Galus 237

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 25

!

"#$%&'&(()&*"$")&#$%+
,-.(*/&&&0((12.34(5((6((5789

`&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK( ‡ (

;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&(
#$rL¤(&&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';(M;c&r#&(

PI(c"*+'J*;!%+(c+#b;%&$cd(L`&;:"c"L#& (
(
)21XD.31B3.( V-.FU3V?-E3T-( .-X3U2( .Z@T2( =( EABED4@D13T-( F4@3@3_(
2.A?W2( .2?@^( SAm( F4-H3?A( S=-C=@AH@130( S=-H[3.=H@130( 1324-1-E3( =( F?AQ
H[=H@130(VBZ4AH[(?V--4XA1-ED13(X@=DWD1=3(EF4DE=D(BDV=(.-X3U(E(42H[I((
%DU3hA(E=GH(2@2F3W1=m(U=?BG(.3H[D1=@.ZE(2.-hU=E=D>^HAH[([-4A@-1BDU1^(
V-.21=VDH>3(1324-1DU1^(1D(F-@=-.=3(?A1DFBAH@1A.(=(X31X4ABAH@1A.I(:-SQ
4A.( VD1XAXDB3.( 1D( 1-]1=V( =1C-4.DH>=( .=GX@AV-.Z4V-E3>( .-h3( SAm( TU3>(
.Z@T-EAI( JX-E-X1=-1-0( h3( V-.Z4V=( TU3>2( EAF3W1=D>^( @W-h-13( C21VH>3(
E(?B42VB24@3( .Z@T20( 1=3( -T4D1=H@D>^H( ?=G( X-( C21VH>=( [-.3-?BDBAH@1AH[(
=(E?F-.DTD>^HAH[( F4DHG( 1324-1ZE( 1D( F-@=-.=3( .3BDS-U=H@1A.( |)&+*:K (
577n0( 5788~I( $EAVU30( .A]U^H( -( .Z@T20( .D.A( 1D( .A]U=( 1324-1AI( c2?=.A(
>3X1DVh3(FD.=GBDm0(h3(U=H@SG(V-.Z43V(TU3>2(V-.Z4V-E3T-(-H31=D(?=G(1D(8(X-(
1DE3B(9(S=U=-1ZE0(H@AU=(-VI(97(4D@A(E=GV?@^(1=h(1324-1ZEI(K@H@3TZU13(C21VQ
H>3(E(.Z@T2(?F3W1=D>^(D?B4-HABAI(`(-?BDB1=.(X@=3?=GH=-U3H=2(EAV-1D1-(E=3Q
U3( SDXD_ in vitro( -4D@ in vivo0( F-BE=34X@D>^HAH[0( h3( D?B4-HABA( -XT4AED>^(
=?B-B1^( 4-UG( E( ?B42VB24@3( ?=3H=( 1324-1-E3>0( D( BDVh3( EA.=31=D>^( =1C-4.DH>3(
@(1324-1D.=I( $3S4D1-( E=3U3( X-E-XZE( 1D( =?B1=31=3( VD1DWZE( >-1-EAH[0( VBZQ
4A.=( B4D1?F-4B-ED13( ?^( =1C-4.DH>3( E( V-.Z4VDH[( TU3>2( |;!;vJ;+( 577Pz(
$l&¥!(;!,d'J£¥`(577g~I(`AVD@2>^(-13(.=GX@A(=11A.=(DVBAE1-]m(3U3VB4-Q
H[3.=H@1^0( VBZ43>( F4@3>DE3.( ?^( BE-4@^H3( ?=G( E( 1=H[( CDU3( >-1ZE( EDF1=DI"
j3134-ED13( F4@3@( D?B4-HABA( CDU3( EDF1=-E3( .-T^( SAm( EAE-WD13( S-XfH3.(
.3H[D1=H@1A.0( >3X1DVh3( 1D>SD4X@=3>( ?V2B3H@1A.( ]4-XV=3.( =H[( EAE-Q
(

:4(=1hI(`&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(6(F4DH-E1=V(+2B[34.(KFI(@(-I-Iz(DX43?(X-(V-43?F-1X31H>=a(2UI($DQ


H[-X@^H3T-(KW-_HD(gn0(78QgO9(`D4?@DEDz(3Q.D=Ua(EITDU2?†32B[34.I32(
5eP( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

WAED1=D(E(.Z@T2(>3?B(TU2BD.=1=D1I(,DVh3(=113(1324-B4D1?.=B34A(.-T^(T313Q
4-EDm( CDU3( EDF1=-E3( E( D?B4-HABDH[I( `( -XF-E=3X@=( 1D( ?BA.2UDH>G( D?B4-HAB(
.-h3( @D43DT-EDm( U-VDU1A.( E@4-?B3.( F-@=-.2( >-1ZE( #D 5 0( -S3>.2>^HA.(
BAUV-(C4DT.31B(V-.Z4V=0(DUS-(CDU^(EDF1=-E^0(4-@F4@3?B4@31=D>^H^(?=G(F-(HDW3>(
V-.Z4H3( U2S( F-.=GX@A( V-.Z4VD.=I( )DUD( 1D>H@G]H=3>( .D( H[D4DVB34( -?HAUDQ
HA>1A0(H[-m(E@Z4(BAH[(-?HAUDH>=( .-h3(SAm(SD4X@-(4Zh1A0(H-(?2T342>3( .-hU=Q
E-]m( >DV=3T-]( V-X-ED1=D( =1C-4.DH>=( -B4@A.D1AH[( -X( ?=3H=( 1324-1DU13>I( #-(
E=GH3>0( -F=?D1-( BDVh3( @>DE=?V-( F-X-S13( X-( E@.-H1=31=D( ?A1DFBAH@13T-(
*,MI( `=3U-V4-B1D( ?BA.2UDH>D( B3>( ?D.3>( V-.Z4V=( F4-EDX@=( X-( F-E?BD1=D(
-?HAUDH>=( -( E@4D?BD>^H3>( H@G?B-BU=E-]H=I( M4GXV-]m( NO6n7( ³.?R( =( .-hU=E-]m(
?2.-ED1=D( 2F-XDS1=D( CDUG( EDF1=-E^( X-( F-B31H>DWZE( F-?B?A1DFBAH@1AH[0(
>3X1DV(@X-U1-]m(X-(?D.-43T3134DH>=(F4@AF-.=1D(F-X-S1^(EWD]H=E-]m(F-B31Q
H>DWZE( H@A11-]H=-EAH[( 6( 4D@( @D=1=H>-ED1D( CDUD( EDF1=-ED( >3?B( 1D( 1-E-(
T3134-ED1D( E( V-U3>1AH[( V-.Z4VDH[( |b ;,,"%( 577g~I( `D421V=( X-( [-4A@-1Q
BDU13>(V-.21=VDH>=(.=GX@A(1324-1-E3>(?^(E=GH(?F3W1=-13I(
(
M-E?BD>3(FABD1=3a(>DV(?^?=3X1=3(1324-1A(=(D?B4-HABA(-XH@AB2>^(=1C-4.DH>3(
F4@3?AWD13(F4@3@(1324-1A(=H[(DV?-1D.=0(X31X4ABD.=(=(?A1DF?D.=„(#@A(.-hQ
U=EA( >3?B( =11A( .3H[D1=@.( ?F4@Gh31=D( 3CDBAH@13T-„( "XF-E=3Xf( .-h3( XDm(
.-X3U( 1324-Q3U3VB4-QXA1D.=H@1A( %+:0( @DF4-F-1-ED1A( F4@3@( ;24D( =( <-TD(
|; J!(§(< "j (5787~(>2h(E(5779(4I(|;J!(=(=1I(57790(577n~I((
jWZE1^( F4@3?WD1V^( F-E?BD1=D( B3T-( .-X3U2( SAW-( @DVE3?B=-1-ED1=3( -S-Q
E=^@2>^H3T-(X-BAH[H@D?(FD4DXAT.DB20(h3(C21XD.31B3.(B4D1?.=?>=(=1C-4.DH>=(
E( ?=3H=( 1324-1-E3>( >3?B( ?B42VB24D( H@D?-ED( ?34==( F=VZE( F-B31H>DW2( H@A11-Q
]H=-E3T-0(EA@EDUD13T-(F4@3@(1324-1A(E(C-4.=3a(H@G?B-]H=(-XFDUD1=D(F=VZE(
|c##*+**;%:( §( !Jc+*b;!,( 8OPP~0( -X?BGFZE( H@D?-EAH[( F-.=GX@A(
F=VD.=( |j+!K,%+!( §( '&K,*+!( 5775D0( &$b&'+p&#b( 5778~( H@A( B3h( FUD?BAH@Q
1-]H=( E@.-H1=31=D( ?A1DFBAH@13T-0( @DU3h13>( -X( ?B42VB24A( H@D?-E3>( F=VZE(
K,:M(Nspike timing dependent plasticityR(|#;M"!;*+( §( :;%(577P~I(:-T.DB(
B31( >3?B( F-XEDhD1A( TWZE1=3( @( F-E-X2( 2>DE1=D>^H3>( ?=G( E( H-4D@( E=GV?@A.(
?B-F1=2(S3@?=U1-]H=(E(EABW2.DH@31=2(@>DE=?V(F?AH[=H@1AH[(E(2.A?WDH[(1DQ
B24DU1AH[0(.3H[D1=@.ZE(FD.=GH=(=(43UDH>=(.=GX@A(FD.=GH=^(4-S-H@^0(V4ZBV-Q
B4EDW^( =( XW2T-B4EDW^0( X3VUD4DBAE1^0( @D4ZE1-( ?3.D1BAH@1^0( >DV( =( 3F=@-XAH@Q
1^0(D(BDVh3(=H[(4-U=(E(F4-H3?DH[(2H@31=D(=(X-]E=DXH@D1=D(3F=@-XZE(E(B4DVH=3(
-?-S1=H@3T-(hAH=DI((
!ZE1=3( =?B-B1^( VE3?B=^0( EA.DTD>^H^( EA>D]1=31=D0( >3?B( F-XW-h3( C=@>-Q
U-T=H@13( =( 1324-U-T=H@13( FD.=GH=( B4EDW3>I( :-BAH[H@D?-EA( FD4DXAT.DB( E( B3>(
X@=3X@=1=3( TW-?=0( h3( E?F-.1=31=D( ?^( F4@3H[-EAED13( X@=GV=( XW2T-B4EDWA.(
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 5eO(

.-XAC=VDH>-.( ?=WA( F-W^H@3_( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[( |' ;%:+*( 57770( 5778~0( X@=GV=(


E@.-H1=31=2(?A1DFBAH@13.2(2ED421V-ED13.2(DVBAE1-]H=^(*,M(U2S(@.=DQ
1=3(-4TD1=@DH>=(F-W^H@3_(?A1DFBAH@1AH[(=(1324-1-EAH[(F-E-X-ED13>(DVBAEQ
1-]H=^( F-S2X@3_0( H[-m( E( H@G]H=( 2ED421V-ED13>( T313BAH@1=3( |l+%K"%( =( =1I(
5788~I(
;24( =( <-T( @DF4-F-1-EDU=( @1DH@1=3( SD4X@=3>( ?2SB3U13( F-X3>]H=3I( JX-E-XQ
1=U=0(h3(H[D4DVB34A?BAVD(H@D?-ED(=.F2U?ZE(F-B31H>DW2(H@A11-]H=-E3T-(E(-XQ
?BGFDH[(.=U=?3V21X-EAH[(1=3(1=3?=3(X-?BDB3H@13>(=U-]H=(=1C-4.DH>=(-(?B42VB2Q
4@3(=( E@-4HDH[(F-S2X@3_(1324-1DU1AH[I($E4ZH=U=(2EDTG0(h3(V?@BDWB( H@D?-EA(
F->3XA1H@3T-( =.F2U?2( @( 4-@X@=3UH@-]H=^( ?2S.=U=?3V21X-E^( @DE=34D( =?B-B13(
=1C-4.DH>3(-(X-H=34D>^HA.(X-(EG@WZE(?=3H=(E@-4H2(F-S2X@31=D(|;J!( §( < "j (
577t0( 577O0( 5787z( ;J!( 57870( 5788~I( $.=311-]m( H@D?-ED( F=V2( F-B31H>DW2(
H@A11-]H=-E3T-( ;M( .-h3( SAm( B4D1?C-4.-ED1D( 1D( E3VB-4( 43F43@31B2>^HA(
H[E=U-E^( TG?B-]m( ?B42.=31=D( WDX21VZE( F4-FDT2>^HAH[( ?=G( E( VD1DWDH[( >-1-Q
EAH[I(`3VB-4(B310(-X@E=34H=3XUD>^HA(U-VDU1A(4-@VWDX(F4@3?B4@311A(WDX21V20(
1D@EDU=( !#$%&'!()(*+#,( =.F2U?2I( <D?13( >3?B0( h3( H[D4DVB34A?BAVD( H@D?-ED(
E3VB-4ZE( V=3421V-E-]H=( 2>DE1=D( @1DH@1=3( E=GV?@^( =U-]m( =1C-4.DH>=0( 1=h(
>3X1-EA.=D4-EA( H=^T( ?BD1XD4X-EAH[( F=VZE( ;MI( #31B4DU1A.( @DTDX1=31=3.(
D1DU=@A( C21VH>=( .Z@T20( VBZ4^( >3?B( 2.A?W0( ?BD>3( ?=G( 4-@VWDX( WDX21VZE( 3U3VQ
B4AH@1AH[( 1D( F-@=-.=3( F4@3?B4@31=( .=GX@A?A1DFBAH@13>( =( VD1DWZE( >-1-EAH[(
E(.3.S4D1DH[0(?A1DF?DH[0(DV?-1DH[(=(F34=VD4=-1=3I(
`=3U3( @>DE=?V( E?VD@2>3( 1D( @1DH@31=3( 4-@VWDX2( WDX21VZE( XUD( F4-H3?ZE(
-SU=H@31=-EAH[(EAV-1AED1AH[(F4@3@(.Z@TI(<3?B(@1D1A.(CDVB3.0(h3(F4-H3?A(
C=@AH@130(X-(VBZ4AH[(1DU3hA(BDVh3(F34H3FH>D(4@3H@AE=?B-]H=(.DB34=DU13>0(.-Q
T^( SAm( .-X3U-ED13( N-SU=H@D13R( @D( F-.-H^( =11AH[( F4-H3?ZE( C=@AH@1AH[0(
>3]U=( @1D>X@=3.A( V-X( -XF-E=3X1=-]H=( FD4D.3B4ZE( C=@AH@1AH[( E( -S2( F4-H3Q
?DH[I( £DX21V=( .-T^( -XH@ABAEDm0( F4@31-?=m( =( B4D1?C34-EDm( =1C-4.DH>G( F-XQ
H@D?( F4@3.=3?@H@D1=D( E( F4@3?B4@31=( FZU( 3U3VB4-.DT13BAH@1AH[0( BE-4@-1AH[(
F4@3@( .DV4-.-U3V2UD41^( ?B42VB24G( E3E1GB4@1^( 1324-1ZE0( -S3>.2>^H^( V-Q
.Z4VG0( X31X4ABA0( DV?-1( =( ?A1DF?A( |;:*+c;%( 8OOg~I( $1DH@^HD( =U-]m( =1C-4Q
.DH>=( >3?B( B4D1?C34-ED1D( E( VDhXA.( F=V2( F-B31H>DW2( H@A11-]H=-E3T-( E( F-Q
?BDH=( E?B4@AV1=GH=D( >-1ZE( E( H@D?=3( .=U=?3V21X-EA.( N.DV?A.DU1=3( ]43X1=-(
P6O(S=BZE(E(VDhXA.(F=V2(F-B31H>DW2RI((
(
,3(?B42.=31=3(WDX21VZE(E(?=3H=(1324-1-E3>(S=-4^(?=G(@3(?B42.=31=(>-1ZE(
EA@EDUD1AH[(F4@3@(F-B31H>DWA(H@A11-]H=-E3(?^?=3X1=H[(EG@WZE(?=3H=I(!-@Q
VWDX( =( -XX@=DWAED1=D( WDX21VZE( 3U3VB4AH@1AH[( -F=?AEDm( 1DU3hA( E3VB-43.(
2E@TUGX1=D>^HA.(@>DE=?VD(VED1B-E30(VBZ4A.(B3(WDX21V=(F-XU3TD>^I(`(F3EQ
5g7( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

