Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Shan 2013
Shan 2013
Shan 2013
L.-S. Shan1, P. Hou1, Z.-J. Wang1, F.-R. Liu1, N. Chen1, L.-H. Shu1, H. Zhang1, X.-H. Han1, X.-X. Cai1, Y.-X. Shang1
and Y. Vandenplas2
1Department of Pediatric Pneumology, Shengjing Hospital of China Medical University, Shenyang 110004, China; 2UZ
Brussel, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Laarbeeklaan 101, 1090 Brussels, Belgium; shangyx@sj-hospital.org
RESEARCH PAPER
Abstract
The aim of this study was to determine whether Saccharomyces boulardii prevents and treats diarrhoea and antibiotic-
associated diarrhoea (AAD) in children. A total of 333 hospitalised children with acute lower respiratory tract
infection were enrolled in a 2-phase open randomised controlled trial. During the 1st phase, all children received
intravenous antibiotics (AB). They were randomly allocated to group A (S. boulardii 500 mg/day + AB, n=167) or
group B (AB alone, n=166) and followed for 2 weeks. Diarrhoea was defined as ≥3 loose/watery stools/day during at
least 2 days, occurring during treatment and/or up to 2 weeks after AB therapy had stopped. AAD was considered
when diarrhoea was caused by Clostridium difficile or when stool cultures remained negative. In the 2nd phase of the
study, group B patients who developed diarrhoea were randomly allocated to two sub-groups: group B1 (S. boulardii
+ oral rehydration solution (ORS)) and group B2 (ORS alone). Data from 283 patients were available for analysis.
Diarrhoea prevalence was lower in group A than in group B (11/139 (7.9%) vs. 42/144 (29.2%); relative risk (RR):
0.27, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.1-0.5). S. boulardii reduced the risk of AAD (6/139 (4.3%) vs. 28/144 (19.4%);
RR: 0.22; 95% CI: 0.1-0.5). When group B patients developed diarrhoea (n=42), S. boulardii treatment during 5
days (group B1) resulted in lower stool frequency (P<0.05) and higher recovery rate (91.3% in group B1 vs. 21.1%
in B2; P<0.001). The mean duration of diarrhoea in group B1 was shorter (2.31±0.95 vs. 8.97±1.07 days; P<0.001).
No adverse effects related to S. boulardii were observed. S. boulardii appeared to be effective in the prevention and
treatment of diarrhoea and AAD in children treated with intravenous antibiotics.
Keywords: antibiotic-associated diarrhoea, Clostridium difficile, Saccharomyces boulardii, acute lower respiratory tract
infection, hospitalised children
2004; Guandalini, 2011; Kotowska et al., 2005; Szajewska neutral envelope was opened each time the next patient
and Mrukowicz, 2005; Vandenplas et al., 2007, 2009, 2011). was included in the study. To evaluate the role of S. boulardii
in prevention, the incidence of diarrhoea and AAD was
Our study aimed to evaluate the efficacy of S. boulardii evaluated every day up to 2 weeks after the antibiotic
in the prevention and treatment of diarrhoea and AAD in therapy had stopped.
hospitalised children with an acute lower respiratory tract
infection. This is the first study evaluating the efficacy of The Bristol stool scale (BSS) classifying stool consistency
S. boulardii in hospitalised children developing diarrhoea in seven categories was used to evaluate stool consistency
during antibiotic treatment. (Lewis and Heaton, 1997). The definition of diarrhoea was
≥3 loose or watery stools (BSS type 5, 6 and 7) per day
2. Materials and methods during at least 2 days, occurring during treatment and/
or up to 2 weeks after the antibiotic therapy had stopped.
Subjects AAD was defined as diarrhoea caused by C. difficile or
diarrhoea with negative stool cultures (Bartlett et al., 1978).
The study was performed between January and June 2012 in Recovery was defined as a decrease in stool frequency and
children (age range from 6 months to 14 years) hospitalised BSS type ≤4. The number of stools, stool consistency, and
in the Department of Pediatric Pulmonology, Shengjing any other symptom were recorded daily in a diary during
Hospital of China Medical University, Shenyang, China hospitalisation and during a two week follow-up period.
