1997 TABLE OF CASES‘TABLE OF CASES rom January 2 to Desmber 1,197 "SCRA Vat 265280) ‘Abaca, Corporatio ofthe Philippines os. Garis, Marin O, 272 ‘Aba Fretino—Pepl of he Philippine , 268 SORA 246. ‘Abivnts, Papo A~Cerula, Bartolome. v, 289 SCRA 152 ‘Aedes amon Signe Peopl ofthe Plipines , 288 SCRA ‘Abels, Fain Bhi Vs. oe, Dlisy, NemasloN 268 SCRA 6 ‘Abe ernarée PP, Damas 8.276 SCRA S02 ‘tse Shipping Eien Amoco, Abaca, Vier -Paopeof the Piippnes oy, 281 SCRA 69 ‘ABSCEN Employees Usio ee. Nato! Labsr Reasons Commie. se, 2T6SCRA 123 Aeshede International Crperton—Samahan 2 Optotsite at pine, leer Sura Chapa, 270 SCRA 208 ‘Adalin, arta, Court of Appi 380 SCRA 596 ‘dors, Masta Pepl fhe Pilipino 278 SCRA 442 ‘ors, Lech Poe Bersamin, Lacan 279 SCRA 217 ‘APP Muto! Bonet Asie, Ine Natisnal Labor Relation (Conmiaan, 267 SCRA ‘AG. Devlopamn! Corporation e Curt of Appa 261 SCRA 155. ‘Agana, Jens V=-Conepcio, Maul Fo, 208 SCRA 37 ‘Agta, Sr Barges A Hep Planters Hank 209 SCRA 2 ‘Ago, Lary ox National Lar Relations Comin (bind Div ‘sles 280 SCRA osu ‘Any lind Ae. Palang, Carin Cori 276 SCRA 40 ‘Aguensa 3 Antonios. Mtrpsian Rani brat Ge, 274 SORA 3 ‘Ageia, Nason People fhe Piippines oa, 279 SCRA 82 ‘Again, Lavi Co Court of Appeals 211 SCRA 45? ‘ke Geen, ne Neon Lab Batons Cini, 631632 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED ‘Alas, Ronlr—Pecple of he Pilpins ve 274 SCRA 310 ‘aay, Sakae M-Als, Sophia or, 28 SCRA 608 ‘law Sophia Aaya, tary 368 SCRA 628, ‘eal, Angel C-—C Ber Corporation ov 7 SORA 402 ‘es, Nid y Vilar -Pope ofthe Philippines 278 SCRA 216 ‘igo Poglacering Cocstracton Cerpraton ss, National Labor "Ralatine Cation, 280 SCRA Ie ‘icbusan, Lepid on Coarof ppens 209 SCRA 206 ‘Amaro nriqee M-Nasares, Hameo Pen, 268 SCRA 687 ‘Amada dy. Cru of Append, 259 SCRA BLS ‘Amendrs, Ma Linda Tos. Cour of Appeals, 260 SCRA 525 ‘Aeron, dole Suri Agunn 8t SCRA 416 ‘Alo, Salvador MeredarPeopia ofthe Phlippaes os, 288 ‘Soka ise Tavestigation and Security Agen, Ine us, National Labor "Relations Comin, 72 SCA 683 ‘Alvaro, Patorne T-—Arags, Lacan Vaud v, 270 SCRA 379 ‘Avarta;Armando- People the Phlgpes 278 SORA 823 ‘Amc, Hénctnng_Peple of th Pilypines 277 SCRA 215 ‘Amerian Inter Petion Careration ve. Clrnua Sun Fabien Gas ‘ent Mancfoctring Ps, Toe, 268 SCRA 258 Amer, Splicus Sandiganaynn 279 SCRA 494 ‘Atco Jevita apo. Court Appenin 274 SERA C76 ‘And, Jue y Mercado Pep of the Pappnas ee, 279 SCRA ie ‘Andan,Pabite y Harnander—People ofthe Phiippnes e209 [Andrea Geap Ins, Court of Argel, 265 SCRA 428 ‘Angra, Plgrdo Tatade,Wigbrs Ete, 272SCRA 18, ‘ngage, dr, Casioa hte, Ombuiaman, 268 SCRA 90 270 Sha 8 ‘Angels Aderacoa ©. Germala Je Pablo, 27450RA 10 ‘ol Danay-—Paole ofthe Pipes, 276 SORA 10 ‘Angshung, Retro Me. Comasin en Bln, 269 SCRA 248, ‘Aemapmate ts. Gere, Ai Ay 279 SORA 270 ‘Azo, Nevers Hees, nase A, 287 SCRA 528 1907 CASES REPORTED esa ‘Aa Rol Alalan—Pupe of he Pirin ot 278 SCRA Axtipna, Hoglo y Legaypl—People af the Philppaes ve, 274 ‘Sia sas Aono, Caro—Pupl the Philippines ve, 279 SCRA $28 ‘Antonis, Severino oe, Court of Appeal, 273 SCRA 28 ‘Azunciaion, Jr Caslane P-—Eqealeal Realty Devdapmant oe. Asia. Mri Cantor, EemeraldoG, 268 8CRA 47 ‘Apontan,Jacato~ People a to Pilipino, 270 SCRA 713 ‘Aguas Seal to. Magne, Bosra 21 SCRA C02 ‘Argo, Lasiana Via, dee vars Paterno 270 SCRA 979 ‘Aragon, Nai on Cont of Appa 270 SORA 608 ‘AvoMen Fon edu, Ine 8: National Labor Blaine Co ‘Sarien 272 SORA ies Arceg, fal Yue, Court of Appeal, 275 SCRA 176 ‘Areloa, Marcling Court f Appel, 290SCBA 20 ‘Anallno,Dalin~ Peale of he Pilipinas ve, 22 SCRA 500 ‘rll dey Adcaee A oe: Nation! Labor Halains Commision, "Ho SCA toe Arias, Felipe E~Banagn, Wied Cv, 274 SCRA.T ‘Army and Nery Chi ef Mana Ineo Cnart of Appel 271 SCRA Avot, Carmen on, Nateal Labor Relations Commision, 279 ‘Soma woe Arta, Pl Po os Jol A, 282 SCRA 28 ‘Arvo dor Ps. De Veeco 277 SORA 258 ‘rag, Line Peas ofthe Phlpinen on, 24 SCRA 635 ‘Arzaga, Bienvenido Concerned isnen of Laoag Cy 8, 287 SHA 18 ‘Aal Thing A~Peping, Mang. 287 CRA 40 ‘A Sean Corporation -Commisone of ntereal Raven e257 ‘Soka ‘Ain, Trea Jami Rolando 276 SCRA 257634 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED ‘Conmisen, 256 SCRA 38 ‘Awan Braet, Cort Appeals, 73 SCRA 2 ‘elians, Tessrco Pepi a te Pilopines 269 SCRA SSS ‘Area lncuranse PLO Court of Appenn 278 SCHA S12, ‘Arsen, Alfodo Le. Saniganbayan, 265 SCRA 7 ‘ArugueBasnale'y Amador" People of the Philippines ox, 268 ‘Sonat ‘Bsbaran, Rao V—Valus, ans on, 278 SORA 472 Baber, Ede, Gaenitarenn, Vite P71 SCRA 23 Bai Rte —Pel tte Psp = 27 SORA 252 Bein Dey eta Patou Bal Mave, 27 SCRA 30 Bagas, Hien y Degen People ef the Phipps, 277 SCRA Bajar, Goran y Cahor—Peole af the Plipynee ve, 281 SCRA Balad, Adois—Poole he Phipps, 274 SCRA 698 Balan Nemeio~Peoplof he Pippo, 272 SCRA 782 Baldra, Raper CebusogPeole of tho Philippines, 278 “Soka 40 Baloging, Leonel, Court of Appeals, 268 SCRA 258 Bannan Growers Gllogive at Paped Faron». Naonal aber “aletins Conlon, 76 SRA 4, Bandeog, nur No, Ching Balla, 208SCBA 1 ‘Bengalan, Daa ve Court Appeals 270 SCRA 619 Bengeanoeigs Bo, Court ef Appeal, 278 SHA S72 Beni NoaPeople tho Phllpplnes 275 SCRA ATS Benogen, Wilds Cs Ai, Pepe 374 SCRA 17 Bates, Gusline Fv Cert App, 370 SORA 38, Basten, ce Cauret Appeal, 267 SCRA S31 Bareat Suge Malinao, Cont of Appele275 SCRA 49? Berra, J Sse —Figueray, Putas, 276 SCRA S49 Bassler NieoDel Beary, J, Maran 270 SCRA 64S Birragn, Inacio. Cort Aged 268 8A 105 Best, Igoenl Rapa Las Be, 268 SCRA 220 ‘Bataan Shinya wad ognering Corporation om. Bassin Renato“ Pepi th Pippine or, 278 SCRA 613 Beyds, Bienen) Arcamo~People af the Pallppoee 0s. 273 Beyhon, Wiliam H.—Caopar, lana Bn, 278 SCRA 482 1907 CASES REPORTED 635 ‘Bayog, Alejandro os, Noting, Antanio M271 SORA 268 Bayview Hotel lwo Couto Apes 278 SORA 640 ‘Balen, Antonis M-—Depertment of Soda Welfare and Devlgment ‘a SCRA 648 ‘Beniter, Rail, Cour of Appeal, 256 SCRA 242 ‘Benita Herierio~ Berni, Huei, 275 SCRA 08 ‘Baresi, ufo Bea, Herbert 375 SORA AS Bernardo, Pas‘ Court of Appeal, 27 SCRA 782 Bernas, Jove Anianio S~Cabarraa Je derane, 279 SCRA 9 Bera, Jee ySonen_Peopl of he Plippne ot, 957 SCRA 270 Borntol ey Doninader Dos Moste, dame 380 SCRA 181 Brahm Tease, Tne. v- Nese Labor Relations Casaaion, "oo SORA ote ‘Brow Matto Intenaioal Ine of. Notional Federation of Labor Union NAPLUY, 221 SCRA 6 Bailanies, dese 5 Gates Rafnery Ermpleyets Asiciaton (CREA) or, 279 ‘ScRA ne Piilipine Anes Ine ve, 280 SCRA 515 Brie, fed y RaveraPeopl fhe Phlipine ts, 286 SCRA686 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED ‘Brass, Vladimir. Vlei, Badan B, 290 SCRA S57 ‘Boga, Marelne A~-Pesps of te Pipines cn, 279 SCRA 304 ‘Bulaogia Resldenia and Bmployows Asmciaton for Development, eo Nuber Malanyaoe, Cran 279 SCRA 482 ‘Buin Care Corpeaton ee National Labor Relations Commie ‘Bundang etna Pooplef the Piippnas n, 272 SCRA 641 ‘Bun, Ram F—Popl of the Pilipino, 271 SCRA 75 ta, Dela Gt, Ranges Masel Mt, 278 SCRA 21. Button Anedin O--Poope of he Phapiner on, 272 SORA 352 Cebaor, Aad Fe Cant, Aledo ©, 271 SCRA 894 {Gahles, Eduardo Pople the Pilipinas 8, 274S0RA 89 bang Arent eral, Ramana Bn, 272 SCRA 08 (barre, Jena Beran Joe Antonia 8,279 SCRA 338, (bana, Heraiow National Labor Relation Commision, 277 ‘SoRAGTT (be slits G—Uanan, Sbanah For, 20 SORA 7 abe doy ng—Puople of he Pilipino, 252 SCRA 410 bilan, Clsdaalto~ People of he Pipne 267 SORA 268 tblng Prom S.