Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Teaching Grammar TEFL
Teaching Grammar TEFL
Teaching Grammar
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 1/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Table of contents
1. Discover China
2. What is Grammar?
3. Meaning
4. Function
5. Teaching Grammar
7. Grammar methods
17. Modality
18. Futurity
20. Determiners
26. Drilling
29. References
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 2/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
2. What is Grammar?
Re ective Task 1
Form
‘This is 01619941222. I am not at home now. Leave a message after the beep.’ (1)
The above is an example of language in use. You will easily recognise it as a typical answerphone message.
This is the text for it. It has three sentences, consisting of words.
All language can similarly be analysed at each of these four levels or forms:
Text.
Sentence.
Word.
Sound.
The study of grammar consists, in part, of analysing the way these forms are arranged and patterned.
For example, if you change the order of the sentences in the short text above, the message conveyed becomes more di cult to
understand:
‘Leave a message after the beep. This is 01619941222. I am not at home now.’
‘peeb’
Grammar is, therefore, partly a study of which forms or structures are possible in a language.
For example, grammar attempts to explain why the following sentences are acceptable.
Grammar also explains why these following sentence are not acceptable.
The system of rules that covers the order of words in a sentence is called syntax. Syntax rules disallow,
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 4/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
1. Discover China
Discover China
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 3/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
The system of rules that covers the formation of words is called morphology. Morphology rules disallow,
Grammar is conventionally seen as the study of syntax and morphology, or linguistic chains and slots i.e. the way words are
chained together in a particular order and what kinds of words can slot into any one link in the chain.
For example, consider the following linguistic chains and slots: (2)
1 2 3 4 5
We are not at home
They are in bed
I am at work
He Is in hospital
As you can see, the order of the words on the horizontal axis is fairly xed.
Switching the order of the rst two columns has a major e ect on the meaning.
It turns a sentence such as ‘They are in bed’ into a question: ‘Are they in bed?’ Switching columns 2, 3, 4 or 5 is simply not
possible because of syntax rules.
It is also clear that each element of the chain performs a similar function summarised below:
We can, therefore, slot di erent words into the chain above to make more sentences, as in this example.
noun
verb not preposition place
subject
You are not in Turkey
She Is at university
It is not, however, possible to take these slot lling elements and make exible chains out of them i.e. ‘Turkey in you not are’.
Activity 1
1. eating/love/sushi/we
2. Pizza Hut/eaten/at/has/Everyone
3. short/to/used/hair/I/have
Answers
1. We love eating sushi – noun subject + verb + verb ‘ing’ + noun object
2. Everyone has eaten at Pizza Hut – noun subject + verb have + past participle + preposition + noun place
3. I used to have short hair – subject noun + ‘used to’ + verb have + adjective + noun object
Di erent languages, of course, have di erent constraints on the way chains are ordered and slots lled.
This leads to learner errors when producing English resulting from overgeneralising rules from the learner’s own language.
In the example below, the learner has chosen the wrong chain to follow the word ‘want’. (3)
In the following sentence, the chain is correct but the words used to ll certain slots in the chain do not t.
‘Notorious’ has the wrong shade of meaning while ‘scienti c’ is an adjective, not a noun.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 5/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 6/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
3. Meaning
It is important for an English language learner to recognise and produce well-formed sentences but overly-focusing on form
also under equips the learner for real language use.
The sentence is grammatically correct i.e. it follows syntax and morphology rules but it lacks real meaning, especially out of
context.
The following text, though grammatically correct, also does not make sense: (4)
Though the sentence, ‘I am home now.’ is grammatically correct, it does not make sense in the context of an answerphone
message.
We would expect someone who is at home to answer the phone rather than rely on an answerphone message.
Sometimes meaning can be simply communicated through vocabulary without the need for grammar.
For example, on a train, the ticket inspector will say, ‘Tickets.’ It is very clear from the context the meaning he wants to convey
i.e. he wants to check your train ticket.
For example, if Milly is phoning Molly to ask Mandy to forward some pre-booked concert tickets, the word ‘tickets’ would be
inadequate and a sentence like the one below would be needed: (5)
‘Can you ask Mandy to send me the tickets that I booked last week?’
Grammatical forms convey two kinds of meaning representing the two main purposes of language: (6)
Representational.
Interpersonal.
Events or processes are conveyed by verbs, for example, ‘The sun sets.’.
Events or processes are intiated by people or things conveyed by nouns. These nouns then become the subject of the verb.
