Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Best Buy Strategic Management Term Paper
Best Buy Strategic Management Term Paper
Best Buy Strategic Management Term Paper
Table of Contents
Introduction ……………………………………………………………………………………. 4
Appendix……….………………………………………………………………………………..1
References ………………………………………………………………………………………1
3
Executive Summary
In this paper, you will discern the strategic analysis of Best Buy, a technology based retailer
headquartered in the United States. The objective of this inquiry is to use both internal analysis,
and external analysis to provide Best Buy with strategy recommendations to help quantify the
overall administrative direction the company should take as well as arrange procedures needed to
be implemented in order to improve its current sales figures. Breaking down the material, the
goal of the external analysis is to assess the general environment in which Best Buy competes on
an industry level, gauge their target market whilst also conducting a Porter’s Five Forces analysis
on the microelectronics industry to license a full audit of the companies financials including
syndicate stability and profitability. For the internal analysis, the aim is to analyze the
advantages and disadvantages of Best Buy’s Value Chain activities and a financial analysis to
collate the firm to one of its biggest competitors: Walmart. Lastly there will be a review of the
maturity level of the industry in which Best Buy competes in, VRIO framework of the company,
and strategy proposals that will help put the company in a preeminent position.
4
Introduction
such as: software, video games, TV’s, music, mobile phones, digital cameras, car stereos, and video
headquartered in Richfield, Minnesota where it was founded and sells products both online and
in physical retail centers. As of 2022 Best Buy owns and operates one thousand one hundred and
forty four brick and mortar retail stores in the United States, Canada and Mexico however the
majority of its revenue is generated in the United States. Recently BestBuy has been
experiencing a decline in physical stores over time; in 2014 the company hit its peak when it
operated 1,779 stores which is a substantial abatement. Despite these setbacks however,
according to the company's S.E.C filings the corporation has been growing steadily since 2009
and generated 51,761 million dollars in revenue the first quarter in January of 2022 and generates
around 49 billion dollars in revenue each year (Cuofano, 2019). For the most part, it is estimated
that Best Buy’s online sales account for around 45% of its total revenue, on average this figure
has been growing since 2018. In addition in 2022 the number of total employees at Best Buy
totaled 105,000. Best Buy was originally founded as an audio specialty company called The
Sound Of Music in 1966 but was rebranded as a general consumer electronics retailer in 1983 .It
is important to note that although Best Buy is predominantly a retailer, Best Buy is also a
wholesaler of eight companies' products: Dynex, RocketFish, Insignia, Modal, Platinum, Init,
defies corporate convention. While a mission statement is provided online and was traced back
5
to the year 2013, it was not formally released by the company. Furthermore, the source is
unknown and only surmised to be affiliated with the company (Jurevicius, 2021). Best Buy’s
unsubstantiated mission statement reads as follows: “we’re a growth company focused on better
solving the unmet needs of our customers—and we rely on our employees to solve those
puzzles” (Samuel, 2021). In addition, the company also does not provide a clear cut vision
statement. Consequently the company’s vision statement is also up for supposition. As of right
now, two different sources listed two different vision statements for Best Buy postulated from
the company's blog and public postings. The first vision statement provided by the website
Strategic Management Insights reads as follows: "We believe technology is amazing, and we
aspire to enhance our customers’ lives through technology – anywhere, anytime." Next, the
second vision statement provided by the website How I got the Job reads as follows: “to
positively impact the world, enrich people’s lives through technology and contribute to the
common good.” Both Best Buys’ vision statements and the mission statement leave room for
amelioration.The senior leadership of the firm includes the current chief executive officer of
BestBuy which is Corie Barry who joined the company in 1999 and has held a variety of
financial and operational roles across the company. The chief financial officer is Matt Bilunas
and he is responsible for overseeing all aspects of global finance and strategic planning. Matt
joined Best Buy in 2006 and has served a variety of financial leadership roles both in the field
Best Buy’s primary target market is Millennials aged 21-40 with low-to middle-class
socioeconomic status as of 2022 (Thomas, n.d.). Best Buy provides counseling services along
with innovative products to the mass market in its stores. It caters to clients who are not
6
technology savvy. This is made evident by the services it provides both in-home and in-store.
Firstly, in-home services include: wifi setup, professional TV mounting, smart doorbell
installations and authorized apple device repair. Secondly, in store services include device
inspection by the Geek Squad and in-store product advisers for unsure clients. Many clients visit
Best Buy in order to receive reassurance that they are buying the best computer, tablet or phone
for their daily needs. On average the demographic for Best Buy tends to skew more male than
female. However, currently Best buy is experiencing a demographics trend which entails an
External Analysis
Industry
The industry in which Best Buy resides is classified as “brick and mortar” electronic
retailing. Although Best Buy competes in both an online and physical marketplace our analysis
will center on the physical market marketplace. In addition, we will be tailoring the analysis to
only include only the business to consumer portion of total transactions in the corporation. Brick
and mortar retail is a colloquial term that refers to a store with at least one physical location that
customers can peruse in person. Businesses that maintain physical locations provide services to
clients, sell goods and display new products. Stores in the electronic retailing industry sell
primarily technology related products such as phones, computers, kitchen appliances, video
games and television sets. To simplify matters we will further cater the review to include only
retailers in the United States since Best Buy generates eighty percent of its revenue from this
region as well as China since retailers source ninety percent of their goods from this country.
7
Maturity Level
The brick and mortar electronic retailing industry on a whole is currently in the growth
phase. Nowadays most individuals have incorporated consumer electronics items into their
leading market players in research and development activities to produce new consumer
electronic items with enhanced features is anticipated to drive most of the new economic growth
of the consumer electronics market in the forecasted years. Likewise, the integration of these
new novel advanced technologies by society is also anticipated to propel sales and heighten
competition in this industry. In 2021 the consumer electronics market was estimated to be worth
728.1 billion U.S dollars and is expected to reach 964.6 billion by 2028 based on primary
research done by Vantage. Additionally, it is important to note that while the comprehensive
electronic retailing industry is in the growth phase, specific items sold in certain categories
within the industry are nearing maturity. For example, the growth for computers and TV’s in the
past three years has been much faster than smartphones. Across all consumer micro-electronic
categories, computer sales are expected to grow over thirty four percent whereas TV sets over
twelve, smartphones however are only projected to grow one percent (Stewart & Crossan, 2022).
