUWDLQVLWXDWLRQV
SDUWLFXODUO\ZKHQWKHYHUELVGHWUDQVLWLYL]HGWKH313LVGHPRWHGIURPWKHDEVROXWLYHWRWKHHVVLYH7KLVGHPR
WLRQRI3ZDVGHPRQVWUDWHGLQH[DPSOH>@DERYH,WLVUHSHDWHGKHUHDV>@

>@ #-"#–E XUТ # –D WҸ ! –(%% =("–#–.–̒ঈ

 WRQJXH6*3266‘$%6WUXH(66ZRUG(66VSHDN$&7O237
 ´0D\\RXUWRQJXHVSHDNWUXHZRUG V µ &K6,LLL

7KHSDWLHQWXUТDWҸDLVQRQVSHFLILFKHUH,WLVQRWWKDWWKHWRQJXHLVWRVSHDNDQ\RQHSDUWLFXODUWUXHZRUGEXW
DOO DQGRQO\ WUXHZRUGV7KHIDFWWKDW3FDQEHGHPRWHGIURPDEVROXWLYHWRHVVLYHLQGLFDWHVWKDWLWLVWREHGLI
IHUHQWLDWHGIURP$DQG6HYHQWKRXJKDOODUHXVXDOO\LQWKHDEVROXWLYHFDVH)RUWKLVUHDVRQLWLVSRVVLEOHWKDWZLWK
WKHVHQRQHUJDWLYHPRGDOIRUPV+XUULDQLVRSHUDWLQJXQGHUDQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHV\VWHP

%HQHÀFLDU\
7KHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHRI%HQHILFLDU\LVXVHGKHUHLQWKHZLGHUVHQVHWRLQFOXGHQRWMXVWEHQHILFLDULHVEXWDOVR
UHFLSLHQWVDQGKXPDQJRDOV

>@ D ,EDNHGDFDNH:6-%A(-' EHQHILFLDU\

 E ,JDYHWKHERRN$6%A(-' UHFLSLHQW
 F ,WRRNIORZHUV$6%A(-' KXPDQJRDO 

7KH%HQHILFLDU\ RUSHUKDSVEHWWHU'DWLYH%HQHILFLDU\ LVWKHWKLUGDUJXPHQWRIDWULYDOHQWYHUE,QWUDGLWLRQDO

JUDPPDUWKH%13LVWKHLQGLUHFWREMHFWZKLOH3LVWKHGLUHFWREMHFW%13VDUHW\SLFDOO\DQLPDWHDQGDUHDIIHFWHG
E\WKHDFWLRQRIWKHSUHGLFDWHDOWKRXJKOHVVGLUHFWO\WKDQ3,QFHUWDLQVLWXDWLRQV+XUULDQDOORZVIRUGDWLYH
VKLIWZKLFKLVWKHSURPRWLRQRI%WRGLUHFWREMHFWSRVLWLRQ,QRWKHUZRUGVLQFDVHPDUNLQJODQJXDJHV%FDQEH
SURPRWHGIURPDQREOLTXHFDVHWRWKHFDVHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHGLUHFWREMHFW LHDEVROXWLYHLQHUJDWLYHV\VWHPV
DFFXVDWLYHLQQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHRQHV 
'DWLYHVKLIWDSSHDUVWREHSUDJPDWLFDOO\PRWLYDWHGLQ+XUULDQP?7KDWLVWRVD\GDWLYHVKLIWGRHVQRWRFFXU
LQ+XUULDQLQRUGHUWRILOOV\QWDFWLFSLYRWV HJWRDOORZ%13VWRIXQFWLRQDVKHDGVRIUHODWLYHFODXVHV $VZLWK
(QJOLVKWKHSURPRWLRQRI%W\SLFDOO\RFFXUVZKHQLWLVPRUHWRSLFDOWKDQ3PO,QFHUWDLQODQJXDJHVWKHVKLIWRI%
IURPLQGLUHFWREMHFWWRGLUHFWREMHFWUHVXOWVLQLVVXHVRIUHFRYHUDELOLW\,Q(QJOLVKZKHQ%LVSURPRWHGERWK%DQG
3DUHJUDPPDWLFDOO\XQPDUNHG HJ´-RKQJDYH0DU\WKHERRNµ P:7KHUHLVQRPRUSKRORJLFDOGLVWLQFWLRQPDGH
EHWZHHQ´0DU\µDQG´WKHERRNµ7KLVLVVXHRIUHFRYHUDELOLW\UHVXOWVLQPDMRUUHVWULFWLRQVRQWKHXVHRIGDWLYH


&DPSEHOO PHQWYHUEVLVDSULPDU\REMHFW %ODQVLWW'U\HU3DOPHU

%(J7J%XUТD´WUXWKµ FIH[DPSOH>@DERYH LVEHLQJXVHGDWWULEX ² 
WLYHO\WRPRGLI\$#!´ZRUGµDQGVR,KDYHWUDQVODWHGLWDVWKHDGMHF PO
'HSHQGLQJRQKRZWKHVSHDNHUZDQWVWRIRFXVWKHGLVFRXUVHWKH
WLYH´WUXHµ VHFRQGDU\WRSLFFDQVKLIWIURP3WR% SULPDU\WRSLFLVDWOHDVWLQ

,RZHWKLVREVHUYDWLRQWR3HWUD*RHGHJHEXXUH (QJOLVKWKH$13  *LYyQ² *LYyQQRWHVWKDWZKLOHGDWLYH

$GDSWHGIURP*LYyQ VKLIWLQ(QJOLVKLVXVXDOO\VHHQDV´RSWLRQDOµWKHUHFHUWDLQSDWWHUQV
GRHPHUJHDQG%LVPRUHRIWHQSURPRWHGZKHQLWLVDSURQRXQWKDQ

3DOPHU
ZKHQLWLVDQ13 ² 
P?
7KHUHDUHWZRW\SHVRIGDWLYHVKLIWRQHWKDWLVSUDJPDWLFDOO\PR P:
,Q5HODWLRQ*UDPPDUWKH313LQDFODXVHLQZKLFK%KDVEHHQ
WLYDWHGDQGRQHWKDWLVV\QWDFWLF,QVRPHODQJXDJHVLWLVWKH%13RI
SURPRWHGWRGLUHFWREMHFWLVDFWXDOO\DFK{PHXU$FK{PHXULVDQ
WULYDOHQWYHUEVWKDWDSSHDUVWREHLGHQWLILHGZLWKWKHVHFRQGWHUP
13ZKRVHXVXDOJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQLVWDNHQE\DQRWKHU13 'U\HU
RIDWKUHHWHUPYHUEWKHVSRWWKDWLVQRUPDOO\KHOGE\WKH3DWLHQW
 ,QWKHSKUDVH´-RKQJDYHWKHERRNWR0DU\µ´WKHERRNµ
,QVXFKFDVHVWKHWHUPVGLUHFWDQGLQGLUHFWREMHFWQRORQJHUDSSO\
LVWKHGLUHFWREMHFWZKLOH´WR0DU\µLVWKHLQGLUHFWREMHFW:KHQWKH
,QVWHDGZHDUHGHDOLQJZLWKSULPDU\DQGVHFRQGDU\REMHFWV,QWUL
SKUDVHXQGHUJRHVGDWLYHVKLIW´-RKQJDYH0DU\WKHERRNµ´0DU\µ
YDOHQWFRQVWUXFWLRQVZLWKREOLJDWRU\GDWLYHVKLIWWKH313LVWKH
EHFRPHVWKHGLUHFWREMHFWZKLOH´WKHERRNµHYHQWKRXJKLWLVWKH3
VHFRQGDU\UHODWLRQZKLOH%LVWKHSULPDU\7KH313RIWZRDUJX
13LVQRZDFK{PHXU
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

VKLIWLQ(QJOLVKPQ'DWLYHVKLIWLQ+XUULDQGRHVQRWUHVXOWLQWKHVDPHUHFRYHUDELOLW\SUREOHPVDVLWGRHVLQ(QJOLVK
:KLOH%LVSURPRWHGWRWKHGLUHFWREMHFWSRVLWLRQDQGLVWKHUHIRUHLQWKHDEVROXWLYHFDVH3GRHVQRWUHPDLQLQWKH
DEVROXWLYH,WLVLQVWHDGGHPRWHGWRWKHHVVLYH LHLI%౏%–‘WKHQ3౏%–( 7KHUHVXOWLVWKDWWKHWZRJUDPPDWLFDO
UROHVDUHNHSWPRUSKRORJLFDOO\GLVWLQFWIURPHDFKRWKHUDQGUHFRYHUDELOLW\LVWKHUHIRUHQRWDQLVVXH
7KHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHRI%HQHILFLDU\LVW\SLFDOO\PDUNHGE\HLWKHUWKHGDWLYH –?(ZLWKDOORPRUSK–9( RU
WKHGLUHFWLYH –"( FDVH7KHGLUHFWLYHW\SLFDOO\LQGLFDWHVWKHJRDORIDQDFWLRQZKLOHWKHGDWLYHFRYHUVWKHUROHV
W\SLFDOO\DVFULEHGWRWKHLQGLUHFWREMHFWLQJUDPPDUV7KHUHLVFHUWDLQO\RYHUODSEHWZHHQWKHGLUHFWLYHDQGWKH
GDWLYHEXWWKHH[DFWQDWXUHRIWKHVHFDVHVUHTXLUHVIXUWKHUUHVHDUFK1RWHWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHVRI%13VLQWKH
GDWLYHGLUHFWLYH7KH%13LVXQGHUOLQHGZKLOH3LVLQEROGIDFH

>@ % GLUHFWLYH
% ߖ̒Q ( –#::1–"(–CCD$E–čQ QҸURঈDHWLߖߖDQSDߖߖ–Rঈ–čY
 EURWKHU6*3266',53/(1&/()%) YHU\ VHQG35(76*$*$*5
 ´,KDYHVHQW<F:G%WRP\EURWKHU%#)%$+!%&!0$%6:%9('0µ 0LWWLY²

>@ % GDWLYH
% ,઄RUöH#"–*I*D$E–čQ ߖ̒Q ( –#Z::1–ঈ M
A()@̒–-Z(@≠ߖ‫(?–گ‬±
 VROGLHU‘$%63/(1&/()EURWKHU6*3266(5*31&206*'$7
% I(kk–{ঈ–(
 VHQG35(76*$*$*5
 ´0>\@EURWKHUKDVVHQWVROGL>HU@V%KF%MJZLWK>0DQ@Hµ 0LWWLL²

>@ % GDWLYHYHUE
% ߖ̒Q ( –#::1–9(–**D$E–čQ NHE–čQ–Rঈ–čY–--.–/$%
 EURWKHU6*3266'$73/(1&/()VHQG () 35(76*$*$*55(/3/5(/$7
% =!&–čQ–Rঈ–čY–**$–>()
 VHQG () 35(76*$*$*53/(1&/>()
 ´&FJK:ZKLFK,KDYHVHQWWRP\EURWKHU,KDYHVHQW<F:Gµ 0LWWLLL² P<

6HYHUDOH[DPSOHVRIWKHSURPRWLRQRI%IURPWKHGDWLYHGLUHFWLYHWRWKHDEVROXWLYHDUHIRXQGWKURXJKRXWWKH
+XUULDQWH[WFRUSXV:KLOHLQIUHTXHQWO\DWWHVWHGFHUWDLQFRQFOXVLRQVFDQEHGUDZQ,QHYHU\FDVHWKHSDWLHQW
LVLQDQLPDWHZKLOHWKH%HQHILFLDU\LVDQLPDWH7KLVGRHVQRWPHDQKRZHYHUWKDWWKHSURPRWLRQRI%WRDEVROX
WLYHLVFRQGLWLRQHGE\WKHHPSDWK\KLHUDUFK\PR7KHSURPRWLRQRI%WRWKHDEVROXWLYHLVQRWPDQGDWRU\ZKHQLWLV
KLJKHURQWKHDQLPDF\VFDOHWKDQ37KLVSURPRWLRQLQ+XUULDQDSSHDUVLQVWHDGWRKDYHDWRSLFDOL]LQJIXQFWLRQ
:KHQ%LVSURPRWHGLWLVEHFDXVHLWLVPRUHWRSLFDOWKDQWKHDFWXDOSDWLHQWLQDSDUWLFXODUFODXVH'DWLYHVKLIW
SODFHVLQFUHDVHGHPSKDVLVRQ%DWWKHH[SHQVHRI37KLVHPSKDVLVRI%LVIXUWKHULQGLFDWHGE\WKHGHPRWLRQRI3
IURPWKHDEVROXWLYHWRWKHHVVLYH
7KHSURPRWLRQRI%DQGVXEVHTXHQWGHPRWLRQRI3KDVFHUWDLQLPSOLFDWLRQVIRU+XUULDQJUDPPDU2XWVLGH
RIWKHLPSHUDWLYHDQGDFWLYHRSWDWLYH+XUULDQGRHVQRWDOORZIRUGRXEOHDEVROXWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQV$OWKRXJKLW
KDVEHHQFODLPHGWRWKHFRQWUDU\LWFDQEHGHPRQVWUDWHGWKDWDOOSRVLWHGH[DPSOHVIRUGRXEOHDEVROXWLYHFRQ
VWUXFWLRQVLQWKHLQGLFDWLYHFDQEHDWWULEXWHGWRHLWKHUVFULEDOHUURURUWKHLPSHUIHFWNQRZOHGJHRI+XUULDQE\D
QRQQDWLYHVSHDNHU(LWKHU3RU%PXVWEHLQDQREOLTXHFDVHLIWKHRWKHULVLQWKHDEVROXWLYHZKLOH$LVDOZD\V
LQWKHHUJDWLYHP@

PQ
*LYyQ VLRQVDQDOWHUQDWHFRQVWUXFWLRQLVXVHGZKHUHZHILQG$–)!3%–"(–.%
P<
1RWHWKHYDULDEOHXVDJHRIWKHGLUHFWLYH–"(>@DQGWKHGDWLYH–9(% 9ZLWKWKH$JHQWIROORZHGE\WKHVLQJXODUUHODWRU–)!2%DLK%HFK%DE%6HE%
>@²>@ZLWKYHUEVRIVHQGLQJ RWKHUPRUSKHPH FI&K6,REY UHY ,LL ,L
PR
,QFHUWDLQODQJXDJHV%LVSURPRWHGZKHQHYHULWLVKLJKHURQWKH  .%RLY 7KLVLVWDNHQE\:HJQHUDVDQH[DPSOHRIGRXEOH
HPSDWK\KLHUDUFK\WKDQ3 DEVROXWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVZLWKERWK$DQG3LQWKHDEVROXWLYH :HJQHU
 :LOKHOPGHPRQVWUDWHVWKDWWKHVHDUH)6$GRXEOHDEVROXWLYHV

$PRQJWKH+XUULDQP\WKRORJLFDOWH[WVDUHDQXPEHURISDVVDJHV
EXWUDWKHUXQJUDPPDWLFDOFRQVWUXFWLRQVWKDWFDQEHDWWULEXWHGWR
ZLWKYHUEDGLFHQGLLQWURGXFLQJQHZTXRWHVE\WKHFKDUDFWHUV7KLV
DQ\RQHRIDQXPEHURIH[SODQDWLRQV :LOKHOP² 
LVW\SLILHGE\SDVVDJHVVXFKDV>@EHORZZLWKWKHEDVLFVWUXFWXUH
$ –)! –ঈ –..(3%–"(–.97KHHUJDWLYHHQGLQJLVHOLGHGEHIRUHWKH
P@
:RUGRUGHULQ+XUULDQLVKLJKO\YDULDEOH7KHVHTXHQFHVLQ>D²F@
WKLUGSHUVRQSOXUDOHQFOLWLF–..(ZKLFKLVIXUWKHUVSHFLILHGDVWLYH–)(% DUHPHDQWWREHUHSUHVHQWDWLYHRIFDVHPRUSKRORJ\LQWULYDOHQWFRQ
DQGDJDLQE\WKHHQFOLWLF–.DIWHUWKHGLUHFWLYHHQGLQJZKLFKPDUNV VWUXFWLRQVEXWQRWQHFHVVDULO\LQGLFDWLYHRIDFWXDOZRUGRUGHU
WKH%HQHILFLDU\RIWKHVSHHFKDFW LHWKHOLVWHQHU 2QVHYHUDORFFD
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% Q@

>@ D $),4%3!#W3*,%5$%6%1#,!+

 E $),4%$%6%5)$$%1#,!+
 F $),4%$%6%5$%6%1#,!+

7KHIROORZLQJWZRUXOHVKROGIRU+XUULDQ

>@ 5XOH
 :KHQIXQFWLRQLQJDFFRUGLQJWRWKHHUJDWLYHV\VWHP+XUULDQRQO\DOORZVIRU
RQHDEVROXWLYHFDVH13LQDWUDQVLWLYHFODXVH

>@ 5XOH
 ,IWKHLQGLUHFWREMHFWLVGHILQLWHDQLPDWHDQGKLJKO\WRSLFDOWKHQLWFDQEH
SURPRWHGIURPWKHGDWLYHRUGLUHFWLYHWRWKHDEVROXWLYH7KLVSURPRWLRQUHVXOWV
LQWKHPDQGDWRU\GHPRWLRQRIWKHGLUHFWREMHFWWRWKHHVVLYHFDVH

'DWLYHVKLIWFDQRFFXULQDQ\FODXVHZKHUHWKHYHUELVWUDQVLWLYH%LVDQLPDWHDQG3LVLQDQLPDWH$OWKRXJKLQ
DOOH[DPSOHVRIGDWLYHVKLIW3LVLQDQLPDWHWKLVPD\VLPSO\EHGXHWRWKHSUHVHUYHGFRUSXVDQGLWPD\QRWUHIOHFW
WKHHQWLUHUDQJHRIWKLVFRQVWUXFWLRQ,WPD\EHSRVVLEOHWKDWGDWLYHVKLIWFRXOGRFFXUZLWKDQLPDWH313V
7KHSURFHVVRIGDWLYHVKLIWLQ+XUULDQLVQRWOLPLWHGWRWULYDOHQWYHUEVVXFKDV´WRJLYHµ7KHIROORZLQJH[DP
SOHVZLWKWKHYHUE=1.´WRVD\VSHDNµVKRZWKLVV\QWDFWLFVKLIW([DPSOHV>@DQG>@DUHWDNHQIURPWKH0LWWDQL
/HWWHUZKLOH>@LVIURPWKHSDUDEOHWH[W.%R,QHDFKH[DPSOHWKH%13LVXQGHUOLQHGZKLOH3LVLQEROGIDFH

>@ ()(>>#–**D$E–čQXQGR%ߖ̒Q ( –#::1–"(% =1.–Rঈ–(?

 VR3/(1&/() QRZ EURWKHU6*3266',5VSHDN35(76*$*$*5
 ´6RQRZ,KDYHVSRNHQ<F:G LHWKHZRUGV WRP\EURWKHUµ 0LWWLL

>@ ߖ̒Q ( –#::1–Gč–>()%% 0"%.11 -&))(%% =1. –# –.!

 EURWKHU6*3266',5>()ZRUG‘$%6RQH‘$%6VSHDN $&7 6*-866
 ´,ZRXOGOLNHWRVD\MXVWJ;:(<FB;9%WRP\EURWKHUµ 0LWWLL 

>@ QčOL%% :(&())#–ঈ%% -"#$'/D"E–$%=1.–‫گ‬U–6–>

 GHHU‘$%6PRXQWDLQ(5*FXUVH(66 VSHDN RU 75$13(5)6*$*$*5
 ´7KHPRXQWDLQWROGWKHGHHU%FXUVHVµ LH´7KHPRXQWDLQFXUVHGWKHGHHUµ  .%RL²

,QH[DPSOHV>@DQG>@%LVLQWKHGLUHFWLYHFDVH,QERWKH[DPSOHV%LVWKH´KXPDQµ RUEHWWHUDQLPDWH 
JRDORIWKHDFWRIVSHHFK,QFRQWUDVWWKHDEVROXWLYHQčOLLQ>@FDQQRWEHWKHSDWLHQWRIWKHYHUE=1.–‫گ‬U–6–>,WLV
QRW´WKHGHHUµWKDWWKHDQWKURSRPRUSKL]HGPRXQWDLQVSHDNVEXWUDWKHUWKHFXUVHV7KHFODXVHXQGHUO\LQJ>@
ZRXOGEHVRPHWKLQJOLNH

>@ k#"(-)#%:(&())#–ঈQčOL–"(%=1.–‫گ‬U–6–>PP
 ´7KHPRXQWDLQVSRNHFXUVHVWRWKHGHHUµ

%DVHGRQ>@DQG>@LWFDQEHDVVXPHGWKDW%13VDUHLQWKHGLUHFWLYHZLWKWKHYHUE=1.7KHPRWLYDWLRQEHKLQG
WKHXVHRIGDWLYHVKLIWLQ>@LVOLNHO\WRSODFHH[WUDHPSKDVLVRQWKHGHHU(DUOLHULQWKHSDUDEOHWKHGHHUKDG
ZLVKHGYDULRXVHYLOVXSRQWKHPRXQWDLQXSRQZKLFKLWZDVERUQ7KHPRXQWDLQKHDUGWKHVHLQYHFWLYHVDQGSUR
FHHGHGWRSODFHDFXUVHXSRQWKHLPSXGHQWGHHU%\SODFLQJWKHGHHULQ>@LQWKHDEVROXWLYHWKHDXWKRUIRFXVHV
WKHFODXVHRQLWDQGQRWRQWKHVHPDQWLFSDWLHQWWKHFXUVH
,QWHUHVWLQJSDUDOOHOVWRWKHSDVVDJHLQ>@DUHIRXQGLQ.%R &K6, WKHULWXDORI8PPD\D:LOKHOP
QRWHGWKDWWKUHHSDVVDJHVLQWKLVWH[WDUHVWUXFWXUDOO\VLPLODUWRWKDWRI>@O??,QWKHULWXDOWH[W.%RZHILQG
WKHIROORZLQJWKUHHSDVVDJHV


:LWKVOLJKWO\GLIIHUHQWZRUGRUGHUWLY̒–PčQߖXNNRߖ̒Q ( –#::1–"(% O??
+HGRHVQRWTXRWHWKHH[DFWSDVVDJHLQ>@EXWUDWKHUWKHSDUDO
=1. –# –.! 0LWWLY  OHOSDVVDJHIURPWKHVDPHWH[W .%RL² =Zč]@#%$(&W?(. # –
PP
,WLVXQFOHDUZKHWKHUWKHGHULYDWLRQDOPRUSKHPH–‫گ‬U–KDVDQ\ .! )! –ঈߖLGDUQ # –(%=1.–ࡃU–6–>´'HU .XSIHU *LH‰HUYHUIOXFKWHGHQ
WKLQJWRGRZLWKWKHGDWLYHVKLIWLQ>@ %HFKHUµ :LOKHOP 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

>@ D G
{(1k=(O?O%–?!–) ( –ঈ–(–QW‫گ‬EW?#–) ( –Dঈ–(–)O?:%W%=1.–!"–čY &K6,LY
 E >@GB#)19(–ТL–) ( –Dঈ–(O?Q%–QW‫گ‬EW?#–) ( –Dঈ–(–)%W%=1.–!"–čYߖLQ]L LELGLY
 F >G"<@..(-–?!–) ( –Dঈ–(%W%W‫گ‬EW?#–) ( –Dঈ–(%W%=1.–!"–čYNLߖNL LELGLY

7KH IRUPV k#)G# DQG =#k=# RI >E²F@ LQGLFDWH WKH WHPSRUDO VHTXHQFH RI HYHQWV DQG DUH WR EH WUDQVODWHG DV
´VHFRQG O\ µDQG´WKLUG O\ µUHVSHFWLYHO\,Q>@ZHKDYHWKHVHTXHQFHk#"(-)(%=1.ZLWK3 k#"(-)( LQWKHHVVLYHO?<%
,Q>D²F@ZHILQGWKHSDUDOOHOW‫گ‬EWYLQDঈDNXO´WRVSHDNLQFDQWDWLRQVµZLWK3 W‫گ‬EWYLQDঈD LQWKHSOXUDOHVVLYHO?RDQG
PRGLILHGE\DSUHFHGLQJJHQLWLYH ZLWKSOXUDOHVVLYH71::#](1:)(+>! 8QOLNH>@ZKLFKKDVDQH[SUHVVHG% QčOL 
LQWKHDEVROXWLYHFDVHLWLVXQFOHDUZKDWWKH%13RI>D²E@LV$SRVVLEOHDEVROXWLYHLQ>D@LVWKHHQFOLWLF–)2%
ZKLFKPD\EHWKHWKLUGVLQJXODUHQFOLWLFSURQRXQ,IVRWKHQWKLVSURQRXQ´KLPKHULWµZRXOGEHWKHSURPRWHG
%13DQGZRXOGUHIHUWRVRPHWKLQJH[SOLFLWLQWKHSKUDVHVSUHFHGLQJ>D@7KHQWKH%RI>D@ZRXOGEHFDUULHG
WKURXJKLQWKHLPPHGLDWHO\IROORZLQJ>E²F@7KHOLQHVSUHFHGLQJ>D@DUHGLIILFXOWWRXQGHUVWDQGDQGFRQWDLQ
DQXPEHURIEUHDNV7KHUHFLSLHQWRIWKHVSHHFKDFW % PXVWEHKLJKO\XQGHUVWRRGKHUHLQRUGHUIRULWWREH
RPLWWHG7KHSDVVDJHVLQ>D²F@FDQEHWUDQVODWHGDV

>@ ´,ZLOOVSHDN WRIRU KLPKHULWWKHLQFDQWDWLRQVRI߰DXߖND6HFRQGO\,ZLOOVSHDN WRIRUKLPKHULW 

WKH1LQLYLWHLQFDQWDWLRQV7KLUGO\,ZLOOVSHDN WRIRUKLPKHULW WKHLQFDQWDWLRQVRI$OODU EL "µO?@

7KHWUDQVODWLRQLQ>@LVVWLOWHGEXWLWEHVWUHSUHVHQWVLQP\RSLQLRQWKHJUDPPDURIWKHVHSDVVDJHV
)XUWKHUH[DPSOHVRIGDWLYHVKLIWDUHIRXQGLQERWKWKH0LWWDQL/HWWHUDQGWKH+XUULDQWH[WVIURPWKH+LW
WLWHFDSLWDORI+DWWXVD7KHUHFRJQLWLRQRIGDWLYHVKLIWLQ+XUULDQFODULILHVWKHUHDGLQJRIDQXPEHURIGLIILFXOW
SDVVDJHV,JLYHKHUHVRPHH[DPSOHVLQRUGHUWREHWWHULOOXVWUDWHWKLVV\QWDFWLFRSHUDWLRQ$VZLWK>@²>@
DERYHWKH%13LVXQGHUOLQHGDQG3LVJLYHQLQEROGIDFH7KHILUVWH[DPSOHFRPHVIURPWKH0LWWDQL/HWWHUDQG
LVVWUDLJKWIRUZDUG

>@ ,઄"$'–(–,઄,઄D"E–ö–$$ ( –čQ%% WHȆQD"E–$1 ߖ̒Q ( –#::1–ঈ%

 JROG 6+઄+઄ # (666*(1&/()PXFK(66EURWKHU6*3266(5*
% =!&–čQ–6–!)
 SURYLGH () 3$7-866
 ´0D\P\EURWKHUSURYLGHMJ%G=@F(9JCLµ 0LWWLLL² 

7KHHVVLYHWH‫گ‬QDLQGLFDWHVWKDWWKHILQDO(RIFODXVHLQLWLDO+઄ #(-6+઄ +઄ (LVDOVRWREHXQGHUVWRRGDVWKHHVVLYHFDVHDQG

QRWWKHUHVXOWRIYRZHOKDUPRQ\ZLWKWKHIROORZLQJHQFOLWLFSURQRXQ–$$(

O?O
2QWKHUHDGLQJ4!\!+"LQVWHDGRI+઄ #VHH:LOKHOP –#ZKLOHPRVWDUHWKHLQWUDQVLWLYH DJHQWLYH –(7KHILUVWSDVVDJH
O?:
7KHIRUPLVDFWXDOO\VSHOOHG$1M1M1&M&#M)(Mk(M()7KLVLVQRW$1II#% LQ&K6,LY LVIROORZHGE\(I0#%W%I#-("#%W%=1"–(..–19(7KH
´WDEOHWµEXWUDWKHUDYDULDQWZULWLQJRI$6&W?#´LQFDQWDWLRQµ :LOKHOP HQGLQJ–19(LVHOVHZKHUHIRXQGZLWKWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVZLWKHUJDWLYH
²  $JHQWV RQWKLVHQGLQJVHHEHORZ 7KLVPHDQVWKDW(I0#%I#-("#LQWKLV
O?Q
7KHVLJQV)(Mk(DUHZULWWHQRYHUDQHUDVXUH VHFRQGFODXVHLVQRWWKHDJHQWRI=1"(..19(&RPELQJWKHWZRZHJHW
VRPHWKLQJOLNH´7KH(LMIL%=1"M+H=1"WKH%(LMILµ&OHDUO\WKLVLVQRW
O?<
:LOKHOPZULWHVWKDW´GDV3UHGLNDWGXUFKHLQHQ(VVLYVHPDQWLVFK
YHU\KHOSIXOIRUXQGHUVWDQGLQJWKLVVHFWLRQRIWKHWH[W)XUWKHURQZH
PRGLIL]LHUWµ  ,SUHIHUWRVHHk#"(-)(LQ>@DVSDUDOOHOWR
ILQGWKHDEVROXWLYHIRUPSčঈL´PRXWKµ LY 7KHIRUP#k$!))(%89%FG%
WKH$#?!LQ>@DQGWKH–..( $#?!–)( LQ>@,QRWKHUZRUGVLQ>@²
VRPHLQWHUHVW,WFDQEHSDUVHGDV#k$!–))(WKHILUVWSHUVRQVLQJXODU
>@ZHKDYH´VSHDNZRUGVµ´VSHDNDZRUGµDQG ´VSHDNDFXUVHµ
=7FHFLH%#k$!ZLWKWKHWKLUGVLQJXODUHQFOLWLFSURQRXQ–))(,I–))(%
UHVSHFWLYHO\:KLOHWKHFRPELQDWLRQ k#"(-)#%=1.FDQEHWUDQVODWHG
LVWKHHTXDWLYHFDVHWKHQZHZRXOGH[SHFWDIRUPߖ‫ ())–گ‬:HJQHU
DV´WRFXUVHµk#"(-)#LVWREHWDNHQDVWKHVHPDQWLFDQGJUDPPDWLFDO
 
=6K8JHK%FG%=1.,WLVQRWLQWKHHVVLYHLQ>@EHFDXVHLWLVPRGLI\LQJ
=1.EXWUDWKHUEHFDXVHWKHIRFXVRIWKHFODXVHLVRQWKHUHFLSLHQWRI
O?@
´,FKZHUGHLKQVLHHV>HUVWHQV " @ PLWGHU%HVFKZ|UXQJ GHU
WKHFXUVHUDWKHUWKDQWKHFXUVHLWVHOI ߰DZXߖNDEHVFKZ|UHQLFKZHUGHLKQVLHHV]ZHLWHQV PLWGHU%H
VFKZ|UXQJ GHU1LQLYLWHULQEHVFKZ|UHQLFKZHUGHLKQVLHHVGULW
O?R
2QWKHIRUPRIWKHSOXUDOHVVLYHVHH:HJQHU
WHQV PLWGHU%HVFKZ|UXQJ GHU$OODUEL " EHVFKZ|UHQµ :LOKHOP

6RPHREVHUYDWLRQVDERXWWKHSUHFHGLQJOLQHVLY ² FDQEH
 )URPWKLVWUDQVODWLRQLWVHHPVDVLIWKHSDWLHQW ´LKQ
PDGH7KHSDVVDJHVLQLY EHJLQDQHZSDUDJUDSKLQWKHWH[W7KLV
VLHHVµ LVWKHWKLQJWKDWLVFRQMXUHGLQFDQWHGWKURXJKWKHXVHRI
QHZVHFWLRQEHJLQVZLWKWKHDQWLSDVVLYHFODXVH>(I0@#%W%I#-("#%W%=1"–
SDUWLFXODUFRQMXUDWLRQVLQFDQWDWLRQV,IHHOWKDWWKHJUDPPDWLFDO
(..–#–&´7KH(  I=1"µ7KHYHUE=1"(..#&PD\FRQWDLQWKHURRW
SDWLHQW LHWKHRPLWWHGDEVROXWLYH13 LVWKHRQHIRUZKRPWKH
=1"´WRIDOO LQWUDQ WRIHOO WUDQ µNQRZQIURPWKH+XUUR+LWWLWH
VSHDNHULVGRLQJWKHLQFDQWDWLRQ LH ´,ZLOOVSHDNWKHFRQMXUDWLRQV
ELOLQJXDO VHH1HX RULWPD\VLPSO\EHDKRPRSKRQH,Q
LQFDQWDWLRQVRI߰DZXߖND:6-%iµ!´,ZLOOVSHDNKLPWKHFRQMXUDWLRQV
.%RLWKHIRUPčPP–#–&VHHPVWREHDYHUERIPRWLRQKHUH
LQFDQWDWLRQVRI߰DZXߖNDµ 
EXWLVLQWKHDQWLSDVVLYH–#,WLVXQFOHDUZK\FHUWDLQPRWLRQVDUHLQ 
7KLVH[DPSOHDSSHDUVHDUOLHUDV>@DERYH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% QP

$FRPPRQH[DPSOHJLYHQDVSURRIRIVSOLWHUJDWLYLW\LQ+XUULDQLVDVIROORZV

>@ WLYDWWčQNXUࡃZDߖ̒QLIIXYHPčQNHOGLQҸULঈHxDঈLOH 0LWWLY²

7KHHQFOLWLFILUVWSHUVRQSURQRXQ–$$(%FG%WLYDWWčQKDVEHHQWDNHQE\VRPHDVWKHVXEMHFWRIWKHILUVWSHUVRQMXV
VLYHYHUE+઄ Dঈ–#–.!´0D\,KHDUµO?P7KHIRUPNXUࡃZDDQGWKHXVHRI–>()%FH%ߖ̒QLIIXYHPčQDUHQHYHUVXIILFLHQWO\
H[SODLQHGOO?7KHHQFOLWLFSDUWLFOH–PčQLVDOPRVWDOZD\VIRXQGRQWKHILUVWZRUGRIDFODXVH LHLQ:DFNHUQDJHO
SRVLWLRQ 7KLVLQGLFDWHVWKDWWLYDWWčQNXUࡃZDVKRXOGDOPRVWFHUWDLQO\EHWDNHQDVDVHSDUDWHFODXVHIURPZKDW
IROORZVLW7KHVHFRQGFODXVHFDQEHWUDQVODWHGDV´0D\,KHDUWKHZHOOEHLQJDQGQҸULঈHRIP\EURWKHUµ$OOWKDW
UHPDLQVLVWRH[SODLQWKHIRUPNXUࡃZD
,WLVQRWSRVVLEOHWRWDNHNXUࡃZDDVDQLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUELQ–(ZLWKWKHILUVWSHUVRQDERVOXWLYH–$$(DV67KH
IRUPGRHVQRWILWRXUXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHLQWUDQVLWLYHWKHXVHRIWKHHVVLYHZRXOGEHVWUDQJHDQGFRQWH[WVSHDNV
DJDLQVWLW)XUWKHUPRUHRWKHUH[DPSOHVRIYHUEVLQ–19(ZLWKGDWLYHVKLIWDUHNQRZQ
%HIRUHDQDO\]LQJWKHWLYDWWčQNXUࡃZDRI>@,ZRXOGOLNHWRWXUQWRWKH+XUUR+LWWLWHELOLQJXDO,QWKHWKLUG
SDUDEOHRI.%RWKHWRSLF=(G#´FXSµLVJLYHQDVWKHDEVROXWLYH313RIWKHLQWURGXFWRU\WUDQVLWLYHFODXVH

>@ Nč]L WDYDO # –.! )! –ঈ «WDY–(k$–‫>–گ‬

 FXS‘$%6VPLWK6*5(/$7(5*«FDVW(k$75$13(5)6*$*$*5
 ´7KHVPLWKFDVWWKHFXS IRUJORU\ µ .%RL²

:KHQDQHZWRSLFLVLQWURGXFHGLQWKLVWH[WLWW\SLFDOO\DSSHDUVDVDQDEVROXWLYH13 HLWKHU6RU3 OOO7KLVLQWUR

GXFWRU\FODXVHLVIROORZHGE\WKUHHDV\QGHWLFFODXVHVZLWKRQO\H[SUHVVHGYHUEDOIRUPV $DQG3DUHERWKRPLWWHG 

>@ OO:%$(?–(k$–‫–گ‬P PXঈ–‫گ‬O–‫>–گ‬%

  FDVW(k$75$13(5)6*$*$*5VKDSH6.75$13(5)6*$*$*5
% ̒OJ # –čH WXQ–ࡃߖW–6–>
 GHFRUDWLRQ,167HTXLS " 1k$75$13(5)6*$*$*5
 ´ 7KHVPLWK FDVW WKHFXS KH –> VKDSHG LW KH –> HTXLSSHG LW ZLWKGHFRUDWLRQµ .%RL²

7KHVDPH313 Nč]L DQGWKHVDPH$13 WDYDOOHঈ IURPOLQHVL²FDUU\WKURXJKWKHVHWKUHHYHUEV7KHRQO\

UHIHUHQFHWRWKHFRUHDUJXPHQWVLVWKURXJKWKHREOLJDWRU\WKLUGVLQJXODUDJHQWDJUHHPHQWPDUNHU–>%RQWKHYHUEV
7KHYDULRXVDFWVLQYROYHGLQWKHFUHDWLRQRIWKHFXSDUHFRQWLQXHGE\WZRPRUHDV\QGHWLFFODXVHVLPPHGLDWHO\
IROORZLQJ>@

>@ DJࡃUQ # –(%(5–6.–ࡃZDߖҸUQ # –(–PPDWDঈ–6.–ࡃZD .%RL² OOQ

7KH–>>(%FH%ߖҸUQD–>>(LVDFRQQHFWLYHLQGLFDWLQJWKDWWKLVLVWKHILQDOFODXVHLQWKLVJURXSRIDV\QGHWRQ7KH
WZRFODXVHVLQ>@DUHJUDPPDWLFDOO\PRUHFRPSOH[WKDQWKHSUHFHGLQJRQHVLQ>@DQG>@7KLVLVHYLQFHGE\
WKHGLIIHUHQWVWUXFWXUHRIWKHYHUEDQGWKHFXULRXVXVHRIHVVLYHIRUPV7KHWHUP(51-)(LVWKHHVVLYHRIDQRXQ
U(51-)#2OO<DQGLWLVFOHDUO\FRJQDWHWRWKHYHUE(5–6.–ࡃZD7KH+LWWLWHWUDQVODWHVWKLVILUVWFODXVHDV´KHHQJUDYHG
LW WKHFXS µWUDQVODWLQJWKH+XUULDQFRPSOH[DJXUQDDJROࡃZDZLWKWKH+LWWLWHSUHWHULW51.M(kM$(2QHZRXOGH[SHFW
DFRJQDWHIRUPOLNH(51-)(WRRFFXUDVWKHSDWLHQWRIWKHYHUEDQGWKHFXSDVWKHLQGLUHFWREMHFW LH´KHHQJUDYHG
HQJUDYLQJ>V@>RQWKHFXS@µ 
7KHVDPHVLWXDWLRQKROGVIRUWKHVHFRQGFODXVHLQ>@7KH+XUULDQߖҸUQD –>>( WDঈ–6.–ࡃZDLVWUDQVODWHGLQWR
(8KK8KJ%69%)1M1kMk#M!kM$(%>(M#kM$#%()M"(%.(M(M.1M1=M=#M#kM)1M1$´KHLOOXPLQDWHGLW RUPDGHLWVKLQH LQZLWKJORVVµOOR%
7KHHVVLYHIRUPk#-)(OLNH(51-)(LQWKHLPPHGLDWHO\SUHFHGLQJFODXVHDSSHDUVWREHWKHVHPDQWLFSDWLHQWRIWKH
YHUEWDঈ$WUDQVODWLRQVXFKDV1HX·V´*ODQ] ZHUN DEHUIJWHHUKLQ]XµOO@OLNHO\FDWFKHVWKHVHQVHRIWKLVFODXVH

O?P
+DDVDQG:HJQHU+D]HQERV OO<
 7KH IRUP (51-)( FDQQRW EH DQDO\]HG DV D SOXUDO DEVROXWLYH
OO?
+DDVDQG:HJQHU FRQWUD1HX)ROORZLQJWKHSDWWHUQ!?!-)#´NLQJµ!!?#-)(%
OOO
)RUWKHXVHRI6DQG3WRLQWURGXFHQHZWRSLFVLQHUJDWLYHODQ ´NLQJ (66 µDQG!?!-)#%X%!?-#))(´NLQJVµ(51-)(FDQRQO\EHDQHV
JXDJHVVHH'L[RQ IROORZLQJWKHZRUNRI'X%RLV  VLYHIRUP7KHH[SHFWHGSOXUDOZRXOGEH (5-1) # –)( WKHYRZHO
LVTXHVWLRQDEOHLWPD\QRWEH1 )RUDJࡃUQDDVDQHVVLYHIRUPVHH
OO:
7KHWH[WXVHVDGLDJRQDOVWURNHWRVHSDUDWHWKHWZRYHUEDOIRUPV
DOUHDG\:LOKHOPE
WKDWEHJLQOLQHL
OOR
7UDQVODWHGE\1HXDV´*ODQ] ZHUN DEHUIJWHHUKLQ]Xµ 
OOQ
7UDQVODWHGE\1HXDV´(U]LVHOLHUWHLKQXQGOLH‰VLH GLH9HU]LHUXQ
FRPPHQWDU\²
JHQ LKPLP*ODQ]HUVWUDKOHQµ  
 oi.uchicago.edu

<?% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

,IHHOWKDWk#-)(DQG(51-)(DOWKRXJKLQWKHHVVLYHFDVHDUHERWKWKHVHPDQWLFSDWLHQWVRIWKHLUUHVSHFWLYHYHUEV
DQGNč]L´WKHFXSµLVWKHLQGLUHFWREMHFWDQGUHFLSLHQW RUSHUKDSVJRDO" RIWKHDFWLRQV$YHU\OLNHO\UHFRQVWUXF
WLRQRIWKHFODXVHVXQGHUO\LQJWKRVHLQ>@LV

>@ (51-)#%$(?(. # –.! )! –ঈNč]L–?(%(5–6.–‫>–گ‬

% ߖҸUQL–>>(%$(?(. # –.! )! –ঈNč]L–YDWDঈ–6.–‫>–گ‬
 ´7KHVPLWKHQJUDYHGHQJUDYLQJVRQWKHFXS7KHVPLWK(""!"%5.600%WRWKHFXSµ

7KHH[SODQDWLRQIRUZK\WKHVHPDQWLFSDWLHQWVLQ>@DUHLQWKHHVVLYHDQGQRWWKHH[SHFWHGDEVROXWLYHFDQ
EHH[SODLQHGE\GDWLYHVKLIW7KHWRSLFRIWKHVHFODXVHVDQGWKHSDUDEOHDVDZKROHLVWKHNč]LFXS7KHSULPDU\
FDVHIRUWRSLFVLVDWOHDVWLQ2OG+XUULDQWKHDEVROXWLYH7KLVIXQFWLRQVZHOOZLWKWKHILUVWIRXUYHUEV>@²>@
ZKHUHNč]LLVERWKWKHJUDPPDWLFDODQGVHPDQWLFSDWLHQW$SRWHQWLDOSUREOHPDULVHVZLWKWKHFODXVHVLQ>@7KH
VHPDQWLFSDWLHQWVDUHQRORQJHUWKHNč]L,QVWHDGRIIXQFWLRQLQJDVWKHXQGHUJRHULWLVQRZWKHUHFLSLHQW RUJRDO 
RIWKHDFWLRQ,I(51-)#DQGk#-)#DUHJLYHQDVWKHJUDPPDWLFDOSDWLHQWVRIWKHLUUHVSHFWLYHYHUEVWKHDXWKRU OOP%
ULVNVSODFLQJXQGXHIRFXVRIIRIWKHWRSLF Nč]L DQGRQWRFRQWH[WXDOO\XQLPSRUWDQWQRXQV7KURXJKWKHXVHRI
GDWLYHVKLIWKRZHYHUWKHDXWKRULVDEOHWRPDLQWDLQNč]LDVWKHDEVROXWLYHDUJXPHQWO:?,WIROORZVWKHQWKDWKH
FDQFRQWLQXHWRRPLWWKLVIRUPDVWKHYHU\JLYHQNQRZQWRSLFRIWKLVVHULHVRIDV\QGHWLFFODXVHV,QVWHDGRIWKH
XQGHUO\LQJFODXVHVSRVWXODWHGLQ>@ZHKDYH

>@ Nč]LWDYDO # –.! )! –ঈDJXUQ # –(%(5–6.–ࡃZD

% Nč]LWDYDO # –.! )! –ঈߖҸUQ # –DWDঈ–6.–ࡃZD
 ´7KHVPLWKHQJUDYHGWKHFXS ZLWK HQJUDYLQJV7KHVPLWKDGGHGJORVV WR WKHFXSµ

$VFDQEHVHHQLQ>@DRQHWRRQHWUDQVODWLRQRIWKH+XUULDQLQWR(QJOLVKLVQRWSRVVLEOH7KLVLVEHFDXVHGDWLYH
VKLIWLVPXFKPRUHUHVWULFWHGLQ(QJOLVKWKDQLWLVLQ+XUULDQ
%HIRUHWXUQLQJWRWKHYHUEDOPRUSKHPH–ࡃZD,ZRXOGOLNHWRUHWXUQWRWKHSDVVDJHLQ>@DERYH,WLVUHSHDWHG
KHUHDV>@

>@ WLYDWWčQNXUࡃZD 0LWWLY

:HKDYHDYHUEDOIRUPLQNXUࡃZDWKDWLVSDUDOOHOWRDJROࡃZDDQGWDঈROࡃZDLQ>@:HDOVRKDYHDQDEVROXWLYH13LQ
WKHHQFOLWLFSURQRXQ–$$(DQGDSRWHQWLDOHVVLYHLQ$#?(,QRUGHUIRU$#?( ! WREHDEVROXWLYH ZLWKYRZHOFKDQJH
FRQGLWLRQHGE\WKHHQFOLWLFSURQRXQ WKHSKUDVHPXVWEHQRQHUJDWLYHO:O%1J7D9%8H%–ࡃZDDSSHDUWRDOOIXQFWLRQ
DFFRUGLQJWRWKHHUJDWLYHV\VWHPWKHUHE\DVVXULQJWKDW$#?(LVLQWKHHVVLYHFDVH,QDOOWKHH[DPSOHVJLYHQDERYH
WKHYHUEVLQ–ࡃZDIXQFWLRQDVLQGLFDWLYHWUDQVLWLYHVDQGWKHUHLVQRHYLGHQFHIRULWEHLQJXVHGZLWKLQWUDQVLWLYHV
7KHUHIRUHWKHDEVROXWLYHSURQRXQ–$$(LVPRVWOLNHO\WREHWDNHQDVWKH313RIWKHWUDQVLWLYH=1-–ࡃZD7KH$JHQW
ZRXOGEHWKH(J\SWLDQSKDUDRK7KLVUHVXOWVLQDFRQVWUXFWLRQYHU\VLPLODUWRWKHRQHVLQ>@>@DQG>@DERYH
,ZRXOGOLNHWRWDNH–$$(DVWKHJUDPPDWLFDOSDWLHQWDQGVHPDQWLFEHQHILFLDU\RIWKHYHUE=1-ZLWK$#?!DVWKH
VHPDQWLFSDWLHQWDQGJUDPPDWLFDOHVVLYH FK{PHXU ,ZRXOGWUDQVODWH>@DVVRPHWKLQJOLNH´+H P\EURWKHU 
9#..%0!)"PHZRUG /HWPHKHDURIWKHZHOOEHLQJDQGQҸULঈHRIP\EURWKHU µ
7KHPRUSKHPH–ࡃZDRQWKHYHUEVLQ>@LVGLIILFXOWWRH[SODLQ,WKDVW\SLFDOO\EHHQDQDO\]HGDVIXQFWLRQLQJ
DVVRPHNLQGRIDVSHFWPDUNHUO::,WLVP\FRQWHQWLRQWKDWLWVIXQFWLRQKDVOHVVWRGRZLWKDVSHFWWKDQZLWKWRSLF
IRFXV,ZRXOGOLNHWRVHHWKH1%FG%–ࡃZDDVFRUUHVSRQGLQJWRWKHLQWUDQVLWLYHSDWLHQWLYH–1PRUSKHPH7KHILQDO
(%PD\SHUKDSVEHWKHWKLUGSHUVRQDJHQWDJUHHPHQWPDUNHUWKDWLVEHWWHUNQRZQIURPIRUPVVXFKDV–#–(1RWH
WKDWLQWKHDERYHH[DPSOHVZKHQGDWLYHVKLIWRFFXUVLQFODXVHVZLWKPRGDOYHUEVWKHSDWLHQWLYH–6–PRUSKHPHLV
XVHGDQGQRWWKHDFWLYH–#–,QLQGLFDWLYHFODXVHVGDWLYHVKLIWLVIRXQGRQFHZLWKDSHUIHFWLYHYHUE>@DQGWKUHH
WLPHVZLWKYHUEVLQ–ࡃZD7KHSHUIHFWLYHLVE\QDWXUHSDWLHQWIRFXVLQJDVLWLQGLFDWHVDFRPSOHWHGVWDWHDQGLWLV


7KHDQDO\VLVRIߖҸUQDDVDQDEVROXWLYHSOXUDOIRUPߖҸU–)(%DE%+JL% O:?
7KLVGRHVQRWYLRODWHUXOHJLYHQDERYHLQ>@7KHSDUDEOHWH[W
² LVQRWSRVVLEOH VHHQDERYH  .%RLVKLJKO\OLWHUDU\LQQDWXUHDQGWKHFXSLVQRWLQDQLPDWH
OO@
1HX KHUHEXWUDWKHUDQWKURSRPRUSKL]HG

'L[RQIROORZLQJ'X%RLV
O:O
,WDOVRPDNHVQRVHQVHWRWDNH$#?(–$$(%DV´,WKHZRUGµ7KHUHLVQR
OOP
%\DXWKRU,DPQRWUHIHUULQJWRWKHWH[WFRS\LVWEXWUDWKHUWKH HYLGHQFHLQWKLVWH[W RULQDQ\RWKHU+XUULDQWH[WWRP\NQRZOHGJH 
RULJLQDO´DXWKRUµRUFUHDWRURIWKH+XUULDQWH[WZKRPD\RUPD\ RIWKHVSHDNHUEHLQJHTXDWHGZLWK´WKHZRUGµ
QRWKDYHEHHQRQHSHUVRQ
O::
1HX²:LOKHOPE
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% <O

SRVVLEOHWKDWWKHSHUIHFWLYHWUDQVLWLYH–6–RIWKHLQGLFDWLYHPD\EHRQHDQGWKHVDPHZLWKWKHSDWLHQWLYH–6–%FG%
WKHPRGDOV\VWHP7KHIRUPVLQ–ࡃZDDUHHLWKHUSUHVHQWRULPSHUIHFWLYH,QH[DPSOH>@LWLVEHVWWDNHQDVWKH
ODWWHU$OWKRXJKWKHDFWLRQRIWKHFXSKDVEHHQFRPSOHWHG QRWHWKHIRUP$(?–(k$–‫ >–گ‬WKHDFWRIHQJUDYLQJDQG
SXWWLQJJORVVRQWKHFXSLQYROYHVPDQ\VWHSVDQGPD\HYHQEHVHHQDVLWHUDWLYH$VVXFKWKHLPSHUIHFWLYHLVXVHG
KHUHWRH[SUHVVDSDVWDFWLRQWKDWKDGDORQJGXUDWLRQ3HUKDSVZHDUHGHDOLQJZLWKWKHSHUIHFWLYHLQ–6 –> XVHG
IRUWHOLFSDVWWHQVHHYHQWVDQG–ࡃZDIRUDWHOLFHYHQWVLQWKHSDVW ERWKIRUWKLUGSHUVRQVLQJXODUDJHQWV ,Q>@
WKHYHUEFDQEHLQWHUSUHWHGDVSUHVHQWIXWXUH
$UHVXOWRIWKHDERYHZRUNRQGDWLYHVKLIWLQ+XUULDQLVWKDWRWKHUZLVHDPELJXRXVSDVVDJHVFDQQRZEHSDUVHG
,QWKHSDUDEOHWH[W.%REHWZHHQHDFKVWRU\WKHOLVWHQHUV DOZD\VVHFRQGSOXUDO DUHHQFRXUDJHGWRIRUJHW
ZKDWWKH\KDYHMXVWKHDUGDQGOLVWHQWR DQGWDNHWRKHDUW WKHQH[WRQH7KLVLVDFFRPSOLVKHGWKURXJKWKHXVHRI
DVHULHVRIQRQLQGLFDWLYHFODXVHV,QFOXGHGDPRQJWKHPZHILQGWKHIROORZLQJ

>@ 6. # –(–::(% =("–6. –6 –.!%% V%>(" # –č–::(%

 RWKHU(663/(1&/WHOO6. 3$7 6*-866«ZLVGRP(663/(1&/
% =("–6. –6 –.!
 WHOO6. 3$7 6*-866
 ´/HWPHWHOO\RX SO DQRWKHU«/HWPHWHOO\RX SO ZLVGRP LHDSDUDEOH µ
 .%RL²

7KHYHUE=("W\SLFDOO\WDNHVZKDWLVVSRNHQDVLWVSDWLHQWZKLOHWKHSHUVRQWRZKRPRQHVSHDNVLVLQWKHGDWLYH
RUGLUHFWLYH

>@ G
b1>(-&#–QҸ –ঈ –.% $#?!–Z)(@ !) # –) ( –(k–$(–.%
 '16*5(/$7 (5* 3/(1&/ZRUG3/$%6JRG3/5(/$73/',53/(1&/
% (.1–PčLZ)% =("–#–(@
 VSHDN*(581'"WHOO75$16*$*$*5
 ´.XPDUELVSHDNVWKHZRUGWRWKHJRGVµ &K6,LY ²

7KHYHUE=("#(LVUHVWRUHGLQ>@EXWWKLVLVVXFKDFRPPRQWXUQRISKUDVHLQ+XUULDQP\WKRORJ\WKDWLWVUHVWRUD
WLRQLVFHUWDLQ7KHVHPDQWLFSDWLHQWVRIWKHWZR=("6..!LQ>@DUH6.#´DQRWKHUµDQG>("#´ZLVGRPSDUDEOH " µ7KH
EHQHILFLDU\JRDO %13 RIWKHVSHHFKDFWLVWKHVHFRQGSHUVRQSOXUDO6LQFH%LVWKHDEVROXWLYHHQFOLWLFSURQRXQ
–::(WKHQ6.(DQG>("(PXVWEHWDNHQDVHVVLYHIRUPVDQGQRWDEVROXWLYHVZLWK#!(WKURXJKYRZHOKDUPRQ\
ZLWK–::(O:Q

-J;@C=KBJ;
7KHUHLVQRRQHWRRQHFRUUHVSRQGHQFHEHWZHHQWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVRI$3DQG%DQGFDVHPRUSKRORJ\
LQ+XUULDQZKLOH6LVOLPLWHGWRWKHDEVROXWLYHFDVH7KHFDVHWKDWDSDUWLFXODUJUDPPDWLFDOUROHWDNHVLQDFODXVH
ZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRI6 LVFRQWUROOHGE\HLWKHUV\QWD[RUGLVFRXUVH,QWKHDERYHVHFWLRQV,KDYHDSSURDFKHG
WKHLVVXHIURPWKHYDQWDJHRIWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUROHV,ZRXOGOLNHWRWDNHWKHRSSRUWXQLW\KHUHWRVXPPDUL]HWKH
VLWXDWLRQIURPWKHSHUVSHFWLYHRIWKHFDVHVWKHPVHOYHV
HUJDWLYH%D–ʿE47KHHUJDWLYHLQ+XUULDQDSSHDUVWREHOLPLWHGWR DQLPDWH $13VLQDFWLYHWUDQVLWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
(UJDWLYH13VFDQQRWEHUHODWLYL]HG,QRUGHUIRUWKH$13WRXQGHUJRUHODWLYL]DWLRQLWPXVWEHGHPRWHGWRWKH
DEVROXWLYHWKURXJKWKHDQWLSDVVLYH
DEVROXWLYH –ME47KHDEVROXWLYHFDVHFRYHUVWKHODUJHVWQXPEHURIJUDPPDWLFDOUROHVEHLQJIRXQGZLWK$63
DQG%13V6WDWLVWLFDOO\VSHDNLQJKRZHYHUWKLVFDVHLVSULPDULO\IRXQGZLWK6DQG37KHPDUNLQJRIWKHVHWZR
JUDPPDWLFDOUROHVE\WKHDEVROXWLYHDORQJZLWKWKHFRQFXUUHQWPDUNLQJRIWKH$13ZLWKWKHHUJDWLYHFDVHLVWKH
KDOOPDUNRIHUJDWLYLW\LQ+XUULDQ

O:Q
(YHQLI+DDVDQG:HJQHU  DUHFRUUHFWLQWKHLUFODLP DQGQRWLঈDঈ WKHDQDO\VLVRI6.(::(DQGPDGčIIDDV13²(66²3/$%6
WKDWILUVWSHUVRQMXVVLYHIRUPVUHTXLUHDEVROXWLYHVXEMHFW LH#k$!% 3521281VWLOOKROGV
 oi.uchicago.edu

<:% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

7KHDEVROXWLYHLVXVHGZLWK$13VLQDOLPLWHGQXPEHURIVLWXDWLRQV,QWKHDQWLSDVVLYHLWLVWKHFDVHWRZKLFK
$LVSURPRWHG7KLVLVGRQHLQSDUWWRDOORZ$13VWRIXQFWLRQLQFHUWDLQV\QWDFWLFRSHUDWLRQVSDUWLFXODUO\UHODWLY
L]DWLRQ7KHDQWLSDVVLYHWUDQVIRUPVDGLYDOHQWWUDQVLWLYHYHUELQWRDPRQRYDOHQWRQH7KHDEVROXWLYHLVDOVRXVHG
WRPDUN$13VIRUWUDQVLWLYHLPSHUDWLYHVDQGDFWLYHRSWDWLYHV,QWKHVHPRRGV+XUULDQLVQRORQJHUIXQFWLRQLQJ
DVDQHUJDWLYHODQJXDJHEXWUDWKHUDVDQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHRQH
,QDFWLYHWUDQVLWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVWKHSDWLHQWLVW\SLFDOO\LQWKHDEVROXWLYH,QFHUWDLQVLWXDWLRQVKRZHYHU3
FDQEHGHPRWHGIURPWKHDEVROXWLYH7KHSURPRWLRQRI%WRWKHDEVROXWLYHUHTXLUHVWKDWWKHSDWLHQWEHGHPRWHG
WRWKHHVVLYH,QWKHPRGDOV\VWHP3LVW\SLFDOO\LQWKHDEVROXWLYHFDVH,QWKHDFWLYHRSWDWLYH3FDQEHGHPRWHG
WRWKHHVVLYH
7KHVLQJOHDUJXPHQWRIDPRQRWUDQVLWLYHYHUELVDOZD\VLQWKHDEVROXWLYH$WOHDVWWZRW\SHVRIWUDQVLWLYHYHUEV
FDQEHGLVWLQJXLVKHGLQ+XUULDQWKRVHZKHUH6H[KLELWVFRQWURORYHUWKHDFWLRQ LHDJHQWOLNH6RU6! DQGWKRVH
ZKHUH6KDVOLWWOHWRQRFRQWURORYHUWKHDFWLRQDQGW\SLFDOO\XQGHUJRHVDFKDQJHRIVWDWH LHSDWLHQWOLNH6RU
$5 7KHUHH[LVWVQRVSHFLDOFDVHPDUNLQJWRGLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQWKHVHWZRGLIIHUHQWW\SHVRI6137KHGLVWLQFWLRQ
LVRQO\LQGLFDWHGE\YHUEDOPRUSKRORJ\WKHIRUPHUE\–(DQGWKHODWWHUE\–!DQG–1
7KH%13RULQGLUHFWREMHFWFDQEHSURPRWHGWRWKHDEVROXWLYH$VPHQWLRQHGDERYHWKHJUDPPDWLFDOUROH
RI%HQHILFLDU\FRYHUVDUDQJHRIVHPDQWLFUROHV$QLPDWHKLJKO\WRSLFDOLQGLUHFWREMHFWVWKDWDUHLQHLWKHUWKH
GDWLYHRUGLUHFWLYHFDVHFDQEHSURPRWHG+XUULDQVHHPVWRDOORZDUDWKHUEURDGUDQJHRIUROHVWRXQGHUJRWKLV
VKLIW7KHSULPDU\IXQFWLRQRIWKLV´GDWLYHVKLIWµLVSUDJPDWLFDQGVHUYHVWRSODFHPRUHHPSKDVLVRUWRSLFDOLW\RQ
WKHLQGLUHFWREMHFW
HVVLYH –$E47KHHVVLYHVWUDGGOHVWKHOLQHEHWZHHQREOLTXH RULQKHUHQW DQGVWUXFWXUDOFDVH$VWKHODWWHULWLV
LQYROYHGZLWKWKHFRUHDUJXPHQWVRIDFODXVH7KHHVVLYHLVWKHFDVHWRZKLFKWKHSDWLHQWFDQEHGHPRWHG+XUULDQ
RQO\DOORZVIRURQHDUJXPHQWWREHLQWKHDEVROXWLYH ZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRIWKHQRQHUJDWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVRIWKH
WUDQVLWLYHLPSHUDWLYHVDQGDFWLYHRSWDWLYHVZKHUHERWK$DQG3DUHLQWKHDEVROXWLYH :KHQDQRQ3DUJXPHQW
RIDWUDQVLWLYHYHUELVSURPRWHGWRWKHDEVROXWLYH LHHLWKHU$RU% LWILOOVWKDWSDUWLFXODUV\QWDFWLFVORW7KLV
UHTXLUHVWKDWWKH3DUJXPHQWWKHQEHGHPRWHGWRWKHHVVLYHPDLQWDLQLQJWKH´RQHDEVROXWLYHµUXOH
7KHWUDQVLWLYHDFWLYHRSWDWLYHW\SLFDOO\UHTXLUHVWKDWERWK$DQG3EHLQWKHDEVROXWLYH,QVLWXDWLRQVZKHUH
HLWKHUWKHYHUELVGHWUDQVLWLYL]HGRUWKHSDWLHQWLVJHQHUDODQGQRQVSHFLILF3FDQEHGHPRWHGWRWKHHVVLYH

3(0! D-(>>($#4(.%K6.!^0` 7')$(4$#4%7#$1($#6)^0`

7UDQVLWLYHFODXVHVLQERWKWKHLQGLFDWLYHDQGQRQLQGLFDWLYH
–ঈ (UJDWLYH !IJHK
ZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRIWKHLPSHUDWLYHDQGDFWLYHRSWDWLYH
6XEMHFW ,QWUDQVLWLYHYHUEV ERWKDFWLYHDQGSDWLHQWLYH
3DWLHQW 7UDQVLWLYHYHUEV
–‘ $EVROXWLYH
$JHQW $QWLSDVVLYHLPSHUDWLYHDFWLYHRSWDWLYH
%HQHϮFLDU\ 7KURXJKGDWLYHVKLIWLQWUDQVLWLYHFODXVHV
,QWKHDQWLSDVVLYH
–D (VVLYH 56K8JHK 6
,QWKHDFWLYHRSWDWLYH
:KHQ%KDVEHHQSURPRWHGWRWKHDEVROXWLYH
6
2XWVLGHRIPDUNLQJWKHSDWLHQWLQFHUWDLQVLWXDWLRQVWKHHVVLYHDOVRKDVDQREOLTXHIXQFWLRQ)RUWKHWRSLFDWKDQG%
,DPRQO\IRFXVLQJRQWKHXVHRIWKLVFDVHDVFRQFHUQVWKHFRUHDUJXPHQWVRIDFODXVH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% <Q

$EEUHYLDWLRQV
.%R +HLQULFK2WWHQ%*!]$!%(10%D!&(1"!%<.HLOVFKULIWWH[WHDXV%RJKD]NRL%HUOLQ*HEU0DQQ
.%R :&/%)/.2#;++&%#,%(#<2)/*+&4#='*+&)8#H#!%+1--#$#04+M+!$+#$#04+!%S#.#)51!%1)"%9!#$!-!%*!]$!%(10%"!-%
,&!-0$("$.HLOVFKULIWWH[WHDXV%RJKD]NRL%HUOLQ*HEU0DQQ

%LEOLRJUDSK\
%ODNH%DUU\-
% :??O% 3(0!QGHGLWLRQ&DPEULGJH7H[WERRNVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
%ODQVLWW(GZDUG/-U
  ´'HFKWLFDHWLDWLYHDQG'DWLYHµ,Q,&c!4$0g%*69(-"0%(%*+!6-'%6:%D-(>>($#4(.%K!.($#6)0HGLWHGE\)¬3ODQN
SS²/RQGRQ$FDGHPLF3UHVV
%RN%HQQHPD5HLQHNH
% OPPO% 3(0!%()"%<5-!!>!)$%#)%/)1#$6WXGLHVLQ*HQHUDWLYH*UDPPDU1HZ<RUN)RULV3XEOLFDWLRQV
%XVK)
  $*UDPPDURIWKH+XUULDQ/DQJXDJH3K'GLVV%UDQGHLV8QLYHUVLW\
&DPSEHOO'HQQLV50
 D 0RRGDQG0RGDOLW\LQ+XUULDQ3K'GLVV8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR
 E ´7KH2OG+XUULDQ9HUEµ,Q´9,&RQJUHVVR,QWHUQD]LRQDOHGL,WWLWRORJLD5RPD²VHWWHPEUH2Y%
HGLWHGE\$$UFKLDQG5)UDQFLDVSHFLDOLVVXH7$1"#%A#4!)!#%!"%85!6M<)($6.#4#²
  ´6SOLWHUJDWLYLW\LQ+XUULDQµ%t!#$04+-#:$%:u-%<00'-#6.65#!²%
'LDNRQRII,JRU0DQG6$6WDURVWLQ
  O1--6M\-(-$#()%(0%()%8(0$!-)%3(14(0#()%N()51(5!0XQLFK5.LW]LQJHU
'LMNVWUD0HLQGHUW
  ´7KH$NNDGR+XUULDQ%LOLQJXDO:LVGRP7H[W565HFRQVLGHUHGµ\5(-#$%F6-04+1)5!)%:RN%
²
'L[RQ5REHUW0:
% OPP<% 8-5($#?#$'L&DPEULGJH6WXGLHVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
'U\HU0DWWKHZ6
  ´3ULPDU\2EMHFWV6HFRQGDU\2EMHFWVDQG$QWLGDWLYHµN()51(5!%²
'X%RLV-RKQ:
  ´7KH'LVFRXUVH%DVLVRI(UJDWLYLW\µN()51(5!²
)ULHGULFK-RKDQQHV
% OPQP% b.!#)!%S!#$-a5!%G1-%4+1--#$#04+!)%D-(>>($#=0LWWHLOXQJHQGHU9RUGHUDVLDWLVFK$HJ\SWLVFKHQ*HVHOO
VFKDIW9ROXPH/HLS]LJ-&+LQULFKV
  ´&KXUULWLVFKµ,Q<.$=.!#)(0#($#04+!%7I-(4+!)SS²+DQGERRNRI2ULHQWDO6WXGLHV9ROXPH6HF
WLRQV²1XPEHU/HLGHQ%ULOO
48F7I8J782%06L7F%
  ´'LHKXUULWLVFKHQ.DVXVHQGXQJHQµ,QB1G#%($%7!?!)$'M:#?!HGLWHGE\'2ZHQDQG*:LOKHOPSS
²6WXGLHVRQWKH&LYLOL]DWLRQDQG&XOWXUHRI1X]LDQGWKH+XUULDQV%HWKHVGD&'/3UHVV
  ´6FKL]]RJUDPPDWLFDOHGHOODOLQJXDKXUULFDµ,QN(%3#?#.$h%"!#%O1--#$#HGLWHGE\*0DFFKLDUROLSS
²/D3DURODGHO3DVVDWR1DSOHV*&DUUDWHOOL
  ´=XGHQKXUULWLVFKHQ9HUEIRUPHQDXIL D(LQH%HULFKWLJXQJµ7$1"#%A#4!)!#%!"%85!6%<)($6.#4#
 oi.uchicago.edu

<<% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

*LUEDO&KULVWLDQ
  ´'DVKXUULWLVFKH$QWLSDVVLYµ7$1"#%A#4!)!#%!"%85!6%<)($6.#4#²
*LYyQ7DOP\
  ´'LUHFW2EMHFWDQG'DWLYH6KLIWLQJ6HPDQWLFDQG3UDJPDWLF&DVHµ,Q,&c!4$0g%*69(-"0%(%*+!6-'%6:%
D-(>>($#4(.%K!.($#6)0HGLWHGE\)3ODQNSS²/RQGRQ$FDGHPLF3UHVV
+DDV9RONHUWDQG,OVH:HJQHU
  ´/LWHUDULVFKHXQGJUDPPDWLNDOLVFKH%HWUDFKWXQJHQ]XHLQHUKXUULWLVFKHQ'LFKWXQJµ,-#!)$(.#0$#04+!%
N#$!-($1-G!#$1)5²
+DDV9RONHUWDQG*HUQRW:LOKHOP
% OP@<% O1--#$#04+!%1)"%.19#04+!%K#$!)%(10%b#GG19($)(L+XUULWRORJLVFKH6WXGLHQ,$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWD
PHQW6RQGHUUHLKH1HXNLUFKHQ9OX\Q1HXNLUFKHQHU9HUODJ
+D]HQERV-RRVW
  ´=XU6\QWD[HLQLJHUPRGDOHU)RUPHQLP+XUULWLVFKHQµ,Qb1.$1-5!04+#4+$!)g%<.$6-#!)$(.#0$#04+!%7$1"#!)%
:u-%T6.=!-$%O((0%G1>%|sL%D!&1-$0$(5HGLWHGE\75LFKWHU'3UHFKHODQG-.OLQJHUSS²6DDU
EUFNHQ6DDUEUFNHU'UXFNHUHLXQG9HUODJ
  ´+XUULWLVFKXQG8UDUWlLVFKµ,Q7I-(4+!)%"!0%<.$!)%,-#!)$0HGLWHGE\06WUHFNSS²'DUP
VWDGW:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH%XFKJHVHOOVFKDIW
.KDɥLNMDQ0DUJDUHW
  ´'LDOHNWQRMHɥOHQHQLMHNKXUULWVNRJRMD]\NDµH-!?)#c%T60$6=²
  ´7KH+XUULDQ9HUE5HYLVLWHGµ,QB1G#%($%7!?!)$'M:#?!HGLWHGE\'2ZHQDQG*:LOKHOPSS²
6WXGLHVRQWKH&LYLOL]DWLRQDQG&XOWXUHRI1X]LDQGWKH+XUULDQV%HWKHVGD&'/3UHVV
0DQQLQJ&KULVWRSKHU'
  8-5($#?#$'g%<-51>!)$%7$-14$1-!%()"%D-(>>($#4(.%K!.($#6)0%'LVVHUWDWLRQVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV6WDQIRUG&HQWHU
IRUWKH6WXG\RI/DQJXDJHDQG,QIRUPDWLRQ3XEOLFDWLRQV
0HVVHUVFKPLGW/HRSROG
  A#$())#M7$1"#!)L0LWWHLOXQJHQGHU9RUGHUDVLDWLVFK$HJ\SWLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIW%HUOLQ:ROI3HLVHU
0LWKXQ0DULDQQH
  ´$FWLYH$JHQWLYH&DVH0DUNLQJDQG,WV0RWLYDWLRQVµN()51(5!²
1HX(ULFK
  ´9DULD+XUULWLFD6SUDFKOLFKH%HREDFKWXQJHQDQGHUKXUULWLVFKKHWKLWLVFKHQ%LOLQJXHDXV҅DWWXߖDµ
*H%H641>!)$1>%<0#(!%A#)6-#0%<)$#X1(!g%F!0$04+-#:$%:u-%O!#)-#4+%,$$!)%G1>%osL%D!&1-$0$(5HGLWHGE\(1HX
DQG&5VWHUSS²:LHVEDGHQ2WWR+DUUDVRZLW]
  H(0%+1--#$#04+!%8I60%"!-%F-!#.(001)52%1F>LMJ%ON%\)$!-014+1)5!)%G1%!#)!>%+1--#$#04+M+!$+#$#04+!)%*!]$!)M
0!>&.!%(10%O($$10(L6WXGLHQ]XGHQ%RJD]N|\7H[WHQ:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
;++&%5#:&/%)/.2
  *!]$!%(10%D!&(1"!%<.HLOVFKULIWWH[WHDXV%RJKD]NRL%HUOLQ*HEU0DQQ
;++&%5#:&/%)/.25#,%(#<2)/*+&4#='*+&)
% OPP?% H#!%+1--#$#04+M+!$+#$#04+!%S#.#)51!%1)"%9!#$!-!%*!]$!%(10%"!-%,&!-0$("$.HLOVFKULIWWH[WHDXV%RJKD]NRL
%HUOLQ*HEU0DQQ
3DOPHU)5
% OPP<% D-(>>($#4(.%K6.!0%()"%K!.($#6)0&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
3ODQN)
  ´'DV+XUULWLVFKHXQGGLH6SUDFKZLVVHQVFDIWµ,QO1--#$!-%1)"%O1--#$#04+HGLWHGE\9+DDVSS²
;HQLD.RQVWDQ]8QLYHUVLWlWVYHUODJ.RQVWDQ]
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <D8B*2%7\SP83*2%@<*/8B*2%<BH%S8B8F/3/<KYg%DK<AA<*/3<N%K,N87%/B%O\KK/<B% <R

6DOYLQL0LUMR
  ´(DUOLHVW(YLGHQFHRIWKH+XUULDQVEHIRUHWKH)RUPDWLRQRIWKH5HLJQRI0LWWDQQLµ,Q\-=!0+%()"%$+!%
O1--#()0g%7$1"#!0%#)%O6)6-%6:%N.6'"%36$0!)HGLWHGE\*%XFFHOODWLDQG0.HOO\%XFFHOODWLSS²
8UNHVK0R]DQ6WXGLHV %LEOLRWKHFD0HVRSRWDPLFD0DOLEX8QGHQD
6DOYLQL0LUMRDQG,OVH:HJQHU
% :??<% H#!%>'$+6.65#04+!)%*!]$!&RUSXVGHUKXUULWLVFKHQ6SUDFKGHQNPlOHU'LH7H[WHDXV%RJD]N|\
5RPH&15,VWLWXWRGL6WXGLVXOOH&LYLOWjGHOO·(JHRHGHO9LFLQR2ULHQWH
6SHLVHU($
% OP<O% /)$-6"14$#6)%$6%O1--#()$QQXDORIWKH$PHULFDQ6FKRROVRI2ULHQWDO5HVHDUFK1HZ+DYHQ$PHUL
FDQ6FKRROVRI2ULHQWDO5HVHDUFK
6WHLQNHOOHU3LRWU
  ´7KH+LVWRULFDO%DFNJURXQGRI8UNHVKDQGWKH+XUULDQ%HJLQQLQJVLQ1RUWKHUQ0HVRSRWDPLDµ,Q
\-=!0+%()"%$+!%O1--#()0g%7$1"#!0%#)%O6)6-%6:%N.6'"%36$0!)HGLWHGE\*%XFFHOODWLDQG0.HOO\%XFFHOOD
WLSS²8UNHVK0R]DQ6WXGLHV %LEOLRWKHFD0HVRSRWDPLFD0DOLEX8QGHQD
7LIIRXeWLHQQHDQG<YHV&KDUOHV0RULQ
  ´$1RWHRQ6SOLW(UJDWLYLW\LQ%XUXVKDVNLµS1..!$#)%6:%$+!%74+66.%6:%,-#!)$(.%()"%<:-#4()%7$1"#!0%<RN%
²
9DQ9DOLQ5REHUW'-UDQG5DQG\-/D3ROOD
% OPP@% 7')$(]g%7$-14$1-!2%A!()#)5%()"%F1)4$#6)&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
:HJQHU,OVH
  ´3KRQRWDNWLVFKHUQ9HUOXVWLQ-XVVLYIRUPHQGHV%RОD]N|\+XUULWLVFKHQµ,-#!)$(.#(2QV²

  ´+XUULWLVFKH9HUEGLFHQGLPLWHLQIDFKHUXQGGRSSHOWHU$EVROXWLY5HNWLRQµ<.$6-#!)$(.#04+!%F6-04+1)M
5!)²
% :???% 8#):u+-1)5%#)%"#!%+1--#$#04+!%7I-(4+!L:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
% :??@% 8#):u+-1)5%#)%"#!%+1--#$#04+!%7I-(4+!2%1F>LMJ%:N%}&!-(-&!#$!$!%<1:.(5!:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVRZLW]
:LOKHOP*HUQRW
  *+!%O1--#()07UDQVODWHGE\-%DUQHV:DUPLQVWHU$ULV 3KLOOLSV
 D ´=XPKXUULWLVFKHQ9HUEDOV\VWHPµ,Q*!]$!2%7a$G!2%J~-$!-%1)"%A6)!>!g%F!0$04+-#:$%:u-%b.(10%O!5!-%G1>%
|sL%D!&1-$0$(5HGLWHGE\6$QVFKW]SS²+HLGHOEHUJ+HLGHOEHUJHU2ULHQWYHUODJ
 E ´+XUULWLVFKH/H[LNRJUDSKLHXQG*UDPPDWLN'LHKXUULWLVFKKHWKLWLVFKH%LOLQJXHDXV%RОD]N|\µ
,-#!)$(.#(2QV²
  ´6XIIL[DXIQDKPHLQ+XUULDQDQG8UDUWLDQµ,QH61&.!%3(0!g%<5-!!>!)$%&'%71::#](1:)(+>!HGLWHGE\
)¬3ODQNSS²1HZ<RUN2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
  ´'LH,QVFKULIWGHV7LߖDWDOYRQ8UNHߖµ,Q\-=!0+%()"%$+!%O1--#()0g%7$1"#!0%#)%O6)6-%6:%N.6'"%36$0!)2%
HGLWHGE\*%XFFHOODWLDQG0.HOO\%XFFHOODWLSS²8UNHVK0R]DQ6WXGLHV %LEOLRWKHFD
0HVRSRWDPLFD0DOLEX8QGHQD
  ´'LH$EVROXWLY(VVLY.RQVWUXNWLRQGHV+XUULWLVFKHQµ,Q81-6I(%!$%<0#(%@6.'5.6$$(M7I-(4+!)%1)"%b1.$1M
-!)Mg%F!0$04+-#:$%:u-%K6&!-$%74+>#$$MS-()"$%G1>%opL%D!&1-$0$(5HGLWHGE\<1LVKLQDSS²>&++&47
?,.2@#A8#:8#=B44#
  ´+XUULWLVFKQDLSWL¶:HLGXQJ·¶:HLGH·RGHUHLQHEHVWLPPWH$UWYRQ:HLGHµ,Qb1.$1-5!04+#4+$!)g%
<.$6-#!)$(.#0$#04+!%7$1"#!)%:u-%T6.=!-$%O((0%G1>%|sL%D!&1-$0$(5HGLWHGE\75LFKWHU'3UHFKHODQG
-¬.OLQJHUSS²6DDUEUFNHQ6DDUEUFNHU'UXFNHUHLXQG9HUODJ
  ´=XUDQJHEOLFKHQ*|WWLQ҅LJDµ,QD!)!-(.%7$1"#!0%()"%8]4(?($#6)0%($%B1G#%_plrHGLWHGE\'2ZHQDQG
*¬:LOKHOPSS²6WXGLHVRQWKH&LYLOL]DWLRQDQG&XOWXUHRI1X]LDQGWKH+XUULDQV%HWKHV
GD&'/3UHVV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H8BB/7%KL%AL%3<A@S8NN

  ´%HPHUNXQJHQ]XGHUDNNDGLVFKKXUULWLVFKHQ%LOLQJXHDXV8JDULWµ,QN#$!-($1-2%@6.#$#=%1)"%K!4+$%#)%
A!06I6$(>#!)g%F!0$04+-#:$%:u-%3.(10%J#.4=!HGLWHGE\:6DOODEHUJHU.9RONDQG$=JROOSS²
2ULHQWDOLD%LEOLFDHW&KULVWLDQD:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]9HUODJ
  ´+XUULDQµ,Q*+!%3(>&-#"5!%8)4'4.6I!"#(%6:%$+!%J6-.";0%<)4#!)$%N()51(5!0HGLWHGE\5':RRGDUGSS
²&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H87%3<7%8B%QN<A/*8[% <@

!
"#$%&'$%#(%)*'+,-#.

F.6-!)4!%A(.&-()MN(&($2%3BK7

/·pODPLWHODQJXHGHO·,UDQSUpDFKpPpQLGHHWDFKpPpQLGHIDLWSDUWLHGHVODQJXHVHQFRUHLPSDUIDLWHPHQW
FRPSULVHV
/HFRUSXVHQHVWjODIRLVOLPLWpHWGLYHUVUpXQLVVDQWGHVWH[WHVTXLV·pWDOHQWVXUSUqVGHGHX[PLOOpQDLUHVHWTXL
DSSDUWLHQQHQWjSOXVLHXUVYDULpWpVGLDOHFWDOHVO&·HVWODODQJXHGXSUHPLHUPLOOpQDLUHTXLHVWODPLHX[GRFXPHQWpH
PDLVF·HVWDXVVLSUREDEOHPHQWODPRLQVUHSUpVHQWDWLYHGXJpQLHSURSUHGHVHVVWUXFWXUHVHOOHHVWDORUVjODIRLV
IRUPXODLUHVWpUpRW\SpHHW´GpFDGHQWHµGDQVODPHVXUHRHOOHHVWWUqVLQIOXHQFpHSDUG·DXWUHVLGLRPHVFRQWHP
SRUDLQV DUDPpHQYLHX[SHUVH GHVWUXFWXUHVUDGLFDOHPHQWGLIIpUHQWHV&HWWHFRQWDPLQDWLRQHVWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQW
QHWWHSRXUFHUWDLQHVUHODWLRQVFRPPHFHOOHG·DSSDUWHQDQFH&HWWHGLVSDULWpGDQVODGRFXPHQWDWLRQUHQGGLIILFLOH
GHVXLYUHO·pYROXWLRQGHO·pODPLWHQRWDPPHQWHQFHTXLFRQFHUQHOHVpWDWVDQFLHQVWUqVSHXDWWHVWpV
4XRLTX·LOHQVRLWGHVGLIIpUHQWVFRUSXVLOHVWQHWTXHO·pODPLWHpYROXDjSDUWLUG·XQHV\QWD[HGHSRVLWLRQIRU
WHPHQWQRPLQDOHDXVHLQGHODTXHOOHODPRUSKRORJLHpWDLWWUqVSDXYUHYHUVXQHUpRUJDQLVDWLRQGHVFRQVWLWXDQWV
³HWGHOHXUVPDUTXHV³DXWRXUG·XQQR\DXYHUEDOSOXVRXPRLQVG\QDPLTXH
-HPHFRQWHQWHUDLLFLG·HVVD\HUGHPHWWUHHQOXPLqUHTXHOTXHVXQVGHVIDFWHXUVVXUOHVTXHOVUHSRVHOHPDU
TXDJHGHVFRQVWLWXDQWVQRPLQDX[GHODSKUDVH&HVPDUTXHVMHO·DLGLWVRQWGDQVO·pWDWDQFLHQGHODODQJXHSHX
QRPEUHXVHVHWVHFRQIRQGHQWORUVTX·HOOHVDSSDUDLVVHQWDYHFOHVPDUTXHVGXJHQUH

*/0%12210343150%615789/548:/0

;221034315%8539<=358539<
(QHIIHWO·pODPLWHODQJXHDJJOXWLQDQWHGRQWRQGLVFXWHOHFDUDFWqUHHUJDWLI:SUpVHQWHDXQLYHDXGXOH[LTXH
XQHRSSRVLWLRQHQWUHVXEVWDQWLIVDQLPpVHWVXEVWDQWLIVLQDQLPpVOHVXQVHWOHVDXWUHVSRXYDQWrWUH´SULPDLUHVµRX
´GpULYpVµQ/HVXEVWDQWLI´SULPDLUHµQHFRPSRUWHSDVGDQVVDIRUPDWLRQOH[LFDOHGHPDUTXHGHVRQFDUDFWqUHDQLPp
RXLQDQLPpjO·HQFRQWUHGXVXEVWDQWLI´GpULYpµTXLHQFRPSRUWHXQH MZ#@-%SRXUO·DQLPpMZ#@>!%SRXUO·LQDQLPp< 

O
2XWUHOHVGLIIpUHQFHVUpJLRQDOHVO·pODPLWHGLVWLQJXHTXDWUHJUDQGHV :%
:LOKHOP6WHLQHU.KDɥLNMDQ²
SpULRGHVOHSDOpRpODPLWH ILQGXqPHPLOOpQDLUH OHPpGLRpODPLWH Q
*ULOORW6XVLQL²
 qPHPRLWLpGX qPHPLOOpQDLUH OHQpRpODPLWH GpEXWGX J7%M8> <
3OXVUDUHPHQW$!/DPDUTXH)HVWFRQVLGpUpHVRLWDXVVLFRPPHXQH
OpQDLUH HWO·pODPLWHDFKpPLGH  qPHPRLWLpGX J7PLOOpQDLUH /HV PDUTXHG·LQDQLPpVRLWFRPPHXQHPDUTXHGHORFDOLVDWHXU
FRUSXVVRQWGHQDWXUHHWG·LPSRUWDQFHYDULpHV&I6WROSHU

<@
 oi.uchicago.edu

% FN,K8B38%A<NSK<BMN<S<*

71&0$()$#:0%I-#>(#-!0 71&0$()$#:0%"U-#?U0
$QLPpV ,QDQLPpV $QLPpV ,QDQLPpV

] ] - >!%$%)
)(I GLHX +10( DF89 01)=L#-% 7F8 01)=L#>! UR\DXWp

-1+ KRPPH +#k HFM ³ ³ 0#'(L) KJM=>J

-1$1 pSRXVH ³ ³ ³ ³ ³ ³

#5# IUqUH ³ ³ ³ ³ ³ ³

k(= G8>9 >!) FRXURQQH >!)L#- VRXYHUDLQ >!)L#) VRXYHUDLQHWp

([HPSOH

'DQVOHGLVFRXUVOHVVXEVWDQWLIVSULPDLUHVDQLPpVVRQWFDUDFWpULVpVHWPDUTXpVFRPPHVHUDSSRUWDQWVRLW
DXORFXWHXU = VRLWjO·DOORFXWHXU M$ VRLWDXGpORFXWHXUR'DQVFHGHUQLHUFDVSRXUOHVVXEVWDQWLIVSULPDLUHV
ODPDUTXHHVW]pURHOOHHVW # -SRXUOHVGpULYpV$XSOXULHO XQLTXHPHQWDQLPp jODqPHSHUVRQQHDSSDUDvWOD
PDUTXHM # I
/HVLQDQLPpVQHVRQWSDVVXVFHSWLEOHVG·rWUHFDUDFWpULVpVFRPPHORFXWHXURXLQWHUORFXWHXULOVQ·RQWSDVGH
SOXULHO

N!]#X1!

,QDQLPpV $QLPpV
578M687J9 'pULYpV 578M687J9 'pULYpV
+10(%DF89 01)=L # >! )(I%GLHX 01)=L # - 'pORFXWLI
)(IL # $ 01)=L # $ $OORFXWLI $8HIL>8J7 A(-X1!0%
)(IL # = 01)=L # = /RFXWLI "#041-0#?!0

)(IL # I 01)=L # I 'pORFXWLI 5>L78J>

([HPSOH

;221034315%2>?80/%04843@A/=2>?80/%7B5893@A/
/·pODPLWHSUpVHQWHGHX[W\SHVGHSKUDVHVODSKUDVHVWDWLTXHQRPLQDOHIUpTXHQWHGDQVODODQJXHDQFLHQQHHW
ODSKUDVHGRWpHG·XQHIRUPHYHUEDOHDXWRXUGHODTXHOOHV·RUJDQLVHQWOHVFRQVWLWXDQWVFHSHQGDQWGDQVFHVHFRQG
W\SHFHWWHIRUPHHVWSOXVRXPRLQVG\QDPLTXH YRLUHVWDWLTXH VXLYDQWOHW\SHGHFRQMXJDLVRQHPSOR\pH
/DSKUDVHQRPLQDOHHVWGHW\SHpTXDWLIHWFRPELQHGHVV\QWDJPHVSOXVRXPRLQVFRPSOH[HVGDQVODPHVXUH
RLOVFRPSRUWHQWSOXVRXPRLQVGHGpWHUPLQDWLRQV&HVV\QWDJPHVGHGpWHUPLQDWLRQIRQFWLRQQHQWSDULQFOXVLRQ
ODPDUTXHGXJHQUHGXWHUPHGpWHUPLQpFORWOHV\QWDJPH

R
(ULFD5HLQHU  DSURSRVpFHVDSSHOODWLRQVSRXUOHVUpIpUHQFHV
DX[GLIIpUHQWHVVSKqUHVGXGLVFRXUVSRXUOHVGLVWLQJXHUGHV´SHU
VRQQHVµTXLDSSDUWLHQQHQWHQSURSUHDXYHUEHG\QDPLTXH FIH[ 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H87%3<7%8B%QN<A/*8[% <P

([HPSOH

*/0%2?1210343150

C?121034315%519358:/
/DSKUDVHQRPLQDOHGHW\SHpTXDWLISUpVHQWHHQWrWHOHWHUPHRXOHV\QWDJPHTXLHQHVWOHWKqPHVXLYLSDU
OHWHUPHRXOHV\QWDJPHTXLOHGpWHUPLQH´DFFRUGpµHWPDUTXpSDUOHPRUSKqPHFRUUHVSRQGDQWDXJHQUHGX
VXEVWDQWLILQLWLDOWKqPHGHODSKUDVH

([HPSOH

/HVQRWLRQVGHORFDOLVDWLRQH[SULPDQWXQHUHODWLRQVSDFLDOH ´VXUµ´VRXVµ´GHYDQWµ´GHUULqUHµ VRQWH[SULPpHV

SDUXQGRXEOHV\QWDJPHGHGpWHUPLQDWLRQOHVXEVWDQWLIH[SULPDQWOHOLHXVSpFLILTXH ´OHGHVVXVµ´OHGHVVRXVµ
HWF HVWOHGpWHUPLQDQWG·XQGHVWHUPHVGHODUHODWLRQVSDFLDOHHWLOHVWGpWHUPLQpSDUO·DXWUHWHUPH´OHFLHOHVW
VXUPRLµHVWH[SULPpSDUODSURSRVLWLRQQRPLQDOH´OHFLHO HVW OHGHVVXVGHPRLµ

([HPSOH


-HQHGLVFXWHSDVLFLODIRQFWLRQGHFHGpWHUPLQDQWPDUTXpOH[LFD
OHPHQWSDU)gRQSHXWOHFRPSUHQGUHVRLWFRPPHXQLQDQLPp G·R
XQHWUDGXFWLRQ´URLG·$Q]DQ>HW@GH6XVHµ VRLWFRPPHXQORFDOLVDWHXU
G·RXQHWUDGXFWLRQ´URLj$Q]DQ>HW@j6XVHµ 
@
-HQHSUHQGVSDVLFLHQFRPSWHODYR\HOOHTXLSUpFqGH #M RXTXL
VXLW M( OHPRUSKqPHGHJHQUH

/HSKpQRPqQHGHFRPSRVLWLRQHVWWUqVLPSRUWDQWGDQVOHOH[LTXH
pODPLWH´O·DYDQWµ´O·DUULqUHµ ´ODYRXWHµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

R?% FN,K8B38%A<NSK<BMN<S<*

C?121034315%D/?E8:/
/HVSURSRVLWLRQVYHUEDOHVIRQWDSSHOjSOXVLHXUVFRQMXJDLVRQVGRQWRQGLVFXWHHQFRUHOHVVLJQLILFDWLRQVUHVSHF
WLYHV6DQVHQWUHULFLGDQVOHXUpWXGHMHPHERUQHUDLjVRXOLJQHUTXHODFRQVWUXFWLRQHWOHPDUTXDJHGHVFRPSRVDQWV
QRPLQDX[YDULHQWVHORQODFRQMXJDLVRQHPSOR\pH/HVFRQMXJDLVRQVYDULHQWHQHIIHWVHORQOHXUGHJUpG·HUJDWLYLWp
HOOHVSHXYHQWH[SULPHUO·pWDWGHFHFHOXLTXLDVXELXQHDFWLRQO·pWDWGHFHOXLTXLDODSRWHQWLDOLWpGHUpDOLVHU
XQHDFWLRQ FHVRQWOHVFRQMXJDLVRQVGLWHV´QRPLQDOHVµGRQWOHVPDUTXHVSHUVRQQHOOHVVRQWFHOOHVGHVVXEVWDQWLIV
DQLPpV-$=I PRXODUpDOLVDWLRQG·XQSURFqVSDUXQDJHQW&HWWHGHUQLqUHFRQMXJDLVRQGLWH´,µODSOXVG\QD
PLTXHDSRXUVXMHWO·DJHQWG·XQSURFqVUpDOLVpVXUXQSDWLHQW FRQMXJDLVRQDFWLYHWUDQVLWLYHRX´HUJDWLYHµ (OOH
VHFDUDFWpULVHSDUGHVVXIIL[HVSHUVRQQHOV UHQYR\DQWjO·DJHQWGXSURFqV TXLOXLVRQWSURSUHV

7#)51.#!- @.1-#!.

O =J79FHHJ
qUH
KXWWDK c;(#%:(#$ KXWWDKX )610%(?6)0%:(#$
:qPH=J79FHHJ KXWWDW $1%(0%:(#$ KXWWDKW ?610%(?!G%:(#$
QqPH=J79FHHJ KXWWDߖ #.%(%:(#$ KXWWDKߖ #.0%6)$%:(#$

([HPSOH

C?121034315%8D/F%D/?E/%G%:8%F15HAI83015%8F43D/J4?850343D/

&1504?AF4315%2?<J7<6353/
'DQVOHVSURSRVLWLRQVGRQWOHYHUEHHVWjODFRQMXJDLVRQ,OD´FRQMXJDLVRQHUJDWLYHµOHVXMHWHVWSDUGpILQLWLRQ
DQLPpHWOHFRPSOpPHQWGLUHFWLQDQLPp,OQ·\DSDVHQFHFDVGHPDUTXHGHIRQFWLRQ6HXOHDSSDUDvWDXVLQJX
OLHUODPDUTXHGXJHQUHDQLPp  # - SRXUOHVVXEVWDQWLIVGpULYpVRXDXSOXULHOSRXUWRXVOHVVXEVWDQWLIVDQLPpV
ODPDUTXH # I,O\DDORUVDFFRUGGHVPDUTXHVDQLPpHVGXVXEVWDQWLIVXMHWDYHFOHVXIIL[HSHUVRQQHOGXYHUEH

71&0$()$#: T!-&!
7#)51.#!- ¡ # - +
@.1-#!.% #I +ߖ

/RUVTXHOHVXMHWGHODSKUDVHHQUHSUpVHQWHOHWKqPHO·RUGUHQRUPDOGHVFRQVWLWXDQWVHVW6XMHW²&RPSOpPHQW²
9HUEH

([HPSOH

P
&I*ULOORW6XVLQL²SRXUODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWKpRULTXHGHV
FRQMXJDLVRQV´QRPLQDOHVµDYHFPDUTXHXUGHGLDWKqVH=%=FL7%>J%=69
VLI)SRXUGLDWKqVH´QHXWUHµ QLSDVVLIQLDFWLIWUDQVLWLI ,OFRQYLHQW
GHQRWHUWRXWHIRLVTXHWRXWHVOHVIRUPHVLQGLTXpHVSRXUOHYHUEH
+1$$(M´IDLUHµQHVRQWSDVHIIHFWLYHPHQWDWWHVWpHV FI+LQ]DQG.RFK
² 
O?
/HV\QWDJPHGRQWOHWHUPHGpWHUPLQpHVWXQLQDQLPpGpULYpHQQ
HVWLFLFORVSDUXQDXWUHPRUSKqPHPDUTXDQWFHJHQUH PH 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H87%3<7%8B%QN<A/*8[% RO

&1504?AF4315%?/J7<6353/
!"#$%&'(%)&*+,-)*+#&./$')%)&
&HSHQGDQWO·RUGUHSHXWrWUHPRGLILpVLOHFRPSOpPHQWUHSUpVHQWHOHWKqPHGHODSKUDVHVDQVTXHOHVPDUTXHV
GLIIqUHQWODIRUPHGXYHUEHLPSOLTXHWRXMRXUVTXHO·DQLPpHVWOHVXMHWO·LQDQLPpOHFRPSOpPHQWOO

([HPSOH

&HW\SHGHGpWHUPLQDWLRQGHODIRQFWLRQGHVFRQVWLWXDQWVSDUOHXUJHQUHSHXWDXVVLIRQFWLRQQHUGDQVGHV
FRQWH[WHVSOXVFRPSOH[HVQRWDPPHQWORUVTXHOHWKqPHGHODSKUDVHQ·HVWQLOHVXMHW FHTXHPDUTXHOHQRQDFFRUG
DYHFOHVXIIL[HSHUVRQQHOGXYHUEH QLOHFRPSOpPHQWGLUHFWPDLVOHGpWHUPLQDQWGHO·XQGHFHVGHX[DFWDQWV&HWWH
IRQFWLRQGHGpWHUPLQDWLRQHVWH[SULPpHSDUXQPRUSKqPHUpVRPSWLIFDUDFWpULVWLTXHGXJHQUH HWGXQRPEUH GX
GpWHUPLQDQWFHWpOpPHQWHVWSODFpDSUqVOHVXEVWDQWLIGpWHUPLQpGDQVXQV\QWDJPHFORVSDUXQpOpPHQWGpPRQV
WUDWLIUHQYR\DQWDXGpWHUPLQpLQDQLPp GpWHUPLQDQWGpWHUPLQpPDUTXHGHJHQUHGXGpWHUPLQDQWUpIpUHQFHDX
GpWHUPLQp ,OQ·\DDXFXQHPDUTXHGHIRQFWLRQSURSUHPHQWGLWHODFRQVWUXFWLRQUHSRVHVXUO·RUGUHGHVpOpPHQWV
DYHFSUROHSVHGXGpWHUPLQDQW HWHPSORLUpVRPSWLIGHODPDUTXHGHJHQUH

([HPSOH

0%&'.)&*%)'$#
/RUVTX·XQDQLPpHVWFRPSOpPHQWGLUHFWG·XQHIRUPHGHFRQMXJDLVRQ,XQPDUTXDJHVSpFLILTXHDSSDUDvW
GHYDQWOHYHUEHF·HVWOHPRUSKqPHTXLFDUDFWpULVHO·DQLPp # -&HPDUTXDJHDXQLYHDXGXYHUEHYLHQWUHTXDOLILHU
OHFRPSOpPHQWHQLQGLTXDQWTX·LODSSDUWLHQWjODFDWpJRULHGHVDQLPpV(QFHFDVO·RUGUHGHVFRQVWLWXDQWVHVW
LPSpUDWLIjO·LQLWLDOOHVXMHW

OO
8QLQDQLPpQHSHXWSDVrWUHVXMHWG·XQHSKUDVHDYHFYHUEHjOD OQ
'DQVXQHSKUDVHDYHFYHUEHjODFRQMXJDLVRQ,OHSURQRPSHUVRQQHO
FRQMXJDLVRQ,/DFRQVWUXFWLRQDYHFXQLQDQLPpVXMHWHQWUDvQHXQH 1 ´MHµ SHXWrWUHDEVHQWTXDQGODIRUPHYHUEDOHFRPSRUWHODPDUTXH
FRQVWUXFWLRQSDVVLYH GHqUHVLQJXOLHU
O:
0DUTXHG·XQV\QWDJPHGHGpWHUPLQDWLRQYHUEDO
 oi.uchicago.edu

R:% FN,K8B38%A<NSK<BMN<S<*

([HPSOH

$LQVLODPDUTXHGHJHQUH DQLPp HVWXWLOLVpHSRXULQGLTXHUODIRQFWLRQGHFRPSOpPHQWG·XQDQLPpGDQVXQH

SKUDVHDYHFXQHIRUPHYHUEDOHDFWLYHWUDQVLWLYHGDQVFHFDVFRPPHGDQVODSKUDVHQRPLQDOHOHVPDUTXHVVRQW
FHOOHVGXJHQUHHWQRQFHOOHVGHVIRQFWLRQVHQWDQWTXHWHOOHV/HPDUTXDJHFRQFHUQHXQHDQRPDOLHSDUUDSSRUWj
ODFRQVWUXFWLRQGHEDVH DQLPpVXMHW²LQDQLPpFRPSOpPHQW²FRQMXJDLVRQDFWLYHWUDQVLWLYH FRQVWUXFWLRQTXLHVW
OLpHjODQDWXUHDJHQWLYHGHO·DQLPp

-?130K9/%8F4854
3RXUFHTXLFRQFHUQHOHWURLVLqPHDFWDQW OHGHVWLQDWDLUH LOHVWHQJpQpUDODQLPpLOHVWQRQPDUTXp TXHFH
VRLWXQVXEVWDQWLIRXXQSURQRPGHqUH%FL%:qPHSHUVRQQH HWVHXOO·DFFRUGGXYHUEHOHGLVWLQJXHGXVXMHWDQLPp

([HPSOH

C>?80/%F192:/L/

M/6<?/5F/%8A%2843/54%358539<
/HPDUTXDJH #- DXQLYHDXGHODIRUPHYHUEDOHG·XQDQLPpFRPSOpPHQWG·XQHIRUPHGHFRQMXJDLVRQ, FI
H[ HVWGLVWLQFWGHFHOXLTXLLQGLTXHGDQVXQHSKUDVHFRPSRVpHGHSOXVLHXUVSURSRVLWLRQVTX·XQVXEVWDQWLI
LQDQLPpGHODSUHPLqUHSURSRVLWLRQHVWUHSULVFRPPHFRPSOpPHQWGDQVODVHFRQGH #) 

O<
´OXLµSOXW{WTXH´OHµFDULOQHV·DJLWSDVG·XQSURQRPPDVFXOLQj
O·DFFXVDWLI
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H87%3<7%8B%QN<A/*8[% RQ

([HPSOH

&HVFRQVWUXFWLRQVUHVWHQWIRQGDPHQWDOHVWRXWDXORQJGHO·pYROXWLRQGHO·pODPLWHPrPHVLGHVFRQVWUXFWLRQV
PDUJLQDOHVIRQWOHXUDSSDULWLRQ&HVRQWHVVHQWLHOOHPHQWOHVPRUSKqPHVGHUDSSHOGHqPHSHUVRQQHTXLpYROXHQW
YHUVXQIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHSURQRPORODPRUSKRORJLHSURQRPLQDOHVHUHQIRUoDQWSURJUHVVLYHPHQW

M<6<?/5F/%/5%4854%@A/%:1F8:3084315
/·H[SUHVVLRQGHODORFDOLVDWLRQVHGLYHUVLILDVHORQTX·LOV·DJLVVDLWG·XQHORFDOLVDWLRQSDUUpIpUHQFH FIFLGHVVXV
H[ RXQRQ'DQVOHSUHPLHUFDVGDQVODSKUDVHYHUEDOHHOOHHVWWUDLWpHFRPPHGpWHUPLQDWLIG·XQWHUPHQRPLQDO
VXEVWDQWLIRXSURQRP FRPSOpPHQWGXYHUEHO@
/RUVTX·XQWHUPHH[SULPHOHOLHXG·XQHDFWLRQVDIRQFWLRQHVWGpWHUPLQpHSDUXQpOpPHQWSODFpGHYDQWOH
YHUEHTXLFRPSRUWHXQHEDVH (+( HWXQUDSSHOGXJHQUHGHFHTXL\HVWORFDOLVp&HOLHXSHXWrWUHOHWKqPHGH
ODSKUDVHHWrWUHSODFpHQWrWH

([HPSOH

&HWpOpPHQWSHXWjOXLVHXOpYRTXHUXQWHUPHGHODSURSRVLWLRQSUpFpGHQWH TXHOOHTXHVRLWVDIRQFWLRQGDQV
FHWWHSUHPLqUHSURSRVLWLRQ HQWDQWTXHOLHXGXVHFRQGSURFqV

OR
&HWWHTXHVWLRQWUqVGpOLFDWHPpULWHXQHpWXGHSRXUHOOHPrPH >´WHµ@SOXU)1=1L)>´QRXVµ@)1>1L)>´YRXVµ@ 3DUH[HPSOHB(I#-#k(%
HOOHDMXVTX·jSUpVHQWpWpVXUWRXWWUDLWpHVHORQOHVVWUXFWXUHVH[LVWDQW 1L)%+()#Lk´1DSLULߖDP·DLPDµ1%)1L)%=1..(L+´PRLMHW·DLLPSORUpµ
GDQVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVHWVpPLWLTXHV O@
&I*ULOORW6XVLQL

%5FL7%>6%OqUH%JK%>6%:qPHSHUVRQQHVGHVIRUPHVPDUTXpHVG·´DFFXVDWLI µ
VRQWDWWHVWpHVWUqVW{WDYHFXQHPDUTXH) VLQJXOLHU%1L)>´PHµ@)1L)%
 oi.uchicago.edu

R<% FN,K8B38%A<NSK<BMN<S<*

([HPSOH

&15F:A0315
/DSUpVHQWDWLRQTXHMHYLHQVGHIDLUHHVWWUqVVFKpPDWLTXHHWQ·DTXHWUqVSHXSULVHQFRPSWHO·pYROXWLRQTXL
V·HVWSURGXLWHGDQVFHWWHVWUDWpJLHGXPDUTXDJHGHVDFWDQWVTXLUHSRVHVXUOHVpPDQWLVPHORUVTXHOHYHUEHHVWj
XQHIRUPHDFWLYHWUDQVLWLYH ´HUJDWLYHµ O·DQLPpHVWDJHQWO·LQDQLPpHVWSDWLHQW
1RWRQVVHXOHPHQWHQJXLVHGHFRQFOXVLRQTXHO·RQYRLWDSSDUDvWUHHQQpRpODPLWHYRLUHGpMjHQPpGLRpOD
PLWHGHVVXIIL[HVTXLPDUTXHQWGHVIRQFWLRQVF·HVWOHFDVG·XQHPDUTXHGHJpQLWLI)(NOPH[k(=%b1-(kM)(´OHILOV
GH&\UXVµ TXLV·RSSRVHjO·DQFLHQQHPDUTXHG·DSSDUWHQDQFHjXQJHQUHk(=%\>>()1)1L-(´ILOVGH8PPDQXQXµ 
HWGHORFDWLI>(RX#==# H[%0#'()% "/)k1k#)(=L)#L>(´GDQVOHWHPSOHGX GLHX ,QߖXߖLQDNµ@#--1>(-$#k%d%A("(LIL#==#%
d%01)=#L>!%+1I#--#%+1$$(Lk´&H3LUUXPDUWLߖH[HUoDODUR\DXWpFKH]OHV0qGHVµ
$LQVLO·pODPLWHVHPEOHELHQDYRLUpYROXpYHUVXQHH[SUHVVLRQGHVFDVSOXVUDSLGHPHQWGDQVODPRUSKRORJLHSUR
QRPLQDOH FIQRWH TXHGDQVFHOOHGHVVXEVWDQWLIV&HSHQGDQWWHOOHVQ·pWDLHQWSDVOHVVWUXFWXUHVIRQGDPHQWDOHV
GHODODQJXHHOOHVUHSRVDLHQWVXUO·RSSRVLWLRQDQLPp²LQDQLPpDUWLFXOpHDYHFO·RSSRVLWLRQVWDWLTXH²G\QDPLTXH'DQV
ODPHVXUHRFHWH[SRVpV·HVWOLPLWpDX[SKUDVHVGRQWOHYHUEHHVWjXQHIRUPHGHODFRQMXJDLVRQDFWLYHWUDQVLWLYH
FRQMXJDLVRQ, LOQHGRQQHTX·XQHYXHSDUWLHOOHOHVFDUDFWpULVWLTXHVGHFHVSKUDVHVHWODTXHVWLRQGHVPDUTXHV
VHFRPSUHQDQWHQRSSRVLWLRQDYHFFHOOHVGHVSKUDVHV´SDVVLYHVµHW´QRQHUJDWLYHVµ
0DLVGDQVO·pWXGHGHVFDVLOSRXYDLWrWUHLQWpUHVVDQWG·pYRTXHUXQDXWUHW\SHGHVWUDWpJLHGpILQLVVDQWOHV
IRQFWLRQVGHVFRQVWLWXDQWVGHODSKUDVH


 ODVWDWXHG· XQHGLYLQLWpHVWFRQVLGpUpHFRPPHDQLPpH
OP
&I*ULOORW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H87%3<7%8B%QN<A/*8[% RR

N3E:31I?82>3/
478>>FK2%)UDQoRLVH
  ´/DSRVWSRVLWLRQJpQLWLYH)(HQpODPLWHµ3(+#!-0%"!%.(%HU.U5($#6)%<-4+U6.65#X1!%F-()R(#0!%!)%/-()%QN%
²
*ULOORW6XVLQL2%)UDQoRLVH
  ´/HPpFDQLVPHGHVJURXSHVQRPLQDX[HQpODPLWHµP61-)(.%<0#($#X1!²
  Q.U>!)$0%"!%5-(>>(#-!%U.(>#$!6\QWKqVH3DULVeGLWLRQV5HFKHUFKHVXUOHV&LYLOLVDWLRQV
+LQ]:DOWKHUHW+HLGHPDULH.RFK
  8.(>#04+!0%J~-$!-&14+%HUOLQ'LHWULFK5HLPHU
.DPPHQKEHU$QHOLVH
  ´+LVWRULVFKJHRJUDSKLVFKH1DFKULFKWHQDXVGHUDOWKXUULWLVFKHQhEHUOLHIHUXQJGHP$OWHODPLVFKHQ
XQGGHQ,QVFKULIWHQGHU.|QLJHYRQ$NNDGIUGLH=HLWYRUGHP(LQIDOOGHU*XWlHU 4(² µ
<4$(%<)$#X1(%<4("!>#(!%74#!)$#(-1>%O1)5(-#4(!%²
.KDɥLNMDQ0DUJDUHW
  *+!%8.(>#$!%N()51(5!'RFXPHQWD$VLDQD5RPH,VWLWXWRSHUJOLVWXGL0LFHQHLHG(JHRDQDWROLFL
/DEDW5HQp
  ´6WUXFWXUHGHODODQJXHpODPLWHµ36):U-!)4!%"!%.;/)0$#$1$%"!%N#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
0DOEUDQ/DEDW)ORUHQFH
  ´$XWRXUGHV¶eOpPHQWVGHJUDPPDLUHpODPLWH·µS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
  ´6\VWqPHSURQRPLQDOHWV\VWqPHYHUEDOHQpODPLWHDFKpPpQLGHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%
"!%@(-#0²
5HLQHU(ULFD
  ´7KH(ODPLWH/DQJDJH%O()"&14+%"!-%,-#!)$(.#0$#=²
6WHLQHU*
  ´7KH,QWUDQVLWLYHSDVVLYDO&RQFHSWLRQRIWKH9HUELQ/DQJXDJHVRIWKH$QFLHQW1HDU(DVWµ'DQV8-M
5($#?#$'g%*69(-"0%(%*+!6-'%6:%D-(>>($#4(.%K!.($#6)0pGLWpSDU)3ODQNSS²/RQGUHV$FDGHPLF
3UHVV
6WROSHU0DWWKHZ:
  ´(ODPLWHµ'DQV*+!%3(>&-#"5!%8)4'4.6I!"#(%6:%$+!%J6-.";0%<)4#!)$%N()51(5!0pGLWpSDU5':RRGDUG
SS²&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
:LOKHOP*HUQRW
  ´,VWGLH(ODPLVFKHHLQH(UJDWLYVSUDFKH"µ<-4+a6.65#04+!%A#$$!#.1)5!)%(10%/-()QV²
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% QT,N\*/,B%H87%3<7%H<B7%N8%7QA/*/e\8%<K3O<Äe\8g%N<%3,B*K/S\*/,B%H8%N;QSN<Ä*8% R@

!
"#$%&'($)*+,-*./-*+/)-*%,*-"0('(1&,*/2.3/41&,5**
%/*.$)'2(6&'($)*+,*%7"6%/4',

@!.#6%F-6)G(-6.#2%\)#?!-0#$h%"#%F#-!)G!

%8*9:;<=<:>*?@*A7BCA8D=@
/DFODVVLILFDWLRQGHO·pEODwWHDVXVFLWpXQYLILQWpUrWGqVOHGpEXWGHVDGpFRXYHUWH4XHOTXHVXQVHVWLPqUHQW
SRXYRLUFRQVLGpUHUODQRXYHOOHODQJXHFRPPHDSSDUWHQDQWDXVpPLWLTXHRFFLGHQWDO 3HWWLQDWRIf'DKRRG
I XQHK\SRWKqVHTXLV·HVWDYpUpHSHXSODXVLEOHDXIXUHWjPHVXUHTXHVDPRUSKRORJLHDpWpPLHX[
FRQQXH%LHQTX·RQDLW%VRXOLJQpTXHODFODVVLILFDWLRQG·XQHODQJXHQHSHXWSDVrWUHIRQGpHVXUVRQOH[LTXH OHQFRUH
UpFHPPHQWRQDGpFULWO·pEODwWHGHODPDQLqUHVXLYDQWH´/·pEODwWH«HVWXQHODQJXHTXLSDUWDJHFHUWDLQVGHVHV
WUDLWVWDQW{WDYHFO·RXHVWVpPLWLTXHWDQW{WDYHFO·HVWVpPLWLTXH&·HVWOHFDVHQSDUWLFXOLHUGDQVOHYRFDEXODLUHµ
+DHOHZ\FN :
&·HVWjSDUWLUGHO·DIILQLWpGHODPRUSKRORJLHpEODwWHDYHFFHOOHGXVpPLWLTXHGHOD0pVRSRWDPLHTXHG·DXWUHV
RQWFRQVLGpUpODQRXYHOOHODQJXHFRPPHXQGLDOHFWHGHO·DNNDGLHQ HJ.UHEHUQLN´7KLVODQJXDJHLVVR
FORVHO\UHODWHGWR$NNDGLDQWKDWLWPD\EHFODVVLILHGDVDQHDUO\$NNDGLDQGLDOHFWµUpFHPPHQW(G]DUGH(0%
8&.(M<==("#04+!%(.0%*!#.%"!0%<.$(==("#04+!)%H#(.!=$=6)$#)11>0 XQHK\SRWKqVHTXLDpWpJpQpUDOHPHQWELHQDFFXHLOOLH
SDUOHVDVV\ULRORJXHV&HSHQGDQW2FHUWDLQHVLQQRYDWLRQVTXLHQFDUDFWpULVHQWODPRUSKRORJLH HWODOLEHUWpV\QWDF
WLTXHSURSUHDX[WH[WHVQDUUDWLIVHWSUHVFULSWLIV PHIRQWSUpIpUHUXQHFODVVLILFDWLRQPRLQVWUDQFKpHRO·pEODwWH
DSSDUDvWFRPPHXQHODQJXHSURFKHGHO·DNNDGLHQPDLVLQGpSHQGDQWHGHFHGHUQLHU )URQ]DUROL)URQ]DUROL
I 8QHFODVVLILFDWLRQGHFHW\SHDpWpUpFHPPHQWLQGLTXpHSDU+XHQHUJDUG ´(EODLWHDQG$N
NDGLDQVKRXOGEHFRQVLGHUHGVHSDUDWHFRRUGLQDWHEUDQFKHVRI(DVW6HPLWLFµ GHPrPHTXHSDU5XELRG·DSUqVTXL
´LWLVPRUHDFFXUDWHWRUHIHUWRWKH(DUO\(DVW6HPLWLFFRQWLQXXPDVLQFOXGLQJWZRPDMRUVHJPHQWV(EODLWHDQG
(DUO\'\QDVWLF$NNDGLDQµ 5XELR eWDQWGRQQpTXHODYDVWHDLUHOLQJXLVWLTXHROHVGHX[ODQJXHVpWDLHQW
SDUOpHVV·pWHQGDLWELHQDXGHOjGHOD0pVRSRWDPLHMHSUpIqUHO·LQGLTXHUFRPPHVpPLWLTXHDUFKDwTXH SOXW{WTXH
VpPLWLTXHRULHQWDO 

+@EF*;G;=HI@;*?@*J8;
/·pEODwWHFRPPHOHSDOpRDNNDGLHQFRQQDvWGHX[VpULHVGHWHUPLQDLVRQVSRXULQGLTXHUOHFDV/DSUHPLqUHVpULH
HVWFRQVWLWXpHSDUGHVGpVLQHQFHVV\QWKpWLTXHV FDVQRPEUH WURLVSRXUOHVLQJXOLHUHWGHX[SRXUOHGXHOHWOH
SOXULHO3RXUOHPDVFXOLQOHVWURLVFDVGXVLQJXOLHU FRQYHQWLRQQHOOHPHQWGpQRPPpVQRPLQDWLIJpQLWLIDFFXVDWLI 
VRQWH[SULPpVSDUOHVWURLVYR\HOOHVEUqYHVM12%M#2%M(/HVFDVGXSOXULHO QRPLQDWLIREOLTXH VRQWH[SULPpVSDUOHV
YR\HOOHVORQJXHVࡃ2%̒WҸQ/HVFDVGXGXHORQWOHVGpVLQHQFHVč2%M(' DNNDGLHQ̒ 3RXUOHIpPLQLQGXVLQJXOLHUHW
GXGXHORQSODFHO·DIIL[HM ( $DYDQWOHVGpVLQHQFHVGXPDVFXOLQSRXUH[SULPHUOHIpPLQLQGXSOXULHORQDOORQJH
ODYR\HOOHGHO·DIIL[HčW

O
'pMj*HOE´ZHPXVWUHFRJQL]HWKDWFHUWDLQOHYHOVKDYH
SUHFHGHQFHRYHURWKHUVJUDPPDURYHUOH[LFRQDQGZLWKLQJUDPPDU
PRUSKRORJ\RYHUSKRQRORJ\µ
:
+DHOHZ\FNTXLVXLWODFODVVLILFDWLRQGH/LSL‫ش‬VNL I FRQVL
GqUHO·pEODwWHFRPPHIDLVDQWSDUWLHG·XQJURXSH´3DOpRV\ULHQµ 
I 6XUODPrPHOLJQH*RUGRQGDQVXQDUWLFOHRHQJpQpUDOOHV
GRQQpHVH[SRVpHVQHVHPEOHQWSDVVXIILVDPPHQWPLVHVjMRXUDYDLW
GpILQLO·pEODwWHFRPPHXQHODQJXHIUDQTXHTXLFRPSUHQGGHVFDUDF
WqUHVRULHQWDX[HWRFFLGHQWDX[TXLQ·DXUDLWSDVpWpSDUOpHFRPPH
XQHODQJXHPDWHUQHOOH *RUGRQ² 
Q
(QSDOpRDNNDGLHQOHSOXUDOREOLTXHGXPDVFXOLQHVWH[SULPpSDU̒%
+DVVHOEDFKI (QFHTXLFRQFHUQHO·pEODwWHOHVOLPLWDWLRQV
GXV\VWqPHJUDSKLTXHQHSHUPHWWHQWSDVGHGLVWLQJXHUOHVYR\HOOHV
LҸGHVH̒RQQHSHXWGRQFSDVH[FOXUHQRQSOXVXQHOHFWXUH
̒HQpEODwWH

R@
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @8N/,%FK,Bt<K,N/

6LO·RQFRQVLGqUHFHV\VWqPHGDQVVRQHQVHPEOHLOUHVVRUWTXHOHVGpVLQHQFHVV\QWKpWLTXHVGXPDVFXOLQSRXU
UDLHQWrWUHO·DERXWLVVHPHQWG·XQV\VWqPHDQDO\WLTXHROHVpOpPHQWVVRQWHQFRUHHQSDUWLHUHFRQQDLVVDEOHV&H
SRLQWGHYXHDYDLWpWpGpYHORSSpSDU*HOE  TXLUpWDEOLVVDLWjWUDYHUVO·DQDO\VHVpTXHQWLHOOHXQSURWRDNNDGLHQ
SUpKLVWRULTXH/DUHFRQVWLWXWLRQSURSRVpHDXPR\HQGHO·DQDO\VHVpTXHQWLHOOHLQGLTXHHQLGHQWLILDQWODSRVLWLRQ
GDQVODVpTXHQFHO·DQWpULRULWpVWUXFWXUHOOHGXJHQUHHWGXQRPEUHSDUUDSSRUWDXFDV&RPPHWRXVOHVPRUSKqPHV
QHVRQWSDVLPPpGLDWHPHQWpYLGHQWVODUpJXODULWpIRUFpHGHODUHFRQVWLWXWLRQLGpDOHHVWREWHQXHjWUDYHUVODVXS
SRVLWLRQGHVWUXFWXUHVVRXVMDFHQWHV$LQVLSDUH[HPSOHGDQV=(.&Å1ÅNÅ1Åk1Å>(>WKqPHJHQUHQRPEUHFDVSURQRP
FRQMRQFWLRQ@´HWVHVFKLHQVµO·DWWHVWDWLRQNDOEࡃߖXPDV·H[SOLTXHSDUODFKXWHGHO·DIIL[H1%GXFDVQRPLQDWLI,O
HVWKRUVGHTXHVWLRQG·DIIURQWHULFLOHVGLIILFXOWpVTX·HQJHQGUHODGRXEOHYDOHXUGHO·DQDO\VH'·XQHSDUWHOOHHVW
SUpVHQWpHFRPPHWHQGDQWjODUHFRQVWLWXWLRQGHVWUXFWXUHVVRXVMDFHQWHVTXLSRXUUDLHQWrWUHFRQVLGpUpHVG·XQ
SRLQWGHYXHV\QFKURQLTXHG·DXWUHSDUWOHUpVXOWDWGHODUHFRQVWLWXWLRQHVWDSSHOp´SURWRDNNDGLHQµFRQVLGpUp
FRPPHXQHSKDVHSUpKLVWRULTXHGHODODQJXHH[DPLQpH</DUHFRQVWLWXWLRQSURSRVpHSDU*HOEHVWUHVWpHVDQVVXLWH
PDLVFHUWDLQHVGHVHVREVHUYDWLRQVVRQWSUREDEOHPHQWjUHWHQLU3RXUFHTXLHVWGHODPRUSKRORJLHGXQRP*HOE
FRQVLGpUDLWTXHOHV\VWqPHGHVFDVV·pWDLWGpYHORSSpSOXVWDUGSDUUDSSRUWDXV\VWqPHGXJHQUHHWGXQRPEUHLO
VRXOLJQDLWTXHOHGLSWRWLVPHGRPLQDLWFRPSOqWHPHQWODVWUXFWXUHGXFDVHWHQDIILUPDLWODSULRULWpFKURQRORJLTXH
SDUUDSSRUWDXWULSWRWLVPH
/HV\VWqPHDQDO\WLTXHGpFULWSOXVKDXWDSSDUDvW2GDQVOHVGHX[ODQJXHV2SOHLQHPHQWGpYHORSSp/HVHFRQG
V\VWqPHFDUDFWpULVpSDUGHVWHUPLQDLVRQVLQGLIIpUHQWHVDXJHQUHHWDXQRPEUHDSSDUDvWDXFRQWUDLUHFRPPH
XQV\VWqPHHQYRLHG·pSXLVHPHQWGRQWOHVODQJXHVSRVWpULHXUHVFRQVHUYHQWVHXOHPHQWGHVWUDFHV.LHQDVW 
IL FODVVLILHFRPPHWHUPLQDLVRQVGHFDVOHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVVXLYDQWHV
% #J7M8H6K8G% Kč2%čK
% 36K8G% % M#k
 $FFXVDWLI M$#2%M($$(
 /RFDWLI  ࡃ1
0DLVFHVRQWVXUWRXWOHVWHUPLQDLVRQVM#k2%M1ELHQDWWHVWpHVHQpEODwWHHWHQDNNDGLHQTXLRQWpWpIUpTXHP
PHQWFRQVLGpUpHV2QSHXWYRLUSDUH[HPSOHO·RSLQLRQWUqVSUXGHQWHGH+XHKQHUJDUGHWGH%:RRGV 
† ´,WLVQRWFOHDUZKHWKHUWKHWHUPLQDWLYHDQGWKHORFDWLYHUHSUHVHQWYHVWLJLDOFDVHPDUNHUVRUDGYHUELDO
IRUPDWLYHVµ2UVLO·RQDGPHWTXHOHVGHX[VXIIL[HVVRQWGHVWHUPLQDLVRQVGHFDVUpVLGXHOOHVODFRwQFLGHQFH%GHOD
WHUPLQDLVRQGXQRPLQDWLI M1 DYHFFHOOHGX´ORFDWLI µRXYUHODSRVVLELOLWpG·XQHK\SRWKqVHHUJDWLYHjO·RULJLQHGX
V\VWqPHIOH[LRQQHOVpPLWLTXH

%7KG9:=KH;@*@LM8=<N@
/·K\SRWKqVHHUJDWLYHpPLVHjSOXVLHXUVUHSULVHVSDUH[HPSOHSDU'LDNRQRII I DpWpSURSR
VpHjQRXYHDXUpFHPPHQWSDU.LHQDVW IL HW/LSL‫ش‬VNL ² 'HVVL[FDUDFWpULVWLTXHVGXVpPLWLTXH
pQXPpUpHVSDU/LSL‫ش‬VNLHQIDYHXUG·XQHVWUXFWXUHHUJDWLYHGXSURWRVpPLWLTXHTXDWUHFRQFHUQHQWODPRUSKRORJLH
HWODV\QWD[HGXFDV&HVRQWOHVVXLYDQWHV  ODFRwQFLGHQFHGHODWHUPLQDLVRQGXQRPLQDWLI M1 % DYHFFHOOHGH
O·´LQVWUXPHQWDOµ DSSHOp´ORFDWLI µHQDVV\ULRORJLH   ODIRQFWLRQGXFDVQRQDFWLIHQ(GDQVOHVSKUDVHVYHUEDOHV
LQWUDQVLWLYHVHWGDQVOHVSKUDVHVQRPLQDOHV  O·XVDJHGHM(SRXUGpVLJQHUO·pWDWFRQVWUXLWGXQRP  O·H[LVWHQFH
G·XQHIRUPHDEVROXHGXQRPTXLjO·RULJLQHFRUUHVSRQGDLWDXFDVHQM(  R/HVGHX[FKHUFKHXUVHW/LSL‫ش‬VNL
HQSDUWLFXOLHURQWFLWpSRXUpWD\HUOHXUVSURSRVLWLRQVTXHOTXHVDWWHVWDWLRQVSURYHQDQWGHWH[WHVpEODwWHV,O
VHPEOHGRQFRSSRUWXQG·HVVD\HUGHYpULILHUOHVDUJXPHQWDWLRQVSURSRVpHVDXVXMHWGHODGRFXPHQWDWLRQpEODwWH
GRQWO·LQWpUrWHVWpYLGHQWWDQWSRXUVRQFDUDFWqUHDUFKDwTXHTXHSRXUVRQDPSOHXU2QVHFRQWHQWHUDLFLG·H[D
PLQHUOHVDWWHVWDWLRQVTXLSRXUUDLHQWIRXUQLUGHVDUJXPHQWVVXSSOpPHQWDLUHV SDUUDSSRUWDXSDOpRDNNDGLHQ HQ
IDYHXUGHO·K\SRWKqVHHUJDWLYH

<
*HOE ;, SUpFLVHTX·LODDSSHOp´SURWRDNNDGLHQµOHV\VWqPH
UHFRQVWLWXpSDUFHTXHODGRFXPHQWDWLRQXWLOLVpHHVWSULQFLSDOHPHQW
DNNDGLHQQHHWSDUFHTXHGDQVFHUWDLQVFDVLOHVWGLIILFLOHG·LGHQWLILHU
FHUWDLQVFDUDFWqUHVSURWRDNNDGLHQVFRPPHpWDQWSURWRVpPLWLTXHV
7RXWHIRLVLQGpSHQGDPPHQWGHFHVUpVHUYHVLODSSDUDvWLPSOLFLWH
WRXWDXORQJGHFHWUDYDLOTXHOHSURWRDNNDGLHQUHFRQVWLWXppTXLYDXW
jXQSURWRVpPLWLTXH
R
/HVGHX[DXWUHVFDUDFWpULVWLTXHV O·XVDJHG·DIIL[HVSURQRPLQDX[
GXYHUEHVHUpIpUDQWQRQVHXOHPHQWjO·´DJHQWµPDLVpJDOHPHQWjOD
FRPSRVDQWHQRQDFWLYHGHODSKUDVHHWO·DEVHQFHG·XQHIRUPHSDVVLYH
VpPLWLTXHFRPPXQH VRQWDWWHVWpHVDXVVLHQpEODwWHHWLOQ·HVWSDV
QpFHVVDLUHGHV·\DWWDUGHULFL
 oi.uchicago.edu

% QT,N\*/,B%H87%3<7%H<B7%N8%7QA/*/e\8%<K3O<Äe\8g%N<%3,B*K/S\*/,B%H8%N;QSN<Ä*8% RP

/==@;=8=<:>;*?7@LM8=<OP
/LSL‫ش‬VNLSHQVHTXHGDQVOHVWH[WHVULWXHOVpEODwWHVLOHVWSRVVLEOHGHWURXYHUWUDFHGHFDVHUJDWLIVHQ1DSUqV
XQHSUpSRVLWLRQHWDSUqVXQQRPUpJLVVDQW OjRO·RQDWWHQGUDLWXQJpQLWLI GHPrPHTX·DSUqVXQHIRUPHYHUEDOH
D\DQWXQHYDOHXULQVWUXPHQWDOH  IL ,OHVWGLIILFLOHFHSHQGDQWG·rWUHG·DFFRUGDYHFOHVWpPRLJQDJHVTX·LO
SURGXLW
&(%W%WL૟jPDGXQHSHXWrWUHLQWHUSUpWpFRPPHPčWLKčPDWX´O·HDXGHODPHUµ/DJUDSKLH&(%QHUHQGMDPDLV
PDGDQVOHVWH[WHVpEODwWHVDORUVTXHODOLVWHOH[LFDOHELOLQJXHDOHVJUDSKLHV>(M91 $% PčZࡃ´HDXµ YDU
>(M1P'Pč\ࡃ 3DUFRQWUHOHVWH[WHVpEODwWHVFRQQDLVVHQWODJUDSKLH&(FRPPHDGYHUEHGHOLHXSčRX
SDZ´LFLµ )URQ]DUROL (QRXWUHODOLVWHOH[LFDOHELOLQJXHSRVVqGHGHX[JORVHVFRPSDUDEOHVDYHFWL૟jPDGXN%
WL૟jPDWXP DEDJ WLKčPDWXP´PHUµHWWL૟jPDWXP QtJOXOX' WLOєDP D WXP´IRXUPLOOHPHQWµ
/DJORVHGXVHFRQGVXPpURJUDPPHHVWVDQVDXFXQGRXWHDSSOLFDEOHDXFRQWH[WHTXLVHUpIqUHjGHVVHUSHQWVD\DQW
SULVSRVVHVVLRQGXSD\V&(Mk(M)1%W%&(%W%WL૟jPDGXਧ()਩M)(%´9UDLPHQWOHVVHUSHQWVIRXUPLOOHQWLFLµ )URQ]DUROL
:??QDN%P@2%PPGL 
0#M#)%W%/M.#M.1´SRXU(QOLOµp/M.#M.1´ODPDLVRQGH(QOLOµFHVGHX[DWWHVWDWLRQVQHSURXYHQWDXFXQHPHQWO·HP
SORLG·XQHWHUPLQDLVRQHQM1Oj%RO·RQV·DWWHQGUDLWjXQJpQLWLIpWDQWGRQQpTX·jeEODOHVQRPVGLYLQVWUDQVFULWV
SKRQpWLTXHPHQWQHVRQWSDVGpFOLQpV,OVXIILWGHVHUpIpUHUSDUH[HPSOHjXQWH[WHVRLJQpFRPPHOHULWXHOUR\DO
jO·RFFDVLRQGHVQRFHVGXURL<LࠂТDU'DPX~LO0#M#)%W%4*\JtJLUVXPG<M)#M.1´LOVSRUWHQWYHUVOHFKDU ODVWDWXH
GXGLHX $QLUµ $5(7;,ਧ~਩LO>0#M#)@ 4*\JtJLUVXP G<M)#M#-2%$5(7;, /DJUDSKLH/M.#M.1GHYUDGRQF
rWUHLQWHUSUpWpHFRPPH,OOLORX(OOLOHWODJUDSKLH<M)#M.1FRPPH$QLUHQWRWDODFFRUGDYHFOHVQRUPHVGHV
VFULEHVpEODwWHV
LQD૟jiߖ%W%QD૟jVX%W%/M.#M.16LFHSDVVDJHGHYDLWrWUHFRPSULVFRPPH´KHZLOOFHUWDLQO\UHFRYHUWKDQNVWR(QOLOµ
/LSL‫ش‬VNL QRXVDXULRQVXQHDWWHVWDWLRQGHODWHUPLQDLVRQM1 > jYDOHXULQVWUXPHQWDOHXQHIRQFWLRQTXLSRXUUDLW
UHPRQWHUjXQHYDOHXUHUJDWLYH0DLVFRPPHQRXVO·DYRQVYXODJUDSKLHGXQRPGLYLQQ·HQDWWHVWHSDVODWHUPL
QDLVRQPDLVVHXOHPHQWODFRQVRQQHILQDOH'HSOXVGDQVOHFRQWH[WHGXP\WKHGHODFRQVWUXFWLRQGHODPDLVRQGH
(QOLOOHSDVVDJHSRXUUDLWSHXWrWUHrWUHPLHX[LQWHUSUpWpFRPPH´LOYLYUDODYLHGH(QOLOµ )URQ]DUROL 

%8*=@LI<>8<;:>*!"Q#R
3RXUFHTXLHVWGHO·XWLOLVDWLRQGXVXIIL[HM1 > %GDQVOHVWH[WHVDGPLQLVWUDWLIVO·XVDJHGHJUDSKLHVORJRJUD
SKLTXHVHPSrFKHGHFRPSUHQGUHV·LOpWDLWXWLOLVpSRXULQGLTXHUO·REMHWRXODSHUVRQQHGHVWLQDWDLUHVG·XQHDWWULEX
WLRQ$FHVXMHW/LSL‫ش‬VNLFRQVLGqUHTXHODJUDSKLH>(MG(M.1>M0Ç%YHXWLQGLTXHUOHVXIIL[HLQVWUXPHQWDOM1>%VXLYLGX
VXIIL[HSURQRPLQDO% ´IRUZLWKLWVKLVPHVVHQJHUµ FRPPHGDQVO·DNNDGLHQߙXSUDQXߖߖXߙXSUčQXPߖX ´ZLWKKLV
FODZVµ  /LSL‫ش‬VNL %/RUVTXHOHVJUDSKLHVHQM1 > DSSDUDLVVHQWGDQVGHVFRQWH[WHVRHOOHVVRQWSUpFpGpHV
SDUGHVTXDQWLWpVGHPpWDX[RQSRXUUDLWSHQVHUjXQVHQVWHOTXH´SRXUVDGpFRUDWLRQµ G#M"1M0Ç ´SRXUVRQEUD
FHOHWµ 5wM.#M.1>M0Ç RXG·DXWUHVH[SUHVVLRQVGXPrPHJHQUHPDLVOHVSDUDJUDSKHVG·DWWULEXWLRQGHELHQVFRQWHQXV
GDQVOHVGHX[ULWXHOVTXLUDFRQWHQWOHVQRFHVUR\DOHVHWTXLSHXYHQWrWUHFRQVLGpUpVFRPPHUHSUpVHQWDWLIVG·XQ
PRGqOHQRUPDWLIPHWWHQWJUDYHPHQWHQGRXWHO·K\SRWKqVHGH/LSL‫ش‬VNLVXUO·HPSORLGXVXIIL[HM1>%DYHFYDOHXU
´LQVWUXPHQWDOHµGDQVOHVWH[WHVDGPLQLVWUDWLIV(QHIIHWGDQVFHFDVRQDGHVJUDSKLHVHQ1 > SRXULQGLTXHU
GHVREMHWVRIIHUWVSDUODUHLQHGRQFGHVORJRJUDPPHVVpPLWLTXHVSRXUOHVTXHOVODODQJXHUHTXLHUWXQDFFXVDWLIHW
O·HPSORLGXVXIIL[H#k%SRXUHQLQGLTXHUODGHVWLQDWLRQ/HPrPHVXIIL[HM#kHVWHPSOR\pRFFDVLRQQHOOHPHQWGDQV
XQHIRQFWLRQDQDORJXHDXVVLGDQVOHVWH[WHVDGPLQLVWUDWLIV0#M5#M#k ߖLNNLߖ ´SRXUODSRLQWH G·XQHODQFH µRX
>(M"(M-ÉM#k PDࠃULߖ ´SRXUODEDQGH RXODFRUGH µTXLDOWHUQHDYHFGHVJUDSKLHVGXVLQJXOLHUHWGXGXHOVDQV
DXFXQHSUpSRVLWLRQQLDXFXQVXIIL[H>(M"(M.1>2%>(M"(M-( PDࠃUXPPDࠃUč Q  HQIRQFWLRQORJRJUDSKLTXH@


(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHOHVHQWUpHVGHODOLVWHOH[LFDOHELOLQJXHOHVVLJOHV 3RXUODGRFXPHQWDWLRQHWSRXUO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGH PDࠃUYRLU&RQWL
@%

$%&'$:IRQWUpIpUHQFHDX[VRXUFHVGHODOLVWHHOOHPrPH $UFKL ² 

 OHVVLJOHVHQOHWWUHVPLQXVFXOHVIRQWUpIpUHQFHDX[H[WUDLWV
VHORQO·pGLWLRQSUpOLPLQDLUHGH3HWWLQDWR ² 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @8N/,%FK,Bt<K,N/

"=8=*J:>;=LE<=*@>*!$
/LSL‫ش‬VNL  SHQVHTXHGDQVXQWH[WHULWXHOpEODwWHHVWDWWHVWpHXQHIRUPHG·pWDWFRQVWUXLWWHUPLQDQWSDU
M(PDLVFRPPH&RQWLO·DPRQWUpO·pEODwWHGDQVODIRUPHGHO·pWDWFRQVWUXLWVXLWOHVPrPHVQRUPHVTXHO·DNNDGLHQ
&RQWL² /HVTXHOTXHVFDVVH%KJ7M8H6HK%6==67JMMJHK%=67%M & (%WURXYHQWWRXVXQHH[SOLFDWLRQSODXVLEOH
GDQVO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQpW\PRORJLTXH HJG(M-(%&(M$#>ߙDUDєED\WLP´SDUWLHKDXWHGHODPDLVRQµ HWRXGDQVOHV
UqJOHVG·XVDJHGXV\OODEDLUH HJ5(M(NDO´ODWRWDOLWpGHµ 

SA:;@;*BCA8D=@;*@>*!$*?8>;*A8*A<;=@*A@F<J8A@*C<A<>ME@
/DOLVWHOH[LFDOHELOLQJXHPFRQVHUYHGHVJORVHVVHWHUPLQDQWHQM(TXLDOWHUQHQWSRXUOHPrPHVXPpURJUDPPH
DYHFGHVJORVHVHQM1>&HVJORVHVDYDLHQWpWpLQWHUSUpWpHVFRPPHGHVIRUPHVGHGXHODYHFYDOHXUG·DEVWUDLWO?%
7RXWHIRLV.LHQDVW  DREVHUYpTXHGDQVOHVODQJXHVVpPLWLTXHVOHGXHOHVWXWLOLVpVHXOHPHQW
GDQVVRQVHQVVSpFLILTXHMDPDLVDYHFXQHYDOHXUG·DEVWUDLW&·HVWSRXUTXRLLODVXJJpUpTXHFHVJORVHVpWDLHQWDX
FRQWUDLUHGHVDWWHVWDWLRQVG·´pWDWGpWHUPLQpµjLQWHUSUpWHUFRPPHč FRPPHO·pWDW%HPSKDWLTXHGHO·DUDPpHQ 
,OFRQYLHQWGRQFG·H[DPLQHUOHVJORVHVHQTXHVWLRQ
>(M&(M"(M-( $ >>@(MZ&(@M"(M.( % >(M&(M"(M.1> &  JLߖVDђDU,,
/DSUpVHQFHGXQXPpUDO´GHX[µ ,, GDQVOHVXPpURJUDPPHUHQGWUqVSUREDEOHTXHOHVJUDSKLHVHQ(%GHV
GHX[VRXUFHV$HW%LQGLTXHQWXQGXHO .UHFKHU /HVXPpURJUDPPHDpWpH[SOLTXpSDU6M|EHUJ E
 FRPPHpWDQWXQHIRUPHDEUpJpHGHJLߖVDђDUJL< JLJLU ´UXQQLQJERDUGGXVWJXDUG RIDFKDULRW µ DNNDGLHQ
0(+઄ DUJ€ /HVJORVHVDXGXHOSRXUUDLHQWGRQFLQGLTXHUOHVGHX[SODQFKHVD\DQWIRQFWLRQGHSDUHSRXVVLqUHGLVSRVpHV
GHVGHX[F{WpVGXFKDUSUREDEOHPHQWGXVpP &$-´FRXSHUµGRQFPDEWDUč Q PDEWDUXPOO
'HPrPHOHVJORVHVHQM(%GHJGLPGLPSHXYHQWVHUpIpUHUjXQYpULWDEOHGXHOVLj(EODOHVXPpURJUDPPH
SRXYDLWDSSDUWHQLUSDUH[HPSOHDXOH[LTXHGHVSDUWLHVGXFRUSVHWLQGLTXHU´OHV GHX[ FRUGHVYRFDOHVµ FRPPH
PHOHVXJJqUH0%RQHFKL 
+઄ 1M&(M-( $& %+઄ 1M&(M.1> '  JGLPGLP
/HVJORVHVLQWHUSUpWDEOHVFRPPHђXEUXP2ђXEUč Q  RXPrPHFRPPHђXEčUXPђXEčUč Q VHORQ
XQVFKqPHXWLOLVpSRXUIRUPHUGHVDGMHFWLIVVXEVWDQWLYpV SHXYHQWGpULYHUGXYHUEH +઄ &-´rWUHEUX\DQWµDWWHVWp
HQDNNDGLHQ &LYLO&RQWL6M|EHUJD O:
/DJORVHG·XQH[WUDLWGHODOLVWHOH[LFDOHELOLQJXHUHTXLHUWXQHWRXWHDXWUHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQ
Z(M5@wjM.1M1> D (M51.M.(% E  uN~ 
/HVXPpURJUDPPHVXJJqUHTXHOHVGHX[JORVHVGpULYHQWGXVpP ૟NO´PDQJHUµ .UHEHUQLN&LYLO
 (OOHVSHXYHQWrWUHLQWHUSUpWpHVFRPPH ૟DNXOOč૟XP´SURYLVLRQVµFRPSDUDEOHjO·DNNDGLHQXNXOO€PPpGLRDV
9E78JHHJ%XNXOOč૟XQpRDVV\ULHQQHDNXOO€SRXUOHSDOpRDNNDGLHQRQVHUpIqUHUDjwM=w.M.(MÑM01´VDSURYLVLRQµ 0$'
9 /DJORVHGHO·H[WUDLWDUHQGXODIRUPHDYHFOHVXIIL[HFRQWUDFWp>૟DNXOOࡃP@ODJORVHGHESHXWrWUHXQH
JUDSKLHLQFRPSOqWHGHODIRUPHQRQFRQWUDFWpH(M51.M.(vM1>Ö
­F{WpGHFHVJORVHVROHVIRUPHVHQM(DOWHUQHQWDYHFOHVIRUPHVHQ1>UHVWHQWFHOOHVGHGHX[VXPpUR
JUDPPHVROHVVRXUFHVGRQQHQWVHXOHPHQWGHVJORVHVHQM(N
"(M.(MG( $%  iH4*<4*< $!M-(MG( '  iHWDђ
PDU૟DsMG( $ >(-M(MG( %&  iHWDђ >(-M(MG( '  iH4*<4*< OQ


(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHO·DWWHVWDWLRQGH&(%W%WL૟jPDGX2%FH%9J%7J=F7KJ76%
jFHTXLHQDpWpGLWSOXVKDXWjODS
P
3RXUOHVVLJOHVTXLVHUpIqUHQWDX[VRXUFHVHWDX[H[WUDLWVGHODOLVWH
OH[LFDOHELOLQJXHYRLUSOXVKDXWjODQ
O?
&·HVWOHFDVGH.UHEHUQLN Q VHUpIpUDQWj"(M.(MG(2%>(-M
(MG(2%PDEDGD૟jHWj%OHXUVYDULDQWHV
OO%
4XDQWjOHXULQWHUSUpWDWLRQ6M|EHUJDUDSSHOpO·DUDP &"-%´Up
SDQGUHGLVSHUVHUµ0DLVOHYHUEHDUDPpHQTXLSURORQJHXQVpP EˁU
´GLVSHUVHUµ FRPPHOHYHXOHQWO·KpEUDwTXH%IG-%JK%O·DUDELTXHEˁU QH
FRUUHVSRQGSDVjODJUDSKLHpEODwWHTXLUHQGDLWOHVLQWHUGHQWDOHVˁ2%
ࠂDYHFOHVVLJQHVGHODVpULH\!
O:
%1F87%6L998%+઄(M+઄(M)(M$1> JpGLPGLP' LQWHUSUpWpSDU6M|EHUJ
DFRQWUD&RQWL FRPPHђDQђDQDWXPjFRP
SDUHUDYHFDU+઄()+઄()(´QDVLOOHUSDUOHUGXQH]µ
OQ
/DVRXUFH'GHODOLVWHOH[LFDOHELOLQJXHLQWHUYHUWLWODSRVLWLRQGHV
JORVHVGHVGHX[VXPpURJUDPPHVSDUUDSSRUWDX[DXWUHVVRXUFHV%LHQ
TXHODVRXUFH'VRLWODSOXVDQFLHQQHLOHVWSUREDEOHTXHFHVRQWOHV
VRXUFHVOHVSOXVUpFHQWHVTXLGRQQHQWODFRUUHVSRQGDQFHH[DFWHGHV
JORVHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% QT,N\*/,B%H87%3<7%H<B7%N8%7QA/*/e\8%<K3O<Äe\8g%N<%3,B*K/S\*/,B%H8%N;QSN<Ä*8% 

/DIRUPHGXVXPpURJUDPPHiH4*<4*<HVWSDUDOOqOHjFHOOHGHiHWDђTXLSHXWrWUHLQWHUSUpWpFRPPH´DMRX
WHUGHODIRUFHDLGHUµ WDђ DNNDGLHQZDߙčEXP´DMRXWHUµ O<,OHVWSRVVLEOHDORUVTXH 4*<4*<DLWpWpXWLOLVpLFLDYHF
ODYDOHXUGHJLO 4*^4* XQVXPpURJUDPPHpTXLYDOHQWjO·DNNDGLHQHJ̒UX´HQWUHODFHUµHWTXH´HQWUHODFHUOHVEUDVµ
DLWpWpFRPSULVSDUOHVVFULEHVFRPPH´XQLUOHVIRUFHVV·HQWUDLGHUµ/DJORVHpEODwWH"(M.(MG(HWVDYDULDQWH$!M-(MG(%
GHODVRXUFH'SHXYHQWrWUHLQWHUSUpWpHVFRPPHXQQRPG·DFWLRQDYHF$MSUpIL[HWDєUčߙWHєUčߙ FI&RQWL
ILDYHFELEOLRJUDSKLH (QDNNDGLHQOHVFKqPHWDčIRXUQLWGHVQRPVG·DFWLRQSRXUOHWKqPHYHUEDO
UpFLSURTXHW6LHQpEODwWHOHVFKqPHDYDLWHXODPrPHYDOHXUOHQRPG·DFWLRQDXUDLWSXVLJQLILHU´O·DFWLRQGHVH
YHQLUHQDLGHµ/DJORVHWDєUčߙVHUDLWGRQFDSSURSULpHSDUUDSSRUWDXVXPpURJUDPPHiH 4*<4*<%JK%>6%KJ7M8H689FH%
GXGXHOSRXUUDLWVHMXVWLILHUjSDUWLUGXVHQVG·DFWLRQUpFLSURTXH
&RPPHpTXLYDOHQWGHODIRUPHYHUEDOHVXPpULHQQHiHWDђjODSODFHGHODTXHOOHRQDWWHQGUDLWXQQRPYHU
EDOpEODwWHOHVVFULEHVRQWFKRLVLODJORVHPDU૟DsMG( HWVHVYDULDQWHV LQWHUSUpWDEOHFRPPHPDUєDߙ´DLGHµ FI
"FHK8%OPP?N%ORRGLDYHFELEOLRJUDSKLH 6LODJUDSKLHHQM(GHPDU૟DsMG(LQGLTXHXQGXHOFHODSRXUUDLWSHXWrWUHVH
MXVWLILHUSDUDQDORJLHDYHFODJUDSKLHGH"(M.(MG(
/·LQWHQWLRQGHVRXOLJQHUOHVHQVG·DFWLRQUpFLSURTXHSRXUUDLWSHXWrWUHMXVWLILHUDXVVLODJUDSKLHHQM(GHV
JORVHVVXLYDQWHV
PDEDGD૟j $ >(M&(M"(M( % >(M&(M"(M1P '  JLߖ*,߰.,0WL
/HVXPpURJUDPPHHWODUDFLQH EࠃєUpFODPHQWXQHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQPDEࠃDє´FRQILDQFHµFRPSDUDEOHjO·KpEU
PLEࠃčє .UHEHUQLN 
(QFRQFOXVLRQOHVJORVHVTXLDYDLHQWpWpLQGLTXpHVSDU.LHQDVWFRPPHGHVDWWHVWDWLRQVG·´pWDWGpWHUPLQpµ
SHXYHQWrWUHGHVGXHOVjWRXVOHVHIIHWV6LTXHOTXHVXQHVG·HQWUHHOOHVFRPPHPDEDGD૟jSRXYDLHQWrWUHH[SOL
TXpHVFRPPHGHVIRUPHVG·´pWDWGpWHUPLQpµLOUHVWHUDLWjVHGHPDQGHUSRXUTXRLFHWWHWHUPLQDLVRQDpWpFRQVHUYpH
GDQVXQRXGHX[PRWVVXUOHVHQYLURQFRQWHQXVGDQVODOLVWHOH[LFDOHELOLQJXH

TLB9:;<=<:>;*U*;EOO<F@*V"Q#R
­ODOXPLqUHGHFHTXHQRXVYHQRQVG·REVHUYHULOV·DYqUHTXHOHVDWWHVWDWLRQVpEODwWHVFLWpHVSDU.LHQDVWHW
/LSL‫ش‬VNLQHVRQWSDVHQPHVXUHGHIRXUQLUGHVDUJXPHQWVVXSSOpPHQWDLUHV SDUUDSSRUWDXSDOpRDNNDGLHQ HQ
IDYHXUGHO·K\SRWKqVHHUJDWLYH$XFRQWUDLUHODFRQWULEXWLRQODSOXVLQWpUHVVDQWHGHO·pEODwWHHQIDYHXUGHO·K\SR
WKqVHHUJDWLYHSRXUUDLWrWUHO·DWWHVWDWLRQG·XQHDQFLHQQHYDOHXULQVWUXPHQWDOHGHODWHUPLQDLVRQM1 > jO·RULJLQH
GHODIRUPDWLRQG·DGYHUEHVHWGHSUpSRVLWLRQVDXVVLELHQHQDNNDGLHQTX·HQpEODwWH&RQVLGpURQVOHVSUpSRVLWLRQV
pEODwWHViߖGX% YDUiߖWXP ´GHµ YDOHXUDEODWLYH &(M.1M´VDQVµ>#M)1´GHµ YDOHXUSDUWLWLYHHWYDOHXUDEODWLYH OR%
/HXUIRUPDWLRQSRXUUDLWrWUHUHFRQGXLWHjODYDOHXU´ORFDWLYHµGHODWHUPLQDLVRQ 9(k$M1>´ DXPLOLHXGHµFI
DUZDVDࠃ2%ZDVࠃ´PLOLHXFHQWUHµJH·H]Z̾Vࠃ´SDUWLHLQWpULHXUHµ &(.M1>´GDQVO·LQH[LVWHQFHGHµ PҸQXP´GDQVOH
PRQWDQWGHµFI >)9W'´FRPSWHUµ 0DLVFHWWHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQQHV·DFFRUGHSDVDYHFOHIDLWTXH(kM"1%JK%>#M)1%FHK%
XQHYDOHXUDEODWLYH ´GHµ HWQRQXQHYDOHXUORFDWLYH ´GDQVµ /·pEODwWHRIIUHXQpOpPHQWXOWpULHXUGHMXJHPHQW
GDQVO·DWWHVWDWLRQGDQVOHVPrPHVWH[WHVG·XQHJUDSKLH>#M#)TXLVLJQLILH´GDQVµ7RXWHIRLVODJUDSKLHpEODwWH
FRQVWDQWHPLLQ´GDQVµYLVjYLVGH>#M)1%´GHµO@QHQRXVREOLJHSDVjDGPHWWUHTX·LOV·DJLWGHGHX[pW\PRQVGLI
IpUHQWVPDLVRSSRVHXQHIRUPHG·pWDWFRQVWUXLW PҸQjXQHIRUPHjWHUPLQDLVRQM1 > 2QQRWHUDTXHODIRUPHj
VXIIL[HM1 > SUpWHQGX´ORFDWLIµHVWDXFRQWUDLUHFHOOHTXLDXQHYDOHXUSDUWLWLYHHWDEODWLYH&HFLVHPEOHVXJJpUHU
TXHOHVXIIL[HM1 > DHXYUDLPHQWXQHYDOHXUSULPDLUH´LQVWUXPHQWDOHµFRPPHO·H[LJHO·K\SRWKqVHHUJDWLYH'RQF
U>M)M1>´jSDUWLUGXPRQWDQWGHµ´DXPR\HQGHµ´GHµ 9(k$M1>´jSDUWLUGXPLOLHXGHµHWFOP

O<
/DJUDSKLHᇀᇹ<ᇀᇹ<GHYUDLWGRQFUHSUpVHQWHUXQYHUEHUpIpUpj´EUDV
IRUFHµ VXPpULHQQHi ­WUDYHUVO·pTXLYDOHQFH0(M)(´VDQGDOHV GX µ
 Jᇀᇹ<^ᇀᇹ<VRXUFH႐: ODOLVWHOH[LFDOHELOLQJXHVXJJqUHSRXUᇀᇹ<^ᇀᇹ<%
pFULWDXVVLᇀᇹ<ᇀᇹ< ODOHFWXUHHVLUR&HFLQHSHXWrWUHODYDOHXUGHOD
JUDSKLHGDQVQRWUHVXPpURJUDPPHRLOHVWGHPDQGpXQHYDOHXU
YHUEDOH
OR%
3RXUODYDOHXUSDUWLWLYHGH>#M)1YRLU$5(7;,,,´GHVRQPLHOOD
PRLWLp«LOGRQQHUDµ )URQ]DUROLD OHVHQVSDUWLWLIRULJLQHO
GHFHWWHSUpSRVLWLRQpWDLWGpMjDGPLVSDU%URFNHOPDQQ²,
<P@GL

9RLUHJ)URQ]DUROLIVY
O@
/DSUpSRVLWLRQ>#M)1Q·DMDPDLVOHVHQVORFDWLI´jHQµFRPPHMH
O·DYDLVFUXSRVVLEOH )URQ]DUROLVY>#M)1 /HVDWWHV
WDWLRQV DYHF OHV QRPV JpRJUDSKLTXHV TX·RQ SHXW REVHUYHU GDQV
$5(7¬;,VHURQWPLHX[LQWHUSUpWpHVSDUOHVHQVDEODWLI´GHµ 7R
QLHWWL 

/LSL‫ش‬VNL  SHQVHj &#M#)%X%>#M#)
OP
3RXUODYDOHXUORFDWLYHGH PҸQRQSRXUUDFRPSDUHUO·HPSORLGH
>#)2%DWWHVWpGDQVTXHOTXHVODQJXHVVpPLWLTXHVRFFLGHQWDOHVSRXU
LQGLTXHUOHPRPHQWRXODSpULRGHRO·DFWLRQV·DFFRPSOLW VLJQLILFD
WLRQVGpULYpHVGHODYDOHXUSDUWLWLYHRULJLQHOOHVHORQ%URFNHOPDQQ
²,,††HɘIǓ 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @8N/,%FK,Bt<K,N/

.:>JAE;<:>;
/·pYDOXDWLRQGHVJUDSKLHVpEODwWHVUHTXLHUWFRPPHQRXVO·DYRQVYXODFRQQDLVVDQFHGHVKDELWXGHVGHVVFULEHV
3DUH[HPSOHO·HPSORLLQWHUPLWWHQWGHODPLPDWLRQ GDQVODIOH[LRQGXVLQJXOLHUHWGXSOXULHO HWFHOXLGHODQXQD
WLRQ GDQVODIOH[LRQGXGXHO GRLWrWUHIDLWUHPRQWHUjFHVKDELWXGHVSOXW{WTX·jOHXULQWURGXFWLRQUpFHQWHGDQV
O·XVDJHOLQJXLVWLTXH(QWRXWFDVO·HPSORLLQWHUPLWWHQWSRXUUDLWVXJJpUHUODSHUWHGHODPLPDWLRQHWGHODQXQDWLRQ
RXOHXU´RSWLRQDOLW\«LQVRPHOLQJXLVWLFDQGVRFLROLQJXLVWLFVHWWLQJVµFRPPHOHSHQVH5XELRIL SOXW{W
TXHOHXULQWURGXFWLRQUpFHQWH$XPRPHQWGHODIRUPDWLRQGHO·pEODwWHHWSOXVHQJpQpUDOGHVGLDOHFWHVQRUGV\
ULHQVGX,,,JPLOOpQDLUHDYDQW-&O·pYROXWLRQGHVFDVGHYDLWrWUHSOHLQHPHQWUpDOLVpH1RVGRFXPHQWVPRQWUHQW
DXEHVRLQO·LQWHQWLRQGHVVFULEHVGHGRQQHUXQHIRUPHXQLWDLUHjODODQJXHGHO·pFROHRFRH[LVWDLHQWGHVPRGqOHV
V\ULHQVHWPpVRSRWDPLHQVGLIIpUHQWV FRPPHGDQVOHFDVGHFHUWDLQHVSUpSRVLWLRQV ­FHSURSRVOHFDVGXVXIIL[H
#k%TXLIXWXWLOLVpSHQGDQWTXHOTXHWHPSVFRPPHSUpSRVLWLRQj7HOO%H\GDUHWj0DULLQQRYDWLRQVDQVVXLWHHVW
SDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWVLJQLILFDWLI

/CLBN<8=<:>;
!"#$%&'% ()*+,-)*./%0112
!"#$%&'''% ()*+,-)*./%3442-
5!6%7% '8+-9:%;<%=:.><%7(-56)#4%*!]$0%#)%$+!%<0+>6.!()%A10!1>2%,]:6-"0DWHULDOVIRUWKH$VV\ULDQ'LFWLRQDU\
&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVV%01?4<

6<CA<:ML89K<@
$UFKL$OIRQVR
  ´7KH$UFKLYHVRI(EODµ'DQV31)!#:6->%<-4+#?!0%()"%N#&-(-#!0% 3DSHUV5HDGDWWKHJ5HQFRQWUH$V
V\ULRORJLTXH,QWHUQDWLRQDOH/HLGHQ²-XO\ pGLWpSDU.59HHQKRISS²8LWJDYHQYDQ
KHW1HGHUODQGV+LVWRULVFK$UFKDHRORJLVFK,QVWLWXXWWH,VWDQEXO/H\GH,QVWLWXXWYRRUKHW1DELMH
2RVWHQ
%URFNHOPDQQ&DUO
 ² D-1)"-#Ü%"!-%?!-5.!#4+!)"!)%D-(>>($#=%"!-%0!>#$#04+!)%7I-(4+!)YROXPHV%HUOLQ5HXWKHU 5HL
FKDUG
&LYLO0LJXHO
  ´%LOLQJXDOLVPLQ/RJRJUDSKLFDOO\:ULWWHQ/DQJXDJHV6XPHULDQLQ(EODµ'DQV/.%&#.#)51#0>6%(%8&.(g%
<$$#%"!.%36)?!5)6%/)$!-)(G#6)(.!2%B(I6.#2%_áqnn%(I-#.!2%_áànpGLWpSDU/&DJQLSS²1DSOHV,VWLWXWR
8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROL
&RQWL*LRYDQQL
% OPP?% /.%0#..(&(-#6%"!..(%X1(-$(%:6)$!%"!..(%.#0$(%.!00#4(.!%&#.#)51!%!&.(#$(0LVFHOODQHD(EODLWLFD4XDGHUQLGL
6HPLWLVWLFD)ORUHQFH'LSDUWLPHQWRGL/LQJXLVWLFD8QLYHUVLWjGL)LUHQ]H
  ´&DUULHGHTXLSDJJLQHLWHVWLGL(EODµ'DQVA#04!..()!(%8&.(#$#4(%pGLWpSDU3)URQ]DUROLSS²
)ORUHQFH'LSDUWLPHQWRGL/LQJXLVWLFD8QLYHUVLWjGL)LUHQ]H
  ´3UREOHPLHPHWRGLQHOODULFRVWUX]LRQHGLXQDOLQJXDPRUWD,OFDVRGHOO·HEODLWDµ'DQVD-(>>($#4(%!%
OHVVLFRGHOOHOLQJXH´PRUWHµpGLWpSDU85DSDOORHW**DUEXJLQRSS²&ROODQDGHO'LSDUWLPHQWR
GLVFLHQ]HJORWWRHWQRORJLFKHGHOO·8QLYHUVLWjGHJOLVWXGLGL*HQRYD$OHVVDQGULD(GL]LRQLGHOO·2UVR
'DKRRG0LWFKHOO
  ´(EOD8JDULWDQGWKH2OG7HVWDPHQWµT!$10%*!0$(>!)$1>L%71II.!>!)$0²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% QT,N\*/,B%H87%3<7%H<B7%N8%7QA/*/e\8%<K3O<Äe\8g%N<%3,B*K/S\*/,B%H8%N;QSN<Ä*8% 

'LDNRQRII,JRU0
  7!>#$6MO(>#$#4%N()51(5!0g%<)%800('%#)%3.(00#:#4($#6)0RVFRX1DXND
  <:-(0#()%N()51(5!00RVFRX1DXND
(G]DUG'LHW]2WWR
  ´'DV(EOD$NNDGLVFKHDOV7HLOGHV$OWDNNDGLVFKHQ'LDOHNWNRQWLQXXPVµ'DQV*+!%<==("#()%N()M
51(5!%#)%/$0%7!>#$#4%36)$!]$g%7$1"#!0%#)%$+!%<==("#()%6:%$+!%*+#-"%()"%7!46)"%A#..!))#1>%SL3LpGLWpSDU
*¬'HXWVFKHUHW1¬-&.RXZHQEHUJSS²8LWJDYHQYDQKHW1HGHUODQGV,QVWLWXXWYRRUKHW
1DELMH2RVWHQWH/HLGHQ/H\GH1HGHUODQGV,QVWLWXXWYRRUKHW1DELMH2RVWHQ
)URQ]DUROL3HOLR
  ´/·DYYHUELRHEODLWD&(µ7$1"#%!I#5-(:#4#%!%.#)51#0$#4#%01.%T#4#)6%,-#!)$!%()$#46%²
  ´7UHVFRQJLXULHEODLWL $5(7² µT#4#)6%,-#!)$!²
% OPPQ% *!0$#%-#$1(.#%"!..(%-!5(.#$h%^(-4+#?#6%NL%no|á`$UFKLYLUHDOLGL(EOD7HVWL5RPH0LVVLRQH$UFKHRORJLFD
,WDOLDQDLQ6LULD
  ´(EODLFDQGWKH6HPLWLF/DQJXDJHVµ'DQV7$1"#%#)%6)6-!%"#%3(-.6%<.&!-$6%A(0$-!..#g%74-#$$#%"#%(..#!?#%!%(>#4#%
:#6-!)$#)#pGLWpSDU*'HO%-XQJR&DPLFLRWWL)4UDQXFFL030DUFKHVHHW5$WHIDQHOOLSS²
4XDGHUQLGHO'LSDUWLPHQWRGL/LQJXLVWLFD6WXGL3DGRXH8QLSUHVV
% :??Q6% *!0$#%"#%4()4!..!-#(g%/%-(II6-$#%46)%.!%4#$$h%^(-4+#?#6%NL%no|á`L$UFKLYLUHDOLGL(EOD7HVWL5RPH0LVVLRQH
$UFKHRORJLFD,WDOLDQDLQ6LULD
 E ´7KH+DLO,QFDQWDWLRQ $5(7 µ'DQVF!0$04+-#:$%:u-%S1-=+(-$%b#!)(0$pGLWpSDU*-6HO]SS
²$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW0QVWHU8JDULW9HUODJ
  ´6WUXFWXUHVOLQJXLVWLTXHVHWKLVWRLUHGHVODQJXHVDX,,,J%PLOOpQDLUHDY-&µ'DQV@-64!!"#)50%6:%$+!%
_p$+%A!!$#)5%6:%O(>#$6M7!>#$#4%^<:-6(0#($#4`%N#)51#0$#40%^F.6-!)4!2%_àqnp%<I-#.%npp_`pGLWpSDU3)URQ]DUROL
HW3¬0DUUDVVLQLSS²)ORUHQFH'LSDUWLPHQWRGL/LQJXLVWLFD8QLYHUVLWjGL)LUHQ]H
*HOE,JQDFH-
  7!X1!)$#(.%K!46)0$-14$#6)%6:%@-6$6M<==("#()$VV\ULRORJLFDO6WXGLHV&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR
3UHVV
  ´7KRXJKWVDERXW(EOD$3UHOLPLQDU\(YDOXDWLRQ0DUFKµ7'-6MA!06I6$(>#()%7$1"#!0²
*RUGRQ&\UXV+
  ´$PRULWHDQG(EODLWHµ'DQV*+!%7!>#$#4%N()51(5!0pGLWpSDU5+HW]URQSS²/RQGUHV5RXW
OHGJH
+DHOHZ\FN-HDQ&ODXGH
  D-(>>(#-!%46>I(-U!%"!0%.()51!0%0U>#$#X1!0g%Q.U>!)$0%"!%I+6)U$#X1!2%"!%>6-I+6.65#!%!$%"!%0')$(]!/DQJXHV
HWFXOWXUHVDQFLHQQHV%UX[HOOHV6DIUDQ
+DVVHOEDFK5HEHFFD
% :??R% 7(-56)#4%<==("#()g%<%O#0$6-#4(.%()"%36>I(-($#?!%7$1"'%6:%$+!%7'..(&#4%*!]$0:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
+XHKQHUJDUG-RKQ
  ´3URWR6HPLWLFDQG3URWR$NNDGLDQµ'DQV*+!%<==("#()%N()51(5!%#)%/$0%7!>#$#4%36)$!]$g%7$1"#!0%#)%$+!%
<==("#()%6:%$+!%*+#-"%()"%7!46)"%A#..!))#1>%SL3LpGLWpSDU*¬'HXWVFKHUHW1-&.RXZHQEHUJSS
²8LWJDYHQYDQKHW1HGHUODQGV,QVWLWXXWYRRUKHW1DELMH2RVWHQWH/HLGHQ/H\GH1HGHU
ODQGV,QVWLWXXWYRRUKHW1DELMH2RVWHQ
+XHKQHUJDUG-RKQHW&KULVWRSKHU:RRGV
  ´$NNDGLDQDQG(EODLWHµ'DQV*+!%3(>&-#"5!%8)4'4.6I!"#(%6:%$+!%J6-.";0%<)4#!)$%N()51(5!0pGLWpSDU
5¬':RRGDUGSS²&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
.LHQDVW%XUNKDUW
  ´G(DXQGGHUDUDPlLVFKH¶VWDWXVHPSKDWLFXV·µ'DQV8&.(%_áosq_áàsg%H#!4#%())#%"#%0$1"#%.#)51#0$#4#%!%:#.6M
.65#4#2%pGLWpSDU/&DJQLSS²1DSOHV,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROL
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @8N/,%FK,Bt<K,N/

% :??O% O#0$6-#04+!%7!>#$#04+!%7I-(4+9#00!)04+(:$:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
.UHEHUQLN%0DQIUHG%
% 01@2% ABC%DE..->-)%C+F%G)HI*8)-JI/:%F:)%.:K/L-./M9I:+%$:KH:%-CM%#>.-N%$:/.%''%O=.*MM-)P<!"#$%&'()*%+&"+,*"
-''.*%/0/1%$%?2Q%0RS?<
  ´7KH/LQJXLVWLF&ODVVLILFDWLRQRI(EODLWH0HWKRGV3UREOHPVDQG5HVXOWVµ'DQV*+!%7$1"'%6:%$+!%<)M
4#!)$%B!(-%8(0$%#)%$+!%*9!)$'M:#-0$%3!)$1-'pGLWpSDU-6&RRSHUHW*06FKZDUW]SS²:LQRQD
/DNH(LVHQEUDXQV
.UHFKHU-RDFKLP
  ´6XPHULVFKH%XQGQLFKWVXPHULVFKH6FKLFKWLQGHU6FKULIWNXOWXUDXV(EODµ'DQV/.%&#.#)51#0>6%(%8&.(g%
<$$#%"!.%36)?!5)6%/)$!-)(G#6)(.!2%B(I6.#2%_áqnn%(I-#.!2%_áànpGLWpSDU/&DJQLSS²1DSOHV,VWLWX
WR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROL
-LSL‫ش‬VNL(GZDUG
% :??O% 7!>#$#4%N()51(5!0g%,1$.#)!%6:%(%36>I(-($#?!%D-(>>(-qPHpG2ULHQWDOLD/RYDQLHQVLD$QDOHFWD/RX
YDLQ3HHWHUV
5HWWLQDWR*LRYDQQL
  ´7HVWLFXQHLIRUPLGHOPLOOHQQLRLQSDOHRFDQDQHRULQYHQXWLQHOODFDPSDJQDD7HOO0DUGLNK 
(EODµ,-#!)$(.#(QV²
  *!0$#%.!00#4(.#%&#.#)51#%"!..(%&#&.#6$!4(%NL%no|áL0DWHULDOLHSLJUDILFLGL(EOD1DSOHV,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWD
ULR2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROL
5XELR*RQ]DOR
  ´(EODLWH$NNDGLDQDQG(DVW6HPLWLFµ'DQV*+!%<==("#()%N()51(5!%#)%/$0%7!>#$#4%36)$!]$g%7$1"#!0%#)%$+!%
<==("#()%6:%$+!%*+#-"%()"%7!46)"%A#..!))#1>%SL3LpGLWpSDU*'HXWVFKHUHW1¬-&.RXZHQEHUJSS
²8LWJDYHQYDQKHW1HGHUODQGV,QVWLWXXWYRRUKHW1DELMH2RVWHQWH/HLGHQ/H\GH1HGHU
ODQGV,QVWLWXXWYRRUKHW1DELMH2RVWHQ
6M|EHUJ$NH:
 D ´1RWHVRQ6HOHFWHG(QWULHVIURPWKH(EOD9RFDEXODU\HߖEDUNLQR , µ'DQVF!0$04+-#:$%:u-%S1-=+(-$%
b#!)(0$pGLWpSDU*-6HO]SS²$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW0QVWHU8JDULW9HU
ODJ
 E ´1RWHVRQ6HOHFWHG(QWULHVIURPWKH(EOD9RFDEXODU\HߖEDUNLQR ,9 µ'DQVN#$!-($1-2%@6.#$#=%1)"%
K!4+$%#)%A!06I6$(>#!)g%F!0$04+-#:$%:u-%3.(10%J#.4=!pGLWpSDU:6DOODEHUJHU.9RONHW$=JROOSS
²2ULHQWDOLD%LEOLFDHW&KULVWLDQD:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
#FH8JKK82%06786%18KKF786%
  ´,OVLVWHPDSUHSRVL]LRQDOHQHLWUHWHVWLGHOULWXDOHGL$5(7;,DQDORJLHHGLYHUJHQ]Hµ'DQVA#04!..(M
)!(%8&.(#$#4(pGLWpSDU3)URQ]DUROLSS²)ORUHQFH'LSDUWLPHQWRGL/LQJXLVWLFD8QLYHUVLWj
GL)LUHQ]H
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% 

!
"#$%&'("%&)*#+,%$"&-.&/0(*-1-'

K6&!-$%O(9.!'2%\AK%à_|o%,-#!)$%!$%AU"#$!--()U!2%3BK72%@(-#0

-23456783952
$PRQJWKHREVWDFOHVWKDWLPSHGHDQ\DWWHPSWWRUHFRQVWUXFWWKHFDVHV\VWHPRIWKHODQJXDJHVSRNHQLQWKH
FLW\RI8JDULWRQWKH0HGLWHUUDQHDQFRDVWRI6\ULDLQWKHWKLUWHHQWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐWKHIROORZLQJDUHRISDUWLFXODU
LPSRUWDQFH
  8JDULWLFLVD´GHDGµODQJXDJH,WKDVEHHQQHLWKHUVSRNHQQRUUHDGIRUVHYHUDOWKRXVDQG\HDUV)XUWKHU
PRUHWKHSUHFLVHGHWDLOVRILWVJHQHWLFUHODWLRQVKLSZLWKWKHPRGHUQ6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVRIWKHDUHD³RU
LQGHHGZLWKDQ\RIWKH´FODVVLFDOµ6HPLWLFOLWHUDU\ODQJXDJHVDQFLHQWDQGPRGHUQ³DUHQRW\HWFOHDUO\
XQGHUVWRRG7KHUHDUHWKXVQRQDWLYHVSHDNHUVZKRPLJKWKDYHVHUYHGDVDXWKRULWDWLYHLQIRUPDQWVQR
OHDUQHGUHDGLQJWUDGLWLRQVWKDWPLJKWKDYHSUHVHUYHG³HYHQLQIUR]HQIRUP³VRPHNQRZOHGJHRIWKH
ODQJXDJHDQGQRUHOLDEOHLQWXLWLYHDSSURDFKHVEDVHGRQFORVHO\UHODWHGFRJQDWHODQJXDJHV,QVWHDGYLUWX
DOO\DOOLQIRUPDWLRQDERXW8JDULWLFGHULYHVIURPPRGHUQSKLORORJLFDODQGFRQWH[WXDODQDO\VHVRIDQFLHQW
WH[WV
  8JDULWLFLVSRRUO\GRFXPHQWHG7KHHQWLUHWH[WXDOFRUSXVLVOLPLWHGWRDERXWWZRWKRXVDQGLQVFULEHGRE
MHFWVRIZKLFKPDQ\DUHIUDJPHQWDU\DQGPDQ\RIXQFHUWDLQLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ7KXVHYHQZLWKUHVSHFWWR
WKRVHDVSHFWVRI8JDULWLFJUDPPDUDQGOH[LFRQWKDW>#5+$%+(?!%&!!)SHUFHSWLEOHWKURXJKWKHDQDO\VLVRI
WH[WVDJUHDWPDQ\RIWKHVHDUHVLPSO\XQGRFXPHQWHG
  8JDULWLFZULWLQJLVGHIHFWLYH7KH8JDULWLFZULWLQJV\VWHPJHQHUDOO\SURYLGHVRQO\WKHEDUHVWRILQGLFD
WLRQVRIWKHSKRQRORJLFDOVWUXFWXUHRIZRUGVDQGSKUDVHV,WLVHVVHQWLDOO\WKHFRQVRQDQWDOVNHOHWRQWKDWLV
UHSUHVHQWHGWKHYRFDOLFVWUXFWXUHRIWKHODQJXDJHUHPDLQVODUJHO\XQNQRZQDQGPXVWEHUHFRQVWUXFWHG
RQWKHEDVLVRIGDWDWKDWDUHRIWHQDPELJXRXVRUXQUHOLDEOH
  7KHVRFLROLQJXLVWLFVWDWXVRIZULWWHQ8JDULWLFLVXQNQRZQ7KHGLVWLQFWLRQLIDQ\EHWZHHQWKHHYHU\GD\
VSRNHQODQJXDJHXVHGE\WKHUHVLGHQWVRIWKH/DWH%URQ]HNLQJGRPRQWKHRQHKDQGDQGWKHYDULRXVOLWHU
DU\LGLRPVLQZKLFKWKHWH[WVZHUHUHFRUGHGRQWKHRWKHULVQRWNQRZQ&RPSDUDWLYHGDWDVXJJHVWWKDW
VXFKGLIIHUHQFHVRIUHJLVWHUFDQEHTXLWHVLJQLILFDQWWKHSKHQRPHQRQRI´GLJORVVLDµLQWKHFRQWHPSRUDU\
$UDEZRUOGLVDQH[WUHPHH[DPSOHRIPDQ\WKDWFRXOGEHFLWHG
,QOLJKWRIWKHVHGLIILFXOWLHVWKLVSDSHUUHYLHZVWKHHVVHQWLDOVRIZKDWLVDQGFDQEHNQRZQDERXWWKH8JDULWLF
FDVHV\VWHPZLWKVSHFLDODWWHQWLRQSDLGWRVRPHRIWKHLQQRYDWLYHSURSRVDOVDGYDQFHGE\-RVHI7URSSHULQKLV
\5(-#$#04+!%D-(>>($#=2ODQGWRYDULRXVPHWKRGRORJLFDOSULQFLSOHVWKDWPD\EHRIVHUYLFHLQHYDOXDWLQJWKHP6LQFH
VRPXFKDERXW8JDULWLFUHPDLQVXQNQRZQ³DQGIRUWKHPRPHQWXQNQRZDEOH³VXFKDWWHQWLRQWRPHWKRGRORJ\LV
LPSRUWDQW,QSDUWLFXODUWKLVSDSHUVHHNV  WRKLJKOLJKWWKHULVNVRIRYHULQWHUSUHWLQJDPELJXRXVJUDSKLFGDWD
DQGDVGLUHFWFRQVHTXHQFHVRIVXFKDPELJXLWLHV  WRUHFRPPHQGVROXWLRQVWRJUDPPDWLFDOSUREOHPVWKDWDUH
EDVHGRQPRUHWKDQRQHGDWXPDQG  WKDWGRQRWFUHDWHIXUWKHUJUDPPDWLFDOLUUHJXODULWLHVRULQFRQVLVWHQFLHV
WKDQWKRVHWKH\SUHWHQGWRVROYH

O
7URSSHU²


 oi.uchicago.edu

% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

1:4;;&૟!"#$&"9<2=
0RGHUQNQRZOHGJHRIWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPLVEDVHGHVVHQWLDOO\WKRXJKQRWHQWLUHO\:RQWKHGLVWULEXWLRQ
RIWKUHHVLJQVZLWKLQWKHORFDOWKLUW\VLJQLQYHQWRU\$VKDVORQJEHHQUHFRJQL]HGWKHWKUHH૟DOLI%98IH9%67J%HFK%
HQWLUHO\DOSKDEHWLFLQQDWXUHEXWUDWKHUV\OODELF0RUHRYHUWKH\DUHSRO\YDOHQW³HDFKKDVVHYHUDOSRWHQWLDO
V\OODELF´YDOXHVµ

7'..(&#4%T(.1!0

7#5)%_ _ ` ૟D ૟č

7#5)%nà _ ` ૟L ૟Ҹ ૟r Y૟ V\OODEOHILQDO૟

7#5)%ná _ ` ૟X ૟ࡃ ૟{

)LJXUH7KUHHSRO\YDOHQWVLJQVQRWLQJDPRQJRWKHUWKLQJVFRQVRQDQWDO૟(.#: Q

(DFKRIWKHVHWKUHHVLJQVGHVLJQDWHVQRWRQO\WKHSUHVHQFHRIFRQVRQDQWDO૟EXWDOVRWKHSDUWLFXODUYRFDOLF
SKRQHPH LQFOXGLQJ´]HURµWKDWLVQRQH WKDWIROORZVWKH૟%HFDXVHWKHQXPEHURISURGXFWLYHYRFDOLFSKR
QHPHVLQ8JDULWLFLVJUHDWHUWKDQWKUHHWKHUHLVQHFHVVDULO\DFHUWDLQDPRXQWRIVXEMHFWLYLW\LQGHWHUPLQLQJWKH
´UHDGLQJµRIHDFKRIWKHVHVLJQV'HVSLWHWKLVLQKHUHQWDPELJXLW\KRZHYHUWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHWKUHH૟%98IH9%
SURYLGHVDFOHDULQGLFDWLRQRIWKHSUHVHQFHRIFDVHYRZHOVDWWDFKHGWRQRPLQDODQGDGMHFWLYDOEDVHVHQGLQJLQ૟
)LJXUHVDQGRIIHUVRPHH[DPSOHV

NSWUNVXૠ ࠂEWK IURPWKH%D૛OX&\FOH2%b*\:%9,²

´ 7KHLVODQGRI &UHWH LV WKHVHDWRIKLVUHVLGHQFHµ
_ `LVUHDGZLWKWKHYDOXHRI૟XNXVVL૟L´ LV WKHVHDWµ
LQWKHQRPLQDWLYHIXQFWLRQLQDQHTXDWLRQDOVHQWHQFH

ਧ'-਩"%.%=0×ૠ%ਧ'਩ࠂEOKGਧ>਩ IURPWKH%D૛OX&\FOH2%b*\:%9,²
´+HGHVFHQGVIURPWKHFKDLUKHVLWVRQWKHIRRWVWRROµ
_ `LVUHDGZLWKWKHYDOXH૟8W%N%W>rNXVVL૟8´IURPWKHFKDLUµ
LQWKHJHQLWLYHIXQFWLRQIRUDSUHSRVLWLRQDOFRPSOH
PHQW

\૛GENVĚ Z\ࠂE IURP56b*\:

´+HWDNHVDFKDLUDQGKHVLWVµ
_ `LVUHDGZLWKWKHYDOXH૟DNXVVL૟6´ KHWDNHV DFKDLUµ
LQWKHDFFXVDWLYHIXQFWLRQIRUDYHUEDOFRPSOHPHQW

)LJXUH0DVFXOLQHVLQJXODUQRXQVZLWKEDVHVHQGLQJLQFRQVRQDQWDO૟(.#:%

:
7KHRUWKRJUDSK\RIWKLUG'QRXQV ZLWKRUZLWKRXWWKH' PD\DOVR DQG3DUGHH² EXWWKHYLHZVRI*LQVEHUJ HODERUDWHG
SURYLGHLQGLUHFWHYLGHQFHIRUWKHFDVHV\VWHPVHH¬7XWWOH¬² LQDVHULHVRIDUWLFOHVSXEOLVKHGEHWZHHQDQGIRUGHWDLOV
DQG+XHKQHUJDUG VHH0DUFXV DSSHDUWRH[SODLQWKHGDWDEHVWDQGDUHWKHUHIRUH
Q
&HUWDLQGHWDLOVUHJDUGLQJWKHH[DFWQDWXUHDQGIXQFWLRQRIWKHVH DGRSWHGKHUH
WKUHHVLJQVDUHQRW\HWHQWLUHO\UHVROYHG VHH¬7URSSHU¬²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% 

ĚࠂUKUSXૠ>%$"" IURPb*\:,,²DQGSDUDOOHOV
´7KHK(I(૟ࡃPDGLYLQLWLHVJRDIWHUKLPµ
_ `LVUHDGZLWKWKHYDOXH૟ࡃ%W%N%W%76=6૟ࡃM6%W
LQWKHQRPLQDWLYHIXQFWLRQDVWKHJUDPPDWLFDOVXEMHFWRIDYHUE

TUXૠ US×ૠPTGP\P IURP56b*\:%

´7KH\KDYHLQYRNHGWKHDQFLHQWK(I(૟ࡃPDGLYLQLWLHVµ
_ `LVUHDGZLWKWKHYDOXH૟ҸW%N%W%76=6૟ҸM6%W
LQWKHDFFXVDWLYHIXQFWLRQIRUDYHUEDOFRPSOHPHQW

)LJXUH0DVFXOLQHSOXUDOQRXQVZLWKEDVHVHQGLQJLQFRQVRQDQWDO૟(.#:%

,WZDVRQWKHEDVLVRIWKLVDSSDUHQWO\SDWWHUQHGGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHWKUHH૟VLJQVWKDWWKHSLRQHHUVRI8JDULWRO
RJ\HYHQDVHDUO\DVWKHV<ZHUHDEOHWRUHFRQVWUXFWWKHHVVHQWLDOVRIWKHV\VWHPRISURGXFWLYHFDVHHQGLQJV
LQ8JDULWLFQRPLQDOPRUSKRORJ\)LJXUHSUHVHQWVWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPDVFODVVLFDOO\XQGHUVWRRG

1RXQVDQG$GMHFWLYHVRI´0DVFXOLQHµ0RUSKRORJ\

$8HIL>67 3L6> 5>L76>

´QRPLQDWLYHµ VXEMHFWDQGQRPLQDWLYHSUHGLFDWH 67(01 67(0č ># 67(0ࡃ >(
´JHQLWLYHµ QRPLQDWLYHRUSUHSRVLWLRQDOFRPSOHPHQW 67(0# 67(0zM ># 67(0Ҹ >(
´DFFXVDWLYHµ YHUEDOFRPSOHPHQW 67(0( 67(0zM ># 67(0Ҹ >(
1RXQVDQG$GMHFWLYHVRI´)HPLQLQHµ0RUSKRORJ\

$8HIL>67 3L6> 5>L76>

´QRPLQDWLYHµ VXEMHFWDQGQRPLQDWLYHSUHGLFDWH 67(0 ( $M1 67(0 ( Wč ># 67(0čWX
´JHQLWLYHµ QRPLQDWLYHRUSUHSRVLWLRQDOFRPSOHPHQW  67(0 ( $M# 67(0 ( $MzM ># 67(0čWL
´DFFXVDWLYHµ YHUEDOFRPSOHPHQW 67(0 ( $M( 67(0 ( $MzM ># 67(0čWL

)LJXUH7KH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHP

7KHV\VWHPLOOXVWUDWHGDERYHUHSUHVHQWVDVFKRODUO\FRQVHQVXVVKDUHGE\YLUWXDOO\DOOVWXGHQWVRI8JDULWLF
&RPSDULVRQZLWKWKHFDVHV\VWHPVRI$NNDGLDQDQGRIFODVVLFDO$UDELFUHYHDOVSURIRXQGVLPLODULWLHVWKHVHSDUDOOHOV
LQWXUQDUHEHVWH[SODLQHGE\SRVWXODWLQJDFRPPRQ´3URWR6HPLWLFµSUHKLVWRU\IRUWKLVV\VWHPR%

">??@A98&"B;??92<=&
,QDGGLWLRQWRWKHGDWDPHQWLRQHGDERYHZKLFKKDYHEHHQWHDVHGRXWRIWKHDOSKDEHWLFFRUSXVDJUHDWGHDO
RISHUWLQHQWLQIRUPDWLRQFDQDOVREHJOHDQHGIURPWKHDQDO\VLVRI8JDULWLFZRUGVWKDWFURSXSKHUHDQGWKHUHLQ
WKHFRUSXVRIWH[WVZULWWHQ ORJR V\OODELFDOO\LQ0HVRSRWDPLDQFXQHLIRUP%

<
$FFRUGLQJWR&URVV  LWZDV$OEULJKWZKR´ZDVWKHILUVWWR
GHVFULEHIXOO\WKHV\VWHPRIFDVHHQGLQJVXVHGLQ8JDULWLFµ,QGHHG
HYHQLIDWWKHWLPHZKHQ$OEULJKWZDVZULWLQJWKHSKRQRORJLFDO
YDOXHRIVLJQ QRZWUDQVFULEHGZLWKWKH^೓Xૠ ೓`V\PERO KDGQRW\HW
EHHQUHFRJQL]HGKHKDGDOUHDG\LQLVRODWHGWKHVSHFLILFDOO\´DF
FXVDWLYHµDQG´JHQLWLYHµIRUPVRIWKHFRPPRQQRXQ´FKDLUµZULWWHQ
^೓NVĚ೓`DQG^೓NV× ೓`ૠ UHVSHFWLYHO\VHH$OEULJKW²
R
)RUWKH´FODVVLFDOµUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIWKH3URWR6HPLWLFFDVHV\VWHP
VHH%HUJVWUlVVHUDQG0RVFDWL%JK%6>L²$WWHPSWV
KDYHDOVREHHQPDGHWRUHFRQVWUXFWWKH3URWR$IURDVLDWLFFDVHV\VWHP
RIZKLFKWKH3URWR6HPLWLFV\VWHPZRXOGKDYHEHHQRQHVXEVHTXHQW
GHYHORSPHQW VHH6DVVH%ODঈHNDQGWKHUHIHUHQFHVFLWHG
EHORZQRWH¬

)XQGDPHQWDOWUHDWPHQWVRIWKHVHGDWDLQFOXGHWKHXQSXEOLVKHGGLV
VHUWDWLRQRI%R\G¬DQGHVSHFLDOO\+XHKQHUJDUG¬
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

,IWKHSURGXFWLYHVWDWXVRIWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPLVRQO\RFFDVLRQDOO\SHUFHSWLEOHIURPDVWXG\RIWKHDO
SKDEHWLFGDWDLWLVHYHQPRUHFOHDUIURPWKHV\OODELFGDWD$WHOOLQJLOOXVWUDWLRQRIWKHVLJQLILFDQFHRIWKLVGDWD
PD\EHGUDZQIURPWKHORFDOVFKRROH[HUFLVHVFRSLHGDQGVWXGLHGE\ORFDODSSUHQWLFHVFULEHVOHDUQLQJWRUHDG DQG
ZULWH WKH0HVRSRWDPLDQZULWLQJV\VWHPDQGWKHODQJXDJHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKLWLQWKHVFKRROVRI8JDULW)LJXUH
LVDQH[DPSOH

N#)! H/{%7#5) 71>!-#()%J6-"%7#5) 7'..(&#4%<==("#() 7'..(&#4%O1--#() 7'..(&#4%\5(-#$#4

,,ਫ਼ >@ .$>5@ >PLVVLQJ@ HђOXXPPH ђXZD~

,,ਫ਼ >@ .$5 .(M0hM>1 #MGZ1@M-# >Z(@M(.M0hM>1
,,ਫ਼ O .$5 (IMI1 I1M1Zђ@ђL (IMI1
,,ਫ਼ O .$5 k1MG1M&1 (M&1M1kM=1M>! SXODࠃX
,,ਫ਼ O .$5 =(M(M-1 PDђDZG@# PDDђђDZ"1@
,,ਫ਼ O %$/ IÉM.(M(=M=1 $!M(M-# IÉM.(=M=1
,,ਫ਼ >@ %$/ )(M&(.M=1M$1â WDSߖXђXZ1@>M>! $1M(MIÉMZ=1S@
,,ਫ਼ >@ \/- HࠃOX 1kM$(M()M)# &Z(@DђђXU
,,ਫ਼ >@ >߰$@҅ ߖHђX~ ~ђL ђX]LU
,,ਫ਼ >@ >߰$҅78@5 S
=1-M=1MG(M)1 m ђHHQQLߙX

)LJXUH([FHUSWIURPWKHOH[LFDOH[HUFLVH56¬%@

,QDGGLWLRQWRFRS\LQJRXW 6XPHULDQ ZRUGVLJQVDQGWKHLUWUDQVODWLRQVLQ$NNDGLDQ ZKLFKZDVDIRUHLJQ

ODQJXDJHIRUWKH8JDULWLDQVFULEHVDQGKDGWREHOHDUQHGLQVFKRRODORQJZLWKWKH0HVRSRWDPLDQFXQHLIRUPZULW
LQJV\VWHP VRPHSDUWLFXODUO\HODERUDWHVFKRROH[HUFLVHVDOVRFRQWDLQHGDFROXPQ VKRZQRQWKHIDUULJKWRQWKH
WDEOHDERYH FRQWDLQLQJWKH´WUDQVODWLRQµRIWKH0HVRSRWDPLDQORJRJUDPLQWRWKHORFDOODQJXDJH8JDULWLF$V
WKLVSDVVDJHVKRZVDOORIWKHVH8JDULWLFZRUGVDUHZULWWHQV\OODELFDOO\DQGDOOEHDUFDVHYRZHOV LQWKLVFDVHLQ
WKHQRPLQDWLYHWKLVEHLQJWKHDSSURSULDWHFDVHIRUOLVWV 
2IIXUWKHULQWHUHVWLQWKLVUHJDUGLVWKHRFFDVLRQDODGGLWLRQRIDFDVHYRZHOWRIRUHLJQSURSHUQDPHVHYHQ
WKRVHZKLFKDUHQRWQRUPDOO\LQIOHFWHGLQRWKHUIXOO\FDVHGODQJXDJHV7KHREVFXUHGHLW\H(">#kIRUH[DPSOHLV
PHQWLRQHGVHYHUDOWLPHVLQWKHJRGOLVWVLQV\OODELFVFULSWIURP5DV6KDPUDXVXDOO\VSHOOHGZLWKRXWDFDVHYRZHO
^೓GDDGPLLߖ೓`RUWKHOLNH ,QWZRVRXUFHVKRZHYHUWKHQDPHLVVSHOOHGZLWKDQDGGHG´QRPLQDWLYHµFDVHYRZHO
8H%M17KDWWKLVDGGHGYRZHOZDVSHUFHLYHGDVEHLQJ´8JDULWLDQµLQVRPHVHQVHLVVKRZQE\RQHRIWKHVHVRXUFHV
DORFDOWKUHHFROXPQHGFRS\RIWKH0HVRSRWDPLDQJRGOLVWFDOOHGE\PRGHUQVFKRODUVWKH´:HLGQHU*RGOLVWµ RU
´ODOLVWH႐ቨµ PLQZKLFK+XUULDQDQG8JDULWLF´UHDGLQJVµDUHSURYLGHGIRU0HVRSRWDPLDQGHLWLHVO?%

N#)! 71>!-65-(> ´+XUULDQµ:ULWLQJ ´8JDULWLFµ:ULWLQJ

*1 ਫ਼
D
>PLVVLQJ@ Z$(M($M@>#M#k Z"(M("@>#Mk1

)LJXUH7KHGLYLQHQDPHH(">#k1ZLWKDFDVHYRZHOLQ8JDULWLF IURPWKHOH[LFDOH[HUFLVH56¬ OO

7KLVWHQGHQF\WRDGGDFDVHYRZHOHYHQWRIRUHLJQSURSHUQDPHVLOOXVWUDWHVWKHH[WHQWWRZKLFKWKHORFDO
8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPZDVSURGXFWLYH<HWDQRWKHUSKHQRPHQRQWKDWKLJKOLJKWVWKHSURGXFWLYLW\RIWKH8JDULWLF

@
6HH1RXJD\URO²+XHKQHUJDUG² P
:HLGQHU/DPEHUW

7KHILUVWLV56¬¬,9D  VHHILJ¬DQGQ¬ WKHVHFRQGLV O?
)RUWKHOLNHO\SXUSRVHRIVXFKFURVVFXOWXUDODQGFURVVOLQJXLVWLF
IURP56¬>9DULD¬@ '2¬³WKLVUHIHUHQFHLVSURYLGHGFRXUWHV\ ´HTXLYDOHQWVµLQWKHORFDOVFULEDOFXOWXUHVHH¬5RFKH
RI&DUROH¬5RFKHZKRVHHGLWLRQLVLQSUHSDUDWLRQ DQXQSXEOLVKHG OO
%+FLI6E7F>¬²
ORJRV\OODELFH[DPSOHRIWKHORFDO8JDULWLDQJRGOLVWFDOOHG´7KH*RGV
RI 0RXQW ߳DSXQXµ RQWKLVOLVWVHH3DUGHHD² LQOLQH
WKHOLVWUHDGV^೓G"(M("M>!Mk1೓`
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% 

FDVHV\VWHPLVDSDUWLFXODUNLQGRIJUDPPDWLFDOHUURUWKDWLVIUHTXHQWLQWKH$NNDGLDQWH[WVFRPSRVHGDW8JDULW
,QVWDQGDUG$NNDGLDQPRUSKRV\QWD[WKH´FRQVWUXFWµRU´ERXQGIRUPµRIWKHQRXQLVQRWSURGXFWLYHO\FDVHG
LWHLWKHUFRQWDLQVQRFDVHYRZHORUDQXQFKDQJLQJYRZHO,QPDQ\RIWKHORFDOO\FRPSRVHGOHJDOHSLVWRODU\DQG
OH[LFDOWH[WVLQ$NNDGLDQKRZHYHUWKH´ERXQGIRUPVµRI$NNDGLDQQRXQVGRVKRZDFDVHYRZHOO:7KHVH´HUURUVµ
LQWHUPVRIVWDQGDUG$NNDGLDQPRUSKRV\QWD[ WKXVUHIOHFWWKHXQGHUO\LQJ:HVW6HPLWLFYHUQDFXODURIWKHORFDO
VFULEHVLQZKLFKDOOFRPPRQQRXQVZKHWKHUERXQGRUXQERXQGZHUHSURGXFWLYHO\FDVHGOQ

)4;C957=&D9=87==952=&
7KHPRVWUHFHQWFRPSUHKHQVLYHVWXG\RIWKHVHGDWDLQDOORIWKHLUFRPSOH[LW\LVWKDWRI7URSSHULQKLV\5(-#M
$#04+!%D-(>>($#=  7URSSHU·VZRUNLVPXFKPRUHWKDQDVXPPDU\RISUHYLRXVVFKRODUVKLSKRZHYHUKHKDV
DOVRRIIHUHGDQXPEHURILQVLJKWIXODQGRULJLQDOSURSRVDOV)RUWKLVUHDVRQLWVHHPVDSSURSULDWHWRRUJDQL]HWKLV
SUHVHQWDWLRQRIWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPDURXQG7URSSHU·VSUHVHQWDWLRQDIILUPLQJRUFULWLTXLQJKLVLQWHUSUHWD
WLRQVZKHUHWKHGDWDDOORZXVWRGRVR3DUGHH  KDVDOUHDG\EHJXQWKLVSURFHVVDQGLQVHYHUDORIWKH
SRLQWVUDLVHGLQWKHIROORZLQJSDJHVLWZLOOEHREYLRXVWRWKHDWWHQWLYHUHDGHUWKDW,KDYHEHQHILWHGPXFKIURP
WKDWGLVFXVVLRQ
7KXVWKLVSDSHULVQRWVRPXFKDSUHVHQWDWLRQRIWKHEDVLFFDVHV\VWHPLQSURGXFWLYHXVHDW8JDULWZKLFK
VHHPVWREHDVZHOOXQGHUVWRRGDVWKHDYDLODEOHGDWDSHUPLWDVLWLVDEULHIRYHUYLHZRIVHYHUDOSDUWLFXODUFDVH
SUREOHPVWKDWSHUVLVWZLWKVSHFLDODWWHQWLRQSDLGWR7URSSHU·VWUHDWPHQWRIWKHP,QZKDWIROORZVIRXUW\SHVRI
FDVHSUREOHPVDUHDGGUHVVHG  QRXQVZLWK´LQFRUUHFWµFDVHHQGLQJV  QRXQVZLWKRXWFDVHHQGLQJV  WKH
TXHVWLRQRIWKHH[LVWHQFHRIDGGLWLRQDOFDVHVEH\RQGWKH´VWDQGDUGWKUHHµDQG  WKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHGLSWRWLF
GHFOHQVLRQRQVLQJXODUQRXQV

'@=;&)45A?;E&FG&"B;??92<&%4454=
(YHQLQDFRUSXVDVTXDQWLWDWLYHO\OLPLWHGDVLV8JDULWLFWKHSUHVHQFHRIDIHZVSHOOLQJHUURUVLVLQHYLWDEOHO<%
6XFKPLVWDNHVDUHSRWHQWLDOO\UHOHYDQWWRWKLVVWXG\VLQFHLWLVREYLRXVO\QHFHVVDU\WRLGHQWLI\WKHPLQRUGHUQRW
WRDWWULEXWHXQGXHVLJQLILFDQFHWRXQLQWHQWLRQDOZULWLQJVLQDWWHPSWLQJWRHYDOXDWHWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHP

"B;??92<&%4454=&92&(?B:@A;398&1;H3=
7URSSHUKDVLGHQWLILHGWZRH[DPSOHV WKHVHFRQGH[DPSOHLVDWWHVWHGWZLFH RIDOSKDEHWLFVSHOOLQJVWKDWFRQ
VWLWXWHSRWHQWLDOH[DPSOHVRI´LQFRUUHFWµFDVHHQGLQJVLQWKHDOSKDEHWLFFRUSXVOR7KHIRUPVLQTXHVWLRQGRQRW
HPSOR\WKHSDUWLFXODU૟VLJQH[SHFWHGIURPFRQWH[WJLYHQWKHV\VWHPDVRXWOLQHGDERYH

×ૠђK\ࠂ૛UPߖUUP IURPb*\:²
´ $VIRU KHUEURWKHUKHJHWVWKH OLWWOH >k-- ZHLJKW VUHDG\µ

Ěђ\P\WQE૛OVSXૠ \ IURPWKH%D૛OX&\FOH.78:9,²
´ $VIRU P\EURWKHUV%D૛OXKDVJLYHQ WKHP  WRPH  DV P\VXVWHQDQFHµ

Ěђ\P\WQWE૛OVSXૠ \ IURPWKH%D૛OX&\FOH.78:9,²
´ $VIRU P\EURWKHUV\RXKDYHJLYHQ WKHP  WRPH 2%D૛OX DV P\VXVWHQDQFHµ

)LJXUH$OSKDEHWLFGDWDIRU´LQFRUUHFWµFDVHHQGLQJV"

O:
)RUDOLVWVHHYDQ¬6ROGW²Q SOR\HG E\WKHVFULEH2QWKLVVHHDOUHDG\6HJHUWDQG
OQ
+XHKQHUJDUG 'LHWULFKDQG/RUHW]
O<
%\´VSHOOLQJHUURUµ,PHDQDQXQLQWHQWLRQDOZULWLQJWKDWGRHV)6$%
OR
7URSSHU¬²
UHIOHFWWKHJUDPPDWLFDOV\VWHPDVXQGHUVWRRG DQGQRUPDOO\HP
 oi.uchicago.edu

@?% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

,QWKHILUVWSDVVDJHIURPDQHSLVRGHRIQDUUDWLYHSRHWU\GHVFULELQJWKHSD\PHQWRIDEULGHSULFH VHWWLQJXS
WKHVFDOHVHWF WKHQRXQ×ૠђK´KHUEURWKHUµVHHPVWREHWKHJUDPPDWLFDOVXEMHFWRIWKHIROORZLQJYHUE\ࠂ૛U´KH
SUHSDUHVµDQGRQHWKXVQDWXUDOO\VXSSRVHVWKHIRUPHUWREHLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHFDVH:HUHWKHIRUPJHQXLQHO\LQ
WKHQRPLQDWLYHKRZHYHURQHZRXOGH[SHFWLWWREHVSHOOHGXૠ ђK2RUSHUKDSVĚђK2O@EXWFHUWDLQO\QRW×ૠђK
,QWKHVHFRQGDQGWKLUGH[DPSOHVIURPDQHSLVRGHRIQDUUDWLYHSRHWU\LQZKLFKWKHJRGAx$1FRPSODLQVWKDW
WKH RQO\ IRRGSURYLGHGIRUKLPWRHDWZDVKLVRZQNLQWKHQRXQ0IXૠ '´P\IRRGµVHHPVWRSOD\WKHDGYHUELDOUROH
RIDQ´DFFXVDWLYHRIVSHFLILFDWLRQµĚђ\%'$) $ «0IXૠ '´+H \RX JDYH PH P\EURWKHUV DV P\IRRGµ$VVXFKRQH
ZRXOGH[SHFWWKHQRXQWREHZULWWHQVSĚ\2%HFK%0IXૠ '
,QWKHILUVWH[DPSOHWKHVSHOOLQJ×ૠђKFRXOGHDVLO\EHDVLPSOHZULWLQJHUURU7KXVJLYHQWKHODUJHQXPEHU
RIH[DPSOHVLQZKLFKWKHXVDJHRIWKHWKUHH૟DOLIVLJQVLVFRQVLVWHQWZLWKWKHH[LVWHQFHRIDIXOO\SURGXFWLYHFDVH
V\VWHPRIWKHVRUWGHVFULEHGDERYH VHH7XWWOH¬ DVLQJOHIRUPVXFKDVWKLVRQHRXJKWQRWKDYHLPSOLFDWLRQV
IRUWKHFDVHV\VWHPOP7KHVHFRQGDQGWKLUGH[DPSOHVKRZHYHUFDQQRWEHH[SODLQHGDZD\LQWKLVPDQQHUVLQFH
WKH\ERWKSUHVHQWWKHVDPHIRUP,ILWLVHDV\WRLPDJLQHDVFULEDOPLVWDNH 0IXૠ 'LQVWHDGRIH[SHFWHGVSĚ\ RQRQH
RFFDVLRQLWLVPXFKPRUHGLIILFXOWWRDFFHSWWZRLGHQWLFDOH[DPSOHVRIWKHVDPHPLVWDNHZLWKLQILYHOLQHVFOHDUO\
WKHIRUP0IXૠ 'RXJKWWREHWDNHQVHULRXVO\DVDFRQVFLRXVDQGLQWHQWLRQDOZULWLQJ6WLOOWKHV\QWDFWLFDQDO\VLVRI
WKLVSKUDVHOHDYHVVRPHURRPIRUGRXEWUHODWLYHFODXVHVLQ8JDULWLFSRHWU\DUHRFFDVLRQDOO\XQPDUNHG:?DQGWKH
SKUDVHV\WQE૛ODQG\WQWE૛OFRXOGDOVREHH[SODLQHGLQWKLVZD\

Ěђ\P\WQE૛OVSXૠ \ IURPWKH%D૛OX&\FOH.78:9,²
´0\EURWKHUV ZKRP %D૛OXKDVJLYHQ PH  DUH P\VXVWHQDQFHµ

Ěђ\P\WQWE૛OVSXૠ \ IURPWKH%D૛OX&\FOH.78:9,²
´0\EURWKHUV ZKRP \RXKDYHJLYHQ PH 2%D૛OX DUH P\VXVWHQDQFHµ

)LJXUH8QPDUNHGUHODWLYHFODXVHVLQb*\:9,"

,IWKHV\QWDFWLFDPELJXLW\RIWKHVHSDVVDJHVLVJUDQWHG:OWKHLULPSRUWDQFHDVHYLGHQFHRIVFULEDOHUURURURI
HUURQHRXVRUYHVWLJLDOXVDJHV::RIWKHFDVHV\VWHPLVJUHDWO\UHGXFHGHYHQWRWKHSRLQWRILQVLJQLILFDQFH:Q
,QVXPWKHQWKHSXWDWLYHH[DPSOHVRI´LQFRUUHFWµFDVHHQGLQJVLGHQWLILHGWKXVIDULQWKHDOSKDEHWLFFRUSXV
PD\EHGHHPHGLQVLJQLILFDQWGXHWRWKHLUVFDUFLW\DQGRUWKHLUV\QWDFWLFDPELJXLW\


7KDWLVRQHPLJKWKDYHH[SHFWHGDVSHOOLQJLQZKLFKWKHLQLWLDO
૟DOLIVLJQUHIOHFWVWKHUHJUHVVLYHDVVLPLODWLRQRIWKHTXDOLW\RIWKHIRO
ORZLQJࡃYRZHO૟XђࡃKD ૟DђࡃKD2QWKLVSKRQRORJLFDOSURFHVV
ZKLFKLVIDLUO\ZHOOGRFXPHQWHGLQ8JDULWLFDQGWKHHQYLURQPHQWV
LQZKLFKLWLVWULJJHUHGVHH+XHKQHUJDUGDQG7URSSHU

O@
$VVXPLQJWKHUHJXODULW\RIWKHSKRQRORJLFDOUXOHGHVFULEHGLQWKH
DERYHQRWHĚђKZRXOGEHDKLVWRULFDOVSHOOLQJUHIOHFWLQJQRWFRQWHP
SRUDU\SURQXQFLDWLRQEXWUDWKHUDQHDUOLHUVWDJH QDPHO\ ૟DђࡃKD 

%\WKHSKRQRORJLFDOSURFHVVGHVFULEHGDERYH Q¬ WKHZULWLQJ
ZLWKWKH^೓× ೓`ૠ VLJQRXJKWWRLPSO\WKHJHQLWLYHFDVH ૟LђҸKD ૟DђҸKD 
OP
7KHPHWKRGRORJLFDOSULQFLSOHHYRNHGKHUHLVWKXV´$!0$#0%1)10%$!0$#0%
)1..10LY
:?
6HHIRUH[DPSOHb*\:¬¬,¬² NVTGߖOWSKQKĚࠂW´DKRO\FXS
>WKDW@QRZRPDQPD\VHHµ DQGb*\:¬¬,9¬² \GPђߙWĚTKW´WKH
KDQG>WKDW@VWUXFN૟$TKDWXµ 
:O
$QRWKHUSUREOHPZKLFKIXUWKHUKLJKOLJKWVWKHDPELJXLW\RIWKHVH
SDVVDJHVVKRXOGEHDOVREHPHQWLRQHGKHUH$¬VSOLWSDUDGLJPLVRIWHQ
UHFRQVWUXFWHGIRUWKH8JDULWLFILUVWSHUVRQVLQJXODUSURQRPLQDOVXI
IL[M'( ZULWWHQ^೓\೓` ZKHQDWWDFKHGWRVLQJXODUQRXQVLQWKHJHQLWLYH
FDVHEXWMy QRWUHSUHVHQWHGDWDOOLQDOSKDEHWLFZULWLQJ ZKHQDW
WDFKHGWRVLQJXODUQRXQVLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHFDVH WKHUHLVGLVDJUHH
PHQWDERXWWKHIRUPDWWDFKHGWRVLQJXODUQRXQVLQWKHDFFXVDWLYH
FDVH VHH¬*RUGRQ¬7URSSHU¬² ZKHUHPRVWRIWKH
SHUWLQHQWGDWDDUHFLWHG )URPWKLVSHUVSHFWLYHWKHIRUP0IXૠ 'KHUH
LQWHUSUHWHGDVj0(I૟1M'(RUWKHOLNH´P\VXVWHQDQFHµLQWKHQRPLQD
WLYHFDVH ZRXOGVHHPWRSUHVHQWDQDQRPDORXVRUWKRJUDSK\ E\WKH
SDUDGLJPMXVWGHVFULEHGRQHZRXOGH[SHFWj0(I૟yZULWWHQ^೓VS× ೓ૠ `IRU
´P\VXVWHQDQFHµLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHFDVH ,WVKRXOGEHQRWHGKRZ
HYHUWKDWWKHGDWDRQWKHEDVLVRIZKLFKWKHVSOLWSDUDGLJPGHVFULEHG
DERYHZDVLWVHOIHODERUDWHGDUHQRWRULRXVO\KHWHURJHQHRXV WKHILUVW
SHUVRQVLQJXODUSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[LVDOVRZULWWHQ^೓\೓`>WKXVM'(@RQ
VRPHQRPLQDWLYHVLQJXODUQRXQVHVSHFLDOO\LQSURVH DQGDPELJXRXV
WKHH[DPSOHVRIWHQFLWHGLQIDYRURIMyDUHRIWHQLQSRHWLFSDVVDJHV
DQGWKXVRIWHQRIDPELJXRXVPRUSKRORJLFDOLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ 
::
6HHEHORZRQWKHSXWDWLYH´ORFDWLYHµFDVHLQ8JDULWLF
:Q
7KHPHWKRGRORJLFDOSULQFLSOHHYRNHGKHUHLVWKXVFRPSDUDEOHWR
:LOOLDPRI2FFDP·VSDUVLPRQ\SULQFLSOH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% @O

"B;??92<&%4454=&92&/<@49398&I@26&(JJ@69@2K&L546=&92&,58@?&,5<5M=>??@A98&1;H3=&
*LYHQWKHOLPLWHGFDSDFLW\IRUUHSUHVHQWLQJYRZHOVLQDOSKDEHWLFVFULSWLWLVQRVXUSULVHWKDWPRVWRIWKHH[
DPSOHVRI´LQFRUUHFWµFDVHYRZHOVDUHWREHIRXQGLQWKHFRUSXVRIORFDOO\ZULWWHQWH[WVLQ0HVRSRWDPLDQFXQHL
IRUPVFULSW7KHVHKDYHEHHQJDWKHUHGDQGDQDO\]HGLQVHYHUDOSUHYLRXVVWXGLHV:<7KH\LQFOXGHQRWRQO\$NNDGLDQ
ZRUGVEXWDOVR8JDULWLFZRUGVXVHGLQ$NNDGLDQFRQWH[WV+HUHDUHVRPHH[DPSOHV

36)$!]$1(.%F1)4$#6) 7I!..#)5 *!]$%K!:!-!)4!

´JHQLWLYHµ ቈዽ
>1-M1 56 @K\%SS²
´JHQLWLYHµ S
ߙtߙ~>( ()M)1M$1< 56YHUVR  @K\%S
´JHQLWLYHµ =h0SMI1 56 @K\%S
´JHQLWLYHµ ቈዽ
(Mk#M-1M>( 56 @K\%QR
´JHQLWLYHµ ቈዽ
>1-MwM>( LELGOLQH

)LJXUH´,QFRUUHFWµFDVHHQGLQJVRQ8JDULWLFZRUGVLQV\OODELFVFULSW

36)$!]$1(.%F1)4$#6) 7I!..#)5 *!]$%K!:!-!)4!

´DFFXVDWLYHµ LQFVWU SXђXND 56 @K\SS²

´DFFXVDWLYHµ LQFVWU ᅷ$1< LELGOLQH
´DFFXVDWLYHµ LQFVWU ᅷ$1< LELGOLQH
´DFFXVDWLYHµ LQFVWU
ᅷ$1< LELGOLQH
´JHQLWLYHµ ቈዽ.1< 56 @K\S
´JHQLWLYHµ ቈዽ.1< LELGOLQH
´DFFXVDWLYHµ ᅷ$1< 56 @K\SS²
´JHQLWLYHµ LQFVWU
k#M#IM-1 LELGOLQH
´DFFXVDWLYHµ ࠃXSSX LELGOLQH
´JHQLWLYHµS ቈዽ
)(M#(M.1 56 @K\SS²
´JHQLWLYHµ LQFVWU ቈዽ
#=M=hM-1Mk1 56 @K\SS²
´JHQLWLYHµ ቈዽ
)(M#(M.1 56 @K\S
´JHQLWLYHµ S
ߙtߙ~>( ()M)1M$1< 56YHUVR  @K\S
´DFFXVDWLYHµ ᅷ$1< 56 @K\S
´DFFXVDWLYHµ ቈዽ
1&M-1 56 @K\SS²
´DFFXVDWLYHµ LQFVWU
IÉ.M=1Mk1 56 @K\S
´DFFXVDWLYHµ LQFVWU ᅷ$1< 56 @K\SS²
´DFFXVDWLYHµ LQFVWU
ᅷ$1< LELGOLQH
´DFFXVDWLYHµ LQFVWU &1M.(Mk1 56 @K\SS²
´DFFXVDWLYHµ G(M(&M.1 56$  @K\QR
´DFFXVDWLYHµ ᇀ႐ቈ$1< 56YHUVR  \5QR

)LJXUH´,QFRUUHFWµFDVHHQGLQJVRQ$NNDGLDQZRUGVLQORFDOO\FRPSRVHGGRFXPHQWV

:<
6HH1RXJD\URO¬+XHKQHUJDUG¬YDQ¬6ROGW
DQG7URSSHU
 oi.uchicago.edu

@:% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

$VWKHDERYHOLVW:RPDNHVFOHDUWKHYDVWPDMRULW\RIWKHVHIRUPVDUHZULWWHQLQFRUUHFWO\LQWKHQRPLQDWLYH
FDVH([DPSOHVRI´LQFRUUHFWµDFFXVDWLYHDQGJHQLWLYHVSHOOLQJVDUHPXFKPRUHUDUH:@+RZVKRXOGVXFKDQXQ
HYHQGLVWULEXWLRQRI´PLVWDNHVµEHH[SODLQHG"+XHKQHUJDUGKDVREVHUYHGWKDWPDQ\RIWKHVHLQFRUUHFWQRPLQDWLYH
IRUPVRFFXUZLWKLQORQJVHTXHQFHVRIQRXQVWKHQRPLQDWLYHFDVHDSSDUHQWO\EHLQJWKHUHVXOWRIDNLQGRIXQLQ
WHQWLRQDOUHIOH[RQWKHSDUWRIFHUWDLQVFULEHVRIW\SLFDOOLVWV\QWD[)RURWKHUH[DPSOHVWKHSRVVLELOLW\RIIUR]HQ
IRUPVKDVEHHQVXJJHVWHGHVSHFLDOO\ZLWKUHVSHFWWROHJDOIRUPXODVVXFKDV^೓ቈዽM.1>%(M)(%ዼᇀዼቈዽM.1>೓`´HDFKZLWK
UHVSHFWWRWKHRWKHUµDQGWKHOLNH:P%
$QRWKHUOLQHRIH[SODQDWLRQFORVHO\UHODWHGWRWKHIUR]HQIRUPVXJJHVWLRQPHQWLRQHGDERYHLVWREHIRXQG
LQWKHFLUFXPVWDQFHVRIVFULEDOWUDLQLQJQ?:LWKWKHSRVVLEOHH[FHSWLRQRIDIHZZL]HQHGPDVWHUVDQGVHDVRQHG
GLSORPDWVPRVWRIWKHVFULEHVRI8JDULWZHUHSUREDEO\QRWSDUWLFXODUO\IOXHQWLQ$NNDGLDQ7KH\VWXGLHGLWLQ
VFKRRORIFRXUVHDQGFRXOGUHDGDQGHYHQZULWHLWLQWKHFRXUVHRIWKHLUGDLO\DGPLQLVWUDWLYHGXWLHVEXWLQPRVW
FDVHVWKHOHYHORIODQJXDJHLQYROYHGFRQVLVWHGRIVWHUHRW\SHGGRFXPHQWVDQGIRUPXODLFSKUDVHVFRPSRVHGDOPRVW
PHFKDQLFDOO\$JODQFHDWWKHFXUVXVRIOH[LFDOH[HUFLVHVVWXGLHGE\WKHDSSUHQWLFHVFULEHVRI8JDULWVXJJHVWVD
SODXVLEOHH[SODQDWLRQIRUPDQ\LIQRWDOORIWKHVH´LQFRUUHFWµQRPLQDWLYHZULWLQJV,QFRS\LQJDQGUHFRS\LQJ
WKHOH[LFDOOLVWVWKHVFULEHVOHDUQHGHVVHQWLDOO\ WKRXJKRIFRXUVHQRWH[FOXVLYHO\ $NNDGLDQQRPLQDWLYHIRUPV
:KHQDVFULEH·VDWWHQWLRQZDQGHUHGRUZKHQIDWLJXHVHWLQUHVXOWLQJLQDJUDPPDWLFDOHUURULWZDVWKXVHVSHFLDOO\
WKHQRPLQDWLYHIRUPVWKDWZHUHZRQWWREHUHSURGXFHGPHFKDQLFDOO\RXWRIUHIOH[DQGORQJKDELWIURP\HDUVRI
FRS\LQJVXFKQRPLQDWLYHOLVWV
7KLVH[SODQDWLRQZRUNVZHOOIRUWKHPRVWIUHTXHQW´PLVWDNHVµOLVWHGDERYHLQILJXUH¬VXFKDV^೓ᅷM$1<೓`DQG
^೓ቈዽM.1<೓`WKHVHVSHOOLQJVEHLQJTXLWHFRPPRQLQWKH´$NNDGLDQµFROXPQRIWKRVHOH[LFDOOLVWVPRVWVWXGLHGLQWKH
SHULSKHU\QO7KHDUFKDLFQDWXUHRIWKHVHVSHOOLQJVZLWKPLPDWLRQ $1<% $1>DQG.1<% .1> VHHPVWRFRQILUPWKHLU
RULJLQVLQFHVXFKDUFKDLVPVDUHDOVRIRXQGLQWKHORFDOOH[LFDOWUDGLWLRQVZKLFKDOPRVWFHUWDLQO\JREDFNWR2OG
%DE\ORQLDQPRGHOVQ:%
7KLVVDPHOLQHRIUHDVRQLQJVHHPVDOVRWRSURYLGHDSODXVLEOHH[SODQDWLRQIRUPRVWRIWKH´LQFRUUHFWO\µLQ
IOHFWHG8JDULWLFZRUGVLQV\OODELFVFULSW ILJ¬ DOORIZKLFKDUHDOVRPLVWDNHQO\ZULWWHQLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHFDVH
)RURQHRIWKHPLVWDNHVFDWDORJXHGE\7URSSHU³IRUH[DPSOHWKHVSHOOLQJ^೓=h0SMI1೓`QQZLWKDQDSSDUHQWQRPLQD
WLYHFDVHYRZHOLQVWHDGRIWKHH[SHFWHGJHQLWLYH³WKHUDUHRUWKRJUDSK\ZLWKWKH^೓NjV೓`VLJQPD\ZHOOKDYHEHHQ
PHFKDQLFDOO\UHSURGXFHGIURPWKHOH[LFDOWUDGLWLRQQ<7KHLQFRUUHFWQRPLQDWLYHFDVHVRQWKHV\OODELFVSHOOLQJVRI

:R
)RUIXUWKHUGHWDLOVDERXWWKHUHDGLQJDQGLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIWKHVH
WH[WVVHHWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJSDVVDJHVLQ/DFNHQEDFKHU ZKHUH
WKHDQWHULRUELEOLRJUDSK\LVDOVRSURYLGHG )RUWKHSUREOHPDWLFUHDG
LQJ^೓NjV೓`LQ56¬VHHEHORZQRWH¬

6HH+XHKQHUJDUGQ¬
:@
+XHKQHUJDUG6XFKPLVWDNHVDUHDOVRRIWHQHDVLHUWRH[
SODLQ+XHKQHUJDUGSRLQWVRXWWKDWWKHVFULEHUHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKH
QRPLQDWLYHIRUPEࡃODߖXIRUH[DPSOHDSSHDUVWRKDYHOHDUQHGWKH
LQIOHFWLRQRIWKDWQRXQDVLILWEHORQJHGWRWKHSDUDGLJPRIQRXQV
VXFKDV.#&&1 .#&&(Mk1LQWKHQRPLQDWLYH UDWKHUWKDQQRXQVVXFK
69%E̒OX E̒OߖXLQWKHQRPLQDWLYH DVLQVWDQGDUG$NNDGLDQ1RWH
KRZHYHUWKH\čQXFRQVWUXFWLRQZLWKDQDFFRPSDQ\LQJDFFXVDWLYH
LQVWHDGRIH[SHFWHGQRPLQDWLYH IRUZKLFKVHHYDQ¬6ROGW¬
DQGQ DQGPRUHJHQHUDOO\,VUDHO

+XHKQHUJDUG¬Q¬VHHDOVRYDQ¬6ROGW¬
:P
6HH¬+XHKQHUJDUG¬ZLWKUHIHUHQFHVWR1RXJD\URO¬
´XQSVHXGRLGJLVVXGHO·DFFDGRJUDPPHKLWWLWHFRUUHVSRQGDQWµ DQG
$UQDXG ´/HV¶FRPSOpPHQWVSKRQpWLTXHV·MRXDLHQWG·XQH
FHUWDLQHPDQLqUHDXVVLOHVLPSOHU{OHGHPDUTXHXUVG·LGpRJUDPPHV
GRQWOHVSOXVFRPPXQVVRQWWRXMRXUVVXLYLVGXPrPHVLJQHSKRQp
WLTXHDXSRLQWGHIDLUHXQQRXYHOLGpRJUDPPHLQYDULDEOHjVRQWRXU
«UHIOpWDQWODSURQRQFLDWLRQGHO·pSRTXHRLODpWpHPSUXQWpDX
EDE\ORQLHQDQFLHQµ 
Q?
&DUROH5RFKHKDVGLVFXVVHGWKLVSUREOHPZLWKPHRQVHYHUDORFFD
VLRQVDQGPXFKLQWKHVHSDUDJUDSKVUHIOHFWVKHUWKRXJKW VHH5RFKH
² 
QO
)RUH[DPSOHQRWHWKHIUHTXHQWSUHVHQFHRIWKHVSHOOLQJ^೓ᅷM$1<೓`LQ
WKH$NNDGLDQFROXPQRIWKHELOLQJXDOFRSLHVRIWKH6 6¬9RFDEXODU\
IURP(PDU IRUH[DPSOHVHH¬$UQDXG² 
Q:
6HH$UQDXG¬ VHHWKHSDVVDJHFLWHGDERYH DQG&LYLO

QQ
7URSSHU¬1RXJD\URO·VUHDGLQJ^೓NjVSX೓`KHUH 56¬
 KDVEHHQTXHVWLRQHGKRZHYHU VHH&KLFDJR$VV\ULDQ'LFWLRQDU\¬߳
ߙXUSXPQJDQG+XHKQHUJDUG¬ZKHUHDUHDGLQJZLWKWKH
^೓ፔዼወ೓`VLJQLVIDYRUHGNDVSXߙXUSX´UHILQHGVLOYHUµ DQGLQGHHGWKH
VLJQ^೓ N jV೓ ` HOVHZKHUHLQWKH5DV6KDPUDFRUSXVLVJHQHUDOO\PXFK
PRUH´FKDUJHGµWKDQLVWKLVVLJQ&ROODWLRQRIWKHWDEOHW FRXUWHV\&
5RFKH KRZHYHUVXJJHVWVWKDW^೓ፔዼወ೓` ZKHWKHULWEHUHDGDVߙXU%F7%
ߙiU LVQRWHQWLUHO\VDWLVIDFWRU\HLWKHU L ¬VLQFHRWKHUFOHDUH[DPSOHV
RIWKH^೓ፔዼወ೓`VLJQDPRQJWKHORFDOO\FRPSRVHGWH[WVWHQGWRKDYHDQ
8H8K86>%J#)=!.+(=!) VHH^೓G႐በ႐ወዼዧዼ೓`LQ56¬ 562¬QR¬ 
ZKHUHDVWKLVVLJQGRHVQRW EXWQRWHWKDWVRPHH[DPSOHVRIWKH^೓ፔዼወ೓`
VLJQIURPWKH$ODODNKFRUSXVGRVHHPWRODFNWKHLQLWLDOREOLTXH
VHH¬:LVHPDQQRV%DQG DQG LL ¬VLQFHWKHUHDUHIRXU
REOLTXHZHGJHVLQDOODWWKHHQGRIWKHVLJQDQGQRWWKUHHDV1RX
JD\URO·VFRS\ZRXOGVXJJHVW$GGLWLRQDOO\ LLL ¬WKHYDOXHVߙXUDQGߙiU%
DUHQRWFRPPRQLQWKH5DV6KDPUDFRUSXVDQG LY HYHQWKRXJK
WKHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ´UHILQHGVLOYHUµGRHVPDNHJRRGVHQVHDQGKDV
FRPSDUDWLYHSDUDOOHOVLWLVRWKHUZLVHXQDWWHVWHGLQWKH5DV6KDPUD
FRUSXVZKLFKJLYHQWKHQXPEHURIWLPHVLQZKLFKILQDQFLDOWUDQVDF
WLRQVLQYROYLQJVLOYHUDUHPHQWLRQHGPDNHVDXQLTXHRFFXUUHQFHRI
WKHH[SUHVVLRQKHUHVXUSULVLQJ,IDQHZSURSRVDOLVWREHPDGHRQ
SXUHO\HSLJUDSKLFJURXQGV5RFKHMXGJHVWKHPRVWREYLRXVUHDGLQJ
WREH^೓ᇀ႐ᄽ೓`WKRXJKVXFKDQLGLRP >QXPEHU@ሳዿᄽ႐ᄽᄽ႐ወ%5(&M&1%#M)(%
ዝ႓በዧᇹቈቈ႐´>QXPEHU@ VKHNHOVRI VLOYHU LQ DOODVWKHIXOOSULFHµ 
VHHPVRGGDQGLVQRW WRP\NQRZOHGJH RWKHUZLVHDWWHVWHGLQWKH
5DV6KDPUD$NNDGLDQFRUSXVHLWKHU
Q<
6HHWKHZULWLQJ^೓NjVSX೓`LQWKH8JDULWLFFROXPQRIDORFDOFRS\RI
WKH7'..(&(-'%<%T64(&1.(-' 56¬¬,,¬ \5¬QR¬+XHKQHU
JDUG¬ 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% @Q

WKHORFDO8JDULWLFSURIHVVLRQVVXFKDV^೓ቈዽ(Mk#M-1M>(೓` ૛čߖLUࡃPDIRUH[SHFWHG૛čߖLUҸPD PD\DOVREHH[SODLQHGLQWKLV

ZD\/LVWVRIZRUGV ORFDOWRSRQ\PVNLQJVJRGVSURIHVVLRQVHWF ZHUHFRSLHG LQERWKVFULSWV GXULQJVFULEDO
K768H8HI2QRDQGWKH´PLVWDNHVµDWWHVWHGKHUHSUREDEO\UHIOHFWVSHOOLQJVOHDUQHGE\URWHLQVFKRRO
7DNHQDVDJURXSWKH´LQFRUUHFWµQRPLQDWLYHIRUPVDWWHVWHGLQ0HVRSRWDPLDQFXQHLIRUPVFULSWZKHWKHUWKH\
UHIOHFW8JDULWLF ILJ¬ RU$NNDGLDQZRUGV ILJ¬ DUHEHVWH[SODLQHGQRWDVSURGXFWLYH´$NNDGRJUDPVµ HOVH
WKH\ZRXOGKDYHEHHQXVHGZLWKJUHDWHUIUHTXHQF\ EXWUDWKHUDVXQLQWHQWLRQDOUHIOH[HVGXHWRLQDWWHQWLRQRU
IDWLJXHRIWKHVSHOOLQJVOHDUQHGE\URWHGXULQJVFULEDOWUDLQLQJ7KHUHPDLQLQJFDVHHUURUVDUHH[FHHGLQJO\UDUH
DQGVWDWLVWLFDOO\FRPSDUDEOHWRWKHOLPLWHGQXPEHURIFDVHHUURUVLQWKHDOSKDEHWLFFRUSXV,QRWKHUZRUGVWKH\
DUHLQVLJQLILFDQWIRUWKHVWXG\RIWKHFDVHV\VWHP

"7EE@4>&
7KHH[DPSOHVRI´PLVWDNHQµFDVHHQGLQJVLQZKDWHYHUVFULSWVHHPWKXVEHVWDWWULEXWHGWRRFFDVLRQDOEXW
LQHYLWDEOHKXPDQHUURU7KH\DUHQRWV\PSWRPDWLFRIDZLGHUSKHQRPHQRQVXFKDVWKHJHQHUDOFROODSVHRIWKH
8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHP+DGWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPEHHQLQWKHSURFHVVRIFROODSVLQJRQHZRXOGH[SHFWWRILQG
 ¬PRUHLQFRQVLVWHQFLHVLQWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHWKUHH૟¬VLJQVRQQRXQVDQGDGMHFWLYHVZKRVHEDVHVHQGLQFRQ
VRQDQWDO૟  DJUHDWHUQXPEHUDQGDERYHDOODPRUHHYHQGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHH[DPSOHVRI´LQFRUUHFWµFDVH
HQGLQJVRQ8JDULWLF DQG$NNDGLDQ ZRUGVZULWWHQLQV\OODELFVFULSWDQG  PRUHH[DPSOHVRI8JDULWLFZRUGV
ZULWWHQZLWKRXWDQ\FDVHHQGLQJZKDWVRHYHU7KLVODVWSRLQWLQWURGXFHVRXUVHFRQGSUREOHP

'@=;&)45A?;E&NG&O54E=&P93:573&'@=;&Q5P;?=
+XHKQHUJDUGDQG7URSSHUKDYHFDWDORJHGDQGGLVFXVVHGDQXPEHURIH[DPSOHVRI8JDULWLFZRUGVDSSHDULQJ
LQV\OODELFVFULSWZLWKRXWFDVHYRZHOVQ@+HUHDUHVRPHH[DPSOHV

7I!..#)5 8]I!4$!"%F6-> *!]$%K!:!-!)4!

႐ዝ႕ በᅵዝ
(.M.(M()% k!M!-M$(M()M)#
M
૟DOOčQL 56² @K\S
>(M=(" UPDTTčGL 56 @K\QR
=1M-#M=(M(Z$@ ਧ[਩ߙ8
S%
UNXULNčWX 56 @K\QR
:%ዼወዼᅡዼPDDPߙDDUEXOL PDPߙčUč 56 @K\QR
SXђXUᅡᇹቨᇀᇹወ በᅵዝ
USXђUX 56 \5QR
>(M.#=በᅵዝ UPDOLNࡃPD 56 \5QR
O%)#M#$ UQL૟ҸWX S
56 \5QR
O%PDUђLLߖLߖLDWLPL UPDUђLߖX 56 \5QR

)LJXUH6RPH8JDULWLFZRUGVLQV\OODELFVFULSWWKDWDSSDUHQWO\ODFNFDVHHQGLQJV

6XSHUILFLDOO\WKHH[LVWHQFHRIVXFKIRUPVPLJKWVHHPWREHDQLQGLFDWLRQRIWKHGHFOLQLQJSURGXFWLYLW\RU
HYHQRIWKHFROODSVHRIWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPEXWJLYHQWKHZHLJKWRIWKHHYLGHQFHWKDWVXJJHVWVLQVWHDGWKH
RYHUDOOYLDELOLW\DQGFRQWLQXLQJSURGXFWLYLW\RIWKHORFDOFDVHLQIOHFWLRQ VHHWKH/)$-6"14$#6)DERYH LWDSSHDUV
PRUHSUXGHQWWRH[SODLQWKHVHIHZIRUPVWKDWODFNFDVHYRZHOVLQRWKHUZD\VVKRXOGVXFKEHSRVVLEOH
7KUHHW\SHVRIDOWHUQDWLYHH[SODQDWLRQVPD\EHHYRNHG  ZHPD\H[SODLQFHUWDLQRIWKHZULWLQJVOLVWHGDERYH
LQILJXUH¬DVEHLQJ´$NNDGLDQL]LQJµIRUPV ZRUGVWKDWDUHOH[LFDOO\8JDULWLFEXWLPLWDWHFHUWDLQDVSHFWVRI$N
NDGLDQPRUSKRORJ\   ZHPD\H[SODLQVHYHUDORWKHUZULWLQJVDVEHLQJ´FDSULFLRXVµLQWKDWWKH\H[WHQGFHUWDLQ

QR
6HH¬+DZOH\²

56¬ 358¬QR¬ ZKLFKLVQRWLWVHOIDVFKRROH[HUFLVH
WKRXJKWKHVSHOOLQJVXVHGWKHUHLQYHU\SUREDEO\GRUHIOHFW LQGL
UHFWO\ WKHFXUULFXOXPFRQWDLQVWKHZULWLQJ^೓ቈዽ(Mk#M-1M>(೓` QRWHWKH
ODFNRIWKH^೓በᅵዝ೓`VLJQDVLQWKHH[DPSOHFLWHGDERYHLQILJ¬ 
Q@
+XHKQHUJDUG¬²7URSSHU¬²$GLVWDQWO\UH
ODWHGEXWQRWLGHQWLFDOSUREOHPLVWKDWRIQRXQVLQ$NNDGLDQWH[WV
WKDWODFNDQH[SHFWHGFDVHYRZHOIRUZKLFKVHHYDQ¬6ROGW¬
DQG*HRUJH RQVHYHUDOVXFKIRUPVLQRQHRIWKHD#.5(>!0+%
PDQXVFULSWVIURP5DV6KDPUD 
 oi.uchicago.edu

@<% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

RUWKRJUDSKLFSULQFLSOHVEH\RQGWKHLUW\SLFDOO\DWWHVWHGHQYLURQPHQWVRIXVDJHDQGILQDOO\  ZHPD\H[SODLQWKH
UHPDLQLQJZULWLQJVDVQRWQHFHVVDULO\SHUWLQHQWWRWKHGLVFXVVLRQRIFDVHHQGLQJVRURI8JDULWLFPRUSKRORJ\$OO
RIWKHH[DPSOHVRIFDVHOHVV8JDULWLFZRUGVLQV\OODELFVFULSWGLVFXVVHGE\+XHKQHUJDUGRU7URSSHUFDQEHHDVLO\
JURXSHGLQWRRQHRUDQRWKHURIWKHVHFDWHJRULHV

/<@49398&L546=&92&">??@A98&"849B3&1:@3&":5P&R(JJ@69@29S92<T&$54B:5?5<98@?&O;@374;=&
+XHKQHUJDUG  KDVGHVFULEHGWKLVFDWHJRU\DVIROORZV´$QXPEHURIIRUPVZKLFKUHIOHFW8JDULWLF
URRWVH[KLELWQRW8JDULWLFPRUSKRORJ\EXWUDWKHUWKHPRUSKRORJ\RIWKH$NNDGLDQGLDOHFWVRIWKHWH[WVLQZKLFK
WKH\RFFXUµ)RXURIWKHZULWLQJVOLVWHGDERYHLQILJXUH¬PD\EHH[SODLQHGXQGHUWKLVUXEULF^೓=1M-#M=(M(Z$@S%
ਧ[਩ߙL೓`^೓PDDPߙDDUEXOL೓`^೓SXђXUᅡᇹቨᇀᇹወበᅵዝ೓`DQG^೓PDUђLLߖLߖLDWLPL೓`
,QWHUPVRILQWHUSUHWDWLRQWKHFOHDUHVWRIWKHVHLV^೓SXђXUᅡᇹቨᇀᇹወ0)\೓`ZKLFKRFFXUVLQRQHRIWKHORFDOJRG
OLVWVLQ0HVRSRWDPLDQVFULSWDQGZKLFKKDVDFRUUHVSRQGLQJHQWU\LQWKHDOSKDEHWLFJRGOLVWVZULWWHQSђU×ૠOP%
´WKH$VVHPEO\RIWKHJRGVµ7KH´$NNDGLDQL]LQJµPRUSKRORJLFDOIHDWXUHLQYROYHGLVWKHDEVHQFHRIDFDVHHQGLQJ
RQWKHERXQGIRUPRIWKH8JDULWLFQRXQLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWK$NNDGLDQPRUSKRORJ\6LQFHWKHUHDUHXQDPELJXRXV
H[DPSOHVRI8JDULWLFFRPPRQQRXQVZLWKFDVHYRZHOVLQWKHFRQVWUXFWVWDWHXQOLNHWKHVLWXDWLRQLQ$NNDGLDQ%
HLWKHUWKHVSHOOLQJSXђXUUHIOHFWVDQLQFRQVLVWHQF\LQWKHXVHRIFDVHYRZHOVE\8JDULWLFVSHDNHUVRULWUHSUHVHQWV
WKHLQWHQWLRQDOXVHRIDQ´$NNDGLDQL]LQJµFRQVWUXFWVWDWHIRUD8JDULWLFFRPPRQQRXQ6LQFHWKHUHLVDJUHDWGHDO
RIHYLGHQFHIRUWKHV\VWHPLFDQGSURGXFWLYHVWDWXVRIWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPDQGVLQFHLQFRQVLVWHQFLHVDUHUHOD
WLYHO\UDUHH[DPSOHVVXFKDV^೓SXђXUᅡᇹቨᇀᇹወበᅵዝ೓`DQGWKHRWKHUWKUHHZULWLQJVFLWHGDERYHDUHPRVWHDVLO\H[SODLQHG
DVV\OODELFZULWLQJVRI8JDULWLFQRXQVWKDWVKRZ´$NNDGLDQL]LQJµPRUSKRORJLFDOIHDWXUHV
6WLOOWKHLPPHGLDWHWH[WXDOFRQWH[WPD\QRWKDYHEHHQWKHRQO\IDFWRUWKDWFRQGLWLRQHGWKHFUHDWLRQDQGXVH
RIVXFK´$NNDGLDQL]LQJµIRUPVVRFLROLQJXLVWLFIDFWRUVPD\DOVRKDYHEHHQLQYROYHG6LQFHWKH0HVRSRWDPLDQ
ZULWLQJV\VWHPDQGWKH$NNDGLDQODQJXDJHKDGDFFXPXODWHGDJUHDWGHDORISUHVWLJHDPRQJWKHLQWHOOHFWXDOHOLWH
RIWKH/DWH%URQ]HZRUOGVRPHWKLQJWRZKLFKWKHVFULEHVRI8JDULWZHUHFHUWDLQO\QRWLPPXQHQPPDQ\RIWKHVH
´$NNDGLDQL]LQJµIRUPVPD\LQIDFWUHSUHVHQWQRWHUURUVLQ8JDULWLFPRUSKRORJ\FRPPLWWHGE\QDWLYHVSHDNHUV
EXWPDQLIHVWDWLRQVRIWKHJUHDWSUHVWLJHRI0HVRSRWDPLDQVFULEDOSUDFWLFHVDPRQJ:HVWHUQSHULSKHUDOVFULEHV
6XFK´HUURUVµPLJKWKDYHEHHQLQDVHQVHLQGLUHFWERDVWVDLPHGDWRWKHUFROOHDJXHVDQGLQWHQGHGWRDIILUPWKH
OHYHORIPDVWHU\LQWKH0HVRSRWDPLDQVFULEDODUWVDFKLHYHGE\WKHVFULEHLQTXHVWLRQZULWLQJVVXFKDVWKHVHZRXOG
KDYHVHQWDPHVVDJHWRFROOHDJXHVWRWKHHIIHFWWKDWQRWRQO\KDGWKHVFULEHUHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKLVWDEOHWPDVWHUHG
$NNDGLDQEXWKHKDGDOVROHDUQHGKRZWRZULWHORFDO8JDULWLFZRUGV´FRUUHFWO\µ WKDWLVWRVD\´LQDPRUHSUHV
WLJHRXVZD\µ ³LQRWKHUZRUGVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHUXOHVRI$NNDGLDQJUDPPDUUDWKHUWKDQDFFRUGLQJWRWKHORFDO
YHUQDFXODUQRPLQDOGHFOHQVLRQ

/<@49398&L546=&92&">??@A98&"849B3&1:@3&(4;&L4933;2&92&R'@B498957=T&L@>=
7KUHHZULWLQJVIURPILJXUH¬DERYHPD\EHFRQVLGHUHG´FDSULFLRXVµLQWKHVHQVHWKDWWKH\HPSOR\FHUWDLQ
VFULEDOFRQYHQWLRQVRXWVLGHRIWKHLUXVXDOFRQWH[WVRULQXQH[SHFWHGZD\V^೓>(M=("೓`^೓>(M.#= በᅵዝ೓`DQG^೓)#M#$೓`6HYHUDO
W\SHVRI´FDSULFHµPD\EHUHFRJQL]HGKHUHDOORIZKLFKLQYROYHVRPHIRUPRUDQRWKHURIJUDSKLFDEEUHYLDWLRQ<?%
7KHZULWLQJ^೓>(M=("೓`KDVEHHQGHVFULEHGDVD´SVHXGRORJRJUDPµ WKXV^೓በ႐ሳ႐ᅡ೓` <OE\ZKLFKLVPHDQWDORJR
JUDSKLFZULWLQJWKDWKDVQRSUHFHGHQWLQPDLQVWUHDP0HVRSRWDPLDQWUDGLWLRQEXWUDWKHUGHYHORSHGVHFRQGDULO\LQ
DSHULSKHUDOFRQWH[W*LYHQWKHH[LVWHQFHRIRWKHU´SVHXGRORJRJUDPVµLQWKHORFDOO\FRPSRVHG$NNDGLDQWH[WV<:%
LWVHHPVOLNHO\WKDWWKLVLQWHUSUHWDWLRQLVFRUUHFW^೓በ႐ሳ႐ᅡ೓`ZDVHPSOR\HGDVDORJRJUDPIRUORFDO>X"SHUKDSV


,QJHQHUDOVHH+XHKQHUJDUG
QP
6HH¬$UQDXGDQG5RFKH
<?
,QWKLVYHLQVHHWKHUHPDUNVRI&LYLO  ´>6WXGHQWVRIFXQHL
IRUPZULWLQJV\VWHPV@«KDYHWRRRIWHQWDNHQWKHZULWWHQYHUVLRQRI
DWH[WDVWUDQVOLWHUDWHGE\WKHPDWLWVIDFHYDOXHGLVUHJDUGLQJVFULEDO
FRQYHQWLRQVDQGDGRSWLQJLQSUDFWLFHLIQRWLQWKHRU\WKHSULQFLSOH
WKDW¶ZKDWLVQRWLQWKHZULWWHQWH[WLVQRWLQWKHXWWHUDQFH·µ S 
´DRQHWRRQHFRUUHVSRQGHQFHEHWZHHQSKRQRORJLFDODQGJUDSKLF
HOHPHQWVLVWKHLGHDOFDVHQHYHUIRXQGLQSUDFWLFHLQ¶QDWXUDO·ZULW
LQJV\VWHPV7KHGHYLDWLRQVIURPWKHQRUPDUHGXHWRWKHKLVWRULFDO
REVHUYDWLRQWKDWPRVWODQJXDJHVKDYHEHHQUHGXFHGWRZULWLQJE\
ERUURZLQJDIRUHLJQVFULSWWRDQLQHUWLDLQWKHVSHOOLQJKDELWV KLV
WRULFDOZULWLQJV DQGODVWEXWQRWOHDVWWRDWHQGHQF\WRVLPSOLI\E\
RPLWWLQJVHWVRISKRQRORJLFDOHOHPHQWV HJWRQHRUVWUHVV ZKLFK
DUHPRUHRUOHVVSUHGLFWDEOHIRUWKHQDWLYHUHDGHUµ S¬ 
<O
+XHKQHUJDUG¬+XHKQHUJDUG¬YDQ¬6ROGW¬
Q
<:
+XHKQHUJDUG¬²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% @R

LQWKHVHQVHRI´SDVWXUH ULJKWVS µ<QSUREDEO\RQWKHDQDORJ\RIWKHXVHRIWKH´FODVVLFDOµORJRJUDP^೓ቨ႐ሳ႐ᅡ೓`<<%GF7%

GHVLJQDWLQJWKHORFDOSURIHVVLRQ)X"´VKHSKHUGµLQWKHORFDOSURIHVVLRQVOLVWV
:ULWLQJVRIWKH^೓>(M.#= በᅵዝ೓`W\SH<RUHSUHVHQWDQRWKHUW\SHRIDEEUHYLDWLRQWKDWLQZKLFKWKH^೓በᅵዝ೓`VLJQUHSODFHV
WKHV\OODELFUHQGHULQJRIWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ8JDULWLFSOXUDOPRUSKHPH
)LQDOO\DWKLUGW\SHRIJUDSKLFDEEUHYLDWLRQLVUHSUHVHQWHGE\VSHOOLQJVRIWKH^೓)#M#$೓`W\SHLQZKLFKDVLJQRI
WKH9& RU&9& W\SHLVHPSOR\HGLQDZD\WKDWLPSOLHVDELV\OODELFORFDOUHDGLQJ

^೓)#M#$%O%>!೓` 56\5%R2%QR
´2QHQL૟ҸWX D[H  LWVZHLJKWEHLQJ RQHKXQ GUHGVKHNHOV µ

)LJXUH$EEUHYLDWHGZULWLQJVLQWKHLQYHQWRU\56¬

,WLVSRVVLEOHRIFRXUVHWKDWWKHZULWLQJ^೓)#M#$೓`LVDQDEEUHYLDWLRQLQWKHVDPHVHQVHDVWKHIROORZLQJ^೓>!೓`VLJQ
WKHVFULEHVLPSO\OHIWRIIWKHHQGRIWKHZRUGVLQFHLWVHHPHGFOHDUIURPFRQWH[W%XWLWDSSHDUVPRUHSODXVLEOH
WRH[SODLQWKHZULWLQJZLWKWKH^೓ᇹᅡ೓`DVD´FDSULFLRXVµRQHDVVXJJHVWHGE\DQDQDORJRXVH[DPSOHRIJUDSKLFDE
EUHYLDWLRQHQFRXQWHUHGLQWKH$NNDGLDQPDQLIHVWDWLRQVRIFHUWDLQVWHUHRW\SHGSROLWHIRUPXODVFKDUDFWHULVWLFRI
WKH:HVWHUQSHULSKHUDOHSLVWRODU\WUDGLWLRQ

56²562QR
^೓  !M)1M>(%#$M$#M#(%k1.M>(%(k M-(M)1%  #$M$#%ዝᅵዝᅡዿᇀᇀ႐#(%>#M)1M1>M>!M!%%
 %k1.M>(M)1%.1Mw%$(Mk(IMI(M-(೓`
´+HUHZLWKPH WKLQJVDUH ZHOO7KHUHZLWKP\¶JRRGEURWKHU·%
UHJDUGLQJ ZKDWHYHULVZHOO\RXVKRXOGZULWH WRPHDERXWWKDW µ

56²\5%R2%QR
^೓  !M)1M>(%ᇹᅡM#(%k1.M>1%  (kM-(M)1%ᇹᅡM=(%>#M)1M>UM!%%
 ߖXOPDQDࠃp©PDªWHM!-M()M)1೓`
´+HUHZLWKPH WKLQJVDUH ZHOO7KHUHZLWK\RX UHJDUGLQJ %
ZKDWHYHULVZHOOUHWXUQZRUG WRPHDERXWWKDW µ

)LJXUH^೓ᇹᅡ೓`ZLWKDELV\OODELF´UHDGLQJµ#$$#LQORFDOHSLVWRODU\XVDJH"

,QWKHVHFRQGSDVVDJHWUDQVFULEHGDERYHWDNHQIURPWKHFRUSXVRIGRPHVWLFFRUUHVSRQGHQFH LQ$NNDGLDQ DW

8JDULWLQZKLFKWKHSUHIHFWZULWHVWRDKLJKUDQNLQJORFDORIILFLDOWKHSUHSRVLWLRQ#$$#´ZLWK4+!GµLVWZLFHZULW
WHQE\WKHVFULEHLQD´FDSULFLRXVµPDQQHUZLWKWKH^೓ᇹᅡ೓`VLJQ<@:HKDYHDOUHDG\VHHQWKDWWKHVFULEHVRI8JDULW
ZHUHQRWDYHUVHWRVKRZLQJRIIWKHLUIDFLOLW\LQ0HVRSRWDPLDQFXQHLIRUPE\HQJDJLQJLQDFHUWDLQDPRXQWRI
FDSULFLRXVZULWLQJV,QWKLVH[DPSOHWKHVFULEHVHHPVWREHGHPRQVWUDWLQJ  ¬KLVNQRZOHGJHWKDWWKH^೓ᇹᅡ೓`VLJQ
FDQEH´UHDGµZLWKWKH$NNDGLDQZRUG#"1´KDQGµ´DUPµDQGVRRQ DQGLWVDFFXVDWLYHDQGJHQLWLYHHTXLYDOHQWV
#"(DQG#"# ³¬VRPHWKLQJKHPD\ZHOOKDYHOHDUQHGLQFRS\LQJ ORFDOIRUHUXQQHUVRI ҅$5UD ђXEXOOX¬,,<P%F7%9FMJ%

<Q
 6R 1RXJD\URO   +XHKQHUJDUG¬   GHO¬ 2OPR¬ /HWH
DQG6DQPDUWtQ2WKHUVROXWLRQVKDYHDOVREHHQSURSRVHG
YRQ¬6RGHQ²E0iUTXH]¬5RZH 
<<
6HH¬YDQ¬6ROGW¬ Q 
<R
&5RFKHLQIRUPVPHWKDWDQRWKHUH[DPSOHRIWKLVW\SHRFFXUV
RQDQXQSXEOLVKHGODEHOIURPWKH´+RXVHRI8UWHQXµ^೓ᇀዼወ%51M.(M
&1¬0(߰೓`´)RXUGࡃGX PHDVXUHV RI51.(&1 JUDLQ µ³¬WKDW^೓ᇀዼወ೓`LVLQ
GHHGWKHORFDOORJRJUDSKLFZULWLQJRIWKHGU\PHDVXUHVSHOOHG"" > 
LQWKHDOSKDEHWLFWH[WV DQHTXLYDOHQFHDOUHDG\VXVSHFWHGE\/LYHUDQL
 LVQRZHVWDEOLVKHGE\D´QHDUELOLQJXDOµHTXLYDOHQFHVHH
0DOEUDQ/DEDWDQG5RFKH7KHZULWLQJ^೓51M.(M&1በᅵዝ೓`ZRXOG
WKXVEHDQDEEUHYLDWHGZULWLQJRI JXODEࡃPDVHH5RFKHIRUWKFRPLQJ

2QWKH$NNDGLDQ+LWWLWHDQG8JDULWLFYHUVLRQVRIWKLV´UHFLSURFDO
IRUPXODRIZHOOEHLQJµVHH3DUGHHDQG+DZOH\¬²
<@
6HHDOUHDG\%HUJHUZKRFLWHVDVLPLODUH[DPSOHLQDQLQ
WHUQDWLRQDOGLSORPDWLFOHWWHU 56¬\5¬QR¬ZKHUH1RX
JD\UROKDGLQWHUSUHWHG^೓ᇹᅡ¬ቈዽ ሳዼወ¬I(M(M.Z#@೓`DV#$ $# DPҸOSčOL´>DY@HF " 
O·KRPPHGX3DO>X@µ 

6HHDERYHQRWH¬
<P
7KH´FDQRQLFDOµYHUVLRQRI҅$5UD ђXEXOOX¬,,FRQWDLQVWKHHTXLYD
OHQFH^೓႓LGX೓`´WKH ^೓ᇹᅡ೓`VLJQZLWKWKH6XPHULDQYDOXH ႓ FDQEH
XVHGIRUWKHZULWLQJRIWKH$NNDGLDQZRUG #"1 ¶KDQGDUPHWF· µ
/DQGVEHUJHU7KLVVHFWLRQLVDWWHVWHGDVSDUWRIWKHFXU
ULFXOXP LQ WKH :HVWHUQ SHULSKHU\ IRU 8JDULW VHH /DQGVEHUJHU
¬¬YDQ¬6ROGWDQGIRU(PDUVHHQRZ*DQW]HUW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

VXFKVLPLODUSHGDJRJLFDOOLVW¬³EXWZLWKWZRDGGHGLQQRYDWLRQVH[WHQGHGE\DQDORJ\IURPVLPLODUSULQFLSOHVLQ
´FODVVLFDOµ0HVRSRWDPLDQVFULEDOWUDGLWLRQ  ¬WKDW0HVRSRWDPLDQ9&VLJQVWHQGQRWWRGLVWLQJXLVKJUDSKLFDOO\
WKHYRLFHGXQYRLFHGDQGHPSKDWLFDUWLFXODWLRQVRIFHUWDLQW\SHVRIFRQVRQDQWV WKXVDSSDUHQWO\DOORZLQJIRU
WKLVVFULEHDWOHDVW#$12%#$(DQG#$#DVWKHRUHWLFDOO\SRVVLEOHUHDGLQJVRI^೓ᇹᅡ೓` DQG  ¬WKDWFRQVRQDQWDOJHPLQDWLRQ
QHHGQRWEHLQGLFDWHGJUDSKLFDOO\R? WKXVDOORZLQJ#$$# 
7KHH[DPSOHRIWKHZULWLQJ^೓QLᇹᅡ೓`IRU8JDULWLFQL૟ҸWXFLWHGDERYHLQILJXUH¬PD\UHIOHFWVLPLODUSURFHVVHV
WKRXJKLQWKLVFDVHZLWKDQDQDORJLFDOH[WHQVLRQRI\HWRWKHUJUDSKLFSULQFLSOHV  ¬WKDWYRFDOLFOHQJWKQHHGQRWEH
LQGLFDWHGJUDSKLFDOO\RO WKXVDOORZLQJҸWX2%ҸWDDQGҸWLDVWKHRUHWLFDOO\SRVVLEOHUHDGLQJV DQG  ¬WKDWLQWHUYRFDOLF૟
PD\EHXQZULWWHQR: WKXVDOORZLQJ૟ҸWXHWF ,QDQ\FDVHZKHWKHURUQRWWKLVVSHFLILFH[SODQDWLRQIRU^೓QLᇹᅡ೓`EH
DFFHSWHGWKHLQQRYDWLYHIOH[LELOLW\PDQLIHVWHGE\WKHORFDO8JDULWLDQVFULEHV·XVHRIWKH0HVRSRWDPLDQV\OODEDU\LV
VLJQLILFDQWHQRXJKIRUWKHUHWREHFRQVLGHUDEOHGRXEWWKDWWKHVSHOOLQJ^೓QLᇹᅡ೓`UHIOHFWVDFDVHOHVVXQGHUO\LQJIRUP
$ILQDOQRWHVKRXOGEHDGGHGRQWKHSURSHUQDPHVDW8JDULWIURPZKLFKVRPHRIWKHFOHDUHVWDQGPRVW
FRQYLQFLQJH[DPSOHVRI´FDSULFLRXVµZULWLQJVGHULYHRQ0DQ\ WKRXJKQRWDOO W\SHVRI8JDULWLDQSURSHUQDPHV
ZKHWKHURFFXUULQJLQ YHUQDFXODU 8JDULWLFRULQ LQWHUQDWLRQDO $NNDGLDQWH[WXDOFRQWH[WVVKRZDIXOO\SURGXF
WLYHXVHRIWKHORFDO8JDULWLFFDVHHQGLQJVR<,QOLJKWRIWKLVWHQGHQF\HVSHFLDOO\RQJHRJUDSKLFDOQDPHVWKHSUHV
HQFHRI´XQLQIOHFWHGµIRUPVLVVWULNLQJDJRRGH[DPSOHLVWKHSODFHQDPH´8JDULWµLWVHOIZKLFKLVRIWHQZULWWHQ
ZLWKRXWDQH[SOLFLWLQGLFDWLRQRIWKHDWWDFKHGFDVHYRZHO RR'DQLHO6LYDQKDVVXJJHVWHGWKDW´WKHSKHQRPHQRQ
>RISURSHUQRXQVZLWKRXWFDVHHQGLQJV@FDQHDVLO\EHH[SODLQHGDVDQDWWHPSWRQWKHSDUWRI:HVWHUQVFULEHVWR
LPLWDWHWKH$NNDGLDQIRUPV LQZKLFKSURSHUQDPHVKDYHQRFDVHHQGLQJV µ )RUPDQ\RIWKHDSSDUHQWH[DPSOHV
RIXQGHFOLQHGSURSHUQDPHVDW8JDULWWKLVPD\ZHOOKDYHEHHQWKHFDVHWKHVHH[DPSOHVZRXOGWKXVEHORQJDPRQJ
WKH´$NNDGLDQL]LQJµIRUPVGLVFXVVHGDERYHR@,WLVDOVRSRVVLEOHKRZHYHUWKDWWKHVH´FDVHOHVVµZULWLQJVDUHQRW
VRPXFK´$NNDGLDQL]LQJµDVWKH\DUH´FDSULFLRXVµLQWKHVHQVHVXJJHVWHGIRUWKHZULWLQJVᇹᅡ UHDGDV#$$# DQG^೓QL
ᇹᅡ೓` UHDGDV)#M ૟ ҸWX GLVFXVVHGDERYH7KLVZRXOGUHVROYHWKHDSSDUHQWGLVFUHSDQF\IRUWKHLQIOHFWLRQRIWKHSODFH
H6MJ%૟8JčUҸWXIRUH[DPSOHZULWLQJVHPSOR\LQJWKHᇹᅡVLJQDVWKHILQDOHOHPHQWPD\ZHOOKDYHEHHQLQWHQGHGWR
EH´UHDGµELV\OODELFDOO\ZLWKDQLPSOLFLWFDVHYRZHO0DQ\RIWKHRWKHUORFDOSODFHQDPHVWKDWVHHPVXSHUILFLDOO\
WRKDYHEHHQ´XQGHFOLQHGµRPPD\DOVREHVXVFHSWLEOHWRVXFKDQH[SODQDWLRQ7KLVWRSLFKRZHYHULVYHU\FRPSOH[
DQGUHTXLUHVPXFKPRUHVWXG\WKDQFDQEHDFFRUGHGWRLWKHUH

(EA9<757=&L49392<=&I92&(?B:@A;398&/<@49398K
,QWKHDOSKDEHWLFFRUSXVH[DPSOHVRI8JDULWLFQRXQVZLWKRXWFDVHYRZHOVKDYHDOVREHHQSURSRVHG6LQFH
WKHRQO\VLJQVLQWKHORFDODOSKDEHWLFV\VWHPWKDWSURYLGHDQH[SOLFLWLQGLFDWLRQRIDVVRFLDWHGYRZHOVDUHWKHWKUHH

R?
6HH¬+XHKQHUJDUG²
RO
+XHKQHUJDUG
R:
6HH¬+XHKQHUJDUG
RQ
2Q´MHX[JUDSKLTXHVµLQWKHORFDO ORJRV\OODELF VSHOOLQJVRISURSHU
QDPHV LQFOXGLQJERWKSHUVRQDODQGJHRJUDSKLFDOQDPHV VHHWKH
H[DPSOHVFLWHGLQ+XHKQHUJDUG²DQG5RFKH
R<
)RUWKHSURGXFWLYLW\RIWKHFDVHLQIOHFWLRQVRQJHRJUDSKLFDOQDPHV
VHH¬YDQ¬6ROGWIRUWKHSHUVRQDOQDPHVVHH¬*U|QGDKO
² DQGVHHEHORZ´&DVH3UREOHPµ 
RR
)RUWKHSUREOHPVSUHVHQWHGE\WKLVJHRJUDSKLFDOQDPHDQGWKH
JHQWLOLFIRUPGHULYHGIURPLWVHH¬3DUGHH¬²DQG+DZ
OH\DQG3DUGHH¬Q¬ ZKHUHWKHSUHYLRXVOLWHUDWXUHLVFLWHG 

6LYDQ
R@
 ,Q IDYRU RI VXFK DQ LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ LV WKH DUFKDLF QDWXUH RI WKH
VSHOOLQJ^೓wM5(M-#M#$ ሳᇹ ೓`LWLVDWWHVWHGDOUHDG\LQWKHHLJKWHHQWKFHQ
WXU\ GRFXPHQWDWLRQ IURP 0DUL VHH *URQHEHUJ¬    DQG LQ
WKH2OG%DE\ORQLDQOHYHO 9,, IURP$ODODNK <*¬VHH%HOPRQ
WH¬0DUtQ¬ DQGLQWKHIRXUWHHQWKFHQWXU\$PDUQDFRUSXV
LELGS¬ 7KHIUHTXHQF\RIWKLVVSHOOLQJDPRQJWKHORFDOVFULEHV
RIWKLUWHHQWKFHQWXU\8JDULWFRXOGWKXVEHYHU\SODXVLEO\H[SODLQHG
DVGXHWRRUWKRJUDSKLFLQHUWLD WKDWLVDVDQROGVSHOOLQJKDELW UDWKHU
WKDQDVDPHDQLQJIXOUHIOHFWLRQRIKRZWKHSURSHUQDPHZDVLQIOHFWHG
LQWKHORFDOYHUQDFXODU

6XFKLVWKH´FODVVLFµYRFDOL]DWLRQ VHH$VWRXUZKHUHSUH
YLRXVELEOLRJUDSK\LVPHQWLRQHG 
RP
)RUWKHOLVWVHH¬YDQ¬6ROGW

,WLVQRWHZRUWK\IRUH[DPSOHWKDWELV\OODELFUHDGLQJVKDYHDOUHDG\
EHHQGRFXPHQWHGIRUVRPHRIWKHVLJQVLQYROYHGHLWKHUVSHFLILFDOO\
IRUWKHORFDOFXQHLIRUPFRUSXV IRU႐ቨUHDGDV#.1VHH+XHKQHUJDUG
³VXFKDUHDGLQJZRXOGDOORZIRULPSOLFLWFDVHHQGLQJVRQ
WKHORFDOYLOODJHQDPHVA(-(૟#.1DQGࠥčED૟#.1 RUIURPWKHEURDGHU
0HVRSRWDPLDQWUDGLWLRQ IRU႐ወUHDGDV(-(LQILUVWPLOOHQQLXPWUD
GLWLRQVVHH%RUJHU³DELV\OODELFUHDGLQJRI႐ወZRXOGQRW
RQO\DOORZIRUDQLPSOLFLWFDVHHQGLQJRQWKHORFDOYLOODJHQDPHA#M
UDUkSEXWDOVRVXJJHVWDVROXWLRQWRWKHSUREOHPRIWKHV\OODELFVSHOO
LQJVRIWKHJHQWLOLFDGMHFWLYH´8JDULWLDQµLQ56¬² @K\¬
QR¬ ^೓ 31 ¬ዼወዼ1M5(M(-M$#Mኹᇹ೓`DQG^೓ 31 ¬ዼወዼ1M5(M(-M$#೓`RQWKHVHZULW
LQJVVHHYDQ¬6ROGW7URSSHU¬3DUGHH¬
²DQG+DZOH\DQG3DUGHH¬Q¬ LQDQ\FDVHLWPD\EH
XQZLVHWRDWWULEXWHXQGXHVLJQLILFDQFHWRWKHVHWZRVSHOOLQJVVLQFH
WKH\DSSHDUWRKDYHEHHQWKHZRUNRI>RUKHDYLO\LQIOXHQFHGE\@DIRU
HLJQVFULEHVHH¬YDQ¬6ROGW¬ 7KHORFDOVFULEHVPD\DOVRKDYH
EHHQ´FDSULFLRXVµLQWKHLUXVHRIRWKHU&9VLJQVDWWULEXWLQJWRWKHP
ELV\OODELFYDOXHVE\WKHDQDORJLFDOH[WHQVLRQRIVLPLODUELV\OODELF
UHDGLQJVNQRZQWRWKHPIRURWKHUHVVHQWLDOO\PRQRV\OODELFVLJQV

7URSSHU¬
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% @@

૟VLJQVWKHRQO\SHUWLQHQWH[DPSOHVKHUHDUHQRXQVGHULYHGIURPURRWVHQGLQJLQ૟ )XUWKHUPRUHVLQFHLWLVDOVR
ZLGHO\DFNQRZOHGJHGWKDWQHLWKHUWKH^೓Ě೓`VLJQQRUWKH^೓Xૠ ೓`VLJQGHQRWHV\OODEOHILQDO૟RQO\ZRUGVHQGLQJLQ^೓× ೓`ૠ 
DUHSRWHQWLDOO\RIUHOHYDQFH
7KH^೓× ೓ૠ `VLJQKRZHYHUDOVRVKRZVWKHJUHDWHVWSRO\YDOHQFHRIDQ\8JDULWLFVLJQ VHHDERYHILJ¬ ³¬LWLV
XVHGQRWRQO\WRUHSUHVHQWFRQVRQDQWDO૟IROORZHGE\DYRZHOPRVWSUREDEO\DKLJKIURQWYRZHO DVLQWKHVSHOO
LQJV^೓NV× ೓ૠ `IRU NXVVL૟L^೓US× P
ૠ ೓`IRU UDSD૟ҸPDDQG^೓× Eૠ ೓`IRU ૟rEX EXWDOVRWRUHSUHVHQWV\OODEOHILQDO૟UHJDUGOHVVRI
WKHTXDOLW\RIWKHSUHFHGLQJYRZHO DVLQWKHVSHOOLQJV^೓U× ߖૠ ೓`IRU UD૟ߖXDQG^೓P× ђૠ G೓`IRU PD૟ђDGX ¬³DQGIURPWKLV
SRO\YDOHQFHLWIROORZVWKDWWKHPRUSKRORJLFDODQDO\VLVRIZRUGVHQGLQJLQWKH^೓× ೓`ૠ VLJQLVSRWHQWLDOO\DPELJXRXV
$QRWKHUSUHOLPLQDU\SRLQWWREHPDGHKHUHLQYROYHVWKHIXQFWLRQDOGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHSXWDWLYHH[DPSOHVRI
8JDULWLFFDVHOHVVQRXQVLQWKHDOSKDEHWLFFRUSXVDJUHDWPDQ\³LQGHHGWKHPRVWSODXVLEOHVXJJHVWHGH[DPSOHV
RIFDVHOHVVQRXQVLQDOSKDEHWLFVFULSW³RFFXULQDYRFDWLYHIXQFWLRQDOFRQWH[W7KHGDWDGLVFXVVHGLQWKLVVHFWLRQ
WKXVKDYHDQDGGHGVLJQLILFDQFH7KH\DUHWKHRQO\´LQWHUQDOµ8JDULWLFGDWDDYDLODEOHIRUDGGUHVVLQJRQHRIWKH
PDQ\DV\HWXQUHVROYHGTXHVWLRQVUHJDUGLQJWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHP+DGQRXQSKUDVHVLQWKHYRFDWLYHIXQF
WLRQLQ8JDULWLFDOUHDG\EHHQDVVLPLODWHGLQWRRQHRUDQRWKHURIWKHIRUPDOFDVHFDWHJRULHVDVWKH\ZHUHWREHLQ
FODVVLFDO$UDELF" 2UZHUHQRXQVLQWKHYRFDWLYHIXQFWLRQVWLOOH[HPSWHGIURPV\VWHPDWLFFDVHPDUNLQJDVWKH\
ZHUHLQ$NNDGLDQ" 
7KH´LQWHUQDOµGDWD VHHEHORZILJ¬ WKXVEHLQJDPELJXRXVDQGOLPLWHGDQGWKHSHUWLQHQWFRPSDUDWLYH
GDWDEHLQJLQFRQVLVWHQWWKHPRVWSODXVLEOHZD\RIDGGUHVVLQJWKHVHTXHVWLRQVLV  ¬E\WDNLQJLQWRFRQVLGHUDWLRQ
LQDVKROLVWLFDPDQQHUDVSRVVLEOHWKHYDULRXVPRUSKRV\QWDFWLFZD\VLQZKLFKYRFDWLYHSKUDVHVZHUHPDUNHG
LQ8JDULWLFDQGWKHQVHDUFKLQJIRUFRPPRQDOLWLHVDQG  ¬E\DWWHPSWLQJWRHYDOXDWHWKH8JDULWLFV\VWHPWKXV
UHYHDOHGDJDLQVWWKHEURDGHUFKURQRORJLFDODQGW\SRORJLFDOEDFNJURXQGVNHWFKHGRXWRQWKHEDVLVRIFRPSDUDWLYH
6HPLWLFGDWD DQGHVSHFLDOO\$NNDGLDQDQG$UDELF DQGZKHUHSRVVLEOHFRPSDUDWLYH$IURDVLDWLFGDWD
,QJHQHUDOSUHOLPLQDU\FRQVLGHUDWLRQVRIWKHEURDGHU$IURDVLDWLFGDWDVXJJHVWWKDWWKHLQYHQWRU\RIIRUPV
DQGIXQFWLRQVRIWKH3URWR$IURDVLDWLFFDVHV\VWHPZHUHQRWGLUHFWO\FRPSDUDEOHWRWKHV\VWHPUHFRQVWUXFWHG
IRU3URWR6HPLWLF,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHIDPLOLDU´FODVVLFDOµ6HPLWLFV\VWHP WULSWRWLFLQWKHVLQJXODU>M12%M(2%M#@


7KHUHDUHDOVRVRPHIRUPVGHULYHGIURPURRWVZLWK<DVWKHILQDO
UDGLFDOWKDWPD\EHSHUWLQHQWKHUH 7XWWOH¬² WKRXJKWKH
LQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIVXFKIRUPV PRVWRIZKLFKGHULYHIURPWKLUG<
URRWV UHPDLQVLQPDQ\FDVHVXQFOHDU+XHKQHUJDUG·VREVHUYDWLRQ
Q¬ LVVWLOOSHUWLQHQW´7KHDSSHDUDQFHRUQRQDSSHDUDQFH
FG%G8H6>%Y RUJ LQERWKQRPLQDODQGYHUEDOIRUPVLQ8JDULWLFSUHV
HQWVDSUREOHPWKDWQHHGVIXUWKHULQYHVWLJDWLRQµ(YHQIRUPVGHULYHG
IURPJHPLQDWH UDWKHUWKDQWKLUGZHDN URRWVZLWKILQDO<DUHSRWHQ
WLDOO\DPELJXRXV2QHVXFKH[DPSOHLVWKHRDWKIRUPXOD´ %\ WKHOLIH
RI P\\RXU VRXOµWZLFHZULWWHQє¬QSߖLQ56¬ VRRQWREH
SXEOLVKHGVHHSURYLVLRQDOO\3DUGHH¬EQ¬ ,WLVSRVVLEOH
WKDWWKLVZULWLQJRIWKHZRUGIRU´OLIHµ´ LV DOLYHµZLWKRXWWKH^೓\೓`
VLJQUHIOHFWVDSDUWLFXODU8JDULWLFPRUSKRV\QWDFWLFSKHQRPHQRQ
SHUKDSVDNLQWRDFHUWDLQH[WDQWWRWKHLGLRPDWLFXVDJHRIWKHVR
FDOOHGDEVROXWHVWDWHRQQRXQVLQ6\ULDF ZKHUHWKHDEVROXWHVWDWHRQ
QRXQVZDVQRORQJHUSURGXFWLYHVHHIRUH[DPSOH1|OGHNH¬²
 6WLOOJLYHQWKHXQFHUWDLQWLHVWKDWSHUVLVWUHJDUGLQJWKHEHKDYLRU
RIWKHFRQVRQDQW'LQ8JDULWLFSKRQRORJ\DQGJLYHQWKHXQFHUWDLQ
H[LVWHQFHRIDQ´DEVROXWHFDVHµDVDYDOLGJUDPPDWLFDOFDWHJRU\LQ
8JDULWLFRQHPXVWEHFDXWLRXVDERXWDWWULEXWLQJWRRPXFKVLJQLIL
FDQFHWRDIRUPVXFKDVWKLVRQHHVSHFLDOO\LQOLJKWRILWVIRUPXODLF
QDWXUH,QGHHGDPRQJWKRVHOLQJXLVWLFHQYLURQPHQWVPRVWOLNHO\
WRSUHVHUYHLQIUR]HQIRUPDUFKDLFSKRQRORJLFDODQGJUDPPDWLFDO
IHDWXUHV ZKLFKDUHGLVWLQFWIURPDQGQRWUHIOHFWLYHRIFRQWHPSRUDU\
XVDJH DUHIRUPXODVVXFKDVRDWKIRUPXODV7KXVD¬SULRULVKRXOG
DQRDWKIRUPXODVKRZ´XQH[SHFWHGµSKRQRORJLFDORUPRUSKRORJLFDO
IHDWXUHVLWLVOHJLWLPDWHWRVXVSHFWWKDWWKHVH´XQH[SHFWHGµIHDWXUHV
DUHLQIDFWDUFKDLFIHDWXUHVSUHVHUYHGLQDSDUWLFXODUIUR]HQIRUP
GHULYHGIURPDSDUWLFXODUFRQWH[W6LQFHWKHZULWLQJRIWKHILUVWQRXQ
LQWKHRDWKIRUPXODє¬QSߖLQ56¬DVєUDWKHUWKDQ є\2%89%
´XQH[SHFWHGµIURPWKHSRLQWRIYLHZRI1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLFKLVWRULFDO
SKRQRORJ\ LQWHUYRFDOLFJHPLQDWHG'LVDOPRVWDOZD\VJUDSKLFDOO\
UHSUHVHQWHG ZHPD\UHDVRQDEO\LQIHUWKDWLWVXQXVXDOZULWLQJKHUH
LVWREHH[SODLQHGDVDQDUFKDLVPUHIOHFWLQJQRWFRQWHPSRUDU\EXW
HDUOLHUSKRQRORJLFDODQGPRUSKRORJLFDOUHDOLWLHV)XUWKHUPRUHVLQFH
WKHH[WHQVLRQRIWKHFDVHV\VWHPLQWR´SHULSKHUDOµDUHDVRIV\QWD[
VXFKDVYRFDWLYHSKUDVHVWKHERXQGIRUPVRIQRXQVDQGSUHGLFDWH
QRXQVDGMHFWLYHV DSSHDUVWRKDYHEHHQDUHODWLYHO\ODWHGHYHORSPHQW
DFRPSDULVRQRIWKH$IURDVLDWLF(DVW6HPLWLFDQG:HVW6HPLWLFGDWD
VXJJHVWVWKDWWKLVSDUDGLJPDWLFH[WHQVLRQRIWKHFDVHV\VWHPZDV
D:HVW6HPLWLFLQQRYDWLRQVHHLQPRUHGHWDLOEHORZ WKHZULWLQJ
є¬QSߖLVPRVWHDVLO\H[SODLQHGDVDIUR]HQIRUPUHIOHFWLQJDSULPLWLYH
3URWR²:HVW¬6HPLWLFRDWKIRUPXODGHULYLQJIURPDSHULRGSULRUWRWKH
SDUDGLJPDWLFH[WHQVLRQRIWKHFDVHV\VWHPRQWRQRXQVLQWKHFRQ
VWUXFWVWDWH 3URWR:HVW6HPLWLF єD\\¬QDSߖLND%X% єD\QDSߖLND%X%/I6
ULWLFєr¬QDSߖLND ,QDQ\FDVHWKHVLWXDWLRQLVQRW\HWVXIILFLHQWO\FOHDU
IRUH[DPSOHVVXFKDVWKLVRQHWRVHUYHDVHYLGHQFHIRUWKHUHFRJQLWLRQ
RIQHZJUDPPDWLFDOFDWHJRULHVLQ8JDULWLFVXFKDQ´DEVROXWHFDVHµ

6HH)LVFKHU†7KHDVVLPLODWLRQRIWKHYRFDWLYHIXQFWLRQ
WRRQHRIWKHFDVHFDWHJRULHVLVQRWHQWLUHO\XQLIRUPKRZHYHU7KH
PRVWFRPPRQLQϰHFWLRQXVHGIRUWKHYRFDWLYHLVWKHQRPLQDWLYH VHH
\č¬UDПXOX´20DQµ DQGWKHDFFXVDWLYHLVXVHGZKHQWKHYRFDWLYH
SKUDVHLVDFRQVWUXFWFKDLQ WKHKHDGQRXQRIWKHFKDLQLVPDUNHG
ZLWKWKHDFFXVDWLYHM(2%69%8H%\čEQD૛1>>y´26RQRIP\XQFOHµ $IHZ
RWKHUSDWWHUQVVHHPWRKDYHEHHQSUHVHUYHGDVLQ\čUDEEL´2/RUGµ
ZLWKWKHIROORZLQJQRXQDSSDUHQWO\LQWKHJHQLWLYHM# XQOHVVWKLVLVD
´VKRUWHQHGµIRUPRIWKHϮUVWFRPPRQVLQJXODUSURQRPLQDOVXϲ[My2%
DV)LVFKHUVXJJHVWV EXWLQDQ\HYHQWDOOH[DPSOHVVKRZFDVHHQGLQJV

6HH.UDXVYRQ¬6RGHQ†M QRWHKRZHYHUWKDWODWHU
GLDOHFWVVKRZDWHQGHQF\IRUWKHQRPLQDWLYH 

6HHDOUHDG\'LDNRQRIIIRUIXUWKHUGLVFXVVLRQDQGVXE
VHTXHQWELEOLRJUDSK\VHH¬6DVVH0OOHU6DW]LQJHU
DDQG
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

GLSWRWLFLQWKHGXDO>čD\@DQGSOXUDO>ࡃҸ@ DSSHDUVQRWWRKDYHEHHQWKHUHVXOWRIDGLUHFWOLQHDULQKHULWDQFH
IURP3URWR$IURDVLDWLFEXWUDWKHUWKHUHVXOWRILQQRYDWLRQUHDQDO\VLVDQGVXEVHTXHQWDQDORJLFDOH[WHQVLRQDQG
OHYHOLQJ7KHQHZV\VWHPVHHPVDOVRWRKDYHEHHQDFFRPSDQLHGE\DVKLIWLQSHUVSHFWLYHIURPDQHUJDWLYHRULHQWD
WLRQ GLVWLQJXLVKLQJHVVHQWLDOO\I($#!)$DQG(5!)$ WRDQDFFXVDWLYHRULHQWDWLRQ GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ5-(>>($#4(.%01&c!4$%
G7FM%?!-&(.%()"%)6>#)(.%46>I.!>!)$0 %
,QGHHGMXGJLQJIURPWKH DGPLWWHGO\PHDJHU DYDLODEOHGDWDWKHVSUHDGRIWKH´FODVVLFDOµ6HPLWLFV\VWHP
GHVFULEHGDERYH³DQGWKHFRQFRPLWDQWGLVSODFHPHQWRIHDUOLHUYDULDQWV\VWHPV³ZDVDVORZDQGJUDGXDOSUR
FHVV,Q(DVW6HPLWLFZKLFKWHQGHGWRSUHVHUYHPRUHDUFKDLFSDWWHUQVRZLQJWRWKHFRQVHUYDWLYHLQIOXHQFHRI
WKHZULWLQJV\VWHPWKH´FODVVLFDOµ6HPLWLFV\VWHPLVSUHVHQWEXWKDVQRW\HWHQWLUHO\GLVSODFHGWKHYHVWLJHVRI
WKHPRUHDUFKDLFV\VWHPIRXQGRQ  ¬QRXQVXVHGDVSUHGLFDWHVLQQRPLQDOVHQWHQFHV  ¬QRXQVLQWKHFRQVWUXFW
RU´ERXQGµ VWDWHDQG  ¬YRFDWLYHSKUDVHVWRFLWHMXVWDIHZH[DPSOHV,Q:HVW6HPLWLFLQFRQWUDVW UHSUHVHQWHG
E\FODVVLFDO$UDELFDQGOHVVH[SOLFLWO\8JDULWLF LQZKLFKFKURQRORJLFDOO\ODWHUPRUHWKRURXJKO\OHYHOHGVWDJHV
WHQGWREHUHSUHVHQWHGWKHSURFHVVRIDVVLPLODWLRQRIWKHVHWKUHHYHVWLJLDOIRUPVWRWKH´FODVVLFDOµFDVHV\VWHP
ZDVIDUPRUHFRPSOHWHQRPLQDOSUHGLFDWHVFRQVWUXFWIRUPVDQGYRFDWLYHVWHQGWRVKRZDIXOOLQWHJUDWLRQLQWR
WKH´FODVVLFDOµV\VWHP
6KRXOGWKLVJHQHUDORXWOLQHEHFRUUHFWRQHZRXOGKDYHH[SHFWHG8JDULWLFDVDUHODWLYHO\HDUO\PDQLIHVWDWLRQ
RI:HVW6HPLWLFWRVKRZDOHYHORIGHYHORSPHQWPRUHDNLQWR$UDELFQRW$NNDGLDQ:LWKUHVSHFWWRQRPLQDO
SUHGLFDWHVDQGWKHFRQVWUXFWIRUPVRIQRXQVDWOHDVWVXFKDSSHDUVWREHWKHFDVH,WZRXOGEHRGGLIWKHYRFDWLYH
FRQVWUXFWLRQZHUHGLIIHUHQW

.=%&$'%-I×ૠ> IURPb*\:%,,DQGSDUDOOHO
´&RPHWRP\KRXVH2K(I(%૟ࡃPD GLYLQLWLHV µ

.%-ZI@×ૠĚUߙ IURP56 ² b*\:%

3RVVLEO\´2K(I(%૟ࡃPDRIWKH(DUWKµ

X-×ૠ$>%-I×ૠĚUߙ IURP56DQGb*\:%
´<RXDUH KHUHE\ LQYRNHG2K(I(%૟ࡃPDRIWKH(DUWKµ

=0×ૠ%)X>"%×ૠ&=' IURP56b*\:%
´27KURQHRI1LTPDGGX%HEHZDLOHGµ

ĚࠂUE૛ONONVਧ×ૠ਩ IURP56²b*\:%
ĚࠂUE૛ONĚUߙUG
´$IWHU\RXUPDVWHU27KURQH%
$IWHU\RXUPDVWHUGHVFHQG LQWR WKH(DUWKµ

)LJXUH3ODXVLEOHH[DPSOHVRIYRFDWLYHSKUDVHVVSHOOHGZLWKWKH^೓× ೓`ૠ VLJQ@?


7KHUHLVGLVDJUHHPHQWRQWKLVVHH:DOWLVEHUJ6DW]LQJHUD
ERWKZLWKELEOLRJUDSK\ 

,QGHHGWKHSURFHVVZDVQRWHQWLUHO\WKRURXJK7UDFHVRIHDUOLHU
´HUJDWLYHµVWDJHVDUHSHUFHSWLEOHLQVRPH6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVWKHGL
YHUVLW\RIIXQFWLRQVDWWHVWHGIRUWKH6HPLWLFVXIIL[LQJFRQMXJDWLRQLV
RQHVXFKYHVWLJH VHH0OOHU WKHSURQRPLQDOSDUDGLJPLV
DQRWKHU VHH¬6DW]LQJHUEHVSSS² 

$V5REHUW+HW]URQGHPRQVWUDWHGLQWKHV IRUUHIHUHQFHVDQG
GLVFXVVLRQVHH)DEHU² IURPDW\SRORJLFDOSHUVSHFWLYH
FODVVLFDO$UDELFLVPXFKPRUHFORVHO\UHODWHGWRWKH1RUWKZHVW6H
PLWLFEUDQFKWKDQKDGSUHYLRXVO\EHHQUHFRJQL]HG

,QRWKHUZRUGVWKH´FDVHOHVVµVWDWHKDVDOOEXWGLVDSSHDUHGLQHDU
O\:HVW6HPLWLFWKHIRUPVLQTXHVWLRQ QRPLQDOSUHGLFDWHVFRQVWUXFW
IRUPVDQGYRFDWLYHV KDYLQJEHHQVKXIIOHGLQWRZKDWHYHUIRUPDOFDVH
FDWHJRU\RIWKHQHZHUV\VWHPWKDWVHHPHGDSSURSULDWH
@?
7KHILQDOSDVVDJHIROORZVWKHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIGH¬0RRU
VRDOVR7URSSHU LWZDVLQWHUSUHWHGGLIIHUHQWO\LQWKH!"#M
$#6%I-#)4!I0ZKHUHWKHHGLWRUVWRRNWKHSKUDVHO¬NV×ૠ% 69%=7J=F98K8FH6>%
´«¬IURPWKHWKURQH¬«¬JRGRZQµ RQWKHDQDORJ\RIDOH[LFDOO\FRP
SDUDEOHLGLRP <5'.LQWKHVHQVHRI´WRGHVFHQGIURPµ ZKLFK
LVDWWHVWHGHOVHZKHUHLQ8JDULWLFSRHWU\ VHHIRUH[DPSOHWKHSDV
VDJHIURPWKHS(૛.1%3'4.!%Zb*\:¬1*¬²@FLWHGDERYHLQILJ¬ 
VHH¬%RUGUHXLODQG3DUGHH'H¬0RRU·VVXJJHVWLRQLV
SODXVLEOHKRZHYHUVLQFHSRHWLFVWUXFWXUHVRIWKLVW\SH DWULFRORQ
LQZKLFKWKHOLQHVDQGEHJLQLGHQWLFDOO\DQGVKRZJUDPPDWLFDO
HQMDPEPHQWDQGOLQHLVVHPDQWLFDOO\SDUDOOHOWROLQHV² RIWHQ
FRQWDLQYRFDWLYHVDWWKHHQGRIOLQH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% @P

6XFKDSXUHO\WKHRUHWLFDODSSURDFKDVWKLVPXVWREYLRXVO\EHFRQIURQWHGDJDLQVWWKHDYDLODEOHGDWDKRZHYHU
(YHQLIWKH^೓× ೓ૠ`VLJQLVSRO\YDOHQW DQGWKHSHUWLQHQWZULWLQJVWKXVIRUPDOO\DPELJXRXV @O QHYHUWKHOHVVFHUWDLQ
LQIHUHQFHVFDQEHPDGHUHJDUGLQJWKHH[DPSOHVFLWHGKHUH
7KDWDVLQJOHH[SODQDWLRQ UDWKHUWKDQPXOWLSOHH[SODQDWLRQV VKRXOGEHVRXJKWIRUWKHZKROHFODVVRIYRFDWLYH
IRUPV ZKHWKHUVLQJXODURUSOXUDOZKHWKHUSUHFHGHGE\DSDUWLFOH>.2%'HWF@ LVVXJJHVWHGE\WKHFRQVLVWHQF\ZLWK
ZKLFKWKH,,,૟QRXQVVKRZQDERYHDUHZULWWHQZLWKWKH^೓× ೓`ૠ VLJQ
)XUWKHUPRUHWKHIDFWWKDWWKLVVROXWLRQPXVWLQYROYHDYRZHORIVRPHVRUWIROORZLQJWKHQRPLQDOEDVHVHHPV
FOHDUQRWRQO\IRU GXDODQG SOXUDOQRXQV VHHH[DPSOHVVXFKDVO¬GJ\¬ĚࠂUW´2¬)LVKHUPHQRI૟ǴࠂLUDWXµ@:DVZHOODV
US×ૠP´2¬5DSD૟ࡃPD GLYLQLWLHV µDQGUS×ૠ¬ ĚUߙ´2¬5DSD૟ࡃPDRIWKH(DUWKµ@QERWKFLWHGDERYHLQILJ¬ EXWDOVR
IRUQRXQVLQWKHVLQJXODU VHHH[DPSOHVVXFKDV\¬\PP´2¬<DPPXµ@<DQGWKHYDULRXVRWKHUYRFDWLYHIRUPVZLWK
DWWDFKHGSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVVXFKDVXૠ >'´2P\0RWKHUµ@R 
7KHOLNHO\H[LVWHQFHRIYRZHOOHVVIRUPVEHLQJWKXVH[FOXGHGWKHRQO\VLQJOHH[SODQDWLRQDYDLODEOHIRUDOORI
WKHIRUPVLVWKHK\SRWKHVLVDFFRUGLQJWRZKLFKDOOQRXQVDQGQRXQSKUDVHVLQWKHYRFDWLYHIXQFWLRQLQ8JDULWLF
ZHUHIRUPDOO\PDUNHGE\DW\SHRILQIOHFWLRQDOYRZHORWKHUZLVHW\SLFDORIWKH´JHQLWLYHµ RUIRUWKHGXDODQG
SOXUDOWKH´REOLTXHµ FDVH:KDWLVDGPLWWHGO\XQH[SHFWHGDERXWWKLVH[SODQDWLRQLVWKHIDFWWKDWLQ$UDELFLW
ZDVQRWLQWRWKH´JHQLWLYHµIRUPDOFDWHJRU\WRZKLFKYRFDWLYHSKUDVHVZHUHDVVLPLODWHGEXWUDWKHUWKHQRPLQDWLYH
ZLWKDPLQRUVXEVHWLQWKHDFFXVDWLYH $SSDUHQWO\WKHDQDORJLHVWKDWWULJJHUHGWKHDVVLPLODWLRQRIQRXQVLQWKH
YRFDWLYHIXQFWLRQLQWRRQHRIWKHIRUPDOFDVHFDWHJRULHVZHUHDOZD\VQRWWKHVDPHLQWKHSUHKLVWRULHVRI8JDULWLF
DQGFODVVLFDO$UDELF)RU8JDULWLFDSODXVLEOH´UDWLRQDOHµIRUWKHDQDORJLFDOH[WHQVLRQRIWKHJHQLWLYHREOLTXH
FDVHDVWKHEDVLFPDUNHURIYRFDWLYHIXQFWLRQPD\EHIRXQGLQWKHRFFDVLRQDOYRFDWLYHXVDJHRIWKHSUHSRVLWLRQ.@@%
(YHQLIZHDGPLWZLWKPDQ\DXWKRUVWKDWWKHUHH[LVWHGDYRFDWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQ3URWR6HPLWLFWKDWFDUULHG
QRFDVHYRZHOWKHXQLIRUPLW\RIWKHDOSKDEHWLFGDWDVXJJHVWVWKDWE\WKHIRXUWHHQWK²WKLUWHHQWKFHQWXULHVᄽᅐ2%
WKLVDQFLHQWXVDJHKDGGLVDSSHDUHGIURP WKH 8JDULWLF EUDQFKRI:HVW6HPLWLF 7KHROGHUFRQVWUXFWLRQZLWKRXW
DFDVHYRZHOVHHPVWRKDYHEHHQUHSODFHGE\DQDQDORJLFDOH[WHQVLRQRIWKHJHQLWLYHREOLTXHFDVH

"7EE@4>&
2IWKHNQRZQH[DPSOHVRI8JDULWLFQRXQVUHSUHVHQWHGJUDSKLFDOO\E\VSHOOLQJV LQHLWKHUV\OODELFRUDOSKDEHWLF
VFULSW WKDWVXJJHVWWKHDEVHQFHRIDFDVHYRZHOHVVHQWLDOO\WZRGLIIHUHQWOLQHVRILQWHUSUHWDWLRQDUHSRVVLEOH
(LWKHUWKHDEVHQFHRIDFDVHYRZHOLV5!)1#)! WKHVSHOOLQJLQTXHVWLRQVWKXVEHLQJVXSHUILFLDOO\VWUDLJKWIRUZDUG
LQWHUPVRIWKHLULQWHUSUHWDWLRQ RUDEVHQFHLVRQO\(II(-!)$EHLQJWKHUHVXOWRIFHUWDLQJUDSKLFFRQYHQWLRQV
HPSOR\HGE\WKHVFULEHVRI8JDULW*LYHQWKHHYLGHQFHIRUWKHSURGXFWLYLW\RIWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPVXUYH\HG
LQWKLVDUWLFOH·VLQWURGXFWLRQFRPPRQVHQVHZRXOGVXJJHVWVHWWLQJDVLGHWKHILUVWOLQHRIH[SODQDWLRQVLQFHVXFK
DVROXWLRQZRXOGLQWURGXFHPRUHSUREOHPVLQWRDQDWWHPSWHGV\QWKHVLVRQWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPWKDQWKRVHLW
SUHWHQGVWRVROYHDQGLQVWHDGIDYRULQJWKHVHFRQGOLQHRIH[SODQDWLRQ ZKHUHVXFKDOWHUQDWLYHH[SODQDWLRQVDUH
SRVVLEOHDQGSURYLGHGWKDWSODXVLEOHHYLGHQFHIRUVXFKH[LVWV 
)RU8JDULWLFQRXQVLQV\OODELFVFULSWWZRVXFKJUDSKLFFRQYHQWLRQVPXVWEHFRQVLGHUHGSODXVLEOHRQWKHEDVLV
RISUHVHQWGDWD  ¬VRPH8JDULWLFZRUGVDUHUHSUHVHQWHGLQPRUSKRORJLFDOSDWWHUQVLQDSSURSULDWHIRU8JDULWLFEXW
DSSURSULDWHIRU$NNDGLDQ ´$NNDGLDQL]LQJµIRUPV WKHUHDVRQIRUWKLVSUREDEO\EHLQJWKHFXOWXUDOSUHVWLJHRIWKH
ODWWHUDQG  ¬VRPH8JDULWLFZRUGVDUHZULWWHQLQDEEUHYLDWHGIRUPXVXDOO\DFFRUGLQJWRVRPHSULQFLSOHIDPLOLDU

@O
 7KH SKUDVH NV×ૠ¬ QTPG VHH DERYH ILJ¬   LV RQH VXFK H[DPSOH
VHH¬7D\ORU ,IRQHDGRSWVDYRFDWLYHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQIRUWKLV
QRXQSKUDVH ´27KURQHRI1LTPDGGXµ RQHPXVWFRQFOXGHHLWKHU
 ¬WKDWWKHVLJQ^೓× ೓ૠ `PXVWKHUHEHUHDGZLWKWKHYDOXH૟LDQGWKDW
WKHYRFDWLYHIXQFWLRQLQ8JDULWLFZDVPDUNHGZLWKVRPHWKLQJUH
VHPEOLQJWKHJHQLWLYHFDVHYRZHORU  ¬WKDWWKHVLJQ^೓× ೓`ૠ PXVWKHUH
EHUHDGDVGHQRWLQJV\OODEOHILQDO૟DQGWKDWYRFDWLYHIXQFWLRQLQ
8JDULWLFZDVPDUNHGE\WKHDEVHQFHRIDFDVHYRZHO
@:
%$JJ%b*\:¬¬9,¬ DQGFRPSDUDEOHSDVVDJHV WKHYRFDWLYHKHUH
LVSUREDEO\LQWKHGXDODVLVDSSURSULDWHIRUDGGUHVVLQJWKHSDLURI
PHVVHQJHUV+DGWKHIRUPEHHQZLWKRXWDILQDOYRZHOWKH^೓\೓`ZRXOG
OLNHO\QRWKDYHEHHQZULWWHQ
@Q
$V7URSSHU  KDVH[SODLQHGLQWKHVHSOXUDOIRUPVWKH
QRPLQDOEDVHZDVIROORZHGE\DYRZHO PDUNLQJJHQGHUQXPEHUDQG
FDVH ,QWKHSKUDVHON¬EW\¬US×ૠPIRUH[DPSOHWKHUHZDVFOHDUO\DFDVH
YRZHOSUHVHQWLQWKLVIRUPEHWZHHQWKHQRPLQDOEDVH-(I(૟MDQGWKH
G8H6>%M>(PRUSKHPHPDUNLQJWKH´QRQERXQGµVWDWH
@<
%$JJ%b*\:¬¬,¬+DGWKHQRXQ'> j'(>>M EHHQYRZHOOHVVRQH
ZRQGHUVZK\WKHIROORZLQJHQFOLWLFM>VKRXOGKDYHEHHQZULWWHQ
VHSDUDWHO\
@R
6HHWKHIRUPVFLWHGE\7URSSHU3DUGHH  
KDVDUJXHGWKDW´WKHUHLVQRHYLGHQFHWKDWSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVZHUH
DWWDFKHGWR]HURHQGLQJIRUPVµ

6HHDOUHDG\%RUGUHXLODQG3DUGHH3DUGHH²

 oi.uchicago.edu

% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

WRWKH8JDULWLFVFULEHVIURPWKHLUVWXG\RI0HVRSRWDPLDQVFULEDOWUDGLWLRQDQGWKHQH[WHQGHGE\DQDORJ\WRWKH
8JDULWLFIRUP)RU8JDULWLFQRXQVLQDOSKDEHWLFVFULSWWKHJUDSKLFFRQYHQWLRQLQYROYHGLVWKHSRO\YDOHQF\RIWKH
^೓× ೓`ૠ VLJQVLQFHSODXVLEOHVROXWLRQVDUHDYDLODEOHWKDWGRQRWLQYROYHSRVLWLQJWKHH[LVWHQFHRIFDVHOHVVFRPPRQ
QRXQVWKHVHRXJKWWREHIDYRUHG

'@=;&)45A?;E&UG&R(6693952@?T&'@=;=
7KH´FODVVLFDOµ6HPLWLFFDVHV\VWHPDVUHFRQVWUXFWHGHVVHQWLDOO\RQWKHEDVLVRI$UDELF$NNDGLDQDQGOHVV
GLUHFWO\8JDULWLF VHHDERYHILJ¬ FRQVLVWVRIWZRLQIOHFWLRQDOFDWHJRULHVIRUGXDODQGSOXUDOQRXQV GLVWLQ
JXLVKLQJ5-(>>($#4(.%01&c!4$DQG?!-&(.l)6>#)(.%46>I.!>!)$ DQGWKUHHIRUVLQJXODUQRXQV LQZKLFK?!-&(.%DQG%
)6>#)(.%46>I.!>!)$0DUHIXUWKHUIRUPDOO\GLVWLQJXLVKHG %HJLQQLQJLQWKHPLGWZHQWLHWKFHQWXU\KRZHYHUDQG
HVSHFLDOO\LQGLVFXVVLRQVLQYROYLQJ$NNDGLDQJUDPPDUWZRDGGLWLRQDOFDVHVFDPHRIWHQWREHSRVLWHGIRU3URWR
6HPLWLFD´WHUPLQDWLYHµFDVHIRUPDOO\PDUNHG LQ$NNDGLDQDWOHDVW E\WKHVXIIL[M#kDQGD´ORFDWLYHµFDVHIRU
PDOO\PDUNHG DJDLQLQ$NNDGLDQ E\M1 >  WKLVPRUSKHPHZRXOGWKXVKDYHRIWHQEHHQIRUPDOO\LGHQWLFDOZLWK
WKDWRIWKH´QRPLQDWLYHµFDVHLQ$NNDGLDQ @P7KHWKLUGFDVH´SUREOHPµDGGUHVVHGLQWKLVDUWLFOHLVWKHSRWHQWLDO
H[LVWHQFHRIWKHVHWZR´DGGLWLRQDOµFDVHVLQ8JDULWLFSRVVLELOLWLHVWKDWPXVWEHWDNHQVHULRXVO\LQOLJKWRIWKHIDFW
WKDW7URSSHUGHYRWHGVL[WHHQSDJHVWRWKHPLQKLV\5(-#$#04+!%D-(>>($#=7KHWKHRUHWLFDOEDVHVHPSOR\HGKHUH
IRUHYDOXDWLQJWKHVHSRVVLELOLWLHVZLOOEHGHULYHGIURPWKHIROORZLQJWZRSUHPLVHV
 ¬/$%#0%10!:1.%$6%"#0$#)51#0+%4(0!0%:-6>%6$+!-%$'I!0%6:%I60$I60#$#6)(.%!.!>!)$0&RPSDUDWLYHVWXG\RIWKHODQJXDJHVRI
WKH$IURDVLDWLFIDPLO\VXJJHVWVWKDWWKHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRI3URWR6HPLWLFFDVHVPXVWWRDFHUWDLQH[WHQWEHOLQNHG
ZLWKWKHVWXG\RIYDULRXVDGSRVLWLRQDOV\VWHPV SUHSRVLWLRQVDQGSRVWSRVLWLRQV 3HUPXWDWLRQVRQWKHGLVWULEX
WLRQRIWKHVHWKUHHSKHQRPHQD FDVHVSUHSRVLWLRQVDQGSRVWSRVLWLRQV HYROYHGLQWKHGLIIHUHQWODQJXDJHIDPLOLHV
DVGLIIHUHQWVWUDWHJLHVIRUPDUNLQJWKHPDMRUV\QWDFWLFDQGVHPDQWLFIXQFWLRQVRIQRXQSKUDVHVZLWKLQXWWHUDQFHV
,QGHHGWUDFHVRIDOOWKUHHRIWKHVHVWUDWHJLHV FDVHVSUHSRVLWLRQVSRVWSRVLWLRQV PD\HYHQEHIRXQGLQ8JDULWLF

kĚ\GNߖPP IURPWKHb#-$(%*!]$2%b*\:,,²
´/LIW\RXUKDQGVLQWKHGLUHFWLRQRIWKHKHDYHQVµ

)kĚਧ'਩"+%k>>+ IURPWKHb#-$(%*!]$2%b*\:,9²
´+HOLIWHGKLVKDQGVLQWKHGLUHFWLRQRIWKHKHDYHQVµ

U)kĚ\GKOk>> 81$77(67('
´+HOLIWHGKLVKDQGVLQWKHGLUHFWLRQRIWKHKHDYHQVµ

)LJXUH7KUHHSRVVLEOHPRUSKRV\QWDFWLFVWUDWHJLHVIRUH[SUHVVLQJ´WHUPLQDWLYHµQXDQFHV

$SSDUHQWO\DWDUDWKHUHDUO\VWDJHLQWKHGHYHORSPHQWRI6HPLWLFWKHSURFHVVHVRIJUDPPDWLFDOL]DWLRQDQDORJL
FDOH[WHQVLRQDQGVXEVHTXHQWOHYHOLQJKHDYLO\IDYRUHGWKHLQFUHDVLQJSURGXFWLYLW\RIWKHFDVHDQGSUHSRVLWLRQDO

@@
3DUGHH²,WLVQRWHQWLUHO\FHUWDLQWKDWWKHYRFDWLYH YHUELDOWHUPLQDWLYHQXDQFHLVSUHVXPDEO\H[SUHVVHGE\WKHREOLTXH
SDUWLFOH.LVLGHQWLFDOZLWKWKHSUHSRVLWLRQ. VHH¬+XHKQHUJDUG FDVHLQIOHFWLRQRI ߖDPҸPD 7KHEURDGUDQJHRIIXQFWLRQVVXEVXPHG
7HVWHQ²DQG7URSSHU¬ 1RSUHQRP XQGHUWKLVLQIOHFWLRQDOFDWHJRU\ WKHDFFXVDWLYHREOLTXHFDVH KRZ
LQDOSDUWLFOHVRWKHUWKDQWKHSUHSRVLWLRQ.DUH\HWFHUWDLQO\NQRZQ HYHUQRGRXEWHQFRXUDJHGWKHGHYHORSPHQWDQGRUSUHVHUYDWLRQRI
IRU8JDULWLFKRZHYHU PRUHKLJKO\PDUNHGIRUPXODWLRQVVXFKDVWKHVHFRQG k>>+ DQG

6HHDERYHQRWH¬ WKLUG O¬ߖPP H[DPSOHVFLWHGDERYH2IWKHVHWZRKRZHYHULWZDV
@P
6HH¬YRQ¬6RGHQ²<RXQJ6SHLVHU*HOE WKHSUHSRVLWLRQDOVWUDWHJ\WKDWEHFDPHWKHPRVWZLGHVSUHDGLQWKH
²0RVFDWL%JK%6>L²'LDNRQRII²*HOE HQGSRVWSRVLWLRQVKDYHRQO\EHHQSUHVHUYHGLQ8JDULWLFLQLVRODWHG
² OH[LFDOL]HGLQVWDQFHV7KHWKLUGSKUDVH O¬ߖPP E\WKHZD\LVXQDW
WHVWHGDVVXFKEXWZDVYHU\SUREDEO\JUDPPDWLFDOLQ8JDULWLFLQ

7URSSHU²
OLJKWRIRWKHU´WHUPLQDWLYHµXVDJHVRIWKHSUHSRVLWLRQ.ZLWKYHUEV

7KH&XVKLWLFGDWDDUHHVSHFLDOO\LPSRUWDQWVHH6DVVH²
LQYROYLQJPRYHPHQWDVIRUH[DPSOH\TOOĚUߙ´+HIDOOVWRWKHJURXQGµ

,QDSSURSULDWHFRQWH[WVDGYHUELDOQXDQFHVFRXOGEHPDUNHGE\ 8H%b*\:¬¬,9¬²DQG૛QWOEWKWPТ\Q´૛<)($1JRHVWRKHUKRXVHµLQ
WKHDFFXVDWLYHREOLTXHFDVHDVLQWKHILUVWH[DPSOH ZKHUHWKHDG b*\:¬¬,,¬ VHH7URSSHU 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% 

V\VWHPVDQGDWWKHVDPHWLPHOHGWRDJUHDWO\UHGXFHGXVDJHRISRVWSRVLWLRQDOV\VWHPVXOWLPDWHO\UHVXOWLQJLQ
WKHKLVWRULFDOO\DWWHVWHGVWDJHVLQZKLFKSRVWSRVLWLRQVDUHJHQHUDOO\OLPLWHGWRDIHZLVRODWHGIUR]HQIRUPV,WLV
WKXVWKHRUHWLFDOO\SRVVLEOHWKDWWKHSXWDWLYH´DGGLWLRQDOµFDVHVXQGHUGLVFXVVLRQKHUHKDGQRWLQIDFWEHHQLQWH
JUDWHGDVSURGXFWLYHHOHPHQWVRIDFDVHV\VWHPRILQIOHFWLRQDOFDWHJRULHV ZKHWKHULQ3URWR6HPLWLFLQ8JDULWLF
RUDQ\ZKHUHLQEHWZHHQ EXWZHUHLQVWHDGIUR]HQOH[LFDOL]HGSRVWSRVLWLRQDOHOHPHQWV
 ¬/$%#0%I600#&.!%$6%"#0$#)51#0+%4(0!0%:-6>%^:-6G!)`%I60$I60#$#6)0$VDQLQIOHFWLRQDOFDWHJRU\FDVHPDUNHUVPD\EH
H[SHFWHGWREHIRXQGLQFRPSOHPHQWDU\GLVWULEXWLRQ,QRWKHUZRUGVLIDJLYHQQRXQLQWKHUROHRIJUDPPDWLFDO
VXEMHFWIRUH[DPSOHLVPDUNHGZLWKWKH´QRPLQDWLYHµFDVHYRZHOM1WKHQE\GHILQLWLRQLWLVQRWPDUNHGZLWK
WKHDFFXVDWLYHYRZHOM(RUWKHJHQLWLYHM#WKHSUHVHQFHRIRQHFDVHYRZHOH[FOXGHVWKHSRVVLELOLW\WKDWDQRWKHULV
SUHVHQW7KXVLIWKH´WHUPLQDWLYHµDQG´ORFDWLYHµVXIIL[HVDUHLQGHHGFDVHVRQHZRXOGH[SHFWWKHPWRDSSHDULQ
FRPSOHPHQWDU\GLVWULEXWLRQZLWKRWKHULQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHV)XUWKHUPRUHLQWHUPVRIPRUSKRORJ\WKHVHTXHQWLDO
RUGHULQJRIFDVHPRUSKHPHVLVTXLWHUHJXODUDQGFRQVLVWHQWLQ6HPLWLF6KRXOGWKH´WHUPLQDWLYHµRU´ORFDWLYHµ
VXIIL[HVVKRZSRVLWLRQDOGLVWULEXWLRQVLQFRQVLVWHQWZLWKWKHQRUPDO´FDVHVORWµWKLVZRXOGLPSO\WKDWWKH\KDG
QRWEHHQDVVLPLODWHGDVIXOO\SURGXFWLYHLQIOHFWLRQDOFDWHJRULHVLQWKHFDVHV\VWHP

(&R1;4E92@39C;T&'@=;&92&/<@49398V
7KHUHLVOLWWOHGRXEWDERXWWKHH[LVWHQFHLQ8JDULWLFRIDSRVWSRVLWLYHSDUWLFOHDWWDFKHGWRQRXQSKUDVHVZULW
KJH%M+ZKLFKIXQFWLRQVDGYHUELDOO\PRVWRIWHQVSHFLILFDOO\LQDORFDWLYHRUWHUPLQDWLYHVHQVH:KDW#0LQGRXEW
LVZKHWKHUWKLVSDUWLFOHLVDFDVHHQGLQJRUUDWKHUVRPHRWKHUW\SHRISRVWSRVLWLRQDOHOHPHQW5HJDUGLQJWKHSRV
VLELOLW\RIGLVWLQJXLVKLQJLQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHVIURPRWKHUW\SHVRISRVWSRVLWLRQDOHOHPHQWVWZRW\SHVRIDUJXPHQWV
VXJJHVWWKDW8JDULWLFDGYHUELDOM+LVQRWDFDVH  ¬LQQHU8JDULWLFPRUSKRORJLFDOGDWDDQG  ¬FRPSDUDWLYH6HPLWLF
DQG$IURDVLDWLFFRQVLGHUDWLRQV
$UHODWLYHO\ODUJHQXPEHURI FHUWDLQRUSRVVLEOH RFFXUUHQFHVRISRVWSRVLWLYHDGYHUELDOM+H[LVWLQ8JDULWLF%
EXWWKHNH\GDWDDUHWKRVHRFFXUUHQFHVLQZKLFKDGYHUELDOM+LVDWWDFKHGWRDPDVFXOLQHSOXUDO RUGXDO QRXQLQ
WKH´XQERXQGµVWDWH

)kĚਧ'਩"+%k>>+ IURPWKHb#-$(%*!]$2%b*\:,9²
´+HOLIWHGKLVKDQGVLQWKHGLUHFWLRQRIWKHKHDYHQVµ

'kXૠ \ਧ-਩%k>>+ IURPH(9)%()"%H10=2%b*\:²

'-%&%kPP૛ߙU
´+HOLIWV WKHURGDQG FDVWV LW LQWRWKHKHDYHQV%
KHFDVWV LWDW DELUGLQWKHKHDYHQVµ

TOEO૛PkєUZk.>%k>>+ IURP56²b*\:
´&DUU\ P\ FU\WR'DZQDQG'XVN ORFDWHG LQWKHKHDYHQVµ

)LJXUH([DPSOHVRISRVWSRVLWLYHDGYHUELDOM+DWWDFKHGWRPDVFXOLQHSOXUDOQRXQVLQWKH´XQERXQGµVWDWH

(YHQWKRXJKWKHVHRFFXUUHQFHVDOOLQYROYHWKHVDPHQRXQk>>+´WRZDUGLQWKHKHDYHQVµWKH\DUHQHYHUWKH
OHVVVXIILFLHQWWRLOOXVWUDWHWKDWLQ8JDULWLFWKHVHTXHQWLDOSRVLWLRQRISRVWSRVLWLYHDGYHUELDOM+ZDV(:$!-DQGQRW
EHIRUHWKHVORWDWWULEXWHGWRWKHM>(PRUSKHPHZKLFKPDUNV XQ ERXQGQHVV)XUWKHUPRUHLQWKHVORWEHWZHHQ


6HHDOUHDG\6SHLVHU7URSSHU²:LWKLQWKH6HPLWLF
IDPLO\WKHSDUWLFOHLVHW\PRORJLFDOO\UHODWHGWRWKH$NNDGLDQVXIIL[
M#kDQGWRWKH+HEUHZ´+!%.64(.!µXQDFFHQWHGɲ ZULWWHQM+ IRUWKH
FRQGLWLRQHGQDWXUHRIWKLVFRUUHVSRQGHQFHVHH9RLJW²
ZKHQ*HQVOHU>@ZULWHVWKDW´$NNDGLDQk¬:HVW6HPLWLF+%89%
HFK%6%)6->(.VRXQGFRUUHVSRQGHQFHµ P\LWDOLFV KHDSSHDUVWRPHDQ
WKDWWKHFRUUHVSRQGHQFHLVQRW1)46)"#$#6)!" 