1A.( ?31?=3( 4DH>G( .=DW( E=GH( M314-?30( F-?B2U2>^H( =1B2=HA>1=30( h3( ]E=DX-.-]m(
V4A>3( ?=G( E( @>DE=?VDH[( VED1B-EAH[( |M +%!"K+( 8OOt~0( BA.( SD4X@=3>( h3( ;24(
=(<-T( F-BE=34X@=U=( .-hU=E-]m( EA?BGF-ED1=D( ?V-43U-ED1AH[( ?BD1ZE( VED1B-Q
EAH[(WDX21VZE(E(?@H@3U=1=3(?A1DFBAH@13>0(D(V=3421V-EA(H[D4DVB34(?B42.=3Q
1=D( >-1-E3T-( F=V2( F-B31H>DW2( H@A11-]H=-E3T-( EAF4-EDX@=U=( @( VED1B-E3>(
B3-4==( F-UDI( ;24( =( <-T( >3X1DVh3( 4ZE1-H@3]1=3( EAVD@DU=0( h3( ?BD1A( VED1B-E3(
-F=?2>^H3(B3(WDX21V=(2U3TD>^(1DBAH[.=D?B-E3>(X3V-[3431H>=(E(-XX@=DWAED1=2(
@(H=GhV=.=(>-1D.=(EDF1=D(=(F-BD?20(@(.DV4-.-U3V2WD.=(S=DWV-EA.=0(F4-B3=Q
1D.=( VD1DWZE( >-1-EAH[( E( .3.S4D1DH[( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[0( -4D@( E( ]H=D1DH[(
X31X4ABZE(=(DV?-1ZEI($(B3T-(F-E-X2(@.2?@31=(>3?B3].A(2@1Dm0(h3(E?@3UV=3(
F4-H3?A( 1324-1-E30( -XF-E=3X@=DU13( @D( B4D1?C34( =1C-4.DH>=( E( ?=3H=( 1324-Q
1-E3>0( .-T^( SAm( -F=?D13( VUD?AH@1A.=( F4-H3?D.=( C=@AH@1A.=( |;J!( §( <"j (
5787z(;24(=(=1I(577n0~I(
(
`A?BGF-ED1=3(F=VZE(V=3421V-EAH[(F-BE=34X@-1-(X-]E=DXH@DU1=3(E(3V?Q
F34A.31BDH[( in vivo( @( ?-1X^( B3B4-X-E^( E=3U-F21VB-E^( |; J!( §( < "j( 5787z(
<"j( §( ;J! (577Oz(<"j(=(=1I(577t~I(,DVh3(c=U?B3=1(=('-H[(X-?BD4H@AU=(1-EAH[(
X-E-XZE0(SDXD>^H(V-.Z4V=([=F-VD.FD0(TX@=3(EAV4AU=(-US4@A.=3(3U3VB4AH@13(
.-.31BA( VEDX42F-U-E30( -XX@=DW2>^H3( 1D( F-B31H>DWA( H@A11-]H=-E3( 1D( -XQ
U3TW-]m(X-(F4DE=3(8(H.I(M-1=3EDh(X-BAH@AW-(B-([=F-VD.FD(?@H@24D0(B-(.-hQ
1D( ?BE=34X@=m0( h3( EAV4AB3( F-U3( -XX@=DWAEDW-( 1D( X2h^( H@G]m( .Z@T2( |c &* Q
K,+&%( § ( ' "#b ( 577P~I( !-@VWDX( WDX21VZE0( =?B-B1A( XUD( B4D1?.=?>=( E( SW-1=3(
?A1DFBAH@13>( .Z@T2( ?@H@24D( in vivo0 F-BE=34X@-1-( B3h( E( F4DHA( ;1D?BD??=-2(
=(E?FZWF4DH-E1=VZE( |; %;K,;KK&"J ( =( =1I( 5787~0( D( WDX21V-E3( ?F4@Gh31=3(
3CDBAH@13(EAVD@D1-(E(SDXD1=DH[(V-4-EAH[(1324-1ZE(F=4D.=XDU1AH[(?@H@2Q
4D(E(SDXD1=2(in vitro |#"K,;K(=(=1I(578e~I(
<DV( ?=3m( 1324-1-ED( .-h3( D1DU=@-EDm( F4@3?B4@311A( 4-@VWDX( WDX21VZE0(
VBZ43(?D.D(EABED4@D„(
`3XW2T( ;24D( =( <-TD( X31X4ABA( =( DV?-1A( 1=3( ?^( FD?AE1A.=( U=1=D.=( B4D1?Q
.=?A>1A.=0( U3H@( @DE=34D>^( @W-h-13( V-.FU3V?A( .DV4-.-U3V2UD413( =( VD1DWA(
>-1-E3(V?@BDWB-ED130(F-X-S1=3(>DV(E(?A1DF?DH[0(F4@3@(?F3HAC=H@13(F4-B3=1AI(
$E=1=GB3( WD_H2H[A( .DV4-.-U3V2UD413( V?@BDWB2>^( ?EZ>( EWD?1A( 4-@VWDX( FZU(
3U3VB4AH@1AH[0( .D>^HAH[( 1D1-.3B4-E3( =( .=V4-.3B4-E3( @D?=GT=I( j42FA( ?AQ
1DF?0( TG?B-( 4-@.=3?@H@-13( E( V-U2.1DH[( 1324-1-EAH[0( ?^( E4DhU=E3( 1D( 4-@Q
VWDX( TG?B-]H=( WDX21VZEI( M-X-S1=3( B-4A( B4D1?.=?>=( WDX21VZE( EA@1DH@-13( ?^(
F4@3@( ?B42VB24G( F4@3?B4@311^( X31X4ABZE( =( DV?-1ZEI( £DX21V=( 3U3VB4AH@13(
1=3?=-13( F4@3@(?B42.=31=3( >-1ZE( -XX@=DW2>^( @( F4-B3=1D.=( ?A1DF?0(X31X4ABZE(
=( DV?-1ZEI( M-@D( -XX@=DWAED1=3.( @3( ]H=D1D.=( VD1DWZE( >-1-EAH[( WDX21V=(
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 5g8(

EABED4@D>^( F-UD( F-@DV-.Z4V-E30( -XX@=DW2>^H3( 1D( ?^?=3X1=3( ?A1DF?AI( $3(


E@TUGX2( 1D( -US4@A.=^( =H[( U=H@SG0( ?@DH-ED1^( 2( H@W-E=3VD( 1D( 8789 0( H-( -XQ
F-E=DXD(-VI(87O(?A1DF?(E(>3X1A.(.=U=.3B4@3(?@3]H=311A.0(@X-U13(?^(-13(X-(
EAH[EABAED1=D( ?2SB3U1AH[( @.=D1( 4-@VWDX2( F-B31H>DWZE( 3U3VB4AH@1AH[I( KAQ
1DF?A(X@=DWD>^(E=GH(1=3H-(F-X-S1=3(>DV(?-1XA(WDX21V-E3I(,3(-XX@=DWAED1=D(
?V2BV2>^( @.=D1D.=( E( V-1BDVB2>^HAH[( ?=G( F4-B3=1DH[( -4D@( ?3U3VBAE1A.=0(
U-VDU1A.=( @.=D1D.=( T313BAH@1A.=( 1D( F-@=-.=3( .-U3V2UD41A.0( D( E=GH( =H[(
@DF=?D1=3.( =( 2B4EDU31=3.I( %D?BGF2>3( .-U3V2UD413( V-X-ED1=30( E( VBZ4A.(
.=V4-F-UD( 3U3VB4AH@13( EABED4@D13( F4@3@( T4DX=31BA( TG?B-]H=( WDX21V20( E( XAQ
1D.=H@1=3( @.=311AH[( ?B42.=31=DH[( >-1ZE0( F-E-X2>^( -XV?@BDWH31=D( WD_H2Q
H[ZE( D.=1-VED?ZE0( ?F3HAC=H@13( U-VDU1=3( @T=1D1=3( =( DT43TDH>G( F4-B3=1I( <DV(
EAVD@D1-0(1DBGh31=D(BAH[(.=V4-FZU(3U3VB4AH@1AH[(?^(EA?BD4H@D>^H3(X-(BDV=H[(
.-XAC=VDH>=I("F4ZH@(1-EAH[(F4-B3=10(F-E?BD>^HAH[(E(X31X4ABDH[0(DV?-1DH[(
=(F34AVD4=-1=3(1324-120(.-T^(F-E?BDEDm(F4-B3=1A(E(?A1DF?DH[0(VBZ43(E([AX4-Q
C-S-EAH[0( 1=3F4@3F2?@H@DU1AH[( XUD( >-1ZE( .3.S4D1DH[( U=F=X-EAH[( C-4.2>^(
1-E3( VD1DWA( >-1-E3I( ,-0( h3( @DF=?-.( E( FD.=GH=( XW2T-B4EDW3>( B-ED4@A?@A(
U-VDU1D( ?A1B3@D( 1-EAH[( F4-B3=10( @1D13( >3?B( -X( UDB( H-( 1D>.1=3>( H@B34X@=3?B2(
N@-SI( 1FI( |K #b`;!,$( =( =1I( 8Ot8~RI( %=3( @1D1-( >3X1DV( .3H[D1=@.20( VBZ4A(
F-E-X2>3( =H[( F-E?BDED1=3( U2S( .-XAC=VDH>GI( M-1DXB-( .-U3V2WA( S=-U-T=H@13(
hA>^(T-X@=1A(U2S(X1=0(F-XH@D?(TXA(FD.=Gm(XW2T-B4EDWD(C21VH>-12>3(E=3U3(UDB0(
D(2(??DVZE(E=3U3(X@=3?=GH=-U3H=0(H@G?B-(HDW3(hAH=3I(M-XB4@A.AED1=3(FD.=GH=(
BW2.DH@-1-(X-BAH[H@D?(F4-H3?3.(-V43?-E3T-(F4@AF-.=1D1=DI(`3XW2T(D2B-Q
4ZE( B3-4==( %+:( @.=D1A( E( T31DH[( =( E( .3H[D1=@.DH[( 3V?F43?>=( T31ZE( 1D(
F-@=-.=3(.-U3V2UD41A.(F-E-X2>^(H=^TW3(-XBED4@D1=3(F4-B3=1(E(V-.Z4VDH[0(
BDV( h3( FD.=Gm( .-h3( SAm( B4EDWD( E( -V43?DH[( E=3U-U3B1=H[( |; J! ( 57870( 5788~I(
lDXD1=D( @DFD.=GBAED1=D( XW2T-B34.=1-E3T-( F-F4@3@( .-XAC=VDH>3( 3F=T313Q
BAH@13( F-BE=34X@D>^0( h3( 1DE3B( 1=3E=3UV=3( -XV?@BDWH31=D( T3-.3B4AH@13( F->3Q
XA1H@AH[(T31ZE(E(>^X4@3(F34=VD4=-12(F-E-X2>^(@.=D1A(=H[(3V?F43?>=0(F4@3@(
H-( .-hU=E3( >3?B( F-E?BDED1=3( ?F3HAC=H@1AH[( S=DW3V( SGX^HAH[( 1-]1=VD.=( FDQ
.=GH=( |` ;*#$;'( 578e~I( &11A( .3H[D1=@.( V?@BDWB-ED1=D( *,c( E?VD@DW(
lD=U3A(=(E?FZWF4DH-E1=HA(|l;&*+d(8OOn0(577g~I(JX-E-X1=U=(-1=0(h3(?3VE31Q
HA>1D( DVBAEDH>D( T31ZE( F-X( EFWAE3.( 2H@31=D( F4-EDX@=( X-( F-E?BDED1=D(
1-EAH[( ?A1DF?( 1324-1-EAH[I( ,DVh3( =( E( BA.( F4@AFDXV2( F4-H3?( B31( >3?B(
?BA.2U-ED1A(1-EA.=(4-X@D>D.=(F4-B3=1(?A1B3BA@-ED1AH[(U-VDU1=3I(
(
`(BDV=(?F-?ZS(@.-XAC=V-ED13(F4-B3=1A(V-X2>^(=1C-4.DH>3(1=3?=-13(F4@3@(
V=3421V-E3(F=V=(;MI(c=.-(h3(U=H@SD(WDX21VZE(X-XDB1=H[(=(2>3.1AH[(?BDBAQ
?BAH@1=3( >3?B( 4ZE1D( E( E=GV?@AH[( -S?@D4DH[( BVD1V=0( B-( =H[( 4-@VWDX( .=V4-Q
5g5( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

?VDU-EA(>3?B(1=3>3X1-4-X1A(=(@.=311AI(`(?BD1=3(?F-H@A1V-EA.(VDhXA(132Q
4-1( @DE=34D( 1=3E=3UV=( 1DX.=D4( WDX21VZE( 2>3.1AH[I( $.=D1D( TG?B-]H=( >-1ZE(
X-XDB1=H[( N1FI( %D R( SU=?V-( .3.S4D1A( ?A1DFBAH@13>( F-E-X2>3( F-UD4A@DH>G0(
VBZ4D( .-h3( -BE-4@Am( ?-X-EA( VD1DW( >-1-EA0( D( 1324-1( EAT31342>3( EZEH@D?(
F=V( F-B31H>DW2( H@A11-]H=-E3T-( |;ll",,( §( !+j+b!( 577g~I( ,-ED4@A?@^H3(
B3.2( E?B4@AV1=GH=3( >-1ZE( @.=31=D( 4-@VWDX( WDX21VZE( E3E1^B4@( =( @3E1^B4@(
V-.Z4V=( 1324-12I( ,E-4@A( ?=G( E( B31( ?F-?ZS( 3U3VB4AH@1A( E@-4@3H( DVBAEDH>=(
F-( VDhXA.( F->3XA1H@A.( F=V2( >DV-( 43@2UBDB( .=V4-?VDU-E3>( XAC2@>=( >-1ZE(
E3E1^B4@( 1324-12( |;J!( §( <"j ( 577n~I( JX-E-X1=-1-0( h3( @E=>D1=3( =( DT43Q
TDH>D(F4-B3=1(F-X(EFWAE3.( .=V4-FZU(3U3VB4AH@1AH[(.-h3(@DH[-X@=m(E(H@DQ
?=3( .=U=?3V21X-EA.I( :@=GV=( B3.2( E( FD.=GH=( B4EDW3>( .-T^( SAm( B4EDU3( 43>3Q
?B4-ED13( >3X1-4D@-E3( EAXD4@31=D( N@DFD.=GBAED1=3( >3X1-4D@-E30( 1DBAH[Q
.=D?B-E3RI( MUD?BAH@1-]m( F-E-X-ED1D( @E=>D1=3.( F4-B3=1( .-h3( EA.DTDm(
BDVh3(XW2h?@AH[(H@D?ZE(=(F-EBD4@D1=D(=.F2U?ZE(F-B31H>DW2I($DH[-X@=(EZEQ
H@D?( E( H@D?=3( V=UV2( ?3V21X0( D( 1DE3B( .=12BI( ,31( F4-H3?( V-X-ED1=D0( H@AU=(
B4D1?C-4.DH>G( F=VZE( V=3421V-EAH[( E( =1C-4.DH>G( @DED4B^( E( F4-B3=1DH[(
=(:%;0( 1D@E=>.A( B4D1?C-4.DH>^( ,I( M4-H3?( @E=>D1=D0( T42F-ED1=D( =( E=^@D1=D(
F4-B3=1( .-h3( SAm( E@.-H1=-1A( F4@3@( -S3H1-]m( ?@ASV-( X@=DWD>^HAH[( 1324-Q
B4D1?.=B34ZE( N?@ASV=3( 2H@31=3R( =( E-U1=3>( X@=DWD>^HAH[( 1324-.-X2UDB-4ZE(
NF-E-U13( 2H@31=3RI( ,DVh3( V-1H31B4DH>D( 2EDT=( =( F-EBD4@D1=3( S-XfHZE( F4@AQ
?F=3?@D>^( F4-H3?( V-X-ED1=D( X@=GV=( B3.20( h3( X2hD( U=H@SD( WDX21VZE( ?A1H[4-Q
1=H@1=3(-XX@=DW2>3(E(E=3U2(1324-1DH[(4ZE1-H@3]1=3I(%-E-(F-E?BD>^H3(DT43Q
TDBA( .DV4-.-U3V2UD413( 1=3( ?^( B4EDW3( =( E( EA1=V2( X@=DWD1=D( .3H[D1=@.ZE(
-S4-11AH[( V-.Z4V=( 2U3TD>^( X3T3134DH>=( U2S( X3?B42VH>=I( <3X1DVh3( @.-XAQ
C=V-ED13(:%;(F-F4@3@(B4D1?V4AFH>G(X-(!%;(=(F-EBZ41^(B4D1?UDH>G(-XBED4@D(
U-VDU1=3(?F3HAC=H@13(?B42VB24A0(@DF3E1=D>^H(E=3U-U3B1=^(B4EDW-]m(@DF=?2I((
(
:3V-X-ED1=3( @DF=?D13>( E( :%;( =1C-4.DH>=( -XSAED( ?=G( F-F4@3@( -XX@=DQ
WAED1=3(WDX21VZE(@(.DV4-.-U3V2WD.=(1324-1ZE0(F4-EDX@^H3(X-(@1DH@^HAH[(
@.=D1( 4-@VWDX2( V-1H31B4DH>=( WDX21VZEI( !-@VWDX( TG?B-]H=( WDX21VZE( F=VZE(
V=3421V-EAH[( 1-EAH[( F-S2X@3_( F-4ZE1AED1A( >3?B( @3( ?B42VB24^( F4@3?B4@311^(
EWD?1AH[( FZU( 3U3VB4-?BDBAH@1AH[( F4-B3=10( :%;( =( !%;0( V?@BDWB-ED1AH[( U2S(
.-XAC=V-ED1AH[( E( ?F3HAC=H@1A( ?F-?ZS( E( F4-H3?=3( V-X-ED1=DI( ,31( F4-H3?(
X3V-X-ED1=D(-XF-E=DXD(B4D1?C-4.DH>=(-XE4-B13>(,-8I(%DE3B(E(F4@AFDXV2(BDV(
@ED1AH[(?A1DF?(H[3.=H@1AH[0(V=3XA(B4D1?C34(=1C-4.DH>=(F-.=GX@A(1324-1D.=(
-XSAED( ?=G( TWZE1=3( F-F4@3@( ?B42.=31=3( >-1ZE0( >-1A( EDF1=-E3( #D5´( 43T2U2>^(
F4-H3?( 2EDU1=D1=D( 1324-B4D1?.=B34ZE0( VBZ43( E( XDU?@3>( V-U3>1-]H=( F-E-X2>^(
F4@3FWAEA(>-1-E3(=(F->DE=31=3(?=G(F-B31H>DWZE(F-?B?A1DFBAH@1AH[I(
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 5ge(

