Critique Paper

You might also like

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 3

"UNDERSTANDING THE EFFECTS OF SCHOOL

FUNDING"

WRITTEN BY JULIEN LAFORTUNE, WITH RESEARCH SUPPORT FROM JOSEPH HERRER

Summary:

Julien Lafortune's paper, "Understanding the Effects of School Funding," aims to


explore the relationship between school funding and student outcomes. The paper
provides an overview of previous research on this topic and presents new findings using
California-specific data. The major ideas and concepts discussed in the paper include
the importance of adequate school funding, the potential impact of funding disparities,
and the role of additional resources in improving student performance.

Issues/Major ideas and concepts:

Lafortune's paper addresses several key issues related to school funding. One major
idea is the importance of equitable funding across schools. The author argues that
persistent disparities in school financing can lead to unequal educational opportunities
for students, particularly those from low-income communities. Another major concept
discussed is the role of additional resources in improving student outcomes. Lafortune
highlights the potential benefits of increased funding, such as smaller class sizes,
improved teacher quality, and enhanced educational programs.

Findings:

The author's research findings suggest that increased school funding has a positive
impact on student achievement. Using California as a case study, Lafortune finds that
students in districts that receive additional funds show improvements in test scores,
graduation rates, and college enrollment rates. These findings support previous studies
that have consistently shown a strong correlation between increased investment in
education and positive student outcomes.

Contributions to the existing body of knowledge:

Lafortune's paper contributes to the existing body of knowledge on the effects of school
funding by providing new empirical evidence. By specifically focusing on California, the
author offers a unique perspective that enhances our understanding of this issue. The
findings presented in the paper support and reinforced the findings of previous studies,
bolstering the argument for increased investment in education.

Limitations:

While Lafortune's paper provides valuable insights, it is not without limitations. One
major limitation is the focus on a specific state, which may limit the generalizability of
the findings to other contexts. Additionally, the study relies on cross-sectional data,
which may overlook potential long-term effects of increased school funding. The paper
also acknowledges that there are other factors beyond school funding that can influence
student outcomes, and these factors are not fully accounted for in the analysis.

Thoughts and Opinions:

Overall, Lafortune's paper is a comprehensive and well-researched contribution to the


field of education policy. The findings align with the consensus among scholars and
policymakers that adequate school funding is essential for improving student outcomes.
The paper effectively highlights the importance of addressing funding disparities to
ensure equity in education. However, it is important to consider that school funding is
not the only factor that determines student success and should be accompanied by
other policy interventions, such as improving teacher quality and providing additional
support services for disadvantaged students.
Potential future research:

Lafortune's paper opens avenues for potential future research in the field of school
funding. One potential area of exploration is a longitudinal analysis to examine the long-
term effects of increased school funding on student outcomes. Additionally, future
studies could delve deeper into understanding the mechanisms through which
increased funding leads to improved student achievement. Exploring the impact of
targeted funding interventions, such as hiring more qualified teachers or implementing
specific educational programs, could also yield valuable insights.

References:

Lafortune, J., with research support from Herrer, J. (2022). Understanding the Effects of
School Funding. Public Policy Institute of California. Retrieved from
https://www.ppic.org/wp-content/uploads/event-briefing-effects-of-school-funding-
052422.pdf

You might also like