Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Recovery and Recycling Processes of Scheduled Waste in Malaysia
Recovery and Recycling Processes of Scheduled Waste in Malaysia
WASTE IN MALAYSIA
NOVEMBER 2009
iii
Thank you very much for your courage and support, may Allah bless my beloved
husband,
Hisam bin Hussain
childrens,
Aqilah Husna
Anwar Hazim
Ammar Hakimi
and sister
Norshuzilah
iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Last but not least, I would also want to thank to my friends and any party who
has contributed into the completion of this thesis. Your contributions are really meaning
to me. To all of you, thank you very much.
v
ABSTRACT
For the past four decades treatment and disposal of scheduled wastes
resulting in many environmental problems such as illegal dumping, illegal export
and import of wastes. Nevertheless, with new technology development and
increasing commitment, many types of scheduled wastes can be recovered or
recycled. However, there are three main issues to consider when discussing
scheduled waste management hierarchy, which are lack of awareness on the
importance of scheduled waste recovery or recycling, regulatory constraints, and
lack of knowledge on the state-of-the-art technology for the recovery or
recycling processes. The aim and objectives of the study are to produce the
recovery or recycling process flow for potential scheduled wastes that can be
recovered or recycled, identify the waste acceptance criteria and material balance
calculation. The study was conducted through an evaluation and comparison on
the recovery or recycling processes done by the related industries in Malaysia
and site visit to recycling factory. From the study, it was found out that out of
total 77 types of scheduled wastes listed in the Environmental Quality
(Scheduled Wastes) Regulations 2005 First Schedule, there are 41(53%) types
are being recovered or recycled while the flow of recovery or recycling processes
for 16 (21%) types of scheduled waste has been reviewed. In addition, the waste
acceptance criteria have been identified from the minimum level of acceptance
prior to recovery or recycling processes. The material balance calculation which
indicates the percentage of treated or recovered waste materials, residual sludge
material generated and wastewater discharged if the plant is operated at its
maximum capacity is also been addressed in order to enable the factory or
consultant have the certainty to invest in the required new technology, hence to
ensure efficient scheduled wastes recovery activities.
vi
ABSTRAK
Dalam tempoh empat dekad yang lalu, rawatan dan pelupusan sisa
terjadual mengakibatkan banyak masaalah alam sekitar. Walaubagaimanapun,
dengan kemajuan teknologi terkini dan komitmen yang tingg, berbagai jenis sisa
terjadual boleh diperoleh semula atau dikitar semula. Namun, terdapat 3 isu
utama yang perlu dipertimbang bila membincangkan tentang hiraki pengurusan
sisa terjadual; iaitu kurangnya kesedaran tentang kepentingan peroleh atau kitar
semula sisa terjadual, kekangan peraturan dan pengetahuan yang cetek tentang
teknologi pembinaan untuk proses perolehan semula atau kitar semula. Tujuan
dan objektif kajian adalah untuk menghasilkan proses aliran peroleh semula atau
kitar semula sisa terjadual yang berpotensi untuk diperoleh atau dikitar semula,
mengenalpasti kriteria kebolehterimaan sisa dan pengiraan keseimbangan bahan.
Kajian dijalanakan melalui penilaian dan perbandingan terhadap proses peroleh
dan kitar semula yang telah dilaksanakan oleh industri yang terlibat di Malaysia
dan lawatan ke kilang kitar semula. Hasil dari kajian, didapati daripada jumlah
77 jenis sisa terjadual yang disenaraikan dalam Peraturan Alam Sekitar (Sisa
Terjadual) 2005, Jadual Pertama, 41 (53%) jenis boleh di peroleh atau dikitar
semula sementara aliran proses peroleh atau kitar semula 16 (21%) jenis sisa
terjadual telah dikaji. Berikutan itu, kriteria kebolehterimaan sisa telah
dikenalpasti dari tahap minimum untuk penerimaan sebelum proses peroleh atau
kitar semula. Pengiraan keseimbangan bahan yang menentukan peratus
perolehan semula bahan dari sisa terjadual, sisa terhasil dan penghasilan air sisa
jika kilang beroperasi pada tahap kapasiti yang maksimum juga dikenalpasti bagi
membolehkan pengusaha kilang atau perunding kitar semula sisa terjadual yakin
untuk melabur dalam teknologi kitar semula sisa terjadual untuk memastikan
kecekapan aktiviti kitar semula sisa terjadual.
vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1 INTRODUCTION 1
1.1 Preface 1
1.2 Problem Statement 2
1.3 Aim and Objectives 4
1.4 Scope of Project 5
viii
2 LITERATURE REVIEW 6
2.1 Introduction 6
2.2 Hazardous Substance and Scheduled Waste 8
2.3 Types of Scheduled Waste Generated in Malaysia 10
2.4 Problems Associated with Scheduled Waste 14
2.5 Environmental Requirements on Scheduled Waste 15
2.6 The Basel Convention 19
2.7 Conclusion 21
3 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 21
3.1 Informations Gathering 22
3.2 List of Data Collected 23
4.1 Introduction 27
4.2 Dust, Slag, Dross Or Ash Recovery 27
4.2.1 General Elements of Dust, Slag, Dross Or 27
Ash
4.2.2 Statement of Need 28
4.2.3 Waste Acceptance Criteria for Solder and 28
Aluminium Dross
4.2.4 Recovery Process Description 29
5 CONCLUSION 79
5.1 Conclusion 79
5.2 Recommendations 80
REFERENCES 81
xi
Appendix A 85
xii
LIST OF TABLES
4.8 Material balance for oil and water mixture or ballast water 56
recovery
xiii
LIST OF FIGURES
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
LIST OF APPENDICES
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Preface
Scheduled wastes such as spent solvent, spent oil, slag and dross, as well as
contaminated rag generated during manufacturing or packaging has been found
having significant values. Hence, recovery and recycling of scheduled waste can
offer a number of environmental in terms of reducing the volume of scheduled waste
that needs to be finally disposed. In addition, recovery and recycling would help
2
There are three main issues to consider when discussing scheduled waste
management hierarchy of reduce, reuse, recycle, and recover. The three main issues
are lack of awareness on the importance of scheduled waste recovery and recycling,
regulatory constraints, and lack of knowledge on the state-of-the-art technology for
the recovery and recycling processes.
Thus, the study would guide the investors on how the scheduled waste can be
recovered and the quantity produced in Material Balance calculation for recovery and
recycling processes.
The aim of the project is to produce the recovery and recycling process flow
of selected scheduled wastes.
The scope of this study is the recovery and recycling processes practiced by
factories in Malaysia who are involved in the scheduled waste recovery and
recycling. Assessment on physical and chemical characteristics, WAC and material
balance calculation will be based on current practice and findings by the related
factories.
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
Many authorities agree, the 3 R’s are the most immediate and effective way
organizations and individuals can conserve resources, prevent pollution and save
money. Waste prevention, or “source reduction,” means consuming and throwing
away less or cutting down on waste and using products made to last rather than
disposable. Reusing products when possible is even better than recycling, because the
item does not need to be reprocessed before it can be used again. Recycling turns
materials that would normally be turned to waste into valuable resources. In addition,
“3 Rs” Concept is buying products that are less toxic for instance polystyrene
container or contain less packaging, using reusable containers and other reusable
7
Source Reduction
Reuse
Landfill
(a) Toxicity
Wastes that produce injury upon contact with or accumulate in man and other
organisms which includes mutagens, teratogens, carcinogens, and bioaccumulation
for instance cleaning products, chemical fertilizers, pesticides, etc.
(b) Reactivity
(c) Corrosiveness
(d) Flammability
Wastes that pose a fire hazard for instance petroleum products, paper.
(e) Radioactivity
(f) Infectious
Having discussed some of those things which make wastes hazardous, it is the
potential for toxicity, particularly to humans, which has caused the greatest public
concern. Toxic effects can range from mild allergic reactions to death through three
main exposure routes; inhalation entry via the respiratory tract; ingestion entry via
the gastrointestinal tract; and dermal contact entry via the skin. The following list in
Table 2.1 is not complete, but indicates various types of scheduled waste.