$( F-EAh?@AH[( F4-H3?ZE( .-U3V2UD41AH[( EAWD1=D( ?=G( .3H[D1=@.( F34H3FQ


H>=0(F-U3TD>^HA(1D(BA.0(h3(F-?B4@3TD13(-S=3VBA(T31342>^H3(E(?31?-4DH[(S-XfQ
H3(?BA.2U2>^H3(2@A?V2>^(43F43@31BDH>G(E(F-?BDH=(E@-4HZE(F-B31H>DWZE(3U3VQ
B4AH@1AH[(E(1324-1DH[I(<DV(2?BDUD(?=G(B31(E3E1GB4@1A0(F4@3?B4@311A(4-@VWDX(
WDX21VZE„( &1C-4.DH>D( E3>]H=-ED( >3?B( .-X2U-ED1D( F4@3@( =1C-4.DH>3( F4@3Q
H[-EAED13( E( FD.=GH=I( `WD]H=E-]H=( -S=3VBZE( 43F43@31B-ED13( ?^( C21VH>^(
TG?B-]H=( WDX21VZE( E( B4Z>EA.=D4-E3>( F4@3?B4@31=( ?A1DFBAH@13>I( %D( B31( 4-@Q
VWDX( WDX21VZE( EFWAED>^( BDVh3( E3E1^B4@V-.Z4V-E3( F4@3FWAEA( ?B42.=31=(
>-1-EAH[0( D( B3( @( V-U3>( X3B34.=1-ED13( ?^( ?B42VB24^( F4@3?B4@311^( X31X4ABZE(
=(DV?-1ZEI( %D?BGF2>3( H=^TWD( =1B34DVH>D( @( >2h( =?B1=3>^HA.=( XD1A.=0( @DFD.=GQ
BD1A.=(E(?B42VB24DH[(.DV4-.-U3V2W0(.-XAC=V-ED1AH[(EH@3]1=3>?@A.=(F4@3Q
FWAED.=(WDX21VZE(E(B4DVH=3(F4-H3X24(2H@31=DI((
(
,-(@DF3E1=D(1=3@SGX1^(FUD?BAH@1-]m(FD.=GH=(.-U3V2UD413>I(&1XAE=X2DU1D(
@X-U1-]m( DXDFBDHA>1D( @DU3hA( -X( =1B34DVH>=( .3H[D1=@.ZE( DXDFBDHA>1AH[( 1D(
4Zh1A.(F-@=-.=3(C21VH>-1DU1A.I(c3H[D1=@.A(DXDFBDHA>13(@E=^@D13(@(.-XAQ
C=VDH>^( 1324-1ZE( =( =H[( DVBAE1-]H=( 1DU3h^( X-( F4-H3?ZE( ?WDS-( >3?@H@3( @SDQ
XD1AH[I( %DU3h^( X-( 1=H[( ?V--4XA1-ED13( F4-H3?A( T313BAH@130( 3F=T313BAH@13(
=(EFWAEA(@3E1GB4@130(BDVh3(E(F-?BDH=(-XX@=DWAED_(WDX21V-EAH[I("S3>.2>^(
-13( .-XAC=VDH>3( T31ZE0( 1=3V-X-ED13T-( :%;( =( !%;( -4D@( F4-B3=1I( $.=D1A(
3F=T313BAH@13( .-T^( SAm( 1=3@.=341=3( @4Zh1=H-ED13( =( X-BAH@Am( .-XAC=VDH>=(
H[3.=H@1AH[( =( 3U3VB4-C=@AH@1AH[( S=DW3V( [=?B-1-EAH[( |`"*)( §( *&%:+% (
5785~I( KB42VB24D( F4@3?B4@311D( H@^?B3H@3V( S=DWV-EAH[( NV-1C-4.DH>DR( >3?B(
2ED421V-ED1D( F4@3@( -XX@=DWAED1=D( .=GX@A( F-?@H@3TZU1A.=( YDB-.D.=\(
=(-XX@=DWAED1=D.=( @( -BDH@D>^HA.=( H@^?B3H@VD.=( S=DW3V( =( VED?ZE( 12VU3=1-Q
EAH[I( `( ?2.=3( -XX@=DWAED1=D( B3( ?VWDXD>^( ?=G( 1D( ?BDS=U=@DH>G( -V43]U-13>(
?B42VB24A( F-F4@3@( H@A11=V=( 3134T3BAH@13( =( 31B4-F-E3I( *=H@SD( X-F2?@H@DUQ
1AH[(V-1C-4.DH>=(E(H@^?B3H@VDH[(S=DW3V(=(VED?ZE(12VU3=1-EAH[(>3?B(-US4@AQ
.=D0(1FI(S=DWV-(-(877(D.=1-VED?DH[(.-h3(F4@A>^m(F-1DX(M(µ(5877(N87e7 R(4ZhQ
1AH[( V-1C-4.DH>=I( #@A11=V=( 31B4-F-E3( ?F4@A>D>^( E=GH( ?B42VB24@3( E(VBZ43>(
E(4ZE1-EDX@3( XA1D.=H@13>( =?B1=3>3( -US4@A.=D( U=H@SD( 4Zh1AH[( C-4.( F4@3Q
?B4@311AH[( S=-.-U3V2WAI( &H[( U=H@SD( >3?B( Dh( 1DXB-( EA?BD4H@D>^HD( X-( V-X-EDQ
1=D(=1C-4.DH>=0(VBZ4^(@DE=34Dm(.-T^(1DE3B(1D>SD4X@=3>(@W-h-13(=.F43?>-1AI((
(
M4@3X?BDE=-1A( .-X3U( 1=3( >3?B( E( ?F4@3H@1-]H=( @( -S-E=^@2>^HA.=( .-X3Q
UD.=( F4-H3?ZE( 1324-1-EAH[( =( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[0( D( 4DH@3>( >3( 2@2F3W1=D( =( -S>D]Q
1=DI(M-(F=34E?@30(E@.DH1=D(-1(B3@G(-(.3X=DHA>13>(4-U=(D?B4-HABZEI(M4@3H=3h(
B-(-13(.D>^(@X-U1-]m(T3134-ED1=D(CDU(EDF1=-EAH[0(VBZ43(V-1B4-U-EDm(.-T^(
5gg( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

2EDU1=D1=3(1324-B4D1?.=B34ZE(X-(F4@3?B4@31=(.=GX@A?A1DFBAH@1AH[I(M-1DXB-(
?BE=34X@-1-0( h3( T31A( D?B4-HABZE( ?^( =?B-B1=3( @DD1TDh-ED13( E( F4-H3?A( F4@3Q
VD@AED1=D( ?AT1DWZEI( ,DV( E=GH( .3H[D1=@.( .-U3V2UD41A( FD.=GH=( B4EDW3>(
.-h3(-S3>.-EDm(4ZE1=3h(D?B4-HAB(E?FZWF4DH2>^H3(=(E(BA.(@DV43?=3(@(1324-Q
1D.=I( M-( X42T=30( -BE=34D1=3( 1-EAH[( VD1DWZE( >-1-EAH[( X@=GV=( 1-E-( F-Q
E?BDWA.( U2S( @.-XAC=V-ED1A.( F4-B3=1-.( EA>D]1=D( .3H[D1=@.( FUD?BAH@1-Q
]H=( ?A1DFBAH@13>I( #AB-ED13( EAh3>( .3H[D1=@.A( BE-4@31=D( =( 3U=.=1DH>=( ?AQ
1DF?0( 2DVBAE1=D1=D( ?A1DF?( 2]F=-1AH[( Nsilent synapseR( F4-EDX@^( X-( @.=D1A(
F4@3?B4@3113T-(4-@VWDX2(?A1DF?(=(=H[(@X-U1-]H=(B4D1?.=?A>1AH[I((
(
'=3XA( 4-@FDB42>3.A( F34H3FH>3( V=UV2( -S=3VBZE( F4@3@( F3E1^( -T4D1=H@-1^(
U=H@SG( 1324-1ZE0( 1DU3hA( @D?B-?-EDm( V-.FU3V?-EA( F4-H3?( ?VWDXD1=D( F=VZE(
V=3421V-EAH[(E(F4A.=BAE13>([=34D4H[=H@13>(?B42VB24@3(1324-1-E3>I(,3(132Q
4-1A( @D>.2>^( -T4D1=H@-1^( F4@3?B4@3_( -SU=H@31=-E^( NF4@3?B4@3_( ?A1DFBAH@1D(
=(1324-1-ED(e:R(=(?^(@X-U13(X-(-XS=-42(?AT1DWZE(-(E@TUGX1=3(S-TDB3>(?B42VQ
B24@3I( 'DhXA( 1324-1( EAV-12>3( V-X-ED1=3( SD@2>^H3( 1D( -B4@A.AED1AH[(
?A1DFBAH@1AH[( E3>]H=DH[( @U=H@D>^HAH[( XD13( E3>]H=-E3I( 'DhX3( E3>]H=3( 132Q
4-12(F-(2H@31=2(.D(1=3H-(@.=31=-1A(4-@VWDX(WDX21VZEI(`-U1D(CD@D(2H@31=D(
V-4AT2>3( ?=WG( F-W^H@3_( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[I( M=V=(V=3421V-E3( ?^( E3VB-4D.=0( D( =H[(
EAFDXV-ED(>3?B(@.=311D(=(BE-4@A(h^XD1^(B4D1?C-4.DH>G0(VBZ4D(-X@E=34H=3XUD(
=.F2U?(?BA.2U2>^HA(F-F4@3@(F4@3?B4@311^(XA?B4AS2H>G(WDX21V2(=(X3B34.=12>3(
H@D?-EA( E@-4@3H( F-S2X@31=D( F-E?BD>^HA( E( F4-H3?=3( F-?B4@3TD1=D2H@31=DI(
M=V=( V=3421V-E3( B4D1?.=B-ED13( F4@3@( .3.S4D1A( ?A1DFBAH@13( 43>3?B4-ED13(
.-T^( SAm( >DV-( F=V=( F-B31H>DW2( 1D( F-?B?A1DF?DH[I( #-( E=GH3>0( 1=3VBZ43( 132Q
4-1A( .-T^( -XS=34Dm( >DV-( ?AT1DW( E3>]H=-EA( 4-@VWDX( WDX21VZE( EA>]H=-EAH[(
?^?=3X1=H[(1324-1ZEI(J?BDUD(?=G(E(B31(?F-?ZS(?D.-2@T-X1=-1A(4-@VWDX(WDX21Q
VZE( E( F4@3?B4@31=( ?A1DFBAH@13>I( M-@D( F4@3?B4@311A.( V-X-ED1=3.( =1C-4Q
.DH>D( -( V?@BDWH=3( V=3421V-EA.( E3VB-4D( F-S2X@31=D( >3?B( -X@E=34H=3XUD1D(
H@G]H=-E-( F4@3@( H@D?-E^( H[D4DVB34A?BAVG( F=VZE( F-B31H>DWZE( H@A11-]H=-Q
EAH[I( "SU=H@-1D( @( .-X3U2( .DB3.DBAH@13T-( C21VH>D( F4DEX-F-X-S=3_?BED(
4-@VWDX2(F=VZE(F-VD@2>30(h3(=?B-B1=3(H@G]m(=1C-4.DH>=(-(BA.(4-@VWDX@=3(.-h3(
SAm( F4@3VD@AED1D( E( C-4.=3( H@D?-E3>( H[D4DVB34A?BAV=( F->DE=D1=D( ?=G( BAH[(
F=VZEI( <3]U=( ?=G( >^( F4@3D1DU=@2>30( B-( ?BD>3( ?=G( E=X-H@130( h3( F4@AF-.=1D( -1D(
B3-43BAH@1A( ?B-H[D?BAH@1A( F4-H3?( F21VB-EA( M-=??-1D0( F-X-S1A( X-( H=^TZE(
=.F2U?ZE(CDVBAH@1=3(43>3?B4-ED1AH[(E(.Z@T2(|%"`;'(=(=1I(8OOtz(K"%j(=(=1I(
5777~I(`(F4@AFDXV2(F34H3FH>=(@W-h-13>(?H31A0(-S3>.2>^H3>(U=H@13(-S=3VBA0(@DQ
D1TDh-ED1D( >3?B( E=3UVD( U=H@SD( 1324-1ZE( =( ?A1DF?0( H[D4DVB34A?BAH@1D( XUD( V-Q
U2.1( 1324-1-EAH[0( VBZ4D( .2?=( F-X-WDm( UDE=1-E3.2( E@4-?B-E=( EA.=D4-Q
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 5g9(

E-]H=( ?AT1DW2( E3>]H=-E3T-I( <3?B( SD4X@-( F4DEX-F-X-S130( h3( F4@3?B4@311-Q


QH@D?-EA(4-@VWDX(WDX21VZE(=(EA1=VD>^H3(?B^X(-XX@=DWAED1=D(?^(F-X?BDE-E^(
F4@AH@A1^( V?@BDWB2( =( H[D4DVB34A?BAV=( H@D?-E3>( F=VZE( F->DE=D>^HAH[( ?=G(
E(1324-1DH[(=(@3?F-WDH[(1324-1ZE(=(=H[(EA?-H3([3B34-T31=H@1AH[(-XF-E=3Q
X@=( 1D( =.F2U?A( ?BA.2U2>^H30( -S?34E-ED13( X-]E=DXH@DU1=3( E( .2UB=1324-Q
1-EA.( @DF=?=3( |d+% ( =( =1I(577tz(,"*bJ!K, (=(=1I( 577O~I(#@G?B-]m(F=VZE( F-Q
S2X@3_( 1=3( V-X2>3( E=GH( =1C-4.DH>=0( D( -X@E=34H=3XUD( F-EBD4@D>^HA( ?=G( ?H[3Q
.DB( 2H@31=DI( $DU3hA( -1D( -X( ?=WA( =( @1DH@31=D( S-XfHD( -4D@( 1DBGh31=D( 2EDT=I(
#DWD( .DB3.DBAH@1D( B3-4=D( V-X-ED1=D( =1C-4.DH>=( E( F-?BDH=( H@G?B-]H=( =( H[DQ
4DVB34A?BAV=( H@D?-E3>( =.F2U?ZE( >3?B( @DB3.( >3X1-EA.=D4-EA.( NE( C21VH>=(
H@D?2R( F4@ASU=h31=3.( SD4X@=3>( -TZU13>( B3-4==( F4@3BED4@D1=D( =1C-4.DH>=( @D(
F-.-H^(WDX21VZE0(VBZ4^(;24(=(<-T(1D@EDU=(%324-Q+U3HB4-Q:A1D.=V^(%+:I(
(
"S4D@(?H31A(.-h3(SAm(@DV-X-ED1A(=(F-@-?BDEDm(E(FD.=GH=(4-S-H@3>(BDV(
XW2T-0(>DV(XW2T-(2B4@A.2>^(?=G(?BD1A(3U3VB4AH@13(1324-1ZE(S=-4^HAH[(2X@=DW(
E( F4-H3?=3( V-X-ED1=DI( ,31( ?D.( -S4D@( .-h3( SAm( F4@AF-.1=D1A-XBE-4@-1A(
@3(E@-4HD(?BD1ZE(3U3VB4AH@1AH[(F-B31H>DWZE(H@A11-]H=-EAH[I(cDB4AHD(?A1DFQ
BAH@1D0( 43DU=@2>^HD( B4D1?C-4.DH>G( ,Q8 ( -XBED4@D( -S4D@( @( 4-@VWDX2( F4@3?B4@31Q
13T-( WDX21VZEI( ,-( @>DE=?V-( F4@AF-.=1D1=D( =1B31H>-1DU13T-( @-?BDW-( F-Q
BE=34X@-13(3V?F34A.31BDU1=3(|j+*l;!:QK;j&p(577P~I(`(B4DVH=3( F4@AF-.=Q
1D1=D(F-S2X@D1A(>3?B(VDhX-4D@-E-(B31(?D.(@3?BDE(1324-1ZE0(VBZ4A(@DD1TDQ
h-ED1A( SAW( E( H@D?=3( F=34E?@3>( F43@31BDH>=( -S=3VB2I( JEDhD( ?=G0( h3( .3H[DQ
1=@.(B31(-XF-E=DXD(@D(C21VH>-1-ED1=3(FD.=GH=(V4ZBV-B4EDW3>(.Z@T2I(
(
,3-4=D( %+:( E?FD1=DU3( 2@2F3W1=D( .-X3U( )KK( =( %McI( `=X@=.A( -S3H1=30(
h3( F-4ZE1AED1=3( E@-4HZE( F-S2X@3_( 1324-1DU1AH[0( E?BGF2>^HAH[( ?@UDVD.=(
DC3431B1A.=( -X( ?31?-4ZE( BE-4@^HAH[( 1D?@3( @.A?WA0( @( E@-4HD.=( .-X3U=(
2BE-4@-1A.=( 2F4@3X1=-( E( EAh?@AH[( ED4?BEDH[( ?=3H=( 1324-1-E3>( E( F4-H3Q
?DH[(2H@31=D0(.-h3(@DH[-X@=m(CDVBAH@1=3I(cD.A(.3H[D1=@.(X-F4-EDX@D1=D(
X-(F->3XA1H@3T-(EG@WD(?=3H=(?AT1DWZE(@(4ZE1-U3TWAH[(]H=3h3V(D1DU=@2>^HAH[(
=113(H3H[A(-S=3VB2(U2S(?AT1DWA(@(=11AH[(.-XDU1-]H=0(H-(2.-hU=E=D(D?-H>DH>3(
=(?V->D4@31=DI( ,-(F-4ZE1AED1=3(.-h3( @DH[-X@=m( 1D( VDhXA.(F-@=-.=3( F4@3Q
BED4@D1=D(=1C-4.DH>=I($1D.A(>2h(.-U3V2UD41A(.3H[D1=@.(BE-4@31=D(.31BDUQ
1AH[(43F43@31BDH>=(.-X3U=I(K^(B-(.DH=34@3(.DV4-.-U3V2UD4130(X3B34.=12>^H3(
-XX@=DWAED1=D( WDX21V-E3( E3VB-4ZE( =.F2U?ZE( 2V=3421V-ED1AH[0( BE-4@^H3(
=.F43?>-1A( 1D( E?@A?BV=H[( ?@H@3SUDH[( [=34D4H[==( 1324-1-EAH[( FZU( .-X3U2Q
>^HAH[0(D?-H>2>^H3(X@=GV=(?F4@Gh31=-.(DC3431B1A.0(3CDBAH@1A.(=(@E4-B1A.I(
(
5gn( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

%=3( E=3.A( BAUV-0( XUDH@3T-( .Z@T( B-( 4-S=I( <DV( X-H[-X@=( X-( XDU?@3T-(
F4@3BED4@D1=D(4D@(>2h(4-@F-@1D1AH[(F34H3FBZE(=(V-1?B42-ED1=D(=.F43?>-1ZE(
EAh?@3T-( 4@GX2„( <DV( F4@3H[-EAED13( ?^( =.F43?>-1A0( VBZ43( -X@E=34H=3XUD>^(
3F=@-XA( @( 1D?@3T-( hAH=D„( #@A( 1DX( C=@AH@1A.=( F4-H3?D.=( -XX@=DWAED1=D(
WDX21VZE( 3U3VB4AH@1AH[( @( 4-@VWDXD.=( F-B31H>DWZE( E( .-U3V2WDH[( 1D?@3>(
BVD1V=( .Z@T-E3>( .-h3.A( @DFD1-EDm( =( H@A( E( @E=^@V2( @( BA.0( F-?=DXD.A(
H[-m(1D.=D?BVG(E-U13>(E-U=„(
(
•3SA( -XF-E=3X@=3m( 1D( B3( FABD1=D0( 1DU3hA( @1DU3fm( .-U3V2UD413( =( 1324-Q
1-E3( .3H[D1=@.A( .-BAEDH>=0( VBZ4A.( F-XU3TD.A0( FD.=GH=( =( =H[( EFWAE2(1D(
-4TD1=@DH>G( F4-H3?2( F34H3FH>=( -4D@( V?@BDWB-ED1=D( ]E=DX-.-]H=I( ,4@3SD( EAQ
>D]1=m0( H-( @.2?@D( 1D?( X-( @X-SAED1=D( 1-E3>( E=3X@A0( S-( E( BA.( ?^( f4ZXWD(
=1?BA1VB2( E=3X@A( N'&RI( %DU3hA( B3h( U3F=3>( @X3C=1=-EDm0( >DV=3T-( 4-X@D>2(
]E=DX-.-]H=( -H@3V2>3.A( =( >DV^( >3?B3].A( @X-U1=( -S>D]1=m( @D( F-.-H^( BDV(
?=U1=3(43X2VH>-1=?BAH@1AH[(.-X3U=I(
(
(
OI(J`;j;I(c+#b;%&$cd(M;c&r#& (
(
M4@3X?BDE=-1A( E( F-F4@3X1=.( 4-@X@=DU3( .-X3U( %+:( -S>D]1=D( C21VH>-1-Q
ED1=3( FD.=GH=( 4-S-H@3>( 2B4@A.AED1=3.( ?BD1ZE( F-B31H>DWZE( 3U3VB4AH@1AH[(
E(?A1DF?DH[(=(=11AH[(H@G]H=DH[(V-.Z43V(1324-1ZE0(D(FD.=GH=(V4ZBV-B4EDW3>(
=(B4EDW3>(V-X-ED1=3.(=1C-4.DH>=(E(@.-XAC=V-ED1AH[(U2S(1-E-(F-E?BDWAH[(
F4-B3=1DH[( =( :%;I( `( BAH[( >3X1DVh3( .3H[D1=@.DH[( V4A>3( ?=G( E=3U3( ?2SB3UQ
1-]H=0( VBZ4AH[( F4@3>DE3.( >3?B( S-TDHBE-( @>DE=?V( X-BAH@^HAH[( @XDED1=D( ?-Q
S=3( ?F4DEA( @( H=^TW-]H=( F4-H3?2( F-?B4@3TD1=D0( @DFD.=GBAED1=D( F-@A?VD13>(
E=3X@A( E( V4ZBV=H[( =( XW2T=H[( -V43?DH[0( F4@AF-.=1D1=D( ?-S=3( -XU3TWAH[( @XDQ
4@3_( E( ?VDU=( hAH=D( -?-S1=H@3T-( -4D@( E=3U2( @>DE=?V( F?AH[=H@1AH[0( @E=^@DQ
1AH[(@(C21VH>-1-ED1=3.(1D?@3>(FD.=GH=I(&?B-B1D(>3?B(43UDH>D(@DF=?D13>(=1C-4Q
.DH>=(X-(F4-H3?ZE(]E=DX-.-]H=(=(2EDT=I(;(BDVh3(.-hU=E-]m(B4D1?C342(=1C-4Q
.DH>=(F-.=GX@A(4Zh1A.=(4-X@D>D.=(FD.=GH=I((
(
J`;j;(

c3H[D1=@.3.0(VBZ4A(.D(=?B-B1A(EFWAE(1D(1D?@^(FD.=Gm0(>3?B(.3H[D1=@.(
Y2EDT=\I(c3H[D1=@.(B31(X3HAX2>30(H-(@1D>X2>3(?=G(E(F-U2(1D?@3T-(E=X@31=D(
U2S(E(F-U2(2EDT=0(D(-@1DH@D(B-(B3(E4Dh31=D0(VBZ43(]E=DX-.=3(E(XD13>(H[E=U=(
-XS=34D.A0( -4D@( B30( -( VBZ4AH[( DVB2DU1=3( .A]U=.AI( $3( E@TUGX2( 1D( F-?B2U-Q
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 5gt(