6HHWKHGLVFXVVLRQLQ7URSSHU²

6HHDOUHDG\3DUGHH6LQFHWKLVZDVDOVRWKHFDVHLQ
+HEUHZ VHH¬*HOE²´7KHIDFWUHPDLQVWKDW+HEUHZDK%
LVDQHQFOLWLFZKLFKIXQFWLRQVDVDSRVWSRVLWLRQSODFHGDIWHUWKHLQ
IOHFWLRQDOHOHPHQWVµ LWZDVSUREDEO\DIHDWXUHRIFRPPRQ3URWR
1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLF SHUKDSVHYHQPRUHEURDGO\:HVW6HPLWLF DQG
QRWDQLQQHU8JDULWLFLQQRYDWLRQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

WKHQRXQEDVHk(>MDQGWKHERXQGQHVVPDUNHUM>(2%WKHUHZDVFHUWDLQO\DYRZHO HOVHWKH>ZRXOGQRWKDYHEHHQ
ZULWWHQWZLFH DQGWKLVYRZHOLQGXELWDEO\PDUNHGWKHLQIOHFWLRQDOFDWHJRU\RIFDVH DORQJZLWKWKRVHRIJHQGHU
DQGQXPEHU :HUHWKHM+VXIIL[WREHLQWHUSUHWHGDVDJHQXLQHFDVHRQHZRXOGWKHQEHREOLJHGWRFRQFOXGHWKDW
WKHIRUPk>>+FRQWDLQHGQRWRQHEXWWZRFDVHPRUSKHPHVRQHLQWKHH[SHFWHGVORWDQGDVHFRQGRQHIROORZLQJ
WKH¬M>(PRUSKHPH6LQFHLWLVXQVRXQGWRSRVWXODWHWKDWVRPHQRXQVERUHPRUHWKDQRQHFDVHPRUSKHPH WKLV
ZRXOGEHLQFRQVLVWHQWZLWKWKHQRWLRQWKDWFDVHLVDQLQIOHFWLRQDOFDWHJRU\ LWZRXOGDSSHDUWKDWZKDWHYHUWKH
HQFOLWLFM+PRUSKHPHLQH[DPSOHVVXFKDVk>>+PLJKWEHLWZDVQRWD´FDVHµ³WKDWLVWKH8JDULWLDQVGLGQRW
WKHPVHOYHVXQGHUVWDQGRUHPSOR\WKLVVXIIL[LQWKHVDPH PRUSKRV\QWDFWLF ZD\WKDWWKH\HPSOR\HGWKHLQIOHF
WLRQDOFDVHV&ODVVLI\LQJM+DVDFDVHPDUNHUVLPLODUWRRWKHUFDVHPDUNHUVFUHDWHVPRUHSUREOHPVIRUDFRKHUHQW
XQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHFDVHV\VWHPWKDQWKRVHLWSUHWHQGVWRVROYH
7KHFRPSDUDWLYHGDWDIURPZLWKLQWKH6HPLWLFIDPLO\DQGIURP$IURDVLDWLFPRUHJHQHUDOO\DUHFRQVLVWHQWZLWK
WKHFRQFOXVLRQUHDFKHGDERYHRQWKHEDVLVRIWKHLQQHU8JDULWLFHYLGHQFHWKH\VXJJHVWWKHH[LVWHQFHRIDIORDWLQJ
DGSRVLWLRQDOHOHPHQW SHUKDSVSKRQRORJLFDOO\j0DWVRPHYHU\HDUO\VWDJH ZKLFKZRXOGKDYHEHHQKLVWRULFDOO\
DVVLPLODWHGLQWRWKHYDULRXVPRUSKRV\QWDFWLFV\VWHPVRIWKHLQGLYLGXDO6HPLWLF DQG$IURDVLDWLF ODQJXDJHVDV
DSRVWSRVLWLRQRUDVDSUHSRVLWLRQ7KLVDGSRVLWLRQDOSDUWLFOHj0WKXVVHHPVWRKDYHEHHQGLVWLQFWIURPWKHPRUH
SULPLWLYHLQIOHFWLRQDOFDWHJRULHVRIFDVH$V6DVVHKDVSRLQWHGRXWIRUWKH&XVKLWLFIDPLO\VRDOVRIRU6HPLWLFLW
LVRIFRXUVHSRVVLEOHIRUSRVWSRVLWLRQDOHOHPHQWVWREHFRPHVHFRQGDULO\DVVLPLODWHGLQWRFDVHV\VWHPV6XFKD
VHFRQGDU\GHYHORSPHQWPD\H[SODLQZKDWKDSSHQHGLQ(DVW6HPLWLFZKHUHWKHOHYHORISURGXFWLYLW\HYHQWXDOO\
DFTXLUHGE\WKHM#kFDVHOLNHVXIIL[LVUHODWLYHO\KLJK
:HVW6HPLWLFKRZHYHUDSSHDUVQRWWRKDYHDVVLPLODWHGSRVWSRVLWLRQDOM+LQWRWKHLQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHFDWHJR
ULHV:KHUHSUHVHUYHGLWLVLQVWHDGDOH[LFDOL]HGDGYHUELDOSRVWSRVLWLRQDOSDUWLFOHVHSDUDWHIURPWKHLQIOHFWLRQDO
PRUSKHPHV

(&R,58@39C;T&'@=;&92&/<@49398V
7URSSHUKDVDOVRVXJJHVWHGWKHH[LVWHQFHLQ8JDULWLFRIDSURGXFWLYHORFDWLYHFDVHIRUPDOO\PDUNHGDVM17KH
QDWXUHRIWKHHYLGHQFH³¬ERWKLQWHUQDODQGFRPSDUDWLYH¬³ZLWKUHJDUGWRWKLVVXJJHVWLRQLVKHUHUHYLHZHGXQGHU
WKHIROORZLQJUXEULFV
 ¬H#0$#)51#0+#)5%:6->(.%4($!56-#!0%()"%:1)4$#6)(.%4($!56-#!0,QIXOO\FDVHG6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVOLNHFODVVLFDO$UDELF
RU$NNDGLDQVHYHUDOGLVWLQFWVHPDQWLFDQGV\QWDFWLFIXQFWLRQVPD\EHDWWULEXWHGWRDVLQJOHIRUPDOFDVHFDWHJRU\
7RFLWHMXVWRQHH[DPSOHWKHLQIOHFWLRQDOPRUSKHPHM( WKH´DFFXVDWLYHµ PD\EHXVHGWRPDUNDQRXQDVWKH
GLUHFWREMHFWRIDWUDQVLWLYHYHUE WKHVRFDOOHGREMHFWLYHDFFXVDWLYH EXWLWPD\DOVREHXVHGWRPDUNDQRXQZLWK
DQDGYHUELDOQXDQFHVXFKDVORFDWLRQ WKHVRFDOOHGORFDORUGLUHFWLYHDFFXVDWLYH 7KHVHWZR DQGPDQ\RWKHU 
IXQFWLRQVPD\EHGXO\GLVWLQJXLVKHGDQGFDWDORJXHGLQGHVFULSWLYHJUDPPDUV P?EXWHDFKV\QWDFWLFVHPDQWLFIXQF
WLRQLVQRWJHQHUDOO\FRQVLGHUHGDFDVHLQDQGRILWVHOIEXWUDWKHURQHRIVHYHUDOIXQFWLRQVJURXSHGWRJHWKHUXQGHU
DVLQJOHIRUPDOFDVHFDWHJRU\$ORQJWKHVHOLQHVLILQGHHGXQDPELJXRXVH[DPSOHVFDQEHIRXQGRI8JDULWLFQRXQV
WKDWIXQFWLRQDVORFDWLYHVEXWEHDUDFDVHYRZHOM1 DQGWKLVLVIDUIURPFHUWDLQVHHEHORZILJ¬ HYHQWKHQLWLV
VWLOOQRWFOHDUZK\VXFKIRUPVFRQVWLWXWHHYLGHQFHIRUDGLVWLQFW´ORFDWLYHµFDVHRYHUDQGDERYHWKH´QRPLQDWLYHµ


)RUWUDFHVRISUHSRVLWLRQDOHOHPHQWVFRQWDLQLQJWKLVSDUWLFOHLQ6H
PLWLFVHHWKHFRQFLVHVXPPDU\LQ)URQ]DUROL²7KHWKLUG
PLOOHQQLXPH[DPSOHVWKHUHFLWHGLQFOXGH(EODLWHk#)DQG0DULRWH૟Lߖ2%
ERWKPHDQLQJ´WRZDUGLQWHQGHGIRUµWKH૟LߖIRUPLVDOVRDWWHVWHGLQ
WKHWH[WVIURP7HOO%H\GDU RQWKLVSDUWLFOHVHHDOVR*HQVOHU
ZKRDUULYHVDWGLIIHUHQWFRQFOXVLRQV $QFLHQWDQGPRGHUQ6RXWK
6HPLWLFSDUDOOHOVDUHDOVRPHQWLRQHGE\)URQ]DUROL LELG 6DEDLF
k9)҇DGUDPLWLF+M0LQDLF+MDVZHOODVSRVVLEOHFRJQDWHVLQPRGHUQ
6RXWK$UDELF IRUZKLFKVHHDOVR6LPHRQH6HQHOOH :K\
WKLVSUHSRVLWLRQVKRXOGVKRZXSLQ3URWR$NNDGLDQDVj+()( ZULW
WHQ^೓DQD೓` LQVWHDGRIH[SHFWHGjk()(LVDP\VWHU\EXWLQDQ\FDVH
RWKHUVXFKLQFRQVLVWHQFLHVLQWKHKLVWRU\DQGZULWLQJRIWKLVVDPH
KLVWRULFDOSKRQHPH j0 DUHDOVRNQRZQIURP:HVW6HPLWLF VHH¬WKH
FDXVDWLYHVWHPLQ8JDULWLFZLWKSUHSRVHGkMLQVWHDGRI´H[SHFWHGµ
+M 2QWKHFRQGLWLRQHGFRUUHVSRQGHQFHVLQWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKLV
SKRQHPHVHHDERYHQRWH¬%

6DVVH´,I>SUHRUSRVWSRVLWLRQV@DUHIRUPHGDWDOOWKH
QRUPDOSODFHRIWKHDGSRVLWLRQDOHOHPHQWVLVDIWHUWKHQRXQ,QWKH
PDMRULW\RIWKHODQJXDJHJURXSVLQYHVWLJDWHGWKLVKDVOHGWRYDUL
RXVV\VWHPVRIVHFRQGDU\FDVHHQGLQJVWKHSRVWSRVLWLRQDOHOHPHQWV
EHFRPHHQFOLWLFL]HGWRWKHILQDOHOHPHQWVRIWKH13DQGLQDPRUH
DGYDQFHGVWDJHRIJUDPPDWLFDOL]DWLRQWKH\WXUQLQWRVXIIL[HVFRQVWL
WXWLQJSDUWVRIWKHQRPLQDOGHFOHQVLRQSDUDGLJPVµ

6HH¬*HOE²

)RUWKHVHWZR´IXQFWLRQVµRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHLQFODVVLFDO$UDELF
VHHIRUH[DPSOH:ULJKW²²DQG)OHLVFK²
IRUWKHVDPHWZR´IXQFWLRQVµLQ$NNDGLDQVHHYRQ¬6RGHQ
²
P?
7URSSHU ² KDVGRQHWKLVIRUWKHYDULRXVIXQFWLRQVRI
WKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVHLQ8JDULWLFIRUH[DPSOH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% 

FDVHPDUNHGZLWKM1*LYHQWKHLGHQWLW\RIWKHSXWDWLYHIRUPDOPDUNHU M1 LWZRXOGEHPRUHIHDVLEOHWRSRVLWQRW
WZRFDVHV ´VXEMHFWµDQG´ORFDWLYHµ EXWUDWKHUWZRIXQFWLRQVRIDVLQJOHFDVH PO7KHEURDGHU$IURDVLDWLFHYLGHQFH
LQIDYRURIDQHDUO\ SUH6HPLWLF FDVHV\VWHPLQZKLFK´ORFDWLYHµDQG´DJHQWµIXQFWLRQDOFDWHJRULHVZHUHJURXSHG
WRJHWKHUXQGHUDVLQJOHIRUPDOFDVHZRXOGQRWEHLQFRQVLVWHQWZLWKVXFKDYLHZP:
 ¬36>I(-($#?!%!?#"!)4!%:6-%.64($#?!%M1 > $EDVLVIRUVXJJHVWLQJWKHH[LVWHQFHLQ8JDULWLFRID´ORFDWLYHµFDVH
PDUNHGM1FDQQRWEHGHULYHGIURPWKHLQWHUQDO8JDULWLFGDWDZKLFKDUHPHDJHUDQGDPELJXRXV VHHEHORZ VXFK
FDQRQO\EHDUJXHGIURPFRPSDUDWLYHHYLGHQFH)XUWKHUPRUHWKHRQO\6HPLWLFODQJXDJHLQZKLFKWKHORFDWLYH
VXIIL[M1 > LVHYHQPDUJLQDOO\SURGXFWLYHLV$NNDGLDQPQDQGHYHQWKHUHWKHM1 > VXIIL[VKRZVDPRUSKRORJLFDO
GLVWULEXWLRQDWRGGVZLWKZKDWRQHZRXOGH[SHFWIRUDQLQIOHFWLRQDOFDWHJRU\VXFKDVFDVHLWLVSUHVHQWRQQRXQV
LQPRUSKRV\QWDFWLFHQYLURQPHQWVLQZKLFKFDVHHQGLQJVDUHJHQHUDOO\ODFNLQJ LQWKH´ERXQGµVWDWHRULQWKH
´SUHGLFDWLYHµVWDWHIRUH[DPSOH DQGLWFRPELQHVZLWKRWKHUSRVWSRVLWLRQVP<6XFKIHDWXUHVPD\EHH[SODLQHGDV
UHWDLQHGDUFKDLVPVLQKHULWHGIURP$IURDVLDWLFRUDVLQQHU$NNDGLDQGHYHORSPHQWV UHDQDO\VLVLQQRYDWLRQDQG
VXEVHTXHQWDQDORJLFDOH[WHQVLRQ PR³EXWLQHLWKHUFDVHXQOHVVFOHDUDQDORJXHVFDQEHIRXQGLQUHODWHG6HPLWLF
ODQJXDJHVWKH\SUREDEO\RXJKWQRWEHDVVXPHGIRU3URWR:HVW6HPLWLF
2XWVLGHRI$NNDGLDQWKHHYLGHQFHIRUD6HPLWLFORFDWLYHFDVHLQM1 > FRQVLVWVRIDKDQGIXORIOH[LFDOL]HGIRVVLO
IRUPVFXOOHGIURPWKHJUDPPDUVDQGOH[LFDRIYDULRXV6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVEXWLQQRQHRIWKHPFDQORFDWLYHM1 > 
EHVDLGWREHSURGXFWLYH6LQFH8JDULWLFWHQGVWRUHVHPEOHRWKHU:HVW6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVLQWHUPVRIPRUSKRORJ\
DQGV\QWD[IDUPRUHFORVHO\WKDQLWUHVHPEOHV$NNDGLDQWKLVODFNRISURGXFWLYLW\IRUDGYHUELDOM1 > LQDQGRI
LWVHOIUDLVHVFRQVLGHUDEOHGRXEWDERXWWKHD¬SULRULOLNHOLKRRGRIWKHSURGXFWLYLW\RIVXFKDPRUSKHPHLQ8JDULWLF
)LQDOO\WKHFRPSDUDWLYHGDWDJHQHUDOO\FLWHGIRU6HPLWLFDGYHUELDOM1 > DUHH[WUHPHO\KHWHURJHQHRXVIURP
DIRUPDOSRLQWRIYLHZ6RPHIRUPVFRQWDLQPLPDWLRQZKLOHRWKHUVGRQRW6RPHIRUPVVXJJHVWDQXQGHUO\LQJ
KLVWRULFDOO\ORQJࡃYRZHORWKHUVVXJJHVWDQXQGHUO\LQJVKRUW1YRZHODQGVWLOORWKHUVSUHVHUYHQRWUDFHRIDQ1%
YRZHOP@(YHQZLWKLQDVLQJOHJLYHQFRUSXVGLYHUJHQWIRUPVDUHFLWHG$UHWKHVHGLYHUVHGDWDUHPQDQWVRIDVLQJOH
JUDPPDWLFDOSKHQRPHQRQRURIVHYHUDO",VWKH´XQH[SHFWHGµSUHVHQFHRIDYRZHORI1TXDOLW\DWWKHHQGRIDQ
DGYHUELDOIRUPVXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHIRUWKHLULQFOXVLRQLQWKLVFDWHJRU\"*LYHQWKHDWWHVWHGKHWHURJHQHLW\LWPD\
ZHOOEHWKDWVRPHRIWKHFRPSDUDWLYHGDWDDUHJHQXLQHO\IRVVLOL]HGUHPQDQWVRIDQDUFKDLFORFDWLYHM1 > VXIIL[
EXWRWKHUVFRXOGEHWKHUHVXOWRIDQDORJLFDOLQQRYDWLRQVDQGUHDQDO\VLVRUHYHQFKDQFHUHVHPEODQFH6HSDUDWLQJ
WKHILUVWFDWHJRU\RIGDWDIURPWKHRWKHUVRQHPSLULFDOJURXQGVPD\QRWEHSRVVLEOH
 ¬/)$!-)(.%\5(-#$#4%!?#"!)4!%:6-%.64($#?!%M1 > ,QOLJKWRIWKHGLYHUVHFRPSDUDWLYHGDWDLI8JDULWLFKDGLQGHHG
LQKHULWHGDSRVWSRVLWLYHORFDWLYHVXIIL[ ZKHWKHURUQRWWKLVEHFRQVLGHUHGDVDPDUNHURIWKHLQIOHFWLRQDOFDW
HJRU\RIFDVH RQHZRXOGD¬SULRULH[SHFWLWVIRUPDOPDUNLQJWRFRQVLVWRIHLWKHUWKHYRZHO1 ORQJࡃRUVKRUW
1 RUWKHFRQVRQDQW>RUERWK LQWKDWRUGHU $WWHPSWVKDYHEHHQPDGHWRILQGWUDFHVRIORFDWLYHDGYHUELDOM>%
ZKHWKHURUQRWWKLVEHH[SODLQHGDVM1> LQ8JDULWLFPPEXWWKHZLGHYDULHW\RIV\QWDFWLFHQYLURQPHQWVLQZKLFK
RQHHQFRXQWHUVHQFOLWLFM>DORQJZLWKWKHGL]]\LQJQXPEHURISODXVLEOHVHPDQWLFQXDQFHVDWWULEXWDEOHWRWKHVH

PO
7KHKLVWRULFDOXQLW\RIQRPLQDWLYHM1 > DQGORFDWLYHM1 > LVRI
WHQDUJXHGE\FRPSDUDWLYH6HPLWLVWV VHH¬/LSL‫ش‬VNL¬.LHQDVW
 WKRXJKQRWDOODJUHHRQWKLV 0OOHU:DOWLVEHUJ
² 
P:
6HHDOUHDG\'LDNRQRII²DQGWKHUHIHUHQFHVFLWHGDERYH
QRWH¬)RUUHDFWLRQVWRWKHWKHVLVRI:DOWLVEHUJ  IURPDQ$I
URDVLDWLFSHUVSHFWLYHVHH¬6DW]LQJHUDDQG6DW]LQJHU ZLWK
ELEOLRJUDSK\ 
PQ
6HH¬YRQ¬6RGHQ²IRUDGHWDLOHGVXUYH\RIRFFXUUHQFHVRI
DGYHUELDOM1 >  DQGM#k LQ2OG%DE\ORQLDQOLWHUDU\WH[WVVHH¬*URQH
EHUJ²
P<
)RUDVXUYH\RIWKHVHGLIIHUHQFHVVHHHVSHFLDOO\*URQHEHUJ
²DQG%XFFHOODWL²
PR
6LQFHVRPHRIWKHVHIHDWXUHVDUHDOUHDG\SUHVHQWLQ2OG$NNDGLDQ
VHH¬*HOE²+DVVHOEDFK² WKHVHSXWDWLYHLQ
QRYDWLRQVZRXOGKDYHDOUHDG\WDNHQSODFHSULRUWRWKHODWHWKLUGPLO
OHQQLXP

6HH<RXQJDQGIRUDPRUHFRPSUHKHQVLYHVXUYH\RIWKHGDWD
.LHQDVW² WKHODQJXDJHVPHQWLRQHGLQFOXGH$UDELFFODVVL
FDO(WKLRSLF6\ULDF+HEUHZFHUWDLQ2OG6RXWK$UDELDQGLDOHFWV8JD
ULWLF$PDUQD&DQQDQLWHDQGHYHQDSRVVLEOHRFFXUUHQFHLQ(EODLWH 
$VIRUWKHGDWDGHULYHGIURPWKH$PDUQDFRUSXV VHHWKHGLVFXVVLRQ
LQ5DLQH\² WKH\GRQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKH´&DQDDQLWHµ
OLQJXLVWLFVXEVWUDWH³WKH\PLJKWYHU\ZHOOEHLQYHQWHG´$NNDGL
DQL]LQJµIRUPVLPLWDWLQJFHUWDLQDVSHFWVRI$NNDGLDQPRUSKRORJ\
HQFRXQWHUHGE\WKHVFULEHVGXULQJHOHPHQWDU\WUDLQLQJLQ$NNDGLDQ
P@
 2Q WKH TXDQWLW\ RI WKH 1 YRZHO RI WKH ORFDWLYH ORQJ RU VKRUW
*HOE¬ ² VXUYH\VWKHLQFRQVLVWHQFLHVDPRQJERWKWKHFRP
SDUDWLYH6HPLWLFGDWDDQGWKHPRGHUQVFKRODUO\SURSRVDOVKHKLPVHOI
DGPLWV´)RU\HDUV,KDYHEHHQZULWLQJORQJࡃ%8H%ࡃPRIWKH/RFIRU
QRRWKHUUHDVRQWKDQWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHLWIURPLMRIWKH1RPµ S 

)RU6\ULDFIRUH[DPSOHVHH=("1´HQRXJKµ WKH૛ߙčߙčYRZHOLQWKLV
HQYLURQPHQWRXJKWWRFRUUHVSRQGWRKLVWRULFDOORQJ ࡃ EXW>$6>2%
´QHYHUµ WKH૛ߙčߙč¬UZLєčYRZHO>VHH¬0DQQD@SULRUWRWKHIL
H6>%>VXJJHVWVKLVWRULFDOM1>ZLWKVKRUW1 )RUFODVVLFDO$UDELFVHH
+(.1>>(´KLWKHUµEXWED૛GX´DIWHUZDUGVµDQGVRRQ
PP
$SRWHQWLDOH[DPSOHZRXOGEHWKHORFDWLYHDGYHUELDOPUєTWP´IURP
DIDUµLQWKHORFDO8JDULWLFHSLVWRODU\WUDGLWLRQ RQZKLFKVHH+DZ
OH\²ZLWKVHOHFWLYHDQWHULRUELEOLRJUDSK\ )RURWKHU
VXJJHVWHGH[DPSOHVRIORFDWLYHM1>LQ8JDULWLFVHH¬7URSSHU
²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

GLYHUVHFRQVWUXFWLRQVKDVOHGWRDJHQHUDODEDQGRQPHQWRIWKHVXJJHVWLRQWKDWWKHDGYHUELDOVHPDQWLFVDUHWR
EHXQGHUVWRRGDVEHLQJ´HQFRGHGµLQWKHHQFOLWLFSDUWLFOH O??7KXVWKHSUHVHQFHRIHQFOLWLFM>RQDQRXQZLWK
DGYHUELDOPHDQLQJQHHGQRWLQGLFDWHWKHSUHVHQFHRI´ORFDWLYHM1µO?O%
+DGWKHUHH[LVWHGLQ8JDULWLFDORFDWLYHDGYHUELDOVXIIL[ZLWKRXWHQFOLWLFM>WKXVM1DV7URSSHUKDVSUR
SRVHGO?:WKHLQWHUQDOHYLGHQFHIRUVXFKZRXOGQHFHVVDULO\EHOLPLWHGWRWKRVHWKLUG૟QRXQVZULWWHQZLWKWKH^೓Xૠ ೓`
VLJQIRUZKLFKDQRQQRPLQDWLYHIXQFWLRQVHHPVFOHDUIURPWH[WXDOFRQWH[W6XFKIRUPVDUHIHZLQQXPEHUDQG
7URSSHUKDVGLVFXVVHGWKHPDOO+HUHDUHVRPHH[DPSOHV

ТPXૠ  ТP×ૠW IURPWKHS(૟.1%3'4.!2%b*\:,9

´<RXPXVWEHUHDOO\WKLUVW\µ OLW´%HLQJWKLUVW\\RXDUHWKLUVW\µ

ߙEXૠ kIk%ZєOPON IURP56b*\:

´7KHULVLQJRIWKHVXQ KDSSHQV DQG WKHQ WKHNLQJ LV GHVDQFWLILHGµ

Ěђ\P\WQE૛OVäSXૠ \ IURPWKH%D૛OX&\FOH.78:9,²
EQPXૠ P\NO\\
´0\RZQEURWKHUV ZKRP %D૛OXJDYH PH DUHP\VXVWHQDQFH%
0\PRWKHU·VVRQV³ WKH\DUH  ZKDW ,FRQVXPHµ

)LJXUH3RVVLEOHRFFXUUHQFHVRIDGYHUELDOM1%

7KHILUVWH[DPSOH ZLWKТPXૠ VHUYHVWRLOOXVWUDWHWKHVRFDOOHGSDURQRPDVWLFLQILQLWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQ8JD

ULWLFLQZKLFKDILQLWHYHUEDOIRUPLVSUHFHHGHGE\DFRJQDWHYHUEDOQRXQWKH8JDULWLFIRUPVVKRZWKDWWKHYHUEDO
QRXQZDVLQIOHFWHGQRWZLWKWKH´DGYHUELDODFFXVDWLYHµ LQM( EXWUDWKHUZLWKDYRZHORI1TXDOLW\O?Q7KHIDFW
WKDWWKHIURQWHGYHUEDOQRXQLQWKLVSDUWLFXODUFRQVWUXFWLRQFDUULHGDFDVHYRZHORI1TXDOLW\KRZHYHUGRHV
QRWQHFHVVLWDWHRUHYHQMXVWLI\SRVWXODWLQJWKHH[LVWHQFHRIDORFDWLYHFDVH6LQFHWKHORJLFDOVXEMHFWRIWKHQRQ
ILQLWHYHUELVWKHVDPHDVWKDWRIWKHIROORZLQJILQLWHIRUPWKHM1FDVHYRZHOLVEHVWH[SODLQHGDVVLPSO\EHLQJWKH
QRPLQDWLYHFDVHXVHGLQDSSRVLWLRQZLWKWKHJUDPPDWLFDOVXEMHFWRIWKHIROORZLQJILQLWHYHUEDOIRUPO?<%
7KHVHFRQGH[DPSOH ZLWKߙE1ૠ LVUHSUHVHQWDWLYHRIDIRUPXODLFV\QWDJPHPSOR\HGRFFDVLRQDOO\LQWKHODFRQLF
SUHVFULSWLYHVDFULILFLDO´DLGHVPpPRLUHVµUHIOHFWLQJWKHPRQWKWRPRQWKDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIWKHORFDOFXOWO?R%#7F=
SHU·VLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIWKHLQIOHFWLRQDOVXIIL[M1RQWKHQRXQߙEXૠ DVDQH[DPSOHRIORFDWLYHDGYHUELDOq1%89%MF7J%
SODXVLEOHKHUHWKDQLQWKHSUHFHGLQJH[DPSOHVLQFH  ¬YDULDQWZULWLQJVRIWKHV\QWDJPDUHDWWHVWHGLQZKLFKWKH
QRXQLVZULWWHQߙEĚ DQGWKXVDSSDUHQWO\WREHLQWHUSUHWHGDVDQ´DGYHUELDODFFXVDWLYHµ O?@DQGVLQFH  ¬VXFK
RYHUODSPLJKWEHH[SHFWHGVKRXOGWKHUHKDYHH[LVWHGLQ8JDULWLFQRWRQHEXWWZR´DGYHUELDOµFDVHVWKDWZHUH HYHQ
PDUJLQDOO\ SURGXFWLYH(YHQVRKRZHYHUVLQFHWKHH[DPSOHVRIWKLVV\QWDJP ZKHWKHUߙEXૠ %F7%ߙEĚ DSSHDULQWKH
DOPRVWV\QWD[OHVV´DLGHVPpPRLUHVµRIWKHULWXDOFRUSXVWKHUHFDQEHYHU\OLWWOHFHUWDLQW\WKDWDQH[SOLFLWO\

O??
6HH¬3RSHDQG7URSSHU ZLWKUHIHUHQFHV 
O?O
3DUGHH  KDVH[SUHVVHGWKLVFOHDUO\´,WFDQQRWEHDG
PLWWHGWKDW¶(LQH+LOIHEHL,GHQWLILNDWLRQ>GHV/RNDWLYV@LVWGDVKlXILJ
DOV(UZHLWHUXQJGHV/RNEH]HXJWHHQNOLWLVFKHM>·>FLWDWLRQRI7URSSHU
@7KHHQFOLWLFM>LVDWWDFKHGWRDOOSDUWVRIVSHHFKDQGLW
SURYLGHVQRKHOSZKDWHYHULQGLVWLQJXLVKLQJEHWZHHQDQDGYHUELDO
DFFXVDWLYHDQGDSXWDWLYHORFDWLYHµ
O?:
7URSSHU²
O?Q
)RURWKHUH[DPSOHVRIYHUEDOQRXQVRIWKLUG૟URRWVDWWHVWHGLQ
WKLVFRQVWUXFWLRQ DOORIZKLFKDUHZULWWHQZLWK^೓ Xૠ ೓ ` VHH7URSSHU

O?<
6HH7URSSHUZKHUHWKHDPELJXLW\RIIRUPVRIWKLVW\SH
LVH[SOLFLWO\DGPLWWHG ´/RNRGHU1RPµ VHHDOVR3DUGHH
,QGHHGWKHVH8JDULWLFGDWDKDYHKHDYLO\LQIOXHQFHGWKHGLVFXV
VLRQRIWKHSDUDOOHOSKHQRPHQRQLQELEOLFDO+HEUHZVHH¬0H\HU
 ´$QDORJLHQZDKUVFKHLQOLFKHUGD‰HVVLFKKLHUEHLHKHUXPHLQH
YHUEDOQRPLQDOH$SSRVLWLRQKDQGHOWGLHLPLVROLHUWHQ1RPVWHKWµ 
:DOWNHDQG2·&RQQRU
O?R
)RUWKHRFFXUUHQFHVVHH¬7URSSHUDQGHVSHFLDOO\3DUG
HH²IRUSKLORORJLFDOGLVFXVVLRQDQGLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ
VHH¬3DUGHH¬²

7URSSHUVXFKDVROXWLRQLVDOVRLPDJLQHGDVDSRVVLELOLW\
E\3DUGHH ´XQQRPSRUWDQWXQpYHQWXHOVXIIL[HSURSUH
PHQWDGYHUELDOµ 
O?@
56¬² b*\ :¬E૛ߖW૛ߖUKߙEĚߖSߖZєOPON´2QWKH
HOHYHQWK>GD\RIWKHULWH@$WWKHULVLQJRIWKHVXQWKHNLQJ>LV@QR
>ORQJHU@VDQFWLILHGµ VHH3DUGHH²

7KHRFFXUUHQFHVRIWKH´ULVLQJRIWKHVXQµLGLRP ߙE૟%k>k LQ
WKHP\WKRORJLFDOFRUSXV VHH3DUGHH² DUHWKXVXVHIXO
IRUHVWDEOLVKLQJWKHVHPDQWLFVRIWKLVIRUPXODEXWQRWQHFHVVDULO\
IRUHVWDEOLVKLQJWKHSUHFLVHV\QWDFWLFUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQߙEXૠ ¬ ߖSߖ%
RUߙEĚߖSߖ DQGWKHIROORZLQJFODXVHZєOPON DQGZєO\P LQWKH
ULWXDOFRUSXV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% 

DGYHUELDOXVDJHRIߙEXૠ ZDVLQWHQGHGDWDOOWKHV\QWDJPFRXOGVLPSO\LQGLFDWHLQWKHODFRQLFWHOHJUDSKLFVW\OHW\SL
FDORIWKHVHGRFXPHQWVWKDWWKHULVLQJRIWKHVXQZDVIROORZHGE\WKHGHVDQFWLILFDWLRQRIWKHNLQJ RURIWKHGD\ 
*LYHQRXUUHODWLYHLJQRUDQFHRIWKHQLFHWLHVRIULWXDOV\QWD[LQ8JDULWLFWKHQLWVHHPVSUREOHPDWLFWRSODFH
WKHEXUGHQRIWKHH[LVWHQFHRIDORFDWLYHFDVHRQWKHWZRRFFXUUHQFHVRIWKLVIRUPXOD,QGHHGJLYHQWKHSHUYDVLYH
OLVWVWUXFWXUHRIWKLVDQGVLPLODUWH[WVLWLVGLIILFXOWWRH[FOXGHGHILQLWLYHO\WKHOHVVH[RWLFDQDO\VLVRIߙEXૠ %69%DJ8HI%
VLPSO\LQWKHQRPLQDWLYHFDVHDVRQHZRXOGH[SHFWLQDOLVW,QDQ\FDVHIRUWKLVH[DPSOHWRFDUU\ZHLJKWLQD
GLVFXVVLRQRIFDVHLWRXJKWWRRFFXULQDFOHDUXQDPELJXRXVDQGZHOOXQGHUVWRRGV\QWDFWLFHQYLURQPHQWWKLV
LVQRWWKHFDVH
)LQDOO\WKHWKLUGH[DPSOH ZLWK0IXૠ ' KDVDOUHDG\EHHQGLVFXVVHG VHHDERYHILJV¬² O?P%

"7EE@4>&
+DYLQJWKXVDWWHPSWHGWRGLVWLQJXLVKFDVHVIURPSRVWSRVLWLRQVWZRTXHVWLRQVPXVWQRZEHDVNHG  'R
WUDFHVRI DQ HDUO\SRVWSRVLWLRQDOV\VWHP V H[LVWDVIUR]HQYHVWLJDOIRUPVLQ8JDULWLF"7KHDQVZHUDSSHDUVWR
EH´\HVµWKHSRVWSRVLWLYHDGYHUELDOSDUWLFOHM+EHLQJRQHVXFKH[DPSOH  ¬6KRXOGVXFKSRVWSRVLWLRQDOHOHPHQWV
EHFRQVLGHUHGWREH´FDVHVµ"+HUHWKHDQVZHUDSSHDUVWREH´QRµLQOLJKWRIWKHVHTXHQWLDOSRVLWLRQRIDGYHUELDO
M+ DVUHYHDOHGE\WKHRFFXUUHQFHVRQPDVFXOLQHSOXUDOQRXQVLQWKHXQERXQGVWDWH ZKLFKLVQRWFRQVLVWHQWZLWK
WKHVHTXHQWLDOSRVLWLRQRIWKHPDUNHUVRIFDVHDQGRWKHULQIOHFWLRQDOFDWHJRULHV
7KHVLWXDWLRQLVVRPHZKDWGLIIHUHQWIRUWKHSUREOHPRIWKHSURGXFWLYHH[LVWHQFHLQ8JDULWLFRIDORFDWLYHFDVH
PDUNHGM1,QRUGHUWRSRVLWVXFKDWOHDVWVRPHGLUHFWHYLGHQFHLVUHTXLUHG7KHPRVWLPSRUWDQWERG\RIHYLGHQFH
DGYDQFHGWKXVIDUKDVEHHQFRPSDUDWLYHLQQDWXUHDQGHVVHQWLDOO\UHVWULFWHGWR(DVW6HPLWLF $NNDGLDQEHLQJWKH
RQO\RWKHU6HPLWLFODQJXDJHLQZKLFKDGYHUELDOM1Z>@FRPHVFORVHWREHLQJSURGXFWLYH ,WLVWKHRUHWLFDOO\SRVVLEOH
WKDWWKH:HVW6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVSUHVHUYHIRVVLOL]HGDQGOH[LFDOL]HGWUDFHVRIVXFKDVXIIL[EXWWKHVHGDWDDUHKHW
HURJHQHRXVDQGQRWFHUWDLQO\RILGHQWLFDORULJLQ7KHLQQHU8JDULWLFGDWDDUHDOVRRIDPELJXRXVLQWHUSUHWDWLRQDQG
DVVXFKLQVXIILFLHQWWRSRVLWWKHH[LVWHQFHRIDQRWKHUZLVHXQDWWHVWHGLQIOHFWLRQDOFDVH7KHH[LVWHQFHLQ8JDULWLF
RIDSURGXFWLYHORFDWLYHFDVHLQM1WKXVPXVWEHVDLGWREHXQOLNHO\RQSUHVHQWHYLGHQFH

'@=;&)45A?;E&WG&1:;&D9=349A73952&5X&3:;&D9B35398&D;8?;2=952&&
52&"92<7?@4&.572=
2QHRIWKHDSSDUHQWLQFRQJUXLWLHVRIWKH´FODVVLFDOµ6HPLWLFFDVHV\VWHPLVWKHIDFWWKDWWZRIRUPDOLQIOHFWLRQDO
FDVHFDWHJRULHVH[LVWIRUGXDOQRXQVDQGSOXUDOQRXQVEXWWKUHHIRUPDOFDWHJRULHVIRUVLQJXODUQRXQV,QGHHGWKLV
GLVSDULW\KDVOHGVRPHOLQJXLVWVWRVXVSHFWWKDWWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQZDVWKHROGHUPRUH´RULJLQDOµSDWWHUQ
DQGWKHWULSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQDPRUHUHFHQWVHFRQGDU\LQQRYDWLRQOO?6XFKDYLHZZRXOGQRWLQIDFWEHLQFRQVLV
WHQWZLWKVRPHRIWKHSUHOLPLQDU\UHFRQVWUXFWLRQVHPHUJLQJIRUWKHFDVHV\VWHPRI3URWR$IURDVLDWLFZKLFKDOVR
VXJJHVWDGLSWRWLFV\VWHPWKRXJKRIDQHUJDWLYHRULHQWDWLRQHVVHQWLDOO\GLVWLQJXLVKLQJI($#!)$ M( IURP(5!)$%
M1 OOO$GLSWRWLFSDWWHUQVXFKDVWKLVDFFRPSDQLHGE\DJUDGXDOSHUVSHFWLYHVKLIWDZD\IURPHUJDWLYLW\DQGLQ
WKHGLUHFWLRQRIDFFXVDWLYLW\PD\YHU\ZHOOKDYHSURYLGHGWKHWHPSODWHIRUZKDWZRXOGEHFRPHWKH6HPLWLF01&c!4$%
M1 DQG6&c!4$ M( FDVHVRQVLQJXODUQRXQVOO:
0RUHRYHUQRWRQO\LVWKHWULSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQOLPLWHGWRVLQJXODUQRXQVLQDOORIWKH6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVWKDW
SRVVHVVHGSURGXFWLYHFDVHV\VWHPVEXWDOVRLQFODVVLFDO$UDELF³WKH6HPLWLFODQJXDJHIRUZKLFKDSURGXFWLYH
FDVHV\VWHPLVEHVWGRFXPHQWHG¬³LWLVRQO\RQHRIWZRGHFOHQVLRQVIRXQGRQVLQJXODUQRXQVWKHRWKHUGHFOHQVLRQ
EHLQJGLSWRWLFGLVWLQJXLVKLQJWKHUROHVRI01&c!4$% M1 DQG?!-&(.l)6>#)(.%46>I.!>!)$ M( OOQ7KHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKH
WZRGHFOHQVLRQVRQVLQJXODUQRXQVLQFODVVLFDO$UDELFLVHVVHQWLDOO\PRUSKRORJLFDOO\FRQGLWLRQHGOO<%

O?P
,QDGGLWLRQWRWKHSURSRVDOVGLVFXVVHGDERYHDQRWKHUSRVVLEOH
DOWHUQDWLYHV\QWDFWLFLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIĚђ\P\WQE૛.%0IXૠ ' DQGWKHSDU
DOOHOSDVVDJH WKDWGRHVQRWLQWURGXFHWKHSUREOHPRI´DGYHUELDOM1Y%
ZRXOGEHWRGLYLGHWKHSRHWLFOLQHLQWRWZRXWWHUDQFHV´0\ RZQ 
EURWKHUVKDV%D૛OXSURYLGHG IRUPH  7KDWLVZKDW P\VXVWHQDQFH
LVWREH µ
OO?
 6HH .XU\‫ן‬RZLF]   *HOE  ² 5DELQ  
.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]
OOO
'LDNRQRII/LSL‫ش‬VNL²6DW]LQJHUD DQG
VHHDERYHQRWHV² 
OO:
6HHDOUHDG\'LDNRQRII DQGVHHWKHSUHFHHGLQJQRWH 
OOQ
6HH)OHLVFK²)LVFKHU²/DN·LDߖYLOLLQ
FOXGHVDGLVFXVVLRQRIWKHFRPSDUDWLYH6HPLWLFGDWD
OO<
6HHWKHUHIHUHQFHVFLWHGLQWKHSUHFHHGLQJQRWH$IHZH[DPSOHV
RIPRUSKRORJLFDOFODVVHVWKDWVKRZWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQLQWKH
LQGHWHUPLQDWHVWDWH ODFNLQJ૟DO LQFOXGHQRXQVDQGDGMHFWLYHVRI
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

,Q&\UXV*RUGRQGHVFULEHGSRVVLEOHWUDFHVRIVXFKDGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQFHUWDLQW\SHVRISURSHUQRXQV
DW8JDULWOOR7KHDSSDUHQWSURGXFWLYLW\RIWKLVGHFOHQVLRQZDVRQO\IXOO\GHPRQVWUDWHGWZHQW\\HDUVODWHUKRZ
HYHUZKHQ0DULR/LYHUDQLLGHQWLILHG VRPHRI WKHPRUSKRORJLFDOFRQGLWLRQVJRYHUQLQJLWVGLVWULEXWLRQ 7KH
H[LVWHQFHRIVXFKDGHFOHQVLRQLQ8JDULWLF³LQDQGRILWVHOI³ZRXOGVXJJHVWWKHVWURQJOLNHOLKRRGWKDWWKHGLSWRWLF
GHFOHQVLRQRQVLQJXODUQRXQVLQFODVVLFDO$UDELFZDVQRWDQLQQRYDWLRQLQ3URWR$UDELFEXWUDWKHUDQLQKHULWHG
IHDWXUHRIFRQVLGHUDEOHDQWLTXLW\GDWLQJEDFNDWOHDVWWR3URWR:HVW6HPLWLFDQGSHUKDSVHYHQ LQVRPHIRUPRU
DQRWKHU DVIDUDV3URWR$IURDVLDWLF
7KHIRXUWKDQGILQDO´FDVHSUREOHPµDGGUHVVHGLQWKLVDUWLFOHGHDOVZLWKWKHSURGXFWLYLW\DQGGLVWULEXWLRQRI
WKLVGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQVLQJXODUQRXQVLQ8JDULWLF

Y5P&)4567839C;&L@=&3:;&D9B35398&D;8?;2=952&52&"92<7?@4&.572=&92&/<@49398V
7KHGDWDDVVHPEOHGDQGDQDO\]HGE\/LYHUDQLVKRZWKDWDFRQVLGHUDEOHQXPEHURISURSHUQDPHVDSSHDULQJ
LQWKH$NNDGLDQWH[WVIURP5DV¬6KDPUDHPSOR\DFDVHYRZHOLQM( UDWKHUWKDQWKHH[SHFWHGM# LQJHQLWLYHHQYL
URQPHQWV6LQFHVXFKDGHFOHQVLRQLVXQNQRZQLQ$NNDGLDQRQHPD\OHJLWLPDWHO\FRQFOXGHWKDWWKLVIHDWXUHRI
PRUSKRV\QWD[³DGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQVLQJXODUQRXQVWKDWGLVWLQJXLVKHGD01&c!4$FDVH M1 DQGD46>I.!>!)$%
FDVH M( ³PXVWKDYHEHHQGXHWRVXEVWUDWHLQWHUIHUHQFH$VLQFODVVLFDO$UDELFWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKLVGHFOHQVLRQ
LQ8JDULWLFLVDSSDUHQWO\OLPLWHGWRRQO\FHUWDLQFODVVHVRIQRXQV DQGHVSHFLDOO\FHUWDLQFODVVHVRISURSHUQDPHV 
WKRXJKWKHSDUWLFXODUPRUSKRORJLFDOFODVVHVLQYROYHGDUHRQO\UHPRWHO\VLPLODUDQGQRWH[DFWO\WKHVDPHLQ$UD
ELFDQG8JDULWLF,QWKH5DV6KDPUDFRUSXVWKHSURSHUQDPHVWKDWVKRZWUDFHVRIDGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQFRQWDLQ
WKHVXIIL[HVčQ2%̒Q2%ҸQDQGࡃQ7KHIROORZLQJVWDWLVWLFVGHVFULEHWKHSURSRUWLRQDOGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHGLSWRWLF
GHFOHQVLRQLQVXFKHQYLURQPHQWV

3HUVRQDOQDPHVHQGLQJLQčQDIIRUPDWLYHXVHGLQDJHQLWLYHHQYLURQPHQW
čQD čQL čQX H[DPSOHV
3HUVRQDOQDPHVHQGLQJLQ̒QDIIRUPDWLYHXVHGLQDJHQLWLYHHQYLURQPHQW
̒QD ̒QL ³ H[DPSOHV
3HUVRQDOQDPHVHQGLQJLQҸQDIIRUPDWLYHXVHGLQDJHQLWLYHHQYLURQPHQW
ҸQD ҸQL ³ H[DPSOHV
3HUVRQDOQDPHVHQGLQJLQࡃQDIIRUPDWLYHXVHGLQDJHQLWLYHHQYLURQPHQW
ࡃQD ࡃQL ࡃQX H[DPSOHV

)LJXUH7KHSURSRUWLRQDOGLVWULEXWLRQRIJHQLWLYHM(RQFHUWDLQFODVVHVRISHUVRQDOQDPHV LQV\OODELFVFULSW OO@

7KHDPRXQWRIGDWDWKDW/LYHUDQLZDVDEOHWRPDUVKDOLQIDYRURIWKHSURGXFWLYHH[LVWHQFHRIWKHGLSWRWLF
GHFOHQVLRQRQFHUWDLQW\SHVRIVLQJXODUQRXQVLVVLJQLILFDQWDQGPRUHRYHUWKHGDWDKDYHLQFUHDVHGFRQVLGHUDEO\
LQWKHLQWHUYHQLQJ\HDUV,WLVWKXVQRWIHDVLEOHWRGHQ\WKHH[LVWHQFHRIWUDFHVRIVXFKDGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQ
FHUWDLQSHUVRQDOQDPHVLQWKH5DV6KDPUD$NNDGLDQFRUSXV:KDWLVLQGRXEWLVWKHSURGXFWLYLW\DQGGLVWULEXWLRQ
RIWKLVGHFOHQVLRQ

WKHSDWWHUQ૟D47D/ RIWHQ´HODWLYHµ QRXQVRIWKHSDWWHUQVe1*(NM2% 

4X7/čQ2%4X7č/DQG>(e*(NMIHPLQLQHQRXQVHQGLQJLQWKHDIIRU
PDWLYHč૟ VXFKDV૟Dߖ\č૟´WKLQJVµ DQGSURSHUQDPHVRIIRUHLJQ
RULJLQ VXFKDV"#>(kXM´'DPDVFXVµ DQGRUFRPSOH[PRUSKRORJ\
WKDWLVPRUHWKDQWKUHHFRQVRQDQWV DQGRUIHPLQLQHJHQGHU VXFK
69%>(==($M´0HNNDµRU+#)"M´>WKHIHPLQLQHSHUVRQDOQDPH@+LQGµ 
OOR
*RUGRQVHHDOVR*RUGRQ1RXJD\URO[[[YL

/LYHUDQL
OO@
7KHVHGDWDKDYHEHHQDGDSWHGIURP/LYHUDQLDQG7URS
SHU
$SUHOLPLQDU\ DQGQHFHVVDULO\LQFRPSOHWH FRQVLGHUDWLRQRIWKH
GDWD SXEOLVKHG VLQFH WKH PLGV HVVHQWLDOO\1RXJD\URO 
$UQDXGHWDO ZRXOGVXJJHVWWKDWWKHSHUFHQWDJHV
UHVXOWLQJIURP/LYHUDQL·VVWXG\DUHVWLOOEDVLFDOO\YDOLG QRWHDOVRWKH
FRKHUHQF\ZLWKZKLFKWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQLVXVHGRQWKHV\OODELF
PDQXVFULSWVRIWKH\5(-#$#4%b#)5%N#0$VHH¬$UQDXG $PRUH
WKRURXJKUHH[DPLQDWLRQRIDOORIWKHV\OODELFGDWDZLOOEHQHFHVVDU\
HVSHFLDOO\RQFHWKHLPSRUWDQWEDWFKRI$NNDGLDQWH[WVUHFRYHUHGLQ
LVSXEOLVKHG SURYLVLRQDOO\VHH¬0DOEUDQ/DEDWDQG¬ 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% 

5HJDUGLQJSURGXFWLYLW\IRUH[DPSOHHYHQLIWKHSURSRUWLRQRIJHQLWLYHIRUPVLQM(LOOXVWUDWHGDERYHLQILJ
XUH¬LVVLJQLILFDQWDQGPXVWEHWDNHQVHULRXVO\QHYHUWKHOHVVDVLJQLILFDQWSHUFHQWDJH URXJKO\ RIPRUSKR
ORJLFDOO\FRPSDUDEOH RULGHQWLFDO IRUPVRFFDVLRQDOO\VKRZDJHQLWLYHLQ#OOP6XFKYDULDWLRQPLJKWEHLQWHUSUHWHG
DVDQLQGLFDWLRQWKDWWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQVLQJXODUQRXQVZDVQRW RUQRORQJHU IXOO\SURGXFWLYHHYHQLQ
WKRVHSDUWLFXODUPRUSKRORJLFDOFODVVHVIRUZKLFKLWLVEHVWDWWHVWHG+HUHDUHVRPHH[DPSOHV

56 358S ^೓«  #$M$(Mk#%ᅷ%Mᅡዼበዼᅡᇹቨᇀᇹወ  Ç%႐ዝ႕ᇛᇹ႐ᇼᅡ%UDDђEDQL  Ç%႐ዝ႐ᇛᇹ႐%

ᅡዼበዼ.(M(&M)(M(%  Ç%#$M$(M"#)Mk1%  %(M)(%M%(M>(M$(M-1M)(%«೓`
´ $VRIWRGD\૛$PPLࠂWDPUX«.LQJRI8JDULW KHUHE\VHL]HV WKHSURSHUW\NQRZQDV 
¶7KH+RXVHRIS#)#M૟/.1·³ LQFOXGLQJ ¶7KH)LHOGVRIWKH5DєEčQX5LYHU·DQG¶7KH
)LHOGVRI%LQX/DEQk·³DQGKHKHUHE\JUDQWVLWWR૟$PDWDUXQXVY

,ELGOLQH^೓«  ᅷM%ᅡዼበዼᅡᇹቨᇀᇹወ  Ç%႐ዝ႐ᇛᇹ႐ᇼᅡ%UDDђEDQD  Ç%႐ዝ႐ᇛᇹ႐%Mᅡዼበዼ.(M(&M)(%%

 ߙDPLLGDQD  M(M>(M$(M-1M)(%«೓`
´ 7KHSURSHUW\NQRZQDV ¶7KH+RXVHRIS#)#M૟/.1·³ LQFOXGLQJ ¶7KH)LHOGVRI
WKH5DєEčQX5LYHU·DQG¶7KH)LHOGVRI%LQX/DEQk·³LVKHUHE\ OHJDOO\ ERXQGWR
૟<>($(-1)1%V%Y

56 358S ^«  ቨ႐<ሳᇹዝᇹᄽ%M(M>#kM$(>M-#%«೓`

´ +HUHIROORZV WKH6HDORI૛$PPLࠂWDPUXVY

56 358S ^«  ቨ႐<ሳᇹዝᇹᄽ%M(M>#kM$(>M-(%«೓`

´ +HUHIROORZV WKH6HDORI૛$PPLࠂWDPUXVY

)LJXUH*HQLWLYHIRUPVLQM(%F7%8H%M#IRUWKHSURSHUQDPHV5DєEčQXDQG૛$PPLࠂWDPUXS%

7KHILUVWWZRH[DPSOHVDUHGHULYHGIURPWKHVDPHMXULGLFDOGRFXPHQW DQGWKXVPD\EHSUHVXPHGWREHWKH
ZRUNRIWKHVDPHVFULEH WKHJUDPPDWLFDOYDULDWLRQHQFRXQWHUHGOHDGVRQHWRZRQGHUZKDWWKH´VWDQGDUGµJHQL
WLYHIRUPDFWXDOO\ZDVLQWKHORFDOYHUQDFXODUIRUWKHSURSHUQDPH´5DєEčQX 5LYHU µ:DVWKH´VWDQGDUGµJHQLWLYH
GF7M%UDєEčQLDVPLJKWEHH[SHFWHGIURPWKHWULSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQDQGDVDWWHVWHGLQWKHILUVWH[DPSOHRUZDVLW
UDєEčQDDVLQWKHVHFRQGSDVVDJH"
7KHWKLUGDQGIRXUWKH[DPSOHVO:?DUHGHULYHGIURPWZRRWKHUWH[WVLQWKHMXULGLFDOFRUSXVIURPWKHIRUPXODLF
VHDOLGHQWLILFDWLRQFODXVHIUHTXHQWO\DSSHQGHGWRMXULGLFDO DQGHVSHFLDOO\UR\DO DFWVEHDULQJDVHDOLPSUHVVLRQ O:O%
7KH\VKRZWKDWWKLVW\SHRIJUDPPDWLFDOYDULDWLRQZDVSRVVLEOHHYHQDPRQJWKHVFULEHVRIWKHSDODFHFKDQFHU\
VRPHVFULEHVZURWHWKHJHQLWLYHIRUPRIWKHNLQJ·VQDPHZLWKDQM#FDVHYRZHORWKHUVZLWKM(
7KHGHFOHQVLRQDO´IOH[LELOLW\µDWWHVWHGE\WKHVHDQGVLPLODUH[DPSOHVFRXOGEHLQWHUSUHWHGLQOLJKWRIOLQJXLVWLF
HYROXWLRQRQHRIWKHIRUPVFRXOGEHWKH´KLVWRULFDOµIRUPDQGWKHRWKHUD´FRQWHPSRUDU\µIRUPUHIOHFWLQJPRUH
UHFHQWVHFRQGDU\GHYHORSPHQWV,IZHHYRNHWKHZLGHVSUHDGSKHQRPHQRQRIDQDORJLFDOOHYHOLQJLQODQJXDJHHYROX
WLRQRQWKHRQHKDQGDQGWKHDVVXPSWLRQRI´DUFKDLFKHWHURJHQHLW\µRQWKHRWKHUO::LWLVIDLUO\VWUDLJKWIRUZDUG
WRSURSRVHWKDWDWRQHSRLQWSULRUWRWKHIRXUWHHQWKFHQWXU\WKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQZDVIXOO\SURGXFWLYHZLWKLQ
FHUWDLQVSHFLILFPRUSKRORJLFDOFODVVHVRIVLQJXODUQRXQVEXWWKDWRYHUWLPHWKH´VWDQGDUGµWULSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQ
ZDVH[WHQGHGE\DQDORJ\DFURVVWKHSDUDGLJPVHYHQLQWRWKRVHPRUSKRORJLFDOFDWHJRULHVZKLFKZHUHKLVWRULFDOO\
GLSWRWLF7KXVIURPWKLVSHUVSHFWLYHIRUPVOLNH^೓(M)(% M1-M$!M)(೓`O:QZRXOGEH´KLVWRULFDOµRUOHDUQHGVSHOOLQJV
UHIOHFWLQJDQROGHUHVWDEOLVKHGXVDJHEXWVSHOOLQJVOLNH^೓(M)(% M1-M$!M)#೓` O:<ZRXOGUHIOHFWDPRUHFRQWHPSRUDU\
VWDWHRIWKHGHFOHQVLRQVLQWKHYHUQDFXODUODQJXDJHVKRZLQJWKDWWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQZDVLQWKHSURFHVVRI
GLVDSSHDULQJIURPSURGXFWLYHXVH

OOP
6HH/LYHUDQLDQG7URSSHU´1RPLQDOIRUPHQ
>XQG(LJHQQDPHQ@PLW9RUOLHEHIUGLSWRWLVFKH)OH[LRQZHUGHQVSR
UDGLVFKDXFKWULSWRWLVFKIOHNWLHUWµ
O:?
7URSSHU  GUHZDWWHQWLRQWRWKHVH
O:O
0iUTXH]¬5RZH ² FKDUDFWHUL]HVWKLVHOHPHQWDVWKH
´VWDWHPHQWVSHFLI\LQJWKHRZQHURIWKHVHDOµ
O::
)RUDFFHVVLEOHJHQHUDOSUHVHQWDWLRQVRIWKHVHSKHQRPHQDVHH
&DPSEHOO²DQG+HW]URQ
O:Q
6HHIRUH[DPSOH56¬ 562¬QR¬ 56¬ 562¬
QR¬ 56¬ 562¬QR¬ DQG56¬ 562¬QR 
O:<
)RUH[DPSOH56¬ 562¬QR 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

7KLVVFHQDULRLVRQHSRVVLELOLW\IRUH[SODLQLQJWKHYDULDWLRQEXWLWLVQRWWKHRQO\RQH$QRWKHURIWKHVXJJHVWHG
SRVVLELOLWLHVDWWHPSWVWRWDNHDFFRXQWRIWKHIDFWWKDWWKHOLQJXLVWLFHQYLURQPHQWLQZKLFKPRVWRIWKHH[DPSOHV
RFFXULVQRW8JDULWLFEXW$NNDGLDQ,QWKLVOLJKWWKHDSSDUHQWGHFOHQVLRQDO´IOH[LELOLW\µFDQEHHDVLO\H[SODLQHG
DVDQLOOXVLRQWKHJHQLWLYHIRUPVLQM(ZRXOGUHIOHFWWKHIXOO\SURGXFWLYHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQLQ8JDULWLF VLQFHQR
VXFKGHFOHQVLRQLVNQRZQLQVWDQGDUG$NNDGLDQ EXWWKHJHQLWLYHVLQM#ZRXOGVLPSO\UHIOHFW´VWDQGDUGµ$NNDGLDQ
PRUSKRV\QWD[O:R:KHQZULWLQJ$NNDGLDQGRFXPHQWVWKDWFRQWDLQHG´ORFDOµSURSHUQDPHVVRPHVFULEHVVLPSO\
IROORZHGWKHLU´$NNDGLDQµWUDLQLQJDQGHPSOR\HGWKH´VWDQGDUGµJHQLWLYHFDVHHQGLQJLQM#ZKLOHRWKHUVWHQGHG
WRIROORZORFDOGHFOHQVLRQDOKDELWVZLWKWKH8JDULWLFJHQLWLYHLQM(LQSHUWLQHQWPRUSKRORJLFDOFDWHJRULHV,QGHHG
WKHH[LVWHQFHRI´$NNDGLDQLVPVµLQ8JDULWLFWH[WVDQGFRQYHUVHO\RI´8JDULWLFLVPVµLQORFDO$NNDGLDQWH[WVLVZHOO
GRFXPHQWHGDQGLQDQ\FDVHWREHH[SHFWHGLQD´PL[HGµVFULEDOWUDGLWLRQVXFKDVWKDWRI8JDULWWKHIRUPHUVLQFH
0HVRSRWDPLDQVFULEDOWUDGLWLRQVKDGDJUHDWGHDORIFXOWXUDOSUHVWLJHLQWKH/DWH%URQ]H:HVWHUQSHULSKHU\DQG
WKHODWWHUVLQFHWKHORFDOVFULEHVKDGWROHDUQ$NNDGLDQ DORQJZLWKWKH0HVRSRWDPLDQZULWLQJV\VWHP PRUHRU
OHVVDVDIRUHLJQODQJXDJHLQVFKRRO¬³DQGLQWKHFDVHRIPDQ\VFULEHVWKLVHGXFDWLRQZDVSDUWLDODQGLQFRPSOHWH
DQGWKHUHIRUH´HUURUVµFRQGLWLRQHGE\VXEVWUDWHXVDJHDOOWKHPRUHFRPPRQ *LYHQWKHOLPLWHGQDWXUHRIWKHGDWD
DQGHVSHFLDOO\WKHIDFWWKDWQRGDWDIURPWKHDOSKDEHWLFFRUSXVH[LVW LWLVWKLVOLQHRIH[SODQDWLRQWKDWSURYLGHV
WKHVLPSOHVW DQGWKHUHIRUHPRVWSUXGHQW H[SODQDWLRQRIWKHGDWDDQGLVWKXVIDYRUHGKHUH

L:@3&L@=&3:;&D9=349A73952&5X&3:;&D9B35398&D;8?;2=952&52&"92<7?@4&.572=&92&/<@49398V
7KHEDVLFGDWDUHJDUGLQJWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQVLQJXODUQRXQVLQ8JDULWLFKDYHDOUHDG\
EHHQFLWHG VHHDERYHILJ¬ 7KHFRQGLWLRQLQJIDFWRUVJRYHUQLQJWKHXVHRIWKHGLSWRWLFRUWULSWRWLFGHFOHQ
VLRQRQ8JDULWLFVLQJXODUQRXQVVHHPWRKDYHEHHQSDUWO\PRUSKRORJLFDODQGSDUWO\VHPDQWLFWKHPRUSKRORJLFDO
FODVVIRUZKLFKWKHGDWDDUHFOHDUHVWLVWKDWRISHUVRQDOQDPHVFRQWDLQLQJWKHVXIIL[čQ IRUZKLFK/LYHUDQLZDV
DEOHWRVDPSOHQHDUO\WKUHHKXQGUHGRFFXUUHQFHV EXWWKRVHSURSHUQDPHVFRQWDLQLQJVLPLODUW\SHVRIRQRPDVWLF
DIIRUPDWLYHV ̒Q2%ҸQDQGࡃQ VKRXOGYHU\SUREDEO\EHLQFOXGHGDVZHOO0RUHRYHUWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQZDV
DOPRVWFHUWDLQO\QRWOLPLWHGWRWKHVHDQGRQO\WKHVHPRUSKRORJLFDOFDWHJRULHVRISURSHUQDPHVDVWKHIUHTXHQW
SUHVHQFHRIDJHQLWLYHFDVHYRZHOLQM(RQRWKHUW\SHVRISHUVRQDOQDPHVVKRZV)LQDOO\ZKDWHYHUWKHSUHFLVH
GLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQSURSHUQDPHVLQ8JDULWLFPD\KDYHEHHQWKHUHLVFOHDUHYLGHQFHWKDW
WKLVSDUWLFXODUSKHQRPHQRQLVQRWVSHFLILFDOO\8JDULWLFEXWPRUHEURDGO\:HVW6HPLWLF O:@6SHFLDOFDUHPXVW
WKXVEHWDNHQZKHQHYDOXDWLQJWKHLPSOLFDWLRQVRIGLSWRWLFSHUVRQDOQDPHVLQLQWHUQDWLRQDOFRUUHVSRQGHQFH
WKH\PLJKWUHIOHFW8JDULWLFXVDJHEXWWKH\PLJKWDOVRUHIOHFWRWKHUORFDO:HVW6HPLWLFYHUQDFXODUVRWKHUWKDQ
8JDULWLFZKHWKHUWKHVHEHFRQWHPSRUDU\O:PRUDQFLHQWOQ?*LYHQWKHOLPLWHGQDWXUHRIWKHGDWDKRZHYHUDVZHOO
DVWKHSRWHQWLDOGLIILFXOWLHVLQYROYHGLQLQWHUSUHWLQJWKHPOLWWOHPRUHFDQEHVDLGDWSUHVHQW

O:R
 /LYHUDQL   ´DQFKH DOO·LQIOXVVR GHOOD QRUPD DFFDGLFD
VSHFLDOPHQWH SHU DOFXQL VFULELµ  3DUGHH   ´,V LW QRW
SRVVLEOH VLQFH DOO VXFK GDWD FRPH IURP V\OODELF WH[WV WKDW WKH
WULSWRWLFLQIOHFWLRQUHIOHFWVWKHODQJXDJHLQZKLFKWKHWH[WVZHUH
ZULWWHQWKHGLSWRWLFLQIOHFWLRQWKHORFDOODQJXDJH",IWKHGLSWRWLVP
RIQRXQVRIWKHVHW\SHVLVD:HVW6HPLWLFSKHQRPHQRQRQHZRXOG
H[SHFWLWWRLQIOXHQFHWKHXVHRIWKHVHZRUGVLQ$NNDGLDQEXWQRW
QHFHVVDULO\ WKDW LW VKRXOG WRWDOO\ UHSODFH WKH SURSHU $NNDGLDQ
LQIOHFWLRQµ 

6HHWKHH[DPSOHVFLWHGLQ7URSSHUDVZHOODVWKHIROORZ
LQJJHQLWLYH૟(ZULPXˁD ^೓#kM$1%ዝዼM$#% MᅵቨM>1MG(೓`LQ56¬²
358¬S¬ EXWQRPLQDWLYH૟(ZULPXˁX ^೓MᅵቨM>1Mk1೓`LQ56¬
562¬QR¬ JHQLWLYH૟(ZULђXࠃD ^೓ ( M)(% MᅵቨђXࠃD೓ ` LQ56¬
562¬QR¬ EXWQRPLQDWLYH૟(ZULђXࠃX ^೓MᅵቨђXࠃX೓`LQ56¬
562¬QR¬ JHQLWLYHN1..( ^೓ᅷ%M.1M1.M.(೓`LQ56¬YHUVR¬ 358¬
S¬ EXWQRPLQDWLYHN1..1 ^೓1>M>(% M.1M1.M.1೓`LQ56¬358¬
QR¬ L0XFKPRUHZRUNRQWKLVSUREOHPLVQHHGHG VHH¬DOUHDG\+HVV
 EXWJLYHQWKHFHQWUDOLW\RIWKHV\OODELFGDWDWKHFRP
SUHKHQVLYHQHVVRIDQ\VXFKIXWXUHLQYHVWLJDWLRQZLOOGHSHQGRQWKH
SXEOLFDWLRQRIWKHWH[WV VHHDERYHQRWH¬ )RUVRPHYHU\
SURYLVLRQDOWUHDWPHQWVVHHWKHV\OODELFDOO\ZULWWHQQDPHVPDUNHG
DV´ * µLQWKHLQGH[RI*U|QGDKO² VHHDOVRWKHUHPDUNV
RI6LYDQ² 
O:@
2QWKHSUHVHQFHRIWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQSHUVRQDOQDPHVLQ
$NNDGLDQGRFXPHQWVIURPWKH+LWWLWHZRUOGVHHDOUHDG\/LYHUDQL
 ´ËWXWWDYLDLQWHUHVVDQWHQRWDUHFKHDQFKHQHLWHVWLGLSUR
YHQLHQ]DKLWWLWDVLLQFRQWUDQRWDOYROWDGHLQRPLLQčQ2%ҸQHFFFRQ
IOHVVLRQHGLSWRWD$EELDPRFRVuLJHQLWLYL ,¬ #M&#M-(M)(«HFF6HPEUD
FKHODVSLHJD]LRQHGHOIDWWRYDGDFHUFDWDQHOODXWLOL]]D]LRQHGLVFULEL
VHPLWLFLQRUGRFFLGHQWDOLGHSDUWHGHOOHFRUWLKLWWLWHWDOLVFULELHUDQR
IRUVHXWLOL]]DWLSDUWLFRODUPHQWHQHOODFRUULVSRQGHQ]DFRQJOLVWDWL
VLULDQLµ 

7KLVFRXOGDSSO\WRWKHGLSWRWLFLQIOHFWLRQIRXQGRQVRPHRIWKH
SHUVRQDOQDPHVLQWKHFRUUHVSRQGHQFHEHWZHHQKLJKUDQNLQJRIIL
FLDOVIURP(PDUDQG8JDULW VHH¬$UQDXG² MXGJLQJ
IURPWKHUHJXODULW\DQGWRQHRIWKHLUH[FKDQJHVHYHQLIWKHORFDO
(PDULRWH:HVW6HPLWLFYHUQDFXODUGLGQRWSURGXFWLYHO\XVHWKHGLS
WRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQSURSHUQDPHV DQGWKLVLVQRWNQRZQ OHDUQHG
(PDULRWHVOLNH'DJDQE̒OXZHUHSUREDEO\ZHOODZDUHRIWKHIDFWWKDWLQ
8JDULWLFWKHJHQLWLYHIRUPRI૟8UW̒QX IRUH[DPSOH ZDV૟8UW̒QD DQG
HFK%૟8UW̒QL ZKHQVXFKVSHOOLQJVVKRZXSLQOHWWHUVVHQWIURP(PDU
WKH\PD\YHU\ZHOOUHSUHVHQWVXFK´OHDUQHGµZULWLQJVRIWKHORFDO
´8JDULWLDQµIRUPXVHGRXWRIFRXUWHV\
O:P
)HZXQDPELJXRXVWUDFHVRIWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQVLQJXODU
QRXQVDUHGLVFHUQLEOHIRU(PDULRWH VHH¬3HQWLXF²>SRV
VLEOHWUDFHVRQFRPPRQQRXQV@DQG3UX]VLQV]NL²Q¬
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% 

L@=&3:;&D9B35398&D;8?;2=952&52&"92<7?@4&.572=&92&/<@49398&,9E93;6&35&);4=52@?&.@E;=V
7URSSHUZDVSUREDEO\FRUUHFWWRVXJJHVWWKHSURGXFWLYHH[LVWHQFHRIWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQVLQJXODUQRXQV
RWKHUWKDQSURSHUQDPHVOQO7KH8JDULWLFZRUG5DєEčQXKRZHYHULVYHU\SUREDEO\QRWPHUHO\DFRPPRQQRXQ
PHDQLQJ´ZLGH>SODFH@µ EXWWKHSURSHUQDPHRI  ¬RQHRIWKHPDMRUULYHUVLQWKHNLQJGRPRI8JDULW SUREDEO\
WKHPRGHUQ1DKUHO.DEҸU DQGE\H[WHQVLRQ  ¬SDUWRUDOORIWKHDJULFXOWXUDOGLVWULFWRQWKHVXUURXQGLQJIORRG
SODLQOQ:$VVXFKLWGRHVQRWSURYLGHXQDPELJXRXVHYLGHQFHIRUWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQVLQJXODUFRPPRQQRXQV
WKRXJKLWGRHVGHPRQVWUDWHWKDWWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQZDVQRWOLPLWHGWRSHUVRQDOQDPHVEXWDOVRLQFOXGHGRWKHU
W\SHVRISURSHUQDPHVLQWKLVFDVHJHRJUDSKLFDOQDPHVOQQ6LQFHKRZHYHUPRVWRIWKHRWKHUJHRJUDSKLFDOQDPHV
ZLWKLQWKHNLQJGRPRI8JDULWVKRZDWULSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQOQ<LWLVSUREDEOHWKDWWKHVDPHRUVLPLODUPRUSKRORJLFDO
FRQGLWLRQVDSSO\WRWKHSUHVHQFHRIWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQJHRJUDSKLFDOQDPHVDVWKRVHREVHUYHGE\/LYHUDQL
IRUSHUVRQDOQDPHV VHHDERYHILJ¬ 
$PXFKPRUHFRPSHOOLQJSRWHQWLDOH[DPSOHRIWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQDVLQJXODUFRPPRQQRXQLVSURYLGHG
E\WKHV\OODELFZULWLQJVRIWKH8JDULWLFQRXQ VLO૛XSHUKDSV´FOLIIURFNFUHYLFHµOQR6XFKDSRVVLELOLW\LVDOOWKHPRUH
LQWHUHVWLQJVLQFHWKHQRXQLQTXHVWLRQIROORZVWKH4L7/PRUSKRORJLFDOSDWWHUQLQZKLFKWKHVWHPGRHVQRWKDYH
DORQJYRZHOLQWKHILQDOV\OODEOH XQOLNHWKHRQRPDVWLFSDWWHUQVHQGLQJLQ̒Q2%ҸQDQGࡃQGLVFXVVHGDERYH WKXV
VXJJHVWLQJWKHSRVVLELOLW\WKDWWKHPRUSKRORJLFDOFRQGLWLRQVJRYHUQLQJWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQ
RQVLQJXODUQRXQVLQ8JDULWLFZHUHLQIDFWEURDGHUWKDQZKDWKDVEHHQKLWKHUWRLPDJLQHG

56 358S ^೓«  >Ç@႐ዝ႕҅,$Pᅵቨቈዼᇀ႐ቈ%k(%#M)(%႐ዝ႕N%0ÉM#.M(%«೓`

´«>DQG@WKH SURSHUW\NQRZQDV ¶7KH)LHOGVRI૟(ZULˁDUUX·ZKLFKLV VLWXDWHG 
ZLWKLQ WKHODUJHUDJULFXOWXUDODUHDNQRZQDV ¶7KH)LHOGRIWKH&UHYLFH·«µ

,ELGOLQH^೓  >ù@႐ዝ႕҅,$%ᅡዼበዼ%MXUђLLDQDߖ႐ዝ႕N%0ÉM#.M(೓`
´«>DQG@ WKHSURSHUW\NQRZQDV ¶7KH)LHOGVRIS#)1M૟8UђL\čQD·ZKLFKLV VLWXDW
HG ZLWKLQ WKHODUJHUDJULFXOWXUDODUHDNQRZQDV ¶7KH)LHOGRIWKH&UHYLFH·«µ

56 358S ^೓«  #$M$(Mk#%ᅷ%ᇀᇹᄽᇹቈ%  ႐ዝ႕ሳ႐ወ႐ዝ႕%VtLODùJiEEi႐ዝ႕0)\%k(%Mk(M#M

'(%  ùLGGLQߖXDQDM=(.M&!M'(%«೓`
´ $VRIWRGD\1LTPrSD¶«.LQJRI8JDULW KHUHE\VHL]HV WKHSURSHUW\NQRZQ
DV ¶7KH+RXVHRI{(૟#'1·³ ZKLFKLQFOXGHV ¶7KH1HZ+RXVH·¶7KH)LHOGRI
WKH+DUERU·¶7KH)LHOGRIWKH&UHYLFH·DQGDOO RWKHU ILHOGVRI{(૟#'1³DQGKH
KHUHE\JUDQWVLWWRb(.&#'(%VY

56UHFWR 358S ^೓«  >#$M$(M(kM@k#%႐ዝ႕҅,$%0ÉM#.M(%ZV%^EURNHQ «@೓`

´ $VRIWRGD\1LTPrSD¶«.LQJRI8JDULW >KHUHE\VHL@]HV WKHSURSHUW\NQRZQ
DV ¶7KH)LHOGVRIWKH&UHYLFH·>« EURNHQ «@µ

,ELGYHUVR^೓«  >«EURNHQ«@  >«႐ዝ႕҅,$0ÉM#@.M(S%>« EURNHQ «@೓`

´>«¶7KH)LHOGRIWKH&UHYL@FH·>« EURNHQ «@µ

)LJXUH2FFXUUHQFHVRIWKH8JDULWLFZRUG VLO૛X LQ$NNDGLDQWH[WV ZLWKDJHQLWLYHLQM(%

>EULHIRYHUYLHZ@ )RUWKH$PDUQDFRUSXVVHHDOUHDG\/LYHUDQL IRUWKHPRUHUHFHQWVWXG\RI$PRULWHRQRPDVWLFVJHQHUDOO\ ZKHWKHU

²WKHGDWDIRUSHUVRQDOQDPHVDUHYHU\PL[HG DQGGRQRWUHJX
ODUO\VKRZFDVHLQIOHFWLRQ EXWFDQEHFRQYHQLHQWO\FRQVXOWHGLQWKH
WDEOHVRIRFFXUUHQFHVDQGFRPPHQWVSURYLGHGLQ+HVV
OQ?
2QWKHODWWHUQRWHIRUH[DPSOHWKHUHJXODULW\RIWKHGLSWRWLF
GHFOHQVLRQRQWKHUR\DOQDPHVHQGLQJLQWKHčQVXIIL[LQWKH\5(-#$#4%
b#)5%N#0$ WKHRQRPDVWLFWUDGLWLRQUHSUHVHQWHGE\WKLVOLVWLVQRWVR
PXFKORFDO´8JDULWLFµDVLWLVPRUHEURDGO\´$PRULWHµ VHH¬$UQDXG
 RQWKH´$PRULWHµVWUDWXPLQWKHORFDO8JDULWLDQRQRPDVWL
FRQVHHDOVR,VUDHO 2QWKHDSSDUHQWH[LVWHQFHRIDGLSWRWLFGH
FOHQVLRQRQVRPHSURSHUQDPHVLQ´$PRULWHµVHH/LYHUDQL
DQG+XIIPRQ¬² ERWKZLWKDQWHULRUELEOLRJUDSK\ DQG
´$PRULWHµEHDGLDOHFWDODQJXDJHRUDIDPLO\RIODQJXDJHV VHH*HOE
6WUHFN HVSSS² DQG2·&RQQRU1RWHWKDW
WKHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIWKH YDULRXVW\SHVRI FDVHHQGLQJVLVSDUWLFX
ODUO\FRPSOH[ IRUWKHUHDVRQVGHVFULEHGLQ6WUHFN DQG
WKHGDWDUHJDUGLQJDSXWDWLYHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQDUHFRQWURYHUVLDO
LELGS¬ 
OQO
7URSSHU
OQ:
6HHWKHV\QWDJPLQ56¬ 358¬QR¬ JHQHUDOO\XVHGLQ
ORFDOMXULGLFDODFWVIRUIXUWKHUVSHFLI\LQJWKHJHRJUDSKLFDOORFDWLRQ
RIWKHSURSHUWLHVFRQFHUQHG
 oi.uchicago.edu

P?% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

(YHQKHUHKRZHYHULWDSSHDUVPRUHOLNHO\WKDWDOORIWKHSDVVDJHVLQZKLFKWKHZRUGLVDWWHVWHGUHIOHFWQRW
WKHFRPPRQQRXQ´FUHYLFHµ WKRXJKVXFKD8JDULWLFFRPPRQQRXQPD\YHU\ZHOOKDYHH[LVWHG EXWUDWKHUWKH
SURSHUQDPHRIDODUJHUDJULFXOWXUDODUHD ZKRVHQDPHMXVWKDSSHQHGWRFRQWDLQWKLV:HVW6HPLWLFFRPPRQQRXQ 
7KDWWKHQRXQSKUDVH߰DG€¬6LO૛DZDVLQGHHGDSURSHUQDPHVHHPVFOHDUIURPLWVXVDJHLQWKHMXULGLFDOFRUSXVLQ
WKHIRUPXODLFPRWLILQZKLFKWKHSUHFLVHJHRJUDSKLFDOORFDWLRQRIWKHSURSHUW\RIFRQFHUQLQWKHDFWLVVSHFLILHG
WKLVPRWLIKDVWKHIRUP´ 3URSHUW\VXFKDQGVXFK k(%#)( $UHDVXFKDVVXFK µDQGWKDWWKHVHFRQGVORWFRQWDLQV
DSURSHUQDPHLVVKRZQE\WKHIUHTXHQWSUHVHQFHRIYLOODJHQDPHVWKHUH
(YHQJUDQWLQJWKDWWKHSKUDVH߰DG€¬6LO૛DLVDSURSHUQDPHLWLVVWLOOQRWFOHDUZKDWIRUPDODVSHFWVFRQGLWLRQHG
WKHSUHVHQFHRIWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQKHUH3RVVLEO\LWZDVVLPSO\WKHPRUSKRORJLFDOSDWWHUQe#*NMWKDWGLGVR
EXWLWDSSHDUVPRUHOLNHO\WRKDYHEHHQWULJJHUHGLQVWHDGE\WKHFRPSRXQGQDWXUHRIWKHWRSRQ\POQ@%

"7EE@4>
6LQFHWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQRQVLQJXODUQRXQV GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ5-(>>($#4(.%01&c!4$%8H%M1DQG5-(>>($#4(.%
46>I.!>!)$%8H%M( LVRWKHUZLVHXQNQRZQLQVWDQGDUG$NNDGLDQLWVVWDWLVWLFDOO\XQGHQLDEOHSUHVHQFHRQFHUWDLQW\SHV
RISURSHUQRXQVLQWKH$NNDGLDQWH[WVIURP5DV6KDPUDVKRXOGEHH[SODLQHGDVGXHWRV\QWDFWLFLQWHUIHUHQFHRIDQ
XQGHUO\LQJVXEVWUDWHYHUQDFXODU6LQFHKRZHYHUVXFKJHQLWLYHIRUPVLQM( WKLVEHLQJWKHPRVWHDVLO\REVHUYDEOH
GLDJQRVWLFVLJQRIWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQ DUHQRWOLPLWHGWR$NNDGLDQGRFXPHQWVFRPSRVHGORFDOO\DW8JDULWEXW
LQFOXGHDOVRWKRVHFRPSRVHGDWRWKHU:HVWHUQSHULSKHUDOVFULEDOFHQWHUVVXFKDV&DUFKHPLVKDQG҅DWWXߖDWKLV
IHDWXUHRIPRUSKRV\QWD[ZDVSUREDEO\QRWOLPLWHGWR8JDULWLFEXWZDVDOVRIRXQGLQRWKHU:HVW6HPLWLFGLDOHFWV
)LQDOO\WKHV\PPHWU\WKDWPD\EHREVHUYHGZLWKERWKWKHIRUPVDQGWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKLVGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQ
RQVLQJXODUQRXQVLQFODVVLFDO$UDELFVXJJHVWV  ¬WKDWWKLVGHFOHQVLRQZDVDQDUFKDLFIHDWXUHRI3URWR²:HVW
6HPLWLFDQG  WKDWLWZDVSUREDEO\DWOHDVWDVSURGXFWLYHLQ8JDULWLF DQGUHODWHG:HVW6HPLWLFGLDOHFWVRIWKH
VHFRQGPLOOHQQLXPᄽᅐ DVLWZDVLQFODVVLFDO$UDELFLWVWUXHGLVWULEXWLRQLQWKHIRUPHUEHLQJODUJHO\KLGGHQE\
WKHDPELJXLWLHVLQKHUHQWLQWKHFRQWHPSRUDU\ZULWLQJV\VWHPV

'528?7=952=
,QFRQFOXVLRQWKHDYDLODEOHGDWDVXFKDVWKH\DUHDOORZXVWRDIILUPWKHYLWDOLW\DQGSURGXFWLYLW\RIWKH
8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPVLQFHWKHUHLVQRXQDPELJXRXVHYLGHQFHRILWVGHFOLQH,QWKHDEVHQFHRIPRUHDEXQGDQW
DQGH[SOLFLWGDWDKRZHYHUWKHQXPEHURISURGXFWLYHFDVHVLQ8JDULWLFPRUSKRORJ\RXJKWWREHOLPLWHGWRWKUHH
LQWKHVLQJXODU QRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHDQGJHQLWLYH DQGWZRLQWKHGXDODQGSOXUDO QRPLQDWLYHDQGREOLTXH 
7KHH[LVWHQFHRIGLVWLQFWLYH´WHUPLQDWLYHµDQG´ORFDWLYHµFDVHVLQ8JDULWLF³EHWKH\SURGXFWLYHRUYHVWLJLDO³

OQQ
)RUH[DPSOHVRIWKHZULWLQJ^೓ ᇼᅡUDDђEDQD೓`LQJHQLWLYHFRQWH[W
VHH 56¬  358¬  S¬   56¬  358¬  S¬  
56¬ 358¬S¬ 56¬ 358¬QR¬ 56¬YHU
VR¬  358¬QR¬ DQGYHU\SUREDEO\56¬7KHZULWLQJV
RIWKHW\SH^೓ᇼᅡUDDђEDQL೓`DUHPRVWHDVLO\H[SODLQHGDV´$NNDGLDQ
LVPVµ VHHDERYHQRWH¬ 
OQ<
6RYDQ¬6ROGW² WKHGDWDDUHFRPSOH[³WKHDSSDUHQW
H[DPSOHVRIJHQLWLYHIRUPVRIWRSRQ\PVHQGLQJLQDQM(YRZHOUH
IOHFWLQPRVWFDVHVQRWDFDVHYRZHOEXWWKH´SKRQHWLFµZULWLQJRI
WKHFRQWUDFWHGWRSRQ\PLFVXIIL[ č '?  WKXV č\Y%X% k ZKLFKLV
ZULWWHQ´KLVWRULFDOO\µLQDOSKDEHWLF8JDULWLFZLWKWKHILQDO^೓'೓`VHH
YDQ¬6ROGW²
OQR
6RDSSDUHQWO\%R\G XQDYDLODEOHWRPH )RUWKHHW\PR
ORJLFDODUJXPHQWVIRUWKHVHPDQWLFVRIWKLVQRXQVHH+XHKQHUJDUG
,FDQQRWDJUHHZLWK7URSSHU  WKDWWKLVH[DPSOH
LV´QLFKW]ZLQJHQGµ³RUDWOHDVWQRWIRUWKHUHDVRQVKHFLWHV ´6LH
GUIWHHLQH)RUPRKQH)OH[LRQVHQGXQJGDUVWHOOHQµ ³,NQRZRIQR
FOHDUXQDPELJXRXVH[DPSOHVRI8JDULWLF FRPPRQ QRXQVZLWKRXW
FDVHHQGLQJV VHHDERYH´&DVH3UREOHPµ 

 6HH IRU H[DPSOH ^೓ Z ႐@ዝ႕ ¬ ҅,$ % M ђXGiߖL% V% k(% #M)(% /,/ ђXXOGD೓ `
56¬²358¬S¬ ´ WKHSURSHUW\NQRZQDV ¶WKH)LHOGV
RI҅XGDߖL· « ZKLFK LV ORFDWHG  LQ WKH YLFLQLW\ RI WKH YLOODJH RI 
҅XOGkµ DQGPDQ\PRUH WKLVV\QWDJPLVDOVRNQRZQLQDOSKDEHWLF
VFULSWEWĚQQˁU«GEU×ૠߖ ´ WKHSURSHUW\NQRZQDV ¶WKH+RXVHRI
૟$QDQLˁDUUX·¬«ZKLFK LVORFDWHG LQWKH YLFLQLW\RIWKHYLOODJHRI 
K(૟k1µ 56¬²b*\:¬ 
OQ@
,QRWKHUZRUGVRQHPLJKWVSHFXODWHWKDWKDGWKHSXWDWLYHSURSHU
H6MJ%DJJH%MJ7J>E%j7#.૛1LWZRXOGKDYHEHHQGHFOLQHGDVDWULSWRWH
EXWDVDQHOHPHQWLQDFRPSRXQGQDPHWKHHQWLUHQDPHZDVWUHDWHG
DVDGLSWRWH ,WHQGWRDJUHHZLWK7URSSHU´'LHGLSWRWLVFKH
)OH[LRQOl‰WVLFKIHUQHUDXFKEHLJHZLVVHQDQGHUHQ VHP (LJHQQD
PHQYRQNRPSOH[HUHU*HVWDOWQDFKZHLVHQµ )XUWKHUPRUHWKDWFRP
SRXQGSURSHUQDPHV HYHQWKRVHZKLFKFRQWDLQDFRQVWUXFWFKDLQ 
DWWDFKHGWKHLULQIOHFWLRQDOHQGLQJVDWWKHHQGRIWKHFRPSRXQG DQG
QRWRQWKHILUVWHOHPHQWRIWKHFRQVWUXFWFKDLQ LVVKRZQE\JHQWLOLF
IRUPVVXFKDVJW¬PON\P´UHVLGHQWVRIWKH IDUPNQRZQDV ¶3UHVV
RIA1.1==1µ·LQ56¬ b*\:¬ 56¬ b*\:¬ DQG
HOVHZKHUH

6HHWKHUHIHUHQFHVFLWHGDERYHQRWH¬$PRQJWKHVKDUHGGLV
WULEXWLRQDOWUDLWVRIWKHGLSWRWLFGHFOHQVLRQLQFODVVLFDO$UDELFDQG
8JDULWLFDUHLWVSUHVHQFHRQ  FHUWDLQQRXQSDWWHUQVFRQWDLQLQJ
WKHčQVXIIL[ LQFOXGLQJWKHSDWWHUQ4D7/čQ DQG  SURSHUQDPHV
LQFOXGLQJWKRVHRIFRPSOH[PRUSKRORJ\RUIRUHLJQRULJLQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% PO

FDQQRWEHGHPRQVWUDWHGRQSUHVHQWGDWDVXFKLVSRVVLEOHIURPWKHSHUVSHFWLYHRIFRPSDUDWLYH6HPLWLFGDWDEXW
WKHDYDLODEOH8JDULWLFGDWDREOLJHXVWRSURQRXQFHLWLPSUREDEOH)LQDOO\DUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIDGLSWRWLFGHFOHQ
VLRQ QRPLQDWLYHM1DQGREOLTXHM( IRUFHUWDLQFDWHJRULHVRIVLQJXODUQRXQVDQGHVSHFLDOO\SURSHUQDPHVFDQEH
VROLGO\MXVWLILHGE\WKHDYDLODEOHV\OODELFGDWD7KHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKLVGHFOHQVLRQLVXQFHUWDLQKRZHYHUWKRXJK
LWVHHPVWRKDYHEHHQSURGXFWLYHIRUSURSHUQDPHVFRQWDLQLQJWKHVXIIL[HVčQ2%̒Q2%ҸQDQGࡃQ2%FH%=7F=J7%H6MJ9%
RIFRPSOH[PRUSKRORJ\DQGSHUKDSVRQRWKHUPRUSKRORJLFDOFDWHJRULHV
$GYDQFHVLQWKHVWXG\RISRRUO\GRFXPHQWHGDQFLHQWODQJXDJHVOLNH8JDULWLFFRPHRQO\ZLWKWKHDVNLQJRI
NH\TXHVWLRQVRQWKHEDVLVRIUHQHZHGVWXG\RIWKHDYDLODEOHGDWDLGHDOO\UHVXOWLQJLQWKHVXEVHTXHQWSURSRVDORI
LQQRYDWLYHUHVSRQVHV0RUHRYHUVFKRODUVKLSLQVXFKDUHDVLVDOZD\VSURYLVLRQDODSHUSHWXDOO\LQFRPSOHWHGLVFRY
HU\SURFHVV(SLJUDSKHUVDQGJUDPPDULDQVDOLNHNQRZDOOWRRZHOOMXVWKRZGLIILFXOWLWLVWRIRUJHDQHZSDWKDQG
FRUUHVSRQGLQJO\KRZHDV\LWLVWRGRIROORZXSZRUNLQWKHZDNHRIDSLRQHHUWLG\LQJXSGLVFUHSDQFLHVKHUHDQG
WKHUH,QWKLVVHQVH-RVHI7URSSHU·V\5(-#$#04+!%D-(>>($#=UHSUHVHQWVRQHRIWKHPRVWVLJQLILFDQWFRQWULEXWLRQV
WRGDWHIRUWKHVWXG\RI8JDULWLFLQJHQHUDODQGRIWKH8JDULWLFFDVHV\VWHPLQSDUWLFXODUQRWRQO\EHFDXVHRIWKH
DOPRVWFRPSUHKHQVLYHWUHDWPHQWDQGFLWDWLRQRIWKHDYDLODEOHGDWHERWKDOSKDEHWLFDQGV\OODELFEXWDOVRDQG
HVSHFLDOO\EHFDXVHRIWKHJUHDWRULJLQDOLW\RIPDQ\RIWKHSURSRVDOVDGYDQFHGOQP,QGHHG\5(-#$#04+!%D-(>>($#=%89%
DPLOHVWRQHRIVRUWVVXEVHTXHQWJUDPPDWLFDOVWXGLHVZLOOLQHYLWDEO\VWDQGRQLWVVKRXOGHUVWRDFHUWDLQH[WHQW
$VLVWREHH[SHFWHGLQDQ\ZRUNRIJUHDWRULJLQDOLW\KRZHYHUQRWDOOWKHSURSRVLWLRQVLQ\5(-#$#04+!%D-(>>($#=%
DUHFRUUHFW,IRQHLVWRJHQHUDOL]HRQWKHEDVLVRIWKLVVWXG\·VILQGLQJVLPSURYHPHQWVWRWKHSUHVHQWDWLRQRIWKH
FDVHV\VWHPPD\EHPDGHLQWZRZD\V  E\SULYLOHJLQJI-6&(&.!VROXWLRQVRYHUWKRVHZKLFKDUHPHUHO\I600#&.!%
LQVLWXDWLRQVZKHUHVHYHUDODOWHUQDWLYHVDUHDYDLODEOHDQG  E\SD\LQJFORVHDWWHQWLRQWRVXEWOHWLHVDQGDPEL
JXLWLHVLQKHUHQWLQERWKRIWKHZULWLQJV\VWHPVLQXVHDW8JDULW6LQFHDOOWH[WXDOGDWDDUHQRWRIHTXDOYDOXHIRU
SKLORORJLFDOLQWHUSUHWDWLRQWKH\FDQQRWEHPDQLSXODWHGZLWKRXWDVHQVLWLYHFRQVLGHUDWLRQRIWKHFRPSOH[VFULEDO
HQYLURQPHQWLQZKLFKZULWLQJZDVWDXJKWOHDUQHGDQGXVHGDWDQFLHQW8JDULWO<?%

(AA4;C9@3952=
! !"! "#$%&'(!)*+,
! #"$-! .%#/0#123!450%/63!'(7!8'(&'0/#(!)**+!
! @K\!,! 95:;'<05=!)*++
! @K\!>! 95:;'<05=!)*?@
! A8! B#%=7!(:&C%0$!5B!/'C=%/$!%D1'E'/%7!'/!A'$!82'&0'
! A8F!?! G0(':7!%/!'=H!)**)
! A8F!)I! G0(':7!%/!'=H!-@@)
! $%!+! 95:;'<05=!)*>J

+9A?95<4@B:>
$OEULJKW:LOOLDP)
  ´7KH1RUWK&DQDDQLWH(SLFRI૟$O૟r\DQ%D૛DODQG0{WµP61-)(.%6:%$+!%@(.!0$#)!%,-#!)$(.%764#!$'%O:N%
²
$UQDXG'DQLHO
  ´/DFXOWXUHVXPpURDFFDGLHQQHµLQWKHDUWLFOH´5DV6KDPUDµ,Q71II.U>!)$%(1%H#4$#6))(#-!%"!%.(%S#&.!2%
HGLWHGE\-"&RXUWRLVHWDOFROV²3DULV/HWRX]H\ $Qp

OQP
7KHDWWHQWLRQDFFRUGHGWR\5(-#$#04+!%D-(>>($#=E\LWVUHYLHZHUV  7KLV LV UHPLQLVFHQW RI &LYLO·V UHIOHFWLRQV RQ WKH SUREOHPV RI
O<?

LVDPSOHWHVWLPRQ\QRWRQO\WRWKHGLIILFXOW\RIWKHWDVNEXWDOVRWR 6XPHULDQJUDPPDU VHHDERYHQRWH¬ 

WKHVLJQLILFDQFHRIWKHFRQWULEXWLRQVSUHVHQWHGVHHHVSHFLDOO\WKH
FRPPHQWVRI3DUGHH¬²
 oi.uchicago.edu

P:% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

  ´8QHOHWWUHGXURLGH7\UDXURLG·2XJDULW0LOLHX[G·DIIDLUHVHWGHFXOWXUHHQ6\ULHjODILQGHO·kJH
GX%URQ]H5pFHQWµ7'-#(²
  (PDU9,*!]$!0%"!%.(%&#&.#6$+EX1!g%*-()04-#I$#6)0%!$%$-("14$#6)05HFKHUFKHVDXSD\VG·$ߖWDWD0LVVLRQ
$UFKpRORJLTXHGH0HVNpQp(PDU3DULVeGLWLRQV5HFKHUFKHVXUOHV&LYLOLVDWLRQV
  ´8QHFRUUHVSRQGDQFHG·DIIDLUHVHQWUH2XJDULWDLQVHW(PDULRWHV QF² µ,Q\)!%&#&.#6$+EX1!%
(1%01"%"!%.(%?#..!g%N!0%$!]$!0%"!%.(%râ!%4(>I(5)!%^_áor`HGLWHGE\3%RUGUHXLOSS²5DV6KDPUD
2XJDULW3DULVeGLWLRQV5HFKHUFKHVXUOHV&LYLOLVDWLRQV
  ´3UROpJRPqQHVjODUpGDFWLRQG·XQHKLVWRLUHG·2XJDULW,,/HVERUGHUHDX[GHURLVGLYLQLVpVµ7$1"#%
A#4!)!#%!"%85!6M<)($6.#4#²
  ´/HWWUHV QRV² µ,QQ$1"!0%615(-#$#X1!02%1F>LMJ%ON%*-(?(1]%_áàsq_áásHGLWHGE\0<RQDQG
'¬$UQDXGSS²5DV6KDPUD2XJDULW3DULVeGLWLRQV5HFKHUFKHVXUOHV&LYLOLVDWLRQV
$UQDXG'DQLHO%$QGUp6DOYLQL6/DFNHQEDFKHUDQG)ORUHQFH0DOEUDQ/DEDW
  ´7H[WHVV\OODELTXHVµ,QQ$1"!0%615(-#$#X1!02%1F>LMJ%ON%*-(?(1]%_áàsq_áásHGLWHGE\0<RQDQG'¬$U
QDXGSS²5DV6KDPUD2XJDULW3DULVeGLWLRQV5HFKHUFKHVXUOHV&LYLOLVDWLRQV
$UQDXG'DQLHO)ORUHQFH0DOEUDQ/DEDW6/DFNHQEDFKHUDQG%$QGUp6DOYLQL
  ´3UHPLqUHSDUWLH/HVWH[WHVDNNDGLHQVµ,Q\)!%&#&.#6$+EX1!%(1%01"%"!%.(%?#..!g%N!0%$!]$!0%"!%.(%râ!%4(>M
I(5)!%^_áor`HGLWHGE\3%RUGUHXLOSS²5DV6KDPUD2XJDULW3DULVeGLWLRQV5HFKHUFKHVXU
OHV&LYLOLVDWLRQV
!9KFL72%0"
  ´6RPH5HFHQW:RUNVRQ$QFLHQW6\ULDDQGWKH6HD3HRSOHµP61-)(.%6:%$+!%<>!-#4()%,-#!)$(.%764#!$'%P:N%
²
%HOPRQWH0DUtQ-XDQ$QWRQLR
% :??O% H#!%,-$0M%1)"%D!9a00!-)(>!)%"!-%*!]$!%(10%7'-#!)%#>%nL%P$L%?L%3+-5pSHUWRLUH*pRJUDSKLTXHGHV7H[WHV
&XQpLIRUPHV9ROXPH1XPEHU%HLKHIWH]XP7ELQJHU$WODVGHV9RUGHUHQ2ULHQWV5HLKH%
*HLVWHVZLVVHQVFKDIWHQ :LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW
%HUJHU35
  ´=XGHQ¶DNNDGLVFKHQ·%ULHIHQ8JDULWLFD9µ\5(-#$MF6-04+1)5!)²
%HUJVWUlVVHU*RWWKHOI
  8#):u+-1)5%#)%"#!%0!>#$#04+!)%7I-(4+!)g%7I-(4+I-6&!)%1)"%5-(>>($#04+!%7=#GG!)0XQLFK0D[+XHEHU
%ODঈHN9iFODY
  ´7UDFHVRID&RPPRQ&DVH6\VWHPLQ$IURDVLDWLFµ,QN6X1!)$!0%.#)51#0g%7$1"#%.#)51#0$#4#%!%6-#!)$(.#%#)%
6)6-!%"#%F(&-#G#6%<L%@!))(44+#!$$#HGLWHGE\34%RUERQH$0HQJR]]LDQG07RVFRSS²:L
HVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
%RUGUHXLO3LHUUHDQG'HQQLV3DUGHH
  ´/HVWH[WHVHQFXQpLIRUPHDOSKDEpWLTXH QR¬² µ,Q\)!%&#&.#6$+EX1!%(1%01"%"!%.(%?#..!g%N!0%$!]$!0%
"!%.(%râ!%4(>I(5)!%^_áor`HGLWHGE\3%RUGUHXLOSS²5DV6KDPUD2XJDULW3DULVeGLWLRQV
5HFKHUFKHVXUOHV&LYLOLVDWLRQV
%RUJHU5LHNHOH
% :??<% A!06I6$(>#04+!0%t!#4+!).!]#=6)$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW0QVWHU8JDULW9HUODJ
%R\G-/,,,
  $&ROOHFWLRQDQG([DPLQDWLRQRIWKH8JDULWLF9RFDEXODU\&RQWDLQHGLQWKH$NNDGLDQ7H[WVIURP5DV
6KDPUD3K'GLVVHUWDWLRQ8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR
%XFFHOODWL*LRUJLR
  <%7$-14$1-(.%D-(>>(-%6:%S(&'.6)#():LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% PQ

"6M=DJ>>2%-E>J
% :??<% O#0$6-#4(.%N#)51#0$#40g%<)%/)$-6"14$#6)QGHGLWLRQ&DPEULGJH0,73UHVV
&LYLO0LJXHO
  ´7KH6XPHULDQ:ULWLQJ6\VWHP6RPH3UREOHPVµ,-#!)$(.#(2%QV²
  ´7KH7H[WVIURP0HVNHQH(PDUµ<1.(%,-#!)$(.#0²
&URVV)UDQN0RRUH
  ´7KH&RQWULEXWLRQVRI:)$OEULJKWWR6HPLWLF(SLJUDSK\DQG3DOHRJUDSK\µ,Q*+!%74+6.(-0+#I%6:%
J#..#(>%F6]9!..%<.&-#5+$g%<)%<II-(#0(.HGLWHGE\*:YDQ%HHNSS²+DUYDUG6HPLWLF6WXG
LHV¬$WODQWD6FKRODUV3UHVV
GH¬0RRU-&
  ´5čSL૟ࡃPD³5HSKDLPµt!#$04+-#:$%:u-%"#!%<.$$!0$(>!)$.#4+!%J#00!)04+(:$²
GHO¬2OPR¬/HWH*UHJRULRDQG-6DQPDUWtQ
% :??Q% <%H#4$#6)(-'%6:%$+!%\5(-#$#4%N()51(5!%#)%$+!%<.I+(&!$#4%*-("#$#6)YROXPHV+DQGEXFKGHU2ULHQWDOLVWLN
6HFWLRQ'HU1DKHXQG0LWWOHUH2VWHQ%ULOO/HLGHQ
'LDNRQRII,JRU0
  7!>#$6MO(>#$#4%N()51(5!0g%<)%800('%#)%3.(00#:#4($#6)0RVFRZ1DXND
'LHWULFK2%0DQG2/RUHW]
  ´5DVXUHQXQG6FKUHLEIHKOHULQGHQNHLODOSKDEHWLVFKHQ7H[WHQDXV8JDULW$QPHUNXQJHQ]XU1HX
DXIODJHYRQ.78µ\5(-#$MF6-04+1)5!)²
.%#/0#123!K'(B0#%7L!F$M'=7!450%/6L!'(7!N5'O:P(!8'(&'0/#(
! )**+! "&'()*+',-./0(!12&34'5,6("'7589(:/.0($%3/,5;(<38(=4+(>3+,(3+?(@5&'/(A136'8B!GC2'(7=:(;%(!6:0!4#/%0'/:0!
G=/Q8<0#%(QR'=S$/#('$!:(7!K%$5T5/'&#%($!JH!KU($/%0V!W;'0#/QX%0=';H
'6DJ72%!
  ´*HQHWLF6XEJURXSLQJVRIWKH6HPLWLF/DQJXDJHVµ,Q*+!%7!>#$#4%N()51(5!0HGLWHGE\5+HW]URQSS
²1HZ<RUN5RXWOHGJH
)LVFKHU:ROIGLHWULFK
  D-(>>($#=%"!0%b.(00#04+!)%<-(&#04+WKHGLWLRQUHYLVHG3RUWD/LQJXDUXP2ULHQWDOLXPQV:LHV
EDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
)OHLVFK+HQUL
  *-(#$U%"!%I+#.6.65#!%(-(&!2%1F>LMJ%ON%@-U.#>#)(#-!02%I+6)U$#X1!2%>6-I+6.65#!%)6>#)(.!5HFKHUFKHV
SXEOLpHVVRXVODGLUHFWLRQGHO·,QVWLWXWGH/HWWUHV2ULHQWDOHVGH%H\URXWK%HLUXW,PSULPHULH
&DWKROLTXH
  N;(-(&!%4.(00#X1!g%80X1#00!%";1)!%0$-14$1-!%.#)51#0$#X1!5HYLVHGHGLWLRQ5HFKHUFKHVSXEOLpHVVRXVOD
GLUHFWLRQGHO·,QVWLWXWGH/HWWUHV2ULHQWDOHVGH%H\URXWK6HULHV/DQJXHHW/LWWpUDWXUH$UDEHV
%HLUXW'DUHO0DFKUHTeGLWHXUV ,PSULPHULH&DWKROLTXH 
)URQ]DUROL3HOLR
  ´/DODQJXHG·eEOD'pFRXYHUWHHWLQWHUSUpWDWLRQµN(.#!0²
*DQW]HUW0
  *+!%8>(-%N!]#4(.%*!]$02%567K%ON%*!]$%8"#$#6)0DDVWULFKW8LWJHYHULM%RHNHQSODQ
*HOE,JQDFH-
  ,."%<==("#()%J-#$#)5%()"%D-(>>(-QGHGLWLRQUHYLVHG0DWHULDOVIRUWKH$VV\ULDQ'LFWLRQDU\&KL
FDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVV
  7!X1!)$#(.%K!46)0$-14$#6)%6:%@-6$6M<==("#()$VV\ULRORJLFDO6WXGLHV&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR
3UHVV
 oi.uchicago.edu

P<% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

  36>I1$!-M(#"!"%<)(.'0#0%6:%<>6-#$!$VV\ULRORJLFDO6WXGLHV&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVV
*HQVOHU2'
  ´0DUL$NNDGLDQ,߰¶WRIRU·DQG3UHSRVLWLRQKRSSLQJLQWKH/LJKWRI&RPSDUDWLYH6HPLWLF6\QWD[µ
,-#!)$(.#(QV²
*HRUJH$
  ´7KH*LOJDPHߖ(SLFDW8JDULWµ<1.(%,-#!)$(.#0²
*RUGRQ&\UXV+
% OP<?% \5(-#$#4%D-(>>(-g%*+!%@-!0!)$%7$($10%6:%$+!%N#)51#0$#4%7$1"'%6:%$+!%7!>#$#4%<.I+(&!$#4%*!]$0%:-6>%K(0%
7+(>-($QDOHFWD2ULHQWDOLD5RPH3RQWLILFLXP,QVWLWXWXP%LEOLFXP
% OPRR% \5(-#$#4%A()1(.g%B!9.'%K!?#0!"%D-(>>(-2%*!]$0%#)%*-()0.#$!-($#6)2%31)!#:6->%7!.!4$#6)02%@(-("#5>02%D.600(-'2%
/)"#4!05RPH3RQWLILFLXP,QVWLWXWXP%LEOLFXP
  \5(-#$#4%*!]$&66=$QDOHFWD2ULHQWDOLD5RPH3RQWLILFLXP,QVWLWXWXP%LEOLFXP
*URQHEHUJ%ULJLWWH
  ´7HUPLQDWLYXQG/RNDWLYDYHUELDOLVLQDOWEDE\ORQLVFKHQOLWHUDULVFKHQ7H[WHQµ<-4+#?%:u-%,-#!)$:6-M
04+1)5²
  H#!%,-$0M%1)"%D!9a00!-)(>!)%"!-%(.$&(&'.6)#04+!)%t!#$5pSHUWRLUH*pRJUDSKLTXHGHV7H[WHV&XQpL
IRUPHV%HLKHIWH]XP7ELQJHU$WODVGHV9RUGHUHQ2ULHQWV5HLKH% *HLVWHVZLVVHQVFKDIWHQ 
:LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW
*U|QGDKO)UDXNH
  H#!%@!-06)!))(>!)%"!-%*!]$!%(10%\5(-#$6WXGLD3RKO5RPH3RQWLILFLXP,QVWLWXWXP%LEOLFXP
+DVVHOEDFK5HEHFFD
  $+LVWRULFDODQG&RPSDUDWLYH6WXG\RI6DUJRQLF$NNDGLDQ3K'GLVVHUWDWLRQ+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\
+DZOH\5REHUW
  6WXGLHVLQ8JDULWLF(SLVWRORJUDSK\3K'GLVVHUWDWLRQ8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR
  ´2QWKH$OSKDEHWLF6FULEDO&XUULFXOXPDW8JDULWµ,Q@-64!!"#)50%6:%$+!%s_0$%K!)46)$-!%<00'-#6.65#X1!%
/)$!-)($#6)(.!2%O!."%($%$+!%,-#!)$(.%/)0$#$1$!%6:%$+!%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%3+#4(562%P1.'%_àqnn2%nppsHGLWHGE\5'
%LJJV-0\HUVDQG075RWKSS²6WXGLHVLQ$QFLHQW2ULHQWDO&LYLOL]DWLRQ&KLFDJR2UL
HQWDO,QVWLWXWH
+DZOH\5REHUWDQG'HQQLV3DUGHH
  ´/HWH[WHMXULGLTXH56¬1RXYHOOHpWXGHpSLJUDSKLTXHµ7!>#$#4(²²
+HVV5LFKDUG6
  ´7KH2QRPDVWLFVRI8JDULWLFµ,QO()"&66=%6:%\5(-#$#4%7$1"#!0HGLWHGE\:*(:DWVRQDQG1¬:\DWW
SS²+DQGEXFKGHU2ULHQWDOLVWLN6HFWLRQ'HU1DKHXQG0LWWOHUH2VWHQ/HLGHQ%ULOO
% OPPQ% <>(-)(%@!-06)(.%B(>!0$PHULFDQ6FKRROVRI2ULHQWDO5HVHDUFK'LVVHUWDWLRQ6HULHV:LQRQD/DNH
(LVHQEUDXQV
+HW]URQ2%,
  ´7ZR3ULQFLSOHVRI*HQHWLF5HFRQVWUXFWLRQµN#)51(²
+XHKQHUJDUG-RKQ
  ´$NNDGLDQ(YLGHQFHIRU&DVHYRZHOVRQ8JDULWLF%RXQG)RUPVµP61-)(.%6:%31)!#:6->%7$1"#!0%QQN%
²
  ´$VVHYHUDWLYH ODDQG+\SRWKHWLFDO OXODZLQ6HPLWLFµP61-)(.%6:%$+!%<>!-#4()%,-#!)$(.%764#!$'%O?QWQN%
²
  \5(-#$#4%T64(&1.(-'%#)%7'..(&#4%*-()04-#I$#6)+DUYDUG6HPLWLF6WXGLHV'HFDWXU6FKRODUV3UHVV
  *+!%<==("#()%6:%\5(-#$+DUYDUG6HPLWLF6WXGLHV$WODQWD6FKRODUV3UHVV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% PR

(LGGMFH2%(%
  <>6-#$!%@!-06)(.%B(>!0%#)%$+!%A(-#%*!]$0g%<%7$-14$1-(.%()"%N!]#4(.%7$1"'%DOWLPRUH-RKQV+RSNLQV
3UHVV
*976J>2%'
  ´<čQXDFFXVDWLYRQHOVHPLWLFRVLURSDOHVWLQHVHHLOVLQFUHWLVPRGHLFDVLQHOVHPLWLFRµ,QN6X1!)$!0%
.#)51#0g%7$1"#%.#)51#0$#4#%!%6-#!)$(.#%#)%6)6-!%"#%F(&-#G#6%<L%@!))(44+#!$$#HGLWHGE\3*%RUERQH$0HQ
JR]]LDQG07RVFRSS²:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
  ´eWXGHVDPRUULWHV,,,/DFRXFKHDPRUULWHGHO·RQRPDVWLTXHRXJDULWLTXHµ,QH;,15(-#$%h%PU-10(.!>g%
K!41!#.%";U$1"!0%UI#5-(I+#X1!0%!$%(-4+U6.65#X1!0%6::!-$%h%@#!--!%S6-"-!1#.HGLWHGE\&5RFKHSS²
2ULHQW 0pGLWHUUDQpH3DULV'H%RFFDUG
.LHQDVW2%%XUNKDUW
% :??O% O#0$6-#04+!%7!>#$#04+!%7I-(4+9#00!)04+(:$:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
.UDXV2%',
  ´'HUDNNDGLVFKH9RNDWLYµ,Qb-(>!-%<))#?!-0(-'%T6.1>!g%31)!#:6->%7$1"#!0%#)%O6)6-%6:%7(>1!.%B6(+%
b-(>!-HGLWHGE\%/(LFKOHUSS²$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW.HYHODHU%XW]RQ 
%HUFNHU
.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]-HU]\
  N;(I6I+6)#!%!)%0U>#$#X1!3UDFHMH]\NR]QDZF]H¬0RXWRQ6*UDYHQKDJH
% OP@:% 7$1"#!0%#)%7!>#$#4%D-(>>(-%()"%A!$-#40%UHVODX:\GDZQLFWZR3ROVNLHM$NDGHPLL1DXN
/DFNHQEDFKHU6\OYLH
% :??:% *!]$!0%(==("#!)0%";\5(-#$g%*!]$!0%I-6?!)()$%"!0%?#)5$M4#)X%I-!>#E-!0%4(>I(5)!0/LWWpUDWXUHVDQFLHQQHV
GX3URFKH2ULHQW3DULV&HUI
/DN·LDߖYLOL2%!
  ´'DVGLSWRWLVFKH6\VWHPLQNODVVLVFKHQ$UDELVFKµ$UFKLY2ULHQWiOQt²
-6MDJ7K2%:4
  ´*|WWHUOLVWHQµK!(..!]#=6)%"!-%<00'-#6.65#!²
/DQGVEHUJHU%HQQR
% OPR@% 7KH6HULHV҅$5UD ђXEXOOX2%*(&.!$0%/q/T0DWHULDOLHQ]XP6XPHULVFKHQ/H[LNRQ5RPH3RQWLILFLXP
,QVWLWXWXP%LEOLFXP
/LSL‫ش‬VNL(GZDUG
% OPP@% 7!>#$#4%N()51(5!0g%,1$.#)!%6:%(%36>I(-($#?!%D-(>>(-2ULHQWDOLD/RYDQLHQVLD$QDOHFWD/HXYHQ
3HHWHUV
/LYHUDQL0DULR
  ´$QWHFHGHQWLGHOGLSWRWLVPRDUDERQHLWHVWLDFFDGLFLGL8JDULWµK#?#0$(%"!5.#%7$1"#%,-#!)$(.#
²
  ´(FRQRPLDGHOOHIDWWRULHSDODWLQHXJDULWLFKHµH#(.65+#%"#%<-4+!6.65#(²
0DOEUDQ/DEDW)ORUHQFH
  ´/DGpFRXYHUWHpSLJUDSKLTXHGHj2XJDULW OHVWH[WHVDNNDGLHQV µ7$1"#%A#4!)!#%!"%85!6M<)($6.#4#%
²
  ´&DWDORJXHUDLVRQQpGHVWH[WHVDNNDGLHQVGHOD¶0DLVRQG·8UW̒QX·µH;,15(-#$%h%PU-10(.!>g%K!41!#.%
";U$1"!0%UI#5-(I+#X1!0%!$%(-4+U6.65#X1!0%6::!-$%h%@#!--!%S6-"-!1#.HGLWHGE\&5RFKHSS²2ULHQW 
0pGLWHUUDQpH3DULV'H¬%RFFDUG
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

0DOEUDQ/DEDW)ORUHQFHDQG&DUROH5RFKH
  ´%RUGHUHDX[GHOD¶0DLVRQG·2XUWHQRX 8UW̒QX ·­SURSRVGHODJHVWLRQGHVpTXLGpVHWGHODSODFH
GHFHWWHPDLVRQGDQVO·pFRQRPLHSDODWLDOHµ,Q,15(-#$%(1%S-6)G!%>6'!)%!$%(1%S-6)G!%-U4!)$g%<4$!0%"1%
&ROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOWHQXj/\RQHQQRYHPEUH´2XJDULWDX,,!%>#..U)(#-!%(?L%PLM3L2%U$($%"!0%-!4+!-4+!02%
HGLWHGE\<&DOYHWDQG0<RQSS²7UDYDX[GHOD0DLVRQGHO·2ULHQWHWGHOD0pGLWHUUDQpH
/\RQ0DLVRQGHO·2ULHQWHWGHOD0pGLWHUUDQpH
0DQQD-DFTXHV(XJqQH
% OP??% T64(&1.(#-!%4+(."U!)M(-(&!0RVXO,PSULPHULHGHV3qUHV'RPLQLFDLQV
0DUFXV2%3
  ´7KH7KUHH$OHSKVLQ8JDULWLFµP61-)(.%6:%$+!%<)4#!)$%B!(-%8(0$!-)%764#!$'²
0iUTXH]5RZH,JQDFLR
  ´0RUH(YLGHQFHRIWKH*UD]LQJ7D[LQ8JDULWµ\5(-#$MF6-04+1)5!)²
  *+!%K6'(.%H!!"0%6:%\5(-#$g%<%7$1"'%6:%<)4#!)$%B!(-%8(0$!-)%H#I.6>($#40$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWD
PHQW¬0QVWHU8JDULW9HUODJ
0JEJ72%,
! )*?-! >'4/C,86&'(D/30035,E3!X5=:&%!,V(F35G1'&/'H!8'&&=:(;!YZ$12%(!+?>+H![%0=#(V!"'=/%0!7%!Y0:</%0H
0RVFDWL6DEDWLQR$6SLWDOHU(8OOHQGRUIIDQG:YRQ¬6RGHQ
  <)%/)$-6"14$#6)%$6%$+!%36>I(-($#?!%D-(>>(-%6:%$+!%7!>#$#4%N()51(5!03RUWD/LQJXDUXP2ULHQWDOLXP
QV:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
0OOHU+DQV3HWHU
  ´(UJDWLYH&RQVWUXFWLRQVLQ(DUO\6HPLWLF/DQJXDJHVµP61-)(.%6:%B!(-%8(0$!-)%7$1"#!0²
1|OGHNH7KHRGRU
% OP?<% 36>I!)"#610%7'-#(4%D-(>>(-7UDQVODWHGE\-$&ULFKWRQ/RQGRQ:LOOLDPV 1RUJDWH
+FLI6E7F>2%[J6H
% OPRR% N!%@(.(#0%K6'(.%";\5(-#$*!]$!0%(44("#!)0%!$%+61--#$!0%"!0%(-4+#?!0%!0$2%61!0$%!$%4!)$-(.!0(GLWHG
DQGWUDQVODWHGE\&)$6FKDHIIHU0LVVLRQGH5DV6KDPUD3DULV,PSULPHULH1DWLRQDOHDQG
.OLQFNVLHFN
  ´7H[WHVVXPpURDFFDGLHQVGHVDUFKLYHVHWELEOLRWKqTXHVSULYpHVG·8JDULWµ,Q\5(-#$#4(HGLWHGE\
-1RXJD\URO(/DURFKH&9LUROOHDXGDQG&)$6FKDHIIHUSS²0LVVLRQGH5DV6KDPUD
%LEOLRWKqTXH$UFKpRORJLTXHHW+LVWRULTXH3DULV,PSULPHULH1DWLRQDOHDQG*HXQWKHU
% OP@?% N!%@(.(#0%K6'(.%";\5(-#$*!]$!0%!)%41)U#:6->!0%&(&'.6)#!)0%"!0%(-4+#?!0%"1%D-()"%@(.(#0%!$%"1%@(.(#0%71"%
";\5(-#$0LVVLRQGH5DV6KDPUD3DULV,PSULPHULH1DWLRQDOHDQG.OLQFNVLHFN
&T"FHHF70
  ´7KH2QRPDVWLF(YLGHQFHIRU%URQ]HDJH:HVW6HPLWLFµP61-)(.%6:%$+!%<>!-#4()%,-#!)$(.%764#!$'%O:<WQN%
²
3DUGHH'HQQLV
% :???% N!0%$!]$!0%-#$1!.05DV6KDPUD2XJDULW3DULVeGLWLRQV5HFKHUFKHVXUOHV&LYLOLVDWLRQV
% :??:6% K#$1(.%()"%31.$%($%\5(-#$6%/:ULWLQJVIURPWKH$QFLHQW:RUOG/HLGHQ%ULOO
 E ´8JDULWLF/HWWHUVµ,Q*+!%36)$!]$%6:%74-#I$1-!2%1F>LMJ%QN%<-4+#?(.%H641>!)$0%:-6>%$+!%S#&.#4(.%J6-."2%
HGLWHGE\:+DOORDQG.<RXQJHUSS²/HLGHQ%ULOO
  ´8QHIRUPXOHpSLVWRODLUHHQRXJDULWLTXHHWDFFDGLHQµ,Q7!>#$#4%()"%<00'-#6.65#4(.%7$1"#!0%@-!0!)$!"%
$6%@!.#6%F-6)G(-6.#%&'%@1I#.0%()"%36..!(51!0HGLWHGE\30DUUDVVLQLHWDOSS²:LHVEDGHQ
+DUUDVVRZLW]
  5HYLHZRI\5(-#$#04+!%D-(>>($#=E\-7URSSHU<-4+#?%:u-%,-#!)$:6-04+1)5RQOLQHYHUVLRQ ²
 ²KWWSRULHQWDOLVWLNXQLYLHDFDWSXEOLNDWLRQHQDUFKLYIXHURULHQWIRUVFKXQJ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% P@

3HQWLXF(XJHQ-
% :??O% J!0$%7!>#$#4%T64(&1.(-'%#)%$+!%<==("#()%*!]$0%:-6>%8>(-+DUYDUG6HPLWLF6WXGLHV:LQRQD/DNH
(LVHQEUDXQV
5F=J2%0
  ´8JDULWLF(QFOLWLFPµP61-)(.%6:%31)!#:6->%7$1"#!0²
3UX]VLQV]NL5HJLQH
% :??Q% H#!%@!-06)!))(>!)%"!-%*!]$!%(10%8>(-6WXGLHVRQWKH&LYLOL]DWLRQDQG&XOWXUHRI1X]LDQGWKH+XUUL
DQV%HWKHVGD&'/3UHVV
,6D8H2%"
  ´7KH6WUXFWXUHRIWKH6HPLWLF6\VWHPRI&DVH(QGLQJVµ,Q@-64!!"#)50%6:%$+!%/)$!-)($#6)(.%36):!-!)4!%
6:%7!>#$#4%7$1"#!02%O!."%#)%P!-10(.!>2%_áqnr%P1.'%_á|sSS²-HUXVDOHP,VUDHO$FDGHP\RI6FLHQFHV
DQG+XPDQLWLHV
5DLQH\$QVRQ)
  3()(()#$!%#)%$+!%<>(-)(%*(&.!$0g%<%N#)51#0$#4%<)(.'0#0%6:%$+!%A#]!"%H#(.!4$%\0!"%&'%$+!%74-#&!0%:-6>%3()(()2%
1F>LMJ%QN%A6-I+60')$(4$#4%<)(.'0#0%6:%$+!%@(-$#4.!0%()"%<"?!-&0L%+DQGEXFKGHU2ULHQWDOLVWLN6HFWLRQ
'HU1DKHXQG0LWWOHUH2VWHQ/HLGHQ%ULOO
5RFKH&DUROH
  ´-HX[GHPRWVMHX[GHVLJQHVHQ2XJDULWRXGHO·LQIOXHQFHGHVWH[WHVOH[LFDX[VXUOHVVFULEHVGH
SpULSKpULHµ,QH;,15(-#$%h%PU-10(.!>g%K!41!#.%";U$1"!0%UI#5-(I+#X1!0%!$%(-4+U6.65#X1!0%6::!-$%h%@#!--!%S6-M
"-!1#.HGLWHGE\&5RFKHSS²2ULHQW 0pGLWHUUDQpH3DULV'H¬%RFFDUG
)RUWKFRPLQJ´/DQJXDJHDQG6FULSWLQWKH¶$NNDGLDQ·(FRQRPLF7H[WVIURP5DV6KDPUDµ,Q@-64!!"#)50%6:%$+!%7'>M
I60#1>%6)%764#!$'%()"%<">#)#0$-($#6)%#)%<)4#!)$%\5(-#$HGLWHGE\:YDQ6ROGW/HLGHQ1,12
$699J2%([
  ´&DVHLQ&XVKLWLF6HPLWLFDQG%HUEHUµ,Q31--!)$%@-65-!00%#)%<:-6M<0#($#4%N#)51#0$#40g%@(I!-0%6:%$+!%*+#-"%
/)$!-)($#6)(.%O(>#$6M7!>#$#4%36)5-!00HGLWHGE\-%\QRQSS²$PVWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
  ´&XVKLWLF$GSRVLWLRQVDQG7KHLU3RVVLEOH5HODWLYHVLQ6HPLWLFµ,Q7!.!4$!"%36>I(-($#?!M+#0$6-#4(.%
<:-(0#()%N#)51#0$#4%7$1"#!0%#)%A!>6-'%6:%/56-%AL%H#(=6)6::HGLWHGE\0/%HQGHU*7DNiFVDQG'/
$SSOH\DUGSS²/LQFRP6WXGLHVLQ$IURDVLDWLF/LQJXLVWLFV0XQLFK/LQFRP(XURSD
6DW]LQJHU+HOPXW
  ´7KH(J\SWLDQ&RQQHFWLRQ(J\SWLDQDQGWKH6HPLWLF/DQJXDJHVµ/0-(!.%,-#!)$(.%7$1"#!0²
 D ´6RPH5HPDUNVRQWKH$IURDVLDWLF&DVH6\VWHPµJ#!)!-%t!#$04+-#:$%:u-%"#!%b1)"!%"!0%A6-5!).()"!0%P<N%
²
 E ´6WDWXVHVDQG&DVHVRIWKH$IURDVLDWLF3HUVRQDO3URQRXQµ,Q85'I$#()%()"%7!>#$6MO(>#$#4%^<:-6M<0#($M
#4`%7$1"#!0%#)%A!>6-#(>%JL%T'4#4+.HGLWHGE\*7DNiFVSS²6WXGLHVLQ6HPLWLF/DQJXDJHVDQG
/LQJXLVWLFV/HLGHQ%ULOO
  ´$EVROXWH6WDWHDQG$EVROXWH&DVHLQ$IUR$VLDWLFµ,Qi//%/)46)$-6%/$(.#()6%"#%N#)51#0$#4(%3(>#$6M0!>#M
$#4(%^<:-6(0#($#4(`g%<$$#HGLWHGE\00RULJJLSS²0HGLRHYR5RPDQ]RH2ULHQWDOH&ROORTXL
6RYHULD0DQHOOL5XEEHWWLQR
$JIJ7K2%$
  ´'LH6FKUHLEIHKOHULQGHQXJDULWLVFKHQOLWHUDULVFKHQ.HLOVFKULIWWH[WHQµ,QT6)%\5(-#$%)(4+%e1>-()2%
HGLWHGE\-+HPSHODQG/5RVWSS²%HLKHIWH]XU=HLWVFKULIWIU$OWWHVWDPHQWOLVFKH:LV
VHQVFKDIWHQ%HUOLQ7|SHOPDQQ
  ´'LH6FKUHLEIHKOHULQGHQXJDULWLVFKHQQLFKWOLWHUDULVFKHQ.HLOVFKULIWWH[WHQLQ$QVFKOX‰DQGDVWH[W
NULWLVFKH+LOIVEXFKYRQ)'HOLW]VFKµt!#$04+-#:$%:1-%"#!%<.$$!0$(>!)$.#4+!%J#00!)04+(:$²²
6LPHRQH6HQHOOH2%0"
  ´7KH0RGHUQ6RXWK$UDELDQ/DQJXDJHVµ,Q*+!%7!>#$#4%N()51(5!0HGLWHGE\5+HW]URQSS²
1HZ<RUN5RXWOHGJH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K,S8K*%O<JN8Y

6LYDQ'DQLHO
  D-(>>($#4(.%<)(.'0#0%()"%D.600(-'%6:%$+!%B6-$+9!0$%7!>#$#4%T64(&.!0%#)%<==("#()%*!]$0%6:%$+!%_s$+q_r$+%4L%
SL3L%:-6>%3()(()%()"%7'-#($OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW.DYHODHU%XW]RQ %HUFNHU
$=J89J72%)!
  ´7KH7HUPLQDWLYHDGYHUELDOLQ&DQDDQLWH8JDULWLFDQG$NNDGLDQµ/0-(!.%8]I.6-($#6)%P61-)(.²
6WUHFN0LFKDHO3
% :???% H(0%(>1--#$#04+!%,)6>(0$#=6)%"!-%(.$&(&'.6)#04+!)%t!#$$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW0Q
VWHU8JDULW9HUODJ
#6E>F72%[4
  ´$/RQJDZDLWHG9RFDWLYH6LQJXODU1RXQZLWK)LQDO<.!I+LQ8JDULWLF .78 "µ\5(-#$MF6-M
04+1)5!)²
7HVWHQ'DYLG
  @(-(..!.0%#)%7!>#$#4%N#)51#0$#40g%*+!%H!?!.6I>!)$%6:%<-(&#4%.(M%()"%K!.($!"%7!>#$#4%@(-$#4.!06WXGLHVLQ6H
PLWLF/DQJXDJHVDQG/LQJXLVWLFV/HLGHQ%ULOO
#7F==J72%[F9JG
% :???% \5(-#$#04+!%D-(>>($#=$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW0QVWHU8JDULW9HUODJ
7XWWOH*DU\$
  ´&DVH9RZHOVRQ0DVFXOLQH6LQJXODU1RXQVLQ&RQVWUXFWLQ8JDULWLFµ,QS#&.#4(.%()"%B!(-%8(0$!-)%
7$1"#!0g%800('0%#)%O6)6-%6:%J#..#(>%7():6-"%N(76-HGLWHGE\*$7XWWOHSS²*UDQG5DSLGV
(HUGPDQV
YDQ6ROGW:LOIUHG
% OPPO% 7$1"#!0%#)%$+!%<==("#()%6:%\5(-#$g%H($#)5%()"%D-(>>(-$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW.HYHODHU
%XW]RQ %HUFNHU
  ´%DE\ORQLDQ/H[LFDO5HOLJLRXVDQG/LWHUDU\7H[WVDQG6FULEDO(GXFDWLRQDW8JDULWDQG,WV,PSOLFD
WLRQVIRUWKH$OSKDEHWLF/LWHUDU\7H[WVµ,Q\5(-#$g%8#)%60$>!"#$!--()!0%b1.$1-G!)$-1>2%8-5!&)#00!%1)"%
@!-0I!=$#?!)%"!-%F6-04+1)52%1F>LMJ%ON%\5(-#$%1)"%0!#)!>%(.$6-#!)$(.#04+!%\>9!.$HGLWHGE\0'LHW
ULFKDQG2/RUHW]SS²$EKDQGOXQJHQ]XU/LWHUDWXU$OW6\ULHQ3DOlVWLQDV0QVWHU
8JDULW9HUODJ
  ´6WXGLHVLQWKH7RSRJUDSK\RI8JDULW  7RZQ6L]HVDQG'LVWULFWVµ\5(-#$MF6-04+1)5!)²
  ´1DђLߖߖDOPX$Q$VV\ULDQ6FULEH:RUNLQJLQWKH¶6RXWKHUQ3DODFH·DW8JDULWµ,QT!!)+6:%<))#?!-M
0(-'%T6.1>!g%7$1"#!0%@-!0!)$!"%$6%b.((0%KL%T!!)+6:%6)%$+!%,44(0#6)%6:%O#0%7#]$'M:#:$+%S#-$+"('HGLWHGE\
:¬YDQ6ROGW-*'HUFNVRQ1-&.RXZHQEHUJDQG7-+.ULVSLMQSS²8LWJDYHQYDQKHW
1HGHUODQGV+LVWRULVFK$UFKDHRORJLVFK,QVWLWXXWWH,VWDQEXO¬/HLGHQ1HGHUODQGV,QVWLWXXWYRRU
KHW1DELMH2RVWHQ
  ´7KH2UWKRJUDSK\RI8JDULWLF:RUGVLQ7H[WV:ULWWHQE\WKH$VV\ULDQ6FULEH1DђLߖߖDOPXµ,Q8]%
A!06I6$(>#(%!$%7'-#(%N1]g%F!0$04+-#:$%:u-%A():-#!"%H#!$-#4+%G1%0!#)!>%|sL%D!&1-$0$(5HGLWHGE\2/R
UHW].$0HW]OHUDQG+6FKDXGLJSS²$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW0QVWHU
8JDULW9HUODJ
% :??R% *+!%*6I65-(I+'%6:%$+!%3#$'M7$($!%6:%\5(-#$$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW0QVWHU
8JDULW9HUODJ
1F8IK2%,
  ´'LH3HUVRQDOSURQRPLQDGHU3HUVRQHQLP6HPLWLVFKHQµH#!%J!.$%"!0%,-#!)$0²
YRQ¬6RGHQ:ROIUDP
  ´'HUK\PQLVFKHSLVFKH'LDOHNWGHV$NNDGLVFKHQ  µt!#$04+-#:$%:u-%<00'-#6.65#!%1)"%?!-9()"$!%D!&#!$!%
²
% OPR:% D-1)"-#00%"!-%(==("#04+!)%D-(>>($#=$QDOHFWD2ULHQWDOLD5RPH3RQWLILFLXP,QVWLWXWXP%LEOLFXP
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7,A8%3<78%@K,SN8A7%/B%\D<K/*/3% PP

² <==("#04+!0%O()"9~-$!-&14+YROXPHV:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
% OPPR% D-1)"-#00%"!-%(==("#04+!)%D-(>>($#=UGHGLWLRQ$QDOHFWD2ULHQWDOLD5RPH3RQWLILFLXP,QVWLWX
WXP%LEOLFXP
:DOWLVEHUJ2%0
  ´=XU(UJDWLYK\SRWKHVHLP6HPLWLVFKHQµt!#$04+-#:$%"!-%H!1$04+!)%A6-5!).a)"#04+!)%D!0!..04+(:$%OR:N%
²
:DOWNH%UXFH.DQG0LFKDHO2·&RQQRU
% OPP?% <)%/)$-6"14$#6)%$6%S#&.#4(.%O!&-!9%7')$(]:LQRQD/DNH(LVHQEUDXQV
:HLGQHU2%)'
 ² ´$OWEDE\ORQLVFKH*|WWHUOLVWHQµ<-4+#?%:u-%b!#.04+-#:$:6-04+1)5²²
:LVHPDQ2%3[
% OPRQ% *+!%<.(.(=+%*(&.!$02FFDVLRQDO3XEOLFDWLRQVRIWKH%ULWLVK,QVWLWXWHRI$UFKDHRORJ\DW$QNDUD/RQ
GRQ%ULWLVK,QVWLWXWHRI$UFKDHRORJ\DW$QNDUD
:ULJKW2%:
  <%D-(>>(-%6:%$+!%<-(&#4%N()51(5!9ROXPHUGHGLWLRQ7UDQVODWHGE\::ULJKW&DPEULGJH&DP
EULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
BFLHI2%)[
  $GYHUELDOM1LQ6HPLWLFJ!0$>#)0$!-%*+!6.65#4(.%P61-)(.²
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 8<KNY%3<B<<B/*8%<BH%,NH%<K<A</3%3<78%/B%*O8%N/DO*%,F%N<BD\<D8%*Y@,N,DY% O?O

!
"#$%&'(#)##)*+"'#),'-%,'#$#.#*('(#/"''
*)'+0"'%*10+'-2'%#)13#1"'+&4-%-1&

K!&!44(%O(00!.&(4+2%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%3+#4(56j

*56789:;6<85
7KHPRVWFRPPRQO\IRXQGGHILQLWLRQRI´FDVHµLVWKDWFDVHPDUNVGHSHQGHQWQRXQVIRUWKHW\SHRIUHODWLRQVKLS
WKH\EHDUWRWKHLUKHDGVO7KHUHDUHWKUHHPDLQZD\VLQZKLFKFDVHFDQEHPDUNHGILUVWE\V\QWKHWLFFRQVWUXFWLRQV
ZKLFKDUHUHSUHVHQWHGE\PRUSKRORJLFDOPDUNLQJVHFRQGE\DQDO\WLFDOFRQVWUXFWLRQVZKLFKSULPDULO\FRQVLVWRI
DGSRVLWLRQSOXVQRXQDQGWKLUGE\SRVLWLRQ:
,QODQJXDJHVWKDWXVHLQIOHFWLRQDOPDUNLQJFDVHIRUPVFDQEHQHXWUDOL]HG7KLVQHXWUDOL]DWLRQUHVXOWVLQWKH
IRUPDOPHUJHURIWZRRUPRUHLQIOHFWLRQDOHQGLQJVDSURFHVVFDOOHG´V\QFUHWLVPµQ$FURVVWKHZRUOG·VODQJXDJHV
V\QFUHWLVPVRFFXUDFFRUGLQJWRFHUWDLQW\SRORJLFDOWHQGHQFLHV,Q/DWLQIRUH[DPSOHWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVD
WLYHWHQGWRPHUJHPRUSKRORJLFDOO\LQWKHQHXWHUGHFOLQDWLRQDQGIRUPDFOHDURSSRVLWLRQWRWKHGDWLYHDQGDEOD
WLYHZKLFKOLNHZLVHWHQGWRPHUJH<7KHPHUJHURIQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYHYHUVXVGDWLYHDQGDEODWLYHFDQEH
H[SODLQHGRQDIXQFWLRQDOEDVLV7KHQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYHSULPDULO\HQFRGHYHUEDOFRPSOHPHQWVZKLOHWKH
GDWLYHDQGDEODWLYHDUHOHVVRIWHQXVHGDVYHUEDOFRPSOHPHQWVDQGDUHPRUHIUHTXHQWO\IRXQGDIWHUSUHSRVLWLRQVR%
7KHPRUSKRORJLFDOPHUJHURUV\QFUHWLVPRIWKHVHFDVHVWKHUHIRUHUHIOHFWVDKLHUDUFK\LQYHUEDOFRPSOHPHQWDWLRQ
WKDWLVFDVHVWKDWDUHFORVHUWRRQHDQRWKHULQIUHTXHQF\DVYHUEDOFRPSOHPHQWVDUHPRUHOLNHO\WRIDOOWRJHWKHU
PRUSKRORJLFDOO\WKDQWKRVHWKDWYDU\JUHDWO\LQWKLVUHVSHFW&DVHVWKDWPHUJHFRQVHTXHQWO\RIWHQKDYHDIXQF
WLRQDORYHUODSWKDWIDFLOLWDWHVWKHPRUSKRORJLFDOPHUJHU
:KHQWKHPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHPDUNHUVRIDODQJXDJHDUHVXEMHFWWRUHGXFWLRQRUORVVGXHWRSKRQRORJLFDO
SURFHVVHVWKHORVVRIWKHVHPRUSKHPHVLVQRWSUHYHQWHG7KLVPHDQVWKDWQRIXQFWLRQDOO\FRQGLWLRQHGSUHVHUYD
WLRQRIFDVHPRUSKHPHVRFFXUVZKHQWKH\FRUUHVSRQGWRSKRQHPHVWKDWDUHRWKHUZLVHVXEMHFWWRFKDQJHRUORVV
*UDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVLQVXFKLQVWDQFHVDUHH[SUHVVHGE\DOWHUQDWHPHDQVVXFKDVZRUGRUGHUDQGDGSRVLWLRQV@%
:KHQWKHLQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHV\VWHPLVORVWRQQRXQVE\HLWKHUV\QFUHWLVPRUSKRQRORJLFDOSURFHVVHVFDVHPDUNLQJ
WHQGVWREHSUHVHUYHGLQWKHSURQRPLQDOV\VWHPHVSHFLDOO\RQERXQGSURQRXQV7KXVPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHPDUNLQJ
GRHVQRWKDYHWRRFFXURQERWKQRXQVDQGSURQRXQVWRWKHVDPHGHJUHHLQDQ\JLYHQODQJXDJH,WIUHTXHQWO\RF
FXUVWKDWFDVHLVRQO\PRUSKRORJLFDOO\PDUNHGLQWKHSURQRPLQDOV\VWHP³UHIOHFWLQJWKHYHVWLJHRIDQRULJLQDOO\

,ZRXOGOLNHWRVLQFHUHO\WKDQN'HQQLV3DUGHHIRUKLVKHOSIXOFRP LQXVHIURPWKHQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHGDWLYHDQGDEODWLYH %ODNH

PHQWVDQGFRUUHFWLRQVIRULPSURYLQJWKLVHVVD\$OORSLQLRQVDQG
HUURUVDUHRIFRXUVHP\UHVSRQVLELOLW\DORQH
O
%ODNH
:
%ODNH²$QGHUVRQ  SURYLGHVWKHIROORZLQJGHIL
QLWLRQEDVHGRQWUDGLWLRQDOWKHRULHVRIFDVH´$JUDPPDURIFDVHJLYHV
DQDFFRXQWRIWKHV\QWD[RIWKHUHODWLRQVWKDWDUHW\SLFDOO\H[SUHVVHG
E\FDVHLQIOHFWLRQRUDGSRVLWLRQVRUSRVLWLRQµ0RVWODQJXDJHVXVH
ERWKDQDO\WLFDODQGV\QWKHWLFFDVHPDUNLQJ$QDO\WLFDOFDVHPDUNHUV
DUHPRUHOLNHO\WREHIRXQGZLWKQRQFRUHFDVHVVXFKDVWKHDEOD
WLYHLQVWUXPHQWDOORFDWLYHDQGVRRQZKLOHV\QWKHWLFPDUNHUVDUH
PRUHOLNHO\WREHXVHGIRUFRUHFDVHVZKLFKLQFOXGHWKHQRPLQDWLYH
HUJDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHDQGGDWLYH %ODNH 
Q
%ODNH
<
%ODNH
R
%ODNH$QGHUVRQ7KHJHQLWLYHLVSULPDULO\DG
QRPLQDOWKDWLVLWLVQRWXVHGDVYHUEDOFRPSOHPHQWDQGWKXVGLIIHUV
 

%ODNH,QDGGLWLRQWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYHDUHZKDW
LVRIWHQUHIHUUHGWRDV´FRUHµFDVHVDOVRFDOOHG´JUDPPDWLFDOFDVHVµ
³VHHDOVRQRWHDERYH³ZKLOHWKHDEODWLYHLQVWUXPHQWDODQGVR
RQDUHUHIHUUHGWRDV´VHPDQWLFµFDVHVZKLFKSULPDULO\H[SUHVVOR
FDWLRQSXWWLQJWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYHDJDLQFORVHUWRJHWKHU
RQDIXQFWLRQDOEDVLV %ODNH² 7KHJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQV
SHUWDLQLQJWRFDVHFDQEHRUGHUHGKLHUDUFKLFDOO\,QIOHFWLRQDOV\VWHPV
WHQGWREXLOGXSLQWKHRUGHU)6>#)($#?!%Ö%(4410($#?!%Ö%5!)#$#?!%Ö%"($#?!%Ö%
.64($#?!%Ö%(&.($#?!l#)0$-1>!)$(.%Ö%6$+!-07KLVKLHUDUFKLFDORUGHUPHDQV
WKDWODQJXDJHVWKDWKDYHDQLQIOHFWLRQDOO\PDUNHGORFDWLYHDOVRKDYH
DQRPLQDWLYHDQGDWOHDVWRQHRWKHUFRUHFDVH %ODNH :KHQ
WKHUHLVDQXQPDUNHGFDVHZLWKLQDODQJXDJHWKDWKDVDQLQIOHFWLRQDO
FDVHV\VWHPLWLVXVXDOO\WKHQRPLQDWLYHUDUHO\WKHDFFXVDWLYH
@
%ODNH

O?O
 oi.uchicago.edu

O?:% K8S833<%O<778NS<3O

PRUHSURGXFWLYHFDVHLQIOHFWLRQ³DVFDQHDVLO\EHH[HPSOLILHGE\(QJOLVKZKLFKIRUH[DPSOHRQO\GLVWLQJXLVKHV
WKHDFFXVDWLYHLQLQGHSHQGHQWSURQRXQVDVLQ´, QRPLQDWLYH VDZKLP DFFXVDWLYH µDQG´+H QRPLQDWLYH VDZ
PH DFFXVDWLYH µYHUVXV´7KHPDQ QRPLQDWLYH FKDVHGWKHGRJ DFFXVDWLYH µDQG´7KHGRJ QRPLQDWLYH FKDVHG
WKHPDQ DFFXVDWLYH µ
,Q6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVZHKDYHHYLGHQFHIRUDQRULJLQDOWULSWRWLFLQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHV\VWHPLQWKHVLQJXODUDQG
DGLSWRWLFLQIOHFWLRQLQWKHGXDODQGSOXUDO7KHWULSWRWLFLQIOHFWLRQFRQVLVWVRIDQRPLQDWLYHPDUNHGE\VXIIL[HG
1DJHQLWLYHH[SUHVVHGE\#DQGDQDFFXVDWLYHPDUNHGE\(7KHGLSWRWLFLQIOHFWLRQRIWKHGXDODQGSOXUDOKDV
DFRQWUDVWEHWZHHQDQRPLQDWLYHYHUVXVREOLTXHWKHPDVFXOLQHQRPLQDWLYHSOXUDOEHLQJPDUNHGE\ࡃDQGWKH
REOLTXHE\ҸZKLOHWKHGXDOLVH[SUHVVHGE\čLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQG('%LQWKHREOLTXHUHVXOWLQJLQWKHIROORZLQJ
SDUDGLJPPZKLFKUHIOHFWVWKH3URWR6HPLWLFFDVHV\VWHPRIPDVFXOLQHQRXQVDFFRUGLQJWRWUDGLWLRQDOUHFRQVWUXF
K8FH9NO?

$8HIL>67 3L6> 5>L76>

1RPLQDWLYH 1 č ࡃ
*HQLWLYH # M(' Ҹ
$FFXVDWLYH ( M(' Ҹ

7KH6HPLWLFVXEEUDQFKUHOHYDQWIRUWKHSUHVHQWLQYHVWLJDWLRQLV1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLFZKLFKFRQVLVWVRI8JD
ULWLF$UDPDLFDQG&DQDDQLWHOO&DQDDQLWHLQWXUQLQFOXGHV+HEUHZ3KRHQLFLDQ3XQLF0RDELWHDQGDIHZRWKHU
VSDUFHO\DWWHVWHGODQJXDJHVGLDOHFWV2IWKH1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLFODQJXDJHV8JDULWLFSUHVHUYHVWKHIXOOLQIOHFWLRQDO
FDVHV\VWHPZKLOH$UDPDLF³LQPRVWRILWVDWWHVWHGVWDJHV³DQG+HEUHZFRPSOHWHO\ORVWPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVH
GLVWLQFWLRQ7KHSUHVHUYDWLRQRIWKHFDVHV\VWHPLQ8JDULWLFDOORZVXVWRUHFRQVWUXFWWKHVDPHIXOO\SURGXFWLYH
LQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHV\VWHPIRU3URWR1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLFDVIRU3URWR6HPLWLFWKDWWKHQXQGHUZHQWUHGXFWLRQDQG
ORVVLQVRPHRILWVGHVFHQGDQWEUDQFKHV7KHYDULRXVVWDJHVRIFDVHPDUNLQJDWWHVWHGLQWKH1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLF
ODQJXDJHVPDNHWKLVVXEEUDQFKRI6HPLWLFRIVSHFLDOLQWHUHVWIRUWKHVWXG\RIFDVHLQIOHFWLRQDQGORVVWKHUHRI
QRWRQO\IRUWKHXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHGHYHORSPHQWVXQGHUO\LQJWKHQRPLQDOLQIOHFWLRQRI1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLFEXW
DOVRIRU6HPLWLFLQJHQHUDO
7KHPDLQTXHVWLRQWREHDVNHGLVZKHWKHULWLVSRVVLEOHWRWUDFHWKHORVVRIPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHPDUNHUVLQ
WKRVH1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLFEUDQFKHVWKDWFOHDUO\VKRZDUHGXFWLRQRILQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHPDUNLQJWKDWLV$UDPDLFDQG
&DQDDQLWHDQGPRUHLPSRUWDQWO\ZKHWKHUWKHSURFHVVXQGHUO\LQJWKLVORVVFRQIRUPVWRWKHW\SRORJLFDOWHQGHQ
FLHVRXWOLQHGDERYH7KHUHPDLQGHURIWKLVDUWLFOHIRFXVHVRQWKHVHTXHVWLRQV

"=<9>5;>
7KHIROORZLQJVHFWLRQVGLVFXVVWKHHYLGHQFHIRUFDVHPDUNLQJLQ2OG$UDPDLF$PDUQD&DQDDQLWHDQG3KRH
QLFLDQ7KHVHHDUOLHVWVWDJHVRI$UDPDLFDQG&DQDDQLWHUHIOHFWWKHSHULRGVLQZKLFKZHFDQVWLOOHLWKHUWUDFHD
SURGXFWLYHLQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHV\VWHPRUFDVHZDVLQWKHSURFHVVRIEHLQJORVW,QJHQHUDOWKHORVVRIFDVHLQIOHFWLRQ
LQWKHVHODQJXDJHVLVGHSHQGHQWRQWKHORVVRIILQDOVKRUWYRZHOVWKDWUHVXOWHGLQWKHFROODSVHRIWKHFDVHV\VWHP
LQWKHVLQJXODUDQGVXEVHTXHQWO\LQWKHSOXUDOE\DQDORJ\WRWKHVLQJXODU


%ODNH
P
$QRPLQDWLYHaREOLTXHGLVWLQFWLRQLVFRPPRQFURVVOLQJXLVWLFDO
O\,QIDFWZKHQDODQJXDJHRQO\KDVDWZRFDVHV\VWHPLWXVXDOO\
FRQVLVWVRIDQRPLQDWLYHYHUVXVREOLTXHGLVWLQFWLRQ³UDWKHUWKDQD
QRPLQDWLYHYHUVXVDFFXVDWLYH³ZLWKWKHREOLTXHFRYHULQJDZLGH
UDQJHRIIXQFWLRQV %ODNH 
O?
)RUWKLVUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDQGSUHVHQWDWLRQRIWKHFDVHV\VWHPRIFODVVLFDO
6HPLWLF ODQJXDJHV VHH IRU H[DPSOH /LSL‫ش‬VNL   +XHKQHUJDUG
  1RXQV LQ 3URWR6HPLWLF DOVR H[KLELW ϮQDO PLPDWLRQ DQG
QXQDWLRQ 0LPDWLRQ DQG QXQDWLRQ FDQ EH QHJOHFWHG LQ WKH SUHVHQW
VWXG\VLQFHWKH\KDYHQRGLUHFWLPSDFWRQWKHLVVXHGLVFXVVHG7KHIXOO
FDVH LQϰHFWLRQ LQ WKH VLQJXODU GXDO DQG SOXUDO DV SUHVHQWHG KHUH LV
IRUH[DPSOHSUHVHUYHGLQ&ODVVLFDO$UDELFDQG$NNDGLDQ2WKHU6HPLWLF
ODQJXDJHV VXFK DV *H૛H] KDYH D UHGXFHG V\VWHP RI FDVH LQϰHFWLRQ
*H૛H]GLVWLQJXLVKHVDQDFFXVDWLYHLQ(IURPDQRQDFFXVDWLYHLQã7KLV
UHGXFHGV\VWHPLVWKHUHVXOWRIDVHULHVRIVRXQGFKDQJHVLQZKLFKVKRUW
LDQGXZHUHUHGXFHGWR̽DQG̽ZDVVXEVHTXHQWO\ORVWLQZRUG
ϮQDOSRVLWLRQ³DSURFHVVWKDWDϸHFWHGWKHPRUSKRORJLFDOPDUNHUVRI
WKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGJHQLWLYHVLQJXODU
OO
7KH6HPLWLFODQJXDJHIDPLO\LVVXEGLYLGHGLQWRWZRPDLQEUDQFKHV
(DVW6HPLWLFFRQVLVWLQJRI$NNDGLDQDQG(EODLWHDQG:HVW6HPLWLF
ZKLFKLQFOXGHVDOORWKHU6HPLWLFODQJXDJHV:HVW6HPLWLFLQWXUQ
EUDQFKHVRIILQWR(WKLRSLDQ6HPLWLF0RGHUQ6RXWK$UDELDQDQG&HQ
WUDO6HPLWLF&HQWUDO6HPLWLFLVVXEGLYLGHGLQWR$UDELF2OG6RXWK
$UDELDQDQG1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLF1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLFDOVRLQFOXGHVWKH
HYLGHQFHIURP$PRULWHSHUVRQDOQDPHVEXWVLQFHWKHFDVHV\VWHP
LQWKHVHQDPHVVWLOOGHILHVFHUWDLQLQWHUSUHWDWLRQLWLVQRWGLVFXVVHG
LQWKHSUHVHQWFRQWH[W)RUWKHFODVVLILFDWLRQRI6HPLWLFDVRXWOLQHG
DERYHVHH+XHKQHUJDUG
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 8<KNY%3<B<<B/*8%<BH%,NH%<K<A</3%3<78%/B%*O8%N/DO*%,F%N<BD\<D8%*Y@,N,DY% O?Q

-?9'#7@A@<;
7KHHDUOLHVW$UDPDLFWH[WXDOPDWHULDO³XVXDOO\UHIHUUHGWRDV´2OG$UDPDLFµ³FRPHVIURPLQVFULSWLRQVGDWLQJ
WRWKHQLQWKWRHLJKWKFHQWXULHVᄽᅐWKDWZHUHSULPDULO\IRXQGLQ6\ULDDQGVRXWKHUQ$QDWROLDO:7KHVFULSWXVHG
LQWKHVHLQVFULSWLRQVLVDFRQVRQDQWDODOSKDEHWWKDWGRHVQRWPDUNVKRUWYRZHOVLQDQ\SRVLWLRQZKLFKPDNHVLW
LPSRVVLEOHWRVD\DQ\WKLQJFRQFOXVLYHDERXWWKHVWDWXVRIPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHPDUNLQJLQWKHVLQJXODU OQ%"FHK767E%
WRVKRUWYRZHOVORQJYRZHOVDUHXVXDOO\LQGLFDWHGDWOHDVWZRUGILQDOO\E\FHUWDLQFRQVRQDQWVIXQFWLRQLQJDVZKDW
LVFRPPRQO\FDOOHG>($-!0%.!4$#6)#0³WKHWZRLPSRUWDQWRQHVLQRXUFRQWH[WDUH:!IRUࡃDQG<!IRUҸ7KH
RQO\HQYLURQPHQWLQZKLFKZHZRXOGH[SHFWDQRUWKRJUDSKLFUHIOH[RIGLIIHUHQWFDVHV³LIWKHXQGHUO\LQJ$UDPDLF
VWLOOGLVWLQJXLVKHGFDVHPRUSKRORJLFDOO\³LVWKHUHIRUHLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGREOLTXHPDVFXOLQHSOXUDO0RVW
2OG$UDPDLFWH[WVGRQRWVKRZDQ\RUWKRJUDSKLFGLVWLQFWLRQRIPDVFXOLQHSOXUDOQRXQVDFFRUGLQJWRV\QWDFWLF
FRQWH[W,QWKH=DNNXU%DU+DGGDG%DUUDNLEDQG6HILUHLQVFULSWLRQVWKHDEVROXWHPDVFXOLQHSOXUDOXVXDOO\HQGV
LQQXQDWLRQZLWKRXWDQ\LQGLFDWLRQRIWKHSUHFHGLQJYRZHODVLQ૟OKQ´JRGVµ>.)´ZRUGVµDQGVRRQZKLOHWKH
FRQVWUXFWUHJXODUO\HQGVLQM'2%69%8H%E૛O\´ORUGVRIµ>X)'´SRVVHVVLRQVRIµDQG)k'´ZRPHQRIµO<%DVHGRQWKHVH
VSHOOLQJVSDUWLFXODUO\WKHXQLIRUPVSHOOLQJRIWKHPDVFXOLQHSOXUDOFRQVWUXFWDV<!LQGHSHQGHQWRIFDVHLWLV
IDLUO\FHUWDLQWKDWPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHPDUNLQJZDVORVWLQWKH$UDPDLFGLDOHFWVUHIOHFWHGE\WKHVHWH[WV7KHRQO\
2OG$UDPDLFVXEFRUSXVWKDWXVHVGLIIHUHQWIRUPVLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGREOLTXHPDVFXOLQHSOXUDOLVWKHWH[WV
IURPWKHDQFLHQWVLWHRI6DP૟DOPRGHUQ=LQoLUOLOR,QWKHVHWH[WVWKHQRPLQDWLYHDEVROXWHLVZULWWHQZLWK:!
DQGWKHREOLTXHZLWK<!DVLQ૟OKZ´JRGVµG=-9´PHQµ>.=9´NLQJVµ QRPLQDWLYH DQG૟EQ\´VWRQHVµ૟OK\´JRGVµ
DQGG=-'´PHQµLQWKHREOLTXH7KHGLVWLQFWLRQRIWKHWZRIRUPVRIWKHPDVFXOLQHSOXUDODFFRUGLQJWRV\QWDFWLF
FRQWH[WVHHPVWREHUHJXODULQ6DP૟DOLDQ$QRWKHULQGLFDWLRQWKDW6DP૟DOLDQKDGPRVWOLNHO\QRW\HWFRPSOHWHO\
ORVWLWVLQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHV\VWHPLVWKHDEVHQFHRIDGLUHFWREMHFWPDUNHUXVHGWRGLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQ6DQG2DIWHU
WKHORVVRIPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHPDUNLQJLQFODXVHVLQZKLFKWKHWZRFRXOGEHFRQIXVHG2WKHU2OG$UDPDLFWH[WV
VXFKDVWKH=DNNXUDQG6HILUHLQVFULSWLRQVXVHWKHGLUHFWREMHFWPDUNHU૟\WDOWKRXJKLWVXVHVHHPVWREHRSWLRQDO
LQWKHVHWH[WVO@1HYHUWKHOHVVWKHUHDUHDOVRLQGLFDWLRQVWKDWFDVHZDVQRWDOZD\VIXOO\SUHVHUYHGLQ6DP૟DOLDQ,Q
WKHZRUGVIRU´IDWKHUµDQG´EURWKHUµDORQJࡃZULWWHQDV:!LVIRXQGDVDOLQNLQJYRZHOEHWZHHQWKHQRPLQDO
EDVHDQGWKHSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[DVLQ૟DEࡃKLZULWWHQ૟EZKZKLFKLVDUHIOH[RIWKHRULJLQDOQRPLQDWLYHFDVHYRZHO
,QWHUHVWLQJO\WKLVIRUPLVFOHDUO\UHSUHVHQWLQJWKHJHQLWLYHLQWKHSKUDVHEE\W૟EZK´LQWKHKRXVHRIKLVIDWKHUµ%
2FFXUUHQFHVOLNHWKLVLQGLFDWHWKDWWKHSUHVXIIL[IRUPRIWKLVQRXQZDVPRVWOLNHO\DOUHDG\IL[HGZLWKWKHYRZHO
WKDWRULJLQDOO\UHSUHVHQWHGWKHQRPLQDWLYHZKLFKLQWXUQVXJJHVWVDWOHDVWDSDUWLDOORVVRIPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVH
GLVWLQFWLRQOP
,WLVFOHDUIURPWKHHYLGHQFHPHQWLRQHGVRIDUWKDWWKHHDUOLHVWIRUPVRI$UDPDLFUHSUHVHQWHGE\WKHLQVFULS
WLRQVIURP6DP૟DOSUHVHUYHGPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHPDUNLQJDWOHDVWLQFHUWDLQLQVWDQFHV,QRWKHU2OG$UDPDLFFRU
SRUDZKLFKUHIOHFWGLIIHUHQWDQGPRUHLQQRYDWLYHGLDOHFWVRI$UDPDLFPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHPDUNLQJZDVORVWLQ
WKHVHWH[WVZHILQGWKHILUVWRFFXUUHQFHVRIDGLUHFWREMHFWPDUNHUZKLFKLQGLFDWHVWKDWDWOHDVWQRPLQDWLYHDQG
DFFXVDWLYHPXVWKDYHEHHQXQGLVWLQJXLVKDEOHPRUSKRORJLFDOO\'HVSLWHWKHIDFWWKDWZHFDQQRWLFHGLIIHUHQWVWDJHV
RIFDVHPDUNLQJLQWKHVHHDUO\$UDPDLFGLDOHFWVLWLVGLIILFXOWWRVD\DQ\WKLQJDERXWWKHH[DFWSURFHVVXQGHUO\LQJ

O:
)RUWKHGHILQLWLRQRI´2OG$UDPDLFµDVUHIOHFWLQJWKHLQVFULSWLRQV
GRZQWRWKHHLJKWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐVHH'HJHQ
OQ
7KHUHDUHYHVWLJHVLQERWK2OG$UDPDLFDQGODWHU$UDPDLFRIRULJL
QDOVLQJXODUFDVHHQGLQJVLQFHUWDLQIUR]HQIRUPVVXFKDVWKHRULJLQDO
QRPLQDWLYHFDVHYRZHOࡃLQWKHZRUGVIRU´IDWKHUµDQG´EURWKHUµ
EHIRUHSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVDQGWKHDFFXVDWLYHHQGLQJDLQFHUWDLQ
DGYHUELDOH[SUHVVLRQVVXFKDV.'.૟´DWQLJKWµ&-૟´RXWVLGHµDQG૟U૛૟%
´EHORZµ 6HJHUW 
O<
'HJHQ
OR
7KHOLQJXLVWLFFODVVLILFDWLRQRIWKHQRQ3KRHQLFLDQDQGQRQ6WDQ
GDUG$UDPDLFWH[WVIURP=LQoLUOLLVVWLOODPDWWHURIGLVSXWHDOWKRXJK
PRVWVFKRODUVWHQGWRZDUGDQLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIWKHODQJXDJHGLDOHFW
DVDQDUFKDLFIRUPRI$UDPDLFVHHIRUH[DPSOH%URFNHOPDQQ
'LRQ*DUU)DOHV

6HJHUW7URSSHU7KHVLWXDWLRQLQWKHFRQVWUXFW
SOXUDOLVOHVVFOHDU7KHUHLVKDUGO\DQ\HYLGHQFHIRUQRXQVLQWKH
QRPLQDWLYHFRQVWUXFW7KHUHVHHPVWRRFFXURQHFDVHRI‘PDUNLQJ
IRUWKHQRPLQDWLYHSOXUDODQGRQHLQ<!7KHODWWHUPLJKWLQGLFDWH
DVKLIWRIWKHFRQVWUXFWPDUNLQJLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHWR' IRU (' 
ZKLFKLVWKHUHJXODUZD\WRPDUNWKHREOLTXHPDVFXOLQHSOXUDOFRQ
VWUXFW 7URSSHU %HIRUHSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVWKHUHVHHPV
WR EH D GLVWLQFWLRQ EHWZHHQ D QRPLQDWLYH SOXUDO LQ ࡃ ZULWWHQ
GHIHFWLYHO\DVLQ૟ \єK´KLVEURWKHUVµ QRPLQDWLYH DQGDQREOLTXH
PDVFXOLQHSOXUDOLQD\ZULWWHQDV<!DVLQ૟ 'є'+´KLVEURWKHUVµ
REOLTXH DQG'9>'+´KLVGD\Vµ REOLTXH  7URSSHU 
O@
*DUU

7URSSHU
OP
7URSSHU7KHVDPHIL[HGYRZHOࡃEHIRUHSURQRPLQDO
VXIIL[HVLVNQRZQIURPODWHU$UDPDLFGLDOHFWVVXFKDV%LEOLFDO$UD
PDLFDQG6\ULDFZKHUHZHUHJXODUO\ILQG૟ (ȯࡃKv´KLVIDWKHUµ %LEOLFDO
$UDPDLF DQG૟(ȯࡃ + y 6\ULDF 'IRUDOOFDVHV6DP૟DOLDQGRHVQRWGLVWLQ
JXLVKFDVHLQLQGHSHQGHQWDQDSKRULFGHPRQVWUDWLYHDQGVXIIL[HG
SURQRXQVZKLFKDOOKDYHDVLQJOHIRUPLQGHSHQGHQWRIFDVH 7URSSHU
 7KHVDPHLVWUXHIRUDOORWKHU2OG$UDPDLFWH[WV 6HJHUW
² 
 oi.uchicago.edu

O?<% K8S833<%O<778NS<3O

WKHORVVRILQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHPDUNLQJ:KHWKHUWKHORVVILUVWUHVXOWHGLQDPHUJHURIQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYHRU
DOVRLQFOXGHGWKHJHQLWLYHFDQQRWEHGHWHUPLQHGRQWKHEDVLVRIWKHDYDLODEOHHYLGHQFH:?

"@7?B'(@5@@5<6>
7KHHDUOLHVWHYLGHQFHIRU&DQDDQLWHOHWWHUVZULWWHQLQD&DQDDQL]LQJIRUPRI$NNDGLDQIRXQGDW(O$PDUQD
GDWLQJWRWKHIRXUWHHQWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐH[KLELWVDIXOO\SURGXFWLYHFDVHV\VWHPWKDWLVLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKWKHFDVH
V\VWHPUHFRQVWUXFWHGIRU3URWR1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLF³WKDWLVZHILQGDWULSWRWLFLQIOHFWLRQLQWKHVLQJXODUDQGD
UHJXODUGLSWRWLFFDVHGLVWLQFWLRQLQWKHGXDODQGSOXUDO:O
7KHIDFWWKDWWKHDWWHVWHGFDVHLQIOHFWLRQLVSDUWRIWKHXQGHUO\LQJ&DQDDQLWHDQGQRWPHUHO\DIHDWXUHRI
$NNDGLDQLVSURYHQE\RFFXUUHQFHVRI&DQDDQLWHJORVVHVWKDWVKRZPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHLQIOHFWLRQVXFKDV-1Mk1M
)1´RXUKHDGµLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGWDDђWDPX´EHQHDWKWKHPµDQGOHOiPD´DWQLJKWµLQWKHDFFXVDWLYH7KH
ILUVWJORVVFDQQRWEHLQWHUSUHWHGDVUHIOHFWLQJ$NNDGLDQPRUSKRORJ\VLQFHQRUPDWLYH$NNDGLDQZRXOGQRWPDUN
WKHPDVFXOLQHVLQJXODUQRPLQDWLYHLQWKHFRQVWUXFWEHIRUHDSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[ZLWK1%LQWKLVQRPLQDOSDWWHUQ::%
)XUWKHUPRUHWKH$NNDGLDQRIWKH$PDUQDOHWWHUVDOVRVRPHWLPHVKDVFDVHYRZHOVRQVLQJXODUFRQVWUXFWVZLWK
DQGZLWKRXWSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVWKDWFDQQRWEHDWWULEXWHGWR$NNDGLDQXVDJH7KHVHRFFXUUHQFHVDUHFRPPRQO\
DWWULEXWHGWR:HVW6HPLWLFLQIOXHQFHH[DPSOHVLQFOXGH(M9(M$1%ቈዼᇀ႐ቈ´WKHZRUGRIWKHNLQJµLQWKHQRPLQDWLYH
(O$PDUQD (M>(M$(R%ቈዼᇀ႐ቈ´WKHFRPPDQGRIWKHNLQJµLQWKHDFFXVDWLYH (O$PDUQD (M"#%=(Mk(M"#%
ቈዼᇀ႐ቈ´XQWLOWKHDUULYDORIWKHNLQJµLQWKHJHQLWLYH (O$PDUQD DQGRWKHUV:Q7KHVHRFFXUUHQFHVVXJJHVW
WKDWWKHXQGHUO\LQJ&DQDDQLWHPRVWOLNHO\SUHVHUYHGFDVHLQIOHFWLRQRQVLQJXODUFRQVWUXFWVFRQWUDU\WR$NNDGLDQ
ZKLFKORVWDQ\NLQGRIFDVHGLVWLQFWLRQLQWKLVHQYLURQPHQWDIWHUWKH2OG$NNDGLDQSHULRG:<
&RQWUDU\WR2OG$UDPDLFWKH$PDUQDOHWWHUVDOVRH[KLELWFDVHGLVWLQFWLRQLQWKHSURQRPLQDOV\VWHP7KHPDV
FXOLQHVLQJXODUDQDSKRULFSURQRXQIRUH[DPSOHKDVGLVWLQFWIRUPVIRUWKHQRPLQDWLYHIRUZKLFKZHILQGk1M1$2%
DQGWKHREOLTXHZKLFKLVDWWHVWHGDVk1M(M$(DQGk1M(M$#:R%
7KHUHJXODUGLVWLQFWLRQRIFDVHVLQERWKWKHQRPLQDODQGSURQRPLQDOV\VWHPLQ$PDUQD&DQDDQLWHDOORZVXV
WRUHFRQVWUXFWDSURGXFWLYHLQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHV\VWHPIRU3URWR&DQDDQLWHZLWKDWULSWRWLFLQIOHFWLRQLQWKHVLQJX
ODURQERWKERXQGDQGXQERXQGQRXQVDQGDGLSWRWLFLQIOHFWLRQLQWKHSOXUDODQGGXDO7KLVUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRI
3URWR&DQDDQLWHDOVRLPSOLHVWKDWWKHDQFHVWRU V RIERWK+HEUHZDQGPRUHLPSRUWDQWO\3KRHQLFLDQH[KLELWHG
WKHVDPHSURGXFWLYHFDVHPDUNLQJV\VWHP

4C8>5<;<@5
3KRHQLFLDQLVWKHPRVWLQIRUPDWLYHFRUSXVZLWKUHJDUGWRFDVHPDUNLQJDQGORVVWKHUHRIGLVFXVVHGLQWKH
SUHVHQWFRQWH[W

:?
$UDPDLFGLDOHFWVDIWHUWKHHLJKWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐFOHDUO\GRQRWSUH
VHUYHDQ\PRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHGLVWLQFWLRQ)RUWKHWH[WVIURPWKH
VHYHQWKDQGVL[WKFHQWXULHVᄽᅐVHH+XJIRUWKHPDWHULDO
IURPWKH$FKDHPHQLGSHULRGVHH0XUDRNDDQG3RUWHQ7KH
ZULWLQJRIPDVFXOLQHSOXUDOQRXQVLQWKHVHFRUSRUDIROORZVWKHVDPH
SULQFLSOHVIRXQGLQ2OG$UDPDLFLQVFULSWLRQVRWKHUWKDQWKRVHIURP
=LQoLUOL
:O
5DLQH\YRO²7KHIXQFWLRQVRIWKHFDVHVDOVRFRQIRUP
WR WKH IXQFWLRQV NQRZQ IURP RWKHU 6HPLWLF ODQJXDJHV WKDW SUHVHUYH
PRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHPDUNLQJVXFKDV$NNDGLDQDQG&ODVVLFDO$UDELF7KH
QRPLQDWLYHLVXVHGWRH[SUHVVWKHVXEMHFWRIDFODXVHDQGDVDSUHGLFDWLYH
IRUPLQQRPLQDOFODXVHV 5DLQH\YRO 7KHJHQLWLYHPDUNVD
)6>!)%-!4$1>LQWKHFRQVWUXFWDQGLVXVHGDIWHUSUHSRVLWLRQVLQDGGLWLRQ
WRPDUNLQJSRVVHVVLRQ7KHDFFXVDWLYHLVSULPDULO\XVHGWRLQGLFDWHWKH
GLUHFWREMHFWEXWDOVRVKRZVWKHVDPHDGYHUELDODQGWHPSRUDOXVHVDV
WKHDFFXVDWLYHLQ$NNDGLDQDQG&ODVVLFDO$UDELFDVLQOHOiPD´DWQLJKWµ
DQG$(M(ђM$(M>1%´EHQHDWKWKHPµ7KHDFFXVDWLYHLVDOVRXVHGWRPDUNWKH
VXEMHFWDIWHUWKHH[LVWHQWLDOQHJDWLYHSDUWLFOH\čQXZKLFKUHϰHFWV:HVW
6HPLWLFXVDJH 5DLQH\ YRO² 'HVSLWHWKHIDFWWKDW
FDVH PDUNLQJ E\ PRUSKRORJLFDO Dϲ[HV LV JHQHUDOO\ SUHVHUYHG LQ WKH
&DQDDQL]LQJ$PDUQDOHWWHUVHUURUVGRRFFXU,WLVDPDWWHURIGLVSXWH
ZKHWKHUWKHVHLQVWDQFHVUHSUHVHQWVFULEDOHUURUVRUPDUNWKHEHJLQQLQJ
RIWKHEUHDNGRZQRIWKHFDVHV\VWHP5DLQH\IDYRUVWKHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ
DVVFULEDOHUURUV 5DLQH\YRO DOWKRXJKLQP\RSLQLRQWKLV
TXHVWLRQUHTXLUHVIXUWKHULQYHVWLJDWLRQ
::
)RUWKHDWWHVWDWLRQVVHH5DLQH\YRO
:Q
)RUPRUHH[DPSOHVVHH5DLQH\YRO²
:<
)RUWKHGLVWLQFWLRQRIDJHQLWLYHRQVLQJXODUFRQVWUXFWVLQ6DUJRQLF
$NNDGLDQVHH+DVVHOEDFK7KHSUHVHUYDWLRQRIFDVHYRZHOV
RQWKHFRQVWUXFWLVDOVRNQRZQIURP&ODVVLFDO$UDELFDQG8JDULWLF
)RU8JDULWLFVHH7URSSHU
:R
5DLQH\YRO²7KHTXHVWLRQQDWXUDOO\DULVHVZKHWKHU
WKHVH IRUPV UHIOHFW JHQXLQH &DQDDQLWH RU $NNDGLDQ GLVWLQFWLRQV
KRZHYHUWKHUHLVQRFHUWDLQDQVZHUWRWKLVTXHVWLRQ7KHIRUPVDUH
$NNDGLDQ³$VV\ULDQLQWKHFDVHRIk1M1$³DOWKRXJKJLYHQWKHRFFXU
UHQFHVRIVHHPLQJO\JHQXLQH&DQDDQLWHFDVHPDUNLQJLQWKHQRPLQDO
V\VWHPLWLVDOVRSRVVLEOHWKDWWKHVHIRUPVUHIOHFW&DQDDQLWHXVDJH
ZLWKUHJDUGWRWKHGLVWLQFWLRQRIFDVH

7KHGXDOLVSULPDULO\XVHGIRUSDLUHGERG\SDUWVLQ$PDUQD&D
QDDQLWH7KHQRPLQDWLYHLVDWWHVWHGDVčLQWKHJORVVђHQDLD´P\
H\HVµDQGWKHREOLTXHDV̒%8H%#M)(%X(M$!M=(´LQ\RXUKDQGVµ 5DLQH\
YRO² 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 8<KNY%3<B<<B/*8%<BH%,NH%<K<A</3%3<78%/B%*O8%N/DO*%,F%N<BD\<D8%*Y@,N,DY% O?R

'XULQJWKHRYHUWKRXVDQG\HDUVRILWVDWWHVWDWLRQWKH3KRHQLFLDQODQJXDJHXQGHUZHQWVHYHUDOQRWLFHDEOH
FKDQJHVDQGLVFRPPRQO\VXEGLYLGHGLQWRYDULRXVSHULRGVDQGGLDOHFWV:@7KHPRVWLPSRUWDQWSHULRGVGLDOHFWVIRU
WKHSUHVHQWLQYHVWLJDWLRQDUH2OG%\EOLDQWKDWLVWKHLQVFULSWLRQDOPDWHULDOIURPWKHWHQWKDQGQLQWKFHQWXULHV
ᄽᅐIURP%\EORVWKDWUHIOHFWVDQDUFKDLFGLDOHFWRI3KRHQLFLDQ%\EOLDQDQG6WDQGDUG3KRHQLFLDQ
2OG%\EOLDQDQG6WDQGDUG3KRHQLFLDQDUHZULWWHQLQDQHQWLUHO\FRQVRQDQWDOVFULSW7KHUHLVQRLQGLFDWLRQRI
HLWKHUVKRUWRUORQJYRZHOVDQGFRQVHTXHQWO\QRGLUHFWHYLGHQFHIRUWKHYRFDOLFFDVHDIIL[HVRIHLWKHUWKHVLQ
JXODURUSOXUDO1HYHUWKHOHVVWKHUHDUHVHYHUDOLQQHU3KRHQLFLDQIHDWXUHVWKDWLQGLFDWHWKHVWDWXVRIWKHRULJLQDO
YRFDOLFFDVHPDUNHUV
,Q2OG%\EOLDQDQG2OG3KRHQLFLDQQRXQVLQWKHFRQVWUXFWVWDWHLQZKLFKWKHILUVWQRXQHQGVLQQDVVLPLODWH
WKHQWRWKHILUVWFRQVRQDQWRIWKHQH[WZRUGDVLQE\єPONEL\\DєࡃPLON´VRQRI<DєࡃPLONµ &#)MYL .$,,
2OG%\EOLDQ DQG&=.&'ELNNDOED\´VRQRI.DOED\µ &#)MbL .$,2OG%\EOLDQ 7KHDVVLPLODWLRQRIQFDQ
RQO\EHDFFRXQWHGIRUE\WKHDEVHQFHRIWKHILQDOFDVHYRZHOLQWKHVLQJXODUFRQVWUXFW$VLPLODUSKHQRPHQRQ
FDQEHREVHUYHGLQZRUGVWKDWHQGLQDQRULJLQDOWULSKWKRQJLQFOXGLQJ\RUZWKDWZDVPRQRSKWKRQJL]HGDV
8H%TQ૟UߙIRUT‫گ‬Q9૟DUߙ´WKHFUHDWRURIWKHHDUWKµ T‫گ‬QL\9૟DUߙ .$,$,,,2OG3KRHQLFLDQ ZKLFKOLNHZLVH
LQGLFDWHVWKHDEVHQFHRIDILQDOFDVHYRZHO&RQVHTXHQWO\WKHORVVRIILQDOYRZHOVLQWKHFRQVWUXFWPXVWKDYH
RFFXUUHGQRODWHUWKDQWKHODWHHOHYHQWKRUHDUO\WHQWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐ2:PDQGLWLVSRVVLEOHWRVWDWHZLWKUHODWLYHFHU
WDLQW\WKDWQHLWKHU2OG%\EOLDQQRU2OG3KRHQLFLDQSUHVHUYHGFDVHPDUNLQJRQVLQJXODUQRXQVLQWKHFRQVWUXFW
ZLWKRXWSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HV
,Q6WDQGDUG3KRHQLFLDQZHILQGYDULDQWIRUPVRIFHUWDLQSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HV³WKHVXIIL[HVRIWKHILUVWFRP
PRQVLQJXODUWKLUGPDVFXOLQHVLQJXODUDQGWKLUGIHPLQLQHVLQJXODU³ZKLFKDUHGHSHQGHQWRQV\QWDFWLFFRQWH[WV
:KHQWKHQRXQLVLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHWKHVHVXIIL[HVDUHQRWLQGLFDWHGLQWKHZULWLQJZKLOHZKHQWKHQRXQLVLQ
WKHJHQLWLYHWKH\DUHUHSUHVHQWHGE\ILQDO<!Q?7KHRUWKRJUDSKLFDOO\XQPDUNHGIRUPVUHIOHFWILQDOYRZHOVZKLOH
WKHZULWLQJZLWK<!VWDQGVIRUDFRQVRQDQWQO

:@
3KRHQLFLDQDWWHVWDWLRQVUHDFKIURPDSSUR[LPDWHO\WKHHOHYHQWK
FHQWXU\ᄽᅐGRZQWRWKHIRXUWKFHQWXU\႐ᅡDQGFRYHUDZLGHJHR
JUDSKLFDODUHDWKDWUHDFKHVIURPWKH3KRHQLFLDQKRPHODQGZLWKLWV
FLWLHV6LGRQ7\UHDQG%\EORVWR6DP૟DOLQVRXWKHUQ$QDWROLDWR
(J\SW1RUWK$IULFD&\SUXVDQGVRRQ 6HJHUW²)ULHG
ULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R² 7KHWZRPDLQGLDOHFWV
GLVWLQJXLVKHGDUH3KRHQLFLDQWKHODQJXDJHRIWKHKRPHODQGDQG
3XQLFWKHYDULDQWRI3KRHQLFLDQXVHGLQWKH0HGLWHUUDQHDQFRORQLHV
SDUWLFXODUO\LQWKH&DUWKDJLQLDQHPSLUH 6HJHUW 3KRHQLFLDQ
LWVHOILVVXEGLYLGHGLQWRWKHGLDOHFWIURP%\EORV³DGLDOHFWWKDWLV
PDUNHGO\GLIIHUHQWIURPWKHUHVWRI3KRHQLFLDQ³WKDWKDVWZRPDLQ
VWDJHV2OG%\EOLDQ FDWHQWK²HLJKWKFHQWXULHVᄽᅐ DQG%\EOLDQ FD
VL[WK²IRXUWKFHQWXULHVᄽᅐ 0RVWRWKHU3KRHQLFLDQLQVFULSWLRQVDUH
ZULWWHQLQZKDWLVFDOOHG´6WDQGDUG3KRHQLFLDQµ6WDQGDUG3KRHQLFLDQ
FDQDJDLQEHVXEGLYLGHGLQWRGLIIHUHQWSHULRGV´2OG3KRHQLFLDQµ
ZKLFKVWDQGVIRUWKHHDUOLHVWDWWHVWDWLRQVIURPWKHQLQWKFHQWXU\WR
DSSUR[LPDWHO\WKHVHYHQWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐ´0LGGOH3KRHQLFLDQµIURP
WKHVL[WKWRIRXUWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐDQG/DWH3KRHQLFLDQIURPWKHWKLUG
WRILUVWFHQWXU\ᄽᅐ 6HJHUW 7KHLQVFULSWLRQVZULWWHQLQ
6WDQGDUG3KRHQLFLDQUHIOHFWDVWDQGDUGL]HGGLDOHFWRIWKHODQJXDJH
DQGDUHOLQJXLVWLFDOO\UHODWLYHO\KRPRJHQHRXV +DFNHWW 
3XQLFLVDWWHVWHGIURPDSSUR[LPDWHO\WKHILIWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐWRWKH
IRXUWKFHQWXU\႐ᅡ,WLVGLYLGHGLQWR´3XQLFµFRPSULVLQJWKHWH[WXDO
PDWHULDOIURPWKHILIWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐWRWKHIDOORI&DUWKDJHLQᄽᅐ2%
DQG´/DWHµRU´1HR3XQLFµZKLFKGHVLJQDWHVWKHODQJXDJHRIWKH
WH[WVIURP1RUWK$IULFDDIWHUWKHIDOORI&DUWKDJH 6HJHUW 

7KHSKUDVHVLQ.$,DQG.$,DUHLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHGHVLJQDW
LQJWKHVXEMHFWVRIWKHLUFODXVHVZKLOHWKHH[DPSOHIURP.$,LVLQ
WKHJHQLWLYH
:P
)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R†
Q?
7KHJHQLWLYHLVXVHGDIWHUDQRXQLQWKHFRQVWUXFWDIWHUSUHSR
VLWLRQVVXFKDV&M2%.MDQG૛.DQGDIWHUWKHGLUHFWREMHFWPDUNHU૟ '$%
)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R†† 
QO
)RUWKHIROORZLQJUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVHH+XHKQHUJDUG7KH
GLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQDQRPLQDWLYHaJHQLWLYHLQWKHILUVWFRPPRQ
VLQJXODULVRQO\SUHVHUYHGLQWKHHDUOLHVWVWDJHVRI3KRHQLFLDQWKDW
LV2OG3KRHQLFLDQDQGWKH.LODPXZDLQVFULSWLRQIURP6DP૟DO,QWKH
UHVWRI3KRHQLFLDQVWDUWLQJZLWKWKH.DUDWHSHLQVFULSWLRQWKHILUVW
FRPPRQVLQJXODUVXIIL[LVDOZD\VZULWWHQ<!LQGHSHQGHQWRIFDVH
)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R† 7KHGLVWLQFWLRQ
LQWKHWKLUGSHUVRQVLQJXODUVXIIL[HVUHPDLQVWKURXJKRXW3KRHQL
FLDQEXWLVORVWLQ/DWH3XQLF )ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R
† 2OG%\EOLDQGLIIHUVIURPWKHSUHVHQWDWLRQDERYHLQWKDW
LWGRHVQRWKDYHGLVWLQFWIRUPVIRUSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVLQWKHQRPL
QDWLYHDQGJHQLWLYH +DFNHWW 7KHWKLUGPDVFXOLQHVLQJX
ODUSRVVHVVLYHVXIIL[LQ2OG%\EOLDQLVJHQHUDOO\ZULWWHQZLWK+!
UHIOHFWLQJWKHRULJLQDOVXIIL[FRQVRQDQWK)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG
$PDGDVL*X]]RDVVXPHWKDWWKHRULJLQDOFDVHYRZHOVZHUHSUHVHUYHG
EHIRUHWKLVVXIIL[ )ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R† 
DOWKRXJKWKHUHLVQRGLUHFWHYLGHQFHIRUWKHSUHVHUYDWLRQRIWKHSUH
VXIIL[YRZHOV+RZHYHU2OG%\EOLDQKDGWZRGLVWLQFWIRUPVIRUWKH
WKLUGPDVFXOLQHVLQJXODULQGHSHQGHQWSURQRXQ+૟DQG+૟$ERWKRI
ZKLFKDUHXVHGIRUWKHQRPLQDWLYHZKLOH2OGDQGODWHU3KRHQLFLDQ
RQO\KDYH+૟$OO3KRHQLFLDQGLDOHFWVKDYHDWKLUGPDVFXOLQHSOXUDO
LQGHSHQGHQWSURQRXQ+>$XVHGIRUDOOFDVHVZKLFKJRHVEDFNWRDQ
RULJLQDOREOLTXHIRUPRIWKHSURQRXQIRUWKHIRUPVVHH)ULHGULFK
5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R†7KHH[LVWHQFHRIWKHLQGHSHQ
GHQWSURQRXQV+૟$DQG+>$VKRZVWKDW3KRHQLFLDQRULJLQDOO\GLVWLQ
JXLVKHGFDVHLQWKHDQDSKRULFSURQRXQV7KHRULJLQDOO\V\QWDFWLFDOO\
GLIIHUHQWLDWHGSURQRXQVZHUHWKHQOHYHOHGLQIDYRURIWKHQRPLQDWLYH
IRUPVH[FHSWLQWKHWKLUGPDVFXOLQHSOXUDO7KHRFFXUUHQFHRIERWK
+૟DQG+૟$LQ2OG%\EOLDQUHIOHFWVDQLQWHUPHGLDWHVWDJHLQZKLFKWKH
REOLTXHIXQFWLRQRI+૟$ZDVORVWDOUHDG\ZKLOHWKHIRUPLWVHOIZDV
VWLOOSUHVHUYHG
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8S833<%O<778NS<3O

 ϮUVWFRPPRQVLQJXODUQRPLQDWLYH &‘ Ҹ

 ϮUVWFRPPRQVLQJXODUJHQLWLYH #M< L\D

 WKLUGPDVFXOLQHVLQJXODUQRPLQDWLYH &‘ ‫گ‬Q:

 WKLUGPDVFXOLQHVLQJXODUJHQLWLYH M#< L\X

 WKLUGIHPLQLQHVLQJXODUQRPLQDWLYH &‘ č

 WKLUGIHPLQLQHJHQLWLYH #< L\D  

7KHSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVRIWKHWKLUGPDVFXOLQHVLQJXODUDQGWKLUGIHPLQLQHVLQJXODURQQRXQVLQWKHQRPL
QDWLYHDUHWKHUHVXOWRIYRZHOFRQWUDFWLRQVZKLOHDIWHUWKHKLJKIURQWYRZHOLRIWKHJHQLWLYHWKHRULJLQDOK
RIWKHVXIIL[ZDVSDODWDOL]HGWR\DQGQRYRZHOFRQWUDFWLRQRFFXUUHG7KHSKRQRORJLFDOSURFHVVHVXQGHUO\LQJ
RUWKRJUDSKLF‘!YHUVXV<!FDQEHVXPPDUL]HGDVIROORZVQQ

 WKLUGPDVFXOLQHVLQJXODUDFFXVDWLYH j>(.=(+1%%X%%U>(.=(9%%X%%PDON‫گ‬
% WKLUGIHPLQLQHVLQJXODUDFFXVDWLYH >(.=(+(% X%%UPDONč
 WKLUGPDVFXOLQHVLQJXODUJHQLWLYH >(.=#+1%% X%%>(.=#'1
% WKLUGIHPLQLQHVLQJXODUJHQLWLYH j>(.=#+(%% X%%>(.=#'( g

6LQFHWKLVUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLVEDVHGRQDQRPLQDOEDVHHQGLQJLQWKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVHYRZHODZHVWLOOKDYHWR
DFFRXQWIRUWKHRUWKRJUDSKLFDQGSKRQRORJLFDOPHUJHURIWKHVXIIL[DWWDFKHGWRDQRULJLQDOEDVHLQWKHQRPLQDWLYH
HQGLQJLQXZLWKWKHIRUPRIWKHVXIIL[GHULYHGIURPWKHDFFXVDWLYH7KHYRZHOFRQWUDFWLRQVLQWKHDFFXVDWLYH
DQGWKHSDODWDOL]DWLRQRIKWR\PXVWKDYHRFFXUUHGEHIRUHWKHORVVRIILQDOVKRUWYRZHOV$IWHUWKHVHIRUPV
GHYHORSHGILQDODDQGXZHUHORVWZKLOHILQDOLZDVSUHVHUYHGZKLFKFDXVHGWKHDFFXVDWLYHDQGQRPLQDWLYH
RIVLQJXODUQRXQVWRPHUJH7KHV\QFUHWLVPRIWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYHLQWKHQRPLQDOV\VWHPWKHQFDXVHG
WKHDQDORJLFDOH[WHQVLRQRIWKHWKLUGSHUVRQVLQJXODUDFFXVDWLYHVXIIL[HVWRWKHQRPLQDWLYHUHVXOWLQJLQWKHELQDU\
V\VWHPRIQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHYHUVXVJHQLWLYHDWWHVWHGLQWKHSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVQ<%
7KHLPSRUWDQWTXHVWLRQWKDWVWLOOUHTXLUHVFODULILFDWLRQLVZKHWKHUWKLVELQDU\FDVHGLVWLQFWLRQZDVDJHQHUDO
IHDWXUHRI6WDQGDUG3KRHQLFLDQPRUSKRORJ\RUZKHWKHULWZDVUHVWULFWHGWRRFFXUUHQFHVEHIRUHSURQRPLQDOVXI
IL[HV+XHKQHUJDUGDVVXPHVWKDWWKHELQDU\LQIOHFWLRQDWWHVWHGLQWKHSURQRPLQDOV\VWHPZDVDOVRSUHVHUYHGLQ
WKHQRPLQDOLQIOHFWLRQVLQFHLWZRXOGQRWPDNHVHQVHWRSUHVHUYHFDVHPDUNLQJRQO\EHIRUHSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVQR%
7KHDUJXPHQWWKDWFDVHGLVWLQFWLRQVKRXOGEHSUHVHUYHGRQQRXQVEHFDXVHLWLVDWWHVWHGLQWKHSURQRPLQDOV\VWHP
LVQRWDQHFHVVDU\FRQFOXVLRQWKRXJK$VPHQWLRQHGEHIRUHLWLVDFURVVOLQJXLVWLFSKHQRPHQRQWKDWSURQRXQV
WHQGWRSUHVHUYHFDVHGLVWLQFWLRQIRUDORQJHUSHULRGRIWLPHWKDQQRXQV&RQVHTXHQWO\WKHSUHVHUYDWLRQRID
JHQLWLYHYHUVXVQRQJHQLWLYHGLVWLQFWLRQLQSDUWVRIWKHSURQRPLQDOV\VWHPLQWKLVFDVHSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVLVQR
LQGLFDWLRQWKDWWKHVDPHGLVWLQFWLRQLVDOVRSUHVHQWLQWKHQRPLQDOV\VWHP7KHTXHVWLRQRIZKHWKHUWKHJHQLWLYH
ZDVSUHVHUYHGRQQRXQVWKHUHIRUHUHTXLUHVIXUWKHULQYHVWLJDWLRQ

Q:
7KHYRFDOL]DWLRQRIWKHWKLUGPDVFXOLQHVLQJXODUVXIIL[DV‫گ‬LV
WDNHQIURP*UHHNWUDQVFULSWLRQV +XHKQHUJDUG 
QQ
$VLPLODUGLVWLQFWLRQLVIRXQGLQWKHWKLUGPDVFXOLQHSOXUDOVXϲ[HV
IRU ZKLFK WKH QRPLQDWLYH LV ZULWWHQ 0! DQG WKH JHQLWLYH 10!
+XHKQHUJDUGYRFDOL]HVWKHIRUPHUDV‫گ‬PDQGWKHODWWHUDVQ‫گ‬P
7KLV YRFDOL]DWLRQ LV GHULYHG IURP T‫گ‬ODKXP ! T‫گ‬ODZP ! T‫گ‬O‫گ‬P DQG
F78I8H6>>E% UT‫گ‬OLKXP ! T‫گ‬OL\XP 7KH Q RI WKH JHQLWLYH LV SUHVXPDEO\
WDNHQIURPWKHORQJLPSHUIHFW'(X$1.1SOXVVXϲ[LQWKHSOXUDOWKDWLV
U\LTWXOࡃQ‫گ‬P ZDV UHDQDO\]HG DV \LTWXOࡃQ‫گ‬P DIWHU WKH PRUSKRORJLFDO
MJ7IJ7% FG% '(X$1. DQG '(X$1.1 7KH IRUP Q‫گ‬P ZDV WKHQ OHYHOHG WR DOO
QRPLQDO DQG YHUEDO IRUPV HQGLQJ LQ D YRZHO +XHKQHUJDUG 
   DQG FRQVHTXHQWO\ WKH DFFXVDWLYH VXϲ[HV VKRZ D VLPLODU
GLVWLQFWLRQEDVHGRQWKHIRUPRIWKHYHUEWRZKLFKWKH\DUHDWWDFKHG
DVWKHSRVVHVVLYHVXϲ[HV:KHQWKHYHUEDOVWHPHQGVLQDFRQVRQDQW
WKH WKLUG PDVFXOLQH VLQJXODU VXϲ[ LV QRW ZULWWHQ ZKLOH ZKHQ WKH
YHUEDOIRUPHQGVLQDYRZHOWKHVXϲ[LVZULWWHQDV<! +DFNHWW
  7KLV GLVWULEXWLRQ VKRZV WKH VDPH SKRQRORJLFDOO\ PRWLYDWHG
SDODWDOL]DWLRQ RI K DIWHU YRZHOV DV VXJJHVWHG IRU QRXQV 7KXV WKH
SDODWDOL]DWLRQ RFFXUUHG DIWHU L Ҹ DQG ࡃ )ULHGULFK 5|OOLJ DQG
$PDGDVL*X]]R†² 
Q<
+XHKQHUJDUG
QR
+XHKQHUJDUGQ5HFHQWWUHDWPHQWVRI3KRHQLFLDQ
JUDPPDU VXFK DV +DFNHWW  IROORZ +XHKQHUJDUG·V DQDO\VLV
)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]RDVVXPHWKDWWKHRSSRVLWLRQRI
JHQLWLYHYHUVXVQRQJHQLWLYHZDVRQO\SUHVHUYHGEHIRUHSURQRPLQDO
VXIIL[HVRQVLQJXODUQRXQV † +DUULVVXJJHVWHGWKDWWKH
GLVWLQFWLRQLQ6WDQGDUG3KRHQLFLDQLVDSXUHO\RUWKRJUDSKLFIHDWXUH
WKDWZDVHVWDEOLVKHGZKHQWKHFDVHGLVWLQFWLRQZDVVWLOOSUHVHQWEXW
DWWKHVDPHWLPHKHDVVXPHGWKDWFDVHVZHUHFRQIXVHGDIWHUWKH
IRXUWHHQWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐ +DUULV 7KLVGDWHLVGHULYHGIURP
WKH&DQDDQL]LQJ$PDUQDOHWWHUV7KLVLQWHUSUHWDWLRQLVSUREOHPDWLF
VLQFHLWDVVXPHVDSHULRGRIDERXWWKUHHKXQGUHG\HDUVRUORQJHULQ
ZKLFKPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHPDUNLQJZDVORVWEXWWKHRUWKRJUDSKLF
GLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQJHQLWLYHDQGQRQJHQLWLYHZDVSUHVHUYHGZKLFK
LVUDWKHUXQOLNHO\+DUULV·H[SODQDWLRQOLNHZLVHGRHVQRWDFFRXQWIRU
WKHUHJXODUGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHGLIIHUHQWIRUPVDFFRUGLQJWRV\QWDFWLF
FRQWH[W
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 8<KNY%3<B<<B/*8%<BH%,NH%<K<A</3%3<78%/B%*O8%N/DO*%,F%N<BD\<D8%*Y@,N,DY% O?@

7KHVWDWXVRIFDVHPDUNLQJLQ3KRHQLFLDQLVRIFRXUVHGHSHQGHQWRQWKHORVVRIILQDOVKRUWYRZHOV,QQHU
3KRHQLFLDQHYLGHQFHIRUWKLVVRXQGFKDQJHLVIRXQGLQWKHWUDQVLWLRQIURP2OG%\EOLDQWR%\EOLDQ,Q2OG%\EOLDQ
,,,9l'URRWVDUHXVXDOO\ZULWWHQZLWKILQDOJOLGHDVLQ૛O\´KHDVFHQGHGµDQG&)'´KHEXLOWµZKLFKLQGLFDWHVWKH
SUHVHUYDWLRQRIWKHRULJLQDOILQDOYRZHORIWKHWKLUGPDVFXOLQHVLQJXODUSHUIHFW7KHYHUEDOIRUPVFDQWKHUHIRUH
EHYRFDOL]HGDV૛DOD\DDQGEDQD\DUHVSHFWLYHO\,QDOORWKHUGLDOHFWVRI3KRHQLFLDQWKHWKLUGURRWOHWWHULVQRW
LQGLFDWHGLQWKHZULWLQJDVLQє]´KHVDZµFRPPRQO\YRFDOL]HGDVєD]‫گ‬7KHDEVHQFHRIDQ\RUWKRJUDSKLFUHS
UHVHQWDWLRQRIWKHJOLGHLQGLFDWHVWKDWWKHRULJLQDOILQDOVKRUWYRZHOZDVORVW$QRWKHULQGLFDWLRQWKDW2OG%\EOLDQ
SUHVHUYHGILQDOVKRUWYRZHOVDWOHDVWWRDFHUWDLQGHJUHHDUHRFFXUUHQFHVRIZKDWVHHPVWREHDFFXVDWLYHVRIGLUHF
WLRQVXFKDV5&.´WR%\EORVµWREHYRFDOL]HGDVJXEODZLWKWKHILQDODUHSUHVHQWLQJWKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVHYRZHOQ@%
$OWKRXJKWKHDIRUHPHQWLRQHGFKDQJHVRQO\RFFXULQWKHWUDQVLWLRQIURP2OG%\EOLDQWR%\EOLDQWKH\ILWLQWR
FHUWDLQSKHQRPHQDWKDWGHYHORSHGLQ3KRHQLFLDQLQJHQHUDOVXFKDVWKHHPHUJHQFHRIDGLUHFWREMHFWPDUNHU
7KH3KRHQLFLDQGLUHFWREMHFWPDUNHU૟\WLVQRWDWWHVWHGLQWKHHDUOLHVWLQVFULSWLRQVIURPWKHWHQWKWRODWHQLQWK
FHQWXU\ᄽᅐZKLFKLQFOXGHWKH2OG%\EOLDQLQVFULSWLRQVDQGWKH.LODPXZDLQVFULSWLRQIURP6DP૟DO,WILUVWRFFXUV
LQDQLQVFULSWLRQIURP&\SUXVWKDWGDWHVWRWKHHQGRIWKHQLQWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐ7KHORVVRIERWKWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQG
DFFXVDWLYHFDVHYRZHOVWKDWLVWKHORVVRIILQDOVKRUWDDQGXDQGWKHVXEVHTXHQWPRUSKRORJLFDOPHUJHURI
WKHVHFDVHVPXVWKDYHSUHFHGHGWKHHPHUJHQFHRIWKHGLUHFWREMHFWPDUNHU7KHILUVWHPHUJHQFHRIWKLVPRU
SKHPHLQWKHODWHQLQWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐILWVZHOOLQWRWKHWLPHIUDPHZKHQ%\EOLDQORVWILQDOVKRUWYRZHOV%DVHGRQ
WKHVHGDWD)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]RVXJJHVWWKDWDOOVKRUWYRZHOVZHUHORVWDWWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKH
G879K%M8>>JHH8LM%ᄽᅐQP,ZRXOGDJUHHZLWKWKLVDQDO\VLVZLWKRQHPLQRUPRGLILFDWLRQ
'HVSLWHWKHIDFWWKDWDOOWKHGDWDUHSUHVHQWHGDERYHLQGLFDWHWKHORVVRIILQDOVKRUWDDQGXLQWKHHDUO\
G879K%M8>>JHH8LM%ᄽᅐLWLVLPSRUWDQWWRQRWHWKDWQRQHRIWKHDIRUHPHQWLRQHGFDVHVFRQFHUQVWKHORVVRIILQDOVKRUW
L7KXVEDVHGRQWKHHYLGHQFHSURYLGHGVRIDUWKHVWDWXVRIWKHLQIOHFWLRQDOO\PDUNHGJHQLWLYHLVVWLOOXQFHUWDLQ
8QIRUWXQDWHO\WKHUHLVQRLQQHU3KRHQLFLDQHYLGHQFHWKDWPLJKWKHOSWRHVWDEOLVKWKHVWDWXVRIWKLVYRZHOLQZRUG
ILQDOSRVLWLRQ,QVWHDGRQHKDVWRUHIHUWRHYLGHQFHIURPRXWVLGHWKH3KRHQLFLDQLQVFULSWLRQDOPDWHULDOVXFKDV
WUDQVFULSWLRQVRI3KRHQLFLDQSURSHUQDPHVLQWRZULWLQJV\VWHPVVXFKDV$NNDGLDQFXQHLIRUP7UDQVFULSWLRQVLQWR
$NNDGLDQFXQHLIRUPDUHDWWHVWHGIURPWKH1HR$VV\ULDQDQG1HR%DE\ORQLDQSHULRGVWKDWLVIURPWKHQLQWKWR
ILIWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐ<?
)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]RVWDWHWKDWFXQHLIRUPWUDQVFULSWLRQVRI3KRHQLFLDQQDPHVIURPWKLVWLPH
VKRZQRHYLGHQFHIRUDSURGXFWLYHV\VWHPRILQIOHFWLRQDOFDVHPDUNLQJ<O2QWKHEDVLVRIP\RZQLQYHVWLJDWLRQRI


)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R†
Q@
)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R†

7KHGLUHFWREMHFWPDUNHULVDOVRDWWHVWHGLQWKH.DUDWHSHLQVFULS
WLRQIURPWKHODWHHLJKWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐDOWKRXJKLWVXVHLVQRWREOLJ
DWRU\,WLVSULPDULO\XVHGEHIRUHGHILQLWHQRXQVEXWHYHQKHUHLW
VHHPVWREHRSWLRQDO )ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R
† *DUUDVVXPHVWKDWWKHGLUHFWREMHFWLVXVXDOO\XQPDUNHGLQ
6WDQGDUG3KRHQLFLDQDQGWKDWWKHGLUHFWREMHFWPDUNHULVXVHGWR
PDUNFRQWUDVWDQGHPSKDVLV*DUUVWDWHV´,Q6WDQGDUG3KRHQLFLDQ
WKHQWKH)6$(%(4410($#?#PDUNHGREMHFWVWKDWZHUHRISDUWLFXODULQWHU
HVWWRWKHDXWKRULWVXVHZDVVXEMHFWWRLQGLYLGXDOVW\OHµ *DUU
 2QHUHDVRQIRUWKHLUUHJXODUXVHRIWKHGLUHFWREMHFWPDUNHU
PLJKWEHWKDWLWZDVUHGXQGDQWLQPDQ\LQVWDQFHVVLQFHJUDPPDWLFDO
UHODWLRQVZHUHSULPDULO\H[SUHVVHGE\ZRUGRUGHU7KHFRPPRQZRUG
RUGHULQ3KRHQLFLDQLVYHUEVXEMHFWREMHFWIRUYHUEDOFODXVHVZLWK
WKHSRVVLELOLW\WRIURQWHLWKHUWKHVXEMHFWRUREMHFWIRUHPSKDVLV
WRSLFDOL]DWLRQDQGVXEMHFWSUHGLFDWHLQQRPLQDOFODXVHVSUHGLFDWH
VXEMHFWZKHQWKHVXEMHFWLVDQLQGHSHQGHQWSURQRXQ )ULHGULFK5|O
OLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R† 6XEMHFWDQGREMHFWZHUHWKHUH
IRUHGLVWLQJXLVKDEOHE\SRVLWLRQXQOHVVHLWKHURIWKHPZDVIURQWHG
IRUHPSKDVLVWRSLFDOL]DWLRQ
QP
)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R†
<?
 7KH XVH RI $NNDGLDQ WUDQVFULSWLRQV LV RI FRXUVH SUREOHPDWLF
DQGFDQRQO\OHDGWRWHQWDWLYHUHVXOWVVLQFHLWLVRIWHQGLIILFXOWWR
GLVWLQJXLVK EHWZHHQ JHQXLQH 3KRHQLFLDQ IRUPV DQG IRUPV WKDW
UHSUHVHQW 1HR$VV\ULDQ DQG 1HR%DE\ORQLDQ PRUSKRORJ\ ,Q RU
GHUWRPDNHDVWDWHPHQWDERXW3KRHQLFLDQFDVHLQIOHFWLRQRQHKDV
WRILQGXVDJHVDQGVSHOOLQJVWKDWGRQRWFRQIRUPWRWKH$NNDGLDQ
PRUSKRORJ\RIWKHUHVSHFWLYHWLPHSHULRG2QHH[DPSOHRIDQDPH
WUDQVFULEHGLQWR1HR$VV\ULDQ VHYHQWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐ WKDWGRHVQRW
UHIOHFW1HR$VV\ULDQPRUSKRORJ\LV G>#M#.MX(-M$10LOTDUW´NLQJRI
WKHFLW\µ7KLVQDPHVKRZVVHYHUDOIHDWXUHVWKDWVKRXOGEHGLIIHUHQW
LILWFRQIRUPHGWR1HR$VV\ULDQWKHIRUPRIWKHFRQVWUXFWVKRXOG
EHGLIIHUHQWDQGQRWVKRZWKHDVVLPLODWLRQRIWKHILQDONRI>#.=%
´NLQJµWRWKHILUVWFRQVRQDQWRIWKHIROORZLQJQRXQTZKLFKDOVR
FOHDUO\VKRZVWKDWWKHILQDOYRZHORIWKHFRQVWUXFWZDVORVW,QDGGL
WLRQWKHVHHPLQJFDVHYRZHOXRQX(-$1VKRXOGEHDJHQLWLYHQRW
DQRPLQDWLYHLILWFRUUHVSRQGHGWR1HR$VV\ULDQPRUSKRORJ\7KH
ILQDOYRZHOXRQX(-$MLVDQRUWKRJUDSKLFGHYLFHWRUHSUHVHQWWKH
ILQDOFRQVRQDQWFOXVWHUDQGGRHVQRWUHIOHFWDFDVHYRZHO IRUWKH
DWWHVWDWLRQVVHH)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R† 
6LQFHWKHVDPHEDVLFIRUPRIWKLVQDPHLVDOVRIRXQGLQ3KRHQLFLDQ
LQVFULSWLRQVZKHUHLWLVZULWWHQ>.X-$ .$,FDᄽᅐ WKH
WUDQVFULSWLRQLQ1HR$VV\ULDQPRVWOLNHO\UHIOHFWVWKHFORVHVWYDUL
DQWRIWKH3KRHQLFLDQIRUPRIWKHQDPHWKDWFRXOGEHH[SUHVVHGLQ
V\OODELFFXQHLIRUP/DWLQDQG*UHHNWUDQVOLWHUDWLRQVIURPWKHILIWK
FHQWXU\ᄽᅐRQFOHDUO\GRQRWUHIOHFWFDVHYRZHOV
<O
)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R††ELV$F
FRUGLQJWR)ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]RILQDOYRZHOVWKDW
ZHUHZULWWHQLQFXQHLIRUPVRXUFHVGRQRWUHIOHFWFDVHYRZHOV&RQ
VRQDQW9RZHOVLJQVDWWKHHQGRIDZRUGZHUHRIWHQXVHGZKHQWKH
3KRHQLFLDQZRUGHQGHGLQDFRQVRQDQWFOXVWHUWKDWFRXOGQRWEHH[
SUHVVHGLQFXQHLIRUPZULWLQJDVLQ&(M૟(M.#l.1IRUED૛O´ORUGµDQG
>#.M=#IRUPLON´NLQJµ7KHXVHRI&RQVRQDQW9RZHOVLJQVIRUILQDO
V\OODEOHVZLWKRXWFRQVRQDQWFOXVWHUVSUHVXPDEO\UHIOHFWVWKHDWWHPSW
WRFOHDUO\H[SUHVVWKHTXDOLW\RIWKHILQDOFRQVRQDQWWKDWLVWKHVLJQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8S833<%O<778NS<3O

3KRHQLFLDQSHUVRQDOQDPHVLQ1HR$VV\ULDQVRXUFHVGDWLQJIURPWKHUHLJQRI6KDOPDQH]HU,,,GRZQWRWKHUHLJQRI
$VKXUEDQLSDOWKDWLVIURPWRᄽᅐ,RIIHUWKHIROORZLQJREVHUYDWLRQV<:,QWKHHDUOLHVWWUDQVFULSWLRQVIURP
WKHPLGQLQWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐFDVHHQGLQJVDUHPRVWO\DOWKRXJKQRWDOZD\VHPSOR\HGFRUUHFWO\<Q7KHQRPLQDWLYH
WHQGVWREHZULWWHQLQFRUUHFWO\PRUHIUHTXHQWO\WKDQWKHJHQLWLYH,QLQVFULSWLRQVIURPWKHHLJKWKFHQWXU\RQ
WKHQRPLQDWLYHLVJHQHUDOO\QRWH[SUHVVHGE\WKHFRUUHFWYRZHO<<
7KHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRIWKHJHQLWLYHGLIIHUVIURPWKDWRIWKHQRPLQDWLYH,QWKHHDUOLHUPDWHULDOGDWLQJWRWKH
UHLJQVRI6KDOPDQH]HU,,,GRZQWR6HQQDFKHULEWKHJHQLWLYHLVXVXDOO\HPSOR\HGFRUUHFWO\<R)URPWKHUHLJQRI
(VDUKDGGRQRQZHILQGZURQJVSHOOLQJVRIWKHJHQLWLYHDQGPRUHIUHTXHQWRPLVVLRQVRIYRZHOV$WWKHWLPHRI
$VKXUEDQLSDOQRFRUUHFWLQGLFDWLRQRIDJHQLWLYHZLWKILQDOLLVDWWHVWHGLQWKHQDPHVWKDWZHUHDYDLODEOHIRUP\
LQYHVWLJDWLRQ,IZHFDQWUXVWWKHHYLGHQFHIURPWKH1HR$VV\ULDQWUDQVFULSWLRQVWKHIROORZLQJSLFWXUHHPHUJHV
WKHQRPLQDWLYHFDVHYRZHO1VHHPVWRKDYHEHHQORVWIURPEDVLFDOO\WKHHDUOLHVWDWWHVWDWLRQVRQDIDFWWKDWFRQ
IRUPVWRLQQHU3KRHQLFLDQHYLGHQFH1HR$VV\ULDQLQFRQWUDVWSUHVHUYHGWKHRULJLQDO1RIWKHQRPLQDWLYHDWWKLV
SHULRGZKLFKFRXOGVWUHQJWKHQWKHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQWKDWWKHVSHOOLQJRIWKHQRPLQDWLYHLQ1HR$VV\ULDQWUDQVFULS
WLRQVUHIOHFWVDJHQXLQH3KRHQLFLDQIHDWXUH7KHJHQLWLYH#ZDVDWOHDVWLQSDUWSUHVHUYHGXSWRWKHODWHHLJKWK
FHQWXU\ᄽᅐEXWSUREDEO\GLVDSSHDUHGE\WKHHDUO\WRPLGVHYHQWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐDIWHUZKLFKLWLVQRWDWWHVWHGLQ
FXQHLIRUPWUDQVFULSWLRQVDQ\ORQJHU%
&RQFOXVLRQVEDVHGRQWUDQVFULSWLRQVLQWR$VV\ULDQDQG%DE\ORQLDQKDYHRIFRXUVHWRUHPDLQWHQWDWLYH%H
IRUHUHDFKLQJHYHQWHQWDWLYHFRQFOXVLRQVLWLVLPSRUWDQWWRGLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQIRUPVDQGVSHOOLQJVWKDWFRXOG
UHIOHFW1HR$VV\ULDQDQG1HR%DE\ORQLDQPRUSKRORJ\DQGWKRVHWKDWFDQQRW'LYHUJHQFHVRIWKHFDVHPDUNLQJ
IURP1HR$VV\ULDQDQG1HR%DE\ORQLDQQRUPVVXFKDVWKHLUUHJXODUVSHOOLQJRIWKHQRPLQDWLYHLQWKHHDUOLHU
1HR$VV\ULDQPDWHULDOPLJKWLQGLFDWHWKDWZHDUHDWOHDVWLQSDUWGHDOLQJZLWK3KRHQLFLDQPRUSKRORJ\,QWKLV
FDVHWKHQDPHVLQWUDQVFULSWLRQFRQILUPWKDW3KRHQLFLDQKDGDELQDU\FDVHLQIOHFWLRQJHQLWLYHYHUVXVQRQ
JHQLWLYHLQERWKWKHQRPLQDODQGSURQRPLQDOV\VWHPLQWKHHDUO\ILUVWPLOOHQQLXPᄽᅐEXWWKDWWKLVV\VWHPZDV
ORVWRQXQERXQGQRXQVHDUOLHUWKDQRQERXQGQRXQVZLWKSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVFRQWUDU\WRSUHYLRXVDVVXPSWLRQV
WKDWWKHJHQLWLYHZDVSUHVHUYHGWKURXJKRXWWKHKLVWRU\RI3KRHQLFLDQ

ኹ႐ZDVFKRVHQIRUWKHV\OODEOH&RQVRQDQW3LQVWHDGRI႐ᄽWRHPSKD
VL]HWKDWWKHILQDOFRQVRQDQWZDVSQRWEDVLQPLONLDߖiSD%GF7%
0LON\DViS )ULHGULFK5|OOLJDQG$PDGDVL*X]]R†ELV 
<:
7KH3KRHQLFLDQQDPHVLQ$VV\ULDQWUDQVFULSWLRQVXVHGIRUWKHSUHV
HQWLQYHVWLJDWLRQDUHSULPDULO\WDNHQIURP%HQ]
<Q
7KLVREVHUYDWLRQKDVDOUHDG\EHHQPDGHE\6HJHUWZKRVWDWHVWKDW
´FDVHHQGLQJVPD\EHUHIOHFWHGLQVRPHWUDQVFULSWLRQVµ 6HJHUW
 6HJHUWTXRWHVQDPHVWUDQVFULEHGDWWKHWLPHRI6KDOPDQH]HU
,,,VXFKDV>(M$#M)1M&(M૟(M.#´JLIWRI%D૛OµDQG(M"1M)1M&(M૟(M.#´%DDOLV
ORUGµ7KHILUVWQDPHHPSOR\VWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGJHQLWLYHFRUUHFWO\
LQWKHILUVWDQGVHFRQGHOHPHQWVUHVSHFWLYHO\ZKLOHWKHVHFRQGQDPH
VHHPVWRKDYHDFRUUHFWVSHOOLQJRIWKHQRPLQDWLYHLQWKHILUVWHOH
PHQW,QDGGLWLRQWKHFDVHPDUNLQJLQWKHILUVWQDPHFDQQRWUHIOHFW
$VV\ULDQXVDJHVLQFH$VV\ULDQZRXOGQRWPDUNFDVHRQVLQJXODUFRQ
VWUXFWV
<<%
$OWKRXJKWKHUHDUHFDVHVLQZKLFKWKHQRPLQDWLYHLVXVHGFRUUHFWO\
LQERWKWKHILUVWDQGVHFRQGHOHPHQWRIDQDPHLQWUDQVFULSWLRQVRI
WKHHLJKWKFHQWXU\ᄽᅐWKHUHLVDQHTXDOQXPEHURIFDVHVLQZKLFK
WKHQRPLQDWLYHLVUHSUHVHQWHGE\WKHZURQJYRZHOLQWKHVDPHSRVL
WLRQ)URPWKHUHLJQRI(VDUKDGGRQRQZURQJPDUNLQJVRIWKHQRPL
QDWLYHIDURXWZHLJKWKHFRUUHFWPDUNLQJVLQERWKWKHILUVWDQGVHFRQG
HOHPHQWRIDQDPH$WWKHWLPHRI$VKXUEDQLSDOWKHQRPLQDWLYHLV
QHYHULQGLFDWHGZLWKWKHFRUUHFWYRZHOLQGHSHQGHQWRISRVLWLRQ
6SHOOLQJVZLWKRXWILQDOYRZHOVLQFUHDVHIURPWKHWLPHRI7LJODWK
3LOHVHU,,,DQGUHSUHVHQWE\IDUWKHPRVWIUHTXHQWO\IRXQGVSHOOLQJ
FRQYHQWLRQDWWKHWLPHRI$VKXUEDQLSDO³]HURPDUNLQJLVDJDLQ
IRXQGLQGLVFULPLQDWHO\RIZKHWKHUZHDUHGHDOLQJZLWKWKHILUVWRU
VHFRQGHOHPHQWRIDQDPHDVLQ&(M૟DDOђDQXQX´%DDOKDVVKRZQ
IDYRUµ $VKXUEDQLSDOLL DQGߖDSDࠃ~ED૟(M(.´%DDOKDVMXGJHGµ%
$VKXUEDQLSDOLL ,WLVLPSRUWDQWWRQRWHWKDW1HR$VV\ULDQSUH
VHUYHGDQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHLQ1DQGDJHQLWLYHLQM#GXULQJPRVW
RIWKLVWLPH2QO\DWWKHWLPHRI(VDUKDGGRQDQG$VKXUEDQLSDOGR
ZHQRWLFHWKHEHJLQQLQJFROODSVHRIWKHHQWLUHFDVHV\VWHPWKDWLV
UHIOHFWHGE\RFFDVLRQDOZURQJVSHOOLQJVRIWKHJHQLWLYHKRZHYHULW
LVLPSRUWDQWWRQRWHWKDWWKLVORVVLVQRW\HWIXOO\GHYHORSHGLQWKH
WH[WXDOPDWHULDO +lPHHQ$QWWLOD 7KHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRI
QRPLQDWLYHDQGJHQLWLYHLQ3KRHQLFLDQQDPHVWKXVGLIIHUVIURPWKH
UHSUHVHQWDWLRQRIFDVHLQWKHFRQWHPSRUDU\1HR$VV\ULDQVRXUFHV
ZKLFKVXJJHVWVWKDWWKHZURQJVSHOOLQJVRIWKHQRPLQDWLYHLQ3KRH
QLFLDQQDPHVPLJKWLQGHHGUHIOHFWWKHORVVRIWKHQRPLQDWLYHFDVH
YRZHOXLQ3KRHQLFLDQ7KDWILQDOVKRUWDZDVPRVWOLNHO\ORVWDV
ZHOOLVVKRZQE\WKHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRIWKHILQDOYRZHORQWKHSHU
IHFWRULJLQDO X($(.(ZKLFKLVQHYHUH[FHSWRQFHVSHOOHGDVILQDO
W6W2%DLK%L9L6>>E%69%WLW2%69%8H%&(M૟(M(.M>(M.1M=1%D૛OPDOyN´%DDO
KDVUHLJQHGµ $VKXUEDQLSDOLL 7KLVXKDVQREDVLVLQHLWKHU
$VV\ULDQRU3KRHQLFLDQPRUSKRORJ\DQGWKXVFOHDUO\LQGLFDWHVWKH
ORVVRIWKHILQDOYRZHO
<R
7KHUHLVRQHRFFXUUHQFHRIDJHQLWLYHVSHOOHGZLWKRXWILQDOYRZHO
LQDQLQVFULSWLRQIURP7LJODWK3LOHVHU,,,>>(@$(M()M&#M૟#M#.´*LIWRI
%̒Oµ ,,, 

7KHORVVRIWKHJHQLWLYHLVDOVRDWWHVWHGLQWKHQRXQV૟&DQG૟є%DJGF7J%
SURQRPLQDOVXIIL[HVZKLFKUHJXODUO\XVHWKHQRPLQDWLYHYRZHOࡃ
EHIRUHVXIIL[HVIURPWKHVHFRQGKDOIRIWKHILUVWPLOOHQQLXPᄽᅐ%FH2%
LQGHSHQGHQWRIFDVH'!"#$%&$'()*+,--./ 7KLVPLJKWOLNHZLVH
LQGLFDWHWKDWWKHFDVHGLVWLQFWLRQRIQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHYHUVXV
JHQLWLYHZDVORVWLQPRVWRIWKHQRPLQDOLQIOHFWLRQEHIRUH/DWH3XQLF
$VPHQWLRQHGLQQRWHDERYH1HR$VV\ULDQSUHVHUYHGWKHJHQL
WLYHGXULQJPRVWRILWVDWWHVWDWLRQDQGKDGRQO\VWDUWHGWRORVHLWDW
WKHWLPHRI(VDUKDGGRQDQG$VKXUEDQLSDO'HVSLWHWKHIDFWWKDWWKH
VLWXDWLRQUHJDUGLQJWKHJHQLWLYHLVQRWDVFOHDUDVZLWKUHJDUGWRWKH
QRPLQDWLYHLWLVVWLOOSRVVLEOHWKDWWKHQDPHVLQ1HR$VV\ULDQWUDQ
VFULSWLRQVUHIOHFW3KRHQLFLDQIRUPVHVSHFLDOO\LQFRQMXQFWLRQZLWK
WKHLQQHU3KRHQLFLDQHYLGHQFHMXVWPHQWLRQHGDOWKRXJK$VV\ULDQ
LQIOXHQFHFDQQRWIXOO\EHH[FOXGHG
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 8<KNY%3<B<<B/*8%<BH%,NH%<K<A</3%3<78%/B%*O8%N/DO*%,F%N<BD\<D8%*Y@,N,DY% O?P

(85;?:D<85
,QFRQFOXVLRQ$UDPDLFDQGHDUO\&DQDDQLWHRULJLQDOO\KDGDSURGXFWLYHFDVHLQIOHFWLRQWKDWZDVORVWLQERWK
EUDQFKHVRI1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLFLQWKHHDUO\ILUVWPLOOHQQLXPᄽᅐ,QERWK$UDPDLFDQG&DQDDQLWHWKHORVVRIFDVH
LQIOHFWLRQZDVFDXVHGE\DSKRQRORJLFDOSURFHVVWKHORVVRIILQDOVKRUWYRZHOV3KRHQLFLDQLVRISDUWLFXODULQWHUHVW
VLQFHLWLVSRVVLEOHWRWUDFHWKLVORVVDQGWKXVWKHFKDQJHVLQWKHQRPLQDOLQIOHFWLRQ7KHORVVRIILQDOVKRUWYRZHOV
LQLWLDOO\RQO\RFFXUUHGZLWKILQDOVKRUWXDQGDZKLFKUHVXOWHGLQWKHPHUJHURIQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYH
YHUVXVDVWLOOGLVWLQFWJHQLWLYHDGLVWLQFWLRQWKDWLVSUHVHUYHGLQWKHSURQRPLQDOV\VWHPWKURXJKRXWPRVWVWDJHV
RIWKHODQJXDJH7KLVW\SHRIGHYHORSPHQWKDVSDUDOOHOVLQRWKHU6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVSDUWLFXODUO\$NNDGLDQZKHUH
ZHILQGDVLPLODUPHUJHURIQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYHYHUVXVDGLVWLQFWJHQLWLYHDWYDULRXVVWDJHVRIWKHODQJXDJH
,Q2OG$NNDGLDQWKHJHQLWLYHZDVSUHVHUYHGRQFRQVWUXFWQRXQVLQWKHVLQJXODUZKLOHWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVD
WLYHZHUHORVW<@,Q1HR$VV\ULDQWKHVDPHW\SHRIELQDU\V\VWHPGHYHORSHGDOWKRXJKWKHQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYH
PHUJHGLQWRWKHRULJLQDOQRPLQDWLYHHQGLQJM1ZKLOHWKHJHQLWLYHNHSWLWVRULJLQDOPDUNLQJ$VLPLODUVLWXDWLRQ
LVDOVRIRXQGLQ1HR%DE\ORQLDQ
,WLVQRFRLQFLGHQFHWKDWDOOWKHVH6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVDQGGLDOHFWVEHKDYHLQEDVLFDOO\WKHVDPHPDQQHUZLWK
UHJDUGWRFDVHV\QFUHWLVPV$VVWDWHGLQWKHLQWURGXFWLRQWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYHJHQHUDOO\WHQGWRPHUJH
EHFDXVHWKH\ERWKUHSUHVHQWFRUHDUJXPHQWVDQGSULPDULO\YHUEDOFRPSOHPHQWVDVRSSRVHGWRWKHJHQLWLYH
ZKLFKLVDGQRPLQDO6HPLWLFODQJXDJHVVXFKDV3KRHQLFLDQWKXVFRQIRUPWRWKHEHKDYLRURIODQJXDJHVUHJDUGLQJ
PRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHPDUNLQJVXJJHVWHGE\W\SRORJLFDOVWXGLHV

#EE7>=<@6<85D
01%2#3$456$'+55+ 78+9)#:;#8+!"#$%&'"()*+(,-./0%#1$"-2"%3(4..*%56-#768.8+<5;13$=;4/+>$##$11)?5@A+.BBC
"0D+ >;#3;#@+E)44;#+$4=+<)'F:$4:+7G''5:8+b()(()a#04+!%1)"%(-(>a#04+!%/)04-#:$!)8+,4=+;=5@5)48
<5;13$=;4/+>$##$11)?5@AH+.BCCI.BCB+

F<E?<8G7@HCB
$QGHUVRQ-RKQ0
  A6"!-)%D-(>>(-0%6:%3(0!g%<%K!$-60I!4$#?!2[IRUG/LQJXLVWLFV2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
%HQ])UDQN/
% OP@:% @!-06)(.%B(>!0%#)%$+!%@+6!)#4#()%()"%@1)#4%/)04-#I$#6)0g%<%3($(.652%D-(>>($#4(.%7$1"'%()"%D.600(-'%6:%8.!M
>!)$06WXGLD3RKO5RPH%LEOLFDO,QVWLWXWH3UHVV
%ODNH%DUU\-
% :??O% 3(0!QGHGLWLRQ&DPEULGJH7H[WERRNVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
%URFNHOPDQQ&DUO
  ´$UDPlLVFKXQG6\ULVFKµ7!>#$#0$#=²
3JIJH2%,68HJ7
  <.$(-(>a#04+!%D-(>>($#=%"!-%/)04+-#:$!)%"!0%_pLqàL%P+L%?L%3+-$EKDQGOXQJHQIUGLH.XQGHGHV0RUJHQ
ODQGHV:LHVEDGHQ)UDQ]6WHLQHU

<@
)RUH[DPSOHVVHH+DVVHOEDFK

9RQ6RGHQ†H
 oi.uchicago.edu

OO?% K8S833<%O<778NS<3O

'LRQ3DXO(XJqQH
% OP@<% N(%.()51!%"!%Y(;1"#g%H!04-#I$#6)%!$%4.(00!>!)$%"!%.;()4#!)%I(-.!-%"!%t!)4#-.#%"()0%.!%4("-!%"!0%.()51!0%0U>#M
$#X1!0%"1%)6-"M61!0$2QWDULR(GLWLRQV65
)DOHV)UHGHULFN0
  ´0RVW$QFLHQW$UDPDLF7H[WVDQG/LQJXLVWLFV$5HYLHZRI5HFHQW6WXGLHVµ/)46)$-#%N#)51#0$#4#%OPN%
²
)ULHGULFK-RKDQQHV:ROIJDQJ5|OOLJ0DULD*LXOLD$PDGDVL*X]]R
% OPPP% @+~)#G#04+M@1)#04+!%D-(>>($#=UGHGLWLRQ$QDOHFWD2ULHQWDOLD5RPH3RQWLILFLXP,QVWLWXWXP
%LEOLFXP
*DUU:5DQGDOO
  H#(.!4$%D!65-(I+'%6:%7'-#(M@(.!0$#)!2%_pppqsà|%SL3L8L3KLODGHOSKLD8QLYHUVLW\RI3HQQV\OYDQLD3UHVV
+DFNHWW-R$QQ
  ´3KRHQLFLDQDQG3XQLFµ,Q*+!%3(>&-#"5!%8)4'4.6I!"#(%6:%$+!%J6-.";0%<)4#!)$%N()51(5!0HGLWHGE\5¬'
:RRGDUGSS²&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
+lPHHQ$QWWLOD-DDNNR
% :???% <%7=!$4+%6:%B!6M<00'-#()%D-(>>(-6WDWH$UFKLYHVRI$VV\ULD6WXGLHV+HOVLQNL1HR$VV\ULDQ7H[W
&RUSXV3URMHFW
+DUULV=HOOLJ6
  <%D-(>>(-%6:%$+!%@+6!)#4#()%N()51(5!$PHULFDQ2ULHQWDO6HULHV1HZ+DYHQ$PHULFDQ2ULHQWDO
6RFLHW\
+DVVHOEDFK5HEHFFD
% :??R% 7(-56)#4%<==("#()g%<%O#0$6-#4(.%()"%36>I(-($#?!%7$1"'%6:%$+!%7'..(&#4%*!]$0:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
+XHKQHUJDUG-RKQ
  ´7KH'HYHORSPHQWRIWKH7KLUG3HUVRQ6XIIL[HVLQ3KRHQLFLDQµA((-(?²
  ´$IUR$VLDWLFµ,Q*+!%3(>&-#"5!%8)4'4.6I!"#(%6:%$+!%J6-.";0%<)4#!)$%N()51(5!0HGLWHGE\5':RRG
DUGSS²&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
+XJ9RONHU
% OPPQ% <.$(-(>a#04+!%D-(>>($#=%"!-%*!]$!%"!0%oL%1)"%|L%P+L0%?L%3+-+HLGHOEHUJHU6WXGLHQ]XPDOWHQ2ULHQW
+HLGHOEHUJ+HLGHOEHUJHU2ULHQWYHUODJ%
.UDKPDONRY&KDUOHV5
% :??O% <%@+6!)#4#()M@1)#4%D-(>>(-+DQGEXFKGHU2ULHQWDOLVWLN6HFWLRQ1DKHXQG0LWWOHUH2VWHQ
/HLGHQ%ULOO
/LSL‫ش‬VNL(GZDUG
% :??O% 7!>#$#4%N()51(5!0g%,1$.#)!%6:%(%36>I(-($#?!%D-(>>(-QGHGLWLRQ2ULHQWDOLD/RYDQLHQVLD$QDOHFWD
/HXYHQ3HHWHUV
0XUDRND7DQG%H]DOHO3RUWHQ
% :??Q% <%D-(>>(-%6:%85'I$#()%<-(>(#4QGHGLWLRQUHYLVHG+DQGEXFKGHU2ULHQWDOLVWLN6HFWLRQ'HU1DKH
XQG0LWWOHUH2VWHQ/HLGHQ%ULOO
5DLQH\$QVRQ)
  3()(()#$!%#)%$+!%<>(-)(%*(&.!$0g%<%N#)51#0$#4%<)(.'0#0%6:%$+!%A#]!"%H#(.!4$%\0!"%&'%$+!%74-#&!0%:-6>%3()(()
YROXPHV+DQGEXFKGHU2ULHQWDOLVWLN6HFWLRQ'HU1DKHXQG0LWWOHUH2VWHQ/HLGHQ%ULOO
6HJHUW6
% OP@R% <.$(-(>a#04+!%D-(>>($#=/HLS]LJ9HUODJ(Q]\NORSlGLH
  <%D-(>>(-%6:%@+6!)#4#()%()"%@1)#40XQLFK&+%HFN
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 8<KNY%3<B<<B/*8%<BH%,NH%<K<A</3%3<78%/B%*O8%N/DO*%,F%N<BD\<D8%*Y@,N,DY% OOO

#7F==J72%[F9JG
% OPPQ% H#!%/)04+-#:$!)%?6)%t#)4#-.#$EKDQGOXQJHQ]XU/LWHUDWXU$OW6\ULHQ3DOlVWLQDV0QVWHU8JDULW
% :???% \5(-#$#04+!%D-(>>($#=$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW0QVWHU8JDULW9HUODJ
YRQ6RGHQ:ROIUDP
% OPPR% D-1)"-#00%"!-%(==("#04+!)%D-(>>($#=UGHGLWLRQ$QDOHFWD2ULHQWDOLD5RPH3RQWLILFLXP,QVWLWX
WXP%LEOLFXP
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% T87*/D87%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%8B*K8%N8%B,A%8*%N8%@K,B,A%7\FF/i8%8B%OQSK8\%S/SN/e\8% OOQ

!
"#$%&'#$()*($+$%,-#(./$*#0(#1%2#(0#(13-((
#%(0#(42313-($*55&6#(#1(7892#*(9&90&:*#

H!))#0%@(-"!!2%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%3+#4(56

(QKpEUHXELEOLTXHXQpWDWDQWpULHXUGHODODQJXHHVWSDUIRLVFRQVHUYpGDQVGHVIRUPHVFRQVLVWDQWHQXQpOp
PHQWGHEDVHDXTXHOXQSURQRPVXIIL[HHVWDWWDFKp1RWRLUHHVWO·H[HPSOHGHODJSHUVRQQHGXIpPLQLQVLQJXOLHU
GHO·DFFRPSOLGRQWODWHUPLQDLVRQQRUPDOHHVWWDORUVTX·RQWURXYHWҸORUVTX·XQSURQRPVXIIL[HHVWDWWDFKp
DXYHUEH

TčWDOW´WX IpPVLQJ DV47/µ

 T̾WDOWҸKࡃ´WX IpPVLQJ O·DV47/µO

/DIRUPHYHUEDOHDUFKDwTXHpWDQWTDWDOWLLOSDUDvWpYLGHQWTXHODIRUPHjVXIIL[HSURQRPLQDOUHIOqWHXQHpYR
OXWLRQGHTDWDOWLjTDWDOWҸTXLSUpFpGDLWFKURQRORJLTXHPHQWODIRUPHGHO·KpEUHXFODVVLTXHRODYR\HOOH
ILQDOHHVWWRPEpHVDQVGRXWHSDULQWHUIpUHQFHDYHFODqUHSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHU&HWWHGHUQLqUHIRUPHpWDLWHQ
SURWRRXHVWVpPLWLTXHTDWDOWXPDLVHOOHHVWGHYHQXHTDWDOWҸVRXVO·LQIOXHQFHGHVQRPEUHX[H[HPSOHVGHҸ
FRPPHYR\HOOHILQDOHG·XQpOpPHQWSURQRPLQDOGHODqUHSHUVRQQH8QHpYROXWLRQVLPLODLUHHVWDWWHVWpHSRXUOH
SURQRPLQGpSHQGDQWGHODqUHSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHU૟DQčNX!૟čQ‫گ‬NҸ:GpYHORSSHPHQWDVVH]WDUGLIGXPRLQV
HQFHTXLFRQFHUQHO·DFFHQWVXUODV\OODEHILQDOHSXLVTXHOHSDVVDJHGHDjTDPHߙGDQVODSUHPLqUHV\OODEHVHORQ
ODWUDGLWLRQPDVVRUpWLTXHUHIOqWHO·pWDSHRO·DFFHQWpWDLWHQFRUHVXUODYR\HOOHORQJXHSULPLWLYHGHODGHX[LqPH
V\OODEH/DFRQVHUYDWLRQGHODIRUPHGHODJSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHUDSSDUWHQDQWjXQpWDWSUpFpGHQWGHODODQJXH
DHXSRXUHIIHWGHFUpHUXQHDPELJXwWpT̾WDOWҸKࡃVLJQLILDQWVHORQOHFRQWH[WH´WX IpPVLQJ O·DV47/µRX´MH
O·DL47/µ/HVSULQFLSDOHVpWDSHVGHO·pYROXWLRQGHFHVIRUPHVGHYDLHQWGRQFrWUH

  TDWDOWX ´M·DL47/µ
  TDWDOWL ´WX IpPVLQJ DV47/µ
   TDWDOWҸ ´M·DL47/µ
  TDWDOWҸ ´WX IpPVLQJ DV47/µ
   TDWDOWҸ ´M·DL47/µ
  TDWDOW ´WX IpPVLQJ DV47/µ

&·HVWODGHX[LqPHGHFHVpWDSHVTXLHVWFRQVHUYpHGDQVODIRUPHFRPSRVLWHT̾WDOWҸKࡃVLJQLILDQWVRLW´WX IpP
VLQJ O·DV47/µVRLW´MHO·DL47/µVHORQODVLWXDWLRQQ
/HVJUDPPDLUHVGHO·KpEUHXELEOLTXHFLWHQWGHVH[HPSOHVSRQFWXHOVSOXVRXPRLQVYUDLVHPEODEOHVGHYHVWLJHV
GXV\VWqPHFDVXHO<SDUH[HPSOHєD\ࠂ‫گ‬૟čUHߙOLWW´OHVErWHVGHODWHUUHµ *HQHVLV¬« RXE̾QҸ૟Dࠂ‫گ‬Q‫گ‬OLWW

O
&HVIRUPHVVRQWSHXDWWHVWpHVGDQVOHSHWLWFRUSXVIRXUQLSDUOD
%LEOH KpEUDwTXH PDLV OH SDUDGLJPH FRPSOHW HVW H[WUDSROp GHV
TXHOTXHVIRUPHVUpHOOHVYRLU*HVHQLXV.DXW]VFKHW&RZOH\
 †D>H@ ²%DXHUHW/HDQGHU¬ †I  ² 
:
 &HWWH pYROXWLRQ V·H[SOLTXH VRLW SDU GLVVLPLODWLRQ ૟DQčNX !
૟DQ‫گ‬NX !૟DQ‫گ‬N‫! گ‬૟DQ‫گ‬NҸ %ODX² VRLWSDUDQD
ORJLHDSUqVODFKXWHGHODYR\HOOHFRXUWHjODILQGXPRW૟DQčNX
!૟DQ‫گ‬NX!૟DQ‫گ‬N!૟čQ‫گ‬N!૟čQ‫گ‬NҸ'DQVXQFDVFRPPHGDQV
O·DXWUHODYR\HOOHҸpWDLWV€UHPHQWFKRLVLSDUDQDORJLHDYHFv
SURQRPGHODqUHSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHUDWWDFKpDXQRPFRPPXQDX
VLQJXOLHU DYHFIRQFWLRQGXJpQLWLI HWDYHFQL!QҸSURQRPGH
ODPrPHSHUVRQQHDWWDFKpDXYHUEH DYHFIRQFWLRQGHO·DFFXVDWLI OD
YR\HOOHHVWORQJXHSDUFHTX·HOOHHVWVLWXpHjODILQGXPRW
Q
/·XVDJHGXPRW´pWDSHµQHVLJQDOHSDVO·H[LVWHQFHFKH]QRXVG·XQH
K\SRWKqVHGpWDLOOpHGXGpYHORSSHPHQWGHVYR\HOOHVFRXUWHVHQWUHOH
SURWRKpEUHXHWO·KpEUHXELEOLTXHQRXVFRQVWDWRQVVLPSOHPHQWTXH
O·LGHQWLWpGHVIRUPHVHQKpEUHXELEOLTXHUHPRQWHjXQHpWDSHSUpFp
GHQWHGHODODQJXHROHVGHX[IRUPHVHQTXHVWLRQpWDLHQWLGHQWLTXHV
<
*HVHQLXV.DXW]VFKHW&RZOH\² † %DXHUHW/HDQGHU
OP::N%² † -RRQ² † FI%URFNHOPDQQ
² †K 

OOQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

OO<% H8BB/7%@<KH88

´OHILOVGHVRQkQHVVHµ *HQHVLV -HQ·DLSDVO·LQWHQWLRQGHWUDLWHULFLFHJHQUHGHGRQQpHVGRQWDXPRLQVGHX[

FDWpJRULHVHQWLqUHVVRQWUHQGXHVFDGXTXHVSDUOHVGRQQpHVGHO·RXJDULWLTXHR
(QUHYDQFKHLOPHSDUDvWQpFHVVDLUHG·H[SOLTXHUODYR\HOOHHQWUHOHQRPFRPPXQHWXQSURQRPVXIIL[HTX·HOOH
VRLWFRQVHUYpHFRPPHO·XQHGHVYR\HOOHVGXV\VWqPHPDVVRUpWLTXHRXFRPPHk̾9(%>!"#1>HQIRQFWLRQGXV\V
WqPHFDVXHOGXSURWRKpEUHX/HVV\VWqPHVFDVXHOVGHVODQJXHVVpPLWLTXHVRFHWWHGpFOLQDLVRQHVWFRQVHUYpHVH
UHVVHPEOHQWWRXVHWFHWWHUHVVHPEODQFHFRQILUPHTXHOHQRPFRPPXQHQSURWRKpEUHXGHYDLWVHGpFOLQHUVHORQ
OHVFDWpJRULHVGHQRPEUHJHQUHHWFDVGHODPDQLqUHVXLYDQWH

% 7#)51.#!-% % H1!.% @.1-#!.

 1RPPDVFVLQJ PDONX 1RPPDVFGXHOPDONčPD 1RPPDVFSOXUPDODNࡃPD
 *pQPDVFVLQJ PDONL 2EOPDVFGXHOPDOND\PD 2EOPDVFSOXUPDODNҸPD
 $FFPDVFVLQJ PDOND  

 1RPIpPVLQJ PDONDWX 1RPIpPGXHOPDONDWčPD 1RPIpPSOXUPDODNčWX

 *pQIpPVLQJ PDONDWL 2EOIpPGXHOPDONDWD\PD 2EOIpPSOXUPDODNčWL
 $FFIpPVLQJ PDONDWD

7URLVUHPDUTXHVjSURSRVGHFHWDEOHDX  OHV\VWqPHHVWWULSWRWLTXHDXVLQJXOLHUGLSWRWLTXHDXGXHOHWDXSOX
ULHO  OHGXHOpWDLWSURGXFWLIHQRXJDULWLTXHFRPPHHQDUDEHF·HVWjGLUHTX·LOV·HPSOR\DLWDYHFWRXVOHVQRPV
FRPPXQVSRXUGLVWLQJXHUGHX[REMHWVGHO·XQLWpG·XQF{WpHWGXJURXSHGHWURLVREMHWVRXSOXVGHO·DXWUHHWLO
O·pWDLWFHUWDLQHPHQWHQSURWRKpEUHX  OHPRWFKRLVLSRXUFHVH[HPSOHV>(.=1´URLµHVWjEDVHGHTDWOHWOHV
VFKqPHVTDWOTLWOTXWOPDQLIHVWHQWXQVFKqPHELV\OODELTXHDXSOXULHO
/·K\SRWKqVHSURSRVpHLFLHVWODVXLYDQWHOHV\VWqPHGHVQRPVFRPPXQVDX[TXHOVXQSURQRPVXIIL[HHVWDWWDFKp
UHSUpVHQWHO·pWDSHRODYR\HOOHPDUTXDQWOHQRPLQDWLIDHQWLqUHPHQWGLVSDUXF·HVWjGLUHDXVLQJXOLHUDXGXHO
HWDXSOXULHOHWROHGXHOQ·pWDLWSOXVSURGXFWLIFHTXLDSHUPLVODUHGLVWULEXWLRQGHVIRUPHVREOLTXHVGXSOXULHO
VHORQOHFULWqUHGHO·pWDWJUDPPDWLFDODEVROXRXFRQVWUXLW$XVLQJXOLHUOHSULQFLSHGHODGLVWULEXWLRQGHVIRUPHV
GHO·DFFXVDWLIHWGXJpQLWLIpWDLWFHOXLGHO·KDUPRQLHYRFDOLTXH/HVSULQFLSDOHVpWDSHVVRQWGRQF
 /·pWDWSULPLWLITXLGHYDLWrWUHFRPPXQDXSURWRQRUGRXHVWVpPLWLTXH

% 1RPPDVFVLQJ PDONX 1RPPDVFGXHOPDONčPD 1RPPDVFSOXUPDODNࡃPD%

 *pQPDVFVLQJ PDONL 2EOPDVFGXHOPDOND\PD 2EOPDVFSOXUPDODNҸPD%
 $FFPDVFVLQJ PDOND

 1RPIpPVLQJ PDONDWX 1RPIpPGXHOPDONDWčPD 1RPIpPSOXUPDODNčWX%

 *pQIpPVLQJ PDONDWL 2EOIpPGXHOPDONDWD\PD 2EOIpPSOXUPDODNčWL%
 $FFIpPVLQJ PDONDWD

 /·pWDWROHQRPLQDWLIHVWSHUGXpWDQWUHPSODFpSDUO·XQRXO·DXWUHGHVGHX[DXWUHVFDVjHQMXJHUG·DSUqV
O·pWDWSURQRPLQDOHQSKpQLFLHQOHQRPLQDWLIHWO·DFFXVDWLIDXUDLHQWIXVLRQQpHWSDUFRQVpTXHQWGDQVOHWDEOHDX
VXLYDQW´$1µGpVLJQHODFRQVHUYDWLRQGHODYR\HOOHGHO·DFFXVDWLIGDQVFHTXLDXUDLWpWpDXPRLQVjO·RULJLQHXQ
V\VWqPHGLSWRWLTXHRO·DQFLHQDFFXVDWLIUHPSODoDLWOHQRPLQDWLISDURSSRVLWLRQDXJpQLWLI$XWUHPHQWGLWVLOHV\V
WqPHjFHWWHpWDSHIRQFWLRQQDLWFRPPHHQSKpQLFLHQFHTX·LOHVWLPSRVVLEOHGHVDYRLUOHJpQLWLIJDUGDLWVDIRQFWLRQ
DORUVTXHOHVXMHWHWOHFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWGLUHFWpWDLHQWWRXVGHX[H[SULPpVSDUODIRUPHVHWHUPLQDQWHQD

% +FMPDVFVLQJ PDONX 1RPPDVFGXHOPDONčPD 1RPPDVFSOXUPDODNࡃPD%

 *pQPDVFVLQJ PDONL 2EOPDVFGXHOPDOND\PD 2EOPDVFSOXUPDODNҸPD%
 $1PDVFVLQJ PDOND

% 1RPIpPVLQJ PDONDWX 1RPIpPGXHOPDONDWčPD 1RPIpPSOXUPDODNčKLW%

 *pQIpPVLQJ PDONDWL 2EOIpPGXHOPDONDWD\PD 2EOIpPSOXUPDODNčWL%
 $1IpPVLQJ PDONDWD

R
%-J%+zORFDWLIGLUHFWLIQ·HVWSDVXQYHVWLJHGHO·DFFXVDWLIPDLVG·XQH JpQLWLIGXPRLQVGDQVWRXWHVOHVRFFXUUHQFHVPDLVG·XQHSDUWLFXOH
SDUWLFXOHDIIRUPDQWHKDHWOH'6"%46>I(5#)#0Q·HVWSDVXQYHVWLJHGX HQFOLWLTXH\D
 oi.uchicago.edu

% T87*/D87%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%8B*K8%N8%B,A%8*%N8%@K,B,A%7\FF/i8%8B%OQSK8\%S/SN/e\8% OOR

 /·pWDWTXHUHIOqWHOHV\VWqPHFRQQXSDUO·KpEUHXELEOLTXHROHVYR\HOOHVPDUTXDQWSULPLWLYHPHQWOHJpQLWLI
HWO·DFFXVDWLIDXVLQJXOLHURQWSHUGXFHWWHIRQFWLRQHWRjO·pWDWSURQRPLQDOO·XQHRXO·DXWUHGHFHVYR\HOOHVHVW
UHWHQXHSDUKDUPRQLHYRFDOLTXHDYHFVRLWODFRQVRQQH qUHSHUVRQQHGXVLQJ VRLWODYR\HOOHGHO·pOpPHQWSURQR
PLQDOVLODYR\HOOHGXSURQRPQHWURXYHSDVGHFRUUHVSRQGDQWHQWUHOHVGHX[YR\HOOHVFDVXHOOHVSULPLWLYHVTXL
VRQWFRQVHUYpHVOHFKRL[HVWRXYHUWHQWUHOHVGHX[9RLFLODGpFOLQDLVRQGXQRPPDVFXOLQ OHVWHUPLQDLVRQVVRQW
LGHQWLTXHVDYHFOHQRPIpPLQLQ 

 PDONv´PRQURLµ PDON¬L\D
 PDON̾Nč´WRQ PDVFVLQJ URLµ PDONDND
 PDON̒N´WRQ IpPVLQJ URLµ PDONLNL
 PDON{´VRQ PDVF¬VLQJ URLµ PDONDKX FIDUDPpHQPDON̒KPDONLKX @

 PDONk´VRQ IpPVLQJ URLµ PDONDKD

 PDON̒Qࡃ´QRWUHURLµ PDONLQࡃ
 PDON̾NHP´YRWUH PDVFSOXU URLµ PDON"NXPX HIpPLQLQ
 PDON̾NHQ´YRWUH IpPSOXU URLµ PDONLNLQL
 PDONčP´OHXU PDVFSOXU URLµ PDONDKXPX
 PDONčQ´OHXU IpPSOXU URLµ PDONLKLQL čPDVFXOLQ

³,OHVWjUHPDUTXHUTXHODSUpVHQFHG·XQHYR\HOOHHQWUHODEDVHQRPLQDOHHWO·pOpPHQWSURQRPLQDODXVVLELHQTXH
O·DVSLUDWLRQGXNGHVSURQRPVGHODJSHUVRQQHQHODLVVHQWSDVGHGRXWHTXHjO·pSRTXHRFHVIRUPHVpWDLHQW
FRXUDQWHVOHVSURQRPVpWDLHQWDWWDFKpVjXQHIRUPHGXQRPTXLFRPSRUWDLWHQFRUHXQHYR\HOOHFDVXHOOH&HOD
pWDQWVLO·pWDWFRQVWUXLWGXQRPDYDLWjFHWWHpSRTXHSHUGXODYR\HOOHFDVXHOOH PDON9!PDON‘ OHVSUR
QRPVVXIIL[HVQ·pWDLHQWSDVDWWDFKpVDXQRPjO·pWDWFRQVWUXLW­FHWWHPDQLqUHGHIRUPXOHUODVLWXDWLRQRQGRLW
SUpIpUHUFHOOHFLOHQRPjO·pWDWFRQVWUXLWDSHUGXODYR\HOOHFDVXHOOHjXQPRPHQWRODGpFOLQDLVRQGHVQRPVDYHF
SURQRPVXIIL[HpWDLWGpMjILJpHHQSODFH,OIDXWGRQFHQYLVDJHUXQHpWDSHROHQRPjO·pWDWDEVROXUHWHQDLWXQH
GHFHVYR\HOOHVFDVXHOOHVRXWRXWHVOHVGHX[ROHQRPjO·pWDWSURQRPLQDOUHWHQDLWFHVGHX[YR\HOOHVUHGLVWULEXpV
VHORQOHSULQFLSHGHO·KDUPRQLHYRFDOLTXHHWROHQRPjO·pWDWFRQVWUXLWDYDLWSHUGXWRXWHYR\HOOHILQDOH

³pWDWDEVROXVFKqPHQRPLQDODLG·DERUGFRPPHYR\HOOHVFDVXHOOHVHQV\VWqPHGLSWRWLTXHHQVXLWH
HQYDULDWLRQOLEUHORUVTXHODIRQFWLRQFDVXHOOHpWDLWSHUGXH
³pWDWFRQVWUXLWVFKqPHQRPLQDO‘
³pWDWSURQRPLQDOVFKqPHQRPLQDODLGLVWULEXpVSDUKDUPRQLHYRFDOLTXH

/HVIRUPHVHQKpEUHXELEOLTXHGHVQRPVFRPPXQVjVFKqPHGHEDVHFRPSRUWDQWGHX[DH[LJHQWFHWWHK\SR
WKqVHGčEčUjO·pWDWDEVROXG̾EDUjO·pWDWFRQVWUXLWG̾EčURXG̾EDUjO·pWDWSURQRPLQDOVHORQOH´SRLGVµ
GXVXIIL[H G̾EčUvG̾EDU֚HP 2QGRLWVDQVGRXWHH[SOLTXHUODGLVSDULWLRQGHODYR\HOOHILQDOHjO·pWDWFRQVWUXLW
DYDQWFHWWHPrPHSHUWHjO·pWDWDEVROXHQIRQFWLRQGHODGLIIpUHQFHG·DFFHQWHQWUHOHVGHX[IRUPHVXQQRPjO·pWDW
FRQVWUXLWSRUWDQWXQDFFHQWIDLEOHGXIDLWGHVDOLDLVRQDXPRWVXLYDQW
³¬/·pOpPHQWOHSOXVGLVSXWpGHFHWDEOHDXVHUDPDON¬D¬KXFDU&URVVVRXWLHQWGHSXLVELHQW{WTXDUDQWHDQV
TXHFHWWHIRUPHUHIOqWHHQIDLWODYR\HOOHFDVXHOOHGXQRPLQDWLIPDONXKX P/HVSULQFLSDX[pOpPHQWVGHOD


PDONpNčHQSDXVHRQWURXYHčNHQSDXVHDYHFFHUWDLQHVSUp
SRVLWLRQV SDUH[EčN´HQWRL>PDVFVLQJ@µ HWDYHFOHQRPN‫گ‬O2%
DWWHVWpVRXVODIRUPHNXOOčNDYHFFHVXIIL[H¬³¬YRLU+XHKQHUJDUG
Q 
@
,OHVWOpJLWLPHG·DIILUPHUTXHO·pWDSHFRQVHUYpHSDUOHV\VWqPHGHV
QRPVFRPPXQVSURQRPVXIIL[HpWDLWLGHQWLTXHHQDUDPpHQHWHQ
KpEUHXjVDYRLUTXHOHQRPLQDWLIDYDLWGLVSDUXjO·pSRTXHTXHUHIOqWH
OHV\VWqPHGHVQRPVFRPPXQVSURQRPVXIIL[H4XHOHDVRLWUH
WHQXHQKpEUHXOHLHQDUDPpHQGDQVFHWWHIRUPHDORUVTXHFHV
GHX[YR\HOOHVVRQWGLVWULEXpHVSDUKDUPRQLHYRFDOLTXHGDQVG·DXWUHV
IRUPHVGDQVOHVGHX[ODQJXHVHVWXQLQGLFHFODLUTXHOHFKRL[pWDLW
RXYHUWHQWUHOHVGHX[YR\HOOHVORUVTXHODYR\HOOHGXSURQRPpWDLW
X/HVHXOLQGLFHGXFRQWUDLUHHQDUDPpHQVHWURXYHGDQVODSHWLWH
FODVVHFRQVWLWXpHSDUOHVQRPV૟DE´SqUHµ૟Dє´IUqUHµHWєDP
´EHDXSqUHµ૟6EvjO·pWDWFRQVWUXLWPDLV૟6E€DYHFOHVSURQRPV
VXIIL[HVRODYR\HOOHFRQVHUYpHHVWHQHIIHWFHOOHGXQRPLQDWLI %URF
NHOPDQQ†KD>S@ &·HVWYUDLVHPEODEOHPHQWODSDUWLFX
ODULWpGHFHVIRUPHVjVDYRLUGHVQRPVVHWHUPLQDQWSDUXQHYR\HOOH
ORQJXHDXVLQJXOLHUTXLDFRQWULEXpjODFRQVHUYDWLRQG·XQHIRUPH
SDUWLFXOLqUHORUVTXHOHV\VWqPHFDVXHODVLPSOLILp

6LPSOLILFDWLRQUDGLFDOHjVDYRLUVDQVFRQWUDFWLRQGHVYR\HOOHVD
HWX
P
&URVVQQD ² HVSS  UpLP
SUHVVLRQ GDQV E   ,Q  )DVVEHUJ D DIILUPp TXH ´7KH
GHYHORSPHQW1+1%X%1+%X%xLVMXVWDVIHDVLEOHDV(+1%X%(9!{IRUWKH
PDVFVLQJSURQRPLQDOVXIIL[µ )DVVEHUJ HWO·H[SOLFDWLRQj
SDUWLUGXQRPLQDWLIDpWpDGRSWpHSDU+DVVHOEDFK QRXVWHQRQV
jUHPHUFLHUQRWUHFROOqJXHGH&KLFDJRG·DYRLUDWWLUpQRWUHDWWHQWLRQ
VXUFHWWHpWXGHHWG·DYRLUOXHWFULWLTXpODQ{WUH 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H8BB/7%@<KH88

GLVFXVVLRQVRQW D GHVDYRLUVLO·K\SRWKqVHGHODFRQVHUYDWLRQGXQRPLQDWLIGDQVOHV\VWqPHWHOTX·RQOHFRQQDvW
HQKpEUHXELEOLTXHHVWjUHWHQLU E OHVGRQQpHVGHVLQVFULSWLRQVKpEUDwTXHVG·DYDQWO·H[LOEDE\ORQLHQ GpEXW9,J%
VLqFOHDYDQW-& ROHVXIIL[HGHODJSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHUV·pFULWWRXMRXUVDYHF^K` F ODFRPSDUDLVRQDYHFFH
PrPHVXIIL[HORUVTX·LOHVWDWWDFKpjXQYHUEHjO·DFFRPSOL9RLFLQRVUpSRQVHVEUqYHVDX[TXHVWLRQVTXHVRXOqYHQW
FHVSRLQWVGHGLVFXVVLRQ

D /·DEVHQFHGHWRXWDXWUHYHVWLJHGXFDVQRPLQDWLIGDQVOHV\VWqPHTXLIDLWO·REMHWGHFHWWHpWXGHIDLWSUpIpUHU
XQHK\SRWKqVHGDQVODTXHOOHOHPRUSKqPHGXQRPLQDWLIHVWH[FOX2QUHPDUTXHUDG·HPEOpHTXHODSUpVHQFHGHOD
YR\HOOHDGDQVG·DXWUHVIRUPHVGHODGpFOLQDLVRQO?H[LJHO·DOWHUQDWLYHVXLYDQWHVRLWOHV\VWqPHYLVLEOHHQKpEUHX
ELEOLTXHUHPRQWHjO·pWDWWULSWRWLTXHHWOHVHXOYHVWLJHGXQRPLQDWLIVHUDLWGHYDQWOHSURQRPGHOD J%=J79FHHJ%
GXPDVFXOLQVLQJXOLHU ODWKqVHGH&URVVHWGH+DVVHOEDFK OOVRLWODIRUPHPDON{UHIOqWHO·pWDSHGLSWRWLTXHTXH
QRXVSUpFRQLVRQV$XWUHPHQWGLWODSUpVHQFHGHDGDQVG·DXWUHVIRUPHVpOLPLQHO·K\SRWKqVHVHORQODTXHOOHF·HVW
ODYR\HOOHGXQRPLQDWLIHWQRQSDVFHOOHGHO·DFFXVDWLITXLDXUDLWpWpFRQVHUYpHjO·pWDSHGLSWRWLTXHO:/·H[LVWHQFH
G·XQHpWDSHGLSWRWLTXHGXQRPVXLYLGHVSURQRPVVXIIL[HVHVWFHUWDLQHSRXUOHSKpQLFLHQFODVVLTXHFHTXLUHQGDX
PRLQVSODXVLEOHTXHO·KpEUHXDLWVXLYLXQHpYROXWLRQVLPLODLUH¬³¬ODTXHVWLRQTXHO·RQVHSRVHHVWGHVDYRLUV·LOHVW
SOXVSODXVLEOHGHIDLUHUHPRQWHUOHV\VWqPHFRQQXSDUO·KpEUHXELEOLTXHjO·pWDSHSULPLWLYHRXVLRQGRLWSUpIpUHU
TXHFHVRLWOHV\VWqPHVHFRQGDLUHTXLVHUDLWFRQVHUYp/HIDLWTXHOHV\VWqPHGHVQRPVDX[GXHOHWSOXULHOVXLYLV
GHSURQRPVVXIIL[HVHQKpEUHXELEOLTXHUHIOqWHPDQLIHVWHPHQWXQHpWDSHVHFRQGDLUH YRLUODVXLWH QRXVSDUDvWXQ
DUJXPHQWHQIDYHXUGHODPrPHUHFRQVWLWXWLRQGXV\VWqPHGHVQRPVDXVLQJXOLHUOQ,OHVWDXVVLOpJLWLPHELHQTXH
PRLQVpYLGHQWG·DMRXWHUO·DUJXPHQWIRXUQLSDUOHVIRUPHVYHUEDOHVDX[TXHOOHVQRXVDYRQVIDLWDOOXVLRQHQJXLVH
G·LQWURGXFWLRQjFHVTXHOTXHVSURSRVT̾WDOWҸKXHVWXQHIRUPHWDUGLYHGHODqUHSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHU(QILQ
O·DUJXPHQWVHORQOHTXHOODYR\HOOHGXSURQRPKXDXUDLWG€WRPEHUFRPPHFHOOHVGHNLHWGHKD O<UHQFRQWUH
GHX[REMHFWLRQV  DXPRLQVGDQVFHUWDLQVGLDOHFWHVODYR\HOOHGXSURQRPNDJSHUVRQQHGXPDVFXOLQVLQJX
>8J72%J9K%6L998%7JKJHLJ2ORHW  RQSHXWFRQMHFWXUHUTX·HQKpEUHXODIRUPHHQWLqUHGXVXIIL[HKXpWDLWUHWHQXH
MXVWHPHQWSDUFHTXHFHWWHYR\HOOHQ·pWDLWSDVLGHQWLTXHjODSUpFpGHQWH

E 6·LOHVWjSHXSUqVFHUWDLQTXHOH^K`GHVLQVFULSWLRQVQHIRQFWLRQQHSDVFRPPH>($!-%.!4$#6)#0SRXU{ HQ
DFFRUGDYHF&URVVHW+DVVHOEDFK RQSHXWUHWHQLUO·H[SOLFDWLRQSDURUWKRJUDSKHKLVWRULTXHODVLPSOLILFDWLRQHQ
{DXUDLWHXOLHXDYDQWO·H[LOEDE\ORQLHQODPRGLILFDWLRQGHO·RUWKRJUDSKHSDUODTXHOOHOH^K`pWDLWUHPSODFp

O?
2QUHPDUTXHUDVXUWRXWPDONčPROHčFRQVWLWXHXQYHVWLJH
GHODYR\HOOHPDUTXDQWO·DFFXVDWLIDORUVTXHO·pOpPHQWSURQRPLQDO
FRPSRUWDLWSUREDEOHPHQWGHVYR\HOOHVX  KXPX /HVUHFRQV
WLWXWLRQVGHO·pOpPHQWSURQRPLQDODX[J%JK%QJSHUVRQQHVGXSOXULHO
YDULHQWVHORQOHVSpFLDOLVWHFRQVXOWpPDLVRQHVWHQJpQpUDOG·DFFRUG
TXHODSUHPLqUHYR\HOOHpWDLWXGDQVOHVIRUPHVGXPDVFXOLQL
GDQVFHOOHVGXIpPLQLQ2QHVWDXVVLJpQpUDOHPHQWG·DFFRUGSRXU
H[SOLTXHUO·LGHQWLWpGHODYR\HOOHGDQVOHVIRUPHVGXPDVFXOLQHWGX
IpPLQLQGDQVODGpFOLQDLVRQGHO·KpEUHXELEOLTXH RXGHO·DUDPpHQ 
FRPPHIXVLRQVXUOHPRGqOHGHO·XQHRXGHO·DXWUHGHVGHX[IRUPHV
SULPLWLYHV
OO
&URVVD +DVVHOEDFK²
O:
6LXQHpWDSHELHQDWWHVWpHGDQVO·pYROXWLRQGHVV\VWqPHVFDVXHOV
HVWFHOOHGHODGLSWRVLHDYHFRSSRVLWLRQQRPLQDWLIREOLTXHO·pOpPHQW
PDUTXDQWOHFDVGDQVOHQRXYHDXV\VWqPHSHXWSURYHQLUGHO·XQRX
O·DXWUHGHVFDVTXLRQWIXVLRQQp YRLU%ODNH² /DSUpVHQFH
GHč TDPHߙVHORQODWUDGLWLRQPDVVRUpWLTXH GDQVSOXVLHXUVIRUPHV
GHODGpFOLQDLVRQGHO·KpEUHXELEOLTXHQHODLVVHDXFXQGRXWHTXDQWj
ODSUpVHQFHGXDSURYHQDQWGHO·DQFLHQDFFXVDWLIGDQVO·pWDSHGHOD
ODQJXHTXHUHIOqWHO·KpEUHXELEOLTXHWHOTX·RQOHFRQQDvW
OQ
6HORQ0F&DUWHU  F·HVWODSHUWHGHVYR\HOOHVFRXUWHVPDU
TXDQWOHFDVDXVLQJXOLHUTXLDSURYRTXpODGLVSDULWLRQGXQRPLQDWLI
DXSOXULHO jFHTXHQRXVYR\RQVFHVSpFLDOLVWHQ·H[SOLTXHSDVOD
SHUWHGXQRPLQDWLIGXGXHO /·H[LVWHQFHGHYHVWLJHVGHFHVYR\HOOHV
GXVLQJXOLHUGDQVODGpFOLQDLVRQGXQRPSURQRPVXIIL[HHQKpEUHX
ELEOLTXHH[LJHSRXUWDQWFHWWHDOWHUQDWLYHVRLWOHV\VWqPHGXQRPDX
VLQJXOLHUGDWHG·DYDQWFHOXLGXGXHOSOXULHO FHVHUDLWO·K\SRWKqVH
TX·HQWUDvQHIRUFpPHQWO·H[SOLFDWLRQGH0F&DUWHU VRLWOHV\VWqPH
FDVXHOpWDLWHQFRUHGLSWRWLTXHDXVLQJXOLHUORUVTXHODGpFOLQDLVRQGX
QRPDXVLQJXOLHUHWFHOOHGXQRPDXGXHOSOXULHOIXVLRQQpVSURQRP
VXIIL[HVHVRQWILJpHVVRXVODIRUPHTXHUHSUpVHQWHO·KpEUHXELEOLTXH
/·pYROXWLRQGXGXHOFRPPHQRPEUHJUDPPDWLFDOSURGXFWLIGRLWDXVVL
FRPSWHUGDQVODUHFRQVWLWXWLRQGHO·pYROXWLRQGHFHVIRUPHV pOpPHQW
TXH0F&DUWHUQ·DGUHVVHSDV FDUODSULVHGHQRXYHOOHVIRQFWLRQVSDU
OHPRUSKqPHGHO·REOLTXHGXHOUHPSODoDQWOHPRUSKqPHGXSOXULHO
DX[pWDWVFRQVWUXLWHWSOXULHOQ·DSXVHUpDOLVHUTXHORUVTXHOHGXHO
Q·pWDLWSOXVSURGXFWLI YRLUSOXVHQGpWDLOFLGHVVRXVHQSDUWLFXOLHU
ODQRWH 
O<
&URVVD +DVVHOEDFK²
OR
4XRLTX·RQIDVVHGHVGRQQpHVGHO·KpEUHXMXGpHQLOIDXWWURXYHU
XQHRULJLQHSRXUODIRUPHNčGHODWUDGLWLRQPDVVRUpWLTXH+DVVHO
EDFK²&URVV D SURSRVHO·H[LVWHQFHGHO·RUWKR
JUDSKHSOHLQHNKGDQVXQHLQVFULSWLRQGH-pUXVDOHPHWGDQVXQH
DXWUHGH+RUYDW8]DRVHSUDWLTXDLWSHXWrWUHXQDXWUHGLDOHFWH j
HQMXJHUG·DSUqVO·XVDJHGX+LSKLOGH%5.jODSODFHGX3LHOGDQVOD
IRUPXOHGHEpQpGLFWLRQDWWHVWpHGDQVXQGRFXPHQWpSLVWRODLUHGX
PrPHVLWH%HLW$ULHKHW&UHVVRQ² 1RXVDYRQVXQHIRLV
SULVO·H[HPSOHGHO·LQVFULSWLRQGH-pUXVDOHPFRPPHLQGLFHGHYDULD
WLRQGDQVOHVFRQYHQWLRQVGHO·RUWKRJUDSKHSOXW{WTXHGHSUHXYHGH
GHX[SURQRQFLDWLRQV 3DUGHH 

 ,O Q·H[LVWH DXFXQH GRQQpH pSLJUDSKLTXH SURXYDQW GH PDQLqUH
FHUWDLQHTXHODGLSKWRQJXHDZDYDLWpWpVLPSOLILpHDYDQWO·H[LOHQ
SRVLWLRQQRQDFFHQWXp3RXUWDQWjFHTXHQRXVVDFKLRQVOHVGRQ
QpHVOHVSOXVWDUGLYHVV·LGHQWLILHQWGDQVOHVIRUPHV^૟ZG`HW^PZߙ૟`
GDWDQWG·HQYLURQDYDQW-& O·LQVFULSWLRQGH6LORDPYRLU&URVV
HW)UHHGPDQ 7RXWHIRLVVLRQWLHQWFRPSWHGHO·RQRPDV
WLTXHOHQRPEUHDXJPHQWH YRLU5HQ],,²*RJHO
² &HUWDLQHVGRQQpHVGHO·KpEUHXELEOLTXHLQGLTXHQWTXHDZ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% T87*/D87%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%8B*K8%N8%B,A%8*%N8%@K,B,A%7\FF/i8%8B%OQSK8\%S/SN/e\8% OO@

SDU^Z`VHXOHPHQWDSUqV O@4XRLTX·LOHQVRLWVLO·RQDGPHWTXHODIRUPHčZGXVXIIL[HGHOD JSHUVRQQHGX

PDVFXOLQVLQJXOLHUDWWDFKpjXQQRPDXGXHOSOXULHOVHORQODWUDGLWLRQPDVVRUpWLTXHUHIOqWHODSURQRQFLDWLRQGH
O·KpEUHXMXGpHQLOHVWQpFHVVDLUHGHSRVWXOHUTXHODIRUPH{O·DLWSUpFpGpVLQRQRQQ·H[SOLTXHSDVO·DEVHQFH
GHO·pYROXWLRQčZ! {pYROXWLRQTXLVHORQFHWWHK\SRWKqVHDXUDLWpWpHPSrFKpHSDUO·H[LVWHQFHGXVXIIL[H
{DWWDFKpDXQRPDXVLQJXOLHU

F 'DQVOHV\VWqPHGHO·DFFRPSOLGXYHUEHSURQRPVXIIL[HRQUHQFRQWUHGHX[FDVRODIRUPHYHUEDOHVHWHUPLQDLW
HQDHWRODIRUPHHQKpEUHXELEOLTXHDYHFFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWGLUHFWVRXVIRUPHGHVXIIL[HSURQRPLQDOGHOD
QJSHUVRQQHGXPDVFXOLQVLQJXOLHUDWWDFKpGLUHFWHPHQWDXYHUEHPDQLIHVWHODYR\HOOH{PDVFVLQJTDWDOD
KX!TčWčO{HWPVLQJTDWDOWDKX!T̾WDOW{6RLWFHVIRUPHVUpVXOWHQWGHODPrPHpYROXWLRQTXHFHOOH
TXHQRXVSUpFRQLVRQVSRXUOHV\VWqPHQRPLQDOVRLWHOOHVRQWpWpDGRSWpHVGDQVOHV\VWqPHYHUEDOSDUDQDORJLH
DYHFOHV\VWqPHQRPLQDOOP/DVHFRQGHH[SOLFDWLRQIDLWSDUWLHLQWpJUDOHGHO·K\SRWKqVHTXHIDLWGpULYHUOHVXIIL[H
{HQKpEUHXELEOLTXHGHODFRPELQDLVRQGHODYR\HOOHFDVXHOOHGXQRPLQDWLIHWOHSURQRPKXFDUGDQVFHV
IRUPHVYHUEDOHVRQQ·DSDVGHFKRL[WKpRULTXHHQWUHWURLVYR\HOOHVOHDIRQFWLRQQDQWFRPPHPDUTXHXUGHOD
SHUVRQQHJUDPPDWLFDOHGDQVFHVIRUPHV(QIDYHXUGHODVHFRQGHH[SOLFDWLRQRQGRLWFRPSWHUODIRUPHGHODJ%
SHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHUPDVFXOLQGHO·DFFRPSOLDYHFOHVXIIL[HGHOD JSHUVRQQHGXIpPLQLQVLQJXOLHUT̾WčO̒N
FDUFH̒QHSHXWSDVGpULYHUGLUHFWHPHQWGHTDWDODNL:?/HIDLWGHFHWHPSUXQWQ·HQWUDvQHFHSHQGDQWSDV
QpFHVVDLUHPHQWODFRQFOXVLRQTXHOHVGHX[IRUPHVFRPSRUWDQWOHSURQRPVXIIL[HGHODJSHUVRQQHGXPDVFXOLQ
VLQJXOLHUT̾WčO{HWT̾WDOW{VRLHQWOHUpVXOWDWGXPrPHSURFHVVXV/HVGRQQpHVGHVLQVFULSWLRQVVRQWLGHQWLTXHV
SRXUOHYHUEHHWSRXUOHQRPVHXOHODIRUPHYHUEDOHGHODJSHUVRQQHHVWDWWHVWpHFHUWDLQHPHQWDYHFFHSURQRP
VXIIL[HPDLVRQWURXYHGHVFDVFODLUVGHO·RUWKRJUDSKHGXVXIIL[HDYHF^K`:O%

(QVRPPHOHVHXODUJXPHQWGHSRLGVFRQWUHODUHFRQVWLWXWLRQGHPDON{GHPDON¬¬D¬¬KXV·LGHQWLILHGDQV
O·RUWKRJUDSKHGHVLQVFULSWLRQVROH^K`VHUDLWRUWKRJUDSKHKLVWRULTXHUHSUpVHQWDQWQRQSDVODSURQRQFLDWLRQ
PDON{GpMjHQXVDJHPDLVO·pWDSHSUpFpGHQWHORUVTXHODIRUPHpWDLWSURQRQFpHPDONDKX1RXVSUpIpURQVFHWWH
H[SOLFDWLRQjFHOOHTXLYRLWHQPDON{XQHSUHXYHTXHODGpFOLQDLVRQjODTXHOOHFHWWHIRUPHDSSDUWLHQWUHPRQWH
jO·pWDSHSULPLWLYHGXV\VWqPHFDVXHODORUVTXHOHVGXHOSOXULHOUHIOqWHQWPDQLIHVWHPHQWXQHpWDSHVHFRQGDLUH

ELV /·pWDWTXHUHIOqWHOHV\VWqPHGXGXHOHWGXSOXULHOHQO·KpEUHXELEOLTXHROHQRPLQDWLIDYDLWGLVSDUXHW
ROHGXHOQHIRQFWLRQQDLWSOXVFRPPHQRPEUHJUDPPDWLFDOSURGXFWLIjO·pWDWDEVROXOHVIRUPHVGXGXHOHWGX
SOXULHOUHVWHQWGLVWLQFWLYHVPDLVODYR\HOOHGXGXHOREOLTXHHVWXWLOLVpHjO·pWDWFRQVWUXLWHWjO·pWDWSURQRPLQDOGHV
QRPVTX·LOVVRLHQWjO·RULJLQHGXHOVRXSOXULHOV

DYUDLVHPEODEOHPHQWpWpVLPSOLILpDYDQWD\QRWDPPHQWOHIDLWTXH WULSKWRQJXHV LKXHWDKD³DYHFYR\HOOHVILQDOHVFRXUWHV¬³¬RQW

ODIRUPHVHFRQGDLUHT{OHVWEHDXFRXSSOXVIUpTXHQWHjO·pWDWDEVROX
GDQVOHVQRPVGXW\SHTDZO SDUH[ߖ{UߖDZU TXHQHO·HVWOD
IRUPHVHFRQGDLUHTrOGHTD\O SDUH[єrOєD\OTXLH[LVWH
jF{WpGHєi\LODYHFXQVHQVSDUWLFXOLHU ¬³¬FI3DUGHH²
O@
(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHO·RUWKRJUDSKH^K`GHVLQVFULSWLRQVSUpH[LOLTXHV
HQKpEUHXMXGpHQLOHVWQpFHVVDLUHGHSRVHUODTXHVWLRQVXLYDQWHj
ODTXHOOHQRXVQ·DYRQVSDVGHUpSRQVHTXLQRXVSDUDLVVHV€UHPDLVTXL
PpULWHUpIOH[LRQHVWLOSOXVSODXVLEOHGHYRLUHQFHWWHFRQVRQQHXQH
UpDOLWpSKRQpWLTXH XKRX‫گ‬KVHORQO·K\SRWKqVHGH&URVVHWGH
+DVVHOEDFK XQHRUWKRJUDSKHKLVWRULTXHVHORQFHWWHPrPHUHFRQV
WLWXWLRQGHODIRUPHRULJLQDOH +DVVHOEDFKODLVVHFHWWHSRV
VLELOLWpRXYHUWH´Xµ RXXQHRUWKRJUDSKHKLVWRULTXHVHORQO·H[SOL
FDWLRQG·DSUqVO·pOLVLRQLQWHUYRFDOLTXHGXK DKX!DXDZ!
{ "7RXWFRPSWHIDLW¬³¬RQFRQQDvWODWHQGDQFHGHODFRQVRQQH
KjGLVSDUDvWUHHQILQGHPRWORUVTX·HOOHQ·HVWSDVSURWpJpHSDU
XQHYR\HOOHVXLYDQWH¬³O·K\SRWKqVHIDLVDQWDSSHOjODVXUYLHG·XQ
KFRQVRQDQWLTXHGHSXLVO·pSRTXHROHVWURLVYR\HOOHVFDVXHOOHVGX
VLQJXOLHUH[LVWDLHQWMXVTX·DXPRPHQWRO·RUWKRJUDSKHGHO·KpEUHX
MXGpHQIXWIL[pH SUREDEOHPHQWDXGpEXWGXSUHPLHUPLOOpQDLUHDYDQW
-& QRXVSDUDvWSOXVGLIILFLOHjGpIHQGUHTXHFHOOHTXLIDLWDSSHOjOD
VXUYLHGHODWULSKWRQJXHDKXMXVTX·jFHWWHpSRTXH/·H[HPSOHGH
O·DUDPpHQROHKGHVSURQRPVVXIIL[HVGHODJSHUVRQQHGXPDV
FXOLQHWGXIpPLQLQVLQJXOLHUHVWHQFRUHFRQVRQDQWLTXHVHORQODWUD
GLWLRQPDVVRUpWLTXH ̒KHWčKUHVSHFWLYHPHQW LQGLTXHTXHOHV
VXUYpFXMXVTX·jWUqVWDUGGDQVO·KLVWRLUHGHODODQJXHHWLOIDXWHQ
GLUHGHPrPHGXVXIIL[HGHODJSHUVRQQHGXVLQJDWWDFKpjXQQRP
DXVLQJXOLHUHQKpEUHX D¬¬KD!čK 6HORQFHWWHUHVWLWXWLRQOHV
IRUPHVFRUUHVSRQGDQWHVHQKpEUHXMXGpHQpWDLHQWHQFRUHSURQRQ
FpHVDKXHWDKDDXWRXUGHO·DQDYDQW-&HWODVXUYLHGHOD
YR\HOOHFRXUWHjODILQGXPRWV·H[SOLTXHSDUPRUSKRSKRQRORJLH LO
V·DJLWGHSURQRPV 

3DUGHHQ
OP
&URVV OLPLWHO·HPSUXQWjO·KpEUHXPDVVRUpWLTXH +DVVHO
EDFK²
:?
+DVVHOEDFKLELG
:O
*RJHO  FLWHGHX[H[HPSOHVFHUWDLQVGHVWH[WHVGH/DNLVK
^OTєK`´LOO·DSULVµHW^ߖOєK`´LOO·DHQYR\pµDXVVLELHQTX·XQH[HPSOH
PRLQVSHUWLQHQWGXIDLWTXHO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGXWH[WHHVWPRLQVV€UH
^NWEK`jODSUHPLqUHOLJQHGHO·LQVFULSWLRQSULQFLSDOHGH.KLUEHWHO
.RP ,OHVWFODLUTXHGDQVG·DXWUHVHQYLURQQHPHQWVSKRQpWLTXHVOD
YR\HOOHGHO·DQFLHQpOpPHQWSURQRPLQDOGHODJSHUVRQQHGXPDVFX
OLQVLQJXOLHUV·pWDLWGpMjDOORQJpHDXGpEXWGX9,JVLqFOHDYDQW-&
ORUVTXHFHSURQRPHVWDWWDFKpjO·LPSpUDWLI)O·RUWKRJUDSKHHVW
^ߖOєQZ`TXLFRUUHVSRQGjߖ̾OčєHQQࡃGDQVODYRFDOLVDWLRQPDVVRUp
WLTXH ߖDODєDQKX 2QFRQQDvWDXVVLODIRUPHTXLFRUUHVSRQGj
HQKࡃGDQVODWUDGLWLRQPDVVRUpWLTXH^૟WQQKZ`VHUDLW૟HWW̾QHQKࡃ
VHORQFHWWHWUDGLWLRQjO·RULJLQH૟DWWLQDQQDKX
 oi.uchicago.edu

% H8BB/7%@<KH88

eWDWDEVROXELUND\LP´GHX[JHQRX[µP̾Oč֚ҸP´GHVURLVµ
eWDWFRQVWUXLWELUNr´GHX[JHQRX[GHµPDO֚r´GHVURLVGHµ
eWDWSURQRPLQDOELUND\´PHVGHX[JHQRX[µP̾Oč֚D\´PHVURLVµ::

9RLFLODGpFOLQDLVRQHQWLqUHDYHFO·H[HPSOHG·XQQRPDXSOXULHO

WM̾Oč֚D\´PHVURLVµ PDODND\\D
WM̾Oč֚p֚č´WHV PDVFVLQJ URLVµ PDODND\ND
WM̾Oč֚i\L֚´WHV IpPVLQJ URLVµ PDODND\NL
WM̾Oč֚č \ Z´VHV PDVFVLQJ URLVµ PDODND\KX:Q
WM̾Oč֚pKč´VHV IpPVLQJ URLVµ PDODND\KD

WM̾Oč֚̒Qࡃ´QRVURLVµ ¬PDODND\Qࡃ
PDO֚֚̒HP´YRV PDVFSOXU URLVµ PDODND\NXPX HIpPLQLQ
PDO֚֚̒HQ´YRV IpPSOXU URLVµ PDODND\NLQL
PDO֚̒KHP´OHXUV PDVFSOXU URLVµ PDODND\KXPX HIpPLQLQ
PDO֚̒KHQ´OHXUV IpPSOXU URLVµ PDODND\KLQL

/HVUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVVRQWLFLPRLQVFRPSOLTXpHVGXIDLWTXHOHV\VWqPHFDVXHODXGXHOHWDXSOXULHOpWDLWGLSWRWLTXH
HWSDUFRQVpTXHQWXQHIRLVOHQRPLQDWLIGLVSDUXLOQHUHVWDLWTXHOHVPRUSKqPHVREOLTXHVGXGXHOHWGXSOXULHO¬³¬HW
FHGHUQLHUQ·DpWpUHWHQXTX·DYHFOHSOXULHOjO·pWDWDEVROX:<2QUHPDUTXHDXVVLTXHOHVGLIILFXOWpVSRVpHVSDUOH
IDLWTXHOHFDVpWDLWH[SULPpDXVLQJXOLHUSDUXQHYR\HOOHFRXUWHHWTXHOHVYR\HOOHVFRXUWHVDYDLHQWWHQGDQFHj
GLVSDUDvWUHHQKpEUHXELEOLTXHVRQWDEVHQWHVLFLODVWUXFWXUHG·XQQRPpWDLWIRUFpPHQWLGHQWLTXHjO·pWDWFRQVWUXLW
HWjO·pWDWSURQRPLQDOjVDYRLUVFKqPHQRPLQDOD\/HVGHX[VFKqPHVTXHO·RQFRQVWDWHGDQVOHVIRUPHVWHOOHV
TX·RQOHVFRQQDvWHQKpEUHXELEOLTXH P̾Oč֚HWPDO֚ UHOqYHQWFRPPHDXVLQJXOLHUGHO·DFFHQWODUpGXFWLRQ
GHODGHX[LqPHYR\HOOHGXVFKqPHQRPLQDOQ·D\DQWOLHXTX·jO·pWDWFRQVWUXLWHWjO·pWDWSURQRPLQDOGHYDQWOHV
SURQRPVTXLjO·RULJLQHpWDLHQWFRPSRVpVGHGHX[V\OODEHV
/·H[SOLFDWLRQTXHQRXVYHQRQVG·HVTXLVVHUGLIIqUHGHFHOOHVGHQRVSUpGpFHVVHXUVVRLWSDUOHIDLWG·LQVLVWHUVXU
ODSUpVHQFHSDUWRXWG·XQHYR\HOOHHQSURWRKpEUHXHQWUHOHQRPHWOHSURQRP:RVRLWSDUOHIDLWG·LGHQWLILHUFHWWH

::
/·HQVHPEOH´YR\HOOHFDVXHOOHSURQRPµHVWLGHQWLTXHTXHOHQRP
VRLWDXSOXULHORXDXGXHOSRXUWDQWOHVFKqPHQRPLQDOUHIOqWHOD
UqJOHVHORQODTXHOOHODEDVHGHVQRPVTDWOTLWOTXWOHVWLGHQWLTXH
DX VLQJXOLHU HW DX GXHO GLIIpUHQWH GRQF GH FHOOH GX SOXULHO R OH
VFKqPHHVWELV\OODELTXHFRPPHQRXVO·DYRQVGpMjLQGLTXpSOXVKDXW
:Q
$GPHWWDQWTXHOH^\`GHO·RUWKRJUDSKHPDVVRUpWLTXHHVWVHFRQGDLUH
pOpPHQWSXUHPHQWJUDSKLTXHSHUPHWWDQWGHGLVWLQJXHUODIRUPHVXI
IL[pHGXQRPVLQJXOLHUSDVVpGH^47/K`j^47/Z`GDQVO·RUWKRJUDSKLH
SRVWH[LOLTXH $QGHUVHQHW)RUEHVFI3DUGHH²
&URVVD  LOUHVWHjH[SOLTXHUODIRUPHčZ1RXVQH
YR\RQVTX·XQHH[SOLFDWLRQSODXVLEOHTXLWLHQQHFRPSWHGHVGRQQpHV
(OOHVHIRQGVXUODIDLEOHVVHGHVGHX[FRQVRQQHVTXLVHUHQFRQWUDLHQW
GDQVODIRUPHSULPLWLYHD\KXFHOOHFLDG€SURYRTXHUODFKXWH
GXKjXQHpSRTXHRODGLSKWRQJXHD\pWDLWPDLQWHQXHHWOD
FKXWHGX^K`DHXSRXUUpVXOWDWTXHODGLSKWRQJXHD\HVWGHYHQXH
WULSKWRQJXH D\X TXLDVLPSOLILpHQDX§DZ 3DUGHH
Q G ROHTDPHߙHQKpEUHXELEOLTXH/·DSSHOjXQHWHUPLQDLVRQGX
SOXULHODZTXLVHWURXYHUDLWXQLTXHPHQWGDQVFHWWHIRUPHGHOD
GpFOLQDLVRQ &URVVD ² QRXVSDUDvWLQYUDLVHPEODEOH YRLU
ODQRWHVXLYDQWH 
:<
&HWWHH[SOLFDWLRQIRQGpHVXUOHUHGLVWULEXWLRQGHODIRQFWLRQGHV
IRUPHVDSUqVODFKXWHGXQRPLQDWLIHWDSUqVODGLVSDULWLRQGXGXHO
FRPPH QRPEUH JUDPPDWLFDO SURGXFWLI QH SRVH DXFXQ SUREOqPH
OLQJXLVWLTXH¬³¬FHTXLQ·HVWSDVOHFDVGHODSURSRVLWLRQUpFHQWHGH
&URVV D ² TXLH[SOLTXHODGpFOLQDLVRQGHVQRPVDXSOX
ULHOFRPPHUHIOpWDQWXQPRUSKqPHGXSOXULHOTXLVHUDLWLGHQWLTXH
jFHOXLGXGXHOjVDYRLUD\FHPRUSKqPHpWDQWUHPSODFpGHYDQW
KXHWVHXOHPHQWGHYDQWFHSURQRPSDUXQDXWUHPRUSKqPHGX
SOXULHOTXLDXUDLWpWpDZ2QQHSHXWSDVDGPHWWUHODIRUPXOD
WLRQVHORQODTXHOOHOHPRUSKqPHD\DXUDLWpWp´ERUURZHG«IURP
WKHGXDOµ S SDUODTXHOOH&URVVFULWLTXHO·H[SOLFDWLRQTXHQRXV
SUpIpURQV,OIDXWLQVLVWHUVXUOHIDLWTXHVHORQFHWWHK\SRWKqVHOHV
IRUPHVVHVHUDLHQWUHGLVWULEXpHVDSUqVODGLVSDULWLRQGXGXHOFRPPH
QRPEUHJUDPPDWLFDOXWLOLVDEOHDYHFWRXVOHVQRPVFRPPXQV5HFRQ
QDvWUHTXHFHWWHGLVSDULWLRQDHXOLHXjXQPRPHQWGHO·KLVWRLUHGHOD
ODQJXHTXLVHVLWXDLWIRUFpPHQWDYDQWO·pWDSHTXHQRXVFRQQDLVVRQV
FRPPHO·KpEUHXELEOLTXHHVWHVVHQWLHOSRXUFRPSUHQGUHO·pYROXWLRQ
GHVIRUPHVGXQRPFRPPXQDXGXHOHWDXSOXULHOTXLDDERXWLDX
V\VWqPHGHO·KpEUHXELEOLTXH2QUHPDUTXHUDHQRXWUHTXHODUHFRQV
WLWXWLRQGH&URVVQHWLHQWSDVFRPSWHGXIDLWTXHODIRUPHGXVXIIL[H
HVWLGHQWLTXHTX·LOVRLWDWWDFKpjXQQRPDXSOXULHORXjXQQRPDX
GXHO/DPRWLYDWLRQGHO·K\SRWKqVHGH&URVVHVWG·pYLWHUO·DQDO\VH
SDUODFRQIXVLRQGHVPRUSKqPHVGXGXHOHWGXSOXULHOPDLVLOGRQQH
VRQH[SOLFDWLRQGXSURQRPDWWDFKpjXQQRPDXSOXULHOVDQVDERUGHU
ODTXHVWLRQGHO·LGHQWLWpGHFHVXIIL[HDWWDFKpjXQQRPDXGXHO2Q
GLUDLWTXHO·K\SRWKqVHGH&URVVOHFRQWUDLQGUDLWjVRXWHQLUTXHOHQRP
DXSOXULHOFRPSRUWDLWXQPRUSKqPHSDUWLFXOLHUjO·pWDWSURQRPLQDO
jVDYRLUD\0(1:GHYDQWOHSURQRPGHODJSHUVRQQHGXPDVFXOLQ
VLQJXOLHUROHPRUSKqPHpWDLWDZDORUVTXHOHQRPDXGXHOFRP
SRUWDLWOHPRUSKqPHD\SDUWRXW0(1:jO·pWDWSURQRPLQDOVXLYLGX
SURQRPGHOD JSHUVRQQHGXPDVFXOLQVLQJXOLHUROHPRUSKqPH
pWDLWDZ
:R
'DQV*HVHQLXV.DXW]VFKHW&RZOH\¬† SS² ODGLV
FXVVLRQGHV´FRQQHFWLQJYRZHOVµHVWOLPLWpHDX[FDVRLOV·DJLWG·XQH
GHVSULQFLSDOHVYR\HOOHVGXV\VWqPHPDVVRUpWLTXH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% T87*/D87%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%8B*K8%N8%B,A%8*%N8%@K,B,A%7\FF/i8%8B%OQSK8\%S/SN/e\8% OOP

YR\HOOHSDUWRXWFRPPHODYR\HOOHFDVXHOOH VRLWSDUOHIDLWGHSURSRVHUXQHH[SOLFDWLRQGHVYDULDQWHVGDQVOD
TXDOLWpGHFHWWHYR\HOOHG·DSUqVO·KDUPRQLHYRFDOLTXHSRXUODGpFOLQDLVRQHQWLqUHGXQRPDXVLQJXOLHU:@%9F8K%=67%
OHIDLWG·H[FOXUHOHPRUSKqPHGXQRPLQDWLIGHODUHVWLWXWLRQGHVIRUPHVFRQQXHVHQKpEUHXELEOLTXHDXVVLELHQDX
VLQJXOLHUTXHGDQVOHSDUDGLJPHXQLTXHFUppGDQVFHWWHODQJXHORUVTXHOHGXHOHWOHSOXULHORQWIXVLRQQpjO·pWDW
=7FHFM8H6>2VRLWHQILQSDUOHIDLWTXHFHWWHH[FOXVLRQGXQRPLQDWLIQRXVDDPHQpjXQHIRUPXODWLRQGHODUqJOH
VHORQODTXHOOHOHFKRL[GHODYR\HOOHFDVXHOOHVHUDLWRXYHUWORUVTX·XQHGLIIpUHQFHH[LVWDLWHQWUHFHOOHFLHWFHOOH
GHO·pOpPHQWSURQRPLQDO(QFRPSDUDLVRQDYHFOHVWKpRULHVGHVJUDQGVJUDPPDLULHQVGXSDVVpFHWWHH[SOLFDWLRQ
GHVIRUPHVGXQRPSURQRPVXIIL[HHQKpEUHXELEOLTXHHVWSRVVLEOHJUkFHjODGpFRXYHUWHGHO·RXJDULWLTXHGRQW
OHVWH[WHVGDWHQWGHV;,,,J²;,,JVLqFOHVDYDQW-&GRQFELHQDYDQWOHVIRUPHVDWWHVWpHVGHO·KpEUHX(QHIIHWRQ
HVWjSHXSUqVG·DFFRUGDXMRXUG·KXLTXHOHQRPjO·pWDWFRQVWUXLWDXVVLELHQTX·jO·pWDWSURQRPLQDOVHGpFOLQDLWHQ
RXJDULWLTXHSRXUOHFDVJUDPPDWLFDO:P

9;<=;>?@ABC;D
$QGHUVHQ)UDQFLV,HW$'HDQ)RUEHV
  7I!..#)5%#)%$+!%O!&-!9%S#&.!g%H(+66"%A!>6-#(.%N!4$1-!%LEOLFDHW2ULHQWDOLD5RPH,QVWLWXW%LEOLTXH
3RQWLILFDO
%DUWK-
  ´%HLWUlJH]XU6XIIL[OHKUHGHV1RUGVHPLWLVFKHQµ<>!-#4()%P61-)(.%6:%7!>#$#4%N()51(5!0%()"%N#$!-($1-!0%
²
%DXHU+DQVHW3RQWXV/HDQGHU%
% OP::% O#0$6-#04+!%D-(>>($#=%"!-%+!&-a#04+!)%7I-(4+!%"!0%<.$!)%*!0$(>!)$!0+DO1LHPH\HU
%HLW$ULHK,HW%&UHVVRQ
  ´$Q(GRPLWH2VWUDFRQIURP҇RUYDW૛8]Dµ*!.%<?#?²
%ODNH%-
% :??O% 3(0!qPHpG&DPEULGJH7H[WERRNVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
%ODX%-
  ´6RPH3KLORORJLFDO1RWHVRQWKH,QVFULSWLRQRI0HߖD૛µA((-(?²


3RXU%DUWK  OH´%LQGHODXWµVHUDLWDTXLFRUUHVSRQGUDLW
jODYR\HOOHGHO·DFFXVDWLI%URFNHOPDQQ †JD>S@ QH
SDUOHTXHGHO·DFFXVDWLIGDQVOHVFDVRODYR\HOOHDHVWFRQVHUYpH
VRXVIRUPHGHTDPHߙ IpPVLQJPDVFIpPSOXU RXELHQDGLV
SDUXSDUFRQWUDFWLRQ PDVFVLQJ HWGXJpQLWLISRXUOHVQRPVGX
W\SH૟čȯvKࡃSRXU-RRQ †E>S@ OHčTXHO·RQWURXYH
GDQVSOXVLHXUVIRUPHVUHIOpWHUDLWODYR\HOOHGHO·DQFLHQDFFXVDWLIPDLV
HHWrSURYLHQGUDLHQW´SUREDEOHPHQWGHVQRPVGHUDFLQH™! ∫µ
+XHKQHUJDUG Q FLWH%URFNHOPDQQHWDMRXWHTXHOTXHV
IRUPHV&URVV D YDXQSHXSOXVORLQHQFLWDQWTXHOTXHV
IRUPHVGHSOXV LOHVWTXHVWLRQGHV´VRFDOOHGFRQQHFWLQJYRZHOV
PRVWO\RULJLQDWLQJLQORVWFDVHHQGLQJVµ +DVVHOEDFK ² D
SRXUVXLYLFHWWHDSSURFKHHQFLWDQWOHVIRUPHVGHVJ%JK%QJ%=J79FHHJ9%
GXVLQJXOLHU
:@
%DXHUHW/HDQGHU%  I >S@ RQWUHPDUTXpTXHODTXD
OLWpGHODYR\HOOHHQWUHOHQRPHWO·pOpPHQWSURQRPLQDOUHVVHPEOH
SDUIRLVjODYR\HOOHGXSURQRPPDLVSUHQDQWO·DFFDGLHQRO·pWDW
FRQVWUXLWQHFRPSRUWHSDVGHYR\HOOHFDVXHOOHFRPPHLQGLFDWHXUGH
ODVLWXDWLRQHQSURWRKpEUHXLOVUHSRXVVHQWIRUPHOOHPHQWO·LGHQWLIL
FDWLRQGHFHWWHYR\HOOHFRPPHpWDQWjO·RULJLQHYR\HOOHFDVXHOOH †F
>S@ SUpIpUDQWOHWHUPH´6YDUDEKDNWLYRNDOµHWLOVH[SOLTXHQWOD
UHVVHPEODQFHHQWUHFHWWHYR\HOOHHWFHOOHGXSURQRPFRPPHOD´FROR
UDWLRQµ ´)lUEXQJµ GHODSUHPLqUHSDUODVHFRQGH/HVVSpFLDOLVWHV
GHFHTX·RQSRXUUDLWDSSHOHUO·pFROHGH+DUYDUGFLWpVjODQRWHSUp
FpGDQWHRQWWRXVpYRTXpOHSULQFLSHGHO·KDUPRQLHYRFDOLTXH VHORQ
+XHQKHUJDUGO·LGpHUHPRQWHj72/DPEGLQ PDLVVDQVSURSRVHUOD
UHVWLWXWLRQGHWRXWHVOHVIRUPHV

&RPPHQRXVO·DYRQVYXSOXVKDXW&URVVHW+DVVHOEDFKUHFRQVWL
WXHQWOHQRPDXVLQJXOLHUSURQRPGHODJSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHU
FRPPHFRPSRUWDQWODYR\HOOHGXQRPLQDWLIHW&URVVHQIDLWGHPrPH
GXQRPDXSOXULHOUHIXVDQWGHYRLUGDQVFHWWHGpFOLQDLVRQODIXVLRQ
GHVDQFLHQVPRUSKqPHVGXFDVREOLTXHGXGXHOHWGXSOXULHOVXUOH
PRGqOHGXGXHO YRLUSOXVKDXWODQRWH /DSOXSDUWGHVVSpFLD
OLVWHVGHSXLV%DXHUHW/HDQGHU †I>S@ MXVTX·j0F&DUWHU
S DGPHWWHQWTXHOHPRUSKqPHGXSOXULHOpWDLWUHP
SODFpSDUFHOXLGXGXHOjO·pWDWSURQRPLQDOPDLVVDQVWLUHUOHVFRQVp
TXHQFHVSRXUODUHVWLWXWLRQGHO·pWDWSURQRPLQDOGXQRPDXVLQJXOLHU
:P
7XWWOH6WHLQHU¬Q+XHKQHUJDUG3DUGHH
LGHP%RUGUHXLOHW3DUGHH²7URSSHU
† S² 
 oi.uchicago.edu

O:?% H8BB/7%@<KH88

%RUGUHXLO3LHUUHHW'HQQLV3DUGHH
% :??<% A()1!.%";615(-#$#X1!3DULV*HXWKQHU
%URFNHOPDQQ&DUO
  D-1)"-#Ü%"!-%?!-5.!#4+!)"!)%D-(>>($#=%"!-%0!>#$#04+!)%7I-(4+!2%1F>LMJ%ON%N(1$M%1)"%F6->!).!+-!%HUOLQ
5HXWKHU 5HLFKDUG
&URVV)UDQN0RRUH
  ´7KH&DYH,QVFULSWLRQVIURP.KLUEHW%HLW/HLµ'DQVB!(-%8(0$!-)%<-4+(!6.65'%#)%$+!%*9!)$#!$+%3!)$1-'g%
800('0%#)%O6)6-%6:%B!.06)%D.1!4=pGLWpSDU-$6DQGHUVSS²*DUGHQ&LW\'RXEOHGD\
  ´$/LWHUDWH6ROGLHU/DFKLVK/HWWHU,,,µ'DQVS#&.#4(.%()"%K!.($!"%7$1"#!0%@-!0!)$!"%$6%7(>1!.%/9-'pGLWp
SDU$.RUWHW60RUVFKDXVHUSS²:LQRQD/DNH(LVHQEUDXQV
 D ´6RPH3UREOHPVLQ2OG+HEUHZ2UWKRJUDSK\ZLWK6SHFLDO$WWHQWLRQWRWKH7KLUG3HUVRQ0DVFXOLQH
6LQJXODU6XIIL[RQ3OXUDO1RQV>kZ@µ8-!$G%/0-(!. ² 
% :??QD% N!(?!0%:-6>%()%8I#5-(I+!-;0%B6$!&66=g%36..!4$!"%@(I!-0%#)%O!&-!9%()"%J!0$%7!>#$#4%@(.(!65-(I+'%()"%8I#5M
-(I+'L+DUYDUG6HPLWLF6WXGLHV:LQRQD/DNH(LVHQEUDXQV
&URVV)UDQN0RRUHHW'DYLG1RHO)UHHGPDQ
% OP@: ´6RPH2EVHUYDWLRQVRQ(DUO\+HEUHZµS#&.#4(²
)DVVEHUJ6(
  ´5HFHQVLRQµP61-)(.%6:%$+!%<>!-#4()%,-#!)$(.%764#!$'²
*HVHQLXV:LOKHOP(.DXWVFKHW$(&RZOH\
% OPO?% D!0!)#10;%O!&-!9%D-(>>(-qPHpGDQJO2[IRUG&ODUHQGRQ3UHVV
*RJHO6DQGUD/DQGLV
  <%D-(>>(-%6:%8I#5-(I+#4%O!&-!96%/5HVRXUFHVIRU%LEOLFDO6WXG\$WODQWD6FKRODUV3UHVV
+DVVHOEDFK5HEHFFD
  ´7KH3URQRPLQDO6XIIL[RIWKH7KLUG3HUVRQ0DVFXOLQH6LQJXODULQ+HEUHZµO(-?(-"%J6-=#)5%@(I!-0%
#)%N#)51#0$#40²
+XHKQHUJDUG-RKQ
  ´$NNDGLDQ(YLGHQFHIRU&DVHYRZHOVRQ8JDULWLF%RXQG)RUPVµP61-)(.%6:%31)!#:6->%7$1"#!0%QQN%
²
  ´7KUHH1RWHVRQ$NNDGLDQ0RUSKRORJ\µ'DQV´:RUNLQJZLWK1R'DWDµ6HPLWLFDQG(J\SWLDQ6WXGLHV
@-!0!)$!"%$6%*+6>(0%,L%N(>&"#)pGLWpSDU'*RORPESS²:LQRQD/DNH(LVHQEUDXQV
-RRQ3DXO
% OP:Q% D-(>>(#-!%"!%.;+U&-!1%&#&.#X1!5RPH,QVWLWXW%LEOLTXH3RQWLILFDO
0F&DUWHU%3.
  ´+HEUHZµ'DQV*+!%3(>&-#"5!%8)4'4.6I!"#(%6:%$+!%J6-.";0%<)4#!)$%N()51(5!0pGLWpSDU5':RRGDUG
SS²&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
3DUGHH'HQQLV
  ´5HFHQVLRQµ3($+6.#4%S#&.#4(.%e1(-$!-.'²
  ´5HFHQVLRQµP61-)(.%6:%B!(-%8(0$!-)%7$1"#!0²
  ´8JDULWLFµ'DQV*+!%7!>#$#4%N()51(5!0pGLWpSDU5+HW]URQSS²/RQGUHV5RXWOHGJH
  ´8JDULWLFµ'DQV*+!%3(>&-#"5!%8)4'4.6I!"#(%6:%$+!%J6-.";0%<)4#!)$%N()51(5!0pGLWpSDU5':RRGDUG
SS²&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
5HQ]-RKDQQHV
% OPPR% O()"&14+%"!-%(.$+!&-a#04+!)%8I#5-(I+#='DUPVWDGW:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH%XFKJHVHOOVFKDIW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% T87*/D87%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%8B*K8%N8%B,A%8*%N8%@K,B,A%7\FF/i8%8B%OQSK8\%S/SN/e\8% O:O

6WHLQHU5
  ´)URP3URWR+HEUHZWR0LVKQDLF+HEUHZ7KH+LVWRU\RIÙ®Ò-DQG´Ò -µO!&-!9%<))1(.%K!?#!9²
#7F==J72%[F9JG%
% :???% \5(-#$#04+!%D-(>>($#=$OWHU2ULHQWXQG$OWHV7HVWDPHQW0QVWHU8JDULW9HUODJ
7XWWOH*DU\$
  ´&DVH9RZHOVRQ0DVFXOLQH6LQJXODU1RXQVLQ&RQVWUXFWLQ8JDULWLFµ'DQVS#&.#4(.%()"%B!(-%8(0$M
!-)%7$1"#!0g%800('0%#)%O6)6-%6:%J#..#(>%7():6-"%N(76-pGLWpSDU*$7XWWOHSS²*UDQG5DSLGV
(HUGPDQV
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8BZ78%8*%QT,N\*/,B%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%/BH,M8\K,@Q8Bg%e\87*/,B7%8*%OY@,*OZ787% O:Q

!
"#$%&#'#(')*+,-(.+$'/-'&0&(%1#'23&-#,'.$/+4#-5+6)#$7''
8-#&(.+$&'#('906+(9%&#&

P!()%O(1"-'2%Q46.!%@-($#X1!%"!0%O(1$!0%Q$1"!0%^@(-#0`

/DSUpVHQWHpWXGHYLVHjLQWHUSUpWHUFRQMRLQWHPHQWGLYHUVHVGRQQpHVPRUSKRORJLTXHVV\QWD[LTXHVHWVpPDQ
WLTXHVUHODWLYHVDXV\VWqPHFDVXHOLQGRHXURSpHQ,OV·DJLWSRXUO·HVVHQWLHOGHGRQQpHVFRQQXHVHWGRQWSOXVLHXUV
RQWpWpFRUUHFWHPHQWLQWHUSUpWpHVGDQVOHSDVVpPDLVTXLVRQWDXMRXUG·KXLPpFRQQXHVRXRFFXOWpHVVRLWSDUFH
TX·HOOHVQHV·LQWqJUHQWSDVGDQVOHV\VWqPHUHFRQVWUXLWVRLWSDUFHTX·HOOHVVHUpSDUWLVVHQWVXUSOXVLHXUVVHFWHXUV
TX·RQDFRXWXPHG·pWXGLHUVpSDUpPHQWPRUSKRORJLHGHVVLJQLILDQWVFDVXHOVHWSDUDGLJPHVQRPLQDX[V\QWD[H
FDVXHOOHVpPDQWLTXHOH[LFDOHIRQWO·REMHWG·XQHpWXGHGLVWLQFWHHQV\QFKURQLHPDLVODGLDFKURQLHLJQRUHOHVIURQ
WLqUHV/·DSSURFKHG·HQVHPEOHSURSRVpHFRQGXLWjSRVHUSOXVLHXUVTXHVWLRQVHWWHQWHG·DSSRUWHUTXHOTXHVUpSRQVHV

:;',<='>?@?>AB@<='C@DE>DC?FG'HF'=I=ABJ<'>?=F<K'@<>LE=A@FDA
:;:;',<='ML@J<='>?=F<KK<=
/HV\VWqPHFDVXHOGHO·HQVHPEOHGHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVDQFLHQQHVHWGRQFGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQUHFRQV
WUXLWHVWXQV\VWqPHIOH[LRQQHOGDQVOHTXHORQFRQVWDWHQRPEUHGHGLVFRUGDQFHVHQWUHOHVVLJQLILDQWVHWOHVVLJQL
ILpVXQHPrPHIRUPHFRUUHVSRQGjGHVVHQVGLIIpUHQWVXQPrPHVHQVV·H[SULPHSDUGHVIRUPHVGLIIpUHQWHV/HV
VLWXDWLRQVG·DPDOJDPH ODWLQERQčUXP2%JpQLWLISOXULHOIpPLQLQ G·DOORPRUSKLVPH OHVGLIIpUHQWHVGpFOLQDLVRQV
DYHFOHXUVGLYHUVW\SHVDFFHQWXHOV G·KRPRQ\PLH ODWLQGRPLQ‫گ‬2%GDWLIRXDEODWLIVLQJXOLHU VRQWRPQLSUpVHQWHV
&HWWHVLWXDWLRQLQGLTXHTX·DXFXQSULQFLSHGLUHFWHXUQHSUpVLGHjO·RUJDQLVDWLRQGHODIOH[LRQF·HVWjGLUHDXSODQ
GLDFKURQLTXHTXHOHVVLJQLILDQWVFDVXHOVQHVRQWSDVLVVXVG·XQHUpIHFWLRQDQDORJLTXHG·HQVHPEOHTXLDXUDLWDERXWL
jXQHVLPSOLILFDWLRQGHOHXUPRUSKRORJLH,OVVRQWSRXUO·HVVHQWLHOOHSURGXLWGHO·pYROXWLRQSKRQpWLTXHHWGHSUR
FHVVXVDJJOXWLQDWLIVDYHFTXHOTXHVUpIHFWLRQVDQDORJLTXHVLVROpHV$LQVLSRXUODGpVLQHQFHGXQRPLQDWLISOXULHO
GHODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXHLQGRHXURSpHQjM6M!02%LVVXHGHO·DGGLWLRQGHODGpVLQHQFHDWKpPDWLTXHjM!0jODYR\HOOH
WKpPDWLTXHjM6M% VXUFHSURFHVVXVYRLUFLGHVVRXV† L%,OHQHVWUpVXOWpG·DERUGXQHIRUPHGLVV\OODELTXHUHIOpWpH
QRWDPPHQWSDUODGpVLQHQFHLQGRLUDQLHQQHjM((02%SXLVXQHIRUPHFRQWUDFWpH7RXWGRQQHjSHQVHUTX·LOHQYDGH
PrPHSRXUOHVGpVLQHQFHVGHVIOH[LRQVDWKpPDWLTXHV2QUHOqYHDXVVLTXHOTXHVH[HPSOHVGHUpIHFWLRQDQDORJLTXH
FRPPHSRXUODGpVLQHQFHODWLQHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOGHVPDVFXOLQVHWQHXWUHVHQjM6M2‫گ‬UXP2%VDQVFRUUHVSRQGDQWVTXL
DpWpIDLWHVXUOHPRGqOHGHODIRUPHIpPLQLQHčUXP2%TXLHVWKpULWpH0DLVGHWHOOHVUpIHFWLRQVLVROpHVQHSRXYDLHQW
FRQGXLUHjXQHUpJXODULVDWLRQGXV\VWqPHGHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHV

:;N;',<='MLE>ADLE='>?=F<KK<=
&RQVLGpUpGXSRLQWGHYXHGHODIRQFWLRQOHV\VWqPHFDVXHOGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQUHFRQVWUXLWTXLUpXQLWVHSW
XQLWpVRXKXLWVLRQOXLDWWULEXHXQGLUHFWLI FLGHVVRXV††HW DSSDUDvWFRPPHXQV\VWqPHK\EULGH¬LO
VHUWjO·H[SUHVVLRQGHVTXDWUHIRQFWLRQVJUDPPDWLFDOHVOHVXMHWO·REMHWSUHPLHUO·REMHWVHFRQGGHVYHUEHVELYDOHQWV%
"6))!-%d%h OHFRPSOpPHQWGHVVXEVWDQWLIVTXLLPSOLTXHQWXQHUHODWLRQ IE-!%"!2%HWF PDLVDXVVLGHTXHOTXHVUHOD
WLRQVFRPPHO·DSSDUWHQDQFH OHJpQLWLIHQGpSHQGDQFHGHVDXWUHVVXEVWDQWLIV ODSURVSHFWLYLWp OHGDWLIGDQVVHV
HPSORLVOLEUHV ODORFDOLVDWLRQ OHORFDWLI ODVLWXDWLRQGHFRQWDFWHWODSRVVHVVLRQ O·LQVWUXPHQWDO OHVPRXYHPHQWV
G·pORLJQHPHQW O·DEODWLI HWGHUDSSURFKHPHQW O·DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLIHWO·pYHQWXHOGLUHFWLI &HWWHOLPLWDWLRQpWURLWH
TXLH[FOXWODJUDQGHPDMRULWpGHVUHODWLRQVORFDOHVRXDXWUHVRUGLQDLUHPHQWH[SULPpHVSDUGHVRXWLOVJUDPPD
WLFDX[ HQIUDQoDLVGHVSUpSRVLWLRQVRXGHVV\QWDJPHVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOV IRQGHODQDWXUHK\EULGHGXV\VWqPHLO

O:Q
 oi.uchicago.edu

O:<% P8<B%O<\HKY

VHVLWXHHQWUHOHVV\VWqPHVjIDLEOHHIIHFWLIFDVXHOTXLVHOLPLWHQWjGHX[WURLVRXTXDWUHFDVJUDPPDWLFDX[HW
FHX[GDQVOHVTXHOVXQJUDQGQRPEUHGHUHODWLRQVVRQWH[SULPpHVSDUGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQV'·DXWUHSDUWODORJLTXH
GXV\VWqPHQ·DSSDUDvWSDVSRXUTXRLFHVTXHOTXHVUHODWLRQVRQWHOOHVpWpSULYLOpJLpHVDX[GpSHQVGHWRXWHVOHV
DXWUHV"/DUpSDUWLWLRQGHO·HIIHFWLIFDVXHOHQ´FDVJUDPPDWLFDX[ VDQVFRQWHQXVpPDQWLTXH µHW´FDVjFRQWHQX
VpPDQWLTXHµHVWDSSUR[LPDWLYHHWPDQLIHVWHPHQWUpFHQWHLOH[LVWHGDQVWRXWHVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV
DQFLHQQHVDXPRLQVjO·pWDWGHWUDFHVXQHYDOHXUGLUHFWLYHGHO·DFFXVDWLI ODWLQ!6%K6>(> %LQYHUVHPHQWSOXVLHXUV
ODQJXHVQRWDPPHQWOHJURXSHGHV´ODQJXHVGXQRUGµJHUPDQLTXHEDOWLTXHVODYHRQWXQ´LQVWUXPHQWDOGH
O·REMHWµTXLVHPEOHDQFLHQ(WFRPPHLODpWpLQGLTXpFLGHVVXVODIURQWLqUHSDVVHpJDOHPHQWDXWUDYHUVGXJpQLWLI
HWGXGDWLI/DVWUXFWXUDWLRQGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOpWDEOLHSDU+HZVRQ +HZVRQHW%XEHQLN VRXVODIRUPH
G·XQWDEOHDXjGRXEOHHQWUpHUHSRVHVXUXQHVLPSOLILFDWLRQPXWLODQWHGHODUpDOLWpGHVHPSORLV +DXGU\ /H
FDUDFWqUHK\EULGHHWQRQQDWXUHOGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOUHVVRUWGHODFRPSDUDLVRQDYHFOHV\VWqPHGHVGpVLQHQFHV
SHUVRQQHOOHVGXYHUEHGRQWODORJLTXHHVWFHOOHGHVUHODWLRQVGLVFXUVLYHV/HV\VWqPHFDVXHOTXLQHUHSRVHVXU
ULHQGHWHODGRQFGHIRUWHVFKDQFHVGHUHSUpVHQWHUOHUpVXOWDWIRUWXLWG·XQHpYROXWLRQDXVVLDYHXJOHTXHFHOOHGHV
SKRQqPHV8QHpYROXWLRQGRQWLOUHVWHjGpWHUPLQHUOHVHQV

N;',<='OPLKFADLE='FKAO@D<F@<='HF'=I=ABJ<
$YDQWGHWHQWHUXQHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQGHVpWDWVOHVSOXVDQFLHQVGHFHV\VWqPHLOQ·HVWSDVLQXWLOHGHMHWHUXQ
FRXSG·±LOVXUVHVpYROXWLRQVXOWpULHXUHV,OH[LVWHXQVHQVGHO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXH +DXGU\E FHUWDLQV
FKDQJHPHQWVVRQWLUUpYHUVLEOHVFRPPHOHVSURFHVVXVDJJOXWLQDWLIVTXLUpGXLVHQWOHQRPEUHGHVXQLWpVGDQVOH
V\QWDJPHODWHQGDQFHjODUpWURJUDGDWLRQGHVXQLWpVGDQVOHSDUDGLJPHHWjODSHUWHRXDXWUDQVIHUWGXFRQWHQX
VpPDQWLTXHGHVXQLWpVQRWDPPHQWSDUJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQ'·DXWUHSDUWLOHVWDGPLVJpQpUDOHPHQWTXHOHVODQJXHV
RQWIRQFWLRQQpHWpYROXpGDQVOHSDVVpVHORQOHVPrPHVPRGDOLWpVTX·DXMRXUG·KXLF·HVWOH´SULQFLSHG·XQLIRUPLWpµ
\)#:6->#$(-#()%@-#)4#I.!2%TXHOHVVRFLROLQJXLVWHVRQWHPSUXQWpDX[JpRORJXHV2ULODSSDUDvWTX·jSDUWLUGXV\VWqPH
FDVXHOUHFRQVWUXLWO·pYROXWLRQHVWDOOpHGDQVWRXWHVOHVGLUHFWLRQV

‡ 'LVSDULWLRQFRPSOqWHGHODϰH[LRQGDQVODSOXSDUWGHVODQJXHVURPDQHVGHVODQJXHVJHUPDQLTXHVDLQVLTX·HQDO
EDQDLVHWGDQVFHUWDLQHVODQJXHVLQGRLUDQLHQQHV
‡ 5pGXFWLRQGDQVFHUWDLQHVGHVODQJXHVTXLRQWPDLQWHQXXQHϰH[LRQ URXPDLQKDXWDOOHPDQGHWLVODQGDLVJUHF 
,OHVWjQRWHUTXHODUpGXFWLRQDERXWLWVRXYHQWjXQV\VWqPHjTXDWUHFDVFHOXLGHVTXDWUHFDVJUDPPDWLFDX[GH
O·RUJDQLVDWLRQUpFHQWHGXV\VWqPHUHFRQVWUXLWRXjGHX[XQFDVGLUHFWHWXQFDVREOLTXHFRPPHHQDQFLHQIUDQoDLV
HWHQKLQGL
‡ 0DLQWLHQSUHVTXHLQWpJUDOGDQVOHVODQJXHVVODYHVjO·H[FHSWLRQGXEXOJDURPDFpGRQLHQHWGDQVOHVODQJXHVEDO
WLTXHV
‡ ([WHQVLRQGDQVSOXVLHXUVODQJXHVFRPPHO·RVVqWHRXOHOLWXDQLHQDX;9,JVLqFOHDYHFOHUHQRXYHOOHPHQWGHODIRUPH
GXORFDWLIHWODFUpDWLRQGHWURLVFDVQRXYHDX[DGHVVLIDOODWLILOODWLITXLVHVRQWPDLQWHQXVHQSDUWLHGDQVFHUWDLQV
SDUOHUV YRLUO·DUWLFOHGH'DQLHO3HWLWGDQVFHPrPHUHFXHLO 

$F{WpGHFHVYDULDWLRQVGHO·HIIHFWLIFDVXHORQUHOqYHGHVUHVWUXFWXUDWLRQVTXLHQRVVqWHHQWRNKDULHQHWHQ
DUPpQLHQPRGHUQHPDQLIHVWHQWXQHWHQGDQFHjO·DJJOXWLQDWLRQDYHFOHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHVGXWRNKDULHQGRQWOD
PDUTXHSHXWVHOLPLWHUDXGHUQLHUWHUPHG·XQV\QWDJPHFRRUGLQDWLI SKpQRPqQHGH´IOH[LRQGHJURXSHµFLGHVVRXV
† NXNODV\XNDVR‫ع‬NlOPčV\R´DYHFFKDUVFKHYDX[HWpOpSKDQWVµHWOHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVGXSOXULHOHQDUPpQLHQ
PRGHUQHHQDUPpQLHQRFFLGHQWDOOHSOXULHOVHIRUPHSDUO·LQIL[DWLRQGHM ) !-M%HQWUHOHUDGLFDOHWOHVGpVLQHQFHV
TXLVRQWHQSDUWLHLGHQWLTXHVjFHOOHVGXVLQJXOLHU
/DVHXOHFRQFOXVLRQTXHO·RQSHXWWLUHUGHFHVREVHUYDWLRQVHVWTXHOHV\VWqPHUHFRQVWUXLWV·HVWFRQVHUYpGDQV
OHVODQJXHVTXLSUpVHQWHQWDXMRXUG·KXLODSOXVIRUWHSURSRUWLRQGHYRFDEXODLUHKpULWpF·HVWjGLUHOHVODQJXHV
VODYHVHWOHVODQJXHVEDOWLTXHVPDLVRQQ·HQWLUHDXFXQHQVHLJQHPHQWVXUO·HIIHFWLIFDVXHOQLVXUODVWUXFWXUHGX
V\VWqPHGDQVOHVpWDWVDQWpULHXUVjHQMXJHUSDUOHVpYROXWLRQVTXLRQWPHQpjO·pWDWDFWXHOGHVGLYHUVHVODQJXHV
GHODIDPLOOHO·HIIHFWLIDQFLHQDSXrWUHVXSpULHXU F·HVWOHSOXVSUREDEOH PDLVDXVVLLQIpULHXUjHQMXJHUSDUOHV
GRQQpHVEDOWLTXHVVDVWUXFWXUHDSXrWUHIOH[LRQQHOOHPDLVULHQQ·LQGLTXHTX·HOOHO·DLWpWpGHWRXWHpWHUQLWp/HV
QRWLRQVDQFLHQQHVG·XQ´pWDWSUpIOH[LRQQHOµHWGH´FDVLQGpILQLµTXHPHQWLRQQHHQFRUH%HQYHQLVWH  QH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8BZ78%8*%QT,N\*/,B%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%/BH,M8\K,@Q8Bg%e\87*/,B7%8*%OY@,*OZ787% O:R

VRQWSDVjUHMHWHUPDLVHOOHVVRQWSXUHPHQWQpJDWLYHV¬ODTXHVWLRQHVWGHVDYRLUSDUTXHOVPR\HQVpWDLHQWH[SUL
PpHVOHVUHODWLRQVV\QWD[LTXHVHWVpPDQWLTXHVGHVGLYHUVFRQVWLWXDQWVGHODSKUDVHHQWUHHX[HWDYHFOHSUpGLFDW
(QILQHQFHTXLFRQFHUQHODVWUXFWXUHGHO·pQRQFpjODTXHOOHFHOOHGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOHVWpWURLWHPHQWOLpH
VLODSOXSDUWGHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVDFWXHOOHVVRQWjVXMHWXQLTXH ´ODQJXHVDFFXVDWLYHVµ SOXVLHXUVODQ
JXHVLQGRLUDQLHQQHVRQWXQHH[SUHVVLRQGXVXMHWTXLGLIIqUHVHORQOHWHPSVGXYHUEH,OQ·\DGRQFSDVGHUDLVRQ
GHFRQVLGpUHUTXHOHVXMHWXQLTXHVRLWXQFDUDFWqUHSHUPDQHQWHWFRQVWLWXWLIGHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV2Q
FRQVWDWHSDUDLOOHXUVXQHWHQGDQFHjVXEVWLWXHUGHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVSHUVRQQHOOHV DYHFVXMHWDXQRPLQDWLIGDQV
OHVODQJXHVjIOH[LRQFDVXHOOH DX[FRQVWUXFWLRQVLPSHUVRQQHOOHVGDQVOHVTXHOOHVO·DFWDQWXQLTXHDODIRUPHG·XQ
FRPSOpPHQW jXQFDVDXWUHTXHOHQRPLQDWLIGDQVOHVODQJXHVjIOH[LRQFDVXHOOH ¬ODWLQ>!%I(!)#$!$%Ö%I(!)#$!6%´MH
MJ%7J=JH92Y%>#+#%?#"!$1-%Ö%?#"!6-%´LOPHVHPEOHµ>#+#%!0$%Ö%+(&!6%´M·DLµIUDQoDLV#.%>!%061?#!)$%Ö%c!%>!%061?#!)02%HWF
DYHFWRXWHIRLVGHVpYROXWLRQVjFRQWUHFRXUDQWQRWDPPHQWHQDOOHPDQG

Q;'*<=ADR<='HSFE'<MM<>ADM'>?=F<K'=FCO@D<F@

Q;:;'TL@J<='>?=F<KK<='MDRO<=
/HVODQJXHVDFWXHOOHVTXLRQWSHUGXODIOH[LRQFDVXHOOHHQSUpVHQWHQWTXHOTXHVUpVLGXVFRPPHOHQRPIUDQoDLV
GHOD´IrWHGHVFKDQGHOOHVµOD3+()"!.!1-2%TXLHVWXQHDQFLHQQHIRUPHGHJpQLWLISOXULHO'HVIDLWVGHFHJHQUHVH
UHQFRQWUHQWXQSHXSDUWRXW,OHVWGRQFSRVVLEOHTXHG·DQFLHQQHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVVHFDFKHQWGDQVOHVLQYDULDQWV
QRWDPPHQWGDQVOHVDGYHUEHV6LGHVIRUPHVFRPPHOHODWLQGRPҸ´jODPDLVRQµVRQWFRQVLGpUpHVGXSRLQWGHYXH
V\QFKURQLTXHFRPPHGHVDGYHUEHVHWQRQFRPPHGHVORFDWLIVF·HVWVHXOHPHQWSDUFHTXHOHVDXWUHVSDUDGLJPHV
QHSUpVHQWHQWSDVGHIRUPHVFRUUHVSRQGDQWHV

Q;N;',<'>?='UHD@<>ADMV
/HVDGYHUEHVjYDOHXUGLUHFWLYHHQ ‫گ‬FRPPHOHVIRUPHVODWLQHVH‫´گ‬Oj DYHFPRXYHPHQW µTX‫´گ‬R"µX16("%
´MXVTX·R"µSHXYHQWUHIOpWHUXQDQFLHQFDVGLUHFWLIUHSUpVHQWpHQKLWWLWHGDQVOHVWH[WHVOHVSOXVDQFLHQV /DURFKH
 FHFDVFRQFXUUHQWGHO·DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLISRXYDLWV·HQGLIIpUHQFLHUFRPPHOHODWLQ("%1-&!>%´YHUVODYLOOHµ
GH#)%1-&!>%´GDQVODYLOOH DYHFPRXYHPHQW µ 0HLHU%UJJHU ,OHQH[LVWHpJDOHPHQWGHVIRUPHVHQ ̒
FRPPHOHJRWLTXHKLGU̒´YHUVLFLµ FLGHVVRXV† 6DGpVLQHQFHGRLWGRQFrWUHDSSDUHQWpHjODSDUWLFXOHGLUHF
WLYH ̒W ‫ گ‬FLGHVVRXV† &HUWDLQHVIRUPDWLRQVHQ ̒W ‫گ‬2%DYHFOHXUVYDULDQWHVEUqYHVSRVHQWXQSUREOqPH
VpPDQWLTXHVXUOHTXHORQUHYLHQGUD††HW G‫گ‬VLJQLILH´YHUVµ G̒´YHQDQWGHµ

Q;Q;',<='?HP<@W<='<E'!"#$%&<A'K<'>?='U<GA@?>ADMV'
,OHQYDSUREDEOHPHQWGHPrPHjXQHpSRTXHDQWpULHXUHSRXUOHVDGYHUEHVHQjM$60JUHF์໵ࠗཬߥ์ဎࠗཬߥ
>6K8H%#)$102%:1)"#$102%4(!.#$102%HWOHXUVFRUUHVSRQGDQWVLQGRLUDQLHQVFRQFXUUHQWV HWXOWpULHXUHPHQWVXEVWLWXWV 
GHO·DEODWLI2QYRLWSDUFHVGHX[GHUQLHUVH[HPSOHVTXHOHPRUSKHQHV·DMRXWHSDVXQLTXHPHQWjGHVLQYDULDQWV
LOSHXWV·DMRXWHUDXWKqPHG·XQVXEVWDQWLIFRPPHXQHGpVLQHQFHGHODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOH,OHQYDGHPrPHSRXU
VRQUHSUpVHQWDQWLQGLHQM$(02GDNߙL‫ؾ‬DWiV´GHGURLWHµ´jGURLWHµ'·DXWUHSDUWM$(0%IRQFWLRQQHSDUIRLVFRPPHXQH
GpVLQHQFHG·DEODWLI3DxFDWDQWUD2%NXWR·SLGKDQLNčW«čGč\D´D\DQWUHoX«G·XQXVXULHUµ=1$(0%pTXLYDXWjO·DEODWLI
NDVPčW(QDUPpQLHQjM$60%DHXOHVWDWXWGHGpVLQHQFHG·DEODWLIVLM6'%7J=F9J%9L7%jM6M$60%JK%Mz%9L7%jM!M$60% 6FKPLWW
 ,ODSXHQDOOHUGHPrPHDQWpULHXUHPHQW(WFRPPHODGpVLQHQFHG·DEODWLIHVWHQjM602%8>%J9K%KJHK6HK%
G·LQWHUSUpWHUjM$60%FRPPHXQDEODWLIHQjM60%TXLDXUDLWpWpEkWLQRQSDVVXUOHWKqPHPDLVVXUXQHIRUPHIOpFKLH
JH%jM$2%jUDSSURFKHUGHODGpVLQHQFHKLWWLWHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOHWGHVDGYHUEHVYpGLTXHVGXW\SHGDNߙL‫ؾ‬tW´jGURLWHµ
SDUDOOqOHPHQWDX[IRUPHVHQjM&+ ' M602%jM>M60% IXWXUHVGpVLQHQFHVG·DEODWLISOXULHOHWVHFRQGDLUHPHQWGHGDWLI
SOXULHO TXLVHPEOHQWDYRLUpWpLQLWLDOHPHQWGHV´H[WUDFWLIVµEkWLVVXUXQHIRUPHVLJQLILDQW´HQWUHSOXVLHXUVSDUPLµ
FRPPHRQYHUUDFLGHVVRXV†L%
'HVK\SRWKqVHVGHFHJHQUHVRQWFHUWHVSDUQDWXUHLQGpPRQWUDEOHVFDUFHTXLGLIIpUHQFLHODGpVLQHQFHFDVXHOOH
GXPRUSKHDGYHUELDOHVWFRPPHRQO·DUDSSHOpSUpFpGHPPHQWVRQFDUDFWqUHUpJXOLHUTXLQHSHXWrWUHPLVHQ
pYLGHQFHGDQVXQpWDWGHODQJXHUHFRQVWUXLW0DLVLOHVWSRVVLEOHGHUpXQLUTXHOTXHVLQGLFHVHQOHXUIDYHXU
 oi.uchicago.edu

% P8<B%O<\HKY

Q;X;',<='?HP<@W<='<E'!"#'"'
/DVLWXDWLRQGHVDGYHUEHVHQjM$60%Q·HVWSDVLVROpH2XWUHOHSDUDOOqOHVLJQDOpFLGHVVXVDYHFj&+ ' M602%jM>M602%
HOOHVHUHWURXYHGDQVOHVDGYHUEHVHQjM$-MGRQWOHPRUSKHjUDSSURFKHUGHVGLYHUVLQYDULDQWVVLJQLILDQW´jWUDYHUVµ
WLUpVGHODUDFLQHj$-!OnM%´WUDYHUVHUµ YLHLOLQGLHQWLUiVHWVHVFRUUHVSRQGDQWVLUDQLHQVODWLQ$-()0JHUPDQLTXH
jå!-+2%å1-+2%YLHLOLUODQGDLV$-!2%$(- %SUpVHQWHODSDUWLFXODULWpVXSSOpPHQWDLUHGHIRQFWLRQQHUFRPPHXQVXIIL[HOD
IRUPDWLRQUpXQLWGHVIRUPHVLQHVVLYHVHQ WUč ODWLQLQWUč %GHVIRUPHVGLUHFWLYHV FLGHVVXV† HQ WU‫ گ‬ODWLQ
LQWU‫  گ‬WU̒ JRWLTXHKLGU̒´YHUVLFLµ HWHQLQGRLUDQLHQGHVIRUPHVLQHVVLYHVjYR\HOOHEUqYHjF{WpGHIRUPHVj
YR\HOOHORQJXHYpGLTXHiWUD2iWUč´LFLµ(OOHVDXVVLSHXYHQWrWUHEkWLHVVXUGHVWKqPHVQRPLQDX[YpGLTXHSXUXWUż%
´HQEHDXFRXSG·HQGURLWVµGHYDWUż´SDUPLOHVGLHX[µHWPrPHߓD\XWUż´VXUODFRXFKHµFRPPHGDQVOHVIRUPHV
JRWLTXHVEkWLHVVXUOHQRPGHODYDOOpH"(.(å%´YHUVOHEDVµ"(.(å(%´HQEDVµ%"(.(å-6%´G·HQEDVµTX·pWXGLH$QGUp
5RXVVHDXGDQVVRQDUWLFOHGHFHPrPHUHFXHLO(WOHVIRUPHVVDQVFULWHVHQM$-(%SHXYHQWIRQFWLRQQHUHQSRVLWLRQ
G·pSLWKqWHGDQVXQV\QWDJPHQRPLQDO$($-(% WDVPLQ %?()!%´GDQVFHERLVµ1DWXUHOOHPHQWODIRUPHSRXYDLWLQL
WLDOHPHQWUHSUpVHQWHUXQHIRQFWLRQFDVXHOOHGLIIpUHQWHDYDQWGHSDVVHUSDUOHVWDWXWDGYHUELDOHWGHGHYHQLUj
QRXYHDXGHIDoRQVSRUDGLTXHXQHGpVLQHQFH

Q;Y;',<='?HP<@W<='<E'H<EA?K<7'!"#"(&!"#)"(&!"*"(&!*)"
2QSHXWFLWHUpJDOHPHQWSOXVLHXUVDXWUHVIRUPDWLRQVFRPPHFHOOHGHYpGLTXHGHYiWč´SDUPLOHVGLHX[µU૖ WXWKĎ%
´DXPRPHQWSURSLFHµEDKXGKčੜ ´PXOWLSOHPHQWµRXOHVDGYHUEHVJUHFVHQཧԅHWཧ͘ဎVRXYHQWFODVVpVSDUPLOHV
´DGYHUEHVSURQRPLQDX[µPDLVTXLFRPPHOHVIRUPHVYpGLTXHVSUpFpGHQWHVILJXUHQWpJDOHPHQWVXUGHVEDVHV
QRPLQDOHVFRPPHOHVIRUPHVKRPpULTXHV‫ڗ‬࿽‫ݰ‬Ǔဎཬཧ͘ဎ´GXFLHOµ‫ڗ‬࿽‫ݰ‬ǓဎཬཧԆ´GDQVOHFLHOµRQQRWHUDHQSDVVDQW
TXHFHWWHGHUQLqUH/.#("!%HVWVXLYLHGHO·DGYHUEH›‫ཬݰ‬ੜTXLVHPEOHMRXHUOHU{OHG·XQHSRVWSRVLWLRQ3DXO0D]RQ
&ROOHFWLRQGHV8QLYHUVLWpVGH)UDQFH WUDGXLW´GHYDQWOHFLHOµF·HVWjGLUH´XSLQWKHDLUZLWKWKHYDXOWRIVN\
DVEDFNJURXQGµFRPPHQWH.LUN  TXLFLWHGHX[H[HPSOHVSDUDOOqOHV8QHILQDOHVLPLODLUHIRQFWLRQQH
FRPPHGpVLQHQFHGHORFDWLIVLQJXOLHUGDQVO·DUPpQLHQRի RGK\YR\HOOH 6FKPLWW /·K\SRWKqVHG·XQH
H[WHQVLRQjSDUWLUGHVIRUPDWLRQVVXUEDVHG·LQYDULDQWRXGHSURQRPHVWFHUWHVHQYLVDJHDEOHPDLVFHWWHH[WHQVLRQ
QHVHSURGXLWSDVSDUWRXWO·K\SRWKqVHLQYHUVHQ·HVWGRQFSDVLPSUREDEOH
/HVDGYHUEHVHQj"2%OLpVjODSDUWLFXOHGpLFWLTXHj"!2%j"#%´LFLµHWjODGpVLQHQFHGHO·DEODWLIVLQJXOLHUGHODIOH[LRQ
WKpPDWLTXHSRVHQWXQSUREOqPHSDUWLFXOLHU VLJQDOpFLGHVVXV† VXUOHTXHORQUHYLHQGUD†

Q;Z;',L>?ADM='=F@HO>KDEO=
/HFDUDFWqUHDSSDUHPPHQW´VXIIL[DOµVLJQDOpFLGHVVXV†GXPRUSKHjM$-MTXLVHFRPELQHDYHFGLIIpUHQWHV
GpVLQHQFHVYRFDOLTXHVVXJJqUHO·H[LVWHQFHG·XQHIOH[LRQFRPSRUWDQWGHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVVHFRQGDLUHVEkWLHVVXU
GHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVSUpH[LVWDQWHVFRPPHO·pWUDQJHIRUPHYpGLTXHGHORFDWLISOXULHOI-૖WV~ߙX2%5૖ JYHGD
GHDVPĎNDPEUiKPDࡃWi\HiYDSU૖ WV~ߙXNĎVXFLW´9LHQVHQDLGHjQRWUHIRUPXOHGDQVWRXVOHVFRPEDWVTXHOVTX·LOV
VRLHQWµ)RUPHpWUDQJHPDLVJDUDQWLHSDUOHPqWUHHWTXLQ·HVWSDVLVROpHVXUOHORFDWLISOXULHOI($0wGHSiG´SLHGµ
DpWpIRUPpXQDGYHUEHSDWVXWiV´DX[SLHGVµ5૖ JYHGDDTXLILJXUHpJDOHPHQWHQSUHPLHUWHUPHGDQVOHFRP
SRVpSDWVXWDєߓһ5૖ JYHGDG´pWHQGXDX[SLHGVGH JpQLWLI µ&RPPHFHSURFpGpIOH[LRQQHOGHVXUGpFOLQDLVRQ
Q·DSSDUDvWSDVGDQVOHVpWDWVXOWpULHXUVGXYLHLOLQGLHQRQDOHFKRL[HQWUHXQHLQQRYDWLRQVDQVOHQGHPDLQHWOD
FRQVHUYDWLRQG·XQDUFKDwVPHO·K\SRVWDVHG·XQHIRUPHGHORFDWLIVHPEODEOHjFHOOHVXUODTXHOOHUHSRVHQWOHVIRUPHV
JH%̒\GHODIOH[LRQGHVWKqPHVHQM#M% W\SH›ཬड़Ԇߥ GXJUHF 5L[ 8QHK\SRVWDVHVLPLODLUHSHXWrWUHj
O·RULJLQHGHODYR\HOOHjM#M%GXJUHF›ཬड़ԆߥHWGXEDOWLTXHjI#.#M% OLWXDQLHQI#.Ñ02%IÑ.M%>JKKJ%I#.0%QRPVGHOLHXSUXVVLHQV
JH%@#.M %TXLGRLWV·LGHQWLILHUjODGpVLQHQFHGHORFDWLIVLQJXOLHUYpGLTXHI1-MÉL%/·K\SRVWDVHG·XQHIRUPHFDVXHOOHRX
G·XQV\QWDJPHSUpSRVLWLRQQHOjYDOHXULQHVVLYHHVWIUpTXHQWHGDQVOHVWRSRQ\PHVFRPPHOHUDSSHOOHQW6ROPVHQ
HW)UDHQNHO I WRSRQ\PHVDOOHPDQGVHQM&("!)2%M:!."!)2%M+(10!)2%DQFLHQVGDWLIVSOXULHOVGHS("2%F!."2%O(10%
J#$$!)&!-5!2%O6+!):!."!2%DQFLHQQHVIRUPHVGHGDWLIVLQJXOLHUTXLSHUGHQWODGpVLQHQFHGXVHFRQGWHUPH FLGHVVRXV
† PDLVFRQVHUYHQWFHOOHGXSUHPLHUWHUPHGDQVOHXUVGRXEOHWVJ#$$!)&!-52%O6+!):!."%>J9%KF=FHEMJ9%8K6>8JH9%
K#>#)#2%D#-5!)$#2%*#?6.#2%3+#10#% &OXVLL %UHSRVHQWVXUXQDQFLHQORFDWLIHQҸGXW\SHGRPҸ FLGHVVXV† HWXQH
K\SRVWDVHVLPLODLUHHVWDWWHVWpHGDQVXQSDVVDJHG·XQHLQVFULSWLRQODWLQH3/N%9,X1#%.6410%(II!..($1-%A!>I+#L%
/HVORFDWLIVVXUGpFOLQpVGXYpGLTXHQHVRQWGRQFSDVXQHLQQRYDWLRQLVROpH%
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8BZ78%8*%QT,N\*/,B%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%/BH,M8\K,@Q8Bg%e\87*/,B7%8*%OY@,*OZ787% O:@

/HV\VWqPHFDVXHOUHFRQVWUXLWVHUDLWGRQFOHUpVLGXG·XQV\VWqPHEHDXFRXSSOXVGpYHORSSpFRPSRUWDQWGLYHUV
FDVORFDX[GRQWXQGLUHFWLI³HWjSOXVLHXUVpWDJHV

Q;[;'"OEDADM='=F@HO>KDEO=\
/·K\SRVWDVHGXJpQLWLIHQKLWWLWH9(k$1.M%´IDXWHµ!9(k$1.M(k%´GHODIDXWHµ!%9(k$1.(M´FHOXLGHODIDXWHOHIDXWLI µ
)ULHGULFK SHXWrWUHXQHLQQRYDWLRQDQDWROLHQQHPDLVVLO·RQHQUDSSURFKHXQHDQFLHQQHLQWHUSUpWD
WLRQGXODWLQ-!10%´DFFXVpµSDUO·K\SRVWDVHG·XQDQFLHQJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHU U̒\RV´FHOXLGHO·DIIDLUHµLOV·DJLWG·XQH
FRQVHUYDWLRQ

X;',<'AOJLDRE?R<'H<='MK<GDLE=']OAO@L>KDAD^F<=
$FHWWHVHFRQGHK\SRWKqVHOHVIOH[LRQVKpWpURFOLWLTXHVDSSRUWHQWXQHFRQILUPDWLRQGpFLVLYH&HVIOH[LRQVQH
UHSUpVHQWHQWSDVODFRQVHUYDWLRQG·XQV\VWqPHDQWpULHXUIL[pPDLVWpPRLJQHQWG·XQV\VWqPHHQpYROXWLRQFRPPH
O·DH[SRVp%HQYHQLVWH I HQFRQFOXVLRQjVRQpWXGH
/HVHIIRUWVHPSOR\pVjLQWHUSUpWHUGLUHFWHPHQWODIOH[LRQHQj-W)% j#W) %RQWGRQFpWpGpSHQVpVHQYDLQLOV
GHYDLHQWpFKRXHUSXLVTXHOHSUREOqPHpWDLWPDOSRVp6LFHWWHIOH[LRQSDUUDSSRUWjFHOOHGHVpWDWVKLVWR
ULTXHVVHPEODLWDUFKDwTXHF·HVWTX·HQHIIHWHOOHDFRQVHUYpTXHOTXHVYHVWLJHVG·XQHSUpKLVWRLUHJpQpUDOHPHQW
DEROLH0DLVFHVYHVWLJHVQHUHFRXYUHQWOHXUYDOHXUTXHGDQVXQHWKpRULHTXLpFODLUHOHVWUDLWVIRQGDPHQWDX[
GHOHXUVWUXFWXUH&RQVLGpUpHVRXVFHMRXUODIOH[LRQKpWpURFOLWLTXHDSSDUDvWSRXUFHTX·HOOHHVW¬XQHWHQWD
WLYHIDLWHSRXULQWpJUHUDX[FDGUHVQRXYHDX[GHODIOH[LRQOHVPXOWLSOHVGpULYpVDQFLHQVTXLVHFRQVWLWXDLHQW
VXUODUDFLQHVXUOHVWKqPHVUDGLFDX[RXVXUGHVIRUPHVGpMjGpULYpHV&HQ·HVWSDVXQHIOH[LRQRUJDQLTXH
PDLVXQDVVHPEODJHGHIRUPHVHPSUXQWpHVjGHVV\VWqPHVWUqVGLIIpUHQWVXQLILpHVDSUqVFRXSHWVRXYHQW
VDQVFRKpUHQFH0DOJUpOHXUDVSHFWULJLGHFHVHQVHPEOHVQRXYHDX[QHGRLYHQWSOXVrWUHWUDQVSRVpVWHOV
TXHOVHQLQGRHXURSpHQ,OIDXWOHVGLVVRFLHUSRXUOHVFRPSUHQGUH$ORUVSULVVpSDUpPHQWOHVpOpPHQWVGH
FHWWHIOH[LRQUpYqOHQWDXWDQWGHFKRVHVTXHSDUOHXUOLDLVRQLOVHQRQWRIIXVTXp

'HFHV\VWqPHHQGHYHQLURQQHUHWLHQGUDTX·XQWUDLWSRXUODSUpVHQWHpWXGHO·H[LVWHQFHGHSOXVLHXUVWKqPHV
SRXUXQPrPHSDUDGLJPH,OFRQYLHQWGHGpWHUPLQHUODQDWXUHGHFHVWKqPHVHWO·RULJLQHGHOHXUVYDULDWLRQV,O
QHSHXWSDVV·DJLUGHYDULDQWHVSKRQpWLTXHVFDURQQ·LPDJLQHSDVXQSKRQqPHTXLSRXUUDLWpYROXHUWDQW{WHQ-2%
WDQW{WHQ)2%WDQW{WHQ#L%0DLVLOQHSHXWSDVGDYDQWDJHV·DJLUGHIRUPHVGpULYpHVFRPPHOHVXJJqUH%HQYHQLVWHj
SDUWLUGHODPRUSKRORJLHFDUHOOHVQ·DXUDLHQWSDVOHPrPHVHQVTXHODIRUPHGHEDVHHWQHSRXUUDLHQWGRQFSDV
FRQVWLWXHUDYHFHOOHXQHXQLWpOH[LFDOH2QHVWGRQFFRQGXLWjOHVLGHQWLILHUFRPPHG·DQFLHQQHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHV
VXUGpFOLQpHVVHPEODEOHVDX[IRUPHVSU૖ WV~ߙX%JK%I($0w$(0%GXYpGLTXHHWjFRQFOXUHTXHGDQVXQpWDWDQWpULHXUOH
V\VWqPHFDVXHODSUDWLTXpO·K\SRVWDVHHWFRPSRUWpGHVVXIIL[HVGHIOH[LRQFRPPHHQSRVVqGHOHYHUEHGDQVOHV
GLYHUVHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV4XHODEDVHVRLWHQjM#2%jM-%FL%jM)M2%HOOHSUpVHQWHO·DVSHFWG·XQORFDWLIVLQJXOLHU
GRQWODGpVLQHQFHHVWjM#2%G·XQDGYHUEHGHOLHXGXW\SHGXOLWXDQLHQNXUટ´R"µHWSRXUjM)M2%FHOXLGHODSDUWLFXOHj!)%
TXLGHYLHQGUDSUpYHUEHHWSUpSRVLWLRQ +LUW²YROI HVWFHXQHVLPSOHFRwQFLGHQFH"

Y;'/<='CL=ACL=DADLE='?FG'HO=DE<E><=

Y;:;',<='EFJO@?FG'>?@HDE?FG
&HVSUHPLqUHVREVHUYDWLRQVSHUPHWWHQWGHVHIDLUHXQHLGpHSOXVSUpFLVHGHFHTXLDSUpFpGpLPPpGLDWHPHQW
O·pWDWUHFRQVWUXLWLODSSDUDvWTXHOHVGpVLQHQFHVGHODIOH[LRQUHFRQVWUXLWHRQWSXrWUHDMRXWpHVjGHVGpVLQHQFHV
DQWpULHXUHVRXjGHV´VXIIL[HVGHIOH[LRQµHWTX·DYDQWGHV·DJJOXWLQHUHOOHVpWDLHQWLQLWLDOHPHQWPRELOHV&·HVWFH
TXHFRQILUPHQWFHUWDLQVIDLWVUpVLGXHOVGHO·LQGRLUDQLHQDYHFFHX[TXLOHXUVRQWOLpVHWDXVVLOHVQXPpUDX[FDU
GLQDX[&RPPHO·LQGLTXH0HLHU%UJJHU  ´OHVQXPpUDX[FDUGLQDX[pWDLHQWSUREDEOHPHQWLQGpFOLQDEOHV
jO·RULJLQH«PDLVSRXUPDUTXHUO·DFFRUGOHVGpVLQHQFHVQRPLQDOHVRQWpWpDMRXWpHVDX[QRPEUHVLQIpULHXUVµ/H
FRQWUDVWHHQWUHjIU)=9!%Iç"M!0%´FLQTSLHGVµHW%j$-U'M!0%Iç"M!0%´WURLVSLHGVµHWO·pYROXWLRQSRVWXOpHj$-U'%Iç"M!0%Ö%j$-U'M
!0%Iç"M!0V·LQVFULYHQWGDQVXQYDVWHHQVHPEOHGHGRQQpHVFRQFRUGDQWHVTXLPRQWUHQWTXHFHUWDLQHVGpVLQHQFHV
FDVXHOOHVGXV\VWqPHUHFRQVWUXLWRQWHXLQLWLDOHPHQWOHVWDWXWGHSRVWSRVLWLRQVILJXUDQWXQHVHXOHIRLVGDQVOH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% P8<B%O<\HKY

V\QWDJPHQRPLQDOFRPPHQRVSUpSRVLWLRQV$LQVLTXHO·RQWPRQWUpGLYHUVDXWHXUVHQGHUQLHUOLHX%ODঈHN  
OHVQXPpUDX[FDUGLQDX[VRQWLVVXVGHOH[qPHVRUGLQDLUHVGpVLJQDQWOHSOXVVRXYHQWXQHSDUWLHGXFRUSVOHXU
PRUSKRORJLHUHIOqWHODUqJOHDQFLHQQHGHODUpSDUWLWLRQGHVGpVLQHQFHVGDQVOHV\QWDJPHQRPLQDO

Y;N;',<'AIC<'POHD^F<'QiY\DVöYiFDV7&K<='?AA<=A?ADLE=
$XFHQWUHGHFHWHQVHPEOHTXHM·DLpWXGLpMDGLVGDQVXQDUWLFOHVXUOD´V\QWD[HGHVGpVLQHQFHVµ +DXGU\ 
SXLVLQWpJUpjXQHVVDLGHSUpKLVWRLUHGHODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHLQGRHXURSpHQQH +DXGU\ LO\DXQIDLWGpMj
QRWpSDU6č\D‫ؾ‬DGDQVVRQFRPPHQWDLUHGX5૖ JYHGDFRQQXGHSXLVOHGpEXWGHVpWXGHVYpGLTXHVHWFRUUHFWHPHQW
LQWHUSUpWpSDU.XKQ  OHVV\QWDJPHVQRPLQDX[pSLWKpWLTXHVGXW\SHQiY\DVčYiFDV2%FHWSDUDOOqOHV%
´DYHFXQHSDUROHQRXYHOOHVRXVXQHIRUPHUHQRXYHOpHµDXOLHXGHQiY\DVčYiFDVč2%RXFRRUGLQDWLIVDV\QGpWLTXHV
FRPPHDPDKQĎ«ߓiYDV ߓiYDVč %´SDUVDJUDQGHXU«SDUVDIRUFHL%/DIRUPHVDQVGpVLQHQFHSHXWDXVVLSUp
FpGHUFRPPHDEVDPtWVDPLW«ߓXFĎߓXFč´E€FKHDSUqVE€FKHIODPPHDSUqVIODPPHµ2QWURXYHGHVH[HPSOHV
DXGDWLIVLQJXOLHUDWKpPDWLTXHFRPPH>(+ç% PDKiVH Uč\p2%GHWSDUDOOXQH[HPSOHDXORFDWLIVLQJXOLHU
DWKpPDWLTXHODIRUPXOHUpFXUUHQWHGXOLYUHiGKLVĎQRiY\H iY\D\H %´VXUOHGRVGHODEUHELVµGHQRPEUHX[
H[HPSOHVjO·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHODWKpPDWLTXHDt‫ד‬čEKLє«VXߓDVWt´DYHFUpFRQIRUWV HW ERQQHVSDUROHVµ
DYDGKiQčEKLUDSUDWt´DYHFGHVDUPHVLPSDUDEOHVµjO·DFFXVDWLIDWKpPDWLTXHDEiKLP«VһGDQ VһGDQ
$(> %´OHVHUSHQWLQVWDOOpµXQH[HPSOHDXQRPLQDWLISOXULHODWKpPDWLTXHDDMLUĎVDVWiGDSDV WiGDSDVDV %GHX[
TXDOLILFDWLIVGHVFKHYDX[GX6ROHLO´DJLOHVµHW´GRQWF·HVWODIRQFWLRQµ*HOGQHUQRWH´WiGDSDє«1RP3OPLW$EIDOO
GHU(QGXQJµ8QH[HPSOHjO·DEODWLIVLQJXOLHUDWKpPDWLTXHHVWSUREDEOHFG\iP«SĎVLW\iMDVčPiUWDPiؐKDєN%
OHVHQVHVWPDQLIHVWHPHQW´OHPRUWHOTXHWXSURWqJHVGHO·DEDQGRQ HW GHO·DQJRLVVHµPDLVOHWH[WHWHOTX·LOQRXV
HVWSDUYHQXHVWLQWUDGXLVLEOHFDURQQHVDLWTXHIDLUHG·XQVHFRQGDFFXVDWLIiؐKDєQLGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOW\iMDVč
/DVROXWLRQFRQVLVWHjFRUULJHUHQW\iMDVDV2%DEODWLIGRQWODGpVLQHQFHYDXWSRXUiؐKDє iؐKDVDє %/·pWDWGXWH[WH
´VFKZLHULJXQGYLHOOHLFKWQLFKWJDQ]NRUUHNWEHUOLHIHUWµVHORQ*HOGQHU SHUPHWG·HQYLVDJHUXQHWHOOHFRUUHFWLRQ
'DQVWRXVFHVH[HPSOHVTXLLPSOLTXHQWGHVIRUPHVDWKpPDWLTXHVODIRUPHFRXUWHV·LGHQWLILHDXWKqPH,OHQYD
GLIIpUHPPHQWSRXUOHORFDWLISOXULHOGHODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXHGHFGPDKiWVXčMtߙXXWpPiUEKH iUEKHߙX %´GDQV
OHVJUDQGHVFRPSpWLWLRQVHWGDQVOHVSHWLWHVµRXGHEHWSDUDOOWULߙ~ĎURFDQp URFDQpߙX GLYiє´GDQVOHVWURLV
HVSDFHVOXPLQHX[GXFLHOµODIRUPHHQM!2iUEKH2%-64()UQ·HVWSDVOHWKqPHSULQFLSDOTXLHVWHQM(M2%PDLVOHWKqPH
VHFRQGDLUHGHVFDVREOLTXHVGXSOXULHOTXLV·LGHQWLILHjODIRUPHGXORFDWLIVLQJXOLHU&HWWHREVHUYDWLRQPRQWUHTXH
OHSKpQRPqQHQHUHSUpVHQWHSDVO·RULJLQHGHODIOH[LRQPDLVV·LQVqUHGDQVXQHIOH[LRQRXXQHPEU\RQGHIOH[LRQ
/DOLPLWDWLRQjFHUWDLQVFDVHVWpJDOHPHQWVLJQLILFDWLYHRQQHUHOqYHSDVG·H[HPSOHVV€UVSRXUOHQRPLQDWLI
VLQJXOLHUQLSRXUOHJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUFHTXLVXJJqUHTXHFHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVVHVHUDLHQWIL[pHVDQWpULHXUHPHQW
DXSKpQRPqQHpWXGLp0DLVFRPPHRQO·DYXGqVO·DERUGDYHFOHVQXPpUDX[FDUGLQDX[ODGpVLQHQFHGXQRPLQDWLI
SOXULHOHVWPRELOH
2QQRWHDXVVLTXHOHSKpQRPqQHFRQFHUQHEHDXFRXSSOXVVRXYHQWOHVIRUPHVDWKpPDWLTXHVHQFRQVRQQHRX
VRQDQWHTXHOHVIRUPHVWKpPDWLTXHVHWFHOOHVGHODIOH[LRQHQč%SOXVLHXUVH[HPSOHVLPSOLTXDQWGHVIRUPHVWKp
PDWLTXHVUHWHQXVSDU5RWK  VRQWjUHMHWHU,OHQHVWWRXWHIRLVFRPPHRQO·DYXTXHOTXHVH[HPSOHVDVVXUpV
/HSKpQRPqQHVHPEOHGRQFGHSHXSRVWpULHXUjODFRQVWLWXWLRQGHODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXH,QGpSHQGDPPHQWGH
WRXWHFRPSDUDLVRQHWGHWRXWHK\SRWKqVHVXUVRQRULJLQHLOUHSUpVHQWHPDQLIHVWHPHQWXQDUFKDwVPHGXYpGLTXH
/DQDWXUHSDUWLFXOLqUHGHODGpVLQHQFHGHORFDWLISOXULHOM01%HWGHVGpVLQHQFHVGHFDVREOLTXHVGHGXHOHWGH
=>L78J>%JH%M&+M%TXHOHVJUDPPDLULHQVFODVVLTXHVQRPPHURQWGpVLQHQFHVI("(%´PRWµUHVVRUWGHO·DSSOLFDWLRQTXLOHXU
HVWIDLWHGHVUqJOHVSKRQpWLTXHVGXVDؐGKL2%TXLYDOHQWSRXUO·LQWHUPRWHWSDUH[WHQVLRQSRXUTXHOTXHVPRUSKHV
DJJOXWLQpV 5HQRXI 

Y;Q;'6?@?KKBK<='?P<=AD^F<=
/·$YHVWDSUpVHQWHTXHOTXHVIDLWVVHPEODEOHVTXHOTXHVXQVRQWpWpUHOHYpVSDU%DUWKRORPDH VRXV
JkWKLTXHXUYč۟č %(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHO·$YHVWDUpFHQWO·pWDWGXWH[WHMHWWHSDUIRLVXQGRXWHVXUOHXUDXWKHQWLFLWp
0DLVRQSHXWGLIILFLOHPHQWUpFXVHUO·H[HPSOHGHY(0+$%DQWDU̾SLWDU̾SX۟U̾PFD´HQWUHSqUHHWILOVµRSLWDU̾
WLHQWODSODFHGHSLWDU̾P/DIRUPHHVWFHOOHTXHGRQQHQWODSOXSDUWGHVPDQXVFULWVHWOHVGHX[YDULDQWHVUHWHQXHV
SDU*HOGQHUSDLWDU̾ / HWI($(-!% - VRQWPDQLIHVWHPHQWDEHUUDQWHV/·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHSLWDU̾FRPPHXQDFFX
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8BZ78%8*%QT,N\*/,B%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%/BH,M8\K,@Q8Bg%e\87*/,B7%8*%OY@,*OZ787% O:P

VDWLIGXHOVLJQLILDQW´OHVSDUHQWVµ %DUWKRORPDH²I HVWSHXYUDLVHPEODEOHHQUDLVRQGHVSDUDOOqOHVGX

9EHK6IMJ%SLWDUSX۟UD2%GDQVOHTXHOOHVGHX[IRUPHVVRQWWRXMRXUVDXVLQJXOLHU&HWH[HPSOHHVWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQW
VLJQLILFDWLISRXUO·DSSUpFLDWLRQGHODQDWXUHGXSKpQRPqQHFRPPHRQYHUUDFLGHVVRXV†
/·H[HPSOHJkWKLTXHUHWHQXSDU%DUWKRORPDHY(0)(%XUYD۟č XUYD۟čE\‫ گ‬GčW‫گ‬LE\DVFčHVWLQFHUWDLQO·LQ
WHUSUpWDWLRQGHXUYD۟čFRPPHXQHIRUPHGHQRPLQDWLISOXULHODGRSWpHSDUOHVSOXVUpFHQWVWUDGXFWHXUVVHPEOH
SUpIpUDEOH(QUHYDQFKHELHQTXHVDYD\‫گ‬SXLVVHpJDOHPHQWrWUHXQHIRUPHSHUVRQQHOOHO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHVGHX[
VXEVWDQWLIVjUHFWLRQYHUEDOHFODVVpVFRPPHLQILQLWLIVSDU%DUWKRORPDHUčߖD\H‫و‬ੜ K̒GU̾JYDQW̾PVDYD\‫گ‬DߖDYDQ̾P2%
Y(0)(%FFRPPHUčߖD\DKDLW%dW0(?('(+ M(# ´SRXUQXLUHDXSDUWLVDQGXPHQVRQJH SRXU IDYRULVHUOHSDUWL
VDQGHODYpULWpµPHVHPEOHFRQILUPpHSDUOHSDUDOOqOHGHY(0)(%EFGDU̾J̾ષPGU̾JY‫گ‬G̾E\‫گ‬UDߖ‫گ‬VDYDFčDߖDYDE\‫گ‬%
´ORQJXHQXLVDQFHSRXUOHVSDUWLVDQVGXPHQVRQJHSURILWSRXUOHVSDUWLVDQVGHODYpULWpµY(0)(%DEDߖ̾PVࡃLG\čL
«UčߖD\H‫و‬ੜ K̒GUX[ߖ´ODYpULWpSRXUIDYRULVHUOHPHQVRQJHSRXUQXLUHµHWY(0)(%TXH.HOOHQVHW3LUDUWWUDGXLVHQW
´(WQRXVYRXORQV{0DvWUHTXHWRQIHXSXLVVDQWLQVWUXFWHXUHWIRUWSDUO·+DUPRQLHVRLWG·XQHIDYHXUUHPDUTXDEOH
SRXUOHVHFRXUDEOHPDLVG·XQHPDOYHLOODQFHYLVLEOHSRXUO·KRVWLOH{0D]GčSDUO·LQWHUYHQWLRQGH WHV PDLQVµ

Y;X;'6?@?KKBK<='<GAO@D<F@='_'KSDEHL4D@?ED<E
$SDUWLUGHFHWWHEDVHTXHFRQVWLWXHQWOHVGRQQpHVLQGRLUDQLHQQHVM·DLSURSRVp +DXGU\ G·LQWHU
SUpWHUGLUHFWHPHQWXQFHUWDLQQRPEUHG·DQRPDOLHVDSSDUHQWHVGDQVOHVUqJOHVG·DFFRUGGHGLYHUVHVODQJXHVLQGR
HXURSpHQQHVDQFLHQQHVHQYLHLOLUODQGDLVSRXUO·DGMHFWLIDQWpSRVp#.%4+($-(#5%M689%4($-(#5%#.#%´GHQRPEUHX[SD\Vµ
HQDUPpQLHQFODVVLTXHSRXUO·DGMHFWLISRO\V\OODELTXHED]XP]DZUXWਖLZQNਖ´DYHFGHQRPEUHXVHVPHUYHLOOHVµHQ
KLWWLWHSRXUTXHOTXHVIORWWHPHQWVFRPPH0*DQKࡃPDQFL%KࡃPDQGDQ´WRXWHODQXLWµHWOHV\QWDJPHQRPLQDO
pSLWKpWLTXHP\FpQLHQ3<7DHW!M-!MI(M$!Mc(MI#%6MI#M=!M-!M>#M)#Mc(MI#%d%X!MX#M)6M>!M)(%´DYHFXQGRVG·LYRLUH
JUDYpµ FLGHVVRXV† '·DXWUHSDUWDYHFVHV´FDVVHFRQGDLUHVµOHWRNKDULHQUHSURGXLWODUpSDUWLWLRQRULJLQHOOH
GHVGpVLQHQFHVGDQVOHV\QWDJPHFRRUGLQDWLI

Y;Y;'.EA<@C@OA?ADLE7'?RRKFADE?ADLE'LF'=FCC@<==DLE'<FC]LED^F<\
0DLV³PLVjSDUWOHIDLWWRNKDULHQTXLV·H[SOLTXHGLUHFWHPHQWjSDUWLUGHODUpRUJDQLVDWLRQGXV\VWqPHFDVXHO
VXUOHPRGqOHDJJOXWLQDWLIGHVODQJXHVYRLVLQHVJpRJUDSKLTXHPHQW³FHWWHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHVDQRPDOLHVGHO·DF
FRUGVXSSRVHTXHO·RQDGRSWHSRXUOHVIDLWVLQGLHQVHWLUDQLHQVFHOOHTXHGRQQDLW.XKQ  GHVV\QWDJPHV
YpGLTXHVGXW\SHGHPDKyUč\pN%´FHVIRUPHVVRQWMHFURLVjFRQVLGpUHUFRPPHHIIHFWLYHPHQWGpSRXUYXHVGHIOH[LRQ
ODODQJXHVHFRQWHQWDQWG·H[SULPHUODIOH[LRQVXUXQVHXOGHVQRPVGXV\QWDJPHµ0DLVGDQVXQHpWXGHXOWpULHXUH
5RWK  SURSRVDXQHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQGLIIpUHQWH´XQHUqJOHG·HXSKRQLHQRQSDVGHQDWXUHJUDPPDWLFDOHPDLV
jTXDOLILHUSOXW{WGHUKpWRULTXHµ&HWWHFRQFHSWLRQV·HVWLPSRVpHGHSXLVRQODUHWURXYHSDUH[HPSOHFKH]5HQRX
 TXLDMRXWHO·LQIOXHQFHGXPqWUH´,OHVWGDQVO·RUGUHG·XQHODQJXHDUWLILFLHOOHTXHSRXUOHFKRL[HQWUHGHV
IRUPHVGHPrPHVLJQLILFDWLRQFHVRLWVRXYHQWOHPqWUHTXLGpFLGHµ0DLVLODMRXWH
6XUXQSRLQWDXPRLQVOHVSRqWHVYpGLTXHVVRQWDOOpVSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWORLQLOVVHVRQWSHUPLVG·RPHWWUH
GHVGpVLQHQFHVFDVXHOOHVRXGHOHVPXWLOHUPDLVVHXOHPHQWGDQVODPHVXUHRODSRUWLRQVXEVLVWDQWHGXPRW
FRQVWLWXDLWXQHIRUPHSOHLQH>:DFNHUQDJHO@,,, ,OVVHVRQWDXWRULVpFHWWHOLFHQFHQRWDPPHQWOjR
XQPRWDIIpUHQWRXSDUDOOqOHpWDLWVLWXpLPPpGLDWHPHQWDYDQWRXDSUqVSRUWDQWODPrPHGpVLQHQFHDLQVL
QiY\DVčYiFDVDXOLHXGH)6YiFDVč

'DQVOHSDVVDJHDXTXHOUHQYRLH5HQRX:DFNHUQDJHOFLWHOHVSULQFLSDX[IDLWVYpGLTXHVHWOHVLQWHUSUpWDWLRQVTXL
HQRQWpWpSURSRVpHVGHSXLV.XKQ

Y;Z;',<='C?@?KKBK<='
+,-,.,&/0&12'233430&2330526*&
,OFRQYLHQWGHV·LQWHUURJHUVXUODYDOLGLWpGHODFRQFHSWLRQGH5RWKTXLVHPEOHOXLDYRLUpWpVXJJpUpHSDUOH
WRXUDOOHPDQG"#!%=(#0!-.#4+%"!1$04+!%K!#4+I60$2%#)%0$#..%1)"%:!14+$!)%S14+$!)% FLWpVS XQWRXUTXLV·H[SOLTXHWRXW
DXWUHPHQW 6WHJOLFK /HWRXUDOOHPDQGHVWXQHLQQRYDWLRQLQFRQQXGXYLHX[KDXWDOOHPDQGLODSSDUDvW
 oi.uchicago.edu

OQ?% P8<B%O<\HKY

HQPR\HQKDXWDOOHPDQGSRXUVHUpGXLUHSURJUHVVLYHPHQWHQDOOHPDQGPRGHUQHHQYpGLTXHFRPPHO·LQGLTXH
5HQRX  ´RQQHWURXYHJXqUHGHIDLWVGHTXHOTXHSUREDELOLWpDSUqVOD5૖ N6DؐKLWčµ/HWRXUDOOHPDQGVH
OLPLWHDX[V\QWDJPHVFRRUGLQDWLIVOHWRXUYpGLTXHFRQFHUQHDXVVLHWVXUWRXWOHVV\QWDJPHVpSLWKpWLTXHV/HWRXU
DOOHPDQGSURYLHQWG·XQHH[WHQVLRQDQDORJLTXHjSDUWLUGHODGRXEOHIRUPHGXQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUHWSOXULHOGHOD
IOH[LRQIRUWHGHO·DGMHFWLIHQYLHX[KDXWDOOHPDQG DXVLQJXOLHUPDVFXOLQ&.#)$W&.#)$!-2%HJLK7J%&.#)$W&.#)$(G2%IpPLQLQ
&.#)$W&.#)$#1 %OHYpGLTXHQ·DULHQGHWHO(QILQHQDOOHPDQGODGLVSDULWLRQGHODGpVLQHQFHUpVXOWHVRXYHQWG·XQH
V\QFRSH 6WHJOLFK RUOHVYR\HOOHVGHVV\OODEHVILQDOHVGXYpGLTXHVRQWVWDEOHV

+,-,7,&86&12'233430&32#96:
6LO·RQHQFURLW&LFpURQ,-($6-%OHODWLQDQFLHQDXUDLWSUDWLTXpXQHV\QFRSHGHILQDOHVKRPRSKRQHV
GDQVOHGpELWUDSLGH7(!I!%&-!?#$($#0%4(10(%46)$-(+!&()$%1$%#$(%"#4!-!)$%>1.$#%>6"#0L,OV·DJLWHQIDLWG·XQHFRQIXVLRQ
O·DGYHUEHPXOWLPRGҸV%HJ%7J=F9J%=69%9L7%LH%9EHK6IMJ%PXOWҸVPRGҸV2%PDLVVXUO·DEODWLISOXULHOGHO·DGMHFWLIFRPSRVp
>1.$#>6"102%FRPPHRPQLPRGҸV2%HWOHVLQJXOLHUFRUUHVSRQGDQWRPQLPRG‫گ‬2%VXUOHFRPSRVp6>)#>6"10(QUHYDQFKH
O·DEVHQFHSUREDEOHPHQWIRUWXLWHGHODEDVHDGMHFWLYDOHSRXUO·DGYHUEHPҸULPRGҸV2%TXLSHXWDYRLUpWpEkWLVXUOHV
SUpFpGHQWVFUpHO·LOOXVLRQG·XQHUpGXFWLRQGHODGpVLQHQFHGXSUHPLHUWHUPHG·XQV\QWDJPHPҸUҸVPRGҸV

Y;[;'2@DAD^F<'H<'KS]ICLA]B=<'HSFE<'=FCC@<==DLE'<FC]LED^F<'H<'K?'HO=DE<E><'>?=F<KK<
'·DXWUHSDUWDYDQWG·DWWULEXHUXQXVDJHYpGLTXHjO·HXSKRQLH³XQFULWqUHGRQWQRXVVRPPHVPDXYDLVMXJHV
³LOFRQYLHQGUDLWjWRXWOHPRLQVGHV·DVVXUHUTXHOHVSRqWHVRQWpYLWpOHVVXFFHVVLRQVGHILQDOHVVHPEODEOHV8Q
FRXSG·±LODXWH[WHGXSUHPLHUK\PQHGX5૖ JYHGDPRQWUHjO·pYLGHQFHTX·LOQ·HQHVWULHQDEFSXUyKLWDP«GHYiP
U૖ WYtMDPKyWčUDؐUDWQDGKčၞ$(>(>2%:6%Sࡃၞ UYHEKLU‫ޚ‬૖ ߙLEKLU2%EFSyߙDP«\DߓiVDؐYҸUiYDWWDPDP2%<6%\iؐ\DMxiPDGKYDUiP2%RD%
VDW\iߓFLWUiߓUDYDVWDPDє,OVHPEOHPrPHSDUIRLVTXHO·HIIHWGHULPHDLWpWpUHFKHUFKpSDUH[HPSOHFDUߙD‫ؾ‬ҸQĎP
«YiVࡃQčP«NߙLWҸQčၞ>L%,OHQYDGHPrPHFKH]OHVDXWHXUVODWLQV\FRPSULVOHVSRqWHV 0DXUDFKI TXLQH
FUDLJQHQWSDVO·KRPpRWpOHXWHDLQVL3ODXWH@6!)1.10%::P%6-)()$1-2%.(?()$1-2%$!-5!)$1-2%I6.#1)$1-L%2QHQFRQQDvWQRWDP
PHQWODSUpVHQFHDX[H[WUpPLWpVGHVGHX[KpPLVWLFKHVGXGLVWLTXHpOpJLDTXH3URSHUFH+(!4%!-#$%!%.(4-#>#0%
:(4$(%.#$1-(%>!#0L'·DXWUHSDUWV·LOV·DJLVVDLWG·XQHVXSSUHVVLRQHXSKRQLTXHHOOHDIIHFWHUDLWOHVILQDOHVKRPRSKRQHV
TXHOOHTXHVRLWOHXUQDWXUHPRUSKRORJLTXHSDUH[HPSOHODILQDOHM(0%G·XQLQYDULDQWHWODGpVLQHQFHG·XQJpQLWLI
VLQJXOLHUDWKpPDWLTXHG·XQQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUWKpPDWLTXHRXXQHGpVLQHQFHYHUEDOH2URQQ·REVHUYHULHQGHWHO
(WVLFRPPHOHUHFRQQDvW5HQRXODVXSSUHVVLRQV·RSqUH´VHXOHPHQWGDQVODPHVXUHRODSRUWLRQVXEVLVWDQWHGX
PRWFRQVWLWXDLWXQHIRUPHSOHLQHµLOQHV·DJLWSDVGH´PXWLODWLRQµODVXSSUHVVLRQG·XQHV\OODEHILQDOHUHVSHFWHOD
PRUSKRORJLH,OHQYDGHPrPHHQDYHVWLTXH/·H[HPSOHUHWHQXFLGHVVXVSRXUO·$YHVWDUpFHQWDQWDU̾SLWDU̾SX۟U̾PFD
QHGRLWULHQjO·HXSKRQLHFDUODVXSSUHVVLRQGHOD´ULPHµSLWDU̾PSX۟U̾PDERXWLWjXQH´ULPHµDQWDU̾SLWDU̾*>%
DSSDUDvWTXHO·HXSKRQLHQ·DDXFXQHSDUWGDQVFHVIDLWVTXLVRQWSXUHPHQWJUDPPDWLFDX[1XOGHQRVMRXUVQH
GpFULUDLWO·LQMRQFWLIj&+U-M$2%FRPPHXQLPSDUIDLWjUM&+!-M$2%WURQTXpGHVRQDXJPHQWRXXQSUpVHQWj&+U-M$#GRQW
>J%j#ILQDOVHUDLW´V\QFRSpµSRXUXQHUDLVRQHXSKRQLTXHRXDXWUHFXULHXVHPHQWRQFRQWLQXHjOHIDLUHSRXUOHV
IRUPHVQRPLQDOHV$PDFRQQDLVVDQFHDXFXQHpWXGHGHVRULJLQHVGHODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHLQGRHXURSpHQQH 9LOODU
/LHEDQD6KLHOGV%HHNHV QLDXFXQHSUpVHQWDWLRQUpFHQWHGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQUHFRQVWUXLW $GUDGRV
6FKPDOVWLHJ6]HPHUpQ\L%HHNHV*DPNUHOLG]HHW,YDQRY0HLHU%UJJHU QHIDLW
pWDWGHFHVGRQQpHVHVVHQWLHOOHVSRXUODSUpKLVWRLUHGXV\VWqPHFDVXHO6HXO(UKDUW  DGPHW´XQH
FRXFKHDQFLHQQHGHIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVTXLVHVRQWFRQVWLWXpHVSDUO·DJJOXWLQDWLRQGHSRVWSRVL
WLRQVµSURFHVVXVUpYpOpSDUOHVYHVWLJHVG·XQH´IOH[LRQGHJURXSHµ

Y;`;',?'UMK<GDLE'H<'R@LFC<V
2QQHVDXUDLWpFDUWHUFHVIDLWVHQOHVFDWDORJXDQW´H[HPSOHVEDQDOVGHODIOH[LRQGHJURXSHµDWWHVWpHDXVVLELHQ
HQODWLQWDUGLITX·HQWRNKDULHQFRPPHRQO·DYXFLGHVVXVHQVRLOHIDLWHVWEDQDOFRPPHO·HVWGDQVOHVODQJXHV
GXPRQGHODVWUXFWXUDWLRQDJJOXWLQDWLYHGHO·pQRQFpVDSUpVHQFHjGDWHDQFLHQQHGDQVXQV\VWqPHSDUDLOOHXUV
W\SLTXHPHQWIOH[LRQQHOHVWDXFRQWUDLUHVLJQLILFDWLYH/HVH[HPSOHVGX5૖ JYHGDDQFLHQQHVRQWSDVFHX[G·XQV\V
WqPHIOH[LRQQHOTXLVHGpIDLWVRXVO·LQIOXHQFHGHFKDQJHPHQWVSKRQpWLTXHVDIIHFWDQWOHVILQDOHVRXVHUHVWUXFWXUH
VRXVO·LQIOXHQFHGHODQJXHVDJJOXWLQDQWHVHQFRQWDFW6LOHV\VWqPHFDVXHOYpGLTXHSDUDLOOHXUVILGqOHUHIOHWGH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8BZ78%8*%QT,N\*/,B%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%/BH,M8\K,@Q8Bg%e\87*/,B7%8*%OY@,*OZ787% OQO

FHOXLGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQUHFRQVWUXLWSUpVHQWHGHVWUDFHVGH´IOH[LRQGHJURXSHµF·HVWQpFHVVDLUHPHQWXQIDLWGH
FRQVHUYDWLRQSUREDEOHPHQWXQDUFKDwVPHGHODODQJXHSRpWLTXH6XUFHSRLQWHWVDQVGRXWHSRXUFHWWHUDLVRQOH
YpGLTXH RXO·LQGRLUDQLHQVLO·RQDGPHWOHVH[HPSOHVDYHVWLTXHV VHPRQWUHSOXVFRQVHUYDWHXUTXHO·DQDWROLHQ
TXLQ·HQDJXqUHGHWUDFHV FLGHVVXV† 