For example, ‘The children are playing.’.
Events or processes have an e ect on other people or things conveyed by nouns. These become the object of the verb. For
example, ‘The dog chased the cat.’.
The events take place in particular circumstances in time or space and these are encoded in adverbials. For example, ‘The dog
chased the cat in the garden.’.
Time can be conveyed by the use of tense. For example, ‘The children were playing.’
Events can be seen in their entirety. For example, ‘The sun sets.’ or ‘The sun was setting.’. The di erence between these
sentences is conveyed by aspect. Tense and aspect combine to form a wide range of meanings.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 7/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Activity 2
Answers
1. Noun subject
2. Noun object
3. Adverbial
4. Aspect (continuous)
5. Verb
Interpersonal meaning is re ected in the way grammar is used to ease the task of getting things done. (7)
For example, the same meaning can be conveyed by the following forms:
‘Tickets!’.
‘Tickets please’.
‘Can you show me your tickets, please?’.
‘Please’ is a lexical way of softening the command ‘tickets’. Using the modal verb ‘can’ and using a question or request rather
than a command is a grammatical way of softening the message.
Though di erent forms are used, the same meaning is conveyed but di erent choices are made with regards to form by the
speaker based on the situation.
An irate passenger, for example, may not respond to a command but may respond to a polite request.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 8/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
4. Function
Meaning, however, is not simply a case of unpacking a sentence’s words and phrases.
Consider the following exchange, from the lm Clueless, between a father and a young man who has arrived to take his
daughter out: (7)
In this exchange, the young man clearly misunderstood the father’s question, misconstruing a request for information as an
o er.
He understood both the form and the meaning. However, he didn’t understand the father’s intended meaning i.e. the function
of the question.
There is more than one function to the question ‘do you drink?’ and intended meaning is inferred in context.
When we process language, we try to make sense of the words and grammar as well as inferring the speaker’s intended
meaning or function.
From the mid-1970s, the relationship between grammar and function became an important consideration for EFL teaching.
There was a movement away from teaching grammatical structures as forms to teaching functions and di erent forms used to
express these functions with the focus on communicating real meaning.
For example, the forms below can all be used to express the function of giving advice:
For example, the 1st conditional form can be used to express a wide range of functions: (8)
Inviting.
Making plans.
Making requests.
Giving opinions – agreeing and disagreeing.
Giving advice.
Making o ers and giving suggestions.
Obligation, prohibition and permission.
Expressing regret.
Probability and possibilities.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 9/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Activity 3
Form Function
Answers
Though it is useful to group grammatical structures in terms of functions, as exempli ed in the earlier extract from Clueless, to
successfully match form and function, it is necessary to read clues from the context to understand the speaker’s meaning.
In Module 3, we considered the importance of planning a suitable context when teaching grammar and vocabulary.
Later in this module, we will consider planning suitable contexts and ways of building context when teaching grammatical
structures.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 10/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
5. Teaching Grammar
For most teachers, the decision about what grammar to teach and in which order is decided by the course book or syllabus.
The criteria for deciding which items to put in a syllabus are decided by: (9)
1. Usefulness.
2. Frequency.
For example, if a group of learners need to learn English to primarily write in English, written features of English such as
reported speech will be more useful.
If a group of learners need to learn English to primarily speak in English, spoken features of English such as making o ers and
requests will be more useful.
Many syllabi use a core grammar that will be useful to all learners, whatever their needs.
Criteria for grading the syllabus, or putting the items in order, include: (10)
1. Complexity.
2. Learnability.
3. Teachability.
Complexity
An item is complex if it has a number of elements and the more elements, the more complex the form.
For example, ‘I have been reading’ is more complex than ‘I am reading’ while ‘I will have been reading’ is more complex still.
Learnability
When considering learnability, research into the natural order of language acquisition has shown that learners acquire
grammatical forms in a predictable order.
Like children acquiring their mother tongue, learners of a foreign language will also go through certain stages in their language
learning.
For example, when learning past tense forms, regular forms (e.g. watched, washed) are acquired earlier than irregular forms
(e.g. swam, wrote) and syllabi re ects these stages.
Teachability
A third factor that in uences syllabus design is teachability, i.e. how easy it is to demonstrate the meaning of a particular
structure.
For example, it is relatively easy to demonstrate the meaning of Present Continuous (e.g. ‘I’m listening to music.’).
It is more di cult to demonstrate the meaning of hypothetical language (e.g. ‘If I’d gone to university, I would’ve become a
doctor.’).