ED1^( E( BAH[( 4-@EDhD1=DH[( >3X1-4-X1-]m( ?B42VB24A( ?=3H=( 1324-1-E3>( .-h1D(


F4@A>^m0( h3( 1D?@A.( 2VWDX3.( E@4-V-EA.0( EAS=34D>^HA.( -S=3VBA0( 1D( VBZ43(
@E4DHD.A( 2EDTG0( SGX^( ?B34-EDWA( F-X-S13( .3H[D1=@.A0( H-( =( 1D?@A.=( F4-Q
H3?D.=(.A]U-EA.=0(EAS=34D>^HA.=(=.F43?>-1A0(VBZ43(F4@AE-W2>3.A(@(1D?@3>(
FD.=GH=(B4EDW3>I(,3(EAS4D13(=.F43?>-1A(D1DU=@2>3.A0(?@2VD>^H(=.F43?>-1ZE(
F-X-S1AH[( U2S( =.F43?>-1ZE( EAh?@3T-( 4@GX20( =( ?BD4D.A( ?=G( EAV4Am( F-X-Q
S=3_?BED(X-(@1D1AH[(>2h(.-X3U=(F->Gm0(@4-@2.=3m(?H31G(E4D@(@3(E?@A?BV=.=(
>3>( -S=3VBD.=( =( EV-.F-1-EDm( >^( E( F-?=DXD1A( >2h( .-X3U( 4@3H@AE=?B-]H=I(
cZ@T( .D( @X-U1-]m( X-( =1B31H>-1DU13T-( F4@3?@2V=ED1=D( FD.=GH=I( <3?B( B-( 4-@Q
E=1=GH=3(@X-U1-]H=(X-(EA?@2V=ED1=D(E@-4HZE0(VBZ43(.-T^(SAm(F-4ZE1AEDQ
13( F4@3@( F-UD( .-X3U2>^H3( %McI( M-S2X@D>^H( =.F43?>-1A( ?V->D4@-13( @( BA.=0(
VBZ43(@1D>X2>^(?=G(E(F-U2(2EDT=0(X-V-12>3.A(F4@3?21=GH=D(2EDT=(1D(B3(1-E3(
=.F43?>-1AI(c3H[D1=@.(2EDT=(B-(EWD]1=3(?3U3VH>D(=.F43?>-1ZE0(VBZ43(@1D>Q
X^( ?=G( E( FD.=GH=( 4-S-H@3>( 2.A?W2( =( @-?BD1^( E( B31( ?F-?ZS( 2]E=DX-.=-13I(
c3H[D1=@.(B31(>3?B(F4@3W^H@D1A(F4@3@(@.=D1A(V-1C=T24DH>=(F-S2X@3_(?A1DFQ
BAH@1AH[(U2S(V-.Z4V-EAH[I((
%D>U3F=3>( >3?B( B-( E=X-H@13( E3( E@4-V-EAH[( V-.Z4VDH[( ?31?-4AH@1AH[0(
@1D>X2>^HAH[( ?=G( E( ?=DBVZEH3( -VDI( `( F4@AFDXV2( 2VWDX2( E@4-V-E3T-( ?E^(
2EDTG(V-1H31B42>3.A(1D(H31B4DU13>( H@G]H=(F-UD(E=X@31=D(-(1D>E=GV?@3>(4-@Q
X@=3UH@-]H=0( @DE=34D>^H3>( 1D>E=GV?@^( U=H@SG( H@-FVZEI( <3]U=( E( -S4D@=3( >DV=](
-S=3VB( @E4ZH=( 1D?@^( 2EDTG0( B-( @E4DHD.A( E@4-V( E( BA.( V=3421V2( =( EFDB42Q
>3.A(?=G(E(B31(-S=3VB(BDV0(DSA(BD(H31B4DU1D(?B43CD(T-(-S3>.-EDWDI(M34AC34A>13(
H@G]H=( ?=DBVZEV=( EAF-?Dh-13( ?^( E( E=GV?@^( U=H@SG( F4GH=VZE0( .1=3>( H@2WAH[(
1D(1DBGh31=3(]E=DBWD(=(V-U-4A0(D(@D(B-(SD4X@=3>(E4DhU=EAH[(1D(42H[(-S=3VBZE(
E(F-U2(E=X@31=DI(c=G]1=3(-H@2(=(TW-EA(F-@EDUD>^(1D.(F-X^hDm(@D(-S=3VB3.(
=(V-1BA12-EDm(EFDB4AED1=3(?=G(E(-S=3VB(F4@AH=^TD>^HA(1D?@^(2EDTGI(#3H[D.=(
-S=3VBZE0( VBZ43( F4@AH=^TD>^( 2EDTG0( ?^( F4@3X3( E?@A?BV=.( 1-E-]m( -S=3VB2(
=(XA1D.=H@1D( @.=D1D( >3T-( H3H[I( M-UD( 43H3FB-4-E3( 43DT2>^( 1D( @.=D1A( 1DBGQ
h31=D(S-XfHZE(?BA.2U2>^HAH[I(`(F->3XA1H@A.(F=V?3U2(B3(@.=D1A(.-T^(SAm(
F-E-X-ED13( @.=D1^( 1DBGh31=D( U2S( SD4EA( ]E=DBWDI( %D>E=GV?@D( >3X1DVh3(
XA1D.=VD(@.=D1(@E=^@D1D(>3?B(@(42H[3.(-S=3VB2I(:-(EAh?@AH[(ED4?BE(?=3H=(
1324-1-E3>( EA?AWD13( ?^( F-S2X@31=D( @( -US4@A.=3>( U=H@SA( H@-FVZE( =( F4GH=Q
VZE( 43F43@31B2>^H3( U=H@13( XA1D.=H@1=3( @.=3113( -S=3VBAI( %D>E=GV?@^( >3XQ
1DVh3( ?=WG( .D>^( B30( VBZ43( F-H[-X@^( @( FZU( H31B4DU1AH[0( TX@=3( @.=D1A( ?^(
1D>SD4X@=3>( XA1D.=H@13I( `( 4-@X@=DU3( e( -F=?DU=].A( F4-H3X24G( `,;0( VBZ4D(
>3?B(?=U1A.(.3H[D1=@.3.(XA?V4A.=1DHA>1A.I(K3U3VH>-12>3(-1D(S-XfH3(-(1D>Q
E=GV?@A.( @1DH@31=2( XUD( ?V2B3H@13T-( X@=DWD1=DI( <3>( X@=DWD1=3( E=^h3( ?=G(
@(.3H[D1=@.D.=( EA@EDUD1=D( F-S2X@3_( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[0( @T-X1A.( @( %+:I(
5gP( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

<3?B(-1D(H@G]H=^([324A?BAV=(-V43]UD>^H3>(?F-?-SA(43DT-ED1=D(1324-12(E(.=V4-Q
V-U2.1=3(1D(X-H=34D>^H3(X-(1=3T-(F-S2X@31=DI((
c3H[D1=@.3.( E@.DH1=D>^HA.( 3C3VB( ?3U3VH>=( >3?B( X@=DWD1=3( BDV( @ED1AH[(
1324-1ZE( [D.2>^HAH[0( EA?BGF2>^HAH[( E( B-ED4@A?BE=3( 1324-1ZE( F-S2X@DQ
>^HAH[0( H@AU=( @EAVU3( V-.Z43V( F=4D.=X-EAH[( =( TE=DfX@=?BAH[I( %324-1A( B30(
1D@AED13( BDVh3( =1B341324-1D.=0( EA?BGF2>^( .1=3>( U=H@1=3( =( ?BD1-E=^( -VI( 896
57¶( 1324-1ZE( F-S2X@D>^HAH[I( &X31BAC=V-ED13( ?^( F4@3EDh1=3( >DV-( 1324-1A(
V-?@AH@V-E3( =( VD1X3UDS4-E3I( JEDU1=D>^( TWZE1=3( 1324-B4D1?.=B34A( j;l;(
-BE=34D>^H3( VD1DWA( >-1-E3( #U-I( #@G]m( @( 1=H[( -XX@=DW2>3( 1D( X31X4ABA( =( F4@AQ
F2?@H@DU1=3( F3W1=( -TZU13( C21VH>3( [D.2>^H30( @DF-S=3TD>^H3( F-E?BDED1=2(
X-XDB1=H[(?F4@Gh3_(@E4-B1AH[(XD>^HAH[(-S>DEA(FDB-U-T=H@13(N1FI(3F=U3F?>GRI(
&113( =1B341324-1A0( DVBAE2>^H3( F4-B3=1G( @ED1^( FD4EDUS2.=1^0( -XX@=DW2>^(
S3@F-]43X1=-(1D(F34AVD4=-1(1324-12I(,3(V-.Z4V=(S2X2>^(EA?-H3(EA?F3H>DU=Q
@-ED13>( ?B42VB24A( =( F4@AH@A1=D>^( ?=G( X-( EA?F3H>DU=@-ED1AH[( 43DVH>=0( VBZ43(
-V43]UD>^( ?3U3VBAE1-]m( 43DVH>=( 1324-1-EAH[I( &H[( X@=DWD1=3( X3C=1=-ED13( >3?B(
F-F4@3@( V-.S=1DH>G( 4Zh1AH[( H3H[0( .=GX@A( =11A.=( ?B42VB24G( F-W^H@3_0( DVBAQ
E-ED1=3( T31ZE0( EWD]H=E-]H=( 3U3VB4-C=@>-U-T=H@13( =( 4-X@D>3( 43DVH>=( |!J%Q
d;% ( =( =1I( 5787~I( :A1D.=@2>^( E( B31( ?F-?ZS( .3H[D1=@.( 2EDT=( EFWAED>^H(
@D4ZE1-(1D(F4-H3?A([DS=B2DH>=0(>DV(=(XA?[DS=B2DH>=I(
M-X-S1=3( 1324-1A( E( EAh?@AH[( ED4?BEDH[( [=34D4H[=H@13>( ?B42VB24A( ?=3H=(
1324-1-E3>(?3U3VH>-12>^(F-S2X@31=D(H[D4DVB34A@2>^H3(?=G(3U3.31BD.=(1-E-Q
]H=( =( @.=311-]H=I( l-XfHD.=( ?^( =.F43?>-1A( SGX^H3( .31BDU1A.=( 43F43@31BDQ
H>D.=(-S=3VBZE0(F34H3FBZE0(?H31(U2S(3F=@-XZEI(&H[(XA1D.=VD(=(@T-X1-]m(@3(
E@-4HD.=( E( FD.=GH=( X3HAX2>3( -( @E4ZH31=2( 1D( 1=3( 1D?@3>( 2EDT=I( ;VBAE13(
F-S2X@31=D( X-H=34D>^H3( X-( ]E=DX-.-]H=( X@=GV=( ?3U3VH>=( F4@3F4-EDX@D13>(
F4@3@(.3H[D1=@.(2EDT=(1D@AED.A(FD.=GH=^(4-S-H@^(U2S(-F34DHA>1^I(,-(B31(
4-X@D>( FD.=GH=( 2.-hU=E=D( F-4ZE1AED1=3( E@-4HZE.-X3U=( @DV-X-ED1AH[(
E(?B42VB24@3(S=DW3V(EAF3W1=D>^HAH[(1324-1A(E?@A?BV=H[(ED4?BE(?=3H=(@(V-1Q
C=T24DH>D.=(?BD1ZE(F-S2X@3_(43F43@31B2>^HA.=(S-XfH3(?31?-4AH@13I(
M4-H3?A( B3( .-T^( -XSAEDm( ?=G( 4ZE1-U3TU3( =( 4ZE1-H@3]1=30( U3H@( ?^( ?3U3VQ
H>-1-ED13( =( X-F2?@H@D13( X-( ]E=DX-.-]H=( F4@3@( .3H[D1=@.( 2EDT=( X@=GV=(
@D?DX@=3( `,;I( c3H[D1=@.( 2EDT=( >3?B( 1DB24DU1=3( 2V?@BDWB-ED1A.( @DH[-Q
ED1=3.0( @E=^@D1A.( @( -T4D1=H@-1^( F4@3F2?B-E-]H=^( =1C-4.DBAH@1^( 1D?@3T-(
.Z@T2I( <DV( >2h( F=?DU=].A( EAh3>0( ?B42.=3_( =1C-4.DH>=( X-H=34D>^HAH[( X-( 1DQ
?@3T-( .Z@T2( @( E=3U2( .-XDU1-]H=( 4ZE1-H@3]1=30( F4@3V4DH@D( 87( cl?0( F-XQ
H@D?(TXA(1D?@3(@.A?WA(S-.SD4X-ED13(?^(?AT1DWD.=(@(-B-H@31=D(@(=1B31?AEQ
1-]H=^(F-1DX(8(jl?I(`(F-U2(F-?B4@3TD1=D(.-h3(@1D>X-EDm(?=G(E=3U3(-S=3VQ
BZE(4ZE1-H@3]1=3I(%D?@3(@.A?WA(1=3(.-T^(4ZE1-H@3]1=3(F-?B4@3TDm(E?@A?BQ
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 5gO(

V=3T-0(D(1D?@(2.A?W(1=3(.-h3(>3X1-H@3]1=3(.A]U3m(-(E?@A?BV=.I(J.A?W(.2?=(
X-V-1AEDm( ?3U3VH>=0( H-( @1D>X@=3( ?=G( E( >3T-( FD.=GH=( 4-S-H@3>0( D( BD( ?3U3VH>D0(
B-( EWD]1=3( Y2EDTD\I( c=.-( h3( F-H@2H=3( Y2EDT=\( >3?B( C31-.313.( F?AH[-Q
U-T=H@1A.0(E?VD@DU=].A(1D(>3T-(F-XW-h3(.-U3V2UD413(=(1324-1-E3I(M-VD@DQ
U=].A(B3h0(h3(.D(-1-(?=U1A(@E=^@3V(@(C21VH>-1-ED1=3.(FD.=GH=(4-S-H@3>I((
(
MD.=Gm(4-S-H@D0(.=.-(h3(>3?B(4-@F4-?@-1D(E(X2hAH[(-S?@D4DH[(?=3H=(132Q
4-1-E3>0( >3?B( -T4D1=H@-1D( .3H[D1=@.3.( 2EDT=I( `( @E=^@V2( @( BA.( .D( 1=3Q
E=3UV^(F->3.1-]mI(lDXD1=D(F?AH[-U-T=H@13(E?VD@2>^0(h3(F->3.1-]m(FD.=GH=(
4-S-H@3>(4Zh1=(?=G(-?-S1=H@-(=(.-h30(F-F4@3@(B431=1T0(@E=GV?@Dm(?E^(F->3.Q
1-]mI( $EAVU3( >3X1DVh3( .Z@T=( U2X@V=3( @DFD.=GB2>^( X-4Df1=3( @DU3XE=3( V=UVD(
3U3.31BZE0( n6P( HAC4( E( 12.34@3( B3U3C-1=H@1A.0( 4DH[21V2( SD1V-EA.( U2S(
V=UVD(1D@E=?V(1D(U=]H=3(-S3H1-]H=I(M-X-S1A(F-B31H>DW(E=^h3(?=G(@(X-F2?@H@3Q
1=3.(U=H@SA(-S=3VBZEF4-H3?ZE(X-(1D?@3>(]E=DX-.-]H=I(&113(SDXD1=D(E?VDQ
@2>^0(h3(F->3.1-]m(FD.=GH=(V4ZBV-B4EDW3>(E=@2DU13>(>3?B(-T4D1=H@-1D(X-(e6g(
3U3.31BZE( |,"::( §( c;!"&K( 577g~I( M-@-41=3( >3?B( B-( E( ?F4@3H@1-]H=( @( V-Q
1=3H@1-]H=^( F4@3BE-4@31=D( F4@3@( BG( FD.=Gm( @1DH@^H3T-( ?B42.=31=D( =1C-4.DQ
H>=I(%DU3hA(>3X1DV(@E4ZH=m(2EDTG0(h3(?BD1A(3U3VB4AH@13(?A1DF?(1324-1ZE(FZU(
?31?-4AH@1AH[( .-T^( 4ZE1-U3TU3( -X@E=34H=3XUDm( -US4@A.=^( U=H@SG( ?BD1ZE(
F-S2X@3_( ?31?-4AH@1AH[I( %DB-.=D?B( .3H[D1=@.( 2EDT=( >3?B( C=UB43.( XA?V4AQ
.=1DHA>1A.( Y?WDS?@AH[\( ?AT1DWZEI( ,DV( E=GH( FD.=Gm( 4-S-H@D0( ?31?-4AH@1D(
.D( X-?BDB3H@1^( F4@3F2?B-E-]m( F4@3X( C=UB43.( =( SD4X@-( 1=3E=3UV^( F->3.1-]m(
3U3.31BZE( F4@3H[-X@^HAH[( F4@3@( C=UB4( 2EDT=( =( ]E=DX-.-]H=0( @DFD.=GBAQ
ED1AH[(1D>F=34E(E(FD.=GH=(V4ZBV-B4EDW3>0(D(F-B3.(XW2T-B4EDW3>I(M4@A>.2>3(
?=G0( h3( 2.A?W( .-h3( 4ZE1-H@3]1=3( V-1B4-U-EDm( 9 · g( H@A11-]H=I( `AXD>3( ?=G0(
h3( E( 4@3H@AE=?B-]H=( 2.A?W( .-h3( V-1H31B4-EDm( ?=G( 1D( >3X13>( H@A11-]H=(
E(XD13>( H[E=U=0( D( EAV-1AED1=3( E=3U2( H@A11-]H=( 4ZE1-H@3]1=3( -XSAED( ?=G(
X@=GV=(?@ASV=3.2(F4@3W^H@D1=2(2EDT=I((
(
,DAU-4( @DF4-F-1-EDW( .-X3U0( E( VBZ4A.( 2EDTD( ?B34-ED1D( >3?B( ?AT1DWD.=(
>^X4D(?=DBV-EDB3T-(E@TZ4@D(Nnucleus reticularis thalami(%!,R0(E@.DH1=D>^Q
HA.=(V-1V2431H>G(?AT1DWZE(|, ;d*"! (577t0(577O~I(K3U3VH>D(?AT1DWZE(-?=^Q
TD1D( X@=GV=( B3.2( .3H[D1=@.-E=( .D( SAm( BDV( ?V2B3H@1D0( h3( ?D.D( Y2EDTD\(
.-h3( SAm( EA?BD4H@D>^HD( X-( F->DE=31=D( ?=G( ]E=DX-.-]H=I( <D12?@( KBD4@AV(
F-BE=34X@D0( h3( C21VH>-1-ED1=3( .3H[D1=@.2( 2EDT=( >3?B( V-1=3H@130( U3H@( 1=3(
EA?BD4H@D>^H3I( :@=DWD1=3( .3H[D1=@.2( F4@3W^H@D>^H3T-( 2EDTG( .2?=( SAm(
E?FD4B3( .-BAEDH>^( X3C=1=2>^H^( H3U( =( E( B31( ?F-?ZS( -V43]UD>^H^0( 1D( H@A.(
2EDTD( F-E=11D( ?=G( V-1H31B4-EDmI( '=34-ED1=3( 2EDT=( 1D?BGF2>3( F4@3@( ]E=DQ
597( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

