Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Product Management Overview
Product Management Overview
Economics of Platform
Introduction to Microeconomics in Business:
Microeconomics is the study of the behavior of individual
markets, businesses, and consumers. It forms the
foundation of management education and is crucial for
understanding various business aspects.
Microeconomics is particularly relevant to product
managers (PMs) as it helps them understand market
dynamics, competition, and customer behavior.
The chapter starts by applying microeconomics to the
technology industry, offering insights for PMs on essential
features, competition, and aligning personal goals with the
organization's strategy.
The Framework for Analyzing Platforms:
The chapter introduces a framework to understand platform businesses. These platforms facilitate
exchanges between different segments of users or sides.
Three critical factors in this framework are:
Economies of Scale: Examines the cost to produce one extra unit or service for one more user.
Network Effects: Focuses on how the platform's value increases as more users join.
Differentiability: Explores how a platform can create a unique space in the customer's mind.
Economies of Scale:
Economies of scale exist when the cost per unit decreases as production or service volume increases.
The concept is explained with a demand-supply curve. Initially, as production increases, the marginal
cost decreases, but after a certain point, it might increase
due to various factors like managerial costs and raw
material costs.
Companies with highly scalable operations can delay the
upward curve of marginal costs, leading to greater market
dominance.
Network Effects:
Network effects occur when the value of a platform or product increases as more users join.
Network effects can be categorized as cross-
side and same-side network effects, and
further as local and global network effects.
Cross-side network effects exist when one side
benefits from more users on the other side.
Same-side network effects occur when adding
more users of the same type increases the
value for everyone.
Local network effects are confined to specific
regions, while global network effects affect broader markets.
Companies with strong network effects tend to dominate markets faster, creating natural monopolies.
Differentiability:
Differentiability means creating a unique value proposition in the customer's mind. It is external and
unrelated to internal processes.
Differentiability can be achieved by increasing customer switching costs or raising convergence costs.
Low customer switching costs and high convergence costs can create space for smaller players to
compete with dominant companies.
Implications and Application:
Companies with strong economies of scale
and network effects are more likely to
become dominant players in their markets.
Late movers must focus on differentiation by
increasing customer switching costs and
introducing features that raise convergence
costs.
Case Studies:
Google: Google's dominance in the search market is attributed to economies of scale and strong
network effects. Google continually improved its search algorithm, benefiting from same-side network
effects, where more searches improved the algorithm's accuracy and usefulness.
Amazon: Amazon, while not necessarily having high economies of scale, understood that customer
switching costs were high. Amazon successfully increased customer switching costs by introducing
Amazon Prime, a loyalty program that offered a wide range of benefits. Amazon also leveraged cross-
side network effects by introducing advertising for third-party sellers.
Uber: Uber faces the challenge of local network effects, meaning its growth is primarily limited to
specific cities. To improve value and compete in local markets, Uber can explore mergers and
acquisitions, introduce loyalty programs, and expand into transportation beyond ride-hailing.
E-commerce
E-commerce, or electronic commerce,
involves buying and selling products online
or over the internet.
The industry can be categorized based on its
business applications, which can range from
online marketplaces to subscription services.
Examples include Amazon (online
marketplace) and Netflix (subscription
service).
User Personas in E-commerce:
Shoppers: Those looking for products.
Sellers: Individuals or businesses selling products.
Admins: Platform administrators managing content and
operations.
User Journey in E-commerce:
E-commerce User Journey Stages:
1. User Acquisition: Begins with attracting users from various internet channels, including Paid (e.g.,
ads), Organic (e.g., SEO), Direct (landing directly), or Referral.
2. Brand Recall: Direct traffic indicates brand
recognition, such as users typing in website
URLs directly, signifying a strong brand
recall.
3. Research: Users search for products on the
platform using avenues like free-text
search, category navigation, or in-app
promotions.
4. Select: Users choose products they want to
buy and add them to the cart.
5. Schedule Order: Users specify when and
where they want the product delivered.
Some platforms ask for delivery times and
addresses.