Y;!;'#G?J<E'H<'^F<K^F<='M?DA='?E?KLRF<=
/HWRXUJUHFԅਗ››ཬࠗǓ1ๆۭࠗङ‫ࠗٗࢆݰ‬ԅ ͘ੜ ࠗǓ=͘࿱ߥGDQVOHTXHOXQHIRUPHGHQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUHQٗVHVWUHPSODFpH
SDUFHOOHGXWKqPHQHGRLWULHQjO·HXSKRQLHOXLQRQSOXVPDLVFHWWHIRUPHHVWLQLWLDOHPHQWFHOOHGXYRFDWLI 5LVFK
 ,OQHFRQVWLWXHGRQFSDVXQSDUDOOqOHDX[IDLWVpWXGLpVFLGHVVXV
3RXUO·H[HPSOHP\FpQLHQFLWpFLGHVVXV†TXLHQFRQVWLWXHXQ9HQWULVHW&KDGZLFN I SUpVHQWHQW
³VDQVUpIpUHQFHjO·HXSKRQLHXQHMXVWLILFDWLRQVXUSUHQDQWHGHSULPHDERUGPDLVVXJJHVWLYH´X!MX#M)6M>!M)(%8H%
OLQHHYLGHQWO\DJUHHVLQVHQVHZLWKRSLNHOHPQLčSKL«EXWWKHHQGLQJMI+#%KDVEHHQVXSSUHVVHGIURPWKHSDUWLFLSOH
LQRUGHUWRPDNHFOHDUHUWKHUHODWLRQWRLWVRZQVXERUGRQDWHLQVWUXPHQWDOVµ3RXUTXH³SDUDGR[DOHPHQW³OD
VXSSUHVVLRQG·XQHGpVLQHQFHVXUO·XQGHVWHUPHVUHQIRUFHODFRKpVLRQG·XQV\QWDJPHQRPLQDOHWSHUPHWWHG·pWD
EOLUXQHGLIIpUHQFHDYHFGHVIRUPHVVXERUGRQQpHVDXPrPHFDVFHWWHVXSSUHVVLRQGRLWVHIRQGHUVXUXQUqJOH
SUpH[LVWDQWHVXIILVDPPHQWELHQpWDEOLH
/·H[HPSOHGHO·LQVFULSWLRQODWLQHDUFKDwTXH 9,,qPHVLqFOH FLWpHSDU0LFKqOH)UX\WGDQVVRQDUWLFOHGHFHPrPH
YROXPHRODGpVLQHQFHGXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUILJXUHXQHVHXOHIRLVGDQVOHV\QWDJPHQRPLQDO*/*<%T8BH/<7%´GH
7LWD9HQGLDµHVWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWLQWpUHVVDQWLOHVWDSSDUXFLGHVVXV†TX·HQYpGLTXHOHIDLWQ·DSSDUDvWSDV
DXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHU/·H[HPSOHODWLQV·LOHVWUHWHQXUHSUpVHQWHGRQFXQHH[WHQVLRQDQDORJLTXHjSDUWLUG·DXWUHV
HPSORLVQRQDWWHVWpVMXVTX·jSUpVHQW

Y;:a;',<='MDE?K<='OK?@RD<=
3DUDOOqOHPHQWDX[´ILQDOHVV\QFRSpHVµRQFRQQDvWGHV´ILQDOHVpODUJLHVµQRWDPPHQWGDQVODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXH
HWFHOOHGHVWKqPHVHQ čHQLQGRLUDQLHQOHGDWLIVLQJXOLHUYLHLOLQGLHQHQč\D2%OHORFDWLIVLQJXOLHUHQč\čPHWF
TXLRQWPDQLIHVWHPHQWDJJOXWLQpXQHSRVWSRVLWLRQFRQIRUPpPHQWjODUqJOHDQWpULHXUHQHGRLYHQWULHQHOOHVQRQ
SOXVjO·HXSKRQLH,OHQYDGHPrPHSRXUOHGRXEOHWHQ čVDVGXQRPLQDWLISOXULHOHQ čV2%HWVHVFRUUHVSRQGDQWV
GHVODQJXHVJHUPDQLTXHVGHO·RXHVW SUREDEOHPHQWLVVXVG·XQHpYROXWLRQSDUDOOqOHLQGpSHQGDQWH DLQVLTXHGX
UHQRXYHOOHPHQWGHODIRUPHGXORFDWLIHQOLWXDQLHQ FLGHVVXV† &HV´ILQDOHVpODUJLHVµUHSURGXLVHQWGLUHFWHPHQW
OHVIDLWVG·K\SRVWDVHHWGHVXUGpFOLQDLVRQVLJQDOpVFLGHVVXV† YpGLTXHSDWV~ߙX2SDWVXWiV %HWUHSUpVHQWHQWXQH
FRQWUHSDUWLHUpFHQWHGHV´ILQDOHVV\QFRSpHVL

Y;::;',SL@DRDE<'H<'K?'HO=DE<E><'HF'HD@<>ADM
/·K\SRWKqVHGpYHORSSpHFLGHVVXVHQJDJHjLGHQWLILHUODGpVLQHQFH ̒ ‫گ‬GXGLUHFWLI † jODSDUWLFXOH
GLUHFWLYH ̒W ‫ گ‬j!W6MO _ %LQGRLUDQLHQ čၞM2%TXLILJXUHQRWDPPHQWGDQVOHVYHUEHVLQGLTXDQWXQPRXYHPHQW
čၞM5(>M%´DOOHUYHUV%HWSHXWrWUHVRXVODIRUPHEUqYHj6M%GDQVOHYHUEHJUHFི໵ๆड़ड़ङ´M·DERUGHµPDLVDXVVL%GDQV%
OHYHUEH ̒W ‫گ‬GH+rM PR\HQ %´UHFHYRLUµLQGRLUDQLHQ čၞGč2%HWOHVDQFLHQVFRPSRVpVODWLQK̒U̒G´KpULWLHUµJUHF
शٗ‫ݰ‬ङۭࠗǓԅ ੜ ´KpULWLHUVFROODWpUDX[L%&HWWHSDUWLFXOHVHPEOHLVVXHG·XQHIRUPHFDVXHOOHGXSURQRPGpPRQVWUDWLIHW
DQDSKRULTXHj!W6MFLGHVVRXV†FHOOHGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOVLQJXOLHUGRQWODGpVLQHQFHHVWKRPRSKRQH 0D\UKRIHU
²YRO RXFHTXLVHUDLWSUpIpUDEOHSRXUOHVHQVFHOOHG·XQSOXVDQFLHQGLUHFWLIHQjMO_",ODSSDUDvW
GRQFTXHFHUWDLQHVIRUPHVGHODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHUHFRQVWUXLWHVRQWLVVXHVG·XQSURFHVVXVDJJOXWLQDWLIPDLVSRXU
XQHSDUWFRPPHRQO·DYXFLGHVVXV††HWjSDUWLUG·XQHIOH[LRQDQWpULHXUH

Z;',?'MK<GDLE'A]OJ?AD^F<
&·HVWpJDOHPHQWXQSURFHVVXVDJJOXWLQDWLITXLDFRQGXLWjODFRQVWLWXWLRQGHODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXHTXLXWLOLVH
OHVGpVLQHQFHVGHODIOH[LRQDWKpPDWLTXHFRPELQpHVpYHQWXHOOHPHQWFRQWUDFWpHVDYHFOD´YR\HOOHWKpPDWLTXHµ
j!W6 0HLHU%UJJHU &HWWHIOH[LRQHVWLVVXHGHV\QWDJPHVFRPSRVpVG·XQWKqPHQRPLQDOVXLYLGXSUR
 oi.uchicago.edu

OQ:% P8<B%O<\HKY

QRPGpPRQVWUDWLIHWDQDSKRULTXHj!W6M 6FKPDOVWLHJ+DXGU\I GDQVOHVTXHOVODGpVLQHQFHILJXUH

XQHVHXOHIRLVVHORQODUqJOHGpFULWHFLGHVVXV†HWV·DWWDFKHDXSURQRPTXLGHYLHQWOD´YR\HOOHWKpPDWLTXHµ
FRPPHGDQVODOLDLVRQG·XQHSUpSRVLWLRQHWGHO·DUWLFOHIUDQoDLV(12%DOOHPDQGG1>2%HWF/HVVXEVWDQWLIVWKpPDWLTXHV
VRQWGRQFLVVXVG·DQFLHQVVXEVWDQWLIVDUWLFXOpVGHOjSURYLHQWODYDOHXU´LQGLYLGXDOLVDQWHµTX·RQOHXUUHFRQQDvW
JpQpUDOHPHQW/HVDGMHFWLIVWKpPDWLTXHVVRQWLVVXVG·XQHDQFLHQQH´IOH[LRQORQJXHµ +DXGU\ /DQDWXUH
SUHPLqUHGHOD´YR\HOOHWKpPDWLTXHµDSSDUDvWFODLUHPHQWGDQVODIRUPDWLRQGHVRUGLQDX[FRPPH VHSWP૖ R´OH
9J=KY%9L7% VHSWP૖ ´VHSWµHWGDQVO·DGMHFWLIHQYDOHXUGHFRPSOpPHQWFLUFRQVWDQFLHO৓้ۭ›ๆ‫ݰ‬ԅ‫ڗ‬ԅ«ර‫ݵ‬ԅ ໵ੜ ‫ڗ‬ဎࠗ‫´ڗ‬LOV
DUULYqUHQWOHVRLUµ &KDQWUDLQH TXLUHSRVHVXUXQHDQFLHQQHVpTXHQFHj9!0I!-#%6'%´HX[OHVRLUµDYDQWGH
V·pWHQGUHDQDORJLTXHPHQWjGHVLPPRWLYpVODWLQҸEDQWREVFࡃUҸ´LOVDOODLHQWGDQVO·REVFXULWpµ
/DIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXHSUpVHQWHXQH[HPSOHGH´ILQDOHpODUJLHµ FLGHVVXV† DXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUODIRUPH
F78I8HJ>>J%jM602%FRQVHUYpHGDQVTXHOTXHVIRUPHVFRPPHOHYpGLTXHUiWKDVSiWL´PDvWUHGXFKDUµDpWpUHPSODFpH
=67%jM60M6%FL%jM60M'6L
/DYR\HOOHWKpPDWLTXHjM!W6M%DXQGRXEOHWjM#M%GRQWOHODWLQFRQVHUYHGHVWUDFHVGDQVOHVFRPSRVpVGXW\SH
#>&!..M#M0%´LQDSWHjODJXHUUHµHQIDFHGH&!..M1M>%´JXHUUHµGDQVOHVSDUWLFLSHVSUpVHQWVHQM)$M#M2%GDQVOHVDQFLHQV
DGMHFWLIVHQjM1M%GXW\SHGHVXčYLV´GRX[µGH VZčG~&RPPHOHUDSSHOOH/DPEHUWHULH I FHQHVRQWSDV
G·DQFLHQVIpPLQLQVPDLVGHVIRUPHVpODUJLHVHQjM#M% YpGLTXHJK‫ޚ‬૖ ߙYL¬NJK‫ޚ‬૖ ߙX´H[FLWpµ SDUDOOqOHVjGHVIRUPHVpODU
I8J9%JH%jM!W6M% EDOWLTXH W̔QYDV2%GHj$!)OnM9M6M0%HQIDFHGXODWLQ$!)1#02%GHj$!)OnM9M#M0 &HWWHYR\HOOHWKpPDWLTXH
jM#M%V·LGHQWLILHDXSURQRPj#M%SURFKHGXSURQRPj!W6M%DXTXHOLOVHPEOHV·rWUHDVVRFLpjODIRLVGDQVOHSDUDGLJPHHW
GDQVOHV\QWDJPHGLYHUVHVIOH[LRQVFRPPHFHOOHGXODWLQ#0%FRPSRUWHQWGHVIRUPHVUHSRVDQWVXUj!W6M% !c102%GHj!M
0'6M HWG·DXWUHVVXUj#M2%JK%>J%=7FHFM%7J>6K8G%j'6M%SHXWUHSUpVHQWHUODFRPELQDLVRQGHVGHX[IRUPHV,OQ·\DDXFXQH
UDLVRQGHVXSSRVHUSRXUFHVGHX[SURQRPVXQHODU\QJDOHLQLWLDOHFRPPHOHIRQWFHUWDLQVDXWHXUV
6XLYLHGHODODU\QJDOHjOn%2%RXG·DXWUHVFRQVRQQHV jM$2%jM" %FHSURQRPj#M%DVHUYLjODIRUPDWLRQGXIpPLQLQDYHF
OHVGHX[W\SHVSULQFLSDX[YU૖ NҸၞM%JK%GHYҸၞM%HWOHVRXVW\SHSiWQҸ 'HEUXQQHUI PDLVDXVVLjM#$M2%YLHLOLQGLHQ%
-6+É$M´JD]HOOHµ 'HEUXQQHUI jM#"M2%JUHFරࠗड़Ǔဎࠗԅ ߥੜ ´ILOOHG·$WODVµ &KDQWUDLQHI WRXWFRPPHOD
D69J%=7FHFM8H6>J%jM!W6M%jODIRUPDWLRQGHVIpPLQLQVHQ č jM!OnM %&HVGLIIpUHQWHVPDUTXHVGXFDVGLUHFWVLQJXOLHU
SHXYHQWUHIOpWHUXQHDQFLHQQHFODVVLILFDWLRQ (UKDUWFLGHVVRXV† 
/DFRQVWLWXWLRQGHODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXHHWODUpGXFWLRQGHO·HIIHFWLIFDVXHO FLGHVVXV††HW VHPEOHQWOLpHV
FRPPHOHVRQWO·DSSDULWLRQGHO·DUWLFOHGpILQLHWODUpGXFWLRQRXODGLVSDULWLRQGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOGDQVSOXVLHXUV
ODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVDFWXHOOHVOLHQVXUOHTXHO+HZVRQ +HZVRQHW%XEHQLN DWWLUHjMXVWHWLWUH
O·DWWHQWLRQ0DLVFRQWUDLUHPHQWjO·DUWLFOHGpILQLGHFHVGLIIpUHQWHVODQJXHVFHOXLGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQQ·DDERXWL
TX·jFRPSOLTXHUODPRUSKRORJLHDYHFODFUpDWLRQG·XQHQRXYHOOHIOH[LRQ

[;'"<EB=<'H<'KS<GC@<==DLE'HF'ELJW@<

[;:'.EHD><='HF'>?@?>AB@<'@O><EA'H<'KS<GC@<==DLE'HF'ELJW@<
&HTXLGDQVODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHV·HVWFRQVWLWXpOHSOXVWDUGHVWO·H[SUHVVLRQGXQRPEUH&RQWUDLUHPHQWj
O·DUPpQLHQPRGHUQHRGDQVVHVGHX[YDULDQWHVSULQFLSDOHVLOV·H[SULPHSDUXQPRUSKHVSpFLDOVXIIL[pDXWKqPH
HWSRUWHXUGHVGpVLQHQFHVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVDQFLHQQHVQ·RQWSDVGHPDUTXHXQLTXHGXSOXULHO
$ORUVTX·DXVLQJXOLHUOHVFRUUHVSRQGDQFHVHQWUHIRUPHVVRQWULJRXUHXVHVjTXHOTXHVH[FHSWLRQVSUqVGHV
IORWWHPHQWVLPSRUWDQWVV·REVHUYHQWDXSOXULHOHWDXGXHO$LQVLODGXDOLWpj&+N%j>%GDQVOHVGpVLQHQFHVGHWURLVFDV
GDWLIDEODWLILQVWUXPHQWDO 
(QKLWWLWHODIOH[LRQGXSOXULHOHVWUpGXLWHHWXQHPrPHGpVLQHQFHM()%LVVXHGHjM6>W)%FL% ‫گ‬PW)2%TXLHVW
DIIHFWpHSDUWRXWDLOOHXUVDXJpQLWLISOXULHOVHUWDXVVLDXVLQJXOLHUjF{WpGHM(k2%GpVLQHQFHLVVXHGHjM60L
2QDYXFLGHVVXV††HWTXHODGpVLQHQFHGXQRPLQDWLISOXULHOHVWPRELOH/HFDUDFWqUHUpFHQWGHO·H[
SUHVVLRQGXQRPEUHHVWpJDOHPHQWFRQILUPpSDUO·DEVHQFHG·DFFRUGHQQRPEUHGDQVTXHOTXHVH[HPSOHVYpGLTXHV
FRPPHWULߙ~čၞ %-64()U2%FLGHVVXV†

[;N;',<='>?='HD@<>A='HF'HF<K
/DGpVLQHQFHGHVFDVGLUHFWVGXGXHOGHODIOH[LRQDWKpPDWLTXHHVWLGHQWLTXHjFHOOHGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOVLQJX
OLHU +DXGU\D HWVLJQLILHLQLWLDOHPHQW´GHX[DYHFµYDOHXUUHSUpVHQWpHGLUHFWHPHQWGDQVOH´GXHO
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8BZ78%8*%QT,N\*/,B%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%/BH,M8\K,@Q8Bg%e\87*/,B7%8*%OY@,*OZ787% OQQ

HOOLSWLTXHµYpGLTXHYiUX‫ؾ‬č´ 0LWUD HW9DUX‫ؾ‬Dµ(UKDUW  \YRLWDXFRQWUDLUHXQHGpVLQHQFHSURSUH

DQFLHQQQHPDUTXHG·XQHFODVVH´SDUDOHµ6XUODTXHVWLRQYRLUHQGHUQLHUOLHX0DWWKLDV)ULW]FKH]0HLHU%UJJHU
I 

[;Q;',<='>?='HD@<>A='HF'E<FA@<'CKF@D<K'
2QVDLWTXHODUqJOHJUDPPDWLFDOHGHO·DFFRUGDXVLQJXOLHUGHVSOXULHOVQHXWUHVLOOXVWUpHSDUO·H[HPSOHJUHF
ࠗඨ৒လǓࠗ‫ݰ‬ๆश͘ԅTXHOHVPRUSKHVGHVFDVVRQWLVVXVGHFHX[G·XQFROOHFWLIG·RVRQWLVVXHVSDUDLOOHXUVGHVIRUPHV
GHVLQJXOLHUOHW\SHJUHF࿹˗ङ‫ݰ‬2UGDQVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVDQFLHQQHVOHFROOHFWLIHVWXQHFDWpJRULH
GpULYDWLRQQHOOHLOV·H[SULPHSDUXQVXIIL[HFRPPH č2 L\č2 Wč2 WčW2%jM$#M2 WࡃW # M2%jM6M2%jM#'6ML%&HWWHpYROXWLRQ
G·XQFROOHFWLIHQSOXULHOGRLWGRQFrWUHFRQVLGpUpHFRPPHXQIDLWGHJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQGDQVOHTXHOO·H[SUHVVLRQ
G·XQVLJQLILpHVWSDVVpHGHODGpULYDWLRQjODIOH[LRQ/DVHXOHTXHVWLRQTXLVHSRVHHVWFHOOHGHVDSRUWpHO·pYROXWLRQ
V·HVWHOOHOLPLWpHjGLYHUVLILHUOHVLJQLILDQWG·XQHFDWpJRULHGpMjLQVWDOOpHGDQVODIOH[LRQRXDWHOOHpWpOHSRLQWGH
GpSDUWGHO·H[SUHVVLRQGXSOXULHO"

[;X;',SDE=A@FJ<EA?K'CKF@D<K
8QHpYROXWLRQDQDORJXHPDLVTXHOTXHSHXGLIIpUHQWHHVWjO·RULJLQHGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHO-·DLMDGLV +DXGU\
II DWWLUpO·DWWHQWLRQVXUXQHYDOHXUGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHOGRQWO·LPSRUWDQFHDpWpPpFRQ
QXHFHOOHGH´HQWUHSDUPLµjSDUWLUG·H[HPSOHVLQFRQWHVWDEOHVWHOVTXH5૖ JYHGDDEF ,QGUD Vyi‫ع‬JLUREKLU
i‫ع‬JLUDVWDPREKࡃGYU૖ ੜߙčY‫ޚ‬૖ ߙDEKLUViNKLEKLєViNKčViQU૖ JPtEKLUU૖ JPһJčW~EKLUML\pVWKDє2%TXH5HQRX  WUDGXLW´/XL
LOHVWSDUPLOHV$‫ع‬JLUDVOHPHLOOHXU$‫ع‬JLUDVOHPkOHSDUPLOHVPkOHVpWDQWXQDPLSDUPLOHVDPLVXQGpWHQWHXUGH
VWURSKHVSDUPLOHVGpWHQWHXUVGHVWURSKHVODPHLOOHXUH YRLH SDUPLOHVYRLHVµRXENDYtEKLєNDYtєViQ´ $JQL 
SRqWHSDUPLOHVSRqWHVµ´SRqWHSDUH[FHOOHQFHµ F·HVWDXVVLO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGH*HOGQHU´XQWHU6HKHUQVHOEVWHLQ
6HKHUµ &HUWDLQVVRQWPRLQVpYLGHQWVjSUHPLqUHYXHiJQH«YtߓYčEKLUGHYiKࡃWLEKLULPiؐVWyPDؐMXߙDVYD
)(´{$JQLDSSUpFLHQRWUHpORJH!)$-! HWQRQ(?!42%(#)0#%X1! %WRXWHVOHVLQYRFDWLRQVDX[GLHX[µ&HSDVVDJHHWOHV
SDVVDJHVVLPLODLUHVFRPPHRQWSRVpXQVpULHX[SUREOqPHDX[WUDGXFWHXUVTXLDWWULEXHQWjO·LQVWUXPHQWDO
XQHYDOHXUVRFLDWLYHRXXQHYDOHXUPpGLDWLYHDXVVLPDODGDSWpHVO·XQHTXHO·DXWUHGDQVFHWWHVLWXDWLRQLOQ·HVW
SDVFRQFHYDEOHTXHGDQVXQHFRPSpWLWLRQSRpWLTXHOHSRqWHHVSqUHJDJQHUJUkFHDX[SUHVWDWLRQVGHVHVFRQFXU
UHQWVRXTX·LOGHPDQGHDXGLHXG·DSSUpFLHU(100#FHVGHUQLqUHV'HSOXVGDQVFHWWHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQO·LQVWUXPHQWDO
V·DSSOLTXHUDLWjO·DVVRFLpGHO·REMHWHPSORLSHXIUpTXHQWDXVLQJXOLHU +DXGU\ &HVHQVGH´HQWUHSDUPLµ
HVWjFRQVLGpUHUFRPPHXQHYDOHXUDXWRQRPHFHQ·HVWSDVOHSOXULHOGH´DYHFµDLQVLTX·RQYLHQWGHOHYRLU0DLVLO
SHXW\FRQGXLUHGDQVFHUWDLQHVVLWXDWLRQVDXWUHVTXHFHOOHVGHODFRQFXUUHQFH´XQSDUPLSOXVLHXUVµSHXWpTXLYD
ORLUj´XQDYHFSOXVLHXUVµV·LOVVRQWGDQVXQPrPHJURXSHDJLVVHQWGDQVOHPrPHVHQVHWVLRQQHOHVGpQRPEUH
SDV-·DLSURSRVpLELGG·LQWHUSUpWHUSDUFHWWHYDOHXU´VRFLDWLYHH[FOXVLYHµOHUpJLPHLQVWUXPHQWDOGHVYHUEHV
´FRPPDQGHUµ ´rWUHFKHII(->#µ %O·LQVWUXPHQWDOGHO·DWWULEXWGHVODQJXHVEDOWRVODYHV ´rWUHI(->#%.!0%dµ %JK%>J9%
QXPpUDX[SHUVRQQHOVGXYLHLOLUODQGDLV&HVLQWHUSUpWDWLRQVVXSSRVHQWTXHODYDOHXUHVWDQFLHQQHHWQHUpVXOWH
SDVG·XQHLQQRYDWLRQSURSUHDXYpGLTXH'HIDLWODYDOHXU´HQWUHSDUPLµV·REVHUYHpJDOHPHQWHQYLHLODYHVWLTXH
Y(0)(%FSDU̾ષYnYҸVSčLߖZSDU̾ષ@YDR[̾PčGD̒YčLߖFč[UDIVWUčLߖPDߖ\čLߖFčTXH.HOOHQVHW3LUDUWHQDFFRUGVXUO·HVVHQWLHO
DYHF,QVOHUHW+XPEDFKWUDGXLVHQW´QRXVYRXVDYRQVWRXMRXUVGpFODUpVVXSpULHXUVjWRXVOHVGLHX[LQIHFWVHWDX[
PDXYDLV KRPPHVµ&HWWHFRQVWUXFWLRQDYHFO·LQVWUXPHQWDOGHI(-(M%´VXSpULHXUµVHUHWURXYHHQYpGLTXH5૖ JYHGD
DSDUyKtPiUWL\DLUiVL´FDUWXHVVXSpULHXUDX[KRPPHVµOHYHUVVXLYDQWVDPyGHYDtUXWiߓUL\Ď´HWpJDODX[
GLHX[HQpFODWµLOOXVWUHjODIRLVODGLIIpUHQFHHQWUHODYDOHXUVRFLDWLYHLQFOXVLYHGXUpJLPHLQVWUXPHQWDOGHVDPi
´pJDOjµHWODYDOHXUVRFLDWLYHH[FOXVLYHGHFHOXLGHSDUi´VXSpULHXUjµODPrPHTX·HQGpSHQGDQFHGHVYHUEHV
´FRPPDQGHUµHWO·LGHQWLWpGHOHXUH[SUHVVLRQ&HWWHYDOHXUVHUHWURXYHSHXWrWUHGDQVTXHOTXHVDXWUHVSDVVDJHV
GXPrPHWH[WHFRPPHFYDKP̒«JDU‫گ‬EҸߖVWࡃWıP´GDQVO·KRPPDJH«I(->#OHVFKDQWVGHORXDQJHVµFRPPHGDQV
OHSDVVDJHYpGLTXHFLWpFLGHVVXVSOXW{WTXH´(?!4%FL%JUkFHDX[2Y%HWSRXUOHVPrPHVUDLVRQVF]DVWčLߖWčLߖG̾U̾ߖWč
D̒QD‫و‬K̾P´XQPDOYLVLEOHI(->#%FHX[TXLYLHQQHQWGHWDPDLQµSOXW{WTXH´I(-%.;#)$!-?!)$#6)%"!%WHVPDLQVµ .HOOHQV
HW3LUDUWVLPLODLUH+XPEDFK $XVVLY(0)(FGU̾JY‫گ‬G̾EҸߖD̒ߖP̾PYčGč\D´DEDWWUHODIXUHXUI(->#%>J9%=67K896H9%
GXPHQVRQJHµ SOXW{WTXH(#)0#%X1!%FL%4(10U!%I(- %HWSHXWrWUHY(0)(%GčLߖSRXUX\‫گ‬TXLVLJQLILHSUREDEOHPHQW
´OHSUHPLHUI(->#%HX[µHWQRQ´!]%éX16%DYHFHX[µFRPPHO·LPSOLTXHODWUDGXFWLRQGH+XPEDFK´(.6)5%9#$+%WKHVHµ
PDLVO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHODIRUPHYHUEDOHIUDY‫گ‬LYҸG̒HVWLQFHUWDLQH
 oi.uchicago.edu

OQ<% P8<B%O<\HKY

/·HPSORLKRPpULTXHGXFDVHQ‫ݵ‬ԅHQYDOHXUGHVLQJXOLHUHVWXQHLQQRYDWLRQ 5L[ 
6LFRPPHLOUHVVRUWGHFHVH[HPSOHVOHVHQVGH´HQWUHSDUPLµQ·HVWSDVXQHLQQRYDWLRQGXYpGLTXHHWSHXW
GRQFVHUYLUjLQWHUSUpWHUOHVGLYHUVHPSORLVUpXQLVFLGHVVXVFHWWHYDOHXUGHODIRUPHGRLWrWUHFRQVLGpUpHFRPPH
ODSOXVDQFLHQQHHWFHOOHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHOFRPPHOHUpVXOWDWG·XQHUpLQWHUSUpWDWLRQjSDUWLUGHVHPSORLVGDQV
OHVTXHOVOHVHQVGH´SDUPLµHWFHOXLG·´DYHFSOXVLHXUVµpWDLHQWVXVFHSWLEOHVGHV·LGHQWLILHU,FLHQFRUHOHSURFHVVXV
DSXV·LQVpUHUGDQVXQHFDWpJRULHGpMjFRQVWLWXpHRXSDUWLFLSHUjVDFRQVWLWXWLRQ

`;',<'>?='H<'KSLWb<A
6LFRPPHLOUHVVRUWGHVSUpFpGHQWVH[HPSOHVOHV\VWqPHFDVXHOV·HVWFRQVWLWXpjSDUWLUG·XQLWpVSRUWHXVHV
G·XQHVLJQLILFDWLRQSUpFLVHORFDOHRXDXWUHWHOOHTXH´FROOHFWLYLWpµ´¬VRFLDWLYLWpH[WHUQH RXH[WUDFWLYH µ´FRQWDFWµ
SRXUO·LQVWUXPHQWDOVLQJXOLHU ´GLUHFWLRQYHUVµ SRXUO·DFFXVDWLI RXHQFRUHSRXUOHGDWLI´SURVSHFWLYLWpµLOHVW
SUREDEOHTXH³VLHOOHVH[LVWDLHQWOHVIRQFWLRQVJUDPPDWLFDOHVFRPPHFHOOHVGHVXMHWG·REMHWHWGHFRPSOpPHQW
GHVVXEVWDQWLIVLPSOLTXDQWXQHUHODWLRQGHYDLHQWUHVWHUHQGHKRUVGHFHV\VWqPHHQYRLHGHFRQVWLWXWLRQSDUO·LQWp
JUDWLRQGHVUpVLGXVGHV\VWqPHVDQWpULHXUV FLGHVVXV††HW O·DJJOXWLQDWLRQGHSRVWSRVLWLRQV † GHSURQRPV
† HWODPLVHHQUHODWLRQGHIRUPHVGRQWOHVLJQLILpLPSOLTXHODSOXUDOLWpDYHFGHVIRUPHVGRQWOHVLJQLILpGHVHQV
YRLVLQQHO·LPSOLTXHSDV † 

`;:;',?'A]OL@D<'H<='H<FG'JLHBK<=
(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHO·REMHWSUHPLHULOVHPEOHTXHGHX[FDVGXV\VWqPHQRXYHDXFHX[GRQWOHVLJQLILDQWHVW
XQHDQFLHQQHSRVWSRVLWLRQILJXUDQWXQHVHXOHIRLVGDQVOHV\QWDJPHQRPLQDOVRLHQWHQWUpVHQFRQFXUUHQFH
O·LQVWUXPHQWDOH[SULPDQWOHFRQWDFWHWO·DFFXVDWLI´GLUHFWLIµ/·DFFXVDWLIFRPPHRQVDLWO·DHPSRUWpSDUWRXW
PDLVO·LQVWUXPHQWDOGHO·REMHWHVWDVVH]ODUJHPHQWUHSUpVHQWpHQJHUPDQLTXHHQEDOWLTXHHWHQVODYH,OSRXUUDLW
V·DJLUG·XQHLQQRYDWLRQFRPPXQHGHV´ODQJXHVGXQRUGµpYHQWXHOOHPHQWG·XQHPSUXQWjGHVODQJXHVQRQLQGR
HXURSpHQQHV0DLVGDQVOHVWUDYDX[SUpFLWpV +DXGU\ M·DLPRQWUpTXHGDQVQRPEUHGHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
TXLUpXQLVVHQWXQLQVWUXPHQWDOHWXQDFFXVDWLIFRPPHFHOOHGHVYHUEHVVLJQLILDQW´ODQFHUµODIRUPHjO·DFFXVDWLI
H[SULPHDXGpSDUWQRQSDVO·REMHWGXSURFqVPDLVODGLUHFWLRQFRPPHGDQVOHIUDQoDLV.()4!-%h2%?!-02%01-2%HWF/D
IRQFWLRQGHODIRUPHjO·LQVWUXPHQWDOTXLH[SULPHOH´FRQWDFWµ HQSDUWLFXOLHUDYHFOHVXMHW HWXQDFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLI
OHFRQWHQXVpPDQWLTXHGHFHGHUQLHUDYDLWWHQGXjVHFRPELQHUjFHOXLGXYHUEHOHVYHUEHV.()4!-%GHYHQDQWGHV
YHUEHV($$!#)"-!2%HWDLQVLGHVXLWH'qVORUVO·DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLIHQGpSHQGDQFHG·XQYHUEHTXLDDEVRUEpODGLUHFWLYLWp
VHWURXYHSDUOjPrPHYLGpGHVRQFRQWHQXHWGHYLHQWGRQFO·REMHWSUHPLHUGHFHYHUEH$SDUWLUGHOjO·DFFXVDWLI
GHO·REMHWSUHPLHUDSXV·pWHQGUHjG·DXWUHVYHUEHVTXLQ·LPSOLTXHQWSDVXQHUHODWLRQGLUHFWLYHHWPrPHFHX[TXL
LPSOLTXHQWODUHODWLRQRSSRVpHFRPPHOHVYHUEHVX1#$$!-L3DUODVXLWHODGLUHFWLYLWpTXLVHPDLQWLHQWHQSDUWLHDX
PRLQVDYHFOHVYHUEHVGHGpSODFHPHQWODWLQ!6%K6>(>2%V·H[SULPHSDUG·DXWUHVPR\HQVGDQVOHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVR
O·DFFXVDWLIHVWSDVVpGHODYDOHXUGLUHFWLYHjODIRQFWLRQG·REMHWGDWLIORFDWLIWRXUSUpSRVLWLRQQHO&·HVWFHTXHM·DL
QRPPpOD´WKpRULHGHVGHX[PRGqOHVµ&HWWHWKpRULHSHUPHWpJDOHPHQWGHUHQGUHFRPSWHGXIDLWTX·XQPrPH
YHUEHSXLVVHSUpVHQWHUGHX[VHQVpWURLWHPHQWOLpVHQWUHHX[SDUOHUpIpUHQWPDLVGRQWODFRQVWUXFWLRQVRQWGLIIp
UHQWHVXQYHUEH.()4!-l($$!#)"-!2%FRPPHOHYHUEHɘඥड़ड़͘ԅဎ%TXLVHUDSSRUWHGDQVVHVGHX[HPSORLVjXQHVLWXDWLRQ
LGHQWLTXHVDQVTX·LOVRLWSRVVLEOHGHSDVVHUGHO·REMHWODQFpjO·REMHWDWWHLQWRXLQYHUVHPHQWɘඥड़ड़͘ԅဎड़ԅ ۟ੜ ‫ڗ‬ဎ´ODQ
FHUXQHSLHUUHµQHSHXWSDVV·LQWHUSUpWHUjSDUWLUG·XQDFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLI&·HVWDLQVLSDUH[HPSOHTXHO·DUPpQLHQ
NH‫´ן‬SODLHµSHXWrWUHO·pTXLYDOHQWGXJUHFɘๆड़‫´ߥڗ‬WUDLWµFRPPHO·DPRQWUpUpFHPPHQW&KDUOHVGH/DPEHUWHULH
I O·XQHWO·DXWUHUHSRVHQWVXUj59U.O_M!W60M2%PDLVOHSUHPLHUVHUDWWDFKHDXVHQVGH´DWWHLQGUHEOHVVHUµ
OHVHFRQGDXVHQVGH´ODQFHUµ%,OHQYDGHPrPHSRXUOHVYHUEHVTXLVLJQLILHQWjODIRLV´DWWHLQGUHµHW´SRUWHUµ
FRPPHGHX[GHVWURLVUDFLQHV)(0M%GXYLHLODYHVWLTXH .HOOHQVHW3LUDUW GH%jO_QH֟HWELHQG·DXWUHV0DLV
RQGRLWDGPHWWUHTXHV\QWD[HFDVXHOOHHWVpPDQWLTXHOH[LFDOHVRQWPXWXHOOHPHQWSHUPpDEOHVFRPPHLOUHVVRUW
GHVHPSORLVGDQVOHVTXHOVXQUpJLPHGDWLIWUDQVIRUPHXQYHUEH´GLUHµHQ´GLUHGHRUGRQQHUµHQV·LQWpJUDQWj
VRQFRQWHQXVpPDQWLTXH +DXGU\EI 6LHOOHVVRQWFRQVLGpUpHVFRPPHpWDQFKHVLOIDXWFKHUFKHUG·DXWUHV
pW\PRORJLHVSRXUFKDFXQHGHVUDFLQHVFRQFHUQpHVFRPPHOHUHJURXSHPHQWGHVIRUPHVVLJQLILDQW´DWWHLQGUHµ
VRXVXQHUDFLQHjOnQH֟´HUUHLFKHQµ .PPHOFKH]5L[HWDO GLVWLQFWHGHODUDFLQHjO_QH֟´HUKDOWHQ
QHKPHQµ .PPHOFKH]5L[HWDO 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8BZ78%8*%QT,N\*/,B%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%/BH,M8\K,@Q8Bg%e\87*/,B7%8*%OY@,*OZ787% OQR

`;N;'2@O?ADLE'H<'K?'MLE>ADLE'LF'@<ELFP<KK<J<EA'H<'=LE'<GC@<==DLE\
,OQ·HVWFHUWHVSDVH[FOXTXHODIRQFWLRQREMHWVRLWDQFLHQQHHQLQGRHXURSpHQ6LSDUH[HPSOHOHVSUpVHQWV
LQIL[pVUHSUpVHQWHQWXQH´FRQMXJDLVRQREMHFWLYHµGDQVODTXHOOHO·LQIL[HQDVDOHVWXQLQGLFHG·REMHWOHSDVVDJH
GHO·DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLIDXFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWFRQVWLWXHXQVLPSOHUHQRXYHOOHPHQWIRUPHODQDORJXHjFHOXLTXLD
DIIHFWpXQHSDUWLHGHOD5RPDQLDRFFLGHQWDOHQRWDPPHQWODSpQLQVXOHLEpULTXHRO·DFFXVDWLIG·REMHWDpWpUHP
SODFpSDUXQHFRQVWUXFWLRQGLUHFWLYHGHO·DFFXVDWLISUpFpGpGHODSUpSRVLWLRQ("0DLVOHSDUDOOqOHDYHFOHVIDLWV
PHQWLRQQpVFLGHVVXVHVWGHSXUHDSSDUHQFH/HUHQRXYHOOHPHQWGHO·H[SUHVVLRQTXLFRQGXLWGXODWLQ:#.#10%(>($%
I($-!>%011>%jO·HVSDJQRO!.%+#c6%(>(%(%01%I("-!2%VHORQXQFRQGLWLRQQHPHQWFRPSOH[H 3RWWLHU %Q·DIIHFWHHQ
ULHQOHVHQVGXYHUEHDORUVTXHO·LQWpJUDWLRQGHODYDOHXUGLUHFWLYHDXVHQVGXYHUEHUpJLVVDQWWUDQVIRUPHFRPPH
RQO·DYXXQYHUEH´ODQFHUµHQXQYHUEH´DWWHLQGUHµ'DQVFHVFRQGLWLRQVODFRQFXUUHQFHHQWUHLQVWUXPHQWDOHW
DFFXVDWLISHXWDYRLUpWpjO·RULJLQHGHODIRQFWLRQREMHW2QSHXWHQYLVDJHUXQpWDWGHODQJXHDQDORJXHjFHOXLGX
YRJXO YRLUO·DUWLFOHGH-HDQ3HUURWGDQVFHPrPHYROXPH RFHTXLVHPEOHWHQLUOLHXG·REMHWHVWXQ´SRVVpGpµ

`;Q;'-E<'HDMMD>FKAO'DJC@OPF<7'K?'JLWDKDAO'H<='P?K<F@='KL>?K<=
/DWKpRULHHVWFRQIURQWpHDXSUREOqPHGHO·KRPRSKRQLHHQWUHODGpVLQHQFHGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOHWFHOXLGXGLUHF
K8G2%jM !W6 O_% FLGHVVXV††HW VLFRPPHLOHVWSRVVLEOHO·KRPRSKRQLHUpYqOHXQHLGHQWLWpRULJLQHOOH *DUFtD
5DPyQ HWVLGRQFO·LQVWUXPHQWDOHVWSURFKHGXGLUHFWLIO·pFDUWVpPDQWLTXHHQWUHOHVGHX[FDVGXPRGqOH
VHUpGXLWFRQVLGpUDEOHPHQW0DLVXQHpYROXWLRQDQFLHQQHGHODYDOHXUGLUHFWLYHjFHOOHGHSUR[LPLWpFRPPH
=FL7%>J%>6K8H%("%GDQV("%1-&!>%!00!%´rWUHSUqVGHODYLOOHµHVWFRQFHYDEOHO·H[SUHVVLRQGHO·REMHWHQFRQWDFWSHXW
GRQFDYRLUpWpDVVXPpHSDUXQDQFLHQGLUHFWLI$YDQWGHGHYHQLUVXFFHVVLYHPHQWO·XQHWO·DXWUHOHFDVGHO·REMHWOH
GLUHFWLILQVWUXPHQWDOHWO·DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLIRQWGRQFFRQQXGHVpYROXWLRQVSDUDOOqOHVPDLVGpFDOpHVGDQVOHWHPSV
3DUOjV·H[SOLTXHOHXUFRPPXQHYDOHXUSHUODWLYH¬O·DFFXVDWLIG·H[WHQVLRQVSDWLDOHODWLQ:600(%$-!0%I!"!0%(.$(%´IRVVp
GHWURLVSLHGVGHSURIRQGHXUµHWWHPSRUHOODWLQ-!5)(?#$%$-!0%())60%´LODUpJQpWURLVDQVµUpSRQGjO·LQVWUXPHQWDO
SHUODWLI/·XQHWO·DXWUHSHXYHQWSURYHQLUG·XQHDQFLHQQHYDOHXUGLUHFWLYHODWLQ("%X16"(>%$!>I10%´SRXUXQFHU
WDLQWHPSVµ8QSUREOqPHVLPLODLUHVLJQDOpFLGHVVXV††HWDIIHFWHOHVLQYDULDQWVIRUPpVVXUODSDUWLFXOH
GpLFWLTXHj"!2%j"#2%TXLV·DMRXWHjGHVWKqPHVSURQRPLQDX[ JUHF཰˗͘YLHLOLUODQGDLV0#)M" %HWTXLHQFRQVWLWXHXQHQ
LUDQLHQDQFLHQLOVSUpVHQWHQWGHX[YDOHXUVRSSRVpHVO·XQHGLUHFWLYHJUHF‫ڗ‬໕໵ཬဎ˗͘DYHVWLTXHUpFHQWYD̒VP̾QGD
´YHUVODPDLVRQµJUHF༜ࢆๆࠗ͘‫ڗݰ‬ဎ˗ङટ ´YHUVFKH]QRXVµO·DXWUHDEODWLYH G̒ ODWLQG̒2%YLHLOLUODQGDLVGҸ %j"!% JDXORLV
˗͘ YDOHXUTXLVHUHWURXYHGDQVOHjM"%GHO·DEODWLIVLQJXOLHUGHODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXH&HVYDOHXUVRSSRVpHVQHVRQW
SDVLQFRQFLOLDEOHVLVVXVG·XQHIRUPDWLRQjYDOHXUH[WUDFWLYH FLGHVVXV† OHVDGYHUEHVODWLQVHQM$10%FHK%=789%
XQHYDOHXUGLUHFWLYH:1)"#$10%´MXVTX·DXIRQGµUčGҸFLWXV´MXVTX·DX[UDFLQHVµHWODFRQVWUXFWLRQDXJpQLWLI DQFLHQ
DEODWLI GHVYHUEHVJUHFVVLJQLILDQW´WHQGUHYHUVXQFRQWDFWµV·H[SOLTXHGHODPrPHIDoRQ/·pYROXWLRQSDUDGR[DOH
GHVIRUPHVTXLH[SULPHQWGHVUHODWLRQVORFDOHVHVWXQHFRQVWDQWHLVVXGH G̒G̒LQWXV2%O·DGYHUEHIUDQoDLV"!"()0%
DXUDLWGHX[RXWURLVERQQHVUDLVRQV G̒´YHQDQWGHVFHQGDQWGHµ%HWOHVXIIL[HH[WUDFWLIM$10 %GHVLJQLILHU´GHKRUVµ
&·HVWSRXUTXRLOHVIRUPHVTXLSRUWHQWFHVYDOHXUVQHGRLYHQWMDPDLVrWUHWUDLWpHVLQGpSHQGDPPHQWGHOHXUVOLDLVRQV
V\QWDJPDWLTXHVHWSDUDGLJPDWLTXHV

!;',<'>?='HF'=Fb<A

!;:;',<='>?='HD@<>A='H<='?EDJO='<A'H<='DE?EDJO=
/DGRQQpHGHEDVHSHUPDQHQWHPLVHHQpYLGHQFHSDU8KOHQEHFN  HVWOHIDLWTX·DXVLQJXOLHUHWDXSOXULHO
OHVLJQLILDQWGXQRPLQDWLIGLIIqUHGHFHOXLGHO·DFFXVDWLIGDQVOHVDQLPpV PDVFXOLQVHWIpPLQLQSRXUOHVODQJXHV
TXLRQWXQIpPLQLQ HWV·LGHQWLILHjOXLGDQVOHVQHXWUHV&HWWHUpSDUWLWLRQVXJJqUHTXHO·LQGRHXURSpHQRSpUDLWXQH
GLVWLQFWLRQHQWUHGHX[W\SHVGHVXMHWRXSOXW{WGHSUHPLHUDFWDQW RXG·DFWDQWXQLTXH VHORQTXHFHOXLFLH[HUoDLW
RXQRQVRQFRQWU{OHVXUOHSURFqVFRPPHOHUDSSHOOHDSUqVG·DXWUHV0DUWLQHW  ´2QDGHSXLVORQJ
WHPSVHQYLVDJpSRXUOHVVWDGHVWUqVDQFLHQVGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQXQHFRQVWUXFWLRQHUJDWLYHF·HVWjGLUHO·HPSORL
G·XQHPDUTXHSRVLWLYHSRXUGpVLJQHUO·DJHQWORUVTX·LOILJXUHGDQVOHPrPHFRQWH[WHTX·XQSDWLHQWDORUVTXHFH
GHUQLHUDSSDUDvWVDQVDXFXQHLQGLFDWLRQGHIRQFWLRQQLGpVLQHQFHQLSDUWLFXOHµ6LO·RQQHSUHQGSDVHQFRPSWH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% P8<B%O<\HKY

ODFKURQRORJLHFHWWHK\SRWKqVHVHKHXUWHDXIDLWTXHO·LQGRHXURSpHQUHFRQVWUXLWQHSUpVHQWHSDVOHVFDUDFWqUHV
W\SRORJLTXHVSULQFLSDX[GHVODQJXHVHUJDWLYHVHQSDUWLFXOLHUGDQVOHYHUEH

!;N;',<'>?='<E'"26;&H<='E<FA@<=']DAADA<=
/·K\SRWKqVHGH/DURFKH  TXLSURSRVDLWGHYRLUGDQVOHVGRXEOHWVHQM()$M%GHFHUWDLQVVXEVWDQWLIVQHXWUHV
GXKLWWLWHOHYHVWLJHG·XQHUJDWLILQGRHXURSpHQDpWpUpIXWpHSDU%HQYHQLVWH  TXLDREVHUYpTXHFHVVXEV
WDQWLIVVHFRQIRUPHQWHQWRXWSRLQWjODV\QWD[HGXKLWWLWHTXLQ·HVWSDVXQHODQJXHHUJDWLYHFHTXLHVWLQFRQWHV
WDEOHDXSODQV\QFKURQLTXHPDLVUHFRQQX S TX·LOVGpVLJQHQW´GHVQRWLRQVPDWpULHOOHVWUDQVIpUpHVDXUDQJ
GHSXLVVDQFHVDFWLYHVµFHTXLSRXUO·pWDWDQWpULHXURXYUHODSRUWHjO·K\SRWKqVHG·XQHUJDWLIFRPPHOHIDLWOD
PRUSKRORJLHGHVFDVGLUHFWV&HGpEDWHVWHPEOpPDWLTXHOHVDGYHUVDLUHVGHO·K\SRWKqVHHUJDWLYHVHFRQFHQWUHQW
VXUODV\QFKURQLHRHOOHHVWH[FOXHSDUODVWUXFWXUHGXV\VWqPHYHUEDOHWVHVSDUWLVDQVVHSURMHWWHQWGDQVOD
GLDFKURQLHHQLPDJLQDQWXQV\VWqPHYHUEDOWRXWGLIIpUHQWTX·LOVVRQWHQSHLQHGHUHFRQVWUXLUH4XHOTXHVDQQpHV
SOXVW{W/HZ\ I DYDLWREVHUYpHQJUHFKRPpULTXHXQHLQFRPSDWLELOLWpSDUWLHOOHHQWUHOHVQHXWUHVHQ
M6M%HWODSRVLWLRQGHVXMHWG·XQYHUEHWUDQVLWLIVDQVSURSRVHUG·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGXIDLWQLGHVDOLPLWDWLRQLOLQGL
TXDLWSDUDLOOHXUVTXHPDOJUpVDGpVLJQDWLRQGHJHQUHQHXWUH›࿰ટ‫ݰ‬OHIHXpWDLWFRQVLGpUpFRPPHXQrWUHDQLPp
&RPSDUpHDX[GRQQpHVKLWWLWHVpWXGLpHVSDU/DURFKHFHWWHREVHUYDWLRQHVWVLJQLILFDWLYHLODSSDUDvWTXHO·DFFHVVLRQ
GHVQHXWUHVjODIRQFWLRQVXMHWGHVYHUEHVWUDQVLWLIVHWGRQFODFRQVWLWXWLRQGHODIRQFWLRQVXMHWSURSUHPHQWGLWH
DpWpJUDGXHOOH¬OHVQHXWUHVOHVSOXVDQFLHQV\DXUDLHQWDFFpGpHQSUHPLHU&UDLJ0HOFKHUWSUpFLVHGDQVFHPrPH
YROXPHTXHODVLWXDWLRQKLWWLWHQ·HVWSDVFHOOHG·XQHGpULYDWLRQDERXWLVVDQWDX´WUDQVIHUWG·XQLQDQLPpGDQVOD
FODVVHDQLPpHµVHORQOHVWHUPHVGH/DURFKHPDLVFHOOHGDQVODTXHOOHOHVQHXWUHVFRQVHUYHQWOHXUJHQUHRULJLQHO
DX[FDVREOLTXHVFRPPHLOUHVVRUWG·XQH[HPSOHROHQRPGHO·HDXTXLILJXUHjO·´HUJDWLI µ9!$!)( ) G%J9K%7J=789%
SDUOHSURQRPDQDSKRULTXHQHXWUHM($L%8QHWHOOH´HUJDWLYLWpSDUWLHOOHµ 0I.#$M!-5($#?#$' Q·H[LJHSDVXQV\VWqPH
YHUEDOVHPEODEOHjFHOXLGHVODQJXHVHUJDWLYHVSURSUHPHQWGLWHV

!;Q;',<'ELJ'D@?ED<E'HF'M<F
$XWUHLQGLFHG·HUJDWLYLWp¬OHQRPLUDQLHQGXIHX čWDU2%LQLWLDOHPHQWGHJHQUHQHXWUHSDVVpDXPDVFXOLQTXDQG
LODpWpVXEVWLWXpjj(5)#M2%GRQWLOUHVWHXQHWUDFHGDQVO·RQRPDVWLTXH¬DXQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUXQHGpVLQHQFHjM0%
DpWpDMRXWpHFRQIRUPpPHQWjODUqJOHJpQpUDOHPDLVFRQWUDLUHPHQWjODUqJOHSDUWLFXOLqUHDX[WKqPHVHQjM-M%JK%
jM)MN%XQDQFLHQPDVFXOLQDXUDLWHXODIRUPH čWč,OSHXWFHUWHVV·DJLUG·XQEDQDOSDVVDJHjO·DQLPpG·XQWKpRQ\PH
LVVXG·XQDEVWUDLWFRPPHSRXUT!)102%JK%>J%A#$-(LQGRLUDQLHQPDLVjHQMXJHUSDU$ߖ̾P9pULWp9RKX0DQ‫گ‬%RQQH
3HQVpH9RKX;ߖD۟U̾P%RQ3RXYRLUOHJHQUHQHXWUHQ·pWDLWSDVLQFRPSDWLEOHDYHFOHVWDWXWG·(QWLWpGDQVOHVJkWKkV
&HVIDLWVFRQFRUGDQWVVHPEOHQWVLJQLILFDWLIVPDLVQHSHUPHWWHQWSDVG·DOOHUSOXVORLQTXHO·K\SRWKqVHVXJJpUpH
SDUODPRUSKRORJLHGHVFDVGLUHFWV/HSUREOqPHUHVWHHQWLHU

!;X;',<='=A@F>AF@<='DEA<@JOHD?D@<=
3RXUWHQWHUG·DSSRUWHUXQGpEXWGHVROXWLRQLOIDXWG·DERUGVRUWLUGXGLOHPPH2QVDLWSDUO·pWXGHGH/D]DUG
 TXHODW\SRORJLHGHVVWUXFWXUHVG·DFWDQFHQHVHUpGXLWSDVDXFRQWUDVWHHQWUHODQJXHVHUJDWLYHVHWODQJXHV
DFFXVDWLYHV%LOH[LVWHGHVVWUXFWXUHV´QHXWUHVµROHVGHX[DFWDQWVGHODSKUDVHELDFWDQFLHOOHVRQWWUDLWpVFRPPH
O·DFWDQWXQLTXHGHODSKUDVHPRQRDFWDQFLHOOHGHVVWUXFWXUHV´PL[WHVµGDQVOHVTXHOOHVFKDFXQSRVVqGHXQHSDUWLH
GHVSURSULpWpVGHO·DFWDQWXQLTXHHWGHVVWUXFWXUHV´GLVMRLQWHVµRDXFXQGHVGHX[Q·DULHQGHFRPPXQDYHFOXL
'·DXWUHSDUWFRPPHF·HVWOHFDVGDQVOHVODQJXHVLUDQLHQQHVODVWUXFWXUHG·DFWDQFHHVWDFFXVDWLYHDXSUpVHQW
HUJDWLYHDXSUpWpULWHWSOXVLHXUVODQJXHVLUDQLHQQHVDFWXHOOHVVRQWUHYHQXHVSDUGLYHUVHVYRLHVjODVWUXFWXUH
DFFXVDWLYHSRXUOHSUpWpULW

!;Y;',<='>?='<E'>LE>F@@<E><'CLF@'KS<GC@<==DLE'HF'=Fb<A
,OIDXWGRQFUHSUHQGUHODTXHVWLRQjODEDVHHWVDQV(%I-#6-#L%2QFRQVWDWHWRXWG·DERUGTXHSOXVLHXUVFDVVHVRQW
WURXYpVHQFRPSpWLWLRQSRXUODSRVLWLRQGHSUHPLHUDFWDQW ODIXWXUHIRQFWLRQGHVXMHWLQGLIIpUHQFLp FRPPHSRXU
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8BZ78%8*%QT,N\*/,B%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%/BH,M8\K,@Q8Bg%e\87*/,B7%8*%OY@,*OZ787% OQ@

FHOOHG·REMHWSUHPLHUO·DFFXVDWLIGDQVOHVWRXUVFRPPHOHODWLQ>!%I(!)#$!$%´MHPHUHSHQVGHµHWVRQFRUUHVSRQGDQW
JRWLTXH=(-;#0$%#)(% FRQVWUXLWpJDOHPHQWDYHFOHJpQLWLI ´LOVHVRXFLHGHµDLQVLTXHOHYpGLTXHNLWDYiؐWDWčSD´OH
MRXHXUDGXUHPRUGVµO·LQVWUXPHQWDOODWLQI.1#$%.(I#"#&10%´LOSOHXWGHVSLHUUHVµ HWVHVFRUUHVSRQGDQWV OHGDWLI
>6K8H%>#+#%?#"!$1-%´LOPHVHPEOHµ!0$%>#+#%´M·DLµ,ODpWpVLJQDOpFLGHVVXV†XQHWHQGDQFHjOHXUUHPSODFHPHQWSDU
OHWRXUSHUVRQQHOFRUUHVSRQGDQWHWOHFDVGHOHXUSUHPLHUDFWDQWSDUOHQRPLQDWLI6LFHWWHWHQGDQFHDFRQFHUQpXQ
JUDQGQRPEUHGHW\SHVG·pQRQFpVHWSDVVHXOHPHQWTXHOTXHVH[SUHVVLRQLVROpHVLOV·HQVXLWTXHO·LQGRHXURSpHQ
Q·DSDVWRXMRXUVpWpXQHODQJXHjVXMHWXQLTXH
/DGRXEOHGpVLJQDWLRQGXIHXHWGHO·HDXpYRTXpHSDU.OLPRY  *DPNUHOLG]HHW,YDQRY YRO 
/HKPDQQ  IRXUQLWpJDOHPHQWXQLQGLFHTXLSDUDvWVLJQLILFDWLI2QUHFRQVWUXLWSRXUFKDFXQHGHFHVGHX[
QRWLRQVGHX[GpVLJQDWLRQVDQFLHQQHVO·XQHQHXWUHjI U On9M-MWM)M%=FL7%>J%GJL2%j9 U "M-MWM)M%SRXUO·HDXHWGHX[
GpVLJQDWLRQVDQLPpHVUHVSHFWLYHPHQWjU5)#M2%PDVFXOLQHWjOn U IM%IpPLQLQIRUPHUHPSODFpHGDQVOHVODQJXHV
RFFLGHQWDOHVSDU DNZčFL%j(=9č2%>6K8H%(X1(2%JHUPDQLTXH DKZ‫گ‬,OV·DJLWGHGHX[QRWLRQVXQLYHUVHOOHVUHSUpVHQ
WpHVO·XQHHWO·DXWUHGDQVOD´OLVWHGHVGHX[FHQWVµGHODOH[LFRVWDWLVWLTXHHWSRXUOHVTXHOOHVRQV·DWWHQGjWURXYHU
XQHGpVLJQDWLRQXQLTXH2UODUDLVRQGHFHWWHGXDOLWpDSSDUDvWFODLUHPHQWSDURSSRVLWLRQjO·HDX´LQDFWLYHµ O·HDX
VWDJQDQWHO·HDXFRQWHQXHGDQVXQUpFLSLHQW j9 U "M-MWM)M2%jOn U IM%JK% DNZčFL%j(=9čGpVLJQHQWO·HDX´DFWLYHµ
F·HVWjGLUHO·HDXFRXUDQWHjHQMXJHUSDUOHYpGLTXHĎSDє´OHVFRXUVG·HDXµOHYLHX[SUXVVLHQ(I!%´UXLVVHDXµOH
>8KL6H8JH%S̜%JK%>J%>JKKFH%1I!%´FRXUVG·HDXµHWG·DXWUHSDUWOHJRWLTXH(+?(%TXLWUDGXLW›‫ࠗڗ‬ǓࢆཬߥHWFOHWRNKDULHQ
$%čSGpVLJQHjODIRLVO·HDXHWOHFRXUVG·HDX%'HODPrPHIDoRQOHIHXDYDLWGHVIRUPHVODWHQWHVIHXGHVHDX[
GHVSODQWHVGHVSLHUUHVHWGLYHUV´IHX[GXFRUSVµFRPPHOHIHXGHODYXHHWMXVTX·jGHV´IHX[IURLGVµFRPPH
>J%I+.!5>!%GHODPpGHFLQHJUHFTXH,OHVWSUREDEOHTXHFHVIHX[ODWHQWVGHYDLHQWrWUHGpVLJQpVSDUOHVXEVWDQWLI
QHXWUHWDQGLVTXHOHVXEVWDQWLIPDVFXOLQGHYDLWV·DSSOLTXHUDXIHXYLVLEOH6LFHVGHX[FRXSOHVGHIRUPHVVRQWOHV
YHVWLJHVG·XQYDVWHHQVHPEOHGHFRXSOHVVLPLODLUHVFHFLRULHQWHYHUVO·K\SRWKqVHG·XQHODQJXH´DFWLYHµDXVHQVGH
O·pWXGHGH.OLPRY  GRQW6FKPLGW  *DPNUHOLG]HHW,YDQRY YROI HW/HKPDQQ  
UHSUHQQHQWOHVFRQFOXVLRQV0DLVHVWFHOHFDV"/HVUDLVRQVLQYRTXpHVFLGHVVXVVXJJqUHQWSOXW{WXQHVLWXDWLRQ
SDUWLFXOLqUH'·DXWUHSDUWLODSSDUDvWLPPpGLDWHPHQWjODOHFWXUHGHFHVpWXGHVTXHODVWUXFWXUHGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQ
UHFRQVWUXLWHVWIRUWpORLJQpHGHFHOOHGHVODQJXHVGHFHW\SHHQSDUWLFXOLHUO·LPSRUWDQFHTX·\WLHQQHQWOHVDGMHFWLIV
QHFRQFRUGHSDVDYHFXQW\SHOLQJXLVWLTXHGDQVOHTXHOODTXDOLWpHVWH[SULPpHSDUGHVYHUEHVLQWUDQVLWLIV)DXWLO
DGPHWWUHDYHF%DXHU I /HKPDQQ I TXHOHVDGMHFWLIVVRQWUpFHQWVHQLQGRHXURSpHQ"&·HVW
SHXSUREDEOHFDUVLOHVDGMHFWLIVSULPDLUHV\VRQWHIIHFWLYHPHQWDVVH]SHXQRPEUHX[HWWHQGHQWjVHUHQRXYHOHULO
H[LVWHGHX[FODVVHVDQFLHQQHVG·DGMHFWLIVOHVDGMHFWLIVG·DSSDUWHQDQFHHWOHVDGMHFWLIVGHSRVVHVVLRQGHX[QRWLRQV
FHQWUDOHVTXLVHUHWURXYHQWjODEDVHGHVYRL[YHUEDOHV +DXGU\DI RHOOHVRQWSOXVG·LPSRUWDQFHTXHOH
FRQWUDVWHHQWUHYHUEHVG·DFWLRQHWYHUEHVG·pWDW/·DGMHFWLIHQYDOHXUGHFRPSOpPHQWFLUFRQVWDQFLHOOHWRXUODWLQ
ҸEDQWREVFࡃUҸ FLGHVVXV† HVWXQHVLQJXODULWpPrPHGDQVOHVODQJXHVTXLXWLOLVHQWODUJHPHQWOHVDGMHFWLIV$XWUH
REMHFWLRQjO·K\SRWKqVHG·XQHODQJXH´DFWLYHµTXLFRPSRUWHQRUPDOHPHQWXQV\VWqPHFDVXHOUpGXLWOHVYHVWLJHV
G·XQHIIHFWLIFDVXHOVXSpULHXUjFHOXLGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQUHFRQVWUXLWGDQVO·pWDWDQWpULHXUGXV\VWqPH FLGHVVXV† 

:a;'*<=ADR<='HS?FA@<='=A@F>AF@<=\
/HVREVHUYDWLRQVIDLWHVVXUO·H[SUHVVLRQGXVXMHWQHSHUPHWWHQWSDVGHUDQJHUGpILQLWLYHPHQWO·LQGRHXURSpHQ
SDUPLOHVODQJXHV´DFWLYHVµQLjSOXVIRUWHUDLVRQG·HQWLUHUDUJXPHQWSRXUODORFDOLVDWLRQGHO·KDELWDWRULJLQHO
FRPPHOHIRQW*DPNUHOLG]HHW,YDQRY(QHIIHWG·DXWUHVGRQQpHVRULHQWHQWYHUVGHVVWUXFWXUHVWRXWHVGLIIpUHQWHV¬
XQHODQJXHjFODVVHV (UKDUW RXXQHODQJXHjFRQVWUXFWLRQVVpULHOOHV +DXGU\D 
/·K\SRWKqVHGHODFODVVLILFDWLRQVHIRQGHVXUODSOXUDOLWpGHVPDUTXHVGXFDVGLUHFWGXVLQJXOLHU (UKDUW
 &HWWHFRQFHSWLRQTXLpFDUWHO·HUJDWLYLWpVHFRQFLOLHDYHFFHOOHTXLDpWpSUpVHQWpHFLGHVVXV†
/·K\SRWKqVHGHFRQVWUXFWLRQVVpULHOOHVSRXUXQpWDWDQWpULHXUGXV\VWqPHP·DpWpVXJJpUpHSDUO·pW\PRORJLH
GXYHUEHJHUPDQLTXHj&-!)5M(M%´DSSRUWHUµGDQVOHTXHORQV·DFFRUGHjUHFRQQDvWUHGHSXLV%UXJPDQQ  
XQDQFLHQFRPSRVpYHUEDOGHj&+!-M%´SRUWHUµHWjO_QH֟´SRUWHUDWWHLQGUHµ VXUFHGRXEOHVHQVYRLUFLGHVVXV† 
GHX[UDFLQHVOLpHVGDQVOHSDUDGLJPHGXYHUEHJUHF‫ݵ‬ๆ‫͘ݰ‬ԅဎRXVHORQG·DXWUHVjOnQH֟´DWWHLQGUHµ,QVROLWHGDQV
OHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVXQHWHOOHFRQVWUXFWLRQHVWFDUDFWpULVWLTXHGHFHUWDLQHVODQJXHVLVRODQWHVFRPPH
OHFKLQRLVRXOHVODQJXHVNZDGHO·$IULTXHRFFLGHQWDOH\RUXEDyJEpHZi´OXLSRUWHUFHODYHQLUµ ´LOO·DSSRUWHµ
/·K\SRWKqVHDQFLHQQHG·XQpWDWLVRODQWGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQDQWpULHXUjO·pWDWDJJOXWLQDQWHWjO·pWDWIOH[LRQQHO
SRXUUDLWGRQFrWUHUHSULVHHQFRQVLGpUDWLRQ&HQ·HVWSDVOHOLHXGHGLVFXWHUGXELHQIRQGpGHFHWWHK\SRWKqVH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% P8<B%O<\HKY

TXLQHFRQFHUQHSDVGLUHFWHPHQWOHV\VWqPHFDVXHOUHFRQVWUXLWQLVDSUpKLVWRLUHLPPpGLDWH6RQUDSSHOQ·DSRXU
EXWTXHG·LOOXVWUHUO·REMHWGXSUpVHQWH[SRVpPRQWUHUTXHODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOLQGRHXURSpHQ
GRLWUHMHWHUO·LGpHSUpFRQoXHG·XQpTXLOLEUHRULJLQHOTXLQHVHVHUDLWURPSXTX·jGDWHUpFHQWH%LHQDXFRQWUDLUH
OHVGRQQpHVUpXQLHVVXJJqUHQWXQV\VWqPHHQpYROXWLRQHWGHVFKDQJHPHQWVEHDXFRXSSOXVSURIRQGVTX·RQQH
O·DGPHWFRPPXQpPHQW%

3W@OPD?ADLE
3/N% 36-I10%/)04-#I$#6)1>%N($#)(-1>²

cDWKDLR@?C]D<
$GUDGRV)UDQFLVFR5
% OP@R% N#)5uÉ0$#4(%#)"6!1-6I!(0DGULG*UHGRV
%DUWKRORPDH&KULVWLDQ
² ´$ZHVWDVSUDFKHXQG$OWSHUVLVFKµ'DQV%D-1)"-#00%"!-%#-()#04+!)%@+#.6.65#!pGLWpSDU:*HLJHUHW
(¬.XKQSS²6WUDVERXUJ.-7UEQHU
% OP?<% <.$#-()#04+!0%J~-$!-&14+5pLPSUHVVLRQ%HUOLQ:DOWHUGH*UX\WHU
%DXHU%ULJLWWH
% :???% <-4+(#4%7')$(]%#)%/)"6M81-6I!()g%*+!%7I-!("%6:%*-()0#$#?#$'%#)%N($#)%()"%F-!)4+7UHQGVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV
6WXGLHVDQG0RQRJUDSKV%HUOLQ0RXWRQGH*UX\WHU
%HHNHV5REHUW63
  *+!%,-#5#)0%6:%$+!%/)"6M81-6I!()%B6>#)(.%/):.!4$#6)%,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW
,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
% OPPR% 36>I(-($#?!%/)"6M81-6I!()%N#)51#0$#40$PVWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
%HQYHQLVWHePLOH
% OPQR% ,-#5#)!0%"!%.(%:6->($#6)%"!0%)6>0%!)%#)"6M!1-6IU!)%3DULV$GULHQ0DLVRQQHXYH
  ´/HVVXEVWDQWLIVHQM()$M%GX+LWWLWHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%²
%ODঈHN9iFODY
% OPPP% B1>!-(.0%%UQR0DVDU\NRYD8QLYHU]LWD
%UXJPDQQ.DUO
  ´+RPHULVFKࢆ͘ဎ‫ڗ‬ԅဎඥङXQGJRWLVFK&-#55()2%]ZHL)lOOHYRQ:XU]HODQJOHLFKXQJµ/)"65!->()#04+!%
F6-04+1)5!)%²
&KDQWUDLQH3LHUUH
% OPQQ% N(%:6->($#6)%"!0%)6>0%!)%5-!4%()4#!)%3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
% OPRQ% D-(>>(#-!%+6>U-#X1!9ROXPH&ROOHFWLRQGH3KLORORJLH&ODVVLTXH3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
3JD7LHHJ72%!>DJ7K%
% OPR<% <.$#)"#04+!%D-(>>($#=2%1F>LMJ%:2%567K%:N%H#!%B6>#)(.01::#]!*|WWLQJHQ9DQGHQKRHFN 5XSUHFKW
(UKDUW$GROI
% OPPQ% H#!%#)"65!->()#04+!%B6>#)(.:.!]#6)%1)"%#+-!%D!)!0!,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW
,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8BZ78%8*%QT,N\*/,B%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%/BH,M8\K,@Q8Bg%e\87*/,B7%8*%OY@,*OZ787% OQP

)ULHGULFK-RKDQQHV
  O!$+#$#04+!0%8.!>!)$(-&14+9ROXPH+HLGHOEHUJ&DUO:LQWHU
*DPNUHOLG]H7KRPDV9HW9MDɥHVODY9,YDQRY
% OPPR% /)"6M81-6I!()%()"%/)"6M81-6I!()0%YROXPHV%HUOLQ0RXWRQ'H*UX\WHU
*DUFtD5DPyQ-RVp/XLV
  ´$GYHUELRVGHGLUHFFLyQHLQVWUXPHQWDOLQGRHXURSHRµ'DQVS!-$+6."%H!.&-u4=%'%.(%0#)$(]#0%#)"6!1-6I!(%
+6'% $FWDVGHOFRORTXLRGHOD,QGRJHUPDQLVFKH*HVHOOVFKDIW0DGULG²GHVHSWLHPEUHGH 
pGLWpSDU(¬&UHVSRHW-/*DUFtD5DPyQSS²0DGULG(GLFLRQHVGHOD8$0
+DXGU\-HDQ
  ´/·LQVWUXPHQWDOHWODVWUXFWXUHGHODSKUDVHVLPSOHHQLQGRHXURSpHQµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0M
$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%²
% OP@@% N;!>I.6#%"!0%4(0%!)%?U"#X1!g%#)$-6"14$#6)%h%.;U$1"!%"!0%4(0%!)%#)"6M!1-6IU!)/HV+RPPHVHWOHV/HWWUHV
/\RQ+HUPqV
  ´/D¶V\QWD[HGHVGpVLQHQFHV·HQLQGRHXURSpHQµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%@RWON%
²
  ´/HVGHX[IOH[LRQVGHO·DGMHFWLIJHUPDQLTXHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0
²
  @-U+#0$6#-!%"!%.(%:.!]#6)%)6>#)(.!%#)"6M!1-6IU!))!%/\RQ,QVWLWXWG·eWXGHV,QGR(XURSpHQQHV
% OPP<6% N;#)"6M!1-6IU!)qPHpG3DULV3UHVVHV8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGH)UDQFH
 E ´'HU8UVSUXQJGHVJHPHLQJHUPDQLVFKHQ,QILQLWLYVXQGGHVZHVWJHUPDQLVFKHQ*HUXQGLXPVµ'DQV
@+#.6.65#04+!%F6-04+1)5!)g%F!0$04+-#:$%:u-%@+#.#II!%A(-4XpGLWpSDU<%'HVSRUWHVSS²*HUPDQLVFKH
%LEOLRWKHNQ)8QWHUVXFKXQJHQ+HLGHOEHUJ&DUO:LQWHU
 D ´9HVWLJHVGHFRQVWUXFWLRQVVpULHOOHVHQLQGRHXURSpHQ"µ<4$!0%"1%iT/!%46)5-E0%#)$!-)($#6)(.%"!0%.#)M
51#0$!02%@(-#02%npqns%c1#..!$%_ááopGLWpSDU%&DURQ&'520
 E ´/HVHQVGHO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHµ'DQVAU.()5!0%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%6::!-$0%h%P(4X1!0%D61"!$pGLWpSDU
%+RULRWHW-+DXGU\SS²/\RQ&HQWUHG·eWXGHV/LQJXLVWLTXHV-DFTXHV*RXGHW
  ´&RPSWHUHQGXGH-RKQ+HZVRQHW9LW%XEHQLNµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%
²
+HZVRQ%-RKQHW9LW%XEHQLN
 % F-6>%3(0!%$6%<"I60#$#6)g%*+!%H!?!.6I>!)$%6:%36):#51-($#6)(.%7')$(]%#)%/)"6M81-6I!()%N()51(5!0&XUUHQW
,VVXHVLQ/LQJXLVWLF7KHRU\$PVWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
(87K2%(J7M6HH%
% OP:O;Q@% /)"65!->()#04+!%D-(>>($#=YROXPHV+HLGHOEHUJ&DUO:LQWHU
.HOOHQV-HDQHWeULF3LUDUW
 ² N!0%$!]$!0%?#!#.M(?!0$#X1!0YROXPHV:LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW
.LUN*HRIIUH\6WHSKHQ
  *+!%/.#("g%<%36>>!)$(-'2%1F>LMJ%ON%S66=0%_qâ&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
.OLPRY*$
  ´2QWKH&KDUDFWHURI/DQJXDJHVRI$FWLYH7\SRORJ\µN#)51#0$#40%²
.XKQ$GDOEHUW
  ´8HEHUGDVDOWH6XQGHLQLJHGDPLWYHUEXQGHQH/DXWHQWZLFNOXQJHQµt!#$04+-#:$%:u-%T!-5.!#4+!)"!%
7I-(4+:6-04+1)5%²
/DPEHUWHULH&KDUOHVGH
% OPP?% /HVDGMHFWLIVJUHFVHQ࿰ߥVpPDQWLTXHHWFRPSDUDLVRQ%LEOLRWKqTXHGHV&DKLHUVGH/LQJXLVWLTXHGH/RX
YDLQ²/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
 oi.uchicago.edu

O<?% P8<B%O<\HKY

  ´/HYHUEHDUPpQLHQ1)#>l=(.('µ%36H9%/)"65!->()#4(g%F!0$04+-#:$%D!-$%b.#)5!)04+>#$$pGLWpSDU*%6FK
ZHLJHUSS²7DLPHULQJ6FKZHLJHUW9:79HUODJ
/DURFKH(PPDQXHO
  ´8Q¶HUJDWLI ·HQLQGRHXURSpHQG·$VLH0LQHXUHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%R@WON%
²
  ´eWXGHVGHOLQJXLVWLTXHDQDWROLHQQH,,,OHGLUHFWLIµK!?1!%+#$$#$!%!$%(0#()#X1!%²¬
/D]DUG*LOEHUW
  ´eOpPHQWVG·XQHW\SRORJLHGHVVWUXFWXUHVG·DFWDQFHVWUXFWXUHVHUJDWLYHVDFFXVDWLYHVHWDXWUHVµ
S1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%²
/HKPDQQ:LQIUHG3
% OPPR% K!0#"1!0%6:%@-!M/)"6M81-6I!()%<4$#?!%7$-14$1-!%()"%*+!#-%/>I.#4($#6)0%:6-%$+!%K!.($#6)0+#I0%(>6)5%$+!%H#(M
.!4$0,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW
GHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
% :??:% @-!M/)"6M81-6I!()2%:DVKLQJWRQ'&,QVWLWXWHIRUWKH6WXG\RI0DQ
/HZ\(UQVW
  ´/HVHIUFKWHµ'DQV7I-(4+5!04+#4+$!%1)"%J6-$&!"!1$1)5g%F!0$04+-#:$%<.&!-$%H!&-1))!-2%5!9#">!$%?6)%
74+u.!-)2%F-!1)"!)%1)"%b6..!5!)SS²%HUQH)UDQFNH
0DUWLQHW$QGUp
  'HVVWHSSHVDX[RFpDQVO·LQGRHXURSpHQHWOHV´,QGRHXURSpHQVµ3DULV3D\RW
0DXUDFK*UHJRU
% OPPR% N($!#)#04+!%H#4+$!-0I-(4+!%'DUPVWDGW:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH%XFKJHVHOOVFKDIW
0D\UKRIHU0DQIUHG
² 8$'>6.65#04+!0%J~-$!-&14+%"!0%<.$#)"6(-#04+!)YROXPHV+HLGHOEHUJ&:LQWHU
0HLHU%UJJHU0LFKDHO
% :??:% /)"65!->()#04+!%7I-(4+9#00!)04+(:$%%HUOLQ:DOWHUGH*UX\WHU
3RWWLHU%HUQDUG
  ´/·HPSORLGHODSUpSRVLWLRQ(%GHYDQWO·REMHWHQHVSDJQROµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%
²
,JHFL2%-FL89%
% OPR:% D-(>>(#-!%"!%.(%.()51!%?U"#X1!%/\RQ,$&
% OPR@% /)$-6"14$#6)%5U)U-(.!%h%P(46&%J(4=!-)(5!.2%<.$#)"#04+!%D-(>>($#=%*|WWLQJHQ9DQGHQKRHFN 5XSUHFKW
  eWXGHVYpGLTXHVHWSč‫ؾ‬LQpHQQHV2%1F>LMJ%3DULV(GH%RFFDUG
5LVFK(UQVW
  ´'HUKRPHULVFKH7\SXVԅਗ››ཬࠗǓ1ๆۭࠗङ‫ݰ‬XQGࢆٗࠗԅ ͘ੜ ࠗǓ=͘࿱ߥµ'DQV7I-(4+5!04+#4+$!%1)"%J6-$&!"!1$1)5g%
F!0$04+-#:$%<.&!-$%H!&-1))!-2%5!9#">!$%?6)%74+u.!-)2%F-!1)"!)%1)"%b6..!5!)pGLWpSDU*5HGDUGSS
²%%HUQH)UDQFNH
5L[+HOPXW
% OPP:% O#0$6-#04+!%D-(>>($#=%"!0%D-#!4+#04+!)qPHpG%'DUPVWDGW:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH%XFKJHVHOOVFKDIW
5L[+HOPXWHWDO
% :??O% N!]#=6)%"!-%#)"65!->()#04+!)%T!-&!)%:LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW
5RWK5XGROIYRQ
  ´8HEHUJHZLVVH.U]XQJHQGHV:RUWHQGHVLP9HGDµ'DQVT!-+()".1)5!)%"!0%T//L%/)$!-)($#6)(.!)%
,-#!)$(.#0$!)M36)5-!00!02%1F>LMJ%:N%<-#04+!%7!4$#6)SS²9LHQQH$OIUHG+ROGHU
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8BZ78%8*%QT,N\*/,B%H\%7Y7*ZA8%3<7\8N%/BH,M8\K,@Q8Bg%e\87*/,B7%8*%OY@,*OZ787% O<O

6FKPDOVWLHJ:LOOLDP5
  /)"6M81-6I!()%N#)51#0$#40%8QLYHUVLW\3DUN3HQQV\OYDQLD6WDWH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
6FKPLGW.DUO+RUVW
  ´=XU7\SRORJLHGHV9RULQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQµ'DQVN#)51#0$#4%K!46)0$-14$#6)%()"%/)"6M81-6I!()%7')$(]2%
pGLWpSDU35DPDWHWDOSS²$PVWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
6FKPLWW5GLJHU
  D-(>>($#=%"!0%b.(00#04+M(->!)#04+!)%,QQVEUXFN,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW
6KLHOGV.HQQHWK
  /)"6M81-6I!()%B61)M#):.!4$#6)8QLYHUVLW\3DUN3HQQV\OYDQLD6WDWH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
6ROPVHQ)HOL[HW(UQVW)UDHQNHO
% OP::% /)"65!->()#04+!%8#5!))(>!)%(.0%7I#!5!.%"!-%b1.$1-5!04+#4+$!%+HLGHOEHUJ&DUO:LQWHU
6WHJOLFK:LOKHOP
  ´hEHUGLH(UVSDUXQJYRQ)OH[LRQVXQG%LOGXQJVVLOEHQEHLFRSXODWLYHQ9HUELQGXQJHQµ%t!#$04+-#:$%:u-%
"!1$04+!%J6-$:6-04+1)5²
6]HPHUpQ\L2VZDOG
% OPP?% 8#):u+-1)5%#)%"#!%?!-5.!#4+!)"!%7I-(4+9#00!)04+(:$%'DUPVWDGW:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH%XFKJHVHOOVFKDIW
8KOHQEHFN&&
  ´$JHQVXQG3DWLHQVLP.DVXVV\VWHPGHULQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ6SUDFKHQµ/)"65!->()#04+!%F6-04+1)5!)%
²
9LOODU/LHEDQD)UDQFLVFR
% OP@<% ,-#5!)%"!%.(%:.!]#ç)%)6>#)(.%#)"6!1-6I!(0DGULG,QVWLWXWR´$QWRQLRGH1HEULMDµ
9HQWULV0LFKDHOHW&KDGZLFN-RKQ
% OP@Q% H641>!)$0%#)%A'4!)(!()%D-!!=qPHpG%&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
:DFNHUQDJHO-DFREHW$OEHUW'HEUXQQHU
 ² <.$#)"#04+!%D-(>>($#=%*|WWLQJHQ9DQGHQKRHFN 5XSUHFKW
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <NN<*/T8%/B%/BH,M8\K,@8<B% O<Q

!"
#$$#%&'()&*)&*+,-(./,0(#*

F6.=!%P60!I+06)2%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%D6$+!)&1-5

,QDV\VWHPRIFRQFUHWHFDVHVWKHIXQGDPHQWDOVSDWLDORSSRVLWLRQLVZKHUHZKHQFHZKLWKHUZKLFKZD\$F
FRUGLQJWRWKHDQDO\VLVRI,QGR(XURSHDQFDVHVLQ.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]WKHUROHRIJRDOZLWKYHUEVRIPRYHPHQWLV
ILOOHGE\WKHDFFXVDWLYHRIGLUHFWLRQZKLFKLVDPDUJLQDOUROHRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVH7KLVXVHRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHLV
UHFHVVLYHLQ*UHHNDQGPDUJLQDOLQ/DWLQ,QFODVVLFDO/DWLQLWLVXVHGRQO\ZLWKSODFHQDPHV6\QFUHWLVPPD\EH
H[SHFWHGWRRFFXUEHWZHHQWKHDFFXVDWLYHRIJRDODQGWKHORFDWLYH'DWLYHLVFRQVLGHUHGWREHDVXEVSHFLHVRIORFD
WLYH$OODWLYHFDVHLVQRWPHQWLRQHGE\.XU\‫ן‬RZLF],QKLVDQDO\VLVWKHIRXUWKPHPEHURIWKHVSDWLDORSSRVLWLRQ
´ZKLFKZD\µLVH[SUHVVHGLQ,QGR(XURSHDQE\WKHLQVWUXPHQWDORIWUDYHUVHGVSDFH
,Q*UHHNZKHUHWKHJHQLWLYHFDUULHVWKHDEODWLYHYDOXHDQGWKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVHKDVDOODWLYHIXQFWLRQZKHUH
ZKHQFHZKLWKHULVH[SUHVVHGE\GDWLYHJHQLWLYHDFFXVDWLYH,Q+RPHUDOOWKRVHWKUHHFDVHVRFFXUZLWKSUHSRVL
WLRQVVXFKDVSDUiDQGPHWi VHH/XUDJKL² 7KHJRDOH[SUHVVHGE\WKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVHFDQEHDSHUVRQ
69%8H%/.#("%
7KHUHDUHODQJXDJHVWKDWPDUNUHFLSLHQWLQWKHVDPHZD\DVDOODWLYH VHHYDQ/DQJHQGRQFNDQG
1HZPDQI :KHQWUDQVIHULVLQWHQGHGWKHRWKHUZLVHFRPSHWLQJUROHVDUHXQLWHGLQWKHUROHRIUHFLSLHQW
7KH/DWLQH[SUHVVLRQ(.#41#%(1]#.#6%!00!%VKRZVWZRGDWLYHVZLWKWKHUHVSHFWLYHUROHVRIEHQHILFLDU\DQGDEVWUDFWJRDO
VHHYDQ/DQJHQGRQFN 7KH/DWLQGDWLYHFDVHFDQDOVRUHIHUWRDFRQFUHWHJRDO,Q#$%4.(>6-%4(!.62%WKH
GDWLYHUHIHUVWRDFRQFUHWHQRQKXPDQJRDODQGLQ(.#41#%(1]#.#6%!00!2%WKHGDWLYH(1]#.#6%UHIHUVWRDQDEVWUDFWQRQ
KXPDQJRDO7KHVHIRUPVKDYHDOODWLYHIXQFWLRQDQGFDQEHGLVWLQJXLVKHGIURPWKRVHGDWLYHVWKDWKDYHDKXPDQ
HQGSRLQWUROHIRUZKLFKWKHDQDO\VLVLVPRUHFRPSOLFDWHGDVWKHSHUVRQLQYROYHGFDQKDYHVHYHUDOVXEUROHV,QWKH
FDVHRIDQLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVXFKDV 6& ?!)#-!WKHGDWLYHRI!#%6&?!)#$%KDVORFDWLYHIXQFWLRQEHFDXVHRIWKHPHDQ
LQJRIWKHYHUE VHHYDQ/DQJHQGRQFN 'DWLYHVWDQGVIRUKXPDQWDUJHWKXPDQHQGSRLQWEHQHILFLDU\
H[SHULHQFHUSRVVHVVRUJRDODVDW\SLFDOO\LQDQLPDWHDWWUDFWRUDQGDFRPELQDWLRQRIWKHODWWHUWZRUROHVZKHQ
WKHSHUVRQLQYROYHGLVDFWLQJDVDJRDO7KHGDWLYHFDVHWKXVH[SUHVVHVDFRPELQDWLRQRI´JRDOµDQGDKXPDQUROH
7KHSURWRW\SLFDOGDWLYHUROHFRQILJXUDWLRQLVJRDOSRVVHVVRUQDPHO\WKHUHFLSLHQWRIWKH"($#?10%"()"#L%7KHUH
FDQDOVREHDFRPELQDWLRQRIWKHVXEUROHVRIH[SHULHQFHUDQGDJHQWLQWKHFDVHRIIRUPVUHODWHGWRWKHSDVVLYHDV
8H%:(4#!)"1>%!0$%>#+#%#..1" VHHDOVR0HOLVII 
$WUDFHRIDQLQKHULWHGFRPELQDWLRQRIDOODWLYHIRUPDQGIXQFWLRQLVIRXQGLQSURQRPLQDOIRUPVVXFKDV/DWLQ
X16%DQG!6L%
,QDODQJXDJHOLNH)LQQLVKWKHUHFLSLHQWUROHLVH[SUHVVHGE\WKHDOODWLYHFDVH´WRVRPHWKLQJµ´RQWRVRPH
WKLQJµZKLFKLVRSSRVHGWRWKHLOODWLYHFDVH´PRYHPHQWLQWRµ VHH1HZPDQ² 6LPLODUO\WKH(QJOLVK
=7J=F98K8FH%$6KDVDFRPELQHGDOODWLYH SDWKOHDGLQJWRDJRDODVWKHODQGPDUN DQGUHFLSLHQWIXQFWLRQ1HZPDQ
 GLVFXVVHVWKHSRO\VHP\RIUHFLSLHQWPDUNLQJDQGDOODWLYHORFDWLYHLQWKHFDVHRIWKH5XVVLDQGDWLYH([
FHSWIRUWKHFLWHGUHPDUNVE\1HZPDQDOODWLYHLVQRWGLVFXVVHGDQ\ZKHUHLQWKHWZRYROXPHVRI*+!%H($#?!%HGLWHG
E\YDQ/DQJHQGRQFNDQGYDQ%HOOH  
,Q,QGR(XURSHDQOLQJXLVWLFVDOODWLYHIXQFWLRQKDVPDLQO\EHHQGLVFXVVHGLQ+LWWLWHDQG7RFKDULDQVWXGLHV
EHFDXVHERWKODQJXDJHVKDYHDQDOODWLYHFDVHWKRXJKRIGLIIHUHQWRULJLQDQGZLWKUDWKHUGLIIHUHQWVHPDQWLFVLQ
WKHWZRODQJXDJHV2WKHUWHUPVKDYHEHHQXVHGLQHDUOLHUUHVHDUFKIRUWKHFDVHVWKDWDUHQRZDGD\VEHLQJFDOOHG
´DOODWLYHµLQ+LWWLWHDQG7RFKDULDQ´7HUPLQDWLYHµDQGRWKHUWHUPVKDYHEHHQXVHGIRUWKH+LWWLWHDOODWLYHDQG
´GDWLYHµIRUWKH7RFKDULDQDOODWLYH
:DDQGHUVLQKLVVWXG\RI*UHHNH[SUHVVLRQVRISHUODWLYHIXQFWLRQ  XVHVWKHWHUP´GLUHFWLRQDOµUDWKHU
WKDQ´DOODWLYHµZKLFKKHFRQVLGHUVWREHDVXEFDWHJRU\RIGLUHFWLRQDO)RUWKHVDPHUHDVRQKHXVHVWKHWHUP
´VHSDUDWLYHµUDWKHUWKDQ´DEODWLYHµ

O<Q
 oi.uchicago.edu

O<<% F,Nb8%P,78@O7,B

7RFKDULDQKDVDSHUODWLYHFDVHZKLFKFDQKDYHDOODWLYHDQGDGHVVLYHIXQFWLRQDQGWKHORFDWLYHFDVHKDVLO
ODWLYHDVZHOODVLQHVVLYHIXQFWLRQ7KH7RFKDULDQDOODWLYHFDVHLVGLUHFWLRQDOEXWQRWWHUPLQDWLYH7KHFRPPRQ
7RFKDULDQREOLTXHDQGDOODWLYHFDVHVZHUHERWKGLUHFWLRQDO7KHSHUODWLYHFDVHZKLFKZDVDNLQHWLFH[WHQVLRQDO
KDGDOODWLYHDVZHOODVDGHVVLYHPHDQLQJ7KHORFDWLYHFDVHFRXOGEHXVHGZLWKWHUPLQDWLYHDQGLOODWLYHPHDQLQJ
VHH-RVHSKVRQDQG&DUOLQJ 
2OG+LWWLWHLVWKHRQO\,QGR(XURSHDQODQJXDJHWRSRVVHVVGDWLYHDOODWLYHDQGORFDWLYHDVVHSDUDWHFDVHV7KH
DOODWLYHIRUPEHFDPHYHVWLJLDOLQ0LGGOHDQG/DWH+LWWLWHDQGZDVUHSODFHGE\WKHORFDWLYH$VHWRIGLUHFWLYHORFDO
DGYHUEVNHSWWKHLUDOODWLYHIRUPEXWWKHGLIIHUHQFHLQPHDQLQJDPRQJVHYHUDORIWKRVHDGYHUEVDQGWKHFRUUH
VSRQGLQJORFDWLYHVHWRIDGYHUEVSUHYHUEVJUDGXDOO\EHFDPHXQFHUWDLQRUHIIDFHG VHH6DOLVEXU\ 7KHGDWLYH
FDVHIRUPZDVUHSODFHGE\WKHORFDWLYH7KHGDWLYHORFDWLYHWKHUHIRUHRIWHQKDVWKHGDWLYHPHDQLQJRIUHFLSLHQW
DPHDQLQJWKDWLVUHODWHGWRDQDOODWLYHVXEPHDQLQJ VHH%ODQVLWW 
,QDQDQDO\VLVRIWKHPHDQLQJRI+LWWLWHORFDOFDVHVDQDGGLWLRQDOIDFWRUKDVWREHWDNHQLQWRDFFRXQWZKLFK
LVWKHVHWRIFOLWLFVWKDWDUHPRVWFRPPRQO\SODFHGLQILQDOSRVLWLRQLQWKHFKDLQRI:DFNHUQDJHOFOLWLFVDQGDUH
XVXDOO\FDOOHG´VHQWHQFHSDUWLFOHVµRU´ORFDOSDUWLFOHVµ7KRVHFOLWLFVDOVRRFFXULQRWKHUSRVLWLRQVLQWKHVHQWHQFH
DQGVRPHRIWKHPFDQTXDOLI\ORFDODGYHUEVDQGFDVHIRUPV7KHPRVWLPSRUWDQWFOLWLFVRIWKLVNLQGDUHM0()DQG%
M=()ZKLFKDUHPXWXDOO\H[FOXVLYHDQGFDQIRUPDOLQNEHWZHHQFDVHDQGYHUEDODFWLRQDOLW\ VHH-RVHSKVRQ )
7KH\DUHRIYLWDOLPSRUWDQFHIRUDQDQDO\VLVRIWKHDOODWLYHDQGGDWLYHIXQFWLRQVRIWKHORFDWLYHDQGRIDOODWLYH
DGHVVLYHLOODWLYHDQGLQHVVLYHPHDQLQJ
7KHFOLWLFVM0()%DQGM=()ZHUHQRWFORVHO\OLQNHGWRWKHORFDODGYHUEVLQ2OG+LWWLWH$WDODWHUVWDJHRIWKH
ODQJXDJHWKH\FDPHWRSOD\LPSRUWDQWVSHFLI\LQJDQGOLPLWLQJUROHVZLWKORFDODGYHUEVSRVWSRVLWLRQVDQGEH
FDPHREOLJDWRU\ZLWKFHUWDLQSUHSRVLWLRQDOORFDWLYHV\QWDJPV)7KH\EHFDPHQHFHVVDU\VHPDQWLFTXDOLILFDWLRQVRI
VHYHUDOORFDODGYHUEV6RPHRIWKRVHORFDODGYHUEVWKDWKDYHGLUHFWLRQDOPHDQLQJDQGDOODWLYHIRUPVXFKDVSDUč
´IRUWKµRIWHQRFFXUZLWKDQLQLWLDOO\OLPLWLQJM=()%DQGDUHLQVLJQLILFDQWFDVHVDFFRPSDQLHGE\M0()ZKLFKVSHFL
ILHVSHUODWLYHDVZHOODVDOODWLYHPHDQLQJ=()%KDVLWVLQLWLDOO\ DQGILQDOO\ OLPLWLQJIXQFWLRQLQFRPPRQZLWK
WKHHW\PRORJLFDOO\UHODWHG/DWLQSUHYHUE46)7KHDGHVVLYHDQGDOODWLYHPHDQLQJWKDWEHORQJVWRM0()%89%98M8>67%
WRWKHPHDQLQJRIWKH/DWLQSUHSRVLWLRQDQGSUHYHUE("ZKLFKLVDOVRIRXQGLQ&HOWLF DQGRWKHU,QGR(XURSHDQ
ODQJXDJHV EXWLWLVQRWIRXQGLQ+LWWLWHZKHUHWKHUHLVQRORFDODGYHUEZLWKDFRUUHVSRQGLQJDGHVVVLYHDOODWLYH
PHDQLQJ VHH-RVHSKVRQIRUWKFRPLQJ 
7KHUHZDVDUHODWLRQRIWKHFOLWLFVWRWKHVHPDQWLFVDQGVSDWLDOIXQFWLRQRIORFDODGYHUEVDQGWKH\DOVRKDG
DQLPSRUWDQWUHODWLRQWRFDVH0()%DQG=()DUHVLPLODUWRSRVWSRVLWLRQVZKHQWKH\DUHSODFHGLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHU
DQLQIOHFWHGQRXQDVLQWKHFRPPRQO\RFFXUULQJFRPELQDWLRQVDEODWLYHM(G%Å%M=()2ORFDWLYH%M#%Å%M=()2DOODWLYH(%Å%
M0()2%DQGGDWLYH%M#%Å%M0()L%&OLWLF=()%LQWKLVSRVLWLRQLVVLPLODUWRM=1>%DIWHUDSUHFHGLQJDEODWLYHRUORFDWLYHFDVHLQ
6DEHOOLDQ VHH-RVHSKVRQIRUWKFRPLQJ 
7KHUHLVDJHQHUDOUHODWLRQVKLSRIM0()%DQGM=()%WRWKHVKDSHRIPDWHULDOREMHFWVSODFHVSHUVRQVDQGVRRQ
M0()%LVXVHGUDWKHUWKDQ%M=()%ZKHQPRXQWDLQVFLWLHVDQGVKRUHVDUHPHQWLRQHGDVORFDWLRQRUJRDO7KHVHPDQ
WLFV $'I(5! RIQRXQVLQGLFDWLQJORFDOLWLHVRUDUHDVWKXVLQIOXHQFHGWKHFKRLFHEHWZHHQWKHLQHVVLYHM=()DQGWKH
DGHVVLYHM0()L7KLVFDQEHREVHUYHGLQ0LGGOH+LWWLWHWH[WVEXWWKHRSSRVLWLRQEHWZHHQWKHWZRFOLWLFVZDVHIIDFHG
ZKHQM=()FDPHWRUHLJQSUDFWLFDOO\DORQHLQ/DWH+LWWLWH
%HFDXVHWKHHQWLUH7RFKDULDQV\VWHPRIORFDOFDVHVZDVUHEXLOWDIWHUDSUHKLVWRULFORVVRIWKHRULJLQDO,QGR
(XURSHDQORFDOFDVHVWKHFRPSDULVRQZLWKRWKHU,QGR(XURSHDQODQJXDJHVZLOOKDYHWREHRIDW\SRORJLFDOQDWXUH
DQGFDQQRWVHUYHWKHSXUSRVHRIUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIWKH,QGR(XURSHDQV\VWHP7KHXVHRIWKH7RFKDULDQORFDOFDVHV
ZDVWKRURXJKO\LQYHVWLJDWHGE\&DUOLQJ  LQDVWXG\WKDWZLOOSURYHXVHIXOIRURXUSXUSRVHV,ZLOOWKHUHIRUH
VXPPDUL]HVRPHRIKHUUHVXOWV
7KH7RFKDULDQ(..($#?!FDVHLVGLUHFWLYHDQGDOVRKDVGDWLYHIXQFWLRQVDVWKDWRIDQLQGLUHFWREMHFW7KLVSDU
WLFXODUIXQFWLRQZDVREWDLQHGE\JUDPPDWLFDOL]DWLRQE\ZD\RIGLUHFWLRQDQGJRDO7KHDOODWLYHFDVHLVXVHGZLWK
WKHPHDQLQJRI´WRZDUGµZLWKZRUGVUHIHUULQJWROLYLQJFUHDWXUHVDQGDEVWUDFWV &DUOLQJ² 7KHDOODWLYH
FDVHVKDUHVGLUHFWLYHIXQFWLRQZLWKWKHORFDWLYHWKHREOLTXHDQGWKHSHUODWLYHFDVHV7KHDOODWLYHFDVHLVXVHG
ZKHQWKHUHIHUHQFHREMHFWLVDSHUVRQDQGWKHPRYHPHQWWRZDUGWKHJRDOLVEHLQJIRFXVHG7KHUHLVQRGLVWLQF
WLRQEHWZHHQLOODWLYHDQGDOODWLYHIXQFWLRQV VHH&DUOLQJ² 7KH.64($#?!FDVHLVXVHGZKHQWKHJRDOLV
VHHQDVUHDFKHG WHUPLQDWLYHIXQFWLRQ 7KH7RFKDULDQSHUODWLYHFDVHKDVDGHVVLYHDQGDOODWLYHDVZHOODVSHUOD
WLYHIXQFWLRQV$QH[SUHVVLRQOLNHWNDQč´RQWKHHDUWKµVKRZVWKHDGHVVLYHIXQFWLRQRIWKHSHUODWLYHFDVHWKDWLV
IRXQGZKHQDQREMHFWLVDGMXVWDEOHLQUHODWLRQWRWKHUHIHUHQFHREMHFW7KHSHUODWLYHLVH[WHQVLRQDOERWKNLQHWLF
DQGVWDWLF VHH&DUOLQJ%:???N%DQG:DDQGHUV 7KHSHUODWLYHLVXVHGLQH[SUHVVLRQVOLNH´EHVLGHWKHULYHUµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <NN<*/T8%/B%/BH,M8\K,@8<B% O<R

RU´RQWKHPRXQWDLQµZKHUHWKHQDWXUHRIWKHODQGPDUNSOD\VDUROH&DUOLQJFDOOVWKLVWKHDGHVVLYHIXQFWLRQRI
´=XVWDQGRGHU%HZHJXQJµ &DUOLQJ 7KH7RFKDULDQORFDWLYHFDVHLQLWVORFDOXVHKDVLOODWLYHDQGLQHVVLYH
IXQFWLRQV7KHDEODWLYHFDVHLQGLFDWHVWKHSRLQWRIRULJLQ,WKDVVHSDUDWLYHPHDQLQJDQGSRVVHVVHVHODWLYHDVZHOO
DVDEODWLYHIXQFWLRQV7KH7RFKDULDQDEODWLYHFDVHLVLUUHOHYDQWIRUORFDOL]DWLRQDQGGLUHFWLRQ &DUOLQJ 
7KHGDWLYHIXQFWLRQRIDQLQGLUHFWREMHFWLVH[SUHVVHGE\WKHJHQLWLYHDQGDOODWLYH7KHJHQLWLYHDORQHLVXVHGIRU
WKHIXQFWLRQRIGDWLYHVXEMHFW
0\FHQDHDQ*UHHNKDGDQLQVWUXPHQWDOFDVHRI,QGR(XURSHDQRULJLQZLWKDFRPLWDWLYHDQGDTXDVLORFDWLYH
PHDQLQJ7KLVKDVEHHQH[SODLQHGDVDUHIOH[RIDQRULJLQDODGHVVLYHPHDQLQJRIWKH,QGR(XURSHDQLQVWUXPHQWDO
´SUqVGHDYHFµ ZKHUHDVWKHORFDWLYHKDGLQHVVLYHPHDQLQJ VHH5XLMJK² 0\FHQDHDQ6IÉ%ZLWKLQ
VWUXPHQWDOFDVHPHDQV´SUqVGHµ%
$QH[WHQVLRQDODQGSHUODWLYHUROH ´SURODWLYHµLQ$QGHUVRQ WKDWGHYHORSHGVRFLDWLYHDQGFRPLWDWLYH
IXQFWLRQVH[SODLQVWKHLQVWUXPHQWDOPHDQLQJRIDQLQVWUXPHQWDOFDVH VHH-RVHSKVRQDQG&DUOLQJ² 
7KHH[SUHVVLRQRIGLUHFWHGSDWK LQDFFRUGDQFHZLWK&DVDG WKDWEHORQJVWR,QGR(XURSHDQDGYHUELDOIRUPV
ZLWKWKHHQGLQJ !l6+OVHHPVWREHDWWKHRULJLQRIWKH,QGR(XURSHDQLQVWUXPHQWDO )RUWKHSUREOHPVRIXVLQJ
H[WHQVLRQDODVDVHSDUDWHPDLQFDWHJRU\VHH:DDQGHUV²$VWDWLFH[WHQVLRQDOLVDNLQGRIORFDWLYH 
7KHVHPDQWLFUROHRID+LWWLWHGDWLYHORFDWLYHFDQEHVSHFLILHGLQWKHODQJXDJHLQVHYHUDOZD\V7KHUHFLSLHQW
UROHRIDSHUVRQLQWKHGDWLYHORFDWLYHFDVHLVVSHFLILHGE\WKHORFDODGYHUE0!-%ZLWKWKHPHDQLQJRI´IRUµLQDSDV
VDJHRIWKHHSLFRIOLEHUDWLRQZKHUHLWWUDQVODWHVD+XUULDQZRUG7!-PD\EHSUHVHQWEHFDXVHRIWKHWUDQVODWLRQ
DQGEHVXSHUIOXRXVLQ+LWWLWHDVVWDWHGE\1HXLQKLVHGLWLRQRIWKHWH[W 1HX EXWLWVSUHVHQFHSUREDEO\
VKRZVWKDWLWVXVHIRUVSHFLILFDWLRQLVQRWDOLHQWRWKH+LWWLWHODQJXDJH6SHFLILFDWLRQRIVHPDQWLFFDVHIXQFWLRQ
LVDUHJXODUIHDWXUHZKHQDQDOODWLYHPHDQLQJRIDGDWLYHORFDWLYHIRUPLVLGHQWLILHGE\WKHXVHRIWKHGLUHFWLYH
FOLWLF0()WKDWIRUPVDOLQNEHWZHHQYHUEDODFWLRQDOLW\DQGWKHJRDOWRZDUGZKLFKWKHDFWLRQLVGLUHFWHG,WLVDQ
LPSRUWDQWIDFWWKDW0()%FDQEHFRPELQHGZLWKWKHDOODWLYHFDVHEXWQRW=()%WRZKLFK0()LVRSSRVHGEHFDXVHRI
LWVIXQGDPHQWDOO\DGHVVLYHIXQFWLRQ%HVLGHVEHLQJDGHVVLYHM0()%LVDOVRGLUHFWLYHWRDSRVLWLRQRIDGMDFHQF\$V
GLUHFWLYLW\DQGDOODWLYHPRWLRQZHUHPHDQLQJVRI0()LWZDVDSWWREHFRQQHFWHGZLWKWKHDOODWLYHDQGGDWLYHDQG
ZLWKWKHORFDWLYHZKHQLWKDVDOODWLYHRUGDWLYHIXQFWLRQ,WLVDOVRM0()DQGQRWM=()WKDW%LVXVHGZLWKWKHDGHVVLYH
ORFDWLYHLQH[SUHVVLRQVVXFKDV´EHVLGHWKHULYHUµDQG´RQWKHPRXQWDLQµ7KLVXVHRI0()%ZDVFDXVHGE\WKHVKDSH
RIWKHREMHFWDVWKH$'I(5!RIQRXQVLQGLFDWLQJORFDOLWLHVRUDUHDVLQIOXHQFHGWKHFKRLFHEHWZHHQLQHVVLYHM=()%DQG
DGHVVLYHM0()7RFKDULDQXVHVSHUODWLYHFDVHIRUWKLVNLQGRIDGHVVLYHRUVWDWLFH[WHQVLRQDOIXQFWLRQ
7KHPHDQLQJRIIRUZDUGPRWLRQWKDWLVSURSHUWRWKHDGYHUESDUčLVGLUHFWLYH:KHQWKHPRWLRQLVPDUNHGDV
LQLWLDOO\OLPLWHGWKHFOLWLFM=()%LVXVHGZLWKSDUčRIWHQLQFRPELQDWLRQZLWKDQDEODWLYHFDVHIRUP3HUODWLYHIXQF
WLRQLVSUREDEO\SUHVHQWLQH[SUHVVLRQVOLNHዧዽᇀ*$'$*$0*(#(M0#M00()%ᇀᇾወD]SDUčGDL´VKHWDNHVWKHEODFNJDLWHUV
DZD\IURPKLVIHHWµ .8%LLI 7KHLQWLDOOLPLWDWLRQLVQRWVWUHVVHGLQVSLWHRIWKHSUHVHQFHRIWKHGDWLYH
ORFDWLYHSURQRXQ0#DQGWKHDEODWLYH4a,(G%´IURPWKHIHHWµ)RUZDUGPRWLRQOHDGLQJWRDFRPSOHWHUHPRYDOLV
HPSKDVL]HGDVDSHUODWLYHDQGGLUHFWLYHPHDQLQJJHWVVWUHVVHGE\WKHFOLWLF0()%UDWKHUWKDQWKHDEDQGRQPHQWRI
WKHSRLQWRIRULJLQWKDWZRXOGKDYHEHHQVWUHVVHGE\=()ZKLFKLVFRPPRQZLWKWKHDEODWLYH)RUSHUODWLYHIXQF
WLRQRI0()%ZLWKSDUč2%9JJ%SDUčPDVVDQ%e<*<AA<%>!>(#%.,0,1´KHFRQWLQXHVWRVSHDNLQWKHVDPHZD\DVIROORZVµ
.8%LY ZKHUHQRFDVHIRUPLVSUHVHQWEXWWKHSURWUDFWLRQRIWKHDFWLRQLVVWUHVVHG VHH%ROH\
 7KLVLVDQH[DPSOHRIDIRUPDOOLQNEHWZHHQSHUODWLYHDQGGXUDWLRQDOH[SUHVVLRQRIWKHNLQGPHQWLRQHGE\
:DDQGHUV ² 3HUODWLYHSURWUDFWLRQEHFRPHVTXLWHREYLRXVO\GLUHFWLYHZKHQDJRDOLVLQGLFDWHGE\DQ
DOODWLYHFDVHIRUPDVLQ†RIWKH+LWWLWH/DZ&RGHQXVVDQSDUčKDPHVKDQGDDUQX]L´KHVKDOOEULQJWKHPWKURXJK
WRWKHVSULQJµ .%RLY² 
$SHUODWLYHIXQFWLRQRIDQDOODWLYHIRUPLVSUREDEO\SUHVHQWLQLQQDUč´RQRQH·VRZQDXWKRULW\µ7KHPHDQLQJ
RIWKHDOODWLYHWDNQč8HWDNQčKDULHPL´,EXU\LQWKHJURXQGµ 6W%R7LLL² LVQRWLOODWLYHDVPLJKWEHDQH[SHFWHG
VHQVHEXWWKLVDOODWLYHLVSUREDEO\RIDIXQGDPHQWDOO\SHUODWLYHPHDQLQJRIWKHNLQGWKDW7RFKDULDQH[SUHVVHVE\
DSHUODWLYHFDVH DVLQWNDQč WKDWKDVWRGRZLWKWKHVKDSHRIWKHODQGPDUN
,QFRQWUDVWZLWK7RFKDULDQ+LWWLWHSRVVHVVHVDQDEODWLYHFDVHWKDWFDQLQGLFDWHWKHSRLQWRIRULJLQRIDPRYH
PHQWRUDQDFWLRQ7KHLQLWLDOO\OLPLWLQJFOLWLF=()2%ZKLFKLVIRXQGZLWKGLUHFWLRQDODGYHUEVSUHYHUEVDQGZLWK
FHUWDLQYHUEVZKHQFRPELQHGZLWKVXFKDGYHUEVSUHYHUEVLVQRUPDOO\XVHGWRJHWKHUZLWKWKHDEODWLYHIRUPWR
ZKLFKLWFDQEHFOLWLFDOO\MX[WDSRVHGLQDPDQQHUWKDWPDNHVLWVLPLODUWRDSRVWSRVLWLRQRIWKHNLQGIRXQGLQ6DEHO
OLDQZKHUHWKHUHODWHGSRVWSRVLWLRQ=1>FDQEHDWWDFKHGWRDQDEODWLYH7KDW+LWWLWH=()KDVDQLQLWLDOO\OLPLWLQJ
IXQFWLRQLQUHJDUGWRYHUEDODFWLRQLVSDUWLFXODUO\FOHDULQWKHFDVHRILWVXVHZLWKYHUEVRIPRWLRQRFFXUULQJZLWK
RUZLWKRXWDORFDODGYHUESUHYHUEDQGE\LWVXVHZLWKWKHYHUEGč´WDNHµ7KHFOLWLF=()%FDQDOVRLQGLFDWHWKH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% F,Nb8%P,78@O7,B

ILQDOOLPLWDWLRQRIDQDFWLRQRUPRWLRQ,WUHIHUVWRDSRLQWDQGQHYHUKDVGLUHFWLYHPHDQLQJ:KHQ=()%LVIRXQG
ZLWKDORFDWLYHWKHPHDQLQJRIWKHFRPELQDWLRQLVWKHUHIRUHLQHVVLYHRULOODWLYHEXWQHYHUDGHVVLYHRUDOODWLYH
7KHEHKDYLRURIWKHFOLWLFVM0()DQGM=()DQGWKHRSSRVLWLRQRIPHDQLQJEHWZHHQWKRVHFOLWLFVVKRZWKDWDGHV
VLYHDQGLQHVVLYHDUHFDWHJRULHVWKDWDUHSUHVHQWLQ+LWWLWHDVZHOODVDOODWLYHDQGLOODWLYHWKRXJKWKHFOLWLFVGR
QRWEHORQJWRWKHPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHV\VWHP7KLVNLQGRIVHPDQWLFRSSRVLWLRQLVQRWIRXQGLQDUHJXODUPDQQHU
LQ7RFKDULDQDVVKRZQLQ&DUOLQJH[FHSWLQFDVHVZKHQ´WKHORFDWHGREMHFWLVDGMXVWDEOHLQUHODWLRQWRWKH
UHIHUHQFHREMHFWµDQGWKHSHUODWLYHFDVHLVXVHGEHFDXVHRIWKHVKDSHRIWKHREMHFW VHH&DUOLQJ² 7KH
DOODWLYHXVHRIWKHSHUODWLYHFDVHLQDGSRVLWLRQDOSKUDVHVZLWKYHUEVRIPRWLRQDVLQ7RFKDULDQ$=a00#)(%=(->!>%
=a>M´FRPHWRWKHSUR[LPLW\RIWKHWHDFKHUµ VHH&DUOLQJ VKRXOGDOVREHQRWLFHG
7KH+LWWLWHDOODWLYHKDVGLUHFWLYHIXQFWLRQ,WLVDOVRXVHGWHPSRUDOO\ZLWKDEVWUDFWPHDQLQJDQGLQRUGHUWR
H[SUHVVSXUSRVH7KHFOLWLF0()%RFFXUVLQVHQWHQFHVWKDWFRQWDLQDQDOODWLYHFDVHZKHQDGLUHFWLRQDODGYHUEVXFK
69%SDUč%F7%=($$(%LVSUHVHQWDQGDGLUHFWLYHPHDQLQJRIWKHDGYHUEVSUHYHUEVLVLQHYLGHQFH7KHUHDUHH[DPSOHV
RIWKHGLUHFWLYHYHUERIPRWLRQI(#M%EHLQJXVHGZLWKRXWDFFRPSDQLPHQWRIDORFDODGYHUEEXWZLWKDQDOODWLYH RU
ORFDWLYH FDVHDQGWKHFOLWLF0()L%,HPSKDVL]HRQFHDJDLQWKHLPSRUWDQWIDFWWKDWWKHOLPLWLQJFOLWLF=()%LVQHYHU
IRXQGZLWKWKHDOODWLYHFDVH
,QFRQWUDVWZLWKWKH7RFKDULDQDOODWLYHWKH+LWWLWHDOODWLYHFDVHGRHVQRWKDYHWKHGDWLYHIXQFWLRQWKDWLVFRQ
QHFWHGZLWKWKHFDWHJRU\RISHUVRQ7KHFOLWLF0()%LVKRZHYHUFRPSDWLEOHZLWKWKHGDWLYHDQGZLWKWKHGDWLYH
PHDQLQJRIWKHORFDWLYHZKHUHDVM=()%89%HFK2%ZKLFKVKRZVWKDWWKHGLUHFWLYHPHDQLQJRIJRDOZDVFRPPRQWRWKH
DOODWLYHDQGWKHGDWLYH7KHUROHSOD\HGE\WKHORFDWLYHFDVHLQFRPELQDWLRQZLWK0()%LVWKDWRID"($#?10%"()"#%8H%
DSDVVDJHVXFKDV,,,RIWKH$SSXVWRU\)1M00#M00()%0()#GG#%.(>()% ቈዽ(/-M.1%"(#0%´DQGVKHJDYHKLP OLWW¶SXWWR
KLP· WKHVZHHWQDPH(YLOµ7KHUROHRIWKHGDWLYHORFDWLYHLQWKLVPHQWLRQRIDEHVWRZDORIDQDPHLVWKHKXPDQ
HQGSRLQWUROHFRPELQHGZLWKDIIHFWHGQHVVIRUWKHUHFLSLHQW VHHYDQ/DQJHQGRQFNI ,WLVDZHDNHUDQG
PRUHDEVWUDFWIRUPRI´LQWHUQDOFRQWDFWµWKDWLPSOLHVDIIHFWHGQHVVIRUWKHUHFLSLHQW9DQ/DQJHQGRQFN·VH[DPSOH
LVWKH'XWFKSKUDVHt!%I.()$!)%^&#c`%+!>%!!)%+(-$%#)L7KHDFWLRQUHVXOWVLQSRVVHVVLRQDQGWKHUROHRI0()%LVWKHQRU
PDODOODWLYHDGHVVLYHRQH$EHVWRZDORIDQDPHUHFXUVLQ,,,RIWKHVDPHWH[WZLWKDQRWKHUYHUEM0()%d%{\AM()%
KDO]HVVDQGX´PD\WKH\FDOOKLPE\WKHQDPH-XVWµZKHUHWKHFDOOLQJRIWKHQDPHLPSOLHVWKHDWWULEXWLRQWKDWZLOO
UHVXOWLQSRVVHVVLRQRIWKHQDPHDVLWVWD\VE\WKHFKLOGM0()WKXVPDUNVWKHJRDO UHFLSLHQW DWWKHHQGRIDVSDWLR
WHPSRUDOSDWKHQGLQJLQDGHVVLYHORFDWLRQDWWKHJRDO VHH1HZPDQ 7KHRSSRVLWHRISRVVHVVLRQ%DJ8HI%
EHUHIWRIVRPHWKLQJLVIRXQGLQ,,RIWKH$SSXVWRU\QXP@XXVVDDQDQXWWDUZDDTT>DU L ´RQHWKLQJLV
ODFNLQJ E\WR PHµZKLFKVKRZVDGDWLYHORFDWLYHRIDGHVVLYHIXQFWLRQDQGWKHFOLWLF0()L%
+LWWLWHKDVD%H($#?10%#1"#4()$#0ZKLFKLVH[SUHVVHGE\WKHGDWLYHORFDWLYH6HH$(==1%($$#M>(%())#%\N%(001´EXW
LILWLVQRWDJUHHDEOHWRWKHIDWKHUDQGPRWKHUµ .%R,,, &RGH DQG>(++()M9(M$$(%(001%)1M9(%e<*<AA<%
#'(%´DVLWLVDJUHHDEOHWR\RXGRVRµ .8%REY 1RM0()LVSUHVHQWLQWKHVHSDVVDJHVZKHUHWKHUHLVQR
GLUHFWLRQDOLW\RUWUDQVIHU
3XUSRVHZDVDIXQFWLRQRIWKH+LWWLWHDOODWLYHDVHYLGHQFHGE\LQILQLWLYHVDQGDOODWLYHVRIYHUEDOQRXQVVXFK
69%("())(%´IRUHDWLQJµDQG9(--(% +(.G(#M ´ FDOO IRUKHOSµDVZHOODV9(5())(%^9(5($(`%+(.G#'(2%ZKLFK%7JGJ79%KF%6H%
LQYLWDWLRQIRUDELWHMXVWDVWKHUHFDQEHDVXPPRQVWRWKHLQQHUFKDPEHUZKHUHWKHDOODWLYHFDVHLVXVHGIRU
WKHJRDO $1))(=#0)(%+(.G#'( L%$JJ%6>9F%=1)())(%0()+M%´VHHNWRNLOOµDQG=1)())(%I(#M%´GHOLYHUIRUNLOOLQJµ%DQG%(--10(%
I(#M%´UHVRUWWRVHFHVVLRQµ
,Q7RFKDULDQWKHDOODWLYHFDVHLVDOVRXVHGLQRUGHUWRWRLQGLFDWHSXUSRVH%,QILQLWLYHVVKRZLQJDOODWLYHFDVHDUH
FRPPRQLQ7RFKDULDQ%DQGDUHIRXQGLQ7RFKDULDQ$ VHH7KRPDV²&DUOLQJ 
7KH7RFKDULDQDOODWLYHLVXVHGLQWKHIXQFWLRQRIDQLQGLUHFWREMHFWDVZLWK$$0a=MDQG%0a.=M &DUOLQJ
 7KHJHQLWLYHFDVHFDQDOVREHXVHGIRULQGLUHFWREMHFWDVZLWK´JLYHµLQ7RFKDULDQ%
7KHIXQFWLRQRIDQLQGLUHFWREMHFWLV)6$%DFKDUDFWHULVWLFRIWKH+LWWLWHDOODWLYH7KHUHDVRQIRUWKLVFRXOGEH
WKHSUHVHQFHRIDGDWLYHFDVHLQ2OG+LWWLWHWKH7RFKDULDQXVHRIWKHDOODWLYHLQRUGHUWRUHIHUWRDSHUVRQDVDJRDO
FRUUHVSRQGVWRDIXQFWLRQRIWKH+LWWLWHGDWLYHDQGRIWKHWKHORFDWLYHFDVHZKHQLWUHSODFHGWKHGDWLYH
7KDWWKH7RFKDULDQSHUODWLYHFDVHFDQEHXVHGZLWKDOODWLYHIXQFWLRQFRQIRUPVW\SRORJLFDOO\WRDSUHKLVWRULF
WHQGHQF\LQ,QGR(XURSHDQZKHUHDSHUODWLYHjM!l6+O%GHYHORSHGWKHDOODWLYHPHDQLQJRI/DWLQX16%DQGWKH+LWWLWH
DOODWLYHFDVHE\ZD\RIWKHQRWLRQRIGLUHFWHGSDWK
7KHDOODWLYHIXQFWLRQRIWKH,QGR(XURSHDQDFFXVDWLYHFDVHZDVWUHDWHGLQ*DUFtD5DPyQDQG
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <NN<*/T8%/B%/BH,M8\K,@8<B% O<@

1233456
3URWR,QGR(XURSHDQKDGORFDWLYHDEODWLYHDFFXVDWLYHLQVWUXPHQWDODQVZHULQJWRZKHUHZKHQFHZKLWKHU
ZKLFKZD\ ORFDWLYHDEODWLYHDOODWLYHSHUODWLYH *UHHNGDWLYHJHQLWLYHDFFXVDWLYHKDYHORFDWLYHDEODWLYHDOODWLYH
IXQFWLRQV0\FHQDHDQ*UHHNDQG6DQVNULWKDYHDQLQVWUXPHQWDORIWUDYHUVHGVSDFH$OODWLYHFDVHLVIRXQGLQWZR
,QGR(XURSHDQODQJXDJHV7RFKDULDQDQG+LWWLWH2OG+LWWLWHKDGORFDWLYHDEODWLYHDOODWLYHFDVHVZLWKORFDWLYH
DEODWLYHDOODWLYHIXQFWLRQV
5HFLSLHQWPDUNLQJLVDVDOLHQWIXQFWLRQRIDGDWLYHFDVH,WLVDQH[WHQVLRQRIDOODWLYHORFDWLYHVHQVH VHH)LQQ
LVK5XVVLDQ 7KH)LQQLVKDOODWLYHFDVHLVDOODWLYHEXWQRWLOODWLYH,OODWLYHLVDFDVHLQ)LQQLVK2OG+LWWLWHLVWKH
RQO\,QGR(XURSHDQODQJXDJHWKDWVKRZVGDWLYHDOODWLYHDQGORFDWLYHFDVHV$QLQGLUHFWREMHFWLVH[SUHVVHGLQ2OG
+LWWLWHE\WKHGDWLYHODWHUE\WKHGDWLYHORFDWLYH7KHJRDORIWKH2OG+LWWLWHDOODWLYHLVVXFFHGHGE\WKHORFDWLYH
7UDQVIHULVDOODWLYHWKHQORFDWLYHM0()L%H($#?10%#1"#4()$#0QRGLUHFWLRQDOLW\RUWUDQVIHU&RPPRQFRPELQDWLRQVDUH
DEODWLYH(G%Å%M=()2LQHVVLYH#%Å%M=()2%DOODWLYHM(%Å%M0()% 2OG+LWWLWHODWHUM#%Å%M0() %DGHVVLYHM#%Å%M0()L%
7RFKDULDQDOODWLYHLVGLUHFWLYHOLNHWKH+LWWLWHDOODWLYH7RFKDULDQDOVRXVHVSHUODWLYHREOLTXHDQGORFDWLYHIRU
GLUHFWLYHIXQFWLRQ6HH+LWWLWHZKLFKH[SUHVVHVGLUHFWLYHE\DOODWLYH M0() DQGORFDWLYH0()L%7RFKDULDQDOODWLYH
KDVGDWLYHIXQFWLRQ+LWWLWHXVHVGDWLYHODWHUGDWLYHORFDWLYH7RFKDULDQKDVQRGDWLYHFDVH8VHRIWKHDOODWLYHFDVH
JRDODQGKXPDQHQGSRLQW> UHFLSLHQW@ DQGJHQLWLYH,Q+LWWLWHKXPDQHQGSRLQWLVH[SUHVVHGE\GDWLYHORFDWLYH
RIWHQZLWKM0() H($#?10%#1"#4()$#0LVQRUPDOO\ZLWKRXW0()L7RFKDULDQSHUODWLYHLVXVHGIRUDOODWLYHPRWLRQ ZLWK
DQLPDWHGDQGDEVWUDFWJRDO 7RFKDULDQSHUODWLYHLVH[WHQVLRQDODQGDGHVVLYH+LWWLWHXVHV0()%WRVSHFLI\SHUOD
WLYHDQGDGHVVLYHPHDQLQJ7RFKDULDQORFDWLYHLVLQHVVLYHDQGLOODWLYH+LWWLWHVSHFLILHVLQHVVLYHPHDQLQJE\M=()%
F7%M#%Å%M=()L%+LWWLWHDEODWLYHFRPPRQO\RFFXUVZLWK%M=()2%ZKLFK%LVQRUPDOO\XVHGIRUOHDYLQJDSRLQWRUSDVVLQJD
OLPLW:KHQDORFDWLYHLVXVHGZLWKDEODWLYHPHDQLQJLWLVDFFRPSDQLHGE\=()L%7RFKDULDQXVHVWKHORFDWLYHIRU
´$EJUHQ]XQJµUHDFKLQJDJRDODQGSDVVLQJDOLPLW%(8KK8KJ%L9J9% M# M=()L%7RFKDULDQXVHVWKHSHUODWLYHIRU´1LFKW
$EJUHQ]XQJµ ´DORQJRYHUµ +LWWLWH% M# M0()L%/DQGPDUN´DWµ%7RFKDULDQSHUODWLYHFDVH+LWWLWHVSHFLILHVE\M0()L%
/DQGPDUN´8HYN%7RFKDULDQORFDWLYHFDVH+LWWLWHVSHFLILHVE\M=()L
+LWWLWHKDGDQDGHVVLYHDQGFRPLWDWLYHFOLWLFM0()L,WZDVDOVRGLUHFWLYHWRDSRVLWLRQRIDGMDFHQF\ DOODWLYHPHDQ
LQJ DQGZDVDSSOLFDEOHWRSHUODWLYHPHDQLQJ$OODWLYHPRWLRQDQGGLUHFWLRQZHUHPHDQLQJVRIM0()WKDWPDGHLW
VXLWDEOHWREHFRQQHFWHGWRWKHDOODWLYHFDVHDQGWRORFDWLYHFDVHIRUPVKDYLQJGDWLYHIXQFWLRQ$OODWLYHVHQVHLV
WKHEULGJHWRGDWLYHVHQVH 6HH1HZPDQ 
7KHVLWXDWLYHM=()KDGLQHVVLYHDQGOLPLWDWLYHIXQFWLRQDQG%FRXOGDFFRPSDQ\DEODWLYHDQGORFDWLYHFDVHIRUPV
,WIXQFWLRQHGZLWKLQWKHV\VWHPRIDVSHFWXDOSRODULW\´SRODULWpDVSHFWXHOOHLQLWLDOILQDOPpGLDQOLHXSDUUDSSRUW
DXTXHOHVWVLWXpODFLEOHSHQGDQWOHGpSODFHPHQWµ %RRQV DQGUHIHUUHGWR´FKDQJHPHQWGHOLHXGHUpIHUHQFHµ
:LWKLQWKHVDPHV\VWHPWKHFOLWLFM0()%ZDVDGDSWDEOHWR´UpDOLVDWLRQHQWUHGHX[pWDWV¶PDUFKHUV·pORLJQHUV·DSSUR
FKHU·µ%RWKFOLWLFVTXDOLILHGYHUEDODFWLRQDQGORFDODGYHUEVDVZHOODVFDVH,QDPRGLILHG.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]V\VWHPZH
ILQGWKHIROORZLQJUHODWLRQVRIWKHFOLWLFVWRFDVH

,QWKLVV\VWHPWKHGLUHFWLYH7RFKDULDQ(..($#?!FDVHFRYHUVWKHDUHDIURPDOODWLYHWRORFDWLYHZLWKWKHGDWLYH
IXQFWLRQRIJRDOKXPDQHQGSRLQWLQFOXGHG7KH7RFKDULDQI!-.($#?!%FDVH%FRYHUVWKHDUHDRISHUODWLYHDOODWLYH
PRWLRQDQGDGHVVLYHORFDWLYHEXWLVH[FOXVLYHRIGDWLYH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% F,Nb8%P,78@O7,B

+LWWLWH0()%FDQTXDOLI\WKHWKUHHSRVLWLRQVWKDWDUHFRYHUHGE\WKH7RFKDULDQSHUODWLYHFDVHLQFOXVLYHRIWKH
DGHVVLYHORFDWLYHEXWFDQDOVRDFFRPSDQ\WKHGDWLYHFDVHRI2OG+LWWLWHDQGWKHORFDWLYHRIGDWLYHPHDQLQJDVLW
UHIHUVWRKXPDQV+LWWLWH=()%LVDSSOLFDEOHWRWKHDEODWLYHFDVHZKHQLWLQGXFHVLQLWLDOOLPLWDWLRQ,WFDQH[SUHVVDQ
LQHVVLYHORFDWLYHPHDQLQJDQGFRPSOHWHGHVWDEOLVKPHQWLQDQLQHVVLYHSRVLWLRQ=()%89%DOVRIRXQGZLWKDORFDWLYH
FDVHLQDEODWLYHSRVLWLRQUHIHUULQJWRDKXPDQSRLQWRIRULJLQ,Q+LWWLWHWKHDEODWLYH4(0!LVQRWQRUPDOO\XVHGIRU
KXPDQVH($#?10%#1"#4()$#0RFFXSLHVWKHORFDWLYHSRVLWLRQEXWGRHVQRWQRUPDOO\RFFXUZLWKDSDUWLFOH
7KHXVHRIM0()DQGM=()ZDVQRWYHU\IUHTXHQWLQ2OG+LWWLWH7KDWWKHGLUHFWLRQDODQGORFDOIXQFWLRQVWKDW
EHORQJHGWRWKRVHFOLWLFVFRXOGEHXVHGIRUVSHFLILFDWLRQRIWKHPHDQLQJRIFDVHVEHFRPHVHYLGHQWLQ0LGGOH+LWWLWH
ZKLFKLVDOVRWKHSHULRGGXULQJZKLFKWKHQXPEHURIFDVHIRUPVZHUHUHGXFHG,Q/DWH+LWWLWHWKHHPSOR\PHQWRI
M0()ZDVPXFKUHGXFHGWKHV\VWHPRIORFDODGYHUEVZDVFKDQJHGDQGWKHHQWLUHV\VWHPRIFDVHDQGFOLWLFVZDVORVW
$IXOOWUHDWPHQWRIWKHIXQFWLRQRIWKHFOLWLFVZLWKORFDODGYHUEVKDVQRWEHHQSUHVHQWHGKHUHEXWWKHIXQGD
PHQWDOSULQFLSOHVRIWKHLUUHODWLRQVZHUHVWXGLHGLQ7MHUNVWUD7KHDFWLRQDOIXQFWLRQRIWKHV\VWHPRIFOLWLFV
DQGWKHPDQQHULQZKLFKWKHLUGLUHFWLYHDQGOLPLWLQJIXQFWLRQVVHUYHGDVDOLQNEHWZHHQFDVHDQGYHUEDODFWLRQDOLW\
LVQRWDWRSLFRIWKHSUHVHQWDUWLFOHEXWVHHWKHJHQHUDOWUHDWPHQWLQ-RVHSKVRQ

#77589:4;:<=>
.%R )ULHGULFK+UR]Qॆb!#.04+-#:$$!]$!%(10%S65+(G=~#2VQDEUFN2WWR=HOOHU
.8% 6WDDWOLFKH0XVHHQ]X%HUOLQ.HLOVFKULIWXUNXQGHQDXV%RJKD]N|L%HUOLQ6WDDWOLFKH0XVHHQ
.8% $OEUHFKW*|W]HO#0$6-#04+!%*!]$!.HLOVFKULIWXUNXQGHQDXV%RJKD]N|L%HUOLQ6WDDWOLFKH0XVHHQ

.8% -RDFKLP6FKLHOHK!.#5#~0!%*!]$!.HLOVFKULIWXUNXQGHQDXV%RJKD]N|L%HUOLQ6WDDWOLFKH0XVHHQ

6W%R7 +HLQULFK2WWHQDQG9ODGLPLU6RXɥHN%8#)%(.$+!$+#$#04+!0%K#$1(.%:u-%"(0%b~)#50I((-6WXGLHQ]XGHQ
%RЭD]N|\7H[WHQ:LHVEDGHQ2WWR+DUUDVVRZLW]

?:7@:<A54BC6
$QGHUVRQ-RKQ0
% OP@O% *+!%D-(>>(-%6:%3(0!g%*69(-"0%(%N64(.#0$#4%*+!6-'L%&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
%ODQVLWW(GZDUG/
  ´'DWLYHVDQG$OODWLYHVµ,Q7$1"#!0%#)%7')$(4$#4%*'I6.65'HGLWHGE\0+DPPRQG($0RUDYVFLNDQG
-$:LUWKSS²$PVWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
%ROH\-DFTXHOLQH
% :???% H')(>#40%6:%*-()0:6->($#6)%#)%O#$$#$!g%*+!%O#$$#$!%@(-$#4.!0%M=()2%M(0$(%()"%M0()L%,QQVEUXFN,QQVEUXFNHU
%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW
%RRQV-HDQ3DXO
  ´/DQRWLRQVpPDQWLTXHGHGpSODFHPHQWGDQVXQHFODVVLILFDWLRQV\QWD[LTXHGHVYHUEHVORFDWLIVµ
N()51!%:-()R(#0!²
&DUOLQJ*HUG
% :???% H#!%F1)=$#6)!)%"!-%.6=(.!)%b(010%#>%*64+(-#04+!)L%HUOLQ0RXWRQGH*UX\WHU
&DVDG(XJHQH+
  ´¶/RFDWLRQV·¶3DWKV·DQGWKH&RUD9HUEµ,Q36)4!I$1(.#G($#6)0%()"%A!)$(.%@-64!00#)5%#)%N()51(5!HG
LWHGE\5$*HLJHUDQG%5XG]ND2VW\QSS²%HUOLQ0RXWRQGH*UX\WHU
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <NN<*/T8%/B%/BH,M8\K,@8<B% O<P

*DUFtD5DPyQ-RVp/XLV
  ´=XP$NNXVDWLYGHU5LFKWXQJLP9HGLVFKHQXQGLP,QGRJHUPDQLVFKHQµ,QT!-&(%!$%7$-14$1-(!g%F!0$M
04+-#:$%:u-%b.(10%7$-1)=%G1>%|sL%D!&1-$0$(5SS²,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW
,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
  ´$GYHUELRVGHGLUHFFLyQHLQVWUXPHQWDOLQGRHXURSHRµ,QS!-$+6."%H!.&-u4=%'%.(%0#)$(]#0%#)"6!1-6I!(%
+6'% $FWDVGHOFRORTXLRGHOD,QGRJHUPDQLVFKH*HVHOOVFKDIW0DGULG²GHVHSWLHPEUHGH 
HGLWHGE\(¬&UHVSRDQG-/*DUFtD5DPyQSS²0DGULG(GLFLRQHVGHOD8$0
-RVHSKVRQ)RONH
  ´'LUHFWLRQDOLW\LQ+LWWLWHµ,Q.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]0HPRULDO%T6.1>!2%3DUW2QHHGLWHGE\:6PRV]\‫ش‬VNLSS
²$QDOHFWD,QGRHYURSDHD&UDFRYLHQVLD.UDFRZ8QLYHUVLWDV
)RUWKFRPLQJ´'LUHFWLRQDOLW\&DVHDQG$FWLRQDOLW\LQ+LWWLWHµ,Q@-64!!"#)50%6:%$+!%7!46)"%36..6X1#1>%6)%N()51(5!%
*'I6.65'%#)%(%H#(4+-6)#4(.%@!-0I!4$#?!%+!."%($%D~$!&6-5%\)#?!-0#$' SURYLVLRQDOWLWOH HGLWHGE\)-RVHSK
VRQDQG,6|KUPDQ
-RVHSKVRQ)RONHDQG*HUG&DUOLQJ
  ´3HUODWLYHDQG,QVWUXPHQWDOLQ6DQVNULWDQG,QGR(XURSHDQµ,Q3($!56-#0($#6)%()"%/)$!-I-!$($#6)g%/)M
"6.65#4(.%()"%36>I(-($#?!%7$1"#!0%:-6>%()%/)$!-)($#6)(.%/)"6.65#4(.%A!!$#)5%($%$+!%H!I(-$>!)$%6:%36>I(-(M
$#?!%@+#.6.65'2%D~$!&6-5%\)#?!-0#$'HGLWHGE\)-RVHSKVRQSS²0HLMHUEHUJVDUNLYI|UVYHQVN
RUGIRUVNQLQJ*|WHERUJ0HLMHUEHUJVLQVWLWXW
.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]-HU]\
  *+!%/):.!4$#6)(.%3($!56-#!0%6:%/)"6M81-6I!()+HLGHOEHUJ&:LQWHU
/XUDJKL6LOYLD
  ´7KH+LVWRU\RIWKH*UHHN3UHSRVLWLRQPHWi)URP3RO\VHP\WRWKH&UHDWLRQRI+RPRQ\PVµD.6$$(%
²
0HOLV/XGR
  ´)URP)RUPWR,QWHUSUHWDWLRQµ,Q*+!%H($#?!2%1F>LMJ%:N%*+!6-!$#4(.%()"%36)$-(0$#?!%7$1"#!0HGLWHGE\
:YDQ/DQJHQGRQFNDQG:YDQ%HOOHSS²$PVWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
1HX(ULFK
  H(0%+1--#$#04+!%8I60%"!-%F-!#.(001)52%1F>LMJ%ON%\)$!-014+1)5!)%G1%!#)!>%+1--#$#04+M+!$+#$#04+!)%*!]$!)M
0!>&.!%(10%O($$10(6WXGLHQ]XGHQ%RJD]N|L7H[WHQ:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
1HZPDQ-RKQ
  ´5HFLSLHQWVDQG¶*LYH·&RQVWUXFWLRQVµ,Q*+!%H($#?!2%1F>LMJ%:N%*+!6-!$#4(.%()"%36)$-(0$#?!%7$1"#!02%
HGLWHGE\:YDQ/DQJHQGRQFNDQG:YDQ%HOOHSS²$PVWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
5XLMJK&RUQHOLV-
  ´/DSUpSRVLWLRQ!IÉ9DOHXUVVpPDQWLTXHVHWFKRL[GHVFDVµ,Q3(0%!$%I-UI60#$#6)0%!)%5-!4%()4#!)% $FWHV
GXFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOGH6DLQWeWLHQQH²MXLQ HGLWHGE\%-DFTXLQRWSS²%6DLQW
eWLHQQH3XEOLFDWLRQVGH/·8QLYHUVLWpGH6DLQWeWLHQQH
$6>89DL7E2%3FHH6%
  ´()"(%DQG()"()%LQ1HR+LWWLWHµP61-)(.%6:%31)!#:6->%7$1"#!0%²
6WDUNH)UDQN
% OP@@% H#!%F1)=$#6)!)%"!-%"#>!)0#6)(.!)%b(010%1)"%<"?!-&#!)%#>%<.$+!$+#$#04+!):LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
7KRPDV:HUQHU
  ´'LH,QILQLWLYHLP7RFKDULVFKHQµ,Q<0#($#4(g%F!0$04+-#:$%F-#!"-#4+%J!..!-%G1>%|sL%D!&1-$0$(52%5!9#"M
>!$%?6)%0!#)!)%F-!1)"!)2%b6..!5!)%1)"%74+u.!-)HGLWHGE\-6FKXEHUWDQG86FKQHLGHUSS²%
/HLS]LJ+DUUDVVRZLW]
 oi.uchicago.edu

OR?% F,Nb8%P,78@O7,B

7MHUNVWUD)UDQoRLVH$
% OPPP% @-#)4#I.!0%6:%$+!%K!.($#6)%&!$9!!)%N64(.%<"?!-&2%T!-&%()"%7!)$!)4!%@(-$#4.!%#)%O#$$#$!&XQHLIRUP0RQR
JUDSKV*URQLQJHQ6W\[3XEOLFDWLRQ
YDQ%HOOH:LOKHOPDQG:YDQ/DQJHQGRQFNHGLWRUV
  *+!%H($#?!2%1F>LMJ%ON%H!04-#I$#?!%7$1"#!0$PVWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
  *+!%H($#?!2%1F>LMJ%:N%*+!6-!$#4(.%()"%36)$-(0$#?!%7$1"#!0$PVWHUGDP-RKQ%HQMDPLQV
YDQ/DQJHQGRQFN:LOO\
  ´7KH'DWLYHLQ/DWLQDQGWKH,QGLUHFW2EMHFWLQ'XWFKµ,Q*+!%H($#?!2%1F>LMJ%:N%*+!6-!$#4(.%()"%
36)$-(0$#?!%7$1"#!0HGLWHGE\:YDQ/DQJHQGRQFNDQG:YDQ%HOOHSS²$PVWHUGDP-RKQ
%HQMDPLQV
:DDQGHUV)UHGHULN0-
  ´$QFLHQW*UHHN3HUODWLYH([SUHVVLRQVµ,Q/)%$+!%F66$0$!I0%6:%K(I+(!.%bu+)!-% 3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH,Q
WHUQDWLRQDO&ROORTXLXPLQ&RPPHPRUDWLRQRIWKHWK$QQLYHUVDU\RIWKH3XEOLFDWLRQRI5DSKDHO
.KQHU·V<10:u+-.#4+!%D-(>>($#=%"!-%D-#!4+#04+!)%7I-(4+!2%1F>LMJ%:N%7')$(]!2%<>0$!-"(>2%_áà| HGLWHG
E\$5LMNVEDURQ+$0XOGHUDQG*&:DNNHUSS²$PVWHUGDP-&*LHEHQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% $120$/,(6*5$00$7,&$/(6­%ԣ627࢜1% ORO

!!
$120$/,(6*5$00$7,&$/(6­%ƺ627ʁ1

QL%@#-(-$2%\)#?!-0#$U%"!%N#E5!

/DYHUVLRQLQGLJqQHGHVLQVFULSWLRQVFXQpLIRUPHVDFKpPpQLGHVFRQVWLWXHXQWpPRLJQDJHOLQJXLVWLTXHIRUW
PDODLVpjXWLOLVHUGDQVOHFDGUHGHODOLQJXLVWLTXHFRPSDUDWLYHLQGRHXURSpHQQH7RXWG·DERUGODTXDQWLWpGHWH[WHV
HVWIRUWSHXpWHQGXHVLQRXVWHQRQVFRPSWHGXWUqVJUDQGQRPEUHGHUpSpWLWLRQVGHSKUDVHVTX·LOVFRQWLHQQHQW
(QVXLWHOHV\VWqPHG·pFULWXUHQ·HVWJXqUHH[SOLFLWHSXLVTXHODYR\HOOHEUqYHúQ·HVWMDPDLVQRWpHVLFHQ·HVWHQILQ
GHPRWRHOOHVHFRQIRQGDYHFčTXHOHVYR\HOOHV8%JK%ҸVRQWFRQIRQGXHVTXHOHVYR\HOOHVL%JK%ࡃ%>J%9FHK%6L998%>J%
SOXVVRXYHQWTXHOHVYR\HOOHVILQDOHV8%JK%LVRQWQRWpHV#M' PDLV'GHUULqUHK HW1M?(TXHE%JK%8EVHFRQIRQGHQW
GHUULqUHFRQVRQQHSRXUrWUHpFULWVWRXVGHX[#M'VDXIDSUqVKRO·RQQHWURXYHTXH'TXHODYR\HOOH7VHFRQIRQG
DYHF6762%76%JK%67TXHOHVGLSKWRQJXHVLQLWLDOHV6L%JK%čXVHFRQIRQGHQWDYHFLTXHSOXVLHXUVFRQVRQQHVILQDOHVQH
VRQWSDVQRWpHVWHOOHVK2%H%FL%KTXHODJUDSKLHGHKHVWIRUWHPHQWDEHUUDQWHTXHODQDVDOHQ·HVWSDVQRWpHGHYDQW
RFFOXVLYHRXGHYDQWMHWF/DOLVWHHVWORQJXH(WELHQV€ULO\DGHVHUUHXUVTXLSHXYHQWrWUHGHVFRTXLOOHVPDLV
DXVVLGHYpULWDEOHVIDXWHVG·RUWKRJUDSKH
/HV\VWqPHJUDSKLTXHGHEDVHHVWOHVXLYDQWFHUWDLQVVLJQHVFRQVRQDQWLTXHVQHVRQWXWLOLVDEOHVTXHGHYDQW
YR\HOOH62%čRX‘-HOHVWUDQVFULV&('·DXWUHVVLJQHVFRQVRQDQWLTXHVQHVRQWXWLOLVDEOHVTXHGHYDQWYR\HOOH62%č‘
82%Ҹ-HOHVWUDQVFULV&('·DXWUHVHQFRUHVRQWXWLOLVDEOHVGHYDQWQ·LPSRUWHTXHOOHYR\HOOH-HOHVWUDQVFULV&,OH[LVWH
DXVVLGHVVLJQHVTXLQHVRQWXWLOLVDEOHVTXHGHYDQW8%JK%ҸRXGHYDQWL%JK%ࡃ-HOHVWUDQVFULVUHVSHFWLYHPHQW&#%JK%"1
-J9%98IHJ9%9FHKN

(% # 1 m
N೓ %=1
(
] J೓ %51
(
m
F೓( m c(%c# m
W೓ %$1
(
۟ "(%"#%"1 Q೓ %)1
(

I : & >(%>#%>1
' U೓(%-1 . ?(%?#
0 G k K೓(
([HPSOHV

T(.!1-0 D-(I+#!0%>U"#(.!0 T(.!1-0 D-(I+#!0%>U"#(.!0

GD "( Qč Q೓(M(
Gč "(M( H82%QҸ2%H68 Q೓(M#
GDUD2%GUD2%GDU2%GU૖ "(M-೓ (
HL2%Qࡃ )1M1
GL2%GҸ "#M# =6 I
GDL "(M# Sč IM(
GčL "(M(M# KD (%FL%K೓(
GX2%Gࡃ "1M1 KDX2%KčX K೓(M1
GUX "1M 1M -1M1 KX 1
H6 Q೓(

ORO
 oi.uchicago.edu

OR:! QL%@/K<K*

(QILQODODQJXHGHODYHUVLRQLQGLJqQHGHVLQVFULSWLRQVDFKpPpQLGHVHVWOHPpODQJHDUELWUDLUHGHGHX[GLD
OHFWHVOTXHMHQRPPHUDL$HW%/HGLDOHFWH$HVWKDELWXHOOHPHQWFRQVLGpUpFRPPHpWDQWOHSHUVHSURSUHPHQWGLW
PDLVFHFLQ·HVWMDPDLVTX·XQHSURIHVVLRQGHIRL&HGLDOHFWHSDUWDJHFHUWDLQHVLVRJORVVHVDYHFODEKčߙčOHGLDOHFWH
GHV%UčKPD‫ؾ‬62:HWG·DXWUHVDYHFOHVSUkFULWVQ3RXUVDSDUWOHGLDOHFWH%SURFKHGHO·DYHVWLTXH<³PDLVFHFLHVW
ODFRQLTXHSXLVTXHO·DYHVWLTXHUHoRLWVRQQRPGHQRWUHLQFDSDFLWpGHVDYRLUGHTXHOOHUpJLRQG·,UDQF·pWDLWOHGLD
OHFWH³DpWpFRQVLGpUpFRPPHpWDQWOHPqGHRPDLVOjDXVVLFHQ·HVWTXHSURIHVVLRQGHIRL
(QRXWUHQRXVGHYRQVVLJQDOHUTXHOHWH[WHGHODYHUVLRQLQGLJqQHGHVLQVFULSWLRQVDFKpPpQLGHVDSSDUDvW
JpQpUDOHPHQWVRXVFHWWHIRUPHTXHODWUDGLWLRQJUDPPDWLFDOHLQGLHQQHDSSHOOHSDGDSčࠃKDF·HVWjGLUHHQGRQQDQW
OHVPRWVVRXVODIRUPHTX·LOVSUpVHQWHQWHQILQDOHDEVROXHDXWUHPHQWGLWXQWH[WHkQRQQpVDQVREVHUYDWLRQGHV
UqJOHVGHVDQGKLRXGHOLDLVRQ1pDQPRLQVojHWOjFHUWDLQVVDQGKLVRQWRSpUpV
(WFHFLQ·pSXLVHSDVODOLVWHGHVHPE€FKHVDX[TXHOOHVODOHFWXUHGHWHOVWH[WHVQRXVFRQIURQWH(QHIIHWGH
QRPEUHXVHVDQRPDOLHVJUDPPDWLFDOHVWDQWV\QWD[LTXHVTXHPRUSKRORJLTXHVRXSKRQpWLTXHVDIIHFWHQWOHVWH[WHV
DFKpPpQLGHVXQHVLWXDWLRQTXHQRXVFRQQDLVVRQVDXVVLGDQVOHVWH[WHVDYHVWLTXHVFRPPHMHO·DLPLVHQOXPLqUH
3LUDUW 
)DFHjDXWDQWG·REVWDFOHVQRXVQHSRXYRQVTXHQRXVFRQVLGpUHUKHXUHX[GHGLVSRVHUGHWUDGXFWLRQVDFFD
GLHQQHpODPLWHRXDUDPpHQQHHWGHO·DLGHTXHQRXVIRXUQLWODOLQJXLVWLTXHFRPSDUDWLYHGHVODQJXHVLQGRLUD
QLHQQHVDQFLHQQHV6DQVGHWHOVVHFRXUVQRWUHFRPSUpKHQVLRQGHODYHUVLRQLQGLJqQHGHVLQVFULSWLRQVFXQpLIRUPHV
DFKpPpQLGHVUHVWHUDLWVDQVQXOGRXWHELHQDSSUR[LPDWLYH
&RPPHOHWKqPHGXSUpVHQWFROORTXHFRQFHUQHO·HPSORLGHVFDVF·HVWSDUPLFHVDQRPDOLHVJUDPPDWLFDOHV
GHO·XQHGHFHOOHVTXLDIIHFWHQWOHVGpFOLQDLVRQVTXHMHPHSURSRVHGHYRXVHQWUHWHQLU
/HSUREOqPHTXHQRXVDOORQVH[DPLQHUVHVLWXHGDQVFHUWDLQHVSKUDVHVGXWH[WHGHODJUDQGHLQVFULSWLRQTXH
'DULXVOH*UDQGILWJUDYHUVXUOHURFKHUGH%ҸVRWࡃQHQDYDQWQRWUHqUHOHVSKUDVHVTXLH[SULPHQWGHVGDWHV
7RXWHVFHVSKUDVHVVWpUpRW\SpHVVRQWSUHVTXHLGHQWLTXHV@%
3RXUOHW\SHJpQpUDOTXHFDUDFWpULVHODPHQWLRQG·XQQRPEUHGHMRXUVpJDORXVXSpULHXUjWURLVLOOXVWUpIRLV
O·H[HPSOHHVW'%,"೓#$%೓#$&#$'$(#$)೓#$*!+!&#$#$)೓#$*$#!+!,-!+!%೓#$.$/೓#$0$1$2+!۟$3೓#$4೓#$#!+!#$)೓#!+!
/HVW\SHVH[FHSWLRQQHOVRXLVROpVVRQWDXQRPEUHGHWURLV
ੑ '%,,,²ROHQRPEUHPHQWLRQQpHVW´XQµ 5೓(M-೓(M>(MIM"(M+೓(M'g%>(M(M+೓(M'M(%g%,!+!%೓#$.$/೓#!
+!۟$3೓#$4೓#$&#!+!#$)೓#!+ 
ੑ '%,¬TXLYXOHQRPEUHPHQWLRQQpGH´GHX[µGHYUDLWrWUHXQHH[FHSWLRQ (M)೓(M(M
>(M=೓(M+೓(M'%g%>(M(M+೓(M'M(%g!,,%g%-೓(M1M4೓(M&M#Mk%g%۟M=೓(M$೓(M(g%(M+೓(%g 
ੑ '%,,RDSSDUDvWXQV\QWDJPHGLIIpUHQWHWSDUWLFXOLHU ۟XU೓(M?(M(M+೓(M-೓(M+೓(M'%g%
>(M(M+೓(M'M(%g%51$1$*$&#$6೓#$&#!+!'$4೓#$1$*!+ HWGRQWSRXUFHWWHUDLVRQQRXVQHWUDLWHURQV
SDVLFL
'DQVFHW\SHGHSKUDVHVFRPPHGDQVEHDXFRXSG·DXWUHVFKDTXHPRWIDLWGLIILFXOWpRXWRXWDXPRLQVSHXW
DSSHOHUXQFRPPHQWDLUH&DUVLOHVHQVQHIDLWELHQpYLGHPPHQWDXFXQGRXWH³QRXVGLVSRVRQVGHWUDGXFWLRQV
HQDFFDGLHQHQpODPLWHHWHQDUDPpHQ³OHMXVWLILHUSKRQpWLTXHPHQWJUDSKLTXHPHQWV\QWD[LTXHPHQWHWPRU
SKRORJLTXHPHQWSHXWUHVWHUSUREOpPDWLTXHGDQVOHGpWDLO
&RPPHQoRQVSDUOHSUHPLHUPRWF·HVWOHQRPSURSUHG·XQPRLVGHO·DQQpHHPSOR\pDXJpQLWLI&RPPHFH
QRPSUpVHQWHOHSOXVVRXYHQWXQWKqPHHQ F6OHJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUHQHVWGRQFHQ FDK\DP-XVTX·LFLWRXWYDELHQ
VLFHQ·HVWTXHQRXVLJQRURQVSRXUTXRLGDQVOHFDVG·XQQRPSURSUHODJUDSKLHpOXGHVRXYHQWODYR\HOOHILQDOHF6%
GXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUHQFDK\DQRXVWURXYRQVLFLOHVVLJQHVFM+೓(M'%gDXOLHXGHFM+೓(M'M(%g
/HGHX[LqPHPRWFHOXLTXLQRXVSHUPHWG·LGHQWLILHUOHSUHPLHUFRPPHpWDQWOHQRPSURSUHG·XQPRLVHVW
PčKDPDVF´OHPRLVµO?PDLVFRPPHYRXVOHYR\H]ODJUDSKLHGHVRQJpQLWLISRVHSUREOqPH>(M(M+(M'M(%g% YRLU

O
&RPPH/HFRT  O·DGpPRQWUp 
eGLWLRQGHUpIpUHQFH6FKPLWW
:
&·HVWDLQVLSDUH[HPSOHTXHOHQRPLQDWLIIpPLQLQSOXULHOD۟J೓(M#M @
6XUWRXWHVFHVGDWHVYRLU/HFRT²
Q೓(M#M' D۟DQJLQ\DK ´ FRORQQHV HQSLHUUHµHVWGXW\SH"!?Ҹ ੜ ¬¬GHY\iє% 
,OQ·\DTX·XQHVHXOHH[FHSWLRQ'%,,²۟DLJ೓(U೓(F೓(Lߖ¬% >(M(M
FRQWUH OH YpGLTXH FKčQGDVD "!?Ҹ ੜ ¬  "!?Ҹ єੜ  RX O·DYHVWLTXH YD‫? و‬KҸ¬  K೓(\D¬,;¬U೓(XF೓(ELߖ¬۟N೓(M$೓(D¬DK೓D¬g
YD‫?و‬KҸߖ YRLU+RIIPDQQHW)RUVVPDQ  P
3URWRLQGRHXURSpHQ F60# 6੷ YpGLTXHF(0'(YLHLODYHVWLTXHFDKLLč
Q
&·HVWDLQVLSDUH[HPSOHTXH(M0´FKHYDOµUDSSHOOHOHSUkFULW(00( O?
9pGLTXH>čੜ0(DYHVWLTXH>čÝ‫و‬KD
<
7RXVGHX[PRQWUHQWOHPrPHWUDLWHPHQWGHVFRQVRQQHV
R
6NM UY¡  DIILUPHTXH´0HGLDQVWURQJO\LQIOXHQFHGWKHYR
FDEXODU\RI2OG3HUVLDQµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% $120$/,(6*5$00$7,&$/(6­%ԣ627࢜1% ORQ

.HQW 'HGHX[FKRVHVO·XQHRXELHQQRXVGHYRQVOLUHPčK\DKDSORORJLTXHSRXUPčKDK\D2%FL%D8JH%
FRQVLGpUHUTXHODJUDSKLHPDDK೓(M'M(%gUHSUpVHQWHEHOHWELHQODIRUPHDWWHQGXHPčKDK\DTXHFHVRLWSDUOHELDLV
G·XQHKDSORJUDSKLHSRXU PDDK೓(K೓(M'M(%gRXHQYHUWXGXIDLWTXH FѓFQHV·pFULWSDVWRXMRXUVHQWUHGHX[YR\HOOHV
GHWLPEUH6³LO\DO·H[HPSOHIDPHX[DU೓(W೓(DF೓(M(gXQLYHUEDWLRQGH7૖ WčW%KDFč´VXUEDVHGHO·KDUPRQLHµ DYHVWLTXH
(ߖ૎čWઝKDFč  YRLU3LUDUWI 
/·K\SRWKqVHGXORFDWLIPčKLčG·XQWKqPHPčKOOSHXWVHGpIHQGUHPRUSKRORJLTXHPHQWVXUEDVHGXYpGLTXH>č0ੜ M%g%g%
PčVt2O:PDLVFHVHUDLWXQHPSORLLQXVXHOGXORFDWLIHQFRPELQDLVRQDYHFOHJpQLWLIGXQRPSURSUHGXPRLVTXLVHUDLWDORUV
G·DSSRVLWLRQ
1RXVDUULYRQVDXWURLVLqPHPRW,OHVWOHSOXVVRXYHQWLPSRVVLEOHGHOHSURQRQFHUDYHFFHUWLWXGHSXLVTX·LOHVW
QRWpDXPR\HQG·XQLGpRJUDPPHHWTXHGqVORUVQRXVQHSRXYRQVVDYRLUV·LOpWDLWjOLUHVHORQOHGLDOHFWH$RXOH
GLDOHFWH%,OV·DJLWG·XQQXPpUDO6LSDUH[HPSOHF·HVW,;¬´QHXIµLOQ·\DJXqUHGHGRXWHjOHSURQRQFHUQDYDYX
ODFRwQFLGHQFHWKpRULTXHGHVGHX[GLDOHFWHVHWGXVDQVFULWPDLVVLF·HVW;,9¬´TXDWRU]HµVDFKRQVTXHODIRUPHHQ
9J768K%UFDoXGD۟DOQGDQVOHGLDOHFWH$PDLV FD۟UXGDVDO<GDQVOHGLDOHFWH%OR
&HQXPpUDOVLF·HQHVWXQGXSOXULHORXOHQRPEUH´GHX[µHVWVXLYLGHU೓(XF೓(ELߖ¬PDLVVLF·HVWOHQRPEUH
´XQµQRXVWURXYRQVU೓(XF೓D¬gjVDVXLWH2QGLWDLQVL´GHX[RXSOXVLHXUVUDXFDELߖµPDLV´XQUDXFDKµ&DUGHWRXWH
pYLGHQFHQRXVVRPPHVHQSUpVHQFHGXPRWUDXFDKQW´MRXUµ$YDQWGHGLVFXWHUO·HPSORLGHVWHUPLQDLVRQVELߖ%
SRXUOHSOXULHORXOHGXHOHW‘SRXUOHVLQJXOLHUYR\RQVODVXLWH
1RXV\WURXYRQVG·DERUG۟N೓(W೓(D¬ORUVTXHOHQXPpUDOHVWpJDORXVXSpULHXUjGHX[PDLV۟N೓(W೓(PD¬ORUVTXH
F·HVW´XQµ6LFRPPHRQOHFRQMHFWXUHKDELWXHOOHPHQWFHPRWGpULYHGHODUDFLQHTXLHQDYHVWLTXHHVW¥0(4´SDV
9J7Y% HQSDUODQWGXWHPSVYRLU%DUWKRORPDHFROI QRXVVRPPHVHQSUpVHQFHG·XQPRWDSSDUWHQDQW
DXGLDOHFWH$HQYHUWXGHODFRUUHVSRQGDQFHpWDEOLHTXHYRLFL YRLU3LUDUWQ HWTXHQRXVDYLRQVGpMj
HQWUHYXHjSURSRVGXQRPEUH´GL[µ

SURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ U=è
YpGLTXH ߓ
DFKpPpQLGH$ ۟
DFKpPpQLGH% 9
DYHVWLTXH 0

$8%۟N೓(W೓(MHVWO·DGMHFWLIYHUEDORXSDUWLFLSHSDVVpHQK6GHFHWWHUDFLQHODIRUPHDYHVWLTXHFRUUHVSRQGDQWHHVW
0(]$(PDLVSRXUOHGLDOHFWH$QRXVQHSRVVpGRQVSDVG·H[HPSOHGXWUDLWHPHQWGXVDQGKLLQWHUQHGHSURWRLQGR
HXURSpHQ F= X੷ W೓R¬pWDLWFHF೓[W೓FDYHFYpODLUHVSLUDQWLVpHFRPPHSRXUOHGLDOHFWH%HWO·DYHVWLTXH"$XFRQWDFWGHOD
GHQWDOHVRXUGHGXVXIIL[HSULPDLUHK6 SURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ $6 GHSDUWLFLSHSDVVpODYpODLUH N೓ X੷ GHYDLWHOOH
DXVVLVHVSLUDQWLVHUGDQVOHGLDOHFWH$"'DQVO·LJQRUDQFH³F·HVWODVHXOHRFFXUUHQFHGHSDUHLOOHVpTXHQFH³SRXU
TXRLQHGpFUpWHULRQVQRXVSDVTXHQRQHWQ·DVVRLULRQVQRXVSDVODFRUUHVSRQGDQFHTXHYRLFL

SURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ U=೓ X੷ M$
YpGLTXH =$
DFKpPpQLGH$ NWS
DFKpPpQLGH% [W
DYHVWLTXH ]$

OO
%DUWKRORPDHFRO6FKPLWW/DIRUPHPDDK೓(M'M O<
&IDYHVWLTXHFD۟UXGDVD 9<W 
D¬%=FL7768K%6L998%9J%>87J%PčKDLč OR
&ISURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ "U=౥ )૖ JUHF"U=(YpGLTXHGiߓDDYHVWLTXH
O:
([HPSOH56 "(0(2QSRVHKDELWXHOOHPHQW%U"U=౥ >૖% YRLU0D\UKRIHU²YRO
OQ
6FKPLWW(QRXWUHQRXVQHSRXYRQVVDYRLUVLWHOOHpWDLW  PDLV F>૖  DXUDLWG€GRQQHU F(>HQSURWRLQGR876H8JH/D
ELHQODIRUPHGXSUHPLHUWHUPHGXFRPSRVpQXPpUDO´TXDWRU]Hµ G8H6>J%F!>GXODWLQ"!4!>GRLWrWUHDQDORJLTXHGH"!4#>10
GDQV OH GLDOHFWH $ pWDLWHOOH ELHQ SDUDOOqOH j FHOOH GH O·DYHVWLTXH 
SURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ .U1=!0FIDYHVWLTXH-(64(+SHUVDQU‫]گ‬N%
FD۟UX  SURWRLQGRLUDQLHQ 4($-1 SOXW{W TX·j FHOOH GX YpGLTXH YRLU0D\UKRIHU²YRO
4($1-SURWRLQGRLUDQLHQ 4($X੷ -૖ "
 oi.uchicago.edu

OR<! QL%@/K<K*

(QHIIHWO·LJQRUDQFHGDQVODTXHOOHQRXVQRXVWURXYRQVLFLDYDLWSRXVVp.HQW  jDGPHWWUHTXHOH

WUDLWHPHQWGHYDLWrWUHVHPEODEOHHQWUHOHVGHX[GLDOHFWHVHWTX·LOIDOODLWSRXUUHQGUHFRPSWHGXFNFQRQVSLUDQWLVp
SRVHUXQGpULYpHQ6K6GH¥%۟DFGRQWOHW\SHPRUSKRORJLTXHGHYDLWrWUHFHOXLGXYpGLTXHSDFDWi´QRXUULWXUH
FXLWHµ ¬SURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ SHN೓X੷ ೓HWy PDLVSRXUTXHSDUHLOOHDOWHUQDWLYHI€WUHFHYDEOHLOH€WIDOOXDXYXGX
YpGLTXHTXHO·LH N೓ X੷ \GHYvQW FFFSOXW{WTXH FNF3RXUVDSDUW%DUWKRORPDH FRO SHQVDLWDXORFDWLI
VLQJXOLHUGXGpULYpHQ6K8GHODPrPHUDFLQH´LP0RQDWGHVDLJLQJHQQHXQ7DJH]X(QGH2Y%M689%>J%98HIL>8J7%
۟N೓(W೓(PD¬V·\RSSRVHGpMj
3DUOHGpFUHWTXHGDQVOHGLDOHFWH$OHWUDLWHPHQWpWDLWFNWFVDQVVSLUDQWLVDWLRQQRXVQRXVDXWRULVRQVGRQFj
SRVHUXQDGMHFWLIYHUEDORXSDUWLFLSHSDVVpHQK6۟DNWD´pWDQWSDVVppWDQWpFRXOpµOHTXHODSSDUDvWVRXVODIRUPH
۟DNWčDXQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLIQHXWUHSOXULHORXGXHOHWVRXVODIRUPH۟DNWDPDXVLQJXOLHU8QHGLIILFXOWpJUDYH
VHIDLWMRXULFLSXLVTXHO·DYHVWLTXHHWOHYpGLTXHV·DFFRUGHQWVXUXQQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLIQHXWUHGXHOHQ F!SOXW{W
TX·HQFčઅ1RXVDWWHQGLRQV ۟DNWDL ۟N೓(W೓(L\¬ 4XHV·HVWLOGRQFSDVVp"6DQVGRXWHGHYRQVQRXVDGPHWWUHRXELHQ
XQHDQDORJLHDYHFOHSOXULHORXELHQXQHVLPSOHHUUHXUGHFRSLVWHXQHSHUVpYpUDWLRQGXSOXULHOXWLOLVpVLVRXYHQW
DLOOHXUV/HVLQJXOLHUSDUFRQWUHDEHOHWELHQpWpUHVSHFWpTXLSRXUWDQWQ·pWDLWUHTXLVTX·HQ'%,,,²۟DNWDP
3DUFRQWUHODYDULDWLRQQXPpULTXHUHVWHLQYLVLEOHSRXUOHYHUEHFRQMXJXpTXLHVWLFLODWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQHGH
O·LQGLFDWLILPSDUIDLWGH¥DK´rWUHµO@SXLVTXHQRXVOLVRQVLQYDULDEOHPHQWOHVVLJQHVDK೓D¬ ¬/DTXHVWLRQTX·LOIDXW
VHSRVHULFLHVWFHOOHGHVDYRLUTXHOOHVVRQWDXUHJDUGGXYpGLTXHHWGHO·DYHVWLTXHOHVIRUPHVDWWHQGXHVSRXUOH
VLQJXOLHUOHGXHOHWOHSOXULHOGHFHWWHWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQHGHO·LQGLFDWLILPSDUIDLWDFKpPpQLGH1RXVVRPPHVDVVH]
GpPXQLVSRXUOHGXHOHWOHSOXULHOGHODWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQHGHO·LQGLFDWLILPSDUIDLWGXYHUEH´rWUHµSXLVTXHO·$YHVWD
Q·HQDWWHVWHSDVOHVIRUPHV1pDQPRLQVLOQ·HVWJXqUHDYHQWXUHX[GHOHVUHFRQVWUXLUH

B6>&-! TU"#X1! <?!0$#X1!

čVҸW%
7#)51.#!- čઅ0
HWGHUDUHVIRLVčє
H1!. čVWčP UčઅVW̾POP
@.1-#!. čVDQ UčÝ ‫و‬K̾Q

&RPPHGHQRPEUHXVHVFRQVRQQHVILQDOHVVRQWUpJXOLqUHPHQWpOXGpHVGDQVODJUDSKLHOHVVLJQHVDK¬SHXYHQW
SDUIDLWHPHQWUHSUpVHQWHUOHSOXULHOčKDQPDLVFRPPHLOHVWWRXWjIDLWLPSRVVLEOHTX·LOVUHSUpVHQWHQWODIRUPH
DWWHQGXHSRXUOHGXHOIRUFHQRXVHVWGHUHSUHQGUHO·LGpHIRUPXOpHjSURSRVGH۟DNWčGXHO DXOLHXGH۟DNWDL%
DWWHQGX G·XQHDQDORJLHRXG·XQHHUUHXU4XDQWjODIRUPHGXVLQJXOLHUQRXVQHSRXYRQVQXOOHPHQWQRXVWRXUQHU
YHUVO·DYHVWLTXHHWSHQVHUDLQVLrWUHHQSUpVHQFHG·XQHIRUPHGXGLDOHFWH%¬SXLVTXHFM+D¬gQHSHXWTXHGLIILFLOHPHQW
QRWHUODVLIIODQWHILQDOHTXHVXJJqUHO·DYHVWLTXHčઅ0/HYpGLTXHčVҸWGRQWODPRUSKRORJLHV·LQVSLUHGHO·DRULVWHHQ
#ߙPRQWUHTXHODODQJXHGXWVHGpIHQGUHGHYDQWXQHXVXUHSKRQpWLTXHTXLSRXYDLWREVFXUFLUODFRPSUpKHQVLRQ
DXGLWLYHGHODWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHUGHO·LQGLFDWLILPSDUIDLWGXYHUEH´rWUHµTXLVRXVVDIRUPHDUFKDwTXH
DWWHVWpHGHUDUHVIRLVGDQV56HVWčє SURWRLQGRLUDQLHQ čVWSURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ !MO_!0M$ (QDYHVWLTXH
OHJURXSHFRQVRQDQWLTXHILQDO F0$VHUpGXLWUpJXOLqUHPHQWj F0 +RIIPDQQHW)RUVVPDQ GXPRLQVGDQV
O·RUWKRJUDSKHTXLFRPPHRQVDLWQHUHIOqWHMDPDLVTXHODSURQRQFLDWLRQPpGLpYDOHPDLVHQYpGLTXHFHJURXSH
VHUpGXLWGDYDQWDJHVHXOHHQVXEVLVWHXQHOpJqUHDVSLUpHVRXUGHTXHOHVJUDPPDLULHQVLQGLHQVRQWDSSHOpHYLVDUJD
RXYLVDUMDQҸ\DFєSRXUDXWDQWELHQV€UTXHQRXVIDVVLRQVFRQILDQFHjODWUDGLWLRQYpGLTXHTXLQ·HVWSDVQRQSOXV
GHSUHPLqUHPDLQ1RXVRSpURQVGRQF´FRPPHVLµ9XTXHODURXWHQRXVHVWEDUUpHVLQRXVFKHUFKRQVjQRXVEDVHU
VXUO·DYHVWLTXHLOFRQYLHQWG·HVVD\HUGHVXLYUHFHOOHTXHQRXVVXJJqUHOHYpGLTXHDUFKDwTXHčє$XWUHPHQWGLW
OHVVLJQHVDFKpPpQLGHVDK೓D¬ gSHXYHQWLOVUHSUpVHQWHUčK",OHVWLFLjVRXOLJQHUTXHODSRVVLELOLWpHQUHVWHIDLEOH
SXLVTXHWRXWHVOHVDXWUHVRFFXUUHQFHVG·XQHILQDOH FčKVRQWQRWpHV FD¬F·HVWjGLUHHQpOXGDQWO·DVSLUpHILQDOH

O@
SURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ¥ OO!0FIYpGLTXH<7DYHVWLTXH¥(+

/HGLVV\OODELVPHGHODVHXOHDWWHVWDWLRQJkWKLTXH <DD·E۟ɘ‫گ‬L
DVčUPDLWLߖ۟ɘ̽˼čJ̽˼XߖWDߖčDߖ[UDWXߖPDLQLLXߖPD]GčDKXUč´7D ILOOH OD
'pIpUHQFHHWWRQ ILOV OH&KDUSHQWLHUGHOD9DFKHpWDLHQWOHWUqVLQWHO
OLJHQWpWDWG·HVSULW{0DvWUH0D]Gčµ>WUDGXFWLRQ.HOOHQVHW3LUDUW
²YRO@ UHVWHLQYpULILDEOHSXLVTX·LO\DFRRUGLQDWLRQSDU
UpSpWLWLRQGXSUpYHUEHč YRLU.HOOHQVHW3LUDUW²YRO 
HWTXHFHGHUQLHUjIXVLRQQHUDYHFOXLVHFRQIRQGDYHFO·DXJPHQW
GH(0 669 ¬۟YDL%öDV%DUDPDWLߖ%۟YDK%ö%JDXߖ%WD[ߖč%Dߖ[UDWXߖ%PDQ\Xߖ%
PD]Gč%DKXUD
OP
eWDQWHQWHQGXTXHO·DYHVWLTXHUHFRXUWSRXUODWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQH
GXGXHOjODPrPHGpVLQHQFHTXHSRXUODGHX[LqPH YRLU.HOOHQV
† VDQVGRXWHDUWLILFLHOOHPHQW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% $120$/,(6*5$00$7,&$/(6­%ԣ627࢜1% ORR

VDXIDXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUDKXUDPD]GčKGXWKpRQ\PHDKXUDPD]GčTXLOHSOXVVRXYHQWHVWpFULW(M1M-(M>(MGM"(M(M
+D¬g%FRQWUDLUHPHQWDXQRPLQDWLITXLWKpRULTXHPHQWRXDSSDUHPPHQWDSRXUWDQWODPrPHIRUPH2ULOH[LVWHXQH
OpJqUHGLIIpUHQFHpW\PRORJLTXHHQWUHFHQRPLQDWLIHWOHJpQLWLIGHPD]Gč
ੑ QRPLQDWLISURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ >)૖ 0"+!OOM7
! YLHLODYHVWLTXH>(G"čÝ DYHFFčÝ PRQRV\OODELTXH
! DFKpPpQLGHDXU೓(PD]GDD¬¬
ੑ JpQLWLISURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ >)૖ 0"+!OOM87%
! YLHLODYHVWLTXH>(G"čÝ DYHFFčÝ GLVV\OODELTXH 3LUDUW 
! DFKpPpQLGHDXU೓(PD]GDDK೓D¬g
&HWWHOpJqUHGLIIpUHQFHGXJpQLWLIV·H[SOLTXHGRQFSDUXQHVpTXHQFHGDQVODTXHOOHQRXVWURXYRQVXQHODU\QJDOH
LQWHUYRFDOLTXHFHTXLHVWSUpFLVpPHQWDXVVLODFDUDFWpULVWLTXHGHO·pW\PRQGHODWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHU
GHO·LQGLFDWLILPSDUIDLWGXYHUEH´rWUHµ
ੑ SURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ >)૖ 0"+9:;80%
! DFKpPpQLGHFPD]GDDK೓D¬¬
ੑ SURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ 9:;90M$%
! DFKpPpQLGHDK೓D¬g
$XVVLEL]DUUHTXHFHSXLVVHSDUDvWUHOHVLJQHK೓(QHVHUDLWGRQFHPSOR\pSRXUQRWHUO·DVSLUpHILQDOHTXHVLOD
YR\HOOHTXLOHSUpFpGDLWpWDLWXQčGLVV\OODELTXHF66R¬N
ੑ DKXUDPD]GDDK´G·+RURPD]qVµ
ੑ DDK´LOpWDLWµ
-HQHSHQVHSOXVTXHQRXVWHQLRQVODVROXWLRQjIDLUHFHUDLVRQQHPHQWOHGLVV\OODELVPHQHGHYDLWSOXVV·rWUH
M68HKJHL%=FL7%>6%G8H6>J%FčKGHFHVGHX[H[HPSOHVSXLVTXHO·DYHVWLTXHUpFHQWQHOHFRQILUPHSDVHWTXHODGpFRP
SRVLWLRQGHODODQJXHGHVLQVFULSWLRQVDFKpPpQLGHVpWDLWWURSDYDQFpHSRXUTXHSDUHLODUFKDwVPHSKRQpWLTXH\
VXEVLVWkW-HSUpIqUHGRQFFRQVLGpUHUTXHODJUDSKLHGXJpQLWLIDFKpPpQLGHGXWKpRQ\PH FPD]GDDK೓D¬gUHOqYH
GXGLDFULWLVPHRXPrPHUpKDELOLWHUODYLHLOOHVROXWLRQTXLFRQVLVWDLWjGRQQHUGHDXU೓(PD]GDDK೓D¬gXQHOHFWXUH
JH%FPD]GčKDKPDLVSRXU\UHFRQQDvWUHXQJpQLWLIIRUPpjSDUWLUGHODIRUPHGXQRPLQDWLI FPD]GčKDKSOXW{W
TX·jSDUWLUGXWKqPHSDUHLOOHPRQVWUXRVLWpUHVWDQWHQYLVDJHDEOHGDQVOHFDGUHG·XQHODQJXHDXVVLDEkWDUGLHTXH
FHOOHGHVLQVFULSWLRQVDFKpPpQLGHV
,OIDXWGRQFUHFKHUFKHUDXVVLXQHDXWUHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHODIRUPHDK೓D¬gTXHPRQWUHODWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQHGX
VLQJXOLHUGHO·LQGLFDWLILPSDUIDLWGXYHUEH´rWUHµ¬(QHIIHWO·pWDWGHGpFRPSRVLWLRQDYDQFpGHODODQJXHVXJJqUH
TX·XQHDQDORJLHDYDLWSXDYRLUOLHXDYHFODIRUPHGHODWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHUGHO·LQGLFDWLILPSDUIDLW
DFKpPpQLGHGHVYHUEHVWKpPDWLTXHV6L´LOGHYHQDLWµpWDLWDEDYDWpFULWDEYD¬LOHVWVDQVGRXWHpFRQRPLTXH
G·DGPHWWUHTXHDK೓D¬gHVWODJUDSKLHGHčKDW
7RXVOHVDXWUHVPRWVD\DQWSXrWUHFRPPHQWpVHWWDQWELHQTXHPDOpOXFLGpVjGHPXOWLSOHVSRLQWVGHYXHUHYH
QRQVjFHOXLTXLQRXVLQWpUHVVHOHSOXVGDQVOHFDGUHGHO·HPSORLGHVFDVHWTXHQRXVDYLRQVSURYLVRLUHPHQWODLVVpGH
F{Wp´MRXUµU೓(XF೓D¬g%6L%98HIL>8J7%JKU೓(XF೓(ELߖ¬DXSOXULHORXDXGXHO1RXVSRXYRQVVDQVGLIILFXOWpLQWHUSUpWHUFHV
JUDSKLHVFRPPHUHSUpVHQWDQWUHVSHFWLYHPHQWUDXFDK%JK%UDXFDELߖOHVIRUPHVUHVSHFWLYHVGXQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLI
VLQJXOLHUHWGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHOGHUDXFDKQW´MRXUµ/HSOXULHOHWOHGXHOUHFRXUUDLHQWGRQFjXQHIRUPH
G·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHOHQELߖ೓:?DORUVPrPHTXHOHVLQJXOLHUIHUDLWXVDJHGHFHOOHDWWHQGXHGXQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLI
³ 'XPRLVGH*DUPDSDGDXQVHXOMRXUpWDLWSDVVp
³ 'XPRLVG·$QčPDNDDYHFGHX[MRXUVpWDLWSDVVp
³ 'XPRLVG·$QčPDNDDYHFYLQJWVHSWMRXUVpWDLWSDVVp
&RPPHFHVGHX[GHUQLqUHVWUDGXFWLRQVHWODYDULDQWH´RIWKHPRQWK$QčPDNDE\GD\VZHUHSDVWµTXH.HQW
HQSURSRVDLW .HQW VRQWELHQpYLGHPPHQWLQVXSSRUWDEOHVLOIDXWDYHF%DUWKRORPDH:OELHQVHUHQGUH

:?
3URWRLQGRHXURSpHQ &+#0YpGLTXH&+#єDYHVWLTXH&#k %DUWKRORPDHFROFI6FKZ\]HU²6NM UY¡
:O


 oi.uchicago.edu

! QL%@/K<K*

jO·pYLGHQFHTXHODIRUPHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHOHVWPLVHUHVSHFWLYHPHQWSRXUFHOOHVGXQRPLQDWLIGXHOHWGX
HFM8H6K8G%=>L78J>N%
³ 'XPRLVGH*DUPDSDGDXQVHXOMRXUpWDLWSDVVp
³ 'XPRLVG·$QčPDNDGHX[MRXUVpWDLHQWSDVVpV
³ 'XPRLVG·$QčPDNDYLQJWVHSWMRXUVpWDLHQWSDVVpV
3UpFLVRQVTXHO·HPSORLDWWHQGXGHELߖHQWDQWTXHPDUTXHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHOH[LVWHEHOHWELHQDXVVL
([HPSOHV
³ '%,²K೓(GDD¬N೓(PDQ೓(LELߖPDU೓(W೓(L\LELߖ¬%
% KDGD%NDPQDLELߖ%PDUWL\DLELߖ%
 DYHFSHXG·KRPPHV::%

³ 3+D% <@;<P% ?(MkM)೓ ( M(% g% (M1M-೓ ( M>(MGM"(M(M+೓ D¬ g% $೓ ( \PDL\¬  N೓ ( M-೓ ( WPD¬  LPDLELߖ¬ 
1M?(M)೓(M-೓(LELߖ¬DNXXQ೓Y(YDPD¬%
% YDߖQč%DKXUDPD]GčKDK%WD\DWPDL%NU૎K6M%LPDLELߖ%KࡃQDUDLELߖ%DNXQDYDP%
 3DUODYRORQWpG·$KXUD0D]GčFHTXHMHILV:QDYHFFHVFRPSpWHQFHVMH OH ILV
1RXVDYLRQVYXTXHOHV\QWDJPHSOXULHO´pWDLHQWSDVVpVµ۟DNWč%čKDQDYHF۟DNWč%HFM8H6K8G%HJLK7J%=>L78J>%JK%
čKDQWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQHGXSOXULHOpWDLWVDXYDJHPHQWHPSOR\pDXVVLSRXUOHGXHO1RXVSRXYRQVGRQFFRQVLGpUHU
TX·LOHQYDGHPrPHSRXUUDXFDELߖOHSOXULHOSRXUOHGXHO&HFLpWDQWDGPLVLOQRXVUHVWHjFRPSUHQGUHFRPPHQW
ODIRUPHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHODSXVHUYLUGHIRUPHGHQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLISOXULHO
,OQHIDXWSDVSHQVHUjXQSKpQRPqQHOLQJXLVWLTXHQDWXUHORXUDLVRQQDEOHjXQHFRQIXVLRQRXjXQUHFRXYUH
PHQWGHVGHX[FDVPDUTXDQWO·REMHWHQFRQWDFWGDQVOHFDGUHGHODWKpRULHGHVGHX[PRGqOHV :<6HORQFHWWHWKpRULH
O·REMHWHQFRQWDFWILJXUHjO·DFFXVDWLIVLO·REMHWSURVSHFWLIHVWH[SULPpDXORFDWLIPDLVjO·LQVWUXPHQWDOVLO·REMHW
SURVSHFWLIHVWH[SULPpjO·DFFXVDWLI
ੑ -HIUDSSHODWDEOHGXPDUWHDX
ੑ -HIUDSSHOHPDUWHDXVXUODWDEOH
3RXUOHYpGLTXHO·H[HPSOHFODVVLTXHELHQFRQQXHVWOHVXLYDQW
ੑ 56FViP<=5%9Ǩö0-૖ c("%?-૖ WUiPtQGUDє
 ,QGUDDWWHLJQLW17૖ K76DYHFOHIRXGUH

ੑ 56GQLMDJiQWKDKiQYRULQGUD4#6*#4>&
 ,QGUDWXDEDWWLVOHWRQQHUUHVXUOHVPkFKRLUHV GH17૖ K76 
$XOLHXGHQRXVLQYLWHUjHQYLVDJHUSDUHLOOHEL]DUUHULHODOHFWXUHGHO·$YHVWDQRXVSURSRVHXQHDXWUHVROXWLRQ
FHOOHTXHM·DLPLVHHQpYLGHQFHHQDXFROORTXHGH:U]EXUJ 3LUDUW /·$YHVWDDYDLWVXELGHQRPEUHXVHV
UHWRXFKHVJUDPPDWLFDOHVGDQVOHVpFROHVVDFHUGRWDOHVHWOHVGLDVFpYDVWHVLVVXVGHFHVpFROHVDYDLHQWDLQVLLQWURGXLW
GHQRPEUHXVHVDQRPDOLHVJUDPPDWLFDOHVGDQVOHVWH[WHVDQRPDOLHVDX[TXHOOHVMHIDLVXQHFKDVVHVDQVPHUFLGHSXLV
SOXVLHXUVDQQpHV'HQRPEUHX[FDVVRQWPLVO·XQSRXUO·DXWUHHWFHODGHIDoRQFRPSOqWHPHQWDUWLILFLHOOHpWDQW
GRQQpO·DPSOHXUSUHVTXHV\VWpPDWLTXHGXSKpQRPqQHHWOHIDLWTXHOHVDQRPDOLHVQHFRQFHUQHQWSDVVHXOHPHQW
O·HPSORLGHVFDVPDLVWRXVOHVFKDSLWUHVGHODJUDPPDLUHSKRQpWLTXHV\QWD[HPRUSKRORJLH&·HVWDLQVLTXHOD
PRUSKRORJLHGHVWKqPHVYHUEDX[HWO·HPSORLGHVGpVLQHQFHVVRQWHX[DXVVLIRUWWRXFKpV
/DUHWRXFKHSUpFLVHG·XQQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLISOXULHOFRQVLVWDQWjOXLGRQQHUOHVKDELWVGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOX
ULHOHVWPDVVLYHPHQWSUpVHQWHGDQVO·$YHVWDFRPPHMHO·DLPRQWUpHQGUHVVDQWODOLVWHGHVHVRFFXUUHQFHVSRXUOH
FRUSXVGHV<DߖW 3LUDUWIII &HSHQGDQWOHVUDLVRQVSRXUOHVTXHOOHVOHVWH[WHVIXUHQWGHODVRUWHVL
JUDYHPHQWFU\SWpVQRXVVRQWLQFRQQXHV

::
 /·DYHVWLTXH UpFHQW QH IDLW XVDJH GH FD̒LELߖ SURWRLQGRLUDQLHQ :Q
0LVSRXU´FHTXHM·DYDLVjIDLUHµ"
U F(#&#k  TXH SRXU OH GpPRQVWUDWLI ( PDLV HQ FKčQGDVD F!&+#є% :<
6XUFHWWHWKpRULH+DXGU\
FRQFXUUHQFHFRPSOqWHPHQW F(#є H[HPSOH56FPiUW\HEKLє 
6XUO·HPSORLGHKDGDDYHFO·LQVWUXPHQWDOYRLU6NM UY¡
 oi.uchicago.edu

% $120$/,(6*5$00$7,&$/(6­%ԣ627࢜1% OR@

&RPPHSDUDOOqOHVDYHVWLTXHVGHODVLWXDWLRQTXHQRXVDYRQVUHQFRQWUpHGDQVO·H[SUHVVLRQDFKpPpQLGHGHOD
GDWHRXQQRPLQDWLIQHXWUHSOXULHO۟DNWčV·RUGRQQHDYHFXQLQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHOUDXFDELߖLO\DSDUPLFHX[TXH
M·DLVLJQDOpV II OHVH[HPSOHVVXLYDQWV
³ <W
% '!‫و‬ੜ +!Yčߖ૎̾PKD‫ؾ‬5-̾ɘQčLWL <WD %
 D˗DXXLߖ೓:RSDRLULߖ೓%Z0I#$(>(@%
 \D۟DGöPıQVUDũɐWöLɐ% +E %
% :@
೓KࡃEöPLLD[ߖD̒WčL
 1RXVRIIURQVOHVDFULILFHj0L۟UD OHV UrQHV GXFKDUGHTXLWHQXHVVDQVHUUHXUSDU
ODGpHVVHǴUWL VRQWDXVVLQRPEUHXVHVTXHOHVrWUHVWUqVEHDX[HWOXPLQHX[ DXVVL
QRPEUHXVHVTXHOHVUD\RQV GXVSOHQGLGH6ROHLO>{GHVFHQGDQWGH6SLWčPD@ YRLU3LUDUW
 

³ <W
 
[UɫPöÝ !#7Ų˻012%ê:-(c#‫ؾ‬$(೓:P
 GčQXQıPQ?ED̒XXDU̾SDLWLQıP%FFF
 'pHVVHV)UDY‫ޠ‬WL 0HWWH]jIHXHWjVDQJOHV]RQHV TXLVRQWDX[PDLQV GHVP\ULDUTXHV
'čQDYD
'DQVOHSUHPLHUH[HPSOHOHVIRUPHVGHQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLIQHXWUHSOXULHOGčPıQ GčPčQ HWEčPLLD EčPD\č QO%
V·RUGRQQHQWDYHFFHOOHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOQHXWUHSOXULHOVUD̒ߖWčLߖ VUD\LߖWčLߖ 'DQVOHVHFRQGFHOOHGHQRPLQDWLIDF
FXVDWLIIpPLQLQSOXULHO[UࡃPčÝ  [UࡃPčK HVWDFFRUGpHDYHFFHOOHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOQHXWUHSOXULHO%(0̾ၹ&#k% čVDKELߖ%X%
čVDELߖ &DUIDXWLOVDYRLUOHVIRUPHVGHQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLIIpPLQLQSOXULHOVRQWWRXWDXVVLVRXYHQWXWLOLVpHVSRXU
OHQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLIQHXWUHSOXULHOTXHFHOOHVG·LQVWUXPHQWDOQHXWUHSOXULHO
/·K\SRWKqVHG·XQHPSORLGLDVFpYDVWLTXHGHODWHUPLQDLVRQG·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHOSRXUPDUTXHUOHQRPLQDWLI
DFFXVDWLISOXULHOSHUPHWGHUHQGUHFRPSWHGHODV\QWD[HpWUDQJHTXHPRQWUHQWG·DXWUHVSDVVDJHVGHO·LQVFULSWLRQ
GH%ҸVRWࡃQ([HPSOHV
³ '%,²DGDPD¬Q೓(M#M'MRM(M-೓(M'M>(%g%=M(M-೓(M+೓(M'M(%g%(M&M#M4೓(M-೓(M#Mk%g%5೓(M#M۟M(M>(M4೓(D¬
>(M(M)೓(M#M'M>(M4೓(D¬YL۟M&M#MkM4೓(D¬W೓(\DGLLߖ¬J೓(M1M>(M(M$೓D¬g%+೓(MZ \¬@PDJXXߖ¬DGL
#M)೓(D¬
% DGDP%QҸočUD\DPQ:%NčUDK\D%DELFDULߖ QQ%I68۟čPFD%QPöQL\DPFD%YL۟ELɐFD"WD\ö೓Q<%GLߖ%5೓(M1M
>(M(M$೓D¬g%KD\DK%PDJXߖ%DGLQčW
 PRLMHUHQGLVjO·DUPpHOHVFKDPSVHWOHVWURXSHDX[OHVHVFODYHVHWOHVGRPDLQHVGRQW
&RPpWqVOH0DJHO·DYDLWGpSRVVpGpH

ੑ '%,²1M$೓(M(g%(M&M#Mkg%)೓(M(M?#M#M'M(g%(M+೓D¬g%
% LK6%DEELɐ"QöYL\öK%čKDQ
 HWOHVHDX[ GX7LJUH pWDLHQWJURVVHV

:R
&LWpSDU<WD :P
,PSpUDWLISUpVHQW JSOXUDFWLYGHIUč¥%GMҸ YpGLTXHSUi.߳ԣ 

6LODSODFHV\QWD[LTXHGHFHPRW´QRPEUHXVHVµHVWLQGpWHUPLQDEOH FRQWUH*HOGQHU ² :-(G#‫ؾ‬$(
F·HVWTXHODSKUDVHHVWXQHWRLOHG·$UOHTXLQIDLWHG·XQHOLJQHUHSULVHj Q?
%-6HILJ%F78I8H6>J%GčQࡃQčP/HV'čQX OHV'čQDYDOHVGHVFHQGDQWV
<W¬DG·XQHOLJQHUHSULVHjXQIUDߖQDLQFRQQXTXHO·DXWHXUGX GH'čQX
<W¬FRQQDLVVDLWVDQVGRXWHHWG·XQHQVHPEOHGHGHX[OLJQHVGRQW QO
%EčP ( ##(HVWOHSDUWLFLSHSUpVHQWHQ F(GXGpQRPLQDWLIWLUpGH
ODSUHPLqUHDSSDUDvWDXVVLPDLVDYHFGDYDQWDJHG·jSURSRVJUDPPD EčPD´pFODWµ
WLFDOGDQVOH+E Q:
&DXVDWLIGHSURWRLQGRLUDQLHQ )É¥ߓUL¬NN%UQtߓUč\D\DPDYHFUpVRUS
:@
%-6HILJ%F78I8H6>J%KXYDQK%EčPD\č%[ߖDLWDK\D 3LUDUW 3LUDV WLRQGH ߓU೓F%JH%RHWGLVVLPLODWLRQGH F'('(F%JH%F-('(FS
 DQDO\VHPDOFHWWHOLJQHEčPLLDHVWpSLWKqWHGHGčPıQ2%JK% QQ
&HPRWHWOHVGHX[VXLYDQWVVRQWGHVVLQJXOLHUVFROOHFWLIV
[ߖD̒WčLJpQLWLIjIRUPHGDWLYHV·DFFRUGHDYHFKࡃ Q<
$FFXVDWLIQHXWUHSOXULHORXPR\HQQDQWVDQGKLIpPLQLQ

&I<WD
 oi.uchicago.edu

! QL%@/K<K*

ੑ '%,²(M)೓(M#M'%g%(MIM#M'M(%g%Z(@M+೓(MZ'M$೓(@M(%Zg@QR%(MIM#MkM#M>(%g%IM-೓(M(M&M-೓D¬g%
% DQ\DK%6=8%č%čK\DWD%^DEELɐߖLP%SDUčEDUDQ
 FRPPH O·DXWUH SDUWLHGHO·DUPpH IXWMHWpHjODULYLqUHOHVHDX[O·HPSRUWqUHQW

'DQVOHSUHPLHUGHFHVSDVVDJHVODFRRUGLQDWLRQGHYL۟ELߖF2IRUPHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHOGHYL۟IpP´FODQµQ@%
DYHFOHVDFFXVDWLIVTXLSUpFqGHQWERLWHXVHGXIDLWGHODGLIIpUHQFHGHFDVPDLVSRXUWDQWDFFHSWpHSDU.HQWTXL
YRXODLW\YRLUXQLQVWUXPHQWDOHPSOR\p´DVDJHQHUDOFDVHIRUPDGGHGDVWKHODVWRIDVHULHVRIDFFXVDWLYHV2Y%JH%
HVWpFODLUpHQPOHPDQTXHGHFRQFRUGDQFHHQFDVGXV\QWDJPHDEELߖ%QčYL\čKGXGHX[LqPHWRXWDXVVLELHQLOHQYD
DXVVLGHPrPHGDQVOHWURLVLqPHSRXUODPDUTXHLQVWUXPHQWDOHHQELߖGXVXMHW ^DEELߖFGHSDUčEDUDQ%=FL7%6LK6HK%
TXHQRXVDFFHSWLRQVGHFRUULJHUO·DEHUUDQWDSLߖLPD¬JH%^DELߖLPD¬/DIDXWHVHUDLWGXHjXQHSHUVpYpUDWLRQ
GHSXLV6=8%čORFDWLIVLQJXOLHUGH6=IpP´ULYLqUHµ<?pWRIIpGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQč<O%
%DUWKRORPDH FRO RX.HQW  SURSRVDLHQWSRXUOHVGHX[IRUPHVDWWHVWpHVHQ'%,²GH
UHFRQQDvWUHXQWKqPHHQ FҸ અOHTXHOSRXUrWUHLQVROLWHDXUHJDUGGHODFRPSDUDLVRQGHVODQJXHVLQGRLUDQLHQQHV
DQFLHQQHVHVWDGKRF(MIM#M k FHQVHUDLWOHQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUHWVHORQXQHPRUSKRORJLHHWXQHSKRQpWLTXHPDO
H[SOLFLWpHVDSL\D¬OHORFDWLIVLQJXOLHU
3RXU5GLJHU6FKPLWW  2%>J9%GF7MJ9%DSL\D¬%JK%(MIM#MFUHSUpVHQWHQWWRXWHVGHX[OHORFDWLIVLQJXOLHU
6=8 č GH6=µULYLqUHµODVHFRQGHSKUDVHDSLߖLPD¬SU೓(DEU೓D¬ gVHUDLWFRQVWUXLWHLPSHUVRQQHOOHPHQW ´ DQG 
LQWKHZDWHULWFDUULHGLWDZD\µ EL]DUUHULHELHQDGKRF
'DQVOHGHX[LqPHH[HPSOH.HQWIDLVDLW  GHDELߖ¬XQLQVWUXPHQWDOGHFDXVH<:HWGHQ೓(DYLL\D¬2%
FRQWUHFHTXHVXJJqUHODFRPSDUDLVRQGHVODQJXHVLQGRLUDQLHQQHVXQDEVWUDLWIpPLQLQVLQJXOLHU´RQDFFRXQWRI
WKHZDWHUVWKHUHZDVQDYLJDELOLW\µ
5FL7%MF82%>J%9EHK6IMJ%DEELߖ%QčYL\čKPDULHODIRUPHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHOHQELߖGXVXEVWDQWLI6=´HDXµ<Q%
DYHFFHOOHDWWHQGXHGHQRPLQDWLIGHVRQDWWULEXWQčYL\čK´QpFHVVLWDQWXQHEDUTXHµ<<WRXWFRPPHOHV\QWDJPH
UDXFDELߖ%۟DNWčTXLQRXVDRFFXSpFRPELQDLWO·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHOHQELߖGXVXEVWDQWLIUDXFDKDYHFFHOOHDWWHQGXH
GHQRPLQDWLIGHVRQDWWULEXW۟DNWč
$MRXWRQVTXHO·HPSORLQRQDWWHQGXGHELߖH[LVWHDXVVLSRXUO·DEODWLISOXULHOWDQWj3HUVpSROLVTXHGDQVO·$YHVWD
³ '3K²LPD[ߖoPD¬W೓(\¬DGDPD¬GDDU೓(\DPLL\¬K೓(M4೓(M(g%0M=೓(LELߖ¬W೓(\L\¬
IM-೓D¬g%0M1M5೓(GDPD¬DPDW೓D¬g%'M(M$೓(D¬DNXXߖD¬K೓(M4೓(D¬K೓(LGDXYD¬DPDW೓D¬g%'M(M$೓(D¬
D¬VSU೓(GDD¬W೓(\PDL\¬DXU೓(PD]GDD¬IU೓(M(M&M-೓D¬g%+೓(\¬PD۟M#MkM$೓D¬g%&M5೓(M(M)೓(DPD¬%
% 8M6K%[ߖDoDP%K6E6K%DGDP%GčUD\čPL%KDFč%VDNDLELߖ%K6E68%SDUDK%VXJGDPN%(M>(M$೓(g%'M(M$೓(M(g%
č%NࡃߖčW%KDFč%KLQGDX¬g೓<R%(M>(M$೓D¬ g%'M(M$೓(D¬%č%VSDUGčW%WD\DWPDL%DKXUDPD]GčK%IUčEDUDW%
KD\DK%M6۟LߖWDK%EDJčQčP
 9RLFLO·(PSLUHTXHPRLMHWLHQVGHSXLVOHV6F\WKHVTXLVRQWDXGHOjGHOD6RJGLDQH
MXVTX·jOD1XELH HW GHSXLVO·,QGHMXVTX·jOD/\GLH O·(PSLUH TX·$KXUD0D]GčOHSOXV
JUDQGGHVGLHX[PHFRQILD

QR
/DUHFRQVWLWXWLRQUHVWHIRUWGRXWHXVHODIRUPHDXUDLWpFKDSSpj <O
 DYHVWLTXHDSĤLLD <WE 
ODYLJLODQFHGHODGLDVFpYDVHTXLDYDLWV\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWFKDQJpHQ <:
&I6FKPLWW´DQGEHFDXVHRIWKHZDWHUV WKHULYHU ZDV
DFWLYHVOHVGpVLQHQFHVPR\HQQHVGXSDVVLI SDVVDEOH RQO\ E\ERDWµ6NM UY¡´$QGLW WKH7LJULV ZDV

/HVDQGKLHQWUHYL۟HWELߖQ·DSDVpWpHIIHFWXp GHHSZLWKZDWHUVµ´KDGWREHFURVVHGE\VKLSEHFDXVHRIWKHZDWHUVµ
Q@
SURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ X੷ É=౥ FIYpGLTXHYtߓDYHVWLTXHYҸV YRLU 2QSRXYDLWHQFRUHLPDJLQHUXQLQVWUXPHQWDOGHOLPLWDWLRQFRPSOp
0D\UKRIHU²YRO  PHQWGHO·DGMHFWLI´(W OH7LJUH pWDLWJURVHQHDXµ

.HQWFHTXH6NM UY¡ I UpIXWHHQGLVDQW´*G%bKF
<Q
 YpGLTXH("&+ÉєFIDYHVWLTXHDLɘLL‫ گ‬YRLU.HOOHQV 
JHWKHUZLWKWKHKRXVHV·ZHUHLQWHQGHGZHZRXOGQRWH[SHFWDQRWKHU <<
 YpGLTXHQčY\jDYHVWLTXHQčXXĤLLD/LWWpUDWXUHFKH]6FKPLWW
Fčµ 
QP
6NM UY¡  GLWH[SOLFLWHPHQWTXH´YL۟ELߖFOHDUO\IXQFWLRQV <R
3LUDUW
DVDFFSOXUSDUDOOHOZLWKWKHRWKHUDFFXVDWLYHVµ
<?
3URWRLQGRHXURSpHQ O :!IKLWWLWH+(IMYpGLTXH(IDYHVWLTXH
(I 0D\UKRIHU²YRO 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% $120$/,(6*5$00$7,&$/(6­%ԣ627࢜1% ORP

³ <YҸQ‫گ‬$ઝELߖXXDWıP$ઝED̒ߖ̾˼EҸߖYҸPDQ‫گ‬EDUDJUDP̾QWıP¬Ã
 Ñ+DXPD WRLTXLDVOHPHQWDOGpSOR\pVpSDUHQRXVGHVQXLVDQFHVGHVQXLVLEOHVTXL
9FHK%GLULHX[
&HWWHDXWUHDQRPDOLHGHO·HPSORLGHELߖSDUWDJpHSDUOHVLQVFULSWLRQVYLHX[SHUVHVHWOHVWH[WHVDYHVWLTXHVQRXV
FRQGXLWjSHQVHUTXHOHXUVGLDVFpYDVHVUHVSHFWLYHVUHOqYHQWG·XQHVHXOHHWPrPHWUDGLWLRQRXpFROHJUDPPDWLFDOH
'HX[FRQFOXVLRQVLPSRUWDQWHVVRQWjWLUHUGHFHWHPSORLGLDVFpYDVWLTXHGHODILQDOHELߖG·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHO
'·XQHSDUWQRXVGHYRQVELHQDGPHWWUHTXHGHWHOOHVLQVFULSWLRQVFRQVWLWXHQWXQELHQPDXYDLVWpPRLJQDJHGHFH
TX·DYDLWSXrWUHODODQJXHGpMjDQFLHQQHjODTXHOOH'DULXVOH*UDQGYRXOXWUHFRXULUDXVL[LqPHVLqFOHDYDQWQRWUH
qUH'·DXWUHSDUWVLFHFLPHWHQpYLGHQFHTXHGHVIDLWVGHGLDVFpYDVHSDUDOOqOHVjFHX[TXHQRXVUHQFRQWURQVGDQV
O·$YHVWDH[LVWHQWGDQVGHWHOOHVLQVFULSWLRQVQRXVGpWHQRQVXQEHODUJXPHQWFRQFHUQDQWODGDWDWLRQGHVWH[WHV
DYHVWLTXHVUpFHQWVOHXUFRPSRVLWLRQIRUFpPHQWDQWpULHXUHjGHWHOOHVUHWRXFKHVGLDVFpYDVWLTXHVGRLWDYRLUOH
GpEXWGXVL[LqPHVLqFOHRXODILQGXVHSWLqPHSRXU$!->#)10%()$!%X1!>SRXUDXWDQWELHQV€UTXHFRPPHLOHVW
PHVHPEOHWLOUDLVRQQDEOHGHOHSHQVHUGHWHOOHVSUDWLTXHVQHIXVVHQWSDVUpFXUUHQWHVVXUGHQRPEUHX[VLqFOHV

$EUpYLDWLRQV
'% *UDQGHLQVFULSWLRQGH'DULXV,J7j%ҸVRWࡃQ
'1E ,QVFULSWLRQEGH'DULXV,J7j1DTߖH5RVWDP
'3K ,QVFULSWLRQKGH'DULXV,J7j3HUVpSROLV
+ IUDJPHQWVGX+čG‫[گ‬W1DVN $YHVWD
56 ߭čNDO\DVD،KLWč ޾JYHGD
9 9LG̒YGčG UpFLWDWLIDYHVWLTXHGHODOLWXUJLHORQJXH
< <DVQD UpFLWDWLIDYHVWLTXHGHODOLWXUJLHORQJXH
<W <DߖW UHFXHLODYHVWLTXHGHVOLWXUJLHVEUqYHV

%LEOLRJUDSKLH
%DUWKRORPDH&KULVWLDQ
% OP?<% <.$#-()#04+!0%J~-$!-&14+6WUDVERXUJ.-7UEQHU
*HOGQHU.DUO)ULHGULFK
² <?!0$(2%"#!%+!#.#5!)%Su4+!-%"!-%@(-0!)YROXPHV6WXWWJDUW:.RKOKDPPHU
+DXGU\-HDQ
% OP@@% N;!>I.6#%"!0%4(0%!)%?U"#X1!g%#)$-6%"14$#6)%h%.;U$1"!%"!0%4(0%!)%#)"6M!1-6IU!)/HV+RPPHVHWOHV/HWWUHV
/\RQ/·+HUPqV
+RIIPDQQ.DUOHW%HUQKDUG)RUVVPDQ
  <?!0$#04+!%N(1$M%1)"%F.!]#6)0.!+-!,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW,QQVEUXFN,QVWL
WXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
.HOOHQV-HDQ
% OP@<% N!0%)6>0M-(4#)!0%"!%.;<?!0$(%HLWUlJH]XU,UDQLVWLN:LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW
  N!%?!-&!%(?!0$#X1!:LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW


7UDGXFWLRQ3LUDUW
 oi.uchicago.edu

! QL%@/K<K*

.HOOHQV-HDQHWeULF3LUDUW
² N!0%$!]$!0%?#!#.M(?!0$#X1!0YROXPHV:LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW
.HQW5RODQG*
% OPRQ% ,."%@!-0#()%D-(>>(-2%*!]$02%N!]#46)qPHpG$PHULFDQ2ULHQWDO6HULHV1HZ+DYHQ$PHULFDQ2UL
HQWDO6RFLHW\
/HFRT3LHUUH
  ´/DODQJXHGHVLQVFULSWLRQVDFKpPpQLGHVµ<4$(%/-()#4(²
% OPP@% N!0%#)04-#I$#6)0%"!%.(%@!-0!%(4+U>U)#"!g%$-("1#$%"1%?#!1]%I!-0!2%"!%.;U.(>#$!2%"1%&(&'.6)#!)%!$%"!%.;(-(>U!)2%
I-U0!)$U%!$%())6$U3DULV*DOOLPDUG
0D\UKRIHU0DQIUHG
OPP:;:??O% 8$'>6.65#04+!0%J~-$!-&14+%"!0%<.$#)"6(-#04+!)YROXPHV+HLGHOEHUJ&:LQWHU
3LUDUWeULF
  ´/HWUDLWHPHQWGHVODU\QJDOHVLQWHUYRFDOLTXHVHQYLHLODYHVWLTXHPpWULTXHµAu)4+!)!-%7$1"#!)%G1-%
7I-(4+9#00!)04+(:$²
  ´$QRPDOLHVJUDPPDWLFDOHVDYHVWLTXHVµP61-)(.%<0#($#X1!²
% :??<% /·pORJHPD]GpHQGHO·LYUHVVHpGLWLRQWUDGXFWLRQHWFRPPHQWDLUHGX+‫گ‬P6W‫گ‬G3DULV/·+DUPDWWDQ
  D1!--#!-0%";/-()g%$-("14$#6)0%())6$U!0%"!0%$!]$!0%(?!0$#X1!0%"1%41.$!%G6-6(0$-#!)%-!)"1%(1]%"#!1]%*#k$-#'(2%
0L۟UDHW9-Ý۟UDJQD3DULV/·+DUPDWWDQ
3LUDV$QGUHD
% :???% +čG‫[گ‬W1DVN%:N%/.%-(446)$6%G6-6(0$-#()6%"!..(%06-$!%"!..;()#>(L%8"#G#6)!%4-#$#4(%"!.%$!0$6%(?!0$#46%!%I(+.(?#2%
$-("1G#6)!%!%46>>!)$65RPH,VWLWXWR,WDOLDQRSHUO·$IULFDHO·2ULHQWH
6FKPLWW5GLJHU
% OPPO% *+!%S#0#$1)%/)04-#I$#6)0%6:%H(-#10%$+!%D-!($%,."%@!-0#()%*!]$&RUSXV,QVFULSWLRQXP,UDQLFDUXP3DUW
,QVFULSWLRQVRI$QFLHQW,UDQ9ROXPH7KH2OG3HUVLDQ,QVFULSWLRQV7H[WV/RQGUHV&RUSXV,Q
VFULSWLRQXP,UDQLFDUXP
6FKZ\]HU(GXDUG
  ´'LHVRJPL‰EUlXFKOLFKHQ,QVWUXPHQWDOHLP$ZHVWDµ%/)"65!->()#04+!%F6-04+1)5!)²
6NM UY¡3URGV2NWRU
  <)%/)$-6"14$#6)%$6%,."%@!-0#()&DPEULGJH+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% *O8%@K,SN8A%,F%*O8%8KD<*/T8%3<78%/B%O/**/*8% 

!"
#$%&'()*+%,&)-&#$%&%(./#01%&2/3%&04&$0##0#%

3-(#5%A!.4+!-$2%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%3(.#:6-)#(2%N60%<)5!.!0

$VHVWDEOLVKHGE\/DURFKH  DJUDPPDWLFDOO\%QHXWHUQRXQFDQQRWIXQFWLRQLQ+LWWLWHDVWKHVXEMHFWRID

WUDQVLWLYHYHUEEXWPXVWEHUHSODFHGE\DVSHFLDOIRUPLQM()G(% DQWV LQWKHVLQJXODUDQGM()$!k%LQWKHSOXUDOO%
7KXVWKHUHJXODUQHXWHUQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHVLQJXODUNҸWXSSL´WKLVWDEOHWµLQ>@LVUHSODFHGE\NčߖWXSSLDQ]D
LQ>@
>@ NčߖD–NDQNҸWXSSLNXHGDQL%/3WLSDUčQHђђXQ
 ´2QWKHGD\RQZKLFK,VHQW\RXWKLVWDEOHWµ

>@ PDђђDQ–WDNčߖWXSSLDQ]DDQGDZHPL\D]]L
 ´:KHQWKLVWDEOHWUHDFKHV\RXµ

/LNHZLVHWKHUHJXODUQHXWHUQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHSOXUDOXGGčU´ZRUGVµLQ>@LVUHSODFHGE\XWWDQčQWHߖLQ>@:
>@ N̒O–NDQWXSSL\DߖXGGčUZDђQXߖL
 ´ $QGLI \RXDOWHUWKHZRUGVRIWKLVWDEOHWµ

>@ )(>>(–'(%(>>!.%{<%'808/Ô8OP/80(߰%XWWDQčQWHߖG*!.!I#)1#%=(-I#)%=(-"#>>#'($$()%
ߖčZDUe<*<AA<%(-()"1
 ´)XUWKHUPD\P\WKHPRUWDO·VZRUGVOLNHZLVHKDOWWKHLUHDQJHUDQGUHVHQWPHQW
RI7HOLSLQXµQ
$OOV\QFKURQLFDQDO\VHVRIWKLVSKHQRPHQRQNQRZQWRPHWDNHRQHRIWZREDVLFDSSURDFKHV  WKHIRUPVLQ
M()G(%DQGM()$!k%DUHQRPLQDWLYHVRIDQLPDWHVWHPVGHULYHGIURPWKHQHXWHUVZLWKDVXIIL[M()$M  WKH\DUHFDVH
IRUPVRIWKHXQGHUO\LQJQHXWHUQRXQVWKHPVHOYHV7KHUHDUHWZRYHUVLRQVRIWKHGHULYDWLRQDODQDO\VLV7KHILUVW
DQGPRVWSRSXODUSURSRVDOFODLPVWKDWWKHM()$M%VXIIL[´DQLPDWL]HVµRU´SHUVRQLILHVµWKHFRQFHSWH[SUHVVHGE\WKH
EDVHQRXQVHHDPRQJRWKHUV%HQYHQLVWH ² 1HX ² DQG7FKpNRII  
$VDOUHDG\DUJXHGE\*DUUHWW ² WKLVDQDO\VLVLVSDWHQWO\IDOVHEHFDXVHLWPDNHVZURQJSUHGLFWLRQV
LQWZRGLUHFWLRQV)LUVWLIWKHIXQFWLRQRIM()G(%DQGM()$!k%ZHUHWRLPEXHZLWK´DFWLYHIRUFHµQRXQVZLWKVHPDQ
WLFDOO\LQDQLPDWHUHIHUHQWVWKHQDOOVXFKQRXQVVKRXOGDSSHDULQWKLVIRUPZKHQIXQFWLRQLQJDVDJHQWV7KLVLV
IDOVLILHGE\QXPHURXVH[DPSOHVVXFKDV>@
>@ I(-)()G(–($%$(-)(1%#k$(-)#'(k–($%())(k)()G(%$(-)(1%4*\.1$$()G(–($%$(-)(1d%#k$(-)#'(k–($%
ђLODߖWDUQDX
 ´0D\WKHKRXVHUHOHDVHLWPD\WKHLQQHU(L%UHOHDVHLWPD\WKHZLQGRZUHOHDVHLW«
PD\WKHLQQHUFRXUW\DUGUHOHDVHLWµ

O
7KLVVWXG\IRFXVHVVROHO\RQWKHV\QFKURQLF&VWDWXVRI´13VSOLWHU
JDWLYLW\µLQ+LWWLWH1RVWDQFHLVWDNHQRQLWVSUHKLVWRU\IRUZKLFK
EHVLGHV *DUUHWW  VHH DPRQJ RWKHUV %HQYHQLVWH  ²
7FKpNKRII2HWWLQJHUE² ZLWKUHIHUHPFHV DQGHV
SHFLDOO\-RVHSKVRQ6HH5XPVH\DJDLQVW3URWR,QGR(XURSHDQ
DVDQHUJDWLYHODQJXDJH
:
1HXWHUQRXQVDOVRDSSHDULQWKHLUUHJXODUQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYH
IRUPDVWKHVXEMHFWVRILQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEV,OOXVWUDWLRQVVHHPXQQHF
HVVDU\
Q
7KHUHDUHDOVRPDWFKLQJIRUPVLQ/XYLDQ VLQJXODUM()$#k2%=>L76>%
M()$#)G# DQGLQ/\FLDQ SOXUDO̎WL ,NQRZRIQRHYLGHQFHLQ3DODLF
RU/\GLDQWRVXJJHVWWKDWWKLVIHDWXUHLVQRWDOUHDG\3URWR$QDWROLDQ


 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3K</D%A8N3O8K*

$OOIRXUVXEMHFWVRIWKHWUDQVLWLYHYHUE$(-)(1%´OHWUHOHDVHµUHIHUWRLQDQLPDWHREMHFWVDKRXVHDQGYDULRXV
SDUWVRIWKHKRXVH,IWKHIXQFWLRQRIM()G(%ZHUHSHUVRQLI\LQJWKHQLWVKRXOGDSSHDURQDOOIRXUDQGZHZRXOG
H[SHFW ђLODQ]DIRUWKHODVW,QIDFWKRZHYHURQO\JUDPPDWLFDOO\QHXWHUQRXQVDSSHDULQWKHIRUPM()G(%ZKHQ
WKH\DUHWKHVXEMHFWRIDWUDQVLWLYHYHUEZKLOHWKHJUDPPDWLFDOO\DQLPDWHQRXQђLODDSSHDUVDVDQRUGLQDU\
QRPLQDWLYHVLQJXODU
7KHFODLPWKDWWKHIXQFWLRQRIWKHVXIIL[M()$M%LVWRPDNHDQRXQ0!>()$#4(..'&DQLPDWH´DFWLYHµRU´SHUVRQLILHGµ
DOVRSUHGLFWVWKDWQRXQVZLWKDQLPDWHUHIHUHQWVVKRXOGQRWUHTXLUHWKHVXIIL[VLQFHWKH\DUHDQLPDWHDOUHDG\
+RZHYHUZHILQGDQWXђߖDQQDQ]DKF%DQWXђߖDWDU´SRSXODFHµ081860(߰ђD]NDUD '( )G(%WRWKHFROOHFWLYH081860(߰ђD]NDUD # %
´IHPDOHPXVLFLDQVµDQG/Ô0(߰9(.9(..( ) G(%WRWKHFROOHFWLYH/Ô0(߰9(.9(..(%´OLRQPHQµ VHHIRUWKHODVWWZR+RIIQHU
² 7KHVHH[DPSOHVFRQILUPWKDWLWLVWKH5-(>>($#4(.%JHQGHURIWKHQRXQWKDWLVWKHGHWHUPLQLQJIDFWRU
QRWWKHDQLPDF\RIWKHUHIHUHQW VHHWKHFRUUHFWREVHUYDWLRQRI3DWUL:Q )RUDQDGGLWLRQDODUJXPHQW
WKDWWKHIRUPVLQM()G(%DQGM()$!k%FDQQRWEHDQLPDWHVHHLPPHGLDWHO\EHORZ
6SRUDGLF&XVHRIWKHM()G(lM()$!k%GF7M9%IRUJHQXLQHSHUVRQLILFDWLRQLVDQHQWLUHO\GLVWLQFWPDWWHUWKDWGRHVQRW
DOWHUWKHLUIXQGDPHQWDOJUDPPDWLFDOVWDWXV7KHGLIIHUHQFHZDVTXLWHFOHDUWRWKH+LWWLWHV7KHZRUGOLQJčL´RDWKµ
DQLPDWHJHQGHU ZDVZULWWHQ$NNDGRJUDSKLFDOO\DVB/{%3*+4*,MN/A%DQGKDGDQRUGLQDU\QRPLQDWLYHSOXUDOOLQJčHߖ
´RDWKVµ+RZHYHURDWKVDVGHLWLHVWKDWSXUVXHWKRVHZKREUHDNDQRDWKZHUH.#)=#'()$!k2%ZULWWHQB/{%',1*,50(߰2%6%
FRPELQDWLRQWKDWPDNHVQRVHQVHLQ$NNDGLDQEXWUHIOHFWVWKH+LWWLWHV·VHQVHWKDWWKH.#)=#'()$!k%ZHUHSHUVRQLILHG
GHLWLHVWKXV',1*,50(߰ VHH*WHUERFNDQG+RIIQHU² $VH[SHFWHGJUDPPDWLFDODQLPDWHJHQGHULV
DOVRXVHGIRUWKHVDPHSXUSRVH 4*\ђDWDONLߖ´KDZWKRUQµ QHXWHU LVUHSODFHGE\ 4*\ђDWDONLߖQDߖ DQLPDWH ZKHQDG
GUHVVHGDVDQDFWRULQDP\WK,VWUHVVWKDWQHLWKHURIWKHVHXVHVLVREOLJDWRU\ VHH.8%LL²ZKHUH´ILUH
VRQRIWKH6XQJRGµDSSHDUVDVQHXWHUSDђђXU QRUDUHWKH\OLPLWHGWRWKHUROHRIVXEMHFWRIWUDQVLWLYHYHUE7KHVH
WZRIHDWXUHVFOHDUO\GLVWLQJXLVKVXFKH[DPSOHVIURPWKHJUDPPDWLFDOO\UHTXLUHGVXEVWLWXWLRQEHLQJDQDO\]HGKHUH
$IXUWKHUGLIILFXOW\ZLWKWKHGHULYDWLRQDODQDO\VLVLVWKDWLIWKHM()G(lM()$!k%GF7M9%DL8>K%KF%HJLKJ7%HFLH9%DJ
ORQJWRDGHULYHGVWHPWKHQWKDWVWHPVKRXOGLQIOHFWIUHHO\LQDOOFDVHVDQGRFFXULQDOOHQYLURQPHQWVH[SHFWHG
RIDJUDPPDWLFDOO\DQLPDWHQRXQ&RPSDUHIXOO\LQIOHFWHG1$)! ' ()$M%´SRSXODWLRQµRUQDPHVRIVHDVRQVOLNH
G!)()$M%´DXWXPQµ7KHODWWHUPD\UHIOHFWWKHVDPHVXIIL["#(4+-6)#4(..' VHHWKHUHIHUHQFHVLQQRWHDERYH EXW
WKH\FDQQRWEHHTXDWHGV\QFKURQLFDOO\GXHWRWKHLUWRWDOO\GLIIHUHQWEHKDYLRUFRQWUD/DURFKH ² 
%HQYHQLVWH  DQGRWKHUV6XFKIRUPVLQM()G(lM()$!k%EXLOWWRQHXWHUVRFFXURQO\&DVVXEMHFWVRIWUDQVLWLYH
YHUEV)XUWKHUPRUHWKH\DUHLQVWULFWFRPSOHPHQWDU\GLVWULEXWLRQZLWKDOO RWKHU IRUPVRIWKHSDUDGLJPRIWKH
QHXWHUQRXQ<7KHSXWDWLYHGHULYHGDQLPDWHQRXQVZRXOGWKXVKDYHDVXVSLFLRXVO\GHIHFWLYHSDUDGLJP6HH3DWUL
² IRUVLPLODUDUJXPHQWV
7KHVHFRQGYHUVLRQRIWKHGHULYDWLRQDODQDO\VLVFODLPVWKDWWKHVXIIL[M()$M%9JJH%8H%M()G(lM()$!k%DOWHUVWKH
JUDPPDWLFDOJHQGHURIWKHEDVHQRXQIURPQHXWHUWRDQLPDWH,QWKHWUDGLWLRQDOWHUPLQRORJ\RI,QGR(XURSHDQ
OLQJXLVWLFVLWLVWKXVD´PRWLRQVXIIL[µ'HVSLWHKLVXVHRIWKHWHUP´HUJDWLYHµWKLVLVFOHDUO\WKHDQDO\VLVRI/DURFKH
 ´OHVXIIL[M()$M%HVWOHPDUTXHGX$-()0:!-$%";1)%#)()#>U%"()0%.(%4.(00!%()#>U!µ HPSKDVLVLQWKHRULJLQDO 6HH
OLNHZLVH/XUDJKL Q 7KLVDQDO\VLVLVIDOVHIRUWKHVDPHUHDVRQDVWKHILUVWSURSRVDODWUXHDQLPDWHJHQGHU
QRXQVKRXOGIXOO\LQIOHFWDVVXFK FRPSDUH/DWLQ"!(%´JRGGHVVµ"!10%´JRGµDQGRWKHUJHQXLQHPRWLRQVXIIL[HV 
2QFHDJDLQWKHUHLVQRH[SODQDWLRQIRUWKHFRPSOHPHQWDU\GLVWULEXWLRQZLWKDOORWKHUIRUPVRIWKHQHXWHUQRXQ
7KHUHLVDIXUWKHUDUJXPHQWDJDLQVWWKHFODLPWKDWWKHWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWIRUPVLQM()G(%DUHDQLPDWHJHQGHU%
7KHRQO\UHOHYDQWH[DPSOHVRIDQDSKRULFUHIHUHQFHDIILUPWKDWWKHJUDPPDWLFDOJHQGHURIWKHQRXQUHPDLQV
QHXWHU*DUUHWW  FLWHGRQHLQVWDQFH

>@ ߖXђђD–>(–=()%/!"#čUULQ–"$–=()%4!0%4*\\)+D]čUߖ]L
 ´7KHZDWHUZDVKHVWKHURRIDQGLWIORZVIURPWKHGUDLQSLSHµ

႐(G%LVDZULWLQJIRU9!$!)( ) GWKHWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWIRUPRIQHXWHUZčWDU´ZDWHUµZKLFKLVUHVXPHGE\M($2%
QHXWHUQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHVLQJXODURIWKHHQFOLWLFDQDSKRULFSURQRXQ´LWµ*DUUHWWH[SUHVVHGUHJUHWWKDWKH

<
7KHFRQWUDU\FODLPE\/XUDJKL  LVSDWHQWO\IDOVHDQGLVGXH
WRKHUIDLOXUHWRGLVWLQJXLVKWKHH[DPSOHVUHVWULFWHGWRWKHUROHRI
WUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWVIURPWKHWUXO\GHULYHGW\SH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% *O8%@K,SN8A%,F%*O8%8KD<*/T8%3<78%/B%O/**/*8% 

FRXOGSURYLGHRQO\DVLQJOHH[DPSOHEXWLQIDFWWKHUHLVDWOHDVWRQHRWKHUWKDWKHRYHUORRNHG .8%YHUVR
² 
>D@% )1–NiQ>'XWђDOL\DQNXL̒ߖNXHQQHUQX̒ߖђDUDSࡃߖߖDUQLZ#)=!-@
 ´7KRVHZKRNLOOHG7XWKDOL\DKDYHPDGHUHVWLWXWLRQIRUWKHEORRGVKHGµ

>E@% )1%ሳዼወዼወዼ҅DWWL–'(% ҅DWWXߖDߖXWQ̒ DSčߖ%&ђ"'"'#"DUђDQDPPD]LQQZ#$@

 ´7KDW567789:;8IXUWKHUILQLVKHGRIIWKHODQGRI+DWWLWRRµ

>F@% )–"$&ሳዼወዼወዼ҅DWWL–'(% ҅DWWXߖDߖXWQ̒\DQ]D NDUࡃߖDUQLNWD

 ´VRWKDWWKHODQGRI+DWWLWRRKDVPDGHUHVWLWXWLRQIRU<=µ

$Q\DWWHPSWWRGLVFRXQWWKLVH[DPSOHE\FODLPLQJWKDWWKHM($%RIFODXVH>F@LVGLUHFWO\UHVXPLQJWKHQHXWHU
GF7M%̒ߖђDURI>D@LVUHIXWHGE\WKHRYHUDOOUKHWRULFDOVWUXFWXUHRIWKHWH[W7KHUHSHWLWLRQRIWKHSKUDVHሳዼወ
ዼወዼ
҅DWWL–'(%´DQGDOVRWKHODQGRI+DWWLµ³ZLWKIURQWLQJRIWKHGLUHFWREMHFWRFFXUUHQFHLQ>E@VRDVWRDFKLHYHD
SUHFLVHPDWFKLQZRUGRUGHUZLWKWKHVXEMHFWRFFXUUHQFHLQ>F@³PDNHVLWDEVROXWHO\FOHDUWKDW>F@LVUHVXPLQJ
>E@)XUWKHUPRUHVLQFHWKH+LWWLWHZRXOGKDYHUHDG҅DWWXߖDߖXWQ̒ LߖђDQDQ]DLQ>E@DQG҅DWWXߖDߖXWQ̒ ' DQ]D ̒ߖђDU
LQ>F@WKHWZRFODXVHVZRXOGDOVRKDYHEHHQUHFLSURFDOLQIRUPDVZHOODVFRQWHQW
1HLWKHUYHUVLRQRIWKHGHULYDWLRQDODQDO\VLVLVYLDEOHKRZHYHUZHDUHWRH[SODLQWKHIRUPDO-!0!>&.()4!%DJ
WZHHQWKHVSHFLDOWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWIRUPVRIQHXWHUQRXQVDQGWKHQRPLQDWLYHVRIUHJXODUDQLPDWHVWHPVLQM()$M2%
WKHIRUPHUDUHQHXWHUQRWDQLPDWH
:HWXUQQRZWRWKHVHFRQGDOWHUQDWLYHM()G(lM()$!k%LQWKHIRUPVXQGHUGLVFXVVLRQDUHLQIOHFWLRQDOHQGLQJV
PDUNLQJDFDVHRIWKHQHXWHUQRXQV+HUHDJDLQZHKDYHWZRFRPSHWLQJSURSRVDOV7KHILUVWLVWKDWRI3DWUL 
² RZKRDUJXHVWKDWM()G(%LVDQDOORPRUSKRIWKHDEODWLYHLQVWUXPHQWDOHQGLQJ+HFLWHVH[WHQVLYHFURVV
OLQJXLVWLFHYLGHQFHIRUWKHSUHVXPHGV\QWD[WKDWLVZKHUHRQHPLJKWH[SHFWDQLQDQLPDWHQRXQWRDSSHDUDVWKH
VXEMHFWRIDWUDQVLWLYHYHUELWDSSHDUVLQVWHDGLQWKHDEODWLYHLQVWUXPHQWDO7KLVDQDO\VLVLVTXLWHFRPSDWLEOHZLWK
WKH+LWWLWHIDFWVLQV\QWDFWLFWHUPVEXWLWLVZKROO\LPSRVVLEOHRQIRUPDOJURXQGV
'879K2%M()G(%LVDQDOORPRUSKRIWKH+LWWLWHDEODWLYHHQGLQJIRURQO\DKDQGIXORIQHXWHUQRXQV VHFXUHO\IHZHU
WKDQWHQ 3DWUL·VFODLPWKDWM()G(%LVWKHSUHIHUUHGDEODWLYHHQGLQJIRU+LWWLWHQHXWHUQRXQVLVVLPSO\IDOVH7KH
YDVWPDMRULW\RI+LWWLWHQHXWHUQRXQVDUHDWWHVWHGRQO\%ZLWKWKHUHJXODUHQGLQJM(G7KHIDFWWKDWGXHWR´QDVDO
UHGXFWLRQµWKHWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWHQGLQJM()G(% >DQWV@ RFFDVLRQDOO\DSSHDUVDVM(G%LQQRZD\DOWHUVWKHIDFWWKDW
LWVXQGHUO\LQJIRUPLVDQWVZKLOHWKDWRIWKHUHJXODUDEODWLYHHQGLQJLQFOXGLQJIRUDOPRVWDOOQHXWHUQRXQV
LVDWV
6HFRQGWKH+LWWLWHDEODWLYHLVLQGLIIHUHQWWRQXPEHU7KHSOXUDOLVDOVRRQO\M(GQHYHUM()$!k%+HQFHDSOXUDO
OLNHXWWDQčQWHߖLQH[DPSOH>@DERYHFDQQRWSRVVLEO\EHDQDEODWLYH7KHDWWHPSWRI3DWUL  WRWUHDWVXFK
GF7M9%8H%M()$!k%DVEHORQJLQJWRGHULYHGVWHPVLQM()$MLVQRWUHPRWHO\FUHGLEOH$OOEHORQJWRQHXWHUQRXQVWKDW
VKRZQRRWKHUFDVHIRUPVLQM()$M7KHUHODWLRQVKLSRIUHJXODUQHXWHUQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHSOXUDOZLGčU´ZDWHUVµ
WRWKHH[FOXVLYHO\WUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWIRUP9#$!)()$!k%LVDEVROXWHO\SDUDOOHOWRWKDWRIUHJXODUQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYH
98HIL>67%ZčWDU´ZDWHUµWRWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWIRUP9#$!)()G($Q\YLDEOHDQDO\VLVRIWKLVSKHQRPHQRQPXVWWUHDW
WKHPDOLNH
7KLUGWKHWUXH+LWWLWHDEODWLYHDOZD\VVKRZVUHJXODUDJUHHPHQWZLWKSURQRPLQDODQGRWKHUPRGLILHUV&RQWUDVW
DEODWLYHN̒]WXSSL\D]´ZLWKIURPWKLVWDEOHWµYHUVXVNčߖWXSSLDQ]DLQ>@DQG#k$(-)#'(k%())(k)()G(%LQ>@DERYH,ILQG
3DWUL·VDWWHPSW ² WRH[SODLQWKHODWWHUSDWWHUQHQWLUHO\FLUFXODU6HHIXUWKHUEHORZRQWKHDJUHHPHQW
SDWWHUQRIWKHWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWIRUPVRIQHXWHUQRXQV

R
,DPLPPHQVHO\JUDWHIXOWR6\OYDLQ3DWULIRUJHQHURXVO\PDNLQJ
DYDLODEOHWRPHLQDGYDQFHRISXEOLFDWLRQWKHFRPSOHWHWH[WRIKLV
PRQRJUDSKWKDWWUHDWVWKHSUHVHQWWRSLFDPRQJRWKHUDVSHFWVRI
DOLJQPHQWLQ+LWWLWHDQGWKHRWKHUDQFLHQW,QGR(XURSHDQODQJXDJHV
RI$QDWROLD+HDOVRSDWLHQWO\WULHGWRH[SODLQWRPHLQHPDLOFRU
UHVSRQGHQFHFHUWDLQGHWDLOVRIKLVDQDO\VLVWKDW,IRXQGSX]]OLQJ,
UHJUHWWKDW,FDQQRWUHPRWHO\DFFHSWKLVDQDO\VLVDQGWKDWGHVSLWH
KLVEHVWHIIRUWV,VWLOOGRQRWIXOO\XQGHUVWDQGVRPHDVSHFWVRIKLV
SURSRVDO)RUWXQDWHO\WKRVHLQWHUHVWHGFDQQRZUHDGKLVZRUNLQIXOO
IRUWKHPVHOYHV

1DVDOUHGXFWLRQLQ+LWWLWHDIIHFWVQEHIRUHDOOVWRSVDQGWKHDI
IULFDWHWV,WPD\UHIOHFWDSURQXQFLDWLRQZLWKDQDVDOL]HGYRZHO
LQWKHSUHVHQWLQVWDQFH>mWV@ RUWRWDOORVV >DWV@ ,QHLWKHUFDVHWKH
XQGHUO\LQJIRUPUHPDLQVXQDIIHFWHG&RPSDUHWKHFDVHRIWKHSUHV
HQWLQGLFDWLYHDFWLYHWKLUGSOXUDOHQGLQJDQWVLZKLFKVRPHWLPHV
6==J679%69%M3(MG#LQVRPHVWHPFODVVHVKRPRQ\PRXV RUPHUHO\KR
PRJUDSKLF" ZLWKWKHSUHVHQWWKLUGVLQJXODUHQGLQJDWVL1RRQH
ZRXOGRQWKLVDFFRXQWVHULRXVO\SURSRVHWKDWWKHVLQJXODUDQGSOXUDO
HQGLQJVDUHWKHVDPH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3K</D%A8N3O8K*

)LQDOO\DVLQGLFDWHGDERYH QRWH WKHDSSHDUDQFHRIVSHFLDOWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWIRUPVIRUQHXWHUQRXQVLVD

IHDWXUHVKDUHGZLWK+LWWLWHE\/XYLDQDQG/\FLDQ7KHRQO\%DWWHVWHGIRUPRIWKHDEODWLYHLQVWUXPHQWDOLQ/XYLDQLV
DGLDQGLQ/\FLDQM!l("#,WLVTXLWHLPSRVVLEOHWKDWWKHQHXWHUWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWIRUPVM()$#0lM()$#)G#%RI/XYLDQ
DQG̎WLRI/\FLDQDUHV\QFKURQLFDEODWLYHLQVWUXPHQWDOV7KLVIDFWDQGWKHRWKHUVMXVWFLWHGGHILQLWLYHO\H[FOXGH
3DWUL·VDQDO\VLVLQWHUPVRIDQDEODWLYHLQVWUXPHQWDO
:HFRPHILQDOO\WRWKHDQDO\VLVRI*DUUHWW  E\ZKLFKWKH+LWWLWHWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWVLQM()G(lM()$!k%DQG
WKHPDWFKLQJIRUPVLQ/XYLDQDQG/\FLDQDUHHUJDWLYHFDVHIRUPVRIQHXWHUQRXQV³DVSDUWRIDV\VWHPRI´13VSOLW
HUJDWLYLW\µ'HVSLWHZLGHVSUHDGEXWVSHFLRXVDUJXPHQWVWRWKHFRQWUDU\DOODWWHVWHG+LWWLWHIDFWVDUHIXOO\FRPSDW
LEOHZLWKVXFKDQDQDO\VLV)LUVWQHXWHUQRXQVGRVKRZWKHH[SHFWHGEHKDYLRURIHUJDWLYHDOLJQPHQWWKH\DSSHDU
LQRQHIRUPLQWKHUROHRIWUDQVLWLYHREMHFWDQGLQWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFW ´2µDQG´6µIXQFWLRQV EXWLQDQRWKHULQWKH
UROHRIWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFW ´$µIXQFWLRQ 2QHPD\ZLWKRXWKDUPUHWDLQWKHWUDGLWLRQDOODEHOQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYH
IRUWKHIRUPHUEXW+LWWLWHIRUPVOLNHVLQJXODUZčWDU´ZDWHUµDQGSOXUDOZLGčU´ZDWHUVµDUHSURSHUO\DEVROXWLYHV
ZLWK*DUUHWW FRQWUDVWLQJZLWKWKHHUJDWLYHVLQJXODUDQGSOXUDO9#$!)()G(l9#$!)()$!k@
6HFRQGWKH+LWWLWHDOLJQPHQWV\VWHPIROORZVWKHZHOOHVWDEOLVKHGDQLPDF\KLHUDUFK\RI6LOYHUVWHLQ  
IRU13VSOLWHUJDWLYLW\E\ZKLFKWKHORZHURQWKHDQLPDF\VFDOHWKHPRUHOLNHO\DQRPLQDOZLOOIROORZDQHUJDWLYH
DEVROXWLYHSDWWHUQWKHKLJKHUWKHDQLPDF\WKHPRUHOLNHO\LWZLOOIROORZDQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHSDWWHUQ VHH
DOVR'L[RQUHSHDWHGDQG/D]DUG²FRQWUD%HQYHQLVWH $VQRWHGE\5XPVH\
 O: WKH+LWWLWHSDWWHUQLVWKXVW\SRORJLFDOO\WULYLDO+LWWLWH$QDWROLDQLVXQXVXDORQO\LQPDNLQJWKH
VSOLWDWWKHYHU\ORZHVWSRVVLEOHSRLQWRQWKHVFDOHZLWKRQO\QHXWHUQRXQVWDNLQJHUJDWLYHDEVROXWLYHDOLJQPHQW
ZKLOHDOORWKHUQRPLQDOVWDNHQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHDOLJQPHQW1HYHUWKHOHVVWKH$XVWUDOLDQODQJXDJH0DQJDUD\L
IXUQLVKHVDFORVHSDUDOOHOOLNHZLVHVKRZLQJHUJDWLYHDEVROXWLYHDOLJQPHQWRQO\IRULQDQLPDWHQRXQV3DWUL 
 GHQLHVWKHYDOLGLW\RIWKLVFRPSDULVRQFODLPLQJWKDWLQ+LWWLWHWKHEDVLVIRUWKHVSOLWLVJUDPPDWLFDOJHQGHU
ZKLOHLQ0DQJDUD\LWKHVSOLWUHIOHFWVWKHVHPDQWLFDQLPDF\LQDQLPDF\RIWKHQRXQ7KHYDOLGLW\RIWKHODWWHUFODLP
LVEHOLHGE\WKHIDFWWKDWLQ0DQJDUD\LGRJVDQGZLQGDUHJUDPPDWLFDOO\DQLPDWHZKLOHFKLOGUHQGHDGSHRSOH
ZDOODEHHVDQGNDQJDURRVDUHQRW ,FLWHWKHVHH[DPSOHVDWUDQGRPIURP0HUODQ ,WLVWUXHWKDWLQ+LWWLWHDV
LQPRVW,QGR(XURSHDQODQJXDJHVWKHQXPEHURIQRXQVZLWKLQDQLPDWHUHIHUHQWVWKDWVKRZDQLPDWHJUDPPDWL
FDOJHQGHULVXQXVXDOO\KLJKEXWWKHGLIIHUHQFHYHUVXVDODQJXDJHOLNH0DQJDUD\LLVPHUHO\DPDWWHURIGHJUHH
0DQJDUD\LDOVRFRQILUPVWKDWDODQJXDJHFDQHDVLO\VKRZ13VSOLWHUJDWLYLW\ZLWKRXWDQ\HUJDWLYHYHUEDOPRU
SKRORJ\ VHHWKHH[DPSOHVFLWHGEHORZ 7KHDEVHQFHRIHUJDWLYHYHUEDOPRUSKRORJ\LQ+LWWLWHLVWKXVQRWDYDOLG
DUJXPHQWDJDLQVWDVVXPLQJ13VSOLWHUJDWLYLW\ FRQWUD&DUUXED 
$OWKRXJKIHZVFKRODUVKDYHPDGHWKHSRLQWH[SOLFLW DSSDUHQWO\ILQGLQJWKHPDWWHUVHOIHYLGHQW WKHUHFDQ
EHOLWWOHGRXEWWKDWWKHNH\IDFWRUFRQWULEXWLQJWRWKHZLGHVSUHDGYLHZWKDWWKHWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWVLQM()G(%67J%
DQLPDWHQRPLQDWLYHV GHVSLWHWKHFOHDUHYLGHQFHWRWKHFRQWUDU\FLWHGDERYH LVWKHDWWHVWHGDJUHHPHQWSDWWHUQ
ZLWKGHPRQVWUDWLYHVDQGDGMHFWLYHV,QNčߖWXSSLDQ]D´WKLVWDEOHWµLQH[DPSOH>@WKHIRUPRINčߖ´WKLVµLVWKDWRI
DQDQLPDWHQRPLQDWLYHVLQJXODU³OLNHZLVHWKDWRI#k$(-)#'(k%´LQWHULRUµLQ#k$(-)#'(k%())(k)()G(%LQH[DPSOH>@,
IROORZ*DUUHWW ² LQUHJDUGLQJWKLVDJUHHPHQWSDWWHUQDVVXSSOHWLYHUHIOHFWLQJSDUDGLJPDWLFJDSV
'HVSLWHWKHSURWHVWVRI3DWUL  WKHUHLVQRWKLQJSUREOHPDWLFLQWKLVLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ2QHPD\FRPSDUHIRU
VLPLODUVXSSOHWLRQZLWKLQ+LWWLWHLWVHOIWKHV\VWHPRI2OG+LWWLWHHQFOLWLFSRVVHVVLYHDGMHFWLYHVZKHUHWKHLQVWUX
PHQWDOLVXVHGIRUWKHDEODWLYHDQGWKHQHXWHUQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHVLQJXODUIRUWKHSOXUDO#kk(G– 0 >#$%´IURP
WKHLUPRXWKVµ WKHUHEHLQJQRDEODWLYHSRVVHVVLYHIRUPjMk>(G DQGߖčNXZD–k>!$%´WKHLUH\HVµ IRUQRQRFFXUULQJ
ߖčNXZD–k>( 7KHUHLVQREDVLVIRUFODLPLQJWKDW#kk(G%PHDQLQJ´IURPWKHPRXWKµLVDQLQVWUXPHQWDOEHFDXVHWKH
DJUHHLQJSRVVHVVLYHMk>#$%LVDQLQVWUXPHQWDO LQ2OG+LWWLWHWKHLQVWUXPHQWDOQHYHUPHDQV´IURPµ ³QRUIRUVXS
SRVLQJWKDWߖčNXZD´H\HVµLVVLQJXODUEHFDXVHMk>!$%LVDIRUPDOVLQJXODU/LNHZLVHWKHQWKHUHLVDOVRQRMXVWLILFD
WLRQIRULQWHUSUHWLQJWKHQHXWHUHUJDWLYH$1II#()G(%DVDQLPDWHQRXQEHFDXVHRIWKHDJUHHLQJGHPRQVWUDWLYHNčߖ
,QDODQJXDJHZLWK13VSOLWDOLJQPHQWLWLVQRUPDOWKDWHDFKFODVVRIQRPLQDOIROORZVLWVRZQDOLJQPHQWV\VWHP
LQFOXGLQJPL[LQJWKHWZRDOLJQPHQWV\VWHPV#)%$+!%0(>!%4.(10!7KDWLVLQDWUDQVLWLYHVHQWHQFHZHH[SHFWWRILQG
DOOIRXUORJLFDOFRPELQDWLRQVDQLPDWHVXEMHFW QRPLQDWLYH DQLPDWHGLUHFWREMHFW DFFXVDWLYH DQLPDWHVXEMHFW

@
7KHFRQWUDU\FODLPRI3DWUL ²² LVEDVHG
HQWLUHO\RQKLVSUHVXPSWLRQ IRUZKLFKKHRIIHUVQRH[SOLFLWDUJX
PHQWV WKDWWKHM()G(lM()$!k%DUHJUDPPDWLFDOO\DQLPDWHZKLFKZH
KDYHVHHQDERYHLVIDOVH

,VWUHVVDJDLQWKDWWKHDUJXPHQWVKHUHDUHPHDQWWRDSSO\SXUHO\
WRWKHV\QFKURQLFVWDWXVRIWKHIRUPVLQTXHVWLRQ,SHUVRQDOO\YLHZ
WKHDWWHVWHGDJUHHPHQWSDWWHUQDVSUREOHPDWLFIRUWKHGLDFKURQLF
DFFRXQWRI*DUUHWW  EXWWKDWUHPDLQVDQHQWLUHO\VHSDUDWHLVVXH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% *O8%@K,SN8A%,F%*O8%8KD<*/T8%3<78%/B%O/**/*8% 

QRPLQDWLYH QHXWHUGLUHFWREMHFW DEVROXWLYH QHXWHUVXEMHFW HUJDWLYH DQLPDWHGLUHFWREMHFW DFFXVDWLYH 

QHXWHUVXEMHFW HUJDWLYH QHXWHUGLUHFWREMHFW DEVROXWLYH 6LQFHLQP\H[SHULHQFHVRPHFROOHDJXHVDSSHDUWR
ILQGWKLVXQQDWXUDO,FLWH0DQJDUD\LSDUDOOHOVIRUWKHUHVSHFWLYH+LWWLWHFRQVWUXFWLRQV,LQFOXGHDOVRLQWUDQVLWLYH
VHQWHQFHVLQSDUWWRVKRZWKDWLQERWKODQJXDJHVWKHYHUEDOPRUSKRORJ\LVWKHVDPHIRUERWKQRPLQDWLYHDQG
HUJDWLYHVXEMHFWV7KH0DQJDUD\LIDFWVDUHWDNHQIURP0HUODQ ²DQGSDVVLP 

(!)*'+$%,'-
/><?@=;&A47?<>@=<B;C
(8KK8KJN% G
7HOLSLQXߖ O̒ODQL\DQ]D XHW
 $QLP1RP6LQJ $QLP1RP6LQJ 3UHW6LQJ
 ´7HOLSLQXFDPHLQDIXU\µ OLW´7HOLSLQXIXULRXVFDPHµ
06HI676E8N%% ‫و‬D‫ד‬DJD˂XJX ‘M'(Mc
% )HP1RPZRPDQ 6LQJJR33
 ´7KHZRPDQZHQWµ
0>@><?@=;&A/5976D=<B;C
(8KK8KJN%% ᄽ႕ᅡ!kk(-–>(% ዝ႐ᇹዠዠᇹ% <?%5#I!kk(-% =($$(% 1!$%
 1HXW$EV6LQJ-SDUW RIZRRG PHDVXUH GRZQ 3UHW6LQJ%
 ´7KHIRUWLILFDWLRQRIZRRGFDPHGRZQ LHIHOO Jµ
06HI676E8N%% ‘M91>&(9(% ‘‫ד‬DQGL MLU ‘MD\JLQL ZXEXUJD ‫ؾ‬DEXQGDODQ
% 1HXW$EVRQH 1HXW$EVWUHHVWDQG6LQJ$X[3& KDOIZD\ 1/RFELOODERQJ1/RF
 ´2QHWUHHZDVVWDQGLQJLQWKHPLGGOHRIWKHELOODERQJµ
.!)*'+$%,'-"'/-0!)*'+$%,'
/><?@=;&3D5E;F=&@>8&/><?@=;&)5E;F=&A47?<>@=<B;&@>8&/FFD9@=<B;C
(8KK8KJN%% QX NXLWPDQP̒\DZDߖ–WHߖ ђDONLQ NDULSSDQ]L
% FRQMZKLOH $QLP1RP3OXU-SRVV $QLP$FF6LQJ ,QG3UHV3OXU
 ´$QGZKLOH\RXUIRXU KRUVHV GHYRXUWKHJUDLQ«µ
06HI676E8N%% ‫و‬D‫ד‬LQD ‫و‬D‫ד‬DEXJEXJ ZXUDQMLUDJ PDODPJDUD‫و‬DQ
% )HP1RP'LV)HP1RPROGSHUVRQ 6LQJ'XDOHDW33 PDQ'XDO$FF
% ´7KDWROGZRPDQDWHWKHWZRPHQµ
/><?@=;&3D5E;F=&@>8&0>@><?@=;&)5E;F=&A47?<>@=<B;&@>8&/5976D=<B;C
(8KK8KJN%% )1–G(% ቈዽ
SDWLOLߖ ZčWDU ᇾᅡዿᇀᇀ႐% GčL%
 FRQM-UHIO $QLP1RP6LQJ 1HXW$EV6LQJ 1HXW$EV6LQJ 3UHV6LQJ
 ´7KHI($#.#MSULHVWWDNHVZDWHU DQG ILQHRLOIRUKLPVHOIµ
06HI676E8N%% ‘‫ד‬DQGL PRG ‘PD\ ‫ؾ‬DPDODP
% 1HXW$EVWUHH FXW 6LQJ6LQJ$X[33 0DVF1RPPDQ
 ´7KHPDQFXWWKHWUHHGRZQµ
0>@><?@=;&3D5E;F=&@>8&/><?@=;&)5E;F=&A%GH@=<B;&@>8&/FFD9@=<B;C
(8KK8KJN%% )1% M.HߖߖLQ LGčODODZDQ]D ᇀᇹᇀDQ]D ђDU]L
% FRQM$QLP$FF6LQJ (UJ6LQJ 1HXW(UJ6LQJ 3UHV6LQJ
 ´$QHYLOVLFNQHVVKROGV.HVVLµ 1%DGMHFWLYHDOVRVKRZVHUJDWLYHHQGLQJ
0DQJDUD\LQRH[DPSOHFLWHGLQ0HUODQEXWVHHFRPPHQWRQSDQGFRPSDUHH[DPSOHVZLWKDQLPDWH
SURQRPLQDOREMHFWV
% ‫ؾ‬DED˂D% ǪDQJD‫و‬Lx ‫ؾ‬D‫و‬XJX xLP ǪDQJD‫و‬Lx
 0DVF1RPIDWKHU 6LQJ6LQJWDNH33 1HXW(UJZDWHU VXEPHUJH6LQJ6LQJ$X[33
 ´0\IDWKHUWRRN?;µ ´7KHZDWHUFRYHUHG?;µ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3K</D%A8N3O8K*

(8KK8KJN%% )1–9(–$" NXHGDQLP̒ђXQL% ቈዽበᅵዝዬᅵበᅵ%% ()"(% 9!>#'(G#

 FRQM-SDUW-WKHH $6LQJ  DWZKDWWLPH PHVVHQJHU$QLP3OXU SUHYHUE ILQG3UHV3OXU
 ´:KHQWKHMJ99JHIJ79UHDFKI7DVY
 PDђђDQ–$"% NčߖWXSSLDQ]D% ()"(% 9!>#'(GG#%
 ZKHQ-WKHH $6LQJ  WKLVWDEOHW(UJ6LQJ SUHYHUE ILQG3UHV6LQJ
 ´:KHQWKLVWDEOHW (UJ6LQJ UHDFKHVI7DVY
0>@><?@=;&3D5E;F=&@>8&0>@><?@=;&)5E;F=&A%GH@=<B;&@>8&/5976D=<B;C
(8KK8KJN%% QX ђDQQLߖQDQ]D ᅡᇹM!kk(-% ᅵᇀᇹወSD S̒ђXWHW
% FRQM 1HXW(UJ6LQJ1HXW$EV6LQJ EDFN 3UHW6LQJ
 ´7KHODZVXLWEURXJKWDODZVXLWLQUHWXUQµ LHDFRXQWHUVXLW
06HI676E8N%% ‫ؾ‬D‫ד‬DQGL MDF‫ؾ‬LGED FPD‫ؾ‬
% 1HXW(UJWUHH 6LQJ6LQJKDYH 1HXW$EVJXP
 ´7KHWUHHKDVJXPµ
1%SUHϮ[‫ؾ‬DLQ0DQJDUD\LPDUNV0DVF1RP1HXW(UJDQG1HXW,QVWU
,QVXPRIWKHDQDO\VHVSUHVHQWHGWKXVIDUIRU+LWWLWHWUDQVLWLYHVXEMHFWVLQM()G(lM()$!k%DL8>K%KF%HJLKJ7%HFLH92%FH>E%
WKH13VSOLWHUJDWLYLW\DQDO\VLVRI*DUUHWW  LVFRPSDWLEOHZLWKDOOWKHDWWHVWHGIDFWV

/55G;B<@=<7>9
.8% $OEUHFKW*|W]HO#0$6-#04+!%*!]$!.HLOVFKULIWXUNXQGHQDXV%RJKD]N|L%HUOLQ6WDDWOLFKH
0L9JJH2%
.8% .DVSDU.5LHPVFKQHLGHU,>#)(2%K#$1(.!%1)"%.#$!-(-#04+!%*!]$!%#)%+!$+#$#04+!-%7I-(4+!2%G1>%*!#.%#>%
(.$!)%H1=$10.HLOVFKULIWXUNXQGHQDXV%RJKD]N|L%HUOLQ$NDGHPLH9HUODJOP@:

*<56<7HG@J:I
%HQYHQLVWH2ePLOH
  ´-J9%9LD9K6HK8G9%JH%M()$%GX+LWWLWHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%²
"677LD62%&HFG78F%
  ´/HQRWD]LRQLGHOO·DJHQWHDQLPDWRQHOOHOLQJXHDQDWROLFKH HO·HUJDWLYR µ,Q@!-%1)(%5-(>>($#4(%#$$#$(2%
HGLWHGE\2&DUUXEDSS²3DYLD,XFXODQR
'L[RQ5REHUW0:
  ´(UJDWLYLW\µN()51(5!%²
% OPP<% 8-5($#?#$'&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
*DUUHWW$QGUHZ
  ´7KH2ULJLQVRI136SOLW(UJDWLYLW\µN()51(5!²
*WHUERFN+DQVDQG+DUU\+RIIQHU
  *+!%O#$$#$!%H#4$#6)(-'%6:%$+!%,-#!)$(.%/)0$#$1$!%6:%$+!%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%3+#4(56&KLFDJR7KH2ULHQWDO,QVWL
WXWH
(FGGHJ72%(677E%
  ´)URPWKH'LVFLSOLQHVRID'LFWLRQDU\(GLWRUµP61-)(.%6:%31)!#:6->%7$1"#!0%²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% *O8%@K,SN8A%,F%*O8%8KD<*/T8%3<78%/B%O/**/*8% 

-RVHSKVRQ)RONH
  ´6HPDQWLFVDQG7\SRORJ\RI+LWWLWHM()$MLY%*H%/)"6M81-6I!()%J6-"%F6->($#6)%^3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH&RQ
IHUHQFH+HOGDWWKH8QLYHUVLW\RI&RSHQKDJHQ2FWREHUWK²QG %HGLWHGE\-&ODFNVRQDQG
%¬$2OVHQSS²&RSHQKDJHQ6WXGLHVLQ,QGR(XURSHDQ&RSHQKDJHQ0XVHXP7XVFXODQXP
3UHVV
/DURFKH(PPDQXHO
  ´8Q¶HUJDWLI ·HQLQGRHXURSpHQG·$VLH0LQHXUHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%R@WON%
²
/D]DUG*LOEHUW
  <4$()4'(PSLULFDO$SSURDFKHVWR/DQJXDJH7\SRORJ\%HUOLQ0RXWRQGH*UX\WHU
/XUDJKL6LOYLD
% OPP@% O#$$#$!0XQLFK/LQFRP(XURSD
0DUD]]L0DVVLPLODQR
  ´+HWKLWLVFKH/H[LNRJUDSKLH3OH%/²1)DV]µ,-#!)$(.#(QV%²
0HUODQ)UDQFHVFD
  A()5(-('#/LQJXD'HVFULSWLYH6WXGLHV$PVWHUGDP1RUWK+ROODQG
1HX(ULFK
  ´=XP$OWHUGHUSHUVRQLIL]LHUHQGHQM()$M%%LOGXQJGHV+HWKLWLVFKHQ(LQ%HLWUDJ]XU*HVFKLFKWHGHU
LQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ*HQXVNDWHJRULHµO#0$6-#04+!%7I-(4+:6-04+1)5%²
&JKK8HIJ72%+F7DJ7K%
  ´1HXH*HGDQNHQEHUGDV)$M6XIIL[µ,Q<)($6.#04+%1)"%/)"65!->()#04+l<)($6.#46%!%/)"6!1-6I!62%HGLWHG
E\2&DUUXEDDQG:0HLGSS²,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW%*HH9
EUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKHQXQG/LWHUDWXUHQGHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
3DWUL6\OYDLQ
% :??@% N!0%0$-14$1-!0%";(.#5)!>!)$%"()0%.!0%.()51!0%#)"6M!1-6IU!))!0%";<)($6.#!6WXGLHQ]XGHQ%RJD]NR\
7H[WHQ:LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
,LM9JE2%!>6H%
  ´7KH&KLPHUDRI3URWR,QGR(XURSHDQ(UJDWLYLW\µN#)51(%²
6LOYHUVWHLQ0LFKDHO
  ´+LHUDUFK\RI)HDWXUHVDQG(UJDWLYLW\µ,QD-(>>($#4(.%3($!56-#!0%#)%<10$-(.#()%N()51(5!0HGLWHGE\5
0:'L[RQSS²&DQEHUUD$XVWUDOLDQ,QVWLWXWHRI$ERULJLQDO6WXGLHV
7FKpNRII&ODXGH
  ´/HGRXEOHFDVVXMHWGHVLQDQLPpHVXQDUFKDwVPHGHODV\QWD[H+LWWLWH"µS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)M
51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%²%
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <%@K,@,7%H8%N;,@@,7/*/,B%8B*K8%N8%7*<*/e\8%8*%N8%HYB<A/e\8%8B%O/**/*8% 

!"
#$%&'%'($)*$+,'%%'(-.-'/$*/.&*$+*$(.#.-01*$$
*.$+*$)2/#3-01*$*/$4-..-.*

A#4+!.%A(G6'!-2%\)#?!-0#$U%"!%@(-#0%/M@()$+U6)M76-&6))!

/HKLWWLWHjODVXLWHG·XQHpYROXWLRQSKRQpWLTXHDUpXQLVRXVXQHIRUPHXQLTXHXQFDVDEVWUDLWOHGDWLISURSUH
PHQWGLWHWXQFDVFRQFUHWOHORFDWLI/HJURXSHDLQVLFRQVWLWXpDpYLQFpOHGLUHFWLIO·DFFXVDWLIGHGLUHFWLRQUHVWDQW
HPEU\RQQDLUH/·H[WHQVLRQGXGDWLIORFDWLIDXGpWULPHQWGXGLUHFWLIDHXSRXUHIIHWFRPPHOHVRXOLJQH(/DURFKH
GHUXLQHUOHV\VWqPHDQDWROLHQGHVFDVFRQFUHWVTXLUHSRVDLWVXUO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHOHVWDWLTXHHWOHG\QDPLTXH
/DURFKH² /HVpWDSHVGHFHWWHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQRQWpWpUHFRQVWLWXpHVDLQVLSDU(/DURFKH
9RLFLWUqVVXFFLQFWHPHQWODVLWXDWLRQGXKLWWLWH
 /HGDWLIHQ!#%pYROXHHQ#%GHPrPHOHORFDWLIHQ#lM!#pYROXHHQ#L/HPrPHFDVHQKLWWLWHH[SULPHUDLW
GRQFDXWHUPHGHFHWWHpYROXWLRQOHVWDWLTXHHWOHG\QDPLTXH
 /H GLUHFWLI QH VXUYLW TXH FRPPH XQ DUFKDwVPH ELHQ DWWHVWp HQ YLHX[KLWWLWH LO HVW UHPSODFp
V\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWSDUOHGDWLIORFDWLI
 /HYLHX[ORFDWLIVDQVGpVLQHQFHQHVXEVLVWHTXHGDQVTXHOTXHVPRWV/HSDVVDJHGXORFDWLIDEVROXjOD
SRVWSRVLWLRQV·REVHUYHGDQVOHVUHFWLRQVSRVVHVVLYHVGXW\SH(>>!.%I!-()´GHYDQWPRLµ3DUWRXWDLOOHXUV
OHGDWLIORFDWLIV·LPSRVH
 /·DFFXVDWLI GH GLUHFWLRQ DWWHVWp QH VH GpYHORSSH SDV LO HVW UHODWLYHPHQW UDUH VRQ H[WHQVLRQ VHPEOH
EORTXpSDUODSODFHFRQVLGpUDEOHTXHSUHQGOHGDWLIORFDWLI
/DTXHVWLRQTXLVHSRVHHVWGHVDYRLUFRPPHQWXQHWHOOHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQDpWpSRVVLEOHTXHOVVRQWOHVIDFWHXUV
TXLHQWUDvQHQWODUXLQHGHO·HQVHPEOHGXV\VWqPH1RXVSDUWLURQVG·XQH[HPSOHHPSUXQWpj(/DURFKHGDQVOH
PrPHDUWLFOH
B!&#k´OHFLHOµ
/HGLUHFWLI!"#$%&'XWLOLVpjO·pSRTXHYLHX[KLWWLWHHVWUHPSODFpSDUODGDWLIORFDWLI!"#$%&$$5$O·pSRTXHUpFHQWH
8QORFDWLIDQFLHQVHSUpVHQWHVRXVODIRUPH)!&#k
/HVWH[WHVUpFHQWVRQW!"#$%$(
-J%"#-!4$#:pSRTXHDQFLHQQH
$(%)(>>(%0/$)++(-()()%!"#$%'($(-)(++#
´(WMHODLVVHHQFRUHO·DLJOHDOOHU67$89:;<
!"#$%'$HVWXQGLUHFWLI
-J%"($#:M.64($#:jO·pSRTXHUpFHQWH
´$GFDHOXPµ
1=–9(–kk()%!"#$%$%I(#>#%
´HWPRLMHYDLVDXFLHOµ
!"#$%$HVWXQGDWLIORFDWLI,OHVWDVVRFLpjXQYHUEHGHPRXYHPHQWI(#M/DSDUWLFXOHkk()%VXJJqUHODUpDOLVDWLRQGX
PRXYHPHQWDEVHQWHDYHFOHGLUHFWLIGDQVO·H[HPSOHSUpFpGHQW
$(==1%'6,16,*Ö%M{\%/4/%)!&#k#W!+)#%)!'()
´6LODFRUQHJDXFKHHVWWRXUQpHHQKDXWYHUVOHFLHOµ
/HYHUEHLPSOLTXHXQHGLUHFWLRQ


 oi.uchicago.edu

O@?% A/3O8N%A<t,Y8K

´LQFDHORµ
)!&#k#%-/4!-1k%!k$(%´LOIXWURLDXFLHOµ
1=–9(–kk()%!"#$%$%I(#>#%
´HWPRLMHYDLVDXFLHOµ

&HVH[HPSOHVDSSHOOHQWOHVUHPDUTXHVVXLYDQWHV$O·pSRTXHUpFHQWHOHGDWLIORFDWLIHVWXWLOLVpUpJXOLqUHPHQW
jODSODFHGXGLUHFWLI$LQVLOHPrPHFDVOHGDWLIORFDWLIH[SULPHUDLWGHVQRWLRQVFRQWUDGLFWRLUHVOHPRXYHPHQW
HWOHVWDWLTXHRXELHQQHGRQQHUDLWSOXVTX·XQHLQGLFDWLRQGHOLHXHQGHKRUVGHO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHOHVWDWLTXHHW
OHG\QDPLTXH
,OUHVVRUWGHFHWWHpYROXWLRQOHVSRLQWVVXLYDQWV
 /HGDWLIORFDWLIHVWXQFDVKpWpURJqQHLOUpXQLWXQFDVDEVWUDLW OHGDWLI HWXQFDVFRQFUHW OHORFDWLI 
/HGDWLIH[SULPHOHPRXYHPHQWHWOHORFDWLITXLVLWXHXQREMHWGDQVO·HVSDFHRXGDQVOHWHPSVH[FOXWOD
GLUHFWLRQG·XQPRXYHPHQWXQHRULHQWDWLRQYHUVXQEXW
$LQVLOHV\QFUpWLVPHDHXSRXUHIIHWTXHOHPrPHFDVHVWDSWHjH[SULPHUOHPRXYHPHQWHWO·DEVHQFHGHPRX
YHPHQW2QSHXWLPDJLQHUTXHSDUWDQWGHODYDOHXUIRQGDPHQWDOHGXGDWLIOHGDWLIORFDWLIDLWSXH[SULPHUOH
PRXYHPHQWGDQVO·HVSDFH
 &HUWDLQHV IRUPXOHV SRXUUDLHQW DYRLU pWp IDYRUDEOHV j FHWWH pYROXWLRQ /HV YHUEHV VLJQLϮDQW ´YHUVHU
MHWHUµSRXYDLHQWrWUHVXLYLVjO·pSRTXHDQFLHQQHG·XQGDWLIORFDWLIH[SULPDQWOHUpVXOWDWGHO·DFWLRQ
$LQVLGDQVO·H[HPSOH-/4!-1k%+1II(-#%k#I()$#´OHURLYHUVHXQHOLEDWLRQGDQVXQEROµ&HWWHWRXUQXUHTXLVH
WURXYHFRXUDPPHQWGqVOHYLHX[KLWWLWHSRXUUDLWpYRTXHUOHUpVXOWDWVWDWLTXHGXPRXYHPHQWOHOLTXLGHHVWGDQV
OHEROO·DFWLRQHVWSHUoXHFRPPHVWDWLTXH$LQVLOHGDWLIORFDWLIGDQVFHWH[HPSOHSRXUUDLWLQGLTXHUOHUpVXOWDWGH
O·DFWLRQHWVHUDLWXQORFDWLI
'HPrPHGDQVODSKUDVH$(==1%/Ô()%I(++1!)#%=1#k=#%I!kk#GG#´VLTXHOTX·XQSUpFLSLWHXQKRPPHGDQVOHIHXµ
.%R,, OGDWLIORFDWLISHXWH[SULPHU$OHUpVXOWDWGHO·DFWLRQ
(QUHYDQFKHRQHPSORLHOHGLUHFWLI)'*!'&%SRXUH[SULPHUOHWHUPHGXPRXYHPHQWGDQV$(==1%/Ô8OP/8()%
=1#k=#%I(-=1)1GG#%=1I$(--M(%1=Z$1-#(k%I!"(# :@$(==1M9(M$(M()%)'*!'M>(%=1!.=(%I!kk!G#%(.1Z9()G($(-%H/B%-/4!-@%´6L
TXHOTX·XQSXULILH PDJLTXHPHQW XQKRPPHLODSSRUWHUDOHVGpFKHWVGDQVOHIR\HUjLQFLQpUHU0DLVV·LOOHVMHWWH
GDQVODPDLVRQGHTXHOTX·XQF·HVWGHODVRUFHOOHULH HW F·HVWXQFDVSRXUOHURLµ .%R,,² 0DLVRQVRXOLJQH
OHUpVXOWDWGHO·DFWLRQDYHF+,-+*$'% GDWLIORFDWLISOGH1=$1-#´IR\HUjLQFLQpUHUµ 
/HVGXSOLFDWVSOXVUpFHQWVVXEVWLWXHQWOHGDWLI;=86>9?%$߰­)#DXGLUHFWLI%I(-)( .%R,,.%R,9¬
 QjXQHpSRTXHRO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHOHGDWLI;=86>9?HWOHGLUHFWLIQ·H[LVWHSOXV
/HGLUHFWLIVHPEOHPRLQVVRXYHQWHPSOR\pDYHFOHYHUEHGHVHQVDQDORJXHk1++#PDLVDWWHVWppJDOHPHQW
% 3
/#/1k%>!>(.%#kk(–kk(%01Z+´ODGLYLQLWpGX6ROHLOYHUVHGX>!>(.GDQVVDERXFKHµ .%R5R
&·HVWOHWHUPHGXPRXYHPHQWTXLHVWHQYLVDJp
/·H[HPSOHGXJUHFHWGXODWLQSRXUUDLWFRQILUPHUFHWHPSORL3RXUQRXVHQWHQLUDXJUHFDQFLHQRQVDLWTXH
FHWWHODQJXHHPSORLHFRXUDPPHQWOHGDWLIORFDWLIDYHFOHVYHUEHVVLJQLILDQW´YHUVHUGRQQHUMHWHUWRPEHUµ
$LQVLSRXUQRXVHQWHQLUDXJUHF
 ,೏์ဎ›࿰‫໇ݰ‬ɘඦड़ड़۟͘࿰ٗड़ඥߥ´LOMHWDLWGDQVOHIHXOHORWUpVHUYpDX[RϸUDQGHVµ
 (೏›͘˗໅ဝ›ๆۭ͘´LOWRPEDGDQVODSODLQHµ
 (VFK\OHN!0%3+6UI+6-!0೏›ۭ͘཭ဎࠗ‫ߥڗ‬Ǔ໒ࢆǓࠗ‫›ߥڗ‬ๆ˗ဝ´OHVDQJpWDQWWRPEpVXUOHVROµ(XULSLGH,-!0$!೏Ҡ཭ۭ‫ڗ‬ဎ
श‫཭ݰ‬ဎ‫ڗ‬ဎ˗่˗͘ࢆဎ໅‫ڗ‬Ԇߥ›ๆࢆࠗङश¶཰˗͘´'HSXLVFRPELHQGHWHPSVFHOXLFLWRPEDVXUODFRXFKH"µ
 ˳೏शǓࢆǓ໇›ๆۭ͘ဎ´LOWRPEDSDUWHUUHµ
36H9Ҡ཭ۭ‫ڗ‬ဎश‫཭ݰ‬ဎ‫ڗ‬ဎ˗่˗͘ࢆဎ໅‫ڗ‬Ԇߥ›ๆࢆࠗङश¶཰˗͘SDUH[HPSOHOHGDWLIVLJQLILHTXHO·LQGLYLGXGRQWRQSDUOHHVWWRPEp
HWTX·LOHVWGHPHXUpVXUODFRXFKH2QQRWHUDTXHGDQVFHVH[HPSOHVOHGDWLI;=86>9?$HVWHQFRQFXUUHQFHDYHF์ဎ
GDWLIHWDFFHVVRLUHPHQWDYHFODIRUPHILJpHGXORFDWLI
,OHQUpVXOWHSRXUFHUWDLQVYHUEHVGHPRXYHPHQWXQHJUDQGHYDULpWpGHFRQVWUXFWLRQV

O
%1=Z$1-#(k@HVWUHVWLWXpG·DSUqV.%R,,YRLU+RIIQHU :
%(FGGHJ7%OPP@N%R:%ZI!kk!GG#@
)UDQFLD Q%
+RIIQHU
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <%@K,@,7%H8%N;,@@,7/*/,B%8B*K8%N8%7*<*/e\8%8*%N8%HYB<A/e\8%8B%O/**/*8% O@O

3RXUWDQWOHIDLWTXHOHJUHFGLVSRVHGHSOXVLHXUVH[SUHVVLRQVYRLVLQHVQ·LPSOLTXHSDVTXHOHVHQWLPHQWOLQJXLV
WLTXHVRLWSHUWXUEp/DOLJQHTXLVpSDUHOHGDWLIORFDWLIHWO·DFFXVDWLIGHGLUHFWLRQVHUDLWGRQFWUqVQHWWHHQJUHF
KRPpULTXHFRPPHHQJUHFFODVVLTXH
/DOLJQHGHGpPDUFDWLRQHQWUHOHGDWLIORFDWLIHWO·DFFXVDWLIGHGLUHFWLRQQHWHQGUDjV·HIIDFHUTX·jSDUWLUGX
SUHPLHUVLqFOHGHQRWUHqUHGDWHjODTXHOOHODQRWLRQVWDWLTXHHVWH[SULPpHSDUO·DFFXVDWLIHQGHKRUVGHWRXWH
YDOHXUPRWLRQQHOOH
3RXUUHYHQLUjQRWUHH[HPSOHLQLWLDOGDQVODSKUDVH-/4!-1k%+1II(-#%k#I()$#´OHURLYHUVHXQHOLEDWLRQGDQV
XQEROµVHORQQRWUHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQSUpFpGHQWHOHGDWLIORFDWLISRXUUDLWLQGLTXHUOHUpVXOWDWGHO·DFWLRQHWVHUDLW
OLpDXORFDWLI
3RXUWDQWRQSHXWHVWLPHUDXVVLTXHGqVO·pSRTXHDQFLHQQHODGLVWLQFWLRQHQWUHOHPRXYHPHQWHWO·DEVHQFHGH
PRXYHPHQWpWDLWFDGXTXHHWTXHGDQVFHWWHH[SUHVVLRQYLHX[KLWWLWHGpMjOHGDWLIORFDWLIQ·H[SULPHSOXVO·DVSHFW
VWDWLTXH2QUHPDUTXHHQHIIHWTXHGqVOHYLHX[KLWWLWHFHWWHGLVWLQFWLRQHVWFDGXTXHGDQVXQFHUWDLQQRPEUHGHFDV
!8H98%/,/-#HVWELHQDWWHVWpDYHFOHVYHUEHV%I(#M´DOOHUµHW19(M´YHQLUµPrPHVL/,/'(HQGLUHFWLIHVWIUp
TXHQW
6XUWRXWDYHFOHVQRPVGHYLOOHVUDUHVVRQWOHVWH[WHVjO·pSRTXHDUFKDwTXHTXLPDLQWLHQQHQWO·RSSRVLWLRQGX
GLUHFWLIHWGXORFDWLIFRPPHF·HVWOHFDVSRXU+DWWXߖL+DWWXߖD/HVQRPVGHYLOOHRQWGRQFFRQWULEXpjSHUWXUEHU
ODGLVWLQFWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXH
'DQVFHVFRQGLWLRQVRQSHXWVXSSRVHUTXHGqVO·pSRTXHDQFLHQQH-/4!-1k%+1II(-#%k#I()$#Q·H[SULPHSOXVGpMj
ODQRWLRQGHVWDWLTXHHWTXHOHVHQWLPHQWOLQJXLVWLTXHHVWGpMjSHUWXUEp
2QREVHUYHGqVO·pSRTXHDUFKDwTXHGHVHPSORLVTXLVXJJqUHQWTXHODGLVWLQFWLRQHQWUHOHPRXYHPHQWHWO·DE
VHQFHGHPRXYHPHQWpWDLWFDGXTXH0DLV/,/-#SUpVHQWHUDLWODPrPHIUpTXHQFHHQIRQFWLRQGHGLUHFWLIjF{Wp
GHVRQHPSORLGLUHFWLISURSUH
'DQVFHVFRQGLWLRQVGqVO·pSRTXHDQFLHQQHODGLVWLQFWLRQHQWUHOHPRXYHPHQWHWOHVWDWLTXHFHVVHUDLWG·rWUH
SHUIRUPDQWH/HGDWLIORFDWLIQ·H[SULPDQWTX·XQHORFDOLVDWLRQGDQVO·HVSDFH/DYDOHXUPRWLRQQHOOHRXVWDWLTXH
Q·pWDQWSOXVH[SULPpHTXHSDUODVpPDQWLTXHGXYHUEH

@=A8;7B9=A
$XWHUPHGHFHWWHDQDO\VHRQDPLVHQpYLGHQFHOHIDLWTXHOHV\VWqPHDQDWROLHQDH[SULPpXQHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQ
UDGLFDOHTXLDHXSRXUHϸHWGHUXLQHUO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHOHVWDWLTXHHWOHG\QDPLTXH/HGDWLIORFDWLITXLHVWHPSOR\p
V\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWjODSODFHGXGLUHFWLIDHPSrFKpO·DFFXVDWLIGHGLUHFWLRQGHVHGpYHORSSHU&HWWHH[WHQVLRQGXGDWLI
SRXUH[SULPHUOHPRXYHPHQWV·H[SOLTXHSDUODYDOHXUGHEDVHGHFHFDVTXLLQFOXWIRQGDPHQWDOHPHQWODGLUHFWLRQ
'HVWRXUQXUHVDPELJXsVDYHFFHUWDLQVYHUEHVRQWFRQWULEXpSHXWrWUHjFHWWHH[WHQVLRQ
0DLVRQREVHUYHIRQGDPHQWDOHPHQWTXHGqVO·pSRTXHDUFKDwTXHO·RSSRVLWLRQPRXYHPHQWDEVHQFHGHPRXYHPHQW
SUpVHQWDLWGHVIDLEOHVVHV&HTXLQ·DSDVSHXFRQWULEXpjUXLQHUOHV\VWqPHG·RSSRVLWLRQjWHOSRLQWTX·RQWURXYHGHV
GLUHFWLIV H[SULPDQW OH ORFDWLI GHV ORFDWLIV HPSOR\pV V\VWpPDWLTXHPHQW j OD SODFH GX GLUHFWLI 2Q SHXW GRQF YRLU OH
FDUDFWqUHWUqVSDUWLFXOLHUGHO·pYROXWLRQGXKLWWLWH0DOJUpGHVWRXUQXUHVDQDORJXHVOHODWLQHWOHJUHFRQWPDLQWHQX
LQWDFWHO·RSSRVLWLRQGXVWDWLTXHHWGXG\QDPLTXHDORUVTXHOHKLWWLWHO·DVXSSULPpHWUqVUDSLGHPHQWDXEpQpϮFHGX
GDWLIORFDWLI
,QYHUVHPHQW j XQH pSRTXH UpFHQWH OHV IRUPHV ϮJpHV DYHF OH GLUHFWLI VH VRQW PDLQWHQXHV $LQVL .(++(% +(.G!kk(#M%
´DSSHOHUDX[DUPHVµVHWURXYHjXQHpSRTXHUpFHQWH
3DU DLOOHXUV GqV O·pSRTXH DQFLHQQH OHV WURLV IRUPHV .1=($(2% .1=($#2% JK%.1=($ ´j O·DXEHµ VRQW pTXLYDOHQWHV7RXV FHV
H[HPSOHV WHQGHQW j VXJJpUHU TXH OH FDV GDQV FHUWDLQHV WRXUQXUHV GqV O·pSRTXH DQFLHQQH Q·H[SULPH SOXV DORUV OHV
QRWLRQVGHVWDWLTXHRXGHG\QDPLTXHPDLVVHXOHPHQWXQHORFDOLVDWLRQGDQVO·HVSDFH
 oi.uchicago.edu

O@:% A/3O8N%A<t,Y8K

#CDEF96>9=AB
.%R ++)LJXOOD<1$65-(I+#!).HLOVFKULIWWH[WHDXV%RJKD]N|L/HLS]LJ-&+LQULFKV
.%R )ULHGULFK+UR]Qဵ%<1$65-(I+#!).HLOVFKULIWWH[WHDXV%RJKD]N|L/HLS]LJ-&+LQULFKV

G9C;9=HD6IJ9:
)UDQFLD5LWD
  ´)XQ]LRQLVLQWDWWLFKHQHLWHVWGHOO·DQWLFRLWWLWDLOORFDWLYRGLPHWDHVFRSRHO·DFFXVDWLYRGLGLUH]LR
QHµ/)46)$-#%N#)51#0$#4#%²
+RIIQHU+DUU\$
% OPP@% *+!%N(90%6:%$+!%O#$$#$!0g%<%3-#$#4(.%8"#$#6)'RFXPHQWDHW0RQXPHQWD2ULHQWLV$QWLTXL/H\GH%ULOO
/DURFKH(PPDQXHO
  ´(WXGHGHOLQJXLVWLTXHDQDWROLHQQH,,,µK!?1!%+#$$#$!%!$%(0#()#X1!²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7\K%N;QT,N\*/,B%H\%N,3<*/F%8B%<KAQB/8B% O@Q

!"
#$%&'()*+'$,-+.&/$&'+01,-2&3.&1%4).-3.

A($$+#(0%F-#$G2%7$($!%N#)51#0$#4%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%Y!-!?()

/HFDVORFDWLIGRQWO·DUPpQLHQGLVSRVHFRPPHFDWpJRULHJUDPPDWLFDOHHVWKpULWpGHODODQJXHPqUHLQGR
HXURSpHQQH$ORUVTX·LOQ·H[LVWHFRPPHFDVjSDUWHQWLqUHGDQVDXFXQHDXWUHODQJXHLQGRHXURSpHQQHDFWXHOOH
O·DUPpQLHQGHODEUDQFKHRULHQWDOHO·DQRQVHXOHPHQWFRQVHUYpMXVTX·jO·KHXUHDFWXHOOHPDLVLODPrPHpODUJLVRQ
pYHQWDLOGHIRQFWLRQVSDUGHOjOHQRPMXVTX·jODIOH[LRQYHUEDOH$XWUDYHUVGHFHWH[SRVpMHYDLVWHQWHUGHUHWUDFHU
FHWWHpYROXWLRQGXORFDWLIGHVGpEXWVLQGRHXURSpHQVjO·XVDJHDFWXHOHQDUPpQLHQRULHQWDOPRGHUQHHQSDVVDQW
SDUODSUpKLVWRLUHJUpFRDUPpQLHQQHHWSDUO·KLVWRLUHGHVODQJXHVDUPpQLHQQHVDQFLHQQHHWPR\HQQH
$XWRXWGpEXWOHORFDWLIGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQHVWSUpVHQWDYHFVHVWHUPLQDLVRQVUHFRQVWLWXDEOHVDXVLQJXOLHUHW
DXSOXULHODXVLQJXOLHUSDU #HWDXSOXULHOSDU 01$XVLQJXOLHULOH[LVWHGHSOXVOHORFDWLIVDQVWHUPLQDLVRQRX
ORFDWLIDYHFODWHUPLQDLVRQ ‘O(QJUpFRDUPpQLHQOHORFDWLIGRLWHQFRUHDYRLUH[LVWpSXLVTX·LOVXEVLVWHGDQVOD
EUDQFKHDUPpQLHQQHDORUVTX·HQJUHFP\FpQLHQDWWHVWpGHSOXVORQJXHGDWHLODGLVSDUXFRPPHFDWpJRULHGHFDV
LQGpSHQGDQWHSDUV\QFUpWLVPHGHFDV
(QDUPpQLHQDQFLHQ:GXSRLQWGHYXHGHODIRUPHOHORFDWLIDXSOXULHOHVWWRXMRXUVLGHQWLTXHjO·DFFXVDWLI
WHUPLQDLVRQ 0TXDQWDXORFDWLISURYHQDQWGXSURWRLQGRHXURSpHQ 01 DORUVTX·DXVLQJXOLHULOSUpVHQWHGLI
IpUHQWHVWHUPLQDLVRQVVHORQODVWUXFWXUHGXWKqPHGXQRPVDFKDQWTX·LFLDXVVLLOHVWIRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQWLTXHj
DXPRLQVXQDXWUHFDV
/HVWKqPHVHQ(RQWFRPPHWHUPLQDLVRQDXORFDWLI # %(G5´SHXSOHµ% %(G5M#IRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQ
WLTXHDYHFOHJpQLWLIHWOHGDWLI OHVQRPVSURSUHVjWKqPHHQ(RQW (' *#$()N%*#$()M('IRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQWLTXH
DYHFOHJpQLWLIOHGDWLIHWO·DEODWLI HWOHW\SHHQ#GHVWKqPHVHQ(SUpVHQWHODWHUPLQDLVRQ Rհၲ %$(-#%
´DQQpHµ %WDUZRհၲ TXLHVWODVHXOHWHUPLQDLVRQVSpFLILTXHGXORFDWLI FI %>#%´XQµ PLRհၲ FHOOHFLD
SUREDEOHPHQWXQHRULJLQHDGYHUELDOHHWGRLWYUDLVHPEODEOHPHQWrWUHUHOLpHDX[DGYHUEHVORFDX[WHOVTXHOHJUHF
61-()ç$+#´GDQVOHFLHOµ'DQVOHFDVGHVWKqPHVHQ6ODWHUPLQDLVRQGXORFDWLIHVWVRXYHQW #VDFKDQWTXHSDUDO
OqOHPHQWRQWURXYHXQHIRUPHVDQVWHUPLQDLVRQHWGHSOXVODIRUPHPDUTXpHHQ Rհၲ %c#´FKHYDOµ MLRհၲ
PDUG´KRPPHµ PDUGRհၲ %իHUP´FKDXGµ իHUPRհၲ 6LOHORFDWLIHVWIRUPpVDQVWHUPLQDLVRQ
DORUVLOHVWIRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQWLTXHDXQRPLQDWLIHWjO·DFFXVDWLI %5!$´ULYLqUHµ ODPrPHFKRVHHVWpJDOHPHQW
YDODEOHSRXUOHW\SHHQ#GHVWKqPHVHQ6VLOHXUORFDWLIVHWHUPLQHHQ # %+65#´HVSULWµ %6-"#´ILOVµ
SDUVRQORFDWLIPDUTXp RUGZRհၲFRQVWLWXHXQHH[FHSWLRQ 
/HORFDWLIGHVWKqPHVHQ#VHWHUPLQHpJDOHPHQWHQ #HWHVWIRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQWLTXHDXJpQLWLIHWDXGDWLI
%&('´PRWµ %&('M# /HVWKqPHVHQ1SUpVHQWHQWXQORFDWLIDYHFODWHUPLQDLVRQ69% ঈDP´WHPSVµ
ঈDP69 TXLGHPrPHHVWIRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQWLTXHDXJpQLWLIDXGDWLIHWjO·LQVWUXPHQWDO/HVW\SHVHQ-
GHVWKqPHVHQ1GLVSRVHpJDOHPHQWGHODWHUPLQDLVRQGXORFDWLI 69HWGHO·LGHQWLWpIRUPHOOHGXORFDWLIDYHF
OHVWURLVFDVFLWpVjO·LQVWDQW %(0-´WRLVRQµ %(069 
'DQVOHFDVGHVWKqPHVHQ-OHORFDWLIVHWHUPLQHSDU !-HWHVWIRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQWLTXHDXJpQLWLIHWDX
GDWLI %60=-´RVµ %60=M!- OHVQRPVHQ!9-DSSDUWHQDQWDX[WKqPHVHQ-SUpVHQWHQWDXVVLODPrPHVLWX
DWLRQ D‫ן‬EHZU´VRXUFHµ D‫ן‬EHU HWGDQVOHFDVGHVWHUPHVGHSDUHQWpjWKqPHHQ-OHORFDWLIHVWGH
PrPHIRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQWLTXHDXJpQLWLIHWDXGDWLI %+('-´SqUHµ %+(9- 3RXUOHVWKqPHVHQ‫ן‬OHORFDWLI
9J%KJ7M8HJ%=67% H‫ן‬HWLOIRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQWLTXHDXJpQLWLIHWDXGDWLI DVW‫´ן‬pWRLOHµ DVWH‫' ן‬DQVOH
FDVGHVWKqPHVHQ)OHORFDWLISUpVHQWHFRPPHWHUPLQDLVRQVRLW #) %(G)´VH[Hµ %(GM#) %>(0)%
´SDUWLHSLqFHµ %>(0M#) VRLW  ! () %($(>)´GHQWµ %($(>() %()=#9)´DQJOHµ
%()=!() %$69)´PDLVRQµ %$() jFKDTXHIRLVDYHFLGHQWLWpIRUPHOOHDYHFOHJpQLWLIHWOHGDWLI

O
0DLVGDQVOHVWKqPHVDLQVLGLWVWKpPDWLTXHVOHORFDWLIVDQVWHUPL 3RXUOHVGDWHVFRQFHUQDQWHVO·DUPpQLHQDQFLHQYRLUSDUH[HPSOHOHV
:

QDLVRQQ·H[LVWHSDVFI0HLHU%UJJHU PDQXHOVGH0HLOOHW  HW6FKPLWW  

O@Q
 oi.uchicago.edu

O@<% A<**O/<7%FK/*t

0rPHSRXUOHVWHUPHVLUUpJXOLHUVRQUHQFRQWUHXQHLGHQWLWpIRUPHOOHGXORFDWLIDYHFOHJpQLWLIHWOHGDWLI %
(9-´MRXUµ %(969- N૛R\U´V±XUµ %N૛H‫ޚ‬ %(=)´±LOµ %(=() %69)=)´RUHLOOHµ %
69)=() %=#)´IHPPHµ %NQRհၲ %('-´KRPPHµ %D‫ޚ‬Q %$#9´SOHLQMRXUµ %$69̾QհၲHDQ VDXI
=FL7% JHZ‫´ן‬YLOODJHµRKRUPLVODIRUPHGXORFDWLI JH‫ן‬հၲLOH[LVWHDXVVLXQHIRUPHGXORFDWLILGHQWLTXHDX
QRPLQDWLIHWjO·DFFXVDWLIFHFLHVWpJDOHPHQWOHFDVSRXU %)69´EHOOHILOOHµ
/HSURQRPSHUVRQQHOGHODqUHSHUVRQQH %#0 FRQQDvWDXVLQJXOLHUXQHLGHQWLWpGHIRUPHGXORFDWLIDYHF
O·DFFXVDWLIjODqPHSHUVRQQH %N૛H] HWDXSOXULHO %>!G%JK% %c!G pJDOHPHQWDYHFOHGDWLI3RXUOHVSURQRPV
GHODqPHSHUVRQQHOHVIRUPHVVXLYDQWHVVRQWLGHQWLTXHVDXVLQJXOLHU DXSOXULHOGHPDQLqUHJpQpUDOHOHORFDWLI
HWO·DFFXVDWLIVRQWIRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQWLTXHVjO·LQVWDUGHODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOH GDQVOHFDVGXSURQRPUpIOpFKL
%#9- ORFDWLIDYHFJpQLWLIHWGDWLIGDQVOHFDVGXSURQRPG·LGHQWLWp ´VRLPrPHµ  %LQN૛HDQ GHPrPH
SRXUOHVSURQRPVSRVVHVVLIVTXLVRQWHQIDLWGHVDGMHFWLIVSRVVHVVLIVORFDWLIDYHFGDWLI %#>M69> %
)6-('M69> SRXUOHVSURQRPVGpPRQVWUDWLIV %('M0M> %('M0>M#= %0M>M#) %0M>M( ORFDWLI
DYHFGDWLIHWHQSDUWLHDXVVLDYHFDEODWLI %('0M>>()z@ %('M0>M#= %0M>M#) GDQVOHFDVGHV
SURQRPVLQWHUURJDWLIV %69> %6-69> %Z+@#> ORFDWLIDYHFGDWLISRXUOHVSURQRPVLQGpILQLV %
69>!M>) RZPHN૛ LPLN૛ GHPrPH
(QILQLOH[LVWHXQJURXSHG·DGMHFWLIVTXLQHVXLYHQWSDVFRPPHOHVDGMHFWLIVFRXUDQWVOHVSDUDGLJPHVQRPL
QDX[PDLVDXFRQWUDLUHOHVSDUDGLJPHVSURQRPLQDX[HWVRQWSRXUFHODDSSHOpVDGMHFWLIVSURQRPLQDX[3DUPL
FHX[FLRQFRPSWH %>#´XQHµ %('.´DXWUHµ %>#90´DXWUHµGRQWOHORFDWLIHQ 69>%J9K%GF7MJ>>JMJHK%
LGHQWLTXHDXGDWLI SRXU %>#LOH[LVWHDXVVLXQHIRUPHVHFRQGDLUHGHORFDWLIGDWLIHWJpQLWLI %PLRհၲ 'HSOXV
IRQWSDUWLHGHVDGMHFWLIVSURQRPLQDX[ D‫ޚ‬DհၲLQ´SUHPLHUSUHPLqUHµ %'!$#)´GHUQLHUGHUQLqUHµ %
?!-#)´VXSpULHXUHµ %=-=#)´GRXEOHµ Dհၲ ´GURLWHµ %c(]´JDXFKHµ %+#)´YLHX[YLHLOOHµ %)6-%
´QRXYHDXQRXYHOOHµHWHQSDUWLHOHVQRPEUHVRUGLQDX[HQ -6-"FKDFXQDYHFOHXUSURSUHORFDWLIHQ 69>
$XQLYHDXGHODIRUPHLOHVWSRVVLEOHG·pWDEOLUOHVWHUPLQDLVRQVGHORFDWLIVXLYDQWHVHQDUPpQLHQDQFLHQ OHV
IRUPHVVDQVWHUPLQDLVRQDQDO\VDEOHVRQWKRUVFRQVLGpUDWLRQ  #2% 692% Rհၲ%=FL7%>J%HFM2% 69>%=FL7%>J%
=7FHFM2% Rհၲ%JK% 69>DXVVLSRXUO·DGMHFWLISURQRPLQDO$XVLQJXOLHUGDQVOHFDVGXQRPODWHUPLQDLVRQGX
ORFDWLIHVWVRXYHQWLGHQWLTXHjFHOOHGXGDWLIHWGXJpQLWLIRXXQLTXHPHQWjFHOOHGXGDWLIGDQVOHFDVGHO·DGMHFWLI
SURQRPLQDOHOOHHVWLGHQWLTXHjFHOOHGXGDWLIRXDORUVOHORFDWLIDXQHWHUPLQDLVRQSURSUHSRXUOHVXEVWDQWLI
RհၲSRXUO·DGMHFWLISURQRPLQDO 69>$XVLQJXOLHUOHORFDWLISUpVHQWHOHSOXVG·DIILQLWpVDYHFOHGDWLIDX
SOXULHOSUHVTXHH[FOXVLYHPHQWDYHFO·DFFXVDWLI(QUDLVRQGHFHVIDLWVGHVKpVLWDWLRQVH[LVWHQWGDQVODJUDPPDLUH
ORFDOHHQFHTXLFRQFHUQHOHVWDWXWGXORFDWLIFRPPHpWDQWFHOXLG·XQFDVLQGpSHQGDQWKpVLWDWLRQVTXLQHVHVRQW
WRXWHIRLVSDVH[SULPpHVGDQVOHVPDQXHOV
$ORUVTXHO·RULJLQHGH Rհၲ QHGRLWSDVrWUHUHFKHUFKpHGDQVOHGRPDLQHGHODIOH[LRQODTXHVWLRQVHSRVH
DORUVFRQFHUQDQWOHVFRUUHVSRQGDQFHVGH #2% RZHW 69>3RXU #%JK% 69QRXVSRXYRQVSDUWLUG·XQH
RULJLQHGHVWKqPHVHQ#RXHQ1 HWG·XQWUDQVIHUWXOWpULHXUDX[DXWUHVFODVVHVWKpPDWLTXHV VDFKDQWTXHOH
VLJQHFDVXHOHQDUPpQLHQFRUUHVSRQGUDLWDXVXIIL[HGHIRUPDWLRQGHWKqPHRULJLQHO #RX 1HWTXHODYpULWDEOH
WHUPLQDLVRQGXGDWLIRXGXJpQLWLIVHUDLHQWWRPEpHSRXUGHVUDLVRQVG·DFFHQWXDWLRQ FIOHORFDWLIGHVWKqPHVHQ
#HW1GXYLHLOLQGLHQ 3RXU 69>QRXVSRXYRQVSDUWLUG·XQHFUpDWLRQUpVXOWDQWGHODFRPELQDLVRQGXVRQ
ILQDOGXWKqPHSURQRPLQDO 6HWGHO·H[WHQVLRQGHWKqPHSURQRPLQDO 0>jODTXHOOHVHVHUDLWDMRXWpHXQH
WHUPLQDLVRQGHGDWLIRXGHORFDWLI& 6M0>M!# 6M0>M# TXRLTXHGHPrPHODYpULWDEOHWHUPLQDLVRQDXUDLWGLVSDUX
SRXUGHVUDLVRQVG·DFFHQWXDWLRQHWODVpTXHQFHSKRQRORJLTXH 60>DXUDLWFKDQJpHQ 69>>1>@/·H[WHQVLRQ
GXWKqPH 0>VHUHWURXYHSDUH[HPSOHHQYLHLOLQGLHQFKH]OHVSURQRPVGpPRQVWUDWLIVXQLTXHPHQWDXVLQJXOLHU
GDQVOHVFDVGDWLIDEODWLIHWORFDWLI WDVPčL2%WDVPčW2%$(0>#) 
/DWHUPLQDLVRQGXORFDWLIHQDUPpQLHQRULHQWDODSSDUDvWGRQFGpMjHQDUPpQLHQFODVVLTXHWRXWHIRLVHQWDQW
TXHWHUPLQDLVRQGHGDWLIFKH]OHVSURQRPVHWOHVDGMHFWLIVSURQRPLQDX[FHTXLHQFRPELQDLVRQDYHFODSUpSRVL
K8FH% %#UHYLHQWDORUVjODVLJQLILFDWLRQGXORFDWLI Q% %'!-=-6-"69>´GHX[LqPHPHQWµ <
'pMjHQDUPpQLHQSRVWFODVVLTXHRQUHQFRQWUHpJDOHPHQWGHVH[HPSOHVGHIRUPHVGHGDWLIORFDWLIHQ 69>%
=FL7%>J%9LD9K6HK8GN% +D\RF૛\HUNURZP´GDQVOHSD\VGHV$UPpQLHQVµ R

Q
&I0HLOOHW R
&I0RYVHV;RUHQDF૛LO , 
<
&I(]QLN.R‫ן‬EDF૛LO ,9 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7\K%N;QT,N\*/,B%H\%N,3<*/F%8B%<KAQB/8B% O@R

!L%1*qPHVLqFOHFHWWHIRUPHGHGDWLIORFDWLIHVWWUqVIUpTXHPPHQWHPSOR\pHDXVVLDYHFOHVXEVWDQWLISDUOHV
KHOOpQLVWHV/HV8QLWHXUVXWLOLVHQWpJDOHPHQWWUqVVRXYHQWOHGDWLIORFDWLIHWHQRXWUHHQUHODWLRQDYHFGHQRXYHDX[
SUpIL[HV %͇QGW૛‫ן‬W૛RZP´GDQVODOHWWUHµ %)!-+)c69>%´GDQVODUpFROWHµHWF
,OH[LVWHQpDQPRLQVTXHOTXHVIRUPHVHQ 69>TXLGDQVFHFRQWH[WHQpFHVVLWHQWFHUWDLQHVH[SOLFDWLRQV
&KH]OHSKLORVRSKH'DYLW૛$Q\D‫ן‬W૛ DLQVLGLW´'DYLGSKLORVRSKXVµ GRQWOHVWUDGXFWLRQVjSDUWLUGXJUHFUHPRQ
WHQWVDQVGRXWHDX9,qPHVLqFOHHWSUpVHQWHQWGHVFDUDFWpULVWLTXHVGHO·DUPpQLHQGXQRUGRXHVWGDQVO·DQDO\VH
GH&O·,VDJRJXHGH3RUSK\UHLOH[LVWHOHGDWLIORFDWLIHQ 69> %>(-"69>@%´GDQVO·KRPPHµ %
QLZW૛RZP%´GDQVODPDWLqUHµ VH‫ޚ‬RZPP%´GDQVOHJHQUHOHVH[Hµ SULQFLSDOHPHQWHQUHODWLRQDYHFODSUpSRVL
WLRQORFDWLYH %#g% % %#%>(->)69>O?´GDQVOHFRUSVµHWSOXVHQFRUH
&HPRUSKqPHFRUUHVSRQGIRUPHOOHPHQWDXORFDWLIXOWpULHXUGHO·DUPpQLHQRULHQWDOTXLDSSDUDvWFKH]O·KLVWRULHQ
9DUGDQ¬9DUGDSHWTXLpFULWHQDUPpQLHQDQFLHQDX;,,,qPHVLqFOHRQWURXYHGDQVVRQ´5HFXHLOG·KLVWRLUHVµXQSDV
VDJHHQDUPpQLHQYXOJDLUHTXLSUpVHQWHGHVWUDLWVGHO·DUPpQLHQRULHQWDOPR\HQGDQVFHWWHODQJXHLOH[LVWHpJDOH
PHQWGHVIRUPHVGHORFDWLIWHOOHVTXH %#%0-$69>0´GDQVPRQF±XUµOOHWF·HVWOjTX·HVWDWWHVWpHSRXUOD
SUHPLqUHIRLVODQRXYHOOHIRUPDWLRQGXSUpVHQWHQDUPpQLHQRULHQWDO D‫گן‬W૛N૛HQD‫ޚ‬QRZPO: jF{Wp
GHO·DUPpQLHQDQFLHQ D‫گן‬W૛N૛D‫ޚ‬QHQOQ ´LOVSULHQWµ$XVVLELHQOHORFDWLIHQ 69>%TXHOHSUpVHQW
JH% 69>%VRQWDORUVWUqVFRXUDQWVGDQVOHVH[WUDLWVTXH-RKDQQ-RDFKLP6FKU|GHUSUpVHQWHGDQVVRQWKpVDXUXV
GDQVODSDUWLH6\QRSVLVOLQJXDHFLYLOLV$UPHQRUXP %>#)%c=)69>O<´GDQVXQSRLVVRQµ GLWFRPPRUDWLYXV
DXOLHXGHORFDWLYXV &JK% %56?69>!>OR´MHORXHµ HFULWHQXQPRWDXOLHXGH56?69>%!>5
&·HVWDLQVLTXHO·RQWURXYHHQDUPpQLHQPR\HQ³FRPPHQRXVO·DYRQVH[SOLTXpjO·LQVWDQW³pJDOHPHQWFKH]
FHUWDLQVDXWHXUVHWGDQVFHUWDLQVWH[WHVGHVIRUPHVGHGDWLIHQ 69>%FKH]OHVXEVWDQWLI
6HXOHPHQWO·DUPpQLHQPR\HQQ·HVWSDVSRXUFHTXLQRXVHQDpWpWUDQVPLVOHGHVFHQGDQWGLUHFWGHO·DUPpQLHQ
DQFLHQTXLQRXVDpWpWUDQVPLV/·DUPpQLHQDQFLHQpWDLWGpMjGLYLVpHQGLDOHFWHVHWGHPrPHO·DUPpQLHQPR\HQ
FRQQDLVVDLWGLIIpUHQWVGLDOHFWHVHWOHVWH[WHVTXLQRXVRQWpWpWUDQVPLVGHGLYHUVHVpSRTXHVQHSUpVHQWHQWSDVOHV
PrPHVFDUDFWpULVWLTXHVGLDOHFWDOHV$LQVLO·DUPpQLHQFLOLFLHQ³F·HVWDLQVLTXHV·DSSHOOHO·DUPpQLHQGHO·pSRTXH
PR\HQDUPpQLHQQHTXLQRXVDpWpWUDQVPLVFDUOHVWpPRLJQDJHVOLQJXLVWLTXHVSURYLHQQHQWHQJUDQGHSDUWLHGH
&LOLFLH³Q·HVWSDVO·DQFrWUHGLUHFWGHO·DUPpQLHQRFFLGHQWDOPRGHUQHELHQTXHO·DUPpQLHQFLOLFLHQDSSDUWLHQQH
WRXWDXWDQWDXJURXSHGLDOHFWDOGHO·DUPpQLHQRFFLGHQWDO&RPPHO·DUPpQLHQFLOLFLHQDSSDUWLHQWjO·DUPpQLHQRF
FLGHQWDOTXLQ·DSDVSHUSpWXpOHFDVORFDWLIO·DUPpQLHQPR\HQQHGHYUDLWGRQFGLVSRVHUG·DXFXQHIRUPHGHORFDWLI
(QJXLVHG·H[FHSWLRQVDSSDUDLVVHQWGHVIRUPHVGHORFDWLIpJDOHPHQWGDQVXQDUUrWpGH5DVKNKRYHQDUPpQLHQ
NLSWFKDN L.DPHQLF૛N૛D‫ן‬N૛RZP%´GDQVODYLOOHGH.DPHQHF૛µ %.૛RZW૛HURZPO@%´j.XW\µ
%PD\UDN૛D‫ן‬DN૛RZP %´GDQVODPpWURSROHµ


0rPHSRXUODIRUPDWLRQGHVQRPEUHVRUGLQDX[O·DUPpQLHQNLSWFKDNXWLOLVHFRPPHVXIIL[H 69>&HWWH
IRUPDWLRQGHVQRPEUHVRUGLQDX[DSHXWrWUHjYRLUQRQVHXOHPHQWDYHFOHGDWLIORFDWLIHQ 69>PDLVDXVVLDYHF
FHOOHGXQRXYHDXSHUVDQ 1> HWpWDLWGpMjXQHFDUDFWpULVWLTXHGXGLDOHFWHG·$QL2QUHQFRQWUHOHVSUHPLqUHVDW
WHVWDWLRQVGHO·RUGLQDOHQ69>GDQVXQPDQXVFULWDVWURORJLTXHHQDUPpQLHQPR\HQFRQWHQXGDQVOHPDQXVFULWGHV
0pFKLWDULVWHVGH9LHQQHQR IHXLOOHWI % %D‫ޚ‬DիLQWRZQQ2% %&L69>%$69))2% %
5L69>%$69))2% % % "L69>%$69))2% %!L69>%$69))2% %GL69>%$69))2% % %̒RZP
$69))2% % ̾RZP WRZQQ2% % W૛RZP WRZQQ2% % % ঈJRZP WRZQQ2% % ঈ]RZP
$69))2% %ঈGRZPWRZQQ2% %ঈHRZPWRZQQ OP­O·pSRTXHVXLYDQWHRQUHWURXYHGHVQRPEUHV
RUGLQDX[HQ69>%GDQVGHVPDQXVFULWVHQDUPpQLHQNLSWFKDN %!-=69069>%´GHX[LqPHµ:?% LUHN૛RZP
´WURLVLqPHµ:O% ɥ૛RUVRZP´TXDWULqPHµ:: 'HSOXVLOH[LVWHDXVWDGHSUpFRFHGHO·DUPpQLHQNLSWFKDNGHV
IRUPHVGHQRPEUHVRUGLQDX[HQ 6-"69>g% %!-=-6-"69>%´GHX[LqPHGHX[LqPHPHQWµ:Q& %


&I$EHJKLDQ OR
6FKU|GHU
@
'DYLW૛$Q\D‫ן‬W૛O¬ 
0LQDV%ঈߖNHDQF૛O

'DYLW૛$Q\D‫ן‬W૛O¬SO¬ O@
0LQDV%ঈߖNHDQF૛O
P
'DYLW૛$Q\D‫ן‬W૛OO¬SOO¬ 
0LQDV%ঈߖNHDQF૛O
O?
'DYLW૛$Q\D‫ן‬W૛O¬ OP
&I.DUVWQ
OO
9DUGDQ9DUGDSHWO :?
0LQDV%ঈߖNHDQF૛OO
O:
9DUGDQ9DUGDSHWOI :O
0LQDV%ঈߖNHDQF૛O
OQ
9DUGDQ9DUGDSHWOI ::
0LQDV%ঈߖNHDQF૛OSO
O<
6FKU|GHU :Q
0LQDV%ঈߖNHDQF૛O
 oi.uchicago.edu

% A<**O/<7%FK/*t

!--6-"69>%´WURLVLqPHWURLVLqPHPHQWµ:<$LQVLODIRUPDWLRQGXQRPEUHRUGLQDODYHF 69>%HQDUPpQLHQRUL
HQWDOSHXWrWUHPLVHHQUDSSRUWG·XQHSDUWDYHFOHGDWLYORFDWLIHQ 69>%HWG·DXWUHSDUWDYHFOHFRQWDFWDYHF
OHSHUVDQHWVDIRUPDWLRQGHVQRPEUHVRUGLQDX[HQ1>
/·DUPpQLHQRULHQWDOPRGHUQHSRXUVDSDUWQHFRQQDvWSDVODFRPELQDLVRQGXQRPEUHRUGLQDODYHFODWHUPL
QDLVRQGXORFDWLI&HSHQGDQWOHORFDWLIHVWFRQVLGpUpHQDUPpQLHQRULHQWDOPRGHUQHFRPPHFDVSURWRW\SLTXHGHV
LQGLFDWLRQVGHOLHX/DWHUPLQDLVRQGXORFDWLI\HVWWRXMRXUV 69>N% %80%(k]($69>%!>%+(>(.0(M
-()69>%´-HWUDYDLOOHjO·XQLYHUVLWpµ %<'0%5-=૛69>%=(%)=(-%´'DQVFHOLYUHLO\DXQHLPDJHµ'DQV
OHFDVG·rWUHVYLYDQWVOHORFDWLIQ·HVWELHQV€USDVXVLWpPDLVjODSODFHRQDUHFRXUVjXQJURXSHSRVWSRVLWLRQQHO
FRPSRVpGXJpQLWLIHWGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQ %PHհၲ
/HPRWSRXUPDLVRQFRQVWLWXHXQHH[FHSWLRQG·LPSRUWDQFH&HOXLFLHVWHQHIIHWXQHGpVLJQDWLRQSURWRW\SLTXH
SRXUXQOLHX­SDUWLUGH ೏WRZQ´PDLVRQµQ·HVWIRUPpDXFXQORFDWLI ೏ $)69> PDLVjODSODFHHVWXWLOLVp
OHGDWLI ೏WDQ̾DYHFOHVHQV´jODPDLVRQµ/HGDWLIHQIDLWHVWHQDUPpQLHQRULHQWDOPRGHUQHXQFDVDX[IRQF
WLRQVPXOWLSOHVTXHO·RQVRXSoRQQHUDLWHQUpDOLWpFRPPHSURSUHVDXORFDWLI$LQVLGHQRPEUHXVHVLQGLFDWLRQV
WHPSRUHOOHVVRQWIRUPpHVjSDUWLUGXGDWLI ೏JDUQDQ̾´DXSULQWHPSVµ ೏JDURZQ  ೏DP‫ޚ‬DQ̾
´HQpWpµ ೏DPD‫ ޚ‬ ೏DߖQDQ̾´HQDXWRPQHµ ೏DߖRZQ  ೏MP‫ޚ‬DQH´HQKLYHUµ ೏MPH‫ ޚ‬/D
PrPHFKRVHHVWpJDOHPHQWYDODEOHSRXUOHVPRLV ೏DSULOLQ´HQDYULOµ OHVMRXUV %(I-#.#%>!=#)%
´OHSUHPLHUDYULOµ OHVPRPHQWVGHODMRXUQpH ೏NHV‫گ‬ULQ´jPLGLOHPLGLµ HWOHVKHXUHV ঈDP̾
>!=#)%´jXQHKHXUHµ 'DQVOHFDVGHGRQQpHVWHPSRUHOOHVPRLQVSUpFLVHVGpVLJQDQWPRLQVXQHGDWHTX·XQHSpUL
RGHRQXWLOLVHG·DLOOHXUVO·DFFXVDWLI % ೏D\VWP\RZVߖDEDW૛̾WDPLV̾W$(-#)´FH WWH 
VHPDLQHPRLVDQQpHODVHPDLQHOHPRLVO·DQQpHSURFKDLQ H µ&HSHQGDQWOHGDWLIQ·HVWSDVXWLOLVpHQIRQFWLRQ
GHORFDWLIXQLTXHPHQWSRXUGHVLQGLFDWLRQVGHWHPSVPDLVDXVVLGDQVOHFDVG·LQGLFDWLRQVORFDOHVELHQFRQFUqWHV
೏.૛DQLJLUN૛NDD\VVH‫ן‬DQLQ´FRPELHQGHOLYUHVLO\DVXUFHWWHWDEOHµSDUDOOqOHPHQW
O·H[SUHVVLRQXWLOLVDQWXQJURXSHSRVWSRVLWLRQQHOHVWpJDOHPHQWSRVVLEOH % %.૛DQL
JLUN૛NDD\VVH‫ן‬DQLYUD´FRPELHQGHOLYUHVLO\DVXUFHWWHWDEOHµ(QRXWUHO·pYHQWDLOGHIRQFWLRQVORFDWLYHVGXGDWLI
HVWHQFRUHSOXVODUJH % ೏2ZVRZF૛Lɥ૛̾JURZP̒JUDWD[WDNLQ´/HSURIHVVHXUpFULWDX
WDEOHDXµ ೏LQɥ૛ RU JUYDF̒JUDWD[WDNLQ´FHTXLHVWpFULWDXWDEOHDXµ
$LQVLHQDUPpQLHQ RULHQWDO PRGHUQHLOH[LVWHjF{WpGXUpHOFDVGHOLHXOHORFDWLIXQDXWUHFDVTXLOXLIDLW
FRQFXUUHQFHDXQLYHDXGHODIRQFWLRQHWLOV·DJLWGXGDWLI
­SUpVHQWGXUDQWFHEUHIDSHUoXGHO·pYROXWLRQGXORFDWLIQRXVDYRQVGpMjREVHUYpTXHOHORFDWLIHWOHGDWLI
HQDUPpQLHQRQWWRXMRXUVpWpWUqVpWURLWHPHQWUHOLpVO·XQjO·DXWUH'pMjHQDUPpQLHQDQFLHQO·LGHQWLWpIRUPHOOH
GXORFDWLIHWGXGDWLITXHO·RQSHXWFRQVWDWHUGDQVGHQRPEUHX[SDUDGLJPHVHVWQRWDEOH2QUHPDUTXHELHQV€U
HQSDUWLFXOLHUTXHPrPHODWHUPLQDLVRQGXORFDWLI %M69>PrPHHQDUPpQLHQSHXWDYRLUpWpjO·RULJLQHDXVVL
IRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQWLTXHjODWHUPLQDLVRQGXGDWLI­O·LQYHUVHRQV·DSHUoRLWDORUVTX·HQDUPpQLHQDFWXHOODWHUPL
QDLVRQGXGDWLI %M#)TXLHVWLFLIL[pHSRXUOHFDVGDWLIDUHSULVGHQRPEUHXVHVIRQFWLRQVGXORFDWLIHWTXHQDWXUHO
OHPHQWHOOHFRwQFLGHDXVVLSDUVDIRUPHDYHFOHVWHUPLQDLVRQVFRUUHVSRQGDQWHVGXORFDWLIHQDUPpQLHQDQFLHQ
(QILQLOUHYLHQWjO·HVSULWGHO·LQGRHXURSpDQLVWHTX·HQJUHFTXLVHPEOHrWUHpWURLWHPHQWDSSDUHQWpjO·DUPpQLHQ
OHORFDWLIDFRwQFLGpGqVOHGpSDUWDYHFOHGDWLISDUO·HIIHWGHV\QFUpWLVPH(WF·HVWDXSOXVWDUGjFHPRPHQWOjTXH
VHSRVHODTXHVWLRQGXW\SHG·H[LVWHQFHTXHPqQHUpHOOHPHQWOHORFDWLIHQDUPpQLHQ
$ILQGHQHPHWWUHHQRSSRVLWLRQTXHO·DUPpQLHQDQFLHQHWO·DUPpQLHQPRGHUQH(QDUPpQLHQDQFLHQOHORFDWLI
DXQHSRVLWLRQGpWHUPLQpHGDQVOHSDUDGLJPHQRPLQDOTXLHVWDYDQWWRXWVRXWHQXHSDUOHIDLWTXHOHORFDWLIHVW
WRXMRXUVIRUPHOOHPHQWLGHQWLTXHjO·DFFXVDWLIDXSOXULHOHWTX·LOQHO·HVWSDVGDQVFHUWDLQVSDUDGLJPHVDXVLQJXOLHU
,FLOHORFDWLIPqQHSRXUDLQVLGLUHXQHH[LVWHQFHUHODWLYHUpVXOWDQWGHVDUHODWLRQDX[DXWUHVFDVTXLRFFXSHQWXQH
SRVLWLRQDEVROXHDXVHLQGXSDUDGLJPH,OVHPEOHWRXWHIRLVTX·LO\DLWHXXQEHVRLQGHPDUTXHUOHORFDWLIFHSRXU
TXRLGHX[VLJQHVRXPRUSKqPHVGLVWLQFWVRQWpWpFUppVHWXWLOLVpVSRXUOHORFDWLI(QDUPpQLHQPRGHUQHO·XQGH
FHVVLJQHVUHVVRUWFRPPHpWDQW/(VLJQHOLQJXLVWLTXHGXORFDWLIHWHVWPrPHXWLOLVpSRXUODIRUPDWLRQG·XQQRX
YHDXSUpVHQWTXLHVWQpHQTXHOTXHVRUWHG·XQH´IRUPHSURJUHVVLYHµ ´MHVXLVHQWUDLQGHSDUOHUµ UHSRVDQWjOD
EDVHVXUXQFRQFHSWORFDWLI(QDUPpQLHQPRGHUQHOHORFDWLIRFFXSHGRQFXQHSRVLWLRQDEVROXHGDQVOHSDUDGLJPH
SDUOHIDLWTX·LOH[LVWHXQVLJQHTXLOXLHVWH[FOXVLYHPHQWDWWULEXpHWTXLPDUTXHGHPDQLqUHXQLYRTXHOHORFDWLI
DXVLQJXOLHUFRPPHDXSOXULHO/HORFDWLIDYHFVRQVLJQHGLVWLQFWQHFRXYUHFHSHQGDQWSDVWRXWHVOHVIRQFWLRQV
ORFDWLYHV&HOOHVFLVRQWDORUVUHSULVHVSDUPLG·DXWUHVFDVDYDQWWRXWSDUOHGDWLI'DQVTXHOOHPHVXUHFHVGHX[

:<
0LQDV%ঈߖNHDQF૛¬OSO
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7\K%N;QT,N\*/,B%H\%N,3<*/F%8B%<KAQB/8B% O@@

SRLQWVILQDX[G·XQHpYROXWLRQGRLYHQWrWUHUDSSURFKpVFHODVHUDODWkFKHGHVUHFKHUFKHVIXWXUHVTXLGHYURQWIDLUH
SRUWHUOHXUDWWHQWLRQVXUOHVWH[WHVHQDUPpQLHQPR\HQ6LOHVGRFXPHQWVpFULWVGLVSRQLEOHVVHURQWHQPHVXUHGH
IRXUQLUGHVUHQVHLJQHPHQWVH[DFWVVXUFHVXMHWFHODHVWXQHWRXWHDXWUHTXHVWLRQ

67897:;<=>?7@
$EHJKLDQ$UWDVFKHV
  B!1(->!)#04+!%D-(>>($#=g%,0$M%1)"%J!0$(->!)#04+%HUOLQ
$Q\D‫ן‬W૛'DYLW૛
  (UHYDQ
%ঈߖNHDQF૛0LQDV
  9HQLVH
.DUVW-RVHI
% OP?O% O#0$6-#04+!%D-(>>($#=%"!0%b#.#=#04+M<->!)#04+!)6WUDVERXUJ
.R‫ן‬EDF૛L(]QLN
  &RQVWDQWLQRSOH
0HLHU%UJJHU0LFKDHO
% :?O?% /)"65!->()#04+!%7I-(4+9#00!)04+(:$qPHpG%HUOLQ
0J8>>JK2%!HKF8HJ
% OPOQ% <.$(->!)#04+!0%8.!>!)$(-&14++HLGHOEHUJ
6FKPLWW5GLJHU
% :??@% D-(>>($#=%"!0%b.(00#04+M<->!)#04+!)%>#$%0I-(4+?!-5.!#4+!)"!)%8-.a1$!-1)5!)qPHpG,QQVEUXFN
6FKU|GHU-RKDQQ-RDFKLP
% O@OO% *+!(0(1-10%.#)51(!%<->!)#4(!2%()$#X1(!%!$%+6"#!-)(!2%31>%?(-#(%@-(]#60%>($!-#(2%41c10%!.!)4+1>%0!X1!)0%I(5!..(%
!]+#&!$$PVWHUGDP
9DUGDSHW9DUGDQ
  9HQLVH
;RUHQDF૛L0RYVHV
  6DLQW3pWHUVERXUJ
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% QB/DA87%<\*,\K%H\%H<*/F%8*%H8%N;/B7*K\A8B*<N% O@P

!"
#$%&'()*+,-.,/*0,*0+-%1*(-*0(*23%$)-/,'($-+2

F-()R6#0!%S("!-2%Q46.!%@-($#X1!%"!0%O(1$!0%Q$1"!0%^@(-#0`

/HVSRqWHVGHODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVRQWFKHUFKpjIRUJHUWRXWHVVRUWHVG·pQLJPHV/HPRQWUHQWSDU
H[HPSOHOHVQRPVTXHFHUWDLQVG·HQWUHHX[VHVRQWGRQQpV$LQVLFHOXLGXSRqWHGH.;O'>)!%?U"#X1!%(1]%U)#5>!02%
K5?!"('ҸUJKiWDPDV´DX[ORQJXHVWpQqEUHVµWpQqEUHVPpWDSKRULTXHVGHO·pQLJPHTXLYDOHQWj+pUDFOLWH
GHV·DSSHOHU0=6$!#)ç0´REVFXUµHWTXLSHXYHQWUHFRXYULUGHVFKRVHVDXVVLFDFKpHVTXHO·LQYHQWDLUHPLQLDWXUHGX
V\VWqPHFRQVRQDQWLTXHLHTX·RIIUHOHQRPUHFRQVWUXLW ´PLQLDWXUHµHQFHTX·LOSHXWSURFpGHUSDUH[HPSODLUHV
G·XQHVpULHGHSKRQqPHV j". +૖ _5+M6M$!>+_M!0jRFFOXVLYHVGHGHX[SRLQWVHWWURLVPRGHVG·DUWLFXODWLRQ"l$%9FHF7J%JK%
VRXUGHHQSDLUHj5+OLTXLGHHWQDVDOHj.l>O·XQHYR\HOOHHWO·DXWUHFRQVRQQHVSLUDQWHVj+_2%>67EHI6>J2%JK%0VLIIODQWH
/HSURFpGpHVWKpULWpFRPPHOHPRQWUHQWOHVQRPVG¶O6>E-!HWG·OU0#6"!N%j0+nM6>૖ +n-M6´TXLDMXVWHOHVOLDJHVµ TXH
VRQWOHVFKDQWVKLWWLWH#0+(>#'(MHWF j0!+nM$#M06"M6M%X%+̒Vt + 6"60´TXLOLHOHVURXWHVµ SUHPLHUVPHPEUHVGHj0 !
+nM´OLHUµjVXIIL[HVM6>M%JK%M$#M QRPVFUppVHQSRODULWpOHSUHPLHUDODSDLUHGHQDVDOHHWOLTXLGHj>૖ l- YR\HOOHHW
FRQVRQQH OHVVSLUDQWHVj0%JK%j+nPDLVHVWGpSRXUYXG·RFFOXVLYHVOHVHFRQGDDXFRQWUDLUHFHVGHUQLqUHVSDUj$l"2%
JK%>J9%9=876HKJ9%j0%JK%j+nPDLVHVWGpSRXUYXGHVQDVDOHVHWOLTXLGHV/HVWURLVQRPVRIIUHQWGHSOXVODFDUDFWpULVWLTXH
JpQpUDOHGHVFRPSRVpVTX·HVWO·LQVWDXUDWLRQGHOLHQVSKRQRORJLTXHVHQWUHOHXUVGHX[PHPEUHV"l$LQLWLDX[SRXU
OHSUHPLHUSRXUOHVHFRQGj+nDOOLWpUDQW HWOHVHFRQGpOpPHQWGHVJURXSHVj0+nM%JK%j>+nMjj>૖ GHYDQWODODU\QJDOH
FRQVRQQH SRXUOHWURLVLqPHj0DOOLWpUDQWjO·LQLWLDOHHWj$l"jO·LQWpULHXUODV\QFKURQLHFRQVHUYH"l$2%-l>jO·LQWp
ULHXUSRXUOHYpGLTXH>l-%=FL7%+ཬP̒URV+DOOLWpUDQWSRXU+̒VtKRGRV2%JK%9TF==F96HK%6L%M0MLQWpULHXU&HVH[HPSOHV
HWELHQG·DXWUHVPRQWUHQWTX·LOIDXWFRPSWHUQRQVHXOHPHQWDYHFOHVDOOLWpUDWLRQVPDLVDYHFOHVSDLUHVSKRQROR
JLTXHV(WOHV´URXWHVµGHVSRqWHVVRQWSDYpHVG·´pQLJPHVµJUHF(y)602%(É)#5>(GHj0+nM!#MjSVLORVHFRPPHGDQV
OHGRXEOHW<#0ÉM6"60GH+̒VtKRGRVIL[DWLRQGXV\QWDJPHGHO·O'>)!%h%O!->E0(#)h%>E)%U)$+!)%+6"6y62%$h%";(#)ç$!-%
ë%U)$+!)%+6"6y6´pQLJPDWLTXHG·XQF{WpGHODURXWHSOXVpQLJPDWLTXHGHO·DXWUHµGLW$SROORQ N6]#(0´REOLTXHµ
pSLFOqVHV·DSSOLTXDQWHQFRUHjO·pQLJPH HQSDUODQWGHV´FKRVHVOLpHVµSDUO·´KHUPpWLTXHµ+HUPqV jQRPGHj0!-M%
´OLHUWUHVVHUµ TXLDEURXLOOpODSLVWHGHVYDFKHVUD]]LpHVjVRQIUqUH
/HVpQLJPHVIRUJpHVSDUOHVSRqWHVVRQWGHIRUPHVWUqVGLYHUVHV,OHQHVWGHSKRQRORJLTXHVFRPPHOHVQRPV
GHSRqWHVFLWpVG·DXWUHVV\QWD[LTXHVFRPPHFHOOHVTXHMHPHSURSRVHG·pWXGLHUjSURSRVGHPDQLSXODWLRQVGH
ILQDOHVFDVXHOOHVHWTXLQHVRQWSDVOHVVHXOHVGHFHWRUGUHXQHIRUPHSULYLOpJLpHHQHVWFHOOHGHVSKUDVHVQRPLQDOHV
jVXMHWHWSUpGLFDWGLVMRLQWVSDUODFRPSRVLWLRQGLVFRQWLQXH HOOHPrPHVRXUFHG·pQLJPHV FRPPH+í0%Iç"(%$U)"!#%
W%!)d%96tN‫گ‬L´FHOXLTXLWHQGVRQSLHGGDQVVDPDLVRQµ+pVLRGHN!0%$-(?(1]%!$%.!0%c61-0² HVW O·´HVFDUJRWµ
I+!-UM96#=60´TXLSRUWHVDPDLVRQµN!0%$-(?(1]UHOLpVSDUODUpFXUUHQFHOH[LFDOHGXQRPGHOD´PDLVRQµDYHF
XQLQYHQWDLUHGHVRFFOXVLYHVI2%$l"2%=GDQVOHSUHPLHUjFRPSOpWHUSDUODSDLUHGHIGXSUHPLHUI+GXVHFRQG
DXWUHOLDJH8QHDXWUHIRUPHHVWFHOOHGHIRUPXODLUHVjDV\QGqWHGXW\SHGHJHU̒QLRVKLSSyWD1pVW‫گ‬U´YLHX[ ELHQTX· 
KRPPHGHFKDUµ HQVDMHXQHVVHFHGRQWLODXUDLWSXPRXULU  HWGRQF ´6XUYLYDQWµ1HVW‫گ‬U GHj)!0M´VXUYLYUHµ 
,OHQHVWDXVVLGH.!]#4(.!0FRPPHFHOOHVGRQWOHUrYHGH3pQpORSHRIIULUDWURLVVRUWHVXQHIRUPHGHFRQVHUYD
WRLUHGHYHQXHLPPRWLYpHHQJUHFDPHQ̒QyV´REVFXUµXQHKRPRQ\PLH(#)ç0´pQLJPDWLTXHµHW´UHGRXWDEOHµXQH
=!))#)5IRUPHjIHXLOOHWDJHKHUPpWLTXH$!$!w=+($(#DSSOLTXpHHQVXUIDFHDX[´SRUWHVµPDLVHQVWUXFWXUHSURIRQGH
DXSRqWHTXL´DIRUJpµOHVpQLJPHV
,OSHXWDUULYHUTXHOHSRqWHGRQQHKHUPpWLTXHPHQWOHVPR\HQVGHFRPSUHQGUHVHVpQLJPHVSDUODODQJXHHW
RXOHP\WKH'DQVODODQJXHLOVVRQWGHWURLVVRUWHVVRLWXQHJORVHFRPPHFHOOHG·/.#("V6DUS̒GyQD
]‫گ‬zQDQDUSi[DV´5D]]LpUD]]LpYLYDQWµGLWG·XQMHXQHJXHUULHU´IDXFKpµ FIKiUS̒´IDXFLOOHµ OHSRqWHVDLWTXHOH
0MGHFHTXLHVWSRXUQRXVj0-૖ IMHVWFRQVHUYpKRUVGXJUHFFRPPHGDQVOHQRPTX·LODWWULEXHDXO\FLHQ6DUSpGRQ
PDLVDOWpUpHQJUHFFRPPHGDQVKDUSi]‫گ‬KiUS̒VRLWSDUOHW\SH7URt̒HUtE‫گ‬ORVIRUPXODLUHGRQWO·DGMHFWLI´DX[
PRWWHVTXLVHVRXOqYHQWµJUkFHjO·DJULFXOWXUHGpYHORSSpHGDQVODSODLQHKHUEHXVHJORVHHQOHFRPSOpWDQWOHQRP
pSLFKRULTXH J É.#6)GRQWOHSRqWHVDLWTX·LOVLJQLILH´SUDLULHµGDQVO·DLUHJpRJUDSKLTXHGH7URLH KLWWLWH9!..1MORXY

O@P
 oi.uchicago.edu

% FK<Bì,/78%S<H8K

J#.1M0( SRXUQHULHQGLUHGHJUHF8.w0#6)%I!"É6)´&KDPSV(O\VpHVµHWF HQXQHVLWXDWLRQGHELOLQJXLVPHVRLWSDU

XQHDQWRQ\PLHGXW\SHDPHQ̒Q{Q´REVFXUµWHUPHREVROqWHDXTXHOOHSRqWHRSSRVHWLVLG̒WDLjSURSRVGHVUrYHVGH
3pQpORSHFRPPHRQOHYHUUD3DUDLOOHXUVOHP\WKHSHXWrWUHXQPR\HQG·H[SOLTXHUOHQRP<=+#.!w0 j>૖ 5+n%M#.M 
HVWXQ´0DKčEDKčUDWDµ $NKLOH€PpJDSKpUWDWH2%/.#("HWFXQ´JUDQGSRXUYR\HXUGHEXWLQµ VDQVNULW%KiUD 
EXWLQGpFULWHQ²/DQJXHHWP\WKHV·XQLURQWSRXUODUpVROXWLRQGHO·pQLJPHGHVVRLGLVDQWSRUWHVGHVVRQJHV
´HQFRUQHHWHQLYRLUHµSDUOHVUpFXUUHQFHVOH[LFDOHVMRLJQDQWO·pQLJPHDXP\WKHGHO·RUGDOLHSDUO·DUFG·8O\VVH
&·HVWOHFDVSDUWLFXOLHUG·pQLJPHVV\QWD[LTXHVRUJDQLVpHVDXWRXUGX"($#:TXHMHYDLVLOOXVWUHULFLSDUTXHOTXHV
H[HPSOHVO·XQDYHVWLTXHGHX[DXWUHVJUHFVSRXUPRQWUHUOHFDUDFWqUHKpULWpGXSURFpGp&HOXLFLFRQVLVWHHQ
PDQLSXODWLRQVIRQGpHVVXUOHV\QFUpWLVPHGXGDWLISURSUHPHQWGLW G·LQWpUrWGHGLUHFWLRQHWF GXORFDWLIGH
O·LQVWUXPHQWDOIRUPHVjSDUWLFXOHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVjM!#GHGDWLIjM#GHORFDWLI GHX[IRUPHVDOWHUQDQWHVVFLQGpHV
V\QWD[LTXHPHQWSRXUOHVGHX[FDV jM!+_G·LQVWUXPHQWDO
-HFRPPHQFHUDLSDUO·DYHVWLTXHSDUFHTXHO·H[HPSOHjGLVFXWHUUHOqYHGXWUDQVIHUWDXGXDOLVPHPD]GpHQGH
OD´ODQJXHGHVGLHX[µF·HVWjGLUHGHODIRUPHGHSRpVLHLQGRHXURSpHQQHTXLVHSURFODPHKHUPpWLTXHSDUO·HP
SORLSRXUXQUpIpUHQWXQLTXHGHGHX[QRPVO·XQ´GRQQpSDUOHVKRPPHVµTXLHVWOHQRPXVXHOO·DXWUH´SDUOHV
GLHX[µTXLHVWXQQRPSRpWLTXHWRXMRXUVPRWLYpOHSUHPLHUSRXYDQWO·rWUHRXQRQGXW\SH/.#("=+(.=É"(%
NLNO̒VNRXVLWKHRtiQGUHVGqN~PLQGLQHQWUHOHVGHX[QRPVSHXWrWUHLQVWDXUpHXQHpQLJPHGXW\SHGHODSKUDVHQRPL
QDOH()ç0$!60%d%I+!-U96#=60LFLSRXUO·RLVHDXDXTXHOHVWFRPSDUpOH6RPPHLOIUqUHMXPHDXGHOD0RUW´ O·RLVHDX 
=w>#)"#0 GHYLHQGUD  O·RLVHDX =+(.=É02Y%=!))#)5IRQGpHVXUNKiONHRQK~SQRQ2%/.#("´VRPPHLOSDUOHEURQ]Hµ
´PRUWSDUO·pSpHµGLULRQVQRXV(QDYHVWLTXHOHGXDOLVPHPD]GpHQIDLWTX·LOQ·\DSOXVGHVSpFLILFDWLRQGHODGDWLRQ
GXQRPSDUOHVGLHX[GLVSDUXVGHFHWpWDWGHUHOLJLRQDXFRQWUDLUHGHFHTXLVHSDVVHSRXUOHVKRPPHVSURSUHPHQW
´PRUWHOVµ >(k'(=(MFIYpGLTXHPiUW\DGHj>-૖ M ´DXPDXYDLVODQJDJHµRSSRVpGDQVOHFDGUHGXPD]GpLVPH´DX
ERQODQJDJHµLPSOLFLWHGHVSRqWHV/·H[HPSOHHVWFHOXLGX´KpULVVRQµ O·DQLPDOjQRPXVXHO GXঈDND´DX[PDXYDLV
SLTXDQWVµ HVWERQHQWDQWTXH YD‫و‬KčSDU̾P´WUDYHUVDQWSDUVDYrWXUHSRXUODYrWXUH GHVKRPPHV µ
9RLFLOHWH[WH WUDG%HQYHQLVWH 9LG̒YGčG´OHFDQLQSHXUHX[DXPXVHDXSRLQWX VSčQ̾PVҸঈGU̾PXUYҸVDU̾P 
OHKpULVVRQ \LPYD‫و‬KčSDU̾P TXHOHVKRPPHVDXPDXYDLVODQJDJH \LPPDߖ\čNDDYLGXঈYDFD‫و‬K‫ گ‬DSSHOOHQWGXঈDNDY%
GXঈDN̾PQıPDDRMDLWH 'DQVOHGpWDLOOHWH[WHFRPPHQFHSDUO·pWKRORJLHGHO·DQLPDO HQWURLVQRPVj0DOOLWpUDQWV
HWSDOLQGURPHVҸҸV DXFHQWUHVRQFRPSRUWHPHQW´SHXUHX[µF·HVWjGLUHGpIHQVLISDUVDPLVHHQERXOH LPSOL
FLWHPHQWHQUHODWLRQDYHFFHTXLOXLYDXWVRQQRPGRQQpSDU´OHVKRPPHVDXPDXYDLVODQJDJHµ WUDLWSV\FKR
SK\VLRORJLTXHHWO·HQWRXUDQW SRXUPHWWUHHQUHOLHIXQHVXFFHVVLRQGHGHX[ELV\OODEHVHWG·XQTXDGULV\OODEH 
XQHQRWDWLRQDQDWRPLTXHFRGDQWOHF\FOHDQQXHOGHVDYLHSDUVRQKLEHUQDWLRQ HWLPSOLFLWHPHQWRSSRVpHjHOOH
VDUHSURGXFWLRQ ´OHFKLHQDXPXVHDXSRLQWXµHQFRUHDXMRXUG·KXLOHV7VLJDQHV G·RULJLQHLQGLHQQHVLELHQTXH
O·pQLJPHHVWLQGRLUDQLHQQH GLVWLQJXHQWHQWUHKpULVVRQV GRQWLOVVRQWIULDQGV jPXVHDXGHFKLHQHWjPXVHDX
GHSRUFTXDQGO·DQLPDOVHUpYHLOOHDXSULQWHPSVLOHVWPDLJUHD\DQWpSXLVpVHVUpVHUYHVHWVRQQH]UHVVHPEOHj
FHOXLG·XQFKLHQHQUHYDQFKHDSUqVO·pSRTXHGHVDUHSURGXFWLRQLODDPDVVpEHDXFRXSGHJUDLVVHHQSUpYLVLRQ
GHO·KLYHULOGRXEOHGHYROXPHHWVRQQH]GHYLHQWFRPSDUDEOHDXJURLQG·XQSRUF UHQVHLJQHPHQWVG€Vj-¬0
/DPEODUGTXHMHUHPHUFLH $SUqVO·pWKRORJLHYLHQWODGRXEOHQRPLQDWLRQOHQRPXVXHOGXঈDNDGpVLJQHO·DQLPDO
FRPPH´DX[PDXYDLVSLTXDQWVµOHQRPSRpWLTXHDXERQXVDJHTXLHQHVWIDLWjFRPSUHQGUHSDUXQSDVVDJHGH
3OLQHTXLGRQQHGHVFRUUHVSRQGDQWVpW\PRORJLTXHVGXVHFRQGPHPEUHGHGXঈDND2%DFXOHҸHWGXSUHPLHUGHYD‫و‬Kč
SDU̾P2%XHVW̒VN%O#0$6#-!%)($1-!..!² WUDG(UQRXW ´4XDQG OHVKpULVVRQV VHQWHQWOHFKDVVHXUUHQWUDQWOHXU
WrWHOHXUVSDWWHVHWWRXWHOHXUSDUWLHLQIpULHXUHRLOVQ·RQWTX·XQGXYHWUDUHHWLQRIIHQVLILOVVHURXOHQWHQERXOH
DILQGHQHSUpVHQWHUjODSULVHTXHOHXUVDLJXLOORQVµ (41.!60 SXLVD\DQWGpFULWOHVPR\HQVFUXHOVHPSOR\pVSDU
OHVFKDVVHXUVSRXUOHVWXHUHQpSDUJQDQWOHXUSHDX3OLQHDMRXWH´FHWDQLPDOQ·HVWSDVFRPPHQRXVOHFUR\RQV
JpQpUDOHPHQWXQHFUpDWXUHVXSHUIOXHSRXUO·KRPPHVDQVFHVDLJXLOORQVF·HVWHQYDLQTXHODPROOHWRLVRQGHV
EUHELVQRXVH€WpWpGRQQpHF·HVWDYHFFHWWHSHDXTX·RQODLQHOHVpWRIIHVµXHVW̒V SDUOHFDUGDJH 'DQVODGRXEOH
HFM8H6K8FH%GXঈDNDYD‫و‬KčSDU̾PVRQWUpSDUWLVO·LQVWUXPHQWGXFDUGDJHM(=(MHWVDGHVWLQDWLRQYD‫و‬KčTXLHVW
XQHIRUPHFDVXHOOHG·#)0$-1>!)$(.%DXTXHOSHXWrWUHVXSHUSRVpXQ"($#:
,OQHIDXWSDVPpFRQQDvWUHO·LPSRUWDQFHGHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVHQSUHPLHUPHPEUHGHFRPSRVpHQSDUWLFXOLHU
G·LQVWUXPHQWDO
6RLWO·pSLWKqWHG·$SROORQOXN̒JHQ̒ߓ2%/.#("%/HFRQWH[WHHVWO\FLHQSDUO·pSLVRGHGH3DQGDUH ILOVGH/\FDRQ
URLO\FLHQ jO·DUFORQJXHPHQWGpFULWDWWDTXDQWHWEOHVVDQW0pQpODV ² HWIDLVDQWYRHXG·LPPROHUXQH
KpFDWRPEHG·DJQHDX[SUHPLHUQpVjVRQUHWRXUj=pOpHYLOOHGHODYDOOpHGHO·$LV̒SRVGXWHUULWRLUHGH&\]LTXH
HQ0\VLHDWWULEXpDX[/\FLHQVSDU+RPqUH VHORQOHVFKROLDVWHjIOHV$QFLHQVDWWULEXDLHQWOHQRPGH/\FLH
jGHX[WHUULWRLUHVO·XQDXVXGRXHVWGHO·$VLH0LQHXUHO·DXWUHDXQRUGGHOD7URDGH &HFRQWH[WHQ·REOLJHSDVj
 oi.uchicago.edu

% QB/DA87%<\*,\K%H\%H<*/F%8*%H8%N;/B7*K\A8B*<N% 

FRPSUHQGUHFRPPH´QpHQ/\FLHµO·pSLWKqWHG·$SROORQSRXUOHSUHPLHUPHPEUHGHODTXHOOHRQWpWpSURSRVpHV
WURLVH[SOLFDWLRQV N!]#=6)%"!0%:-u+5-#!4+#0+!)%8I60VX>:¬%HFN@ SDUOHQRPGH´/\FLHµjH[FOXUHSDUFHTX·RQ
DWWHQGUDLWDORUV/XNtč2/XNt̒ jVXSSRVHUTX·XQQRPLQDWLIVRLWOpJLWLPH SDUOHQRPGX´ORXSµGXW\SHJUHF.w=602%
TXLSHXWrWUHjODEDVHGHWRSRQ\PHV´DX[ORXSVµFRPPH/XNtčOXLPrPHG·DQWKURSRQ\PHVDORUVGHVHQV´ORXS
JDURXµFRPPH/XNčZ‫گ‬QHQILQSDUOHQRPGHOD´OXPLqUHµj.1=M SDVVpDX[WKqPHVHQčGDQVJUHF$PSKLO~N̒%
)w]PRPHQWOLPLQDOHQWUHODQXLWHWOHMRXU/.#(" TXLGRLWrWUHjODEDVHGHO·pSLWKqWHGXGLHXNw=!#602%=>L9%
V€UHPHQW´OXPLQHX[µTX¶´D\DQWDIIDLUHDX[ORXSVµ&·HVWO·H[SOLFDWLRQTXHM·DGRSWHUDLLFLHQIDLVDQWGHOXN̒%LH%
#)0$-1>!)$(.M46>#$($#:FRUUHVSRQGDQWpW\PRORJLTXHPHQWjVDQVNULWUXFč$SROORQHVW´QpDYHFODOXPLqUHµFHTXL
FRQYLHQWDXGLHXVRODLUHDSSDUDLVVDQWjO·DXEHUHYHQDQWDXSULQWHPSVj'HOSKHVHWPDUTXpSDUOHVGHX[WRSR
Q\PHVTXLDOOLWqUHQWHU.60%JK%H!.I+!0$VWpULD'pORV´$VWUH TXLGHYLQW YLVLEOHµjODQDLVVDQFHGXGLHX'HOSKHV
´0DWULFHµHW´(PEU\RQµ^j59!.M&+MVDQVNULWJiUEKDHWF VRUWDQWGHO·REVFXULWpGHODPDWULFHSRXUYRLUODOXPLqUH
GXMRXU ]‫گ‬HLNDuKRUkLSKiRV+HOtRLR2%/.#("HWF GHX[WRSRQ\PHVUHQYR\DQWFHOXLFLDXPLFURFRVPH GHOD
QDLVVDQFHPDPPLIqUH FHOXLOjDXFRVPRV­ODVSKqUHG·$SROORQDSSDUWLHQWXQDXWUHFRPSRVpjSUHPLHUPHPEUH
#)0$-1>!)$(.2%KHN̒EyORV´TXLODQFHjYRORQWpµ VHVIOqFKHV RKHN̒HVWO·LQVWUXPHQWDOG·XQ ZHNč jM(M+_ FIGRU
KHNčEyORVSOXW{WTXHG·XQ9!=M6MFRPPHDYHVWLTXHYDV̾2%YDV‫گ‬
2QQHVDXUDLWYRLUXQHGpVLQHQFHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOGDQVWRXVOHV̒LQWpULHXUVGHFRPSRVpVSDUH[HPSOHO·pSL
FOqVHGH3RVpLGRQJDL̒ 9 6=+60´TXLpEUDQOHODWHUUHµYLHQWGHj5(y(%Zj5!+nM'(@j+_9M65+M6M%Zj+_9M!5+M´PHWWUHHQ
EUDQOHµVSpFLDOHPHQWXQ´YpKLFXOHµ@jjM(+_M%X%č LRQ̒ HQVDQGKLGHFRPSRVLWLRQ FRPSRVpDX[GHX[PHPEUHV
UHOLpVSDUOHVSDLUHVSKRQRORJLTXHVj5l5+2%j+nl+_2%j'l9H[HPSODLUHVG·RFFOXVLYHVVSLUDQWHVVRQDQWHVFRQVRQQHV 
0DLVF·HVWXQLQVWUXPHQWDOTX·RIIUHOHSUHPLHUPHPEUHYD‫و‬KčGXQRPDYHVWLTXHSRpWLTXHGX´KpULVVRQµGHj9!0M
6MDWWHVWpDXVHFRQGPHPEUHG·DYHVWLTXHPDߖ\‫گ‬YD‫و‬KD<DVKWGLWGHODODLQHGHVFKDPHDX[´TXLYrWOHVPRU
WHOVµ'HSOXVjYD‫و‬KčSDUDFRUUHVSRQGHQWOHVFRPSRVpVJUHFVjVHFRQGPHPEUHLGHQWLTXHjMI6-M6M(PSpGRFOH
JODXN̒SyURV2(PSpGRFOH7I+(!-6%O<Q2%SRWDP̒SyURV2SS3´TXLWUDYHUVHSDUODPHUµ WKqPHHQ č2%JODXNč 
´SDUOHIOHXYHµ FUppVXUOHSUHPLHUDYHFXQ ̒TXLHQHVWDQDORJLTXHDXOLHXGH ‫گ‬jM6M+_M /HQRPSRpWLTXH
GX´KpULVVRQµHVWGRQFjFRPSUHQGUHFRPPH´TXLWUDYHUVHSDUVDYrWXUHµ OHVSLTXDQWV´DLJXLOORQVµGHVRQQRP
XVXHO HWSHXWrWUHPLHX[´TXLWUDYHUVHI(-VDYrWXUHI61-ODYrWXUHµ pWRIIHVTXLQ·H[LVWHUDLHQWSDVVDQVFDUGDJH VL
jODGpVLQHQFHG·LQVWUXPHQWDODYHVWLTXHčRQVXSHUSRVHOHGRXEOHWčGHODGpVLQHQFHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOč\DGHGDWLI
FRQQXHHQYpGLTXH :DFNHUQDJHODQG'HEUXQQHUYRO HOOHSHXWHOOHPrPHSURYHQLUG·XQV\QFUpWLVPH
DQFLHQGXGDWLIHWGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOHQVXLWHVFLQGpVSDUDJJOXWLQDWLRQDXVHFRQGG·XQHSRVWSRVLWLRQFDVXHOOHjM'62%
FRQQXHSDUDLOOHXUVDXJpQLWLIWKpPDWLTXHHQjM60M'6%jM60GpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLIM'6 HQJORWWRJRQLHWKpPDWLVDWLRQ
G·XQHSRVWSRVLWLRQHQjM#FIjM#lM!#GHORFDWLIHWGDWLI" &HVIDLWVSURSUHVDX[GLIIpUHQFLDWLRQVSURJUHVVLYHVGHV
ILQDOHVGHFDVREOLTXHVDSSHOOHUDLHQWXQHDXWUHpWXGH'DQVFHWH[HPSOHODSRVVLEOHpQLJPHV\QWD[LTXHVHJUHIIH
VXUXQHpQLJPHOH[LFDOHFHUWDLQHODUpIpUHQFHLPSOLFLWHDXFDUGDJHGXQRP/HVGHX[H[HPSOHVJUHFVTXLVXLYHQW
VHFDUDFWpULVHQWGHODPrPHIDoRQSDUGHVpQLJPHVV\QWD[LTXHVDFFRPSDJQpHVG·pQLJPHVG·DXWUHQDWXUH
/HSUHPLHUILJXUHDXGpEXWGHODJpQpDORJLHGH%HOOpURSKRQJUDQGSqUHGH*ODXNRV,,OHQDUUDWHXUGHOD
FLQTXLqPHJpQpUDWLRQG·XQHIDPLOOHTXLFRPSUHQGHQGHVFHQGDQFHSDWHUQHOOH6LV\SKH*ODXNRV,%HOOpURSKRQ
+LSSRORTXH*ODXNRV,,/HGRPDLQHGHO·DwHXOHVWGpILQLDXGpEXWSDUXQYHUVKRORGDFW\OLTXH SURFpGpGHIRFDOL
VDWLRQ /.#("
U0$#%Iç.#0%(SK~U̒PXNK{LÉUJHRV%+#II6&ç$6#6
$XFHQWUHVHWURXYHO·pQLJPHGHWURLVPRWVGHX[WRSRQ\PHVGHWURLVV\OODEHVHQWRXUDQWOHGDWLIGHGHX[
V\OODEHVjGLVFXWHUpQLJPHTXHMHFRPSUHQGUDLFRPPH´/D7D[DLHTXLV·pWHQGGH&RULQWKHMXVTX·DXIRQGG·$UJRV
HWGH7LU\QWKHµ HQG·DXWUHVWHUPHVGXJROIHGH&RULQWKHDXJROIHG·$UJROLGH HWQRQ´(SK\UHDXIRQGGHO·$UJR
OLGHµ 0D]RQ QLFRPPHOHVLQWHUSUpWDWLRQVGLYHUVHVTXLHQRQWpWpGRQQpHV YRLU.LUN("%/.#("´/HDIDQG
RWKHUV>LQFOXGLQJ%HWKH0DOWHQ@VDZGLIILFXOW\LQWKHGHVFULSWLRQRI.RULQWKRVDV¶LQDFRUQHU
RUUHFHVVRI$UJRVVT%EXWWKDWLVDSSURSULDWHSURYLGHGZHWDNH$UJRVWRUHIHUHLWKHUPDLQO\WRWKH3HORSRQQHVHV%
RUWR$JDPHPQRQ·VNLQJGRPDVGHILQHGLQWKH&DWDORJXHµ
-HSHQVHSRXUPDSDUWTXH(SK~U̒PXNK{LÉUJHRVFRQWLHQWDXWDQWG·pQLJPHVTXHGHPRWVXQHOH[LFDOH (SK~U̒ 
GHX[ V\QWD[LTXHV >1=+x# GDWLI GH GLUHFWLRQ QRQ ORFDWLI ÉUJHRV SDU LQFOXVLRQ OLQJXLVWLTXH SRXU ´$UJRV HW
7LU\QWKHµ HWGHSOXVGHX[pQLJPHVGDQVO·pQLJPHXQHUpIpUHQFHDXGLSW\TXHHQLILQVFULWHQOLQpDLUH%DSSRUWp
GH7LU\QWKHHQ/\FLHSDU%HOOpURSKRQXQHDXWUHDX[FRUUHVSRQGDQFHVUR\DOHVUHODWLYHDX[DOOLDQFHVPDWULPRQLDOHV
FRQQXHVHQ$VLH0LQHXUHjODILQGHO·kJHGXEURQ]H
 oi.uchicago.edu