All together, this gives a sense of assurance of longevity for the firm. A growing and stable
industry with new products available for consumers to purchase every season due to a high
influx of money into key research and development sectors secures a loyal customer base for
P.E.S.T.E.L
The 2020 to present global silicone chip shortage is an ongoing global crisis which is
currently affecting many electronic retailers. The crisis has led to major price increases, shortage
queues among computers, video game consoles, graphics applications, household appliances and
other products that require semiconductors. In early 2020 the governments of Taiwan, South
Korea, China mitigated production due to the COVID-19 pandemic disrupting supply chains
(Taylor, 2021). The antecedent outsourcing of production of silicone chips had made western
electronics retailers reliant upon Asian producers overseas so when the Taiwenese and Chinese
market. Furthermore, domestically the perfect storm of supply and demand forces brought upon
by the pandemic caused a surge in inquiry for computers, peripherals and networks due to an
increase in remote learning and work from subsequent governmental state-wide lockdowns.
Thereafter, the price of noble gasses like neon, argon, xenon and helium increased sixfold
due to political tension in Ukraine. Noble gasses are critical in the production of
microelectronics, neon, in particular, plays a vital role in the optical lithographic process used to
etch patterns on silicon wafers, creating circuits in semiconductor chips (Wong, 2022). The
supply of neon was severely constrained by the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine sparking
concerns that the conflict will further the transpiring chip shortage. The second largest country in
Europe, Ukraine extracts around half of the global neon supply from the atmosphere as a
byproduct of steel smelting, and around 90% of the United States semiconductor-grade neon is
imported from Ukraine. As of late semiconductor manufacturers have been searching for
alternative suppliers in China but the existing facilities would need at least nine months
preparation to increase extraction levels to the desired amount (Howley, 2021). However,
9
fortunately over the last seven to eight years suppliers have already started shifting production to
other countries since chipmakers have been aware of such an eventuality for a long time. In any
case the result of this conflict will be one to three percent increase in price in many stores since
The Federal Reserve of the United States in order to curtail the rising 8.3% inflation rate
(the highest at nearly 40 years) has raised interest rates by 75 bps or basis points which can
impact retailers' access to capital for expansion (Schulze & Jamner, 2022). The results of the
Federal Reserve's plan to tighten the economy can have devastating implications for the future if
not executed carefully. For instance, it could potentially make it harder for retailers to raise the
capital needed to open new stores. Moreover, raising inflation in the United States is going to
drive down the value of the currency while concurrently raising prices which greatly abbreviates
consumers’ disposable income. Moody’s Analytics and Penn-Wharton estimate that inflation is
costing the average household three hundred dollars per month. In addition, the Harris Poll, a
global market research and consulting firm recently conducted a survey and found that eighty
four of Americans are planning to cut back on key purchases (Riedl, 2022). The significance of
which cannot be over-emphasized since the majority of consumer electronics goods sold are
considered commodities and the sale of such items is reliant upon customers’ disposable income.
In addition, the sale of microelectronics is also dependent upon the Chinese economy
since 90.6% percent of the world's personal computers and 70.6% of the global supply of
smartphones were produced in China (Bühring, 2018). The Chinese Yuan is currently
10
depreciating against the dollar. China's growth rate by year has slowed dramatically since the
10.6% extensive growth in 2010 to 2.3% in 2020. For foreign producers this means their capital
has further reach and expansion is a viable option but the dire state of the U.S economy can
diminish the value of this recourse. Many market watchers such as Clearbridge are predicting a
recession anywhere within a few months to a year. The prices of the current economy are steady
In the year 2012 margins tightened for physical consumer electronics stores the reason:
the consumer market place had changed. As digital e-commerce, and comparison apps have
grown in popularity, more consumers have retreated to device retailers exclusively to touch or
inspect novel technology gadgets and interact with them instead of actually intending to buy
them (Moores, 2018). This new trend entails customers browsing and evaluating in-store what
suits them best and later finalizing their purchase on online platforms for the lowest price they
find. Moving forward into 2023 and beyond this new concept deemed “showcasing" will become
increasingly more relevant as the online retailing branch expands. It is important to note that
showcasing does not act in accordance with the traditional business model where the
business model implies making most of their revenue by using their physical space to showcase
Nevertheless, retail stores still have the upper hand in providing customers with presale
assurance even though online retailers may offer a wider assortment of goods at a lower price.
11
This contemporary consumer trend involves consumers being reluctant to buy big-ticket items
such as high-priced electronics online. In fact, Kbb Review, an independent news and current
event magazine found that eighty two percent of consumers surveyed believed that in-store
purchasing gave them more security when buying expensive items, as they could look at the
product, affirm its quality and determine how it functioned before committing to a purchase.
Lastly, other consumer-related purchase trends show an increased movement towards experience
related procurement. This emphasizes the importance of proper customer service as well as the
enhancement of a store’s contextual elements or the look and feel of the store. To summarize,
electronics retailers should make an effort to provide clean, sleek and modern product
customer’s experience.
the point of sales system for instance which is a computerized administration apparatus used to
manage transactions at the end of a customer’s shopping experience. The point of sale system
terminal and software components that handle inventory management, customer tracking, and
sales data analysis. Not to mention, the retail industry has greatly benefited from the advent of
the internet since it is basically a digital catalog for their products which are either shipped to the
customers’ home or the closest store for pickup. The ERP core software program is used by
many companies to integrate and coordinate information in every area of the business including,
sales marketing, logistics, accounting and staffing in real time. In addition, Enterprise Resource
12
planning or ERP allows customers to type in the address of certain store locations and check the
availability of the item in stores. With the advent of new technologies retailers can now build on
the data they have and use it to create more intelligent and AI-enabled services. This means
engines are becoming increasingly important (Marr, 2021). Technology has also made the flow
of information practically seamless meaning it is easier than ever before for consumers to
compare products online escalating the already rigorous competition among respective retailers.