because of an acute lower respiratory infection and the When diarrhoea occurred, stool samples were analysed
need of administration of intravenous antibiotics. Acute for rotavirus antigen using a colloidal gold test device
lower respiratory infections included bronchitis, bronchial (Rotavirus Group A diagnostic kit; Beijing Wantai Biological
pneumonia, extended lobar pneumonia, and asthma attacks Pharmacy Enterprise Co., Beijing, China); standard stool
together with lower respiratory tract infections. Exclusion cultures (Salmonella, Shigella, Yersinia, Campylobacter,
criteria were obvious malnutrition, severe dehydration, Escherichia coli) were performed and C. difficile toxins A
unconsciousness, gastrointestinal disease, a central line, and B were looked for using an enzyme immunoassay (C.
and use of antifungal drugs or probiotics. Participation in difficile TOX A/B Test; Tech Lab Inc., Blacksburg, VA,
this clinical study was voluntary. Informed consent was USA). Treatment compliance was evaluated by returning
obtained from the children’s guardian. The study protocol medication after the intervention period.
was approved by the University Hospital Ethical Committee.
Children who developed diarrhoea were rehydrated with
Sample size oral or intravenous fluids, but antibiotic treatment was
continued. Children from group B who developed diarrhoea
It was assumed that the incidence rate of diarrhoea were divided in two sub-groups: group B1, S. boulardii
development in the control groups would be equal to 25%. (daily 2×250 mg for 5 days) + oral rehydration solution
Based on this, we estimated that a minimum sample size (ORS), and group B2, ORS only. The enrolment method
of 129 children in each treatment group would show 15% for the second part of the study was identical to that of
reduction in the proportion of children with AAD in the the first part.
intervention groups with a significance level of 5% and
power of 90%. It was assumed that the study withdrawal Outcome measures
rate would be at least 20-25% and, therefore, the sample
size was increased to compensate for the potential influence The outcome measures were twofold. For the first part
of loss to follow-up. of the study, the development of diarrhoea between the
start of antibiotic treatment up to two weeks later was
Study design the primary outcome. The secondary outcome was AAD,
when all cultures were negative or when diarrhoea was
This study was an open, randomised, controlled clinical caused by C. difficile. For the second part of the study,
trial. All patients included were given the standard only groups B1 and B2 were considered. In those patients,
intravenous antibiotic treatment according to the hospital duration of diarrhoea was the primary endpoint. Duration
recommendations and were randomly allocated to two of diarrhoea was determined by the number of days of
groups. Group A received S. boulardii daily 2×250 mg continuous diarrhoea, from the first diarrheic stool until
(Bioflor; CMS·Shenzhen Kangzhe Pharmaceutical Co. the first normal stool.
Ltd., Shenzhen, China) for the duration of the antibiotic
treatment (n=167) and group B received no additional
therapy (n=166). Randomisation was done according to
a computer-determined allocation to group A or B. The
sequence was concealed in an envelope, and the next
Group A: SB + iv AB Group B: iv AB
(n=167) (n=166)
n=139 n=144
Figure 1. Study flow chart. Abbreviations used: iv AB = intravenous antibiotics, n = number of patients, ORS = oral rehydration
solution.
Table 2. Primary and secondary outcomes in patients receiving Saccharomyces boulardii during antibiotic treatment or antibiotics
alone.
1 iv AB = intravenous antibiotics.
2 RR = relative risk, CI = confidence interval.
3 AAD = antibiotic-associated diarrhoea.
AAD was diagnosed in 34/53 (64%) patients. The AAD recovery rate was significantly higher than in group B2 (83
risk was lower in group A (RR=0.22; 95% CI = 0.09-0.56), vs. 16%; χ2=18.62, P<0.001) (Table 4). The mean duration
especially in patients treated with cefuroxime (1/30 of diarrhoea in group B1 was significantly shorter than in
(3.3%) vs. 8/31 (25.8%); RR=0.13; 95% CI = 0.02-0.97), or group B2 (2.31±0.95 vs. 8.97±1.07 days, t=21.36, P<0.001).
amoxicillin/clavulanic acid (2/36 (5.6%) vs. 9/37 (24.3%);
RR=0.23; 95% CI = 0.05-0.99) (Table 3). The incidence Adverse reactions
of rotavirus gastroenteritis was similar in both groups
(Table 2). No adverse reaction to S. boulardii and no case of drug
discontinuation (neither antibiotics nor S. boulardii) have
Therapeutic effect of Saccharomyces boulardii on been reported.
diarrhoea
4. Discussion
For the second part of the study, the sample size calculation
was not performed. The 42 patients with diarrhoea in group This study confirms the efficacy of S. boulardii in the
B were further randomly allocated: 23 to group B1 (ORS prevention of diarrhoea and AAD developing during or
+ S. boulardii) and 19 to group B2 (ORS). After 3 days of short after antibiotic treatment. The administration of
administration of S. boulardii to patients in group B1, the S. boulardii during 5 days in the group of children that
1 iv AB = intravenous antibiotics.
