Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MT105 Lecture 6
MT105 Lecture 6
MT105 Lecture 6
Motivation
● The term motivation encompasses many images. It implies the existence of incentives, motives, and purpose. It also incorporate
ideas about the drive, desires, and needs of an individual. Motivation can be cited as the reason someone behaves in a certain
manner or is blamed for failure, for example, “Although they were obviously the better team they were just not motivated enough
to win.” It is also a source of hope, for example, “If only I could motivate my child to get better grades” or “I know we have the
talent; if we could just motivate the staff to pull together as a team.”
● Motivation can be defined concisely as the reason people do the things they do. This simplification addresses questions such as
“Why do we act in the way we do?” and “What will cause us to change or do things differently?”. In this definition, motive is the
key component.
● Motive: A desire or need that acts as a stimulus for action
o “Motive” is not only the root word for motivation but also its essence. Discovering the motive for an action such as murder or
robbery has provided both suspense and solutions to real-life and fictional mysteries. Once the motive has been revealed, most of
the other clues begin to fall in place. This also applies to the workplace. By identifying and understanding the motives and
reasons people work, and what they are looking for in a job, we can develop a plan that matches the motivational goals of the
individual with those of the organization.
● Decisional Limitations
o It is tempting but erroneous to conclude that a causal relationship exists between motive and reaction. Taken to its extreme, this
definition of “motive” implies a cause-effect model. However, human beings are much more complicated than this simple
explanation implies. Certainly we react in an immediate and very predictable manner to a harsh stimulus such as pain. In the
complex area of people, with their often competing personal, physical, emotional, social, and family objectives, predicting a
specific reaction to an isolated stimulus is extremely difficult, if not impossible. This point is illustrated by the fact that a person
may view a situation or comment a humorous at one time yet take it as an insult at another time under very similar circumstances.
● Attitude
o What a manager wants most from any motivation plan is to understand what causes people to behave in a certain manner and
how to get staff members to perform consistently according to the standards of the institution out of their own desire and not
because they are afraid or forced to do so. A word that embodies these objectives is attitude: “That technologist has a bad
attitude.” “They certainly have an attitude problem.” “There is nothing like a willing worker”. These statements all encompass
this management wish.
o Attitude in the workplace is a person’s outward disposition toward his or her job and coworker . A primary goal of the manager
is to help the staff develop and maintain positive attitudes toward the laboratory and its mission. The next section reviews the
major theories about achieving this goal in the workplace.
▪
Managers want their staffs to be highly motivated. Although, individuals may have personal motives for reaching the
productivity and quality objectives of the laboratory, if these goals are unrealistic or the personal benefits of achieving the
goals are limited, the staff may become discouraged.
▪ Motive is a major component of laboratory job descriptions and performance reviews. If objectives involve Herculean efforts
or are unfeasible, the technologist may simply give up no matter how attractive the potential rewards (money, promotions, and
so on). An important point of the achievement equation is that if the individual scores a minimal or negative value in any of
the factors, a low level of aroused motivation results.
● Process Motivational Theories
o The process approach seeks to understand how people are motivated in contrast to the content theories which are concerned
with the internal motivational forces. It also attempts to analyze how the person reacts to external stimuli. Three primary process
theories have achieved popularity: Vroom’s expectancy theory, Adam’s equity theory, and Skinner's reinforcement theory.
o Vroom’s Expectancy Theory
▪ Victor H. Vroom proposed a theory of motivation that explains behavior as a process of making choices in direct response to
the expected potential for reward. This concept developed from the opinion that humans are rational of thinking beings who act
in anticipation of their own best interest. The resulting motivational theory suggests that people believe:
1. Effort will bring reward.
2. The effort expanded will be related to the perceived value of the reward to the person.
▪ Based on these assumptions, this theory concludes that people make choice between alternative courses of actions according to
how they perceive the resulting benefits. Five variables have been identified that influence the selection decision:
❖ Expectancy- the belief that effort brings performance and performance leads to rewards
❖ Outcome- the perceived expectancy that the outcome from the effort (reward) will actually be realized
❖ Instrumentality- the degree of faith in the belief that current efforts may make possible (i.e., be instrumental) achieving even
larger or more long-term rewards. For example, although efforts on the job are directed towards the immediate reward of
money, this money maybe instrumental in obtaining another item, such as a new car.