% FK<Bì,/78%S<H8K

(SK~U̒HVWXQH´7D[DLHµWLUpHG·XQQRPGHO·´LI µ +_ !&+1-60 YLUO#&(-L2HWF TXLVXEVLVWHHQFRUHGDQVGHQRP

EUHX[WRSRQ\PHVGXW\SHGH8?-!1] )UDQFH 8?6-( 3RUWXJDO Y?!-"6) 6XLVVH S-)6 0RUDYLH Y6-= $QJOHWHUUH 
HWFQRPEUHX[LOVWpPRLJQHQWGHO·LPSRUWDQFHGHVIRUrWVG·LIVGpERLVpHVGqVODSUpKLVWRLUHSRXUODIDEULFDWLRQ
G·DUFVHWGHOHXUVIOqFKHVHPSRLVRQQpHV'HO·DUEUH+RPqUHFRQQDvWODVHPSHUYLUHVFHQFHHWODWR[LFLWp/DSUHPLqUH
HVWDWWHVWpHSDUODFRPSDUDLVRQTXLSUpFqGHLPPpGLDWHPHQWO·pQLJPH² 0D]RQ ´FRPPHQDLVVHQWOHV
IHXLOOHV SK~OO‫گ‬QJHQH̒ DLQVLIRQWOHVKRPPHV ()"-x) /HVIHXLOOHVWRXUjWRXUF·HVWOHYHQWTXLOHVpSDQGVXUOH
VROHWODIRUrWYHUGR\DQWHTXLOHVIDLWQDvWUHTXDQGVHOqYHQWOHVMRXUVGXSULQWHPSVµ

೏I+wOODWjPpQW·iQHPRVNKDPiGLVNKpHLi..(%"U%$+;+wO̒
೏WpOHWKy‫گ‬VDI+wHLpDURVG·HSLJtQHWDLK‫گ‬U̒2

FRPSDUDLVRQGHV´JpQpUDWLRQVµGHIHXLOOHVHWG·KRPPHVGDQVGHX[YHUVKRORGDFW\OLTXHVGRQWOHSUHPLHUGLVMRLQW
OHVGHX[V\OODEHVGHVRQSUHPLHUPRWI+w..(%JH%I+wd..( iOOD HWI+wdO̒SRXUOHV´IHXLOOHVµHWOD´UDFHµGHVKRPPHV
HWGRQWOHVHFRQGTXLV·\UDWWDFKHSDUO·DOOLWpUDWLRQHQI+1MGRQQHSDUOHVGHX[V\OODEHVGLVMRLQWHVI+w !#dK‫گ‬
U̒OHVGHX[GHUQLqUHVV\OODEHVGH(SK~U̒LO\DGRQFOjGHVSDURQRPDVHVI+w..(2%SKࡃO̒2%SKXU̒%=FL7%>J9%GJL8>>J92%>J9%
KRPPHVOHWRSRQ\PH
'XFDUDFWqUHWR[LTXHGHO·DUEUH HQWLqUHPHQWYpQpQHX[VDXISDUVRQDULOOH WpPRLJQHGDQVO·,"'00U!%LHJ%6LK7J%
(SK~U̒TXHFHOOHFL&RULQWKH FLGHVVRXV SUREDEOHPHQWHQ(OLGHFHOOHR8O\VVHYDFKHUFKHUGXSRLVRQSRXUHQ
HQGXLUHVHVIOqFKHV ² HWG·ROHVSUpWHQGDQWVFUDLJQHQWTXH7pOpPDTXHQHOHXUUDSSRUWHGHTXRLOHXUIDLUH
XQEUHXYDJHHPSRLVRQQp ² GHX[IRUPHVG·HPSRLVRQQHPHQWSDUO·LITX·RIIUHDXVVLODILQGHO·O(>.!$GH
6KDNHVSHDUH&HFDUDFWqUHWR[LTXHUHQGFRPSWHGHO·pW\PRORJLHGHGHX[GHVQRPVGHO·LI/·XQHVWGXW\SHHSK~U̒2%
GHj+_!&+M´IUDSSHUjPRUWµGHIRUPHj+_&+M!)M YLVO&()#´PRUWPHXUWULHUµHWF FRPPHK!#>96-$&#."1)5GH
j59+!)M´IUDSSHUSRXUPDvWULVHUµ JUHFSKRQཬVpWDQWjFHWpJDUGDPELJX ODVROXWLRQGXSUREOqPHGXUDSSRUWHQWUH
O·´LI µHWOH´VDQJOLHUµ W\SHDOOHPDQG8&!-2%I6L>F89%<1.!-4#%8&1-61#4!0GRQWOHVPRQQDLHVUHSUpVHQWHQWXQVDQJOLHU
HWOHQRPVLJQLILH´YDLQTXHXUVSDUO·LIµPpWRQ\PLTXHGHO·DUF SDVVHGRQFSDUGHX[DSSOLFDWLRQVPpWDSKRULTXHV
GH´TXLIUDSSHµjXQSK\WRQ\PHHWjXQ]RRQ\PHHWPrPHGHX[VLDX´VDQJOLHUµRQDMRXWHOH´ERXFµWKUDFU&-60
/·DXWUHQRPGHO·LI G·RHVWWLUp´WD[DLHµ HVWODWLQ$(]10GHODUDFLQHj$+nM´IUDSSHUµGHKLWWLWH jUHGRXEOHPHQW 
$!M$+M(GLWGXWRQQHUUHHWGRQWOHGpULYpj$+nM1MDGRQQpDYHFOHVGHX[WUDLWHPHQWVj$ +n M1M%X% W࠽M2%JK%j$1+nM%X% Wࡃ%
SDUPpWDWKqVHGHVIRUPHVjpODUJLVVHPHQWVGHVWURLVSRLQWVHWWURLVPRGHVG·DUWLFXODWLRQHQM"MVDQVNULWWXGiWL2%
>6K8H%WXQG‫گ‬JUHF7ࡃGH~V2%7XQGiUH‫گ‬V ´7\GpHµ´7\QGDUHµ HQjM&+M2%7XSKi‫گ‬Q2%7ࡃSK‫گ‬Q ´7\SKpHµ HQjM=MJUHF$w=60%
´KDFKHµYVO$1=)‫ۓ‬Wү´IUDSSHUµ ࠽ $'=($# ࡃ HQj$!1MGpYHORSSpVXUj$1Mj$ +n 1M2%7H€NURVjIRUPXODLUHWy[‫گ‬QH€
HLG‫گ‬V2%/.#("HWF´H[SHUWHQO·DUFµ$ç]60GRQWOHQRPj$+nM6=M06MHVWDLQVLUHOLpjFHOXLGHO·LIj$+nM!=M06M%X%
>6K8H%$(]10PDWpULDXDYHFOHTXHOVRQWHPSRLVRQQpVOHVIOqFKHVHWOHEUHXYDJH´WR[LTXHµG·(SK~U̒HWIDLWO·DUFGH
7H€NURVTXL´IUDSSHµSDUVRQ$ç]60IDLWHQERLVGH$(]10
(SK~U̒HVWOHQRPDQFLHQGH&RULQWKHFRQQXG·+RPqUH bç-#)$+6)2%/.#("b6-#)$+ç$+# 6·LOHVW
FRQVHUYpGDQVOHSDVVDJHGXP\WKHGH%HOOpURSKRQTXLHVWXQP\WKHG·pFULWXUHF·HVWHQIRQFWLRQGHFHOXLFL
'·XQHSDUWRQFRQQDvWODUHODWLRQGHO·LIjO·pFULWXUHHQJHUPDQLTXHRODUXQHGX:1$+(-=SRUWHOHQRPGHO·´LIµ*
HWHQFHOWLTXHSDUOHP\WKHGH%DLOOLODSUqVODPRUWGXKpURVGXHjGHVFDORPQLHVHQUDSSRUWDYHFXQHKLVWRLUH
G·DPRXU³FHTXLpYRTXHOHP\WKHGH%HOOpURSKRQHQYR\pHQ/\FLHSDUOHURLGH7\ULQWKH3URLWRVjODVXLWHGHV
FDORPQLHVIDLWHVjO·HQFRQWUHGXKpURVSDUO·pSRXVHGHFHGHUQLHUGXW\SH3XWLSKDU³XQLIV·pOHYDVXUVDWRPEH
HWRQHQILWGHVWDEOHWWHVHQ65(>'·DXWUHSDUWODWR[LFLWpGHO·LIDSXrWUHPLVHHQUDSSRUWSDUOHSRqWHDYHFOH
PHVVDJHGHPRUW³VDSURSUHPRUW³TXH%HOOpURSKRQGRLWDSSRUWHUDXSqUHG·$QWHLD3XWLSKDUURLGH/\FLHVL
ELHQTXHSHXWrWUHHQLIOHGLSW\TXHVXUOHTXHO3URLWRVDLQVFULWGHQRPEUHX[´VLJQHVµ V̒PDWD PHXUWULHUV
JUiSVDVHQStQDNLSWXNW{LWKXPRSKWKyUDSROOiROHVV̒PDWDWKXPRSKWyUDUHQYRLHQWHQLQWHUWH[WXDOLWpDX[$+1>6I+$ç-(%
SKiUPDN (  HQFKLDVPH OHVSRLVRQVPHXUWULHUV ,"'00U! UDPHQpVG·XQHDXWUH(SK\UHSDU7pOpPDTXHSRXU
HPSRLVRQQHUOHVSUpWHQGDQWVVHORQOHVFUDLQWHVGHFHVGHUQLHUV/HVVLJQHVLQVFULWVVXUOHGLSW\TXHHQLISDUOH
IXWXUEHDXIUqUH SDUOHVIHPPHV GH%HOOpURSKRQGHX[JpQpUDWLRQVDYDQWODJXHUUHGH7URLHGRLYHQWDSSDUWHQLU
DXOLQpDLUH%LQVFULWVXUGHVWDEOHWWHVP\FpQLHQQHVWURXYpHVj7LU\QWKHFHTXLFRPPHOHERLVG·LIGXGLSW\TXH
HVWXQHpQLJPHGDQVO·pQLJPH
/HVHFRQGWRSRQ\PHWURLVLqPHPRWGHO·pQLJPHFRQWLHQWXQHDXWUHpQLJPHQRQSOXVOH[LFDOHFRPPH(SK~U̒2%
IRUPHGHFRQVHUYDWRLUHDYHFVRQDUULqUHSODQFXOWXUHOPDLVV\QWD[LTXHXQHLQFOXVLRQOLQJXLVWLTXH'pMjGDQV
OHYHQWUHGHOHXUPqUHOHVMXPHDX[$FULVLRVHW3URLWRVVHGLVSXWqUHQWODVRXYHUDLQHWpG·$UJRVHWGH7LU\QWKH/D
SUHPLqUHpFKXWj$FULVLRVODVHFRQGHj3URLWRV'HVGHX[YLOOHVMXPHOOHVÉUJRVd%*#-w)$+(%$!2%/.#("VHXOHOD
 oi.uchicago.edu

% QB/DA87%<\*,\K%H\%H<*/F%8*%H8%N;/B7*K\A8B*<N% 

SUHPLqUHHVWQRPPpHGDQVO·pQLJPHODVHFRQGHHVWFDFKpHSDUXQHLQFOXVLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHGXW\SHGH$ç](%=FL7%
´DUF HWIOqFKHV µ2QHVWG·DXWDQWSOXVHQFOLQjFURLUHTXH%HOOpURSKRQV·HVWHPEDUTXpSRXUOD/\FLHj7LU\QWKH
TXHOHQRPHVW´OLHXGH7UDYHUVpHµj$-૖ +nM1M)MM"+6MDYHFPrPHWUDLWHPHQWGHj-૖ TXHGDQVVDQVNULWWLUiWLHWPrPH
WKqPHHQ%M1TXHKLWWLWH%$(-+M1M%j$-૖ +nM1MFI*(-()$1>j$-૖ +nMU)$M6M7URLH7URtčj$-6+n\čHWFTXDQWj>1=+x#2%FH%
QHSHXWOHFRPSUHQGUHFRPPHXQORFDWLISRXUOHTXHORQDWWHQGUDLWODSUpSRVLWLRQ!)FRPPHFKH]3LQGDUHGDQV
XQSDVVDJHTXLVHUDSSRUWHjO·HVSDFHGpILQLSDUO·pQLJPHKRPpULTXH HQVHQVLQYHUVHGXSRLQWGHYXHGHO·RUGUH
GHVWRSRQ\PHV 1O?2%<O;<:2%6ߓWXWz3URÉ c$6#6%V%b6-É)$+61%$;!)%>1=+x#0L&HWHVSDFHHVWDYHFXQ"($#:%"!%"#-!4$#6)2%
FHOXLGHO·H[WHQVLRQG·XQHDQFLHQQH´*(](#!% QRPDQFLHQGH&RULQWKH c10X1;(1%:6)"%";<-560%!$%"!%*#-')$+!2µVRLWGX
JROIHGH&RULQWKHDXJROIHG·$UJROLGH(SK~U̒DFKDQJpVRQQRPGH*(](#!%JH%36-#)$+!%DSUqVOHVERXOHYHUVHPHQWV
TX·RQWHQWUDvQpVSRXUO·pFRQRPLHOHVGpERLVHPHQWVGHODIRUrWG·LIVGRQWO·DFWLYLWpDpWpUHPSODFpHSDUOHVDFWLYLWpV
PDULWLPHVGHV´FRUQHVµ j=6-#M)M"+6M TXHVRQWOHVJROIHVFIO(.#M=(-)(00ç0´&RUQHGHOD0HUµHWF
/·HVSDFHDLQVLGpILQLSDUO·pQLJPHHVWFHOXLGHVGHX[H[SORLWVGH%HOOpURSKRQGDQVVRQP\WKHOHGRPSWDJHGH
3pJDVHj&RULQWKHVRQGpSDUWGH7LU\QWKHSRXUOD/\FLHPXQLG·XQGLSW\TXHHQLIWpPRLQG·XQHFRUUHVSRQGDQFH
HQWUHOHURLGH7LU\QWKHHWFHOXLGH/\FLHF·HVWXQHWUDQVSRVLWLRQP\WKLTXHG·XQIDLWKLVWRULTXHFRQQXSDUGHV
DUFKLYHVG·$VLHPLQHXUHO·H[LVWHQFHGHFRUUHVSRQGDQFHVUR\DOHVjODILQGHO·kJHGHEURQ]HFRQFHUQDQWQRWDPPHQW
GHVDOOLDQFHVPDWULPRQLDOHV/·HVSDFHGpILQLSDUO·pQLJPHHVWDORUVFHOXLRV·XQLUHQWOHVPDLVRQVGH7LU\QWKH
&RULQWKHDLQVLTXHGH/\FLHGHVWLQDWLRQGXSRUWHXUGHODWDEOHWWH3URLWRVURLGH7LU\QWKHDYDLWSRXUpSRXVHXQH
ILOOHGXURLGH/\FLHHW%HOOpURSKRQLVVXG·XQHIDPLOOHGH&RULQWKHpSRXVHUDXQHVRHXUGHFHWWHGHUQLqUHHQFRUH
GHVpQLJPHVGDQVO·pQLJPHV\QWD[LTXH
,OYDHQrWUHGHPrPHGDQVO·H[HPSOHjGHX[GDWLIVGHVSRUWHVGHVVRQJHVNHUiHVVLV!.UI+()$#2%SUpWHQG€PHQW
´HQFRUQHHWHQLYRLUHµHQIDLW"($#:%!$%#)0$-1>!)$(.SRUWHVRXYHUWHVI61-OHVGHX[46-)!0% DMXVWpHV GHO·DUFG·8O\VVH
I(-ODFOpjSRLJQpH";#?6#-!GHODFOpGH3pQpORSHRXYUDQWOHWUpVRURVHWURXYHO·DUFGHO·RUGDOLHG·8O\VVHFRPPH
M·HVVDLHUDLGHOHPRQWUHUHQFRPPHQoDQWFRPPHGDQVO·H[HPSOHSUpFpGHQWSDUO·pOXFLGDWLRQG·pQLJPHVDXWUHV
TXHFHOOHGHVGDWLIV
&HVSRUWHVVRQWOHV´SRUWHVMXPHOOHVGHVVRQJHVµ"6#(ÑV%Iw.(#V%RQHtU‫گ‬Q2%,"'00U!SDUXQWUDQVIHUWGHV
´VRQJHVMXPHDX[µGHO·DYHVWLTXHY(0)(%'̾ષPč[?DI̾Qč/DJpPHOOLWpGHVVRQJHVHVWSRXUDLQVLGLUHWULSOHLOV
SHXYHQWrWUHGHERQVUrYHVRXGHVFDXFKHPDUVSRXUOHGRUPHXUREVFXUVRXFODLUVSRXUFHOXLFLjVRQUpYHLODYHF
RXQRQO·DLGHG·XQ H RQLURPDQFLHQ QH VHUpDOLVHURXQRQRXFRPPHGLWOHJUHFrWUHWURPSHXUVç)(-RXYpUL
GLTXHV+wI(- FIKLWWLWH01II(-M#'(MG·XQWKqPHHQjM-KpWpURFOLWLTXHGXWKqPHHQjM)MJUHF+wI)60DYHVWLTXH
]?DI̾QD2%>6K8H%96>)10%vj09 ! %IM-l)L 
3HXWrWUHLFRQLTXHGHFHWWHWULSOLFLWpOHIDLWTXHGDQVO·,"'00U!3pQpORSHIDLWWURLVUrYHVOHVGHX[SUHPLHUV
RQWODIRUPHGHGLDORJXHVHQWUHODUrYHXVHHWXQ H RQLURPDQFLHQ QH GDQVOHSUHPLHUVDV±XUGDQVOHUrYHGDQV
OHVHFRQG8O\VVHGDQVOHUrYHSXLVGDQVODUpDOLWp/HVWURLVUrYHV ,"'00U!²²² VRQW
DUWLFXOpVOHVXQVDX[DXWUHVGHGHX[IDoRQVSDUOHWKqPHGHO·K̒GXPRV%+wI)60GXSUHPLHU´VRPPHLOGRX[µ
HQFHTX·LO´IDLWRXEOLHUOHVERQQHVHWPDXYDLVHVFKRVHVµGHODUpDOLWpFRPPHGLWOHWURLVLqPH²HSpO̒VHQVl
HVWKO{Q̒GqNDN{QHWSDUGHVUpFXUUHQFHVOH[LFDOHVHWGHVDQWRQ\PHVFRQFHUQDQW

D  ODFODUWpGXSUHPLHUUrYH!)(-5U0%O·REVFXULWpGHVUrYHVDPHQ̒Q{QDLQyQGH
 VHFRQGUrYH 
E  OHVVRQJHVWURPSHXUVRXYpULGLTXHVç)(-%FL%+wI(-2
F  OD´FOpGHODSRUWHGHVVRQJHVµRQHLUHt̒LVLSXO̒LVL«NO̒vGDGRQQpHGHPDQLqUHFXPXODWLYH
SDUOHSUHPLHUUrYHHQFRPSRVLWLRQGLVFRQWLQXHV%HWGLVVRFLpHHQS~ODLRQHtU‫گ‬Q2%
 VHFRQGUrYH HWNO̒vGD DFWLRQGLIIpUpH 

(WO·DIIDEXODWLRQGXSUHPLHUUrYHQRXVOLYUHODWULSOLFLWpGHVVRQJHVMXPHDX['DQVO·RUGUHGXWH[WHYLHQWHQSUHPLHU
ODQRQUpDOLVDWLRQGXUrYHXQFDXFKHPDUTXLIDLWGH3pQpORSHXQHRGXURPpQ̒Q´VHODPHQWDQWµ  HQ
VHFRQGOHUpFLWGXFDXFKHPDUIDLWGHVRGXQč‫گ‬Q  HQUDSSRUWpW\PRORJLTXHDYHFOHSDUWLFLSHGHV´GRXOHXUVµ
FRQIRUPHVGDQVOHUrYHjODUpDOLWpGHFHTXHVRXIIUH3pQpORSHQRQHQGRUPLHSDUOHVVRXFLVTXHOXLGRQQHOH
YR\DJHGH7pOpPDTXHSDUWLV·LQIRUPHUGXVRUWGHVRQSqUH ²SRXUO·pWDWGHYHLOOH²SRXUOHUrYH HQ
WURLVLqPHODFODUWpGXVRQJH !)(-5E0%ç)!#-6) SRXU3pQpORSHUpYHLOOpHDSUqVOHVH[SOLFDWLRQVGHO·RQLURPDQFLHQQH
/HWURLVLqPHUrYH ² H[DPLQpLFLDYDQWOHVHFRQGHQUDLVRQGHVpQLJPHVQRPEUHXVHVGHFHGHUQLHU
GRQQHOHWKqPHGHO·RXEOLGHVERQQHVHWPDXYDLVHVFKRVHVSURFXUpSDUOHVRPPHLO´GRX[µGDQVOHSUHPLHUUrYH
TXDQWDX[WURLVDVSHFWVGHVVRQJHVMXPHDX[QRXVQ·HQFRQQDLVVRQVTXHGHX[3pQpORSHIDLWXQERQUrYHHQYR\DQW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% FK<Bì,/78%S<H8K

8O\VVHWHOTX·LOpWDLWjVRQGpSDUW ² PDLVHOOHFUDLQWTX·LOIDVVHSDUWLHGHV6)!É-($ ( V%=(=hHOOHQHVDLW

JH%JGGJK%=69%9T8>%J9K%LH%ç)(-%FL%LH%+wI(-HQO·DEVHQFHG·XQ H RQLURPDQFLHQ QH TXLOXLIHUDLWFRPSUHQGUHV·LOHVW
FODLU !)(-5E0 RXREVFXU DPHQ̒QyV 
&·HVWGDQVOHVHFRQGUrYHTXHILJXUHSDUPLG·DXWUHVO·pQLJPHV\QWD[LTXHGHVNHUiHVVLV!.UI+()$#´¬JpPHOODLUH¬´
SDUFHTX·HOOHHVWHOOHPrPHGRXEOHSDUO·HPSORLGHGHX[GDWLIV XQGDWLIHWXQLQVWUXPHQWDO HWSDUFHOXLG·XQ
SOXULHO SOXUDOLVDWLRQG·XQGXHO HWG·XQVLQJXOLHU
-·pWXGLHDYDQWGHODUpVRXGUHODWULSOLFLWpGHVVRQJHVMXPHDX[GDQVFHSDVVDJHGpOLPLWpSDUOHVyQHLU‫گ‬QGH
HW
9LHQWHQSUHPLHUOHFDUDFWqUHGHFDXFKHPDUGXUrYHQDUUpSDU3pQpORSHj8O\VVHTX·HOOHQ·DSDVUHFRQQX³
XQDLJOHDWXpOHVYLQJWRLHVGHVRQWURXSHDX²0DLVFHFDXFKHPDUGDQVOHUrYHPrPHHVWFRQWUDLUHjVD
UpDOLVDWLRQFRPPHOHOXLDQQRQFHO·RQLURPDQFLHQO·DLJOHOXLPrPH²61=%ç)(-2%(..;%+wI(-%!0$+.ç)2%+ç%$6#%
$!$!.!0>U)6)%U0$(#´FHQ·HVWSDVXQUrYHWURPSHXUPDLVXQUrYHYpULGLTXHTXLVHUpDOLVHUDSRXUWRLµOHVSUpWHQGDQWV
VHURQWFHVRLHVHWO·DLJOHO·pSRX[GH3pQpORSHTXLOHVWXHUD­VRQUpYHLOODUpDOLWpHVWELHQFRQWUDLUHDXFDXFKH
PDUVHVRLHVVRQWYLYDQWHV ² HWO·RQLURPDQFLHQ8O\VVHFRQILUPHO·RQLURPDQFLHGHO·DLJOHGXUrYH ² 
9LHQWHQVXLWHODGLVVHUWDWLRQUKpWRULTXHGH3pQpORSHVXUOHVUrYHVHQJpQpUDOGHGL[YHUV ²  WUDGXFWLRQ
GH-DFRWWHW ´/HVVRQJHVpWUDQJHUVVRQWFRQIXVHWSDUOHQWSHXFODLU yQHLURLDP̒NKDQRLDNULWyPXWKRL ,OVVRQW
ELHQORLQGHWRXVVHUpDOLVHU $!.!É!$(# SRXUOHVKRPPHV&DUSRXUOHVVRQJHVYDFLOODQWVLOHVWGHX[SRUWHV
O·XQHHVWIDLWHGHFRUQHHWO·DXWUHO·HVWG·LYRLUH ²GRLDuJiUWHS~ODLDPHQ̒Q{QHLVuQRQHtU‫گ‬Q_+(#%>E)%5h-%NHUiHVVL%
$!$!w=+($(#2%+(#%";!.UI+()$# OHVUrYHVDUULYDQWSDUO·LYRLUHVFLp !.UI+()$60 VRQWUrYHVGpULVRLUHVQ·DSSRUWDQW
TXHSDUROHVYDLQHV KRtU·HOHSKDtURQWDLpSH·DNUiDQWDSKpURQWHV PDLVFHX[TXLHQWUHQWSDUODFRUQHELHQSROLH
[HVW{QNHUi‫گ‬Qd%$+w-(G! FRUQHQWODYpULWp U$1>(%=-(É)610# DXPRUWHOTXLOHVYRLW2UMHGRXWHTXHVRLW
YHQXSDUOjFHUHGRXWDEOHVRQJH (#)í)%ç)!#-6) µ
/·pQLJPHV\QWD[LTXH NHUiHVVLHOpSKDQWL Q·HVWTXHO·XQHGHVQRPEUHXVHVpQLJPHVGXSDVVDJHLF{QLTXHPHQW
DGDSWpHVDXFDUDFWqUHpQLJPDWLTXHG·XQUrYHGRQWRQQHVDLWVLç)(-%FL%+wI(-LOVHUpDOLVHUDHWVLRXLVRXVODIRUPH
G·XQERQRXG·XQPDXYDLVUrYH/DUpSRQVHVHUDGRQQpHSDUODFRPSRVLWLRQGLIIpUpHSDUODTXHOOHVHUDH[SOLTXpH
O·pQLJPHV\QWD[LTXHHWTX·LQGLTXHOHIXWXUU0$(#GH
/DWULSOLFLWpGHVVRQJHVMXPHDX[HVWWUDLWpHDXSODQOLQJXLVWLTXHSDUODJpPHOOLWpGHVWHUPHVDQWRQ\PHV
UpSpWpVHQSDURQRPDVHKRPRQ\PHV
/·DFFRPSOLVVHPHQWHVWLQFHUWDLQOHUrYHVHUDXQ+wI(-VHORQO·RQLURPDQFLHQ61=%ç)(-2%(..;%+wI(-%!0$+.ç)2%+ç%
$6#%$!$!.!0>U)6)%U0$(#PDLVODUrYHXVHQ·HQHVWSDVV€UHSXLVTXHRXGpWLSiQWDWHOHtHWDLDQWKU‫گ‬SRLVLDYHFUpSpWLWLRQ
GXYHUEHDXSDUIDLWLQGLTXDQWO·DFFRPSOL&HWKqPHHVWPLVHQUDSSRUWDYHFO·pQLJPHV\QWD[LTXHSDUO·LQVWDXUDWLRQ
G·XQHUHODWLRQHQWUHODWURPSHULHGHO·ç)(-HWODYpUDFLWpGHOT+wI(-UHVSHFWLYHPHQWDYHFODFRUQHHWO·LYRLUHHQ
FKLDVPHDYHFOHV=!-(U00#d!.UI+()$#GHO·pQLJPHV\QWD[LTXHUHODWLRQGHODWURPSHULHHWGHO·LYRLUH SULVWR€
´VFLpµDXVHQVWHFKQLTXHµPDLVDXVVLHQIHXLOOHWDJHKHUPpWLTXHSRXUXQHVSRLU´VFLpµ SDUODSDURQRPDVHGHV
HOpSKDQWLHOpSKDQWRV UpSpWLWLRQ HWGH!.!I+(É-6)$(#SRXUOHVUrYHV´TXLWURPSHQWµGHODYpUDFLWp
HWGHODFRUQHSDUFHTXLHVWSOXVTX·XQHSDURQRPDVHXQUDSSRUWpW\PRORJLTXH DXPRLQVSRXUQRXV HQWUH=U-(0%
´FRUQHµHWSDUPpWRQ\PLHGHOD´FRUQHµSRXUODWrWHNUDtQ‫´گ‬DFKHYHUµ FIIUDQoDLV´FKHI µGH4(I1$ OXLDXVVL
G·XQHUpSpWLWLRQJpPHOODLUHSDUDQWRQ\PLHGHVGHX[IRUPHVYHUEDOHVHQWRXUDQWNHUi‫گ‬QUI! ( DNUiDQWD
RSSRVLWLRQGHVSDUROHVjO·DFWLRQ GDQVOHYHUVTXLFRQWLHQW!.!I+(É-6)$(#2%JK%U$1>(%=-(É)610#TXLRSSRVHj
FHWWHWURPSHULHODYpULWp U$1>( 
/HWKqPHGXERQHWGXPDXYDLVUrYHHVWLQFOXVGDQVFHOXLGHO·DFFRPSOLVVHPHQWHQ+wI(-RSSRVpjç)(-%=67%
O·RQLFURPDQFLHQ  PDLVDXVVLjODILQGXSDVVDJHHQJpPHOOLWpSDUODUrYHXVHRSSRVDQWWRXMRXUVHQJpPHOOLWp
VRQFDXFKHPDU(#)í)%ç)!#-6)HWODMRLH (0I(0$ç) TXHOHXUDSSRUWHUDLWjHOOHHWVRQILOVFRPPHHOOHOHVRX
KDLWHXQHUpDOLVDWLRQGHVRQUrYHFRQIRUPHDX[SUpGLFWLRQVGHO·RQLURPDQFLH (0I(0$í)%!>6Ñ%=(Ñ%I(#"Ñ%5U)6#$6 
´MHGRXWHTXHVRLWYHQXSDU>ODSRUWHNHUiHVVL@FHUHGRXWDEOHVRQJHQRXVHQDXULRQV7pOpPDTXHHWPRLWURSGH
MRLHµ WUDG-DFRWWHW 
(QWURLVLqPHOLHXOHWKqPHGHO·REVFXULWpGHVUrYHVpQLJPDWLTXHVHVWWUDLWpHQFRUHHQJpPHOOLWpSDUGHX[
OH[qPHVHWXQGLVWLTXH/HVSUHPLHUVDPHQ̒Q{Q%JK%(#)ç)UHOLpVSDU(Md)6MVRQWDXVVLFKDFXQOHVLqJHG·XQHJpPHO
OLWpOHSUHPLHUSDUDQWRQ\PLHOHVHFRQGSDUKRPRQ\PLH$PHQ̒Q{QdRQHtU‫گ‬QV·RSSRVHQRQVHXOHPHQWj
>T!)(-5U0%ç)!#-6)GXSUHPLHUUrYH  PDLVGDQVODWLUDGHGH3pQpORSHjO·LVRV\OODELTXHEURW{QKzWHNpQWLVLG̒WDL2%
 ´TXDQGO·XQGHVPRUWHOVYRLWµ ,OV·DSSOLTXHDX[´VRQJHVREVFXUVµSURSUHPHQW´QRQYLVLEOHVµSULYDWLIG·XQ
GpULYpGHj>!)MTXLDJDUGpOHVHQVDQFLHQGHODUDFLQH´YRLUµ FIDQDWRO>!)#Ml(M DYDQWG·rWUHHPSOR\pSRXUOD
SHQVpHGRQWOHPRGHSULYLOpJLpHVWODYLVLRQ FIODWLQPHQWLVRFXOҸHWF &HGpULYpGHj>!)M!0M JUHF>U)60VDQVNULW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% QB/DA87%<\*,\K%H\%H<*/F%8*%H8%N;/B7*K\A8B*<N% 

PiQDVHWF HQQDVDOHHVWKpULWpjF{WpGHFHj>!)!0M)6M%>J%>6K8H%6%0HQ̒QLXV $JULSSD j>!)!0M)#M6M´GRXpGHSHQ

VpHµOHXUHVWDSSDUHQWpJUPHQHDtQ‫گ‬j>!)!0M6)M'6M´rWUHSULVGHIXUHXUµ FI>U)60TXLPRQWUHTXHFRPPHG·XQH
DXWUHIDoRQ(1$çM>($60LOV·DJLWG·XQHSHQVpHHQPRXYHPHQWFIPHQRLQi‫´گ‬rWUHSOHLQG·DUGHXUµpW\PRORJLTXHPHQW
´DYRLUO·pODQGHODSHQVpHµFRPSRVpGHj>!)MQRPUDFLQHHWG·XQGpULYpHQQDVDOHOXLDXVVLGHODUDFLQHGHO·´pODQµ
j+n6#MjYRFDOLVPHM6MFIJUHF+#!-í)%>U)60VDQVNULW#ɓLUiPiQDVjDGMHFWLIGHj+n#M0M ´2EVFXUµXQVRQJHO·HVWSDU
VRQFDUDFWqUH´pQLJPDWLTXHµDLQyQHQOHTXHOOHSRqWHDVXSHUSRVpGHX[KRPRQ\PHV´UHGRXWDEOHµ FDXFKHPDU HW
´pQLJPDWLTXHµ SURSUHPHQW´OLpµFI<É)#II60´DX[FKHYDX[OLpVKDUQDFKpVµ DGMHFWLIR[\WRQjF{WpGXVXEVWDQWLI
D67EKFH%(y)60´pQLJPHµGHj0+nM!#M´OLHUµjSVLORVHFRPPHGDQV<#0ÉM6"602%$tV‫گ‬SRV´+pVLRGHµ´(VRSHµXQVFKROLDVWH
DELHQYXO·KRPRQ\PLHDLQzQyQHLURQWzQWKDXPDVWzQ̒SKREHUzQ̒WzQVNRWHLQyQ
/HGLVWLTXH೉೉GRLDuJiUWHS~ODLDPHQ̒Q{QHLVuQRQHtU‫گ‬Q%
 ೉KDLPqQJjUNHUiHVVLWHWH~NKDWDLKDLG·HOqSKDQWL%
HVWWUXIIpG·pQLJPHVGHX[OH[LFDOHVDPHQ̒Q{QGpMjYXHVGHSOXV$!$!w=+($(#HQIHXLOOHWDJHKHUPpWLTXHSRXUOHV
SRUWHVHWOHSRqWHRQOHYHUUDGHX[V\QWD[LTXHVOHSOXULHOGXQRPGHOD´FRUQHµ SOXUDOLVDWLRQG·XQGXHORQOH
YHUUDDXVVLHWODSDLUHGHGDWLIVNHUiHVVLHOpSKDQWLSDUODTXHOOHMHFRPPHQFHUDL 
8QHWUDGXFWLRQFRPPH´O·XQH GHVSRUWHV HVWIDLWHGHFRUQHO·DXWUHO·HVWG·LYRLUHµ -DFRWWHW HVWLPSRVVLEOH
SRXUGHVUDLVRQVV\QWD[LTXHVWUqVVLPSOHVHOOHQHWLHQWSDVFRPSWHGHODGLIIpUHQFHHQWUHSOXULHOHWVLQJXOLHU
HWODIRUPHFDVXHOOHHPSOR\pHSRXULQGLTXHUODPDWLqUHQ·HVWSDVOHGDWLIPDLVOHJpQLWLIFRPPHO·!.UI+()$60GH
HPSOR\pSRXUODSRLJQpHHQLYRLUHGHODFOpGH3pQpORSHXQH´FOpGHO·pQLJPHµ&HWWHGHUQLqUHQHSRXUUD
rWUHUpVROXHTX·HQFRPSRVLWLRQGLVFRQWLQXHSDUO·DFWLRQGLIIpUpHGXFKDQW DSUqVOHVUrYHVGHHW FOpj
SRLJQpHG·LYRLUHSDUODTXHOOHO·H[UrYHXVHYDDJLUHQRXYUDQWODSRUWHGXWUpVRUSRXU\SUHQGUHO·DUFG·8O\VVHIDLW
GHO·DVVHPEODJHGHGHX[FRUQHV
&HWWHDFWLRQ TXLV·RSSRVHDXUrYH HVWOHWURLVLqPHYROHWGHODWULDGHJpQpUDOHSHQVpHSDUROHDFWLRQGHVGHX[
SUHPLHUVODSHQVpHHVWUHSUpVHQWpHSDUOHUrYHYLVLRQHQSHQVpHFI (M PHQ̒QyVODVHFRQGHO·HVWSDUOHVGLDORJXHV
HQWUHODUrYHXVHHWOHVRQLURPDQFLHQVODWURLVLqPHHVWDQQRQFpHELHQDYDQWG·rWUHUpDOLVpHSDUFHTXHGLW3pQpORSH
MXVWHDSUqVVDWLUDGHVXUOHVUrYHVF·HVWO·RUGDOLHG·8O\VVHSDUO·DUFHQIDLWSDUODIOqFKHXQLTXHTXHOXLVHXOVDLW
IDLUHSDVVHUSDUOHVWURXVGHGRX]HKDFKHVOHXUV´\HX[µSDUOHVTXHOVRQHQIRQFHOHVPDQFKHV 0$!#.!#z0 
²SDUODERXFKHGHO·KpURwQHODSRqWHMRXHGHVGHX[VHQVGHiHWKORQ´MHXµSRXU8O\VVH´pSUHXYHµSRXUOHV
SUpWHQGDQWV WUDG-DFRWWHW ´MHYDLVSURSRVHUXQHpSUHXYHFHOOHGHVKDFKHVTXHFHKpURVQDJXqUHHQVRQSDODLV
DOLJQDLWGRX]HHQWRXWVHWGHERXWDVVH]ORLQLOOHVWUDYHUVDLWGHVDIOqFKH9RLOjO·pSUHXYHTXHM·LPSRVHUDLDX[
SUpWHQGDQWVµHWTXLFRPPHFKDFXQVDLWQ·DSXrWUHUpXVVLHTXHSDU8O\VVH
'HVUpFXUUHQFHVOH[LFDOHVUHOLHQWOHVUrYHVjO·DFWLRQGLIIpUpHHQGHX[DFWHVSRXU3pQpORSHFOpHWLYRLUHSRXU
8O\VVHFRUQHVHWSRUWHV $+w-(#2%HFH%Iw.(# UHOLDQWGDQVOHGpURXOHPHQWGHO·pQRQFpODUrYHXVHO·KpURwQHHQDFWLRQ
O·DXWHXUGHO·RUGDOLH
(WG·DERUG3pQpORSH² -DFRWWHW (OOH´SULWV%XQHEHOOHFOp =.!y" (  UHFRXUEpHWRXWHQDLUDLQODSRL
JQpHHQpWDLWG·LYRLUH !.UI+()$60 (OOHJDJQHODFKDPEUHV%WRXWDXIRQGOjVHWURXYDLWOHVWUpVRUVGXVHLJQHXU
OHEURQ]HO·RUHWOHIHUELHQEDWWX/jVHWURXYDLWDXVVLVRQDUFV%HWVRQFDUTXRLVROHVIOqFKHVV%HQJUDQGQRPEUH
pWDLHQWORJpHVµ3XLV ² ´ORUVTXHODPHUYHLOOHXVHIHPPHHXWDWWHLQWOHWUpVRUHWDSSURFKpOHVHXLOGHFKrQH
V%SURPSWHPHQWHOOHGpWDFKDODFRXUURLHGXFRUEHDXLQWURGXLVLWODFOp NO̒vG (  SRXVVDOHYHUURXGHODSRUWH
WKXUp‫گ‬Q V%OHVEHDX[EDWWDQWV $+w-!$-( PXJLUHQWVRXVOHKHXUWGHODFOp NO̒vG #  HWV·RXYULUHQWELHQW{W
WRXWJUDQGVV%7HQGDQWODPDLQHOOHGpFURFKDO·DUFGHVDFKHYLOOHDYHFO·pWXLEULOODQWGRQWLOpWDLWHQWRXUpµ
3XLV8O\VVH ² ´GpMjPDQLDLWVRQDUFOHWRXUQDLWHQWRXWVHQVOHWkWDLWGHF{WpHWG·DXWUHFUDLJQDQW
TX·HQVRQDEVHQFHOHVYHUVQ·HXVVHQWURQJpODFRUQHµ P̒=U-(%yI!0%U"6#!) /HNpUčGRQQH´OHPRWGHO·pQLJPHµ
GXSOXULHOGHO·pQLJPHNHUiHVVLHOpSKDQWLGDQVODTXHOOHLOHVWHQFKkVVpDYHFDEUqJHPHQWGH čGHYDQWYR\HOOHGDQV
OHYHUVLOV·DSSOLTXHj´GHX[FRUQHVµGXHONpUč jM(0M!jGpVLQHQFHGHGXHOjM+_FRPPHGDQVIç"M!´OHVGHX[
SLHGVµODWLQFRUQࡃjࡃjM1M+_ OHVGHX[FRUQHVG·XQDQLPDODMXVWpHVHQVHPEOHSRXUIDLUHXQDUFFRPPHFHOXLGH
3DQGDUH/.#("²SDVVDJHTXLRIIUHDXVVLNpUúNpUčGHYDQWYR\HOOH&HGXHOHVWSOXUDOLVpGDQVOHVNHUiHVVLGX
UrYHGHSRXUO·pQLJPHGHVGDWLIVNHUiHVVLV!.UI+()$#HWGHOjGDQVNHUi‫گ‬Q
(QILQYLHQWO·RUGDOLH´4XDQGLOHXWVRXSHVpHWH[DPLQpOHJUDQGDUFV2%8O\VVHVDQVODPRLQGUHSHLQHWHQGLW
O·DUF  'HODPDLQGURLWHLOSULWODFRUGHHWO·HVVD\DHOOHUHQGLWXQERQVRQ«,OSULWODIOqFKHV%DLJXsTXLpWDLW
DXSUqVVXUODWDEOHKRUVGXFDUTXRLV«/DSRVDQWVXUOHPDQFKHLOWLUDODFRUGHHWO·HQFRFKDVDQVPrPHVHOHYHUGH
VRQVLqJHLOODQoDOHWUDLWHQYLVDQWGURLWLOQHPDQTXDSDVXQHKDFKHGHSXLVOHSUHPLHUWURXµ 0$!#.!#z0WUDG
-DFRWWHW HWOHWUDLWFKDUJpGHEURQ]H"#h%"#(>I!-E0%z.$+!%$+w-(G!2´DOODWRXWDXWUDYHUVMXVTX·jOHXUVSRUWHVµXQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% FK<Bì,/78%S<H8K

$+w-(G!TXLVHUHOLHDX$+w-(G!GHODGLVVHUWDWLRQGH3pQpORSHKRLGqGLj[HVW{QNHUi‫گ‬QpOWK‫گ‬VLWK~UD]HGLWGHV
VRQJHV´TXLHQWUHQWSDUOHVGHX[FRUQHVELHQSROLHVµSDUDQQRQFHGHVFRUQHVELHQSROLHVGHO·DUFG·8O\VVHDXTXHO
SRXUUDLWV·DSSOLTXHUFHTXLHVWGLWGHO·DUFGH3DQGDUH²=U-(VDVN̒VDVNHUDR[yRV̒UDUHWpNW‫گ‬Q´OHVFRUQHV GH
O·LVDUG XQDUWLVDQXQSROLVVHXUGHFRUQHVOHVDWUDYDLOOpHVSXLVDMXVWpHVHQVHPEOHµ 0D]RQ 
"J%$+w-(G!%IDLWSDUWLHGHVUpFXUUHQFHVOH[LFDOHVTXLXQLVVDQWUrYHHWDFWLRQGLIIpUpHSHUPHWWURQWGHUpVRXGUH
O·pQLJPHGHVGDWLIV(OOHVV·DSSOLTXHQWDX[SRUWHVjODFOpDX[FRUQHVjO·LYRLUH3DUFHTXHOHVSRUWHVRQWGHX[
QRPVRQV·DUUrWHUDG·DERUGjFHX[FLHWDXSUREOqPHGHQRPEUHTX·LOSRVHDXWUDGXFWHXU$+w-(#2%Iw.(#%VRQWGHV
GXHOVDSSURSULpVDX[GHX[EDWWDQWVGHODSRUWH $+w-!$-( PDLVSDUFHTXH$+w-(G!%V·DSSOLTXHDXVVLDX[SRUWHV
GHVGRX]HKDFKHVHW%"6É(#%Iw.(#%DX[GHX[SRUWHVGHVVRQJHV HQTXHOTXHVRUWHGHX[IRLVXQGXHO M·DLSDUFRPPRGLWp
WUDGXLW.!0SRUWHV3RXUOHVHQV$+w-(#HVWOHYLHX[QRPGHOD´SRUWHµ FIODWLQIRU̒VSOXUDOLVDWLRQG·XQGXHOHWF 
Iw.(#%HVWG·HPSORLPDUTXpSRXUGHVP\WKHVGHWHPSV SRUWHGHVKHXUHV%/.#("%HWF OXLPrPHPDUTXpFRPPH
WHPSVGHODQXLWSDUGHVVRQJHVQRQVHXOHPHQW,"'00U!PDLVSRXU+HUPqVSV\FKRSRPSHFH
TXLQRXVDFKHPLQHYHUVODQXLWLQIHUQDOHHWVHV´SRUWHVG·+DGqVµIw.(#%<É"(62%/.#("%HWF$tGDRSXOiUWDR,OLDG%
 UHQRXYHOpHVGDQVO·pQLJPH/̒WKRLRV@1.(#>U)!60%G;/.#("V´TXLDWWHQGjODSRUWHGX/qWKqµ FHOD
MXVTXHGDQVO·XVDJHWRSRQ\PLTXHGH3~O‫گ‬LHQQHN~HVVL,OLDGjSHXSUqV´jODSRUWH 3\ORV FKH]OHVPRUWVµ
/HVGHX[QRPVIRQWSDUWLHGHVUpFXUUHQFHVOH[LFDOHVFHOOHVFLDVVXUHQWXQHOLDLVRQG·DXWDQWSOXVVROLGHTX·HOOHV
VRQWjODPrPHIRUPHFDVXHOOHFHTXLHVWOHFDVSRXUOD´FOpµNO̒vGD´O·LYRLUHµHOpSKDQWRV´YHUVOHVSRUWHVµ$+w-(G!L%
/HVUpFXUUHQFHVXWLOHVjO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHO·pQLJPHV\QWD[LTXHVRQWDEVHQWHVGXWURLVLqPHUrYH UHOLpHQVHFRQG
=67%ç)(-V+wI(-HW -HOHVLQGLTXHGRQFSRXU

+4*25*6758957*7:;5 <4*25*=5>?@A*7:;5 B4*23C>D9?@*A9EEF7F5

RQHLUHL̒LVLSXO̒LVL S~ODLRQHtU‫گ‬Q
 

`
NO̒vGD WK~UDV«NO̒vG (
3pQpORSH
 «
% !.UI+()$60 !.UI+()$60
 
!.UI+()$#

% $+w-(G!% $+w-(G!
  ` />E99J

-·DLHQFDGUpOHVUpFXUUHQFHVTXLH[SOLTXHQWO·pQLJPHGHO·´LYRLUHµ DXJpQLWLIGHPDWLqUHHQ&DXGDWLISRXU
O·pQLJPHHWDXJpQLWLISDUUpFXUUHQFHGpLFWLTXHHQ% HWGHV´FRUQHVµ DXGDWLISOXULHOHQ%jO·DFFXVDWLIGXHOHQ
&SOXUDOLVpHQ% /·LYRLUHHWOHVFRUQHVGH%VRQWjH[SOLTXHUSDUO·LYRLUHHWOHVFRUQHVGH&O·LYRLUHGHODSRLJQpH
GHODFOpSDUODTXHOOH3pQpORSHRXYUHODSRUWHGXWUpVRURHOOHSUHQGO·DUFG·8O\VVHHQFRUQH³GHX[PDWpULDX[
RXYUpVO·LYRLUHVFLpOHVGHX[FRUQHVSROLHVHWDMXVWpHVFRPPHFHOOHGHO·DUFGH3DQGDUH²
/HVSRUWHVGHVVRQJHVMXPHOOHVSDUXQWUDQVIHUWGHV´VRQJHVMXPHDX[µTX·RIIUHO·DYHVWLTXH WUDQVIHUWGHVWLQpj
O·pQLJPHNHUiHVVLV!.UI+()$# VHURQWRXYHUWHVFRPPHODSRUWHGXWUpVRUGHO·DFWLRQGLIIpUpH´I(-%.;#?6#-!%"!%.(%4.UY%
FI´SRXUOHVGHX[FRUQHV GHO·DUF µFIDYHFXQFKLDVPHHQWUHOHVGHX[QRPVGDQVO·RUGUHGHVPRWVGH
O·pQLJPHHWOHGpURXOHPHQWGHO·DFWLRQ
/DPDQLSXODWLRQGHVGHX["($#:02%"($#:SURSUHPHQWGLW´SRXUOHVFRUQHVµHW%#)0$-1>!)$(.´SDUO·LYRLUHµDXQ
VLJQLILDQWGDQVO·pQLJPH$!$!w=+($(#OHYHUEHV·DSSOLTXHjODIDEULFDWLRQQRQGHVSRUWHVPDLVGHO·pQLJPHTXHOH
SRqWH´IRUJHµFRPPHXQIRUJHURQXQHFOpHQEURQ]HWHOOHFHOOHGH3pQpORSH NKDONHt̒Q 
/HVSRUWHVVRQWHQHIIHWPpWDSKRULTXHV´ODFOpGHODSRUWHGHVVRQJHVµGXSUHPLHUUrYHSURFqGHHQHIIHWGH
´ODFOpGHO·pQLJPHµ$XGpSDUW´RQRXYUHO·pQLJPHFRPPHXQHSRUWHµHQYpGLTXH RRQQHFRQQDvWSDVOHQRP
GHOD´FOpµ K5?!"(J~KčKLWiPiSDYkULYDYUiQDYHFXQYHUEH FRPSRVpGHj(I6 HWXQQRPGHOD´SRUWHµGH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% QB/DA87%<\*,\K%H\%H<*/F%8*%H8%N;/B7*K\A8B*<N% 

j+_9M!-M´RXYULUIHUPHUµ GHX[RSpUDWLRQVFRPSOpPHQWDLUHV FIODWLQDSHUL‫´گ‬RXYULUµRVFRRPEU1!-1MOLWWYD‫ޝ‬WDV2%

HWF´SRUWHµ&HWWHPpWDSKRUHVFLQGpHHQ´SRUWHµHW´FOpµ ´SRUWHGHO·pQLJPHµHQYpGLTXH´FOpGHO·pQLJPHµHQ
IUDQoDLV HQDHQJHQGUpG·DXWUHVHQIRQFWLRQGHODQDWXUHGHVpQLJPHV,OSHXWV·DJLUGHFHOOHGHVP\VWqUHVTXH
O·LQLWLpQHGRLWSDVUpYpOHUUHVWDQW´ODQJXHOLpHµFRPPHQRXVGLVRQVRX´PHWWDQWXQHFOpVXUVDODQJXHµFRPPH
(VFK\OH:-(5>!)$%NO̒tVHSuJO‫گ‬VV̒LRXGHFHOOHVG·XQUrYH´pQLJPDWLTXHµ%(#)ç) G·XQHUDFLQH´OLHUµ>j0+nM!#M@FI
QRWUH´ODQJXHOLpHµ FRPPHGDQV´OHVSRUWHVGHVVRQJHVµGXJUHFRXQRWUH´FOpGHVVRQJHVµ
3DUODGHUQLqUHGHVJpPHOOLWpVjDSSDUDvWUHLFLOHSRqWHDIDLWFRQYHUJHUGHX[VRUWHVG·pQLJPHVGDQVODGLVVHU
WDWLRQGH3pQpORSHpQLJPHVV\QWD[LTXHVSRVpHVSDUNHUiHVVLV!.UI+()$#2%FRQFHUQDQWOHQRPEUH GXHOSOXUDOLVpHW
VLQJXOLHU HWOHV\QFUpWLVPHG·XQGDWLISURSUHPHQWGLWHWG·XQLQVWUXPHQWDOpQLJPHGHVRQHLUHt̒VLS~O̒LVLV%NO̒vGDj
ODTXHOOHRQV·DUUrWHUDXQHGHUQLqUHIRLVSRXUODGLVVRFLDWLRQHQFRPSRVLWLRQGLVFRQWLQXHGHODSRUWHHWGHVDFOp
HOOHHVWFRQIRUPHjO·DFWLRQGH3pQpORSHTXLHQ²V·DUUrWHDXVHXLO61"ç)GHODSRUWH$+w-(0%<R2%8H9K6>
OpHSDUXQFKDUSHQWLHU ² DYDQWG·LQWURGXLUHVDFOpNO̒vG ( %'HPrPHDXVHXLOGHODSRUWHPpWDSKRULTXH
GHVVRQJHVOHUrYHXUQ·HQDSDVHQFRUHODFOp FHOOHG·XQYHUURXjOLHQVGRQWHVWPpWDSKRULTXHO·pQLJPHOLDJH 
7RXWOHSDVVDJHV·DFFURvWG·pQLJPHVSDUVRXVHQWHQGXVRPLVVLRQVGHFHTXLVHUDGLWGDQVO·DFWLRQGLIIpUpH2Q
GRLWGRQFFRPSUHQGUHOHSDVVDJHj´FRUQHVHWLYRLUHµG·,"'00U!²DLQVL
MXPHOOHVRQWpWpIRUJpHV SDUpQLJPH OHVSRUWHVGHVVRQJHVREVFXUV GDQVODUpDOLWpFHOOHVGXWUpVRURXYHUW
SDU3pQpORSH I61- \SUHQGUH OHVGHX[46-)!0 GHO·DUFG·8O\VVH (1%>6'!)%"!O·LYRLUH GHVDFOp GHVUrYHV
OHVXQVYRQWSDUO·LQWHUPpGLDLUHGHO·LYRLUHVWULpFHVRQWFHX[TXLOHWURPSHQWHQDSSRUWDQWGHVSDUROHV
VDQVUpDOLVDWLRQOHVDXWUHVYRQWSDUO·LQWHUPpGLDLUHGHVGHX[FRUQHVSROLHVYHUVOHVSRUWHV GHVKDFKHV HX[
UpDOLVHQWGHVFKRVHVYpULWDEOHV

´%HOOHVLQILGqOHVµOHVWUDGXFWLRQV"/DPLHQQHHVWPRLQVEHOOHTXHFHOOHGH-DFRWWHWSOXVILGqOHMHO·HVSqUHjFH
TX·DYRXOXGLUHOHSRqWHSDUGHVpQLJPHVFRPSUpKHQVLEOHVVHXOHPHQWSDUO·DFWLRQTXLFRPSOqWHOHGLVFRXUV,QIL
GqOHDXVVLODWUDGXFWLRQGHO·pQLJPHGH%HOOpURSKRQTXLSRVpHjSDUWLUGHODIRQFWLRQG·XQGDWLIQRXVDFRQGXLWV
QRQYHUVO·LPDJLQDLUHFRPPHOHVSRUWHVMXPHOOHVGHVVRQJHVPDLVMXVTX·DXVHXLOGHO·KLVWRLUHSDUO·pFULWXUHHWOHV
DOOLDQFHVPDWULPRQLDOHVSUpSDUpHVSDUGHVFRUUHVSRQGDQFHVUR\DOHVO

<9GH9?I7C6J95
%DGHU)UDQoRLVH
  ´9R\DJHVG·8O\VVHj(SKXUDO·LIOHSRLVRQHWODQpFURPDQFLHµ,..6"(560²
  ´6RQJHVMXPHDX[GHO·DYHVWLTXHHWFOpGHVVRQJHVDX[SRUWHVMXPHOOHVGHO·2G\VVpHµP61-)(.%<0#($#X1!%
²
  ´%HOOpURSKRQHWO·pFULWXUHGDQVO·,OLDGHµ'DQV7$1"#%N#)51#0$#4#%#)%6)6-!%"#%K6&!-$6%D10>()#pGLWpSDU
E\5¬%RPELSS²$OH[DQGULHGHOO·2UVR
  ´)UDSSHVGXWRQQHUUHjO·LIO·DUFOHVDQJOLHUO·LYRLUHOHERXFODFRUQHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)M
51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
9FL9%=7J99J೉´7ULDGHVDQLPDOHVHQDYHVWLTXHHWHQJUHFµ7$1"#(%/)"6M81-6I(!(
%HWKH(ULFK
  *+!&()#04+!%O!."!).#!"!-g%\)$!-014+1)5!)%u&!-%"#!%8I!)%"!0%$+!&()#04+M(-5#?#04+!)%7(5!)=-!#0!0/HLS]LJ
6¬+LU]HO
.LUN*HRIIUH\6WHSKHQ
% OPP?% *+!%/.#("g%<%36>>!)$(-'2%1F>LMJ%:N%S66=0%sqà&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
0DOWHQ/XGROI
  ´+RPHUXQGGLH/\NLVFKHQ)UVWHQµO!->!0²

O
-HUHPHUFLH5DSKDsO1LFROOHG·DYRLUPLVHQIRUPHFHGLIILFLOHPD G·pWXGHVFRQVDFUpHVjG·DXWUHVGRQQpHV%DGHU
QXVFULW-·DLH[SORLWpLFLG·XQSRLQWGHYXHV\QWD[LTXHGHVIDLWVWLUpV HWVRXVSUHVVH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% FK<Bì,/78%S<H8K

!"#$%&'"(%)*+,"#-.*+"'/+0).%&1+2%.&3''%&
+ 4567+ !"#$%&$'()*+,-.//.#$08+6+9-)3:%;8+<=11>'(%'?+@"'/%'A-%#$+B+C3D&%#A18
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% 

!"
#$%&'()*+$%&,(%+$##$%&-(.%&#$%&-/,+'$.0%&
1(#2/3%(4$##5*+$%&$0&#(&'/)16/#/75$&&
-+&72.5058&1#+)5$#&%+-315,2.5$.

T#)4!)$%A(-$G.6::2%\)#?!-0#$U%"!%@(-#0%/T%M%76-&6))!

'HSXLVODSXEOLFDWLRQHQGXOLYUHIRQGDWHXUG·$QQD0DULQHWWLODFRPPXQDXWpVFLHQWLILTXHGLVSRVHG·XQH
pGLWLRQVDWLVIDLVDQWHGXFRUSXVGLW01"I#4U)#!)¬GRFXPHQWpSDULQVFULSWLRQVGRQWSOXVLHXUVGDWHQWGHODILQ
GX9,JVLqFOHDYDQWQRWUHqUHRXGXGpEXWGX9J'HVGpFRXYHUWHVSOXVUpFHQWHVFRPPHOHFLSSHGH7RUWRUDRQW
SHUPLVGHGpJDJHUXQHSURYLQFHQRXYHOOHGHODGLDOHFWRORJLHLWDOLTXHOHI(.U6M0(&!..#X1!GRQWOHVXGSLFpQLHQQH
IRUPHTX·XQUDPHDX1RXVDFFHSWRQVODGLVWLQFWLRQWHUPLQRORJLTXHHWFRQFHSWXHOOHpWDEOLHSDU+HOPXW5L[HW
*HUKDUG0HLVHUHQWUH0(&!..#X1!QRWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHTXLIDLWUpIpUHQFHjO·RVTXHjO·RPEULHQHWDXSDOpRVDEHOOLTXH
FRUSXVVXGSLFpQLHQ±Q{WUHHWDXWUHVLQVFULSWLRQVSUpVDPQLWHV HW#$(.#X1!HQWLWpOLQJXLVWLTXHSOXVYDVWHTXL
HQJOREHOHODWLQOHIDOLVTXHHWOHVGLDOHFWHVVDEHOOLTXHVLGLRPHVDX[TXHOVLOIDXWSHXWrWUHMRLQGUHGHVODQJXHVGRQW
ODSRVLWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHUHVWHFRQWURYHUVpHFRPPHOHYpQqWHHWOHVLFXOH$ORUVTXHOHI(.U6M0(&!..#X1!HVWDWWHVWp
SDUSOXVG·XQHTXDUDQWDLQHG·LQVFULSWLRQVOHI-6$6M0(&!..#X1!pWDWGHODQJXHG·RSURFqGHQWOHVGLIIpUHQWVSDUOHUV
VDEHOOLTXHVQ·HVWSDVGRFXPHQWpPDLVXQLTXHPHQW-!46)0$-1#$6LO·!]#0$!)4!GXSURWRVDEHOOLTXHIDLWO·REMHWG·XQ
ODUJHFRQVHQVXVTXLHQOpJLWLPHODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQFHOOHGXI-6$6M#$(.#X1!Q·HVWSDVDGPLVHGHWRXVPrPHVLO·RQ
SHXWDYDQFHUGHERQVDUJXPHQWVHQVDIDYHXU5DSSHORQVSRXUSUpYHQLUG·pYHQWXHOOHVFRQIXVLRQVTXHFHUWDLQV
VDYDQWVDSSHOOHQW#$(.#X1!FHTXHQRXVGpVLJQRQVjODVXLWHGH5L[HWGH0HLVHUVRXVOHQRPGH0(&!..#X1!
,OHVWOpJLWLPHG·pWXGLHUSRXUOXLPrPHOHFRUSXVVXGSLFpQLHQTXLIRUPHXQHQVHPEOHQHWWHPHQWjSDUWGDQV
O·pSLJUDSKLHVDEHOOLTXHjODIRLVSRXUOHW\SHG·DOSKDEHWHPSOR\pSRXUODORQJXHXUHWODQDWXUHGHVGRFXPHQWV
FRPSRUWDQWGHVSKUDVHVDX[VWUXFWXUHVpODERUpHVTXLLQYLWHQWGHFHIDLWjXQHUpIOH[LRQV\QWD[LTXHSRXUOHXU
FRQWHQXDXVVL DOOLWpUDWLRQVHWVpTXHQFHVLVRV\OODELTXHVWUDKLVVHQWHQHIIHWSDUIRLVGHVWH[WHVSRpWLTXHV SRXUOHXU
SKUDVpRORJLHGLIILFLOHPHQWUpGXFWLEOHDX[IRUPXODLUHVKDELWXHOVTXHSUpVHQWHO·pSLJUDSKLHGHVDXWUHVSDUOHUVGH
O·,WDOLHSUpURPDLQHHWVXUWRXWSRXUODODQJXHVLQJXOLqUHGDQVODTXHOOHLOVRQWpWpUpGLJpV
/HVWH[WHVVXGSLFpQLHQVVRQWQRPPpVG·DSUqVOHVVLJOHVGHO·pGLWLRQGH0DULQHWWL  GRQWODQRPHQFODWXUH
DpWpUHSULVHGDQVOHV7(&!..#04+!%*!]$!GH5L[ ² /DGpVLJQDWLRQGHVDXWUHVWH[WHVVDEHOOLTXHVVHIRQGH
pJDOHPHQWVXUOHUHFXHLOGH5L[1RXVMRLJQRQVTXDQGLOH[LVWHOHQXPpURTXHSRUWHO·LQVFULSWLRQGDQVOHUHFXHLO
GH9HWWHU HQDEUpJp9H 1RXVHPSORLHURQVjO·RFFDVLRQSRXUGpVLJQHUODODQJXHFRQVLGpUpHOHWHUPHGH
´SLFpQLHQµFRQFXUUHPPHQWjFHOXLGH´VXGSLFpQLHQµ/H´QRUGSLFpQLHQµI61--(#$HQHIIHWrWUHXQFRUSXVIDQW{PH
FRPPHO·DVXJJpUp$JRVWLQLDQLDYHFGHVDUJXPHQWVTXLQHODLVVHQWSDVLQGLIIpUHQWGDQVSOXVLHXUVSXEOLFDWLRQV
HW VLELHQTXHO·RSSRVLWLRQWHUPLQRORJLTXHHQWUH´QRUGµHW´VXGSLFpQLHQµVHUDLWFDGXTXH,OHVW
QpDQPRLQVSUXGHQWG·DWWHQGUHTXHGHVpWXGHVXOWpULHXUHVFRQILUPHQWRXLQILUPHQWOHSRLQWGHYXHG·$JRVWLQLDQL
0DLVPrPHVLO·RQSUHQDLWHQFRPSWHOHVGRFXPHQWVQRUGSLFpQLHQVOLOVHUDLWHQGURLWSUpIpUDEOHGHUpVHUYHUOD
GpQRPLQDWLRQVLPSOHPDQLDEOHHWpFRQRPLTXHGH´SLFpQLHQµjQRWUHFRUSXV HQHPSOR\DQWOHWHUPH)6)%>(-X1U%
SRXUO·HQWLWpFRXUDQWH HQO·RSSRVDQWDX´QRUGSLFpQLHQµ WHUPHPDUTXpSRXUXQHHQWLWpPRLQVVRXYHQWFLWpH 
7RXWHIRLVO·H[SUHVVLRQGHVXGSLFpQLHQV·pWDQWDXMRXUG·KXLLPSRVpHDXVVLELHQSDUPLOHVFRPSDUDWLVWHVGHVODQJXHV
LQGRHXURSpHQQHVTXHFKH]OHVVSpFLDOLVWHVGHO·,WDOLHSUpURPDLQHLOQRXVVHPEOHUDLVRQQDEOHGHODPDLQWHQLULFL
G·DXWDQWTX·HOOHDOOLHOHVPpULWHVGHODFODUWpHWGHO·H[DFWLWXGHJpRJUDSKLTXH PrPHVLFHUWDLQHVLQVFULSWLRQVRQW
pWpUHWURXYpHVIRUWORLQGHODSDUWLHPpULGLRQDOHGX3LFpQXPFRPPHOHFLSSH5,GH&XUHV 

O
(QIDYHXUGHO·DXWKHQWLFLWpGHODVWqOHGH1RYLODUDYRLUHQGHUQLHU
OLHXO·K\SRWKqVHGH/K{WH ² 


 oi.uchicago.edu

OP?% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

/HSUpVHQWWUDYDLODSRXUREMHWXQHTXHVWLRQGpOLFDWHGH>6-I+65-(I+U>#!FHOOHTXHSRVHOHJpQLWLISOXULHO­
FHSRLQWGXSDUDGLJPHQRPLQDORQUHQFRQWUHUDLWVHORQO·RSLQLRQFRPPXQHXQHILQDOHLQGLIIpUHPPHQWpSHOpH
9:!;:!RX<:!8QHDQDO\VHDWWHQWLYHGXV\VWqPHI+6)6.65#X1!GHFHWWHODQJXHFRPELQpHjGHVUpIOH[LRQV
JpQpUDOHVGHI+6)U$#X1!%(-$#41.($6#-!HWXQHDSSURFKHI+#.6.65#X1!GHVWH[WHVGRLYHQWFRQWULEXHUPDOJUpO·pWURLWHVVH
GXFRUSXVjUHPHWWUHGHO·RUGUHGDQVFHWWHDSSDUHQWHDQDUFKLHJUDSKLTXH:

#=&>?@ABAC&DE<FA=E&=@&G<H3DAI?@A=@J&?BKB&H=&EK&L<=GBA9@
(FFAMF=3DEK@&DN9@9E9>AL<=J&E=G&O9P=EE=G&D9GB?FA=<F=G&H<&G<H3DAI?@A=@
'DQVO·pWDWDFWXHOGHQRVFRQQDLVVDQFHVOHVXGSLFpQLHQHVWOHVHXOGLDOHFWHVDEHOOLTXHGDQVOHV\VWqPHYRFD
OLTXHGXTXHOVHSURORQJHHQFRUHjO·pSRTXHKLVWRULTXHOD"#0$#)4$#6)GHVWURLVWLPEUHVGHVYR\HOOHVSRVWpULHXUHV
TXLpWDLWFDUDFWpULVWLTXHGXSURWRVDEHOOLTXH&HWpWDWGHODQJXHSRVVpGDLWHQHIIHWOHVYR\HOOHVRRXYHUWEUHI
‫ۆ‬IHUPpORQJXEUHIHWXORQJ(QSURWRVDEHOOLTXHOHWLPEUH>‫@ۆ‬IHUPppWDLWQRUPDOHPHQWFHOXLG·XQH
YR\HOOHORQJXH‫ۆ‬LVVXHGH RLWDOLTXHjODVXLWHGHOD>1$($#6)%?64(.#X1!TXLDpJDOHPHQWWRXFKpHQ%36H9%
VDSUpKLVWRLUHLPPpGLDWHOHVXGSLFpQLHQSRVVpGDLWTXDQWjOXLOHVYR\HOOHVSRVWpULHXUHVRHWR‫ۆ‬HW‫ۆ‬
XHWXHWSHXWrWUHHQFRUHn  <2UjFHWULSOHWI+6)6.65#X1!FRUUHVSRQGXQWULSOHW5-(I+#X1!9!;!<!
/HVORFXWHXUVRQWGRQFXQUpSHUWRLUHJUDSKLTXHVXIILVDPPHQWULFKHSRXUTXHO·RQVRLWHQGURLWG·DWWHQGUHG·HX[
XQHQRWDWLRQULJRXUHXVHGHVYR\HOOHVG·DUULqUH
&HWWHWULSOHUHSUpVHQWDWLRQFRQVWLWXHXQDUFKDwVPHUHPDUTXDEOHPDLVODSHUSpWXDWLRQHQVXGSLFpQLHQGHOD
"#0$#)4$#6)%I+6)6.65#X1!HQWUHOHVUHIOHWVGHFHVWURLVWLPEUHVELHQTX·HOOHQHVRLWJXqUHFRQWHVWDEOHQ·LPSOLTXH
SDVQpFHVVDLUHPHQWOHPDLQWLHQGDQVOHV-U(.#0($#6)0%I+6)U$#X1!0GHVWURLVWLPEUHVHQTXHVWLRQVRXVXQHIRUPH
LGHQWLTXH'HX[FRQFHSWLRQVWRXFKDQWO·RUJDQLVDWLRQV\QFKURQLTXHGXV\VWqPHGHVYR\HOOHVG·DUULqUHHQSLFpQLHQ
SDUDLVVHQWHQHIIHWUHFHYDEOHV'·XQF{WpLOVHUDLWFHUWHVOpJLWLPHGHFRQVLGpUHUTXHSRXUODVpULHSRVWpULHXUHOHV
$#>&-!0SURWRVDEHOOLTXHVVRQWFRQWLQXpVGHIDoRQOLQpDLUHHQVXGSLFpQLHQHWTXHSDUFRQVpTXHQWRHWR
RXYHUWVVRQWQRWpVDXPR\HQGH9!‫ۆ‬HW‫ۆ‬IHUPpVDXPR\HQGH;!HWXHWXDXPR\HQGH<! OHV
OHWWUHVHQTXHVWLRQQHQRWHQWSDVHQHOOHVPrPHVODTXDQWLWpO·LQGLFDWLRQGHORQJXHXUVHPEOHrWUHUHQGXHSDU
O·DGMRQFWLRQ:(41.$($#?!GHN!HQILQGHPRW 2QSRXUUDLWGRQFDGPHWWUHVHPEOHWLOXQHSDUIDLWH0'>U$-#!%JHK7J%
ODVpULHG·DUULqUHHWODVpULHG·DYDQWHHWHRXYHUWVVHUDLHQWQRWpVSDU=!̩HW̩IHUPpVSDUQ! GXPRLQV
GDQVOHVLQVFULSWLRQVTXLXWLOLVHQWQ!DYHFXQHYDOHXUYRFDOLTXH LHWLSDUA!
'·XQDXWUHF{WpGHX[W\SHVGHFRQVLGpUDWLRQVGpFRQVHLOOHQWHQUpDOLWpO·K\SRWKqVHG·XQHVWULFWHKRPRORJLH
HQWUHOHVGHX[VpULHV'·XQHSDUWXQHUDLVRQGH"-6#$&RPPHO·RQWIRUWMXVWHPHQWVRXOLJQpjODVXLWHGHVWUDYDX[
G·$QGUp0DUWLQHW  SOXVLHXUVOLQJXLVWHVYHUVpVGDQVODGLDOHFWRORJLHJUHFTXHFRPPH5XLSpUH]  
%UL[KH Q HW%LOH Q O·HVSDFHDUWLFXODWRLUHLPSDUWLDX[YR\HOOHVSRVWpULHXUHV
HVWjFDXVHGHO·(0'>U$-#!GHVRUJDQHVGHODSDUROHELHQPRLQGUHTXHFHOXLGRQWGLVSRVHQWOHVYR\HOOHVG·DYDQW
3DUFRQVpTXHQWXQV\VWqPHPHWWDQWHQMHXR  RXYHUW‫  ۆ‬IHUPpHWX  pWDLWGDQVXQHFHUWDLQHPHVXUH
LQVWDEOH2QSRXUUDLWREMHFWHUFRQWUHO·LGpHGHFHWWHLQVWDELOLWpTXHOHVXGSLFpQLHQDKpULWpGXSURWRVDEHOOLTXH
XQLTXHPHQWRRXYHUWEUHI‫ۆ‬IHUPpORQJ LVVXGHRRXYHUWORQJSDUPXWDWLRQ XEUHIHWXORQJ0DLV
ODODQJXHDUHFUppXQRORQJRXYHUW DWWHVWpGDQVOHVGDWLIVVLQJXOLHUVHQ9NFRPPHD<LE9N´SRXUOHILOVµHQ
$4¬PDLVTXLGHYDLWVHUHQFRQWUHUDLOOHXUVGDQVODODQJXHR HWDFRPSOpWpODVpULHHQLQWURGXLVDQWXQ‫ۆ‬EUHI
IHUPp SDUH[HPSOHGDQVODGpVLQHQFHYHUEDOHB;FLVVXHSDUFKDQJHPHQWFRQGLWLRQQpGH $6-HWGDQVODILQDOH

:
/·DXWHXUWLHQWjUHPHUFLHUOHVRUJDQLVDWHXUVHWOHVSDUWLFLSDQWVSRXU
OHXUVREVHUYDWLRQVQRWDPPHQW0HVVLHXUVOHV3URIHVVHXUV/XFLDQR
$JRVWLQLDQL 3pURXVH 'RPLQLTXH%ULTXHO&KDUOHVGH/DPEHUWHULH
*HRUJHV-HDQ3LQDXOW WRXVWURLV3DULV HW3DROR3RFFHWWL 5RPH 1RXV
GHYRQV pJDOHPHQW j 0LFKDHO :HLVV &RUQHOO 8QLYHUVLW\  G·DSSUp
FLDEOHVpFKDQJHVGHSRLQWVGHYXHSDUFRXUULHOVLQWHUSRVpV MXLOOHW
 TX·LOWURXYHLFLO·H[SUHVVLRQGHQRWUHYLYHUHFRQQDLVVDQFH
Q
6XUODPXWDWLRQYRFDOLTXHYRLU5L[²UHSULVGDQVb.!#)!%
74+-#:$!)²0HLVHU²HW$GLHJR/DMDUD
²
<
1RXVODLVVRQVRXYHUWHODTXHVWLRQGHODSRVVLEOHSUpVHQFHGHn  
GRQW 0HLVHU D PRQWUp O·H[LVWHQFH HW OH VWDWXW I+6)U>($#X1!% =FL7%
O·RPEULHQ ² /·pYROXWLRQ č%X%n g DG€DYRLUOLHXj
XQPRPHQWGRQQpGHODSUpKLVWRLUHGXVXGSLFpQLHQjHQMXJHUSDU
NKEAɘKB;GH$4¬ B;FRUUHVSRQGDQWDXPRUSKqPHRPEULHQBKB<2%
$6GHYDOHXUVpSDUDWLYHLPSOLTXH Wn g  Wč PDLVRQLJQRUHVLFH
n  DJDUGpVRQWLPEUHVSpFLILTXHMXVTX·jO·pSRTXHGHQRVLQV
FULSWLRQVRXV·LOV·HVWFRQIRQGXDYHFOHUHIOHWGH‫  ۆ‬HQ$4 G·R
ODQRWDWLRQSDU;! RXGHD  GDQVOHVLQVFULSWLRQVDXWUHVTXH
$4¬ DLQVLGDQVOHQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUL9FKGH&+¬E /·H[LVWHQFH
GHn  Q·DXUDLWDXFXQHLQFLGHQFHVXUOHUDLVRQQHPHQWH[SRVpLFL
1RXVQ·DERUGRQVSDVQRQSOXVODGHVFULSWLRQGHVGLSKWRQJXHVDVSHFW
TXLHVWVDQVFRQVpTXHQFHSRXUQRWUHDUJXPHQWDWLRQ
R
1RWDPPHQWHQFDVG·DOORQJHPHQWFRPSHQVDWRLUHSDUH[HPSOHGDQV
XQHDQFLHQQHVpTXHQFHj6=$M
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% OPO

;:TXLQRXVOHYHUURQVV·RSSRVHj9: (QRXWUHVLPDLVF·HVWLQFHUWDLQOHSLFpQLHQDFRQQXFRPPHO·RVTXH
HWO·RPEULHQXQHWHQGDQFHjQHXWUDOLVHUOHVRSSRVLWLRQVGHTXDQWLWpHQV\OODEHDWRQHLO\DYDLWVXUOHORQJWHUPH
GXIDLWGHO·HVSDFHDUWLFXODWRLUHUHVWUHLQWXQULVTXHG·HPSLqWHPHQWHQWUHOHVGRPDLQHVGHRRXYHUWHWGH‫  ۆ‬
IHUPpHWDXVVLHQWUHFHX[GH‫  ۆ‬IHUPpHWGHX  /DIUDJLOLWpG·XQWHOV\VWqPHHQWLqUHPHQWV\PpWULTXHHVW
GRQFELHQUpHOOH2QV·DWWHQGGRQFjFHTX·XQHUHVWUXFWXUDWLRQOHPRGLILHHQSURIRQGHXU
'·DXWUHSDUWXQHUDLVRQGH:(#$3OXVLHXUVLQGLFHVSKRQpWLTXHVGpFHODEOHVjO·H[DPHQGXFRUSXVSRUWHQWj
FURLUHTXHOH<!VXGSLFpQLHQSRXYDLWrWUHUpDOLVpVRLW>8X  @ YR\HOOHG·DWWDTXHSDODWDOH VRLW>  @ YR\HOOHIHU
PpHDQWpULHXUHDUURQGLH@ VRLWPrPH>8  @(QSUHPLHUOLHXX  SDODWDOLVHOGRQWODUpDOLVDWLRQFRQWH[WXHOOH
HVWDORUVQRWpHH!FHTXLSHUPHWGHUHQGUHFRPSWHGHVVpTXHQFHVJUDSKLTXHVRH!LH!HWDH!TXLVHUDLHQW
GLIILFLOHPHQWH[SOLFDEOHVVLQRQ5L[  DDLQVLSXpWDEOLUOHVFRUUHVSRQGDQFHVHQWUHOHSLFpQLHQRH<Q; 3VLQJ
LQGLFDWLISUpVHQW HWOHODWLQFOXH‫ گ‬NOX̒‫ گ‬G·XQHSDUWHWHQWUHLH<C=@A;QGDWLIG·XQFRQVWLWXDQWRQRPDVWLTXH
JK%>J%>6K8H%3.1:!))#10%W%3.w:!))#10 3/N,,, G·DXWUHSDUW'DQVVRQpWXGHGH5L[DVXJJpUp
VDQVODGpYHORSSHUXQHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHDH<C=: &+D jSDUWLUGHODUDFLQH I.!9´FRXOHUµ S¬ %LHQTXHOD
PRUSKRORJLHGHDH<C=:UHVWHP\VWpULHXVHFHWWHK\SRWKqVHQHPDQTXHSDVG·DWWUDLWYXODSUpVHQFHjSUR[LPLWp
GXPRWSA=TXLUDSSHOOHOHVGpVLJQDWLRQVVDEHOOLTXHVGHOD´IRQWDLQHµRPEULHQ&#( 8P9H &#6 8P9H
 SpOLJQLHQ&#(> 3J¬9H QRUGRVTXH&!( 09¬ 'DQVFHFDVFHTXLHVWQRWp<!DXUDLWPRGLILpO
DXVVLELHQDSUqVSTX·DSUqVN(QUHYDQFKHRQQ·REVHUYHSDVXQHWHOOHpYROXWLRQGHOGHYDQWOHVYR\HOOHV
QRWpHV;!9N!RXK!¬SXLVTX·RQUHQFRQWUH:;CLE;: 7(¬ D<LE9N $4¬ DFKAGBKREKGK 7( &RPPHO·DELHQ
YX5L[LOHVWWUqVSUREDEOHTXHF·HVWXQPpFDQLVPHGHI(.($(.#0($#6)TXLDpWpjO·±XYUHGDQVO·DOWpUDWLRQGHO
SXLVTXHODPrPHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQHVWGpFOHQFKpHpJDOHPHQWSDUHGDQVHZA@RH=A@B=: $3¬ 5HSUHQDQWjQRWUH
FRPSWHFHSRLQWGHO·DUJXPHQWDWLRQGH5L[QRXVDYRQVSURSRVp PG·DQDO\VHUHZA@RH=A@B=:FRPPHO·XQLYHUEDWLRQ
SDUVDQGKLG·XQV\QWDJPH GLNHOčDJHQWHP¬ ´TXLIDLWPRQWUH>GHVH[SORLWV@µ 'DQVFHFDVOH\RGVHFRQGDLUHLVVXGH
O·DOWpUDWLRQGH 5 DORUVTXHOD061-"! =UpVLVWHGDQV GLNHOč SDODWDOLVHOH (TXLSUpFqGHHQ !¬ č(5!)$!>%X%
( g 5;!)$!>! ( g c ! )$!>%>RX ( g c#)$!>@Ö% =A@B=:2O?%M689%JH%#)%R%KAB;DKGLVVXGH DJHWčKDSčVSUpVHUYHVRQ
(#jO·LQLWLDOHOO VLELHQTXHDSUqVO·pOLVLRQGH čRXVDFRQWUDFWLRQDYHFOH (FRQVpFXWLIHWDSUqVODV\QFRSHGH
!GDQV GLNHOčOH .V·HVWUHWURXYpSODFpHQWUH =HW !SRVLWLRQGDQVODTXHOOHLODpWpVXMHWjODSDODWDOLVDWLRQ
FRPPHGDQVRH<Q; &HWWHDQDO\VHGHHZA@RH=A@B=:&HVWMXVWLILpHSDUOHUHPDUTXDEOHSDUDOOqOHSKUDVpRORJLTXH
TXLHQUpVXOWHHQWUHOHVLQVFULSWLRQV$3¬HW7(¬(QHIIHWODILJXUHpW\PRORJLTXHTXHSUpVHQWH>HARH@=A@B=:&
KBQ: >GLNHOč@!"M!M)$M!>%!"M$#M>O: G·$3¬FRUUHVSRQGjFHOOHGH7(¬>D9O@KAGAG&ZDAH@KAB;DKG& >=9‫"!@گ‬VҸVZ=9#"@
!"HWčKDSčVOQ ´>DILQTXH@WXIDVVHV>FHTXH@WXDVIDLWµ/·DFFXVDWLIQHXWUHSOXULHO GLNHOč ´GpPRQVWUDWLRQIDLW
GHPRQWUHUµ DSSDUHQWpjH=ARBK:GH&+¬DUpSRQGj:;CLE;:GH7(¬TXLVLJQLILHpJDOHPHQW´GpPRQVWUD
WLRQµ3RXUH[SOLTXHUO·pOLPLQDWLRQGX!TXLVXLWOHcXQHSUHPLqUHSRVVLELOLWpVHUDLWG·DGPHWWUHXQHV\QFRSH
HQSRO\V\OODEHV\QWD[LTXHORQJGH!GHYDQW)$VRLWTXHODV\QFRSHDLWpWpRFFDVLRQQHOOHPHQWSRVVLEOHGHYDQW
)(0(.!SOXVRFFOXVLYHFRPPHHOOHO·HVWGHYDQW0#::.()$!VXLYLHG·RFFOXVLYHHWGHVRQDQWH :;CLE;: >6)!0$.6> 


6LO·RQDFFHSWHXQWHODEUqJHPHQWLOIDXWDGPHWWUHTX·LOHVWDQWp
ULHXUjO·DOORQJHPHQWFRPSHQVDWRLUHG€jODFKXWHGH" TXLDSURGXLW
;N HWjODPRQRSKWRQJDLVRQGHVGLSKWRQJXHV TXLDGRQQpOLHXj
9NHWj=N SKpQRPqQHVSDUOHVTXHOVODODQJXHDUpLQWURGXLWGHV
RSSRVLWLRQVGHTXDQWLWpHQV\OODEHILQDOHDWRQH0DLVLOVHSHXWTX·XQH
VHFRQGHYDJXHG·DEUqJHPHQWVDLWHXOLHXELHQSOXVWDUGFHTXLH[SOL
TXHUDLWO·DEVHQFHGHNGDQVO·DEODWLIGD9EQBA; %2¬ 
@
6XUO·DUWLFXODWLRQGXIUDQoDLV QRWp\GDQVOHVFRQYHQWLRQV
GHO·<.I+(&!$%@+6)U$#X1!%/)$!-)($#6)(. YRLU*UDPPRQW²

6XUFHVWHUPHVYRLU/HMHXQH²HW'H6LPRQH²
P
0DUW]ORII
O?
&HWWHpYROXWLRQHVWH[DFWHPHQWFRPSDUDEOHjFHOOHTXHFRQQDvW
O·RPEULHQGDQVC=AB<2%C=B<2%:!#$12%:!$1HWGDQV=ABAD=G$LQVLC=AB<%
V·H[SOLTXHFRPPHOHUHIOHWUpJXOLHUGH IDNLW‫گ‬GDYHFXQHpYROXWLRQ
U:(=#M$6%X%UIDश·̩W6%X%UIDश·W6%X%U:(c$6%X%:!c$6 0HLVHU 'HPrPH
HQV·LQVSLUDQWGHO·DQDO\VHGH0HLVHU  RQSHXWWUDQVSRVHU
OD3SOXUGHSDUIDLW=ABAD=G´!5!-1)$µHQXQHSpULSKUDVHYHUEDOH
UDJHWčK̒SHQV
OO
(QUpDOLWpRQQHSHXWGpWHUPLQHUjFRXSV€UVLOHPDLQWLHQGH
(#jO·LQLWLDOHGHKAB;DKGGDQV4!$$!LQVFULSWLRQHVWXQSKpQRPqQH
I+6)U$#X1!RXVLOHYRFDOLVPHUDGLFDODpWpUHWRXFKpSDU()(.65#!GH
O·LQGLFDWLISUpVHQW !cUHIDLWHQ(cG·DSUqV(5 &RPPHO·H[SOLTXH
0HLVHU ² XQHWHOOHUpIHFWLRQGXYRFDOLVPHHVWDWWHVWpH
HQRPEULHQGDQVKAB<LVVXGH DJHW‫گ‬G2QDWWHQGDLWHQHIIHW (5!M$6%X%
UDࣹ·HW6%X%UDࣹ·W6%X%U(c$6%X%!c$6/HVORFXWHXUVGHO·RPEULHQRQWSXVHQWLU
OHEHVRLQG·XQHUHVWLWXWLRQGXYRFDOLVPHGDQVKAB<SDUFHTXHF·HVW
>T#)#$#(.!GXPRWTXLHVWFRQFHUQpH jODGLIIpUHQFHGHC=AB< HWTX·LO
V·DJLWGXWKqPHGHI-U0!)$ FHTXLMXVWLILHTXHO·LQLWLDOHGH=ABAD=G%
Q·DLWSDVpWpUHPDQLpH 
O:
 /·DFFXVDWLI VXGSLFpQLHQ KBQ: HVW j FRPSDUHU j O·DEODWLI SOX
78J>%FMD78JH%KNBAG D=F 6XUFHWWHIRUPHYRLU0HLVHUQ
 ´GLH +DQGOXQJHQµ HW :HLVV   ´WKH DFWVµ /D VpTXHQFH
ZHARH@=A@B=:&KBQ:VLJQLILHUDLW´OHIDLWGHIDLUHPRQWUHµ´O·DFWHGH
IDLUHPRQWUHµ
OQ
&HWWHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQIDLWO·REMHWG·XQHGLVFXVVLRQGpWDLOOpHGDQV
QRWUHpWXGHGH SS¬²HW KAGAGV·H[SOLTXHFRPPHXQH
GHX[LqPHSHUVRQQHVLQJGXW\SHč[LP2%:(]#>6XUFHVIRUPHVGXODWLQ
DUFKDwTXHTXLG·XQSRLQWGHYXHIRUPHOHWGHVFULSWLIQHUHOqYHQWQL
GHO·#):!4$1>QLGXI!-:!4$1>RQFRQVXOWHUDO·RXYUDJHGH'H0HOR
²²² 
 oi.uchicago.edu

OP:% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

VRLWTXHODV\OODEDWLRQDLWpWpUHPRGHOpHLFLVXLYDQWODIURQWLqUHGHPRUSKqPHV (L5!LM)$M!>SOXW{WTXH (L5!)L$!> 

1pDQPRLQVTXLGRXWHGHODSRVVLELOLWpG·XQHWHOOHV\QFRSHSRXUUDDOWHUQDWLYHPHQWVXSSRVHUXQHIHUPHWXUHGH
!HQV\OODEHIHUPpHVRXVO·HIIHWGXc¬TXLSUpFqGH ( g 5;!)$!>! ( g c!)$!>%Ö% !c#)$!>!=A@B=:O<2QFRQVWDWH
TXHO·DOWpUDWLRQGH.DG€DYRLUOLHX(I-E0ODV\QFRSHGH!HQWUH=HW.HWVRXVO·HIIHWG·XQHYR\HOOHSDODWDOH
HOOHPrPH0!46)"(#-!LOGRLWGRQFV·DJLUG·XQSKpQRPqQHUHODWLYHPHQWWDUGLIGDQVODSUpKLVWRLUHGHODODQJXHFH
TXLQHVXUSUHQGSDVYXTXHOH:-6)$#)5GHXTXHVXSSRVHRH<Q;HVWFHUWDLQHPHQWOXLPrPHUpFHQW)LQDOHPHQW
SXLVTXHO·DOWpUDWLRQGHODSUqVNRXSHVWSRVVLEOHGHYDQWOHVYR\HOOHVQRWpHV<!HW=!PDLVQRQGHYDQW
K!;!9N!QRXVWHQRQVXQLQGLFHVLJQLILFDWLITXLSRUWHjFURLUHTXHOHVYR\HOOHVQRWpHV<!GRLYHQWVLQRQ
DSSDUWHQLUjODVpULHDQWpULHXUHjO·LQVWDUGH=!GXPRLQVSRVVpGHUXQHDWWDTXHSDODWDOH2UFHWWHK\SRWKqVHHVW
FRQILUPpHSDUG·DXWUHVREVHUYDWLRQV
(QVHFRQGOLHXF·HVW<!TXLQRWHOHUHIOHW>@GH 6#GDQVD=FG<RK@BGH7( GpQRPLQDWLIGH VRLNčOH
VHQVHVWLQFHUWDLQPDLVO·RQDFRPSDUpDYHFYUDLVHPEODQFHOHVYHUEHVRPEULHQVDF<GAR<F=@B%JK%G<RKB<2ORG·XQH
UDFLQH 0!#=N/T:S DORUVTXH 61VHPRQRSKWRQJXHHQXQHYR\HOOHQRWpH;!FRPPHOHPRQWUHQWB;BKG%JK%
DK@AO;&VXUXQDXWUHFLSSHGH3HQQD6$QGUHD 7(¬ 8QHWHOOHPRQRSKWRQJDLVRQGH 6#HQ>@HVWDFFHSWDEOH
HQHOOHPrPHHWWURXYHUDLWXQSDUDOOqOHHQEpRWLHQO@
(QWURLVLqPHOLHXLOQ·HVWJXqUHVDWLVIDLVDQWPDOJUpOHVDSSDUHQFHVGHFRQVLGpUHUTXHODIRUPH=G<: 7(
 ´MHVXLVµVRLWH[DFWHPHQWLGHQWLTXHj!06>GXODWLQDUFKDwTXH(QHIIHWRQ·HVWMDPDLVQRWp<X2%JK%98%>TFH%
VXSSRVDLWXQHIHUPHWXUHGHRGXHjO·HQFOLVHRQDXUDLWSOXW{WDWWHQGX =G;:!OP$LQVLG;N;N! 7( ´016Y%
LPSOLTXHWLOXQHpYROXWLRQ VRZ‫گ‬G%X%UVRZ‫ ۆ‬g "%X%UV‫ ۆ‬9 ‫ ۆ‬g +>HQFOLVH@!V‫ۆۆ‬QRWpG;N;N! :HLVV ,OHQ
YDGHPrPHSRXUG;KQG $3 ­FHWDUJXPHQWHQOXLPrPHQRQGLULPDQWFDU<!SRXUUDLWrWUHjODULJXHXUXQH
VLPSOHQpJOLJHQFHSRXU;!V·DMRXWHO·H[LVWHQFHG·XQHIRUPHGA: &+¬DLQGLFDWLI GHPrPHVHQVDYHFpOLVLRQ
LQYHUVH:?GDQV=R;GA: ´!56%01>µ HWF<CFKGA: ´MHVXLVF<CFKY:O 2UWRXWFRPPH:=ABA:G´SUpVHQWµLVVXGH
U>!#$>60 JRWLTXH>(#å>0´GRQµ GA:WpPRLJQHGXGpJDJHPHQWSDU>G·XQSRLQWG·DSSXLYRFDOLTXHGHWLPEUH
>L@ !0>#! ! 0> # ! 06>%X%GA:::/DGXDOLWpDSSDUHPPHQWLUUpGXFWLEOHGHGA:HWGH=G<:GLVSDUDvWGqVORUVTXH
O·RQDGPHWTXH<!QRWHLFLXQSKRQqPHGRQWODUpDOLVDWLRQSHXWrWUHSURFKHGH>L@ VHORQTXHOHVOqYUHVVRQWSOXV
RXPRLQVpWLUpHV /HFRXSOHGA:%W%=G<:UDSSHOOHGRQFH[WpULHXUHPHQWOHELQ{PH>(]#>!%W%>(]1>!GXODWLQ:Q%
'HIDoRQDQDORJXHPDLVSRXUOHVORQJXHVRQWURXYHHPSOR\pHQEpRWLHQUpFHQW͘Ԇ! YDODQWQRUPDOHPHQWҸ 
SRXUQRWHUUHIOHWGHRL 5XLSpUH]%XFN 1RWUHDQDO\VHGXSLFpQLHQ=G<: 7( GDQV
OHTXHOQRXVQRXVUHIXVRQVjYRLUXQHQRWDWLRQGHHVRPQHSUpMXJHHQULHQGHFHOOHGXSUpVDPQLWH=G<: 3V 
$MRXWRQVHQTXDWULqPHOLHXXQWpPRLJQDJHLQGLUHFWVLO·RQpWDLWHQGURLWGHWLUHUGHO·LQGLFDWLRQGH9DUURQ
4#I-1>%7(&#)!%&6)1>2%NN GHVFRQFOXVLRQVDSSOLFDEOHVDXVXGSLFpQLHQ RQVDLWHQHIIHWTXHGDQVFHUWDLQHV
LQVFULSWLRQVSLFpQLHQQHVDXPRLQV´6DELQµVHPEOHIRQFWLRQQHUFRPPHDXWRHWKQRQ\PHGKCA@;G%JK%GKCA@KG%JH%
7(¬ DORUVRQDXUDLWDSSDUHPPHQWXQHFRQILUPDWLRQGHFHTXHOH<!GHVDGYHUEHVL<DQFQN $3¬ HWR<DFQ%
$4¬ QRWHXQSKRQqPHUpDOLVpSDUXQVRQLQWHUPpGLDLUHHQWUH>L@HW>X@:<

O<
2QFLWHUDFRPPHSDUDOOqOHDSSUR[LPDWLIOHVIRUPHVRPEULHQQHV
N=FA@BA=G 8P9HD HWN=FA@BA= 8P9HE IRQGpHV
VXUOHSDUWLFLSHSUpVHQWG·XQWKqPH +!-M'!l6 KHU\HQW'DQV
FHWWHYDULpWpG·RPEULHQOH!SODFpHQWUH-' RX-; HW)$DSX
VHIHUPHUHQ>L@VHORQXQFKDQJHPHQWFRQGLWLRQQp&HWWHDQDO\VHGH
QDWXUHSKRQpWLTXHSDUDvWSUpIpUDEOHjO·K\SRWKqVHG·XQHUpIHFWLRQ
PRUSKRORJLTXHGH +!-'!)$HQ KHU̩QWVRXVODSUHVVLRQGXWKqPHGH
SUpVHQW KHUү! KHU̩ 0HLVHU 
OR
6XUFHVIRUPHVYRLU0HLVHU²0HLVHUE5L[
HW*DUFtD&DVWLOOHUR²

,OQ·HVWSDVQpFHVVDLUHGHYRLUHQB;BKGGH7(¬XQHIDXWHSRXU B9;3
BKG SRVVLELOLWpVXJJpUpHSDU-DQVRQQHWSDU6FKULMYHU
 FDU7(IRXUQLWXQVHFRQGH[HPSOHGHPRQRSKWRQJDLVRQ
GDQVDK@AO;TXH0HLVHU D DFRPSDUpDYHFEHDXFRXSGH
YUDLVHPEODQFHjODFRQMRQFWLRQTXDPGLࡃ¬GXODWLQ NZčPGLHX!
SčQGLRX! SDQGLRX ORLG·2VWKRII ! SDQQLRX DVVLPLODWLRQ 
! SDQQL‫ۆ‬UpDOLVp>SDQ Q LZ‫@  ۆ‬
O@
5XLSpUH]/HMHXQH6FKPLWW/HSDVVDJH
GH 6#j>@DHXOLHXHQEpRWLHQDORUVTXHFHGLDOHFWHQHFRQQDvWSDV
GHSDODWDOLVDWLRQJpQpUDOHGHX  HQ   %XFN%UL[KH
 6XUODUHSUpVHQWDWLRQGHX  SDUԆ‫ڗ‬࿰!DSUqVDSLFDOH
XQLTXHPHQWjSDUWLUGX,,,JVLqFOHYRLU%UL[KH ²
 OH\RGHVWXQVRQGHWUDQVLWLRQGHYDQWODYR\HOOHG·(--#E-!X  

6XUFHWWHIRUPHYRLU9LQH
OP
5L[  pFULWSDUHUUHXU´!0w>$3¬µ,OIDXWOLUH´!01>7(µ
:?
6XUFHWWHQRWLRQYRLU/HMHXQHD
:O
(LFKQHU  jTXLO·RQGRLWFHWWHDQDO\VHFRQVLGqUHTXH
F<CFKVLJQLILH´URXJHµ6DQVQRXVSURQRQFHULFLVXUO·H[DFWLWXGHGH
FHWWHpW\PRORJLHERUQRQVQRXVjVLJQDOHUjSURSRVGXFLSSH$4GH
&DVWHOGLHULTXH´>X@QDSXOLWXUDGHOOHLQFURVWD]LRQLFKHFRSULYDQROD
VXSHUILFLHKDULYHODWRO·HVLVWHQ]DGLWUDFFHGLFRORUHURVVRFKHRULJL
QDULDPHQWHGRYHYDFRSULUHWXWWDODIDFFLDGHOODSLHWUDµ &LDQIDUDQL
 6XUOHVYDOHXUVV\PEROLTXHVGRQWODFRXOHXUURXJHSRXYDLW
rWUHSRUWHXVHYRLUOHVUpIOH[LRQVGH3HWHUVPDQ %b.!#)!%74+-#:$!)2%
Q 
::
(LFKQHUQ
:Q
9RLU6RPPHUHW3ILVWHU²2QWURXYHUDFKH]*RLGDQLFK
 XQHSUpVHQWDWLRQDYHFXQHVVDLG·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHVWpPRL
JQDJHVGHVJUDPPDLULHQVUHODWLIVjFHSUREOqPH
:<
 1pDQPRLQV¬ OD IRUFH GH O·DUJXPHQW GRLW rWUH UHODWLYLVpH FDU LO
SRXUUDLWV·DJLUG·XQFKDQJHPHQW46)$!]$1!. 1!#(1%46)$(4$%";1)!%
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% OPQ

&HVFRQVLGpUDWLRQVSKRQRORJLTXHVLQYLWHUDLHQWHQFLQTXLqPHOLHXjUHSHQVHUODGLVWULEXWLRQJUDSKLTXHGH
L!HWGHR!/HVXGSLFpQLHQQHSDUDvWSDVVXLYUHDYHFFRQVWDQFHOD´ORL=(4-#X1µTXLUqJOHODGLVWULEXWLRQGHR2&
I2%L!GDQVXQHSDUWLHGHO·pSLJUDSKLHpWUXVTXH6LRQODLVVHGHF{WpOHJDPPD TXLDSSDUDvWGDQVBF=S=>A=G7(¬
PDLVTXLDODYDOHXUGHɘGDQV;E;ɘ=F@KGH%$¬ SRXUVHFRQFHQWUHUVXUL!HWR!RQREVHUYHGHVIORWWHPHQWV2Q
WURXYHDLQVLRH<Q; &+¬E HQUHJDUGGHLH<C=@A;Q 7(¬ (QUpDOLWpOH<!QRWDQWSUREDEOHPHQWHQVXGSLFpQLHQ
XQHYR\HOOHjDWWDTXHSDODWDOHF·HVWSDUDGR[DOHPHQWR<DFQ $4¬ HWRH<Q; &+¬E TXLGRLYHQWrWUHFRQVLGpUpV
FRPPHUpJXOLHUVGDQVODPHVXUHROHFKRL[GHR!\HVWSKRQpWLTXHPHQWPRWLYp RH<Q;MRX[WHG·DLOOHXUVOHQRQ
PRLQVUpJXOLHUL9FKHQ&+¬EO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHL9!HWRH<!pWDQWLFLVLJQLILFDWLYH WDQGLVTXHL<DKB 0&¬
$3¬ L<DQFQN $3¬ HWLH<C=@A;Q 7(¬ UpVXOWHQWG·XQHDSSOLFDWLRQPpFDQLTXHQRQUpIOpFKLHGHODORL=(4-#X1%
WUDQVSRVpHHQVXGSLFpQLHQjPRLQVTXHO·LQLWLDOHGHLH<C=@A;QQHVRLWGXHjO·DQDORJLHGX"61&.!L!GH>9@DG;L%
L9FKG!TXLSUpFqGHLPPpGLDWHPHQW FHODHVWG·DXWDQWSOXVSUREDEOHTXHODPrPHLQVFULSWLRQSUpVHQWHO·RSSRVL
WLRQJUDSKLTXHDWWHQGXHGDQVSFQ:=LE;Q&JK&9RF=Q 0DLVLOIDXWUHFRQQDvWUHTXHFHUWDLQVIORWWHPHQWVQHVHPEOHQW
UpSRQGUHjDXFXQHORJLTXHVLPSOHQRWDPPHQWGHYDQW9!HW;!RQWURXYHR9FK: $4¬ jF{WpGHVJUDSKLHV
DWWHQGXHVL9E9CQB;F $3¬ L9FKG 7( L9FK &+E D<LE9N $4¬ 'HYDQW;!RQDWWHQGL! K;HKL;:$3¬
:;CLE;:%#)%R2%SFQ:=LE;Q7( PDLVO·RQWURXYHDXVVLR!VDQVUDLVRQDSSDUHQWH¬GDQVR@;GR=:&+¬HWGDQV
=R;GA: &+¬D GRQWO·RUWKRJUDSKHHVWLQH[SOLFDEOHGDQVOHFDGUHGHFHWWHDQDO\VH0DLVGDQVODSOXSDUWGHVFDV
RQSHXWHQWUHYRLUXQHMXVWLILFDWLRQSRXUFHVFDSULFHV$LQVLR@;GR=:%I61--(#$rWUHDQDORJLTXHGHD9GBAR@K:¬TXL
SUpFqGHHWO·RQI61--(#$H[SOLTXHUO·LQLWLDOHLQDWWHQGXHGHR9FK: $4¬ HQDOOpJXDQWO·LQIOXHQFHGHR<DFQ UpJXOLHU 
TXLILJXUHMXVWHDYDQW'HPrPHL<DQFQN%=FL7768K%8M8KJ7%L9E9CQB;FTXLSUpFqGH:R,OHVWSRVVLEOHTXHOHVDXWHXUVGH
FHUWDLQHVLQVFULSWLRQVDLHQWLJQRUpWRXWHRSSRVLWLRQHQWUHR!HWL!FRPPH&+¬HW&+¬D PDLVSDV&+¬EGRQW
OHV\VWqPHRUWKRJUDSKLTXHHVWWUqVGLIIpUHQW 2QLQVLVWHUDVXU&+¬ETXLSUpVHQWHPDQLIHVWHPHQWXQ46)$-(0$!%
JUDSKLTXHWUDGXLVDQWFHUWDLQHPHQWXQHRSSRVLWLRQVLJQLILFDWLYHHQWUHL9FKDYHFL!GHYDQWYR\HOOHG·DUULqUHHW
RH<Q;DYHFXQR!MXVWLILpFDU<!GRLWQRWHUXQHYR\HOOHDQWpULHXUH HQWRXWFDVXQHYR\HOOHG·DWWDTXHSDODWDOH 
6RXOLJQRQVTXHO·XWLOLVDWLRQGH<!SRXUQRWHUZFRQVRQQHGDQV<=D=BQZ%,*%O2%<=D=BQ@%0"%:2%G<KADAG2%=N<=EQ%
7(¬><@=EQ;:2%<=EKA:=G&+¬EHWBKF<AG$3Q·HVWSDVXQHREMHFWLRQDXFRQWUDLUHFDULOQHV·DJLWSDVG·XQXVDJH
JpQpUDOSXLVTXHEHDXFRXSG·LQVFULSWLRQVXWLOLVHQWVRLWO! O=AKB2%O=D=BQ0&OAK:2%OAH=BKG2%O=DG=G2%O=D=B=@%#)%
D9OKAGAG2%DK@AO;7( VRLW;! @9;Q@AG$3D9A9;=CK&+D>R@K;A=N2%RK;A=AG$4S9;=HAQ@$4 /HVJUD
SKLHVGXW\SH<=EKA:=G DYHF<! VRQWPpFDQLTXHVWDQGLVTXHO·HPSORLGH;!SRXUZVXUSUHQDQWDXSUHPLHU
DERUGHVWHQIDLWUpIOpFKL;!TXLHQIRQFWLRQYRFDOLTXHUHQGDLWXQHYR\HOOHG·DUULqUHDVVH]IHUPpHpWDLWVHQWL
FRPPHXQHQRWDWLRQSOXVDSSURSULpHTXH<!SRXUQRWHUZGDQVOHVLQVFULSWLRQVTXLLJQRUDLHQWO·XVDJHGHO!
)LQDOHPHQWHQVXGSLFpQLHQ<!GRLWQRWHU>8X  @RXPrPH>  @6LF·HVWOHFDVLOHVWORLVLEOHGHVXSSRVHU
TXHOHSDVVDJHGH>X@j>@DHXSRXUIRQFWLRQGH"U.!0$!-%.(%0U-#!%I60$U-#!1-!%01-4+(-5U!HWG·pYLWHUO·HPSLqWHPHQWGHV
FKDPSVGHGLVSHUVLRQGHRGH‫ۆ‬HWGHX GHPrPHSRXUOHVYR\HOOHVORQJXHVFRUUHVSRQGDQWHV 3DUFRQVp
TXHQWVLO·RQYDMXVTX·jFRQVLGpUHUQRQSDVVLPSOHPHQWTXHXpWDLWUpDOLVp>@PDLVTXHOHSKRQqPH XGX
SUpSLFpQLHQHVWUHSUpVHQWpSDUXQSKRQqPHDORUVULHQQ·LQWHUGLW PDLVULHQQ·LPSRVHQRQSOXV GHFRQVLGpUHU
TXH;!QRWHQRQSDV>‫@  ۆ‬PDLV>X  @UpDOLVDWLRQGH‫&  ۆ‬HWWHSURQRQFLDWLRQ>X  @VHUDLWQDWXUHOOHHQFHTX·HOOH
SHUPHWWUDLWG·DFFURvWUHOHFRQWUDVWHDFRXVWLTXHHQWUHOHVGHX[YR\HOOHVTXLUHVWHQWGDQVODVpULHSRVWpULHXUHHW
GRQFGHPLQLPLVHUOHVULVTXHVG·HPSLqWHPHQWVXUOHXUVFKDPSVGHGLVSHUVLRQUHVSHFWLIVHQDVVXUDQWOHVPDUJHV
GHVpFXULWpVXIILVDQWHVSRXUpYLWHUWRXWHFRQIXVLRQ,OHQUpVXOWHHWF·HVWOjXQSRLQWHVVHQWLHOTXHGHVFRQIX
VLRQVGHODSDUWGHVORFXWHXUVHQWUHOHVWLPEUHVGHVYR\HOOHVQRWpHV9!;!HW<X%9FHK%(%I-#6-#WUqVLPSUREDEOHV

.(&#(.!8QWHOFKDQJHPHQWSKRQpWLTXHHVWSUpFLVpPHQWDWWHVWpHQ
QRUGRVTXH¬GDQV4#&($ 09 SDURSSRVLWLRQjODIRUPH#)41&($ 3J
 GXSpOLJQLHQXQDXWUHGLDOHFWHQRUGRVTXH 'H6LPRQH
-LPpQH]=DPXGLR0HLVHUE 
:R
&HODQ·DXUDLWULHQGHVXUSUHQDQWSXLVTXHVXUODIDFH$GXFLSSH$3
N!DpWpFRQVFLHPPHQWDMRXWpVDQVYDOHXUSKRQpWLTXHSURSUHj
:KB=F=QNHWjDKB=F=QNG·DSUqVO·DQDORJLHJUDSKLTXHGHL<DQFQN2%KFQ3
BAN2%Q:AN%JK%D<QNVLELHQTXHVXUODIDFHGXFLSSHRLOVILJXUHQWWRXV
OHVPRWVHQGHKRUVGXYHUEH L9E9CQB;F VHWHUPLQHQWSDUN6XUOD
IDFH%jSDUW=GB<CRHWOHYHUEHKHGBKQ;N TXLOXLVHILQLWMXVWHPHQW
SDUN! WRXVOHVPRWVVHWHUPLQHQWVRLWSDU:! D;D;@<:2%:=ABA3
:;:DX[GHX[H[WUpPLWpV VRLWSDUG! KDKA;G2%G;KQG2%:K@<G OHV
OHWWUHVG!HW:!GRQQDQWjO·±LOO·LPSUHVVLRQG·rWUHLGHQWLTXHVj
XQHURWDWLRQSUqV/HVGHX[WHUPHVH[FOXV=GB<CR%JK%KHGBKQ;NSUp
VHQWHQWG·DLOOHXUVXQHVpTXHQFHGB!HWOHVWURLVGHUQLHUVWHUPHV
G;KQG2%:K@<G2%:=ABA:;: FRPPHQFHQWSDUG!RXSDU:!/HVLQL
WLDOHVLGHQWLTXHVGHL<DQFQNHWGHL9E9CQB;FFRQWULEXHUDLHQWjFHWWH
UHFKHUFKHHVWKpWLTXHGHO·KDUPRQLHJUDSKLTXHIUDSSDQWHjODVHXOH
YXHG·XQHSKRWRJUDSKLHGXFLSSH

 0DUWLQHW    DSSHOOH ´FKDPS GH GLVSHUVLRQµ OD ODWLWXGH
TX·DXQVXMHWSRXUUpDOLVHUXQSKRQqPHGDQVXQFRQWH[WHGRQQp/H
FKDPSGHGLVSHUVLRQG·XQSKRQqPHQ·HVWQRUPDOHPHQWSDVLPPp
GLDWHPHQWFRQWLJXjFHOXLGHVHVYRLVLQV¬FHVSKRQqPHVVRQWVpSDUpV
SDUFHTXH0DUWLQHWQRPPHXQH´PDUJHGHVpFXULWpµ ² 
 oi.uchicago.edu

OP<% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

(QFRQFOXVLRQLOQRXVVHPEOHQpFHVVDLUHGHUHQRQFHUSRXUOHV\VWqPHYRFDOLTXHGXVXGSLFpQLHQjO·K\SR
WKqVHG·XQV\VWqPHVWULFWHPHQW0'>U$-#X1!TX·LOOXVWUHUDLWOHVFKpPDVXLYDQWTXLVHOLPLWHDX[YR\HOOHVEUqYHV :@%
GLDJUDPPH$ 

386I76MMJ%!N LAX X<X

̩QX ‫;ۆ‬X
H=X R9X
DKX

7RXWHIRLVOHGLDJUDPPH$Q·HVWSDVSRXUDXWDQWGpQXpGHWRXWHYDOHXUOLQJXLVWLTXHVLPSOHPHQWLOUHIOqWHO·pWDW
LQVWDEOHTXLDSXrWUHFHOXLGXYRFDOLVPHVXGSLFpQLHQjXQPRPHQWTXLDI-U4U"U%"!%I!1%.;UI6X1!%+#0$6-#X1!3RXU
OHVXGSLFpQLHQWHOTX·LOHVWDWWHVWpGDQVOHVLQVFULSWLRQVQRXVSUpIpURQVDGRSWHUOHV\VWqPHSOXVUpDOLVWHUHIOpWp
SDUOHGLDJUDPPH%FLGHVVRXV

'LDJUDPPH% LAX <X

̩QX ‫;ۆ‬X
H=X R9X
DKX

,OHVWpJDOHPHQWSRVVLEOHPDLVQRQQpFHVVDLUHTXHODUHFKHUFKHG·XQFRQWUDVWHSOXVQHWHQWUHOHVGHX[YR\HOOHV
G·DUULqUHDLWFRQGXLWOHVORFXWHXUVjXQHUpDOLVDWLRQJpQpUDOHHWQRQSDVRFFDVLRQQHOOH>X@GH‫ۆ‬HW>X@GH‫ۆ‬
YRLUHjXQGpSODFHPHQWGHVSKRQqPHV‫ۆ‬HW‫ۆ‬YHUVXHWX2QDERXWLUDLWDXV\VWqPHUHSUpVHQWpSDUOH
GLDJUDPPH&

386I76MMJ%"N LAX <X X;X

̩QX
H=X R9X
DKX

'DQVODVXLWHGHQRWUHpWXGHQRXVDGPHWWRQVTXHOHPRGqOHSURSRVpGDQVOHGLDJUDPPH%UHIOqWHDGpTXDWHPHQWOH
V\VWqPHYRFDOLTXHSLFpQLHQ DEVWUDFWLRQIDLWHGHVTXDQWLWpVHWGHVGLSKWRQJXHV 1RXVDXURQVWRXWHIRLVO·RFFDVLRQ
GHWHVWHUODYDOLGLWpGXGLDJUDPPH&
6RXOLJQRQVDYHFIRUFHTX·LOH[LVWHXQOLHQVWUXFWXUHOHQWUHOH>(#)$#!)HQVXGSLFpQLHQGHWURLVUHIOHWV"#::U-!)4#U0%
GHVWURLVWLPEUHVGHVYR\HOOHVSRVWpULHXUHVGXSURWRVDEHOOLTXHG·XQHSDUWHWG·DXWUHSDUWOH"UI.(4!>!)$%?!-0%.;(?()$%
GHVYR\HOOHVXHWࡃDXWLPEUHOHSOXVIHUPp6DQVFH:-6)$#)5‫ۆ‬VHVHUDLWSUREDEOHPHQWFRQIRQGXDYHFࡃ
FRPPHF·HVWOHFDVHQRPEULHQ:P%-T(-4+(V0>!SKRQRORJLTXHGHODWULSOHUHSUpVHQWDWLRQQ·DGRQFSXVHPDLQWHQLU
TX·DXSUL[G·XQH#))6?($#6)FHOOHG·XQ(..E5!>!)$GHODVpULHSRVWpULHXUHTXLDHQULFKLODVpULHGHVYR\HOOHVG·DYDQW
,OUpVXOWHGHFHVUpIOH[LRQVSUpOLPLQDLUHVTXHOHVFKDPSVGHUpDOLVDWLRQGHVWLPEUHVYRFDOLTXHVQRWpV9!;X2%
<!GHYDLHQWrWUHVpSDUpVOHVXQVGHVDXWUHVSDUGHVPDUJHVGHVpFXULWpVXIILVDPPHQWJUDQGHVSRXUTXHO·RQSXLVVH
pFDUWHUG·HPEOpHWRXWULVTXHGHFRQIXVLRQSKRQpWLTXHHQWUHHX[2QHVWGRQFHQGURLWGHVXSSRVHUXQHXWLOLVDWLRQ
QRQDUELWUDLUHGHVOHWWUHV9!;!HW<!

:@
1RXVODLVVRQVGHF{WpODSRVVLEOHSUpVHQFHGHn  

$GLHJR/DMDUD  HVWLPHTXHO·XWLOLVDWLRQGH;X%=FL7%HFKJ7%
ZFRQVRQQHGDQVSOXVLHXUVLQVFULSWLRQV OjRG·DXWUHVHPSORLHQW
O!RX<! VHUDLWXQLQGLFHGXFDUDFWqUHWUqVIHUPpGH;!YR\HOOH
YDODQWTXDVLPHQW>X  @7RXWHIRLVHQRPEULHQpFULWHQDOSKDEHWODWLQ
OHSURGXLWGHODPRQRSKWRQJDLVRQGH 61HVWUHQGXSDU6! $6$(2%
$6$(> ,OHQYDGHPrPHSRXUOHQRUGRVTXH $6$(#jF{WpGH$61$(#2%
5DSLQR099H 3XLVTXHF·HVW;!TXLQRWHOHIUXLWGHODPR
QRSKWRQJDLVRQGH 61HQVXGSLFpQLHQ B;BKG7( FH;!GHYUDLW
FRUUHVSRQGUHSOXW{WjXQ>‫@ۆ‬WUqVIHUPpTX·jXQYpULWDEOH>X@
:P
&RPPHO·DVRXOLJQpjMXVWHWLWUH0HLVHU  OHVRUWGH
‫ۆ‬GDQVODSUpKLVWRLUHGHO·RVTXHHVWEHDXFRXSSOXVGLIILFLOHjFHU
QHU
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% OPR

#=&DF9SEM:=&:9FDN9@9E9>AL<=&D9G?&DKF&EK&CA@KE=&H=&>?@ABAC&DE<FA=E&=@&G<H3DAI?@A=@
'XSRLQWGHYXHGLDFKURQLTXHRQDFRQVLGpUpTXHOHVDERXWLVVHPHQWVGHVYR\HOOHVRHWGH‫ ۆ‬LVVXGH
‫گ‬LWDOLTXH GXSURWRVDEHOOLTXHQ·pWDLHQWSDVOHVPrPHVHQVXGSLFpQLHQVHORQTXHOHVYR\HOOHVHQTXHVWLRQ
ILJXUDLHQWHQV\OODEHILQDOHRXQRQ&·HVWOHSRLQWGHYXHGpIHQGXSDU0LFKDHO:HLVVGDQVXQDUWLFOHUpFHQWHW
IRQGDPHQWDODXWLWUHVLJQLILFDWLI´2Q6RPH3UREOHPVRI)LQDO6\OODEOHVLQ6RXWK3LFHQHµ  3RXUOHVV\OODEHV
QRQILQDOHVOHVFRUUHVSRQGDQFHVHQWUHSURWRVDEHOOLTXHHWVXGSLFpQLHQVRQWFODLUHVQ?4XDQGLOQ·HVWSDVSUHPLHU
pOpPHQWGHGLSKWRQJXH 6EUHIHVWUHIOpWpVDXIFRQGLWLRQQHPHQWSDUWLFXOLHUSDURQRWp9XN%D9GBA@7( ODWLQ
I60$ B9RK:7( ODWLQ$65( D9G:;A7(7( GDWLIVLQJXOLHUPDVFXOLQGXSURQRPUHODWLI =960>M L9FKG%#)%
@2%L9FK%"(%OD2%R9FK:$4 ´HIILJLHGHSLHUUHµ>"@UDFLQH 0 =!-´FRXSHUµDYHFODPrPHPDWULFHPpWDSKRULTXHQO%
TXHFHOOHTXHO·RQWURXYHGDQV0#5)1>YLVjYLVGHVHFčUH´FRXSHUµ 9D=GK>!5,¬ ODWLQRSHUčUҸ 9RF=Q%#)%@2%9RZF@
ARK:&+¬D PRWVDSSDUHQWpVDXODWLQ64-#0´pPLQHQFHµHWjGLYHUVWRSRQ\PHVGHO·,WDOLHDQFLHQQHSUpVHQWpVSDU
&DO]HFFKL2QHVWL ¬L9E9CQB;F$3¬ ´>OHFLSSH@VHGUHVVHµSUpVHQWGpSRQHQWRXSDVVLITXLSURFqGHRXELHQGH
UNROI̩WRU NROLI̒WRU =6.M#"+̒WRUGpQRPLQDWLIG·XQDGMHFWLI =6.+rM#M"+ +_ M6M2%RXELHQGH NROI̩WRU =6.M"+̒WRU2%
GpQRPLQDWLIGH =6.+rM"+ +_ M6M2Q:DYHFGHJUpRUDGLFDOQQRXELHQjODULJXHXUGH NROI̒WRU NO G૖ +̒WRUVWDWLIG·XQH
QpRUDFLQHDYHFGHJUpUpGXLWUDGLFDOOHVHFRQG9V·H[SOLTXHGDQVWRXVOHVFDVSDUDQDSW\[HFRPPHO·DpWDEOL
9LQHODIRUPHGHIRQGDWLRQGHFHYHUEHHVWDSSDUHQWpHDXJUHF໵‫ڗ‬ड़‫ߥཬۭۭڗ‬UHIOHWGH =6.6$ +M'6WHUPHTXLGpVLJQH
HQFRQWH[WHIXQpUDLUHGHVVXEVWLWXWVULWXHOVG·DVSHFWKXPDQRwGH @9;Q@AG$3¬ QRZ̒Q # '6 S9;=HAQ@$4¬
jUDSSURFKHUGXI(510%&6!"#)10Q<%GH3/N,;OHUDGLFDOSRXUUDLWrWUHLGHQWLTXHjFHOXLGHO·RVTXHS;OKAK@;H%
6D¬9H $MRXWRQVjFHWWHOLVWHXQHIRUPHGH$4¬TXHQRXVUHVWLWXRQV>L@9NKF:= RX>R@9NKF:= ´SRXUOH
SRUWHXUG·DUPHVµRX´SRXUOHFRPSDJQRQG·DUPHVµ GDWLIODVWUXFWXUHHVWFHOOHGXODWLQ#)!->#0 DYHFODYDULDQWH
DQWpYRFDOLTXH =6MGXSUpIL[H =6>MQR(QFHTXLFRQFHUQH:;CLE;:7(¬´IDLWGHPRQWUHUµODFRPSDUDLVRQDYHF
>6)0$-1>LQYLWHjSRVHU >6)!0$.6>PDLVOHWUDLWHPHQWGH 6HQV\OODEHIHUPpH DSUqVV\QFRSHGH! \HVW
SRXUO·KHXUHPDOH[SOLTXpVDQVTXHFHWWHLQFHUWLWXGHDIIHFWHODYDOLGLWpJpQpUDOHGHODORLGHUHSUpVHQWDWLRQGH
6SDU9!FDUO·HQYLURQQHPHQWSKRQpWLTXHSURSUHSRXUUDLWDYRLULPSRVpXQFKDQJHPHQWFRQGLWLRQQpGRQWOH
GpWDLOQRXVpFKDSSHHQFRUH
/H ‫ۆ‬IHUPpHWORQJGXSURWRVDEHOOLTXHLVVXGXSURWRLWDOLTXH ‫گ‬HVWUHSUpVHQWpSDU;!HQVXGSLFpQLHQ
GDQVOHVV\OODEHVQRQILQDOHVD<;H=7(¬ =9XZ‫گ‬GHGRQWOHSUHPLHUpOpPHQWHVWFRPSDUDEOHDXYpGLTXHNYj¬DYHF
XQHILQDOHGHGLUHFWLIOHVHQVHVWFHOXLGXODWLQX16("Q@ @=:;@=Q7(¬ QHP‫گ‬Q´RFFXSDQW>GHODWRPEH@µ 
:;F=AG&+¬E ´JUDQGµ´H[FHOOHQWµDSSDUHQWpDXVHFRQGPHPEUHGXFRPSRVpJUHF์ࣹशۭ͘໅ࢆङ‫ ߥڗݰ‬H;@9N&+¬
ODWLQG‫گ‬QXP ,OHVWLQXWLOHGHFRQVLGpUHUTXHO·LQVFULSWLRQ&+¬DIDLWXQXVDJHLQFRKpUHQWGH;!HWGH9!(Q
HIIHWULHQQ·REOLJHjVXSSRVHUXQ ‫گ‬GDQVOHSURWRW\SHGH9CB9FA:TXLUHPRQWHjO·DGMHFWLYDWLRQG·XQV\QWDJPH
SUpSRVLWLRQQHO 6&%#$6-% GH 6I # %#$6- FRPSDUDEOHDXODWLQ6&#$!-HWTXLVLJQLILH´VLWXpOHORQJGXFKHPLQµ #$6-%
 LWU૖ UpIHFWLRQGH +_HLWU૖DYHFXQGHJUpUpGXLWVXIIL[DOFRPPHOHKLWWLWH#M$(-X2<?HWQRQXQGHJUp‫گ‬FRPPHOH
WRNKDULHQ$\WčU<O 3DUDLOOHXUVPrPHVLO·RQUDWWDFKHOHSUHPLHUPHPEUHGXFRPSRVpA9RAD=H<%6L%>6K8H%OࡃFXV2%JH%
=F96HK%U.!9=! .69=! '6g=OHIDLWTXHOHUpVXOWDWGHODFRQWUDFWLRQVRLWQRWp9!HWQRQ;!FRPPHGDQVB;BKG%
GH7(¬QHSHUPHWSDVGHFRQFOXUHjXQIORWWHPHQWRUWKRJUDSKLTXH6LPSOHPHQWOHVUpVXOWDWVGHVFRQWUDFWLRQV
VRQWGLIIpUHQWVGDQVOHSLFpQLHQGH&+DHWGDQVFHOXLGH7(¬HWO·RQVDLWTXHOHVODQJXHVGHFHVGHX[LQVFULSWLRQV
GLYHUJHQWVXUG·DXWUHVSRLQWVHQFRUH

Q?
/HSUHPLHUHVVDLG·pWXGHV\VWpPDWLTXHHVWFHOXLG·$GLHJR/DMDUD
 
QO
6XUFHWWHQRWLRQYRLU7DLOODUGDW
Q:
,FLODODU\QJDOHWRPEHDXYRLVLQDJHGXYRFDOLVPHRFRQIRUPp
PHQWjO·!::!$%7(1001-! VXUFHSKpQRPqQHYRLU1XVVEDXPHW
/DPEHUWHULH 
QQ
9LQHD²
Q<
0RUDQGL²-DQGD
QR
'XQNHO ² UpIXWHDYHFUDLVRQO·LGpHG·XQHJHQqVHLQ
WpULHXUHDXODWLQGXSUpIL[H46HWSODLGHSRXUODFRH[LVWHQFHGqV
O·LQGRHXURSpHQGH =6>HWGH =6/HSURWRW\SHHVW =6M(->M!#2%
DYHFPRQRSKWRQJDLVRQGHODILQDOH/HN!TXLILJXUHGHYDQWO·LQLWLDOH
K!GXVHFRQGPHPEUHGHFRPSRVpVRXOLJQHO·KLDWXVjODIURQWLqUH
GHFRPSRVLWLRQHWQ·DSDVSOXVGHYDOHXUSKRQpWLTXHSURSUHTXH
OHN!LQLWLDOGDQVNKEAɘKB; DSSDUHQWpDXWRSRQ\PH<..#:(! GHOD
PrPHLQVFULSWLRQ

1RXVQHGLVFXWRQVSDVLFLO·RULJLQHLQGRHXURSpHQQHGHFHWWHILQDOH
‫گ‬HWUHQYR\RQVjO·pWXGHGH*DUFtD5DPyQ  
Q@
0DUW]ORIIQ SURORQJHDQWHQODPRGLILDQWXQHVXJ
JHVWLRQGH:HLVV 

3RXUXQHGLVFXVVLRQGHFHWWHIRUPHHWGHVGLIIpUHQWHVLQWHUSUpWD
WLRQVSRVVLEOHVYRLU0DUW]ORII²
QP
/DVpTXHQFHH=ARBK:&T&DA:&9CB9FA:&T&KHGBK=9:GVHWUDGXLW
DORUV´OHPRQXPHQWV%TXHQRXVDYRQVGUHVVpV%DXERUGGXFKHPLQµ
&HWWHLQGLFDWLRQHVWFRPSDUDEOHjD9GBA@&OAK:´DXGHOjGXFKHPLQµ
GH7(¬%LHQTXHO·DQWpFpGHQWH=ARBK:GXUHODWLIDA:VRLWIpPLQLQ
F·HVWODIRUPHPDVFXOLQHGHO·DGMHFWLITXLHVWHPSOR\pH 9CB9FA: FDU
HOOHV·DFFRUGHDYHFDA: TXLQ·DTX·XQHIRUPHGHPDVFXOLQ 
<?
'DQVODIRUPHDQDWROLHQQHOHGHJUpSOHLQUDGLFDODpWpVHFRQGDLUH
PHQWUHPSODFpSDUOHGHJUpUpGXLW 5LHNHQ 
<O
:RGWNR,UVOLQJHUHW6FKQHLGHUHWQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

4XDQWjO·DEODWLIGXWRSRQ\PH¬GD9EQBA; <:TXLILJXUHVXUOHFDVTXH%2¬OH9!HVWSUREOpPDWLTXHPDLVQRQ
LQFRQFLOLDEOHDYHFOHODWLQ6S‫گ‬O̒WLXP2<QFDUO·DXWHXUGHFHWWHLQVFULSWLRQUpFHQWHQ·pWDLWSHXWrWUHSOXVDXIDLWGHV
FRQYHQWLRQVRUWKRJUDSKLTXHVSLFpQLHQQHV&RPPH0HLVHU:HLVV  SRVHWRXWHIRLV 6SRO̒W # \‫گ‬G DYHF
EUqYH $XWUHGLIILFXOWpODVLPLOLWXGHHQWUHFHTX·RQDOXD=BA=F9@AGX<<HQ$3¬HWOHD=BF;@AGGH$3¬SRXUUDLW
VXJJpUHUTXHOH9GHD=BA=F9@AGUHPRQWHjXQHORQJXH6LOHUDSSURFKHPHQWGHVGHX[IRUPHVpWDLWH[DFWLO
IDXGUDLWDGPHWWUHTXHODYR\HOOHG·DQDSW\[H !DSDODWDOLVpODGHQWDOHSUpFpGHQWH G·ROHA! /HWLPEUH>H@GH
O·DQDSW\[HQHFRUUHVSRQGSDVjODYR\HOOHGHODV\OODEHRILJXUDLWOH-PDLVHVWLGHQWLTXHjFHOXLGHODYR\HOOH
VLWXpHSDUGHOjO·RFFOXVLYHFRPPHF·HVWOHFDVGDQVKFQBANGH$3¬ RQ!QRWHWRXWHIRLVXQVRQSOXVRXYHUWTXH
A! (QIDLWD=BA=F9@AGDSSDUWLHQWLODXIRQGVRQRPDVWLTXHSURSUHPHQWSLFpQLHQ"5DSSHORQVTX·RQDSURSRVp
GHYRLUHQBKF<AG $3¬ XQDQWKURSRQ\PHG·RULJLQHFHOWLTXH :HLVVFLWH*(-1#10%3/N9 (QWRXW
FDVGD9EQBA;%JK%D=BA=F9@AG GHOHFWXUHDXGHPHXUDQWLQFHUWDLQH VRQWGHSHXGHSRLGVHWQHFRQWUDLJQHQWSDVj
VXSSRVHUXQPDQTXHGHULJXHXU5U)U-(.GDQVO·HPSORLGH9!HWGH;!SRXUOHVLQVFULSWLRQVOHVSOXVDQFLHQQHV
&·HVWDXFRQWUDLUHXQHLPSUHVVLRQJOREDOHGHIRUWHFRKpUHQFHRUWKRJUDSKLTXHTXLVHGpJDJH
(QILQOHVUHIOHWVGH X TXLQ·HVWSDVVHFRQGpOpPHQWGHGLSKWRQJXH HWGHࡃVRQWQRWpV<XN%L<DKB0&¬
$3¬´LOHVWFRXFKpLOUHSRVHµ FRPSDUDEOHDXODWLQFXEčUHjVHVFRUUHVSRQGDQWVIDOLVTXHVHWDXQRUGRVTXH4#&($ 
D<LE9N$4¬´DXILOVµ<R%R<DFQ$4¬L<DQFQN$3¬ ´GHIDoRQEHOOHµGH NXSU̒GDYHFODUDFLQHGXODWLQ41I!-! 
RH<Q;&+E VXSHUSRVDEOHDXODWLQFOXH‫گ‬%UNOX̒‫ گ‬D<QN$3 ´SL̒µGH Sࡃ\̒G2DYHFODUDFLQHGHSࡃUXV 5DSSHORQV
TXHCABAKG9:%#)%R%JK%CQBAKG5, HWSHXWrWUH$3 QHUHSRVHQWSDVVXU &+ࡃWLPDLVVXU "+̒WL UDFLQH "+!+_M 
(QUHYDQFKHSRXUOHVV\OODEHVILQDOHVOHVIDLWVVRQWEHDXFRXSSOXVGLIILFLOHVjGpFULUH<@&HUWHVOHUHIOHWGH
ࡃVHPEOHrWUHQRWp<X2VLGXPRLQVA9RAD=H< &+¬D VLJQLILH´GHSXLVODSDUWLHEDVVH OHI#!" FRQVWLWXpH
=67%>J%.1410µ SDURSSRVLWLRQDXPRWFRQVpFXWLI9RZF@ARK:TXLGpVLJQHOD´SDUWLHKDXWHµOD´FLWDGHOOHµ HWVLOH
VHFRQGWHUPHGHFRPSRVpUHPRQWHj SHGࡃGXQDEODWLITXLVXLWODIOH[LRQHQ1SDUDQDORJLHGXQRPGHOD´PDLQµ
FRPPHF·HVWSUpFLVpPHQWOHFDVHQRPEULHQ 0HLVHU 0DLVUHWUDFHUODSUpKLVWRLUHGHVWHUPLQDLVRQVR
LQWHUYLHQQHQWOHVYR\HOOHV RRX ‫گ‬GHO·LWDOLTXHSDUDvWSOXVFRPSOH[H,OIDXWSUREDEOHPHQWIDLUHLQWHUYHQLU
GHVPpFDQLVPHVG·DQDORJLHLQWUDSDUDGLJPDWLTXHSRXUH[SOLTXHUFHUWDLQHVILQDOHV­QRV\HX[DEVWUDFWLRQIDLWH
GHVGLSKWRQJXHVOHVVHXOVFDV(001-U0GHUHSUpVHQWDWLRQI+6)U$#X1!<PVRQWOHVVXLYDQWV REUHIHVWUHIOpWpSDU
;!HQV\OODEHILQDOHGHYDQW -% L9E9CQB;F$3¬ GHYDQW )"LVVXGH )$ KHGBKQ;N$3¬>D@FKAGBKQ;N%,*%O2%>J%

<:
/·DEVHQFHGHN!ILQDOVRLWHVWXQHVLPSOHQpJOLJHQFHJUDSKLTXH
VRLWWUDGXLWXQHpYROXWLRQTXLWLHQWDXFDUDFWqUHWDUGLIGHO·LQVFULS
WLRQGDQVFHFDVRXELHQ +ILQDOFRQVRQQHjSDUWHQWLqUHHVWWRP
EpRXELHQODORQJXHVHFRQGDLUHLVVXHG·XQDOORQJHPHQWFRPSHQ
VDWRLUHFDXVpSDUODFKXWHGH +HWQRWpHDLOOHXUV;N!SDUJUDSKLH
pW\PRORJLTXHDpWpDEUpJpHHQILQDOHjFHWWHpSRTXH
<Q
% -T,]:6-"% N($#)% H#4$#6)(-' LQGLTXH XQH ORQJXH SRXU OD SUHPLqUH
YR\HOOHGHFHPRW
<<
/DOHFWXUHHVWHQUpDOLWpLQFHUWDLQH2QVHUHSRUWHUDDXFRPPHQ
WDLUHGH0DULQHWWL ² 
<R
,QGRHXURSpHQ I1$.6M YRLU+DMQDO²Q 

&HWWHpW\PRORJLHGXHj$GLHJR/DMDUD ² DpWpDFFHSWpH
jMXVWHWLWUHSDU9LQH D 1RXVDGPHWWRQVTXHODFKXWHGH
\RGLQWHUYRFDOLTXHGHYDQW!HVWHQSURWRLWDOLTXHFKURQRORJLTXH
PHQWDQWpULHXUHjODORLGH7KXUQH\VHQ ࡃ\! Ҹ\ TXLSUpFqGH
HOOHPrPHODFKXWHGH\RGLQWHUYRFDOLTXHGHYDQW6 g HW( g ,O
HVWSRVVLEOHTXHFHOOHFLDLWHXOLHXGDQVODSUpKLVWRLUHFRPPXQHGX
ODWLQHWGXVDEHOOLTXHPDLVQRQGXYpQqWH&HWWHFKURQRORJLHUHOD
WLYHDXUDLWO·DYDQWDJHG·H[SOLTXHUOHPDLQWLHQGX\RGLQWHUYRFDOLTXH
GDQVN9F=A9@B=FRUUHFWLRQWUqVSODXVLEOHGH0LFKHO/HMHXQH F
 SRXU [ N9FOA9@B=WUDQVPLV¬ QRXVVRQJHULRQVjFRPSDUHUSRXU
ODIRUPHOHWKqPH=!-#'!´ULUHµGXWRNKDULHQ%LVVXGH Н + 6-MU'6M%
RXGH Н + 6-!M'6M+LOPDUVVRQ5LQJH.LP
Q VDQVSRXUDXWDQWH[FOXUHOHYpQqWHGXJURXSHLWDOLTXH/D
OpJLWLPLWpG·XQHLQFOXVLRQGXYpQqWHSDUPLOHVODQJXHVLWDOLTXHVHVW
G·DLOOHXUVFRQIRUWpHSDUO·DQWKURSRQ\PHN9GBANKO9G /HMHXQH%
QR V·LOVLJQLILH´TXLPHWO·HQQHPLHQGpURXWHµ Н +69M6M0OD
UDFLQHpODUJLHDSSDUDvWGDQVOHODWLQ:1)"!-! SRXUOHVHQVRQFRP
=67J76%>TFMD78JH%+6)"1´GLVSHUVHµ Н + XQGHW‫گ‬G HWOHODWLQ%+60$!0%
:1)"#$%:15($X1! 7LWH/LYH 'XSRLQWGHYXHSKRQpWLTXHO·pYR
OXWLRQ 69!(9VHPEOHUDLWrWUH$'I#X1!>!)$SURWRLWDOLTXH HQFH
VHQV9LQHDTXLDUHFRQQXGDQVO·RPEULHQ0(1#$1OHUHIOHWG·XQ
LWpUDWLI =069U'!DSSDUHQWpDXODWLQ0(14#10´EOHVVpµ &HWWHDQDO\VH
SKRQpWLTXHUHVWHLQFKDQJpHVLO·RQSUpIqUHYRLUGDQVOHQRPSURSUH
N9GBANKO9GXQFRPSRVpVLJQLILDQW´TXLKRQRUHO·pWUDQJHUµ 18HJ%
E /HYRFDOLVPHGHO·("?!-&!RVTXH›͘K͘˗ /X9H 
HVWTXDQWjOXLDQDORJLTXHGHO·("c!4$#:(QVXGSLFpQLHQODORLGH
7KXUQH\VHQSRXUUDLWDYRLUMRXpGDQVH=CAK &+¬ V·LOV·DJLVVDLWELHQ
G·XQVXEMRQFWLISUpYHUEpFRUUHVSRQGDQWj:#($VHORQXQGpYHORSSH
PHQW & + ࡃ\čG! :Ҹ\čG! IҸ\čK!CAK ODGpVLQHQFHVHFRQGDLUHQ·D
SDVpWpUHPSODFpHLFLSDUXQHGpVLQHQFHSULPDLUH )LQDOHPHQWRQ
DGPHWWUDTXHVRQW46>I($#&.!0OHVGHX[pYROXWLRQV Sࡃ\̒G%X%USࡃ̒GX%
D<QN%JK%USࡃ\RV%X%USҸ\RV%X%I#10/·DGYHUEHD<QNSHXWGRQFQRXVUHQ
VHLJQHUVXUWUDLWHPHQWGHࡃHQVXGSLFpQLHQ
<@
8QSUHPLHUHVVDLG·DQDO\VHWRXFKDQWODGLVWULEXWLRQGH9:;:%
HW<:VHWURXYHFKH]$GLHJR/DMDUD ² 

&RQWUDLUHPHQWjXQHRSLQLRQSDUIRLVH[SULPpHULHQQ·DXWRULVHj
DGPHWWUHTXHO·pYROXWLRQGHࡃHQҸHQV\OODEHILQDOHTX·DWWHVWH
O·DEODWLIRVTXH4(0$-#" WKqPHHQ1 DLWpWpDFKHYpHHQSURWRVDEHO
OLTXH
<P
 1RXV DSSHORQV LFL -!I-U0!)$($#6)% I+6)U$#X1! O·DERXWLVVHPHQW GH
WUDQVIRUPDWLRQVTXLRQWPHQpDXFRXUVGHO·KLVWRLUHGHODODQJXH
G·XQVHJPHQWjXQDXWUHGDQVXQFRQWH[WHGRQQpVXLYDQWXQHQ
VHPEOH GH SKpQRPqQHV GH QDWXUH 1)#X1!>!)$ SKRQpWLTXH 1RXV
RSSRVHURQVGDQVODVXLWHFHVUHSUpVHQWDWLRQVSKRQpWLTXHVjFHOOHV
TXLUpVXOWHQWGH-U:!4$#6)0PRUSKRORJLTXHVRLQWHUYLHQQHQWGHVSUR
FHVVXVDQDORJLTXHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% OP@

PRUSKqPHGHSUpWpULW;pWDQWLVVXGHODYR\HOOHWKpPDWLTXH 6SRXUYXHG·XQHIRQFWLRQQRXYHOOHR? HW ‫گ‬

ORQJLWDOLTXHHVWUHIOpWpSDU;!GHYDQW 0 QRPLQDWLIVSOXULHOVKDKA;G$3¬GKCA@;G7( HWGHYDQW " DEODWLIV
98HIL>8J79%BABA;N RO%"(%:2%GD9EQBA;R:%2¬ /HV3VLQJGHSUpWpULW9DG;B%!.%:%JK%Z9@DG;L7(SRXUUDLHQWDYRLU
XQYRFDOLVPHDQDORJLTXHGHODWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQHGXSOXULHORQ'DQVOHFDVGHOD3SOXUKHGBK=9:G &+¬D OH
YRFDOLVPHRULJLQHORDSUREDEOHPHQWpWpSUpVHUYp UpSpWRQVTX·LOQ·HVWSDVQpFHVVDLUHGHFRQVLGpUHUTXH&+¬D
IDLWXQXVDJHLQFRKpUHQWHWQRQV\VWpPDWLTXHGH;! 
8QSUREOqPHpSLQHX[TXH:HLVV  DUHSpUpHWGpFULWDYHFEHDXFRXSGHSHUVSLFDFLWpHVWSRVpSDUOHV
ILQDOHVGHJpQLWLISOXULHOG·XQF{WpHWG·DFFXVDWLIPDVFXOLQHWGHQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLIQHXWUHVLQJXOLHUVGHVVXEVWDQ
WLIVWKpPDWLTXHVG·XQDXWUHF{Wp/DGLIILFXOWpHVWGRXEOH'·XQHSDUWVLHQV\OODEHQRQILQDOH 6EUHIHVWUHIOpWp
SDU9HQSLFpQLHQRQDWWHQGTXHOHVWHUPLQDLVRQVG·DFFXVDWLIPDVFXOLQHWGHQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLIQHXWUHVLQJX
OLHUVGHVVXEVWDQWLIVWKpPDWLTXHVVRLHQWHQ9:2URQWURXYH;:PDLVMDPDLV 9:'·DXWUHSDUWVLHQV\OODEH
QRQILQDOH ‫گ‬HVWUHIOpWpSDU;RQDWWHQGTXHODILQDOHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOJpQpUDOHPHQWUHFRQVWUXLWH ‫گ‬P2%9F8K%
UHIOpWpHSDU;:2UQRQVHXOHPHQWODGpVLQHQFHQRUPDOHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOHVW9:PDLVVHORQ:HLVVODJUDSKLH
GHFHWWHILQDOH+U0#$!-(#$HQWUH9:!;:!HW<:!$XJpQLWLISOXULHOSLFpQLHQVHUDLHQWGRQFDWWDFKpHVGHX[
pQLJPHVO·XQHWRXFKDQWODV\QFKURQLH O·XVDJHGHVWURLVOHWWUHV9!<!HW;!VHPEOHIOXFWXHUGDQVXQHHWXQH
VHXOHSRVLWLRQFHOOHGXJpQLWLISOXULHO O·DXWUHODGLDFKURQLH FRPPHQWH[SOLTXHUO·LQYHUVLRQGHVILQDOHV9:%=FL7%
;:DWWHQGXDXJpQLWLISOXULHO;:SRXU9:DWWHQGXjO·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHU" /HSUpVHQWH[SRVpVHFRQFHQWUHUD
VXUFHIORWWHPHQWUpHORXDSSDUHQWDWRQDIIDLUHjXQHYDULDWLRQSKRQRORJLTXHRXPRUSKRORJLTXHjO·LQWpULHXU
GHODODQJXH"2XELHQODYDULDWLRQHVWHOOHVHXOHPHQWJUDSKLTXH"0DLVLOVHSRXUUDLWpJDOHPHQWTXHFHWWHSUpWHQGXH
YDULDWLRQQHVRLWjELHQ\UHJDUGHUTX·XQPLUDJHGHODSKLORORJLH

#=G&C9F:=G&=@&39:U&=B&E=G&>?@ABACG&DE<FA=EG&DF?G<:?G&=@&3;:&=B&=@&3<:
1RXVFRPPHQFHURQVSDUXQUHOHYpH[KDXVWLIGHVGRQQpHVSHUWLQHQWHV1RXVGLVSRVRQVGHWURLVH[HPSOHVV€UV%
GHJpQLWLIVSOXULHOVHQ9:'·DERUGCABAKG9:&:;CLE;:&HQ7(¬´OHPRQXPHQW :;CLE;: GHVKDXWVIDLWV¬ CABAK3
G9: µDYHFXQHILQDOHKG9:%9L=J7=F96D>J%6L%>6K8H%čUXP&RPPHCQBAKGGH5,HWGH$3 OHFWXUHGH0HLVHU
D CABAKG9:%7J=F9J%9L7%U"+!+_WLčWKqPHFRPSDUDEOHDXODWLQI̒WLčOLVDXJRWLTXHG̒‫ݫ‬VDXYLHX[
KDXWDOOHPDQGWčW WKqPHHQ#´DFWLRQFRQGXLWHµDOOHPDQG*($R< (EQ@BA9:&9RF=QHQVXLWHHQ7(´VXUSRXU
ODFLWDGHOOHGHV<. . HQW̒VµRKEQ@BA9:VHPEOHrWUHXQGpULYpHQ $#G·XQWRSRQ\PH (. . ̒QRP :HLVV 
(QILQ¬=R;3GA:&FK=EA9:&´M·DSSDUWLHQVDX[K( # !.##µVXU&+¬DWRXUQXUHDVVRFLDQWOHYHUEH´rWUHµjXQQRPDX
JpQLWLI :HLVV 
,OH[LVWHHQFRUHWURLVDXWUHVFDQGLGDWVSRWHQWLHOVELHQSOXVLQFHUWDLQVDXWLWUHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOHQ9:
'·DERUGBABA=@9:7( VDQVFRQWH[WH (QVXLWHVXU&+¬XQHIRUPHGHOHFWXUHLQFHUWDLQHHWGHVHQVLQFRQQX
E<CK@A9:RR%FL%F<BK@A9:(QILQOHVHJPHQW@9F9:!VXUO·LQVFULSWLRQ&+DRQRXVDYRQVGpMjGpFHOpXQH[HPSOH
V€UGHJpQLWLISOXULHOFK=EA9:)DXWLOLVROHUGDQVODVpTXHQFH<D=R=>  @9F9:2%LH%9LD9K6HK8G%R=>  @9F9:2%>J%
FRPSOpWHUHQR=Z@ K B@9F9:´GHVDQFrWUHVGHVDwHX[µ ODVRQRUHJpWDQWQRWpHR!HQ&+DFRPPHOHPRQWUH
=R;´!56µ OHFRPSDUHUDXODWLQ5!)#$6- LVVXGH JHQDW‫گ‬UR@ НHQK_W‫گ‬U HWVXSSRVHUXQHGLVMRQFWLRQR=Z@ K B@

R?
5L[²HWQ
RO
/HYRLVLQDJHGXGDWLIB=C=N &+¬ QHSURXYHHQDXFXQFDVTXH
BABA;NVRLWOXLDXVVLXQGDWLI/DSUR[LPLWpGHVGHX[IRUPHVV·H[SOLTXH
QRQVHXOHPHQWSDUODUHFKHUFKHGHO·DOOLWpUDWLRQPDLVDXVVLSRXUGHV
UDLVRQVGHVHQVFDUHOOHVSRXUUDLHQWUHSUpVHQWHUOHVGHX[S{OHVG·XQ
pFKDQJH´GHODSDUWGH7LWLXVSRXUWRLµ
R:
3RXUO·DQDO\VHFRPPHDEODWLIYRLU0HLVHUEG·DSUqV
5L[HW:HLVV²HWQ
RQ
/·H[WHQVLRQDQDORJLTXHGHVPDUTXHVIRUPHOOHVGHOD3SOXUjOD
3VLQJYRLUHDX[WURLVSHUVRQQHVGXVLQJXOLHUDGHERQVSDUDOOqOHV
W\SRORJLTXHVGDQVOHGRPDLQHLWDOLTXHQRWDPPHQWHQODWLQ :DWNLQV
² 
R<
(LFKQHUQVXUFHWWHIDPLOOHYRLU9LQHER
VRQWFLWpVG·DXWUHVFRUUHVSRQGDQWVQRWDPPHQWOHO\GLHQ$( ( 4´RI
IUDQGHµ *pUDUG 
RR
6WXDUW6PLWK²HW

&ODFNVRQ ¬Q IDLWUHPDUTXHUTXHOH´F<B@A9:µGH5L[
 HVWXQODSVXVFRPPHHQWpPRLJQHOHOH[LTXH SSHW
 RODIRUPHHVWFRUUHFWHPHQWFLWpH
R@
%$8%>TFH%7JK8JHK%R=Z@KB@9F9: HQTXDWUHV\OODEHV O·DEVHQFHGHV\Q
FRSHGX(EUHIPpGLDQVHUDLWLPSXWDEOHjO·DQDORJLHGHIRUPHVROH
VXIIL[HDSSDUDvWDXGHJUpUpGXLW $-'HWHOOHVIRUPHVH[LVWDLHQWFHU
WDLQHPHQWjHQMXJHUSDUOHODWLQJHQHWUҸ[2QQRWHUDHQWRXWFDVTXH
O·RVTXH>=@=BKQ 6D9H FRQVHUYHOXLDXVVLVDYR\HOOHLQWpULHXUH
=67%()(.65#!G·DXWUHVIRUPHV YRLUHQGHUQLHUOLHX+DXJ 

6XUOHVIRQGHPHQWVLQGRHXURSpHQVGHFHWWHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQYRLU
:RGWNR,UVOLQJHUHW6FKQHLGHU (QSLFpQLHQPrPHRQ
WURXYHK:>=@KG $3¬ TX·RQDSURSRVpGHUDWWDFKHUjFHWWHUDFLQH
0DULQHWWL  FRPSDUHSRXUODIRUPDWLRQOHODWLQ#)"#5!)(
(QUpDOLWpK:>=@KGVHUDLWSOXW{WXQDGMHFWLIGHSUHPLqUHFODVVH
jO·DFFXVDWLIIpPLQLQSOXULHO FRPPHL9FKGGH7( RXDXJpQLWLI
IpPLQLQVLQJXOLHU (>& + # M5!)M6M 0DLVOHVLJQH¬´µRX´!µ YDODQW
JDPPDHQ7(¬GDQVBF=S=>A=GFRPSDUDEOHj*-!&!l#4#102%*-!&!4#()102%
YRLU6FKXO]H QRWH>ɘ@ VSLUDQWHVRQRUHELODELDOH>"@ HQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

9F9:&T&FK=EA9:V%-6%9L8KJ%R=Z@ K B@9F9:&T&=R;GA:%FK=EA9:&VHUDLWjFRPSUHQGUH´M·DSSDUWLHQVDX[DwHX[OHVK( #
!.##µ,QVLVWRQVWRXWHIRLVVXUOHVLQFHUWLWXGHVELHQpYLGHPPHQWDWWDFKpHVjXQHWHOOHFRQMHFWXUHRPTXLDXUDLWSRXUWDQW
O·DYDQWDJHGHIDLUHDSSHOjXQPDWpULHOOH[LFDOELHQDWWHVWpHQODWLQ0DLVLQGpSHQGDPPHQWGHWRXWHUHFKHUFKH
pW\PRORJLTXHO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGH@9F9:!FRPPHILQDOHQRPLQDOHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOSDUDvWDVVH]SUREDEOH
/HVVSpFLDOLVWHVFLWHQW1)HWXQVHXOH[HPSOHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOHQ<:,OV·DJLWGHD;D;@<:¬HQ$3¬E(Q
FLK7J2%FH%6L768K%$-6#0VSpFLPHQVGHJpQLWLIVSOXULHOVHQ;:N%GKCA@;:7(¬:KF9;:&+¬E RQDSURSRVpGLYHUVHV
FRUUHFWLRQVSRXUFHWWHIRUPH HW><@=EQ;:&+¬E/HWH[WH$3QRXVOLYUHpJDOHPHQWTXDWUHPRWVHQ;:¬GRQW
FHUWDLQVDXPRLQVI61--(#!)$SDVVHUSRXUGHVH[HPSOHVVXSSOpPHQWDLUHVGHJpQLWLIVSOXULHOV
'DQVODGLVFXVVLRQPLQXWLHXVHTX·LODFRQVDFUpHDXSUREOqPH:HLVVDGPHWjMXVWHWLWUHFUR\RQVQRXVTXH9:%
HVWODGpVLQHQFHQRUPDOHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOHWSHQVHTXHODILQDOH;:HVWVLPSOHPHQWGXHjO·DQDORJLH5-(I+#X1!%
GXQRPLQDWLISOXULHOGXW\SHKDKA;GDYHF;GLVVXUpJXOLqUHPHQWGH ‫گ‬V :HLVV 4XDQWjO·XQLTXHRFFXU
UHQFHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOHQ<:!LOV·DJLUDLWG·XQHVLPSOHQpJOLJHQFHSRXU;:SDURPLVVLRQGHODKDVWHYHUWLFDOH
/HPrPHW\SHG·DQDO\VHDpWpSURSRVpSRXUO·RVTXHGX3#II10%<&!..()10RODGpFOLQDLVRQWKpPDWLTXHSUpVHQWH
XQDEODWLIVLQJXOLHUHQ;H!HWXQQRPLQDWLISOXULHOHQ;G!TXLVXLYUDLHQWOHPRGqOH5-(I+#X1!GHO·DFFXVDWLI
PDVFXOLQHWGHVQRPLQDWLIHWDFFXVDWLIQHXWUHVVLQJXOLHUVpFULWV;:! UDSSHORQVTXH;X%HFKJ%HF7M6>JMJHK%
XQHYR\HOOHG·DUULqUHGHWLPEUHRXYHUWHQDOSKDEHWQDWLRQDORVTXHUpIRUPp>R@SDURSSRVLWLRQjFHTXLHVWQRWp
<!DORUVTX·HQSLFpQLHQ;!QRWHXQWLPEUHIHUPpSDUUDSSRUWj9!OHVFRQYHQWLRQVJUDSKLTXHVGHFHVGHX[
ODQJXHVVRQWGRQFHQWLqUHPHQWGLIIpUHQWHV &RPPHOHUHIOHWGHODGpVLQHQFHG·LPSpUDWLI W‫گ‬GHVWQRWpB<HX%9L7%
OH&LSSHG·$EHOODLOSRXUUDLWVHPEOHUTXHF·HVWO·DSSDUWHQDQFHjXQSDUDGLJPHQRPLQDOWKpPDWLTXHTXLHQWUDvQH
XQHJUDSKLH;H! 0HLVHU &RPPHOHVRXOLJQH:HLVV  OHQLYHOOHPHQWLQWUDSDUDGLJPDWLTXH
HQTXHVWLRQVHPEOHDSSX\HUO·K\SRWKqVHTX·LOIRUPXOHSRXUOHVXGSLFpQLHQHQOXLGRQQDQWXQSDUDOOqOHRVTXH
0DLV5L[ ² DH[SORUpDYHFVXFFqVFUR\RQVQRXVXQHDOWHUQDWLYH&RQVWDWDQWTXHO·DEODWLIVLQJXOLHUHQ
;H!HWOHQRPLQDWLISOXULHOHQ;G!Q·pWDLHQWSDVOLPLWpVjOD]RQHG·$EHOODPDLVHPEUDVVDLHQWXQHYDVWH]RQH
TXLV·pWHQGDLWMXVTX·j$JQRQH 6D9H 5L[FRQVLGqUHH[SOLFLWHPHQWTX·LOQHV·DJLWSDVVHXOHPHQWG·XQSKp
QRPqQHRUWKRJUDSKLTXHPDLVG·XQHLQQRYDWLRQ>6-I+6.65#X1!GHFDUDFWqUHGLDOHFWDOELHQ-U!..!GDQVODODQJXH
/HSOXVVLPSOHHVWG·DGPHWWUHTX·jXQHpSRTXHUpFHQWHGHODSUpKLVWRLUHGHO·RVTXHXQHIRLVTXHOHVYR\HOOHV
EUqYHVHWORQJXHVKpULWpHVIXUHQWGHYHQXHVLVRFKURQHVHQILQDOHOHQRPLQDWLISOXULHOHQ XV GH ‫گ‬V HWO·DEODWLI
VLQJXOLHUHQ XG GH ‫گ‬G RQWpWpUHIDLWVHQRV QRWp;G!HQDOSKDEHWQDWLRQDO HWHQRG QRWp;H! 
G·DSUqVO·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHUHQRP QRWp;:!HWYHQDQWGH 6> WDQGLVTXHOHUHVWHGXWHUULWRLUHRVFRSKRQH
DFRQVHUYpOHVDQFLHQQHVILQDOHVXV <G! HWXG <H! /HSUpWHQGXSDUDOOqOH6-$+65-(I+#X1!RVTXHLQYRTXp
SRXUUHQGUHFRPSWHGHVIDLWVSLFpQLHQVSRXUUDLWGRQFrWUHWURPSHXU
­YUDLGLUHDEVWUDFWLRQIDLWHGHODTXHVWLRQG·XQSDUDOOqOHH[WpULHXUVLO·RQVHUHFHQWUHVXUOHVXGSLFpQLHQRQ
FRPSUHQGDVVH]PDOODUDLVRQG·rWUHGHFHWWHLQIOXHQFHJUDSKLTXHSUpVXPpHTXLVHUDLWODVRXUFHGXJpQLWLISOXULHO
HQ;:!8QHWHOOHDQDORJLHVHUDLWPrPHIUDQFKHPHQWSUREOpPDWLTXHFDUHOOHDXUDLWFRQGXLWORUVGHODOHFWXUH
jXQHFRQIXVLRQHQWUHOHJpQLWLISOXULHOHWO·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHUWKpPDWLTXHTXLHVWSUpFLVpPHQWHQ;:FRPPH
OHSURXYHQW:=ABA:;:%JK%:;CLE;:&HWWHDQDORJLHFRQWUHGLUDLWOHSULQFLSHGHPRUSKRJUDSKpPLHIRUPXOpSDU
%UL[KH ¬ RQQ·DWWHQGSDVG·pFDUWVRUWKRJUDSKLTXHVSRXUXQVHJPHQWTXLYpKLFXOHXQHFKDUJHLQIRUPDWLYH

$4¬HWHQ%$¬ -DQGD /DYDOHXUSKRQpWLTXHGXVLJQH´µHVWHQ PHPEUHpWDQWjUDSSURFKHUGHO·DYHVWLTXHXLWL¬>"@ (QRXWUHLOVH

IDLWDPELJXsGDQVK:W=@KGRPGHYUDLWrWUHHQSULQFLSHVXLYL
G·XQSKRQqPHFRQVRQDQWLTXHSRVVpGDQWXQWUDLWODELDO8QHFRQFOX
VLRQGpILQLWLYHQ·HVWQDWXUHOOHPHQWSDVSRVVLEOHFDU:X%=FL7768K%
HQGURLWQRWHUPPPDLQWHQXHQSRVLWLRQLPSORVLYHFRPPHGDQV
O·RVTXHI6>$#07%  >I$  (>&+#M56 RX (>&+ # M(5M ! (>&56%X%
U(>>56QRWpK:>!5L[  DGRQFUDLVRQG·pGLWHUK:>=@KG%
1!.%K:ɘ=@KG'HX[XVDJHVVHPEOHQWFRH[LVWHUɘ OHFWXUHGH-DQGD
KRUV7( HW>ࣹ@>J@ 7(HWSHXWrWUH$3¬ 1RWRQVTXH
0#O·pW\PRORJLHGH0DULQHWWLHVWH[DFWHDORUV 5DSSX\pSDU>
UpVLVWHjODSDODWDOLVDWLRQjODGLIIpUHQFHGH 5LQWHUYRFDOLTXHGDQV
č(5!)$!>! ( g c#)$!>!=A@B=: $3¬pJDOHPHQW 
RP
,OIDXGUDLWHQFRUHDGPHWWUHTXHO·DOORPRUSKH W‫ڨ‬UDYHFEUqYH HW
QRQ W‫گ‬U GXVXIIL[HDpWpJpQpUDOLVp VXUFHSRLQWYRLUO·DYLVGH
0HLVHU HWH[SOLTXHU<D= 1$TM=9!2%FL%U1$TM=9#"RXHQFRUH
U1$TMI!DYHFOHPrPHpOpPHQWTXHGDQVOHODWLQX1#II!2%>J%=7JM8J7%
SRXUUDLWTXHODODFXQHGLIILFLOHjHVWLPHUFRXYUHGHX[WURLVYRLUH
TXDWUHOHWWUHV O·LQVFULSWLRQVHPEOHDPRUFHUXQFRXGHjFHWHQGURLW
VLELHQTXHOHQRPEUHGHFDUDFWqUHVPDQTXDQWVQHGRLWSDVrWUHWUqV
pOHYp 0DOJUpO·DEVHQFHG·LQWHUSRQFWLRQLOQ·HVWSDVLOOpJLWLPHGH
VXSSRVHUXQHIURQWLqUHGHPRWVDSUqV<D=!SXLVTXHO·RQQHWURXYH
DXFXQHLQWHUSRQFWLRQHQWUH=G:=@%JK%KHGBK=9:G9XOHSDVVDJH
UHPDUTXDEOHGHODSUHPLqUHSHUVRQQHGXSOXULHO KHGBK=9:G jOD
SUHPLqUHGXVLQJXOLHU =R;&GA: LOVHUDLWFRQFHYDEOHTXHOHPRWRXWLO
SURFOLWLTXH<D=DLWSRXUU{OHG·LQGLTXHUOHGpEXWG·XQGLVFRXUVGLUHFW
DSSHOpSDUH=ARBK:VDIRQFWLRQVHUDLWDORUVFRPSDUDEOHDX#$#%96H9
NULWTXLOXLFO{WXUHXQHFLWDWLRQRXO·H[SUHVVLRQG·XQHSHQVpH/H
VXMHWLPSOLFLWHGHKHGBK=9:GIHUDLWLOUpIpUHQFHDX[PHPEUHVYLYDQWV
GHODOLJQpHGHVK( # !.##"&HVUpIOH[LRQVGRLYHQWLQpYLWDEOHPHQWUHVWHU
K\SRWKpWLTXHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% OPP

DXVVLLPSRUWDQWHTX·XQPRUSKqPHFDVXHORODJUDSKLHHVWHQJpQpUDOSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWFRQVHUYDWULFHjSOXV
IRUWHUDLVRQVLFHVpFDUWVFRQGXLVHQWjXQHDPELJXwWpIkFKHXVHTXLSRXUUDLWrWUH:(4#.!>!)$OHYpH,OQHVHUDLWSDV
OpJLWLPHG·LQYRTXHUFRPPHREMHFWLRQGHPpWKRGHOHVYDULDWLRQVJUDSKLTXHVTXHSUpVHQWHODGpVLQHQFHGHGDWLI
LVVXHGH !#GDQVOHV\QWDJPHODWLQ/1)6)!%7!#0I#$!#%A($-#!'·DERUGFHSRO\PRUSKLVPHWLHQWjO·H[LVWHQFHHQ
ODWLQG·XQHORQJXHWUDGLWLRQpSLJUDSKLTXHTXLMXVWLILHODFRQFXUUHQFHHQWUHJUDSKLHVKLVWRULTXHVHWJUDSKLHVLQQR
YDQWHV(QVXLWHOHODWLQQHSRVVpGDLWSDVGHJUDSKqPHVSpFLILTXHSRXUQRWHU̩DORUVTXHOHSLFpQLHQDODSRV
VLELOLWpG·RSSRVHU9!;!HW<!(QILQHWVXUWRXWDORUVTX·HQODWLQODGpVLQHQFHGHGDWLIDHIIHFWLYHPHQWFRQQX
VXFFHVVLYHPHQWGHVSKDVHVHLSXLV̩SXLVLQRWpHVUHVSHFWLYHPHQW!#!!!#! DYHFGHVSRVVLELOLWpV
GHJUDSKLHVLQYHUVHV QRXVQ·DYRQVDXFXQHSUHXYHTXHODWUDGLWLRQpSLJUDSKLTXHSLFpQLHQQHDLWFRQQXXQVWDGH
RODILQDOHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOpWDLWQRWpH;:!RX<:!,OQ·HVWGRQFSDVSRVVLEOHG·H[SOLTXHUOHVIOXFWXDWLRQV
HQTXHVWLRQHQUHFRXUDQWjO·K\SRWKqVHGHJUDSKLHVKLVWRULFLVDQWHV2QHVWGRQFHQGURLWG·DIILUPHUTXHSRXUOHV
JUDSKqPHV9!;!HW<!GXSLFpQLHQRQVHWURXYHHQVLWXDWLRQG·#)0U41-#$U%6-$+65-(I+#X1!%PLQLPDOH
(QUpDOLWpFRQWUDLUHPHQWjO·DYLVTXDVLXQDQLPHGHVH[pJqWHVLOQ·HVWSDVGXWRXWV€UTXH><@=EQ;:%JK%D;D;3
@<:¬VRLHQWGHVJpQLWLIVSOXULHOV1RXVSURSRVRQVGRQFGHUHSUHQGUHLFLO·DQDO\VHSKLORORJLTXHHWV\QWD[LTXHGHV
FRQWH[WHVRFHVIRUPHVDSSDUDLVVHQW

+@&?E?:=@B&DNAE9E9>AL<=&@9<O=K<
1F?G=@BKBA9@&H=&EXA@GIFADBA9@&,6&!S&=B&EXA@B=FDF?BKBA9@&H=&)AY
1RXVFRPPHQFHURQVSDUO·LQVFULSWLRQ&+¬EFDUFHOOHFLHVWFHQVpHOLYUHU"!1]IRUPHVGHJpQLWLISOXULHOHQ;:2%
:KF9;:%JK%Z<@=EQ;:,OV·DJLWGHO·LQVFULSWLRQODSOXVEUqYHGXJUDQGFLSSHGH&UHFFKLR/·LQLWLDOHGH><@=EQ;:&J9K%
HQGRPPDJpHPDLVODUHVWLWXWLRQGH<G·DLOOHXUVDFFHSWpHSDUWRXVVHMXVWLILHSDUO·DOOLWpUDWLRQTXLHVWV\VWpPD
WLTXHHQGHKRUVGXVHFRQGQRPSURSUHGBKBA=GRVRQDEVHQFHHVWH[FXVDEOH1RWRQVG·HPEOpHTX·HQUDLVRQGX
FDUDFWqUHPDQLIHVWHPHQWSRpWLTXHGXWH[WHTXHO·DOOLWpUDWLRQSHUPHWGHGpFHOHUO·pWXGHV\QWD[LTXHGHYUDWHQLU
FRPSWHGHODSRVVLELOLWpGH"#0c6)4$#6)0HWG·#)0!-$#6)0%I(-!)$+U$#X1!0GRQWRQDG·DLOOHXUVG·DXWUHVH[HPSOHVV€UVHQ
SLFpQLHQ/HWH[WHHVWOHVXLYDQW
:;F=AG&J&:KF9;:&J&Z<@=EQ;:J&<=EKA:=G&J&GBKBA=G&J&L9FK&J&RH<Q;
&RPPHO·DPRQWUp+HOPXW5L[GDQVXQHpWXGHTXLDIDLWGDWH  RH<Q;HQILQGHSKUDVHHVWXQHSUHPLqUH
SHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHUG·LQGLFDWLISUpVHQWDFWLIHWVLJQLILH´MHP·DSSHOOHµ*9FKTXLOHSUpFqGH¬HVWXQQRPLQDWLI
VLQJXOLHUIpPLQLQVLJQLILDQW´VWDWXHµ´PRQXPHQWµRX´HIILJLHµ+=EKA:=G&GBKBA=G&HVWXQHGpVLJQDWLRQG·KRPPH
DXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUTXLGpWHUPLQHL9FK';F=AGHQWrWHGHSKUDVHHVWXQDGMHFWLIDXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUPDVFXOLQ
DSSRVpj<=EKA:=G&GBKBA=GTXHVDSDUHQWpDYHFOHVHFRQGPHPEUHGXFRPSRVpJUHF์ࣹशۭ͘໅ࢆङ‫´ߥڗݰ‬IDPHX[SDUVD
ODQFHµDYHFOHJRWLTXH>!-c()´DQQRQFHUµHWDYHFOHVDQWKURSRQ\PHV9RONPčUGXYLHX[KDXWDOOHPDQGHW9ODGLP̍U࠽%
GXVODYHLQYLWHjFRPSUHQGUHFRPPH´IDPHX[FpOqEUH¬H[FHOOHQWpPLQHQWµ >6+_M-6RX >6+_M-# /DILQDOH=AG%
GH:;F=AG&J9K%LHJ%HFK6K8FH%:(100!>!)$DUFKDwVDQWH RQDXUDLWDWWHQGX =QGDYHFXQVHFRQGpOpPHQWGHGLSKWRQJXH
QRWpQ!HQV\OODEHILQDOH FHTXLLPSOLTXHTXHODGpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUD"UchpWpPRQRSKWRQJXpHFRPPH
O·DWWHVWHQWSUpFLVpPHQWOHVUHIOHWV=GGH !#0GDQV<=EKA:=G&JK&GBKBA=G'HX[K\SRWKqVHVVRQWjpFDUWHUG·XQHSDUW
<=EKA:=G&JK&GBKBA=GQHSHXYHQWSDVrWUHGHVQRPLQDWLIVVLQJXOLHUV FDURQDGpMjXQQRPLQDWLIL9FK2%JK%8>%HTJ9K%
JXqUHVDWLVIDLVDQWGHIDLUHGH<=EKA:=G&JK&GHGBKBA=GGHVDSSRVLWLRQVjFHVXEVWDQWLI HWG·DXWUHSDUWOHVILQDOHV


%3/N¬,: 'HVVDXQR :DUPLQJWRQ/HXPDQQ
%DUWRQ̍N

([SUHVVLRQHPSUXQWpHj%UL[KH  

6XUO·LQVFULSWLRQ7(¬WRXVOHVWHUPHVDOOLWqUHQWSDUSDLUHjO·H[FHS
WLRQGXSUHPLHUD9GBA@0DLVLOHVWUHPDUTXDEOHTXHOHVFRQVRQQHV
GHD9GBA@KRUPLVOH0LPSORVLIVRQWUHSULVHVGDQVFHWRUGUHSDUOH
GHUQLHUPRWO=D=B=@ I2%$2%) 6XUOHVHIIHWVSKRQLTXHVGDQVFHWWH
LQVFULSWLRQYRLU0DUW]ORII²

/KU  VpSDUHO·LUODQGDLVPiU´JUDQGµHWOHJDOORLV>(9-%
N8/<0 TXLVHUDLHQWLVVXVGH >!+nM-60DLV9LQH  
=F9J%U>6+_-6

%-J9%GF7MJ9%KDK=G0&¬HWD9:D;@A=G OHFWXUHLQFHUWDLQH 0&¬
VRQWGHVQRPLQDWLIVVLQJXOLHUV(QUHYDQFKHKEA=G7(¬KDA=G7(¬
GBKBA=G&+¬E BAB=G SRXU [B=BAGHUUHXUSUREDEOH 7(BF=S=>A=G%
7(¬<=EKA:=G&+¬EHWO=DG=G7(VRQWSRXUGHVUDLVRQVV\Q
WD[LTXHVFHUWDLQHPHQWGHVJpQLWLIVVLQJXOLHUVDYHFXQHDQFLHQQH
WHUPLQDLVRQ !#0PRQRSKWRQJXpH XQDXWUHSRLQWGHYXHDpWpIRU
PXOpSDU$JRVWLQLDQL &HWWHDQDO\VHHVWpJDOHPHQWSRVVLEOH
PDLVQRQFHUWDLQHSRXUA9FR=G&+¬D/DIRUPHN=FA=GGH$3VDQV
FRQWH[WHQ·HVWSDVH[SORLWDEOH3RXUODFRH[LVWHQFHGH=AG!HWGH
=G!HQ&+¬EODFRPSDUDLVRQW\SRORJLTXHDYHFOHODWLQ/1)6)!%
7!#0I#$!#%A($-#! DYHFIORWWHPHQWRUWKRJUDSKLTXHHQILQDOH HVWOLFLWH
 oi.uchicago.edu

:??% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

=GGHJpQLWLIQHSHXYHQWHQDXFXQFDVrWUHGHVWUDFHVGXJpQLWLIGHVWKqPHVFRQVRQDQWLTXHV !0 FDUODYR\HOOH

EUqYHDXUDLWpWpV\QFRSpH2QQHSHXWGRQFSDVIDLUHO·pFRQRPLHGHO·K\SRWKqVHG·XQHPRQRSKWRQJDLVRQGH !#0
5HVWHQWOHVGHX[WHUPHV:KF9;:%JK%<=EQ;:TXH5L[  LQWHUSUqWHFRPPHGHX[JpQLWLIVSOXULHOV
GpSHQGDQWGH:;F=AG&·HVWSUREDEOHPHQWYUDLSRXUFHTXLHVWQRWp:KF9;:!JpQLWLISOXULHOG·XQVXEVWDQWLI
DSSDUHQWpjO·pWUXVTXH>(-1%JK%6L%>6K8H%PDU‫گ‬2GRQWOHVHQVDSSUR[LPDWLIGRLWrWUH´FKHIPDJLVWUDWµ/DSUpVHQFH
GHFHPRWHQVXGSLFpQLHQVHPEOHLQILUPHUOHMXJHPHQWG·(QULFR&DPSDQLOHSRXUWDQWIRQGpVXUXQHFULWLTXH
UDLVRQQpHGHVDWWHVWDWLRQVDSSDUHQWHVGXPRWHQIDOLVTXH 9H HWHQVLFXOH¬ DVNRVGH&HQWXULSH ´QHOPRQGR
H[WUDHWUXVFRQRQVLKDQQRLQUHDOWjWUDFFHGLPDURQLDOGLIXRULGHOO·8PEULDµ  6LO·RQIDLWDEVWUDFWLRQ
GXPRWSRXUOHPRPHQWREVFXU<=EQ;:RQREWLHQWODWUDGXFWLRQSURYLVRLUH¬VXLYDQWH´-HVXLVMHVXLVQRPPp H 
ODVWDWXHGHT!.(#>0%7$($#0XQSHUVRQQDJHpPLQHQWSDUPLOHVFKHIVµ+HOPXW5L[YRLWHQ<=EQ;:XQJpQLWLISOXULHO
DSSRVpj:KF9;:HWGRQFDFFRUGpDYHFOXL,OV·DJLUDLWG·XQDGMHFWLIGpULYpG·XQWRSRQ\PHHQ  # '6
0DLVFHWWHDQDO\VHGH:KF9;:&<=EQ;:VHKHXUWHjGHVREMHFWLRQVLQVXUPRQWDEOHV(QSUHPLHUOLHXRQD
VXSSRVpXQHHUUHXUGDQV:KF9;:HQUDLVRQGHO·KLDWXVLQDWWHQGXHQWUH9HW;PDLVDXFXQHGHVFRUUHFWLRQV
DSSRUWpHVQ·HVWSOHLQHPHQWFRQYDLQFDQWH2QDDPHQGp [:KF9;:¬VRLW>@HQ :KF9@;: 0DULQHWWL 
VRLW>@HQ:KF;: 5L[[:KF;:GHYDQWOXLPrPHSURYHQLUGH:KF ;@ ;:&SDUSVHXGRKDSORJUDSKLH
VHORQOHWHUPHGH.HQW GDQVOHVGHX[FDVHQVXSSULPDQWOH9!VRLWHQFRUH>@HQ:KF;@9: :HLVV
Q /DVLPSOHUHVWLWXWLRQGH@GDQV :KF9@;:>@VHUDLWpFRQRPLTXHPDLVO·RQDWWHQGSRXUOHVXIIL[H
XQHIRUPH ‫گ‬QTXLDXUDLWpWpUHIOpWpHSDU;@ :KF;@;: 6LO·RQDGPHWWDLWODFRUUHFWLRQ>@OHPpFDQLVPH
GHODIDXWHVHUDLWULJRXUHXVHPHQWLQFRPSUpKHQVLEOH'·RYLHQGUDLWGRQFOH9!"7RXWHVVDLGHFRUUHFWLRQGRLW
SUpFLVpPHQWUHQGUHFRPSWHGHFH9!4XDQWj :KF;@9:>@FHWWHIRUPHHVWPRUSKRORJLTXHPHQWDFFHSWDEOH
PDLVLOIDXGUDLWVXSSRVHU"!1]HUUHXUVO·RPLVVLRQGH@!HWODSHUPXWDWLRQGHVOHWWUHVFHTXLHVWDVVH]GLIILFLOH
jDGPHWWUH(QVHFRQGOLHXOHQ!GH<=EQ;:QHSHXWSDVQRWHUOHUHIOHWGH\RGRXGH үEUHI'DQVRH<Q;GHOD
PrPHLQVFULSWLRQQ!HVWOHUHIOHWGH ̒ORQJ NOX̒‫' گ‬DQVCQBAKGGH$3¬HWGH5,OHUHIOHWGH #'HVWQRWpA!
'DQVWRXWHVOHVLQVFULSWLRQVSLFpQLHQQHVTXLSRVVqGHQWFHWWHOHWWUHKRUPLV&+Q!QRWHVRLWXQVHFRQGpOpPHQW
GHGLSKWRQJXHVRLWXQHYR\HOOHGHWLPEUH>̩@IHUPp ̩RX̩ (WGDQV&+R̩HW̩VRQWQRWpV=X2%
OHVFRQYHQWLRQVRUWKRJUDSKLTXHVVRQWHQWLqUHPHQWGLIIpUHQWHVGHFHOOHVGH&+¬E/DYDOHXUGHJOLGHG·DLOOHXUV
H[FHSWLRQQHOOHTX·DQ!GDQV9:SFAQ=@%JH%"(%:%);LPSOLTXHGRQFI(0TXHQ!MRXHXQU{OHGHFRQVRQQHHQ&+¬E
(QWURLVLqPHOLHXOHUDWWDFKHPHQWGH<=EQ;:%6L%KF=FHEMJ%T!.#(RXjO·K\GURQ\PHT!.#)10SURSRVpSDU5L[ 
 HVWFHUWHVFRQFHYDEOHPDLVGHWRXWHIDoRQLQYpULILDEOH/DFRPSDUDLVRQpJDOHPHQWLQYRTXpHSDUOHVDYDQW
DOOHPDQGDYHFOHVXEVWDQWLIRVTXHO=EEAK: &S9H ´?6.1)$($!>µQHFRQYDLQFSDVQRQSOXV1RXVUHFKHUFKH
URQVGRQFXQHpW\PRORJLHDOWHUQDWLYHSRXU<=EQ;:HQSURSRVDQWDXSUpDODEOHXQHQRXYHOOHDQDO\VHGHODILQDOH

(@KEPG=&9FBN9>FKDNAL<=&=B&:9FDN9E9>AL<=&H=&EK&CA@KE=&3Q;:&Z1!&GA@>[&DF?B?FAB&H=&GBKBAC\
/HVXGSLFpQLHQSRVVqGHXQSUpWpULWHQ;H[HPSOLILpSDUKH3GBKQ3;3N%JK%9DG3;3B2UOHWH[WHGH&+¬EFRQWLHQW
XQHSUHPLqUHSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHUGHO·LQGLFDWLISUpVHQWRH<Q;´MHPHQRPPHµROHQ!HVWOHUHIOHWGH ̒3DU
FRQVpTXHQWQRXVSURSRVRQVG·DQDO\VHU<=EQ;:FRPPHXQHIRUPHYHUEDOHpJDOHPHQWXQHSUHPLqUHSHUVRQQHGX
VLQJXOLHUG·XQLQGLFDWLII-U$U-#$DFWLIHQ;WLUpG·XQWKqPHHQ ̒GRQWOHVHQVUHVWHjSUpFLVHU(QWRXWFDVOD
ILQDOHQ;:HVWO·DYDWDUGH ̒RP3UpFLVRQVTXH;:Q·HVWSDVQpFHVVDLUHPHQWLFLOHSURGXLWI+6)U$#X1!GH ‫ڨ‬P%
HQILQDOH/DIHUPHWXUHVHORQXQSURFHVVXVSKRQpWLTXHGH 6HQ‫ۆ‬QRWp;!SHXWDYRLUHXOLHXXQLTXHPHQW
HQ3SOXU¬ 6)$! 6)"! ‫ ) ۆ‬+! ‫ۆ‬K !‫ ۆ‬QRWp;N!&HYRFDOLVPH‫  ۆ‬IHUPpDSXrWUHHQVXLWHpWHQGXDX
VLQJXOLHUjODWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQH 9DG3;3B%!.%:%JK%Z9@DG3;3L7( HWjODSUHPLqUH GDQV<=EQ3;3: )LQDOHPHQW
HWF·HVWXQSRLQWFDSLWDOQRWUHDQDO\VHGH<=EQ;:QHSURXYHUDLWQXOOHPHQWTXHFHTXLHVWQRWp;:VRLWOHSURGXLW
I+6)U$#X1!GH 6>ILQDOGHPRW(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHKHGBK=9:G &+¬D LOIDXWFRQVLGpUHURXELHQTXH6QHVH


1RXVGpYHORSSRQVODTXHVWLRQGDQV0DUW]ORII²6FKULM
YHU ² H[SOLTXHOXLDXVVLOHVILQDOHVGH<=EKA:=GHWGH
GBKBA=GjSDUWLUGH !#0WRXWHQHVWLPDQWTXHOHSURFHVVXVjO·±XYUH
GDQVO·pYROXWLRQ !#0!=GQ·HVWSDVXQHPRQRSKWRQJDLVRQ/·DXWHXU
SUpIqUHFRQVLGpUHUTXHOHVHFRQGpOpPHQWGHGLSKWRQJXHDpWpUpLQ
WHUSUpWpFRPPHXQ´DXWRPDWLVFKHU*OHLWODXWµSXLVVXSSULPp

6XUFHWHUPHYRLU/DVVqUH²

%-J%T!.#)10HVWFHUWHVSUpVHQWpFRPPHXQODFSLFpQLHQSDUO·O#0$6#-!%
B($1-!..!GH3OLQH #)%@#4!)6%.(41%T!.#)6%.#5)1>%"!#!4$1>%.(I#"!6%46-$#4!%
6&"14#$1-´GDQVOHODF9pOLQGX3LFpQXPXQPRUFHDXGHERLVMHWpGDQV
O·HDXVHFRXYUHG·XQHpFRUFHSLHUUHXVHµ,,WUDGXFWLRQGH%HDX
MHX PDLVVHORQ5DGNH @(1.'0%K!(.!)4'4.6Ia"#!%"!-%4.(00#04+!)%
<.$!-$1>09#00!)04+(:$2%_sL%O(.&&()"VY´YHOLQXVµFRO OHSDVVDJH
SRXUUDLWSUpVHQWHUXQHFRQIXVLRQ4XRLTX·LOHQVRLWOHWH[WHGH3OLQH
Q·HVWSDVVXVFHSWLEOHG·pFODLUHUOHPRWVXGSLFpQLHQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% :?O

IHUPHSDVVSRQWDQpPHQWGHYDQW >0VHFRQGDLUH LVVXGH >!0RXGH >60 HWTXHOHYRFDOLVPHGHODWHUPLQDLVRQ

GH3SOXUQ·DSDVSpQpWUpGDQVFHOOHGH3SOXU F·HVWODSRVLWLRQTXHQRXVSUpIpURQVDGRSWHU RXELHQTXH6
V·HVWFHUWHVIHUPpVSRQWDQpPHQWGHYDQW>0VHFRQGDLUHRXTXHOHYRFDOLVPHGHODWHUPLQDLVRQGH3SOXUDELHQ
SpQpWUpGDQVFHOOHGH3SOXUSDU()(.65#!PDLVTXH&+DIDLWXQXVDJHFDSULFLHX[HWLQFRQVWDQWGH;! FHWWH
K\SRWKqVHVHUDLWWRXWHIRLVpWD\pHSDUFHVHXOH[HPSOHjPRLQVTXHGDQV@9F9:!GH&+¬DQHVHFDFKHOHJpQLWLI
SOXULHOG·XQQRPHQ W‫گ‬UDYHFJpQpUDOLVDWLRQGHODORQJXHGXVXIIL[HPDLVFHODUHVWHWUqVLQFHUWDLQFDUULHQ
Q·HPSrFKHG·DGPHWWUHODJpQpUDOLVDWLRQGH W‫ڨ‬U (QWRXWFDVTXHOOHTXHVRLWO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQTX·LOIDLOOHUHWHQLU
SRXUODJUDSKLHKHGBK=9:G!OHVWHUPLQDLVRQV=9:G 3SOXU Q;N& 3SOXU HWQ;: 3VLQJ DSSDUWLHQQHQW
DXPrPHSDUDGLJPHGHSUpWpULWDFWLIGHVYHUEHVHQ̒
,OHVWGqVORUVDLVpG·DSSUpKHQGHUODJHQqVHGHODIRUPHpFULWH:KF9;:!,OV·DJLWELHQG·XQJpQLWLISOXULHO
PDLVG·XQQRP$+U>($#X1!HWQRQSDVG·XQWKqPHHQ)­O·LQVWDUGH5L[HWGH0DULQHWWLQRXVSURSRVRQVXQH
FRUUHFWLRQPDLVGLIIpUHQWHODLVVDQWDSSDUDvWUHOHPpFDQLVPHGHODIDXWH/DIRUPHDWWHQGXHHVW¬ :KF9:DYHF
93PDLVSDUXQHDQWLFLSDWLRQIDXWLYHGHODILQDOHGXYHUEHTXLVXLW<=EQ;:ROH;HVWMXVWLILpGXSRLQWGHYXH
PRUSKRORJLTXHXQ;DpWpLQWURGXLWDYDQWOH:G·R:KF9;:!

M67F ³ ~ ³M XHOt ³ ~ ³M
y \

,OV·DJLWG·XQHWpOpGLWWRJUDSKLHUpJUHVVLYHEDQDOHHQVRQSULQFLSH .HQW &·HVWGRQFOH;TXLHVWXQLQWUXV

HWQRQSDVOH9,OIDXWGRQFpFDUWHUFHTX·RQDFRQVLGpUpFRPPHOHVGHX[PHLOOHXUVH[HPSOHVGHJpQLWLIVSOXULHOV
HQ;:!GXVXGSLFpQLHQ(WQRXVJDJQRQVXQVSpFLPHQVXSSOpPHQWDLUHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOHQ9:G·XQQRPWKp
PDWLTXHJ%:KF9:'DQVXQDXWUHFDVHQFRUHOHVXGSLFpQLHQDWWHVWHODEDVHWKpPDWLTXH HQ 6 G·XQVXEVWDQWLI
H[LVWDQWjF{WpG·XQGpULYpHQ ‫گ‬QGHW\SHSURGXFWLI,OV·DJLWGXGDWLID=BF9N7(¬ G·XQWKqPH I!$-6 IRUPH
GHIRQGDWLRQGXQRPHQ ‫گ‬QVXSSRVpSDUD=BF;@AG$3¬1RXVGHYRQVWRXWHIRLVODLVVHURXYHUWHODTXHVWLRQGX
UDSSRUWPRUSKRORJLTXHH[DFWH[LVWDQWHQWUH:KF9:HWO·pWUXVTXH>(-16LODIRUPHVXGSLFpQLHQQHHVWELHQXQ
HPSUXQWjO·pWUXVTXH HPSUXQWGLUHFW"RXSDUO·LQWHUPpGLDLUHGXVDELQGHOD]RQHWLEpULQH" LOVHSHXWTXHOHPRW
SRXUXQHUDLVRQTXLQRXVpFKDSSHDLWpWpLQWpJUpDX[WKqPHVHQ6

2BP:9E9>A=&H=&]<^=EQ;:
/·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQDYDQFpHQHSRXUUDrWUHUHFHYDEOHTXHVLQRXVVRPPHVHQPHVXUHGHSURSRVHUXQHDQDO\VH
VpPDQWLTXHHWXQHpW\PRORJLHSODXVLEOHVSRXU<=EQ;:8QHSUHPLqUHK\SRWKqVHTXHQRXVIRUPXORQVSRXUO·pFDU
WHUFRQVLVWHUDLWjUDSSURFKHUOHYHUEHODWLQ1(..!0#$DPHQGpHQ1(..!00#$SDU/DFKPDQQ  TXLHVWJORVp
I!-#!-#$GDQV3)8QSDVVDJHG·$FFLXV *-(55LEEHFN FRQVHUYHUDLWSHXWrWUHXQHWUDFHVXSSOpPHQWDLUH
GXYHUEHHQTXHVWLRQI(00#>X1!%! ] %I-(!"(%I!41(%1(..!&()$%(5-#0´LOEHVWLDPHGHOODSURYHQLHQWHGDOODUD]]LDPRULYD
TXDHOjQHLFDPSLµ 1RVDUWL 'DQVFHFDV<=EQ;:VHUDLWOHWHUPHSURSUHSRXU´PRXULUµ%LHQTXHOH
VHQVOLWWpUDODLQVLREWHQXSRXU<=EQ;: ´MHVXLVPRUWµ FRQYLHQQHDVVH]ELHQDXFRQWH[WHTXLHVWFHUWDLQHPHQW
FHOXLG·XQHLQVFULSWLRQIXQpUDLUHRQUHFRQQDvWUDTX·LOPDQTXHVLQJXOLqUHPHQWGHSDQDFKH(QRXWUHRQLJQRUH
98%>J%1LQLWLDOGH1(..!00#$UHPRQWHjXQ 9LQGRHXURSpHQFHTXLSHUPHWWUDLWGHUDSSURFKHUODIDPLOOHGXYLHLO
LVODQGDLV?(.-´PRUWµ´ KpURV WRPEpVXUOHFKDPSGHEDWDLOOHµ /KU RXV·LOSURFqGHGH 592QSRXU
UDLWDORUVFRPSDUHUHQVXLYDQWOHGLFWLRQQDLUHGH:DOGHHWGH+RIPDQQO·LUODQGDLV($&(#..´LOPHXUWµ N8/<$
6FKXPDFKHU HWO·DOOHPDQGe1(.'·XQDXWUHF{WpPrPHVLO·RQDFFHSWDLWO·H[LVWHQFHG·XQHSDUHQWpHQWUH
?(.-%JK%1(..!00#$HOOHQ·LPSOLTXHUDLWSDVTXH<=EQ;:DSSDUWLHQQHjFHWWHIDPLOOH'HIDLWXQHDQDO\VHFRQFXUUHQWH
HWSUpIpUDEOHH[LVWHSRXUOHYHUEHSLFpQLHQ
1RXVUDWWDFKRQV<=EQ;:%6L%>6K8H%XDOH‫´گ‬rWUHIRUWrWUHELHQSRUWDQWSUpYDORLUrWUHHIILFDFHµGRQWRQFRQQDvW
SOXVLHXUVFRUUHVSRQGDQWVH[DFWVHQVDEHOOLTXH/DIRUPHRVTXHFǓड़͘¬DSSDUDvWGDQVXQHIRUPXOHGHVDOXWDWLRQ /X
9H ¬VXUXQHLQVFULSWLRQGHVHQVWUqVGLVFXWp YRLU3RFFHWWLHW/HMHXQHE /HYHUEH
HVWpJDOHPHQWDWWHVWpHQQRUGRVTXHSDU1(.# 09 /·LQVFULSWLRQ3J 9H SRUWHjODWURLVLqPHOLJQH+Z60@
I10%1(.Z#@! RX1(.Z!@! ,OV·DJLWSUREDEOHPHQWG·XQHDGUHVVHDXOHFWHXU ´+60I!0%?(.!µ ­FHWWHIDPLOOHDSSDU
K8JHHJHK%T(.!-#10 ¬ 9(.!0#'6 T6.10102%T6.!010 ¬ 9!.!06>"@ HWHQSpOLJQLHQ1(.!0#!0 3J¬9H¬D ,OIDXWDMRX


.OLQJHQVFKPLWW:HLVVQ:HLVV² 
9RLU-LPpQH]=DPXGLRHWVXUO·HQVHPEOHGHVIRUPHV
VDEHOOLTXHVFLWpHV*DUFtD&DVWLOOHUR²
 oi.uchicago.edu

:?:% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

WHUHQRVTXH1(.(!>6> 7% HWOKEKA:KG &S9H HQ±Q{WUHOHVDGMHFWLIV VXEVWDQWLYpV¬>"@ F‫ڗ‬ड़ǓԆۭ࿰ࢆ‫ߥڗ‬%

VXSHUODWLI HWF‫ڗ‬ड़‫ ߥڗ‬/D]]DULQLHW3RFFHWWL² HWHQSLFpQLHQSUpFLVpPHQWVXUQRWUHLQVFULSWLRQ&+¬E
O·DQWKURSRQ\PH<=EKA:=G/HODWLQDWWHVWHpJDOHPHQWOHQRP16.(!>1>G·XQH5-600!SRLUH´SRLUHYROqPHµ :HLVV
Q 
3RXUOHVHQVjGRQQHUj<=EQ;:OHFRQWH[WHGHO·LQVFULSWLRQSHUPHWDXPRLQVWURLVLQWHUSUpWDWLRQV2XELHQ
OHVHQVVHUDLWFHOXLGXODWLQXҸ[Ҹ´M·DLYpFXµHWGRQF´MHVXLVPRUWµVHQVTXLQHVXUSUHQGUDLWQXOOHPHQWGDQVO·pSL
JUDSKLHVXGSLFpQLHQQHHVVHQWLHOOHPHQWIXQpUDLUH2QSRXUUDLWDORUVWUDGXLUHO·HQVHPEOHHQUHQGDQW<=EQ;:%=67%
XQHLQFLVH´'·XQJUDQGSDUPLOHV>(-6³M·DLYpFX³GH9HODLPV6WDWLVMHVXLVOHPRQXPHQWµ&HWWHWUDGXFWLRQ
pFKDSSHDXUHSURFKHG·LQFRQJUXLWpTXHQRXVDYRQVpYRTXpjSURSRVGHO·pW\PRORJLHSDU1(..!00#$FDUELHQTX·LO
\DLWXQHOLWRWH ´M·DLYpFXµ౏´MHVXLVPRUWµ OHVFRQQRWDWLRQVDWWDFKpHVj<=EQ;:QHVRQWSDVGXWRXWOHVPrPHV
SXLVTXHOHVHQVIRQGDPHQWDOGHODUDFLQHpWDLW´rWUHGDQVVDIOHXUµ2XELHQOHYHUEHDFWXDOLVHUDLWXQVHQVSROLWLTXH
TX·RQUHWURXYHHQWRNKDULHQGDQV$9a.%9(.6´URLµHQLUODQGDLVGDQV:.(#$+´VRXYHUDLQHWpµ0DLVGDQVXQGRPDLQH
OLQJXLVWLTXHEHDXFRXSSOXVSURFKHHQFRUHGXSLFpQLHQTXHOHFHOWLTXHLOIDXWFLWHUOHVXSHUODWLI±Q{WUHF‫ڗ‬ड़ǓԆۭ࿰ࢆ‫ߥڗ‬
TXLSRXUUDLWELHQrWUHXQHGpVLJQDWLRQFRPSDUDEOHjFHOOHGXODWLQRSWLPčW̒V /D]]DULQLHW3RFFHWWL (Q
&+¬EFHVHQVVHUDLWDSSHOpSDU:KF9:&TXLSUpFqGHLPPpGLDWHPHQWHWIHUDLWUpIpUHQFHDX[pOLWHV´'·XQJUDQG
=67M8%>J9%>(-6³M·DLGpWHQXOHSRXYRLU³GH9HODLPV6WDWLVMHVXLVOHPRQXPHQWµ2XELHQ<=EQ;:IDLWUpIpUHQFH
jODYDOHXUJXHUULqUHGXSHUVRQQDJHFpOpEUpVHQVTXHMXVWLILHUDLW:;F=AG&TXLGRLWDSSDUWHQLUDXOH[LTXHKpURwTXH
´'·XQ KRPPH LOOXVWUHSDUPLOHV>(-6³M·DLpWpYDOHXUHX[³GH9HODLPV6WDWLVMHVXLVOHPRQXPHQWµ'DQVWRXV
OHVFDVODMX[WDSRVLWLRQVXU&+¬EGXYHUEH<=EQ;:¬HWGXQRPSURSUH<=EKA:=GFRQGXLWjXQUHQRXYHOOHPHQW
GHODPRWLYDWLRQVpPDQWLTXHGHFHWDQWKURSRQ\PHKLVWRULTXHPHQWDSSDUHQWpSDUUpDFWLYDWLRQGXVHQVpW\PR
ORJLTXH&·HVWXQFDVSDUWLFXOLHUG·DQWDQDFODVHDSSHOpDQQRPLQDWLRQXQHILJXUHGRQW:DWNLQVDVXGpFHOHUXQ
DXWUHH[HPSOHVXGSLFpQLHQHQ7(¬RB=BAG&V%KEA=G¬V·LQWHUSUqWHjODIRLVFRPPH´GH7LWXV$OLXVµHWFRPPH´GX
JpQLHGHVPkQHVG·XQDXWUHµ @?
,OUHVWHjUpVRXGUHOHSUREOqPHGXYRFDOLVPHUDGLFDO@O3RXUXQVWDWLIRQDWWHQGXQGHJUpUpGXLWUDGLFDOSUpFL
VpPHQWFRPPHGDQVOHODWLQXDOH‫گ‬TXLVXSSRVHXQWKqPH ZO + ૖ HK_M'!l6 0HLVHUN/T:S¬ 1RXVpFDU
WRQVUpVROXPHQWO·K\SRWKqVHG·XQHLQWURGXFWLRQ()(.65#X1!GH!GDQVOHUDGLFDOFDURQQHYRLWSDVTXHOOHVHUDLWOD
VRXUFHGHFHWUDQVIHUWHWOHUHFRXUVDXWKqPHIRUWG·XQpYHQWXHODRULVWHUDGLFDODRULVWHTX·RQDFKHUFKpjUHWURXYHU
GDQVOHQRPWRNKDULHQGX´URLµ %9(.6REOLTXHOčQW VHUDLWDVVH]VSpFXODWLI1RXVSHQVRQVDXFRQWUDLUHTXHOH
!UDGLFDOGH<=EQ;:%6%LHJ%F78I8HJ%I+6)U$#X1!HWTX·LOHVWG€DXFDUDFWqUHSDODWDOGXO UpDOLVp>O·@ FRQVpFXWLI
ZDO̒! ZDO̩! ZDO·̩! ZHO·̩ QRWp<=EQ! 
&HWWHK\SRWKqVHVHKHXUWHHQDSSDUHQFHjXQHREMHFWLRQLPPpGLDWHOHWLPEUHGHODYR\HOOHúEUqYHHVWVWDEOH
HQSLFpQLHQjSOXVIRUWHUDLVRQVRXVO·DFFHQWHQV\OODEHLQLWLDOH2QSRVVqGHPrPHXQH[HPSOHGHODVpTXHQFH
KEQ!GDQVKEQ@BA9:GH7(j3HQQD6$QGUHD(Q7(KEA=GUHIOqWH (.'!#0%FL%U(.#'!#08QpYHQWXHOSURWRW\SH
ZDO̩‫ۆ‬P SRXUOHTXHORQDWWHQGXQUHIOHWJUDSKLTXH <KEQ;:! ¬Q·DXUDLWSDUFRQVpTXHQWMDPDLVG€VHPEOH
WLOpYROXHUHQ<=EQ;:
3RXUWDQWFHWWHREMHFWLRQGHERQVHQVPpFRQQDvWXQHGRQQpHOLQJXLVWLTXHIRQGDPHQWDOHRQGLVSRVHHQHIIHW
G·XQLQGLFHFODLUVXJJpUDQWTX·j&UHFFKLRHWj&UHFFKLR0!1.!>!)$ODYDLWXQHUpDOLVDWLRQSDODWDOH2QVDLWTXH
GDQVOHUHVWHGXGRPDLQHSLFpQLHQ .LQLWLDODpWpYpODULVpHQ9 .! ‫!ן‬9 FRPPHOHPRQWUHOHQRPGHOD
´SLHUUHWRPEDOHµO=D=BQ0&¬<=D=BQ@0&¬O=D=B=@7(¬¬HW<=D=BQ>5,¬2UVXUO·LQVFULSWLRQ&+¬DpFULWHVXU
>J%>z>!VXSSRUWTXH&+¬ERQOLWA=D=B=@DYHF\RGLQLWLDO1RQVHXOHPHQWODOHFWXUHA=D=B=@HVWLQGXELWDEOHG·XQ
SRLQWGHYXHSDOpRJUDSKLTXHPDLVLOQHSHXWV·DJLUG·XQHHUUHXUFDUA=D=B=@DOOLWqUHDYHFA9FR=G,OIDXWGRQF
FRQFOXUHTX·j&UHFFKLROHVWSDODWDOLVpHQ>O·@HWTXHVLjO·LQLWLDOH>O·@SDODWDOYDMXVTX·jUHMRLQGUH\ jFRXS
V€UGDQVA=D=B=@HWSUREDEOHPHQWGDQVA9RAD=H<GRQWOHSUHPLHUPHPEUHGRLWrWUHDSSDUHQWpDXODWLQOࡃFXV%JK%
DXSDOpRYROVTXHA;R;N%FL%A;R;Q@:90¬ jO·LQWHUYRFDOLTXHHQUHYDQFKHFH>O·@SURYRTXHODPpWDSKRQLHG·XQD
SUpFpGHQWHQ> @ RXPrPHHQ>H@ QRWp=!&·HVWMXVWHPHQWOHFDVGDQV<=EQ;:@Q,OH[LVWHG·DLOOHXUVGDQVOHFRUSXV
SLFpQLHQXQDXWUHFDVYUDLVHPEODEOHG·DOWpUDWLRQGXWLPEUH>D@SDU:-6)$#)5VRXVO·HIIHWG·XQSKRQqPHFRQVpFXWLI

@?
:DWNLQVQ0DUW]ORII @:
&RPPHO·RQWVRXOLJQp5RFFD  HW0DJJLDQL  OD
@O
/DTXHVWLRQQHVHSRVHSDVGHIDoRQDXVVLDLJXsSRXU<=EKA:=GFDU OHFWXUHODSOXVSUREDEOHSRXUOHVLJQHHQIRUPHGHFDUUpjFORLVRQ
LOV·DJLWG·XQHIRUPDWLRQQRPLQDOHTXLHQWDQWTXHWHOOHGRLWrWUH LQWpULHXUHHVWQ!
WUDLWpHVpSDUpPHQW @Q
,OIDXWDEDQGRQQHUO·K\SRWKqVHGH*HUW.OLQJHQVFKPLWW 
Q TXLVDQVPHQWLRQQHUG·DLOOHXUVODIRUPHA=D=B=@2%=F9J%LH%U9M%
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% :?Q

,OV·DJLWGHHARH=A@B=:VLFHWWHIRUPHUHIOqWHELHQOHV\QWDJPH GLNHOčDJHQWHPXQLYHUEpSDUVDQGKL (5;!)$!>%X%

UDࣹ·HQWHP%X%U(c!)$!>TXLpYROXHHQVXLWHRXELHQHQ !c ! )$!> DYHFV\QFRSH RXELHQHQ !c#)$!> DYHFIHUPHWXUH
GX!PpGLDQVRXVO·HIIHWGHc G·R=A@B=:)LQDOHPHQWGHUULqUHOHYRLOHGHVpYROXWLRQVSKRQpWLTXHVOHVXG
SLFpQLHQ<=EQ;:&SRVVqGHH[DFWHPHQWOHPrPHWKqPHYHUEDOGHSUpVHQWTXHOHODWLQXDOH‫گ‬
/DFRUUHFWLRQ :KF9:HWQRWUHDQDO\VHGH<=EQ;:SUpVHQWHUDLHQWHQRXWUHO·DYDQWDJHGHSHUPHWWUHOHUDS
SURFKHPHQWSRXUODIDFWXUHSRpWLTXHGH&+EHWG·XQHDXWUHLQVFULSWLRQSLFpQLHQQH0&¬KDK=G&L<DKB&=G:Q@&
D;D;@AG&@QF&:=CAQ@&O=AKB&O=D=BQ´&LJvW XQ (I(!0XQSULQFH%IwIw)#0_ TX· LOUHSRVHDXPLOLHXGHODWRPEHµ
/DFRQVWUXFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHGH0&¬HVWVXUSUHQDQWHHQFHTXH=G:Q@%JK%O=D=BQ&9JMD>JHK&GF7MJ7%LH%9EHK6IMJ%
GLVMRLQWVLELHQTXH0&¬QHGRLWFRQVWLWXHUTX·XQHVHXOHSKUDVHDYHFGHX[YHUEHV!)%(0')"E$! L<DKB&JK&O=AKB 
FRPPHF·HVWMXVWHPHQWOHFDVGDQV&+¬EDYHF<=EQ;:%JK%RH<Q;(QRXWUHSXLVTXHODVpTXHQFHpFULWH:KF9;:X%
HVWHQIDLWGLVV\OODELTXHRQREWLHQWXQHFRORPpWULHFRPSDUDEOHHQWURLVPHPEUHVGDQVXQFDVGDQV
O·DXWUH

% :;F=AG&:KF9:&<=EQ;:% <=EKA:=G& GBKBA=G&L9FK&RH<Q;

 V\OODEHV V\OODEHV V\OODEHV
 >VpTXHQFH$@% >VpTXHQFH%@ >VpTXHQFH&@
& KDK=G&L<DKBHVPtQ S~S~QLVQtU PHÀtQO=AKB&O=D=BQ
 V\OODEHV V\OODEHV V\OODEHV
 >VpTXHQFH$@% >VpTXHQFH%@ >VpTXHQFH&@

1RWRQVTXHOHWH[WHGH0&HVWGDYDQWDJHIRQGpVXUOD0'>U$-#! $?!-010&OHYHUEHRFFXSDQWOD
PrPHSRVLWLRQFHQWUDOHHQ$HWHQ& WDQGLVTXH&+¬EHVWVWUXFWXUpVHORQXQSDUDOOpOLVPH $?!-010&
OHVPRWVpWDQWUDQJpVVXLYDQWXQYROXPHV\OODELTXHFURLVVDQWDYHFOHYHUEHHQILQGHJURXSH@< 1DWXUHOOHPHQWh%
01II60!-%X1!&+¬EVRLW´PpWULTXHµRQSRXUUDLWHQWKpRULHDXVVLVHJPHQWHUHQ6XUWRXWHWF·HVWOjOHSRLQW
FRPPXQOHSOXVIUDSSDQWGDQVOHVGHX[LQVFULSWLRQVRQFRQVWDWHODSUpVHQFHG·XQV\QWDJPHQRPLQDOjFKHYDO
VXUOHVGHX[VpTXHQFHVSpULSKpULTXHV$HW&=G:Q@&T&_:=CAQ@&T&O=D=BQ`DXORFDWLI:;F=AG&T&<=EKA:=G%GBKBA=G%
DXJpQLWLIO·XQGHVpOpPHQWVILJXUDQWDXVVLHQ%GDQVFHGHUQLHUFDV/DWHFKQLTXHGHFRPSRVLWLRQGHFKDFXQGH
FHVGHX[WH[WHVSUpVHQWHGRQFSDUDGR[DOHPHQWVLQRQXQFRQIOLWGXPRLQVXQHIRUWHWHQVLRQHQWUHFRKpVLRQ
WH[WXHOOHHWFRKpUHQFHV\QWD[LTXH

)=B9<F&`&EK&DF9SE?:KBAL<=&H<&>?@ABAC&DE<FA=E
'AG=&=@&L<=GBA9@&H=&EX=YAGB=@I=U&=@&G<H3DAI?@A=@U&H=&>?@ABACG&DE<FA=EG&=@&3<:&=B&=@&3;:
2QSHXWPDLQWHQDQWUHSUHQGUHODSUREOpPDWLTXHGXJpQLWLISOXULHOVXUGHQRXYHOOHVEDVHVHQPRQWUDQWTXH
D;D;@<:GH$3EFRQWUDLUHPHQWjO·RSLQLRQUHoXHQ·HVWSDVQRQSOXVXQJpQLWLISOXULHOPDLVXQDFFXVDWLIVLQ
JXOLHU/DVpTXHQFHD;D;@<:&=GB<CR&KDKA;G&KHGBKQ;N&G;KQG&:K@<G&:=ABA:;:HVWJpQpUDOHPHQWWUDGXLWH´/HV
KDKA;G&GHVD;D;@<:&RQWLFLpOHYp>OHFLSSH@GHOHXUVPDLQVFRPPHSUpVHQWµ1RXVLJQRURQVOHVVHQVH[DFWVGH
KDKA;G&HWGHD;D;@<:@R/·LQVFULSWLRQ0& RILJXUHG·DLOOHXUVXQWKqPHHQ  # '6D;D;@AG QHSHUPHWSDV
GHFRQFOXUHTXHKDKA;G&GpVLJQHXQVRXVHQVHPEOHGHVD;D;@<:,OHVWSUpIpUDEOHGHFRQVLGpUHUTXHD;D;@<:%
HVWXQDFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHUDWWULEXWGHO·REMHW:=ABA:;:RXTXH:=ABA:;:HVWO·DWWULEXWGHO·REMHWD;D;@<:N%
´/HVKDKA;G&RQWLFLpOHYpOHD;D;@<:&GHOHXUVPDLQVFRPPHSUpVHQWµ/HFLSSHTXLHVWOHSUpVHQWDpWppOHYp
=FL7%-!I-U0!)$!-%>J%D;D;@<:HQHIILJLH&RPPH(LFKQHUO·DELHQYXjSURSRVGH7(¬LO\DHQ$3(00#>#.($#6)%

pW\PRORJLTXHHWFRPSDUHO=D=B=@DXYpGLTXHYiSUD´(UGDXIZXUIµ
­ODGLIIpUHQFHGXWRNKDULHQ%OHSLFpQLHQGH&UHFFKLRQHFRQQDvW
SUREDEOHPHQWSDVGHORL 9! 'GHYDQWYR\HOOHDQWpULHXUHHWO·LGpH
IRUPXOpHSDU(LFKQHU Q G·XQHDOWpUDWLRQGHO·LQLWLDOH
GHA=D=B=@G·DSUqVOHPRWA9FR=GTXLSUpFqGHHVWHQWLqUHPHQWDUEL
WUDLUHeWUDQJHPHQW(LFKQHUDGPHWSRXUWDQWHWFHODjMXVWHWLWUHXQH
pYROXWLRQ .!'j&UHFFKLRSXLVTX·LOUDPqQHA9FR=Gj .6-5!#0 YLVO
.1-=-´.QWWHOµ PDLVFHWWHGHUQLqUHpW\PRORJLHHVWFRQWHVWDEOHDORUV
TXHSDUDGR[DOHPHQW(LFKQHUUHMHWWHOHVHXOH[HPSOHLQDWWDTXDEOHj
O·DSSXLGHFHWWHORLjVDYRLUA=D=B=@
@<
6XUODORLGHVPHPEUHVFURLVVDQWVYRLU%HKDJHO
@R
%$L7%KDKA;GYRLU0DULQHWWL,OQ·HVWSDVGpPRQWUDEOHPDOJUp
OHVDOOpJDWLRQVG·(LFKQHU Q TXHD;D;@AG%JK%D;D;@<:%
VLJQLILHQW´SLFpQLHQµHWVRLHQWJpQpWLTXHPHQWDSSDUHQWpVjO·DOOH
PDQG7I!4+$´SLYHUWµTX·LOIDXGUDLWDORUVVpSDUHUGHSҸFXV´SLYHUWµ
&RPPHO·REVHUYH/D5HJLQD  D;D;@AG%JK%D;D;@<:%HJ%
VRQWSDVQpFHVVDLUHPHQWGHVJHQWLOLFHV

$LQVLTXHO·pFULW(LFKQHU  ´'HU*HHKUWHVWHKWKLHUJOHLFK
96M%#)%I!-06)(DOV'HQNPDOYRUXQVµ&RPPHSDUDOOqOHODWLQRQFLWHUD
+RUDFHTXLV·DGUHVVHDLQVLj9pQXV$!%d%I6)!$%>(->6-!(>´LOWHGUHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

:?<% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

"1%4#II!%(1%"U:1)$ FHTXLH[SOLTXHpJDOHPHQWTXHVXU&+¬EDXVHLQG·XQHPrPHSKUDVHODSUHPLqUHSHUVRQQH
GH<=EQ;:IDVVHUpIpUHQFHDXSHUVRQQDJHQRPPpDXJpQLWLI<=EKA:=G%GBKBA=GWDQGLVTXHODSUHPLqUHSHUVRQQH
GHRH<Q;&9J%76==F7KJ%6L%MFHLMJHK%=67>6HK2%L9FK 7RXWFRPPHD;D;@AGpSLWKqWHGH@QF%JH%0"%O2%9J%76==F7KJ%
FODLUHPHQWDXGpIXQWOHSHUVRQQDJHDSSHOpD;D;@<:&HQ$3HVWLGHQWLILpDXFLSSHOXLPrPHGpVLJQpFRPPHXQ
SUpVHQW :=ABA:;:WHUPHTX·(LFKQHUDUDSSURFKpGXJRWLTXH>(#å>0 PrPHVLOHFLSSHGH&DVWLJQDQR$3Q·D
SDVXQFDUDFWqUHDXVVLQHWWHPHQWKXPDQRwGHTXHFHOXLGH3HQQD6$QGUHD 7( /·LQWXLWLRQG·(LFKQHUUHFHYUDLW
XQHFRQILUPDWLRQVXSSOpPHQWDLUHVLQ:AN $3D pWDLWELHQDSSDUHQWpDXODWLQLPčJ‫ گ‬WKqPH +n#>M#@@ DXTXHOFDV
L9E9CQB;F&V%Q:ANVLJQLILHUDLW´LOV·pOqYH«FRPPHUHSUpVHQWDWLRQµ,OHVWGLIILFLOHGHSUpFLVHUOHUDSSRUWTXLXQLWOH
SqUHHWODPqUH :KB=F=QN&DKB=F=QN G·XQF{WpHWOHSHUVRQQDJHQRPPpD;D;@<:GHO·DXWUH6·DJLWLOG·XQOLHQ
GHILOLDWLRQKXPDLQH"0DLVO·RQDUpFHPPHQWSURSRVpGHYRLUHQ:KB=F=QN&DKB=F=QNXQFRXSOHGHGLYLQLWpV@P%*>%
IDXWHQIDLWVHUpVLJQHUjODLVVHUHQVXVSHQVWRXWHWHQWDWLYHGHUHVWLWXWLRQGXFRQWH[WHTXLDYXODJHQqVHGXFLSSH
$3HWGHO·LQVFULSWLRQTX·LOSRUWH
'DQVOHFDGUHGHO·K\SRWKqVHGpIHQGXHLFL$3¬ESUpVHQWHH[DFWHPHQWOHPrPHVFKqPHGHFRPSRVLWLRQTXH
OHGpEXWGH7(RODVpTXHQFHɍLGRPVDILQ~VHVWXIHɍHOVtWWtRPVLJQLILH´/HV6DELQVWHGUHVVHQWLFLHQFHFLµ
´/HV6DELQVGUHVVHQWLFLFHFLTXLHVWWRLµ/HSURQRPSHUVRQQHOGHGHX[LqPHSHUVRQQHBQ9:&HVWO·DWWULEXWGH
O·REMHWFRQVWLWXpSDUOHGpPRQVWUDWLIɍLGRP RXɍLGRPHVWO·DWWULEXWGHO·REMHWBQ9: /HSDUDOOpOLVPHV\QWD[LTXH
HWVpPDQWLTXHHVWUHSUpVHQWpSDUOHWDEOHDXVXLYDQW

71c!$ ´GUHVVHUµ <$$-#&1$ ,&c!$

<@%n KDKA;G KHGBKQ;N& :=ABA:;:% D;D;@<:& OHGpIXQW
*8%s VDÀQ~V HɍHOVtW ɍLGRP´FHFLµ BQ9:´WRLµ OHGpIXQW

-6%"#0c6)4$#6)GHSDUWHWG·DXWUHGHODSURSRVLWLRQGHO·REMHWHWGHVRQDWWULEXW ɍLGRPVBQ9:2%D;D;@<::=ABA3
:;: HVWXQWUDLWVW\OLVWLTXHFRPPXQ/·H[SUHVVLRQGHODGpL[LVDXPR\HQGH=GB<CHWGH=GB<CRHVWLGHQWLTXH
/DWHFKQLTXHGHFRPSRVLWLRQHVWODPrPH
'XSRLQWGHYXHIRUPHOGHX[DQDO\VHVVRQWSRVVLEOHVSRXUD;D;@<:2XELHQODJUDSKLHD;D;@<:¬DYHF
<:!HVWOHIUXLWG·XQHQpJOLJHQFHYpQLHOOHSDURPLVVLRQGHODKDVWHFHQWUDOHGH;X2%=FL7%D;D;@;:DYHFWURLV
;aHWO·RQREWLHQGUDLWDORUVSDUXQHFRUUHFWLRQVLPSOHXQDFFXVDWLIHQ;:QRUPDOG·XQWKqPHHQ 6 QRQHQ
 # '6FRPPHD;D;@AG 2XELHQVLO·RQDGPHWWDLWTXHOHVXGSLFpQLHQQHSRVVqGHTXH"!1]GHJUpVG·DSHUWXUH
SRXUOHVYR\HOOHVSRVWpULHXUHVR  RXYHUWHW‫  ۆ‬IHUPpQRWpVUHVSHFWLYHPHQW9!HW;! VLELHQTXH‫  ۆ‬
IHUPpSHXWrWUHUpDOLVp>X  @  WDQGLVTXH<!QRWHXQHYR\HOOH()$U-#!1-!DUURQGLH   VXVFHSWLEOHG·rWUH
UpDOLVpH>8  @RX>8X  @DYHFDWWDTXHSDODWDOH LOVHUDLWFRQFHYDEOHTXHD;D;@<:&VRLWXQWKqPHHQ  # '6H[DF
WHPHQWFRPPHD;D;@AGHWTXHODVpTXHQFHELSKRQpPDWLTXH\‫ ۆ‬GHQ\‫ۆ‬P UpDOLVpH>\X@DLWpWpQRWpHSDU<X%
JUDSKqPHQRUPDOHPHQWUpVHUYpjODQRWDWLRQGHODVpTXHQFHPRQRSKRQpPDWLTXH  UpDOLVpH> 8X  @ HQUDLVRQ
GHODSUR[LPLWpDFRXVWLTXHGXSKRQqPH\RGHWGHO·DWWDTXHSDODWDOHDVVRFLpHj  $LQVLD;D;@<:X%6L768K%
GRQFpWpVHQWLFRPPHOHTXDVLpTXLYDOHQWGHODJUDSKLH D;D;@A;:!3RXUFHODLOIDXWHWLOVXIILWGHVXSSRVHUTXH
GDQVOHXUVUpDOLVDWLRQVSKRQpWLTXHVFRQFUqWHV‫ۆ‬IHUPpHWDYDLHQWOHPrPHGHJUpG·DSHUWXUHVDQVc(>(#0%9J%
FRQIRQGUHSRXUWDQWSXLVTXHpWDLWSURQRQFpjO·DYDQW RXDYDLWXQHDWWDTXHSDODWDOH WDQGLVTXH‫ۆ‬IHUPp
pWDLWSURQRQFpjO·DUULqUHHWQHFRPSRUWDLWSDVG·DWWDTXHSDODWDOH8QDUJXPHQWHQIDYHXUG·XQHWHOOHDQDO\VH
9J768K%GFL7H8%=67%D=BA=F9@AG $3¬ GRQWOHSUHPLHUA!QHVHUDLWSDVXQHHUUHXU PDOJUp5L[ PDLVOD
WUDFHJUDSKLTXHGHO·DWWDTXHSDODWDOHGHODYR\HOOHG·DQDSW\[H>H@DXWUHPHQWGLWXQHYR\HOOHSRXUYXHG·DWWDTXH
SDODWDOHSHXWrWUHWUDLWpHGDQVODJUDSKLH46>>!XQHVpTXHQFHELSKRQpPDWLTXHFHTXLRXYUHODSRVVLELOLWpTX·XQH
VpTXHQFHELSKRQpPDWLTXHVRLWWUDLWpHGDQVODJUDSKLH46>>!XQHVpTXHQFHPRQRSKRQpPDWLTXH&HWWHK\SRWKqVH

VHUDGHPDUEUHµ ,"!0² /DVWDWXHVHQVLEOHDX[RGHXUV #..#4% GXILOVG·XQHIDPLOOHGHOHXUFRPPXQDXWpWRPEpDXFRPEDWHQGH

I.1-#>(%)(-#&10%"14!0%$1-( HVWSOHLQHPHQWDVVLPLOpHjODGpHVVH
@@
,OIDXGUDLWFRPSDUHUOHKLWWLWH+#>>(´VXEVWLWXWµ 0DUW]ORII
² %LHQTXHQRWUHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQDLWpWpDFFHSWpHSDU('XSUD]
 QRXVUHVWRQVFRQVFLHQWTXHG·DXWUHVpW\PRORJLHVVRQW
FRQFHYDEOHVSRXUFHPRW

 6·LO IDOODLW ULVTXHU XQH K\SRWKqVH LQWHUSUpWDWLYH LO VHUDLW SDU
H[HPSOHORLVLEOHG·LPDJLQHUTXHOHVKDKA;GSRXUFpOpEUHUODPpPRLUH
JORULHXVHVFLUFRQVWDQFHVRQWGUHVVpHQVLJQHGHUHFRQQDLVVDQFHXQ
PRQXPHQWHQO·KRQQHXUGHVSDUHQWVTXLOXLRQWGRQQpOHMRXU
@P
1RXVUHQYR\RQVjO·DUJXPHQWDWLRQGH&DSGHYLOOH ² 

/DWHQGDQFHVSRQWDQpHjXQHUpDOLVDWLRQWUqVIHUPpHYLVDLWjDF
FURvWUHODPDUJHGHVpFXULWpHQWUHOHVGHX[GHJUpVG·DSHUWXUHGHV
YR\HOOHVG·DUULqUH

/DOHFWXUHD=BA=F9@AG!Q·HVWWRXWHIRLVSDVHQWLqUHPHQWV€UH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% :?R

TXLQ·HVWFRPSOH[HTX·HQDSSDUHQFHSUpVHQWHUDLWXQGRXEOHDYDQWDJH  UDPHQHUD;D;@AG&JK%D;D;@<:jXQ
VHXOSDUDGLJPHFHOXLG·XQWKqPHHQ  # '6HW  GLVSHQVHUGHO·K\SRWKqVHG·XQHHUUHXUPrPHEDQDOHFHOOHGH
O·HPSORLGH<!SRXU;!2QIHUDLWPrPHO·pFRQRPLHGH"!1]HUUHXUVSXLVTXHOHVJUDSKLHVD=BA=F9@AG!HWD;D;3
@<:!FRQVWLWXHUDLHQWHQIDLWO·HQYHUVHWOHUHYHUVG·XQPrPHSURFpGpRUWKRJUDSKLTXH1RWRQVWRXWHIRLVTXHVL
FHWWHGpVLQHQFH@<:!UHQGDLWELHQQ\‫ۆ‬PLOIDXGUDLWDGPHWWUHTXHQ\‫ۆ‬PHVWXQHUpIHFWLRQGH )#>DYHF
V\QFRSHDWWHQGXH RVTXHDKRA:&S¬9H¬RPEULHQDɂNDQLGH ("M=()M'6M> DORUVTX·XQWHOUHPDQLHPHQWQ·D
SDVHXOLHXGDQV9CB9FA: &+¬D 1RXVQ·LQVLVWRQVSDVVXUFHWWHDQDO\VHPDLVLOpWDLWQpFHVVDLUHGHODIRUPXOHU
SRXUHQH[SORUHUOHVSURILWVHWOHVOLPLWHV
/·DQDO\VHGHD;D;@<:!FRPPHDFFXVDWLIQ·HVWSDVVDQVFRQVpTXHQFHSRXUFHOOHGHD<QNTXLILJXUHVXUOD
PrPHLQVFULSWLRQSXLVTXH<:!QHUHPSODFHSDV9:! DWWHQGXDXJpQLWLISOXULHO RQQ·HVWSDVHQGURLWGH
FRQVLGpUHUTXH<!V·HVWVXEVWLWXpDUELWUDLUHPHQWj9!GDQVD<QNTXLGHFHIDLWQHSHXWSDVV·DQDO\VHUFRPPHOH
QRPLQDWLIG·XQSURQRPUHODWLI,OV·DJLWSUREDEOHPHQWG·XQDGYHUEHVLJQLILDQW´HQWRXWHSLpWpµUHIOHWSKRQpWLTXH
GH Sࡃ\̒GFRPPHO·DSURSRVp$GLHJR/DMDUD  
(QRXWUHWRXVOHVH[HPSOHVDOOpJXpVGHJpQLWLIVSOXULHOVHQ;:VRQWKDXWHPHQWLQFHUWDLQV&HODYDXWSRXUOD
VpTXHQFHGKCA@;:&@=FCGHO·LQVFULSWLRQIUDJPHQWDLUH7(
@@AGJ&GKCA@;:J&@=FCJ&D=FG<RK@BJ&D>
,OQ·H[LVWHSDVG·LQGLFHSRVLWLITXLSRUWHjSHQVHUTXHGKCA@;:VRLWXQJpQLWLISOXULHOHW0HLVHUDH[SULPpGHV
GRXWHVMXVWLILpVjFHSURSRV%%KCA@;:¬SRXUUDLWrWUHSDUH[HPSOHO·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHUG·XQVXEVWDQWLISUHPLHU
RXVHFRQGDFWDQWDXVHLQG·XQHSURSRVLWLRQLQILQLWLYHGpSHQGDQWGXYHUEHLQWURGXFWHXUD=FG<RK@B0DLVGKCA@;:%
SRXUUDLWDXVVLrWUHXQDGMHFWLIGpWHUPLQDQWXQVXEVWDQWLIGLVSDUX(QUDLVRQGXFRQWH[WHODFXQDLUHLOQHQRXVSDUDvW
SDVSRVVLEOHG·DIILQHUO·DQDO\VH1RXVWHQLRQVVLPSOHPHQWjVXJJpUHUTX·LOH[LVWHGHVDOWHUQDWLYHVjO·K\SRWKqVH
GXJpQLWLISOXULHOPrPHVLFHWWHGHUQLqUHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQUHVWHSRVVLEOHDXTXHOFDVGKCA@;:VHUDLWOHFRPSOpPHQW
GXQRP@=FC
(QILQO·LQVFULSWLRQ$3¬QHFRQWLHQWDSSDUHPPHQWSDVGHYHUEHHWVDV\QWD[HHVWGHVSOXVRSDTXHV3HXWrWUH
IDXWLOVRXVHQWHQGUHXQYHUEHGXW\SH´DLQKXPpµRX´DKRQRUpµ(QWRXWFDVO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHVIRUPHVFKA=A3
:;:2&BAB;:2&K@KA;:%FL%K;HKL;:SDUOHJpQLWLIQHVHMXVWLILHSDVPLHX[TXHFHOOHSDUO·DFFXVDWLI

-AGI<GGA9@&IFABAL<=&H=&EXK@KEPG=&H=&'AINK=E&b=AGG
1RXVDYRQVYXTXHO·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHUGHVVXEVWDQWLIVWKpPDWLTXHVHVWWRXMRXUVHQ;:HWIDLWQRXYHDXTXH
OHSLFpQLHQGLVSRVHSRXUOHJpQLWLISOXULHOG·XQHVHXOHGpVLQHQFHYLYDQWH9:,OUHVWHjH[SOLTXHUO·RULJLQHGH
FHVILQDOHV/DVHXOHGLVFXVVLRQV\VWpPDWLTXHHVWO·LPSRUWDQWHpWXGHGH0LFKDHO:HLVV  3RXUO·DQDO\VHV\Q
FKURQLTXH:HLVVFRQVLGqUH  TXH9:HVWODGpVLQHQFHQRUPDOHGHJpQLWLISOXULHO  TXHOHSLFpQLHQSRVVqGH
pJDOHPHQWXQHGpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOHQ;:_  TXHODGpVLQHQFH;:GHJpQLWLISOXULHOHVWQpHGDQVOHV
QRPVWKpPDWLTXHVGHO·DQDORJLH5-(I+#X1!GXQRPLQDWLISOXULHOHQ;G_  TXHD;D;@<:HVWXQJpQLWLISOXULHO  
TXHODGpVLQHQFH<:GHD;D;@<:HVWXQHHUUHXUSRXU;:1RXVDYRQVDGPLVODWKqVH  HWFRQWHVWpOHVSRLQWV
 HW  /·K\SRWKqVH  QRXVVHPEOHLQXWLOH1RXVDYRQVHQYLVDJpXQHDOWHUQDWLYHSRXU  PDLVXQHVLPSOH
HUUHXUUHVWHSRVVLEOH
3RXUO·DQDO\VHGLDFKURQLTXH:HLVVFRQVLGqUH  TXHOHUHIOHWVXGSLFpQLHQGH ‫ڨ‬EUHIHQV\OODEHQRQILQDOH
HVW VDXIFRQGLWLRQQHPHQW 9!  TXHWRXWHIRLVOHUHIOHWI+6)U$#X1!GH ‫ڨ‬PILQDOHVW;:!  TXHOHUHIOHW
SLFpQLHQGH ‫گ‬LWDOLTXHHQV\OODEHQRQILQDOHHVW;!  TXHWRXWHIRLVOHUHIOHWSKRQpWLTXHGH ‫گ‬PLWDOLTXHHQ
ILQDOHHVW9:!  TXH ‫گ‬LWDOLTXHV·HVWIHUPpHQ‫ۆ‬HQSURWRVDEHOOLTXHHWFHODHQWRXWHSRVLWLRQ¬  TXH
GDQVODSUpKLVWRLUHGXSLFpQLHQDRSpUpXQHORLDSSHOpH´6KRUW 65DLVLQJ5XOHµ 7,KK DIIHFWDQW RP¬ILQDO  
TXHGDQVODSUpKLVWRLUHGXSLFpQLHQDRSpUpRXELHQXQHORL´6KRUWHQLQJDQG/RZHULQJ5XOHµ 7NK RXELHQXQHORL


%0HLVHU 
%-6%GF7MJ%@=FCHVWHQSULQFLSHjDQDO\VHUFRPPHO·DFFXVDWLISOXULHO

0DOJUp'XSUD]/HVXMHWGHL9E9CQB;FHVWjWLUHUGHD;D;3 FRUUHVSRQGDQWDXQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHU@QF 0&HWSHXWrWUH$3 
@<:RXGH:=ABA:;: PrPHVLOHVXGSLFpQLHQDSXWKpRULTXHPHQW PDLVFHODQHV·LPSRVH

0HLVHU Q HPSORLHjSURSRVGHGKCA@;:UO·H[SUHVVLRQ SDV  HPSOR\HU O·DFFXVDWLI SOXULHO GHV WKqPHV FRQVRQDQWLTXHV HQ
FLUFRQVSHFWH´YRUDXVJHVHW]WHVKDQGHOWVLFKXPHLQH*HQLWLYIRUPµ IRQFWLRQGHQRPLQDWLISOXULHOSDUDQDORJLHGHVWKqPHVHQčROHV
ILQDOHVGHQRPLQDWLIHWG·DFFXVDWLISOXULHOV čV pWDLHQWKRPRQ\PHV
5L[ 6XU7(HVWHQHIIHWDWWHVWpO·DFFXVDWLISOXULHOL9FKG
 oi.uchicago.edu

% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

´/RZHULQJ5XOHµ NK O·XQHHWO·DXWUHDIIHFWDQW ‫ۆ‬P  TXHO·RUGUHG·DSSOLFDWLRQHVWRXELHQ^7,KK%=L89%7NK`2%

RXELHQPLHX[ " ^NK%=L89%7,KK`  TXHSDUFRQVpTXHQWɍLGRP%JK%BQ9:FRPSRUWHQWXQDQFLHQ ‫گ‬P%G8H6>2%JK%
QRQ ‫ڨ‬P1RWUHpWXGHDFFHSWHOHVWKqVHVFRQWHVWHOHVWKqVHVHWVDQVUHMHWHUFDWpJRULTXHPHQW
HWSURSRVHXQHDOWHUQDWLYH
:HLVVGpIHQGGRQFSRXU REUHIRXYHUWHW ‫ۆ‬ORQJIHUPpO·LGpHG·XQH#)?!-0#6)SKRQpWLTXHDXFRXUVGH
O·pYROXWLRQHQIRQFWLRQGHODSRVLWLRQGDQVOHPRW(QV\OODEHQRQILQDOH REUHIRXYHUWHVWUHIOpWpSDU9X2%
WDQGLVTX·HQILQDOHOHSURGXLWSKRQpWLTXHGH RPVHUDLWQRWp;:!,QYHUVHPHQWHQV\OODEHQRQILQDOH ‫ۆ‬
HVWUHIOpWpSDU;!DORUVTX·HQILQDOHOHUHIOHWSKRQpWLTXHGH ‫ۆ‬PHVWQRWp9:!3DUFRQVpTXHQW:HLVVHVW
DPHQpjFRQFOXUHTXH9:ILQDOUHIOqWHQpFHVVDLUHPHQW ‫گ‬PGDQVGHVFDVGHILJXUHDXWUHVTXHOHJpQLWLISOXULHO
:HLVVUHFRQVWUXLWDLQVL NLG‫گ‬P%=FL7%ɍLGRPK\SRWKqVHHQDSSDUHQFHpWD\pHSDUOHVFRUUHVSRQGDQWVJHUPDQLTXHV
JRWLTXH1)"%+#$( :HLVVYRLWHQRXWUHHQBQ9:OHUHIOHWGH W̒‫گ‬PDYHFGHX[ORQJXHVHQKLDWXV
&HWWHWKpRULHGX´FURLVHPHQWµ¬SKRQpWLTXHDSSHOOHSRXUWDQWSOXVLHXUVUpVHUYHV'·DERUGOHQRPLQDWLIRVTXH
BA; 6D9H LQYLWHUDLWjSRVHU W̒‫ڨ‬PDYHFEUqYH(QUHYDQFKHOH:Q9:&CKI=GHO·LQVFULSWLRQGH7ROID 8P¬
YRLU5L[DHWE Q·HVWG·DXFXQVHFRXUVGDQVODSUpVHQWHDUJXPHQWDWLRQ QRXVLJQRURQVHQHIIHWVL9X%
V·RSSRVHj;!GDQVOHVFRQYHQWLRQVRUWKRJUDSKLTXHVGHFHWLGLRPH /·RPEULHQG·,JXYLXP$#6>2%$#62%$!#6QHSURXYH
ULHQFDU 1>V·RXYUHGHWRXWHIDoRQHQ6>FRPPHOHPRQWUHQWOHVVXSLQVHQ $1>pFULWV$6!(QVXLWHODFRP
SDUDLVRQHQWUHOHVILQDOHVGHɍLGRPHWGXJRWLTXH+#$(QHV·LPSRVHQXOOHPHQWFRPPHXQHQpFHVVLWp(QRXWUHVL
FRPPHOHSHQVH5L[  LOIDXWELHQOLUH9D=GK;9:HQ5,FHWLQILQLWLIPRQWUHUDLWTXH RPDYHFYR\HOOH
EUqYHHVWUHIOpWpSDU9:QRQSDU;:(QILQHWVXUWRXWO·K\SRWKqVHSDUDGR[DOHGHO·LQYHUVLRQSKRQpWLTXHHVW
SHXWrWUHLQXWLOHPHQWFRPSOH[H
3RXUH[SOLTXHUFHVGRQQpHVQRXVSUpFRQLVRQVGHSUHQGUHHQFRPSWHXQHGLPHQVLRQPRUSKRORJLTXHRLQWHU
YLHQWOHIDFWHXUGHO·()(.65#!&RQWUDLUHPHQWj:HLVVQRXVFUR\RQVTXHO·DERXWLVVHPHQWSKRQpWLTXHGH ‫ڨ‬P
HQILQDOHHVW9:&HWWHpYROXWLRQHVWSUpVHUYpHGDQVGHVPRWVLVROpV ɍLGRP2%BQ9: HWSHXWrWUHGDQVO·LQILQLWLI
9D=GK;9: VLGXPRLQVO·RQUHWLHQWFHWWHOHFWXUH 1RXVVXJJpURQVHQUHYDQFKHTXHODILQDOHG·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHU
‫ۆ‬PQRWpH;:HVWDQDORJLTXHSRXUVRQWLPEUHGHO·DFFXVDWLIPDVFXOLQSOXULHOWKpPDWLTXHSDUKDVDUGQRQ
DWWHVWpGDQVOHFRUSXVPDLVGRQWODYR\HOOHFDUDFWpULVWLTXHGHYDLWrWUHGHWLPEUH>‫@ۆ‬/DUHVWLWXWLRQODSOXVVLPSOH
HWODSOXVYUDLVHPEODEOHVHUDLW‫ۆ‬VLVVXGH ‫گ‬V FRPSDUDEOHjO·DFFXVDWLISOXULHOODWLQHQ‫گ‬V PDLVODYR\HOOHGH
FHWWHWHUPLQDLVRQDSXrWUHDEUpJpH LOIDXGUDLWDORUVSRVHU‫ۆ‬V 2QQHSHXWWRXWHIRLVH[FOXUHTXHODWHUPLQDLVRQ
G·DFFXVDWLIPDVFXOLQSOXULHOWKpPDWLTXHDLWHXODIRUPH‫ۆ‬I RX‫ۆ‬IHQFDVG·DEUqJHPHQW VRLWTXHO·RQSRVWXOH
XQHGpVLQHQFHGRQWODIRUPHRULJLQHOOHDXUDLWpWp ‫گ‬QV G·R‫ۆ‬IGLUHFWHPHQW RXPRLQVSUREDEOHPHQW 6)0%
TXLGRQQHUDLWRIGDQVXQSUHPLHUWHPSVVLELHQTX·LOIDXGUDLWSRVWXOHUHQRXWUHXQHIHUPHWXUHGH6GHYDQW
:%ILQDOFRPPHF·HVWOHFDVGHYDQW-GDQVL9E9CQB;F VRLWTXHO·RQDGPHWWHTXH‫ۆ‬VDpWpUHIDLWHQ‫ۆ‬IG·DSUqV
O·DFFXVDWLISOXULHOGHVWKqPHVHQFRQVRQQH FRPPH@=FC W\SHGHUpIHFWLRQSRXUOHTXHOO·RPEULHQIRXUQLUDLW
MXVWHPHQWXQSDUDOOqOH'DQVWRXVOHVFDVRQHVWHQGURLWGHVXSSRVHUXQHYR\HOOHGHWLPEUH>‫@ۆ‬IHUPpGDQVOD
WHUPLQDLVRQG·DFFXVDWLISOXULHOWKpPDWLTXHG·DSUqVODTXHOOHODILQDOHG·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHUDpWpUHIDLWHHQ‫ۆ‬P
&HWWHILQDOHG·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHUPDVFXOLQDG€HQVXLWHVHGLIIXVHUDXQHXWUHWKpPDWLTXHjO·DFFXVDWLIHWDXQRPL
QDWLIVLQJXOLHUV
(QRXWUHVLO·RQSUHQDLWDXVpULHX[ODILQDOH@<:!GHO·DFFXVDWLIPDVFXOLQVLQJXOLHUD;D;@<: $3 HQ
DGPHWWDQWTX·HOOHUHQGELHQQ\‫ۆ‬PUpDOLVp>Q\XP@ DYHFHPSORLH[FHSWLRQQHOPDLVELHQFRPSUpKHQVLEOHGH
<!TXLQRWHDLOOHXUVXQHVpTXHQFH>6)6I+6)U>($#X1!%Z8X@ LOVHUDLWDLVpGDQVOHFDGUHGHODSUpVHQWHK\SRWKqVH
G·DSSUpKHQGHUSRXUTXRL QLPDERXWLVVHPHQWUpJXOLHUGH )'6> DYHFV\QFRSHDWWHQGXHFRPPHGDQVO·RVTXH
DKRA: DpWpUHIDLWHQQ\‫ۆ‬P(QHIIHWDXPRPHQWRODILQDOH 36>pWDLWUHPSODFpHSDU&‫ۆ‬P ;: VRXVOD
SUHVVLRQGHO·DFFXVDWLISOXULHO HQ&‫ ۆ‬g 0RX&‫ ۆ‬g : XQHI(-$#!GHVDFFXVDWLIVPDVFXOLQVHQ3#> GH 3'6> DSX
rWUHHQWUDvQpHGDQVFHPrPHPRXYHPHQWGHUpIHFWLRQ‫ۆ‬DDORUVpWp#)0U-UGDQV 3#> G·R &\‫ۆ‬P DORUVTX·LO
DpWp01&0$#$1Uj 6GDQV 36> G·R&‫ۆ‬P 0DLVFHWWHLQVHUWLRQQ·DXUDLWSDVpWpJpQpUDOH 9CB9FA:GHPHXUH 
#FLKJGF89%D;D;@<:SHXWrWUHXQHVLPSOHHUUHXUSRXU D;D;@;:6RXOLJQRQVHQILQTXHO·pQLJPDWLTXHBABA=@9:%


$YHFXQHSDODWDOHLQGRHXURSpHQQHjO·LQLWLDOHUHIOpWpHSDUN 
2QREVHUYHUDTXHO·pYHQWXHOOHUpIHFWLRQGHVDFFXVDWLIVG·DQWKUR
GDQVODSUpKLVWRLUHGHO·LWDOLTXH SRQ\PHV DX[TXHOVD;D;@<:SHXWrWUHDVVLPLOpDXPRLQVSRXUOH

5L[²1pDQPRLQVO·DFFXVDWLISOXULHOL9FKG7( ¬ čV  FRPSRUWHPHQWPRUSKRORJLTXH HQ 3#> GH 3 # '6> DSXrWUH
QHSUpVHQWHDXFXQHWUDFHGHUpIHFWLRQ&·HVWGRQF‫ۆ‬V RX‫ۆ‬V TXL LQIOXHQFpHSDUOHVQRPVSURSUHVTXLDYDLHQWXQDFFXVDWLIHQ &Ҹ\RP%
HVWOHSOXVYUDLVHPEODEOH GH 3#'M#'6M> FRPPHO·RVTXHRE<OKBAA<: &S¬ (QUHYDQFKH
O·DGMHFWLI9CB9FA:pFKDSSDLWWRXWQDWXUHOOHPHQWjOHXUDQDORJLH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% :?@

GH7(SRXUUDLWHQWKpRULHV·LQWHUSUpWHUFRPPHXQHUHOLTXHGHO·DQFLHQDFFXVDWLIHQ9:SUpVHUYpHGDQVXQQRP
SURSUHPrPHVLO·DQDO\VHFRPPHJpQLWLISOXULHOGHPHXUHpYLGHPPHQWGHORLQODSOXVVLPSOHHWODSOXVpFRQRPLTXH
,OUHVWHUDLWjGpFRXYULUOD-(#06)%";z$-!GXWUDQVIHUWDQDORJLTXHGHWLPEUHjO·DFFXVDWLIGXSOXULHODXVLQJXOLHU

#=&>?@ABAC&DE<FA=E&DAI?@A=@J&H=&EXKDDF9IN=&GP@INF9@AL<=&`&EXK@KEPG=&HAKINF9@AL<=
6LO·RQDGPHWTXHO·LWDOLTXHDKpULWpSXLVWUDQVPLVDXVDEHOOLTXHHWHQVXLWHDXVXGSLFpQLHQVRXVODIRUPH
‫ۆ‬PXQHGpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOLQGRHXURSpHQQHHQ ‫گ‬PDORUVLOIDXWSRVWXOHUDYHF:HLVVSRXUODSUp
KLVWRLUHLPPpGLDWHGXSLFpQLHQXQHORLG·RXYHUWXUHHWSHXWrWUHDXVVLG·DEUpJHPHQWDIIHFWDQWWRXW‫ۆ‬GHYDQW
>ILQDO,OQHV·DJLUDLWSDVG·XQHK\SRWKqVHJUDWXLWHLQYHQWpHSRXUOHVEHVRLQVGHODFDXVHFDUXQHORLG·RXYHUWXUH
98M8>687J%I61--(#$rWUHSRVWXOpHGDQVXQHSDUWLHGXGRPDLQHSLFpQLHQDXPRLQVSRXUH[SOLTXHUOHGDWLIVLQJXOLHU
HQ9NDWWHVWpGDQVD<LE9NHQ$4 O·DQDO\VHFRPPHGDWLIHVWV€UH GDQVH;@9NHQ&+¬HWSHXWrWUHGDQV
D=BF9NHQ7( V·LOV·pWDLWDJLG·XQQRPLQDWLIGHWKqPHHQ‫گ‬QQRQVLJPDWLVpRQDXUDLWDWWHQGXXQHJUDSKLH;! 
HWHQ=NGDQV>R@K;A=NHQ$4 DYHFYR\HOOHG·DYDQWHQUDLVRQGX:-6)$#)5GpFOHQFKpSDUOH\RGTXLSUpFqGHP? /HV
GHX[GpVLQHQFHV9NHW=NSRVVqGHQWXQWLPEUHRXYHUWDORUVTXHO·DXWUHGpVLQHQFHGHGDWLIWKpPDWLTXHHVWXQH
GLSKWRQJXHGRQWODQRWDWLRQ;QGpPRQWUHTXHOHVGHX[pOpPHQWVFRQVWLWXWLIVVRQWSOXVIHUPpV ‫ ̩ۆ‬RX ‫ ̩ۆ‬PO%
1pDQPRLQVWRXWHWHQWDWLYHG·pOXFLGDWLRQGHODSUpKLVWRLUHGHODWHUPLQDLVRQSLFpQLHQQH9:GHJpQLWLISOXULHO
GRLWWHQLUFRPSWHGHGHX[FRQFHSWLRQVDQWLWKpWLTXHVGHVFRPSDUDWLVWHVVXUODILQDOHFRUUHVSRQGDQWHHQLQGRHX
URSpHQ&HUWDLQVOLQJXLVWHVDGPHWWHQWO·H[LVWHQFHjF{WpGH ‫گ‬PG·XQHGpVLQHQFH ‫ڨ‬PHQVHIRQGDQWSULQFLSDOH
PHQWVXUOHVGRQQpHVVODYHV 2VWKRII0HLOOHW WDQGLVTXHG·DXWUHVVDYDQWVFRPPH-DVDQRII  
HW:HLVV  UpYRTXHQWHQGRXWHO·H[LVWHQFHGH ‫ڨ‬PDYHFEUqYH PrPHSRXUOHVODYH 'DQVFHGpEDWTXL
WRXFKHO·LQGRHXURSpHQOXLPrPHOHVDEHOOLTXHVHUDLWVXVFHSWLEOHG·DSSRUWHUjO·DUJXPHQWDWLRQXQHFRQWULEXWLRQ
SHUWLQHQWH/HVGRQQpHVRVTXHVHWRPEULHQQHVVRQWWRXWHIRLVHQSDUWLHFRQIXVHV P:-DVDQRII ¬ DUDLVRQ
G·DIILUPHUTXH´WKHDOOHJHGHYLGHQFHIRU ‫ڨ‬PLQ8PEULDQ«LVLQGHFLVLYHµSXLVTXHO·RQVDLWTXHWRXW 1>%G8H6>%
GHYLHQWDXWRPDWLTXHPHQW6>HQRPEULHQ 0HLVHU² FRPPHOHGpPRQWUHOHVXSLQ()0!-#($67,J9,D
  $1> 'RQFVLO·RQSDUWDLWG·XQHGpVLQHQFHjORQJXHRQDXUDLW ‫گ‬P! ‫ۆ‬P! 1 g >DYHFUpYHUVLRQDXWRPD
WLTXHHQ6 g >0HLVHUH[SOLTXHDYHFYUDLVHPEODQFHOHJpQLWLII-(4($(-1> 9,D SDUXQHLQIOXHQFHG·XQPRGqOH
JUDSKLTXHHQDOSKDEHWQDWLRQDORPEULHQRR  HVWQRWp<!/HVDPELJXwWpVGXFRUSXVRVTXHRQWpWpVRXOLJQpHV
SDU2VWKRII ² (VWLPDQWTXHGKCA@A: Q3J HVWXQJpQLWLISOXULHO2VWKRII\YRLWXQHSUHXYHTXHOD
GpVLQHQFHpWDLWDQFLHQQHPHQW ‫ڨ‬P&HWDUJXPHQWVHUDLWHQGURLWYDOLGHFDUOHSURGXLWSKRQpWLTXHGH 3#'6>%
HVW3#>WDQGLVTXH &Ҹ\RP GH 3#'M#'6M> DERXWLWj3#'6>HQRVTXH RE<OKBAA<:&S¬LQVFULSWLRQTXLLJQRUH
O·XVDJHGH;! /DGpVLQHQFH ‫ڨ‬PGHVWKqPHVFRQVRQDQWLTXHVDXUDLWSXSpQpWUHUGDQVOHVQRPVWKpPDWLTXHVVDQV
pYLQFHUWRWDOHPHQW ‫گ‬P0DLVSDUPDOKHXUGKCA@A:SRXUUDLWV·DQDO\VHUFRPPHXQQHXWUHVLQJXOLHU
1RXVGHYRQVGRQFQRXVFRQWHQWHULFLG·XQHDQDO\VHLQWHUQHGXFRUSXVSLFpQLHQ0DLVLQFRQWHVWDEOHPHQWOD
GpVLQHQFHSLFpQLHQQH9:GHJpQLWLISOXULHOV·H[SOLTXHUDLWELHQSOXVDLVpPHQWVLO·RQDGPHWWDLWTXHO·LWDOLTXHD
KpULWpG·XQHGpVLQHQFHLQGRHXURSpHQQH ‫ڨ‬PDYHFYR\HOOHEUqYH'XSRLQWGHYXHSKRQpWLTXHODGpVLQHQFHGH
JpQLWLISOXULHOSUpVHQWHUDLWDORUVH[DFWHPHQWOHPrPHUHIOHW9:GH ‫ڨ‬PTXHFHOXLTXHO·RQWURXYHGDQVG·DXWUHV
FDWpJRULHVJUDPPDWLFDOHVGDQVɍLGRP2%BQ9:HWSHXWrWUHGDQVO·LQILQLWLI9D=GK;9:2QDXUDLWWRUWG·REMHFWHUj
SURSRVGHKEQ@BA9:TXHOHVILQDOHVHQ 3#'6>VRQWUHSUpVHQWpHVSDU3#>HQVDEHOOLTXHFDULOVXIILWG·DGPHWWUH
TXHODV\QFRSHDpWpFRQWUHFDUUpHHQUDLVRQGHODIURQWLqUHPRUSKpPDWLTXH6LO·RQVRXKDLWHGpIHQGUHO·LQWHUSUp
WDWLRQGHGKCA@;:& 7( FRPPHJpQLWLISOXULHOLOVXIILWGHFRQVLGpUHUTXHOHUHIOHWSURGXFWLI9: LVVXGH ‫ڨ‬P 


,OVHUDLWSDUIDLWHPHQWDUELWUDLUHGHSRVWXOHUXQHORLG·DEUqJHPHQW
GH ‫گ‬PHQ 6>DXVWDGHGXI-6$6M#$(.#X1!RXjFHOXLGX%I-6$6M0(&!.M
.#X1!6LO·LWDOLTXHDKpULWpG·XQHILQDOH ‫گ‬PLQGRHXURSpHQQHDORUV
FHOOHFLDG€rWUHWUDQVPLVHj4+(X1!ODQJXHVDEHOOLTXHVRXVODIRUPH
‫ۆ‬PDYHFXQHYR\HOOHORQJXHHWIHUPpH IRUPXODWLRQSUXGHQWHGX
SUREOqPHSDU5L[ 
P?
&HWWHDQDO\VHDpWpSURSRVpHLQGpSHQGDPPHQWSDU$GLHJR/DMDUD
²HW HWSDU:HLVV  
PO
7RXWHIRLVODGLSKWRQJXH ‫گ‬LGHODWHUPLQDLVRQGHGDWLIDSXrWUH
DEUpJpHGHERQQHKHXUHHQ 6#GHYHQDQW F̩ DQWpFpGHQWLPPp
GLDWGH‫ گ‬QRWp9N! HWGH ‫  ̩ۆ‬QRWp;Q! 'DQVFHFDVDXFXQH
ORLG·RXYHUWXUHG·XQHORQJXHQ·DXUDLWpWpjO·±XYUH
P:
-XJHPHQWSUXGHQWGH0HLVHU´2EGHU*HQ3OGHU66WlPPHLP
8UVDEHOOLVFKHQODQJHVRGHUNXU]HV6DXIZLHVOl‰WVLFKQLFKWHQWVFKHL
GHQµ  
 oi.uchicago.edu

% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

Q·DSDVHQWLqUHPHQWpYLQFpOHUHIOHW;: GH ‫گ‬PDWWHQGXGDQVOHVQRPVWKpPDWLTXHV 3HXWrWUHOHV\QWDJPH

GKCA@;:&@=FC´OHVSULQFHVGHV6DELQVµFRQVWLWXDLWLOXQHH[SUHVVLRQWRXWHIDLWHTXLGHYDLWjVDQREOHVVHHWjVRQ
pYHQWXHOFDUDFWqUHIRUPXODLUHODSUpVHUYDWLRQG·XQDUFKDwVPH,OQ·HVWGRQFSDVQpFHVVDLUHGHVXSSRVHUTXH7(¬
XWLOLVHDUELWUDLUHPHQW;!SRXU9!RXTXHFHWWHLQVFULSWLRQLJQRUHO·XVDJHGH9!)LQDOHPHQWODFRQFRUGDQFH
HQWUHOHVXGSLFpQLHQHWOHVODYHVHUDLWUHPDUTXDEOH
,OQ·HVWSDVGDQVO·HVSULWGHQRWUHSURSRVGHGRQQHUXQHUpSRQVHSpUHPSWRLUHDXSUREOqPHQLG·DIILUPHUTXH
O·K\SRWKqVHLFLGpIHQGXHHVWSUpIpUDEOHjFHOOHDYDQFpHSDU:HLVVG·XQHRXYHUWXUHGH‫ۆ‬HQRGHYDQWP
ILQDO1RXVVRXKDLWRQVVLPSOHPHQWDSSUpFLHUjVDMXVWHYDOHXUO·DSSRUWGHVGRQQpHVSDOpRVDEHOOLTXHVHQUHVWDQW
ELHQFRQVFLHQWTXHOHFDUDFWqUHU46)6>#X1!G·XQHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQQ·HVWSDVXQFULWqUHDEVROXGHYpULWp(QWRXWFDV
O·H[LVWHQFHG·XQHKRPRQ\PLHIkFKHXVHHQWUHODGpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOHQ 6>HWFHOOHG·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHU
HQ 6>DYHFXQHEUqYHGDQVOHVGHX[PRUSKqPHVDXUDLWSXGpFOHQFKHUODUpIHFWLRQGHO·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHUWKp
PDWLTXHPDVFXOLQHQ‫ۆ‬PDYHFXQWLPEUHYRFDOLTXHSOXVIHUPpDQDORJLTXHGHO·DFFXVDWLISOXULHOPDVFXOLQ
(QFRQFOXVLRQXQHDQDO\VHFRQWH[WXHOOHHWpW\PRORJLTXHG·XQHHQWLWpOH[LFDOH<=EQ;:HQODTXHOOHQRXV
UHFRQQDLVVRQVQRQSDVOHJpQLWLISOXULHOG·XQDGMHFWLIPDLVXQHIRUPHGHSUpWpULWQRXVDHQJDJpjUHSUHQGUHOH
GRVVLHUGXJpQLWLISOXULHOVXUGHQRXYHOOHVEDVHVHQUpYLVDQWO·LQYHQWDLUHGHVILQDOHV1RXVDYRQVPRQWUpTXHOD
VHXOHGpVLQHQFH(001-U!GHJpQLWLISOXULHOHVW9:TXLILJXUHjFRXSV€UGDQVCABAKG9:2%KEQ@BA9:2%FK=EA9:2%:KF9:2%
DYHFXQHFHUWDLQHSUREDELOLWpGDQV@9F9:!HWSHXWrWUHDXVVLGDQVBABA=@9:%JK%F<BK@A9: OHFWXUHLQFHUWDLQH ,O
VHSHXWWRXWHIRLVTXHGKCA@;:V·DQDO\VHpJDOHPHQWFRPPHXQJpQLWLISOXULHOGRQWODWHUPLQDLVRQ;: GH ‫گ‬P 
Q·DSDVpWppOLPLQpHPDOJUpODJpQpUDOLVDWLRQGHODILQDOH9: GH ‫ڨ‬P 4XDQWjODSUpKLVWRLUHGHVILQDOHVQRQ
SURQRPLQDOHVG·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHUWKpPDWLTXHHWGHJpQLWLISOXULHOTXLQRXVO·DYRQVYXQHVHFRQIRQGHQWSDV
HQSULQFLSHGDQVODJUDSKLHQLGDQVODSURQRQFLDWLRQLOQ·HVWSRVVLEOHGHO·DSSUpKHQGHUTX·HQIDLVDQWLQWHUYHQLU
GHVFRQVLGpUDWLRQVG·RUGUHPRUSKRORJLTXH
(QWRXWFDVO·K\SRWKqVHG·XQHYDULDWLRQ5-(I+#X1!DXJpQLWLISOXULHOHVWXQSXUPLUDJH6LODIRUPHGKCA@;:%J9K%
XQJpQLWLISOXULHOHOOHGRLWVDILQDOHjXQHSURQRQFLDWLRQUpHOOHDUFKDwTXHGLVWLQFWHGHFHOOHGHVDXWUHVJpQLWLIV
SOXULHOV/DQRWDWLRQGHVYR\HOOHVHQVXGSLFpQLHQHVWGRQFjODIRLVULJRXUHXVHHWUDWLRQQHOOH(OOHHVWIRQGpHVXU
XQHVWULFWHSULVHHQFRPSWHGHVWLPEUHVYRFDOLTXHV&RPPHO·DREVHUYp:HLVV  DYHFEHDXFRXSGHMXV
WHVVHOHV3LFpQLHQVLQYHQWHXUVHWXVDJHUVSRXUFHUWDLQHVLQVFULSWLRQVDXPRLQVG·XQUpSHUWRLUHJUDSKLTXHDSWH
jGLIIpUHQFLHUOHV0!I$WLPEUHVYRFDOLTXHVGHOHXUODQJXHpWDLHQWGHYpULWDEOHVH[SHUWVHQPDWLqUHG·RUWKRJUDSKH
HWG·6-$+6UI#!

(SF?OAKBA9@G
3/N% 36-I10%/)04-#I$#6)1>%N($#)(-1>²
N8/<% -RVHSK9HQGU\HVN!]#X1!%U$'>6.65#X1!%"!%.;#-.()"(#0%()4#!)'XEOLQ'XEOLQ,QVWLWXWHIRU$GYDQFHG
6WXGLHVOPRP;
N/T: +HOPXW5L[pGN!]#=6)%"!-%#)"65!->()#04+!)%T!-&!)g%H#!%J1-G!.)%1)"%#+-!%@-#>a-0$(>>&#."1)5!)L%
:qPHpGUHY:LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW%:??O%
3) 3DXOXVH[)HVWRFLWpG·DSUqV:0/LQGVD\ pG 7!]$#%@6>I!#%F!0$#%H!%T!-&6-1>%7#5)#:#4($1%X1(!%
01I!-01)$%41>%@(1.#%8I#$6>!/HLS]LJ7HXEQHU

4ASEA9>FKDNA=
$GLHJR/DMDUD%,JQDFLR-DYLHU
  ´6REUHODQRWDFLyQGHODVYRFDOHVSRVWHULRUHVHQVXGSLFpQLFRµ<)1(-#%"!%F#.6.65#(6HFFLy'²
% OPP:% @-6$60(&!.#62%6046M1>&-62%01"I#4!)68QLYHUVLWDV%DUFHORQD338
  ´3DUHQWHVFRFRQWDFWRHLQQRYDFLyQSDUDOHODHOFDVRGHODVOHQJXDVVDEpOLFDVµ/)46)$-#%N#)51#0$#4#
²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% :?P

$JRVWLQLDQL/XFLDQR
% OPPP% ´/HLVFUL]LRQLGL1RYLODUDY%36H9%@#4!)#g%@6I6.6%";81-6I(pGLWpSDU*&RORQQDSS²5RPH'H
/XFD
% :??Q ´/HLVFUL]LRQLGL1RYLODUDY%36H9%/%@#4!)#%!%.;/$(.#(%A!"#6M<"-#($#4(% $WWLGHO;;,,&RQYHJQRGL6WXGL
(WUXVFKLHG,WDOLFL$VFROL3LFHQR7HUDPR$QFRQD²DSULOH SS²5RPH,VWLWXWL
(GLWRULDOL3ROLJUDILFL,QWHUQD]LRQDOL
  ´5XNHV+D]VXLHV8QWUDWWRPRUIRORJLFRSDOHRLWDOLFRQHOOHSDUODWHDQHOOHQLFKHGL6LFLOLDµ'DQV
7(>)#$#4!%.6X1#g%7$1"#%#)%6)6-!%"#%<."6%@-60"64#>#%I!-%#.%I-!>#6%/%7())#$#pGLWpSDU'&DLD]]DYROSS
²/LEUL&DPSDQR6DQQLWLFL3LHGLPRQWH0DWHVH$UWL*UDILFKH*ULOOR
%DUWRQ̍N%$QWRQtQ
  ´6FKULIWVSUDFKH8PJDQJVVSUDFKH'LDOHNWLP/DWHLQµ'DQVN($#)%?1.5(#-!%q%N($#)%$(-"#:%T% $FWHVGX
1JFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOVXUOHODWLQYXOJDLUHHWWDUGLI+HLGHOEHUJ²VHSWHPEUH pGLWpSDU
+¬3HWHUVPDQQHW5.HWWHPDQQSS²+HLGHOEHUJ&:LQWHU
%HDXMHX-HDQ%
% OPR?% @.#)!%.;<)4#!)O#0$6#-!%B($1-!..!2/LYUH,,&ROOHFWLRQGHV8QLYHUVLWpVGH)UDQFHVRXVOHSDWURQDJHGH
O·$VVRFLDWLRQ*XLOODXPH%XGp3DULV/HV%HOOHV/HWWUHV
%HKDJHO%&KKF%
%  ´%H]LHKXQJHQ]ZLVFKHQ8PIDQJXQG5HLKHQIROJHYRQ6DW]JOLHGHUQµ/)"65!->()#04+!%F6-04+1)5!)%:RN%
²
%LOH0RQLTXH
  N!%"#(.!4$!%4-U$6#0%()4#!)2%Q$1"!%"!%.(%.()51!%"!0%#)04-#I$#6)02%-!41!#.%"!0%#)04-#I$#6)0%I60$U-#!1-!0%(1]%/3L%
eWXGHVFUpWRLVHV3DULV3DXO*HXWKQHU
%UL[KH&ODXGH
  N!%"#(.!4$!%5-!4%"!%@(>I+'.#!g%"641>!)$0%!$%5-(>>(#-!%LEOLRWKqTXHGHO·,QVWLWXWIUDQoDLVG·,VWDQEXO
3DULV$GULHQ0DLVRQQHXYH
  ´/HVSDODWDOLVDWLRQVHQJUHFDQFLHQDSSURFKHVQRXYHOOHVµ'DQVQ$-!))!0%"!%0!I$()$(#)!g%$-(?(1]%"!%
.#)51#0$#X1!%!$%"!%5-(>>(#-!%46>I(-U!%6::!-$0%h%A#4+!.%N!c!1)!SS²eWXGHVHW&RPPHQWDLUHV
3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
  ´0RUSKRQRORJLHRXPRUSKRJUDSKpPLH"­SURSRVGHTXHOTXHVYDULDWLRQVJUDSKLTXHVHQJUHF
DQFLHQµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
  @+6)U$#X1!%!$%I+6)6.65#!%"1%5-!4%()4#!)%*N%X1!.X1!0%5-()"!0%X1!0$#6)0%LEOLRWKqTXHGHV&DKLHUVGHO·,QVWL
WXWGH/LQJXLVWLTXHGH/RXYDLQ/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
%XFN&DUO'DUOLQJ
% OPRR% *+!%D-!!=%H#(.!4$0g%D-(>>(-2%7!.!4$!"%/)04-#I$#6)02%D.600(-'&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVV
&DO]HFFKL2QHVWL%48F7I8F%
  ´,4-%HG(4-QHOODWRSRQRPDVWLFDGHOO·,WDOLDDQWLFDµ7$1"#%8$-104+#²
"6M=6H8>J2%(QULFR
  ´,WHVWLXPEULPLQRULµ'DQV%<00#0#%!%5.#%\>&-#%)!..;()$#4+#$h% $WWLGHOFRQYHJQRLQWHUQD]LRQDOH$VVLVL
²GLFHPEUH pGLWpSDU*%RQDPHQWHHW)&RDUHOOLSS²$VVLVL0LQHUYD
&DSGHYLOOH*pUDUG
  ´/DUHOLJLRQGHV3LFpQLHQVµ'DQV/$(.6M*1046MK6>()(2%F!0$04+-#:$%:u-%N14#()(%<#5)!-MF6-!0$#pGLWpSDU
3¬$PDQQ03HGUD]]LHW+7DHXEHUSS²9LHQQH+RO]KDXVHQ
"86HG676H82%16>J78F%
  <)$#4+!%4#?#.$h%";<&-1GG65RPH'H/XFD
 oi.uchicago.edu

:O?% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

&ODFNVRQ%[6MJ9%
  ´7KH:RUG2UGHU3DWWHUQ>(5)(%41>%.(1"!LQ/DWLQDQG6DEHOOLDQµ'DQV/)"6M81-6I!()%@!-0I!4$#?!0g%
7$1"#!0%#)%O6)61-%6:%<))(%A6-I1-56%H(?#!0pGLWpSDU-+:3HQQH\SS²2[IRUG2[IRUG
8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
'H0HOR:ROIJDQJ'DYLG&LULOR
% :??@% *+!%8(-.'%N($#)%T!-&%7'0$!>L%<-4+(#4%F6->0%#)%@.(1$102%*!-!)4!2%()"%S!'6)"2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\
3UHVV
3J%$8MFHJ2%"67>F%
  ´&RQWULEXWL3HOLJQLµ<))(.#2%/0$#$1$6%,-#!)$(.!%"#%B(I6.#2%7!G#6)!%N#)51#0$#4(²
3J996L2%(J7M6HHL9%
% OP?:% /)04-#I$#6)!0%N($#)(!%7!.!4$(!9ROXPH3DUW%HUOLQ:HLGPDQQ
'XQNHO*HRUJH(
  ´3,( =6^>`¶ZLWK·DQG )1^>`¶QRZ·'LG,(+DYHD)DFXOWDWLYH)LQDO1DVDO"µ'DQV7(-)#=G!.g%
O!$+#$6.65#04+!%7$1"#!)%G1>%D!"!)=!)%()%8>#.%,-5!$6-#]%F6--!-pGLWpSDU'*URGGHNHW65|VVOHSS
²'UHVGQHU%HLWUlJH]XU+HWKLWRORJLH'UHVGHQ9HUODJGHU7HFKQLVFKHQ8QLYHUVLWlW
'UHVGHQ
'XSUD](PPDQXHO
  ´([RSKRULTXHVHWHQGRSKRULTXHVHQVDEHOOLTXHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%O?QWON%
²
(LFKQHU%(J8HJ7%
%  ´RGHU"=XU(QWZLFNOXQJGHURVNLVFKXPEULVFKHQ6WXGLHQQHEVWHLQHUQHXHQ
,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGHV7H[WHVYRQ)RQWH5RPLWR 9HWWHU1U µ'DQV,0=#04+M\>&-#04+g%*!]$!%
1)"%D-(>>($#=% $UEHLWVWDJXQJGHU,QGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWXQGGHU6RFLHWj,WDOLDQDGL
*ORWWRORJLDYRPELV6HSWHPEHULQ)UHLEXUJ pGLWpSDU+5L[SS²:LHVEDGHQ
5HLFKHUW
*DUFtD&DVWLOOHUR&DUORV
% :???% N(%:6->(4#ç)%"!.%$!>(%"!%I-!0!)$!%I-#>(-#6%6046M1>&-69LWRULD*DVWHL]8QLYHUVLGDGGHO3DtV9DVFR
*DUFtD5DPyQ-RVp/XLV%
%  ´$GYHUELRVGHGLUHFFLyQHLQVWUXPHQWDOLQGRHXURSHRµ'DQVS!-$+6."%H!.&-u4=%'%.(%0#)$(]#0%#)"6!1-6I!(%
+6'% $FWDVGHOFRORTXLRGHOD,QGRJHUPDQLVFKH*HVHOOVFKDIW0DGULG²GHVHSWLHPEUHGH 
pGLWpSDU(¬&UHVSRHW-/*DUFtD5DPyQSS²0DGULG(GLFLRQHVGHOD8$0
*pUDUG%5DSKDsO
% :??R% @+6)U$#X1!%!$%>6-I+6.65#!%"!%.(%.()51!%.'"#!))!%LEOLRWKqTXHGHV&DKLHUVGHO·,QVWLWXWGH/LQJXLVWLTXH
GH/RXYDLQ/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
*RLGDQLFK3LHU*
  ´'HOFRVLGHWWR¶6RQXVTXLGDPPHGLXV8HW,·GL4XLQWLOLDQRµ<$$#%"!..(%<44("!>#(%)(G#6)(.!%"!#%N#)4!#2%
K!)"#46)$#2%3.(00!%"#%74#!)G!%>6-(.#2%0$6-#4+!%!%:#.6.65#4+!²
*UDPPRQW0DXULFH
% OPR?% *-(#$U%"!%I+6)U$#X1!3DULV/LEUDLULH'HODJUDYH
+DMQDO,YR
  ´'DVRVNLVFKH&RJQRPHQ3XNDODW~tµ'DQV,0=#04+M\>&-#04+g%*!]$!%1)"%D-(>>($#=% $UEHLWVWDJXQJGHU
,QGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWXQGGHU6RFLHWj,WDOLDQDGL*ORWWRORJLDYRPELV6HSWHPEHU
LQ)UHLEXUJ pGLWpSDU+5L[SS²:LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% :OO

(6LI2%36I%
  ´2Q8QDFFHQWHG6KRUW9RZHOVLQ6DEHOOLDQDQGWKH0RUSKRORJ\RIWKH,WDOLFQG&RQMXJDWLRQµ
/)"65!->()#04+!%F6-04+1)5!)²
+LOPDUVVRQ-|UXQGXU
  A($!-#(.0%:6-%(%*64+(-#()%O#0$6-#4(.%()"%8$'>6.65#4(.%H#4$#6)(-'7RFKDULDQDQG,QGR(XURSHDQ6WXGLHV
6XSSOHPHQWDU\6HULHV5H\NMDYtN0iOYtVLQGDVWRIQXQ+iVNyODÌVODQGV
-DQGD%0LFKDHO
  ´'LH,QVFKULIWGHV+HOPVYRQ&DQRVDXQGGHU%XFKVWDEHɘGHV6GSLNHQLVFKHQµ'DQV,0=#04+M
\>&-#04+g%*!]$!%1)"%D-(>>($#=% $UEHLWVWDJXQJGHU,QGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWXQGGHU6RFLHWj
,WDOLDQDGL*ORWWRORJLDYRPELV6HSWHPEHULQ)UHLEXUJ pGLWpSDU+5L[SS²
:LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW
-DQVRQ%HUQG
  ´%HPHUNXQJHQ]XGHQVGSLNHQLVFKHQ,QVFKULIWHQµ'DQV,0=#04+M\>&-#04+g%*!]$!%1)"%D-(>>($#=%
^$UEHLWVWDJXQJGHU,QGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWXQGGHU6RFLHWj,WDOLDQDGL*ORWWRORJLDYRP
ELV6HSWHPEHULQ)UHLEXUJ pGLWpSDU+5L[SS²:LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW
-DVDQRII-D\+
  ´$5XOHRI)LQDO6\OODEOHVLQ6ODYLFµP61-)(.%6:%/)"6M81-6I!()%7$1"#!0²
-LPpQH]=DPXGLR5DIDHO%
  80$1"#6%"!.%"#(.!4$6%I!.#5)6%'%01%!)$6-)6%.#)5uÉ0$#466DODPDQFD8QLYHUVLGDGGH6DODPDQFD
.HQW5RODQG*
  *+!%*!]$1(.%3-#$#4#0>%6:%/)04-#I$#6)03KLODGHOSKLD/LQJXLVWLF6RFLHW\RI$PHULFD
.LP5RQDOG,
  ´8QFRYHULQJWKH3UHKLVWRU\RIWKH7RFKDULDQ&ODVV,,3UHWHULWHµO#0$6-#04+!%7I-(4+:6-04+1)5
²
.OLQJHQVFKPLWW%4J7K%
%  ´'LHODWHLQLVFKH1RPLQDOIOH[LRQµ'DQVN($!#)%1)"%/)"65!->()#04+% $NWHQGHV.ROORTXLXPVGHU
,QGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIW6DO]EXUJ²6HSWHPEHU pGLWpSDU23DQDJOHW7
.ULVFKSS²,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU
6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
/DFKPDQQ.DUO
  /)%*L%N14-!$##%3(-#%"!%-!-1>%)($1-(%.#&-60%46>>!)$(-#10qPHpG%HUROLQL5HLPHU
-6MDJ7KJ78J2%&KDUOHVGH
  ´¶3HVWHHWIDPLQHjODIRLV·XQQRXYHOH[HPSOHGHO·¶HIIHW6DXVVXUH·HQJUHFDQFLHQµ'DQVH!%3'-E)!%
h%3($+!-#)!g%$-6#0%>#..!%()0%"!%N#&'!))!02%Q$1"!0%5-!4X1!0%!$%.($#)!0%6::!-$!0%h%3($+!-#)!%H6&#(0MN(.61SS
²1DQF\'H%RFFDUG
-6%,JI8H62%$GULDQR
  ´$SSXQWLVXHQWLWjHWQLFKHHVWUXWWXUHLVWLWX]LRQDOLQHO6DQQLRDQWLFRµ<))(.#%"!.%7!>#)(-#6%"#%7$1"#%
"!.%>6)"6%4.(00#462%<-4+!6.65#(%!%7$6-#(%()$#4(% </,B ²
/DVVqUH-HDQ0DULH
% :??R% A()1!.%";UI#5-(I+#!%-6>(#)!YROXPHV3DULV3LFDUG
/D]]DULQL0DULD/HWL]LDHW3DROR3RFFHWWLpGV
% :??O% /.%>6)"6%!)6$-#6%$-(%T/%!%T%0!46.6%(L3L%N;#04-#G#6)!%I(.!6#$(.#4(%"(%*6-$6-(L%$WWLGHLVHPLQDULQDSROHWDQL
² 1DSOHV/RIIUHGR
 oi.uchicago.edu

:O:% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

/HMHXQH%0LFKHO
% OP@:6% @+6)U$#X1!%+#0$6-#X1!%"1%>'4U)#!)%!$%"1%5-!4%()4#!)7UDGLWLRQGHO·+XPDQLVPH3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
% E ´ <#01¶GLHX·HWODTXDWULqPHGpFOLQDLVRQLWDOLTXHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0
²
 F ´8QH()$#X1#00#>(YpQqWHOHEURQ]HYRWLIGH/R]]R$WHVWLQRµK!?1!%"!0%Q$1"!0%N($#)!0²
% OP@<% A()1!.%"!%.(%.()51!%?U)E$!,QGRJHUPDQLVFKH%LEOLRWKHN5HLKH/HKUXQG+DQGEFKHU+HLGHOEHUJ
:LQWHU
  ´1RPVRVFRRPEULHQVGHVHDX[GHVVRXUFHVHWGHVIRQWDLQHVµ'DQVN;/$(.#!%I-U-6>(#)!%!$%.(%K6>!%
-UI1&.#4(#)!L%AU.()5!0%6::!-$0%h%P(4X1!0%O!1-56)9ROXPHSS²&ROOHFWLRQGHO·eFROH)UDQoDLVH
GH5RPH5RPHeFROH)UDQoDLVHGH5RPH
-JLM6HH2%06HL%
% OP@@% N($!#)#04+!%N(1$M%1)"%F6->!).!+-!L0XQLFK&+%HFN
/K{WH%eULF
  N!0%.(>!..!0%6-(41.(#-!0%"!%H6"6)!+DXWHVeWXGHVGX0RQGH*UpFRURPDLQ*HQqYH'UR]
/KU5RVHPDULH
% :???% H#!%D!"#4+$!%"!0%7=(."!)%85#..-HQDHULQGRJHUPDQLVWLVFKH7H[WEHDUEHLWXQJ'HWWHOEDFK5|OO
0DJJLDQL$GULDQR
  ´8QDLVFUL]LRQH¶SDOHRXPEUD·GD&KLXVLµ%K#?#0$(%"#%<-4+!6.65#(²
0678HJKK82%!HH6%
  ´$WWDXV$SSLXVODWDWWDVDELQR DSSDHVXGSLFHQRDSDLR6DELQLD5RPDH¶6DILQL·QHOOHLVFUL]LRQL
VXGSLFHQHµK!0%@1&.#4(%N#$$!-(-1>2%7$1"#!0%#)%$+!%3.(00#4(.%*-("#$#6)²
  N!%#04-#G#6)#%01"I#4!)!2%/2%*!0$#)ORUHQFH2OVFKNL
0DUWLQHW$QGUp
% OPRR% Q46)6>#!%"!0%4+()5!>!)$0%I+6)U$#X1!0g%$-(#$U%"!%I+6)6.65#!%"#(4+-6)#X1!%HUQH$)UDQFNH
0DUW]ORII9LQFHQW
  ´3LFpQLHQÉ>#+%I1É+FRQWULEXWLRQjO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHVFLSSHVSDOpRVDEHOOLTXHVGH&DVWLJQDQR
$3¬ HWGH3HQQD6$QGUHD 7( µN(.#!0²
  ´/DWLQI6..#)4$6-JUHFड़໅› Ǔ SLFpQLHQጟᅵኹዘᅵዘSKUDVpRORJLHHWpODERUDWLRQSRpWLTXHµ'DQV@-64U"U0%
0')4+-6)#X1!0%"!%.(%.()51!%I6U$#X1!%!)%5-!4%!$%!)%.($#)pGLWpSDU$¬%ODQFHW(¬'XSUD]SS²
/DQJXHVHWFXOWXUHVDQFLHQQHV%UX[HOOHV6DIUDQ
  ´/HVV\QWDJPHVSLFpQLHQVI6?(#0#0%I#"(#$wI(02%>!î)$ï:#0$-wÉ%)!>w)!É2%$-!&!5#!0%$#$wɵK!?1!%"!%@+#.6.65#!2%
"!%N#$$U-($1-!%!$%";O#0$6#-!%<)4#!))!0²
0J8>>JK2%!HKF8HJ%
% OPQ<% N!%0.(?!%46>>1)qPHpG&ROOHFWLRQGH0DQXHOVGHO·,QVWLWXWG·eWXGHV6ODYHV3DULV&KDPSLRQ
0HLVHU*HUKDUG
  N(1$5!04+#4+$!%"!-%1>&-#04+!)%7I-(4+!,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW,QQVEUXFN
,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
 D &RPSWHUHQGXGH0DULQHWWLN!%#04-#G#6)#%01"I#4!)!  b-($'.60²
 E ´3lOLJQLVFK/DWHLQXQG6GSLNHQLVFKµD.6$$(²
  O#0$6-#04+!%N(1$M%1)"%F6->!).!+-!%"!-%.($!#)#04+!)%7I-(4+!'DUPVWDGW:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH
%XFKJHVHOOVFKDIW
0RUDQGL$OHVVDQGUR
  ´7UD(SLJUDILDH7RSRJUDILD1RWDVX$HTXLH6XSHUDHTXDQLµ<-4+!6.65#(%3.(00#4(²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% :OQ

1RVDUWL/RUHQ]R¬
  ´&RQLHFWDQHD,, 3DFXYLR$FFLR&RULSSR µA10!1>%@($(1#)1>²
+L99D6LM2%!>6H%
  ´7KH¶6DXVVXUH(IIHFW·LQ/DWLQDQG,WDOLFµ'DQV761)"%N(9%()"%<)(.65'g%@(I!-0%#)%O6)6-%6:%K6&!-$%7L%@L%
S!!=!0%6)%$+!%,44(0#6)%6:%O#0%|p$+%S#-$+"('pGLWpSDU$/XERWVN\SS²/HLGHQ6WXGLHVLQ,QGR
(XURSHDQ$PVWHUGDP5RGRSL
2VWKRII+HUPDQQ
  ´.OHLQH%HLWUlJH]XU'HNOLQDWLRQVOHKUHGHULQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ6SUDFKHQ¬,µ'DQVA6-I+6.65#04+!%
\)$!-014+1)5!)%(1:%"!>%D!&#!$!%"!-%#)"65!->()#04+!)%7I-(4+!)3DUWpGLWpSDU+2VWKRIIHW
.¬%UXJPDQSS²/HLS]LJ6+LU]HO
5JKJ79M6HH2%(LDJ7K%
%  ´6SULQJHQGHXQGWDQ]HQGH*|WWHUEHLPDQWLNHQ)HVWµ'DQVH(0%F!0$%1)"%"(0%O!#.#5!g%K!.#5#~0!%
b6)$-(I1)=$!%G1-%<..$(509!.$pGLWpSDU-$VVPDQQHW76XQGHUPHLHUSS²6WXGLHQ]XP
9HUVWHKHQIUHPGHU5HOLJLRQHQ*WHUVORK*HUG0RKQ
3RFFHWWL%56F>F%
  ´3HU¬XQGRVVLHUGRFXPHQWDULRGHLULIOHVVLGLGRWWULQHPLVWHULFKHHVDSLHQ]LDOLQHOOHFXOWXUHLQGLJHQH
GHOO·,WDOLDDQWLFD1RWHVXOOHLVFUL]LRQLRVFKH9H3Rµ'DQVF6->!%"#%-!.#5#60#$h%!%$-("#G#6)#%
0(I#!)G#(.#%#)%A(5)(%D-!4#(% $WWLGHOFRQYHJQR1DSROL²GLFHPEUH pGLWpSDU$&&DVVLRHW
33RFFHWWLSS²$QQDOLGHOO·,VWLWXWR8QLYHUVLWDULR2ULHQWDOHGL1DSROLILORORJLFROHWWHUDULD
3LVH,VWLWXWL(GLWRULDOLH3ROLJUDILFL,QWHUQD]LRQDOL
5LHNHQ(OLVDEHWK
% OPPP% \)$!-014+1)5!)%G1-%)6>#)(.!)%7$(>>&#."1)5%"!0%O!$+#$#04+!):LHVEDGHQ+DUUDVVRZLW]
5LQJH'RQDOG$-U
  ´7RFKDULDQ¬&ODVV,,3UHVHQWVDQG6XEMXQFWLYHVDQGWKH5HFRQVWUXFWLRQRIWKH3URWR,QGR(XURSHDQ
9HUEµ*64+(-#()%()"%/)"6M81-6I!()%7$1"#!0²
5L[+HOPXW
  ´8PEURH3URWR2VFR8PEURµ'DQVN!%.#)51!%#)"6!1-6I!!%"#%:-(>>!)$(-#(%($$!0$(G#6)!g%H#!%#)"65!->(M
)#04+!)%K!0$0I-(4+!)% $WWLGHO&RQYHJQRGHOOj6RFLHWj,WDOLDQDGL*ORWWRORJLDHGHOOD,QGRJHUPDQLVFKH
*HVHOOVFKDIW8GLQH²6HWWHPEUH pGLWpSDU(9LQHLVSS²3LVH*LDUGLQL
  ´'LH(QGXQJGHV$NNXVDWLY3OXUDOFRPPXQHLP2VNLVFKHQµ'DQV,M6MI!M-6M0#g%F!0$04+-#:$%:u-%8-)0$%
K#04+%G1>%osL%D!&1-$0$(5pGLWpSDU$(WWHUSS²%HUOLQGH*UX\WHU
 D ´/DOLQJXDGHL9ROVFLWHVWLHSDUHQWHODµe1("!-)#%"#%<-4+!6.65#(%8$-1046M/$(.#4(²
 E ´8QDILUPDSDOHRXPEUDµ<-4+#?#6%D.6$$6.65#46%/$(.#()6²
  ´2VNwI0())(>M11I0!)0XQG=XJHK|ULJHVµ'DQV7I-(4+!)%1)"%74+-#:$!)%"!0%()$#=!)%A#$$!.>!!--(1>0g%
F!0$04+-#:$%:u-%Pu-5!)%\)$!->())%G1>%|sL%D!&1-$0$(5pGLWpSDU)+HLGHUPDQQV+5L[HW(6HHEROGSS
²,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW
GHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
  ´6GSLNHQLVFK="1ÉwLY%O#0$6-#04+!%7I-(4+:6-04+1)5²
  ´9DULD]LRQLORFDOLLQRVFRµ'DQVN(%*(?6.(%"#%<5)6)!%)!.%46)$!0$6%#$(.#46g%36)?!5)6%"#%7$1"#6%^<5)6)!2%
_rq_s%(I-#.!%_ááâ`pGLWpSDU/RUHWWD'HO7XWWR3DOPDSS²)ORUHQFH/62OVFKNL
% :??:% 7(&!..#04+!%*!]$!g%H#!%*!]$!%"!0%,0=#04+!)2%\>&-#04+!)%1)"%7u"I#=!)#04+!)+HLGHOEHUJ&:LQWHU
  ´$XVJOLHGHUXQJXQG$XIJOLHGHUXQJGHULWDOLVFKHQ6SUDFKHQµ'DQVN()51(5!0%#)%@-!+#0$6-#4%81-6I!2%
pGLWpSDU$¬%DPPHVEHUJHU7¬9HQQHPDQQ0¬%LHVZDQJHUHW-¬*U]HJDSS²+HLGHOEHUJ
:LQWHU
 oi.uchicago.edu

:O<% T/B38B*%A<K*tN,FF

5RFFD*LRYDQQD
  ´,UDSSRUWLGHOODWLQRFRQOHYDULHWjLWDOLFKH,OFDVRGL6DWULFXPµ'DQV<$$#%"!.%36)?!5)6%/)$!-)(G#6)(.!%
´1RPHQ/DWLQXPµ/DWLQLH5RPDQLSULPDGL$QQLEDOH5RPD$FFDGHPLDGL6/XFD²2WWREUHIDVFL
FXOHKRUVVpULHGH81$6I#(²
5XLSpUH]0DUWtQ6%
  ´(VTXLVVHG·XQHKLVWRLUHGXYRFDOLVPHJUHFµJ6-"²
6FKPLWW5GLJHU
% OP@@% 8#):u+-1)5%#)%"#!%5-#!4+#04+!)%H#(.!=$!'DUPVWDGW:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH%XFKJHVHOOVFKDIW
6FKULMYHU3HWHU
  ´6XEVWUDWHLQIOVVHXQGKLVWRULVFKH/DXWOHKUH/DWHLQXQG6DELQLVFKµ'DQV7I-(4+=6)$(=$%1)"%
7I-(4+9()"!.2%<=$!)%"!-%i/L%F(4+$(51)5%"!-%/)"65!->()#04+!)%D!0!..04+(:$2%_oLqnrL%7!I$!>&!-%nppp2%O(..!%()%
"!-%7((.!pGLWpSDU*0HLVHUHW2+DFNVWHLQSS²:LHVEDGHQ5HLFKHUW
6FKXO]H%:LOKHOP
% OP?<% t1-%D!04+#4+$!%.($!#)#04+!-%8#5!))(>!)%HUOLQ:HLGPDQQ
6FKXPDFKHU%$KJG6H%
% :??<% H#!%=!.$#04+!)%@-#>a-?!-&!)g%8#)%?!-5.!#4+!)"!02%!$'>6.65#04+!0%1)"%>6-I+6.65#04+!0%N!]#=6),QQVEUXFNHU
%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW
,QQVEUXFN
6RPPHU)HUGLQDQGHW5DLPXQG3ILVWHU
% OP@@% O()"&14+%"!-%.($!#)#04+!)%N(1$M%1)"%F6->!).!+-!9ROXPH,8#).!#$1)5%1)"%N(1$.!+-!+HLGHOEHUJ
:LQWHU
6WXDUW6PLWK%[6HJ%
  ´7ZR6RXWK3LFHQH,QVFULSWLRQVUHUHDG&+DQG$3µ@(I!-0%6:%$+!%S-#$#0+%74+66.%($%K6>!
²
7DLOODUGDW-HDQ
  ´,PDJHVHWPDWULFHVPpWDSKRULTXHVµS1..!$#)%"!%.;<0064#($#6)%D1#..(1>!%S1"U²
1JKKJ72%)M8>%
% OPRQ% O()"&14+%"!-%#$(.#04+!)%H#(.!=$!+HLGHOEHUJ:LQWHU
18HJ2%%UHQW
  ´5HPDUNVRQWKH$UFKDLF/DWLQ¶*DULJOLDQR%RZO·,QVFULSWLRQµt!#$04+-#:$%:u-%@(I'-6.65#!%1)"%
8I#5-(I+#=²
  ´2Q)XOOJUDGH -6IRUPDWLRQVLQ*UHHNDQG,QGR(XURSHDQµ'DQV/)"6M81-6I!()%@!-0I!4$#?!0pGLWp
SDU0DUN596RXWKHUQP61-)(.%6:%/)"6M81-6I!()%7$1"#!0²
 D ´1HZ7KRXJKWVRQDQ2OG&XUVH 7DE,J9,E9,,D µ'DQV@!-%<0I!-(%("%<0$!-#0460g%
7$1"#(%/)"65!->()#4(%#)%+6)6-!>%PL%8L%K(0>100!)%0!](5!)(-##%/"#&10%A(-$##0%())6%AA/TpGLWpSDU$
+\OOHVWHG$5-¡UJHQVHQ-+/DUVVRQHW72ODQGHUSS²,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU
6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
 E ´2Q3,()XOO*UDGHVLQ6RPH=HURJUDGH&RQWH[WV $É $çµ'DQV%/)"6M81-6I!()%J6-"%F6->($#6)g%
@-64!!"#)50%6:%$+!%36):!-!)4!%O!."%($%$+!%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%36I!)+(5!)2%,4$6&!-%np$+qnn)"2%nppppGLWpSDU
-¬&ODFNVRQHW%$2OVHQSS²&RSHQKDJHQ6WXGLHVLQ,QGR(XURSHDQ&RSHQKDJHQ
0XVHXP7XVFXODQXP3UHVV
 D ´$XWRXUGHVXGSLFpQLHQX6.6:É$w-gpW\PRORJLHHWSRpWLTXHµ'DQVN(%.()51!%I6U$#X1!%#)"6M!1-6IU!))!%
$FWHVGX&ROORTXHGHWUDYDLOGHOD6RFLpWpGHVeWXGHV,QGR(XURSpHQQHV3DULV²RFWREUH 
pGLWpSDU*-3LQDXOWHW'3HWLWSS²/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
 E ´2Q¶7KXUQH\VHQ+DYHW·V/DZ·LQ/DWLQDQG,WDOLFµO#0$6-#04+!%7I-(4+:6-04+1)5²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N87%A<Ke\87%3<7\8NN87%H<B7%N87%H,3\A8B*7%@<NQ,M7<S8NN/e\87% :OR

:DOGH$ORLVHW-RKDQQ%DSWLVW+RIPDQQ
² N($!#)#04+!0%8$'>6.65#04+!0%J~-$!-&14+9ROXPH $²/  0²=  LQGH[ 
+HLGHOEHUJ:LQWHU
:DUPLQJWRQ(+
% OP<?% K!>(#)0%6:%,."%N($#)g%<-4+(#4%/)04-#I$#6)0/RHE&ODVVLFDO/LEUDU\&DPEULGJH+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
:DWNLQV%&DOYHUW
  ´(YLGHQFHLQ,WDOLFµ'DQV8?#"!)4!%:6-%N(-')5!(.0pGLWpSDU::LQWHUSS²7KH+DJXH
0RXWRQ
% OPPR% O69%$6%b#..%(%H-(56)g%<0I!4$0%6:%/8%@6!$#401HZ<RUN2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
:HLVV0LFKDHO
  ´2Q6RPH3UREOHPVRI)LQDO6\OODEOHVLQ6RXWK3LFHQHµ'DQVAÉ-%31-("g%7$1"#!0%#)%O6)6-%6:%3(.?!-$%
J($=#)0pGLWpSDU-+-DVDQRII+&0HOFKHUWHW/2OLYHUSS²,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU
6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
  ´2EVHUYDWLRQVRQWKH6RXWK3LFHQH,QVFULSWLRQ7( 62PHUR µ'DQV/)"6M81-6I!()%@!-0I!4$#?!02%
pGLWpSDU0DUN596RXWKHUQP61-)(.%6:%/)"6M81-6I!()%7$1"#!0²
  ´&XL%RQR"7KH%HQHILFLDU\3KUDVHVRIWKH7KLUG,JXYLQH7DEOHµ'DQVT!-&(%H64!)$#g%7$1"#!0%#)%
O#0$6-#4(.%()"%/)"6M81-6I!()%N#)51#0$#40%@-!0!)$!"%$6%P('%OL%P(0()6::2%&'%7$1"!)$02%36..!(51!02%()"%F-#!)"02%
pGLWpSDU$¬-1XVVEDXPSS²$QQ$UERU%HHFK6WDYH
:RGWNR'DJPDU6%ULWWD,UVOLQJHUHW&DUROLQ6FKQHLGHU
  B6>#)(%#>%/)"65!->()#04+!)%N!]#=6)+HLGHOEHUJ:LQWHU
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% F,KA<*/,B%8*%T<K/<*/,B7%H<B7%N87%7Y7*ZA87%FN8i/,BB8N7%H87%N<BD\87%7<S8NN/e\87% :O@

!"
#$%&'()$*+,(+-'%)'()$*.+/'*.+0,.+.1.(2&,.+#0,3)$**,0.+/,.+
0'*45,.+.'6,00)75,.8+,*(%,+.1*9:%$*),+,(+/)'9:%$*),

3DROR3RFFHWWL8QLYHUVLWjGL5RPD´7RU9HUJDWDµ

/HV\VWqPHGHODIOH[LRQHWOHVYDULDWLRQVGHVFDVGDQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVSHXYHQWQRXVLQWpUHVVHUVRXV
WURLVSRLQWVGHYXHGLIIpUHQWVFHTXLFRUUHVSRQGjWURLVQLYHDX[GLIIpUHQWVG·DQDO\VH'HX[GHFHVSRLQWVV·LQVFUL
YHQWGDQVODGLDFKURQLHGDQVOHVHQVGHODFRPSDUDLVRQDYHFOHVDXWUHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVHWGDQVFHOXL
GHO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXH/·DXWUHSRLQWSRUWHVXUODV\QFKURQLHHWOHVDVSHFWVJpQpUDX[GHODW\SRORJLHGHFHV
ODQJXHV2QSHXWUHSUpVHQWHUFHVGpPDUFKHVGDQVOHWDEOHDXVXLYDQW

'LDFKURQLH  UHFRQVWUXFWLRQjSDUWLUGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQ  pYROXWLRQYHUVOHVODQJXHVURPDQHV

6\QFKURQLH  LPSOLFDWLRQVW\SRORJLTXHV  YDULDWLRQVVRFLROLQJXLVWLTXHV

/HVWURLVDVSHFWVVHUDPqQHQWjXQVHXOSUREOqPHODSRVLWLRQGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVGDQVODOLJQHGLUHFWHTXL
UHOLHODEUDQFKH´LWDOLTXHµGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQGRQWOHODWLQUHSUpVHQWHOHFRPSRVDQWOHSOXVLPSRUWDQWGXSRLQW
GHYXHGHO·KLVWRLUHHWOHSOXVULFKHGXSRLQWGHYXHGHODGRFXPHQWDWLRQDX[ODQJXHVURPDQHV
/DIOH[LRQHWOHV\VWqPHGHVFDVMRXHQWXQU{OHIRQGDPHQWDOGDQVFHSDUFRXUVpWHQGXHWFRPSOH[HTXLDIIHFWH
OHF±XUPrPHGHO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHGHODSUpKLVWRLUHDX[ODQJXHVGHO·(XURSHPRGHUQH
/DOLQJXLVWLTXHFRPSDUpHDSULYLOpJLpOHGRPDLQHGHODGpFOLQDLVRQGDQVODGpILQLWLRQGHVOLHQVGHSDUHQWp
HQWUHOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVGHO·,WDOLH0DLVODUHFKHUFKHGHSDUHQWpV·HVWUpSHUFXWpHGDQVODGHVFULSWLRQ
GXV\VWqPHGHVFDVGHFHVODQJXHV'·XQF{WpOHVGpFOLQDLVRQVODWLQHVRQWDWWLUpGHSXLVORQJWHPSVO·DWWHQWLRQGHV
FRPSDUDWLVWHVHQFHTXLFRQFHUQHOHXUGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQSDUUDSSRUWjO·LQGRHXURSpHQGHO·DXWUHOHVV\VWqPHV
IOH[LRQQHOVGHVDXWUHVODQJXHVDQFLHQQHVGHO·,WDOLHRQWpWpHQYLVDJpVGDQVODSHUVSHFWLYHGHOHXUGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQ
SDUUDSSRUWDXODWLQ(QHIIHWGDQVOHVPDQXHOVGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVOHVOLJQHVPRUSKRORJLTXHVHWV\QWD[LTXHV
GHODIOH[LRQRQWpWpUHWUDFpHVSRXUPRQWUHUWDQW{WOHVFRQYHUJHQFHVWDQW{WOHVGLYHUJHQFHVSDUUDSSRUWDXODWLQ
'DQVOHGRPDLQHGHODPRUSKRORJLHOHVUHODWLRQVHQWUHODGpFOLQDLVRQODWLQHHWLWDOLTXHHWFHOOHGHVDXWUHVODQ
JXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVRQWDWWLUpDXGpEXWGXVLqFOHSDVVpO·DWWHQWLRQG·$0HLOOHWTXLDFRQVDFUpXQHpWXGHDX[
´LQQRYDWLRQVGHODGpFOLQDLVRQODWLQHµ O0HLOOHWVRXOLJQDLWTXHOHODWLQ´DpWpXQHODQJXHjWUDQVIRUPDWLRQVWUqV
UDSLGHVHWGqVOHGpEXWGHO·pSRTXHKLVWRULTXHLODSSDUDLWjXQGHJUpGHGpYHORSSHPHQWEHDXFRXSSOXVDYDQFpTXH
G·DXWUHVODQJXHVµ(QRXWUHLOVRXOLJQDLWTXH´OHV\VWqPHGHVFDVQHUHSRVHSDVG·XQHPDQLqUHLPPpGLDWHVXUOH
V\VWqPHLQGRHXURSpHQPDLVVXUXQV\VWqPHLWDOLTXHµ&HWWHSHUVSHFWLYHLOO·DUHSULVHSOXVWDUGGDQVVRQ80X1#00!%
";1)!%+#0$6#-!%"!%.(%.()51!%.($#)!RLO%DWWULEXHjODPRUSKRORJLHGHODIOH[LRQ´GHVSUHXYHVSOXVVDLVLVVDQWHVHQFRUH
GHO·XQLWpLWDOLTXHµ:FHTXHO·RQSHXWV\QWKpWLVHUGHODPDQLqUHVXLYDQWH
  /DUpGXFWLRQGHVFDWpJRULHVJUDPPDWLFDOHVTXLQ·H[SULPHQWSDVGHVUHODWLRQVV\QWD[LTXHV
F·HVWjGLUHG·DSUqVODWHUPLQRORJLHGH&RVHULXFHOOHVTXLQHVRQWSDV´UHODWLRQQHOOHVµ
  /DUpGXFWLRQGXQRPEUHGHVFDVjSDUWLUGHVKXLWFDVTX·RQUHFRQVWUXLWSRXUO·LQGR
HXURSpHQOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVPRQWUHQWXQHFRwQFLGHQFHSUHVTXHSDUIDLWHDYHFOHODWLQ
GDQVODUpGXFWLRQGHVFDVFRQYHQWLRQQHOOHPHQWDSSHOpV´FRQFUHWVµRX´VpPDQWLTXHVµSDU
RSSRVLWLRQDX[FDV´V\QWD[LTXHVµQ
  /HGpYHORSSHPHQWGHO·HPSORLGHVSUpSRVLWLRQVTXLUHPSODFHQWOHVIRQFWLRQVGHVFDV

O
0HLOOHW :
0HLOOHW

:O@
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @<,N,%@,338**/

/HSUHPLHUSRLQWPHWHQOXPLqUHGHX[IDLWVIRQGDPHQWDX[¬TXLFRQFHUQHQWOHQRPEUHHWOHJHQUHJUDPPDWLFDX[
D  /HQRPEUHJUDPPDWLFDOHVWOLPLWpjO·RSSRVLWLRQ´VLQJXOLHUaSOXULHOµ/DGLVSDULWLRQGX
GXHODSSDUWLHQWjO·pSRTXHTXLSUpFqGHOHVSUHPLqUHVDWWHVWDWLRQVGHGRFXPHQWVGDQV
WRXWHVOHVODQJXHVLWDOLTXHV
E  2QREVHUYHODWHQGDQFHjODGLVSDULWLRQGXQHXWUHFHTXLHQUHYDQFKHUHOqYHGHO·KLVWRLUH
GHFHVODQJXHV
/DUpGXFWLRQGHFHVFDWpJRULHVJUDPPDWLFDOHVVHUpSHUFXWHGDQVODUpRUJDQLVDWLRQGHODIOH[LRQFRPPHO·DYDLW
GpMjVLJQDOp$¬0HLOOHWHQVRXOLJQDQWOHOLHQSURSRUWLRQQHOHQWUHOHGpYHORSSHPHQWGXJHQUHJUDPPDWLFDOHWOH
GpYHORSSHPHQWGHODIOH[LRQ<%
(QODWLQODWHQGDQFHjODGLVSDULWLRQGXQHXWUHVHPDQLIHVWHjWUDYHUVOHVIORWWHPHQWVHQWUHQHXWUHHWPDV
FXOLQIpPLQLQWHOVTXHSDUH[HPSOHOHVGRXEOHWVODWLQVGXW\SH:6-10l:6-1>f%5.("#10l5.("#1>PDLVDXVVLGDQVOHV
FKDQJHPHQWVGHJHQUHGDQVOHVHPSUXQWVDXJUHF H[ࣹड़Ǔ࿱໵ङࢆǓ>QHXW@!JODXFࡃPD>IpP@ࢆ͘ड़‫>ߥڗ‬QHXW@!>!.10%
>PDVF@ R3DUIRLVODODQJXHOLWWpUDLUHDGLVWLQJXpVpPDQWLTXHPHQWFHVIORWWHPHQWVGHJHQUHVFRPPHGDQVODIOH[LRQ
6L%=>L78J>%.64#l.64(L7RXWHIRLVHQODWLQOHVGRXEOHWVGXW\SH:6-10l:6-1>f%5.("#10l5.("#1>%HWFSHXYHQWLPSOLTXHU
XQHUpRUJDQLVDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHQRPLQDWLIHWDFFXVDWLIGDQVODQRXYHOOHIRQFWLRQ´DFWLIaLQDFWLIµTXLVH
PDQLIHVWHHQODWLQWDUGLISDUOHGpYHORSSHPHQWGHO·DFFXVDWLIjODSODFHGXQRPLQDWLI0DLVOHVUDFLQHVGHFHWWH
pYROXWLRQUHPRQWHQWjXQHpSRTXHEHDXFRXSSOXVDQFLHQQH%
'HVWUDFHVGHFHSURFpGpVHUHWURXYHQWGDQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHV(QRVTXHRQWURXYHGHVFKDQJHPHQWVGH
JHQUHGDQVOHVHPSUXQWVRVTXH$+!0(?-w>JUHFۭ۟ٗǓ࿰‫ߥ཭ݰ‬DORUVTXHOHODWLQDJDUGpOHJHQUHRULJLQHO $+!0(1-10 
/·RPEULHQSUpVHQWHXQHH[WHQVLRQGHODPDUTXHGXPDVFXOLQDX[QHXWUHVGXSOXULHOFHTXLDPqQHjODFUpDWLRQ
GHGRXEOHWVV\QFKURQLTXHVjO·DFFXVDWLIWHOVTXH=-!>($-1l=-!>($-1:f%=(0$-1?1l=(0$-1?1:0DLVTXDQWDXQHXWUHOHV
GRQQpHVGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVVRQWSOXVFRPSOH[HVHWPpULWHQWXQHDWWHQWLRQSDUWLFXOLqUHSDUUDSSRUWDXODWLQ
GDQVODSHUVSHFWLYHGHVpYROXWLRQVURPDQHV/HWUDLWHPHQWGXQHXWUHDXSOXULHOSUpVHQWHGHVGpYHORSSHPHQWV
GLIIpUHQFLpVTXLVRQWVXERUGRQQpVDXPrPHSULQFLSH(QRVTXHOHQRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLISOXULHOGXQHXWUHSUpVHQWH
OHPrPHWUDLWHPHQWTXHOHQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUGHVWKqPHVHQčF·HVWjGLUHO·DEUpJHPHQWGHODYR\HOOHč!(%JK%
VDYpODULVDWLRQ(%Ö%M6@&HWDERXWLVVHPHQWSDUWDJpSDUO·RPEULHQHVWFRPPXQDXODWLQRLOFRQVWLWXHOHSRLQWGH
GpSDUWGHVIORWWHPHQWVWHOVTXH>!)"1>2%M#l>!)"(2%M(!f%-(I1>%M#l-(I(2%M(!&HSURFpGpPRUSKRORJLTXHHVWFRQQH[H
DX[GpYHORSSHPHQWVGXQHXWUHGDQVOHVODQJXHVURPDQHVRVXUOHSODQOH[LFDOLODSURGXLWGHVGLVWLQFWLRQVGX
W\SHGHO·LWDOLHQ:65.#6l:65.#(:6.#1>HWVXUOHSODQPRUSKRORJLTXHLOHVWFRQWLQXpGDQVODPDUTXHGXFROOHFWLI
GLVWLQFWGXSOXULHOFRPPHSDUH[HPSOHGDQVOHVGRXEOHWVGHO·LWDOLHQ&-(44#l&-(44#(&-(44+#1>LP
/·RPEULHQDWWHVWHGHVUpIHFWLRQVGHODIOH[LRQTXLGpQRQFHQWODFULVHGX´JHQUHQHXWUHµHQDQWLFLSDQWG·XQH
PDQLqUHWUqVQHWWHOHVpYROXWLRQVODWLQHV$XVLQJXOLHURQWURXYHGHVIORWWHPHQWVHQWUHODIOH[LRQGXQHXWUHHQ6%
HWFHOOHGHVWKqPHVHQčFRPPHSDUH[HPSOH!-!R.1>l!-!R.(>O?%
$XSOXULHOFRPPHRQYLHQWGHOHGLUHF·HVWO·DFFXVDWLITXLDUHoXODPrPHPDUTXHTXHODIOH[LRQGXPDVFXOLQ
FHTXLDSURGXLWGHVGRXEOHWVWHOVTXH=(0$-1?1l=(0$-1?1:(QUHYDQFKHOHQRPLQDWLISOXULHOV·HVWGRWpG·XQHWHUPL
QDLVRQ6-XQHLQQRYDWLRQGRQWO·RULJLQHHVWFRQWURYHUVpHOO­QRWUHDYLVO·H[SOLFDWLRQSURSRVpHSDU7KXUQH\VHQO:%
TXLIDLWDSSHOjXQHUpIHFWLRQDQDORJLTXHG·DSUqVOHQRPLQDWLIGHVPDVFXOLQVV·LQVFULWG·XQHPDQLqUHFRKpUHQWH
GDQVODUpRUJDQLVDWLRQGXV\VWqPHRULHQWpHYHUVXQHUpIHFWLRQWRWDOHGHODIOH[LRQGXQHXWUHG·DSUqVOHPDVFXOLQ
0DLVOHIDLWTXHOHQRPLQDWLIQHXWUHGHO·RPEULHQQ·DGPHWWHSDVGHIORWWHPHQWVHQWUHO·DQFLHQPRUSKqPHGXQHXWUH
HWOHQRXYHDXPRUSKqPHLPSOLTXHTXHOHQRPLQDWLIDLWpWpFRPSOqWHPHQWUHIDLWDSUqVTXHO·DFFXVDWLIHXWUHoXOD
PDUTXHGXPDVFXOLQ/DSUpVHUYDWLRQGHO·DQFLHQQHWHUPLQDLVRQGXQHXWUHjO·DFFXVDWLISOXW{WTX·DXQRPLQDWLI
HVWOLpHDXU{OHVpPDQWLFRV\QWD[LTXHMRXpSDU´OHFDVGHO·REMHWµFHTXLV·LQVFULWGDQVODPrPHWHQGDQFHTXHOH
GpYHORSSHPHQWGHFHFDVPDQLIHVWpHQODWLQWDUGLIOQ

Q
$XVXMHWGHFHWWHWHUPLQRORJLHHWGHVWKpRULHVVRXVMDFHQWHVFI 
­FHVXMHWOHPpPRLUHGH7HUUDFLQLHVWWRXMRXUVXWLOH
6HUEDWII P
6XUOHVFRQWLQXDWHXUVGXQHXWUHGDQVOHVODQJXHVURPDQHVFI0DJQL
<
&I0HLOOHW 
R
&I$QGUp¬ O?
&I8QWHUPDQQVY´HUHoOXPµ

&I5RYDL OO
8QHGLVFXVVLRQTXLUHPHWHQFDXVHO·H[SOLFDWLRQGH7KXUQH\VHQ
@
(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHFHWUDLWHPHQWYRLU/HMHXQHPDLVODILOLqUH VHWURXYHGDQV'HYRWR
FRUUHFWH DEUqJHPHQWSXLVYpODULVDWLRQ HVWFHOOHVXJJpUpHSDU&LSULD O:
7KXUQH\VHQ&I0HLVHU
QR0DQFLQLI OQ
­FHVXMHWFI5RYDLHW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% F,KA<*/,B%8*%T<K/<*/,B7%H<B7%N87%7Y7*ZA87%FN8i/,BB8N7%H87%N<BD\87%7<S8NN/e\87% :OP

(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHOHSRLQW  F·HVWjGLUHODUpGXFWLRQGXQRPEUHGHVFDVFRQYHQWLRQQHOOHPHQWDSSHOpV
´FRQFUHWVµRX´VpPDQWLTXHVµ OHODWLQHWOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVPRQWUHQWGHVFRQYHUJHQFHVTXLHQSDUWLHUHPRQ
WHQWjO·pSRTXHSUpGRFXPHQWDLUHHWHQSDUWLHDSSDUWLHQQHQWjO·pSRTXHKLVWRULTXH
­O·DXEHGHODGRFXPHQWDWLRQUHPRQWHO·XQGHVIDLWVUHFRQQXVGHSXLVORQJWHPSVFRPPH´SUHXYHVDLVLVVDQWHGH
O·XQLWpLWDOLTXHµO<QRWDPPHQWOHV\QFUpWLVPHGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOHWGHO·DEODWLI(QHIIHWFHSKpQRPqQHUHSUpVHQWH
ODFRQYHUJHQFHODSOXVDQFLHQQHHQWUHODGpFOLQDLVRQODWLQHHWFHOOHGHO·RVFRRPEULHQjWUDYHUVOHPrPHSDUFRXUV
$XVLQJXOLHUF·HVWODIRUPHGHO·DEODWLITXLV·HVWFRQVHUYpHjSDUWLUGHVWKqPHVHQ 6M3DUOjODWHUPLQDLVRQ
FRQVRQDQWLTXH"V·HVWpWHQGXHDX[DXWUHVWKqPHV HQ čHWHQ#M $XSOXULHOLO\DXQSDUDOOpOLVPHHQFRUHSOXV
VDLVLVVDQWHQWUHODWLQHWODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVSDUFHTXHODGpVLQHQFHGHO·DQFLHQLQVWUXPHQWDOV·HVWLPSRVpHDX[
GpSHQVGHFHOOHVGHO·DEODWLIGXGDWLIHWGXORFDWLI8QHIRLVGHSOXVOHSRLQWGHGpSDUWFHVRQWOHVWKqPHVHQ 6M2%
G·RO·LQQRYDWLRQV·HVWpWHQGXHDX[WKqPHVHQčHWDVHUYLFRPPHPRGqOHSRXUOHVWKqPHVHQ#MHWHQFRQVRQQH
TXLRQWLQWURGXLWOHPRUSKqPH #M&+60
2QSHXWV\QWKpWLVHUGDQVOHVFKpPDVXLYDQWOHSURFpGpGX´V\QFUpWLVPHµGHVIRUPHVHWGHVIRQFWLRQVORFDUDF
WpULVDQWOHVPDUTXHVGHO·DEODWLIGXVLQJXOLHUHWGXSOXULHOGDQVODIOH[LRQODWLQHHWVDEHOOLTXH

WKqPHVHQč WKqPHVHQ6M% WKqPHVHQ#MFRQVRQQH

7#)51.#!-

č" ో ‫گ‬G ౏ M!"

@.1-#!.
#&+60
M(#0 ో 6#0
GDWLIోLQVWUXPHQWDO౏DEODWLI

'DQVFHGpYHORSSHPHQWTXLDGHVUDFLQHVWUqVDQFLHQQHVLOIDXWVRXOLJQHUODIRUFHG·DWWUDFWLRQH[HUFpHSDUOHV
WKqPHVHQ6MVXUOHVDXWUHVSDUDGLJPHVGHODIOH[LRQ/DIRUFHFHQWULSqWHGHVWKqPHVHQ6MVXUOHVDXWUHVWKqPHV
FDUDFWpULVHOHFRXUVHQWLHUGHO·KLVWRLUHQRQVHXOHPHQWGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVPDLVGDQVXQHFHUWDLQHPHVXUH
DXVVLGXODWLQHWVHUHWURXYHjODEDVHGHVpYROXWLRQVURPDQHV
/DTXHVWLRQGHODIRUPDWLRQGHO·DEODWLIODWLQHWVDEHOOLTXHSDUUDSSRUWDX´V\QFUpWLVPHµDYHFO·LQVWUXPHQWDO
HVWOLpHVWULFWHPHQWjODIRUPDWLRQGHVDGYHUEHVHQ̒G/·H[SOLFDWLRQGHFHPRUSKqPHGHVDGYHUEHVFRPPXQDX
ODWLQHWDX[ODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVHVWFRQWURYHUVpH(QHIIHWOHVJUDPPDLUHVKLVWRULTXHVGXODWLQKpVLWHQWHQWUHGHX[
VROXWLRQVGLIIpUHQWHVO·XQHGHWUDGLWLRQDOOHPDQGHIXWLQDXJXUpHSDU%UXJPDQQTXLUDPHQDLWFHWWHWHUPLQDLVRQ
jXQDEODWLIDYHFDSRSKRQLH̒G‫گ‬G'DQVFHFDVODFRQVRQQHILQDOHVHUDLWRULJLQHOOH PDLVOHVGHX[YDULDQWHV
GHODWHUPLQDLVRQGHO·DEODWLIVHVHUDLHQWGLVWULEXpHVjXQHpSRTXHSURWRLWDOLTXHHQWUHODIOH[LRQGHVQRPVHW¬OD
IRUPDWLRQGHVDGYHUEHV
/·DXWUHVROXWLRQGHWUDGLWLRQIUDQoDLVHIXWSURSRVpHSDU$0HLOOHWTXL\UHFRQQXWODWHUPLQDLVRQGHO·DQFLHQ
LQVWUXPHQWDOTXLDVHUYLjODIRUPDWLRQGHVDGYHUEHVGDQVG·DXWUHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVFRPPHOHYLHX[VODYH
HWOHJUHFO@'DQVFHWWHSHUVSHFWLYHOHM"%ILQDOFRQVHUYpHQODWLQDUFKDwTXHHWDXPRLQVGDQVXQFHUWDLQQRPEUH
G·DWWHVWDWLRQVVDEHOOLTXHVQHSURYLHQGUDLWTXHGHO·DQDORJLHDYHFOHVIRUPHVGHO·DEODWLIVLQJXOLHUROHM"%9TJ9K%
UpSDQGXGDQVWRXVOHVWKqPHVGHODGpFOLQDLVRQODWLQHHWVDEHOOLTXH7RXWHIRLVFHWWHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQQHGHYLHQW
SOXVSRVVLEOHVLO·RQFRQVLGqUHOHVIRUPDWLRQVGXYLHX[VODYHHWDXVVLGXEDOWLTXHFRPPHLVVXHVG·XQORFDWLIHWVL
O·RQHQYLVDJHOHPRUSKqPHGHVDGYHUEHVJUHFV ङङߥ FRPPHLVVXGHO·DEODWLI
/HVGHX[H[SOLFDWLRQVRQWGHX[FRQVpTXHQFHVGLIIpUHQWHVO·XQHVXSSRVHTXHOHVGHX[JURXSHVGHODQJXHVRQW
SRVVpGpMXVTX·jXQPRPHQWGRQQpGHOHXUKLVWRLUHOHFDVLQVWUXPHQWDOTXLDYDQWRXHQSDUDOOqOHDX´V\QFUpWLVPHµ
DYHFO·DEODWLIIXWDVVXMHWWLjXQSURFpGpFRPPXQGHJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQSRXUVHUYLUXQLTXHPHQWjODIRUPDWLRQ
GHVDGYHUEHV

O<
&I0HLOOHW O@
&HWWHLGpHH[SRVpHGDQV0HLOOHW%VHUHWURXYHGDQVOHVWUDLWpV
OR
/HVDVSHFWVHWOHVHQMHX[GXV\QFUpWLVPHGHVFDVVRQWWURSYDVWHV GHJUDPPDLUHFRPSDUpHGHWUDGLWLRQIUDQoDLVHWHOOHVTXH0HLOOHW
SRXUrWUHDERUGpVLFL2QVHERUQHjUHQYR\HUSRXUOHVOLJQHVHVVHQ 9HQGU\HV(UQRXW
WLHOOHVj&ROHPDQ6HUEDW0HLVHU 
&I5L[

&·HVWODVROXWLRQDGRSWpHSDUH[SDU/HXPDQQ%.OLQ
JHQVFKPLWW%
 oi.uchicago.edu

::?% @<,N,%@,338**/

/·DXWUHLPSOLTXHO·H[WHQVLRQGXPRUSKqPHGHO·DEODWLIGHWRXWHFODVVHIOH[LRQQHOOHjODIRUPDWLRQGHVDGYHUEHV
­FHWpJDUGOHODWLQHWOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVSUpVHQWHQWXQHFRQYHUJHQFHWUqVSURQRQFpHGDQVODIRUPDWLRQGHV
DGYHUEHVSDUOHVPRUSKqPHVGHO·DEODWLI/DUHODWLRQDYHFO·DEODWLIHVWVLJQDOpHDXVVLDXQLYHDXV\QFKURQLTXHSDUOHV
IORWWHPHQWVHQWUHOHPRUSKqPH̒̒GHWOHVWHUPLQDLVRQVFRXUDQWHV ‫گ‬GčG GHO·DEODWLIVLQJXOLHUGHODIOH[LRQ
QRPLQDOHFHTXLHVWUpYpOpSDUOHVQRPEUHX[GRXEOHWVG·DGYHUEHVODWLQVVHWHUPLQDQWHQ̒JK%JH‫گ‬JK%=67GF89%JH%
č H[UHFW̒UHFW‫گ‬FHUW̒FHUW‫گ‬XOWU‫گ‬XOWUč (QG·DXWUHVWHUPHV̒QHUHSUpVHQWHV\QFKURQLTXHPHQWTX·XQDOOR
PRUSKHGH‫گ‬0DLVFHPrPHU{OHHVWLPSOLTXpDXVVLGLDFKURQLTXHPHQWGDQVO·RULJLQHGX̒HWVHORQO·H[SOLFDWLRQ
GH0HLOOHWHWVHORQFHOOHGH%UXJPDQQ
(QRXWUHV\QFKURQLTXHPHQWO·LQWHUFKDQJHDELOLWpHQWUH̒‫گ‬HWčGDQVODWHUPLQDLVRQGHVDGYHUEHVVHFRQVWDWH
G·XQHPDQLqUHFRQWUDVWLYHHQWUHOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVHWOHODWLQ3DUH[HPSOHRQWURXYHHQRPEULHQ(I!+$-!%
U(IM!=M$ ! U̒G RXҸG ´GHGHKRUV´YLVjYLVGHO·RVTXH!+$-(" !=M$ ! UčG ODWLQH[WUč 'DQVFHFDVOHODWLQHW
O·RVTXHPRQWUHQWXQHFRQYHUJHQFHGDQVO·HPSORLGHčGVHGLVWLQJXDQWGHO·RPEULHQTXLSUpVHQWH̒GҸG,QYHU
VHPHQWO·RVTXHHWOHODWLQVHGLIIpUHQFLHQWGDQVODGLVWULEXWLRQGH‫گ‬GHWGHčGjSDUWLUGHODPrPHEDVHWHOOHTXH
O·RVTXH46)$-1"% FRQWU‫گ‬G HQFRUUHVSRQGDQFHDYHFOHODWLQ46)$-(% FRQWUčG OP2QSHXWV\QWKpWLVHUOHVIDLWVV\Q
FKURQLTXHVFRQFHUQDQWODIRUPDWLRQGHVDGYHUEHVHQODWLQHWGDQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVVHORQOHVFKpPDVXLYDQW

-6K8H% /DQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHV

̒G೏౏ 4!-$!% I-1:!