A global trend that is currently sweeping the market with increasing traction is the
environmentally friendly or “green” initiative also known as sustainability. The use of natural
resources is always at the forefront of this movement. As of late, many retail players have
experienced a significant shift in customer preferences and expectations; they now predicate
more transparency from companies. This is due to the fact that sustainability is more than just an
values: people, planet, and profit. The main issues concerning the broad environment include,
natural habitat destruction, climate change, and equitable treatment of employees regardless of
their location in the world. Customers expect companies to show their impact on the
retailers enact common practices such as switching from plastic bags to paper bags,
manufacturing products with recycled materials or setting aside a portion of their returns for a
cause. For instance, a paper company may replant a tree for every ten packs of paper sold, a shoe
13
company may fundraise money for animal shelters, and a travel agency may set aside a fund to
structure as producers that switch to sourcing environmentally friendly materials need to forego
convenience to obtain them. Also, the fabrication of many goods and fossil fuel energy in
general has been linked to greenhouse gas emissions and a disseminating ozone layer. For
example, the mining of coal or oil releases methane gas, a potent hydrocarbon which causes
harmful greenhouse gasses to emerge that absorb infrared radiation and reradiate it back (Niall,
2009). As time goes on more and more players in the European Union and the Unites States are
turning away from coal and oil production, instituting strict governmental restrictions that ban
coal production altogether as an initiative to switch to cleaner energy sources. For example,
England plans to phase out coal-fired power stations by 2024, while Drax, the country’s largest
power station, has pledged to stop using coal by March 2021 (Wood, 2021). Likewise the United
States has closed the KeyStone Pipeline after ten years of protests, legal battles and flip-flopping
executive orders. The KeyStone pipeline increased capacity to process one hundred sixty eight
billion barrels of crude oil locked up under Canada’s boreal forest. The repercussions for these
closures will be rising energy prices; the substituted renewable energy is intermittent and on
average more expensive to maintain. For electronic retailers this means higher energy costs for
lighting as well as heating or cooling the store and charging products in venue demonstrations.
Legal: (Laws, Mandates and Regulations or court decisions which impact profit)
Legality is a huge issue when it comes to the profits being made by retailers and can
impact a company's ability to make money if not looked into properly. When it comes to
14
regulations, tariffs have been the front-runner for issues that have made it seemingly terrifying to
determine profit numbers in the coming years. It’s caused stores to have to strategize differently
and for some retailers, they have taken advantage of some of the specialized stores' struggles as
they have brought other offerings that allow for their stores to remain functional. Deglobalization
has added continuous issues in the retail market as globalization has stalled due to the potential
of a global recession in the year 2024 that could cause the free flow of trade, capital, and
technology to come to a standstill preventing certain retailers from exceling and causing stores to
shut down operations in certain areas. They aren't receiving the proper resources to allow
themselves to maintain business in their expanded store fronts. Foreign companies have helped
by large margins to contribute to the US economy and are some of the main reasons retailers in
the United States are so functional. Having to rely on domestic resources will cause retailers to
pay higher costs and could lead to a shortage of supply for those resources. Overall, the barriers
to trade are minimal in the consumer electronics industry which help reduce transportation and
Porter's Five Forces is an analytical model that helps marketers and business managers
look at the 'balance of power' in a market between different organizations to analyze the
attractiveness and profitability of an industry sector. The first force according to Porter’s Five
Forces Model which affects overall competitive advantage is the Threat of New Entrants. The
threat of new entrants in the brick and mortar electronic retailing industry is medium. This is due
to the fact that customers are very loyal to existing brands and retail stores on the market. It also
takes a significant amount of time to build a brand image to get consumers into new stores. Not
to mention, strong distribution networks need to be established to keep the retail store fully
15
stocked. The industry’s profit margin on average is only 3.8% which is low compared to some
other industries. Admittedly, however the legal requirements for starting a store are not high and
no specific knowledge or skill is required for proper initiation. Moreover, it is possible to start a
retail business on a small scale without requiring massive capital. Customers switching costs are
low as each sale is handled on an individual basis and no long term contracts or commitments
secure sales for the future. Network effects are defined as the occurrence in which people or
participants join a platform, rapidly increasing the value of the platform and the service it offers.
The network effect is not present in this industry as the value of a retail store does not increase
its worth to consumers as more customers utilize its service or purchase its products. In addition,
the technology sector is currently experiencing a lot of direct investment into development and
research of novel software and hardware. As a result many retailers will want to profit on the
In the brick and mortar electronic retailing industry the Power of Suppliers is high. The
primary suppliers in this industry include electronic manufacturers such as Apple, Samsung, and
Hewlett-Packard. The reason the power of suppliers is high is because they are not reliant upon
brick and mortar retailers to sell their products. Forward integration is a practical alternative for
many electronics manufacturers as the barriers to entry for establishing a new store are low.
Apple for instance has created a brick and mortar wholesale chain to sell and service their own
products and this has allowed them to exert a greater degree of control on their brand. In
addition, suppliers could also sell their products online to forego the retailer entirely. Likewise,
suppliers often lock retailers into long-term supply deals with manufacturers oftentimes these
deals provide goods at a reduced price for a sustained period raising the cost of switching to a
new supplier. To a certain extent the products sold are differentiated giving the supplier even
16
further leverage. However, brick and mortar stores still have power since the number of potential
suppliers or manufacturers outnumbers the amount of physical retailers on the market. This
means suppliers have a limited number of brick and mortar retailers to select from when
negotiating.