—Toren, Pata yon, 278 SCRAS20 {ror Plind Vas, dee, Cour f Appa, 257 SCRA 80 (een Maria Soars Court ef Apeas 976 SCRA 128, (ee, Tent ve, Court of Apes 369 SCRA 168, 76 SCRA 420 ‘een ibethy Palmar People of he Philippine 269 SCRA m1 CCehindn Remeo—Peole ofthe Philippines ot, 266 SCRA 554 nn ane Repl Anco (ORES, ein, oe alaeg, od Ce, Commission on Rees, 274 SCRA 405 Calvo at, Sebas—Pepi fhe Plippnar 209 SCRA 676 (Camanag, Oli. Correr, rus F265 SORA ATS (Camara Raby B-—Enrigees, Joni 280 SCRA L (Camilan aan se. Gomainton on Elen, 271 SCRA 76? ‘Gaia, Wiltedo Roe. Nason Labor Reiaons Comminson, 279 ‘Sona ts canicna, Rito v, Commision on Eacton, 22 SCRA 612 ‘Canter, Bemeraldo GA, Mara 6,268 SORA 7 ‘Canta Aledo C Cabaer, Amado Fb, 271 SCRA 39. 1907 CASES REPORTED 637 Cadet, Vegi. Rabo, Se, Maro B.278 SRA 478 (Cana, Carmen Cour of Appa 288 SCRA Bo {Cail Ove. Naina! Labor Rantion Consinson, 270 SCRA 488 ‘el Jo Natal Laer Hltons Goan, 27 SOTA pital Medel Center Alice of Conrad Employer United ‘gn Savin Wakes te. Lagren, Blarney 267 Cera Baralome Cox. Abarat Papi A, 209 SCRA 132 an eoaray Le Penn ote Plpien tn 28 SCRA, (asl ge Fv, Court Appt, 218 SCRA 9T (tol Cacia ve. Cour of Apen 268 SORA 25 (rp tbr D—Pesle ofthe Philipines o, 82 SCRA 22 (erreo, Erlinda y Prec—Pepl of te Plippnes x, 282 SORA, Cera Jann Con Corto Appel 280 SCRA 261 Cesar, Absillth- Sad, Makadaya ve, 266 SCRA ‘Cuid, Wiliam 0~-Penple of te Plippinee e269 SCRA 960 ‘Cao, Sr, pani Lve Coat Appa, 278 SCRA 237 {Cen Sete B~ Miranda, Vr fe, 274 SORA S08 {Cestle,MajrePeopla of tin Phipps, 278 SCRA 22 ‘Castile, Jr Domingo People ef he Pippa iy 276 SCRA 62 (astro, DaniePeope of he Paipinn oy 276 SCRA 6 {ase Bagardo—Prple the Paine 282 SCRA 212 Ct, Vitrin y‘CalgnoPerpl ft Filner, 274 ‘CatromerClerine—evgl tn Phiipins on 80 SCRA 4. (Cee, Lvinion Poe. he Onan, 278 SCRA 636 Catan, rice y Teng Pople ofthe Pipes te 278 Cetra Segu B—Cortey, Navan Hv, 219 SCRA 1 stinga i, li Msn fn Plies 272 Ceonigah, Beajamin y Bagnyan—Peopl ofthe Pippin oe, 274 ‘SORA ae? ‘abe Jnana ase Corporation Cort Appa, Cecile Realty and Service Corporation ee Court of Ape 278 ‘Soka sia ei ado Amoent Apel Hal Hy 270638 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED ‘eat Bact Unversity vs Natinal Labor Balas Commision, "ist Dvn, 276 SCRA 60 ‘ha, No ee. Couto Appel, 277 SCRA 600 ‘Chaves Astonio Examanto~ People of te Philipines ee, 276 ‘Sona 230 Chong, Bare Peope ofthe Phppines ot, 279 SCRA 129, (hi ing Tons, Cour of Apes 266 SCHA 324 ‘hina Baalng Corporat se our ofAppenia 270 SCRA Gn Ching, Halla t—Dandang Jeo No, 288 SCA 1 ‘Ghani Gs, Nasion Labor Ralaons Common, 267 SCRA (Cha, Parcacion ve. Cort of Appeals, 271 SCRA {ibank, LA ts. Court of Appel, 280 SCRA 450 (Cy Shei, Manile~-Modin, Vitra, 276SCRA 183, (it Aeronaats Bourd—Pllpine Aine, te. ve, 270 SCRA Chet Saves Commie — “Dat Cantle, Eapwr Re, 218 SCRA 209 br Slay Rafal, 374 S0RA DE (KH Undated Development Corporation Cour of Appl, ‘ra SORA 208 os Stock Brokerage, Inve. Court of Appel 278 SCRA 790 Co Tember Corporation Akal Anal C, 273 SCRA S02 ‘Commision oa Eletine “nsbune, Ricro Mo, 260 SCRA 245 TieisT dena a, 270 SORA D8 “Titi Antoni 279 80RA 468 ‘Ttattabage, Ee ve, 280 SCRA Bo? Tent, lp Te, 276 SCRA 706, Tg en Bay, etn Cy alr 371 SCRA tim, Nomter C02, 262 SORA 53 ‘Tiida, Cond 214 SORA S12 gato Mes 270 SCRA 04 tons, yea Ov, 260 SCRA 80 teal, Nordin Mv, 271 SCRA 73S 1997 CASES REPORTED 639 Nese, vn Bo 279 SORA 88 ‘SNatbe Blgtao © 47 SCRA Tez esas Hd Hand mney 374 SORA A Fete Gin a SeRa at BO Pedram on 27 SCRA Ie ‘Btotage Sra Beton on 70 SCRA 106 Tore onsre Loy 770 SCRA 58 Conninionet atralRverwe= A. Sern Corporate, 257 SCRA 318, SS Gout hope Soma Ser, 27 SA cos ‘©: Sant Apna B27 SCRA C1 omnis Sng Fat Garston Cou of re encopco,Antn EA. Court of Appeals 274 SCRA 614 ‘Sncopeln, Manel te guon, es 286084307 ced tn of Lan hag, Benn 27 SCRA Coneree AeeegteCrportion vs Gout Appa 28 STA 88 (nie, Nves = Patras Wears Uaton PTW) oe, 269 SCRA 83 canary tina FUSCA statin, Ligue, Peps 299 SCRA 68 et Aor. Natinal Lab Rllne Gm, 271 SCRA Contre Lat. Mind, Sted C290 SRA 68 (Gerben Dany OlsoPepisf te Philippine vo. 270 SCRA 465 ‘Geren bere, ascave Seren FT SCRA 6 even defen fh Pines, Se SAT ‘Sere Cara, Care Appeals 274 SCRA 28, ‘ern Fano Bt Carl Send B, 279 SA 3 recede Salvador ©, 276 SCRA 48 inrds Nana! ter Blend Gero, 272 Sen 3 (Causes Being Carpeation ot. Nato Labor Ralations Commi our hiner ve Seile, Wins C, 20 SRA 190 our Appa “Ase Detelpsnt Corporation ve, 286 CRA 429 Acai rt 0 SORA Se SAG Beaopmen’ Copan 281 SCRA 165 “Rett LeominGns21S0RA 4 Alien oes, 260 SCRA 8 Te Radyo, 209 308A a8640 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED —Almendeas, Ma. Linda, 259 SORA 528 : Thm, deve Yap n, 274 SCRA 676 ‘Thndresns Group, ne, 286 SCRA 428 nti, Severin wt 278 SCRA 838 ‘hregon, Nace Pos, 270 SORA 608 rcge Rafal ¥en, 276 SCRA 176 Aron, Marling o, 250 SCRA 20 Thy and Navy Clb of Mai, Ie 272 SCRA 96 ‘TAG IT, erntne 266 SCRA 606 tts, emet e273 SCRA 296 Aven taarane PLC re, 278 SCRA 312 Bagg, Leela, 269 SCRA 208, TBangnana Delnee, 276 SCRA 619 TBargnyan Rodrigo Bn, 278 SCRA 79 cen deme, 287 SCRA ‘ Tete Sagar il nen, 275 SORA 407 erg, Lea, 266 SCRA 108 Bepvow Hoa, Ine 278 SCRA 60 Bale Manon, 279 SCH 487 Tie, Abana, 280 SCRA 780 Taber, Felcided Vi, dv, 25 SORA 389 xen, Mara Stora oy 276 SCRA 333 “Geet Teflon, 269 SCRA 185, 976 SCRA 420 Tuten Carmen om, 268 SORA 640 ate Ces. 268 SCRA 25 ‘Feral Sues Cv, 20 SORA 851 ttt ey Bp aos, 276 SCRA 257 Serica sd are Corn 8 SERA cae No, 277 SCRA 690 hing Tot, 266 SCRA 824 ‘Chine Banking Corporatio vn, 270 SCRA 68 ‘Then Parecon sy 271 SCRA BB Guten, Ao 285 SCRA 49 ‘THT ines and Development Corporation on, 272 ‘CHA 308 CMS Sock Brokerage, Inn, 278 SCRA 190 1 Commitee of Tater! Reveaue ve, 267 SCRA B57, 680, ‘mecha cos 1907 CASES REPORTED 641 ~Commaditin Strnge Tes Plant Corporton vi, 274 SCRA Conoco, Anteio A on, 274 SORA 614 enrages Corpora 288 SCRA 86 espn, Carino. os 14 SCRA Fi rar, Gree. 281 SCRA 43 Tone, Nineveh 282 SCRA 188 Deion, Raynunds Me, 275 SCRA 96 ‘Davi, hon Cv, 276 SCRA. Dees Chan, Paco 968 CHA 677 ‘De Diss, Dominado Verge, 274 SCRA 500, TDS Gesman Nena on, 271SCRA'28 Det Rosevo, Virgilio M. os, 267 SCRA 158 Dea Rowe, Carats Delgads Va. deve, 280 SCRA 4k Defer Senay, Hiro Tv, 278 SCRA 69 Dae Transport Lies, Ie, 258 SCRA 87 Dai Motors Carporation ow, 26 SCRA 