6. Pay For Order: Users select payment methods, which may vary based on the product and platform.
7. Place Order: Users confirm the order, and it is placed with the platform.
8. Order Fulfillment: In most cases, the order is fulfilled offline by a delivery executive. For platforms like
BookMyShow, the ticket is available as a QR code.
9. User Retention: Platforms aim to bring users back and increase their lifetime value through
notifications and pixel retargeting on other platforms.
Platform Structure:
E-commerce platforms have three primary sections:
Section I: Research and selection phase,
including the landing page, product listing
page, product description page, cart page,
and confirming the delivery schedule.
Section II: Managing orders, tracking, and
viewing order history.
Section III: Allowing users to provide reviews
and feedback.
Challenges and Risks in E-commerce:
Customer Loyalty: Retaining users
in a competitive market.
Consumer Protection Guidelines:
Complying with changing
regulations and antitrust laws.
FDI Rules: Adhering to evolving
government regulations on foreign
direct investment.
Rural Reach: Expanding into rural
areas with limited infrastructure
and education.
Reverse Logistics: Efficiently
managing returns.
SEO Evolution: Adapting to new
search methods, like voice search.
Entrepreneurial Opportunities in E-
commerce:
Creating niche online
marketplaces tailored to
specific products or
industries.
Developing innovative last-mile delivery solutions for efficient and cost-effective service.
Offering SEO services that adapt to evolving search trends.
Providing solutions to enhance customer data security and compliance with regulations.
Fintech in India and Business Models:
Fintech Growth in India:
Fintech is one of India's fastest-growing
sectors.
Expected to see substantial growth from
$65 billion in 2019 to $140 billion in 2023.
Digital payments are a significant
contributor, with a CAGR of 20% until 2023.
Key drivers include NEFT, RTGS, IMPS, and
digital wallets, along with the 2016
demonetization initiative.
Government support and innovation have led to new business models.
Fintech Startup Models in India (2019):
Payment Gateways
Digital Wallets
Digital Insurance/InsurTech
Digital Lending
Point of Sale (PoS)
Neo Banking
WealthTech
Fintech Business Models:
Payment Gateways and Digital Wallets:
Witnessed significant growth after demonetization.
Key players: PayTM, MobiKwik, FreeCharge, RazorPay.
Digital Lending:
Focused on meeting credit demand for MSMEs and consumers.
Utilizes technology and credit scores for loans.
Notable companies: LendingKart, Capital Float, RupeePower, Rupeek.
Point of Sale (PoS):
Facilitates retail transactions, particularly card payments.
Providers like Ezetap, Mswipe, Pine Labs, Innoviti, Mosambee, Payswiff.
Neo Banking:
Emerging as digital-only platforms offering efficient and cost-effective banking services.
Examples: SBI Yono, Open, Kotak 811.
Wealth Management (WealthTech):
Digital solutions for investment management.
Benefiting both investors and firms.
Prominent companies: Zerodha, PayTM Money, Groww.
Zerodha: A Case Study:
Pioneered the online discount brokerage model in India.
Notable platforms: Kite for trading and Coin for
commission-free mutual funds.
Accounts for about 15% of retail trading volume.
Focused on organic growth, recently valued at $1 billion.
Utilizes a discount broking model with low operating costs.
Business Model Analysis (Osterwalder's Framework):
1. Tech Stack: Utilizes C++, Java, VueJS, Flutter, Kafka, and other technologies.
2. App Critique: Login page can be optimized for faster loading; stock trend view may benefit from
simplification; watchlist is user-friendly.
3. Feature Enhancement: Adding stock history, relevant news, and analysis can improve user
engagement.
4. Home Page: Consider refining the design to include daily news updates and stock filters for ease of
access.
5. News and Partner Apps: Integrating partner apps into the main app may enhance the user
experience.
Healthtech Industry:
Healthtech refers to the use of technology to improve
various aspects of the healthcare system.
Encompasses a wide range of applications, from telehealth
to robotic-assisted medical procedures and fitness apps.
The healthtech industry is experiencing rapid growth,
attracting significant venture capital funding.