Therefore, such language is often taught at a higher level, by which time simpler structures can be used to demonstrate and
check meaning.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 11/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Re ective Task 2
What do you consider the pros and cons of teaching grammar?
Pros Cons
Grammar as a sentence-machine.
Learning grammatical structures or patterns gives the learner the means for potentially limitless linguistic creativity.
Learners can communicate whatever they want once they have the structures in mind.
Fine-tuning.
Grammar allows for greater subtlety of meaning than vocabulary.
To avoid fossilisation.
Motivated learners can learn a language to a certain level of proficiency with formal study.
However, these learners often reach a plateau, beyond which it is difficult to progress.
Errors then become fossilised. However, grammar instruction can help to avoid fossilisation.
Advance-organiser.
Having an awareness of grammatical structures can help learners notice such language used in texts and interaction, thereby aiding language
acquisition.
Discrete Item.
By organising grammar into tidy categories, language learning becomes more digestible.
Rule-of-law.
Structured grammar rules can be taught and tested in methodical steps.
Learner expectations.
Many learners come to a language class with fixed expectations, including the teaching of grammar.
Experiential learning.
It is possible to learn all the grammar rules but not be given the chance to use these rules in real-life communication.
For example, if you know all the grammar rules but do not know how to use these rules to order a coffee or hire a taxi, communication is not possible.
Communication.
There is more to learning a language than just knowing it’s grammar system.
Communication can be successful even if the grammatical structures used are incorrect.
For example, the grammatically incorrect sentence ‘I go to the cinema last night’ causes no communication problems.
However, the grammatically correct sentence ‘I went to the orange last night’, using an incorrect word, causes confusion and a break down in
communication.
Acquisition.
Research by the linguist Stephen Krashen and others led some to argue that second language learning could mirror the way children learn their first
language, without formal instruction on grammatical rules.
Natural Order.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 12/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Noam Chomsky and others argued that there is a natural order in which learners learn grammar irrespective as to how grammar is taught in class.
For example, English-speaking children as well as foreign learners are likely to go through a phase of saying ‘I no like chips.’ before they progress to ‘I
don’t like chips.’.
Lexical chunks.
Michael Lewis and other proponents of the Lexical Approach argued that all language is essentially chunks of vocabulary items, for example, ‘Have a
nice day.’.
A lexical approach to language learning promotes the learning of chunks of language such as, ‘Have you ever been…?’, without labelling this as a
Present Perfect question form.
Learner expectations.
Many learners of English come to language classes, having already studied English grammar for many years.
Even so-called Beginner level students may already have a bank of passive grammar knowledge.
Students often come to language classes with the aim of speaking English, i.e. producing the language.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 13/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
7. Grammar methods
Over the last 100 or more years, the architects of language teaching methods have been concerned with the following
regarding the teaching of grammar: (12)
As discussed in Module 1, answers to the questions above have changed over the years as seen in some of the main methods
and approaches to teaching English:
Even in methods where grammar rules were made explicit, there was a di erent emphasis on the way the learner arrived at
these rules with two broadly di erent approaches to grammar teaching:
The deductive approach – Rules are explicitly presented to the learners and they are given practice in using them.
The inductive approach – Students study examples and work out the rules for themselves.
We will look at these two approaches in greater detail later in the module.
It has been said that grammar has experienced a ‘revival’ (13) in current EFL teaching because of the emergence of two
theoretical concepts:
Focus on form.
Consciousness-raising.
Research suggests that without some focus on form, learners run the risk of fossilisation.
While Krashen and others argued that learners can learn by being exposed to large doses of comprehensible input, others
argue that learners need to be consciously trained in noticing language contained in such input.
For example, learners can have their consciousness about the use of past tenses raised by underlining past tense forms used in
a newspaper article, then discuss why such forms are used.
To sum up, current thinking about teaching grammar is that if the teacher uses techniques to direct attention to form, and
provides activities that promote awareness of grammar, then learning is the result.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 14/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
The following principles are useful when thinking about grammar teaching: (14)
Prolonged attention to grammar is di cult to justify as the teacher’s attention should be partly directed at getting their learners
to communicate.
Economy is a key factor in any kind of training and, the more instructions given, the more confused a learner will be.
The most important factor is e cacy i.e. will it work? The e cacy of a grammar activity can be measured by the attention it
arouses, the quality of contextual information, explanation and checking, as well as how memorable it is to learners.
