Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Test Bank For Financial Statement Analysis and Valuation 2nd Edition Easton
Test Bank For Financial Statement Analysis and Valuation 2nd Edition Easton
Test Bank For Financial Statement Analysis and Valuation 2nd Edition Easton
Multiple Choice
Topic: Revenue recognition
LO: 1
1. Which of the following items do not create risk related to revenue recognition?
a. Bonuses tied to sales goals
b. Long-term construction contracts
c. Multiple element sales contracts
d. Consignment goods
e. All of the above
Answer: e
Rationale: Each of these types of revenue or business conditions creates risk associated with
revenue recognition. Each requires good internal controls to prevent and detect inappropriate
revenue recognition, as well as extra management vigilance and auditor care.
Answer: b
Rationale: When contracts are over-budget, managers should estimate the new, revised, total
engagement cost. If this results in a loss on the engagement, that loss should be recognized
immediately rather than over the remaining term of the engagement.
Tri-State uses the percentage of completion method to recognize revenue. Which of the following
represent the revenue recognized in 2010, 2011, and 2012?
a. $70 million, $70 million, $70 million
b. $15 million, $90 million, $45 million
c. $6 million, $36 million, $18 million
d. $21 million, $126 million, $ 63 million
e. None of the above
Answer: d
Rationale:
($ in millions) Year 1 Year 2 Year 3
Construction costs incurred $15 $90 $45
Percentage to total costs $15 / $150 = 10% $90 / $150 = 60% $45 / $150 = 30%
Revenue recognized 10% × $210 = $21 60% ×210 = $126 30% × 210= $63
Answer: a.
Rationale: According to the percentage-of-completion method Mainline Engineering Company
should recognize the revenues as shown in the table below:
Total
Year contract Percentage completed Revenue Recognized
40% × $40 million =
2010 $40 million $12 million/$30 million = 40% $16 million
Answer: b
Rationale: Sam’s should record membership fees evenly over the year even if the fee is
nonrefundable because Sam’s has an obligation to stay open for business for a year to honor the
customer’s membership.
Answer: b
Tickets Now should record $7 revenue each time it sells a ticket. Of that $2 will be received in
cash and $5 will be recorded as receivable from the Riverdance producers.
Answer: e
Rationale: Yahoo included in product development expense certain non-cash expenses such as
depreciation on related assets, thus a is not correct. Yahoo recorded deferred tax expense on the
product development expense, thus net income was affected on an after-tax basis and b is
therefore not correct. Under US GAAP firms may not capitalize R&D costs, thus c is not correct.
All R&D expenses must be included in the income statement in the period, thus d is wrong.
Answer: b
Rationale: R&D expenses exclude any costs related to sales.
Answer: d
Rationale: To make comparisons, we need to common size the R&D expenditures of both firms
by scaling by total revenues and calculate growth rates.
Life Technologies Corporation Affymetrix Inc
2008 2007 2006 2008 2007 2006
Common
sized R&D 8.8% 9.0% 9.1% 20.6% 19.6% 24.3%
R&D growth 23.03% 11.01% 14.14% -15.71%
Affymetrix spends proportionately more on R&D than Life Technologies, thus a is not true. Life
Technologies has spent less on R&D over the three year period, thus b is not true. Affymetrix
grew R&D by 14% in 2008 compared to Life Technologies’ growth of 23%, thus c is not true.
Affymetrix decreased R&D from 24.2% in 2006 to 20.6% in 2008, thus d is true.
Answer: b
Rationale: Project-directed or highly-specific research buildings and equipment with no alternate
uses must be expensed as incurred.
December December
31, 2007 31, 2008
Total assets $12,229,741 $13,689,848
Revenues $6,969,274 $7,208,502
Product development expense $1,084,238 $1,221,787
Net income $660,000 $424,298
Answer: d
Rationale: To common-size income statement items, we divide by current period sales.
Common-sized product development expense for 2008 is therefore $1,221,787/ $7,208,502 =
16.949%.
Answer: c.
Rationale: The total restructuring charge accrued was $4.2 million because asset write-downs are
not accrued. That is there is no credit to a liability account for write-downs, the assets are credited
(reduced). Thus, the company must have paid $4,200,000 - $900,000 = $3,300,000 in cash
during fiscal 2009.
Answer: b
Rationale: Of the $785 million total restructuring charge, only the exit costs and severance costs
must eventually be settled in cash. The asset write downs are not accrued – they reduce the
assets on the balance sheet. The company accrued $128 million + $321 million = $449 million as
a liability. Thus, if the company paid $2 million cash, the remaining accrual is $447 million at year
end.
Answer: c
Rationale: The total restructuring charge accrued was $78,514 of which $9,881 was still unpaid
(a liability) at the end of the year. The difference of $68,633 must have been paid in cash during
the year. The cash flow effect is $68,633.
Answer: a.
Rationale: Microsoft reported income before income tax expense of $23,817 million. This is
calculated as Income tax expense / Effective tax rate = $6,133 million / 0.2575 = $23,817 million.
Answer: a
Rationale: Snap-On reported taxes on the income statement of $117.7 million. This is calculated
as Income before tax × Effective tax rate = $357.8 × 0.329 = $117.7
Answer: d
Rationale: Changes in valuation allowance affect net income in the opposite direction, dollar for
dollar. Dow Chemical increased the allowance by $164 million ($487 million - $323 million). The
effect was to reduce Dow’s net income by $164 million in 2008.
Answer: b.