❖ Valence- the value placed on the available rewards. The more highly value the prize, the more motivated the individual; the
less desirable, the less motivation
❖ Choices- a quantified model, called the VIE equation, has been developed to demonstrate the relationship between these
factors and the likelihood of a person’s choosing to behave in a certain manner.
𝑀𝑜𝑡𝑖𝑣𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑜𝑛 (𝑜𝑟 𝑒𝑓𝑓𝑜𝑟𝑡 𝑒𝑥𝑡𝑒𝑛𝑑𝑒𝑑) = 𝑉𝑎𝑙𝑒𝑛𝑐𝑒 𝑥 𝐼𝑛𝑠𝑡𝑟𝑢𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑡𝑎𝑙𝑖𝑡𝑦 𝑥 𝐸𝑥𝑝𝑒𝑐𝑡𝑎𝑛𝑐𝑖𝑒𝑠
Leadership
● Leadership has been partially defined in the previous chapter in order to distinguish it from motivation. Often these two concepts
have been used interchangeably; however, in practice they are quite different. Motivation deals with the reason people act the way
they do whereas leadership attempts to use motivational principles in an effort to achieve organizational goals. It is the matching
of the goals and the objectives of these two entities, the individual and the institution, that is the essence of leadership.
● Leadership, like management, has been given about as many meanings and explanations as there are people discussing the topic.
Several popular definition follow:
o Some proponents have suggested that leadership is tied to the personality and persuasive talents (i.e., charisma) of the person, a
demonstrated by the great leaders of history.
o Others point out that the situation or special circumstances enable a person to rise to the occasion. In another setting, the person
may have simply remained anonymous.
o Still another common belief is that it is the power, either the formal authority or money that makes the leader. With the same
resources and the right job, we can all succeed.
● These opinions of leadership and how it develop all have elements of truth. They raise the salient question: Are leaders born, or
can they be trained? All of us have weaknesses, special talents, and strength. Some people make friends and influence other easily,
but they may have trouble organizing or lack the necessary analytical skills. There are those who are natural organizers, but they
have difficulty dealing with people and need direction in electing goals and solving problems. Others may be talented in analytic
and troubleshooting situations but deficient in organizing and people skills. We each, however, can build on our strengths and
tackle our weaknesses through training education, and experience. The answer to the leadership question is that leaders are made,
not born!
Individual-Group Interface
● Group and individual maintain a push-pull relationship: Each put pressure on the other to change and adapt. The character and
performance of each is molded by this dynamic interaction. Individual are the substance of a group and provide the source of it
energy. In return, the group enables individuals to achieve goals far beyond what they could accomplish by themselves.
● The importance of member to the group must be kept in perspective throughout this review. If the people desert the group, it
disappears. If the group disbands, the individual simply seek other alliances. However, the group has a tremendous impact on its
members in both shaping their daily work lives and providing boundaries for their futures, which are accomplished through the
interaction of the individuals with other members of the group and from interaction with other groups.
● Interpersonal Relationships
o People have definite goal and expectations for their interactions with other individuals. How they respond to fellow members of
the group is guided by several factors, including how they view themselves (personal image), how they believe other will
behave (behavior expectations) and what they expect to receive from the relationship (personal benefits).
o Personal Image
▪ How we see ourselves and how we think others see us combine to form our self-concept or personal image. The importance of
this self-image to our well-being and success in social intercourse is demonstrated by the attention psychologists give to
identifying its parameters and developing techniques for improving and healing this fragile entity.
▪ Self-concepts include our personal goals, belief systems, assumptions about ourselves and others, social and moral values,
confidence in our ability to perform in the workplace, and amount of control we exercise over our affairs.
o Behavior Expectations
▪ If personal image match our expectations of how fellow humans are supposed to behave, harmony is achieved. If it does not,
the conflict must be resolved. Behavior expectations are derived from the experiences and feedback we have received from
our daily encounters. Our personal image and the behavior expectation we hold for others are an extremely complex montage
of family, genetic, cultural, and religious factors that science is only beginning to understand. The resulting emotional and
personality package defines the nature of the person who comes to the group and the type of relationship and influence he or he
will exert on others.
o Personal Benefits
▪ The final factor in the interpersonal relationship is the attractiveness of membership in the group. The needs of the group
must be weighed against the needs of each member. Each gives up something in exchange for something else. As long as
individuals perceive that belonging to the group is in their best interests, the bond is strong.