‫گ‬G೏౏ 4!-$6 46)$-1"
čG೏౏ 46)$-(2%!]$-( !+$-("

/HVIDLWVTX·RQYLHQWG·HVTXLVVHURQWGHVUHWRPEpHVLPSRUWDQWHVGDQVODSHUVSHFWLYHDXVVLELHQIRQFWLRQQHOOH
TX·KLVWRULTXH(QODWLQHWGDQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVODIRUPDWLRQGHVDGYHUEHVVHWURXYHjPLFKHPLQHQWUH
IOH[LRQHWGpULYDWLRQOH[LFDOHG·XQHPDQLqUHSOXVQHWWHTXHGDQVG·DXWUHVODQJXHV&HSDUFRXUVTXLVHPDQLIHVWH
WUqVFODLUHPHQWHQV\QFKURQLHVHUHFRQVWUXLWDLVpPHQWDXVVLHQGLDFKURQLHRV·REVHUYHQWOHVUHODWLRQVHQWUHOHV
IRQFWLRQVHWOHVPRUSKqPHVGHO·DQFLHQLQVWUXPHQWDOHWFHX[GHO·DEODWLI
3RXUUHYHQLUDXSRLQW O·DXWUHIDLWUHPDUTXDEOHFRQFHUQDQWODUpGXFWLRQGHVFDVFRQYHQWLRQQHOOHPHQWDSSH
OpV´FRQFUHWVµRX´VpPDQWLTXHVµTX·RQSHXWVDLVLUDXFRXUVGHO·KLVWRLUHGXODWLQHWGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVHVW
UHSUpVHQWpSDUOD´FULVHµGXORFDWLIPDQLIHVWpHSDUODWHQGDQFHDXUHPSODFHPHQWSDUO·HPSORLGHVSUpSRVLWLRQV
RXGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQV&HWWHWHQGDQFHVHGpYHORSSHHQSDUWLHHQSDUDOOqOHHQSDUWLHGLIIpUHPPHQWHQODWLQHWGDQV
OHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHV&RPPHRQOHVDLWHQODWLQOHORFDWLIDXQHPSORLWUqVUpGXLWTXLHVWHQFRQFXUUHQFHDYHF
O·DEODWLIHWDYHFOHVWRXUQXUHVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHV/HORFDWLIDJDUGpXQHFHUWDLQHYLWDOLWpGDQVOHVQRPVSURSUHV
SOXW{WTXHGDQVOHVQRPVFRPPXQVRLOQ·HVWFRQVHUYpTXHGDQVWUqVSHXGHPRWVHPSOR\pVFRPPHH[SUHVVLRQV
ILJpHVVWULFWHPHQWOLpHVjFHUWDLQVFRQWH[WHVSRXUYXVGHVHQVILJXUpV WHOVTXH+1>#2%-1-#2%"6>#2%>#.#$#(! 
'DQVOHGRPDLQHGHVQRPVSURSUHVOHODWLQDSSOLTXHOHORFDWLISUHVTXHH[FOXVLYHPHQWDX[QRPVGHVYLOOHVHW
GHVSHWLWHVvOHVPDLVDYHFGHVUHVWULFWLRQVVDLVLVVDQWHVD LOQ·HVWHPSOR\pTX·DXVLQJXOLHUHWGDQVOHVQRPVDSSDU
WHQDQWDX[WKqPHVHQčHWHQ6M ,qUH%JK%**qPHGpFOLQDLVRQV DORUVTXHOHVDXWUHVWKqPHV FRQFUqWHPHQWFHX[GHOD
***qPHGpFOLQDLVRQ VDXITXHOTXHVH[FHSWLRQV:?XWLOLVHQWO·DEODWLI¬VDQVSUpSRVLWLRQE OHQRPDXORFDWLIQHSHXWSDV
rWUHDFFRPSDJQpSDUXQHGpWHUPLQDWLRQDGMHFWLYDOHRXQRPLQDOHHQFHFDVRQWURXYHO·DEODWLIDYHFSUpSRVLWLRQ
(QUHYDQFKHDXSOXULHOFHVGLVWLQFWLRQVQHV·DSSOLTXHQWSDVSDUFHTXHF·HVWOHGDWLIDEODWLITXLV·LPSRVHSDU
WRXW&HWWHUqJOHDLQVLGpFULWHGDQVOHVJUDPPDLUHVSHXWrWUHLOOXVWUpHGHODPDQLqUHVXLYDQWH

VLQJ ೏౏೏<.!]()"-#(!%ñ%#)%1-&!%<.!]()"-#(f%#)%#I0(%<.!]()"-#(%FL%<.!]()"-#(!2%#)%#I0(%1-&!
SOXU ೏౏೏<$+!)#0 ñ%#)%1-&!%<$+!)#0f%#)%#I0#0%<$+!)#0

7RXWHIRLVOHFDVORFDWLIVHSUpVHQWHGHWUqVERQQHKHXUHHQFRQFXUUHQFHDYHFO·DEODWLI DYHFRXVDQVSUpSRVL
WLRQ jO·LQWpULHXUG·XQPrPHRXYUDJHFRPPHOHVLJQDOHQWOHVIORWWHPHQWVHQWUHA(5)!0#(! ORFDWLI HW*(-062%<--!$#6%
DEODWLI FKH]9LWUXYHRXFKH]9DUURQHQWUH<!5'I$#%JK%#)%N($#6GDQVOHH!%.#)51(%N($#)(%FL%JHK7J%@!.6I6))!0#%JK%#)%
/$(.#(%GDQVOHH!%-!%-10$#4(:O

OP
 5DSSHORQV TXH OH ODWLQ SUpVHQWH FRQWU‫ گ‬LVVX GH FRQWU‫گ‬G FRPPH :?
&I5LHPDQQ
46)$-1"%GHO·RVTXH GDQVOHFRPSRVpFRQWU‫گ‬YHUVLD :O
/|IVWHGW,,
 oi.uchicago.edu

% F,KA<*/,B%8*%T<K/<*/,B7%H<B7%N87%7Y7*ZA87%FN8i/,BB8N7%H87%N<BD\87%7<S8NN/e\87% ::O

/HVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVPRQWUHQWXQHYLWDOLWpGXORFDWLISOXVSURQRQFpHGDQVOHVQRPVFRPPXQVHWKRUVGHV
H[SUHVVLRQVILJpHV(QRXWUHjODGLIIpUHQFHGXODWLQHOOHVDGPHWWHQWODFRQFRUGDQFHV\QWD[LTXHDXORFDWLIGDQV
OHVV\QWDJPHVQRPLQDX[WHOVTXHSDUH[HPSOHHQRVTXH>wÉ)#=!É%$!-!É´GDQVOHVROFRPPXQµ?#(É%>!:#(É´GDQVOD
UXHPR\HQQHµ&HSHQGDQWFHVODQJXHVPDQLIHVWHQWHQPrPHWHPSVXQHWHQGDQFHSURQRQFpHDXUHPSODFHPHQW
GHFHFDVSDUO·HPSORLGHSDUWLFXOHVWDQW{WDQWpSRVpHVWDQW{WSRVWSRVpHV
'·DLOOHXUVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVGDQVOHVIRQFWLRQVGHVFDV´FRQFUHWVµSUpVHQWHQWXQHYLWDOLWpGHVSRVWSRVL
WLRQVEHDXFRXSSOXVJUDQGHTX·HQODWLQRO·HPSORLGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVQ·HVWFRQVHUYpTXHGDQVGHVFLUFRQVWDQFHV
IRUWOLPLWpHV H[OHVSURQRPVX1#&1041>2%>!41> HWGDQVGHVIRUPHVϮJpHVG·DGYHUEHV H[0!>I!-2%I(1.#0I!- 'H
FHSRLQWGHYXHOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVVRQWDSSDUHPPHQWSOXVϮGqOHVjODFODVVLϮFDWLRQW\SRORJLTXHLPSOLTXpH
XQLYHUVHOOHPHQWSDUOHVODQJXHVFDUDFWpULVpHVSDUO·RUGUHV\QWD[LTXH629VHORQOHVFULWqUHVϮ[pVSDU*UHHQEHUJ::%
0DLVVRXVG DXWUHVSRLQWVGHYXHODGLVWULEXWLRQHQWUHSUpSRVLWLRQVHWSRVWSRVLWLRQVQ·HVWSDVWRXMRXUVFRKpUHQWHHW
HOOHHVWDVVXMHWWLHjGHVGpYHORSSHPHQWVGLϸpUHQWVHQRVTXHHWHQRPEULHQ/HVYDULDWLRQVVW\OLVWLTXHVG·XQWH[WHj
O·DXWUHRQWMRXpXQU{OHLPSRUWDQWGDQVODGLVWULEXWLRQGLϸpUHQWHGHVSUpSRVLWLRQVHWGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQV&HQ·HVWSDV
SDUKDVDUGTXHSDUPLOHVWH[WHVRPEULHQVVHXOHVOHV*(&.!0%";/51?#1>VRLHQWWUqVULFKHVHQSRVWSRVLWLRQVDORUVTXH
OHVDXWUHVWH[WHVGHO·RPEULHQQHOHVFRQQDLVVHQWSDV2QDO·LPSUHVVLRQTXHOHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVUHOqYHQWG·XQpWDWGH
ODQJXHSOXVDUFKDwTXHTXLHVWPLHX[FRQVHUYpGDQVFHUWDLQVW\SHVGHWH[WHV ULWXHOVUHOLJLHX[IRUPXOHVRϲFLHOOHV 
8QGpYHORSSHPHQWWRXWjIDLWVDLVLVVDQWGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVTXLHVWFRPPXQjO·RVTXHHWjO·RPEULHQFRQVLVWH
HQODUpSpWLWLRQGHODPrPHSDUWLFXOHSRVWSRVpHGDQVOHVGHX[pOpPHQWVG·XQV\QWDJPHQRPLQDODYHFO·REVFXUFLV
VHPHQWGHODGpVLQHQFHRULJLQHOOH7RXWDGMHFWLISHXWDGPHWWUHODSRVWSRVLWLRQUpSpWpHGDQVOHVGHX[FRPSRVDQWV
GXV\QWDJPHQRPLQDOFRPPHOHPRQWUHQWOHVGLYHUVDGMHFWLIVGDQVOHVV\QWDJPHV+w-$#É)%=!--#É)´GDQVO·HQFORV
VDFUpGH&pUqVµۭ‫ڗ‬࿰F͘ဎ—͘˗Ԇ໵͘ဎ:Q´VRXVVD>!""#=#(µ UpIOH[LI HW!0>!)%?!I!$!)´GDQVFHWWHSLHUUHµ GpLFWLTXH :<%
/DUpSpWLWLRQGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQUHPRQWHjXQHpSRTXHWUqVDQFLHQQHSDUFHTX·HOOHVHWURXYHGpMjGDQVOHVLQV
FULSWLRQVVXGSLFpQLHQQHVSDUH[HPSOHOHVV\QWDJPHV!0>!)%?!I!$!)´GDQVFHWWHSLHUUHµ6>&-#É!)%(=-!)´GDQVOD
UpJLRQRPEULHQQHµ:R
'HFHWWHPDQLqUHODSRVWSRVLWLRQUpSpWpHGHYLHQWXQYpULWDEOH´PDUTXHXUGHFDVµTXLV\QFKURQLTXHPHQW
IRQFWLRQQHFRPPHODGpVLQHQFHRULJLQHOOHPDUTXDQWODFRQFRUGDQFHV\QWD[LTXHH[+w-$#É)%=!--#É)´GDQVO·HQFORV
VDFUpGH&pUqVµa>wÉ)#=!É%$!-!É´GDQVOHVROFRPPXQµ%
7RXWHIRLVFHWHPSORLQ·HVWSDVODUqJOHSDUFHTXHO·RQWURXYHGHVV\QWDJPHVQRPLQDX[VDQVUpSpWLWLRQGHOD
SDUWLFXOHSRVWSRVpH H[HQRPEULHQ164146>%#61#1´GDQVOHERLVVDFUpGH,XSSLWHUµ:@%?!-#046%*-!&.()#-´SUqVGHOD
=F7KJ%*-!&1.()(Y 
(QRXWUHO·HPSORLGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQVHWURXYHHQFRQFXUUHQFHWDQW{WDYHFOHVSUpSRVLWLRQV VXLYLHVGXORFDWLI
RXGHO·DEODWLI WDQW{WDYHFOHORFDWLIWRXWVLPSOHPHQW2QFRQIURQWHUDSDUH[HPSOHOHVFRXSOHVGHVIRUPXOHVpSR
Q\PHVWHOOHVTX·HQRPEULHQ>(-6)($!# ORFDWLI :Pa01%>(-6)($6 SUpSRVLWLRQDEODWLI Q?´VRXVOH>(-6)($10 GH; µHW
HQRVTXH>!""#=#(# ORFDWLI QOaۭ࿰›—͘˗Ԇ໵ԆǓԆ SUpSRVLWLRQORFDWLI ´VRXVOD>!""#=#( GH; µQ:aۭ‫ڗ‬࿰F͘ဎ—͘˗Ԇ໵͘ဎ´VRXV
96%>!""#=#(µ SRVWSRVLWLRQUpSpWpH QQ&HVIORWWHPHQWVVHWURXYHQWGpMjGDQVODGRFXPHQWDWLRQODSOXVDQFLHQQH
FRPPHOHPRQWUHQWOHVFRXSOHVGXPrPHV\QWDJPHHQVXGSLFpQLHQ!0>!)%?!I!$!) SRVWSRVLWLRQUpSpWpH a!0@
>!É%?Z!I!$!É ORFDWLI ´GDQVFHWWHSLHUUHµQ<'HPrPHHQRPEULHQRQWURXYH?1=! ORFDWLI QR%JK%?1=1=1>W164146>%
DEODWLISRVWSRVLWLRQ HWFRPPHYDULDQWHVGDQVGHVUpGDFWLRQVGLYHUVHVGXPrPHWH[WH$NH‫ޝ‬XQLH ORFDWLI Q@%JK%
<4!-06)#!> DEODWLISRVWSRVLWLRQ 
­FHVXMHWVLJQDORQVO·HPSORLHOOLSWLTXHGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQDYHFOHJpQLWLIGXGpWHUPLQDQWFRPPHGDQVOHJUDI
ILWHGH3RPSpLA((>##!#0! )%$-#É&1> ´GDQV ODPDLVRQ GHA(>#10 FKH]A(>#10µQP0DLVGHPDQLqUHVLJQLILFDWLYH

::
(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHOHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVHQRVTXHHWHQRPEULHQFI QO
5L[67&S&S
1RFHQWLQLI Q:
5L[67/X
:Q
5L[676S/X QQ
5L[67/X
:<
5L[676S7( Q<
5L[675,
:R
5L[676S&+ QR
7,,,,

$WWHVWpVUHVSHFWLYHPHQWGDQVOHEURQ]HG·$JQRQHHWGDQVOHFLSSH 
7,,E9,E
G·$EHOOD Q@
7,,E
:@
7,9,E 
7,9,,D

7,9,D QP
5L[673R/HWH[WHIDLWDOOXVLRQjGHVIrWHVGpGLpHVjODGpHVVH
:P
5L[678P 0pILWLVTXLVRQWFpOpEUpHVGDQVODPDLVRQG·XQA(>#10­FHVXMHWRQ
Q?
5L[678P UHQYRLHj3RFFHWWL
 oi.uchicago.edu

:::% @<,N,%@,338**/

RQQHWURXYHMDPDLVFHWHPSORLHOOLSWLTXHGDQVOHVIRUPXOHVpSRQ\PHVGXW\SH H!=#!#0!)%O!-#!#0!) VFLO>!"#=#(# 

´VRXV OD>!""#=#( GH'HFLXV+HULXVµ&·HVWGRQFODYDULDWLRQGHVWH[WHVHWGHVFRQWH[WHVTXLGpWHUPLQHOHFKRL[
HQWUHOHVGLYHUVPR\HQVG·H[SUHVVLRQGHODORFDOLVDWLRQVSDWLRWHPSRUHOOH
(QVRPPHOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVSUpVHQWHQWGDQVXQHGRFXPHQWDWLRQELHQSOXVOLPLWpHTXHOHODWLQXQH
YDULpWpEHDXFRXSSOXVVDLVLVVDQWHG·H[SUHVVLRQVSRXUODORFDOLVDWLRQVSDWLRWHPSRUHOOH'·XQF{WpO·HPSORLGHV
SRVWSRVLWLRQVFRQIqUHDX[ODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVXQDVSHFWSOXVDUFKDwTXHHWSOXVFRKpUHQWTXHODODQJXHGH5RPH
SDUUDSSRUWDX[FDUDFWqUHVW\SRORJLTXHVUHTXLVSDUOHVODQJXHV6290DLVGHO·DXWUHF{WpOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHV
RQWGpYHORSSpO·HPSORLGHVSDUWLFXOHVSRVWSRVpHVG·XQHPDQLqUHWRXWjIDLWVSpFLILTXHHWWUqVOLEUHDXFRXUVGH
OHXUKLVWRLUHO·LQVFULYDQWGDQVOHFDGUHGHOHXUVYDULDWLRQVGLDV\VWpPLTXHV
/·HPSORLGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVHVWSUpGRPLQDQWGDQVOHVLQGLFDWLRQVGHOLHXHWWRXWVSpFLDOHPHQWHQIRQFWLRQGH
ORFDWLI(QPrPHWHPSVO·HPSORLGHFHFDVG·XQHPDQLqUHSOXVSURIRQGHTXHG·DXWUHVIRQFWLRQVV\QWD[LTXHVD
VXELGHWUqVERQQHKHXUHODFRQFXUUHQFHG·DXWUHVPR\HQVG·H[SUHVVLRQWHOVTXHO·HPSORLGHSDUWLFXOHVGLYHUVHV
WDQW{WDQWpSRVpHVWDQW{WSRVWSRVpHVDLQVLTXHG·DXWUHVFDVWHOVTXHFRPPHRQOHYHUUDSOXVORLQO·DEODWLI VDQV
RXDYHFSUpSRVLWLRQ HQFRQYHUJHQFHDYHFOHODWLQ(QFRQFOXVLRQOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVFRQWLQXHQWGDQVOHV
SRVWSRVLWLRQVXQXVDJHWUqVDQFLHQTX·HOOHVRQWGpYHORSSpG·XQHPDQLqUHWRXWjIDLWDXWRQRPHHWHQIRQFWLRQ
G·XQpTXLOLEUHQRXYHDXSDUUDSSRUWDX[LQQRYDWLRQVGXV\VWqPHPRUSKRORJLTXH
/·HPSORLGHVSUpSRVLWLRQVSRVWSRVLWLRQVEHDXFRXSSOXVOLEUHHWGLYHUVLILpTX·HQODWLQGXSRLQWGHYXHV\Q
FKURQLTXHHWGLDFKURQLTXHVHPDQLIHVWHSDUOHVIDLWVVXLYDQWV
(  /·HPSORLG·XQHPrPHSDUWLFXOHDQWpSRVpHHQRVTXHHWSRVWSRVpHHQRPEULHQH[RVTXH
(G%+w-$w>%ñ%FMD78JHDVDPD‫ޝ‬RVTXH46>%I-!#?($1"%ñ%FMD78JH%?1=1=1>L
&  /HVIORWWHPHQWVHQWUHDQWpSRVLWLRQHWSRVWSRVLWLRQG·XQHPrPHSDUWLFXOHjO·LQWpULHXUG·XQ
PrPHWH[WHH[HPSOHGDQVODORLRVTXHGH%DQWLD¬!)%!#$1(0%ñ%4!)0$6>!)L%
4  /·HPSORLGHGLYHUVHVSDUWLFXOHVDQWpSRVpHVRXSRVWSRVpHVSRXUODPrPHIRQFWLRQH[
>!"#=#(# ORFDWLI 01I%>!"#=#(# SUpSRVLWLRQ01IORFDWLI >!"#=!) SRVWSRVLWLRQ!)FRPPH
´PDUTXHXUGHFDVµ 
"  /·HPSORLGHGLYHUVHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVFRPPH´PDUTXHXUVGHFDVµSRXUODPrPHIRQFWLRQH[
FMD78JH%?1=1=1%#61#1´GDQVOHERLVVDFUpGH- Xႃ SSLWHUµ SRVWSRVLWLRQ=6> RVTXH+w-$#É)%
=!--#É)´GDQVO·HQFORVVDFUpGH&pUqVµ SRVWSRVLWLRQ!) 
!  /HVGpYHORSSHPHQWVGHVHQVGLIIpUHQWGHODPrPHSDUWLFXOHSRVWSRVpHV·DFFRPSDJQDQW
GXPrPHFDVWHOVTXHSDUH[HPSOHHQRVTXH!)DEODWLI!](#04!)%.#5#0´GDQVFHVORLVµa
!#014!)%G#41.1"´jSDUWLUGHFHMRXUOjµ
:  /HVGLYHUVHVIRQFWLRQVGHODPrPHSDUWLFXOHDQWpSRVpH¬SDUUDSSRUWjODYDULDWLRQGHVFDV
3DUH[HPSOHHQRPEULHQ!)DFFXVDWLIH[SULPHODGLUHFWLRQ H[?1=1>!)%!01)1>!)´ VH
UHQGUH GDQVOHERLVVDFUpYHUVOHVDFULILFHµ<?DORUVTXH!)FRPPH´PDUTXHXUGHFDVµHQ
IRQFWLRQGHORFDWLILQGLTXHODORFDOLVDWLRQ H[<4!-06)#!)´GDQVOHVLWHGH$FHGRQLDµ <O%
GHPrPHTX·HQRVTXH H[+w-$#É)%=!--#É)´GDQVO·HQFORVVDFUpGH&pUqVµ (QUHYDQFKHHQ
RVTXH!)DEODWLIPDUTXHOHSRLQWGHGpSDUW H[!#014!)%G#41.1"%´jSDUWLUGHFHMRXUOjµ 
FHTXLVHUDLWH[SULPpHQODWLQSDUODSUpSRVLWLRQ(l(& H[(&%!6%"#! 
&RPPHFRQVpTXHQFHGH" ! HW: XQHFRQYHUJHQFHHQWUHOHVIRQFWLRQVGHGLYHUVHVSDUWLFXOHV DQWpSRVpHV
RXSRVWSRVpHV V·HVWSURGXLWH$LQVLSDUH[HPSOHHQRPEULHQD‫ޝ‬HW!)V·DFFRPSDJQDQWGHO·DFFXVDWLILQGLTXHQW
LQGLIIpUHPPHQWODGLUHFWLRQG·XQPRXYHPHQW´YHUVµ H[DVDPD‫ޝ‬HVXPHQ '·XQHPDQLqUHHQFRUHSOXVVXUSUHQDQWH
HQRVTXHFHUWDLQVHPSORLVGH!) SRVWSRVpRXDQWpSRVp DYHFOHJpQLWLIRXO·DEODWLIVHUDSSURFKHQWGHVIRQFWLRQV
H[SULPpHVSDUOHVSDUWLFXOHVGHVHQVDSSDUHPPHQWRSSRVp3DUH[HPSOHGDQVFHUWDLQVFRQWH[WHV!) SRVWSRVp
RXDQWpSRVp VHVXSHUSRVHDX[IRQFWLRQVGHODSUpSRVLWLRQ"($ RVTXH RXGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQRPEULHQQH$(lM$62<:%
TXLPDUTXHQWOHSRLQWGHGpSDUW
$LQVLODIRUPXOHRVTXHPHQWLRQQpHFLGHVVXV!#014!)%G#41.1" !)DEODWLI LQGLTXHOHSRLQWGHGpSDUWWHPSRUHO
SRXUODYDOLGLWpG·XQHLQWHUGLFWLRQ'HPrPHO·H[SUHVVLRQGHODN6#%"!%S()$#(g%"($%4(0$-#"%.61:#-%!)%!#$1(0%G68K%6>>L
VLRQDX[FULWqUHVIL[pVVHORQOHFKRL[GXPDJLVWUDWSRXUODFRQYRFDWLRQGHV46>#$#(2FHTXHO·RQSRXUUDLWWUDGXLUH

<?
7,,,, &I8QWHUPDQQ´GLH3RVWS0LW$EOLVWIXQNWLRQVJOHLFK
<:

<O
7,9,,D PLWGHU3RVWS%M$6LY
 oi.uchicago.edu

% F,KA<*/,B%8*%T<K/<*/,B7%H<B7%N87%7Y7*ZA87%FN8i/,BB8N7%H87%N<BD\87%7<S8NN/e\87% ::Q

OLEUHPHQW´SDUUDSSRUWDX[ ELHQV LPPHXEOHVRXjO·DUJHQWµ/HVGHX[pOpPHQWVOLpVSDUODSDUWLFXOHGLVMRQFWLYH

G68D>J%.61:#-VRQWIRUPpVO·XQSDU"($%DEODWLI "($%4(0$-#" O·DXWUHSDU!)DFFXVDWLIRXJpQLWLI !)%!#$1(0 FHTXL
VLJQDOHXQEDODQFHPHQWHQWUHOHVGHX[PR\HQVG·H[SUHVVLRQ
'·DLOOHXUVGDQVODORLRVTXHGHS()$#(ODSUpSRVLWLRQ"($H[SULPHGHVYDOHXUVTXLVHUDSSURFKHQWGHFHOOHVGH
"!HQODWLQPDUTXDQWODUHODWLRQDYHFXQSURSRVFHTXLDPqQHjO·HPSORLELHQFRQQXGH"!DEODWLIGDQVOHVHQV
GH´DXVXMHWGHTXDQWjµ&HWHPSORLHVWLOOXVWUpSDUO·H[SUHVVLRQ"($%!#G(04%#"#4%$()5#)!#0%"!#41>´VHSURQRQFHUDX
VXMHWGHFHWWHGpOLEpUDWLRQµ
8QSRLQWGHGpSDUWSHXWGHYHQLUXQSRLQWGHUHSqUHSRXUH[SULPHUODUHODWLRQHQWUHGHX[pOpPHQWVRXGHX[
DFWLRQVFHTXLSHXWUpDOLVHUWDQW{WXQHORFDOLVDWLRQ ´GDQVµ WDQW{WO·LQGLFDWLRQG·XQUDSSRUW ´TXDQWjDX
VXMHWGHµ /HODWLQHWOHVODQJXHVURPDQHVQRXVRIIUHQWSOXVLHXUVH[HPSOHVGHFHGpYHORSSHPHQWTXLjWUDYHUV
XQHJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQWRWDOHRXSDUWLHOOHDDERXWLjGHQRPEUHXVHVORFXWLRQVTXLIRQFWLRQQHQWDXVVLFRPPH
DGYHUEHVRXFRPPHFRQQHFWHXUVWHOVTXHHQIUDQoDLV"!"()02%"!+6-0%  "!:6-#0 %"!?()$%  "!(&()$! %"!%4!%4x$U2%
";1)%4x$U2%"!%.;(1$-!%4x$U2%";(#..!1-02%JH%8K6>8JH%"!)$-6%  "!#)$-6 %"(%1)%.($62%"(..;(.$-6%.($62%";(.$-6%4()$62%JH%>6K8H%(%.($!-!2%
(&%1$-(X1!%I(-$!¬
/HJOLVVHPHQWVpPDQWLTXHGHODSURYHQDQFHHWGHO·pORLJQHPHQWYHUVODORFDOLVDWLRQVHUHWURXYHGDQVOHV
WRXUQXUHVV\QWD[LTXHVRPEULHQQHV)!0#>!#%(0(%"!1!#(%´jSUR[LPLWpGHWRXWSUqVGH¬O·DXWHOGLYLQµ%)!0#>!#%1(I!-010%
(1#!+4.!#-%´jSUR[LPLWpGHWRXWSUqVGHVLqJHVGHO·(10I#4#1>µ<Q&HVH[SUHVVLRQVVHFRPSRVHQWG·XQORFDWLI )!0#M
>!# ILJpHQIRQFWLRQG·DGYHUEH ´jSUR[LPLWpµ VXLYLG·XQDEODWLIG·pORLJQHPHQWPDUTXDQWOHSRLQWGHUHSqUH
5DSSHORQVTX·HQODWLQOHVORFXWLRQVFRUUHVSRQGDQWHVH[SULPDQWODSUR[LPLWp I-6I!2%I-6]#>! V·DFFRPSDJQHQWGH
O·DFFXVDWLIRXGHO·DEODWLISUpFpGpSDU(&2<<WDQGLVTXHO·pORLJQHPHQWHQRPEULHQHVWFRXUDPPHQWH[SULPpSDUOD
SRVWSRVLWLRQ$(lM$6 H[()5.1$6%+6)"6>1´GXFRLQ¬OHSOXVEDVµ 
/·RVTXHVHPEOHPLHX[JDUGHUODIRQFWLRQIRQGDPHQWDOHGHO·DEODWLIQRWDPPHQWODSURYHQDQFHRXO·RULJLQHVDQV
O·DLGHGHSUpSRVLWLRQVRXSRVWSRVLWLRQVFRPPHOHPRQWUHQWOHVHPSORLVILJXUpVWHOVTXH0!)($!#0%$()5#)1"´G·DSUqV
ODGpOLEpUDWLRQGXVpQDWµ01?("%!#$#1?("´GHO·DUJHQWTXLOXLDSSDUWHQDLWµ$-#0$((>!)$1"´G·DSUqVOHWHVWDPHQWµ
TXLHQODWLQSUpVHQWHQWGHVIORWWHPHQWVGDQVO·HPSORLGHODSUpSRVLWLRQ "! 0!)($10%0!)$!)$#( "! 01(%I!41)#( !] 
$!0$(>!)$6<R3RXUFHWWHUDLVRQO·RQSHXWVRXSoRQQHUTXHO·HPSORLLVROpGHODSUpSRVLWLRQGDQVODN6#%"!%S()$#(g%"($%
0!)($!#0%$()5#)1"2DXOLHXGXVLPSOHDEODWLI0!)($!#0%$()5#)1"DWWHVWpDLOOHXUVSXLVVHDYRLUpWpLQIOXHQFpSDUOHODWLQ%
"!%0!)($10%0!)$!)$#(0DLVOHPRGqOHODWLQQ·HVWSDVHQFRQWUDVWHDYHFXQHWHQGDQFHFRPPXQHDX[GHX[ODQJXHV
jUHQIRUFHUFHWWHIRQFWLRQGHO·DEODWLIjO·DLGHGHSUpSRVLWLRQV/HVFRQWDFWVDYHFODODQJXHGRPLQDQWHRQWVWLPXOp
FHWWHWHQGDQFH
(QFRQFOXVLRQO·DEODWLIVHXOVHPEOHDYRLUFRQQXXQDIIDLEOLVVHPHQWGHVDIRQFWLRQRULJLQHOOHF·HVWjGLUH
O·LQGLFDWLRQGHODSURYHQDQFHGHO·pORLJQHPHQWHWFHODGHPDQLqUHFRQYHUJHQWHHQODWLQHWGDQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHO
OLTXHV0DLVOHVSDUFRXUVGHFHWDIIDLEOLVVHPHQWVRQWGLIIpUHQWVHQWUHO·RVTXHHWO·RPEULHQ9UDLVHPEODEOHPHQW
OHEHVRLQGHIRXUQLUXQPDUTXDJHVSpFLILTXHjODIRQFWLRQRULJLQHOOHGHO·DEODWLIV·HVWGpYHORSSpjODVXLWHGHV
IRQFWLRQVQRXYHOOHVDFTXLVHVSDUFHFDVQRWDPPHQWFHOOHVGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDO jXQHpSRTXHSUpGRFXPHQWDLUH HW
FHOOHVGXORFDWLI jO·pSRTXHKLVWRULTXH (QHIIHW³FRPPHRQOHYHUUDSOXVORLQ³FHUWDLQVHPSORLVGHO·DEODWLIHQ
RVTXHVXUWRXWHQSUpVHQFHGHWRSRQ\PHVVRQWVRXSoRQQpVGHVHFKDUJHUGHODIRQFWLRQGXORFDWLIHQSDUDOOqOH
DX[pYROXWLRQVGXODWLQ
&HVGpYHORSSHPHQWVGHVVLQHQWXQHOLJQHGHFRQYHUJHQFHHQWUHOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVHWOHODWLQTXLDPqQH
DX[pYROXWLRQVURPDQHVF·HVWjGLUHODWHQGDQFHjDFFRPSDJQHUOHVFDVVLPSOHVSDUGHVSDUWLFXOHV SUpSRVLWLRQ
QHOOHVSOXW{WTXHSRVWSRVLWLRQQHOOHV HWjFKDUJHUFHVSDUWLFXOHVGHSOXVLHXUVIRQFWLRQV/DSOXUDOLWpGHVIRQFWLRQV
TXLjO·RULJLQHDSSDUWHQDLWWRXWVLPSOHPHQWDX[FDV´FRQFUHWVµWHOVTXHO·DEODWLIOHORFDWLIO·LQVWUXPHQWDOV·HVW
WUDQVIpUpHDX[SUpSRVLWLRQVRXDX[SRVWSRVLWLRQV/·DERXWLVVHPHQWGHFHSDUFRXUVVHWURXYHGDQVOHVODQJXHV
URPDQHVTXLJpQpUDOHPHQWVRQWFDUDFWpULVpHVSDUODFRQFHQWUDWLRQGHSOXVLHXUVIRQFWLRQVGDQVXQHPrPHSUp
SRVLWLRQ SDUH[HQIUDQoDLV"!2%h2%I(-HQLWDOLHQ"#2%(2%"(HQHVSDJQRO"!2%(2%I6- 0DLVFHWpWDWGHFKRVHVDSSDUWLHQW
GpMjDXODWLQWDUGLI<@%
(QRXWUHOHVIDLWVHVTXLVVpVQRXVPRQWUHQWXQHVLWXDWLRQWUqVPrOpHSRXUOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVHQFHTXL
FRQFHUQHO·HPSORLGHVFDVHWOHGpYHORSSHPHQWGHVSDUWLFXOHVTXLOHVDFFRPSDJQHQW'·XQHSDUWFHVODQJXHVSUp
VHQWHQWXQHPSORLGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVEHDXFRXSSOXVpWHQGXHWPDVVLITX·HQODWLQGHFHSRLQWGHYXHHOOHVVRQW

<Q
%7,9,D 
3RU]LR*HUQLD
<<
/HXPDQQ+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U <@
&I0ROLQHOOLI
<R
&I3RU]LR*HUQLD
 oi.uchicago.edu

::<% @<,N,%@,338**/

DXVVLSOXVILGqOHVjXQRUGUHV\QWD[LTXHTXLHVWFHQVprWUHW\SRORJLTXHPHQWSOXVDQFLHQ0DLVG·DXWUHSDUWHOOHV
FRQQDLVVHQWWUqVODUJHPHQWOHVSUpSRVLWLRQVTXLYRQWVHVXEVWLWXHUDX[FDVVLPSOHVHWSDUIRLVDX[SRVWSRVLWLRQV
(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHOHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVGRQWODGLVWULEXWLRQHVWVXERUGRQQpHDX[FRQWH[WHVOHVODQJXHVVDEHO
OLTXHVRQWGpYHORSSpG·XQHPDQLqUHDXWRQRPHOHXUHPSORLUpSpWpGDQVOHVGHX[FRPSRVDQWVG·XQV\QWDJPH
QRPLQDO&HGpYHORSSHPHQWQHFRUUHVSRQGSDVDXIRQFWLRQQHPHQWQRUPDOGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVGDQVOHVODQJXHV
IOH[LRQQHOOHV,OVHWURXYHSOXW{WjPLFKHPLQHQWUHODVLWXDWLRQGHVODQJXHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVHWOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQW
GHO·DJJOXWLQDWLRQ(QHIIHWG·XQHSDUWODSRVWSRVLWLRQUpSpWpHGDQVOHVGHX[FRPSRVDQWVG·XQV\QWDJPHR
HOOHUHPSODFHODGpVLQHQFHRULJLQHOOHWRWDOHPHQWREVFXUFLHV·LQVFULWGDQVOHW\SHIOH[LRQQHO&RQFUqWHPHQWHOOH
IRQFWLRQQHV\QFKURQLTXHPHQWFRPPHXQHYpULWDEOHGpVLQHQFHGHORFDWLI'·DXWUHSDUWODSRVWSRVLWLRQJDUGHXQH
FHUWDLQHDXWRQRPLHGDQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVSDUFHTX·HOOHSHXWrWUHHPSOR\pHVDQVDXFXQHUpSpWLWLRQHQVH
VXUDMRXWDQWDXFDVGHODIOH[LRQTXLGHPHXUHELHQYLVLEOHFRPPHQRXVOHPRQWUHO·H[HPSOHRVTXH!](#04!)%.#5#0%
´GDQVFHVORLVµ&HODVHUDSSURFKHGXIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHVODQJXHVDJJOXWLQDQWHV
(QRXWUHOHVPrPHVpOpPHQWVTXLVRQWHPSOR\pVSRVWSRVpVVHSUpVHQWHQWDXVVLFRPPHSUpSRVLWLRQVFHTXL
PRQWUHOHXUFRQGLWLRQG·pOpPHQWVOLEUHV/DSDUWLFXOH!)VHWURXYHjO·LQWpULHXUG·XQPrPHWH[WH OD.6#%60X1!%"!%
S()$#( HPSOR\pHWDQW{WDQWpSRVpHWDQW{WSRVWSRVpH% H[%!)%!#$1(0a4!)0$6>!) /·LQIOXHQFHG·XQPRGqOHODWLQLQYR
TXpHSRXUH[SOLTXHUO·DQWpSRVLWLRQGDQVODIRUPXOH%!)%!#$1(0 FDOTXpHG·DSUqV#)%I!41)#(0 GHYUDLWrWUHpJDOHPHQW
YDODEOHSRXUO·HPSORLSRVWSRVp4!)0$6>!)2GRQWOHPRGqOHDpWpIRXUQLSDUOHVH[SUHVVLRQVODWLQHV#) (" 4!)01><P%
)LQDOHPHQWRQFRQVWDWHGDQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVGHX[HPSORLVGLIIpUHQWVGHODPrPHSDUWLFXOH!)D 
FRPPHPDUTXHXUGHFDVTXLUHPSODFHOHVGpVLQHQFHVRULJLQHOOHVE FRPPHpOpPHQWOLEUHOjRODGpVLQHQFHGH
ODIOH[LRQHVWELHQYLVLEOH'DQVFHWWHIRQFWLRQLOSHXWrWUHDQWpSRVpRXSRVWSRVpPDLVVDQVDXFXQHUpSpWLWLRQ
'·DXWUHSDUWO·HPSORLSRVWSRVpGH!)UHSUpVHQWHOHVHXOSRLQWGHYpULWDEOHFRwQFLGHQFHHQWUHWRXWHVOHVODQ
JXHVVDEHOOLTXHVHQFHTXLFRQFHUQHO·HPSORLGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQV(QRXWUHVHXOHFHWWHSDUWLFXOHHVWDVVXMHWWLHjOD
UpSpWLWLRQGDQVOHVV\QWDJPHVQRPLQDX[GRQWWpPRLJQHQWSOXVLHXUVEUDQFKHVGHFHVODQJXHV H[VXGSLFpQLHQ%
6>&-#É!)%(=-!)RVTXH+w-$#É)%=!--#É) /HORFDWLIHVWGRQFH[SULPpjWUDYHUVGHVPR\HQVWUqVGLIIpUHQWVTXLUHOqYHQW
G·XQF{WpGHODFRQVHUYDWLRQGHVIDLWVDUFKDwTXHVHWGHO·DXWUHG·LQQRYDWLRQVUHPDUTXDEOHVTXLDPqQHQWSUHVTXH
DXVHXLOGHVpYROXWLRQVURPDQHV2QV\QWKpWLVHGDQVOHVFKpPDVXLYDQWODYDULpWpGHVH[SUHVVLRQVGXORFDWLIGH
O·pQXPpUDWLRQGHVIDLWVGHFRQVHUYDWLRQYHUVOHVIDLWVG·LQQRYDWLRQ

/·H[SUHVVLRQGXORFDWLIGDQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVHQWUHFRQVHUYDWLRQLQQRYDWLRQ¬HWYDULDWLRQ

 VLPSOHHPSORLGHO·DQFLHQPRUSKqPH¬FRQVHUYpDXVLQJXOLHU RVTXH >!"#=#(#%F-!)$-!#

 ´V\QFUpWLVPHµDYHFO·DEODWLIGDWLIDXSOXULHOH[ RVTXH F#0$.1#0
 DFFRPSDJQpSDUGHVSDUWLFXOHVDQWpSRVpHVRXSRVWSRVpHV
D DQWpSRVpHV RVTXH 01I%>!"#=#(#
E SRVWSRVpHV RPEULHQ <4!-06)#!>2%$!$$6>!)
 SRVWSRVLWLRQ!)PDUTXHXUGHFDVHWpOpPHQWOLEUH
D PDUTXHXUGHFDVVXGSLFpQLHQ%6>&-#É!)%(=-!)´GDQVODUpJLRQRPEULHQQHµRVTXH+w-$#É)%
=!--#É)´GDQVO·HQFORVVDFUpGH&pUqVµ
E pOpPHQWOLEUHRVTXH!](#04!)%.#5#0%´GDQVFHVORLVµ SRVWSRVpjO·DEOSOXUPDLVSDV
UpSpWp !#014!)%G#41.1"´jSDUWLUGHFHMRXUOjµ
 DXWUHVPR\HQVG·H[SUHVVLRQ
D VLPSOHDEODWLI RVTXH S1?(#()1"2%*##()1"
E DEODWLIDYHFSUpSRVLWLRQ RPEULHQ 01%>(-6)($6
F DEODWLIDYHFSRVWSRVLWLRQ RPEULHQ %?1=1=1>
G DXWUHVWRXUQXUHVV\QWD[LTXHV RPEULHQ )!0#>!#%(0(%"!1!#(


&RPPHO·DYDLWGpMjVLJQDOp3URVGRFLPL <P
3RU]LR*HUQLD
 oi.uchicago.edu

% F,KA<*/,B%8*%T<K/<*/,B7%H<B7%N87%7Y7*ZA87%FN8i/,BB8N7%H87%N<BD\87%7<S8NN/e\87% ::R

1pDQPRLQVODYDULpWpGHVPR\HQVG·H[SUHVVLRQGpQRQFHODWHQGDQFHDXGpFOLQGHO·DQFLHQORFDWLIGDQVOHV
ODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVHQFRQYHUJHQFHDYHFOHODWLQ'·XQHSDUWRQDGpMjFRQVWDWpODFRQFXUUHQFHDYHFO·HPSORLGH
ODSRVWSRVLWLRQ!)GRQWODVRXSOHVVHV·DGDSWHGHWUqVERQQHKHXUHjODUpSpWLWLRQ¬GDQVOHVGHX[FRPSRVDQWVG·XQ
V\QWDJPHGHO·DXWUHDXSOXULHOODGpVLQHQFHKpULWpHGXORFDWLIDpWpVXEVWLWXpHSDUFHOOHGHO·DEODWLIGDWLIFRPPH
OHUpYqOHOHV\QWDJPHRVTXH!](#04!)%.#5#0%´GDQVFHVORLVµ'HODPrPHPDQLqUHGDQVOHVWRSRQ\PHVDWWHVWpVGDQVOHV
PRQQDLHVVHUpIpUDQWjODYLOOHRXjODFRPPXQDXWpTXLHVWFHQVpHrWUHOHOLHXGHODIUDSSHOHORFDWLIVHSUpVHQWH
DXVLQJXOLHUWDQGLVTXHDXSOXULHORQWURXYHOHGDWLIDEODWLISDUH[F-!)$-!É% ORFVLQJ aF#0$.1#0 GDWDEOSOXU R?%
&HWWHGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQHQWUHVLQJXOLHUHWSOXULHOjO·pJDUGGHODSUpVHUYDWLRQGHO·DQFLHQORFDWLIDPqQHjFRQVWDWHU
XQSDUDOOpOLVPHSDUIDLWDYHFOHVGLVWLQFWLRQVODWLQHVGXW\SHK6>(!%ñ%7'-(410#0%H!.#%ñ%@1$!6.#0
/DYDULDWLRQGHVFDVGDQVOHVWRSRQ\PHVGHVPRQQDLHVDLQVLTXHGDQVG·DXWUHVLQVFULSWLRQVGDQVOHVGLYHUVHV
ODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVSRVHG·DXWUHVSUREOqPHVTXLUHOqYHQWGHO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHVWH[WHVDLQVLTXHGHVIDLWVKLVWR
ULTXHVVRXVMDFHQWV'DQVOHVOpJHQGHVPRQpWDLUHVRVTXHVRQWURXYHSDUIRLVO·DEODWLIDXOLHXGXORFDWLIFRPPHSDU
H[HPSOHGDQVOHVPRQQDLHVGH*!()1>%7#"#4#)1>HQ&DPSDQLHHWGH<X1#.6)#(%6L%7(>)#1>TXLSUpVHQWHQWOHVIRUPHV
G·DEODWLI*É()1"%7#"#=#)1" ‫گ‬G HW<=1"1))#(" čG RO/HQRPGH*!()1>HVWDWWHVWpDXORFDWLIGDQVXQHLQVFULS
WLRQGHSRWLHUTXLpQRQFHOHOLHXGHIDEULFDWLRQ1I0($1+%0!)$%*##()!#´ FHVYDVHV RQWpWpIDEULTXpVj*!()1>µ R:%
$XVXMHWGHFHVOpJHQGHVPRQpWDLUHVVHSRVHODTXHVWLRQGHVDYRLUVLO·DEODWLIQ·HVWTX·XQHYDULDQWH V\QFKURQLTXH
RXGLDFKURQLTXH GXORFDWLIRXELHQVLO·HPSORLGHO·DEODWLIDXQHVLJQLILFDWLRQGLIIpUHQWHjSDUWLUGHODIRQFWLRQ
IRQGDPHQWDOHTXLOXLHVWSURSUHQRWDPPHQWO·LQGLFDWLRQGHO·RULJLQHHWGHODSURYHQDQFH
/HVGHX[VROXWLRQVRQWGHVLPSOLFDWLRQVGLIIpUHQWHVGHVSRLQWVGHYXHHWOLQJXLVWLTXHHWLQVWLWXWLRQQHO(QFH
TXLFRQFHUQHOHV\VWqPHGHODODQJXHOHIORWWHPHQWHQWUHDEODWLIVLPSOHDEODWLIDYHFSUpSRVLWLRQHWFDVORFDWLI
SRXULQGLTXHUODORFDOLVDWLRQ F·HVWjGLUHODIRQFWLRQSURSUHGXFDVORFDWLI VLJQDOHOD´FULVHµGXFDVORFDWLIOXL
PrPHDYHFGHVDERXWLVVHPHQWVSDUDOOqOHVDXODWLQ(QODWLQWDUGLIOHORFDWLIUpVHUYpDX[QRPVGHYLOOHVHWSHWLWHV
vOHVDSSDUWHQDQWDX[WKqPHVHQčHWHQ6MHVWUHPSODFpVRXYHQWSDUO·DEODWLIVDQVSUpSRVLWLRQTXLILJXUHGDQV
FHWHPSORLGpMjFKH]9LWUXYHFRPPHOHVLJQDOH(/|IVWHGWRQ'DQVFHFDVO·RVTXHDQWLFLSHFRPPHGDQVG·DXWUHV
FLUFRQVWDQFHVOHVpYROXWLRQVGXODWLQ
'HODPrPHPDQLqUHRQVHUDDPHQpjLQWHUSUpWHUOHVWRSRQ\PHVDXFDVDEODWLIHQIRQFWLRQGHORFDWLIGDQVOHV
OpJHQGHVPRQpWDLUHVG·DSUqVODODWLQLVDWLRQGXSD\VRVTXHWHOVTXHOHVQRPVS!)!?!)$6"%JK%N(-#)6"R<GDQVOHVPRQ
QDLHVDSSDUWHQDQWDX[YLOOHVGHS!)!?!)$1>%JK%N(-#)1>0DLVRXWUHN(-#)6"ODSURGXFWLRQPRQpWDLUHGHFHWWHYLOOH
FRQQDvWDXVVLOHORFDWLIN(-#)!#2RRFHTXLDPqQHjVXSSRVHUXQHLGHQWLWpGHIRQFWLRQHQWUHOHVGHX[FDV2QODLVVHUD
RXYHUWHODTXHVWLRQGHVDYRLUVLGDQVFHFDVLOV·DJLWGXODWLQLQIOXHQFpSDUO·RVTXHRXELHQG·XQHFRQYHUJHQFHHQWUH
ODWLQHWRVTXHTXLVHPDQLIHVWHHQSD\VRVTXHG·XQHPDQLqUHSOXVSUpFRFHHWjGHVQLYHDX[VRFLROLQJXLVWLTXHVSOXV
pOHYpVTX·j5RPH
/·DXWUHVROXWLRQTXLHQYLVDJHODFRQVHUYDWLRQGHODYDOHXURULJLQDLUHGHO·DEODWLIDWWULEXDEOHjO·LQGRHXUR
SpHQF·HVWjGLUHO·RULJLQHRXODSURYHQDQFHDGHVLPSOLFDWLRQVLQVWLWXWLRQQHOOHVGDQVO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHVWH[WHV
TXLQHQRXVFRQFHUQHQWSDVLFL(QHIIHWVLO·RQUHFRQQDvWjO·DEODWLIGHVWRSRQ\PHVJUDYpVVXUOHVPRQQDLHVXQH
IRQFWLRQGLIIpUHQWHGXORFDWLI LQGLFDWLRQGHODSURYHQDQFH LOIDXGUDFRQFOXUHTXHODGLVWLQFWLRQHQWUHOHVGHX[
FDVFRUUHVSRQGjXQHORFDOLVDWLRQGLIIpUHQWHGHODFRPPXQDXWpSDUUDSSRUWjO·DXWRULWpUHVSRQVDEOHGHODIUDSSH
8QSUREOqPHVHPEODEOHVHSRVHHQFHTXLFRQFHUQHO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQG·DXWUHVLQVFULSWLRQVFRQWHQDQWXQWRSR
Q\PHjO·DEODWLIGRQWODIRQFWLRQ QRQFODULILpHSDUOHFRQWH[WHV\QWD[LTXH DVXVFLWpGHVGLVFXVVLRQVDXWRXUGH
O·LGHQWLILFDWLRQGXQRPDQFLHQGHODORFDOLWpRO·LQVFULSWLRQDpWpGpFRXYHUWH7URLVLQVFULSWLRQVRVTXHVSUpVHQ
WHQWFHIDLWV\QWD[LTXHLOV·DJLWGHGHX[GpGLFDFHVYRWLYHV O!-!$$($!0%01>%<5!-..w"f %?!-!#(0%Nw?=()($#0%<(I(0%=(É(0%
@(.()w"R@ HWG·XQWH[WHRIILFLHO BLT!01..#(É0%*-L%A !""#0 * w?$#=0 !=É=%0(=(-(=.w>%Sw?(#()w"%(É="(:!"  TXLVHFDUDF
WpULVHQWSDUODSUpVHQFHG·XQWRSRQ\PHjO·DEODWLI UHVSHFWLYHPHQW<5!-..w"2%@(.()w"2%Sw?(#()w" 
/HWH[WHRIILFLHODDWWLUpGDYDQWDJHO·DWWHQWLRQSDUFHTXHO·LQVFULSWLRQIDLVDQWDOOXVLRQjODFRQVWUXFWLRQG·XQ
VDQFWXDLUHUpDOLVpSDUOHVVRLQVG·XQA!""#]%*w?$#=02F·HVWjGLUHODFKDUJHODSOXVpOHYpHGHODFRPPXQDXWpD
pWpWURXYpHGDQVO·LPSRUWDQWVLWHDUFKpRORJLTXHGH3LHWUDEERQGDQWHGRQWRQLJQRUHOHQRPDQFLHQ(QRXWUHOH
WRSRQ\PHjO·DEODWLI Sw?(#()w" FRUUHVSRQGjS6?#()1>PHQWLRQQpSDUOHVVRXUFHVODWLQHVRPGRQWODORFDOLVDWLRQ

R?
5L[67¬16LDEF RR
5L[671)UE
RO
5L[67¬Q6D 
5L[67)U
R:
5L[676L R@
5L[67)U
RQ
/|IVWHGW 
5L[676D
R<
5L[671)UD
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @<,N,%@,338**/

H[DFWHDXF±XUGX6DPQLXPGHPHXUHLQFRQQXH/·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHO·DEODWLIGHO·LQVFULSWLRQRVTXHSHXWSHUPHWWUH
GHWUDQFKHUODTXHVWLRQGDQVXQVHQVRXGDQVXQDXWUH6LO·RQLQWHUSUqWHO·DEODWLIGXWRSRQ\PHFRPPHpWDQWHQ
IRQFWLRQGHORFDWLIOHWH[WHVLJQDOHTXHO·LQGLYLGXTXLDODFKDUJHGHA!""#]%*w?$#=0GHS6?#()1>DRUGRQQpOD
UpDOLVDWLRQGXVDQFWXDLUHOjRO·LQVFULSWLRQpWDLWDSSRVpHGDQVODORFDOLWpDSSDUWHQDQWjVDMXULGLFWLRQFHWWHORFD
OLWpSRXYDLWVHQRPPHUHOOHPrPHS6?#()1>(QUHYDQFKHVLO·RQDWWULEXHjO·DEODWLISw?(#()w"%VDIRQFWLRQSURSUH
jVDYRLUG·LQGLTXHUODSURYHQDQFHRXO·RULJLQHOHWH[WHVHFKDUJHG·XQVHQVGLIIpUHQWGXSRLQWGHYXHMXULGLTXH
HWWRSRJUDSKLTXH,OV·DJLUDLWG·XQA!""#]%*w?$#=0SURYHQDQWGHS6?#()1>TXLDXUDLWRUGRQQpODUpDOLVDWLRQGX
EkWLPHQWVDFUpGDQVXQHQGURLWTXLQ·DSSDUWHQDLWSDVjVDMXULGLFWLRQ(QFRQVpTXHQFHOHQRPGHO·HQGURLWR
O·LQVFULSWLRQDpWpWURXYpHGRLWrWUHIRUFpPHQWGLIIpUHQWGHFHOXLGHS6?#()1>
­TXHOTXHVH[FHSWLRQVSUqVOHSDQRUDPDGHODIOH[LRQGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVSUpVHQWHXQFDUDFWqUHSOXV
pYROXpTXHOHODWLQHWDQWLFLSHG·XQHPDQLqUHVXUSUHQDQWHOHVGpYHORSSHPHQWVGXODWLQWDUGLIDLQVLTXHOHVDERX
WLVVHPHQWVURPDQV0rPHGDQVO·HPSORLGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVTXLUHOqYHQWG·XQpWDWDUFKDwTXHVHPDQLIHVWHXQH
pYROXWLRQUHPDUTXDEOH
/DIOH[LRQVDEHOOLTXHREpLWjXQSULQFLSHJpQpUDOGqVOHVGpEXWVGHODGRFXPHQWDWLRQjVDYRLUODUpGXFWLRQ
GHVSDUDGLJPHVIOH[LRQQHOVjWUDYHUVGHVH[WHQVLRQVDQDORJLTXHV­FHWpJDUGRQFRQVWDWHGHVFRQYHUJHQFHVHW
GHVGLYHUJHQFHVSDUUDSSRUWDXODWLQGRQWOHVOLJQHVQHVRQWSDVWRXMRXUVFODLUHV
'HX[WHQGDQFHVFRPPXQHVjODEUDQFKH´LWDOLTXHµGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQVRQWWUqVQHWWHVD OHSDUDOOpOLVPHWUqV
SURQRQFpGDQVODIOH[LRQHQWUHWKqPHVHQ6MHWWKqPHVHQčE ODUpGXFWLRQGHO·DXWRQRPLHGHVWKqPHVHQ#M%JK%
HQ1M&HVGHX[IDLWVVRQWjODEDVHGHVW\SHVOH[LFDX[GHVODQJXHVURPDQHVTXLVRQWHVVHQWLHOOHPHQWEkWLVVXUWURLV
PRGqOHVIRQGDPHQWDX[KpULWpVGHVSDUDGLJPHVIOH[LRQQHOVODWLQVOHVWKqPHVHQčOHVWKqPHVHQ6M2OHVWKqPHV
HQFRQVRQQH/HVWUDFHVGHFHWWHpYROXWLRQVHUHWURXYHQWGpMjGDQVO·pWDWGXODWLQOLWWpUDLUHROHVWKqPHVHQ#M%JK%
HQ1MQHUHSUpVHQWHQWTX·XQHSHWLWHPLQRULWpGRQWO·LQVWDELOLWpHVWVLJQDOpHSDUOHVIORWWHPHQWVSRXUOHVXQV
DYHFODGpFOLQDLVRQGHVWKqPHVHQFRQVRQQHHWSRXUOHVDXWUHVDYHFOHVWKqPHVHQ6ML(QRXWUHG·DXWUHVPRGqOHV
IOH[LRQQHOVRQWGHVGRXEOHWVGDQVG·DXWUHVGpFOLQDLVRQVFRPPHSDUH[HPSOHOHVWKqPHVHQL̒VDSSDUWHQDQWj
>6%1qPHGpFOLQDLVRQODWLQHTXLRQWGHVGRXEOHWVGDQVOD,qUHGpFOLQDLVRQWHOVTXH>($!-#!0l>($!-#(¬!::#5#!0l!::#5#(!%
&·HVWO·DOORPRUSKHGHODGpFOLQDLVRQHQčTXLDWULRPSKpGDQVOHVpYROXWLRQVURPDQHV H[LWDOLHQ>($!-#(2%:(44#(2%
.1001-#(HWF 
/HV ODQJXHV VDEHOOLTXHV V·LQVFULYHQW GDQV OD PrPH WHQGDQFH PDLV j WUDYHUV GHV SDUFRXUV GLIIpUHQWV /D
FRQIOXHQFHSURJUHVVLYHGHVWKqPHVHQ#MHWHQ1MDYHFOHVDXWUHVSDUDGLJPHVIOH[LRQQHOVUHPRQWHjODSpULRGH
KLVWRULTXHjODIRLVGXODWLQHWGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHV'DQVOHVGHX[EUDQFKHVGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQG·,WDOLHOHV
WKqPHVHQ1M%9J%MFHK7JHK%SOXVIDLEOHVWDQGLVTXHOHVWKqPHVHQ#M%RQWUpVLVWpSOXVORQJWHPSVHQJDUGDQWXQH
IRUFHG·DWWUDFWLRQHQYHUVG·DXWUHVWKqPHV
'DQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVODIDLEOHVVHGHVWKqPHVHQ1MHVWUpYpOpHSDUOHVIORWWHPHQWVHQWUHODIOH[LRQHQ
6M SDUDOOqOHPHQWDXODWLQ HWHQ#MFRPPHHQWpPRLJQHOHGRXEOHWRVTXH—Ǔဎ‫—ڗ‬HW>()#>2DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHU
GH>()1´PDLQµ'HFHPrPHPRWO·RPEULHQFRQQDvWXQHYDULDQWHVXSSOpPHQWDLUHFRPPHWKqPHHQFRQVRQQH
O·DFFXVDWLISOXULHO>():'HVGpEULVGHO·DQFLHQQHIOH[LRQHQ1MVHUHWURXYHQWGDQVOHORFDWLIRPEULHQ>()1?! 
U>()61!) SHXWrWUHVDXYHJDUGpSDUODSUpVHQFHGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQTXLHVWGHYHQXHOHYpULWDEOH´PDUTXHXUGX
FDVµ
'HVLQGLFHVG·XQIORWWHPHQWHQWUHWKqPHVHQ1MHWWKqPHVHQ6MVHUHWURXYHQWHQRVTXHDXQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHU
GHVSDUWLFLSHVGRQWOHVYDULDQWHV0#I102%:(410HW‫͘ݰ‬໵‫ߥڗ‬SHXYHQWDEULWHUXQGRXEOHSDUDGLJPHIOH[LRQQHOOHVXQV
UHOHYDQWGHVWKqPHVHQ1MO·DXWUHGHVWKqPHVHQ6M%
/·RVTXHHWO·RPEULHQPRQWUHQWXQHGLYHUJHQFHGDQVO·DEODWLIGDWLIGXSOXULHOGHVWKqPHVHQFRQVRQQHO·XQ
DpWHQGXODGpVLQHQFHGHVWKqPHVHQ#MSDUDOOqOHPHQWDXODWLQ #M&+60%Ö%M#:0%ÖM#00aODWLQ#&10 O·DXWUHSUpVHQWH
ODWHUPLQDLVRQ10 H[+6>1)102%=(-)102%1(I!-010 GHPrPHTX·HQVXGSLFpQLHQ>()10 DEOGDWSOXU 9UDLVHP
EODEOHPHQWjO·RULJLQHGHFHWWHUpIHFWLRQDQDORJLTXHLO\DOHVIORWWHPHQWVHQWUHWKqPHVHQ1MHWWKqPHVHQ
FRQVRQQHFRPPHOHPRQWUHO·H[HPSOHGH>()1> DFFVLQJ >(): DFFSOXU G·DSUqVODILOLqUHUHFRQVWUXLWHSDU

RP
(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHODPHQWLRQGHS6?#()1>GDQVOHVRSpUDWLRQVGHV 
­FHVXMHWYRLU/D5HJLQD
JXHUUHVFRQWUHOHV6DPQLWHVYRLU/D5HJLQD 
&I/HXPDQQ

6LJQDORQVHQWUHDXWUHVO·DIILUPDWLRQWUqVQHWWHGDQV3LVDQL 
&I8QWHUPDQQVY>()#>
´/·DEODWLYRKDFKLDUDPHQWHVLJQLILFDWRGLORFDWLYRY(QFHTXL 
3RXUOHVGpWDLOVFI*XVPDQL3RFFHWWL
FRQFHUQHOHVDXWUHVLQWHUSUpWDWLRQVYRLU'L,RULR 
&I.OLQJHQVFKPLWW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% F,KA<*/,B%8*%T<K/<*/,B7%H<B7%N87%7Y7*ZA87%FN8i/,BB8N7%H87%N<BD\87%7<S8NN/e\87% ::@

.OLQJHQVFKPLWW(QFRQVpTXHQFHFHSKpQRPqQHGHO·RPEULHQUHOqYHGHO·LQQRYDWLRQSOXW{WTXHGHODFRQVHUYDWLRQ
GHODIOH[LRQHQ1M'·DLOOHXUVHQODWLQDXGDWLIDEODWLIGXSOXULHO#&10V·HVWVXEVWLWXpjO·DQFLHQQHWHUPLQDLVRQ
1&10TXLQ·DVXUYpFXTXHFRPPHDUFKDwVPH%
/DUpVLVWDQFHGHVWKqPHVHQ#MVHPDQLIHVWHHQODWLQHWGDQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVG·XQHPDQLqUHFRQYHU
JHQWHPDLVDYHFGHVGLIIpUHQFHVUHPDUTXDEOHV(QODWLQOHVWUDFHVV\QFKURQLTXHVGHODIOH[LRQHQ#MILJXUHQWj
O·DEODWLIVLQJXOLHURODWHUPLQDLVRQ#DFRQFXUUHQFp!2HWDXJpQLWLISOXULHOR#1>DVXUYpFXGDQVGHVPRWV
FRPPHI(-02%>6)02%(-0GRQWO·DSSDUWHQDQFHDX[WKqPHVHQ#MQ·pWDLWSOXVYLVLEOHV\QFKURQLTXHPHQW'HO·DFFXVDWLI
HQ#>RXWUHOHVHPSORLVV\QFKURQLTXHPHQWWUqVOLPLWpVGDQVGHVPRWVFRPPH$1--#>2%$100#>HWFOHVWUDFHVGLD
FKURQLTXHVVHUHWURXYHQWGDQVGHVDGYHUEHVTXLHQGpQRQFHQWODYLWDOLWpMXVTX·jXQHpSRTXHSHXpORLJQpHGXGpEXW
GHODOLWWpUDWXUHFRPPH0$($#>2%(":($#>2%I(-$#>HWF/·RVTXHHWO·RPEULHQUpYqOHQWXQHDXWRQRPLHHWXQHYLWDOLWp
GHODFODVVHIOH[LRQQHOOHHQ#MELHQSOXVSXLVVDQWHVTX·HQODWLQ3DUH[HPSOHFHWWHIOH[LRQQ·DSDVpWpDIIHFWpHSDU
ODIRUFHGHO·DQDORJLHTXLDpWHQGXDX[WKqPHVHQFRQVRQQHOHVGpVLQHQFHVGHO·DFFXVDWLIHWGHO·DEODWLIGHVWKqPHV
HQ6M$LQVLO·RQWURXYHHQRVTXH0.(5É> DFFVLQJ 0.(5#" DEOVLQJ GH0.(5# WKqPHHQ#M %M689%.!5#)1> DFF
VLQJ $()5#)1" DEOVLQJ GDQVOHVWKqPHVHQ ‫گ‬Q(QRXWUHODIOH[LRQHQ#MJDUGHODIRUFHG·DWWUDFWLRQGHVWKqPHV
HQ1MGDQVOHVPrPHVFDVFRPPHOHPRQWUHQWHQRVTXH>()#> DFFVLQJ 4(0$-#" DEOVLQJ HWHQRPEULHQ$-!:#%
DEOVLQJ UHVSHFWLYHPHQWGH>()14(0$-1$-#:1%
0DLVODSXLVVDQFHGHVWKqPHVHQM#MVHPDQLIHVWHSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWGDQVODWHUPLQDLVRQGXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHU
!É0 TXLSDUWRXWHQRVTXHHWSDUWLHOOHPHQWGDQVG·DXWUHVYDULpWpVVDEHOOLTXHVV·HVWLPSRVpHGDQVOHVWKqPHV
HQ6MHWHQFRQVRQQHDX[GpSHQVGHOHXUVPRUSKqPHVRULJLQHOV­FHSURSRVUDSSHORQVTXHODWHUPLQDLVRQGX
JpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUGHVWKqPHVHQ6MUHSUpVHQWHO·XQHGHVTXHVWLRQVOHVSOXVFRPSOH[HVHWFRQWURYHUVpHVFRQFHUQDQW
O·pYROXWLRQGHODGpFOLQDLVRQGHVODQJXHV¬LQGRHXURSpHQQHVG·,WDOLH
/HVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVQ·RQWSDVSDUWLFLSpjO·LQQRYDWLRQTXHOHVDXWUHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVG·,WDOLH
ODWLQIDOLVTXHYpQqWHPHVVDSLHQ SDUWDJHQWDYHFOHFHOWLTXHQRWDPPHQWOHҸTXLGHYLHQWOHPRUSKqPHGHJpQL
WLIVLQJXOLHUGHVWKqPHVHQM6MGXODWLQOLWWpUDLUH/HVWURXYDLOOHVGHVGHUQLqUHVGL]DLQHVG·DQQpHVRQWSHUPLVGH
UHWUDFHUOHVSDUFRXUVTXLRQWDPHQpjODGLIIXVLRQGHFHPRUSKqPH GRQWO·RULJLQHQ·HVWSDVFODLUH OHVGRQQpHVGX
ODWLQHWGXIDOLVTXHWpPRLJQHQWGHVDGLIIXVLRQ DXPRLQVGDQVFHVODQJXHV DXWRXUGX9qPHVLqFOHDYDQWQRWUHqUH
0DLVSOXVLHXUVDVSHFWVGHODTXHVWLRQ¬GHPHXUHQWRXYHUWVD ODIRQFWLRQRULJLQHOOHGHFHPRUSKqPHE OHSRLQWGH
GpSDUWGHOD´JUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQµGHҸ HQIRQFWLRQGHJpQLWLI DLQVLTXHOHVSURFpGpVGHVDGLIIXVLRQ¬GDQVSOX
VLHXUVODQJXHVF ODUDLVRQSRXUODTXHOOHVHXOHVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVQ·RQWSDVpWpDIIHFWpHVSDUFHWWHLQQRYDWLRQ
&HGHUQLHUSRLQWVHUHOLHVWULFWHPHQWjGHX[DXWUHVTXHVWLRQVD OHIDLWTXHOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVjODGLIIp
UHQFHGHVDXWUHVODQJXHV´LWDOLTXHVµQ·RQWDXFXQHDWWHVWDWLRQGHODGpVLQHQFHKpULWpHGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQ 60#6 
E O·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHVIORWWHPHQWVHQWUH!É0HW!0TXLVHSUpVHQWHQWGDQVODGRFXPHQWDWLRQVDEHOOLTXH
2QSHXWHVVD\HUGHGRQQHUXQHUpSRQVHjFHVGHX[TXHVWLRQVGDQVXQHSHUVSHFWLYHjODIRLVV\QFKURQLTXHHW
GLDFKURQLTXH2QSDUWLUDGXSRLQWE  F·HVWjGLUHOHVIORWWHPHQWVHQWUH!É0HW!0 TXLQpFHVVLWHGHVSUpFLVLRQV
SUpDODEOHV
3DUPLOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVO·RVTXHDSUHVTXHJpQpUDOLVpODWHUPLQDLVRQ!É02WDQGLVTXHO·RPEULHQSUpVHQWH
SDUWRXW!0TXLSHXWFRQWLQXHU!0RXrWUHLVVXGH!É0SDUPRQRSKWRQJDLVRQ0DLVHQRVTXHHWGDQVOHVWH[WHV
SDOpRVDEHOOLTXHV VSpFLILTXHPHQWVXGSLFpQLHQVHWSUpVDPQLWHV RQWURXYHSDUIRLVVLPXOWDQpPHQW!É0jF{Wp
GH!0L/·pYDOXDWLRQGXUDSSRUWHQWUHFHVGHX[GpVLQHQFHVHVWFRQWURYHUVpHGXSRLQWGHYXHjODIRLVV\QFKURQLTXH
HWGLDFKURQLTXH
/·HQVHLJQHPHQWWUDGLWLRQQHOGHVJUDPPDLUHVFRPSDUpHVGLVWLQJXH!É0UHOHYDQWGHVWKqPHVHQ#M2GH!02%
DSSDUWHQDQWDX[WKqPHVHQFRQVRQQH3OXVUpFHPPHQWRQDUHPLVHQFDXVHODFRH[LVWHQFHV\QFKURQLTXHGHVGHX[
GpVLQHQFHVHQIDYHXUGH!É0SRXUQLHUO·H[LVWHQFHG·XQJpQLWLIHQ!0VDXIHQRPEULHQR!0Q·HVWTXHO·DERXWLVVH
PHQWGH!É0'·DXWUHSDUWKRUVGHO·RPEULHQOHJpQLWLIHQ!0Q·HVWDWWHVWpTXHGDQVGHVQRPVSHUVRQQHOVHQ '6M2%
FHTXLSHUPHWDXVVLVRQLQWHUSUpWDWLRQHQIRQFWLRQGHQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUHQFRQVpTXHQFHGHO·pYROXWLRQ '60%Ö%
M#!07RXWHIRLVPLVjSDUWXQFHUWDLQQRPEUHGHWH[WHVRO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGH#!0FRPPHQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUG·XQ
QRPSHUVRQQHOGHPHXUHWRXWjIDLWRXYHUWHLOQRXVVHPEOHGLIILFLOHG·H[FOXUHFRPSOqWHPHQWO·H[LVWHQFHG·XQ
JpQLWLIHQ!0WDQW{WFRPPHUpVXOWDWGH!É0% DSSDUWHQDQWDX[WKqPHVHQ#M WDQW{WFRPPHFRQWLQXDWHXUGH!0%
GHVWKqPHVHQFRQVRQQH 


&I/HXPDQQ 
&I8QWHUPDQQ

&I8QWHUPDQQ 
9RLUO·DQDO\VHGHVWH[WHVGDQV$JRVWLQLDQL
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @<,N,%@,338**/

/HVGRFXPHQWVOHVSOXVDQFLHQVHWOHVWH[WHVRXQHRUWKRJUDSKHULJLGHQHV·HVWSDVHQFRUHIL[pHSUpVHQWHQW
GHVIORWWHPHQWVHQWUH!0HW!É02%DORUVTXHO·RVTXH´RIILFLHOµDFKRLVL!É0HWTXHO·RPEULHQjODVXLWHGHODUpGXFWLRQ
GHVGLSKWRQJXHVQHSRXYDLWWUDQFKHUTX·HQIDYHXUGH!0(QFRQVpTXHQFHOHVKpVLWDWLRQVHWODGLVWULEXWLRQGHFHV
GHX[GpVLQHQFHVV·LQVFULYHQWG·XQF{WpGDQVODOXWWHGLDFKURQLTXHHQWUHOHPRUSKqPHGHVWKqPHVHQ#MHWFHOXL
GHVWKqPHVHQFRQVRQQHSRXUV·LPSRVHUSDUWRXWHWGHO·DXWUHF{WpGDQVODIL[DWLRQG·XQHUqJOHV\QFKURQLTXHTXL
GRLWVHUYLUSRXUODODQJXHRIILFLHOOH(QG·DXWUHVWHUPHV!É0HW!0QHVRQWV\QFKURQLTXHPHQWTXHGHX[YDULDQWHV
VW\OLVWLTXHVTXLGHYDLHQWFRUUHVSRQGUHVHXOHPHQWjXQHGLVWLQFWLRQJUDSKLTXHSOXW{WTX·jXQHUpDOLWpSKRQpWLTXH
(QODWLQXQGHVWLQVHPEODEOHVHPEOHDYRLUDIIHFWpOHVIORWWHPHQWVHQWUHOHVWHUPLQDLVRQVҸVHW̒VGHO·DFFXVDWLI
SOXULHOGHVWKqPHVHQ#MHWHQFRQVRQQH/·HPSORLGHҸVLVVXGHVWKqPHVHQ#MHQWDQWTX·DUFKDwVPHFRPPXQ
jODODQJXHSRpWLTXHQHVLJQDOHTXH³FRPPHOHVRXOLJQH/HXPDQQ³´HLQH$QJHOHJHQKHLWGHV6WLOVQLFKWGHU
6SUDFKJHVFKLFKWHµ @?
'XSRLQWGHYXHGLDFKURQLTXHO·H[WHQVLRQGXJpQLWLI!É0!0GHVWKqPHVHQ#MHWHQFRQVRQQHDXJpQLWLIGHV
WKqPHVHQ6MDX[GpSHQVGXPRUSKqPHRULJLQHOFRPPHO·RQYLHQWGHOHUDSSHOHUDHXOLHXjXQHpSRTXHSUp
GRFXPHQWDLUH@O&HWWHVLWXDWLRQDSHUGXUpGXUDQWO·KLVWRLUHHQWLqUHGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVTXLRQWRSSRVpGHOD
UpVLVWDQFHjO·LQWURGXFWLRQGXPRUSKqPHQRXYHDXDORUVTXHFHOXLFLV·HVWGLIIXVpG·XQHPDQLqUHSUHVTXHVLPXO
WDQpH DX[DOHQWRXUVGX9qPHVLqFOHDYDQWQRWUHqUH GDQVOHVDXWUHVODQJXHVGHO·,WDOLHDQFLHQQHDXFRXUVGHOHXU
KLVWRLUHVRXVO·HIIHWGHODFRQYHUJHQFHOLQJXLVWLTXH ´6SUDFKEXQGµ @:%
8QHWHOOHUpVLVWDQFHjODFRQYHUJHQFHDYHFOHVODQJXHVYRLVLQHVjO·pSRTXHKLVWRULTXHV·H[SOLTXHGXSRLQWGH
YXHV\QFKURQLTXHSDUOHVPrPHVUDLVRQVTXLRQWDPHQpjODUpIHFWLRQDQDORJLTXHjO·pSRTXHSUpKLVWRULTXH/H
SRLQWGHGpSDUWGHFHWWHUpIHFWLRQHVWOHQRPLQDWLITXLjODVXLWHG·XQHV\QFRSHGDQVODV\OODEHILQDOHDSHUGXOD
YR\HOOHWKqPDWLTXH6MFHTXLUHPRQWHjO·pSRTXHSUpGRFXPHQWDLUHL @Q3DUOjOHQRPLQDWLIGHVWKqPHVHQ6M%9J%
FRQIRQGDYHFFHOXLGHVWKqPHVHQFRQVRQQHHWHQ#M$LQVL$w?$#=0 $61$#=6HW>1$É.%v%>1$#.6 WKqPHVHQ6M QH
VHGLVWLQJXHQWSDVUHVSHFWLYHPHQWGH>!""#=0¬ WKqPHHQFRQVRQQH HWGH(#"É.%v%(#"#.#0 WKqPHHQ#M 3XLVTXH
JpQpUDOHPHQWOHQRPLQDWLIRULHQWHOHSDUDGLJPHIOH[LRQQHOXQHGHVFRQVpTXHQFHVGHFHFKDQJHPHQWPRUSKR
SKRQRORJLTXHGXQRPLQDWLIDpWpODGLVSDULWLRQGXPRUSKqPHKpULWpGHJpQLWLI60#62TXLPDLQWLHQWYLVLEOHPHQWOD
PDUTXHWKpPDWLTXHHQ6M2@<REVFXUFLHDXQRPLQDWLI6RQUHPSODFHPHQWSDUODGpVLQHQFHGHVWKqPHVHQFRQVRQQH
HWHQ#M¬SHUPHWO·pWDEOLUXQSDUDOOpOLVPHDYHFO·pYROXWLRQGXQRPLQDWLI$XWUHPHQWGLWjSDUWLUGXPRPHQWROH
QRPLQDWLIGHVWKqPHVHQ6MV·pWDLWFRQIRUPpDX[WKqPHVHQFRQVRQQHHWHQ#MOHJpQLWLIDVXLYLOHPrPHGHVWLQ
&HWWHV\PpWULHIOH[LRQQHOOHTXLDXQLYHDXV\QFKURQLTXHV·HVWIL[pHGDQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVGqVO·pSRTXH
SUpGRFXPHQWDLUHDYUDLVHPEODEOHPHQWHPSrFKpODUpIHFWLRQGXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUTXLDDIIHFWpOHVDXWUHVODQJXHV
GHO·,WDOLHDQFLHQQHDXFRXUVGHOHXUGRFXPHQWDWLRQ
(QRXWUHO·H[WHQVLRQGHODGpVLQHQFH!É0lM!0DX[WKqPHVHQ6MDHXGHVUHWRPEpHVLPSRUWDQWHVGXSRLQWGH
YXHV\QFKURQLTXHFHSKpQRPqQHDFRQWULEXpjODWHQGDQFHjXQLIRUPLVHUOHVPDUTXHXUVGHODIOH[LRQHQWUHOHV
GLYHUVHVFODVVHVWKpPDWLTXHV$LQVLOHJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUGHVSDUDGLJPHVIOH[LRQQHOVGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVDpWp
UpGXLWjWURLVPRUSKqPHVOHVWKqPHVHQčJDUGHQWO·DQFLHQQHGpVLQHQFH(0DLQVLTXHOHVWKqPHVHQ1MTXLSUp
VHQWHQW610DORUVTXH!#0lM!É0V·pWHQGDX[WKqPHVHQ6MHQFRQVRQQHHWHQ#ML
'HFHWWHPDQLqUHOHJpQLWLIGHWRXWSDUDGLJPHIOH[LRQQHOHVWPDUTXpSDUODFRQVRQQH0­FHSURSRVVRXOL
JQRQVTXHOHVWKqPHVHQ1MQHVHPEOHQWJDUGHUOHXUPRUSKqPHRULJLQHOTX·DXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUDORUVTXHOHVDXWUHV
FDVGHOHXUGpFOLQDLVRQ³FRPPHO·RQYLHQWGHOHUDSSHOHUFLGHVVXV³RQWVXELGHVUpIHFWLRQVpFUDVDQWHVG·DSUqV
O·DQDORJLHDYHFOHVWKqPHVHQ6MHWHQ#MTXLRQWDERXWLjGHVIORWWHPHQWVUHPDUTXDEOHV$LQVLHQRPEULHQO·RQ
WURXYHOHJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHU$-#:6-  $-#&+610 jFRWpGHO·DEODWLI$-!:#%  $-#EKҸGLVVXGHVWKqPHVHQ#M PDLVO·DFFX
96K8G%$-#:6  $-#&+6>IOpFKLVHORQOHVWKqPHVHQ6M O·RVTXHSUpVHQWHOHJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHU4(0$-610jF{WpGHO·DEODWLI
4(0$-#"%  FDVWUҸG 'XGRXEOHWRVTXHGHO·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHU —Ǔဎ‫—ڗ‬HW>()#> GXPRW>()1´PDLQµRQDGpMjSDUOp
0DLVODWHQGDQFHDXUHPSODFHPHQWGXPRUSKqPHDQFLHQGXJpQLWLIGHVWKqPHVHQ1MSDU!É0VHPDQLIHVWHGDQV
OHJpQLWLIGXPRWHPSUXQWpDXODWLQ0!)($!#00rPHVLOHODWLQSUpVHQWHGHQRPEUHX[H[HPSOHVGHIORWWHPHQWGDQV
ODIOH[LRQGHFHPRWG·DSUqVOHVWKqPHVHQ6M VSpFLDOHPHQWOHJpQLWLIVHQDWҸDXOLHXGHVHQDWࡃV OHVDWWHVWDWLRQVGH
O·RVTXHQHFRQQDLVVHQWDXFXQH[HPSOHGHIOH[LRQG·DSUqVOHVWKqPHVHQ1M F·HVWjGLUH 0!)($610 F·HVWGRQFOH
PRGqOHIOH[LRQQHOHQ6MTXLV·HVWLPSRVpSDUWRXW

@?
&I/HXPDQQ &I0HLVHU
@Q

@O
9RLUjFHVXMHW3URVGRFLPL 6XUO·RULJLQHGHFHPRUSKqPHjSDUWLUGH6M0#6YRLU'H6LPRQH
@<

@:
&I:DOODFHHW(VND 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% F,KA<*/,B%8*%T<K/<*/,B7%H<B7%N87%7Y7*ZA87%FN8i/,BB8N7%H87%N<BD\87%7<S8NN/e\87% ::P

(QVRPPHODUpVLVWDQFHGXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUjODIRUFHGHO·DQDORJLHTXLDSUHVTXHDQpDQWLOHFDUDFWqUHRUL
JLQHOGHODGpFOLQDLVRQHQ1M2HVWDWWULEXDEOHjODSUpVHQFHGX02TXLDSRXUFRQVpTXHQFHXQHV\PpWULHDYHFOD
PrPHWHUPLQDLVRQFRQVRQDQWLTXHGHVDXWUHVSDUDGLJPHV$XWUHPHQWGLWODSUpVHQFHGX0DVHUYLjFUpHUXQH
V\PpWULHSDUIDLWHHQWUHOHVGLYHUVHVFODVVHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVTXLUHOqYHHQSDUWLHGHODFRQVHUYDWLRQHWHQSDUWLH
GHO·LQQRYDWLRQDQDORJLTXHYLVDQWDXPrPHEXWF·HVWjGLUHODIL[DWLRQG·XQHWHUPLQDLVRQXQLTXHHQ0GHYDQW
VHUYLUSRXUOHJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUGHWRXWW\SHQRPLQDO&HSURFpGpV·LQVFULWGDQVODPrPHWHQGDQFHTXHFHOOHTXHOH
ODWLQPDQLIHVWHDXFRXUVGHVRQKLVWRLUHSDUGHVPR\HQVGLIIpUHQWVO·KDUPRQLVDWLRQGXJpQLWLIGHVWKqPHVHQč%
SDUODUpIHFWLRQGHO·DQFLHQ(0SDU(!%G·DSUqVҸ UHPRQWDQWDXGpEXWGHODOLWWpUDWXUH jWUDYHUVODILOLqUHčҸ!(#%
HWO·DGRSWLRQGXJpQLWLIHQҸSDUOHVWKqPHVHQ1M H[GRPҸDXOLHXGH"6>10 
/HVIDLWVTXHQRXVDYRQVHVTXLVVpVFDUDFWpULVHQWODIOH[LRQGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVSDUGHVLQQRYDWLRQVDQDOR
JLTXHVTXLRQWFRQQXXQHYLWDOLWpELHQSOXVUHPDUTXDEOHTX·HQODWLQ&HVpYROXWLRQVRQWHXOHPrPHSRLQWGHGpSDUW
TX·HQODWLQF·HVWjGLUHO·DIIDLEOLVVHPHQWGHVV\OODEHVILQDOHVFRPPHFRQVpTXHQFHGHODSRVLWLRQGHO·DFFHQWHWGHV
FKDQJHPHQWVSKRQpWLTXHV ODWUDQVIRUPDWLRQGHVYR\HOOHVSDUDEUqJHPHQWHWPRQRSKWRQJDLVRQO·DPXwVVHPHQW
SDUGHVSDUFRXUVGLYHUVGHVFRQVRQQHVRFFOXVLYHVHWFRQWLQXHVWHOOHVTXH"2%M02%M>ODUpGXFWLRQGXJURXSH#60%
HQ#0lM#!0 
/HODWLQDXVVLIXWDVVXMHWWLjFHVPrPHVWHQGDQFHVPDLV³IDLWELHQFRQQX³ODODQJXHOLWWpUDLUHDH[HUFpXQ
FRQWU{OHULJLGHVXUODSURQRQFLDWLRQFRUUHFWHGHVGpVLQHQFHVFHTXLDpULJpXQHOLJQHGHGpPDUFDWLRQWUqVQHWWH
HQWUHODODQJXHpFULWHHWRIILFLHOOHHWO·XVDJHGXSDUOHULQIRUPHO(QUHYDQFKHOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVSHUPHWWHQW
GHPHWWUHjMRXUXQJUDQGQRPEUHGHIDLWVTXLGHPHXUHQWPDVTXpVGDQVO·KLVWRLUHGXODWLQ&·HVWVXUWRXWJUkFH
DX[WUDGLWLRQVRUWKRJUDSKLTXHVGLIIpUHQWHVTX·RQSHXWDSHUFHYRLUGHVIDLWVV\QFKURQLTXHVHWGLDFKURQLTXHVTXH
ODULJLGLWpGHODJUDSKLHODWLQHQHSHUPHWSDVG·HQWUHYRLU
/HVFKDQJHPHQWVSKRQpWLTXHVTXLVHPDQLIHVWHQWG·XQHPDQLqUHSOXVpFUDVDQWHHQRPEULHQTX·HQRVTXHVH
VRQWUpSHUFXWpVGDQVODVWUXFWXUHGHODGpFOLQDLVRQTXLDVXELGHVWUDQVIRUPDWLRQVSURIRQGHVSXLVTX·XQHVHXOH
GpVLQHQFHPDUTXHSOXVLHXUVFDVHWDSSDUWLHQWjGHVFODVVHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVGLYHUVHV2QUHSURGXLWLFLOHVFKpPD
XWLOLVpjSOXVLHXUVUHSULVHVSRXUPRQWUHUODFRQFHQWUDWLRQGHVIRQFWLRQVGLYHUVHVGDQVXQHPrPHWHUPLQDLVRQ
IOH[LRQQHOOHTXLVHUpDOLVHVXUWRXWHQRPEULHQ

1lM6 !

1RPVLQJWKqPHVHQč%
$FFVLQJWKqPHVHQ6M2%FRQVRQQH
$EOVLQJWKqPHVHQM6M
1RPSOXUWKqPHVHQ6M%
$FFSOXUPDVFQHXWWKqPHVHQ6M2%M1M
*pQSOXUWKqPHVHQFRQVRQQH
'DWSOXUWKqPHVHQ1M
'DWVLQJWKqPHVHQč6M2%M#MFRQVRQQH
/RFVLQJWKqPHVHQč6M2%M#M2%FRQVRQQH
$FFVLQJWKqPHVHQ%M#M
$EOVLQJWKqPHVHQM#MFRQVRQQH
m
³
m

&HWWHVLWXDWLRQWpPRLJQHG·XQH´FULVHµGXV\VWqPHGHODIOH[LRQTXLVHGpURXOHGHPDQLqUHSDUDOOqOHDX[GpYH
ORSSHPHQWVGXODWLQWDUGLIHWDX[pYROXWLRQVURPDQHV'HFHSRLQWGHYXHOHWpPRLJQDJHGHO·RPEULHQV·LQVFULW
GDQVODFRQWLQXLWpGHO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHTXLDIIHFWHXQLWDLUHPHQWOHVODQJXHVGHO·,WDOLHDQFLHQQHPDLVTXLHQ
ODWLQHVWUpSULPpHSDUO·HQVHLJQHPHQWOLWWpUDLUHHWPDVTXpHSDUODWUDGLWLRQRUWKRJUDSKLTXH'·DXWUHSDUWFRQWUH
FHFDUDFWqUHpYROXWLIO·RPEULHQDUpDJLHQGpYHORSSDQWjO·LQWpULHXUGHVRQV\VWqPHPRUSKRORJLTXHO·HPSORLGHV
SRVWSRVLWLRQVTXLUHPSODFHQWOHVDQFLHQQHVIRQFWLRQVGHVFDV&HVRQWOHVFDVGLWV´ORFDX[µTXLRQWVXELSOXVV\V
WpPDWLTXHPHQWO·LQWURGXFWLRQGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQV¬TXLIRQFWLRQQHQWFRPPHGHYpULWDEOHV´PDUTXHXUVGHFDVµHQ
VHVXEVWLWXDQWDX[GpVLQHQFHVDQFLHQQHV(QRPEULHQODIRQFWLRQGXORFDWLIDpWpPDUTXpHSDU=6>RX!) H[
?1=1=1>2%<4!06)#!> ODSURYHQDQFHRXO·pORLJQHPHQWDSSDUWHQDQWjO·DEODWLIpWDQWVLJQDOpVSDU$($6 H[()5.1$6 
'HVRQF{WpO·RVTXHV·LQVFULWGDQVODPrPHWHQGDQFHjXQLIRUPLVHUOHVFODVVHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVPDLVDSSDUHPPHQW
FHWWHWHQGDQFHHVWPRLQVVLJQLILFDWLYHTX·HQRPEULHQ2QSHXWV·LQWHUURJHUSRXUVDYRLUVLOHGHJUpPRLQVpYROXWLI
GHO·RVTXHHVWjDWWULEXHUjO·RUWKRJUDSKHFRQVHUYDWULFHTXLPDVTXHODUpDOLWpGHODODQJXHSDUOpH'HWRXWHIDoRQ
O·RVTXHSUpVHQWHXQHPSORLPRLQVPDVVLIGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVTXHO·RPEULHQFHTXLSODLGHHQIDYHXUG·XQHDXWRQRPLH
SOXVSURQRQFpHGHVWHUPLQDLVRQVIOH[LRQQHOOHVHWFRQVpTXHPPHQWGXPDLQWLHQGHVIRQFWLRQVRULJLQHOOHVGHVFDV
8QH[HPSOHQRXVHVWIRXUQLSDUO·DEODWLIRODFRQVHUYDWLRQGX"³DXPRLQVDXQLYHDXGHO·pFULWXUH³SHUPHW
 oi.uchicago.edu

:Q?% @<,N,%@,338**/

GHOHGLVWLQJXHULPPpGLDWHPHQWGDQVWRXWHFODVVHIOH[LRQQHOOHFHTXLOXLFRQIqUHODSURSULpWpWDQW{WGHJDUGHU
VHVIRQFWLRQVRULJLQHOOHV QRWDPPHQWODSURYHQDQFHRXO·pORLJQHPHQW WDQW{WG·DFTXpULUGHQRXYHOOHVIRQFWLRQV
QRWDPPHQWODORFDOLVDWLRQHQVHVXEVWLWXDQWDXORFDWLI 
1pDQPRLQVO·RVTXHOXLPrPHVHPEOHSHQFKHUSOXW{WYHUVO·HPSORLGHVSUpSRVLWLRQVHWPDQLIHVWHXQHWHQGDQFH
WUqVQHWWHjODVLPSOLILFDWLRQGHVSDUDGLJPHVIOH[LRQQHOVTXLDPqQHjXQLIRUPLVHUOHVWKqPHVHQFRQVRQQHHWOHV
WKqPHVHQ6M%jWUDYHUVO·H[WHQVLRQDQDORJLTXHGHVGpVLQHQFHVG·XQW\SHjO·DXWUH3DUH[HPSOHO·RVTXHHWO·RPEULHQ
SDUWDJHQWO·H[WHQVLRQGXPRUSKqPHGHO·DFFXVDWLIGHVWKqPHVHQ6MDX[WKqPHVHQFRQVRQQHPDLVO·RVTXHD
pWHQGXFHPrPHSURFpGpjO·DEODWLI XG‫گ‬G WDQGLVTXHO·RPEULHQVHGLVWLQJXHHQSUpVHQWDQWOHPRUSKqPHM!%
TXLSRXUUDLWV·H[SOLTXHUDXVVLjSDUWLUGXORFDWLI !%v%M!# @R&HWWHGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQVHUHIOqWHGDQVOHIORWWHPHQWGH
O·DEODWLIG·XQPrPHPRWWHOTXH(!$($1W(!$($!DWWHVWpHQSD\VSpOLJQLHQ&RPPHRQOHVDLWOHVDQFLHQVWUDLWVGH
O·RPEULHQHWOHVLQIOXHQFHVGHO·RVTXHVHFURLVHQWGDQVOHGLDOHFWHSpOLJQLHQ 7RXWHIRLVLOHVWpJDOHPHQWSRVVLEOH
TXH(!$($! DXOLHXGH(!$($1 UHOqYHGHODODWLQLVDWLRQGHODUpJLRQ@@%
3RXUFRQFOXUHHQRVTXHSUHVTXHWRXVOHVFDVGHODGpFOLQDLVRQGHVWKqPHVHQ6MHWGHVWKqPHVHQFRQVRQQH
VRQWPDUTXpVSDUOHVPrPHVPRUSKqPHVTXLDXVLQJXOLHUQHSHUPHWWHQWDXFXQHGLVWLQFWLRQHQWUHOHVGHX[SDUD
GLJPHVIOH[LRQQHOVVDXIDXGDWLI/HVFKpPDVXLYDQWLOOXVWUHFHVFRwQFLGHQFHV

$8HIL>8J7 WKqPHVHQ6M WKqPHVHQFRQVRQQH

+FM8H6K8G *w?$#=0 >!"#=0
*pQLWLI 7(=(-(=.!É0 >!"#=!É0
$FFXVDWLI 0(=(-(=.1>% .!5#)1>
!D>6K8G 0(=(-(=.1"% $()5#)1"

&HVSKpQRPqQHVG·KRPRJpQpLVDWLRQHQWUHOHVGHX[FODVVHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVRQWFRPPHUpVXOWDWV\QFKURQLTXH
O·REVFXUFLVVHPHQWGXVWDWXWG·DSSDUWHQDQFHRULJLQHOOHG·XQPRW&HWWHGpPDUFKHIDFLOLWHOHSDVVDJHG·XQPRW
G·XQSDUDGLJPHIOH[LRQQHOjO·DXWUHFRPPHSDUH[HPSOHHQWUHWKqPHVHQ ‫گ‬QHWWKqPHVHQ )6&HSURFpGp
FDUDFWpULVHDXVVLOHVYDULDWLRQVGXODWLQPDQLIHVWpHVSDUODGRXEOHIOH[LRQGHPRWVWHOVTXHHSXORQXVHSXO‫گ‬Q2%=67%>J9%
HPSUXQWVDXJUHFFRPPHSDUH[HPSOH˗Ԇඥ໵ङဎ!"#(46)10HWILQDOHPHQWSDUOHVDERXWLVVHPHQWVURPDQVFRPPH
SDUH[HPSOHLWDOLHQI("-6)!IUDQoDLVI($-6)LVVXVGHI($-6)10TXLVXSSRVHXQDOORPRUSKH SDWU‫گ‬QDWWHVWpHQJUHF
FRPPHHPSUXQWDXODWLQ ›ඥࠗ‫ݰ‬ङဎ 'HVRQF{WpO·RVTXHQRXVIRXUQLWO·H[HPSOHGH$-#&1:2QRPG·XQHFKDUJH
RIILFLHOOHGRQWOHPRGqOHHVWOH$-#&1)10URPDLQ/DPRUSKRORJLHGXPRWRVTXH³jODGLIIpUHQFHGHVRQFRUUHVSRQ
GDQWODWLQ³Q·DSSDUWLHQWSDVDX[WKqPHVHQ6M2PDLVDX[WKqPHVHQFRQVRQQHQRWDPPHQW WULE‫گ‬Q$LQVLOHPRW
RVTXH$-#&1:³PrPHV·LOV·DJLWG·XQHFUpDWLRQDXWRQRPH³pWDEOLWDYHFOHODWLQ$-#&1)10 @POHPrPHUDSSRUWTXHGHV
YDULDQWHVV\QFKURQLTXHVFRPPHHSXORQXVHSXO‫گ‬Q˗Ԇඥ໵ङဎGLDFRQXVSDWURQXVSDWU‫گ‬Q
3RXUFRPSOpWHUOHSDQRUDPDGHVFKDQJHPHQWVTXLRQWDSSRUWpGHVPRGLILFDWLRQVSURIRQGHVjODIOH[LRQRVTXH
LOQRXVVHPEOHXWLOHG·pYRTXHUXQIDLWG·LQQRYDWLRQWRXWjIDLWVSpFLDO/·DERXWLVVHPHQWSKRQpWLTXHGH '60%Ö%M#0%6%
VWLPXOpODGLVWLQFWLRQHQWUHOHVSUpQRPVHWOHVJHQWLOLFHVDXQRPLQDWLISDUODFUpDWLRQG·XQHWHUPLQDLVRQ#0%=FL7%
OHVXQVHW##0SRXUOHVDXWUHV$LQVLRQWURXYHO!-#02%Nw?=#0 SUpQRPV HWO!-##02%Nw?=##0 JHQWLOLFHV /·RVTXHDpWHQGX
FHWWHGLVWLQFWLRQjO·DFFXVDWLIHQUpDOLVDQWXQSDUDOOpOLVPHSDUIDLWGDQVODGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQPRUSKRORJLTXHHQWUH
SUpQRPVHWJHQWLOLFHVDXQRPLQDWLIHWjO·DFFXVDWLITXLQ·H[LVWHSDVHQODWLQ$LQVLO·RVTXHDPDUTXpOHVSUpQRPV
SDUOHVWHUPLQDLVRQV#0%v%jM'60DXQRPLQDWLIHW#>%v%jM'6>¬jO·DFFXVDWLIDORUVTXHOHJHQWLOLFHVSUpVHQWHQW##0
 ' '60DXQRPLQDWLIHW#6>%v%jM'6>jO·DFFXVDWLI&HWWHGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQPRUSKRORJLTXHQ·REpLWQLjGHVUDLVRQV
SKRQpWLTXHVQLjGHVIRQFWLRQVV\QWD[LTXHVPDLVHOOHUHSRVHVXUODGLVWLQFWLRQFXOWXUHOOHHWLQVWLWXWLRQQHOOHHQWUH
OHVGHX[pOpPHQWVGHODGpQRPLQDWLRQSHUVRQQHOOH(QHIIHWFHWWHGLVWLQFWLRQVHUWjO·LGHQWLILFDWLRQLPPpGLDWHGX
SUpQRPSDUUDSSRUWDXQRPGHIDPLOOHGDQVOHVGHX[IRQFWLRQVIRQGDPHQWDOHVFHOOHGXVXMHWHWFHOOHGHO·REMHW
$XFXQHGLVWLQFWLRQIRUPHOOHQHVpSDUHOHVDXWUHVFDVGHODIOH[LRQ/HVFKpPDVXLYDQWPRQWUHO·LQQRYDWLRQGH
O·RVTXHHQFRQWUDVWHDYHFOHODWLQ

@R
&IYRQ3ODQWD²YRO @P
­FHVXMHWRQUHQYRLHj3RFFHWWL

&I0HLVHUI 
­FHVXMHWFI/HMHXQH
@@
&I0HLVHU

&I&DPHURQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% F,KA<*/,B%8*%T<K/<*/,B7%H<B7%N87%7Y7*ZA87%FN8i/,BB8N7%H87%N<BD\87%7<S8NN/e\87% :QO

/))6?($#6)%"!%.;60X1!g%"#0$#)4$#6)%>6-I+6.65#X1!%"!0%()$+-6I6)'>!0%I(-%
-(II6-$%h%.!1-%:6)4$#6)%#)0$#$1$#6))!..!
3UpQRPV¬ *HQWLOLFHV

+FM8H6K8G N14#10% 36-)!.#10

-6K8H
$FFXVDWLI N14#1> 36-)!.#1>
+FM8H6K8G Nw?=#0% Nw?=##0lNw?=#!0%
2VTXH
$FFXVDWLI Nw?=#>% Nw?=#6>

3RXUFRQFOXUHODIOH[LRQGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVSUpVHQWHSOXVG·LQWpUrWSRXUOHVIDLWVG·LQQRYDWLRQTXHSRXU
OHVIDLWVGHFRQVHUYDWLRQSDUUDSSRUWjO·LQGRHXURSpHQ&HVODQJXHVSUpVHQWHQWGHVpYROXWLRQVDXWRQRPHVHQ
SDUWLHGLYHUJHQWHVHQSDUWLHFRQYHUJHQWHVDYHFOHODWLQPDLVTXLDQWLFLSHQWGHPDQLqUHVLJQLILFDWLYHOHVGpYH
ORSSHPHQWVGHO·pSRTXHWDUGLYHDLQVLTXHGHVODQJXHVURPDQHV

';<=>?@A?BCD
5L[67 +HOPXW5L[7(&!..#04+!%*!]$!g%H#!%*!]$!%"!0%,0=#04+!)2%\>&-#04+!)%1)"%7u"I#=!)#04+!)+HLGHOEHUJ&DUO
:LQWHU9HUODJ
7, -DPHV:3RXOWQH\*+!%S-6)G!%*(&.!0%6:%/51?#1>3KLORORJLFDO0RQRJUDSKV%DOWLPRUH$PHULFDQ
3KLORORJLFDO$VVRFLDWLRQ

6?;E?BF<@GH?I
$JRVWLQLDQL/XFLDQR
  ´5XNHV+D]VXLHV8QWUDWWRPRUIRORJLFRSDOHRLWDOLFRQHOOHSDUODWHDQHOOHQLFKHGL6LFLOLDµ'DQV
6DPQLWLFHORTXL6WXGLLQRQRUHGL$OGR3URVGRFLPLSHULOSUHPLR´,6DQQLWLµpGLWpSDU'&DLD]]DYROSS
²/LEUL&DPSDQR6DQQLWLFL$OLIH%DQFD&DSDVVR$QWRQLR
$QGUp-DFTXHV
  ´/HVFKDQJHPHQWVGHJHQUHGDQVOHVHPSUXQWVGXODWLQDXJUHFµJ6-"%²
"6MJ7FH2%!>6H%
  ´/DWLQ:RUGVLQWKH*UHHN,QVFULSWLRQVRI$VLD0LQRUµ<>!-#4()%P61-)(.%6:%@+#.6.65'²
&LSULDQR3HW00DQFLQL
  ´(QFOLVLHPRUIRORJLDGHOYHUER¶HVVHUH·QHOODWLQRHQHOO·RVFRµ7$1"#%.($#)#%!%-6>()G#%#)%>!>6-#(%"#%<)M
$6)#)6%@(5.#(-6pGLWpSDU:%HODUGLSS²%LEOLRWHFDGL5LFHUFKH/LQJXLVWLFKHH)LORORJLFKH
5RPH'LSDUWLPHQWRGL6WXGL*ORWWRDQWURSRORJLFL8QLYHUVLWj´/D6DSLHQ]Dµ
&ROHPDQ5
  ´3DWWHUQVRI6\QFUHWLVPLQ/DWLQµ'DQV7$1"#!0%#)%D-!!=2%/$(.#4%()"%/)"6M81-6I!()%N#)51#0$#40%,::!-!"%
$6%N!6)(-"%KL%@(.>!-pGLWpSDU$0RUSXUJR'DYLHVHW:0HLGSS²,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU
6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
'H6LPRQH&
  ´A!-41-#10%v%j>!-41M0#60HJOLDJJHWWLYLGLFODVVLILFD]LRQHLQ č -#10 č 0#60µK#?#0$(%"#%F#.6.65#(%!%"#%
/0$-1G#6)!%3.(00#4(²
 oi.uchicago.edu

:Q:% @<,N,%@,338**/

'HYRWR*
  ´8PEULFDµ'DQVAU.()5!0%.#)51#0$#X1!0%6::!-$0%h%AL%O6.5!-%@!"!-0!)SS²$DUKXV
8QLYHUVLWHWVIRUODJHW
38%*F78F2%!HKFH8F
% OP@<% S6?#()1>%T!$102%655#%@#!$-(&&6)"()$!5RPHQS
(UQRXW$
% OPRQ% A6-I+6.65#!%+#0$6-#X1!%"1%.($#)3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
*XVPDQL5
  ´1RWHPDUJLQDOLVXOODGHFOLQD]LRQHRVFRXPEUDµK!)"#46)$#%"!..;/0$#$1$6%N6>&(-"6%"#%74#!)G!%!%N!$$!-!%
²
.OLQJHQVFKPLWW*HUW
  ´'LHODWHLQLVFKH1RPLQDOIOH[LRQµ'DQVN($!#)%1)"%/)"65!->()#04+g%<=$!)%"!0%b6..6X1#1>0%"!-%/)"65!-M
>()#04+!)%D!0!..04+(:$2%7(.G&1-52%nrLqn|L%7!I$!>&!-%_áà|pGLWpSDU23DQDJOHW7.ULVFKSS²
,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU
8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
/D5HJLQD$GULDQR
  ´/HLVFUL]LRQLRVFKHGL3LHWUDEERQGDQWHHODTXHVWLRQHGL%RYLDQXPYHWXVµK+!#)#04+!0%A10!1>%O?PN%
²
  ´,6DQQLWLµ'DQV/$(.#(%6>)#1>%$!--(-1>%I(-!)0pGLWpSDU*3XJOLHVH&DUUDWHOOLSS²0LODQ
/LEUL6FKHLZLOOHU
/HMHXQH0LFKHO
  ´6XUOHWUDLWHPHQWRVTXHGH čILQDOµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
  N;()$+-6I6)'>#!%60X1!3DULV%HOOHVOHWWUHV
-JLM6HH2%06HL
% OP@@% N($!#)#04+!%D-(>>($#=0XQLFK%HFN
/HXPDQQ0DQX-RKDQQ%DSWLVW+RIPDQQHW$QWRQ6]DQW\U
% OP@:% N($!#)#04+!%D-(>>($#=0XQLFK%HFN
/|IVWHGW(LQDU
  7')$(4$#4(g%7$1"#!)%1)"%S!#$-a5!%G1-%+#0$6-#04+!)%7')$(]%"!0%N($!#)02%1F>LMJ%:N%7')$(=$#04+!M0$#.#0$#04+!%
D!0#4+$0I1)=$!%1)"%@-6&.!>!pPHpG$FWD5HJLDH6RFLHWDWLV+XPDQLRUXP/LWWHUDUXP/XQGHQVLV
/XQG*OHHUXS
0DJQL(
  ´,OQHXWURQHOOHOLQJXHURPDQ]HWUDUHOLWWLHSURWRWLSLµ7$1"#%!%7(55#%N#)51#0$#4#²
0J8>>JK2%!HKF8HJ%
  H!%X1!.X1!0%#))6?($#6)0%"!%.(%"U4.#)(#06)%.($#)!3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
  ´/HJHQUHJUDPPDWLFDOHWO·pOLPLQDWLRQGHODIOH[LRQµ74#!)$#(²
  80X1#00!%";1)!%+#0$6#-!%"!%.(%.()51!%.($#)!3DULV/LEUDLULH+DFKHWWH
0HLOOHW$QWRLQHHW-9HQGU\HV
% OP:@% *-(#$U%"!%5-(>>(#-!%46>I(-U!%"!0%.()51!0%4.(00#X1!03DULV&KDPSLRQ
0HLVHU*HUKDUG
  N(1$5!04+#4+$!%"!-%1>&-#04+!)%7I-(4+!L%,QQVEUXFNHU%HLWUlJH]XU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW,QQVEUXFN
,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN
  ´3lOLJQLVFK/DWHLQXQG6GSLNHQLVFKµD.6$$(²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% F,KA<*/,B%8*%T<K/<*/,B7%H<B7%N87%7Y7*ZA87%FN8i/,BB8N7%H87%N<BD\87%7<S8NN/e\87% :QQ

  ´6\QFUHWLVPLQ,QGR(XURSHDQ/DQJXDJHV0RWLYHV3URFHVVDQG5HVXOWVµ*-()0(4$#6)0%6:%$+!%@+#.6.65#M
4(.%764#!$'%²
0F>8HJ>>82%58J76
  ´&DVLHSUHSRVL]LRQLLQODWLQR/RVYLOXSSRGHOJHQLWLYRHGHOGDWLYR8QDSURVSHWWLYD DQFKH VRFLR
OLQJXLVWLFDµN#)51#0$#4(%!%F#.6.65#(²
1RFHQWLQL$OEHUWR
  ´3UHSRVL]LRQLHSRVSRVL]LRQLLQRVFRXPEURµ<-4+#?#6%D.6$$6.65#46%/$(.#()6²
5896H82%18KKF7J
  N!%.#)51!%"!..;/$(.#(%()$#4(%6.$-!%#.%.($#)6pPHpG0DQXHOHVWRULFRGHOODOLQJXDODWLQD7XULQ5RVHQEHUJ
6HOOLHU
3RFFHWWL3DROR
  ´1RWHVXOODGHFOLQD]LRQHLWDOLFDGHLWHPLLQM1LY%/)46)$-#%N#)51#0$#4#²
  ´8QDQXRYDFDULFDSXEEOLFDRVFD $-#&1:%I.#:-#=0 WUDSUREOHPLOLQJXLVWLFLHGLVWLWX]LRQDOLµ7$1"#%!%7(5M
5#%N#)51#0$#4#²²
  ´0HILWLVULYLVLWDWD YHQW·DQQLGRSR«HROWUHFRQSUROHJRPHQLHHSLOHJRPHQLPLQLPL µ'DQV%/.%41.$6%
"!..(%"!(%A!:#$!%!%.(%T(..!%";<)0()$6L%K#4!-4+!%01%1)%5#(4#>!)$6%(-4+!6.65#46%"!#%7(>)#$!0%O#-I#)#pGLWpSDU
$0HOHSS²$YHOOLQR6HOOLQR
3RU]LR*HUQLD0/
  ´$VSHWWLGHOO·LQIOXVVRODWLQRVXOOHVVLFRHVXOODVLQWDVVLRVFDµ<-4+#?#6%D.6$$6.65#46%/$(.#()6²
  ´7LSRORJLDOLQJXLVWLFDHFULVLGHOODGHFOLQD]LRQHLWDOLFDµ'DQV74-#$$#%.#)51#0$#4#%#)%6)6-!%"#%DL%SL%@!..!5-#M
)#SS²3LVH3DQFLQL
3URVGRFLPL$/
  ´1RWHVXOOHWDYROHGL*XEELRµ<$$#%!%A!>6-#!%"!..;<44("!>#(%@($(?#)(%"#%74#!)G!2%N!$$!-!%!%<-$#²
  ´,OJHQLWLYRVLQJRODUHQHOOHYDULHWjLWDOLFKH RVFRVDQQLWDXPEURVXGSLFHQRHWF µ/)46)$-#%N#)51#M
0$#4#²
5LHPDQQ2
% OP<P% 7')$(]!%.($#)!3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
5L[+HOPXW
  O#0$6-#04+!%D-(>>($#=%"!0%D-#!4+#04+!)'DUPVWDGW:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH%XFKJHVHOOVFKDIW
5RYDL)
  ´/·HVWHQVLRQHGHOO·DFFXVDWLYRLQODWLQRWDUGRHPHGLHYDOHµ<-4+#?#6%D.6$$6.65#46%/$(.#()6²
  ´0DQLIHVWD]LRQLGLVXEVLVWHPLWLSRORJLFLDWWLYLLQODWLQRµ<-4+#?#6%D.6$$6.65#46%/$(.#()6²
$J7D6K2%4LE
  3(0%!$%:6)4$#6)0g%U$1"!%"!0%I-#)4#I(.!0%"64$-#)!0%4(01!..!0%"1%A6'!)%<5!%h%)60%c61-0/LQJXLVWLTXHQRXYHOOH
3DULV3UHVVHV8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGH)UDQFH
  ´/HV\QFUpWLVPHGHVFDVTXHOTXHVUpIOH[LRQVµ'DQV71&6-"#)($#6)%()"%,$+!-%*6I#40%#)%N($#) 3URFHHG
LQJVRIWKH7KLUG&ROORTXLXPRQ/DWLQ/LQJXLVWLFV%RORJQD²$SULO pGLWpSDU*XDOWLHUR
&DOEROLSS²$PVWHUGDP%HQMDPLQV
7HUUDFLQL%
  ´3HUODVWRULDGHOQHXWURSOXUDOHODWLQR,OQHXWURSOXUDOHQHLGLDOHWWLLWDOLFLµK#?#0$(%"#%F#.6.65#(%!%"#%
/0$-1G#6)!%3.(00#4(²
7KXUQH\VHQ5
  ´,WDOLVFKHVµt!#$04+-#:$%:u-%?!-5.!#4+!)"!%7I-(4+:6-04+1)5²
 oi.uchicago.edu

:Q<% @<,N,%@,338**/

8QWHUPDQQ-UJHQ
% :???% J~-$!-&14+%"!0%,0=#04+M\>&-#04+!)+HLGHOEHUJ&:LQWHU
9RQ3ODQWD5
² D-(>>($#=%"!-%,0=#04+M\>&-#04+!)%H#(.!=$!6WUDVERXUJ7UEQHU
:DOODFH5(HW-)(VND
  ´5HPDUNVRQWKH7KHPDWLF*HQLWLYH6LQJXODULQ$QFLHQW,WDO\DQG5HODWHG0DWWHUVµ/)46)$-#%.#)51#0$#M
4#²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%QT,N\*/,B%N/BD\/7*/e\8%8B%N<*/B% :QR

!"
#$%&'(&)*+,-(.+/&,./0-.%(.1-'&'/&,$(./

A#4+E.!%F-1'$2%\)#?!-0#$U%"!%@(-#0%/T%M%76-&6))!

/HVFDVHQODWLQIXUHQWpWXGLpVGHSXLVSDUOHVSOXVJUDQGVOLQJXLVWHV -HDQ3HUURWO&KULVWLDQ7RXUDWLHU:%
(LILJKKJ%'LI8J72Q-HDQ+DXGU\<+DQV+DSS R,OVUHSUpVHQWHQWOHSUHPLHUGRPDLQHIRQGDWHXUDXTXHOIXUHQWDSSOL
TXpHVHQODWLQOHVPpWKRGHVGHODV\QWD[HFRQWHPSRUDLQHHWJUkFHDX[WUDYDX[GHFHVOLQJXLVWHVODWLQLVWHVO·pWXGH
UHQRXYHOpHGHODV\QWD[HFDVXHOOHRFFXSDGqVOHVDQQpHVXQHSODFHSULYLOpJLpHDXVVLELHQGDQVOHGpYHORSSHPHQW
GHODOLQJXLVWLTXHODWLQHV\QFKURQLTXHTXHGDQVODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHLQGRHXURSpHQQH
1RXVQRXVSURSRVRQVLFLGHWUDLWHUGHVFDVHQODWLQVRXVO·DQJOHGHO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHDXWUHGRPDLQHR
OHODWLQHVWDPHQpjMRXHUXQJUDQGU{OHpWDQWGRQQpODULFKHVVHGHVGRFXPHQWVIRXUQLVHWFHODVXUGHQRPEUHX[
VLqFOHV
&HWKqPHQRXVREOLJHjIDLUHGHX[UHPDUTXHVSUpOLPLQDLUHV(QSUHPLHUOLHXXQHODQJXHpWDQWHVVHQWLHOOHPHQW
XQSKpQRPqQHRUDOHWO·pFULWQ·pWDQWTX·XQHQRWDWLRQGHO·RUDOSRXUOHVODQJXHVDQFLHQQHVRQSRXUUDLWYpULWDEOH
PHQWSDUOHUGH´ODUHFKHUFKHGHO·RUDOSHUGXµ'HUULqUHO·pFULWTXLQHQRXVGRQQHTXHGHVLQIRUPDWLRQVSDUWLHOOHV
HWLQFRPSOqWHVVXUOHVpQRQFpVRUDX[F·HVWO·RUDOTX·LOQRXVIDXGUDLWHVVD\HUGHUHWURXYHU3RXUFHTXLHVWGHVFDV
LOHVWLPSRUWDQWGHVHIRQGHUGDQVODPHVXUHGXSRVVLEOHVXUODSURQRQFLDWLRQGHVGpVLQHQFHVFDVXHOOHVSOXW{WTXH
VXUODJUDSKLHOLYUpHSDUOHVWH[WHV(QVHFRQGOLHXLOHVWXWLOHGHUDSSHOHUTXHWRXWHVOHVODQJXHVQDWXUHOOHVVRQW
VRXPLVHVjO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHTXLHVWjO·RHXYUHGDQVWRXVOHVVHFWHXUVG·XQHODQJXHGRQQpHHWSDUWLFXOLqUH
PHQWGDQVOD]RQHGHODSKRQpWLTXHHWGHODSKRQRORJLHROHVpYROXWLRQVVRQWIDFLOHPHQWREVHUYDEOHV'HFHIDLW
OHVFDVFRPPHFDWpJRULHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHVRQWHX[DXVVLQpFHVVDLUHPHQWDIIHFWpVSDUO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXH
HWOHVPRUSKqPHVFDVXHOVVRQWLQpYLWDEOHPHQWVHQVLEOHVDX[pYROXWLRQVSKRQpWLTXHVHWSKRQRORJLTXHV
1RXVpWXGLHURQVGRQFHQSUHPLHUOLHX d OHVFDVHWOHVRUWGHVPRUSKqPHVFDVXHOVIDFHDX[SKpQRPqQHV
SKRQpWLTXHVHWSKRQRORJLTXHVGDQVO·KLVWRLUHGXODWLQ
1RXVSDVVHURQVHQVXLWHjODPDQLqUHGRQWO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHDSXDIIHFWHUODFDWpJRULHGHVFDVHWVHV
UHSUpVHQWDQWVVXUOHSODQPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHHQODWLQ$LQVLHQVHFRQGOLHX d YHUURQVQRXVFRPPHQWXQHIRUPH
FDVXHOOHIOpFKLHDSXrWUHOHVLqJHG·XQHWUDQVFDWpJRULVDWLRQVRLWHQGHYHQDQWXQOH[qPHjSDUWHQWLqUH JpQpUDOH
PHQWLQYDULDEOH VRLWHQpWDQWWUDQVIpUpHDYHFOHVWDWXWGHIRUPHGHOH[qPHGDQVXQDXWUHSDUDGLJPHIOH[LRQQHO
(QGHUQLHUOLHX d QRXVpYRTXHURQVUDSLGHPHQWG·DXWUHVVLWXDWLRQVRIIHUWHVSDUODPRUSKRV\QWD[HGHVFDV
HQODWLQTXLSUpVHQWHQWXQLQWpUrWFHUWDLQSRXUODOLQJXLVWLTXHHQJpQpUDO

O
3HUURW R
&IOHVDUWLFOHVGH+DXGU\HW7RXUDWLHUGDQVFHPrPHRXYUDJH
:
7RXUDWLHU!"#$"%& 
6HORQGHVWHQGDQFHVpYROXWLYHVTXHQRXVSRXYRQVH[SOLTXHUHWMXV
Q
)XJLHU WLILHUDSUqVFRXSORUVTX·HOOHVVHVRQWSURGXLWHVPDLVTXHJpQpUDOH
<
+DXGU\ PHQWQRXVQHVRPPHVSDVHQPHVXUHGHSUpYRLUDYDQWTX·HOOHVQH
VHSURGXLVHQW

:QR
 oi.uchicago.edu

% A/3OZN8%FK\Y*

!2&3456789:;<&<8&=4565>5?9<@&><&A9?69B9C68&D;&E5F=4GE<&HCA;<>
!2!2&34765EG6<A&?767FC;I
!2!2!2&.E=5F8C6H<&D<A&B96C><A&D<&E58A&DC6A&;6<&>C6?;<&B><I9566<>><
(QODWLQODQJXHIOH[LRQQHOOHOHVGpVLQHQFHVVRQWGHVPRUSKqPHV F·HVWjGLUHGHVXQLWpVPLQLPDOHVGHVLJQL
ILFDWLRQ HWSOXVSUpFLVpPHQWGHV>6-I+E>!0%(>(.5(>U02@GpQRWDQWFRQMRLQWHPHQWOHFDVHWOHQRPEUH VLQJYV
SOXU SRXUOHVVXEVWDQWLIVHWPrPHOHJHQUHSRXUOHVDGMHFWLIVHWFHUWDLQVVXEVWDQWLIV&HVPRUSKqPHVFDVXHOV
VLWXpVjODILQDOHGHPRWIXUHQWIUDJLOLVpVWUqVW{WHQODWLQGDQVODPHVXUHRO·pYROXWLRQSKRQpWLTXHHQWUDvQDOD
FKXWHGHVFRQVRQQHVILQDOHV³REVHUYDEOHGqVOHVLQVFULSWLRQVDUFKDwTXHVSUpOLWWpUDLUHV³DLQVLTXHGHVFKDQJH
PHQWVVWUXFWXUDX[GDQVOHV\VWqPHYRFDOLTXH

!2!2J2&#4C6?<E<68&D<A&8FC98A&=<F896<68A&DC6A&><&AKA8GE<&L5HC>9:;<&>C896
'DQV OH FRXUV GH OD ODWLQLWp RQ REVHUYH XQ FKDQJHPHQW GHV WUDLWV SHUWLQHQWV GDQV OH V\VWqPH GHV SKRQqPHV
YRFDOLTXHV ODWLQV ,O V·DJLW SULQFLSDOHPHQW GH OD GpSKRQRORJLVDWLRQ GH OD TXDQWLWp YRFDOLTXH SRXU ODTXHOOH QRXV
SRVVpGRQVOHWpPRLJQDJHGHVDLQW$XJXVWLQSRXUOHODWLQSDUOpSDUOHVJHQVLOOHWWUpVRXSHXOHWWUpVHQ<:-#4($XJXVWLQ
QRXVGLWHQHϸHWTXHOHVKDELWDQWVGHFHWWHUpJLRQQHGLVWLQJXHQWSDVOHVYR\HOOHVEUqYHVHWOHVYR\HOOHVORQJXHVHWLO
FLWHHQH[HPSOHOHVGHX[QRPLQDWLIVDFFXVDWLIVVLQJQHXW‫ڨ‬V´RVµDYHFXQ6%D7JG%JK%‫گ‬V´EDVGXYLVDJHERXFKHµDYHFXQ6%
ORQJjVRQpSRTXHFHVGHX[IRUPHVQHVRQWSOXVGLVWLQJXpHVQRXVGLWLOSDUOHVKDELWDQWVGHO·<:-#4(L%
'DQVFHVFDVG·KRPRSKRQLH$XJXVWLQ H!%"64$-#)(%4+-#0$#()( UHIXVHO·DPELJXwWpHWO·´REVFXULWpµ 1!-&1>%
6&041-1>%1!.%(>&#511>f%(>&#51#$(0%6&041-#$(0X1! HWLOFRQVHLOOHGHSULYLOpJLHUODFODUWpGHO·H[SUHVVLRQ !1#"!)$#(f%X1#"%
&!)!%#)"#4!$%($X1!%#)$#>!$%X16"%60$!)"!-!%#)$!)"#$ PrPHV·LOIDXWSRXUFHODUHFRXULUDXQLYHDXGHODQJXHSDUOpSDU
GHVSHUVRQQHVQRQOHWWUpHV 11.5#%>6-!f%#)"64$# ,OIDXWDORUVUHQRQFHUpFULWLODX[WHUPHV´FRUUHFWVµVHORQO·XVDJH
GHVVDYDQWV (%"64$#0f%1!-&(%41.$#6-(f%X1#"%&!)!%06)!$ HWHPSOR\HUOHVWHUPHVXVXHOVGDQVODODQJXHFRPPXQH2UOD
GF7MJ%6001>SRXUOHQRPLQDWLIHWO·DFFXVDWLIQHXWVLQJGXQRPGHO·RVDQDORJLTXHGHVQHXWUHVGHODJ%GpFOLQDLVRQ
GXW\SH$!>I.1>pWDLWODIRUPHXVXHOOHHQXVDJHGDQVOHODWLQ´VWDQGDUGµGHVJHQVQRQRXSHXFXOWLYpVjODSODFH
GH‫ڨ‬V DYHFYR\HOOHEUqYHDSSDUWHQDQWjODJGpFOLQDLVRQ 

!LIL9K8H2%H!%"64$-#)(%4+-#0$#()(«FXUSLHWDWLVGRFWRUHPSLJHDWLPSHULWLVORTXHQWHP´F99LM%I6$#10%X1(>%
´F9µGLFHUHQHLVWDV\OODEDQRQDEHRTXRGVXQW´F996µVHGDEHRTXRGVXQW´F76%#)$!..!5($1-2%1&#%<:-(!%(1-!0%"!%
46--!I$#6)!%164(.#1>%1!.%I-6"14$#6)!%)6)%#1"#4()$[%
´SRXUTXRLXQVDYDQWSLHX[SDUODQWjGHVJHQVQRQFXOWLYpVUpSXJQHUDLWLOjGLUH´6001>µSOXW{WTXH´602Y%
SRXUpYLWHUTXHFHWWHV\OODEHQHVRLWFRPSULVHQRQSDUUDSSURFKHPHQWDYHF´600(µ ´OHVRVµSOXULHO PDLV
DYHF6-( ´OHVERXFKHVOHVYLVDJHVµSOXULHO pWDQWGRQQpTXHOHVRUHLOOHVGHVKDELWDQWVGHO·<:-#4(%HJ%9FHK%=69%
VHQVLEOHVjODGLIIpUHQFHHQWUHYR\HOOHPEUqYHHWYR\HOOHORQJXH"µ

3RXUWUDQVSRVHUHQWHUPHVOLQJXLVWLTXHVFRQWHPSRUDLQVODWUDGXFWLRQGHFHGHUQLHUSDVVDJHRQSHXWGLUH
TXHGDQVODODQJXHSDUOpHGHVKDELWDQWVQRQOHWWUpVGHO·<:-#4(jO·pSRTXHG·$XJXVWLQO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHYR\HOOH
ORQJXHHWYR\HOOHEUqYHGHPrPHWLPEUH LFLHQWUH‫گ‬%>FHI%JK%‫ڨ‬EUHI pWDLWGpMjQHXWUDOLVpH&HSDVVDJHFRQVWLWXHXQ
WpPRLJQDJHLQGLUHFWGHO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHTXLDIIHFWDGDQVFHWWHUpJLRQGHO·HPSLUHOHV\VWqPHYRFDOLTXH
HQVXSSULPDQWOHWUDLWSHUWLQHQWTX·pWDLWODORQJXHXUGHVYR\HOOHV
(QHIIHWSRXUUHPSODFHUO·DQFLHQQHRSSRVLWLRQTXDQWLWDWLYHGHVYR\HOOHVV·HVWSURGXLWHODSKRQRORJLVDWLRQ
GHO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHYR\HOOHRXYHUWHHWYR\HOOHIHUPpH 6RXYHUWYV6IHUPp!RXYHUWYV!IHUPpHWF HQV\OODEH
DFFHQWXpHFRPPHOHSURXYHQWOHVUpVXOWDWVREVHUYDEOHVGDQVSOXVLHXUVODQJXHVURPDQHV

@
6HORQODWHUPLQRORJLHG·$0DUWLQHW

3RXYDQWpYHQWXHOOHPHQWDOOHUGDQVFHUWDLQVFDVMXVTX·jXQHKRPR
Q\PLHFRPSOqWHORUVTXHWRXWHVOHVIRUPHVGHGHX[OH[qPHVGLIIpUHQWV
VHSURQRQFHQWGHODPrPHPDQLqUH
P
%!LIL9K8H%JM=>F8J%>J%MFK%164(.#1> JpQSOXU ODWUDGXFWLRQFRU
UHFWHHVWGRQF´ODTXDQWLWpEUqYHRXORQJXHGHVYR\HOOHVµHWQRQSDV
GHV´V\OODEHVµFRPPHFHODILJXUHGDQVODWUDGXFWLRQGH0DGHOHLQH
0F7J6L%OPP@N%QRRTXLHVWODVXLYDQWH´«SRXUTXRLXQPDvWUHGHSLpWp
UpSXJQHUDLWLOSDUODQWjGHVLJQRUDQWVjGLUH´6001>µSOXW{WTXH´602Y%
SRXUpYLWHUTX·RQSUHQQHFHWWHV\OODEHGRQWOHSOXULHOHVW´6-(µ OHV
ERXFKHV SRXUFHOOHGRQWOHSOXULHOHVW´600(µ OHVRV pWDQWGRQQp
TXHOHVRUHLOOHVDIULFDLQHVQHGLVWLQJXHQWSDVXQH9E>>6DJEUqYHG·XQH
9E>>6DJ%>FHILJSY%
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%QT,N\*/,B%N/BD\/7*/e\8%8B%N<*/B% :Q@

!2!2M2&,<A&96A;BB9AC6H<A&D;&AKA8GE<&?FC=49:;<
0DOKHXUHXVHPHQWOHVFKDQJHPHQWVSKRQRORJLTXHVGRQWODODQJXHODWLQHIXWOHVLqJHQHVHVRQWSDVDFFRP
SDJQpVGHFKDQJHPHQWVJUDSKLTXHVRXSOXW{WJUDSKpPDWLTXHVLOQHIXWSDVLQVWLWXpGHQRXYHDXV\VWqPHJUDSKp
PDWLTXHSRXUGpQRWHUOHQRXYHDXV\VWqPHSKRQRORJLTXH
&HVLQVXIILVDQFHVGXV\VWqPHJUDSKLTXHVHPDQLIHVWHQWGDQVOHVWH[WHVSDUGHVYDULDWLRQVHQWUHOHVJUDSKLHV
F·HVWjGLUHLFLOHVOHWWUHVRXVLJQHVJUDSKLTXHV H!HWL!G·XQHSDUWHWHQWUHR!HWX!GHO·DXWUH/DJUDSKLHH!
HQDUULYHjQRWHUTXDWUHDQFLHQVSKRQqPHVODGLSKWRQJXHDHOH̒RXYHUWOH̋ FHTXLHVWGpMjYLVLEOHGDQV
OHVLQVFULSWLRQVGH3RPSpLjODILQGX,J7VLqFOH SXLVOH̒IHUPpSXLVTXHGDQVOHVWDEOHWWHVGH9LQGRODQGD ILQ
GX,J7HWGpEXWGX,,JVLqFOH RQWURXYHODJUDSKLHPDH!SRXUP̒SRXUOHSURQRPSHUVRQQHOGHJSHUVRQQHGXVLQJ
$LQVLOHVVLJQHVJUDSKLTXHVGHVWH[WHVODWLQVVRQWLOVjO·pSRTXHSRVWFODVVLTXHORLQG·rWUHGHVJUDSKqPHV
F·HVWjGLUHGHVXQLWpVJUDSKLTXHVSHUWLQHQWHVUHQYR\DQWFKDFXQHjGHVSKRQqPHVGHPDQLqUHELXQLYRTXH

!2J2&,<&D<L<69F&D;&E5F=4GE<&HCA;<>@&>C&BFC?9>987&D<A&D7A96<6H<A
$XVHLQGHFHVWHQGDQFHVpYROXWLYHVXQHSRVLWLRQGDQVOHPRWHVWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWH[SRVpHjO·pURVLRQSKR
QpWLTXHODILQGHPRWTXLHVWSUpFLVpPHQWODSRVLWLRQRFFXSpHSDUOHPRUSKqPHIOH[LRQQHODXVVLELHQGDQVOD
IOH[LRQQRPLQDOHTXHGDQVODIOH[LRQYHUEDOH
'qVOHVLQVFULSWLRQVDUFKDwTXHVSUpOLWWpUDLUHVO·DEVHQFHGHQRWDWLRQGHVFRQVRQQHVHQILQGHPRWUHIOqWH
ODFKXWHGHVFRQVRQQHVILQDOHVjO·RUDO/HIDLWTXHOHVYR\HOOHVEUqYHVHQV\OODEHILQDOHIHUPpHQHVHVRLHQWSDV
HQFRUHIHUPpHVHWTX·HQRXWUHjO·pFULWRQQHQRWHSDVODORQJXHXUGHVYR\HOOHVFUpHGHVDPELJXwWpVSDUH[HPSOH
HQWUHDFFXVDWLIHWDEODWLIVLQJGDQVOD JGpFOLQDLVRQXQPRWTXLVHWHUPLQHGDQVXQHLQVFULSWLRQDYHFODOHWWUH
R!SHXWFRUUHVSRQGUHjGHX[PRUSKqPHVGpVLQHQWLHOV࠽P DFFVLQJ O?HW‫ گ‬DEOVLQJ 2QREVHUYHGRQFGqV
OHVLQVFULSWLRQVGHO·pSRTXHDUFKDwTXHSUpOLWWpUDLUHGHVKRPRSKRQLHVHQWUHDFFXVDWLIVLQJHWDEODWLIVLQJGDQV
FHUWDLQHVIOH[LRQV

!2J2!2&N5E5=4569<&<68F<&B5FE<A&O&>PCHH;AC89B&A96?;>9<F&<8&B5FE<A&O&>PCQ>C89B&A96?;>9<F
$SUqVO·pSRTXHFODVVLTXHOHVIORWWHPHQWVHWYDULDWLRQVHQWUHDFFXVDWLIHWDEODWLIjO·pFULWVHPXOWLSOLHQWGDQV
OHVWH[WHVGHEDVQLYHDXGHODQJXHFRPPHOHVOHWWUHVGHVROGDWV³GRQWRQSHXWFRQVLGpUHUTX·HOOHVRQWjODIRLV
OHVWDWXWGHO·´RUDOpFULWµHWGHO·´pFULWRUDOLVpµ³HWVXUWRXWGDQVOHVWH[WHVGHO·pSRTXHWDUGLYHTXLUHVWHQWUHOD
WLYHPHQWSURFKHVGHODODQJXHSDUOpH

!2J2J2&/<;8FC>9AC8956&D<&>P5==5A98956&CHH;AC89B&LA2&CQ>C89B&D<FF9GF<&=F7=5A98956
/HVQHXWUDOLVDWLRQVHQWUHDFFXVDWLIHWDEODWLIVRQWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWQHWWHVGHUULqUHSUpSRVLWLRQGDQVOHVV\Q
WDJPHVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOV'DQVOHVOHWWUHVGXVROGDW5XVWLXV%DUEDUXV VROGDWURPDLQFDQWRQQpHQ(J\SWH jVRQ
FDPDUDGH3RPSHLXVOOODSUpSRVLWLRQG̒HVWSDUH[HPSOHGDQVOHSDVVDJHVXLYDQWVXLYLHQRQG·XQHIRUPHG·DEODWLI
PDLVG·XQHIRUPHJUDSKLTXHG·DFFXVDWLI

856%)6)%$()X1(>%(>#41>%+(&#62%0!$%$()X1(%:-($-!>%5!>!..1>2%X1#%"!%1)1>%1!)$-!>%!]#1$%
´0RLMHWHFRQVLGqUHQRQFRPPHXQDPLPDLVFRPPHXQIUqUHMXPHDXTXLHVWVRUWLG·XQVHXOYHQWUHµ

'DQVFHSDVVDJHOHVIORWWHPHQWVJUDSKLTXHVUpYqOHQWXQHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGDQVODSURQRQFLDWLRQGHVGHX[IRUPHV
FDVXHOOHVGHO·DFFXVDWLIVLQJHWGHO·DEODWLIVLQJGHVJ ࡃQXPGHࡃQXV(1>´XQµ HWJ 1!)$-!>GH1!)$!-2%M$-#0%
´YHQWUHµ GpFOLQDLVRQV
'DQVOHVV\QWDJPHVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOVFHWWHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQHVWFRQVWDQWHGDQVODSOXSDUWGHVWH[WHVG·pSRTXH
WDUGLYH&KH]*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVjO·H[WUrPLWpGHO·$QWLTXLWpWDUGLYH 9,JVLqFOH XQSDVVDJHFRPPHOHVXLYDQW
PRQWUHGHUULqUHODSUpSRVLWLRQ"!XQHIRUPHGH+#4DGMHFWLIGpLFWLTXH+64TXLSRXUUDLWrWUHXQDFFXVDWLIQHXW

O?
&HWWHILQDOHHQR!SHXWHQRXWUHUHSUpVHQWHUODGpVLQHQFHDU OO
9llQlQHQ,J7%FL%**J%VLqFOH *XpUDXG² 
FKDwTXHGHJpQLWLISOXULHOGHODJGpFOLQDLVRQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% A/3OZN8%FK\Y*

VLQJ DQFLHQQHPHQWK‫ڨ‬F RXXQDEODWLIPDVFRXQHXWVLQJ DQFLHQQHPHQWK‫گ‬F GpWHUPLQDQWXQHIRUPHVXEVWDQ

WLYDOH>1)"1>G·DFFXVDWLIVLQJJUDSKLTXHDORUVTXHOHWHUPH%>1)"10%´PRQGHµpWDLWPDVFXOLQjO·pSRTXHFODVVLTXH
*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV2%O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>9,,,´/(>2%#)X1#"2%>!%H!10%I-(!4!I#$%"!%+64%>1)"1>%164(-!L
´'pMjGLWLO'LHXDGpFLGpGHPHUDSSHOHUGHFHPRQGHµ

2QDGRQFGDQVFHWH[HPSOHXQGpFDODJHJUDSKLTXHPHQWHQWUHXQVXEVWDQWLI>1)"1>2TXLHVWjO·DFFXVDWLI
JUDSKLTXHHWSRXUUDLWrWUHDXPDVFXOLQDWWHQGXRXDXQHXWUHLQDWWHQGXHWXQGpWHUPLQDQW+64TXLV·LOHVWDX
PDVFXOLQHVWjO·DEODWLIHWV·LOHVWDXQHXWUHHVWjO·DFFXVDWLI'DQVFHELQ{PHJUDSKLTXH´GpWHUPLQDQWVXEVWDQ
WLIµRQQHSHXWGRQFWURXYHUGHVLWXDWLRQGHFRQFRUGDQFHROHVGHX[WHUPHVVRLHQWDFFRUGpVO·XQDYHFO·DXWUH
/·K\SRWKqVHODSOXVSUREDEOHHVWTXHKRF!pWDLWSURQRQFpRFDYHFXQHYR\HOOH6 XQ6IHUPpRXXQ6RXYHUW" 
LQGLVWLQFWHSRXUODORQJXHXUWDQGLVTXHGDQVODILQDOHGH>1)"1>Ö2%ODQDVDOHILQDOHP!Q·pWDLWSDVSURQRQFpH
HWTXHODYR\HOOHjODILQDOHDEVROXHpWDLWSURQRQFpHGHWHOOHPDQLqUHTX·RQQHSRXYDLW\UHFRQQDvWUHQLOH࠽
DQFLHQQLOH‫گ‬DQFLHQ

!2J2M2&/<;8FC>9AC8956&DC6A&>C&E5F=45>5?9<&D<A&:;<A8956A&D<&>9<;
&HVQHXWUDOLVDWLRQVHQWUHDFFXVDWLIHWDEODWLIXVXHOOHVjO·RUDOGDQVFHUWDLQVQLYHDX[GHODQJXHRQWEURXLOOpOD
SHUFHSWLRQHWODFRQVFLHQFHTXHOHVXMHWSDUODQWDYDLWGXV\VWqPHGHVTXDWUHTXHVWLRQVGHOLHX1&#[%TX‫"گ‬XQGH"TXč"
'pMjjO·pSRTXHDUFKDwTXHHWFODVVLTXHFHUWDLQVDGYHUEHVVSDWLDX[pWDLHQWSRO\VpPLTXHVHWSRXYDLHQWGpQRWHU
GHVPRXYHPHQWVUHOHYDQWGHGHX[RXWURLVGHFHVTXHVWLRQVGHOLHX/·DGYHUEHODW#)$10GHSDUVDIRUPDWLRQ $10%
SURYLHQWG·XQHDQFLHQQHGpVLQHQFHG·DEODWLIDSSDUHQWpHGDQVOHVDQVNULW$(0 GHYDLWPDUTXHUO·RULJLQHHWVLJQLILHU
´jSDUWLUGHO·LQWpULHXUµ GHODPDLVRQHWF VHQVDWWHVWpFKH]3ODXWH0DLVLOHVWDXVVLDWWHVWpDYHFOHVHQVGH´YHUV
O·LQWpULHXUµ /XFUqFH7LWH/LYH HWDYHFOHVHQVGH´jO·LQWpULHXUµVDQVPRXYHPHQW &LFpURQ#)$10%#)%()#>#02%#)$10%
#)%46-I6-!´GDQVOHVHVSULWVµ´GDQVOHFRUSVµ 
/HVWH[WHVGXODWLQWDUGLIRIIUHQWGHVLQGLFHVGHODSHUWHGHO·RSSRVLWLRQ´VDQVPRXYHPHQWµ DEODWLIORFDWLI
TXHVWLRQ1&#[ YV´DYHFPRXYHPHQWYHUVµ DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLITXHVWLRQTX‫ "گ‬/DT!$10%N($#)(O:%RIIUHGpMjGHVYD
ULDQWHVDYHF#)DEODWLI GDQVO·/$(.( HWDYHFO·DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLI GDQVO·<:-( SRXUGpQRWHUXQ´PRXYHPHQWYHUVµ
³GHPDQLqUHDWWHQGXHHWFRQIRUPpPHQWjODV\QWD[HFODVVLTXHSRXUO·DFFXVDWLI³GDQVOHSDVVDJHVXLYDQWGH
>T8?()5#.!%0!.6)%0(#)$%P!()WDQGLVTXHODT1.5($!2OQHPSORLHO·DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLI
T!$10%N($#)(2%/6+,WDOD!$%(04!)"#$%/!010%#)%O#!-606.'>#0$IUD!$%/!010%(04!)"#$%O#!-606.'>(f%1L>I6KJN%!$%
(04!)"#$%O#!-606.'>(>%/!010´(W-pVXVPRQWDj-pUXVDOHPµ

!2J2R2&,<A&H56A8F;H8956A&CQA5>;<A&O&>P7=5:;<&8CFD9L<
&HVIORWWHPHQWVFDVXHOVjO·RUDOHWjO·pFULWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWIUpTXHQWVHQWUHDFFXVDWLIHWDEODWLIVHPDQL
IHVWHQWFODLUHPHQWGDQVOHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVDEVROXHVjO·pSRTXHWDUGLYHRDXOLHXGXVHXODEODWLIDEVROXFRQQX
SDUO·pSRTXHFODVVLTXHRQDHQRXWUHGDQVODJUDSKLHGHVDFFXVDWLIVDEVROXVGHVQRPLQDWLIVDEVROXVHWPrPHGHV
FRQVWUXFWLRQV´PL[WHVµRIIUDQWFRQMRLQWHPHQWGHX[IRUPHVjGHX[FDVGLIIpUHQWVSDUH[HPSOHO·XQHjO·DEODWLIHW
O·DXWUHjO·DFFXVDWLI
/HVSULQFLSHVGHODGLVWULEXWLRQHQWUHFHVDEODWLIVDFFXVDWLIVQRPLQDWLIVDEVROXVQHVRQWSDVFODLUVpWDQW
GRQQpTXHOHVVXMHWVSDUODQWVDYDLHQWSUREDEOHPHQWSHUGXODFRQQDLVVDQFHGHVFDWpJRULHVPRUSKRORJLTXHVSRU
WDQWFHVGpQRPLQDWLRQV&HWWHSHUWHGHFRQVFLHQFHHVWHOOHPrPHXQHIIHWVHFRQGDLUHGHODSHUWHGHVRSSRVLWLRQV
GLVWLQFWLYHVHQWUHOHVGpVLQHQFHVjO·RUDO
1RXVSRXUULRQVLOOXVWUHUOHSKpQRPqQHSDUGHQRPEUHX[WH[WHVGH*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO<%&H%6%LH%6D>6K8G%6D9F>L%
JUDSKLTXHGDQV
*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV2%O#0$L%F-LSOO1#10%1!-6%&-(4+#1>%&!($10%46):!006-%41>%6.!6%&!)!"#4$6%46)$-!4$()02%
#)I60#$6%0#5)6%4-14#02%-!0$#$1#$%0()1>´0DLVOHVDLQWFRQIHVVHXU HQ IURWWDQWOHEUDVGHFHWKRPPHDYHFGH

O:
6HORQOHWH[WHpWDEOLSDU$-OLFKHU O<
&I*D\QRHWjSDUDvWUH
OQ
6HORQOHWH[WHGH1HVWOHHW$ODQG
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%QT,N\*/,B%N/BD\/7*/e\8%8B%N<*/B% :QP

O·KXLOHEpQLWHDSUqV \ DYRLULPSRVpOHVLJQHGHODFURL[OHJXpULWµOLWW´OHVDLQWFRQIHVVHXUOHVLJQHGHOD
FURL[D\DQWpWpLPSRVp SDUOXL µ

jF{WpG·XQHFRQVWUXFWLRQPL[WHDYHFO·DFFXVDWLISRXUOHSDUWLFLSHSXLVO·DEODWLISRXUOHVXEVWDQWLI ODJUDSKLHDH!
FRUUHVSRQGjO·DQFLHQ̒GHGL̒DEODWLIGHGL̒VµMRXUµ GDQV
*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV2%O#0$L%F-L%1***2%QON%<"1!)#!)$!>%(1$!>%"6>#)#4(!%-!01--!4$#6)#0%"#(!2%d
´/HMRXUGHODUpVXUUHFWLRQGX6HLJQHXUDUULYDQW«µ

0DLVRQDHQUHYDQFKHGHVDFFXVDWLIVDEVROXVJUDSKLTXHVGDQVOHVH[HPSOHVVXLYDQWV
*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV2%O#0$L%F-LSOe1!>%0(4!-"60%(-4!00#$1>%0!4-#$#10%46!I#$%!#%#)0#)1(-!%1$%d

´/·pYrTXHO·D\DQWIDLWYHQLUHQVHFUHWFRPPHQFHjLQVLQXHUTXH«µOLWW´FHWKRPPHD\DQWpWpPDQGp SDU
O·pYrTXH O·pYrTXHFRPPHQFHj«µ

*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV2%O#0$L%F-LSO<"!I$1>%!-56%dI6)$#:#4($10%6::#4#1>2%6-($#6)#%1(4(&($%
´$\DQWREWHQXODFKDUJHGHSDSHLOVHFRQVDFUDjO·RUDLVRQ«µ´DSUqVDYRLUREWHQX«µ´TXDQGLOHXWREWHQX
«µOLWW´/DFKDUJHGHSDSHD\DQWpWpREWHQXH SDUOXL LO«µ

*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV2%O#0$L%F-Lg%dL%/..!%d%!I#046I102%164($1>%("%0!%X1!)"(>%+6>#)!>%d2%(#$g%d
´/·pYrTXHD\DQWPDQGpDXSUqVGHOXLXQKRPPH«GLW«µOLWW´O·pYrTXHXQKRPPHD\DQWpWpPDQGpDXSUqV
GHOXL SDUOXL GLW«µ

!2M2&,<A&B>588<E<68A&HCA;<>A&?FC=49:;<A&H5EE<&96D9H<&DP;6&H4C6?<E<68&E5F=45AK68CI9:;<
/HVIORWWHPHQWVFDVXHOVDXQLYHDXJUDSKLTXHGDQVOHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVSDUWLFLSLDOHVFKH]*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVVRQW
SUREDEOHPHQWHQSDUWLHODPDUTXHGHO·pPHUJHQFHG·XQHQRXYHOOHFDWpJRULHJUDPPDWLFDOHOHSDUWLFLSHSDUIDLW
DFWLI8QV\VWqPHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHQRXYHDXHVWHQWUDLQGHV·LQVWDOOHU2QGHYLQHGHUULqUHFHUWDLQVHPSORLVGX
SDUWLFLSHSUpVHQWDFWLIHQM)0RXGXSDUWLFLSHSDVVpSDVVLIHQ$102%M(2%M1>OHVSUpPLFHVG·XQHQRXYHOOHFDWpJRULH
JUDPPDWLFDOHTXLIDLVDLWGpIDXWHQODWLQFODVVLTXHHWTXLH[LVWHUDGDQVOHVODQJXHVURPDQHVOHSDUWLFLSHSDVVp
DFWLI/HVIDLWVVRQWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWYLVLEOHVORUVTXHODIRUPHHVWVLWXpHDXGpEXWGHODSKUDVHHWDSSRVpHDXVXMHW
GXYHUEHSULQFLSDOFRPPHGDQVOHVSKUDVHVGXW\SHIUDQoDLV('()$%:(#$%$!..!%4+60!2%#.%0!%-!)"#$%!)01#$!%h%$!.%!)"-6#$
/HSDUWLFLSHHQ$10(1> RXVDYDULDQWHSKRQpWLTXHPHQWFRQGLWLRQQpH010(1> DYDLWGHSXLVOHGpEXW
GHODODWLQLWpQRQXQVHQVSDVVLIPDLVXQVHQVDFWLIGDQVOHSDUDGLJPHGHVYHUEHVGpSRQHQWV2UFHVYHUEHVVRQW
ELHQUHSUpVHQWpVGDQVODFDWpJRULHVpPDQWLTXHGpQRWDQWXQPRXYHPHQWRXXQGpSODFHPHQWHWLOVRQWXQHJUDQGH
IUpTXHQFHGDQVOHUpFLWFKH]*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVRO·RQWURXYHSDUH[HPSOH-!5-!0010´pWDQWUHYHQXµ GH-!5-!"#6-%
´UHYHQLUµ %FL%-!1!-010GHPrPHVHQV GH-!1!-$6- (%*+6-#)5#(%-!5-!0010´pWDQWUHQWUpGH7KRULQJHµ-!1!-0#0%)1)$##0%
´OHVPHVVDJHUVpWDQWUHYHQXV¬pWDQWGHUHWRXUµ´DSUqVOHUHWRXUGHVPHVVDJHUVµ
&HVIDLWVDYDLHQWG€MHWHUXQFHUWDLQGRXWHGDQVODFRQVFLHQFHOLQJXLVWLTXHGHVVXMHWVSDUODQWVOHVPRLQVFXOWL
YpVVXUODYDOHXUSDVVLYHGXSDUWLFLSHSDUIDLWHQ$10 010 2QSHXWGRQFFRPSUHQGUHTXHSDUXQHpYROXWLRQXOWp
ULHXUHUHQIRUFpHOHSDUWLFLSHHQ$10DLWWDQW{WODYDOHXUDQFLHQQHG·XQSDUWLFLSHSDUIDLWSDVVLIHWWDQW{WODYDOHXU
QRXYHOOHG·XQSDUWLFLSHSDUIDLWDFWLISUpILJXUDQWDLQVLO·H[LVWHQFHGHFHWWHQRXYHOOHFDWpJRULHPRUSKRORJLTXHGDQV
OHVODQJXHVURPDQHV&RPPHSRXUOHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVDEVROXHVPHQWLRQQpHVSUpFpGHPPHQWGHWHOOHVpYROXWLRQV
IXUHQWIDYRULVpHVSDUODSHUWHGHSHUWLQHQFHHWGHGLVWLQFWLYLWpGHVGpVLQHQFHVFDVXHOOHVjO·RUDO

!2R2&S7HC>C?<&<68F<&?FC=49<&<8&=F5656H9C8956&<6&>C896&8CFD9B
$O·pSRTXHGH*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVODJUDSKLHRIIUDLWXQGpFDODJHFHUWDLQDYHFODSURQRQFLDWLRQFHODpWDLWG€
QRQVHXOHPHQWDX[SKpQRPqQHVSKRQpWLTXHVPHQWLRQQpVSOXVKDXW GLVSDULWLRQGHVFRQVRQQHVILQDOHVGDQVOD
SURQRQFLDWLRQGpSKRQRORJLVDWLRQGHODORQJXHXUGHVYR\HOOHV PDLVHQRXWUHjODSRVVLEOHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHV
YR\HOOHVHQV\OODEHILQDOHHQXQ´HFHQWUDOµTXLVHORQ-DQVRQORWRXFKDLWOHVDQFLHQQHVYR\HOOHVEUqYHVú̋

OR
&I-DQVRQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

:<?% A/3OZN8%FK\Y*

Wү࠽GDQVOHVJUDSKLHVQRPLQDOHVD!DP!H!HP!XP!HWSRXUOHVYHUEHVGDQVOHVJUDSKLHVLW!WDQGLV
TXHOHVDQFLHQQHVYR\HOOHVORQJXHVGRQQDLHQWč!D̒!HIHUPpҸ!L‫!گ‬RIHUPpࡃ!X
$LQVLOHVJUDSKLHVVRQWHOOHVjFHWWHpSRTXHVHXOHPHQWOHUHIOHWGHODFRQVFLHQFHOLQJXLVWLTXHGHVVFULEHVHW
GHVVFULSWHXUVHWQRQOHUHIOHWGXIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHODODQJXH/HVVFULEHVVXLYHQWOHVHQVHLJQHPHQWVTX·LOVRQW
UHoXVVHORQOHVTXHOVLOFRQYLHQWG·pFULUHWHOOHRXWHOOHOHWWUHGDQVWHOOHRXWHOOHVLWXDWLRQ8QV\VWqPHSKRQRORJLTXH
QRXYHDXV·HVWLQVWDOOpjO·RUDOVDQVTXHO·pFULWVRLWFDSDEOHGHOHQRWHU

!2T2&/<;8FC>9AC8956&<68F<&D<;I&8K=<A&D<&A;Q5FD5667<A&H5E=>789L<A
/DSHUWHGHSHUWLQHQFHjO·RUDOSXLVjO·pFULWGHFHUWDLQVpOpPHQWVIOH[LRQQHOVHVWpJDOHPHQWUHVSRQVDEOHGH
FKDQJHPHQWVGDQVO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQV\QFKURQLTXHGHVVXERUGRQQpHVFRPSOpWLYHV&HVRQWOjOHVFRQVpTXHQFHVGH
O·KRPRSKRQLHHQWUHFHUWDLQHVIRUPHVG·LQILQLWLI VXUWRXWO·LQILQLWLISUpVHQWDFWLIGHVW\SHVDPčUHPRQ̒UHOHJHUH
FDSHUHDXGҸUH HWFHUWDLQHVIRUPHVGHVXEMRQFWLI VXUWRXWOHVXEMRQFWLILPSDUIDLWjODJSHUVRQQHVLQJJ%=J79FHHJ%
VLQJJSHUVRQQHSOXUDPčUHPDPčUHWDPčUHQWPRQ̒UHPPRQ̒UHWPRQ̒UHQW.!5!-!>2%.!5!-!$2%.!5!-!)$HWF (Q
UDLVRQGHODSHUWHGHVFRQVRQQHVILQDOHVGDQVODSURQRQFLDWLRQXQHIRUPHG·LQILQLWLISUpVHQWDFWLIFRPPHGࡃFHUH%
pWDLWKRPRSKRQHGHVIRUPHVGHVXEMRQFWLILPSDUIDLWGHVJSHUVRQQHVLQJJSHUVRQQHVGXVLQJHWSOXUGࡃFHUH > 
GࡃFHUH $ GࡃFHUH )$ L%(QRXWUHXQHIRUPHG·LQILQLWLISDUIDLWDFWLIFRPPHXҸGLVVHpWDLWKRPRSKRQHGHVIRUPHVGH
VXEMRQFWLISOXVTXHSDUIDLWGHVJSHUVRQQHVLQJJSHUVRQQHVGXVLQJHWSOXUXҸGLVVH > XҸGLVVH $ XҸGLVVH )$ L
&HWWHKRPRSKRQLHHQWUDvQDGDQVODSHUFHSWLRQGXVXMHWSDUODQWHWPrPHGDQVODFRQVFLHQFHOLQJXLVWLTXHGX
VFULSWHXURXGXVFULEHSURIHVVLRQQHOXQHSHUWHGHFRQQDLVVDQFHGHODGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQHQWUHXQHSURSRVLWLRQLQIL
QLWLYHDYHFXQVXMHWjO·DFFXVDWLIHWXQYHUEHjO·LQILQLWLIG·XQHSDUWHWXQHSURSRVLWLRQFRPSOpWLYHDXVXEMRQFWLI
DYHFXQVXMHWDXQRPLQDWLIGHO·DXWUH
'DQVODOHWWUHVXLYDQWHGXVROGDW5XVWLXV%DUEDUXVOHYHUEHSULQFLSDOVFҸUH´VDYRLUµGHPDQGHUDLWXQHSUR
SRVLWLRQLQILQLWLYHOHVXMHWP̒HVWELHQjO·DFFXVDWLIDWWHQGXPDLVODIRUPHYHUEDOHGࡃFHUHPHVWXQHJUDSKLHGH
VXEMRQFWLILPSDUIDLWjODJSHUVRQQHVLQJDXOLHXGHO·LQILQLWLIGࡃFHUHDWWHQGX
74#$6%!)#>%l%>!%1]6-!>%"14!-!>L´6DFKHHQHIIHWTXHMHPHPDULHµ

3XLVTXHODSURQRQFLDWLRQFRUUHVSRQGDLWjGࡃFHUHVDQV>ILQDOVLOHVFULSWHXUDWUDFpXQ>SXUHPHQWJUDSKLTXH
HWQRQSURQRQFpF·HVWTX·LOQHFRQQDLVVDLWSOXVODIRUPHPRUSKRORJLTXHH[DFWHGHODSURSRVLWLRQLQILQLWLYH
,QYHUVHPHQWOHVVXERUGRQQpHVFRPSOpWLYHVHQX1#(%GHUULqUHXQYHUEH´GLUHµGHYLHQQHQWXVXHOOHVHQODWLQ
WDUGLIRHOOHVUHPSODFHQWO·DQFLHQQHVWUXFWXUHGHODSURSRVLWLRQLQILQLWLYH*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVSHXWFRPPHQFHU
XQHWHOOHFRPSOpWLYHSDUXQVXERUGRQQDQWX1#(DWWHQGXHQODWLQWDUGLIPDLVSRXUVXLYUHDYHFXQHIRUPHJUDSKLTXH
G·LQILQLWLI GRQF´LPSHUVRQQHOOHµ SRXUOHYHUEHOjRO·RQDWWHQGUDLWXQVXEMRQFWLI´SHUVRQQHOµRQDODJUDSKLH
1#"#00!Ö TXLGHYDLWUHIOpWHUODSURQRQFLDWLRQVDQV$%ILQDO DXOLHXGHODJUDSKLH1#"#00!$ÖN
*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV2%O#0$L%F-L,,SO<#1)$%!)#>2%X1#(2%I-#10X1(>%+#%+60$!0%1!)!-!)$2%1#"#00!%1#-1>%:#"!.!>%
#)%1#01%d%´2QGLWHQHIIHWTXHDYDQWTXHFHVHQQHPLVQ·DUULYHQWXQILGqOHDXUDLWHXXQHYLVLRQµ

2QSRXUUDLWFLWHUHQRXWUHGHVH[HPSOHVGHVXMHWVGHSURSRVLWLRQLQILQLWLYHTXLQHVRQWSDVjO·DFFXVDWLIHWGHVXMHWV
GHSURSRVLWLRQVFRPSOpWLYHVjYHUEHSHUVRQQHOTXLVRQWjO·DFFXVDWLI

!2U2&,<A&A<;9>A&D<&85>7FC6H<&D<A&45E5=4569<AV&><A&CDC=8C8956A
2QGHYLQHDLVpPHQWTXHOHVKRPRSKRQLHVSRXYDLHQWGHYHQLUXQREVWDFOHDXIRQFWLRQQHPHQWPRUSKRV\Q
WD[LTXHGHODODQJXH&HUWDLQHVKRPRSKRQLHVJrQDQWHVRQWSURYRTXpGHVUpDFWLRQVGHODSDUWGHODODQJXHTXL
SURFqGDjGHVDGDSWDWLRQVSRXUOHXUWURXYHUXQUHPqGH0DLVRQFRQVWDWHTX·jO·LQYHUVHFHUWDLQHVKRPRSKRQLHV
pWDLHQWWROpUpHVSDUODODQJXHRQGRLWVXSSRVHUGHFHIDLWTX·HOOHVQHJrQDLHQWSDVOHV\VWqPHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXH
GDQVVRQHIILFDFLWp

9llQlQHQ,J7%FL%**JVLqFOH *XpUDXG² &I



VXSUD†B!1$-(.#0($#6)%"!%.;6II60#$#6)%(4410($#:%?0L%(&.($#:%"!--#E-!%
I-UI60#$#6)HWQRWH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%QT,N\*/,B%N/BD\/7*/e\8%8B%N<*/B% :<O

'qVO·pSRTXHGHVSUHPLHUVWH[WHVOLWWpUDLUHVH[LVWHQWGHVKRPRSKRQLHVDQFLHQQHVWROpUpHVSDUODODQJXHSDU
H[HPSOH
‡ QRPLQDWLIVLQJHWJpQLWLIVLQJGDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQFҸXLV
‡ GDWLISOXUHWDEODWLISOXUGDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQGRPLQҸV !#0 GDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQ
FRQVXOLEXVFҸXLEXVGDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQ>()#&10GDQVODqPHGpFOLQDLVRQU̒EXV
‡ GDWLIVLQJHWDEODWLIVLQJGDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQSXSSҸ
‡ QRPLQDWLISOXUHWDFFXVDWLISOXUGDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQFRQVXO̒V
‡ JpQLWLIVLQJHWQRPLQDWLISOXUGDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQPDQࡃV

'HVKRPRSKRQLHVSOXVUpFHQWHVIXUHQWpJDOHPHQWWROpUpHV

‡ GDWLIVLQJHWDEODWLIVLQJGDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQGRPLQ‫ گ‬6#RX‫گ‬LDXGDWLIVLQJPDLV
‫گ‬HW‫گ‬GjO·DEODWLIVLQJ 
‡ JpQLWLIVLQJHWGDWLIVLQJGHODJGpFOLQDLVRQ1#(! JpQLWLIVLQJ«čҸPDLVGDWLIVLQJ
GLSKWRQJXH«DL čL 
‡ JpQLWLIVLQJHWQRPLQDWLISOXUGDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQGRPLQҸ ҸSRXUOHJpQLWLIVLQJPDLV
«!#SRXUOHQRPLQDWLISOXU 
‡ /DILQG·XQ´V\QFUpWLVPHµHVWDWWHVWpHSRXUO·DEODWLIVLQJGHODJGpFOLQDLVRQHQWUHXQ
DQFLHQLQVWUXPHQWDOHQ‫گ‬HWXQDEODWLIG·RULJLQHHQ‫گ‬G!‫گ‬
$XFRQWUDLUHRQFRQVWDWHTXHGHVKRPRSKRQLHVJrQDQWHVRQWpWppYLWpHV$YDQWO·pSRTXHOLWWpUDLUHRQpYLWD
GDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQO·KRPRSKRQLHHQWUHOHQRPLQDWLIVLQJHWO·DEODWLIVLQJTXLDXUDLHQWSXrWUHWRXVGHX[
HQč'DQVFHWWHVWUDWpJLHG·pYLWHPHQWLO\HXWXQDEUpJHPHQWGHODYR\HOOHGXQRPLQDWLIVLQJFHTXLFUpDXQH
RSSRVLWLRQ´YR\HOOHEUqYHYVYR\HOOHORQJXHGHPrPHWLPEUHµSRXUOHQRPLQDWLIVLQJYVO·DEODWLIVLQJ QRPLQDWLI
HQúYVDEODWLIHQč 
'DQVOHVLQVFULSWLRQVDUFKDwTXHVXQ6!JUDSKLTXHjODILQDOHDEVROXHGHPRWSHXWFRUUHVSRQGUHDXVVLELHQj
XQQRPLQDWLIVLQJHQ«‫ڨ‬V TXLGRQQHUDHQVXLWH࠽V TX·jXQDFFXVDWLIVLQJHQ«‫ڨ‬P TXLGRQQHUDHQVXLWH࠽P RX
HQFRUHjXQJpQLWLISOXU JpQLWLIDUFKDwTXHSRXUODJGpFOLQDLVRQ HQ«‫ڨ‬P TXLGRQQHUDHQVXLWH࠽P &HVKRPR
SKRQLHVPHWWDLHQWOHV\VWqPHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHHQGDQJHU3RXU\UHPpGLHURQUpWDEOLWODVLIIODQWH0ILQDOHGX
QRPLQDWLIVLQJ GDQVODJUDSKLHPDLVDXVVLGDQVODSURQRQFLDWLRQ ODQDVDOH>ILQDOHGHO·DFFXVDWLIVLQJ GDQV
ODJUDSKLHPDLVVDSURQRQFLDWLRQGHPHXUDIDLEOHHWSKRQpWLTXHPHQWFRQGLWLRQQpHSDUOHVDؐGKLH[WHUQHDYDQW
O·DPXLVVHPHQWGHFHWWHFRQVRQQHILQDOH $XVVLFHVpYROXWLRQVSKRQpWLTXHVSDUFHTX·HOOHVPHQDoDLHQWODYLDELOLWp
GXV\VWqPHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHIXUHQWHOOHVMXJpHVLQWROpUDEOHVHWIXUHQWHOOHVFRQWUHFDUUpHV
,OHVWSUREDEOHHQRXWUHTXHGDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQWKpPDWLTXHO·DPELJXwWpGHODIRUPHHQ‫ڨ‬P!࠽PTXL
SRXYDLWrWUHXQDFFXVDWLIVLQJRXELHQXQJpQLWLISOXUDUFKDwTXHDIDYRULVpODFUpDWLRQG·XQHQRXYHOOHIRUPHSOXV
GLVWLQFWLYHHQ‫گ‬UXPGHJpQLWLISOXULHOjYR\HOOHORQJXHLQLWLDOH DQDORJLTXHGHODJGpFOLQDLVRQGHVVXEVWDQWLIV 
pWHQGXHjSDUWLUGHODGpVLQHQFH V‫گ‬PKpULWpHGDQVODIOH[LRQSURQRPLQDOH

J2&W9?<E<68&DP;6<&B5FE<&HCA;<>><&B>7H49<@&8FC6AHC87?5F9AC8956
/RUVTXHOHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVODWLQHVIXUHQWVRXPLVHVjO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHFRPPHGDQVG·DXWUHVODQJXHV
IOH[LRQQHOOHVHOOHVIXUHQWSDUIRLVO·REMHWGHILJHPHQWVHWFRQQXUHQWXQHWUDQVFDWpJRULVDWLRQ
&HSURFHVVXVGHULJLGLILFDWLRQGHFHUWDLQHVIRUPHVIOpFKLHVDERXWLWjODIRUPDWLRQGHOH[qPHVLQYDULDEOHV GHV
DGYHUEHVGHVpPDQWLVPHYDULpHWGLYHUVpOpPHQWVGHUHODWLRQGHVFRQMRQFWLRQVGHVXERUGLQDWLRQGHVSUpSRVLWLRQV 
RXELHQDXWUDQVIHUWGHFHUWDLQHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVVXEVWDQWLYDOHVGDQVXQSDUDGLJPHYHUEDORHOOHVRQWDORUVMRXp
OHU{OHGHIRUPHVQRPLQDOHVGXYHUEH
 oi.uchicago.edu

:<:% A/3OZN8%FK\Y*

J2!2&,<A&D7A96<6H<A&O&>P5F9?96<&D<&H56X56H8956A&D<&A;Q5FD96C8956&
8QJUDQGQRPEUHGHVFRQMRQFWLRQVGHVXERUGLQDWLRQHWGHVDGYHUEHVFRUUpODWLIVGXODWLQVRQWLVVXVGHODSKUDVH
FRUUpODWLYHO@RGHVWKqPHVHQX1M%W%1MGHSURQRPDGMHFWLIDGYHUEHUHODWLIpWDLHQWDVVRFLpVjGHVWKqPHVHQ$M%l%#M%
GHSURQRPDGMHFWLIDGYHUEHFRUUpODWLIGDQVGHVFRXSOHVWHOVTXHX16>% !41> d2%$1>%d´ORUVTXH«DORUV«µ%X1(>%
d%$(>d%1&#%d%#&#d´OjR«Oj«µRXELHQ´ORUVTXH«Oj«µ%1$%d2%#$(%d´GDQVODPHVXUHR«GDQVFHWWHPHVXUH«µ%
X1()$1>d%2%$()$1>d´DXWDQWTXH«DXWDQW«µ/·RULJLQHH[DFWHGHVPRUSKqPHVILQDX[GDQVFHVOH[qPHVGHPHXUH
XQVXMHWGHGpEDWSRXUOHVFRPSDUDWLVWHVPDLVRQSHXWVXSSRVHUTXHGDQVXQERQQRPEUHGHFHVOH[qPHVLOV·DJLW
G·DQFLHQQHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVQRPLQDOHVRXDGYHUELDOHVOH[LFDOLVpHV
$YHFGDYDQWDJHGHFHUWLWXGHQRXVSRXYRQVDIILUPHUTXHOHVVXERUGRQQDQWVX16"%JK%X1#(UHSUpVHQWHQWUHVSHF
WLYHPHQWO·DFFXVDWLIQHXWVLQJGXWKqPH =96TXLIRXUQLWDXODWLQXQHERQQHSDUWLHGHVIRUPHVGHVRQSURQRP
UHODWLI TXҸ2%41#102%TX‫گ‬HWF 2HWO·DFFXVDWLIQHXWSOXU%GXWKqPHj=9#TXLIRXUQLWXQHDXWUHSDUWLHGHVIRUPHVGX
UHODWLIODWLQ X1!>2%X1#&10HWF 'HPrPHOHVDQVNULWDWLOFRQQXXQHOH[LFDOLVDWLRQGHODIRUPHG·DFFXVDWLIQHXWUH
VLQJGHVRQSURQRPUHODWLIGHYHQXXQHFRQMRQFWLRQGHVXERUGLQDWLRQK\SRWKpWLTXHVDQVNULW'("%´VLµ/HSUR
FHVVXVG·pYROXWLRQTXLPHQDjODOH[LFDOLVDWLRQGHODIRUPHODWLQHX16"GXSURQRPUHODWLIHQXQHFRQMRQFWLRQGH
VXERUGLQDWLRQFDXVDOHHVWHQFRUHGpFHODEOHHQODWLQGDQVFHUWDLQVFDVLQWHUPpGLDLUHVRX16"pTXLYDXWjIUDQoDLV
.!%:(#$%X1!«pYROXDQWIDFLOHPHQWGDQVFHUWDLQVFRQWH[WHVYHUVIUDQoDLV"1%:(#$%X1!«jYDOHXUFDXVDOH
8QDEODWLILQVWUXPHQWDOILJpGXWKqPH =9#HVWSUREDEOHPHQWjO·RULJLQHGHTXҸQ%JK%TXҸ´FRPPHQWµFHVGHX[
OH[qPHVSRXYDQWIRQFWLRQQHUFRPPHGHVVXERUGRQQDQWVPDLVDXVVLFRPPHGHVDGYHUEHVLQWHUURJDWLIV UHVSHF
WLYHPHQW´SRXUTXRLQHSDV"µHW´FRPPHQW"µ 

J2J2&,<A&D7A96<6H<A&HCA;<>><A&O&>P5F9?96<&DP7>7E<68A&D<&F<>C8956&<8&D<&><IGE<A&:;C689B9HC8<;FA&
'HQRPEUHX[OH[qPHVODWLQVLQYDULDEOHVUpVXOWHQWGXILJHPHQWG·XQHIRUPHVXEVWDQWLYDOHIOpFKLH7HOOHHVW
O·KLVWRLUHGHO·DGYHUEHTXDQWLILFDWHXUI(-$#>%´HQSDUWLHµ SDUWLP«SDUWLPSDUWLP«DOLҸV´XQHSDUWLH«XQHDXWUH
SDUWLH«µ´OHVXQV«OHVDXWUHV«µ SUREDEOHPHQWLVVXGXILJHPHQWGHO·DFFXVDWLIGXVXEVWDQWLITXDQWLILFDWHXU
I(-02%I(-$#0%´SDUWLHµ6LO·DFFXVDWLIXVXHOGDQVOHSDUDGLJPHGHFHVXEVWDQWLIHVWI(-$!>LOQHVHUDLWSDVpWRQQDQW
TXHO·DGYHUEHDLWFRQVHUYpODWUDFHG·XQHIRUPHDUFKDwTXHHQ#
8QUHODWHXUVSDWLRWHPSRUHOFRPPHODSUpSRVLWLRQ()$!´GHYDQWµ!HVWLVVXGXILJHPHQWG·XQHIRUPHGHORFDWLI
VLQJG·XQDQFLHQQRPGXYLVDJHVHORQOHSURFpGpELHQLOOXVWUpGHODJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQG·XQQRPGHSDUWLHGX
FRUSV FIIUDQoDLV!)%:(4!%"!DQJODLV#)%:-6)$%6: 
/HVpWDSHVLQWHUPpGLDLUHVG·XQHWHOOHJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQVRQWYLVLEOHVHQODWLQSRXUOHVXEVWDQWLI:-6)02%:-6)$#0%
IpP´KDXWGXYLVDJHIURQWYLVDJHµ2QREVHUYHHQHIIHWGDQVXQHSUHPLqUHpWDSHGXSURFHVVXVXQHPpWDSKRUH
OH[LFDOHORUVTXH:-6)0HVWWUDQVIpUpjODGpQRWDWLRQGHOD´SDUWLHDQWpULHXUHG·XQEkWLPHQWG·XQFDPSG·XQQDYLUH
HWFµ3XLVGDQVXQHVHFRQGHpWDSHpYROXWLYHRQUHQFRQWUHOHVVpTXHQFHVOH[LFDOLVpHV#)%:-6)$!> &pVDUS!..1>%
D(..#41> DXVHQVGH´VXUOHGHYDQWGH«HQIDFHGH«µHW(%:-6)$!´GHIURQWµ &LFpURQ&pVDU RLOQHV·DJLW
SOXVGHV\QWDJPHVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOVPDLVGpMjGHOH[LHVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHVF·HVWjGLUHGHSUpSRVLWLRQVVSDWLDOHV
UpDOLVpHVVRXVODIRUPHPRUSKRORJLTXHG·XQHOH[LHFRPSOH[HG·XQHVpTXHQFHGH´PRWVµIRUPDQWJOREDOHPHQW
XQHVHXOHXQLWpOH[LFDOH
/RUVTX·XQHIRUPHIOpFKLHVRUWG·XQSDUDGLJPHSRXUGHYHQLUXQOH[qPHDGYHUELDODXWRQRPHLOQ·HVWSDVUDUH
TXHOHQRXYHDXOH[qPHRIIUHXQHGpVLQHQFHFDVXHOOHGLIIpUHQWHGHODIRUPHXVLWpHGDQVOHSDUDGLJPHGXVXEVWDQWLI
GHGpSDUW$LQVLO·DGYHUEHWHPSRUHOQRFWࡃ´GHQXLWµDWLOXQࡃORQJTXLFRQWUDVWHDYHFOH̋EUHIGHQRFW̋6D>6K8G%
GXVXEVWDQWLI)6]2%)64$#0IpP´QXLWµOP&HWWHGLIIpUHQFHHQWUHO·DGYHUEHHWODIRUPHOLEUHGXOH[qPHG·RLOHVWLVVX
V·H[SOLTXHLFLSUREDEOHPHQW:?SDUXQHLQIOXHQFHDQDORJLTXHGHVRQDQWRQ\PHGLࡃ´GHMRXUµDQFLHQORFDWLIILJp
GXQRPGXMRXUOXPLQHX[GHYHQXDGYHUEHWHPSRUHOHQSDVVDQWSDUOHVHQV´GXUDQWWRXWOHMRXUµSRXUDERXWLUj

O@
+DXGU\)UX\WHW EDJDJHV«µ@.!-#X1!%4!)0!&()$%1$%)64$1%#$!-%:(4!-!)$´/DSOXSDUW

)OHFN pWDLHQWG·DYLVGHYR\DJHUGHQXLWµHQIDFHGHA!"#(%4#-4#$!-%
OP
/DGLIIpUHQFHG·HPSORLHQWUHO·DGYHUEHQRFWࡃ%JK%>6%GF7MJ%9LD9K6H )64$!2%d´(QYLURQDXPLOLHXGHODQXLW«µ
WLYDOH)64$! VXVFHSWLEOHG·rWUHGpWHUPLQpHSDUXQDGMHFWLILFLPHGLč 
:?
2QDSXDXVVLO·H[SOLTXHUSDUODWUDFHG·XQDQFLHQWKqPHHQ1%=FL7%
V·REVHUYHGDQVOHVH[HPSOHVVXLYDQWV&pVDUS!..1>%4#?#.!/..#% FHVXEVWDQWLITXLDQRUPDOHPHQWXQWKqPHFRQVRQDQWLTXHHQGHQWDOH
d%1!-#$#%)!%)64$1%#>I!"#$#%01&%6)!-!%46):.#5!-!%465!-!)$1-´/·HQQHPL« VRXUGH
FUDLJQDQWG·rWUHREOLJpGHFRPEDWWUHGHQXLWDORXUGLSDUOHSRLGVGHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%QT,N\*/,B%N/BD\/7*/e\8%8B%N<*/B% :<Q

´ORQJWHPSVµ FILQWHUGLࡃ´GHMRXUY :O OHVGHX[DGYHUEHVDQWRQ\PHVpWDLHQWHQHIIHWDVVRFLpVGDQVXQV\QWDJPH

FRRUGRQQpILJpHQXQHVpTXHQFHDGYHUELDOHGHYHQXHXQVHXODGYHUEHGLࡃQRFWࡃTXH´GHMRXUHWGHQXLWµPDUTXDQW
ODFRQWLQXLWpG·XQSURFqV
&HVILJHPHQWVHWOH[LFDOLVDWLRQVFRQVHUYHQWSDUIRLVG·DQFLHQQHVGpVLQHQFHVIRVVLOLVpHVGDQVO·DGYHUEHWHPSRUHO
SRVWUҸGL̒´OHOHQGHPDLQµRQWURXYHjODILQDOHGXSUHPLHUpOpPHQWXQҸSURYHQDQWG·XQDQFLHQORFDWLIVLQJIRVVL
OLVpDORUVTXHOHV\QWDJPHQRPLQDOSURGXFWLIHVWSRVWHU‫گ‬GL̒´OHMRXUVXLYDQWµjO·DEODWLIVLQJ::%"J%ҸG·DQFLHQORFDWLI
Q·HVWSOXVXQPRUSKqPHHQDFWLYLWpPDLVVHXOHPHQWODWUDFHG·XQDQFLHQPRUSKqPH:Q2QWURXYHXQҸGHPrPH
RULJLQHORFDWLYHGDQVG·DXWUHVDGYHUEHVDSSDUWHQDQWDXPrPHSDUDGLJPHVpPDQWLTXHWHPSRUHOSDUH[HPSOHGDQV%
PHUҸGL̒´jPLGLµ´DXVXGµ G·RIXWWLUpOHVXEVWDQWLIPHUҸGL̒VHLIpP´OHPLGLOHVXGµ GRQWOHSUHPLHUpOpPHQW
UHSUpVHQWHXQHDQFLHQQHIRUPHGHORFDWLIVLQJGHO·DGMHFWLI>!"#10´TXLVHWURXYHDXPLOLHXµ/DIRUPDWLRQDGRQF
SRXUVHQVDQFLHQ´DXPLOLHXGXMRXUµ OLWWpUDOHPHQW´DXMRXUSULVGDQVVRQPRPHQWPpGLDQµDYHFO·DGMHFWLI>!"#10%
HQHPSORLSDUWLWLIGpOLPLWDQWXQVRXVHQVHPEOHGHGL̒V :<
8QJpQLWLIVLQJIRVVLOLVpGHOD JGpFOLQDLVRQHQčVHVWpJDOHPHQWDWWHVWpGDQVODOH[LHVXEVWDQWLYDOH&I($!-%
IDPLOLčV´FKHIGHIDPLOOHµDORUVTXHODIRUPHXVXHOOHSURGXFWLYHHVWGpVRUPDLV(!/HPDLQWLHQG·XQHGpVLQHQFH
IRVVLOHKRUVVHUYLFHIXWUHQGXSRVVLEOHSDUODOH[LFDOLVDWLRQGHO·HQVHPEOHGHFHWWHVpTXHQFHGHGHX[PRWVGHVRUWH
TXHODVHXOHGpVLQHQFHSHUWLQHQWHHVWFHOOHGHI($!-
/HVGpVLQHQFHVIRVVLOHVGHPDQLqUHJpQpUDOHVHUHQFRQWUHQWGDQVOHVpOpPHQWVTXLpWDLHQWDQFLHQQHPHQWGHV
GpWHUPLQDQWVGDQVSDWHUIDPLOLčVLOV·DJLWG·XQVXEVWDQWLISRVWSRVpGDQVXQHIRUPDWLRQGXYRFDEXODLUHSROLWLTXH
DQFLHQROHGpWHUPLQDQWIDPLOLčVDYDLWXQHYDOHXUVpPDQWLTXHPHQWUHVWULFWLYHG·pSLWKqWHGpWHUPLQDWLYH/DSRVW
SRVLWLRQGHIDPLOLčVH[SOLTXHTXHOHWHUPHDLWpWpGpWDFKpGDQVODJUDSKLHGHI($!-HWTXHO·HQVHPEOHSDWHUIDPLOLčV
DLWDLQVLHQDSSDUHQFHO·DOOXUHG·XQV\QWJDPHQRPLQDO0DLVOHGpWHUPLQDQWSRUWDQWXQHGpVLQHQFHIRVVLOLVpHSHXW
pJDOHPHQWrWUHDQWpSRVpFRPPHGDQV$-#1>M1#-2!"Ҹ´XQWULXPYLUµ% PHPEUHG·XQHFRPPLVVLRQGHWURLVSHUVRQQHV 
&HVXEVWDQWLIHVWXQHIRUPDWLRQVLQJXODWLYHIDEULTXpHjSDUWLUGXV\QWDJPH$-#1>%1#-1>´GHWURLVKRPPHVGHV
WULXPYLUVµDXJpQLWLISOXU:R/DVWUXFWXUHVLQJXODWLYHDFRQVLVWpjHQWLUHUXQVXEVWDQWLIHQUHWUDQFKDQWjODILQDOHOD
GpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLISOXUOHQRXYHDXOH[qPHHVW$-#1>1#-/DGpVLQHQFHIRVVLOLVpHSRUWpHSDUO·pOpPHQWGpWHUPLQDQW
SDVVHGpVRUPDLVLQDSHUoXHSDUFHTXHO·DQWpSRVLWLRQGH$-#1>DHQWUDvQpXQHUpLQWHUSUpWDWLRQHQXQFRPSRVp
GpWHUPLQDWLIjRUGUHUpJUHVVLI/HPrPHSKpQRPqQHHVWDWWHVWpGDQVXQOH[qPHUHOHYDQWGXPrPHSDUDGLJPHGHV
GpVLJQDWLRQVSROLWLTXHVSRXUOHVPHPEUHVG·XQFROOqJHGXXPXLUҸPDVF´XQGXXPYLUµVLQJXODWLILVVXGHO·DGDS
WDWLRQGXV\QWDJPHDXJpQLWLISOXU "11>%1#-1>´GHGHX[KRPPHVGHGHX[GXXPYLUVµ
1RXVFRQQDLVVRQVOHVGLIIpUHQWHVpWDSHVGHFHVSURFHVVXVG·DJJOXWLQDWLRQGHSOXVLHXUVPRWVHQXQVHXOOH[qPH
GDQVODPHVXUHROHVWH[WHVQRXVIRXUQLVVHQWGHWHOVSKpQRPqQHVHQFRXUVGHUpDOLVDWLRQ&$8%DJUҸFXOWࡃUD´O·DJULFXO
KL7JY&DELHQpWpGqVOHODWLQFODVVLTXHXQVHXOOH[qPHRQWURXYHQpDQPRLQVHQFRUHjFHWWHpSRTXHGHVYDULDQWHV
WHOOHVTXHDJU‫گ‬UXPFXOWࡃUD2%DJUҸFXOWL‫گ‬HWFTXLPRQWUHQWTXHO·HPSORLG·XQV\QWDJPHOLEUHHVWHQFRUHSRVVLEOH(Q
RXWUH9DUURQ DXGpEXWGHVK!0%-10$#4(! UHODWHXQHGLVFXVVLRQHQWUHGHVVSpFLDOLVWHVGHVH[SORLWDWLRQVDJULFROHV
VXUFHTXHGpQRWHOHWHUPHDJUҸFXOWࡃUDLOVVHGHPDQGHQWV·LOUHQYRLHVHXOHPHQWjODFXOWXUHGHVFKDPSV³FHTXL
HVWVRQVHQVOLWWpUDOHWFRPSRVLWLRQQHOHQFRUHSDUIDLWHPHQWPRWLYpHWUHVVHQWLSDUOHVVXMHWVSDUODQWV³RXELHQ
V·LOLQFOXWO·pOHYDJHHWUHQYRLHjO·HQVHPEOHIRUPpSDUODFXOWXUHDJULFROHHWO·pOHYDJHSXLVTXHOHVDJULFXOWHXUV
SUDWLTXHQWFRQMRLQWHPHQW SRXUGHVUDLVRQVSUDWLTXHVHWpFRQRPLTXHV FHVGHX[DFWLYLWpV

:O
&pVDUS!..1>%4#?#.!6>)#%-($#6)!%!00!%#)$!-"#1%I!--1>I!)"1>%
´ LOVGLVDLHQW TX·LOIDOODLWSDUWRXVOHVPR\HQVIRUFHUOHSDVVDJHGH
MRXUµ%
::
,OQ·\DSDVGHGLIIpUHQFHVpPDQWLTXHGpQRWDWLYHHQWUHO·DGYHUEH
SRVWUҸGL̒HWOHV\QWDJPHILJpSRVWHU‫گ‬GL̒SXLVTXHOHVGHX[WRXUQXUHV
GpQRWHQW´OHOHQGHPDLQµ &pVDUS!..1>%4#?#.!I60$!-6%"#!%@!M
$-!#10%d%6441.$!%("%!]I.6-()"(%.64(%I-6:#4#04#$1-´/HOHQGHPDLQ3pWUHLXV
SDUWHQVHFUHWSRXUUHFRQQDvWUHOHVOLHX[µ!$%I-#>(%.14!%I60M
$-#"#!%46)0$#$11)$%I-6:#4#04#´HWLOVGpFLGHQWGHSDUWLUDX[SUHPLqUHV
OXHXUVGXMRXU DXSHWLWMRXU OHOHQGHPDLQµ PDLVLOSHXW\DYRLU
GHVGLIIpUHQFHVSUDJPDWLTXHVDXQLYHDXGHODVWUXFWXUHLQIRUPDWLYH
:Q
,ODGRQFVXELXQHJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQTXLSUHQGLFLODIRUPHG·XQH
EDLVVHGDQVODKLpUDUFKLHGHVXQLWpVOLQJXLVWLTXHV FIDQJODLV"69)M
5-("#)5 
:<
0DOJUpODVLPLOLWXGHGHIRUPHOHҸGHO·DGYHUEHSUҸGL̒´ODYHLOOHµ
&pVDUS!..1>%4#?#.!I-#"#!%)64$1´ODYHLOOHGXUDQWODQXLWµ UH
SUpVHQWHSOXW{WODEDVHDQFLHQQH jI-#0M D\DQWVHUYLjIRUPHUO·DGMHF
WLIQXPpUDORUGLQDOSUҸPXV´SUHPLHUµOHFRPSDUDWLII-#6-HWSHXWrWUH
O·DGMHFWLIDUFKDwTXHI-#0410´DQFLHQµ SULVFҸ/čWҸQҸ´OHVDQFLHQV/DWLQVµ 
:R
%-6%GF7MJ%1#-M1>LFLHVWO·DQFLHQJpQLWLISOXUKpULWpHQM1> LH
U‫گ‬P%FL%U‫ڨ‬P TXLpWDLWHQXVDJHDYDQWTXHFHWWHGpVLQHQFHQHVRLW
UHPSODFpHSDU‫گ‬UXPGDQVODJGpFOLQDLVRQWKpPDWLTXH
 oi.uchicago.edu

:<<% A/3OZN8%FK\Y*

J2M2&S<A&B5FE<A&HCA;<>><A&DPCDX<H89BA&:;C>9B9HC89BA&8FC6AB5FE7<A&<6&CDL<FQ<A&?FCD;CQ><A&
/HVDGYHUEHVLVVXVGXILJHPHQWFDVXHOG·DGMHFWLIVTXDOLILFDWLIVRIIUHQWGHVIRUPDWLRQVSURGXFWLYHVHQODWLQ
FRPPHGDQVOHVDXWUHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVDQFLHQQHV$LQVLSDUH[HPSOHOHVXIIL[HDGYHUELDOGpDGMHFWLYDO
HQ̒DQFLHQLQVWUXPHQWDOVLQJGHODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXHIXWSURGXFWLIGDQVODSpULRGHSUpOLWWpUDLUHHWOHUHVWD
DXFRXUVGHODODWLQLWp&!)!´ELHQµ E̋Q̒%X%E̋Q̋SDUODORLGHO·DEUqJHPHQWGHVPRWVLDPELTXHV HVWDLQVLLVVXGX
ILJHPHQWG·XQDQFLHQLQVWUXPHQWDOVLQJGHO·DGMHFWLI&6)102%M(2%M1>%´ERQµGHPrPHSRXURFFXOW̒´VHFUqWHPHQWµ
SDUUDSSRUWj6441.$10´FDFKpµ FIVXSUD&pVDUS!..1>%4#?#.! 

J2R2&S<A&D7A96<6H<A&B9?7<A&A<EQ>CQ><A&C;I&D7A96<6H<A&<6H5F<&5=7FC89566<>><A&DC6A&>C&
B><I956&65E96C><
'DQVGHVIRUPDWLRQVUHODWLYHPHQWUpFHQWHVGDQVO·KLVWRLUHGXODWLQOHV&GpVLQHQFHVILJpHVVRQWHQFRUHKRPR
SKRQHVGHVGpVLQHQFHVRSpUDWLRQQHOOHVGDQVODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOH$LQVLXQDGYHUEHHQ‫ گ‬PRUSKqPHUHSUpVHQWDQW
XQHDQFLHQQHGpVLQHQFHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOVLQJWKpPDWLTXH HVWKRPRSKRQHGHODIRUPHG·DEODWLIVLQJQRPLQDOG·R
LOHVWLVVXO·DGYHUEHFRQWLQX‫گ‬HVWKRPRSKRQHGHO·DEODWLIVLQJPDVFHWQHXWGHO·DGMHFWLI%46)$#)1102%M(2%M1>L/·DGYHUEH
VLOHQWL‫´گ‬HQVLOHQFHµ &pVDUS!..1>%4#?#.! UHSUpVHQWHXQDQFLHQLQVWUXPHQWDOVLQJGXVXEVWDQWLIVLOHQWLXPҸ%
QHXW´VLOHQFHµHWLODHQFRUHOHPrPHVLJQLILDQWTXHO·DEODWLIGHFHVXEVWDQWLI
&HVSKpQRPqQHVQRXVVRQWELHQFRQQXVGXIDLWTX·LOVVRQWSDUIRLVHQGHYHQLUHWREVHUYDEOHVGDQVOHVWH[WHV
ODWLQV/HVVXEVWDQWLIV4(10((!IpP´SURFqVFDXVHUDLVRQµHWJUčWLD(!IpP´UHFRQQDLVVDQFHµRQWVHUYLGHSRLQW
GHGpSDUWjODIRUPDWLRQGHV´SUpSRVLWLRQVµ³SDUIRLVDSSHOpHVX1(0#MI-UI60#$#6)0³GHVHQVFDXVDO ´jFDXVHGHµ 
HWILQDO ´HQYXHGHµ RQSHXWFLWHUSRXUFDXVč%G8H6>%FHSDVVDJHGH&pVDU
&pVDUS!..1>%4#?#.!%##0%X1#%(X1()"#%4(10(%.6)5#10%(%4(0$-#0%I-64!00!-()$%V%
´FHX[TXLV·pWDLHQWDYDQFpVDVVH]ORLQGXFDPS=FL7DOOHUFKHUFKHUGHO·HDX«µ

&DXVč%JK%JUčWLčFRQVHUYHQWHQFRUHGHVSURSULpWpVGHOHXURULJLQHQRPLQDOHOHXUSRVWSRVLWLRQSDUUDSSRUWjOHXU
´UpJLPHµHWOHIDLWTXHOHXU´UpJLPHµSUHQQHOHJpQLWLIFRQVWUXFWLRQFDUDFWpULVWLTXHSRXUXQpOpPHQWHQSRVLWLRQ
GHGpWHUPLQDWLRQDGQRPLQDOHSDUUDSSRUWjXQVXEVWDQWLI0DLVjF{WpGH4(10(%JK%5-($#(HPSOR\pVFRPPHGHV
OH[qPHVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOVOHVVXEVWDQWLIVG·RLOVVRQWVRUWLVHWGRQWLOVVHVRQWGpWDFKpVFRQWLQXHQWjH[LVWHUHW
PDLQWLHQQHQWOHXUSRO\VpPLH2QUHQFRQWUHSDUIRLVGHVFRQWH[WHVDPELJXVROHVIRUPHVFDXVč%JK%JUčWLčSHXYHQW
rWUHFRQVLGpUpHVVRLWFRPPHGHVVXEVWDQWLIVVRLWFRPPHGHVSUpSRVLWLRQV2QSHXWDGPHWWUHDORUVO·H[LVWHQFH
G·XQVWDWXWLQWHUPpGLDLUH
'·DXWUHV´SUpSRVLWLRQVµG·RULJLQHVXEVWDQWLYDOHVSRVWSRVpHVjOHXUUpJLPHHWSUpFpGpHVG·XQJpQLWLIGHQDWXUH
DGQRPLQDOHFRH[LVWHQWDYHFOHVXEVWDQWLIG·RHOOHVVRQWLVVXHVHWVRQWKRPRSKRQHVGHO·DEODWLIGHFHVXEVWDQWLI
3DUH[HPSOHORF‫´&گ‬HQOLHXGHµDEODWLIVLQJGXVXEVWDQWLIK\SHURQ\PH.64102ҸPDVF´OLHXHQGURLWµHVWSUpFpGp
GXJpQLWLI(-51>!)$#GDQVOHSDVVDJHVXLYDQWDYHFXQHGLVMRQFWLRQHQWUHOHVWHUPHVFHTXLUHSUpVHQWHXQHWUDFH
VXSSOpPHQWDLUHG·XQHRULJLQHQRPLQDOH
&pVDUS!..1>%4#?#.!<.##2%X16"%I-#"#!%)64$1%46)4.(>($1>%!00!$%#)%3(!0(-#0%4(0$-#02%(-51>!)$#%01>!&()$%.646%
)6)%I600!%4.(>%!]#-#L%
´4XDQWDX[DXWUHVOHIDLWTXHODYHLOOHGXUDQWODQXLWO·DOHUWHDYDLWpWpGRQQpHGDQVOHFDPSGH&pVDULOV
>TLK8>8968JHK%HQJXLVHG·DUJXPHQWSRXUDIILUPHUTX·RQQHSRXYDLWSDVVRUWLUHQFDFKHWWHµ

/·DEODWLIVLQJP‫گ‬UHGHP‫گ‬VP‫گ‬ULVPDVF´ODFRXWXPHO·KDELWXGHµDFFRPSDJQpG·XQDGMHFWLIDFFRUGp GDQVO·H[HPSOH
VXLYDQWPLOLWčUҸGHPLOLWčULV´PLOLWDLUHµ RXGXJpQLWLIG·XQVXEVWDQWLIVHOH[LFDOLVHHQXQHTXDVLSUpSRVLWLRQVLJQL
ILDQW´jODPDQLqUHGHµ
&pVDUS!..1>%4#?#.!4XRFRJQLWRVLJQXPGDULLXEHWHW´XDVDµ>#.#$(-#%>6-!%46)4.(>(-#
´$FHVQRXYHOOHV&pVDUGRQQHO·RUGUHGHVRQQHUO·DOHUWHHWGHFULHU´$X[EDJDJHVµVHORQO·KDELWXGHGDQV
O·DUPpHµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%QT,N\*/,B%N/BD\/7*/e\8%8B%N<*/B% :<R

J2T2&-6<&B5FE<&HCA;<>><&D<&=CF89H9=<&=CAA7&8FC6AB5FE7<&<6&7>7E<68&D<&F<>C8956&A=C89C><&
8QHIRUPHFDVXHOOHGHSDUWLFLSHSDVVpHQ$102%M(2%M1> $6 SHXWpJDOHPHQWrWUHWUDQVIRUPpHHQXQpOpPHQW
GHUHODWLRQDSSOLTXpjODGLPHQVLRQVSDWLDOH&·HVWOHSKpQRPqQHSDUOHTXHORQUHQFRQWUHOHILJHPHQWODOH[LFDOL
VDWLRQHWODJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQGXSDUWLFLSHSDVVpG·XQYHUEHGHPRXYHPHQWGDQV1!-0102%M(2M%1>´WRXUQpYHUV«µ
GH1!-$6-´VHWRXUQHUµGHYDOHXUPpGLRSDVVLYHRXXHUW‫´گ‬WRXUQHUµ TXLHVWjO·RULJLQHGHSOXVLHXUVOH[qPHVLQYD
ULDEOHV SUpSRVLWLRQVDGYHUEHV jYDOHXUGLUHFWLRQQHOOHVLJQLILDQW´HQGLUHFWLRQGHµSRXUGpQRWHUGHVPRXYHPHQWV
SURJUHVVDQWYHUVXQHFLEOH

J2T2!2&#$%&'(%)*+$%&'(%(!96LCF9CQ><!
/HVGHX[IRUPHVLQYDULDEOHV("1!-01> DQFLHQDFFXVDWLIVLQJPDVF HW("1!-010 DQFLHQQRPLQDWLIPDVF VRQW
GHVYDULDQWHVIRUPHOOHVRXDOORPRUSKHVG·XQVHXOHWPrPHOH[qPHIRQFWLRQQDQWFRPPHXQUHODWHXUVSDWLDOVRLW
FRPPHSUpSRVLWLRQVRLWFRPPHDGYHUEH
&HOH[qPHHVWLVVXGXILJHPHQWGXSDUWLFLSHSDUIDLWSDVVLIRXGpSRQHQWGXYHUEHSUpYHUEpHQ("MN%("1!-$!-!%
´WRXUQHUYHUVµRXSOXW{WGHVDIRUPHPpGLRSDVVLYHDGXHUWҸ´VHWRXUQHUYHUVµRXHQFRUHSURQRPLQDOHUpIOpFKLHV̒
("1!-$!-!´VHWRXUQHUYHUVµ/H&SDUWLFLSH("1!-0102%M(2%M1>VLJQLILHGRQF´SODFpHQIDFHµ2QSHXWVXLYUHSDVjSDV
OHVpWDSHVGHVWUDQVIRUPDWLRQVHQFRXUXHV

J2T2!2!2&,<A&78C=<A&A;HH<AA9L<A&D<&>C&8FC6AB5FEC8956&DP+$%&'(%)!*!+$%&'(%(
D  3UHPLqUHpWDSHGXSDUWLFLSHjO·DGMHFWLIGHYDOHXUVSDWLDOHDFFRUGp

3RXUFRPSUHQGUHODWUDQVIRUPDWLRQGXSDUWLFLSHSDUIDLWHQXQpOpPHQWGHUHODWLRQLQYDULDEOHLOIDXWSDUWLU
G·XQHpWDSHLQLWLDOHROHSDUWLFLSHHQ$10HVWGHYHQXXQDGMHFWLI IDLWELHQDWWHVWpDLOOHXUVHQODWLQ DXVHQVGH
´HQVHQVLQYHUVHHQVHQVFRQWUDLUHµSRXUXQIOHXYH/XFUqFH#)%("1!-01>%:.1>!)%´FRQWUHOHFRXUDQWµ3RXU
XQHDXWUHHQWLWpTX·XQIOHXYHO·DGMHFWLI("1!-010%VLJQLILH´TXLIDLWIDFHjTXLHVWHQIDFHGHµFRPPHO·LOOXVWUHQW
OHVH[HPSOHVVXLYDQWV
3URSHUFH8.U5#!0%²(0I!-(%3!)$(1-60%!("!>%"!>!)$#(%#100#$%l%:-()5!-!%#)%("1!-01>%I641.(%@#-#$+61>L%´OD
PrPHGpPHQFHPDXYDLVHSRXVVDOHV&HQWDXUHVjEULVHUOHXUVFRXSHVVXU3LURWKRXVTXLpWDLWHQIDFHG·HX[
GHYDQWHX[ µ

5>8HJ2%O#0$6#-!%)($1-!..!N#&()10%>6)0%AH%0$("##0%t#>'-(>%10X1!%I6--#5#$1-d%O1#4%I(-%#)$!-1!)#!)$!%1(..!%>6)0%
("1!-010%<)$#.#&()10%6&$!)"#$1-L

´/DPRQWDJQHGX/LEDQV·pWHQGVXUVWDGHVMXVTX·j=LP\UD«'HPrPHWDLOOHTXHFHWWHGHUQLqUHDYHF
XQHYDOOpHLQWHUSRVpHHQIDFHV·pWHQGODPRQWDJQHGHO·$QWLOLEDQµ

E  'HX[LqPHpWDSHXQHSUpSRVLWLRQLQYDULDEOH

$O·pWDSHVXLYDQWHRQWURXYHXQOH[qPHLQYDULDEOHGXSRLQWGHYXHIOH[LRQQHOHWSUpVHQWDQWGHVYDULDQWHV
IRUPHOOHVjODIRLVPRUSKRORJLTXH("1!-01>%l%("1!-010 >%l%M0 HWSKRQpWLTXH%("16-01>%l%("16-010 6! 2Q
UHWURXYHUDFHVYDULDQWHVIRUPHOOHVGDQVOHVDXWUHVVWDGHVGHO·pYROXWLRQHWWRXWDXORQJGHODODWLQLWp
&HVHFRQGVWDGHHVWFHOXLGHODSUpSRVLWLRQ("1!-010FRQVWUXLWHDYHFXQDFFXVDWLIDXVHQVGH´FRQWUH TXHOTXH
FKRVH µ
"6KFH2%H!%(5-#41.$1-(0#%X1#0%("1!-010%!(%:!4!-#$2%d´VLTXHOTX·XQYLHQWjIDLUHTXHOTXHFKRVHFRQWUHFHOD«µ
/XFUqFHd("1!-010%)($1-(!%:6!"!-(%)#$#[%´OXWWHUFRQWUHOHVORLVGHODQDWXUH"µ

&HWWHpWDSHHVWFDUDFWpULVpHSDUODSHUWHGHVSRVVLELOLWpVIOH[LRQQHOOHVGHO·DQFLHQSDUWLFLSHDGMHFWLYLVpPDLVLOUHVWH
QpDQPRLQVXQVXEVWDQWLIjF{WpGHODIRUPHpYROXWLYH("1!-010O·DFFXVDWLIDQFLHQFRPSOpPHQWGXSDUWLFLSH ("1!-M
010DFF´WRXUQpFRQWUH«µ HVWLFLUpDQDO\VpHQXQFRPSOpPHQWjO·DFFXVDWLIGHODSUpSRVLWLRQ("1!-010´FRQWUHµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% A/3OZN8%FK\Y*

F  7URLVLqPHpWDSHXQDGYHUEH

$O·pWDSHVXLYDQWH("1!-010Q·HVWSOXVFRQVWUXLWDYHFOHVXEVWDQWLIjO·DFFXVDWLIGpQRWDQWOHUHSqUHSDUUDSSRUW
DXTXHORQVLWXHXQHHQWLWpF·HVWXQDGYHUEHVLJQLILDQW´HQIDFHµ
5>6LKJ2%<>I+#$-'6)%Q??N%4.(-!%("16-01>%:(&1.(&6-´MHYDLVSDUOHUjKDXWHYRL[HQIDFHµ O·HQWLWpVHUYDQWGH
UHSqUHHVWLGHQWLILpHSDUDQDSKRUH 

&HWDGYHUEH("1!-010HVWOHFRQVWLWXDQWGHGHX[OH[LHVYHUEDOHVFRQWHQDQWOHVYHUEHVGHPRXYHPHQWҸUH´DOOHUµ
JK%XHQҸUH´DOOHUYHQLUµDYHFOHGDWLIGHODSHUVRQQHYHUVODTXHOOHRQVHGLULJHDGXHUVXPҸUH DOLFXҸ %JK%DGXHUVXPXHQҸUH
DOLFXҸ ´DOOHUYHQLUjODUHQFRQWUHGHTXHOTX·XQµ
5>6LKJ2%3(0#)(%@:Q;:<N%<$$($2%4!006%>(5)1:#4!%I($-#4!X1!%(>#4#-#!-%($X1!%#$(%!-6%>!6%#-!%("16-01>[%
´$XIDLW4X·HVWFHTXHM·DWWHQGVSRXUUHYrWLUPRQPDJQLILTXHFRVWXPHjODSDWULFLHQQHHWSRXUDOOHUjOD
UHQFRQWUHGHPRQPDvWUH"µ

5>6LKJ2%AU)!4+>!0%<Q@N%*1%:(4#$6%()$!%06.!>%644(01>%1$%1!)#(0%("16-01>%>#+#L%
´4XDQWjWRLDUUDQJHWRLSRXUYHQLUjPDUHQFRQWUHDYDQWOHFRXFKHUGXVROHLOµ

G  8QV\QWDJPHSUpSRVLWLRQQHOILJp

/HVWDWXWDGYHUELDOG·("1!-010HVWFRQILUPpSDUO·H[LVWHQFHGHVVpTXHQFHVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHV#)%("1!-01>GHUULqUH
XQYHUEHGpQRWDQWXQPRXYHPHQWYHUV
3URSHUFH8.U5#!08$%"16%#)%("1!-01>%>#00#%I!-%>6!)#(%41--10l%B!4%I600!)$%$(4$6%0$-#)5!-!%(&%(]!%.($10´HW
TXHGHX[FKDUVODQFpVVXUOHVUHPSDUWVHQVHQVLQYHUVHSRXYDLHQWQHSDVDEvPHUOHXUVF{WpVOHXUVHVVLHX[
QHVHWRXFKDQWSDVµ

JKH[DGXHUV‫´گ‬HQIDFHjO·RSSRVpµ 7LWH/LYHO#0$6#-!%-6>(#)! 

J2T2!2J2&'8C=<A&968<FE7D9C9F<A&<8&HCA&CEQ9?;A@&B5FE<&CHH5FD7<&5;&96LCF9CQ><Y
'HPDQLqUHDWWHQGXHRQUHQFRQWUHGHVpWDSHVLQWHUPpGLDLUHVHWGHVFDVDPELJXVRO·RQSHXWOpJLWLPHPHQW
VHGHPDQGHUVLODIRUPHHVWDFFRUGpHRXLQYDULDEOH'DQVOHSDVVDJHVXLYDQW("1!-01>SRXUUDLWHQFRUHrWUHOHSDU
WLFLSHGXYHUEHUpIOpFKLV̒DGXHUWHUHDXVHQVGH´WRXUQpYHUVµFRQVWUXLWDYHFXQREMHWjO·DFFXVDWLI0DLVLOSRXUUDLW
pJDOHPHQWV·DJLUGpMjGHODSUpSRVLWLRQ("1!-01>FRQVWUXLWHDYHFO·DFFXVDWLI
)HH8L92%*-(5U"#!0%9 ²:7!"%1#-1>%1!-(%1#-$1$!%1#1!-!%()#>($1>%(""!4!$%l%F6-$#$!-X1!%#))6]#1>%0$(-!%
("1!-01>%("1!-0(-#60´%XWLWEHKRYHVDPDQWROLYHDOLIH,QVSLUHGZLWKYLUWXHWUXHWRVWDQGVWHDGIDVWZLWK
JXLOWOHVVEUDYHU\LQWKHIDFHRI%GFJ9µ WUDGXFWLRQ(+:DUPLQJWRQFROOHFWLRQ/RHES 

'DQVG·DXWUHVSDVVDJHVRQSRXUUDLWKpVLWHUHQWUHXQSDUWLFLSHHWXQDGYHUEHVSDWLDO
187I8>J2%8)U#"!!$%T!)1.6%<HT8K7TA%0!%$1-&#"10%#):!-$%´FRPPHXQRXUDJDQLOIRQGVXU9pQXOXVµ WUD
GXFWLRQ-3HUUHW3DULV&ROOHFWLRQGHVXQLYHUVLWpVGH)UDQFH 

&DWXOOHe1#%0!"!)0%<HT8K7T7%#"!)$#"!>%$!l%7I!4$($%!$%(1"#$%
´FHOXLTXLDVVLV(1)$&('(72,SHXWVRXYHQWWHFRQWHPSOHUHWW·HQWHQGUHµ

7LWH/LYHO#0$6#-!%-6>(#)!%@60$X1(>%)!>6%<HT8K7T7%/S<*2%4.(00!%"#1#0(2%I(-0%#)%0(.6%("%60$#1>%I6-$10%#)%
()46-#0%0$!$#$2%I(-0%#)%$!--(>%>#.#$!0%!]I601#$L%´&RPPHSHUVRQQHQHYHQDLWjODUHQFRQWUHRQGLYLVDODIORWWH
XQHSDUWLHPRXLOODHQUDGHjODVRUWLHGXSRUWO·DXWUHGpEDUTXDGHVVROGDWVµ

5>6LKJ2%A60$!..(-#(<$%$1%>!41>2%I!00#>!2%/*,%<HT8K7T7%
´(QWRXWFDVYDXULHQYLHQVDYHFPRLDXGHYDQW GXPDvWUH µ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%QT,N\*/,B%N/BD\/7*/e\8%8B%N<*/B% :<@

J2T2J2&,&'(%(!96LCF9CQ><!
T!-0102%M(2%M1>HVWjO·RULJLQHOHSDUWLFLSHSDUIDLWGXYHUEH1!-$!-!´WRXUQHUYHUVµVRXVVDIRUPHPpGLRSDVVLYH
XHUWҸRXUpIOpFKLHV̒XHUWHUH´VHWRXUQHUYHUVµ/HVHQVDQFLHQGH1!-010HVWGRQF´WRXUQpYHUVµVHPEODEOHjFHOXL
G·("M1!-010LVVXGXPrPHYHUEHSUpYHUEpHQ("%"FMMJ%("1!-010FHWDQFLHQSDUWLFLSHDpYROXpYHUVGHVHPSORLV
LQYDULDEOHVDYHFGHVYDULDQWHVIRUPHOOHVGHQDWXUHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXH 0>VHORQTXHO·RQSDUWGXILJHPHQW
G·XQQRPLQDWLIRXG·XQDFFXVDWLIPDVFVLQJ HWSKRQpWLTXH 1!16 1!-010%l%16-010%JK%1!-01>%l%16-01>L%

J2T2J2!2&,&'(%(!=CF89H9=<&CHH5FD7
/HVHPSORLVFRPPHSDUWLFLSHDFFRUGpVRQWFODLUVORUVTXHOHWHUPHHVWGpWHUPLQpSDUXQV\QWDJPHSUpSRVL
K8FHHJ>N%#)%DFF1!-0102%M(2%M1>´WRXUQpYHUV FRQWUH µ
7LWH/LYHO#0$6#-!%-6>(#)!/)%!60%1!-0(%I!"#$1>%(4#!0%+(1"%"1&#1>%:!4#$%X1#)%V
´/DOLJQHGHVIDQWDVVLQVTXLpWDLWWRXUQpHFRQWUHHX[PLWKRUVGHGRXWHOHIDLWTXH«µ

J2T2J2J2&,&'(%(!656&CHH5FD7
0689%>6%GF7MJ%1!-010ILJpHQRQDFFRUGpHDXVHQVGH&´WRXUQpGHWHOOHPDQLqUHµDFFRPSDJQHHWSUpFLVHVpPDQ
WLTXHPHQWXQV\QWDJPHSUpSRVLWLRQQHOGHYDOHXUGLUHFWLYHHWSOXVSUpFLVpPHQWGLUHFWLRQQHOOH´GDQVODGLUHFWLRQ
GHµ DYHF("DFFXVDWLI HQVHVLWXDQWGHUULqUHOXL
/HWRXUHVWOH[LFDOHPHQWFRQGLWLRQQpDSSDUDLVVDQWHVVHQWLHOOHPHQWDYHFGHVWRSRQ\PHVGpVLJQDQWGHVHQWL
WpVJpRJUDSKLTXHVHWGHVSRLQWVFDUGLQDX[,OV·DJLWGDQVWRXVFHVFDVG·XQPRXYHPHQWHQGLUHFWLRQG·XQHHQWLWp
SURFKHRXORLQWDLQHTXHO·RQQ·DWWHLQGUDSDVPDLVTXLVHUWVHXOHPHQWGHUHSqUHjXQHWUDMHFWRLUHSRXUGpQRWHU
ODGLUHFWLRQGXPRXYHPHQW&HWWHYDOHXUGH´GLUHFWLRQYHUVµDXUDLWSXrWUHUHQGXHSDUODSUpSRVLWLRQ("VHXOHTXL
PDUTXHOHPRXYHPHQWYHUVDYHFDUUrWjSUR[LPLWpGXOLHXFLEOHHWVDQVIUDQFKLVVHPHQWGHVOLPLWHVGXOLHXFLEOH
/·DGYHUEH1!-010SRVWSRVpYLHQWGRQFLFLVHXOHPHQWUHQIRUFHUODSUpSRVLWLRQ("GDQVVDYDOHXUGLUHFWLRQQHOOHQRQ
WHUPLQDWLYH
$FHVWDGH1!-010HVWGpMjXQpOpPHQWGHUHODWLRQLQYDULDEOHjYDOHXUVSDWLDOHPDLVLOQ·HVWSDVHQFRUHXQH
SUpRXSRVWSRVLWLRQLQWURGXLVDQWXQVXEVWDQWLIDXTXHOLOLPSRVHOHFDVDFFXVDWLIGDQVVDYDOHXUGLUHFWLYH
1677FH2%K!0%-10$#4(!"1(!%4(1!(!%d%46)0$#$1!)"(!2%X1(!%0I!4$!)$%("%6-#!)$!>%1!-010
´LOIDXWFRQVWUXLUHGHX[SRXODLOOHUVTXLVRLHQWRULHQWpVYHUVO·HVWµ

&pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>("%64!()1>%1!-010%d%I-6:#4#04#%´SDUWLUGDQVODGLUHFWLRQGHO·RFpDQµ

&pVDUS!..1>%<:-#41>%#1&!$%6>)!0%.!5#6)!0%!]$-(%4(0$-(%!"14#%($X1!%0!%46)0!X1#%("%6II#"1>%K10I#)(>%1!-010%
´LORUGRQQHTX·RQIDVVHVRUWLUWRXWHVOHVOpJLRQVGXFDPSHWTX·HOOHVOHVXLYHQWHQGLUHFWLRQGH%ODSODFHIRUWH
GH5XVSLQDµ

2QWURXYHpJDOHPHQW1!-01>FRPPHDGYHUEHSRXUUHQIRUFHUODYDOHXUGLUHFWLYHG·XQDGYHUEHGLUHFWLIHQV-01>2%
DORUVTXHFHWWHFDWpJRULHDGYHUELDOHpWDLWGpMjIRUPpHSDUO·DJJOXWLQDWLRQG·XQHIRUPH1!-01>%W%1!-010 16-01>%
W%16-010 GHUULqUHXQDGYHUEHGLUHFWLI3XLVTXHODSUpVHQFHGH1!-01>Q·pWDLWDORUVSDVQpFHVVDLUHSRXUOHVHQVHW
ODJUDPPDWLFDOLWpGHODSKUDVHLOIDXWVXSSRVHUTXHODIRUPDWLRQGHO·DGYHUEHHQ«-01>WHQGDLWjVHGpPRWLYHU
SRXUOHVXMHWSDUODQW2QDLFLG·XQSRLQWGHYXHGLDFKURQLTXHXQHUpIHFWLRQjO·LGHQWLTXHRXXQUHQRXYHOOHPHQW
F\FOLTXHGDQVXQHVpTXHQFHFRQVWLWXpHGH´DGYHUEHHQ«‫ گ‬- 010%Å%1!-010L2QUHPDUTXHODSRVWSRVLWLRQGH1!-01>N
7pUHQFH<"!.I+!0%R@RN%4.#160%H8,K7TA%T8K7TA%!0$L´LO\DXQHSHQWHYHUVOHEDVµ

"6KFH2%H!%(5-#41.$1-(7T7TA%T8K7TA%0!>I!-%"14#$6L%´FRQGXLVH] OD WRXMRXUVYHUVOHKDXWµ jSURSRVGH

ODYLJQH 

1677FH2%H!%.#)51(%N($#)(g%3.#110%@-6]#>10%(%F.6-(%7T7T7%T8K7T7%3(I#$6.#1>%1!$10L


$YHFXQDXWUHSUpYHUEH (&MPDUTXDQWO·pORLJQHPHQWHWO·RULJLQH 
RQUHQFRQWUHDXVVLčXHUVXV2%M(2%M1>´GpWRXUQpGHµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% A/3OZN8%FK\Y*

´/H3.#110%@-6]#>10%(%F.6-( /D0RQWpH-RX[WH)ORUH PRQWHYHUVOH3(I#$6.#1>%T!$10 OH9LHX[FDSLWROH µ WUDG

-&ROODUW3DULV/HV%HOOHV/HWWUHVS 

J2T2J2M2&,&'(%(&=5A8=5A7&O&;6&CHH;AC89B&D9F<H89B
8QSDVVXSSOpPHQWDLUHYHUVOHVWDWXWSUpSRVLWLRQQHOHVWIUDQFKLSDUO·pOpPHQWGHUHODWLRQLQYDULDEOH1!-010%
ORUVTX·LOHVWSRVWSRVpjXQDFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLIHQO·DEVHQFHGHODSUpSRVLWLRQ("&HWHPSORLFRPPHOHSUpFpGHQWHVW
OH[LFDOHPHQWFRQGLWLRQQpSXLVTX·RQOHWURXYHSRXUGHVQRPVGHIOHXYHVSD\VYLOOHVHWGHVSRLQWVFDUGLQDX[HWTXH
1!-010SHXW\rWUHWUDGXLWSDU´GDQVODGLUHFWLRQGHµ´GXF{WpGHµVDQVTXHOHPRXYHPHQWHQTXHVWLRQSDUYLHQQH
MXVTX·DXOLHXGpVLJQp/DYDOHXUGH1!-010FRPPHFHOOHGH("2HVWSXUHPHQWGLUHFWLRQQHOOHHWQRQWHUPLQDWLYH
5>8HJ2%O#0$6#-!%)($1-!..!D.(141>X1!%T8K7T7%(>)!>%N(510(2%A(4-#0d%´HWGDQVODGLUHFWLRQGHODULYLqUH
*ODXFXV LO\D /DJXVD0DFULV«µ´DQG72:$5'6WKHULYHU*ODXFXV/DJXVVD0DFULV«µ WUDG+¬5DFNKDP
FROOHFWLRQ/RHES 

/HSDVVDJHVXLYDQWGH6DOOXVWHTXLHPSORLHVXFFHVVLYHPHQW("DYHFOHQRPGHODYLOOHGH5RPHHW16-010%
SRVWSRVpSRXUOHQRPGHOD*DXOHPHWHQOXPLqUHODGLIIpUHQFHVpPDQWLFRUpIpUHQWLHOOHHQWUHOHVGHX[WRXUV<"%
1-&!>%´YHUV5RPHµHVWOHWRXUQRQPDUTXpSRXUXQOLHXFLEOHTXLLFLQ·HVWSDVWUqVpORLJQpSXLVTXH&DWLOLQDVH
WURXYHHQFRUHHQ,WDOLH/DGLUHFWLRQGpVLJQpHHVWGRQFUHODWLYHPHQWSUpFLVHD(..#(>%16-010DXFRQWUDLUHHVWXQH
WRXUQXUHPDUTXpHTXLPHWO·DFFHQWVXUXQHGLUHFWLRQJOREDOHHWJpQpUDOHGpVLJQpHSDUXQOLHXFLEOHORLQWDLQ$FH
PRPHQWGXUpFLWOHQDUUDWHXUQHOHSUpVHQWHSDVFRPPHXQHFLEOHGHYDQWrWUHDWWHLQWHPDLVVHXOHPHQWFRPPH
XQHRULHQWDWLRQIORXHGDQVO·HVSDFH
$6>>L9KJ2%3($#.#)(7!"%I60$X1(>%<)$6)#10%41>%!]!-4#$1%("1!)$(&($2%3($#.#)(%I!-%>6)$#0%#$!-%:(4!-!f%>6"6%("%
1-&!>2%>6"6%D(..#(>%16-010%4(0$-(%>61!-!f%+60$#&10%644(0#6)!>%I15)()"#%)6)%"(-!L%
´0DLVGHSXLVTX·$QWRLQHQHFHVVDLWG·DYDQFHUDYHFVRQDUPpH&DWLOLQDIDLVDLWURXWHjWUDYHUVOHVPRQWDJQHV
LOGpSODoDLWVRQFDPSWDQW{WYHUV5RPHWDQW{WGDQVODGLUHFWLRQGHOD*DXOHLOQHGRQQDLWSDVjVHVHQQHPLV
O·RFFDVLRQGHFRPEDWWUHµ

/DGpVLJQDWLRQG·XQHVLPSOHGLUHFWLRQjYDOHXUG·RULHQWDWLRQIORXHQRQWHUPLQDWLYHFRQYLHQWELHQDX[SRLQWV
FDUGLQDX[ ´YHUVOHQRUGYHUVO·HVWYHUVOHVXGYHUVO·RXHVWµ SXLVTXHOHVSRLQWVFDUGLQDX[SDUGpILQLWLRQQH
GpQRWHQWSDVGHVOLHX[FRQFUHWVVLWXpVVXUODVXUIDFHWHUUHVWUHHWTXHO·RQSRXUUDLWDWWHLQGUH'DQVXQHGHVFULSWLRQ
JpRJUDSKLTXHGH3OLQHO·$QFLHQ1!-010%HVWSRVWSRVpj644#"!)$!>OHQRPGXFRXFKDQWHWOHUHSqUHHVWH[SULPp
=67%(&HWO·DEODWLIG·RULJLQH
5>8HJ2%O#0$6#-!%)($1-!..!)6)%.6)5!%!60%(%*-656"'$#0%(&!00!2%-1-010X1!%(&%+#0%644#"!)$!>%1!-010%X160"(>%0#)!%
4!-1#4!%641.60%#)%+1>!-#0%+(&!)$!0L´HWTX·LOVQHVRQWSDVpORLJQpVGHV*-656"'$# ´7URJORG\WHVµ HWGHQRXYHDX
HQGLUHFWLRQGHO·RXHVW%SDUUDSSRUWjHX[FHUWDLQVSHXSOHVVDQVFRXTXLRQWOHV\HX[GDQVOHVpSDXOHVµ´DQG
WKDWWKH\DUHQRWIDUDZD\IURPWKH&DYHGZHOOHUVDQGDJDLQZHVW:$5'IURPWKHVHWKHUHDUHVRPHSHRSOH
ZLWKRXWQHFNVKDYLQJWKHLUH\HVLQWKHLUVKRXOGHUVµ WUDG+5DFNKDPFROOHFWLRQ/RHES 

/RUVTXH1!-010HVWSRVWSRVpjXQQRPGHYLOOHLOPDUTXH³SUREDEOHPHQWGHPDQLqUHSOXVH[SOLFLWHTXH("%
DFF³TXHO·RQQ·HQYLVDJHSDVGHIDLUHDERXWLUOHPRXYHPHQWGDQVFHWWHYLOOHPDLVTXHODYLOOHHVWVHXOHPHQW
XWLOLVpHFRPPHUHSqUHGLUHFWLRQQHO
&LFpURQN!$$-!0%h%<$$#410%T!-$#%#5#$1-%>!%(%A#)$1-)#0%<-I#)1>%1!-010
´-HPHGLULJHGRQFjSDUWLUGH0LQWXUQHVGDQVODGLUHFWLRQG·$USLQXPµ´$F%G7FM%0JHKL7H6J%*%6M%KL7H8HI%
FGG%WRZDUGV%!7=8HLMµ WUDG(2:LQVWHGWFROOHFWLRQ/RHES 

'DQVOHSDVVDJHSUpFpGHQWGH&LFpURQOHSRLQWGHGpSDUWGXGpSODFHPHQWHVWFRQQX A#)$1-)(!%´0LQWXUQHVµ
YLOOHGX/DWLXP FHTXLHQWUDvQHO·HPSORLGHODSUpSRVLWLRQ(&DEODWLI4XDQWjODORFDOLWpG·$USLQXPHOOHQ·HVW
SDVSUpVHQWpHSDUOHORFXWHXUFRPPHODFLEOHGXYR\DJHPDLVVHXOHPHQWFRPPHXQOLHXXWLOLVpSRXUGRQQHUXQH
GLUHFWLRQGHWUDMHFWRLUH,OHQHVWGHPrPHSRXU5RPHGDQVOHWH[WHVXLYDQWGH7LWH/LYHRO·RQWURXYHVHXOHPHQW
XQHLQGLFDWLRQIORXHIDLVDQWVXLWHjXQHLQGLFDWLRQSUpFLVHGHVXUIDFHIRQGpHVXUXQHOLPLWHPD[LPDOHTXLHVWHQ
O·RFFXUUHQFHXQIOHXYH
7LWH/LYHO#0$6#-!%-6>(#)!!60%-.(!/.'.)!+)0&)%K6>(>%1!-010%d%!>61!)"60L%
´LOVGHYDLHQWrWUHGpSODFpV<6&D<ZO&D;&B><;L<&,9F9A%HQGLUHFWLRQGH5RPHµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%QT,N\*/,B%N/BD\/7*/e\8%8B%N<*/B% :<P

$FHVWDGHGHO·pYROXWLRQRQSHXWFRQVLGpUHU1!-010FRPPHXQYpULWDEOHpOpPHQWGHUHODWLRQVSDWLDOUpJLVVDQW
O·DFFXVDWLI GLUHFWLI G·XQVXEVWDQWLIHWUHOHYDQWGHODFDWpJRULHGHVSUpSRVLWLRQV3OXVSUpFLVpPHQWDXVHLQGHOD
FDWpJRULHSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHLOIDLWSDUWLHGHV´SUpSRVLWLRQVSRVWSRVpHVµ/DSUpVHQFHGH1!-010GDQVOHVpQRQFpV
SUpFpGHQWVHVWHQHIIHWLQGLVSHQVDEOHSRXUDVVXUHUODJUDPPDWLFDOLWpGHODSKUDVH

J2T2J2R2&-6<&=F7[=5A98956&=F5858K=9:;<&
/DGHUQLqUHpWDSHTXLIHUDGH1!-010XQHSUpSRVLWLRQSURWRW\SLTXHHVWFHOOHRLOHVWDQWpSRVpDXVXEVWDQWLI
TX·LOJRXYHUQHSUpILJXUDQWO·HPSORLSUpSRVLWLRQQHOGHVKpULWLHUVGXWHUPHODWLQGDQVOHVODQJXHVURPDQHV IUDQoDLV
?!-0%.!%.!?(QW &·HVWODVLWXDWLRQLOOXVWUpHSDUO·LQVFULSWLRQVXLYDQWH:@
3/N9,/NN/3%TBH8%*<DT7%8*%B,S/N8%FNTA8B%O/S8KT7%T8K7\A%,K*T7%T8K7TA%,33<7T7%FNT/*%<N*8K%
8*%<N*8K%´OjEDVG·ROH7DJHHWOHFpOqEUHIOHXYH+LEqUHYHUVOHOHYDQWHWYHUVOHFRXFKDQWFRXOHQWO·XQHW
O·DXWUHµ

J2U2&S<&>C&B><I956&65E96C><&O&>C&B><I956&L<FQC><
2QSRXUUUDLWSHQVHUjSUHPLqUHYXHTXHODFDWpJRULHFDVXHOOHFRQFHUQHVHXOHPHQWODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHOHV
FDWpJRULHVPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHVGXVXEVWDQWLIHWGHO·DGMHFWLI0DLVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVDQFLHQQHVIRXU
QLVVHQWDXVVLGHVH[HPSOHVGHWUDQVFDWpJRULVDWLRQG·XQHIRUPHVXEVWDQWLYDOHIOpFKLHHQXQHIRUPHYHUEDOHGDQV
ODPHVXUHROHVSDUDGLJPHVYHUEDX[FRQWLHQQHQWOHVIRUPHVQRPLQDOHVGXYHUEHTXLVRQWHQODWLQOHVSDUWLFLSHV
OHVLQILQLWLIVOHVVXSLQVOHVJpURQGLIVHWOHVDGMHFWLIVYHUEDX[
(OOHVVRQWjO·LQWHUVHFWLRQHQWUHODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHHWGHODIOH[LRQYHUEDOHOHVSDUWLFLSHVSDUH[HPSOHSDU
WDJHQWDYHFODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHODYDULDELOLWpHQJHQUHHQQRPEUHHWHQFDVHWSDUWDJHQWDYHFODIOH[LRQYHUEDOH
ODFRQVWUXFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHGXYHUEHDXSDUDGLJPHGXTXHOLOVDSSDUWLHQQHQW
2UFHUWDLQHVIRUPHVQRPLQDOHVGXYHUEHVRQWFRQVWLWXpHVHQODWLQ HWGDQVG·DXWUHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV
DQFLHQQHV SDUOHILJHPHQWG·XQHIRUPHFDVXHOOHGHQRPGHSURFqVDYHFPDLQWLHQGHODYDOHXUVpPDQWLTXHGXFDV
&·HVWOjO·RULJLQHGHVLQILQLWLIVHWGHVVXSLQVLVVXVGHIRUPHVILJpHVGHQRPVGHSURFqVVXIIL[pVHQ $1jO·DFFXVDWLI
GLUHFWLI VXSLQHQ$1>01>FRPSOpPHQWG·XQYHUEHGHPRXYHPHQW DXGDWLI OHW\SHPҸUčELOHXҸVࡃ´pWRQQDQW
jYRLUµGLIILFLOHGLFWࡃ´GLIILFLOHjGLUHµFRPPHFRPSOpPHQWG·XQDGMHFWLI RXpYHQWXHOOHPHQWjO·DEODWLIG·RULJLQH
pYHQWXHOOHPHQWSRXUFHUWDLQVH[HPSOHVGHO·pSRTXHDUFKDwTXHSRXUPDUTXHUO·RULJLQHG·XQPRXYHPHQWOHW\SH
RSV‫گ‬QčWࡃUHGH‫´گ‬MHUHYLHQVGHIDLUHOHVFRXUVHVDXPDUFKpµ 
,OV·DJLWGHODUpXWLOLVDWLRQG·XQHIRUPHFDVXHOOHODWUDQVIRUPDWLRQG·XQHIRUPHVXEVWDQWLYDOHHQXQHIRUPH
YHUEDOH&HVHPSORLVUHOqYHQWGHODJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQHWSOXVSUpFLVpPHQWGHODSDUDGLJPDWLVDWLRQORUVGHOD
FRQVWLWXWLRQGXSDUDGLJPHYHUEDO,OVVRQWVRXPLVjGHVFRQWUDLQWHVVpPDQWLTXHVOH[LFDOHVHWV\QWD[LTXHVIRUWHV
GHVRUWHTX·RQQHSHXWV·pWRQQHUGHODSHUWHGHSURGXFWLYLWpGHFHVWRXUQXUHV:P%

J2U2!2&,<&A;=96&<6&"1%)&\"(%)]
J2U2!2!2&,<&L<FQ<&968F5D;H8<;F
/HVXSLQHQ$1>HVWXQDFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLIHWLOQHVHUHQFRQWUHTXHGHUULqUHXQYHUEHGpQRWDQWXQPRXYHPHQW
GDQVGHVWRXUQXUHVFRPPHҸUHTXDHULWXPDOLTXLG´DOOHUFKHUFKHUTXHOTXHFKRVHµOLWWpUDOHPHQW´DOOHUSRXUOH
IDLWGHFKHUFKHUTXHOTXHFKRVHµ (&M ҸUHDUFHVVLWXPDOLTXHP´ V·HQ DOOHUFKHUFKHUTXHOTX·XQµ%H[WUࡃGHUHDOLTXHP
PHUFčWXP´FKDVVHUTXHOTX·XQSRXUTX·LODLOOHIDLUHGXFRPPHUFHµOLWWpUDOHPHQW´FKDVVHUTXHOTX·XQSRXUOH

:@
'DQVFHWWHLQVFULSWLRQOHVVXEVWDQWLIV 6-$10´OHYDQWµHWRFFčVXV%
´FRXFKDQWµ QH VRQW SDV DX FDV DWWHQGX DFFXVDWLI VLQJXOLHU  /HV
GF7MJ9%6-$10%JK%644(010SRXUUDLHQWrWUHPRUSKRORJLTXHPHQWGHVDFFX
VDWLIVSOXULHOV'HUULqUHOHVSUpSRVLWLRQVHQODWLQSRVWFODVVLTXHGHEDV
QLYHDXGHODQJXHRQREVHUYHVRXYHQWGHVIORWWHPHQWVFDVXHOVGDQV
OHVJUDSKLHV FIVXSUD 

)UX\WHW
:P
2QYRLWGpMjFODLUHPHQWGpFOLQHUOHVXSLQHQM$1>HQWUHODSpULRGH
DUFKDwTXHHWODSpULRGHFODVVLTXH&HWWHVWUXFWXUHpWDLWHQFRUHUHOD
WLYHPHQWSURGXFWLYHFKH]3ODXWHRHOOHV·DFFRPPRGDLWGHYHUEHV
UpJLVVDQWVDVVH]QRPEUHX[HWGHVHQVDVVH]YDULpV FHSHQGDQWLOV
LQGLTXDLHQWWRXVXQPRXYHPHQW 0DLVHOOHYRLWVHUHVWUHLQGUHVRQ
FKDPSG·DFWLRQHQODWLQFODVVLTXHROHQRPEUHHWOHVHQVGHVYHUEHV
UpJLVVDQWVVRQWWUqVOLPLWpV
 oi.uchicago.edu

:R?% A/3OZN8%FK\Y*

IDLWGHIDLUHGXFRPPHUFHµ%XRFčUHDOLTXHPX̒QčWXP´DSSHOHUTXHOTX·XQjYHQLUFKDVVHUµOLWWpUDOHPHQW´DSSHOHU
TXHOTX·XQSRXUOHIDLWGHFKDVVHUSRXUODFKDVVHµQ?
&RPPHRQOHYRLWLOH[LVWHLFLGHX[W\SHVVpPDQWLTXHVGHYHUEHV´DOOHUVHPHWWUHVRLPrPHHQPRXYHPHQWµ
RXXQHWRXUQXUHFDXVDWLYH´IDLUHDOOHUPHWWUHTXHOTX·XQG·DXWUHHQPRXYHPHQWµ,O\DGRQFGHX[VWUXFWXUHV
V\QWD[LTXHVHWVpPDQWLTXHVVRXVMDFHQWHVjFHVWRXUQXUHVDXVXSLQ
$YHFOHYHUEHҸUH´DOOHUµO·DJHQWGHҸUHHVWDXVVLO·DJHQWGXSURFqVGpQRWpSDUOHVXSLQX1(!-#$1>2%(-4!00#$1>%
´FKHUFKHUµHWOHWHUPHjO·DFFXVDWLI (.#X1#" HVWOHFRPSOpPHQW FRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWGLUHFW GXVXSLQ
$XFRQWUDLUHDYHFOHVYHUEHVGHVHQVFDXVDWLIYLVDQWjIDLUHVHGpSODFHUDXWUXLWHOVH[WUࡃGHUH´FKDVVHUMHWHU%
GHKRUV2Y%XRFčUH´DSSHOHUµOHWHUPHjO·DFFXVDWLI LFL(.#X1!> HVWOHFRPSOpPHQW FRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWGLUHFW GX
YHUEH´SULQFLSDOµ H[WUࡃGHUH2%XRFčUH GHVRUWHTXHFHYHUEH´SULQFLSDOµDGHX[REMHWVXQSURQRPRXVXEVWDQWLI
LFL(.#X1!>TXLGpVLJQHODSHUVRQQHPLVHHQPRXYHPHQW HWOHVXSLQ/HFRPSOpPHQWjO·DFFXVDWLIHVWO·DJHQWGX
SURFqVGpQRWpSDUOHVXSLQ1RXVDYRQVLFLOHVSUpPLFHVG·XQHUHODWLRQGHVXMHW DJHQW jSUpGLFDW VXSLQ TXL
SRXUUDLWpYHQWXHOOHPHQWDERXWLUjXQHVWUXFWXUHGXW\SHGHODSURSRVLWLRQLQILQLWLYHODWLQHDWWHVWpHDYHFOHYHUEH
LXEH‫´گ‬RUGRQQHUµLXEH‫گ‬DOLTXHPXHQҸUH´M·RUGRQQHjTXHOTX·XQGHYHQLUµ OLWWpUDOHPHQW´M·RUGRQQHTXHTXHOTX·XQ
YLHQQHµ LXEH‫گ‬DOLTXHPPHUFčUҸ%´M·RUGRQQHjTXHOTX·XQGHIDLUHGXFRPPHUFHµLXEH‫گ‬DOLTXHPX̒QčUҸ´M·RUGRQQHj
TXHOTX·XQGHFKDVVHUµ

J2U2!2J2&$EQ9?;^87A
'XIDLWTXHGHVIRUPHVVXEVWDQWLYDOHVIXUHQWUpHPSOR\pHVHQIRUPHVYHUEDOHVKRPRSKRQHVRQQHVDXUDLW
V·pWRQQHUGHFHTXHO·RQSXLVVHjO·RFFDVLRQVHWURXYHUIDFHjGHVDPELJXwWpVHQWUHIRUPHVQRPLQDOHVG·XQQRP
GHSURFqVHQWXVࡃVPDVFjO·DFFXVDWLIHWIRUPHYHUEDOHGHVXSLQHQ$1>jO·DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLI/HYRFDEXODLUH
PLOLWDLUHTXLHVWVXUFHSRLQWFRQVHUYDWHXUQRXVHQIRXUQLWGHVH[HPSOHVGDQVODFKDvQHGHGpULYDWLRQVXLYDQWH
(X1(%´HDXµ¬౏%DTXčUҸ´IDLUHODFRUYpHG·HDXDOOHUFKHUFKHUGHO·HDXµ౏%DTXčWXVࡃVPDVF´OHIDLWG·DOOHUFKHUFKHU
GHO·HDXµ&HGHUQLHUVXEVWDQWLIOHQRPGHSURFqVDTXčWXVࡃVPDVFHVWHPSOR\pHQSDUWLFXOLHUGDQVODOH[LH
DTXčWXPҸUH´DOOHUjODFRUYpHG·HDXDOOHUFKHUFKHUGHO·HDXµRQSHXWDORUVVHGHPDQGHUVLODIRUPHDTXčWXPGRLW
rWUHFRQVLGpUpHFRPPHOHVXEVWDQWLIjO·DFFXVDWLIRXFRPPHOHVXSLQGXYHUEHDTXčUҸ/DPrPHDPELJXwWpHVW
LOOXVWUpHSRXUGHX[DXWUHVWHUPHVGXPrPHFKDPSOH[LFDOOLJQčWXVࡃVPDVF´OHIDLWG·DOOHUFKHUFKHUGXERLVOD
FRUYpHGHERLVµQOGDQVODOH[LHOLJQčWXPҸUH´DOOHUjODFRUYpHGHERLVµHWSčEXOčWXVࡃVPDVF´OHIDLWG·DOOHUFKHUFKHU
GXIRXUUDJHODFRUYpHGHIRXUUDJHµQ:GDQVODOH[LHSčEXOčWXPҸUH´DOOHUjODFRUYpHGHIRXUUDJHµ
'DQVELHQGHVFDVLO\DFRH[LVWHQFHGDQVOHPrPHpWDWGHODQJXHHQWUHOHVXEVWDQWLIHQWXVࡃVPDVFHWOD
IRUPHGXVXSLQHQ$1>TXLV·HQHVWGpWDFKpH6LODIRUPHPHUFčWXPHVWOHVXSLQGXYHUEHPHUFčUҸ´IDLUHGXFRP
PHUFHµF·HVWDXVVLO·DFFXVDWLIGXVXEVWDQWLIPHUFčWXVࡃVPDVF´OHIDLWGHIDLUHGXFRPPHUFHµ RXGHPHUFčWXVҸ
´PDUFKpµ 
5>6LKJ2%A!-4($6->!-4($1>%(06$1>%:#.#1>%!]$-1"#$%I($!-%´/HSqUHHQYRLHGHIRUFHVRQILOVGpEDXFKpG687J%
GXFRPPHUFHµ

5>6LKJ2%@!-0(%Q::N%H6>#)10%>!%&61!0%>!-4($1>%8-!$-#(>%>#0#$%´/HPDvWUHP·DHQYR\pHQ(UpWULHSRXUDFKHWHU%
GHVERYLQVµ

'DQVFHGHUQLHUH[HPSOHDYHF>#$$!-!%´HQYR\HUµOHYHUEHPҸVLW´LOHQYR\DµDWURLVFRPSOpPHQWVjO·DFFXVDWLI
O·DFFXVDWLIGXSURQRPSHUVRQQHOP̒ SHUVRQQHHQYR\pH´DJHQWPDQLSXOpµGDQVXQHUHODWLRQFDXVDWLYH OHVXSLQ
PHUFčWXP TXLGpQRWHOHSURFqVGRQWO·DJHQWHVWGpVLJQpSDUP̒ HWOHWRSRQ\PH8-!$-#(>jO·DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLISRXU
GpVLJQHUOHSRLQWG·DERXWLVVHPHQW HWODFLEOH GXPRXYHPHQWYRXOXSDUO·DJHQWFDXVDWHXUVXMHWGHPҸVLW
-6%GF7MJ%RSV‫گ‬QčWXPHVWVRLWOHVXSLQG·RSV‫گ‬QčUҸ´IDLUHGHVFRPPLVVLRQVIDLUHGHVFRXUVHVGHQRXUULWXUHµGDQV
LHJ%KFL7HL7J&PLWWHUHDOLTXHPRSV‫گ‬QčWXPFXPDOLTX‫´گ‬HQYR\HUTXHOTX·XQIDLUHOHVFRXUVHVDYHFTXHOTX·XQµ

Q?
$XWUHVIRUPHVGHVXSLQUHQFRQWUpHVFKH]3ODXWHDSUqVXQYHUEHGH
PRXYHPHQW41&#$1> (4M2%"#0M ´FRXFKHUµDGLࡃWXP´DLGHUµDPEXOčWXP%
´PDUFKHUVHSURPHQHUµFDSWčWXP2%H[WHQWčWXP2%RVWHQWčWXP2%XčSXOčWXP2%
!] 0 XOčWXP H[XOčUH´YLYUHHQH[LOµ 464$1>2%FRTXҸQčWXP FRTXҸQčUH%
´IDLUHODFXLVLQHµ3ODXWH@0!1"6.10 
QO
6HORQODFKDvQHGHGpULYDWLRQ.#5)1>2%ҸQHXW´ERLVGHFKDXIIDJH
=JK8K%DF89Y%౏%OLJQčUҸ´V·RFFXSHUGXERLVFKHUFKHUGXERLVµ౏%OLJQč
$102%ࡃVPDVF´OHIDLWGHFKHUFKHUGXERLVµ
Q:
6HORQODFKDvQHGHGpULYDWLRQSčEXOXP2%ҸQHXW´IRXUUDJHSRXU
OHVDQLPDX[µ౏%SčEXOčUҸ´V·RFFXSHUGXIRXUUDJHµ౏%SčEXOčWXV2%ࡃV%
PDVF´OHIDLWGHV·RFFXSHUGXIRXUUDJHµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%QT,N\*/,B%N/BD\/7*/e\8%8B%N<*/B% :RO

5>6LKJ2%3(0#)(%<<?;<ON%T6.1#%3+(.#)1>%d%>#$$!-!%l%*!41>%6I06)($1>%d%´-·DXUDLVYRXOX«HQYR\HU&KDOLQXVIDLUH
OHVFRXUVHVDYHFWRLµ

VRLWG·DFFXVDWLIVLQJGXVXEVWDQWLIQRPGHSURFqVRSV‫گ‬QčWXVࡃVPDVF´IDLWGHIDLUHOHVFRXUVHVµ
5>6LKJ2%A#.!0%5.6-#6010%@<PN%B1)4%X16"%644!I#%6I06)($1>%I!-5(>´0DLQWHQDQWFRPPHM·DYDLVFRPPHQFpjOH
IDLUHMHYDLVFRQWLQXHUjDOOHUIDLUHOHPDUFKpµ

/DSUHXYHGHFHTXHOHVXSLQHVWELHQXQHIRUPHYHUEDOHFRQVLVWHGDQVOHIDLWTX·LOSHXWDYRLUXQFRPSOpPHQW
G·REMHW FRG jO·DFFXVDWLIF·HVWjGLUHODPrPHUHFWLRQTXHOHYHUEHGRQWLOUHOqYHHWFHODQRQVHXOHPHQWj
O·pSRTXHDUFKDwTXHGHSXLV3ODXWHPDLVDXVVLjO·pSRTXHFODVVLTXH
&pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>O(!"1#2%41>%0!%01(X1!%(&%##0%"!:!)"!-!%)6)%I600!)$2%.!5($60%("%3(!0(-!>%>#$$1)$%
K,D<*TA%(1]#.#1>´/HV+pGXHQVQHSRXYDQWGpIHQGUHOHXUVSHUVRQQHVHWOHXUVELHQVHQYRLHQWXQHDPEDV
VDGHj&pVDUSRXUOXLGHPDQGHUGHO·DLGHµ

$6>>L9KJ2%/151-$+(S644+10%#)#$#6%+1#104!%&!..#%.!5($60%K6>(>%>#0!-($%:6!"10%!$%(>#4#$#(>%@8*/*TA%´%RFFKXV
DXGpEXWGHFHWWHJXHUUHDYDLWHQYR\pj5RPHXQHDPEDVVDGHSRXUGHPDQGHUXQWUDLWpG·DOOLDQFHµ

&RPPHOHYHUEHPRQH‫گ‬DOLTXHPDOLTXLG´DYHUWLUTXHOTX·XQGHTXHOTXHFKRVHµVHFRQVWUXLWDYHFXQGRXEOHDFFXVDWLI
LOHQHVWGHPrPHSRXUVRQVXSLQ
5>6LKJ2%<1.1.(-#(%@QPN%/"%("!6%$!%,K<*TA%("1!)#6%1$%()#>6%(!X16%#5)604(0%>#+#L%´$XVVLMHYLHQVWHSULHUGHPH
SDUGRQQHUDYHFELHQYHLOODQFHµ

/HVXSLQG·XQYHUEHGRQWOHSUHPLHUREMHWVHPHWDXGDWLI RSLWXOčUҸ2%VXSSOLFčUH VHFRQVWUXLWpJDOHPHQWDYHFXQGDWLI

5>6LKJ2%A#.!0%5.6-#6010A#+#X1!%(>()$#%#-!%,@/*TN<*TA´PHYHQLUHQDLGHGDQVPHVDPRXUVµ

5>6LKJ2%<1.1.(-#(%@R:N%e1#)%$#&#%1.$-6%7T@@N/3<*TA%1!)#6%6&%0$1.$#$#(>%>!(>L%´%LHQSOXVMHYLHQVGHPDSURSUH
YRORQWpSRXUWHVXSSOLHUGHSDUGRQQHUPDVRWWLVHµ

'HPrPHVLXQYHUEHVHFRQVWUXLWDYHFXQHSURSRVLWLRQVXERUGRQQpHFRPSOpWLYHWHOOHHVWDXVVLODFRQVWUXFWLRQ
GHVRQVXSLQFHTXHQRXVLOOXVWURQVFLGHVVRXVVXFFHVVLYHPHQWSDUXQHFRPSOpWLYHHQ1$VXEMRQFWLIQ̒VXEM
X16"VXEMHWXQHSURSRVLWLRQLQILQLWLYH
‡ XW&pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>%1!)#1)$%,K<*TA%1$%d4#1#$($#%01&1!)#($L%´LOVYLHQQHQW OXL 
GHPDQGHUGHYHQLUHQDLGHjOHXUFvWpµ
‡ Q̒&pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>%N!5($60%("%3(!0(-!>%>#0!-1)$%,K<*TA%)!%0!%#)%+60$#1>%
)1>!-6%"14!-!$L%´LOVHQYR\qUHQWGHVDPEDVVDGHXUVDXSUqVGH&pVDUSRXUOXLGHPDQGHUGH
QHSDVOHVFRPSWHUDXQRPEUHGHVHVHQQHPLVµ FI6DOOXVWH/151-$+( 
‡ TXRG&pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>²O(!"1#%^1!)#!&()$`%eT87*TA%X16"%O(-1"!02%X1#%)1I!-%#)%
D(..#(>%$-()0I6-$($#%!00!)$2%:#)!0%!6-1>%I6I1.(-!)$1-%´/HV+pGXHQV YHQDLHQW VHSODLQGUHGH
FHTXHOHV+DUXGHVTXLpWDLHQWUpFHPPHQWSDVVpVHQ*DXOHUDYDJHDLHQWOHXUWHUULWRLUHµ
‡ SURSRVLWLRQLQILQLWLYH6DOOXVWH/151-$+(e1!>%S644+10%d%("%71..(>%BTB*/<*TA%>#$$#$%
I(-($1>%0!0!%:(4!-!%X1(!%I6I1.10%K6>()10%1!..!$L´%RFFKXVO·HQYRLHDXSUqVGH6\OODSRXUOXL
DQQRQFHUTX·LOpWDLWSUrWjH[pFXWHUOHVYRORQWpVGXSHXSOHURPDLQµ

J2U2J2&,<&A;=96&<6&Wɫ&H5EE<&DC89B
$F{WpGHODIRUPHSURGXFWLYHGHGDWLIHQXҸ PDQXҸ%=FL7%>()10ࡃV GHODJGpFOLQDLVRQQRXVVDYRQVTX·LOD
H[LVWpSRXUFHWWHIOH[LRQGHVWKqPHVHQ «1MXQGDWLIHQࡃPrPHVLFHWWHGpVLQHQFHDOORPRUSKHQ·DSDVHXOH
PrPHVXFFqVHWODPrPHSURGXFWLYLWpTXHO·XVXHOXҸQQ&HWWHYDULDQWHPLQRULWDLUHHQࡃHVWFHOOHTXLILJXUHGDQV
OHVXSLQHQWࡃ Vࡃ FRPSOpPHQWGHFHUWDLQVDGMHFWLIV&HVXSLQHVWHQHIIHWVRXPLVjGHVFRQWUDLQWHVOH[LFDOHV

QQ
&I$XOX*HOOHB64$!0%<$$#4(!²jSURSRVGHࡃDUFKDwTXHHW
FODVVLTXHFRPPHDOORPRUSKHGHXҸ
 oi.uchicago.edu

:R:% A/3OZN8%FK\Y*

GpMjIRUWHVjODSpULRGHDUFKDwTXHHWTXLYRQWFURLVVDQWGDQVOHVSpULRGHVXOWpULHXUHVGHODODWLQLWp2QOHWURXYH
VHXOHPHQWGDQVGHVH[SUHVVLRQVIRUPXODLUHVGXW\SHIDFLOHGLFWࡃ &pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>I!-:(4#.!%"#4$1 2%"#::#4#.!%
GLFWࡃIDFLOHIDFWࡃPҸUčELOHXҸVࡃLQFU̒GLELOHPHPRUčWࡃ% 6DOOXVWH/151-$+(% RSWLPXPIDFWࡃ &pVDU%S!..1>%D(..#41>%
6DOOXVWH/151-$+( 2QUHQFRQWUHDXVVLGLFWࡃFRPPHFRPSOpPHQWGHODOH[LHQHIčVHVW´LOHVWLQWHUGLW
VDFULOqJHGHµ &LFpURQ3($6%A(#6-%OQN%)!:(0%!0$%H/3*T2%>#0!-(>%:1#00!%$(.!>%0!)!4$1$!>%´LOHVWVDFULOqJHGHGLUHTX·XQH
WHOOHYLHLOOHVVHHVWPLVpUDEOHµ 
0DLVjO·pSRTXHDUFKDwTXHHWQRWDPPHQWFKH]3ODXWHRQWURXYHXQHSOXVJUDQGHYDULpWpGHWRXUQXUHVjODIRLV
SRXUO·DGMHFWLIUpJLVVDQWHWSRXUOHVXSLQUpJLOHVXSLQHQWࡃHVWFRPSOpPHQWGHVDGMHFWLIV%ULGLFXOXVPҸUXV2%>#0!-2%
IRUPLGRO‫گ‬VXV2%HWFHWOHVIRUPHVGHVXSLQSHXYHQWrWUHHQWUHDXWUHV%JHVWࡃLQXHQWࡃ 3ODXWH*-#)1>>10 HVVࡃg
5>6LKJ2%@0!1"6.10²e16>%+(04!%+!-&(0%+1#10%>6"#%#)%016>%(.16>%46)5!-1)$2l%F6->#"6.60(0%H/3*T2%)6)%877T%
>6"6d´4XDQGOHVJHQVVHPHWWHQWGDQVOHYHQWUHGHVKHUEHVGHFHWWHQDWXUHTXLVRQWHIIUD\DQWHVjQRPPHU%
JK%=69%9JL>JMJHK%jPDQJHU%VY

J2U2M2&,C&:;<A8956&H568F5L<FA7<&D;&A;=96&<6&Wɫ&H5EE<&CQ>C89B&
J2U2M2!2&-6&CQ>C89B&DP5F9?96<&?FCEEC89HC>9A7&<6&A;=96Y
&HUWDLQHVV\QWD[HVFRQVLGqUHQWTX·LOH[LVWHDXVVLXQVXSLQjO·DEODWLIHQWࡃTXLUHSUpVHQWHXQQRPGHSURFqV
ILJpjO·DEODWLIG·RULJLQHGDQVO·H[SUHVVLRQSODXWLQLHQQHUHGH‫گ‬RSV‫گ‬QčWࡃ´MHUHYLHQVGHIDLUHOHVFRXUVHVMHUHYLHQV
GXPDUFKpµjF{WpGXVXEVWDQWLIREV‫گ‬QčWXVࡃVPDVF´DFKDWGHSURYLVLRQVµQ<%

5>6LKJ2%AU)!4+>!0%)1)4%,@7,B<*T%-!"!6L%´­SUpVHQWMHUHYLHQVGHIDLUHOHVFRXUVHVµ

5>6LKJ2%3(0#)(%@OPN%-!"#$%!441>%$()"!>%,S7,B<*T%>!10%("#1$6-L´9RLFLPRQDLGHTXLUHYLHQWHQILQGHIDLUHOHV
FRXUVHVµ

5>6LKJ2%AU)!4+>!0%:@@N%@-#10%#(>%46)1#1(!%(>&1.()$%()$!%60$#1>%l%e1(>%!56%,@7,B<*T%-!"!6L%
´/HVFRQYLYHVVHSURPqQHQWGpMjGHYDQWODSRUWHHWMHQHVXLVSDVHQFRUHUHYHQXGXPDUFKpµ

8QDUJXPHQWHQIDYHXUGHO·H[LVWHQFHGHFHVXSLQHQWࡃG·DEODWLIG·RULJLQHHVWXQSDVVDJHFRPPHFHOXLGH
&DWRQRXQHIRUPHHQWࡃPDUTXDQWO·RULJLQHHVWRSSRVpHjXQHIRUPHV\PpWULTXHHQ$1>GXPrPHOH[qPH ´VH
FRXFKHUµ jO·DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLIPDUTXDQWODFLEOHGXPRXYHPHQW
"6KFH2%H!%(5-#41.$1-(I-#>10%3TS/*T%01-5($2%I60$-!>10%3TS/*TA%!($L
´4X·LOVRLWOHSUHPLHUjVHOHYHUHWOHGHUQLHUjDOOHUVHFRXFKHUµ

2QSHXWWUDGXLUHOLWWpUDOHPHQW´TX·LOVRUWHGXIDLWG·rWUHFRXFKpOHSUHPLHUTX·LODLOOHYHUVOHIDLWGH%VHFRXFKHU%
OHGHUQLHUµ6LO·RQFRQVLGqUHTXH41&#$1>GDQVFXELWXPҸUH´DOOHUDXOLWµHVWXQVXSLQLOIDXWFRQVLGpUHUTXHFXELWࡃ
GDQVFXELWࡃVXUJHUH´VRUWLUGXOLWVHOHYHUµTXLGpQRWHOHPRXYHPHQWV\PpWULTXHHVWDXVVLXQVXSLQ,OH[LVWHGRQF
HQODWLQDUFKDwTXHOHVWUDFHV RXOHVGpEXWVDYRUWpV" G·XQVXSLQjO·DEODWLIG·RULJLQH

J2U2M2J2&-6&CQ>C89B[96A8F;E<68C>&?FCEEC89HC>9A7&<6&A;=96Y&
1RXVSRXUULRQVQRXVGHPDQGHUGHFHIDLWV·LOH[LVWHDXVVLHQODWLQDUFKDwTXHRXFODVVLTXHGHVWUDFHVG·XQ
VXSLQjO·DEODWLILQVWUXPHQWDO
&HUWDLQVVXEVWDQWLIVHQ$10ࡃVPDVFGHODJGpFOLQDLVRQ LH $1 QHVRQWDWWHVWpVHQODWLQTX·jO·DEODWLI
VLQJRXVRQWSUHVTXHWRXMRXUVDWWHVWpVjO·DEODWLIVLQJFRPPHV·LOVpWDLHQWGHVVXEVWDQWLIVjIOH[LRQGpIHFWLYH
6LOHVGLFWLRQQDLUHVIRQWXQHHQWUpHSRXUOHVXEVWDQWLIQčWXVࡃVPDVF´QDLVVDQFHIDLWGHQDvWUHµRQQHWURXYH
HQUpDOLWpFHWHUPHTX·jO·DEODWLIVLQJGDQVXQHWRXUQXUHIRUPXODLUHPčLRUQčWࡃ´SOXVkJpµ OLWWpUDOHPHQW´SOXV

Q<
/DSUHXYHGHO·H[LVWHQFHGXVXEVWDQWLIHVWIRXUQLHSDUXQHPSORL TX·RQOXLSRUWHFLQTPLQHVG·DUJHQWHWHQRXWUHXQHPLQHSRXUO·DFKDW
GHUULqUHSUpSRVLWLRQ3ODXWH*-141.!)$10%@QP;<?N%#100#X%!#%X1#)X1!% GHSURYLVLRQVµ
(-5!)$#%"!:!--#%>#)(02%l%@-(!$!-!(%1)(>%/B%,@7,B<*TA´M·DLRUGRQQp
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%QT,N\*/,B%N/BD\/7*/e\8%8B%N<*/B% :RQ

JUDQGSDUODQDLVVDQFHµ&LFpURQ3($6%A(#6-%<QN%>(#6-!0%)($1 HWPLQRUQčWࡃ´SOXVMHXQHµ OLWWpUDOHPHQW´SOXVSHWLW

SDUODQDLVVDQFHµ 8QHWHOOHUHVWULFWLRQG·HPSORLHVWO·LQGLFHG·XQHIRUPHOH[LFDOHPHQWFRQGLWLRQQpH
$O·pSRTXHFODVVLTXHFKH]&pVDURQWURXYHO·DEODWLIVLQJG·XQQRPGHSURFqVUpSHUWRULpSDUOHVGLFWLRQQDLUHV
VRXVO·HQWUpHLXVVXVࡃVPDVF´RUGUHIDLWG·RUGRQQHUµGDQVOHVWRXUQXUHVLXVVࡃ&DHVDULV´VXUO·RUGUHGH&pVDUµHWOH
V\PpWULTXHQpJDWLIjPRUSKqPHSUpIL[DO#)QpJDWLILQLXVVࡃ&DHVDULV´VDQVDYRLUUHoXO·RUGUHGH&pVDUµ/DYDOHXU
TXDVLJUDPPDWLFDOHGHFHVGHX[IRUPHVG·DEODWLIVLQJQRXVVHPEOHSURXYpHSDUO·H[LVWHQFHGXPRUSKqPHQpJDWLI
#)TXLQHVHWURXYHSDVQRUPDOHPHQWSUpIL[pjXQVXEVWDQWLIPDLVVHXOHPHQWjXQSDUWLFLSHRXjXQDGMHFWLI
&HFLQRXVSRXVVHUDLWjFRQVLGpUHULXVVࡃ%JK%LQLXVVࡃGDQVFHVWRXUQXUHVFRPPHGHVHPEU\RQVGHVXSLQjO·DEODWLI
LQVWUXPHQWDO
/·pYHQWXHOOHH[LVWHQFHG·XQVXSLQjO·DEODWLILQVWUXPHQWDOSRXUUDLWpJDOHPHQWrWUHSULVHHQFRQVLGpUDWLRQGDQV
GHVFDVG·DPELJXwWpRO·RQYRLWWUDGLWLRQQHOOHPHQWGHVVXSLQVDXGDWLITXLSRXUUDLHQWrWUHLQWHUSUpWpVQRXV
VHPEOHWLOFRPPHGHVDEODWLIVLQVWUXPHQWDX[WHOOHSDVVDJHVXLYDQWGH9LUJLOHRO·RQSRXUUDLWFRQVLGpUHUTXH
XҸVࡃHVWXQDEODWLILQVWUXPHQWDOGHSRLQWGHYXHDX[F{WpVGXVXSHUODWLI(.$#00#>(OLWWpUDOHPHQW´WUqVKDXWHGX
SRLQWGHYXHGXUHJDUGVRXVO·DVSHFWGHODYXHSDUODYXHµ
187I8>J2%8)U#"!%²g%7$(&($%(41$(%0#.!]%I-(!4#0#0%1)"#X1!%0(]#0%l%7I!.1)4(!%"6-06%#)01-5!)02%(.$#00#>(%T/7Tl%
"#-(-1>%)#"#0%"6>10%6II6-$1)(%16.14-1>
´,O\DYDLWOjGHERXWV·pOHYDQWGXGRVGHODFDYHUQHXQHDLJXLOOHGHVLOH[HQWRXUpHGHURFVDEUXSWVWUqV%
KDXWH$/·°,/VpMRXUELHQIDLWSRXUOHQLGGHVRLVHDX[GHPDOKHXUµ WUDG-3HUUHW3DULV&ROOHFWLRQ
GHVXQLYHUVLWpVGH)UDQFHWRPHS 

J2U2M2M2&,<A&A;QA8C89BA&<6&"1%(_&ɫV&ECAH2@&;6<&B5FEC8956&656&=F5D;H89L<
/HVUHPDUTXHVSUpFpGHQWHVWHQGHQWjPRQWUHUOHFDUDWqUHQRQSURGXFWLIGHVIRUPDWLRQVHQWXVࡃVPDVF
$1 VXEVWDQWLYDOHVHQODWLQDUFKDwTXH2QSRXUUDLWDMRXWHUFRPPHDUJXPHQWDOODQWGDQVOHPrPHVHQVTXH
FHUWDLQVGHFHVVXEVWDQWLIVHQWXVࡃVPDVFVRQWOLPLWpVDXGDWLIVLQJGDQVGHVOH[LHVYHUEDOHVDXGRXEOHGDWLI
VHUYDQWGHWRXUQXUHSDVVLYHGHVSLFčWXҸHVVHDOLFXҸOLWWpUDOHPHQW´rWUHjPpSULVSRXUTXHOTX·XQµ´rWUHXQREMHW
GHPpSULVSRXUTXHOTX·XQµ´rWUHPpSULVpSDUTXHOTX·XQµSDURSSRVLWLRQjODWRXUQXUHDFWLYH"!0I#4!-!%(.#X1!>%
´PpSULVHUTXHOTX·XQµ
&HWWHIRUPDWLRQHQWXVࡃVPDVFHVWLPSURGXFWLYHGDQVOHVHQVRODODQJXHDFHUWHVFRQVHUYpOHVVXEVWDQ
WLIVDQFLHQVGRQWHOOHDKpULWpPDLVQ·HQDSDVFUppGHQRXYHDX[jFHWWHpSRTXHODIRUPDWLRQSURGXFWLYHSRXUOHV
QRPVGHSURFqVHVWDORUVOHVVXEVWDQWLIVHQWL‫ گ‬WL‫گ‬QLV IpPTXLUHVWHURQWSURGXFWLIVSHQGDQWWRXWHODODWLQLWpHW
SDVVHURQWGDQVOHVODQJXHVURPDQHV

J2U2R2&$EQ9?;^87&D<&>PCHH;AC89B@&>C&B5FEC8956&D<&>P96B96989B&B;8;F&=CAA9B&>C896
/HODWLQLOOXVWUHpJDOHPHQWODUpDQDO\VHG·XQHIRUPHG·DFFXVDWLIORUVGHODIRUPDWLRQG·XQHSpULSKUDVHYHUEDOH
FHOOHGHO·LQILQLWLIIXWXUSDVVLIGXW\SHOHFWXPҸUҸ´VHUDOXµ jO·LQILQLWLI DXGҸWXPҸUҸ´VHUDHQWHQGXµ jO·LQILQLWLI 
DPčWXPҸUҸ&HWWHSpULSKUDVHUHFRXUWjODJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQGXYHUEHҸUH´DOOHUµTXLVHWURXYHjO·LQILQLWLISDVVLI
DORUVTXHFRPPHYHUEHLQWUDQVLWLILOQ·DSDVGHSDVVLISHUVRQQHOORUVTX·LOHVWHPSOR\pDYHFVDYDOHXUOH[LFDOHQRQ
JUDPPDWLFDOLVpH,OHVWDFFRPSDJQpG·XQHIRUPHGHVXSLQTXLGpQRWHODYDOHXUOH[LFDOHGHODSpULSKUDVH
6HORQO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHODV\QWD[HGH.KQHUHW6WHJPDQQ †G LOIDXGUDLWSDUWLUGHWRXUQXUHV
FRPPHOHSDVVDJHVXLYDQWGH7pUHQFH
7pUHQFHOU4'-!%QP;<?N%K1>6-%1!)#$%l%H($1>%#-#%5.("#($6-!0L%´OHEUXLWVHUpSDQGLWTX·RQDOODLWGRQQHUGHV FRP
EDWVGH JODGLDWHXUVµ

RҸUҸHVWO·LQILQLWLIGHҸUH´DOOHUµDXSDVVLILPSHUVRQQHOFRUUHVSRQGDQWjҸWXU´RQYDµjO·LQGLFDWLISUpVHQW'DQV
FHSDVVDJHJODGLčW‫گ‬U̒VVHUDLWRULJLQHOOHPHQWOHFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHW FRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWGLUHFWSUHPLHUREMHWj
O·DFFXVDWLI GXYHUEH"(-!´GRQQHUµUHSUpVHQWpLFLVRXVODIRUPHGXVXSLQ"($1>%jYDOHXUGLUHFWLYHL%$SDUWLUGHOj
LO\DXUDLWHXUpDQDO\VHSDUXQHWRXUQXUHDXSDVVLISHUVRQQHO*ODGLčW‫گ‬U̒VVHUDLWFRPSULVFRPPHOHVXMHWGXYHUEH
=6998G%GDWXPҸUҸ´TX·DOODLHQWrWUHGRQQpVGHVJODGLDWHXUVµ
,OHVWFODLUTXHOHVHPSORLVGHFHWWHSpULSKUDVHVRQWFHX[G·XQLQILQLWLIIXWXUSDVVLI
5>6LKJ2%31-41.#6%<P?;PON%A!>!)$6%I-6>#0#00!%$!d%l%d%>#+#%6>)!%(-5!)$1>%K8HH/*TA%/K/
 oi.uchicago.edu

:R<% A/3OZN8%FK\Y*

´6RXYLHQVWRLTXHWXDVSURPLV«TXHWRXWO·DUJHQWPHVHUDLWUHQGXµ

&pVDUS!..1>%4#?#.!3(!0(-%.6)5#10%&!..1>%HT3*TA%/K/%!]#0$#>()0%d´&pVDUHVWLPDQWTXHODJXHUUHVHUDLW
SURORQJpHSOXVORQJWHPSV«µ

M2&$;8F<A&A98;C8956A&>96?;9A89:;<A&F<ECF:;CQ><A&5BB<F8<A&=CF&><&>C896
'XSRLQWGHYXHGHODV\QWD[HGHVFDVOHODWLQRIIUHHQRXWUHSOXVLHXUVVLWXDWLRQVLQWpUHVVDQWHVGHPDQLqUH
JpQpUDOHSRXUODUpIOH[LRQOLQJXLVWLTXH
2QQRWHWRXWG·DERUGXQHUpJXODULVDWLRQGHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVFDVXHOOHVGHFHUWDLQVYHUEHVDQFLHQQHVHWKpUL
WpHVPDLVGHYHQXHVPLQRULWDLUHVHOOHVIXUHQWpOLPLQpHVDXSURILWGHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVXVXHOOHVPDMRULWDLUHV$LQVL
XQSHWLWJURXSHGHYHUEHVDQFLHQQHPHQWFRQVWUXLWVDYHFXQSUHPLHUREMHWjO·DEODWLILQVWUXPHQWDO ࡃWRU´XWLOLVHUµ
:-16-´MRXLUGHµ:1)56-%´V·DFTXLWWHUGHµHWF HXUHQWWHQGDQFHjSDVVHUjXQHFRQVWUXFWLRQDFFXVDWLYHQRWDPPHQW
HQODWLQWDUGLIRO·RQWURXYHIUpTXHPPHQWࡃWRUFRQVWUXLWDYHFXQSUHPLHUREMHWjO·DFFXVDWLI&HWWHWHQGDQFHjOD
WUDQVLWLYDWLRQGHVYHUEHVHQODWLQV·LQVFULWGDQVODWHQGDQFHGHVODQJXHVjODUpJXODULVDWLRQHWjO·DOLJQHPHQWGHV
IRUPHVUDUHVMXJpHVDQRPDOHVVXUOHVIRUPHVXVXHOOHVTXLGHYLHQQHQWODQRUPHHWpWHQGHQWOHXULQIOXHQFHSDU
DQDORJLH
2QSRXUUDLWpJDOHPHQWVHGHPDQGHUVLOHODWLQQHSRXUUDLWSDVLOOXVWUHUXQSKpQRPqQHPLVHQYDOHXUSDU
+DXGU\  VHORQOHTXHORQSHXWSDUIRLVWURXYHUXQHVHXOHGpVLQHQFHSDUV\QWDJPH³HWQRQSDVXQHGpVLQHQFH
SDUPRWFRQVWLWXWLIGHFHV\QWDJPH2QWURXYHHQHIIHWGDQVXQHLQVFULSWLRQODWLQHQRGX²9,,JVLqFOHWURXYpHj
&DHUHHQ(WUXULHO·pQRQFpVXLYDQW
(&2951$7,7$9(1',$60$0$5 &26  0 ('9+( 9+$.('
´-HVXLVOHSRWGH7LWD9HQGLD0DPDUFRVP·DIDEULTXpµ

6HORQO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQODSOXVYUDLVHPEODEOHODVpTXHQFH*/*<%T8BH/<7HVWXQV\QWDJPHDXJpQLWLIVLQJSRXU
XQDQWKURSRQ\PHIpPLQLQRODGpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLIVLQJILJXUHVHXOHPHQWVXUOHVHFRQGpOpPHQWT8BH/<72%M689%
YDXWDXVVLSRXUOHSUHPLHU*/*<F·HVWjGLUHSRXUO·HQVHPEOHGHODVpTXHQFHDQWKURSRQ\PLTXH
1RXVYRXGULRQVFRQFOXUHVXUO·LQWpUrWUHPDUTXDEOHGHODODQJXHODWLQHSRXUOHWKqPHGHOLQJXLVWLTXHJpQpUDOH
LFLWUDLWpFHTXLWLHQWjODULFKHVVHGHVPDWpULDX[RIIHUWVODYDULpWpHWO·DPSOHXUGHVWH[WHVHWGRFXPHQWVFRQVHUYpV
ODSRVVLELOLWpG·LQIpUHUGHVpWDWVGHODQJXHDQWpULHXUVJUkFHjO·H[LVWHQFHGH´ODQJXHVVRHXUVµGRQWOHVGRQQpHV
VRQWH[SORLWpHVSDUODJUDPPDLUHFRPSDUpHGHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVHQILQO·H[LVWHQFHGHVSURORQJDWLRQV
OLQJXLVWLTXHVTXHUHSUpVHQWHQWOHVODQJXHVURPDQHV3DUPLOHVODQJXHVDQFLHQQHVOHODWLQHVWDLQVLXQFKDPS
G·REVHUYDWLRQSULYLOpJLpSRXUO·pWXGHGHO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHSXLVTX·LOV·LQVFULWGDQVXQHFKDvQHOLQJXLVWLTXH
GHVLqFOHVGHSXLVOHVSUHPLqUHVLQVFULSWLRQVODWLQHV DX²9,,JVLqFOH MXVTX·jO·pSRTXHFRQWHPSRUDLQH

$QF7L9C8956
3/N% 36-I10%/)04-#I$#6)1>%N($#)(-1>²

QR
&HWWHLQVFULSWLRQHVWFRQVLGpUpHFRPPHGHODQJXHODWLQHGHSXLV 
3RFFHWWL
&ULVWRIDQL ² DORUVTX·HOOHpWDLWDXSDUDYDQWFRQVLGpUpH
FRPPHpWDQWpFULWHHQODQJXHIDOLVTXHGHSXLVVRQpGLWLRQSDU3HUX]]L
² FI3RFFHWWL
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%8*%QT,N\*/,B%N/BD\/7*/e\8%8B%N<*/B% :RR

`9Q>95?FC=49<
"789KFG6H82%06L7F
  ´/HSULPHLVFUL]LRQLODWLQHGHOO·(WUXULDµ,Q3(-($$!-#%!%"#::10#6)!%"!.%.($#)6%#)%!$h%(-4(#4(pGLWpSDU
(¬&DPSDQLOHSS²3LVH*LDUGLQL
)OHFN)UpGpULTXH
  /)$!--65($#6)2%466-"#)($#6)%!$%01&6-"#)($#6)g%.!%.($#)%X1#)&ROOHFWLRQ/LQJXDODWLQD3DULV3836
)UX\W0LFKqOH¬
% % ´/DV\QWD[HGHO·LQILQLWLIHQODWLQWDUGLIUpIOH[LRQVVXUODQDWXUHGHVSURFHVVXVpYROXWLIVµK!4+!-4+!0%
<1510$#)#!))!0%²
%  ´7KH'HYHORSPHQWRIWKH,QILQLWLYHLQ/DWH/DWLQµ,Q%@(I!-0%@-!0!)$!"%($%$+!%*9!.:$+%/)$!-)($#6)(.%36)M
:!-!)4!%6)%@($-#0$#4%7$1"#!02%O!."%#)%,]:6-"2%_ááspGLWpSDU(¬$/LYLQJVWRQHSS²6WXGLD3DWULV
WLFD+LVWRULFD7KHRORJLFDHW3KLORVRSKLFD&ULWLFDHW3KLORORJLFD/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
&  ´/DFRUUpODWLRQHQODWLQVRQU{OHGDQVODVXERUGLQDWLRQHWO·HQGRSKRUHµ,Q%<)(I+6-!2%4($(I+6-!%!$%
46--U.($#6)%!)%.($#)% $FWHVGHODMRXUQpHG·pWXGHGHOLQJXLVWLTXHODWLQH8QLYHUVLWp%ODLVH3DVFDO&OHU
PRQW)HUUDQG,,MDQYLHU pGLWpSDU&%RGHORWSS²&OHUPRQW)HUUDQG3UHVVHV8QLYHU
VLWDLUHV%ODLVH3DVFDO
  ´/DFRUUpODWLRQHQODWLQGpILQLWLRQHWGHVFULSWLRQµ,Q%7$-14$1-!0%I(-(..E.!0%!$%46--U.($#?!0%!)%5-!4%!$%
!)%.($#)% $FWHVGXFROORTXHGHOLQJXLVWLTXHJUHFTXHHWODWLQH%RUGHDX[²VHSWHPEUH 
pGLWpSDU3GH&DUYDOKRHW)/DPEHUWSS²6DLQWeWLHQQH3XEOLFDWLRQVGHO·8QLYHUVLWpGH
6DLQW(WLHQQH
'LI8J72%(LILJKKJ%
 % ´2UJDQLVDWLRQV\QWD[LTXHGHVFRPSOpPHQWVGHOLHXHWGHWHPSVHQODWLQDUFKDwTXHµ,QN($#)%N#)M
51#0$#40%()"%N#)51#0$#4%*+!6-'% 3URFHHGLQJVRIWKHVW,QWHUQDWLRQDO&ROORTXLXPRQ/DWLQ/LQJXLVWLFV
$PVWHUGDP$SULO pGLWpSDU+3LQNVWHUSS²6WXGLHVLQ/DQJXDJH&RPSDQLRQ6HULHV
$PVWHUGDP%HQMDPLQV
46EHF2%067E9J%
 % N(%>6-I+60')$(]!%"1%?!-&!%4+!G%D-U56#-!%"!%*61-0g%.!0%46)0$-14$#6)0%I(-$#4#I#(.!0%(&06.1!0'LSO{PH
G·eWXGHV$SSURIRQGLHVGHO·8QLYHUVLWpGH3DULV,9VRXWHQXHQVHSWHPEUHLQpGLW
jSDUDvWUH ´/HVFRQVWUXFWLRQVDEVROXHVFKH]*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVµ,Q<4$!0%"1%áE>!FROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDO´/DWLQYXOM
5(#-!M.($#)%$(-"#:ĵ8QLYHUVLWpGH/\RQ²VHSWHPEUH/\RQpGLWpSDU)%LYLOOH
*XpUDXG2FWDYH
  ´2VWUDFDJUHFVHWODWLQVGHO·:kGL)DZkNKLUµS1..!$#)%"!%.;/)0$#$1$%:-()R(#0%";(-4+U6.65#!%6-#!)$(.!%<ON%
²
+DXGU\-HDQ
  ´/HVHPSORLVGRXEOHVGXGDWLIHWODIRQFWLRQGXGDWLILQGRHXURSpHQµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0M
$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
  ´/·LQVWUXPHQWDOHWODVWUXFWXUHGHODSKUDVHVLPSOHHQLQGRHXURSpHQµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0M
$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
% OP@Q% ´3DUDWD[HK\SRWD[HFRUUpODWLRQGDQVODSKUDVHODWLQHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%
²
% OP@@% N;!>I.6#%"!0%4(0%!)%?U"#X1!g%#)$-6"14$#6)%h%.;U$1"!%"!0%4(0%!)%#)"6M!1-6IU!)/HV+RPPHVHWOHV/HWWUHV%
/\RQeGLWLRQVO·+HUPqV
  ´/DV\QWD[HGHVGpVLQHQFHVHQLQGRHXURSpHQµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%@RWON%
²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% A/3OZN8%FK\Y*

[6H9FH2%#F7J%
  ´7KH9RZHO6\VWHPVRI/DWH/DWLQµ,QN($#)%?1.5(#-!%q%N($#)%$(-"#:%T///% $FWHVGX9,,,JFROORTXHLQWHU
QDWLRQDOVXUOHODWLQYXOJDLUHHWWDUGLI2[IRUG²VHSWHPEUH pGLWpSDU5:ULJKWSS²
1HZ<RUN2OPV:HLGPDQQ
-OLFKHU$GROI
  /$(.(g%H(0%)!1!%*!0$(>!)$%#)%(.$.($!#)#04+!-%}&!-.#!:!-1)52%1F>LMJ%<N%P6+())!0M8?()5!.#1>%HUOLQ:DOWHU
GH*UX\WHU
.KQHU5DSKDHOHW&DUO6WHJPDQQ
% OPO<% <10:u+-.#4+!%D-(>>($#=%"!-%.($!#)#04+!)%7I-(4+!2%1F>LMJ%:N%7($G.!+-!pPHpG+DQQRYHU+DKQ
/HXPDQQ0DQX-HDQ%DSWLVW+RIPDQQHW$QWRQ6]DQW\U
  N($!#)#04+!%D-(>>($#=2%1F>LMJ%:N%7')$(]%1)"%7$#.#0$#=0XQLFK%HFN
0RUHDX0DGHOHLQH
% OPP@% ,!1?-!0%"!%7(#)$%<1510$#)2%1F>LMJ%OO2%567K%:N%.(%"64$-#)!%4+-U$#!))!3DULV%LEOLRWKqTXH$XJXVWLQLHQQH
,QVWLWXWG·eWXGHV$XJXVWLQLHQQHV
1HVWOH(EHUKDUGHW.XUW$ODQG
% OPPQ% B6?1>%*!0$(>!)$1>%D-(!4!%!$%N($#)!6WXWWJDUW'HXWVFKH%LEHOJHVHOOVFKDIW
5J77FK2%[J6H%
  ´/HIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGXV\VWqPHGHVFDVHQODWLQµK!?1!%"!%I+#.6.65#!²
3HUX]]L(PLOLR
  ´/·LVFUL]LRQHGL9HQGLDµA(#(²
3RFFHWWL3DROR
% :??R ´/HVLQVFULSWLRQVODWLQHVDUFKDwTXHVSUpOLWWpUDLUHVµFRQIpUHQFHjO·XQLYHUVLWpGH3DULV,96RUERQQH
GpFHPEUHLQpGLW
7RXUDWLHU&KULVWLDQ
  ´&RPPHQWGpILQLUOHVIRQFWLRQVV\QWD[LTXHV"µS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
  ´4XHOTXHVSULQFLSHVSRXUO·pWXGHGHVFDV DYHFDSSOLFDWLRQjO·DEODWLIODWLQ µN()5(5!0²
  ´$FFXVDWLIHWDQDO\VHHQPRUSKqPHVµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
 D ´1RWHVXUOHSDVVLIODWLQµN(.#!0
 E ´/·DFFXVDWLISUROHSWLTXHHQODWLQµN(.#!0²
  ´9DOHQFHYHUEDOHHWLQWUDQVLWLYDWLRQµ,QQ$1"!0%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%5U)U-(.!%!$%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%.($#)!%6::!-$!0%
!)%+6>>(5!%h%D1'%7!-&($SS²3DULV6RFLpWpSRXUO·,QIRUPDWLRQJUDPPDWLFDOH
% OPP<% 7')$(]!%.($#)!%LEOLRWKqTXHGHV&DKLHUVGHO·,QVWLWXWGHOLQJXLVWLTXHGH/RXYDLQ/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
  ´/HFDVHVWLOXQHXQLWpIRQFWLRQQHOOHOHJpQLWLIODWLQµLQH8%T7Tg%U$1"!0%"!%0')$(]!%.($#)!%6::!-$!0%!)%
+6>>(5!%h%A(-#10%N(?!)4'pGLWpSDU'/RQJUpHSS²%LEOLRWKqTXHGHV&DKLHUVGHO·,QVWLWXWGH
OLQJXLVWLTXHGH/RXYDLQ/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
9llQlQHQ9HLNNR
  /)$-6"14$#6)%(1%.($#)%?1.5(#-!qPHpG%LEOLRWKqTXH)UDQoDLVHHW5RPDQH6HULHV$0DQXHOVHWeWXGHV
/LQJXLVWLTXHV3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N<%3<7\<N/*Q%N<*/B8%8B%T<K/<*/,B%H/<7*K<*/e\8g%H\%@<KN8K%@,@\N</K8%ó%N<%H/3*/,B%@,Q*/e\8% :R@

!"
#$%&$'($#)*+%#$*),-%-,%.$/)$*)0,%1)$'*/$*)2(-3%%
1(%4$/#-/%404(#$)/-%5%#$%1)&*)0,%40+*)2(-

3(-6.!%F-'2%\)#?!-0#$U%"!%D!)E?!

!6%789:;<%=;8<=;>?@:;<%<A8%BC%>C<ACB@?D%BC?@E;
3RXUOHOLQJXLVWHTXLVHVRXFLHGHFDVXDOLWpOHODWLQHVWHQJpQpUDOOHOLHXG·H[DPHQG·XQHPRUSKRORJLHHWG·XQH
V\QWD[H/DPRUSKRORJLHV·\YRLWG·KDELWXGHO·REMHWG·XQHpWXGHGLDFKURQLTXH ODORUVTXHODV\QWD[HVXVFLWHSOX
W{WGHVDQDO\VHVV\QFKURQLTXHV:&RQVLGpUHUODFDVXDOLWpODWLQHHQSHUVSHFWLYHGLDVWUDWLTXHYRLUHGLDSKUDVWLTXH
F·HVWjGLUHVRXVO·DQJOHVRFLRORJLTXHHWVW\OLVWLTXHQ·HVWHQJpQpUDOSDVjO·RUGUHGXMRXUQ2UODFDVXDOLWpODWLQH
HVWDXVVLXQIDLWVRFLDOHPHQWGLVWLQFWLI

F6%'G>@GBGH@;%HDED?@IA;%JA%BC?@E
/HODWLQWHOTX·LOVHOLWGDQVOHVWH[WHVTXLOHSRUWHQWHVWXQHODQJXHG·DUWTXHVRQFDUDFWqUHpORLJQHDVVH]GH
O·XVDJHFRPPXQSRXUOXLUHWLUHUVRQFDUDFWqUHQDWXUHOPDLVVDQVSRXUDXWDQWHQIDLUHXQHODQJXHDUWLILFLHOOH
'€PHQWFRGLILpSDUO·pFROHGDQVVHVUqJOHVHWFRPSOH[LWpVOHODWLQOLWWpUDLUHVHJDJQHXQHGLVWDQFHTXLOHIRQGH
pJDOHPHQWFRPPHPDUTXHXUVRFLDO,OHQDFTXLHUWDLQVLXQVWDWXWGHGLVFULPLQDQWFXOWXUHOYRLUHGHFULWqUHFODVVDQW
HQQHGHYHQDQWSOXVDFFHVVLEOHjTXLQHO·DSDVDSSULVjIRQG,OHQJDJQHVXUWRXWFHWWHVWDELOLWpTXHOXLFRQIqUHQW
ODUpJXODWLRQQRUPDOLVDWULFHHWVDSUDWLTXHSDUXQHpOLWHFXOWXUHOOHPHQWFRQVHUYDWULFHDYLGHGHVLJQHVGHUHFRQ
QDLVVDQFHSpUHQQHV
&HWWHUpJXODULWpHWFHWWHFRPSOH[LWpV·pWDQWFRQVWUXLWHVVXUXQHYRORQWpG·DUWPDLVDXVVLGHFRQWUDVWHVRFLROR
JLTXH<LOQ·HVWJXqUHpWRQQDQWGHYRLUOHVWKpRULFLHQVDQFLHQVRSSRVHUELHQQHWWHPHQWHWDYHFXQHUpJXODULWpTXL
QHVHGpPHQWLUDMDPDLVOHFRUUHFWG·XQHFDWpJRULHVRFLDOHjO·LQFRUUHFWGHVRQPRQGHH[WpULHXU/·RSSRVLWLRQTXLVH
FUpHDLQVLDIIURQWHFRQWLQ€PHQWO·XVDJHGHVpOLWHVXUEDLQHVO·1-&()#$(0jFHOXLGHODFDPSDJQHOD-10$#4#$(02%>TL96IJ%
GHO·DXWRFKWRQLHGHODN($#)#$(0jFHOXLGHO·DOORJpQLHGHODI!-!5-#)#$(02RHWHQILQO·XVDJHGX1#-%&6)10%"#4!)"#%I!-#$10GH
O·KRPPHGRQWO·KDELOHWpODQJDJLqUHVHUqJOHVXUGHVTXDOLWpVPRUDOHVjFHOXLGHO·LQFXOWXUHSRSXODLUHHWGpEUDLOOpH
GX0!->6%I.!&!#10(QpWHQGDQWjO·HQWLHUGHODODQJXHOHVWHUPHVPrPHVG·XQGpEDWDQWLTXHRULJLQDLUHPHQWOLPLWp
jGHODPRUSKRORJLH@%RQSHXWDIILUPHUVDQVVHWURPSHUTXHODUpJXODULWpOLQJXLVWLTXHGHO·()(.65#(DULVWRFUDWLTXH
DYDLQFXO·()6>(.#(GHSDUOHUVSRSXODLUHVTXHVHXOVDQFWLRQQHO·LFLHWPDLQWHQDQWGHODSDUROHVSRQWDQpH&pVDU
OHSDWULFLHQVRQWUDLWpH!%()(.65#(HWVDUHFRPPDQGDWLRQGHIXLUO·#)(1"#$1>%($X1!%#)06.!)0%1!-&1>2F·HVWjGLUHOD
SDUROHQpRORJLTXHHWDQRPDOHI€WHOOHVDQFWLILpHG·DUFKDwVPHHQVRQWOHFODLUWpPRLJQDJH
/DODQJXHG·DUWODWLQHVHPRQWUHDLQVLFRPPHXQSURGXLWpODERUpGDQVXQHYRORQWpGHFRQWUDVWHYLVjYLVGH
SDUOHUVFRQoXVFRPPHGpYDORULVDQWVTXHOVTX·LOVVRLHQW'HFHSRLQWGHYXHIRUFHHVWGHFRQVWDWHUTXHOHODWLQ
YXOJDLUHQ·HVWHQULHQFRPPHRQO·DORQJWHPSVFUXXQDEkWDUGLVVHPHQWGXODWLQGLW´FODVVLTXHµ%LHQDXFRQWUDLUH
VRXVTXHOTXHYDULDQWHTX·RQOHVDLVLVVH POHODWLQGHO·RUDOLWpYXOJDLUHDSSDUDvWFRPPHODQRUPHVWDWLVWLTXHOD
ODQJXHGHODWUqVpFUDVDQWHPDMRULWpGHVORFXWHXUV&HWWHLQYHUVLRQGHODSHUVSHFWLYHVRFLROLQJXLVWLTXHSHUPHW

O
.KQHUHW+RO]ZHLVVLJ²/HXPDQQ²0HLVHU R
5RVpQ²
² 
0OOHUD
:
.KQHUHW6WHJPDQ²+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U² @
&DUGDXQV²
7RXUDWLHU²6HUEDW 
$XOX*HOOHB64$!0%<$$#4(!
Q
9llQlQHQ² P
9llQlQHQ²0OOHUE
<
5RVpQ²

:R@
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<K,N8%FKY

G·DSHUFHYRLUOHODWLQGLW´OLWWpUDLUHµFRPPHXQHGpULYDWLRQGHVSDUOHUVSRSXODLUHVUHQGXHGLVWLQFWHGHFHX[FL
SDUVpOHFWLRQUDWLRQDOLVDWLRQHWFRPSOH[LILFDWLRQ3OXVSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWDIIHFWpjO·H[SUHVVLRQDUWLVWLTXHOHODWLQ
OLWWpUDLUHGHYLHQWGHFHIDLWXQHODQJXHWHFKQLTXHSDUPLG·DXWUHV/·LPSUHVVLRQGHJpQpUDOLWpTXHGRQQHVRQ
RPQLSUpVHQFHHVWXQDUWHIDFWUpVXOWDQWGXPRGHGHWUDQVPLVVLRQDQWLTXHHWPpGLpYDOGXODWLQDQFLHQTXLSDUVD
QDWXUHPrPHDDVVXUpODVDXYHJDUGHGHVVHXOVGRFXPHQWVpFULWVHWGRQFUpGLJpVSDUGHVOHWWUpVGDQVXQHODQJXH
pORLJQpHGHO·RUDOLWp
,OLPSRUWHGqVORUVGHGLVWLQJXHUFODLUHPHQWOHODWLQGLW´OLWWpUDLUHµGXODWLQGLW´FODVVLTXHµ/HODWLQOLWWpUDLUH
HVWODODQJXHWHFKQLTXHGHO·H[SUHVVLRQDUWLVWLTXH,OQDvWHQPrPHWHPSVTXHODOLWWpUDWXUHDXPLOLHXGXWURL
VLqPHVLqFOHDYDQW-&GHO·HIIRUWGHFUpDWLRQGHVpFULYDLQVHWGHUDWLRQDOLVDWLRQGHVJUDPPDLULHQV FILQIUD† 
HWVHVXUYLYUDDXVVLORQJWHPSVTXHGHVORFXWHXUVQDWLIVRXQRQVHURQWFDSDEOHVGHO·XWLOLVHU/HODWLQFODVVLTXH
HVWTXDQWjOXLXQHIRUPHSDUWLFXOLqUHGXODWLQOLWWpUDLUHWHOTX·LOHVWDWWHVWpHQWUHOHSUHPLHUVLqFOHDYDQW-&HW
ODSUHPLqUHPRLWLpGXSUHPLHUVLqFOHDSUqV-&/HODWLQOLWWpUDLUHFHOXLG·XQHFDWpJRULHGHORFXWHXUVGRLWGRQF
V·HQYLVDJHUG·XQSRLQWGHYXHGLDVWUDWLTXHDORUVTXHOHODWLQFODVVLTXHFHOXLG·XQHpSRTXHQHSHXWV·DSSUpKHQGHU
TXHGLDFKURQLTXHPHQW

K6%$<=;>?<%=LGEGBGH@IA;<%HDED8CAM%J;%BC%>C<ACB@?D%BC?@E;
/DSKRQRORJLHRIIUHXQERQPR\HQG·DSSURFKHUODFDVXDOLWpODWLQHDXWUDYHUVGHVHVYDULDWLRQVGLDVWUDWLTXHV
2QVDLWHQHIIHWTXHOHVSDUOHUVSRSXODLUHVODWLQVVHGLVWLQJXHQWSDUXQHVRXVDUWLFXODWLRQTXLSDUGpVRFFOXVLRQV
VXFFHVVLYHVDERXWLWQRWDPPHQWjXQDPXwVVHPHQWGHVpOpPHQWVV\OODELTXHVSRVWWRQLTXHV O?&HSKpQRPqQHHVWHQ
JpQpUDOFRQVLGpUpGXVWULFWSRLQWGHYXHWDUGLISXLVTXHF·HVWjOXLTXHO·RQGRLWFHWWHGLVSDULWLRQGXV\VWqPHFDVXHO
TXLIHUDO·DYqQHPHQWURPDQG·XQPDUTXDJHV\QWD[LTXHSDUXQHUqJOHWDFWLTXH2UOHSKpQRPqQHGHO·DPXwVVHPHQW
HWGHODGpVRFFOXVLRQHQJpQpUDOHVWDQFLHQHWHQWRXWFDVFRH[WHQVLIjO·HQWLHUGHODGXUpHGHYLHGXODWLQYLYDQW
LOHVWLQWLPHPHQWOLpjODSUpVHQFHG·XQDFFHQWTXHODODQJXHSRSXODLUHQ·DMDPDLVFRQQXTXHWRQLTXH'HSXLV
WRXMRXUVDVVH]SXLVVDQWSRXUGpYLWDOLVHUOHVRFFOXVLRQVTXLOXLpWDLHQWSpULSKpULTXHVFHWDFFHQWV·HVWILQDOHPHQW
LPSRVpGDQVOHFRXUDQWGXWURLVLqPHVLqFOHDSUqV-&SDUXQJDLQHQLQWHQVLWpOO,OHQGHYLQWFDSDEOHGHGpWUXLUH
QRQVHXOHPHQWOHV\VWqPHTXDQWLWDWLIGHODYR\HOOHGXODWLQPDLVDXVVLVRQV\VWqPHFDVXHOGRQWOHVGpVLQHQFHV
SRVWWRQLTXHVSDUODQpFHVVLWpG·XQHODQJXHGpSRXUYXHG·DFFHQWVR[\WRQVQ·DYDLHQWULHQSRXUVHJDUDQWLUGHOXL

N6%.C8@CE>;%=LGEGBGH@IA;%;?%J@C<?8C?@<O;
$O·pSRTXHDUFKDwTXHOHODWLQOLWWpUDLUHHQGHYHQLUSHXWDLQVLDGPHWWUHO·DPXwVVHPHQWG·XQHFRQVRQQHILQDOH
TXHOHODWLQOLWWpUDLUHFODVVLTXHVDXYHUDFRPPHHQWpPRLJQHO·H[HPSOHR"!"!YDXWSRXU"!"#$RXQHVDXYHUD
SDVFRPPHGDQVO·H[HPSOH>@RI-(#"("FRQVHUYHXQM"GpVLQHQWLHOTXHOHODWLQOLWWpUDLUHDEDQGRQQHUD8QDXWUH
WpPRLQGHFHJHQUHGHYDULDQFHHVWIRXUQLSDUODFRQFXUUHQFHTXLRSSRVHV\QFKURQLTXHPHQWODIRUPHDPXwH"!"!%
FI>@ jVDIRUPHFRPSOqWH"!"!$ FI>@ 

 >@ 3/N%*:&3ODFHQWLXV+HU)0DUWHGRQX"!"! "!"#$  7LEXU,,,JW**JVLqFOH

  &DLXV3ODFHQWLXVDGRQQpXQHRIIUDQGHj0DUV

 >@ 3/N%*:)XULR&IWULEXQRVPLOLWDUHGHSUDLGDG I-(!"( )RUWXQH"!"!$ 7XVFXOXP,,,J%

VLqFOH
% % 3(#10%F1-#102%$-#&1)%>#.#$(#-!2%(%"6))U%^4!.(`%h%.(%F6-$1)!%!)%.!%I-!)()$%01-%.!%&1$#)L

'DQVOHGRPDLQHQRPLQDOOHVSKpQRPqQHVGHFHJHQUHVXUDERQGHQW/HVH[HPSOHV>@HW>@GDWpVGXPLOLHX
GXWURLVLqPHVLqFOHDYDQW-&O:%MFHK7JHK%LH%36-)!.#6YDODQWSRXUOHQRPLQDWLI36-)!.#10GHV1#-62%74#I#6)!2%36-0#4(2%
<.!-#(2%1-&!%JK%(#"!PLVSRXUOHVDFFXVDWLIV1#-1>ò%74#I#6)!>2%36-0#4(>2%<.!-#(>2%1-&!>%JK%(!"!>2%JK%JHG8H%LH%"16)6-6%
TXHOHODWLQOLWWpUDLUHYRXGUDVRXVODIRUPHGXJpQLWLI&6)6-1>

O?
9llQlQHQ O:
(UQRXW
OO
1RUEHUJ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N<%3<7\<N/*Q%N<*/B8%8B%T<K/<*/,B%H/<7*K<*/e\8g%H\%@<KN8K%@,@\N</K8%ó%N<%H/3*/,B%@,Q*/e\8% :RP

 >@ 3/N%*:%
/36-)!.#6/I6FLSLR%
DLGLOHVFRVROFHVRU%
N14#10%36-)!.#10%74#I#6)2%U"#.!2%46)01.2%4!)0!1-

 >@ 3/N%*:2%PN%
+RQFRLQRSORLUXPHFRVHQWLRQW5>RPDH@%
GXRQRURRSWXPRIXLVH1#-6%
/XFLRP74#I#6)!ILOLRV%DUEDWL%
FRQVROFHQVRUDLGLOLVKLFIXHWD>SXGXRV@%
KHFFHSLW36-0#4(%<.!-#(%TXH1-&!%
GHGHWWHPSHVWDWHEXV(#"!PHUHWR>G"@
% % /DWLQOLWWpUDLUH+XQFXQXPSOXULPLFRQVHQWLXQW5RPDH%RQRUXPRSWLPXPIXLVVHXLUXP
XLURUXP" /XFLXP6FLSLRQHP)LOLXV%DUEDWL&RQVXOFHQVRUDHGLOLVKLFIXLWDSXGXRV
+LFFHSLW&RUVLFDP$OHULDPTXHXUEHP'HGLW7HPSHVWDWLEXVDHGHPPHULWR
% % <%K6>!2%.(%I.1I(-$%"!0%5!)0%0;(446-"!%01-%.!%:(#$%X1;#.%:1$%.;+6>>!%.!%>!#..!1-%"!%$6102%.1#2%N14#10%74#I#6)L%
F#.0%"!%S(-&($102%#.%:1$%(1I-E0%"!%?610%46)01.2%4!)0!1-2%U"#.!L%/.%I-#$%.(%36-0!%!$%.(%?#..!%";<.U-#(L%3;!0$%
h%c10$!%$#$-!%X1;#.%(%"6))U%1)%$!>I.!%(1]%*!>Iz$!0L

2QQRWHUDO·LQVWDELOLWpG·XQHSKRQRORJLHGpMjDUFKDwVDQWHTXLDXWRULVHHQFRUHHQFRQWLJXwWpXQJURXSHPRU
SKRORJLTXHPHQWLQKRPRJqQHWHON14#6>%74#I#6)!XQVHJPHQWjO·DFFXVDWLITXHOHOLWWpUDLUHH[LJHUDVRXVODIRUPH
QRUPDOLVpHN14#1>%74#I#6)!>4XDQWDXM0%JK%6L%M>GpVLQHQWLHOVLOVRQWEHDXrWUHODELOHVLOUHVWHTXHODODQJXHG·DUW
OHVSUpVHUYHUDDYHFVRLQH[FHSWLRQIDLWHGHODSRpVLHGHODQJXHFODVVLTXHTXLFRPPH6-($#6%1#)4$(%GRQWO·6-)($10%
GRLWEHDXFRXSjODODQJXHRUDOH OQDXWRULVHUDO·pOLVLRQGXM>ILQDOPDLVSDVFHOXLGXM0ILQDOUHVVHQWLHFRPPH
DUFKDwTXHRXDSUqV&DWXOOHFRPPHDUFKDwVDQWHO<
,OHVWVLJQLILFDWLIGHODYDOHXUFODVVDQWHG·XQHSURQRQFLDWLRQTX·LOIDXWTXDOLILHUG·RUWKRpSLTXHTXHOHVHQWLPHQW
G·XQHGLVSDULWLRQIDXWLYHPrPHQRQGpVLQHQWLHOOHDJLWHOHVORFXWHXUVSHXIDPLOLHUVGXSDUOHUGHO·pOLWHURPDLQH
3DUIRUFHFHVHQWLPHQWVXVFLWHUDGHVK\SHUXUEDQLVPHVWHOFHOXLEURFDUGpSDUO·XUEDLQ&DWXOOH>@TXLVHJDXVVH
G·XQ$UULXVVRXFLHX[GHIDLUHRXEOLHUGHVRULJLQHVVDQVGRXWHSD\VDQQHV>@

 >@ &DWXOOH%
3+6>>6"(%GLFHEDWVLTXDQGR46>>6"(%LJ>>JK%
GLFHUHHW#)0#"#(0%!778L9%+#)0#"#(02%
HWWXPPLULILFHVSHUDEDWVHHVVHORFXWXP%
FXPTXDQWXPSRWHUDWGL[HUDW+#)0#"#(0
  $UULXVGLVDLW´FKRPPRGHVµTXDQGLOYRXODLWGLUH´FRPPRGHVµHW´KHPE€FKHVµSRXU´HPE€FKHVµHW
#.%!0IU-(#$%(?6#-%I-6)6)4U%>!-?!#..!10!>!)$%X1()"%#.%(?(#$%(II1'U%"!%$61$!0%0!0%:6-4!0%01-%.;+%"!%
´KHPE€FKHVµ

 >@ $XOX*HOOHB64$!0%<$$#4(!5XVWLFXVILWVHUPRVLDGVSLUHVSHUSHUDP
  7DSURQRQFLDWLRQVHPDUTXHFRPPHSD\VDQQHVLWXSODFHVPDOWHVDVSLUDWLRQV

&DWXOOHHVWGHFHVSRqWHVG·XQPLOLHXGXSUHPLHUVLqFOHDYDQW-&ELHQUHSUpVHQWDWLIGHODPRXYDQFHPRGHU
QLVWHHWSXULVWHTXLDFRQWULEXpjH[SXUJHUODODQJXHSRpWLTXHGHFHVIUDJPHQWVG·RUDOLWpDQFLHQQHDX[TXHOVXQ
SRqWHDUFKDwVDQWFRPPH/XFUqFHTXLHVWSRXUWDQWO·H[DFWFRQWHPSRUDLQGH&DWXOOHDWWULEXHHQFRUHFHWWHYDOHXU
RUQHPHQWDOHTXHORXHWDQWXQFRQVHUYDWHXUFRPPH&LFpURQ3HUoXHFRPPHSD\VDQQHSDUOHVSXULVWHVO·DEVHQFH
G·DVSLUpHQHIDLWSRXUWDQWTXHSHUSpWXHUO·KDELWXGHDUFKDwTXHORF·HVWjGLUHRUDOHGHQHSDVODUpDOLVHUGHYDQW
XQHFRQVRQQH&HUWHV$UULXVLJQRUHFHWWHSUpFLVLRQSXLVTX·LODVSLUHDYDQWXQHYR\HOOHFHTXLDFFHQWXHHQFRUH
OHFRPLTXHG·K\SHUXUEDQLVPHPDLVLOHVWGHIDLWTX·LODODQHWWHFRQVFLHQFHTXHO·DULVWRFUDWLHXUEDLQHGpVLUHXVH

OQ
)U\ &LFpURQN;6-($!1-%HW1LHGHUPDQQ†9llQlQHQ
OR

O<
9llQlQHQ²HW1LHGHUPDQQ† HW†
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<K,N8%FKY

G·KHOOpQLVHUVDSURQRQFLDWLRQSRXUODGLIIpUHQFLHUGHFHOOHGXSHXSOHVRXVDUWLFXOpHDGpVRUPDLVSULVO·KDELWXGH
GHVXUDUWLFXOHUODVLHQQH FILQIUD† ,OIDXWFHSHQGDQWGLUHjVDGpFKDUJHTXHOHVODWLQVHX[PrPHVQ·RQWMDPDLV
UpXVVLjGpFLGHUGHO·DVSLUDWLRQSUpYRFDOLTXHGHPRWVWUqVEDQDOVWHOV + (-!)(´VDEOHµRX + 1>6-´OLTXLGHµYRLUH
+ 1>!-10´pSDXOHµHWTXHELHQSOXVWDUGSUREDEOHPHQWYHUVOHFLQTXLqPHVLqFOHOHJUDPPDLULHQDQRQ\PHGHO·<IM
I!)"#]%@-6&#VHVHQWLUDREOLJpGHUDSSHOHUO·RUWKRGR[LHjGHVORFXWHXUVTXLV·DEDQGRQQHQWSDUWURSjO·DPXwVVHPHQW

 >@ <II!)"#]%@-6&#+RVWLDHQRQRVWLDHL
% % ´+RVWLDHµHWQRQSDV´RVWLDHµ

P6%.C8@CE>;%=LGEGBGH@IA;%;?%@E>;8?@?AJ;%QGE>?@GEE;BB;
6LOHVWUDLWVGpVRFFOXVLIVSURSUHVjXQHRUDOLWpPpSULVpHGLVSDUDLVVHQWPDVVLYHPHQWGHODODQJXHG·DUWLOVYRQW
FHSHQGDQWVXEVLVWHUHWPrPHV·DPSOLILHUGDQVOHVSDUOHUVSRSXODLUHVVRXVO·HIIHWGXUHQIRUFHPHQWGHO·DFFHQW
G·LQWHQVLWpTXLVXUYLHQWGDQVOHFRXUDQWGXWURLVLqPHVLqFOH FIVXSUD† /HVLQVFULSWLRQVSDULpWDLUHVGH3RP
SpLGpWUXLWHOHDR€WDSUqV-&HQWpPRLJQHQWG·DERQGDQFHGqVDYDQWOHWURLVLqPHVLqFOH3DUPLG·DXWUHV
PDUTXHVG·DPXwVVHPHQWRQ\REVHUYH >@>@ O·HIIDFHPHQWGpMjSOXVRXPRLQVDERXWLGHV\OODEHVSRVWWRQLTXHV
HWGpVLQHQWLHOOHVVXVFHSWLEOHVGHUHQGUHO·LGHQWLILFDWLRQFDVXHOOHSUREOpPDWLTXH%

 >@ 3/N,96XFFHVVXVWH[WRUDPDW&RSRQLDHVDQFLOOD P 
  /HWLVVHUDQG6XFFHVVXVDLPHODVHUYDQWHGH&RSRQLD

 >@ 3/N,9$GSRUWD P 5RPDQD P 

% % ó%.(%@6-$!%K6>(#)!

0DLVFHVFRQIXVLRQVV·REVHUYHQWDLOOHXUVHWQDWXUHOOHPHQWSOXVWDUGFRPPHGDQVODWDEOHWWHG·H[pFUDWLRQ>@
WURXYpHj0LQWXUQDHGDQVOHVXGGX/DWLXPHWTXLGDWHGXGpEXWGX,,JVLqFOHDYDQW-&

 >@ 3/N;'LLLIHULXRELVFRPHGRLOLXVPHPUDFRORUHILFXUDFDSXWFDSLOODXPUDFHUHEUX
IUXWH« $XGROOHQW
  /DWLQOLWWpUDLUH´'LLLQIHULXRELVFRPPHQGRLOOLXVPHPEUDFRORUHPILJXUDPFDSXWFDSLOORV
XPEUDPFHUHEUXPIURQWHPµ
% % H#!1]%#):!-)(1]2%c!%?610%46):#!%0!0%>!>&-!02%06)%$!#)$2%06)%?#0(5!2%0(%$z$!2%0(%4+!?!.1-!2%06)%6>&-!2%06)%
4!-?!(12%06)%:-6)$L

&HVFRQIXVLRQVVRQWjODIRLVOHVVLJQHVHWOHVFDXVHVG·XQHGpEkFOHIRQFWLRQQHOOHTXLV·REVHUYHGpMjVXUOHVPXUV
SRPSpLHQV>@2QODFUpGLWHUDQRQVHXOHPHQWjODGLVSDULWLRQGHPRUSKqPHVFDVXHOVDPXwVO@PDLVDXVVLjXQH
LQFDSDFLWpFURLVVDQWHGHVORFXWHXUVYXOJDLUHVjUHFRQQDvWUHGHVIRQFWLRQVGHUULqUHGHVFDV$LQVLGDQVO·LQVFULSWLRQ
VXLYDQWH46)1!)$1SHXWrWUHXQDEODWLIORFDWLIQRQDPXwPDLVIDXWLIRXXQDFFXVDWLIFRUUHFWPDLVDPXw

 >@ 3/N,9,QFRQXHQWX P XHQL%

P!%01#0%?!)1%h%.(%-U1)#6)

&HWWHLQFHUWLWXGHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHYDG·DERUGSURYRTXHUODGpVXpWXGHGHVFDVFLUFRQVWDQFLHOVVRLWGX
JpQLWLIGXGDWLIHWGHO·DEODWLIDXSURILWGHVFDVDFWDQWLHOVVRLWGXQRPLQDWLIHWGHO·DFFXVDWLIOHVIXWXUVFDVVXMHW
HWFDVUpJLPHGXURPDQ&HWWHpYROXWLRQV·DSHUoRLWQRWDPPHQWGDQVO·pYROXWLRQG·XQVHJPHQWH[WUDSRVpG·LQWHU
SUpWDWLRQIRQFWLRQQHOOHDUGXHWHOFHOXLGLW´DEODWLIDEVROXµ)RQFWLRQQHOOHPHQWRSDTXHORUVTX·LOHVWjXQDEODWLI
SDUQDWXUHSRO\VpPLTXHHWLQWULQVqTXHPHQWDPELJXHWSHXDFFXHLOODQWjXQJpQLWLITX·DIIHFWLRQQHOHJUHF>@
PDLVTXHOHORFXWHXUSRSXODLUHQHFRPSUHQGJXqUHPLHX[TXHO·DEODWLIFHOXLFLVHIL[HUDjXQDFFXVDWLI>@SDUIRLV
FRQFXUUHQFpSDUOHQRPLQDWLI>@OP


9llQlQHQ² 
9llQlQHQ²
O@
9llQlQHQ² OP
)U\
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N<%3<7\<N/*Q%N<*/B8%8B%T<K/<*/,B%H/<7*K<*/e\8g%H\%@<KN8K%@,@\N</K8%ó%N<%H/3*/,B%@,Q*/e\8% 

 >@ 3V&DHVDUS!..1>%O#0I()#41>8#10%I-(!$!-#$#%$!>I6-#02%5FM=J8L9%K76H9%G>LMJH%$6>9LM%
FDVWHOOXPFRQVWLWXLW
% % 3!%$!>I0%('()$%I(00U2%@6>IU!%U$(&.#$%1)!%I.(4!%:6-$!%(1M"!.h%"1%7(.01> :?%

 >@ 3/N%1***2%<Q@:N%5J7%ML>KLM%KJM=F789%8HKJ7L6>>LM2%-!.#X1#(0%46..!4$(0WXPXOXPWLELFRQVWLWXL
% % <I-E0%1)%.6)5%.(I0%"!%$!>I02%$!0%-!0$!0%('()$%U$U%-(00!>&.U02%c!%$;(#%U.!?U%1)%$6>&!(1L

 >@ &DUPLQD/DWLQD(SLJUDSKLFD&XL46)#1]%>6-#!)02QRQIXLWDOWHUDPRU%
e1#%);!1$2%(1%"U4E0%"!%06)%46)c6#)$2%";(1$-!%(>61-

'HVWpPRLQVSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWVLJQLILFDWLIVG·XQHHUUDQFHIRQFWLRQQHOOHGXHDXGpFRXSODJHGXPRUSKRORJLTXH
HWGXV\QWD[LTXHVRQWOHVVLWXDWLRQVGHPL[LWpFDVXHOOHDXVHLQG·XQVHJPHQWGHV\QWD[HXQLWDLUH'qVOHTXDWULqPH
VLqFOHDSUqV-&HWGDQVGHVpQRQFpVRXQHpJDOLVDWLRQSDUDPXwVVHPHQW>@QHSHXWrWUHDOOpJXpHOHORFXWHXU
Q·DXUDDLQVLQXOVFUXSXOHjPrOHUDFFXVDWLIHWDEODWLIDXVHLQG·XQHPrPHSKUDVH>@YRLUHPrPHDXVHLQG·XQ
PrPHVHJPHQW>@RVHSHXYHQWpJDOHPHQWUHQFRQWUHUHQFRSUpVHQFHXQJpQLWLIHWXQDEODWLI>@

 >@ @!-!5-#)($#6%<!$+!-#(!$FVLFHUJR1#0(%.64(%0()4$(%6>)#(% DFF %TXDHGHVLGHUDXLPXV>«@1#0#0%

!$#(>%!$%0()4$#0%1#-#0 DEO %TXL%LELFRPPRUDEDQWXULQQRPLQH'HLUHJUHVVLVXPXVLQ)DUDQ
% % *610%.!0%.#!1]%0(#)$0%X1!%)610%"U0#-#6)0%('()$%U$U%?102%!$%.!0%0(#)$0%+6>>!0%X1#%'%-U0#"(#!)$%('()$%(100#%
U$U%?102%(1%)6>%"!%H#!12%)610%06>>!0%-!?!)10%h%@+(-()

 >@ /RQJREDUGRUXPDFWDSK!5)()$! DEO %"6>#)10 QRP %N!6I-()"6 DEO XLUR

H[FHOOHQWLVVLPRUHJHLQ,WDOLD%
% % N!%0!#5)!1-%-6#%N!6I-()"10%-U5)()$2%1)%+6>>!%X1#%:1$%1)%$-E0%!]4!..!)$%-6#%!)%/$(.#!L

 >@ $FWD3HWUL@.()5!)$#1>% JpQ %(1$!>%6>)#&10 DEO SHUXHQLWLQPXOWLWXGLQHP%

  0DLVWRXVSOHXUDQWLOSDUYLQWDXPLOLHXGHODIRXOH

R6%4LGED?@IA;%;?%<SE?CM;%;E%OC8IA;A8<%<G>@CAM
'DQVFHWWHDPELDQFHGHFRQIXVLRQDUWLFXODWRLUHHWIRQFWLRQQHOOHO·HVSULWTXLSUpVLGHjO·pODERUDWLRQGXODWLQ
OLWWpUDLUHYDLQVSLUHUjVHVXWLOLVDWHXUVXQVRXFLGLVWLQFWLIVXIILVDPPHQWSXLVVDQWHWFRQVHUYDWLISRXUGRQQHUjOD
FDVXDOLWpXQHYDOHXUGHPDUTXDJHQRQJUDPPDWLFDOG·DXWDQWSOXVSXLVVDQWHTXHFHOOHFLWHQGUDGDYDQWDJHjVH
SHUGUHGDQVOHVSDUOHUVSRSXODLUHV
$YDQWG·rWUHDUWLFXODWRLUHFHPDUTXDJHHVWG·DERUGDIIpUHQWjXQHPLVHHQYDOHXUSDUWLFXOLqUHGXOLHQV\Q
WD[LTXH(QHIIHWRQFUpGLWHHQJpQpUDOjO·DPXwVVHPHQWO·HQWLHUGHODUHVSRQVDELOLWpGHODGLVSDULWLRQFDVXHOOH:O%
0DLVTXLFRQTXHDpWXGLpOHODWLQVDLWELHQTXHVDGLIILFXOWpOXLYLHQWDXVVLG·XQHPRUSKRORJLHGpVLQHQWLHOOHQRPLQDOH
UHQGXHDPELJXsSDUVDVRXVGpWHUPLQDWLRQPRUSKRORJLTXHF·HVWjGLUHDVVH]SDXYUHSRXUTX·XQHPXOWLWXGHGH
FDVGHJHQUHVHWGHQRPEUHVSXLVVHQWV·LQFDUQHUGDQVXQHPrPHGpVLQHQFH2QVDLWDVVXUpPHQWTXHG·XQHPrPH
GpFOLQDLVRQXQ"6>#)6SHXWrWUHXQGDWLIHWWURLVVRUWHVG·DEODWLIVPDLVDXVVLTXHGHVPRWVDSSDUWHQDQWjGHV
GpFOLQDLVRQVGHW\SHVYDULpVRQWIUDSSpVGXPrPHWUDYHUV$LQVL-60(!%FL%X1(!SHXYHQWrWUHjGHVFDVGHVJHQUHV
HWGHVQRPEUHVWUqVGLIIpUHQWV,OHQYDGHPrPHGH"6>#)102%>()102%46-I102%"#1#)#$10HWGH"6>#)#2%X1#2%46)01.#2%
>(-#HWGH4()6-1>2%&6)6-1>HWGH-60(2%$!>I.(HWGH4#1#02%"6>#)#0HWGH"6>#)!2%.!1!2%:6-$!HWGH>#0!-2%:6-$#$!-2%#$!-%
HWO·RQSRXUUDLWSRXUVXLYUH0DvWULVHUDFWLYHPHQWHWSDVVLYHPHQWOHODWLQOLWWpUDLUHUHTXpUDLWSDUFRQVpTXHQWXQH
FDSDFLWpGHGpVDPELJXwVDWLRQUHQGXHGHSOXVHQSOXVDUGXHjPHVXUHTXHOHQLYHDXGHODGLFWLRQV·pOHYDLW,OHVW
VLJQLILFDWLITXHO·K\SHUEDWH::HWGDQVXQHPRLQGUHPHVXUHO·DQDVWURSKHTXLGLVORTXHQWOHOLHQWDFWLTXHHWREVFXU
FLVVHQWOHVHQVV·LPSRVHQWDYHFIRUFHGDQVODSRpVLHGHTXHOTXHpOpYDWLRQ :Q,OQ·HVWTXHGHFRPSDUHUXQH[WUDLWGH
SRpVLHpSLTXHFODVVLTXH>@DYHFFHTX·LOGHYLHQGUDLWYUDLVHPEODEOHPHQWVRXVXQHIRUPHTXLYRXGUDLWXQRUGUH
GHVPRWVGpMjSURWRURPDQWHOTXHOHORFXWHXUYXOJDLUHFRPPHQFHjOHSUDWLTXHUGqVOHSUHPLHUVLqFOHGHQRWUH

:?
9RLUDXVVL)U\ ::
'HYLQHHW6WHSKHQV²
:O
9llQlQHQ† :Q
5RVpQ)U\jSDUDvWUH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<K,N8%FKY

qUHF·HVWjGLUHGqVTXHO·DPXwVVHPHQWVHIDLWDVVH]UDYDJHXUSRXUTXHOHPDUTXDJHV\QWD[LTXHQHVHVRLWSOXV
PRUSKRORJLTXHPDLVWDFWLTXH>@

 >@ 2YLGHA!$(>6-I+60!0²
  1RQGXPFDHVDVXLVSHUHJULQXPXWXLVHUHWRUEHP%
PRQWLEXVLQOLTXLGDVSLQXVGHVFHQGHUDWXQGDV
% % N!%I#)%461IU%);U$(#$%I(0%!)46-!%"!04!)"1%"!%0!0%>6)$(5)!0%c10X1!%"()0%.!0%!(1]%4.(#-!0%I61-%0;!)%(..!-%
?#0#$!-%.!%>6)"!%U$-()5!-L

 >@ /DWLQRUDO3LQXVFDHVDVXLVPRQWLEXVQRQGXPGHVFHQGHUDWLQDTXDVOLTXLGDVXWXLVHUHWRUEHP
SHUHJULQXP

9LVjYLVG·XQHSRSXODWLRQTXLVRLWQ·XVHSOXVGHODFDVXDOLWpSDUOHGpIDXWGHVDUpDOLVDWLRQSKRQpWLTXHVRLW
Q·HQVDLVLWSOXVOHVYDOHXUVIRQFWLRQQHOOHVFRPPHFHODV·REVHUYHGDQVOHVVHJPHQWVH[WUDSRVpVjO·DEODWLIGLW
´DEVROXµ FIVXSUD† O·pOLWHOHWWUpHYDV·DWWDFKHUjXQXVDJHGHODFDVXDOLWpTX·HOOHSRXVVHUDDXSOXVSUpFLVGH
VRQLQWULQVqTXHDPELJXwWp

T6%/DC>?@GE%C8@<?G>8C?@IA;%U%BC%JD<G>>BA<@GE%=G=ABC@8;
/HVLJQHOHSOXVpYLGHQWGHFHWDWWDFKHPHQWHVWGHQDWXUHDUWLFXODWRLUH(QHIIHWIDFHjXQHODQJXHYXOJDLUH
GRQWOHWUDLWGLVWLQFWLIIRQFLHUHQPDWLqUHSKRQpWLTXHHVWXQHVRXVDUWLFXODWLRQTXLVXVFLWHDPXwVVHPHQWVDSR
FRSHVV\QFRSHVHWPRQRSKWRQJDLVRQVHWSOXVJpQpUDOHPHQWHIIDFHPHQWGHVSKRQqPHVVLWXpVKRUVGHVFKDPSV
WRQLTXHVF·HVWjGLUHKRUVGHVV\OODEHVLQLWLDOHVRXDFFHQWXpHVO·pOLWHOHWWUpHYDVHGLVWLQJXHUSDUVRQFRQVHUYD
WLVPHDUWLFXODWRLUH&HOXLFLHVWVRFLDOHPHQWGLVWLQFWLIDXSRLQWG·rWUHFODVVDQW>@2QSRXUUDLWOHFURLUHVLPSOHPHQW
RUWKRJUDSKLTXHFRPPHF·HVWOHFDVHQIUDQoDLVRXQOH[qPHSHXWV·pFULUH´HDXµHWVHSURQRQFHUR0DLVFH
Q·HVWSDVOHFDVHWLOQ·HVWSDVTXHVWLRQSRXUXQDULVWRFUDWHGHSURQRQFHUDXWUHPHQWTXHDZ¬OHJUDSKqPH_DX_

 >@ 6HXWRQLXVH#?10%T!0I(0#()100HVWULXPF.6-1>%FRQVXODUHPDGPRQLWXVDEHRI.(10$-(%
SRWLXVTXDPI.60$-(GLFHQGDSRVWHURGLHF.(1-1>VDOXWDXLW
  /HFRQVXODLUH0HVWULXV)ORUXVOXL VFLO9HVSDVLHQ D\DQWIDLWREVHUYHUTX·LOIDOODLWSURQRQFHU
´SODXVWUDµ FKDULRW SOXW{WTXH´SORVWUDµOHOHQGHPDLQLOOHVDOXDGXQRPGH´)ODXUXVµ

,OIDXWGRQFDFFHSWHUFRPPHXQWUDLWGLVWLQFWLIGHODSURQRQFLDWLRQOHWWUpHXQHDUWLFXODWLRQVDQVGRXWHOpJqUH
PHQWVXUH[SULPpHTXLGDQVOHFDVGHVpOpPHQWVSRVWWRQLTXHVWKpPDWLVDLWGHIDLWOD]RQHGpVLQHQWLHOOHHWGRQQDLW
GHODVXEVWDQFHjXQHPRUSKRORJLHFDVXHOOHGqVORUVSOHLQHPHQWH[SORLWDEOH
3DUPDQLqUHGHFRPSDUDLVRQ³HWQRQGHSUHXYH³RQSRXUUDLWDOOpJXHUODSURQRQFLDWLRQGHO·DULVWRFUDWLH
IUDQoDLVHWHOOHTX·HOOHV·REVHUYDLWDXPLOLHXGXYLQJWLqPHVLqFOH(OOHVHVLJQDOHSDUXQHUpDOLVDWLRQYRORQWDLUHPHQW
FRQWUDVWLYHGXYRFDOLVPH>@HWIRUWHPHQWRFFOXVHGXFRQVRQDQWLVPH>@
 >@ H()0%.(%I-6)6)4#($#6)%"!0%?6'!..!02%6)%6&0!-?!%$-6#0%I+U)6>E)!0%I-#)4#I(1]L%N!%I-!>#!-%!0$%1)!%.(-5!%
?(-#($#6)%"!%.;(I!-$1-!2%X1#%46)$-(0$!%(?!4%4!%X1!%.;6)%6&0!-?!%"()0%.!0%>#.#!1]%6-"#)(#-!0%6Ç2%!)%5UM
)U-(.2%$61$!0%.!0%?6'!..!0%06)$%:!->U!0L%N!%0!46)"%I+U)6>E)!%!0$%.;(..6)5!>!)$%"!%.(%?6'!..!%4!)$-(.!%
l(l%^U"14($#6)`2%"!%.(%?6'!..!%61?!-$!%l6l%^:6->#"(&.!`%!$%"!0%"#I+$6)51!0%l(#l%!$%l6#l%^"#0$-(#-!2%(1%
-!?6#-`L%N!0%!)X1z$U0%I-6)6)4!)$%4!0%?6'!..!0%";1)!%>()#E-!%>(-X1U!%h%.;(--#E-!%"!%.(%&614+!L%3!$$!%
I-6:6)"!1-%"!0%?6'!..!0%!$%.;(44!)$1($#6)%"!%.(%"#I+$6)5(#06)%06)$%.!0%46>I60()$!0%I-#)4#I(.!0%"1%
IDPHX[´DFFHQW0DULH&KDQWDOµ/HWURLVLqPHSKpQRPqQHHVWO·KDELWXGH³HQFRPSOqWHRSSRVLWLRQ
(?!4%.;U?6.1$#6)%(4$1!..!%"!%.(%I-6)6)4#($#6)%³"!%)!%I(0%I-6)6)4!-%.!0%:#)(.!0%"!0%>6$0%46>I6-$()$%
XQ´HµPXHW 3KLOLSSHX :<

 >@ e1()$%(1]%46)06))!02%!..!0%06)$%:6-$!>!)$%(1"#&.!0%!$%.(-5!>!)$%"#::U-!)4#U!0L%\)!%06)6-#$U%I(-$#41.#E-!%
!0$%"6))U!%h%.(%I-6)6)4#($#6)%"!0%46)06))!0%#)#$#(.!02%!)%I(-$#41.#!-%lIl2%l=l%!$2%"()0%1)!%>6#)"-!%

:<
0HQVLRQ5LJDX² :R
0HQVLRQ5LJDX²L
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N<%3<7\<N/*Q%N<*/B8%8B%T<K/<*/,B%H/<7*K<*/e\8g%H\%@<KN8K%@,@\N</K8%ó%N<%H/3*/,B%@,Q*/e\8% 

>!01-!%l&l%!$%l$lL%@(-%!]!>I.!2%"()0%EDQTXHSUpVLGHQWSORXFTXDQWLWpTXDWUH.(%46)06))!%
#)#$#(.!%!0$%I-6)6)4U!%(?!4%1)!%644.10#6)%:6-$!2%h%.;()5.(#0!L%N!%l.l%:#)(.2%"()0%"!0%>6$0%46>>!%K{WHO2%
!0$%!)%5U)U-(.%$-E0%(1"#&.!:R

V6%&GE<?@?A?@GE%JWAE;%=8GEGE>@C?@GE%EGE%=G=ABC@8;
(QIDFHG·XQHSURQRQFLDWLRQHWG·XQHV\QWD[HSRSXODLUHVVRXPLVHVjXQHFRQVWDQWHIOXHQFHO·pOLWHOHWWUpHVH
IL[HXQFRPSRUWHPHQW-·DLpYRTXpSOXVKDXW FI† ODGLVSXWHTXLDXSUHPLHUVLqFOHDYDQW-&RSSRVHGHPDQLqUH
WUqVVLJQLILFDWLYHOHVWHQDQWVGHO·DQDORJLHGHODUqJOHFRQWUHFHX[GHO·DQRPDOLHGHO·XVDJH,OIDXWWRXWHIRLVUDSSH
OHUTXHVLO·RQFRQVXOWHOHSUHPLHUFKDSLWUHGXH!%5-(>>($#4#0GH6XpWRQHRQGRLWFRQVWDWHUTXHOHVWHQWDWLYHVGH
UpJXODWLRQFRQVHUYDWULFHGXODWLQQDLVVHQWSUDWLTXHPHQWHQPrPHWHPSVTXHODOLWWpUDWXUHODWLQHHOOHPrPHYHUV
ODILQGXWURLVLqPHVLqFOHDYDQW-&/DIRUFHGHFHWWHYRORQWpUpJXODWULFHVHPDQLIHVWHUDWRXWDXORQJGHODODWLQLWp
SDUXQHH[WUDRUGLQDLUHIORUDLVRQDUWLJUDSKLTXHRVHGpQRWHPRLQVXQJR€WDEVROXSRXUODJUDPPDLUHTX·XQEHVRLQ
GHFRGLILHUXQLQVWUXPHQWOLQJXLVWLTXHHQOXLDVVLJQDQWXQHFRPSOH[LWpGLIILFLOHjOLPLWHUSUpFLVpPHQW&HUWHVLO
LPSRUWDLWG·HQWLUHUXQHPDUTXHVRFLDOHDXVVLSDUIDLWHPHQWVWDEOHHWUHFRQQDLVVDEOHTXHSRVVLEOHHWVXUWRXWG·XQ
PDQLHPHQWDVVH]DUGXSRXUUHSRXVVHUOHYXOJDLUHPDLVLOV·DJLVVDLWDXVVLGHQHSDVH[FpGHUFHUWDLQHVERUQHVVRXV
SHLQHG·LUUpGXFWLEOHREVFXULWpHWGHUXSWXUHG·LQWHUFRPSUpKHQVLRQ$FHWH[HUFLFHGpOLFDWODFDVXDOLWpSUHQGVRQ
SOHLQU{OH(OOHOHMRXHUDDYDQWWRXWSDUXQHSUpVHQFHJUDSKLTXHHWSKRQLTXHTXLGRLWGpVRUPDLVLPSpUDWLYHPHQW
rWUHVWDEOHHWFRPSOqWH
/DFRQVpTXHQFHGHFHPDUTXDJHFDVXHOVDQVGRXWHSKRQLTXHPHQWVXUH[SULPp >@>@ HVWG·DERUGG·RUGUH
V\QWD[LTXH/DSUpVHQFHG·XQFDVG€PHQWGpVLJQpSDUOHJUDPPDLULHQHQWUDvQHODFRQVROLGDWLRQFRUUpODWLYHGHOD
IRQFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHTX·LOGpVLJQH$XVVLWRXWHHPEU\RQQDLUHHWLQWXLWLYHTXHVRLWODFRQVFLHQFHV\QWD[LTXHGHV
>6K8H92OHUHVSHFWGHODUHODWLRQTXLXQLWFDVHWIRQFWLRQQRWDPPHQWHQPDWLqUHSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHQHFRQQDvWLO
QXOOHUHPLVHHQTXHVWLRQ6HXOVVXEVLVWHQWTXHOTXHVUDUHVYDFLOOHPHQWVGpSRXUYXVGHFRQVpTXHQFHVV\QWD[LTXHV
WHOFHOXLTXLPHWHQFRQFXUUHQFHVXUXQDEODWLIVLQJXOLHUGHVIRUPHVFRPPHI-1"!)$#%JK%I-1"!)$!2QVDLWFHSHQ
GDQWTXHFRQWUHWRXWHUpJXODULVDWLRQOHVHHWLGpVLQHQWLHOVUHVWHURQWLQGpILQLPHQWDSRSKRQLTXHVDLQVLTX·HQ
WpPRLJQHjODILQGXSUHPLHUVLqFOHDSUqV-&4XLQWLOLHQ>@ORUVTX·LODYRXHTXHVRQRUHLOOHSHLQHjGLVFULPLQHU
OHVGHX[VRQV
 >@ 4XLQWLOLHQ/)0$#$1$#6%6-($6-#(,Q´KHUHµQHTXHHSODQHQHTXHLDXGLWXU
% % H()0%KHUH%^+#!-`%6)%);!)$!)"%!](4$!>!)$%)#%1)%l!l%)#%1)%l#lL:@%

"6%1@>?@GE%B@??D8C@8;%;?%J@>?@GE%=G=ABC@8;%;E%=;8<=;>?@:;%>GE?8C<?@:;3%%
B;%8XB;%J;%BWCJY;>?@Q
&HPDUTXDJHFDVXHOHQWUDvQHpJDOHPHQWGHVFRQVpTXHQFHVWDFWLTXHVTXLSHXYHQWV·REVHUYHUGHGLYHUVHVPD
QLqUHVPDLVSOXVQHWWHPHQWjWUDYHUVO·XVDJHGHO·DGMHFWLI&HOXLFLSRVVqGHHQHIIHWGHX[WUDLWVSURSUHVjSHUPHWWUH
GHVDLVLUODFDVXDOLWpGDQVFHUWDLQHVGHVHVYDULDWLRQVGLDVWUDWLTXHV/HSUHPLHUHVWVRQpWDWGHQRPLQDOTXLIDLW
GHOXLOHSRUWHXUG·XQHPDUTXHFDVXHOOH/HVHFRQGWLHQWDXIDLWTX·LOVHWURXYHVRXPLVjXQHUqJOHG·DFFRUGFRP
SOqWHTXLYHXWO·H[SUHVVLRQG·XQJHQUHG·XQQRPEUHHWG·XQFDV&HOOHFLSHUPHWjO·DGMHFWLIGHV·DIIUDQFKLUGHOD
FRQWLJXwWpWDFWLTXHHWRIIUHjO·DUWLVWHXQHOLEHUWp FIVXSUD† GDQVVRQHPSORLGRQWOHORFXWHXUSRSXODLUHHQ
XWLOLVDWHXUG·XQHODQJXHDPXwHRXVLPSOHPHQWVRXFLHX[GHQHSDVRSDFLILHUVRQ"#4$1>QHGLVSRVHSDV
/·REVHUYDWLRQFRQWUDVWLYHGXUpJLPHWDFWLTXHGHO·DGMHFWLIVHKHXUWHFHSHQGDQWjFHWWHGLIILFXOWpGRFXPHQ
WDLUHW\SLTXHPHQWODWLQHTXLHVWOHPDQTXHGHWH[WHVG·DPSOHXUQHWWHPHQWGpQRWpVFRPPHRUDX[HWSRSXODLUHV
1RXVGLVSRVRQVSRXUWDQWSDUODK+U$6-#X1!%h%OU-!))#10³XQPDQXHOG·DUWRUDWRLUHDQRQ\PHGHVDQQpHVDYDQW
-&³G·XQUpSHUWRLUHG·H[HPSOHVGHQLYHDX[GHVW\OHGXSOXVpOHYpDXSOXVEDVGHODJUDPPDWLFDOLWpODSOXV
DULVWRFUDWLTXHjXQGpEUDLOOpG·XQHRUDOLWpTXLQHWRXFKHSRXUWDQWSDVjO·H[DFWIRQGSRSXODLUHLQWULQVqTXHPHQW
LQDFFHVVLEOHPDLVTXLV·HQDSSURFKHWRXWHQQ·pWDQWTXHO·LQFDUQDWLRQGHO·LGpHTX·XQJUDPPDLULHQSHXWVHIDLUH
GHODGLFWLRQGHO·LQFXOWH&HVH[HPSOHVVRQWPDOKHXUHXVHPHQWFUppVSDUO·DXWHXUOXLPrPHPDLVLOVUHVWHQWWRX


%DUDWLQ 
0OOHUE
:@
9RLUDXVVL%DUDWLQ :P
0DURX]HDX²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<K,N8%FKY

WHIRLVDVVH]FODLUHPHQWLOOXVWUDWLIVSRXUPRQSURSRV/HVW\OHpOHYp\HVWSUpVHQWpFRPPHW\SpSDUHQWUHDXWUH
GHV6-)($#00#>(%1!-&(DLQVLTXHGHV!]6-)($#6)!0%0!)$!)$#(-1>%(1$%1!-&6-1>N

 >@ K+U$6-#X1!%h%OU-!))#10,Q5-(1!#%FRQVXPHWXURUDWLRILJXUDH5!)!-!VLTXDHFXLXVTXH
7J8%=FKJ7LHK%6-)($#00#>(%1!-&(%UHSHULULVLXHSURSULDVLXHH[WUDQHDXQDPTXDPTXHUHP
DGFRPPRGDEXQWXUHWVLJUDXHVVHQWHQWLDH>«@HWVL!]6-)($#6)!0%0!)$!)$#(-1>%(1$%1!-&6-1>2%
TXDHJUDXLWDWHPKDEHEXQW>«@DGKLEHEXQWXU
% % \)%"#0461-0%(1-(%1)%0$'.!%"!%$'I!%U.!?U%0#%.;6)%(II.#X1!%h%4+(X1!%#"U!%.!%?64(&1.(#-!2%"!%0!)0%I-6I-!%61%
:#51-U2%.!%I.10%&!(1%X1!%.;6)%I61--(%$-61?!-2%!$%0#%.;6)%!>I.6#!%"!0%>6'!)0%";(5-U>!)$!-%I!)0U!0%!$%
>6$0%X1#%6)$%"!%.(%5-()"!1-L
/·DXWHXUHQIRXUQLWFHWH[HPSOHRMHVLJQDOHSDUO·LWDOLTXHOHVDGMHFWLIVHWOHVVXEVWDQWLIVTX·LOV
TXDOLILHQWRXGpWHUPLQHQW

 >@ K+U$6-#X1!%h%OU-!))#101DPTXLVHVWXHVWUXPLXGLFHVTXLVDWLV#"6)!(>%=F998K%8H%JLM%
I6!)(> H[FRJLWDUH TXL SURGHUH KRVWLEXV SDWULDP FRJLWDULW" 4XRG PDOHILFLXP FXP
+64%04!.!-!FRQSDUDULTXRG+1#4%>(.!:#4#6%"#5)1>%01II.#4#1>SRWHVWLQXHQLUL",QLLVTXL
XLRODVVHQWLQJHQXXPPDWUHPIDPLOLDVFRQVWXSUDVVHQWXROQHUDVVHQWDOLTXHPDXWSRVWUHPR
QHFDVVHQW>(]#>(%01II.#4#(PDLRUHVFRQVXPSVHUXQW+1#4%$-141.!)$#00#>6DF)!:(-#6%:(4#)6-#%
0#)51.(-!>%I6!)(>QRQUHOLTXHUXQW$WTXHLQ(.##0%>(.!:#4##0DGVLQJXORVDXWDGSDXFRVH[
(.#!)6%I!44($6%8H8L786%=J7LJH8KN%+1#10%04!.!-#0TXLVXQWDGILQHV1)6%46)0#.#6%1)#1!-0#0%4#1#&10%
($-64#00#>(0%4(.(>#$($!0PDFKLQDQWXU2:!-60%()#>6024-1"!.!0%465#$($#6)!02"!-!.#4$60%
+6>#)!0DEKXPDQLWDWH4XLGDJHUHDXVLVXQWDXWFRJLWDUHSRVVXQW"e16SDFWR+60$#02%-!11.0#0%
>(#6-1>%0!I1.4-#02%"##!4$#0%>6!)#&102%61()$!0LQUXHUHQWLQFLXLWDWHPTXRPRGRGHXP$!>I.#0%
0I6.#($#02%6I$#>($#&10%$-14#"($#02%(.##0%(&-!I$#0%8H%9J7L8KLKJM2%>($-#&10:(>#.##0%JK%#)5!)1#0%9LD%
+60$#.!>%.#&#"#)!>%01&#!4$#0%L7D9%(4!-&#00#>6FRQFLGDW#)4!)"#6%46):.(5-($(TXLVHQRQSXWDQW
LGTXRGXROXHULQWDGH[LWXPSHUGX[LVVHQLVL0()4$#00#>(!%I($-#(!%>#0!-()"1>VFHOHUDWL
XLGHULQW4#)!-!>1HTXHRXHUELVFRQVHTXLLXGLFHVLQGLJQLWDWHPUHLVHGQHJOHJHQWLXV
LGIHURTXLDXRVPHLQRQHJHWLVT!0$!-%JH8M%LF9%()#>10%(>()$#00#>10UHLSXEOLFDHIDFLOH
HGRFHWXWHXPTXLIRUWXQDVRPQLXPXROXHULWSURGHUHSUDHFLSLWHPSURWXUEHWLVH[!(%
4#1#$($!TXDPLVWH+60$#1>%0I1-4#00#>6-1>%"6>#)($1%)!:(-#6XROXHULWREUXHUH
/DOHFWXUHGHFHWH[WHTX·LOQ·HVWLFLQXOEHVRLQGHWUDGXLUHSRXUHQWLUHUFHTXLGRLWO·rWUHIDLWDXVVLW{WDSSD
UDvWUHOHU{OHTX·\MRXHO·DGMHFWLI,OV·\PRQWUHHPSOR\pDYHFDERQGDQFH3RXUHQpYDOXHUO·LPSRUWDQFHLOIDXWOH
FRQVLGpUHUVHORQVHVWURLVRUGUHVVpPDQWLTXHV
(QWDQWTXHGpWHUPLQDQW +#42%#02%(.#102%1)102%X1#02%1!0$!- LOWLUHGHVDQDWXUHGHGpLFWLTXHHWGHPRWVHPLJUDP
PDWLFDOXQHQpFHVVLWpGHSUpVHQFHTXLOHUHQGGLIILFLOHPHQWpYLWDEOH,OQ·DSSRUWHSDUFRQVpTXHQWTXHSHXG·6-)($10%
DXWH[WHVDXISHXWrWUHORUVTX·LOHVWWKpPDWLVpSDUXQHK\SHUEDWH FIVXSUD† TXLO·pORLJQHGHO·XVDJHSRSXODLUH
HWTXHMHQRWHDXPR\HQGXVRXOLJQHPHQW
(QWDQWTXHGpYHUEDOI€WLOSDUWLFLSHRXDGMHFWLIYHUEDO "!-!.#4$102%-!11.0102%"##!4$102%61()02%0I6.#($102%$-14#"($102%
(&-!I$102%01&#!4$#02%46):.(5-($102%>#0!-()"102%(>()0 O·DGMHFWLIWLUHXQHQpFHVVLWpGHSUpVHQFHLPSRUWDQWHG·XQH
HVVHQFHYHUEDOHTXLO·DQFUHGDQVOHQR\DXSKUDVWLTXHIRQGDPHQWDO,OIDXWUHPDUTXHUWRXWHIRLVTX·LODSSDUDvWSDU
ERXIIpHVHWVRXVGHVIRUPHVVpPDQWLTXHVSHXIUpTXHQWHVGDQVOHODQJDJHGHPRLQGUHpOpYDWLRQHWHQILQTX·LOVH
WURXYHIUpTXHPPHQWGRWpG·XQSUpYHUEHTXLHQDFFURvWO·pWRIIHSKRQLTXH6·LOQ·HVWTXHSHXVRXPLVjO·K\SHUEDWH
F·HVWVDQVGRXWHG€DXIDLWTX·RQOHUHQFRQWUHLFLVRXYHQWGDQVGHVVHJPHQWVSUpVHQWDQWGHVDEODWLIVDEVROXVGRQW
ODEULqYHWpHWODFRPSDFLWpQHO·DXWRULVDLHQWTXHSHX
(QWDQWTXHSXUQRPLQDOQRQGpLFWLTXH #"6)!102%"#5)102%>(]#>102%$-141.!)$#00#>102%)!:(-#102%0#)51.(-#02%(.#!)102%
1)#1!-0102%($-64#00#>102%:!-102%4-1"!.#02%+60$#.#02%0()4$#00#>102%0I1-4#00#>10 O·DGMHFWLIVHPRQWUHG·XQVpPDQWLVPHLQYHVWL
G·XQHpPRWLRQQDOLWpELHQSUpVHQWHPDLVWUqVDULVWRFUDWLTXHPHQWSRQGpUpHHWUDLVRQQDEOHPHQWDXJPHQWpHGH
VXSHUODWLIVSRLQWWURSQRPEUHX[3RVWSRVLWLRQVHWK\SHUEDWHVOXLVRQWG·XQHPSORLUDUH,OUHVWHTXHVDVRXVWUDF
WLRQQ·HQWUDvQHUDLWTXHGHUDUHVDFFURFVDXVHQVJpQpUDOGHVFKRVHVHWTXHSRXUWRXWHVOHVUDLVRQVTXLYLHQQHQW
G·rWUHpQRQFpHVLODSSDUDvWFRPPHXQPR\HQG·6-)($10SULYLOpJLpPDLVXWLOLVpVHORQXQVFKpPDWDFWLTXHGRQWOD
FRQWLJXwWpFRQVWLWXWLYHHVWHQFRUHDUFKDwTXHPHQWRUDOH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N<%3<7\<N/*Q%N<*/B8%8B%T<K/<*/,B%H/<7*K<*/e\8g%H\%@<KN8K%@,@\N</K8%ó%N<%H/3*/,B%@,Q*/e\8% 

3DUFRQWUDVWHOHVW\OHEDVWHOTXHOHGpFULWO·DXWHXUGHODK+U$6-#X1!%h%OU-!))#10>@DSSDUDvWGDQVXQHQXGLWp
TXLQ·DSSHOOHPrPHSDVODGpVLJQDWLRQGHFRQVWLWXDQWVTXLOXLVHUDLHQWVLJQLILFDWLIV$YDQWWRXWVpPDQWLTXHVD
EDVVHVVHHVWDXVVLIDLWHG·DEVHQFHV

 >@ K+U$6-#X1!%h%OU-!))#10,QDGWHQXDWRILJXUDHJHQHUHLGTXRGDGLQIXPXPHWFRWWLGLDQXP
VHUPRQHPGHPLVVXPHVWKRFHULWH[HPSOXP
% % @61-%.!%0$'.!%0#>I.!2%4;!0$MhM"#-!%4!.1#%X1#%0;(&(#00!%c10X1;(1%.()5(5!%.!%I.10%6-"#)(#-!%!$%.!%I.10%461-()$2%
?6#4#%1)%!]!>I.!