The trend of scheduled wastes generation shows that, the amount is adequate
for recovery. In 2006, 122 scheduled waste recyclers were licensed by the
11
Neverheless, a total of 609 licences were issued for both existing and new
facilities for off-site recovery, off-site storage-transportation, scheduled wastes
incinerators, land treatment, off-site treatment and secured landfills.This data shows
that a significant amount of scheduled wastes have been recovered, with many types
of these wastes being traded in local and international market.
There are various types of scheduled waste specifically in Malaysia that could
be recycled, reused or recovered. Rags and filters for example, are used to clean a
variety of contaminated substances such as mixed solvent, organic-based oil, paint,
dye and grease, ink in printing and electronic industries that produce PCB, IC and
parts as well as other industry including adhesive industries and factories using paint
and ink products are categorized as scheduled waste.
12
700
0 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Year
Figure 2.2: Scheduled waste generation Malaysia 1994 – 2005 (DOE, 1995;
2003; 2006).
A spent material is any material that has been used and as a result of
contamination can no longer serve the purpose for which it was produced without
processing. Spent material may be recycled for reuse either at the facility or off-site
of the generating facility. Spent solvent and spent coolant are some common type of
scheduled waste generated by a variety of industries in Malaysia and have great value
added after recycled or recovered.
Spent or discarded paints from paint product could be recovered and reused
for the production of lower quality paints where color control is not required.
Nevertheless, used industrial containers including high-density polyethylene (HDPE)
drums, intermediate bulk container (IBC), steel drums, tin, carboy and jerry can
could be reused after the process of re-conditioned. A lower quality paints produced
from spent or discarded paints would be used for re-conditioned industrial containers
painting.
The types of waste oil normally recovered are spent lubricating oil, hydraulic
oil, cutting oil, oily residue from automotive workshop, service station, oil or grease
13
interceptor, etc. Besides, oil could also be recovered from oil and water mixture of
ship industries. These types of wastes have potential adverse impact to the
environment through indiscriminate handling, storage, usage and disposal activities.
Aluminium, solder dross, brass dross and waste from electrical and electronic
assemblies’ have a potential for recovery and recycling activities. Figure 2.3 shows
types of scheduled wastes that could be recycled or recovered. Due to market need,
the recovered dust, slag, dross, ash and waste catalysts containing metal collected
from industries are known to be profitable business.
A B C
Under the stated regulations, a waste generator may store scheduled wastes
generated by him for 180 days or less after its generation provided that the quantity
of scheduled wastes accumulated on site shall not exceed 20 metric tones. However,
waste generators may apply to the Director General of the Department of
Environment in writing to store more than 20 metric tones of scheduled wastes. The
containers that are used to store scheduled wastes shall be clearly labeled with the
18
date when the scheduled wastes are first generated and name, address and telephone
number of the waste generator.
The regulations also stated that land farming, incineration, disposal and off-
site facilities for recovery, storage and treatment can only be carried out at prescribed
premises licensed by the Department of Environment. However, with the signing of
the concession agreement between the Government of Malaysia and Kualiti Alam
Sdn. Bhd on 18 December 1995 (15 years concession period), all off-site treatment
and disposal (incineration, wastewater treatment, storage and secure landfill) of
scheduled wastes is not allowed.
years or both together (EQA 1974). Figure 2.5 illustrates an overview of the
scheduled waste management in Malaysia.
The Basel Convention was the only global legal instrument dealing with the
sound management of hazardous wastes, their disposal and transboundary movement.
It had achieved remarkable success in establishing a ban on the transboundary
movement of hazardous wastes from developed to developing countries.
During its first Decade (1989-1999), the Convention was principally devoted to
setting up a framework for controlling the “transboundary” movements of hazardous
wastes from developed to developing countries.
During its first Decade (1989-1999), the Convention was principally devoted
to setting up a framework for controlling the “transboundary” movements of
hazardous wastes, that is, the movement of hazardous wastes across international
frontiers. It also developed the criteria for “environmentally sound management”. A
Control System, based on prior written notification, was also put into place.
Malaysia has signed up for Basel Convention on the 8th October 1993. The
fourth meeting of the Conference of the Parties to the Basel Convention on the
Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal was
opened in Kuching on 23 February 1998. The President of the third meeting of the
Conference of the Parties, Mr. Bakary Kante from Senegal officiated the meeting
20
(Report Of The Fourth Meeting Of The Conference Of The Parties To The Basel
Convention, 1998)
During Basel Convention 2002, it was reported that Malaysia and other
signatory countries restricts the export of hazardous wastes and other wastes for final
disposal and restricts the import of hazardous wastes and other wastes for recovery as
well. The Malaysian Government through the funding agencies provided special
capital allowance incentive to companies which generate wastes and intend to set up
facilities to treat their own wastes covering all capital expenditure incurred. The
Government also encourages industries to use locally produced wastes as raw
materials (Malaysia Country Fact Sheet, 2006).
Waste Prescribed
Transporter Premises
License, Section 18
License, Section 18, Act
127
2.7 Conclusion
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The approach of the present research includes a literature review and making
comparison and evaluation on the recovery and recycling processes done by the
scheduled waste recyclers in Malaysia Informations were collected from the
Department of Environment at Johor Bahru, Putrajaya and Ipoh. Informations
gathered for the study are;
Site visit to few scheduled waste recovery factories was conducted in 2009.
The purpose of the visit was to observe scheduled wastes recovery and recycling
processes done in the premise.
A common process for recovery and recycling selected scheduled waste has
been developed for the study. The selected scheduled wastes are:
Through reviewing the literature and personnel interview, it was found out
that 41 types of scheduled wastes listed in the Environmental Quality (Scheduled
Wastes) Regulations, 2005, First Schedule are found being recovered or recycled as
listed in Table 3.1.
4.1 Introduction
Currently, there are two such facilities have been licensed for treatment and
disposal of scheduled wastes, one in Negeri Sembilan and the other in Sarawak. As
for the study, a common process for recovery and recycling of selected scheduled
waste has been developed and the residual sludge will be disposed at the prescribed
premise such as Kualiti Alam Sdn Bhd.
27
Scheduled waste categorized under group SW 104 are dust, slag, dross or ash
containing aluminium, arsenic, mercury, lead, cadmium, chromium, nickel, copper,
vanadium, beryllium, antimony, tellurium, thallium or selenium.
Durinck, et.al, (2008) stated that slags are an indispensable tool for the
pyrometallurgical industry to extract and purify metals. Slag represents undesired
impurities in the metals being smelted, which float to the top during the smelting
process. While metals start to oxidize as they are smelted, slag forms a protective
crust of oxides on the top of the metal and protects the liquid metal underneath.
When the metal is smelted to satisfaction, the slag is skimmed from the top and
disposed of in a slag heap to age. Aging slag is an important part of the process, as it
needs to be exposed to the weather and allowed to break down slightly before it can
be used.
melting of low melting point of metals or alloys such as tin, lead, zinc or aluminium,
or by oxidation of the metals. Due to impurities such as metal oxides, dross is also
refers to the lead oxides, copper, antimony, and other elements that float to the top of
the molten lead. It can easily be skimmed off the surface before pouring the metal
into a mold or casting flask into ingot.
Based on the study, solder dross and aluminium dross are the most metal and
metal-bearing wastes being recycled and recovered in Malaysia. Due to the second
source of supply for raw materials, scraps are also an important indicator for the
sustainability of alloy and aluminium. As cited by Ahmad Fariz et.al., (2008) metal
engineering includes solder and aluminium dross recycling and recovery is the third
types of industrial scheduled wastes recovered by the recyclers.in Malaysia.
Dross product is not entirely waste material; aluminum dross, for example, is
used in secondary steelmaking for slag deoxidation, reducing processing costs by
minimizing use of pure aluminum. Dross recycling is very attractive from both the
energy and the economic standpoints.