Appropriacy
All learners of English are di erent so an activity that works for one group of learners may not be appropriate for another
group of learners.
For example, a lesson based on discussing personal regrets to teach the 3rd conditional structure (e.g. ‘If I’d studied medicine, I
would’ve become a doctor.’) is appropriate for a group of adult learners but the same lesson will be less successful delivered to
a group of teenagers or younger learners, as they may not be familiar with the concept of regret.
Age.
Level.
Group size.
Monolingual or multilingual group.
Learner needs.
Learner interests.
Materials and resources available.
Previous learning experience.
Cultural factors.
Educational context.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 15/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
The purpose of this section is to introduce you to some key grammatical structures and concepts used in the English grammar
system.
You are not expected to be a grammar expert by the end of the section and it is advisable to purchase a grammar book to refer
to before and during your planning.
Suitable grammar books are included in the ‘Further Reading’ section at the end of this module.
Some of the explanations of the grammar points will start with a short activity so you can see how much you already know
about the grammar points.
Whether you are very familiar with the grammar system or not, it will be useful to attempt these activities, perhaps referring
back to them after each mini section to re-assess what you know.
It is highly likely that when you start teaching, your students may be more familiar with the names of di erent grammatical
structures than you.
While that may seem daunting, it is always important to remember that, as a teacher, you are likely to be either a native
speaker of English or a very high level non-native speaker of English so have the knowledge and experience of using English to
assist your learners.
If you are a native speaker of English, you will nd that high level non-native English speaking colleagues can be a valuable
resource to refer to about their experience of using English.
If you are a high level non-native speaker of English, native speakers can also be a valuable resource as native speakers will
have learned and use English without reference to grammar rules.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 16/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
A basic understanding of word classes and phrases, often called ‘parts of speech’ is a useful starting point for our consideration
of the English grammar system. (15)
Activity 4
1. Noun
2. Pronoun
3. Verb
4. Adjective
5. Adverb
6. Preposition
7. Determiner
8. Conjunction
The purpose of the parts of speech listed above can be summarised below:
Noun: A word which names things, people, places, objects, activities etc.
Pronoun: A word applied to a subject or object which substitutes for a noun.
Verb: A word that expresses an action, process or state.
Adjective: A word that identi es an aspect of a noun.
Adverb: A word that speci es the time, place or manner of a verb.
Preposition: A word that relates the nouns to other elements, for example, time and place.
Determiner: A word used in front of a noun to express number and quantity.
Conjunction: A word used to link clauses or words to each other.
Analysis of the rst sentence in the example shows that many of the words in sentences cluster in groups as below.
These groupings are called phrases and have functions like individual parts of speech:
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 18/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Sentence Elements
There are ve di erent types of sentence elements: (16)
Subject: Identi es the topic of the sentence and agent of the action.
Verb: Expresses an action, process or state.
Object: Identi es who or what is a ected by the action.
Complement: Gives further information about some element.
Adverbial: Gives information about the time, manner or place of the situation.
Activity 5
Answers
Sentence Structures
There are four types of sentence structures:
1. Simple Sentence: This contains one independent clause. For example: I will do some studying.
2. Complex sentences are those that consist of one independent clause and at least one dependent clause. The independent
clause can stand alone as a sentence but a dependent clause cannot.
An example of a complex sentence below shows the independent clause underlined and the dependent clause in bold:
Dependent
Example
Clause
Relative Clause There was an old woman who lived in a shoe.
She had so many children she didn’t know what
Noun Clause
to do.
Adverbial As I was going to St Ives, I met a man with
Clause seven wives.
3. Compound Sentences have 2 or more independent clauses. For example: I will do some studying and I will go for a run.
4. Compound - Complex Sentences have at least 2 independent clauses and at least one dependent clause. For example: I will
do some studying and I will go for a run before I have dinner.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 19/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
English uses a variety of syntactic and lexical features to form negative statements.
There are slightly di erent ways of forming questions in di erent tenses. However, the general rules are below:
Direct yes/no
Did you go to the
questions other Aux + subject + verb
cinema?
verbs
Direct wh-question Wh Q + to be +
Where are you from?
verb to be subject
When did Queen
Direct wh-question Wh Q + aux + subject
release Bohemian
other verbs + verb
Rhapsody?
Indirect question Phrase + if + subject I wonder if you are
yes/no + verb OK.
Indirect question Phrase + Wh Q + I wonder where you
Wh Q subject +verb are
Subject question Wh Q + verb? Who shot JFK?