X-.A(EA?=W3VI(`(3C3VH=3(EAWD1=D1=3(?=G(]E=DX-.-]H=(1D?BGF2>3(F-X(EFWAE3.(
?AT1DWZE(top-down0(F-F4@3@(V-1H31B4DH>G(2EDT=(1D(EAS4D1AH[(F-S2X@31=DH[0(
EDh1AH[( @3( E@TUGX2( 1D( 43DU=@-ED13( H3U3I( `( V-1?3VE31H>=( KBD4@AV( @T-X1A(
>3?B( @( ,DAU-43.( H-( X-( ?B342>^H3>( 4-U=( ]E=DX-.-]H=0( EF4-EDX@D>^H( .-BAEDH>G(
>DV-(2@2F3W1=D>^HA(ED4213V(>3>(EA?BGF-ED1=D(|K,;!$d'(§(M!;K;:(5788~I(
(
M;c&r¤(

<3?B( SD4X@-( F4DEX-F-X-S130( h3( EA4Zh1=D1A( E]4ZX( =11AH[( .3H[D1=@.( FDQ


.=GH=( V4ZBV-B4EDW3>0(F-@EDUD>^HA( 1D.(@DFD.=GBAEDm( -S=3VBA( @E=^@D13(@(S=3Q
h^HA.=( @DXD1=D.=0( >3?B( F4@3XW2h31=3.( FD.=GH=( 4-S-H@3>I( %D?2ED( ?=G( EABW2Q
.DH@31=3( B3T-( 4-X@D>2( .3H[D1=@.2( >DV-( ?BD1( F-]43X1=( F-.=GX@A( -F=?D1^(
F-EAh3>(FD.=GH=^(B4EDW^(D(FD.=GH=^(4-S-H@^I(M-?B2U-ED1A(.3H[D1=@.(.-h3(
SAm( @E=^@D1A( @( BE-4@31=3.( =( .-XAC=VDH>^( F4-B3=1( F-X( EFWAE3.( 4-@VWDXZE(
F-B31H>DWZE( EA1=VD>^HA.( @3( ?BD1ZE( 3U3VB4AH@1AH[( FD.=GH=( 4-S-H@3>I( %=3(
@DH[-X@=(B2(>3X1DV(B4D1?V4AFH>D(X-(:%;!%;I(`(@E=^@V2(@(BA.(H@D?(B4EDQ
1=D( @DF=?ZE( E( B3>( FD.=GH=( E=^h3( ?=G( @( B4EDW-]H=^( @.-XAC=V-ED1AH[( .DV4-Q
.-U3V2W0( ?=GTD>^H^0( >DV( E?VD@AEDU=].A( EAh3>0( -X( V=UV2( .=12B0( T-X@=1( X-(
V=UV2( X1=I( M-@EDUD( 1D.( B-( @DFD.=GBDm( E=34?@( U2S( XD13( X-( @DXD_0( VBZ43(
DVB2DU1=3( EAV-12>3.AI( JB4EDU31=2( @DF=?ZE( ?F4@A>D( F-EBD4@D1=3( F4-H3X24A(
2H@31=D(U2S(F-?B4@3TD1=D(B3T-(?D.3T-(-S=3VB2I(M-1=3EDh(.-U3V2WA(B3(F-?=DQ
XD>^(F4@3XW2h-1^(B4EDW-]m(F-(@D1=V2(?BD1ZE(3U3VB4AH@1AH[(FD.=GH=(4-S-H@3>0(
F->3.1-]m( B3>( FD.=GH=( >3?B( @1DH@1=3( E=GV?@DI( $D1=V( ?BD1ZE( 3U3VB4AH@1AH[(
-@1DH@D( 2?21=GH=3( =1C-4.DH>=( @3( ]E=DX-.-]H=I( `( VDhX3>( H[E=U=( .-T^( -13(
SAm(F4@AE-WD13(F-F4@3@(F4-H3?(F4@AF-.=1D1=DI(M4@AF-.=1D1=3(F4@3XW2hD(B3h(
B4ED1=3( @DF=?ZE( E( FD.=GH=( V4ZBV-B4EDW3>I( "XSAEDm( ?=G( B-( .-h3( X@=GV=(
E?F-.1=D1A.(EAh3>(FGBU-.(?F4@Gh3_(@E4-B1AH[(BE-4@-1AH[(F4@3@(1324-1A(
43V2431HA>13(|l !":$&;'(5778~I(
<3?B(BDVh3(EA?-H3(F4DEX-F-X-S130(h3(EA?3U3VH>-1-ED13(F4@3@(.3H[D1=@.(
Y2EDT=\( ?AT1DWA( 1D( F-@=-.=3( ?31?-4AH@1A.( U2S( ?A.S-U=H@1A.0( 2]E=DX-Q
.=-13(E(FD.=GH=(V4ZBV-B4EDW3>0(.-T^(SAm(2B4EDU-13(E(FD.=GH=(XW2T-B4EDW3>I(
(
M;c&r¤(,!`;£;(&(K,!J',J!d(`!":$"%+(

#[-m(EAXD>3(?=G0(h3(X-BAH[H@D?-E3(F-TU^XA(1D(.3H[D1=@.( @DF=?2(=1C-4Q
.DH>=(E(FD.=GH=(B4EDW3>(?^(F4@3V-1AED>^H30(B-(>3X1DV(VUD?AH@1A(b3SS-E?V=(
.3H[D1=@.(E@.-H1=31=D(?A1DFBAH@13T-(@-?BDW(@DVE3?B=-1-ED1A(F4@3@(E=3U2(
SDXDH@A( F-F4@3@( EAVD@D1=30( h3( XA1D.=H@13( @.=D1A( ?A1DFBAH@13( 1=3( .-T^(
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 598(

SAm( -XF-E=3X@=DU13( @D( B4EDW3( @.=D1A( E( B4D1?.=?>=( ?=3H=I( :-BAH[H@D?-EA(


FD4DXAT.DB( -F=34DW( ?=G( 1D( XEZH[( @DW-h31=DH[a( 8I( MD.=Gm( >3?B( F4@3H[-EAQ
ED1D( E( V-1C=T24DH>=( F-W^H@3_( 1324-1-EAH[( =( E( @3?BDEDH[( EDT( F-W^H@3_(
?A1DFBAH@1AH[( BAH[( 1324-1ZEz( 5I( JH@31=3( =( X-]E=DXH@31=D( hAH=-E3( .-T^(
?E-S-X1=3( 2C-4.-EDm( EDT=( ?A1DFBAH@13( =( V-1C=T24DH>3( F-W^H@3_( 1324-1-Q
EAH[( |l+!*J##b&( § ( lJ#b,+*( 577O~I( "X( XDE1D( E^BFU=E-]m( S2X@=WD( ]E=DQ
X-.-]m0( h3( E( B4DVH=3( 1DED4?BE=D1=D( X-]E=DXH@3_( ?=WD( F-W^H@3_( -?=^T1=3(
1D?AH31=3( =( XDU?@A( F4-H3?( 2H@31=D( 1=3( SGX@=3( .-hU=EA( |c &**+!( §( c;#';d (
8OOgz( j+!K,%+!( §( '&K,*+!( 5775Dz( l;!%+K( =( =1I( 8OOg~I( $.=311D( ?=WD( F-Q
W^H@3_( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[( 1=3( .-h3( SAm( ?BDS=U1A.( .3H[D1=@.3.( F-XB4@A.AQ
ED1=D( FD.=GH=( B4EDW3>( BDVh3( @( B3T-( U-T=H@13T-( F-E-X20( h3( @.=311-]m( EDT(
F-W^H@3_( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[( @DVWDXD( 1=3B4EDW-]m0( H-( >3?B( E( ?F4@3H@1-]H=( @( EAQ
.DTD1=3.( B4EDW-]H=( E( F4@AFDXV2( FD.=GH=( XW2T-B4EDW3>I( "H@3V=ED1=3( B4EDQ
W-]H=(FD.=GH=(EAVU2H@D(>3>(FUD?BAH@1-]m(|;!Kb;pK'd(577n~I(
%-E?@3(SDXD1=D(E(>3?@H@3(E=GV?@A.(?B-F1=2(F4@AH@A1=D>^(?=G(X-(@DVE3Q
?B=-1-ED1=D( X-BAH[H@D?( -S-E=^@2>^H3T-( FD4DXAT.DB2I( `A.=31=-13( EAh3>(
N4-@X@=DW" OR( F4DH3( M34=1D0( cD4V4D.D( =( E?FZWF4DH-E1=VZE0( X-E-X@^0( h3( V-Q
U2.1A( 1324-1-E3( V-4A( .Z@T-E3>( F-?=DXD>^( E4-X@-13( ?B42VB24A( T42F2>^H3(
1324-1A( E3XW2T( F-EBD4@DU1AH[0( ?E-=?BAH[( TDB21V-E-( 43T2W( |c;!'!;c( § (
M+!&%( 5788z( M+!&%( =( =1I( 5788~I( jG?B-]m( F-W^H@3_( 1324-1-EAH[( -XS=3TD( -X(
?BDBA?BAV=( @E=^@D13>( @3( @EAVWA.( ?^?=3X@BE3.( 1324-1ZEI( KA1DF?A( BE-4@^(
?V2F=?VD(=(FGV=(F4@AF-.=1D>^H3(EA?3FV=(?A1DFBAH@13(pDXDVVD1D(-F=?AED13(
E( 4-@X@=DU3( n" N4A?I(eRI( KV2F=?VD( B3( 1=3( ?^( -T4D1=H@-13( X-( F->3XA1H@AH[(
.=V4-V-U2.1( N-( 4-@.=D4DH[( 8776897( ³.R0( DU3( .-T^( -S3>.-EDm( V-U2.1A(
N-(4-@.=D4DH[( e776977( ³.RI( M-@D( ?B42VB24^( F4@3?B4@311^( EA?3F3V( ?A1DFQ
BAH@1AH[( BDVh3( ?=WD( F-W^H@3_( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[( .D( XA?B4AS2H>G( -X@E=34H=3Q
XUD>^H^( ?B42VB24G( EAV4ABAH[( @3?F-WZE( 1324-1-EAH[I( M-?@H@3TZU13( @3?F-WA(
F4@31=VD>^( ?=G0( BE-4@^H( ?=3m( E=3U2( @3?F-WZE( E( B3>( ?D.3>( F4@3?B4@31=( ?A1DFQ
BAH@13>I(M-1=3EDh(SDXD1=D(F4@3F4-EDX@D1-(?-1XD.=(85QVD1DW-EA.=(1D(EAQ
H=1VDH[( V-4A( .Z@TZE( 8gQX1=-EAH[( ?@H@24ZE0( EAVU2H@-13( >3?B0( DSA( ?B42VQ
B24A( BAH[( F-W^H@3_( F-E?BDWA( E( B4DVH=3( 2H@31=D( =( X-]E=DXH@3_( -?-S1=H@AH[I(
,3(-XV4AH=D(F-BE=34X@D>^(=1B2=H>3(cH#2UU-H[D(|c##J**"#b(§(M&,,K(8Ogez(
c##J**"#b( 8OPP~( -( E4-X@-1A.( @DT1=3hXh31=2( E@-4HZE( E( .Z@T20( H-( .D(
@E=^@3V( @( -S?34E-ED1A.=( E( 1DB24@3( @DH[-ED1=D.=( =1?BA1VB-E1A.=I( ,-(
.-h3( BDVh3( EA>D]1=Dm0( XUDH@3T-( .Z@T=( @E=34@GH3( =( U2X@V=3( .D>^( F-X-S13(
.3H[D1=@.A(F34H3FH>=I(&H[(=1XAE=X2DU13(H3H[A(F?AH[=H@13(4Zh1=^(?=G(>3X1DV(
1D( ?V2B3V( 2H@31=D( ?=G( E( =11AH[( ED421VDH[( =( 1D( F-X?BDE=3( =11AH[( X-]E=DXQ
H@3_( hAH=-EAH[I( "XV4AB3( ?B42VB24A( E4-X@-13( 1=3( EAVU2H@D>^( -H@AE=]H=3(
595( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

FUD?BAH@1-]H=( 2.-hU=E=D>^H3>( 2H@31=3I( :-E-XA( 3V?F34A.31BDU13( E?VD@2>^(


>3X1DV0(h3(TWZE13(?B42VB24A(F-W^H@3_(1324-1-EAH[(=(?A1DFBAH@1AH[(?^(@X3Q
B34.=1-ED13(T313BAH@1=3I(M-XEDhD(B-(X-.=12>^H^(4-U3(FUD?BAH@1-]H=(?A1DFQ
BAH@13>( F-?B2U-ED13>( F4@3@( b3SSDI( ;2B-4@A( -XE-W2>^( ?=G( X-( 4-@E=1=GB3>(
EH@3]1=3>( V-1H3FH>=( XD4E=1=@.2( 1324-1-E3T-0( E3XW2T( VBZ43>( ?=3m( 1324-Q
1-ED(V-4A(V?@BDWB2>3(?=G(E(-V43?=3(E@4-?B2(NX-(1DE3B(g(4-V2(hAH=DR0(BE-4@^H(
F4@AFDXV-E^(?=3m(F-W^H@3_I(`(F4-H3?=3(2H@31=D(1D?BGF2>3(?3U3VH>D(F-W^H@3_I(
M-@-?BD>^( B30( VBZ43( EAV-4@A?BAED13( ?^( E( F34H3FH>=( =( DVBAE1AH[( F4-H3?DH[(
.31BDU1AH[I( :DU?@D( .=3U=1=@DH>D( =( DX=2?BDH>D( EDT( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[( X-?V-1DU=(
?B42VB24A( -4D@( =H[( @X-U1-]H=( X-( F4@3BED4@D1=D( =( F4@3H[-EAED1=D( =1C-4.DH>=(
|+:+*c;%( 8OPtz( +:+*c;%( §( j ;**d( 5778~I( KWDS-]H=^( B3T-( .3H[D1=@.20(
@ED13T-( BDVh3( 3X3U.D1=@.3.( 1324-1-EA.0( >3?B( B42X1-]m( -S>D]1=31=D( .-hQ
U=E-]H=( =1B31?AE13T-( 2H@31=D( X->4@DWAH[( U2X@=( F-( 58( 4-V2( hAH=D0( V=3XA(
F4-H3?( .=3U=1=@DH>=( ?=G( V-_H@AI( "H@AE=]H=3( F4-H3?A( 2H@31=D( .-T^( SAm( EAQ
>D]1=D13( V-.S=1DH>^( E=3U2( EA.=31=-1AH[( EAh3>( .3H[D1=@.ZE0( 2@2F3W1=-Q
1AH[( -( F4-H3?A( @DF-.=1D1=D0( @.=D1A( ?B42VB24A( ?=3H=( F4@3@( @DF4-T4D.-ED1^(
].=34m( V-.Z43V0( 1324-T313@G0( V-1E34?>G( D?B4-HABZE( X-( 1324-1ZE( =( E=3U3(
=11AH[0(VBZ43(-F4DH-ED1-0(DSA(EABW2.DH@Am(-S?34E-ED1^(E(1DB24@3(1324-Q
FUD?BAH@1-]m0( F-H@^E?@A( -X( F4-H3?ZE( 2H@31=D( Dh( F-( 3V?F34A.31BA( ?2S?BAQ
B2H>=(@.A?W-E3>(|l;#bQ dQ!&,;(577gz(%"¸(5779~I(
%D>EDh1=3>?@A.( 2@2F3W1=31=3.( V-1H3FH>=( +X3U.D1D0( 2?2ED>^HA.( E?VDQ
@D13( EAh3>( E^BFU=E-]H=0( .-h3( SAm( B3-4=D( %+:( .-XAC=VDH>=( F4-B3=1( =( :%;(
@X-U13T-(X-(-XBED4@D1=D(@.-XAC=V-ED1AH[(.DV4-.-U3V2WI($(X2hA.(F4DEX-Q
F-X-S=3_?BE3.(.-h1D(F4@3E=XAEDm0(h3(-XV4AB3(E4-X@-130(E@TUGX1=3(B4EDW3(
?B42VB24A(?=3H=(.-T^(EAVD@AEDm(1=3@SGX1^(FUD?BAH@1-]m(X@=GV=(.-XAC=VDH>=(
EWD?1-]H=( F-F4@3@( 2B4EDUD1=3( -XV?@BDWH3_( .DV4-.-U3V2WI( `A?3FV=( ?A1DFQ
BAH@13( ?^( X-?V-1DWA.=( ?-1XD.=( WDX21V-EA.=I( &H[( E@D>3.13( F4@31=VD1=3(
E(F4@3?B4@31=( ?A1DFBAH@13>( TED4D1B2>3( C21VH>-1-ED1=3( .3H[D1=@.2( )KKI(
$DT43T-ED13( ?B42VB24A( 1324-1-E30( -S3>.2>^H3( V-U2.1A( V-4A0( .-h1D( 2B-hQ
?D.=Dm( @( 1324-1-EA.=( F-UD.=( .-X3U2>^HA.=( %McI( <3?B( B-( =X3DU13( F-XW-h3(
XUD( 43>3?B4DH>=( =.F43?>-1ZEI( `AV4AB3( ?B42VB24A( EAVD@2>^( -4TD1=@DH>G( EAhQ
?@3T-( 4@GX20( W^H@^H( ?=G( E( ?B42VB24A( -S3>.2>^H3( E=3U3( V-U2.10( D( 1DE3B( HDW3(
F-UD( .Z@T-E3I( <3?B( B-( -4TD1=@DH>D( @S=3h1D( @( F-?B2U-ED1^( ?B42VB24^( =.F43?Q
>-1ZE( EAh?@AH[( 4@GXZEI( ,DV( @D4A?-ED1A( V?@BDWB( FD.=GH=( B4EDW3>( F-E=1=31(
SAm(2@2F3W1=-1A0(XUD(?E->3>(V-.FU3B1-]H=0(E(3U3.31BA(F-@EDUD>^H3(43>3?B4-Q
EDm(.-hU=E=3(X2h^(H@G]m(F-?B4@3TD13>(4@3H@AE=?B-]H=I(
MD.=Gm( B4EDWD( X3VUD4DBAE1D( F-.=3]H=m( .2?=( XED( 4-X@D>3( =1C-4.DH>=a(
NF-.=>D.A( B2( FD.=Gm( 1=3X3VUD4DBAE1^0( 1=3]E=DX-.^0( 1=3F4@AH@A1=D>^H^( ?=G(
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 59e(