Solder dross alloy composition normally containing tin, silver and copper, or
antimony or bismuth with the ratio either tin (96.3%) : silver (3.2%) : copper (0.5%),
or tin (96.5%) : silver (3.5%), or tin (90%) : bismuth (5%) : silver (5%), or tin
(95%) : antimony (5%) (DOE, 2008).
The sources of wastes are mainly from the metal manufacturing industries.
Raw material must meet the acceptance criteria prior recycling and recovery as
categorized in Table 4.1.
29
Table 4.1: Solder and aluminium dross waste acceptance criteria (DOE, 2008).
Molten dross will then undergo refining process where non-purified brass will
be re-introduced into the smelting cycle repeatedly until the desired dross
composition is achieved. Purified molten dross will then be casted into ingots and
lastly being packaged for commercial use.
The by-products of the recovery cycle will be slag, dust and fume (DOE,
2008). Slag containing high amount of impurities which are no longer usable will be
collected and sent to Kualiti Alam for safe disposal. Dust and fume generated during
the smelting process will then be collected by a series of cyclone dust filtered and
only clean air will be permitted to be released into the atmosphere. The collected dust
will also be sent to Kualiti Alam for safe disposal.
The collected residue from the furnace that contained different types of waste
may be classified as scheduled wastes under the Environmental Quality (Scheduled
Wastes) Regulations, 2005, and require proper disposal. Figure 4.1, Figure 4.2 and
30
Figure 4.3 show ingots, furnace, and dross respectively while the process flow
diagram for solder dross recovery is shown in Figure 4.4.
RAW MATERIAL
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
Yes
STORE
Fuel SORTING
Clean air
SMELTING / FURNACE
at 8000C DUST
(100%) COLLECTION
Dispose at Kualiti
CASTING Alam
PACKAGING
METAL INGOTS
(99.9 %)
Figure 4.4: Typical process flow diagram and material balance for solder and aluminium
dross recovery
32
Table 4.2 and Figure 4.4 represent the estimated value of material balance
across the maximum solder and aluminium dross recovery production process.
Depends on the plant capacity, from 100% of raw material collected, about 0.001%
will be the slag containing high amount of impurities which are no longer usable,
0.001% residue and 0.098% dross containing metal oxide which can be recovered.
Throughout the recovery process, it is estimated to recover about 99.9% of metal
ingots if the plant is operated at its maximum capacity.
Table 4.2: Material balance for solder and aluminium dross recovery
Mori and McElroy (1996) have written that numerous metals are utilized as
catalysts. Major catalyst deactivation metals are nickel, vanadium, iron and arsenic,
whereas catalyst used in synthetic fuels have been identified as cobalt, molybdenum,
iron, nickel, chromium, and tungsten.
Regardless of how catalysts are used, or whether they take the form of
monolithic structures, pellets, beads, extradates or solution, most companies
especially in the electronic and chemical process industries depend on precious
metals refiners to recover the valuable metals from their spent catalysts (Robert,
2005)
In economic point of view, waste catalyst recovery is not only profit making
business, but reinventing the use of materials is pollution abatement technology, as
electrical and electronics industries is the first types of industrial scheduled wastes
recovered by the recyclers .in Malaysia (Ahmad Fariz et.al., 2008). Moreover, these
catalysts contain environmentally critical and economically valuable metals such as
gold, silver and palladium.
are present in the wastes. This is important for the determination of the waste
composition and quantity of chemicals to be added in the reaction process.
The sources of wastes are mainly from the metal manufacturing and
electrolysis industries. Raw material must meet the acceptance criteria prior recycling
and recovery as categorized in Table 4.3.
There will be two processes involved in the gold recovery, namely direct ion
exchange and acid treatment. The ion exchange process is designed to recover gold
in spent solution while the latter is for recovery of gold entrapped in the deposited
activated carbon (DOE, 2008).
The direct ion exchange gold recovery is a simple process with the use of
synthetic resins (equation 4.1). The waste catalyst containing gold will be directly
pumped into the resin column to undergo ion exchange process. The gold will be
"exchanged" and retained on the resin. The spent solution from the resin column will
be directed to waste treatment plant for further treatment.
The regeneration of the resin by the use of hydrochloride acid is the next step
to precipitate the gold from the resin and dissolved it into aqueous gold monochloride
(equation 4.2)
AuR + 2HCI -> AuCl + HR (4.2)
35
The aqueous gold is then reduced into the metal form by addition of
hydrazine in the drum. Gold ingots are obtained after further refining in the furnace.
(equation 4.3) The process flow diagram of ion-exchange gold recovery process is
shown in Figure 4.5.
Diluted nitric and hydrochloride acids will be added into the spent waste
catalyst solution in the case of recovery gold using acid treatment method (equation
4.4). The mixing process uses a stirrer. Gold monochloride in aqueous form will be
produced after solution is left to stand for a day.
Before proceeding to the reduction process, the solution will be filtered using
fine nylon or steel mesh (depending on the nature of waste) to remove all the non-
metallic impurities, for instances, unburned carbon. The filtration is carried out by
transferring the solution into another drum fitted with mesh. After soaking for a few
hours, hydrazine will be added to reduce the aqueous gold into metal form followed
by the addition of polymer. The end product of gold ingot is obtained after refining in
the furnace (equation 4.5). The process flow diagram of acid treatment gold recovery
process from deposited carbon is shown in Figure 4.6.
Silver recovery process is specifically designed for the waste materials that
contain silver. There are two types of waste that are subjected to this recovery
36
RAW MATERIAL
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
Yes
HCl GOLD
regenerant AQUEOUS
REFINING
CASTING
PACKAGING
METAL INGOTS
(30 %)
Figure 4.5: Typical gold recovery process flow and material balance
by ion exchange
37
process, namely ashes from rags contaminated with silver and silver sludge (DOE,
2008).
Waste material is transferred into the drum and diluted with nitric acid using a
hand pump. The acid acts to dissolve the silver and to form silver nitrate. Non-
metallic impurities such as epoxy and ceramic are separated from the aqueous silver
solution by manually transferring the mixture into another drum with pump and filter
mesh. The impurities will be sprayed with water to wash out any residual silver from
the impurities. The resulting non-metallic impurities are non-toxic materials and will
be discarded as normal solid waste. The chemical reaction between silver and nitric
acid is shown in equation (4.6).
The silver nitrate solution will be added with sodium chloride aided with
polymer to obtain aqueous silver chloride. Mixing is achieved using a stirrer.
Assisted with agitation, the sediment layer containing silver chloride will be mixed
with hydrazine and water to precipitate out the silver. Silver in semi-solid form will
be transferred to the furnace for refining. The upper layer that contains spent acids
will be pumped to the wastewater treatment plant for treatment. The process flow
diagram of silver recovery from wastes is shown in Figure 4.7. The chemical
reactions are as in equation (4.7) and (4.8).
RAW MATERIAL
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
HNO3 Yes
H2O
SPENT SOLUTION OF
GOLD (100%)
GOLD NITRATE
AQUEOUS
Polymer
NON METALLIC OF
IMPURITIES OF GOLD
NITRATE AQUEOUS
GOLD IN SEMI-
SOLID FORM
Wastewater
treatment plant
REFINING (70%)
CASTING
PACKAGING
METAL INGOTS
(30 %)
RAW MATERIAL
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
Yes
HNO3
H2O SILVER ASH /
SLUDGE (100%)
SILVER NITRATE
AQUEOUS
NACL
NON METALLIC OF
Polymer
IMPURITIES OF SILVER
NITRATE AQUEOUS
SILVER IN SEMI-
SOLID FORM
REFINING
CASTING
Figure 4.7: Typical silver recovery process flow and material balance by acid
treatment
40
The regeneration of resin by the use of ammonium solution is the next step to release
palladium from the resin and dissolved it into aqueous palladium. The reactions
taking place are as in equation (4.9) and (4.10).
The aqueous palladium is then reduced to its solid form by the addition of
hydrazine in the drum as in equation (4.11). The palladium end product is cast into
ingots in the furnace. The process flow diagram of the palladium recovery from
wastes is shown in Figure 4.8.
