Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

Schwerpunkt Perspektiven auf den Luxusmarkt

Selling luxury watches


in Asia: the changing
position of independent
distributors
Asia has increasingly become the place to sell luxury goods as a result of
economic growth. Swiss luxury watch groups have all turned to new Asian
markets since the late 1990s, with the help of key intermediaries such as local
distributors and retailers. However, facing the verticalization strategies of
large groups to improve the control and even to develop in-house retail
management, independent distributors have needed to change their business
models and offer new kinds of services to access customers. This article gives
two examples of local independent distributors’ new strategies to cope with
verticalization by large groups. While the first company, The Hour Glass,
turned to mono- and multi-brand stores for independent luxury brands in
South East Asia, the second one, Hengdeli, specialized in retail by running
in-house shops for the market expansion in China of one of its main partners,
Swatch Group.

Pierre-Yves Donzé, Thierry Theurillat

50 Marketing Review St. Gallen 5 | 2016

050-057_MRSG_SPT_Donze_Theurillat_cw_mw.indd 50 20.10.16 14:55


Schwerpunkt Perspektiven auf den Luxusmarkt

D
istribution plays a key role in lack of studies about the distribution of Pierre-Yves Donzé
the luxury business and must luxury goods has been highlighted re- Associate professor,
be understood within the cently (Coe and Bok 2014). Osaka University
broader context of the strategy imple- Based on a case study of two inde- donze@econ.osaka-u.ac.jp

mented by luxury companies since the pendent retailers in this industry in


late 1990s (Donzé & Fujioka, forthco- East Asia, this article aims to demons-
Thierry Theurillat
ming). The transformation of the orga- trate the strategies they followed to Postdoc researcher of
nizational structure experienced by cope with verticalization by large the Swiss National Science
this industry, characterized by the for- watch companies and to keep their Foundation, Université
mation of groups and conglomerates competitive advantage. It contributes Paris-Est Marne-la-Vallée
such as LVMH (1987) and Richemont to the understanding of the dynamics thierry.theurillat@unine.ch
(1988), led these large companies to of the distribution of luxury goods
take control of their distribution and since the 1990s, in relation to two to-
retail networks (Bonin 2012, Moore & pics of this special issue. We show that
Birtwistle 2004, Moore, Doherty & one retailer (The Hour Glass) re-positi-
Doyle 2010). For example, the number oned and specialized in offering new
of shops owned by LVMH went from services to independent Swiss watch
1,286 in 2000 to 3,708 in 2014 (LVMH companies who had difficulties acces-
2000–2014). The expansion of the retail sing Asian markets due to verticaliza-
network is based both on the opening tion by large luxury groups. The se-
of new outlets and the takeover of exis- cond company’s (Hengdeli) strategy
ting shops. The objective of this strate- relied on running in-house shops for
gy was not only to internalize profits the market expansion in China of one
(Okonkwo 2007), but also to control of its main partners, Swatch Group.
brand identity. Shopping spaces, in par- This research is a qualitative case
ticular mono-brand stores, contribute study based on interviews carried out
greatly to building brands, such that in 2014-2015 with representatives of
their direct control has become a major Swiss watch companies and managers
issue in this industry. This feature is of independent distributing firms in
particularly important in emerging Hong Kong, Singapore and Taiwan.
countries, where boutiques are impor- Annual reports of these companies pro-
tant tools to educate customers about vided supplementary information.
luxury goods in general and specific The paper comprises three sec-
brands in particular (Zhan & He 2012). tions. At first, we present briefly the
Yet the verticalization of distributi- issue of verticalization of distribution
on by luxury big business has challen- in the watch industry. Then, the fol-
ged the position of independent distribu- lowing sections discuss the new strate-
tors and retailers. Literature in manage- gies adopted by the two companies
ment on the process of internationaliza- (The Hour Glass and Hengdeli).
tion in retail focused essentially on
large Western distributors (e.g. Wal- 1. The shift to luxury and the
Mart, Carrefour) and the way they adap- new challenge of distribution
ted or not to local markets (Dupuis et al. in the watch industry
2006; Durand and Wrigley, 2009; Daw-
son and Mukoyama 2014). However, for Three features characterize the evolu-
some products such as luxury goods, we tion of the Swiss watch industry since
can still observe the existence of nu- 1990. First, there is the shift towards
merous small independent retailers. The luxury. Foreign trade statistics express