X-(BE-4@31=D(]E=DX-.-]H=0(-S3>.2>^H^(FD.=Gm(F4-H3X24DU1^(N?3VE31H>3(H@A1Q
1-]H=0( 2.=3>GB1-]H=R0( -X42H[ZE( ED421V-EAH[( NT-B-E-]H=( 43DVH>=0( XA?F-@AQ
HA>1-]H=R0([DS=B2DH>=Q?31?ABA@DH>=(N1=3D?-H>DHA>1DR(-4D@(B-4-ED1=D(NprimingR RI(
8I(,4EDW^( =1C-4.DH>G0( 2.-hU=E=D>^H^( 4-@F-@1D1=3( -S=3VBZE( 1=3@.=311AH[(
E(H@D?=30(X-BAH@^H^(CDVBZE(=(E=3X@A(-F=?-E3>(-TZU13>(-X(F-@=-.2(F4@3X.=-Q
BZE0( 3U3.31BZE( =( H3H[( -S=3VBZE( X-( F-@=-.2( F->Gm0( -S4D@ZE( =( =.F43?>-1ZEQ
.-X3U=I(,D(H@G]m(FD.=GH=(X3VUD4DBAE13>(1D@ED1D(>3?B(FD.=GH=^(?3.D1BAH@1^I(
5I(&1C-4.DH>G( -( F4-H3?DH[( @DH[-X@^HAH[( E( =1B34EDWDH[( H@D?-EAH[0( -S3>Q
.2>^HAH[( 3F=@-XA0( [=?B-4=G( hAH=D0( ?3VE31H>3( XfE=GVZE( =BFI0( H@AU=( =.F43?Q
>-1ZE( XA1D.=H@1=3( @.=311AH[( E( H@D?=3I( ,D( H@G]m( FD.=GH=( B4EDW3>( X3VUD4DQ
BAE13>(1D@AED1D(>3?B(FD.=GH=^(3F=@-XAH@1^I((
MD.=Gm(.-U3V2UD41D(EAXD>3(?=G0(1D(F=34E?@A(4@2B(-VD0(SAm(EA>^BV-E-(fU3(
X-?B-?-ED1D(X-(@DF=?2(3F=@-XZE(@(XA1D.=H@1=3(@.=311^(?H31^I(%D(BA.(F-U2(
V-1?B42VB-4@A(;&(EAF4@3X@=U=(1=3H-(S3@4DX1AH[(X-BAH[H@D?(1324-C=@>-U-TZEI(
,A.( F=34E?@A.( FD.=GH=( 3F=@-XAH@13( 1=3@SGX13( SAWA( X-( @DX3.-1?B4-ED1=D(
@X-U1-]H=( ?D.-2H@31=D( =H[( .-X3U-EAH[( ?A?B3.ZEI( M-VD@DU=( -1=0( h3( .-h1D(
?V-1?B42-EDm(?V2B3H@13(FD.=GH=(3F=@-XAH@130(@D.=31=D>^H(?3VE31H>3(H@D?-Q
E3( 1D( ?3VE31H>3( F4@3?B4@3113I( "@1DH@D( B-0( h3( EAS4D1A( .-.31B( H@D?-EA(
43>3?B4-ED1A( SAW( E( V-U3>13>( V-.Z4H3( FD.=GH=( F-X-S1=3( >DV( VUDBV=( C=U.2I(
!-@E=^@D1-( 1DE3B( F4-SU3.A( BDV=3T-( DX43?-ED1=D( BAH[( VUDB3V0( DSA( .-h1D(
SAW-( X-B4@3m( X-( 1=H[( =( 4-@F-H@^m( =H[( -XBED4@D1=3( E( X-E-U1A.( EAS4D1A.(
.-.31H=3(|,J*p&%j(8OPez(K,;!$d'( § ( b+(577Oz(`;%j(=(=1I(5785z(%J/"**(
§(*;&!:(577g0(5785~I(,-0(H-(X-S43(XUD(.-X3U=(3U3VB4-1=H@1AH[0(B42X1-(EAQ
-S4D@=m( ?-S=3( E( hAEAH[( V-.Z4VDH[( 1324-1ZE( 1=3F-?=DXD>^HAH[( DX43?ZE0(
E(F4@AFDXV-E-( F-W^H@-13>( ?=3H=( 1324-1-E3>I( !-@E=^@D1=3( B3T-( F4-SU3.2(
@1DU3fm( .-h1D( E( 4D.DH[( [324A?BAV=( 1324-1-E3T-( F-UD( .-X3U2>^H3T-I( <3>(
X@=DWD1=3( .2?=( @D.=31=Dm( 4-@VWDX( H@D?-EA( F-?B4@3TD1AH[( S-XfHZE( 1D( 4-@Q
VWDXA(F4@3?B4@3113(=1C-4.DH>=(@DF=?AED13>(E(?B42VB24DH[(%McI(
((
M;c&r¤(+M&$":d#$%;(

M-?W2h.A(?=G(@DF=?3.(D1DU-T=H@1A.(X-(?B-?-ED13T-(E(4-@X@=DU3"e(NH@G]m(&R(
E( H3U2( -F=?D1=D0( >DV( .-h3( ?=G( -XSAEDm( BDVD( B4D1?C-4.DH>D( ?AT1DWZE( @.=31Q
1AH[(E(H@D?=3(1D(.DB4AHG(?BD1ZE(F4@3?B4@311AH[I(<3]U=0(D1DU=@2>^H(F-S2X@31=D(
X-H=34D>^H3( X-( 1324-1ZE( FZU( 43H3FHA>1AH[0( ?AT1DW( F-S2X@D>^HA( @S=Z4( ?A1DF?(
VBZ43T-V-UE=3V( 1324-12( 1( -@1DH@A.A( >DV-( .N1R0( B-( @DVWDXD>^H0( h3( F-S2X@DQ
1AH[(>3?B(:(?A1DF?(B3T-(1324-120(?BD1(>3T-(F-S2X@31=D(.-h3.A(@DF=?Dm(>DV-a((
.'(µ(¹/X10(X(µ(80III(:º(N8R(
59g( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

"XF-E=DXD(-1(=.F43?>-1-E=(1D>1=h?@3T-(4@GX2I((
<3]U=(2E@TUGX1=.A0(h3(?AT1DW(F-S2X@D>^HA(-X@1DH@D(?=G(XA1D.=V^(@.=31Q
1^( E( H@D?=3( B4ED1=D( F-S2X@31=D0( B-( .-h3.A( B-( 2E@TUGX1=m0( F4@A>.2>^H0( h3(
X-(F3E13>(H@G]H=(-X(:(X-(:»(?A1DF?(1324-12(1(X-H=34D>^(F-S2X@31=D(@.=31Q
13(E(H@D?=3a(
./'(NBR(µ(¹(/»X1(NBR0(X(µ(80III(:»º(µ(¹(/»X1(NBR0(X(µ(80III(0(:Q80(:0III0(:»º(µ(
µ(¹/»X10(X(µ(80III(:Q8º(´(¹(/»X1 (NBR0(X(µ(:0III(:»º(N5R(
`( B31( ?F-?ZS( 43F43@31BDH>G( ?A1DFBAH@1^( ?AT1DW2( F-S2X@D>^H3T-( F-X@=3Q
U=U=].A( 1D( H@G]m( ?BDW^( =( @.=311^( E( H@D?=3I( M4@A>.=>.A0( h3( 1D?@( ?A?B3.(
F34H3FHA>1A( .D( .-hU=E-]m( F4ZSV-ED1=D( X-H=34D>^HAH[( ?AT1DWZE( E( -X?BGQ
FDH[( H@D?2( ¼B( -4D@( h3( ED4B-]m( ?AT1DW2( E( V-U3>1AH[( -X?BGFDH[( H@D?2( @DQ
F=?AED1D( >3?B( E( ?A1DF?DH[( ?^?=DX2>^HAH[( @( ?A1DF?D.=( :0}}0( :»0( BE-4@^H(
V-U3>13(@DF=?A(E(?34=DH[(?A1DF?(:=( 0}}0(:»=0(TX@=3(=(-@1DH@D(12.34(V-U3>13>(
F4ZSV=I( `ZEH@D?( F-( H@D?=3( -S?34EDH>=( -S=3VB2( ,( E3VB-4( 43F43@31B2>^HA(
H@G]m(@.=311^(/»1NBR(4-@S=>3.A(1D(@S=Z4(43F43@31B2>^HA(F-S2X@31=3(-(U=H@S=3(
3U3.31BZE( F-E=GV?@-13>( -( ?A1DF?A( 2B4EDUD>^H3( ?BD1( -S=3VB2( E( F-?@H@3TZUQ
1AH[(.-.31BDH[(H@D?-EAH[(=I((
/»X(1(NBR(µ(½(N/»X(=(1R z(TX@=3(&(µ(,(¼B 0(U=H@SD(F4ZS3V(NeR(
i(!(80IIII0(&(
$E4Zm.A(2EDTG0(h3(-S3H1=3(/»X( 1=3(>3?B(C21VH>^(H@D?2I(,34D@(F-S2X@31=3(
1324-12( ?AT1DW3.( @.=311A.( SGX@=3( .=DW-( 2F4-?@H@-1^( F-?BDm0( BDVh3( 1=3Q
@DU3h1^(-X(H@D?2I(
./'(µ(½(N/»X(1R(´(½(½(N/»X(=(1R(NgR((
X(!(80}0(N: ¾ 8R(=(!"8(0}0(&(
X(!"(:0}0(:»((
*=H@1-]m(X42T=3T-(@S=-42(>3?B(=U-H@A13.(& ‡ N:» ¾ :R0(>3X1DVh3(>3]U=(N:» ¾ (:R(
¿¿( :0( B-( W^H@1D( U=H@SD( 3U3.31BZE( E3VB-4D( /»1( 1=3( -XS=3TD( @1DH@^H-( -X(
U=H@SA( 3U3.31BZE( :( 43>3?B42>^HAH[( F-S2X@31=3( /1I( "XF-E=DXD( B-( ?AB2DH>=0(
TXA( BAUV-( H@G]m( -S?34E-ED13>( ?H31A( 2U3TD( XA1D.=H@1A.( @.=D1-.I( `ZEQ
H@D?( -TZU1A( -S4D@( F-@-?BD>3( E( FD.=GH=0( D( 43>3?B4-ED13( ?^( >3XA1=3( B3( 3U3Q
.31BA( -S4D@20( VBZ43( 2U3TD>^( @.=D1=3I( %DU3hA( ?=G( ?F-X@=3EDm0( h3( >3]U=( X-(
E3>]m( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[( X-H=34D( @W-h-1A( ?AT1DW( @.=311A( E( H@D?=30( B-( >3T-(
D?F3VBA( ?BDW30( 4D@( @D43>3?B4-ED130( 1=3( SGX^( F-E-X-EDWA( @.=D1( E( F-UDH[(
FD.=GH=I( %DB-.=D?B( F-S2X@31=D( -XF-E=DXD>^H3( D?F3VB-.( @.=311A.( SGX^(
B4DVB-ED13( >DV-( 3U3.31BA( 1-E-]H=( =( B4DVB-ED13( >DV-( ?=U1A( ?AT1DW( @DFD.=GQ
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 599(

BAED1A( E( V-U3>1AH[( -S?@D4DH[( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[0( U3h^HAH[( F4DEX-F-X-S1=3(


E(?^?=3X@BE=3(EA?FA(?A1DFBAH@13>(-S?W2T2>^H3>(-V43]U-13(F-S2X@31=3I(J@AQ
?VD.A( E( B31( ?F-?ZS( =.F43?>-10( -XF-E=DXD>^HA( -S=3VB-E=( 10( 2B4EDUD>^HA(
@.=D1A( 3U3.31BZE( B3T-( -S=3VB2( NU2S( ?H31AR( E( H@D?=3I( c-h1D( 4-@4Zh1=m(
@DB3.(=.F43?>-1A(?BDBAH@13(/1(=(=H[(43F43@31BDH>3(.31BDU13(F4@3H[-EAED13(
E( FD.=GH=( X3VUD4DBAE13>( -4D@( =.F43?>-1A( XA1D.=H@13( /»10( @DFD.=GBAED13(
E(FD.=GH=(3F=@-XAH@13>I((
(
M4DEX-F-X-S1D( >3?B( [=F-B3@D0( h3( X@=GV=( .3H[D1=@.-.( %+:( F-S2X@31=3(
VBZ43T-V-UE=3V( =.F43?>-12( ?F-E-X2>3( F4-FDTDH>3( 2V=3421V-ED13T-( =.F2UQ
?2( WDX21VZE0( VBZ4A( =1X2V-EDm( SGX@=3( V-U3>13( =.F43?>-1A( XA1D.=H@130( -XQ
BED4@D>^H0( 1=H@A.( 1D( C=U.=30( VUDBVD( F-( VUDBH30( F4@3S=3T( H@D?-EA( @DFD.=GQ
BD13T-(F4-H3?2-S=3VB2I(<DVD(F-E=11D(SAm(H@G?B-]m(F4ZSV-ED1=D(@.=D10(DSA(
@DH[-EDm( H=^TW^( V-1B4-UG( XA1D.=H@1=3( @.=3113T-( -B-H@31=D„( <DVD( F-E=11D(
SAm(E=341-]m(BDV=3T-(@DF=?2(=(FZf1=3>?@3T-(-XBED4@D1=D(2B4EDU-1AH[(3F=@-Q
XZE„( :-BAH@A( B-( @D4ZE1-( 4-@X@=3UH@-]H=( H@D?-E3>( @E=^@D13>( @( H@G?B-]H=^(
F4ZSV-ED1=D0( >DV( =( 4-@X@=3UH@-]H=( F4@3?B4@3113>I( :UD( 43>3?B4DH>=( E4Dh3_(
E@4-V-EAH[( H@D?( F4ZSV-ED1=D( 3F=@-XZE( .2?=( SAm( X-?BDB3H@1=3( V4ZBV=0( DSA(
F-E?BDEDW-( E4Dh31=3( H=^TW-]H=( -S4D@2I( %DB-.=D?B( 1=3( .-h3( -1( SAm( V4ZB?@A(
1=h( H@D?( F-B4@3S1A( 1D( F4@3BE-4@31=3( -S4D@2( E( >3T-( XA1D.=H@1=3( @.=31=DQ
>^HAH[(?=G(D?F3VBDH[I(`AXD>3(?=G0(h3(E(.Z@TDH[(@E=34@GHAH[(H@D?A(F4ZSV-Q
ED1=D( ?^( @.=3113( =( @DU3h^( -X( B3>( XA1D.=V=( ?H31A( E( 1DB24DU1A( ?F-?ZSI( <3]U=(
-S4D@( ?H31A0( E( >DV=.]( >3>( C4DT.31H=30( F-( H@D?=3( ¼B( EAVDh3( X-?BDB3H@1^(
@.=D1G0(B-(F-E?BDWA(E(V-.Z4VDH[(?31?-4AH@1AH[(1-EA(?AT1DW(NF-X-S1=3(>DV(
E( .3H[D1=@.=3(2EDT=R( SGX@=3( .=DW( ?@D1?G( F-S2X@=m( 1-EA( ?@UDV( WDX21V-EA(
=(EAT3134-EDm( 1-EA( =.F2U?( V=3421V-EA( @T-X1=3( @( %+:I( ,DV( E=GH( H@D?A(
F4ZSV-ED1=D( =( EA1=VD>^HD( ?B^X( H@G?B-]m( F4ZSV-ED1=D( SGX@=3( ?=G( 2?BDUDWD(
D2B-.DBAH@1=3I( %D>E=GH3>( XD1AH[( 1D( B31( B3.DB( X-BAH@A( .Z@T2( U2X@V=3T-I(
`AXD>3(?=G0(h3(E(BA.(F4@AFDXV2(H@D?(F4ZSV-ED1=D(-XF-E=DXD(43>3?B4DH>=(-X(
V=UV2( X-( V=UV2X@=3?=GH=2( VUDB3V( 1D( ?3V21XGI( '4ZB?@A( H@D?( F4ZSV-ED1=D( EAQ
.DTD1A( >3?B( XUD( @.A?W2( ?W2H[2( =( @E=^@D1A( >3?B( @3( @X-U1-]H=^( ?W2H[2( X-(
4-@4Zh1=D1=D( H@G?B-( F-EBD4@D>^HAH[( ?=G( XfE=GVZEI( #@D?A( B3( -XF-E=DXD>^(
H@G?B-BU=E-]H=(V=UV2?3B([34HZEI(&113(@.A?WA(1=3(EA.DTD>^(BDV(E=3UV=3>(H@G?Q
B-]H=(F4ZSV-ED1=D(?AT1DWZEI($(X42T=3>(?B4-1A(H@D?A(F4ZSV-ED1=D(-T4D1=H@-Q
13( ?^( 1324-C=@>-U-T=H@1=3I( K2S.=U=?3V21X-E3( F4-H3?A( FD.=GH=( 4-S-H@3>( F-Q
@EDUD>^( 1D( F4ZSV-ED1=3(@( H@G?B-]H=^( V=UV2?3B( [34HZE0( H-( >3?B( EA?BD4H@D>^H3(
X-(-S?W2h31=D(E4Dh3_(?W2H[-EAH[I(
(
59n( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