● Role Expectations
o Individuals bring to a group their personal abilities and talents; they also look to the group for satisfaction of their motivational
needs and ambitions. These two factors, group and individual expectations are encompassed in the role that individuals play in a
group.
o Roles are acquired and assigned by forces in both the formal and the informal group network that exist in an organization.
● Work Group Behavior
o One variation of an old joke could be “What do the employees in this laboratory have in common? They share a parking lot.” The
underlying question is “What cause a group to change from being just a collection of individuals, each with a separate agenda
and nothing much in common except a parking lot, to a fully functioning entity unto itself?” The answer lies in the inner
functioning of a work group: its synergism, effectiveness, and teamwork.
o Synergism, in which the whole become greater (more productive, effective) than the sum of its individual parts, results from the
bonding of the members into a viable and effective unit with a common mission and goals. To understand this force, two aspects
of this synergistic process need to be examined: (1) determinants that bring about cohesiveness and functional effectiveness and
(2) dysfunctional factors.
o Work Group Functional Factors
▪ The following list contains factors that contribute to and enhance work group performance, synergism and effectiveness by
nurturing positive emergent behavior.
❖ Shared values of the members and their commitment to the goals and objectives of the work group
❖ The success of the group in achieving its mission
❖ The status of a group within the organization, as viewed by its members and peers.
❖ The amount and quality of participation in the decision-making process. This includes the level of creativity encouraged, as
well as the degree of conformity enforced.
o Work Group Dysfunctional Factors
▪ Lack of self-esteem and group esteem or low status of the group within the organization
▪ Failure in reaching goals
▪ Poor physical working conditions
▪ Dictatorial management styles that discourage creativity and participation
Group Interaction
● This topic like personal relationships and internal group functioning, is many-faceted. It depends on the relationship between
members of each group, because a group consist of its members, and on the nature of the group itself. An example of this
dichotomy of relationship is how the laboratory interfaces with and views nursing or the purchasing departments.
● As a group, such as the Hematology section, becomes a coherent entity, it assumes some of the characteristics of individual persons
and develop a personality of its own. One of these features is ownership.
● Factors Influencing Intergroup Relationship
● Union-Management Interaction: An example of Intergroup Relationships
o Group Formation: Why do employees join unions
o Management-Union relations
▪ Arguments in Favor of Unions
❖ Provide a mechanism to offset or balance managerial power
❖ Allow employees to gain some control over their future and everyday work life
▪ Arguments Against Unions
❖ Cause loss of managerial control over timely implementation and adaptation of company strategy in the changing market
environment
❖ Lose competitive advantage to other geographic areas or foreign countries that have significantly lower wage scales
Management of Groups
● Group Building and Teamwork
o A manager can intervene in three area to build a strong work group: the leadership style of the supervisor, the bureaucratic
structure of the work group and the organization, and the level of success achieved by the manager in building a team.
● Leadership Strategies
o Structural Techniques
▪ Just as our bodies have both abilities and limitations, the nature of the organization gives character to the type of work groups
that evolve. The kinds of work performed, the skill and educational level of the work force, the technology and methodology
used in the production process, and the space in which the work is performed all influence the selection of members of a work
group and how well they come together as a team.
▪ The bureaucratic structure set in place to organize these factors also plays a major role in the functioning of work groups.
o Team Building: Organizational Development Strategy
▪ Teamwork, the goal of all work groups, arises from following the principles of good management and leadership. Sometimes
referred to as esprit de corps or team spirit, teamwork gives the group a feeling of shared enthusiasm for their common mission,
be it winning a football game or meeting production goals.
● Intergroup Management
Job
● A collection of tasks, duties and responsibilities assigned to an individual worker
● Job Design is the process of organizing work into jobs
● Job Enrichment are efforts to make work more meaningful and satisfying, especially by increasing the level of autonomy, control
and responsibility for job performance and in area that allow the worker to grow professionally.
● Job Analysis is the process of collecting and analyzing information about the tasks, work flow and jobs being done in an
organization so that job descriptions, work standards and performance appraisal systems can be developed.