Marketing Review St. Gallen 5 | 2016 51

050-057_MRSG_SPT_Donze_Theurillat_cw_mw.indd 51 20.10.16 14:55


Schwerpunkt Perspektiven auf den Luxusmarkt

well this phenomenon. While the volu- Swiss companies, as did LVMH (1999) ly declined, but was still the no. 4 outlet
me of watches exported by Switzerland and Kering (1999). Today, there is a in 2014 (6%). As for China, which had
declined from 43.7 million in 1995 to high concentration in the global watch been constantly below 1% until 2002, it
31.9 million in 2010, at the same time industry, and companies established in emerged in the mid-2000s, and peaked
their value increased from 6.8 billion Switzerland dominate. In 2014, the at 8.5% in 2011 (6.3% in 2014). Alto-
CHF to 15.3 billion CHF (Federation of three largest companies (Swatch, Ri- gether, Hong Kong, Japan and China
the Swiss Watch Industry 2016). Many chemont and Rolex) controlled nearly had a cumulative market share of 19.6%
authors have tackled this transformati- half of world markets (47.5%). Of the in 1980, 26.1% in 1990, 23.3% in 2000,
on, emphasizing that the new competi- ten largest companies, accounting for 31.4% in 2010 and 30.8% in 2014.
tiveness of the Swiss watch industry 72.6% of market share, all except Seiko The vertical integration of whole-
relied on marketing strategy, called by sale and retail was the consequence of
some authors „non-technological inno-
Independent luxury this threefold transformation. It has
vation“ (Jeannerat and Crevoisier progressed since the late 1990s. The
2011), which made it possible to greatly watch distributors idea is to improve the quality of distri-
increase the value-added of the pro- in Asia face a process bution rather than to increase the num-
ber of sales outlets. Accordingly, the
ducts (Kebir and Crevoisier 2008, Raf-
faelli 2013, Donzé 2014).
of verticalization Omega distribution network was re-
Second, this sector was marked by by large Swiss luxury structured in 2005-06 in the German,
a deep transformation of industrial or-
groups and need British and Japanese markets, where
ganization. The number of watch com- the number of sales outlets was redu-
panies amounted to 572 in 1990 and to offer new services. ced by 20 to 25 per cent. At the same
was averaged 589 for the years 2000- time, groups started to create new sales
2013. Besides, the average number of subsidiaries around the world. Swatch
workers per company increased at the and Casio base their production subsi- had 23 such units in 1998, but their
same time (59.3 in 1990, 64.9 in 2000 diaries in Switzerland (Vontobel 2015). number had virtually tripled to 65 by
and 100.2 in 2014) (Convention patro- Third, this transformation went to- 2009 (Donzé 2014). Among them, ma-
nale 2014). Likewise, most of these gether with the emergence and growth ny were opened in emerging countries
companies were gathered into large of new markets, particularly in Asia after 2000, for example in India (2001),
holding companies and groups, the (Donze & Fujioka 2015). Trade statis- Thailand (2002), Taiwan (2004) and
most famous being Swatch Group tics show the key position occupied by the United Arab Emirates (2006).
(founded in 1983) and Compagnie fi- Hong Kong, with an average share of In addition, a reference should be
nancière Richemont (1988), while 16.4% of Swiss watch exports in 1990- made to the engagement in retailing.
French luxury big business entered 2014. Japan was a key market during Since 2000, SG, Richemont and inde-
watchmaking through the merger of the years 1990–2003 (9%), then slight- pendent companies like Rolex and Pa-
tek Philippe developed their own net-
work of flagship stores. The number of
Richemont’s mono-brand stores went
from 320 in 1995 to 1,370 in 2009. In
Management Summary 2009, the company directly held 797
stores (58.2% of the total), the remai-
Independent luxury watch distributors in Asia face a process of verticali-
ning 573 being managed by local part-
zation by large Swiss luxury groups and need to offer new services. This
article focuses on two major independent retailers (The Hour Glass, ners. The number of Richemont’s di-
based in Singapore, and Hengdeli, based in Hong Kong). While the first rectly owned stores grew to 1,056
Foto: Unternehmen

company, The Hour Glass, turned to mono- and multi-brand stores for stores in 2014. This will to control re-
independent luxury brands in South East Asia, the second one, tail also led SG to take interests in re-
Hengdeli, specialized in retail by running in-house shops for the market tail firms, in particular in Thailand
expansion in China of one of its main partners, Swatch Group. (2002), in the United Arab Emirates
(2008) and in Saudi Arabia (2010).