Table 4.4, Figure 4.6, Figure 4.7 and Figure 4.8 represent the estimated value
of material balance across the maximum waste catalyst recovery production process.
Depends on the plant capacity, from 100% of raw material collected, about 30% will
be the metal ingots. Throughout the recovery process, it is estimated to produce about
70% will be the wastewater which need proper treatment if the plant is operated at
its maximum capacity.
RAW MATERIAL
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
Yes
NH+ PALLADIUM IN
regenerant RESIN / SPENT
SOLUTION (100%)
PALLADIUM
SOLUTION
PALLADIUM IN
SEMI-SOLID FORM
REFINING
CASTING
Figure 4.8: Typical palladium recovery process flow and material balance
42
There are nine types of scheduled waste containing oil listed in the
Environmental Quality (Scheduled Wastes) Regulations 2005 First Schedule have a
common recovery process
Waste oils are petroleum or synthetic oils that have been previously used for
lubricating, heating, corrosion protecting or other purposes and no longer meet the
requirements of these applications due to the loss of original properties and presence
of contaminants or impurities. Wherever possible, every effort should be made to
encourage the resource recovery such as re-refining, re-conditioning and re-
processing of used oils, particularly since virgin petroleum oil is a non-renewable
fossil fuel resource that is in high global demand.
Almost all of the manufacturing activities use oil products such as lubricating
oil, heat transfer oil, fuel, hydraulic oil, gear oils used in cars or bikes, etc. The used
oil can pollute the environment if it is not disposed of properly despite it has high
energy value and can be used as fuel for a lot of industries. Waste oil poured directly
onto the ground or into storm drains, or tossed into trash cans even in a sealed
container can contaminate and pollute the soil and all water bodies such as
groundwater, rivers and streams.
Oil and associated contaminants floating on the groundwater beneath the site
are a continuing source of water bodies’ contamination either ground or surface
water. Removing the oil will keep the floating contamination from moving off the
site and will reduce the chances of water pollution that the public will be exposed.
This action will accelerate the overall site cleanup by removing a known source of
ongoing groundwater contamination; however, it does not constitute the complete
and final cleanup plan for the site.There are some general facts about used oils as
revealed by Vander Pol, (2006):
43
There is a promising market for Refined Fuel Oil (RFO) both locally and
internationally. In Malaysia, the demand for recycled oil is continuing to escalate as
the oil production is expected to reduce 3.98% between 2008 and 2018 and oil
consumption is set to increase by 16.45% as reported in The Malaysian Oil Report
(2009).
The types of waste oil normally recovered are spent lubricating oil, hydraulic
oil, cutting oil, oily residue from automotive workshop, service station, oil or grease
interceptor, etc. There are some potential land-based and water-based sources of used
oils generated for recovery as listed in Table 4.5.
accept oily wastes that meet or fall within a certain acceptable range to ensure
compatibility with the waste processing systems employed.
Table 4.5: Potential land-based and water-based sources of used oils recovery
(VanderPol, 2006)
The classical and most feasible solution to the waste oil recovery is
distillation, evaporation or pyrolysis (DOE, 2008). Most of the commonly waste oil
has boiling points no higher than 200oC. Hence the oil can be separated from the
45
dissolved substances which normally have much higher boiling point by distillation.
The process requires minimal manual operation and the process is done is batches.
There is no chemical reaction involves but physical separation. The process is
selected due to the operational stability and easiness of maintenance of the system.
As oil is inflammable which pose fire hazard to the surrounding, close monitoring
and proper safety procedures are necessary to ensure safety.
The waste oil will normally undergo two stages of the process i.e. separation
and recovery process. During separation process, the waste oil collected need to
undergo physical separation process for large suspended solid removal before
46
transferred for the recovery process. Waste oil which contain water but immiscible
with water will be pumped to a decanter where the water separated will be discarded
as scheduled waste (DOE, 2008).
The outflow from the desorber will be enter the oil water separator tank
where water or moisture will be stripped and the water by virtue of density difference
settles down at the bottom of tank while the oil is removed from the unit via the
outlet located at the top of the equipment. Water accumulated at the bottom of the
tank is periodically removed through the opening of the water drain at the bottom.
Pneumatic pump will be used to transfer oils from one container to another. Since the
pump is driven by high pressure air from air compressor, it is spark and explosive
proof. All containers will be covered during transferring process to minimize fugitive
vapor. The water will be directed to the oil interceptor before being disposed to
nearby wastewater treatment plant. The captured oil will then be directed back to the
collection tank for reprocessing. The sludge will be extracted out to be dried,
thickened and disposed.
The oil is then being directed through a couple of stainless steel wire mesh
bag filters to eliminate unwanted suspended solids with the help of a pressure pump.
The stainless steel wire cloth bag filters remove any type of suspended solids ranging
from 2 to 50 micron and the filter media is washable for reuse.
47
The waste oil recovery process could be carried out through distillation,
evaporation or pyrolysis method for recovery process. The detail of the process are as
the following:
(a) Distillation
As for distillation method, the clean oil is fed into the vacuum dehydration
system to remove access water (below 50% of oil saturation point), dissolved gasses
and cracked oil (DOE, 2008)
Then the oil would be to channel the outflow from the dehydration system to
the membrane separator where the oil will pass through an electric field to remove
oxidation products where positively charged particles are drawn to the negative pole
and vice versa. The schematic flow diagram is given in Figure 4.9.
(b) Evaporation
The vacuum evaporator evaporates unwanted vapor in oil. To purify the oil,
the metal jacket will be heated at 140oC below atmospheric pressure to eliminate
water vapor in the oil with the application of venture vacuum pump. The heated
vaporous will then be condensed into droplets when passing through a condenser.
The condensed water will then be passed through the oil interceptor before
being discharged. The purified oil will then be channeled and stored into the product
tank for further use or sell. The typical flow of the evaporation process is shown in
Figure 4.10.
48
WASTE OIL
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
Yes
COLLECTION TANK
(100%)
DESORBER
SS BAG FILTERS
DISTILLATION
SLUDGE SYSTEM
OUT
(3%) OIL
INTERCEPTOR
MEMBRANE SEPARATION
Dispose at
Kualiti
Alam Wastewater
treatment
RECOVERD OIL plant
( 97%)
Figure 4.9: Typical process flow and material balance across the oil recovery
distillation process
49
WASTE OIL
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
Yes
CONDENSER
Dispose
at Kualiti
Alam
RECOVERED OIL
(95%)
Figure 4.10: The typical flow and material balance of the evaporation process
50
(c) Pyrolysis
Pyrolysis is another alternative method for waste oil recovery. The waste oil
collected need to undergo physical separation process, before transferring to the
pyrolysis process. Pyrolysis will involve heating process where the water content will
be removed from waste oil by heating up the oil at 400 - 600oC in an oxygen-free
atmosphere. At such high temperature, most organic substances are decomposed by
thermal cracking into gaseous, liquid, and solid (DOE, 2008). Pyrolysis is the term
used to describe the process of this conversion. The term destructive distillation is
often used as an alternative term for pyrolysis.
Waste oil containing recoverable oil will be injected into the pyrolysis reactor
at atmospheric condition, which later will be heated up to 600°C. During the
pyrolysis process, about 97% of oil, gas and water vapour will be recovered. All
substances will be directed into a cyclone separator to completely separate liquids
from solids.
The volatile gases will pass through condensers which most of the organic
contents will be condensed into liquid phase as light oils. The uncondensed gases
will then be recycled as fuel to heat up the pyrolysis reactor. The final product of
waste oil pyrolysis process contains high energy value, acts as replacement for fuel
oils or diesel which can be used as burner fuels for boilers, generators and other
energy requirement applications. The typical flow of waste oil pyrolysis recovery
process is given in Figure 4.1, while Figure 4.12 is the schematic diagram of
pyrolysis system. Any residual released gas which is estimated 2% will be trap by the
wet scrubber.