%D?2ED( ?=G( FABD1=3a( H@A( =?B1=3>3( EA?BD4H@D>^HD( U=H@SD( S=DW3V0( F4-B3=10(


-X.=D1( .-U3V2W0( SGX^HAH[( .-U3V2UD41A.( F-XW-h3.( FD.=GH=0( X-( @DV-X-Q
ED1=D( BDV( E=3UV=3>( =U-]H=( =1C-4.DH>=0( VBZ4^( T31342>^( E4Dh31=D( X-?BD4H@D13(
F4@3@( 1D?@3( @.A?W2( E( H=^T2( HDW3T-( hAH=D„( #[-m( U=H@SD( .-hU=EAH[( .-XAQ
C=VDH>=(WD_H2H[ZE(S=DWV-EAH[0(:%;(=(!%;(EAXD>3(?=G(-T4-.1D0(B-(@DF3E13(
1=3( E?@A?BV=3( -13( .-T^( SAm( BE-4@-13( =( F4@3H[-EAED13( E( ?B42VB24DH[( 132Q
4-1-EAH[I( %D( ?@H@G]H=3( 1=3( VDhX3.2( =.F43?>-1-E=( T3134-ED13.2( F4@3@(
2.A?W( .2?=.A( F4@AF=?Dm( >3X310( ?F3HAC=H@1A( 4-X@D>( .-U3V2WAI( *=H@13( BAFA(
X-?BGF1AH[( .-XAC=VDH>=( .-U3V2W( EAV-4@A?BAED13( ?^( 1=H@A.( U=B34A( DUCDS3B2(
V-X2>^H3T-( =1C-4.DH>G( E( E=3U-3U3.31B-EAH[( .DH=34@DH[( ?A1DFBAH@1AH[(
1324-1-EAH[( FZU( .-X3U2>^HAH[I( `( EA1=V2( BDV=3T-( V-X-ED1=D( U=H@3S1-]m(
V-.S=1DB-4AH@1D( X-?BGF1AH[( V-1C=T24DH>=( V-X-ED1=D( -?=^TD( EA.=D4( F4@3Q
EAh?@D>^HA(F-B4@3SA(=1C-4.DHA>13(2.A?WZE(1DB24DU1AH[I((
(
`( F4@AFDXV2( V-X-ED1=D( F4@3S=3T2( -S?34E-ED1AH[( @XD4@3_( E( FD.=GH=(
3F=@-XAH@13>( .D.A( X-( H@A1=31=D( @( B4D1?C-4.DH>^( F4-H3?ZE( H@D?-EAH[( X-(
C-4.( F4@3?B4@311AH[0( D( F-E?BD>^H3( E( B31( ?F-?ZS( =.F43?>-1A( XA1D.=H@13(
.D>^(=X31BAH@1^(?B42VB24G(>DV(B3(?BDBAH@13I(c-T^(E=GH(SAm(E(B31(?D.(?F-?ZS(
F-4ZE1AED13( E( 1324-1-EAH[( F-UDH[( .-X3U2>^HAH[I( KB-?2>3( ?=G( X-( 1=H[(
DUT-4AB.( M34U-o?VA3T-( BDV( ?D.-0( >DV( XUD( BAF-EAH[( ?BDBAH@1AH[( =.F43?Q
>-1ZEI( %=3( .-h3.A( BDVh3( @DF-.=1Dm( -( [=34D4H[=H@13>0( ED4?BE-E3>( ?B42VQ
B24@3( ?=3H=0( @( H@3T-( EA1=VD0( h3( F-E?BD>^H3( E( %Mc( =.F43?>-1A( ?^( @( V-U3=(
?2S=.F43?>-1D.=(XUD(=.F43?>-1ZE(EAh?@3T-(4@GX2I(:-F=34-(F4@3X(1D.=(>3?B(
@=X31BAC=V-ED1=3([324A?BAV=(C21VH>-12>^H3>(E(.Z@TDH[(1DB24DU1AH[0(F-@EDQ
UD>^H3>(1D(X-BD4H=3(=(-XBE-4@31=3(X-E-U13T-(3F=@-X2(@(1D?@3T-(hAH=DI(c-h1D(
>3X1DV( F4@3E=X@=3m( E=3U3( V-1?3VE31H>=( EAFWAED>^HAH[( @( F-?B2U-ED13T-(
.3H[D1=@.2I( M-4ZE1AED1=3( =.F43?>-1ZE( XA1D.=H@1AH[( F-@EDUD( 1D( 4-@Q
F-@1DED1=3( 1=3( BAUV-( -S=3VBZE( ?BDBAH@1AH[0( DU3( =( F4-H3?ZEI( J.-hU=E=D( B-(
BE-4@31=3( .-X3U=( XA1D.=H@1AH[( @>DE=?VI( K3VE31HA>13( -XBED4@D1=3( 3F=@-Q
XZE( @( FD.=GH=( 3F=@-XAH@13>( F4-EDX@=( X-( ?2S=3VBAE13T-( -XH@2ED1=D( H@D?2(
|b ;KK+*c" ( 577O~I( &1X2V-ED1=3( F-E=^@D1AH[( =.F43?>-1ZE( XA1D.=H@1AH[(
F-@EDUD( 1D( V--4XA1DH>3( H@A11-]H=( 42H[-EAH[I( M-S2X@D1=3( ?@34?@3>( ?B42VQ
B24A( =.F43?>-1ZE( F-@EDUD( 1=3( BAUV-( 1D( [DU2HA1DH>3( -S=3VBZE( ?BDBAH@1AH[(
=(XA1D.=H@1AH[0( DU3( BDVh3( 1D( EA-S4Dh31=3( F4@3S=3T2( @XD4@3_I( %D( F-@=-.=3(
?31?-4AH@1A.( F-@EDUD( B-( F4@AF-.=1Dm( ?-S=3( ?@H@3TZWA( XDE1-( E=X@=D1AH[(
@XD4@3_I(%D(F-@=-.=3(?A.S-U=H@1A.(F-@EDUD(1D(FUD1-ED1=3(X@=DWD_(=(F4@3Q
E=XAED1=3( =H[( ?V2BVZEI( !@DXV-( F4@AF-.=1D13( 3F=@-XA( ?B-F1=-E-( @DF-.=Q
1D.A( N@D( EA>^BV=3.( C4DT.31BZE( H@G?B-( -XBED4@D1AH[( >DV-( ?2S3F=@-XAR(
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 59t(

=(@EAVU30( F-( F3E1A.( H@D?=30( FD.=GBD.A( 1=342H[-.3( ?H31A( N?2S=.F43?>-1A(


?BDBAH@13R0( D( F-42?@D( >3( BAUV-( EA-S4Df1=D( U2S( 1D44DH>D( E34SDU1DI( `( V-_H2(
=(B3(E?F-.1=31=D(2UDB2>^(@(1D?@3>(FD.=GH=0(>3]U=(=H[(1=3(-X1DE=D.AI(
(
c3H[D1=@.( @DF-.=1D1=D( >3?B( 4ZE1=3( =?B-B1A( >DV( .3H[D1=@.( @DFD.=GBAQ
ED1=D(3F=@-XZEI(MD.=Gm(3F=@-XAH@1D(V4ZBV-B4EDWD(FZU(?31?-4AH@1AH[(DS?-4Q
S-ED1D(>3?B(1=32?BD11=3(-T4-.1^(U=H@S^(?AT1DWZEI(c3H[D1=@.A(V-1V2431H>=(
=( [D.-ED1=D( ?3U3VH>-12>^( >3XA1=3( 1=3U=H@13( @( 1=H[( X-( F4@3BED4@D1=D( =( @DFDQ
.=GBAED1=D( E( FD.=GH=( 3F=@-XAH@13>( B4EDW3>I( MD.=Gm( 4-S-H@D( .2?=( SAm( 1=3Q
2?BD11=3(-F4Zh1=D1D0(DSA(2.-hU=E=m(F4@A>.-ED1=3(1-EAH[(S-XfHZEI(`ASZ4(
H@D?2(@DFD.=GBAED1=D(=1C-4.DH>=(E(FD.=GH=(B4EDW3>(@DU3hA(-X(?B4DB3T==(hAH=D(
2H=3U3]1=-13>( =1B3U=T31H>=I( M4@A( -T4D1=H@-1AH[( @D?-SDH[( FD.=GH=( V-4@A?B13(
.-h3( SAm( @DF-.=1D1=3( =1C-4.DH>=( 1=3EAV-4@A?BAED1AH[( E( SD4X@-( XW2T=H[(
-V43?DH[( H@D?2I( KB4DB3T=G( @DF-.=1D1=D0( VBZ4^( @E=34@GBD( EAV?@BDWH=WA( 3E-U2Q
HA>1=30(V-1?B42VB-4@A(?@B2H@13>(=1B3U=T31H>=( .2?@^(2?BDU=m(D4S=B4DU1=30(3V?F3Q
4A.31BDU1=3(U2S(E(X4-X@3(D1DU=@A(3V-1-.=H@13>I(
K=GTD1=3( X-( ?2S=.F43?>-1ZE( F-@=-.2( ?31?-4AH@13T-( XD>3( 1D.( @W2X13(
F4@3V-1D1=3(X-VWDX13T-(FD.=GBD1=D(F4@3S=3T2(-XU3TWAH[(3F=@-XZE( @(1D?@3T-(
hAH=DI( #@G?B-( >3X1DV( B3( F4@3hAH=D( FD.=GBD.A( .TU=]H=30( 1=3-?B4-0( F-X-S1=3(
>DV(=.F43?>-1AQ.-X3U3QF->GH=D(@(FD.=GH=(?3.D1BAH@13>I(%DE3B(TXA(2XD(1D.(
?=G( ]E=DX-.=3( F4@AE-WDm( ?@H@3TZWA( XDE1AH[( @XD4@3_0( 1=3( .-h3.A( SAm(
F3E1=0( H@A( F4@AE-WD13( ?2S3F=@-XA( F-H[-X@^( 1D( F3E1-( Y@( B3>( ?D.3>( SD>V=\I(
#@A(1=3(1D?B^F=WD(D?-H>DH>D(?2S=.F43?>-1ZE(2BE-4@-1AH[(E(@2F3W1=3(=11AH[(
-V-U=H@1-]H=DH[I( `=GH3>( 1D( B31( B3.DB( 1DF=?DU=SA( F3E1=3( F?AH[-U-X@A( =( F4-Q
V24DB-4@A(F4@3?W2H[2>^HA(BDV(@ED1AH[(1D-H@1AH[(]E=DXVZEI(
(
:UD( =?B-B( F-?=DXD>^HAH[( ?D.-]E=DX-.-]m0( >DV=.=( =( .A( >3?B3].A0( FD.=Gm(
3F=@-XAH@1D(.D(@D?DX1=H@3(@1DH@31=3(XUD(4-@2.=31=D0(?V^X(?=G(B2(E@=GU=].A(
=(>DVD(>3?B([=?B-4=D(1D?@3T-(hAH=DI(,42X1-(EA-S4D@=m(?-S=3(@DH[-ED1=3(@X4-Q
E=D( F?AH[=H@13T-( =( F-H@2H=D( B-h?D.-]H=( S3@( E4Dh31=D( H=^TW-]H=( [=?B-4==I(
,42X1-(EA-S4D@=m(?-S=3(?V2B3H@1^(DXDFBDH>G(X-(XA1D.=H@1=3(@.=3113T-(]4-Q
X-E=?VD(S3@(3C3VBAE13>(FD.=GH=(3F=@-XAH@13>I((
(
<DV( F4@3X?BDE=-13( .3H[D1=@.A( X-F4-EDX@D>^( X-( =1B31H>-1DU13T-( C21VQ
H>-1-ED1=D(2.A?W20(F4@3X?BDE=-1-(E(H@G]H=(&&&(D4BAV2W2I (
(
(
59P( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

l&l*&"j!;)&;(
(
;ll",,0(*I)I0(D1X(`DX3(jI(!+j+b!I(577gI(yKA1DFB=H(H-.F2BDB=-1\I(Nature(ge8(Nt787Ra(tOn6P7eI(
;:*+c;%0( *3-1D4X( cI( 8OOgI( yc-U3H2UD4( H-.F2BDB=-1( -C( ?-U2B=-1?( B-( H-.S=1DB-4=DU( F4-SU3.?I\(
Science(5nn(N98PtRa(87586875gI(
;%;K,;KK&"J0( #-?BD?( ;I0( K3D1( cI( c"%,j"c+!d0( cD24=H=-( l;!;b"%;0( jA—4TA( l2@?¢V=0( D1X(
#[4=?B-C('"#bI(5787I(y,[3(3CC3HB(-C(?FDB=DUUA(=1[-.-T313-2?(3{B4DH3UU2UD4(3U3HB4=H(C=3UX?(-1(
1324-1?\I <-241DU(-C(%324-?H=31H3(e7a(8O5968Oen((
;!;vJ;+0((;UC-1?-I(577PI(y;?B4-HAB3?(F4-H3??(?A1DFB=H(=1C-4.DB=-1\I(Neuron Glia Biology(ga(e687I(
;!Kb;pK'd0(d24=(&I(577nI(y€,[3(?3o31(?=1?(-C(B[3(b3SS=D1(?A1DF?3a(#D1(B[3([AF-B[3?=?(-C(?A1Q
DFB=H(FUD?B=H=BA(3{FUD=1(U-1TQB34.(.3.-4A(H-1?-U=XDB=-1„\I(Progress in Neurobiology(P7(NeRa(
OO688e((
;J!0(:-4=D10(#[4=?B-F[34(&I(#"%%"**d0(D1X(cD1XD4(KI(<"jI(5779DI(y#-.F2B=1T(?F=V3(X=43HB=o=BA(
E=B[(B3B4-X3?\I(Journal of Neuroscience Methods0(8gO0(&??23(80(e7a(9t6neI(
;J!0( :-4=D10( #[4=?B-F[34( &I( #"%%"**d0( #I&I0( D1X( cD1XD4( KI(<"jI( 5779SI( y#-.F2B=1T( &1C-4.DQ
B=-1(=1(%324-1DU(KF=V3?\I(Neural Processing Letters(5e(0(&??23(5a(8Pe68OOI(
;J!0(:-4=D10(D1X(cD1XD4(KI(<"jI(577nI(yl2=UX=1T(KF=V3(!3F43?31BDB=-1(=1(,3B4-X3?\I(Journal of
Neuroscience Methods(89t0(&??23(5(0(e7("HB-S34a(eng6eteI(
;J!0( :-4=D10( D1X( cD1XD4( KI(<"jI( 577tI( y%324-1DU( ?FDB=DU( U3D41=1T\I(Neural Processing Letters(
590(1-(8a(e80(gt0(
;J!0(:-4=D10(D1X(cD1XD4(KI(<"jI(5787I(y%324-3U3HB4-XA1D.=H?(6(J1X34?BD1X=1T(,[3(l4D=1(*D1Q
T2DT3\I(IOS Pressa(865e9I(
;J!0(:-4=D1I(5787I(y`[343(=?(B[3(€<311=C34(;1=?B-1(1324-1„\I(Nature PrecedingsI(
;J!0(:-4=D1I(5788I(yJ1X34?BD1X=1T(B[3(M[A?=HDU(c3H[D1=?.(-C(,4D1?=B=-1(B-(+F=U3FB=H(K3=@243?\I(
Journal of Neuroscience Methods(5770(&??23(80(e7(;2T2?Ba(P76P9I(
l;#bQdQ!&,;0(MD2UI(577gI(y,DHB=U3(?31?-4A(?2S?B=B2B=-1(?B2X=3?\I(Annals of New York Academic
Sciences(878ea(Pe6O8I((
l;&*+d0(#4D=T(bI0(:2?D1(l;!,&K#b0(D1X(+4=H(!I(';%:+*I(8OOnI(y,-ED4X(D(.-U3H2UD4(X3C=1=B=-1(
-C(U-1TQB34.(.3.-4A(?B-4DT3\I(Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of USA Oe0(
%-o3.S34a(8egg968eg95I(
l;&*+d0( #4D=T( bI0( +4=H( !I( ';%:+*0( D1X( 'D2?=V( K&I( 577gI( y,[3( M34?=?B31H3( -C( *-1TQ,34.( c3Q
.-4Aa( ;( c-U3H2UD4( ;FF4-DH[( B-( K3UCQK2?BD=1=1T( #[D1T3?\I( Learning-Induced Synaptic
Growth, Neuron(gg0(K3FB3.S34(e7a(gO69tI(
l;!%+K0( #I;I0( ( cI( `I( <J%j0( lI*I( c#%;Jjb,"%0( :I*I( '"!"*0( 'I( ;%:!+;KK"%0( D1X( MI)I(
`"!*+dI(8OOgI(y*,M(?DB24DB=-1(D1X(?FDB=DU(U3D41=1T(X=?42FB=-1a(+CC3HB?(-C(BD?V(oD4=DSU3?(D1X(
?DB24DB=-1(U3o3U?\I(Journal of Neuroscience(8ga(9tOe69P7nI(
l+%K"%0(:3D11D(*I0(:Do=X(!I(#"*c;%0(D1X(j3-4T3(`I(bJ%,*+dI(5778I(yc-U3H2U3?0(.DF?(D1X(
?A1DF?3(?F3H=C=H=BA\I(Nature Reviews Neuroscience(5a(POO6O7OI(
l+!*J##b&0( j=-oD11=0( D1X( b314A( ;I( lJ#b,+*I( 577OI( y%324-1DU( FUD?B=H=BAa( [=?B-4=HDU( 4--B?( D1X(
3o-U2B=-1(-C(.3D1=1T\I(Experimental Brain Research(8O5(NeRa(e7tQe8OI((
l!":$&;'0( ;1X4@3>I( 5778I( y%324-F[A?=-U-TA( -C( B[3( .31BDU( =.DT3\I( Medical Science Monitor((
t(NeRa(9eg69ePI(
#;M"!;*+0(%DBDU=D0(D1X(dD1T(:;%I(577PI(yKF=V3(B=.=1TQX3F31X31B(FUD?B=H=BAa(D(b3SS=D1(U3D41=1T(
42U3\I(Annual Review of Neuroscience(e8a(596gnI((
#"K,;0( !2=( M-1B30( M34( <3?F34( K<¦K,!¦c0( D1X(oD1( cD4V( #I`I( !"KKJcI( 578eI( yM4-SDS=U=?B=H( &1Q
C3431H3( -C( K[-4BQ,34.( KA1DFB=H( MUD?B=H=BA( =1( %3-H-4B=HDU( c=H4-H=4H2=B?\I(Frontiers in Com-
putational Neuroscience(ta(t9I((
+:+*c;%0( j34DUX( cI( 8OPtI( Neural Darwinism: The Theory of Neuronal Group Selection.( %3E(
d-4Va(lD?=H(l--V?I(
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 59O(