52 Marketing Review St. Gallen 5 | 2016

050-057_MRSG_SPT_Donze_Theurillat_cw_mw.indd 52 20.10.16 14:55


Schwerpunkt Perspektiven auf den Luxusmarkt

MALMAISON
by The Hour
2. The re-focus on retail for tion presents the case of The Hour shops distributed a wide range of Swiss Glass watch
high-end independent watch Glass, a major independent watch dis- luxury brands through a retail network boutique at
companies (The Hour Glass) tributor based in Singapore and active of multi-brand stores. In 1990, THG Knightsbridge
in all South-East Asia. opened a wholesale division, to distri- in Singapore.
The first model observed in East Asia The Hour Glass (THG) is a family bute luxury watches throughout South-
is the re-focus of independent distribu- business established in 1979 in Singa- East Asia. It had, for example, the licen-
tors towards the needs of specific cus- pore by Henry Tay and Jannie Chan. It se for Christian Dior and Burberry wat-
tomers: Swiss luxury watch artisans experienced its evolution until today in ches during the 1990s. Moreover, THG
and independent companies. They did three major phases. bought two small Swiss watch compa-
not verticalize distribution, for strate- First, the phase of early develop- nies, Daniel Roth SA (1994) and Gérald
gic reasons or lack of capital, and ac- ment was characterized by a positioning Genta SA (1996), the objective being to
cessing markets in Asia became a ma- in a niche market and the attempt to take control of their retail network out-
jor challenge for them, due to the grow through the expansion of markets side of Asia (Europe, Middle East, Rus-
domination of large groups over retail and diversification of activities. THG sia, and the US). Besides this expansion
networks. Hence, several independent started with a single multi-brand store of retail network, THG diversified their
distributors, like Cortina in Singapore in Singapore (1979). It opened new activities to include Italian restaurants
and South-East Asia, or Dickson in stores in the following years, essentially in Singapore (1989; closed in 1995), sa-
Taiwan, offer since the late 1990s new in Singapore during the 1980s, and then les of perfume in the US (1990), and of
services (rent of shopping spaces, ma- elsewhere in South-East Asia (e.g. Indo- jewelry in Asia (1990). The objective
nagement of mono-brand boutique, and nesia in 1991, Thailand in 1996) and was to become a diversified company in
access to retailers) to such watch com- Australia during the following decade. luxury business.
panies, and make it possible for them to In 1994, it owned a total of 20 stores, of Second, the years 1997–2003 were
be present in Asian markets. This sec- which 11 were in Singapore. These a period of deep mutation. THG was

Marketing Review St. Gallen 5 | 2016 53

050-057_MRSG_SPT_Donze_Theurillat_cw_mw.indd 53 20.10.16 14:55


Schwerpunkt Perspektiven auf den Luxusmarkt

affected by the Asian financial crisis. Patek Philippe, Rolex and Ulysse Nar- works for groups, but such relations are
Gross sales dropped from 434 million din. For these firms, the stronger con- instable. For example, in 2011, THG
S$ in 1996 to 256 million in 2003, trol of distribution by luxury groups lost its contract for four Montblanc bou-
while operating profits amounted only makes it more difficult to access mar- tiques because Richemont had decided
to an average of 2.7% in 1997–2003. kets, and THG provides them a service to control directly this brand’s retail.
These difficulties led THG to sell the to benefit from mono-brand stores, The second service is the access to a
American wholesale subsidiary as well even if they do not own them. THG also new kind of multi-brand store which
as the two Swiss companies Daniel
Roth and Gérald Genta to Bulgari in
1999. Moreover, it disinvested from the
perfume business (2001) and closed Lessons Learned
down unprofitable watch stores. In
• Strengthening the co-development of marketing and real estate
2000, THG had only 13 stores left.
strategies between luxury watch distributors and local distributors
Third, since 2003, THG re-focused and retailers.
on Asia and retail, rather than wholesa-
le. It offers two kinds of services to • For Asian distributors and retailers: training the local staff of retailers
to Swiss watch tradition.
Swiss watch companies. The first is the
management of mono-brand stores, es- • For Swiss watch companies: internalizing knowledge about urban
pecially for companies outside of the development in East Asia.
large groups, like Chopard, Parmigiani,

