Psych 110 - Final Empirical Paper - The Relationship Between Stress Levels and Weekly Exercise Frequency

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 14

University of the Philippines Cebu

Gorordo Avenue, Lahug, Cebu City

In partial fulfillment of the requirements


For Psychological Statistics (Psych 110)

The Relationship between Stress Levels


and Weekly Exercise Frequency
An Empirical Paper

Submitted by:
Abellanosa, Mary Francine D.
Del Mar, Elian
Jarabo, Keannu von

Submitted to:
Ms. Rowena V. Mende
Professor

Author Note
The authors of this study are currently enrolled in University of the Philippines - Cebu currently taking
Psychology 110 - Psychological Statistics. We do not have any conflicts of interest to be disclosed.

We would like to thank Ms. Rowena V. Mende for her guidance throughout the writing of this study.

Correspondence concerning this study should be addressed to Elian R. del Mar. Email:
erdelmar@up.edu.ph
2

Stress is a natural aspect of human life. It can with stress—while reducing stress hormones
even be said that a normal and controlled such as adrenaline and cortisol (Harvard Health
amount of it can contribute to a healthy and Publishing, 2020). Research shows that exercise
productive personality and activity. However, an and physical activity, in general, may be an
uncontrolled amount of stress can bear the effective strategy for preventing depression
opposite and can bring about negative and (Choi, et. al., 2019) and that increasing physical
harmful effects to the person unable to deal activity volume is related to higher levels of
with them well. With this, techniques and happiness (Richards, 2015). Even a simple
strategies to deal with stress have been ten-minute physical activity per week may result
formulated, made, and disseminated in order in increased happiness. Exercise has even been
for more and more people to be able to learn shown to help solve serious mental health issues
how to control their stress and alleviate the such as depression. In one study, for example,
negative effects of its excess. At the time of this the effect of exercise on patients diagnosed
writing, the researchers are interested in looking with major depression disorder is comparable to
into the use of exercise or physical activity in the the efficacy of antidepressant medication
alleviation of stress. Specifically, they aim to (Blumenthal, et al., 2007). Exercise can also
look at the kind of effect it has relative to its indirectly improve mental health, decrease
frequency towards the level of stress stress, and make people happier by increasing
experienced. self-esteem. When people exercise and feel
good about themselves, they get a boost in
I. Review of Related Literature self-esteem and feel happier as a result (Fisher,
Exercise has long been a marker of 2020).
good health not just physically, but mentally The frequency of exercise is highly
and emotionally as well. While frequent exercise correlated with stress levels according to de
is associated with more health benefits, even a Camargo, et al. (2021) conducted amidst the
single bout of exercise has been shown to be COVID-19 restrictions. The study affirmed the
associated with improved executive functions, popular concept in the literature of exercise and
enhanced mood states, and decreased stress stress levels which goes to say that the higher
levels (Suzuki & Basso, 2017). Exercise can the frequency of a person’s exercise, the lower
improve one’s overall mood and reduce stress his/her stress levels are regardless of the
by diverting attention away from sources of adjustments done in relation to other factors
stress and decreasing muscle tension (Ratey, like body type (overweight & obesity), age and
2019). In addition, exercise may also prevent food consumption. Specifically, those who
stress in the first place by improving their exercise 4 to 5 times a week, as part of the
resiliency to stress. A study investigating the study’s minimum recommendation to obtain
association between emotional resiliency to health benefits, had significantly higher stress
acute stress found that regular exercise had levels compared to those who exercise 6 to 7
significantly lower heart rates than sedentary times a week. While those who ceased to do
participants when exposed to a psychosocial physical activity had the highest stress levels
stressor. They also showed a smaller decline in among others (de Camargo, et al., 2021).
positive affect compared to sedentary
participants when they experienced a stressful A. Statement of the Problem
situation. (Childs & de Wit, 2014). The study aims to identify the effect of
On the biochemical level, it may also weekly exercise frequency on the level of stress
assist in the production of endorphins—natural experienced by answering the questions:
painkillers and mood elevators that help cope
3