You’re hungry, aren’t
Positive statement +
you?
negative tag
Tag question Doctor Who wasn’t
Negative statement +
on TV last night, was
positive tag
it?
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 21/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
This section introduces the areas of grammatical tenses, which is the main focus of most grammar and teaching materials.
Activity 6
I eat chocolate.
Suggested Answers
Verbs are modi ed according to the rules of grammar morphology in the following ways to form di erent structures.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 22/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Activity 7
Perfect
Time Simple Continuous Perfect
Continuous
Present I watch TV
I was I had been
Past
watching TV watching TV
I will watch I will have
Future
TV watched
Answers
Perfect
Time Simple Continuous Perfect
Continuous
I am I have I have been
Present I watch TV
watching TV watched TV watching TV
I was
I watched I had I had been
Past watching
TV watched TV watching TV
TV.
I will have
I will watch I will be I will have
Future been
TV watching TV watched
watching TV
Activity 8
Can you identify the underlined verb forms in the text below?
Answers
1. Present Simple
2. Present Perfect Simple
3. Past Simple
4. Past Perfect Simple
5. Present Perfect Continuous
6. Present Perfect Simple
7. Future Simple
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 23/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
One of the purposes of grammar is to identify the relationship between tense and real time.
Activity 9
As you can see from the examples below, tenses can be used to describe di erent time references as exempli ed by the
Present Simple tense below.
For example, it would be appropriate to teach Present Simple tense for Present habits or routines and states to Beginner and
Elementary learners, for future scheduled events at Intermediate level and conditionals and adverbial clauses at Intermediate
and higher levels.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 24/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Activity 10
Answers
Past Simple is used to describe past states, past events and past habits as well as describing hypothetical meaning with a
present time reference.
Activity 11
Answers
Past Perfect Simple is usually used with Past Simple to highlight that one action happened before another action in the past.
For example, in the sentence above, ‘been there for only a few hours’ happened before Robert ‘started to feel really ill’.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 25/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
The di erent ways of marking a verb phrase to convey the speaker’s perception of the event is called ‘aspect’.
The continuous aspect is used when the speaker perceives an action as being in progress, having limited duration or
incomplete or temporary.
Simple and continuous tense forms are often interchangeable depending on the speaker’s perception of the situation.
For example, in the rst sentence below, the speaker views his situation as permanent.
Even though the speaker has been driving taxis for 20 years, he hopes to do something else in the future.
The continuous aspect is formed by the auxiliary verb ‘to be’ and the present participle i.e. subject + verb to be + present
participle.
Here is a list of a number of di erent uses for the Present Continuous tense.
Use Example
Events in progress at the I’m listening to the radio at the
time of speaking moment.
I’m working in McDonalds for a
Temporary situations in the
few weeks while I nish
present
university.
Changing or developing
Prices are rising.
events in the present
Repeated actions in the He’s always singing in the
present shower.
The sun is shining. The birds are
Describe the background to
singing. I’m in love and life is
an event
wonderful.
Present arrangement for a
I’m ying to Ireland next week.
future event
The Past Continuous tense can also be used to describe events in progress at the time of speaking, temporary situations in the
past, changing events in the past, repeated actions in the past and describing the background to an event.
Past Continuous is also often used with Past Simple in narratives to compare two actions in which one action is interrupted by
another action.
For example,
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 26/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
In the example sentence above, John started watching TV before the phone rang.
The short, completed action of the phone ringing interrupted the longer action of TV watching.
The speaker looks back from one time to the time before and views the action described as completed.
For example, in the sentence ‘I’ve been to Turkey.’ (Present Perfect Simple), the speaker is talking from the present time looking
back at an unspeci ed past time viewed as completed.
In the sentence, ‘By the end of the evening, I’ll have nished the assignment.’ the speaker is imagining themselves at a future
point in time (end of the evening) looking back at an earlier future time and viewing the action as completed (have nished).
Present Perfect Simple is used to link the present and past times and has the following uses. (19)
The Present Perfect Continuous is used to suggest the incompleteness of an activity that started in the past and continued to
the present for example ‘I’ve been listening to the radio all day’ i.e. the action started in the past, is still happening and is likely
to continue into the future.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 27/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
In an active sentence, the subject of the sentence is at the start of the sentence, followed by the verb then the object.
In a passive sentence, the sentence starts with the object, followed by the verb form in the passive voice then possibly followed
by the subject.
The passive voice is often used when we want to place more importance on the object of the sentence.