/·H[HPSOHTXHO·DXWHXUHQIRXUQLWHVWG·XQHEULqYHWpTXLHQVLJQDOHOHGpQXHPHQW

 >@ K+U$6-#X1!%h%OU-!))#101DPXWIRUWHKLFLQEDOLQHDVXHQLWFRHSLWSRVWTXDPSHUIXVXV
HVWGHIULFDULGHLQGHXELXLVXPHVWXWLQDOXHXPGHVFHQGHUHWHFFHWLELLVWHGHWUDXHUVR
´+HXVµLQTXLW´DGROHVFHQVI1!-#%$1#PRGRPHSXOVDUXQWVDWLVIDFLDVRSRUWHWµ+LFTXL
LGDHWDWLVDELJQRWRSUDHWHUFRQVXHWXGLQHPDSSHOODWXVHVVHWHUXEXLW,VWHFODULXVHDGHP
HWDOLDGLFHUHFRHSLW+LF´9L[WDPHQµLQTXLW´VLQHPHFRQVLGHUDUHµ7XPXHURLVWH
FODPDUH164!%#0$(TXDHSHUIDFLOHFXLXLVUXERUHVHLFHUHSRWHVWLWDSHWXODQVHVWDWTXHDFHU
QHDGVRODULXPTXLGHPXWPLKLXLGHWXUVHGSRQHVFDHQDPHWLQHLXVPRGLORFLVH[HUFLWDWXV
VLV&RQWXUEDWXVHVWDGROHVFHQVQHFPLUXPFXLHWLDPQXQFSHGDJRJLOLWHVDGRULFXODV
XHUVDUHQWXULQSHULWRKXLXVPRGLFRQXLFLRUXP9ELHQLPLVWHXLGLVVHWVFXUUDP!]+(10$6%
-1&6-!TXLVHSXWDUHWQLKLOKDEHUHTXRGGHH[LVWLPDWLRQHSHUGHUHWXW!RPQLDVLQHIDPDH
GHWULPHQWRIDFHUHSRVVHW"

$VDOHFWXUHLODSSDUDvWTXHO·DGMHFWLIGpVLJQpSDUO·LWDOLTXHHQHVWSRXUDLQVLGLUHDEVHQW8QHIRLVODSDUW
IDLWHDX[GpWHUPLQDQWVHWDX[TXDOLILFDWLIVG·DEODWLIVDEVROXV $1102%#0$(!2%!]+(10$6 F·HVWjGLUHDX[GHX[SUHPLqUHV
FDWpJRULHVTXLRQWpWpH[DPLQpHVjSURSRVGHO·H[WUDLWSUpFpGHQWFHWH[WHVHPRQWUHWRWDOHPHQWGpSRXUYXGHFHV
pSLWKqWHVGHODWURLVLqPHFDWpJRULHGHFHX[TXLVRQWDLQVLFODLUHPHQWGpQRWpVFRPPHPR\HQVG·DUW:P%
'DQVO·RUGUHGHO·H[FHVVLYHPHQWEUXWDOGXSOXVGpQXpG·DUWHWGHFLYLOLWpDULVWRFUDWLTXHGX´YXOJDLUHµOH
UKpWHXUSURSRVHXQGHUQLHUH[HPSOH>@GRQWLOQ·\DULHQjGLUHTXLQ·DLWGpVRUPDLVpWpGLWjSURSRVGHO·DGMHFWLI

 >@ K+U$6-#X1!%h%OU-!))#101DPLVWLFLQEDOLQHLVDFFHVVLWDGKXQFSRVWHDGLFLW´+LF$110%
0!-110PHSXOVDXLWµ3RVWHDKLFGLFLWLOOL´&RQVLGHUDERµ3RVWLOOHFRQXLFLXPIHFLWHWPDJLV
PDJLVTXHI-(!0!)$!%>1.$#0FODPDXLW

!Z6%1@>?@GE%B@??D8C@8;%;?%J@>?@GE%=G=ABC@8;%;E%=;8<=;>?@:;%>GE?8C<?@:;3%%
=C?LGBGH@;%J;%BWCJY;>?@Q
/RUVTXHO·DXWHXUGHODK+U$6-#X1!%h%OU-!))#10H[DPLQHFHTXHGHYLHQGUDLWOHVW\OHpOHYpVLVHVWUDLWVGLVWLQFWLIV
SRXVVpVMXVTX·jODFDULFDWXUHHWO·H[FqVG·DUWVHWURXYDLHQWDPSOLILpVMXVTX·DX1#$#1>>@LOIRXUQLWXQH[HPSOH
>@SRXUYXG·XQDGMHFWLIGHODWURLVLqPHFDWpJRULH B!I$1)#(0 TX·LOFKRLVLWUDUHpUXGLWHWPpWRQ\PLTXHPDLV
VXUWRXWELHQQHWWHPHQWVpSDUpGXTXDOLILp .(41)(0 SDUXQHQHWWHK\SHUEDWHGRQWODFRPSUpKHQVLRQPRELOLVHOD
UqJOHG·DFFRUGpYRTXpHSOXVKDXW FIVXSUD† 

 >@ K+U$6-#X1!%h%OU-!))#10%(VWDXWHPFDXHQGXPQHGXPKDHFJHQHUDFRQVHFWHPXULQ
ILQLWXPDHWSURSLQTXD1#$#(XHQLDPXV1DPJUDXLILJXUDHTXDHODXGDQGDHVWSURSLQTXD
HVWHDTXDHIXJLHQGDTXDHUHFWHXLGHELWXUDSSHOODULVLVXIIODWDQRPLQDELWXU
  ,OIDXGUDYHLOOHUHQRXWUHHQYRXODQWSUDWLTXHUFHVVW\OHVjQHSDVWRPEHUGDQVGHVGpIDXWVSOXV
RXPRLQVSURFKHV(QHIIHWV·DSSDUHQWHDXVW\OHpOHYpTXLOXLHVWGLJQHG·pORJHVXQJHQUH
TXLGRLWrWUHpYLWp2QO·DSSHOOHUDFRUUHFWHPHQWMHFURLVHQOHTXDOLILDQWGHERXUVRXIIOp

Q?
)U\
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<K,N8%FKY

 >@ K+U$6-#X1!%h%OU-!))#101DPTXLSHUGXHOOLRQLEXVXHQGLWDWSDWULDPQRQVDWLVVXESOLFLL
GHGHULWVLSUDHFHSVLQB!I$1)#(0GHSXOWXVHULW.(41)(0
% % 3(-2%I61-%X1#%?!)"%0(%I($-#!%(1]%("?!-0(#-!02%4!%)!%0!-(%I(0%1)%01II.#4!%01::#0()$%X1!%";z$-!%c!$U%(1]%
561::-!0%)!I$1)#!)0

!!6%&GE?@HA[?D%;?%8C@<GE%>GOOAE@>C?@GEE;BB;
/DFRPSDUDLVRQWpPRLJQHGHFHTXHO·DGMHFWLIORUVTX·LOQ·HVWQLGpWHUPLQDQWGpLFWLTXHQLGpYHUEDOHVWXWLOLVp
FRPPHXQPR\HQG·DUW(OOHPRQWUHHQRXWUHTXHHQWDQWTXHWHOHWSDUIRLVpJDOHPHQWVRXVVDIRUPHGpYHUEDOH
O·DGMHFWLISHXWWRXWDXVVLELHQVHIDLUHOHOLHXG·XQMHXWDFWLTXHSURSUHPHQWHVWKpWLTXH&HMHXWLUHVRQHIILFDFLWpGX
IDLWTX·LOWURPSHO·DWWHQWHLQIRUPDWLRQQHOOHG·XQORFXWHXUQ?TXLVHSUpSDUHjWURXYHUTXDOLILDQWVHWTXDOLILpVOLpV
SDUFRQWLJXwWpHWFHODTXHOOHTXHVRLWOHXUSODFHUpFLSURTXH/DUXSWXUHGHODOLQpDULWpGXVLJQLILDQWLQGXLWHSDU
OHXUVpSDUDWLRQRXWUHTX·HOOHVXVFLWHXQHGLIILFXOWpGHFRPSUpKHQVLRQTXLGRQQHOHSDVjODOHFWXUHSHUVRQQHOOH
VXUODUpFLWDWLRQSDUXQWLHUVYDORULVHjO·H[WUrPHXQHUqJOHG·DFFRUGPRUSKRORJLTXHPHQWPDUTXpHVHXOHjPrPH
GHUHOLHUjGLVWDQFHOHVOH[qPHVSHUWLQHQWV,OYDGHVRLTXHOHGpVLUG·pOHYHUOHQLYHDXDUWLVWLTXHGXVLJQLILDQWHQOH
GLVORTXDQWQ·DSDVVHXOSUpVHUYpOHVGpVLQHQFHVQRPLQDOHVGHODGHVWUXFWLRQSDUDPXwVVHPHQW0DLVLOUHVWHTXH
IDYRULVpHGDQVVHVPR\HQVSDUOHFRQVHUYDWLVPHHWODVXUH[SUHVVLRQRUWKRpSLTXHGHVpOLWHVOHWWUpHVO·K\SHUEDWH
IUpTXHPPHQWFRPSOLTXpHG·DQDVWURSKHDG€FRQWULEXHUjIL[HUDXPRLQVJUDSKLTXHPHQWXQHPRUSKRORJLH
QRPLQDOHGpVLQHQWLHOOHLQGLVSHQVDEOHjODVDXYHJDUGHGHODFDVXDOLWpODWLQH

!F6%#WCJY;>?@Q%;E%O@8G@8%JWAE;%;<?LD?@IA;%J;%BC%?C>?@IA;%>C<A;BB;3%>CJ8;%HDED8CB
$XQQLYHDXSOXVpOHYpTXHFHOXLGXVLPSOHUDSSRUWGHTXDOLILFDWLRQOHMHXHVWKpWLTXHVXUODFDVXDOLWpODWLQH
GRLWV·HQYLVDJHUVXUOHSODQJpQpUDOGHODVWUXFWXUHWDFWLTXHJOREDOHGHODSKUDVH&HMHXWURXYHVRQSUHPLHUFKDPS
G·H[HUFLFHGDQVODPDQLSXODWLRQGHO·RUGUHSKUDVWLTXHKDELWXHOGXODWLQ QOXQRUGUHVXMHWREMHWYHUEHTXLYRXGUDLW
GDQVODPHVXUHGHOHXUSUpVHQFHODFRPSOpPHQWDWLRQGLUHFWHHQFHQWUDOLWpVHJPHQWDOHOHVXMHWjVDJDXFKHHWOH
YHUEHjVDGURLWHRXSOXVJpQpUDOHPHQWOHVDFWDQWVjJDXFKHHWOHYHUEHjGURLWH&HWWHVWUXFWXUHV·REVHUYHjO·pWDW
EUXWGDQVGHVWH[WHVDUFKDwTXHVRXDUFKDwVDQWVHWGpSRXUYXVG·6-)($10DLQVLTX·RQSHXWOHYRLUGDQVGHVWH[WHV
pSLJUDSKLTXHVWHOVFHX[GHV)DVWHVFRQVXODLUHV>@²>@RM·DLGpVLJQpOHVXMHWSDUXQVRXOLJQHPHQWVLPSOHOD
FRPSOpPHQWDWLRQSDUXQVRXOLJQHPHQWGRXEOHHWOHYHUEHSDUGHO·LWDOLTXH

% Z@ '69K8%46)01.(#-!0 'HJUDVVLSS² &,XOLXVVS)9RSLVFLQ,XOXV%8H%M6I89K76KL%>6-$110%

!0$
  &DLXV-XOLXVHVWPRUWHQFKDUJH

 >@ '69K8%46)01.(#-!0 'HJUDVVLS '-XQLXV'I'Q3HUD%(&"#4(1#$2%/3RVWXPLXV/I/Q

0HJHOOXVLGHPTXLSUDHWRUHUDW2%8H%M6I89K76KL%>6-$110%!0$
  'HFLPXV-XQLXVUHQRQoDjVDPDJLVWUDWXUH/XFLXV3RVWXPLXVOHPrPHTXLpWDLWSUpWHXUHVW
PRUWHQFKDUJH

 >@ '69K8%46)01.(#-!0% 'HJUDVVLSS² ,PS&DHVDU'LXLI&Q$XJXVWXV2%SRVWHDTXDP

FRQVXODWXVH%(&"#4(1#$2%WULEXQLFLDPSRWHVWDWHP%(44!I#$
  /·HPSHUHXU &pVDU $XJXVWH DSUqV TX·LO HXW UHQRQFp DX FRQVXODW UHoXW OD SXLVVDQFH
WULEXQLFLHQQH

&HWWHVWUXFWXUHWDFWLTXHV·DYqUHUDH[WUrPHPHQWUpVLVWDQWHHWQHFpGHUDjO·RUGUHURPDQTX·jSDUWLUGHFH
PRPHQWRO·DPXwVVHPHQWUHQGDQWGLIILFLOHOHGpSDUWHQWUHVXMHWHWFRPSOpPHQWQRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHORXGLUHFW

QO
(OHULFN Q:
'HYLQHHW6WHSKHQV²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N<%3<7\<N/*Q%N<*/B8%8B%T<K/<*/,B%H/<7*K<*/e\8g%H\%@<KN8K%@,@\N</K8%ó%N<%H/3*/,B%@,Q*/e\8% 

DXUDUDPHQpOHYHUEHGDQVODFHQWUDOLWpVHJPHQWDOH(QYRXODQWOHVXMHWjODJDXFKHYHUEDOHHWODFRPSOpPHQWDWLRQ
jVDGURLWHFHSODFHPHQWGLVFULPLQHHIILFDFHPHQWGHVDFWDQWVDFWLIVHWSDVVLIVGHYHQXVIRQFWLRQQHOOHPHQWPDO
LGHQWLILDEOHV&HSHQGDQWSRXUO·XVDJHUGXODWLQOLWWpUDLUHODVWUXFWXUHVXMHWREMHWYHUEHUHVWHXQGRQQpWDFWLTXH
VXIILVDPPHQWSXLVVDQWSRXUTXHVDVHXOHPDQLSXODWLRQVXIILVHjVLJQDOHUODYRORQWpG·DUW
$FHWH[HUFLFHTXHVHXOHDXWRULVHXQHFDVXDOLWpPDUTXpHGHPDQLqUHDVVH]ULFKHSRXUH[FOXUHDXWDQWTXHSRV
VLEOHO·DPELJXwWpO·DGMHFWLIUHVWHXQPR\HQSULYLOpJLpGHMRXHUVXUXQHGLIILFXOWpLQIRUPDWLRQQHOOHHWLQWHOOHFWLYH
TXLHVWHOOHDXVVLXQPR\HQG·DUWHWQRQGHVPRLQGUHV&HMHXFRQQDvWWURLVpWDWVGHGLIILFXOWpTXLSHXYHQWG·DLOOHXUV
SDUIDLWHPHQWELHQVHFRPELQHU
/HSUHPLHURSSRVH FIVXSUD† XQHSKUDVHRO·DGMHFWLIHVWSUpVHQWHWXQHSKUDVHGRQWLOHVWDEVHQW

/HGHX[LqPHRSSRVHGHVSKUDVHVjFRQWLJXwWpWDFWLTXHHWGHVSKUDVHVjK\SHUEDWH FIVXSUD††HW 

/HWURLVLqPHRSSRVHGHVSKUDVHVRO·RUGUHVXMHWREMHWYHUEHHVWPRGLILpjGHVSKUDVHVRLOQHO·HVWSDVQ:

!K6%#WCJY;>?@Q%;E%O@8G@8%JWAE;%;<?LD?@IA;%J;%BC%?C>?@IA;%>C<A;BB;3%%
;M;O=B;<%=GD?@IA;<
'HX[WH[WHVGH3ODXWH>@²>@GDWpVGHODILQGXWURLVLqPHRXGXGpEXWGXGHX[LqPHVLqFOHDYDQW-&
SHUPHWWHQWG·DSSUpKHQGHUODPDQLqUHGRQWXQPrPHDXWHXUXVHGHFHMHXWDFWLTXHVHORQOHQLYHDXGHVW\OHTX·LO
HQWHQGPHWWUHHQ±XYUH
/HSUHPLHUG·HQWUHHX[>@HVWFRPSRVpGHVpQDLUHVLDPELTXHVTXLOHGHVWLQHQWjODYRL[SDUOpH(QWDQW
TXHWHOLOVHPRQWUHFRPPHO·H[SRVpG·XQHSDUWLHGHO·DFWLRQGUDPDWLTXHRO·DXGLWHXUQHGRLWSDVDWWHQGUHGHV
PRUFHDX[GHKDXWHpOpYDWLRQ(WGHIDLWOHFRQWHQXGHFHSDVVDJHHVWG·RUGUHQHWWHPHQWWULYLDOSXLVTX·LOPHWHQ
VFqQHXQSDUDVLWHTXLVHSUpVHQWHDXSXEOLFYDQWHO·HIILFDFLWpGHVRQDSSpWLWHWO·DJUpPHQWGHVRQUpJLPHGHYLH
TX·LODVVLPLOHjXQHVFODYDJHRO·DVVLHWWHHWVRQFRQWHQXDXUDLHQWUHPSODFpODFKDvQH'DQVFHSDVVDJHROD1#0%
46>#4(VHIDLWSRSXODLUHRQFRQVWDWHFHUWHVODSUpVHQFHG·DGMHFWLIVFHTXLQ·pWDLWSDVOHFDVGDQVOHVH[HPSOHVGH
SURVHSRSXODLUHSUpVHQWpVFLGHVVXV >@>@ PDLVRQOHVWURXYHV\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWIXVVHQWLOVDQWpSRVpVRX
SRVWSRVpVHQUpJLPHGHVWULFWHFRQWLJXwWpWDFWLTXH/HYHUVDSSHOOHWRXWHIRLVXQFRPPHQWDLUHA!(%HTE%J9K%=69%
YUDLPHQWVpSDUpGH0!)$!)$#(SDUO·DGYHUEHGHYDOLGDWLRQX1#"!>TXLHQWDQWTXHPRGLILFDWHXUSRVWSRVpjO·REMHW
TX·LOWKpPDWLVHQHSRXYDLWrWUHjXQDXWUHHQGURLWTX·LPPpGLDWHPHQWDSUqV>!(XQGpWHUPLQDQWTXHO·KDELWXGH
YHXWSUpSRVpDXGpWHUPLQp/DVpTXHQFH>!(%X1#"!>%0!)$!)$#(Q·pWDLWDLQVLTXHODPDQLqUHODSOXVpFRQRPLTXHGH
VDWLVIDLUHVLPXOWDQpPHQWjGHX[H[LJHQFHVGHFRQWLJXwWpWDFWLTXHFRQWUDGLFWRLUHV
 >@ 3ODXWHA!)(!4+>#²
  ,XXHQWXVQRPHQIHFLW3HQLFXORPLKL%
LGHRTXLDPHQVDPTXDQGRHGRGHWHUJHR%
O6>#)!0%4(I$#160TXLFDWHQLVXLQFLXQW%
HWTXL:15#$#1#0%0!-1#0LQGXQWFRPSHGHV%
QLPLVVWXOWHIDFLXQW>!(%X1#"!>%0!)$!)$#(%
+6M%+6>#)#%>#0!-6VLDGPDOXPDFFHGLWPDOXP%
>(#6-%.1&#"6HVWIXJHUHHWIDFHUHQHTXLWHU%
1DPVHH[FDWHQLVH[LPXQW(.#X16%>6"6%
7XPFRPSHGLWLDQXPOLPDSUDHWHUXQW%
DXWODSLGHH[FXWLXQWFODXRP1XJDHVXQWHDH%
4XHPWXDGVHUXDUHUHFWHQHDXIXJLDWXROHV%
HVFDDWTXHSRWLRQHXLQFLULGHFHW

QQ
0DURX]HDX%RONHVWHLQ'HYLQHHW6WHSKHQV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<K,N8%FKY

/HVHFRQGWH[WH>@GRQWMHQ·DLFRQVHUYpTXHOHVpOpPHQWVVLJQLILFDWLIVSRUWHOHUpFLWG·XQHEDWDLOOHYLFWR
ULHXVHPHQWOLYUpHSDUOHQDUUDWHXU'HPqWUHVO\ULTXHVYDULpVLOHVWGHVWLQpDXFKDQWHWSDUFHODPrPHV·DQQRQFH
G·XQQLYHDXGHVW\OHTX·LOIDXWSODFHUDX[DQWLSRGHVGHFHOXLGXWH[WHSUpFpGHQW>@/HWRQ\HVWQHWWHPHQWpSLTXH
JK%>T6-)($10VXUDERQGDQWOXLDMRXWHXQHQRWHLURQLTXH2Q\WURXYHSDUH[HPSOHXQYHUV  TXLFRPSRUWHXQH
K\SHUEDWH 1#4$6-!0%d%.!5#6)!0 JpQpUDWULFHG·XQVDYDQWSRO\SWRWHDQWRQ\PLTXH 1#4$6-!0%1#4$#0 HWXQDXWUH  TXL
FRQWLHQWjODIRLVGHVPRWVDUFKDwTXHV "1!..6 HWUDUHV #)$!-)!4($#0 FRQVWLWXWLIVG·XQFKLDVPHHQJOREDQWO·HQWLHU
GHVDORQJXHXU3RXUVXLYUHO·DQDO\VHGHO·6-)($10GHFHWH[WHWURSORQJSRXUrWUHLFLH[DPLQpHQGpWDLOQHIHUDLW
TX·REOLJHUjXQHUpSpWLWLRQTXLQHSURXYHUDLWSDVGDYDQWDJHFHTXLO·HVWGpMj3DUPLFHVPR\HQVG·6-)($10VHWURXYH
O·K\SHUEDWH  %LHQPRLQVXWLOLVpHHQFHVWHPSVDUFKDwTXHVTX·HOOHQHOHVHUDSOXVWDUG
FILQIUD† O·K\SHUEDWHVHGpQRWHSRXUWDQWGpMjFODLUHPHQWFRPPHPR\HQG·DUWXQPR\HQGRQWO·H[LVWHQFHHVW
WUqVpWURLWHPHQWFRQGLWLRQQpHSDUO·H[LVWHQFHG·XQHFDVXDOLWpGRWpHG·XQHPRUSKRORJLHFHUWHVVRXVGpWHUPLQpH
HWDPELJXsPDLVQpDQPRLQVYLVLEOH
 >@ 3ODXWH<>I+#$-16²
% % ೏T#4$6-!0XLFWLVKRVWLEXV.!5#6)!0UHXHQLXQWGRPXP%
೏H1!..6H[WLQFWRPD[LPRDWTXH#)$!-)!4($#0KRVWLEXV%
೏TXRG>1.$(7KHEDQRSRSOR(4!-&(RELHFLW:1)!-(2%
೏UHJLTXH7KHEDQR&UHRQL-!5)1>%9K6D8>8L8K%016>%
೏UHGXFWXUXP(&#$1-60%6I7F%<-5#160SDFHPDWTXHRWLXP%
೏GHQLTXHXWXROXLPXV)60$-(%9L=J76K%>()10%
೏!X1#$!0%=67JHK%4#$#DEGH[WHUDPD[LPR

!N6%#WCJY;>?@Q%;E%O@8G@8%JWAE;%;<?LD?@IA;%J;%BC%?C>?@IA;%>C<A;BB;3%%
;M;O=B;<%=8G<C[IA;<
&HMHXGHFDVXDOLWpH[SUHVVLIHWWKpPDWLVDQWILQLUDSDUSDVVHUGDQVXQHSURVHFODVVLTXHDYLGHG·HIIHWVWHOOH
FHOOHTXLV·REVHUYHGDQVGHVGLVFRXUVRO·pPRWLRQQHODVDSOHLQHSDUW/RUVTX·HQDYDQW-&LOV·DJLUDSRXU
&LFpURQGHGpQRQFHUGHPDQLqUHHIILFDFHOHVPHQpHVVpGLWLHXVHVGH&DWLOLQD>@LOUHFRXUUDWRXWQDWXUHOOHPHQWj
O·K\SHUEDWHWKpPDWLVDQWHSRXUGpVLJQHUjO·DWWHQWLRQGHVRQDXGLWRLUHGHVpQDWHXUVKDXWHPHQWFXOWLYpVOHVSRLQWV
VDLOODQWVGHVRQDUJXPHQWDWLRQ

 >@ &LFpURQ/)%3($#.#)(>4XRXVTXHWDQGHPDEXWHUH&DWLOLQDSDWLHQWLDQRVWUD"TXDPGLX
HWLDPIXURULVWHWXXVQRVHOXGHW"TXHPDGILQHPVHVH!::-!)($(LDFWDELW(1"(4#([1LKLOQH
WHQRFWXUQXPSUDHVLGLXP3DODWLQLKLOXUELVXLJLOLDHQLKLOWLPRUSRSXOLQLKLOFRQFXUVXV
ERQRUXPRPQLXPQLKLOKLF>1)#$#00#>10KDEHQGLVHQDWXV.6410QLKLOKRUXPRUDXROWXVTXH
PRXHUXQW"3DWHUHWXDFRQVLOLDQRQVHQWLV46)0$-#4$(>LDPKRUXPRPQLXPVFLHQWLDWHQHUL
46)#1-($#6)!>%$1(>QRQXLGHV"
% % P10X1!0%h%X1()"%!):#)2%3($#.#)(2%(&10!-(0M$1%"!%)6$-!%I($#!)4![%36>&#!)%"!%$!>I0%!)46-!%$(%:1-!1-%
!0X1#?!-(M$M!..!%)60%461I0[%P10X1;6Ç%0;!>I6-$!-(%$6)%(1"(4!%!::-U)U![%K#!)L%B#%.!0%$-61I!0%X1#%.(%
)1#$%6441I!)$%.!%@(.($#)2%)#%.!0%-6)"!0%h%$-(?!-0%.(%?#..!2%)#%.;()]#U$U%"1%I!1I.!2%)#%4!%-(00!>&.!>!)$%
"!%$610%.!0%&6)0%4#$6'!)02%)#%.!%4+6#]%"!%FHOLHXOHSOXVV€U%"!%$6102%I61-%.(%46)?64($#6)%"1%7U)($2%)#%
.;(#-%)#%.;!]I-!00#6)%"!%$610%4!1]%X1#%06)$%#4#2%)6)2%-#!)%);(%I1%$!%"U46)4!-$!-[%*!0%I-6c!$0%06)$%I!-4U0%
h%c61-f%)!%.!%0!)0M$1%I(0[%*(%46)0I#-($#6)2%46))1!%"!%$6102%!0$%"Uch%>(y$-#0U!f%)!%.!%?6#0M$1%I(0[

,OHVWVLJQLILFDWLIGHFRQVWDWHUTXHVLO·RQUDVVHPEOHOHVWHUPHVWKpPDWLVpVSDUO·K\SHUEDWHO·RQREWLHQWOH
UpVXPpG·XQHVWUXFWXUHDUJXPHQWDWLYHUpGXLWHjVRQH[SUHVVLRQODSOXVFRQFHQWUpH(QO·RFFXUUHQFH&LFpURQQH
IDLWTX·DPSOLILHUXQVFKpPDOLPLWpjGHVFDXVHVHWGHVFRQVpTXHQFHVVRLW´/·DXGDFHVDQVIUHLQGH&DWLOLQDQHSHXW
SpQpWUHUGDQVFHOLHXSDUFHTX·LOHVWOHSOXVV€UHWSDUFRQVpTXHQWVDFRQVSLUDWLRQHVWPDvWULVpHµ6DQVEUXWDOLVHUj
O·H[FqVODSHQVpHFLFpURQLHQQHLOHVWPrPHSRVVLEOHGHODUpGXLUHjFHTX·H[SULPHQWOHVVHXOVDGMHFWLIVWKpPDWLVpV
VRLW´O·H[FHVVLIVHKHXUWHDXV€UHWV·HQWURXYHPDvWULVpµ
(QUHFRXUDQWGHODVRUWHjXQHILJXUHVpSDUDWULFHO·DXWHXUPHWHQpYLGHQFHGHPDQLqUHpFRQRPLTXHOHVWHUPHV
TX·LOHQWHQGUHQGUHVDLOODQWV$XWRULVpHSDUO·H[LVWHQFHG·XQHFDVXDOLWpPDUTXpHO·K\SHUEDWHVHIDLWDLQVLOHPR\HQ
G·XQPpWDGLVFRXUVWHQXVXUVDSURSUH±XYUHSDUO·DXWHXUOXLPrPH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N<%3<7\<N/*Q%N<*/B8%8B%T<K/<*/,B%H/<7*K<*/e\8g%H\%@<KN8K%@,@\N</K8%ó%N<%H/3*/,B%@,Q*/e\8% 

!P6%\S=;8]C?;%;?%OCE@=ABC?@GE%=L8C<?@IA;%;E%=8G<;
/HVH[HPSOHVSURGXLWVMXVTX·LFLLOOXVWUDLHQWVXUWRXWOHVGHX[SUHPLHUVGHJUpVGHODPDQLSXODWLRQDGMHFWLYDOH
WHOOHTXHMHO·DLpYRTXpHSOXVKDXW FIVXSUD† FHOXLGHODVLPSOHSUpVHQFHHWFHOXLGHODUXSWXUHGHODFRQWLJXwWp
TXLOLHTXDOLILDQWHWTXDOLILp/HWURLVLqPHGHJUpGHFHWWHPDQLSXODWLRQFHOXLTXLVHGpGXLWGHO·DWWHLQWHSRUWpH
jODVWUXFWXUHIRQGDPHQWDOHG·XQODWLQTXLYHXWVXMHWHWYHUEHGHSDUWHWG·DXWUHGHODFRPSOpPHQWDWLRQHVWXQ
V€UJDJHGHYRORQWpVLQRQDUWLVWLTXHGXPRLQVH[SUHVVLYH/HVSURVDWHXUVIXVVHQWLOVGHVDUWLVWHVWHOV6DOOXVWH
7LWH/LYH6pQqTXH7DFLWHRX$PPLHQ0DUFHOOLQUHVWHQWIRQFLqUHPHQWILGqOHVDXYLHX[PRGqOHVWUXFWXUHO,OQ·HVW
MXVTX·jXQDUWLVWHWHOTXH3OLQHOH-HXQH>@TXLQHUHVSHFWHXQVFKpPDSKUDVWLTXHTXHODPRLQGUHSKUDVHGX&pVDU
GHODD1!--!%"!0%D(1.!0>@LOOXVWUHDXPLHX[,OHVWPrPHDUGXGHOHXUWURXYHUXQHK\SHUEDWHQQ/DFRPSDUDLVRQ
HIIHFWXpHFLGHVVRXVDIIURQWHGHX[pFKDQWLOORQVSULVDXKDVDUGGHFHVGHX[GHUQLHUVDXWHXUV(OOHHQPRQWUHXQH
YRORQWp³TXHO·RQYRXGUDFURLUHVLJQLILFDWLYHG·XQHJpQpUDOLWp³GHSODFHUOHVXMHW VRXOLJQp ORUVTX·LOHVWH[SULPp
HQRXYHUWXUHVHJPHQWDOHODFRPSOpPHQWDWLRQ GRXEOHVRXOLJQp HQFHQWUDOLWpHWOHYHUEHHQFODXVXOH2QDXUD
UHPDUTXpOHSODFHPHQWHQFRQWLJXwWpGHVTXDOLILDQWVHWGHVTXDOLILpV LWDOLTXH GRQWODVpSDUDWLRQSDUK\SHUEDWH
HVWG·DXWDQWSOXVUDUHTXHO·DXWHXUVHYHXWPRLQVDUWLVWH,OHVWGHFHSRLQWGHYXHVLJQLILFDWLITXH&pVDUV·LOUDUpILH
jO·H[WUrPHO·K\SHUEDWHGDQVXQHD1!--!%"!0%D(1.!0TX·LOYHXWWUqVEUXWHODODLVVHVHPXOWLSOLHUGDQVXQHD1!--!%4#?#.!%
TX·LOSUpYRLWSOXVDUWLVWHQ<

 >@ 3OLQH8I#0$1.(!%4XLD$(-"#6-!>%("1!)$1>%$11>SURVSLFLROLEUXPTXHPI-#6-#&10%!I#0$1.#0%
SURPLVHUDPH[KLEHR
  3XLVTXHWRQDUULYpHMHOHSUpYRLVYDrWUHUHWDUGpHMHWHUHPHWVO·RXYUDJHDQQRQFpSDUPD
GHUQLqUHOHWWUH

 >@ &pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>08>8KJ9%!%.646%01I!-#6-!%I#.#0%>#00#0%:(4#.!%+60$#1>%I+(.()5!>%
SHUIUHJHUXQW
  1RVVROGDWVODQoDQWOHMDYHORWG·XQHSRVLWLRQVXSpULHXUHUpXVVLUHQWDLVpPHQWjEULVHUOD
SKDODQJHGHVHQQHPLV

!R6%\S=;8]C?;%;?%OCE@=ABC?@GE%=L8C<?@IA;3%AB?@OC%8C?@G%=G;?C8AO
'pMjFRQVLGpUpHVSOXVKDXW FIVXSUD† FRPPHPR\HQVSRpWLTXHVOHVK\SHUEDWHVVHWURXYHQWIUpTXHPPHQW
DVVRFLpHVSDUOHVSRqWHVHWOHVSOXVIULDQGVG·DUWLILFLDOLWpQRjXQHPDQLSXODWLRQWDFWLTXHTXLYDMXVTX·jODPRGLILFD
WLRQGHODGLVSRVLWLRQWUDGLWLRQQHOOHGHODSKUDVHODWLQHRO·RUGUHVXMHWREMHWYHUEHDXUDLWFRUUHVSRQGXDX[DWWHQWHV
GXOHFWHXU FIVXSUD† 8QDUWLVWHDXJR€WWUqVV€UFRPPH9LUJLOH>@QRQVHXOHPHQWSODFHTXDOLILDQWVHW
TXDOLILpVGHVGHX[SUHPLHUVYHUVGXTXDWULqPHFKDQWGHVRQ8)U#"!HQK\SHUEDWHPDLVHQFRUHOHVGLVSRVHHQXQH
ILJXUHGHWUqVKDXWHVRSKLVWLFDWLRQREWHQXHSDUVXSHUSRVLWLRQG·XQSDUDOOpOLVPHFDVXHO QRPLQDWLIDEODWLIQRPL
QDWLIDEODWLI HWG·XQFKLDVPH VXEVWDQWLIDGMHFWLIDGMHFWLIVXEVWDQWLI ,OJDUGHUDSRXUWDQWjVDSKUDVHXQRUGUH
WDFWLTXHIRQFLqUHPHQWWUDGLWLRQQHOTX·HOOHGRLWDXUHVSHFWGHODVpTXHQFHVXMHW -!5#)( REMHW 11.)10 YHUEH (.#$ 

 >@ 9LUJLOH8)U#"!²
% % !K%-!5#)( QRP 5-(1#W= DEO LDPGXGXP0(14#( QRP 41-( DEO %
LL>HL9%6>8K%LJH89%JK%4(!46FDUSLWXU#5)#
  0DLVODUHLQHGHSXLVORQJWHPSVEOHVVpHG·XQPDOSURIRQGQRXUULWVDSODLHGXVDQJGHVHV
YHLQHVHWVHFRQVXPHG·XQIHXFDFKp

2QWURXYHFHSHQGDQWVDQVSHLQHFKH]9LUJLOHHWSOXVTX·DLOOHXUVGDQVGHVSRqPHVWHOVOHVS146.#X1!0ROD
VRSKLVWLFDWLRQVHIDLWREOLJpHGHVH[HPSOHVG·K\SHUEDWHVDVVRFLpHVjGHVPRGLILFDWLRQVGHO·RUGUHWDFWLTXHWUDGL
WLRQQHO&HVPRGLILFDWLRQVSHXYHQWDOOHUMXVTX·jVRQLQYHUVLRQFRPSOqWHFRPPHGDQVO·H[HPSOH>@R46>I1.!-()$%

 
3DQKXLV²
Q<
'HYLQHHW6WHSKHQV Q@
)U\jSDUDvWUH
QR
&RQUDG$GDPV
 oi.uchicago.edu

:@?% 3<K,N8%FKY

HVWXQYHUEH5-!5!0XQREMHWHW36-'"6)%!$%*+'-0#0GHVVXMHWV2QUHPDUTXHUDHQFRUHTXHODORFXWLRQDGYHUELDOH#)%
1)1>TXDOLILFDWLYHGXYHUEH46>I1.!-()$HQHVWVpSDUpHSDUXQHK\SHUEDWHSRODLUHTXLYHXWOHVWHUPHVFRUUpOpV
SODFpVDX[H[WUrPHVGHO·DWWDTXHHWGHODFODXVXOHGXYHUVQ@

 >@ 9LUJLOH84.651!0²
% % 'F7KJ%9LD%(-51$(FRQVHGHUDW#.#4!'DSKQLV%
36>I1.!-()$X1!JUHJHV&RU\GRQHW7K\UVLV#)%1)1>
% % \)%c61-%H(I+)#0%0;U$(#$%(00#0%0610%1)!%'!10!%&-1#00()$!f%36-'"6)%!$%*+'-0#0%(?(#!)$%>#0%!)0!>&.!%
.!1-0%$-61I!(1]L

!T6%\S=;8]C?;^%OCE@=ABC?@GE%=L8C<?@IA;%;?%C<<@<?CE>;%@EQG8OC?@GEE;BB;
6XULPSRVpHjXQERXOHYHUVHPHQWGHODGLVSRVLWLRQSKUDVWLTXHXVXHOOHO·K\SHUEDWHDMRXWHXQREVWDFOHVXS
SOpPHQWDLUHjO·LQWHOOLJHQFHG·XQ"#4$1>GRQWODFRPSOH[LWpDWWHLQWDX[OLPLWHVGHO·LQWHOOLJLEOHHWjODGLVWDQFHOD
SOXVJUDQGHSRVVLEOHSDUUDSSRUWDX[SDUOHUVYXOJDLUHV8QHSKUDVHWLUpHGHOD@!-!5-#)($#6%<!$+!-#(!>@XQWH[WH
pFULWjODILQGXTXDWULqPHVLqFOHDSUqV-&SDUXQHIHPPHLVVXHGHODPHLOOHXUHVRFLpWpPDLVLJQRUDQWHGHVDUWL
ILFHVGHODSURVHG·DUWHWGpMjSUDWLTXDQWHG·XQRUGUHSKUDVWLTXHTXLWHQGYHUVFHOXLGXSURWRURPDQPRQWUHGHV
TXDOLILDQWVHWGHVTXDOLILpV LWDOLTXH OLpVHQFRQWLJXwWpHWGHVFRPSRVDQWVSKUDVWLTXHVTXLWHQGHQWPDLVDYHFGH
IRUWHVIOXFWXDWLRQVYHUVO·RUGUHVXMHWYHUEHFRPSOpPHQWDWLRQ VRXOLJQp 

 >@ @!-!5-#)($#6%<!$+!-#(!,ELHUJRPDQVLPXVLQ!(%)64$!HWLQGHPDWXULXV"#!%"6>#)#4(FXP#I06%
I-!0&'$!-6%HWPRQDFKLVTXLLELFRPPRUDEDQWXUFRHSLPXVDVFHQGHUH>6)$!0%0#)51.604XL
PRQWHVFXP#):#)#$6%.(&6-!DVFHQGXQWXU
  /jGRQFQRXVVRPPHUHVWpVSRXUODQXLWHWGHOjW{WOHPDWLQGXGLPDQFKHDFFRPSDJQpVGX
SUrWUHOXLPrPHHWGHVPRLQHVTXLUpVLGDLHQWOjQRXVDYRQVFRPPHQFpjHVFDODGHUFKD
FXQHGHVPRQWDJQHV&HVPRQWDJQHVV·HVFDODGHQWDYHFXQHSHLQHLQILQLH

3DUFRQWUDVWHXQSRqPHpFULWYHUVOHGpEXWGXSUHPLHUVLqFOHDSUqV-&SDUXQHDXWUHIHPPH6XOSLFLDTXL
HOOHSRVVqGHODSOHLQHPDvWULVHG·XQDUWGHSRqWHGHYHQXWUqVUKpWRULTXHXU>@SURSRVHGHVSKUDVHVRTXDOLILDQWV
>!#0l)60$-1> HWTXDOLILpV 3(>!)#0l0#)1> VRQWGLVMRLQWVHWRO·RUGUHSKUDVWLTXHVHIDLWQRQFDQRQLTXHPDLVVHORQ
GHVYRLHVTXLQHVRQWSDVFHOOHVGXIXWXUSURWRURPDQSXLVTX·LOIDLWVHVXFFpGHUVDQVGRXWHjILQVWKpPDWLVDQWHV
XQFRPSOpPHQW #..1> XQVXMHW 3'$+!-!( HWXQYHUEH ("$1.#$l"!I601#$ 

 >@ 6XOSLFLD*#&²
%  ([RUDWD>!#0W=LOOXP&\WKHUHD3(>!)#0%
DGWXOLWLQ)60$-1>W=GHSRVXLWTXH0#)1>
  )OpFKLHSDUPHVYHUV&\WKpUpHPHO·DDPHQpHWO·DGpSRVpHQWUHPHVEUDV

/·DSSOLFDWLRQPD[LPDOHGHSULQFLSHVWDFWLTXHVHVWKpWLTXHPHQWHWVRFLDOHPHQWYDORULVpVPDLVQXLVLEOHVjOD
IDFLOHLQWHOOLJHQFHGXWH[WHDUDSLGHPHQWLPSRVpO·HPSORLGHPR\HQVGHGpVDPELJXwVDWLRQ&RQWUDLUHPHQWjODSURVH
GRQWODFRPSDFLWpQHODLVVHULHQVDLOOLUVLQRQSDUXQHpYHQWXHOOHPLVHHQSDJHI!-%46.(%!$%46>>($(ODSRpVLHpWDLW
UpJLHSDUXQHDUFKLWHFWXUHWH[WXHOOHLPSpULHXVHHWSDUGHVUqJOHVPpWULTXHVVDQVGpIDXWVTXLHQFRPPDQGDLHQW
ODSRUWpHVHJPHQWDOH(QJpQpUDQWGHVVHJPHQWVjWUqVFRXUWHSRUWpHFpVXUHVHWFODXVXOHVDXWRULVHQWGHVUHODLV
GHWURLVjGL[V\OODEHVHQYLURQGHGLVWDQFH,OVVHUYLURQWjUHOLHUOHVpSDUp$LQVLGDQVOHWH[WHWUqVFRPSOH[HGH
6XOSLFLD>@>!#0%JK%)60$-1>GHVTXDOLILDQWVVHWURXYHQWPLVHQpYLGHQFHSDUXQHFpVXUHSHQWKpPLPqUHTXLOHV
SODFHGDQVXQHILQVHJPHQWDOHDQDORJXHjFHOOHTXHVLJQDOHXQHFODXVXOHTXLPHWGHODPrPHPDQLqUHHQH[WUp
PLWpVHJPHQWDOHOHXUVTXDOLILpV3(>!)#0%JK%0#)1>/DUHODWLRQVHIDLWDORUVYLVXHOOHPHQWSDULGHQWLWpWRSRORJLTXH
HWDXGLWLYHPHQWSDUO·DUUrWGHODYRL[9LUJLOH>@Q·DSDVDJLDXWUHPHQWVLQRQGDQVO·H[HPSOHWLUpGHVS146.#X1!0%
>@RVRQUHQRQFHPHQWSHXWrWUHLQWHUSUpWpFRPPHXQVDFULILFHIDLWjODFRPSOH[LWpUHTXLVHSDUOHJHQUH


)U\ QP
6HUEDW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N<%3<7\<N/*Q%N<*/B8%8B%T<K/<*/,B%H/<7*K<*/e\8g%H\%@<KN8K%@,@\N</K8%ó%N<%H/3*/,B%@,Q*/e\8% :@O

&HWWHPDQLqUHGHUpXQLUSDUFRXSXUHWKpPDWLVDQWHFHTXHODWDFWLTXHSRpWLTXHDYDLWVpSDUpVHULJLGLILHUDDX
ILOGXWHPSVSRXUVHIDLUHSHXjSHXLQGLFDWHXUG·KpPLVWLFKH&HWDXWRPDWLVPHUHVWHUDVDQVDXFXQGRXWHFRPPHOD
PDUTXHGHIDEULTXHG·XQHSRpVLHFRQVWUXLWHVXUOHVFDQRQVGHO·DQFLHQQHHVWKpWLTXH$OFLPXV$YLWXV>@XQSRqWH
KDXWHPHQWOHWWUpGHODILQGXFLQTXLqPHVLqFOHDSUqV-&HQXVHDYHFDUWHWFRQVFLHQFH,OUHVWHTXHO·RQQHSHXW
V·HPSrFKHUGHFURLUHTXHHQFHVWHPSVSURWRURPDQVRO·DPXwVVHPHQWYXOJDULVDLWMXVTX·jODODQJXHGHVpOLWHVFH
JHQUHGHPDUTXDJHGHODUHODWLRQV\QWD[LTXHGHYDLWGpVRUPDLVDXWDQWGpFRUHUOHWH[WHTX·HQIDFLOLWHUO·LQWHOOLJHQFH
 >@ $OFLPXV$YLWXV2%3(->#)(%ONO; %
೏4XLGTXLGDJLW1(-#60W=KXPDQDLQJHQWH.(&6-!0%
೏XQGH&-!1!>W KFDUSXQWPRUWDOLDWHPSRUD1#$(>%
೏XHOTXRGI6..1$#W=%L8K86HKL7%F78I8HJ%>6-!0%
೏TXRGWDPHQ(">#006W=GXGXPSHFFDWXU+6)6-!%
೏DGVFULEDPWLELSULPHSDWHUTXLVHPLQHPRUWLV%
೏WROOLV0144#"1(!W=%L8K6>86%IJ7M8H6%I-6.#
% % *61$%4!%X1#2%"()0%.!%5!)-!%+1>(#)2%!)5!)"-!%"!0%$-#&1.($#6)0%?(-#U!02%";6Ç%.;!]#0$!)4!%"!0%>6-$!.0%$#-!%
.(%&-#E?!$U%"!%.(%?#!2%61%.(%-(#06)%I61-%.(X1!..!%)60%>ô1-0%06)$%46--6>I1!0%"E0%.;6-#5#)!>«@2%)6$-!%
#)4.#)($#6)%h%IU4+!-%"1%:(#$%"!%.(%I!-$!%"Uch%()4#!))!%"!%)60%I-U-65($#?!02%c!%$!%.;#>I1$!-(#2%IE-!%
I-!>#!-2%$6#%X1#2%I(-%.(%0!>!)4!%"!%.(%>6-$2%!).E?!0%h%$(%I60$U-#$U%"U4+1!%.!0%5!->!0%"!%.(%?#!L

!V6%&GE>BA<@GE%!3%_G8=LG<SE?CM;%J;%BC%>C<ACB@?D
/HMHXGHODGLVVRFLDWLRQWDFWLTXHWHOTX·LODpWpREVHUYpREOLJHjFRQVLGpUHUOHUDSSRUWTXLOLHFDVHWIRQFWLRQ
RXSOXVSUpFLVpPHQWPRUSKRORJLHHWV\QWD[H/·H[HPSOHGHO·DGMHFWLIDPLVHQOXPLqUHO·LPSRUWDQFHHWOHU{OHTXH
OHORFXWHXUIDLWMRXHUjODUqJOHG·DFFRUGORUVTX·LOV·DJLWSRXUOXLGHFUpHUGHODSDUROHGLVWLQFWHGHODODQJXHSRSX
ODLUHRXVLPSOHPHQWXVXHOOH&·HVWJUkFHjO·H[LVWHQFHGHFHWWHUqJOHG·DFFRUGTXLUHQGSRVVLEOHO·LGHQWLILFDWLRQGH
UHODWLRQVIRQFWLRQQHOOHVpWLUpHVjGLVWDQFHTXHV·RIIUHjOXLODSRVVLELOLWpG·XQMHXHVWKpWLTXH&HOXLFLDSSOLFDEOH
DXVXEVWDQWLIWURXYHVRQDPSOHXUPD[LPDOHORUVTX·LOWRXFKHjO·DGMHFWLI&HWWHOLEHUWpWDFWLTXHREOLJHjFRQVLGpUHU
VpSDUpPHQWFDVHWIRQFWLRQQP(QHIIHWODUXSWXUHGHFRQWLJXwWpPRQWUHTXHGDQVO·HVSULWGXORFXWHXUOHWWUpOD
IRQFWLRQHQWDQWTXHUHODWLRQVHGLVWLQJXHDVVH]IRUWHPHQWGXFDVHQWDQWTXHPDUTXHSRXUTXHFHOXLFLSXLVVH
IDLUHO·REMHWG·XQHPDQLSXODWLRQSURSUH&HOOHFLpWLUHOHOLHQIRQFWLRQQHOPDLVVDQVOHURPSUH,OHQUpVXOWHXQH
VpSDUDWLRQYRORQWDLUHGXPRUSKRORJLTXHHWGXVpPDQWLTXHGXVLJQLILDQWHWGXVLJQLILpFHTXLHVWWUqVH[DFWHPHQW
ODPDQLIHVWDWLRQGHO·DUW

!"6%&GE>BA<@GE%F3%'DOCE?@IA;%;?%;<?LD?@IA;%J;%BC%>C<ACB@?D
'DQVXQHHVWKpWLTXHGHODVpSDUDWLRQWDFWLTXHOHMHXVHIDLWSXUHPHQWVpPDQWLTXHSXLVTXHODUHODWLRQFDVXHOOH
SUpVHUYHOHOLHQV\QWD[LTXH,OHQUpVXOWHODSURGXFWLRQG·XQWH[WHRODOLQpDULWpGXVLJQLILDQWVHWURXYHJUDYHPHQW
UHPLVHHQFDXVH(QHIIHWVLW{WTXHOHORFXWHXUDFRQVFLHQFHTXHODVWUXFWXUHGX"#4$1>HVWUpJLHSDUXQHVWUXFWXUH
WDFWLTXHWUDQVFHQGDQWHLOVDLWH[DFWHPHQWFRPPHQWLQWHUSUpWHUOHVFRQVWLWXDQWVSKUDVWLTXHVTXLVHSUpVHQWHQW
VXFFHVVLYHPHQWjOXL/RUVTXHFHQ·HVWSOXVOHFDVOHUpFHSWHXUGXPHVVDJHVHWURXYHHQWLqUHPHQWGpSHQGDQW
G·XQHYRORQWpFRPPXQLFDWLRQQHOOHTX·LOVHWURXYHHQGHYRLUGHSHUFHU,OGRLWGRQFVHIDLUHUpFHSWHXUDFWLIVDXI
jUHQRQFHUjFRPSUHQGUHFHTXLOXLHVWGLW/DUXSWXUHGHODOLQpDULWpGXVLJQLILDQWWHOOHTX·HOOHHVWLQGXLWHSDU
XQUpJLPHVpSDUDWLIO·REOLJHjFRQVLGpUHUO·HQVHPEOHGXVLJQLILDQWGDQVXQHVLPXOWDQpLWpTXLOHFRQWUDLQWjV·HQ
H[WUDLUH(WFHODO·DXWHXUOHVDLW3RXVVDQWVRQMHXjO·H[WUrPHFHOXLFLORUVTX·LOHVWSRqWHYDHQPRELOLVHUVHV
UHVVRXUFHVWDFWLTXHVMXVTX·jpWLUHUODUHODWLRQV\QWD[LTXHDX[H[WUrPHVOLPLWHVGXYHUVHWSDUIRLVPrPHDXGHOj
GDQVXQGpERUGHPHQWTXLQ·HVWQLGHO·HQMDPEHPHQWQLGXUHMHWPDLVGHO·HQWUHODFV<?/·H[WUDLWG·2YLGHFRPPHQWp
SOXVKDXW >@FIVXSUD† ROHVDGMHFWLIV4(!0(%JK%01#0VDXWDLHQWODEDUULqUHPpWULTXHSRXUVHOLHUGDQVOHYHUV
VXLYDQWHQFKLDVPHDYHF>6)$#&10%JK%I#)10WpPRLJQHELHQQHWWHPHQWGHODFRQVFLHQFHDFTXLVHSDUO·DXWHXUTXHVRQ
"#4$1>SDUOHMHXFDVXHODDFFpGpjXQHELGLPHQWLRQQDOLWpTXLOXLUHWURXYHVRQVHQVSUHPLHUGH$!]$10G·REMHWWLVVX

<?
)U\ <O
6KDQQRQ²%DWWDLO²)U\
 oi.uchicago.edu

:@:% 3<K,N8%FKY

G·KRUL]RQWDOLWpPDLVDXVVLGHYHUWLFDOLWp,OYDGHVRLTXHODFUpDWLRQG·HQWUHODFVUHQGDXYLVXHOXQHLPSRUWDQFH
TXHODVWULFWHOLQpDULWpOXLDYDLWUHWLUpHDXSURILWGHO·DXGLWLIHWREOLJHjFRQVLGpUHUOHVFRPSOH[LWpVWDFWLTXHVGHOD
SRpVLHFRPPHGHVWLQpHDXPRLQVDXWDQWjXQOHFWHXUTX·jXQDXGLWHXU

FZ6%&GE>BA<@GE%K3%&GOOAE@>C?@GE^%>GHE@?@GE%;?%>C<ACB@?D
/HMHXGHODVpSDUDWLRQWDFWLTXHHVWFUpDWHXUGHGLIILFXOWpVFRPPXQLFDWLRQQHOOHV(QHIIHWOHUpFHSWHXUG·XQ
PHVVDJHDLQVLVWUXFWXUpVHWURXYHWURPSpGDQVVHVDWWHQWHVjPHVXUHTXHSURJUHVVHVDUpFHSWLRQGXPHVVDJH(Q
WKpRULHPDWKpPDWLTXHGHO·LQIRUPDWLRQXQWHOPHVVDJHVHUDLWFRQVLGpUpFRPPHSRUWHXUG·XQ&-1#$RFFDVLRQQpHQ
O·RFFXUUHQFHSDUOHIDLWTXHOHVWHUPHVQHV·\VXFFqGHQWSDVHQIRQFWLRQGHOHXUSUREDELOLWpG·DSSDULWLRQ<O%36H9%LHJ%
VHPEODEOHVLWXDWLRQF·HVWQRQVHXOHPHQWOHVHQVGHODYXHTXLHVWFRQYRTXpPDLVDXVVLODPpPRLUHDLQVLTX·XQH
DFWLYLWpGHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQGXVHQVTXLVROOLFLWHOHVFDSDFLWpVSURSUHPHQWFRPSXWDWLRQQHOOHVGXUpFHSWHXU <:%#FLK2%
FHSHQGDQWPRQWUHTXHO·DXWHXUDFRQVFLHQFHGHODGLIILFXOWpLQWHOOHFWLYHG·XQPHVVDJHTX·LOSRXVVHFHUWHVSDUIRLV
MXVTX·jVRQPD[LPXPPDLVTX·LODOOqJHHQIRXUQLVVDQWjVRQGHVWLQDWDLUHTXHOTXHVUHSqUHVIDFLOLWDWHXUV&HX[FL
V·DSHUoRLYHQWGDQVOHVPR\HQVPpWULTXHVWHOOHVOHVFpVXUHVHWOHVFODXVXOHVTXHO·DXWHXUVHGRQQHSRXUGpVLJQHU
jVRQOHFWHXUFHTX·LOMXJHOXLPrPHLPSRUWDQWQRQVHXOHPHQWGDQVO·RUGUHVpPDQWLTXHPDLVDXVVLGDQVO·RUGUH
V\QWD[LTXH&RQVFLHQWGHVROOLFLWHUOHVFDSDFLWpVFRJQLWLYHVHWLQWHOOHFWLYHVGHVRQOHFWHXUMXVTX·jVHVOLPLWHV
O·DXWHXUVHVDLWSRXUWDQWO·REOLJDWLRQGHVHPRGpUHUVRXVSHLQHG·REVFXULWpLUUpPpGLDEOH,OVXIILVDLWWRXWHIRLVTXH
G·XQHHVWKpWLTXHGHODFRPSOH[LWpVXUJLVVHO·HQWpQpEUHPHQWSUpPpGLWpGXOHFWHXUQRQLQWURGXLW

UUUUUUUUUU
1%/HVWUDGXFWLRQVSURSRVpHVVRQWHQJpQpUDOHWjTXHOTXHVDPpQDJHPHQWVSUqVFHOOHVSXEOLpHVSDUOD&ROOHFWLRQ
GHV8QLYHUVLWpGH)UDQFHRXSDUOHV6RXUFHV&KUpWLHQQHV
UUUUUUUUUU

$]8D:@C?@GE
3/N% 36-I10%/)04-#I$#6)1>%N($#)(-1>²

7@]B@GH8C=L@;
$GDPV-1
  ´$7\SRORJLFDO$SSURDFKWR/DWLQ:RUG2UGHUµ/)"65!->()#04+!%F6-04+1)5!)²
%DUDWLQ0DUF
  N(%)(#00()4!%"!%.(%0')$(]!%h%K6>!3DULV0LQXLW
%DWWDLO*pUDUG
% OPP@% *+U6-#!%"!%.;#):6->($#6)g%(II.#4($#6)%(1]%$!4+)#X1!0%"!%46>>1)#4($#6)&ROOHFWLRQ3pGDJRJLTXHGH7pOp
FRPPXQLFDWLRQ3DULV0DVVRQ
%RONHVWHLQ0
  ´5DQGRP6FUDPEOLQJ"&RQVWUDLQWVRQ'LVFRQWLQXLW\µ,QH!%.#)51(%N($#)(%)61(!%X1(!0$#6)!0% $FWHV
GX;JFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOGHOLQJXLVWLTXHODWLQH3DULV6qYUHV²DYULO pGLWpSDU&
0RXVV\SS²%LEOLRWKqTXHG·eWXGHV&ODVVLTXHV/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
&DUGDXQV%XUNKDUW
% :??O% A(-410%*!-!)$#10%T(--6g%8#):u+-1)5%#)%0!#)%J!-=+HLGHOEHUJHU6WXGLHQKHIWH]XU$OWHUWXPVZLVVHQ
VFKDIW+HLGHOEHUJ&:LQWHU

<:
5DVWLHU²)UDQoRLVHW7DSLHUR²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N<%3<7\<N/*Q%N<*/B8%8B%T<K/<*/,B%H/<7*K<*/e\8g%H\%@<KN8K%@,@\N</K8%ó%N<%H/3*/,B%@,Q*/e\8% :@Q

&RQUDG&DUO:
% OPP?% F-6>%8I#4%$6%N'-#4g%<%7$1"'%#)%$+!%O#0$6-'%6:%*-("#$#6)(.%J6-"M6-"!-%#)%D-!!=%()"%N($#)%@6!$-'+DUYDUG'LV
VHUWDWLRQVLQ&ODVVLFV1HZ<RUN*DUODQG
'HYLQH$0HW/DXUHQFH'6WHSKHQV
  N($#)%J6-"%,-"!-g%7$-14$1-!"%A!()#)5%()"%/):6->($#6)1HZ<RUN2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
(OHULFN&KDUOHV
  ´/DWLQDVD6'29/DQJXDJH7KH(YLGHQFHIURP&LFHURµ@(I!-0%6)%D-(>>(-²
(UQRXW$
% OPR@% K!41!#.%"!%$!]$!0%.($#)0%(-4+(VX1!01RXYHOOHpG3DULV&.OLQFNVLHFN
)UDQoRLV-DFTXHVHW,7DSLHUR
  ´/·LGHQWLILFDWLRQGHVSURFqVHQFRQWH[WH,XQPRGqOHSURFpGXUDOGXWUDLWHPHQWFRJQLWLIGHVWLWUHV
ELSDUWLWHVGHODSUHVVHµ,Q7U>()$#X1!%.#)51#0$#X1!%!$%I0'4+6.65#!%465)#$#?!g%(0I!4$0%$+U6-#X1!0%!$%!]IU-#M
>!)$(1]pGLWpSDU-)UDQoRLVHW*'HKLqUHSS²6FLHQFHVHW7HFKQRORJLHVGHOD&RQQDLVVDQFH
*UHQREOH3UHVVHV8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGH*UHQREOH
'7E2%"67F>J
  ´,QWHUDFWLRQVPpWULFROLQJXLVWLTXHVFKH]TXHOTXHVSRqWHVGHODFpVXUHFKH]9LUJLOH/XFDLQHW$YLWµ
*H%O6>>(5!0%h%3(-.%H!-61]2%1F>LMJ%ON%I6U0#!2%pGLWpSDU3'HIRVVHSS²%UX[HOHV/DWRPXV
  ´(VWKpWLTXHGHODFRPSOH[LWpLQIRUPDWLRQQHOOHGXPRLQHDXGH/HVELHDX[EDLVHUVGH&DWXOOH
"!#1-- µN($6>10²
  ´'HO·LQIRUPDWLRQDWWHQGXHjO·LQIRUPDWLRQGpOLYUpHLQWpJUHUODSDUROHGXWHFKQLFLHQµ,QN($#)%!$%
.()51!0%$!4+)#X1!0pGLWpSDU-3%UDFKHWHW&0RXVV\SS²/LQJXD/DWLQD3DULV3UHVVHV
8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGH3DULV6RUERQQH
  ´/·DEODWLIDEVROXXQHKLVWRLUHGHIORXµ,Q(OpPHQWV´DV\QWD[LTXHVµRXKRUVVWUXFWXUHGDQVO·pQRQFpODWLQ2%
pGLWpSDU&%RGHORWSS²(5*$5HFKHUFKHVVXUO·$QWLTXLWp&OHUPRQW)HUUDQG3UHVVHV8QL
YHUVLWDLUHV%ODLVH3DVFDO
  ´/HVH[SUHVVLRQVODWLQHVGHODSOXUDOLWpH[WHQVLYHHWGHODVLQJXODULWpFRPSUpKHQVLYH ,>)!0%+6>#)!0%
ll%6>)#0%+6>6 µ'DQVN(%X1()$#:#4($#6)%!)%.($#)pGLWpSDU0)UX\WHW26SHYDNSS².XEDED
*UDPPDLUHHW/LQJXLVWLTXH3DULV/·+DUPDWWDQ
jSDUDvWUH ´/DSK\VLTXHGHO·DGYHUEHODSRUWpHG·XQHIRUFHHWO·RUGUHGHVPRWVµ&RPPXQLFDWLRQIDLWHDXFRO
ORTXHN!0%("?!-&!0%!)%.($#)&HQWUH$OIUHG(UQRXW3DULV6RUERQQH
+RIPDQQ-%HW$QWRQ6]DQW\U
% OP@:% N($!#)#04+!%D-(>>($#=%1)"%7$#.#0$#=L+DQGEXFKGHU$OWHUWXPVZLVVHQVFKDIW3DUW0XQLFK%HFN
.KQHU5DSKDHO)ULHGULFK:+RO]ZHLVVLJ
% OPO:% <10:u+-.#4+!%D-(>>($#=%"!-%.($!#)#04+!)%7I-(4+!2%1F>LMJ%ON%8.!>!)$(-M2%F6->!)M%1)"%J6-$.!+-!+DQQR
YHU+DKQ
.KQHU5DSKDHOHW&DUO6WHJPDQ
% OPO<% <10:u+-.#4+!%D-(>>($#=%"!-%.($!#)#04+!)%7I-(4+!2%1F>LMJ%:N%7($G.!+-!pPHpG+DQQRYHU+DKQ
-JLM6HH2%06HL
% OP@@% N($!#)#04+!%N(1$M%1)"%F6->!).!+-!+DQGEXFKGHU$OWHUWXPVZLVVHQVFKDIW9ROXPH3DUW0XQLFK
%HFN
0DURX]HDX-
% OP::% N;6-"-!%"!%>6$0%"()0%.(%I+-(0!%.($#)!2%1F>LMJ%ON.!0%5-61I!0%)6>#)(1]3DULV/HV%HOOHV/HWWUHV
% OP@?% *-(#$U%"!%0$'.#0$#X1!%.($#)!3DULV/HV%HOOHV/HWWUHV
0HLVHU*HUKDUG
  O#0$6-#04+!%N(1$M%1)"%F6->!).!+-!%"!-%.($!#)#04+!)%7I-(4+!'DUPVWDGW:LVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH
%XFKJHVHOOVFKDIW
 oi.uchicago.edu

:@<% 3<K,N8%FKY

0HQVLRQ5LJDXeULF
% :??@% <-#0$64-($!0%!$%5-()"0%&61-5!6#0g%U"14($#6)2%$-("#$#6)02%?(.!1-0&ROOHFWLRQ7HPSXV3DULV3HUULQ
0OOHU%,FM6H%
% :??O6% 7I-(4+&!9100$0!#)%1)"%7I-(4+?(-#($#6)%#>%.($!#)#04+!)%74+-#:$$1>%"!-%<)$#=!CJKJM6K60XQLFK
%HFN
 E ´:LHYXOJDULVWGHU7!->6%11.5(-#0[Y%*H%H!%.#)51(%N($#)(%)61(!%X1(!0$#6)!0% $FWHVGX;JFROORTXHLQWHU
QDWLRQDOGHOLQJXLVWLTXHODWLQH3DULV6qYUHV²DYULO pGLWpSDU&0RXVV\SS²
%LEOLRWKqTXHG·eWXGHV&ODVVLTXHV/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
1LHGHUPDQQ0D[
  @-U4#0%"!%I+6)U$#X1!%+#0$6-#X1!%"1%.($#)1RXYHOOH&ROOHFWLRQjO·8VDJHGHV&ODVVHV3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
1RUEHUJ'DJ/XGYLJ
  ´0qWUHHWU\WKPHHQWUHOH%DV(PSLUHHWOH0R\HQ$JHµ,Q<1%0!1#.%"1%A6'!)%<5!2%**N%U$1"!0%.#)51#0M
$#X1!02%>U$-#X1!0%!$%.#$$U-(#-!0%^_áosq_áás`pGLWpSDU5-DFREVVRQHW)6DQGJUHQSS²)LORORJLVNW
DUNLY6WRFNKROP.XQJO9LWWHUKHWV+LVWRULHRFK$QWLNYLWHWV$FDGHPLHQ
3DQKXLV'LUN*-
  *+!%36>>1)#4($#?!%@!-0I!4$#?!%#)%$+!%7!)$!)4!g%<%7$1"'%6:%N($#)%J6-"%,-"!-6WXGLHVLQ/DQJXDJH&RP
SDQLRQ6HULHV$PVWHUGDP%HQMDPLQV
5DVWLHU)UDQoRLV
% :??O% 7U>()$#X1!%!$%-!4+!-4+!0%465)#$#?!0)RUPHVVpPLRWLTXHV3DULV3UHVVHV8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGH)UDQFH
5RVpQ+DQQDK
% OPPP% N($#)!%.6X1#g%*-!)"0%()"%H#-!4$#6)0%#)%$+!%3-'0$(..#0($#6)%6:%3.(00#4(.%N($#)0XQLFK:)LQN
  ´/DFRQFHSWLRQGHODGLFWLRQpSLTXHGDQVO·HVSULWGHVSRqWHVUpSXEOLFDLQVHWOHXUVVXFFHVVHXUVµ,Q
H!%.#)51(%N($#)(%)61(!%X1(!0$#6)!0% $FWHVGX;JFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOGHOLQJXLVWLTXHODWLQH3DULV
6qYUHV²DYULO pGLWpSDU&0RXVV\SS²%LEOLRWKqTXHG·eWXGHV&ODVVLTXHV/RX
YDLQ3HHWHUV
$J7D6K2%4LE
  3(0%!$%:6)4$#6)0g%U$1"!%"!0%I-#)4#I(.!0%"64$-#)!0%4(01!..!0%"1%A6'!)%<5!%h%)60%c61-0/LQJXLVWLTXH1RXYHOOH
3DULV3UHVVHV8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGH)UDQFH
  N;!>I.6#%"!0%4(0%!)%.($#)*UDPPDLUHIRQGDPHQWDOHGXODWLQW&ROOHFWLRQ%LEOLRWKqTXHG·eWXGHV
&ODVVLTXHV/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
6KDQQRQ&ODXGH(HW:DUUHQ:HDYHU
  *+!%A($+!>($#4(.%*+!6-'%6:%36>>1)#4($#6)L&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI,OOLQRLV3UHVV
7RXUDWLHU&KULVWLDQ
% OPP<% 7')$(]!%.($#)!%LEOLRWKqTXHGHV&DKLHUVGHO·,QVWLWXWGH/LQJXLVWLTXHGH/RXYDLQ/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
9llQlQHQ9HLNNR
  N!%.($#)%?1.5(#-!%"!0%#)04-#I$#6)0%I6>IU#!))!0qPHpG%HUOLQ$NDGHPLH9HUODJ
  /)$-6"14$#6)%(1%.($#)%?1.5(#-!qPHUpYpG%LEOLRWKqTXH)UDQoDLVHHW5RPDQH6HULHV$0DQXHOVHW
eWXGHV/LQJXLVWLTXHV3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
:DFKWHU5XGROI
  <.$.($!#)#04+!%/)04+-#:$!)g%7I-(4+.#4+!%1)"%!I#5-(I+#04+!%\)$!-014+1)5!)%G1%"!)%H6=1>!)$!)%&#0%!$9(%_sp%?L%
3+-(XURSlLVFKH+RFKVFKXOVFKULIWHQ.ODVVLVFKH6SUDFKHQXQG/LWHUDWXUHQ)UDQNIXUWVXUOH
0DLQ3HWHU/DQJ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N8%FN,**8A8B*%8B*K8%N87%3<7%8B%N<*/B%*<KH/F% :@R

!"
#$%&#'(($)$*(%$*(+$%#$,%-.,%$*%#.(/*%(.+0/&

D!-"%TL%AL%O(?!-.#)52%\II0(.(%\)#?!-0#$!$

/12345672841
/DSpULRGHGXODWLQWDUGLIFRPPHQFHYHUVDSUqV-&HWGXUHMXVTX·jODILQGX9,JVLqFOH&·HVWXQHSpULRGH
TXLYRLWGHVJUDQGVFKDQJHPHQWVFXOWXUHOVHWSROLWLTXHVWHOVTXHOD&KULVWLDQLVDWLRQGXPRQGHDQFLHQYHUVHW
ODFKXWHGHO·(PSLUHURPDLQHQ2FFLGHQWYHUV$SUqVFHWWHFDWDVWURSKHODVRFLpWpURPDLQHFRQWLQXHjVXEVLVWHU
SHQGDQWSOXVLHXUVJpQpUDWLRQVHWFHQ·HVWTXHYHUVTXHQRXVSRXYRQVREVHUYHUXQGpFOLQQRWRLUHGHVFRQQDLV
VDQFHVFRQFHUQDQWOHVOHWWUHVHWODOLWWpUDWXUHURPDLQH$YHFODUpIRUPHFDUROLQJLHQQHYHUVRQDVVLVWHjXQH
UHFUXGHVFHQFHGHFHVFRQQDLVVDQFHVTXLPDUTXHUDODQDLVVDQFHGXODWLQPpGLpYDOSURSUHPHQWGLWHWODQDLVVDQFH
GHVODQJXHVURPDQHV
/DSpULRGHTXLQRXVRFFXSHHVWGRQFDVVH]ORQJXHHWLOH[LVWHpYLGHPPHQWGHVGLIIpUHQFHVLPSRUWDQWHVHQWUH
OHVWH[WHVGX,,,JVLqFOHHWOHVWH[WHVGX9,,JVLqFOHGHQRWUHqUH­FKDTXHpSRTXHRQREVHUYHDXVVLGHVGLIIpUHQFHV
FRQVLGpUDEOHVHQWUHOHVWH[WHVGHVDXWHXUVOLWWpUDLUHVSRVVpGDQWXQHJUDQGHFXOWXUHHWOHVWH[WHVGHVDXWHXUVVHP
EODQWWUqVSHXFRQQDvWUHODWUDGLWLRQOLWWpUDLUHGHV5RPDLQVHWOHVUqJOHVJUDPPDWLFDOHVGXODWLQFODVVLTXH&KDTXH
pSRTXHDVHVDXWHXUVOLWWpUDLUHVWUqVFXOWLYpVpFULYDQWG·XQHIDoRQSUHVTXHFODVVLTXH>D@VHVDXWHXUVGHFXOWXUH
PR\HQQHHPSOR\DQWSOXVVRXYHQWGHVH[SUHVVLRQVW\SLTXHPHQWWDUGLYHVWRXWHQUHVSHFWDQWHQFRUHOHVUqJOHV
IRQGDPHQWDOHVGXODWLQ>E@HWVHVDXWHXUVVHPEODQWWUqVSHXFRQQDvWUHODWUDGLWLRQOLWWpUDLUHGHV5RPDLQVHWOHV
UqJOHVJUDPPDWLFDOHVGXODWLQFODVVLTXH>F@

>D@ VW\OHpOHYp³YHUVSDUH[HPSOHOHVSqUHVGHO·(JOLVHFRPPH 6W$XJXVWLQHW6W

-pU{PHHWOHVpQDWHXUSD\HQ6\PPDTXHDXGpEXWGX9,JVLqFOH%RqFHSKLORVRSKHHWKDXW
IRQFWLRQQDLUHHW&DVVLRGRUHPLQLVWUHGXURLRVWURJRWK7KpRGRULFOH*UDQGHWIRQGDWHXU
G·XQPRQDVWqUHj9LYDULXP
>E@ VW\OHPR\HQ³SDUH[HPSOHO·KLVWRULHQFKUpWLHQ2URVHDXGpEXWGX9JVLqFOHTXHOTXHV
DXWHXUVGHWH[WHVWHFKQLTXHVHW*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVpYrTXHHWKLVWRULHQYHUVODILQGX
1*JVLqFOH
>F@ VW\OHEDV³FRQFHUQHVXUWRXWOHVDXWHXUVGHVWH[WHVSUpVHUYpVGDQVOHVLQVFULSWLRQVPDLV
DXVVLTXHOTXHVDXWHXUVGHWH[WHVSUpVHUYpVGDQVOHVPDQXVFULWV

1RXVGLVFXWHURQVLFLTXHOTXHVDVSHFWVGHO·HPSORLGHVFDV1RXVVDYRQVTXHOHODWLQWHOTXHQRXVOHWURXYRQVGDQV
OHVWH[WHVOHVSOXVDQFLHQVDYDLWGpMjSHUGXGHX[GHVKXLWFDVWUDGLWLRQHOOHPHQWDWWULEXpVDX3URWR,QGRHXURSpHQO%
0DLVFHODQ·HVWSDVWRXWHODYpULWpFDUHQUpDOLWpRQDHXDϸDLUHjXQFKHYDXFKHPHQWHQWUHSOXVLHXUVIRQFWLRQVG€
jODFRQIXVLRQGHVIRUPHV>D²E@3RXUOHVQHXWUHVODϰH[LRQVHUpGXLVDLWSUDWLTXHPHQWjWURLVIRUPHV>F@:

>D@ VLQJXOLHU
 L  QRPLQDWLIHWDFFXVDWLIOHVQHXWUHV $!>I.1>2%41&#.!
 LL  JpQLWLIHWGDWLIqUH%JK%RqPHGpFOLQDLVRQV -60(!W"#!#
 LLL  GDWLIHWDEODWLIqPH "6>#)62%$!>I.6 qPHFKHYDXFKHPHQWSDUWLHO 41&#.#2%:6-$#%M689%-!5#%
YV-!5!

O
9RLU%DOGL²+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U†HW9llQlQHQ :
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†
†

:@R
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8KH%TL%AL%O<T8KN/BD

>E@ SOXULHO
 L  QRPLQDWLIHWDFFXVDWLIOHVQHXWUHV $!>I.(2%41&#.#(
 LL  GDWLIHWDEODWLIWRXWHVOHVGpFOLQDLVRQV -60#02%"6>#)#02%$!>I.#02%41&#.#&102%:-14$#&102%"#!&10
>F@ OHVWURLVRSSRVLWLRQVGHVQHXWUHV
 L  QRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLI $!>I.1>W$!>I.(
 LL  JpQLWLI $!>I.#W$!>I.6-1>
 LLL  GDWLIDEODWLI $!>I.6W$!>I.#0

6HORQO·RUWKRJUDSKHLO\DXUDLWGRQFGqVOHODWLQFODVVLTXHEHDXFRXSGHFKHYDXFKHPHQWV­FDXVHGXGpYH
ORSSHPHQWSKRQpWLTXHQRXVDYRQV³VXUWRXWGDQVODODQJXHSDUOpHGHO·pSRTXHWDUGLYH³XQV\VWqPHHQFRUHSOXV
UpGXLWQHFRPSUHQDQWTXHGHX[RXWURLVRSSRVLWLRQV>D²F@Q

>D@ qUHGpFOLQDLVRQVLQJXOLHU
 L  QRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLIDEODWLI -60(
 LL  JpQLWLIGDWLI -60!
>E@ qPHGpFOLQDLVRQPDVFXOLQVLQJXOLHU
 L  QRPLQDWLI "6>#)10
 LL  JpQLWLI "6>#)#
 LLL  GDWLIDFFXVDWLIDEODWLI "6>#)6
>F@ qPHGpFOLQDLVRQQHXWUHVLQJXOLHU
 L  QRPLQDWLIGDWLIDFFXVDWLIDEODWLI $!>I.6
 LL  JpQLWLI $!>I.#

(QODWLQFODVVLTXHOHQRPLQDWLIHVWOHFDVGXVXMHW/HYRFDWLITXLQHVHWURXYHTXHGDQVXQFHUWDLQQRPEUHGH
PRWVDOWHUQHDYHFOHQRPLQDWLIGDQVODIRQFWLRQG·DSSHO </·DFFXVDWLIHVWOHFDVGXFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWGLUHFWHWOH
GDWLIFHOXLGXFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWLQGLUHFWROHJpQLWLIHVWHPSOR\pSRXUGpWHUPLQHUOHQRPHWO·DEODWLIHVWXWLOLVp
GDQVGHVFRPSOpPHQWVFLUFRQVWDQFLHOV'DQVODIRQFWLRQTXLLQGLTXHOHOLHXRQDXQFKHYDXFKHPHQWHQWUHO·DEODWLI
HWOHORFDWLITXLQ·HVWHPSOR\pTXHSRXUFHUWDLQVPRWV@6XUSOXVLHXUVSRLQWVRQHQWUHYRLWGDQVOHODWLQFODVVLTXH
GHVIRQFWLRQVFDVXHOOHVDSSDUWHQDQWjXQVWDGHDQWpULHXUSDVHQFRUHGRPLQpSDUOHUDSSRUWHQWUHWUDQVLWLYLWpHW
DFFXVDWLIH[SULPDQWO·REMHW,O\DDXVVLXQHDOWHUQDQFHHQWUHOHVFDVGDQVSOXVLHXUVIRQFWLRQVHWOHVFDVVRQWSHXj
SHXUHPSODFpVSDUGHVWRXUQXUHVDYHFSUpSRVLWLRQV/RUVGXGpYHORSSHPHQWGXODWLQSUpFODVVLTXHDXODWLQWDUGLI
OHQRPEUHGHVFDVHWGHVIRQFWLRQVH[SULPpHVXQLTXHPHQWSDUOHVFDVGLPLQXHWDQGLVTXHOHQRPEUHGHVORFXWLRQV
SUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHVDXJPHQWH
0DLVO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHFHTXLVHSDVVHGDQVOHVWH[WHVWDUGLIVQ·HVWSDVWRXMRXUVIDFLOH/·XQGHVSUREOqPHV
F·HVWODWUDQVPLVVLRQGHVWH[WHV'DQVSOXVLHXUVWH[WHVGHVVLqFOHVGHUQLHUVQRXVWURXYRQVDSUqVOHVSUpSRVLWLRQV
XQHPSORLGHVFDVTXLQHVXLWSDVOHVUqJOHVGHODJUDPPDLUHFODVVLTXHSDUH[HPSOHOHVSUpSRVLWLRQV(&%JK%"!VXLYLHV
GHO·DFFXVDWLIDXOLHXGHO·DEODWLI >D@>F@ HWODSUpSRVLWLRQI60$DYHFO·DEODWLIDXOLHXGHO·DFFXVDWLI>E@&HODQ·HVW
SDVVXSUHQDQWFDUQRXVVDYRQVTXHSOXVLHXUVIRUPHVGHVFDVpWDLHQWGpMjHQWUDLQGHGLVSDUDvWUH&HSHQGDQWLO\
DVRXYHQWXQHYDULDWLRQLPSRUWDQWHHQWUHOHVGLIIpUHQWVPDQXVFULWVGHVWH[WHV>D@HWSDUIRLVPrPHHQWUHGLIIp
UHQWHV±XYUHVG·XQPrPHDXWHXU>E@4XHOTXHVSKLORORJXHVRQWDWWULEXpFHVIDXWHVJUDPPDWLFDOHVDX[DXWHXUV
GHVWH[WHVHX[PrPHV0DLVLOVHSHXWpJDOHPHQWTX·XQWH[WHDLWpWpYXOJDULVpSDUGHVFRSLVWHVSHQGDQWOHVGHX[
VLqFOHVTXLSUpFqGHQWODUpIRUPHFDUROLQJLHQQH3RXUFHWWHUDLVRQQRXVWURXYRQVGHVGLIIpUHQFHVQRWRLUHVHQWUH
OHVpGLWLRQVGXPrPHWH[WH>F@P

Q
9RLU9llQlQHQ†² @
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†²HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U
<
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U†² †
HW9llQlQHQ† 
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†²+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U†
R
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U HW9llQlQHQ†²
† P
9RLU+DYHUOLQJFI&ROHPDQ

9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U
†
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N8%FN,**8A8B*%8B*K8%N87%3<7%8B%N<*/B%*<KH/F% :@@

>D@ YDULDWLRQHQWUHOHVPDQXVFULWVGHODWUDGXFWLRQGHV<I+6-#0>!0%+#II64-($#X1!0 YHUV

DSUqV-&
 L  <I+6-#0>#FRPPVHORQOHVPDQXVFULWV9F9D$K5J*%D³(DEO ODWLQ
FODVVLTXH (%0!I$!>%>!)0#&10´GHSXLVPRLV·µ
 LL  <I+6-#0>#FRPPVHORQOHVPDQXVFULWV5H(L30F0S³(DFF ODWLQYXOJDLUH 
(%0!I$!>%>!)0!0 FHVPrPHVPDQXVFULWVRQW(%)1$-#4#&10GDQV<I+6-#0>#
>E@ YDULDWLRQHQWUHOHV±XYUHVGH*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ²
 L  I60$DFFXVDWLI ODWLQFODVVLTXH ³H[HPSOHVGDQVO·O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>HWH[HPSOHV
GDQVOHVDXWUHV±XYUHVI60$%i%"#!0´DSUqV;MRXUVµ
 LL  I60$DEODWLI ODWLQYXOJDLUH ³H[HPSOHVGDQVO·O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>HWDXFXQH[HPSOH
GDQV OHV DXWUHV ±XYUHV O#0$6-#(% F-()46-1> ೏I60$% >1.$#0% "#!&10 « HW ೏I60$%
X1("-(5#)$(%"#!&10
>F@ YDULDWLRQHQWUHOHVpGLWLRQVGH-RUGDQqV YHUV
 L  *LXQWDHW*ULOORQH  ³"!DEO ODWLQFODVVLTXH -RUGDQqVD!$#4(೏"!%X1#&10%V%
$!0$($1-
 LL  0RPPVHQ  ³"!DFF ODWLQYXOJDLUH -RUGDQqVD!$#4(೏"!%X1(0%V%$!0$($1-

3DUIRLVLO\DDXVVLOHULVTXHTXHTXHOTX·XQDLWFRUULJpFHTX·LODFRQVLGpUpFRPPHOHVIDXWHVG·XQDXWHXUWDUGLI
>D@2QSHXWFRQVWDWHUTX·XQFHUWDLQQRPEUHGHPDQXVFULWVVRXYHQWUHODWLYHPHQWUpFHQWVSUpVHQWHGHVYDULDQWHV
TXLVHPEOHQWSOXVFRQIRUPHVDX[WHQGDQFHVJpQpUDOHVGXODWLQFODVVLTXH>E@O?

>D@ PDQXVFULWV30F*%D(V(L0S 5H  ,;J²;,JV <I+6-#0>!0%+#II64-($#X1!0 YHUV

DSUqV-&
 L  <I+6-#0>#೏46>I(-(-!(" ODWLQFODVVLTXH ("%I-6.#](>%(-$!>%?#$(>%46)I(-(?#$%&-!?!>%
d´LODFRPSDUpODYLHFRXUWHjO·DUWORQJµ
 LL  <I+6-#0>#FRPP$!>I!-($10JpQLWLI ODWLQWDUGLI >!"#64-#$!-%$!>I!-($(%0#?!%4(.6-#0%
0#?!%:-#5"6-#0´PRGpUpPHQWWHPSpUpVRLWTXDQWjODFKDOHXUVRLWTXDQWDXIURLGµ
>E@ PDQXVFULWV9FHW9D ;,JV HWO·pGLWLRQGH:LQWHU  <I+6-#0>!0%+#II64-($#X1!0 YHUV
DSUqV-&
 L  <I+6-#0>#೏46>I(-(-!"($ ODWLQFODVVLTXH I-6.#](>%(-$!>%?#$(!%46>I(-(?#$%&-!?#%V%´LO
DFRPSDUpO·DUWORQJjODYLHFRXUWHµ
 LL  <I+6-#0>#FRPP೏$!>I!-($10DEODWLI ODWLQFODVVLTXH >!"#64-#$!-%$!>I!-($(%0#?!%4(.6-!%
0#?!%:-#56-!´PRGpUpPHQWWHPSpUpVRLWTXDQWjODFKDOHXUVRLWTXDQWDXIURLGµ

,OIDXWWRXMRXUVrWUHWUqVDWWHQWLIjFHSUREOqPHTXDQGRQGLVFXWHGHO·HPSORLGHVFDVGDQVOHVWH[WHVSUpVHUYpV
GDQVXQPDQXVFULWGRQWO·kJHHVWSRVWpULHXUjFHOXLGHO·DXWHXU
/DWUDGLWLRQOLWWpUDLUHHWO·LQIOXHQFHGHO·pFROHSRVHQWXQDXWUHSUREOqPHOO/HGpYHORSSHPHQWGHO·HPSORLGHV
FDVpWDLWXQFKDQJHPHQWTXHOHVJUDPPDLULHQVHVVD\DLHQWGHFRUULJHUGDQVOHVpFROHV1RXVSRVVpGRQVGHVWH[WHV
TXLQRXVLQIRUPHQWVXUFHWUDYDLOSDUH[HPSOHXQHFROOHFWLRQGHSKUDVHVDSSDUWHQDQWjTXDWUHDXWHXUVFODVVLTXHV
WHOVTXH&LFpURQ>DL²LLLY²Y@HW9LUJLOH>DLLL²LY@HWXQHOLVWHGHPRWVHWGHFRQVWUXFWLRQVUHFRPPDQGpVjO·pSRTXH
>E@

>D@ <-10#()##%A!00#%!]!>I.(%!.641$#6)1> ,9JV

 L  SO(&1)"($%#..(%-! DEO &LFI-6%3.1!)$#6  >1.#!-%(&1)"($%(1"(4#(
 LL  SO6&.#?#046-%+1#10%-!# JpQ &LF#)%3($#.%/  6&.#?#04!-!%4(!"#0%($X1!%#)4!)"#6-1>
 LLL  SOT$6-%#..6 DEO 9HUJ<!)L%i//  1$!-!%06-$!%$1(

O?
9RLU+DYHUOLQJ OO
9RLU+DYHUOLQJ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8KH%TL%AL%O<T8KN/BD

 LY  SO85-!"#6-%#..6%.646 DEO 9HUJ<!)L%//  !0$%1-&!%!5-!00#0%$1>1.10&LFI-6%

N#5(-#6  "6>6%!0$%!5-!0010
 Y  SO!]#$%!%.646 !]DEO &LF"!%01II.#4##0³1$%!]!1)$%!%7#4#.#(%I-(!"6)!0
>E@ <II!)"#]%@-6&#SOVV 9,,JV
 L  N641$#6%41>%(&.($#?6%4(01%+(!4%46)?!)#-!%-!I!-#$1-N%"!.!4$6-%4+6-(1.(2%("?!-$6-%I()$6>#>62%
:-16-%(-5!)$62%I6$#6-%(1-62%1$6-%$65(2%I-#?6-%I600!00#6)!2%#)"#5!6%46)0#.#62%!5!6%01>I$12%4(-!6%
>6.!0$#(2%(&0$#)!6%4#&62%:1)56-%6::#4#62%0(4-#:#46%?#4$#>(2%"6)($10%46-6)(2%"#5)10%+6)6-!2%
#)"#5)10%:(>(2%6-&10%.#&!-#02%:-!$10%(>#4#$#(2%I.!)10%I!41)#(2%?!+!>!)0%#-(41)"#(2%6I10%!0$%
I($-6)62%#)"1.5!6%?#)62%!]I6.#6%&#--62%#)$!-"#46%(>#4#$#(

­FDXVHGHFHWWHWUDGLWLRQOLWWpUDLUHQRXVDYRQVVRXYHQWGHVUDLVRQVGHSHQVHUTXHO·HPSORLGHVFDVWURXYp
FKH]OHVDXWHXUVOLWWpUDLUHVpWDLWDVVH]GLIIpUHQWGHO·HPSORLFRXUDQWFHOXLGHODODQJXHGHWRXVOHVMRXUV

#9%5:;9<4==9>912%59%<?@776A@28B
(QODWLQFODVVLTXHO·DFFXVDWLIHVWOHFDVGXFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWGLUHFW/DWHQGDQFHJpQpUDOHGXGpYHORSSH
PHQWSRVWFODVVLTXHF·HVWTXHO·DFFXVDWLIGHYLHQWSOXVLPSRUWDQWGDQVFHWWHIRQFWLRQ,OHVWGRQFSHXVXUSUHQDQW
TXHEHDXFRXSGHYHUEHVTXLGHPDQGDLHQWDXWUHIRLVO·DEODWLIGHPR\HQRXOHGDWLISDUH[HPSOHWHQGHQWDORUVj
GHPDQGHUO·DFFXVDWLI>@(WPrPHVLOHVJUDPPDLULHQVFKHUFKDLHQWjFRUULJHUFHGpYHORSSHPHQWQRXVHQWURXYRQV
TXHOTXHVH[HPSOHVFKH]OHVDXWHXUVOLWWpUDLUHVHX[PrPHVFRPPHSDUH[HPSOHFKH]*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ² 
DXWHXUGHVW\OHPR\HQ FIH[HPSOH>E@ O:

>D@ O·DFFXVDWLIUHPSODFHO·DEODWLIGHPR\HQ
 L  1$6-´VHVHUYLUGHHPSOR\HUµ ODWLQFODVVLTXHO·DEOO·DFFUDUH *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV
O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>+!-#>1>%1$1)$1-
 LL  :1)56-´V·DFTXLWWHUGHDFFRPSOLUDFKHYHUµ ODWLQFODVVLTXHO·DEOO·DFFUDUH *UpJRLUH
GH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>0(4!-"6$#0%:1)5!-!$1-%6::#4#1>
 LLL  :-16-´IDLUHXVDJHGHMRXLUGHµ ODWLQFODVVLTXHO·DEOO·DFFUDUH *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV
O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>?#$(%X1(>%:-1!>1-
 LY  I6$#6-´SUHQGUHHQVRQSRXYRLUV·HPSDUHUGHµ ODWLQFODVVLTXHDEORXJpQGDQVFHUWDLQHV
ORFXWLRQV *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>41>%!I#046I($1>%I6$#-!$1-
>E@ O·DFFXVDWLIUHPSODFHO·DEODWLIVpSDUDWLI
 L  4(-!6´rWUHH[HPSWGHSULYpGHµ ODWLQFODVVLTXHDEO *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%
F-()46-1>6I$($(>%4(-1#$%0!I1.$1-(>
>F@ O·DFFXVDWLIUHPSODFHOHGDWLI
 L  )64!6´QXLUHIDLUGXPDOjµ ODWLQFODVVLTXHGDWDFFDYHFOHVSURQRPVQHXW *UpJRLUH
GH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>1$%)!X1!%$!%)!X1!%+()4%)64!()$%-!5#6)!>
 LL  0$1"!6´V·DSSOLTXHUjV·LQWpUHVVHUjµ ODWLQFODVVLTXHGDWDFFDYHFOHVSURQRPVQHXW 
*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>1$%>6.#)(0%(!4.!0#(0$#4(0%0$1"!-!$

'DQVOHODWLQFODVVLTXHO·DFFXVDWLIDHQFRUHSOXVLHXUVIRQFWLRQVDGYHUELDOHVTX·LOSHUGJUDGXHOOHPHQWSRXU
O·DEODWLIRXSRXUGHVORFXWLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHV,OPDUTXHSDUH[HPSOHODGXUpHG·XQHVLWXDWLRQ>D@WDQGLVTXH
O·DEODWLILQGLTXHOHPRPHQWRV·DFFRPSOLWO·DFWLRQRXOHODSVGHWHPSVGXUDQWOHTXHOVHSDVVHXQpYpQHPHQW FI
!6%$!>I6-!´jFHPRPHQWµ&#"16%´GDQVGHX[MRXUVµHW´HQGHX[MRXUVµHWF ,O\DFHSHQGDQWGqVOHODWLQFODVVLTXH
TXHOTXHVH[HPSOHVGDQVOHVTXHOVO·DEODWLIVHPEOHLQGLTXHUODGXUpHG·XQHVLWXDWLRQ>E@HWGDQVFHWWHIRQFWLRQ
QRXV DYRQV DXVVL OD SUpSRVLWLRQ I!- HW O·DFFXVDWLI >F@ 'DQV OH ODWLQ SRVWFODVVLTXH O·DEODWLI WHQG j UHPSODFHU
O·DFFXVDWLI GDQV OHV H[SUHVVLRQV LQGLTXDQW OD GXUpH >E@ 0DLV O·DFFXVDWLI H[LVWH HQFRUH LO HVW SDU H[HPSOH

9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†²+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U†
O:

HFI%RQQHWVT
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N8%FN,**8A8B*%8B*K8%N87%3<7%8B%N<*/B%*<KH/F% :@P

SDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWIUpTXHQWFKH]OHVKLVWRULHQV>D@HWQRXVOHWURXYRQVDXVVLGDQVOHVLQVFULSWLRQVIXQpUDLUHV³
SDUIRLVDYHFO·DEODWLI>G@1RXVDYRQVDXVVLOHVORFXWLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQHOOHV>F@OQ

>D@ DFFXVDWLI&LFpURQH!%)($1-(%"!6-1>೏H16"!X1("-(5#)$(%H#6)'0#10%$'-())10%())60% DFF 

:1#$%6I1.!)$#00#>(!%!$%&!($#00#>(!%4#1#$($#0´'LRQ\VLXVIXWOHW\UDQG·XQHYLOOHWUqVULFKHHW
IRUWXQpHSHQGDQWDQVµ
>E@ DEODWLI H[FHSWLRQ &LFpURQH!%6-($6-!೏ @!-#4.!0 iN%())#0% DEO I-(!:1#$%<$+!)#0%
´3HULFOqVGLULJHD$WKqQHVSHQGDQWDQVµ
>F@ I!-DFFXVDWLI&LFpURQ8I#0$1.(!%("%<$$#41>೏$!)1#0$#%I-61#)4#(>%I!-%"!4!>%())60´WX
DVFRQWU{OpODSURYLQFHSHQGDQWDQVµ
>D@ DFFXVDWLI
 L  VW\OHpOHYp&DVVLRGRUHO#0$6-#(೏e1#%41>%:-($-!%-!5)(?#$%())60%$-!"!4#>2%I60$%:-($-!>%
?!-6%$-!0´TXLUpJQDSHQGDQWWUHL]HDQV¬DYHFVRQIUqUHHWSHQGDQWWURLVDQVDSUqVOD
PRUWGXIUqUHµ
 LL  VW\OHPR\HQ*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏K!5)(?#$%(1$!>%<.(-#410%())60%nn%
´$ODULFUpJQDDQVµ
>E@ DEODWLI
 L  VW\OHpOHYp&DVVLRGRUHO#0$6-#(೏T#]#$%(1$!>%36)0$()$#)10%#>I!-($6-%())#0%0!](5#)$(%
!$%X1#)X1!2%-!5)(?#$%(1$!>%$-#5#)$(%!$%1)6´O·HPSHUHXU&RQVWDQWLQYpFXWDQVHWUpJQD
QO%6H9Y
 LL  VW\OHPR\HQ*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏/5#$1-%H#)#:#6%!I#046I6%(I1"%*6-6)10%
"#4!"!)$!2%,>>($#10%$-#&10%())#0%I-(!:1#$´DSUqVODPRUWGH'LQLILXVpYrTXHGH7RXUV
2PPDWLXVIXWjODWrWHGHO·pSLVFRSDWSHQGDQWDQVµ
>F@ I!-DFFXVDWLI
 L  VW\OHpOHYp&DVVLRGRUHO#0$6-#(೏´&RQILGHµLQTXLW´ILOLI!-%?#5#)$#%())60%)!X1!%I()!%
)!X1!%(X1(%)!X1!%06>)6%01>%0($#($10%V´&URLVPRLPRQILOVGLWLOSHQGDQWYLQJWDQV
MHQ·DLpWpUDVVDVLpQLGHSDLQQLG·HDXQLGHVRPPHLOµ
 LL  VW\OHPR\HQ*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>%71&%H#64.#4#()6%V%I!-%())60%
X1($$16-%I!-0!41$#6%!](5#$($(%!0$´6RXV'LRFOpWLHQLO\HXWXQHSHUVpFXWLRQSHQGDQW
6H9Y
>G@ DOWHUQDQFHHQWUHDFFXVDWLIHWDEODWLI
 L  VW\OHEDV¬ FI*DOGL &೏?#]#$%())#0%Ni DEO 2%>!)0!0% DFF "16&10 DEO 2%"#!0%
DFF T//´LOYpFXWSHQGDQWDQVPRLVHWMRXUVµ

/·DFFXVDWLIG·H[WHQVLRQDFHSHQGDQWFRQVHUYpODIRQFWLRQG·LQGLTXHUOHGHJUpRXODPHVXUHGHTXHOTXHFKRVH
>D@'DQVXQHIRQFWLRQVHPEODEOHQRXVDYRQVDXVVLOHJpQLWLIG·HVWLPDWLRQHQODWLQFODVVLTXH>E@+RUVGHOD
ODQJXHOLWWpUDLUHO·DFFXVDWLIVHVXEVWLWXDLWDXJpQLWLIGDQVFHWWHIRQFWLRQ>F@'DQVOHODWLQWDUGLIQRXVUHQFRQ
WURQVOHJpQLWLIFKH]OHVDXWHXUVOHVSOXVOLWWpUDLUHV>D@WDQGLVTXHO·DFFXVDWLIGHYLHQWSOXVIUpTXHQWGDQVOHV
WH[WHVHQJpQpUDO>E@O<

>D@ O·DFFXVDWLILQGLTXH
 L  OH GHJUp 7pUHQFH @+6->#6 ೏#)4-!"#&#.!0$% X1()$1>% !-1>% ()$!% !6% 0(I#!)$#( ´F·HVW
LQFUR\DEOHFRPELHQMHVXUSDVVHPRQPDvWUHHQVDJHVVHµ
 LL  ODPHVXUH9DUURQH!%.#)51(%N($#)(೏"!)(-##2%X16"%"!)60% VFLO%)1>>60 V%?(.!&()$%
´OHVGHQLHUV DLQVLGpQRPPpV SDUFHTX·LOVYDODLHQWFKDFXQGL[FDVµ3OLQHB($1-(.#0%
+#0$6-#(%೏4'($+10%I!)"!$%"-(4+>(0%"!4!>´XQF\DWKHSqVHGL[GUDFKPHVµ

9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U
OQ O<
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†²HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U
†EFI/|IVWHGWVTT+DYHUOLQJ²*DOGL †
²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8KH%TL%AL%O<T8KN/BD

>E@ OHJpQLWLILQGLTXHODYDOHXU
 &LFpURQ8I#0$1.(!%("%:(>#.#(-!0೏0#%>!%$()$#%:(4#0%X1()$#%4!-$!%:(4#0´VLWXP·HVWLPHV
DXWDQWTXHWXP·HVWLPHVVDQVGRXWHµ
>F@ O·DFFXVDWLIGHPHVXUHUHPSODFHOHJpQLWLIGHSUL[GDQVODODQJXHPRLQVOLWWpUDLUH
 YHUVDSUqV-&3pWURQH7($'-#4(೏?!)"#"#$%!1>%?#)1>%X1()$1> DFF #I0!%?6.1#$%
V%´LOYHQGLWFHYLQDXSUL[TX·LOYRXODLWµ
>D@ VXUYLHGXJpQLWLIFKH]OHVDXWHXUVOHVSOXVOLWWpUDLUHVGHODSpULRGHWDUGLYH
 6\PPDTXH8I#0$1.(!೏X1()$#%(%$!%:#(>´O·HVWLPHRWXPHWLHQVµ
>E@ O·DFFXVDWLIGHPHVXUHUHPSODFHOHJpQLWLIGHSUL[
 YHUVDSUqV-&7HUWXOOLHQ%H!%$!0$#>6)#6%()#>(!೏#..(%4!-$!%!0$2%X1(>%$()$# JpQ 
:(4#02%X1()$1> DFF #..(%$!%:(4#$´F·HVWHOOHTXHWXHVWLPHVDXWDQWTX·HOOHW·HVWLPHµ
% *1JVLqFOHDSUqV-&/XFLIHU&DODULWDQXVH!%<$+()(0#6೏#..60%X1#%I.10 DFF I.1-#0%
JpQ >!)0(!%$1(!%46I#(0%:!4!-1)$%´FHX[TXLHVWLPqUHQWHQSOXVODULFKHVVHGHWD
K6D>JY

'DQVFHVFDVO·DOWHUQDQFHHQWUHOHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVHVWGHFDUDFWqUHVW\OLVWLTXHHWO·HPSORLGHODFRQVWUXFWLRQ
FODVVLTXHHVWVXUWRXWXQSKpQRPqQHOLWWpUDLUH
/·DFFXVDWLIGHPRXYHPHQWDpWpUHPSODFpSDUODORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHGDQVODSOXSDUWGHVFDV SDUH[HPSOH
!6%#)%/$(.#(>´MHYDLVHQ,WDOLHµ PDLVLOHVWHQFRUHHPSOR\pHQODWLQFODVVLTXHDYHFXQFHUWDLQQRPEUHGHPRWV
GRQWOHVQRPVGHYLOOHV SDUH[HPSOH!6%K6>(>´MHYDLVj5RPHµ ­O·pSRTXHWDUGLYHQRXVWURXYRQVFHWDFFXVDWLI
GDQVOHVWH[WHVOLWWpUDLUHV>D@PDLVGDQVOHVWH[WHVPRLQVOLWWpUDLUHVLODOWHUQHDYHFODORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOH
>E@HWDXVVLGDQVFHUWDLQVWH[WHVDVVH]WDUGLIVDYHFOHGDWLI>F@OR

>D@ DFFXVDWLIVW\OHOLWWpUDLUHpOHYpHWPR\HQ ODWLQFODVVLTXH

 VW\OHpOHYp
 6\PPDTXH YHUV²YHUV 8I#0$1.(!K6>(>%V%?!)#$´LOHVWYHQXj5RPHµ
 6W$XJXVWLQ ² 36):!00#6)!0೏(%*+(5(0$!)0#%6II#"6%?!)#%3(-$+(5#)!>´GHOD
YLOOH7KDJDVWHMHVXLVYHQXj&DUWKDJHµHW೏K6>(>%I!-5!-!´VHGLULJHUj5RPHµ
% 9KE>J%MFEJH
 2URVH GpEXWGX9JV O#0$6-#(!೏<)$#64+#(>%V%-!"##$´LOHVWUHWRXUQpj$QWLRFKHµ
 *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ² O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>SO೏K6>(>%(1:15#$´LOV·HVW
HQIXLj5RPHµ
 IRUPHQRQGpFOLQpHODWLQWDUGLI*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏@(-#0#10%
?!)#$´LOHVWYHQXj3DULVµ
 VW\OHUHODWLYHPHQWEDV
% /$#)!-(-#1>% 85!-#(! YHUV   ೏-!?!-$!&(-% 36)0$()$#)6I6.#> ´MH UHYHQDLV j
&RQVWDQWLQRSOHµHW೏1&#%V%!$%!1)"6%/!-106.#>(>%#(>%:1!-(>´RM·DYDLVGpMj
pWpHQDOODQWj-pUXVDOHPµ
>E@ #)DFFXVDWLI ODWLQWDUGLI
 VW\OHUHODWLYHPHQWEDV
% /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(! YHUV ೏-!5-!00#%01>10%#)%/!-106.#>(>´QRXVVRPPHV
UHQWUpVj-pUXVDOHPµHW೏6>)!0%V%#)%/!-106.#>(%-!1!-$1)$1-´WRXVUHYLHQQHQW
j-pUXVDOHPµ
>F@ GDWLI
 VW\OHPR\HQ³*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ²
% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>S೏N15"1)6%-!5-!0010%!0$´LOHVWUHWRXUQpj/\RQµ
% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>S೏<)"!4(?6%?!)#$´LOHVWYHQXj$QMRXµ
% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>S೏*6.60(!%"#-#5#$1-´RQVHGLULJHYHUV7RXORXVHµ

OR
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U
†
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N8%FN,**8A8B*%8B*K8%N87%3<7%8B%N<*/B%*<KH/F% 

'DQVOHODWLQWDUGLIYXOJDLUHO·DFFXVDWLIDOWHUQHSDUIRLVDXVVLDYHFOHQRPLQDWLI>D@RXDYHFOHJpQLWLI>E@
!L%1*JVLqFOHLODOWHUQHDXVVLDYHFO·DEODWLIGDQVOHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVDEVROXHVUHPSODoDQWXQHSURSRVLWLRQGDQVOHV
WH[WHVOLWWpUDLUHV>F@

>D@ O·DFFXVDWLIDOWHUQHDYHFOHQRPLQDWLI
 L  ,9JVLqFOH%3+#-6)೏+1#10%0141>%V%?!$10$#00#>(!641.6-1>%?#$#(%0()($´OHVXFGHFHOXLFL
JXpULWOHVPDODGLHVGHV\HX[µ 01410
 LL  ILQGX,9JVLqFOH/$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏I!-%?(..!^>`%#..(^>`%X1(>%"#]#%#)5!)0´SDUFHWWH
YDOOpHTXHM·DLGLWHLPPHQVHµ
 LLL  ,'5೏<04.!I#10%V%4#?!0%S#$+#)1>´$VFOHSLXVFLWR\HQELWK\QLHQµ S#$+')10 FI*DOGL

>E@ O·DFFXVDWLIDOWHUQHDYHFOHJpQLWLI FI*DOGL
 L  ,/%೏H1-(G#0%:-(Z$!@-%!#10%>!>6-#(>%4(10(>%I601#$´VRQIUqUH'XUD]LVO·pULJHDjVDPpPRLUHµ%
>!>6-#(!
 LL  &೏$-#1>:($6-%$!--(!%(4%>(-#(%?#4$6-´WULRPSKDWHXUSDUWHUUHHWSDUPHUµ >(-#1>
>F@ O·DFFXVDWLIUHPSODFHSDUIRLVO·DEODWLIGDQVOHVFRQVWUXFWLRQV´DEVROXHVµ
 L  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏31>X1!%-!]2%(1"#$(0%!#10%#)I-6&#$($!02%#100#00!$%
V%´(WTXDQGOHURLD\DQWUHoXOHVQRXYHOOHVGHVHVFULPHVDYDLWGRQQpO·RUGUHTXHVY%
(1"#$#0%V%#)I-6&#$($#&10

/·DFFXVDWLIWHQGGRQFjUHPSODFHUSOXVLHXUVFDVHQODWLQYXOJDLUHWDUGLIHWOHVIDLWVREVHUYpVGDQVOHVODQJXHV
URPDQHVUHIOqWHQWVRQLPSRUWDQFHGDQVODODQJXHSDUOpH­FDXVHGXGpYHORSSHPHQWSKRQpWLTXHODGLIIpUHQFH
HQWUHODSURQRQFLDWLRQGHO·DFFXVDWLIHWGHSOXVLHXUVDXWUHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVHVWGHYHQXHLPSHUFHSWLEOH FIH[HPSOH
>@ &HODDPrPHSURYRTXpXQFKHYDXFKHPHQWDYHFOHQRPLQDWLIXQSUREOqPHUpVROXSDUO·LQWURGXFWLRQGDQVOHV
ODQJXHVURPDQHVG·XQRUGUHGHVPRWVIL[H

#?@C<@28BD%<9%5@28BD%<9%E:1828B%92%<9A%<4762841A%=3:=4A8284119<<9A
/HGpYHORSSHPHQWGHVDXWUHVFDVREOLTXHVHVWVXUWRXWFDUDFWpULVpSDUO·LPSRUWDQFHFURLVVDQWHGHVORFXWLRQV
SUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHVPDLVDXVVLSDUXQHWHQGDQFHGXJpQLWLIjV·pWDOHUDX[GpSHQVGHVDXWUHVFDV

#9%7F9;@67F9>912%91239%<9A%7@A%92%<9A%=3:=4A82841A
'DQVOHODWLQWDUGLIHWYXOJDLUHF·HVWVXUWRXWODSUpSRVLWLRQ"!TXLWHQGjUHPSODFHUOHJpQLWLIGDQVSOXVLHXUV
IRQFWLRQVSDUH[HPSOHOHJpQLWLI´REMHFWLI µ>D@HWOHJpQLWLIGHTXDOLWp>E@PDLVOHJpQLWLIHVWDXVVLUHPSODFp
SDUG·DXWUHVSUpSRVLWLRQVO@

>D@ "!DEODWLIDXOLHXGXJpQLWLIREMHFWLI&\SULHQ<"%H6)($1>೏)1..10%"!%.!5#&10%>!$10%!0$2%
"!%X1(!0#$6-!2%"!%#1"#4!%I(?6-%)1..10´LOQ·\DDXFXQHFUDLQWHGHVORLVDXFXQHFUDLQWHGHV
DXWRULWpVSROLFLqUHVHWMXGLFLDLUHVµ ODWLQFODVVLTXH>!$10%.!51>´ODFUDLQWHGHVORLVµ
>!$10%(%I-(!$6-!´ODFUDLQWHGXSUHWpXUµ
>E@ "!  DEODWLI DX OLHX GX JpQLWLI GH TXDOLWp 2URVH N#&!-% (I6.65!$#410% 46)$-(% @!.(5#()60%
೏+6>#)!0%V%"!%#..(%4(-)(.#%(--65()$#(´OHVKRPPHVGHFHWWHDUURJDQFHFKDUQHOOHµ

/·HPSORLGXGDWLIVHPEOHrWUHHQFRUHUHODWLYHPHQWVWDEOHDX,9JVLqFOHPDLVDX9,JVLqFOHQRXVWURXYRQVXQ
HPSORLQRXYHDXSRXUOHGDWLIGDQVSOXVLHXUVIRQFWLRQV(QPrPHWHPSVQRXVSRXYRQVREVHUYHUTXHOHGDWLIWHQGj

9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U†
 O@
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U
FGHW9llQlQHQ†²FI+HOWWXODHW*DOGL †DԆD۟HW9llQlQHQ†
²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8KH%TL%AL%O<T8KN/BD

rWUHUHPSODFpSDUODFRQVWUXFWLRQDYHF("fDXOLHXGXGDWLIDYHFOHVYHUEHVTXLRQWOHVHQVGH´GLUHµQRXVWURXYRQV
FKH]XQDXWHXUGX9,JVLqFOHODSUpSRVLWLRQ("DYHFO·DFFXVDWLI>@

>@ *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏("%!I#046I1>%(#!&($´LOGLVDLWjO·pYrTXHµ 
!I#046I6HQODWLQFODVVLTXH

0DLVSDUIRLVO·HPSORLGXGDWLIVHPEOHUHIOpWHUOHUHPSODFHPHQWGXFDVSDUODORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHTXLD
OLHXGDQVODODQJXHSDUOpH$YHFOHVYHUEHVGHPRXYHPHQWQRXVWURXYRQVQRUPDOHPHQWODORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQ
QHOOHWDQWHQODWLQFODVVLTXHTX·HQODWLQWDUGLIOLWWpUDLUHHWPRLQVOLWWpUDLUH>D@'DQVXQWH[WHPRLQVOLWWpUDLUH
GHODPrPHpSRTXHQRXVWURXYRQVFHSHQGDQWDXVVLOHGDWLI>E@&HWHPSORLGXGDWLIHVWDVVH]UDUHHWYXOJDLUH
YHUVODILQGX,9JVLqFOHPDLVLOGHYLHQWSOXVIUpTXHQWHWQRXVOHWURXYRQVPrPHFKH]OHVDXWHXUVOLWWpUDLUHVDX9,J%
VLqFOHOP,OSHXWDORUV\DYRLUDOWHUQDQFHHQWUHGDWLIHWORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHjO·LQWpULHXUGHVPrPHVWH[WHV

>D@ ("DYHFOHVYHUEHVGHPRXYHPHQW ODWLQFODVVLTXH

 L  6W$XJXVWLQ ² VW\OHpOHYp36):!00#6)!0೏#)"!%("%>($-!>%#)5-!"#>1-´GHOj
QRXVVRPPHVHQWUpVFKH]PDPqUHµ
 LL  /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(! YHUV VW\OHUHODWLYHPHQWEDV
% % ೏31>%(1$!>%#)5-!00#%:1#00!>10%("%!60´8QHIRLVHQWUpVFKH]HX[µ
% % ೏(4%0#4%!-56%"!)16%I.#4(?#>10%)60%("%>(-!´HWQRXVQRXVVRPPHVjQRXYHDXDSSURFKpV
GHODPHUµ
>E@ GDWLIDYHFOHVYHUEHVGHPRXYHPHQW ODWLQWDUGLI
 L  /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(! YHUV VW\OHUHODWLYHPHQWEDV
% % ೏#)5-!0010%!0$%"#04#I1.#0´LOHQWUDDXPLOLHXGHVGLVFLSOHVµ
% % ೏41>%#(>%I-6I!%I.#4(-!)$%4#?#$($#´DORUVTX·LOVDWWHLJQDLHQWSUHVTXHODYLOOHµ
 LL  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ² VW\OHPR\HQ
% % D.6-#(%>(-$'-1>೏.#$6-#%41#%("?!)!-($´LOpWDLWYHQXDXULYDJHµ
% % O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏!1>%4#?#$($#%#)$-6>#0#$´LOOHILWHQWUHUGDQVODYLOOHµ
% % D.6-#(%46):!006-1>೏-#I(!%(.$!-#%01>10%"!?!4$#´QRXVVRPPHVDUULYpVjO·DXWUHULYHµ

$YHFOHVQRPVGHYLOOHVOHODWLQFODVVLTXHFRQVHUYHXQHPSORLDUFKDwTXHGHVFDVDEVHQWGHODSOXSDUWGHVORFX
WLRQVD\DQWOHVPrPHVIRQFWLRQV1RXVDYRQVQRWpO·HPSORLGHO·DFFXVDWLIGHPRXYHPHQWDYHFOHVQRPVGHYLOOH
SDUIRLVUHPSODFpSDUODORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHHWPrPHSDUOHGDWLI FIH[HPSOH>@ /HORFDWLIQHVXEVLVWHHQ
ODWLQTXHGDQVXQSHWLWQRPEUHGHORFXWLRQV3DUPLHOOHVVHWURXYHQWOHVQRPVGHYLOOHV'DQVOHVWH[WHVOLWWpUDLUHV
GHO·pSRTXHWDUGLYHRQREVHUYHHQFRUHFHWXVDJHGXORFDWLI>D@PDLVXQQRXYHDXFKHYDXFKHPHQWDYHFXQHORFX
WLRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHDSSDUDvWDXVVLOHFKRL[GHODSUpSRVLWLRQ(I1">E@VHPEOHSRXUWDQWPRLQVYXOJDLUHTXHOH
FKRL[GHODSUpSRVLWLRQ#)>F@:?

>D@ ORFDWLI ODWLQFODVVLTXH

 L  VW\OHpOHYp
  6\PPDTXH YHUV²YHUV 8I#0$1.(!೏I!-(4$6%X16"%K6>(!%(5!-!%"!0$#)(0$#0´D\DQW
DFKHYpFHTXHYRXVYRXVSURSRVLH]GHUpJOHUj5RPHµHWA!"#6.()#%$!%(5!-!%
´TXHWXHVj0LODQµ
  6W$XJXVWLQ ² 36):!00#6)!0೏0$1"1!-($%V%3(-$+(5#)#´LODYDLWpWXGLpj&DUWKDJHµ


9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†²+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U 9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U
:?

†HW9llQlQHQ† †FI+DYHUOLQJ²VT
OP
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†²HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U
†FI%RQQHWVTT6NDKLOO%LHWHUVTT
0ROLQHOOLHW+DYHUOLQJ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N8%FN,**8A8B*%8B*K8%N87%3<7%8B%N<*/B%*<KH/F% 

 LL  VW\OHPR\HQ
  2URVH GpEXWGX9JV O#0$6-#(!೏I(1.#0I!-%<.!]()"-#(!%01&0$#$#$´LOILWKDOWHj$OH[DQGULH
=FL7%LH%MFMJHKY
  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ² O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>SO೏:#.#6%K6>(!%-!.!4$6´OHILOV
D\DQWpWpODLVVpj5RPHµ
>E@ (I1"DFFXVDWLI QRQFODVVLTXH 
 L  VW\OHpOHYp
  6\PPDTXH YHUV²YHUV 8I#0$1.(!೏41#%.(-%(I1"%<-#>#)1>%:1#$´TXLDYDLWVD
PDLVRQj5LPLQLµ
  6W$XJXVWLQ ² 36):!00#6)!0೏(I1"%3(-$+(5#)!>%:6!"(%!0$%!$%#)$!>I!-()0%.#4!)$#(%
04+6.(0$#46-1>´ODOLFHQFHVDQVFRQWU{OHGHVpWXGLDQWVj&DUWKDJHHVWKRUULEOHµ
 LL  VW\OHPR\HQ
  2URVH GpEXWGX9JV O#0$6-#(!I!0$#.!)$#(%#)5!)0%(I1"%K6>(>%46):.(5-(?#$´XQH
JUDQGHSHVWHVpYLWj5RPHµ
 LLL  VW\OHUHODWLYHPHQWEDV
% % /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(! YHUV ೏X1(>%V%(I1"%/!-106.#>(>%)6?!-(>´TXHM·DYDLVFRQQXH
j-pUXVDOHPµ
>F@ #)DEODWLI QRQFODVVLTXH
 L  VW\OHPR\HQ
  2URVH GpEXWGX9JV O#0$6-#(!೏$!--(!%>6$10%#)%<)$#64+#(%I(!)!%$6$(>%01&-1#$%
4#?#$($!> ´XQ WUHPEOHPHQW GH WHUUH j $QWLRFKH UHQYHUVD SUHVTXH OD YLOOHµ
HW  #)%<.!]()"-#(%(1$!>%46>>#006%I-6!.#6 ´TXDQG OD EDWDLOOH IXW OLYUpH j
$OH[DQGULHµ
 LL  VW\OHUHODWLYHPHQWEDV
% % /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(! YHUV ೏#)%S!$+.!!>%I!-1#5#.()$%V%X1#(%!I#046I1>%)!4!00!%!0$%
+60%"#!0%0!>I!-%#)%/!-106.#>(%$!)!-!´LOVYHLOOHQWj%HWKOpHPV%TXDQWjO·pYrTXHLO
GRLWWRXMRXUVFpOpEUHUFHVMRXUVGHIrWHj-pUXVDOHPµ

/·HPSORLLQFRUUHFWGXORFDWLIGDQVTXHOTXHVWH[WHVPRLQVOLWWpUDLUHVPRQWUHTXHFHWWHIRUPHQ·pWDLWSOXVIUp
TXHQWHGDQVODODQJXHGHWRXVOHVMRXUV>D@ FIH[HPSOH>@ SDUIRLVQRXVUHQFRQWURQVPrPHXQHIRUPHQRQ
GpFOLQpHGDQVFHWWHIRQFWLRQ>E@

>D@ ORFDWLIK\SHUFRUUHFWDXOLHXGHO·DFFXVDWLIGHPRXYHPHQW³VW\OHEDV
 L  SHXWrWUHFKH]3pWURQHDX,J7VLqFOH7($'-#4(೏:6-$!%"6>#)10%3(I1(!%!]#!-($´OHPDvWUH
pWDLWVRUWLSRXUDOOHUj&DSRXHµ 3(I1(>
 LL  HQODWLQWDUGLI
% % 1JKL9%-6K8H6%**%*#>6$+!10FRGH[G?!)#00!$%K6>(!´LOpWDLWYHQXj5RPHµ K6>(>
  -RUGDQqVK6>()(೏K6>(!%I-6:!4$10´SDUWLSRXU5RPHµ K6>(>
  -RUGDQqVD!$#4(೏X1($$16-%:#.##0%"6>#%"#>#00#0%´TXDQGTXDWUHGHVILOVpWDLHQWHQYR\pVj
ODPDLVRQµ "6>1>
>E@ IRUPHQRQGpFOLQpH
 L  VW\OHPR\HQ
  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ² O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>%SO೏H1>%V%-!5#)(%@(-#0#10%
>6-(-!$1-´SHQGDQWTXHODUHLQHUHVWHj3DULVµ
 LL  VW\OHUHODWLYHPHQWEDV
% % /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(! YHUV ೏8I#046I#%V%+#0"!>%"#!&10%/!-106.#>(%I.10%X1("-(5#)$(%V%
01)$´LOVVRQWFHVMRXUVOjj-pUXVDOHPSOXVGHTXDUDQWHRXFLQTXDQWHµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8KH%TL%AL%O<T8KN/BD

'DQVOHVH[SUHVVLRQVLQGLTXDQWOHGpSDUWG·XQHYLOOH K6>(´GH5RPHµ(%K6>(´GH5RPHµ RQWURXYHGqV

O·pSRTXHFODVVLTXHXQHDOWHUQDQFHHQWUHO·DEODWLIVpSDUDWLIHWODORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOH(QODWLQWDUGLIQRXV
WURXYRQVQRUPDOHPHQWGDQVFHFDVODORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHO·HPSORLGHO·DEODWLIVHXODXQFDUDFWqUHWUqV
OLWWpUDLUH>D@/HVDXWHXUVOLWWpUDLUHVHPSORLHQWSOXW{WODSUpSRVLWLRQ(&>E@WDQGLVTXHODODQJXHGHWRXVOHV
MRXUVSUpIqUHODSUpSRVLWLRQ"!>F@:O'DQVFHFDVDXVVLQRXVWURXYRQVSDUIRLVGHVIRUPHVQRQGpFOLQpHV>G@

>D@ DEODWLIGHVpSDUDWLRQ K6>(´GH5RPHµSDUH[HPSOH&LFpURQ

 L  VW\OHWUqVOLWWpUDLUH$PPLHQ0DUFHOOLQ ,9JV ೏#I0!%<)$#64+#(%I-6$#)10%!5-!001-102%1$%
36)0$()$#)6I6.#>%#)$!-#>%I!$!-!$%V%´LODYDLWO·LQWHQWLRQGHV·HQDOOHUDXVVLW{WG·$QWLRFKH
SRXUGLULJHUVDFRXUVHYHUV&RQVWDQWLQRSOHµ
>E@ (&DEODWLI (%K6>(µGH5RPHµSDUH[HPSOH7LWH/LYH
 L  VW\OHpOHYp
  6W$XJXVWLQ ² 36):!00#6)!0೏>#001>%!0$%(%A!"#6.()#6%K6>(>%("%I-(!:!4$1>%1-&#0%
´XQPHVVDJHIXWHQYR\pGH0LODQDXSUpIHWGHODYLOOHj5RPHµHW36):!00#6)!0%
೏($X1!%(%*+(5(0$!)0#%6II#"6%?!)#%3(-$+(5#)!>´MHVXLVYHQXj&DUWKDJHGHODYLOOH
GH7KDJDVWHµ
 LL  VW\OHPR\HQ
  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ² O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>SO೏-!5-!0010%V%(%K6>(´UHWRXUQp
j5RPHµ
>F@ "!DEODWLI ODWLQWDUGLI
 L  VW\OHPR\HQ
  2URVH GpEXWGX9JV O#0$6-#(!೏T(.!)0%!5-!0010%"!%<)$#64+#(´TXDQG9DOHQVDYDLW
TXLWWp$QWLRFKHµ
  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ² O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>SO೏-!5!%!5-!006%"!%@(-#0#10%
´TXDQGOHURLDYDLWTXLWWp3DULVµ
 LL  VW\OHUHODWLYHPHQWEDV
% % /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(! YHUV ೏I-6:!4$(%01>%"!%/!-106.#>(´MHVXLVGRQFSDUWLHGH
-pUXVDOHPµHW೏I-6:!4$(%01>%"!%<)$#64+#(%("%A!06I6$(>#(>´MHVXLVGRQFSDUWLH
G·$QWLRFKHYHUVOD0pVRSRWDPLHµHWI-6:#4#04!)0%"!%*+(-06%V%´SDUWDQWGH
#679JY
>G@ IRUPHVQRQGpFOLQpHV
 L  VW\OHUHODWLYHPHQWEDV
% % /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(! YHUV ೏@-6:#4#04!)0%!-56%/!-106.#>(%:(4#!)0%#$!-%41>%0()4$#0%
´3DUWDQWGH-pUXVDOHPHWIDLVDQWURXWHDYHFGHVVDLQWVµ

/HJpQLWLISDUWLWLILQGLTXHOHWRXWGRQWRQH[WUDLWXQHSDUWLH0DLVGpMjjO·pSRTXHFODVVLTXHRQWURXYHDXVVL
OHVSUpSRVLWLRQV!]%JK%"!GDQVOHVH[SUHVVLRQVSDUWLWLYHV>D@(QODWLQWDUGLIO·HPSORLGHVSUpSRVLWLRQVGDQVFHWWH
IRQFWLRQDXJPHQWH>E@&KH]OHVDXWHXUVOLWWpUDLUHVO·XVDJHFRUUHVSRQGDVVH]ELHQjFHOXLGXODWLQFODVVLTXH
/·HPSORLIUpTXHQWGHODSUpSRVLWLRQHVWXQPDUTXHXUGHVLPSOLFLWpVW\OLVWLTXHPDLVODORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOH
UHPSODoDQWOHJpQLWLIWHQGjUHSUHQGUHXQHIRQFWLRQTXHOHJpQLWLIDYDLWSHUGXHHQODWLQjVDYRLUODIRQFWLRQTXL
LQGLTXHODTXDQWLWpLQGpILQLHGHTXHOTXHFKRVH::

>D@ ODWLQFODVVLTXH
 L  JpQLWLI&LFpURQH!%)($1-(%"!6-1>೏1)10%!6-1>%/6?!%)($10%V%(.$!-%O'I!-#6)!%V%´O·XQ
G·HQWUHHX[HVWQpGH-XSLWHUO·DXWUHG·+\SpULRQµ
 LL  !]g7LWH/LYH೏1)10%!]%##0%"6>1>%(&##$´O·XQG·HQWUHHX[V·HQHVWDOOpjODPDLVRQµ

9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U†
:O
FI+DYHUOLQJ²VT
::
(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U†D
=XVԆHW9llQlQHQ†FI+DYHUOLQJHW
0ROLQHOOLVTTVTT
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N8%FN,**8A8B*%8B*K8%N87%3<7%8B%N<*/B%*<KH/F% 

 LLL  "!g&LFpURQ@-6%F.(446೏0#%X1#0%V%"!%)60$-#0%+6>#)#&10´VLTXHOTX·XQGHQRVKRPPHV2Y%
3pWURQH7($'-#4(೏$(>X1(>%1)10%"!%)6&#0´FRPPHO·XQGHQRXVµ
>E@ ODWLQWDUGLI
 L  JpQLWLISDUWLWLI
% % /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏.6410%!?()5!.##%-!01--!4$#6)#0%´OHSDVVDJHGHO·pYDQJLOHGHOD
UpVXUUHFWLRQµ H[HPSOH HW೏I(-0%X1(!"(>%:.1>#)#0%B#.#´XQEUDVGXIOHXYH
1LOµHW೏#)%!(%I(-$!%-#I(!2%X1(%!0$%/!-#4+6´VXUODULYHGXIOHXYHRVHWURXYH
-pULFKRµHW೏.!4$(%!$#(>%I(-0%X1!"(>%H!1$!-6)6>##%#)%!6%.646%V%´RQDOXHQ
FHOLHXXQSDVVDJHGX'HXWpURQRPHµHW೏#)%#I0(%01>>#$($!%>6)$#0%V%´VXUOH
VRPPHWOXLPrPHGHFHWWHPRQWDJQHµ
 LL  "!DEODWLI
% % /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏.6410%"!%.#&-6%-!5)6-1>´OHSDVVDJHGXOLYUHGHV5qJQHVµ 
H[HPSOHV
% % /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏:1)"(>!)$(%"!%4(0$-#0%:#.#6-1>%/0-(+!.%!$%+(&#$($#6)#&10%#I06-1>´OHV
IRQGDWLRQVGXFDPSGHVILOVG·,VUDsOHWGHOHXUVKDELWDWLRQVµHW೏06.(%"!%#..#0%
X1#)X1!´ODVHXOHGHVFLQTµHW೏"!%(-5!)$6%!$%"!%+!-(>!)$6%>6"#4(%:-10$!..(´GH
PHQXVIUDJPHQWVG·DUJHQWRXGHEURQ]HµHW೏01>>#$($!0%"!%.#5)6%0()4$6´OHV
H[WUpPLWpVGXERLVVDFUpµ
 LLL  IRQFWLRQLQGpILQLHDYHF"!DEODWLI
% % /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏"!"!-1)$%)6&#0%I-!0&'$!-#%.64#%#I0#10%!1.65#(02%#"%!0$%"!%I6>#0´OHV
SUrWUHVGXOLHXQRXVILUHQWGHSHWLWVSUpVHQWVjVDYRLUGHVIUXLWVµ
  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVD.6-#(%>(-$'-1>%೏"!%0()4$(%4!-(%01I!-%(-&6-!>%I601#´MHPLVGHOD
VDLQWHFLUHVXUO·DUEUHµ

'DQVOHODWLQFODVVLTXHO·DEODWLIGHWHPSVLQGLTXHOHPRPHQWRV·DFFRPSOLWO·DFWLRQ SDUH[HPSOH+(4%)64$!%
´FHWWHQXLWµ!6%$!>I6-!´jFHPRPHQWµ+#!>!´HQKLYHUµ RXOHODSVGHWHPSVGXUDQWOHTXHOVHSDVVHXQpYpQH
PHQW &#"16´HQGHX[MRXUVµ (QODWLQWDUGLIQRXVWURXYRQVVRXYHQWO·DEODWLIGDQVFHWWHIRQFWLRQ>D@PDLVQRXV
WURXYRQVDXVVLTXHOHVORFXWLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHVWHQGHQWjUHPSODFHUO·DEODWLIVHXO>E@ :Q,O\DEHDXFRXSGH
YDULDWLRQGDQVOHVPrPHVWH[WHVGHFHSRLQWGHYXH

>D@ O·DEODWLILQGLTXHOHPRPHQW
 L  6W$XJXVWLQ ²
% % H!%46)0!)01%!?()5!.#0$(-1>೏V%(>!)%"#46%$#&#2%X1#(%+(4%)64$!2%()$!X1(>%5(..10%4()$!$2%$!-%
>!%)!5(&#0%V%´MHWHGLVYUDLPHQWTXHFHWWHQXLWDYDQWTXHOHFRTFKDQWHWXPH
7JH8J769Y
% % H!%46)0!)01%!?()5!.#0$(-1>೏$(>X1(>%0#%(.#41#%"#4!-!$1-%+(4%)64$!2%()$!X1(>%5(..10%
4()$!$2%("%>!%04-#&!0%!I#0$1.(>2%#)%X1(%>#+#%$!-%46)1#4#(&!-#0%V%´FRPPHVLO·RQGLVDLW
jTXHOTX·XQTXHFHWWHQXLWDYDQWTXHOHFRTFKDQWHWXP·pFULUDVXQHOHWWUHGDQV
ODTXHOOHWXP·LQVXOWHUDVWURLVIRLVµ
 LL  /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(! YHUV
% % ೏4#?#$(02%X1(!%:1#$%#..6%$!>I6-!%V%´XQHYLOOHTXLH[LVWDLWHQFHWHPSVOjµ
% % ೏!(%"#!´FHMRXUOjµ
 LLL  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ²
% % +#0%"#!&10 *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>H[HPSOHVOHVDXWUHV±XYUHV
H[HPSOHV

9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U
:Q

†FI+DYHUOLQJ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8KH%TL%AL%O<T8KN/BD

% % !6%$!>I6-! *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>H[HPSOHVOHVDXWUHV±XYUHV
H[HPSOHV +64%$!>I6-! O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>H[HPSOHVOHVDXWUHV±XYUHV
>E@ #)DEODWLI
 L  6W$XJXVWLQ ²
% % H!%46)0!)01%!?()5!.#0$(-1>೏(#$%#..#%/!010g%(>!)%"#46%$#&#2%X1#(%#)%+(4%)64$!2%()$!X1(>%
5(..10%4()$!$2%$!-%>!%)!5(&#0´HW-pVXVOXLDGLWMHWHGLVYUDLPHQWTXHFHWWHQXLW
DYDQWTXHOHFRTFKDQWHWXPHUHQLHUDVµ LELG
 LL  /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(! YHUV
% % ೏B(>%46)01!$1"6%$(.#0%!-($%#)%#..6%$!>I6-!2%1$%V%´&DUF·pWDLWO·KDELWXGHHQFHWHPSVOjµ
% % ೏#)%!(%"#!2%X1(%>6)0%:1>#5(&($´HQFHMRXURODPRQWDJQHpWDLWIXPDQWHµ
% % ೏#&#%!-56%>()0#>10%#)%!(%)64$!´QRXVVRPPHVUHVWpVOjFHWWHQXLWOjµHW೏#)%#0"!>%
"#!&10´SHQGDQWFHVMRXUVOjµ
 LLL  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ²
% % O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏8-($%#)%+#0%"#!&10%?#-%.(1"(&#.#0%0()4$#$($#0%«´LO\DYDLWjFHWWH
pSRTXHOjXQKRPPHGHJUDQGHVDLQWHWpVY
% % O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏!$%6>)#&10%#):#->#0%>(5)1>%#)%+64%$!>I6-!%+(&!$1-%I-(!0#"#1>´HW
SRXUWRXVFHX[TXLVRQWIDLEOHVLO\DjFHPRPHQWXQHJUDQGHSURWHFWLRQµ

/·DQFLHQLQWUXPHQWDOH[SULPDLWOHPR\HQHPSOR\pSRXUIDLUHTXHOTXHFKRVH(QODWLQFODVVLTXHRQWURXYH
VRXYHQWO·DEODWLIVHXOGDQVFHWWHIRQFWLRQPDLVRQ\WURXYHDXVVLVRXYHQWODSUpSRVLWLRQI!-HWSDUIRLVPrPHOD
SUpSRVLWLRQ41>>D@/·HPSORLGHODFRQVWUXFWLRQDYHF"!DEODWLIVHPEOHDYRLUpWpUHODWLYHPHQWYXOJDLUHDX,9J%
VLqFOHPDLVFHWHPSORLGHYLHQWSOXVIUpTXHQWDX9,JVLqFOH>E@'DQVXQWH[WHDVVH]SHXOLWWpUDLUHTXLVHPEOH
rWUHpFULWYHUVODILQGX,9 JVLqFOHQRXVWURXYRQVGDQVFHWWHIRQFWLRQXQHDOWHUQDQFHHQWUHO·DEODWLIVHXOHWOD
FRQVWUXFWLRQDYHF"!0DLVGDQVOHVWH[WHVWDUGLIVO·DEODWLILQVWUXPHQWDOSHXWDXVVLrWUHUHPSODFpSDUG·DXWUHV
FRQVWUXFWLRQV:<

>D@ ODWLQFODVVLTXH
 L  DEODWLI&pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>೏5.("##0%I15)($1>%!0$´RQFRPEDWWLWDYHFO·pSpHµHW
೏.#$$!-#0%d%4!-$#6-%:#!&($´LOIXWLQIRUPpSDUXQHOHWWUHµ
 LL  I!-DYHFGHVSHUVRQQHV&pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>೏I!-%!]I.6-($6-!0%4!-$#6-%:(4$10%
´LQIRUPpSDUGHVHVSLRQVµ
 LLL  41>g&DWXOOH²೏#0$(%41>%.#)51(%V%I600#0%V%´WXSHX[DYHFFHWWHODQJXHµ LVWčOLQJXč
>E@ ODWLQWDUGLI
 L  DEODWLI/$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏:-14$10%X160%V%>()#&10%01#0%!.(&6-(00!%?#"!()$1-´DORUVTX·LOV
RQWUpFROWpOHVIUXLWVGXWUDYDLOGHOHXUPDLQVµ
 LL  I!-g%(8J7FHEML92%8I#0$1.(!೏0#%.64(%0()4$(%I!-%#"6.(%I6..1#00!)$´V·LODYDLHQWVRXLOOpOHV
OLHX[VDLQWVDYHFGHVLGROHVµ
 LLL  41>g%*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏46):-(4$1>%41>%>(..!#0´EULVpjFRXSVGH
M67KJ6LY
 LY  "!
% % /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏"!%>()#&10%01#0%01>>#$($!0%V%I-!>!$´LODSSXLHGHVHVPDLQVVXU
OHVH[WUpPLWpVVY
  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏+6--!(%"!%.(I#"#&10%X1("-#0%(!"#:#4(?#$´LO
FRQVWUXLWGHVJUHQLHUVDYHFGHVSLHUUHVFDUUpHVµ

:<
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†²+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U
†HW9llQlQHQ†FIGHOD9LOOD
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N8%FN,**8A8B*%8B*K8%N87%3<7%8B%N<*/B%*<KH/F% 

  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVD.6-#(%>(-$'-1>೏"!%I(..(%V%641.60%(&0$!-5!)0´HQHVVX\DQWOHV\HX[
DYHFOHPDQWHDXµ
 Y  (&
  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏V%(&%1)(%>()1%I(..(0%(.$(-#0%$!)!-!>%V%(&%(.#(%
?!-6%V%4.!-#460%V%I-60$!-)!-!>´TXHMHWHQDLVODQDSSHG·DXWHODYHFXQHPDLQHW
DEDWWDLVOHVFOHUFVDYHFO·DXWUHµ
  *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>%೏(&%+#0%$!%5.("##0%$-()0:6"!-!%?6.1!>10´QRXV
YRXO€PHVWHWUDQVSHUFHUDYHFFHVpSpHVµ

'DQVFHVH[HPSOHVO·DOWHUQDQFHHQWUHOHVFDVHWOHVWRXUQXUHVDYHFOHVSUpSRVLWLRQVVHPEOHGRQFrWUHGHFDUDF
WqUHVW\OLVWLTXH/DORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQHOOHVHUDLWOHPDUTXHXUG·XQVW\OHSHXpOHYpPDLVGDQVFHUWDLQHVIRQFWLRQV
RQWURXYHXQHDOWHUQDQFHHQWUHFDVHWORFXWLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHVPrPHGDQVOHVWH[WHVGHVDXWHXUVOLWWpUDLUHV

09%<?@C<@28BD%56%5@28B%92%56%14>81@28B%@6%E:1828B
'DQVOHODWLQFODVVLTXHOHJpQLWLISHXWLQGLTXHUFHTXLHVWW\SLTXHSRXUTXHOTX·XQRXFHTXLGpSHQGGHTXHOTXH
FKRVH,O\DXVVLXQHPSORLPRLQVIUpTXHQWGXJpQLWLISRXULQGLTXHUODFDXVHRXODILQDOLWp>D@'DQVOHODWLQWDUGLI
OLWWpUDLUHQRXVWURXYRQVHQFRUHOHJpQLWLIGHSURSULpWpTXLPDLQWHQDQWLQGLTXHDXVVLSDUIRLVODFDXVH>E@:R

>D@ ODWLQFODVVLTXH
 L  SURSULpWp
% % 5>6LKJ2% 3(I$#?# ೏!0$% >#0!-6-1>2% 1$% >(.!?6.!)$!0% 0#)$% !$% #)?#"!()$% &6)#0 ´LO HVW
FDUDFWpULVWLTXHGHVPDOKHXUHX[G·rWUHPDOYHLOODQWVHWGHSRUWHUHQYLHDX[ERQVµ
  &LFpURQH!%:($6೏1$%0!"!(>10%X1#"!>%(1$%(>&1.!>10%?6.1)$($#0%!00!´VLQRXVQRXVWURXYRQV
DVVLVRXVLQRXVQRXVSURPHQRQVFHODGpSHQGGHQRWUHYRORQWpµ
 LL  FDXVH
% % K+!$6-#4(%("%O!-!))#1>೏1$-1>%(?(-#$#(!%()%!5!0$($#0%(44!00#$%("%>(.!:#4#1>´V·LODIDLW
GXPDOSRXUFDXVHG·DYDULFHRXSRXUFDXVHGHSDXYUHWpµ
% % 3/N;46)0!-?6%I#!$($#0%:!4#$´jVRQFRPSDJQRQG·HVFODYDJHSDUDPRXUµ
>E@ ODWLQWDUGLI
 L  SURSULpWp6\PPDTXH8I#0$1.(!೏)1)4%$1(-1>%I(-$#1>%!-#$%-!0I6)"!-!´PDLQWHQDQWFH
VHUDWRQU{OHGHPHUpSRQGUHµ
 LL  FDXVH
  6\PPDTXH8I#0$1.(!೏0!"%?!.#>%4-!"(02%#):6-$1)##%:1#00!%)6)%?6.1)$($#02%X16"%"#1%6::#4#6%
04-#I$#6)#0%(&0$#)1#´0DLVMHYRXGUDLVTXHWXOHFURLHVFHWWHORQJXHQpJOLJHQFH
HVWO·HIIHWGXPDOKHXUQRQFHOXLGHPDYRORQWpµ
  6\PPDTXH8I#0$1.(!%೏X16"%04-#&#02%?6.1)$(-#(!%&!)#5)#$($#0%!0$2%X16"%0!-62%41-(-1>´WX
pFULVF·HVWOHSURSUHG·XQHELHQYHLOODQFHVSRQWDQpHPDLVDYHFUHWDUGOHVVRXFLV
HQVRQWODFDXVHµ
  6\PPDTXH8I#0$1.(!%೏X16"%)1..(0%01>I0#%.#$$!-(0%$1(0%V%04#6%)6)%:1#00!%:(0$#"##%$1#´6L
MHQ·DLSDVUHoXGHOHWWUHGHWRL«MHVDLVTXHFHQHIXWSDVO·HIIHWGHO·HQQXLµ

'DQVOHODWLQFODVVLTXHQRXVUHQFRQWURQVFHJpQLWLIDYHFXQDWWULEXWSRXULQGLTXHUFHTXLFRUUHVSRQGjO·KDEL
WXGHGHTXHOTX·XQ>D@PDLVGDQVOHODWLQSRVWFODVVLTXHRQWURXYHFHJpQLWLIPrPHVDQVDWWULEXWHWGDQVODPrPH
IRQFWLRQTXHOHQRPLQDWLI>E@'DQVOHODWLQWDUGLIQRXVWURXYRQVFHJpQLWLIpJDOHPHQWDYHFG·DXWUHVPRWVHW

:R
9RLU+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U†ED=XVǓFI/|IVWHGW
VTTHW+DYHUOLQJ²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8KH%TL%AL%O<T8KN/BD

GDQVODPrPHIRQFWLRQTXHOHQRPLQDWLI>F@3RXUPDSDUWMHGRXWHTXHFHSKpQRPqQHDLWYUDLPHQWDSSDUWHQX
jODODQJXHSDUOpH:@

>D@ DX,J7VLqFOHDYDQW-&
 L  JpQLWLIDWWULEXW&LFpURQ/)%T!--!>೏)!5(?#$%>6-#0%!00!%D-(!46-1>2%1$%#)%46)?#?#6%
?#-6-1>%(441>&!-!)$%>1.#!-!0´LODGLWTX·LOQ·pWDLWSDVFRQIRUPHjO·KDELWXGHGHV*UHFV
TXHOHVIHPPHVSDUWLFLSHQWDXIHVWLQGHVKRPPHVµ
 LL  QRPLQDWLIHWGDWLI7LWH/LYH೏>60%!-($%F(.#04#0%!6"!>%>(5#0$-6%1$#%V%´OHV)DOLVTXHV
DYDLHQWO·KDELWXGHG·DYRLUOHPrPHFKHI µ
>E@ DX,J7VLqFOHDSUqV-&
 L  JpQLWLIVDQVDWWULEXWHWDYHFGDWLI9HOOHLXV3DWHUFXOXV೏0#41$#%5FM=J8F%>6-#0%!-($%
´FRPPHF·pWDLWO·KDELWXGHGH3RPSpHµ
>F@ ODWLQWDUGLI
 L  JpQLWLIVDQVDWWULEXWHWDYHFGDWLI
% % /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏/"%!)#>%)6&#0%0!>I!-%46)01!$1"#)#0%!-($2%1$%V%´7HOOHpWDLWHQHIIHW
QRWUHFRQVWDQWHKDELWXGHVYHW೏0#)51.(2%X1(!%46)01!$1"#)#0%)6&#0%!-()$%:(4!-!%
V%´FKDFXQHGHVFKRVHVTXHQRXVpWLRQVDFFRXWXPpVjIDLUHµ 46)01!$1"6%)6&#0%
!0$%´QRXVDYRQVO·KDELWXGHµ
 LL  JpQLWLIVDQVDWWULEXW QRPLQDWLI/$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏"!0#"!-##%!-56%:1#$2%1$%V%´M·DYDLV
GRQFO·HQYLHGHVY
 LLL  JpQLWLIDYHFDWWULEXW QRPLQDWLI6\PPDTXH8I#0$1.(!೏?1.5($#%X1#II!%I-6?!-&##%!0$2%
!)(?#5($6%A(.!6%6&.#>(-#%!(-1>%>!>6-#(>2%X160%"6>#%-!.#X1!-#0%V%´FDUVHORQXQSURYHUEH
ELHQFRQQXXQHIRLVSDVVpOHFDS0DOpHRQHIIDFHGHVDPpPRLUHFHX[TXLVRQWODLVVpV
jODPDLVRQµ

/·DEODWLIDFRPPHQRXVO·DYRQVYXUHPSODFpO·DFFXVDWLIGDQVTXHOTXHVXQHVGHVIRQFWLRQVDGYHUELDOHVPDLV
LOHVWDXVVLUHPSODFpSDUOHJpQLWLIGDQVFHUWDLQHVGHVHVDXWUHVIRQFWLRQV(QODWLQFODVVLTXHO·DEODWLIGHTXDOLWp
GpVLJQHODSDUWLFXODULWpG·XQLQGLYLGXWDQGLVTXHOHJpQLWLIGHTXDOLWpGpVLJQHO·HVSqFHGHTXHOTXHFKRVHRXO·pYD
OXDWLRQG·XQHVRUWHGHFKRVH>D@'HSXLVOHODWLQFODVVLTXHRQSHXWREVHUYHUXQFHUWDLQGHJUpGHFKHYDXFKHPHQW
GHVGHX[FRQVWUXFWLRQVHWGDQVOHODWLQSRVWFODVVLTXHO·DEODWLIGHTXDOLWpHVWVRXYHQWUHPSODFpSDUOHJpQLWLI>E@
GDQVOHODWLQWDUGLIO·DEODWLIHVWXQDUFKDwVPHTXHO·RQWURXYHVXUWRXWGDQVOHVWH[WHVOHVSOXVOLWWpUDLUHV>F@ 

>D@ ODWLQFODVVLTXH
 L  DEODWLI
  &pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>೏3L%T(.!-#1>%@-64#..1>%V%01>>(%?#-$1$!%!$%+1>()#$($!%
("1.!04!)$!>´XQMHXQHKRPPHGHODSOXVJUDQGHYHUWXHWERQWpµ
  &LFpURQ/)%T!--!>,,೏>1.#!-!>%!]#>#(%I1.4+-#$1"#)!´XQHIHPPHG·XQHEHDXWp
H[WUDRUGLQDLUHµ
 LL  JpQLWLI
% % 5>6LKJ2%A!-4($6-೏5!)!-#0%D-(!4#%!0$´LOHVWGHUDFHJUHFTXHµ
  &pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>%೏:600(%I!"1>%X1#)"!4#>´XQHIRVVHGHSLHGVµ
>E@ GHO·DEODWLIDXJpQLWLI
 L  GHSXLVOHODWLQFODVVLTXH
% % &pVDUS!..1>%D(..#41>೏+6>#)!0%V%>(5)(!%?#-$1$#0´GHVKRPPHVG·XQJUDQGFRXUDJHµ
  &LFpURQH!%.!5#&10೏1#-%>(5)#%#)5!)## JpQ 01>>(X1!%I-1"!)$#( DEO ´XQKRPPHGH
JUDQGWDOHQWHWGHODSOXVJUDQGHVDJHVVHµ


9RLU+DYHUOLQJ²FIOHQRPLQDWLIFKH]6pQqTXH 8I#0M 9RLU+DYHUOLQJVTFI/|IVWHGWVTT
:@

$1.(!೏T!$10%I-6?!-&#1>%!0$%5.("#($6-!>%#)%+(-!)(%4(I!-!%46)0#.#1>g% 9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U


(.#X1#"% ("?!-0(-##% ?1.$102% (.#X1#"% >()10% >6$(2% (.#X1#"% #I0(% #)4.#)($#6% †FI+DYHUOLQJVTT
46-I6-#0%#)$1!)$!>%>6)!$ 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N8%FN,**8A8B*%8B*K8%N87%3<7%8B%N<*/B%*<KH/F% 

 LL  OHJpQLWLIFRPPHQFHjVHVXEVWLWXHUjO·DEODWLIDX,J7VLqFOHDSUHV-&
% % 5>8HJ2%B($1-(.#0%+#0$6-#(%೏A#)!-?(>%V%!]#>#(!%I1.4+-#$1"#)#0 JpQ ´XQHVWDWXHGH
0LQHUYHG·XQHEHDXWpH[WUDRUGLQDLUHµ
>F@ ODWLQWDUGLI
 L  DEODWLI UDUH &DVVLRGRUHO#0$6-#(೏&6)(%0I!4#!%46)#15!>%V%´XQHpSRXVHGHEHODVSHFWµ
 LL  JpQLWLI WUqVIUpTXHQW *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏F!--!6.10%>(5)(!%?#-%
0()4$#$($#0%V%´XQKRPPHGHJUDQGHSURELWpµ
,OH[LVWHSOXVLHXUVH[HPSOHVGHFHUDSSRUWHQWUHO·DEODWLIOHJpQLWLIHWODSUpSRVLWLRQ"!'DQVODIRQFWLRQGH
FRPSOpPHQWGHO·DGMHFWLIO·DEODWLITXHQRXVWURXYRQVHQODWLQFODVVLTXH>D@HVWVRXYHQWUHPSODFpSDUODSUpSR
98K8FH%"!GDQVOHODWLQWDUGLIPRLQVpOpJDQW>E@HWSDUOHJpQLWLIGDQVOHVWH[WHVOLWWpUDLUHV>F@:P

>D@ ODWLQFODVVLTXHDEODWLI&LFpURQH!%6-($6-!೏.#$$!-#0%#)0$-14$#6-´SOXVYHUVpGDQVOD
OLWWpUDWXUHµ
>E@ ODWLQWDUGLIVW\OHPR\HQRXEDV³"!DEODWLI/$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏?(."!%#)0$-14$10%
!0$%"!%04-#I$1-#0´WUqVYHUVpGDQVOHVeFULWXUHVµ
>F@ ODWLQWDUGLIVW\OHpOHYpJpQLWLI6XOSLFH6pYqUH3+-6)#4(?#-%"#?#)(-1>%-!-1>%
#)0$-14$#00#>10´WUqVYHUVpGDQVOHVFKRVHVVDLQWHVµ

3DUIRLVQRXVWURXYRQVPrPHOHJpQLWLIDXOLHXGHODSUpSRVLWLRQGXODWLQFODVVLTXH$YHFGHVYHUEHVFRPPH
"#00!)$#-!´rWUHG·XQDYLVGLIIpUHQWµ>D@HW!-1&!04!-!´DYRLUKRQWHµ>E@OHODWLQFODVVLTXHHPSORLHQRUPDOHPHQW
ODSUpSRVLWLRQ"!DYHFO·DEODWLIDORUVTXHOHODWLQWDUGLIOLWWpUDLUHHPSORLHUDVRXYHQWOHJpQLWLIQ?

>D@ "#00!)$#6´MHVXLVG·XQDYLVGLIIpUHQWGHTXHOTXHFKRVHµ
 L  ODWLQFODVVLTXHSUpSRVLWLRQ&LFpURQH!%6-($6-!೏41-%"64$#00#>#%+6>#)!0%"!%>(]#>#0%
-!&10%"#00!)$#()$´SRXUTXRLOHVKRPPHVOHVSOXVpUXGLWVRQWGHVRSLQLRQVGLIIpUHQWHV
GHVFKRVHVOHVSOXVLPSRUWDQWHVµ
 LL  ODWLQWDUGLIOLWWpUDLUHJpQLWLI6\PPDTXH8I#0$1.(!೏$1)4%)60$-($!0%?#-#2%X1#%#)$!-%0!%
(.#(-1>%-!-1>%0(!I!%"#00!)$#1)$2%46)46-"!>%0!)$!)$#(>%01I!-%+1#10%.(1"!%$!)1!-1)$´1RV
FRQFLWR\HQVTXLVRXYHQWVXUG·DXWUHVSRLQWVQHV·HQWHQGHQWSDVHQWUHHX[RQWHQFHWWH
RFFDVLRQHXVXUOHVPpULWHVGH3DOODGLXVGHVDYLVFRQFRUGDQWVµ
>E@ !-1&!046´MHGHYLHQVURXJHGHKRQWHµ´M·DLKRQWHGHTXHOTXHFKRVHµ
 L  ODWLQFODVVLTXHSUpSRVLWLRQ6pQqTXHO·$QFLHQ36)$-6?!-0#(!೏)!4!00!%!0$%"!%(.##0%
X1!-(-2%"!%(.##0%!-1&!04(>´LOHVWQpFHVVDLUHTXHMHPHSODLJQHGHVDXWUHVTXHMHVRLV
KRQWHX[GHVDXWUHVµ
 LL  ODWLQWDUGLIOLWWpUDLUHJpQLWLI+LHURQ\PXV8I#0$1.(!೏)6)%!-1&!046%#):!.#4#$($#0%>!(!%
V%´MHQ·DLSDVKRQWHGHPRQPDOKHXUµ

,OHVWSUREDEOHTXHO·HPSORLGXJpQLWLIGDQVFHVH[HPSOHVVRLWOLpjO·HPSORLGXJpQLWLIDYHFOHVDGMHFWLIV
H[HPSOH>@ 
4XHOTXHVQRXYHOOHVORFXWLRQVDYHFOHJpQLWLIHWDYHFODSUpSRVLWLRQ"!PRQWUHQWpJDOHPHQWXQHUHVVHPEODQFH
UHPDUTXDEOH'DQVOHODWLQFODVVLTXHRQHPSORLHXQDGMHFWLIFRPPHK6>()10%FL%7(-"10SRXULQGLTXHUTXHTXHOTX·XQ
HVW´GH5RPHµRX´GH6DUGDLJQHµSDUH[HPSOH0DLVGDQVOHODWLQWDUGLIRQWURXYHVRXYHQWGDQVFHVIRQFWLRQXQH
H[SUHVVLRQDWWULEXWLYHFRQWHQDQWODSUpSRVLWLRQ"!>D²E@QO/HVORFXWLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHVVHPEOHQWpJDOHPHQW
UHPSODFHUGHVDGMHFWLIVFRPPH4(!.!0$#0%JK%0(!41.(-#0SDUH[HPSOH>F@'DQVOHVWH[WHVOLWWpUDLUHVOHJpQLWLIVHPEOH

:P
 9RLU +DYHUOLQJ    VTT     VT FI QO
9RLU+DYHUOLQJHW0ROLQHOOLFI
9llQlQHQ &ODLULQVT
Q?
9RLU+DYHUOLQJVT
 oi.uchicago.edu

:P?% D8KH%TL%AL%O<T8KN/BD

SDUIRLVDYRLUXQHIRQFWLRQTXLFRUUHVSRQGjFHWHPSORLDWWULEXWLIGHODORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOH>D²E@Q:%*>%J9K%
SUREDEOHTXHFHTXHO·RQDVRXYHQWDSSHOpOHJpQLWLIGHTXDOLWpVDQVDWWULEXWVRLWOLpjFHGpYHORSSHPHQWQQ

>D@ G·XQHYLOOHRXG·XQYLOODJH FIK6>()10´GH5RPHµ

% /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏41>%0()4$#02%#"%!0$%I-!0&'$!-6%!$%"#(46)#&10%"!%/!-106.'>(´DYHF
GHVVDLQWVXQSUrWUHHWGHVGLDFUHVGH-pUXVDOHPµ
% /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏I-!0&'$!-%.64#%#I#102%#"%!0$%"!%N#&#("(!´XQSUrWUHGHFHWHQGURLW
F·HVWjGLUHGH/LYLDVµ
% /$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!೏!I#046I10%.64#%#I0#102%#"%!0$%"!%7!56-%´O·pYrTXHGHFHWHQGURLW
F·HVWjGLUHGH6pJRUµ
>E@ G·XQSD\V FI7(-"10%´GH6DUGDLJQHµ
 6\PPDTXH8I#0$1.(!$೏X160"(>%(.#60%"!%7(-"#)#(%V%0!)($6-!0´FHUWDLQVDXWUHV
VpQDWHXUVRULJLQDLUHVGH6DUGDLJQHµ
>F@ G·XQDXWUHOLHX
 6\PPDTXH8I#0$1.(!೏"!%0!I$!>%>6)$#&10%?#-1>´XQKRPPHGHVVHSWFROOLQHVµ
% #J7KL>>8JH2%<"?!-010%A(-4#6)!>೏()5!.10%"!%4(!.6´XQDQJHFpOHVWHµ 4(!.!0$#0
% "E=78JH2%8I#0$1.(!"!%0(!41.6%+6>#)!0%´GHVKRPPHVGHFHPRQGHµ% 0(!41.(-!0
>D@ G·XQHYLOOHRXG·XQYLOODJH
 *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVD.6-#(%46):!006-1>೏:1#$%?#-%?#$(!%@(1.#)10%B6.()(!%1-&#0%!]%)6&#.!%
0$#-I!%6-$10´O·KRPPHGHYLH3DXOLQXVGHODYLOOH1RODIXWRULJLQDLUHG·XQHIDPLOOH
QREOHµ B6.()10
>E@ G·XQDXWUHOLHX
 6\PPDTXH 8I#0$1.(! ೏0#% 46)$!>I.!-#0% ("% ?#4#)#(>% K+!)#% V% )1..1>% I(-$#1>%
)60$-(-1>%46>>!(-!´VLWXFRQVLGqUHVTXHYHUVOHVSDUDJHVGX5KLQSHUVRQQHGH
QRVUpJLRQVQHVHGpSODFHµ
>F@ §?#-%"!%?#$( VFLO(!$!-)( FI+6>6%"!%0(!41.6
 *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVD.6-#(%46):!006-1>೏:1#$%?#-%?#$(!%@(1.#)10%B6.()(!%1-&#0%!]%)6&#.!%
0$#-I!%6-$10´O·KRPPHGHYLH3DXOLQXVGHODYLOOHGH1RODIXWRULJLQDLUHG·XQH
G6M8>>J%HFD>JY

,OHVWGLIILFLOHGHQHSDVYRLUXQUDSSRUWHQWUHO·HPSORLGHODSUpSRVLWLRQ"!HWO·HPSORLGXJpQLWLIGDQVFHVFDV
PDLVFHODQHYHXWSDVGLUHTXHQRXVGHYLRQVGpILQLUO·HPSORLGXJpQLWLIXQLTXHPHQWFRPPHXQHPSORLK\SHUFRUUHFW
/HJpQLWLIDUULYDLWSDUIRLVjPDUTXHUOHSRLQWGHGpSDUWORFDO>E@>E@SHXWrWUHSDUXQHVRUWHGHFRQWDPL
QDWLRQGHODWRXUQXUHSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOH>D@>D@Q<

>D@ ODWLQFODVVLTXH³(&
 7LWH/LYH೏X1#)X1!%(&%1-&!%>#.#(%I(0011>%V%´FLQTPLOOHSDVGHOD9LOOH 5RPH µ
>E@ ODWLQWDUGLI³JpQLWLI
 (XWURSH೏10X1!%("%X1#)$1>%>#.#(-#1>%T-&#0´MXVTX·DXJPLOOLDLUHGHOD9LOOHµ "!%
1-&!S
 &DVVLRGRUHT(-#(!೏#)$-(%X1("-(5!0#>1>%0(4-($#00#>(!%1-&#0´HQGHojGXJ%
PLOOLDUHGHODYLOOHµ
>D@ ODWLQWDUGLI³(&
 *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏"!$-(4$1%(%&(.$!6%5.("#6´D\DQWWLUpO·pSpH
GXEDXGULHUµ

Q:
9RLU+DYHUOLQJVTT >(5)#X1!%>!-#$#´XQKRPPHKRQRUDEOHHWGHPpULWHµ 6\PPDTXH
QQ
9RLU+DYHUOLQJVTTFI%RQQHWFI´XQKRPPH 8I#0$1.(!% 
GHOHWWUHVµ ?#-%.#$$!-(-1>ODWLQWDUGLI ?#-%.#$$!-($10ODWLQFODVVLTXH Q<
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U
6\PPDTXH8I#0$1.(! HW?#-%+6)6-#0%!$%>!-#$#%§%?#-%>(5)#%+6)6-#0% †D=XV˗
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N8%FN,**8A8B*%8B*K8%N87%3<7%8B%N<*/B%*<KH/F% :PO

>E@ JpQLWLI
 *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏!]$-(4$6%&(.$!#%5.("#6´D\DQWWLUpO·pSpHGX
EDXGULHUµ "!%&(.$!6S

2QUHQFRQWUHSDUIRLVGHVH[HPSOHVDVVH]VXSUHQDQWVGHFHWWHWHQGDQFH(QODWLQFODVVLTXHFHUWDLQHVH[SUHV
VLRQVFRQWLHQQHQWXQDFFXVDWLIDGYHUELDOHWXQJpQLWLITXL¬FRUUHVSRQGHQWjO·DEODWLI!6%$!>I6-!GDQVOHVHQVGH´j
FHPRPHQWµ1RXVWURXYRQVTXHOTXHVH[HPSOHVGHFHWWHWRXUQXUHDUFKDwTXHFKH]OHVDXWHXUVWDUGLIVOLWWpUDLUHV
>D@QR'DQVXQHLQVFULSWLRQRQWURXYHFHSHQGDQWDXVVLXQH[HPSOHGHJpQLWLIVHXOGDQVODIRQFWLRQGHO·DEODWLIGH
WHPSV>F@,OHVWSRVVLEOHTXHFHVRLWODWRXUQXUHDYHFDFFXVDWLIHWJpQLWLITXLVHFDFKHGHUULqUHFHWWHFRQVWUXF
K8FH2PDLVLOHVWDXVVLSRVVLEOH³HWSHXWrWUHPrPHSUREDEOH³TXHQRXVD\RQVLFLXQH[HPSOHGHODFRQIXVLRQ
GHVIRQFWLRQVGXJpQLWLIHWGHO·DEODWLI>E@

>D@ DFFXVDWLIJpQLWLIHQODWLQWDUGLIOLWWpUDLUH ODWLQFODVVLTXH

 6\PPDTXH8I#0$1.(!೏)(>%S(#(!%#"%$!>I6-#0%#(>%0#.!&()$´FDUj%DwDVGpVRUPDLV
OHVLOHQFHpWDLWUHYHQXµ
>E@ )64$1%X%)64$!%X%"!%)64$!´ODQXLWGDQVODQXLWµ GHSXLVOHODWLQSUpFODVVLTXH
>F@ JpQLWLI DEODWLI"
 ,/,೏3+#))(>#0%NL%8))#%3.!>!)$#0%46)$1&!-)(.#0%&!)!%>!-!)$#%I60#$%+1)4%$#$1.1>%(44!I#%
01I-!>#%$!>I6-#0%(%$!%>()"($1%I601#´&KLQQDPLVO·DPLHGH/(QQLXV&OHPHQV
ILWIDLUHFHWWHLQVFULSWLRQjVRQDPLTXLOHPpULWH-HO·DLIDLWIDLUHD\DQWHXDX
GHUQLHUPRPHQWGHWRLODFKDUJHGHOHIDLUHµ 01I-!>6%$!>I6-!S

0rPHFKH]OHVDXWHXUVOHVSOXVOLWWpUDLUHVQRXVWURXYRQVSDUIRLVXQHPSORLGXJpQLWLIVXUSUHQDQWTXLIDLW
SHQVHUjXQFKHYDXFKHPHQWHQWUHFHFDVHWO·DEODWLIHWOHVORFXWLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHVQ@

06%5@28B%@6%E:1828B
/DGDWLIH[SULPDQWODILQDOLWpTXHQRXVWURXYRQVDVVH]VRXYHQWHQODWLQFODVVLTXH>D@GHYLHQWUDUHGDQVOH
ODWLQWDUGLIPDLVQRXVOHWURXYRQVHQFRUHFKH]TXHOTXHVDXWHXUVGHJUDQGHFXOWXUHOLWWpUDLUH>E@3DUIRLVLOHVW
UHPSODFpSDUOHQRPLQDWLI>F@HWTXHOTXHIRLVPrPHSDUOHJpQLWLI>G@

>D@ ODWLQFODVVLTXHGDWLI&pVDUS!..1>%4#?#.!೏31-#6%V%!]#!-($%46+6-$#&10%T%I-(!0#"#6%4(0$-#0%
-!.#4$#0´&XULRV%pWDLWSDUWLDSUqVDYRLUODLVVpFLQTFRKRUWHVSRXUODGpIHQVHGXFDPSµ
>E@ ODWLQ WDUGLI OLWWpUDLUH HW pOHYp ,9 J  V  GDWLI 6\PPDTXH 8I#0$1.(!   $#&#%
I!-!5-#)($#6)!>%0!)#6%!00!2%#)?#$10%(1"#?#´WRQpORLJQHPHQWWHFKDJULQHUDLWYRLOjFHTXH
M·DLDSSULVjUHJUHWµ
>F@ ODWLQWDUGLIOLWWpUDLUH 9,JV QRPLQDWLI&DVVLRGRUHO#0$6-#(೏7#%41#%(1$!>%+(!4%!00!$%
41-(´VLFHODpWDLWO·REMHWGHVRXFLSRXUTXHOTX·XQµ 41-(!
>G@ ODWLQWDUGLIVW\OHPR\HQHWEDVJpQLWLI
% &7F9J2%O#0$6-#(!೏I!->!$#!)02%-!>%01#0%>(]#>#%I!-#41.#%:6-!´HQFDOFXODQWTXHOD
FKRVHVHUDLWWUqVGDQJHUHXVHSRXUVHVKRPPHVµ
% &7F9J2%O#0$6-#(!೏1)1>%06.1>%!00!%I-(!0#"##2%0#%V%´TX·XQHFKRVHXQLTXHPHQW
VHUYLUDLWGHGpIHQVHVLVY

QR
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U 9RLU+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U†E=XVࣹFI6YHQQXQJ


†D=XVɘ ²/|IVWHGWVTT*DOGLHW+DYHUOLQJ

9RLU*DOGLVT 
Q@
9RLU+DYHUOLQJ
 oi.uchicago.edu

:P:% D8KH%TL%AL%O<T8KN/BD

 *UpJRLUHGH7RXUVD.6-#(%>(-$'-1>೏I1$()0%0#&#%I-(!0#"##%:6-!2%0#%V%´HQSHQVDQW
TX·LOOXLVHUYLUDLWGHVHFRXUVVLVY
 3pWURQH7($'-#4(೏+64%"!"!46-#0%I6I1.6 VFLO!0$ ´FHODHVWXQREMHWGHKRQWH
=FL7%>J%=JL=>JY

­O·DEODWLIVpSDUDWLIVHUDWWDFKHOHFRPSOpPHQWFRPSDUDWLIVDQVSUpSRVLWLRQ'DQVOHODWLQFODVVLTXHO·DEODWLID
FHWWHIRQFWLRQVXUWRXWTXDQGO·DGMHFWLIFRPSDUDWLIHVWDXQRPLQDWLI>D@PDLVQRXVDYRQVDXVVLODFRQVWUXFWLRQ
DYHF%X1(>TXLHVWIUpTXHQWGDQVOHVDXWUHVFDV>E@QP

>D@ ODWLQFODVVLTXHO·DEODWLIGHFRPSDUDLVRQ
% 5>6LKJ2%<0#)(-#(೏$!%V%)#+#.%!0$%#>I1"!)$#10¬´ULHQQ·HVWSOXVLPSXGHQWTXHWRLµ
 +RUDFH3(->#)(:6)0%V%0I.!)"#"#6-%1#$-6¬´IRQWDLQHSOXVEULOODQWHTXHOHFULVWDOµ
>E@ ODWLQFODVVLTXHX1(>
 &LFpURQ8I#0$1.(!%("%:(>#.#(-!0೏$#&#%>1.$6%>(#6-#%X1(>%<:-#4()10%:1#$´jWRLTXLHV
EHDXFRXSSOXVJUDQGTXHQHIXWO·$IULFDLQµ

(QODWLQWDUGLIQRXVWURXYRQVVRXYHQWO·DEODWLIGHFRPSDUDLVRQHWX1(>GDQVFHWWHIRQFWLRQ>D²E@PDLV
GDQVOHODWLQWDUGLIPRLQVpOpJDQWRQUHQFRQWUHDXVVLOHJpQLWLI>D@HWOHGDWLI>E@/·DEODWLIHVWUHODWLYHPHQW
UDUHFKH]*UpJRLUHGH7RXUVTXLVHPEOHHPSOR\HUDVVH]VRXYHQWOHGDWLI VLO·RQSHXWVHILHUjO·RUWKRJUDSKHGHV
PDQXVFULWV <?1RXVWURXYRQVOHJpQLWLIGDQVTXHOTXHVWH[WHVWUDGXLWVGXJUHFPDLVDXVVLGDQVGHVWH[WHVpFULWV
GLUHFWHPHQWHQODWLQ

>D@ ODWLQWDUGLIDEODWLI
 &DVVLRGRUH YHUV³YHUV VW\OHpOHYp%8]I60#$#6%I0(.>6-1>X1#%!1>%>#)6-!>%
I($-!%1!.%:#.#6%"#4#$´TXLGLWTX·LOHVWSOXVSHWLWTXHOHSqUHRXOHILOVµ
 *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ² VW\OHPR\HQ
% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏LQKDF VFLO4!..6.( I!-%64$6%(1$%!6%(>I.#10%())60%46>>6-($10%
´pWDQWUHVWpSHQGDQWKXLWDQVRXSOXV¬GDQVFHOLHXµ
% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏)1&0%6>)!%.14!%.14#"#6-2%#)%X16%)6)%06.%V%01I!-%+#0%6>)#&10%)($1-(.#%
.14!%0I.!)"#"#10%!::1.5!&($%V%´XQQXDJHSOXVFODLUTXHODOXPLqUHV%D78>>68K%9L7%KFL9%
FHVFKRVHVDYHFXQHOXPLqUHSOXVFODLUHTXHODOXPLqUHQDWXUHOOHµ
>E@ ODWLQWDUGLIX1(>
 *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ² VW\OHPR\HQO#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏)#+#.%>!.#10%X1(>%>!%
#I01>%#)?!)#´MHQ·DLULHQWURXYpSOXVLPSRUWDQWTXHPRLPrPHµ
>D@ ODWLQWDUGLIJpQLWLI
 /XFLIHU&DODULWDQXV PRUWYHUV H!%-!5#&10%(I60$($#4#0೏41#10%$1%#)%4-1"!.#$($!%
!$%0(4-#.!5#6%)6)%>#)6-%!0´WXQ·HVSDVSOXVSHWLWTXHOXLGDQVODFUXDXWpHWOH
VDFULOqJHµ
% T#$(!%I($-1> 9,JV
% ೏41>%0#0%6>)#1>%>#)6-´SDUFHTXHWXHVSOXVSHWLWTXHWRXVOHVDXWUHVµ FI
JUHFࢆԆ໵‫ߥڗݰࠗ͘཭ݰ‬%›ඦဎࠗङဎ
% ೏6>)#1>%I!44($6-1>%!00!%"!$!-#6-!>´TX·LOVRLWSLUHTXHWRXVOHVSpFKHXUVµ
FIJUHF›ඦဎࠗङဎනࢆǓ‫ࠗݰ‬ङड़཭ࠗ͘‫ڗݰ‬ဎ
% ೏>#)6-!>%!00!%$6$#10%4-!($1-(!%´SOXVSHWLWTXHWRXWHODFUpDWLRQµ

QP
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U† <?
 9RLU %RQQHW    VHORQ %RQQHW  QRXV DYRQV 
H[HPSOHVGHO·DEODWLIGXGDWLISHXWrWUHGXJpQLWLIH[HPSOHV
DYHFX1(>HWDYHF(&FKH]*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N8%FN,**8A8B*%8B*K8%N87%3<7%8B%N<*/B%*<KH/F% :PQ

>E@ ODWLQWDUGLIGDWLI
 *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ² VW\OHPR\HQ
% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏)!4%>#)6-!>%F#.#1>%@($-#%7I#-#$1#X1!%0()4$62%)!X1!%7I#-#$1>%
0()4$1>%>#)6-!>%@($-#%?!.%F#.#6´HWOH)LOVQ·HVWSDVSOXVSHWLWTXHOH3qUHHWOH
6DLQW(VSULWHWOH6DLQW(VSULWQ·HVWSDVSOXVSHWLWTXHOH3qUHHWOH)LOVµ
% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏B6)%!0$%!-56%(!X11>2%1$%!#%0#>#.#0%!0$#>!$1-2%41#%0!%>#)6-!>%"#4#$%
´LOQ·HVWSDVMXVWHTX·LOVRLWFRQVLGpUpFRPPHVHPEODEOHjFHOXLSDUUDSSRUW
DXTXHOLOGLWTX·LOHVWSOXVSHWLWµ
% O#0$6-#(% F-()46-1> ೏)1..1>% 0#&#% I1$()0% #)% 0()4$#$($!% +(&!-#% I-(!0$()$#6-!> ´HQ
SHQVDQWTX·LOQ·\DSHUVRQQHTXLH[FHOOHSOXVTXHOXLPrPHHQLQWpJULWpµ
% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏B1..1>X1!%0#&#%("0!-!&($%!00!%I-1"!)$#6-!>´LOGLVDLWTX·LOQ·\
DYDLWSHUVRQQHGHSOXVSUXGHQWTXHOXLPrPHµ
>F@ (&
 *UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ² VW\OHPR\HQ
% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏0!)#6-%(%S-1)#4+#."!´SOXVkJpHTXH%UXQKLOGHµ
% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏>!.#6-!>%(%0!%!]#0$#>()0´TX·LOSHQVDLWPHLOOHXUTXHOXLPrPHµ
% T#$(!%I($-1> 9,JV 
 ೏>#)6-!>%(&%!6´SOXVSHWLWTXHOXLµ
'DQVOHODWLQWDUGLIGX9,JVLqFOHQRXVWURXYRQVFHFKHYDXFKHPHQWHQWUHOHGDWLIHWOHJpQLWLIGDQVSOXVLHXUV
IRQFWLRQV
/HGDWLIGDQVGHVH[SUHVVLRQVGHSRVVHVVLRQHVWXQDUFKDwVPHV\QWD[LTXHHQFRUHWUqVIUpTXHQWGDQVOHODWLQ
FODVVLTXHRFHWWHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOWHUQHFHSHQGDQWDYHFOHYHUEH´DYRLUµHWDYHFOHJpQLWLIGHSRVVHVVLRQ,O\D
EHDXFRXSG·H[HPSOHVG·XQHPSORLFODVVLTXHGHFHWWHORFXWLRQHQODWLQWDUGLI>D@PDLVGDQVOHODWLQWDUGLIFH
GDWLIDODIRQFWLRQG·LQGLTXHUOHSRVVHVVHXUpJDOHPHQWTXDQGLOHVWDGQRPLQDO>E@,O\DPrPHGHVH[HPSOHVGH
ORFXWLRQSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOH>F@<O

>D@ GDWLIGHSRVVHVVLRQHPSORLSUpGLFDW*UpJRLUHGH7RXUV ²

% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏>(#6-%!#%?#-$10%()$!%!I#046I($1>%:1#$´VDYHUWXpWDLWSOXVJUDQGH
DYDQWO·pSLVFRSDWµ
% O#0$6-#(%F-()46-1>೏41#%X1(.#0%#)$!-#$10%:1!-#$%V%´TXHOOHIXWVDPRUWµ
>E@ GDWLIGHSRVVHVVLRQHPSORLDGQRPLQDOLQVFULSWLRQV
% 3/N;,,,೏X1#%:6!-1)$%:#.#%A(5)6´TXLpWDLHQWOHVILOVGH0DJQXVµ
% 3/N;,,,೏I60$%46)06.($6%/>I6-$1)6%?#-6%4.(-#00#>6´DSUqVOHFRQVXODWGH,PSRUWXQXV
9&µ
 66,%೏46)#1]%V%@L%K(0#)(4#6%V%"!:1)4$(%!0$%V%´ODIHPPHGH35DVLQDFLRHVWPRUWHµ%
FI*DOGL
>F@ ("GHSRVVHVVLRQLQVFULSWLRQV
% 3/N;,,, 9, JV ೏+#4%-!X1#!041)$%>!>&-(%("%"110%:-($-!02%D(..6%!$%F#"!)4#6´LFL
UHVWHQWOHVPHPEUHVGHVGHX[IUqUHV*DOOXVHW)LGHQFLXVµ

0DLVSDUIRLVF·HVWOHJpQLWLITXLUHPSODFHOHGDWLI(QODWLQFODVVLTXHHWSRVWFODVVLTXHQRXVWURXYRQVVHORQV
OHVPDQXVFULWVTXHOTXHVH[HPSOHVGHJpQLWLIGDQVGHVORFXWLRQVRO·RQDQRUPDOHPHQWOHGDWLI>D²E@SDUIRLV
QRXVUHQFRQWURQVFHSKpQRPqQHGDQVXQHLQVFULSWLRQ,O\DSOXVLHXUVH[HPSOHVGHFHWHPSORLHQODWLQYXOJDLUH
HWWDUGLIQRWDPPHQWGDQVOHVLQVFULSWLRQV>F@<:

>D@ ODWLQFODVVLTXHOLWWpUDLUH
 &LFpURQH!%6-($6-!೏)($1-(%-!-1>2%41#10%465)#$#6%>(5)(>%6-($#6)#0%01II!"#$($%46I#(>%
´ODQDWXUHGHVFKRVHVGRQWODFRQQDLVVDQFHIRXUQLWJUDQGHDEERQGDQFHDX
GLVFRXUVµ 6-($#6)#

<O
9RLU(UQRXWHW7KRPDV†HW+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U† <:
9RLU+RIPDQQHW6]DQW\U†D=XV˗
 oi.uchicago.edu

:P<% D8KH%TL%AL%O<T8KN/BD

 7LWH/LYH೏>!-4!0%0!"#$#6)#0%I-6I60#$(%46):!0$#>%0!"#$#6)!>%!]4#$(?#$%´ODUpFRPSHQVH
SUpVHQWpHSRXUUpYROWHUSURYRTXDDXVVLW{WXQHUpYROWHµ¬ VHGLWLRQL
>E@ ODWLQSRVWFODVVLTXH
 OLWWpUDLUH4XLQWLOLHQH!4.(>($#6)!0%>#)6-!0೏#)%X16%!0$%!>!)"($#6)#0%.6410´RLO\
DSODFHSRXUODFRUUHFWLRQµ !>!)"($#6)#
 YXOJDLUH 3RPSHL 3/N,9೏\$-#10X1!%&!)!%!?!)#($´TX·LODLWXQERQUpVXOWDWSRXU
WRXVOHVGHX[µ 1$-#X1!
>F@ ODWLQWDUGLIYXOJDLUHLQVFULSWLRQV *DOGL
 $(೏AL%T(.!-#10%,>1)4#6%V%:!4#$%>6)#>!)$1>%T(.!-#)#%:#.#2%X1#%?#]#$%>!)0!0%T//%
´0¬9DOHULXV2PXQFLRDIDLWFHPRQXPHQWIXQpUDLUHjVRQILOV9DOHULQXVTXLD
YpFXSHQGDQWPRLVµ
 ,06೏"16%5!->()60%V%<)$6)#)6%!$%D!)$#6)!2%X1#%#)%1)6%>!)0!%0#>1.%?#$(%:#)#-1)$%!$%
>(]#>6%.14$1 >(]#>1>%.14$1> >($-#0%"!-!.#X1!-1)$´GHX[IUqUHV$QWRQLQXV
HW*HQWLRTXLSHQGDQWOHPrPHPRLVRQWDFKHYpOHXUYLHHQVHPEOHHWTXLRQW
ODLVVpOHXUPqUHGDQVOHFKDJULQOHSOXVSURIRQGµ >($-#
 $(೏F6.)#%A(-4!..10%V%?6$1>%I($-#0%"!"#4´0DUFHOOXVDGpGLpV%OHVY±X[jVRQ
SqUHµ I($-#

/·DEODWLIHVWDXWDQWUHPSODFpSDUOHJpQLWLI H[HPSOHV>@>@ TXHSDUGHVORFXWLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHV

H[HPSOHV>@>@>@>@ /HGDWLIpJDOHPHQWHVWUHPSODFpSDUGHVORFXWLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHV H[HPSOHV
>@>@ PDLVLODOWHUQHDXVVLDYHFOHJpQLWLI H[HPSOHV>@>@ /HJpQLWLIDOXLDXVVLXQUDSSRUWDYHFOHVORFX
WLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHV VXUWRXWFHOOHVFRQWHQDQWODSUpSRVLWLRQ"!`HPSOR\pHVGHSOXVLHXUVIDoRQVHQODWLQWDUGLI
H[HPSOHV>@>@>@²>@ 

-417<6A841
/HPRW´IORWWHPHQWµLPSOLTXHXQFHUWDLQGHJUpG·LQFHUWLWXGH0DLVQRXVQRWRQVTX·DYDQWODWRWDOHFRQIXVLRQ
WURXYpHGDQVFHUWDLQVWH[WHVWUqVWDUGLIVLOH[LVWHXQHSKDVHGH´FKHYDXFKHPHQWFURLVVDQWµHQWUHOHVGLIIpUHQWHV
IRQFWLRQVGHVORFXWLRQV/HSUREOqPHIRQGDPHQWDOSRVpSDUOHVWH[WHVHVWFHOXLGHVDYRLUVLOHFKHYDXFKHPHQWHQWUH
OHVFDVHVWOHUpVXOWDWG·XQHPSORLSOXVIUpTXHQWGHVORFXWLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHV HWGRQFXQLTXHPHQWOHUpVXOWDW
GHFHUWDLQHVK\SHUFRUUHFWLRQV ³RXV·LO\DDXVVLpFKDQJHGHIRQFWLRQVHQWUHOHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHV
­QRWUHDYLVODUpSRQVHHVWFRPSOH[H³LO\DVDQVGRXWHGHVH[HPSOHVGDQVOHVTXHOVOHFKRL[G·XQFDVHVW
OHUpVXOWDWG·XQPDOHQWHQGX0DLVQRXVSHQVRQVTX·jSOXVLHXUVUHSULVHVLOV·DJLWELHQG·XQHPSORLQRXYHDXGHV
DQFLHQQHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHV
1RXVWURXYRQVSOXVLHXUVQLYHDX[GHVW\OHGDQVOHODWLQWDUGLIHWEHDXFRXSG·pFULYDLQVVRQWVRXPLVjO·LQIOXHQFH
WUqVIRUWHGHVWH[WHVOLWWpUDLUHVGHO·pSRTXHFODVVLTXHFHTXLUHQGO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHVWpPRLJQDJHVTXHQRXVWURX
YRQVGDQVOHVWH[WHVWDUGLIVIRUWFRPSOLTXpH/HIDLWTX·LO\DLWSOXVLHXUVFRQWUDGLFWLRQVGDQVOHVWH[WHVHWHQWUHOHV
PDQXVFULWVGHVWH[WHVHVWpJDOHPHQWSUREOpPDWLTXH
(QILQPDOJUpOHVSUREOqPHVFDXVpVSDUODWUDGLWLRQOLWWpUDLUHQRXVWURXYRQVTXHPrPHOHVWH[WHVOHVSOXV
pOpJDQWVQRXVGRQQHQWGHSUpFLHXVHVLQIRUPDWLRQVVXUOHGpYHORSSHPHQWGHODODQJXH

.C3:;8@2841A
!)% N;())U!%UI#5-(I+#X1!L%3DULV²
3/N% 36-I10%/)04-#I$#6)1>%N($#)(-1>%HUOLQ²
*3,% /)04-#I$#6)!0%H(4#(!%K6>()(!%XFKDUHVW²
,/% %*HURYpG/)04-#I$#6)!0%N($#)(!%#)%S1.5(-#(%-!I!-$(!6RILD
,/, $߰DߖHO/)04-#I$#6)!0%N($#)(!%X1(!%#)%/1560.(?#(%#)$!-%())60%A3A//%!$%A3AiN%-!I!-$(!%!$%!"#M
$(!%01)$L%YROXPHV/MXEOMDQD²
,06 )3DSD]RJORXpG/)04-#I$#6)0%"!%.(%AU0#!%71I!-#!1-!%HOJUDGH²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% N8%FN,**8A8B*%8B*K8%N87%3<7%8B%N<*/B%*<KH/F% :PR

66,% 9%HVHYOLHYpG7Ia$5-#!4+#04+!%1)"%0Ia$.($!#)#04+!%/)04+-#:$!)%(10%S1.5(-#!)%HUOLQ$NDGH
PLH9HUODJ

G8C<84E3@=F89
%DOGL3KLOLS
% :??:% *+!%F61)"($#6)0%6:%N($#)%HUOLQ0RXWRQGH*UX\WHU
%LHWHU)UHGHULF$
  *+!%7')$(]%6:%$+!%3(0!0%()"%$+!%@-!I60#$#6)0%#)%3(00#6"6-10;%O#0$6-#(%844.!0#(0$#4(%*-#I!-$#$(6WXGLHVLQ0H
GLHYDODQG5HQDLVVDQFH/DWLQ:DVKLQJWRQ'&&DWKROLF8QLYHUVLW\RI$PHULFD
%RQQHW0D[
  N!%.($#)%"!%D-U56#-!%"!%*61-03DULV+DFKHWWH
">6878H2%56L>%
  H1%DU)#$#:%N($#)%!$%"!%.(%I-UI60#$#6)%"!g%U$1"!%"!%0')$(]!%+#0$6-#X1!%01-%.(%"U46>I60#$#6)%"1%.($#)%!$%.(%:6->(M
$#6)%"1%:-()R(#03DULV)9LHZHJ
"F>JM6H2%,FDJ7K%
  ´9XOJDULVPDQG1RUPDOL]DWLRQLQWKH7H[WRIK!51.(%7()4$#%S!)!"#4$#LY%36H9%N($#)%?1.5(#-!%q%N($#)%
WDUGLI¬1% $FWHVGX9JFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOVXUOHODWLQYXOJDLUHHWWDUGLI+HLGHOEHUJ²VHSWHPEUH
 pGLWpSDU+¬3HWHUVPDQQHW5.HWWHPDQQSS²+HLGHOEHUJ&:LQWHU
GHOD9LOOD-pVXV
  ´7KH6XEVWLWXWLRQRI,QVWUXPHQWDO$EODWLYHE\3UHSRVLWLRQDO3KUDVHVLQ/DWLQ6RPH(YLGHQFHIURP
WKH9XOJDWDµ'DQV80$1"#60%"!%.#)5uÉ0$#4(%.($#)( $FWDVGHO,;&RORTXLR,QWHUQDFLRQDOGH/LQJtVWLFD
/DWLQD8QLYHUVLGDG$XWyQRPDGH0DGULG²DEULOGH pGLWpSDU%*DU]tD+HUQiQGH]SS
²0DGULG(GLFLRQHV&OiVLFDV
(UQRXW$OIUHGHW)UDQoRLV7KRPDV
% OPRQ% 7')$(]!%N($#)!qPHUpYpG1RXYHOOH&ROOHFWLRQjO·8VDJHGHV&ODVVHV3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
*DOGL*LRYDQEDWWLVWD
  ´2QWKH/DWLQ*HQLWLYH6RPH6SHFLDO8VHVµ'DQV@(I!-0%6)%D-(>>(-%9,,,pGLWpSDU*&DOEROLSS
²5RPH+HUGHU
% :??<% D-(>>($#4(%"!..!%#04-#G#6)#%.($#)!%"!..;#>I!-6%^@-6?#)4!%,-#!)$(.#`g%A6-:60#)$(00#%)6>#)(.!3DSHUVRQ*UDP
PDU0RQRJUDSKV5RPH+HUGHU
*LXQWD)UDQFHVFRHW$QWRQLQR*ULOORQHpGV
% OPPO% /6-"()#0%H!%6-#5#)!%(4$#&10X1!%D!$(-1>)RQWLSHUOD6WRULDG·,WDOLD5RPH,VWLWXWR6WRULFR,WDOLDQR
SHULO0HGLR(YR
+DYHUOLQJ*HUG
  7$1"#!0%6)%7'>>(4+10;%N()51(5!%()"%7$'.!6WXGLD*UDHFDHW/DWLQD*RWKREXUJHQVLD*|WHERUJ$FWD
XQLYHUVLWDWLV*RWKREXUJHQVLV
  ´6XUOHODWLQYXOJDLUHGDQVODWUDGXFWLRQ¶UDYHQQDWH·GHV<I+6-#0>!0G·+LSSRFUDWHµ'DQVN($#)%?1.M
5(#-!%q%N($#)%$(-"#:%1*% $FWHVGX9,JFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOVXUOHODWLQYXOJDLUHHWWDUGLI+HOVLQNL
DR€W²VHSWHPEUH pGLWpSDU+6ROLQ0/HLZRHW++DOODDKRSS²+LOGHVKHLP
=ULFK1HZ<RUN2OPV:HLGPDQQ
  ´2Q/LQJXLVWLF'HYHORSPHQWDQG6FKRRO7UDGLWLRQ'LUHFWDQG,QGLUHFW(YLGHQFHRIWKH'HYHORSPHQW
RI/DWH/DWLQµ3.(00#4(%!$%A!"#(!?(.#(%RRN%Q:Qq
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8KH%TL%AL%O<T8KN/BD

  ´2Q&DVHVDQG3UHSRVLWLRQVLQ9XOJDUDQGLQ/LWHUDU\/DWH/DWLQµ'DQVN($#)%?1.5(#-!%q%N($#)%$(-"#:%1**%
$FWHVGX9,,pPHFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOVXUOHODWLQYXOJDLUHHWWDUGLI6HYLOOD²VHSWHPEUH 2%
pGLWpSDU&¬$ULDV$EHOOiQSS²6pYLOOH8QLYHUVLGDGGH6HYLOOD
  ´2Q9DULDWLRQLQ6\QWD[DQG0RUSKRORJ\LQ/DWH/DWLQWH[WVµ'DQVN($#)%?1.5(#-!%q%N($#)%$(-"#:%1***%
$FWHVGX9,,,JFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOVXUOHODWLQYXOJDLUHHWWDUGLI2[IRUG²VHSWHPEUH 2%
pGLWpSDU5¬:ULJKWSS²+LOGHVKHLP=ULFK1HZ<RUN2OPV:HLGPDQQ
(J>KKL>62%!HHJ
  7$1"#!0%6)%$+!%N($#)%<4410($#?!%<&06.1$!L&RPPHQWDWLRQHV+XPDQDUXP/LWWHUDUXP+HOVLQNL6RFL
HWDV6FLHQWLDUXP)HQQLFD
+RIPDQQ-RKDQQ%DSWLVWHW$QWRQ6]DQW\U
  N($!#)#04+!%7')$(]%1)"%7$#.#0$#=0XQLFK%HFN
/|IVWHGW(LQDU
% OPOO% @+#.6.65#04+!-%b6>>!)$(-%G1-%@!-!5-#)($#6%<!$+!-#(!g%\)$!-014+1)5!)%G1-%D!04+#4+$!%"!-%.($!#)#04+!)%7I-(M
4+!8SSVDOD$OPTYLVW :LNVHOO
% OPQQ% 7')$(4$#4(g%7$1"#!)%1)"%S!#$-a5!%G1-%+#0$6-#04+!)%7')$(]%"!0%N($!#)02%1F>LMJ%:N%7')$(=$#04+M0$#.#0$#04+!%
D!0#4+$0I1)=$!%1)"%@-6&.!>!$FWD5HJLDH6RFLHWDWLV+XPDQLRUXP/LWWHUDUXP/XQGHQVLV/XQG
*OHHUXS
% OP<:% 7')$(4$#4(g%7$1"#!)%1)"%S!#$-a5!%G1-%+#0$6-#04+!)%7')$(]%"!0%N($!#)02%1F>LMJ%ON%}&!-%!#)#5!%D-1)":-(5!)%
"!-%.($!#)#04+!)%B6>#)(.0')$(]pPHpG$FWD5HJLDH6RFLHWDWLV+XPDQLRUXP/LWWHUDUXP/XQGHQVLV
/XQG*OHHUXS
% OPRP% N($!%N($#),QVWLWXWWHWIRU6DPPHQOLJQHQGH.XOWXUIRUVNQLQJ2VOR+$VFKHKRXJ
0F>8HJ>>82%58J76%
  ´&DVLHSUHSRVL]LRQLLQODWLQR/RVYLOXSSRGHOJHQLWLYRHGHOGDWLYR8QDSURVSHWWLYD DQFKH VRFLR
OLQJXLVWLFDµN#)51#0$#4(%!%:#.6.65#(²
0RPPVHQ7KHRGRUpG
  /6-"()#0%K6>()(%!$%D!$#4(0RQXPHQWD*HUPDQLDHKLVWRULFD$XFW$QW3W%HUOLQ:HLGPDQQ
6NDKLOO%+
% OPQ<% *+!%7')$(]%6:%$+!%16786J%6:%3(00#6"6-106WXGLHVLQ0HGLHYDODQG5HQDLVVDQFH/DWLQ:DVKLQJWRQ
'&&DWKROLF8QLYHUVLW\RI$PHULFD
6YHQQXQJ-RVHI
% OP::% ,-60#()(g%7')$(=$#04+!2%0!>(0#6.65#04+!%1)"%=-#$#04+!%7$1"#!)%G1%,-60#108SSVDOD8QLYHUVLWHWVჍUVVNULIW
8SSVDOD$NDGHPLVND%RNKDQGHOQ
OPQO;Q<% \)$!-014+1)5!)%G1%@(..("#10%1)"%G1-%.($!#)#04+!)%F(4+M%1)"%T6.=00I-(4+!8SSVDOD$OPTYLVW :LNVHOO
9llQlQHQ9HLNNR
  /)$-6"14$#6)%(1%N($#)%?1.5(#-!qPHUpYpG%LEOLRWKqTXH)UDQoDLVHHW5RPDQH6HULHV$0DQXHOVHW
eWXGHV/LQJXLVWLTXHV3DULV.OLQFNVLHN
 % N!%P61-)(.MUIy$-!%";Q5U-#!%^/$#)!-(-#1>%85!-#(!`g%U$1"!%.#)51#0$#X1!+HOVLQNL$FDGHPLD6FLHQWLDUXP
)HQQLFD
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<78%A<Kb/BD%,F%3,K8%<KD\A8B*7%<BH%<N/DBA8B*%/B%N<*8%N<*/B% :P@

!"
#$%&'($)*+,-'./'#.)&'$)-0(&,1%'
$,2'$3+-,(&,1'+,'3$1&'3$1+,

A#4+!.(%3!))(>62%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%B(I.!0%F!"!-#46%//j

$ZHOONQRZQDQGZLGHO\LQYHVWLJDWHGFKDQJHWDNLQJSODFHLQWKHWUDQVLWLRQIURP/DWLQWR5RPDQFHLVWKHXVH
RIWKHDFFXVDWLYHDVWKH´XQLYHUVDOµFDVHLQVHYHUDODUHDVRIWKHHPSLUH,QWKLVSDSHU,GLVFXVVRQHDVSHFWRIWKLV
SKHQRPHQRQWKHVRFDOOHG!]$!)"!"%(4410($#?! 0RUDYFVLN3ODQN WKHXVHRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHLQVXEMHFW
IXQFWLRQLQVRPHFRQVWUXFWLRQVDOUHDG\DWWHVWHGE\WKHHQGRIWKHVHFRQG²WKLUGFHQWXU\႐ᅡ $XGROOHQW
+HUPDQ² DQGDPSO\GRFXPHQWHGE\WKHIRXUWK²ILIWKFHQWXU\႐ᅡ 6YHQQXQJ DQG
HYHQPRUHVRLQODWHUFHQWXULHV /|IVWHGW²1RUEHUJ²²
$IWHULOOXVWUDWLQJWKHSKHQRPHQRQDQGLWVPDQLIHVWDWLRQVLQWKHIROORZLQJVHFWLRQ,LQYHVWLJDWHLWVUHODWLRQVKLS
ZLWKWKHFRQFRPLWDQWUHRUJDQL]DWLRQRIYRLFHGLVWLQFWLRQV &HQQDPRDE ,QSDUWLFXODU,VKRZWKDW
WKHXVHRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHDVD01&c!=$=(010UHIOHFWVDQLQLWLDOO\´DFWLYHµDQGVXEVHTXHQWO\´QHXWUDOµUHDOLJQPHQWRI
JUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQV T6#4!%()"%D-(>>($#4(.%K!.($#6)0%#)%N($!%N($#) GHYHORSLQJDOUHDG\H[LVWLQJSDWWHUQVRIDFWLYH
V\QWD[LQHDUO\/DWLQDQG,DUJXH e1#-='%<-51>!)$0%()"%$+!%K#0!%6:%O!("%A(-=#)5 WKDWLWPD\EHUHJDUGHGDVRQH
RIWKHRXWFRPHVRIDPRUHJHQHUDODQGSHUYDVLYHFKDQJHLQYROYLQJDGHHSUHVWUXFWXULQJLQWKHZKROHV\VWHPRI
DUJXPHQWPDUNLQJLQWKHWUDQVLWLRQIURP/DWLQWR5RPDQFHWKHHPHUJHQFHRI+!("M>(-=#)5SDWWHUQVLQDFDQRQL
FDO"!I!)"!)$M>(-=#)5%ODQJXDJHVXFKDV/DWLQ &HQQDPR 

145'&6758959'$::;<=7>?5'=89'@A;>BCDE'&8:F9>8G<''
FH'#FB5'$BG;I587<'>8'3=75'3=7>8
7KHWHUP!]$!)"!"%(4410($#?! 0RUDYFVLN UHIHUVWRDQHUJDWLYHOLNHFRGLQJSDWWHUQLQQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVD
WLYHODQJXDJHVWKHH[WHQVLRQRIDPRUSKRORJLFDOPDUNHU WKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVH JHQHUDOO\XVHGIRUWKHREMHFW 2 
RIDWUDQVLWLYHYHUEWRHQFRGHWKHVROHDUJXPHQW 6 ORIVRPHLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVPDLQO\GHQRWLQJPHQWDOSURFHVV
LQYROXQWDU\DFWLRQVDQGH[LVWHQFH7KLVSDWWHUQLVZHOODWWHVWHGFURVVOLQJXLVWLFDOO\ERWKV\QFKURQLFDOO\ 0RUDYF
VLN² DQGGLDFKURQLFDOO\ 3ODQN%XUULGJH²IRUPLGGOH'XWFK 
8QOLNH0RUDYFVLN  IROORZLQJ3ODQN  ,UHJDUGWKLVVWUXFWXUHDVWKHPDQLIHVWDWLRQRIDQDFWLYH
FRGLQJV\VWHPZKHUHE\WKHVROHDUJXPHQWRIDQLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUESDWWHUQ 6 LVFRGHGOLNHWKHVXEMHFW $ RID
WUDQVLWLYHYHUEZLWKVRPHYHUEVSDWWHUQVDQGOLNHWKHREMHFW 2 RIWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVZLWKRWKHUYHUEVSDWWHUQV
,Q/DWH/DWLQWKH!]$!)"!"%(4410($#?!%LVDWWHVWHGLQLWLDOO\ZLWKHTXDWLYHVWUXFWXUHV>@ILHQWLYHV:DQWLFDXVDWLYHVQ%
>D²E@SDVVLYHV>@DQGIRUWKHVROHDUJXPHQWRILPSHUVRQDOFRQVWUXFWLRQV>@DVZHOODVZLWKLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEV

7KLVSDSHULVDQDEULGJHGYHUVLRQRI&HQQDPRZKHUHVRPH L]DWLRQVWRWKHQRWLRQVRIVXEMHFWDQGREMHFW LQWKHODQJXDJHVZKHUH

RIWKHGDWDDQGLGHDVSUHVHQWHGKHUHDUHPRUHWKRURXJKO\LQYHVWL
JDWHG,KDYHEHQHILWHGIURPLQWHUHVWLQJDQGVWLPXODWLQJGLVFXVVLRQ
DWGLIIHUHQWVWDJHVZLWK+HQQLQJ$QGHUVHQ-RKDQQD%DUGGDO-DQ
7HULH)DDUOXQG0LFKqOH)UX\W0DLU3DUU\+DUP3LQNVWHU5RPDQR
/D]]HURQL1LJHO9LQFHQWDQGWKHODWH-yV]HI+HUPDQDQG$OEHUWR
=DPERQL,DPGHHSO\JUDWHIXODQGLQGHEWHGWRDOORIWKHP,DOVRZLVK
WRWKDQN'HQQLV3DUGHHIRUKLVFRQVWUXFWLYHDGYLFH$OOVKRUWFRPLQJV
KRZHYHUDUHP\RZQUHVSRQVLELOLW\
O
6$DQG2DUHV\QWDFWLFRVHPDQWLFSULPLWLYHVUHIHUULQJWRWKH
QXFOHDUDUJXPHQWVRIDFODXVH6LVWKHVROHDUJXPHQWRIDQLQWUDQVL
WLYHYHUESDWWHUQ$DQG2DUHUHVSHFWLYHO\WKH$JHQWDQG3DWLHQW
DUJXPHQWVRIWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVFRUUHVSRQGLQJLQWKHLUFDQRQLFDOUHDO
WKHVHUHODWLRQVFDQEHLGHQWLILHG 6HH'L[RQ²DQGUHFHQW
GLVFXVVLRQLQ0LWKXQDQG&KDIH
:
7KHWHUPUHIHUVWRSUHGLFDWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVJHQHUDOO\GHULYHG
IURPDGMHFWLYHVGHQRWLQJWKHWUDQVLWLRQIURPDVWDWHWRDQHZVWDWH
+DVSHOPDWK 
Q
$QWLFDXVDWLYHVDUHLQWUDQVLWLYHSDWWHUQV PDLQO\GHQRWLQJFKDQJH
RIVWDWHORFDWLRQ GHULYHGIURPRULJLQDOO\WUDQVLWLYHRQHVZLWKWKH
RULJLQDO2 WKHREMHFW >$Q@RFFXUULQJDV6 VXEMHFW WKHSURFHVV
EHLQJGHVFULEHGDVWDNLQJSODFHVSRQWDQHRXVO\:KHQWKHVXEMHFWLV
>$Q@WKHSDWWHUQUHDOL]HVDVRFDOOHGDJHQWLYHDQWLFDXVDWLYH +DVSHO
PDWK² 

:P@
 oi.uchicago.edu

% A/3O8N<%38BB<A,

GHQRWLQJFKDQJHRIVWDWHORFDWLRQ>D²E@³WKDWLVZLWKXQDFFXVDWLYHYHUEVSDWWHUQV )RUWKHUHOHYDQFHRIWKLV
QRWLRQDOVRWRRWKHUDUHDVRI/DWH/DWLQV\QWD[VHH/D)DXFL&HQQDPR 

 >@ 10$#6)!>% )!4!00(-#(% -!0% !0$% 3+#-6)  HTXDWLYH  ,9႐ᅡ

 FDXWHUL]DWLRQ$&&QHFHVVD\120WKLQJ120EH35(6,1'6*
 ´&DXWHUL]DWLRQLVQHFHVVDU\µ

 >D@ :#41>% 46)$1)"#$62% 10X1!%"1>%!"#$%$!& '"(%%

 ILJ$&&FXW,03(53/XQWLO PLQXWH$&&EHFRPH35(668%-6*
 ´&XWWKHILJXQWLOLWLVUHGXFHGWRVPDOOSLHFHVµ 3+#-6)  ILHQWLYH
 >E@ )(>% !$)%*+& )(#,$*-.+& +(#(#%$-% #)%
 LQSRLQWRIIDFWPDQ\3/$&&LOOQHVVHV3/$&&120KHDO03$6635(6,1'3/LQ

% #I0#0% .64#0% 1&#% 4("#$% #I0!% -60

 VDPH3/$%/SODFH3/$%/ZKHUHIDOO35(6,1'6*VDPH120URVH120
 <)$6)L%@.(4L%/$#)&RUS&KULVW  DQWLFDXVDWLYH
 ´6HYHUDOLOOQHVVHVKHDOLQWKHSODFHVZKHUHWKLVURVHIDOOVµ

 >@ 6>)!9% /"0*+& /*!.1(#%$- <)$+#>  I(00#?!

 DOO1203/IRRG$&&3/HDW03$6635(668%-3/
 ´7KDWDOOWKHIRRGLVHDWHQµ

 >@ '"%& *-(%"*#.!& I-6%6>)#&10 @!-L%<!$+L 

 EHFRPH35(6,1'6*SUD\HU$&&IRUHYHU\ERG\$%/ LPSHUVRQDOSDVVLYH 
 ´3UD\LQJWDNHVSODFHRQH LQGHILQLWH VD\VDSUD\HUDSUD\HULVVDLGµ

 >D@ 1$% +(#,$"#.!&&.2.(%% 46I#601> 3+#-6)  #)$-()0#$#?!`

 LQRUGHUWREORRG$&&FRPHRXW35(668%-6*DEXQGDQW$&&
 ´6RWKDWWKHEORRGFRPHVRXWDEXQGDQWO\µ

 >E@ )$/.!3& /(-$"%& 3/N%9,,,+HUPDQ

 OLJKW$&&ODFN3(5),1'6*
 ´7KHOLJKWZDVODFNLQJµ

,QODWHU VHYHQWKWRQLQWKFHQWXU\ WH[WVDFFXVDWLYHVXEMHFWVDOVRRFFXUZLWKQRQDJHQWLYHDFWLYLW\>F@PR

WLRQDFWLYLW\ G DQGLQGHILQLWHFKDQJHRIVWDWHYHUEV>H@ 1RUEHUJ²&HQQDPR 

 >F@ /-.4"%(5"%& 4(#.!% #)%:1-)6 <5)!.. 

 FUDFNOH3(5),1'6*EUHDG$&&LQRYHQ$%/
 ´%UHDGFUDFNOHGLQWKHRYHQµ

 >G@ 0#LLL%"4+$!& /$--"% N!]%<.(>;&,9FRGG$

 LI KH$&&UXQ35(6,1'6*
 ´,IKHUXQVµ

 >H@ 0#%#)$!-% !60d% /($+(!& (15.#"-"% LG

 LIEHWZHHQWKH\$&&GLVSXWH$&&DULVH)873(5)6*
 ´,IDGLVSXWHDURVHEHWZHHQWKHPµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<78%A<Kb/BD%,F%3,K8%<KD\A8B*7%<BH%<N/DBA8B*%/B%N<*8%N<*/B% :PP

7KHDFFXVDWLYHLQ6IXQFWLRQWKHUHIRUHDSSHDUVWRRFFXULQLWLDOO\PDLQO\ZLWKFRUHXQDFFXVDWLYHV WHOLFFKDQJH
RIVWDWHORFDWLRQYHUEV JUDGXDOO\VSUHDGLQJWRSHULSKHUDOXQDFFXVDWLYHV VWDWHVLQGHILQLWHFKDQJHVRIVWDWH DQG
XQHUJDWLYHV DFWLYLW\YHUEV DQLVVXHWKDWQHHGVKRZHYHUIXUWKHULQYHVWLJDWLRQ VHHDOVR&HQQDPR² 
(DUO\H[DPSOHVRIDFFXVDWLYHVXEMHFWVDUHUHSRUWHGDOVRIRUH[HFUDWLRQWDEOHWVIURP1RUWKHUQ$IULFDRIWKH
VHFRQG²WKLUGFHQWXULHV႐ᅡ $XGROOHQW+HUPDQ² ZLWKLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVGHQRW
LQJFKDQJHRIVWDWHORFDWLRQVXFKDV4("!-!%´IDOOµLQ>D@DQGDJHQWLYHDQWLFDXVDWLYHVVXFKDV?!-$!-!´WXUQµLQ>E@
ZLWK>$Q@>“+XP@<QRXQVRIWKHVHFRQG 0!-?1%´VHUYDQWµ >E@DQGWKLUG T#4$6-! GHFOHQVLRQV>D@DOWHUQDWLQJ
ZLWKFDQRQLFDOQRPLQDWLYHVXEMHFWV>F@RIWHQZLWKDPELJXLW\EHWZHHQDQXFOHDU LHVXEMHFW RUH[WUDV\QWDFWLF
WRSLFIXQFWLRQ +HUPDQDOVR&HQQDPR 

 >D@ 64('$& 7"/%*-.& /(1(#%2% 891.$& /(1(%« #)$-()0#$#?!`%

 (SDIXV$&&9LFWRU$&&IDOO35(668%-3//\GHXV$&&IDOO35(668%-6*
 ´/HW(SDIXV9LFWRU«IDOO«µ H!:L%*(&L$²+HUPDQ

 >E@ :$4.-+%"(#$d% !$% ;($/.))"$& /(1(%<& 5.-%(%3

 6XSHUVWLDQXV$&&DQG1DXFHOOXV$&&IDOO35(668%-6*WXUQ35(668%-6*
% 0!-?1d% 4("($% H!:L%*(&L%$²LG+HUPDQ
 VHUYDQW$&&IDOO35(668%-6*
 ´/HW6XSHUVWLDQXVDQG1DXFHOOLXVIDOOWXUQWKHVHUYDQWIDOOµ

$WDODWHUVWDJHWKHDFFXVDWLYHDOVRRFFXUVIRUWKH$DUJXPHQWRIWUDQVLWLYHYHUEV>@LQLWLDOO\ZLWKLQDQLPDWH
DUJXPHQWV>D@VXEVHTXHQWO\ZLWKDQLPDWHRQHV>E@ VHHIXUWKHUGLVFXVVLRQLQ&HQQDPR 

 >D@% 0#%"$!.#%$!& !*-0$!& -.#().!& %.!4%(5"%% 3+#-6)

 LI EHDVWRIEXUGHQ1(87LOOQHVV$&&UHQDO$&&DIIHFW3(5),1'6*
 ´,IWKLVEHDVWRIEXUGHQVXIIHUVIURPNLGQH\WURXEOHµ

 >E@ '")"*+& !$% #.4*%.+3& >!>6-#(% 4*+$.-$#% 3/N9,,,

 FKLOG3/$&&DQGQHSKHZ3/PHPRU\$%/EXLOG3(5),1'3/
 ´+LVFKLOGUHQDQGQHSKHZVEXLOWLW VFLOWKHWRPE µ

)RUPVVXFKDVT#4$6-!2%0!-?1LQ>D²E@GRQRWH[HPSOLI\DSKRQHWLFFKDQJHWKHIDOORIILQDOM>DQGM0LQDWRQLF
V\OODEOHV HJ0ROLQHOOL+HUPDQ EXWWKHXVHRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHIRUWKHQRPLQDWLYHLQVXEMHFWWRSLF
IXQFWLRQZLWKDOWHUQDWLRQEHWZHHQWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGWKHDFFXVDWLYH‘a! !> IRUWKHVLQJXODURIWKHWKLUG
GHFOHQVLRQDQGM10%aM1 M1>  6LQODWHWH[WVZLWKIDOORIILQDO>LQSURQXQFLDWLRQDQGORVVRITXDQWLW\LQILQDO

<
7KHUHDUHKRZHYHUYHU\IHZH[DPSOHVRIWKHH[WHQGHGDFFXVDWLYH
ZLWK>$Q@QRXQVLQQRQ$IULFDQIRXUWK²ILIWKFHQWXU\WH[WVZKHUH
PRVWW\SLFDOO\WKHDFFXVDWLYHRFFXUVZLWKLQDFWLYHLQDQLPDWHSDU
WLFLSDQWV VHHDOVR3ODQN&HQQDPRQ 2QO\LQVL[WK²
VHYHQWKFHQWXU\WH[WVLVWKHDFFXVDWLYHIUHTXHQWO\DWWHVWHGDOVRZLWK
>+XP@QRXQV5RYDL  ZKRGLVFXVVHVWKHLVVXHZLWKUHIHUHQFH
WRWKHUROHSOD\HGE\WKHDQLPDF\DQGLQGLYLGXDWLRQKLHUDUFKLHV
DUJXHVWKDWWKHDFFXVDWLYHVSUHDGVDORQJWKHIROORZLQJKLHUDUFK\RI
DQLPDF\LQGLYLGXDWLRQIURPULJKWWROHIW PRUHZLGHO\DQGDSSDUHQWO\HDUOLHUWKDQFRPPRQQRXQV 3HL
ILUVWVHFRQGSHUVRQ VLQJXODU ! WKLUGSHUVRQ VLQ
JXODU ! SURSHU QRXQV ! DQLPDWH KXPDQ QRXQV !
DQLPDWHQRXQV!LQDQLPDWHQRXQV SODFHQDPHV!
FRPPRQQRXQV !DEVWUDFW YHUEDO QRXQV
:KHUHDVLWLVXQGRXEWHGO\WUXHWKDWLQWKHPDMRULW\RIQRQ$IUL
FDQWH[WVWKHH[WHQVLRQRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHDSSHDUVWREHVHQVLWLYHQRW
RQO\WRWKHW\SHRISDWWHUQEXWDOVRWRWKHDFWLYHLQDFWLYHQDWXUH
RIWKHVXEMHFW HJDQLPDF\DQGRUFRQWURO LWLVPRUHGLIILFXOWWR
SURYHWKHUHOHYDQFHRIWKHKLJKHQGRIWKHKLHUDUFK\IRUWKHVSUHDG
RIWKHSKHQRPHQRQDWDODWHVWDJHZKLFKPD\YDU\DFFRUGLQJWR
WKHWH[WVDQGWKHDUHDVFRQVLGHUHG:KHUHDVWKHKLHUDUFK\DSSHDUV
WREHEURXJKWRXWE\WKHN!]%31-#!)0#0 DQHLJKWKFHQWXU\WH[WIURP
5KHWLD  5RYDL WH[WVIURPRWKHUDUHDVJLYHFRQWUDVWLQJUHVXOWV
)RULQVWDQFHLQ7DUGLIDQGRWKHU0HURYLQJLDQWH[WVSODFHQDPHVDQG
SURSHUQDPHVDUHDWWHVWHGZLWKWKHDFFXVDWLYHLQVXEMHFWIXQFWLRQ
²DQGUHIHUHQFHVWKHUHLQ ,Q$IULFDQ/DWLQWKHSKHQRPHQRQ
LVDWWHVWHGZLWKSURSHUQRXQV >“+XP@DVHDUO\DVLWVILUVWDWWHVWD
WLRQV VHH>D²E@ 
7KHLVVXHREYLRXVO\QHHGVIXUWKHULQYHVWLJDWLRQDOVRLQWKDWVLQFH
WKHSKHQRPHQRQDSSHDUVWREHWKHUHVXOWRIVHYHUDOGLIIHUHQWSDWKV
RIFKDQJHWKDWDWVRPHSRLQWFRQYHUJHSUREDEO\DOLQHRIGHYHORS
PHQWWKDWDSSHDUVWRKROGWUXHIRURQHSDWKPD\QRWKROGIRUDQRWKHU
SDWK
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q??% A/3O8N<%38BB<A,

YRZHOZKHUHE\1%Ö%6 IRUVHFRQGGHFOHQVLRQQRXQV +HUPDQ²9llQlQlQIRUILIWK²VL[WK

FHQWXU\$IULFDQ/DWLQ3HLIRU0HURYLQJLDQ/DWLQ 
7KHSKHQRPHQRQFRQFHUQVPDLQO\WKHVRXWKHUQSURYLQFHVRIWKHHPSLUH³$IULFD,WDO\DQG6SDLQ WRD
OHVVHUH[WHQWDQGDWDODWHUVWDJH+HUPDQ² DQGSUREDEO\WKH%DONDQV +HUPDQ ³ZLWK
ODWH ILIWK²HLJKWKFHQWXU\ H[DPSOHVDOVRIURP*DXOZKHUHKRZHYHUE\WKHVDPHSHULRGWKHUHDOVRVHHPVWREH
HYLGHQFHIRUWKHWZRFDVHGHFOHQVLRQDOV\VWHPWKDWGHYHORSHGLQ2OG)UHQFKZLWKWKHQRPLQDWLYHREOLTXHRSSRVL
WLRQVRFDOOHG4(0%01c!$YV4(0%-U5#>! LHZLWKWKHDFFXVDWLYHXVHGDVDJHQHUDOREOLTXHFDVHUHSODFLQJWKHRWKHU
FDVHVPDUNLQJFRUHDQGQRQFRUHUHODWLRQVDVZHOOVHH3HL²&HQQDPRIRUH[DPSOHV
DQGIXUWKHUGLVFXVVLRQ 
7KHSDWWHUQVLOOXVWUDWHGLQ>@²>@DERYHQRWRQO\H[HPSOLI\WKHIXQFWLRQDOHTXLYDOHQFHEHWZHHQWKHQRPL
QDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYHFDVHVLQVRPHV\QWDFWLFFRQWH[WVLQWKHYDULRXVDUHDVRIWKH5RPjQLDEXWDOVRUHSUHVHQW
DWUDQVLWLRQDOVWDJHLQWKHHQFRGLQJRIJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQ/DWH/DWLQDQGHDUO\5RPDQFHRQHGXU
LQJZKLFKWKH\VKRZDQLQWLDOO\DFWLYHLQDFWLYHDQGVXEVHTXHQWO\QHXWUDORULHQWDWLRQPDQLIHVWHGWKURXJKFDVH
PDUNLQJ7KLVSKHQRPHQRQRIWHQWDNHVSODFHLQWKHWUDQVLWLRQIURPDFFXVDWLYHWRHUJDWLYHFRGLQJV\VWHPVZKHUH
LQWHUPHGLDWHVWDJHVFRQIRUPWRDQDFWLYHLQDFWLYHFRGLQJV\VWHPZLWKH[WHQVLRQRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHDQGUHJUHV
VLRQRIWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGLVUHIHUUHGWRLQWKHOLWHUDWXUHDVWKH!]$!)"!"%(4410($#?!l-!0$-#4$!"%)6>#)($#?!%(.#5)>!)$%
3ODQN 7KHDFFXVDWLYHJHQHUDOO\RFFXUVZLWKLQDFWLYHSDWLHQWWKHPHVXEMHFWVZKLOHWKHQRPLQDWLYHFRGHV
DFWLYHG\QDPLFDUJXPHQWVRILQWUDQVLWLYHVLWXDWLRQVWKDWPD\EHDIIHFWHGE\WKHFKDQJHDWDODWHUVWDJH FI3ODQN
+DUULV²'L[RQ²+DUULVDQG&DPSEHOO² 
8QOLNHLQRWKHUODQJXDJHVWKDWVKRZVLPLODULQWUDQVLWLYHEDVHGFKDQJHVWKH%!]$!)"!"%(4410($#?!l-!0$-#4$!"%
)6>#)($#?!LQ/DWH/DWLQGRHVQRWVHHPWREHDQLQWHUPHGLDWHVWDJHLQWKHVKLIWIURPDQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHWR
DQHUJDWLYHDEVROXWLYHFRGLQJV\VWHP³DOWKRXJKVXFKDFKDQJHFDQQRWEHH[FOXGHGRQFHDOO6DUJXPHQWVPD\
EHPDUNHGE\WKHDFFXVDWLYH =DPERQL² ³EXWLWPD\EHUHJDUGHGDVWKHLQLWLDOVWHSLQWKHORVV
RIWKHQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHFRQWUDVW +HUPDQ3ODQN DQGDFFRPSDQLHVRWKHUPDQLIHVWD
WLRQVRIDQDFWLYHLQDFWLYHFRGLQJV\VWHPVXFKDVWKHDOWHUQDWLRQRIWKHSOHRQDVWLFUHIOH[LYHV0!l0#&#RFFXUULQJ
UHVSHFWLYHO\ZLWKXQHUJDWLYHVDQGXQDFFXVDWLYHV HJ0!%?(4(-!%´GHDOZLWKµYV0#&#%-!?!-$#%´JREDFNµ&HQQDP6%
 
$FFXVDWLYHVXEMHFWVKRZHYHULQWKHWH[WVZKHUHWKH\DUHDWWHVWHGFRQWLQXHWRDOWHUQDWHZLWKSDWWHUQVZKHUH
WKHQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHGLVWLQFWLRQLVNHSWERWKLQWKHHDUO\H[DPSOHVRIWKHSKHQRPHQRQ &HQQDPR>FI
D²EYVF²G@ DQGDWDODWHUVWDJHUHJDUGOHVVRIWKHDQLPDF\RIWKH6$DUJXPHQW>@

 >@ !$% "4+.& /*)*#$+d% ("%0!-?#$#1>% -.5.-%(%$- N!]%31-#!)0#0

 DQGWKLV120SHDVDQW120WRVODYHU\$&&JREDFN03$6635(668%-6*
 ´$QGWKLVSHDVDQWZHQWEDFNWRVODYHU\µ

7KHVHIRUPVDUHWREHGLVWLQJXLVKHGIURPWKHDFFXVDWLYHIRUWKHQRPLQDWLYHLQWKHSOXUDORIILUVWGHFOHQVLRQ
QRXQV LHWKH(0%IRUPV ZKLFKDOUHDG\LQWKHLUHDUO\DWWHVWDWLRQVDUHQRWFRQILQHGWRWKHLQDFWLYH6DUJXPHQW
RILQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVSDWWHUQV WKDWLVWRSDVVLYHVLPSHUVRQDOVDQWLFDXVDWLYHVHTXDWLYHVWUXFWXUHVDQGVRPH
LQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEV EXWRFFXULQDOOFODXVHW\SHVWKDWLVDOVRLQWUDQVLWLYHFODXVHV3UREDEO\WKH\RULJLQDWHIURP
2VFR8PEULDQIRUPV 1RUEHUJ²/|IVWHGWII*HUROD² $VDPDWWHURI
IDFWWKH\DUHDOUHDG\DWWHVWHGLQ3RPSRQLXV·F(&1.(!%<$!..()! IURPWKHILUVWFHQWXU\ᄽᅐ >D@DQGDOVRRFFXULQ
ODWHWH[WVDVLOOXVWUDWHGLQ>E@IURPWKHN!]%31-#!)0#0% HLJKWKFHQWXU\ 

 >D@ TXRW)(.%"%"(+% #)0I!-($(d% >#% "#-.4+.-.% #)% 0#)1>% ^5FM=FH8L92% F(&1.(!%

<$!..()(!
 WKDWKDSSLQHVV$&&XQH[SHFWHG$&&,'$7SHQHWUDWH3(5),1'3/LQEUHDVW$&&
 ´7KDWXQH[SHFWHGKDSSLQHVVRYHUWRRNPHµ

 >E@ 0#% #I0(0% I!-06)(0d% $(.!>% :-(1"!>%% 46)0!)$#-!%% ?6.1!-#)$%^N!]%31-#!)0#0%

 LIWKHVDPH3/$&&)SHRSOH3/$&&)WKLV$&&IUDXG$&&OHW,1)35(6ZDQW)8768%-d%
 ´,IWKHVHSHRSOHZDQWHGWRDFFHSWWKLVIUDXGµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<78%A<Kb/BD%,F%3,K8%<KD\A8B*7%<BH%<N/DBA8B*%/B%N<*8%N<*/B% Q?O

7KH\GLVDSSHDUIURPWKHOLWHUDWXUHGXULQJWKHFODVVLFDODJHDQGUHHPHUJHURXJKO\E\WKHWKLUGFHQWXU\႐ᅡ%
>D@ 1RUEHUJ DQGDUHZHOODWWHVWHGLQWHFKQLFDOWH[WVIURPWKHIRXUWKFHQWXU\DVZHOODVLQWKHLQVFULS
WLRQV>E@ FIDOVR6YHQQXQJ 

 >D@ *!#"$!& $%& 4($+.#%& 4-(./*-1"(+& %(#%*& '$-*-.&

 DOO3/*(1LQRGHUWRVWRS35(668%-3/KHDUW3/120VXFKDELJ$%/IXU\$%/ &RPPRGLDQXV
/)0$-14$#6)!0,,
 ´6RWKDWWKHKHDUWVRIDOOUHIUDLQIURPVXFKDIXU\µ

 >E@ &!)!%=$".+/.#%& -.)"=$"(+& 3/N9

 ZHOOUHVW35(668%-3/UHOLFV
 ´/HWWKHUHOLFVUHVWLQSHDFHµ

8QGRXEWHGO\WKHILUVWGHFOHQVLRQSOXUDODFFXVDWLYHVLQM(0VKRZDGLIIHUHQWGHYHORSPHQWVLQFHWKH\RFFXULQ
DOOFODXVHW\SHVIURPWKHLUILUVWDWWHVWDWLRQV,QDGGLWLRQLQODWHUFHQWXULHVIRULQVWDQFHGXULQJWKHVL[WK²VHYHQWK
FHQWXULHVWKH\DOVRRFFXULQDXWKRUVZKRQHYHUXVHWKHDFFXVDWLYHLQVXEMHFWIXQFWLRQ 1RUEHUJ*HUROD
 ,QVRPHODWH0HURYLQJLDQGRFXPHQWVWKH\YLUWXDOO\VXSSODQWWKHFDQRQLFDO(!HQGLQJV 3LUVRQ
 3UREDEO\DOUHDG\LQHDUO\/DWLQWKH\ZHUHSHUFHLYHGDVSOXUDOQRPLQDWLYHVUDWKHUWKDQDFFXVDWLYHVWKLV
DSSHDUVWREHFRQILUPHGE\LGLRPDWLFH[SUHVVLRQVIURPWKHYXOJDUODQJXDJHVXFKDV0!%?#?(0%´ZKLOHDOLYHµ OLW
´WKHPVHOYHVDOLYHµ ZKLFKZHUHFKDUDFWHULVWLFRIWKHLQVFULSWLRQV FI+HOWWXOD!"#$%&'#()*+,-.)/%#0
#12")*++*34 2QWKHGLIIHUHQWDUHDOGLVWULEXWLRQDQGFKURQRORJ\RIWKHVHIRUPVLQ/DWH/DWLQVHH+HUPDQ
²² R
,Q/DWH/DWLQZLWKH[DPSOHVIURPVL[WK²HLJKWKFHQWXU\WH[WVWKHUHDOVRRFFXUQRPLQDWLYH´REMHFWVµWKDWLV
2DUJXPHQWVLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHFDVHZLWK>“DQ@QRXQV>@DSSDUHQWO\ZLWKHDUOLHURFFXUUHQFHVRILQDQLPDWH2V
DVLQ>D@IURPWKHVL[WKFHQWXU\႐ᅡSRLQWLQJWRWKHXVHRIWKHQRPLQDWLYHIRUDOOFRUHIXQFWLRQV$6DQG2
VHHDOVR&HQQDPR 

 >D@ I1.?#0% 01I!-(0I(-5#0 2ULEDVLXV0]UODQG

 SRZGHU120VSULQNOH35(6,1'6*
 ´<RXVSULQNOHWKHSRZGHUµ

 >E@ VLI($!-% I!-4100!-#$ 8"#4$L%K6$+L,,/|IVWHGW

 LIIDWKHU120EHDW68%-)876*
 ´,IKHEHDWVKLVIDWKHUµ

,Q/DWH/DWLQWKHUHIRUHE\WKHVL[WK²VHYHQWKFHQWXU\DVSDUWRIWKHEUHDNLQJGRZQRIWKHFDVHV\VWHPWKH
IXQFWLRQDOLGHQWLW\EHWZHHQQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYHWRHQFRGHQXFOHDUDUJXPHQWVLQLWLDOO\FRQILQHGWRDVXEVHW
FG%$$2%$&JUDGXDOO\VSUHDGVWR6!WKHQ$DQGILQDOO\LQYROYHVDOVRWKH2GRPDLQVZLWKQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYH
EHFRPLQJLQWHUFKDQJHDEOHLQVRPHDUHDVWH[WVDOVRWRPDUN2FRUHDUJXPHQWV7KHGDWDWKHUHIRUHSRLQWWRDUH
DOLJQPHQWRIWKHHQFRGLQJRIFRUHDUJXPHQWVLQLWLDOO\VHQVLWLYHWRWKHQRWLRQVRIDQLPDF\DQGFRQWUROOHDGLQJ
WRDWHPSRUDU\GHSHQGHQWPDUNHGDFWLYHLQDFWLYHV\VWHP H[HPSOLILHGE\DFFXVDWLYHVXEMHFWVZLWKXQDFFXVDWLYH
SDWWHUQV ZKLFKJUDGXDOO\HYROYHVLQWRDQHXWUDOV\VWHPZKHQWKHDFFXVDWLYHDOVRRFFXUVZLWKDOOFRUHDUJXPHQWV
WKHUHIRUHFRPSULVLQJ6!VDQG$VZLWKFDVHPDUNLQJQRORQJHUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ$IURP2DQGRWKHUWRROVEHLQJXVHG
LQVWHDGVXFKDVZRUGRUGHUDQGDJUHHPHQW VHHT6#4!%()"%D-(>>($#4(.%K!.($#6)0%#)%N($!%N($#)%DQGe1#-='%<-51>!)$0%
()"%$+!%K#0!%6:%O!("%A(-=#)5DQGIXUWKHUGLVFXVVLRQLQ&HQQDPR² 

R
$GLIIHUHQWYLHZKDVEHHQUHFHQWO\SXWIRUZDUGE\5RYDL   GHWHUPLQHGE\WKHLQWHUSOD\RIDQXPEHURIWUDQVLWLYLW\IHDWXUHVVXFK
ZKRGHQLHVWKHFRQWLQXLW\RIWKHM(0SOXUDOVZLWKDQDORJRXVHDUO\ DVWKHLQKHUHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIWKHSDUWLFLSDQW V WKHLUUHODWLRQWR
/DWLQIRUPVDQGUHJDUGVWKHPLQVWHDGDVSDUWDQGSDUFHORIWKHVDPH WKHSUHGLFDWH LHWKHPDWLFUHODWLRQV DQGLQKHUHQWOH[LFDODVSHFW
SKHQRPHQRQWKHVSUHDGRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHWR6DQG$IXQFWLRQ /HKPDQQ&RPULH² 

7KLVQRWLRQZKLFKUHIOHFWVWKHGHJUHHRISULPDU\UHVSRQVLELOLW\RI
DSDUWLFLSDQWRYHUWKHYHUEDOSURFHVVLVDPXOWLIDFWRULDOGLPHQVLRQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q?:% A/3O8N<%38BB<A,

.745B'J=775B8<'K>74'$::;<=7>?5'$BG;I587<'>8'3=75'3=7>8
,Q/DWH/DWLQHVSHFLDOO\LQWHFKQLFDOWH[WVIURPWKHIRXUWK²ILIWKFHQWXULHVZLWKDQLVRODWHGH[DPSOHDOUHDG\
RFFXUULQJLQ3HWURQLXV·7($'-#46)>D@ ILUVWFHQWXU\႐ᅡZKHUHWKHYHUELVLQWKHQRQDJUHHLQJWKLUGSHUVRQ
VLQJXODUIRUPIROORZHGE\DSOXUDODUJXPHQW WKHUHIUHTXHQWO\RFFXUVDOVRWKHDFFXVDWLYHRIWKH26DUJXPHQW
LQLPSHUVRQDOFRQVWUXFWLRQVLQERWKWKHWHQVHVRIWKH#):!4$1>%>E²G@DQGWKHI!-:!4$1>>H@DVZHOODVZLWKWKH
YHUEDODGMHFWLYHM)"10ZLWKDGHRQWLFYDOXH>I@DOUHDG\DWWHVWHGLQDUFKDLF/DWLQ WKRXJKUDUHO\LQQRQJHUXQGLYH
IRUPV >@ FI(UQRXW6YHQQXQJ² UHFHQWO\GLVFXVVHGE\56%7"#6)8*+++39%

 >D@ '(/"(%$-d% %-"/)"#"(& 3HWURQ7($'-#46)  LPSHUVRQDO

 PDNH03$6635(668%-6*EDQTXHW3/1(87
 ´6RWKDWEDQTXHWVDUHPDGHµ

% >E@% d)!%0(4%">.%$-& .*+ ,WDODDQG$FWV

 QRWEDSWL]H03$6635(668%-6*WKH\3/$&&
 ´7KDWRQHVKRXOGQRWEDSWL]HWKHPµ

% >F@% '"%& *-(%"*#.!% I-6%6>)#&10% @!-L%<!$+L

 EHFRPH35(6,1'6*SUD\HU$&&IRUHYHU\ERG\$%/ LPSHUVRQDOSDVVLYH 
 ´3UD\LQJWDNHVSODFHRQH LQGHILQLWH VD\VDSUD\HUDSUD\HULVVDLGµ

% >G@% /$%.! !064#0LLL% )6)%!(#1$/.%$-& $QWKLP 

 VNLQ$&&SLNH*(1QRWHDW03$6635(668%-6*
 ´2QHVKRXOGQRWHDWWKHSLNH·VVNLQµ

% >H@% 41>% :(4$1>% :1!-#$% >#00(>

 ZKHQPDNH331(876*EH)873(5)6*0DVV$&&
 ´:KHQWKH0DVVLVRYHUµ @!-L%<!$+L%

% >I@% "!% 4(-)#&10% ?(I6-($(0% :(4$(0d% $%.#1$! $QWKLP

 DERXWPHDW3/$%/VWHZ333/)$&&PDNH333/)$&&XVH*(581'1(87
 ´$VIRUPHDWLWVKRXOGEHEHHDWHQVWHZHGµ

 >D@ 5"%(!& 5"5"%$- (QQLXV*-(5!"#!0

 OLIH$&&OLYH03$6635(6,1'
 ´2QHOLYHVOLIHµ

% >E@% !.???& 1.+4"/(%$- 3ODXWXV3(0#)(

 ,$&&GHVSLVH03$6635(6,1'
 ´,DPGHVSLVHGRQHGHVSLVHVPH OLW LW LVGHVSLVHGPH µ

% >F@ 1$ % 5(+(& 5"#.(-#(%!$%% *).(-"(%'(/".#1$!%

 LQRUGHUWRFRQWDLQHUVZLQH DQGRLO PDNH*(51(876*
 ´,QRUGHUWRPDNHFRQWDLQHUVIRUZLQHDQGRLOµ 9DUU;,,,

:KHQWKHQRXQLQWKHDFFXVDWLYHDJUHHVZLWKWKHYHUE FI>F@%:#$%6-($#6)!> >G@41$!>%)6)%>()"14!$1- DOVR

>D@?#$(>%?#?#$1- WKHSDWWHUQLVDPELJXRXVEHWZHHQDQLPSHUVRQDODQGDSDVVLYHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ WKHUHIRUHLW
LVQRWFOHDUZKHWKHUWKHQRXQLQWKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVHLVHLWKHUDQ6RUDQ2DUJXPHQWVHH&HQQDPR 
$FKDUDFWHULVWLF/DWH/DWLQGHYHORSPHQWLVDOVRWKHLPSHUVRQDOXVHRIWKHWKLUGSHUVRQVLQJXODUIRUPRIWKH
YHUELQWKHDFWLYHYRLFHZLWKWKH26DUJXPHQWLQWKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVH I6$!0$2%?(.!$2%"!&!$2%+6--!$2%#1?($2%41-($2%"#4#$2%
H[LVWHQWLDO+(&!$ >@ FI/|IVWHGW²*+:;9)*:*<=>.6YHQQXQJ² 7KLVSDWWHUQLQWXUQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<78%A<Kb/BD%,F%3,K8%<KD\A8B*7%<BH%<N/DBA8B*%/B%N<*8%N<*/B% Q?Q

GHYHORSVWKHXVHRIWKHWKLUGSHUVRQVLQJXODUDFWLYHWRPDUNLPSHUVRQDOLW\ZKLFKZDVFRQILQHGWRVRPHYHUEV
6I6-$!$2%#)X1#$2%(#$2%$(!"!$2%I(!)#$!$2%I1"!$ LQDUFKDLF/DWLQ FI?"#@"#6)*+;-9)*=<*A.DOVRUHFHQWGLVFXVVLRQLQ%DXHU
²&HQQDPRE 

 >D@ .2"-.& +*).%d% '*-$#/$)*+& 3+#-6)

 JRRXW,1)LVXVXDOERLOV3/$&&
 ´7KHUHFRPHRXWERLOVµ

% >E@% @(0.0(%%% "!%% 4#?#$($!%% :6-0#$()% !")).&& =$"#,.#%*+&& 4(++$+%

 KDYH,03),1'6*IURPWRZQ$%/SHUKDSVRQHWKRXVDQGILYHKXQGUHG\DUG @!-L%<!$+L
 ´ 7KHSODFH ZDVDSSUR[LPDWHO\RQHWKRXVDQGDQGILYHKXQGUHG\DUGVIURPWKHWRZQµ

% >F@% #)%O!&-(!6LLL% )6)%@(0.%%% @$#/&& #$!.-$!???& -HURPH8G!=#!.%

 LQ+HEUHZ$%/QRWKDYH35(6,1'6*WKLV$&&QXPEHU$&&
 ´,Q+HEUHZWKLVQXPEHUGRHVQRWH[LVWµ OLWQRWKDVWKLVQXPEHU$&&

7KHDFFXVDWLYHFDVHDOVRIUHTXHQWO\RFFXUVLQQRPLQDOFODXVHVWKDWLVLQH[FODPDWLRQVOLVWLQJVUHFLSHVDS
SRVLWLRQVDQGFRPPDQGV>D@ FI6YHQQXQJ²*HUROD² 7KLVXVHWRRGHYHORSVSDWWHUQV
WKDWZHUHFKDUDFWHULVWLFRIHDUO\/DWLQLQZKLFKWKHDFFXVDWLYHUHSODFHGWKHQRPLQDWLYHLUUHVSHFWLYHRIWKHQRXQ
GHFOHQVLRQDOFODVV>E@ FI1RUEHUJ²²&HQQDPR² 

 >D@ 4*%"*#.!%% ("%!602%% X1#%% 0()51#)!>% >!#!)$ 3+#-6)

 SRWLRQ$&&WRWKHP$&&ZKR120EORRG$&&XULQDWH35(6,1'3/
 ´ 2QHVKRXOGJLYH DSRWLRQWRWKRVHZKRXULQDWHEORRGµ

% >E@& !.&& "#'.)"/.!%% JK%% 0/.).+%(! 3ODXWXV3#0$!..(-#(

 ,$&&XQKDSS\$&&DQGGUHDGIXO$&&
 ´:KDWDQXQIRUWXQDWHVFRXQGUHO,DPµ

LF>:5'=89'-B=II=7>:=M')5M=7>F8<'>8'3=75'3=7>8
7KHXVHRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHLQVXEMHFWIXQFWLRQLQWHUDFWVLQ/DWH/DWLQZLWKWKHFRQFRPLWDQWUHRUJDQL]DWLRQ
RIYRLFHGLVWLQFWLRQVVLJQDOHGE\WKHLQWHUFKDQJHDELOLW\DPRQJYRLFHIRUPVZKHUHE\WKHSDVVLYHYRLFHPD\RF
FXULQDFWLYHIXQFWLRQ>D²E@VRFDOOHGGHSRQHQWL]DWLRQ )OREHUW DQGFRQYHUVHO\WKHDFWLYHPD\RFFXULQ
SDVVLYHIXQFWLRQ>F@

 >D@ /*!!.(%$- FRPPHDW  0()51#0%% I!-%% $6$1>%% 46-I10 3+#-6)

 FRPHRXW03$6635(6,1'6*EORRG120WKURXJKZKROH$&&ERG\$&&
 ´7KHEORRGFRPHVRXWIURPDOOKLVERG\µ

% >E@% 0#%X1#0.#&!$%% !(>%% /*.-/.0(%$- 3+-6)#46)%7(.!-)#$()1>%1RUEHUJ

 LIVRPHERG\120VKH$&&IRUFH,03),1'03$666*
 ´,IVRPHERG\SXQLVKHGKHU OLWLVSXQLVKHGKHU µ

% >F@% /()9/$)*+d% 0(.!%% (0I!-060%% "#'.-$#%& &"#'.-$#%$- '

 PXVKURRPV$&&VDOW$%/VSULQNOHG$&&VHUYH35(6,1'3/
 ´0XVKURRPVDUHVHUYHGVSULQNOHGZLWKWKHLURZQMXLFHRUZLWKVDOWµ $SLFLXVH!%-!%46X1#)(-#( 

7KHSDWWHUQVLOOXVWUDWHGLQ>D²E@H[HPSOLI\LQJWKHIXQFWLRQDOHTXLYDOHQFHDPRQJYRLFHIRUPVVKRZDYLR
ODWLRQRIWKHFDQRQLFDOUXOHVDVVLJQLQJJUDPPDWLFDOIXQFWLRQVWRWKHDUJXPHQWVRIWKHYHUESUHGLFDWH VRFDOOHG
OLQNLQJUXOHV ,QSRLQWRIIDFWLQWKHSDVVLYHYRLFHWKHUHRFFXUVDQ$DUJXPHQW UDWKHUWKDQ2 LQVXEMHFWIXQF
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q?<% A/3O8N<%38BB<A,

WLRQ X1#0.#&!$%46!-4!&($1- 46!-4!&($LQ>E@ DQGZLWKWKHDFWLYHPRUSKRORJ\WKHUHRFFXUVDQ2DUJXPHQWLQ

VXEMHFWIXQFWLRQ UDWKHUWKDQ$4(.'41.60%#):!-1)$ #):!-1)$1-LQ>F@ :KHQWKHUROHRIYHUEDODUJXPHQWVLVQR
ORQJHUFRQVLVWHQWO\LGHQWLILHGWKRXJKFDVHPDUNLQJWKDWVWDUWVSDWWHUQLQJRQDQDFWLYHLQDFWLYHQHXWUDOEDVLVDV
WHVWLILHGE\WKHXVHRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHLQ6$IXQFWLRQWKHUHRFFXUVDGHHSUHVWUXFWXULQJLQWKHHQFRGLQJRIWKH
DUJXPHQWVWUXFWXUHRIWKHFODXVHLQYROYLQJERWKWKHUXOHVOLQNLQJDUJXPHQWVWRWKHLUV\QWDFWLFIXQFWLRQDQGWKH
LGHQWLILFDWLRQRIWKHUROHRIYHUEDODUJXPHQWV7KHVDPHDUJXPHQWLQIDFWPD\EHLQWHUSUHWHGDVHLWKHU2RU6&2%
GHSHQGLQJRQWKHFRQWH[W VHH&HQQDPR>,,*1B)>,,*CB 7KLVDPELJXLW\PLJKWKDYHIDFLOLWDWHGWKHUHLQWHUSUH
WDWLRQRIDJUDPPDWLFDOREMHFW 2 DVDQ6&DUJXPHQWDVLOOXVWUDWHGLQ>@ZKLFKRZLQJWRWKHDPELJXLW\RIYRLFH
PRUSKRORJ\DQGWKHODFNRIIXQFWLRQRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHZKLFKQRORQJHUFRQVLVWHQWO\VLJQDOVDQ2DUJXPHQWPD\
EHDPELJXRXVEHWZHHQDQLPSHUVRQDOLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ´RQHVKRXOGQRWWXUQWKHJUDYHRYHUµZLWK.(I#"!> 2WKH
REMHFWDSDVVLYHIXQFWLRQ´WKHJUDYHVKRXOGQRWEHWXUQHGRYHUµZLWK.(I#"!> 2WKHVXEMHFWDQGDQLQWUDQVLWLYH
DQWLFDXVDWLYH PHDQLQJ´WKHJUDYHVKRXOGQRWWXUQRYHUµZLWK.(I#"!> 6&%VXEMHFW

 >@ .(I#"! > % )6)%-!?6.?($1-%

 WKHJUDYHQRWWXUQRYHU35(668%-03$666*
 YHUEWKLUGVLQJLPSHUVRQDOSDVVLYHIRUPDFFXVDWLYHDUJXPHQW

$QLQWUDQVLWLYH DQWLFDXVDWLYH SDWWHUQVXFKDV>@ZLWKDQDFFXVDWLYHVXEMHFWDQGDSDVVLYHPRUSKRORJ\

LQGHHGPLJKWKDYHEHHQRQHRIWKHSDWKVDORQJZKLFKDQDFWLYHLQDFWLYHV\VWHPPDUNHGWKRXJKFDVHPDUNLQJ
DURVHLQ/DWH/DWLQZLWKDVKLIWRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHIURPPDUNLQJWKH6&2DUJXPHQWRISHULSKHUDOWUDQVLWLYLW\GR
PDLQVVXFKDVLPSHUVRQDOSDVVLYHV DVLQ>D@ WRFRUHRQHVDVZLWKLQWUDQVLWLYHXQDFFXVDWLYHV &HQQDPR
DQGJHQHUDOGLVFXVVLRQRQWKHUROHSOD\HGE\LPSHUVRQDOFRQVWUXFWLRQVLQWKHULVHRIDFWLYHV\VWHPVLQ'RQRKXH
>,,-.0DOFKXNRY0LWKXQ 

A;>BCD'$BG;I587<'=89'745')><5'FH'N5=9'(=BC>8G'
$WVRPHSRLQWLQWLPHLQ/DWH/DWLQRQFHFDVHPDUNLQJVWDUWVSDWWHUQLQJRQDQDFWLYHQHXWUDOEDVLVDVLQ>@
WKHV\QWDFWLFUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHYHUEDQGLWVDUJXPHQW V FRPHVWREHPDUNHGRQWKHYHUERQO\ LHRQWKHKHDG
RIWKHFRQVWUXFWLRQ UDWKHUWKDQRQWKHDUJXPHQW V  LHWKHGHSHQGHQWHOHPHQW DVLQDUFKDLFDQGFODVVLFDO/DWLQ

 >D@ +1#10%% +$/$!' $ 641.6-1>%% ?#$#(%% +(#($ >$*5@

 ZKRVH*(1MXLFH$&& H\H3/*(1LQIHFWLRQV1(87KHDO35(6,1'6*
 ´:KRVHMXLFHKHDOVH\HLQIHFWLRQVµ&/01410 >&$6(@>$*5@  3+#-6)5RYDL$SS,

,Q>E@LQIDFWWKH$VWDWXVRIWKHQRXQLQWKHDFFXVDWLYH0141>2LVVLJQDOHGE\WKHWKLUGSHUVRQVLQJXODU
DJUHHPHQWRQWKHYHUE 0()($ DQGLQ>E@WKHPDVFXOLQH QRPLQDWLYH VLQJXODUHQGLQJRIWKHSDVWSDUWLFLSOH
I(0010 DQGWKHWKLUGSHUVRQVLQJXODUHQGLQJRIWKHILQLWHYHUE :1!-#$ LGHQWLI\DQGGLIIHUHQWLDWHWKH$DUJXPHQW
LQWKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVH  4.!-#41> IURP2 #)#1-#(  QRPLQDWLYH 

 >E@ 0#%d%/).-"/$!d%(.#X1(%% #)#1-#(%% 4(++$+&& '$.-"%%

 LI FOHULF$&&DQ\120RIIHQFH120VXIIHU3306*120EH)873(5)6*
 ´,IDFOHULF«VXIIHUHGDQRIIHQFHµ N!]%<.(>;9FRGG$

7KHSKHQRPHQRQZKHUHE\DJUHHPHQWRQO\UDWKHUWKDQFDVHPDUNLQJPD\LGHQWLI\WKHV\QWDFWLFIXQFWLRQRI
WKHYHUEDODUJXPHQW V PLJKWEHLQWHUSUHWHGDVUHVXOWLQJIURPDPRUHJHQHUDOFKDQJHWKHVKLIWIURPDFDQRQLFDO
"!I!)"!)$M>(-=#)5%ODQJXDJH/DWLQ LQZKLFKV\QWDFWLFUHODWLRQVZLWKLQDFRQVWUXFWLRQDUHPRVWW\SLFDOO\PDUNHG
RQWKHGHSHQGHQWHOHPHQW WRODQJXDJHVZLWK%+!("M>(-=#)5FRGLQJSDWWHUQV LQZKLFKV\QWDFWLFUHODWLRQVDUH
PDUNHGRQWKHKHDGRIWKHFRQVWUXFWLRQ WKH5RPDQFHODQJXDJHV 1LFKROVDE9LQFHQWIRU
WKHULVHRIFOLWLFVDOVR/HGJHZD\IRUWKFRPLQJ&HQQDPR  @

@
7KHGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQKHDGPDUNLQJDQGGHSHQGHQWPDUNLQJODQ GHSHQGHQWPDUNLQJODQJXDJHVPD\KDYHVRPHKHDGPDUNLQJIHDWXUHV
JXDJHVLVQRWFOHDUFXWEXWDJUDGLHQWDORQJZKLFKSUHGRPLQDQWO\ DQGYLFHYHUVD 1LFKROVD 9HUEDJUHHPHQWLQ/DWLQ DQGJHQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<78%A<Kb/BD%,F%3,K8%<KD\A8B*7%<BH%<N/DBA8B*%/B%N<*8%N<*/B% Q?R

,QSRLQWRIIDFWWKH´TXLUN\µXVHVRIWKHQRPLQDWLYHDQGWKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVHVWRPDUNFRUHDUJXPHQWVLQ/DWH
/DWLQPD\EHFRPSDUHGZLWKVLPLODUVXEV\VWHPVRFFXUULQJLQ SUHGRPLQDQWO\ +!("M>(-=#)5ODQJXDJHVZLWKD
4(0!%0'0$!>PDUNLQJWKHV\QWDFWLFUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWZRHOHPHQWVRIDFRQVWUXFWLRQERWKRQWKHKHDGDQGRQWKH
GHSHQGHQW 1LFKROVD ZKLFKPD\H[KLELWWKHIROORZLQJ

 L RQO\6)! RULJLQDOO\REOLTXH 4(0!XVHGIRU$2DQG6 DVLQVHYHUDOQRQ3DPD1\XQJDQ

ODQJXDJHVRI$XVWUDOLDHJ:DUQGDUDQJ'L[RQ²LQ1LFKROV*+-;19 WKDWLV
RQHFDVH:6-%46-!%()"%)6)M46-!%(-51>!)$0
 LL D>#)#>(.%0'0$!>%6:%4(0!%6II60#$#6)ZLWK$6 LHWKHVXEMHFW LQWKH"#-!4$%4(0!DQG&% WKHREMHFW 
DQGQRQFRUHDUJXPHQWVLQWKH6&.#X1!FDVH DVLQ$G\JKH:HVW&LUFDVVLDQ 
 LLL D$96M4(0!%0'0$!>LQYROYLQJ#"!)$#4(.%>(-=#)5%:6-%$2DQG6ZKLFKJRLQWKH"#-!4$%4(0!ZKHUHDV
)6)M46-!%(-51>!)$0DUHLQWKH6&.#X1!FDVH DVLQ6KXVZDS,QWHULRU6DOLVK  1LFKROVD 

7KH/DWH/DWLQFKDQJHVLQWKHPDUNLQJDQGOLQNLQJRIFRUHDUJXPHQWVWKHUHIRUHPLJKWEHUHJDUGHGDVGLIIHUHQW
PDQLIHVWDWLRQVRIDPRUHJHQHUDOW\SRORJLFDOFKDQJHWKHPRYHWRZDUGWKHKHDGPDUNLQJRUJDQL]DWLRQRIVRPH
JUDPPDWLFDOGRPDLQVLQWKHWUDQVLWLRQWR5RPDQFH 9LQFHQW&HQQDPRE/HGJHZD\IRUWK
FRPLQJ 7KLVZRXOGDOORZXVWRYLHZLQDGLIIHUHQWOLJKWVRPHFDVHSDWWHUQVVXEV\VWHPVGLVFXVVHGDERYHVXFKDV
WKHQRPLQDWLYHIRU2DUJXPHQWV >“DQ@LQVRPHODWHWH[WVUHVHPEOLQJWKHGLUHFWFDVHRI6KXVZDS WKHDFFXVDWLYH
DVWKHRQO\FDVHIRUQXFOHDU DVZHOODVQRQQXFOHDU DUJXPHQWVLQDOO5RPDQFHDUHDVDWVRPHSRLQW DVLWXDWLRQ
WKDWLVUHPLQLVFHQWRI:DUQGDUDQJ DQGWKHODWHUUHVWULFWLRQRIDFFXVDWLYHWR2 DQGQRQFRUH DUJXPHQWVLQ*DXO
ZLWK$6EHLQJPDUNHGE\WKHQRPLQDWLYHLQVWHDG UHVHPEOLQJWKH$G\JKHFDVHRSSRVLWLRQ 
7KH/DWH/DWLQGDWDWKXVSURYLGHLQWHUHVWLQJLQVLJKWVLQWRI600#&.!%-61$!0%$+-615+%9+#4+%(%"!I!)"!)$MPDUNLQJ
ODQJXDJHPD\GHYHORSKHDGPDUNLQJFRGLQJSDWWHUQVDVDUHVXOWRIFKDQJHVLQWKHDOLJQPHQWRIFRUHDUJXPHQWV
LQYDULRXVWUDQVLWLYLW\GRPDLQV
)XUWKHUHYLGHQFHIRUKHDGPDUNLQJFRGLQJSDWWHUQVDULVLQJLQWKHWUDQVLWLRQWR5RPDQFHLVSURYLGHGE\WKH
HPHUJHQFHRIFOLWLFVZHOODWWHVWHGLQ0HURYLQJLDQ/DWLQ FI>@IURPWKHHLJKWKFHQWXU\႐ᅡ PDUNLQJGLVORFDWHG
2DUJXPHQWVRQWKHYHUEDIXQFWLRQWKDWZDVFDUULHGE\FDVHPDUNLQJLQHDUO\DQGFODVVLFDO/DWLQ 1LFKROVD
DQGGLVFXVVLRQLQ9LQFHQW/HGJHZD\IRUWKFRPLQJ 

 >@ #I0(%% 41II(%% :-()5()$.(%% $6$(%

 WKLV120$&&FXS120$&&FXW35(668%-3/LW)DOO120$&&
 ´7KLVFXSWKDWWKH\EUHDNLWXS OLWWKLVFXSEUHDNXSLWDOO µ 3DURG\RIWKHN!]%7(.L9LQFHQW


$875:59587<'FH'745'&6758959'$::;<=7>?5
7KHVWUXFWXUHVLOOXVWUDWHGHDUOLHUH[HPSOLI\LQJWKHXVHRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHZLWKHTXDWLYHDQWLFDXVDWLYHLP
SHUVRQDODQGSDVVLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQVDVZHOODVZLWKVRPHLQWUDQVLWLYHYHUEVDOWKRXJKFKDUDFWHULVWLFRI/DWHDQG
0HGLHYDO/DWLQDSSHDUWRGHYHORSSDWWHUQVRIDFWLYHFRGLQJV\VWHPVDOUHDG\RFFXUULQJLQHDUO\/DWLQLQVRPHJUDP
PDWLFDOGRPDLQVZKHUHWKH6DUJXPHQWGRHVQRWRFFXULQWKHH[SHFWHGQRPLQDWLYHFDVHEXWLQWKHDFFXVDWLYH7KLV
LVWKHFDVHIRUWKHLQDFWLYHDUJXPHQWVRIQRPLQDOFODXVHV6&HVSHFLDOO\WKRVHWKDWFDQEHLQWHUSUHWHGDVHTXDWLYH
FODXVHVLQYROYLQJHOOLSVLVRIWKHYHUE!00!´EHµDVLQ>@DVZHOODVIRUWKH6DUJXPHQWRIH[FODPDWLYHSUHVHQWDWLYH
VWUXFWXUHVLQWURGXFHGE\WKHDGYHUE!44!%´KHUHµWKHDFFXVDWLYHRIDXQLYHUEDWHGSURQRXQ #02%8>>J%´+!µLVWH´$+#0µ 
IROORZHGE\DQDFFXVDWLYHDUJXPHQWIRUZKLFKWKHDFFXVDWLYHLVDSSDUHQWO\ROGHUWKDQWKHQRPLQDWLYHZKLFKLV
UHSRUWHGDVDWWHVWHGIURP&LFHURRQZDUGV FI+RIPDQQDQG6]DQW\U† 

HUDOO\LQWKH,QGR(XURSHDQODQJXDJHV LVDKHDGPDUNLQJIHDWXUH DUJXPHQW LHWKHGHSHQGHQW XQOLNHLQSRODUGHSHQGHQWPDUNLQJ

VLQFHLWPDUNVWKHV\QWDFWLFUHODWLRQEHWZHHQDYHUEDQGLWVDUJX ODQJXDJHVVXFKDV-DSDQHVHZKLFKGRQRWKDYHYHUEDJUHHPHQW VHH
PHQW WKHVXEMHFW RQWKHYHUE LHRQWKHKHDG UDWKHUWKDQRQWKH GLVFXVVLRQLQ1LFKROVDE 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% A/3O8N<%38BB<A,

 >@ :6-$1)($1>%B#46&1.1>%
 OXFN\$&&1LFREXOXV$&&
 ´+RZOXFN\LV1LFREXOXVµ 3ODXWXVS(44+#"!0

 >D@ 0!"%!441>%% @(.(0$-#6)!>2%% 0$($%% 41>%% >#.#$!

 EXWKHUH0$&&3DODVWULR$&&VWD\35(6,1'6*ZLWKVROGLHU$%/
 ´%XWKHUHLV3DODVWULRZKRLVZLWKDVROGLHU OLWKHUH3DODVWULRVWD\VZLWKVROGLHU µ 3ODXWXVA#.!0%
5.6-#6010 

 >E@ 0!"%!441>%% <>I+#$-16)!>2%% ("?!)#$%

 EXWKHUHKH$&&$PSKLWUXR$&&FRPH35(6,1'6*
 ´%XWKHUHFRPHV$PSKLWUXRµ 3ODXWXV<>I+#$-16 %

$OVRWKH26&DUJXPHQWRIVRPHLPSHUVRQDOYHUEVFRQVWUXFWLRQVHLWKHULQWKHDFWLYH>D@RULQWKHPHGLR
SDVVLYHMKIRUP>E@RFFXULQWKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVHZLWKDPELJXLW\EHWZHHQDQLPSHUVRQDODQGDSHUVRQDO SDVVLYH 
LQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIWKHSDWWHUQZKHQWKHVROHDUJXPHQWDJUHHVZLWKWKHYHUELQWKHMKIRUPDVLQ>F@

 >D@ >!%% $(!"!$

 ,$&&DQQR\35(6,1'6* ,03 
 ´,DPDQQR\HGµ OLW>LW@PHDQQR\V

% Z::E@ )#.)!% $!%% I6I1.#%% ?!-!-!$1-S%

 QRWDWDOO\RX$&&SHRSOH*(1IHDU03$66,1'6*,03
 ´'RQ·W\RXKDYHDQ\UHVSHFWIRUWKHDXGLHQFH" OLWGRHVQ·W>LW@IHDU\RXRISHRSOH" µ $WWD46>L%

% Z::F@ ?#$(>%% ?#?#$1-%

 OLIH$&&OLYH03$6635(6,1'
 ´2QHOLYHVOLIHOLIHLVOLYHGµ (QQLXV*-(5!"#!0

7KHVHFRQVWUXFWLRQVLQGLFDWHWKHH[LVWHQFHRI GHSHQGHQWPDUNLQJ SDWWHUQVRIDFWLYHV\QWD[DOUHDG\LQDUFKDLF

/DWLQWKHLQDFWLYHVROHDUJXPHQWRIQRQFDQRQLFDOLQWUDQVLWLYHVLWXDWLRQV 6& LVPDUNHGOLNHWKH2DUJXPHQWRI
FDQRQLFDOWUDQVLWLYHVLWXDWLRQV LHWKHREMHFW JHQHUDOO\RFFXUULQJLQWKHDFFXVDWLYHFDVH
$OVRWKHVHFRQGGHFOHQVLRQ´WKHPDWLFZHDNQHXWHUVµRIWKH6VWHP HJ1$!-1>´EHOO\µ46-#1>´VNLQµ4(!.1>%
´VN\µ ZKRVHQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHIRUPVDUHLGHQWLFDOZLWKWKHDFFXVDWLYHRIVHFRQGGHFOHQVLRQPDVFXOLQH
QRXQV HJ"!10%>120@%ñ%"!1>>$&&@´*RGµ PD\EHUHJDUGHGDVHDUO\LQVWDQFHVRIDFWLYHLQDFWLYHFRGLQJV\VWHPV
LQ/DWLQ /D]]HURQL>,,>C.5RYDLD 
)RUWKHVHQHXWHUQRXQVWUDGLWLRQDOUHIHUHQFHJUDPPDUVRI/DWLQDOVRJLYHWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ´VHFRQGDU\µ
IRUPVRIDQLPDWHJHQGHU PDVFXOLQH>PRUHUDUHO\@IHPLQLQHJHQGHU GHSHQGLQJRQWKHQRXQ7KHUHIRUHDORQJVLGH
WKHQHXWHUIRUP46-#1>DWWHVWHGDWDOOVWDJHVRIWKHODQJXDJHLQHDUO\/DWLQ HJ3ODXWXV³WKLUGFHQWXU\ᄽᅐ%
9DUUR³ILUVWFHQWXU\ᄽᅐ WKHUHDOVRRFFXUVWKHPDVFXOLQH46-#10 5RYDLDE 

 >D@ WULV IDFLOH46-#60%% FRQWULYLVWL &1&1.60V

 WKUHHHDVLO\VNLQV$&&0FRQVXPH3(5)35(66*RIEXOORFNV$&&0
 ´<RXKDYHHDVLO\FRQVXPHGWKUHHEXOORFNVVNLQVµ 3ODXWXV@6!)1.10

 >E@ LDP WLEL« 4-(0010%% 46-#10 UHGGLWXVW

 DOUHDG\\RX'$7WKLFN1200VNLQ1200UHWXUQ33%(35(6,1'6*
 ´7KHWKLFNVNLQKDVDOUHDG\EHHQUHWXUQHGWR\RXµ 3ODXWXVF-(5>!)$(,,
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<78%A<Kb/BD%,F%3,K8%<KD\A8B*7%<BH%<N/DBA8B*%/B%N<*8%N<*/B% Q?@

7KHQHXWHUIRUPRIWKHVHQRXQVLQHDUO\/DWLQRFFXUVLQV\QWDFWLFFRQWH[WVZKHUHWKHVXEMHFWLVLQDFWLYH LH
QRQDJHQWLYH g%SDVVLYHV>D@ILHQWLYHV%>E@HTXDWLYHVWUXFWXUHV>F@FKDQJHVRIVWDWH>G@WKDWLVZLWKXQDF
FXVDWLYHVWUXFWXUHV H[DPSOHVIURP5RYDLD² 

 >D@ "!$!5!$1-%% 46-#1> GH WHUJR« PHR

 XQFRYHU03$6635(6,1'6*VNLQ1(87IURPEDFN$%/P\$%/
 ´7KHVNLQLVXQFRYHUHGIURPP\EDFNµ 3ODXWXV8I#"#410

 >E@ :#!-!$%% 46-#1>d% >(41.601>V

 EHFRPH,03)68%-6*VNLQ1(87PRWWOHG1(87«
 ´7KDWWKHVNLQEHFDPHPRWWOHGµ 3ODXWXVS(44+#"!0

 >F@ 46-#1> >VLW@« QRQ (0I!-1> DFd% "1-1>d

 VNLQ1(87EH68%-35(66*QHLWKHUURXJK1(87QRU«KDUG1(87«
 ´7KDWWKHVNLQEHQHLWKHUURXJKQRUKDUGµ 9DUU

 >G@ TXRG SHULLW I!-##$N%

 ZKDW1(87JRORVW35(6,1'6*JRORVW35(6,1'6*

% >!1>%% 46-#1> FXP!FLVWHOOD

 P\1(87VNLQ1(87ZLWK EDVNHW$%/
 ´:KDWJHWVORVWJHWVORVWP\VNLQZLWKWKHEDVNHWµ 3ODXWXV3#0$!..(-#(

)ROORZLQJ/D]]HURQL E DQG5RYDL DE ,DUJXHWKDWWKHVHDOWHUQDWLRQVDUHQRWFDVHVRIIUHHDO

ORPRUSK\EHWZHHQWKHPDVFXOLQHDQGQHXWHUIRUPV /HXPDQQ+RIPDQQDQG6]DQW\U††² EXWWKDWWKH
´QHXWHUµYDULDQWRIWKHVHQRXQVUHDOL]HWKHHDUO\DWWHVWDWLRQRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHWRPDUNQXFOHDUQRQ2DUJXPHQWV
DSKHQRPHQRQWKDWEHFRPHVTXLWHZLGHVSUHDGLQ/DWH/DWLQDVSDUWRIWKHORVVRIWKHFDVHV\VWHP 
8QGHUWKLVYLHZWKHPDWLFQHXWHUVLQVWDQWLDWHWKHJHQHUDOL]DWLRQRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHLQ6DQG$IXQFWLRQZLWK
VRPHQRXQVRFFXUULQJLQLWLDOO\LQV\QWDFWLFFRQWH[WVZKHUHWKHVXEMHFWLVLQDFWLYHDQGLQDQLPDWH7KLVSDWWHUQ
LVRI,QGR(XURSHDQLQKHULWDQFH DWWHVWHGLQ+LWWLWH$YHVWLFDQG,QGR,UDQLDQDVZHOODV*UHHNDORQJVLGH/DWLQ 
DQGSRLQWVWRWKHH[LVWHQFHRIVRPHDUHDVRIWKHV\QWD[WKDWIROORZHGDQDFWLYHLQDFWLYHRULHQWDWLRQLQWKHFRGLQJ
RIYHUEDODUJXPHQWV /D]]HURQLDE 
$OUHDG\LQHDUO\/DWLQWKHUHIRUHDORQJVLGHWKHFDQRQLFDOQRPLQDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHDOLJQPHQWRIWKHFRUHDUJX
PHQWVRIWKHFODXVH6$DQG2WKHUHRFFXUVWUXFWXUHVWKDWVKRZDVHPDQWLFDOO\FRQVWUDLQHGVSOLWPDUNLQJRI6
VHQVLWLYHWRWKHPRUHJHQHUDOQRWLRQRIFRQWURODQGDQLPDF\ZKLFKSOD\DQLPSRUWDQWUROHLQWKHHQFRGLQJRIWKH
DUJXPHQWVWUXFWXUHRIWKHFODXVHLQ/DWLQERWKV\QFKURQLFDOO\DQGGLDFKURQLFDOO\ &HQQDPRDE
 
,QSDUWLFXODU,DUJXHWKDWSDWWHUQVRIDFWLYHV\QWD[DOUHDG\H[LVWLQJLQHDUO\/DWLQLQVRPHSHULSKHUDOORZ
WUDQVLWLYLW\GRPDLQVVSUHDGWRPRUHFHQWUDOFDQRQLFDOVWUXFWXUHVH[WHQGLQJIURPQRQFDQRQLFDOHTXDWLYHFODXVHV
VXFKDVQRPLQDOFODXVHVWRSURWRW\SLFDOHTXDWLYHFODXVHVDQGIURPLPSHUVRQDOFRQVWUXFWLRQVWRSDVVLYHLQWUDQVL
WLYHFODXVHVSUREDEO\RZLQJWRWKHLQWHUFKDQJHDELOLW\DPRQJYRLFHIRUPV HJDPRQJDQWLFDXVDWLYHVSDVVLYHV
DQGLPSHUVRQDOV DQGODWHUWRWUDQVLWLYHRQHV VHHDOVR1RUEHUJ 


$ORQJVLGHWKHPDWLFQHXWHUVVXFKDV46-#1>´VNLQµ%4(!.1>´VN\µDQG%
$!-51>´EDFNµZKLFKLQHDUO\/DWLQRFFXUPRVWW\SLFDOO\LQWKHDQL
PDWHJHQGHU LHWKHPDVFXOLQHIRUP WKHQHXWHUIRUPRQO\DSSHDU
LQJLQXQDFFXVDWLYHVWUXFWXUHV H[>D²G@ 5RYDL E LGHQWLILHV
WZRRWKHUVXEW\SHV D WKRVHZKRVHPDVFXOLQHIRUPLVDWWHVWHGDW
DOOVWDJHVZLWKWKHQHXWHUIRUPRQO\RFFXUULQJLQHDUO\/DWLQRQO\
DQGRQO\LQXQDFFXVDWLYHVWUXFWXUHV HJI())10´EDQGDJHµ DQG
E WKRVHIRUZKLFKWKHQHXWHUIRUPRFFXUVWKURXJKRXWWKHKLVWRU\
RIWKHODQJXDJH &(.)!1>%´EDWKµ%:($1>%´GHVWLQ\µ ZLWKWKHPDVFX
OLQHIRUPDWWHVWHGGXULQJWKHLPSHULDODJHEXWRQO\LQ$IXQFWLRQ
WKDWLVDVVXEMHFWVRIWUDQVLWLYHSUHGLFDWHVWKDWLVZLWKWKHDFWLYH
DUJXPHQWRISURWRW\SLFDOWUDQVLWLYHFODXVHV HJ>(.10%:($10%#..60%6IM
I-!00!-#$EDG120GHVWLQ\120WKH\$&&RSSUHVV)873(5)6*´$
EDGGHVWLQ\ZLOOKDYHRSSUHVVHGWKHPµ3HWURQ7($'-#46) 2Q
WKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQJUDPPDWLFDOJHQGHUDQGWKHPDWLFUROHVLQ
,QGR(XURSHDQVHHDOVR/D]]HURQLD
 oi.uchicago.edu

% A/3O8N<%38BB<A,

8QOLNHHDUOLHUDWWHVWDWLRQVLQ/DWH/DWLQWKHSKHQRPHQRQLVQRWFRQILQHGWRPDUJLQDODUHDVRIWUDQVLWLYLW\,W
UHIOHFWVLQVWHDGDJHQXLQHFKDQJHWDNLQJSODFHLQWKHHQFRGLQJRIJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVZKLFKSUHOXGHVWKHEUHDN
LQJGRZQRIWKHFDVHV\VWHPDQGWKHXVHRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHDVWKHRQO\FDVH 3ODQN² DSKHQRPHQRQ
WKDWDVDOUHDG\SRLQWHGRXWE\WKHHLJKWKFHQWXU\႐ᅡRFFXUVDOVRLQ*DXOWKRXJKLWZLWKGUDZVVXEVHTXHQWO\LQ
IDYRURIWKHFRPSHWLQJWZRFDVHV\VWHP 3HL² 

#F8:M;<>F8<
7KHVWXG\RIHDUO\DQG/DWH/DWLQGDWDVKRZVWKHULVHRILQLWLDOO\DFWLYHDQGVXEVHTXHQWO\QHXWUDOSDWWHUQVRI
DOLJQPHQWWHVWLILHGE\WKHH[WHQVLRQRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHZKLFKJUDGXDOO\UHSODFHVWKHQRPLQDWLYHWRPDUNQXFOHDU
DUJXPHQWVRIWKHFODXVH LQLWLDOO\6&DQGVXEVHTXHQWO\6!$ LQWKH5RPDQFHDUHD
7KHFKDQJHVWDNLQJSODFHLQ/DWH/DWLQLQWKHHQFRGLQJRIJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVWKDWLVLQWKHDOLJQPHQWRI
WKHFRUHDUJXPHQWVRIWKHFODXVHLQWHUDFWLQWKHFRXUVHRIWLPHZLWKWKHUHRUJDQL]DWLRQRIYRLFHGLVWLQFWLRQV
OHDGLQJWRWKHWHPSRUDU\ORVVRIWKHJUDPPDWLFDOGLPHQVLRQRIYRLFHZKLFKZLOOEHUHFRQVWLWXWHGLQ5RPDQFHLQ
GLIIHUHQWZD\VDQGDORQJGLIIHUHQWGLPHQVLRQV7KHLQWHUSOD\EHWZHHQWKHWZRFOXVWHUVRIFKDQJHVGHWHUPLQHVD
GHHSUHVWUXFWXULQJLQWKHHQFRGLQJRIWKHDUJXPHQWVWUXFWXUHRIWKHFODXVHSUREDEO\UHIOHFWLQJDPRUHJHQHUDO
SKHQRPHQRQWKHULVHRIKHDGPDUNLQJFRGLQJSDWWHUQVLQDSUHGRPLQDQWO\GHSHQGHQWPDUNLQJODQJXDJHVXFK
DV/DWLQ

$OOB5?>=7>F8<
$%/ DEODWLYH FDVH
$&& DFFXVDWLYH FDVH
$&7 DFWLYH
!4,% 6I7JJMJHK
!+% 6H8M6KJ
&/ FODVVLFDO/DWLQ
'$7 GDWLYH FDVH
'% GJM8H8HJ
'/#% GLKL7J
*(5 JHUXQGLYH
+80 KXPDQ
,03) LPSHUIHFW WHQVH
,03(5 LPSHUDWLYH
*05),$% 8M=J79FH6>
,1' LQGLFDWLYH
,1) LQϮQLWLYH
0 PDVFXOLQH
03$66 PHGLRSDVVLYHPDUNHUMK% LQPLGGOHSDVVLYHRULPSHUVRQDOIXQFWLRQ`
3$66 SDVVLYH
3(5) SHUIHFW WHQVHPDUNHU
5-% =>L76>
35(6 SUHVHQW WHQVHPDUNHU
35(6357 SUHVHQWSDUWLFLSOH
33 SDVWSDUWLFLSOH
3/83 SOXSHUIHFW WHQVHPDUNHU
5)/ UHϰH[LYH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<78%A<Kb/BD%,F%3,K8%<KD\A8B*7%<BH%<N/DBA8B*%/B%N<*8%N<*/B% Q?P

$4% 98HIL>67
68%- VXEMXQFWLYH

<5)!..L%% $JQHOOL /LEHU 3RQWLϮFDOLV (FFOHVLDH 5DYHQQDWLV HGLWHG E\ 2 +ROGHU(JJHU 0RQXPHQWD
*HUPDQLDH +LVWRULFD 6FULSWRUHV 5HUXP /DQJREDUGLFDUXP HW ,WDOLFDUXP 6DHF 9,²,;
+DQQRYHU+DKQVFKH
<)$+#>L%% <)$+#>#2% H!% ,&0!-?($#6)!% 3#&6-1>% ("% *+!6"6-#41>% K!5!>% F-()46-1>% 8I#0$1.( HGLWHG E\ (
/LHFKWHQKDQ&RUSXV0HGLFRUXP/DWLQRUXP9,,,/HLS]LJ7HXEQHU
<)$6)L%@.(4L%/$#)L%% <)$6)#)#%@.(4!)$#)#%/$#)!-(-#1>HGLWHGE\3*H\HU7XUQKRXW%UHSROV
$WWD 7LWXV4XLQFWLXV$WWD36>#46-1>%N($#)6-1>%K!.#X1#(!HGLWHGE\25LEEHFN/HLS]LJ7HXEQHU

3+#-6)%% 3.(1"##%A!->!-#2%A1.6>!"#4#)(%3+#-6)#02HGLWHGE\(2GHU/HLS]LJ7HXEQHU
3/N%% 36-I10%/)04-#I$#6)1>%N($#)(-1>%HUOLQϸ
&RUS&KULVW /$#)!-(-#(%!$%<.#(%D!65-(I+#4( &RUSXV &KULVWLDQRUXP 6HULHV /DWLQD  7XUQKROW %UHSROV

H!:L%*(&L $XGROODQW
8"#4$L%K6$+L%% 8"#4$10%K6$+(-#HGLWHGE\)%OXKPH0RQXPHQWD*HUPDQLDH+LVWRULFDOHJXP,,6WXWWJDUW
+LHUVHPDQQ
N!]%<.(>L%% N!]%<.(>())6-1>HGLWHGE\./HKPDQQ0RQXPHQWD*HUPDQLDH+LVWRULFDOHJXPVHFWLR,
9+DQQRYHU+DKQVFKH
N!]%7(.L% @(4$10%N!5#0%7(.#4(HGLWHGE\.$(FNKDUGW0RQXPHQWD*HUPDQLDH+LVWRULFDOHJXPVHFWLR
,,9,+DQQRYHU+DKQVFKH
@!-L%<!$+L%% 7#.?#(!% ?!.% I6$#10% <!$+!-#(!% @!-!5-#)($#6% ("% .64(% 7()4$(% ,WLQHUDULXP $HJHULDH  HGLWHG E\ :
+HUDHXV+HLGHOEHUJ:LQWHUV
@!$-6)L%7($'-#46)% @!$-6)##%<-&#$-#2%7($'-#46)HGLWHGE\&3HOOHJULQL5RPH$WHQHR
9DUU 9DUURK !0 - 10$#4(! HGLWHGE\**RHW]7HXEQHU/HLS]LJ

P>OM>FGB=Q4D
$XGROOHQW$XJXVWH0DULH+HQUL
  H!:#]#6)1>%$(&!..(!g%e16$X16$%#))6$1!-1)$%$(>%#)%D-(!4#0%6-#!)$#0%X1(>%#)%$6$#10%644#"!)$#0%I(-$#&10%I-(!$!-%
<$$#4(0%#)%46-I6-!%#)04-#I$#6)1>%<$$#4(-1>%!"#$(0)UDQNIXUW0LQHUYD
%DVVROVGH&OLPHQW0DULDQR
% OP<R% 7#)$(]#0%+#0$ç-#4(%"!%.(%.!)51(%.($#)(9ROXPH%DUFHORQD(VFXHODGH)LORORJtD
%DVWDUGDV3DUHUD-
% OPRQ% @(-$#41.(-#"("!0%0#)$(4$#4(0%"!.%N($É)%>!"#!?(.%DUFHORQD(VFXHODGH)LORORJtD
%DXHU%ULJLWWH
% :???% <-4+(#4%7')$(]%#)%/)"6M81-6I!()g%*+!%7I-!("%6:%*-()0#$#?#$'%#)%N($#)%()"%F-!)4+L%7UHQGVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV
6WXGLHVDQG0RQRJUDSKV%HUOLQ0RXWRQGH*UX\WHU
%LFNHO%DQG-1LFKROV
  ´&DVH0DUNLQJDQG$OLJQPHQWµ,Q*+!%O()"&66=%6:%3(0!2HGLWHGE\$0DOFKXNRYDQG$6SHQFHUSS
²2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
 oi.uchicago.edu

QO?% A/3O8N<%38BB<A,

%RQQHW0D[
  N!%.($#)%"!%D-U56#-!%"!%*61-03DULV+DFKHWWH
%XUULGJH.DWH
% OPPQ% 7')$(4$#4%3+()5!%#)%D!->()#4g%<0I!4$0%6:%N()51(5!%3+()5!%#)%D!->()#4%9#$+%@(-$#41.(-%K!:!-!)4!%$6%A#"".!%
H1$4+&XUUHQW,VVXHVLQ/LQJXLVWLF7KHRU\$PVWHUGDP%HQMDPLQV
&HQQDPR0LFKHOD
  ´6HVXXVVLELQHOOH,QVFULSWLRQHV/DWLQDH&KULVWLDQDH9HWHUHVHGLVXFFHVVLYLVYLOXSSLURPDQ]LµA!M
"#6!?6%K6>()G6²
  ´7KH/RVVRIWKH9RLFH'LPHQVLRQEHWZHHQ/DWH/DWLQDQG(DUO\5RPDQFHµ,QO#0$6-#4(.%N#)51#0$#40%
_ááo2%1F>LMJ%ON%D!)!-(.%/001!0%()"%B6)MD!->()#4%N()51(5!0% 6HOHFWHG3DSHUVIURPWKHWK,QWHU
QDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ+LVWRULFDO/LQJXLVWLFV'VVHOGRUI²$XJXVW HGLWHGE\06
6FKPLG-5$XVWLQDQG'6WHLQSS²&XUUHQW,VVXHVLQ/LQJXLVWLF7KHRU\$PVWHUGDP
%HQMDPLQV
  ´/DWH/DWLQ3OHRQDVWLF5HIOH[LYHVDQGWKH8QDFFXVDWLYH+\SRWKHVLVµ*-()0(4$#6)0%6:%$+!%@+#.6.65#4(.%
764#!$'%²
  ´3DWWHUQVRI$FWLYH6\QWD[LQ/DWH/DWLQ3OHRQDVWLF5HIOH[LYHVµ,Q%O#0$6-#4(.%N#)51#0$#40%_áás% 6HOHFWHG
3DSHUVIURPWKHWK,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ+LVWRULFDO/LQJXLVWLFV0DQFKHVWHU$XJXVW 
HGLWHGE\-&6PLWKDQG'%HQWOH\SS²&XUUHQW,VVXHVLQ/LQJXLVWLF7KHRU\$PVWHU
GDP%HQMDPLQV
 D ´2QWKH5HRUJDQL]DWLRQRI9RLFH'LVWLQFWLRQVDQG*UDPPDWLFDO5HODWLRQVLQ/DWH/DWLQµ,Q%H!%.#)51(%
N($#)(%)6?(!%X1(!0$#6)!0% $FWHVGX;JFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOGHOLQJXLVWLTXHODWLQH3DULV6qYUHV²
DYULO HGLWHGE\&0RXVV\SS²%LEOLRWKqTXHG·pWXGHVFODVVLTXHV3DULV3HHWHUV
 E ´/·H[WHQGHGDFFXVDWLYH%HOHQR]LRQLGLYRFHHUHOD]LRQHJUDPPDWLFDOHQHOODWLQRWDUGRHPHGLHYDOHµ
*H%K#4!-4+!%.#)51#0$#4+!%$-(%()$#46%!%>6"!-)6HGLWHGE\99LSDUHOOLSS²/LQJXLVWLFDHOLQJXDJJL
1DSOHV/LJXRUL
  ´3DVVLYH$X[LOLDULHVLQ/DWH/DWLQµ,QN($#)%!$%.()51!0%-6>()!0g%Q$1"!0%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%6::!-$!0%h%PçG0!:%
O!->()%h%.;644(0#6)%"!%06)%àpE>!())#?!-0(#-!HGLWHGE\6.LVV/0RQGLQDQG*6DOYLSS²
7ELQJHQ1LHPH\HU
  ´7KH5LVHDQG*UDPPDWLFDOL]DWLRQ3DWKVRI/DWLQ:#!-#DQG:(4!-!DV3DVVLYH$X[LOLDULHVµ,Q@(00#?#G(M
$#6)%()"%*'I6.65'g%F6->%()"%F1)4$#6)HGLWHGE\:$EUDKDPDQG//HLVL|SS%²7\SRORJLFDO
6WXGLHVLQ/DQJXDJH$PVWHUGDP%HQMDPLQV
 D ´7KH5LVHDQG'HYHORSPHQWRI$QDO\WLF3HUIHFWVLQ,WDOR5RPDQFHµ,QD-(>>($#4(.%3+()5!%()"%
N#)51#0$#4%*+!6-'g%*+!%K60!)"(.%@(I!-0HGLWHGE\7(\WKyUVVRQSS²/LQJXLVWLFV7RGD\
$PVWHUGDP%HQMDPLQV
 E ´,PSHUVRQDO&RQVWUXFWLRQVDQG$UJXPHQW0DUNLQJLQ/DWLQµ3DSHUSUHVHQWHGDWWKH:RUNVKRSRQ
&DVHDQG$UJXPHQW6WUXFWXUHLQ,QGR(XURSHDQIURPD7\SRORJLFDO3HUVSHFWLYH%HUJHQ$XJXVW
²
  ´$UJXPHQW6WUXFWXUHDQG$OLJQPHQW9DULDWLRQVDQG&KDQJHVLQ/DWH/DWLQµ,Q*+!%K6.!%6:%7!>()$#42%
@-(5>($#42%()"%H#0461-0!%F(4$6-0%#)%$+!%H!?!.6I>!)$%6:%3(0!HGLWHGE\-%DU}GDODODQG6/&KHOOLDKSS
²6WXGLHVLQ/DQJXDJH&RPSDQLRQ6HULHV$PVWHUGDP%HQMDPLQV
  ´,PSHUVRQDO&RQVWUXFWLRQVDQG$FFXVDWLYH6XEMHFWVLQ/DWH/DWLQµ,Q/>I!-06)(.%36)0$-14$#6)0g%<%
3-600M.#)51#0$#4%@!-0I!4$#?!HGLWHGE\$0DOFKXNRYDQG$6LHZLHUVNDSS²6WXGLHVLQ/DQ
JXDJH&RPSDQLRQ6HULHV$PVWHUGDP%HQMDPLQV
&RPULH%HUQDUG
  N()51(5!%\)#?!-0(.0%()"%N#)51#0$#4%*'I6.65'g%7')$(]%()"%A6-I+6.65'QGHGLWLRQ&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI
&KLFDJR3UHVV
  ´$OLJQPHQWRI&DVH0DUNLQJµ,Q*+!%J6-."%<$.(0%6:%N()51(5!%7$-14$1-!02HGLWHGE\0+DVSHOPDWK
0¬6'U\HU'*LODQG%&RPULHSS%²2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<78%A<Kb/BD%,F%3,K8%<KD\A8B*7%<BH%<N/DBA8B*%/B%N<*8%N<*/B% QOO

'L[RQ5REHUW0:
  ´(UJDWLYLW\µN()51(5!²
  *+!%N()51(5!0%6:%<10$-(.#(&DPEULGJH/DQJXDJH6XUYH\V&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
% OPP<% 8-5($#?#$'&DPEULGJH6WXGLHVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
'RQRKXH0DUN
  ´6HPDQWLF$OLJQPHQW6\VWHPV:KDW·V:KDWDQG:KDW·V1RWµ,Q*+!%*'I6.65'%6:%7!>()$#4%<.#5)>!)$2%
HGLWHGE\%0'RQRKXHDQG6:LFKPDQQSS²2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
'RQRKXH0DUNDQG6¡UHQ:LFKPDQQHGLWRUV
  *+!%*'I6.65'%6:%7!>()$#4%<.#5)>!)$2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
(UQRXW$
 ´5HFKHUFKHVVXUO·HPSORLGXSDVVLI/DWLQjO·pSRTXHUpSXEOLFDLQHµAU>6#-!0%"!%.(%764#!$U%"!%.#)51#0M
$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%²
(UQRXW$DQG)UDQoRLV7KRPDV
  7')$(]!%N($#)!QGHGLWLRQ3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
*HUROD%HUHQJDULR
  ´$VSHWWLGHOODVLQWDVVLGHOQRPLQDWLYRHGHOO·DFFXVDWLYRQHO7DUGRODWLQRµ<$$#%"!..;/0$#$1$6%T!)!$6%"#%
74#!)G!2%N!$$!-!%!"%<-$#²
+DUULV$OLFH&
  ´$OLJQPHQW7\SRORJ\DQG'LDFKURQLF&KDQJHµ,QN()51(5!%*'I6.65'%_áàog%7'0$!>($#4%S(.()4!%#)%
N()51(5!HGLWHGE\:3/HKPDQQSS²&XUUHQW,VVXHVLQ/LQJXLVWLF7KHRU\$PVWHUGDP
%HQMDPLQV
+DUULV$OLFH&DQG/\OH&DPSEHOO
% OPPR% O#0$6-#4(.%7')$(]%#)%3-600M.#)51#0$#4%@!-0I!4$#?!&DPEULGJH6WXGLHVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV&DPEULGJH&DP
EULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
+DVSHOPDWK0DUWLQ
  *-()0#$#?#$'%<.$!-)($#6)0%6:%$+!%<)$#4(10($#?!%*'I!L%&RORJQH,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW8QLYHUVL
WlW]X.|OQ
  ´0RUHRQWKH7\SRORJ\RI,QFKRDWLYH&DXVDWLYH9HUE$OWHUQDWLRQVµ,Q3(10($#?!0%()"%*-()0#$#?#$'2%
HGLWHGE\%&RPULHDQG03ROLQVN\SS²6WXGLHVLQ/DQJXDJH&RPSDQLRQ6HULHV$PVWHU
GDP%HQMDPLQV
(J>KKL>62%!HHJ
  7$1"#!0%6)%$+!%N($#)%<4410($#?!%<&06.1$!+HOVLQNL)LQQLVK6RFLHW\RI6FLHQFHVDQG/HWWHUV
+HUPDQ-y]VHI
  ´/DGLVSDULWLRQGHM0HWODPRUSKRORJLHGLDOHFWDOHGXODWLQSDUOpµ%*H%N($#)%?1.5(#-!%q%N($#)%$(-"#:%*%
$FWHVGX,J7FROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOVXUOHODWLQYXOJDLUHHWWDUGLI3pFV²VHSWHPEUH HGLWHG
E\-+HUPDQSS²7ELQJHQ1LHPH\HU
  ´/DGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQWHUULWRULDOHGXODWLQHWODIRUPDWLRQGHVODQJXHVURPDQHVµ,QPç0G!:%O!->()g%
H1%.($#)%(1]%.()51!0%-6>()!0g%Q$1"!0%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%+#0$6-#X1!HGLWHGE\6.LVVSS²7ELQJHQ
1LHPH\HU
  ´/HVDUGRLVHZLVLJRWKLTXHVHWOHSUREOqPHGHODGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQWHUULWRULDOHGXODWLQµ,Q%N($#)%?1.M
5(#-!%q%N($#)%$(-"#:%,9 $FWHVGX,9JFROORTXHLQWHUQDWLRQDOVXUOHODWLQYXOJDLUHHWWDUGLI&DHQ²
VHSWHPEUH HGLWHGE\/&DOOHEDWSS²+LOGHVKHLP2OPV
  ´­SURSRVGXGpEDWVXUOHSOXULHOGHVQRPVLWDOLHQV HWURXPDLQV ­ODUHFKHUFKHG·XQHFRQFOXVLRQµ
*H%/$(.#4(%!$%K6>()#4(g%F!0$04+-#:$%:u-%A(]%@:#0$!-%G1>%|sL%D!&1-0$(5HGLWHGE\*+ROWXV-.UDPHUDQG
:¬6FKZHLFNDUGSS²7ELQJHQ1LHPH\HU%
 oi.uchicago.edu

QO:% A/3O8N<%38BB<A,

  ´/DGLVSDULWLRQGXSDVVLIV\QWKpWLTXHODWLQ1RXYHOHVVDLVXUO·pFULWHWOHSDUOpHQODWLQPpURYLQJLHQµ
(VWXGLRV5RPiQLFRV²
.RQMHW]Q\*
  ´'HLGLRWLVPLVV\QWDFWLFLVLQWLWXOLVODWLQLVXUEDQLVFRQVSLFXLVµ<-4+#?%:u-%N($!#)#04+!%N!]#465-(I+#!%1)"%
D-(>>($#=²
/D)DXFL1XQ]LR
  ´/DFRQWLQXLWjQHOODGLYHUVLWjIRUPDOH$VSHWWLGLPRUIRVLQWDVVLGLDFURQLFDURPDQ]Dµ,Q/))6?(G#6)!%
!%36)0!-?(G#6)!%)!..!%N#)51!% $WWLGHO&RQYHJQRGHOOD6RFLHWj,WDOLDQDGL*ORWWRORJLD0HVVLQD²
QRYHPEUH HGLWHGE\92ULROHVSS²%LEOLRWHFDGHOOD6RFLHWjLWDOLDQDGLJORWWRORJLD
3LVD*LDUGLQL
% OPP<% ,&c!4$0%()"%71&c!4$0%#)%$+!%F6->($#6)%6:%K6>()4!%A6-I+60')$(]%ORRPLQJWRQ,QGLDQD8QLYHUVLW\/LQ
JXLVWLFV&OXE3XEOLFDWLRQV
% OPP@% @!-%1)(%$!6-#(%5-(>>($#4(.!%"!.%>1$(>!)$6%>6-:60#)$($$#46g%H(.%.($#)6%?!-06%#.%-6>()G63URJHWWLOLQJXLVWLFL
3LVD(76
  ´5LIOHWWHQGRVXOPXWDPHQWRPRUIRVLQWDWWLFR1HOODWLQRYHUVRLOURPDQ]Rµ,Q7#)$(00#%0$6-#4(% $WWL
GHO;;;&RQJUHVVRLQWHUQD]LRQDOHGHOOD6RFLHWjGLOLQJXLVWLFDLWDOLDQD3DYLD²VHWWHPEUH 2%
HGLWHGE\3¬5DPDWDQG(5RPDSS²3XEEOLFD]LRQLGHOOD6RFLHWjGLOLQJXLVWLFDLWDOLDQD
5RPH%XO]RQL
  ´4XHOSDVWLFFLDFFLREUXWWRGHOODGHFOLQD]LRQHµT6]%K6>()#4(²
  ´'LQDPLFKHVLVWHPDWLFKH6FRPSDUVDGHOODGHFOLQD]LRQHµ,QA6-:60#)$(00#%.($#)(g%@1)$#%"#%?#0$(HGLWHG
E\1/D)DXFLDQG63LHURQLSS²3URJHWWLOLQJXLVWLFL3LVD(76
/D]]HURQL5
 D ´5XROLWHPDWLFLHJHQHUHJUDPPDWLFDOH8QDVSHWWRGHOODPRUIRVLQWDVVLLQGRHXURSHD"µ<-4+#?#6%D.6$M
$6.65#46%/$(.#()6%²
 E ´,OQRPH*UHFRGHOVRJQRHLOQHXWURLQGRHXURSHRµ<-4+#?#6%D.6$$6.65#46%/$(.#()6²%
/HGJHZD\$GDP
)RUWKFRPLQJ´6\QWDFWLFDQG0RUSKRV\QWDFWLF7\SRORJ\DQG&KDQJHLQ/DWLQDQG5RPDQFHµ,Q*+!%3(>&-#"5!%O#0M
$6-'%6:%$+!%K6>()4!%N()51(5!02%1F>LMJ%ON%7$-14$1-!02HGLWHGE\00DLGHQ-&6PLWKDQG$/HGJH
ZD\SS²&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
/HKPDQQ&KULVWLDQ
  ´/DWLQ&DVH5HODWLRQVLQ7\SRORJLFDO3HUVSHFWLYHµ,Q%7')$(]!%!$%.($#)% $FWHVGX,,qPH&RQJUqVLQWHUQD
WLRQDOGHOLQJXLVWLTXHODWLQH$L[HQ3URYHQFH²PDUV HGLWHGE\&7RXUDWLHUSS²
$L[HQ3URYHQFH8QLYHUVLWpGH3URYHQFH
  ´3UHGLFDWH&ODVVHVDQG3DUWLFLSDWLRQµ,Q7$1"#!0%#)%D!)!-(.%36>I(-($#?!%N#)51#0$#40HGLWHGE\0/HX
PDQQ-%+RIPDQQDQG$6]DQW\USS²&RORJQH$.83
/HXPDQQ0DQX-RKDQ%DSWLVW+RIPDQQDQG$QWRQ6]DQW\U
  N($!#)#04+!%D-(>>($#=9ROXPH0XQLFK%HFN
/|IVWHGW%HQJW
% OP@@% 7$1"#!)%u&!-%"#!%7I-(4+!%"!-%N()56&(-"#04+!)%D!0!$G!g%S!#$-a5!%G1-%:-u+>#$$!.(.$!-.#4+!)%N($#)#$a$L$FWD
8QLYHUVLWDWLV8SVDOLHQVLV6WXGLD/DWLQD8SVDOLHQVLD8SSVDOD$OPTYLVW :LNVHOO
/|IVWHGW(LQDU
% OPOO% @+#.6.65#04+!-%b6>>!)$(-%G1-%@!-!5-#)($#6%<!$+!-#(!g%\)$!-014+1)5!)%G1-%D!04+#4+$!%"!-%.($!#)#04+!)%7I-(M
4+!L8SSVDOD$OPTYLVW :LNVHOO
% OPQQ% 7')$(4$#4(g%7$1"#!)%1)"%S!#$-a5!%G1-%+#0$6-#04+!)%7')$(]%"!0%N($!#)02%1F>LMJ%:N%7')$(=$#04+M0$#.#0$#04+!%
D!0#4+$0I1)=$!%1)"%@-6&.!>!$FWD5HJLDH6RFLHWDWLV+XPDQLRUXP/LWWHUDUXP/XQGHQVLV/XQG
*OHHUXS
  T!->#04+$!%7$1"#!)%G1-%.($!#)#04+!)%7I-(4+=1)"!%1)"%7')$(]/XQG*OHHUXS
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<78%A<Kb/BD%,F%3,K8%<KD\A8B*7%<BH%<N/DBA8B*%/B%N<*8%N<*/B% QOQ

0DOFKXNRY$QGUHM
  ´6SOLW,QWUDQVLWLYHV([SHULHQFHU2EMHFWVDQG¶7UDQVLPSHUVRQDO·&RQVWUXFWLRQV 5H HVWDEOLVKLQJ
WKH&RQQHFWLRQµ,Q*+!%*'I6.65'%6:%7!>()$#4%<.#5)>!)$HGLWHGE\0'RQRKXHDQG6:LFKPDQQSS
²2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
0LWKXQ0DULDQQH
  ´$FWLYH$JHQWLYH&DVH0DUNLQJDQG,WV0RWLYDWLRQVµN()51(5!²
  ´7KH(PHUJHQFHRI$JHQWLYH6\VWHPVLQ&RUH$UJXPHQW0DUNLQJµ,Q*+!%*'I6.65'%6:%7!>()$#4%<.#5)M
>!)$HGLWHGE\0'RQRKXHDQG6:LFKPDQQSS²2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
0LWKXQ0DULDQQHDQG:DOODFH&KDIH
  ´:KDW$UH6$DQG2"µ7$1"#!0%#)%N()51(5!%²
0F>8HJ>>82%58J76
  ´/DFDGXWDGHOODGHVLQHQ]DGLDFFXVDWLYRVLQJRODUHLQODWLQR7UDPRUIRORJLDHRUGLQHGHOOHSDUROHµ
e1("!-)#%"!.%H#I(-$#>!)$6%"#%N#)51#0$#4(%!%N!$$!-($1-!%36>I(-($!%²
0RUDYFVLN(GLWK$
  ´2QWKH'LVWULEXWLRQRI$FWLYHDQG(UJDWLYH3DWWHUQVµN#)51(²
0¡UODQG+HQQLQJ
% OPQ:% H#!%N($!#)#04+!)%,-#&(0#10u&!-0!$G1)5!)L%2VOR%U¡JJHUL
1LFKROV-
 D ´+HDGPDUNLQJDQG'HSHQGHQWPDUNLQJ*UDPPDUµN()51(5!%²%
 E ´2Q)RUPDQG&RQWHQWLQ7\SRORJ\µ,Q%N()51(5!%*'I6.65'%_áàs% 3DSHUVIURPWKH/LQJXLVWLF7\SRORJ\
6\PSRVLXP0RVFRZ²'HFHPEHU HGLWHGE\:3/HKPDQQSS²&XUUHQW,VVXHVLQ
/LQJXLVWLF7KHRU\$PVWHUGDP%HQMDPLQV
  ´6RPH3UHFRQGLWLRQVDQG7\SLFDO7UDLWVRIWKH6WDWLYH੒DFWLYH/DQJXDJH7\SHµ,Q%N()51(5!%*'I6.65'%
_áàog%7'0$!>($#4%S(.()4!%#)%N()51(5!HGLWHGE\:3/HKPDQQSS²&XUUHQW,VVXHVLQ/LQJXLV
WLF7KHRU\$PVWHUGDP%HQMDPLQV
+F7DJ7I2'DJ/XGYLJ
% OP<Q% 7')$(=$#04+!%F6-04+1)5!)%(1:%"!>%D!&#!$!%"!0%7Ia$.($!#)0%1)"%"!0%:-u+!)%A#$$!..($!#)08SSVDOD
/XQGHTYLVW
% OP<<% S!#$-a5!%G1-%0Ia$.($!#)#04+!)%7')$(]8SSVDOD$OPTYLVW :LNVHOO
5J82%0678F
% OPQ:% *+!%N()51(5!%6:%$+!%8#5+$+M4!)$1-'%*!]$0%#)%B6-$+!-)%F-()4!g%<%7$1"'%6:%$+!%,-#5#)(.%H641>!)$0%#)%$+!%36.M
.!4$#6)%6:%*(-"#:%()"%,$+!-%761-4!01HZ<RUN&DUUDQ]D &R
3LHURQL6LOYLD
  ´1RQSURPRWLRQDO2EMHFWVLQ/DWH/DWLQµT!-&1>²
3LQNVWHU+DUP
  ´/DWLQ&DVHVDQG9DOHQF\*UDPPDU6RPH3UREOHPVµ,Q7')$(]!%!$%.($#)% $FWHVGX,,qPH&RQJUqV
LQWHUQDWLRQDOGHOLQJXLVWLTXHODWLQH$L[HQ3URYHQFH²PDUV HGLWHGE\&7RXUDWLHUSS
²$L[HQ3URYHQFH8QLYHUVLWpGH3URYHQFH
5879FH2%[L>J9
% OP?O% N(%.()51!%"!0%#)04-#I$#6)0%.($#)!0%"!%.(%D(1.!L%%UXVVHOV2IILFHGH3XEOLFLWp
3ODQN)UDQV
  ´7KH([WHQGHG$FFXVDWLYH5HVWULFWHG1RPLQDWLYHLQ3HUVSHFWLYHµ,QK!.($#6)(.%*'I6.65'HGLWHGE\
)¬3ODQNSS²%HUOLQ0RXWRQGH*UX\WHU
 oi.uchicago.edu

QO<% A/3O8N<%38BB<A,

  ´(UJDWLYLW\µ,Q7')$(]g%<)%/)$!-)($#6)(.%O()"&66=%6:%36)$!>I6-(-'%K!0!(-4+HGLWHGE\--DFREV$¬YRQ
6WHFKRZDQG:6WHUQHIHOGSS²+DQGEFKHU]XU6SUDFKXQG.RPPXQLNDWLRQVZLVVHQ
VFKDIW%HUOLQ:DOWHUGH*UX\WHU
5RQFRQL$OHVVDQGUR
  /.%T!-&6%N($#)65HYLVHGHGLWLRQ)ORUHQFH/H0RQQLHU
5RYDL)
  ´/·HVWHQVLRQHGHOO·DFFXVDWLYRLQODWLQRWDUGRHPHGLHYDOHµ<-4+#?#6%D.6$$6.65#46%/$(.#()6%²
 D ´0DQLIHVWD]LRQLGLVXEVLVWHPLWLSRORJLFLDWWLYLLQODWLQRµ<-4+#?#6%D.6$$6.65#46%/$(.#()6²
 E ,OODWLQRQRQFODVVLFR&RGLILFKHDWWLYHHQHXWULGHEROL3K'GLVVHUWDWLRQ8QLYHUVLW\RI3LVD
  7UDWWL$WWLYLLQ/DWLQR,O&DVRGHO*HQHUHL%3K'GLVVHUWDWLRQ8QLYHUVLW\RI3LVD
6FK¡VOHU/HQH
  ´)URP/DWLQWR0RGHUQ)UHQFK$FWXDOL]DWLRQDQG0DUNHGQHVVµ,Q<4$1(.#G($#6)g%N#)51#0$#4%3+()5!%#)%
@-65-!00HGLWHGE\+$QGHUVHQSS²&XUUHQW,VVXHVLQ/LQJXLVWLF7KHRU\$PVWHUGDP
%HQMDPLQV
6RUQLFROD5RVDQQD
  ´5LIOHVVLRQLVXOORVWXGLRGHOFDPELDPHQWRPRUIRVLQWDWWLFRGDOODSURVSHWWLYDGLXQURPDQLVWD6LQ
FURQLDHGLDFURQLDULYLVLWDWHµK!?1!%"!%N#)51#0$#X1!%K6>()!%²
6YHQQXQJ-RVHI*$
% OPQR% \)$!-014+1)5!)%G1%@(..("#10%1)"%G1-%.($!#)#04+!)%F(4+M%1)"%T6.=00I-(4+!L%8SSVDOD$OPTYLVW :LNVHOO
9llQlQHQ9HLNNR
  Q$1"!%01-%.!%*!]$!%!$%.(%N()51!%"!0%*(&.!$$!0%<.&!-$#)#L%+HOVLQNL6XRPDODLQHQ7LHGHDNDWHPLD
 % /)$-6"14$#6)%(1%.($#)%?1.5(#-!1HZHGLWLRQZLWKDQWKRORJ\DQGFRPPHQWDU\%LEOLRWKqTXHIUDQoDLVHHW
URPDQH6HULHV$0DQXHOVHWpWXGHVOLQJXLVWLTXHV3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
9LHOOLDUG-HDQQH
% OP:@% N!%N($#)%"!0%"#I.x>!0%-6'(1]%!$%4+(-$!0%I-#?U!0%"!%.;UI6X1!%AU-6?#)5#!))!3DULV&KDPSLRQ
9LQFHQW1LJHO
  ´7KH(PHUJHQFHRIWKH'6\VWHPLQ5RPDQFHµ,Q@(-(>!$!-0%6:%A6-I+60')$(4$#4%3+()5!HGLWHGE\
$¬YDQ.HPHQDGHDQG19LQFHQWSS²&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
  ´7UDJUDPPDWLFDHJUDPPDWLFDOL]]D]LRQH$UWLFROLHFOLWLFLQHOOHOLQJXH LWDOR URPDQ]Hµ,Q7#)$(00#%
0$6-#4(% $WWLGHO;;;&RQJUHVVRLQWHUQD]LRQDOHGHOOD6RFLHWjGLOLQJXLVWLFDLWDOLDQD3DYLD²VHW
WHPEUH HGLWHGE\35DPDWDQG(5RPDSS²3XEEOLFD]LRQLGHOOD6RFLHWjGLOLQJXLVWLFD
LWDOLDQD5RPH%XO]RQL
C6MDFH82%!>DJ7KF
  ´'DOODWLQRWDUGRDOURPDQ]RDUFDLFRDVSHWWLGLDFURQLFRWLSRORJLFLGHOODIOHVVLRQHQRPLQDOHµ,Q%7#)M
$(00#%0$6-#4(% $WWLGHO;;;&RQJUHVVRLQWHUQD]LRQDOHGHOOD6RFLHWjGLOLQJXLVWLFDLWDOLDQD3DYLD²
VHWWHPEUH 2HGLWHGE\35DPDWDQG(5RPDSS²3XEEOLFD]LRQLGHOOD6RFLHWjGLOLQJXL
VWLFDLWDOLDQD5RPH%XO]RQL
% :???% <..!%6-#5#)#%"!..;/$(.#()6g%H#)(>#4+!%!%$#I6.65#!%"!..(%$-()0#G#6)!%"(.%N($#)65RPH&DURFFL
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%DK<AA<*/3<\i%8*%3<7%N,3<\i%8B%D,*/e\8g%N87%A,HZN87%3<7\8N7%8B%D,*/e\8% QOR

!!
"#$%&'#((#)*"#+,%-)%"#$%./"#+,%-0%&/)*1+-2%
.-$%(/34.-$%"#$+-.$%-0%&/)*1+-

<)"-U%K6100!(12%\AK%o_ào%N(&6-($6#-!%NLHL/L2%\)#?!-0#$U%"!%@(-#0%_r

*56789:;6<85
=>?/HJRWLTXHHVWFHWWHPHUYHLOOHXVHODQJXHJHUPDQLTXHDQFLHQQHWUqVVRXYHQWDUFKDwTXHDWWHVWpHVHORQOHV
GDWDWLRQVOHVSOXVUpFHQWHVGHSXLVOH,,,qPHVLqFOHDYDQW-&SDUO·LQVFULSWLRQILJXUDQWVXUOHFDVTXH%GH1HJDX
KDULJDVWLWHLZD!´DXGLHX+DULJDVWµ0DLVOHJRWLTXHHVWUHSUpVHQWpSULQFLSDOHPHQWSDUXQHWUDGXFWLRQGHOHS#&.!%
UpDOLVpHDXPLOLHXGXqPHVLqFOHSDU:XOILODHWFHUWDLQHPHQWXQJURXSHGHWUDGXFWHXUV,OSUpVHQWHXQHVLWXDWLRQ
SDUWLFXOLqUH¬HQWDQWTXHODQJXHFKDUQLqUHTXLRIIUHXQGRXEOHYLVDJHHWTXLGHFHIDLWDSSRUWHLQFRQWHVWDEOHPHQW
XQGRXEOHWpPRLJQDJHWRXMRXUVWUqVSUpFLHX[

 ‡ F·HVWXQ´FKDQWLHUHQUXLQHVµFRQVHUYDQWGHVVXUYLYDQFHVQRPEUHXVHVHWWRXMRXUVYLYDQWHVGHO·pWDW
LQGRHXURSpHQDQFLHQ

 ‡ F·HVWDXVVLXQ´FKDQWLHUHQFRQVWUXFWLRQµRFRPPHQFHQWjV·pGLILHUXQHQRXYHOOHRUJDQLVDWLRQGH
ODODQJXHjDSSDUDvWUHOHVSUpPLVVHVG·XQQRXYHOpWDWGHODQJXHHWjVHPHWWUHHQSODFHGHQRXYHOOHV
ORLVGHSRVLWLRQFRQFHUQDQWQRWDPPHQWOHVSDUWLFXOHV

% =!? /DV\QWD[HGXJRWLTXH
8QSULQFLSHpWDEOLSDU(%HQYHQLVWHOQRXVVHPEOHIRQGDPHQWDOHWOHUHVSHFWHUHVWFHUWDLQHPHQWODSUHPLqUH
XUJHQFHSRXUO·pWXGHGXJRWLTXHLOIDXWDGPHWWUH´FHSULQFLSHTXHOHJRWLTXHGRLWrWUHpWXGLpHWDQDO\VpSRXUOXL
PrPH«>DORUVVHXOHPHQW@ODFRQGLWLRQSUHPLqUHVHUDDFTXLVHG·XQHGHVFULSWLRQTXLDWWHLQGUD.(%0')$(]!%56$#X1!2%
)6)%.!%-!?z$!>!)$%56$#X1!%";1)!%0')$(]!%5-!4X1!µ  
'DQVQRWUHHVSULWODFRPSDUDLVRQDYHFOHJUHFQHSRXUUDVHUYLUDXPLHX[TXHGHFRQILUPDWLRQRXGHSUHXYH
VXSSOpPHQWDLUHV·LOHQHVWEHVRLQ

% =@?% 'HX[W\SHVGHFDVHQJRWLTXH
/HJHUPDQLTXHDQFLHQSRVVqGHGHX[W\SHVGHFDVGHVFDVV\QWD[LTXHV LO\HQDTXDWUHDXSODQPRUSKRORJLTXH
1RPLQDWLI$FFXVDWLI'DWLI*pQLWLIPDLVGDYDQWDJHDXSODQGHVIRQFWLRQVVpPDQWLTXHV GHVWLQpVjPDUTXHUGHV
IRQFWLRQVV\QWD[LTXHVHWGHVFDVORFDX[DUFKDwTXHV /RFDWLI$OODWLI,OODWLI$EODWLI(ODWLI3HUODWLI DSWHVjLQGLTXHU
GHVUHODWLRQVVSDWLDOHVHWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWELHQDWWHVWpVVXUOHVGpLFWLTXHVHWOHVpOpPHQWVSURFKHV

% =A? /DPpWKRGRORJLHXWLOLVpHSRXUO·pWXGHGHVFDVJUDPPDWLFDX[
/HSRLQWGHGpSDUWPpWKRGRORJLTXHVHWURXYHGDQVQRWUHDUWLFOHSXEOLpHQVXUN!0%>6"E.!0%4(01!.0%!$%I-UM
I60#$#6))!.0%"()0%.(%0')$(]!%"!%.;(..!>()"%>6"!-)!GRQWOHIRQGHPHQWHVWGRXEOHjVDYRLUOHV7($G&(1I.a)!%SUpVHQWV
GDQVGLYHUVHVJUDPPDLUHVGHO·DOOHPDQGHWODWKpRULHGHVGHX[PRGqOHVWHOOHTX·HOOHILJXUHGDQVODWKqVHGH-HDQ
+DXGU\  VXUOHVFDVGXYpGLTXH

O
4XLDSUqVOHGpFqVGH)HUQDQG0RVVpHQDGRQQpSHQGDQW
WURLVDQVGHVVpPLQDLUHVVXUOHJRWLTXHjO·(FROH3UDWLTXHGHV+DXWHV
eWXGHV (3+( 

QOR
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <BHKQ%K,\778<\

>B%$C56DEF%9F%GHI585;I%F5%<598JF:78KIF5
3RXUWUDLWHUGHO·RUJDQLVDWLRQHWGXIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHVFDVGDQVXQHODQJXHLQGRHXURSpHQQHDQFLHQQHLOHVW
DEVROXPHQWQpFHVVDLUHGHVHIRQGHUVXUXQHFRQFHSWLRQGHO·pQRQFpLQGRHXURSpHQVLQRQRQSDUOH¶GDQVOHYLGH·
/DPpWKRGRORJLHHVWDEVROXPHQWLQFRQWRXUQDEOH7RXWVHSDVVHFRPPHVLO·pQRQFpLQGRHXURSpHQpWDLWFRPSRVp
GHGHX[SDUWLHVO·XQHFRQFHUQDQWOHV¶pOpPHQWVOpJHUV·RX´FKDvQHGHVSDUWLFXOHVµO·DXWUHUHJURXSDQWOHV¶pOpPHQWV
ORXUGV·HQ´PRGqOHVFDVXHOVµ

>B>B%.D%L;MDN5F%9FO%KD76<;:GFOP
,OHVWDEVROXPHQWQpFHVVDLUHGHUDSSHOHULFLOHVJUDQGHVOLJQHVGHODVWUXFWXUHGHO·pQRQFpHQLQGRHXURSpHQ
WHOOHVTXHOHVDPDJLVWUDOHPHQWUHFRQVWLWXpHV(/DURFKH  jSDUWLUGHODFRPSDUDLVRQGHVODQJXHVDQDWR
OLHQQHVUpVXOWDWVFRQILUPpVSDUOHVUHFKHUFKHVXOWpULHXUHVGH&:DWNLQV  
6·DSSX\DQWVXUOD´ORLGH:DFNHUQDJHOµ  (/DURFKHDUHFRQVWUXLWOHSRVLWLRQQHPHQWHWLGHQWLILpOHV
IRQFWLRQVVpPDQWLTXHVGHVGLIIpUHQWVW\SHVGHSDUWLFXOHVjSDUWLUGHGHX[ODQJXHVDQDWROLHQQHVOHORXYLWHHWOH
O\FLHQFHTX·LOUHSRUWHVXUOHKLWWLWHSURSRVDQWODGHVFULSWLRQVXLYDQWH
´/DSKUDVHKLWWLWHHVWFRPPDQGpHSDUXQSUHPLHUPRWWRQLTXHDXTXHOV·DWWDFKHXQQRPEUHSOXVRXPRLQV
JUDQGG·HQFOLWLTXHV«/·RUGUHGDQVOHTXHOOHVHQFOLWLTXHVKLWWLWHVV·DWWDFKHQWj)1HVWFRQVWDQWHWULJRXUHX[µ
 &HWWHJUDQGHVWDELOLWpGHFHTX·RQDSSHOOHOD´FKDvQHGHVSDUWLFXOHVµDXWRULVH/DURFKHjSRVHU
O·H[LVWHQFHGHFLQTFODVVHVIRQFWLRQQHOOHVHWVpPDQWLTXHVGHSDUWLFXOHV

>D@ * ** *** *Q Q
)1 M9( - M M(kMk#M% MG(M M=()
Mk()

´HWµ PDUTXHGH =7FHFM9% UpϰH[LI SDUWLFXOHV

GLVFRXUV 6H6=KRULTXHV DVSHFWXHOOHV
LQGLUHFW FXORFDOHV

(QQHUHWHQDQWTXHOHVJUDQGHVIRQFWLRQVH[HUFpHVLOQRXVHVWSRVVLEOH³pYLGHPPHQWVRXVQRWUHVHXOHUHVSRQVD
ELOLWp³GHUpGXLUHOHQRPEUHGHFODVVHVGLVWLQFWHVjTXDWUHVHXOHPHQW

>E@ * ** *** *Q
-8I6KJL7 )RQFWHXUGH 57FHFM9 0RGDOLWpVGX
SKUDVH SURFqV

&HVFKpPDTXLRXYUHO·pQRQFpLQGRHXURSpHQHVWUHSULVTXHOTXHVDQQpHVSOXVWDUGGDQVOHVUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVV\Q
WD[LTXHVSURSRVpHVSDU&:DWNLQV  TXLXWLOLVHOHVV\PEROHVVXLYDQWV

>F@ " - R7 R Q

"FHHHFWHXU )QFOLWLTXH 57FHFM9% 3UpYHUEH 1J7DJ

KFH8TXH 6KFHJ

&HVVFKpPDVVRQWH[WUrPHPHQWILDEOHVGDQVODSUpFLVLRQREWHQXHSDUODFRPSDUDLVRQHWFRQILUPpHVSDUOD
WRWDOLWpGHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVDQFLHQQHV

>D@ " ) 57 5 1

MD ED 8 JD ODXEMDP ,7KHVVDORQLFLHQV

 ´VLQRXVFUR\RQVµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%DK<AA<*/3<\i%8*%3<7%N,3<\i%8B%D,*/e\8g%N87%A,HZN87%3<7\8N7%8B%D,*/e\8% QO@

,OIDXWELHQVpSDUHUGHX[SKpQRPqQHVG·RULJLQHLQGRHXURSpHQQHGLVWLQFWVHQJRWLTXHGLVWLQFWLRQTXLQ·D
MDPDLVpWpIDLWH

 ‡ ODYpULWDEOHWPqVHFRPPHGDQVOHPDJQLILTXHH[HPSOHGRQQpSDU0FTXLIDLWGH5(M%LHJ%
SDUWLFXOHGHSKUDVHSRUWDQWOHWRQHWFRPPDQGDQWO·HQVHPEOHGHO·pQRQFp

/HJRWLTXHHQRϸUHHQHϸHWTXHOTXHVH[HPSOHV

>E@ 5 ) 57 1
IUDKLQD JD X KZD VHKZL 0DUF
´ LOOXLGHPDQGD V·LOYR\DLWTXHOTXHFKRVH"µ

>F@ VDHLJDODXEHL‫ݫ‬GXPLV ‫ݫ‬DXK JD ED GDX‫ݫ‬QL‫ݫ‬OLEDLG -HDQ

´ FHOXLTXLFURLWHQPRL PrPHV·LOHVWPRUWLOYLWµ

 ‡ O·LQVHUWLRQG·XQHSDUWLFXOHDWRQHHQVHFRQGHSRVLWLRQSURYRTXDQWODVpSDUDWLRQGXSUpYHUEHGX
YHUEHFRPPHGDQVOHVH[HPSOHVVXLYDQWV
 >D@ LQXKVDQGLGHGXQ -HDQ
 >E@ X]XKKRI -HDQ
 >F@ X]XKLGGMD -HDQ
 >G@ DQXKNXPEHL /XF
 >H@ XEXKZRSLGD /XF
 >I@ DWXKJDI (SKpVLHQV 
 >J@ JDKPHOLGD /XF :

'HPDQLqUHH[DFWHPHQWSDUDOOqOHM1+V·LQWHUFDOHHQWUHSUpSRVLWLRQHWJURXSHQRPLQDO
 >D@ DQGXK‫ݫ‬DQDODLVW 6NHLUHLQV 
 >E@ IUDPXK‫ݫ‬DPPD -HDQ
 >F@ LQXKMDLQDPPDPHOD -HDQ HWF FI*(%†

/·pYROXWLRQTXLYDVHWUDGXLUHSDUO·pFODWHPHQWGHOD´FKDvQHGHVSDUWLFXOHVµVHPEOHrWUHFRQGLWLRQQpHSDUGHX[
IDFWHXUVHVVHQWLHOVO·XQSDUWLFXOLHUO·DXWUHG·RUGUHEHDXFRXSSOXVJpQpUDO

 ‡ ODGLVSDULWLRQFRPSOqWHGHVHQFOLWLTXHVHVWGXHjFHOOHGXWRQLHUHPSODFpSDUO·DFFHQWLQLWLDO
G·LQWHQVLWpHQJHUPDQLTXH

 ‡ OHUHQRXYHOOHPHQWWRWDOGHVVLJQLILDQWVDIIHFWHHQSUHPLHUOHVSDUWLFXOHVFRPPHO·DSUpFLVp$0HLOOHW
² 

  ´VLµHVWUHQGXHQJRWLTXHSDUc(&(#%JK%M1+fPDLVHQDOOHPDQGSDU9!))%JK%6&f%

  ´HWµHVWUHQGXHQJRWLTXHSDUc(+%JK%M1+fPDLVHQDOOHPDQGSDU1)"

>B!B%.D%O67:;6:7F%9FO%IGISF56O%LG8:79OP
/HWpPRLJQDJHGHOD´ϮJXUHpW\PRORJLTXHµVXUYLYDQFHFDUDFWpULVWLTXHGHODSRpVLHLQGRHXURSpHQQHHVW
DEVROXPHQWFDSLWDOFDULOSHUPHWGHFRPSUHQGUHFRPPHQWV·RUJDQLVHQWOHVPRGqOHVHWVHϮ[HOHVHQVGHVPRWV
/HVH[HPSOHVGH´ϮJXUHpW\PRORJLTXHµQHVRQWSDVDEVHQWVGHOD%LEOHJRWLTXH

:
&I-RQHVVV6FKHUHU
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <BHKQ%K,\778<\

 >@ ZXOIRVZLOZDQGDQV 0DWWKLHX ´GHVORXSVSUpGDWHXUVGpYRUDQWVµ

2UV·LOHVWXQHUDFLQHSRUWHXVHF·HVWELHQODUDFLQHj&+!-M´SRUWHUµTXLHVWjO·RULJLQHG·XQHIDPLOOHGHPRWV
WUqVULFKHHQJHUPDQLTXH
JRW&(#-()´SRUWHUµ&(-)´HQIDQWµ&(->0´YHQWUHµE̒UXVMRV´SDUHQWVµ&(1-´QRXYHDXQpµ5(&(1-å0´QDLVVDQFHµ
5(&(1-´FROOHFWHLPS{WµHWFL
&RPPHQWV·H[SOLTXHQWGHVVLJQLILpVDXVVLGLIIpUHQWV"/D´ILJXUHpW\PRORJLTXHµRUJDQLVpHHQ´PRGqOHVFDVXHOVµ
HVWVHXOHFDSDEOHGHUpSRQGUHjFHWWHTXHVWLRQGHODIDEULFDWLRQGXVHQVVLQRXVSDUWRQVGH

>D@ D67H D67M9 D6876H

´HQIDQWµ ´YHQWUHµ ´SRUWHUµ

RQUHPDUTXHTXHOHVVLJQLILpVUHVSHFWLIVQHSHXYHQWFRUUHVSRQGUHTX·DX´PRGqOHFDVXHOµ

>E@ #;;:OD6<T *5O67:SF56DG R7I9<;D6

(QG·DXWUHVWHUPHVF·HVWOH´PRGqOHFDVXHOµTXLDIL[pOHVHQVGHVpOpPHQWVLVVXVGHODUDFLQHj&+!-&(-)DUHoXOH
VHQVG·´HQIDQWµSDUFHTX·LOIRQFWLRQQHFRPPHXQREMHWjO·DFFXVDWLI&(->0DDFTXLVOHVHQVGH´YHQWUHVHLQµSDUFH
TX·LOH[HUFHODIRQFWLRQG·REMHWLQVWUXPHQWDO(WO·RQSRXUUDLWFRQWLQXHUVLOHVHQVGH´SDUHQWVµDpWpDWWULEXpj
E̒UXVMRVF·HVW%SDUFHTXHLODpWpFRQoXFRPPHXQDXWKHQWLTXHDJHQWG·ROHVXIIL[HMc( M‫گ‬VDXSOXULHO 

!B%.H87UD5<OD6<85%9FO%;DO%U7DSSD6<;D:E
&RPPHQRXVO·DYRQVUDSSHOpSUpFpGHPPHQWFHVFDVVRQWOHVPDUTXHVGHUHODWLRQVV\QWD[LTXHVHQWUHOHV
JURXSHVjIRQFWLRQG·REMHWHWOHSUpGLFDW1RXVRSpUHURQVVXUGHVPRGqOHVjGRXEOHREMHWjSDUWLUGXSUpGLFDW

!B>B%.F%OCO6VSF%9F%WDOF
&HV\VWqPHHVWFRQVWLWXpGHTXDWUH´PRGqOHVFDVXHOVµRUJDQLVpVGHODPDQLqUHVXLYDQWH

 ‡ GHX[PRGqOHVIRQGDPHQWDX[TXLIRXUQLVVHQWGHX[YLVLRQVGX´PrPHµSURFqVjSDUWLUGHVPrPHV
pOpPHQWVFRQVWLWXWLIV
 ‡ GHX[DXWUHVPRGqOHVREWHQXVSDUFURLVHPHQWGHVGHX[SUHPLHUV

!"#$%"&'$()%*+"#$,)-%.("-/.&'$"/$+"&0#$1.02.-/"#
&HVPRGqOHVVRQWVXVFHSWLEOHVGHFRQYHUWLELOLWpUpFLSURTXHHQWUHHX[FRPPHQRXVOHGpPRQWUHURQV
/HPRGqOHOHSOXVDQFLHQTXHQRXVEDSWLVHURQVPRGqOH$HVWFHUWDLQHPHQWFHOXLTXLFRUUHVSRQGjODJpQpUD
WLRQGXVHQVGHVpOpPHQWVFRQVWLWXWLIVF·HVWjGLUH
 >D@ #;;:OD6<T% *5O67:SF56DG%=9D6<T?% R7I9<;D6
DWWHVWpSDU

 >E@ JDZDVLGHGXQLQDSDXUSXUDL 0DUF 

 ´LOVO·KDELOOqUHQWDYHFGHODSRXUSUHµ

&HPRGqOHSUpVHQWHXQHYDULDQWHLQWpUHVVDQWHPRGqOH$:2%9FL9%>6%GF7MJN

 >D@ #;;:OD6<T% #WGD6<T%=9D6<T?% R7I9<;D6

ELHQDWWHVWpSDU

 >E@ DQGZDVLGHGXQLQDSDXUSXUDL 0DUF

  OLWW´LOVOHGpVKDELOOqUHQWjSDUWLUGHODSRXUSUHµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%DK<AA<*/3<\i%8*%3<7%N,3<\i%8B%D,*/e\8g%N87%A,HZN87%3<7\8N7%8B%D,*/e\8% QOP

/HVHFRQGPRGqOHEDSWLVpPRGqOH%SHXWrWUHFRQVLGpUpFRPPHLVVXGHVPRGqOHV$O% FL% !:% SDUXQHUHODWLRQGH

FRQYHUVLRQFRPPHOHSURXYHFHFRXSOHG·H[HPSOHV¬EkWLVXU9(#-I()´MHWHUODQFHUµ

 >D@ ‫ݫ‬DQDVWDLQDPZDLUSDQGDQV 0DUF

  ´OHMHWDQWDYHFGHVSLHUUHVµ ´OHODSLGDQWµ

 >E@ KODLEEDUQH«KXQGDPZDLUSDQ 0DUF

  ´MHWHUOHSDLQGHVHQIDQWVDX[FKLHQVµ

/HPRGqOH%HVWUHSUpVHQWpSDUODFRQILJXUDWLRQFDVXHOOHVXLYDQWH

 >D@ 3D6<T% #;;:OD6<T!% R7I9<;D6

 >E@ PDWJLILPPD 5RPDLQV

 ´GRQQHOXLGHODQRXUULWXUHµ

,O\DGRQFGHX[DFFXVDWLIVELHQGLVWLQFWVXQDFFXVDWLIOILJXUDQWGDQVOHVPRGqOHV$O% FL% !:XQDFFXVDWLI:% SUpVHQW

GDQVOHPRGqOH%/HGHVFULSWHXUQ·DSDVOHGURLWGHOHVFRQIRQGUHFDULO\DXQHFRQVWDQWHOHSUHPLHUUHSUpVHQWH
WRXMRXUVXQDQLPpHWOHVHFRQGUpJXOLqUHPHQWXQQRQDQLPpTXLVRQWHQRXWUHVXVFHSWLEOHVGHV·DVVRFLHU³FRPPH
OHVQRXYHDX[PRGqOHVYRQWOHGpPRQWUHU

3)&1".&'$()%*+"#$)4/"-&#$5.0$60)2#"("-/
/HFURLVHPHQWGHVGHX[SUHPLHUVPRGqOHV$HW%GRQQHQDLVVDQFHjGHX[DXWUHVPRGqOHVTXHQRXVEDSWLVRQV
"%JK%3N

 ‡ OHPRGqOHjGRXEOHDFFXVDWLIDWWHVWpGDQVGLYHUVHVODQJXHV ODWLQSRORQDLV 

 >D@ #;;:OD6<T>% #;;:OD6<T!% R7I9<;D6

 >E@ ODLVLGDLQVLQJDMXNRPPDQDJ 0DUF

  ´LOOHXUHQVHLJQDEHDXFRXSHQSDUDEROHVµ

 >F@ ‫ݫ‬LVKZDK‫ݫ‬HLELGMDLVPLN 0DUF

  ´WRXWFHTXHWXSHX[PHGHPDQGHUµ

 >G@ JLEDQVDLZDODVHLQDIDXUPDQDJDQVOXQ 0DUF

  ´GRQQHUVDYLHHQUDQoRQSRXUSOXVLHXUVµ

 ‡ OH PRGqOH ¶'DWLI *pQLWLI  $EODWLI  3UpGLFDW· GDQV OHTXHO OH *pQLWLI D OD YDOHXU G·XQ $EODWLI HW
O·$FFXVDWLIVHWURXYHWRXWVLPSOHPHQWH[FOXGHODPDUTXHG·REMHW

 >D@ 3D6<T% &I5<6<T% R7I9<;D6

 >E@ QLZDVLPEDUQH /XF 

  ´LOVQ·DYDLHQWSDVG·HQIDQWVµ

RXVLO·RQSHQVHTXHGDQV E OHJpQLWLIHVWGpSHQGDQWGHODQpJDWLRQLO\DHQFRUH

 >F@ MDEDLJLEDLGDXNXQMD‫ݫ‬DPPDWDLNQH /XF

 ´V·LOpWDLWGRQQpGHVVLJQHVjFHWWHJpQpUDWLRQµ Q

Q
&IpJDOHPHQW/XF/XF0DUFHWF
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q:?% <BHKQ%K,\778<\

/DPpWKRGHGXFURLVHPHQWGHVGHX[PRGqOHVUHFRQQXVDXGpSDUWSRXUREWHQLUGHX[PRGqOHVQRXYHDX[LVVXVGHV
GHX[SUHPLHUVGpPRQWUH

   O·DQFUDJHSURIRQGGHVFDVGDQVODV\QWD[HGHODODQJXHFRQVLGpUpH

   ODVROLGLWpGHODPpWKRGRORJLHXWLOLVpHSRXUFHWWHSUpVHQWDWLRQ

'·DXWUHSDUWFHVW\SHVGH´PRGqOHVFDVXHOVµVRQWSUpVHQWVMXVTX·HQDOOHPDQGPRGHUQHFRPPHMHO·DLPRQWUp
GDQVPRQDUWLFOHGH

!B!B%$85%IX8G:6<85%XF7O%:5%S89VGF%K7IK8O<6<855FG
/HVFDVH[HUoDQWSOXVLHXUVIRQFWLRQVYRQWrWUHGLVFULPLQpVSDUGHVSUpSRVLWLRQV$LQVLOHGDWLIJHUPDQLTXH
VXUFKDUJpGHIRQFWLRQVFDULOHVWHQJDJpDXWRWDOGDQVWURLVPRGqOHVFDVXHOVDYHFGHVYDOHXUVGLIIpUHQWHV

 ‡ LOLQGLTXHO·RULJLQHGDQVOHPRGqOH¶DFFGDW DEO SUpGLFDW·

 >D@ DQGZDVLGHGXQLQDSDXUSXUDL 0DUF 

  ´LOVOHGpVKDELOOqUHQWjSDUWLUGHODSRXUSUHµ

 ‡ LOPDUTXHO·LQVWUXPHQWRXOHPR\HQGDQVOHPRGqOH¶DFFGDW LQVWUXPHQWDO SUpGLFDW·

 >E@ JDZDVLGHGXQLQDSDXUSXUDL 0DUF 

  ´LOVO·KDELOOqUHQWDYHFGHODSRXUSUHµ

 ‡ LOH[SULPHODGHVWLQDWLRQGDQVOHPRGqOH¶DFFGDWSUpGLFDW·

 >F@ ‫ݫ‬DQHLLNLQVDQGMDL]ZLVIUDPDWWLQ
  ´FHOXLTXHMHYRXVHQYRLHGHODSDUWGX3qUHµ -HDQ

2UOHJRWLTXHQRXVPRQWUHODGLVFULPLQDWLRQGHVFDVSDUGHVSUpSRVLWLRQVDLQVLXQGDWLIjYDOHXUG·LQVWUXPHQWDO
HVWGLVFULPLQpSDU>#åg

 >@ VWLEQDLPLNLODL 0DWWKLHX  S<Y%VWLEQDLPLNLODL /XF

  ´G·XQHYRL[IRUWHµ

GHPrPHXQGDWLIjYDOHXUG·DEODWLIVHUDGLVFULPLQpSDUOHVSUpSRVLWLRQV(:2%:-(>2%10g

 >D@ DIZDQGLGHGXQVLNDTPLV ,,7LPRWKpH 

  ´LOVVHGpWRXUQqUHQWGHPRLµ

 >E@ ‫ݫ‬DWHLJDUDKQLGHGXQT7DSVXQXP,VUDHOLV 0DWWKLHX

  ´TX·LOVDFKHWqUHQWGHVHQIDQWVG·,VUDsOµ

 >F@ XUUDLV:OGDX‫ݫ‬DLP 0DWWKLHX

  ´LOHVWUHVVXVFLWpGHVPRUWVµ

GDQVOHVPrPHVFRQGLWLRQVXQGDWLIjYDOHXUGHGLUHFWLIHVWGLVFULPLQpSDUODSUpSRVLWLRQ"1g

   TD‫ݫ‬LPPD 0DWWKLHX  TD‫ݫ‬9:%LPPD 0DWWKLHX 

  ´LOOXLGLWµ

/·HVVHQWLHOHVWGHELHQFRPSUHQGUHTXHODSUpSRVLWLRQTXHOOHTX·HOOHVRLWHVWDVVRFLpHjXQ*URXSH1RPLQDODX
GDWLIGRQWHOOHpSRXVHREOLJDWRLUHPHQWOHFDV,FLFHQ·HVWSDVODSUpSRVLWLRQTXLJRXYHUQHOHFDVHOOHGLVFULPLQH
ODYDOHXUGXGDWLIXQLTXHPHQWSDUVRQVLJQLILpOH[LFDO
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%DK<AA<*/3<\i%8*%3<7%N,3<\i%8B%D,*/e\8g%N87%A,HZN87%3<7\8N7%8B%D,*/e\8% Q:O

!B@B%+5%S89VGF%Z%98:WGF%9D6<T A
,OH[LVWHDXVVLODWUDFHG·XQHFRQVWUXFWLRQDQFLHQQHDXGRXEOHGDWLIPrPHVLODPDUTXHGHFDVQ·DSSDUDvWSOXV
VXUO·LQILQLWLIJHUPDQLTXHGHYHQXLQYDULDEOHFDUODILQDOHHQM()%UHSUpVHQWHXQHDQFLHQQHPDUTXHGHGDWLI

 >D@ ZDU‫ݫݫ‬DQJDVZLOWDQ‫ݫ‬DPPDXQOHGLQ /XF

  ´LODUULYDDXSDXYUHGHPRXULUµ

 >E@ MDKZDU‫ݫ‬LQVDEEDWRDQ‫ݫ‬DUDPPDIUXPLQJDJJDQLPPD‫ݫ‬DLUKDWLVN /XF

  ´HWXQMRXUGHVDEEDWO·DXWUHSUHPLHULOOXLDUULYDGHWUDYHUVHUXQFKDPSGHEOpµ R

,OHVWWULVWHPDLVSDVWRXWjIDLWVXUSUHQDQWGHFRQVWDWHUTXHOjHQFRUH6WUHLWEHUJQHFKHUFKHSDVj\YRLUXQ
DUFKDwVPHGXJRWLTXHPDLVWHQWHGHV·HQGpEDUUDVVHUFRPPHSUHXYHVXSSOpPHQWDLUHGHODVHUYLOLWpGHODWUDGXF
WLRQYLVjYLVGXSUpWHQGXRULJLQDOJUHF
(QIDLWQRXVUHQFRQWURQVHQJRWLTXHOHVGHX[W\SHVGHFRQVWUXFWLRQjGRXEOHGDWLITXH-+DXGU\DGLVWLQJXpV
HQYpGLTXHFHOXLFRQFHUQDQWO·DJHQW tQGUč\DSčWDYH´SRXUTX·,QGUDERLYHµ HWFHOXLFRQFHUQDQWO·REMHWRXOHSDWLHQW
Y‫ޠ‬WUč\DKiQWDYH´SRXUWXHU9‫ޠ‬WUDµ 

 >D@ ZDU‫ݫݫ‬DQJDVZLOWDQ‫ݫ‬DPPDXQOHGLQ /XF

  ´LODUULYDDXSDXYUHGHPRXULUµ

 >F@ VXQXVPDQVQLTDPVDLZDORPTLVWMDQDNQDVMDQ /XF

  ´OH)LOVGHO·KRPPHQ·HVWSDVYHQXSRXUSHUGUHOHVkPHVPDLVSRXU OHV VDXYHUµ

&HWWHFRQVWUXFWLRQH[LVWHPrPHVXUOHQRPYHUEDOGRQWODPDUTXHGHGDWLIHVWGLVFULPLQpHSDU"1 N

 >@ ZDXUGDPZHLKDQGXQLZDLKWDLGDXJQLEDXVZDOWHLQDL‫ݫ‬DLPKDXVMRQGDP ,,7LPRWKpH

  ´FRPEDWWUHDYHFGHVPRWVQHVHUWjULHQVLFHQ·HVWjODUXLQHSRXUFHX[TXLpFRXWHQWµ

/DFRQVWUXFWLRQj´GRXEOHGDWLI µLQWURGXLWHSDU5#&()´GRQQHUµHVWVXVFHSWLEOHGHVHWUDQVIRUPHUHQFRQVWUXF
WLRQ$F, $FFXVDWLYXVFXP,QILQLWLYR F·HVWjGLUHj¶GRXEOHDFFXVDWLI ·LQWURGXLWHSDUO̒WDQ´IDLUHODLVVHUµFRPPH
GDQVFHVH[HPSOHV

% =>? O·LQILQLWLITXLSRVVqGHGpMjXQHPDUTXHDQFLHQQHGHGDWLIHQM()SHXWrWUHSUpFpGpRXQRQGH"12%
PDUTXHQRXYHOOHGHGDWLI

 >D@ KODLIXVKLPLQDJDILPGXPDWMDQ -HDQ

  ´LOOHXUGRQQDOHSDLQGXFLHOjPDQJHUµ

 >E@ MDQQLJHEX‫ݫ‬PLVPDWMDQ>«@MDQQLGUDJNLGHGX‫ݫ‬PLN 0DWWKLHX

  ´HWYRXVQHP·DYH]SDVGRQQpjPDQJHU>«@HWYRXVQHP·DYH]SDVGpVDOWpUpµ

 >F@ MDKJHEXQLPPDGULJNDQ« 0DUF

  ´HWLOVOXLGRQQqUHQWjERLUH«µ @

<
&I-+DXGU\  WRXVOHVpOpPHQWVFRQFHUQDQWFHWWHFRQVWUXF
WLRQILJXUHQWGDQVQRWUH7KqVHG·pWDW 5RXVVHDX² !
R
&IpJDOHPHQW/XF&RULQWKLHQV

%´'LH$XVGHKQXQJGLHGHU'DWP,QILQGHUJRWLVFKHQ%LEHOHUODQJW
KDWLVWVLFKHUOLFKGHP%HVWUHEHQ]X]XVFKUHLEHQGHQ$QVFKOX‰DQV
2ULJLQDOVRHQJDOVP|JOLFK]XJHVWDOWHQ«µ*(%†S
@
&IpJDOHPHQW/XF
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q::% <BHKQ%K,\778<\

% =!?% ODFRQVWUXFWLRQj´GRXEOHDFFXVDWLI µVRXVODIRUPH$F,HVWDWWHVWpHSDU

 >D@ OHW‫ݫ‬DQVGDX‫ݫ‬DQVILOKDQVHLQDQVGDX‫ݫ‬DQV 0DWWKLHX

  ´ODLVVHOHVPRUWVHQVHYHOLUOHXUVPRUWVµ

 >E@ OHWIDXU‫ݫ‬LVVDGDZDLU‫ݫ‬DQEDUQD 0DUF

  ´ODLVVHG·DERUGOHVHQIDQWVVHUDVVDVLHUµ

 >F@ OHWL‫ݫݫ‬REDUQDJDJJDQGXPLV 0DUF

  ´ODLVVH]OHVHQIDQWVYHQLUjPRLµ 

2QREVHUYHDLQVLTX·LOH[LVWHXQYDVWHUpVHDXGH´PRGqOHVFDVXHOVµSRVVpGDQWGHVSRVVLELOLWpVGHFRQYHUWLELOLWp
LQWHUQHFHTXLGRQQHXQHYLVLRQQRXYHOOHGHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVFDVXHOOHV

@B%.F%OCO6VSF%9FO%;DO%G8;D:E%F5%U86<[:F
$F{WpGHVFDVJUDPPDWLFDX[jIRQFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHOHJRWLTXHDWWHVWHO·H[LVWHQFHG·XQHIOH[LRQFRPSOqWHGH
´FDVORFDX[µEHDXFRXSSOXVFRPSOqWHHWKRPRJqQHTXHOHVTXHOTXHVVXUYLYDQFHVpSDUVHVTXHQRXVSRXYRQVUHQ
FRQWUHUHQKLWWLWHRXHQYpGLTXH
&HWWHIOH[LRQHVWSDUIDLWHPHQWDWWHVWpHVXUOHVGpLFWLTXHVVSDWLDX[HWOHVpOpPHQWVTXLRIIUHQWXQFRPSRUWH
PHQWLGHQWLTXH

@B>B%$KI;<T<;<6I%9:%OCO6VSF%9FO%L;DO%G8;D:EP
$XFXQHJUDPPDLUHGXJRWLTXHQ·DUHFRQQXjVDYUDLHYDOHXUFHWWHIOH[LRQVSpFLILTXHDX[´FDVORFDX[µGRQW
QRXVDOORQVUDSLGHPHQWpYRTXHUOHVSULQFLSDX[IDLWV)0RVVpOHVUDVVHPEOHELHQHQXQWDEOHDXGDQVVRQA()1!.%
"!%.(%.()51!%56$#X1!%  PDLVVDQVHQGLVFHUQHUO·RUJDQLVDWLRQVSpFLILTXHQLHQVRXSoRQQHUO·DUFKDwVPH
/HVIRUPHVDWWHVWpHVGH´FDVORFDX[µVXUGpLFWLTXHVVRQWOHVVXLYDQWHV

 >@ VXUj=#MGpLFWLTXHGXORFXWHXUK̒U2%KLGU̒HWpJDOHPHQW+#-#2%+#-c($0
% % 9L7%j06Ml$6GpLFWLTXHGHO·LQWHUORFXWHXUå(-2%jå(å GHå("!# ‫ݫ‬D‫ݫ‬U‫گ‬2%jå()(
% % 9L7%j!)6GpLFWLTXHGHODqPH%=J79FHHJN%c(#)(-2%c(#)"2%MDLQ‫ݫ‬U‫گ‬2%MDLQGU̒

0DLVODIOH[LRQHQ´FDVORFDX[µFRQFHUQHpJDOHPHQWG·DXWUHVpOpPHQWVH[HUoDQWGHVIRQFWLRQVYDULpHVGDQV
O·XQLYHUVGpLFWLTXH

 ‡ XQSUHPLHUpOpPHQWIDLWIRQFWLRQG·DQDSKRULTXHVSDWLDOSDUUDSSRUWjO·XQGHVGpLFWLTXHVSUpFpGHQWV

 >D@ j0(>(-´DXPrPHHQGURLWµ0(>(å2%0(>()(

 ‡ XQVHFRQGpOpPHQWHVWVXVFHSWLEOHGHV·RSSRVHUjXQHUpIpUHQFHGpLFWLTXH

 >E@ (.c(-´DLOOHXUVµ(.c(å2%DOMD‫ݫ‬U‫گ‬

 ‡ XQWURLVLqPHpOpPHQWLQFOXWODSUpVHQFHGHVWURLVGpLFWLTXHV

 >F@ j(..(-´SDUWRXWµDOOD‫ݫ‬U‫گ‬

 ‡ HQILQXQTXDWULqPHpOpPHQWO·LQWHUURJDWLILPSOLTXHXQHUpIpUHQFHjO·#4#GXORFXWHXU

 >G@ +9(-2%+9(å2%KZD‫ݫ‬U‫گ‬2%KZDGU̒


&IpJDOHPHQW/XF-HDQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%DK<AA<*/3<\i%8*%3<7%N,3<\i%8B%D,*/e\8g%N87%A,HZN87%3<7\8N7%8B%D,*/e\8% Q:Q

/DFODVVHGHVDXWUHVpOpPHQWVVSDWLDX[UHOHYDQWGHODIOH[LRQGpLFWLTXHHVWGpFLVLYHpJDOHPHQWSRXUXQHQRXYHOOH
FRQFHSWLRQGHODGHL[LVTXLUHQRXYHOOHSURIRQGpPHQWODWKpRULHGpYHORSSpHSDU.%KOHU  

@B!B%/7UD5<OD6<85%<56F75F%F6%7FK7IOF56D6<85%9:%OCO6VSF%9FO%L;DO%G8;D:EP
/HV\VWqPHGpLFWLTXHGHV´FDVORFDX[µSUpVHQWHXQHRSSRVLWLRQ¶LQWpULHXU·\%¶H[WpULHXU·TXLWUDYHUVHWRXWOH
V\VWqPHHWOHUDSSURFKHGHV´FDVORFDX[µGXILQQRLV³TXLLJQRUHWRXWHIRLVOHSHUODWLI

 >@ 4XHVWLRQ8%, $GHVVLI\%*HJ998G

% % .LJ9K8FH%./&N% !>>6K8G%\%*>>6K8G
% % .LJ9K8FH%/+3)N% !D>6K8G%\%)>6K8G
% % .LJ9K8FH%./!N% 5J7>6K8G%\´7UDYHUVLI µ

/HV\VWqPHGXJHUPDQLTXHQ·DSDVG€LJQRUHUFHWWHRSSRVLWLRQQLSRXUOH/RFDWLIRQRXVUHQFRQWURQVHQ
YLHX[KDXWDOOHPDQG+#(´LFLµjF{WpGH¬+#(-´LFLµQLSRXUODUHODWLRQGHSDVVDJHRHQWpPRLJQHO·RSSRVLWLRQGH
O·DOOHPDQGPRGHUQHu&!-%\%"1-4+
/HV\VWqPHGHV´FDVORFDX[µHQJRWLTXHSUpVHQWHODFRQILJXUDWLRQVXLYDQWH

>@ !>>6K8G !D>6K8G

M" jMå
/RFDWLI 5J7>6K8G
M- *>>6K8G )>6K8G M()(
M"-! Må-6

@B@%+5%LK789IS85O67D6<TP%F5%U86<[:F
36H9%96%7I-(4+$+!6-#!  .%KOHUDGpILQLFHTX·LOHQWHQGSDUFHWHUPHFHVRQWGHVpOpPHQWVUpIpUHQ
WLHOVHPSOR\pVFRPPH´VLJQHVGpLFWLTXHVRXPRQVWUDWLIVµHWLODFKHUFKpjLOOXVWUHUFHWWHQRWLRQSDUXQH[HPSOH
HPSUXQWpDXMDSRQDLV
2UOHJRWLTXHRIIUHjFHWpJDUGXQPDJQLILTXHH[HPSOHOHPRW"(.0´YDOOpHµ PTXLIRQFWLRQQHFRPPHWRXWQHXWUH
JH%M(SUpVHQWHHQRXWUHGHVIRUPHVGH´FDVORFDX[µORFDWLI"(.(å(GLUHFWLI"(.(å2%6D>6K8G%"(.(å-63DUOHXUHPSORL
FHVIRUPHVGpWHUPLQHQWWRXMRXUVODSRVLWLRQEDVVHSDUUDSSRUWDXORFXWHXURXDXQDUUDWHXU

 >D@ ZDLUS‫ݫ‬XN‫ݫ‬D‫ݫ‬UR9DGDY% /XF 

  ´MHWWHWRLG·LFLHQEDVµ

 >E@ MDKZLVDQGLQ3DLWUDXLQURKVQDL9DGDYD 0DUF O?