Rationale: Changes in the deferred tax asset account, inversely affects tax expense. Changes in
the deferred tax liability account, directly affects tax expense. Therefore Dow’s increase in
deferred tax assets and decrease in deferred tax liabilities, both decrease tax expense for the
year by $1,931 million ( $1,205 million + $726 million = $ 1,931 million decrease in tax expense).
Answer: c
Rationale: The tax expense of $93 million will reduce net income by that amount and thus,
retained earnings on the balance sheet will be $93 million lower. The company pays $103 million
tax in cash, which reduces assets (cash). The difference of $10 million is recorded as an increase
in deferred tax asset.
a. $124,299 thousand
b. $67,899 thousand
c. $56,400 thousand
d. $27,064 thousand
e. None of the above
Answer: b.
Rationale: The current tax provision of $67,899 is payable in 2008.
During fiscal 2009, the U.S. dollar strengthened relative to the other principal currencies in which
we transact business with the exception of the Japanese Yen.
What effect did these currency fluctuations have on Dell’s 2009 consolidated income statement?
a. Net profit of the Japanese subsidiary will be higher
b. Net profit of the Japanese subsidiary will be lower
c. Net assets of the subsidiaries that report in the other principal currencies will be higher
d. Net assets of the subsidiaries that report in the other principal currencies will be lower
e. Both a and d
Answer: a
Because the US dollar weakened during the year, each Yen will translate to more dollars. Thus,
revenues, expenses, and net profit of the Japanese subsidiary will be higher than they would
have been absent the foreign currency fluctuations. With respect to the other principal currencies,
given that the US dollar strengthened during the year, the profits in these countries will translate
to fewer dollars. Thus, revenues, expenses, and net profits of these subsidiaries will be lower
than they would have been absent the foreign currency fluctuations. However, d is not a correct
answer because the question asked about the income statement, not the balance sheet. This
render answer e incorrect too.
Answer: c.
Rationale: Basic EPS = $5,521 / 5,133 = $1.07559 = $1.08
Diluted EPS = $5,521 / 5,229 = $1.05584 = $1.06
Stock options are only included in the computation of EPS if they are, in fact, dilutive. If they are
anti-dilutive, they are excluded from the computation.
Answer: a
The company included about 295,808 thousand shares for the diluted EPS calculation. This is
computed as: $609,365 thousand / $2.06 = 295,808 thousand. Thus, the company included 2,329
thousand dilutive shares computed as: 295,808 thousand – 293,479 thousand.
Answer: a.
Rationale: Net income = basic EPS × Average number of shares outstanding during the year.
Thus, net income is $1.35 × 5,986 million = $8,081 million
Answer: b
Rationale: Preferred stock is not considered dilutive unless it is convertible.
Answer:
a) Valero: revenues are recognized when the products are delivered, which occurs when the gas
station owner (for independent stations) or the retail customer (for company owned locations) has
taken delivery of the gasoline.
b) Boeing: Record revenue using a percentage of completion method.
c) Wells Fargo: Interest is earned by the passage of time. If cash is not received, Citibank
accrues income on its loans and establishes an account receivable on its balance sheet.
d) Harley Davidson: Retail revenue recorded when customer takes delivery of the motorcycle.
Sales that are financed will yield interest revenue over the life of the note. This is similar to how
banks earn revenue.
Answer:
a. BCG should recognize revenues from long-term contracts on a percentage-of-completion basis
as services are provided.
b. Client deposits and prepayments (even if nonrefundable) should not be recorded as revenue.
Instead, BCG should record deferred revenue (a liability) recognize the revenue over future
periods as services are delivered or performed.
c. When contracts are over-budget, managers should estimate the new, revised, total
engagement cost. If this results in a loss on the engagement, that loss should be recognized
immediately rather than over the remaining term of the engagement.
2010 $ 15 million
2011 $ 90 million
2012 $ 45 million
Compute the revenue recognized, construction costs expensed, and income earned for each year
using the percentage of completion method.
Answer:
($ in millions) 2010 2011 2012
Construction costs incurred $15 $90 $45
Percentage to total costs $15 / $150 = 10% $90 / $150 = 60% $45 / $150 = 30%
Revenue recognized 10% × $210 = $21 60% ×210 = $126 30% × 210= $63
Income earned $21 - $15 = $6 $126 - $90 = $36 $63 - $45 = $18
Answer:
Bainbridge has a multiple element contract with UPS. Each of the four elements must be
accounted for separately: hardware (recognize revenue when installed and running), software
(recognize when client signs off on installation and beta tests), warranty (recognize over the one-
year coverage period), and software updates / tech support (recognize over the two-year
coverage period). To determine the amount of each part, Bainbridge must determine the fair
value of each element separately and then allocate the contract price $4,500,000 to each
element. The retainer received is unearned revenue (a liability) until the educational services are
rendered. Each month, as Bainbridge provides training, it will bill UPS and reduce the unearned
revenue liability. When total educational services exceed $250,000, Bainbridge will set up a
receivable from UPS.
Contracted
Year Sales Percentage completed Revenue Recognized
(40% of $40 million)
2010 $12 million/$30 million = 40% or $16 million
$40 million
(60% of $40 million)
2011 $18 million/$30 million = 60% or $24 million
Mainline will earn profits according to the revenue recognized, which means that 40% of the
profits ($4 million) should be recorded in 2009 and the rest ($6 million) in 2010 when the building
construction is completed.