All in all the Power of Buyers force for business to consumer sales is low in the brick and
mortar electronic retailing industry. Mainly, because there are many customers in the mass
market and each customer usually only buys a single high order item. In addition, it is hard for
the customer to threaten to vertically integrate into the production. The buyer's switching costs
are low. The industry’s products, while not direct substitutes, are largely standardized and there
are numerous other types of lower cost and higher cost devices that a consumer could use to
directly substitute them. For instance, China has started producing new phone brands such as
OnePlus, Oppo, Vivo, and Realme which are beating giants like Samsung and Apple. In essence
these products are direct substitutions for smart phones with the only difference being built in
ads and a cheaper selling price. In addition, more prosperous consumers could substitute physical
retailer laptops with other models found online such as the Dragonfly Futurfön, MSI GT80 Titan
The Threat of Substitutes, is relatively high. E-commerce sites such as Amazon, and Ebay
provide a viable alternative to instore shopping and provide a substantial variety of benefits. The
first advantage is convenience since consumers can shop from home, on the go or even from
halfway around the world to procure the same quality product as in a physical brick and mortar
electronics retailer. Moreover, online stores do not have opening or closing times; they are open
17
to customers' inquiries twenty-four hours a day. It is also time saving for the consumer if they are
looking for a specific item. For example, rather than spending hours searching for the product in
different stores they can find and acquire the item in a matter of minutes with a straightforward
internet web-browser search and a couple of clicks to finalize their purchase. Apart from
convenience e-commerce sites also provide customers with lower prices since items sold online
can be brought directly from the manufacturer eliminating retailer mark-up costs. In like manner
a larger stock is available online since the capacity of warehouses and in-store space limits the
amount of inventory accessible in local stores. The next advantage is a larger product register,
some e-commerce sites offer online exclusive products as well as brands no longer prevalent on
the streets. Furthermore online e-commerce sites provide more information and longer product
descriptions than the labels in store as well as product reviews giving the customer a more
accurate depiction of the item itself. Lastly, it is easier to compare the prices and attributes of the
products sold by different online vendors due to the availability of this supplement information.
All things considered, online e-commerce centers provide an attractive price-performance trade-
off to consumers which brick and mortar retailers must be wary of.
When it comes to the prevailing Rivalry Among Existing Competitors for brick and
mortar electronic retailing it is on average pretty high. The biggest rivals in this industry are very
well established, they include retailers such as Walmart, Target, Amazon and Costco. Most
electronic retailers sell "big-ticket" goods in which people spend an extended amount of time
researching before making a purchase. This means that customers spend a lot of time comparing
prices with other retailers. Also, if the device is of the same model, make and condition they are
perfect substitutes meaning the rivalry increases exponentially and stores run the risk of pursuing
18
solely price based competition. There is also a deal with commodification between the core
products of electronic retailing. Retailers are starting to notice this weakness in other retailers
and are able to strengthen their departments which is affecting specialized stores who mainly
The effect that PESTLE will have on Porter's five forces model includes raising the barriers to
entry. The current chip silicon shortages, high interest rate on commercial properties as well as
raising energy prices will make it harder for new brick and mortar electronic retailers to get
established, decreasing the impact of the Threat of New Entrants force. In addition, as physical
retailers goods become more expensive due to supply chain shortages substitute e-commerce
centers will take precedence so the Threat of Substitutes increases. The United States, although
currently grappling with high inflation, has a stronger currency than a myriad of other countries
in the world. When the domestic currency appreciates, goods from abroad become more
affordable. This signifies domestic retailers can leverage their strong currency to buy more
All things considered, Power of Buyers and Rivalry Among Existing Competitors will remain
largely unaffected.
Internal Analysis
Porter's generic business model framework describes four distinct strategies companies
can pursue; in 1985 he devised the generic strategy model, a visual representation set up as a
graph with four quadrants in his book Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior
Performance. The y-axis of this graph included the scope of the business or the size of its target
19
market. The negative region was defined as narrow meaning the company caters to niche
clientele while the positive region was defined as broad meaning the business caters to the mass
market. In our analysis we found Best Buy catered to a broader customer base in the mass
market. The x-axis of this graph defines how focused the company is on differentiating or
providing quality products. The negative region is defined as cost-leadership while the positive
That being said, Best Buy is both a differentiator and quality leader when taking its
services and products into account. The generic business market strategy Best Buy follows is
simply called a differentiation strategy. This strategy is evident in Best Buy’s business model
because although they do offer a price matching policy it requires the customer to actively seek
out the alternative price. In addition, it offers an extended electronics assortment to a broad scope
of consumers both budget conscious as well as more high-end upscale consumers.When it comes
to price strategies there are two a company can implement: everyday low pricing (EDLP) and
high/low pricing. An everyday low pricing strategy incorporates no promotions into its business
model because prices are already appraised lower than its competitors. Whereas a high/low
pricing strategy means a company relies on discounts and sales promotions to generate revenue.
The resource based view is a model that sees resources as the key to distinguished
source of competitive advantage that contributes to the perceived customer value of the
difficult for competition to imitate. Best Buy’s valuable resource is convenience and emanates
from having established considerable market share in the United States. Namely, seventy percent
of residents can access a store within fifteen minutes of their lodgings. Furthermore, another
accompanying competence includes the interplay of technology related services to augment its
main retail strategic business unit. For instance, Best Buy developer is a related subsidiary
business unit which has an extensive application programming interface for databases that allows
developers to query products, stores, categories, and more. Social Complexity describes the
different social and business systems in which businesses interact and is a source of competitive
advantage. This emerges when two or more individual systems are combined; the interaction
between the different technology services and branches that a Best Buy runs creates too many
Valuable: Firstly, Best Buy’s value comes from its ability to provide differentiated
support and services for their stores and offer a diverse selection of products at a variety of price
points. For instance, for customers simply perusing Best Buy has the competitive advantage of
an extended selection compared to other retailers selling similar products such as Costco or
Walmart which do not specialize in electronics. Additionally, they provide on-site service visits
for business locations, in-store services for everyday customers, and in-home services for those
who are unable to come in store. Moreover, a highly knowledgeable salesforce allows Bestbuy to
charge a premium price. In addition, the vertically integrated Geek Squad company gives the
firm a competitive advantage over other electronic retailers such as Walmart, Amazon, or Apple.
21
All together, Best Buy's services have a high consumer satisfaction rate; they set themselves
Rare: Best Buy’s business model is unique in that it offers repair services within its retail
stores. While admittedly, there are a few device rehabilitation services that are located within
retail stores, on average they are far and few between. For example, the only other competitor
that offers a similar service in its electronics section is Target. In essence, all other businesses
separate the sale and refurbishment of microelectronics. This means that they either specialize in
electronic retailing, or device restoration. The multifarious composite in-store service offerings
of Best Buy such as product advising, device repair and simple everyday retailing, distinguishes
its business model from other similar retailers competing in the market
Hard to Imitate: Best Buy has been around a long time this means they have had time to
hone their skills with integration of other companies such as Geek Squad as well as develop top
notch employee training. This means they have developed path dependence which is the
dependence of value creation based on the path of previous decisions of research investment,
rather than simply on favorable conditions. Consequently, other firms will experience time
compression diseconomies, if they attempt to imitate Geek Squad or any of its other in-home
consulting services. While other firms can attempt to compress resources and labor into a shorter
period of time the push will not be as effective as when the firm spreads out its efforts and
investments over a longer time. In addition, over the years they have also been able to build up a
considerable loyal customer base. It also has intellectual protection for the eight of the
company's products it wholesales, preventing other firms from copying and redistricting legally.