● Staffing is the process of matching the number and types of people with jobs that meet the goals and structure of the organization
● Job Description is a written statement that designates the tasks, duties, working conditions and reporting relationships for a
specific job.
● Authority Scale is a quantitative scale that defines the specific level of independence or freedom to act in performing a job duty
without immediate consultation with a supervisor.
● Job Specifications is a summary in abridged form of the formal education, skills and experience required to perform the duties of
the job; also included are any unusual physical requirements or working conditions.
Job Design
● Jobs are the link between people and the organization. They encompass the expectations of both the company and the individual.
Jobs are the mechanism through which work is done, products and services delivered, and all parties ultimately rewarded. Given
this importance, close attention must be given to how jobs are constructed, who does the work, and what resource are needed to
accomplish the associated tasks.
● Each person within the institution- executives, supervisors, peers, incumbents, and customer -has a different perspective of exactly
what a particular job entails.
● Many factors influence the makeup of a job. The main determinants are the following:
o Organizational factors- These include management styles, bureaucratic structure, product or services produced, technology
requirements, and the general economic health of the enterprise.
o People issues- These include people’s skills and limitations, personal motivational needs, behavior characteristics, expectations,
social mores, work force availability, and ability to function in the conditions of the work environment.
o Legal and union requirements- These include legislative and labor rules and regulations.
● Herzberg’s Motivators
o Herzberg’s theory suggests that the following motivators should be an integral part of a job design:
▪ Opportunity for achievement; that is, the feeling of making a difference and having a sense of contribution and
accomplishment
▪ Recognition for one’s role in the success of the group
▪ Challenging work that reinforces employees’ confidence in their abilities
▪ Responsibility and the feeling that one is in control of one’s future
▪ The chance for advancement and personal growth
● Job Behavior Factors
o Research, including the Herzberg model, has shown that there are five basic areas, or job behavior factors, in which a manager
can intervene in the job design process to help satisfy human needs.
▪ The level of autonomy, independence, freedom and responsibility that workers can exercise in performing their duties
▪ The variety of skills, talents and activities needed to perform the job
▪ Task identity- the extent to which the work being done is identified with the final product
▪ Task significance- the degree of significance attached to the work by both the organization and the employee
▪ The immediacy and clarity of feedback on the effectiveness of the employee’s performance
Job Analysis
● The job design process involves analysis of the work that needs to be done and a plan to break the job down into identifiable units
that can be assigned to individual workers with specific skills. This three-step process- analysis, job, assignment- culminates in a
formal written document called the job description.
● Following is a list of factors that must be considered in a job analysis:
o Working conditions: physical environment, temperature extremes, manual labor exertion (i.e., extended standing or walking,
strength requirements such a heavy lifting, isolation, and work hours).
o Technology: methodology and instrumentation, both technical skills and physical dexterity factors
o Job specifications: qualifications, skills, special knowledge, and experience.
o Availability of labor: types and quality of personnel available; both are limiting factors in job design.
o Personal interaction: types, frequency, and degree of coordination required with other people, both inside and outside the
organization.
o Legal aspects: personnel and facility licensure requirements.
o Work flow: time of arrival of work orders and service needs, test requests, volume and predictability of STATs, routine,
AM-timed test, turnaround times.
o Work itself: actual tasks and duties that must be performed and completed to do the work.
o Work process: similar to methodology and work flow but deals with the steps and timing of task that must take place in the
work process; specifically, coordination with other jobs or departments. For example, the receipt of specimens from Phlebotomy,
and the availability of total CPK/LDH results and sample for performing isoenzymes.
● Industrial Engineering
o The basic industrial engineering process consists of the following steps:
▪ Break each job and task down into its smallest components, which particular emphasis on the motions involved in the work
▪ Time each of the motions involved in each step
▪ Attempt to eliminate unnecessary motions, specifically by making suggestions about the layout of workstations, machinery, and
equipment and the production process to improve and conserve the number of steps and motions necessary to perform a task.
● Strategies for Data Collection
o There are several other methods for obtaining information for analysis:
▪ Interview the workers, their supervisors and customers.
▪ Hire a job analyst or supervisor trained in job design methodology to make observations.