+:+*c;%0(j34DUX0(D1X(<-?3F[(jDUUAI(5778I(y:3T3134DHA(D1X(H-.FU3{=BA(=1(S=-U-T=HDU(?A?B3.?\I(
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of USA(OP(N5gRa(8etne68etnPI(
)&+*:K0( !I( :-2TUD?I( 577nI( yl3A-1X( B[3( 1324-1( X-HB4=13\I( Scientific American Mind0( <213<2UA(
8ta(5765tI(
)&+*:K0(!I(:-2TUD?I(5788I(Drugi mózg. Rewolucja w nauce i medycynieI(`D4?@DEDa(M4Z?@A_?V=(
c3X=DI(
j+*l;!:QK;j&p0( bDTD40( !-A( cJ';c+*0( c=H[DU( b;!+*0( !DCD3U( c;*;#b0( &B@[DV( )!&+:I( 577PI(
y&1B341DUUA( T3134DB3X( 43DHB=oDB=-1( -C( ?=1TU3( 1324-1?( =1( [2.D1( [=FF-HD.F2?( X24=1T( C433(
43HDUU\I(Science(e55(N9POPRa(On6878I(
j+!K,%+!0(`2UC4D.0(D1X(`34134('&K,*+!I(5775DI(Spiking neuron models: Single neurons, popu-
lations, plasticityI(#D.S4=XT30(J'a(#D.S4=XT3(J1=o34?=BA(M43??I((
j+!K,%+!0( `2UC4D.0( D1X( `34134( '&K,*+!I( 5775SI( ycDB[3.DB=HDU( )-4.2UDB=-1?( -C( b3SS=D1(
*3D41=1T\I(Biological Cybernetics(Pt0(1-I(96na(g7g6g89I((
&$b&'+p&#b0(+2T313(cI(5778I((y!3?-1DB3QD1XQC=43(1324-1?\0(Neural Network 8ga(PPe6POgI(
<"j0( cD1XD4( KI0(:-4=D1( ;J!0( D1X( #[4=?B-F[34( &I( #"%%"**dI( 577tI( y&?( B[343( D( ,=FF=1T( M-=1B( =1(
%324-1DU(+1?3.SU3?(X24=1T(*3D41=1T„\I(Neuroscience Letters(g850(&??23(80(55(<D12D4Aa(eO6ggI((
<"j0( cD1XD4(KI0(D1X(:-4=D1(;J!I( 577OI(y;(,[3-43B=HDU(&1C-4.DB=-1(M4-H3??=1TQlD?3X(;FF4-DH[(
B-(lD?DU(jD1TU=D()21HB=-1\I(Advances in Behavioral Biology(9P0(MD4B(5a(5886555(
';%:+*0( +4=H( !I( 5777I( y#3UU2UD4( .3H[D1=?.?( -C( U3D41=1T( D1X( B[3( S=-U-T=HDU( SD?=?( -C( =1X=o=X2DQ
U=BA\I( &1( Principles of Neural Science. gB[( 3X=B=-10( 3X=B3X( SA( +4=H( !I( 'D1X3U0( <D.3?( bI(
KH[ED4B@0( ,[-.D?( cI( <3??3UU0( KB3o31( ;I( K=3T3USD2.0( ;I( <I( b2X?F3B[0( 85gt65tOI( cHj4DEQ
b=UU0(%3E(d-4VI((
';%:+*0(+4=H(!I(5778I(y,[3(.-U3H2UD4(S=-U-TA(-C(.3.-4A(?B-4DT3a(D(X=DU-T(S3BE331(T313?(D1X(
?A1DF?3?\I(Bioscience Reports(58a(9n96n88I(
c;!'!;c0( b314A0( D1X( !-X4=T-( M+!&%I( N5788RI( y&11DB3( 1324DU( D??3.SU=3?( C-4( *3T-( .3.-4A\I((
Frontiers in Neural Circuits(9a(nI(
c&**+!0('3113B[(:I0(:Do=X(<I#I(c;#';dI(8OOgI(y,[3(4-U3(-C(H-1?B4D=1B?(=1(b3SS=D1(U3D41=1T\I(
Neural Comput(na(877685nI((
c&*K,+&%0(<-?[2D(%I0(D1X(#[4=?B-C('"#bI(577PI(y:A1D.=H(c-.31B(;1DUA?=?(-C(B[3(+{B4DH3UU2UD4(
+U3HB4=H( )=3UX( -C( D( l=-U-T=HDUUA( !3DU=?B=H( KF=V=1T( %324-1\I( Neural Computation( 570( 1-I( Pa(
57t7657PgI((
c##*+**;%:0( <D.3?( *I0( D1X( :Do=X( +I( !Jc+*b;!,I( 8OPPI( Exploration in parallel distributing
processingI(#D.S4=XT3a(l4D1XC-4X(l--V?0(c&,(M43??I((
c##J**"#b0(`D4431(KI0(D1X(`DUB34((M&,,KI(8OgeI(y;(*-T=HDU(#DUH2U2?(-C(B[3(&X3D?(&..D131B(=1(
%34o-2?(;HB=o=BA\I(Bulletin of Mathematical Biophysics ta(88968ee0I(
c##J**"#b0(`D4431(KI(8OPPI(Embodiments of Mind. 51X(3X=B=-1. #D.S4=XT30(c;a(c&,(M43??I((
%"¸0(;UoDI(5779I(Action in PerceptionI(#D.S4=XT30(c;a(c&,(M43??I(
%"`;'0( *=-13U( jI0( cD4=D( pI( K;%#b+$Qp&p+K0( D1X( :Do=X( ;I( c##"!c&#'I( 8OOtI( y&1CU231H3( -C(
U-E( D1X( [=T[( C43x231HA(=1F2B?(-1( ?F=V3( B=.=1T( =1( o=?2DU( H-4B=HDU( 1324-1?\I(Cerebral Cortex(
t(NnRa(gPt6978I((
%J/"**0(;1X43E0(D1X(<-[1(+I(*;&!:I(577gI(y;(#-T1=B=o3(c-X3U(-C(+F=?-X=H(c3.-4A(&1B3T4DB3X(
`=B[( D( j3134DU( #-T1=B=o3( ;4H[=B3HB243\I( International Conference on Cognitive Modeling(
N;;;&RI((
%J/"**0( ;1X43E( cI0( <-[1( +I( *;&!:I( ( 5785I( y+1[D1H=1T( &1B3UU=T31B( ;T31B?( E=B[( +F=?-X=H( c3Q
.-4A\I(Cognitive Systems Research(5785(NIn Proceedings of the twenty-second AAAI confe-
rence on artificial intelligence.( pD1H-2o340( 577tR( [BBFaCDH2UBAI2FI3X212{-UUF2S?#-TKA?À(
%2{-UU*D=4XÀo345tIFXCI((
M+%!"K+0( !-T34I( 8OOtI( yM[A?=H?( D1X( B[3( .=1X\I( &1( The large, the small and the human mind0(
3X=B3X(SA(cDUH-U.(*-1TD=40(Oe68geI(#D.S4=XT3a(#D.S4=XT3(J1=o34?=BA(M43??I(
5n7( `&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK(

M+!&%0(!-X4=T-0( ,[-.D?( 'I( l+!j+!0(D1X( b314A(c;!'!;cI( 5788I( y;( ?A1DFB=H(-4TD1=@=1T( F4=1Q


H=FU3(C-4(H-4B=HDU(1324-1DU(T4-2F?\0((Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of USA((
87P0(1-I(8ea((9g8O69g5gI((
!J%d;%0( #D4-U=13( ;I0( <D.3?( K#bJcc+!K0( ;2X4D( p;%( `;!,0( KD1X4D( <I( 'Jb*c;%0( %DB[D1( !I(
`&*K"%0( $I( <-?[( bJ;%j0( D1X( c4=TD1VD( KJ!I( 5787I( y!3?F-1?3( C3DB243?( -C( FD4oDUS2.=1Q
3{F43??=1T( =1B341324-1?( ?2TT3?B( F43H=?3( 4-U3?( C-4( ?2SBAF3?( -C( =1[=S=B=-1( =1( o=?2DU( H-4B3{\I(
Neuron(t(N9Ra(Pgt6P9tI((
K#b`;!,$0( <D.3?( bI0( p=1H31B( )I( #;K,+**J##&0( D1X( +4=H( !I( ';%:+*I( 8Ot8I( y)21HB=-1=1T( -C(
=X31B=C=3X(1324-1?(D1X(?A1DF?3?(=1(DSX-.=1DU(TD1TU=-1(-C(;FUA?=D(=1(DS?31H3(-C(F4-B3=1(?A1Q
B[3?=?\I(Journal of Neurophysiology(ega(OeO6O9eI(
K"%j0(K310('3113B[(:I(c&**+!0(D1X(*I)I(;ll",,I(5777I(y#-.F3B=B=o3(b3SS=D1(U3D41=1T(B[4-2T[(
?F=V3QB=.=1TQX3F31X31B(?A1DFB=H(FUD?B=H=BA\I(Nature Neuroscience(e0(1-(Oa(O8OQO5nI(
K,;!$d'0( <D12?@( ;I0(( D1X( bD=S-( b+I( 577OI( yKFDB=-Q,3.F-4DU(c3.-4=3?( C-4(cDH[=13(*3D41=1Ta(
;(*-1TQ,34.( c3.-4A( "4TD1=@DB=-1\I( Neural Networks, IEEE Transactions on 2009(
570(1-I(9a(tnP6tP7I((
K,;!$d'0( <D12?@( ;I0( D1X( :=U=F( 'I( M!;K;:I( 5788I( y;( #-.F2BDB=-1DU( c-X3U( -C( cDH[=13( #-1Q
?H=-2?13??\I(International Journal of Machine Cosciousness(7e0(&??23(75a(599I((
,;d*"!0(<-[1(jI(577tI(y#":;ca(;(1324DU(13BE-4V(.-X3U(-C(H-1?H=-2?13??\I(Neural Networks(
57(NOR0(OPe6OO5I((
,;d*"!0( <-[1(jI(577OI(Yl3A-1X(H-1?H=-2?13??„\( International Journal of Machine Conscious-
ness(8(N8Ra(88658I((
,"::0( <I( <DA0( D1X( !31u( c;!"&KI( 577gI( y#DFDH=BA( U=.=B( -C( o=?2DU( ?[-4BQB34.( .3.-4A( =1( [2.D1(
F-?B34=-4(FD4=3BDU(H-4B3{\I(Nature(g5Pa(577g(
,"*bJ!K,0(:Do=X(<I0(:D44DT[(Kcd,b0(D1X(&D1(:I(,b"cMK"%I(577OI(y,[3(?FD4?313??(-C(1324-1DU(
43?F-1?3?(=1(C3443B(F4=.D4A(o=?2DU(H-4B3{\I(Journal of Neuroscience(5O(NPRa(5e99Q5et7I(
,J*p&%j0(+1X3UI(8OPeI(Elements of Episodic MemoryI("{C-4Xa(#UD431X-1(M43??I((
`;*#$;'0( ;T1=3?@VD0( ;1X4@3>( ;I( K$#$+M;%'&+`&#$0( lUD@3>( !JK$#$d#'&0( ;X4=D1D( c;j;*K';0(
'DBD4@A1D( $;c*d%K';0( <-D11D( :$`"%+'0( +ED( `&*#$+'0( 'DBD4@A1D( $dlJ!;Ql!":;0(
cD4H=1(!d*K'&0(c-1=VD(c;*&%"`K';0(c=H[DU(:;l!"`K'&0(,343?D(K$#$+M&%K';0('4@A?@B-C(
M;`*"`K'&0( cD4BD( MdK';,d0( <DV2S( `*":;!#$d'0( &@DS3UD( K$#$+!l;*0( cD43V( K`&,"%K'&0(
cD4=-1(#!+c+!0(D1X(j4@3T-4@(cI(`&*#$d%K'&I(578eI(y%-o3U(b=T[34Q"4X34(+F=T313B=H(!3Q
T2UDB=-1(-C(B[3(lX1C(j313(2F-1(K3=@243?\0(The Journal of Neuroscience ee(NnRa(597tQ5988I(((
`;%j0(`31E310(l2X[=BD.D(KJl;j:<;0(;[QbE33(,;%0(D1X(<D12?@(;I(K,;!$d'I(5785I(y%324DU(
c-X3U=1T(-C(+F=?-X=H(c3.-4Aa(+1H-X=1T0(!3B4=3oDU0(D1X()-4T3BB=1T\I(IEEE Transactions on
Neural Networks and Learning System(5e0(1-I(87a(89tg689PnI((
`"*)0( #I<I0( D1X( :Do=X( *&%:+%I( 5785I( yl=-U-T=HDU( FDB[EDA?( B-( DXDFBDS=U=BA( 6( =1B34DHB=-1?( S3Q
BE331( T31-.30(3F=T31-.30( 134o-2?( ?A?B3.(D1X( 31o=4-1.31B( C-4(DXDFB=o3( S3[Do=-4\I(Genes,
Brain and Behavior((880(&??23(8a(e65PI(
d+%0( K[=[Q#[31T0( <-1DB[D1( l;'+!0( D1X( #[D4U3?( cI( j!;dI( 577tI( yb3B34-T313=BA( =1( B[3( !3?Q
F-1?3?( -C( ;X>DH31B( %324-1?( B-( %DB24DU( KB=.2U=( =1( #DB( KB4=DB3( #-4B3{\I( <-241DU( -C( %324-Q
F[A?=-U-TA(Ota(8e5nQ8eg8(
$l&¥!(;!,d'J£¥`a(577gI(Glial Neuronal Signaling0(3X=B3X(SA(jU311(&I(bDBB-1(D1X(pUDX=.=4(MD4Q
F24D0(o-UI(8I(KF4=1T34(KH=31H3(§(l2?=13??(c3X=DI((
(
(
(
(
(
(
;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&I(#$I(&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';III( 5n8(

;!#b&,+',J!;(L`&;:"c"L#&(
#$rL¤(&&a(K,!J',J!;(c"*+'J*;!%;(&(l&")&$d';(M;c&r#&(

KB43?@H@31=3(
#@G]m(&&(F4DHA(-S>D]1=D(.-U3V2UD413(F-XW-h3(FD.=GH=(E(-FD4H=2(-(@DW-h31=D(%324-Q+U3VB4-Q
:A1D.=V=( F-?B2U-ED13>( F4@3@( ;24D( =( d-TDI( `?VD@D1-( 1D( S=-C=@AH@13( .3H[D1=@.A( T3134DH>=(
E?F-.1=3_0(43CU3V?>=(=(-XH@2m(X@=GV=(3CDBAH@1A.(?F4@Gh31=-.(?A1DFBAH@1A.0(?F3W1=D>^HA.(EAQ
.DTD1=D( =1X2V-ED1=D( =.F43?>-1ZE( pDXDVVD1DI( `AVD@D1-0( h3( X@=DWD1=3( .3H[D1=@.2( ?3U3VHA>Q
13T-( `,;( .-h3( SAm( X-S4A.( .-X3U3.( -F=?2>^HA.( C21VH>G( F4@3W^H@D1=D( 2EDT=I( `?VD@D1-( 1D(
43UDH>3(.=GX@A(FD.=GH=^(4-S-H@^0(V4ZBV-B34.=1-E^(=(B4EDW^(=(=H[(?FZ>1-]m(@(.-U3V2UD41A.=(F4-Q
H3?D.=( @DFD.=GBAED1=D( =( 4-@F-@1DED1=D( E@-4HZEI( `?VD@D1-0( h3( B4EDWD( FD.=Gm( 3F=@-XAH@1D(
EA.DTD( V-1E34?>=( ?3VE31H>=( H@D?-EAH[( ?AT1DWZE( bottom-up( X-( 4-@VWDX2( F4@3?B4@3113T-( BE-Q
4@^H3T-( =.F43?>-1A( XA1D.=H@13I( "XE4-B1D( B4D1?C-4.DH>D( BAH[( =.F43?>-1ZE( 2.-hU=E=D( F4@AF-Q
.=1D1=3( 3F=@-XZE( @( F4@3?@W-]H=I( ".ZE=-1-( @1DH@31=3( E4-X@-1AH[( ?B42VB24( ?=3H=( 1324-1-EAH[(
@DF3E1=D>^HAH[( X@=3X@=H@31=3( @DH[-ED_( =1?BA1VB-E1AH[I( KB42VB24A( B3( 1=3( EAVU2H@D>^( @DH[-Q
ED1=D(FUD?BAH@1-]H=(2.A?W2(2.-hU=E=D>^H3>(3C3VBAE13(2H@31=3I((
(
(
;!#b&,+#,J!+(")(#"%K#&"JK%+KK(
M;!,(,`"a(c"*+#J*;!(K,!J#,J!+(;%:(l&"MbdK&#K(")(c+c"!d(

K2..D4A(
MD4B( &&( 3{FUD=1?( .-U3H2UD4( SDHVT4-21X( -C( B[3( .3.-4A( SD?3X( -1( B[3( D??2.FB=-1?( -C( %324-Q
+U3HB4-Q:A1D.=H(F-?B2UDB3X(SA(;24(§(d-TI((l=-F[A?=HDU(.3H[D1=?.(-C(.3.-4A(C-4.DB=-1(ED?(
=1X=HDB3X( 43?F-1?=SU3( DU?-( C-4( ?31?3?( D1X( 43CU3HB=-1?( B[4-2T[( B[3( 3F[DB=H( =1B34QF-?B?A1DFB=H(
C21HB=-1DU(H-2FU=1T(E[=H[(HD1(=1X2H3(pDXDVVD1(?3.SU=-1?I(`,;(?3U3HB=o3(.3H[D1=?.(ED?(F4-Q
F-?3X( D?( B[3( SD?3( C-4( B[3( .-X3U( -C( DBB31B=-1( ?E=BH[=1TI( !3UDB=-1?( S3BE331( E-4V=1T0( ?[-4B( B34.(
D1X( F34.D131B( .3.-4A( E343( =1X=HDB3X( D1X( B[3=4( H-[3431H3( E=B[( .-U3H2UD4( .3.-4A( C-4.DB=-1(
F4-H3??(D1X(FDBB341(43H-T1=B=-1I(&B(ED?(?[-E10(F34.D131B(3F=?-X=H(.3.-4A(43x2=43?((S-BB-.Q2F(
?=T1DU?(B=.3(?3x231H3(H-1o34?=-1(B-(B[3(?FDB=DU(X=?B4=S2B=-1(FDBB341?(C-4.=1T(XA1D.=H(?3.SU=-1?(
MD?B(3F=?-X3?(43.=1X=1T(=?(F-??=SU3(SA(43H=F4-HDU(B4D1?C-4.DB=-1(-C(B[3?3(?3.SU=-1?I(&11DB3(132Q
4DU(13BE-4V(?B42HB243?(ED?(X=?H2??3X(E[=H[(31?243(=1?B=1HB(S3[Do=-4(=1[34=BD1H3I(,[3?3(?B42HB243(
X-3?1B(3{HU2X3(.=1X(FUD?B=H=BA(13H3??D4A(C-4(3CC3HB=o3(U3D41=1TI(
"
"
01()2"!3&+4()$5".-U3V2UD413(F-XW-h3(FD.=GH=0(3CDBAH@13(?F4@Gh31=3(?A1DFBAH@130(=1X2V-ED1=3(
E?F-.1=3_0(F4@AF-.=1D1=30((F4@3W^H@D1=3(2EDT=I(
6$7")(%895(.-U3H2UD4(SDHVT4-21X(-C(.3.-4A0(3F[DB=H(?A1DFB=H(H-2FU=1T0(43.3.S4D1H3((=1X2HQ
B=-10(.3.-4A(43.=1X=1T0(DBB31B=-1(?E=BH[=1TI(
(
(
:';(%<2=#('"2>(&="?&=@(%5"`&+K£;`( *I( j;*JK0(:IKHI +2B[34.(KFI(@(-I-Iz(DXX43??(C-4(H-443?Q
F-1X31H3a(2UI($DH[-X@^H3T-(KW-_HD(gn0(M*(78QgO9(`D4?@DEDz(3Q.D=Ua(EITDU2?†32B[34.I32((

You might also like