212 Deparment of AgaranRefrm Adjudeation Board oe, 266 Dera eden 270 SCRA 98 “Dae, Fretlin oa, 270SCRA201 Ter ea dw, 267 SCRA Sa? Ttslant Mare 277 SCRA S81 ‘Tibet, Ula 278 SCRA 182 Bip San Gv 30 SERA 11 —Rarulvas Slvador 8. oe, 272 SCRA 808 -Esonina, vind 8,8, 268 SCRA 627 ela Armand ve, 269 SCRA 255 Terre, bia n, 274 80Ra 210 TEP. ManaeopGnastrstion Co, Ineo, 258 SORA 235. “Bard Palppos Ine ony 367 SCRA 200 ‘Torch, Sanyo, 268 SCRA IB ‘Tete Motes (Ph) Corporation, 267 SCRA 658 Cert Astenio we. 279 SCRA 238 tri, ev Gv, 86 SCRA STs Garments en Tele Expat Board os, 268 SCRA 258 TGatmayean, Augusta ve B67 SCRA 434 eel Neney on, 272 SOR 752642 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED Tomales, ease 7 River, 277 SCRA 518 —overament Serve Insarance Sytem on, 266 SCRA 187 “ree Christin High Stole, 261 SORA 159 rom Link Ine, 29 SCRA C19 Titan fed ns 266SCRA 7 “Hire of Fads Cangoa £76 SCRA 76 ildin of Manel A Ronn 270 SORA 900 THs of MarelinePaabn 260 SCRA 870 THe of Marca Nagas e252 SCRA 4S Hy of Paro Hoare, 981 SCRA 76 Tite ef Sunda Maningding 276 SCRA 60) Heya the Late Teodor Guerin, Jv, 269 SCRA 285 Tega, Frasca u 81 SCRA 177 Tine amen ve 298 SCRA 122 Tinned Realy Invent Serie, neon, 273 SCRA 70 Tine Dretrate of te Pippin oe SCRA 454 ‘Teas, Morinda os, 281 SCRA? tte Alor Soweto, 270SCRA 270 Toran Land Teese 268 SCRA 00 “RI Realy Ineo 271 SCRA 238 Lait, Of cv, 271 SRA 1 en Bonamin ae, 89 9CRA 6 ‘Ledosme Rhdore Me, 278 SCRA 65 opard, Vicor, 28 SCRA 642 i Reymond Poon, 270 SCRA 2 Tie Rome, 271 SORA 2, Tiana, Carmen on, 261 S0RA 225 ‘ads, Rare Ain, 270 SCRA 25 eyoia Grand Vilar Soh Arian, I, 276 SCRA lusts, Adoracin of, 266 SCRA 659 TMsegagn, Artaze er 271 SORA 491 Maja lures Corpretin a 270 SCRA 242 TatansopPlrene Fon 217 SORA ST 1907 CASES REPORTED 643 Maal, Alain y itn, 20 SCRA 400 ata Bicre Company x, 271 SORA 17 ‘Miata, Begala oe, 2T8SCRA 668 atape Parte Sun, 218 S0RA286 Tatars Jive, 273 Sema 36 Toler Inlet or 278 SCRA 963 Blase Ferdinand ve, 273 SCRA 47 ‘Baie CriinnFereizer Cperatien or, 273 SCRA 152 Maenguthan Ponino Tv, 275 SCRA 360 Mayr Ste Pipe Corgan a, 274S0RA 412 ated, Nati Son 274 SCRA 62? Tern atin Mo, 277 SCRA 8 Saat Phippins, Tou, 272 SCRA 548 ‘Bleday, Peeve, 266 SCRA 886 eral, Roda, 204 SCRA 8 tenia of San Suan, Metro Mand, 279 SCRA 112 Ratonl Hictrfenon Administration e290 SCRA 108 Natal investment nd Developmen Capeation "PhilppineNetinal Ba 270 SCRA 7 National Power Corporation on 273 SORA 419; 279 SCRA co Negros Nevigtion Ca, Ine 281 SCRA 894 Siva dr Astno vr 9 SCRA | Nos, Conta, 276 SCRA 49 lars dearest, 25050RA 255, TPati Lenard Ao, 268 SCRA 167 ‘Padi Rabin Caras oe, 269 SORA a0 =Briomo, Inacio, 29880RA 392 Patera, Be Oo Pett Development neo, 270 SCRA 82 People ods aad’ Commerc Corpor "BoRA t06644 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED Pages Tang Contin Corporati ty 27 9B _—Poaippine Aine, nen, 275 SCRA 621 ‘Patippise amerscan General Insurance Company, Ine. os, ‘o OcRA Sea \—Pisigpne Amusement and Gaming Corperation 275 ‘SCRA 122 _—Plippne Bank of Commerce ve, 289 SCRA 695 ‘TPilippne Bank of Commanintins en 273 SCRA 682; 279 ‘SCRA -~PioippneTnteriland Shipping Asvocatin ofthe Phiip- pins, 200 8A 49 “—PlippineMatonl Bank ee, 288 SCRA 186,272 SCRA 291; ‘2H SCRATO —Philigine National Contrustion Cororton ve, 272 SCRA Philp Stok Behang, Ines, 281 SRA 22 Tse tavestment Corporation vy 274 STA 102 TPiitrane Service Bterprns ne ve, 279 SCRA S62 TPHIVIDEC Industral Anton, 270 SORA 606 TPM Pasar Brokerage 208 SCRA 368 Totcuin Maynards ee 280 8CRA 3 Tower Commerc sod Indueal Coporstion ot, 274 rade, ete Ncomede 266 SCRA 489 ProLine Sports Center, Ie, 281 SA 162 sical, Protas, 279 SORA 3? Ths, Maun, 260 SCRA 290 “Rati ‘Communtctons of the Phippnes, In oe, 272 ‘SORA 256 Tso, Astn on, 250 SCRA 94 ae, Remedi Nevu ve, 275 SORA 167 Tagua, Antonie Ve, 271 SCRA 148, Tatas Bquipea Haale vn 272 SCRA 196 emia Eaters, Ie, 288 SCRA 638 Repu ef the Philipines on, 268 SCBA 195; 277 SCRA Go Research and Serves Hany, In, 268 SCRA 731 ejen Fla, 279 SCRA 160 ‘tej, Manual Gb, 21 SCRA277 aeje,Znaia we, 26 SORA Be? Tits Bolane ue 4 SCBA GL 1907 CASES REPORTED 645 “Bobet Indus Construction Corporation et, 286 SORA —Rolrgue, Abdali ve, 278 8084 507 ‘Roman Cah Archbishop of Maia ue 269 SCRA 145 ‘Brat Bank of Gepost, 271 SCRA TS Sawant Maro 82 SCRA 78 ‘Soefa aan Teresa ve, 286 SCRA 817 ‘Brome, Gongs Fen, 369 SCRA 64 Benches Bold ox, 29.90RA 64? Stating, Regan, 278SCRA 88 Ststige Lned Devopmest Copnraton ve, 267 SCRA 7; ‘Siveri icrde Cy 271 SCRA 402 Singaen, Cans ve, 252 CRA 149 ‘Sith al Co, ine v8? SCRA 620 ‘Bast ine French Labret La Ssbrepete, Jr Barque A, 280 SCRA 76 Seta Hones, ine on 271 SORA L278 SCRA 267 Sta An, Je Pablo co, 281 SCRA 624 Sta Instat Houde ae 277 SORA 209 Bue, Cesar. 288 SCRA i Stimnpong, hart n, 268 80RA 764 Sate, Bibra Mo 78 SCRA 284 “Bren Tel out Deomest Cron ty 28 as, lf a, 273 SCRA 229 Tee Antonio Pe, 275 SCRA 568 Traspalle eda, 2 SCRA 76 ‘SteegeatPillpines Manufacturing Corpeaton ve, 288 tense Rugenioee, 28 SORA 81 Ti Rose e266 S0RA 167 Tie Rods ve, den SHA 2 ice Brosdastiag Newer 274 SCRA 988 se, Corase Desoler ve, 276 SCRA 582 een, Benjamin, 260 SCRA 226 ‘eres, Band A 278 SCRA 796 teeta Cae ine Cees oye! Sai646 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED Trans Trane & Surety Corporation vs, 272 SORA 6 Sata, Rene ie asscan ch vies Caton 20 S0RA 04 die Soa 205 SCBA 38 dima mpeg, oe o,267 SCRA 768 Urmce oes 38 SRA ed Ube ese Sa a67 Vilemein Harned an Idan Sarpy oe oe 24 cea oat —Vuteor Verte, 80 SRA. 297 alo ern 278 SCRA S40 Tiere Bes, SR Valen pia 37 SCRA Wise Prato [ny 269 SCRA 654 ya brass Seat aul Cv: 278 SCRA 65 out Agena Spa Sth DServe, len Gt, ‘San as Crus, Gi Cart of Apel, 281 SCRA 48 rat Simeon Court Ape, 282 SCRA 88 Dubey Ander _Penple fh Pippin se, 271 SRA, Basten !Narito—People of the Philippines vs., 278 SCRA 998 Daan Honeoye fe Pilipino 390 SCRA. 66 alan NemaoN-Abllrs,Pln He Vas Sor 258 SCEA 8 Danni Sache Ganto, Hanon 260 SCRA Dass Dartngs “Foe the Prins oy 70 SCRA tO Din Ramanan Court hee Ra Del aya Pvp te Pupp 272 SCRA Devi Air sn Common or lcs 27 SCRA SD Divi Non 6 Oar Apel, 276 SCRA 24 ivid Gn Pac Gar of Ape, 260 SCBA 67 esr liay 8s. Comoe on Batons, 27 SCRA 606 ‘ebin Boinaor Vrs n,Cur f npn 4 SCRA S20 De Ol, Pal) Qurine-Ptopl of te Papin, 250 SCRA De Oman, Nena Court of Apps 271 SORA 728 Be Gunman Jy Sekador P= “Bert Sne ce 971 SGRA 828 1997 CASES REPORTED 647 Otic of th Court Administer se, 267 SCRA 201 Den, Anrrae. Court f Appeal 27 SCRA 478 De ten, Delores 7 Aimjn—Pene ofthe Pilpice ve, 267 De Laon, GA. Bains Redo 250 SCRA 494 De Verecia, Jene—Aror, Jka 277 SCRA 268 De Wor, Atado A~Lambing,Oncar Bt, 28 SCRA 60 ‘De Vern, Harty Satae Pepi othe Pliptns ve, 275 SORA, ‘Del Galas, Octavio w. alder, gna I, 269 SCRA 320 Dl Gasil, Rdgar Rom Ch Series Corton, 218 SCRA 200 il Mtr Demet Haters om: Natonal Labor Blains Coe asia, 