▪ Have workers fill out questionnaires and checklists about their work.
▪ Talk with experts such as industrial engineers, employees, managers, instrument manufacturers and suppliers, or peers from
other laboratories.
▪ Get employees to maintain logs or diaries of the steps and motions involved in their tasks
o Dictionary of Occupational Titles
▪ The data is the 4th digit (0-6), the people is the 5th digit (0-8), and the things is the 6th digit (0-7).
▪ The higher number refers to a less and the smaller number refer to more of the factor
▪ Th first three digits of the code, contained in the Dictionary of Occupational Title (DOT), indicate the occupational category
of the job, such as professional, clerical, farming, or a machine trade. The next three digits classify a job based on the degree
of functional difficulty with respect to data, people, and things. The last three digits of the DOT code simply list alphabetically
the descriptive title of jobs within the same occupational category.
▪ The first two digits (07) indicate a medical and health occupation. The number 8 in the third column (Manager, Technologist,
and Technician) signifies a position in dental and medical technology whereas the 0 (pathologist) is used for physicians and
surgeons.
▪ The middle three digits indicate the job’s functional level of difficulty with respect to data, people, and things. From these
codes, this system ranks these jobs a highly complex with respect to data (digit 4) and things (digit 6) but a having a relatively
low level of difficulty with respect to people (digit 5) functions.
● Functional Job Analysis
o The US employment service has developed an FJA system that builds on the DOT but adds four additional categories
▪ Worker functions (the DOT criteria)
▪ Work fields, an analysis of the specific tasks and methods performed in a job
▪ Machines, tools, equipment and work aids used by the worker
▪ Materials, products, subject matter and or services produced in the job
▪ Worker traits, including temperament, working conditions and training are necessary to do the job
Job Descriptions
● The most basic of the job design documents, the job description, establishes the
foundations for many other employment-related activities including the development and
implementation of the performance appraisal system. A job description is a written
statement that designates the tasks, duties, working conditions, and reporting relationships for a specific job.
● Employee Objectives
o Identify the duties, tasks and responsibilities of the job
o Provide orientation to the organization, supervisory and peer networks, and workplace arrangements
o Give guidelines and direction to the performance expectations of the organization
o Set the limits and boundaries of responsibility
o Assign the authority to act in performing duties
● Format: Writing the Job Description
o Identification and Headings o Preparer
o Job Specifications o Date of Preparation and Activation
o Reporting Relationships o Approval Signatures
o Duties
Performance Appraisal
● The formal communication system used by an organization to assess and provide feedback to employees about job performance
expectations
● Performance Standard is an item (statistics, statement, model) against which the performance or behavior of an employee can be
compared to obtain a relative measurement.
● Performance Criterion is a standard, test, guideline, or rule upon which a judgement can be based.
● Performance Appraisal Measurement Instrument is the formal system (forms, paperwork, checklist) used by an organization to
document the results of the performance review and feedback conference
● The performance appraisal process represents the formal communication system used by an organization to assess and provide
feedback to employees about job performance expectations.
1. A person expected to perform a job with a designated job description
2. Standards and criteria that clearly state what is expected and how it is measured
3. A measurement instrument to compare actual performance with the desired behavior
4. A judge or assessor trained and competent in using the measurement instrument to do the appraisal
5. A feedback mechanism (conference, information report) to share the results of the review, take corrective action, and arrive at an
agreement on a plan for the future.
● Performance Standards
o Laboratorians are quite familiar with the concept of standards. Standards provide a measurement against which a similar object
can be compared.
o In another instance, the control results are compared against the accept-reject criteria before a batch run on a laboratory
instrument is accepted. One level of controls may fail the ±2 standard deviation (SD) standard, but a decision or judgment to
accept the run may be appropriate if it meets the established QC criteria for both levels, such as the 13s, 22s, or R4s guidelines in
the Westgard rules.
o In a similar process, management uses standards as targets, or performance criteria, against which to gauge performance. A
criterion, by definition, is a standard, test, guideline, or rule upon which a decision or judgment about job performance can be
based.
o Source of Performance Standards
▪ Performance standards are a major component of the management control function and of
many management programs such as management by objectives and total quality
management.