WASTE OIL
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
Yes
HEATER
at 400 – 6000C
(100%)
Air
scrubber PYROLYSIS REACTOR
(2%) (98%)
CONDENSER
Dispose at
Kualiti RECOVERED OIL
Alam (97%)
Figure 4.11: The typical flow and material balance of waste oil pyrolysis recovery
process
52
WET Wastewater
SCRUBBER Treatment Plant
Gas to purification
(gas release to
scrubber)
PYROLISIS
WASTE REACTOR
OIL Heat
Exchang
CONDENSING
TOWER
HEATING
Char
UNIT
(Coke)
Heavy Light
Oil Oil
Figure 4.9, Figure 4.10, Figure 4.11 and Table 4.7, represent the material
balance across the maximum oil recovery production process. Depends on the plant
capacity, from 100% of waste oil collected, it is estimated to recover total 97% of
recovered oil in distillation process, 95% of recovered oil in evaporation process and
97% in pyrolysis recovery system. The residual sludge that need to be proper
disposed is estimated to be 3% in distillation process, 5% in evaporation process and
1% in pyrolysis process.
53
Large quantities of waste water and oils mixture are continuously generated
by ship activities to provide stability and maneuverability during a voyage. The oil
and water mixture generated from these sources predominately those recovered from
ballast water. These oils are composed primarily of the fuel used by particular ship.
Steel drums or skid tank will be used to store the oil and water mixture. They are
tough for handling, transportation and storage. Incoming oil water mixture varies
depend on the type of ship.
In general, the oil and water mixture will undergo two stages of the recovery
process i.e. separation and recovery as mentioned above. In spite of the salinity
presence in ballast water, the recovery process should be done separately from other
waste oil materials if the above processes (distillation, evaporation or pyrolysis)
needs to be applied.
One other alternative for oil and water recovery is through centrifuge system.
The oil and water mixture collected need to undergo separation process by means of
gravitation separation in the skid tank. By leaving the oil in the skid tank undisturbed
for enough time (normally 2 days), they will eventually settle at the tank bottom and
can be easily removed. Then the oil will undergo the centrifuge system
(hydrocyclones) at high pressure producing a rotor jet speed of 4,000 to 8,000 rpm
for further separation in order to get better impurities removal (DOE, 2008).
Debris and dirt will be pushed against the side inner wall of the rotor bowl
while the clean oil is fed into the product storage tank. When sufficient time is not
available, the centrifuge separation process may be accelerated by heating the oil to
some safe temperature (with a steam coil heater to 90oC). Most of solids and sludge
generated from centrifuge system are collected in the sludge holding bin, prior
disposed at Kualiti Alam Sdn Bhd. The centrifuge system for oil and water mixture
recovery process as well as the material balance is shown in Figure 4.15 and Table
4.8.
55
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
Yes
RAW MATERIAL
(100%)
SEPARATION
(95%)
WATER
(5%) HEATER
at 90oC
(90%)
Wastewater
treatment SUSPENDED
SOLID
plant
(10%)
CENTRIFUGE Dispose at
SYSTEM Kualiti Alam
(80%)
RECOVERED
OIL
(80%)
Figure 4.15: The typical flow of oil and water mixture centrifuge
system recovery process
56
Table 4.8: Material balance for oil and water mixture or ballast water recovery
Table 4.9: Standard and specification of recovered waste oil (DOE, 2009)
Parameters / Constituents Allowable Level
There are various sources of coolant which can be collected from industries
and such as:
There are four types of contaminants that need treatment in waste coolant
(DOE, 2008). The first contaminant is tramp oil which consist of free-floating oil,
unstable oil coolant emulsion and microscopic oil particles. The second contaminant
is suspended solids which exist in the form of particles from machine operation can
58
be present in the coolant, inhibiting heat transfer efficiency of the coolant. Thirdly,
bacteria from water multiplies in warm conditions of the machine tool coolant sump.
Finally the level of dissolved solids present in all water resources will contaminate
coolant as dissolved solids reaches its threshold.
Table 4.10: Waste coolant acceptance criteria for recovery (DOE, 2008)
The coolant recovery system is devided into tramp oil removal, suspended
solids removal and bacterial disinfections (DOE, 2008). Waste coolant from waste
generators will be stored temporarily at the collection tank. A series of wire mesh
particle filters (100 mesh, 150 mesh and 200 mesh) will be used consecutively to
screen out various size particles to prevent clogging from build up at only 1 filter.
With this design the frequency of filter cleaning is reduced. At this stage the feed is
still contaminated with oil, fine particles passing 200 mesh filter and dissolved solids.
Next, the contaminated feed will be fed into the Desorber to remove free-
floating oil and oil coolant unstable emulsion completely (DOE, 2007). Due to the
density difference between settleability solids, coolant and oil under the gravity
effect, solids and coolant will settle below the top later of oil. A valve will be
installed at the bottom part of the Desorber to discharge the solids as well as coolant
for further recovery processes. The oil mixed coolant will be directed to the oil
interceptor before being directed back to the temporary collection tank for
reprocessing. The sludge will be extracted out to be dried, thickened and disposed.
The coolant is then being directed through a couple of stainless steel wire
mesh bag filters to eliminate unwanted suspended solids ranging from 2 to 25 micron
with the help of a pressure pump. The stainless steel wire cloth bag filters is
washable for reuse. The sludge will be removed for thickening and disposal.
After the removal of tramp oil and machine solids, coolant will be passed
through the disinfecting unit where it will be exposed to high strength UV light. The
wavelength of 253nm is lethal enough to destroy bacteria thus disinfects the coolant.
Coolant being opaque is thinned down into a fine sheet of paper before subjecting to
UV treatment. UV reflector bulbs are positioned inside the disinfection unit for
maximum destruction rate and area usage. Figure 4.16 shows the process flow and
material balance across the maximum coolant recovery.
60
WASTE COOLANT
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
YES
COLLECTION TANK
(100%)
DESORBER OIL
SLUDGE INTERCEPTOR
OUT
(19%)%)
SS BAG FILTER
Dispose at
Kualiti OIL
Alam PARTICLES
BACTERIAL DISINFECTION UNIT OUT
(1%)
RECOVERED COOLANT
(80% )
Figure 4.16: Typical process flow and material balance across the coolant recovery
61
Table 4.11 and Figure 4.16 represents the material balance across the
maximum coolant recovery production process. Depends on the plant capacity, from
100% of waste oil collected, it is estimated to recover about 80% of treated coolant
and generate about 15% of residual sludge material and 1% is estimated to be oil
particle if the plant is operated at its maximum capacity.
Solvents have many diverse uses from paints and coatings, personal care
products and pharmaceuticals to pesticides, cleaners and inks. Thousands of
producers and manufacturers, and millions of workers, rely on solvents every day to
provide solutions to new manufacturing needs and to sustain excellence in functional
performance.
A solvent is a liquid that has the ability to dissolve, suspend, or extract other
materials without causing a chemical change to the material or solvent. Solvents
62
There are various types of solvent which can be collected from industries.
Table 4.12 lists down the examples of solvents to be recovered..The used solvents
can be recovered by distillation or evaporation to separate the more volatile materials
from less volatile materials by a process of vaporisation and condensation.
Considerably, the most numerous industrial applications of evaporation have been for
purification in chemical manufacturing and in processes involving solvent recycling
as well.
The solvents recovered have purity greater than 95%, varied from times to
times depends on the nature of the spent solvents (DOE, 2007). To purify spent
solvents which contain single solvent is simple. Whereas to separate mixed solvents
like thinner requires more tedious process like longer condensing columns and longer
evaporation time. The solvents that used in plating process may contain oil and
grease that needs to be removed as this contributes to inefficient in plating process.
factories, ink industry from ink manufacturer and printing companies and other
industry including adhesive industries and factories using paint and ink products.
Upon receiving, the waste will be analysed to reconfirm their characteristic based on
the information furnished by the spent solvent waste generators. The waste spent
solvent must meet the acceptance criteria prior recycling as categorized in Table
4.13.