282 SCRA 608 Det Rearn, Deogrcas Navarre, Wied 270 SORA 264 el Reara,Rady~Pepl of the Pippen 389 SCRA 179 Dat Roars, Virgo Mts Cur of Apri 367 SCA 188 Dal earn, J Mariano Bartslome, Ni, 270 SCRA 65 ‘ala Gran, Gliia 8s Natona! Late Relation Commie, 296 Sora ‘De in Cra, aonards P—People ofthe Philippines er, 226 SCRA, Dela Cru, Ricky—Pepl fhe Phippngs 278 SORA 191 Del Gru, RoelionPepl af be Pippin, 279 SCRA 24S ‘De a Crus, Rasemare Nir —Peope of Se Pilipcs ves 277 ‘som 178 De a Graz, Reali Lo, National Labor Relations Cosi, ‘27 SORA 663 ‘Dela Peta, Clemente Pup fhe Pipiney on, 226 SCRA £58 ‘eta Rest, Carta Delgaie Vu. dev Coar of Appeal, 209 SCRA, a De a Ron, Roa G—Supenn Rodsign Be, 287 SCRA 1 Dele Tor, Feerzo~ Pepi of the Pippin en, 278 SORA O15 Delos Reyes, Oscar Ps Brie, ey EstetanH, S76 SCRA 36 De oe Santon loa RLarano, Royal Ma, 274 SORA 482 Deli Santon Hari ve, Court of Appel, 279 SCRA C2 Dela ranmore ns, Inve. Cour ef Apes, 258 SCRA S87 Data otra Corporation. Coat Appeal 276 SCRA 22 Depursea! of Agrarian Hafra Atjedtaten Boards, Coat of Depee: Sal Wl ad Deven Bae, Atonio i 27 SORA BAS648 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED Devers Sr NerbersC—Gachon, Viera Gv, 274 SCRA 510 Deville, Agandro—Pepl af tae Phipps, 269 SCRA 716 Dian anal yTulpar~People of the Pilppinaa we, 271 SCRA. Diets, ina P-o8Ferntn de, Ruso, 288 SCRA 68 Dinglanan, Habert'y Mangino—Peopl of th Palippnes oe, 207 ‘oR Dini, Gaal v Laguenna,Blnveide 273 SCRA 108 Disopal HraestoSunsn Alan, 281 SCRA 88 Dire of Lands. Ona f opens, 276 SCRA 276 Disilra Washinglons Tne oF? La Teadeta Dialers, Ine, 200 Diao, Ferando St. Lopes, Lia, 278 SCRA 48s ‘abn, ds Nac V- Sani, Oeste e280 SCRA 618 ‘Doran Feds Cotto Appel 270 SCRA S28 ‘Dero, Gary Laja-Peopl of the Pipes 8,262 SCRA 1 ‘Dro, Frail Me. Court f Appeal, 710 SCRA 211 Behar, Looy Pis—Papl of the Pippin ve, 267 SCRA 682 ‘Beube-Dadal Maria, Badal, Devid Dee Pe, 213 SCRA 820, ‘Bnalino,JeeanPoopl of he Pippin 211 SCRA 19 -EMS Manpower & Paceeat Series Noon Labor Relations ‘Ensandn, Hack People ofthe Plipines 280 SORA 72 ‘Enrique, rest 7 Rosles~People of tho Pallpines "Soka toa ovigen Jolt Ro Canara, Raby B, 280S0RA 1 evataral Ranty Drelopment, neo Anuncace, Je, Casino, guia Banking Caperaton vo, Netinal Labor Rlations Com: inion, 273 SCRA 552 rar, Marelno Paolo he Philipines ve 27 SCRA S43 res, Alan y Balingit-Poope ofthe Palipine, ve, 281 SCRA [ic Pt, Li. Car of Appeals, 257 SCRA 857 Tipe J, Eatban Delon gen Oser Pe 276 SORA 36 [Enon aronis-Cout of Appeal, 277 SCRA 381 ‘ocean lenclte y Heoento People ofthe Faipine oe, 281 Sena 08 -osstn Uidarso Cour of Apes 278 SCRA 762 Engr Justa Vu Court af peas, 257 SCRA 80 ‘Expane; Chrntper y Paquingne Pople of the Phiipine ‘miscna exe 1007 CASES REPORTED 9 opate, Se, Modest. oe. Cour of Appeds, 268 SCRA 511 opt, ober o-Jevlans, dards, 260 SCRA 570 Equiv Gaver oe. Cout of Appi, 272 SCRA 802 ‘Bnares, Hectr—Poole of he Piles ve, 282 SCRA 524 Eetnin, Tid 8 ve Car of Appeals 266 SCRA 62? ataller,Lewiyn Sve Mannie, Jr Soi, 28 SCRA 608 ‘Bernal Gardens Memorial Park Carporation vs. Court of Appeals, ain Aber Barone fhe Pipe, 274 SCRA, ‘Bvanelt, Hoger—People ofthe Philippines ot, 262 SCRA7 ‘Bren Seetary—Cordeailo, Hobart, 278 SCRA 652 [Beet Secretary TheLarn,Aglina Te, 280 SCRA 713 ‘Brees, Aono GLomigld, Arsenio Pv, 382 SCRA 125 ‘aba, Armand Court of Appel, 262 SCRA 256 abr, Scmades People of the Papper ng 277SCRA19 abr, Ronald y Sores People of he Philipines oe, 278 SORA ae ornan, Je, Rasoe—Diclean, las Pv, 288 SCRA 69 eranan, Fernand 9 Magne—Propleo he Philipines 0, 275. SCRA eraanen, Jat B, , National Labor latins Comino, 281 erer, Norn 8-—Pespla fhe Philipines o, 212 SCRA 695 Pere, Hain vs, Court of Appeal, 2745CRA 310 Pere Cll, PureHatipaneng mga Mengeaawa ce Deungen ip, Napoleon Carel, J, Joos Bo, ‘lore, Dama 8. beens, Bernard, 278 SCRA 302 Flores, Dela Mabe Naan 272 SCRA 615 ‘lore, Renato~Poops ofthe Phlipines sx, 29 SCRA 62 [ord Phlppoe Inet, Gort Appi 287 SCRA 39, ‘oruey, PermoateJoy—Pepie of the Pilppnee Un, 281 SORA ove Stanley Jo. Court of Appeals, 268 SCRA 152 ortune Motors Pla) Corea om ConrofAppeal, 287 SORA650 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED ‘rant, Jelly Tiasen—People f the Philippines on, 289 SORA ‘Fuel, Rasa—Pooplef the Pippaas un, 261 SCRA 452 ‘ue, Mains. Cour Appeals 268 SCHA 708, ‘Puente, odlo ne Naieoal Labor Raations Comin, 268 ‘sera ‘Furaswn Rubber Plippne, oe os. Seretary of Labor and ‘armect, 252 SCRA 638 CGatayon Jery—Panle fhe Pilipino, 278 SCRA 78 (Garr, LacreclaPeple the Pasi, 287 SCRA S81 (Gacos, Vera. Dever, Je, Norbert 274 SCRA S10 er Fandango he Pains aD SCRA (ali, ky ve. National Labor Halatine Commission, 276 SCRA ‘Cance-n, Teta Cu, Soertary of Labor and Employment, 275 ‘SCRA 204 Gareitorea, Vito P— Bebo, Be, 271 SORA 23 ‘Geen Aotoio Mo Cour 0 pens 273 SCRA 239 aS y PnP of Papin, 271 SORA canis ‘Davi y Qutrio—Peopl of he Pipl, 61 SCRA ann Sn. Cort Agen, 26 SCRA 678 Geren, Marta O—Abeea Corpotson ofthe Phiippinos ve, 272 ‘Sona a5 Garcia, Sry Jesus Be, Feje,Napslace R208 SCRA 489 (Garintead, Lara Pass, Wied Ly 276 SCRA 769 ‘Gurma, Ale “Pespe ef the Phipine ve, 272 SCRA 617, ‘Garments and Teal port Board ve Court of Appeal, 26 SORA (Gari, Lets G1, Sle, de, PoveioG, 271 SRA 767 [Gaape Eleaar oe Bayboo, Will i, 276 SCRA 92 ‘Guperdesue~Orcin, Anglia C. cu 279 SCRA.TO ‘Gatmeyian, Augusta Court of Apes 267 SCRA 487 ‘Ontwar, Nig! Bichard-Peope af the Phllplnes bo, 287 SORA ‘Sapo, pfanio—Pepl a the Pippen, 269 SCRA Se (Glo, Jory Pople of tne Palippnes 277 SORA 450 (Gemala Jr, Polo C~Angls, Adoracon ©. 274 SCRA 10 1907 CASES REPORTED 651 Geren, Neto y VilanuevePeple ofthe Philipines ox, 261 evi Adele A Anonymous 4, 279 SCRA 279 CGiodout Sn ‘Fein Garment’ Mannfnetoring (Pie) Toe— “American Iter ashen Corpration vn 268 SCRA 258 (GMCM, fe Bll Teecomeuntestion Philippe, ine, 272 SORA (Go, Ripar Mo. Nation Plce Commision, 271 SCRA 447 (Ge, Nene. Court of Appeal 272 SORA 782 ‘GOA, Into, Court Appeal, 278 SCRA 350 ‘Going Santiago Viera, Rolando R28 SCRA 1 SGalenges ens Uy om Viana, Cando P 278 SCRA 14 ‘Gomes Eduardo People cf the Phipins 2.70 SCRA 432 (ores MarePeope af the Papineau, 279 SCRA 28. ep Serve Gps. Nan! ior ean Coe ‘Goals Raynldoy Rivera, Court of Appa, 277 SCRA S18 ‘overeat rie lnuree Sytem Gnu of Appeal, 209 SCRA 167 anil Price Hel or, 257 SORA 408 ‘race Cirtan High Scho ve Cour of Apes, 281 SCRA 128 Grea, Bare Poole othe Palins 271 SCRA SO] Gog, Wize on Cnenein om Bletlnn #74 SORA 481 ‘Growth Link, ine, Cour ef Apeds, 278 SCRA 419 (Gaerere, Jona F~Camanag, Olas Bo. 268 SCRA 673 ‘Oar Rar y Anghat-People ofthe Pains on 277 SCRA oe uiten, Pept w, Contain, Lai, 252 SCRA 8 (Gsnnax Interior Ine Notienal Laber Relations Comision, "72 SCRA 600 Casino, Pina 6. Comalasion on Baton, 270 SCRA 413 “ihn, Ald ot. Court of Appel, 286 SCRA 557 “raya, Anotia~Poope ofthe Phipps ve, 79 SCRA