Herausforderung suchen
Wer verkaufen will, muss kommunizieren.
Lassen Sie uns reden und Ihren Vertrieb pushen.

www.commnet-media.de

Communication Network Media • Ridlerstraße 35 a • 80339 München • Tel.: 0 89/72 95 99 15

050-057_MRSG_SPT_Donze_Theurillat_cw_mw.indd 54 20.10.16 14:55


Schwerpunkt Perspektiven auf den Luxusmarkt

offers a particular atmosphere to em- Fig. 1: Turnover and operating profit of The Hour Glass company
phasize the tradition and uniqueness of
Swiss mechanical watches (e.g. classic 1985–2014 Turnover, 1000 S$ (left) Operating profit, % (right)
design of the boutique, display of old
tools and instruments to make watches). 800 000 14
The thematic salons L’Atelier and Mal- 700 000 12
maison, opened in Singapore after
10
2010, notably provide shopping spaces 600 000
for high-end products of independent 8
500 000
craftsmen (like MB&F and Uhrwerk), 6
together with the top end brands of lu- 400 000
4
xury groups (like Breguet and Hublot).
300 000
Hence, THG presents itself on its web- 2
site as a „cultural retail enterprise“ 200 000
0
( ht t p://w w w.t hehou rg la ss.com / ).
100 000 –2
THG’s new shops display watches in an
environment that emphasizes Swiss tra- 0 –4
ditional watchmaking. For example,
19 5
86

19 7
19 8
19 9
90

19 1
92

19 3
94

19 5
96

19 7
98
20 9
00

20 1
02
20 3
04
20 5
06
20 7
08

20 9
10

20 1 1
20 2
20 3
14
0
9

0
8

9
9

1
1
8

0
9
8

20
19

20
19
19
19

20
20
19

19
19

20

20
watchmaker artisan’s workshops were
re-created, showing the Swiss han- Source: The Hour Glass, Annual report, 1985–2014

communication
network
media
Marketing & Vertrieb

E-Mail: info@commnet-media.de

050-057_MRSG_SPT_Donze_Theurillat_cw_mw.indd 55 20.10.16 14:55


Schwerpunkt Perspektiven auf den Luxusmarkt

Fig. 2: Gross sales of Hengdeli Holdings, in million RMB,


and shares of wholesale and retail as a % Main Propositions

2004–2014 Gross sales (left) Retail, as a % (right) Wholesale, as a % (right) • Cultural retail enterprise
(The Hour Glasse): THG’s
16 000 90 new shops display watches
in an environment that
14 000 80
emphasizes Swiss traditional
12 000
70 watchmaking (e.g. re-creati-
on of watchmaker artisan’s
60
10 000 workshops), showing the
50 Swiss handicraft authentici-
8 000
40 ty to customers.
6 000
30 • Real estate business
4 000 (Hengdeli): Providing
20
access to shopping spaces
2 000 10 through negotiations with
0 0 the developers of luxury
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
shopping malls, particularly
in China.
Source: Hengdeli Holdings, Annual report, 2004–2014.