Table 4.12: Boiling point, density and TLV of some common solvents base on
Material Safety Data Sheet
The solvent is then being directed through a couple of stainless steel wire
mesh bag filters to eliminate unwanted suspended solids ranging from 1 to 25 micron
with the help of a pressure pump. The stainless steel wire cloth bag filters is
washable for reuse. The sludge will be removed for thickening and disposal.
Figure 4.17 and Table 4.14 represent the material balance across the
maximum solvent separation and evaporation recovery production process. Depends
on the plant capacity, from 100% of waste oil collected, about 0.02% will be the
settable solid. Throughout the recovery process, it is estimated to recover about 83%
of treated coolant and generate about 2.0% of residual sludge material and 15.0% is
estimated to be oily wastewater if the plant is operated at its maximum capacity.
66
WASTE SOLVENT
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
Yes
COLLECTION TANK
(100%)
DESORBER
(83%)
SS BAG FILTER
Dispose at
Kualiti Alam
VACUUM EVAPORATION
CHAMBER
Wastewater
treatment
plant
(15%)
CONDENSER Air
SCRUBBER
(1%)
RECOVERED SOLVENT
(82%)
Figure 4.17: The typical flow diagram of solvent separation and evaporation
recovery process
67
Steel containers and tin have been used for a long time as a means of storing
or transporting a variety of materials including resins, paints and some viscous
organic chemical. These containers are built to withstand the exigencies of transit.
Moreover, steel drums are typically made of a heavy gauge metal and are relatively
expensive
Carboy
A B
C D
high pressure water. In addition, jumbo bags made of woven poly propylene
normally used to contain dust or granule in some industries can also be recovered.
Many types of containers are being used in industries for chemical storage
such as high-density polyethylene (HDPE) drums, intermediate bulk container (IBC),
steel drums, tin, carboy and jerry can (DOE, 2007). Containers tainted with
contaminants such as used or spent chemicals are considered as scheduled waste.
These containers should be recovered properly to ensure the materials will have no
unreasonable adverse effect on the environment, people handling the containers or
users of the end-use products manufactured.
The process flow starts from the collection of containers as classified under
SW409 of the Environmental Quality (Scheduled Wastes) Regulations 2005. The
incoming containers are first segregated and classified based on the type of
containers and the liquid raw materials that were transported in them and the cleaning
techniques needed to be employed. These containers are further classified as mainly
containing solvents, acid and alkaline.
Each container is inverted and drained off its contents. Due to the viscous
nature of the above compounds, the duration of the draining time will vary and may
range between 2 to 6 hours (DOE, 2007). The containers containing solvent soluble
residue will be sent for solvent recovery. Then they will be loaded onto a solvent
washing machine, where the inside of the containers are mechanically sprayed with
recycled solvent to wash off heavy solids, grease, paint, ink, oil and solvent. The
containers containing acid and alkaline will go through drip drying process.
Then the containers will go through the first stage rinsing process using city
water and cleaning agent. The second stage rinsing process is to remove excess
washing agent from the containers and to ensure the containers are clean. Liquid
residue will be treated in the wastewater treatment plant and the collected residual
sludge will be sent for disposal at the Kualiti Khidmat Alam.
pressure leak test will be conducted to check the containers for leakage as well as
reconditioned the containers to prevent contamination of materials from one cargo to
the next and to ensure integrity of the containers.
CONTAMINATED CONTAINERS
Contaminated waste
solvent Contaminated waste acid / alkaline
NEUTRALIZATION
2nd . STAGE
WATER Sludge
WASTEWATER to
RINSING TREAMENT
PROCESS Kualiti
Alam
Table 4.16 represents the material balance across the maximum containers
recovery production process depends on the plant capacity, from 100% of
contaminated containers collected, all of the containers can be recovered consider
they are in good condition for recovery. Relative to the total weight of contaminated
containers collected, 2% is estimated to be discharge as residual sludge material.
100% 2% 98%
Rags (also called wipes, wipers, and shop towels); filters and absorbent
materials (such as mats, socks, and loose material such as speedy-dry) are use to
clean a variety of contaminated substances. Besides widely use to clean mixed
solvent, organic-based oil, paint, dye and grease; rags or filters and are also use to
clean ink in printing and electronic industries that produce PCB, IC and parts as well
as other industry including adhesive industries and factories using paint and ink
products. Specifically, filters are cotton construction used mainly for particulate and
organic waste removal to protect sensitive machines.
74
The contaminated rags or filters become solid wastes when they are too dirty
and not suitable for cleaning purpose anymore. Hence, they are subjected to a
hazardous waste determination under Environmental Quality (Scheduled Wastes)
Regulations, 2005 (DOE, 2007). The contaminated rags or filters must be carefully
managed to prevent or reduce the risk to human health and the environment.
Subsequently, the contaminated rags or filters are valuable and could be recovered
for reuse. The recycled rags or filters could be sold back to some waste generators
especially for cleaning purpose at a discount price. The recycled materials could also
be sold to traders or manufacturers or industries including printing and electronic due
to high quality of recycled material.
The most efficient way of separating contaminants from used rags or filters is
by washing and rinsing either with solvent or water. Normally the recovered rags or
filters recovered have purity greater than 95%, varied from times to times depends on
the efficiency during washing and rinsing (DOE, 2007). To purify the used rags or
filters contaminated with acid or alkaline is simple that is through washing and
rinsing with water. Whereas to separate mixed solvents, organic-based oil, paint, dye
and grease requires more tedious process like washing using solvent followed with
detergent and water.
The sources of wastes are mainly from the printing and electronic industries.
Waste collected must meet the acceptance criteria prior recycling as categorized in
Table 4.17.
75
Table 4.17: Used rags and filters acceptance criteria (DOE, 2007)
Wastes materials Waste Acceptance Criteria1
Waste cotton rags filters and From waste contaminated with acid, solvent,
absorbent materials such as cotton of electronic, printing, plastic injection
mats, socks, and loose material moulding, packaging and machinery of
such as speedy-dry materials. industry.
Non toxic substances.
Good conditions and can be recycled and
reused
The semi dry rags or filters will be placed in a fiber trolley before them being
loaded into the industrial washing machine. A non-ionic surfactant degreasing
detergent, which produces minimal foam, will be used to soak and wash the rags or
filters.
After rinsing and drying in the industrial washing machine, the cleaned rags
or filters will be dried in a controlled temperature of 100 - 250 oC oven. (DOE,
2007). The wastewater from washing and drying processes will be sent to the
wastewater treatment plant and the collected residual sludge will be sent for disposal
at the Kualiti Khidmat Alam. Finally, the cleaned rags or filters will undergo sewing
and converted to the recycled rags or filters. Figure 4.22 shows the flow process of
contaminated rags and filters.
CONTAMINATED RAGS
OR FILTERS
Yes
No
WASTE ACCEPTANCE
CRITERIA
OK
SOAKING TANK
(100% Waste Materials) NOT OK
SOLVENT
OK
RECOVERY
PROCESS
CENTRIFUGAL DRYING
Waste
WASHING Solvent DRYING
Sludge to
Kualiti Alam
RINSING AND DRYING (9%)
OVEN DRY
Wastewater
CLEANED RAGS OR
FILTERS (90%)
Wastewater
treatment plant
(1%)
Figure 4.22: The typical flow process of contaminated rags or filters recycling
78
Table 4.18 and Figure 4.22 represent the material balance across the
maximum contaminated rags or filters recycling production processes. Depends on
the plant capacity, from 100% of contaminated rags or filters collected, about 90%
could be recycled. Throughout the recovery process, it is estimated about 9.00% of
residual sludge material will be disposed to Kualiti Alam Sdn. Bhd. and 1.00% of
wastewater must be properly treated in the plant.
100% 90 % 9% 1%
4.9 Conclusion
From the study, innovative recovery process flow is designed to satisfy all
regulatory requirements, to protect and enhance the value of physical assets as well
as corporate reputations. Hence, the invention of recovery and recycling processes is
an integral plan between technology, environment and economy, given the concept of
waste as a valuable resource and waste to wealth.