22
Organized to Capitalize on Benefits: Best Buy has all of the latest technology and
enterprise resource systems in place to coordinate and streamline the services it provides in real
time. In this regard regular everyday sales functions are made more efficient so less effort is
needed by employees to handle mechanistic day to day operations. This is evident in its supply
chain, human resource department as well as its brick and mortar vocation. As a result this frees
up time for management to focus on long-term strategic commitments or decisions which could
Value chain activities include a company-wide inspection of all processes, from the raw
resource to the final product to the after-sale customer service. For the most part the majority of
goods Best Buy markets are produced by independent subsidiaries from profuse electronic
manufacturers. For instance Apple phones and computers, items sold frequently in the firm’s
store are manufactured by Foxconn, a Taiwanese electronics company in China. As a result solid
relationships with suppliers is crucial to take part in proper receiving, storing, and delivering the
product. As mentioned above in the Power of Suppliers section in the Porter’s Five Forces
analysis Best Buy has significant leverage at this stage of the value chain as it gets to set the
When it comes to the storage and logistics portion of the Value Chain activities, Best Buy
outsources this division to another company called Bastian Solutions to create a more efficient
warehouse operating system as well as to create broader delivery provisions. In the recent past
Best Buy has faced corporate challenges with other companies who had consolidated their
23
supply chains to be more modern much earlier into their logistics program such as the e-
commerce giant Amazon. In order to capitalize on their new strategy which required deployment
of advanced automation across multiple sites in a very short time frame they decided to partner
with Bastian Solutions. Together the companies integrated automated storage, retrieval
technology, conveyor and warehouse software to best serve each facility. Also, as part of their
supply chain revitalization initiative Best Buy decided to redesign its regional distribution
Some advantages of the new automated storage and retrieval system include storage
density since the new Autostore system provided by Bastian Solutions is ultra-dense with four
times the storage capacity of manual storage. In addition, natural slotting improves the flow of
goods through the warehouse. With this system the similar merchandise is stored in bins,
“popular” bins stay at the top of the facility whereas other bins needed less frequently “sink''
meaning that merchandise is delivered quickly to ports decreasing lead time as less digging is
required to obtain the most frequently needed bins (Grady, 2020). Other advantages include
greater flexibility and ergonomics; it provides a higher-quality work environment for Best Buy’s
workers. The only disadvantage from this partnership is that BestBuy is reliant upon another
company to store and deliver its goods; this means that if Bastian Solutions forecloses Best Buy
Technology permeates almost every aspect of Best Buy's value chain and the human
resource department is no exception. Best Buy has interwoven digital technology to help assist
the human resource process. Since bureaucratic and administrative tasks are handed over to
24
software systems the human resource department can spend more time on the personal aspects of
their roles which relate more directly to helping employees. In the modern workplace many
human resource employees are so saturated with busy work that they have very little time left to
devote to speaking and interacting with the actual people they're supposed to be responsible for
(WBR Insights, n.d.). Modern technology allows administrative tasks to easily be handled by
technology greatly easing this disparity. For example, the informative software system can vet
candidates in the first stage of the employment process. When enquiring about positions job
seekers can get details about the role and can even request application packs. Reducing the
amount of time the human resources staff must spend answering the phone or emails to provide
It's not just the process of hiring new staff which can benefit from the implementation of
digital technology. Best Buy also uses this technology to give employees more ways to manage
their career development and reach out to their superiors. Its online platforms can be used by
employees to track, share, and meet their career goals. The platform also includes gamification
such as achievement badges or leaderboards which can help foster a sense of friendly
competition which motivates everyone to reach their potential. Chris Taylor, the current head of
the human resource department for Best Buy spearheaded the change and when interviewed
about the novel stratagem the company has taken he responded: "We've completely re-imagined
how we approach and execute projects to adopt new ways of doing business. Work is self-driven
in an environment of accountability, with team coaches there to help staff members along the
The next value chain activities Best Buy must also engage are marketing and sales
promotion. This is a crucial step to make prospective customers believe that they are investing in
the right products. In the past the corporation has shown vivid efforts in the way of marketing by
campaigns, finding the right pricing strategy, and enhancing relationship management with all
stakeholders of the advertising team. On average, Best Buy has spent over a hundred million on
advertising on over two hundred and fifty different media formats in the last year. The most
prevalent formats used were digital print and premium national television ad units. The company
also partners with Media Radar to assist their marketing department and advertising sales teams
(Augusta, 2022). In essence, Media Radar helps Best Buy make key marketing decisions. It is an
produce promotional media for the mass market; it also offers long term advertising plans and
counseling services. The main advantage Best Buy receives from partnering with the company
Media Radar is being able to focus more wholly on their core competency: providing a wide
variety of technology and services. When it comes to sales promotion of products in stores,
knowledgeable employees combine marketing and expert service to help customers find the right
product. This however doesn’t happen by chance. Sales training at Best Buy continues to receive
strong financial backing because of its direct connection to driving sales and improving the
in classrooms or online. Sales and Solutions Essentials (SSE) is a four-day training class that
equips all new sales employees with skills and behaviors to successfully deliver a differentiated
experience to every customer (Freifeld, 2019). The course is divided into four distinct segments
26
each covering the main product categories sold in stores: Computing, Home Theater, Appliances,
and Mobile.
After-sale customer services are vertically integrated into the corporation. Best Buy has a
department solely dedicated to help manage consumers' accounts, orders, purchases, rewards,
product repair, store information and more. In addition, it also offers geek squad and experts who
can deliver, install, protect and repair major household appliances such as refrigerators, washers
dryers, or haul away and recycle old ones. The advantages of having completely vertically
integrated after-sale services include complete control of their daily business functions and
As a whole the company has a modern distribution network that keeps it thriving in the
current digital economy. The firm has achieved a better supply chain by integrating efficient
stock control and advanced expertise. It is important to note that the retailing conglomerate
outsources both its marketing and logistics division but has incorporated its own human resource
department for better functionality. Nevertheless, Best Buy has vertically integrated with
Magnolia Hi-Fi, a manufacturer of high-end in-home theater LED screens, Pacific Sales Kitchen
and Bath Centers which offer upscale brand-name kitchen and home appliances as well as Geek
Squad which provides Best Buy customers with after-sales service support.