  ´HW3LHUUHpWDQWHQEDVGDQVODFRXUµ

 >F@ MXVXV‫ݫ‬DLPGDODȹUȆVLMX‫ ݫ‬-HDQ

  ´YRXVrWHVGHFHX[YHQXVG·HQEDVµ

"85;G:O<85
&HWWHpWXGHDGpPRQWUpGHPDQLqUHGpFLVLYHHQJRWLTXHHWGRQFHQJHUPDQLTXHDQWLTXH

% =>?% TX·LODH[LVWpGHX[W\SHVGHFDVGHVFDVSXUHPHQWJUDPPDWLFDX[jIRQFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHHWGHV´FDV
ORFDX[µRUJDQLVpVHQXQV\VWqPHFRKpUHQW

P
&HTXLFRQILUPHTXHOHV*RWKVRQWKDELWpGDQVXQHUpJLRQROHV O?
,OV·DJLWG·XQHFRQVWUXFWLRQDEVROXHDXGDWLITXLHVWSOXW{WXQLQV
YDOOpHVpWDLHQWSURIRQGHVHQO·RFFXUUHQFHOD6FDQGLQDYLH WUXPHQWDODEVROX
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q:<% <BHKQ%K,\778<\

% =!?% TXHOHVFDVV\QWD[LTXHVVRQWULJRXUHXVHPHQWUpSDUWLVHQ´PRGqOHVFDVXHOVµD\DQWXQHIRUWH
VROLGDULWpHQWUHHX[WUDGXLWHSDUXQHFRQYHUWLELOLWpUpFLSURTXH

% =@? TXHOHV´FDVORFDX[µGXJRWLTXHSUpVHQWHQWXQV\VWqPHWUqVDUFKDwTXHSDUIDLWHPHQWFRQVHUYp
VDQVFRPSDUDLVRQDYHFOHVTXHOTXHVVXUYLYDQFHVGXYpGLTXHHWGXKLWWLWH

/HJRWLTXHELHQTXHOD%LEOHVRLWXQWH[WHGHWUDGXFWLRQQRXVDSSDUDvWXQHIRLVGHSOXVHWFRQWUDLUHPHQW
DX[RSLQLRQVFRPPXQpPHQWpPLVHVFRPPHXQWpPRLQDEVROXPHQWLQFRQWRXUQDEOHSRXUODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQGR
HXURSpHQQH

#W7IX<D6<85
*(% :LOKHOP6WUHLWEHUJD6$#04+!0%8.!>!)$(-&14+L+HLGHOEHUJ:LQWHU

]<WG<8U7DKM<F
%HQYHQLVWH(
  ´/DFRQMRQFWLRQ"2GDQVODV\QWD[HJRWLTXHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
%KOHU.DUO
% OPQ<% 7I-(4+$+!6-#!g%H#!%H(-0$!..1)50:1)=$#6)%"!-%7I-(4+!L-HQD*XVWDY)LVFKHU
+DXGU\-HDQ
  ´/HVHPSORLVGRXEOHVGXGDWLIHWODIRQFWLRQGXGDWLILQGRHXURSpHQµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0M
$#X1!%"!%@(-#0%²
% OP@@% N;!>I.6#%"!0%4(0%!)%?U"#X1!g%#)$-6"14$#6)%h%.;U$1"!%"!0%4(0%!)%#)"6M!1-6IU!)/\RQ+HUPqV
-RQHV2VFDU
  ´7KH,QWHUURJDWLYH3DUWLFOH7&LQ*HUPDQLFµJ6-" ² ²
.UDXVH:F>GI6HI
  O()"&14+%"!0%D6$#04+!)0XQLFK%HFN
/DURFKH(PPDQXHO
  ´&RPSDUDLVRQGXORXYLWHHWGXO\FLHQµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
Meillet, Antoine
 ² ´/HUHQRXYHOOHPHQWGHVFRQMRQFWLRQVµ<))1(#-!%"!%.;Q46.!%@-($#X1!%"!0%O(1$!0%Q$1"!02SS²
0RVVp)HUQDQG
  A()1!.%"!%.(%.()51!%56$#X1!L3DULV$XELHU0RQWDLJQH
5RXVVHDX$QGUp
  /DSKUDVHFRPSOH[HHQJHUPDQLTXHDQFLHQFRQWULEXWLRQjO·pWXGHGHO·LPSOLFDWLRQHQLQGRHXUR
SpHQ9ROXPHV3K'GLVVHUWDWLRQ8QLYHUVLWpGH3DULV6RUERQQH
  ´/HVPRGqOHVFDVXHOVHWSUpSRVLWLRQQHOVGDQVODV\QWD[HGHO·DOOHPDQGPRGHUQHµ'DQV7'0$E>!0%
#)$!-(4$#:0pGLWpSDU**UpFLDQRHW*.OHLEHUSS²3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
  ´/HVFDVORFDX[HQJHUPDQLTXHDQFLHQHWOHXUVVXUYLYDQFHVHQDQJODLVHWHQDOOHPDQGPRGHUQHVµ
36H9%Q$1"!0%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%!$%"!%.#$$U-($1-!%!)%.;+6))!1-%";<)"-U%3-UI#)pGLWpSDU'%XVFKLQJHUHW
:¬6SLHZRNSS²*UHLIVZDOG5HLQHNH
 D ´/DVpPDQWLTXHGHVUHODWLRQVFDVXHOOHVµ'DQVN(%0U>()$#X1!%"!0%-!.($#6)0pGLWpSDU$5RXVVHDXSS
²9LOOHQHXYHG·$VFT8QLYHUVLWp&KDUOHVGH*DXOOH/LOOH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3<7%DK<AA<*/3<\i%8*%3<7%N,3<\i%8B%D,*/e\8g%N87%A,HZN87%3<7\8N7%8B%D,*/e\8% Q:R

 E ´5pIOH[LRQVWKpRULTXHVHWKLVWRULTXHVVXUODWKpRULHGH%KOHUOHVV\VWqPHVGpLFWLTXHVHWOHV¶FDV
ORFDX[·µ'DQVQ$1"!0%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%5U)U-(.!%!$%46)$-(0$#?!g%+6>>(5!%h%P!()%@!--6$pGLWpSDU$0/RI
IOHU/DXULDQSS²3DULV&5(/6
% :?OO ´/HJRWLTXHµH#4$#6))(#-!%"!0%.()51!02SS²3DULV3UHVVHV8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGH)UDQFH
jSDUDvWUH ´*HUPDQLF6FDQGLQDYLDQ)DPLO\µ'DQV*+!%N()51(5!0%6:%$+!%noL%
6FKHUHU3KLOLS
  ´7KH*RWKLF,QWHUURJDWLYHDQGWKH3UREOHPRIWKH(QFOLWLF¶M1·µJ6-"²
Watkins, Calvert
  ´3UHOLPLQDULHVWRD+LVWRULFDODQG&RPSDUDWLYH$QDO\VLVRIWKH6\QWD[RIWKH2OG,ULVK9HUEµ3!.$#4(%
²
  ´3UHOLPLQDULHVWRWKH5HFRQVWUXFWLRQRIWKH,QGR(XURSHDQ6HQWHQFH6WUXFWXUHµ,Q@-64!!"#)50%6:%$+!%
B#)$+%/)$!-)($#6)(.%36)5-!00%6:%N#)51#0$0 &DPEULGJH0DVVDFKXVHWWV$XJXVW² HGLWHGE\+
*/XQWSS²7KH+DJXH0RXWRQ
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8A<Ke\87%7\K%N8%H<*/F%8B%/7N<BH</7%A,H8KB8% Q:@

!"
#$%&#'($)*)(#*+$*,&-./*$0*.)+&0,&.)*%1,$#0$

@($-#4=%D1!.I(2%\)#?!-0#$U%3+(-.!0%"!%D(1..!%M%N#..!%///

/·LVODQGDLVPRGHUQHHVWXQHODQJXHKDXWHPHQWIOH[LRQQHOOHTXLFRQQDvWOHVPrPHVFDVTXHO·DOOHPDQGPRGHUQH
QRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLIGDWLIHWJpQLWLI 3DUPLOHVODQJXHVG·(XURSHjGpFOLQDLVRQLOQ·\DJXqUHTXHOHUXVVHHWOH
SRORQDLVTXLFRPSRUWHQWGHVFDVVXSSOpPHQWDLUHV jVDYRLUSRXUOHUXVVH%OHORFDWLIHWO·LQVWUXPHQWDOHWSRXUOH
=F>FH689N%ORFDWLILQVWUXPHQWDOHWYRFDWLI 0DLVQRXVVDYRQVTXHO·LVODQGDLVHVWDXVVLWRXWHVSURSRUWLRQVJDUGpHV
OH´ODWLQGHVODQJXHVJHUPDQLTXHVµHWSDUFRQVpTXHQWTX·LOSUpVHQWHGHVWUDLWVDQFLHQVHWDUFKDwTXHVTX·LOSDU
WDJHDYHFOHVODQJXHVDQFLHQQHVFRPPHOHODWLQOHJUHFDQFLHQHWG·DXWUHVHQFRUH3UpFLVRQVTXHODGLIIpUHQFH
WUqVPLQLPHHQFRPSDUDLVRQGHVDXWUHVODQJXHVG·(XURSH HQWUHLVODQGDLVDQFLHQHWLVODQGDLVPRGHUQHHVWVDQV
SHUWLQHQFHSRXUQRWUHVXMHW
$SUqVDYRLUSDVVpHQUHYXHOHVHPSORLVGXGDWLIHQLVODQGDLVPRGHUQHQRXVQRXVDWWDFKHURQVDX[SUREOqPHV
V\QWD[LTXHVHWVpPDQWLTXHVSRXUHQVXLWHQRXVSHQFKHUVXUOD´GDWLYLWHµQRXYHOOHPDODGLHOLQJXLVWLTXH,OVHUD
WHPSVHQVXLWHG·HQWLUHUOHVOHoRQVHWGHGLVFXWHUFHUWDLQVFDVROHGDWLIDSSDUDvWGHPDQLqUHjSUHPLqUHYXHLQR
SLQpHHWLQFRPSUpKHQVLEOHSRXUXQOLQJXLVWHKDELWXpDX[DXWUHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV

23*.456789:;<*<8*497=>9?<*4675@6A6?B=><
,OQ·HVWTXHGHUHJDUGHUDWWHQWLYHPHQWXQWH[WHDOOHPDQGRXLVODQGDLVOSRXUV·DSHUFHYRLUTXHFHWHQVHPEOHGH
PRWVHVWFRPPHWLVVpSDUODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHSURQRPLQDOHHWDGMHFWLYDOH6LO·RQHQOqYHOHVpOpPHQWVTXLH[HUFHQW
O·XQHGHVTXDWUHIRQFWLRQVV\QWD[LTXHVGHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVDFWXHOOHVLOQHUHVWHTXDVLPHQWULHQGXWH[WH
(WOHGDWLISUHQGXQHSDUWQRQQpJOLJHDEOHGHFHWHQVHPEOH(QLVODQGDLVLOHVWPDUTXpPRUSKRORJLTXHPHQWSDU
OHVPRUSKqPHVVXLYDQWVGDQVOHVOH[qPHVQRPLQDX[
PDVFXOLQV
 VLQJXOLHU‘#2%M(
 SOXULHO1>
IpPLQLQV
 VLQJXOLHU‘X
 SOXULHO1>
HJLK7J9N
 VLQJXOLHU#2%M(
 SOXULHO1>
/HVSURQRPVVRQWOHVVXLYDQWV
=J79FHHJ>9N

O7J%=J79FHHJ :J%=J79FHHJ QJ%=J79FHHJ UpIOpFKL

98HIL>8J7 PpU åU- +6)1>l+!))#lå?É 0U-
=>L78J> 6==1-l600% '==1-l'ö1-% å!#> 0U-

O
'·DSUqVXQHpWXGHGXOLQJXLVWHLVODQGDLV(LUtNXU5|JQYDOGVVRQLQWL O·DFFXVDWLIHWDXGDWLIV·pWDEOLWSRXUFKDFXQG·HX[HQODQJXHDFWXHOOH
WXOpHF~..%65%=')%(e%:6-)1%65%)õc1 ´&DVHWJHQUHVDXWUHIRLVHWPDLQWH DXWRXUGHDORUVTX·HOOHWRXUQHDXWRXUGHSRXUOHJpQLWLI
QDQWµ SXEOLpHVXULQWHUQHWODIUpTXHQFHGHVPRWVDXQRPLQDWLIj

Q:@
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @<*K/3b%D\8N@<

GpPRQVWUDWLIV

PDVFXOLQ IpPLQLQ HJLK7J% =>L78J>

å!#> å!#--#% å?É å!#>

å!001>% å!00(-# å!001% å!001>

OHVDGMHFWLIVSURQRPVLQWHUURJDWLIVTXDQWLILFDWHXUVHWFRQWOHVPDUTXHVVXLYDQWHV

PDVFXOLQ IpPLQLQ HJLK7J =>L78J>

M1> M-#l))# M1 M1>

fODGpFOLQDLVRQIDLEOH ORUVTXHOHQRPHVWGpWHUPLQpSDUXQSURQRPRXXQDUWLFOHGpILQL O·DGMHFWLISUHQGOHV

GpVLQHQFHVVXLYDQWHV

PDVFXOLQ IpPLQLQ HJLK7J =>L78J>

M( M1 M( M1

3DUFRQVpTXHQWOHGDWLIGDQVOHJURXSHQRPLQDORXFKH]OHVSURQRPVHVWFODLUHPHQWPDUTXpPRUSKRORJLTXH
PHQWHWIDFLOHPHQWUHSpUDEOH,OVHGLVWLQJXHELHQGHO·DFFXVDWLIHWGXJpQLWLIVDXISRXUOHVLQJXOLHULQGpILQLGHV
OH[qPHVQRPLQDX[IDLEOHV GRQFWHUPLQpVSDUXQHYR\HOOH PDVFXOLQVIpPLQLQVHWQHXWUHVRO·RQUHQFRQWUHGH
QRPEUHX[V\QFUpWLVPHV

PDVFXOLQ IpPLQLQ HJLK7J%

´ XQ HQVHLJQDQWµ ´ XQH IHPPHµ ´ XQ ±LOµ
+FM8H6K8G =!))(-# =6)( (15(
$FFXVDWLI =!))(-( =6)1 (15(
36K8G =!))(-( =6)1 (15(
*pQLWLI =!))(-( =6)1 (15(

/DGpFOLQDLVRQGXJURXSHQRPLQDOVHWUDGXLWSDUXQHVpTXHQFHGHPRUSKqPHVGLVFRQWLQXHGDQVODTXHOOHVRQW
DPDOJDPpVOHVFDWpJRULHV GpILQLWXGHHWQRPEUH OHJHQUHHWOHFDV

$8HIL>8J7% 5>L78J>
PDVFXOLQ IpPLQLQ %HJLK7J PDVFXOLQ IpPLQLQ HJLK7J
,QGpILQL $GMHFWLIEDVH1RPLQDOH $GMHFWLIEDVH1RPLQDOH

XPXPL ‘  D  ULUL‘ X XL D XPXP

DUWLFOHGpILQLHQFOLWLTXH

'pILQL% DDLDQXP XXLXQQL DDLDQX XXXQXP:

'RQFjSDUWTXHOTXHVV\QFUpWLVPHVOHGDWLIHQLVODQGDLVHVWQHWWHPHQWPDUTXpPRUSKRORJLTXHPHQW,OQRXV
IDXWPDLQWHQDQWDQDO\VHUVHVHPSORLVV\QWD[LTXHVHWVpPDQWLTXHV

:
3RXUSOXVGHGpWDLOVYRLUOHVPDQXHOVG·LVODQGDLVLQGLTXpVGDQVOD
ELEOLRJUDSKLH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8A<Ke\87%7\K%N8%H<*/F%8B%/7N<BH</7%A,H8KB8% Q:P

!3*)C:89D<
1RXVDOORQVQRXVOLPLWHULFLDXQR\DXYHUEDO 9 jO·REMHWDXGDWLI 3 jO·DFFXVDWLI $ HWDXJpQLWLI * HWDX
VXMHWDXQRPLQDWLI 1 HQQpJOLJHDQWO·REMHWSUpSRVLWLRQQHOHWOHSRVWYHUEH
9'೉*!)#)51)1> ' !-%=(0$(ö´/HGpVVRQWMHWpVY Q
9'1೉Q5%?(-%.!')" 1- 0()).!#=()1> ' ´2QP·DFDFKpODYpULWpY <%
9''1೉6WUiNXULQQNDVWDUKHQQL ' &6.$()1> ' 0É)1>´/HJDUoRQOXL jHOOH ODQFHVRQEDOORQ jOXL Y R%
9'*೉O!))#%?(-%ç0=(ö%(..0%5çö0´2QOXLVRXKDLWD jHOOH ERQQHFKDQFHY %
9'1*೉+DQQV\QMD˙LKHQQLUi˙DKDJVLQV´,OOXLUHIXVDOHPDULDJHY @%

/HGDWLIHVWGLW´UHFWLRQQHOµTXDQGLOIDLWSDUWLHGXSURJUDPPHYDOHQFLHOGXQR\DXYHUEDO

ODQQYLOGLKMiOSDPpU´LOYRXODLWYRXOXWYRXGUDLWP·DLGHUµ,OHVWFRQFXUUHQFpSDUO·DFFXVDWLIPDLVDYHFXQ
DXWUHYHUEHGHPrPHVHQV+())%?#."#%(ö0$6ö(%>#5
úç$$%U5%$(.(ö#%$1)51>%>())(%65%!)5.(%d%´4XDQGELHQPrPHMHSDUOHUDLVOHVODQJXHVGHVKRPPHVHWGHVDQJHV%
VY% .RULQWXEUpI7J/HWWUHDX[&RULQWKLHQVN ,FLMHSHQVHTXH$(.(´SDUOHU2µTXLSUHQGQRUPDOHPHQW
O·DFFXVDWLI pJWDODP|UJHUOHQGWXQJXPiO´MHSDUOHSOXVLHXUVODQJXHVpWUDQJqUHVµ GRLWVHFRPSUHQGUHDYHF
XQREMHWLQVWUXPHQWDOMHSDUOHDXPR\HQGHSDUOHWUXFKHPHQWGH%V

&HVYDULDQWHVPRQWUHQWODJUDQGHVRXSOHVVHGHO·LVODQGDLVN

V%‫ݫ‬HJDUpJYHU˙VYLSWXUUi˙VPHQQVNXQQL´«VLMHVXLVSULYpGHO·LQWHQGDQFHµ /~NDV6DLQW/XFN< 
d%O())%0$!'I$#%)#ö1-%I!)#)51>%?É].(-())(%65%+-($$%1>%&6-ö1>%å!#--(%d´«%,OMHWDSDUWHUUHO·DUJHQWGHVFKDQ
JHXUVHWUHQYHUVDOHXUVFRPSWRLUV%VY% -yKDQQHV6DLQW-HDQN
V%RJK|IX˙VPHQQLUQLUOpWXIOHWWD‫ݫ‬iNO ˙XPRJVNLSX˙XD˙%«´«HWOHVPDJLVWUDWVOHVILUHQWGpSRXLOOHUGHOHXUV
YrWHPHQWVHWRUGRQQqUHQWTXH%VY% 3RVWXODVDJDQ$FWHVGHV$S{WUHVN

,OH[LVWHDXVVLODSRVVLELOLWpG·DYRLUREMHWVDXGDWLI

2UQRXVWURXYRQVDXVVLREMHWVjO·DFFXVDWLIDORUVTXHQRXVDXULRQVDWWHQGXTXHOHVHFRQGVRLWDXGDWLI
2JHU‫ݫ‬HLUK|I˙XORVWL˙‫ݫ‬iP|UJK|JJ%«´(WORUVTX·LOVOHVHXUHQWURXpVGHFRXSV%VY% 3RVWXODVDJDQ$FWHVGHV
$S{WUHVN

3DUIRLVOHPrPHYHUEHV·HPSORLHDSSDUHPPHQWLQGLIIpUHPPHQWDYHFO·REMHWDXGDWLIRXDYHFSUpSRVLWLRQ
DFFXVDWLI

*-w(%!#)+?!-c1>´FURLUHTXHOTX·XQµ GDWLG $-w(%!#)+?!-c1´FURLUHTXHOTXHFKRVHµ GDWLG

*U~DiHLQKYHUQ´FURLUHHQTXHOTX·XQµ DFFXVDWLI WU~DiHLWWKYD˙´FURLUHjTXHOTXHFKRVHµ DFFXVDWLG
úHJDUKDQQYDUULVLQQXSSIUiGDX˙XPPLQQWXVWO ULVYHLQDUKDQVD˙KDQQKDI˙LVDJW‫ݫ‬HWWDRJWU~˙XULWQLQJXQQL
65%6-ö#)12%0!>%P!0w0%+(:ö#%$(.(ö´/RUVTX·LOIXWUHVVXVFLWpG·HQWUHOHVPRUWVVHVGLVFLSOHVVHUDSSHOqUHQWTX·LO
DYDLWGLWFHODHWLOVFUXUHQWDX[pFULWXUHHWjODSDUROHTXH-pVXVDYDLWGLWHµ -yKDQQHV6DLQW-HDQN
0H˙DQKDQQYDUt-HU~VDOHPiSiVNDKiWt˙LQQLIyUXPDUJLUD˙WU~DiQDIQKDQV2%V%´7DQGLVTX·LOpWDLWj-pUXVDOHP
SHQGDQWODIrWHGHOD3kTXHEHDXFRXSFRPPHQFqUHQWjFURLUHHQVRQQRP%VY% -yKDQQHV6DLQW-HDQN

Q
&IELEOLRJUDSKLHÉVWD6YDYDUVGyWWLU 
,ELGHP
<
,ELGHP @
*X˙ILQVVRQ
R
,ELGHP
 oi.uchicago.edu

QQ?% @<*K/3b%D\8N@<

'HPrPH%.õ0(%´pFODLUHUµHVWHPSOR\pDYHFXQREMHWTXLHVWXQHFKRVHGDQVXQPrPHWH[WHHWjTXHOTXHVOLJQHV
G·LQWHUYDOOHWDQW{WDYHFO·DFFXVDWLIWDQW{WDYHFOHGDWLI

2J‫ݫ‬DXVpXOMyViIHVWLQJXKLPLQVLQVWLOD˙OॆVDM|U˙LQD´(WTX·LO\DLWGHVOXPLQDLUHVDXILUPDPHQWSRXUpFODLUHU
>6%KJ77JY
2J*X˙VHWWL‫ݫ‬DXiIHVWLQJXKLPLQVLQVD˙‫ݫ‬DXVN\OGXOॆVDM|U˙LQQL%V´(W'LHXOHVSODoDGDQVOHILUPDPHQWDILQ
TX·LOVpFODLUHQWODWHUUHµ,OHVWYUDLTXHGDQVFHVHFRQGH[HPSOHDYHFOHGDWLIOHYHUEH.õ0(HVWHPSOR\p
DYHFOHYHUEHGHPRGDOLWp0=1.1DXVXEMRQFWLISDVVp 0='."#TXLFRUUHVSRQGDX0+61."%JK%6L%961."GHO·DQJODLV
JK%6L%06..$!GHO·DOOHPDQGGHYHQDQWDLQVLDX[LOLDLUHGXFRQGLWLRQQHO 0DLVRQGHPHXUHSHUSOH[HTXDQWDX
FDUDFWqUHDSSDUHPPHQWLQWHUFKDQJHDEOHGHO·DFFXVDWLIHWGXGDWLI

2QSHXWPrPHWURXYHUGHX[REMHWVDXGDWLIP/HVYHUEHVH[LJHDQWOHGDWLIVRQWWUqVQRPEUHX[HWWUqVFRXUDQWV
(QYRLFLTXHOTXHVXQV

6WHOSDQKHLOVDUVWUiNQXP´/DILOOHVDOXHOHJDUoRQµ
A!))#-)#-%)!#$(%:-U$$#))# O?´/HVKRPPHVGpPHQWHQWODQRXYHOOHµ
A(ö1-#))%&c(-5(-%&~-)1)1> OO´/·KRPPHVDXYHOHVHQIDQWVµ
6LJJL WODUD˙JLIWDVW VNXiVWLQQLVLQQ# O:´6LJJLDO·LQWHQWLRQG·pSRXVHUVRQDPRXUGHMHXQHVVHµ
71>1>%:#))0$%!-:#$$%(ö%?!)c(0$%$~.?1> OQ´&HUWDLQHVSHUVRQQHVRQWGXPDOjV·KDELWXHUDX[RUGLQDWHXUVµ

/HGDWLIOLpjO·DGMHFWLIRXjODSUpSRVLWLRQ UHFWLRQ 

O())%!-%?()1-%å!001 O<´,OHVWKDELWXpjFHODµ
+~QEॆUQiO JWPp- OR´(OOHKDELWHjF{WpGHPRLµ

$XSODQV\QWD[LTXHFHTXLHVWUHPDUTXDEOHOF·HVWFHTXLSHXWDSSDUDvWUHFRPPHXQGRXEOHREMHWDXGDWLI

O())%=(0$(ö#%+6)1>%0$!#)#´,OOXLODQoDXQHSLHUUHµ
O())%+U$%+6)1>%0$1ö)#)5# O@´,OOXLSURPLWVRQDLGHµ

(QUpDOLWpLO\DELHQGRXEOHGDWLIPDLVSDVGRXEOHREMHWFDUVLO·XQGHVGHX[GDWLIVHVWELHQXQREMHWUHFWLRQQHO
DFWDQWSUpYXFRPPHREOLJDWRLUHGDQVOHSURJUDPPHYDOHQFLHO OHVHFRQGGDWLIHVWXQFLUFRQVWDQW&·HVWXQGDWLI
LQVWUXPHQWDORXPRGDO
$LQVLGDQVOHVGHX[H[HPSOHV01I-(QRXVDYRQVXQGDWLIREMHWUHFWLRQQHODYHFOHVJURXSHVQRPLQDX[UpGXLWV
jOHXUEDVH0$!#)M#% QRPLQDWLI0$!#)) %JK%0$1ö)#)5M#% QRPLQDWLI0$1ö)#)51- HWXQ´GDWLYXVµUHVSHFWLYHPHQW´LQFRP
PRGLµHW´FRPPRGLµDYHFOHSURQRPSHUVRQQHO+6)1>
/DSUHXYHHQHVWTXHFH´GDWLYXVLQFRPPRGLµRX´FRPPRGLµHVWGRXEOpRXFRQFXUUHQFpSDUXQJURXSHSUp
SRVLWLRQQHO GRQWRQVDLWTX·LOHVWQHXIIRLVVXUGL[XQFLUFRQVWDQWO 
!8H982%O())%=(0$(ö#%+6)1>%0$!#)#%HVWUHPSODoDEOHSDU+DQQ+DQQNDVWD˙LVWHLQLiKDQQ&HTX·LQGLTXHFODLUHPHQW
O·H[HPSOHVXLYDQWGHO·(YDQJLOHGH6DLQW-HDQN@N%6i\˙DUVHPV\QGODXVHUNDVWLI\UVWXUVWHLQLiKDQD /LWWpUDOHPHQW %
´4XHFHOXLG·HQWUHYRXVTXLHVWVDQVSpFKpMHWWHOHSUHPLHUXQHSLHUUHVXUHOOHY


&HVH[HPSOHVYLHQQHQWGH‫މ‬yULVVRQS 
-HPHSHUPHWVGHUHQYR\HUSRXUXQHW\SRORJLHV\QWD[LTXHjPRQ
P
&I#):-( DUWLFOH¬LQGLTXpGDQVODELEOLRJUDSKLH
O?
&HVGHX[H[HPSOHVYLHQQHQWG·ÉVWD6YDYDUVGyWWLU GpVRUPDLVDEUp
O@
0PRGLILp
JpHQ$  
/HJURXSHSUpSRVLWLRQQHOSHXWGDQVFHUWDLQVFDVrWUHDFWDQWF·HVW
OO
$ jGLUHREMHWSUpSRVLWLRQQHOREOLJDWRLUH
O:
$ ´-·KDELWHDXFHQWUHYLOOHµ/4+%96+)!%#)%"!-%7$("$>#$$!L%Q5%&õ%%#%
OQ
$ >#ö&é)1>,OHVWLFLLQpOLGDEOHVRXVSHLQHGHUHQGUHDJUDP
PDWLFDOHODSKUDVH0DLVODSOXSDUWGXWHPSVLOHVWFLUFRQVWDQW
O<
&I0DJQ~V3pWXUVVRQHW(PLO+(\MyOIVVRQ DEUpJpHQ0  PHPEUHGHJURXSHYHUEDOFRPSOpPHQWFLUFRQVWDQFLHOpOL
OR
,ELGHPH[HPSOHOpJqUHPHQWPRGLILp GDEOHFHVWURLVFRQGLWLRQVpWDQWHQVHPEOHQpFHVVDLUHVHWVXI
ILVDQWHV 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8A<Ke\87%7\K%N8%H<*/F%8B%/7N<BH</7%A,H8KB8% QQO

0DLVOH´GDWLYXVFRPPRGLLQFRPPRGLµQ·HVWpYLGHPPHQWSDVWRXMRXUVUHPSODoDEOHSDUXQJURXSHSUpSRVL
K8FHHJ>N

 ‡ Q5%.6:(ö#%+!))#%&É.)1>OP´-HOXLDLSURPLV>jHOOH@ODYRLWXUHµ

 ‡ ù:5(>!))%+ç$1ö1%+6)1>%~..1%#..1:?¬´'HVH[WUpPLVWHVOHPHQDFqUHQWGHWRXVOHVPDX[µ

 ‡ 2J XP QyWWLQD i˙XU KpW ‫މ‬yU˙XU i ‫މ‬yU WLO VLJXUV VpU '  D1)).(150% 0(5(% 6->0$1)51  ¬ ´(W OD QXLW
DXSDUDYDQW‫މ‬yU˙XULQYRTXD‫މ‬yUSRXUTX·LOOXLGRQQH jOXL ODYLFWRLUHµ ´6DJDGH*XQQODXJU
/DQJXHGHVHUSHQWµFKDS8K7J

 ‡ .RQXUViWXiSDOOLRJVDW+HOJDKLQIDJUDQ VWEU~˙LQQLRJUHQQGLRIWDXJXP ' %$#.%D1)).(150%« D1)).(150%

0(5(%6->0$1)51% ¬´/HVIHPPHVpWDLHQWDVVLVHVVXUO·HVWUDGHHW+HOJDOD%HOOHWRXWSUqVGHODPDULpH
HWHOOHMHWDLWVRXYHQWGHVUHJDUGVYHUV*XQQODXJUµ ´6DJDGH*XQQODXJU/DQJXHGHVHUSHQWµ
FKDS8K7J

"3*)E49:8B=><
$XSODQVpPDQWLTXHO·LVODQGDLVSRVVqGHXQ

% Q%´GDWLYXVFRPPRGLYHOLQFRPPRGLµ
  FRPSOpPHQWG·DWWULEXWLRQDXEpQpILFHGHTXHOTX·XQRXTXHOTXHFKRVHRXELHQDFWLRQIDLWH
DXGpWULPHQWGHTXHOTX·XQRXTXHOTXHFKRVH F·HVWOjOHU{OHJpQpUDOGXGDWLG 
 JUHFDQFLHQ%
Г࿰ဎǓԆ৓໅›ඥۭǓԆߥ໵ཬۭࢆ‫ڗ‬ဎ༓ۭԆࣹ༓۟ๆ‫͘ݰ‬Ԇ´/HVLOHQFHHPEHOOLWWRXWHVOHVIHPPHVµ 0pQDQGUH2%
A6)60$#4+(
 LVODQGDLV
% % S(-)#ö%0õ)"#%>U-%&6=#)(´/·HQIDQWP·DPRQWUpOHOLYUHµ
  +DQQYHLWWLKRQXPYL˙QiP´,OOXLRSSRVDUpVLVWDQFHµ
% % Ow)%-(=%+6)1>%=#))+!0$´(OOHOXLGRQQDXQHJLIOHµ

% Q%´GDWLYXVLQVWUXPHQWDOLVµ
% % KÉö(%+!0$#´PRQWHUjFKHYDO2Y%5-(0#%?(]#))´UHFRXYHUWG·KHUEH2Y%&!#$(%!#)+?!-)%+~-=1´WUDLWHU
TXHOTX·XQDYHFGXUHWp2Y%:c~-ö1-#))%?(-%å(=#))%+(:É0´OHIMRUGpWDLWFRXYHUWGHJODFHµ
% % 7$w.=()%=.é""#0$%-(1ö1>%=cç.´/DMHXQHILOOHV·HVWKDELOOpHG·XQPDQWHDXURXJHµ
  ‫މ‬HLUJHQJX‫ݫ‬XUUXPIyWXP\ILUiQD´,OVSDVVqUHQWODULYLqUHjSLHGVHFµ,OV·DJLWLFLG·XQGDWLI
DEVROX
% % O())%?(-%>'-$1-%-õ$#)5#´,ODpWpDVVDVVLQpDYHFXQSRLJQDUGµ

8QFDVSDUWLFXOLHUOHGDWLILQVWUXPHQWDORXPRGDOHQWDQWTX·REMHWLQWHUQH

 ‡ D'-ö(%0#5%&!.$#¬´VHFHLQGUHG·XQHFHLQWXUHµ /~NDV6DLQW/XFN

 ‡ ÌQ VWXK~VLVHIXUSUHVWXUVYHIQLKLQQDUpWWOiWX%´'DQVODPDLVRQVXLYDQWHLO\DXQSUrWUH¬TXLGRUWGX
VRPPHLOGXMXVWHµ (OtDVVRQ%OPP?N

 ‡ «%!=1-ö1%å!001>%&É.´WXFRQGXLVFHWWHYRLWXUHµ (OtDVVRQ%OPP?N

OP
0PRGLILp :?
$PRGLILp
 oi.uchicago.edu

QQ:% @<*K/3b%D\8N@<

% Q%´GDWLYXVPRGLµ
  *ॆJXULQ‫|މ‬NNNYD˙VWPXQGXJUiWD%DOGXU‫ݫ‬XUUXPWiUXP´/DJpDQWH‫|މ‬NN HQUpDOLWp/RNL
GpJXLVp GpFODUDTX·HOOHSOHXUHUDLW%DOGUDYHFGHVODUPHVVqFKHVµ
% % $(=(%!#)+?!-c1>%6I)1>%~->1>´DFFXHLOOLUTXHOTX·XQjEUDVRXYHUWVµ

% Q%´GDWLYXVORFLµ
% % O())%&õ-%K!'=c(?É=1-?!5#%:2%O(:)(-:#-ö#´LOKDELWHDXQXPpURGHOD5H\NMDYtNXUYHJXUj
+DIQDUIM|U˙XUY%-DWUDGXFWLRQIUDQoDLVHXWLOLVHJpQpUDOHPHQWOHQRPLQDWLI
% % 85#.00$~ö1>2%())()%cw.É% ´(JLOVVWD˙LUOHGHX[MXLOOHWµ

 ,FLOHGDWLILVODQGDLVFRUUHVSRQGDXORFDWLIUXVVHRXSRORQDLVGRQFjO·DEODWLIORFDWLIODWLQK6>(!%
´j5RPHµ/·DOOHPDQGPRGHUQHHPSORLHREOLJDWRLUHPHQWXQHSUpSRVLWLRQ #)2%(1:2%G1%« 

% Q%´GDWLYXVWHPSRULVµ

 ,FLOHGDWLIPDUTXHODUpSpWLWLRQ GDWLILWpUDWLI RXXQPRPHQWLQGpWHUPLQp

% % É%01))1"~51>´OHVGLPDQFKHV2Y%0$w.=()%.(0%~..1>%0$1)"1>´ODMHXQHILOOHOLVDLWjWRXV
MFMJHK9Y
% % 8#)1%0#))#%?(-%«´,OpWDLWXQHIRLV%V%2Y%+())%!)"1-$ç=%å(ö%>~-51>%0#))1>´LOO·DUpSpWp
=>L98JL79%GF89Y

 /HGDWLIV·RSSRVHLFLjO·DFFXVDWLIOHTXHOPDUTXHOHPRPHQWSUpFLVRXODGXUpH
% É%01))1"(5#))´GLPDQFKHµ FHGLPDQFKH 2%0$w.=()%.(0%(..()%"(5#))%´ODMHXQHILOOHDOX
WRXWHODMRXUQpHµ

% Q%´GDWLYXVGLIIHUHQWLDHµ
% % Pç)%!-%>#=.1%0$é--#%!)%O(.."ç-´-yQHVWEHDXFRXSSOXVJUDQGTX·+DOOGyUµ
  +DQQHUHLQXiUL\QJULHQK~Q´,OHVWG·XQDQSOXVMHXQHTX·HOOHµ

% Q%´GDWLYXVFRPSDUDWLYXVµ
  0D˙XUi˙KOXVWDiVpUYLWUDULPHQQ´,OIDXWpFRXWHUOHVSOXVVDJHVTXHVRLµ
% % 8)5#))%!-%~ö-1>%:-!>-#%É%å!001´$XFXQQ·HVWSOXVDYDQFpTXHO·DXWUHGDQVFHWWHDIIDLUHµ 8>%
Q·\HQDSDVXQSRXUUDFKHWHUO·DXWUH
% % úw%!-$%+!))#%-!')"(-#´7XDVSOXVG·H[SpULHQFHTX·HOOHµ
 &HGDWLIFRPSDUDWLIV·DSSOLTXHDX[GLIIpUHQFHVGDQVOHWHPSV
  eJNRPKHLP‫ݫ‬UHPXUPtQ~WXPiXQGDQ‫ݫ‬pU´-HVXLVUHQWUpFKH]PRLWURLVPLQXWHVDYDQWWRLµ
  ‫މ‬HLUNRPXWYHLPXUYLNXPiHIWLURNNXU´,OVVRQWDUULYpVGHX[VHPDLQHVDSUqVQRXVµ
% % úDXIOXWWXWLO9HVWPDQQDH\MDHLQXiULHIWLUJRV´,OVRQWGpPpQDJpDX[vOHV9HVWPDQQXQDQ
DSUqVO·pUXSWLRQµ
% % T#ö%+-!#)5!-1>%É&wö#)(%)6==-1>%"~51>%:'-#-%cç.´1RXVQHWWRLHURQVO·DSSDUWHPHQWTXHOTXHV
MRXUVDYDQW1RsOµ
% % *?!#>1-%"~51>%:'--´GHX[MRXUVDXSDUDYDQW2Y%:cç-1>%?#=1>%0!#))(´TXDWUHVHPDLQHVSOXV
WDUG2Y%)6==-1>%>É)w$1>%6:%0!#)$´TXHOTXHVPLQXWHVWURSWDUGµ

% Q%8QGDWLIGHODSHUVRQQHTXLGDQVG·DXWUHVODQJXHVH[SULPH>J%JpQLWLIGHODFKRVH VRXYHQW
SRXUOHVSDUWLHVGXFRUSV 
% % V%<))(-%=!>1-%!:$#-%>#52%65%!-%U5%!#5#%?!-ö1-%å!00%(ö%.!'0(%0=ç%(:%:ç$1>%@6:>4%´8QDXWUHYLHQW
DSUqVPRLHWMHQHVXLVSDVGLJQHGHGpIDLUHOHVFKDXVVXUHVGHVHVSLHGVµ 5F9KL>696I6HW
$FWHVGHV$S{WUHVN
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8A<Ke\87%7\K%N8%H<*/F%8B%/7N<BH</7%A,H8KB8% QQQ

% % SOiVDHLQKYHUMXtEUMyVWHLQKYHUMXP´LQVSLUpTXHOTXHFKRVHjTXHOTX·XQµ -yKDQQHV6DLQW-HDQ
OQN 2RRQDWWHQGUDLWOHJpQLWLIHQDOOHPDQGRXOHFRPSOpPHQWGXQRPLQWURGXLWSDUOD
SUpSRVLWLRQGHHQIUDQoDLV
% % V%.(5$%É%+!)"1-%+6)1>¬´«UHPLVHQWUHVHVPDLQVµ -yKDQQHV6DLQW-HDQNQ
  3RXUOHVSDUWLHVGXFRUSVRQDVRXYHQWVRXYHQWit'DWLI
% % Ow)%$ç=%É%+~)"%>U-´(OOHPHSULWODPDLQµLFLLO\DFRQFXUUHQFHDYHFOHSRVVHVVLI
DFFXVDWLIFDURQSHXWGLUHDXVVLDYHFOHPrPHVHQV2%Ow)%$ç=%É%+~)"%>É)(
% % ú!#-%0!$$1%)c(-ö(-?~$$%:'..$()%!"#$#itVySVOHJJRJ%EiUXD˙PXQQL%&'()´,OVIL[qUHQWXQH
pSRQJHUHPSOLHGHYLQDLJUHjXQHEUDQFKHG·\VRSHHWLOVO·DSSURFKqUHQWGHVDERXFKHµ
-yKDQQHV6DLQW-HDQN !"#=#HVWXQGDWLILQVWUXPHQWDO´DXPR\HQGHDYHF2Y%KFLK%
FRPPHGDQV
  -HV~V VHJLU YL˙ ‫ݫ‬i ´:'..#ö% =!-#)% ?($)#Y ´-pVXV OHXU GLW% bUHPSOLVVH] G·HDX OHV MDUUHVTY%
-yKDQQHV6DLQW-HDQN@

% Q%$YHFXQYHUEHUpIOpFKLO·REMHWSURQRPLQDOHVWDXGDWLIDORUVTX·DYHFOHPrPHYHUEHO·REMHW
QRPLQDOHVWjO·DFFXVDWLI&HODVHPEOHSRXUO·LQVWDQWQHFRQFHUQHUTXHOHVVRLQVFRUSRUHOV
% % O())%å?é-%>U-%1>%:é$1-)(´LOPHODYHOHVSLHGV2Y%M689N%å?6%:é$1-%>É)(%´ODYHUPHVSLHGVµ%
DFFXVDWLISOXULHOPDVFXOLQ
% % Q5%5-éö#%>U-´MHPHSHLJQH2Y%M689N%pJJU ˙LKiUL˙PLWW´MHSHLJQHPHVFKHYHX[µ

% %´GDWLYXVHWKLFXVµ
,OV·H[SULPHJpQpUDOHPHQWSDUOHSURQRPSHUVRQQHOGHSUHPLqUHSHUVRQQHDYHFXQHIIHWLOORFXWRLUHF·HVWj
GLUHHQLQVWDXUDQWXQHFRQQLYHQFHHQWUHOHORFXWHXUHWO·LQWHUORFXWHXU/HSURQRPSHUVRQQHOVHYLGHSRXUDLXQVL
GLUHGHVRQVHQVKDELWXHOSRXUSRUWHUVXUODUHODWLRQHQWUHOHVGHX[SDUWHQDLUHVODQJDJLHUVDXQLYHDXGHO·DIIHFWLYLWp
VXUSULVHLQMRQFWLRQUHFRPPDQGDWLRQGpFHSWLRQMRLHKkWH2HWF2QRPHWGHWUDGXLUHFHSURQRP
% b6>"1%>U-%!==#%6:%0!#)$%(:$1-´QHUHYLHQVSDVWURSWDUGµ

)LQDOHPHQWQRXVSRXYRQVUpVXPHUjFLQTOHVU{OHVVpPDQWLTXHVGXGDWLIVHORQ)LOOPRUH:O

 ‡ DJHQWAU-%0=#.0$%(ö%+())%0U%+é$$1-¬´-HFRPSUHQGVTX·LODLWDUUrWpµ

 ‡ VLqJHGXSURFqV ´H[SpULHQFHXUµ 7$!.I1))#%=ç.)(ö# ::¬µ/DMHXQHILOOHSUHQDLWIURLGµ(QLVODQGDLV

FRPPHHQDOOHPDQGRQDLQWpUrWjpWHQGUHODQRWLRQGHVXMHWWUDGLWLRQQHOOHPHQWFRQILQpHDX
U{OHG·DJHQW´FHOXLIDLWO·DFWLRQµDXSDWLHQWF·HVWjGLUHDXVLqJHGXSURFqV(QHIIHWRQSRXUUD
WRXMRXUVQLHUGHPDXYDLVHIRLTX·LOQ·\DSDVGHVXMHWPDLVM·REMHFWHUDLTXHGDQVWRXVOHVFDVLO\D
TXDQGPrPHTXHOTX·XQTXLDIURLG3RXUSODJLHUXQWLWUHGHILOPFpOqEUH´<DWLOXQSLORWHGDQV
O·DYLRQ"µ<DWLOXQVXMHWGDQVODSKUDVH"2XLHWHQDOOHPDQGLOSHXWrWUHHQGHKRUVGXQRPLQDWLI
O·LPPHQVHPDMRULWpGHVFDV WUqVUDUHPHQWjO·DFFXVDWLIRXDXGDWLIHWHQLVODQGDLVLOSHXWrWUH
jFKDFXQGHVTXDWUHFDV

 ‡ DOOHPDQG

% A#4+ DFFXVDWLI :-#!-$´-HJqOHµWRXUQXUHGpVXqWHUHPSODFpHSDU#4+ QRPLQDWLI :-#!-!

A#- GDWLI #0$%=(.$´-·DLIURLGµ
 ‡ LVODQGDLV
% AU- GDWLI !-%=(.$´-·DLIURLGµ
% A#5 DFFXVDWLI "-!'>"#%É%)ç$$´-·DLUrYpFHWWHQXLWµ
% O()0 JpQLWLI ?(-%5!$#ö´,OIXWPHQWLRQQpµ

:O
)LOOPRUH ::
+
 oi.uchicago.edu

QQ<% @<*K/3b%D\8N@<

fODGLIIpUHQFHGHO·DOOHPDQGFHVRQWWRXWHVOjGHVWRXUQXUHVWUqVFRXUDQWHVHQLVODQGDLV
 ‡ LQVWUXPHQWO())%?(-%.60$#))%0?!-ö# :Q¬´,OIXWIUDSSpSDUXQHpSpHµ
 ‡ EpQpILFLDLUH<>>(%I-cç)(ö#%>U-%I!'01:<¬´0DPLHP·DWULFRWpXQSXOOµ
 ‡ ORFDWLIT6I)(:#-ö#DQQDUIHEU~DU¬´9RSQDIM|U˙XUGHX[IpYULHU2Y%Q5%?(-%É%0=ç.()1>%´-·pWDLV
jO·pFROHµ

3RXUODSHWLWHKLVWRLUHRQSRXUUDLWDMRXWHUHQFRUHXQHQRXYHOOHVRUWHGHGDWLI$˙DOVWHLQQ(\‫ݫ‬yUVVRQGDQV
XQDUWLFOHVXULQWHUQHWQRWHTXHOHVPDVFXOLQVPRQRV\OODELTXHVLVODQGDLVSHXYHQWSUHQGUHODGpVLQHQFHã%FL%#%
DXGDWLIVLQJXOLHU,OREVHUYHXQIORWWHPHQWVLJQLILFDWLIHQTXDQWLWpGDQVODUpSDUWLWLRQGHFHVGHX[PRUSKqPHV
=FL7%>J%MFK%+)É:1-´FRXWHDXFDQLG YN%+)É:RX+)É:#,OFKHUFKHjHQWUHYRLUODSHUWLQHQFHGHFHWWHGLVWLQFWLRQDSULRUL
VSpFLHXVHDXGHPHXUDQW(QGHKRUVGHVH[HPSOHVROHPRWHVWXWLOLVpDYHFODSUpSRVLWLRQ>!ö´DYHFDXPR\HQGH
=672µOHYHUEHXWLOLVpDYHFOHGDWLILQVWUXPHQWDODEVROX VDQVSUpSRVLWLRQ HVW0$#)5(´SRLJQDUGHUSRLQGUHµ6WDWLV
WLTXHPHQWLOV·DSHUoRLWTXHOHGDWLIHQM#VHUHQFRQWUHGDQVGHVH[HPSOHVDYHFOHYHUEH0$#)5(,OHQFRQFOXW
TXHODWHQGDQFHGHODODQJXHHVWGHPDUTXHURXPrPHGHVWLJPDWLVHUODYLROHQFHSDUXQPRUSKqPHDXGLEOHHW
YLVLEOHHQO·RFFXUUHQFH#,OSURSRVHGRQFHVWF·HVWOHWLWUHGHVRQDUWLFOHHQOLJQHG·DSSHOHUFHWWHQRXYHOOHVRUWH
GHGDWLIOH"($#?10%4-#>#)(.#0

F3*+9*GH98BIB8<J
,O\DEHDXFRXSGHYHUEHVLPSHUVRQQHOVH[LJHDQWXQVXMHWDXGDWLIFRPPHVLqJHGXSURFqV H[SHULHQFHUFI
KWWSZZZPDLVLVPDOWDOPDOIDURSHUKWPGLFWLRQQDLUHLVODQGDLVLVODQGDLVGHPDELEOLRJUDSKLH 

% AU-%:#))0$%å(ö%0=!>>$#.!5$´-HWURXYHFHODDPXVDQWµ
% AU-%.!#ö#0$%å(ö´&HODP·HQQXLHµ
% AU-%.É=(-%å(ö%#..(´&HODPHGpSODvWµ
% AU-%å'=#-%?é)$%1>%+()(´-HO·DLPHELHQHOOHµ
% AU-%5!öc(0$%+w)% ?!. %>U-%5!öc(0$%?!.%(ö%+!))#%´(OOHPHSODvWELHQµ
 0pUOLJJXUi´-HVXLVSUHVVpµ OLWWpUDOHPHQW´jPRLJvWGHVVXV2µGRQF´TXHOTXHFKRVHSqVHVXU
PRLMHVXLVSUHVVpGHP·HQGpEDUUDVVHUY
% AU-%0?Éö1-%$cç)#ö´&HWWHSHUWHPHIDLWPDOµ
% AU-%"!$$1-%É%+15´,OPHYLHQWjO·HVSULWµ
 0pUViUQDU´&HODPHQDYUHµ
% AU-%&.éö#-´-HVDLJQHµ
% AU-%+.õ)(-´-HPHUpFKDXIIHµ
% AU-%=ç.)(-´-HFRPPHQFHjDYRLUIURLGµ
 0pUGiPDUHNNL´&HODQHPHSODvWSDVµ
 0pUOtVWYHOi‫ݫ‬D˙´-·DLPHELHQFHODµ
 0pUVWHQGXUiVDPD´&HODP·HVWpJDOµ
% AU-%&!-%(ö%5!-(%!#$$+?(ö´,OP·DSSDUWLHQWGHIDLUHTXHOTXHFKRVHµ
% AU-%.Éö1-%?!.l#..(´&HODPHSODvWGpSODvWµ
% AU-%&.~0=-(-%å(ö´&HODPHVWXSpILHµ
% AU-%6:&õö1-%å(ö´&HODPHIDLWKRUUHXUµ
% AU-%$!=0$2%>U-%+!II)(0$´-HUpXVVLVjM·DUULYHjµFIDOOHPDQG0LUJHOLQJWHV%V

:Q
+ :<
+
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8A<Ke\87%7\K%N8%H<*/F%8B%/7N<BH</7%A,H8KB8% QQR

% AU-%>#0$!=0$2%>U-%>#0+!II)(0$´-·pFKRXHMHQ·DUULYHSDVjµ
% AU-%.É=(-%?#ö%'==1-´9RXV :JSHUVRQQHGXSOXULHO PHSODLVH]µ
% AU-%å'=#-2%>U-%?#-ö#0$2%>U-%:#))0$2%>U-%0õ)#0$´,OPHVHPEOHLOPHSDUDvWMHWURXYHµ

2QUHPDUTXHUDTX·LOV·DJLWGHYHUEHVGHVHQVDWLRQVG·RSLQLRQVGHVHQWLPHQWV2UXQFHUWDLQVQRPEUHG·DXWUHV
YHUEHVFRQFHUQDQWFHFKDPSVpPDQWLTXHVRQWYLFWLPHVGHODFRQWDPLQDWLRQGXGDWLIGHFHVGHUQLHUVYHUEHV&·HVW
FHTX·RQDSSHOOHOD´GDWLYLWHµ HQLVODQGDLV‫ݫ‬iJXIDOOVVॆNL 9RLFLXQHOLVWHQRQH[KDXVWLYHGHVYHUEHVLPSHUVRQQHOV
H[LJHDQWQRUPDOHPHQWO·DFFXVDWLIPDLVYLFWLPHVGHOD´GDWLYLWHµHQLVODQGDLV

% A#5%.()5(-%(ö%:(-(´,OPHWDUGHGHSDUWLUµ
% A#5%.()5(-%É%0w==1.(ö#2%É%å(ö´-·DLHQYLHGHFKRFRODWGHoDY
% A#5%"-!'>"#%"-(1>´-·DLIDLWXQUrYHµ
% A#5%0':c(-´-·DLVRPPHLOµ
% A#5%å'-0$#-´-·DLVRLG Y
% A#5%>#))#-´-·DLVRXYHQDQFHµ
% A#5%5-1)(-%!#$$+?(ö´-HVRXSoRQQHTXHOTXHFKRVHµ
 0LJVYt˙XUtViUL˙´-·DLPDOjPDEOHVVXUHµ
% A#5%?()$(-%I!)#)5(%´,OPHPDQTXHGHO·DUJHQWµ
 0LJUiPDUtHLWWKYD˙´-HPHVRXYLHQVYDJXHPHQWGHTXHOTXHFKRVHµ
 0LJKUMiLU´-HVXLVWRXUPHQWpµ
% A#5%?!-=c(-%É%(151)´-·DLPDODX[\HX[µ
% A#5%=.É5c(-%?#ö%!#)+?!-c1´4XHOTXHFKRVHPHGRQQHODQDXVpHµ
 0LJWHNXUViUW´-HVXLVQDYUpµ
% A#5%ç-(-%:'-#-%!#)+?!-c1´-·DLOHSUHVVHQWLPHQWGHTXHOTXHFKRVHMHPHGRXWHGHTXHOTXHFKRVHµ
 0LJNO MDUiEDNLQX´-·DLOHGRVTXLPHGpPDQJHµ
% A#5%0?!)5#-´-·DLIDLPµ
% A#5%+-'..#-%?#ö%!#)+?!-c1´-·DLKRUUHXUGHTXHOTXHFKRVHµ
% A#5%:õ0#-´-·DLHQYLHµ
% A#5%&!-%(ö%.()"#´-·DFFRVWHµ
% A#5%-!=1-%(ö%.()"#´-HVXLVGURVVpVXUOHULYDJHµ
% A#5%0=6-$#-%I!)#)5(%!ö(%$É>(´-HVXLVjFRXUWG·DUJHQWRXGHWHPSVµ
% A#5%>1)(-%1>%_p%=-ç)1-´-HVXLVjGL[FRXURQQHVSUqVµ
% A#5%&-!0$1-%=c(-=´/HFRXUDJHPHPDQTXHµ
% A#5%0?#>(-%´-·DLODWrWHTXLWRXUQHµ
% A#5%.!)5#-%!:$#-%!#)+?!-c1´-HGpVLUHDUGHPPHQWTXHOTXHFKRVHµ
% A#5%+1)5-(-´M·DLIDLPµ
% A#5%+.é5#-%å(ö2%(ö%«´FHODP·DPXVHTXH%VY

/D´GDWLYLWHµGDQVWRXVFHVFDVFRQVLVWHjUHPSODFHU>#5%=67%>U- G·ROHWHUPHGH>U-1)2%=>L78J>%>U-()#-%JH%
LVODQGDLVSRXUTXDOLILHUODRXOHVWRXUQXUHVDYHFOHGDWLIGXSURQRPSHUVRQQHOGHSUHPLqUHSHUVRQQHVLQJXOLHU 
FHTXHIRQWGHWUqVQRPEUHX[MHXQHV,VODQGDLV&RQVLGpUDQWOHVHQVGHFHVH[SUHVVLRQVRQSUHQGODPHVXUHGX
SKpQRPqQHVLQRQGXGpVDVWUH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @<*K/3b%D\8N@<

0DLVHQ,VODQGHO·pFROHVHPRELOLVHHWFRPEDWpQHUJLTXHPHQWFHWWH´KpUpVLHOLQJXLVWLTXHµHWYDVDQVDXFXQ
GRXWHUpXVVLUjO·pUDGLTXHUFHQHVHUDLWSDVODSUHPLqUHIRLVG·DLOOHXUVWDQWODODQJXHHVWFKH]QRVDPLV,VODQGDLV
XQHTXHVWLRQSULRULWDLUHG·LQWpUrWQDWLRQDO0DLVODPHQDFHHVWJUDYH
(QHIIHWFHQ·HVWSDVWRXWFHUWDLQVYHUEHVSHUVRQQHOVDYHFVXMHWDXQRPLQDWLIGHYLHQQHQWVRXVOD
SUHVVLRQGHOD´GDWLYLWHµGHVYHUEHVLPSHUVRQQHOVDYHFGDWLI&LWRQVOHVGDQVOHXUHPSORLFRUUHFW
 ‡ eJKODNNDWLOD˙VMiKDQDGyWWXUPtQDDIWXU HWQRQ%S>U-%+.(==(-%$#.%« %´MHPHUpMRXLVG·DYDQFHjO·LGpH
GHUHYRLUPDILOOHµ
 ‡ 6WUiNDUQLUNYt˙DI\ULUD˙IDUD´OHVJDUVDSSUpKHQGHQWGHSDUWLUµ
 ‡ úw%:#))1-%$#.´WXUHPDUTXHVWXVHQVµ
 ‡ Q5%=!))#%$#.%É%:é$#)1´MHVRXIIUHGXSLHGµ

K3*+<*;@6BD*LE49:8B=><*H>*H98BM
6RXYHQWOHGDWLIH[SULPHXQFKRL[VpPDQWLTXHjVDYRLUOHORFDWLIDSUqVXQHSUpSRVLWLRQTXLSHXWSUHQGUH
DXVVLO·DFFXVDWLI

% û%+w0#´GDQVODPDLVRQµ RQ\HVW SDUUDSSRUWjÉ%+w0#ö%´GDQVODPDLVRQµ RQ\YD ,OHVWYUDL

TXHODODQJXHVXUSUpFLVHO·HVSDFHHQOHYDQWWRXWHDPELJXwWp

'DQVOHSUHPLHUFDV+())%!-%#))#%É%+w0# jO·LQWpULHXUGHGDQV HWGDQVOHVHFRQG+())%:!-%#))%É%+w0#ö jO·LQWp

ULHXUGHGDQV /HVODQJXHVJHUPDQLTXHVVXUFDUDFWpULVHQWO·HVSDFHSDUFHJHQUHGHUHGRQGDQFHVDORUVTXHOHV
ODQJXHVURPDQHVQ·HQpSURXYHQWQXOEHVRLQ6DQVYRXORLUGRQQHUWURSGDQVOHVWKpRULHVGH:LOKHOP+XPEROGW
VXUODFUpDWLYLWpGHVODQJXHVHWOHXUTXDOLWpGHUHIOHWGXVFKpPDPHQWDOGHVSHXSOHVQRXVSRXYRQVFRPSUHQGUH
TXHOH´*HUPDLQµYLWHVVHQWLHOOHPHQWGDQVVDPDLVRQHWHQSUHQGJUDQGVRLQHWLOHVWXQSHXSHUGXDXGHKRUVF·HVW
SRXUTXRLLOGRLWVHUDVVXUHUHQSUpFLVDQWSOXVLHXUVIRLVRHVWTXRL/H´/DWLQµOXLYLWHVVHQWLHOOHPHQWGHKRUVHW
V·\VHQWjO·DLVHG·HPEOpH&HODSDUDvWUDXQSHXFDULFDWXUDOPDLVFHODFRQWLHQWPHVHPEOHWLOXQHSDUWGHYpULWp
ODTXHOOHVHUHIOqWHGDQVODODQJXH
6LOHGDWLIHVWREOLJDWRLUHDSUqVFHUWDLQHVSUpSRVLWLRQV D˙DIIUiKMiHWF HWGDQVFHFDVQ·HVWTX·XQHVHUYLWXGH
JUDPPDWLFDOHVDQVSHUWLQHQFHOLQJXLVWLTXHHQUHYDQFKHDSUqVG·DXWUHVSUpSRVLWLRQVFRXUDQWHVFRPPHtiI\ULU
1)"#-2%':#-2%!:$#-2%>!ö2%?#öLOMRXHXQU{OHVpPDQWLTXHLPSRUWDQW&HU{OHHVWGLIIpUHQWSRXUOHVFLQTSUHPLqUHVHWOHV
WURLVGHUQLqUHV
$YHFÉ2%i2%:'-#-2%1)"#-%JK%':#-LOPDUTXHODUHODWLRQORFDWLYH DORUVTXHO·DFFXVDWLIH[SULPHODUHODWLRQWUDQVOR
FDWLYH 
% T#ö%!-1>%É%0=ç.()1>´QRXVVRPPHVjO·pFROHµ T#ö%:~-1>%É%0=ç.())´QRXVDOORQVjO·pFROHµ
% ú!#-%!-1%É%å'==-#%I!'01´LOVRQWVXUHX[XQJURVSXOOµ
 $FFXVDWLIú!#-%:(-(%É%å'==(%I!'01´LOVPHWWHQWXQJURVSXOOµ :R

&HVPrPHVRSSRVLWLRQVV\QWD[LFRVpPDQWLTXHVVHUHWURXYHQWFKH]OHVSUpSRVLWLRQV:'-#- ´GHYDQWµ 1)"#-%

´VRXVµ ':#- ´DXGHVVXVSDUGHVVXVµ &·HVWOjXQWUDLWFRPPXQDYHFO·DOOHPDQGOHUXVVHHWOHSRORQDLV SRXUFHV
GHX[ODQJXHVOHGDWLIHVWUHOD\pSDUOHORFDWLI 
(QUHYDQFKHLOQ·HQYDSDVGHPrPHSRXU!:$#- ´DSUqVµ >!ö ´DYHFµ HW?#ö ´DYHFFRQWUHHQYHUVSUqVGHµ 

 ‡ 8:$#-
% F(-(%!:$#-%!#)+?!-c1>¬ ´VXLYUH TXHOTX·XQ2Y% KDQQHUiHIWLUPpU¬ ´LO HVW DSUqV PRLµ 0I'-c(%!:$#-%
!#+)?!-c1>¬ ´GHPDQGHU DSUqV TXHOTX·XQµ-#$(%!:$#-%!#)+?!-c1>¬ ´pFULUH G·DSUqV OHV GLUHV GH
TXHOTX·XQ2Y%:(-(%!:$#-%5~$1))#%´ORQJHUODUXHµ

:R
$
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8A<Ke\87%7\K%N8%H<*/F%8B%/7N<BH</7%A,H8KB8% QQ@

3DUFRQWUHO·DFFXVDWLIHVWUHTXLVSRXUOHWHPSV
% 8:$#-%å!))()%"(5¬´DSUqVFHMRXUµå-!'$$1-%!:$#-%?#))1)(¬´IDWLJXpDSUqVOHWUDYDLOµ5-!#)%!:$#-%
ú6-&!-5¬´XQDUWLFOHGH‫މ‬RUEHUJXUµ

 ‡ A!ö

% O())%=6>%>!ö%=6)1))#%0#))#¬´LOHVWYHQXDYHFVDIHPPHµ GDWLYXVVRFLHWDWLYXV
% O())%=6>%>!ö%=6)1)(%0É)(¬´LODDPHQpVDIHPPHµ GDWLYXVFRPLWDWLYXV

!8H98N
% b6>0$1%>!ö%&É.)1>%åÉ)1>"¬´(VWXYHQX H DYHFWDYRLWXUHµGDWLILQVWUXPHQWDOHW
% 8-$1%>!ö%&É.#))%å#))"¬´DVWXWDYRLWXUH SUpVHQWHPHQW "µ
% Ow)%!-%>!ö%&(-)#¬´HOOHHVWHQFHLQWHµ OLWWpUDOHPHQW´HOOHHVWDYHFXQHQIDQWµ
% Ow)%!-%>!ö%&(-)¬´HOOHDXQHQIDQWDYHFHOOHHOOHHVWYHQXHDYHFXQHQIDQWµ
% >!ö%I!)#)51>¬´DYHFGHO·DUJHQWµ PR\HQ
% ?!-(%>!ö%I!)#)5(¬´DYRLUGHO·DUJHQWVXUVRLµ
% Q5%!-%>!ö%=?!:´M·DLXQUKXPHµ

 ‡ T#ö
&HWWHSUpSRVLWLRQGRQQHO·RFFDVLRQDXJHUPDQLVWHTXHMHVXLVGHVHVFDQGDOLVHU¬GDQVXQHUpDFWLRQDSULRUL
HQHIIHWHOOHGHYUDLWVHORQODORJLTXHGHO·DOOHPDQGVHFRQVWUXLUHDYHFOHGDWLISRXUPDUTXHUOHORFDWLIPDLVHOOH
IRQFWLRQQHGDQVFHFDVDYHFO·DFFXVDWLI0DLVQRXVVDYRQVGHSXLV)HUGLQDQGGH6DXVVXUHTXHQRXVQHGHYRQVSDV
DQDO\VHUXQHODQJXHHQIRQFWLRQG·XQHDXWUHPDLVSRXUHOOHPrPH&HODQHQRXVHPSrFKHSDVGHFRPSDUHUGDQV
XQEXWSpGDJRJLTXHHWF·HVWFHTXHQRXVIDLVRQVLFLHQHVSpUDQWrWUHXWLOHDX[DSSUHQDQWV

% O())%0$!)"1-%?#ö%5.155())¬´,OVHWLHQWSUqVGHODIHQrWUH2Y%U5%0!:%(..$(:%?#ö%6I#))%5.155(´MHGRUV
WRXMRXUVODIHQrWUHRXYHUWH2Y%+w)%0#$1-%?#ö%0$õ-#ö¬´HOOHHVWDXYRODQWµKDQQYLQQXUYL˙KiVNyODQQ¬´LO
WUDYDLOOHjO·XQLYHUVLWpµHWF

% T#öHVWFHSHQGDQWVXLYLGXGDWLITXDQGLOVLJQLILH´DYHFµ5!$(%&(-)%?#ö%=6)1¬´HQJHQGUHUXQ
HQIDQWDYHFXQHIHPPHµ&6-ö(%0>c~-%?#ö%&-(1ö#¬´PDQJHUGXEHXUUHDYHFGXSDLQ2µRXSRXUjOD
SODFHGH?#ö%>#=.1%?!-ö#%´SRXUXQSUL[pOHYpµVHJMDMiYL˙HLQKYHUMX¬´GLUHRXLjTXHOTXHFKRVHµ

N3*+9*GH98BIB8<J*<:*9AA<49:H*<8*<:*BLA9:H9BL
&RPPHHQDOOHPDQGPRGHUQHVpYLWHQ,VODQGHDFWXHOOHPHQWOHSKpQRPqQHGLWGHOD´GDWLYLWHµF·HVWjGLUH
GHO·HPSORLLQWHPSHVWLIDEXVLIHWIDXWLIGXGDWLIDXOLHXGHVDXWUHVFDVREOLTXHV DFFXVDWLIHWJpQLWLI (QDOOHPDQG
FHODVHPDQLIHVWHGHODIDoRQVXLYDQWH
'DQVXQHJUDPPDLUHIUDQoDLVHGHO·DOOHPDQGUHFRPPDQGpHDX[pWXGLDQWVJHUPDQLVWHVHQ)UDQFH 6FKDQHQJK%
"FHG689%N† MHGpFRXYUHDYHFDXWDQWGHVWXSHXUTXHG·LQGLJQDWLRQTXHOHGDWLIVHVXEVWLWXHUDLWjO·DFFXVDWLI
RXDXJpQLWLITXDQGOHJURXSHQRPLQDOHVWHQDSSRVLWLRQjXQDXWUH
$LQVLLOUHPSODFHUDLWO·DFFXVDWLIGDQVOHVH[HPSOHVVXLYDQWV

 ´:LUZXUGHQLQGLH(WDJHJHVWHFNW"!-%6&!-0$!)%#>%D!&a1"!L%H!-%D!&-(14+%"!-%7$-!4=:6->%#0$%"1-4+%
G9!#%<0I!=$!2%"!-%0$#.#0$#04+!)%1)"%5-(>>($#04+M0')$(=$#04+!)%A6$#?($#6)2%&!0$#>>$L

'HODPrPHIDoRQLOUHPSODFHUDLWOHJpQLWLIGDQVOHVH[HPSOHVVXLYDQWV
 ´6WDWWGHUEOLFKHQ5HLJHQWlQ]H"#!0!>%O!-1>5!+6I0!2%=(>%)1)%"(0%S(..!$$%(1:L%\)9!#$%"!-%(.$!)%
F!0$1)5%D!->!-0+!#>2%c!)!>%$-("#$#6)!..!)%A()~?!-:!."%#)%"!-%b(#0!-G!#$%dL%H#!%S!-51)50>(Ü)(+>!)%
=(>!)%9!5!)%"!0%7$1->02%!#)!>%9(+-!)%,-=()2%)1-%.()50(>%?6-()L
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @<*K/3b%D\8N@<

/HGDWLIVHUDLWGRQFGDQVFHVFLUFRQVWDQFHVODIRUPHGHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHVRSSRVLWLRQVFDVXHOOHVGDQVOH
JURXSHQRPLQDO ELHQTXHSDUIRLVFHVRLWOHQRPLQDWLI´7#!%0(+!)l"()=$!)%O!--)%iY2%-!5#!-!)"!-%Su-5!->!#0$!-%?6)%
S!-.#)f%#+>%(.0%-!5#!-!)"!-%Su-5!->!#0$!-%dL%H(0%J#-=!)%"#!0!0%A())!02%T6-=a>I:!-%:u-%"#!%K(00!)5.!#4++!#$%d%7#!%96+)$%
D6!$+!0$-(Ü!2%G9!#$!-%7$64= µ
2UOHVDIILUPDWLRQVGHODJUDPPDLUH6FKDQHQ%JK%&RQIDLVVRQWFRQWUHGLWHVFDWpJRULTXHPHQWSDUOHH1"!)%<%
H1"!)%DQGN%H#!%D-(>>($#=%Z0DQQKHLPN'XGHQYHUODJ@†HW†; TXLIDLWDXWRULWpHQPDWLqUH
GHJUDPPDLUHHQ$OOHPDJQH
 ´1LFKWVHOWHQZLUGGLH$SSRVLWLRQm%?6-%(..!>%)(4+%@-aI60#$#6)(.5!:u5!)%m%:a.04+.#4+%#)%"!)%H($#?%
5!0!$G$2%6&96+.%"(0%S!G15096-$%#)%!#)!>%()"!-!)%b(010%0$!+$L
% 1RXVWUDGXLVRQV´,OQ·HVWSDVUDUHTXHO·DSSRVLWLRQ VXUWRXWDSUqVOHVJURXSHVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOV 
VRLWPLVHHUURQpPHQWDXGDWLIELHQTXHOHPRWDXTXHOHOOHVHUDSSRUWHVRLWjXQDXWUHFDVµ

&·HVWOjXQHFRQGDPQDWLRQVDQVDSSHOGHFHVHPSORLVHUURQpVGXGDWLIjODSODFHGHO·DFFXVDWLIRXGXJpQLWLI
$VVXUpPHQWHQDOOHPDQGOHJpQLWLIVHPEOHIRUWHPHQWFRQFXUUHQFpSDUOHGDWLIQRWDPPHQWDSUqVOHVSUpSR
98K8FH9%9!5!)´jFDXVHGHµ 9L7KFLK%9!5!)HVWVXLYLG·XQSURQRPSHUVRQQHO9!5!)%"#-¬´jFDXVHGHWRLµHQODQJXH
SDUOpVXSSODQWHODUJHPHQW9!5!)%"!#)!-UHVVHQWLFRPPHK\SHUFRUUHFWRXFRPPHUHOHYDQWGHODSURVHQREOHHW
DUFKDwVDQWH "()=´JUkFHjµHWTXHOTXHVDXWUHV/DODQJXHSDUOpHSUpIqUHVRXYHQWDXJpQLWLIXQHWRXUQXUHDYHF
YRQGDWLI "(0%O(10%0!#)!0%T($!-0g%"(0%O(10%?6)%0!#)!>%T($!7&·HVWHQFRUHSOXVQHWORUVTXHOHJpQLWLIQ·HVWSDVVXI
ILVDPPHQWPDUTXp"#!%8.$!-)%?6)%:u):%b#)"!-) /DWRXUQXUHTXLFRQVLVWHjUHPSODFHUOHJpQLWLISRVVHVVLISRVWSRVp
jODEDVHQRPLQDOHSDUXQGDWLISUpSRVpHVWIDPLOLqUHYRLUHXQSHXYXOJDLUH"#!%F-(1%"!0%Sa4=!-0g%"!>%Sa4=!-%0!#)!%
F-(1L%H(0%O(10%0!#)!0%T($!-0g%7!#)!>%T($!-%"(0%O(10L$YHFFHUWDLQVQRPVSURSUHVGLIILFLOHVjPHWWUHDXJpQLWLISRXU
GHVUDLVRQVG·HXSKRQLH"#!%74+9!0$!-%A(]!)02%6"!-%F-#$G!)0g%"#!%74+9!0$!-%?6)%A(]%6"!-%?6)%F-#$G,OHVWYUDLTXHGDQV
OHJURXSHYHUEDOO·REMHWDXJpQLWLIHVWGHYHQXUDUHHWQHVHFRQoRLWSOXVTX·DYHFTXHOTXHVYHUEHV0#4+%04+a>!)2%
c!>()"!)%"!0%H#!&0$(+.0%&!04+1."#5!)2%c!>()"!)%0!#)!0%<>$!0%!)$+!&!)2%"#!%F-(1%91-"!%!#)!0%P1)5!)%!)$&1)"!)2HWF,O
IDXWSDUFRQWUHVRXOLJQHUDYHFIRUFHFRQWUDLUHPHQWDXWLWUHSURYRFDWHXUG·XQRXYUDJHUpFHQW :TXHOHJpQLWLI
HVWWUqVSUpVHQWGDQVOHJURXSHQRPLQDOHWDHQFRUHXQEHODYHQLUGHYDQWOXLJUkFHDXIDPHX[B6>#)(.0$#.>´VW\OH
QRPLQDOµ@UHVVHQWLFRPPHORXUGWUqVHPSOR\pGDQVODSUHVVHHWOHODQJDJHVSpFLDOLVp MXULGLTXHWHFKQLTXHHWF 
&·HVWXQSHXODPrPHFKRVHHQLVODQGDLVRVpYLWpJDOHPHQWOD´GDWLYLWHµ&·HVWDLQVLTXH.ULVWMiQÉUQDVRQ
GDQVXQDUWLFOHVXUOH´QHWµLQWLWXOp+XJOHL˙LQJDUXPtVOHQVNWODJDPiO¬´5pIOH[LRQVVXUODODQJXHMXULGLTXHLVODQGDLVHµ
GpFODUH´&HUWDLQHVIDXWHVGHODQJXHRQWXQHWHOOHYDOHXUVRFLDOHTXHOHVJHQVVRQWTXDVLPHQWPDUTXpVDXIHUURXJH
V·LOVXWLOLVHQWTXHOTXHVYDULDQWHVGHODODQJXH&HTX·LOHVWFRQYHQXG·DSSHOHUODGDWLYLWHHQHVWXQH[HPSOH0DLVOHV
IDXWHVSHXYHQWrWUHG·XQHWRXWDXWUHQDWXUHHWrWUHGXHVjO·LQDGYHUWDQFHRXjODSUpFLSLWDWLRQFHTXLHVWSHXWrWUH
SOXVIUpTXHQWTX·RQQHOHSHQVH,OSHXWQRWDPPHQWDUULYHUHWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWTXDQGOHWH[WHHVWFRPSOLTXpHW
TXHOHVSKUDVHVVRQWORQJXHVTXHOHVJHQVSHUGHQWOHFRQWU{OHHWTX·LOVRXEOLHQWXQHSDUWLHGXFRQWH[WH&·HVWDLQVL
TXHOHVSKUDVHVVRQWPDOIRUPpHV(QUHODWLRQDYHFFHODMHYRXGUDLVPHQWLRQQHUFHTXH+HOJL6N~OL.MDUWDQVVRQ
DSSHOOHODIXLWHGXJpQLWLIGDQVO·DUWLFOHGXPrPHQRPTX·LODpFULWLO\DjSHXSUqVGL[DQV-·DLTXHOTXHSHXVXLYL
OHSKpQRPqQHHWMHIDLVVXLYUHLFLTXHOTXHVH[HPSOHV

 ‡ )RUV WLVUi˙KHUUDiIiUUDNRVWDY|ODQQDUUDHQ‫ݫ‬i>DFFXVDWLIDORUVTX·LOGHYUDLW\DYRLUOHJpQLWLIå!#--(%
FL%å!00@(ö%5()5(%$#.%0(>0$(-:0´/H3UHPLHU0LQLVWUHDSHXG·DXWUHVFKRL[TXHFHOXLGHVHPHWWUHj
FRRSpUHUµ 1RXYHOOHVGHODUDGLRQDWLRQDOHGXMDQYLHU 
 ‡ %yNLQÐOMy˙KHIXUDOOWDIVWD˙L˙KiOISDUWLQQtVNXJJD6M|G JUXPHLVWDUDYHUNL>GDWLIDORUVTX·LOIDXWOH
JpQLWLI>!#0$(-(?!-=0@Pç+())!0(->~U.|WOXP@IUi´/HOLYUHü.cçö>´$QWL&KDQW@DWRXMRXUVpWp
TXHOTXHSHXpFOLSVpSDU7c~"é5-(>/D6HSW-RXUVQRPG·XQHPRQWDJQHDLQVLDSSHOpHQRXVGLW
5pJLV%R\HU :@´SDUFHTXHF·pWDLWOHODSVGHWHPSVTX·LOIDOODLWSDUDvWLOSRXUODWUDYHUVHUµ@OH
FKHIG·±XYUHGH-yKDQQHV>~U.|WOXP@GHµ 'LVVHUWDWLRQVFRODLUHGXO\FpHGH+DPUDKOt˙
GpFHPEUH 


%H!-%H($#?%#0$%"!>%D!)#$#?%0!#)%*6">UHSUHQDQWODWRXUQXUHIDPLOLqUH :@
%R\HU
FLWpHVXSUD@´/HGDWLIHVWODPRUWGXJpQLWLI µ 6LFN *
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8A<Ke\87%7\K%N8%H<*/F%8B%/7N<BH</7%A,H8KB8% QQP

 ‡ i%!-%=6>#))%É%0$cç-)%D1#))!00%@!(4!%<?#($#6)2%!#))#%0$é-0$X>GDWLIDORUVTX·LOIDXGUDLWOHJpQLWLI!#))(-%
0$é-0$1@:.15?U.(.!#51%+!#>0¬´;DSULVOHFRQWU{OHGH*XLQQHVV3HDFH$YLDWLRQO·XQHGHVSOXVJUDQGHV
VRFLpWpVGHORFDWLRQG·DYLRQVGXPRQGHµ UDGLRQDWLRQDOHGXIpYULHU
 ‡ T#ö%>#))1>0$%5çö0%"-!)502%:1..()>DFFXVDWLIDORUVTX·RQDWWHQGOHJpQLWLI:1..0@(:%0$(-:05.!ö#¬´1RXV
IDLVRQVPpPRLUHG·XQEUDYHSOHLQG·HQWUDLQDXWUDYDLOµ A6-51)&.(ö#öFKURQLTXHQpFURORJLTXH
GXDR€W& % ILQGHODFLWDWLRQGH.ULVWMiQÉUQDVRQ %
'DQVFHVTXDWUHH[HPSOHVFLGHVVXVLOV·DJLWGHJURXSHVQRPLQDX[RXGHSURQRPVHQDSSRVLWLRQ(WFRPPHHQ
DOOHPDQGODUqJOHYHXWTXHO·DSSRVLWLRQVHPHWWHDXPrPHFDVTXHOHQRPDXTXHOHOOHVHUDSSRUWH&HODPRQWUH
QRXVGLWO·DXWHXUGHO·DUWLFOHTXHPrPHOHVPpGLDVOHVSOXVHQYXHVRQWVXMHWVjFHVIORWWHPHQWV/HPrPH.ULVWMiQ
ÉUQDVRQSRXUVXLWHQGLVDQWTXHVLOHJpQLWLIFqGHSDUIRLVGXWHUUDLQDXGDWLIFHODHVWORLQG·HQWUDvQHUXQFKDQJH
PHQWGXV\VWqPHGHVFDVHQFRUHPRLQVODGLVSDULWLRQGXJpQLWLITXLDHQFRUHXQEHODYHQLUGHYDQWOXL:
'DQVVRQDUWLFOHGHVXUOD´GDWLYLWHµÉVWD6YDYDUVGyWWLUFRQVLGqUHFHOOHFLFRPPHXQSKpQRPqQHUHOD
WLYHPHQWFRXUDQWHWSHQVHTX·HQFHTXLFRQFHUQHOHVSKUDVHVLPSHUVRQQHOOHVFHWWH´GDWLYLWHµHVWEHDXFRXSSOXV
IUpTXHQWHDYHFO6%QJSHUVRQQHTX·DYHFOD7J OHVJHQVGLVHQWFRUUHFWHPHQW>#5%.()5(-¬´M·DLHQYLHGHµPDLVWUqV
VRXYHQW"VWUiNQXPODQJDU´OHJDUoRQDHQYLHGHµ(OOHSDUYLHQWDXVVLjFHWWHFRQFOXVLRQFHSKpQRPqQHDIIHFWH
WRXWHVOHVUpJLRQVG·,VODQGHHWLOHVWEHDXFRXSSOXVIUpTXHQWFKH]OHVSHUVRQQHVDXQLYHDXLQWHOOHFWXHOSHXpOHYp
/HGDWLIDSSDUDvWDORUVFRPPHXQHVROXWLRQGHIDFLOLWp
5HYHQRQVVXUFHUWDLQVDVSHFWVSURSUHPHQWGpURXWDQWVGXGDWLIGDQVO·HPSORLGHFHUWDLQVYHUEHV'HQRPEUHX[
H[HPSOHVWHQGHQWjPRQWUHUTX·DXFRXUVGHVVLqFOHVODUHFWLRQGHVYHUEHVDSHXRXSURXFKDQJp:P

 ‡ 8==#%-15.(%>#5 DFFXVDWLG ¬´1HPHWURXEOH ] SDVµ

 ‡ úw%-15.(-%>#5 DFFXVDWLG %É%-É>#)1¬´7XPHIDLVSHUGUHOHILOY ´WXP·HPEURXLOOHVµ
 ‡ 8==#%-15.(%+-#)5c1)1>%>É)1>¬´1HGpUDQJH ] SDVPHVDQQHDX[µ
 ‡ 6WUiNXULQQUXJODU|OOXVDPDQ´/HJDUoRQMp>6HIJ%KFLKY

fSUHPLqUHYXHO·DFFXVDWLIFRQFHUQHO·REMHWSURQRPLQDOLVpOHGDWLIO·REMHWVRXVIRUPHGHJURXSHQRPLQDO
0DLVOHVFKRVHVVHPEOHQWSOXVFRPSOH[HVTXDQGRQFRQVWDWHTXH
% 7çI(%0$U$$#)(´%DOD\HUOHWURWWRLUµXWLOLVHXQJURXSHQRPLQDOREMHWjO·DFFXVDWLIHWTXH
 6ySiUXVOLQX´%DOD\HUODSRXVVLqUHµIRQFWLRQQHDYHFXQJURXSHQRPLQDOREMHWDXGDWLI

'HPrPH
% A6=(%$-~II1-)(-´%DOD\HUO·HVFDOLHUµHW>6=(%0)cç)1>¬µHQOHYHUODQHLJHDYHFOHEDODLµ
 ‫މ‬HLUMXVXYDWQLQX~UEiWQXP¬´,OVpFRSqUHQWO·HDXGXEDWHDXµ
 ‫މ‬HLUMXVXEiWLQQ DFFXVDWLG ´,OVpFRSqUHQWOHEDWHDXµ

,OVHPEOHUDLWTXHORUVTXHO·REMHWHVWXQHFKRVHTXLHVWIL[HLOVRLWjO·DFFXVDWLIHWORUVTX·LOSHXWVHGpSODFHU
SDUOXLPrPHLOVRLWDXGDWLI
/HPRXYHPHQWLPSULPpjO·REMHWUHQGUDLWGRQFFHOXLFLVHQVLEOHDXGDWLI
% B!5.(%)(5.())>DFFXVDWLG @¬´FORXHU SOXVMXVWHPHQWHQIUDQoDLV´SODQWHUµ XQFORXµPDLV)!5.(%
&6.$()1>>GDWLG @É%>(-=#ö¬´H[SpGLHUOHEDOORQGDQVOHEXWµDWHQGDQFHjO·HPSRUWHUHQODQJXH
FRXUDQWHVXU)!5.(%&6.$())>DFFXVDWLG @É%>(-=#ö/·pYROXWLRQVpPDQWLTXHIDLWTXHODUHFWLRQ
FKDQJHHQODQJXHSDUOpH

0DLVRQREVHUYHGHVGpULYHVVHPEODEOHVYHUVOHGDWLIDYHFpYROXWLRQGHVHQVSRXUQRPEUHGHYHUEHVSDU
H[HPSOH


&·HVWOHVHQVGHFHTX·LOGLWjODSDJHGHO·DUWLFOHG·LQWHUQHWVXV :P
/HVH[HPSOHVHWUpIOH[LRQVTXLVXLYHQWV·LQVSLUHQWGHO·DUWLFOHGX
PHQWLRQQp 0RUJXQEODˇLˇPHQWLRQQpGDQVODELEOLRJUDSKLH
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q<?% @<*K/3b%D\8N@<

% SF.U$$(%~..1>DXOLHXGH(..$@0(>()¬´UHFROOHUWRXWHQVHPEOHµ-w0$(%~..1>DXOLHXGHDOOW@´GpPROLU
KFLKY
% SF-(>.!)5c(%!#)+?!-c1>DXOLHXGH!#$$+?(ö@¬´SURORQJHUTXHOTXHFKRVHµ

&HUWDLQVH[HPSOHVUpFHQWVHQWHQGXVjODUDGLRRXOXVGDQVODSUHVVHYRQWGDQVOHPrPHVHQVHWDWWHVWHQWWDQW
HWSOXVGHOD´GDWLYLWHµTXLV·HPSDUHGHEHDXFRXSGHORFXWHXUV
% S0|JXOHLNDUiVDPNRPXO JLRSQX˙XVWHIWLUD˙VNLO\U˙XPYDUXSSI\OOW UDGLRGX ¬µ'HV
SRVVLELOLWpVG·DFFRUGVRQWDSSDUXHVDSUqVTXHOHVFRQGLWLRQVHXUHQWpWpUHPSOLHVµDORUVTXH
1II:'..(H[LJHXQREMHWjO·DFFXVDWLI 1II:'..(%0=#.'-ö#
% S‫׋‬O|JXQXPVHJLUD˙‫ݫ‬DQQHLQDQPHJLVNLSDtHPE WWLK VWDUpWWDUGyPDUDVHPXSSI\OOLHIWLUW|OGXP
0=#.'-ö1>¬´/HVORLVGLVHQWTXHVHXOSHXWrWUHQRPPpDXSRVWHGHMXJHGHOD&RXUVXSUrPHFHOXL
TXLUHPSOLOHVFRQGLWLRQVFLDSUqVY% A6-51)&.(ö#öGX

1DWXUHOOHPHQWLOIDXWGLUH\II:'..(%!:$#-$(.#)%0=#.'-ö# DFFXVDWLG ,QYHUVHPHQWXQREMHWWUDGLWLRQQHOOHPHQWj

O·DFFXVDWLIHQODQJXHDQFLHQQHVHPHWGpVRUPDLVQRUPDOHPHQWHWFRUUHFWHPHQWDXGDWLI
$ORUVTX·RQGLVDLWHQFRUHDX;9,,,JVLqFOH
% <:0(.(%-U$$>DFFXVDWLG @%0#$$%&-çö1-%0É)1>¬´UHQRQFHUjVRQGURLWHQIDYHXUGHVRQIUqUHµRQGLW
M68HKJH6HK%(:0(.(%0U-%-U$$#>GDWLG @Q?¬´UHQRQFHUjXQGURLWµ

,OHVWSRVVLEOHTX·LO\DLWFRQWDPLQDWLRQDQDORJLHDYHFGHVYHUEHVGHVHQVYRLVLQTXLH[LJHQWOHGDWLI(:)!#$(%
´QLHUUHQLHUµ+(:)(¬´UHIXVHUµIDOODIUi¬´UHQRQFHUjµ
'XSRLQWGHYXHGHODIRQFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHOHGDWLISHXWGRQFrWUHVXMHWREMHWRXFLUFRQVWDQW LQVWUXPHQWDO 
(QFRUHXQIDLWTXLUHWLHQGUDQRWUHDWWHQWLRQGDQVO·RUGUHGHODV\QWD[HHWGHODVpPDQWLTXHFRQWUDLUHPHQWDX
IUDQoDLVHWjO·DOOHPDQGTXLSULYLOpJLHQWDYHFFHUWDLQVYHUEHVQRWDPPHQWGHGRQRXGHSULYDWLRQODGLVWULEXWLRQ
VXLYDQWHGDWLIGHODSHUVRQQHHWDFFXVDWLIGHODFKRVH

)UDQFDLV%% /.0%>;% jPRLFRPSOpPHQWG·DWWULEXWLRQFHTXLFRUUHVSRQGDXGDWLIDOOHPDQG 6)$%4(4+U%

.(%?U-#$U

$OOHPDQG%% 7#!%?!-+!#>.#4+$!)%>#- GDWLG "#!%J(+-+!#$ DFFXVDWLG 

$XFRQWUDLUHO·LVODQGDLVXWLOLVHO·DFFXVDWLIGHODSHUVRQQHHWOHGDWLIGHODFKRVH
% ú!#-%.!')"1%>#5QO DFFXVDWLG 0()).!#=()1> GDWLG ¬´,OVP·RQWFDFKpODYpULWpµ
(WHQFRUH
% 7?#I$(%!#)+?!-) DFFXVDWLG !#)+?!-c1 GDWLG ¬´SULYHUTXHOT·XQGHTXHOTXHFKRVHµ
% S!#$(%!#)+?!-) DFFXVDWLG +1)"1>¬ GDWLG ¬´H[FLWHUGHVFKLHQVFRQWUHTXHOTX·XQµ
% S.ç$(%+!#ö#)%56ö DFFXVDWLG ¬"õ-# GDWLG ´VDFULILHUDX[GLHX[SDwHQVXQDQLPDOµ

5HPDUTXRQVpJDOHPHQWTXHOHGDWLISUpFpGpGHODSUpSRVLWLRQi VHQVVSDWLDOJpQpUDO¬´VXUµDYHFFRQWDFWj
O·DSSXLGHODSHVDQWHXU H[SULPHOHJpQLWLIRXFRPSOpPHQWGHQRP$ORUVTX·RQDWWHQGUDLWHQDOOHPDQGOHJpQLWLI
DGQRPLQDOjJDXFKHGHODEDVHHWHQIUDQoDLV"1l"!%.(l";1)l";1)!%FL%"!0l"! "#!%}&!-0!$G1)5%"!0%S14+0´ODWUDGXFWLRQ
GXOLYUHµ HQDQJODLV6:()l$+! WKHWUDQVODWLRQRIWKHERRN RQDHQLVODQGDLV‫˙ॆݫ‬LQJiEyNLQQL
8QHRSSRVLWLRQV\QWD[LTXHQRQSHUWLQHQWHV·pWDEOLWFKH]FHUWDLQVYHUEHVTXLH[SULPHO·LGpHGHIDLUHGXELHQ
jXQrWUHDQLPpOHJURXSHQRPLQDOREMHWHVWDXGDWLIOHSURQRPjO·DFFXVDWLI
% Ow)%=.ç-(ö#%=!$$#)1>Q:% GDWLG ¬´HOOHDJULIIpOHFKDWµ
% =.ç-(%!#)+?!-c1> GDWLG ¬´JULIIHUTXHOTX·XQµPDLV
% b~$$1-#))%=.ç-(ö#%+()( DFFXVDWLG ¬´OHFKDWO·DJULIIpHµ

Q?
&HWH[HPSOHHWWRXVFHX[TXLSUpFqGHQWGDQVFHSDUDJUDSKHVRQW QO
+
WLUpVGX´ÌVOHQVNWPiO‫ݫ‬iWWXU2Y%0RUJXQEODˇLˇ% SULQFLSDOTXRWLGLHQ Q:
&HWH[HPSOHHWWRXVFHX[TXLVXLYHQWVRQWWLUpVGH+
G·,VODQGH RFWREUH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8A<Ke\87%7\K%N8%H<*/F%8B%/7N<BH</7%A,H8KB8% Q<O

$WWHQWLRQVLOHYHUEHHVWUpIOpFKLOHSURQRPUpIOpFKLHVWDXGDWLG 
% b.ç-(%0U-¬´VHJULIIHU2Y%=.ç-(%0U-%>!ö%:#)5-1)1>¬´VHJULIIHUDYHFOHVRQJOHVµ/HIDLWG·DGUHVVHU
G·DWWULEXHUGHIDLUHG·HQYR\HUG·LQIOLJHUTXHOTXHFKRVHjTXHOTX·XQLPSRVHODYLVLRQGXGDWLG 

fO·LQYHUVHFHUWDLQVYHUEHVjREMHWUHFWLRQQHODXGDWLIDYHFOHJURXSHQRPLQDOVHFRQVWUXLVHQWDYHFO·DFFXVDWLI
TXDQGO·REMHWHVWXQSURQRPHWSRXUOHVTXHOVRQFEVHUYHXQHRSSRVLWLRQV\QWD[LTXHGDWLIDFFXVDWLITXLFRUUHVSRQG
jXQHRSSRVLWLRQVpPDQWLTXHDQLPpaLQDQLPp
% A(-É(%å1--=(ö#%&(-)#)1 GDWLG ¬´0DUtDDHVVX\pO·HQIDQWµ
% A(-É(%å1--=(ö#%:#0=#)) DFFXVDWLG ¬´0DUtDDVpFKpOHSRLVVRQµ
% O())%0$-(1=%+!0$#)1>¬´,OFDUHVVDOHFKHYDOµ
% O())%0$-(1=%+-600+wö#)(¬´,ODFDUHVVpODSHDXGHFKHYDOµ
% Ocw=-1)(-=6)()%å?6ö#%0cw=.#)5)1>¬ GDWLG ¬´/·LQILUPLqUHDODYpOHPDODGHµ
% Né=)#-#))%å?6ö#%.É=#ö DFFXVDWLG ¬´/HPpGHFLQDODYpOHFDGDYUHµ

(QOLHQDYHFFHTXHQRXVDYRQVGLW01I-(VXUOHVYHUEHVDYHFREMHWDXGDWLITXDQGLOV·DJLWG·XQREMHWVXVFHSWLEOH
GHVHGpSODFHUTXLSUHQQHO·DFFXVDWLITXDQGO·REMHWHVWLPPRELOHQRXVSRXYRQVPHWWUHFHVYHUEHVGDQVODPrPH
FODVVHTXHFHX[TXLYLHQQHQWG·rWUHpYRTXpVDYHFXQHRSSRVLWLRQDQLPpLQDQLPp
&HODFRQILUPHUDLWQRWUHK\SRWKqVHG·XQHFODVVHGHYHUEHVVHQVLEOHVDXPRXYHPHQWHWjO·rWUHGRQFODFRQFHS
WLRQG\QDPLTXHGHO·LVODQGDLV
1RWRQVTXHGDQVODWUDQVIRUPDWLRQSDVVLYHOHJURXSHQRPLQDORXOHSURQRPDXGDWLI HWDXJpQLWLIDXVVL 
UpVLVWHQWDXFKDQJHPHQW
% T#ö0=#I$(?#)#-)#-%0=#.1ö1%?~-1)1> GDWLG ¬´/HVFOLHQWVUHQGLUHQWOHVPDUFKDQGLVHVµ
% T~-1)1> GDWLG ?(-%0=#.(ö (:%?#ö0=#I$(?#)1)1> ¬´/HVPDUFKDQGLVHVIXUHQWUHQGXH SDUOHV
FOLHQWV µ

5HPDUTXRQVHQRXWUHTXHOHVYHUEHVjREMHWUHFWLRQQHODXGDWLI OHGDWLIHVWDXWRPDWLTXHSXUHVHUYLWXGHJUDP
PDWLFDOHVDQVSHUWLQHQFHOLQJXLVWLTXHDYRQVQRXVGLW01I-( HQDOOHPDQGFRQVWLWXHQWXQHFODVVHUHODWLYHPHQW
UHVWUHLQWH M·HQGpQRPEUHHQYLURQG·DVVH]FRXUDQWVGDQVODJUDPPDLUHH1"!)¬††²HQIDLWOHQRPEUH
GHVYHUEHVWUqVFRXUDQWVHVWG·HQYLURQ DORUVTX·HQLVODQGDLVOHVYHUEHVWUqVFRXUDQWVDYHFGDWLIVRQWOpJLRQ
&HODSRXUUDLWWHQLUDXVHQWLPHQWWUqVYLIGHV,VODQGDLVSRXUOHVUHODWLRQVLQWHUSHUVRQQHOOHVHWSRXUOHXUVHQVLELOLWp
H[WUrPHSRXUODUHODWLRQTXLH[SULPHOHGRQOHIDLWG·DFFRUGHUTXHOTXHFKRVHG·HQYR\HUG·LPSULPHUXQPRXYH
PHQWjTXHOTXHFKRVHRXGHUHIXVHUTXHOTXHFKRVH&HODWUDKLUDLWXQHFRQFHSWLRQWUqVG\QDPLTXHGHODODQJXH
FRQWUDLUHPHQWjODSHUFHSWLRQSOXW{WVWDWLTXHTXHO·RQSRXUUDLWDYRLUGXGDWLI RQSHQVHjODUHODWLRQORFDWLYHPDLV
QRXVDYRQVYXTXHO·DFFXVDWLIHQFRQFXUUHQFHVpULHXVHPHQWO·H[SUHVVLRQDXGDWLI -HVXLVWHQWpG·DERQGHUGDQV
OHVHQVGXJUDQGOLQJXLVWHDOOHPDQG:LOKHOPYRQ+XPEROGW ; TXLYR\DLWGDQVFKDTXHODQJXHOHUHIOHW
GHVUHSUpVHQWDWLRQVPHQWDOHVGXSHXSOHTXLODSDUOHQQ)RUFHHVWGHFRQVWDWHUTXHGDQVFHTXHQRXVDYRQVH[SRVp
01I-(ODODQJXHVHPEOHLQIRUPpHSDUOHVFRQFHSWLRQVVRFLDOHVUHOLJLHXVHVRXKLVWRULTXHVGXSHXSOHFRQFHUQp/H
JUDQGQRPEUHGHWRXUQXUHVLPSHUVRQQHOOHVHQLVODQGDLVIRQFWLRQQDQWDYHFOHGDWLI EHDXFRXSSOXVLPSRUWDQWTX·HQ
DOOHPDQG QRXVLQFOLQHjSHQVHUTXHOHV,VODQGDLVG·XQHSDUWSHUVRQQLILHQWGDYDQWDJHOHVpOpPHQWVQDWXUHOVOHV
FKRVHVRXOHVpYpQHPHQWVG·DXWUHSDUWOHVUDSSRUWHQWGLUHFWHPHQWjODSHUVRQQHFRQFHUQpHSDUOHSURFqVH[SULPp
SDUOHYHUEH&HUWHVG·XQVLPSOHSRLQWGHYXHV\QWD[LTXHOHFDVHVWGpWHUPLQpSDUOHYHUEHOHJURXSHQRPLQDO
HWRXODSUpSRVLWLRQPDLVLOVHPEOHYUDLPHQWTXHGDQVOHFDVGHO·LVODQGDLVFHVRLWOHQR\DXYHUEDOTXLFRPPDQGH
HQSUHPLHU&HODFRQIqUHjO·LVODQGDLVXQFDUDFWqUHG\QDPLTXH
8QHSDUWLFXODULWpGHO·LVODQGDLVSDUUDSSRUWjWRXWHVOHVDXWUHVODQJXHVJHUPDQLTXHVYLYDQWHVHWPRUWHVHVW
FHOOHFLOHYHUEHTXLVLJQLILH´YHQLUµHQLVODQGDLV=6>(V·HPSORLHGHPDQLqUHWUDQVLWLYHHWDYHFOHGDWLIHQSUHQDQW
XQVHQVIDFWLWLI´IDLUHYHQLUDPHQHUGDQVXQOLHXRXDPHQHUj IDLUH TXHOTXHFKRVHRXTXHOTX·XQµQ<

QQ
&I71-%.(%"#::U-!)4!%"!%0$-14$1-!%"!0%.()51!0%+1>(#)!0   Q<
%|˙YDUVVRQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q<:% @<*K/3b%D\8N@<

% +())%=6>%>U-% GDWLIGHU5SURQRPGHSUHPLqUHSHUVRQQHVLQJXOLHUGpLFWLTXH %å()5(ö´LOP·\

DDPHQpµ
% =6>(%!#)+?!-c1% GDWLIGH!#$$+?(ö´TXHOTXHFKRVHµ %iVLQQVWD˙¬´PHWWUHTXHOTXHFKRVHjVDSODFH2Y%
=6>(%!#)+?!-c1>%w$% w-%+w0# ¬´IDLUHVRUWLUTXHOTX·XQ !#)+?!-c1>HVWOHGDWLIGH!#)+?!-  G·XQH
PDLVRQ µ

&HUWHVHQYLHX[KDXWDOOHPDQGOHYHUEHFRUUHVSRQGDQWX1†>()%FL%X+1†>()2%4+9†>()2%4+6>!) RQVDLWTXH
O·RUWKRJUDSKHGHFHWWHODQJXHYDULHEHDXFRXSVHORQOHVUpJLRQV V·HPSORLHDX9VLDYHFOHGDWLIPDLVGDQVXQVHQV
LQWUDQVLWLI´DOOHUjSDUYHQLUGDQVXQOLHXY QR
&HGLFWLRQQDLUHSUpFLVHH[SUHVVpPHQW S :é-(%w-%!#)1>%0$(ö%É%())()2%?!)c1.!5(%>!ö%($?#=06-ö%!ö(%:6-0!$)#)51%
WLOVWD˙DUiNY|U˙XQDUVRLWHQIUDQoDLV¬µWUDQVSRUWHUG·XQHQGURLWjXQDXWUHDYHFXQDGYHUEHRXXQHSUpSRVLWLRQGH
OLHXµ
/HGLFWLRQQDLUHLVODQGDLVIUDQoDLVGH*pUDUG%RRWVQGRQQHEHDXFRXSG·DXWUHVH[HPSOHVGRQWOHVVXLYDQWV
% =6>(%&-U:#´IDLUHSDUYHQLUXQHOHWWUH2Y%NRPDHLQKYHUMXP\ILUiQD¬´SDVVHUTXHOTX·XQGHO·DXWUHF{Wp
GHODULYLqUH2Y%=6>(%!#)+?!-c1>%$#.%(ö%5!-(%!#$$+?(ö´DPHQHUTXHOTX·XQjIDLUHTXHOTXHFKRVHµ%
V%NRPDODJLiHLWWKYD˙´PHWWUHHQRUGUHTXHOTXHFKRVH2Y%V%=6>(%1II%0=ç.(¬´pWDEOLUIRQGHUXQH
pFROH2Y%V%=6>(%!#)+?!-c1>%1)"()¬´V%DLGHUTXHOTX·XQjV·pFKDSSHUµ

/·DIIHFWDWLRQjXQDXWUHOLHXG·XQHSHUVRQQHRXG·XQREMHWSDUXQDJHQWVHWUDGXLWGRQFSDUO·HPSORLGXGDWLI
FDVG\QDPLTXHDSSOLTXpjO·REMHWDIIHFWpfWLWUHGHFRPSDUDLVRQHQDOOHPDQGO·REMHWDIIHFWpHVWjO·DFFXVDWLI
1RXVDYRQVSXYRLUTXHODVpPDQWLTXHGHO·REMHWLQIOXHVRXYHQWGHPDQLqUHGpFLVLYHVXUOHFKRL[GXFDV3DU
FRQVpTXHQWOHPDQLHPHQWGXGDWLIHQLVODQGDLVSRXUDXWDQWTX·LOUHOqYHGHODOLEHUWpGXORFXWHXUVHUpYqOHrWUH
DVVH]FRPSOH[HWUqVFRXUDQWHWFRUUHVSRQGDQWjXQHYLVLRQG\QDPLTXHGXPRQGHHWGHVUHODWLRQVLQWHUSHUVRQ
QHOOHVGRQFGHODYLHHQJpQpUDO

&O7EIB98B6:L
!% ÉVWD%6YDYDUVGyWWLUJK0DUJUpW-yQVGyWWLUÌVOHQVNDI\ULU~WOHQGLQJDNHQQVOXEyNtPiOIU ˜L5H\NMDYtN
0iOYtVLQGDVWRIQXQ+iVNyODÌVODQGV
(% -yQVVRQ
0% 0DJQ~V3pWXUVVRQHW(Pt>%(\MyOIVVRQA()1!.%";#0.()"(#03DULV.OLQFNVLHFN

PBOAB6?795@B<
%RRWV*pUDUG
% OPR?% ‫׋‬VOHQ]NIU|QVNRU˙DEyN5H\NMDYtN‫׋‬VDIROGDUSUHQWVPL˙MD
%|ˇYDUVVRQÉUQL
  û0.!)G=%6-e(&ç=%+()"(%0=ç.1>%65%(.>!))#)5#5H\NMDYtN%yND~WJiID0HQQLQJDUVMy˙V
%R\HU5pJLV
  O#0$6#-!%"!0%.#$$U-($1-!0%04()"#)(?!03DULV)D\DUG
'XSSOHU5tWDJK$VWULGYDQ1DKO
% OPPR% N!+-&14+%"!0%/0.a)"#04+!)%HUOLQ/DQJHQVFKHLGW9HUODJ(Q]\NORSlGLH

QR
&I-ROLYHWHW0RVVp 
%RRWV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8A<Ke\87%7\K%N8%H<*/F%8B%/7N<BH</7%A,H8KB8% Q<Q

(OtDVVRQ*\U˙LU
% OPP?% 7?!:)+cç.#ö5H\NMDYtN0iORJ0HQQLQJ
'8>>MF7J2%&KDUOHV-
  ´7KH&DVHIRU&DVHµ36H9%\)#?!-0(.0%#)%N#)51#0$#4%*+!6-'2%pGLWpSDU(%DFKJK5+DUPVSS²1HZ
<RUN+ROW5LQHKDUW2%DQG:LQVWRQ
)ULˇMyQVVRQ-yQ
% OPPQ% F6-0!$)#)5(-%É%É0.!)0=15H\NMDYtN0iOYtVLQGDVWRIQXQ+iVNyODÌVODQGV
4LeG8H99FH2%%M|UQ
% OP<Q% û0.!)0=%0!$)#)5(:-éö#%+()"(%0=ç.1>%65%w$?(-I#5H\NMDYtNÌVDIROGDU3UHQWVPL˙MD
*XHOSD3DWULFN
  ´/DWUDQVLWLYLWpHWODW\SRORJLHYHUEDOHHQLVODQGDLVPRGHUQHµ36H9%N(%$-()0#$#?#$U2%pGLWpSDU$5RXV
VHDXSS²9LOOHQHXYHG·$VFT3UHVVHV8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGX6HSWHQWULRQ
+DOOGyU+DOOGyUVVRQ
  ´8PPpUDQLU'U|JiVDPWtPDOHJULRJV|JXOHJULDWKXJXQµÌVOHQVNW0iO²
-ROLYHW$OIUHGJK)HUQDQG0RVVp
% OP<@% A()1!.%"!%.;(..!>()"%"1%A6'!)M°5!2%"!0%6-#5#)!0%(1%iT/!%0#E4.!g%5-(>>(#-!2%$!]$!02%5.600(#-!%LEOLRWKqTXH
GH5KLORORJLH4HUPDQLTXH3DULV$XELHU0RQWDLJQH
-yQVVRQ-yKDQQHV*tVOL
% :???% ´&DVHDQG'RXEOH2EMHFWVLQ,FHODQGLFµN!!"0%J6-=#)5%@(I!-0%#)%N#)51#0$#40 pGLWpSDU'LDQH1HOVRQHW
3DXO)RXONHV ²
1RXYHDX7HVWDPHQWHQLVODQGDLV
% OPP@% 1ॆMD7HVWDPHQWL˙RJ'DYt˙VViOPDU5H\NMDYtN+L˙tVOHQVNDELEOtXIpODJ
5|JQYDOGVVRQ(LUtNXU
  ´‫މ‬iJXIDOOVVॆNLRJIDOODNHUILtVOHQVNXµ7=É>(²
6FKDQHQ)UDQoRLVJK-HDQ3DXO&RQIDLV
  D-(>>(#-!%"!%.;(..!>()"g%:6->!0%!$%:6)4$#6)0L3DULV1DWKDQXQLYHUVLWp
6LFN%DVWLDQ
% :??<% H!-%H($#?%#0$%"!>%D!)#$#?%0!#)%*6"g%8#)%J!59!#0!-%"1-4+%"!)%/--5(-$!)%"!-%"!1$04+!)%7I-(4+!&RORJQH9HU
ODJ.LHSHQKHXHU :LWVFK
$8IL7e99FH2%+DOOGyUÉUPDQQ
% % 9HUEDO6\QWD[DQG&DVHLQ,FHODQGLF'RFWRUDOGLVVHUWDWLRQ8QLYHUVLW\RI/XQG5pLPSUHVVLRQ,QVWL
WXWHRI/LQJXLVWLFV8QLYHUVLW\RI,FHODQG5H\NMDYtN
6LJXUMyQVGyWWLU6LJUt˙XUJK%[F6H%068>8HI
  ´‫މ‬D˙YDUKULQWtPpUiOHL˙LQQLtVNyODQQ‫މ‬ROP\QGH˙DHNNL‫ݫ‬ROP\QG"µÌVOHQVNW0iO%:Q²*
6YDYDUVGyWWLUÉVWD
  ´‫މ‬iJXIDOOVVॆNLµ%ÌVOHQVNW0iO²
6YDYDUVGyWWLUÉVWDJK0DUJUpW-yQVGyWWLU
% OPPO% ÌVOHQVNDI\ULU~WOHQGLQJDNHQQVOXEyNtPiOIU ˜L5H\NMDYtN0iOYtVLQGDVWRIQXQ+iVNyODÌVODQGV
6YDYDUVGyWWLUÉVWD*tVOL3iOVVRQJK‫މ‬yUyOIXU‫މ‬yUOLQGVVRQ
  ´)DOOHUIDUDUKHLOO8PIDOOQRWNXQPH˙ySHUVyQXOHJXPV|JQXPµÌVOHQVNW0iONQQ;RR
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q<<% @<*K/3b%D\8N@<

‫މ‬yULVVRQ2%-yQpGLWHXU
% OPPP% )\ULUKHLWQDODQGL˙)UiVDJQLU~U%LEOtXQQL5H\NMDYtN+iVNyOD~WJiIDQ%
‫މ‬UiLQVVRQ2%+|VNXOGXU
% OPPP% û0.!)0=%0!$)#)5(:-éö#5H\NMDYtN0iOYtVLQGDVWRIQXQ+iVNyODÌVODQGV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% AQ3<B/7A87%H8%KQ<FF83*<*/,B%HQ7/B8B*/8NN8%8*%O/QK<K3O/8%H87%,@@,7/*/,B7%3<7\8NN87%8B%7N<T8% Q<R

!"
#$%&'()#*)+,*+-$&..*%/&/(0'+,$)('*'/(*11*+*/+2($-&-%2(*++
,*)+0330)(/(0')+%&)4*11*)+*'+)1&5*

3.(#-!%N!%F!1?-!2%/)0$#$1$%B($#6)(.%"!0%N()51!0%!$%3#?#.#0($#6)0%,-#!)$(.!02%@(-#0

'DQVOHVGLIIpUHQWVSUREOqPHVSRVpVSDUO·pYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHVHWURXYHOHSUREOqPHGXV\QFUpWLVPHHWGH
O·KRPRSKRQLHHQWUHIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVLQLWLDOHPHQWGLVWLQFWHV/HV\QFUpWLVPHpWDQWO·DEDQGRQG·XQHGLVWLQFWLRQ
FDVXHOOHGDQVWRXVOHVSDUDGLJPHV SDUH[HPSOHODFRQIXVLRQGXGDWLIGXORFDWLIHWGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOHQJUHF
DQFLHQTXLVRQWGDQVWRXVOHVSDUDGLJPHVUHSUpVHQWpVSDUXQHIRUPHXQLTXH QHQRXVLQWpUHVVHUDSDVLFL/·REMHW
GHFHWWHpWXGHHVWOHSUREOqPHTXHSRVHQWOHVKRPRSKRQLHVVHFRQGDLUHVHQWUHGHX[FDVjO·LQWpULHXUG·XQPrPH
SDUDGLJPHWDQGLVTXHOHVDXWUHVW\SHVIOH[LRQQHOVQHVRQWSDVFRQFHUQpV2UOHVODYHHVWSHXWrWUHOHJURXSHGH
ODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVGDQVOHTXHOFHSUREOqPHV·HVWSRVpDYHFOHSOXVG·DFXwWpHWGDQVOHTXHOLODpWpUpVROX
GHODPDQLqUHODSOXVRULJLQDOH

67+18+9:;<=+>:+?@?ABC=+DE=F;G<<=E+H9GAGI?E8J=
/HVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVVRQWGHVODQJXHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVFHTXLVLJQLILHTXHODIRQFWLRQG·XQHIRUPH
QRPLQDOHHVWH[SULPpHSDUXQPRUSKqPHSODFpjODILQGXPRWDSSHOpGpVLQHQFHTXLHVWSRUWHXUGHSOXVLHXUV
LQIRUPDWLRQVOHJHQUHOHQRPEUHHWOHFDV/HVGpVLQHQFHVGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQpWDLHQWSRXUODSOXSDUWFRQVR
QDQWLTXHV QRPVLQJ M0DFFVLQJ M>JpQVLQJ M!0WM60LQVWVLQJ M+O HWFOHVGpVLQHQFHVYRFDOLTXHVpWDLHQW
PLQRULWDLUHV GDWVLQJ M!#ORFVLQJ M# 
/·XQHGHVORLVHVVHQWLHOOHVGHODSKRQpWLTXHKLVWRULTXHVODYHHVWFHTX·RQDSSHOOHOD´ORLGHVV\OODEHVRXYHUWHVµ
ODVWUXFWXUHGHODODQJXHQ·DGPHWTXHGHVV\OODEHVRXYHUWHVGRQFGHW\SH V &9RX V &59/DUqJOHHVWTXHO·RUJD
QLVDWLRQGHVSKRQqPHVjO·LQWpULHXUGHODV\OODEHREpLWDXSULQFLSHGHVRQRULWpFURLVVDQWHO·pOpPHQWOHSOXVVRQRUH
GRLWrWUHOHGHUQLHUpOpPHQWGHODV\OODEH2UOHVYR\HOOHVVRQWOHVSKRQqPHVOHVSOXVVRQRUHVGRQFWRXWHV\OODEH
GRLWVHWHUPLQHUSDUXQHYR\HOOH7RXWHVOHVFRQVRQQHVHQSRVLWLRQLPSORVLYHF·HVWjGLUHILQDOHVGHV\OODEH
V·DPXwVVHQW/DFRQVpTXHQFHVXUODPRUSKRORJLHIOH[LRQQHOOHHVWVLPSOHHWUDGLFDOHWRXWHVOHVGpVLQHQFHVFRQVR
QDQWLTXHVGLVSDUDLVVHQW,OV·HQVXLWLQpYLWDEOHPHQWGHVKRPRSKRQLHVHQWUHFDVDLQVLO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHQRPVLQJ
HWDFFVLQJGHVQRQQHXWUHVHQLQGRHXURSpHQ M0WUM>HVWQHXWUDOLVpHGDQVODSOXSDUWGHVSDUDGLJPHV
8QHDXWUHFRQVpTXHQFHGHODORLGHVV\OODEHVRXYHUWHVHVWO·pOLPLQDWLRQGHVGLSKWRQJXHV(OOHDHOOHDXVVL
HQWUDvQpODQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHFHUWDLQHVRSSRVLWLRQVDLQVLSRXUOHVWKqPHVHQ M#MOHGDWVLQJ HL ੷ HL ੷UpGXLWj HL ੷
SDUKDSORORJLHV·HVWPRQRSKWRQJXpHQM#/HORFVLQJ ̒ҸV·HVWOXLDXVVLPRQRSKWRQJXpHQM#(WOHVGHX[VHVRQW
GRQFFRQIRQGXVDYHFO·DQFLHQDFFSOXU M#M)0%X%M#'HPrPHSRXUOHVWKqPHVHQM6MO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHOHGDWVLQJ
UM6M!#%X%U‫گ‬L JUHFဝODWLQ‫ ̍ ! گ‬ODGpVLQHQFHDWWHVWpHM1HVWVHFRQGDLUHHWQRQSKRQpWLTXH HWOHORFVLQJ M6#%
JUHF‫ڗ‬ԆODWLQҸ !̍HVWHOOHDXVVLQHXWUDOLVpHHWOHVGHX[VHFRQIRQGHQWDYHFOHQRPSOXU M6#%X%U̍ TXLDpWp
JH9L8KJ%7JG68K%JH%M# 
6·DMRXWHQWjFHODGHVDOWpUDWLRQVGHWLPEUHGHVYR\HOOHVHQVODYHFRQGLWLRQQpHVRXQRQTXLRQWHOOHVDXVVL
DPHQpGHVKRPRSKRQLHVVHFRQGDLUHV8QH[HPSOHGHFKDQJHPHQWQRQFRQGLWLRQQpHVWODFRQIXVLRQGH ‫گ‬HWGH
UčTXLGHYLHQQHQWWRXVGHX[>č@'DQVOHVWKqPHVHQM6MFHFKDQJHPHQWDSRXUUpVXOWDWODSHUWHGHO·RSSRVLWLRQ
HQWUHO·LQVWVLQJ M6+O%X%U‫گ‬%X%UčHWO·DEOVLQJ č " ! č TXLHQVODYHHVWODIRUPHGHJpQVLQJHQV\QFKURQLHHQ
YHUWXG·XQV\QFUpWLVPHDQFLHQHQWUHJpQVLQJHWDEOVLQJ 8QH[HPSOHGHFKDQJHPHQWFRQGLWLRQQpHVWODIHU
PHWXUHGH ‫ڨ‬HQV\OODEHILQDOHGHYDQW>Q@ ‫ڨ‬Q%X%U࠽QFHTXLDPqQHXQHKRPRSKRQLHHQWUHO·DFFVLQJGHVWKqPHV
JH%M6MHWFHOXLGHVWKqPHVHQ%M1M
/HUpVXOWDWGHFHVFKDQJHPHQWVSKRQpWLTXHVHVWGRQFXQERXOHYHUVHPHQWFRPSOHWGHODPRUSKRORJLHIOH[LRQ
QHOOH/HVODYHV·HVWUHWURXYpDPSXWpOLWWpUDOHPHQWGHVHVPDUTXHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVWDQWOHV\VWqPHpWDLWLOOLVLEOHHW
WUDYHUVpSDUGHVKRPRSKRQLHVGHWRXWHVRUWHKRPRSKRQLHVHQWUHGLYHUVW\SHVIOH[LRQQHOVPDLVVXUWRXWQHXWUD

Q<R
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3N</K8%N8%F8\TK8

OLVDWLRQG·RSSRVLWLRQVFDVXHOOHVjO·LQWpULHXUG·XQPrPHSDUDGLJPH/DVROXWLRQjFHSUREOqPHDXUDLWSXrWUHXQH
VROXWLRQWHOOHTX·RQODWURXYHHQDQJODLVRXGDQVOHVODQJXHVURPDQHVXQUHQRQFHPHQWjODIOH[LRQHWXQUHFRXUV
jG·DXWUHVPR\HQV IL[DWLRQGHO·RUGUHGHVPRWVHWXVDJHV\VWpPDWLTXHGHSUpSRVLWLRQV 2UFRPPHRQOHVDLWOHV
ODQJXHVVODYHVVRQWORLQG·DYRLUHPSUXQWpFHWWHYRLHSXLVTXHODSOXSDUWGHVODQJXHVPRGHUQHVFRQVHUYHQWVL[RX
VHSWFDVYLYDQWV/DTXHVWLRQTXLVHSRVHHVWGRQFODVXLYDQWHFRPPHQWHQSDUWDQWG·XQHVLWXDWLRQDXVVLSURIRQ
GpPHQWDOWpUpHHWDXVVLSHXIRQFWLRQQHOOHOHVODYHV·HVWLOGRWpG·XQV\VWqPHVWDEOH"4XHOVVRQWOHVPpFDQLVPHV
DX[TXHOVLODHXUHFRXUVSRXUpOLPLQHUOHVKRPRSKRQLHVVHFRQGDLUHV"

!7+/@H=?+>=+9KD=LA;G<+L8?:=EE=
,O\DSOXVLHXUVPR\HQVGHUHPpGLHUjXQHKRPRSKRQLHVHFRQGDLUHHQWUHGHX[IRUPHVFDVXHOOHVHWGRQFGLI
IpUHQWVW\SHVGHUpIHFWLRQO
8QSUHPLHUW\SH W\SH$ HVWODUHFDUDFWpULVDWLRQG·XQHGpVLQHQFHSDUDGMRQFWLRQG·XQpOpPHQWTXLSHXWrWUH
XQHSDUWLFXOH SDUH[HPSOHOHčGHO·LUDQLHQGDQVOHORFVLQJDYHVWLTXHYҸVLLčYLHX[SHUVHYL۟L\čGH X੷ LN੸M´YLOODJHµ
ROHORFVLQJ X੷ LߖLHVWUHFDUDFWpULVpSDUXQHSDUWLFXOHDGYHUELDOHORFDWLYHSRVWSRVpHč%FL%>J%U̒QGXEDOWLTXHSRXU
O·LQHVVLIDQFLHQORFVLQJ RXXQHGpVLQHQFHUDMRXWpHGHPDQLqUHWDXWRORJLTXH SDUH[HPSOHODUHFDUDFWpULVDWLRQ
GHO·DFFVLQJGXSURQRPLQWHUURJDWLILQGpILQL =X੷ #M>! ࠗ໅ဎHQࠗ໅ဎǓHQJUHFDYHFXQHGHX[LqPHGpVLQHQFHG·DFF
VLQJǓ P૖ RXWRXMRXUVHQJUHFODUHFDUDFWpULVDWLRQGXORFVLQJ ̒L ੷ GHVWKqPHVHQM#M%JH%U̒L ੷ L!ٗԆ ›཭ड़ٗԆ 
8QGHX[LqPHW\SH W\SH% HVWO·DQDORJLHG·DXWUHVIRUPHVGXPrPHSDUDGLJPHSDUH[HPSOHGDQVOHFDVGH
SDUDGLJPHVDOWHUQDQWVROHPRUSKqPHSUpGpVLQHQWLHOILJXUHWDQW{WDXGHJUpSOHLQWDQW{WDXGHJUp]pURFHTXL
HQWUDvQHXQQLYHOOHPHQW&·HVWXQSURFHVVXVWUqVELHQUHSUpVHQWpGDQVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVROHVSDUD
GLJPHVDOWHUQDQWVRQWpWpODUJHPHQWQLYHOpV8QH[HPSOHHVWOHFDVGXJpQVLQJJUHF›཭ड़͘ङߥ›཭ड़ٗ‫ ߥڗ‬KRPpULTXH 
ROHٗHVWDQDORJLTXHGXGDWVLQJ›཭ड़ٗԆDQFLHQORFVLQJ ̒L ੷
8QWURLVLqPHW\SH W\SH& HVWOHUHPSODFHPHQWG·XQHGpVLQHQFHSDUODGpVLQHQFHFRUUHVSRQGDQWHG·XQDXWUH
W\SHIOH[LRQQHOFDVH[WUrPHPHQWIUpTXHQWHQVODYHFRPPHDLOOHXUV2QSHXWSUHQGUHO·H[HPSOHGHODUpIHFWLRQGX
JpQSOXUHQ M6>%JH%>6K8H%JH%‫گ‬UXPG·DSUqVOHčUXPGHVWKqPHVHQM(MTXLHVWVHXODQFLHQ  čV‫گ‬PJUHFKRPp
ULTXHථੜङဎ FHTXLSHUPHWGHVXSSULPHUO·KRPRSKRQLHHQWUHJpQSOXU"!1> FRQVHUYpGDQVX1#0%"!1>´OHTXHO
GHVGLHX[µ HWDFFVLQJ"!1>(QVODYHRQSHXWSUHQGUHO·H[HPSOHGXWUDQVIHUWGHODGpVLQHQFHGHJpQSOXURYȽ%
GHVWKqPHVHQM1MDX[WKqPHVHQM6MRODGpVLQHQFHpW\PRORJLTXHpWDLWȽKRPRSKRQHGXQRPDFFVLQJ YLHX[
VODYHJpQSOXUGDURYȽ´GHVSUpVHQWVµG·DSUqVV\QRYȽ´GHVILOVµjF{WpGXJpQLWLIDQFLHQGDUȽKRPRSKRQHGXQRP
DFFVLQJGDUȽO·H[WHQVLRQGHRYȽSHUPHWGHVXSSULPHUO·KRPRSKRQLHGXJpQSOXUDYHFOHQRPDFFVLQJSRXUOHV
PDVFXOLQVHQ%M6MG·RODJpQpUDOLVDWLRQGHFHWWHGpVLQHQFHGDQVOHVODQJXHVPRGHUQHV (QJpQpUDOOHSDUDGLJPH
GRQQHXUHWOHSDUDGLJPHUHFHYHXURQWGHVIRUPHVFRPPXQHVTXLIDFLOLWHQWO·DQDORJLHVXLYDQWODUqJOHGHODTXD
WULqPHSURSRUWLRQQHOOH HQO·RFFXUUHQFHSRXUOHJpQSOXUHQRYȽGXVODYHOHVQRPDFFVLQJVRQWLGHQWLTXHVGDQV
>J%KE=J%JH%M1MHWGDQVOHW\SHHQM6MN%V\QȽ2%GDUȽG·RODSURSRUWLRQQRPDFFV\QȽJpQSOXUV\QRYȽ!QRPDFFGDUȽN%
JpQSOXU; "(-6YȽ 
8QTXDWULqPHW\SH W\SH' FRQVLVWHHQXQHUpRUJDQLVDWLRQLQWHUQHjXQSDUDGLJPHTXLFRQGXLWjUpDIIHFWHU
XQHGpVLQHQFHH[LVWDQWHDXPDUTXDJHG·XQQRXYHDXFDVHQJpQpUDOHQUpSRQVHjXQHDQRPDOLH IRUPHQRQYLDEOH
SKRQpWLTXHPHQWKRPRSKRQLHJrQDQWHDYHFG·DXWUHVFDVMXVWHPHQW /HUpVXOWDWHVWODFUpDWLRQG·XQHKRPRSKR
QLHVHFRQGDLUHSXLVTXHODGpVLQHQFHUpDIIHFWpHQHSHUGSDVSRXUDXWDQWVDIRQFWLRQG·RULJLQHHWVHUHWURXYHGRQF
PDUTXHUGHX[FDVGLIIpUHQWV&·HVWXQSURFHVVXVQHWWHPHQWSOXVUDUHTXHOHVWURLVSUHPLHUVW\SHVVDQVGRXWHSDUFH
TX·LOHVWSOXVFRPSOH[HLOUHTXLHUWHQHIIHWGHVFRQGLWLRQVSUpFLVHVVXUOHVTXHOOHVMHUHYLHQGUDLHWDXVVLSDUFHTX·LO
VHPEOHSHXpFRQRPLTXHpWDQWGRQQpTX·LOLPSOLTXHGHWRXWHIDoRQXQHKRPRSKRQLHVHFRQGDLUHHWODQHXWUDOLVD
WLRQG·XQHRSSRVLWLRQFDVXHOOH3RXUpOLPLQHUOHSUREOqPHFUppSDUXQHKRPRSKRQLHODODQJXHHQFUpHXQHDXWUH
MXJpHPRLQVJrQDQWH(QG·DXWUHVWHUPHVO·H[SUHVVLRQG·XQHGLVWLQFWLRQVHFRQGDLUHRXSpULSKpULTXHHVWVDFULILpH
jO·H[SUHVVLRQG·XQHGLVWLQFWLRQIRQGDPHQWDOHRXFHQWUDOHF·HVWODFLQTXLqPHORLGHO·DQDORJLHGH.XU\‫ן‬RZLF] :%"J%
TXLSRVHODTXHVWLRQGHODKLpUDUFKLHGHVRSSRVLWLRQVFDVXHOOHV&·HVWODUpIHFWLRQGHW\SH'TXLUHQGFRPSWHGH
ODGpVLQHQFHM!GXORFVLQJGHVWKqPHVFRQVRQDQWLTXHVHQVODYHQ/DGpVLQHQFHKpULWpH үIDLVDLWTXHOHORFVLQJ

O
-HUHSUHQGVLFLXQHW\SRORJLHVRPPDLUHTXHM·DLGpMjHXO·RFFDVLRQ :
.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]I
GHGUHVVHUDLOOHXUVFI/H)HXYUH Q
/H)HXYUH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% AQ3<B/7A87%H8%KQ<FF83*<*/,B%HQ7/B8B*/8NN8%8*%O/QK<K3O/8%H87%,@@,7/*/,B7%3<7\8NN87%8B%7N<T8% Q<@

pWDLWKRPRSKRQHGHO·DFFVLQJ ү үP HWGXQRPVLQJ ү үV 3RXUpOLPLQHUFHWWHKRPRSKRQLHHWUHVWDX

UHUXQHRSSRVLWLRQIRQGDPHQWDOH QRP DFF ORF ODODQJXHDUpDIIHFWpjO·H[SUHVVLRQGXORFVLQJODGpVLQHQFH
GHJpQVLQJ M! M!0 G·RXQHKRPRSKRQLHVHFRQGDLUHHQWUHJpQVLQJHWORFVLQJSDUDOOqOHjO·KRPRSKRQLHGH
FHVGHX[FDVGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQM#M%JK%JH%M1M/DQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQJpQORFDXSURILWGXPDUTXDJHGH
O·RSSRVLWLRQQRP DFF ORFVXSSRVHTXHODSUHPLqUHpWDLWKLpUDUFKLTXHPHQWLQIpULHXUHjODVHFRQGH
&HSURFHVVXVSRXUFRPSOH[HHWSHXpFRQRPLTXHTX·LOVRLWDpWpDVVH]ODUJHPHQWXWLOLVpSDUOHVODYHHWF·HVW
OjO·XQHGHVVSpFLILFLWpVGXVODYHTXLGRQQHjODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHXQDVSHFWXQLTXHSDUPLOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXUR
SpHQQHV'DQVO·pWDWPpFRQQDLVVDEOHRVHWURXYDLWOHV\VWqPHIOH[LRQQHOjODVXLWHGHVpYROXWLRQVSKRQpWLTXHV
GRQWRQDSDUOpODODQJXHDIDLWIOqFKHGHWRXWERLVVLO·RQSHXWGLUH2QO·pWXGLHUDLFLjWUDYHUVXQH[HPSOHFHOXL
GHODGLVWLQFWLRQHQWUHQRPVLQJHWDFFVLQJGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQM6M

M7+,;?A;<LA;G<+>:+<GC7+?;<N7+=A+>=+EO8LL7+?;<N7+>8<?+E=?+APBC=?+=<!"#"
M767+,;?A9;Q:A;G<+>=?+C89R:=?+DE=F;G<<=EE=?+=<+J;=:F+?E8J=
/DFKXWHGHVFRQVRQQHVILQDOHVDHQWUDvQpODFRQIXVLRQGXQRPVLQJHWGHO·DFFVLQJGDQVWRXVOHVW\SHVYRFD
OLTXHV WKqPHVHQM6M2%M#M2%M1M jO·H[FHSWLRQGHVWKqPHVHQM(M3RXUOHVWKqPHVHQM6MODFRQIXVLRQQHUpVXOWHSDV
VHXOHPHQWGHO·pYROXWLRQSKRQpWLTXHPDLVFHODLPSRUWHSHXLFL<2QSDUWLUDGXVWDGHRQRPVLQJHWDFFVLQJRQW
WRXVGHX[ODGpVLQHQFHȽjODTXHOOHFRUUHVSRQG%MᅄGDQVOHW\SHSDUDOOqOHHQMc6M W\SHPRX &HWWHKRPRSKRQLHHVW
FRQVHUYpHSRXUOHVPDVFXOLQVGpVLJQDQWGHVLQDQLPpVODIRUPHGHO·DFFHVWLGHQWLTXHjFHOOHGXQRPODGpVLQHQFH
J9K%ȽWMᅄGDQVOHVGHX[FDV YLHX[VODYHɥORY̍NȽZ$QRP@YLGLWȽ>9@JUDGȽZ&DFF@%´O·KRPPHYRLWODYLOOHµ R/HVPDVFXOLQV
LQDQLPpVRQWGRQFODPrPHFRQILJXUDWLRQDXVLQJXOLHUTXHOHVQHXWUHVF·HVWjGLUHXQHIRUPHXQLTXHSRXUOHQRP
HWO·DFF ODVLWXDWLRQHVWGLIIpUHQWHDXSOXULHO (QUHYDQFKHLOHQYDGLIIpUHPPHQWSRXUOHVVXEVWDQWLIVPDVFXOLQV
GpVLJQDQWGHVDQLPpVSRXUOHVTXHOVODIRUPHGHO·DFFRQOHVDLWHVWLGHQWLTXHQRQSDVjFHOOHGXQRPPDLVj
FHOOHGXJpQYLHX[VODYHɥORY̍NȽZ$QRP@YLGLWȽ>9@ɥORY̍NDZ&DFF@%´O·KRPPHYRLWO·KRPPHµDYHFODPrPHGpVLQHQFH%
M(%TXHGDQVYLGLWȽ>9@%.#4!%Z&DFF@ɥORY̍NDZ"KJpQ@%´LOYRLWOHYLVDJHGHO·KRPPHµDYHFXQJpQLWLIDGQRPLQDO&·HVWFH
TX·RQDSSHOOHOHJpQDFFTXLHVWXQHGHVIRUPHVGXPDUTXDJHGLIIpUHQWLHOGHO·REMHW
/HWDEOHDXFLGHVVRXVUpFDSLWXOHODGLVWULEXWLRQGHVPDUTXHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVHQYLHX[VODYH LOHVWLGHQWLTXHGDQV
OHVODQJXHVVODYHVPRGHUQHVjFHWWHGLIIpUHQFHSUqVTXHȽ%JK%MᅄVRQWUHSUpVHQWpVSDU‘ 

QRPVLQJ DFFVLQJLQDQLPp DFFVLQJDQLPp JpQVLQJ

WKqPHHQM6MPDVF Ƚ Ƚ M( M(

WKqPHHQMc6MPDVF Mᅄ Mᅄ M( M(

WKqPHHQM6MQHXW M6 M6 m M(

WKqPHHQMc6MQHXW M! M! m M(

&HWWHGLVWULEXWLRQQ·HVWSDVHQFRUHFRPSOqWHPHQWV\VWpPDWLVpHHQYLHX[VODYHRQOHVDLWHWG·DXWUHVFULWqUHV
LQWHUYLHQQHQWQRWDPPHQWOHFDUDFWqUHGpWHUPLQpRXQRQGXVXEVWDQWLIODIRUPHpW\PRORJLTXHG·DFFȽWMᅄ%J9K%JH%
JpQpUDOFRQVHUYpHSRXUOHVVXEVWDQWLIVDQLPpVQRQGpWHUPLQpVHWVHXOVOHVDQLPpVGpWHUPLQpVSUHQQHQWOHJpQ
DFF YLGLWȽɥORY̍ND´LOYRLWO·KRPPHµYLGLWȽɥORY̍NȽ´LOYRLWXQKRPPHµ ,O\DDXVVLGHVFULWqUHVVHFRQGDLUHVFRPPH
O·HPSORLSUpSRVLWLRQQHORXQRQOHJpQDFFpWDQWPRLQVIUpTXHQWGDQVOHVHPSORLVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOV2QFRQVWDWH
XQFHUWDLQIORWWHPHQWGDQVOHVWH[WHVYLHX[VODYHVDYHFSDUIRLVQRWDPPHQWGDQVOH71I-(0.#!)0#0XQHH[WHQVLRQ

<
-·DGPHWVTXHOHUpVXOWDWSKRQpWLTXHGH M60%JH%G8H6>J%J9K%M62%JK%HFH% R
/HVGpVLQHQFHVȽ%JK%MᅄVHVRQWDPXwHVHWVRQWUHSUpVHQWpHVSDU‘
UȽHWTXHODGpVLQHQFHGHQRPVLQJȽGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQM6M%J9K% GDQVOHVODQJXHVPRGHUQHVUXVVHPRGHUQHQRPVLQJ5ç-6"DFFVLQJ
DQDORJLTXHGXW\SHHQM1MRO·KRPRSKRQLHHQWUHQRPVLQJȽ ࠽V% 5ç-6"´YLOOHµ
HWDFFVLQJȽ ࠽QHVWSKRQpWLTXH RQUHYLHQGUDFLGHVVRXVVXUFH 
%RVVRQJ
SRLQW /DTXHVWLRQGXWUDLWHPHQWGH M60HQILQDOHHVWGLVSXWpHSRXU
OHVXQVOHWUDLWHPHQWSKRQpWLTXHHVWM62%=FL7%>J9%6LK7J9%Ƚ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3N</K8%N8%F8\TK8

GXJpQDFFDX[LQDQLPpV'DQVOHVODQJXHVVODYHVPRGHUQHVOHFULWqUHGpWHUPLQpQRQGpWHUPLQpDpWpDEDQGRQQp
HWVHXOOHFULWqUHDQLPpLQDQLPpV·HVWLPSRVp

M7!7+2;K989LP;=+9=E8A;J=+>=?+GHHG?;A;G<?+<GC7S8LL7+=A+8LL7SNK<7
/·pYROXWLRQSKRQpWLTXHD\DQWIDLWGLVSDUDvWUHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPDFFOHVODYHO·DUHVWDXUpH&RPPHODODQJXH
QHSRXYDLWSDVMRXHUVXUO·RUGUHGHVPRWVSXLVTXHFHOXLFLHVWOLEUHGDQVOHVODQJXHVVODYHVHOOHDUpDIIHFWpODGpVL
QHQFHG·XQDXWUHFDVjO·H[SUHVVLRQGHO·DFF/HFDVHQTXHVWLRQHVWOHJpQ/DODQJXHDGRQFQHXWUDOLVpO·RSSRVLWLRQ
DFFJpQSRXUDVVXUHUOHPDUTXDJHGHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPDFFTXLDSSDUDvWSDUOjPrPHFRPPHKLpUDUFKLTXHPHQW
VXSpULHXUH
/HIDLWTXHO·RSSRVLWLRQDFFJpQQHVRLWDLQVLQHXWUDOLVpHTXHSRXUOHVDQLPpVHWQRQSRXUOHVLQDQLPpVQH
VLJQLILHSDVTXHODKLpUDUFKLHGHVGHX[RSSRVLWLRQVHVWGLIIpUHQWHSRXUOHVLQDQLPpVODKLpUDUFKLHGHVRSSRVLWLRQV
FDVXHOOHVQ·HVWSDVjJpRPpWULHYDULDEOH&HODVLJQLILHVLPSOHPHQWTXHFHWWHKLpUDUFKLHQ·HVWSDVPDWpULDOLVpHGH
ODPrPHPDQLqUHGDQVOHVGHX[FDVHWTX·HOOHGpSHQGG·XQFULWqUHVpPDQWLTXHODVpOHFWLRQGXFULWqUH´DQLPpµ
HQWUDvQHODQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQDFFJpQDXSURILWGXPDUTXDJHGHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPDFFKLpUDUFKL
TXHPHQWVXSpULHXUHODKLpUDUFKLHVWUXFWXUHOOHHVWPDWpULDOLVpHPRUSKRORJLTXHPHQWGDQVODVWUXFWXUHGHVXUIDFH
HOOHHVWGRQFYLVLEOH(QUHYDQFKHHQO·DEVHQFHGHVpOHFWLRQGXFULWqUH´DQLPpµLOQ·\DSDVGHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQHWOD
SULPDXWpVWUXFWXUHOOHGHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPDFFVXUO·RSSRVLWLRQDFFJpQQHUHoRLWSDVG·H[SUHVVLRQPRUSKROR
JLTXHGDQVODVWUXFWXUHGHVXUIDFHODKLpUDUFKLHHVWGRQFLQYLVLEOHPDLVQ·HQHVWSDVPRLQVUpHOOH
5HVWHjH[SOLTXHUOHVUDLVRQVGHFHFRPSRUWHPHQWGLIIpUHQWGHVDQLPpVHWGHVLQDQLPpVHWODPDQLqUHGRQWOH
VODYHHVWSDUYHQXjODGLVWULEXWLRQHIIHFWLYHPHQWDWWHVWpH

M7M7+#89R:8N=+>=+EO8<;CK
/DGLVWLQFWLRQDJHQWSDWLHQWHVWIRQGDPHQWDOHSRXUOHVDQLPpVPDLVPRLQVSRXUOHVLQDQLPpVTXLVRQWUDUH
PHQWDJHQWV6DQVHQWUHUGDQVOHGpWDLOGHODTXHVWLRQG·XQVWDGHHUJDWLISRXUXQHSKDVHDUFKDwTXHGHO·LQGR
HXURSpHQMHPHOLPLWHUDLjTXHOTXHVUHPDUTXHVVXUODGLVWULEXWLRQGHVPDUTXHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVWHOOHTX·HOOHHVW
UpFDSLWXOpHGDQVOHWDEOHDXFLGHVVRXV

VXMHWDJHQWLI% VXMHWQRQDJHQWLI% SDWLHQWQRQDQLPp SDWLHQWDQLPp

DQLPp DQLPpRXQRQ
J7I6K8G
 ; ; ;
VXMHWQRQQHXWUH VXMHWQHXWUH REMHWQHXWUH REMHWQRQQHXWUH
QRPDFF%
DJHQWLIRXQRQ
LQGRHXURSpHQW\SH
WKpPDWLTXH M0 M> M> M>

QRPDFFVODYH VXMHWDQLPp VXMHWLQDQLPp REMHWLQDQLPp REMHWDQLPp

PDVFL>8H M6M% Ƚ Ƚ Ƚ M(%

PDVFXOLQ Mc6M% M ᅄ% M ᅄ% M ᅄ% M(%
HJLK7J M6M% m% M6% M6% m%
HJLK7J Mc6M m M! M! m

6FKpPDWLTXHPHQWGDQVXQV\VWqPHHUJDWLIOHPDUTXDJHRSSRVHO·DJHQW TXLHVWWRXMRXUVDQLPp jWRXWOH

UHVWH VXMHWQRQDJHQWLIDQLPpRXLQDQLPpSDWLHQWDQLPpRXLQDQLPp /HVDQLPpVTXLSHXYHQWrWUHDJHQWVDXVVL
ELHQTXHQRQDJHQWVVRQWGRQFVXVFHSWLEOHVG·DYRLUGHX[IRUPHVOHVLQDQLPpVDXFRQWUDLUHTXLQHSHXYHQWrWUH
DJHQWVPDLVVHXOHPHQWSDWLHQWVRXVXMHWVG·XQSURFqVQRQDJHQWLIQ·RQWTX·XQHVHXOHIRUPH'DQVOHV\VWqPH
QRPDFFGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQRODGLVWULEXWLRQVHIDLWHQIRQFWLRQG·XQFULWqUHV\QWD[LTXH VXMHWREMHW HWQRQ
G·XQFULWqUHVpPDQWLTXH DJHQWQRQDJHQW RQUHWURXYHXQHGLVWULEXWLRQVHPEODEOHSRXUOHW\SHWKpPDWLTXHDX
VLQJXOLHUOHPDUTXDJHRSSRVHOHVXMHWDQLPp GpVLQHQFH M0 jWRXWOHUHVWH VXMHWQRQDQLPpREMHWQRQDQLPp
REMHWDQLPpGpVLQHQFH M> /HVDQLPpV QRQQHXWUHV RSSRVHQWGHX[IRUPHVOjROHVLQDQLPpV QHXWUHV RQW
XQHIRUPHXQLTXHTXLVHWURXYHrWUHODPrPHTXHODIRUPHG·REMHWDQLPpOHVFKpPDFRUUHVSRQGGRQFHQJURVj
FHOXLG·XQHODQJXHjHUJDWLI/HSUREOqPHRQOHVDLWHVWTXHGDQVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVODFDWpJRULHGHV
QHXWUHVFRUUHVSRQGELHQDX[LQDQLPpVPDLVODFDWpJRULHGHVQRQQHXWUHVFRPSUHQGQRQVHXOHPHQWGHVDQLPpV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% AQ3<B/7A87%H8%KQ<FF83*<*/,B%HQ7/B8B*/8NN8%8*%O/QK<K3O/8%H87%,@@,7/*/,B7%3<7\8NN87%8B%7N<T8% Q<P

PDLVDXVVLGHVLQDQLPpVSDUFHTXHOHJHQUHJUDPPDWLFDODIDLWDVVLJQHUOHJHQUHPDVFXOLQRXIpPLQLQjGHVLQDQL
PpVODGLVWLQFWLRQGHJHQUHQ·HVWGRQFSDVIRQFWLRQGXVHXOFULWqUHVpPDQWLTXHTXLFRQVWLWXHOHQR\DXGXV\VWqPH
DQLPpLQDQLPp PDLVVHIDLWDXVVLHQIRQFWLRQG·XQFULWqUHPRUSKRORJLTXH
'DQVOHW\SHWKpPDWLTXHHQVODYHQRPVLQJHWDFFVLQJVRQWGHYHQXVKRPRSKRQHV/DQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGH
O·RSSRVLWLRQQRPDFFSRXUOHVLQDQLPpVHVWDQFLHQQHHWLQVFULWHGDQVODVWUXFWXUHPRUSKRORJLTXHGHVODQJXHV
LQGRHXURSpHQQHVF·HVWFHOOHTXLGpILQLWODFDWpJRULHJUDPPDWLFDOHGXQHXWUH(QUHYDQFKHO·KRPRSKRQLHHVW
JrQDQWHSRXUOHVDQLPpVTXLVHGpILQLVVHQWSDUOHIDLWTX·LOVRSSRVHQWGHX[IRUPHV DJHQWQRQDJHQWGDQVXQ
V\VWqPHHUJDWLIVXMHWREMHWGDQVXQV\VWqPHQRPDFF /HVODYHHQUpWDEOLVVDQWODGLIIpUHQFHHQWUHQRPHWDFF
SRXUOHVVHXOVDQLPpVHWHQWROpUDQWO·KRPRSKRQLHSRXUOHVLQDQLPpVUHFHQWUHHQIDLWOHV\VWqPHVXUVRQQR\DX
VpPDQWLTXHRVHXOOHFULWqUHDQLPpLQDQLPpGpWHUPLQHODIRUPHGXPRW/HFULWqUHVpPDQWLTXHSULPHGRQFVXU
OHFULWqUHPRUSKRORJLTXHVLOHFULWqUHPRUSKRORJLTXHO·HPSRUWDLWRQDXUDLWXQHRSSRVLWLRQV\VWpPDWLTXHQRP
DFFSRXUWRXVOHVPDVFXOLQVDQLPpVRXQRQ0DLVGDQVFHWWHORJLTXHRQV·DWWHQGUDLWjXQHGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQGHV
IRUPHVSDUXQPDUTXDJHVSpFLILTXHGXVXMHWDQLPpSXLVTXHVXLYDQWOHFULWqUHVpPDQWLTXHO·RSSRVLWLRQSDVVHHQWUH
VXMHWDQLPp DJHQW HWWRXWOHUHVWH2UFHQ·HVWSDVFHTXLV·HVWSDVVpHQVODYHODIRUPHPDUTXpHHVWQRQSDVOH
VXMHWPDLVO·REMHWDQLPpTXLV·RSSRVHjWRXWOHUHVWH VXMHWDQLPpVXMHWLQDQLPpREMHWLQDQLPpGpVLQHQFHȽWMᅄ 
'XSRLQWGHYXHGHODGLVWULEXWLRQGHVPDUTXHVPRUSKRORJLTXHVOHVODYHSUpVHQWHXQV\VWqPHTXLHVWXQHVRUWH
G·HUJDWLILQYHUVpSRXUDLQVLGLUH@

M7"7+#KL8<;?C=+>=+E8+9K8DD=LA8A;G<
8QHGHVFDUDFWpULVWLTXHVV\QWD[LTXHVGXVODYHHVWFHTX·RQDSSHOOHOHJpQLWLIGHQpJDWLRQGDQVXQHSKUDVH
QpJDWLYHWRXWFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWHVWDXJpQHWQRQjO·DFF YLHX[VODYHQHYLGLWȽɥORY̍ND´LOQHYRLWSDVO·KRPPHµ
PDVFDQLPpFRPPHQHYLGLWȽJUDGD´LOQHYRLWSDVODYLOOHµPDVFLQDQLPpFRPPHQHYLGLWȽOLFD´LOQHYRLWSDVOH
YLVDJHµQHXW (QSKUDVHQpJDWLYHO·RSSRVLWLRQDFFJpQHVWGRQFQHXWUDOLVpHSRXUWRXVOHVW\SHVIOH[LRQQHOV
LOQ·\DDXFXQHSRVVLELOLWpGHFKRL[HQWUHO·DFFHWOHJpQGDQVFHFRQWH[WH/DSKUDVHQpJDWLYHDSSDUDvWGRQF
FRPPHXQFDWDO\VHXUF·HVWjGLUHXQFRQWH[WHTXLSHUPHWODUpLQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHODGpVLQHQFHSXLVTXHO·RSSRVL
WLRQFDVXHOOH\HVWQHXWUDOLVpH'DQVOHVH[HPSOHVSUpFpGHQWVOHVIRUPHVɥORY̍NDJUDGDSHXYHQWrWUHLQWHUSUpWpHV
FRPPHGHVDFFSXLVTX·HOOHVVRQWFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWHWTXHOHXUFRUUHVSRQGHQSKUDVHQRQQpJDWLYHXQDFF
FRPSOpPHQWG·REMHW YLGLWȽJUDGȽ´LOYRLWODYLOOHµ /DGpVLQHQFHM(SHXWGRQFrWUHDQDO\VpHFRPPHXQDOORPRUSKH
GHODGpVLQHQFHG·DFFȽDOORPRUSKHLGHQWLTXHjODGpVLQHQFHGHJpQpWDQWGRQQpTX·LOV·DJLWGHODGpVLQHQFH
GHJpQjO·RULJLQH/DODQJXHDDORUVpWHQGXFHWDOORPRUSKHKRUVGHVRQFRQWH[WHLQLWLDO ODSKUDVHQpJDWLYH HQ
OXLDVVLJQDQWXQHQRXYHOOHIRQFWLRQTXLpWDLWGHPDUTXHUO·DFFHQSKUDVHQRQQpJDWLYHSDURSSRVLWLRQDXQRP
SRXUOHVDQLPpV SRXUOHVTXHOVODGLVWLQFWLRQHVWIRQGDPHQWDOH (WO·RQFRPSUHQGGqVORUVSRXUTXRLODPDUTXH
PRUSKRORJLTXHHVWSRUWpHSDUO·DFFHWQRQSDUOHQRPFRPPHODVWUXFWXUHGXV\VWqPHOHIHUDLWDWWHQGUH&·HVW
SDUFHTXHGDQVOHFRQWH[WHFDWDO\VHXU JpQGHQpJDWLRQ O·RSSRVLWLRQQHXWUDOLVpHpWDLWDFFJpQHWQRQQRP
JpQHWTXHOHFRQWH[WH JpQDFFDQLPp GpSHQGGXFRQWH[WH/DQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGDQVOHFRQWH[WHFDWDO\VHXU
HVWGpWHUPLQpHSDUXQFULWqUHV\QWD[LTXH ODQpJDWLRQ WDQGLVTXHGDQVOHFRQWH[WHHOOHHVWGpWHUPLQpHSDUXQ
FULWqUHVpPDQWLTXH OHFDUDFWqUHDQLPp /DQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGDQVOHFRQWH[WH JpQGHQpJDWLRQ QHGRQQHDXFXQ
UHQVHLJQHPHQWVXUODKLpUDUFKLHGHVRSSRVLWLRQVFDVXHOOHVFRQWUDLUHPHQWjODQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGDQVOHFRQWH[WH
JpQDFFDQLPp ROHPDUTXDJHG·XQHRSSRVLWLRQ DFFJpQ HVWVDFULILpDXPDUTXDJHG·XQHDXWUHRSSRVLWLRQ
QRPDFF FHTXLpWDEOLWFODLUHPHQWODKLpUDUFKLH

@
2QUHWURXYHGHVIDLWVVLPLODLUHVGDQVG·DXWUHVODQJXHVLQGRHXUR
SpHQQHVOHWRNKDULHQDXQHIRUPHVSpFLILTXHSRXUO·DFFGHVQRPV
WKpPDWLTXHVGpVLJQDQWGHVKXPDLQVWDQGLVTXHSRXUOHVDXWUHVVXEV
WDQWLIVODIRUPHG·DFF REOLTXH HVWLGHQWLTXHjODIRUPHGHQRP
FIO·DUWLFOHGH*-3LQDXOWGDQVFHUHFXHLO /HFULWqUHLFLHVWSOXV
UHVWULFWLITX·HQVODYH KXPDLQQRQKXPDLQYVDQLPpLQDQLPpPDLV
HQVODYHjGDWHDQFLHQQHODFDWpJRULHDQLPpQHFRPSUHQGHIIHFWLYH
PHQWTXHGHVKXPDLQVHWOHVQRPVG·DQLPDX[Q·\VRQWSDVLQFOXV 
2QFRPSDUHUDDXVVLOHFDVGHO·HVSDJQROROHFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHW
KXPDLQDXQHPDUTXHVSpFLILTXHTXLHVWODSUpSRVLWLRQ(DLQVLTXH
OHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHVSRXUO·REMHWHQURXPDLQHWHQ
DUPpQLHQ7RXVFHVIDLWVVRQWUHJURXSpVVRXVO·DSSHOODWLRQGH´PDU
TXDJHGLIIpUHQWLHOGHO·REMHWµFI%RVVRQJHW7RXWHIRLV
O·H[WHQVLRQGXSKpQRPqQHHVWGLIIpUHQWHODFRQVWUXFWLRQSUpSRVL
WLRQQHOOHSRXUOHFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWKXPDLQHQHVSDJQROQ·HVWSDV
OLPLWpHjXQHFDWpJRULHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHWDQGLVTX·HQYLHX[VODYH
OHJpQLWLIDFFXVDWLIQHFRQFHUQHTXHOHPDVFXOLQVLQJXOLHUHWQRQOH
SOXULHOQLOHIpPLQLQHWVHXOHPHQWSRXUOHW\SHWKpPDWLTXH/HJpQL
WLIDFFXVDWLIHVWGRQFPRUSKRORJLTXHPHQWFRQGLWLRQQp/HVODQJXHV
VODYHVGpYHORSSHURQWSDUODVXLWHODFDWpJRULHGHO·DQLPpHQO·pWHQ
GDQWDXPDVFXOLQSOXULHOYRLUHDXIpPLQLQSOXULHOHQVODYHRULHQWDO
HWHQGpYHORSSDQWSRXUFHUWDLQHVXQPDUTXDJHGLIIpUHQWLHOGXVXMHW
FI%RVVRQJ² 

'LDFKURQLTXHPHQWOHJpQLWLIGHQpJDWLRQUHSUpVHQWHXQHH[WHQVLRQ
G·HPSORLG·XQDQFLHQJpQLWLISDUWLWLI
 oi.uchicago.edu

QR?% 3N</K8%N8%F8\TK8

/HPDUTXDJHGHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPDFFVHIDLWGRQFDXSUL[G·XQHSHUWHG·LQIRUPDWLRQSXLVTX·LOLPSOLTXHOD
QHXWUDOLVDWLRQG·XQHDXWUHRSSRVLWLRQFDVXHOOHDFFJpQ&·HVWVDQVGRXWHXQHGHVUDLVRQVSRXUOHVTXHOOHVOHJpQ
DFFHVWUHVWpOLPLWpDX[DQLPpVSRXUOHVDQLPpVOHJDLQTXHUHSUpVHQWDLWODUHVWDXUDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRP
DFFpWDLWVXSpULHXUjODSHUWHTXHUHSUpVHQWDLWODQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQDFFJpQ(QUHYDQFKHSRXUOHV
LQDQLPpVOHJDLQQ·pWDLWSDVVXSpULHXUjODSHUWHHWOHQRXYHDXPDUTXDJHGHVFDVQHV·HVWSDVLPSODQWpGDQVOHV
LQDQLPpV
/DUpIHFWLRQGHW\SH'SURFqGHWRXMRXUVDLQVLjSDUWLUG·XQFRQWH[WHRXQHRSSRVLWLRQFDVXHOOHHVWQHXWUDOLVpH
TXHOOHTX·HQVRLWODUDLVRQODGRXEOHSRVVLELOLWpG·DQDO\VHSHUPHWXQHUpLQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHODGpVLQHQFHHWGRQQH
QDLVVDQFHjXQDOORPRUSKHTXLSHXWHQVXLWHrWUHUpDIIHFWp&HWWHQRWLRQGHFRQWH[WHFDWDO\VHXUHVWIRQGDPHQWDOH
F·HVWODFRQGLWLRQSUHPLqUHG·XQHUpIHFWLRQGHFHW\SHP
/DGHX[LqPHFRQGLWLRQG·XQHUpIHFWLRQGHFHW\SHHVWO·H[LVWHQFHG·XQPRGqOHVXUOHTXHOODQRXYHOOHVWUXFWXUH
SHXWV·DSSX\HUF·HVWjGLUHGDQVOHFDVGXJpQDFFGHVFDVRO·RQWURXYHXQJpQHQIRQFWLRQGHFRPSOpPHQW
G·REMHWHQSKUDVHQRQQpJDWLYH,O\DHQVODYHGHX[PRGqOHVGDQVOHVTXHOVRQDFKHUFKpO·RULJLQHGXJpQDFF
/HSUHPLHUHVWIRXUQLSDUOHVYHUEHVTXLUpJLVVHQWOHJpQLWLIFRQVWUXFWLRQGDQVODTXHOOHRQDGRQFXQJpQLWLI
FRPSOpPHQWGHYHUEHFRPPHWU̍ERYDWLJpQ´DYRLUEHVRLQGHµG·R´H[LJHUµ0.1k($#%JpQ´pFRXWHUµO?%&H%6%D8JH%
GDQVFHFDVXQHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQDFFJpQFRQGLWLRQQpHSDUOHOH[qPHYHUEDO&HPRGqOHHVWLQVXI
ILVDQWSRXUUHQGUHFRPSWHGXJpQDFFDQLPpSDUFHTXHOHFRQGLWLRQQHPHQWOH[LFDOVWULFWSHUPHWWUDLWO·H[WHQVLRQ
GHODFRQVWUXFWLRQjTXHOTXHVDXWUHVOH[qPHVPDLVSDVjXQXVDJHWRWDOHPHQWLQGpSHQGDQWGXOH[qPHYHUEDO
FRPPHO·HVWOHJpQDFF/HVHFRQGPRGqOHHVWO·XVDJHDQFLHQHWKpULWpGXJpQSDUWLWLIYLHX[VODYHɥORY̍NȽMDVWȽ[O̍EȽ%
´O·KRPPHPDQJHOHSDLQµ ȽDFF ɥORY̍NȽMDVWȽ[O̍ED´O·KRPPHPDQJHGXSDLQµ M(JpQ TXLIRXUQLWXQH[HPSOH
GHIRUPHGHJpQHQIRQFWLRQGHFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWHQSKUDVHQRQQpJDWLYHOO0DLVODVWUXFWXUHHVWGLIIpUHQWH
OHJpQSDUWLWLIQHUHSUpVHQWHSDVXQFDVGHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQDFFJpQDXFRQWUDLUHOHIDLWTX·RQ
WURXYHHWODIRUPHG·DFFHWODIRUPHGHJpQGDQVOHPrPHFRQWH[WHHWSRXUXQPrPHOH[qPH [O̍EȽ´SDLQµGDQV
O·H[HPSOHFRQVLGpUp HWTXHODODQJXHDLWOHFKRL[HQWUHOHVGHX[LQGLTXHTXHFHWWHRSSRVLWLRQHVWSUpJQDQWH
HOOHH[SULPHXQHRSSRVLWLRQVpPDQWLTXH$XFRQWUDLUHSRXUOHJpQDFFDQLPpLO\DELHQQHXWUDOLVDWLRQHWLOHVW
H[FOXTXHODODQJXHDLWOHFKRL[HQWUHODIRUPHHQȽ%JK%>6%GF7MJ%JH%M(SRXUXQPrPHOH[qPHVLOHPRWDSSDUWLHQW
jODFDWpJRULH´DQLPpµRQDXUDDXWRPDWLTXHPHQWODIRUPHHQM(VLOHPRWDSSDUWLHQWjODFDWpJRULH´LQDQLPpµRQ
DXUDDXWRPDWLTXHPHQWODIRUPHHQȽᅄ2HWOHVGHX[QHSHXYHQWV·RSSRVHUSRXUXQOH[qPHGRQQpGDQVOHVODQJXHV
VODYHVPRGHUQHV/HJpQSDUWLWLIIRXUQLWGRQFXQHVWUXFWXUHHQDSSDUHQFHVLPLODLUH IRUPHGHJpQHQIRQFWLRQ
GHFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHW PDLVHQUpDOLWpGLIIpUHQWHSXLVTXHOHJpQSDUWLWLIQ·HVWSDVXQFDVGHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGH
O·RSSRVLWLRQDFFJpQODTXHOOHFRQVHUYHVDSOHLQHYDOHXU&·HVWSRXUTXRLLOQHVDXUDLWVXIILUHjH[SOLTXHUOHJpQ
DFFG·DXWDQWTX·LO\DXQHLQFRPSDWLELOLWpVpPDQWLTXHHQWUHOHVGHX[OHJpQSDUWLWLIpWDQWSDUGpILQLWLRQH[FOX
SRXUOHVDQLPpVHWSRVVLEOHVHXOHPHQWSRXUOHVLQDQLPpV
3RXUUHQGUHFRPSWHGXJpQDFFDQLPpLOIDXWFRPELQHUOHFRQWH[WHFDWDO\VHXU OHJpQLWLIGHQpJDWLRQR
ODQHXWUDOLVDWLRQHVWLQGpSHQGDQWHGHVFULWqUHVOH[LFDOHWVpPDQWLTXH HWOHVGHX[PRGqOHV OHJpQSDUWLWLIHWOH
KE=J%WU̍ERYDWLVOXߖDWLJpQ GRQWDXFXQQHVXIILWjOXLVHXOjUHQGUHFRPSWHGXJpQDFFDQLPp&·HVWSDUFHTXH
O·RSSRVLWLRQDFFJpQHVWQHXWUDOLVpHGDQVXQFRQWH[WHGRQQpTXHODGpVLQHQFHSHXWrWUHUpLQWHUSUpWpHG·DSUqV
XQDXWUHPRGqOH

"7+18+?GE:A;G<+>:+J;=:F+<GJNG9G>;=<
2QWURXYHXQHVROXWLRQGLIIpUHQWHjFHPrPHSUREOqPHGHODGLVWLQFWLRQQRPDFFGDQVXQGLDOHFWHYLHX[
UXVVHOHGLDOHFWHGH1RYJRURGO:/·RSSRVLWLRQQRPDFF\DpJDOHPHQWpWpUHVWDXUpHGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQM6M2%>J%
QRPVLQJDODGpVLQHQFHM!O·DFFVLQJODGpVLQHQFHȽ/DGpVLQHQFHGHQRPVLQJM!HVWXQLTXHGDQVOHGRPDLQH

P
/HFDWDO\VHXUGDQVO·H[HPSOHGXJpQDFFHVWV\QWD[LTXHPDLVLO
SHXWDXVVLrWUHG·XQDXWUHRUGUHSDUH[HPSOHOH[LFDOFRPPHF·HVW
OHFDVSRXUODGpVLQHQFHGHORFVLQJGHVWKqPHVFRQVRQDQWLTXHVFI
/H)HXYUHI
O?
%168>>6HK2%D3N7FRQVLGqUHTXHODVRXUFHGXJpQDFFDQLPpHVW
jFKHUFKHUGDQVFHW\SHGHFRQVWUXFWLRQHWUHMHWWHO·H[SOLFDWLRQSDU
OHJpQSDUWLWLITXLHVWO·K\SRWKqVHODSOXVFRXUDQWH
OO
&RPULHDSUqVG·DXWUHVFRQVLGqUHTXHOHJpQSDUWLWLIHVWOD
VRXUFHGXJpQDFFDQLPp
O:
/HYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQHVWFRQQXHVVHQWLHOOHPHQWSDUOHVGRFXPHQWV
VXUpFRUFHGHERXOHDXWURXYpVj1RYJRURGHWGDQVGHVORFDOLWpVYRL
VLQHV/HVWH[WHVV·pFKHORQQHQWHQWUHOH;,J¬HWOH;9J¬VLqFOHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% AQ3<B/7A87%H8%KQ<FF83*<*/,B%HQ7/B8B*/8NN8%8*%O/QK<K3O/8%H87%,@@,7/*/,B7%3<7\8NN87%8B%7N<T8% QRO

VODYHHOOHQHVHUHWURXYHGDQVDXFXQDXWUHGLDOHFWHHWF·HVWODFDUDFWpULVWLTXHPRUSKRORJLTXHODSOXVVDLOODQWHGX
YLHX[QRYJRURGLHQ

"767+,;?A9;Q:A;G<+>=?+C89R:=?+DE=F;G<<=EE=?+=<+J;=:F+<GJNG9G>;=<
/HWDEOHDXFLGHVVRXVUpFDSLWXOHODGLVWULEXWLRQGHVPDUTXHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQM6M%JK%JH%Mc6M W\SH
WKpPDWLTXHLQGRHXURSpHQ HQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQ

QRPVLQJ DFFVLQJLQDQLPp DFFVLQJDQLPp JpQVLQJ

WKqPHHQM6MPDVF "$ Ƚ ȽWM(%Z GpWHUPLQp@ M(
WKqPHHQMc6MPDVF Mᅄ Mᅄ ᅄWM(%Z GpWHUPLQp@ M(
WKqPHHQM6MQHXW M6 M6 ³ M(
WKqPHHQMc6MQHXW M! M! ³ M(

&RPPHRQOHYRLWODGLVWLQFWLRQHVWLQGpSHQGDQWHGXFULWqUHVpPDQWLTXHODGLVWLQFWLRQQRP M!lDFFȽ
FRQFHUQHDXVVLELHQOHVDQLPpVTXHOHVLQDQLPpV3DUDLOOHXUVOHV\VWqPHGXYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQFRQQDvWDXVVLOH
JpQDFFGDQVOHVPrPHVFRQGLWLRQVTXHOHUHVWHGXVODYHF·HVWjGLUHTXHO·DFFPDVFDGHX[DOORPRUSKHVM( LGHQ
WLTXHDXJpQ HWȽ TXLQHVHFRQIRQGSDVDYHFOHQRPTXLHVWHQM! /HV\VWqPHFRPELQHGRQFGHX[RSSRVLWLRQV
XQHRSSRVLWLRQPRUSKRORJLTXHV\VWpPDWLTXHQRP M! DFF Ƚ DYHFXQHRSSRVLWLRQVpPDQWLTXHDFFDQLPp M( 
DFFLQDQLPp Ƚ OjROHUHVWHGXVODYHQ·DTX·XQHVHXOHRSSRVLWLRQVpPDQWLTXH(QYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQOHVGHX[
RSSRVLWLRQVQHVRQWSDVVXUOHPrPHSODQSXLVTXHODSUHPLqUHHVWPRUSKRORJLTXHHWODVHFRQGHVpPDQWLTXHHW
QHVRQWGRQFSDVUHGRQGDQWHV
2QFRQVWDWHWRXWHIRLVTX·HQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQOHJpQDFFDQLPpHVWPRLQVIUpTXHQWTX·DLOOHXUVODIRUPHpW\
PRORJLTXHG·DFFȽHVWELHQSOXVIUpTXHQWHTXHODIRUPHHQM(GDQVOHVWH[WHVGHV;,JHW;,,JVLqFOHV2QLQWHUSUqWH
G·RUGLQDLUHFHIDLWFRPPHODPDUTXHG·XQUHWDUGGDQVOHGpYHORSSHPHQWGXJpQDFFDQLPpHQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQ
OHGLDOHFWHGLVSRVDQWGpMjG·XQHGLVWLQFWLRQV\VWpPDWLTXHHQWUHQRPVLQJHWDFFVLQJQ·DXUDLWSDVHXDXWDQWEHVRLQ
GXJpQDFF0DLVHQIDLWOHVGHX[RSSRVLWLRQVGXYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQQHVRQWSDVVXUOHPrPHSODQHWQHVRQWGRQF
SDVHQFRQFXUUHQFHGLUHFWH FLGHVVXV 3DUDLOOHXUVO·HPSORLGXJpQDFFGpSHQGGHGHX[FULWqUHVOHFULWqUHDQLPp
LQDQLPpG·XQHSDUWPDLVDXVVLOHFULWqUHGpWHUPLQpLQGpWHUPLQpXQVXEVWDQWLIDQLPpLQGpWHUPLQpQHSUHQGSDV
OHJpQDFFTXLHVWUpVHUYpDX[VXEVWDQWLIVDQLPpVGpWHUPLQpV FLGHVVXV† 2ULOVHWURXYHTXHOHVH[HPSOHV
VXVFHSWLEOHVGHSUpVHQWHUXQJpQDFFIRQWLQWHUYHQLUPDMRULWDLUHPHQWGHVVXEVWDQWLIVQRQGpWHUPLQpVRQDGRQF
VXUWRXWGHVDFFHQȽPrPHSRXUOHVDQLPpVSDUFHTXHOHFULWqUHGHODGpWHUPLQDWLRQQ·HVWSDVUHPSOL/DUHODWLYH
UDUHWpGXJpQDFFHQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQWLHQWGRQFDYDQWWRXWjODQDWXUHGXFRUSXVTXLIDLWTX·RQDSHXGHIRUPHV
GpWHUPLQpHV8QH[HPSOHFODLUHQHVWIRXUQLSDUO·pFRUFHGHERXOHDXQR GHX[LqPHPRLWLpGX;,J¬ VLqFOH R
O·RQDUpJXOLqUHPHQWOHQRPHQM! ]DPȽNH´YHUURXµ HWRILJXUHXQJpQDFFI-6"(c%=.!?!$ᅄ)#=(%$656´SXQLVG·XQH
DPHQGHFHWDFFXVDWHXUµDYHFVXEVWDQWLIGpWHUPLQp GpPRQVWUDWLI$656 FHTXLPRQWUHELHQTXHOHVGHX[RSSRVL
WLRQVFRH[LVWHQWGDQVOHPrPHpWDWGHODQJXHGqVOHVSUHPLHUVWH[WHV0rPHVLOHJpQDFFV·HVWGpYHORSSpPRLQV
UDSLGHPHQWHQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQLODSSDUWLHQWDXV\VWqPHGXGLDOHFWHGqVOHVSUHPLqUHVDWWHVWDWLRQVGHFHGHUQLHU
&HSHQGDQWOHQRPHQM!%DXQHH[WHQVLRQOLPLWpHDX[WKqPHVHQM6M% W\SHGXU HWLOQ·H[LVWHSDVGDQVOHVWKqPHV
JH%Mc6M W\SHPRX SRXUOHVTXHOVODGpVLQHQFHGHQRPHVWKRPRSKRQHGHFHOOHG·DFF Mᅄ 'DQVOHVWKqPHVHQMc6M2%>6%
VHXOHPDQLqUHGHGLIIpUHQFLHUQRPHWDFFHVWO·HPSORLGXJpQDFFGRQFODGLVWLQFWLRQQ·HVWSRVVLEOHTXHSRXUOHV
DQLPpVFRPPHHQYLHX[VODYH2QDGRQFHQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQXQV\VWqPHGLVV\PpWULTXHRVHXOXQVRXVW\SH
OHW\SHGXUWKqPHVHQM6M DXQHGLVWLQFWLRQV\VWpPDWLTXHLQGpSHQGDQWHGXFULWqUHVpPDQWLTXH7RXWHH[SOLFDWLRQ
GXQRPHQM!%GRLWpJDOHPHQWUHQGUHFRPSWHGHFHWWHGLVV\PpWULH

"7!7+2@HGAPB?=?+H9GHG?K=?+HG:9+E=+<GC7+=<+"$
2QDSURSRVpSOXVLHXUVK\SRWKqVHVSRXUO·RULJLQHGHODGpVLQHQFHM!GXQRP,OHVWGHWRXWHIDoRQFHUWDLQTXH
FHWWHGpVLQHQFHHVWUpFHQWHHWQHUHSUpVHQWHSDVXQKpULWDJHGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQ,OQ·\DSDVGHSDODWDOLVDWLRQGDQV
OHVWKqPHVHQYpODLUH]DPȽNH´YHUURXµGDQVO·pFRUFHGHERXOHDXQR¬DXQHYpODLUHGHYDQWM!FHTXLLQGLTXHTXH
O·LQWURGXFWLRQGHM!DXQRPVLQJHVWSRVWpULHXUHjODSUHPLqUHSDODWDOLVDWLRQ VDQVTXRLRQDXUDLW ]DPȽɥH 6LO·RQ
VXLWODFKURQRORJLHSURSRVpHSDU6KHYHORYOQODSUHPLqUHSDODWDOLVDWLRQGHVYpODLUHVGDWHGHV9J;1*J¬VLqFOHVGRQF
O·LQWURGXFWLRQGHM!DXQRPVLQJPDVFGXW\SHGXUQHVDXUDLWrWUHDQWpULHXUHDX9,J¬VLqFOHO<
 oi.uchicago.edu

QR:% 3N</K8%N8%F8\TK8

(QFRQVpTXHQFHOHVK\SRWKqVHVSURSRVpHVSRXUODGpVLQHQFHM!TXL\YRLHQWXQHIRUPHDQFLHQQH 4(010%(&06M
.1$10F·HVWjGLUHIRUPHjGpVLQHQFH]pURDUFKDwTXHRXpYROXWLRQSKRQpWLTXHDGKRFGH M60HQILQDOHjGDWHSUp
KLVWRULTXH QHSHXYHQWrWUHUHWHQXHV/DGpVLQHQFHGXYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQQ·DULHQG·DQFLHQ
5HVWHQWGRQFGHX[K\SRWKqVHVODSUHPLqUHSURSRVpHSDU:9HUPHHUORHWjODTXHOOHVHVRQWUDOOLpVSOXVLHXUV
VDYDQWVHVWTXHOHQRPVLQJHQM!HVWODGpVLQHQFHpW\PRORJLTXHGHVWKqPHVHQMc6MF·HVWjGLUHGXW\SHPRX
9F8K%UMc60¢%X%UMc!HQILQDOH$O·RULJLQHOHW\SHGXUDYDLW M60g%X%UM6g%JH%G8H6>J2%JK%>J%KE=J%MFL%UMc60g%X%UMc!'DQV
WRXVOHVGLDOHFWHVVODYHVjO·H[FHSWLRQGXYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQOH M6GXQRPVLQJPDVFGXUDpWpUHPSODFpSDUȽ%
HPSUXQWpDX[WKqPHVHQM1MG·RGDQVOHW\SHPRX MȽ%X%McᅄHQYHUWXGHO·KDUPRQLHLQWUDV\OODELTXH/·K\SRWKqVH
GH9HUPHHUHVWTXHOHM!GXQRPVLQJPDVFPRXDXUDLWpWpWUDQVIpUpDX[WKqPHVHQM6MF·HVWjGLUHDXW\SHGXU
HQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQjXQHGDWHDQWpULHXUHRXFRQWHPSRUDLQHGXUHPSODFHPHQWGH M6%=67%ȽGDQVOHUHVWHGX
VODYH&HWWHK\SRWKqVHV·DSSXLHVXUXQHWHQGDQFHVXSSRVpHGXYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQjDOLJQHUOHW\SHGXUVXUOHW\SH
PRXOHW\SHGXUHPSUXQWDQWSOXVLHXUVGpVLQHQFHVDXW\SHPRX2UFHWWHWHQGDQFHHVWSOXVDSSDUHQWHTXHUpHOOH
HWOHYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQQHPRQWUHSDVYUDLPHQWG·LQIOXHQFHGXW\SHPRXVXUOHW\SHGXUGDQVODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOH
FHQ·HVWTXHGDQVODIOH[LRQSURQRPLQDOHTXHFHWWHLQIOXHQFHHVWUpHOOH'DQVODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHOHVW\SHVGXUHW
PRXPDQLIHVWHQWHQHIIHWXQHWHQGDQFHjO·DOLJQHPHQWPDLVF·HVWWDQW{WOHW\SHPRXTXLHPSUXQWHODGpVLQHQFH
GXW\SHGXUWDQW{WO·LQYHUVHHWVXUWRXWFHVUpIHFWLRQVQHVHSURGXLVHQWTXHGDQVXQVHXOFDVGHILJXUHFHOXLR
ODGpVLQHQFHpWDLW̍ pOLPLQDWLRQGHODGRXEOHDOWHUQDQFH̍a#W'a̍ HWMDPDLVSRXUOHVDXWUHVGpVLQHQFHVO@%"J>6%
FRQVWLWXHXQHSUHPLqUHREMHFWLRQ
,O\DSDUDLOOHXUVXQHDXWUHREMHFWLRQjFHWWHK\SRWKqVHQRQVHXOHPHQWDXFXQGLDOHFWHVODYHQ·DWWHVWHOD
GpVLQHQFHM!SRXUOHW\SHPRXPDLVHQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQPrPHOHW\SHPRXQ·DMDPDLVODGpVLQHQFHM!2%M689%
VHXOHPHQWODGpVLQHQFHMᅄFRPPHGDQVOHUHVWHGXVODYH,OIDXGUDLWGqVORUVVXSSRVHUTXHOHW\SHPRXDSUrWpVD
GpVLQHQFHDXW\SHGXUHWTXHODGpVLQHQFHDpWpUHIDLWHHQVXLWHGDQVOHW\SHPRXHW9HUPHHUDGPHWTXHOHW\SH
PRXDXUDLWSDUODVXLWHHPSUXQWpOHQRPVLQJPDVFMᅄGHVWKqPHVHQM#M&HSURFHVVXVVXSSRVHGHX[UHPSODFH
PHQWVDQDORJLTXHV M6UHPSODFpSDUM!GDQVOHW\SHGXU M!UHPSODFpSDUMᅄGDQVOHW\SHPRX HWODLVVHHQWLqUH
ODTXHVWLRQGHODGLVV\PpWULHHQWUHOHW\SHGXUHWOHW\SHPRX'DQVOHVFDVRHQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQOHW\SHGXU
HPSUXQWHODGpVLQHQFHGXW\SHPRX RXO·LQYHUVH RQDXQHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHOHVGHX[W\SHV
SRXUOHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVFRQFHUQpHVHWOHVGHX[W\SHVRQWODPrPHGpVLQHQFH6LM!HVWO·DQFLHQQHGpVLQHQFHGX
W\SHPRXHPSUXQWpHSDUOHW\SHGXUFHVHUDLWOHVHXOFDVRO·HPSUXQWQHV·DFFRPSDJQHUDLWSDVGHODQHXWUDOLVD
WLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHOHVGHX[W\SHVPDLVRO·RQGHYUDLWVXSSRVHUXQHGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQVHFRQGDLUH OHW\SH
PRXHPSUXQWDQWSOXVWDUGMᅄ 
6HSRVHHQILQXQHTXHVWLRQGHVWUXFWXUH/·pOLPLQDWLRQGH M6 M60DXQRPVLQJPDVFHQVODYHFRPPXQHVW
OLpHDXPDUTXDJHGXJHQUHIRQGDPHQWDOGDQVOHV\VWqPHVODYHDQFLHQM6%JK%M!VRQWGHVGpVLQHQFHVUpVHUYpHVDX
QHXWUHOP&·HVWSUpFLVpPHQWSRXUFHWWHUDLVRQTXH M6 M60DXQRPVLQJPDVFDpWppOLPLQpHQVODYHFRPPXQHW
UHPSODFpSDU࠽GpVLQHQFHGHVPDVFXOLQVHQM1MHWV\PpWULTXHPHQWGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQMc6:?/DUHGLVWULEXWLRQGHV
PDUTXHVHQIRQFWLRQGXJHQUHM6%JK%M!%6L%HJLK7J2%Ƚ%JK%MᅄDXPDVFXOLQIDLWO·REMHWG·XQFRQVHQVXVTX·RQDGPHWWH
TXH M60%X%UM6%RXTXH M60%X%U࠽VX%Ƚ2UOHUHPSODFHPHQWGH M6 M60%=67%UM! M c 60GHVWKqPHVHQMc6M%9J768K%
LPPRWLYpGDQVFHFRQWH[WHVLODUpIHFWLRQDSRXUEXWGHGLIIpUHQFLHUPDVFXOLQHWQHXWUHOHUHPSODFHPHQWGH M6%
=67%UM!OXLDXVVLGpVLQHQFHGHQHXWUHQHSHUPHWSDVODGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQGHVJHQUHVHWHVWVWUXFWXUHOOHPHQWLQXWLOH
&·HVWSRXUTXRLOHUHPSODFHPHQWGH M6%=67%UM!DGPLVSDU9HUPHHUQ·HVWSDVFRPSDUDEOHDXUHPSODFHPHQWGH M6%
=67%U࠽HWLOQHSHXWV·DJLUGHGHX[SURFHVVXVSDUDOOqOHV
/DVHFRQGHK\SRWKqVHSURSRVpHGHSXLVORQJWHPSVGpMjHVWTXHM!UHSUpVHQWHO·DQFLHQQHGpVLQHQFHGHYRFD
WLIGHVWKqPHVHQM6M YLHX[VODYHɥORY̍ɥH2%>6K8H%"6>#)! 2QIDLWHQJpQpUDOGHX[REMHFWLRQVjFHWWHK\SRWKqVH/D
SUHPLqUHHVWTXHGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQYpODLUHOHYRFSUpVHQWHUpJXOLqUHPHQWODSDODWDOLVDWLRQ YLHX[VODYHɥORY̍ɥH2%
GHɥORY̍NȽ WDQGLVTXHOHQRPVLQJHQM!GXYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQQHSUpVHQWHMDPDLVODSDODWDOLVDWLRQ ]DPȽNH%

OQ
6KHYHORY VLQJMᅄGDQVWRXVOHVGLDOHFWHVVODYHV0DLVHQJpQpUDOOHVWKqPHVHQ
O<
9HUPHHUDGPHWpJDOHPHQWTXHO·LQWURGXFWLRQGHM!FRPPHGp M#MQ·RQWHXDXFXQHLQIOXHQFHVXUOHVWKqPHVHQMc6MjSDUWO·HPSUXQW
VLQHQFHGXQRPVLQJGXW\SHGXUHVWSRVWpULHXUHDX[SDODWDOLVDWLRQV GHODGpVLQHQFHGHJpQSOXUM!c
OR
9HUPHHU
OP
6XUO·LPSRUWDQFHGXPDUTXDJHGXJHQUHHQVODYHFI.U\V·NRHW

=DOL]QLDN ,RUGDQLGLSDVVLP
O@
/H)HXYUH
:?
-HQ·HQWUHSDVLFLGDQVODTXHVWLRQGHODFKURQRORJLHTXHODUpIHF
WLRQVRLWDQWpULHXUHRXSRVWpULHXUHjODFKXWHGX VILQDOHVWVDQV

/HVWKqPHVHQM#MTXLFRPSUHQQHQWVXUWRXWGHVIpPLQLQVPDLVDXV
FRQVpTXHQFHVXUOHSURFHVVXVFRQVLGpUpLFL
VLTXHOTXHVPDVFXOLQVRQWXQHIRUPHXQLTXHSRXUOHVQRPYRFDFF
 oi.uchicago.edu

% AQ3<B/7A87%H8%KQ<FF83*<*/,B%HQ7/B8B*/8NN8%8*%O/QK<K3O/8%H87%,@@,7/*/,B7%3<7\8NN87%8B%7N<T8% QRQ

´YHUURXµ 0DLVGDQVFHWWHK\SRWKqVHFHQ·HVWSDVODIRUPHGHYRFTXLVHUDLWGHYHQXHXQHIRUPHGHQRPF·HVW
ODGpVLQHQFHGHYRFM!TXLHVWGHYHQXHXQHGpVLQHQFHGHQRPHWHOOHV·DGMRLQWDXWKqPHGXPRWFRPPHWRXWHV
OHVGpVLQHQFHVSDUH[HPSOHSRXUEUDWȽ´IUqUHµOHYRFHVW&-($!HWOHWKqPHHVW&-($M2%JK%=FL7%ɥORY̍NȽ´KRPPHµ
OHYRFHVWɥORY̍ɥH IRUPHKpULWpHDQWpULHXUHjODSUHPLqUHSDODWDOLVDWLRQ PDLVOHWKqPHHVWɥORY̍NHWjSDUWLU
GXPRPHQWRODGpVLQHQFHGHYRFM!HVWLQWHUSUpWpHFRPPHGpVLQHQFHGHQRPHOOHV·DGMRLQWDXWKqPHGXPRW
GRQF&-($M!2%ɥORY̍NH2URQDYXFLGHVVXVTXHO·LQWURGXFWLRQGHFHWWHGpVLQHQFHM!DXQRPVLQJGHVWKqPHVHQM6M%
pWDLWUpFHQWHSRVWpULHXUHjODSUHPLqUHSDODWDOLVDWLRQGHVYpODLUHV'RQFODQRXYHOOHGpVLQHQFHM!LVVXHGXYRFVL
HOOHV·DGMRLQWjXQWKqPHHQYpODLUHQHSURYRTXHUDSDVODSDODWDOLVDWLRQSDUFHTXHFHWWHGHUQLqUHDGpMjHXOLHX
/DVHFRQGHREMHFWLRQHVWTXHO·HPSORLGHODIRUPHGHYRFHQIRQFWLRQGHQRPSHXWVHFRPSUHQGUHSRXUGHV
VXEVWDQWLIVGpVLJQDQWGHVDQLPpVPDLVPRLQVSRXUGHVVXEVWDQWLIVGpVLJQDQWGHVLQDQLPpVHWHQFRUHPRLQVSRXU
GHVDGMHFWLIVRXGHVSDUWLFLSHVRUOHVDGMHFWLIVHWSDUWLFLSHVRQWDXVVLODGpVLQHQFHM!DXQRPVLQJHWHQSDUWLFXOLHU
OHSDUWLFLSHSDUIDLWTXLVHUWjIRUPHUOHSUpWpULW/HYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQDUpJXOLqUHPHQWM!SRXUOHSDUWLFLSHSDU
G68KN%MHVLYȽGDOH´WXDVGRQQpµGDQVO·pFRUFHGHERXOHDXQR ILQGX;,J²GpEXWGX;,,J¬VLqFOH YȽ]·DOHMHVPᅄ´M·DL
SULVµpFRUFHGHERXOHDXQR¬ SUHPLqUHPRLWLpGX;,,J¬VLqFOH 2USDUGpILQLWLRQFHSDUWLFLSHTXLHVWOHQR\DX
G·XQWHPSVSpULSKUDVWLTXHQ·HVWMDPDLVHQSRVLWLRQV\QWD[LTXHGHYRFPDLVHVWWRXMRXUVSUpGLFDWHWFRPPHWHO
Q·H[LVWHTX·DXQRPLQDWLIGRQFRQQHGHYUDLWSDVDYRLUXQHIRUPHGHYRFHQIRQFWLRQGHQRP2QSHXWIDLUHODPrPH
UpSRQVHTX·jO·REMHFWLRQSUpFpGHQWHFHQ·HVWSDVODIRUPHGHYRFTXLGHYLHQWODIRUPHGHQRPFHTXLH[FOXUDLW
HQHIIHWWRXWHVOHVIRUPHVGpSRXUYXHVGHYRFjO·RULJLQHF·HVWODGpVLQHQFHM!TXLXQHIRLVLQWHUSUpWpHFRPPH
XQHGpVLQHQFHGHQRPGHYLHQWODGpVLQHQFHGHQRPVLQJGHWRXVOHVWKqPHVHQM6MLQGpSHQGDPPHQWGHWRXW
FULWqUHVpPDQWLTXHRXPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXH2UOHSDUWLFLSHSDUIDLWVXLWODIOH[LRQGHVWKqPHVHQM6MGRQFLOUHoRLW
FRPPHOHVDXWUHVODPDUTXHM!GHPrPHTXHOHVDGMHFWLIVTXDQGjSDUWLUGHODVHFRQGHPRLWLpGX;,,JVLqFOHDX
QRPSOXUGXW\SHGXUODGpVLQHQFHM#HVWFRQFXUUHQFpHSDU̍HQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQOHSDUIDLWSUpVHQWHDXVVLDX
PDVFSOXUO̍SDUFHTX·LOVXLWODIOH[LRQGXW\SHGXU
/·H[SOLFDWLRQGXQRPVLQJHQM!SDUO·DQFLHQQHGpVLQHQFHGHYRFDWLIQ·HVWGRQFSDVLQGpIHQGDEOHHWODSULQ
FLSDOHREMHFWLRQTX·RQOXLIDLWWRPEHjSDUWLUGXPRPHQWRO·RQH[DPLQHODFKURQRORJLH5HVWHjH[SOLTXHUOH
PpFDQLVPHTXLVRXVWHQGUDLWFHWWHUpIHFWLRQ

"7M7+-K8DD=LA8A;G<+>=+E8+>K?;<=<L=+>=+5GL8A;D
/HPpFDQLVPHTX·RQYLHQWGHYRLUSRXUOHJpQDFFSRXUUDLWUHQGUHFRPSWHDXVVLGXQRPVLQJHQM!/DGpVL
QHQFHGHYRFDXUDLWpWpUpDIIHFWpHjO·H[SUHVVLRQG·XQDXWUHFDVVHORQOHPrPHSURFHVVXVXQHRSSRVLWLRQVHFRQ
GDLUH QRPYRF HVWQHXWUDOLVpHDXSURILWG·XQHRSSRVLWLRQIRQGDPHQWDOH QRPDFF SRXUUHPpGLHUDXSUREOqPH
GHO·KRPRSKRQLHHQWUHQRPVLQJHWDFFVLQJ&HODVXSSRVHTXHOHV\VWqPHGXYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQV·HVWGpYHORSSp
jSDUWLUGXV\VWqPHGXVODYHFRPPXQWDUGLIRQRPVLQJ࠽HWDFFVLQJ࠽VRQWKRPRSKRQHVWDQGLVTXHGDQV
O·K\SRWKqVHGH9HUPHHUOHVGHX[V\VWqPHVVRQWSDUDOOqOHVHWLOQ·\DSDVGHMXVWLILFDWLRQVWUXFWXUHOOHjODUpIHFWLRQ
&RQWUDLUHPHQWj$¬=DOL]QLDNTXLFRQVLGqUHTXHO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHQRPVLQJHWDFFVLQJHQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQ
FRQWLQXHGLUHFWHPHQWOHVWDGHDQWpULHXUjODFRQIXVLRQGXQRPVLQJHWGHO·DFFVLQJHQVODYHFRPPXQDYHFXQ
UHPDQLHPHQWIRUPHOHWTX·LOV·DJLWG·XQDUFKDwVPH:OMHSHQVHTXHO·RSSRVLWLRQFDVXHOOHHQWUHQRPVLQJM!HWDFF
VLQJȽHVWXQHFRQVpTXHQFHGHO·KRPRSKRQLHGHFHVGHX[FDVHQVODYHFRPPXQF·HVWXQHUHVWDXUDWLRQVHFRQGDLUH
GHO·RSSRVLWLRQTXLREpLWDXPrPHSULQFLSHTXHOHJpQDFFHWLOV·DJLWG·XQHLQQRYDWLRQ DVVH]UpFHQWHSXLVTXH
SRVWpULHXUHDX[SDODWDOLVDWLRQVFIFLGHVVXV† 
2QVDLWTXHO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHYRFHWQRPHVWDVVH]IUDJLOHHOOHQ·H[LVWDLWTX·DXVLQJXOLHUHQLQGRHXURSpHQ
SDVDXGXHOQLDXSOXULHOHOOHQ·H[LVWDLWSDVGDQVODIOH[LRQSURQRPLQDOHHWDXVLQJXOLHUPrPHHOOHHVWVRXYHQW
pOLPLQpHGDQVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV3DUH[HPSOHGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQM(MHQJUHFODIRUPHGHYRFHQද
HVWWUqVUDUHHWF·HVWHQJpQpUDOODIRUPHGHQRPHQථٗTXLHVWHPSOR\pHHQIRQFWLRQGHYRFHWODVLWXDWLRQ
HVWLGHQWLTXHSRXUOHVWKqPHVFRQVRQDQWLTXHVHQRFFOXVLYHHQODWLQVHXOOHW\SH"6>#)10FRQVHUYHXQYRFGLVWLQFW
GXQRPGDQVOHVDXWUHVW\SHVLOQ·\DSOXVGHIRUPHSURSUHGHYRF
2QVDLWTX·HQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQLOQ·\DYDLWSOXVTX·XQHVHXOHIRUPHSRXUOHQRPHWOHYRFGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQ
M6MHQHIIHWOHVWH[WHVTXLXWLOLVHQWOHV\VWqPHGLDOHFWDORQWM!DXQRPFRPPHDXYRF&RPPHjODPrPHpSRTXH

:O
=DOL]QLDN
 oi.uchicago.edu

QR<% 3N</K8%N8%F8\TK8

O·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHQRPHWYRFHVWHQFRUHELHQSUpVHUYpHGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQM(MHWGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQM1MFHOD
PRQWUHTX·LOQHV·DJLWSDVG·XQHSHUWHJpQpUDOHGXYRFPDLVELHQG·XQHVLWXDWLRQSURSUHDX[WKqPHVHQM6MTXL
QHXWUDOLVHQWO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHQRPHWYRF5HVWHjGpWHUPLQHUO·RULJLQHGHFHWWHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQ
QRPYRF
2ULOH[LVWHXQFDVGDQVOHTXHOO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPYRFpWDLWQHXWUDOLVpHjGDWHDQFLHQQHHQLQGRHXURSpHQ
TXDQGRQFRRUGRQQHGHX[YRFRXSOXVODVWUXFWXUHDQFLHQQHQ·HPSORLHTX·XQHVHXOHIRLVODGpVLQHQFHGHYRFSRXU
OHSUHPLHUWHUPHHWODLVVHO·DXWUH OHVDXWUHV WHUPH V DXQRP&·HVWOHW\SHELHQFRQQXGXVDQVNULWYč\DYLQGUDߓ
4(´{9č\XHW,QGUDµ5LJYHGDJUHFঝ͘࿵›ඥࠗ͘‫@«>ݰ‬༦ๆड़Ԇ཭ߥࠗ͘«´{=HXVSqUH«HWWRL6ROHLOµ/.#("!²
#)"-(0HW༦ๆड़Ԇ཭ߥµVRQWDXQRP 'DQVFHFRQWH[WHODGpVLQHQFHGHQRPHVWXQDOORPRUSKHGHODGpVLQHQFHGHYRF
F·HVWGRQFXQFRQWH[WHFDWDO\VHXUGDQVOHTXHOXQHGpVLQHQFHHVWVXVFHSWLEOHG·rWUHUpLQWHUSUpWpH&HWXVDJHQHVH
WURXYHSDVHQYLHX[VODYHPDLVFHODHVWG€jO·DEVHQFHGHFHWRXUGDQVO·RULJLQDOJUHF2QWURXYHSDUDLOOHXUVHQ
VODYHXQVFKpPDV\QWD[LTXHPHQWGLIIpUHQWDYHFSOXVLHXUVYRFDWLIVQRQSDVFRRUGRQQpVPDLVHQDSSRVLWLRQDYHF
XQUpIpUHQWLGHQWLTXHGDQV560I6"#)!%=);(Gᅄ%?!.#=#c´VHLJQHXUJUDQGSULQFHµ 1DVRQRYb6>Y 560I6"#)!%
HVWDXYRFPDLVO·DSSRVLWLRQ=);(Gᅄ%?!.#=#cHVWDXQRPHWQRQDXYRFTXLVHUDLWNQ·DঈH&HWRXUHVWUpJXOLHUHQYLHX[
UXVVHHWGDQVFHFRQWH[WHDXVVLODGpVLQHQFHGHQRPDSSDUDvWFRPPHXQDOORPRUSKHGHODGpVLQHQFHGHYRF,O
YRLVLQHDYHFXQHVWUXFWXUHROHVGHX[WHUPHVVRQWDXYRF560I6"#)!%&-($!´0RQVLHXUPRQIUqUHµGDQVO·pFRUFH
GHERXOHDXQR GpEXWGX;,,,JVLqFOH 2QSHXWHQILQpYRTXHUOHVFDVSOXVPDUJLQDX[GHIOH[LRQGHJURXSH
FRPPH*RVSRGL,VXVȽ;ULVWH 6D[PDWRYHW/DYURYF DYHFXQHVHXOHPDUTXHGHYRFSRXU,VXVȽ;ULVWHjODILQ
GXV\QWDJPH,VXVȽUHVWDQWDXQRPHQIDFHGHODIRUPHDYHFOHVGHX[YRFDWLIVD60I6"#%/010!%i-#0$!GDQVXQHDXWUH
YHUVLRQGXPrPHWH[WH @TN 1DVRQRY%b6> 
2QWURXYHG·DXWUHSDUWHQVODYHXQDXWUHFDVGHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHQRPHWYRFF·HVWFHOXL
GHVDGMHFWLIVjODIRUPHGpWHUPLQpHTXLQ·RQWSDVGHIRUPHGHYRFGDQVYLHX[VODYHGREU\UDEHLEODJ\LY̍Uᅄ)!%
´EUDYHVHUYLWHXUERQHWILGqOHµ 0DWWKLHX-DJLɣ OHVXEVWDQWLI-(&!HVWDXYRFGHPrPHTXHO·DGMHFWLI
jODIRUPHLQGpWHUPLQpHY̍Uᅄ)!WDQGLVTXHOHVGHX[DGMHFWLIVjODIRUPHGpWHUPLQpH"6&-'%JK%&.(5'VRQWDXQRP
2QQRWHUDTXHO·DSSRVLWLRQFRRUGRQQHODIRUPHDXYRFY̍Uᅄ)!HWODIRUPHDXQRP&.(5'&HPrPHWRXUHVWDWWHVWp
HQVODYRQUXVVHHWHQYLHX[UXVVH'DQVFHFRQWH[WHDXVVLODGpVLQHQFHGHQRPHVWXQDOORPRUSKHGHODGpVLQHQFH
GHYRF
'DQVOHFRQWH[WHGHYRFDWLIVVXFFHVVLIVFRRUGRQQpVRXHQDSSRVLWLRQ OHFDVGHODIRUPHGpWHUPLQpHGHO·DGMHFWLI
pWDQWXQSHXGLIIpUHQW ȽpWDLWXQDOORPRUSKHGHODGpVLQHQFHGHYRF%M!&HFRQWH[WHSHXWGRQFrWUHOHFRQWH[WH
FDWDO\VHXU0DLVFRPPHODGLVWLQFWLRQQRPYRFQ·H[LVWHSDVHQGHKRUVGXVLQJXOLHUGHODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHHW
FRPPHSDUWRXWDLOOHXUVF·HVWODIRUPHGHQRPTXLHVWHPSOR\pHHQIRQFWLRQGHYRF DXSOXULHOGDQVOHVSURQRPV
GDQVODIOH[LRQGpWHUPLQpHGHO·DGMHFWLI RQSRXYDLWpJDOHPHQWjO·LQYHUVHUpLQWHUSUpWHUM!FRPPHXQDOORPRUSKH
GHODGpVLQHQFHGHQRPȽ'HPrPHTXHODGpVLQHQFHM(GXJpQHQSKUDVHQpJDWLYHDpWpUpLQWHUSUpWpHFRPPH
XQDOORPRUSKHGHO·DFFG·DSUqVOHPRGqOHGXJpQSDUWLWLIHWGXW\SHDYHFFRPSOpPHQWGHYHUEHDXJpQ WU̍ERYDWL
0.1k($#JpQ GHPrPHM!DSXrWUHUpLQWHUSUpWpFRPPHXQDOORPRUSKHGXQRPG·DSUqVOHPRGqOHGXSOXULHOHWGHV
SURQRPV/DUpLQWHUSUpWDWLRQGDQVFHFDVFRQVLVWHHQXQHLQYHUVLRQGHODUHODWLRQG·DOORPRUSKLH>ȽDOORPRUSKH
GHM!@HVWUpLQWHUSUpWp>M!DOORPRUSKHGHȽ@
&HWWHDOORPRUSKLHM!WȽDDORUVSXrWUHXWLOLVpHSRXUOHPDUTXDJHGHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPDFFDYHFH[WHQVLRQ
GHODGpVLQHQFHM!jWRXVOHVQRPVLQJGXW\SHGXULQGpSHQGDPPHQWGHOHXUVpPDQWLVPH DQLPpVHWLQDQLPpV 
RXGHOHXUFDWpJRULHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXH VXEVWDQWLIVDGMHFWLIVSDUWLFLSHVGDQVOHVWHPSVSpULSKUDVWLTXHV TXLQH
VRQWSDVGHVFULWqUHVSHUWLQHQWVLFLFRQWUDLUHPHQWjFHTXLV·HVWSDVVpSRXUOHJpQDFFROHFULWqUHVpPDQWLTXH
HVWGpWHUPLQDQW/jHQFRUHO·H[WHQVLRQGHM!YDjO·HQFRQWUHGHODWHQGDQFHGRPLQDQWHHQJpQpUDOO·DEDQGRQGH
ODGLVWLQFWLRQQRPYRFVHIDLWDXSURILWGXQRPHWF·HVWDXVVLOHFDVHQUXVVHPRGHUQHSDUH[HPSOHRUHQYLHX[
QRYJRURGLHQF·HVWO·LQYHUVHTXLV·HVWSURGXLWHWF·HVWODGpVLQHQFHpW\PRORJLTXHGHYRFTXLV·HVWLPSRVpH&HWWH
VLQJXODULWpWLHQWDXFRQWH[WHSDUWLFXOLHUDXVODYHGDQVVRQHQVHPEOHTXLHVWODQpFHVVLWpGHPDUTXHUO·RSSRVLWLRQ
QRPDFFODJpQpUDOLVDWLRQGHO·DOORPRUSKHȽGpVLQHQFHpW\PRORJLTXHGHQRPQHUpVROYDLWSDVFHSUREOqPH
ODJpQpUDOLVDWLRQGHO·DOORPRUSKHM!GpVLQHQFHpW\PRORJLTXHGHYRFIRXUQLVVDLWXQHVROXWLRQVLPSOH4XLSOXV
HVWFHWWHVROXWLRQHVWFRQIRUPHjFHTXHIDLWDWWHQGUHOHV\VWqPHGHODODQJXHF·HVWODIRUPHGHVXMHWQRQQHXWUH
QRPPDVF TXLSRUWHXQHPDUTXHVSpFLILTXHHWQRQODIRUPHG·REMHW(QYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQSDUDLOOHXUVF·HVW
OHFULWqUHPRUSKRORJLTXHTXLSULPHVXUOHFULWqUHVpPDQWLTXHF·HVWjGLUHTXHWRXVOHVQRPPDVFVRQWPDUTXpV
HWSDVVHXOHPHQWOHVDQLPpV
8QDXWUHpOpPHQWDSXMRXHUGXUHVWHHWO·H[SOLFDWLRQHVWHQSDUWLHGHW\SHVRFLROLQJXLVWLTXH/HGLDOHFWH
QRYJRURGLHQV·HVWGpYHORSSpVXUXQVXEVWUDWOLQJXLVWLTXHQRQLQGRHXURSpHQHQO·RFFXUUHQFHILQQRRXJULHQHW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% AQ3<B/7A87%H8%KQ<FF83*<*/,B%HQ7/B8B*/8NN8%8*%O/QK<K3O/8%H87%,@@,7/*/,B7%3<7\8NN87%8B%7N<T8% QRR

SOXVSUpFLVpPHQWIHQQLTXHTXLHVWOHJURXSHGXERUGGHOD%DOWLTXHILQQRLVHVWRQLHQFDUpOLHQ2UOHVODQJXHV
IHQQLTXHVQ·RQWSDVGHYRFF·HVWODIRUPHGHQRPTXLHVWHPSOR\pHHQIRQFWLRQG·DGUHVVHGRQFGDQVO·XVDJH
GHORFXWHXUVELOLQJXHVO·pTXLYDOHQFHHQWUHOHVGHX[GpVLQHQFHVpWDLWLQpYLWDEOH&HUWHVOHVXEVWUDWQHVXIILWSDVj
H[SOLTXHUXQWHOFKDQJHPHQWGDQVODVWUXFWXUHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHGHODODQJXHPDLVHQO·RFFXUUHQFHLOQ·HVWSDV
VHXOHQFDXVHLOVHWURXYHTXHODVWUXFWXUHGHODODQJXHGHVXEVWUDW DEVHQFHG·RSSRVLWLRQQRPYRF FRUUHVSRQGDLW
jXQHVWUXFWXUHH[LVWDQWHGDQVOHGLDOHFWHVODYHFRQVLGpUp QHXWUDOLVDWLRQFRQWH[WXHOOHGHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPYRF 
&HWWHVWUXFWXUHpWDLWXQHYDULDQWHHQVODYHOLPLWpHjFHUWDLQVFRQWH[WHV HQO·RFFXUUHQFHSOXVLHXUVYRFFRRUGRQ
QpVRXMX[WDSRVpV PDLVHOOHpWDLWGpMjEHOHWELHQSUpVHQWHGDQVODODQJXH/DFRQMRQFWLRQHQWUHFHWWHVWUXFWXUH
FRQWH[WXHOOHPHQWOLPLWpHHWODVWUXFWXUHGHODODQJXHGHVXEVWUDWDSXIDYRULVHUODUpDIIHFWDWLRQGHODGpVLQHQFHGH
YRFGHVRUWHTXHODVWUXFWXUHTXLjO·RULJLQHpWDLWXQHYDULDQWHFRQWH[WXHOOHPHQWOLPLWpHHVWGHYHQXHODVWUXFWXUH
QRUPDOHHQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQ::
/·HPSORLG·XQHIRUPHGHYRFDWLIHQIRQFWLRQGHQRPLQDWLIQ·HVWSDVFHSHQGDQWWRWDOHPHQWLVROp2QUDSSHOOHUD
OHW\SHJUHFKRPpULTXHHQO·RFFXUUHQFHဎ͘‫͘ݵ‬ड़ࣹٗ͘‫ݰ‬ๆࠗǓঝ͘࿲ߥ´=HXVDVVHPEOHXUGHQXpHVµ໌››཭ࠗǓ༱ๆۭࠗङ‫´ݰ‬1HV
WRUPHQHXUGHFDYDOHVµROHVXEVWDQWLIHQࠗථߥDSSRVpHVWXQHIRUPHGHYRFDWLIHQࠗදWDQGLVTXHঝ͘࿲ߥ༱ๆۭࠗङ‫ݰ‬
VRQWDXQRPLQDWLI&HWXVDJHYLHQWGHODGpFOLQDLVRQG·DQFLHQQHVIRUPXOHVG·DGUHVVHGRQWOHYRFDWLIpWDLWODIRUPH
SULPRUGLDOH ီဎ͘‫͘ݵ‬ड़ࣹٗ͘‫ݰ‬ๆࠗǓঝ͘࿵ီ໌››཭ࠗǓ༱ๆۭࠗ‫ ݰڗ‬HWRVHXOO·XQGHVpOpPHQWVGXV\QWDJPHHQO·RFFXUUHQFH
OHQRPSURSUHYDULHHQWUHOHQRPLQDWLIHWOHYRFDWLIWDQGLVTXHO·DSSRVLWLRQUHVWHILJpHjODIRUPHGHYRFDWLIPDO
JUpOHFKDQJHPHQWGHIRQFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHQRPVLQJ໌››཭ࠗǓ༱ๆۭࠗङ‫ݰ‬YRFVLQJ໌››཭ࠗǓ༱ๆۭࠗ‫&ݰڗ‬HW\SHV·DSSXLH
HQIDLWVXUOHW\SHDYHFSOXVLHXUVYRFVXFFHVVLIVFRRUGRQQpV Yč\DYLQGUDߓFD RXQRQRODGpVLQHQFHGHQRP
HVWXQDOORPRUSKHGHODGpVLQHQFHGHYRF,OSUpVHQWHOHPrPHUHQYHUVHPHQWTXHOHYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQGDQV
FHFRQWH[WHFDWDO\VHXUODUHODWLRQG·DOORPRUSKLHDpWpLQYHUVpHVRXVO·LQIOXHQFHGXSOXULHORF·HVWODIRUPHGH
QRPTXLHVWXWLOLVpHHQIRQFWLRQGHYRFHWODGpVLQHQFHGHYRFDpWpUpLQWHUSUpWpHFRPPHXQDOORPRUSKHGH
ODGpVLQHQFHGHQRPG·ROHPDLQWLHQGHVIRUPHV໌››཭ࠗǓဎ͘‫͘ݵ‬ड़ࣹٗ͘‫ݰ‬ๆࠗǓGDQVXQV\QWDJPHVXMHWDXQRP2QD
SURSRVpG·LQWHUSUpWHUGHFHWWHPDQLqUHOHVQRPVLQJHQࠗǓǓGHVPDVFXOLQVHQM(MGDQVOHVGLDOHFWHVEpRWLHQHW
WKHVVDOLHQHQIDFHGHࠗථߥථߥGHVDXWUHVGLDOHFWHV:Q6LFHVIRUPHVVRQWELHQG·DQFLHQVYRFHQIRQFWLRQGHQRP
FRPPHOHVIRUPHVpSLTXHVRQDXUDLWOjXQSDUDOOqOHFRPSOHWDYHFOHYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQGDQVOHVGHX[FDVO·LQYHU
VLRQGHODUHODWLRQG·DOORPRUSKLHGDQVOHW\SHjSOXVLHXUVYRFDWLIVVXFFHVVLIVDIDLWUpLQWHUSUpWHUODGpVLQHQFHGH
YRF දHQJUHFM!HQVODYH FRPPHXQDOORPRUSKHGXQRPGDQVOHVGHX[FDVFHWDOORPRUSKHDpWppWHQGXHQ
GHKRUVGHVRQFRQWH[WHG·RULJLQHHWHVWGHYHQXODPDUTXHUpJXOLqUHGXQRPGDQVOHVGHX[FDVLOV·DJLWG·XQIDLW
GHODQJXHG·H[WHQVLRQOLPLWpHTXLQHFRQFHUQHTX·XQJURXSHGLDOHFWDO O·HQVHPEOHEpRWLHQWKHVVDOLHQSRXUOH
JUHFOHGLDOHFWHGH1RYJRURG3VNRYSRXUOHVODYH GDQVOHVGHX[FDVODUpDIIHFWDWLRQGHODGpVLQHQFHGHYRFQH
FRQFHUQHTX·XQVHXOVRXVW\SHPRUSKRORJLTXH OHVPDVFXOLQVHQථߥHQJUHFOHVPDVFXOLQVHQM6MHQVODYH HWOHV
DXWUHVW\SHVQHVRQWSDVDIIHFWpV
/HQRPHQM!FRPSRUWHELHQWRXVOHVpOpPHQWVG·XQHUpIHFWLRQGHW\SH'KRPRSKRQLHGHGpSDUWJrQDQWH
QRPDFF QHXWUDOLVDWLRQG·XQHRSSRVLWLRQSpULSKpULTXH QRPYRF DXSURILWG·XQHRSSRVLWLRQFHQWUDOH QRP
DFF KLpUDUFKLTXHPHQWVXSpULHXUHjSDUWLUG·XQFRQWH[WHFDWDO\VHXURODGpVLQHQFHM!SRXYDLWrWUHUpLQWHUSUpWpH
FRPPHXQDOORPRUSKHGHODGpVLQHQFHGHQRP SOXVLHXUVYRFDWLIVFRRUGRQQpVRXMX[WDSRVpVGRQWXQVHXOSRUWH
ODPDUTXHGH9RFOHVDXWUHVpWDQWDXQRP G·DSUqVXQPRGqOHGHPrPHVWUXFWXUH ODGLVWLQFWLRQQRPYRFHVW
DEVHQWHDXSOXULHODXGXHOGDQVOHVSURQRPV 

"7"7+2;K989LP;=+9=E8A;J=+=<A9=+GHHG?;A;G<+>=+L8?+=A+GHHG?;A;G<+>=+N=<9=
'DQVFHVFRQGLWLRQVpWDQWGRQQpODVLPSOLFLWpGHODVROXWLRQGXYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQTXLSHUPHWXQHGLVWLQFWLRQ
V\VWpPDWLTXHHQWUHQRPHWDFFRQSHXWVHGHPDQGHUSRXUTXRLFHWWHVROXWLRQHVWUHVWpHOLPLWpHjFHGLDOHFWHHWQ·D
SDVpWpUHWHQXHSDUOHVDXWUHVGLDOHFWHVVODYHV,O\DVDQVGRXWHSOXVLHXUVUDLVRQVjFHODPDLVODUDLVRQSULQFLSDOH
SRXUUDLWWHQLUDXPDUTXDJHGXJHQUH

::
9HUPHHUDGPHWGpMjOHU{OHGXVXEVWUDWIHQQLTXHPDLV EpRWLHQHWGXWKHVVDOLHQODIRUPHDQFLHQQHGXQRPVLQJ !+:DQWp
HQSURSRVDQWXQDXWUHPpFDQLVPH ULHXUHjODUHFDUDFWpULVDWLRQSDU M0%TXLHVWSURSUHDXJUHFHWVHUDLW
:Q
0HQGH]'RVXQD&HWWHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQDpWpFRQWHVWpHSDU+ GRQFDVVH]UpFHQWHYRLUODGLVFXVVLRQFKH]0LQRQ
T7+5GAAK9G+6UUVWX<GA+;<+Q;QEYYZTXLYRLWGDQVOHVIRUPHVHQDGX
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3N</K8%N8%F8\TK8

(QHIIHWGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQM6M2OHYRFVLQJ5-("!HVWKRPRSKRQHGXQRPDFFQHXWUHGHVWKqPHVHQMc6M%GX
KE=J%>6-;!´PHUµ FI%WDEOHDXFLGHVVXV† :<&HWWHKRPRSKRQLHHVWWROpUpHSDUODODQJXHHQUDLVRQGXVWDWXW
VSpFLILTXHGXYRFF·HVWXQFDVKRUVV\QWD[HFRQWUDLUHPHQWDXQRPRXjO·DFFHWLOHVWGHWRXWHIDoRQPDUTXp
SDUGHVPR\HQVQRQIOH[LRQQHOV SDXVHV\QWD[LTXHLQWRQDWLRQGHSKUDVH /DGpVLQHQFHQ·HVWTX·XQPR\HQGH
PDUTXHUOHYRFHWFHQ·HVWSDVODPDUTXHSULQFLSDOH0DLVUpDIIHFWHUM!DXPDUTXDJHGXQRPVLQJPDVFDERX
WLVVDLWjXQHKRPRSKRQLHHQWUHOHQRPVLQJPDVFHWOHQRPVLQJQHXWGXW\SH>6-;!GRQFjXQHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQ
GHO·RSSRVLWLRQGHJHQUHSRXUOHPrPHFDV QRPVLQJPDVFQRPVLQJQHXW FHTXLHVWQHWWHPHQWSOXVJrQDQW
2QDYXFLGHVVXV FI† TXHOHPDUTXDJHGXJHQUHHVWIRQGDPHQWDOGDQVOHV\VWqPHVODYHDQFLHQM6%JK%M!%9FHK%
GHVGpVLQHQFHVUpVHUYpHVDXQHXWUH,O\DGRQFXQFRQIOLWHQWUHOHPDUTXDJHGXFDV RSSRVLWLRQQRPDFF HWOH
PDUTXDJHGXJHQUH RSSRVLWLRQPDVFQHXW FKRLVLUGHPDUTXHUO·RSSRVLWLRQFDVXHOOHQRPDFFSDUO·H[WHQVLRQ
GHM!VXSSRVHGHVDFULILHUHQSDUWLHO·RSSRVLWLRQGHJHQUHQRPPDVFQRPQHXW/·LPSRUWDQFHGHO·RSSRVLWLRQGH
JHQUHGHYDLWVXIILUHjEORTXHUODUpDIIHFWDWLRQGHODGpVLQHQFHGHYRF%M!DXPDUTXDJHGXQRPGDQVOHVPDVFXOLQV
HQUDLVRQGHODQpFHVVLWpGHPDLQWHQLUXQHRSSRVLWLRQKLpUDUFKLTXHPHQWVXSpULHXUHRXGHPrPHQLYHDX
/HQRPVLQJHQ%M!GXYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQVHPEOHUDLWGqVORUVLQGLTXHUTXHODKLpUDUFKLHHQWUHO·RSSRVLWLRQ
GHFDVHWO·RSSRVLWLRQGHJHQUHHVWGLIIpUHQWHGDQVFHGLDOHFWHHWTXHO·RSSRVLWLRQGHJHQUHDpWpVDFULILpHj
O·RSSRVLWLRQGHFDVGRQFTX·HOOHHVWKLpUDUFKLTXHPHQWLQIpULHXUH6LWHOHVWOHFDVRQSHXWOjHQFRUHLQYRTXHUOH
VXEVWUDWIHQQLTXHOHVODQJXHVIHQQLTXHVQHFRQQDLVVHQWSDVOHJHQUHJUDPPDWLFDOSRXUGHVORFXWHXUVELOLQJXHV
ODGLVWLQFWLRQHQWUHQHXWUHHWPDVFXOLQQ·DGRQFSDVGHVHQV'HSOXVFRPPHRQOHVDLWO·RSSRVLWLRQPDVFQHXW
Q·HVWH[SOLFLWHTX·DX[QRPDFFGDQVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVOHUHVWHGXSDUDGLJPHpWDQWFRPPXQDX[
GHX[JHQUHVFHTXLIUDJLOLVHHQFRUHFHWWHRSSRVLWLRQSRXUGHVORFXWHXUVELOLQJXHV/DODQJXHGHVXEVWUDWQ·D\DQW
SDVG·RSSRVLWLRQGHJHQUHPDLVD\DQWXQHRSSRVLWLRQGHFDVWUqVQHWWHODSULPDXWpGHO·RSSRVLWLRQFDVXHOOHVXU
O·RSSRVLWLRQGHJHQUHSRXUUDLWrWUHGLUHFWHPHQWOLpHjODVLWXDWLRQGXGLDOHFWHQRYJRURGLHQGDQVO·HQVHPEOHVODYH
HWDX[FRQGLWLRQVGDQVOHVTXHOOHVFHGLDOHFWHV·HVWGpYHORSSpVXUXQVXEVWUDWILQQRRXJULHQ

"7[7+,;??@CKA9;=+=<A9=+APBC=?+=<+"#"+=A+APBC=?+=<+"%#"
/HV\VWqPHGXYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQRQO·DGLWHVWGLVV\PpWULTXHOHVWKqPHVHQM6MHWOHVWKqPHVHQMc6M%HTFHK%
SDVODPrPHVWUXFWXUH W\SHGXUQRPM!DFFȽDYHFXQHGLVWLQFWLRQV\VWpPDWLTXHW\SHPRXQRPMᅄDFFMᅄ2%
KRPRSKRQHV 
&HWWHGLVV\PpWULHSRXUUDLWWHQLUVLPSOHPHQWDXIDLWTXHODIRUPHGHYRFpWDLWGLIIpUHQWHOHYRFGHVWKqPHVHQ
Mc6M2%JH%JGGJK2%HTJ9K%=69%JH%M!2%M689%JH%M1HQYLHX[VODYHFRPPHHQYLHX[UXVVH YLHX[VODYHP‫ۓ‬ঈX´KRPPHµ ,OV·DJLW
G·XQHPSUXQWDX[WKqPHVHQM1MHWFHWHPSUXQWVHPEOHrWUHGHGDWHVODYHFRPPXQH:R2QQ·DFHSHQGDQWDXFXQ
H[HPSOHGHYRFVLQJGXW\SHPRXHQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQHQO·pWDWDFWXHOGXFRUSXVRQSHXWVXSSRVHUHQO·DEVHQFH
G·LQGLFHGXFRQWUDLUHTXHODGpVLQHQFHpWDLWODPrPHTX·DLOOHXUVPDLVLOQ·HVWSDVH[FOXTX·HOOHDLWpWpGLIIpUHQWH6L
OHYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQDYDLWODPrPHGpVLQHQFHM1TXHOHVDXWUHVGLDOHFWHVRQSHXWSURSRVHUO·K\SRWKqVHVXLYDQWH
,OVHWURXYHTXHM1HVWODGpVLQHQFHGHGDWGHVWKqPHVHQM6M 5-("1´SRXUODYLOOHµ HWHQMc6M P‫ۓ‬ঈX´SRXU
O·KRPPHµ 'DQVOHVWKqPHVHQMc6MRQDGRQFXQHKRPRSKRQLHHQWUHYRFVLQJHWGDWVLQJ&HWWHKRPRSKRQLHHVW
WROpUpHSDUODODQJXHHQUDLVRQGXVWDWXWVSpFLILTXHGXYRF FLGHVVXV† ,OQ·\DDXFXQFRQWH[WHROHYRFHW
OHGDWSHXYHQWVHFRQIRQGUHODGpVDPELJXwVDWLRQQ·HVWGRQFSDVQpFHVVDLUH
'DQVOHVWKqPHVHQM6M W\SHGXU ODGpVLQHQFHGHYRFM!HVWXQLYRTXHHWODUpDIIHFWDWLRQGHM!DXPDUTXDJH
GXQRPQHQHXWUDOLVHDXFXQHRSSRVLWLRQFDVXHOOHIRQGDPHQWDOH'DQVOHVWKqPHVHQMc6MDXFRQWUDLUHODGpVLQHQFH
GHYRFM1Q·HVWSDVXQLYRTXHSXLVTX·HOOHHVWKRPRSKRQHGXGDWUpDIIHFWHUODGpVLQHQFHM1GHYRFDXPDUTXDJH
GXQRPHQWUDvQHUDLWXQHKRPRSKRQLHVHFRQGDLUHHQWUHQRPHWGDWGRQFODQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRP
GDW2UODUqJOHGDQVFHW\SHGHUpIHFWLRQHVWTX·XQHRSSRVLWLRQQHSHXWrWUHQHXWUDOLVpHTX·DXSURILWG·XQHRSSR
VLWLRQKLpUDUFKLTXHPHQWVXSpULHXUHOHIDLWTXHODODQJXHQ·DLWSDVGDQVFHFDVDGPLVOHPDUTXDJHGHO·RSSRVLWLRQ
QRPDFFDXSUL[GHODQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPGDWODLVVHSHQVHUTXHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPGDWQ·HVW
SDVKLpUDUFKLTXHPHQWLQIpULHXUHjO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPDFF'DQVOHFDVG·XQYHUEHWULYDOHQWSDUH[HPSOHO·RSSR
VLWLRQQRPGDW SUHPLHUDFWDQWWURLVLqPHDFWDQW HVWDXVVLIRQGDPHQWDOHTXHO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPDFF SUHPLHU
DFWDQWGHX[LqPHDFWDQW 

:<
&HODV·DSSOLTXHjXQpWDWGHODQJXHDQWpULHXUDXGpYHORSSHPHQWGH :R
(QVODYHRFFLGHQWDORQDSRORQDLVP̵ঋXWFKqTXHPXঈL Mc1FI
ODFRUUpODWLRQGHPRXLOOXUH 168>>6HK2%D3N7
 oi.uchicago.edu

% AQ3<B/7A87%H8%KQ<FF83*<*/,B%HQ7/B8B*/8NN8%8*%O/QK<K3O/8%H87%,@@,7/*/,B7%3<7\8NN87%8B%7N<T8% QR@

/·DQDO\VHGXQRPHQ%M!SDUODUpDIIHFWDWLRQGHODGpVLQHQFHGHYRFSHUPHWWUDLWDLQVLGHUHQGUHFRPSWHGHOD
GLVV\PpWULHFRQVWDWpHHQWUHOHVWKqPHVHQM6MHWOHVWKqPHVHQMc6MFHOOHFLVHUDLWGXHDXIDLWTXHODIRUPHGHYRF
pWDLWGLIIpUHQWHGDQVOHVGHX[W\SHVHWTXHWRXWHUpDIIHFWDWLRQpWDLWEORTXpHGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQMc6MSDUODQpFHVVLWp
GHSUpVHUYHUO·RSSRVLWLRQQRPGDW/DFOHIGHO·H[SOLFDWLRQUpVLGHUDLWGDQVODSULVHHQFRPSWHGHODKLpUDUFKLH
HQWUHOHVGLIIpUHQWHVRSSRVLWLRQVFDVXHOOHV&HODVXSSRVHTXHO·H[WHQVLRQGHM!DXQRPVLQJGXW\SHHQM6M%J9K%
SRVWpULHXUHjO·pOLPLQDWLRQGHO·DQFLHQQHGpVLQHQFHGHYRFM!GDQVOHW\SHHQMc6MHWjVRQUHPSODFHPHQWSDUM1FH
TXLFRQFRUGHDYHFOHFDUDFWqUHUpFHQWGHODGpVLQHQFHGHQRPVLQJM!SRVWpULHXUHDX[SDODWDOLVDWLRQV FLGHVVXV
O'I6$+E0!0%I-6I60U!0%I61-%.!%)6>L%!)%M! 

[7+/8QE=8:+LGCH898A;D+>=?+>=:F+?GE:A;G<?
2QSHXWUpVXPHUOHVSULQFLSHVGHVGHX[UpDIIHFWDWLRQVVRXVODIRUPHGXWDEOHDXVXLYDQW

*'I! 5U)L(44L%()#>U )6>L%!)%M!

H[WHQVLRQ VODYHFRPPXQ GLDOHFWDO
IRUPHPDUTXpH DFF QRP
RSSRVLWLRQQHXWUDOLVpH DFFJpQ QRPYRF
FRQWH[WHGHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQ JpQGHQpJDWLRQ YRFFRRUGRQQpVRXMX[WDSRVpV
FULWqUHGRPLQDQW VpPDQWLTXH PRUSKRORJLTXH
W\SHVIOH[LRQQHOV M6M%JK%Mc6 RVHXOHPHQW

2QYRLWSDUFHVGHX[H[HPSOHVTX·LOSHXW\DYRLUSOXVLHXUVVROXWLRQVjXQPrPHSUREOqPHHQO·RFFXUUHQFHOD
GLVWLQFWLRQQRPDFFHWTXHOHVGLDOHFWHVVODYHVRQWSDUIRLVVXLYLGHVYRLHVGLYHUJHQWHV/HSRLQWFRPPXQHQWUH
OHVGHX[VROXWLRQVHVWTXHODUpRUJDQLVDWLRQGHVPDUTXHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVjO·LQWpULHXUG·XQPrPHSDUDGLJPHHVW
WRXMRXUVHQFDGUpHHWOLPLWpHSDUODKLpUDUFKLHGHVRSSRVLWLRQVLQVFULWHGDQVODVWUXFWXUHGHODODQJXH

&Q9KJ;8A;G<
D3N7% $QGUp9DLOODQWD-(>>(#-!%46>I(-U!%"!0%.()51!0%0.(?!09ROXPHV@+6)U$#X1!  A6-I+6.65#!%
 T!-&!  F6->($#6)%"!0%)6>0  7')$(]!  3DULV,PSULPHULH1DWLRQDOH

\;QE;GN98HP;=
%RVVRQJ*HRUJ
  8>I#-#04+!%\)#?!-0(.#!):6-04+1)5g%H#::!-!)$#!..!%,&c!=$>(-=#!-1)5%#)%"!)%)!1#-()#04+!)%7I-(4+!)$UV/LQ
JXLVWLFD7ELQJHQ1DUU
  ´/HPDUTXDJHGLIIpUHQWLHOGHO·REMHWGDQVOHVODQJXHVG·(XURSHµ'DQV<4$()4!%!$%?(.!)4!%"()0%.!0%N()M
51!0%"!%.;81-6I!pGLWpSDU-)HXLOOHWSS²(PSLULFDO$SSURDFKHVWR/DQJXDJH7\SRORJ\²
%HUOLQ0RXWRQGH*UX\WHU
"FM78J2%
  ´0RUSKRORJLFDO&ODVVLILFDWLRQRI&DVHVLQWKH6ODYRQLF/DQJXDJHVµ7.(?6)#4%()"%8(0$%81-6I!()%K!?#!9%
²


­FHODV·DMRXWHOHSDUDOOqOHGHVWKqPHVHQM#MTXLRQWXQHIRUPH WKqPHVHQMc6MFHTXLUHQIRUoDLWOHVFKpPDKpULWpGDQVOHVWKqPHV
XQLTXHSRXUOHQRPDFFVLQJMᅄKRPRSKRQHGXQRPDFFVLQJGHV JH%Mc6M
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 3N</K8%N8%F8\TK8

-DJLɣ9DWURVODY
  0DULLQVNRHɥHWYHURHYDQJHOLHVSULPHɥDQLMDPLLVSULORঈHQLMDPL%HUOLQ:HLGPDQQ
.U\V·NR29%HW6,,RUGDQLGL
% :???% ,VWRULɥHVNDMDJUDPPDWLNDGUHYQHUXVVNRJRMD]\ND0RVFRX1DXND
.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]2-HU]\
  ´/DQDWXUHGHVSURFqVGLWV¶DQDORJLTXHV·µ'DQV80X1#00!0%.#)51#0$#X1!09ROXPHpGLWpSDU-
.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]SS²0XQLFK)LQN
/H)HXYUH&ODLUH
  ´/.#%)(%I6.1";)!%#.#%I6.1)6k$#¶jPLGLRXjPLQXLW· 814+D OHORFDWLIVLQJXOLHUGHVWKqPHVFRQVR
QDQWLTXHVHQVODYHµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
  ´6XUODIOH[LRQGHVWKqPHVHQM(MHQYLHX[QRYJRURGLHQµK!?1!%"!0%Q$1"!0%7.(?!0²
0HQGH]'RVXQD-
%  ´8QHDXWUHTXHVWLRQGHGLDOHFWRORJLHJUHFTXHµD.6$$(²
0LQRQ6RSKLH
% :??@% N!0%#)04-#I$#6)0%U.U!))!0%"#(.!4$(.!0%^T/!q//!%0#E4.!%(?()$%PLM3L`L+DXWHVeWXGHVGX0RQGH*UpFRURPDLQ
*HQqYH'UR]
1DVRQRY$1
% OPR?% B6?56-6"0=(c(%@!-?(c(%N!$6I#0;%0$(-k!56%#%>.("k!56%#G?6"6?0RVFRX,]GYR$NDGHPLL1DXN6665
6D[PDWRY$$HW3$/DYURY
  6ERUQLNȽ;,,Y̍NDPRVNRYVNDJR8VSHQVNDJRVRERUD0RVFRX0RXWRQ
6KHYHORY2*HRUJH<
  @-!+#0$6-'%6:%7.(?#4g%*+!%O#0$6-#4(.%@+6)6.65'%6:%36>>6)%7.(?#4L+HLGHOEHUJ&:LQWHU
168>>6HK2%$QGUp
  A()1!.%"1%?#!1]%0.(?!3DULV,QVWLWXWG·eWXGHV6ODYHV
1J7MJJ72:
  ´7KH0\VWHULRXV1RUWK5XVVLDQ1RPLQDWLYH6LQJXODU(QGLQJ!DQGWKH3UREOHPRIWKH5HIOH[RI
3URWR,QGR(XURSHDQ M60LQ6ODYLFµJ!.$%"!-%7.(?!)²
  ´2Q([SODLQLQJ:K\WKH(DUO\1RUWK5XVVLDQ1RPLQDWLYH6LQJXODULQ!'RHV1RW3DODWDOL]H6WHP
ILQDO9HODUVµK100#()%N#)51#0$#40²
9RWWpUR*X\
% OPP@% K!4+!-4+!0%01-%.!%"#(.!4$!%&U6$#!)L%7KqVHG·(WDW1DQF\8QLYHUVLWp
=DOL]QLDN2$$
% :??<% H-!?)!)6?56-6"0=#c%"#(.!=$L%:qPHpG0RVFRX1DXND
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @,\Ke\,/%H8\i%DQB/*/F7%8*%H8\i%N,3<*/F7%8B%K\778%@,\K%38K*</B7%7\S7*<B*/F7[% QRP

!"
#$%&'%$()*+%,)-./(0(12)+0)*+%,)3$450(12)+/)&%22+)#$%&)
4+&05(/2)2%6205/0(127)+050)540%+3)*+2)#5&5*(-8+2)
+0)52#+402)*(549&$/('%+2

7!-51!V%7(=+)62%\)#?!-0#$U%@(-#0%,1!0$%B()$!--!%M%N(%HU:!)0!

/·H[LVWHQFHGDQVOHUXVVHPRGHUQHG·XQJpQLWLIVHFRQGHWG·XQORFDWLIVHFRQGFRQVLGpUpVVRXYHQWFRPPHGHV
FDV´LQFRPSOHWVµ )!I6.)'! RX´VXSSOpPHQWDLUHVµ GRSROQLWHO૟Q\H  OFRQVWLWXHXQSKpQRPqQHDVVH]FRPSOH[H
FRQFHUQDQWQRWDPPHQWODQDWXUHOLQJXLVWLTXHGHFHVFDWpJRULHVHWOHXUMXVWLILFDWLRQVpPDQWLTXH/DTXHVWLRQD
IDLWO·REMHWG·XQHOLWWpUDWXUHLPSRUWDQWHHQVODYLVWLTXHGRQWLOHVWLPSRVVLEOHGHIDLUHLFLXQUpVXPpQLPrPHXQ
DSHUoXVXFFLQFW3DUPLOHVWUDYDX[PDMHXUVRQUHWLHQGUD-DNREVRQ=DOL]QMDN3ORWQLNRYD
:RUWKঢXUDYOHY-DQGD6XOOLYDQ3OXQJMDQ8VSHQVNLM/HFDGUHUHVWUHLQWGHFHW
DUWLFOHQHSHUPHWJXqUHGHIDLUHXQHDQDO\VHVXIILVDPPHQWGpWDLOOpHGHFHSKpQRPqQH'·DXWUHVODQJXHVVODYHV
QRWDPPHQWO·XNUDLQLHQHWOHELpORUXVVLHQ SUpVHQWHQWGHVIDLWVHQSDUWLHDQDORJXHVTXLQHSHXYHQWSDVQRQSOXV
rWUHGpFULWVLFLHQGpSLWGHOHXUJUDQGLQWpUrW:1RXVQRXVOLPLWRQVDX[IDLWVHVVHQWLHOVGXUXVVHVWDQGDUG ODQJXH
QRUPpHpFULWHHWRUDOH OHVGRQQpHVGLDOHFWDOHVQHVRQWSDVDERUGpHVGHIDoRQV\VWpPDWLTXH

:;)1<=>?)@A)BA??C)CD)?EDFGBHD=CI)@HAJKC)LMD=>=N)C>)@HAJKC)KHF<>=N)OHAB)FCB><=D?)DHP?
:;:;)7RXWHVOHVJUDPPDLUHVGXUXVVHPRGHUQH ߰YHGRYD*DUGH&RPWHW.RU&KDKLQHHW5RXGHW
6DNKQRHWG·DXWUHV VLJQDOHQWO·H[LVWHQFH@QAD)LMD=>=N)?CFHD@DXVLQJXOLHUSRXUFHUWDLQVPDVFXOLQV
LQDQLPpV SOXVGHVLRQQHFRPSWHTXHOHVPRWVXVLWpV GRQWXQHJUDQGHPDMRULWpGHQRPVQRQQRPEUDEOHV
GHO·DFWXHOOHJGpFOLQDLVRQWHOVTXH"6>´PDLVRQµ>†"´PLHOµ0)!5´QHLJHµɥDM´WKpµQ'HO·DYLVGHSOXVLHXUVOLQ
JXLVWHV GRQW-DNREVRQ RQSHXWDGPHWWUHTXHFHVVXEVWDQWLIVRQW@CAR)LMD=>=N?

O
3RXUOHSUHPLHUWHUPHYRLUOHFRPPHQWDLUHGH93OXQJMDQ 
 SRXUOHVHFRQG VXJJpUpSDU$3HߖNRYVNLMHQ YRLU-DNRE
VRQ1RWRQVTXHO·H[LVWHQFHGHFHVFDVQ·HVWSDVPHQWLRQQpH
H[SOLFLWHPHQW SDU O·HQF\FORSpGLH N()51!%-100! DX[ HQWUpHV ´&DVµ
´/RFDWLIµ´*pQLWLI µ )LOLQ²² 'DQV-DUFHYD
 HQWUpH´&DVµ SDVGHPHQWLRQFODLUHQRQSOXVVDXISRXUOH
JpQLWLIVHFRQG TXLQ·HVWSDVQRPPpHQWDQWTXHWHOOHVIRUPHVUXVVHV
FRUUHVSRQGDQWHVVRQWFLWpHVFRPPH´FDVSDUWLWLIKRPRQ\PLTXHVGX
JpQLWLIRXGXGDWLI µ 2QVHUDSSHOOHUDHQUHYDQFKHTXHVHORQ17UX
EHW]NR\  O·H[LVWHQFHHQUXVVHGHGHX[JpQLWLIVHWGHGHX[
ORFDWLIVHVWXQDUJXPHQWLPSRUWDQWTXLVRXOLJQHODULFKHVVHFDVXHOOH
GXUXVVH´ODQJXHTXLVHWURXYH¬DXFHQWUHGHO·DLUHGpFOLQDWLRQQHOOH
GHO·$QFLHQ0RQGHµ
:
7/RPWHY ² HW9ঢXUDYOHY ² HQGRQQHQW
GHVDSHUoXVWUqVSHUWLQHQWV
Q
2Q\WURXYHGHVVXEVWDQWLIV´PDVVLIVµGpVLJQDQWGHVVXEVWDQFHVHW
GHVPDWLqUHV Vi[DU´VXFUHµk†.=´VRLHµ5-("´JUrOHµ)(?çG´IXPLHUµ
HWF GHVQRPVGHPDQLIHVWDWLRQVG·pWDWVSK\VLTXHVHWQDWXUHOV ]ç.6"%
´OHIURLGµk1>´EUXLWµ?=10´JR€Wµ?!0´SRLGVµHWF GHVQRWLRQVDEV
WUDLWHVOLpHVjGHVDFWLYLWpVKXPDLQHV 0-(>´KRQWHµ(II!$É$´DSSpWLWµ
HWF GHVFROOHFWLIVFRQFUHWV >w06-´GpFKHWVRUGXUHVµHWF RXFROOHF
WLIV´FRQFHSWXHOVµ )(-ç"´JHQVPRQGHµ"6]ç"´UHYHQXµHWF 4XDQW
DX[QRPV´GLVFUHWVµRXQRPV´ORFDOLVDWHXUVµWHOVTXH"6>´PDLVRQµ
.!0´IRUrWERLV PDWpULDX µ)60´QH]µ-6$´ERXFKHµ5.(G´±LOµ&6=%
´IODQFF{Wpµ=-(c´ERUGOLPLWHµ56"´DQµOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHOHXU
JpQ,,HVWOLPLWpjGHVORFXWLRQVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOOHVVRXYHQWILJpHV0%
JOi]XQDJOD]´HQWrWHjWrWHµGDQVSOXVLHXUVFDVOHJpQ,HVWSRVVLEOH
FIÉG%)601´YHQDQWGXQH]µ JpQ,,DFFHQWGpSODFpVXUODSUpSRVL
WLRQ HW#G%)ç0(% JpQ, 'DQVGHVGLDOHFWHVUXVVHVJpQ,,HVWDVVH]
UpSDQGXHWLOV·pWHQGMXVTX·DX[DQLPpVFI&!G%6$4w%´VDQVOHSqUHµ
UXVVHVWDQGDUGEH]RWFi HWDX[QHXWUHVFI"6%)U&1´MXVTX·DXFLHOµ
UXVVHVWDQGDUG"6%)U&( 

QRP
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 78KD\8Ä)7<bOB,

:;:;:;)-MD=>=N)( RX5U)#$#:WRXWFRXUWFRQVLGpUpFRPPH´QRUPDOµGDQVODPHVXUHRLOFDUDFWpULVHO·HQVHPEOH
GHVPDVFXOLQVHWGHVQHXWUHVGHJGpFOLQDLVRQ< DYHFGpVLQHQFHM(DFFHQWXpHRXSDVR

"ç>(FII6=1I=(%"ç>(´O·DFKDWG·XQHPDLVRQµ?'c$#%#G%"ç>(´VRUWLUGHODPDLVRQGHFKH]VRLµ
>†"(FINDɥHVWYRPsGD´ODTXDOLWpGXPLHOµ
0)U5(FI&!.#G)(%0)U5(´ODEODQFKHXUGHODQHLJHµERMDW૟VMDVQpJD´FUDLQGUHODQHLJHµ
ɥŃM(FIDURPDWɥDMD´O·DU{PHGHGXWKpµ

:;:;!;)-MD=>=N)(( GLWDXVVL5U)#$#:%I(-$#$#:%FL%X1()$#$($#:SRXUOHVQRPV´PDVVLIVµYRLUDXVVLODQRWH DYHF

GpVLQHQFH1JpQpUDOHPHQWQRQDFFHQWXpH@

"ç>1FI?'c$#%ÉG%"6>1¬ DYHFGpSODFHPHQWGHO·DFFHQWVXUODSUpSRVLWLRQ ´VRUWLUGHODPDLVRQGH

FKH]VRLµ
>†"1FIORঈNDPsGX´XQHFXLOOHUpHGHPLHOµ
0)U51FI%>)656%0)U51%´EHDXFRXSGHQHLJHµ7)U51M$6ä´4XHGHQHLJHµ¬
ɥŃM12%FIɥDߖNDɥŃMX´XQHWDVVHGHWKpµY\SLW૟ɥŃMX´ERLUHGXWKpµ

:;:;S;)/DFRH[LVWHQFHGHVGHX[JpQLWLIVHVWSDUIRLVSRVVLEOHRQOLWHWRQHQWHQG?'c$#%ÉG%"6>1W#G%"ç>(´VRUWLU
GHFKH]VRLµORঈNDPsGXPsGD´XQHFXLOOHUpHGHPLHOµ>)656%0)U51l0)U5(%´EHDXFRXSGHQHLJHµPDLVDYHFXQH
SUpIpUHQFHGDQVO·XVDJHRUDODFWXHO VXUWRXWFKH]OHVMHXQHV GHODVHFRQGHYDULDQWHJpQ,,pWDQWSDUIRLVUHVVHQWL
FRPPHDUFKDwTXHRXOLPLWpjGHVH[SUHVVLRQVILJpHV6·LO\DXQGpWHUPLQDQWRQHPSORLHJpQ,ɥDߖNDNUHSNRJR
ɥiMD´XQHWDVVHGHWKpIRUWµ
&HSHQGDQWJpQ,,HVWLPSRVVLEOHGDQVFHUWDLQHVVWUXFWXUHV¬ FRPSOpPHQWGXQRPRXDYHFFHUWDLQVYHUEHV 

I6=1I=(%j"ç>1%´O·DFKDWG·XQHPDLVRQµ&!.#G)(%j0)U51%´ODEODQFKHXUGHODQHLJHµ
ERMDW૟VMD VQpJX´FUDLQGUHODQHLJHµ¬

3DUIRLVDXFRQWUDLUHF·HVWJpQ,TXLHVWTXDVLPHQWLPSRVVLEOHDLQVLGDQVFHUWDLQHVFRQVWUXFWLRQVjVHQVTXDQ
K8K6K8GN% [[7)U5(M$6ä´4XHGHQHLJHµ&HWWHUHVWULFWLRQFRQFHUQHpJDOHPHQWTXHOTXHVGLPLQXWLIVGHQRPV´PDVVLIVµ
3DUH[HPSOHDYHFɥDsN´SHWLWWKpµ GLPLQXWLIFRXUDQWGHɥDM´WKpµ RQSHXWDYRLUXQJpQ,,Y\SLW૟%ɥDMN~´ERLUH
GXWKpµ ODGpVLQHQFH1HVWDORUVDFFHQWXpHYRLUQRWH PDLVJpQ,VHUDLWGLIILFLOHVDXIGDQVXQXVDJHRUDOWUqV
´UHOkFKpµY\SLW૟[[ɥDMNi MXJpLQFRUUHFWGXSRLQWGHYXHGHODQRUPHJUDPPDWLFDOH L
:;!;)'·DXWUHSDUWOHVJUDPPDLUHVIRQWpWDWG·XQKHF<>=N)?CFHD@)DXVLQJXOLHUSRXUFHUWDLQVPDVFXOLQVLQDQLPpVP%
GHJGpFOLQDLVRQ PRWVHQYLURQO? HWSRXUTXHOTXHVIpPLQLQVLQDQLPpVGHJGpFOLQDLVRQGXW\SHNURY૟´VDQJµ

<
$SSHOpH´7JGpFOLQDLVRQµGDQVODWUDGLWLRQJUDPPDWLFDOHUXVVH
R
/·DFFHQWXDWLRQGHODGpVLQHQFHM(HVWFHSHQGDQWUDUHSRXUOHVPRWV
D\DQWjODIRLVJpQ,HWJpQ,, YRLUDXVVLQRWH 8QJUDQGQRPEUH
GHVXEVWDQWLIVPDVFXOLQVLQDQLPpVDYHFM(DFFHQWXpDXJpQLWLIQ·RQW
SDVGHJpQ,,FI&.#)´FUrSHµI#-ç5´SkWpµJpQEOLQi2%SLURJi PDLV
JpQ,,LPSRVVLEOHj&.É)1%lj&.#)w2%jI#-ç51%l%UI#-65w LOVQ·RQWSDVQRQ
SOXVGHORF,,

%-6%HFK6K8FH%†LQGLTXHXQ>R@DFFHQWXpDSUqVFRQVRQQHPROOHHW
GHYDQWFRQVRQQHGXUH1RXVXWLOLVRQVSDUWRXWODWUDQVOLWWpUDWLRQGLWH
GHVVODYLVWHVODQRWDWLRQ૟FRUUHVSRQGDXVLJQHPRXɎGXUXVVHHW
PDUTXHODPRXLOOXUHGHODFRQVRQQH SDUIRLVXQ\RGDSUqVFRQVRQQH
HWGHYDQWYR\HOOH ʋHVWUHQGXSDUqGDQVOHVH[HPSOHVVHXOVOHVPRWV
LPSRUWDQWVSRXUQRWUHDQDO\VHVRQWDFFHQWXpV
@
/DGpVLQHQFHM1DFFHQWXpHFDUDFWpULVHOHVPRWVFRPSRUWDQWXQVXI
IL[HDFFHQWXpDXQRPLQDWLIWHOTXHM6=2%M(=FII!0ç= QRP ´VDEOHµ
³JpQ,,I!0=w FIJpQ,SHVNi P\ߖMiN´DUVHQLFµ³JpQ,,>'kc(=w%
FIJpQ,P\ߖMDNi RXXQpOpPHQWILQDODFFHQWXpDXQRPLQDWLIUHV
VHQWLFRPPHXQVXIIL[HNRQMiN´FRJQDFYLQFXLWµ PRWLVVXGXIUDQ
oDLV465)(4 ³=6)c(=w FIJpQ,NRQMDNi MDQWiU૟´DPEUHµ HPSUXQW
6L%>8KL6H8JH%5#)$£-(0´DPEUHµ ³JpQ,,c()$(-cw FIJpQ,MDQWDUMi 
MDɥPpQ૟´RUJHµ³JpQ,,MDɥPHQM~ FIJpQ,MDɥPHQMi &HODYDXWDXVVL
SRXUOHVVXIIL[HVGLPLQXWLIVM6=%l%M†=%DFFHQWXpVDXQRPLQDWLI>!"ç=%
´SHWLWPLHOµ³JpQ,,>!"=wVDXITXHOHVPRWVGHFHW\SHQ·RQWSDV
GHJpQ, WRXWFRPPH4(†=´SHWLWWKpµ³JpQ,,ɥDMN~ 2QQRWHUD
TXHOHVXIIL[HGLPLQXWLIɥLNQ·HVWSDVDFFHQWXpNHItUɥLNGH=!:É-´ODLW
IHUPHQWpµ DFFHQWVXU# ³JpQ,,)NHItUɥLNX JpQ,NHItUɥLND L

&HUWDLQVDGYHUEHVWHOVTXH0?U-]1 0%?U-]1 ´YHQDQWGXKDXWGX
9FMMJK2Y%0)ÉG1 0%)ÉG1 ´YHQDQWGXEDVµVRQWG·DQFLHQQHVORFXWLRQV
DYHFJpQ,,'DQVSOXVLHXUVORFXWLRQVILJpHVGHUHJLVWUHIDPLOLHURX
SRSXODLUHLGLRPDWLTXHVRXQRQVHXOJpQ,,HVWSRVVLEOHQLUi]X IDP 
´SDVXQHVHXOHIRLVµGDW૟GUiSX SRS ´VHEDUUHUµGDW૟Pi[X IDP 
´IDLUHXQHErWLVHµ)#%0.w]12%)#%"w]1% IDP ´GLVSDUXGDQVODQDWXUHµ
P
/HVPDVFXOLQVDQLPpVVRQWH[FOXVPDLVGDQVGHVGLDOHFWHVUXVVHV
PrPH OHV QHXWUHV NU\O૟FR ´SHUURQ GH OD PDLVRQµ6=)6 ´IHQrWUHµ 
SHXYHQWDYRLUXQORF,,QDNU\O૟F~´VXUOHSHUURQµ)(%6=)w´DXERUG
GHODIHQrWUHµ)(%0!.w´jODFDPSDJQHµ
O?
2Q\WURXYHGHVQRPVLQDQLPpVSRXUODSOXSDUWLPPRWLYpV pW\
PRORJLTXHPHQWRSDTXHVSRXUXQORFXWHXUPR\HQ GRQWODPDMRULWp
VRQWPRQRV\OODELTXHVPRWVGpVLJQDQWGHVHVSDFHVHWGHVVXUIDFHV
VXVFHSWLEOHVGHORFDOLVHUXQREMHW.!0´IRUrWµ=-15´FHUFOHµ&U-!5%
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @,\Ke\,/%H8\i%DQB/*/F7%8*%H8\i%N,3<*/F7%8B%K\778%@,\K%38K*</B7%7\S7*<B*/F7[% 

GYHU૟´SRUWHµ XQHWUHQWDLQHGHPRWVOOSDVGHIOH[LRQVSpFLILTXHO:ODGLIIpUHQFHHVWUHQGXHSDUODSODFHGHO·DFFHQW
DFFHQWUDGLFDOSRXUORF,DFFHQWILQDOSRXUORF,, 
6HORQSOXVLHXUVOLQJXLVWHV -DNREVRQ3OXQJMDQHWG·DXWUHV RQSHXWFRQVLGpUHUTXHFHVQRPVSRV
VqGHQW!)KHF<>=N?
:;!;:;)3HF<>=N)( RXI-UI60#$#:%/2%FL%I-UI60#$#: OQWRXWFRXUWGDQVODPHVXUHRLOFDUDFWpULVHO·HQVHPEOHGHVPDVFX
OLQVHWGHVQHXWUHVGHJGpFOLQDLVRQ DYHFGpVLQHQFHM! DFFHQWXpHRXQRQ¬SRXUOHVPDVFXOLQV HWDYHFGpVLQHQFH
#%QRQDFFHQWXpHSRXUOHVIpPLQLQV
:;!;:;:;)0DVFXOLQV

"ç>!FI?%"ç>!´jODGDQVODPDLVRQjO·LQWpULHXUGHODPDLVRQµ
>†"!FI%T%>†"!%PQRJRSROH]Q\[YHߖɥHVWY´'DQVOHPLHOLO\DEHDXFRXSGHVXEVWDQFHVEpQpILTXHVµ
GXPDW૟RPsGH´SHQVHUDXPLHOµ
0)U5!FIPHɥWDW૟RVQpJH´UrYHUGHODQHLJHµLVNDW૟NUDVRWXYVQpJH´FKHUFKHUODEHDXWpGDQVODQHLJHµ
VHQVDEVWUDLW 
>ç0$UFIJRYRULW ૟RPyVWp´SDUOHUGXSRQWµ

:;!;:;!;))pPLQLQV

=-ç?#FILVNDW૟VOHG\MDGDYNUyYLERO૟QRJR´FKHUFKHUOHVWUDFHVGXSRLVRQGDQVOHVDQJG·XQPDODGHµ
GXPDW ૟RNUyYL´SHQVHUDXVDQJµ
"?U-#FIJRYRULW ૟RGYpUL´SDUOHUGHODSRUWHµ

:;!;!;)3HF<>=N)(( DSSHOpDXVVLSDUFHUWDLQHVJUDPPDLUHVSUpSRVLWLI¬,,2%FL%.64($#:WRXWFRXUWGDQVODPHVXUHRLO
VHUDSSRUWHHQSULQFLSHjXQHORFDOLVDWLRQ DYHFGpVLQHQFHMwO<DFFHQWXpHSRXUOHVPDVFXOLQVHWDYHFGpVLQHQFH
MÉDFFHQWXpHSRXUOHVIpPLQLQV YRLUQRWH 
:;!;!;:;)0DVFXOLQV

"6>wFIUDERWDW૟QDGRP~´WUDYDLOOHUjGRPLFLOHµ
>!"wFI\%>!)c(%-1=#%?%>!"w´-·DLOHVOHVPDLQVFRXYHUWHVGHPLHOPjPGDQVOHPLHOµ=?(0%)(%
>!"w´NYDV ERLVVRQIHUPHQWpH jEDVHGHPLHOµ

´ULYHµ.15´SUpµI6-$´SRUWµ0("´MDUGLQµI6.´VROSODQFKHUµw56.%
´FRLQDQJOHµ-6?´IRVVpµHWF DLQVLTXHGHVFRQFHSWVV·DSSDUHQ
WDQWjGHVHVSDFHV ("´HQIHUµ-(c´SDUDGLVµI.!)´FDSWLYLWpµ GHV
REMHWVjVXUIDFHIRQFWLRQQHOOH >60$´SRQWµI.6$´UDGHDXµHWF GHV
UpFLSLHQWV $(G´EDVVLQHEDVVLQ>DQDWRPLTXH@ µk=(:´DUPRLUHµ5-6&%
´FHUFXHLOµ GHVREMHWVVHUYDQWGHVXSSRUW =-c1=´FURFKHWµHWF PRWV
GpVLJQDQWGHVVXEVWDQFHV >†"´PLHOµঈLU´JUDLVVHµI1]´GXYHWµ0)!5%
´QHLJHµHWF QRPVFROOHFWLIV >#-%´PRQGHVRFLpWpODwTXHFRPPX
QDXWpUXUDOHDQFLHQQHµI6.=´DUPpHUpJLPHQWµHWF QRPVG·DFWLRQV
G·pWDWVGHVLWXDWLRQV &!5´FRXUVHµ&6c´FRPEDWµç$I10=´FRQJpµI#-%
´IHVWLQµ]6"´PDUFKHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWµHWF QRPVG·pOpPHQWVQDWX
UHOV ]ç.6"´IURLGµ?U$!-´YHQWµ0?!$´OXPLqUHµ PRWVGpVLJQDQWGHV
SpULRGHVWHPSRUHOOHV ?!=´VLqFOHYLHKXPDLQHµ56"´DQµ TXHOTXHV
WRSRQ\PHV b-'>´&ULPpHµH6)´OH'RQµ /HVHPSUXQWVQHVRQWSDV
H[FOXVI6-$%´SRUWµI6.= HPSUXQWDQFLHQDXJHUPDQLTXHFIDOOHPDQG
T6.= I60$´SRVWH GHVHQWLQHOOHGHPLQLVWUH µI60$´MH€QHµ HPSUXQW
DQFLHQDXJHUPDQLTXHFIDOOHPDQGF(0$!) HWF/DSOXSDUWRQWXQDF
FHQWUDGLFDODXJpQLWLIVLQJ FI.!0³JpQ,.U0(JpQ,,.U01 &HUWDLQV
SHXYHQWDYRLUXQJpQ,, OHVPsGঈLUSX[VQHJHWF G·DXWUHVQ·RQWSDV
GHJpQ,, VDXIGDQVGHVGLDOHFWHV FRPPHSDUH[HPSOH&!-!52%>60$
OO
2XWUHOHVGHX[FLWpVHQYRLFLTXHOTXHVXQVSDUPLOHVDXWUHVPRWV
L9LJ>9N%JOXE૟´SURIRQGHXUµJUMD]૟´ERXHµGDO૟´OHORLQWDLQµS\O૟´SRXV
VLqUHµVYMD]૟´OLHQOLDLVRQFRQWDFWµEURY૟´VRXUFLOµJUXG૟´SRLWULQHµ
SHɥ ૟´OHSRrOHIRXUµNRVW૟´RVµQRɥ ૟´QXLWµRV૟´D[HµVHW૟´UpVHDXµ
VWHS૟´VWHSSHµWHQ૟´RPEUHµFHS૟´FKDvQHµ3RXUOHXUFODVVLILFDWLRQ
VpPDQWLTXHYRLU3OXQJMDQ²
O:
'DQVFHWWHGpFOLQDLVRQO·KRPRQ\PLHJUDPPDWLFDOHHVWLPSRUWDQWH
ODGpVLQHQFH#FDUDFWpULVHFDVFISRXUNURY ૟ JpQ=-ç?#GDW=-ç?#2%
ORF,=-ç?#ORF,,=-6?É/·KRPRQ\PLHHVWSDUIDLWHHQWUHJpQGDWHW
ORF,
OQ
/HWHUPHGHI-UI60#$#:% SUHGORঈQ\M V·H[SOLTXHSDUOHIDLWTXHFHFDVQH
SHXWIRQFWLRQQHUGDQVOHUXVVHPRGHUQHTX·DYHFXQHSUpSRVLWLRQ ?%
´GDQVµ)(´VXUµ6%l%6&´jSURSRVGHµI-#´DXSUqVGHµI6´DSUqVµ /HV
JUDPPDLUHVUXVVHVSXEOLpHVHQ5XVVLHUpVHUYHQWSDUIRLVOHWHUPHGH
PHVWQ\MSDGHঈ´FDVORFDWLI µDXORF,,HQOHGLVWLQJXDQWGHFHWWHIDoRQ
GHSUHGORঈQ\MSDGHঈ´FDVSUpSRVLWLIµ3ORWQLNRYD  DSSHOOHOH
ORF,,´FDVSUpSRVLWLRQQHODYHFXQVHQVVSDWLDO ORFDWLI µ
O<
4XLHVWKRPRQ\PLTXHGHODGpVLQHQFHGXJpQ,,HWGXGDWPRLQV
O·DFFHQW&ISRXU0)!5JpQ,,0)U51GDW0)U51ORF,,0)!5w/·KRPR
Q\PLHVHUDLWSDUIDLWHSRXUOHVVXEVWDQWLIVD\DQWJpQ,,HWGDWDFFHQ
WXpVjODGpVLQHQFHFRPPHSDUH[HPSOH%I!0ç=´VDEOHµ YRLUQRWH 
³JpQ¬,,I!0=w2%GDW%I!0=w2%PDLVOHVQRPVGHFHW\SHQ·RQWSDVGHORF
,, VDXIGDQVGHVGLDOHFWHV 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 78KD\8Ä)7<bOB,

0)!5w2%FILVNDW૟NOMXɥLYVQHJ~´FKHUFKHUVHVFOpVGDQVODQHLJHµ VHQVFRQFUHW 
>60$wFIVWRMDW૟QDPRVW~´rWUHGHERXWVXUOHSRQWµ

:;!;!;!;))pPLQLQV

=-6?ÉFI\%)!56%.#46%?%=-6?É´,ODOHYLVDJHFRXYHUWGHVDQJµ PjP´6RQYLVDJHHVWGDQVOHVDQJ
HQVDQJµ \%)#]%E$6%?%=-6?É´,OVRQWoDGDQVOHVDQJ¬ V·DJLVVDQWG·XQWUDLWGHFDUDFWqUHG·XQH
WUDGLWLRQG·XQHKDELWXGHELHQDQFUpH µ
"?!-É%FIB(%"?!-É%?#0#$%G(>6=%´8QFDGHQDVHVWVXUODSRUWHµ

:;!;S;)/RUVTX·LOV·DJLWG·XQHYUDLHORFDOLVDWLRQODYDULDWLRQORF,ORF,,HVWSRVVLEOHSRXUXQFHUWDLQVQRPEUHGH
VXEVWDQWLIV (!-6I6-$%>´DpURSRUWµ]6.6"%>´IURLGµGYHU૟I´SRUWHµ HWHOOHQ·HVWSDVWRXMRXUVOLpHjXQHGLIIpUHQFH
GHVHQV'DQVO·XVDJHPRGHUQHRQSHXWDYRLUSDUH[HPSOH

ঈGDW૟%?%(!-6Iç-$!l?%(!-6I6-$w%´DWWHQGUHjO·DpURSRUWµ
0$6c($%)(%]ç.6"!l)(%]6.6"w%´UHVWHUGHERXWGDQVXQHQGURLWIURLGµ
B(%"?U-#l)(%"?!-É%?#0#$%G(>6=%´8QFDGHQDVHVWVXUODSRUWHµ

0DLVORF,HWORF,,QHVRQWSDVLQWHUFKDQJHDEOHVORUVTXHOHSUHPLHUUHQYRLHjXQH´IDXVVHµORFDOLVDWLRQ TXDVL
ORFDOLVDWLRQ RXORUVTXHOHQRPHQTXHVWLRQIDLWSDUWLHGXWLWUHG·XQH±XYUHOLWWpUDLUHG·XQVSHFWDFOHHWFDORUV
TXHOHVHFRQGUHQYRLHjXQHYUDLHORFDOLVDWLRQ ORFDOLVDWLRQ0$-#4$6%0!)01 OR

$U[LWHNWRUVRVUHGRWRɥLOYVHXVLOLMDQDqWRPPyVWp ORF, %´/·DUFKLWHFWHDFRQFHQWUpWRXVVHVHIIRUWVVXU

FHSRQWµ¬ LPSRVVLEOH)(%E$6>%j>60$w 
,)%0$6#$%)(%>60$w ORF,, ´,OHVWGHERXWVXUOHSRQWµ LPSRVVLEOHRXGLIILFLOH)(%j%l[[>ç0$U 
$NWULVDLJUDHWY´9LߖQsYRPViGHµ´/DFRPpGLHQQHMRXHGDQV¶/D&HULVDLH·>GH7FKHNKRY@µ LPSRVVLEOH
?´T#k)†?6>%j0("w 
'HYRɥNDLJUDHWYYLߖQsYRPVDG~ ORF,, ´/DSHWLWHILOOHMRXHGDQVXQHFHULVDLHµ ?%?#k)†?6>[ViGH%9J768K%
FRQWUDLQWRXOLYUHVTXH 

&HSHQGDQWXQHORFDOLVDWLRQ0$-#4$6%0!)01ORUVTX·HOOHQ·HVWSDVSURWRW\SLTXHSRXUO·REMHWORFDOLVDWHXUIDYRULVH
ORF,3DUH[HPSOH

b$6M$6%)(I#0(.%65-6>)'>#%&1=?(>#%#>c(%)6?656%I-!G#"!)$(%)(%>ç0$U% ORF, %<.!=0()"-(%///´4XHOTX·XQD

pFULWOHQRPGXQRXYHDXSUpVLGHQWHQJURVVHVOHWWUHVVXUOHSRQW$OH[DQGUH,,,µO@

'DQVOHVWURLVFRQWH[WHVVXLYDQWVODEDVVLQHHVWG·DERUG L XQORFDOLVDWHXUpPLQHPPHQWSURWRW\SLTXH IDLUH

WUHPSHUVRQOLQJHVHODYHUOHVSLHGV HQVXLWH LL XQORFDOLVDWHXUSHXSURWRW\SLTXH WUDQVSRUWHUGHVEULTXHVVXU
XQFKDQWLHU GDQV LLL LOQHV·DJLWSDVG·XQHYUDLHORFDOLVDWLRQ
L \%>!)c(%$1$%&!.૟†%>6=)!$lP(%>6c1%)65#%?%$(Gw% ORF,, %´-HIDLVWUHPSHUPRQOLQJH PjPOHOLQJHWUHPSH 
-HPHODYHOHVSLHGVGDQVXQHEDVVLQHµ YWi]H¬HVWSOXVGLIILFLOHTXRLTXHQRQLPSRVVLEOH¬GDQVFHW\SHGH
FRQWH[WHV 
LL  8PHQMDQHWWDɥNLLMDQRߖXNLUSLɥLYWi]H ORF, ´-HQ·DLSDVGHEURXHWWHHWMHWUDQVSRUWHGHVEULTXHVGDQV
XQHEDVVLQHµ QRVLQIRUPDWHXUVUXVVRSKRQHVMXJHQW?%$(GwDFFHSWDEOHTXRLTXHXQSHXFRQWUDLQW 

OR
1RWRQVTXHODORFDOLVDWLRQDYHFORF,,SHXWrWUHWHPSRUHOOH?%E$6>%
56"w´ DXFRXUVGH FHWWHDQQpHµ

7HUPHXWLOLVppJDOHPHQWGDQV3OXQJMDQ
O@
2QFRPSUHQGTXHOHQRPHVWpFULWVXUODVXUIDFHODWpUDOHGXSRQW
RXVXUXQGHVSLOLHUV)([>60$wVHUDLWFRQWUDLQW2U)(%>60$w%9J768K%
DFFHSWDEOHVLOHQRPpWDLWpFULWVXUODVXUIDFHSULQFLSDOHVXSpULHXUH
GXSRQW*RRJOH FRQVXOWpHQMXLOOHW GRQQHHQYLURQPLOOH
RFFXUUHQFHVSRXUODVpTXHQFH´)(%>ç0$UµHWFHUWDLQVFRQWH[WHVVRQW
SURFKHVGHQRWUHH[HPSOH PDLVG·DXWUHVVRQWSOXVSUREOpPDWLTXHV 
FRQWUHSOXVG·XQPLOOLRQG·RFFXUUHQFHVSRXU´)(%>60$wµ%K1046-I6-(%
²IRXUQLWH[HPSOHVSRXU )(% « >ç0$!FID-()($(%c1.6c%
]DYHUWHODV૟QDPyVWH *6<TK<DHU):V"WXYDH>)=D)J=JK77Z´/DJUHQDGH
H[SORVLYH VH PLW j WRXUQHU VXU OH SRQW WHOOH XQH WRXSLHµ R OD
ORFDOLVDWLRQQ·HVWSDVSURWRW\SLTXHXQSRQWQ·HVWSDVXQOLHXQRUPDO
SRXUXQHJUHQDGHSURMHWpH TXLGRLWH[SORVHU 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @,\Ke\,/%H8\i%DQB/*/F7%8*%H8\i%N,3<*/F7%8B%K\778%@,\K%38K*</B7%7\S7*<B*/F7[% 

LLL  2EQDUXঈLOL%GHIHNWYWi]H ORF, ´2QDUHOHYpXQGpIDXWGDQV>OHPDWpULDXODVWUXFWXUHODFRQFHSWLRQGH@OD

EDVVLQHµ PDLV?%j$(GwVHUDLWLPSRVVLEOH L

(PSOR\pDXVHQVDQDWRPLTXH ´EDVVLQµ $(GDXWRULVHORF,¬HWORF,,EROLYWi]HYWD]~´GRXOHXUVDXEDVVLQµ

3RXUFHUWDLQVPRWVODORFDOLVDWLRQ0$-#4$6%0!)01SHXWrWUHH[SULPpHSDUORF,RXORF,,HQIRQFWLRQGXVHQVFI

 ORFDWLI, ORFDWLI,,
% T%"ç>!%1%)#]%>)656%>!&!.#%% T%"6>w% Y[RXSRS XQL[SMDW૟GHWHM%
 ´,OVRQWFKH]HX[EHDXFRXSGHPHXEOHVµ ´,OVRQWjODPDLVRQ GDQVOHXUIDPLOOH HQIDQWVµ
% )(%"ç>!´VXU OHWRLWGH ODPDLVRQµ )(%"6>w´jGRPLFLOH WUDYDLOHWF µ
% T%=ç0$#%-()!)656%)(k.#%I1.c1%% ,)%k#-6=%?%=60$É
 ´'DQVO·RVGXEOHVVpRQDWURXYpXQHEDOOHµ ´,ODGHJURVRV PjP,OHVWODUJHGDQVO·RV µ

'DQVFHVFDVORF,VHPEOHOLpjXQHORFDOLVDWLRQ´FRQWLQJHQWHµDORUVTXHORF,,VHPEOHLPSOLTXHUXQHORFDOL
VDWLRQ´SURWRW\SLTXHµRX´HVVHQWLHOOHµ ODPDLVRQHVWO·HQGURLWTXLDEULWHXQHIDPLOOHRXXQHDFWLYLWpSURIHVVLRQ
QHOOHO·RVVDWXUHHVWOHIDFWHXUTXLGpWHUPLQHOHVSURSRUWLRQVFRUSRUHOOHVG·XQLQGLYLGX PrPHVLOHVGHX[GHUQLHUV
H[HPSOHVSUpVHQWHQWGHVORFXWLRQVVHPLILJpHV )(%"6>w2%k#-6=#c%?%=60$É 
0DLVVXUWRXWORF,,QHSHXWSDVVHVXEVWLWXHUjORF,GDQVGHVFRQWH[WHVPDQLIHVWHPHQW´DEVWUDLWVµ¬RLOQH
V·DJLWSDVGXWRXWGHORFDOLVDWLRQ¬ FHWHPSORLGXORFDWLIHVWSDUIRLVDSSHOp´H[SOLFDWLIµL]૟૟MDVQLWHO૟QRHGDQVOHV
JUDPPDLUHVUXVVHV LOVHUDLWLPSRVVLEOH¬G·DYRLUSDUH[HPSOH
JRYRULW૟R PRVW~´SDUOHUGXSRQWµPHɥWDW૟R%U0("w%´UrYHUG·XQMDUGLQµGXPDW૟R NURYt´SHQVHUDXVDQJµ
:;!;[;)­ODGLIIpUHQFHGHJpQ,, VRXYHQWSHUoXFRPPHDUFKDwTXHSDUUDSSRUWjJpQ, ORF,,GHVPDVFXOLQV
HQwGpVLJQDQWXQHORFDOLVDWLRQQ·HVWSDVUHVVHQWLFRPPHYLHLOOLSDUUDSSRUWjORF,%LHQDXFRQWUDLUHGDQVOHV
H[HPSOHVVXLYDQWVF·HVWORF,TXLHVWYLHLOOLHWRXOLYUHVTXHDORUVTXHORF,,HVWVW\OLVWLTXHPHQWQHXWUHHWWRXWj
G68K%L9LJ>N

 ORFDWLI, ORFDWLI,, VHQV

 YiGH Y[  ?%("w ´HQHQIHUµ
% ?%&ç! Y[  ?%&6cw ´SHQGDQWOHFRPEDWDXFRPEDWµ
% ?%5-ç&! Y[  ?%5-6&w ´GDQVOHFHUFXHLOµ
 QDߖNiIH Y[  )(%k=(:w% ´VXUO·DUPRLUHµ
% )(%0)U5! OLYU  )(%0)!5w% ´VXUODQHLJHµ

3RXUG·DXWUHVPRWVODFRUUpODWLRQHVWGLIIpUHQWHORF,HVWVW\OLVWLTXHPHQWQHXWUHQRQPDUTXpDORUVTXHORF¬,,
HVWPDUTXpFRPPHIDPLOLHUSRSXODLUHRXELHQDSSDUWHQDQWjXQXVDJHSURIHVVLRQQHOFI

 ORFDWLI, ORFDWLI,, VHQV

% ?%0wI!% ?%01Iw% IDP  ´GDQVODVRXSHµ
% ?%ç$I10=!% ?%6$I10=w IDP  ´HQFRQJpµ
% )(%]ç.6"!%% )(%]6.6"w SRS  ´HQSOHLQIURLGGDQVXQHQGURLWIURLGµ

:;!;";)3DUIRLVO·RSSRVLWLRQORF,ORF,,FRUUHVSRQGjXQHGLVWLQFWLRQVpPDQWLTXHSRXUGHVPRWVSRO\VpPLTXHV
FRPPHSDUH[HPSOH=-(c´ERUGERUGXUHµHW´JUDQGHUpJLRQDGPLQLVWUDWLYH )pGpUDWLRQGH5XVVLH µ?!=´VLqFOHµHW
´GXUpHGHYLHG·XQLQGLYLGXµRXELHQjXQHGLIIpUHQFHG·HPSORLDXVHLQGHVORFXWLRQV¬SOXVRXPRLQVILJpHV

2QঈLYsWY.UDVQRGDUVNRPNUiH% ORF, ´,OYLWGDQVODUpJLRQGH.UDVQRGDUµ

,)%0$6#$%)(%=-(cw% ORF,, I-6I(0$#%´,OVHWLHQWDXERUGG·XQSUpFLSLFHµ


&HWWHGLIIpUHQFHVHPEOHOLpHjXQHFRQWUDLQWHV\QWD[LTXHORF,HVW
SDUIRLVSUpIpUpORUVTXHOHVXEVWDQWLIHVWDFFRPSDJQpG·XQDGMHFWLI
pSLWKqWHFIQDSHUHGQHPNUiMH´HQSUHPLqUHOLJQH PjPDXERUG
G·DYDQW µ)(%=-(cw´DXERUGGHHQERUGXUHGHµYVLO૟QRP[PpOH´GDQV
XQpWDWGHJUDQGHLYUHVVHµ?%]>!.cw´HQpWDWG·LYUHVVHµ0DLVRQGLUD
?%-6")6>%=-(cw´GDQVVRQSD\VQDWDOµHQUHJDUGGHYqN]RWLɥHVNRPNUiH
´GDQVXQSD\VH[RWLTXHµ UHPDUTXHGH-DNREVRQ /DWHQGDQFH
HVWDQFLHQQHDXGpEXWGX;,;JVLqFOHRQSUpIpUDLW?%$U)#´jO·RPEUHµ
ORF¬, j?%$!)É ORF,, VLOHQRPpWDLWDFFRPSDJQpG·XQHpSLWKqWH
VSDW૟YSUR[ODGQRMWpQL .ROHVRY &HWWHWHQGDQFHVHPEOHYL
YDQWHOHORF,HVWSDUIRLVSUpIpUpjORF,,V·LO\DXQDGMHFWLIRXXQ)
DXWUHGpWHUPLQDQW?%-õ].6>%0)U5! YRLUFHWH[HPSOHGDQVOHWDEOHDX
GHODFRQFOXVLRQ 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 78KD\8Ä)7<bOB,

8$6%&'.6%?%I-6k.6>%?U=!% ORF, ´&HODHVWDUULYpDXVLqFOHGHUQLHUµ

,)%>)656%I6?#"(.%)(%0?6†>%?!=w% ORF,, ´,ODYXELHQGHVFKRVHVDXFRXUVGHVDYLHµ
?%0U$# ORF, ঈHOH]Q\[GRURJ´GDQVOHUpVHDXIHUURYLDLUHµ
YqOHNWULɥHVNRMVHWt ORF,, ´GDQVOHUpVHDXpOHFWULTXHµ
E\W ૟YQHUD]U\YQRMVYMi]L ORF, VNHPVɥHPOLER´rWUHpWURLWHPHQWOLpjTTFKTTQGpSHQGUHGH
TTFKTTQµ
E\W૟YVYMD]t ORF,, 0%=!>M.#&6´DYRLUGHVUHODWLRQVSURFKHVDYHFTTQµ?%0?c(GÉ% ORF,, VɥHPOLER´HQ
UDLVRQGHTTFKµ

!;)1<=>?)@A)BA??C)CD)@=<FGBHD=CI)\BMFAOMB<>=HD])@QADC)HOOH?=>=HD)PHBOGHKHL=^AC)<DF=CDDC)
OHAB)KC?)P<?FAK=D?)C>)@QADC)U<B=<>=HD)<FFCD>ACKKC)OHAB)KC?)NMP=D=D?

!;:;)+LVWRULTXHPHQWJpQ,,HWORF,,GHVPDVFXOLQVUHPRQWHQWjODGpFOLQDLVRQGHVVXEVWDQWLIVPDVFXOLQVVH
FDUDFWpULVDQWSDUOHWKqPHHQ ࠽/HVVXEVWDQWLIVGHFHW\SHpWDLHQWSHXQRPEUHX[%HQYLHX[UXVVHOP%GRP࠽´PDL
9FH2Y%PHG࠽´PLHOµ jO·RULJLQHXQQHXWUH V\Q࠽´ILOVµMDG࠽´SRLVRQµVDG࠽´MDUGLQµYүU[࠽:?´VRPPHWOHGHVVXVµOHG࠽
´JODFHµYRO࠽´E±XIµVDQ࠽´RUGUHUDQJµHWFHWSUREDEOHPHQWGDU࠽´GRQµSLU࠽´IHVWLQµHWG·DXWUHV ,YDQRY
 /DGpFOLQDLVRQHQ ࠽pWDLWHQFRQFXUUHQFHDYHFODGpFOLQDLVRQHQ ‫ڨ‬jODTXHOOHDSSDUWHQDLWXQWUqVJUDQG
QRPEUHGHVXEVWDQWLIVPDVFXOLQVHWODPDMRULWpGHVQHXWUHV'qVO·pSRTXHDQFLHQQH SUHPLHUVWH[WHVYLHX[UXVVHV
;,JVLqFOH OHVGHX[W\SHVV·LQIOXHQFHQWUpFLSURTXHPHQW/HVIDLWVGXYLHX[VODYHHWFHX[G·DXWUHVODQJXHVVODYHV
VRQWVLPLODLUHV 0HLOOHW²/RPWHY²)HXLOOHW² 
$YDQWGHGLVSDUDvWUHOHW\SHHQ ࠽´FRQWDPLQDµHQSDUWLHOHW\SHHQ ‫\ ڨ‬FRPSULVSRXUG·DXWUHVIRUPHVFD
VXHOOHVFRPPHOHGDWLIVLQJXOLHURXOHJpQLWLISOXULHO DLQVLTXHOHW\SHHQWKqPHFRQVRQDQWLTXH DXTXHOUHPRQWH
SDUH[HPSOHMDɥPHQ૟´RUJHµ TXLV·pWDLWUDSSURFKpGXW\SHHQ ‫߰ ڨ‬D[PDWRY²%XOD[RYVNLM²
'RPEURYV]N\²9H\UHQF 
/HVIRUPHVUXVVHVDFWXHOOHVGXJpQLWLIHWGXORFDWLIHQ1VRQWGHVYHVWLJHV VRLWGLUHFWVVRLWGXVjXQMHXWUqV
DQFLHQGHO·DQDORJLHJUDPPDWLFDOH GXW\SHHQ ࠽_)\FRPSULVOHVHPSUXQWVDSSDUXVHQUXVVHSDUDQDORJLHDYDQW
OHPLOLHXGX;,;JVLqFOH WHOVTXH01I´VRXSHµ4!]´DWHOLHUµHWF(E-6I6-$%HVWFHUWHVSOXVUpFHQWPDLVLOIRQFWLRQQH
JUDPPDWLFDOHPHQWFRPPHI6-$ 
/·H[WHQVLRQGXJpQLWLIHWGXORFDWLIHQ1DWWHLQWVRQDSRJpHHQUXVVHDX[;9,J²;9,,JVLqFOHV 8QEHJDXQ
²&RFURQ² RQ\WURXYHPrPHGHVDQLPpV$X;9,,JVLqFOHO·DFFHQWXDWLRQUHVWDLWYDULDEOHOH
JpQLWLIHQ1SRXYDLWDYRLUXQDFFHQWUDGLFDORXXQDFFHQWGpVLQHQWLHOOHORFDWLIHQ1VHFDUDFWpULVDLWGHSUpIpUHQFH
SDUXQDFFHQWGpVLQHQWLHOPDLVLO\DYDLWGHVH[HPSOHVG·DFFHQWUDGLFDO ʓHUQ\[² $X;9,,,JVLqFOHOH
JpQLWLIHQ(¬pWDLWSHUoXFRPPHOLYUHVTXH VW\OHVRXWHQX DORUVTXHOHJpQLWLIHQ1¬pWDLWUHVVHQWLFRPPHXVXHO
UHOHYDQWGXVW\OHGLW´VLPSOHµ0rPHUDSSRUWjO·pSRTXHSRXUOHORFDWLIHQWUHOHVIRUPHVHQ̍!%JK%>J9%GF7MJ9%JH%
1 9LQRJUDGRY 
&HWWHpYROXWLRQHVWUpVXPpHGHIDoRQVFKpPDWLTXHGDQVOHWDEOHDX

OP
5DSSHORQVTXHSDU?#!1]%-100!RQHQWHQGODODQJXHFRPPXQHj
WRXVOHV6ODYHVGHO·(VW ;,J²;9JV OHYLHX[UXVVHUHSUpVHQWHOHSUH
PLHUpWDWQRQVHXOHPHQWGXUXVVHDFWXHOPDLVDXVVLGHO·XNUDLQLHQ
HWGXELpORUXVVHTXLVHFRQVWLWXHQWHQODQJXHVQDWLRQDOHVDSUqVOH
;9JVLqFOH4XDQWDX?#!1]%0.(?!LOV·DJLWG·XQHODQJXHpFULWHpODERUpH
GDQVOHVDQQpHVVXUODEDVHGHO·DQFLHQGLDOHFWHVODYHGXVXG ?#!1]%
&1.5(-6M>(4U"6)#!) SRXUWUDGXLUHGXJUHFOHVOLYUHVVDLQWV/HYLHX[
VODYHIXWORQJWHPSVXWLOLVp DYHFGHVYDULDQWHVORFDOHV HQ5XVVLHHW
GDQVG·DXWUHVSD\VVODYHVFRPPHODQJXHGHFXOWXUHHWODQJXHG·pJOLVH
RUWKRGR[H
:?
/DWUDQVOLWWpUDWLRQXWLOLVpHSRXUOHVYR\HOOHVVSpFLILTXHVGXYLHX[
7L99JN%̍ YR\HOOHIHUPpHDQWpULHXUHү YR\HOOHXOWUDEUqYHDQWp
78JL7J2%࠽ YR\HOOHXOWUDEUqYHSRVWpULHXUH OHVGHX[GHUQLqUHVQRQ
DFFHQWXpHVVLILQDOHV 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @,\Ke\,/%H8\i%DQB/*/F7%8*%H8\i%N,3<*/F7%8B%K\778%@,\K%38K*</B7%7\S7*<B*/F7[% 

`=CAR)BA??C)a,(C)?=bFKCX%
8<?FAK=D)?=DLAK=CB)) 8<?FAK=D)?=DLAK=CB)
'pFOLQDLVRQHQ ȁ 'pFOLQDLVRQHQ ɧ
VQ̍J࠽´QHLJHµ  VQRLJ‫ڨ‬V  GRP࠽´PDLVRQµ  GRP࠽V 
/HP=D<>=N PRVW࠽´SRQWµ  PRVW‫ڨ‬V  PHG࠽ PHG࠽V ´PLHOµ
VWRO࠽´VLqJHWDEOHµ  VWRO‫ڨ‬V V\Q࠽´ILOVµ%  VࡃQ࠽V
-MD=>=N)CD)!"#!$ VQ̍JDPRVWDVWROD "ç>1:O%>U"1%0õ)1
3HF<>=N)CDŧX VQ̍]̍ PRVW̍VWRO̍
::
"6>w%>!"w%0')w
&A??C)PH@CBDC
8<?FAK=D)?=DLAK=CB)!C)@MFK=D<=?HD
%&'(´QHLJHµ% %)*+´PDLVRQµ
/HP=D<>=N >60$´SRQWµ +,)´PLHOµ
0$6.´WDEOHµ 0')´ILOVµ
0)U5(%F,% "ç>(%F<%
-MD=>=N)()CD)c") PyVWi)2 >†"(%F<%
VWROi)2 0õ)(%F<
-MD=>=N)(()CD)!$-- 0)U51%F<% "ç>1%F,% HQORFXWLRQVHXOW 
a?HAUCD>) >†"1%F,%
=D<FFCD>AMX Z/;6;%>60$2%0$6.SDVGHJpQ,,@ Z/;6;%0')SDVGHJpQ,,@
0)U5!%F,% "ç>!%F<%
3HF<>=N)()
a#BMOH?=>=NX)CD)!' >ç0$U%F,% >†"!%F<%
0$6.U%F, 0õ)!%F<
0)!5w%F<% "6>w%F,% ?]%FL%I6ILHWHQORFXWLRQ 
3HF<>=N)(()CD)!.-
<FFCD>AM >60$w%F<% >!"w%F,%
Z/;6;%0$6.SDVGHORF,,@ Z/;6;%0')SDVGHORF,,@
/;6;%F,IRUPHG·RULJLQHF<IRUPHDQDORJLTXH/HVPRWVGXUXVVHPRGHUQHD\DQWjODIRLVJpQ,,HWORF,,
VRQWHQJUDV/HVIRUPHVTXLVRQWKDXWHPHQWFRQFXUUHQWHVGDQVO·XVDJHPRGHUQHVRQWVRXOLJQpHV

!;!;)4XDQWDXORFDWLIGHVIpPLQLQVHQ#DFFHQWXpGXW\SHNRVW૟´RVµ UHPRQWDQWSULQFLSDOHPHQWjO·DQFLHQQH
GpFOLQDLVRQHQ үTXLLQIOXHQoDSDUDLOOHXUVODGpFOLQDLVRQHQ ࠽jODTXHOOHDYDLWDSSDUWHQXXQVXEVWDQWLIFRPPH
NURY૟´VDQJµYLHX[UXVVH =-' LOV·DJLWGHOD´UpFXSpUDWLRQµG·XQHYDULDWLRQDFFHQWXHOOHTXLUHPRQWHjXQpWDW
SURWRVODYH YRLU.ROHVRY²² 
$XGpEXWGX;,;JVLqFOHO·DFFHQWXDWLRQ=-6?É%SRXYDLWrWUHSHUoXHFRPPHSRSXODLUHDORUVTXH=-ç?#pWDLWMXJpH
OLWWpUDLUHHWRXSURSUHjODODQJXHOLWXUJLTXH .ROHVRY² 

S;)#BHJKbPC?)@A)?><>A>)?MP<D>=^AC)@C)LMD;)(()C>)@C)KHF;)((

S;:;)3RXUFHUWDLQVOLQJXLVWHVFRPPH9ঢXUDYOHY ² OHGRXEOHJpQLWLIHWOHGRXEOHORFDWLIGXUXVVH

UHOqYHQWDYDQWWRXWG·XQQLYHOOHPHQWGHVDOORPRUSKHVHWG·XQHQHXWUDOLVDWLRQGHVRSSRVLWLRQVFDVXHOOHVDYHFOH
GDWLI GDW¬ÃORFGDW¬ÃJpQ 6HORQঢXUDYOHYFHVIRUPHVQHSHXYHQWrWUHHQYLVDJpHVHQGLDFKURQLHHWHQV\QFKURQLH
TXHFRPSWHWHQXGHO·HQVHPEOHGHVRSSRVLWLRQVFDVXHOOHVHWGHVSDUDGLJPHV W\SHVGHGpFOLQDLVRQJHQUHQRPEUH
FDWpJRULH´DQLPpµ ,OVRXOLJQHQRWDPPHQWTXHOHQRPVDQLPpVGXW\SHHQ ࠽WHOVTXHV\Q࠽´ILOVµYRO࠽´E±XI µ
IXUHQWOHVSUHPLHUVjUHPSODFHUDXJpQLWLIODGpVLQHQFHG·RULJLQH1%SDUODGpVLQHQFH(% 0')12%?6.1%Ö%0')(2%?6.( j
FDXVHGHO·pPHUJHQFHGXQRXYHO´DFFXVDWLIDQLPpµTXLV·DOLJQDLWVXUOHJpQLWLI DFFDQLPpÃJpQ HWVHFDUDFWpULVDLW
SDUODGpVLQHQFH(FHOOHGXJpQLWLIGXW\SHHQ ‫ڨ‬,OHQUpVXOWHXQHFRUUpODWLRQTXLVHIRUPHSURJUHVVLYHPHQW
VॆQDYyOi JpQDFF a"ç>12%>U"1 JpQ

/·DFFHQWHVWGRQQpjWLWUHK\SRWKpWLTXHOHVWH[WHVDQFLHQVQ·pWDLHQW
:O
SDVWRXMRXUVDFFHQWXpVODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQGHO·DFFHQWXDWLRQQRPLQDOH
HQVODYHFRPPXQHVWGLIILFLOH *DUGH,²² OHV
GRQQpHVpFULWHVGXYLHX[UXVVHHWGXPR\HQUXVVHPRQWUHQWG·LPSRU
WDQWHVYDULDWLRQVDFFHQWXHOOHV .ROHVRY² $YDQWOH;9,,,J%
VLqFOHO·DFFHQWILQDOQ·pWDLWSDVREOLJDWRLUHSRXUOHVIRUPHVGXORFDWLI
JH%M1% ʓHUQ\[² 
::
$YHFXQHSDODWDOLVDWLRQPXWDWLRQKLVWRULTXHGH>J૟@HQ>]૟@
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 78KD\8Ä)7<bOB,

/DSDUWLHJDXFKHGHFHWWHRSSRVLWLRQQHSRXYDLWSDVGHYHQLUPDUTXpHSXLVTXHODIOH[LRQ(FDUDFWpULVDLW
pJDOHPHQWOHVQHXWUHV JpQVLQJQRPDFFSOXU (QUHYDQFKHODSDUWLHGURLWH FHOOHGHVLQDQLPpV GHFHWWH
RSSRVLWLRQGHYLQWPDUTXpHDYHFXQHYDULDWLRQ DOORPRUSKLH M1lM(G·RO·pPHUJHQFHGHVIRUPHVGXJpQLWLIHQ1%
WHOOHVTXH?ç0=1´GHODFLUHµ YHUV V>ç0$1´YHQDQWGXSRQWµ YHUV jF{WpGHVDQFLHQQHV?60=(2%>60$(
&HWWHDSSURFKHSHUPHWG·H[SOLTXHUQRWDPPHQWSRXUTXRLOHVDQLPpVGXUXVVHPRGHUQHWHOVTXH0')2%?6.2%HTFHK%
SDVGHJpQ,,
/DYDULDWLRQORFHQ!ORFHQ1GRLWVHORQঢXUDYOHYrWUHWUDLWpHGDQVOHFDGUHGHVRSSRVLWLRQVGDWORFJpQ
ORF
S;!;)'·DXWUHVOLQJXLVWHVLQVLVWHQWVXUOHFDUDFWqUHVpPDQWLTXHGHVRSSRVLWLRQVJpQ,JpQ,,HWORF,ORF,,
FRPPHOHIDLW5¬-DNREVRQ ² TXLLQVFULWJpQ,,HWORF,,GDQVVRQPRGqOHGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOGXUXVVH
PRGqOHGHYHQXFODVVLTXH¬GDQVOHVWUXFWXUDOLVPHGX;;J%VLqFOH
 QRP ౓ DFF  ౓ JpQ, ౓ JpQ,,
 ౉  ౉  ౉  ౉
 LQVWU ౓ GDW  ౓ ORF, ౓ ORF,,
'DQVFHPRGqOHJpQ,HVWGpILQLFRPPHXQFDVG·´H[WHQVLRQµ \>:()50=(010 ORF,HVWjODIRLVXQFDVG·´H[WHQ
VLRQµ \>:()50=(010 HWXQFDV´SpULSKpULTXHµ K()"=(010 
*pQ,,HWORF,,VHGLVWLQJXHQWLFLGHJpQ,HWORF,SDUAD)PdPCWUDLWVpPDQWLTXH:QFHOXLGH´IRUPDWDJHµ D!0M
$(.$1)5 'XSRLQWGHYXHGHFHWUDLWJpQ,,HWORF,,VRQWGHVFDWpJRULHVPDUTXpHVSDUUDSSRUWjUHVSHFWLYHPHQW
JpQ,HWORF, FDWpJRULHVQRQPDUTXpHV *pQ,,HWORF,,VRQWGRQFGHV´FDVGHIRUPDWDJHµ D!0$(.$1)50=(010 LOV
VLJQDOHQWTXH´O·REMHWQ·DSSDUDvWSDVSDUUDSSRUWDXFRQWHQXGHO·pQRQFpFRPPHXQHIRUPHPDLVFRPPHTXHOTXH
FKRVHHQWUDLQG·rWUHIRUPDWpRXVXVFHSWLEOHG·rWUHIRUPDWpµ "!-%&!G!#4+)!$!%D!5!)0$()"%)#4+$%(.0%D!0$(.$%06)"!-)%(.0%
!$9(0%D!0$(.$!)"!0%6"!-%G1%D!0$(.$!)"!0%#>%7(4+?!-+(.$!%"!-%<100(5!%:1)5#!-$ &HVFKpPDUHQGDVVH]ELHQFRPSWHGX
IRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHJpQ,, FIQHGRVWDWRNɥiMXJpQ,,´TXDQWLWpLQVXIILVDQWHGHWKpµHQUHJDUGGHQHGRVWDWRNɥiMDJpQ
,´GpIDXWGXG·XQWKpµ HWGHORF,, FIU\W૟VMDYVQHJ~ORF,,´IRXLOOHUGDQVODQHLJHµHQUHJDUGGHQD[RGLW૟SUHOHVW૟Y
0)U5!´WURXYHUGXFKDUPHGDQVjODQHLJHµ PDLVLOGHPDQGHXQFHUWDLQHIIRUWG·DEVWUDFWLRQ
3OXVWDUG5-DNREVRQGpYHORSSH  VRQPRGqOHHQpWDEOLVVDQWODSURSRUWLRQVXLYDQWH¬GXSRLQWGHYXH
GXWUDLW´DWWULEXWLRQµ QDGHOLWHO૟QRVW૟ 
5U)L%/% % .64L%/% % "($L% % (44L
JpQ,,  ORF,,  LQVWU  QRP

&HODVLJQLILHTXHJpQ,HWORF,jODGLIIpUHQFHGHJpQ,,HWORF,,DWWULEXHQWjO·REMHWXQHSURSULpWpRXXQpWDW
TXLGpFRXOHGHO·DFWLRQRULHQWpHYHUVO·REMHW$LQVLGDQVERMDW૟VMDVQpJD JpQ, ´FUDLQGUHODQHLJHµODQHLJHDSSD
UDvWFRPPHTXHOTXHFKRVHTXLIRQGHODFUDLQWHGDQVPHɥWDW૟RVQpJH´UrYHUGHODQHLJHµODQHLJH¬DSSDUDvWFRPPH
TXHOTXHFKRVHTXLFRQVWLWXHODVXEVWDQFHGXUrYH(QUHYDQFKHDYHFJpQ,,O·REMHWUHoRLWXQHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQEDQD
OHPHQWTXDQWLWDWLYHDYHFORF,,O·REMHWFRUUHVSRQGVLPSOHPHQWjXQ´UpFLSLHQWµjXQVLPSOH´OLHXµRVHUpDOLVH
O·DFWLRQGpFULWHSDUO·pQRQFp/HVFKpPDQHPDQTXHSDVG·pOpJDQFHPDLVOHUDLVRQQHPHQWVHPEOHWDXWRORJLTXH
(QRXWUHOHVIDLWVGXUXVVHPRGHUQH YRLUQRVH[HPSOHVFRPPHQWpV01I-( WHQGHQWjPRQWUHUO·LQYHUVHHQFHTXL
FRQFHUQHOHUDSSRUWORF,ORF,,F·HVWHQUpDOLWpORF,,TXLLQGLTXHGDQVSOXVLHXUVFRQWH[WHVXQHORFDOLVDWLRQSUR
WRW\SLTXHHVVHQWLHOOHOLpHjODSURSULpWpRXjO·pWDWTXLGpFRXOHGHO·DFWLRQGpFULWHSDUO·pQRQFp$LQVLRQSRXUUDLW
FRQVLGpUHUTXHGDQV%HO૟sPRNQHWYWD]~´/HOLQJHWUHPSHGDQVODEDVVLQHµODEDVVLQHHVWOHORFDOLVDWHXUPXQLGHV
SURSULpWpVTXLGpFRXOHQWGHO·DFWLRQGHWUHPSHUOHOLQJH
S;S;)93OXQJMDQ  SURSRVHSRXUORF,,XQHH[SOLFDWLRQUpVROXPHQWVpPDQWLTXHORF,,VHUDLWOLpjXQH
ORFDOLVDWLRQSDUWLFXOLqUHGpILQLHFRPPH´IL[Hµ´ULJLGHµHW´FRQWUDLQWHµ ঈHVWNRGHWHUPLQLURYDQQDMDORNDOL]DFLMD
VPLQLPDO૟QRMVWHSHQ૟MXVYRERG\ O·REMHWHVWLQVFULWGDQVXQHFRQILJXUDWLRQVSDWLDOHTXLOXLLPSRVHXQHSRVLWLRQ
FRQWUDLQWH )(%&!-!5w´VXUODEHUJHµ?%15.w´GDQVXQFRLQµ RXTXLO·HPSrFKHGHVHGpSODFHUOLEUHPHQW )(%0)!5w%
´VXUODQHLJHµQDO૟GX´VXUODJODFHµ RXELHQLOHVWGDQVXQHFRQILJXUDWLRQIRQFWLRQQHOOHGHW\SH´ULJLGHµFHTXL

:Q
,FLFKH]-DNREVRQOHVWUDLWVVRQWWRXMRXUVQpJDWLIVODFDWpJRULH
PDUTXpHSODFHO·REMHWjXQUDQJKLpUDUFKLTXHLQIpULHXUHQOLPLWDQW
VDPDQLIHVWDWLRQGDQVOHFRQWHQXGHO·pQRQFp$LQVLOHWUDLWG·´H[WHQ
VLRQµLQGLTXHXQHOLPLWDWLRQGHO·H[WHQVLRQQRWLRQQHOOHGHO·REMHWOH
WUDLW´SpULSKpULHµVLJQDOHTXHO·REMHWRFFXSHXQHSODFHQRQFHQWUDOH
GDQVOHFRQWHQXGHO·pQRQFp'HPrPHOHWUDLW´IRUPDWDJHµLQGLTXH
TXHO·REMHWHVW´DEDLVVpµDXUDQJG·XQHVLPSOHTXDQWLILFDWLRQ JpQ¬,, 
RXG·XQVLPSOH´UpFLSLHQWµ ORF,, 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @,\Ke\,/%H8\i%DQB/*/F7%8*%H8\i%N,3<*/F7%8B%K\778%@,\K%38K*</B7%7\S7*<B*/F7[% 

G·DLOOHXUVQ·H[FOXWSDVOD´IL[LWpµVSDWLDOH )(%I60$w´jVRQSRVWHµ%)(%>60$w´VXUOHSRQWµ RXHQFRUHO·REMHWHVW

´SULVµGDQVXQHVXEVWDQFHTXLOHUHFRXYUHFRPSOqWHPHQWTXLFROOHjO·REMHW -1=#%?%>!"w%´OHVPDLQVFRXYHUWHV
WRXWHVJOXDQWHVGHPLHOµ7\YHV૟YJUMD]t´7XHVFRXYHUWGHERXHµ 93OXQJMDQQRWHXQSDUDOOqOHW\SRORJLTXHDYHF
ODSOXSDUWGHVODQJXHVGX'DJKHVWDQTXLGLVSRVHQWGHIRUPHVVSpFLILTXHVFDVXHOOHVSRXUH[SULPHUGHVVLWXDWLRQV
GHORFDOLVDWLRQDQDORJXHV
&HSULQFLSHSHUPHWG·H[SOLTXHUODSOXSDUWGHVHPSORLVGHORF,, FISDUPLOHVSOXVW\SLTXHV¬HWOHVSOXVSDUODQWV%
?%I.!)w´HQFDSWLYLWpµ SDUUDSSRUWjORF,2QFRPSUHQGPLHX[SRXUTXRLFHUWDLQVVXEVWDQWLIVWHOVTXH0$6.´WDEOHµ
Q·RQWSDVGHORF,, LPSRVVLEOH¬G·DYRLU)(%j0$6.wFHVHUDWRXMRXUV)(%0$6.UORF, ELHQTX·LOVVRLHQWHQDSSDUHQFH
GHVFDQGLGDWVLGpDX[SRXUFHU{OH(QHIIHWODWDEOHHVWXQREMHWKDXWHPHQWSRO\IRQFWLRQQHOTXLWHQGjH[FOXUHOD
ORFDOLVDWLRQ´IL[HµVLTXHOTXHFKRVHHVWSODFp01-%.(%$(&.!QRUPDOHPHQWFHQ·HVWSDVSRXU\UHVWHUPDLVSRXUrWUH
PDQLSXOpXWLOLVpHWF3DUFRQVpTXHQWODSRVLWLRQ01-%.(%$(&.!Q·HVWSDVXQHSRVLWLRQVXIILVDPPHQW´FRQWUDLQWHµ
SRXUMXVWLILHUXQORF,,(QUHYDQFKHODSRVLWLRQ%(1l01-%.!%06.l01-%.!%I.()4+!-%VDWLVIDLWELHQPLHX[DXFULWqUHGH
SRVLWLRQ´FRQWUDLQWHµXQREMHWTXLWRPEHVXUOHVRODSOXVGHFKDQFHVG·\UHVWHULQGpILQLPHQW :<SXLVTX·LOGHYLHQW
SOXVGLIILFLOHjPDQLSXOHU LOIDXWVHEDLVVHUSRXUOHUDPDVVHUDOOHUOHFKHUFKHUVRXVXQPHXEOHHWF ,OHVWGRQF
ORJLTXHTXHODVLWXDWLRQFRUUHVSRQGDQWHVRLWGpFULWHSDUORF,,)(%I6.wL
&HPRGqOHVpPDQWLTXHSHXWjQRWUHDYLVrWUHDFFHSWpjFRQGLWLRQSHXWrWUHGHSUpIpUHUDXWHUPHGH.64(.#0($#6)%
:#]!-FL--#5#"!-FHOXLGH.64(.#0($#6)%46)$-(#)$!%HQSUpFLVDQW«!$l61%I-6$6$'I#X1!% YRLUOHVH[HPSOHVHWQRWUHDUJXPHQ
K6K8FH%01I-( ¬/DTXHVWLRQPpULWHFHUWHVXQHpWXGHSOXVDSSURIRQGLHQRWDPPHQWFRQFHUQDQWOHVQRPVDXWRULVDQW
XQHYDULDWLRQORF,ORF,,

4HDFKA?=HD

/DGXDOLWpSDUWLHOOHGXJpQLWLIHWGXORFDWLIUXVVHVSRVHSOXVLHXUVSUREOqPHVGRQWOHVIDFWHXUVVRQWOHVVXL
YDQWV
ƒ OHVIRUPHVGXJpQLWLIHWGXORFDWLIPDVFXOLQHQ1VRQWXQHVXUYLYDQFHGHVDQFLHQVWKqPHVGHGpFOLQDLVRQ
HQ ࠽FHVDQFLHQVWKqPHVD\DQWFRQQXXQHH[WHQVLRQDVVH]LPSRUWDQWHDXFRXUVGHO·pYROXWLRQGHOD
ODQJXH
ƒ O·DFFHQWHVWLQWHUYHQXGDQVO·pYROXWLRQGHVIRUPHVSRXUOHVPDVFXOLQVGXUXVVHPRGHUQHD\DQWjODIRLV
JpQ,,HWORF,,OHORFDWLIHQ1HVWWRXMRXUVDFFHQWXpVXUODILQDOHjODGLIIpUHQFHGXJpQLWLIHQ1% JpQ
,, HWGXGDWLIjDFFHQWUDGLFDOTXDQWDXORFDWLIIpPLQLQHQ#DFFHQWXp ORF,, VHXOO·DFFHQWOHGLVWLQJXH
GXORF,HQM#LQDFFHQWXpDLQVLTXHGXJpQLWLIHWGXGDWLI OHVGHX[HQM#LQDFFHQWXppJDOHPHQW 
ƒ HQGHKRUVGHVORFXWLRQVILJpHVOHJpQLWLIVHFRQGGXUXVVHPRGHUQHDSSDUDvWGDQVGHVFRQWH[WHVOLpVjOD
TXDQWLILFDWLRQ HPSORL´SDUWLWLI µ PDLVO·XVDJHPRGHUQHWHQGjOXLVXEVWLWXHUGDQVFHWWHIRQFWLRQOHJpQLWLI
´RUGLQDLUHµHQ(:RJpQ,,QHFRQVWLWXHSDVXQHFDWpJRULHYUDLPHQWVSpFLILTXH G·DXWDQWSOXVTX·LOHVW
KRPRQ\PLTXHGXGDWLI VDXIGDQVGHVUDUHVRFFDVLRQVRJpQ,UHVWHGLIILFLOH9RLFLHQVFKpPDWLVDQW

&RPPHOHGLWVLELHQOHIUDQoDLVSRSXODLUHì(%)!%$6>&!-(%I(0%I.10%&(0ä
:<
:R
(QHIIHWOHJpQLWLIGHVDXWUHVVXEVWDQWLIVPDVVLIV PDVFXOLQVVDQV
JpQ,,IpPLQLQVHQ(IpPLQLQVGHW\SHVRO૟´VHOµQHXWUHVHWF SHXW
DXVVL DYRLU XQ HPSORL ´SDUWLWLIµ VDQV TX·LO \ DLW GHV IRUPHV VSp
FLILTXHVFIY\SLW૟YRGॆYLQi´ERLUHGHO·HDXGXYLQµHWNDɥHVWYR
?6"õ%YLQi´ODTXDOLWpGHO·HDXGXYLQµ6XUOHSODQW\SRORJLTXHRQ
SHXWSHQVHUDXSDUWLWLIIUDQoDLVTXLOXLQRQSOXVQ·DSDVGHIRUPH
SDUWLFXOLqUHSDUUDSSRUWDX´JpQLWLIDQDO\WLTXHµGXFRPSOpPHQWGX
HFMN%&6#-!%)'-/0'"$%l%)$-123%m%.(%X1(.#$U-)'-/0'"$-#-)$-123
&HWHPSORLGXJpQLWLIDSXVHGpYHORSSHUHQUXVVHVRXVO·LQIOXHQFH
GHVODQJXHVILQQRRXJULHQQHVGHOD%DOWLTXH FRPPHOHYHSVH TXL
GLVSRVHQWG·XQFDVVSpFLILTXHSRXUOHSDUWLWLI 3OXQJMDQ² 
jPRLQVTX·LOQHV·DJLVVHG·XQHFRQVWDQWHW\SRORJLTXH FIjSURSRV
GXSDVVDJH´DEODWLI!SDUWLWLIµ+HLQHHW.XWHYD 3DUDLOOHXUV
RQVDLWTXHOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGXJpQLWLI´SDUWLWLI µUXVVH H[SULPp
SDUJpQ,RXJpQ,, HVWOLPLWpSDUO·DVSHFWGXYHUEHVHXOOHSHUIHF
WLI SDVVpRXIXWXU DGPHWOHJpQLWLI´SDUWLWLI µ-DY\SLOY\S૟MXYRGॆ
JpQ YLQi JpQ ɥiMX JpQ,, ɥiMD JpQ, ´-·DLEXMHERLUDLGH
O·HDXGXYLQGXWKpµ2QQHSHXWSDVDYRLUjO·LPSHUIHFWLI SUpVHQW
SDVVpRXIXWXU -DS૟MXSLOEXGXSLW૟ YRGॆ JpQ  YLQi JpQ  ɥiMX%
JpQ,,  ɥiMD JpQ, ­O·LPSHUIHFWLIVHXOO·DFFXVDWLIHVWSRVVLEOH
VDXIV·LO\DQpJDWLRQ HWOHVHQVSDUWLWLIQ·DSDVDORUVGHPDUTXDJH
HQGHKRUVGXFRQWH[WH-DS૟MXSLOEXGXSLW૟YyGX DFF l%?#)ç% DFF 
ɥDM DFF ´-·DLEXMHERLUDL@C)KQJ6L%61%KQJ6L%W%@AYLQ61%KCYLQ
@AWKp61%KCWKpµ

 (Q GpSLW GH O·DYLV GH 9 9LQRJUDGRY    TXL YD MXVTX·j
SURSRVHU SRXU JpQ ,, XQH ´FDWpJRULH G·DEVWUDFWLRQµ =($!56-#c(%
RWYOHɥsQQRVWL  HW XQH ´FDWpJRULH GH VXEVWDQWLDOLWp PDWpULHOOHµ
=($!56-#c(%YHߖɥHVWYHQQRVWL 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 78KD\8Ä)7<bOB,

LMD;)(I)0HA?)KC?)?AJ?><D>=N?) LMD;)((I)%DC)O<B>=C)@C?)?AJ?><D>=N?)
@MFK=D<JKC?)a?=)?CD?)<@<O>MX @MFK=D<JKC?)P<?F;)!C)@MFK;

0HA?)CPOKH=?)GHB?)?CD?)
^A<D>=><>=Ne\O<B>=>=N] &!.#G)(%0)U5(´ODEODQFKHXU% 
GHODQHLJHµ
^A<?=)>H><K=>M)@C?)  
DHP?)P<??=N? >)656%0)U5(%´EHDXFRXSGHQHLJHµ >)656%0)U51%´EHDXFRXSGHQHLJHµ
0HA?)CPOKH=?)
f)?CD?)^A<D>=><>=Ne 
FCB><=D?)@=P=DA>=N?)
\O<B>=>=N] @C?)DHP?)P<??=N?)) c 'REDY૟VQHঈN~´$MRXWHXQSHX
aCD)!*45-,45-!64X GHQHLJHµ1%VQHঈyN%J9K%LH%
GLPLQXWLIGH0)!5
4CB><=DC?)FHD?>BAF>=HD?)f)?CD?)
c 
^A<D>=><>=N)<UCF)DHP?)P<??=N? 7)U51M$6ä´4XHGHQHLJHµ

ƒ HQGHKRUVGHVORFXWLRQVILJpHVOHORFDWLIVHFRQGGXUXVVHPRGHUQHSUpVHQWHSDUUDSSRUWjORF,XQHPSORL
VpPDQWLTXHSDUWLFXOLHUHWVHPEOHFRQVWLWXHUXQHFDWpJRULHVSpFLILTXH TXRLTXHDSSDUDLVVDQWFRPPH
PDUJLQDOH´LQFRPSOqWHµSXLVTXHV·pWHQGDQWjXQQRPEUHOLPLWpGHVXEVWDQWLIV GDQVODPHVXUHRLO
H[SULPHGDQVOHFDGUHGHODORFDOLVDWLRQ0$-#4$6%0!)01SDURSSRVLWLRQjODTXDVLORFDOLVDWLRQ ORFDOLVDWLRQ
DEVWUDLWH XQHORFDOLVDWLRQ´FRQWUDLQWHµHWRXSURWRW\SLTXHSDURSSRVLWLRQjXQHORFDOLVDWLRQ´JOREDOHµ
PrPHVLO·XVDJHPRGHUQHSHXWSDUIRLVOXLVXEVWLWXHUGDQVFHWWHIRQFWLRQOHORFDWLI´RUGLQDLUHµHQ! RQ
SHXWVFKpPDWLVHUODVLWXDWLRQDFWXHOOHGDQVOHWDEOHDXVXLYDQWVXUO·H[HPSOHGH0)!5´QHLJHµ.!0´IRUrW
ERLV FRPPHPDWpULDXGHFRQVWUXFWLRQ µHWGHJUMD]૟´ERXHµ

KHF;)(I)0HA?)KC?)?AJ?><D>=N?)@MFK=D<JKC?)) KHF;)((I)%DC)O<B>=C)@C?)?AJ?><D>=N?)
a?=)?CD?)<@<O>MX @MFK=D<JKC?)P<?F;)!C)@MFK;)g)NMP;)SC)@MFK;
g)
+POKH=)\CROK=F<>=N])a<UCF) JRYRULW૟RVQpJH%ROpVHRJUMi]L´SDUOHU
c
OBMOH?=>=HD)<A>BC)^AC)7_)&"X GHODQHLJHGHODIRUrW*$GXERLV
FRPPHPDWpULDX GHODERXHµ

'A<?=)KHF<K=?<>=HD))
2QQD[RGLWSUHOHVW૟GDঈHYVQpJH%ll%?%.U0!%ll%?%
a\<J?>B<=>C]X JUMi]L´,OWURXYHGXFKDUPHPrPHGDQVj c
ODQHLJHGDQVjODIRUrW*$GDQVOHERLV
FRPPHPDWpULDX GDQVjODERXHµ
g) g)
B(k.#%0.!"'%-("#6(=$#?)60$#%?%0)U5!:@%ll%7- B(k.#%0.!"'%-("#6(=$#?)60$#%7-/'%.-´2QD
/3%'YJUMi]L´2QDWURXYpGHVWUDFHVGH WURXYpGHVWUDFHVGHUDGLRDFWLYLWp@<D?)K<)
\LKHJ<KC]
UDGLRDFWLYLWpGDQVODQHLJH@<D?%KC) NHBd>Y%/;6;%?%[[0)!5w%ll%?%[[5-c(GÉ
JH=?)aFHPPC)P<>MB=<AXGDQVODERXHµ

3HF<K=?<>=HD) agX) :-
%18691*-%'&%$ A'%1?c(G.#%?%§-'].6>•%0)U5!%ll%?%§$†>)6c•% A'%1?c(G.#%?%0)!5w%ll%?%5-c(GÉ%´1RVSLHGVVH
JUMi]L´1RVSLHGVVHVRQWHQIRQFpVGDQVOD VRQWHQIRQFpVGDQVODQHLJHGDQVOD
\FHD>B<=D>C]) QHLJH>SRXGUHXVH@GDQVODERXH>QRLUH@ ERXH FHTXLQRXVHPSrFKHG·DYDQFHU µ
C>eHA)
OBH>H>EO=^AC FHTXLQRXVHPSrFKHG·DYDQFHU µ
g)
c JXOMDW૟%WW%]DEOXGLW૟VMDYOHV~:P%´VHSURPHQHU
VHSHUGUHGDQVODIRUrWµ
/;6;/HVLJQH  LQGLTXHTXHOHVIRUPHVGHFHW\SHSHXYHQWrWUHUHVVHQWLHVSDUFHUWDLQVORFXWHXUVFRPPHLQFRUUHFWHVRXTX·HOOHV
VRQWOLpHVjGHVSDUWLFXODULWpVFRQWH[WXHOOHVVpPDQWLFRV\QWD[LTXHV/HJUDVVLJQDOHGHX[VHQVGLIIpUHQWVSRXU.!0

:@
/DPRLWLpGHVKXLWH[HPSOHVSRXU?% d %0)U5!%GFL7H89%=67%K1046-I6-(%
²VRQWSURFKHVGHFHFRQWH[WH3DUDLOOHXUV*RRJOHGRQQH
SRXUODVpTXHQFH´?%0)U5!% WRXVFRQWH[WHV HQYLURQPLOOHRFFXU
UHQFHVHWSRXU´?%0)!5wµSOXVGHPLOOHRFFXUUHQFHV

1RXVDYRQVSOXVLHXUVH[HPSOHVGHW\SHVSURFKHV PrPHVDQVDGMHF
WLIRXDXWUHGpWHUPLQDQWGHYDQW0)!5! IRXUQLVSDU*RRJOHHWSDU
K1046-I6-(%²(QUHYDQFKHSRXUOHFRQWH[WHGXW\SH856%)(k.#%
>†-$?'>%?%0)!5w% ORF,, ´2QO·D UH WURXYpPRUWGDQVODQHLJHµQRXV
Q·DYRQVULHQUHOHYpDYHF?% d %0)U5! ORF, 
:P
/DIRUPHHQ! ORF, UHVWHLPSRVVLEOHGDQVO·H[SUHVVLRQGHFHW\SH
GHORFDOLVDWLRQDLQVLODFRQVWUXFWLRQJXOMDW૟%?% d %U.U0!%HVWDEVHQWHGH
K1046-I6-( XQVHXOH[HPSOHHVWIRXUQLSDU*RRJOHPDLVLOHVWIRUW
GRXWHX[ 
Q?
-HUHPHUFLH)UDQoRLV0XOOHU3URIHVVHXUjO·8QLYHUVLWp3DULVTXL
DUHOXFHWH[WHHWDSSRUWpGHVFRUUHFWLRQV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @,\Ke\,/%H8\i%DQB/*/F7%8*%H8\i%N,3<*/F7%8B%K\778%@,\K%38K*</B7%7\S7*<B*/F7[% 

3RXUUpVXPHUVXUXQHQRWHKXPRULVWLTXHWDQWTX·HQ5XVVLHLO\DXUDGHVIRUrWV RRQULVTXHGHVHSHUGUH GH

ODQHLJHHWGHODERXH TXLUHQGHQWSDUIRLVLPSUDWLFDEOHVURXWHVFKHPLQVVHQWLHUVHWWURWWRLUV OHORFDWLIVHFRQG
QHYDSDVGLVSDUDvWUHQ?
(QUHYDQFKHOHJpQLWLIVHFRQGULVTXHGHGHYHQLUGHSOXVHQSOXVPDUJLQDOFRPPHOHPRQWUHQWOHVWHQGDQFHV
GHO·XVDJHPRGHUQHGDQVOHVWH[WHVGHVYLQJWGHUQLqUHVDQQpHVK1046-I6-(QHUHFHQVHTXHGHX[RFFXUUHQFHVGH
>)656%0)U51 JpQ,, ´EHDXFRXSGHQHLJHµOHVGHX[OLpHVjGHVFRQWH[WHVGXSDVVp VRXYHQLUVGHSHUVRQQHVQpHV
DYDQW VXUTXDWRU]HRFFXUUHQFHVGH>)656%0)U5( JpQ, GRQWODSOXSDUWOLpHVjGHVHPSORLVFRQWHPSRUDLQV
1pDQPRLQVOHJpQLWLIVHFRQGQ·HVWSDVYRXpjXQHGLVSDULWLRQLPPLQHQWHHWLOGRLWVHPDLQWHQLUGDQVOHV\V
WqPHGXUXVVHFDULOFRQVWLWXHOHSHQGDQWGXORFDWLIVHFRQG6HORQ%8VSHQVNLM  TXLGpYHORSSHHWHQULFKLW
ODGpPDUFKHGH5-DNREVRQ  ODFRUUpODWLRQJpQ,JpQ,,HWODFRUUpODWLRQORF,ORF,,SHXYHQWrWUH
VLWXpHVWRXWHVOHVGHX[GDQVOHFDGUHGHO·RSSRVLWLRQJpQpUDOH´XQWRXWµ´SDUWLHG·XQWRXWµRSSRVLWLRQjODTXHOOH
VHUDWWDFKHQWpJDOHPHQWG·DXWUHVSKpQRPqQHVJUDPPDWLFDX[GXUXVVH
%8VSHQVNLM  UHPDUTXHjMXVWHWLWUHTXH?%0)!5w ORF,, ´GDQVODQHLJHµSHXWLPSOLTXHU>)656%0)U51%
JpQ,, ´EHDXFRXSGHQHLJHµ&HODpWDEOLWXQUDSSRUWLPSRUWDQWDYHFO·RSSRVLWLRQ´XQWRXW´´SDUWLHG·XQWRXWµ
HQHIIHW´rWUHjO·LQWpULHXUGHTTFKµVXSSRVH´IDLUHSDUWLHGHTTFKµ&HWWHLGpHV·DFFRUGHELHQDYHFODQRWLRQGH
´ORFDOLVDWLRQFRQWUDLQWHµFRPPHFDUDFWpULVDWLRQVpPDQWLTXHGXORFDWLIVHFRQGDLQVLTX·DYHFOHVHQVTXDQWLWDWLI
´SDUWLWLI µGXJpQLWLIVHFRQG
/DTXHVWLRQGXGRXEOHJpQLWLIHWGXGRXEOHORFDWLIUHVWHXQVXMHWOLQJXLVWLTXHSDVVLRQQDQWTXLQ·HVWSDVHQWLq
UHPHQWH[SORUp

6=JK=HLB<OG=C
%DNODQRY*-X
% OPR@% -XঈQHHJODYQRJRXGDUD0RVFRX6RYHWVNLMSLVDWHO
%XOD[RYVNLM/$
  ,VWRULɥHVNLMNRPPHQWDULMNUXVVNRPXMD]\NX.LHY5DGMDQV૟NDߖNROD
ʓHUQ\[3-
% OPRQ% -D]\N8ORঈHQLMDJRGD0RVFRX,]G$NDGHPLL1DXN6665
&RFURQ)ULHGULFK
  N(%.()51!%-100!%"()0%.(%0!46)"!%>6#$#U%"1%iT//%!%0#E4.!g%>6-I+6.65#!3DULV,QVWLWXWG·eWXGHV6ODYHV
"FMKJK2%,FIJ7
  ´3RXUXQHDSSURFKHV\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWYDULDWLRQQLVWHGXUXVVHG·DXMRXUG·KXLµN(%-!?1!%-100!%RN%
²
% :??:% D-(>>(#-!%"1%-100!%46)$!>I6-(#)7RXORXVH3UHVVHV8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGX0LUDLO
'RPEURYV]N\-
  ,VWRULɥHVNDMDJUDPPDWLNDUXVVNRJRMD]\ND0RUIRORJLMDLVLQWDNVLV%XGDSHVW7DQN|Q\YNLDGR
'DVPHU 9DVPHU 0
  (WLPRORJLɥHVNLMVORYDU૟UXVVNRJRMD]\ND7²0RVFRX3URJUHVV
)HXLOOHW-DFN
% OPPP% D-(>>(#-!%+#0$6-#X1!%"1%&1.5(-!3DULV,QVWLWXWG·eWXGHV6ODYHV
)LOLQ)3pG
% OP@P% K100=#c%c(G'=g%8)4#=.6I!"#c(L%0RVFRX6RYHWVNDMD(QFLNORSHGLMD
*DUGH3DXO
  O#0$6#-!%"!%.;(44!)$1($#6)%0.(?!L%3DULV,QVWLWXWG·eWXGHV6ODYHV
  D-(>>(#-!%-100!g%I+6)6.65#!2%>6-I+6.65#!L3DULV,QVWLWXWG·eWXGHV6ODYHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q@?% 78KD\8Ä)7<bOB,

+HLQH%HUQGHW7DQLD.XWHYD
% :??:% J6-."%N!]#46)%6:%D-(>>($#4(.#G($#6)&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
,YDQRY99
% OPP?% ,VWRULɥHVNDMDJUDPPDWLNDUXVVNRJRMD]\ND0RVFRX3URVYHߖɥHQLH
-DNREVRQ5RPDQ
  ´%HLWUDJ]XUDOOJHPHLQHQ.DVXVOHKUH*HVDPWEHGHXWXQJHQGHUUXVVLVFKHQ.DVXVµ'DQV*-(?(1]%"1%
3!-4.!%N#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@-(51!9ROXPHSS²5HLPSUHVVLRQK!("#)50%#)%N#)51#0$#40,,pGLWpSDU(
3+DPSHWDOSS²&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVV
  ´0RUIRORJLɥHVNLHQDEOMXGHQLMDQDGVODYMDQVNLPVNORQHQLHP6RVWDYUXVVNL[SDGHঈQ\[IRUPµ'DQV
7!.!4$!"%J-#$#)502%1F>LMJ%:N%J6-"%()"%N()51(5!pGLWpSDU5-DNREVRQSS²7KH+D\H0RXWRQ
3UHPLqUHSXEOLFDWLRQ
-DQGD/DXUD$
  S(4=%:-6>%$+!%S-#)=g%<%7$1"'%6:%O69%K!.#4%F6->0%#)%N()51(5!0%7!-?!%(0%761-4!%A($!-#(.%:6-%<)(.65#4(.%8]$!)M
0#6)0XQLFK/,1&20
-DUFHYD91pG
% OPP?% /LQJYLVWLɥHVNLMqQFLNORSHGLɥHVNLMVORYDU૟0RVFRX6RYHWVNDMD(QFLNORSHGLMD
.ROHVRY9ODGLPLU9
% OP@:% /0$6-#c(%-100=656%1"(-!)#c(g%/>!))(c(%(=4!)$1(4#c(%?%"-!?)!-100=6>%c(G'=!L6DLQW3pWHUVERXUJ/HQLQ
JUDGVNRJR8QLY
.RU&KDKLQH,ULQDHW5REHUW5RXGHW
% :??Q% D-(>>(#-!%-100!g%.!0%0$-14$1-!0%"!%&(0!3DULV(OOLSVHV
/RPWHY73
  6UDYQLWHO૟QRLVWRULɥHVNDMDJUDPPDWLNDYRVWRɥQRVODYMDQVNL[MD]\NRY0RVFRX9\VߖDMDߖNROD
0J8>>JK2%!HKF8HJ
% OPQ<% N!%0.(?!%46>>1)JMJpG&ROOHFWLRQGH0DQXHOV3DULV&KDPSLRQ
3ORWQLNRYD9$
  ´6NORQHQLHLPHQVXߖɥHVWYLWHO૟Q\[µ'DQVK100=(c(%5-(>>($#=(pGLWpSDU1-߰YHGRYDSS²
0RVFRX1DXND
3OXQJMDQ9$
% :???% 2EߖɥDMDPRUIRORJLMD9YHGHQLHYSUREOHPDWLNX0RVFRX(GLWRULDO8566
  ´.VHPDQWLNHUXVVNRJRORNDWLYD ¶YWRURJRSUHGORঈQRJR·SDGHঈD µ7!>#6$#=(%#%/):6->($#=(²
K1046-I6-(%
% ² 1DFLRQDO૟Q\MNRUSXVUXVVNRJRMD]\NDZZZUXVFRUSRUDUX
6DNKQR6HUJXHL
  N!0%o%IU4+U0%"1%-100!L%3DULV(OOLSVHV
߰D[PDWRY$$
% OPR@% ,VWRULɥHVNDMDPRUIRORJLMDUXVVNRJRMD]\ND0RVFRX*RVXɥSHGJL]
߰YHGRYD1-pG
  K100=(c(%5-(>>($#=(L0RVFRX1DXND
6XOOLYDQ:LOOLDP-
  7I(4!%()"%*#>!%#)%K100#()g%<%H!04-#I$#6)%6:%$+!%N6410%@-!I60#$#6)0%6:%K100#()0XQLFK/,1&20
 oi.uchicago.edu

% @,\Ke\,/%H8\i%DQB/*/F7%8*%H8\i%N,3<*/F7%8B%K\778%@,\K%38K*</B7%7\S7*<B*/F7[% Q@O

7UXEHW]NR\16
  ´*HGDQNHQEHUGLHVORYDNLVFKH'HNOLQDWLRQµ7&6-)#=%A($#4!%0.6?!)0=U²5HLPSUHVVLRQ
K!("#)50%#)%N#)51#0$#40,,pGLWpSDU(3+DPSHWDOSS²&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR
3UHVV
8QEHJDXQ%RULV2WWRNDU
% OPQR% N(%.()51!%-100!%(1%iT/%!%0#E4.!%^_sppq_ssp`2%1F>LMJ%ON%.(%:.!]#6)%"!0%)6>0L%3DULV,QVWLWXWG·eWXGHV6ODYHV
8VSHQVNLM%$
% OPP<% .UDWNLMRɥHUNLVWRULLUXVVNRJROLWHUDWXUQRJRMD]\ND ;,²;,;YY 0RVFRX*QR]LV
% :??<% ʓDVW·LFHORHYUXVVNRMJUDPPDWLNH0RVFRX-D]\NLUXVVNRMNXO·WXU\
9DLOODQW$QGUp
  D-(>>(#-!%46>I(-U!%"!0%.()51!0%0.(?!02%1F>LMJ%:N%A6-I+6.65#!/\RQ,$&
9H\UHQF&KDUOHV-DFTXHV
% OP@?% O#0$6#-!%"!%.(%.()51!%-100!3DULV3UHVVHV8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGH)UDQFH
9LQRJUDGRY9LNWRU9
% OPQ<% 2ɥHUNLSRLVWRULLUXVVNRJROLWHUDWXUQRJRMD]\ND;9,,²;,;YY0RVFRZ*RVXɥSHGL]G
  5XVVNLMMD]\N*UDPPDWLɥHVNRHXɥHQLHRVORYHqPHpG0RVFRX9\VߖDMDߖNROD
:RUWK'6
  ´5XVVLDQJHQড়ORFড়UHYLVLWHGµ'DQV7#5)0%6:%F-#!)"0+#Ig%*6%O6)61-%<L%DL%FL%?()%O6.=2%7.(?#0$2%N#)51#0$2%
7!>#6$#4#()pGLWpSDU--YDQ%DDNSS²$PVWHUGDP5RGRSL
=DOL]QLDN$$
  K100=6!%#>!))6!%0.6?6#G>!)!)#!0RVFRX1DXND
ঢXUDYOHY9.
% OPPO% 'LD[URQLɥHVNDMDPRUIRORJLMD0RVFRX1DXND
oi.uchicago.edu
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8D<KH7%7\K%N87%3<7%H<B7%N87%N<BD\87%,\K<N/8BB87% Q@Q

!"
#$%&#'()(*#)+$(),&()'&-()+$()+&-%*$().*#&+/$--$(

P!()%@!--6$W2%Q46.!%@-($#X1!%"!0%O(1$!0%Q$1"!0%^@(-#0`

/·H[SRVpTXLVXLWVHOLPLWHUDjODSUpVHQWDWLRQGHTXHOTXHVIDLWVFRQFHUQDQWODPRUSKRORJLHFDVXHOOHHWOHIRQF
WLRQQHPHQWGHVFDVGDQVOHVODQJXHVGHODIDPLOOHRXUDOLHQQHVRLWSRXUXQHYXHG·HQVHPEOHGHFHVIDLWVGDQVOD
IDPLOOHVRLWSRXUPHWWUHHQpYLGHQFHODVSpFLILFLWpGHFHUWDLQHVGRQQpHVREVHUYpHVGDQVWHOOHODQJXHRXEUDQFKH
GHODIDPLOOHpYHQWXHOOHPHQWDILQGHFRQWHVWHUOHVDQDO\VHVSURSRVpHVSRXUFHVGRQQpHV/HVIDLWVpYRTXpVFRQFHU
QHURQWG·DERUGO·H[WHQVLRQGHODPRUSKRORJLHFDVXHOOHSXLVODVWUXFWXUHLQWHUQHGHVV\VWqPHVGHFDV

01)$23456785)94):;)<8=>?8:8@74)A;6B4::4
/HQRPEUHGHVFDVYDULHEHDXFRXSVHORQOHVODQJXHVHWjO·LQWpULHXUPrPHGHVGLIIpUHQWHVEUDQFKHVGHO·HQ
VHPEOHILQQRRXJULHQLO\DGDYDQWDJHG·XQLWpGDQVOHVODQJXHVGHODEUDQFKHVDPR\qGHRRQDHQUqJOHJpQpUDOH
VL[FDVPDUTXpVjF{WpGXQRPLQDWLIQRQPDUTXp'DQVODEUDQFKHRXJULHQQHGHODVRXVIDPLOOHILQQRRXJULHQQH
OHKRQJURLVHVWQHWWHPHQWULFKHHQFDV6DXYDJHRWGDQVO·80X1#00!%"!%.(%.()51!%+6)5-6#0! 6DXYDJHRW SDUWGHV
FDVTXH6]LQQ\HLDYDLWMDGLVUHFRQQXVHQDMRXWDQWPrPHTXHO·RQSRXUUDLWDOOHUMXVTX·jUHFRQQDvWUHFDV
$XMRXUG·KXLRQWHQGjIL[HUQHWWHPHQWSOXVEDVO·HIIHFWLIGHVFDVDXWKHQWLTXHVXQOLQJXLVWHV·DUUrWHjIRUPHV
FDVXHOOHVXQDXWUHj .LHIHU HWODSUpVHQWDWLRQTXLVHUDIDLWHGHVFDVLFLHQUpGXLWOHQRPEUHj/HV
ODQJXHVRXJULHQQHVGH6LEpULHSDUHQWHVOHVSOXVSURFKHVGXKRQJURLVRQWHOOHVXQQRPEUHGHFDVWUqVLQIpULHXU
FDV QRPLQDWLIFRPSULV HQYRJRXOGXQRUG VHXOGLDOHFWHYRJRXOHQFRUHYLYDQW HWOHSOXVVRXYHQWjFDVHQ
RVWLDNQRPLQDWLIFRPSULV/HVFDVPDUTXpVVRQWXQGDWLIODWLIXQORFDWLIXQDEODWLIXQLQVWUXPHQWDOILQDOHW
XQLQVWUXPHQWDOVRFLDWLI2QREVHUYHUDTXHODGpFOLQDLVRQGHVQRPVGDQVOHVGHX[ODQJXHVRXJULHQQHVGH6LEpULH
QHFRPSRUWHSDVG·DFFXVDWLIFRQWUDLUHPHQWDXKRQJURLVRXJULHQG·(XURSHGRQWOHV\VWqPHFDVXHOVHUDH[DPLQp
SOXVORLQ
'XF{WpEDOWRIHQQLTXHpJDOHPHQWLO\DGHVVLWXDWLRQVYDULDEOHVVHORQOHVEUDQFKHVDYHFDXPRLQVFDV
´JUDPPDWLFDX[µ QRPLQDWLIRXFDV]pURJpQLWLISDUWLWLI XQQRPEUHYDULDEOHGHFDV´DGYHUELDX[µGHVFDVORFDX[
HWXQWUDQVODWLI2QUHFHQVHFDVHQHVWRQLHQGRQWOHVFDVJUDPPDWLFDX[HWpJDOHPHQWFDVHQILQQRLVDYHF
LH%<JFDVJUDPPDWLFDOO·DFFXVDWLI'DQVODEUDQFKHILQQRSHUPLHQQHLO\DFDVHQ]\ULqQHHWHQYRWLDNLO\D
FDVGDQVODGpFOLQDLVRQLQGpWHUPLQpHHWFDVGDQVODGpFOLQDLVRQGpWHUPLQpH SRVVHVVLYH /HPRUGYHSRVVqGH
FDVPDLVRIIUHXQHVLWXDWLRQSDUWLFXOLqUHTXLVHUDpYRTXpHSOXVORLQ/HODSRQDFDV
$XQLYHDXGHODSURWRODQJXHRXUDOLHQQHRQQHUHFRQVWUXLWTXHFDVGRQWFDVJUDPPDWLFDX[ QRPLQDWLI
DFFXVDWLIJpQLWLI HWFDVORFDX[ ORFDWLIODWLIHWDEODWLI 0DLVGHQRPEUHXVHVGLVFXVVLRQVVRQWLQWHUYHQXHVQRWDP
PHQWVXUO·DFFXVDWLIHQM>TXLH[LVWHHQWFKpUpPLVVHGLDOHFWDOHPHQWHQODSRQHQYRJRXOHWHQVDPR\qGHRQDYX
GDQVFHM>XQHPDUTXHGHGpILQLWXGHOLpHjODJSHUVRQQH GHPDUTXHM> K\SRWKqVHWUqVGRXWHXVH/HJpQLWLIHVW
DEVHQWGHODEUDQFKHSHUPLHQQHFRPPHGHODEUDQFKHRXJULHQQH
/DJUDQGHGLYHUVLWpGHVVLWXDWLRQVGDQVODIDPLOOHRXUDOLHQQHHWODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQG·XQSHWLWQRPEUHGHFDVj
ODTXHOOHDERXWLWODJUDPPDLUHFRPSDUpHVLJQLILHQWTXHFKDTXHUDPHDXGHODIDPLOOHDFRQQXVDSURSUHpYROXWLRQ
GDQVODPRUSKRORJLHQRPLQDOHOLpHDX[UHODWLRQVV\QWD[LTXHV6LOHQRPEUHGHVFDVHVWWUqVYDULDEOHGDQVO·HQVHPEOH
RXUDOLHQODVWUXFWXUHLQWHUQHGHVV\VWqPHVO·HVWpJDOHPHQW2QQHIRXUQLUDLFLTX·XQDSHUoXGHFHWWHGLYHUVLWpSDU
O·H[DPHQGHODVLWXDWLRQREVHUYpHGDQVTXHOTXHVODQJXHVGHODIDPLOOH

!1)+4)6C63D<4)946)=4:;34B=6)45)?85@=876
/DPRUSKRORJLHQRPLQDOHGXKRQJURLVFRPSRUWHSRXUO·H[SUHVVLRQGHVUHODWLRQVV\QWD[LTXHVDXVHLQGHV
pQRQFpVXQHQVHPEOHGHPR\HQVGRQWO·H[DPHQSUpVHQWHXQGRXEOHLQWpUrWG·XQHSDUWLO\DOHVFDVIRXUQLVSDU

Q@Q
 oi.uchicago.edu

Q@<% P8<B%@8KK,*

XQHQVHPEOHGHVXIIL[HVTXHFRPSOqWHXQMHXGHSRVWSRVLWLRQVG·DXWUHSDUWXQHSDUWLHGHVVXIIL[HVFHX[GRQW
ODYDOHXUSUHPLqUHHVWOHPDUTXDJHGHUHODWLRQVGDQVO·HVSDFHV·RUJDQLVHHQXQV\VWqPHTXLFRPELQHDXPRLQV
SDUWLHOOHPHQWHWGHIDoRQFODLUHOHVPDUTXHVGHVWUDLWVFRQVWLWXWLIVGHVGLIIpUHQWHVYDOHXUVHQFDXVH(QRXWUHOHV
pOpPHQWVUHODWHXUVTXLV·DSSOLTXHQWDX[VXEVWDQWLIVQHIRQFWLRQQHQWSDVDYHFOHVSURQRPVSHUVRQQHOVOHUHODWHXU
GHYLHQWEDVHHWUHoRLWGHVVXIIL[HVSHUVRQQHOV SRVVHVVLIV FRUUHVSRQGDQWDX[GLIIpUHQWHVSHUVRQQHVGXSURQRP
$LQVLHQIDFHGH(%=~)'?M?!.´DYHFOHOLYUHµRQDSRXU´DYHFOXLµ?!.M!R?!.IRQFWLRQQHFRPPHEDVHHWUHoRLWOH
VXIIL[HSRVVHVVLIM!SRUWDQWUpIpUHQFHjXQSRVVHVVHXUGHJ%=J79FHHJ2%JK%HFH%=69%U‫ڛ‬YHOF·HVWjGLUHOHSURQRP‫ڛ‬
´OXLµDYHFOHVXIIL[HFDVXHOM?!.
/HVOLQJXLVWHVRQWGHSXLVORQJWHPSVVHQWLODQpFHVVLWpGHIDLUHXQWULGDQVOHVIRUPDWLRQVVXIIL[DOHVGHOD
PRUSKRORJLHQRPLQDOHSRXUQHUHWHQLUFRPPH´FDVµFRQVWLWXDQWXQHFDWpJRULHKRPRJqQHGHUHODWHXUVTXHOHV
IRUPDWLRQVUpSRQGDQWjFHUWDLQVFULWqUHV­GDWHUpFHQWHLOIDXWVLJQDOHUXQHWHQWDWLYHLQWpUHVVDQWHGH).LHIHU
.LHIHU TXLDDERXWLjODGpILQLWLRQVXLYDQWHGHODGpVLQHQFHFDVXHOOH´XQDIIL[HHVWGpVLQHQFHFDVXHOOHVLHW
VHXOHPHQWVLOHQRP V\QWDJPHQRPLQDO DXTXHOLOV·DMRXWHSHXWRFFXSHUODSRVLWLRQG·XQDUJXPHQWGXYHUEHHW
VLODIRUPHGHO·DUJXPHQWHVWGpWHUPLQpHDXVVLSDUOHYHUEHµ&·HVWXQHQVHPEOHGHIRUPDWLRQVVXIIL[DOHVTXL
HVWUHWHQXHQYHUWXGHFHWWHGpILQLWLRQ6RLWSRXUOHQRP!>&!-´KRPPHrWUHKXPDLQµODOLVWHVXLYDQWHGDQV
ODTXHOOHRQGLVWLQJXHUDLFLSOXVLHXUVVRXVHQVHPEOHVGHVXIIL[HVHQIRQFWLRQGHVYDOHXUVH[SULPpHV GRQWRQQH
SHXWGRQQHUTXHGHVWUDGXFWLRQVWUqVPDODGURLWHVHQIUDQoDLV DYHFXQHOpJqUHPRGLILFDWLRQGHO·RUGUHVXLYLSDU
).LHIHUHWHQSURSRVDQWGH$j&XQLIRUPpPHQWPDLVDUELWUDLUHPHQWO·DUWLFOHGpILQLGDQVFHVWUDGXFWLRQVTXL
H[LJHQWHQIUDQoDLVODSUpVHQFHG·XQGpWHUPLQDQW
$ ೏&DVGLWVJUDPPDWLFDX[
QRPLQDWLI FDV]pUR !>&!- FDVGXVXMHW
DFFXVDWLIM$% !>&!-M$ FDVGHO·REMHW
GDWLIM)(=WM)!= !>&!-M)!=% FDVGXGHVWLQDWDLUH 

% ೏&DVH[SULPDQWGHVUHODWLRQV´DEVWUDLWHVµFDXVDOLWpILQDOLWpDVVRFLDWLRQPR\HQ

LQVWUXPHQWDOVRFLDWLI!>&!-M-!. M?!. ´O·KRPPHµ

FDXVDOILQDO!>&!-MU-$´SRXUO·KRPPHjFDXVHGHO·KRPPHµ

& ೏&DVVSDWLDX[ DYHFGHVHPSORLVWHPSRUHOV

,QWpULRULWp &RQWDFW 3UR[LPLWp
6WDWLTXHV  !>&!-M&!)  !>&!-M!)  !>&!-M)U.
ORFDWLIV 8HJ998G 9L=J7J998G DGHVVLI
´GDQVO·KRPPHµ ´VXUO·KRPPHµ ´FKH]O·KRPPHµ
'\QDPLTXHV  !>&!-M&!  !>&!-M-!  !>&!-M+!G
DSSURFKH  8>>6K8G% 9LD>6K8G% 6>>6K8G
´GDQVO·KRPPHµ ´VXUjO·KRPPHµ ´YHUVFKH]O·KRPPHµ
'\QDPLTXHV²  HPEHUE‫ڛ‬O%  HPEHUU‫ڛ‬O  HPEHUW‫ڛ‬O
pORLJQHPHQW  pODWLI GpODWLI 6D>6K8G
´GHGDQVO·KRPPHµ ´GHGHVXUO·KRPPHµ ´GHGHFKH]
O·KRPPHµ
WHUPLQDWLIGXUDWLI HVSDFHHWWHPSV !>&!-M#5´MXVTX·jO·KRPPHµ

' ೏&DVPRGDX[
HVVLIPRGDOGHSRLQWGHYXH!>&!-M=U)$´FRPPHKRPPHµ
HVVLIPRGDOGHTXDOLILFDWLRQ!>&!-Mu.´HQKRPPH YLULOHPHQW µ
WUDQVIRUPDWLI DERXWLVVHPHQW ¬!>&!-M-U M?U ´ FKDQJp HQKRPPHµ

/HGHUQLHUJURXSHGHVFDVFHOXLGHV´PRGDX[µSRVHSUREOqPH).LHIHUDpWDEOLFHWWHOLVWHGHFDVHQIRQFWLRQ
G·XQHVpULHGHFULWqUHVjODTXHOOHLO\DOLHXG·HQDMRXWHUXQUHODWLIjO·HIIHWGHVVXIIL[DWLRQVGHVHQV´PRGDOµ DX[
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8D<KH7%7\K%N87%3<7%H<B7%N87%N<BD\87%,\K<N/8BB87% Q@R

TXHOOHVRQDSSOLTXHVRXYHQWODGpQRPLQDWLRQG·´HVVLIVµ&HVVXIIL[DWLRQVEORTXHQWOHVXEVWDQWLITXLHQHVWDIIHFWp
GDQVXQIRQFWLRQQHPHQWTXLH[FOXWODSUpVHQFHGHGpWHUPLQDQWVOHVVXIIL[HVM=U)$%JK%O@%M1.WMu.%FHK%LH%JGGJK%
DGYHUELDOLVDQWVXUOHVXEVWDQWLI³G·DLOOHXUVOHVXIIL[HM1.WMu.VHUWjIDEULTXHUGHVDGYHUEHVVXUEDVHDGMHFWLYDOH -600G%
´PDXYDLVµ-600G1.´PDOµ ³HWOHVXIIL[H¬YiWM?USUpVHQWGDQV!>&!-M-UDSSOLTXpjXQWHUPHTXLDLQVLVXIIL[p
SUpVHQWHFHWHUPHFRPPHFRQVWLWXDQWO·DERXWLVVHPHQWG·XQHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQQ·HVWSOXVXQDGYHUELDOLVDQWPDLV
XQPDUTXHXUGHO·HPSORLSUpGLFDWLI DWWULEXWLI G·XQDGMHFWLIRXG·XQVXEVWDQWLI N|YpYiOLN´LOVHFKDQJHHQSLHUUHµ 
/HVFDVVSDWLDX[FRQVWLWXHQWGDQVO·HQVHPEOHGHVFDVXQVRXVV\VWqPHGRQWODPRUSKRORJLHPrPHPDQLIHVWH
O·RUJDQLVDWLRQFDVUHOLpVG·XQHSDUWSDUXQWUDLWRSSRVDQWXQHYDOHXUVWDWLTXH ORFDWLI jXQHYDOHXUG\QDPLTXH
SRVLWLYH PRXYHPHQWG·DSSURFKH RXQpJDWLYH PRXYHPHQWG·pORLJQHPHQW G·DXWUHSDUWSDUXQWUDLWRSSRVDQWGHV
SRVLWLRQVUHODWLYHVGDQVO·HVSDFH LQWpULRULWpFRQWDFWSUR[LPLWp ODIRUPHGHVPDUTXHVFDVXHOOHVFRPSRUWHSRXU
OHVVXIIL[HVLPSOLTXDQWO·LQWpULRULWpXQHEDVHM&MGDQVOHVWURLVFDVTXLV·\UDSSRUWHQWXQHEDVHM-MGDQVGHX[GHV
WURLVFDVLPSOLTXDQWXQFRQWDFWWDQGLVTXHODSUR[LPLWpQ·HVWSDVUHSUpVHQWpHSDUXQpOpPHQWFRPPXQDX[WURLV
VXIIL[HVFRQFHUQpVSRXUO·RSSRVLWLRQVWDWLTXHG\QDPLTXHSRVLWLYHG\QDPLTXHQpJDWLYHRQUHOqYHODSUpVHQFH
G·XQpOpPHQWILQDOç.W‫ڛ‬OFRPPXQDX[WURLVIRUPHVFRQFHUQpHV
/HV\VWqPHFDVXHOGXILQQRLVTXLDFDVSUpVHQWHGHVVLPLOLWXGHVDYHFOHV\VWqPHKRQJURLVPRLQVSDUOD
SUpVHQFHG·XQDFFXVDWLI GRQWODIRUPHLGHQWLTXHjFHOOHTXLIRQFWLRQQHFRPPHJpQLWLISRVHXQSUREOqPHVSp
FLILTXHG·LGHQWLWpTXLVHUDpYRTXpSOXVORLQ TXHSDUFHOOHG·XQVRXVV\VWqPHGHFDVORFDX[HQSDUWLHUHOLpVGDQV
OHXUVVLJQLILDQWV2QFRQVWDWHHQHIIHWXQHUHODWLRQSDUWLHOOHHQWUHOHVIRUPHVGHVFDVVSDWLDX[VWDWLTXHVHWFHOOHV
GHVFDVVSDWLDX[G\QDPLTXHV SRVLWLIVHWQpJDWLIV DLQVLSRXUXQVXEVWDQWLI$(.6´PDLVRQµLOH[LVWHXQUDSSRUW
HQWUHOHFRXSOHLQHVVLI M00(N%$(.6M00(´GDQVODPDLVRQµ HWpODWLI M0$(N%$(.6M0$(´>VRUWDQW@GHODPDLVRQµ G·XQHSDUW
HWOHFRXSOHDGHVVLI M..(N%$(.6M..(´SUqVGHODPDLVRQµ HWDEODWLI M.$(N%$(.6M.$(´>V·pORLJQDQW@GHODPDLVRQµ UHODWLRQ
pJDOHPHQWHQWUHOHVGHX[HVVLIVORFDX[$(.6M00(%JK%$(.6M..( TXLSUpVHQWHQWXQHFRQVRQQHJpPLQpH HWOHVGHX[FDV
G\QDPLTXHV pORLJQHPHQW $(.6M0$( pODWLI HW$(.6M.$( DEODWLI TXLSUpVHQWHQWXQHILQDOHM$(FRPPXQHHWV·RSSRVHQW
SDUODFRQVRQQHLQLWLDOHGXVXIIL[H
/HV\VWqPHFDVXHOGXKRQJURLVHVWFRPSOpWpSDUXQHQVHPEOHGHSRVWSRVLWLRQVGRQWFHUWDLQHVFRPSRUWHQW
SOXVLHXUVIRUPHVLGHQWLILDEOHVFRPPHGHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVFRUUHVSRQGDQWSRXUXQHPrPHYDOHXUGHODEDVHj
O·RSSRVLWLRQVWDWLTXHG\QDPLTXHG·DSSURFKHG\QDPLTXHG·pORLJQHPHQW$LQVLODSRVWSRVLWLRQjEDVH(.M´VRXVµ
IRXUQLWWURLVIRUPHV¬(.($$´VRXVµ VWDWLTXHORFDWLI DOi´VRXVµ VHQVG\QDPLTXHSRVLWLI (.ç.´GHGHVVRXVµ VHQV
G\QDPLTXHQpJDWLI 
/HVSRVWSRVLWLRQVVRQWFRPPHOHVVXIIL[HVFDVXHOVFRPELQDEOHVDYHFOHVVXIIL[HVSRVVHVVLIVFRPELQDLVRQTXL
FRPPHRQO·DGpMjLQGLTXpVHVXEVWLWXHREOLJDWRLUHPHQWjFHTXHVHUDLWXQSURQRPSRXUYXG·XQVXIIL[HFDVXHORX
VXLYLG·XQHSRVWSRVLWLRQOHVU{OHVVRQWLQYHUVpVF·HVWOHVXIIL[HRXODSRVWSRVLWLRQTXLGHYLHQWODEDVHHWF·HVWOD
PDUTXHSRVVHVVLYHTXLVHVXEVWLWXHDXSURQRPSRXUIDLUHUpIpUHQFHjODSHUVRQQH
;%(G%!>&!-M-!. M?!.´DYHFµ ´DYHFO·KRPPHµ
M689%?!.M!´DYHFOXLHOOHµVXIIL[HFDVXHOGHYHQXEDVHHWVXLYLGHM!VXIIL[HSRVVHVVLIGHJ%=J79FHHJ2
HWGHPrPH?!.M!>´DYHFPRLµY!.M!"´DYHFWRLµHWF
;%(%:(%(.($$´VRXVO·DUEUHµ
M689%(.($$M(>´VRXVPRLµ(.($$M("´VRXVWRLµHW(.($$M(´VRXVOXLHOOHµHWF
&HWWHVLWXDWLRQGRLWrWUHUDSSURFKpHG·DXWUHVHPSORLVGHIRUPHVSRVVHVVLYpHVTXLVRQWLPSRUWDQWVHQKRQJURLV
FRPPHGDQVOHFDGUHGXYHUEHO·XVDJHGHO·LQILQLWLISRVVHVVLYp !.%=!..%>!))!>´LOIDXWTXHMHSDUWHµOLWW´LOIDXW
PRQSDUWLUµDYHFO·LQILQLWLI!.>!))#´SDUWLUµSRXUYXGXVXIIL[HSRVVHVVLIM> RXO·XVDJHGXSDUWLFLSHSDVVpSRVVHV
VLYp)UDQFLDRUV]iJEDQMiUWRPEDQ´GDQVPRQFLUFXOpHQ)UDQFHµF·HVWjGLUH´SHQGDQWTXHMHFLUFXODLVHQ)UDQFHµHW
VXUWRXWFHVHPSORLVVRQWjUHOLHUjO·XVDJHGHVPDUTXHVSRVVHVVLYHVGDQVODFRQMXJDLVRQKRQJURLVHSULQFLSDOHPHQW
GDQVODFRQMXJDLVRQREMHFWLYHjODTXHOOHLOVHUDIDLWDOOXVLRQSOXVORLQ VRXV 

E1)+;)=4:;3785)453=4);AAB6;37F)43)@G5737F
/HVODQJXHVRXUDOLHQQHVSUpVHQWHQWGHVGRQQpHVFRPSOH[HVHWWUqVGLIIpUHQFLpHVGDQVOHXUVV\VWqPHVFDVXHOV
G·H[WHQVLRQWUqVYDULDEOHFRPPHRQO·DYX /·DFFXVDWLIHWOHJpQLWLIUHWLHQQHQWSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWO·DWWHQWLRQSRXU
GLIIpUHQWHVUDLVRQV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% P8<B%@8KK,*

7RXWG·DERUGFHVGHX[FDVQ·H[LVWHQWSDVSDUWRXWFHUWDLQHVODQJXHVQ·RQWSDVGHJpQLWLI F·HVWOHFDVGXKRQ
JURLVRM)(=WM)!=HVWXQVXIIL[HGHGDWLITXLSHXWLQWHUYHQLUGDQVFHUWDLQHVFRQGLWLRQVFRPPHjHQIUDQoDLV
SRXUPDUTXHUXQHUHODWLRQG·DSSDUWHQDQFH)!=#%)#)40%IU)G!´LOQ·DSDVG·DUJHQWµ OLWW´LOQ·\DSDVG·DUJHQWjOXLµ 
'·DXWUHVODQJXHVQHSRVVqGHQWSDVO·DFFXVDWLIF·HVWOHFDVGHVODQJXHVRXJULHQQHVGH6LEpULHVDXIOHVGLDOHFWHV
YRJRXOVDXWUHVTXHOHGLDOHFWHGXQRUGFHVGLDOHFWHVDXMRXUG·KXLSUDWLTXHPHQWDEDQGRQQpVD\DQWODIRUPHG·DFFX
96K8G%JH%M>TXHSRVVqGHOHVDPR\qGHHWTXLUHPRQWHjO·RXUDOLHQPDLVTXLQHSHXWSDVrWUHFRQVLGpUpHFRPPHXQ
YpULWDEOHDFFXVDWLIM>Q·DSSDUDvWTX·DXVLQJXOLHUHWQ·HVWSDVG·HPSORLJpQpUDOLVpRQGLVFXWHHQFRUHGHODYpULWDEOH
IRQFWLRQGHFHM>TXLSRXUUDLWELHQMRXHUXQU{OHSUDJPDWLTXHSOXW{WTXHV\QWD[LTXHFRPPHO·DVXJJpUp%&RPULH%
&RPULH VHXOOHWFKpUpPLVVHDJpQpUDOLVpO·XVDJHGHM>DXSOXULHOFRPPHDXVLQJXOLHU/HKRQJURLVRIIUHGqV
OHVSUHPLHUVWH[WHVXQHSUpVHQFHG·DFFXVDWLIHQM$PDLVF·HVWXQHFUpDWLRQGRQWO·RULJLQHHVWXQREMHWGHGLVFXV
VLRQFHWWHPDUTXHM$SRXUO·REMHWDpWpLQWHUSUpWpHSDU$6DXYDJHRW  DYHFTXHOTXHVERQVDUJXPHQWV
FRPPHUHSUpVHQWDQWXQDQFLHQORFDWLIHQFRUHSUpVHQWGDQVGHVIRUPHVLVROpHVHQKRQJURLVG·DXMRXUG·KXL
4XDQWDXJpQLWLILODpWpGLWSUpFpGHPPHQWTXHFHUWDLQHVODQJXHVQ·HQSRVVpGDLHQWSDVDORUVTX·LOV·DJLWG·XQ
FDVSRXUOHTXHOODJUDPPDLUHFRPSDUpHDUHFRQVWUXLWGHIDoRQWUqVFODLUHXQHPDUTXH M)&H M)Q·HVWSDVUHSUp
VHQWpGDQVOHVVXIIL[HVFDVXHOVHQKRQJURLVFHTXLIDLWTX·HQGpILQLWLYHOHKRQJURLVQ·DQLJpQLWLIQLDFFXVDWLIGH
SURYHQDQFHRXUDOLHQQHLODSRXUO·REMHWDGRSWpXQVXIIL[HM$´UpFHQWµHWSRXUOHUDSSRUWG·DSSDUWHQDQFHLOFRQWLQXH
jH[SORLWHUODPDUTXHGHSRVVHVVLYDWLRQGDQVXQHIRUPXOH´;VRQ<µ (%5'!-!=%=~)'?M!´O·HQIDQWVRQOLYUHµSRXU´
OHOLYUHGHO·HQIDQWµ 
&HUWDLQHVODQJXHVRXUDOLHQQHVRQWXQHIRUPHXQLTXHTXLIRQFWLRQQHjODIRLVFRPPHJpQLWLIHWFRPPHDFFX
VDWLIVLWXDWLRQTXLVXVFLWHGHX[LQWHUSUpWDWLRQVGLIIpUHQWHVRXELHQLOV·DJLWG·XQFDVG·KRPRQ\PLHRXELHQLOIDXW
FRQVLGpUHUTXHOHVGHX[YDOHXUVUHOqYHQWG·XQPrPHVLJQHHWTXHOHXUGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQV·H[SOLTXHSDUGHVFRQGLWLRQV
GHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHGHX[W\SHVGLIIpUHQWV/DTXHVWLRQVHSRVHSRXUOHILQQRLVRXQHIRUPHHQM)DSSDUDvW
G·XQHSDUWDYHFXQHYDOHXUGHJpQLWLI VDQVIRUPHFRQFXUUHQWHSRXUFHWWHYDOHXU HWG·DXWUHSDUWDYHFXQHYDOHXU
GHFDVREMHWHOOHIRQFWLRQQHDORUVHQFRQFXUUHQFHG·XQHSDUWDYHFOHQRPLQDWLI DXSOXULHOIDXWHG·DFFXVDWLIHW
REOLJDWRLUHPHQWSRXUO·REMHWG·XQLPSpUDWLI HWG·DXWUHSDUWDYHFOHSDUWLWLIFHTXLV·HVWWUDGXLWSDUEHDXFRXSGH
FRQIXVLRQGDQVOHVJUDPPDLUHVILQQRLVHVTXLUpXQLVVDLHQWYRORQWLHUVVRXVO·DSSHOODWLRQG·DFFXVDWLIOHQRPLQDWLI
PDUTXH]pUR HWOHJpQLWLIHQM)HQWDQWTXHIRUPHVVHSDUWDJHDQWO·H[SUHVVLRQGXFRPSOpPHQWGLUHFWG·REMHW$X
SOXULHO PDUTXpFRPPHWHOSDUM$ F·HVWOHQRPLQDWLITXLIRQFWLRQQHGDQVOHVFDVRDXVLQJXOLHURQHPSORLHM)2%
F·HVWjGLUHTXDQGGDQVXQpQRQFpjSUpGLFDWYHUEDOSRVLWLIOHVXEVWDQWLIHPSOR\pFRPPH´FRPSOpPHQWG·REMHW
GLUHFWµGpVLJQHXQHHQWLWpLQGLYLGXDOLVpHGpILQLHRXQRQ60$()%=#-c()VLJQLILHjODIRLV´M·DFKqWHOHOLYUHµHW´M·DFKqWH
XQOLYUHµPDLVDXSOXULHOF·HVWDXQRPLQDWLITX·HVWH[SULPpO·REMHWIDXWHG·DFFXVDWLIF·HVWOHSDUWLWLITXLDSSDUDvW
VLOHSUpGLFDWHVWQpJDWLI!)%60$()%(1$6M(´MHQ·DFKqWHSDVGHYRLWXUHODYRLWXUHµHWTXLV·LPSRVHHQpQRQFpSRVLWLI
FRPPHHQpQRQFpQpJDWLIVLOHFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWGpVLJQHXQHPDWLqUHXQHPDVVHQRQLQGLYLGXDOLVpH60$()%
6.1$M$(´M·DFKqWHGHODELqUHµ PDLV60$()%6.1!M)´M·DFKqWHMHYDLVDFKHWHUODELqUH>ODERXWHLOOHGRQWLOV·DJLW@ 
-XKD-DQKXQHQDGDQVXQHSXEOLFDWLRQUpFHQWH -DQKXQHQ SURSRVpGHYRLUGDQVOHVGHX[IRUPHVPDU
TXpHVKpULWpHVGHO·RXUDOLHQTX·RQSHXWVXSSRVHUGHUULqUHODIRUPHHQM)PDUTXDQWO·REMHWGDQVFHUWDLQHVFRQGL
WLRQVHQILQQRLV¬ XQDFFXVDWLIHQ M>HWXQJpQLWLIHQ M) GHX[IRUPHVFDVXHOOHVPDUTXpHVV·RSSRVDQWjODIRUPH
GHEDVHQRQPDUTXpHDSSHOpHQRPLQDWLIFHVGHX[IRUPHVVHGpILQLVVHQWV\QWD[LTXHPHQWO·XQHOHJpQLWLIFRPPH
ODPDUTXHGXFRPSOpPHQWGHQRPO·DXWUHO·DFFXVDWLIFRPPHODPDUTXHGHO·REMHW-DQKXQHQpWHQGFHWWHDQDO\VH
jXQHQVHPEOHGHODQJXHVDVVRFLDQWODIDPLOOHRXUDOLHQQHHWODIDPLOOHDOWDwTXH/HVGHX[FDVFRQVLGpUpVIRUPHQW
DYHFOHQRPLQDWLIOHVRXVV\VWqPHGHV´FDVJUDPPDWLFDX[µDX[TXHOVV·HVWDMRXWpOHSDUWLWLI,OUHVWHjFRPSUHQGUH
FRPPHQWRQSHXWGLUHG·XQHODQJXHFRPPHOHILQQRLVTX·HOOHDXQFDVJpQLWLITXDQGHOOHQ·DTX·XQHVHXOHIRUPH
FDVXHOOHGHVLQJXOLHUIRQFWLRQQDQWjODIRLVDGQRPLQDOHPHQW IRQFWLRQGHJpQLWLI HWDGYHUEDOHPHQW IRQFWLRQ
G·DFFXVDWLI ,OIDXGUDLWSOXW{WVHORQOXLSDUOHUGH´FDVFRQQHFWLI µSRXUGpVLJQHUXQFDVTXLDSRXUIRQFWLRQGH
UHOLHUXQPRWQRPLQDOGpSHQGDQW FRPSOpPHQWGHQRPRXREMHW jXQHWrWHTXLHVWVRLWXQQRPVRLWXQYHUEH
,OVHUDLWXWLOHSRXUFRPSUHQGUHFHWWHVLWXDWLRQGHPDvWULVHUOHSURFHVVXVKLVWRULTXHGRQWHOOHHVWO·DERXWLV
VHPHQWPDLVGDQVODPHVXUHROHVFRQGLWLRQVGHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHM)PDUTXDQWO·REMHWHWGHM)HQIRQFWLRQGH
JpQLWLIGRQFPDUTXDQWXQHUHODWLRQG·DSSDUWHQDQFHVRQWQHWWHPHQWGLIIpUHQFLpHVRQSHXWDGPHWWUHTXHODODQJXH
V·DFFRPPRGHGHFHWWHVLWXDWLRQG·DXWDQWSOXVIDFLOHPHQWTX·HQWUHOHVGHX[IRQFWLRQVLOH[LVWHXQOLHQFRPPHOH
GLW-DQKXQHQOLHQG·DXWDQWSOXVVHQVLEOH³SHXWRQDMRXWHU³TXHODSUpGLFDWLRQHQRXUDOLHQDG€rWUHFHTX·HOOH
HVWHQFRUHGHIDoRQWUqVV\VWpPDWLTXHHQRERXJULHQF·HVWjGLUHIRQGpHVXUXQHUHODWLRQG·DSSDUWHQDQFH 3HUURW
YRLULFL3(0%!$%(4$()4! 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8D<KH7%7\K%N87%3<7%H<B7%N87%N<BD\87%,\K<N/8BB87% Q@@

8QHODQJXHILQQRRXJULHQQHDXWUHTXHOHILQQRLVRIIUHXQHVLWXDWLRQGLIIpUHQWHSRXUOHUDSSRUWHQWUHDFFX
VDWLIHWJpQLWLIPDLVFHWWHVLWXDWLRQGDQVVRQSULQFLSHSHXWDSSDUDvWUHFRPPHXQHUDGLFDOLVDWLRQGHODIXVLRQGHV
GHX[YDOHXUVFRUUHVSRQGDQWUHVSHFWLYHPHQWjO·DFFXVDWLIHWDXJpQLWLI&·HVWODVLWXDWLRQTX·RIIUHOHPRUGYHGRQW
ODGpFOLQDLVRQSUpVHQWHWURLVFDUDFWpULVWLTXHVG·XQHSDUWXQSDUDGLJPHFRPSOHWSRXUODGpFOLQDLVRQGpILQLHDYHF
VLQJXOLHUHWSOXULHOHWXQSDUDGLJPHUpGXLWDXVLQJXOLHUHWjXQHIRUPHXQLTXHGHSOXULHOVDQVVXIIL[HFDVXHO¬SRXU
ODGpFOLQDLVRQQRQGpILQLHG·DXWUHSDUWXQHIRUPHXQLTXHSRXUOHJpQLWLIHWO·DFFXVDWLIGDQVOHVGHX[SDUDGLJPHV
HQILQO·XWLOLVDWLRQGHODIRUPHGHJpQLWLIDFFXVDWLIFRPPHEDVHSRXUOHVDXWUHVFDV

'pFOLQDLVRQGXQRPHQPRUGYHHU]DH[HPSOHSDNߓD´FKDPSµ
1RQGpILQL 'pILQL
$8HIL>8J7 $8HIL>8J7
HFM8H6K8G% SDNߓD HFM8H6K8G SDNߓDߓ
JpQLWLIDFF SDNߓD‫ش‬ JpQLWLIDFF SDNߓD‫ࠆش‬
GDWLIDOODWLI SDNߓD‫ش‬H‫ش‬ GDWLIDOODWLI SDNߓD‫ࠆش‬H‫ش‬
8HJ998G SDNߓDVR 8HJ998G SDNߓDVR‫ࠆش‬
pODWLI SDNߓDVWR pODWLI SDNߓDVWR‫ࠆش‬
8>>6K8G SDNߓDV 8>>6K8G SDNߓD‫ࠆش‬H‫ش‬
=7F>6K8G SDNߓDYD =7F>6K8G SDNߓDYD‫ࠆش‬
6D>6K8G SDNߓDGR 6D>6K8G SDNߓDGR‫ࠆش‬
K76H9>6K8G SDNߓDNV K76H9>6K8G SDNߓDNVR‫ࠆش‬
6DJ998G SDNߓDYWPR 6DJ998G SDNߓDYWRPR‫ࠆش‬
FRPSDUDWLI SDNߓDߖND FRPSDUDWLI SDߓNDߖND‫ࠆش‬
5>L78J> 5>L78J>
HFM8H6K8G SDNߓDW HFM8H6K8G SDNߓDࠆ‫ش‬H
JpQLWLIDFF SDNߓDࠆ‫ش‬H‫ش‬
GDWLIDOODWLI SDNߓDࠆ‫ش‬H‫ش‬H‫ش‬
8HJ998G SDNߓDࠆ‫ش‬HVH
UU pODWLI SDNߓDࠆ‫ش‬HVWH
೉ 8>>6K8G SDNߓDࠆ‫ش‬HV
UU =7F>6K8G SDNߓDࠆ‫ش‬HYD
6D>6K8G SDNߓDࠆ‫ش‬H˄H
K76H9>6K8G SDNߓDࠆ‫ش‬HNV
6DJ998G SDNߓDࠆ‫ش‬HYࠆHPH
FRPSDUDWLI SDNߓDࠆ‫ش‬HߖND

,OUHVVRUWGHFHWDEOHDXTXHODIRUPHGHJpQLWLIDFFXVDWLIFDUDFWpULVpHSDUXQVXIIL[H‫ࠆش‬R‫ش‬UHSUpVHQWHOH
JpQLWLIRXUDOLHQ M)%JK%ࠆODPDUTXHGHGpILQLWXGH TXLHVWߓDXQRPLQDWLI VHUWGHEDVHDX[DXWUHVFDVRODPDUTXH
FDVXHOOHSUpFqGHOHSOXVVRXYHQWODILQDOH‫ࠆش‬GXJpQLWLIDFFXVDWLIPDLVODVXLWDXGDWLIHWjO·DEODWLI
/HIDLWTXHOHPRUGYHSUpVHQWHXQHIRUPHGHJpQLWLIDFFXVDWLIHQ‫ش‬GDQVODGpFOLQDLVRQQRQGpILQLHHWHQ‫ࠆش‬
GDQVODGpFOLQDLVRQGpILQLHRࠆHVWODPDUTXHGHGpILQLWXGHGRQFOHIDLWTXHGDQVOHVGHX[SDUDGLJPHVF·HVW
XQHIRUPHXQLTXHTXLIRQFWLRQQHFRPPHDFFXVDWLIHWFRPPHJpQLWLIHWTXHFHWWHIRUPHXQLTXHVRUWVHORQWRXWH
YUDLVHPEODQFHGX ‫ش‬RXUDOLHQGHJpQLWLIQHSHXWSDVQHSDVPDQTXHUGHFUpHUXQGRXWHVpULHX[VXUODFUpGLEL
OLWpGHO·RULJLQHDFFXVDWLYHGHFHM)ILQQRLVG·DXWDQWSOXVTXHFRPPHRQO·DVRXYHQWUHPDUTXpLO\DSOXVG·XQH
FRQFRUGDQFHHQWUHGRQQpHVPRUGYHVHWGRQQpHVILQQRLVHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% P8<B%@8KK,*

(WO·LQWHUURJDWLRQTXHSRVHFHWWHLQWHUYHQWLRQGXJpQLWLISRXUPDUTXHUXQSDUWLFLSDQWTXLGDQVODVpPDQWLTXH
GHVUDSSRUWVV\QWD[LTXHVVHSUpVHQWHFRPPHXQREMHWLQFLWHjVLWXHUFHSUREOqPHGDQVOHFDGUHEHDXFRXSSOXVODUJH
GXERXOHYHUVHPHQWGXV\VWqPHDQFLHQGHSUpGLFDWLRQIRQGpHVXUXQHUHODWLRQG·DSSDUWHQDQFHERXOHYHUVHPHQW
TXLDLQVWDOOpODUHODWLRQREMHFWDOHHWTXLVHUDpYRTXpSOXVORLQ 3(0%!$%(4$()4! 