Answer:
a. Sam’s should record membership fees evenly over the year. A risk is that they might record all
the fees as revenue when the customer makes the initial payment. This won’t really be a
significant issue if Sam’s receives about the same membership fees over the year.
b. The Wall Street Journal should record the revenue as each ad appears (weekly). There is a
potential risk that the company could record all of the advance payment as revenue when Banco
do Brasil pays it. This could be a significant issue if advance advertising revenues are not uniform
during the year.
c. Even though cash is received (credit cards are essentially cash), revenue should not be
recognized until the product is shipped. Until that time, the cash received is recognized as an
asset on the balance sheet and a liability (deferred revenue) is recorded to reflect an obligation to
deliver product. Thus, one revenue risk is that J. Jill could record the cash receipts as revenue,
before the product is delivered, to boost current sales and profit. This risk is small however in that
most shipments follow cash receipt by only a few days.
d. Tickets Now should record $7 revenue each time it sells a ticket. Of that $2 will be received in
cash and $5 will be recorded as receivable from the Riverdance producers. The risk exposure is
that Tickets Now could record $77 for each ticket sold and offset that with a cost of goods sold of
$70 (along with a $70 accounts payable) to the Riverdance producer. This would seriously
overinflate the company’s top line but would not have any effect on the bottom line.
2007 2008
Total assets $25,335,806 $31,767,575
Revenues $16,593,986 $21,795,550
Research and development expense $ 2,119,985 $ 2,793,192
Answer: Google spent more dollars on R&D in 2008, $2.8 billion versus $2.1 billion in 2007. But
to determine the more significant expenditure, we need to common-size the R&D expense. To
common-size income statement items, we divide by current period sales. Common-sized R&D for
2008 is $2,793,192 / $21,795,550 = 12.82% and for 2007 is $2,119,985 / $16,593,986 = 12.78%.
Thus, even on a percentage basis, Google spent more in 2008.
a. List three types of costs that Yahoo likely includes in the product development line item on the
income statement. b. What trend do you notice in Yahoo’s spending for product development?
Answer:
a. Types of costs included in product development could include:
• salaries and wages for R&D personnel
• computer and other types of equipment used by programmers
• costs of applying for patents and copyright protection
• legal fees for new patents
• overhead for R&D activities (heat, lighting, etc in research labs and offices)
• depreciation of capitalized R&D fixed assets
• lease payments for leased equipment or space
b. To detect a trend, we need to calculate common sized R&D expense, which means to divide
each year’s expense by that year’s revenues. Yahoo is spending proportionately more each year,
thus the trend is an increase in R&D spending.
Answer: Life Technologies Corporation would report for each of the R&D items as follows:
a. salaries and wages for R&D personnel – as paid and would include amounts incurred at year
end but not yet paid
b. supplies and inventory – would set up inventory as asset and expense items as they are used
up in R&D activities
c. equipment used in experiments – if equipment has no alternate use, Merck would expense in
period acquired. But if equipment has alternate use, Merck would capitalize as PPE and
depreciate over assets’ lives.
d. costs of applying for FDA approval – as incurred
e. overhead for R&D activities – allocate R&D related overhead as incurred
a. Compare R&D expenses of the two companies. Which company is more R&D intensive?
b. What trend do you notice in the R&D expense of each company over time?
Answer:
a. Comparing R&D measured in dollars indicates that Life Technologies spends more. However,
common sizing the expense is more appropriate to make comparisons:
Life Technologies Corporation Affymetrix Inc
2008 2007 2006 2008 2007 2006
8.8% 9.0% 9.1% 20.6% 19.6% 24.3%
Affymetrix spends proportionately more on R&D than Life Technologies – nearly 2.5 times more
which is a significant difference. Affymetrix is more R&D intensive.
b. Life Technologies maintained R&D spending at about 9% over the three-year period.
Affymetrix decreased R&D spending but still has significant R&D expenses.
Answer: The total restructuring charge accrued was $4.2 million because asset write-downs are
not accrued. That is there is no credit to a liability account for write-downs, the assets are credited
(reduced). Thus, the company must have paid $4,200,000 - $900,000 = $3,300,000 in cash
during fiscal 2009.
a) Reconcile the various parts of Dow Chemical’s “Restructuring charges” of $785 million.
b) How should Dow Chemical report the restructuring charges in its income statement? On its
balance sheet?
c) The SEC has expressed concern about abuses surrounding restructuring charges. What is the
nature of the SEC’s concerns?
Answer:
a) (in millions)
Asset write-downs and write-offs $336
Exit or disposal activities 128
Severance costs 321
$785
b) Under GAAP, the net restructuring gain (loss) would be reported as a separate line item in the
income statement, if it’s material, which $785 certainly is. In addition, any accrued liabilities
resulting from the restructuring would be reflected on the balance sheet. The footnotes detail the
change in the accrual (liability) account each period.
c) The timing and magnitude of restructuring costs is subject to management’s discretion. Thus,
some companies might overestimate such costs, especially if earnings are already low, a practice
which is referred to as a “big bath.” Overestimating the restructuring costs creates a cushion for
adjusting future earnings. On the other hand, because materiality is also discretionary,
management could deem these costs to be immaterial in order to avoid recording them as
separate items. Either tactic would impair the quality of the companies’ financial reports.
Answer: Microsoft reported income before income tax expense of $23,817 million. This is
calculated as Income tax expense / Effective tax rate = $6,133 million / 0.2575 = $23,817 million.
Answer: Snap-On reported taxes on the income statement of $117.7 million. This is calculated as
Income before tax × Effective tax rate = $357.8 million × 0.329 = $117.7 million.