Best Buy is currently the leader in the electronics and appliance retailing industry due to
its monumental size. Their biggest competitor is Walmart, a diversified retailer, as they offer
27
similar products to consumers both online and in brick-and-mortar locations. Walmart has a
significantly wider reach on consumers as they operate in twenty-four countries with over 10,500
stores, compared to Best Buy, which operates in three countries and has just over 1,100 stores.
Although Walmart has a larger product portfolio, they compete with Best Buy in the consumer
electronics market. They have consistently surpassed Best Buy in terms of sales revenue simply
because of their cost leadership strategy. Looking at the financial ratios of both companies for
the years 2019, 2020, and 2021, revealed the following information.
In all three years (2019, 2020, 2021), Best Buy had higher ROA and ROE ratios when
compared to Walmart. This is due to the fact that Walmart has much higher amounts of assets
Return on assets (ROA) and return on equity (ROE) are important metrics that businesses utilize
to gauge how well they can successfully manage capital. The term return on assets (ROA) and
return on equity (ROE) both refer to a financial ratio that indicates how profitable a company is
in relation to its total assets. Corporate management, analysts, and investors can use ROA and
ROE to determine how efficiently a company uses its assets to generate a profit. The only
discernible difference between the two is ROA accounts for a company’s debt and ROE does
not. Thus, as a company takes on more debt, its ROE would be higher than its ROA.
In terms of liquidity ratios, Best Buy once again had stronger current and quick ratios across all
three years. A stronger current ratio means that Best Buy was able to pay their current liabilities
using only their current assets better than Walmart could. A stronger quick ratio means that Best
The total asset turnover ratio measures how efficient a business’s assets are in generating
revenue or sales. This is done by comparing the dollar amount of sales to its total assets as an
annualized percentage. When compared to Walmart, Best Buy outperforms them in asset
Strategy Recommendations
Strengths
The concept of “showrooming” is becoming more prevalent in modern times. This means
that customers are more interested in viewing, testing, playing and learning about the products
than actually purchasing them in stores. This trend is also evident in Best Buy’s S.E.C filings
since sales in their online division are expanding more rapidly each year than their in store sales.
This means that in store inventory can be reduced to only include the most frequently sold items
in store. In addition, more displays and product demonstrations should be established and the
fees charged to vendors raised. This is a similar business strategy that other corporations that sell
expensive big-ticket items that consumers spend more time researching before purchasing such
as IKEA are currently pursuing. It is also advisable that new stores which open reduce square
footage by ten percent to cut the costs of rent and merchandise. The space that would be cut
would be the space in which formerly in store inventory would have been kept. Best Buy should
also make an effort to always keep up with the newest and latest innovations on the market.
Since the industry in which Best Buy is currently competing in: electronic retailing is growing
and receiving a high influx of money for Research and Development, Best Buy should have no
problem finding innovative vendors with innovative products. In a letter to shareholders Best
29
Buy elucidated: “Our vendors spend billions of dollars developing amazing new technology
to be able to touch, feel and experience them in real life.” It is recommended that Best Buy keep
its promotions and offer exclusive in-store only sales to keep customers coming back to the store
and reverse the movement towards solely online purchases. This would boost revenue for the
physical stores so they can provide a better experience for the customer when it comes to
displays, in-store advising and Geek Squad. Best Buy obtains its competitive advantage from the
service it provides so the proper quality controls are very important. In addition, consumer-
related purchase trends show an increased movement towards experience related procurement.
This is important because a recent analysis of Best Buy's business model makes evident that they
are currently expanding considerably more into their online division as time passes. Each year
their online division brings in around five percent more revenue than that of the previous year.
Furthermore, their physical presence is being phased out gradually. This emphasizes the
Weaknesses
Firstly, the firm should publish an official mission on its website and also consider
placing a framed printout of the statements in all of the managers offices since creating a mission
statement is an inexpensive way to boost employee morale. In addition, Best Buy should also
make a corporate effort to revise their current mission statement or fabricate a new one. Their
current presumed mission statement does not give any mention to the products or services that
they provide nor the market that they compete in. Technologic services are an preeminent aspect
30
of the firm and also where they hone their core competency. Moreover, their current mission
statement does not allude to values like excellence, corporate citizenship, teamwork or integrity
so it is unclear what drives Best Buy’s actions and decision-making. A mission statement must
include a firm’s philosophy and self-concept so consumers and stakeholders know what the
company’s aspirations are and why it undertakes what it does. On average, mission statements
help unify employees’ efforts in pursuing company goals and show that the company is being
winning and a sense of where the company is headed in the future. Employees in visionary
companies feel part of something bigger than themselves. At present time Best Buy does not
supply a vision statement and should make haste to do so and publish it on its website and
Employee training is innovative and provides much expertise and value to the customer.