▪ The perpetual and cyclical nature of the management process tied to the development of job standards is demonstrated in the
following schematic model:
o Writing Performance Standards
▪ Performance standards and criteria must clearly define acceptable performance, detail work that falls below expectations, and
recognize exceptional achievement. To meet these specifications, performance standards should satisfy the following four
goals:
1. Be relevant to the actual job and tasks being done.
2. Allow for fair comparison between different positions; one person or group should not be held to higher or more difficult
standards than other peers.
3. Ensure consistent application of organizational programs for which the performance appraisal system is used.
4. Be objective, which is not only a goal of fairness but also a requirement for compliance with the laws and regulations of
such agencies as the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
Judging Performance
● The stage at which most of the criticisms of performance reviews are focused is performance judgment. The criticism center
around three issues: (1) problems in judging, particularly the subjective nature of the review; (2) the qualifications of the judge;
and (3) the person who is in the proper position to do the judging.
o Judgement Problems
▪ Both the strengths and weaknesses of any performance review system stem from the fact that people are being evaluated and
people are doing the judging. One accept the verdict of overweight that the scale objectively declare but reacts defensively to a
fellow human being stating the same “objective” fact.
o Qualification to Judge
▪
“Passing judgment” is something we have been socialized to avoid because of the implications of our own shortcomings;
however, it is a task that each manager must come to grips with. In spite of this taboo, judging is a common and respected
component of many parts of our lives-for example, in the justice system, academia, sporting events, art and music shows, and
business decisions. The judge in all of these activities are expected to be prepared by formal training and appropriate
experience.
o Appraiser Selection
▪ This raises the question of who should do the appraising. Appraiser options include the following:
❖ Immediate supervisor ❖ Subordinates
❖ Higher-level managers ❖ Customers and Suppliers (TQM)
❖ Employee ❖ Independent Experts
❖ Coworkers
Evaluation Interviews
● The moment most feared by the Hematology supervisor and technologists has arrived. It may have been delayed and postponed
repeatedly by both parties in efforts to avoid the inevitable, but here it is. Each is determined to get it over quickly, with as little
pain as possible. The employee want a raise, and the supervisor wants to get the personnel department off his or her back.
● What's wrong with this description? Does it sound familiar? Why should this scenario be the most frequently cited example of the
performance appraisal meeting?
● Conference Suggestions
o Even in the best of circumstances there is still some major apprehension about the formal documentation of a person's
performance record. The following suggestions are designed to make the conference as productive and rewarding as possible:
▪ Emphasis should be on behavior and performance improvement, not a tally of weaknesses transgressions, personal
characteristics, or discipline.
▪ Time should be allocated for an unhurried and complete review and explanation of the measurement instrument.
▪ Sufficient advance notice should be given to allow for preparation including supplying the employee with information upon
which the review will be based.
▪ The appraiser should convey to the employee the feeling that he or she is important and that his or her concerns and presence
are a top priority for the appraiser.
● Types of Evaluation Interviews
o According to Norman R. F. Maier, a well-known authority in this area, has identified three types of appraisal interviews.
▪ Tell and sell method- The strategy in this session is to inform the worker of the results of the performance appraisal and then
persuade the person to change. This method is considered useful only in dealing with young or inexperienced employees.
▪ Tell and listen method- The key here is to share the results of the review with the employee and then actively solicit his/her
opinion and feelings.
▪ Problem solving method- The focus of this meeting is on the mutual identification and solving of problems, with particular
emphasis on stimulating the growth and development of the employee.
● Questioning and Discussion Strategy
o Techniques designed to bring the employee into the conversation focus on how questions should be worded. Because a primary
goal of the performance review is to have employees assume responsibility for the establishment and achievement of
performance goals, their active participation in the conference is essential.
Orientation
● Orientation is the introduction of new employees to the organization and their duties. It is the beginning of the process of
professional development and training. At this point in the relationship the rights, privileges, responsibilities, and expectations of
both parties should be clarified. The success of this initiation period forms the foundation for the future.
● The three aspects to the orientation program are a general organizational review of the policies and procedures that apply to all
employees, department policies and rules governing behavior, and specific job duties.
● A key objective of the orientation program is to familiarize and socialize the new employee into the institution.
● Seeking the advice of senior managers, human resource experts, and colleague who may have had similar experiences is also a
wise strategy.