Answer: Changes in valuation allowance affect net income in the opposite direction, dollar for
dollar. Dow Chemical increased the allowance by $164 million ($487 million - $323 million). The
effect was to reduce Dow’s net income by $164 million in 2008.
Answer: Changes in deferred tax asset account, inversely affects tax expense. Changes in the
deferred tax liability account, directly affects tax expense. Therefore Dow’s increase in deferred
tax assets and decrease in deferred tax liabilities, both decrease tax expense for the year by
$1,931 million ( $1,205 million + $726 million = $ 1,931 million decrease in tax expense).
Answer: The tax expense of $93 million will reduce net income by that amount and thus, retained
earnings on the balance sheet will be $93 million lower. The company pays $103 million tax in
cash, which reduces assets. The difference of $10 million is recorded as an increase in deferred
tax asset.
Answer: The restructuring charge of $785 million reduces income before taxes by that amount.
However, restructuring charges are not deductible until they are paid. Thus, during 2008, the tax-
basis expense for restructuring was $2 million. The difference of $783 million gives rise to a
deferred tax asset of $274 million ($785 million × 0.35) reported on the 2008 balance sheet.
a. What income tax expense did Life Technologies Company report in its 2008 income
statement?
b. How much of the income tax expense is payable in 2008?
Answer:
a. The income statement will show $124,299 for income tax expense.
b. The current tax provision of $67,899 is payable in 2008.
Answer:
Because the US $ strengthened during the year, each Euro will translate to fewer dollars. Thus,
revenues, expenses, and net profit of the Portugese subsidiary will be lower than they would have
been absent the foreign currency fluctuations.
During fiscal 2009, the U.S. dollar strengthened relative to the other principal currencies in which
we transact business with the exception of the Japanese Yen.
Explain the effect on Dell’s 2009 income statement of the U.S. dollar a) weakening vis-à-vis the
Japanese Yen, and b) strengthening versus all other currencies. Assume that Dell reported a net
profit in each of the countries involved.
Answer:
a) Because the US dollar weakened during the year, each Yen will translate to more dollars.
Thus, revenues, expenses, and net profit of the Japanese subsidiary will be higher than they
would have been absent the foreign currency fluctuations.
b) With respect to the other principal currencies, given that the US dollar strengthened during the
year, the profits in these countries will translate to fewer dollars. Thus, revenues, expenses, and
net profits of these subsidiaries will be lower than they would have been absent the foreign
currency fluctuations.
Topic: Computing EPS and explaining anti-dilutive stock options – Numerical calculations
required
LO: 5
22. Oracle reported the following earnings per share information in its 2008 annual report filed on
Form 10-K (in millions except per share data). The company has only one class of stock. a)
Compute basic and diluted earnings per share. b) Oracle also reports that it excludes 98 million
stock options from the diluted earnings per share calculation. Explain why Oracle excludes these
shares.
Answer:
a. Basic EPS = $5,521 / 5,133 = $1.07559 = $1.08
Diluted EPS = $5,521 / 5,229 = $1.05584 = $1.06
b. Stock options are only included in the computation of EPS if they are, in fact, dilutive. If they
are anti-dilutive, they are excluded from the computation. Oracle reports the number of these anti-
dilutive securities because they could be dilutive in the future if stock price increases.
Answer:
a. $609,365 / 293,479 = $2.07635
b. The company included about 295,808 thousand shares for the diluted EPS calculation. This is
computed as: $609,365 thousand / $2.06 = 295,808 thousand. Thus, the company included 2,329
thousand dilutive shares computed as: 295,808 thousand – 293,479 thousand.
Answer: Average number of shares outstanding during the year = Net income / basic EPS =
$8,052 million / $1.35 = 5,964.4 million shares. Average diluted number of shares outstanding
during the year = Net income / diluted EPS = $8,052 million / $1.35 = 6,146.6 million shares.
Total number of dilutive additional shares = 6,146.6 million shares - 5,964.4 million shares =
182.2 million shares
Topic: Earnings per share definition and computations– Numerical calculations required
LO: 5
25. OMNICARE, INC. reports the following in its 2008 10-K report (in thousands). Use the
information to calculate basic and diluted earnings per share (EPS) numbers.
Answer:
Basic EPS: $156,108 / 117,466 = $1.33
Diluted EPS: $156,108 118,313 = $1.32
Revenue Recognition
The Company generally recognizes sales, net of estimated returns, at the time the member takes
possession of merchandise or receives services. When the Company collects payments from
customers prior to the transfer of ownership of merchandise or the performance of services, the
amounts received are generally recorded as deferred revenue until the sale or service is
completed. The Company provides for estimated sales returns based on historical merchandise
returns levels.
The Company evaluates the criteria of the FASB Emerging Issues Task Force (EITF) 99-19,
“Reporting Revenue Gross as a Principal Versus Net as an Agent,” in determining whether it is
appropriate to record the gross amount of merchandise sales and related costs or the net amount
earned as commissions. Generally, when Costco is the primary obligor, is subject to inventory
risk, has latitude in establishing prices and selecting suppliers, can influence product or service
specifications, or has several but not all of these indicators, revenue is recorded on a gross basis.
If the Company is not the primary obligor and does not possess other indicators of gross reporting
as noted above, it records the net amounts as commissions earned, which is reflected in net
sales.
Membership fee revenue represents annual membership fees paid by substantially all of the
Company’s members. The Company accounts for membership fee revenue on a deferred basis,
whereby revenue is recognized ratably over the one-year membership period.