dicraft authenticity to customers. This large groups included, lack the know- This partnership is very important
new strategy is very profitable. THG ledge and the power necessary to nego- in the twofold context of the fast
entered a new phase of growth in 2004. tiate with local landlords and develo- growth of the Chinese market and
Growth sales went from 320 million S$ pers, so it is necessary to work with Swatch’s will to control retailing. Figu-
that year to 683 million in 2014, while intermediaries. Hengdeli is precisely re 2 shows that Hengdeli’s gross sales
operating profits skyrocketed from such a firm, one of the major interme- increased from 1.5 billion RMB in
1.9% in 2004 to 9.9% in 2014. diaries between European luxury com- 2004 to 14.8 billion RMB in 2014 and
panies and Chinese customers. that such a development was based es-
3. The investment in retailing Hengdeli is a former State-owned sentially on retailing, whereas Hengde-
in China (Hengdeli) company, purchased in 1997 by the li had specialized in wholesale until
Zhang family, active in the trade of wat- then. The number of stores managed by
A second model of the new services ches in Hong Kong since the 1980s. It Hengdeli went from 65 in 2005 (all in
offered by independent retailers to dominates watch distribution retail busi- mainland China) to 513 in 2014 (428 in
Swiss luxury watch companies is em- ness in China, and after 2000 became the China). Hence, the share of retailing in
bodied by the Hong Kong based enter- local partner of Swatch Group, LVMH gross sales grew from 34.9% in 2004 to
prise Xinyu Hengdeli Holdings. It con- and Richemont to enter the Chinese mar- 71.9% in 2014. To set up these shops,
sists in providing access to shopping ket. Swatch and LVMH took a stake in Hengdeli partnered with local Chinese
spaces through negotiations with the Hengdeli, respectively 20.6% and 6.4% developers (tier 3 and 4 cities) and lar-
developers of luxury shopping malls. of capital in 2013 (Xinyu Hengdeli ge developers from Hong Kong and
This pattern can be observed particu- 2013), but Swatch is the only one to have China (tier 1 and 2 cities), choosing the
larly in Mainland China, where the a member on the board of directors and developer to partner with for a particu-
expansion of sales of luxury goods re- to have founded joint ventures with this lar shop on a case-by-case basis.
lies on a new network of shopping out- Chinese partner. Both companies co- In 2007, Swatch and Hengdeli foun-
lets built within the context of urban founded two major companies for the ded an equally-owned subsidiary to take
development (Wang et al., 2006; Wang, exclusive distribution of Omega and Ra- charge of retail business in China. On
2009). Swiss luxury watch companies, do watches (2003) (Donzé 2014). this occasion, Zhang Yu Ping, chairman