DISCUSSION OF RESULTS
Table 5.1: 41 Types of Scheduled Wastes Listed in the First Schedule Are Being
Recovered or Recycled (the recovered or recycled process flow are produced for the
bolded 16 types)
No. Code Type of waste No. of
Recyclers
SW1 - Metal and metal bearing wastes
1 SW102 Waste of lead acid batteries in whole or crushed form 4
2 SW104 Dust, slag, dross or ash containing aluminium, 18
arsenic, mercury, lead, cadmium, chromium,
nickel, copper, vanadium, beryllium, antimony,
tellurium, thallium or selenium excluding slag
from iron and steel factory
3 SW107 Slags from copper processing for further processing 1
or refining containing arsenic, lead or cadmium
4 SW108 Leaching residues from zinc processing in dust and 5
sludges form
80
From the study, innovative recovery process flow is designed to satisfy all
regulatory requirements, to protect and enhance the value of physical assets as well
as corporate reputations. Hence, the invention of recovery and recycling processes is
an integral plan between technology, environment and economy, given the concept of
waste as a valuable resource and waste to wealth.
CONCLUSION
5.1 Conclusion
The study has met the aim and objectives that have been setup earlier. Based
on the Environmental Quality (Scheduled Wastes) Regulations 2005 First Scheduled,
41 types of scheduled waste generated from 4 categories which are SW 1, SW 2, SW
3 and SW 4 are found have been recycled and recovered by recyclers in Malaysia.
By comparison, the Waste Acceptance Criteria have been identified from the
minimum level of acceptance prior to recovery and recycling processes and the
Material Balance calculation indicate the estimated percentage of treated or
recovered waste materials, residual sludge material generated and wastewater
discharged if the plant is operated at its maximum capacity.
80
5.2 Recommendations
In line with the concept of 4R (reduction, reuse, recycling and recovery) and
“from cradle to grave” waste management, a greener environmental solution, thereby
enabling the recycling industries to achieve 30% of total solid and scheduled waste
recycling in 2020 besides 5% currently (Utusan Malaysia, 2009). Hence, the
following recommendations should be carried out to improve the study:
(i) The general recovery and recycling process flow for another 61 types
or the most waste generated from the First Schedule Environmental
Quality (Scheduled Wastes) Regulations 2005 should be produced.
(ii) The costs associated with the price discovery for the technology which
give NPV (Net Present Value) could be another element that should be
enhanced in the study in order to give value added to the recycling
industry.
81
REFERENCES
Ahmad Fariz Mohamed, Mohd Raihan Taha, Shaharudin Idrus, Abdul Samad Hadi and
Abdul Hadi Harman Shah (2008). Title of Paper: Infrastructure for Sustainable
Industrial Wastes Recovery in Malaysia
A S Hornby , 1983. Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary of Current English, Oxford
University Press
Azni Idris, Bulent Inanc and Mohd Nasir Hasan, (2004). Overview of Waste Disposal
and Landfills/Dumps in Asian Countries. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste
Management. Volume 6, No.2, pp 104-110
Department of Environment (2007) Environmental Impact Assessment Guidance
Document for The Construction of Scheduled Waste Recovery Plant (Off-Site)
Putrajaya
Department of Environment Malaysia (DOE), (2007). Environmental Requirements:
A Guide For Investors. Putrajaya.
Department of Environment Malaysia (DOE), (1995). Malaysia Environmental Quality
Report 1994. Kuala Lumpur
Department of Environment Malaysia (DOE), (2003). Malaysia Environmental Quality
Report 2002. Putrajaya.
Department of Environment Malaysia (DOE), (2006). Malaysia Environmental Quality
Report 2005. Putrajaya.
Dirk Durinck, Fredrik Engström, Sander Arnout, Jeroen Heulens, Peter Tom Jones, Bo
Björkman, Bart Blanpain, Patrick Wollants, (2008). Resources, Conservation and
Recycling, Volume 52, Issue 10, Pages 1121-1131
82
Malaysia, (2008). Malaysian Economy In Figures 2008. Economic Planning Unit, Prime
Ministers
Michael VanderPol, (2006). Regional Strategy For The Environmentally Sound
Management Of Used Oils In The Caribbean Island States: Environment Canada,
National Office of Pollution Prevention
M.K. Carol Lee (2008). Non-Halogenated Solvent Dry Cleaning M.K. United States of
America
Mohd Najib Bin Tun Haji Abdul Razak, (2009). Pelancaran Dasar Teknologi Hijau
Negara dan Perasmian Bangunan Baru Pusat Tenaga Manusia. Bangi, Selangor
Naval School, Civil Engineer Corps Officers, (1997). Trainee Guide For Hazardous
Waste Generators Course. Port Hueneme, California
Report Of The Fourth Meeting Of The Conference Of The Parties To The Basel
Convention, (1998)
Scott Kidd, John S. Bowers (1995). Treatment of Mixed Waste Coolant. Lawrence
Livermore National Laboratory Hazardous Waste Management Division,
California
Secretariat Of The Basel Convention (March 2009). Report On The Review Of The
Implementation Of The Current Strategic Plan.
Shuji Mori and A. D. McElroy, (1996). Future Catalyst Metals Availability And
Assessment Of Waste Catalyst Reclamation, Midwest Research Institute, Kansas
City, Missouri, USA
The Star, (2003). RM 12 Million Disposal Costs Shock Selangor Exco, 4th December
2003
TF Market Research, (2009). Malaysia Oil and Gas Report Q3 2009, Malaysia:
Business
Utusan Malaysia, (2009). “Malaysia mahu capai 30 peratus kadar kitar semula”,
Waste Oil: Technology, Economics and Environment,(1987) Health and Safety
Considerations, US Department of Energy
Zulkifli Abdul Rashid, Azil Bahari Alias, Mohd Jindra Aris, Mohanad El-Harbawi, H.
84
APPENDIX A
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT 1974
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY (SCHEDULED WASTES)
REGULATIONS 2005
__________________________________
ARRANGEMENT OF REGULATIONS
Regulation
1. Citation and commencement
2. Interpretation
3. Notification of the generation of scheduled wastes
4. Disposal of scheduled wastes
5. Treatment of scheduled wastes
6. Recovery of material or product from scheduled wastes
7. Application for special management of scheduled wastes
8. Responsibility of waste generator
9. Storage of scheduled wastes
10. Labelling of scheduled wastes
11. Waste generator shall keep an inventory of scheduled wastes
12. Information to be provided by waste generator, contractor
and occupier of prescribed premises
13. Scheduled wastes transported outside waste generator's
premises to be accompanied by information
14. Spill or accidental discharge
15. Training Programme
16. Compounding of offences
17. Revocation
SCHEDULES
86
Interpretation
"scheduled wastes" means any waste falling within the categories of waste
listed in the First Schedule;
(2) Words and expressions which are not defined in these Regulations
shall have the same meaning as assigned to them in the Act and in the Environmental
Quality (Prescribed Premises) (Scheduled Waste Treatment and Disposal Facilities)
Order 1989.
3. (1) Every waste generator shall, within 30 days from the date of
generation of scheduled wastes, notify the Director General of the new categories and
quantities of scheduled wastes which are generated.
(2) The notification given under subregulation (1) shall include the
information provided in the Second Schedule.
(3) If the Director General is satisfied with the application made under
subregulation (1), the Director General may grant a written approval either with or
without conditions.
8. (1) Every waste generator shall ensure that scheduled wastes generated by
him are properly stored, treated on-site, recovered on-site for material or product from
such scheduled wastes or delivered to and received at prescribed premises for
treatment, disposal or recovery of material or product from scheduled wastes.
(2) Every waste generator shall ensure that scheduled wastes that are
subjected to movement or transfer be packaged, labelled and transported in
accordance with the guidelines prescribed by the Director General.
(4) Areas for the storage of the containers shall be designed, constructed
and maintained adequately in accordance with the guidelines prescribed by the
Director General to prevent spillage or leakage of scheduled wastes into the
environment.