Required:
a. Explain in plain English how Costco recognizes the cash received from customers who
purchase goods or services.
b. What are “sales returns” and how does Costco record them in their financial statements?
c. Explain in plain English how Costco recognizes revenue from annual memberships.
d. Assume that on September 1, 2008, Costco collected $1,800 in membership fees from
customers. Use the financial statements effects template below to show how Costco would record
this transaction and what accounting adjustment Costco would record on November 30, 2008.
e. Costco is contemplating adding a fitness facility to its warehouses – customers would pay a
monthly fee to use fitness equipment and take classes. How would Costco record monthly fees
from customers if Costco runs the facility itself, that is Costco purchases all the equipment and
the fitness facility is staffed entirely by Costco employees? How would Costco record revenue if
the company sub-contracts the fitness facility to a third-party operator and receives a percentage
of monthly customer fees from the sub-contractor?
Sep. 1/08 = – =
Nov. 20/08 = – =
Cambridge Business Publishers, ©2010
5-24 Financial Statement Analysis & Valuation, 2nd Edition
Answer:
a. Costco recognizes cash from customers as the goods or services are delivered. For goods,
revenue is recognized when the customer leaves the store with the products. For services,
revenue is recognized with completion of the service. Deposits for either goods or services are
not recorded as revenue.
b. Sales returns happen when customers bring goods back. This represents revenue that was not
really earned, in the end. In anticipation of this, Costco estimates the value of goods that will be
returned, based on historical experience. Costco reduces sales revenue for this and sets up a
“sales return” liability for the same amount.
c. Members join for a year at a time. Costco recognizes the membership fee over the year, likely
recognizing 1/12 per month.
d.
Balance Sheet Income Statement
e. Costco would apply EITF 99-19 to determine how to recognize revenue. If Costco runs the
fitness facility itself, it would seem like the company “is subject to inventory risk, has latitude in
establishing prices and selecting suppliers, can influence product or service specifications” and
so Costco should record revenue from customers on a gross basis – record the fitness facility
monthly fees at the end of each month. If however, Costco sub-contracts the fitness facility to a
third-party operator, it would seem like the company is not the primary obligor and should only
record the “commission earned” which would be the contractual percentage of the fitness fees
received from the third party.
Revenue Recognition
We derive revenues from the following sources: (1) software, which includes new software
license and software license updates and product support revenues, and (2) services, which
include consulting, On Demand, and education revenues.
We recognize new software license revenue when: (1) we enter into a legally binding
arrangement with a customer for the license of software; (2) we deliver the products; (3) customer
payment is deemed fixed or determinable and free of contingencies or significant uncertainties;
and (4) collection is probable. Substantially all of our new software license revenues are
recognized in this manner.
The vast majority of our software license arrangements include software license updates and
product support, which are recognized ratably over the term of the arrangement, typically one
year.
Revenues for consulting services are generally recognized as the services are performed. If there
is a significant uncertainty about the project completion or receipt of payment for the consulting
services, revenues are deferred until the uncertainty is sufficiently resolved. We estimate the
proportional performance on contracts with fixed or “not to exceed” fees on a monthly basis
utilizing hours incurred to date as a percentage of total estimated hours to complete the project. If
we do not have a sufficient basis to measure progress towards completion, revenue is recognized
when we receive final acceptance from the customer.
Education revenues include instructor-led, media-based and internet-based training in the use of
our products. Education revenues are recognized as the classes or other education offerings are
delivered.
For arrangements with multiple elements, we allocate revenue to each element of a transaction
based upon its fair value as determined by “vendor specific objective evidence.” Vendor specific
objective evidence of fair value for all elements of an arrangement is based upon the normal
pricing and discounting practices for those products and services when sold separately and for
software license updates and product support services is also measured by the renewal rate
offered to the customer.
Required:
a. What are the five sources of revenue for Oracle Corporation?
b. Explain in plain English how Oracle recognizes revenue for each of the five types of revenue.
c. What are “arrangements with multiple elements”? How does Oracle account for such
arrangements?
d. Assume that Oracle has a sale that involves new software, software license updates and
product support for two years, and an educational package for the customer’s employees, which
will be fulfilled in six months. If sold separately, Oracle would charge the following for each of
these elements: $1 million, $150,000, and $400,000. Because the customer buys the entire
package, the sales price is $1,317,500. What revenue would Oracle record for each element?
Required:
a. How do Life Technologies and Affymetrix account for R&D expenditures?
b. Life Technologies and Affymetrix R&D expense includes many different types of costs. List
three specific costs included in R&D expense on the income statement.
c. Compare R&D expenses of the two companies. (Hint: prepare common size R&D expenses.
Consider both direct R&D expenses as well as acquired R&D.)
d. What trend do you notice in the R&D expenses of each company over time?
Affymetrix spends proportionately more on R&D than Life Technologies – nearly 2.5 times more
which is a significant difference.
We can extend the analysis to include both in-house R&D expenses as well as purchased R&D,
which is research acquired in a merger or acquisition.
d. Life Technologies maintained R&D spending at about 9% over the three-year period.
Affymetrix decreased R&D spending but still has significant R&D expenses. When we consider
both types of R&D, the company’s comparisons are closer. However the acquired R&D at both
firms does not appear to be a persistent item. Thus, it appears that Affymetrix is a more research
intensive firm.
Google Inc.