In the passive example above, the assassination of JF Kennedy is more important than the unknown person who carried it out.
The passive voice is formed using the verb ‘to be’ in the appropriate tense followed by the past participle i.e. subject + verb to
be + past participle.
The passive voice can also be used for the following reasons:
The object is more important e.g. ‘JF Kennedy was shot.’ (by an unknown assailant).
The subject is unknown e.g. ‘My laptop was stolen last night.’.
Formal register e.g. ‘You are advised to buy home insurance.’.
Activity 12
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 28/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
17. Modality
As well as being marked for tense, aspect and voice, verbs can be marked for modality.
Modal verbs are auxiliary verbs that function as an indicator of the speaker’s judgement about the likelihood or desirability of
the situation.
They convey a range of di erent meanings and some modal verbs can express a range of di erent meanings, depending on the
context. (20)
Activity 13
Answers
1. Can’t – prohibition
2. Must – strong obligation
3. Should – obligation
4. Will – future
Modal verbs function di erently syntactically compared to lexical verbs in the following ways:
For example, ‘Must you go?’ NOT ‘Do you have to go?’.
The chart below shows some concepts expressed by common modal verbs:
May/may
Can/can’t Could/couldn’t Might/mightn’t Should/shouldn’t Must/mustn’t
not
Likelihood/Probability Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 29/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 30/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
18. Futurity
The above sounds strange because we have already discussed ways of expressing the future.
However, unlike other languages, there is no speci c tense form to express futurity.
We have previously discussed ways of forming the future using the modal verb ‘will’ and the form will + base in nitive.
The choice of future form is determined by the speaker’s perception of how the future event is to come about.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 31/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Hypothetical meaning is meaning expressed through conditional sentences, described as ‘real’ or ‘unreal’ conditionals.
The main clause expresses the proposition, quali ed by the dependent or condition clause.
The conjunction ‘if’ is often, though not exclusively used to link both clauses.
For example, ‘If it rains tomorrow (proposition), I’ll bring my umbrella (condition or result).’.
The modal verb ‘will’ is used in real conditionals, while ‘would’ is used in unreal conditional.
In real conditionals, the verb form refers to real time, indicating that the events or states expressed are theoretically possible.
In unreal conditionals, the verb forms do not refer to real time as the events or states described are unlikely or impossible.
Conditional Time
Real/Unreal Example
Form Reference
Zero All Real If it rains, you get wet.
If it rains tomorrow, I’ll take
First Future Real
an umbrella.
If I won the lottery, I would
Second Present/future Unreal
travel around the world.
If I had married him, I would
Third Past Unreal
have been happy.
Mixed (2 If I had studied medicine, I
Past/Present Unreal
and 3) would be a doctor.
While real conditionals express probability or possibility, unreal conditionals related to present time are used to express the
following functions:
Hypothesising about unlikely or impossible situations e.g. ‘If I won the lottery, I would travel around the world.'.
Giving advice e.g. ‘If I were you, I would go to the doctor.’.
In older English, the subjunctive mood was used to express hypothetical meaning.
The subjunctive mood can still be seen in the use of ‘were’ instead of ‘was’ when giving advice using a Second Conditional form.
In modern English, it has become acceptable to also say ‘If I was you’ and course books and grammars will teach both forms.
The Third and Mixed Conditional forms are also used to express past regret.
In addition to conditional forms, hypothetical meaning can also be expressed using the following phrases.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 32/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 33/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
20. Determiners
Determiners are a class of words used with nouns and have the function of de ning the reference of the noun in some way.
Some/any
Some is mainly used in a rmative statements and ‘any’ in negative statements and questions.
Limited but vague numbers or quantities. For example, ‘We’ve planted some roses’.
With uncountable and plural nouns. For example, ‘some cheese’, ‘I don’t have any eggs’.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 34/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
The deductive - Rules are explicitly presented to the learners and they are given practise in using them.
The inductive - Students study examples and work out the rules for themselves.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 35/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
The deductive, rule-driven approach to language learning was traditionally associated with the Grammar-Translation method
and a rule-driven approach can be used when appropriate in modern EFL classes.
Re ective Task 3
What are the advantages and disadvantages of a deductive
approach to language learning?
Advantages Disadvantages
It gets straight to the point and can be time-saving. Some rules can be more simply and e ciently explained than deduced
from examples.
It acknowledges the role of cognitive processes in language learning.
It meets student expectations of how language are learned. Learners with an analytical learning style enjoy these lessons.