H1)I7G=;=A?74)A;6B4::4
/HWDEOHDXGHODGpFOLQDLVRQQRPLQDOHHQPRUGYHIDLWFODLUHPHQWDSSDUDvWUHTXHPLVjSDUWOHQRPLQDWLITXL
Q·HVWPDUTXpTXHFRPPHGpILQLGDQVODGpFOLQDLVRQGpILQLHODIRUPHGHJpQLWLIDFFXVDWLIHVWSUpVHQWHGDQVWRXWHV
OHVDXWUHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVGXVLQJXOLHUSUpFpGDQWRX³OHSOXVVRXYHQW³VXLYDQWODPDUTXHFDVXHOOHHWIRQFWLRQQH
DLQVLFRPPHXQHEDVHpODUJLHSRXUODIRUPDWLRQGHVFDV/HVXIIL[H‫ࠆش‬TXLFDUDFWpULVHOHJpQLWLIHWTXLHVWDQDO\Vp
FRPPHFRPSRUWDQWXQHPDUTXHGHJpQLWLIM)HWXQHPDUTXHGHGpILQLWXGHM$VHUHWURXYHGDQVWRXWOHSDUDGLJPH
GHODGpFOLQDLVRQGpILQLHPDMRULWDLUHPHQWHQILQGHPRWDXVLQJXOLHUDSUqVODPDUTXHFDVXHOOHPDLVGHYDQWFHWWH
PDUTXHGDQVWRXWOHSOXULHO
,OHVWGLIILFLOHG·LQWHUSUpWHUODKLpUDUFKLHLQVWLWXpHGDQVFHUDSSRUWHQWUHOHFDVJpQLWLIDFFXVDWLIHWOHVDXWUHV
FDVGHODGpFOLQDLVRQ7RXWVHSDVVHFRPPHVLOHPDUTXDJHGXJpQLWLIDFFXVDWLIVHFRPSRUWDLWFRPPHXQHPDUTXH
GHGpSHQGDQFHV\QWD[LTXHDXVHQVOHSOXVDEVWUDLW FHTXLV·DFFRUGHDYHFODGpQRPLQDWLRQGHFDVJUDPPDWLFDX[ 
OHVDXWUHVPDUTXHVFDVXHOOHVLQWURGXLVDQWGHVUHODWLRQVG·XQDXWUHRUGUH
/DVLWXDWLRQHVWFRPSDUDEOHHQHVWRQLHQPDLVHOOH\HVWSOXVFRPSOH[HGXIDLWGHO·LQWHUYHQWLRQGXSDUWLWLI
OHVFDVJUDPPDWLFDX[pWDQWOHQRPLQDWLIOHJpQLWLIHWOHSDUWLWLI LOQ·\DSDVG·DFFXVDWLI /HWDEOHDXVXLYDQWSUp
VHQWHXQHQVHPEOHGHIRUPHVGXQRPGXSLHGc(.52%=>L78J>%c(.("DXQRPLQDWLI XQHIRUPHG·LOODWLIGLWHLOODWLITXL
FRQVWLWXHXQFDVSDUWLFXOLHUQHILJXUHSDVGDQVFHWDEOHDXGDQVXQDXWUHW\SHGHWKqPHQRPLQDOOHUDSSRUWHQWUH
OHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVVHSUpVHQWHGHODPrPHPDQLqUH 

&DVJUDPPDWLFDX[ 98HIL>8J7 =>L78J>

+FM8H6K8G MDOJ MDODG

567K8K8G MDOJD MDOJDVLG
*pQLWLI MDOD MDOJDGH
$XWUHVFDV
*>>6K8G%:% MDODVVH MDOJDGHVVH
*HJ998G MDODV MDOJDGHV
)>6K8G MDODVW MDOJDGHVW
!>>6K8G MDODOH MDOJDGHO
!D>6K8G MDODOW MDOJDGHOW
#76H9>6K8G MDODNV MDOJDGHNV
#J7M8H6K8G MDODQL MDOJDGHQL
)998G MDODQD MDOJDGHQD
!DJ998G MDODWD MDOJDGHWD
"FM=676K8G MDODJD MDOJDGHJD

/HVpOpPHQWVGHFHWDEOHDXVRQWHPSUXQWpVj7LLW5HLQ9LLWVRTXLGDQVVDSUpVHQWDWLRQGHODPRUSKRORJLH
QRPLQDOHGHO·HVWRQLHQ 9LLWVR² DELHQPLVHQpYLGHQFHODVWUXFWXUHLQWHUQHGXV\VWqPHGHVIRUPHV
FDVXHOOHVHWOHU{OHGHVIRUPHVGHVFDVGLWVJUDPPDWLFDX[GDQVODIRUPDWLRQGHVDXWUHVFDVRQIRUPHFHVGHUQLHUV
DXVLQJXOLHUHQDMRXWDQWOHXUVGpVLQHQFHVUHVSHFWLYHVDXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUHWDXSOXULHOHQOHVDMRXWDQWDXSDUWLWLI
SOXULHOjODVXLWHGHODPDUTXHGHSOXULHOM"!
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8D<KH7%7\K%N87%3<7%H<B7%N87%N<BD\87%,\K<N/8BB87% Q@P

2QSHXWUDSSURFKHUGHFHVH[HPSOHVGHKLpUDUFKLHFDVXHOOHHQPRUGYHHWHQHVWRQLHQXQH[HPSOHGHKLpUDUFKLH
HQWUHPRUSKqPHVTXLVHVLWXHKRUVGXGRPDLQHGHVFDVPDLVTXLHVWGHPrPHRUGUH&HWH[HPSOHEHDXFRXSSOXV
OLPLWpGHKLpUDUFKLHPRUSKpPDWLTXHVHSUpVHQWHHQRVWLDN,ODSSDUDvWTXHGDQVO·HQVHPEOHGHO·RVWLDNDYHFGHV
YDULDWLRQVGHGpWDLOVHORQOHVGLDOHFWHVO·H[SUHVVLRQGXGXHO³HQFRUHYLYDQWGDQVFHWWHODQJXH³HVWUpDOLVpH
SDUXQHIRUPHFRPSOH[HGDQVODVXIIL[DWLRQSRVVHVVLYHSRXUIDLUHUpIpUHQFHjXQSRVVpGpGXHOO·pOpPHQWLQIL[p
TXLSRUWHFHWWHUpIpUHQFHHVWFRQVWLWXpSDUODFRPELQDLVRQGXVXIIL[HTXLIDLWUpIpUHQFHjXQSRVVpGpSOXULHO M.M 
SUpFpGpG·XQHPDUTXHGHGXHO ࣹ OHGXHODSSDUDvWDLQVLFRPPHXQHPDUTXHGHSOXUDOLWpSDUWLFXOLqUHHWQRQSDV
FRPPHO·H[SUHVVLRQG·XQQRPEUHTXLV·RSSRVHUDLWG·XQHSDUWjXQVLQJXOLHUHWG·DXWUHSDUWjXQSOXULHO
([HPSOHGDQVOHGLDOHFWHYDFK RVWLDNGHO·HVW 
MRࣹ̾.´DUFµGXHOMRࣹ̾.Mࣹ̾)´  DUFVµSOXULHOMRࣹ̾.M$´ ! DUFVµ
)RUPHSRVVHVVLYpHH[HPSOHSRXUODJ%=J79FHHJN
c6ࣹ.M(>´PRQDUFµc6ࣹ.Mࣹ̾M.M(>´PHV  DUFVµc6ࣹ̾.M.M(>´PHV ! DUFVµ
/HVPrPHVGRQQpHVVHUHWURXYHQWGDQVOHV\VWqPHYHUEDORODFRQMXJDLVRQREMHFWLYHDGHVIRUPHVVWUXFWXUpHV
FRPPHOHVIRUPHVSRVVHVVLYpHVGXQRPDYHFUpIpUHQFHjGHX[SDUWLFLSDQWV

J1),;6)43);A3;5A4
/DUHODWLRQHQWUHOHVFDVHWO·DFWDQFHFRQFHUQHQDWXUHOOHPHQWDXSUHPLHUFKHIOHVFDVGLWVJUDPPDWLFDX[TXL
DVVXUHQWOHPDUTXDJHGHIRQFWLRQVpWURLWHPHQWOLpHVjODSUpGLFDWLRQFHOOHVGHVDFWDQWV,O\DSRXUWDQWGHVIDLWV
TXLPRQWUHQWTXHFHUWDLQHVIRQFWLRQVDFWDQFLHOOHVSHXYHQWrWUHLGHQWLILpHVSRXUGHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVjIRQFWLRQ
SUHPLqUHQRQDFWDQFLHOOHQRWDPPHQWSRXUGHVIRUPHVGHFDVORFDX[8QH[HPSOHGRLWrWUHDERUGpLFLDXPRLQV
SRXUXQHSUpVHQWDWLRQUDSLGHGHVGRQQpHVFHOXLGHO·RVWLDNRRQDFUXGpFHOHUXQHYDOHXUDJHQWLYHGHORFDWLI
'DQVOHGRPDLQHGHVFDVJUDPPDWLFDX[XQHGRQQpHPDMHXUHGDQVO·KLVWRLUHGHVODQJXHVRXUDOLHQQHVHVWOH
GpYHORSSHPHQWGHODUHODWLRQREMHFWDOHHWO·LPSODQWDWLRQGDQVOHSDUDGLJPHGHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVGHODPDUTXHGH
FHWWHUHODWLRQF·HVWjGLUHG·XQHIRUPHG·DFFXVDWLI&RPPHRQO·DUDSSHOpSOXVKDXWRQUHVWLWXHHQRXUDOLHQXQH
PDUTXH M>G·DFFXVDWLIPDLVOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHFHWWHPDUTXHGDQVODSURWRODQJXHFRPSRUWHEHDXFRXSGHUHV
WULFWLRQVHWQ·HVWSDVWRWDOHPHQWFODULILpFHQ·HVWTX·HQWFKpUpPLVVHTX·LODpWpLQWpJUpjODGpFOLQDLVRQQRPLQDOH
DXVLQJXOLHUHWDXSOXULHO2QWURXYHFH M>HQYRJRXOPDLVSDVHQYRJRXOGXQRUGVHXOGLDOHFWHHQFRUHUpHOOHPHQW
YLYDQW&HYRJRXOGXQRUGDFRQVHUYpXQHPRUSKRORJLHQRPLQDOHVDQVDFFXVDWLI
(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHO·RERXJULHQRQDLQYRTXpO·H[LVWHQFHG·XQDFFXVDWLIGDQVODGpFOLQDLVRQGHVSURQRPV
SHUVRQQHOVPDLVLOHVWFODLUFRPPHRQO·DLQGLTXpGDQVXQDUWLFOHFRQVDFUpDXSUpWHQGXDFFXVDWLISURQRPLQDOHQ
ILQQRRXJULHQ 3HUURW TX·LOV·DJLWHQRERXJULHQGHIRUPHVSHUVRQQHOOHVUHQIRUFpHVGRQWODPDUTXHHVWOD
UHSULVHGXVXIIL[HSHUVRQQHOGHVIRUPHVSRVVHVVLYHV
6LQJJ%=J79FHHJ%(>´DFFXVDWLI µ()M1>DYHFM>´PRQPDµ
% :J%=J79FHHJ%QD‫´و‬DFFXVDWLI µQD‫)̾و‬DYHFM)´WRQWDµ
% QJ%=J79FHHJ%$(9´DFFXVDWLI µ$(9M!DYHFM!´VRQVDµHWF
/HVIRUPHVGLWHVDFFXVDWLYHVFRQVWLWXHQWXQHVRUWHGHFDV]pURIRUWDYHFPDUTXHSHUVRQQHOOHUHQIRUFpH(Q
RVWLDNOHVIRUPHVGLWHVG·DFFXVDWLISUpVHQWHQWXQM$JpQpUDOLVp jWRXWHVOHVSHUVRQQHVHWSRXUOHVWURLVQRPEUHV 
TXLHVWDXVVLXQpOpPHQWGHUHQIRUFHPHQWDVVRFLpjGHVPDUTXHVFDVXHOOHVGDQVG·DXWUHVIRUPHVSURQRPLQDOHV
/·DEVHQFHG·XQHPDUTXHREMHFWDOHHQRERXJULHQHVWOLpHjXQHGRQQpHV\QWD[LTXHIRQGDPHQWDOHFRQFHUQDQW
O·RUJDQLVDWLRQGHODSUpGLFDWLRQ
8QVLPSOHH[HPSOHG·pQRQFpVYpKLFXODQWOHPrPHFRQWHQXHQYRJRXOHWHQKRQJURLVSHUPHWGHPHWWUHHQ
pYLGHQFHODGLIIpUHQFHUDGLFDOHHQWUHOHVGHX[ODQJXHVSRXUO·RUJDQLVDWLRQGHODSUpGLFDWLRQ
KRQJURLV 6% J\HUHNHN PHJOiWWiN 6% NpW UpQV]DUYDVW
!,#% HQIDQW5-/,% 35(9YRLU35(7Q5-/,% !,#% :% 7JHHJ%!""
 &21-2%-
YRJRXO ‫ش‬DZUDP̾K% VčOLMӢࣹ NčVDODVDࣹDQ̾>%
HQIDQW5-/, UHQQH3/)-% DSHUFHYRLU35(7'8(/32665
6HQVGHVGHX[pQRQFpV´/HVHQIDQWVDSHUoXUHQWOHVGHX[UHQQHVµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% P8<B%@8KK,*

'DQVO·pQRQFpKRQJURLVOHSUpGLFDWHVWXQHIRUPHYHUEDOHGHODFRQMXJDLVRQREMHFWLYHHWO·DFWDQWREMHWHVW
PDUTXpFRPPHWHOSDUOHVXIIL[HG·DFFXVDWLIM$OHVHXODFFRUGH[LVWDQWGDQVO·pQRQFpHVWFHOXLGHODIRUPHYHUEDOH
DYHFOHQRP´HQIDQWVµSOXULHOTXLHQWUDvQHODJSHUVRQQHGXSOXULHOjGpVLQHQFHiNRM(MPDUTXHODJ%=J79FHHJ%
JK%M=OHSOXULHO DXVLQJXOLHUGpVLQHQFHM( 
'DQVO·pQRQFpYRJRXORQFRQVWDWHTXHOHVIRUPHVQRPLQDOHVGpVLJQDQWOHVHQIDQWVHWOHVGHX[UHQQHVQ·RQW
DXFXQVXIIL[HFDVXHO FHVRQWGHVQRPLQDWLIVOHSUHPLHUDYHFXQHPDUTXHGHSOXULHOOHVHFRQGDYHFXQHPDUTXH
GHGXHO HWTXHODIRUPHYHUEDOHNčVDODVDࣹDQ̾OGXSUpWpULW PDUTXHM(0M FRQWLHQWGHX[pOpPHQWVOHSUHPLHUHVW
XQHPDUTXHGHGXHOOHVHFRQGHVWXQVXIIL[HSRVVHVVLIUHQYR\DQWjXQSRVVHVVHXU JSHUVRQQHGXSOXULHO IUDQoDLV
´OHXUµ FHWWHIRUPHTXLFRQVWLWXHOHSUpGLFDWHVWFRQVWUXLWHFRPPHXQHIRUPHQRPLQDOHSRVVHVVLYpHTXLFRQWLHQ
GUDLWXQHUpIpUHQFHDXSRVVHVVHXU JSHUVRQQHGXSOXULHO HWXQHUpIpUHQFHDXSRVVpGpFRPPHODIRUPHQRPLQDOH
[čSDࣹDQ̾.TXLDYHFSRXUUDGLFDO[čS´EDUTXHµVLJQLILHUDLW´OHXUVEDUTXHVµ
&HWWHDQDO\VHFRQGXLWGRQFjWUDGXLUHOLWWpUDOHPHQWO·pQRQFpYRJRXO´OHVHQIDQWVOHVGHX[UHQQHV>VRQW@OHXUV
GHX[ DSHUoXVµDYHFXQSUpGLFDWjODIRLVYHUEDOSDUVDEDVHHWVDPDUTXHWHPSRUHOOHHWQRPLQDOSDUOHVUpIpUHQFHV
GHQRPEUHHWGHSHUVRQQH&HWWHIRUPHYHUEDOHFRQWLHQWH[DFWHPHQWOHVPrPHVUpIpUHQFHVTXHODIRUPHSXUHPHQW
HFM8H6>J%[čSDࣹDQ̾./HSUpGLFDWV·DFFRUGHHQQRPEUHDYHFOHGXHOVčOLMӢࣹ O·DFFRUGVHGpILQLWSDUOHWUDQVIHUWGH
FDWpJRULHGXQRPDXYHUEH TX·LOIDXWFRQVLGpUHUGHFHIDLWFRPPHOHVXMHWHWQRQFRPPHO·REMHWOHFRQVWLWXDQW
´HQIDQWVµD\DQWOXLXQHIRQFWLRQSXUHPHQWWKpPDWLTXHVDQVIRQFWLRQV\QWD[LTXH
2QVHFRQWHQWHUDLFLGHFHWWHUDSLGHLOOXVWUDWLRQGHVFDUDFWpULVWLTXHVIRQGDPHQWDOHVGHODSUpGLFDWLRQHQ
YRJRXOHQUHQYR\DQWSRXUXQHLQIRUPDWLRQSOXVFRPSOqWHjGHVSXEOLFDWLRQVDQWpULHXUHV YRLUQRWDPPHQW
3HUURW 
/DFRQFOXVLRQTXLVHGpJDJHGHO·H[DPHQGHVIDLWVREVHUYpVHQRERXJULHQF·HVWTXHWUqVYUDLVHPEODEOHPHQW
GDQVODFRQWLQXLWpSDUUDSSRUWjODSURWRODQJXHRXUDOLHQQHF·HVWO·H[SUHVVLRQG·XQUDSSRUWG·DSSDUWHQDQFHTXLD
MRXpGHIDoRQSUpSRQGpUDQWHGDQVO·RUJDQLVDWLRQGHODSUpGLFDWLRQHWTXHF·HVWXQHHUUHXUPDQLIHVWHG·DSSOLTXHU
V\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWjO·RXUDOLHQXQHDQDO\VHIRQGpHVXUOHVUHODWLRQVDFWDQFLHOOHVHQFRQIRQGDQWOHU{OHGHSDWLHQW
DYHFODIRQFWLRQV\QWD[LTXHG·REMHWGDQVGHVODQJXHVRODUHODWLRQREMHFWDOHQ·DDXFXQHH[LVWHQFHPRUSKRV\Q
WD[LTXH
(QRVWLDN OHVIDLWVGpFULWVLFLDSSDUWLHQQHQWjXQGLDOHFWHRULHQWDOOHYDFK ODGpFOLQDLVRQQRPLQDOHFRPSUHQG
HVVHQWLHOOHPHQWVL[IRUPHVFDVXHOOHVDX[TXHOOHVV·DMRXWHOHQRPLQDWLIjPDUTXH]pURHWOHYHUEHSUpVHQWHGHX[
FRQMXJDLVRQVO·XQHGLWHREMHFWLYHRXGpILQLHO·DXWUHGLWHVXEMHFWLYHRXQRQGpILQLHODSUHPLqUHVHSUpVHQWDQW
TXDQGOHYHUEHUpJLWXQREMHWGpILQLH[SOLFLWHRXLPSOLFLWHODVHFRQGHTXDQGLO\DXQREMHWQRQGpILQLRXTXDQGOH
YHUEHQHUpJLWDXFXQREMHWOHV\VWqPHYHUEDOFRPSRUWHHQRXWUHXQSDVVLI/DGpFOLQDLVRQQRPLQDOHFRPSRUWHXQ
ORFDWLIHQM)̾WQ̾TXLVHSUpVHQWHHQGHKRUVGHVHVHPSORLVGHFDVORFDOGDQVGHX[IRQFWLRQVLQWpUHVVDQWO·DFWDQFH
³G·XQHSDUWLOPDUTXHOHFRPSOpPHQWG·DJHQWG·XQYHUEHSDVVLI
³G·DXWUHSDUWLOVHSUpVHQWHSRXUPDUTXHUXQDFWDQWUHOLpjXQSUpGLFDWYHUEDODFWLIOHSOXVVRXYHQWjOD
FRQMXJDLVRQREMHFWLYH &2 PDLVSDUIRLVjODFRQMXJDLVRQVXEMHFWLYH &6 
([HPSOHV
³FRPSOpPHQWG·DJHQWG·XQSUpGLFDWYHUEDODXSDVVLI
lPSQ̾ NXO MF7K8 HLࣹO8 VL
%FKLHQ/2& =F899FH%+&0 FRPSOqWHPHQW 35(9PDQJHU 35(7 %$*+4%5!$$*'
J

´/HSRLVVRQDpWpGpYRUpFRPSOqWHPHQWSDUOHFKLHQµ

6=8PQ̾ MRࣹ̾OW Wࣹ̾ WXOL

SqUHPRQ/2& DUF3/85 LFL DSSRUWHU35(6QJ6,1*3$66,)
´XQDUFHVWDSSRUWpLFLSDUPRQSqUHµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% K8D<KH7%7\K%N87%3<7%H<B7%N87%N<BD\87%,\K<N/8BB87% 

³HPSORLOLpjXQDFWDQWGDQVXQpQRQFpDYHF&2
6=8PQ̾ MRࣹ̾OW Wࣹ̾ WXO̾>>̾%
SqUHPRQ/2& DUF3/85 LFL DSSRUWHU35(6&23266U6,1*3266p3/85
´PRQSqUHDSSRUWHLFLOHVDUFVµ

/·DQDO\VHVHKHXUWHLPPpGLDWHPHQWDYHFXQpQRQFpGHFHW\SHjXQSUREOqPHSRXUO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHOD
SUpGLFDWLRQSUREOqPHTXLDpWppYRTXpSUpFpGHPPHQWSRXUXQpQRQFpYRJRXO
/DWUDGXFWLRQIUDQoDLVHGHO·pQRQFpRVWLDNWUDLWH(I#M>M)̾FRPPHOHVXMHWGXYHUEHPDLVSRXUXQHDQDO\VHFRU
UHFWHLOIDXWH[DPLQHUODPRUSKRORJLHGXPRWTXLIDLWIRQFWLRQGHSUpGLFDWFHPRWGRQWOHUDGLFDOHVWXQOH[qPH
YHUEDOVRXPLVjXQHFRQMXJDLVRQGRQFLQWpJUpDXSDUDGLJPHYHUEDOQ·HQHVWSDVPRLQVXQHIRUPHSRVVHVVLYHDYHF
XQVXIIL[H̾..̾TXLUHQYRLHjXQSRVVHVVHXUJSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHUHWjXQSRVVpGpSOXULHOF·HVWjGLUHXQVXIIL[H
SRVVHVVLIGRQWOHVUpIpUHQFHVFRUUHVSRQGHQWjFHOOHVGH´VHVµHQIUDQoDLVF·HVWjGLUHDXVVLXQVXIIL[HTXLDFFRUGH
OHSUpGLFDWQRQSDVDYHF(I#M>M)̾PDLVDYHFOHSOXULHOMRࣹ̾.M$O·DFFRUGYHUEDODYHFOHVXMHWVHGpILQLVVDQWFRPPHOH
WUDQVIHUWG·XQHFDWpJRULH HQO·RFFXUUHQFHOHQRPEUH GXVXMHWDXYHUEHO·DXWUHUpIpUHQFHFRQWHQXHGDQVOHVXIIL[H
SRVVHVVLIUHSUpVHQWHQRQSDVXQDFFRUG SDUWUDQVIHUWGHFDWpJRULH PDLVO·pWDEOLVVHPHQWG·XQHFRQJUXHQFHHQWUH
ODIRUPHYHUEDOHHWOHWHUPHLQLWLDOGHODSKUDVHUHODWLYHPHQWjODSHUVRQQHYLVpHODJSHUVRQQHGXVLQJXOLHUSRXU
(I#M>´PRQSqUHµ&RQFOXVLRQODWUDGXFWLRQOLWWpUDOHHVW´PRQSqUHOHVDUFV>VRQW@VHVDSSRUWpVLFLµGHUULqUHOH
PDVTXHTXHFRQVWLWXHO·LQVHUWLRQGHFHVIRUPHVREMHFWLYHVGDQVOHSDUDGLJPHYHUEDOVHFDFKHXQHSKUDVHjSUpGLFDW
QRPLQDO³RXVLO·RQSUpIqUHYHUERQRPLQDO RQQHSHXWSDVSRVHUOHFOLYDJHQRPYHUEHHQRVWLDNRXHQYRJRXO
FRPPHHQIUDQoDLV F·HVWXQHIRUPXOHGHSUpGLFDWLRQQRPLQDOHTXLVHSUpVHQWHLFLSDUFHTXHODSUpGLFDWLRQSUHQG
ODIRUPHG·XQHUHODWLRQG·DSSDUWHQDQFH
6LRQSDVVHGXSOXULHODXGXHOSRXUOHVDUFVRQYHUUDO·DFFRUGGX´YHUEHµVHIDLUHDYHFFHGXHOF·HVWjGLUH
DYHFODIRUPHGHGXHOMRࣹ̾Oࣹ̾QN

6=8PQ̾ MRࣹ̾Oࣹ̾Q Wࣹ̾̾Q Wࣹ̾ WXOࣹ̾>%

´PRQSqUHDSSRUWHLFLOHV  DUFVµ¬
OLWW´PRQSqUHOHV  DUFV>VRQW@VHVDSSRUWpVµ

ࣹ̾.UpDOLVHGDQVOHSUpGLFDWO·DFFRUGDYHFࣹ̾)GDQVOHVXMHWODPDUTXHGXGXHOpWDQWOHࣹFRPPXQDX[GHX[
VXIIL[HV
3HXWRQGDQVFHVFRQGLWLRQVFRQVLGpUHUTX·LO\DHUJDWLYLWpHWTXHOHVXIIL[HORFDWLIQ̾WM)̾DXQHIRQFWLRQDJHQ
WLYH"/HUHFRXUVjXQVXIIL[HORFDWLIPHWHQpYLGHQFHO·DJHQWGXSURFqVHQOHWUDLWDQWFRPPHOHVLqJHGHFHSURFqVHW
RQFRQoRLWELHQTXHFHPDUTXDJHORFDWLIDLWSXVHIDLUHDXVVLELHQSRXUOHFRPSOpPHQWG·DJHQWG·XQSUpGLFDWYHUEDO
DXSDVVLI0DLVIDXWLOSRXUDXWDQWSDUOHUG·HUJDWLI"'DQVODSUDWLTXHW\SRORJLTXHOHVVWUXFWXUHVG·DFWDQFHVRQW
GpILQLHVVXUGHVFULWqUHVWUqVSUpFLVFRQFHUQDQWOHWUDLWHPHQWFRPSDUpGHVDFWDQWVGDQVOHVpQRQFpVXQLDFWDQFLHOV
HWELDFWDQFLHOVHWFHTX·RQGRLWSUHQGUHHQFRPSWHFHVRQWOHVPDUTXHVTXHOHVDFWDQWVHX[PrPHVFRPPHFRQVWL
WXDQWVG·pQRQFpVUHoRLYHQWGDQVOHVGLIIpUHQWHVFRPSRVLWLRQVGHVpQRQFpV'DQVOHVODQJXHVRXJULHQQHVGH6LEpULH
ODVLWXDWLRQQHVHSUrWHSDVjO·DSSOLFDWLRQGHWHOVFULWqUHVOHYRJRXOGXQRUGHWO·RVWLDNQ·RQWSDVXQV\VWqPHFDVXHO
LQFOXDQWO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHXQQRPLQDWLIHWXQDFFXVDWLIFHTXLYHXWGLUHTXHSRXUH[DPLQHUOH´WUDLWHPHQWGHV
DFWDQWVµLOIDXWSRUWHUODUHFKHUFKHGHVLQGLFHVDLOOHXUVTXHGDQVODPRUSKRORJLHGHVDFWDQWVHX[PrPHVHWSXLVHU
GDQVODFRQVWLWXWLRQGHVIRUPHVYHUEDOHV&·HVWXQHWRXWDXWUHDIIDLUHPDLVF·HVWFHTXHIDLW*LOEHUW/D]DUGSRXU
´OpJLWLPHUOHVDSSURFKHVPXOWLSOHVHQW\SRORJLHµ /D]DUG LOQHSHXWSRXUWDQWOHIDLUHTX·DX[GpSHQVGHOD
SHUWLQHQFHGHVLQGLFHVVXUOHVTXHOVV·DSSXLHDORUVO·H[DPHQGHVGLIIpUHQWHVVWUXFWXUHVG·pQRQFpV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% P8<B%@8KK,*

K7L:78@=;>?74
$ERQGROR'DQLHO0pG
  *+!%\-(.#4%N()51(5!05RXWOHGJH/DQJXDJH)DPLO\'HVFULSWLRQV1HZ<RUN5RXWOHGJH
&RPULH%HUQDUG
  ´6XEMHFWVDQG'LUHFW2EMHFWVLQ8UDOLF/DQJXDJHV$)XQFWLRQDO([SODQDWLRQRI&DVHPDUNLQJ6\V
WHPVµQ$1"!0%:#))6M615-#!))!0²
*UHHQEHUJ-RVHSK+DUROG
% :??Q% N!0%.()51!0%#)"6!1-6IU!))!0%!$%.(%:(>#..!%!1-(0#($#X1!3DULV%HOLQ
-DQKXQHQ-XKD
  ´2QWKH&RQYHUJHQFHRIWKH*HQLWLYHDQG$FFXVDWLYH&DVHVLQ/DQJXDJHVRIWKH8UDODOWDwF7\SHµ
36H9%N!0%.()51!0%61-(.#!))!0%(1c61-";+1#g%(II-64+!%.#)51#0$#X1!%!$%465)#$#?!pGLWpSDU00-%)HUQDQGH]
9HVWSS²3DULV&KDPSLRQ
.LHIHU)HUHQF
  ´/DGpFOLQDLVRQGXQRPHQKRQJURLVOHVGpVLQHQFHVFDVXHOOHVµ'DQVN!0%.()51!0%61-(.#!))!0%(1M
c61-";+1#g%(II-64+!%.#)51#0$#X1!%!$%465)#$#?!pGLWpSDU00-%)HUQDQGH]9HVWSS²3DULV
&KDPSLRQ
/D]DUG*LOEHUW
  ´/pJLWLPLWpGHVDSSURFKHVPXOWLSOHVHQW\SRORJLH8QH[HPSOHDFWDQFHHWSRVVHVVLRQµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%
764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
5J77FK2%[J6H%
  ´6XUO·DFFXVDWLISURQRPLQDOHQILQQRRXJULHQµ'DQVQ$1"!0%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%:#))6M615-#!))!SS²
/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
 ´0RUSKRORJLHYHUEDOHHWUHODWLRQVDFWDQFLHOOHVHQRVWLDNRULHQWDOµA6"E.!0%.#)51#0$#X1!0²
  ´6WUXFWXUHGHODPRUSKRORJLHYHUEDOHHQPRUGYHOHVLQGLFHVDFWDQFLHOVµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)M
51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
  ´/·H[SUHVVLRQGHO·REMHWHQPRUGYHHU]DµQ$1"!0%:#))6M615-#!))!0²
  ´$VSHFWVGHODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQHQILQQRRXJULHQPRUSKRV\QWD[HGHO·DFWDQFHµAU>6#-!0%"!%.(%764#U$U%
"!%N#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
  ´4XHOTXHVIDLWVFRQFHUQDQWOHQRPEUHGDQVOHVODQJXHVRXUDOLHQQHVµAU>6#-!0%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%N#)M
51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
% :??R%% Q$1"!0%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%:#))6M615-#!))!/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
  K!5(-"0%01-%.!0%.()51!0%61-(.#!))!0g%U$1"!0%0$-14$1-(.!02%(II-64+!0%46)$-(0$#?!02%-!5(-"0%"!%.#)51#0$!03DULV
/·+DUPDWWDQ
  ´0pWKRGRORJLHGHODJUDPPDLUHFRPSDUpHHWFRPSDUDWLVPHRXUDOLHQµAU>6#-!0%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%N#)M
51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
6DXYDJHRW$XUpOLHQ
% OPRO% 80X1#00!%"!%.(%.()51!%+6)5-6#0!3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
% OP@O% N;U"#:#4($#6)%"!%.(%.()51!%+6)5-6#0!3DULV.OLQFNVLHFN
6LQRU'HQLVpG
  *+!%\-(.#4%N()51(5!0L+DQGEXFKGHU2ULHQWDOLVWLN+DQGERRNRI8UDOLF6WXGLHV/H\GH%ULOO
9LLWVR7LLW5HLQ
  ´(VWRQLDQµ'DQV*+!%\-(.#4%N()51(5!0pGLWpSDU'0$ERQGRORSS²1HZ<RUN5RXWOHGJH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7\K%N;O/7*,/K8%H87%3<7%8B%*,bO<K/8B% 

!"
#$%&'()*#+,*%-&.-#&/0#&-1&+,2)0%*-1

D!6-5!0MP!()%@#)(1.$2%Q46.!%@-($#X1!%"!0%O(1$!0%Q$1"!0%^@(-#0`

34(QXQHQRXYHOOHEUDQFKHGHODIDPLOOHOLQJXLVWLTXHLQGRHXURSpHQQHDpWpLGHQWLϮpHOH´WRNKDULHQµ
JUkFHDXGpFKLϸUHPHQWGHGHX[ODQJXHVpWURLWHPHQWDSSDUHQWpHVELHQTXHGLϸpUHQWHVHOOHVRQWUHoXOHVGpVLJQD
WLRQVFRQYHQWLRQQHOOHV´WRNKDULHQ$µHW´WRNKDULHQ%µ&HOOHVFLVRQWSUpIpUDEOHVDX[WHUPHVJpRJUDSKLTXHVDOOH
PDQG,0$$64+(-#04+ WRNK$ HWJ!0$$64+(-#04+ WRNK% TXLQHFRUUHVSRQGHQWTX·LPSDUIDLWHPHQWjODGLVWULEXWLRQ
GHVPDQXVFULWVGHVGHX[ODQJXHVVXUOHVVLWHVGXEDVVLQGX7DULPOHORQJGHODURXWHVHSWHQWULRQDOHGX7XUNHVWDQ
FKLQRLVDFWXHO;LQMLDQJ$XVHQVVWULFW´WRNKDULHQµGHYUDLWGRQFGpVLJQHUXQHIDPLOOHGHODQJXHVjO·LQVWDUGH
´JHUPDQLTXHµRX´VODYHµ­SDUWLUGHVGHX[ODQJXHVDWWHVWpHVWRNKDULHQ$HWWRNKDULHQ%RQGRLWG·DERUGWHQWHUGH
UHFRQVWUXLUHODODQJXHFRPPXQHGRQWHOOHVSURFqGHQWOH´WRNKDULHQFRPPXQµ DQJODLV36>>6)%*64+(-#() TXLSHXW
pYHQWXHOOHPHQWrWUHFRPSDUpDX[VWDGHVDQFLHQVRXUHFRQVWUXLWV SDUH[HPSOHJUHFFRPPXQJHUPDQLTXHFRPPXQ
VODYHFRPPXQHWF GHVDXWUHVEUDQFKHVGHODIDPLOOHLQGRHXURSpHQQH,OYDXGUDLWPLHX[jPRQDYLVUpVHUYHU
OHWHUPH´SURWRWRNKDULHQµ DQJODLV@-6$6M*64+(-#() jODSpULRGHDQWpULHXUHDXWRNKDULHQFRPPXQ FLDSUqVWRNK
FRP TXLVpSDUHFHOXLFLGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQUHFRQVWUXLWHWTXLFRPSRUWHFRPPHSRXUWRXWHODQJXHLQGRHXUR
SpHQQHSOXVLHXUVSKDVHVFHOOHVFLSHXYHQWrWUHDSSUpKHQGpHVHWRUGRQQpHVSDUODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQWHUQH'qVVRQ
GpFKLϸUHPHQWOHWRNKDULHQDDWWLUpO·DWWHQWLRQGHVFRPSDUDWLVWHVHWGHVOLQJXLVWHVHQJpQpUDOSDUODVLQJXODULWpGH
VDGpFOLQDLVRQQRPLQDOHDORUVTXHODϰH[LRQYHUEDOHQHSUpVHQWHSDVGXSRLQWGHYXHGHVVWUXFWXUHVGHGLϸpUHQFH
QRWDEOHSDUUDSSRUWDX[DXWUHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVHQGHKRUVGXPDUTXDJHVSpFLϮTXHGHODWUDQVLWLYLWpSDU
OHWKqPHYHUEDO'DQVOHVGHX[ODQJXHVWRNKDULHQQHVODGpFOLQDLVRQQRPLQDOHHVWjGHX[´pWDJHVµVHORQO·H[SUHVVLRQ
KHXUHXVHGHVSUHPLHUVWRNKDURORJXHV2QSHXWSUpFLVHU¬FHODOHSUHPLHUpWDJHHVWGHW\SHϰH[LRQQHODORUVTXHOH
VHFRQGHVWGHW\SHDJJOXWLQDWLI'HX[W\SHVGH´FDVµVRQWGRQFGLVWLQJXpV OHVFDVGLWV=78M687J9 DOOI-#>a-!%b(010 
H[SULPpVSDUGHVGpVLQHQFHVV\QWKpWLTXHV FDVQRPEUH ³¬QRPLQDWLI³YRFDWLI VHXOHPHQWHQ% ³´REOLTXHµ 
DFFXVDWLI ³JpQLWLI OHVFDVGLWVVHFRQGDLUHV DOO0!=1)"a-!%b(010 H[SULPpVSDUGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVLQGLϸpUHQWHV
DXQRPEUHHWDXJHQUHDMRXWpHVjODIRUPHG·DFFXVDWLI GXVLQJXOLHUGXSOXULHORXGXGXHO HWQRQSDVDXWKqPH
&RPPHOHWHUPH´GpVLQHQFHµVRXVHQWHQGXGHW\SHϰH[LRQQHOGRLWrWUHDSSOLTXpVHXOHPHQWDX[PRUSKqPHVGX
SUHPLHUW\SHMHSURSRVHGHGpQRPPHU´Dϲ[HVFDVXHOVµOHVPRUSKqPHVGXVHFRQGW\SH
!4/·LQYHQWDLUHGHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOVV·pWDEOLWFRPPHVXLWVLO·RQUHSUHQGODWHUPLQRORJLHGXPDQXHOGHWRNKD
ULHQ *8S,² ,OVVRQWVHSWHQWRXWGRQWFLQTVRQWFRPPXQVDX[GHX[ODQJXHV-·DLSODFpGDQVXQHWURLVLqPH
FRORQQHOHVPRUSKqPHVLQGpSHQGDQWVTXLSHXYHQWrWUHUDSSURFKpVHQV\QFKURQLHDYHFSOXVRXPRLQVGHVXFFqV
GHFHVDIIL[HVQRXVHQUHSDUOHURQVSOXVORLQ † 

% ! % DGYHUEHSUpRXSRVWSRVLWLRQ

5J7>6K8G č 0( Vč ³

*H9K7LMJHK6> '6 ‘ !%'6 FRQMRQFWLRQ ¬
"FM8K6K8G DߓߓlO >I( !%ߓOD%ߓDOHߓOH%>I(
!>>6K8G (4 ߓ 4 !čxF%%!44!2%!%(4#
!D>6K8G lߙ Dߙ PHؐ %>()$!2%!%ߙX " 
/RFDWLI Dؐ )! !%()^)`!2%%HQHؐ
"6L96> ‘ x l ³


 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8,KD87MP8<B%@/B<\N*

543DUDGLJPHVGHUpIpUHQFH%'(=9!2%!%'1=´FKHYDOµHW%H‫ع‬NZH2%!%R‫ع‬N´KRPPH PkOH µ

% !
$8HIL>8J7 5>L78J> $8HIL>8J7 5>L78J>
´FKHYDOµ
+FM8H6K8G '(=9! '(=9# '1= \XNDx
*pQLWLI 'a=9!)$0! \lNZHؐWV '1=!0 \XNDߓߓL
2EOLTXH '(=9! \DNZHؐ '1= '1=(0
*H9K7LMJHK6> ‘ ‘ '1='6 '1=(0'6
5J7>6K8G '(=9!0( '(=9!)$0( \XNč \XNDVč
"FM8K6K8G '(=9!>I( \DNZHؐPSD \XNDߓߓlO \XNDVDߓߓlO
!>>6K8G \DNZHߓ 4 \DNZHؐߓ 4 '1=(4 '1=(0(4
!D>6K8G \lNZHPHؐ \DNZHQPHؐ \XNlߙ \XNDVlߙ
/RFDWLI '(=9!)! \DNZHؐQH \XNDؐ \XNDVDؐ
´KRPPH PkOH µ
+FM8H6K8G H‫ع‬NZH H‫ع‬NZL R‫ع‬N R‫ع‬NDx
*pQLWLI H‫ع‬NZHQWVH H‫ع‬NZHQWV R‫ع‬NLV R‫ع‬NDߓߓL
2EOLTXH H‫ع‬NZHؐ H‫ع‬NZHؐ R‫ع‬NDؐ R‫ع‬NDV
5J7>6K8G H‫ع‬NZHQWVD H‫ع‬NZHQWVD R‫ع‬NQč R‫ع‬NVč
"FM8K6K8G H‫ع‬NZHؐPSD H‫ع‬NZHؐPSD R‫ع‬NQDߓߓlO R‫ع‬NVDߓߓlO
!>>6K8G H‫ع‬NZHؐߓ 4 H‫ع‬NZHؐߓ 4 R‫ع‬NQDF R‫ع‬NVDF
!D>6K8G H‫ع‬NZHؐPHؐ H‫ع‬NZHؐPHؐ R‫ع‬NQlߙ R‫ع‬NVlߙ
/RFDWLI H‫ع‬NZHؐQH H‫ع‬NZHؐQH R‫ع‬NQDؐ R‫ع‬NVDؐ

'HFHWDEOHDXVHXOHVWH[FOXOHFDXVDOGXWRNKDULHQ%FDUFHFDVHVWUHVWUHLQWVXUOHSODQOH[LFDODX[QRPVTXL
H[SULPHQWXQVHQWLPHQWRXXQpWDWSV\FKRORJLTXHHJ%!)$0!´HQYLHµFDXVDOHQWVHx 6 ´SDUHQYLHµ%NčZR´GpVLUµ
%FDXVDONDZčx%.(=.!´VRXIIUDQFHµ%OlNOHx3RXUXQHDXWUHUDLVRQQRXVDYRQVDXVVLODLVVpGHF{WpOHYRFDWLITXL
Q·HVWFRQQXTX·HQWRNKDULHQ%HWVHXOHPHQWDXVLQJXOLHUGHFHUWDLQVW\SHVGHVXEVWDQWLIVHWG·DGMHFWLIVHQWRNKD
ULHQ$OHQRPLQDWLIVHUWDXVVLGHYRFDWLI'HWRXWHIDoRQLOHVWLPSRVVLEOHGHIDLUHUHPRQWHUOHVGLYHUVHVIRUPHV
GXYRFDWLIHQWRNKDULHQ%TXLFRQFHUQHQWVHXOHPHQWXQHSDUWLHGHVQRPVDX[IRUPDWLRQVVSpFLILTXHVGHYRFDWLI
FRQQXHVSDUOHVDXWUHVODQJXHVjVDYRLUWKqPHHQ !HWGpVLQHQFH]pURGDQVOHVQRPVWKpPDWLTXHVW\SHODWLQ
"6>#)! GH"6>#)10 HWJUHF‫ݵ‬໅ड़͘ GH‫ݵ‬໅ड़‫ ߥڗ‬WKqPHIRUWVXLYLGHGpVLQHQFH]pURW\SHJUHF›ඥࠗ͘‫ݰ‬YpGLTXHI#$(-
UI+n$!- QRPVLQJJUHF›Ǔࠗ༓‫ݰ‬YpGLTXHI#$Ď JUHF༦श‫ ່ڗ‬GH༦शန YpGLTXH0(=+! GHViNKč\ HWF
/DFRPSDUDLVRQGHODGpFOLQDLVRQGHFHVGHX[QRPVGHJHQUHPDVFXOLQQRXVDSSUHQGLPPpGLDWHPHQWSOXVLHXUV
IDLWV3RXUOHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHVODVHXOHGLIIpUHQFHHQWUHOHVLQJXOLHUHWOHSOXULHOUpVLGHGDQVODEDVHTXLHVWO·DFFX
VDWLIVLQJXOLHU%'(=9! $'1= %H‫ع‬NZHؐ $R‫ع‬NDؐ GDQVOHSUHPLHUFDVO·DFFXVDWLISOXULHO%\DNZHؐ $'1=(0 %
H‫ع‬NZHؐ $R‫ع‬NDV GDQVOHVHFRQGFDV-HUDSSHOOHTXHOHVLJQHؐ! DQXVYčUDGDQVOHV\OODEDLUHEUčKPҸHPSUXQWp
HWFRPSOpWpSDUOHVVFULEHVWRNKDULHQV QRWHXQHQDVDOHGHQWDOHQ/HVIRUPHVDWWHVWpHVVRQWGXHVjO·DSSOLFDWLRQ
GHORLVSKRQpWLTXHVUHODWLYHPHQWWDUGLYHVpSHQWKqVH)$0( QVčGDQV%SHUOSOXU'(=9!)$0(GDQV%SHUOVLQJ
HWSOXUH‫ع‬NZHQWVDHQWRNKDULHQ$IHUPHWXUHHWV\QFRSHGH(HQV\OODEHLQWpULHXUHRXYHUWHDSUqVV\OODEHDYHF
YR\HOOHRXYHUWHG·RDXVLQJXOLHU R‫ع‬NDQč%X%R‫ع‬NQč2%UR‫ع‬NDQDߓߓlO%X%R‫ع‬NQDߓߓlO2%UR‫ع‬NDQDF%X%R‫ع‬NQDF2%UR‫ع‬NDQlߙ%X%R‫ع‬NQlߙ2%
UR‫ع‬NDQDؐ%X%R‫ع‬NQDؐ2%6L%=>L78J>%UR‫ع‬NDVč%X%R‫ع‬NVč2%UR‫ع‬NDVDߓߓlO2%UR‫ع‬NDVDF%X%R‫ع‬NVDFHWF6LO·RQUHVWLWXHOHVIRUPHVVRXV
MDFHQWHVODV\PpWULHGHODGpFOLQDLVRQHVWWRWDOH&HUWDLQHVGRQQpHVVRQWSURSUHVDXWRNKDULHQ%'DQVOHW\SHGH
%H‫ع‬NZHjSDUWLUGHO·REOLTXH DFFXVDWLI OHVIRUPHVVRQWLGHQWLTXHVDXVLQJXOLHUHWDXSOXULHOVLODGLVWLQFWLRQ
HVWQpFHVVDLUHSRXUODFRPSUpKHQVLRQGXPHVVDJHOHSOXULHOGHYUDrWUHSUpFLVpSDUXQDGMHFWLIXQGpWHUPLQDQWRX
XQSURQRPGHUDSSHO&HWWHKRPRQ\PLHHVWGXHjODFRQIXVLRQIRUWXLWHGHO·REOLTXHVLQJXOLHUH‫ع‬NZHؐSRXUYXGH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7\K%N;O/7*,/K8%H87%3<7%8B%*,bO<K/8B% 

ODGpVLQHQFHFDUDFWpULVWLTXHGHVrWUHVFODVVpVFRPPH>KXPDLQ@ YRLUSOXVORLQ† HWGHO·REOLTXHSOXULHOH‫ع‬NZHؐ2%

GHPrPHW\SHIOH[LRQQHOTXH'(=9!´FKHYDOµ(QHIIHWODGpFOLQDLVRQGH%H‫ع‬NZH%JK%'(=9!UHIOqWHOHW\SHWKpPD
WLTXHLQGRHXURSpHQDYHFDXSOXULHOQRP# a' 6#% FIODWLQHTXҸJUHFໍ››‫ڗ‬ԆILQDOHHPSUXQWpHDX[SURQRPV
GpPRQVWUDWLIV HWDFF Hؐ é)0 6M)0 FIODWLQHTX‫گ‬VJUHFໍ››‫ڗ‬࿰ߥJUHFFRPPXQ‫ڗ‬ဎߥFRQVHUYpHQDUJLHQHW
HQFUpWRLV /DILQDOHG·DFFXVDWLISOXUWRNKDULHQFRPPXQ é)0DGRQQpWRNKDULHQ$(0FIUHVSHFWLYHPHQW'1=(0%
JK%R‫ع‬NDVPDLVOHQRPLQDWLISOXUDpWpUHQRXYHOpSDUXQHILQDOHLVVXHGHODIOH[LRQHQQDVDOH 6)M!0!WRNKDULHQ
FRPPXQ  xl!$DxGRQWOHW\SHHVWGHYHQXWUqVSURGXFWLIGDQVFHWWHODQJXH

64)RQFWLRQQHPHQWGHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOV
6434$XWRQRPLHDFFHQWXHOOHHWVpSDUDELOLWpGHVDIIL[HV
5DSSHORQVTXHOHWRNKDULHQ%SRVVqGHXQDFFHQWGRQWODSODFHHVWUpYpOpHSDUOHVFKDQJHPHQWVGHWLPEUH
GHVYR\HOOHVFHQWUDOHVHWSDUODV\QFRSHGHODYR\HOOHFHQWUDOHODSOXVIHUPpHVDQVWHQLUFRPSWHGHFHUWDLQHV
H[FHSWLRQVFHWDFFHQWWRPEHVXUODGHX[LqPHYR\HOOHGHVPRWVGHWURLVV\OODEHVHWSOXVGDQVOHVPRWVGHGHX[
V\OODEHVLOUHPRQWHVXUODSUHPLqUHV\OODEH'·DSUqVOHWRNKDULHQ%O·DGGLWLRQGHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOVjODGLIIpUHQFH
GHVVXIIL[HVGHSOXULHOHWGHVGpVLQHQFHVSULPDLUHVQ·DIIHFWHSDVOHPRWSKRQRORJLTXHTXLUHoRLWO·DFFHQW3UHQRQV
SDUH[HPSOHXQVXEVWDQWLIWUqVIUpTXHQWGDQVOHVWH[WHVERXGGKLTXHVWRNKDULHQV%OiNOH´GRXOHXUµ6DIRUPHVRXV
MDFHQWHHVW .a=.!DFFHQWXpVXUODSUHPLqUHV\OODEHG·RVLQJQRPREOOiNOH .đ=.!PDLVOHQRPHVWDFFHQWXpVXU
ODGHX[LqPHV\OODEHGDQVOHVIRUPHVGHWURLVV\OODEHVSOXUQRPREO.a=.UM)$( OlNOHQWčDYHFVXIIL[HGHSOXULHO
YRLUSOXVEDV† VLQJJpQ.a=.UM)$0!3DUFRQWUHOHVIRUPHVGHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHVRQWODPrPHDFFHQWXDWLRQTXH
O·REOLTXHVLQJVXUOHVTXHOVLOVVRQWIRQGpVPrPHTXDQGO·DIIL[HFDVXHOFRQVWLWXHXQHV\OODEHSOHLQHVLQJSHUO
OiNOHVDORFOiNOHQHFRPPXQOiNOHPSDDOOOiNOHߓF 6 )RQWH[FHSWLRQjFHWWHUqJOHGHX[FDVO·DEODWLITXLHVWOH
SOXVVRXYHQWGXW\SH.a=.UM>!ؐHWOHFDXVDOOlNOpx/DJUDSKLHxRGHO·DIIL[HGXFDXVDOGDQVOHVWH[WHVSRpWLTXHV
UpYqOHTXHFHPRUSKqPHFRPPHG·DXWUHVFRPSRUWDLWRULJLQHOOHPHQWXQHV\OODEHPDLVODYR\HOOHILQDOHV·HVWDPXwH
SOXVWDUGLYHPHQWTXHG·DXWUHVVXIILVDPPHQWWDUGSRXUTXHFHGRXEOHWGXWRNKDULHQ%DUFKDwTXHDLWpWpLQWpJUpj
ODODQJXHSRpWLTXH(QFHTXLFRQFHUQHO·DEODWLIOHW\SHOiNOHPHؐDYHFODPrPHDFFHQWXDWLRQTXHOHVDXWUHVFDV
VHFRQGDLUHVHVWpJDOHPHQWFRQQXPDLVLOHVWHQIDLWWUqVUDUH/·DFFHQWXDWLRQGXW\SHOlNOpPHؐHVWUpJXOLqUHHWVH
YpULILHTXHOTXHVRLWOHW\SHGHWKqPH YRLU†3LQDXOW² ,OQ·HVWSDVGLIILFLOHG·H[SOLTXHUODYDULDQWH
M8HF78K687J%OiNOHPHؐSDUO·LQIOXHQFHGHVDXWUHVFDVGHPrPHVWUXFWXUHIRUPHOOHSHUOOiNOHVDORFOiNOHQHHWF6XU
OHSODQV\QWD[LTXHULHQQHSHXWMXVWLILHUODGLYHUJHQFHGHO·DEODWLIHWGXFDXVDOSDUUDSSRUWDX[DXWUHVFDV/·LGpH
G·XQHGLVWLQFWLRQHQWUH´V\QWDJPHµHW´JURXSHGHPRWVµ J6-$5-1II! DYDQFpHSDU.OLQJHQVFKPLWW I 
HVWVSpFLHXVHFDUO·DIIL[HG·DEODWLISUpVHQWHH[DFWHPHQWOHPrPHFRPSRUWHPHQWTXHOHVDXWUHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOVHW
FRQVWLWXHpJDOHPHQWXQV\QWDJPHIRUPpSDUXQHSRVWSRVLWLRQDMRXWpHjODIRUPHG·REOLTXH
6pSDUDELOLWp¬GHVDIIL[HVRQO·REVHUYHGDQVOHVIRUPXOHVGHGDWDWLRQTXLVRQWQRPEUHXVHVGDQVOHVWH[WHVpFR
QRPLTXHVHQWRNKDULHQ%5DSSHORQVTXHOHTXDQWLqPHGXMRXUHVWLQGLTXpSDUOHQXPpUDOFDUGLQDOHWQRQSDVSDU
O·RUGLQDOFRPPHFHODHVWSRVVLEOHHQIUDQoDLVFRXUDQW
ߓDN% PHxDQWVH QH ´GDQVOHGL[ LqPH >MRXU@GXPRLVµ
GL[ PRLV*e1 GDQV
ߙNDV PHxDQWVH PHؐ ´GHSXLVOHVL[ LqPH >MRXU@GXPRLVµ
VL[ PRLV*e1 GHSXLV
&HVFRQVWUXFWLRQVEDQDOHVSUpVHQWHQWO·LQWpUrWVXLYDQWOHJpQLWLIG·DSSDUWHQDQFHGH%PHxH´PRLVµHVWLQVpUpGDQV
OHV\QWDJPHQXPpUDODIIL[HFDVXHOUHVSHFWLYHPHQWߓDNQH´GDQVOHGL[µߙNDVPHؐ´GHSXLVOHVL[µ

64!4'LVWULEXWLRQV\QWDJPDWLTXHFRUROODLUHGHO·DGGLWLRQGHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOVjODIRUPHG·REOLTXH DFFXVDWLI
64!4346\QWDJPHFRRUGLQDWLI
3UHQRQVOHSOXULHOGHVVXEVWDQWLIV$=1=a.´FKDUµ'1=´FKHYDOµ6‫(=ع‬.a>´pOpSKDQWµ
% +FM8H6K8G%=>L78J>%% NXNODx\XNDxR‫ع‬NlOPčx ´FKDUVFKHYDX[pOpSKDQWVµ
 2EOLTXHSOXULHO =1=.(02%'1=(02%R‫ع‬NlOPčV
 ,QVWUXPHQWDOSOXULHO¬ NXNODV\XNDVR‫ع‬NlOPčV\R ´DYHFGHVFKDUVFKHYDX[pOpSKDQWVµ
!% =1=.(0% %'1=(0%% 6‫ع‬NlOPčV \R
% FKDUV FKHYDX[ pOpSKDQWV DYHF
 [2%/3/85% ,1675
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8,KD87MP8<B%@/B<\N*

3UHQRQVOHVLQJXOLHUGHVVXEVWDQWLIVGHODWULDGH´FRUSVSDUROHHVSULWµHQWRNKDULHQ%
+FM8H6K8G%98HIL>8J7% NHNWVHxH2%-!=#2%I(.0=6
2EOLTXHVLQJXOLHU NHNWVHx2%-!=#2%I(.0=6
5J7>6K8G%98HIL>8J7%% NHNWVHxUHNLSDOVNRVD´SDUOHFRUSVODSDUROHO·HVSULWµ
% NHNWVHx UHNL SDOVNR VD%
 FRUSV SDUROH HVSULW SDU
 [2%/6,1* 3(5/

64!4!46\QWDJPHDWWULEXWLIDGMHFWLI RXGpPRQVWUDWLI VXEVWDQWLI

$೏QRPVLQJSXNNDSߓDxL¬´WRXWOHFRUSVµSRQWVčؐNDSߓLxxlߙ´KRUVGHWRXWOHFRUSVµ
% SRQWVčؐ NDSߓLxx lߙ%
 2%/6,1*)e0 2%/6,1* $%/
%೏QRPVLQJ=(-$0!%I!.(#=)!´ODERQQH/RLµ=-!)$%I!.(#=)!)!´GDQVODERQQH/RLµ
% =-!)$%% %I!.(#=)!% %M)!
% 2%/6,1*0$6& 2%/6,1* /2&

64!4548VDJHLQWHUPpGLDLUHGXJpQLWLIHQV\QWDJPHDWWULEXWLI
3UHQRQVGHVV\QWDJPHVIRUPpVGHVPRWVVXLYDQWV$9-(06>´rWUHYLYDQWµSOXULHOQRPZUDVDxREO9-(0(0JpQ
ZUDVDߓߓL%6)6.>!PrPHVHQVVLQJREO6)6.>!JpQ6)6.>!)$0!SOXULHOQRP6)6.>#REO6)6.>!ؐJpQRQROPHؐWV
pSLWKqWH$WčOR´PDOKHXUHX[µPDVFVLQJREOWčORQWJpQWčORQWčSSOXULHOQRPWčORߙREOWčORxFlVJpQWčORxFlߓߓL2%
HW%WDOOč1 PrPHVHQV HWGHIRUPDWLRQDSSDUHQWpH PDVFVLQJREOWDOOčQWJpQWDOOčQWHSOXULHOQRPWDOOčxFREO
WDOOčQWlؐJpQWDOOčQWlؐWV/HVV\QWDJPHVUHVSHFWLIVDXQRPLQDWLIHWjO·REOLTXH DFFXVDWLI SOXULHOVRQWDFFRUGpVHQ
JHQUHHQQRPEUHHWHQFDV´OHVrWUHVPDOKHXUHX[µ$QRPWčORߙZUDVDxREOWčORxFlVZUDVDV%QRPWDOOčxFRQROPL2%
REOWDOOčQWlؐ%RQROPHؐ3RXUOHV\QWDJPHDXJpQLWLILOH[LVWHXQHDOWHUQDWLYH
  7RXVOHVWHUPHVVRQWDXJpQLWLI
!%% WčORxFlߓߓLZUDVDߓߓL ´GHVrWUHVPDOKHXUHX[µ
% WDOOčQWlؐWV%RQROPHؐWV ೏*e13/85*e13/85%
  6HXOOHGHUQLHUWHUPHOHVXEVWDQWLIHVWDXJpQLWLIOHSUpFpGHQWHVWjO·REOLTXH
!%% WčORxFlVZUDVDߓߓL
% WDOOčQWlؐRQROPHؐWV% 2%/3/85*e13/85
'DQVODVHFRQGHRSWLRQODFRQVWUXFWLRQHVWLGHQWLTXHjFHOOHGXPrPHV\QWDJPHjXQFDVVHFRQGDLUHHJDX
FRPLWDWLIDIIL[H$DߓߓlO%>I(N%
!%% WčORxFlVZUDVDߓߓlO%
% WDOOčQWlؐRQROPHؐPSD% Z2%/3/852%/3/85@%"&0*#!#*'%
743DUFRQVpTXHQWOHJpQLWLITXLHVWXQFDVSULPDLUHWHQGjV·DOLJQHUVXUOHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHV&HODSHXWV·H[SOL
TXHUSDUSOXVLHXUVUDLVRQV/DSULQFLSDOHUpVLGHGDQVODPRUSKRORJLHGXJpQLWLI/·DQFLHQJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUDWKpPD
WLTXH 60!WRNKFRPPXQ éQ·HVWSOXVFRQVHUYpTXHSDUFHUWDLQVW\SHVGHPRWVWKqPHVHQ )$FRPPHOHQRP
GX´URLµ%9(.6VLQJREOOčQW $OčQW JpQOčQWHHWOHVDGMHFWLIVjREOVLQJPDVFHQ$%)$ )$a )  )$P૖ FI
%WDOOč1 ´PDOKHXUHX[µFLWpDXSDUDJUDSKHSUpFpGHQWPDVFVLQJREOWDOOčQWJpQWDOOčQWHHW%H‫ع‬NDOVX´SDVVLRQQpµ
GpULYpGHH‫ع‬NlO´SDVVLRQµ PDVFVLQJREOH‫ع‬NDOVRQWJpQH‫ع‬NDOVRQWH&HWWHILQDOHDVHUYLSUREDEOHPHQWGHEDVHjOD
GpVLQHQFHDGMHFWLYDOHGHJpQLWLIVLQJPDVFODSOXVIUpTXHQWHHQWRNKDULHQ%jVDYRLU!I#TXLUHSRVHFHUWDLQHPHQW
VXU!MI#pODUJLHDYHFODILQDOHGHJpQLWLIVLQJPDVF49#W4I#  4aÜ# GHVGpPRQVWUDWLIV/DGpVLQHQFHYLYDQWHGH
JpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUHVW%)$0!$0WRNKDULHQFRPPXQ )0éG·RGHVDERXWLVVHPHQWVGLIIpUHQWVVHORQODILQDOHGX
WKqPHGHEDVHGDQVOHVQRPVWKpPDWLTXHV%'a=9U)$0!GH\iNZH´FKHYDOµ$'1=!0GH'1=  (#)0(DYHFpSHQWKqVH
 éM)0é HWGDQVOHVWKqPHVHQFRQVRQQH%HNiQWVH !=Ma)$0!GH!=´±LOµ$(=#0GH(=  a#)0(DYHFpSHQWKqVH
 a)0é 6DQVUHSUHQGUHLFLXQHGpPRQVWUDWLRQGRQQpHDLOOHXUVLOHVWWUqVSUREDEOHTXHODGpVLQHQFHWRNKDULHQ
FRPPXQ )0éUHPRQWHj )0M60DYHFUHFDUDFWpULVDWLRQGHODILQDOHjM ! )M0G·XQJpQLWLIVLQJGHIOH[LRQ´IHUPpHµ
SURWpURNLQpWLTXH GHWKqPHHQQDVDOHVXUOHPRGqOHGHODIOH[LRQ´RXYHUWHµDYHFILQDOH )M60/HVWKqPHVHQ
QDVDOHRQWMRXpXQJUDQGU{OHGDQVODSUpKLVWRLUHGXWRNKDULHQSRXUIRXUQLUXQHIOH[LRQ´ORQJXHµRX´IDLEOHµjOD
SOXSDUWGHVVXEVWDQWLIVHWDGMHFWLIVFHVIRUPHVORQJXHVRQWpWpHQSDUWLHHPSOR\pHVSRXUUHPSODFHUOHVILQDOHVGH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7\K%N;O/7*,/K8%H87%3<7%8B%*,bO<K/8B% 

ODIOH[LRQGHEDVHQRWDPPHQWGDQVOHW\SHWKpPDWLTXHHWFHWWHVXEVWLWXWLRQV·HVWSRXUVXLYLHDXFRXUVGHO·KLVWRLUH
GXWRNKDULHQFRPPHOHPRQWUHOHWRNKDULHQ$&RQVLGpURQVPDLQWHQDQWOHJpQLWLISOXULHOGRQWOHVGpVLQHQFHV
VRQWEHDXFRXSPRLQVYDULpHVTXHFHOOHVGXVLQJXOLHU/DVHXOHILQDOHFRQQXHHQWRNKDULHQ%HVWؐWV pFULWDXVVL
)$0VRXYHQWVLPSOLILpHQ$0 WHUPLQpHjO·RULJLQHSDUXQHYR\HOOHTXLV·HVWDPXwHWDUGLYHPHQWG·ROHGRXEOHW
ؐWVRGDQVOHVWH[WHVYHUVLILpV&HWWHIRUPHUHPRQWHjWRNKDULHQFRPPXQ )0a )01 QV‫گ‬PSRLQWGHGpSDUW
TXLV·H[SOLTXHSDUODUpIHFWLRQGXJpQLWLISOXULHO Q‫گ‬PGHVWKqPHVHQQDVDOHVXUOHPRGqOHGXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHU
)0M60UHFDUDFWpULVpFRPPHQRXVO·DYRQVYXSOXVKDXW2UFHWWHILQDOHGHJpQLWLISOXULHODSSDUDvWHQWRNKDULHQ%
FRPPHIRQGpHVXUODILQDOHFRPPXQHG·REOLTXH DFFXVDWLI SOXULHOGHVQRPVDQLPpV PDVFXOLQHWIpPLQLQ TXLHVW
ؐ )0YRLUSOXVKDXWOHUDSSRUWHQWUH%\iNZHؐJK%\lNZpؐWV(QGHKRUVGHO·DFFHQWODVHXOHGLIIpUHQFHWLHQWj
O·DIIULTXpHILQDOHGHODGpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLISOXULHO(QIDLWGqVOHWRNKDULHQFRPPXQODGpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLISOXULHO
)0aQHVHGLVWLQJXDLWGHODGpVLQHQFHG·DFFXVDWLISOXULHO )0TXHSDUXQHYR\HOOHGHVWLQpHjGHYHQLUFDGXTXH
/DFRQVpTXHQFHGUDPDWLTXHGHFHIDLWVHUpDOLVHHQWRNKDULHQ$ODGpVLQHQFHGHVQRPVDQLPpVHVWߓߓLGRQWOD
UpDOLVDWLRQHVWHQWLqUHPHQWVROLGDLUHGHODIRUPHGHO·REOLTXHSOXULHOGHIDoRQHQFRUHSOXVQHWWHTX·HQWRNKDULHQ
%FRPPHOHPRQWUHQWOHVLPSOLFDWLRQVVXLYDQWHVSOXUREO(0%౏JpQDߓߓL YRLUSOXVKDXWSRXU´FKHYDOµ SOXU
REOčV%౏JpQčߓߓLSOXUREOa0%౏JpQlߓߓL YRLUSOXVKDXWSRXUO·DGMHFWLI´PDOKHXUHX[µ SOXUREO!0%౏JpQ
HߓߓLHWF'HIDLWODILQDOHGHJpQLWLISOXULHO )0aVHFRQIRQGDLWHQWRNKDULHQ$DYHFFHOOHG·REOLTXHSOXULHO )0%X%
0/HJpQLWLISOXULHODpWpUHQIRUFHHQߓߓL VߓLDXPR\HQG·XQVXIIL[HDGMHFWLYDO&HVXIIL[H$ߓLHVWHIIHFWLYH
PHQWDWWHVWpGDQVTXHOTXHVQRPVHWDGMHFWLIVFRPPHOHVXIIL[HFRUUHVSRQGDQW%ߓHWRNKDULHQFRPPXQ ߓ\ 
= # '62TXLDYDLWUHPSODFpOHVXIIL[HG·DSSDUWHQDQFH =6 FI 0=6HQJHUPDQLTXHEDOWLTXHVODYH SDUDOOqOH
PHQWDXUHPSODFHPHQWGXVXIIL[HSRVVHVVLI $6SDU $'6!WRNKDULHQFRPPXQ $0é!%$0$0!$$0/·H[SUHVVLRQ
GXJpQLWLIHQSDUWLFXOLHUDXSOXULHOSDUXQVXIIL[HG·DGMHFWLIG·DSSDUWHQDQFHHVWXQIDLWEDQDOFIHQYpGLTXHOH
JpQLWLIGHVSURQRPVSHUVRQQHOVGXSOXULHO 7JSOXU(0>Ď=(>2%:JSOXU\XߙPĎ=(> LGHQWLTXHDXQHXWUHVLQJXOLHU
G·XQDGMHFWLI'DQVOHVQRPVTXLQHGLVWLQJXHQWSDVDXSOXULHOHQWUHQRPLQDWLIHWREOLTXHOHWRNKDULHQ$HPSORLH
XQHGpVLQHQFH#0FHOOHFLHVWLGHQWLTXHjODGpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHU#0TXLHVWHPSOR\pHDSUqVWKqPHVHQ
FRQVRQQHHWTXHQRXVDYRQVGpFULWHSUpFpGHPPHQW&HWWHGpVLQHQFHHVWGRQFHQSDVVHGHGHYHQLULQGLIIpUHQWH
DXQRPEUHFRPPHOHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOV
843RXUDSSUpFLHUFHSKpQRPqQHLOFRQYLHQWGHUDSSHOHUG·DXWUHVSDUDPqWUHVGHODGpFOLQDLVRQGHVVXEVWDQWLIV
HQWRNKDULHQ/HPDQXHOGHWRNKDULHQGLVWLQJXH0!I$FODVVHVGHVXEVWDQWLIVG·DSUqVOHXUVIRUPHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVGH
SOXULHODXWUHPHQWGLWOHXUVIRUPHVGHQRPLQDWLIHWREOLTXH DFFXVDWLI SOXULHO&HVVHSWFODVVHVVHUDPqQHQWSRXU
O·HVVHQWLHOjGHX[W\SHV D 6XEVWDQWLIVDYHFREOLTXHSOXULGHQWLTXHDXQRPSOXU¬ FODVVHV,²,,,  E VXEVWDQWLIV
DYHFREOLTXHSOXUGLIIpUHQWGXQRPSOXU FODVVHV,9²9,, /HVVXEVWDQWLIVGXVHFRQGW\SHVRQWHVVHQWLHOOHPHQWGH
JHQUHDQLPpOHXUREOLTXHSOXUUHPRQWHjO·DFFXVDWLISOXU )0 YRLUSOXVKDXW† HWOHVGLIIpUHQWHVFODVVHVFRUUHV
SRQGHQWDX[GLYHUVHVIRUPHVLQGRHXURSpHQGHQRPLQDWLISOXUGHWKqPHVPDVFXOLQVHWIpPLQLQVW\SHWKpPDWLTXH
HQ 6#W\SHDWKpPDWLTXHHQ !0'HSOXVFHVVXEVWDQWLIVRQWXQJHQUHFRQVWDQWGDQVWRXWHODIOH[LRQPDVFXOLQ
RXIpPLQLQ3DUFRQWUHOHVVXEVWDQWLIVGXSUHPLHUW\SHjO·H[FHSWLRQGHTXHOTXHVDQLPpVVRQWQRUPDOHPHQWGH
JHQUHGLW´DOWHUQDQWµLOVVRQWGHJHQUHPDVFXOLQDXVLQJXOLHUHWGHJHQUHIpPLQLQDXSOXULHO&HWWHYDULDWLRQHVW
UpYpOpHSDUO·DFFRUGDXSOXULHODYHFXQDGMHFWLIRXXQGpPRQVWUDWLIIpPLQLQ&HVQRPVUHIOqWHQWG·DQFLHQVQHXWUHV
'XIDLWGHODFRQIXVLRQIRUPHOOHGXQHXWUHDYHFOHPDVFXOLQDXVLQJXOLHUHWDYHFOHIpPLQLQDXSOXULHOOHJHQUH
QHXWUHDGLVSDUXHQWRNKDULHQFRPPXQjO·H[FHSWLRQGHO·HPSORLSURQRPLQDODXVLQJXOLHUGHVGpPRQVWUDWLIVR
O·RSSRVLWLRQGHJHQUHHVWPDUTXpHSDUOHWKqPHHWQRQSDUXQHGpVLQHQFH,OQRXVVXIILUDGHFLWHUOHGpPRQVWUDWLI
OHSOXVVLPSOHDORUVTXHOHVDXWUHVVHGLVWLQJXHQWSDUGHVLQGLFHVYRFDOLTXHVRXFRQVRQDQWLTXHVDMRXWpVjODIRUPH
GHEDVHQHXWUH%$! $$(  $é $6M"HQUHJDUGGXPDVFXOLQ0! $0(  0é 06HWGXIpPLQLQVč $Vč  Vč
U0( O  0!+n2UOHVVXEVWDQWLIVGXW\SHD SUpVHQWHQWDXSOXULHOXQHILQDOHGHFDVGLUHFW QRPLQDWLI DFFXVDWLI 
TXLFRQVWLWXHHQV\QFKURQLHXQVXIIL[HDMRXWpjODIRUPHGXVLQJXOLHU&HVVXIIL[HVGHSOXULHOVHODLVVHQWUDPHQHU
jTXHOTXHVIRUPDWLRQVWRNKDULHQFRPPXQ č Zč Qč PQč QWč(OOHVRQWWRXWHVHQFRPPXQOHPRUSKqPH
ILQDO č ( +nODGpVLQHQFHLQGRHXUGHQHXWUHSOXULHODWKpPDWLTXHHWDXVVLYLUWXHOOHPHQWWKpPDWLTXHFDU
GDQVSOXVLHXUVODQJXHV FRPPHHQJUHF ODIRUPHWKpPDWLTXHDVXELODFKXWHGHODODU\QJDOHILQDOHSDUODORLGH
.XLSHUVRLW !+n! (O! ( O ! (TXLVHFRQIRQGDLWDYHFODIRUPHSUpFpGHQWH/HPpFDQLVPHGHIRUPDWLRQ
GHFHVVXIIL[HVGHSOXULHOHVWVLPSOHLOVUpVXOWHQWGHO·DPXwVVHPHQWGHODSDUWLHILQDOHGXQHXWUHVLQJXOLHUFHTXL
HQWUDvQDLWSDUPpWDQDO\VHO·LQWpJUDWLRQDXQHXWUHSOXULHOGHODILQDOHGXWKqPHSDUH[HPSOHGDQVOHVQHXWUHV
HQ 1QRPDFFVLQJUF3M1YVQRPDFFSOXU F3M1+n!WRNKDULHQFRPPXQUF3 a YV F&ZčUHVHJPHQWpHQ
UF&Zč2XWUHOHVWKqPHVHQ 1HWHQFRQVRQQH RFFOXVLYHHWIULFDWLYH RQUHFRQQDvWGRQFGDQVFHVFDWpJRULHVOHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8,KD87MP8<B%@/B<\N*

GHVFHQGDQWVORLQWDLQVGHVQHXWUHVHQjM ! )HW > ! )/HVVXIIL[HVFRUUHVSRQGDQWVVHVRQWSURSDJpVODUJHPHQW

DXGHOjHQV·DMRXWDQWjG·DXWUHVIRUPDWLRQVDQFLHQQHVGHQHXWUHSDUH[HPSOHDX[QHXWUHVVLJPDWLTXHVW\SHODW
5!)10HWJUHFࣹๆဎ‫ ߥڗ‬QRPDFFVLQJ 60!WRNKDULHQFRPPXQ éGRQWOHSOXULHOpWDLWH[SULPpjO·RULJLQHSDUXQH
IRUPDWLRQGHFROOHFWLIHQ ̒VRX ‫گ‬VFHVIRUPHVGHYDLHQWDERXWLUUHVSHFWLYHPHQWj é SUDWLTXHPHQWFRQIRQGX
DYHFOHVLQJXOLHU HWj 1! aYR\HOOHFDGXTXH/HXUSOXULHOGHYDLWGRQFrWUHUHQRXYHOpHWOHVVXIIL[HVGHSOXULHO
RQWpWpHPSOR\pVGDQVFHEXW6HVRQWDMRXWpVDXVVLDYHFXQHJUDQGHSURGXFWLYLWpOHVIRUPHVHQ QWč !%)$(2%
$)$OXLPrPHpODUJLHQ)$1SDUO·DGGLWLRQGXSOXULHO1 Zč TXLSURYLHQQHQWGXSOXULHOGHGpULYpVLQGLYL
GXDOLVDQWVHQjM !l6 )$IDLWVVXUGHVFROOHFWLIVHWTXLRQWIRXUQLGHQRXYHDX[SOXULHOV´FRPSWDEOHVµ YRLU0HOFKHUW
 FI%ߓčQWD  ߓčQWč ´XQLWpVGHSHWLWEpWDLOµHQUHJDUGGXFROOHFWLI ߓč´SHWLWEpWDLOµ RYLQVHWFDSULQV 
SUpVXSSRVpSDUOHVLQJXODWLI%ߓDL\\H-XVWHPHQWOHVXEVWDQWLITXLQRXVDVHUYLG·H[HPSOHSOXVKDXW † DUHoX
FHSOXULHOFRPPHG·DXWUHVWKqPHVjQRPVLQJHQ! TXHOOHTXHVRLWOHXURULJLQH OiNOH2%=>L78J>%.a=.U)$( .a=.UM
QWčOHPRWFRUUHVSRQGDQWHQWRNKDULHQ$HVW=.6ISOXU=.6IMa)$1/HVIRUPHVGHVGHX[ODQJXHVQHVHUHFRXYUHQW
SDVWRXMRXUVH[DFWHPHQWYRLUHQFRUH%ZiU¬µHDXµSOXUZUiQWD  ZlUlQWč HQUHJDUGGH$9a-SOXU9-a)$1%
xHP´QRPµSOXUxHPQD ERQH[HPSOHG·DQFLHQQHXWUHHQ > ! ) HQUHJDUGGH$xRPSOXUxRPlQWX%DNUࡃQD%
´ODUPHVµSOXUWDQWXPHQUHJDUGGH$čNUXQWTXLSUpVXSSRVHQWXQFROOHFWLI čNUX !$VLQJčNlU &HVREVHUYDWLRQV
VXIILVHQWSRXUODVXLWHGHPRQSURSRV
3UHQRQVFRPPHH[HPSOHOHSOXULHOGXVXEVWDQWLIGHJHQUH´DOWHUQDQWµ%FiPHO2%!%4>6.´QDLVVDQFHµTXLUHPRQWH
jXQHIRUPDWLRQGHQRPG·DFWLRQQHXWUHHQjM !l6 .VXUODUDFLQH$%$a>´QDvWUHµOHXUSOXULHOUHVSHFWLIHVW%4>!.(%
 FlPpOčDYHFOHW\SHOHSOXVVLPSOHGHVXIIL[HGHSOXULHOHW$4>6.1 FPROZčDYHFXQHIRUPHpODUJLHTXH
QRXVDYRQVH[SOLTXpHSOXVKDXW/HWLPEUHYRFDOLTXHGH$4>6.%HVWG€jXQHODELDOLVDWLRQSURSUHDXWRNKDULHQ$
&RQIURQWRQVOHXUGpFOLQDLVRQHQSUHQDQWOHSHUODWLIFRPPHUHSUpVHQWDWLIGHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHV9R\RQVG·DERUGOH
WRNKDULHQ%GRQWODGpFOLQDLVRQFRPSRUWHXQGpSODFHPHQWG·DFFHQWUpJXOLHUHQIRQFWLRQGXQRPEUHGHV\OODEHV

$8HIL>8J7 5>L78J>
+FM8H6K8G FiPHO 4>U.(%  FlPpOč
2EOLTXH FiPHO 4>U.(
*pQLWLI 4>U.)$0! 4a>U.M)$0! FPpODؐWV
5J7>6K8G FiPHOWVD FlPHOVč 4>U.(M0(

2QFRQVWDWHTXHOHJpQLWLIDXVLQJXOLHUHWDXSOXULHOHVWDMRXWpjODIRUPHG·REOLTXH DFFXVDWLI PDLVOHVGpVL

QHQFHVUHVSHFWLYHVUHVWHQWGLVWLQFWHVjODGLIIpUHQFHGHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOV(QWRNKDULHQ$ODV\PpWULHHVWWRWDOH

$8HIL>8J7 5>L78J>
+FM8H6K8G 4>6. 4>6.M1
2EOLTXH 4>6. 4>6.M1
*pQLWLI 4>6.M#0 4>6.M9M#0
5J7>6K8G FPROč FPROZč

/HWRNKDULHQ$Q·HVWSDVFRQFHUQpSDUOHPRXYHPHQWG·DFFHQWREVHUYpGDQVO·DXWUHODQJXH,OHVWLQFRQWHVWDEOH
TXHFHWWHGHUQLqUHGpFOLQDLVRQUHSUpVHQWHXQDOLJQHPHQWSOXVPDUTXpVXUOHW\SHDJJOXWLQDQWFHODUHQIRUFHOD
UHVVHPEODQFHHQWUHOHWRNKDULHQHWOHVODQJXHVYRLVLQHVQRWDPPHQWOHVODQJXHVDOWDwTXHVTXLSRVVqGHQWpJDOHPHQW
SOXVLHXUVVXIIL[HVGHSOXULHOTXLQHVRQWSDVREOLJDWRLUHVjO·RULJLQHOHWXUFDQFLHQDIDYRULVpOHVXIIL[HGHSOXULHO
.<-DXTXHOV·DMRXWHQWGHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOVLQGLIIpUHQWVDXQRPEUHDFFXVDWLIJpQLWLIORFDWLIDEODWLIGDWLIHWF FI
(UGDO² 1pDQPRLQVFHWH[HPSOHPRQWUHDXVVLTX·LOVHUDLWVLPSOLVWHG·DWWULEXHUHQWLqUHPHQW
jO·LQIOXHQFHGHODQJXHVYRLVLQHVOHGpYHORSSHPHQWWRNKDULHQO·pWDSHSUpDODEOHHVWSXUHPHQWLQWHUQHHOOHUpVLGH
GDQVODIRUPDWLRQGHVVXIIL[HVLQYDULDEOHVGHSOXULHOHWGDQVODSUR[LPLWpIRUPHOOHSXUHPHQWIRUWXLWHGHVGpVL
QHQFHVGHJpQLWLISOXULHOHWG·REOLTXHSOXULHO
"4/HWHUPHG·REOLTXH DOO,&.#X110 FKRLVLSDUOHVSUHPLHUVWRNKDURORJXHVSUpVHQWHO·LQFRQYpQLHQWGHPDVTXHU
TXHOTXHSHXXQIDLWHVVHQWLHO/HGLWFDVREOLTXHIRQFWLRQQHH[DFWHPHQWFRPPHO·DFFXVDWLIGHVDXWUHVODQJXHVLQGR
HXURSpHQQHVGDQVVHVGLYHUVHVUpDOLVDWLRQVDFFXVDWLIG·REMHWDFFXVDWLIG·H[WHQVLRQVSDWLDOHHWWHPSRUHOOHDFFX
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7\K%N;O/7*,/K8%H87%3<7%8B%*,bO<K/8B% 

VDWLIGLUHFWLI&HGHUQLHUHPSORL FI7KRPDV HVWFODLUHPHQWXQYHVWLJHTXLQHVXEVLVWHSOXVTX·DYHFOHYHUEH

$%#´DOOHUµHWFHUWDLQVOH[qPHV PDLVRQSD\VIRUrWHWF 6XUOHSODQIRUPHOOHVGLIIpUHQWHVILQDOHVG·REOLTXH
UHPRQWHQWWRXWHVjG·DQFLHQQHVIRUPHVG·DFFXVDWLIDXVLQJXOLHUHWDXSOXULHO\FRPSULVGDQVOHVQRPEUHX[QRPV
TXLQ·RQWSDVGHIRUPHG·REOLTXHVLQJXOLHUGLVWLQFWHGHFHOOHGXQRPLQDWLI&HODUpVXOWHVLPSOHPHQWGHODGLVSDULWLRQ
GHODTXDVLWRWDOLWpGHVFRQVRQQHVILQDOHVHQSURWRWRNKDULHQVDXIOHVOLTXLGHV([HPSOHDXVLQJXOLHUGXVXEV
WDQWLI´FKHYDOµOHQRPLQDWLIj +_ U֖96M0HWO·DFFXVDWLIj +_ U֖96M>VHFRQIRQGDLHQWHQWRNKDULHQFRPPXQ 'a=9é%
!%\iNZH $'1= 5LHQQHGLVWLQJXHDXVLQJXOLHUGXPRLQVODIOH[LRQGHFHQRPGHFHOOHG·XQDQFLHQQHXWUHVRLW
WKpPDWLTXHDYHFQRPDFF 6M>! éVRLWVLJPDWLTXHDYHFQRPDFF 60! éFIUHVSHFWLYHPHQW%=()$! $
=a)$ ´FHQWµ =a)$é ֖Q૖ $6>j " ֖P૖ $6>HW%ߙ(.'I! $ߙa.'I ´JUDLVVHµ ߙa.'Ié 0U.IM60DYHFH[WHQVLRQGHOD
OLTXLGHSDODWDOLVpHjSDUWLUGHO·DOORPRUSKHDWWHQGXDXWKqPHIDLEOH ߙa.'IaF 0U.IM!0FIJUHFํड़›‫ ߥڗ‬DYHFSVLORVH 
HWYpGLTXH0(-IÉߙ DSUqVUHPSODFHPHQWGXVXIIL[HGHQHXWUHVLJPDWLTXHSDUXQDXWUHLVVXGHFURLVHPHQW 2QSHXW
FRPSUHQGUHTXHOHWHUPH´REOLTXHµDpWpFKRLVLSDUFHTXHFHFDVHVWODEDVHGHVFDV´REOLTXHVµVLO·RQYHXWELHQ
GpQRPPHUDLQVLOHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHVpQXPpUpVSOXVKDXW1pDQPRLQVRQQHSHXWSDVDGKpUHUDXUDLVRQQHPHQW
EL]DUUHTXLIDLWGHO·REOLTXHXQ´FDVDEVROXµFRPPHLOHVWpFULWGDQVOHPDQXHOGHWRNKDULHQ´O·REOLTXH HPSOR\p
GHIDoRQDEVROXHDXVHQVGHO·DFFXVDWLI µ *8S,†S ,OIDXWVLPSOHPHQWDGPHWWUHTXHO·REOLTXH!0$%LH%
DFFXVDWLIHWTXHOHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHVVRQWIRUPpVSDUO·DGGLWLRQGHSRVWSRVLWLRQVjODIRUPHG·DFFXVDWLI (QIDLW
O·pYROXWLRQGHVV\OODEHVILQDOHVDSULYpOHQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUGHWRXWHPDUTXHSURSUH¬HQWRNKDULHQFRPPXQLOQ·D
SOXVGHGpVLQHQFH/HQRPLQDWLIVHGpILQLWSDUUDSSRUWjO·REOLTXHVLQJXOLHUTXDQGFHOXLFLFRQVHUYHRXDFTXLHUW
XQHIRUPHSURSUH­OXLVHXOOHQRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUQHSHUPHWSDVGHSUpYRLUOHJHQUHRXOHW\SHIOH[LRQQHOG·XQ
VXEVWDQWLI/HVQRPVGXW\SHE FRPPHGpILQLSOXVKDXW † SHXYHQWSUpVHQWHUODPrPHIRUPHjO·REOLTXHHWDX
QRPLQDWLIVLQJXOLHUF·HVWOHFDVGXQRPGX´FKHYDOµSDUH[HPSOHTXLQRXVDIRXUQLOHSDUDGLJPHGHUpIpUHQFH
HWTXLUHIOqWHOHW\SHWKpPDWLTXHLQGRHXURSpHQ1pDQPRLQVOHVQRPVGHVGLYHUVHVFODVVHVGXW\SHE GHJHQUH
FRQVWDQW PDVFXOLQRXIpPLQLQ RQWGHVIRUPHVVSpFLILTXHVG·REOLTXHVLQJXOLHUTXLUHIOqWHQWGHVILQDOHVLQGRHXU
KpULWpHVRXUHPRGHOpHVHWTXLFRUUHVSRQGHQWjGLYHUVHVIRUPDWLRQVGRQWOHGpWDLOQ·HVWSDVLPSRUWDQWGDQVOH
SUpVHQWFRQWH[WH8QHSDUWLFXODULWpGXWRNKDULHQFRPPXQTXLOHGLVWLQJXHG·XQHODQJXHGHW\SHLQGRHXURSpHQ
HVWOHPDUTXDJHVpPDQWLTXHG·XQHGpVLQHQFHG·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHUjVDYRLUQQRWpؐTXLFDUDFWpULVHVHXOHPHQW
OHVQRPV>KXPDLQ@(QWRNKDULHQ%GDQVOHVVXEVWDQWLIVGHJHQUHPDVFXOLQFHWWHGpVLQHQFHGLVWLQJXHOHVQRPV
>KXPDLQ@TXLQHVRQWSDVDXWUHPHQWPDUTXpVjO·DFFXVDWLI REOLTXH VLQJXOLHUFI%SčFHU´SqUHµDFFVLQJSčWlU2%
%9(.6´URLµDFFVLQJOčQW&HWWHGpVLQHQFHHVWHPSOR\pHDXVVLGDQVXQHSDUWLHGHVDGMHFWLIVHQWRNKDULHQ%HW
HOOHHVWpWHQGXHDX[VXEVWDQWLIVIpPLQLQV>KXPDLQ@HWjWRXVOHVDGMHFWLIVHQWRNKDULHQ$(QGpSLWGHWHQWDWLYHV
UpSpWpHV YRLUSDUH[HPSOH.OLQJHQVFKPLWW FHWWHGpVLQHQFHQHSHXWSDVFRQWLQXHUIRUPHOOHPHQWOD
GpVLQHQFHG·DFFXVDWLIVLQJLQGRHXU >GHVQRPVGHJHQUHDQLPpTXLGLVSDUDLVVDLWGqVOHWRNKDULHQFRPPXQVDQV
ODLVVHUGHWUDFHYR\H]SDUH[HPSOHOHQXPpUDO´FHQWµFLWpSOXVKDXW-HQHUHYLHQVSDVLFLVXUODGpPRQVWUDWLRQ
TXLIDLWGpVRUPDLVO·REMHWG·XQFRQVHQVXV&HWWHGpVLQHQFHHVWLVVXHG·XQHIOH[LRQORQJXHHQQDVDOHSDUDOOqOHDX
W\SHWKpPDWLTXHjYDOHXULQGLYLGXDOLVDQWH

)OH[LRQIRUWH )OH[LRQIDLEOH
$8HIL>8J7%+FM8H6K8G% 6M0! é!%!% R‫گ‬Q! ‫ ! ) گ‬1!]pUR
$FFXVDWLI 6M>! é!%! RQP૖ ! é)a ) !%H ؐ2%

UHVHJPHQWpHQWRNKDULHQFRPPXQ (!Å) !%!Åؐ HWDGRSWpSDUOHVQRPV>KXPDLQ@YRLUSDUH[HPSOH%H‫ع‬NZHؐ%

$R‫ع‬NDؐ GHH‫ع‬NZH´KRPPHµ $R‫ع‬N FLWpSOXVKDXW † SDUFRQWUDVWHDYHFOHQRPGX´FKHYDOµ%'(=9! $'1= 
&HWWHGLIIpUHQFLDWLRQVpPDQWLTXHGHO·DFFXVDWLIWURXYHXQSDUDOOqOHGDQVXQHODQJXHPR\HQLUDQLHQQHSURFKHJpR
JUDSKLTXHPHQWHWGRQWOHVFRQWDFWVDYHFOHWRNKDULHQFRPPXQVRQWDYpUpVjVDYRLUOHEDFWULHQGDQVFHWWHODQJXH
O·REMHWGLUHFWTXDQGLOHVWjODIRLVKXPDLQHWGpILQLHVWPDUTXpSDUODSUpSRVLWLRQǓɘ‫ڗ‬ǓɘǓ FI6LPV:LOOLDPV
D /HSURFpGpHVWWRWDOHPHQWGLIIpUHQWVXUOHSODQIRUPHOGHFHOXLGXWRNKDULHQPDLVVDSRUWpHHVWLGHQWLTXH
94/HWHUPHDOO*UXSSHQϰH[LRQDGRSWpSDUOHVDXWHXUVGHODSUHPLqUHJUDPPDLUHFHOOHGXWRNKDULHQ$SXEOLpH
HQ YRLU*64+D-HWODGHVFULSWLRQ² DpWpUHSULVSDUOHPDQXHOGHWRNKDULHQ *8S,HWSDVVLP LO
DSDUIRLVpWpWUDQVSRVpGDQVG·DXWUHVODQJXHVFIDQJODLVJURXSLQϰHFWLRQIUDQoDLV´ϰH[LRQGHJURXSHµ,OHVWQpDQ
PRLQVDVVH]EL]DUUHFDULODVVRFLHGHX[QRWLRQVFRQWUDGLFWRLUHVFHOOHGHϰH[LRQODTXHOOHSUpVXSSRVHGHVGpVLQHQFHV
V\QWKpWLTXHVTXLH[SULPHQWjODIRLVOHFDVHWOHQRPEUHDMRXWpHVjXQWKqPHQRPLQDOHWFHOOHGHV\QWDJPH'DQV
FHOXLFLOHFDVSHXWrWUHH[SULPpSDUXQHSUpSRVLWLRQRXXQHSRVWSRVLWLRQFRPELQpHRXQRQDYHFXQHGpVLQHQFH
 oi.uchicago.edu

QP?% D8,KD87MP8<B%@/B<\N*

GRQQpHRXSDUOHVVHXOHVIRUPHVϰpFKLHV2UOHVDϲ[HVFDVXHOVGXWRNKDULHQSUpVHQWHQWWRXWHVOHVSURSULpWpVGH
SRVWSRVLWLRQVFRPPHQRXVO·DYRQVYX † ,OHVWYUDLTXHODVLWXDWLRQHVWEHDXFRXSSOXVQHWWHGXIDLWGHO·DFFHQ
WXDWLRQHQWRNKDULHQ%TX·HQWRNKDULHQ$/DSUHPLqUHJUDPPDLUHGXWRNKDULHQDpWpIDLWHVXUOHVSUHPLHUVWH[WHV
SXEOLpVTXLpWDLHQWFHX[HQWRNKDULHQ$GRQWOHVPDQXVFULWVRQWpWppGLWpVSDUOHVPrPHVDXWHXUVHQ/D
GHVFULSWLRQHVWGRQFHQSDUWLHWULEXWDLUHGHODQDWXUHGXFRUSXVHWHOOHQ·DSDVpWpUHPLVHHQFDXVHSRXUO·HVVHQWLHO
SDUO·H[SORLWDWLRQGHODPDVVHGHVPDQXVFULWVUpGLJpVGDQVO·DXWUHODQJXH,OQ·HVWSDVIDFLOHGHIDLUHO·KLVWRLUHGHFH
WHUPH´*UXSSHQϰH[LRQµHWFHODPpULWHUDLWXQHHQTXrWHV\VWpPDWLTXH,OVHPEOHQpDQPRLQVTXHVDVRXUFHUpVLGH
GDQVOHVWUDYDX[GXOLQJXLVWHDOOHPDQG)1)LQFN ² WKpRULFLHQGHVODQJXHVHWGHVSURSULpWpVJpQpUDOHV
GXODQJDJHGDQVODOLJQpHGH:LOKHOPYRQ+XPEROGW ² HWGHTXHOTXHVDXWUHV8QHSDUWLHQRWDEOHGHVHV
UHFKHUFKHVFRQFHUQHFHTXHQRXVDSSHOOHULRQVDXMRXUG·KXLODW\SRORJLHGHVODQJXHVTXRLTXHVRXVXQHIRUPHTXHOTXH
SHX´SKLORVRSKLTXHµ'DQVXQSHWLWRXYUDJHTXLDHXXQHJUDQGHLQϰXHQFHSDUXHQHWLQWLWXOp´/HVW\SHVSULQ
FLSDX[GHVWUXFWXUHOLQJXLVWLTXHµ VHORQPDWUDGXFWLRQ )LQFNDFODVVpVHORQOHFULWqUHGHODFRQVWUXFWLRQHWGHOD
FRPELQDLVRQG·pOpPHQWVGHEDVHGHO·pQRQFpKXLWODQJXHVYLYDQWHV/HWHUPHGH´*UXSSHQϰH[LRQµ FIHW
 HVWDSSOLTXpDXJpRUJLHQHWRSSRVpjFHX[GH´6WDPPϰH[LRQµ JUHFPRGHUQH HW´:XU]HOϰH[LRQµ DUDEH &H
OLYUHHVWSDUXGDQVXQHFROOHFWLRQVFLHQWLϮTXHGHJUDQGHGLϸXVLRQGHVWLQpHDXSXEOLFFXOWLYpHWLOHVWYUDLVHPEODEOH
TX·LODLQϰXHQFpOHVSUHPLHUVWRNKDURORJXHVTXLDSSDUWHQDLHQWHQJURVjODPrPHJpQpUDWLRQ
'HIDLWODVWUXFWXUHGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOGXWRNKDULHQVHODLVVHUDSSURFKHUGHIDoRQDVVH]QHWWHGHFHOOHGHV
ODQJXHVFDXFDVLTXHV 6FKPLGW /HVVLPLODULWpVVRQWHQFRUHSOXVQHWWHVDYHFXQHODQJXHGX&DXFDVHG·RULJLQH
LUDQLHQQHjVDYRLUO·RVVqWH YRLU9RJW6FKPLGW &HUDSSURFKHPHQWDpWpVRXOLJQpGHPDQLqUHH[SOLFLWH
HQWUHDXWUHVSDU6FKPLGWHWI /HV\VWqPHDJJOXWLQDWLIGHO·RVVqWHUpVXOWHGHODUHVWUXFWXUDWLRQ
GXV\VWqPHIOH[LRQQHOGHO·LUDQLHQDQFLHQFRPSDUDEOHjFHOXLGHVDXWUHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVDQFLHQQHV
&HSHQGDQWODGHVFULSWLRQGHVIDLWVWRNKDULHQVDpWpLQIOXHQFpHSDUGHVDQDORJLHVSOXVRXPRLQVSUpFLVHVDYHF
GHVODQJXHVTXLSRVVqGHQWXQULFKHHQVHPEOHGHFDVGLWV´FRQFUHWVµ¬H[SULPpVSDUGHVVXIIL[HVODQJXHVILQQRRX
JULHQQHVWXUTXHVPRQJROHV&HVUDSSURFKHPHQWVVRQWHQJUDQGHSDUWLHWULEXWDLUHG·K\SRWKqVHVYDULpHVVXUOHV
FRQWDFWVGX´SURWRWRNKDULHQµDYHFGLYHUVJURXSHVGHODQJXHVQRQLQGRHXURSpHQQHV YRLU.UDXVH ,OHVW
FHUWDLQTXHOHV\VWqPHFDVXHOWRNKDULHQFRPPHG·DLOOHXUVG·DXWUHVIDLWVGRLWrWUHDSSUpFLpGDQVXQHSHUVSHFWLYH
GHOLQJXLVWLTXHDUpDOH3RXUGHVOLQJXLVWHVTXLWUDYDLOOHQWVXUGHVODQJXHVGHODPrPHUpJLRQODVLWXDWLRQGXWRNKD
ULHQFRPPXQQ·DULHQTXLSXLVVHVXUSUHQGUH FI&RXYUHXU 2QDUHOHYpGHVVWUXFWXUHVFRPSDUDEOHVGDQVOHV
ODQJXHVGXVWDGHPR\HQLQGLHQRXPR\HQLUDQLHQjSDUWLUG·XQSRLQWGHGpSDUWVWULFWHPHQWIOH[LRQQHO'HIDLWOH
UHPSODFHPHQWGHFHUWDLQHVIRUPHVFDVXHOOHVSDUGHVFRPELQDLVRQVGpVLQHQFHSRVWSRVLWLRQHWILQDOHPHQWSDUGHV
PRUSKqPHV´VpSDUDEOHVµGXW\SHGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVQ·DULHQGHWUqVRULJLQDO&·HVWDSSDUHPPHQWODFRQVpTXHQFH
GHO·DIIDLEOLVVHPHQWGHVPDUTXHVFDVXHOOHVH[SULPpHVSDUOHVGpVLQHQFHV/HVORLVSKRQpWLTXHVTXLRQWDIIHFWpOHV
V\OODEHVILQDOHVGRQWQRXVDYRQVGpMjpYRTXpTXHOTXHVXQHVUHQGDLHQWHIIHFWLYHPHQWLQGLVWLQFWHVSOXVLHXUVILQDOHV
>WKqPHGpVLQHQFH@KpULWpHVGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQLOQ·HVWSDVQpFHVVDLUHGHSURFpGHUjO·pQXPpUDWLRQGHWRXWHVOHV
VLWXDWLRQVSRVVLEOHV-HUHQYRLHjO·DUWLFOHFODVVLTXHGH/DQH  TX·LOIDXGUDLWFRPSOpWHUXQSHXHQIRQFWLRQ
GHVSURJUqVGHODSKLORORJLHWRNKDULHQQH
:4,OFRQYLHQWGHQHSDVFRQIRQGUHO·HIIHWHWODFDXVH/DPXWLODWLRQGHVILQDOHVGpVLQHQWLHOOHVG·XQFHUWDLQ
QRPEUHGHFDVQHVXIILWSDVHQVRLjH[SOLTXHUFRPSOqWHPHQWO·DERXWLVVHPHQWGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOHQWRNKDULHQ
FRPPXQHWGDQVOHVGHX[ODQJXHVWRNKDULHQQHV,OLPSRUWHG·DLOOHXUVGHQHSDVFURLUHTXHWRXVOHVFDVWRNKDULHQV
VRQWLGHQWLILpVGHPDQLqUHFHUWDLQH'HVYDULDQWHVQRQQpJOLJHDEOHVGHWHUPLQRORJLHHWG·LGHQWLILFDWLRQV·DFFUp
GLWHQWVLO·RQFRPSDUHWURLVVRXUFHVOHVGHX[SUHPLqUHVHQDOOHPDQGODWURLVLqPHHQDQJODLV

*64+D-  *8S  :LQWHU 

*H9K7LMJHK6> *H9K7LMJHK6> DFFXVDWLYHSRVWSRVLWLRQ
.RPLWDWLY .RPLWDWLY FRPLWDWLYH
č.DVXV 3HUODWLY 8H9K7LMJHK6>
'DWLY $OODWLY GDWLYH
$EODWLY $EODWLY DEODWLYH
/RNDWLY /RNDWLY ORFDWLYH
³ .DXVDOLV FDXVDO
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7\K%N;O/7*,/K8%H87%3<7%8B%*,bO<K/8B% QPO

&HVGLVWLQFWLRQVVRQWGXHVHQSDUWLHjGHVK\SRWKqVHVVXUODPRUSKRORJLHFDVXHOOHSRXUSUHQGUHXQH[HPSOH
W\SLTXHOHPRUSKqPH'6HVWLGHQWLILpSDU:LQWHU   jODFRQMRQFWLRQGHFRRUGLQDWLRQ'62%JK%
QHFRQVWLWXHSDVVHORQOXLXQDIIL[HFDVXHO/DLVVRQVFHSUREOqPHGHF{WpSRXUOHPRPHQWDYDQWG·\UHYHQLUSOXV
WDUG † 2QSHXWFRQIURQWHUjFHVOLVWHVODOLVWHWUDGLWLRQQHOOHGHVFDVUHFRQVWUXLWVSRXUOHVLQJXOLHUHQSURWR
LQGRHXURSpHQHQGHKRUVGXQRPLQDWLIGXYRFDWLIGHO·DFFXVDWLIHWGXJpQLWLILQVWUXPHQWDOGDWLIDEODWLIORFDWLI
(QGpSLWGHODWHUPLQRORJLHLOHVWLPSRVVLEOHG·pWDEOLUGHVpTXLYDOHQFHVHQWUHGHVFDVTXLDSSDUHPPHQWSRUWHQW
OHPrPHQRP(QHIIHWTXDWUHFDVSUpVHQWHQWGHVIRQFWLRQVTXLFRUUHVSRQGHQWjFHOOHVGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOLQGR
HXURSpHQLQVWUXPHQWDO HQ$ SHUODWLIFRPLWDWLIFDXVDO HQ% PDLVDXFXQGHFHX[FLQHUHIOqWHGLUHFWHPHQWVXU
OHSODQIRUPHOO·LQVWUXPHQWDOLQGRHXURSpHQDYHFGpVLQHQFHjM ! +_DXVLQJXOLHU'HPrPHOHGDWLILQGRHXURSpHQ
HVW´UHPSODFpµVLO·RQYHXWSDUSOXVLHXUVFDVVDQVTX·DXFXQFRQWLQXHXQHIRUPHFDVXHOOHGHGDWLIDOODWLI EXW
YLVp HWJpQLWLI DWWULEXWLRQDJHQWGHVQRPVYHUEDX[SRVVHVVLRQ &HTXLHVWGpQRPPp´JpQLWLI µHVWHQIDLWXQ
JpQLWLIGDWLI(QUpIpUHQFHDXOLHXODGLVWULEXWLRQHQWUHOHSHUODWLIHWOHORFDWLIQHFRUUHVSRQGDEVROXPHQWSDVjFHOOH
TX·RQSRXUUDLWSUpYRLUHQWUHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOHWOHORFDWLIG·DSUqVOHVDXWUHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV/·HPSORL
GHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHVDGpMjIDLWO·REMHWG·pWXGHVV\VWpPDWLTXHV YRLU.|OYHUHWSOXVUpFHPPHQW&DUOLQJ
VXUODEDVHGHPDWpULDX[WH[WXHOVSOXVDERQGDQWV PDLVOHVXMHWQ·HVWSDVpSXLVp-HUHQYRLHQRWDPPHQWDXOLYUH
GH&DUOLQJSRXUODGLVWULEXWLRQHQWUHOHSHUODWLIHWOHORFDWLI3DUFRQVpTXHQWRQGRLWDGPHWWUHTXHOHV\VWqPH
FDVXHOWRNKDULHQHVWWRWDOHPHQWGLIIpUHQWSRXUOHVFDVGLWV´FRQFUHWVµHWPrPHSRXUXQFDVGLW´DEVWUDLWµFRPPH
OHGDWLIGXV\VWqPHLQGRHXURSpHQ6·DJLWLOG·XQV\VWqPHHQWLqUHPHQWQRXYHDXEkWLVXUODUXLQHSDUWLHOOHGXV\V
WqPHDQFLHQ"'RLWRQVHUHSUpVHQWHUODIRUPDWLRQGHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHVFRPPHOHUpVXOWDWGXYLGHWRWDOODLVVpSDU
ODFRQIXVLRQSUpDODEOHGHVFDV´FRQFUHWVµKpULWpVGHO·LQGRHXURSpHQ"0rPHVLGHVODQJXHVYRLVLQHVRQWXQV\V
WqPHFRPSDUDEOHVXUOHSODQW\SRORJLTXHOHVFDVLGHQWLILpVVRQWGLIIpUHQWVRQQHSHXWGRQFSDVSRVHUGHPDQLqUH
DUJXPHQWpHO·K\SRWKqVHG·XQHLQIOXHQFHH[WpULHXUHVXUODIRUPDWLRQGHWHORXWHOFDV
3;4,OHVWFHUWDLQTXHOHV\VWqPHFDVXHOGXWRNKDULHQFRPPXQDGpMjXQHORQJXHKLVWRLUHGHUULqUHOXLDXPRPHQW
RQRXVO·DSSUpKHQGRQVjSDUWLUGHVODQJXHVDWWHVWpHVF·HVWjGLUHDXPLOLHXHQYLURQGXSUHPLHUPLOOpQDLUHGH
QRWUHqUHOHWRNKDULHQFRPPXQGRLWrWUHUHSRXVVpDXPRLQVMXVTX·DXGpEXWGHQRWUHqUH&HWWHKLVWRLUHQ·HVW
SDVWHUPLQpHFDUOHVPRUSKqPHVGLIIqUHQWDSSDUHPPHQWG·XQHODQJXHjO·DXWUHPrPHTXDQGOHVHPSORLVVRQW
LGHQWLTXHVSDUH[HPSOHSRXUOHVFDVVXLYDQWVSHUODWLIDOODWLIFRPLWDWLIDEODWLIHWORFDWLI8QSUREOqPHHVVHQWLHO
GRLWrWUHSRVpHWMHQ·DLSDVO·DPELWLRQGHOHUpVRXGUHHQWLqUHPHQWGDQVOHVTXHOTXHVSDUDJUDSKHVTXLVXLYHQW
'LYHUVHVODQJXHVRQWDFTXLVGHVFDVGLWV´VHFRQGDLUHVµSDUFRPELQDLVRQG·XQHIRUPHFDVXHOOHLGHQWLILDEOHHWG·XQH
SRVWSRVLWLRQYRLUSDUH[HPSOHODIRUPDWLRQGHTXDWUHFDVVXSSOpPHQWDLUHVHQOLWXDQLHQjVDYRLULQHVVLILOODWLI
DGHVVLIHWDOODWLI FI3HWLW 5LHQGHWHOHQWRNKDULHQSXLVTXHOHVDIIL[HVVRQWGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVLQGLIIpUHQWHV
DXQRPEUHDMRXWpHVjXQHPrPHIRUPHFHOOHG·DFFXVDWLI REOLTXH VLQJXOLHUSOXULHORXGXHO'HSOXVLOQ·HVWSDV
SRVVLEOHG·pWDEOLUXQHWUDQVLWLRQVLPSOHHQWUHSUpRXSRVWSRVLWLRQVFRQQXHVHWDIIL[HVFDVXHOV
'qVODSUHPLqUHJUDPPDLUHGXWRNKDULHQOHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOV GXWRNK$ RQWpWpUDSSURFKpVGHSUpRX
SRVWSRVLWLRQVDWWHVWpHVGDQVODPrPHODQJXH *64+D-†S &HODODLVVHGHF{WpOHSHUODWLISRXUOHTXHODXFXQ
UDSSURFKHPHQWQHVHSURSRVH2QDUDSSHOpSOXVKDXW †WURLVLqPHFRORQQHGXWDEOHDX FHVUDSSURFKHPHQWV
TXLUHVWHQWSOXVRXPRLQVDXSRLQWGHGpSDUWGHVLQWHUSUpWDWLRQVSOXVUpFHQWHV(QGHKRUVGXFRPLWDWLI$DߓߓlO2%
VROLGDLUHGHߓODDGYHUEHHWSUpSRVLWLRQ´HQVHPEOHDYHFµLOVVRQWYDJXHVHWGRXWHX[,OQ·HVWSDVLPSRVVLEOHTXH
O·DGYHUEH()! YDULDQWH())! ´GHGDQVjO·LQWpULHXUµFRQWLHQQHXQPRUSKqPHDSSDUHQWpHQGpILQLWLYHjO·DIIL[H
GHORFDWLI(ؐPDLVOHFRUUHVSRQGDQWHVW%HQHؐHQVRUWHTXHO·XQHHWO·DXWUHIRUPHSHXYHQWUHPRQWHUDXORFDWLI
G·XQWKqPHSURQRPLQDO é !%!$( RXjXQHIRUPHpODUJLHGH é)j +_ Q૖ ´GDQVµDSSDUHQWpjO·DGYHUEHHW
SUpSRVLWLRQj +_ U)PrPHVHQV ODWLQ#)JUHF์ဎ 'HSOXVO·DGYHUEH$() ) !HVWXWLOLVpSRXUUHQIRUFHUXQHIRUPH
GHORFDWLIHJUL\DؐDQQH´jO·LQWpULHXUGHODYLOOHµ ORFVLQJGH-#´YLOOHµ HWQRQSDVFRPPHXQHSRVWSRVLWLRQ
/·DGYHUEH$ߙXGLIIqUHQRWDEOHPHQWGHO·DIIL[HG·DEODWLIaߙGRQWODIRUPHDUFKDwTXHHVW(ߙGDQVGHVORFXWLRQV
ILJpHV/DSDUHQWpDYHFO·DGYHUEH$ߙXVHUDLWDXPLHX[LQGLUHFWHFDULOH[SULPHIRQGDPHQWDOHPHQWXQPRXYHPHQW
GLULJpYHUVOHORFXWHXU´SDULFLµHW´G·LFLGHFHF{WpµLOSURYLHQWVDQVGRXWHGXWKqPHGHUpIOpFKL 09!jSDUWLU
GXVHQV´YHUVVRLµ FI+DFNVWHLQ² (QGHKRUVGHODGLIIpUHQFHVpPDQWLTXHRQQHYRLWSDVFRPPHQW
QLSRXUTXRL1DXUDLWGLVSDUXGHO·DIIL[HG·DEODWLI$aߙ,OQ·HVWSDVGDQVPRQLQWHQWLRQGHSDVVHUHQUHYXHWRXWHV
OHVLQWHUSUpWDWLRQVpW\PRORJLTXHVGHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOVGHVGHX[ODQJXHV-HPHFRQWHQWHGHUHQYR\HUjGHX[WUDL
WHPHQWVGHUpIpUHQFHSDU9DQ:LQGHNHQV ² HW.OLQJHQVFKPLWW ² OHVUHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
GRQQpHVGDQVOHFKDSLWUHFRQVDFUpDXWRNKDULHQG·XQRXYUDJHUpFHQW FI+HZVRQHW%XEHQLN² VRQW
WUqVDSSUR[LPDWLYHVHWQ·DMRXWHQWULHQDX[VSpFXODWLRQVDQWpULHXUHV/DSOXSDUWGHVK\SRWKqVHVpW\PRORJLTXHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

QP:% D8,KD87MP8<B%@/B<\N*

UHODWLYHVjFHVPRUSKqPHVRQWSRXUSRLQWFRPPXQG·rWUHDWRPLVWLTXHVHWGHQHSDVFRQVLGpUHUGHIDoRQVXIILVDQWH
O·pWDWGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOGXWRNKDULHQFRPPXQ
334'DQVOHVGHX[ODQJXHVWRNKDULHQQHVOHVSUpHWSRVWSRVLWLRQVVRQWQRUPDOHPHQWFRQVWUXLWHVDYHFO·DFFX
VDWLI REOLTXH HWVRQWVRXYHQWFRPPHLOHVWSUpYLVLEOHDWWHVWpHVHQHPSORLDGYHUELDO3RXUWDQWRQQHSHXWSDV
pWDEOLUGHFRQWLQXLWpHQWUHFHVpOpPHQWVHWOHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOVTXLV·DMRXWHQWjODIRUPHG·REOLTXHjO·H[FHSWLRQ
GXFRPLWDWLIGpMjPHQWLRQQpYRLUSDUH[HPSOH$ߓODZUDVDV´DYHFOHVrWUHVYLYDQWVµSUpSRVLWLRQREOLTXHSOXU
GH9-(06>2%JK%ZUDVDߓߓlOPrPHVHQVREOLTXHSOXUDIIL[H,OH[LVWHQpDQPRLQVXQHGLIIpUHQFHFKURQRORJLTXHHQWUH
O·DIIL[HDߓߓlOTXLHVWGpSRXUYXGHYR\HOOHILQDOHHWODSUpSRVLWLRQ$ߓODTXLFRQVHUYHFHWWHYR\HOOHFRPPHOD
SUpSRVLWLRQVXSHUSRVDEOH%ߓDOH GRXEOHWߓOH /DIRUPHGHODSUpSRVLWLRQHQWRNKDULHQFRPPXQHVW ߓlO HWFHWWH
IRUPHGRQQHUDLWUpJXOLqUHPHQW ߓlOHQWRNKDULHQ$'DQVODSUpSRVLWLRQ$ߓODODYR\HOOHILQDOHV·HVWPDLQWHQXHj
ODIDYHXUGHO·HPSORLHQSUHPLHUPHPEUHGHFRPSRVpRHOOHWUDGXLWVDQVNULW0(´HQVHPEOHDYHFµHWJUkFHjOD
IRUPHDGYHUELDOHߓODNUHQIRUFpHSDUODSDUWLFXOHDVVpUDWLYH= a FISDUDOOqOHPHQW%ߓOHN/DVLWXDWLRQGXFRPLWDWLI
HVWDSSDUHPPHQWVLPSOHPDLVLOHVWWRWDOHPHQWLVROp/HVDXWUHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOVQHSHXYHQWSDVrWUHPLVHQUHODWLRQ
DYHFXQHSUpRXSRVWSRVLWLRQYLYDQWHGDQVO·XQHRXO·DXWUHODQJXH&HSHQGDQWFRPPHQWH[SOLTXHUODYR\HOOHLQL
WLDOHGHWRNKDULHQ$DߓߓlO"8QSUREOqPHDQDORJXHVHSRVHSRXUOHVDIIL[HVGHORFDWLIHWG·DOODWLIGXWRNKDULHQ$FI
UHVSHFWLYHPHQW(ؐHW(42QGRLWUHFRQQDvWUHLFLOHU{OHFKDUQLqUHMRXpSDUOHVIRUPHVGHODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXH FI
*LSSHUWGRQWMHUHSUHQGVOHVDQDO\VHVDYHFTXHOTXHVGLIIpUHQFHVGHGpWDLO /DYR\HOOH(UHSUpVHQWHODYR\HOOH
GHVQRPVWKpPDWLTXHVLQWpJUpHjODIRUPHGHO·DIIL[HFDVXHO3UHQRQVFRPPHH[HPSOHGHQRPWKpPDWLTXH$'1=M
(ؐ%'(=9!M)!ORFVLQJGH´FKHYDOµ FLWpSOXVKDXW† GRQWOHSRLQWGHGpSDUWHVW 'a=9éM)é$SUqVO·DSRFRSH
GHODYR\HOOHILQDOH éDX[FDVGLUHFWVHWGDQVODIRUPHGHORFDWLIXQQRXYHDXUDSSRUWV·pWDEOLVVDLWHQWRNKDULHQ
!%JHK7J%'1=  'a=9 HW\XNDؐ  'a=9() G·RODUHVHJPHQWDWLRQGHFHWWHGHUQLqUHIRUPHHQ'1=M(ؐ/HPrPH
W\SHG·H[SOLFDWLRQSHXWrWUHDYDQFpSRXUO·DIIL[HGHFRPLWDWLI$DߓߓlOELHQTXHFHODQ·H[SOLTXHSDVWRWDOHPHQW
ODJpPLQpHHWSRXUO·DIIL[HG·DOODWLI$(43RXUFHGHUQLHUFDVRQUHWURXYHLPPpGLDWHPHQWO·pOpPHQW 4 a GDQV
O·DIIL[HFRUUHVSRQGDQW%ߓF 6 ODJUDSKLHߓFRHVWFHOOHGHVWH[WHVYHUVLILpVHWDUFKDwVDQWVTXLSUpVXSSRVHXQH
IRUPHVRXVMDFHQWH ߓFlODIRUPHVWDQGDUGHVWߓFVRXYHQWVLPSOLILpHQߓFHTXLFRQVWLWXHO·DERXWLVVHPHQWGDQVOD
ODQJXHWDUGLYHHWYXOJDLUH'HPrPHXQpOpPHQW čHVWFRPPXQDX[IRUPHVGHSHUODWLI$čHW%0( VčSXLVTXH
FHWDIIL[HHVWHQFOLWLTXH$XGpEXWGHVPRUSKqPHVGHSHUODWLIHWG·DOODWLIODVLIIODQWH0SURYLHQWGHO·LQWpJUDWLRQ
jO·DIIL[HG·XQpOpPHQWDQWpULHXUSUREDEOHPHQWODILQDOHG·REOLTXHSOXULHO )0GXWRNKDULHQFRPPXQFRPPH
QRXVDYRQVYX † OHVIRUPHV%'(=9!ؐ%JK%!%'1=(0UHPRQWHQWj 'a=9é)03RVRQVOHVIRUPHVGHVFDVHQTXHVWLRQ
³SHUODWLISOXU \lNZ QVč!% \lNZHQVč!% \iNZHQWVD2%!%\XNDVč
³DOODWLISOXU 'a=9é)0Å4a!% \lNZHQߓFl!% \iNZHؐߓF R 
$SUqVOHSDVVDJHGH)0j) QRWpؐ HQILQDOHDEVROXHHQWRNKDULHQ%FHVIRUPHVSRXYDLHQWrWUHUHVHJ
PHQWpHVHQ \lNZHQVč%JK%U\lNZHQߓFlOHVPRUSKqPHVDLQVLREWHQXVpWDLHQWDMRXWpVV\PpWULTXHPHQWjO·REOLTXH
VLQJG·R \lNZHVč!%\iNZHVD%JK%U\lNZHߓFl%X%\iNZHߓF 6 3DUFRQWUHSRXUO·DOODWLIOHWRNKDULHQ$DJDUGp
ODIRUPHGHVLQJXOLHU'1=(4 'a=9éM4aHWDpWHQGXDSUqVPpWDQDO\VH SDUDOOqOHPHQWDXORFDWLI O·DIIL[H(4%6L%
SOXULHOG·R'1=(0M(4&HODSHUPHWWUDLWGHUHQGUHFRPSWHGHODVLIIODQWHJpPLQpHGHO·DOODWLIGDQVODPHVXUHROH
SRLQWGHGpSDUWVHUDLWHQFRUHXQHIRLVO·REOLTXHSOXUVRLW  QVߓlO !  QVߓlO ( UHPSODFpHQWRNKDULHQ$SDU
ODIRUPHOLEUHG·REOLTXHSOXUG·R DVߓlO ( ! DߓߓlO ( SDUDVVLPLODWLRQSXLVH[WHQVLRQGH ߓߓlO ( DXVLQJXOLHU
G·R\XNDߓߓlODQDO\VpHQ\XNDߓߓlOG·DSUqVO·DOODWLI'1=M(4HWOHORFDWLI'1=M(ؐ3DUFRQVpTXHQWVLO·RQIDLWDEVWUDF
WLRQGHFHVDSSHQGLFHVLVVXVGHO·DFFXVDWLIVLQJXOLHUHWSOXULHOGHODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXHRQSHXWGpMjLGHQWLILHU
WURLVDIIL[HVFDVXHOVFRPPXQVDX[GHX[ODQJXHVORFDWLI )é  )6" DOODWLI 4a  "+#2%U"+!2%U$!" SHUODWLI č 
U($l"2%U(I" /HVpW\PRORJLHVSRVVLEOHVUHVWHQWWULEXWDLUHVGHO·DPELJXwWpLQKpUHQWHjGHQRPEUHXVHVpYROXWLRQV
SKRQpWLTXHVHQWUHO·LQGRHXURSpHQHWOHWRNKDULHQFRPPXQHWMHQ·LQVLVWHUDLSDVLFLVXUOHVGLYHUVHVRSWLRQV2Q
SHXWUHFRQQDvWUHGHVPRUSKqPHVDWWHVWpVGDQVWHOOHRXWHOOHODQJXHLQGRHXURSpHQQHFRPPHILQDOHVDGYHUELDOHV
RXELHQFRPPHSUpRXSRVWSRVLWLRQV
3!4'HVDQDO\VHVSUpFpGHQWHVUHVVRUWXQHFRQILUPDWLRQQRQQpJOLJHDEOHPrPHORUVTX·RQSHXWUHVWLWXHUXQH
IRUPHFRPPXQHGHVDIIL[HVOHVGLYHUJHQFHVHQWUHOHVGHX[ODQJXHVUHVWHQWLPSRUWDQWHV&·HVWHQFRUHSOXVpYLGHQW
ORUVTXHOHVDIIL[HVVRQWWRWDOHPHQWGLIIpUHQWVFRPPHSRXUO·DEODWLIHWOHFRPLWDWLI2QSHXWpYLGHPPHQWVXSSRVHU
TXHO·XQDUHPSODFpO·DXWUHPDLVTXHOpWDLWOHSUHPLHU"$YDQWG·DOOHUSOXVORLQLOFRQYLHQWGHSRVHUjQRXYHDX
ODTXHVWLRQGHODEDVHGHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHVGDQVOHVGHX[ODQJXHVLOV·DJLWGHO·DFFXVDWLI REOLTXH PDLVFHODQH
VHUDLWLOSDVG€jXQQLYHOOHPHQWUHODWLYHPHQWWDUGLIVXUOHPRGqOHGHSRVWSRVLWLRQV´OLEUHVµTXLVHFRQVWUXLVHQW
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7\K%N;O/7*,/K8%H87%3<7%8B%*,bO<K/8B% QPQ

WRXMRXUVDYHFO·REOLTXH"2QDUDSSHOpSOXVKDXWO·HPSORLUpVLGXHOGHO·REOLTXH DFFXVDWLI FRPPHGLUHFWLIGDQVGHV

H[SUHVVLRQVILJpHVDYHFXQUpIpUHQWJpQpUDO ´jODPDLVRQYHUVODWHUUHGDQVODIRUrWµ HQGHKRUVGHFHWWHVLWXDWLRQ
OHGLUHFWLIVSpFLILTXHHVWH[SULPpSDUO·DOODWLIHWOHEXWDWWHLQWSDUOHORFDWLI,OHVWFRQFHYDEOHTXHOHPRUSKqPH
G·DOODWLIpWDLWjO·RULJLQHXQHSDUWLFXOHTXLUHQIRUoDLWXQDFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLIVHORQOHVFKpPDVXLYDQW
LQGRHXURSpHQ iM 6M >´YHUV1¬VLQJµ !WRNKFRP iM éM ]pUR
% %UiM 6M )0´YHUV1SOXUµ !WRNKFRP iMé)0!$(02%!ؐ
% %UiM 6M >%"+# !WRNKFRP iMé%4a%X%UiMéM4a!$(4
% %UiM 6M )0%"+# !WRNKFRP iMéM)0%4a%X%U; QߓFl!%HؐߓFl
'DQVFHFDVO·DIIL[HG·DOODWLIHVWDMRXWpjO·DFFXVDWLIHQV\QFKURQLHSDUFHTXHFHODUpVXOWHGXILJHPHQWGXGpYH
ORSSHPHQWKLVWRULTXHOHUHQIRUFHPHQWGHO·DFFXVDWLIGLUHFWLISDUXQPRUSKqPHjYDOHXUVSpFLILTXHPHQWGLUHFWLYH
3DUDOOqOHPHQWODIRQFWLRQSUpGRPLQDQWHGHO·DFFXVDWLIOLEUHGHYHQDLWFHOOHGHFRPSOpPHQWG·REMHWGLUHFW
8QUDLVRQQHPHQWDQDORJXHV·DSSOLTXHDXORFDWLI'DQVOHVQRPVDWKpPDWLTXHVVHSURGXLVDLWODFRQIXVLRQ
IRUPHOOHGXORFDWLIDYHFOHQRPLQDWLIHWO·DFFXVDWLIDXVLQJXOLHUHJ +rç=9M0´±LOµ! é=!%!=2%!%(=DFF +rç=9MP૖%
X%Ué= 9 a ) ORF +rç=9#%X%Ué= 9 aDYHFJpQpUDOLVDWLRQGHO·DOORPRUSKHDYHFSHUWHGHO·DSSHQGLFHODELRYpODLUH
/·DGYHUEH%\QHߓ´pYLGHPPHQWFODLUHPHQWµ µGDQVOHVGHX[\HX[µ \lQ ߓlHVWLVVXG·XQV\QWDJPHSUpSR
98K8FHHJ>%U!)%+r6=9#+_DYHFOHYLHX[GXHOGXQRPGHO·±LO FIJUHFKRPpULTXHཱིۭۭ͘OLWXDQLHQ(=ÑYLHX[VODYRɥL 
6\PpWULTXHPHQWRQSHXWSRVHUXQV\QWDJPHDYHFUHQIRUFHPHQWGXORFDWLIVLQJSDUXQDGYHUEHVLJQLILDQW´GHGDQV
jO·LQWpULHXUµ +rç=9#%X%Ué= 9 %Å%)é!%!=M)! $DNDؐ ´GDQVO·±LOµ'XIDLWGHODGLVSDULWLRQGXORFDWLIHQWDQWTXH
WHOSXLVTX·LOQHVHGLVWLQJXDLWSOXVGXWKqPH é=GXQRPHQTXHVWLRQO·DIIL[H )épWDLWFRQVLGpUpFRPPHDMRXWp
jODIRUPHG·REOLTXHVLQJSDUDOOqOHPHQWjO·DOODWLIFI%HNlߓ 4 $(=M(4´YHUVO·±LOµ
3543OXVLHXUVIRUPHVRQWGRQFSXVHUYLUG·DYDQWFRXUULHUVjODJpQpUDOLVDWLRQGHO·DFFXVDWLI REOLTXH FRPPH
EDVHGHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHV(QIDLWOHFRPLWDWLIUHSUpVHQWHXQFDVWRWDOHPHQWLVROpSDUFHTX·LOHVWOHVHXOSRXU
OHTXHOLOH[LVWHXQHSUpSRVLWLRQGHIRUPHFRPSDWLEOHHWFRQVWUXLWHDYHFO·REOLTXH1pDQPRLQVFHODQ·pSXLVHSDV
OHSUREOqPHFDULOUHVWHjH[SOLTXHUO·RULJLQHGHO·DIIL[H%>I(,OH[LVWHjF{WpXQDGYHUEH>I(jO·pWDWOLEUHGDQV
TXHOTXHVH[HPSOHVLOVLJQLILH´HQVHPEOHDYHFµ2QSRXUUDLW\UHWURXYHUOHSDVVDJHG·XQDGYHUEHjXQDIIL[HFRPPH
GDQV$ D ߓߓlOHQUHJDUGGHO·DGYHUEH HWSUpSRVLWLRQ $ߓOD%ߓDOH ߓOH ,OHVWFHUWDLQTXHODIRUPHHQFOLWLTXH>I(%
SURYLHQWGH PSčPDLVLOQ·H[LVWHSDVHQUHJDUGXQHIRUPH% PiSD PlSčDYHFDFFHQWXDWLRQQRUPDOHFRPPH
%ߓiOH ߓlO HQUHJDUGGHODIRUPHHQFOLWLTXHߓOH3DUFRQVpTXHQWLOPHSDUDvWWUqVGRXWHX[GHVXLYUHOHYLHX[
UDSSURFKHPHQWGHFHPRUSKqPHDYHFJUࢆๆࠗǓ´DXPLOLHXGHSDUPLµG·RDYHFOHJpQLWLI´DYHFµ6XUOHSODQIRUPHO
FHODFRQGXLWjSRVHU >!&+(TXLHVWFRPSDUpIDFLOHPHQWjJUHFࢆๆۭ‫ݵ‬ǓDGYHWFRQMRQFWLRQ´MXVTXHµ >!M0M&+(2%6L%
SUpWH[WHTX·LOH[LVWHGHVIRUPHVDOWHUQDWLYHV GLDOHFWDOHV ࢆๆۭࠗǓࢆๆۭࠗ͘ࢆๆۭ‫ݵ‬ԆHWF FI.OLQJHQVFKPLWWI 
(QGHKRUVGXIDLWTXHOHVHQVGHVIRUPHVDXWUHVTXHࢆๆࠗǓHVWDVVH]GLIIpUHQWFHODUHYLHQWILQDOHPHQWjIDLUHGX
WRNKDULHQXQGLDOHFWHJUHFLQFRQQXHWjWUDLWHUOHVLJQLILDQWGHPDQLqUHWRWDOHPHQWVSpFXODWLYH2QSHXWFUDLQGUH
TXHFHWWHDQDO\VHVRLWFDQRQLVpHGDQVOHGLFWLRQQDLUHGHVSDUWLFXOHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVGRQWODSDUXWLRQSURFKDLQH
HVWDQQRQFpH,OUHVWHH[WUrPHPHQWGRXWHX[GH´FRXSHUµWRNKDULHQ%>MI(%JH%UPlSč(QHIIHWLOHVWTXDVLFHUWDLQ
TXHOHJURXSHPS!QRWHLFLHWGDQVG·DXWUHVPRWVXQHFRQVRQQHXQLTXHODIULFDWLYHELODELDOH‰TXLSHXWrWUH
QRWpHDXVVLZ!RXS!LOQ·H[LVWDLWSDVGHOHWWUHH[DFWHPHQWFRUUHVSRQGDQWHGDQVOHV\OODEDLUHEUčKPҸHPSOR\p
SDUOHVVFULEHVWRNKDULHQV¬SRXUOHXUSURSUHODQJXHLOVUpVHUYDLHQWHQSULQFLSHOHJUDSKqPHY!DX[PRWVHPSUXQ
WpVDXVDQVNULW2QDGpVRUPDLVODSUHXYHGHODYDOHXUSKRQpWLTXHGHFHWWHQRWDWLRQPS!G·DSUqVWRNKDULHQ%
>I!=TXLGpVLJQHGDQVGHVUHJLVWUHVGHFRPSWDELOLWpXQSHUVRQQDJHGRWpHQRXWUHGXWLWUH46-LOIDXWFRPSUHQGUH
pYLGHPPHQWWXUFDQFLHQElJɥRU/DQRWDWLRQGHWXUF&a5´FKHI µSDU>I!=Q·DSDVG·pTXLYDOHQWGDQVOHVODQJXHV
YRLVLQHVTXLHPSORLHQWDXVVLOHV\OODEDLUHEUčKPҸ&HWXVDJHHVWFRQILUPpSDUGHVH[HPSOHVHQV\OODEHLQWpULHXUH
ROHSDVVDJHGHSjXQHIULFDWLYHVRQRUHHQSRVLWLRQLQWHUYRFDOLTXHpWDLWSUpYLVLEOHG·DLOOHXUVOHSKpQRPqQH
VHSURGXLVDLWSDUDOOqOHPHQWHQPR\HQLQGLHQ FI+LQEHU HJ$DUlPSčW´IRUPHH[WpULHXUHEHDXWpµ
HQUHJDUGGH%!-!I($! pTXLYDOHQWGHVDQVNULWUࡃSD &HVGHX[PRWVUHIOqWHQWXQHIRUPHFRPPXQH U ‰čW DYHF
XQHQRWDWLRQDUFKDwVDQWHHQWRNKDULHQ%SDUUHWRXUjODIRUPHQRQYRLVpHGHO·RFFOXVLYHLQWHUYRFDOLTXH&HSRLQW
VHUDWUDLWpSOXVORQJXHPHQWjXQHDXWUHRFFDVLRQ3RXUOHPRPHQWLOQRXVVXIILWGHSRVHUTXHWRNKDULHQ%>I(%
FRQWLQXHXQHIRUPHPRQRV\OODELTXHHWUHIOqWHXQPRUSKqPH ‰čGRQWSOXVLHXUVLQWHUSUpWDWLRQVVRQWWKpRULTXH
PHQWSRVVLEOHV0DLVFHODQRXVpORLJQHUDLWEHDXFRXSGHQRWUHVXMHW
364/·DEODWLISRVHXQSUREOqPHHQSDUWLHLGHQWLTXHjFHOXLGXFRPLWDWLISDUFHTXHOHVDIIL[HVGHVGHX[ODQJXHV
VRQWWRWDOHPHQWLQFRPSDWLEOHV(QWRNKDULHQ$ODIRUPHSOXVUDUH(ߙSURYLHQWGHVQRPVWKpPDWLTXHVFRPPHOHV
 oi.uchicago.edu

QP<% D8,KD87MP8<B%@/B<\N*

IRUPHVG·DOODWLI(4GHORFDWLI(ؐHWGHFRPLWDWLIDߓߓlO/DODQJXHDJpQpUDOLVpODIRUPHaߙjSDUWLUGHVWKqPHVHQ
FRQVRQQHjWRXVOHVW\SHVGHWKqPHV\FRPSULVDX[DQFLHQVQRPVWKpPDWLTXHVFIMXVWHPHQW\XNlߙ8QHLQGLFD
WLRQGpFLVLYHVXUODIRUPDWLRQGHFHFDVQRXVHVWIRXUQLHSDUOHWRNKDULHQ%1RXVDYRQVQRWp † O·DFFHQWXDWLRQ
LGHQWLTXHGHVIRUPHVG·DEODWLIVLQJjFHOOHGHVFDV´SULPDLUHVµHQWRNKDULHQ%ELHQTXHO·DIIL[HFDVXHO>!ؐ%7J9KJ%
VpSDUDEOHHJ.a=.UM>!ؐFRPPHJpQLWLIVLQJ.a=.UM)$0!'DQVODPHVXUHRO·DIIL[HG·DEODWLIVHFRPSRUWHH[DFWH
PHQWG·DSUqVVDVpSDUDELOLWpFRPPHOHVDXWUHVDIIL[HVFHWWHGpSHQGDQFHDFFHQWXHOOHDYHFODEDVHHVWVHFRQGDLUH
HOOHHVWGXHDXIDLWTXHODIRUPHGHEDVHGHO·DEODWLISDUFHTX·HOOHFRPSRUWDLWGpMjWURLVV\OODEHVpWDLWDFFHQWXpH
UpJXOLqUHPHQWVXUODGHX[LqPHV\OODEH .a=.ULa%Å>!)$XWUHPHQWGLWODIRUPDWLRQGHO·DEODWLIHQWRNKDULHQ%
SUpVXSSRVHXQHFRQWUDFWLRQ ULa!USDUDOOqOHPHQWjWRNKDULHQ$(ؐ Dlߙ&HWWHILQDOHWRNKDULHQFRPPXQ
éLa 3 GHVQRPVWKpPDWLTXHVV·HVWpWHQGXHjWRXVOHVW\SHVGHWKqPHV #La 3  1La 3  čl 3  T3La 3 DYHF
ODPrPHDFFHQWXDWLRQG·RHJ%=a.'>ÉM>!ؐHQUHJDUGGHO·REOVLQJNiO\PLGH=a.'>É'!´GLUHFWLRQµVQࡃPHؐ%9L7%
ViQX  0a)1 ´GDQJHUµVWDQčPHؐ%9L7%VWčQD  VWčQč SOXUGHVWčP´DUEUHµSZčUPHؐHQUHJDUGGHSࡃZDU´IHXµ
9>U-M>!ؐHQUHJDUGGHZiPHU  9a>!- ´MR\DXµ3DUFRQVpTXHQWGHIDoRQSXUHPHQWGHVFULSWLYHLOVHPEOHTXH
O·DIIL[H>!ؐ´DWWLUHµO·DFFHQWVXUODV\OODEHLPPpGLDWHPHQWSUpFpGHQWH7RXVOHVWKqPHVRQWDGRSWpODILQDOH
G·DEODWLILVVXHGHODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXHFHSKpQRPqQHUDSSHOOHGHPDQLqUHIUDSSDQWHO·H[WHQVLRQGXW\SHGH
O·DEODWLIVLQJ‫گ‬GHQODWLQ HWGDQVOHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHV G·RčGҸGࡃG̒GHWFHOOHGHODILQDOH($જG·DEODWLI
VLQJHQDYHVWLTXH3DUFRQVpTXHQWM·DLLQWHUSUpWpODIRUPHGHGpSDUW éLa 3 GHVQRPVWKpPDWLTXHVjSDUWLU
GHO·DEODWLIVLQJXOLHUWKpPDWLTXHTXLSUpVHQWDLWXQHFRQWUDFWLRQ(QSURWRLQGRHXURSpHQO·DEODWLIVLQJXOLHU
pWDLWGLVWLQFWGXJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUVHXOHPHQWGDQVODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXHVRLW ‫گ‬GUHIOpWpSDUODWLQDUFKDwTXH‫گ‬G2%
YpGLTXHčG 5LJYHGD(L(" DYHVWLTXHč$જFHOWLEqUH1GJUHFङHWFFHWWHILQDOHHVWLVVXHGHFRQWUDFWLRQFRPPH
OHPRQWUHODVFDQVLRQHQGHX[V\OODEHVHQYpGLTXHHWDXVVLO·LQWRQDWLRQGLVWLQFWLYHHQEDOWLTXH JpQLWLIVLQJ ź¶2%
FIOLWXDQLHQ"#̎?62%>JKKFH%"Ñ!?( VODYHHWJHUPDQLTXH-HQHUHYLHQVSDVLFLVXUWRXWHODGpPRQVWUDWLRQTXHM·DL
GpYHORSSpHDLOOHXUV  3RXUOHPRPHQWOHUDSSURFKHPHQWDYHFOHWRNKDULHQHWODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQG·XQHILQDOH
6O!" 6+_!"REOLJHUDLWjUHQRQFHUjODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQGHYHQXHVFRODLUH YRLUSDUH[HPSOH)RUWVRQ 
6O("  6+n("" TXLV·DSSXLHH[FOXVLYHPHQWVXUOHEDOWLTXH SXLVTXHOHYRFDOLVPHGXVODYHHVWDPELJX DORUV
TX·XQHH[SOLFDWLRQDQDORJLTXHGXYRFDOLVPHGHODILQDOHFRQWUDFWpHEDOW ź¶ (L( 3 HVWSRVVLEOH-HODLVVHDXVVL
GHF{WpOHSUREOqPHGHODUHVWLWXWLRQGHODFRQVRQQHILQDOHGHFHWWHGpVLQHQFHM·DGPHWVTX·HOOHHVWUHIOpWpHSDU
WRNKDULHQ$ߙTXLSUpVXSSRVHHQO·RFFXUUHQFHXQHIULFDWLYHVRQRUH ঈODTXHOOHDVXELOHGpYRLVHPHQWGHWRXWHV
OHVFRQVRQQHVHQWRNKDULHQFRPPXQ/DIRUPHGXWRNKDULHQ%V·H[SOLTXHUDLWSDUODFKXWHGHFHWWHFRQVRQQHGHYDQW
XQPRUSKqPHDMRXWpjODIRUPHG·DEODWLI%>!) QRWp>!ؐ UHSRVHFRPPHRQO·DGpMjHQYLVDJpVXU >é)a ) 
DFFVLQJ >ç)P૖ G·XQQRPUDFLQHVLJQLILDQW´KDXWHXUpPLQHQFHµDSSDUHQWpj%>()$! VDQVNULWࡃUGKYDP´YHUV
OHKDXWµ  >a)$é >Q૖ $ç0DEODWLIVLQJDGYHUELDO'·DLOOHXUVFHWDGYHUEH>()$!V·HPSORLHQRWDPPHQWDSUqV
GHVIRUPHVG·DEODWLI/DIRUPHIOpFKLHG·DEODWLIVLQJXOLHUDpWpUHFDUDFWpULVpHVHXOHPHQWHQWRNKDULHQ%jSDUWLU
G·XQHORFXWLRQTXLH[LVWDLWVDQVGRXWHHQWRNKDULHQFRPPXQ é O a3GpYHORSSpHQ éLa3>é)a ) VRLW% i
ULa 3 M>!)%X%ipPHؐ´HQSDUWDQWGH;YHUVOHKDXWµG·R´HQSDUWDQWGH;SRXUVRUWLUµ!´GH;HQSDUWDQWµ!´j
SDUWLUGH;µ2QSHXWSRVHUTXHODFRQVRQQHILQDOHGHODIRUPHIOpFKLHV·HVWDPXwHGHYDQWODFRQVRQQHLQLWLDOHGX
PRUSKqPHDMRXWp/DYDOHXUFDVXHOOHGXV\QWDJPHFRPSOHWHVWWUDQVIpUpHDXPRUSKqPHILQDOTXLGHYLHQWO·DIIL[H
SURSUHjFHFDV3OXVTXHVXUO·DVSHFWIRUPHOMHYRXGUDLVLQVLVWHUVXUODJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQGXPRUSKqPH%>!)N%
LODSSDUDLVVDLWDSUqVFRQWUDFWLRQHWFKXWHGHODFRQVRQQHFRPPHDMRXWpjODIRUPHG·DFFXVDWLIVLQJHWSRXYDLW
GRQFrWUHDMRXWpjO·DFFXVDWLISOXUSDUDOOqOHPHQWDX[DXWUHVDIIL[HVQRWDPPHQWFHX[TXLH[SULPHQWGHVFDV
ORFDX[ORFDWLIDOODWLIHWSHUODWLI,QGpSHQGDPPHQWWRNKDULHQ$aߙVHSURSDJHDLWDXVVLSRXUOHVPrPHVUDLVRQV
GXVLQJXOLHUDXSOXULHO1RXVDYRQVLFLXQHKLVWRLUHGLIIpUHQWHHQIDLWO·DEODWLIGXWRNKDULHQQ·HVWSDVFRQVWLWXp
G·XQHSRVWSRVLWLRQFRQVWUXLWHDYHFO·REOLTXHPDLVUHSRVHVXUXQHDQFLHQQHIRUPHG·DEODWLI0DLVRQHVWSDVVpG·XQH
H[SUHVVLRQIOH[LRQQHOOHjXQHH[SUHVVLRQDJJOXWLQDWLYH
374/HFDXVDOGXWRNKDULHQ%SRVHXQSUREOqPHLGHQWLTXHjFHOXLGHO·DEODWLIO·DFFHQWXDWLRQGLYHUJHQWHSDU
UDSSRUWDX[DXWUHVFDVVHFRQGDLUHV(VWLOUHGHYDEOHG·XQHVROXWLRQDQDORJXH"-XVTX·jSUpVHQWRQFRQVLGqUHTXH
O·DIIL[Hx a TXLHQWUDvQHFHPRXYHPHQWG·DFFHQWSURYLHQWGXJpQLWLIDEODWLIVLQJGHWKqPHHQQDVDOH )M!0%
*8S,†SVXLYLSDU9DQ:LQGHNHQVS &HODHVWWKpRULTXHPHQWSRVVLEOHHWV·DFFRUGHUDLWELHQDYHF
O·LPSRUWDQFHTXHQRXVDYRQVGpMjPHQWLRQQpHjSOXVLHXUVUHSULVHVGHVWKqPHVpODUJLVHQQDVDOHGDQVOHV\VWqPH
QRPLQDOGXWRNKDULHQFRPPXQPDLVRQVHKHXUWHDVVH]YLWHjGHVREMHFWLRQVVpULHXVHV/DGpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLI
VLQJDWKpPDWLTXHQ·HVWFRQQXHMXVTX·jSUpVHQW YRLUSOXVKDXW† TXHVRXVODIRUPH é 60SRXUTXRLXQGRX
EOHW !0VHUDLWLOUpVHUYpjFHWWHIRUPDWLRQ"2QQHSHXWWLUHUDUJXPHQWGHODGpVLQHQFHGHJpQLWLIVLQJXOLHUxTXL
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7\K%N;O/7*,/K8%H87%3<7%8B%*,bO<K/8B% QPR

HVWHPSOR\pHHQWRNKDULHQ%VHXOHPHQWSDUGHVQRPVHPSUXQWpVDXVDQVNULWHQ#1HW(HQHIIHWOHWRNKDULHQ
$SUpVHQWHHQUHJDUGXQHILQDOH'FHTXLVXJJqUHXQVFpQDULRDVVH]GLIIpUHQWjSDUWLUGXPR\HQLQGLHQ'HSOXV
ODYDOHXUFDVXHOOHHVWDXWUHJpQLWLIHWDEODWLIVRQWH[SULPpVSDUOHPrPHPRUSKqPHDXVLQJXOLHUGHODIOH[LRQ
DWKpPDWLTXHHQSURWRLQGRHXURSpHQDORUVTXHJpQLWLIHWDEODWLIVRQWGHVFDVGLVWLQFWVHQWRNKDULHQ,OHVWGRQF
DQDFKURQLTXHGHYRLUGDQVOHFDXVDOGXWRNKDULHQ%XQUHIOHWGHO·DEODWLIGHFDXVH/HSUREOqPHFRPSRUWHXQH
GLPHQVLRQVXSSOpPHQWDLUH)DXWLOVHFRQWHQWHUGHODFUpDWLRQHQTXHOTXHVRUWHVSRQWDQpHGHFDVGDQVOHVGHX[
ODQJXHVWRNKDULHQQHVjSDUWLUG·XQHWDEOHUDVHjVDYRLUODUXLQHGHODIOH[LRQQRPLQDOHLQGRHXURSpHQQH"/HVFDV
QHQDLVVHQWSDVjSDUWLUGHVIRUPHVTXLVHUYHQWjOHVH[SULPHU/HGpYHORSSHPHQWLQYHUVHHVWQRUPDOLOH[LVWH
XQHFDWpJRULHFDVXHOOHGRQWODIRUPHHVWUHQRXYHOpHpYHQWXHOOHPHQWJUkFHDXUHPSODFHPHQWG·XQHH[SUHVVLRQ
V\QWKpWLTXHSDUXQHH[SUHVVLRQDQDO\WLTXHGXW\SHGpVLQHQFHSUpRXSRVWSRVLWLRQ%LHQV€UO·DSSDULWLRQGH
QRXYHOOHVFDWpJRULHVFDVXHOOHVQ·HVWSDVH[FOXHPDLVHOOHLPSOLTXHXQUHPRGHODJHGXV\VWqPHHWQRWDPPHQWGH
ODUHODWLRQHQWUHOHVFDV'DQVOHGRPDLQHWRNKDULHQRQGRLWWRXMRXUVVHVRXFLHUGHODUHFRQVWUXFWLRQGHODODQJXH
FRPPXQHDQWpULHXUHjODVpSDUDWLRQGHVGHX[GLDOHFWHVTXLDERXWLURQWDX[GHX[ODQJXHVFRQQXHV/HFDVSURSUHDX
WRNKDULHQ$HVWO·LQVWUXPHQWDOGRQWOHVHPSORLV PR\HQFDXVHDJHQW VRQWH[SULPpVHQWRNKDULHQ%SDUOHSHUODWLI
2ULOHVWDGPLVWDFLWHPHQWRXH[SOLFLWHPHQWGDQVODWUDGLWLRQWRNKDURORJLTXHTXHOHWRNKDULHQFRPPXQQ·DYDLW
SDVG·LQVWUXPHQWDOHWTXHFHOXLFLpWDLWHQIDLWUHSUpVHQWpSDUOHSHUODWLIO·LQVWUXPHQWDOVHUDLWXQHLQQRYDWLRQGX
WRNKDULHQ$FHTXLVXUOHSODQIRUPHOV·DSSXLHVXUO·LVROHPHQWGXPRUSKqPH'6HWVRQLGHQWLWpDSSDUHQWHDYHF
ODFRQMRQFWLRQGHFRRUGLQDWLRQ'6&HWWHFRQMRQFWLRQDXQHPSORLELHQVSpFLILTXHSDUUDSSRUWjODFRQMRQFWLRQGH
FRRUGLQDWLRQRUGLQDLUH$ߓNDؐ %ߙSlQRQDSSDUHQWp GRQWO·HPSORLFRUUHVSRQGjFHOXLGHVDQVNULW4(¬ FI7KRPDV
 HOOHVHUWjFRRUGRQQHUGHVVXEVWDQWLIVSURFKHVRXFRPSOpPHQWDLUHVGDQVOHPrPHFKDPSVpPDQWLTXHFI
R‫ع‬N\RN1.#´KRPPHHWIHPPHµ.(I%'6%(=>(.´WrWHHWYLVDJHµSčSߙXQH\RNQčQPXQH´PRUDOLWpHWVDJHVVHµHOOHVH
SODFHHQWUHOHVGHX[WHUPHVjODGLIIpUHQFHGHODFRQMRQFWLRQ$ߓNDؐ %ߙSl TXLVHSODFHDSUqVOHGHUQLHUWHUPH
/DSDUWLFXOHGHPrPHHPSORLHQWRNKDULHQ%HVW9(#TXLQHSHXWJXqUHrWUHDSSDUHQWpjWRNKDULHQ$'62%96LG%6L%
SUL[G·XQHPpWDWKqVHWRWDOHPHQWDUELWUDLUH FI.OLQJHQVFKPLWW /DUHODWLRQVpPDQWLTXHHQWUHO·DIIL[H
G·LQVWUXPHQWDOVLVRQVHQVSUHPLHUHVW´DYHFµHWXQHWHOOHFRQMRQFWLRQ ´HWDXVVLHWjODIRLVµ HVWSRVVLEOHHOOH
SHXWrWUHHQYLVDJpHGDQVOHVGHX[VHQV(QHIIHW´<DYHF;µSHXWrWUHFRQoXFRPPHpTXLYDOHQWj´;HWDXVVL<µHW
LQYHUVHPHQWFHGHUQLHUV\QWDJPHSHXWVHUYLUGHEDVHjXQLQVWUXPHQWDOVRFLDWLITXLILQLWSDURFFXSHUOHVDXWUHV
HPSORLVGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDO8QGpWDLOIRUPHOQRXVUpYqOHTXHO·DIIL[HG·LQVWUXPHQWDO$'6Q·HVWSDVLGHQWLTXHDX[
DXWUHVDIIL[HVVRQDMRXWQ·DIIHFWHSDVOHYRFDOLVPHGHODV\OODEHSUpFpGHQWHjODGLIIpUHQFHGHO·DMRXWGHVDXWUHV
DIIL[HVFDVXHOVTXLSURYRTXHODIHUPHWXUHHWODV\QFRSHGHODGLWHYR\HOOH3DUH[HPSOHGHWRNKDULHQ$NOD‫ع‬N%
´YpKLFXOHµ %NOH‫ع‬NH TXLVXLWODIOH[LRQODSOXVFRXUDQWHOHSOXULHOHVWQRPNOD‫ع‬NDxDFFNOD‫ع‬NDVOHVIRUPHVGH
ORFDWLISOXUNOD‫ع‬NVDؐ NOD‫ع‬NDVDؐHWGHSHUODWLISOXUNOD‫ع‬NVč NOD‫ع‬NDVčSUpVHQWHQWODV\QFRSHDWWHQGXHDORUV
TXHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOSOXUHVWNOD‫ع‬NDV\R2%JK%HFH%=69%UNOD‫ع‬NlV\RDWWHQGXSDUO·DSSOLFDWLRQVWULFWHGHODORLSKRQpWLTXH
3RXUFHWWHUDLVRQ:LQWHU  FRQVLGqUHTXHFHVIRUPHVQHFRQVWLWXHQWSDVXQPRWXQLWDLUHPDLV´XQ
V\QWDJPHQRPLQDOIRUPpGHO·DFFXVDWLIHWG·XQHSRVWSRVLWLRQµ (%96-"%I+-(0!%46)0#0$#)5%6:%(4410($#?!%()"%I60$I60#M
$#6) &HODLPSOLTXHTXHOHVHQVSUHPLHUGHFHWWHSRVWSRVLWLRQpWDLW´DYHFµHWTXHO·HPSORLFRPPHFRRUGLQDWLRQ
UpVXOWHG·XQHVSpFLDOLVDWLRQVHFRQGDLUH&HUDLVRQQHPHQWHVWFRQWUDGLFWRLUHDYHFODGpILQLWLRQJpQpUDOHGHWRXVOHV
DIIL[HVTXLVRQWHIIHFWLYHPHQWHQV\QFKURQLHGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVDMRXWpVjODIRUPHG·DFFXVDWLI REOLTXH (QGHKRUV
GHODSDUWLFXODULWpVLJQDOpHSOXVKDXWO·DIIL[H'6QHVHFRPSRUWHSDVGHPDQLqUHGLIIpUHQWHGDQVOHV\QWDJPHSDU
UDSSRUWDX[DXWUHVDIIL[HV
3842QQ·DSDVSULVJDUGHDXIDLWTXHOHGRPDLQHGXFDXVDOGXWRNKDULHQ%HVWFRXYHUWSDUO·LQVWUXPHQWDOHQ
WRNKDULHQ$FRPPHLOHVWpQRQFpWUqVFODLUHPHQWGDQVOHPDQXHO *8S,†S DYHFOHVVXEVWDQWLIVH[SULPDQW
XQVHQWLPHQW YRLUSOXVKDXW† $NčFNH\R´SDUMRLHµ=#I'6´SDUKRQWHµWX‫ع‬N\R´SDUDPRXUµHWF&HODGpQRQFH
O·RULJLQHFRPPXQHGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOGXWRNKDULHQ$HWGXFDXVDOGXWRNKDULHQ%FDXVDO% pHxl DMRXWGHxl%
WLUpGXJpQLWLIGDWLISURQRPLQDOFI%ߙDx´VLHQµWDx´GHWRLSRXUWRLµ DYHFXQHFRQWUDFWLRQGHODVpTXHQFH UL!M
x a !px a TXLH[SOLTXHO·DFFHQWXDWLRQGXFDXVDOFRPPHSRXUO·DEODWLI YRLUSOXVKDXW† /DILQDOH% UL!%
VHUDLWLVVXHGH é'é  x  6M)M!+_ILQDOHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOVLQJGHODIOH[LRQHQQDVDOH/HGpYHORSSHPHQW
SKRQpWLTXHFLGHVVXV GpQDVDOLVDWLRQGH xLQWHUYRFDOLTXHHWFRQWUDFWLRQ V·DSSXLHVXUG·DXWUHVH[HPSOHVFI%
ߓUč\´KRPPHVkJpVQRPSOXU ߓlUčxlHQUHJDUGGXWKqPH ߓlUčQGDQVO·REOSOXUߓUčQlؐHWF(QWRNKDULHQ$
ODILQDOHSURYHQDQWGH é'éIXWUHQRXYHOpHDYDQWODFRQWUDFWLRQGH (L'(SDUODFRQMRQFWLRQ'6´DYHFµ RX´HQ
DVVRFLDWLRQµ G·R (Å'6&HWDSSXLVXUODFRQMRQFWLRQDSHUPLVGH´VDXYHUµO·DIIL[HFDVXHOTXLDXUDLWpWpDPXw
WRWDOHPHQWHOOHSUpVXSSRVHpYLGHPPHQWXQHDIILQLWpVpPDQWLTXHDYHFODFRQMRQFWLRQ/DTXHVWLRQGHVRQpW\PR
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8,KD87MP8<B%@/B<\N*

ORJLHQ·DSDVG·LQFLGHQFHVXUQRWUHDUJXPHQWDWLRQ/·H[LVWHQFHGXW\SHWRNKDULHQ$ (Å'6QRXVSHUPHWG·H[SOLTXHU
SDUODPrPHFOHIODSDUWLFXODULWpIRUPHOOHGXSOXULHOODWUDQVSRVLWLRQGHFHWWHVpTXHQFHDXSOXULHOGRQQDLW(0Å'62%
DYHFPDLQWLHQGXPrPHYRFDOLVPHDYDQWTXHODIRUPHGXVLQJXOLHUVRLWUHIDLWHVXUODIRUPHQRUPDOHG·DFFXVDWLI
TXLSHUGDLWVDYR\HOOHILQDOHVRLWNOD‫ع‬N\RSRXUOHQRPGX´YpKLFXOHµFLWpSOXVKDXW/·pODUJLVVHPHQWSDUx a GH
ODIRUPHGXWRNKDULHQ%V·H[SOLTXHDXVVLGDQVOHFDGUHGXV\QWDJPHDYHFXQWHUPHTXLUpIqUHjXQVHQWLPHQW
RXXQpWDWSV\FKRORJLTXHGHO·DJHQWGXSURFqVRQSHXWV·DWWHQGUHjO·HPSORLFRPPHGpWHUPLQDQWGXSRVVHVVLI
UpIOpFKL WRNK%ߙDx2%!%ߙxL TXLUHQYRLHjFHWDJHQW´SDUKRQWHµVLJQLILHWRXMRXUVLPSOLFLWHPHQW´SDUVDSURSUH
KRQWHµ/·HPSORLGXSRVVHVVLIUpIOpFKLDYHFXQQRPGHVHQWLPHQWjO·LQVWUXPHQWDOVHUHQFRQWUHDXVVLHQWRNKDULHQ
$HJߙxLčNčO\R´SDUVRQSURSUHVRXKDLWµߙxLNORS\R´SDUVDSURSUHGRXOHXUµ3DUFRQVpTXHQWRQSHXWUHVWLWXHU
LH%9EHK6IMJ%UߙlxlHQWVpH´SDUVDSURSUHHQYLHµDYHFUHFDUDFWpULVDWLRQGXVHFRQGWHUPHGDQV ߙlx a HQWVpHx a 
/DFRQWUDFWLRQGH UL!HQUULVTXDLWGHSULYHUFHWWHIRUPHGHWRXWHPDUTXHFDVXHOOHSXLVTXHODIRUPH!)$0!pWDLW
LGHQWLTXHjFHOOHGHQRPDFFVLQJXOLHU
,OH[LVWDLWGRQFXQFDVLQVWUXPHQWDOHQWRNKDULHQFRPPXQTXLDpWpUHVWUHLQWHQWRNKDULHQ%DXFDXVDOSDU
O·H[WHQVLRQGXSHUODWLIDORUVTXHOHWRNKDULHQ$DGpYHORSSpXQHGLVWULEXWLRQVSpFLILTXHGXSHUODWLIHWGHO·LQV
WUXPHQWDOO·LQVWUXPHQWDOSUpGRPLQHGDQVO·H[SUHVVLRQGXPR\HQPDWpULHOHWSRXUO·H[SUHVVLRQGHO·DJHQWOD
UpSDUWLWLRQVHIDLWG·DSUqVXQHFDWpJRULVDWLRQOH[LFDOHSHUODWLI>KXPDLQ@YVLQVWUXPHQWDO>²KXPDLQ@/·LQVWUX
PHQWDOUHVWHH[FOXGHVHPSORLVORFDX[GXSHUODWLIHPSORL´WDQJHQWLHOµFRQWDFWDYHFXQHVXUIDFHQRQOLPLWpHSDU
RSSRVLWLRQDXORFDWLI/HUHFRXYUHPHQWSDUWLHOHWILQDOHPHQWDVVH]OLPLWpGHFHUWDLQVHPSORLVGXSHUODWLIHWGH
O·LQVWUXPHQWDOHQWRNKDULHQ$ PDQLqUH SHXWrWUHG€jO·LQIOXHQFHGXWRNKDULHQ%

/<=>?@AB<=
/·pWXGHGHVFDVGLWV´VHFRQGDLUHVµGHVGHX[ODQJXHVWRNKDULHQQHVTXLHQV\QFKURQLHVRQWH[SULPpVSDUGHV
PRUSKqPHVLQGLIIpUHQWVDXQRPEUHHWDMRXWpVjODIRUPHG·DFFXVDWLIUpYqOHXQHKLVWRLUHDVVH]FRPSOH[HTXLD
FRPSRUWpSOXVLHXUVpWDSHV-HSURSRVHGHUHVWLWXHUHQWRNKDULHQFRPPXQHQSOXVGHVFDV QRPLQDWLIDFFXVDWLI
JpQLWLI GRWpVG·XQHIRUPHIOpFKLHFLQT´FDVµSRXUYXVG·XQHIRUPHSUpFLVHELHQTXHQHUHOHYDQWSOXVGHODIOH[LRQ
DXVHQVVWULFWLQVWUXPHQWDO é'éDEODWLI éLa3SHUODWLI čDOODWLI 4aORFDWLI )é(QGHKRUVGHO·DEODWLIHWGH
O·LQVWUXPHQWDOOHVIRUPHVGHSHUODWLIDOODWLIORFDWLISUpVXSSRVHQWXQHXQLYHUEDWLRQDYHFOHSURGXLWGHFDVKpULWpV
DFFXVDWLIHWORFDWLI%LHQTX·LVVXVGHILQDOHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVDYHFGpVLQHQFHVOHVDIIL[HVG·DEODWLIHWG·LQVWUXPHQWDO
RQWpWpDGDSWpVDXW\SHDJJOXWLQDWLI2QREVHUYHOHU{OHLPSRUWDQWMRXpSDUODIOH[LRQWKpPDWLTXHGDQVOHUHQRX
YHOOHPHQWIRUPHOGHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOV3OXVLHXUVSUREOqPHVRQWpWpVHXOHPHQWHVTXLVVpV(QGpSLWGHVSURJUqVGHOD
SKLORORJLHO·KLVWRLUHGHVFDVWRNKDULHQVHVWORLQG·rWUHFRPSOqWHPHQWpFULWH

0CDEFBGHB<=A
*8S :ROIJDQJ.UDXVHHW:HUQHU7KRPDV*64+(-#04+!0%8.!>!)$(-&14+9ROXPHV²+HLGHOEHUJ:LQ
KJ72%²
*64+D- (PLO6LHJHW:LOKHOP6LHJOLQJ*64+(-#04+!%D-(>>($#=g%/>%<1:$-(5!%"!-%@-!1Ü#04+!)%<=("!>#!%"!-%
J#00!)04+(:$!)%&!(-&!#$!$%#)%D!>!#)04+(:$%>#$%J#.+!.>%74+1.G!*|WWLQJHQ9DQGHQKRHFN 5XSUH
FKW

IBC?B<JDGKLBM
&DUOLQJ*HUG
% :???% H#!%F1)=$#6)!)%"!-%.6=(.!)%b(010%#>%*64+(-#04+!)%HUOLQ0RXWRQGH*UX\WHU
&RXYUHXU:DOWHU
  ´1RWHVXUODIOH[LRQWRFKDULHQQHµK!?1!%"!0%Q$1"!0%/)"6M81-6IU!))!0²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7\K%N;O/7*,/K8%H87%3<7%8B%*,bO<K/8B% QP@

(UGDO0DUFHO
% :??<% <%D-(>>(-%6:%,."%*1-=#4+DQGERRNRI2ULHQWDO6WXGLHV6HFWLRQ9ROXPH/H\GH%ULOO
)LQFN)UDQ]1LNRODXV
% OPO?% H#!%O(1I$$'I!)%"!0%7I-(4+&(10$XV1DWXUXQG*HLVWHVZHOW6DPPOXQJZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKJHPHLQYHU
VWlQGOLFKHU'DUVWHOOXQJHQ/HLS]LJ%*7HXEQHU
)RUWVRQ%HQMDPLQ:
% :??<% /)"6M81-6I!()%N()51(5!%()"%31.$1-!g%<)%/)$-6"14$#6)2[IRUG%ODFNZHOO
48==J7K2%[F9K
  ´=XGHQVHNXQGlUHQ.DVXVDIIL[HQGHV7RFKDULVFKHQµ*64+(-#()%()"%/)"6M81-6I!()%7$1"#!0²
+DFNVWHLQ2ODY
  ´5HIOH[LYSURQRPLQD3UlYHUELHQXQG/RNDOSDUWLNHOLQGHQLQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ6SUDFKHQµ*64+(-#()%
()"%/)"6M81-6I!()%7$1"#!0²
+HZVRQ-RKQHW9LW%XEHQLN
  F-6>%3(0!%$6%<"I60#$#6)g%*+!%H!?!.6I>!)$%6:%36):#51-($#6)(.%7')$(]%#)%/)"6M81-6I!()%N()51(5!0&XUUHQW
,VVXHVLQ/LQJXLVWLF7KHRU\$PVWHUGDP%HQMDPLQV
+LQEHU2VNDUYRQ
% :??O% H(0%a.$!-!%A#$$!.#)"#04+%#>%}&!-&.#4=9LHQQHgVWHUUHLFKLVFKH$NDGHPLHGHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ
.OLQJHQVFKPLWW*HUW
  ´'DV7RFKDULVFKHLQLQGRJHUPDQLVWLVFKHU6LFKWµ'DQV*64+(-#04+g%<=$!)%"!-%<-&!#$0$(51)5%"!-%/)"6M
5!->()#04+!)%D!0!..04+(:$pGLWpSDU%6FKOHUDWKSS²7RFKDULDQDQG,QGR(XURSHDQ6WXGLHV
6XSSOHPHQWDU\6HULHV5H\NMDYtN0iOYtVLQGDVWRQXQ+iVNyODÌVODQGV
.|OYHU%HUQKDUG
  H!-%D!&-(14+%"!-%0!=1)"a-!)%b(010%#>%*64+(-#04+!)'LVVHUWDWLRQ)UDQNIXUWDP0DLQ
.UDXVH:ROIJDQJ
  ´=XU)UDJHQDFKGHPQLFKWLQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ6XEVWUDWGHV7RFKDULVFKHQµt!#$04+-#:$%:u-%T!-5.!#4+!)M
"!%7I-(4+:6-04+1)5%^bt`%²
/DQH*HRUJH6KHUPDQ
  ´1RWHVVXUOHVRUWGHVILQDOHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVHQWRNKDULHQµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%
@(-#0²
0HOFKHUW+&UDLJ
  ´7RFKDULDQ3OXUDOVLQ)$DQG5HODWHG3KHQRPHQDµ*64+(-#()%()"%/)"6M81-6I!()%7$1"#!0²
5JK8K2%36H8J>
  ´6\QFUpWLVPHVRXVVSpFLILFDWLRQHWFUpDWLRQFDVXHOOHGDQVOHVODQJXHVEDOWLTXHVµS1..!$#)%"!%.(%
764#U$U%"!%.#)51#0$#X1!%"!%@(-#0²
3LQDXOW*HRUJHV-HDQ
  ´0RUSKRORJLHGHO·DEODWLIWRNKDULHQµ'DQV*,߰+8551.MG(M($M$(M-(g%F!0$04+-#:$%:6-%F6.=!%P60!I+06)pGLWp
SDU*HUG&DUOLQJSS²*|WHERUJ0HLMHUEHUJV,QVWLWXWI|U6YHQVN(W\PRORJLVN)RUVNQLQJ
  3+-!0$6>($+#!%$6=+(-#!))!g%$!]$!0%!$%5-(>>(#-!&ROOHFWLRQ/LQJXLVWLTXHGHOD6RFLpWpGH/LQJXLVWLTXH
GH3DULV/RXYDLQ3HHWHUV
6FKPLGW.DUO+RUVW
  ´$JJOXWLQDWLRQXQG3RVWSRVLWLRQLP7RFKDULVFKHQµAu)4+!)!-%7$1"#!)%G1-%7I-(4+9#00!)04+(:$%:RN%
²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8,KD87MP8<B%@/B<\N*

  ´7\SXVUHOHYDQWHU6SUDFKZDQGHOIOHNWLHUHQG]XDJJOXWLQLHUHQGXQGVHLQH.RUUHODWLRQHQµQ$1"!0%
:#))6M615-#!))!0²
  ´=XP7\SXVGHVRVVHWLVFKHQ.DVXVV\VWHPVµN#)51#0$#4(²
6LPV:LOOLDPV1LFKRODV
% :??@% S(4$-#()%H641>!)$0%:-6>%B6-$+!-)%<:5+()#0$()2%1F>LMJ%:N%N!$$!-0%()"%S1""+#0$%*!]$0L6WXGLHVLQWKH
.KDOLOL&ROOHFWLRQ/RQGUHV7KH1RXU)RXQGDWLRQ$]LPXWK(GLWLRQV
7KRPDV:HUQHU
  ´%HPHUNXQJHQ]XP*HEUDXFKYRQWRFK!%'6XQG%9(#L%3!)$-(.%<0#($#4%P61-)(.²
  H!-%$64+(-#04+!%,&.#X110%#>%7#))!%!#)!0%<==10($#?0%"!-%K#4+$1)5$EKDQGOXQJHQGHU*HLVWHVXQG6R]LDO
ZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHQ.ODVVH:LHVEDGHQ)6WHLQHU
9DQ:LQGHNHQV$OEHUW-RULV
% OP@P% N!%$6=+(-#!)%46):-6)$U%(?!4%.!0%(1$-!0%.()51!0%#)"6M!1-6IU!))!02%1F>LMJ%:2%567K%ON%.(%>6-I+6.65#!%)6>#M
)(.!/RXYDLQ&HQWUH,QWHUQDWLRQDOGH'LDOHFWRORJLH*pQpUDOH
1FIK2%(6H9
  ´/HV\VWqPHGHVFDVHQRVVqWHµ<4$(%N#)51#0$#4(²
:LQWHU:HUQHU
  ´$1RWHRQ&DVHVµ'DQV*6%O6)6-%K6>()%P(=6&06)SS²3DULV0RXWRQ
% :??R% b.!#)!%74+-#:$!)W7!.!4$!"%J-#$#)50g%F!0$5(&!%(10%<).(00%"!0%àpL%D!&1-$0$(5!02%1F>LMJ%ON%*64+(-#04+%1)"%
/)"65!->()#04+eGLWpSDU2+DFNVWHLQ%UrPH+HPSHQ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <33,KH%7\K%N8%HQ7<33,KH% QPP

!"
#$$%&'()*&(+,('-)#$$%&'.(/*,+/*,)(&-0+,12%3)((
)*&(+,)(&#44%&5)(,35&,(6%&4786,)($#)*,+)((
,5(#'4%)252%3)(,3(-5&*)/*,

DL%?()%O!!>02%\)#?!-0#$U%N1>#E-!%q%N'6)%n j

29:;<=>?:@<9
0DOJUpXQHTXDQWLWpGHWH[WHVTXLIDLWGXFRUSXVpWUXVTXHO·XQGHVSOXVULFKHVGHVODQJXHVDQFLHQQHVGXPRQGH
FODVVLTXH GXVWULFWSRLQWGHYXHTXDQWLWDWLIHQHIIHWLODUULYHjODWURLVLqPHSODFHDSUqVOHVFRUSXVJUHFHWODWLQ 
RQQHVDLWTXHWURSELHQTXHOOHVVRQWOHVOLPLWHVHWOHVFRQWUDLQWHVTX·LOLPSRVHjQRWUHFRQQDLVVDQFHGHODODQJXH
pWUXVTXH&HOOHFLTXDVLPHQWLVROpHGXSRLQWGHYXHJpQpDORJLTXH OHWVXIILVDPPHQWGLIIpUHQWHGHVODQJXHVLQGR
HXURSpHQQHVSRXUTX·RQVRLWHQGURLWGHODFODVVHUjSDUWRSSRVHHQFRUHGHQRPEUHXVHVUpVLVWDQFHVDX[VDYDQWV
'DQVFHVFRQGLWLRQVLOQ·HVWSDVpWRQQDQWTXHODSKRQRORJLHHWODPRUSKRV\QWD[HDSSDUDLVVHQWFRPPHOHVGR
PDLQHVGHODODQJXHpWUXVTXHOHVPLHX[FRQQXVDORUVTXHOHOH[LTXHHVWOXLGHPDQLqUHVDQVGRXWHLUUpPpGLDEOH
FRQGDPQpjUHVWHU$!--(%#)465)#$('HIDLWRQHVWHQPHVXUHDXMRXUG·KXLGHUHFRQVWLWXHUDYHFXQFHUWDLQGHJUpGH
SUpFLVLRQHWGHILQHVVHXQWDEOHDXGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOUHODWLYHPHQWFRPSOH[HTXLWpPRLJQHGHVSURJUqVTXLRQW
pWpIDLWVGDQVQRWUHFRQQDLVVDQFHGHODPRUSKRV\QWD[HGXQRPGHSXLVOHVGpEXWVGHO·pWUXVFRORJLHOLQJXLVWLTXH
3RXUQRWUHSDUWQRXVQRXVSHQFKHURQVVXUXQSRLQWSDUWLFXOLHUGHODPRUSKRV\QWD[HpWUXVTXHO·DFFRUGHQFDV:%
GDQVOHVV\QWDJPHVQRPLQDX[/DTXHVWLRQGHO·DFFRUGSRXUUDSDUDvWUHjSUHPLqUHYXHVHFRQGDLUHQRXVYHUURQV

3UpFLVLRQVWHUPLQRORJLTXHVRQDSSHOOH´DEVROXWLIµVXUOHPRGqOH FROORTXHGH &LXUOHWWLHW0DU]DWLFR  /DODQJXHSUpKHO

SURSRVpSDU/$JRVWLQLDQL GqV$JRVWLQLDQLI ODIRUPHSULVH
SDU OHV VXEVWDQWLIV HW OHV DGMHFWLIV FDUDFWpULVpH SDU OH VXIIL[H ¡
ORUVTX·LOVDVVXPHQWOHVIRQFWLRQVGH6XMHWHW2EMHW FHFDVUHFRXYUH
GRQFOHQRPLQDWLIHWO·DFFXVDWLIGHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV (Q
UHYDQFKHSRXUOHVSURQRPVQRXVGLVWLQJXRQVSURSUHPHQWOHQRPL
QDWLI VXII¡ GHO·DFFXVDWLI VXIIM)2%M)# /·DVWpULVTXH PDUTXHXQH
IRUPHLQFRUUHFWHRXXQHV\QWD[HDJUDPPDWLFDOHWDQGLVTXHOHGRXEOH
DVWpULVTXH LQGLTXHXQHIRUPHRXXQV\QWDJPHQRQDWWHVWpVPDLV
FRUUHFWVGXSRLQWGHYXHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXH/HVDEUpYLDWLRQVDX[
TXHOOHVQRXVUHFRXURQVVRQWFHOOHVHQXVDJHGDQVOHVSXEOLFDWLRQVGH
OLQJXLVWLTXH$GM DGMHFWLI $UW DUWLFOH 'pW GpWHUPLQDQWGXQRP 
'pP GpPRQVWUDWLI 1XP QXPpUDO 1 QRP 3RVWS SRVWSRVLWLRQ 
3UpW SUpWpULW 3UVW SUpVHQW 61 V\QWDJPHQRPLQDO 1RXVDMRX
WHURQVWRXWHIRLVjFHWWHOLVWHOHVVLJOHV31SRXUSUpQRPHW*SRXU
JHQWLOLFH
O
'HX[´ODQJXHVµVRQWFODLUHPHQWDSSDUHQWpHVjO·pWUXVTXH /H
UpWLTXHDWWHVWpSDUXQHFHQWDLQHG·LQVFULSWLRQVGXQRUGGHO·,WDOLH
UpJLRQGX7UHQWLQ+DXW$GLJH7\UROPpULGLRQDO HWGRQWODSUR[L
PLWpDYHFO·pWUXVTXHpWDLWHQFRUHFRQQXHSDUOHV$QWLTXDLUHVGHOD
ILQGHOD5pSXEOLTXHYRLUHHQFRUHHIIHFWLYHPHQWSHUoXHVLO·RQHQ
FURLWOHWpPRLJQDJHGH7LWH/LYHGDQVVRQIDPHX[H[FXUVXVVXUOHV
SHXSOHVGHV$OSHV /LY9<.I#)#0%X16X1!%!(%5!)$#&10%+(1"%"1&#!%
6-#56%!0$>VFLOO·RULJLQHGHVeWUXVTXHV@>(]#>!%K(!$#02%X160%.64(%#I0(%
!::!-(-1)$%)!%X1#"%!]%()$#X16%I-(!$!-%06)1>%.#)51(!%)!4%!1>%#)46--1I$1>%
-!$#)!-!)$YRLUpJDOHPHQWSRXUGHVWpPRLJQDJHVSOXVWDUGLIVUHPRQ
WDQWSUREDEOHPHQWDX[PrPHVVRXUFHV-XVW;;3OLQBO2%***2%OQQ%
HWODJORVHG·eWLHQQHGH%\]DQFHGDQVVHV8$+)#=(ྦྷǓԆࠗ‫ڗ‬໅ਟࠞ࿰‫ٗݰݰ‬ဎԆ໵཮ဎ
ํ۟ဎ‫ ߥڗ‬³VXUOHV5KqWHVHWOHXUODQJXHYRLU5L[HWOHVDFWHVGX
OpQLTXHGRFXPHQWpHSDUODVWqOHGH.DPLQLDXQHLQVFULSWLRQODSL
GDLUHGpFRXYHUWHUpFHPPHQWHWTXHOTXHVDXWUHVJUDIILWHVVXUO·vOHGH
/HPQRVDXQRUGGHODPHUeJpHDORQJWHPSVpWpFRQVLGpUpHFRPPH
OHUHSUpVHQWDQWG·XQHEUDQFKHGXJURXSH´W\UUKpQLHQµSDUDOOqOHDX
W\UUKpQLHQG·,WDOLH VXUFHWWHWKqVHYRLU5L[DYHFELEOLRJUD
SKLH 3RXUG·DXWUHVFHSHQGDQWOHOHPQLHQQHVHUDLWTX·XQGLDOHFWH
GHO·pWUXVTXHFRQWLQHQWDOLPSODQWpVXUO·vOHSDUODVXLWHGHPLJUDWLRQV
GH´SLUDWHVµjO·DXEHGHODWUDGLWLRQKLVWRULTXH F·HVWODWKqVHGpYH
ORSSpHSDU&'H6LPRQH'H6LPRQHLGHPD²ELGHP 
HOOHQ·HQFRQVWLWXHUDLWSDVPRLQVXQGLDOHFWHRXXQHODQJXH´V±XUµ
GHO·pWUXVTXHSURSUHPHQWGLW
:
1RXVSUHQRQVOHSDUWLDYHFODJUDPPDLUHWUDGLWLRQQHOOHGHFRQVL
GpUHU TXH OH FDV HVW DX PrPH WLWUH TXH OH JHQUH OH QRPEUH HW
G·DXWUHVWUDLWVXQHGHVFDWpJRULHVPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHVFRQFHUQpHV
=67%>T(446-"DORUVPrPHTXHEHDXFRXSGHOLQJXLVWHVDXMRXUG·KXL
WHQGHQWjGLVWLQJXHUGHO·DFFRUG DQJO(5-!!>!)$ SURSUHPHQWGLW
OHVSKpQRPqQHVGHUHFWLRQ DQJO56?!-)>!)$ HWjIDLUHGXFDVXQ
WUDLW´LQGLUHFWHPHQWµFRQFHUQpSDUO·DFFRUG VXUFHSRLQWYRLUOD
ERQQHSUpVHQWDWLRQIDLWHSDU**&RUEHWWGDQV&RUEHWW²
²HW² /DVLWXDWLRQHVWFHSHQGDQWPRLQVFODLUHTX·LOQ·\
SDUDvWDLQVLGDQVXQV\QWDJPHGXW\SH#)%IRU‫گ‬ERčUL‫گ‬RQSHXWFHUWHV
HVWLPHUTXHODPDUTXHG·DEOHVWpWHQGXHjO·$GMHQYHUWXGHODIRQF
WLRQGX5HODWHXU#)PDLVO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQWUDGLWLRQQHOOHRERčUL‫گ‬%
HVWLQGpSHQGDPPHQWGHODVWUXFWXUHV\QWD[LTXHGDQVODTXHOOHHVW
LQVpUpOHVXEVWDQWLISUpFLVpPHQWDFFRUGpjIRU‫گ‬DXPrPHWLWUHTX·LO
HVWDFFRUGpHQJHQUHHWHQQRPEUH GpVLQHQFHV\QWKpWLTXH Q·HVW
SDVSRXUDXWDQWjpFDUWHU&·HVWSRXUTXRLQRXVFRQVLGqUHURQVGDQV
QRWUHpWXGHTXHOHFDVHVWXQHFDWpJRULHFRQFHUQpHjSDUWHQWLqUH
SDUO·DFFRUG

QPP
 oi.uchicago.edu

<??% DL%T<B%O88A7

TX·HOOHHVWDXFRQWUDLUHXQpOpPHQWFHQWUDOVRUWHGHSLHUUHGHWRXFKHDXPR\HQGHODTXHOOHSXLVTXHO·RQSHXW
GpILQLUO·DFFRUGFRPPHXQFDVSDUWLFXOLHUGH-!4$#6)WRXVOHVDVSHFWVGHODV\QWD[HGXQRPSRXUURQWrWUHDERUGpV
GHVUDSSRUWVVWULFWHPHQWV\QWD[LTXHVDX[TXHVWLRQVSOXVGpOLFDWHVGHVUHODWLRQVGLDFKURQLTXHVHWV\QFKURQLTXHV
HQWUHOHVPRUSKqPHVFDVXHOVHWOHVDGSRVLWLRQVHQpWUXVTXHODQJXHTXLSHXWDSSRUWHUQRXVHVVDLHURQVGHOHPRQ
WUHUXQpFODLUDJHLQWpUHVVDQWVXUOHVSUREOqPHVGHJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQ
'DQVFHWWHSHUVSHFWLYHQRXVFKHUFKHURQVG·DERUGjGpWHUPLQHUO·H[WHQVLRQGHO·DFFRUGHQpWUXVTXHHQQRXV
IRQGDQWVXUXQFRUSXVDXVVLFRPSOHWTXHSRVVLEOHDILQGHGpJDJHUODQRUPHHQPDWLqUHG·DFFRUGFDVXHO(QVXLWH
QRXVQRXVLQWpUHVVHURQVSOXVSDUWLFXOLqUHPHQWjGHX[W\SHVG·pFDUWVjFHWWHQRUPHTXHQRXVGRFXPHQWHQWOHV
LQVFULSWLRQVpWUXVTXHV

AB(,C:D9E@<9(=D(FGH??<;=
4;IED9:H:@<9(=>(?<;J>E
1RWUHUHFKHUFKHVHIRQGHVXUXQFRUSXVSDUDGR[DOHPHQWjODIRLVDPSOHHWWUqVUHVWUHLQWRQVDLWTXHOHFRU
SXVpWUXVTXHDXQFRQWHQXHVVHQWLHOOHPHQWRQRPDVWLTXHSXLVTXHO·pFUDVDQWHPDMRULWpGHVLQVFULSWLRQVTXLQRXV
VRQWSDUYHQXHVVRQWVRLWGHVpSLWDSKHVVRLWGHVLQVFULSWLRQVGHGRQGHGpGLFDFHRXGHSURSULpWpWRXVWH[WHVTXL
VRQWFHQWUpVDXWRXUG·XQQRP QRPGXGpIXQWQRPGXSURSULpWDLUHQRPGXGpGLFDQWRXQRPGXGRQDWHXUHWGX
GHVWLQDWDLUHGXGRQ 2UpWDQWGRQQpTXHOHV\VWqPHRQRPDVWLTXHpWUXVTXHHVWFRPPHF·HVWODQRUPHDXSUqVGH
SUHVTXHWRXVOHVSHXSOHVGHOD3pQLQVXOHXQV\VWqPHJHQWLOLFHF·HVWjGLUHTX·LOMRLQWjO·DQFLHQQRPLQGLYLGXHO
GXV\VWqPHSDWURQ\PLTXHXQJHQWLOLFH ODWLQ)6>!)%5!)$#.! IL[HHWKpUpGLWDLUHHWTXHFHJHQWLOLFHSUHQGJpQpUDOH
PHQWODIRUPHG·XQDGMHFWLIDFFRUGpDXSUpQRPTXLHVWOHQR\DXV\QWD[LTXHGHODIRUPXOHRQRPDVWLTXHWRXWHVFHV
LQVFULSWLRQVQRXVRIIUHQWTXDQWLWpGHV\QWDJPHVQRPLQDX[GXW\SH´1$GMµ&HSHQGDQWRQVHWURPSHUDLWVLO·RQ
FUR\DLWTXHFHVV\QWDJPHVRQRPDVWLTXHVQRXVRIIUHQWXQWDEOHDXH[KDXVWLIGHO·DFFRUGQRPLQDOHQpWUXVTXHLOV
DSSDUDLVVHQWJpQpUDOHPHQWjO·DEVROXWLIRXSOXVUDUHPHQWDXJpQLWLIFHTXLIDLWTXHOHVDXWUHVFDVREOLTXHVVRQW
ELHQPRLQVGRFXPHQWpV4XDQWDX[V\QWDJPHVFRPSRVpVG·DSSHOODWLIVRXD\DQWXQHVWUXFWXUHGLIIpUHQWHGXW\SH´1
$GMµLOVVRQWHQUHYDQFKHH[WUrPHPHQWPRLQVQRPEUHX[(QFRQVpTXHQFHQRXVDYRQVSULVOHSDUWLGHUDVVHPEOHU
XQFRUSXVQRQH[KDXVWLIGXSRLQWGHYXHQXPpULTXH LOH€WpWpLPSRVVLEOHHWGHWRXWHIDoRQSHXLQWpUHVVDQWGH
UDVVHPEOHUWRXVOHVV\QWDJPHV´DQWKURSRQ\PLTXHVµ PDLVFRPSOHWGXSRLQWGHYXHW\SRORJLTXHDILQGHSUHQGUH
HQFRPSWHWRXVOHVW\SHVGHV\QWDJPHVQRPLQDX[DWWHVWpVDXPRLQVXQHIRLV/HFRUSXVXWLOHDpWpFODVVpVHORQOHV
SULQFLSHVVXLYDQWVOHSUHPLHUSULQFLSHUHWHQXHVWODSUpVHQFHRXQRQG·XQUHODWHXUHQO·RFFXUUHQFHSRXUOHVV\Q
WDJPHVQRPLQDX[ODSUpVHQFHG·XQHDGSRVLWLRQTXLHQpWUXVTXHHWFRQIRUPpPHQWjFHTX·HQVHLJQHODW\SRORJLH
GHVODQJXHVDJJOXWLQDQWHVSUHQGV\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWODIRUPHG·XQHSRVWSRVLWLRQ/HSUHPLHUJURXSHUDVVHPEOH
GRQFOHVV\QWDJPHVDXWRQRPHVRXGLUHFWHPHQWUpJLVSDUOHYHUEHHWOHVLQVFULSWLRQVVRQWHQVXLWHFODVVpHVVHORQ
ODVWUXFWXUHGXV\QWDJPH QRPEUHGHVpOpPHQWV HWODQDWXUHGHVPRGLILFDWHXUVGXQRP $GM'pP$UW1XP -H
IHUDLXQHSUpFLVLRQSDUOHWHUPHG·´DUWLFOHµRXGH´SURQRPDUWLFXOpµMHIDLVUpIpUHQFHLFLjO·HPSORLHQFOLWLTXH
GHVSURQRPVGpPRQVWUDWLIVM4(%JK%M$(GXSURQRPM0( DQDSKRULTXHHWRXGpPRQVWUDWLI Q³FHVWURLVSURQRPV
RQWSDUDOOqOHPHQWGHVHPSORLVWRQLTXHV³HWGXSURQRPM # ۭDTXLOXLQ·HVWSDVDWWHVWpHQGHKRUVGHVHVHPSORLV
FOLWLTXHV < YRLUHQDQQH[HOHWDEOHDXPRUSKRORJLTXHGHVSURQRPVDGMHFWLIVDUWLFXOpV *pQpUDOHPHQWO·DUWLFOH
VHUWjLQWURGXLUHXQPRGLILFDWHXUGXQRP$GMRX1HWFRQFRXUWDVVH]IUpTXHPPHQWjO·H[SUHVVLRQGHVpOpPHQWV
LQGLUHFWVGHODIRUPXOHRQRPDVWLTXHQRWDPPHQWjFHOOHGXSDWURQ\PHRXGXSDSSRQ\PH
R% YHO۟XUSDUWXQXV ODULVDOLۭD «
% 5+9<K% 4JpQ% 5+JpQ$UW9<K
 ´9HO۟XU3DUWXQXFHOXLGH/DULV«µ

Q
/DFRUUHFWHLGHQWLILFDWLRQGHFHSURQRPHVWXQHDFTXLVLWLRQUHODWL
YHPHQWUpFHQWH YRLUSRXUO·KLVWRLUHGHFHWWHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQ:\OLQ
² 1RXVQHSDUWDJHRQVQpDQPRLQVSDVO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQ
VpPDQWLTXHSURSRVpHSDU.:\OLQ ´#I0!µRX´#"!>µ SUpFLVpPHQWHQ
UDLVRQGHVHPSORLVHQFOLWLTXHVGHFHSURQRPTXLO·DSSDUHQWHQWSOXW{W
DX[GpPRQVWUDWLIV4(2%$(%JK%ۭD1RXVSHQFKHULRQVjWLWUHG·K\SRWKqVH
SRXUXQSURQRPSHUVRQQHOGHWURLVLqPHSHUVRQQHGRQWO·pWUXVTXH
DEHVRLQSRXUO·H[SUHVVLRQGHODSHUVRQQHSXLVTXHVDPRUSKRORJLH
YHUEDOHQHSUpYRLWSDVGHPDUTXHVGHSHUVRQQHVXUOHYHUEH
<
2QGRLWO·LGHQWLILFDWLRQHWO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHFHSURQRPj+5L[
FI5L[†
R
/HVUpIpUHQFHVGHFKDTXHH[HPSOHVRQWGRQQpHVGDQVOHVDQQH[HV
DYHF O·LQGLFDWLRQ GX VXSSRUW GX OLHX G·RULJLQH HW G·XQH GDWDWLRQ
DSSUR[LPDWLYH
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <33,KH%7\K%N8%HQ7<33,KH% <?O

% WLWHVYHOXV DUQ۟DOLۭOD

% 4JpQ%%%%%5+LI9% 5+JpQ$UWLI9
 ´ WRPEH GH9HO7LWH GH FHOXLG·$UQ۟µ
 IZ1@ۭ૎ Oӓ‫ؾ‬HL YHOD% ODU۟DO VHश DSXQDOF ODU۟LDO
% 4HFM% 5+HFM% 5+JpQ% +HFM% 4JpQFRRUG31JpQ
 ´ILOOHµ ´HWµ
 ´9HOD3XۭOLQHLILOOHGH/DU۟HWGH/DU۟L$SXQHL
DQLQDV YHO۟XUXV YHO۟XUXۭOD SXLD «
4LI9% 5+LI9% 5+JpQ$UWLI9% +HFM
 ´pSRXVHµ
pSRXVHGHJpQ9HO۟XU$QLQDFHOXLJpQGH9HO۟XUµ

/·HPSORLGHO·DUWLFXODWLRQDXQDYDQWDJHpYLGHQWLOSHUPHWG·pYLWHUO·DPELJXwWpUpIpUHQWLHOOHG·XQHVpTXHQFH
GHSOXVLHXUVJpQLWLIV

+GH??<;=(D9(?HE
8QHIRLVFHVTXHOTXHVSUpFLVLRQVIDLWHVRQSHXWHQWUHUSOXVDYDQWGDQVO·HQTXrWHTXLQRXVRFFXSH,OQHIDLW
SDVGHGRXWHTXHODFDWpJRULHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHODSOXVLPSOLTXpHSDUOHVSKpQRPqQHVG·DFFRUGHVWFHOOHGXFDV
DXSRLQWTXHO·RQHVWHQGURLWG·pGLFWHUODUqJOHVXLYDQWHFRQFHUQDQWO·DFFRUGjO·LQWpULHXUGXV\QWDJPHQRPLQDO

!"#$%&'()(*+,"-.#$'-$/&%0$1-"22"$1-"$#&(,$2"-.$/+,-."0$#3+**&.'"/,$"/$*+#$+4"*$2"$/&%$1-3(2#$%&'()("/,
&HWWHUqJOHVHYpULILHGDQVOHVV\QWDJPHVjGHX[pOpPHQWV´1$GMµHWjWRXVOHVFDVODQDWXUHGX1WrWHGH
V\QWDJPH QRPSURSUHRXQRPFRPPXQ QHFKDQJHSDVODVLWXDWLRQFRPPHOHSURXYHQWOHVH[HPSOHVVXLYDQWV
 QRP  PLQL P࡜‫ד‬YDQLFH 4"2۟-.$1-.,(/(("%
( 57FDFF% 1SUpW >31*@6D9
 ´9HO۟XU4XUWLQLLHP·DGRQQpµ
 DFF  >#L%% 4(I#L%l% 25$4".#/(5$2%ll
% >#L% 4(I#%l% OYHɅVQLۭ˧H%l «
( 57FHFM% 1=79K >31*@6D9
 ´-HFRQWLHQV/DU۟9HUVQL « µ
 JpQ  >#% 4"2۟-.6-#$#7+/"#/+6#> YHO۟XUVNDQHVQD@
( 57FHFM% >31*@JpQ
 ´-H VXLV GH9HO۟XU6NDQHVQD!-·DSSDUWLHQVj9HO۟XU6NDQHVQDµ
 SHUW  YHOXVL KXOशQLHVL> YHOKXOशQLH@
( >31*@=J7K
 DEO  PDUFHV WDUQHV UDP۟HVF शDLUHDOV%
% 5+6D>% 46D>% 5+6D>FRRUG *6D>> PDUFHWDUQDUDP۟DFशDLUHL@
 ´SDU@0DUFH7DUQDHW5DP۟DऺDLUHLµ
 JpQ  WLQߓLWLXULP +4(26#$ शLɍ%> DYLOशL@
% % +JpQ $GMSJpQ
 ´DXMRXUHWDXPRLVGHO·DQQpHशLY


3RXUODWUDGXFWLRQGHFHW\SHGHV\QWDJPHYRLU#):-(SS²
@
/HFDVDSSHOpJpQpUDOHPHQWDEODWLIHQpWUXVTXHUHSUpVHQWHGDQV
EHDXFRXSGHVHVHPSORLVXQDJHQWLI&·HVWOHFDVGDQVFHWWHLQVFULS
WLRQROHV\QWDJPHGpSHQGG·XQYHUEHIDU۟QDशHIOpFKLDXSDVVLI

&HOH[qPHSRXUUDLWpYHQWXHOOHPHQWDSSDUWHQLUjODFODVVHGHVGp
WHUPLQDQWVGXQRPQRWDPPHQWDX[LQGpILQLV शL ´FKDTXHWRXWµ
FRPPHGpMjOHSURSRVDLW$7RUSDXGpEXWGX;; JVLqFOHFI7RUS
7URPEHWWL† 0DLVOHVSURSRVLWLRQVG·LQWHUSUp
WDWLRQFRPPHYpULWDEOHDGMHFWLITXDOLILFDWLIQHPDQTXHQWSDVQRXV
UDSSHOOHURQVODWUDGXFWLRQ´#10$10µSURSRVpHSDU(*ROGPDQQ *ROG
PDQQHW TXLDFRQQXUpFHPPHQWXQUHJDLQG·LQWpUrW
FI&RORQQDQTXLGRQQHDXPRWXQVHQV5#1-#"#46M
0(4-(.! (QGHUQLHUOLHXVXUFHPRWYRLU%HOILRUH²0DLV
ODQDWXUHGXOH[qPHFRPPHQRXVOHYHUURQVQ·DSDVG·LQFLGHQFHVXU
OHVSKpQRPqQHVG·DFFRUGTXLQRXVLQWpUHVVHQW
 oi.uchicago.edu

<?:% DL%T<B%O88A7

 ORFLQVWU  .1-M#% >.(4M!> OXUPODश"@

% +ORFLQVWU $GMORFLQVWU
 ´OH.1- " pWDQWEHDXERQµP
2QDMRXWHUDTX·RQSHXWWURXYHUjODSODFHGHO·$GMXQ1DSSRVpDFFRUGpDXVXEVWDQWLITX·LOPRGLILH
 DEV  2+.(#$ +42"% .(-#0M(.% *2"/6+. Mß % #4+2 Mß
( 5+6D9%% 5+6D9% 5+JpQ% +SODEV $GMS6D9
    ´ILOVµ ´YLYDQWµ
 FQ ۭ੩ X۟L FHULशXQFH «
 'pPDFF% +6D9% 1SUpW
   ´IDLUHpOHYHUIDLUHFRQVWUXLUHµ
 ´/DULV HW $YOHILOVGH/DULVGHOHXUYLYDQWO?RQWIDLWEkWLUFHWWHWRPEHµ
,OHQYDGHPrPHSRXUOHVV\QWDJPHV´'pW1µHQSDUWLFXOLHUDYHFOHGpPRQVWUDWLISRXUGpWHUPLQDQW
 QRP  *8/5$ 9(*5 ]LशXशH
( 'pPHFM% +6D9% 1
 ´&HWpFULWFLDpWppFULWµ
R4z)HVWXQGpPRQVWUDWLIHPSKDWLTXHIRUPpVXUODEDVHGH4(2
 DFF  ۟-/6*/$$ ۭ"666ۭ̂g% >(40$%l% G#.4% $!)1
( 1XP$UWDFF% +6D9% +6D9% +6D9% 1
 ´ ; DH[HUFpOHۭHۭFHOXLXQ SUHPLHU" ODPDJLVWUDWXUH>(40$ -!?4 ODPDJLVWUDWXUHG#.4
 QRP  "*+5$$ ۭ-۟(5 ODU۟DOWDUVDOXV VDFQLX
( 'pPHFM% +6D9 >31*JpQ@ 9
  ´WRPEHµ
 ´&HWWHWRPEHDpWpFRQVDFUpHj/DU۟µ
( QRP  $(%g% >1$)(%g% >(-4!M0%g%0I1-#)(M0
( 'pPHFM% +6D9 >31*@JpQ
  ´VDUFRSKDJHµ
 ´&HVDUFRSKDJH HVW GH0DUFH6SXULQDFHVDUFRSKDJHDSSDUWLHQWj06µ
PrPHVLGDQVFHVGHX[GHUQLHUVFDVQRWUHDQDO\VHV\QWDJPDWLTXHQ·HVWSDVODVHXOHSRVVLEOH2QSRXUUDLWHQHI
IHWDYRLUXQHVWUXFWXUHSUpGLFDWLYH´6SUpGLFDWQRPLQDOµOO´&HFL HVW ODWRPEHFRQVDFUpHj/DU۟µ´&HFL HVW 
OHVDUFRSKDJHGH0DUFH6SXULQDµ
/HFRUSXVpWUXVTXHQRXVIRXUQLWXQDVVH]JUDQGQRPEUHGHV\QWDJPHV´11XPµJUkFHHQSDUWLFXOLHUDX[
IRUPXODLUHVG·LQGLFDWLRQGHO·kJHGXGpIXQWjVDPRUW
 JpQ  DYLOV FLV ]D۟UPLVF
% +JpQ ´µJpQ ´µJpQFRRUG
 ´DQQpHµ
 ´ kJp GHDQVµ
(QILQRQGLVSRVHG·XQV\QWDJPHjWURLVpOpPHQWV´'pP1$GMµLQGXELWDEOHPHQWIOpFKLjO·DFFXVDWLIFRPPH
O·LQGLTXHQWjODIRLVODIOH[LRQGXSURQRPTXLUHoRLWXQHPDUTXHG·DFFXVDWLI M) HWODV\QWD[HGHODSURSRVLWLRQR
()RFFXSHODIRQFWLRQGHVXMHWHW(4(04!FHOOHGHYHUEHDXSUpWpULWDFWLI2QUHPDUTXHTXHOHVGHX[PRGLILFDWHXUVGH
]LशVRQWDFFRUGpVDYHFFHGHUQLHUPrPHVLOHVVROXWLRQVPRUSKRORJLTXHVSRXUH[SULPHUOHFDVDFFXVDWLIGLIIqUHQW
VHORQODFODVVHOH[LFDOHGHVPRGLILFDWHXUVOHV$GMVHGpFOLQHQWVXUOHPRGqOHGHVVXEVWDQWLIVHWQ·RQWSDVGHPDUTXH
GLVWLQFWLYHGHO·DFFXVDWLIWDQGLVTXHOHV'pPHWWRXVOHVSURQRPVO:PDUTXHQWFHFDVSDUXQVXIIL[HRXLQIL[HQDVDO

P
6XUFHW\SHG·DQDO\VHQRXVQRXVSHUPHWWRQVGHUHQYR\HUjYDQ
+HHPVVRXVSUHVVHD
O?
/DQDWXUHDGMHFWLYDOHGXOH[qPH0?(.Q·HVWSDVFHUWDLQH,OSRXU
UDLWV·DJLUG·XQHIRUPH´QRPLQDOHµGXYHUEH4XDQWDXSUREOqPHGH
O·DFFRUGHQQRPEUHTXLQ·HVWSDVV\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWPDUTXp 4.!)M(-%
YV0?(. YRLU#):-(
OO
&DUODFRSXOHHVWQRUPDOHPHQWVRXVMDFHQWHHQpWUXVTXHVXUOD
TXHVWLRQQRXVQRXVSHUPHWWRQVGHUHQYR\HUjYDQ+HHPV
O:
$LQVLSHXWrWUHTXHOHQXPpUDOGHO·XQLWp۟XGRQW۟XQ%=FL7768K%
rWUHO·DFFXVDWLI3RXUFHWWHK\SRWKqVHYRLUYDQ+HHPV
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <33,KH%7\K%N8%HQ7<33,KH% <?Q

( DFF  FQ ]Lश QHۭ۟UDF

 'pPDFF% +6D9 $GM6D9
  ´pFULWµ ´UHODWLIjO·KDUXVSLFLQHµ
 ´FHWpFULWG·KDUXVSLFLQHµ
(QILQRQHVWDXWRULVpjFRQFOXUHTXHO·DFFRUGHQFDVDELHQSRXUU{OHGHVRXOLJQHUODFRKpUHQFHV\QWDJPDWLTXH
SDUOHFRPSRUWHPHQWGHVV\QWDJPHVQRPLQDX[UpJLVSDUGHVSRVWSRVLWLRQV
´ORFLQVWU۟LY% FLO۟FYHWL KLODUH > FLO۟FYDLWLKLODUDL@
% +SOORFLQVWUSRVWSOQ $GMORFLQVWU
 ´GDQVOHVFLWDGHOOHV¬+#.(- " µ
/DQDWXUHDGMHFWLYDOHGH+#.(-HVWUHQGXHIRUWSUREDEOHSDUVRQRFFXUUHQFHFRPPHPRGLILFDWHXUGH$1.(-´ERUQH
IURQWLqUHµGDQVOHV\QWDJPHWXODUKLODUQHۭੜ OVXUXQFLSSHGH&KLXVLO<PrPHVLO·RQQHSHXWIRUPHOOHPHQWH[FOXUH
TX·LOV·DJLVVHG·XQVXEVWDQWLI2QWURXYHpJDOHPHQWGDQVXQHLQVFULSWLRQVXUXQVDUFRSKDJHGH&HUYHWHULORGHX[
V\QWDJPHVSRVWSRVLWLRQQHOVTXLQRXVFRQILUPHQWVDQVpTXLYRTXHFHU{OHMRXpSDUOHPRUSKqPHFDVXHOSRXUDV
VXUHUODFRKpUHQFHV\QWDJPDWLTXH
 ORFSRVW  ?!)!.%g%$(>0)#!0%()%% 9(2*6($$ %-/(6*2"6,%>@-#(.%(-10#()4!%
% % +F<?M@9E:; $GM$UWF<?M@9E:;SRVWS
  ´I-(!$1-(µ ´"µ
$ :-9./"۟($ *+(#.(4ė(%()%g%.(-#0DŽOࠃDPVQLHVDUXVP‫ؾ‬DO%W%۟DQशY૎>#.1@ߙF૎FZ.()%g@(Z>4!@
% +F<?M@9E:;SRVWS $GMF<?M@9E:;
 ´"µ ´FpULWHµ
´9HQHO7DPVQLHTXLDXFRXUVGHODPDJLVWUDWXUHG#.4%>1)#M4( OLWW´GDQVOHG#.4FHOXL>1)# D
IDLWWHOOHDFWLRQ (-10#()4! M-#(. " GDQVOD+1G-)(GH&DHUp HW TXLDpWpILOVGH/DULV7DPVQLH
HWGH$UXVPHL݅DQशYLOµ
/·pWUXVTXHFRPPHQRPEUHG·DXWUHVODQJXHVHWQRXVQHQRXVHQpWRQQHURQVSDVFRQIqUHDX[VXIIL[HVFDVXHOV
OHU{OHGHPDUTXHUODFRKpUHQFHV\QWDJPDWLTXH/jRHQUHYDQFKHO·pWUXVTXHGLIIqUHGHVODQJXHVIOH[LRQQHOOHV
F·HVWGDQVVDFDSDFLWpjpWHQGUHFHWWHPDUTXHIOH[LRQQHOOHG·DFFRUGjXQGHUQLHUW\SHGHPRGLILFDWHXUGXQRPOH
JpQLWLIDGQRPLQDO/·H[WHQVLRQGHFHGHUQLHUHQpWUXVTXHHVWJUDQGHGXPRLQVjO·pFKHOOHGHFHTXHQRXVODLVVH
HQWUHYRLUGHODODQJXHOHFRUSXVGLVSRQLEOHHWSOXVG·XQLQGLFHVXJJqUHTX·LOHVWOHVWULFWpTXLYDOHQWV\QWD[LTXH
HWVpPDQWLTXHG·XQDGMHFWLIGHUHODWLRQ$LQVLRQUHQFRQWUHGHVV\QWDJPHVRXQDGMHFWLIGHUHODWLRQHQM)(%J9K%
FRRUGRQQpjXQJpQLWLIDGQRPLQDOFRPPHHQ8*7DOX۟FYDFD۟DVSDशDQDFTXLUHQYRLHjGHVREMHWV OX۟FYD 
DSSDUWHQDQWj&D۟D GLYLQLWp HWDX[%DFFKDQWV SDशDQD´UHODWLIDX [ %DFFKDQW V µ O@2URQREVHUYHTX·XQJp
QLWLIDGQRPLQDOSHXWHQYHUWXGHVSRVVLELOLWpVTX·RIIUHODPRUSKRORJLHDJJOXWLQDQWHUHFHYRLUODPDUTXHFDVXHOOH
REOLTXHGXVXEVWDQWLITX·LOPRGLILH&·HVWFHTXHUpYqOHQWSOXVLHXUVV\QWDJPHVIOpFKLVjFHTXHQRXVDYRQVSURSRVp
G·DSSHOHUO·LQVWUXPHQWDODEVROX/HVPLHX[FRQQXVG·HQWUHHX[VRQWFHTX·RQDLGHQWLILpGHSXLVORQJWHPSVFRPPH
GHVIRUPXOHVGHGDWDWLRQSDUPDJLVWUDWVpSRQ\PHVGXW\SH

OQ
%M4?(HVWODIRUPHG·DEVGXPRUSKqPHGHSOXULHOSRXUOHVQRPV
PDUTXpVGXWUDLW>DQLPpKXPDLQ@HWM#ODPDUTXHGXORFDWLILQVWUX
PHQWDOO·pYROXWLRQGHODGLSKWRQJXHD M!H VDQVGRXWHRXYHUW 
UHQGLOOLVLEOHHQV\QFKURQLHO·DJJOXWLQDWLRQGHVPDUTXHVjO·RULJLQH
ELHQGLVWLQFWHV/DUHFRQVWUXFWLRQGLDFKURQLTXHTXHQRXVSURSRVRQV
HQWUHFURFKHWVH[SOLFLWHODIRUPDWLRQGHFHV\QWDJPHSRVWSRVLWLRQQHO
O<
&I8*&O
OR
1RXVDGRSWRQVSRXUFHVDUFRSKDJHGHODWRPEHGHV7DPVQLHOHV
GHX[OHFWXUHVSURSRVpHVVXFFHVVLYHPHQWSDU$0DJJLDQL G·DERUG
0DJJLDQLQSXLV0DJJLDQL 

/HUDSSURFKHPHQWDYHFKXۭXUKXۭੜ LXU ´HQIDQWVµ TXLDFRQGXLWFHU
WDLQVVDYDQWVjSURSRVHUXQHWUDGXFWLRQSDU´MHXQHVVHµQRXVVHPEOH
LQIRQGpSRXUGHVUDLVRQVIRUPHOOHV SDVVDJHGHۭ!j]! /·RFFXU
UHQFHVXUOHVDUFRSKDJHGH9HQHO7DPVQLHSRXUUDLWVXJJpUHUXQH
YDOHXU´LQVWLWXWLRQQHOOHµVDQVTX·LOVRLWSRVVLEOHG·rWUHSOXVSUpFLV
O@
 /D GLYLQLWp 4( ? ۟D DUF FDYD۟D  HVW IUpTXHPPHQW DVVRFLpH DX[
%DFFKDQWVj7DUTXLQLDYRLUHQFRUHO·pSLWDSKHGH/DU۟6WDWODQHGH
7XVFDQLD 8* $7   TXL SRUWH OH WLWUH GHPDUXSDशD۟XUDVFD۟VF2%
F·HVWjGLUHGH>(-1 PDJLVWUDW GHV%DFFKDQWVHWGH&D۟DRQPDQTXH
G·XQHpWXGHG·HQVHPEOHGHFHWWHGLYLQLWpGRQWOHVDWWHVWDWLRQVpSL
JUDSKLTXHVVHVRQWUpFHPPHQWQHWWHPHQWDFFUXHVJUkFHDX[IRXLOOHV
GH3\UJL4XDQWjSDशDTX·RQDSHQGDQWORQJWHPSVYRXOXFRQVLGpUHU
FRPPHODIRUPHpWUXVTXLVpHGXWKpRQ\PHJUHFɃඥ໵श‫ߥڗ‬HQGpSLWGH
ODGLIILFXOWpIRUPHOOH RQDWWHQGUDLWODIRUPH SDशH LOGRLWV·DJLUVRLW
GHO·HPSUXQWGXJUHFIpPɃඥ໵शථ DWWɃඥ໵शٗ ´EDFFKDQWHµ DYHF
H[WHQVLRQGHODGpVLJQDWLRQDX[GHX[VH[HV VRLWG·XQHpODERUDWLRQ
DXWRQRPHHQpWUXVTXH FODVVHGHQRPVDQLPpVHQM("8WLOLVDWLRQGX
VXIIL[HM(FDUM!VHUYDLWGpMjjGpVLJQHUOHGLHX" 

6XUODPLVHHQpYLGHQFHGHFHWRXUHWVRQLQWHUSUpWDWLRQFIYDQ
+HHPVVRXVSUHVVHD
 oi.uchicago.edu

<?<% DL%T<B%O88A7

 LQVWUDEV  G#.46(%% ?!.M106(KXOशQLHV6(

% +ORFLQVWU >31*@JpQORFLQVWU
2QGRLWj+5L[OHPpULWHG·DYRLUDWWLUpO·DWWHQWLRQVXUFH´FDVµDSSDUHPPHQWELPRUSKpPDWLTXHTX·LODDS
SHOp´SHUWLQHQWLIµHWDXTXHOLODGRQQpHQWUHDXWUHVIRQFWLRQVXQHYDOHXUGDWLYH %pQpILFLDLUHGHO·DFWLRQ ,O
WUDGXLVDLWDLQVLFHVIRUPXOHVGRQWRQDGHWUqVQRPEUHX[H[HPSOHVFRPPHXQORFDWLI G#.4# VXLYLGXQRPGHOD
RXGHVSHUVRQQHVFRQFHUQpHV ODWLQI!-$#)!-! ´GDQVDXFRXUVGHODSUpWXUHFRQFHUQDQW9+µ1RXVSURSRVHULRQV
XQHDQDO\VHOpJqUHPHQWGLIIpUHQWHHQJUDQGHSDUWLHSDUFHTXHOHVIRUPHVHQM#FRPPHG#.4M#QHVRQWSDVGHYpUL
WDEOHVORFDWLIVDORUVTX·HQpWUXVTXHGXPRLQVjpSRTXHKLVWRULTXHODIRQFWLRQORFLQHVVLIQ·HVWSOXVH[SULPpH
VDXISRXUTXHOTXHVDUFKDwVPHVTXHSDUODSRVWSRVLWLRQ۟LUpJLVVDQWFHFDVHQM#,OQRXVVHPEOHSOXW{WTXHQRXV
DYRQVDIIDLUHjXQWRXUV\QWD[LTXHpTXLYDOHQWDX[JpQLWLIHWDEODWLIDEVROXVGXJUHFHWGXODWLQ]LOFLYHOXVLKXOशQLHVL%
VHUDLWGDQVFHVFRQGLWLRQVODWUDQVSRVLWLRQHQVXERUGLQDWLRQGXV\QWDJPHOLEUH jO·DEVROXWLI  ]LOFYHOXVKXOशQLHV2%
TXLGRLWVHWUDGXLUHSXLVTXHODFRSXOHQ·HVWUpJXOLqUHPHQWSDVH[SULPpHHQpWUXVTXHSDU´ODSUpWXUH pWDQW GH
9HO+XOशQLHµ/RUVGHODWUDQVSRVLWLRQjO·LQVWUXPHQWDOODPDUTXHM#YLHQWpJDOHPHQWV·DGMRLQGUHDXJURXSHDX
JpQLWLISRXUPDUTXHUODFRKpUHQFHGXV\QWDJPH]LOFLYHOXVLKXOशQLHVL&HPDUTXDJHQ·HVWSDVREOLJDWRLUHFRPPH
O·LQGLTXHQWOHVTXHOTXHVIRUPXOHVGHGDWDWLRQROHQRPGXPDJLVWUDWUHVWHDXJpQ
 LQVWUDEV OP
% ODU۟DO6"ODSLFDQ̩ZM0@6(YFؐDUXQXF6(> ODU۟DOD6(%.(I#4()!M06(@
 ´6RXVOH¶PDURQDW·GH/DU۟/DSLFDQHILOVGH9HOµ
 LQVWUDEV  G#.46(ODU۟DOFXۭੜ XߓWLWLQDOODULVDOFۭੜ DOLQLߓDXOHۭ૎ OD
 ´6RXVOD¶SUpWXUH·GH/DU۟&XۭੜXGH7LWLQHLHWGH/DULVমDOLQLFHOXLG·$XOHµ
&HVGHX[WRXUVVRQWFODLUHPHQWpTXLYDOHQWV+5L[DYRXOXH[SOLTXHUOHWRXUDXJpQLWLIFRPPHO·HIIHWG·XQH
FRQWDPLQDWLRQGHVODQJXHVLWDOLTXHVHWODWLQRIDOLVTXHV:?DORUVTXHO·DXWUHVHUDLWSURSUHPHQWYHUQDFXODLUHPDLV
LOHVWSRXUOHPRLQVGpOLFDWYXQRVPDLJUHVFHUWLWXGHVVXUODV\QWD[HGHO·pWUXVTXHGHWLUHUGHWHOOHVFRQFOXVLRQV
/HVGHX[WRXUQXUHVVHODLVVDQWELHQFRPSUHQGUHQRXVQRXVDVWUHLQGURQVSRXUOHPRPHQWjOHVSRVHUFRPPH
VWULFWHPHQWpTXLYDOHQWHVHWWRXWHVGHX[FRUUHFWHV1RXVVRXOLJQHURQVHQUHYDQFKHGHX[SRLQWV LOHVWLQWpUHV
VDQWGHFRQVWDWHUTXHOHJpQLWLIDGQRPLQDOHVWWUDLWpGXSRLQWGHYXHV\QWD[LTXHH[DFWHPHQWFRPPHXQ$GM OH
WRXUROHPRUSKqPHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOHVWpWHQGXjWRXVOHVpOpPHQWVGXV\QWDJPHPrPHTXDQGLOVVRQWGpMjGRWpV
G·XQHPDUTXHFDVXHOOHSURSUHUHQWUHSDUIDLWHPHQWGDQVOHFDGUHG·XQHPRUSKRORJLHDJJOXWLQDQWH:O

;-,."#$*+,<=&.("#$*&/*"./<"#$>+.$23+**&.'
/HFDVQ·HVWSDVODVHXOHFDWpJRULHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHjrWUHFRQFHUQpHSDUOHVSKpQRPqQHVG·DFFRUGLQWUDV\Q
WDJPDWLTXH3RXUOHQRPEUHRQVDLWGHSXLVOHVWUDYDX[TXH/$JRVWLQLDQLDFRQVDFUpVjODTXHVWLRQTXHODVLWXD
WLRQHVWUHQGXHDVVH]FRPSOH[HSDUO·LQWHUYHQWLRQGHO·pFKHOOHG·KXPDQLWXGH&HVDYDQWDHQHIIHWPRQWUpTXHOHV
V\QWDJPHVDXSOXULHODYDLHQWXQFRPSRUWHPHQWGLIIpUHQWVHORQTX·LOVpWDLHQWPDUTXpVRXQRQGXWUDLW>KXPDLQ@
RX>DQLPp@ OHVVXEVWDQWLIVPDUTXpVGHFHWUDLWSUHQQHQWV\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWODPDUTXHGHSOXULHOTXLOHXUHVW
UpVHUYpH M- WDQGLVTXHODPDUTXHशYDGHVVXEVWDQWLIVQRQKXPDLQVRXLQDQLPpVHVWIDFXOWDWLYHHWGpSHQGHQ
RXWUHGHFULWqUHVWDFWLTXHVFRPPHRQOHYRLWjODOHFWXUHGHO·LQVFULSWLRQVXLYDQWH 8*7D:: 
 PHࠃOLDUQ۟LSXLDDPFHVSLࠃXVODU۟DOVYDOFHDYLO/;,,,,FLFOHQDUDF૎‫ؾ‬ĤQDVDUFH
RO·RQDGHX[V\QWDJPHVjO·DFF´11XPµ GDQVXQHVpTXHQFHGLIIpUHQWH (?#.%Ni////%JK%4#%4.!)(-PDLVRXQVHXOGHV
VXEVWDQWLIVHVWPDUTXpFRPPHSOXULHO4.!)(-DEVSOXUGH4.()´ILOVµ(?#.´DQQpHµDXFRQWUDLUHQ·HVWSDVPDUTXp
GXSRLQWGHYXHGXQRPEUHTXRLTX·LOVRLWVDQVOHPRLQGUHGRXWHDXSOXULHO2QQRWHUDHQUHYDQFKHTXHFRPPH
RQSHXWV·\DWWHQGUHOHVQXPpUDX[VXSpULHXUVj´µQ·RQWSDVGHPDUTXHVSpFLILTXHGXSOXULHO0DOKHXUHXVHPHQW

OP
1RXVQRXVUpIpURQVjODQRXYHOOHOHFWXUHLQILQLPHQWSOXVVDWLVIDL
VDQWHTXHFHOOHGHODSUHPLqUHpGLWLRQGXWH[WH (%HQHOOLLQK88%RR2%
²QSS² UHSURSRVpHSDUO·pGLWHXULQ%HQHOOL
QSS²
:?
5L[
:O
&HSKpQRPqQHG·DFFXPXODWLRQGHVXIIL[HVHVWELHQGRFXPHQWp
2QSHXWFLWHUSRXUXQSDUDOOqOHH[RWLTXHHWLQWpUHVVDQWOHFDVGX
ND\DUGLOGXQHODQJXHDERULJqQHG·$XVWUDOLH JURXSHWDQNLTXHIDPLOOH
3DPD1\XQJDQ 1RXVUHQYR\RQVHQSDUWLFXOLHUDX[H[HPSOHVHWUpIp
UHQFHVSUpVHQWpVGDQV&RUEHWW²HW²HQSDUWLFXOLHUOD
SKUDVH  RODPDUTXHG·LQVWUXPHQWDOV·DGMRLQWjFHOOHGHO·DEODWLI
TXLPDUTXHGDQVFHWWHODQJXHOHSRVVHVVHXU SRXULQWURGXLUHOHFRP
SOpPHQWG·XQQRPIOpFKLjO·LQVWUXPHQWDO
::
,QVFULWHVXUOHVPXUVGHODWRPEHGHV6SLWXj7DUTXLQLD
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <33,KH%7\K%N8%HQ7<33,KH% <?R

SRXUOHVDXWUHVPRGLILFDWHXUVGXQRPLOHVWGLIILFLOHGHVHSURQRQFHUVXUOHFDUDFWqUHREOLJDWRLUHRXIDFXOWDWLIGH
O·DFFRUGHQQRPEUHFDURQQ·DSDVGHV\QWDJPHV´1$GMµFHUWDLQHPHQWDXSOXULHO2QDELHQODVpTXHQFHPXQLVYOH۟
4(.101-(0#GDQVXQHLQVFULSWLRQGHODWRPEHGHV$OH۟QDGH0XVDUQD:QRPXQLVYOH۟HVWXQDGMHFWLIDUWLFXOpDX
SOXULHO LQIL[HM?l1M HWIOpFKLDXORFLQVWUSDUODSRVWSRVLWLRQ۟HWRO·RQUHFRQQDvWGDQV4(.10M1-M(0M#%>J%MF7
SKqPHGHSOXULHOM-PDLVRQGRLWLFLrWUHGDQVOHFDVYXSOXVKDXWROHVXIIL[HM#GHORFLQVWUHVWpWHQGXjWRXV
OHVpOpPHQWVGXV\QWDJPHHWQRWDPPHQWDXJpQSOXUj4(.101-(0FRPSOpPHQWGHO·DGMHFWLIVXEVWDQWLYpPXQLVYOH۟
/·HQVHPEOHGRLWGRQFVHFRPSUHQGUHjQRWUHDYLVFRPPH´GDQVOHVFKRVHV>1)#GHV&DOXVXUµ:<OHV&DOXVXUpWDQW
XQJURXSHGHGLYLQLWpVUHODWLYHPHQWELHQGRFXPHQWp:RHWQRQFRPPH´GDQVSDUPLOHV&DOXVXUFHX[>1)#L%&H%HJ%
SHXWSDUFRQVpTXHQWSURSRVHUGHFRQFOXVLRQVV€UHVSRXUO·DFFRUGHQQRPEUHPDLVLOHVWSUREDEOHTX·LOHVWVRX
PLVDX[PrPHVUHVWULFWLRQVTXHO·pFKHOOHG·KXPDQLWXGHRXGHGpILQLWLRQIDLWSHVHUVXUOHVVXEVWDQWLIVREOLJDWRLUH
SRXUOHVpOpPHQWVVLWXpVOHSOXVHQKDXWGHFHWWHpFKHOOHHWIDFXOWDWLISRXUFHX[VLWXpVOHSOXVHQEDV'DQVFHV
FRQGLWLRQVLOIDXWSUREDEOHPHQWV·DWWHQGUHjFHTXHOHVSURQRPVDLHQWXQFRPSRUWHPHQWGLIIpUHQWGHFHOXLGHV
DGMHFWLIVHWTX·LOVUHoRLYHQWREOLJDWRLUHPHQWRXSOXVIUpTXHPPHQWODPDUTXHGHSOXULHO'HIDLWOHVDWWHVWDWLRQV
GHIRUPHVDUWLFXOpHV F·HVWjGLUHGHIRUPHVROHSURQRPHVWHPSOR\pFRPPHDUWLFOHHQFOLWLTXH DXSOXULHOVRQW
UHODWLYHPHQWQRPEUHXVHV:@
3DUHLOOHPHQWODTXHVWLRQGHO·DFFRUGHQJHQUHHVWPRLQVQHWWHTXHFHOOHGHO·DFFRUGHQFDV2QVDLWGHSXLV
ORQJWHPSVTXHFHWWHODQJXHQHFRQQDvWSDVGXPRLQVSRXUOHVQRPVFRPPXQVGHJHQUHJUDPPDWLFDO3RXUOHV
DQWKURSRQ\PHVHWXQLTXHPHQWFHVGHUQLHUVHOOHDSDUWLHOOHPHQWLQWpJUpODGLVWLQFWLRQJpQpULTXHGHVODQJXHV
LQGRHXURSpHQQHVDYHFOHVTXHOOHVHOOHpWDLWHQFRQWDFWHWLQWURGXLWXQHRSSRVLWLRQjGHX[WHUPHVPDVFYVIpP
UHSURGXLVDQWOHJHQUHQDWXUHOHWOLPLWpHSDUFRQVpTXHQWDX[OH[qPHVGpVLJQDQWGHVrWUHVKXPDLQVRXDQLPpV
HVVHQWLHOOHPHQWGHVDQWKURSRQ\PHVPDLVDXVVLTXHOTXHVWKpRQ\PHVHWQRPVGHIRQFWLRQ:P &HSKpQRPqQH
V·REVHUYHOHPLHX[DYHFOHVJHQWLOLFHVQ?TXLSRXUODSOXSDUWIRUPHQWOHXUIpPLQLQSDUO·DGMRQFWLRQG·XQHPDUTXH
jODIRUPHQRQPDUTXpHGHPDVFXOLQODU۟PDUFQDYV۟DQशYLOPDUFQHL j>(-4)(M# 'DQVFHFDVWUqVSDUWLFXOLHUHW
XQLTXHPHQWGDQVFHFDVRQSHXWGLUHDYHFFHUWLWXGHTXHO·DFFRUGHVWREOLJDWRLUHHWODGRFXPHQWDWLRQSHUPHWWDQW
GHOHSURXYHUHVWSUHVTXHLQILQLH3RXUOHVDSSHOODWLIVHQUHYDQFKHF·HVWHQFRUHXQHIRLVFRPPHO·DELHQPRQWUp/
$JRVWLQLDQLO·pFKHOOHG·KXPDQLWXGHTXLLQWHUYLHQWVDQVTX·DXFXQHPDUTXHIRUPHOOHFHSHQGDQWYLHQQHGLVWLQJXHU
DXVLQJXOLHUOHVVXEVWDQWLIVPDUTXpVGXWUDLW>KXPDLQ@GHFHX[PDUTXpVGXWUDLW>KXPDLQ@,OVXIILUDG·RSSRVHU
SRXUFHODOHVFRXSOHVGHVXEVWDQWLIV4.()´ILOVµ(.I()´RIIUDQGHYRWLYHµRX($#´PqUHµۭX۟L´WRPEHµFDUDFWpULVpVSDU
OHVPrPHVILQDOHV2QGRLWGRQFFRQFOXUHTXHKRUPLVSRXUOHFDVWUqVSDUWLFXOLHUGHVDQWKURSRQ\PHVO·pWUXVTXH
Q·HVWSDVFRQFHUQpSDUO·DFFRUGLQWUDV\QWDJPDWLTXHHQJHQUHPrPHVLODGLVWLQFWLRQ>“KXPDLQ@DXQHLQFLGHQFH
VXUO·DFFRUGHQQRPEUH
­ODVXLWHGHFHWH[DPHQRQHVWGRQFHQPHVXUHGHSURSRVHUXQHKLpUDUFKLHGHVFDWpJRULHVPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHV
FRQFHUQpHVSDUO·DFFRUGHQSUHPLHUOLHXYLHQWDVVXUpPHQWODFDWpJRULHGXFDVFHOOHGXQRPEUHHVWWUqVSUREDEOH
PHQWIDFXOWDWLYHPrPHVLO·RQPDQTXHGHGRQQpHVFHUWDLQHVSRXUO·DIILUPHUTXDQWjFHOOHGXJHQUHHOOHHVWVRX
PLVHjGHVUHVWULFWLRQVWUqVIRUWHVHWO·RQSHXWGLUHTX·HOOHQHFRQFHUQHO·pWUXVTXHTXHSRXUXQHFDWpJRULHOH[LFDOH
WUqVUpGXLWHFHOOHGHVDQWKURSRQ\PHV,O\DGRQFXQHGLIIpUHQFHHVVHQWLHOOHHQWUHOHVFDWpJRULHVFRQFHUQpHV
FHOOHGXFDVLQWHUYLHQWWRXMRXUVGDQVOHVSKpQRPqQHVG·DFFRUGLQWUDV\QWDJPDWLTXHVVDQVTX·LQWHUYLHQQHO·pFKHOOH
G·KXPDQLWXGHRXGHGpILQLWLRQWDQGLVTXHODUpDOLVDWLRQGHO·DFFRUGHQJHQUHHWHQQRPEUHHVWFRQGLWLRQQpHSDU
FHWWHGHUQLqUH&·HVWOjXQHVLWXDWLRQTXHO·RQUHWURXYHGDQVSOXVG·XQHODQJXHGXPRQGHQO

:Q
%8*$7
:<
&HQ·HVWSDVOHOLHXGHQRXVSHQFKHUVXUOHSUREOqPHGXVHQVGHFHW
DGMHFWLIGRQWOHVLJQLILp HWPrPHODQDWXUH HVWHQFRUHWUqVGpEDWWX
DXSUqVGHVpWUXVFRORJXHV1RXVGLURQVGRQFMXVWHTXHVXUODEDVHGH
VHVDXWUHVRFFXUUHQFHVFHWDGMHFWLIGRLWDYRLUXQGRPDLQHVpPDQ
WLTXHVXVFHSWLEOHG·H[SULPHUXQHORFDOLVDWLRQGDQVO·HVSDFH SOXW{W
TXHGDQVOHWHPSV 
:R
6XUFHVGLYLQLWpVYRLUGHUQLqUHPHQW0DUDV¬I

6XUFHWWHKLpUDUFKLHYRLU&RUEHWW²HW/D]DUG
²HW²
:@
3HQGDQWORQJWHPSVRQpWDLWLQFDSDEOHGHGLVWLQJXHUOHVIRUPHVGH
SOXULHOGHVIRUPHVGHVLQJXOLHU&·HVWj'6WHLQEDXHUTXHUHYLHQWOH
PpULWHG·DYRLUSURSRVpO·K\SRWKqVHVHORQODTXHOOHO·LQIL[HM?l1MGDQV
FHVIRUPHVPDUTXHUDLWOHSOXULHO 6WHLQEDXHUHW K\SR
WKqVHTXLHVWFRQIRUWpHSRXUOHVSURQRPVۭD%JK%M0( YRLUWDEOHDX 
2QDUpFHPPHQWSURSRVpGHFRQILHUFHU{OHjO·LQIL[HOTXLDSSDUDvW
IUpTXHPPHQWGDQVODIOH[LRQGHVSURQRPVPDLVFHWWHK\SRWKqVHVH
KHXUWHjWURSGHGLIILFXOWpVSRXUrWUHVXLYLH

&IFDY۟D
:P
&IPDVF.(1$)#%IpPODXWQL۟D ´DIIUDQFKL H µ 
Q?
2QHQWHQGSDUOjOHVJHQWLOLFHVIRUPHOOHPHQWPDUTXpVFRPPHDG
MHFWLIV LOV·DJLWSULQFLSDOHPHQWGHVFDWpJRULHVGHVJHQWLOLFHVSDWUR
Q\PLTXHVW\SLTXHPHQWWHUPLQpVSDUOHVVXIIL[HVGpULYDWLIVM)(%JK%
M#!HWGHVJHQWLOLFHVHWKQLTXHVWHUPLQpVJpQpUDOHPHQWHQD۟HWM($!%
JK%L۟HWM#$! 
QO
6XUOHFDVSDUWLFXOLHUTXHUHSUpVHQWHO·´DFFRUGµHQFDVSDUUDSSRUW
DX[DXWUHVFDWpJRULHV HQSDUWLFXOLHUJHQUHHWQRPEUH QRXVUHQ
YR\RQVj&RUEHWW²HW²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% DL%T<B%O88A7

!B(6<;JNOKDE(?HE>DFE(D:(J<E:J<E@:@<9E
2QSHXWGRQFpWDEOLUXQHQRUPHGHO·DFFRUGHQFDVHQpWUXVTXHWRXVOHVPRGLILFDWHXUVG·XQQRPSUHQQHQW
ODPDUTXHGXFDVDXTXHOFHGHUQLHUHVWIOpFKL7RXWHIRLVj\UHJDUGHUGHSOXVSUqVRQVHUHQGFRPSWHTXHGHX[
W\SHVG·pFDUWjFHWWHQRUPHDSSDUDLVVHQWGDQVOHVWH[WHVjQRWUHGLVSRVLWLRQ,OQRXVIDXWGRQFjSUpVHQWFKHUFKHU
jUHQGUHFRPSWHGHFHV´IDXWHVG·DFFRUGµ/DSUHPLqUHG·HQWUHHOOHVLQWHUYLHQWGDQVODV\QWD[HGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQ
GDQVFHUWDLQVV\QWDJPHVHQHIIHWODSRVWSRVLWLRQHVWDFFROpHWDQWDXQRPTX·jVRQPRGLILFDWHXU

)P9:HCD(=D(FH(J<E:J<E@:@<9
8QGHVWUDLWVOHVSOXVW\SLTXHVGHODPRUSKRV\QWD[HpWUXVTXHSDUOHTXHOHOOHVHGLVWLQJXHQHWWHPHQWGHV
ODQJXHVFODVVLTXHVHVWO·XWLOLVDWLRQGHSRVWSRVLWLRQVSRXUSDOOLHUOHVLQVXIILVDQFHVVpPDQWLTXHVGHVFDVOjR
OHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVRQWJpQpUDOHPHQWGHVSUpSRVLWLRQVQ:³VLWXDWLRQTXLHVWG·DLOOHXUVFRQIRUPHjFH
TX·HQVHLJQHODW\SRORJLHOLQJXLVWLTXHQQ2QUHFHQVHVL[SRVWSRVLWLRQVHQpWUXVTXHQ<%۟L ORF M-# EpQpIDFWLI MI#%
EpQpIDFWLI"REM" M!>2QR%M$-( DEO" HWFHशD EpQpIDFWLI" &HWWHGHUQLqUHHVWjPHWWUHjSDUWSDUFHTXHVDIRQFWLRQ
SRVWSRVLWLRQQHOOHQ·HVWSDVDVVXUpHHWTXHGHVXUFURvWVLO·RQDELHQDIIDLUHjXQHSRVWSRVLWLRQLOV·DJLWGHWRXWH
pYLGHQFHG·XQHSRVWSRVLWLRQ´VHFRQGDLUHµF·HVWjGLUHGXHjXQJOLVVHPHQWFDWpJRULHOSOXVUpFHQWTXHFHOXLTXLD
FRQGXLWjO·DXWRQRPLVDWLRQGHVDXWUHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVGHO·pWUXVTXH'HIDLWFHशDHVWDYDQWWRXWGRFXPHQWpFRPPH
DGYHUEH VLJQLILDQW´01I-( LODXUDLWVHFRQGDLUHPHQWSXrWUHHPSOR\pDSUqVXQVXEVWDQWLIjO·DEORXjXQDXWUH
FDVREOLTXHSRXUH[SULPHUXQHIRQFWLRQVpPDQWLTXHGLIILFLOHjGpWHUPLQHU/HVFLQTDXWUHVHQUHYDQFKHIRU
PHQWXQJURXSHWUqVFRKpUHQWGXSRLQWGHYXHSKRQRV\QWD[LTXH VWUXFWXUHPRQRV\OODELTXHWURLVG·HQWUHHOOHV
REpLVVHQWjXQHVWUXFWXUH´&#µ HWSURVRGLTXH HQFOLWLTXHV FHTXLVXJJqUHHQFRUHO·DQFLHQQHWpGHOHXUIRUPDWLRQ
/HFRPSRUWHPHQWPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHGHFHVFLQTpOpPHQWVSODLGHSRXUXQHDQDO\VHSRVWSRVLWLRQQHOOHSOXW{WTXH
PRUSKpPDWLTXHQ@SXLVTX·LOVVRQWFDUDFWpULVpVSDUOHVWUDLWVVXLYDQWV
 ‡ UHFWLRQFDVXHOOHFKDFXQHGHFHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVUpJLWXQRXSOXVLHXUVFDVREOLTXHV ۟LORFLQVWUHWJpQMI#%JK%
M-#gORFLQVWUM!>gDEVDFFM$-(gDEVJpQORFLQVWUHWDEO 2UODUHFWLRQHVWELHQOHWUDLWGpILQLWRLUH
OHSOXVLPSRUWDQWGHVDGSRVLWLRQVHWSHUPHWGHOHVGLVWLQJXHUGHVDIIL[HVFDVXHOV
 ‡ DXWRQRPLHV\QWD[LTXHQXOOHOHVpOpPHQWV۟L2%MI#2%M-#2%M!>%JK%M$-(Q·RQWTXHGHVHPSORLVHQFOLWLTXHVFHTXLGRLW
VHFRPSUHQGUHFRPPHO·XQGHVVLJQHVGLVWLQFWLIVGHODJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQGHFHVpOpPHQWVQP YRLUOHV
SUpSRVLWLRQVPRQRV\OODELTXHVGXJUHFHWGXODWLQ 
 ‡ DXWRQRPLHPRUSKRORJLTXHO·pOpPHQWM-#LQWHUYLHQWGDQVGHVIRUPDWLRQVYHUEDOHVSRXUO·H[SUHVVLRQPRGDOH
GHO·REOLJDWLRQ <?,OVHPEOHUDLWDLQVLTXHGHPrPHTXHOHVSUpSRVLWLRQVVRQWpJDOHPHQWGHVSUpYHUEHV

Q:
3RXUOHPRPHQWDXFXQHSUpSRVLWLRQQ·DSXrWUHGpFRXYHUWHHQ
pWUXVTXH/HVSURSRVLWLRQVIDLWHVHQFHVHQVQHWLHQQHQWSDVIDFHjXQ
H[DPHQDWWHQWLIDLQVLO·LGpHDVVH]DQFLHQQHTXHO·DGYH۟%9F8K%LHJ%
SUpSRVLWLRQORFDOH´#)µ FI&ULVWRIDQL GRLWrWUHUHMHWpHVDQV
KpVLWDWLRQ/DVLQJXODULWpGHO·pWUXVTXHQHWLHQWGRQFSDVWDQWGDQV
O·HPSORLGHSRVWSRVLWLRQVTXLH[LVWHQWDXVVLGDQVOHVODQJXHVIOH[LRQ
QHOOHVPDLVGDQVVRQHPSORLH[FOXVLIRXWUqVODUJHPHQWGRPLQDQW
DORUVTXHOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVSULYLOpJLHQWPDVVLYHPHQW
O·HPSORLGHSUpSRVLWLRQV
QQ
$JRVWLQLDQL
Q<
6XUOHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVpWUXVTXHVQRXVQRXVSHUPHWWRQVXQHIRLVGH
SOXVGHUHQYR\HUjYDQ+HHPVVRXVSUHVVHD
QR
%M!>DOHFRPSRUWHPHQWG·XQHSRVWSRVLWLRQUpJLVVDQWO·DFFXVDWLIHW
GRQWOHVHQVJUDYLWHDXWRXUGHVQRWLRQVGH´VDQVµHW´VDXIH[FHSWpµ
3RXUO·LGHQWLILFDWLRQGHFHWWHYDOHXUHWODFRUUHFWHDQDO\VHGHVQXPp
UDX[FRPSOH[HVRFHWWHSRVWSRVLWLRQDSSDUDvWYRLU$JRVWLQLDQL
²

&·HVWOHUDSSURFKHPHQWGXJURXSHFOHQFHशD DWWHVWpGDQVWURLVLQV
FULSWLRQVYRWLYHVG·pSRTXHUpFHQWH8*&R2$HW2% GH
>6%GF7ML>J%>6K8HJ%I-6%:#.#6GpMjGRFXPHQWpHVXUODEDVHGH7LEXU 3/N%
* :I-6%:#.!6" TXLDFRQGXLWjIDLUHGHFHशDGRQWOHVHPSORLV
DGYHUELDX[VRQWFHUWDLQV YRLUODFODXVXOHTXLFO{WOHWH[WHGX&LSSHGH
3pURXVH8*3HLशFDFHशD]LशXशH´FRPPHFHODDpWppFULW01I-(µ 
XQH SRVWSRVLWLRQ FI &RORQQD    0DLV LQGpSHQGDPPHQW
GXSUREOqPHSRVpSDUODIRUPH4.!)FRQVLGpUpHFRPPHXQDEODWLI
DPRUSKpPDWLTXH ´DEODWLI,,,µVHORQODWHUPLQRORJLHGH5L[
† RQ QRWH QpDQPRLQV O·DSRSKRQLH TXL GLVWLQJXH 4.!) GH O·DEV
4.() RQGRLWFRQYHQLUTXHOHFRQWH[WHQHSHUPHWQLGHFRQILUPHUQL
G·LQILUPHUO·K\SRWKqVH(QWRXWFDVO·DSSDUHQWHSURIXVLRQGHSRVW
SRVLWLRQVLQGLTXDQWOHEpQpILFLDLUHGHO·DFWLRQQHGRLWSDVpWRQQHU
HOOHHVWG·DERUGHQSDUWLHGXHDXW\SHGHGRFXPHQWDWLRQTXLQRXV
IDLWFRQQDvWUHO·pWUXVTXH RDERQGHQWOHVLQVFULSWLRQVGHGpGLFDFHV
GHGRQHWG·RIIUDQGHVYRWLYHV HQVXLWHRQGRLWVHUDSSHOHUTX·XQH
ODQJXHGRQQpHSHXWDYRLUSOXVG·XQPR\HQOLQJXLVWLTXHG·H[SULPHU
XQHPrPHIRQFWLRQ(QODWLQPrPHG·DLOOHXUVODIRQFWLRQ%pQHI
SHXWrWUHUHQGXHSDUSOXVLHXUVWRXUVFRQFXUUHQWVSUpSRVLWLRQQHOV
I-6%:#.#62%("%:#.#1>2%:#.##%5-($#(« RXQRQ :#.#6 
Q@
9RLUHQFRUHYDQ+HHPVVRXVSUHVVHD

,OQ·HVWSDVV€UTXHO·DEOVRLWjSURSUHPHQWSDUOHUXQFDVUpJLSDU
ODSRVWSRVLWLRQLOQ·DSSDUDvWTXHGDQVGHVV\QWDJPHVRM$-(HVWOXL
PrPHIOpFKLjFHFDV 8*&U1)#(.(0M$-!02%8*%--2%=6998M2%ߓSXUHߓ
WUHߓ LOSRXUUDLWGRQFV·DJLUG·XQHWUDQVSRVLWLRQGHWRXWOHV\QWDJPH
SRVWSRVLWLRQQHOjXQFDVREOLTXH
QP
6XUODTXHVWLRQYRLU+DJqJHHVSSSI
<?
´1pFHVVLWDWLI µVHORQ5L[†
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <33,KH%7\K%N8%HQ7<33,KH% <?@

OHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVSXLVVHQWDXVVLrWUHGHV´SRVWYHUEHVµVLJQHTXHO·RQDELHQDIIDLUHjXQpOpPHQWFKDUJp
VpPDQWLTXHPHQWTXLV·HVWJUDPPDWLFDOLVp<O
 ‡ LQYDULDELOLWpDORUVTXH۟L2%MI#2%M-#%JK%M!>VRQWLQYDULDEOHVFRPPHF·HVWJpQpUDOHPHQWOHFDVSRXUOHVDGSRVL
K8FH92%M$-(HVWVRXPLVjODIOH[LRQ<:0rPHVLFHWUDLWOHUDSSURFKHGHODFDWpJRULHGHVSURQRPV<Q%8>%HTJ9K%
WRXWHIRLVSDVQpFHVVDLUHGHUHQRQFHUjO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQSRVWSRVLWLRQQHOOHODIOH[LRQGHVDGSRVLWLRQVHVW
GRFXPHQWpHGDQVSOXVG·XQHODQJXH<<
2QHVWSDUFRQVpTXHQWDXWRULVpjSRVHUO·H[LVWHQFHHQpWUXVTXHG·XQHFODVVHDVVH]ELHQIRXUQLHGHSRVWSRVLWLRQV
'DQVOHFDGUHG·XQHpWXGHPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHWHOOHTXHODQ{WUHLOHVWLQGLVSHQVDEOHGHSRUWHUXQHDWWHQWLRQ
SDUWLFXOLqUHDX[V\QWDJPHVUpJLVSDUGHVUHODWHXUVGDQVODPHVXUHRLOVSUpVHQWHQWXQHFRPSOH[LWpPRUSKR
V\QWD[LTXHPDMHXUH³RQSHXWHQHIIHWSDUOHUGHPRUSKqPHVGLVFRQWLQXV³TXHOHVV\QWDJPHVVDQVUHODWHXUV
1RXVDYRQVYXSUpFpGHPPHQWTXHO·DFFRUGHQFDVpWDLWREOLJDWRLUHGDQVFHVV\QWDJPHVSRXUDVVXUHUODFRKpUHQFH
V\QWDJPDWLTXH/·pWXGHGHVHPSORLVV\QWD[LTXHVGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQHVWDVVH]LQWpUHVVDQWH6XUOHVLQVFULSWLRQV
XWLOHVSRXUFHWWHpWXGHHWUDVVHPEOpHVHQDQQH[HFRQWLHQQHQWXQ61FRPSOH[H F·HVWjGLUHFRPSRVpG·XQ
1HWG·DXPRLQVXQPRGLILFDWHXUHQO·RFFXUUHQFHXQ$GM HWSHUPHWWHQWGHFHIDLWXQHpWXGHDSSURIRQGLHGHOD
V\QWD[HGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQpWUXVTXH
 FLO۟FYHWLKLODUH
 G#.4M#%>1)#M4.!M$
 >$!#@0)#M4.M$!%W%:.!)G)M!
 KX]UQH۟LFDLVULYDLZS
 FOHQVLPXOH۟VYDODVL
 VSXUH۟LDSDVL
 YLSLQDOWUDXOशQLۭੜ OD
 UL۟QDLWXOWUDLV
 UL۟QDLWXODVQHQD]LXODVWUD
 UL۟QDLWXODKLYXVWUD
 (?#.0g%FLHP]D۟UPVOXSX
 FO۟L%ZۭX۟L@۟L
 ۟XL%Z4.@ۭ۟X۟L۟
 FO۟VX۟L۟
 FDOWLۭX۟LWL
 HFO۟LۭXZ۟L۟L"
 ߓDFQLFOHULFLO۟OߓSXUHULPH۟OXPHULFHQDߓ «
/·H[DPHQGHFHVLQVFULSWLRQVSHUPHWGHWLUHUOHVFRQFOXVLRQVVXLYDQWHVFRQFHUQDQWODSODFHGHODSRVWSRVL
WLRQ&HOOHFLGDQVOHVV\QWDJPHV´1PRGLILFDWHXUSRVWSµQHVHPEOHSDVIL[HOHVTXHOTXHVH[HPSOHVTXHO·RQ
SHXWHPSOR\HUjFHWWHILQPDOKHXUHXVHPHQWDVVH]SHXQRPEUHX[VHPEOHQWLQGLTXHUTXHODSRVWSRVLWLRQVHWURXYH
SOXVYRORQWLHUVDFFROpHDXSUHPLHUpOpPHQWGXV\QWDJPHTX·DXVHFRQGPDLVODSURSRUWLRQHVWjSHLQHHQIDYHXU
GHFHWWHSRVLWLRQVL[H[HPSOHVVXUOHVQHXIV\QWDJPHVTX·RQSHXWHPSOR\HUDYHFFHUWLWXGH<R&HWWHGLVWULEXWLRQ
HQWRXWFDVQHGpSHQGQLGHODQDWXUHGXOH[qPH OHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVV·DFFROHQWDXVVLELHQDXQRPTX·jVRQPRG

<O
2QSHXWSHQVHUjO·pOpPHQWDQJO$6TXLVHUWDXVVLELHQjLQWURGXLUH
GHVFRPSOpPHQWVQRPLQDX[ 0+!%$(.=!"%$6%+#>%HPSORLSUpSRVLWLRQ
QHO TX·jSURGXLUHGHVIRUPHVYHUEDOHV +!%9()$0%$6%46>!%N%JM=>F8%
SUpYHUEDO ,ORIIULUDLWDLQVLXQSDUIDLWSDUDOOqOHjpWUM-#GRQWOHV
HPSORLVSRVWSRVLWLRQQHOVVRQWWUqVSUREDEOHPHQWSURFKHVGXGDWLI
LQGRHXURSpHQ PH۟OXPHUL´SRXUODFRPPXQDXWpµ HWGRQWOHVHP
SORLVYHUEDX[RQWFODLUHPHQWSRXUIRQFWLRQGHPRGDOLVHUO·pQRQFp
REOLJDWLRQ"GHVWLQDWLRQ"IXWXU" 
<:
3RXUODOLVWHGHVIRUPHVYRLU5L[†
<Q
&RPPHOHVXJJqUHGpMj+5L[ORFFLW
<<
2QSHQVHjFHUWDLQHVODQJXHVFDXFDVLHQQHV WVDNKXUDENKD] jGH
QRPEUHXVHVODQJXHVGHO·,QGHRXDX[ODQJXHVFHOWLTXHV3RXUXQHOLVWH
SOXVSUpFLVHHWGHVH[HPSOHVWLUpVGXWVDNKXUYRLU&RUEHWW
<R
%$82%JH%8*7DPHDQLPXQLFOH۟%GF7MJ%LH%9EHK6IMJ%LH8K687J2%FH%6%
XQHXOWpULHXUHDWWHVWDWLRQGHO·HPSORLHQVHFRQGHSRVLWLRQGHODSRVW
SRVLWLRQ6HXOHODVpPDQWLTXHSHUPHWWUDLWGHUpVRXGUHFHGLOHPPH
V\QWD[LTXHPDLVFRPPHSUHVTXHWRXMRXUVHQpWUXVTXHO·LQWHUSUp
WDWLRQHVWORLQG·rWUHXQLYRTXH7UDGLWLRQQHOOHPHQWRQFRPSUHQG
>!()TXLVXUOHVOpJHQGHVGHPLURLUVFDUDFWpULVHXQHILJXUHVHP
EODEOHjOD༱໅໵ٗGHV*UHFVFRPPHVLJQLILDQW´YLFWRLUHµ SRXUXQH
LQWHUSUpWDWLRQDOWHUQDWLYHPDLVWRXMRXUV´DEVWUDLWHµSDU´MHXQHVVHµ
YRLU6WHLQEDXHU OHJURXSHSRXUUDLWGRQFVLJQLILHU´GDQVOD
YLFWRLUHFHOOH>1)#µPrPHVLODVLWXDWLRQHVWUHQGXHSOXVFRPSOH[H
SDUODSUpVHQFHGDQVODSURSRVLWLRQGHODIRUPH4(.10#>HWGXYHUEH
.1I1TXLFRQVWLWXHQWDYHFXQHIRUPHDUWLFXOpHGHO·DGMHFWLI>1)#2%LH%
IRUPXODLUHIXQpUDLUHUpFXUUHQWGRQWOHVHQVPDOKHXUHXVHPHQWQ·HVW
SDVFODLU
 oi.uchicago.edu

% DL%T<B%O88A7

LILFDWHXU HWOHVFKRL[DXVHLQG·XQPrPHWH[WHSHXYHQWV·DYpUHUGLIIpUHQWV <@FHTXLODLVVHUDLVRQQDEOHPHQW

SHQVHUTXHODSODFHGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQGDQVOHV\QWDJPHpWDLWOLEUH2QDMRXWHUDTX·LOHVWQRUPDOSRXUGHVUDLVRQV
GHFODUWpGHO·pQRQFpTXHODSRVWSRVLWLRQDSSDUDLVVHSOXVVRXYHQWDSUqVOHSUHPLHUpOpPHQWGXV\QWDJPHTX·DSUqV
OHVHFRQGPDLVTXHO·H[WHQVLRQGHO·DFFRUGjWRXVOHVpOpPHQWVGXV\QWDJPHUHQGSRVVLEOHXQHPSORL PDUTXp" 
GHODSRVWSRVLWLRQHQILQGHV\QWDJPH

6<;JNIKH:@EH:@<9((/$)(".((=D(FH(J<E:J<E@:@<9(M۟(
,OHVWXQWUDLWFRPELQDWRLUHIUDSSDQWGDQVO·HPSORLGHFHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVTXLHVWODSRVVLELOLWpUpVHUYpHjFHU
WDLQHVG·HQWUHHOOHVGHYHQLUPDUTXHUjODIRLVOHQRPHWOHPRGLILFDWHXUG·XQPrPHV\QWDJPH­ODYpULWpFHWWH
SRVVLELOLWpQ·HVWDYpUpHTXHSRXUODSRVWSRVLWLRQ۟LHWFHTXHO·RQFRQVLGqUHJpQpUDOHPHQWFRPPHVHVDOORPRUSKHV
۟2%M$#2%M$HWSHXWrWUHM$! HWGDQVGHVFRQGLWLRQVELHQSUpFLVHVFRPPHOHUpYqOHXQHpWXGHFRPELQDWRLUHDWWHQ
WLYH1RXVDYRQVSRXUFHODUDVVHPEOpWRXVOHVJURXSHVGHGHX[OH[qPHVFRQWLJXVPDUTXpVSDUODPrPHSRVWSRVL
WLRQ0DLVLOIDXWG·HPEOpHVpSDUHUOHVV\QWDJPHVXQLWDLUHVGHVV\QWDJPHVDXWRQRPHVSXLVTXHOHVGHX[OH[qPHV
HQTXHVWLRQSHXYHQWSDUIDLWHPHQWrWUHMX[WDSRVpVVDQVIRUPHUXQPrPHV\QWDJPHVXUOHPRGqOHGHVIRUPXOHV
UpFXUUHQWHVGXULWXHOGHOD0RPLHGH=DJUHEߓSXUHULPH۟OXPHULF%JK%>!.!-#%0?!.!-#4TXLJUkFHjO·HPSORLGHODSDU
WLFXOHHQFOLWLTXHGHFRRUGLQDWLRQM4QHVRQWSDVDPELJXsVHWUHQYRLHQWjFKDTXHIRLVDX[GHX[´LQVWLWXWLRQVµj
GHVWLQDWLRQGHVTXHOOHVVHIRQWOHVDFWLRQVPHQWLRQQpHVjVDYRLU´SRXUODFLWpHWODFRPPXQDXWpµHW´SRXUOH>!.M%
JK%>J%0?!.Mµ6LO·RQPHWGHF{WpFHVGHX[JURXSHVRQFRQVWDWHTXHVHXOHODSRVWSRVLWLRQ۟L ´GDQVµORFLQHVVLI HVW
FRQFHUQpHSDUFHWWHUpGXSOLFDWLRQLQWUDV\QWDJPDWLTXH
 FO۟L%ZۭX۟L@۟L
 ۟XL%Z4.@ۭ۟X۟L۟
 FOۭ۟X۟L۟
 FDOWLۭX۟LWL
 HFO۟LۭXZ۟L۟L"
% ۟-(5$*2۟LPXWQD̂̂ (૎۟(YHOYHOXۭDDYLOVFLV]D۟UPLVFVHLࠃL۟૎ LDOLۭD
 Q*RüO۟̂LPXWQ/"۟(5%?@HODSQDVOD‫۟ޢ‬LDZ.L%4.(@‫ؾ‬DYLOVFH]SDZ
 WXWHVۭੜ H۟UH « 9(2*,(5$>-.,ۭ4+4*,(5$2->-5DYLOVPDशV]D۟UXPV
 PLDUQ۟LDOWHWQLHV%ۭ-۟(۟($4"2*2۟(
'HWRXWHVFHVRFFXUUHQFHVOHVGHX[GHUQLqUHVVRQWjPHWWUHjSDUWFDUۭX۟L۟LYHOFO۟LJK%]LOFWLSXUWۭYDYFWL%E%GF7
PHQWWUqVSUREDEOHPHQWGHX[V\QWDJPHVDXWRQRPHV<P7RXWHVOHVDXWUHVHQUHYDQFKHFRQVWLWXHQWXQJURXSHWUqV
FRKpUHQWSXLVTXHOHVV\QWDJPHVUHWHQXVRQWWRXVODVWUXFWXUH´'pP1µPLHX[HQFRUHRQFRQVWDWHTXHOHVFKRL[
OH[LFDX[VRQWjFKDTXHIRLVOHVPrPHVGpPRQVWUDWLI4(HWVXEVWDQWLIGpVLJQDQWOHPRQXPHQWIXQpUDLUHTXLDFFXHLOOH
OHGpIXQW VRLWۭX۟L´WRPEHµVRLW>1$)(´VDUFRSKDJHµ ³FHTXLVXJJqUHTX·RQDDIIDLUHjXQIRUPXODLUHIXQpUDLUH
ELHQGLIIXVpHQeWUXULHPpULGLRQDOH'DQVFHFDVO·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQGHFHVJURXSHVFRPPHGHVV\QWDJPHVXQLWDLUHV
HVWFRQIRUWpHSDUXQIDLVFHDXGHPRWLIV


&RPSDUHUSDUH[HPSOHGDQVODPrPHLQVFULSWLRQ 8*&U G#.4#%
PXQLFOHWHWKX]UQH۟LFDLVULYDL
<@
9RLUHQFRUHO·LQVFULSWLRQFLWpHjODQRWHSUpFpGHQWH2QSHXWDXV
VLUHQYR\HUjXQJURXSHGHWH[WHVFRKpUHQWOHVLQVFULSWLRQV8*%!#%
HWGHODWRPEHGHV$OH۟QD 0XVDUQD TXLUHQYRLHQWO·XQ
jO·DXWUHHWRO·RQWURXYHUHVSHFWLYHPHQWOHVJURXSHVVSXUH۟LDSDVL%
´GDQVODFLWpGXSqUHµ HWFOHQVLPXOH۟ ´DXFRXUVGX>1.(%Z96H9%
GRXWHXQHPDJLVWUDWXUH@GXILOVµVXUOHSUREOqPHSRVpSDUO·LQWHU
SUpWDWLRQGHFHVLQVFULSWLRQVYRLUHQFRUHYDQ+HHPVVRXVSUHVVHD 
0DLVRQHVWOjGHYDQWGHVFDVSDUWLFXOLHUVOHVPRGLILFDWHXUVpWDQW
GDQVOHVGHX[FDVGHVJpQLWLIVDGQRPLQDX[RODGpVLQHQFHM#YLHQW
VHVXUDMRXWHUjFHOOHGHJpQLOHVWSUREDEOHTXHSRXUGHVUDLVRQVGH
FODUWpFHVIRUPHVQ·pWDLHQWSDVHQPHVXUHGHVXSSRUWHUODSRVWSRVL
WLRQ DSDVL۟HW FOHQVL۟VHUDLHQWWUqVSUREDEOHPHQWGHVVROpFLVPHV 
RQSHUoRLWGRQFOjSUREDEOHPHQWXQHOLPLWHDXWUDLWHPHQWV\QWD[LTXH
LGHQWLTXHUpVHUYpDX[DGMHFWLIVHWDX[JpQLWLIVDGQRPLQDX[

3UpFLVRQVTXHFHWWHUpSDUWLWLRQHVWWUqVSUREDEOHPHQWGXHDXIDLW
TXH۟LHVWODSRVWSRVLWLRQGHORLQODPLHX[DWWHVWpHGDQVOHFRUSXV
pWUXVTXHLOHVWGqVORUVSUREDEOHPrPHVLRQQHSHXWOHFHUWLILHUTXH
OHSKpQRPqQHTXHQRXVDOORQVFRPPHQWHUSXLVVHVHSURGXLUHDYHF
OHVDXWUHVSRVWSRVLWLRQVpWUXVTXHV
<P
&·HVWFHUWDLQSRXU]LOFWLSXUWۭYDYFWLGDQVODPHVXUHRSXUWۭYDYF%J9K%
IRUPHOOHPHQWPDUTXpFRPPHQRPDEVWUDLWGpVLJQDQWXQHPDJLVWUD
WXUH VXIIL[HM?4%SRXUO·LGHQWLILFDWLRQGHFHWWHFODVVHOH[LFDOHYRLU
0DJJLDQL² /HVGHX[OH[qPHVMX[WDSRVpVGRLYHQWGRQF
IDLUHUpIpUHQFHDX[FKDUJHVSROLWLTXHVHWRXVDFHUGRWDOHVGDQVO·H[HU
FLFHGHVTXHOOHV M$# মH۟UH7XWHHVWPRUW ´LOHVWPRUWDXFRXUVGXG#.4%
HW GXSXUWۭYDYFµ 4XDQWjO·LQVFULSWLRQFRQVHUYpHj0RQWSHOOLHU
 OHVUDLVRQVTXLQRXVIRQWSHQFKHUSRXUXQHWHOOHOHFWXUHVRQW
H[SRVpHVLQYDQ+HHPVD²HWQRXVUHFRQQDLVVRQVFHSHQ
GDQWTXHFHQHVRQWOjTXHGHVUDLVRQVGHYUDLVHPEODQFHHWTX·DXFXQ
REVWDFOHIRUPHOQ·HPSrFKHXQHOHFWXUH´XQLWDLUHµGHۭX۟L۟LYHOFO۟LR
OHV\QWDJPHVLJQLILHUDLW´GDQVODWRPEHGH9XOFLµ
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <33,KH%7\K%N8%HQ7<33,KH% <?P

  SDUO·DQDO\VHFDWpJRULHOOHN%FO۟LpWDQWXQGpPRQVWUDWLIRQV·DWWHQGjFHTX·LODLWOHU{OHGHPRGLILFDWHXUGX
VXEVWDQWLITXLOHVXLW GpWHUPLQDQWGXQRP FHUWHVFHQ·HVW(%I-#6-#SDVODVHXOHVROXWLRQHQYLVDJHDEOH
SXLVTXHOHSURQRP!4( 4( DDXVVLGHVHPSORLVSURQRPLQDX[PDLVODVWUXFWXUHV\QWD[LTXHFRQWUDLJQDQWH
GHVSDVVDJHVRFHWWHIRUPXOHDSSDUDvWUHQGSUHVTXHQpFHVVDLUHFHWWHDQDO\VH
  SDUO·DQDO\VHVpPDQWLTXHRQV·DWWHQGORJLTXHPHQWjFHTXHOHGpPRQVWUDWLIGpWHUPLQHOHVXEVWDQWLITXL
VXLW YRLUSRLQWSUpFpGHQW 
  SDUO·DQDO\VHFRPELQDWRLUHj7DUTXLQLDODIRUPXOH´FO۟LۭX۟L۟Lµ HWYDULDQWHV HVWHQGLVWULEXWLRQFRP
SOpPHQWDLUHDYHFOHIRUPXODLUH´۟XLFHVXY%´FLJvWµFRPSRVpGHO·DGYHUEHGpLFWLTXHGHOLHX۟XL´LFLµHWGX
YHUEHDXI!-:!4$1>%4!01´DpWpGpSRVpUHSRVHJvWµpTXLYDOHQWVOH[LFDX[UHVSHFWLIVGXV\QWDJPHFO۟LۭX۟L۟L%
G·XQHSDUWHWGHODFRSXOHVRXVMDFHQWHG·DXWUHSDUWG·DLOOHXUVOHVLQVFULSWLRQV  HW  VRQWLQWpUHV
VDQWHVHQFHTX·HOOHIRQWSUpFpGHUO·H[SUHVVLRQDYHFXQHUHGRQGDQFHTXLQ·HVWSDVpWUDQJqUHDX[WUDGLWLRQV
pSLJUDSKLTXHVWDUTXLQLHQQHVGHO·DGYHUEH۟XL
  =67%>T6H6>E9J%GF7MJ>>JODSRVWSRVLWLRQGDQVFHVIRUPXOHVHVWUpSpWpHjFKDTXHIRLVVRXVVDPrPHIRUPH
۟2%M$#2%۟L« DORUVTX·RQDXQH[HPSOHRGDQVODPrPHLQVFULSWLRQ 8*7DWGHV&DPQD ODSRVW
=F98K8FH%۟LHVWHPSOR\pHVRXVGHX[IRUPHVGLIIpUHQWHVXQHIRLV۟ ۭX۟L۟ HWXQHIRLVM$# FDOWLۭX۟LWL FH
TXLVXJJqUHHQFRUHXQHIRLVTXHOHVFULEHSHUFHYDLWODVpTXHQFHFO۟LۭX۟L۟LFRPPHXQJURXSHXQLWDLUH

7PJ<:NOED(=G@9:D;J;I:H:@<9(=@H?N;<9@S>D
2QGRLWGRQFSRXUOHPRLQVV·pWRQQHUGHFHWWHpWUDQJHUpGXSOLFDWLRQGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQTXLYDjO·HQFRQWUH
GHVSULQFLSHVGHUHFWLRQGXUHODWHXU SXLVTXHODGpILQLWLRQWUDGLWLRQQHOOHIDLWELHQGHO·DGSRVLWLRQXQPRUSKqPH
XQLTXHGDQVOHV\QWDJPHDORUVTXHOHFDVFKDUJpGHPDUTXHUO·DFFRUGHVWXQPRUSKqPHSDUQDWXUHGXSOLFDEOH
jO·LQWpULHXUGXV\QWDJPHRQDXUDLWVLO·RQWUDQVSRVDLWO·H[SUHVVLRQHQODWLQOHPRQVWUHV\QWD[LTXHj#)%+64%#)%
0!I1.4+-6 ODVXUSULVHHVWSOXVJUDQGHHQFRUHTXDQGRQUHPDUTXHTXHFHSKpQRPqQHQ·HVWDWWHVWpTXHGDQVGHV
FRQGLWLRQVWUqVSUpFLVHVDYHFOHVV\QWDJPHV´'pP1µR?­QRWUHDYLVRQGRLWSRVWXOHUSRXUUHQGUHFRPSWHGHFH
SKpQRPqQHXQHJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQSDUWLHOOHHW#)%:#!-# ROGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQ۟LHOOHHVWHQDFWHFDUFRPPHRQ
O·DYXOHVV\QWDJPHV´1$GMµQHVRQWSDVVRXPLVjFHWWHUpGXSOLFDWLRQHWTX·HOOHQ·DSSDUDvWTXHGDQVXQW\SH
WUqVOLPLWpGHV\QWDJPHV/HVFDXVHVGHFHWWHPRUSKpPDWLVDWLRQR:VRQWVDQVGRXWHOLpHVjODVSpFLDOLVDWLRQGX
PRUSKqPHM#GDQVO·H[SUHVVLRQGHO·,QVWUXPHQWDODORUVTXHOHORFDWLILQHVVLIHVWV\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWH[SULPpGqV
O·pSRTXHKLVWRULTXHHQGHKRUVGHTXHOTXHVDUFKDwVPHVDXPR\HQGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQ۟LPDLVLOQHV·DJLWSDVG·XQH
UDLVRQVXIILVDQWHSXLVTX·HOOHQHUHQGSDVFRPSWHGHODGLVWULEXWLRQWUqVSDUWLFXOLqUHGXSKpQRPqQH FHWWHUpGX
SOLFDWLRQQHFRQFHUQHTXHOHGpPRQVWUDWLI ,OIDXWGRQFDXVVLLQYRTXHUODVWUXFWXUHIRUWEUqYHGXSURQRP!4(W
4(HWXQHSDUWLFXODULWpGHVDIOH[LRQVRQJpQLWLIHWVRQORFLQVWUVRQWUHVSHFWLYHPHQW4.(%JK%4.!GRQWOHVILQDOHV
YRFDOLTXHVVRQWIUDJLOHVHQGHKRUVGHOHXUVHPSORLVHQFOLWLTXHV2QSHXWVHGHPDQGHUVLODODQJXHQ·DSDVYRXOX
pWRIIHUODVWUXFWXUHV\OODELTXHGHFHGpPRQVWUDWLIHQOXLDFFRODQWV\VWpPDWLTXHPHQWODSRVWSRVLWLRQ2QSRXUUDLW
QpDQPRLQVLPDJLQHUXQHDOWHUQDWLYHFRQVLVWDQWjIDLUHSRUWHUODSRVWSRVLWLRQVXUOHGpPRQVWUDWLISOXW{WTXHVXU
OHVXEVWDQWLI 61GXW\SH FO۟LۭX۟L PDLVHOOHVRXOqYHjVRQWRXUG·DXWUHVGLIILFXOWpVGDQVODPHVXUHRۭX۟Lj
FDXVHGHVDILQDOHHQM#Q·DSDVGHORFLQVWUGLVWLQFWGHVRQDEV DEVۭX۟LORFLQVWU ۭX۟L ۭX۟LL 4XRLTX·LO
HQVRLWLOUHVWHTXHO·H[WHQVLRQGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQDX[GHX[pOpPHQWVGXV\QWDJPHWpPRLJQHLQGXELWDEOHPHQW
G·XQHPRUSKpPDWLVDWLRQGHO·pOpPHQW۟LSHXWrWUHGHVWLQpHjSDOOLHUOHVLQVXIILVDQFHVGHODIOH[LRQTXLSUpYRLW
XQFHUWDLQQRPEUHG·KRPRSKRQHVRXGHIRUPHVIUDJLOHVHQWRXWFDVFHW\SHGHJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQQ·HVWSDVVDQV
SDUDOOqOHVW\SRORJLTXHVRQQLVDQVLQWpUrWSV\FKROLQJXLVWLTXHODUpGXSOLFDWLRQGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQHVWOHPR\HQOH

R?
9RLUOHVLQVFULSWLRQVQQ²SRXUGHVH[HPSOHVGHV\QWDJPHV
SRVWSRVLWLRQQHOV´1$GM3RVWSµHWQRWUHpWXGHGHODSODFHGHODSRVW
SRVLWLRQGDQVOHV\QWDJPH6LGDQVO·LQVFULSWLRQ  ۭX۟L۟LYHOFO۟L%
IRUPHXQVHXOV\QWDJPHRQDXUDLWXQH[HPSOHGHUpGXSOLFDWLRQGH
ODSRVWSRVLWLRQGDQVXQV\QWDJPHDYHFXQPRGLILFDWHXUGXQRPGH
W\SHGLIIpUHQWPDLVQRXVDYRQVYXTXHFHWWHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQpWDLWSHX
VDWLVIDLVDQWHSRXUGHVUDLVRQVVpPDQWLTXHV3RXUOHPRPHQWGRQF
PrPHVLFHWDUJXPHQW(%0#.!)$#6SHXWSDUDvWUHIDLEOHRQGRLWSRVHU
TXHFHWWHUpGXSOLFDWLRQQHVHIDLWTXHSRXUOHVV\QWDJPHV´'pP1µ
YRLUHTXHSRXUOHVV\QWDJPHV´!4(VXEVWDQWLI µ
RO
6XUFHWWHJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQHQDFWHYRLU+DJqJHIHQ
SDUW´/DJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQpWDQWXQSURFHVVXVG\QDPLTXHLODUULYH
WUqVVRXYHQWTXHSRXUXQHPrPHXQLWpOHVWDGHHQFRUHOH[pPDWLTXH
HWOHVWDGHGpMjJUDPPDWLFDOLVpFRH[LVWHQWµ
R:
6XUFHVFDXVHVYRLUYDQ+HHPVVRXVSUHVVHD
RQ
/HUXVVHOLWWpUDLUHFRQQDvWpJDOHPHQWFHWWHUpGXSOLFDWLRQGHO·DGSR
VLWLRQ DYHFOHVSUpSRVLWLRQV 6$%E$M6c%6$%0(>M6c%6$%&(-'0)M# ´GHFHWWH
GDPHPrPHµ,7RXUJXHQLHY*64d%*64d%*64äFLWpGDQV&RUEHWW
 RODSUpSRVLWLRQ6$ 2ULJLQH HVWDGMRLQWHjFKDTXHpOpPHQWGX
V\QWDJPH&HWWHH[WHQVLRQGHODSUpSRVLWLRQDFODLUHPHQWSRXUIRQF
WLRQGHPDUTXHUODFRKpUHQFHV\QWDJPDWLTXH,OUHVWHTXHFHWWHWRXU
QXUHHVWG·HPSORLWUqVOLPLWpHWTXDVLPRUWHHQUXVVHFRQWHPSRUDLQ
9&KHQWVRYDFRPPXQLFDWLRQSHUVRQQHOOH 
 oi.uchicago.edu

<O?% DL%T<B%O88A7

SOXVV€UG·DVVXUHUODFRKpUHQFHV\QWDJPDWLTXHHQUDLVRQGHO·LPSRVVLELOLWpGDQVODTXHOOHOHORFXWHXUpWUXVTXHHVW
GDQVELHQGHVFDVGHGLVWLQJXHUOHPRUSKqPHFDVXHOjFDXVHGHODV\QFRSHGHVYR\HOOHVSRVWWRQLTXHV \FRPSULV
OHVYR\HOOHVGpVLQHQWLHOOHVORUVTX·HOOHVVHWURXYHQWGHYDQWODSRVWSRVLWLRQ /HSULQFLSDOLQWpUrWGXWpPRLJQDJHGH
O·pWUXVTXHHVWDORUVTX·LOQRXVGRQQHjVDLVLUXQHPRUSKpPDWLVDWLRQHQDFWHGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQTX·RQQHUHSqUHHQ
JpQpUDOTX·HQ´DYDOµVLO·RQSHXWGLUHHWTX·RQHVWFRQGXLWjUHFRQVWUXLUHR<HQG·DXWUHVWHUPHVOHPDWpULHOpWUXVTXH
DPqQHjUHSRVHUODTXHVWLRQGHFHTX·HVWXQPRUSKqPHHWGHFHTX·HVWXQHDGSRVLWLRQ4XDQWDX[SDUDOOqOHVOLQJXLV
WLTXHVRRQRXVQHPHQWLRQQHURQVLFLTXHODSDUWLFXOHP\FpQLHQQHMI#HWKRPpULTXH‫ݵ‬ԆjODTXHOOHQRXVDYRQVGpMj
FRQVDFUpXQHpWXGHHWTXLDOHPpULWHGHPRQWUHUXQHpYROXWLRQGDQVOHORQJWHUPHG·XQpOpPHQWTXLDWRXWHVOHV
FDUDFWpULVWLTXHVG·XQHSRVWSRVLWLRQHWTXLSHXjSHXHVWVHQWLHWHPSOR\pFRPPHXQYpULWDEOHPRUSKqPHFDVXHO
(QHIIHWTXRLTXHO·pOpPHQWP\FMI#KRP‫ݵ‬ԆVRLWJpQpUDOHPHQWFRQVLGpUpFRPPHXQPRUSKqPHFDVXHOR@%8>%=F9
VqGHSOXVLHXUVWUDLWVPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHVW\SLTXHVGHVDGSRVLWLRQV  LQGLIIpUHQFHDXQRPEUHDORUVTX·HQJUHF
OHVPDUTXHVFDVXHOOHVLQWqJUHQWODGLVWLQFWLRQJpQpULTXH  PDUTXDJHG·XQVHXOpOpPHQWGXV\QWDJPHPrPHVL
FRPPHHQpWUXVTXHMI#‫ݵ‬ԆSHXWrWUHpWHQGXjWRXVOHVpOpPHQWVGXV\QWDJPH  YHVWLJHVGHUHFWLRQSUREDEOHV
GpMjHQP\FpQLHQDYHFGHVIRUPHVFRPPH!M-!MI(M$!Mc6MI#ROHM6MTXLSUpFqGHOD´SRVWSRVLWLRQµFDFKHSUREDEOH
PHQWXQHGpVLQHQFHGHGDWLISOXU,OVHUDLWpWRQQDQWHWDVVH]pWUDQJHUjODVWUXFWXUHOLQJXLVWLTXHGXJUHFTX·RQ
DLWXQGRXEOHPDUTXDJHFDVXHO ‫ڗ‬Ԇۭ‫ݵ‬Ԇ DORUVTXHODIRUPHHVWOLPSLGHVLO·RQIDLWGHMI#‫ݵ‬ԆXQHSRVWSRVLWLRQ
(QG·DXWUHVWHUPHVWRXWODLVVHSHQVHUTXHOHP\FpQLHQHWOHJUHFKRPpULTXHFRQQDLVVDLHQWXQHVLWXDWLRQHQELHQ
GHVSRLQWVVHPEODEOHjFHOOHTXHQRXVREVHUYRQVHQpWUXVTXH

TB(29?@=D9?DE(=D(FGH;:@?>FH:@<9(E>;(FGH??<;=
8QDXWUHpFDUWjODQRUPHGHO·DFFRUGLQWUDV\QWDJPDWLTXHFRQFHUQHFHWWHIRLVOHVIRUPHVDUWLFXOpHVTXLVHUYHQW
GHPRGLILFDWHXUjODWrWHGX61GDQVOHVV\QWDJPHV´1$GMµRO·DGMHFWLIHVWLQWURGXLWSDUXQDUWLFOH GXW\SHG#.4M#%
>1)#M4.!M$%´DXFRXUVGX]LOशFHOXL>1)# HQHIIHWO·DGMHFWLIQ·HVWFRQWUHWRXWHDWWHQWHMDPDLVIOpFKL

-:>=D(?<KU@9H:<@;D(#=VMH;:B.(3MH;:
/·pWXGHFRPELQDWRLUHPRQWUHTXHGHX[W\SHVGHPRGLILFDWHXUVGDQVOHVV\QWDJPHVQRPLQDX[VRQWHPSOR\pV
OHV$GMHWOHV1DXJpQLWLIDGQRPLQDO2UHOOHUpYqOHXQFRPSRUWHPHQWWUqVGLIIpUHQWGHFHVpOpPHQWV'DQVOHFDV
GpMjFLWpGHPXQLFOH۟O·LQYDULDELOLWpGHO·DGMHFWLIHVWFDFKpHSDUGHVSKpQRPqQHVGHVXUIDFH >1)#pWDQWXQ$GMHQ
M#VRQORFLQVWUHVWKRPRSKRQHHWKRPRJUDSKHGHO·DEV PDLVHOOHHVWELHQYLVLEOHTXDQGOHVV\QWDJPHVVRQWDX
JpQLWLIRXTXDQGRQDDIIDLUHjXQ$GMRODGpVLQHQFHG·DEVROXWLIQ·HVWSDVDPELJXs&RPSDURQV
 UL۟QDLWXOD KLYXVWUD
 $GM6D9$UWJpQ% +JpQSRVWS
 YLSLQDOWUD XOशQLۭੜ OD
% 4JpQSRVWS $GM " 6D9$UWJpQ
RM$-(UpJLWOHJpQ
 >1)#M4.(M$
 $GM6D9$UWJpQSRVWS
RM$ ۟L UpJLWOHJpQ

R<
&HVSKpQRPqQHVGHUHQIRUFHPHQWSKRQpWLTXHGHVGpVLQHQFHVSDU
FRDOHVFHQFHGHPRUSKqPHVVRQWELHQFRQQXVQRXVQHPHQWLRQQH
URQVLFLTXHODGpVLQHQFHGHJpQSOXUODWLQ‫گ‬UXPIRUJpHDQDORJL
TXHPHQWjSDUWLUGHčUXPFRPPHXQHIRUPHpWRIIpHGHM1> JUDSKLH
DUFM6> 
RR
3RXUXQSDUDOOqOHLQWpUHVVDQWFDUSURYHQDQWG·XQHDLUHOLQJXLVWLTXH
HQpWURLWFRQWDFWDYHFOD]RQHG·H[SDQVLRQGHO·pWUXVTXHYRLUO·DUWLFOH
GH33RFFHWWLGDQVFHYROXPH/HSDUDOOpOLVPHHVWWUqVpWURLWSXLVTXH
OHVDWWHVWDWLRQVLWDOLTXHVFRQFHUQHQWpJDOHPHQWODSRVWSRVLWLRQM!)%
GHORFDOLVDWLRQGDQVO·HVSDFH2QSRXUUDLWDLQVLDYRLUDIIDLUHVRLWjXQ
SKpQRPqQHG·HPSUXQWV\QWD[LTXHjO·pWUXVTXHSDUXQRXSOXVLHXUV
GLDOHFWHVVDEHOOLTXHVVRLWjXQHLVRJORVVHFRPPXQHjGHX[ODQJXHV
GHGHX[JURXSHVOLQJXLVWLTXHVGLIIpUHQWV

YDQ+HHPVVRXVSUHVVH
R@
&I%DUWRQ̍N²/·pWXGHODSOXVFRPSOqWHVXUFHWWHILQDOH
UHVWHQpDQPRLQVFHOOHTXH0/HMHXQHDSURSRVpHGDQVVHVAU>6#-!0%
"!%I+#.6.65#!%>'4U)#!))! /HMHXQH 

/DOHFWXUHGXM(MTXLSUpFqGHODSRVWSRVLWLRQQ·HVWWRXWHIRLVSDV
WRWDOHPHQWV€UH FIK88Q 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <33,KH%7\K%N8%HQ7<33,KH% <OO

 ]HULF]HFD۟HOLߓ% ɍDFQLFOD%W%FLO۟OߓSXUDOPH۟OXPHVFHQDߓ

  $GM6D9$UWJpQ
RO·DUWLFOHHVWDXJpQLWLIHWFRQJUXDQWGXSRLQWGHYXHFDVXHODYHFWRXVOHVDXWUHVOH[qPHVGHODVpTXHQFHjSDUWLU
GHD۟HOLߓMXVTX·DXSURQRPHQDߓWDQGLVTXHO·$GMߓDFQLQHSRUWHSDVODPDUTXHDWWHQGXHGHJpQ M0 
'DQVFHVFRQGLWLRQVRQGRLWVXSSRVHUTXHGDQVODORQJXHLQVFULSWLRQGHIRQGDWLRQSHLQWHVXUOHSLOLHUFHQWUDO
GHODWRPEHWDUTXLQLHQQHGX7\SKRQ
 !_#`۟NIDQXۭD۟HFODYWQSXPSXVW%041)1Z#@VۭX۟L۟L ૎ LQIOHQ]QDW%WHLVQLFDFDOLSDPDࠃDQLWLQHULW>%$#01%
ۭZMM@‫ؾ‬DPXWQHLSDWUZMMM M @0)#4.$!%W%IOH‫]ؾ‬QHYHVZMM@̩ZM@F૎ZM@ߙZM@‫۟ޢ‬ZM@g%#I૎ Z(>%M@ĤWDQӓZMMM M @H‫ޢ‬FHD۟LV۟QDP
:.!)G)(%g%$!ZMRlM@4!%g%ZMRM@($(ZMM@HQDFF૎HOLW%F̩VDߙLQ۟XQशXPHQDFशӓؐZM@lM@?!-%g%4(.>"@%W%Z(@UQ۟DOODZ-#0(@
OLۭODश࡜ZMRlM@ĤOUZDP۟D@VF‫ד‬HQVW%041)(
OHV\QWDJPHTX·RQHVWDXWRULVpjUHVWLWXHUDX[OO²>$!#@0)#4.$!%:.!)G)!VXUODEDVHGHVOO² :.!)G)(%$!#0)#4( HVW
XQV\QWDJPHDXORFSRVWS´$GM3RVWS1µRO·DGMHFWLIRP%j$!#0)#Q·HVWSDVIOpFKLWDQGLVTXHO·DUWLFOHHVWDXORFLQVWU
HWLOGRLWHQrWUHDLQVLSRXUWRXVOHV$GMHQM#TXLDSSDUDLVVHQWGDQVGHVFRQWH[WHVVLPLODLUHV 0(4)#M4.!M-#2%0(4)#M$.!2%
PXQLFOH۟2%PXQLVYOH۟« 2QVHUDSSHOOHTXHGDQVQRWUHDQDO\VHGHODIRUPHPXQLVYOH۟QRXVDYLRQVELHQSUpFLVp
TXHO·DUWLFOHpWDLWIOpFKLDXORFLQVWUSOXU jM0?.!MgORFLQVWUVLQJM0.! >1)#HQUHYDQFKHQHSRUWHQXOOHPDUTXH
4XDQGOHPRGLILFDWHXUGX1HVWXQDXWUH1HQUHYDQFKHOHFRPSRUWHPHQWHVWGLIIpUHQW7DQW{WLOSUHQGOD
PDUTXHGHJpQ
 HWYH ۟DXUH ODXWQHߓFOH
 $GM8H9K7% +8H9K7% +JpQ$UW8H9K7
 ´JUDQGµ "  ´VpSXOFUHµ ´IDPLOOHµ
 ´/HJUDQGWRPEHDXpWDQWFHOXLGHOD5!)0/HJUDQG " WRPEHDXDSSDUWHQDQWjOD5!)0 « µ LQVWUX
PHQWDODEVROX 
7DQW{WLOQHODSUHQGSDV
 ߓ HODQߓO  FDOXߓWOD
% +JpQ% +6D9$UWJpQ
 ´­6HODQVFHOXL&DOXVµ
&·HVWTXHGDQVOHSUHPLHUFDVOHVXEVWDQWLIHVWDXJpQDGQRPLQDOF·HVWjGLUHTX·LODXQHIRQFWLRQGHPLVHHQ
UHODWLRQWUqVSDUWLFXOLqUHHQWUHODWrWHGXV\QWDJPHHWVRQPRGLILFDWHXUWDQGLVTXHGDQVOHVHFRQGOHQRPFDOXߓ2%
WKpRQ\PHHVWO·pTXLYDOHQWG·XQDGMHFWLIG·pSLFOqVHTXLVSpFLILHjTXHO6HODQVODVWDWXHWWHHVWRIIHUWH'XUHVWHOHV
YpULWDEOHVDGMHFWLIVHPSOR\pVDYHFO·DUWLFOHHWVHUYDQWG·pSLFOqVHGDQVXQHGpQRPLQDWLRQWKpRQ\PLTXHjGHX[
HFM92UHVWHQWELHQLQYDULDEOHVHQpWUXVTXHFRPPHOHSURXYHOHWH[WHYRWLIVXLYDQW
 PDULۭO PHQLWOD
% +JpQ $GM6D9$UWJpQ
 ´­0DULۭFHOXL>!)#µ

29:D;J;I:H:@<9
&HWWHDQRPDOLHGDQVOHFRPSRUWHPHQWV\QWD[LTXHGHVDGMHFWLIVDHOOHDXVVLEHDXFRXSjQRXVDSSUHQGUHVXUOH
VWDWXWGHVIRUPHVDUWLFXOpHVVXUOHU{OHMRXpSDUO·DUWLFXODWLRQHWVHVLQFLGHQFHVVXUOHVSKpQRPqQHVG·DFFRUG/D
GF7MJ%0(4)#M4.(SDUH[HPSOHDXOLHXGHO·DWWHQGXj0(4)#M0M4.(WpPRLJQHG·XQW\SHG·DFFRUGSDUWLFXOLHUFDUDFWpULVp
SDUXQK\SRPDUTXDJH LOV·DJLWVLO·RQYHXWG·XQVRUWHGH´D-1II!):.!]#6)µ G·DXWDQWSOXVSODXVLEOHLFLTX·RQD
DIIDLUHjXQHIRUPHDUWLFXOpHFHUWHVDQDO\VDEOHPDLVROHSURQRPGHYDLWrWUHSHUoXFRPPHSDUWLHLQWpJUDQWH
GXOH[qPHHWSDUFRQVpTXHQWFRPPHXQV\QWDJPHGRQWODFRKpVLRQRXOHGHJUpGHOH[LFDOLVDWLRQGHYDLHQWrWUH

RP
/·LQWHUSUpWDWLRQDGMHFWLYDOHGH$!#0)#HVWIRQGpHQRQVHXOHPHQWVXU 
6XUOHVTXHOOHV&'H6LPRQHDDWWLUpO·DWWHQWLRQYRLU'H6LPRQH
OHIDLWTXHFHOH[qPHHVWLFLDUWLFXOp FHTXLWRXWHIRLVQHVHUDLWSDV IHWSRXUOHSUREOqPHTXLQRXVUHWLHQW
HQVRLVXIILVDQWOHVVXEVWDQWLIVVRQWHX[DXVVLQDWXUHOOHPHQWVRXPLV 
%567%96%GF7MJ2%>!)#DGHIRUWHVFKDQFHVG·rWUHXQDGMHFWLI FIQ 
jO·DUWLFXODWLRQ PDLVDXVVLHWVXUWRXWSDUFHTX·RQSHXWPHWWUHHQ
pYLGHQFHWRXWHXQHFODVVHG·DGMHQM)#%N%.(?$)#´IDPLOLDOJHQWLOLFHµ
0(4)#2%>1)#2%>!)#HWF
 oi.uchicago.edu

<O:% DL%T<B%O88A7

QHWWHPHQWSOXVJUDQGVTXHSRXUXQV\QWDJPH´'pP$GMµ2QDGRQFDIIDLUHXQHIRLVGHSOXVjXQSKpQRPqQHGH
OH[LFDOLVDWLRQSDUWLHOOH'HWRXWHpYLGHQFHWRXWVHSDVVHFRPPHVLSRXUOHVDGMHFWLIVDUWLFXOpVODFRKpVLRQHQWUH
O·DGMHFWLIHWVRQDUWLFOHHVWVLIRUWHTXHVHXOO·pOpPHQWILQDOGXV\QWDJPHjVDYRLUO·DUWLFOHSRUWHODPDUTXHFDVXHOOH
HWSHXWRQDMRXWHUODPDUTXHGHSOXUTXDQGEHVRLQHVW 
8QHTXHVWLRQUHVWHHQVXVSHQVFHWWHLQYDULDELOLWppWDLWHOOHREOLJDWRLUHRXO·DGMHFWLISRXYDLWLOTXDQGPrPH
UHFHYRLUODPDUTXHFDVXHOOHTXHVDIRQFWLRQODLVVHDWWHQGUH"/HVHXOH[HPSOHSRWHQWLHOG·DGMHFWLIIOpFKLHWDUWLFXOp
VHUDLWIRXUQLSDUOHVIDPHXVHVODPHOOHVELOLQJXHVGH3\UJLGXGpEXWGX9JVLqFOHRO·RQWURXYHODIRUPH>1)#0M$(0
,OHVWWRXWHIRLVGLIILFLOHG·\YRLUXQHIRUPHDUWLFXOpHGH>1)#GDQVODPHVXUHROHJpQGXSURQRP$(Q·HVWMDPDLV
j$(02%M689%D8JH%j$.( YRLUOHVIRUPHVSDUDOOqOHVM4.(2%ۭODHWF /HVHXOPR\HQGHVDXYHUFHWWHLQWHUSUpWDWLRQVHUDLW
GRQFGHVXSSRVHUTXHGDQVOD&HUYHWHULGHO·pSRTXHOHSURQRPVXLYDLWXQHGpFOLQDLVRQDOWHUQDWLYHFHTXLQRXV
VHPEOHSRXUOHPRLQVGLIILFLOHjDFFHSWHU$XVVLSRXUOHPRPHQWGHYRQVQRXVFRQFOXUHGHYDQWO·DEVHQFHGH
FRQWUHH[HPSOHVTXHO·DGMHFWLIUHVWHQRUPDOHPHQWLQYDULDEOHORUVTX·LOHVWDUWLFXOp
2QQHV·pWRQQHUDSDVGXSRLQWGHYXHW\SRORJLTXHG·XQWHOSKpQRPqQHGHOH[LFDOLVDWLRQG€jODFRDOHVFHQFH
GHO·DUWLFOHDYHFOHOH[qPHGpWHUPLQpPDLVGDQVOHFDGUHG·XQHODQJXHFRPPHO·pWUXVTXHSRXUODTXHOOHODGRFX
PHQWDWLRQHVWSOXVTXHUHVWUHLQWHFHSRLQWDSSRUWHQRQVHXOHPHQWXQHSLHUUHLPSRUWDQWHjO·pGLILFHJUDPPDWLFDO
jUHFRQVWUXLUHPDLVQRXVGRQQHDXVVLG·LQWpUHVVDQWVLQGLFHVVXUODSHUFHSWLRQTXHSRXYDLHQWDYRLUOHVORFXWHXUV
GHFHVIRUPHVDUWLFXOpHVHOOHVVRQWFODLUHPHQWSHUoXHVFRPPHQHIRUPDQWTX·XQHXQLWp'HVXUFURvWLOVQRXVGRQ
QHQWXQHLGpHFHUWHVODFXQDLUHPDLVSUpFLHXVHGHODFRPSOH[LWpV\QWD[LTXHGHO·pWUXVTXH

$<9?F>E@<9
'XSRLQWGHYXHW\SRORJLTXHRQSRXUUDFRQFOXUHTXHO·pWUXVTXHIDLWSDUWLHGHFHVODQJXHVRO·DFFRUGHVWUHOD
WLYHPHQWFRQWUDLJQDQW3DUUDSSRUWDX[ODQJXHVIOH[LRQQHOOHVHWHQSDUWLFXOLHUDX[ODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHV
LO\FRQQDvWXQHH[WHQVLRQPRLQGUHSRXUFHUWDLQHVFDWpJRULHV RQSHQVHjO·DFFRUGHQQRPEUH PDLVLOPRQWUH
GHVWUDLWVPRUSKRV\QWD[LTXHVGLVWLQFWLIVHVVHQWLHOVTXLPDUTXHQWjOHXUWRXUHQSURIRQGHXUVRQLGHQWLWpOLQJXLV
WLTXHSDUUDSSRUWDX[ODQJXHVTXLO·HQWRXUHQW8QGHFHVWUDLWVOHVSOXVLQWpUHVVDQWVHVWjQRWUHVHQVO·LQFLGHQFH
GHO·pFKHOOHGHGpILQLWLRQVXUWRXVOHVSKpQRPqQHVG·DFFRUGQRQVHXOHPHQWSRXUO·DFFRUGHQQRPEUHHWHQJHQUH
DQLPpLQDQLPp PDLVDXVVLTXRLTXHGHPDQLqUHSOXVVXEWLOHSRXUO·DFFRUGHQFDVVHORQGHVPRGDOLWpVTX·RQQH
UHWURXYHSDVGDQVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURSpHQQHVYRLVLQHV(QILQO·XQGHVLQWpUrWVSULQFLSDX[TX·RIIUHO·pWXGHGH
ODPRUSKRV\QWD[HpWUXVTXHjWUDYHUVOHSULVPHGHODV\QWD[HGXFDVHVWG·RIIULUGHVDSHUoXVGXGpYHORSSHPHQW
GLDFKURQLTXHGHFHWWHODQJXH


9RLUOHVIRUPHVGpMjFRPPHQWpHVPXQLVYOH۟PXQLVXOH۟

(QFRUHXQHIRLVRQDXQHLOOXVWUDWLRQGHO·LQFLGHQFHGHOD"U:#)#$#6)%
VXUODPRUSKRV\QWD[HpWUXVTXHSXLVTXHO·HPSORLGHO·DUWLFOHGpILQL
LQIOXHFODLUHPHQWVXUO·DFFRUG/HVFKpPDUHSUpVHQWpSDUO·pWUXVTXH
RO·DUWLFOHGHYLHQWOHVHXOpOpPHQWGHUHODWLRQDYHFODWrWHGXV\Q
WDJPHHVWWUqVUpSDQGXGDQVOHVODQJXHVGXPRQGHYRLUODVLWXDWLRQ
GHO·KpEUHXRO·DUWLFOHGpILQL+(PDUTXHWRXVOHVpOpPHQWVG·XQV\Q
WDJPHGpILQL³FIED\Lࠂ\DIqK´XQHEHOOHPDLVRQµYVKDED\Lࠂ\DIqK%
´ODPDLVRQHVWEHOOHµYVKDED\LࠂKD\DIqK´ODEHOOHPDLVRQµ OLWW.(M
>(#06)%.(M&!..! 
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <33,KH%7\K%N8%HQ7<33,KH% <OQ

#99DCDE

5HUFDH>(6<;JN<F<L@S>D
( ( WFDC@<9(=DE(J;<9<KEMH=VD?:@WE(D9?F@:@S>DE(D9(W<9?:@<9(=GH;:@?FDEXY

FDV ۭD FDWD VD

HFM8H6K8G ۭD M4(%l%M$( M0(
DFFXVDWLI  M4)%l%M$) ߓQ
JpQLWLI ۭOD M4.(%l%M$.( M
³ m M$(0 " ³
98HIL>8J7
JpQLWLISRVWS  M4.(M$ 
ORFDWLILQVWU  M4.!M M0.!f%M0! "
ORFDWLILQVWU
 FOH۟2%M4.!M$ 
SRVWS
HFM8H6K8G ۭ੩ YD M4?( M0?(
=>L78J> ORFDWLILQVWU PXQLVYOH۟2%
 
SRVWS PXQLVXOH۟

29E?;@J:@<9E
 8*7DVDUFRSKDJHG·DOEkWUH7DUTXLQLDFD²
 8*7DFLSSHGHWXI7DUTXLQLDILQ,9J;**JV
 8*7DpSLWDSKHSHLQWHVXUOHVPXUVGHODW7DUTXLQLD,,JV
 8*9HLQVFULSWLRQYDVFXODLUH9pLHV9,JV
 8*9W²XUQHFLQpUDLUHGHWXI9ROWHUUD,,,J;*J7V
 8*9VpSLWDSKHJUDYpHVXUO·DUFKLWUDYHG·XQHWRPEH9ROVLQLHVILQ9,J²GpEXW9JV
 8*7D²WRPEHGHV%RXFOLHUV7DUTXLQLD,9JVV\QWDJPHUHFRQVWLWXpjSDUWLUGHVRFFXUUHQFHVGHV
GHX[LQVFULSWLRQVSHLQWHV
 8*9FVDUFRSKDJHG·DOEkWUH9XOFLFD
 8*%//SDVVLP YRLUSDUH[FRO,,,O OLYUHGHOLQeJ\SWH,J7V
 8*%$7VDUFRSKDJH0XVDUQDFD²
 8*&USLOLHUFHQWUDOGHODWRPEHGHV&ODYWLH3.(1"##&DHUp,9JV
 *(&36-$%$WDEOHHQEURQ]H&RUWRQH,,JV
 8*7DVDUFRSKDJHGHODWRPEHGHV$QLQD7DUTXLQLDILQ,,,JV
 8*9FFLSSHGHWXI9XOFLpSRTXHUpFHQWH
 8*$7VDUFRSKDJH%OHUD,9J;***JV
 8*%7DLQVFULSWLRQSHLQWHVXUOHVPXUVGHODWRPEH%UXVFKL7DUTXLQLD,,JV
 8*7DVDUFRSKDJHGHODWRPEHGHV3XOHQD7DUTXLQLDPLOLHXGX,,,JV
 8*//9,,
 8*&U>VHORQOHVOHoRQ0DJJLDQLQHWLGHP@VDUFRSKDJHGHODWRPEHGHV7DPVQLH
&DHUpPLOLHXGX,9JV


'DQVFHWDEOHDXOHWLUHWPDUTXHOHVIRUPHVQRQDWWHVWpHVTXHO·RQ 6·LOHVWSHUPLVG·DQDO\VHUDLQVLODIRUPHFHXߓQTXLDSSDUDvWVXUOD


HVWWRXWHIRLVHQGURLWGHUHFRQVWUXLUHjSDUWLUGHVIRUPHVDWWHVWpHV "!:#]#6GH0RQWH3LWWL 8*3RO 

SRXUOHVDXWUHVSURQRPV/HVFRORQQHVPDQTXDQWHVHQUHYDQFKH
VLJQDOHQWXQHSDUWLHGXSDUDGLJPHTXLQ·HVWDWWHVWpHSRXUDXFXQGHV
WURLVSURQRPVDGMHFWLIV
 oi.uchicago.edu

<O<% DL%T<B%O88A7

 FILQVFULSWLRQ
 %HQHOOLQLQVFULSWLRQJUDYpHVXUODSDURLVXUSORPEDQWXQHURXWH&HUYHWHUL QpFURSROHGHOD(
%DQGLWDFFLD pSRTXHUpFHQWH
 *(&36-$%²
 8*%7DPXUGHODWRPEHGHV6SLWX7DUTXLQLD,,,JV
 FILQVFULSWLRQ
 FILQVFULSWLRQ
 8*LQVFULSWLRQJUDYpHVXUOHSLOLHUFHQWUDOGHODWRPEHGX7\SKRQ7DUTXLQLDPLOLHXWURLVLqPHTXDUW
GX,,,JV
 FILQVFULSWLRQ
 8*%$7VDUFRSKDJHGHODWRPEHGHV$OH۟QD0XVDUQDPLOLHXGX,,,JV
 8*$7VDUFRSKDJHGHODWRPEHGHV$OH۟QD0XVDUQDGHUQLHUTXDUWGX,,,JV
 8*9WFRORPEHGHEURQ]HLQVFULWH&DVDELDQFD 9ROWHUUD pSRTXHUpFHQWH
 8*7&´WXLOHGH&DSRXHµ WDEOHGHWHUUHFXLWH &DSRXH9JV
 8*7&
 8*7&²
 8*$7VDUFRSKDJHGHODWRPEHGHVऺXUशOH1RUFKLDFD²
 8*9FVWqOHGHWXIGHODWRPEHGHV,QVFULSWLRQVpSRTXHUpFHQWH
 8*7DLQVFULSWLRQSHLQWHVXUXQPXUGHODWRPEHGHV%RXFOLHUV7DUTXLQLD,9JV
 8*%$7PXUGHWRPEHjFKDPEUHDSSDUWHQDQWDX[݅DQVLQD6DQ*LXOLDQRVHFRQGHPRLWLpGX,9JV
 8*7DVDUFRSKDJHGHODWRPEHGHV&DPQD7DUTXLQLD,,,JV
 8*7DVWqOH7DUTXLQLDpSRTXHUpFHQWH
 8*%//SDVVLP YRLUSDUH[FRO9OO² 
 FILQVFU
 8*%7DLQVFULSWLRQSHLQWHVXUOHVPXUVGHODWRPEH%UXVFKL7DUTXLQLD,,JV
 8*%9FVDUFRSKDJHGHODWRPEHGHV6DUFRSKDJHV9XOFLGHX[LqPHTXDUWGX,,,JV
 K88QSS²±QRFKRpGHEURQ]H9XOFL " GHX[LqPHPRLWLpGX9JV
 FILQVFULSWLRQ
 8*//9²
 FILQVFULSWLRQ
 8*3HPXUGHO·K\SRJpHGH6DQ0DQQR3pURXVH,,JVLqFOH
 8*&RVWDWXHWWHYRWLYHHQEURQ]HUHSUpVHQWDQWXQFKLHQRXXQORXS&RUWRQHpSRTXHUpFHQWH
 8*$9LQVFULSWLRQVXUGLVTXHGHSORPE0DJOLDQR 9XOFL PLOLHXGX9JV

#U;IZ@H:@<9E
3/N% 36-I10%/)04-#I$#6)1>%N($#)(-1>²
8* +HOPXW5L[pG8$-10=#04+!%*!]$!YROXPHV7ELQJHQ*1DUU
K88%% K#?#0$(%"#%!I#5-(:#(%!$-104(L%7$1"#%8$-104+#L
*(&36-$% /XFLDQR!IF9K8H86H8%JK%)UDQFHVFR1LFRVLD*(&1.(%36-$6)!)0#06WXGLD$UFKDHRORJLFD5RPH
´/·(UPDµGL%UHWVFKQHLGHU

[@UF@<L;HJN@D
$JRVWLQLDQL/XFLDQR
  ´&RQWULEXWLRQjO·pWXGHGHO·pSLJUDSKLHHWGHODOLQJXLVWLTXHpWUXVTXHVµN(.#!0²
  ´/DFRQVLGHUD]LRQHWLSRORJLFDQHOORVWXGLRGHOO·HWUXVFRµ/)46)$-#%N#)51#0$#4#²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% <33,KH%7\K%N8%HQ7<33,KH% <OR

  ´6XLQXPHUDOLHWUXVFKLHODORURUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQHµ<))(.#%"!..;/)0$#$1$6%\)#?!-0#$(-#6%,-#!)$(.!%"!%B(M
I6.#2%7!G#6)!%N#)51#0$#4(²
%DUWRQ̍N$QWRQtQ
% :??Q% O()"&14+%"!0%>'=!)#04+!)%D-#!4+#04++HLGHOEHUJ:LQWHU
%HOILRUH9DOHQWLQD
% :?O?% /.%-8DJ7%>8HKJL9%"#%t(5(&-#(L%*!0$1(.#$h%!%46)$!)1$63LVH5RPH)6HUUD
%HQHOOL(QULFR
( :??@% /04-#G#6)#%!$-104+!g%N!55!-.!%!%4(I#-.!$QF{QH6DFL
&LXUOHWWL*LDQQLHW)UDQFR0DU]DWLFRpGV
% OPPP% /%K!$#%l%"#!%Ka$!-%7UHQWH$FWHVGX&ROORTXH
&RORQQD*LRYDQQL
  ´(SLJUDILHWUXVFKHHODWLQHDFRQIURQWRµ'DQV%<$$#%"!..;i/%46)5-!006%#)$!-)(G#6)(.!%"#%!I#5-(:#(%5-!4(%!%
.($#)(9ROXPHSS²5RPH4XDVDU
  ´,OVDQWXDULRGL3\UJLGDOOHRULJLQLPLWLVWRULFKHDJOLDOWRULOLHYLIURQWRQDOLGHL6HWWHHGL/HXFRWHDµ
74#!)G!%"!..;<)$#4+#$h²
&RUEHWW*UHYLOOH
  ´1XPEHUµ'DQVN()51(5!%*'I6.65'%()"%N()51(5!%\)#?!-0(.0g%<)%/)$!-)($#6)(.%O()"&66=2%1F>LMJ%O2%
pGLWpSDU0+DVSHOPDWK(.|QLJ:2HVWHUUHLFKHUHW:5DLEOHSS²%HUOLQ:GH*UX\WHU
  <5-!!>!)$&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
"789KFG6H82%06L7F%
% OPPR% *(&1.(%3(I1()(g%\)%4(.!)"(-#6%:!0$#?6%"#%!$h%(-4(#4()ORUHQFH/62OVFKNL
3J%$8MFHJ2%"67>F%
  /%*#--!)#%(%N!>)60g%8?#"!)G(%.#)51#0$#4(%!%$-("#G#6)#%0$6-#4+!)ORUHQFH/62OVFKNL
  ´'pQRPLQDWLRQVGLYLQHVpWUXVTXHVELQDLUHVFRQVLGpUDWLRQVSUpOLPLQDLUHVµ'DQVN!0%Q$-10X1!02%.!0%
I.10%-!.#5#!1]%"!0%+6>>!0pGLWpSDU'%ULTXHOHW)*DXOWLHUSS²3DULVeFROHGX/RXYUH
  ´(WUXVFRH¶WLUUHQR·GL/HPQRV¶8UYHUZDQGWVFKDIW·"µK#?#0$(%"#%:#.6.65#(%!%"#%#0$-1G#6)!%4.(00#4(
²
  ´,7LUUHQLD/HPQRV3DUDOLSRPHQDPHWRGRORJLFL QRQFKpWHRULFL µ,0$-(=(²
  ´,7LUUHQLGL/HPQRVµ'DQVD.#%8$-104+#g%3($(.651!%"!%.;!]I60#$#6)%^T!)#0!2%npppqnpp_`pGLWpSDU0
#F7J>>82%SS²0LODQ%RPSLDQL
*ROGPDQQ(PLO
  B!1!%S!#$-a5!%G1-%N!+-!%?6>%#)"65!->()#04+!)%3+(-(=$!-%"!-%!$-10=#04+!)%7I-(4+!9LHQQH*HUROG
+DJqJH&ODXGH
  ´/HVSURFHVVXVGHJUDPPDWLFDOLVDWLRQµ'DQVN()51(5!%*'I6.65'%()"%N()51(5!%\)#?!-0(.0g%<)%/)$!-M
)($#6)(.%O()"&66=9ROXPHpGLWpSDU0+DVSHOPDWK(.|QLJ:2HVWHUUHLFKHUHW:5DLEOHSS
²%HUOLQ:GH*UX\WHU
/D]DUG*LOEHUW
% OPP<% N;<4$()4!3DULV3UHVVHV8QLYHUVLWDLUHVGH)UDQFH
/HMHXQH0LFKHO
  ´/DGpVLQHQFH‫ݵ‬ԆHQP\FpQLHQµ'DQVAU>6#-!0%"!%I+#.6.65#!%>'4U)#!))!2%pGLWpSDU0/HMHXQHSS
²3DULV&HQWUH1DWLRQDOGHOD5HFKHUFKH6FLHQWLILTXH
0DJJLDQL$GULDQR
  ´$SSXQWLVXOOHPDJLVWUDWXUHHWUXVFKHµ7$1"#%8$-104+#²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% DL%T<B%O88A7

  ´0DJLVWUDWXUHFLWWDGLQHPDJLVWUDWXUHIHGHUDOLµ'DQVN(%.!5(%!$-104(g%H(..(%"6"!4(I6.#%(#%X1#)"!4#>%
I6I1.#% $FWHVGHODMRXUQpHG·pWXGH&KLXVL SS²5RPH,VWLWXWL(GLWRULDOLH3ROLJUDILFL
,QWHUQD]LRQDOL
067692%36H8J>J%
  ´/DGHD7KDQUHOHFHUFKLHGLYLQHLQ(WUXULDQXRYHDFTXLVL]LRQLµ7$1"#%8$-104+#²
5L[+HOPXW
% OPPQ% ´/DVFULWWXUDHODOLQJXDµ'DQVD.#%8$-104+#g%\)(%)16?(%#>>(5#)!pGLWpSDU0&ULVWRIDQLSS²
)ORUHQFH*LXQWL
  ´/·HWUXVFRWUDO·,WDOLDHLOPRQGRPHGLWHUUDQHRµ'DQV%N;/$(.#(%!%#.%>!"#$!--()!6%()$#46% $FWHVGXFROOR
TXHGHOD6,*)LVFLDQR$PDOIL5DLWR pGLWpSDU$/DQGLSS²3LVH*LDUGLQL
  Ka$#04+%1)"%8$-10=#04+,QQVEUXFN,QVWLWXWIU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW
  ´/DVHFRQGDPHWjGHOQXRYRWHVWRGL&RUWRQDµ'DQV%N(%#6DL>6%"F7KFHJH989%!%#.%016%46)$!0$6%0$6-#46M
(-4+!6.65#46 $FWHVGXFROORTXH5RPH SS²5RPH&RQVLJOLR1D]LRQDOHGHOOH5LFHUFKH
$KJ8HD6LJ72%38JKJ7%
  ´=XU*UDELQVFKULIWGHU/DUWKL&LOQHLDXV$ULWLP$UUHWLXP$UH]]Rµt!#$04+-#:$%:u-%@(I'-6.65#!%1)"%
8I#5-(I+#=²
% OPPP% B!1!0%O()"&14+%"!0%8$-10=#04+!)6W.DWKDULQHQ6FULSWD0HUFDWXUDH
#F7=2%!>G%
% OP?:% 8$-10=#04+!%S!#$-a5!9ROXPH/HLS]LJ%DUWK
7URPEHWWL$OIUHGR
  N(%N#)51(%!$-104(g%D-(>>($#4(2%$!0$#%46)%46>>!)$62%0(55#%"#%$-("1G#6)!%#)$!-.#)!(-!2%.!00#46)ORUHQFH5LQD
VFLPHQWRGHO/LEUR
16H%(JJM92%48>>J9%
  ´/DFRSXODHODIUDVHQRPLQDOHQHOOHLVFUL]LRQLIXQHUDULHGL7DUTXLQLDµ'DQVH#)(>#4+!%"#%0?#.1II6%
"!..!%4#$$h%)!..;8$-1-#(%>!-#"#6)(.!g%T!#62%3(!-!2%*(-X1#)#(%!%T1.4#SS²5RPH,VWLWXWL(GLWRULDOLH
3ROLJUDILFL,QWHUQD]LRQDOL
  ´/·LQVFULSWLRQGHO·±QRFKRpGH0RQWSHOOLHUXQIRUPXODLUHRULJLQDOµAU.()5!0%"!%.;Q46.!%F-()R(#0!%"!%
K6>!²
% :??P% ´/LUHpFULUHFRPSWHUTXHOTXHVUpIOH[LRQVHWK\SRWKqVHVVXUOHV\VWqPHQXPpUDOpWUXVTXHHQ
PDUJHGHVWUDYDX[GH0LFKHO/HMHXQHµ'DQV<1$61-%"!%AL%N!c!1)!pGLWpSDU)%LYLOOHHW,%RHKPSS
²/\RQ0DLVRQGHO·2ULHQWHWGHOD0pGLWHUUDQpH
9FL9%=7J99J ´/HORFDWLIHWODIRUPDWLRQGHVFDVREOLTXHVHQeWUXVTXHµ'DQVN(%@(-6.(%"!.%@(00($6
:\OLQ.RHQ
  ´8QWHU]RSURQRPHDJJHWWLYRGLPRVWUDWLYRHWUXVFR0(Y%7$1"#%8$-104+#²
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7YB*OZ78g%*O8%HYB<A/37%,F%3<78%m%K83<@/*\N<*/,B%<BH%F\*\K8%H/K83*/,B7% <O@

!"
#$%&'(#)*+&')+,$%-./0#+12+0-#)+3++
4)0-5/&67-&/1%+-%,+26&64)+,/4)0&/1%#

D!)!%D-(552%\)#?!-0#$'%6:%3+#4(56

$VWKHGHVLJQDWHGDPDQXHQVLVRIWKLVFRQIHUHQFHP\WDVNZDVWRGUDZXSWKHPLQXWHVWKHSURFqVYHUEDORI
ZKDWWKHWKUHHGD\VKDYHEHHQDERXWRIZKDWKDVEHHQDFFRPSOLVKHG5HFRUGHGPLQXWHVDUHRIFRXUVHLQWHQGHG
WRGUDZRXWDVWUXFWXUHDQDUUDWLYHIURPMX[WDSRVLWLRQRISRVVLEO\XQIRUHVHHDEOHLQWHUDFWLRQV³EXWWRWKHH[WHQW
WKDWZHJHWLWULJKWLWFDQVXJJHVWWKHVWUXFWXUHQDUUDWLYHWKDWUHDOO\GLGHPHUJH:LWKWKLVLQPLQGZKDWLQIDFW
,RIIHUDUHDFRXSOHYHU\JHQHUDOUHPDUNVIROORZHGE\DKLJKO\SHUVRQDOUHDVRQHGFDWDORJRIWKHFRPPXQLFDWLRQV
7KHJRDORIWKHFRQIHUHQFHZDVWKHH[SORUDWLRQRI´9DULDWLRQVFRQFXUUHQFHHWpYROXWLRQGHVFDVµZKLFKLVRI
FRXUVHYHU\JHQHUDOTXDOLILHG´GDQVGLYHUVGRPDLQHVOLQJXLVWLTXHVµZKLFKLVSUREDEO\PRUHYDJXHWKDQWKHDFWXDO
XQGHUWDNLQJ,QIDFW,WKLQNWKHUHZDVDVWURQJJHROLQJXLVWLFXQLW\WRWKHGDWDFRQVLGHUHGKHUH%\DQGODUJH,
EHOLHYHFDVHZDVWDNHQE\DOPRVWDOOFRQIHUHQFHSDUWLFLSDQWVLQWKHWUDGLWLRQDOVHQVHRILQIOHFWLRQDOPRUSKRORJ\
³LQWKHVHQVHLQZKLFKWRFLWHDSKUDVHXVHGPRUHWKDQRQFH´&KLQHVHKDVQRFDVHµ7KHFRQIHUHQFHZDVWKXV
FRQFHUQHGFHQWUDOO\ZLWKODQJXDJHVKDYLQJLQIOHFWLRQDOPRUSKRORJ\DQGWKHWZRODQJXDJHIDPLOLHVSDUH[FHOOHQFH
PHHWLQJWKLVUHTXLUHPHQWDQGKDYLQJDULFKDQGGHHSGRFXPHQWHGDWWHVWDWLRQDUH,QGR(XURSHDQDQG6HPLWLF
,QIDFWLWZDVIRFXVHGKHDYLO\RQWKHFLUFXP0HGLWHUUDQHDQPHPEHUVRIWKRVHIDPLOLHV³H[WUDSRODWLQJDVIDUDV
2OG3HUVLDQDQG7RFKDULDQWRWKH(DVWDQGDUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRI%DOWLF6ODYLFDQG*HUPDQLFWRWKH:HVW,QDGGL
WLRQWKHUHZDVDJRRGVDPSOLQJRIWKHQRQ,QGR(XURSHDQQRQ6HPLWLFFRQWDFWDQGFRQWH[WODQJXDJHV)LQQR
8JULFDQG(WUXVFDQLQWKH:HVWDQG+XUULDQ6XPHULDQDQG(ODPLWHWRWKH(DVW,WKLQNZHKDGDERXWDVJRRGD
FRPELQDWLRQRIGHSWKDQGYDULHW\DVLVSRVVLEOHLQWKHWKUHHGD\VDWRXUGLVSRVDO,QIDFWWKHUHDUHVXEVHTXHQFHV
RISDSHUVWKDWFRQVWLWXWHLQP\RSLQLRQPLQLFROORTXLDZKLFKZLOOVWDQGRQWKHLURZQULJKWDVQRWDEOHHYHQWVLQ
WKHVWXG\RIFDVHLQILHOGVRI6HPLWLF$QDWROLDQDQG,WDOLF
)URPWKHSRLQWRIYLHZRIOLQJXLVWLFWKHRU\ZHZHUHHFOHFWLFDQGWKHSDSHUVUHSUHVHQWHGWKHPDLQVWUHDPLQ
RXUYDULRXVGLVFLSOLQHV³DPDLQVWUHDP,VKRXOGSRLQWRXWWKDWLVDOZD\VDQJMJ7I8HIPDLQVWUHDP \RXFDQQRW
VWHSLQWRWKHVDPHLGHQWLFDOPDLQVWUHDPWZLFH 7KHFHQWUDOLW\RIFDVHIRUOLQJXLVWLFVFDQQRWEHH[DJJHUDWHG
&DVHLVDVDUHFHQWFROOHFWLRQRIDUWLFOHVSRLQWVRXW´RQHRIWKHPDLQUHDOL]DWLRQVRIWKHUHODWLRQEHWZHHQIRUP
DQGPHDQLQJµ +RRSHWDO $VLQKHULWRUVDOORIXVRIPRUHRUOHVVORQJWUDGLWLRQVRIFDUHIXOWH[WXDOVWXG\
RIWKHPDQLIHVWDWLRQVRILQIOHFWLRQDOPRUSKRORJ\RXUSRLQWRIGHSDUWXUHLVDWWKHRSSRVLWHSROHIURPZKDWZH
PLJKWSURMHFWDVD´UHGXFWLRQLVWµYLHZ VRFKDUDFWHUL]HGE\%RXFKDUGLQWKHDERYHPHQWLRQHGFROOHFWLRQ 
DFWXDOO\DFDULFDWXUHWKDWDOOODQJXDJHVDUHDOLNHLI\RXJHWGRZQGHHSHQRXJKDQGWKDWPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVH
ZKLFKDSSHDUVLQVRPHODQJXDJHVLVVLPSO\DVXSHUILFLDOHSLSKHQRPHQRQ³DUHODWLYHO\LQVLJQLILFDQWODVWPLQXWH
VSHOORXWLQWKHSURFHVVRISURGXFLQJVSHHFK2QWKHFRQWUDU\LIPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHLVLPSRUWDQWLWLVLPSRUWDQW
WRNQRZKRZODQJXDJHVJHWPRUSKRORJLFDOO\HQFRGHGFDVHKRZWKH\XVHWKHPKRZWKH\WUDQVIRUPWKHPDQG
KRZWKH\ORVHWKHP
,QWKLVFRQWH[WLWLVHQFRXUDJLQJDQGLQVWUXFWLYHWRILQGWKHIROORZLQJUHPDUNE\DQLPSRUWDQWFRQWULEXWRU
WRFRQWHPSRUDU\V\QFKURQLFDQGGLDFKURQLFWKHRU\3DXO.LSDUVN\LQDQRWDEOHFRQWULEXWLRQRQ´6WUXFWXUDO&DVH
LQ)LQQLVKµ
0XOWLOHYHOFDVHWKHRULHVGHDOZLWKWKHPLVPDWFKEHWZHHQPRUSKRORJLFDOIRUPDQGV\QWDFWLFIXQFWLRQE\
GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ0253+2/2*,&$/&$6(RQWKHEDVLVRIIRUPDQG$%675$&7&$6(RQWKHEDVLVRIIXQFWLRQ
$SSURDFKHVWKDWGLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQDEVWUDFWFDVHDQGPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHLQWKLVZD\W\SLFDOO\HQYLVDJH
DQLQWHUIDFHFDOOHG¶VSHOORXW·WKDWGHWHUPLQHVWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWKHP,QSUDFWLFHWKLVRXWORRNKDV
VHUYHGWROHJLWLPL]HDQHJOHFWRILQIOHFWLRQDOPRUSKRORJ\7KHQHJOHFWLVXQGHUVWDQGDEOHIRUV\QWDFWLFLDQV·
LQWHUHVWLQPRUSKRORJLFDOFDVHLVQDWXUDOO\OHVVDVDV\VWHPLQLWVRZQULJKWWKDQDVDGLDJQRVWLFIRUDEVWUDFW
FDVHDQGJUDPPDWLFDOUHODWLRQV%XWLWLVQRWHQWLUHO\EHQLJQFRPSDUHWKHDEXQGDQFHRIH[SOLFLWSURSRVDOV

<O@
 oi.uchicago.edu

% D8B8%DK<DD

DERXWKRZDEVWUDFWFDVHVDUHDVVLJQHGZLWKWKHPLQLPDODWWHQWLRQSDLGWRKRZWKH\DUHPRUSKRORJLFDOO\
UHDOL]HG .LSDUVN\ 

)URPDOLQJXLVWLFSRLQWRIYLHZLIWKHFRQIHUHQFHDQGWKHVFKRODUO\DFWLYLW\LWUHSUHVHQWHGKDGDFRPPRQ
GHQRPLQDWRUDQGDUDLVRQG·rWUHLWZDVVXUHO\WRSURYLGHVRPHRIWKHPLVVLQJGDWDVWUXFWXUHVWKDWOLQJXLVWLFWKHRU\
QHHGVWRILOOLQWKHYDFXXPFUHDWHGE\WKH´EHQLJQQHJOHFWµGHSORUHGE\.LSDUVN\7KLVVFKRODUO\DFWLYLW\LVDQ
RQJRLQJHIIRUWFDUULHGRXWRQYDULRXVIURQWVDWYDULRXVUK\WKPVDQGRQYDULRXVSUHPLVHVE\DORRVHO\FRXSOHG
QHWZRUNRIUHVHDUFKHUV
8OWLPDWHO\,WKLQNWKDWWKHVLJQLILFDQFHRIWKLVFRQIHUHQFHLVWKDWLWLVDVRUWRIPXOWLGLPHQVLRQDOVQDSVKRW
IUHH]HIUDPHFU\VWDOL]DWLRQRIWKHDFWLYLW\RIWKLVQHWZRUNDVLWH[LVWHGLQ$SULO7KHVQDSVKRWZLOOORRNGLI
IHUHQWIURPGLIIHUHQWYLHZLQJDQJOHVDQGGHSWKRIVDPSOLQJ7KHIROORZLQJSUHOLPLQDU\PDSLVWKHEULHIHVWSRVVLEOH
IO\RYHUIURPRQHSRLQWRIYLHZRIWKHULFKDQGFRPSOH[VWUXFWXUHPDGHXSRIWKHDVVHPEOHGSDSHUV
$OUHDG\DWWKHEHJLQQLQJLWZDVPRVWKHOSIXOWRKDYH&KULVWLDQ7RXUDWLHU ´&DVHWDQDO\VHHQPRUSKqPHV"µ 
UHPLQGXVLQKLVLQWURGXFWRU\SDSHURILPSRUWDQWFRQFHSWXDODQGWHUPLQRORJLFDOGLVWLQFWLRQVPDGHLQLQIOHFWLRQDO
PRUSKRORJ\E\WZRXQIRUWXQDWHO\RIWHQRYHUORRNHGJLDQWVLQOLQJXLVWLFWKHRU\DQGLQ6HPLWLFDQG,QGR(XURSHDQ
VWXGLHV=HOLJ+DUULVDQG-HU]\.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]OLQJXLVWLFWKHRU\SDVWDQGSUHVHQWLVDULFKVRXUFHRIVWUXFWXULQJ
K\SRWKHVHVZKLFKGRQRWKDYHWRDQGSUREDEO\FDQQRWEHUHLQYHQWHGE\WKHZRUNLQJODQJXDJHDQGODQJXDJH
IDPLO\VSHFLDOLVW
7REHJLQORRNLQJVOLJKWO\RIIFHQWHUDWWKHODQJXDJHVSHFLILFPDWHULDORQHVXUSULVLQJO\UHFXUUHQWWKHPHKDV
EHHQHUJDWLYLW\,QIDFWP\LPSUHVVLRQIURPWKHSDSHUV,KDYHVHHQLVWKDW'L[RQ·VPRQRJUDSKRQWKHVXE
MHFWDSSHDUVLQPRUHLQGLYLGXDOELEOLRJUDSKLHVWKDQDQ\RWKHUVLQJOHUHIHUHQFH2IWKHODQJXDJHVGLVFXVVHGKHUH
+XUULDQKROGVSULGHRISODFHLQWKLVFDWHJRU\ZLWKLWVWLJKWO\FKRUHRJUDSKHGEDOOHWRIDJHQWSDWLHQWVXEMHFWDQG
EHQHILFLDU\RIZKLFK'HQQLV&DPSEHOO ´$JHQW6XEMHFW3DWLHQWDQG%HQHILFLDU\*UDPPDWLFDO5ROHVLQ+XUULDQµ 
JDYHXVDJOLPSVH6XPHULDQLVDQRWKHUHUJDWLYHVWDUEXWDV&KULVWRSKHU:RRGV ´7KH&RQMXJDWLRQ3UHIL[HVWKH
'DWLYH&DVHDQGWKH(PSDWK\+LHUDUFK\LQ6XPHULDQµ VKRZHGDQLPDF\KDVEHFRPHVXFKDQRUJDQL]LQJSROH
WKDWLWFDQEHFRQVLGHUHGWRRFFXS\FHQWHUVWDJH$QLPDF\PDUNLQJLVHTXDOO\FHQWUDODVDQRUJDQL]LQJSULQFLSDO
LQ(ODPLWHDVSUHVHQWHGE\)ORUHQFH0DOEUDQ/DEDW ´'HVFDVHQpODPLWH"µ EXWDQHQWLUHO\GLIIHUHQWVWUXFWXUH
HPHUJHVKHUHZLWK(ODPLWH·VQHVWHGDUJXPHQWSDWWHUQVDVFRUHPDUNHUVRIV\QWDFWLFVWUXFWXUHLQDODQJXDJHZLWK
UHODWLYHO\OLWWOHFDVHPDUNLQJRXWVLGHWKHSURQRPLQDOV\VWHP$VLPLODUEUDFNHWLQJE\FDVHDJUHHPHQWSDWWHUQV
ZDVVKRZQE\*LOOHVYDQ+HHPVLQ(WUXVFDQ ´$FFRUGVXUOHGpVDFFRUGTXHOTXHVUpIOH[LRQVVXUHOHVUDSSRUWVHQWUH
PRUSKqPHVFDVXHOVHWDGSRVLWLRQVHQpWUXVTXHµ 
(UJDWLYLW\LVDEDFNJURXQGLVVXHLQWZRRYHUYLHZVRIFDVHV\VWHPJHQHVLV)RU,QGR(XURSHDQ-HDQ+DXGU\
´*HQqVHHWpYROXWLRQGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOLQGRHXURSpHQTXHVWLRQVHWK\SRWKqVHVµ VKRZHGWKDWQRVLPSOHOLQHDU
SURMHFWLRQZLOOJHWXVWRWKHRULJLQRI,QGR(XURSHDQEXWELWVDQGSLHFHVGRVKRZKRZYDULDEOHWKHSURFHVVVKRXOG
KDYHEHHQ)RU3URWR6HPLWLF3HOLR)URQ]DUROL ´(YROXWLRQGHVFDVGDQVOHVpPLWLTXHDUFKDwTXHODFRQWULEXWLRQ
GHO·pEODwWHµ GLVFRXQWHGSXWDWLYHHYLGHQFHRIHUJDWLYLW\IURP(EOLWHFDVHPDUNLQJVKRZLQJWKDWRQHKDVWRSD\
DWWHQWLRQWRWKHKDELWVDQGFRQYHQWLRQVRIVFULEHV ZKLOHRSHQLQJXSDQRWKHUGRRUWRWKLVLUUHSUHVVLEOHIHDWXUH
LQVRPHDGYHUELDOIRVVLOIRUPV 2QDGLIIHUHQWJUDPPDWLFDOSODQHEXWVWLOOLQWKHDQFLHQW1HDU(DVWWKHQHFHVVLW\
RIFDXWLRQZLWKVFULEDOKDELWVDQGZKDWFDQEHGHGXFHGIURPWKHPZDVXQGHUOLQHGE\eULF3LUDUW ´!HFM6>8J9%
JUDPPDWLFDOHVj%ҸVRWࡃQµ 
%XWFDVHVDOVRDULVH&UDLJ0HOFKHUW ´7KH3UREOHPRIWKH(UJDWLYH&DVHLQ+LWWLWHµ VKRZHGZLWKHUJDWLYH
DWWKHORZHQGRIWKHVSOLWHUJDWLYLW\VFDOHWKDWDFDVHFDQOLYHRQ$GLIIHUHQWNLQGRIFDVHUHLQFDUQDWLRQUHVXU
UHFWLRQZDVDOVRVKRZQE\0DWWKLDV)ULW] ´6XUO·pYROXWLRQGXORFDWLIHQDUPpQLHQµ ZKRWDOOLHGXSWKHQXPEHU
RIPRUSKRORJLFDOGLVJXLVHVWDNHQE\WKHORFDWLYHLQ$UPHQLDQ³DOZD\VLGHQWLFDOWRDWOHDVWRQHRWKHUFDVHEXW
YDU\LQJZLWKVWHPFODVVHV
,QWKHGRPDLQRIFDVHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQWKHUDGLFDOUHPRGHOLQJRI7RNKDULDQFDVHZDVRXWOLQHGE\*HRUJHV-HDQ
3LQDXOW ´6XUO·KLVWRLUHGHVFDVHQWRNKDULHQµ &ODLUH/H)HXYUH ´0pFDQLVPHVGHUpDIIHFWDWLRQGpVLQHQWLHOOHHW
KLpUDUFKLHGHVRSSRVLWLRQVFDVXHOOHVHQVODYHµ GLVFRYHUHGLQ6ODYLFDPRUHVXEWOHUHPRGHOLQJE\WZRGLIIHUHQW
´WKHUDSHXWLFµUHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQVjOD.XU\‫ן‬RZLF]
)XQFWLRQVORDGHGLQWRFDVHVVXUYLYHLQSUHSRVLWLRQDOPRGHOVDQGV\QWDFWLFWHPSODWHV7KLVLVGRFXPHQWHGLQ
DQXPEHURIODQJXDJHV$QGUp5RXVVHDX ´&DVJUDPPDWLFDX[HWFDVORFDX[HQJRWLTXH/HVPRGqOHVFDVXHOVGX
JRWLTXHµ VKRZHGWKLVIRU*RWKLFDQG0LFKHO0D]R\HU ´$SURSRVGHO·RSSRVLWLRQHQWUHOHVWDWLTXHHWOHG\QDPLTXH
HQKLWWLWHµ IRU+LWWLWH$QG)RONH-RVHSKVRQ ´$OODWLYHLQ,QGR(XURSHDQµ WDONHGDERXWWKHPHWDPRUSKRVHVRI
 oi.uchicago.edu

% 7YB*OZ78g%*O8%HYB<A/37%,F%3<78%m%K83<@/*\N<*/,B%<BH%F\*\K8%H/K83*/,B7% <OP

WKHLOODWLYHLQ+LWWLWHZKRVHIXQFWLRQDORYHUORDGFDQEHVXSSOHPHQWHGE\HQFOLWLFSDUWLFOHVLQWKH:DFNHUQDJHO
SRVLWLRQ:KDWDPRXQWVWRDFDVHVSOLWZDVGLVFXVVHGE\6HUJXHL6DNKQR ´3RXUTXRLGHX[JpQLWLIVHWGHX[ORFDWLIV
HQUXVVHSRXUFHUWDLQVVXEVWDQWLIV"(WDWDFWXHOGHVSDUDGLJPHVHWDVSHFWVGLDFKURQLTXHVµ 
7KHUHZHUHDQXPEHURIH[SORUDWLRQVRIPDLQWDLQHGULFKQHVVRIFDVHV\VWHPV5REHUW+DZOH\ ´6RPH&DVH
3UREOHPVLQ8JDULWLFµ VKRZHGIRU8JDULWLFWKDWWKHFDVHV\VWHPZDVDVDOLYHDQGZHOODVRQHFRXOGH[SHFWIRUD
:HVW6HPLWLFODQJXDJH,QWKH,QGR(XURSHDQGRPDLQWKHUHLVDORQJDQGSURXGKLVWRU\RIWKLVULFKQHVV)RU*UHHN
)UDQoRLVH%DGHU ´eQLJPHVDXWRXUGXGDWLIHWGHO·LQVWUXPHQWDOµ WDQWDOL]HGXVZLWKDP\WKRSRHWLFH[SORUDWLRQ
RIWKHODQGVFDSHRIWKHGDWLYHVWDUWLQJIURP(SK~U̒PXNK{LÉUJHRV´WXFNHGDZD\GHHSLQWKH$UJROLGµ)RUPRGHUQ
,FHODQGLF3DWULFN*XHOSDH[SORUHGWKHYLWDOLW\RIWKHGDWLYHDYLWDOLW\WKDWPDQLIHVWVLWVHOIh%61$-()4!%8H%6%ME9KJ
ULRXVV\QGURPHWKDWPLJKWEHGXEEHG´GDWLYLWLVµ)LQDOO\RXWVLGHWKHERXQGDULHVRI,QGR(XURSHDQDJDLQ-HDQ
3HUURW ´5HJDUGVVXUOHVFDVGDQVOHVODQJXHVRXUDOLHQQHVµ RSHQHGDV\QFKURQLFFRPSDUDWLYHSHUVSHFWLYHRQWKH
IDPRXVULFKHVRIWKHFDVHV\VWHPVRI)LQQR8JULF
/DVWEXWH[WUHPHO\LPSRUWDQWLVWKHGHDWKRIFDVH³SHUKDSVZHFDQVD\4(010%4(0107KHLPSRYHULVKPHQW
DQGGLVDSSHDUDQFHRIDZKROHFDVHV\VWHPZDVGRFXPHQWHGE\'HQQLV3DUGHH ´9HVWLJHVGXV\VWqPHFDVXHOHQWUH
OHQRPHWOHSURQRPVXIIL[HQKpEUHXELEOLTXHµ IRU&DQDDQLWHDQGE\5HEHFFD+DVVHOEDFK ´(DUO\&DQDDQLWHDQG
2OG$UDPDLF&DVHLQWKH/LJKWRI/DQJXDJH7\SRORJ\µ IRU1RUWKZHVW6HPLWLFJHQHUDOO\
3ULGHRISODFHLQWKLVDVSHFWRIFDVHEHFDXVHRIWKHZHDOWKRIGDWDKDVWREHORQJWR/DWLQDQGLWVFRQWHPSR
UDULHVDQGVXFFHVVRUVLQ5RPDQLD7KHFRPSOLFDWHGVLWXDWLRQLQ6DEHOOLDQZDVH[SORUHGE\9LQFHQW0DUW]ORII ´-J9%
PDUTXHVFDVXHOOHVGDQVOHVGRFXPHQWVSDOpRVDEHOOLTXHVHWODPRUSKRORJLHGXJpQLWLISOXULHOVXGSLFpQLHQµ 3DROR
3RFFHWWL ´)RUPDWLRQHWYDULDWLRQVGDQVOHVV\VWqPHGHODIOH[LRQGHVODQJXHVVDEHOOLTXHVHQWUHV\QFKURQLHHWGLD
FKURQLHµ JDYHDQRYHUYLHZRIWKHFDVHV\VWHPDVDZKROHLQWKH6DEHOOLDQODQJXDJHVVLWXDWLQJWKHVHODQJXDJHVLQ
WKHLU,WDOLFDQG,QGR(XURSHDQFRQWH[WDQGVKRZLQJIDVFLQDWLQJW\SRORJLFDOFRQYHUJHQFHVEHWZHHQGHYHORSPHQWV
LQ6DEHOOLDQDQGWKRVHWKDWZRXOGWDNHSODFHLQODWH/DWLQDQGHDUO\5RPDQFH
7KHULFKYDULDELOLW\RI/DWLQDWDOOSHULRGVZDVVKRZQE\&DUROH)U\ ´/DFDVXDOLWpODWLQHHQYDULDWLRQGLDV
WUDWLTXH'XSDUOHUSRSXODLUHjODGLFWLRQSRpWLTXHµ DQGWKHYXOQHUDELOLW\RIWKHLQIOHFWLRQDOVLJQLILDQWDQGWKH
FRQVHTXHQWFROODSVHVDQGKRPRSKRQLHVFDWDORJXHGE\0LFKqOH)UX\W ´&DVHWpYROXWLRQOLQJXLVWLTXHHQODWLQµ 
*HUG+DYHUOLQJ ´/HIORWWHPHQWHQWUHOHVFDVHQODWLQWDUGLIµ JDYHDWRXURIFDVHIXQFWLRQVWKDWJHWQRUPDOL]HGDQG
SDWWHUQVWKDWPRYHIURPV\QWKHVLVWRDQDO\VLV)LQDOO\0LFKHOD&HQQDPR ´&DVH0DUNLQJRI&RUH$UJXPHQWVDQG
$OLJQPHQWLQ/DWH/DWLQµ ORRNHGIRUSULQFLSOHGUHDVRQVIRUH[WHQVLRQRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHDQGIRXQGLWLQDQDFWLYH
FDVHDOLJQPHQWDQGDVKLIWLQKHDGPDUNLQJVWUDWHJ\
7KHWLWOHRIWKLVVXPPDU\RYHUYLHZFRQWDLQVWKHH[SUHVVLRQ´IXWXUHGLUHFWLRQVµ,WZRXOGRIFRXUVHEHSUHVXPS
WLYHIRUDQRXWVLGHUWRSUHGLFWKRZ/DWLQLVWVDUHJRLQJWRGR/DWLQ+LWWLWRORJLVWVWRGR+LWWLWH:KHUHDGLVFLSOLQH
ZLOOJRGHSHQGVREYLRXVO\RQDQLQWHUQDOG\QDPLFRIPRYLQJRQIURPDFXUUHQWVWDWHRIWKHTXHVWLRQ&XUUHQW
OLQJXLVWLFSUHRFFXSDWLRQVFDQQRWGLFWDWHWKHDJHQGDRIRQJRLQJODQJXDJHLQYHVWLJDWLRQ%XW,ZRXOGSRLQWRXW
WKDWWKHUHLVDOVRDWZROHYHOH[WHUQDOG\QDPLFGLDOHFWLF$UHWKHUHFXUUHQWOLQJXLVWLFSUHRFFXSDWLRQVWKDWKHOS
SXWRXUGDWDLQSHUVSHFWLYHDQGYLFHYHUVD"2QWKHRWKHUKDQGDUHZHGHDOLQJZLWKODQJXDJHSKHQRPHQDVLPSO\
DEVHQWIURPWKHSUHVHQWJULGRIODQJXDJHWKHRUHWLFSUHRFFXSDWLRQVEXWWKDWPLJKWWXUQRXWWREHSRVVLEOHIXWXUH
DQVZHUVWRDV\HWXQIRUPXODWHGOLQJXLVWLFTXHVWLRQV"$FRQIHUHQFHVXFKDVWKHSUHVHQWDOORZVXVWRJHWVRPHJUDVS
RIERWKRIWKHVHG\QDPLFV

89:;9<=>?@AB
%RXFKDUG'HQLV
  ´7KH&RQFHSWRI¶8QLYHUVDO·DQGWKH&DVHRI-DSDQHVHµN#)51(²
'L[RQ5REHUW0:
% OPP<% 8-5($#?#$'&DPEULGJH6WXGLHVLQ/LQJXLVWLFV&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
+RRS+HOHQGH2ODI.RHQHPDQ,ULV0XOGHUVDQG)UHG:HHUPDQ
  ´,QWURGXFWLRQ6SHFLDO,VVXHRQ0RUSKRORJLFDO&DVHµN#)51(%²
.LSDUVN\3DXO
  ´6WUXFWXUDO&DVHLQ)LQQLVKµN#)51(%²