2 RR = relative risk, CI = confidence interval.
3 SD = standard deviation.
4 The difference in number of children with antibiotics between Tables 1 and 3 is due to the withdrawals.
Table 4. Efficacy of Saccharomyces boulardii in children from the initial control group that developed diarrhoea.
Day 0
Stool frequency (n/day) 4.03±0.61 3.98±0.52 0.28 0.779
Day 3
Stool frequency (n/day) 2.22±1.89 4.01±2.15 2.87 0.006
Recovery rate (%) 19/23 (82.6) 3/19 (15.8) χ2=18.62 <0.001
Day 5
Stool frequency (n/day) 1.01±0.85 3.98±1.89 6.766 <0.001
Recovery rate (%) 21/23 (91.3) 4/19 (21.1) χ2=21.31 <0.001
developed diarrhoea during antibiotic treatment or boulardii is not inactivated by gastric acid and antibiotics,
during the following two weeks, shortened the duration except for fungicides. These properties make S. boulardii an
of diarrhoea. After 3 days, diarrhoea had stopped in 83% attractive probiotic to test in the prevention and treatment
of the children in the S. boulardii group compared to of AAD.
only 16% in the untreated group. There were no adverse
reactions. These results suggest that S. boulardii offers an A major shortcoming of this trial is its ‘open’ design.
appropriate and safe therapeutic intervention to prevent Because there is no placebo control group, a placebo effect
and treat diarrhoea and AAD. cannot be excluded. However, a previous placebo-controlled
trial reported similar results (Johnston et al., 2011). The
Antibiotic use in children is three times higher than in age-range of the patients included is quite wide, but other
adults due to more frequent infections in that age group studies used similar inclusion criteria (McFarland, 1998).
(Szajewska et al., 2006). Besides being an effective treatment Another limitation of this study is the 2-week follow-up.
for bacterial infections, antibiotics may also induce AAD AAD may occur within 2 months after antibiotic treatment
by disrupting the balance of the intestinal flora. Antibiotics had stopped, therefore, some AAD cases might not have
may cause direct damage to the intestinal mucosa and been included. In addition, we only tested for the major
atrophy of intestinal epithelium, and reduce the activity of stool pathogens; other pathogens may have been missed.
cellular enzymes (disaccharidases), which leads to diarrhoea Therefore, AAD in this study was defined as diarrhoea
and abdominal pain (Johnston et al., 2011). Children may caused by C. difficile or as unexplained diarrhoea that
be prone to AAD because of their still-developing immune might be related to antibiotics (McFarland, 1998). Only
system. All antibiotics can cause AAD depending on type the children without acute or chronic diarrhoea and without
and duration of administration (Bergogne-Berezin, 2000) other chronic gastrointestinal diseases were enrolled in this
rather than dosage or administration route (McFarland, study to reduce interference.
1998). While AAD in children is estimated at 11-40%, it has
been reported that incidence for cephalosporin, penicillin, 5. Conclusions
and clindamycin may be higher (Kotowska et al., 2005).
Similar results were obtained in our study. The results of the present study confirm that prophylactic
use of oral S. boulardii reduces the risk to develop
The yeast S. boulardii secretes proteins that lower the (antibiotic-associated) diarrhoea during treatment or during
cAMP activity of intestinal epithelium cells and, therefore, two weeks after antibiotic administration had stopped. It is
reduces the secretory watery diarrhoea (Czerucka et al., for the first time that the efficacy of S. boulardii is suggested
1994). Moreover, S. boulardii increases production of when diarrhoea occurs during antibiotic treatment or
polyamines and activates mucosal enzymes (Buts et al., the following two weeks. Future double-blind placebo-
1999; Vandenplas et al., 2007). Furthermore, as it secretes controlled trials are needed to confirm these data.
proteases, S. boulardii can directly hydrolyse the toxins
secreted by C. difficile, resulting in a reduction of the Conflict of interest
occurrence of AAD. In addition, S. boulardii can stimulate
the gastrointestinal immune system, such as intestinal Y. Vandenplas is consultant for Biocodex and United
phagocytosis, intestinal secretary IgA, and other non- Pharmaceuticals.
specific immunity functions (Czerucka et al., 2007). S.