It allows for teachers to deal with language points as they come up.
Starting the lesson o with a grammar presentation may be o -putting for learners.
Grammar explanation encourages a teacher-centred approach.
Explanation is seldom as memorable as other forms of presentation such as demonstration.
A deductive approach encourages the belief that learning a language is simply a case of learning the rules.
The success of a rule-driven approach hinges on the quality of the rule explanation. A good rule follows the following criteria:
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 36/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Inductive learning involves exposure to a large amount of input in which the patterns of the language become evident.
The learner studies examples of language use and derives an understanding of the rules from these.
Natural language acquisition in uences approaches such as the Direct Method to encourage the teaching of English without
explicit reference to grammatical rules.
Approaches such as Situational Learning Teaching sought to generate situations in which the language is clear.
Students studied the examples with the teacher guiding them to reach the grammatical rules.
Developments in language learning have promoted the use of guided discovery, in which learners are given examples to
analyse, and guided by the teacher to analyse language and draw conclusions about language use.
Discovery learning involves a cycle of trial and error with guidance and feedback from the teacher.
Inductive learning can be done through the analysis of sample sentences or by using reading or listening texts.
When using texts, the students read or listen for comprehension, then analyse the text for grammatical forms.
Re ective 4
What are the advantages and disadvantages of an inductive
approach to learning?
Advantages Disadvantages
Rules learners discover for themselves are more likely to be memorable for learners.
The mental e ort involved in working out the rules ensures greater memorability.
Students are more actively involved in the learning process.
It is an approach which favours pattern-recognition and problem-solving.
If the problem-solving is done collaboratively, students get extra language practice in the target language.
Working things out for themselves encourages learner autonomy. Learners will then, hopefully, show greater autonomy
outside the class by independently reading and listening to texts, working out the meaning of language in context.
The teacher gives students examples of Present Simple and Present Continuous sentences.
Students analyse the sentences collaboratively and decide on rules.
Teacher gives feedback on the rules and guides in the correct direction.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 37/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Students read an extract from a short story and answer comprehension questions.
Students underline all uses of narrative tenses – Past Simple, Past Continuous and Past Perfect.
Students analyse the example sentences for rules.
Teacher gives feedback on the rules and more guidance on the rules.
Students re-analyse for rules.
Rules are drawn and language then practised.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 38/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
As discussed previously, it is important to set a context, especially when presenting language in a situational context.
Students are at a low level and the teacher wants to keep extraneous language to a minimum.
If the meaning and use of the language is complex then clear, simple and generative context is needed to illustrate the
meaning.
If a single language item is being introduced.
To create a natural and memorable context the students can relate to.
To bolster understanding.
To generate and provide students with several examples of grammatical form.
To engage students.
To challenge students who claim to ‘know’ grammatical structures but who are unable to produce these structures naturally.
Give students examples of real language.
Focus on function rather than just form. This is particularly important when grammatical forms have multiple functions.
Natural.
Unambiguous.
Engaging.
Related to the students’ lives.
Generative, many examples can be made from the context.
Clear and simple.
Memorable.
Student-involving.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 39/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Activity 14
Suggested Answers
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 40/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Concept checking
Once target language has been elicited from context, it is important to check that students fully understand the target
language.
Timelines
Concept questions
Timelines are an e ective way of checking understanding of grammatical tenses and their relationship with time.
The basic diagram consists of a straight line which can be labelled as necessary:
Crosses can be used to represent single or repeated actions and wavy lines to represent continuous actions.
An example is below:
Checking understanding by just asking students ‘Do you understand?’ is a poor way of checking understanding.
It is likely that students will just say ‘yes’ to save face or to please you.
Alternatively, they may think they understand but have grasped the wrong meaning of a structure.
Concept questions should not use the target language you are going to teach.
You should be able to write 3 statements about the target language, then turn these statements into yes/no questions.
For example,
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 41/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Activity 15
Suggested Answers
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 42/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Instant or ‘hot’ correction is used by the teacher during the drills to focus on accuracy.
If students are having pronunciation issues with one part of the structure, the teacher can focus on that part and provide extra
drilling practice.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 44/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
26. Drilling
Drilling is a technique developed in the Audio-Lingual Method, in which the teacher models the target language clearly and the
students repeat that language.
Drilling takes place once the target language has been presented through context and the model sentence elicited.
Activity 16
Drilling is a useful technique to provide learners with controlled practice of form and focuses on pronunciation.