S67 “oir f Balan Nero oe. Ilaruint Appllate Cour, 206, ‘SCRA 4; 390 SCRA SO” ir of Pala Cangue ve, Cort Appeal, 278 SCRA 74, tire of Mail A Hone. Court of Appeal 270 SCA 909 ele of Mal. Sune, Cour of Appa 260 SCRA aut eis of Maetine Pago ve. Court of Appel, 280 SCRA B70 ‘Hs arian Nog Court Appona 282 SCRA 43(652 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED oir of Pedro Ecanlar ot. Cnurt of Appel, 281 SORA 176 Heir of Segunda Maaingiing se. Court Appi, 216 SCRA 6OL Heir of the Late WO Repaid nian =, Natt] Labor lations Geman, 282 SCRA 77 Heir ofthe Late Teador Ouarog, Jee, Court of Appeals, 260, ‘Sona Ie. Naina Laer Relation Conison, 276 SCRA Ho, Dora Twrna ve, Pople the Phaipines ut, 280 SCRA 968 ‘bili Marita™Vanqun, Conrado M271 SORA 67 olga France Coon Apps 28 SCRA 177 eee nl Laer Blinn Coin, 21 ERAS epresetaies Berl Tribunal-Pe, Tei @. so SGua 0 nian Norvio—Pesl of si Phiipins 278 SORA 118 {Ene tourc Vp te Pans, SORA As ‘i Snel Slae onde Tropes A, #0 GORA358 Ine Al Argon, 270 SRA 98, {tdaral Ber Crporton National Taber Relations Ca "nan, 29 SCRA 300, Sng in Sendo, 22 CEA IEE oly Svetment Serve, Curt f Appel, 273 ‘cua armed Apple Coart— is of lane Naver, 268 SCRA 74 290 SCRA S67 “iar Raya Bc 279 SCRA SE luni, Grgut te Nac Labor Rltons Coin, 206 na, na ~Pepl fhe Pipes os 278 SCRA sole Dinca of the Phlipace os. Court of Appel, 272 Sct Ture Sony Bitnoni—Porl ofthe Flip 72 SCRA 98 {oan Saye: Mine no: Os te Present 20 SERA 62 1907 CASES REPORTED 653 Jains, Melinda oar of Apes 281 SCRA 657 ‘eco, Alory Somentaia se. Cou hyped, 210 SCRA 20. ‘Tasinay, Mame People othe Phipps v, 260 SCRA 768 ‘Teme Corazon Natal Labor Relations omen, 278 ‘Sona soa miro, BroetoSantlage—People ofthe Philippoes 70 SCRA, umd Hlando— Asta, Teresa ot, 218 SCRA257 Sunuato, Rene yRalan~Peopl of th Papier, 267 SCRA, ‘oo Jari Machine Shop and Aste Sepp, eve Jos Ae, Conlin om Elections. 270 SCRA 255. “evr, Benedicto” People a th Pippen, 269 SCRA 181 “Tyee, Wenesao Peri ofthe Pipes, 289 SCRA 108 SEDO. Aguiar Corperatin ee, National Labor Relation Com ‘msi, 26 SCRA Soe Jone, Vai Lature—Peope ofthe Philipines, 278 SCRA 245 ‘Svan Land. new Gaur o Appel, 258 SCRA 160 ‘ovllane, Eduardo Exit Reber wr 80 SCRA 679 ‘oy Brahe Ineo. National Wage snd Padus Commie, ‘7a SCRA soa EB Healy, oe Cour ef Appeal, 271 SCRA 205, Sur, Bonemin Coe Nevonl Labor Ralutions Carian, 277 CEA 628 Jian, Hain—Poope othe Philipines, 270SCRA 782 ‘Tiana, Araroce,Sandgnyaa, 269 20H 92 0 Nets aber Rte. Hanlon Construction Enterprises Co, In, Nasional Labo ala ‘Sons Commision 270 SCRA SEF Katipunan ag gn Manezagena on Dengan vs, erre-Clle, ura 278 SCRA 83) ‘Antonio. Commission on Beton, 278 SCRA 462 ier, Vier Court of Appeal, 260 SORA 488 —Pantrancs North xpos, ncrporatad et, 269 SCRA 498 ‘Kaban, ne» Commie e Beco 250 CRA a2 istanar Sinean 1 ve Ball Tolecrmaaiain Pilpines, Ine ‘gr soma Teo ‘La Tondeia Dis, Ine—Distilria Washington, In. v8, 280 1 Vista Aszeciatin, Tne, Curt Appel, 28 SCRA 408654 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED Leshan, Csar—People othe Pippin 270 SCRA 68 {Geena Neil y Carero~People fhe Philippinen, 278 SCRA "i Lagan J, FdtPepl of ha Philppings 271 SCRA 51 {agate Sees: Pen Jr dae, 20 SCRA 46 {gman Beal Tove, Raber, 281 SCRA 380 262 SCRA 837 {agua Biavene B— “Galt Medd Center Aline of Cosered Eaplyee: "United Flpine Service Worker on, 267 SCRA 503 Dini, Gamal te, 279 SCRA 100 Progeanive Development Coporstion Fase Hat ee, 271 Soka so —Sunahan hg Manemngnwa m Pac Pate vt, 267 SCRA 30 San Mig! Corporation Supervisors and Exempt Employee "Untn vs FFF SCRA 97 ian, ana e Vergra, Flonene A. 278 SCRA S18 {Cabin Our Boe De Vern Armedo A275 SCHA 6D {moran ten River Rama A, 250 SCRA 69 ands Linas, Molec PNP Criminal Tnvatiation Command on, 262 SCRA 76 Court of Appel: 271 SORA 477 geo, Comminan os Election, 278 SCRA 705 {tin Agena T-vr'The Brow Secreay, 280 SCRA 713 ergs Francie Jun Court Appeals 281 SCRA 234 aneta dohany 7 Candong--People of he Philippines os 275, Lasreano Investment and Development Corporation ws. Court of “Kopel 272 SCRA 259 Lavi ila Gos, Coot of Appeal 271 SCRA 148 {Cavin Sure Serve, ne. National Labor Relations Commis Lara, Benji S. vs. Court of Appeals, 269 SCRA 684 ‘Leachen Sr il Leg, Brest, 208 SCRA 777 oder Mndre Mo, Cort of Appeal 218 SCRA 58 ogee Vieorio,Court of Appi, 289 SCRA 642 {alg Areeiow Poole ofthe Poin oe, 208 SCRA 227 igen ge Barangy, Quote Cay Conger se, Conmioion ex letens 27150330 Li, Nester or, Commison on Bletions, 262 SCRA 53 1907 CASES REPORTED 655 Lim, Je, Rodrigo F—Pacarbot, Herel ML, 278 SCRA 84 Lind, Gonradne,Cmmiason oy Beton 274 SCRA Sat ising Renate ySansnge—People af the Paipines om, 226 SCRA mana Caren ve Cour of Apes 281 SCRA 25, ‘inmado, eos Bo Reva, Armand, 290 SORA S07 ‘Undo, ieardo A. Caar f Apes. 70 SCRA 423 Unnes, dy Peers A~Development Bank of the Philipines ot, Lowa, Joel AA, Pike Pon, 282 SCRA 248 sar, Fernanda yBering~Peiplc af th Piipins ox, 280 SCRA Lape, iia Die, Fernand 278 SORA 483 Lopes, Perce —Sattar, Abt An, 371 SORA 200 ‘apola Grand Vile South) Amocaen, nee. Court of Appeals, Layla, Ray Mo. Commision en Elctany, 270 SCRA 404 rman, Reynaldo Ms De ln Santon, Esser R274 SCRA 452 Unhgaban, Antoni C-—Temarong, Herma, 269 SCRA 624 ‘Vamiqud, rsa P. Eaeton oil 289 SCRA 125, ‘Lin, Panel. on Natal Lebar Raat Coma, 270 ‘SCRA 227 ‘asia, Adbacon Court ef Apes, 266 SCRA 6 Maat, Fernando y Pajrdo—Poople of the Philippines ot, 275 ‘Sona aos Mate Nica Nao Lair Relat Conmiin, 271 Macalintl,Haulb But. Te, Angelito C, 260 SCRA 629 Macau, Madoona ve. Tia Je Dominge, 378 SCRA 83 ‘Macapagal Arar, Cour Apes 271 SORA 01 Maco, Lyndon V--Boope of tho Pipyoes so 28 SCRA Mapallanen Grogaro People the Philippines vr 218 SOA 222 “Magallen, DismetesPeople of the Philippac ty 258 SCRA $06 ‘Magadan lero ve, Netonel Labor Relaene Gamsiton, 269 ‘SRA 4S. Magdamt, Jary—Peopl of he Pippines 279 SCRA 428 Masia, Hater Ps Taye, Ariston 274 SCRA26 Magnaye, Bieveade S~Agunas Schau 278 SCRA 622 aber, Saly Hose ort Pippa 282 SCRA Matas Angas Masato Pliny 21656 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED Matayan nearanceCarperton ve, Cour of Appl, 270 SCRA 242 Malin Romane Ron Cebanting, Aran Per 272 SCRA 408 DMalonn, Reyaale 0, Commision on Besos, 209 SCRA 380 ‘Maraleyan Metel— Poole he Philpins on, 290 SCRA 74S: ‘Mansyp Praia Poe Cort of Appen 277 BA 5? ‘Manel Aleiny Dien, Cort Apes 260 SCRA 400 ‘Manabi, Antnin~Poope of the Pippnas on, 271 SCRA Sta ‘Mansnal, Dane y ManslanaagPeple ofthe Pullppises v6, ‘Mansind Jr, Stoo Baral, Levly Sv, 268 SORA 608 ‘Mania Bening Corporation Notonal Labor Relations Commis- tan, 279 SCR oa ‘Manila Electric Company — Court of Appel 271 SCRA 617 or National Labor alton Conaiasa, 281 SCRA 423 ‘Mania rice Ht. Government Servis Laseace Systm, 267 ‘SORA 108 ‘Manol, adie... Contraction Suply, 284 SCRA 806 ‘Mana! Guesen University Nessa Labor Raations