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME
(In thousands)
Year Ended December 31, 2006 2007 2008
Revenues $10,604,917 $16,593,986 $21,795,550
Cost of revenues 4,225,027 6,649,085 8,621,506
Research and development 1,228,589 2,119,985 2,793,192
Sales and marketing 849,518 1,461,266 1,946,244
General and administrative 751,787 1,279,250 1,802,639
Total costs and expenses 7,054,921 11,509,586 15,163,581
Income from operations 3,549,996 5,084,400 6,631,969
Impairment of equity investments - - (1,094,757)
Interest income and other, net 461,044 589,580 316,384
Income before income taxes 4,011,040 5,673,980 5,853,596
Provision for income taxes 933,594 1,470,260 1,626,738
Net income $ 3,077,446 $ 4,203,720 $ 4,226,858
Yahoo, Inc.
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME
(In thousands)
Years Ended December 31, 2006 2007 2008
Revenues $6,425,679 $6,969,274 $7,208,502
Cost of revenues 2,675,723 2,838,758 3,023,362
Gross profit 3,749,956 4,130,516 4,185,140
Sales and marketing 1,322,259 1,610,357 1,563,313
Product development 833,147 1,084,238 1,221,787
General and administrative 528,798 633,431 705,136
Amortization of intangibles 124,786 107,077 87,550
Restructuring charges, net - - 106,854
Goodwill impairment charge - - 487,537
Total operating expenses 2,808,990 3,435,103 4,172,177
Income from operations 940,966 695,413 12,963
Other income, net 157,034 154,011 82,838
Income before provision for income taxes,
earnings in equity interests and other 1,098,000 849,424 95,801
Provision for income taxes (458,011) (337,263) (262,717)
Earnings in equity interests and other 111,402 147,839 591,214
Net income $ 751,391 $ 660,000 $ 424,298
Answer:
a. All R&D costs are expensed in the income statement, except for the portion relating to
depreciable assets that have alternate uses. Expensing of R&D expenses (rather than
capitalizing and depreciating them) reduces assets on both Google and Yahoo’s balance sheets.
As well, expensing R&D expenses as incurred, increases expenses, which reduces profit
reported on the income statement and stockholders’ equity on the balance sheet (via the
reduction in retained earnings).
b.
Google (in thousands) 2006 2007 2008
Revenues $10,604,917 $16,593,986 $21,795,550
Research and development expense $ 1,228,589 $ 2,119,985 $ 2,793,192
Common-sized R&D expense 11.59% 12.78% 12.82%
Google spent more dollars on R&D than Yahoo, in 2008: $2.8 billion versus $1.2 billion. But to
determine the more significant expenditure, we need to common-size the R&D expense. To
common-size income statement items, we divide by current period sales. The table below shows
the common-sized amount. From this we see that, on a percentage basis, Yahoo spent more for
product development each year.
As far as trends, both firms have increased the R&D expenses over the past three years. Yahoo
has increased spending more, which has increased the difference between common-sized
expense from about 1.5 percentage points in 2006 (11.59% versus 12.97%) to 4 percentage
points (12.82% versus 16.95%).
c. It is very difficult to evaluate the effectiveness of R&D because R&D spending affects revenues
but with some time lag (current period R&D expenditures yield future sales). Over time, however,
the number and quality of new product introductions, number of patents, market share, etc., can
be compared across companies and against relative levels of R&D spending. Both Google and
Yahoo spend considerable amounts on their R&D because innovating and developing new web
technologies is the lifeblood for these companies.
d. Google is very profitable, and as a consequence, very visible to the public and to governmental
agencies. Thus, Google probably welcomes additional expenses and would not favor capitalizing
their R&D expenses. Yahoo is less profitable and likely could improve its income statement by
capitalizing some R&D expenses.
On December 5, 2008, the Company’s Board of Directors approved a restructuring plan as part of
a series of actions to advance the Company’s strategy and respond to the recent, severe
economic downturn. The restructuring plan includes the shutdown of a number of facilities and a
global workforce reduction, which are targeted to be completed by the end of 2010. As a result of
the shutdowns and global workforce reduction, the Company recorded pretax restructuring
charges of $785 million in the fourth quarter of 2008. The following table summarizes the
activities related to the Company’s restructuring charge and reserve (liability):
Costs
Impairment of associated with
(in millions) long-lived exit or disposal Severance
assets activities costs Total
Restructuring charge in
fourth quarter 336 128 321 785
Cash payments 0 0 (2) (2)
Charges against reserve (336) 0 0 (336)
Reserve balance at
December 31, 2008 0 128 319 447
Required:
a. Explain why Dow Chemical planned this restructuring. When did the company record the
restructuring expense? When will the restructuring take place? Explain the difference.
b. What are the three types of restructuring costs for Dow Chemical for 2008?
c. Explain why no cash is involved in settling the impairment of long-lived assets portion of the
restructuring reserve.
d. Dow Chemical managers estimated all of the charges above. What would be the income-
statement consequences next year (in 2009) if only $300 million of additional cash payments
were necessary to completely settle the employee severance costs? Assume that Dow Chemical
did not intentionally overestimate these severance costs.