1. What kind of effect does the have been established. With this, the
participants’ weekly exercise frequency researchers wanted to test if the frequency of
have on the level of stress that they exercise would also affect the levels of stress.
experience? For the independent variable of weekly exercise
2. Which frequency of exercise would frequency, the researchers decided to have
result in the lowest mean level of stress three groups: No Exercise, Occasional Exercise
among the participants? (1-3 times a week), and Frequent Exercise (4-7
3. Which frequency of exercise would times a week). For the dependent variable of
result in the highest mean level of stress stress levels, an 11-point Likert scale was used
among the participants? for its measurement.

B. Hypotheses 4. Instrument
Null Hypothesis: There are no An online survey was created in order to
significant differences among the three groups conduct the data collection. The form and
in terms of stress levels. questions were structured using the English
Language. The form would first ask for their
Alternative Hypothesis: There are emails in order for the researchers to ensure that
significant differences among the three groups real people answered the survey. It then asked
in terms of stress levels. about the weekly frequency of their exercise.
The next question pertained to their stress
levels which was presented in an 11-point Likert
II. Methodology scale.

1. Participants 5. Procedure
Participants in this study were not Data was gathered using an online
subject to any criteria when selected other than Google Forms survey accessed through a link
that they should be capable of exercising provided for by the researchers. It asked
whether they actually do or not. participants to answer a Likert scale and a
Socio-demographic information on the 45 multiple choice question in order for the
participants were not collected as they were not researchers to gather the necessary data.
relevant to the research problem being studied
by the researchers. 6. Data Analysis
The data gathered through the
2. Method collection process will be processed through the
A deviation of the snowball sampling Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS)
method was used to gather the needed number program. A statistical analysis (One-Way
of participants for data analysis to be ANOVA) will be done in order to make concrete
administered. Links to the survey were conclusions and answer the research questions.
disseminated through the associates of the Ethical considerations
researchers who may or may not exercise and
they themselves were asked to send the same 7. Ethical Considerations
link to interested peers who themselves have
varying frequencies of exercise. Ethical considerations were considered
and applied before and after the data collection
3. Variables process. Before any data was collected, an
Based on existing literature, a informed consent form had to be filled out by
relationship between exercise and stress levels the participants in order for them to proceed to
4

the questions themselves. If they answered the raw data for personal use pertaining only to
“no”, they were immediately sent to the final the data presentation and analysis of this
section of the survey, without any data research. All copies of the data will be promptly
collected. The researchers ensured that names deleted once the research has been completed,
or any form of explicit identification was not approved, and graded by the research adviser.
taken during the data collection process in
order to protect the confidentiality and 7.2 Benefits and Risks
anonymity of the participants. Participants of this study will not
have any direct and immediate benefits.
7.1 Data Privacy The results of this research, however,
Only the researchers and their may add to the existing body of
adviser are allowed to access the raw data research pertaining to the relationship
collected from the data gathering process. The between exercise and stress levels,
data will be stored in Google Drive, shared which could benefit the participants if
between the three researchers. They will be they are interested in this particular
permitted to make their own offline copies of topic of research.

III. Results

Table 1

Means, Standard Deviations, and One-Way Analyses of Variance stress levels according to weekly
exercise frequency.