However the staff numbers of the individual stores themselves are oftentimes inconsistent. In
order to properly retain staff, enterprises require flexibility, and managers should staff
strategically and this is where profound complications in Best Buy’s retailing model become
evident. For instance, managers often provide preferential treatment to certain employees who
elude formal corporate punishment when they violate employee conduct. Furthermore, managers
often nominate and promote employees based on personal bias and not their efficiency or
readiness for the occupation. As a result, employees are promoted to positions they were not
qualified for creating structural problems in the business. According to Randell, a website
disclosing firm-wide internal concerns, one employee received no raise even though he was
given high marks in evaluation. Moreover, employee working hours are inconsistent and
31
fluctuate weekly. The workload is also divided unequally among employees, some of which
work unyieldingly to compensate for other more negligent employees in the staff. Although
complaints about this issue have been filed to supervisors they have been largely dismissed by
the firm. While flexibility is important for a store to thrive it does not mean adjusting the rules as
the superior sees fit. For example, certain locations have been reported to not follow protocol and
adjust rules without reason causing derangement in the entire store. It is recommended that Best
Buy decentralize their hierarchy to allow more employees from lower ranking sales positions to
imperative that formalization be implemented into the company. Formalization is the extent to
which employee behavior is steered by explicit and codified rules. These arrangements are
written rules and policies reviewing what to do in certain situations. It is proposed that these
Threats
established for Best Buy. A functional structure is a structure in which employees are grouped
into distinct functional areas based on domain expertise. These functional areas often correspond
to distinct stages in the value chain such as manufacturing, R&D, or marketing as well as
supporting areas such as the human source department, finance and accounting. Each department
head reports to the CEO who coordinates and integrates the work of each function. A functional
structure allows for a higher degree of specialization and division of labor as well as deeper
32
domain expertise. It also allows for efficient bottom-up and top-down communication. An
important aspect to consider because Best Buy will be increasing its bottom-up communication
channel significantly and organizations that implement bottom-up communications often develop
management. By increasing employee potentiality we should be aware of the issues that may
consequently arise from this decision and make resolutions accordingly. A functional structure
will allow the firm to increase bottom-up communications while at the same time also
2019). On a side note, Best Buy follows a dominant business strategy that means at the corporate
level at least seventy percent of its revenue is generated from its primary activity. Companies
that pursue this kind of strategy usually employ a functional business strategy.
Since Best Buy’s generic business level strategy is differentiation and its corporate level
functional structure in tandem with an organic organization allows the differentiator to nurture
and constantly upgrade their core competencies in R&D, innovation and marketing. Organic
decentralized decision making. Of course, organic organizations are correlated with the
following benefits when coupled with a functional corporate structure: fluid flexible information
flow among employees in both horizontal and vertical directions, faster decision making and
Vertical integration
33
Best Buy is currently vertically integrated with many minor firms to aid in its core
competency of providing consumers with differentiated products and services. The company
however shows less integration in its value chain which could increase its dependence upon the
vitality of those firms. It is recommended that Best Buy merge with Bastian Solutions to reduce
these liabilities. In addition, it is recommended that at least some type of investment is made into
these firms, especially Bastian Solutions, since this company is reliant upon this company to
stock its stores, a failure which could jeopardize Best Buy's entire supply chain. Also, the
company would save money in the long run since they no longer have to pay royalty fees to the
company. In addition, Best Buy could provide the same storage service to the other firms to earn
extra capital on the side. Likewise, while not mandatory, Best Buy could also merge with Media
Radar to consolidate its marketing operations. The merging of these two companies could help
provide better management oversight and efficiency. However, the company may also make the
strategic decision not to merge with this company for the following reasons. Firstly, it is not
reliant upon the company for the functionality of the physical stores so it does not pose as big of
a risk to its operation as Bastian Solutions per say. Secondly, an outside view of the market may
benefit the company by providing broader provisions and new perspectives to the marketing
department at Best Buy. This in turn would augment their promotional material by making them
resonate with a greater number of prospective customers in the mass market. All things
considered, the greatest liability for the company at the moment is Bastian Solutions.
According to Porter the two forces that impact the company's profitability the most are
threat of substitutes and rivalry among existing competitors. This highlights Best Buy's need to
differentiate and innovate its current products and focus on improving its service sector in order
34
to thrive. Both the power of buyers and suppliers demonstrate low potentiality for driving down
profit. This increases the attractiveness of the electronic device retailing industry and ultimately
works as an advantage for Best Buy to increase efficiency. Finally, the company as a whole must
work on becoming more adaptive to keep up with the constant innovation in the industry.
Opportunities
Diversification
Best Buy is a corporate stock owned company meaning the ownership structure is
eminently diversified through equity. The current volatility of the stock market makes it lucrative
for Best Buy to increase its private ownership of the firm temporarily by buying back some of its
outstanding shares to return its wealth to its shareholders. Best Buy's Stock was valued at 135.63
USD on November 12, 2021 and dropped to 64.53 USD on October 8, 2022. While buying back
some stock would represent a short-term expense for the company, it would also increase the
total reserves of the company in the long-run since no monthly dividends would need to be paid.
In addition, Best Buy would have access to more capital for investments and expansions in the
future if these assets or IPOS are traded properly. The company could profit greatly by buying
back their own stock while it is undervalued and subsequently selling it on the open market while
it is overvalued. This would allow Best Buy to expedite arbitrage to secure their own financial
security. In order to repurchase the stock Best Buy will conduct a tender offer and to a lesser
extent an open market Buy Back. In a tender offer corporate shareholders receive a form that
requires them to submit a portion of their shares within a certain time frame. The offer states the
number of shares the company wants to repurchase along with a price range of the shares. Once
the company receives all the offers it has the right mix to buy the shares at the lowest cost.
35
One week after the initial stock buy back has been completed an official announcement should
be made by the company that it plans to conduct an open market buy back. The announcement of
an open market buy back tends to appreciate the price of the stock since it is perceived as a
positive signal by the market. The company then should proceed to purchase stock on the open
market and once the price appreciates over fifteen percent sell the repurchased stock from the
tender offers on the open market (Janssen, 2019). In a perfect market price discrepancies should
instantly be arbitraged away however due to imperfect information short leads occur. According
to Wiley in the journal, market stock leads tend to last fifteen to twenty minutes giving the
company adequate time to take advantage of these market fluctuations. The company should not
sell all of the stock it bought from the tender options but keep some of the shares as reserves as
well.
Geographic Scope
Currently Best Buy operates in three countries: America, Canada and Mexico. Expansion
into new international markets is an option for Best Buy. While extension is not compulsory for
the firm, if implemented correctly it would allow Best Buy to capitalize on economies of scope
and scale to drive down prices while still keeping a highly differentiated product selection
available to consumers. A small-scale approach with a few locations in urban areas is advisable
to help the firm first assess the market before entering it on a larger scale. It is recommended the
firm take two different strategies depending upon if the country has a high or low cultural
distance score relative to the United States. Nations with low cultural distance scores usually
features, colonization ties, and often speak the same language. To expand into countries with a
low cultural score it is advised Best Buy follow an international strategy. An international
36
strategy ranks low on both global integration and local responsiveness since it’s essentially an
which a company sells the same products or services in both domestic and foreign markets. It
enables MNE's to leverage their core competencies in foreign markets. The advantages to this
include a standardized brand that is immediately recognizable. The entry method Best Buy
should pursue is a wholly-owned subsidiary, or a company who is owned by the home branch.