Components of income tax expense (benefit) related to continuing operations were as follows (in
millions):
Deferred:
U.S. federal 543 155 285
U.S. state (8) 31 (5)
Canada 140 (90) 3
Total deferred 675 96 283
Income tax expense $1,467 $2,161 $2,611
The significant components of deferred tax assets and liabilities were as follows (in millions):
Answer:
a. Valero Energy reports $1,467 million of tax expense in its 2008 income statement. Of this
amount, $792 million is currently payable.
b. Deferred tax liabilities relating to property plant and equipment relate to accelerated
depreciation. These liabilities arise because the company is depreciating buildings and equipment
more quickly in its tax return than in its GAAP income statement. Thus, the assets’ tax-reporting
book value is less than the financial-reporting book value, which yields a deferred tax liability. For
any particular asset, future depreciation expense in the tax return will be lower and the difference
between the two net book values will shrink and the liability will reverse. However, if Valero adds
significant depreciable assets each year, the first-year’s accelerated depreciation on the new
assets will more than offset the lower depreciation on the older assets, resulting in a permanent
deferred tax liability. Once the growth rate for assets subsides, the depreciation expense
deduction in the tax return will as well, and the deferred tax liability will shrink.
c. Valero reports an accrued liability of $394 million for compensation and employee benefit
liabilities on its balance sheet. This does not create a tax-basis liability however because the tax
authorities do not permit a deduction for this sort of expense until employees (retirees) are paid.
Consequently, GAAP liabilities are greater than tax-basis liabilities, which creates a deferred tax
asset that recognizes the future deductions of pension payments.
d. Net operating losses (NOL) arise when a company reports a tax loss. Such losses can be
carried back for up to two years to offset against taxable income and the company receives a tax
refund. Unused tax losses can be carried forward for up to 20 years as future tax deductions to
reduce future taxable income and tax liability. This creates a deferred tax asset because at some
point in the future, the company will pay fewer taxes than it would absent the NOL carryforward.
e. The valuation allowance arises when the company believes that some of the related deferred
tax assets will not generate future benefits. These allowances typically arise because the carry
forward deduction will likely not be used before it expires. Increases and decreases in deferred
tax valuation allowances affect net income dollar-for-dollar in the opposite direction. For 2008, the
increase in the allowance decreased net income by $8 million. Since establishing and
subsequently adjusting the valuation allowance is highly subjective (dependent upon the
company’s estimation of whether the deductions will or will not be realized), companies might
increase or decrease this account to manage net income to reach income targets. Financial
statement users need to be aware of how changes in the valuation allowance affects net income
in their analysis of the profitability of the company.
The components of provision for income taxes for all periods presented were as follows (in
thousands)
Year ended December 31, 2008 2007 2006
Current tax provision:
Federal $41,883 $37,770 $10,119
State 14,585 7,208 4,804
Total current 56,468 44,978 14,923
Deferred tax provision:
Federal (3,680) (413) 15,005
State (4,314) (248) 1,145
Total deferred (7,994) (661) 16,150
Provision for income taxes $48,474 $44,317 $31,073
Required:
a. Use the financial statement effects template below to record income tax expense for Netflix for
2008.
12/31/2008 = – =
b. Netflix reports deferred tax assets relating to depreciation. Describe how these assets arise.
How likely is it that these assets will be recouped?
c. Assume that Netflix records deferred tax assets at a rate of 35%. The balance sheet reports
property, plant and equipment, net of $124,948 thousand. Compute the tax basis for these
assets. Hint: recall that the difference between the assets’ net book value and the tax basis is the
timing difference and that deferred taxes are recorded as timing difference × tax rate.
d. Netflix reports a significant deferred tax asset relating to stock-based compensation. The
company has compensated executives and other managers with stock options. Explain why this
gives rise to a deferred tax asset.
b. Deferred tax assets relating to depreciation arise because Netflix is depreciating buildings and
equipment less quickly in its tax return than for its GAAP income statement. This could relate to
its investment in a movie library. Thus, the assets’ tax-reporting book value is greater than the
financial-reporting book value, which yields a deferred tax asset. This is the opposite of the typical
situation.
c. Timing difference = Deferred tax asset / Tax rate = $2,947 thousand / 0.35 = $8,420 thousand.
Tax basis = GAAP net book value + timing differences. Tax basis = $124,948 thousand + $8,420
thousand = $133,368 thousand.
d. Netflix Co. reports GAAP expense for stock options as the options are granted. However for
tax purposes, the company may only expense the options if and when they exercised. This
creates a timing difference and, a deferred tax asset.
d. Operating loss carry forwards arise when a company reports a tax loss, which it can carry back
for up to 2 years to offset against taxable income and receive a tax refund. Unused tax losses can
be carried forward for up to 20 years as future tax deductions to reduce future taxable income
and tax liability. This creates a deferred tax asset.
Disclosed in the table below is geographic information for each country that comprised greater
than three percent of our total revenues for fiscal 2008, fiscal 2007 or fiscal 2006.
Year Ended May 31,
2008 2007 2006
Long Lived Long Lived Long Lived
(in millions) Revenues Assets(1) Revenues Assets(1) Revenues Assets(1)
(1) Long-lived assets exclude goodwill, intangible assets, equity investments and deferred taxes, which are
not allocated to specific geographic locations as it is impracticable to do so.
a. What proportion of Oracle’s total revenue is potentially exposed to foreign currency risk?
b. Assume that Oracle does not undertake any measures to reduce its foreign currency exposure.
If the U.S. dollar strengthens on average 10% vis-à-vis the European currencies in which the
company transacts, and weakens 5% relative to the Japanese yen, what will be the impact on
revenues in 2008?
c. Explain what steps Oracle can take to reduce its foreign currency risk.
c. Company such as Oracle, can take several steps to mitigate foreign currency risk. The
company can match its revenues and expenses in the various foreign currencies. This will mean
that only the total (net income) will be exposed to risk. The company can also use hedging
instruments such as options and forward contracts that pay off when the company’s foreign
currency position is in a loss.