Frequent exercise Occasional exercise No exercise F(2,42)

M SD M SD M SD

stress levels 4.47 2.973 7.93 1.486 8.13 1.642 13.918**

**p<0.001

Table 2

Descriptive table of stress levels for the relationship between Weekly Exercise Frequency and Stress
Levels.
95% Confidence
Interval for Mean
Std. lower upper
Exercise frequency N Mean Std. error minimum maximum
deviation bound bound
No exercise 15 8.13 1.642 0.424 7.22 9.04 4 10

Occasional exercise 15 7.93 1.486 0.384 7.11 8.76 5 10


5

Frequent exercise 15 4.47 2.973 0.768 2.82 6.11 0 10

Total 45 6.84 2.696 0.402 6.03 7.65 0 10

Table 3

One-way ANOVA

Sum of squares df Mean square F Sig

Between groups 127.511 2 63.756 13.918 0.000


Within groups 192.400 42 4.581
Total 319.911 44

Table 4

Post hoc tests - Multiple Comparisons

95% Confidence Interval for


Mean
(I) (J) Mean
Frequency of Frequency of difference Std. error Sig. lower bound upper bound
exercise exercise (I-J)

No exercise Occasional
0.200 0.782 1.000 -1.75 2.15
exercise
Frequent
3.667* 0.782 0.000 1.72 5.62
exercise
Occasional
No exercise -0.200 0.782 1.000 -2.15 1.75
exercise
Frequent
3.467* 0.782 0.000 1.52 5.42
exercise
Frequent
No exercise -3.667* 0.782 0.000 -5.62 -1.72
exercise
Occasional
-3.467* 0.782 0.000 -5.42 -1.52
exercise
*The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level

Decision Rule: Reject the Null Hypothesis. Results show that there are significant differences
among the three groups in terms of stress levels.
6

Analysis of Variance showed that the stressful situations despite their baseline
frequency of exercise has a significant effect on positive and negative affect being the same as
stress levels, F = (2,42) = 13.918, p<0.05. A test that of sedentary participants. Their findings
of multiple comparisons using Bonferroni’s test suggest that exercise could improve stress
revealed that those who exercised Frequently resilience, a finding that might explain the
(M = 4.47, sd = 2.973) had significantly lower reason behind similar results in the present
stress levels compared to those who had No study. Another possible explanation for stress’
Exercise (M = 8.13, sd = 1.642) and Occasional effect on exercise is its ability to produce
Exercise (M = 7.93, sd = 1.486). There is no mood-elevating biochemicals and reduce stress
significant difference between those who had hormones (Choi, et. al., 2019). The positive
No Exercise and those who had Occasional effects of exercise on self-esteem and,
Exercise in terms of stress levels. Thus, it is indirectly, stress, could also be a contributing
recommended to exercise 4-7 times a week in factor to the findings of the present study.
order to have the lowest stress levels. Overall, the results of this empirical paper
concur with pre-existing psychological literature
IV. Discussion exploring associations between stress and
exercise: that exercise may improve mood,
A. Interpretation decrease stress, and improve psychological
The researchers found that there are health in total (Suzuki & Brasso, 2017; Ratey,
significant differences among the three groups 2019).
in terms of stress levels. However, upon
processing the data in a test of multiple However, there is a slight disagreement
comparisons using Bonferroni’s test, it is between the results of this study compared to
revealed that there is no significant difference the literature of de Camargo, et al. (2021) about
between those who do not exercise and those the cross-sectional study of frequency of
who exercise occasionally in terms of stress physical activity and stress levels. The findings
levels. In the conduct of the study, findings are generated from the study de Camargo, et al.
enumerated. The more frequent a person’s (2021) has shown that those who do not
exercise is, the lower the stress levels that exercise at all have significantly higher stress
person has. Conversely, the less frequent a levels compared to those who do exercise no
person’s exercise is, the higher the stress levels matter the frequency. Contrary to this, the
that person has. Frequent exercise (4-7 times a researchers’ study upon subjecting the raw data
week) led to the lowest mean level of stress, under a test of multiple comparisons using
while no exercise led to the highest mean level Bonferroni’s test revealed that there is no
of stress. significant difference between those who do not
exercise and those who exercise occasionally in
B. Similarity of Results terms of stress levels.
The results of the present research
coincide with previous findings in the literature. C. Limitations
A study by Childs & de Wit (2014) exploring the Because the study was focused solely
association between regular exercise and on the relationship between the frequency of
emotional resiliency to stress has similar results exercise and its effect on perceived stress levels,
to the ones presented here. The former the results are limited in terms of the variables
research, which like the present research, relied focused on. The study did not make use of
on self-reported weekly exercise frequency. It other variables that could have an effect on the
was shown that those who exercised regularly perceived stress levels of a person such as
had a smaller decline in positive affect during sociodemographic characteristics and the type
7