Commie. ‘Manaron Nat People a he Pippa ve, 277 SCRA 50 ‘Manca, Angelia, Court of Appeals 70 SCRA 698 ‘Maan, Neto > Almario~Peple of th Philippines ee, 269 ‘Mapa, Puta 8, Court Appl, 275SCRA 266, ‘Mare, Jlovs. Court Aen 278 SCRA 276 ‘Maren Inelse cv, Gout of Appeal 18 SRA 23 Maree Ferdinand 3 os: Onat af Appeal 278 SCRA 47 Mara Crintna Fertilizer Carprtion te. Court of Appeals, 273 Maran, Jury People of be Philips os, 279 SCRA 70 Marlins, Doisto= Popo ftw Pilipinas, 276 SCRA B& Marine, Beno y Dele RoaPoope of tho Philips bx, 274 CRA M8 Martins Nelly Acta ot None Labor Relations Commiin, 272 SCRA 198 DMatalam, Keren Mr, Commision on Elen, 271 SCRA 788, Matanguian, Pencnae Toe Court of Appeal, 278 SCRA 380 Mayer Sel Pipe Carpration ve. Court of Appeal, 2 SCRA 432 Medina, Veron Gay Sherif Masia, 276 SCRA 183, ‘Maganape Gara Services os. Natonl Labor Relations Commi le, 274 SCRA 17 Maja Groprio 7 Vilataie—Poopla of che Pippen ve, 275 ‘sora ia? 1997 CASES REPORTED 657 Melgar Mereaer, Ania y Tongeo—Pople ofthe Piping, 27 ‘SCRA soo Momsen, Salvador A—Beraah, Gado 277 SCRA.1 ‘Mendova ds Te Angelo C269 SCRA 264 ‘Mendoza, Nala ee, Court of Appin, 274 SCRA 527 Merce Rga y PicePepo th Pippin o,275 SCRA Fleeting Tsao ofthe Pipa, 27 SCBA Matoplitn Bank & Trust Co—Aguense, J Antonis oe, 271 SCRA, Mijare,Bith M. ,Coar of Appel 27 SORA 558 ‘Mire, Pils Cstillo Van. eo. Villun, Onan A, 274 SCRA t Mindince Termine! und Brokerage Servic, Ins, os. Rldan- Confess, Ma. Nir, 272 SCRA 63 Mirani, Vier Rae Cut, Sone By 224 SCRA 608 Mirani, Salvador C— ~tzeras, Lata Pr, 20 SCRA 608 Cara, ry CrvcesVo, 216 SCRA M6 ‘Mica, Fein os Netinal Labor Blaine Cammiasio, 279 ‘Sonase ‘Mia, berAlune afl Mon, 276 SRA 804 ‘Moi Paine, nee, Cour o Appeals, 72 SCRA 88 ‘Moday, Perla Court of hppa, 268 SCRA 666 ait, Antone Be: Navona Labor Reateas Commiaen, 28 sie Doe 2 Pring go TC Queen Ci, Be. 106, Moogzipa Carat 8S Mel ,267 SRA S37 Montel, Handa y Bald Peopl of the Padipynes ey 289 Bows 735 Mone, VtetoPespl of he Phlipins t, 277 SORA 194 Menten T~Dornua de, Doeinador D200 SORA 181 Morale, odo, Cours f Arpaia 14 SCRA 262 “Moreno, Domingo“ Poo fhe Pipins oy 278 SCRA 207 ‘Mi amires Indust Scary of abe ag Been, 28 MSCINAGUBIP Ls Catoron. Nation! Wag nd Pros ‘omnia 260 SCRA 18 iy Manteo a Jam Ma Mas, rar of pei, 278658 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED [Nacuray, Dante, National Labor Relaies Coniston, 270 ‘Sekas’ Nashleln Maren Sen MAMAS, Natenl aor [Negulat, Serio Foe National Lato Relations Corio, 269 ‘SCRA S64 ‘Nalangan, Geer;—Peple of the Piping 270 SCRA 204 art Hoenn y Ogu Prgi ct Palin 576 SCRA ‘Nant, Roland Ss People he Philipines, 280 SORA 268 ‘Naro, dwin~People the Phipps oy 270 SCRA 62 Narede, Jason People of he Phipps, 976 SCRA 43 GG Blab Non Cor Rots Cnn 274 SCRA ‘Nan, AntnloM—Bayeg,Aleianér oe, 271 SORA 358 [Nation Brendestiog Corpratin sr Nationa! Labor Relations emminie, 0 SORA atnl Bure if lve Teli, Rao Gy 270 SCRA National Hlcfieton Adaintain o, Ceart of Apane, 240 Sex io fee Natioal Federation of Labor Unlna (VAFLU)—Brew Matar In terntinnn Inet 271 SCRA P76 Natioal Invent ad Development Corpiaton~Phiippine "Nao! Bank oe. Ceare ef Appein20 SCRA 40? asia Labor laos Ganon ““ABS.CHN Baployees Union 2 276SCRA 129 ‘TARP Mutual Bent Ateiato,Inen, 267 SORA 47 Al ode Greens, Tne, 289 SCRA 47 Ries Pewee Cen Gpetn e280 SCRA Al vento and Srey Ags. 72.SCRA —AreMon Feed indus Ineo 22 SCRA 966 ‘etn, Je, Advtans Aen 278 SCRA 306 ‘Teta, Cars on, 279 SERA 806 ‘Tatton, Zaid 278 SCRA 408 ales Perle Conporatien vy 278 SCRA 40 ‘Aurea and Projet Comoran 266 SCRA 48 Bane Growers Cassin st Pug Pama, 276 SCRA, Boa, Shiperd and Engineering Corporation ot, 269 ‘SCRA 19 Bion Henny Bgulpment, Ineo, 278 SCRA253. 1907 CASES REPORTED 659 Bend, Apslnio ve, 276 SORA 298 Bahan eaten, neve, 20 SCRA 626 ‘—BUling Care Corporat, 268 SCRA 606 “thea, Hermit ve 277 SCRACT. tm, Wied on” 270 SCRA 4S ep citon, 20 SCRA 488 Sept, Sove 7, 278 SCRA 876 Th Sale on, 969 SCRA 196 Tre Amor sn #71 SCRA 14 oni Conrado, 274 SORA 582 Cems Batting Corporation on, 281 SCRA 46 DENG Revi Ly 277 SOA 868 [Darter Dement Hntrpinr on, 262 SCRA 602 Bt Manpower Pacoment Servint 206 SCRA 217 Baia Banking Corporation on, 273 SCRA 382 Ferseadee Joss Bon, 261 SORA 423 ‘eens, Rel ve, 265 SCRA 24 ate, Rieko, 6 SCRA 83. ‘np Serves Carporton ve, 266 SCRA 657 ‘Gensnon vr vx, 279 SORA 126 sino intro neo, 22 SCRA 8 THicesathe Late BO Reyanide Ania 282 SCRA 377 THtspate nee 276503315 Toten Mining engine and Shag Basing Capron Raph Toil Timber Corporation 273 SCRA 200 Titel Grapes 6 SCRA 1a ester Ceraren ty 7OSCHA 6 tee Machine Shp and Aut Suply, In. ve, 258 SCRA 7” 3.81.0. Aur Corpcatin ve, 289 SCRA 596 Tete Benjamin Co 277 SCRA B28 THettaon Controntion Ratnpies Co, Is oy 278 SCRA Lara Security Servis, ne, 273 SORA 182 Tite, rence 20 SCRA 227 ‘Babee, Norma 271 8CRA 870 Magen, Haro, 260 SCRA 48 ‘Saati Banking Cnpocation ve, 279 SCRA 602 ‘=BMasi eee Company 251 SCRA 423, ‘TRdSea Ls Gamer Unione 374 SCRA 36 Marien Naly coe, 2s SCRA To660 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED Meso Gaperal Saree vs, 274SCRA 141 treo, Ptcad ve, 270SCRA 96 tlt Antonie Bo, 268 SCRA 42 —Reearey, Dantes, 20 SCRA 9 =Nighatainang Mangungewa st Sony (VAMASO) on, 272 ‘Sona aca _—Reguit Serio. x, 209 SORA 64 Rath Mav, 2743oRa 370 ‘TivinBrsadesting Corporation us, 20 SORA 65 ‘Resin Power Crporen on, 27 SCRA 704 Node Sey and Aled ren Ine, 278 SORA Nara, Benard on, 274 S0RA 350 ‘SNED international Manning Agents, ne 269 SCRA 495 AtAConsls ine e208 SCRA 1? aging, Bayer n,270 SORA 618 “ones Exorae Placimené Phlippaes te, 257 SCRA 267, “ra SCRA 36 Badia, Wires ve, 273 SCRA AST “Palmar Perna by 277 SRA 42 ‘Pampanga Sugar Develoeent Company PASUDECO), fe es 272 SCRA 737 Pal Meine Be, 261 RA 59 ‘TPeeaCaa Distt of Be Philipines, Te. ot, 272 ‘SCRA 262 _—Poilipise Aine, te ve, 276 SCRA 301; 279 SCRA 448, Pauline Long Ditan Telephone Company on, 216 SCRA. tat Prine National Centrution Corporation v, 277 SCRA 31,280 S0RA 300 Pepin Rat Bs ns, In. ot 278 SCRA 106 Pipine Sect VetoansSeously and Tovstaton “Age oe 71 SEA 309 Pig spn Pt Sei, 27 SORA, ulin Tera and gene Cpe, 22 Phipps Tey, ne, 267 SRA 202 “Phineas, Ineo, 279 SCRA 286 =P. Bangoer irs fo 376 SRA 1997 CASES REPORTED 661 Povo, otnds Boe, 275 SCRA GIL “Progra Homes, 369 SCRA 274 Tea Corporation ve, 271 SORA 247 TBhrit elo of 8B Liner Ineo 286 SCRA 733 Repl Paster Bank ve, 208 SCRA Laz Titman og men Manggure oe BendoineLMLC ve, 275, CRA 6 Samar Il lease Coperativ,Insoroated ve, 270 SCRA, “San Jann De Dic Hopital Raployees Aston AFW os, baa SCRA 316 Seay earl Coreen 290 SCRA 109 “Sigs Ship Manges Pi, neo, 206 SCRA 201 Sie Mg, 4 SCRA se Stern Cotabato Development and Constructo, le. ‘20 SCRA 863 Soil Pain and Wathen Assan (PLAID Peder "ion Sy 218 SCRA B28 —tesang.Parieacos Go, 266 SORA 402 Taser Genege M v0, 278 80RA31 Tae Marine Nee, 274 SCRA 18 Ta teri, 