56 Marketing Review St. Gallen 5 | 2016

050-057_MRSG_SPT_Donze_Theurillat_cw_mw.indd 56 20.10.16 14:55


Schwerpunkt Perspektiven auf den Luxusmarkt

of Hengdeli Holdings, argued that „this national groups need to have local part- lopers in South East Asia and China is
agreement establishes a closer bond bet- ners - keeping in mind that they are still under-researched. In this case, so-
ween Xinyu Hengdeli and the Swatch often institutionally forced to do so – to me Hong Kong developers shifted to
Group, as the two parties fully utilize get knowledge and skills relevant to high-end shopping malls, and Swiss
their resources to strengthen their rela- local markets. Then they would tend to luxury brands are a key part of the
tionship in the Chinese retail market“. improve the control of the supply chain commercial mix, bringing the best ren-
(Xinyu Hengdeli 2007). Yet, such a stra- by getting rid of some intermediaries, tal income. This positioning is part of a
tegy requires an involvement in real not only to increase profits but also to new phase of commercial expansion
estate business, to secure stores in new better control the image of the brand. In since mid-2000, mainly in China, whe-
shopping malls. Consequently, in 2010, the case of Swiss luxury brands, the re the shopping environment and de-
Swatch took a 50% stake in Beijing Xin way large groups negotiate directly sign for luxury goods plays a more sig-
Yu Heng Rui Watch & Clock Co., a sub- with some of high-end shopping deve- nificant and credible role.
sidiary of Hengdeli specialized in real
estate in China (Xinyu Hengdeli 2013).
Literature
Conclusion
Bonin, H. (2012), Reassessment of the Business History Kebir, L. and Crevoisier, O. (2008), Cultural resources and
of the French Luxury Sector. The Emergence of a New regional development: The case of the cultural legacy of
This article highlights the change of Business Model and a Renewed Corporate Image watchmaking, European Planning Studies, 16, 9, pp. 1189–1205.
business models since the mid-2000s of (from the 1970s), In: Bonin, H., Kozminski, A. K., & Manera,
C. (Eds.), European Business and Brand Building, Moore, C. M., and Birtwistle, G. (2004), The Burberry
two independent distributors that used PIE Peter Lang, Brussels, pp. 113–135. business model: creating an international luxury fashion
to be traditional key intermediaries bet- brand, International Journal of Retail & Distribution
Convention patronale (2014), Recensement 2013, Management, 32, 8, pp. 412–422.
ween Swiss watchmakers and local Convention patronale, La Chaux-de-Fonds.
markets in South East Asia and China. Moore, C. M., Doherty, A.M. and Doyle, S. A. (2010),
Dawson J. and Mukoyama M. (2014), Global Strategies in Flagship stores as a market entry method: the perspective
Facing a process of verticalization by Retailing: Asian and European Experiences, Routledge. of luxury fashion retailing, European Journal of Marketing,
large Swiss luxury groups, both compa- 44, 1/2, pp. 139–161.
Donzé, P.-Y. (2014), A Business History of the Swatch
nies needed to offer new services. Group: The Rebirth of Swiss Watchmaking and the Okonkwo, U. (2007), Luxury fashion branding: trends,
The Hour Group, which focuses on Globalization of the Luxury Industry, Palgrave Macmillan, tactics, techniques, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke.
various markets in South East Asia, Basingstoke.
LVMH (2000-2014), Annual report.
turned towards independent luxury Donzé, P.-Y. and Fujioka, R. (2015), European Luxury
Big Business and Asian Emerging Markets, 1960–2010, Raffaelli, R. (2013), Mechanisms of Technology
watchmakers to provide them some Re-Emergence and Identity Change in a Mature Field:
Business History, 57, 6, pp. 822–840.
multi- and mono-brands shops based Swiss Watchmaking, 1970–2008, Harvard Business
Donzé, P.-Y. and Fujioka, R. (forthcoming), Luxury School Working Paper, No. 14-048.
on a design and atmosphere that em-
Business, In: Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Business
phasizes the tradition and authenticity and Management (http://business.oxfordre.com/), Vontobel (2015), Vontobel Luxury Goods Shop –
accessed: 10.3.2016. Watch Industry, Vontobel Equity Research, Zurich.
of Swiss mechanical watches. Hengde-
li, whose main market is China, chan- Dupuis, M., Choi, S.-C. and Roy L. (2006), Carrefour: Wang, S. (2009), Foreign retailers in post-WTO China:
being aware of the domestic market!, in Dawson, stories of success and setbacks, Asia Pacific Business
ged its business model from wholesale Review, 15, 1, pp. 59–77.
J. et al. (eds.), Strategic Issues in International Retailing,
to retail. Thanks to a close partnership
Routledge, London, pp. 71–90. Wang, S., Zhang, Y., Wang, Y. (2006), Opportunities and
first with Swatch Group and second Challenges of Shopping Center Development in China:
Durant C. and Wrigley, N. (2009), Institutional and
with LVMH, Hengdeli could increase Economic Determinants of Transnational Retailer a Case Study of Shanghai, Journal of Shopping Center
its number of in-house shops all over Expansion and Performance: A Comparative Analysis of Research, 13, 1, pp. 19–55.
China since 2007, based on negotia- Wal-Mart and Carrefour, Environment and Planning A, Xinyu Hengdeli (2007), Memorandum of Under-
41(7), pp. 1534–1555 standing between Xinyu Hengdeli and Swatch Group
tions with Chinese as well as Hong
Federation of the Swiss Watch Industry (2016), Watch (http://www.hmdatalink.com/PDF/C01700/e03389
Kong developers. (60).pdf), accessed: 10.3.2016.
Industry Statistics (http://www.fhs.ch/eng/statistics.
The control of outlets as part of the html), accessed: 8.3.2016. Xinyu Hengdeli (2013), Annual report.
verticalization strategy by some groups
Jeannerat, H. and Crevoisier, O. (2011), Non-technological Zhan, L., and Y. He (2012), Understanding luxury
goes hand in hand with the evolution innovation and multi-local territorial knowledge dynamics consumption in China: Consumer perceptions of best
process in accessing new markets and in the Swiss watch industry, International Journal of known brands, Journal of Business Research, 65, 10,
countries. In the original phase, inter- Innovation and Regional Development, 3, 1, pp. 26–44. pp. 1452–1460.

Marketing Review St. Gallen 5 | 2016 57

050-057_MRSG_SPT_Donze_Theurillat_cw_mw.indd 57 20.10.16 14:55

You might also like