(5) Any person may store scheduled wastes generated by him for 180 days
or less after its generation provided that
(b) the Director General may at any time, direct the waste
generator to send any scheduled wastes for treatment, disposal
or recovery of material or product from the scheduled wastes
up to such quantity as he deems necessary.
(7) If the Director General is satisfied with the application made under
subregulation (6), the Director General may grant a written approval either with or
without conditions.
10. (1) The date when the scheduled wastes are first generated, name, address
and telephone number of the waste generator shall be clearly labelled on the
containers that are used to store the scheduled wastes.
11. A waste generator shall keep accurate and up-to-date inventory in accordance
with the Fifth Schedule of the categories and quantities of scheduled wastes being
generated, treated and disposed of and of materials or product recovered from such
scheduled wastes for a period up to three years from the date the scheduled wastes
was generated.
12. (1) A waste generator, contractor and occupier of the prescribed premises
shall provide information in accordance with the Sixth Schedule in the manner
provided in this regulation or Director General shall determine other method as he
thinks fit.
(2) A waste generator shall complete Part I of the Sixth Schedule in six
copies and hand over the six copies of the Schedule to the contractor when the
scheduled wastes are delivered to him.
(3) The contractor shall, upon receiving scheduled wastes from a waste
generator, complete Part II of the Sixth Schedule in the six copies given to him by the
waste generator and shall thereafter immediately hand over two copies of the
91
Schedule to the waste generator who in turn shall submit a copy to the Director
General within 30 days from the date of transportation of the scheduled wastes.
(4) The contractor shall, within 10 days from the date of receipt of the
scheduled wastes, deliver the scheduled wastes to the occupier of any prescribed
premises and hand over the remaining four copies of the Sixth Schedule to the
occupier.
(6) If the waste generator fails to receive his copy of the Sixth Schedule
from the occupier of the prescribed premises referred to in subregulation (5) within
30 days from the date of delivery of the scheduled wastes to the contractor referred to
in subregulation (2), he shall notify the Director General immediately and shall
investigate and inform the Director General of the result of his investigation.
13. (1) Every waste generator shall provide information in accordance with
the Seventh Schedule in respect of each category of scheduled wastes to be delivered
to the contractor and shall give the Schedule to the contractor upon delivery of the
waste to him.
(2) The waste generator shall inform the contractor of the purpose and use
of the Seventh Schedule.
92
(3) The contractor shall carry with him the Seventh Schedule for each
category of scheduled wastes being transported and shall observe and comply with
the instructions contained therein.
(6) The contractor shall ensure that during the training programme each
employee is well informed on the purpose and use of the Seventh Schedule.
14. (1) In the event of any spill or accidental discharge of any scheduled
wastes, the contractor responsible for the waste shall immediately inform the Director
General of the occurrence.
(3) The waste generator shall provide technical expertise and supporting
assistance in any clean-up operation referred to in subregulation (2).
(4) The contractor shall undertake studies to determine the impact of the
spillage or accidental discharge on the environment over a period of time to be
determined by the Director General.
Training Programme
15. Every waste generator shall ensure that all his employees involved in the
93
Compounding of offences
16. (1) Every offence which consists of any omission or neglect to comply
with, or any act done or attempted to be done contrary to these Regulations may be
compounded under section 45 of the Act.
Revocation
17. The Environmental Quality (Scheduled Wastes) Regulations 1989 [P.U. (A)
139/1989] is hereby repealed as from the commencement of these Regulations.
FIRST SCHEDULE
(Regulation 2)
SW 104 Dust, slag, dross or ash containing arsenic, mercury, lead, cadmium,
chromium, nickel, copper, vanadium, beryllium, antimony,
tellurium, thallium or selenium excluding slag from iron and steel
factory
SW 108 Leaching residues from zinc processing in dust and sludges form
SW 301 Spent organic acids with pH less or equal to 2 which are corrosive or hazardous
SW 402 Spent alkalis with pH more or equal to 11.5 which are corrosive or
hazardous
SW 5 Other wastes
SECOND SCHEDULE
(Regulation 3)
REGULATIONS 2005
State Code:
1. IDENTIFICATION
Designation:
.………………………………………………………………………
.
2. PRODUCTION DATA
3. WASTE DATA
Code
1
Note: Unit Operation in the process/plant
2
Name the elements, compound or material
3
Guide to conversion (only data in metric tonnes/month is
acceptable)
* Use additional sheet if required
** Estimates
I certify that the information provided is true and correct to the best
of my knowledge.
……………………………
…………..
Signature of Reporting
Officer ***
Name:
…………………………………..
Designation:
……………………………
Date:
…………………………………….
Note:
THIRD SCHEDULE
(Regulation 10)
100
EXPLOSIVE SUBSTANCES
(WASTE)
Label 1
INFLAMMABLE LIQUIDS
(WASTE)
Label 2
101
INFLAMMABLE SOLIDS
(WASTE)
Label 3
Label 4
Label 5
102
OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES
(WASTE)
Label 6
ORGANIC PEROXIDES
(WASTE)
Label 7
103
TOXIC SUBSTANCES
(WASTE)
Label 8
INFECTIOUS SUBSTANCES
(WASTE)
Label 9
CORROSIVE SUBSTANCES
(WASTE)
Symbol (liquids spilling from two glass vessels and attacking a hand and a metal):
black; Background: upper half white, lower half black
Label 10
104
Symbol (nil); Background: white with upper half vertical black stripes
Label 11
PARTICULARS OF LABELS
1. The label shall be a square set at an angle of 45 degrees. The dimension of the
label shall not be less than 10 cm by 10 cm except where the size of the
container or package warrants for a label of smaller size.
3. The labels shall be divided into halves, the upper half of the label shall be
reserved for the pictorial symbol and the lower half for text printed in block
capitals.
4. The text shall be printed in black on all labels except when the background of
the label is black, red or blue, the text shall be in white.
6. All labels shall be able to withstand open weather exposure without a substantial
reduction in effectiveness.
8. In the case of waste capable of causing two or more hazards, all the hazards
must be clearly identified and the waste shall be labelled accordingly.
FOURTH SCHEDULE
(Regulation 2)
The mixing of a waste in Group A with a waste in Group B may have the
following potential consequences:
Asbestos Solvents
Beryllium Explosives
Unrinsed pesticide containers Petroleum
Pesticides Oil and other flammable
wastes
Magnesium
Potassium
Sodium
Zinc powder and other reactive
metals and metal hydrides
FIFTH SCHEDULE
(Regulation 11)
Note:
I hereby declare that all information given in this form is to the best of my
knowledge and belief true and correct in all respect.
SIXTH SCHEDULE
(Regulation 12)
State Code:
109
Address:
…………………………………………………………………………...…………
…….
Waste Component:
…………………………………………………………………………………
Quantity: And If
Possible
Metric Tonnes m3
Delivery Time:…………………………………
………………………………………
II CONTRACTOR
110
For office
use only
Contractor Code:
State Code:
Name of Contractor:
…………………………...…………………………………………………..
Address:
…...…………………………………………………………………………………
…….
Name of Responsible
Person:………………………………………………………………………
Name of Driver:
……………………………………………………………………………………
Temporary
Storage: No Yes, Address:
…………….…………………………………
State Code:
111
Name of Facility:
..………………………………….…..…………………………………………
Address of Facility:
…………………………………………..……………………………………
Type of Operation:
…….……………
SEVENTH SCHEDULE
(Regulation 13)
INFORMATION
A. Properties
1. Category of waste
- according to the First Schedule
2. Origin
112
4. Risks
- by inhalation
- by oral intake
- by dermal contact
B. Handling of waste
1. Personal protection equipment
- gloves, goggles, face shield etc.
2. Procedures/Precautions in handling, packaging, transporting and
storage
3. Appropriate label
- labels for the containers
4. Recommended method of disposal
Made 2005
[AS(S)91/110/919/014; PN(PU2)280/VII]