277 SORA 60 Traders Reyal Bank Employees Unien-Independent or, 269 ‘Sona Tas trendline Employees AreiatonSouthers Philipines Fed. ration of Labor to 27250RA 172 Tumba Marcin os, 274 SCRA 888 ‘TIGER Rimi Modi Conte, 69 SCRA 70 ‘Ciergra, Lada P. ow, 283 SORA 406 Wilt tlm, 260 SCRA 620 aero Dro Corporation 280 SORA 785 —atora Security Newnes and Ali’ Servis vs, 270 SCRA, ‘ocala Univesity oe, 276 SCRA 692(662 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED Nate La Rei Cin Tit Divina, ay Natal Flue Gemmiio—GoEdga M.o,27 SCRA 47 :Gnartof Appel, 373 SCRA 49; 279 SCRA S08 : Natea! Later Beason Commas, 272 SORA 704 ‘Notioni Wore aad Predctiviy Common “Joy Brother Ine, 27990RA 622 SGISCENACUSIP Local Chapern, 269 SORA 179 [Nationwide Soearty and Aled Serie’ Ineo, National Labor elton Cosieon, 276 SCRA 34. ‘Nawal David Cw Pandey, JoeB, 275 SCRA 654 ‘Nemlo, oenari—Poople of te Pilipinas, 208 SCRA 569 ‘Navareia, Nou! Gavil, Benign Gta, 275 SCRA 66 [Nivare Globe S~Fepl the Pipes, 270 SORA 385, ‘Nevare, Wie o Del Roar, Drogas K, £7 SCRA 204 ‘Neto, Berar Matos! Labor Balaton Comminnn, 24 ‘SCRA 350 ‘Nera, Ela B- bt. Common oo Blciong, 279 SORA 69 ‘Nenaron Ramee Pov Alar Brigue M208 SCRA 60? NO. CaoetrctonSupl-—Manoe, Eden, 282 SCRA 506. ‘Negron Naviaton Ca oe. Goat of pec 261 SCRA BA ‘Neves, Deis on, Gil Serie Commit, 278 SCRA 610 [NPD International Manag Agel Ine: Natal Labor Ral ‘ion Commun, 368 SCRA 428 NAConalt oe Nation aber Relations Corian, 256 ‘Soka? ‘Nien dr, Antonio, Court Appi, 272 SCRA 1 ‘Ninoy Aina nts Alper Ato: Cart of Appa [elas Eaarde ox. Commision on Becton, 276 SCRA T62 ‘Neo Cancion. Gaur f Apply SCRA 1 ‘Neth Front Shopng Sern, In —Tbwenera Tnmorane Co, aSCRAG? ‘Note ceel Sevla—People of the Piigpines e270 SCRA Ne Malanyeen, Corton Dubrgin Heiesta and Employee "Asseiaton or Deeapmnt, Ine ve, 8 SCRA 42 Oar, Zacnia ve, Cour of Appenis, 250 SCRA 235 ‘bun, en. Court Appeals, 365 SORA 281 ‘eins Sabadar Mea, France, 266 SCRA 28 Sip Far Cnr a Aah 0 SCRA 38 1997 CASES REPORTED 663 De Guaas,J, Salvadr F267 SCRA 201 ‘Paoganiban, Daa 277 SCRA 408 ‘Suman, Auguste 271 SCRA S16 $e Vilnser Olver, 279SCRA 267 (tc he Onda Canel, Lavining Pv 276 SA 695 ‘Ofte fhe President Legon Supe Mines, foto 270 SCRA 68 ‘tra, Aly Cortro—Paople othe Papin 282 SCRA 470 nop. Blavenie y Magdaraog—Feople ofthe Phlipgines Se sca oo COmbaieman Abang, Je, Caslane os, 268 SCRA 301; 270 ‘nota, Ersoy Carlegn—Peole fhe Phipins ve, 257 SCRA saa, Pero—Poope ofthe Philipines va, 272 SORA 631 ‘Seg, Mga Camper Court of Apple 272 SCRA T38 ‘Onckinge, Bierande ve: National Lar Relations Conse, ning Angee Ce. spar, Jove, 219 SCRA 7S ‘rot, Vilanor—Peopl the Plippinas 277 SCRA SO. (fain Genet Dr—Guios,Hana S272 SCRA 84; 277 SCRA Orient Erpress Placement Plppines Naina Labor Ralatnes ‘Commuvion, 257 SCRA 25273 SORA 256 natal Son Cart Appel, 26 SCRA SEL rege Jr Bexbamin 9 CanePeopla of the Philipines ws, 276 ScRA 168 nign Cos La. Paenertip oe Vea, Teo, 277 SRA 2 ‘si Hany Puople the Phspines 266 SCHA B81 ‘fee Miynm Lato People ofthe Philips ve, 279 SCRA 380 an, leno. Court Appeals, 282 SCRA $48 Pani Lagarde Aco Coat ot Appeal 256 SCRA 167 Pate Maritime Seve Ine anay Ncanoe 275 SORA 717 Pacurbot Row! Me Linde Hedi F275 SCRA 6% Pian Santino 3 Blenzel~People of th Philippines, 257 SCRA ‘adil Robin Cri, Cort of Appeal, 269 SCRA 02 Padi Wilda. oe Navona! LaberRetans Comision, 278 aga Naly amaut—Poope cf the Pippees vs, 272 SCRA 449 Pagar, Pedr 7 Thing People of te Pipnes oe, 267 SCRA664 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED Palen, Carina (Comal) V—Agnpay, Belinda A. vy 278 SORA Palo, Jeu y Gubtan-Poope of he Philippine 279 SCRA, Palomar Dione_Peopl af the Pippen, 278 SCRA 114 Palomar, Ferdinand ve. Naina Labor Relais Commision, or scRA a8 Pampanga, Supt Dewlomert Natt Later Hlatne Comins 272 SRA 7 emia; Dia HO othe Gs Aaa 27 anglina,Adercin Oo, Cou of Appel, 279 SCRA 590 Pen, Motes B. ve. Nelionl Labor Ralations Comision, 281 ‘ScRAS anos BarnrdePeore ofthe Philips ve, 278 SCRA 857 ‘Pantazon,Susan—Pesla of he Philipines 274 SCRA 133 Pintrases Mert Breen, Incrporsed ee. Kiera, Vicor, 259 Parada, Deno Bs. Veeracin, Lorene B. 289 SCRA 37 Peratague Kings Roterprie, Tecrperated ve Court of Apes, ma SCRA T2? area, Marion 7 Pransace—People of the Philippines ot, 272 Purdie Jr, Araton~ Pople of th Philippines, 262 SCRA 286, stone, Pei Onur of Apple 251 SCHA 267 Patrvare, Rede—Peope of te Philipines or, £74 SCRA 180 Pteron Pls Cour Appa 273 SCRA 70 oy Hed Haid mun Cominon on Blt Palas Developnent, nee Cour of Apes, 270 SCRA 82 Pot, Teodoro. House of Repreaematvs Hector Tibanl, Petar, Carano B. ox, Commiesin on Evens, 252 SCRA, ‘Peary, Jimny y Baranda-Poopa ofthe Philipines, 276 SCRA esas J Joe Lagat Joe, 76 SCRA 8 People ofthe Phlppnee— te Abad, Flaecin, 268 SCRA 246 :Abedes Ramon 9 Salen, 268 SCRA 619 = Abecino, Vitor, 28 SORA 1907 CASES REPORTED 665, Adora, Marino, 275 SCRA 44s Agung, Nelo, 279 SCRA 52 Als, Rane, 34 SCRA 310 Alera Nida Vilar 278 SCRA 216 Allo. Salvdery Morndan 268 SCRA 154 ts: Avaredn Ral Liner 275 SCRA 722 -Alnare, Boy Vill, 257 SCRA 266 teva, Armandn 278 SCRA 629 ts: And, ary y Meno, 279 SCRA 64 Anda, Palio Hereades, 258 SCRA 95 fo Angeles, Dany, 278 SCRA 1 Ani guy Alan, 278 SCRA 405 Ati Rogelio Lapep 274 SCRA 28 1: Aston, Cart, 273 SCRA 928 ‘Arliao; Diva 268 SERA S20 fe Arng, Lina 274 SCRA 685 Asta eve SCRA 60! 1s: Rllse, Teoarv, 259 SCRA 83. ts: Aras, Buenfey Amado 268 SCRA 71) Beat, 217 SCRA 2 {Bahr Giwna y Cg,2t SCRA 252 Baad, Admin 774 SCA 6S { Baluns, Nemes, 272608 782 Balers RupertayCabasop, 276 SCRA 470 Banal New SCRA (78 Bastia, est, 278 SCRA 619 Bayo, Benvntoy Areamo, 275 SCRA 526 Bena, Armando y Ale, 277 SCRA 252 be Begonia Raands 973804 78 St: Bernal, Theodore 4 SCRA Besos, Sogo 279 SCRA S22 Bina ‘Anon 278 SCRA 454 ‘Bool, Teor Dela Grn 274 SCRA 298 Briones, Aled y Ravers 256 SCRA 254 er Buguri, Merelizo A373 SCRA 334 5 Bandung Art 22 SCRA al Bars Federico A, 269 SCRA 300 1 Barges Anton 279 SCRA 69? Barto, Willa Reber, 286 SCRA 891(666 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED Ban, Rema F201 SORA 375 Gabalon Bouads 374 SCRA 8S Gabel ely Tw, 282 SCRA 410 fr Calan, lea 267 SCRA 258 Caco, bets y Paar, 268 SCRA 273 Caine omen, 266 SORA Boe Gal, dy Sab, 80 SCRA 06 ‘1 Garin Leonards y Lames, 278 SORA 263 ‘Crp Albers D252 Sa 23 ‘Carre, ina Pre, 282 8CRA SEA 2 Cane Willa O, 290 SCRA 360 ‘Casto Marjorie, 273 SCRA 22 Castle, J, Domigo, 278 SCRA 762 ta Gat, Dante, PTBSCRA S72 to: Gat Baar, 2 SCRA 212 1 Gat, Vitoran y Calagno,214SCRA 115 ‘Cantona, Cris, 2905CRA 21 ‘. Cotantay, Hine 9 Tuyen, 278 SCRA 761 Cayeby, Bejamiay Bagh, 274SCRA387 fr Charen Antena y Enamarte, 278 SCRA 20 Cheng Blas, 279 SCRA 18 st Contes, Dany Oman 20 SORA 485 ‘Datay,Anres 277 SCRA 431 ‘Daal, Nari, 278 SCRA 308 Dalaba, Hermanda, 280 SCRA 696 te: Dans Dias, 278 SCRA BEB Daten, Rays, 272 SCRA 380 {De ula, Fliy Quinn, 280SCRA 