The global healthtech market is expected to reach $112
billion by 2025, with a CAGR of 44.2%.
Healthtech includes various categories of apps, such as
health habits, productivity, healthcare checkups,
meditation, fitness, and medicine delivery.
Practo: A Case Study in Healthtech:
Key Activities:
Software development.
Networking with multiple
stakeholders.
Promotions.
Consumer/Partner Segments:
Patients.
Clinics.
Hospitals.
Pathology Labs.
Pharmacies.
Insurance companies.
Doctors.
Delivery partners.
Key Resources:
Website and mobile app.
Manpower skills.
IT infrastructure.
Crossing the Chasm:
Geoffrey Moore's theory of "crossing the chasm" applies to technology products.
Practo addressed the challenge of crossing the chasm by focusing on creating value for consumers and
ease of use.
Practo started as a multi-sided platform, involving doctors, clinics, hospitals, and patients.
Revenue Model:
Practo adopted a three-tier pricing plan for
doctors.
Initially offered free services for patients
and later introduced a nominal monthly
charge for listing doctors.
Focused on acquiring more doctors and
patients, resulting in network effects.
App Critique:
The Practo app provides a good user
interface but has a lengthy home page with
too many features.
The app's menu bar is intuitive and easy to
use.
Features like reminders are simple and
effective.
The app has the potential to improve user
ratings on Android based on its
performance on iOS.
Future Trends in Healthtech:
Future healthtech innovations will be built
on mobile applications, blockchain back-
end, AI, and big data analysis.
User empathy and personalization are
crucial in designing healthtech solutions.
Deep multi-level architecture in apps can
lead to users missing out on important
features.
Consistency in visual design is essential for
clear communication.
Providing a summary of the complete
process can enhance user understanding.
In-depth user profiling and understanding jobs to be done are vital for designing effective solutions.
Identifying the platform and business strategy is crucial, with a focus on modules for patients, doctors,
clinics, diagnostics, and delivery
Ride-Hailing Industry.
The taxi-booking market was once fragmented and lacked transparency.
Regional players existed but offered little differentiation from traditional taxi services.
Uber and Ola introduced transparency and reliability to the industry, along with lower search costs.
The Indian ride-hailing market is estimated to be ₹20,000-25,000 crores.
Business Model Canvas:
Value Proposition: Transparency, reliability, and convenience in booking rides.
Competitive advantage: Introducing disruptive technology and efficient service.
Customer Segment: Passengers and drivers.
Channels: Mobile apps and websites.
Customer Relationships: Convenient, hassle-free, and reliable service.
Key Activities: Technology development, driver recruitment, passenger engagement.
Key Resources: Mobile apps, IT infrastructure, customer base.
Key Partners: Drivers and vehicle partners.
Tech Stack:
Infrastructure and Storage: Hybrid cloud model (cloud and physical data centers), Schemaless, SQL,
Riak, Cassandra.
Logging: Interaction data stored and analyzed through distributed file systems (Hadoop).
App Provisioning: Docker containers on Mesos, Aurora for long-running services, and cron jobs.
Routing and Service Discovery: Service-oriented architecture (SOA), HAProxy, Hyperbahn.
Development, Deployment, and Testing: Simulations on virtual machines.
App Comparison:
Login:
Uber offers a minimalist design focused on essential information.
Ola's login process includes switching on GPS and may be less user-friendly.
Landing Screen:
Uber provides a simple, distraction-free screen.
Ola's landing screen includes ride options and offers, potentially overwhelming users.
Confirming the Ride:
Uber offers default options based on previous rides, enhancing user experience.
Ola's default option is often "Book Any," potentially less economical.
Scheduling the Ride:
Uber integrates ride details with the calendar, making it easier for users.
Ola's scheduling option appears after selecting the route.
COVID-19 Upgrades:
Ola emphasizes safety guidelines and customer feedback regarding COVID-19.
Uber's approach to COVID-19 safety measures is not mentioned in the provided text.
Travel Tech
Impact of COVID-19 on the Travel Industry:
The COVID-19 pandemic severely impacted
the travel industry and has driven its
transformation.