Required:
a. What are the potential sources of dilution of NetFlix’s earnings per share?
b. List two additional dilutive securities (other than those NetFlix includes).
c. NetFlix did not include all outstanding employee stock options in the calculation of diluted net
income per share in 2008? Why not? How many options were excluded?
d. Calculate basic EPS for each of the three years.
e. Calculate diluted EPS for each of the three years.
SLM CORPORATION
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME
(Dollars and shares in thousands, except per share amounts)
For the year ended December 31, 2008 2007 2006
Answer:
For the year ended December 31, 2008 2007 2006
Answer:
a. Microsoft recognizes revenue when there exists persuasive evidence of an arrangement,
delivery has occurred, the contract or sales price is fixed or determinable, and collectibility is
probable.
b. Neiman Marcus is a retailer and revenue recognition is fairly straight-forward. The company will
record revenue when the customer takes possession of the merchandise and pays (primarily with
either cash or credit card). Catalogue and e-commerce sales are recorded upon customer receipt
of merchandise. Amounts relating to shipping and handling billed to customers are classified as
revenue and the related costs are classified as cost of goods sold.
Answer: Companies sometimes act as agents for other companies. A company might attempt to
inflate revenues by reporting these transactions on a “gross” basis, when in fact these
commissions or revenues should be reported on a net basis. Start-up and dot.com companies
may employ this method under the assumption that the market prices of their stocks are
determined by revenue growth and profitability. The SEC mandates that all such sales should be
reported on a net basis.
Topic: Percentage-of-completion
LO: 1
3. When is the percentage-of-completion method an appropriate method to recognize revenues.
What are some of the potential risks associated with this practice?
Answer: Companies that are awarded long-term contracts that span over one year typically use
the percentage-of-completion method to recognize revenue. The difficulty arises when a company
must forecast all project-related costs in order to accurately estimate at any given point in time
how far along the percentage of completion. Errors can result whereby the company recognizes
too much revenue on the front end, only to be reversed at the end of the project.
Answer: Restructuring costs consist of three general categories: asset write-downs, liability
accruals for severance and relocation costs, and accruals of other restructuring-related costs.
Asset write-downs reduce assets’ net book value and are recognized in the income statement as
an expense. Liability accruals for severance and other expenses create a liability, such as for
anticipated severance costs and exit costs, and yield a corresponding expense that reduces
income and equity.
Answer: “Big Bath” behavior refers to an event in which companies are perceived as
overestimating the amount of asset write-downs or liability accruals to deliberately reduce current
period earnings. The effect is to remove future costs from the balance sheet or to create reserves
that can be used to increase future period earnings. An example of big bath behavior would be to
time recognition of restructuring costs for a year when its income is already depressed. An
analyst or potential investor may be concerned with this behavior because of the inaccurate
portrayal of a company’s costs and or earnings that result.
Answer: Gross profit margin is an important profitability measure. However, it is just one
measure and needs to be viewed in conjunction with other equally important measures such as
SG&A, R&D and net income percentages. Retailers, for example, cannot charge higher prices
per unit given the significant competition and product similarity across companies in this industry.
However, they compensate for these low margins in other areas e.g. with lower R&D costs (given
a lack of need for product differentiation) and lower SG&A expenses. Conversely, companies in
the Oil & Gas sector typically require higher profit margins to off-set much higher SG&A expenses
as well as R&D costs in order to remain economically viable. Hence, different companies may
use different combinations of margin and turnover to achieve the same return on net operating
assets, given the dynamics of their particular sector.
Answer: There are two kinds of deferred taxes: deferred tax liabilities and deferred tax assets.
The former arise when a company’s taxable income is less than its book income, typically
resulting from higher depreciation expense for tax reporting. The company records this effect in
its financial statements as an increase in deferred tax liability to recognize the taxes that will be
paid when the item causing the difference reverses. Deferred tax assets arise for the opposite
reason: taxable income is greater than financial reporting income. This can arise, for example,
when a company reports a restructuring expense that is recognized for financial reporting
purposes when incurred, but is not deductible for tax purposes until paid.
Answer: When the U.S. dollar strengthens foreign currencies weaken – they are translated to
fewer USD. This reduces every reported number on the financial statements compared to what
the USD equivalent would have been if the U.S. dollar had not strengthened. Thus, reported
sales, expenses and net income are all smaller.
Answer: There are two measures of reporting the earnings per share (EPS) figures: basic and
diluted EPS.
Basic EPS is equal to the ratio of net income less dividends on preferred stock to the weighted
average of common shares outstanding for the year. Computation of diluted EPS reflects the
additional shares that would be issued assuming all stock options and convertible securities are
exercised at the beginning of the year. Therefore, diluted EPS is calculated by subtracting the
EPS impact of dilutive options and warrants and the EPS impact of dilutive convertibles from
basic EPS.
Some financial analysts and investors compare EPS figures across companies of different sizes.
The assumption is that the number of shares outstanding is proportional to the income level.
However, this assumption is not correct, since the number of shares outstanding is controlled by
managers, and different companies may have different share issuance and repurchase attitudes.
Answer: Basic earnings per share is defined as net income less any preferred dividends divided
by the weighted average number of common shares outstanding for the period. Diluted earnings
per share adjusts the numerator (earnings) for the impact of issuing dilutive securities (such as
convertible securities or employee stock options); and the denominator. Consequently, diluted
earnings per share is always less than or equal to basic earnings per share. As an investor, I pay
more attention to diluted earnings per share because it tells me about the worst-case scenario if
all dilutive security holders converted their debt or exercised their options. This informs me about
the potential loss in value of my holdings.