It maximises student talking time and gives students chance to practise in a group without embarrassment and with support
from the teacher.
A technique for drilling more complex structures is back-chaining or drilling in short chunks starting at the end of the sentence.
For example, if your model sentence is, ‘If I won the lottery, I’d travel around the world.’, the sentence can be back-chained in
the following way with students repeating each utterance as it becomes longer and longer.
Grammatical practice is needed to ensure that students can use the language presented to them either deductively or
inductively.
Learners also need to appreciate the value of focusing on accuracy i.e. without accuracy learners risk being unintelligible and
communication breaking down.
Attention to form.
Familiarity.
Thinking time.
Feedback.
A rmative/negative/questions. Students are given a sentence and asked to write the question form or the negative form.
This helps to practise the mechanics of form.
Matching/categorising exercises. Students are given six sentences using di erent grammatical forms. Students match the
sentences to the correct grammatical tense.
Matching sentence halves. Matching the beginning of sentences to the end of sentences.
Cloze test. A gap ll with random words gapped out – This is good for practising language with higher levels.
Multiple choice. E.g. ‘Choose the right word for the sentence – If I won the lottery I _________ travel around the world’ a)
would b) will c) to.
Put one word from a list into a multi-gapped text. For example, ‘When he _____ the beautiful woman in the bar, he _____ up
to her and _____ her if she _____ a drink. Unfortunately, she _____ ‘no’. SAID/WANTED/WENT/ASKED/SAW.
Change a sentence to a di erent time, aspect or voice. E.g. ‘She’s dancing’ – ‘She was dancing’.
Rearrange words to make a sentence. E.g. ‘you very I much love’ – I love you very much.
Using key words to make a sentence. E.g. ‘despite/bad headache/I/go/school’ – Despite having a bad headache, I went to
school.
Find and correct the mistake. E.g. ‘When I will visit you, I’ll see your new at’ – mistake is extra ‘will’ in the main clause – the
correct sentence should be ‘When I visit you, I’ll see your new at’.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 45/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Dictation. Say a sentence at natural speed and ask learners to write down – some unstressed words will be di cult to hear
so students will need to use their knowledge of form to write correct sentences.
With monolingual classes you can also use translation into their rst language to check meaning.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 46/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Practice activities aimed at developing uency need to divert attention away from form.
One way of doing this is to prepare tasks which focus primarily on meaning.
Information gap activities. Students have two texts or pictures with di erent information missing from each text. Students
must answer questions to their partner to nd the information. For example, the complete sentence in a text may be ‘John
Lennon was born in 1940 in Liverpool.’. Student A may have the following information ‘John Lennon was born in 1940 in
_______ while student B has the following information ‘John Lennon was born in ______ in Liverpool.’. They both need to ask
questions to nd the missing information.
Problem-solving task. Students are presented with a problem to solve and need to use the target language to discuss the
problem. For example, students may have a list of equipment to take with them to a desert island then decide which items
are the most necessary for example ‘If we took the rope, we could use it to…’.
Role-play. Students are given a role-play. The main aim is to communicate to achieve an aim but they need to use the target
language in order to do this for example a role-play in which students are attending a job interview and need to answer
questions with ‘have you ever…’ for example, ‘Have you ever used a computer?’.
Group work task. Students are given a task to complete, for example, organising a party. They use the target language to
give suggestions and o ers for example ‘I’ll bring the balloons’ ‘Why don’t we hire a band?’ and so on.
Giving opinions. Set up a debate to discuss the pros and cons of an argument, for example, ‘I think we should ban fox-
hunting’.
Group writing. Students write a story with prompts to practise narrative tenses.
Real life communication. Encourage students to use the real world environment if possible, for example, order a co ee at
the local café, interview a member of sta or a fellow student.
Surveys and reports. Students prepare questions then prepare a summary or short report, for example, 10 people in our
class have been to China.
Personalisation activities. Any type of personalised discussion works well as students focus on what they want to
communicate, focusing on meaning rather than form.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 47/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
29. References
'Ibid' means a reference has quoted work from the previously used reference.
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 48/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
Swan, M (1995) Practical English Usage (2nd edition) Oxford University Press
Swan, M & Smith, B (2001) Learner English (3rd Edition) Cambridge University Press
Swan, M & Walter, C (2001) The Good Grammar Book, Oxford University Press
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 49/50
03/08/2020 Teaching Grammar
https://courses.premiertefl.com/mod/book/tool/print/index.php?id=141 50/50