141 ‘Deleon, Delray Minn, 257 SCRA 644 {De Vara Roberta y Seta, 278 SORA 87 Dat Raara Rody 289 SCRA 17 te: Dela Gra Lenaido P 216 SCRA 352 {e:Date Gren, ieky, 276 SCRA 31 te Des Gr, Rodis 19 SCRA 245 {Dela Gran lonmariey Nev, 277 SCRA 178 Dale Tee, Feere 272 SCRA 616 ‘Der, Homan, 271 SCRA 638 ‘Dele, Aland 268 SCRA 76 to: ian Mana! y Tapas, 271 SCRA S06 te: Dinglsa, Rare Mangin, 257 SCRA 26 (sD, Oven y Lan 282 SCRA 1 1997 CASES REPORTED 667 ex. Behar, Loy Po, 267 SCRA 652 alia Soran 271 SCRA 180, : Enanada, Rol 20 SCRA 72 .nviqes, roe y nal, 281 SCRA 103 {s-Brard,Marelne, 277 SCRA 649 1, Hrs Alen Boling, 281 SCRA 26 1 Haesedenltey Recent, 251 SCRA 498 Expo, CritpheryPaqinga, 271 SCRA 629 ‘Baars, Hove, 282 SCRA S24 Bar, Abney Barton, 274 SCRA 160 Brant oer, 252 SCRA.ST to: Far Nice 277 SCRA 18 e- abreReraldsy Servants, 278 SCRA 204 0s: Pernaden,Frzanday Mago, 275 SCRA 49 1, Far, Nora 272 SCRA GS 1, Fores Reo, 260 SCRA ‘Porch Permonete Jy, 281 SCRA 600 Fane, Jl y Tans, 269 SCRA 212 Poenelid, Rane, 281 CHA 52 Gatagran, ery 278 SCRA 76 t Gatren sere, 267 SCRA 682 Gar, Fernanda y Hele, 280 SCRA 42 Gari, Crary Pine, 371 SCRA 622 Gari, David y Quits 281 SCRA 465, Gara, Alar, 272 SORA BI? Gatward Nie Rihar, 267 SORA 705 1: Gapon, Epi, 269 CHA S67 Galen Soup, 7? SCRA 450, 3. Gare, Novy Vilnuer, 281 SCRA 36 1 Gamer, Eduard, 270 SCRA 482 Games, Mara 279 SCRA Sot Greflin, Bags, 279 SCRA SOL Gea Rarely Angas 27 SCRA 68 Haye, Astin 279 SCRA 86? Heese C, 2708CRA 4 2 Heb, Cones, 289 SCRA 472 ‘Hernan, ion L, 28450RA 367 i Dor ernno, 380 GORA 988 ‘oIgdane, Nove, 272 SCRA 118 Ignacio Rare V, 270 SCRA 45 (lla, Zaaidn 278 3CRA 47 mre Joany Batata 272 SCRA 95 Sogllapny, Marner, 280 CRA 768, ‘sami, Ernesto Santiago, 279 SCRA 290668 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED Januar Bene yRldan, 267 SCRA 6a Says Weve, 252 SCRA 16 ‘ Lacanes Cane, 270 SCRA 1 ‘ Lacerng, Narl y Cordero, 278 SCRA 581 Lage de, Fa 271 SCRA 1 {Latin renin 288 SCRA 201 {Lining Renato ySasigs, 276 SCRA 804 Lear: Penance y Bering, 20 SCRA 207 tt Maal, Ferman y Pardo, 278 SCRA 208 1 Maar, mde V, 278 SCRA 2 tt Mogaanes, Grego 276 SCRA 222 fe Mapallane,Disede, 26 SCRA 305 ‘Mami, Jury, 279 SCRA 23 ‘Mahony, Smeal y lve, 282 SCRA 80 tt Malahage, Anata y Maui, 27 SCRA 464 fr Malay, Medal, 20 SCRA 713 fh Mena Antonin 271 SERA S44 ‘ Mananala Dare Manalansong, 273 SCRA 612 2 Menunn, Nl, 277 SCRA 680. Sh Maton, Newry Alri 209 SCRA 61 ‘Mia Suny, 279 SCRA 70 Merona Dio 276 SCRA Sr Metnes nfo ela Han, 274SCRA 250 Se Mef, Gregorio Vilna 75 8CRA 127 GF MolgerMerade, aie y Tenge, 277 SCRA 609 Mereedo, gai y Pei, 276 SCRA 881 Mess, rete ype, 8 SCRA 407 ‘Montel Rand sla, 29 SCRA 756 ‘Montero, jr Vitrb 27 SCRA 188 Nala, Gey, 270 SCRA 22 ‘Naren, Hodes yGapein, 27 SCRA 608 "Narco olde ea 2605S0RA 865 ‘st Nerd, Bin, 270 SCRA 672 {0 Naren, 276 SCRA $00 tt Naval, Joma, 288 SCRA 60 ft Navarre, Glam 8, 270 SORA 983 Neer Stay Seria, 209024 9 ‘Ombre, Bsns Mapdareg 08 SCRA 93 1907 CASES REPORTED 669 Omaay, Ernst Caring, 267 SCRA 143 edna, Pee 279 SCA Ordo, Vilas, 277 SCRA 381 St Org, Bahay Gn, 276SORA 60 ‘Ore Mia, Lani 299 SORA 280 'o-Padeo, Seatagy Blea, 267 SORA 64 ‘Pagal Noll Leal 272 SCRA 463 ‘n Paprr, Pdr Ting, 207 SCRA 12 1, Palo, Jeu yGubaton, 279 SCRA 852 ‘8 Palma, Dor, 218SCRA 114 ‘Se Pane, Bomar 278 SCRA 357 fo Pantelson, Suse 214 SORA 129 Se Padi dey Aristo, 262 SORA 236 .Patawaran, Red 274 SCRA 190 te: Peers, Jin y Boeanda, 276 SCRA B64 Pela, Parfro M267 SCRA 58 (Poe rnue y Rafe, 270 SCRA 526 br. Pandieng, Dantay Cal, 268 SCRA 555, Quien, Daary, 279 SCRA 8 Quien, Api, 228 SCRA 816 Qua eddy 380 SCA 35, br Qutoriane, garda y Brine, 208 SCRA 978 Haber Heard 0,278 SCRA a2 o:Rabatl, Ela, 272 SCRA 107 1 Raga, ily Be Roe 277 SCRA 108 s:egn,Werlo, 282 SCRA 9) aires Brae y Antoni, 25 SCRA 33 abated eat, 279 SORA 79 ese Soy Magpetay, 292 SCRA 274 ees, Hane, 82 SCRA 108 Roma, Armando, 272 SCRA 818 Renal edad 9 Son, 272 SCRA 242 Sagar, Antoni 87 SCRA 67 ‘Saucy Ral 277 SCRA 183 7 $2 Satan, Hol Z, 294 SCRA 208 9 Sates, ey vin 277 SCRA S78 Salar, Deming y Serena, 277 SCRA 67 ‘, Slaear Jacinta, 212SCRA 481 1, Slee, Saturna y Panes 286 SCRA 607 ‘Slam, Ro damian, 290 SCRA 842670 SUPREME COURT REPORTS ANNOTATED on. Stvador, Be, 279 SCRA 164 (t Slvame, Alri, 270 SCRA 766 Salvator, Davy Baul, 276 SCRA SS San Jean, Hada 2TOSCRA 659 Sencha, Hite 371 SORA 82 tr: Sendigaayen, 25 SCRA 5 Sel Sr, elpe, 275 8CRA 532 en Sats, ranean yBalagas, 270 SCRA 65D State, Panos ySatamaria 278 SCRA 520 ral, Gry 268 SRA 471 Str, eben, 268 SCRA 136 Setarn, Eh y imeem, 267 SCRA 278 Serr, de Maria 270 SCRA BS te Sicuna, Green, 271 SORA 169 Sine. Dano Senay, 275 SCRA 957 Slo, lp, 27 SCRA 12? be: Sater, dol 281 SCHA 138 ‘Bl Jo 272 SCRA 92 1 Seriany ity Segue, 272 SCRA 760 ‘= Srl, acy Vln, 278 SCRA 960 ‘Sut, Again 276 SCRA 191 ‘ Soarer Ferdinag, 267 SCRA 119 Samii Reyanan,271 SORA 26 {Take Maro 270 SCRA 32 ‘Tab. Calo, 268 SCRA 115. bt Tabeleoms, dose yOlevee, 277 SCRA 59 ‘Teal, vny pan, 271 SCRA 288 Tagolint, Rasen 383 SCRA 291, ‘ Tlingig, Aro 381 SCRA 9 fe Tain emmy 9Vilemor 278 SCRA 17 Pen Teng Mang 271 SORA 125 Tang Wat Ln, 576 SCRA2¢ Tada, Vir, 208 SORA 3¢ Tato, Eduard, 232 SCRA 300 Teer, Wired , 200 SCRA 596 Tio, Vitor y Cann 261 SORA 577 Tobi, Rind, 287 SCRA 229 1: Topnroen, Leroe 269 SCRA 602 ‘rarer Roche) 216 SCRA30) 1 Ratner Baran, 282 SCRA 424 0 Unaro Haruo 20 SCRA 756,272 SCRA 921 salle, ang, 267 SCRA 208 ‘m Vaeqeo, Domensane, 261 SORA 125 ‘ Vasguer, Her, 280 SCRA 160, ‘Philppiae Amunement sed Caning Corpeation 1907 CASES REPORTED on. Vergara, Reero F270 SCRA 624 fr Vilsnve, Edgar 270 SCRA 458 1 Vlnere, Haney, 266 SCRA S56 te Vilseve Over 278 SORA 80 o-Vilre, Belinda y Foran, 209 SORA 620 il, hired y Ngan 277 SCRA 902 iia, nto, 286 SCRA 226 vets Habert ss, 276508209 tr Ypareir, Crapo, 208 SCRA 95 Zahara, Vieont, 214 SCRA 627 ‘amore, Bona, 278 SOBA 80 ‘amiga, 78 SORA 182 ‘oops Indu and Corser Crpratin 2. Court of Ap als, 251 SCRA 206 epi, Maauel Tv ual, ing A, 267 SCRA 40 ‘Pepin, Prfrio People ofthe Pippinas 287 SCRA 38 Pepa ola Distt af the Pippen, Ine, National Labor Relations Commie, 272 CHA 267 oral, Adsfo Mv. Sandganbayan (Fst Division) 268 SCRA ore, nees yRicafrt—Poope ofthe Phlppinas s, 270 SCRA, ‘Pera Compania de Seguros, In. s, Sagulaboa, Benedict G, 271 Pippen, le — Bilao, ese 5, 290SCRA S16 ir Aarons Board, 210 SCRA B38 Gout Appi 278 SCRA 36 1 Nason! Later Halatnn Comma, 276 SCRA 91; 279 SRA 46,68, 252 SRA so ‘Papp Aaian General Insane Oompany, In. 8. Cort of "Appi 273 SORA 32 cont of Ap ele 2TSSORA «35 _Pappioeank of Comnere vs, Court of Appel, 269 SCRA 695 ‘Flipyie Ben of Communtatinn ew: Cour of Appel, 278 SCRA, ‘Philippine Federation of Fihfara Producer, Ine. ve. Secrtary of “he Depurtnns of Agrarian Rar, 274 SCRA 30 ‘Philppee Interisland Shippag Asocaton ofthe Philyace ws. "Gor Appeals, 266 SCRA 430, ‘hippie Long Distance Telepbaoe Campany es. National Labor