Before the lockdown, technology
companies were already changing how
people travel.
In 2019, the travel industry was at its peak, with leisure travel spending at $4.7 trillion.
User Journey in Travel:
A user's journey in the travel industry mainly consists of discovery, booking, and the travel experience.
Various players are involved in each step of the journey, shaping the customer experience.
Business Model Elements in Travel:
The business model choices of travel tech
companies determine their strategies.
There are nine different categories shaping
the modern travel experience, based on an
umbrella business model.
Online Travel Agencies (OTA) in India:
Convenience and price comparison have
driven the adoption of OTAs in India.
OTAs compete for market share by focusing
on offering better services and improving the user experience.
UX Design Principles:
UX design follows five basic principles: design for users, provide feedback, ensure digestibility, offer
clarity, and incorporate familiarity.
Comparison of OTA Apps:
The UX of two popular OTA apps in India, MakeMyTrip and Yatra, is compared to improve user
engagement and revenue.
EdTech
EdTech refers to the use of technology in education, and India has a vast wireless internet subscriber
base.
In 2018, EdTech was the fourth-largest sector in terms of startup investments.
K12 and online certifications received significant investments, driven by India's demand for education
and skilled labor.
Customer Needs in EdTech:
EdTech apps serve as supplements to classroom learning, tailored to individual learning speeds.
The journey of school students through these apps is crucial and needs to be personalized based on
their abilities and interests.
Student Journey:
A typical school student's
journey in an EdTech platform
involves progression from
kindergarten to grade 12,
with a focus on competitive
exams.
Byju's:
Byju's is India's highest-valued EdTech company, offering pre-recorded course videos through mobile
apps and tablets.
It targets students from kindergarten to grade 12, enhancing customer lifetime value.
Parent Journey:
Parents play a vital role in the
decisions about their
children's education, and
both students and parents
must see value in the
platform.
Vedantu:
Vedantu operates as a marketplace for teachers and students, offering live classes through its
proprietary virtual learning environment.
It caters to students from grades 6 to 12, primarily from the CBSE and ICSE boards.
Evaluation of the Product:
Subscription-based EdTech companies focus on signing up customers and reducing churn through
higher engagement and value delivery.
UI/UX and features of apps have been
evaluated based on three stages:
Trial & On-boarding,
Nurturing & Expansion, and
Renewal & Loyalty.
Business Model Canvas:
The Business Model Canvas highlights
specific elements for Byju's and Vedantu,
covering aspects like customer segments,
value propositions, and distribution
channels.
Recommendations and Product Improvement:
Suggestions for product improvement
include the introduction of a search bar for
direct lesson access, a help document for
issue resolution, and in-app purchases for
content upgrades.
Foodtech Industry
Online food orders have seen significant
growth in recent years, contributing a
growing share to the food delivery market.
Zomato experienced a four-fold increase in
orders in the first quarter of 2020 compared
to 2019, indicating the rising popularity of
online food delivery.
The Foodtech industry encompasses various
business models, including home food
delivery, recipe discovery, and personalized
nutrition.
Business Model Analysis:
Swiggy primarily helps users find restaurants and dishes and coordinates delivery.
Zomato offers restaurant discovery, detailed reviews, and a pickup option, along with a service called
'hyperpure' for high-quality raw materials to restaurants.
User Personas:
Three user personas are identified based on order frequency and dish affinity: New User,
Cuisine/Restaurant Explorer, and Frequent Repeat User.
App Critique and Comparison:
Lazy Sign-In: Both Swiggy and Zomato allow users to explore without mandatory sign-in. Zomato's
"Skip" option is more intuitive than Swiggy's.
Restaurant Explorer Page: Zomato offers better organization, filtering options, and additional features
like videos and community insights, enhancing user experience.
Restaurant Landing Page: Zomato provides more comprehensive restaurant reviews and better
placement of best-seller dishes, improving the ordering experience.
Covid-Related Initiatives: Zomato excels in communicating safety measures, providing transparency
on orders delivered, and detailing restaurant-specific safety precautions.