For countries with a high cultural distance score relative to the U.S score a multi-
domestic strategy is advised. Many countries with high cultural distances scores have different
levels of economic development or other attributes that make them diverge immensely from the
western market. In addition, greater cultural distance increases the uncertainty of conducting
responsiveness hoping that consumers will perceive it as local. This strategy works for
idiosyncratic and individual markets such as Japan, or Saudi Arabia. Over time as Best Buy
diversifies into different product lines and geographies it should implement a multidivisional or
matrix structure. A multidivisional structure or M-Form consists of several disparate SBU’s each
with its own profit-and-loss center that is operated independently from one another. Best Buy
can use the new SBU’s to organize around different businesses and product lines in different
geographical areas.
37
Countries with lower levels of economic development may need lower quality product
and price accommodations whereas countries with different cultural mindsets may need
corresponding employee training or service arrangements. Last but not least, it is also advised
that Best Buy established a joint venture or a partnership with a local firm that is familiar with
Appendix
Financial Analysis
38
References
Adamkasi. (2018, December 15). Porter’s Five Forces of Best Buy|Porter Analysis. Porter
Analysis. https://www.porteranalysis.com/porters-five-forces-of-best-buy/
Best Buy Is Making Its HR More Human with... Machines? (n.d.). HR Retail 2023.
https://hrretail.wbresearch.com/blog/best-buy-human-resource-hr-machine-strategy
Bühring, J. (2018, February). Consumer Electronics Industry Report. Intrepid Sourcing and
Services; Intrepid Sourcing and Services.
https://intrepidsourcing.com/industry-reports/consumer-electronics-industry-report/
39
Chan, K., Chung, Y. P., & Johnson, H. (1993). Why Option Prices Lag Stock Prices: A Trading-
Based Explanation. The Journal of Finance, 48(5), 1957–1967. https://doi.org/10.2307/2329075
Cuofano, G. (2019, May 18). How Best Buy Business Model Transformation Saved It From Sure
Failure FourWeekMBA; The Leading Source of Insights On Business Model Strategy & Tech
Business Models
https://fourweekmba.com/best-buy-business-model/
Feemster, J. (2021, April 29). P.O.S. Doesn’t Mean What You Think it Does... POSUSA.com.
https://www.posusa.com/what-is-pos/#:~:text=A%20point%20of%20sale%20system%20or
%20POS%20system
Grady, L (2020, March 3). Delivering Best Buy’s Supply Chain Transformation | Bastian
Solutions. www.bastiansolutions.com. https://www.bastiansolutions.com/blog/delivering-best-
buys-supply-chain-transformation/
Hamilton, J.-I. (2019, June 26). HomeCookery & Baking 11 Kitchen Appliances You Never
Knew You Needed. EWfood; Cookery & Baking.
https://www.expatwoman.com/ewfood/cookery-baking/11-kitchen-appliances-you-never-knew-
you-needed
Howley, D. (2021, April 25). These 169 industries are being hit by the global chip shortage.
Finance.yahoo.com. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/these-industries-are-hit-hardest-by-the-
global-chip-shortage-122854251.html
Jurevicius, O. (2021, October 20). Best Buy Mission Statement. Strategic Management Insight.
https://strategicmanagementinsight.com/mission-statements/best-buy-mission-statement/
Marr, B. (n.d.). The 8 Biggest Retail Trends Every Retailer Needs To Be Ready For. Forbes.
Retrieved November 22, 2022, from https://www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2021/09/20/the-
8-biggest-retail-trends-every-retailer-needs-to-be-ready-for/?sh=ed7d9d35d67a
40
Moores, K. (2018, January 24). Kbbreview. Consumers are reluctant to buy big-ticket items
online. Kbbreview. https://www.kbbreview.com/13500/news/consumers-reluctant-buy-big-
ticket-items-online/
Riedl, B. (2022, May 11). What Biden can do to lower inflation — but stubbornly refuses to.
New York Post. https://nypost.com/2022/05/11/what-biden-can-do-to-lower-inflation-but-
refuses-to/
Research, V. M. (2022, June 13). Insights on the $964.6 Bn Consumer Electronics Market is
Expected to Grow at a CAGR of over 4.8% During 2022-2028 | Vantage Market Research.
GlobeNewswire News Room.
https://www.globenewswire.com/en/news-release/2022/06/13/2461027/0/en/Insights-on-the-964-
6-Bn-Consumer-Electronics-Market-is-Expected-to-Grow-at-a-CAGR-of-over-4-8-During-2022-
2028-Vantage-Market-Research.html
Samuel, T. (2021, November 3). Best Buy Mission and Vision Statements- And Values Analysis.
How I Got the Job. https://howigotjob.com/mission-statement/best-buy-mission-and-vision-
statements/
Sinra, K. (2022, March 19). Best Buy Value Chain Analysis in 2022 (Detail Analysis).
WikiSME. https://www.wikisme.com/best-buy-value-chain-analysis/
Stewart, D., & Crossan, G. (2022, February 17). Consumer electronics sales: During the
pandemic, computer and TV sets outgrew smartphones. Deloitte Insights.
https://www2.deloitte.com/xe/en/insights/industry/technology/consumer-electronics-sales-
growth-covid-19.html
Taylor, E. (2021, March 23). How COVID, Climate Change and Trump Created a Global Chip
Shortage. World Politics Review. https://www.worldpoliticsreview.com/how-covid-climate-
change-and-trump-created-a-global-chip-shortage/
Total number of Best Buy stores worldwide 2010-2019 | Statista. (2010). Statista; Statista.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/249585/total-number-of-best-buy-stores-worldwide/
Vomhof Jr, J. (2019, March 5). Why Best Buy’s employee training program is world class - Best
Buy Corporate News and Information. Best Buy Corporate News and Information.
https://corporate.bestbuy.com/why-best-buys-employee-training-program-is-world-class/
41
Villas-Boas, A. (2016, April 26). 8 absolutely insane laptops you never knew existed. Insider;
Business Insider. https://www.businessinsider.com/8-of-the-weirdest-laptops-on-earth-2016-4