of exercise that they engage in. The use of be done in order to know which reduces stress
perceived stress levels as a measure of stress most effectively.
also limits the research in terms of accuracy
since these are subjective perceptions of stress
and not an exact, accurate, and precise measure
of it. As the research sought to determine the
relationship between exercise frequency and
perceived stress levels, data collected did not
include the participants’ sociodemographic
characteristics, where the various variables
under this umbrella can perhaps have an effect
on the frequency of exercise and the perceived
stress levels of the participants.

V. Conclusion
It has been shown through the results
that there is a relationship between exercise
frequency and perceived stress levels. It is
shown that exercise frequency has a significant
effect on stress levels, where the participants
who exercised had significantly lower levels of
perceived stress as opposed to those who did
not exercise at all. The results of this study has
some congruence with the findings of Childs &
de Wit (2014) and Choi, et. al. (2019) supporting
the idea that exercise has an effect on stress,
where the latter is reduced as a result of the
former. As such, the researchers recommend
exercise as an effective technique towards the
healthy reduction of stress.

Recommendations
It is recommended that a study, that
also looks into the relationship between
exercise and stress levels, should be conducted
albeit with a larger sample size as well as the
integration and comparison between multiple
variables. Sociodemographic characteristics like
age, educational attainment, socio-economic
status, biological sex, and gender can be
variables that can be taken into account when
looking into the relationship of exercise
frequency and stress levels. The type of exercise
that the participant is doing should also be
considered in order for the researchers to be
able to determine what kind of exercise should
8

References: much you need to improve your mood”.


Blumenthal JA, et al. (2007). “Exercise and Insider. Retrieved from:
pharmacotherapy in the treatment of https://www.insider.com/does-exercise-
major depressive disorder”. Psychosom make-you-happy
Med, 69(7), 587-596. Harvard Health Publishing. (July 7, 2020).
DOI:10.1097/PSY.0b013e318148c19a “Exercising to relax: How does exercise
Childs, E., de Wit, H. (2014). Regular exercise is reduce stress?” Harvard Health
associated with emotional resilience to Publishing. Retrieved from:
acute stress in healthy adults. Frontiers https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-
in Physiology, 5, 161. healthy/exercising-to-relax
https://doi.org/10.3389/fphys.2014.001 Ratey, J. (October 24, 2019). “Can exercise help
61 treat anxiety?”. Harvard Health
Choi, et. al (January 23, 2019). “Assessment of Publishing. Retrieved from:
Bidirectional Relationships Between https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/ca
Physical Activity and Depression Among n-exercise-help-treat-anxiety-20191024
Adults: A 2-Sample Mendelian 18096
Randomization Study”. JAMA Richards, J., et al. (2015). “Don't worry, be
psychiatry, 76(4), 399–408. DOI: happy: cross-sectional associations
10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2018.4175 between physical activity and happiness
de Camargo, E. M., Piola, T. S., dos Santos, L. P., in 15 European countries”. BMC public
de Borba, E. F., de Campos, W., & da health, 15, 53. DOI:
Silva, S. G. (2021). Frequency of https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-015-13
physical activity and stress levels among 91-4
Brazilian adults during social distancing Suzuki, W. A. & Basso, J. C.(2017). The Effects
due to the coronavirus (COVID-19): of Acute Exercise on Mood, Cognition,
cross-sectional study. Sao Paulo Medical Neurophysiology, and Neurochemical
Journal, 139(4), 325–330. Pathways: A Review. Brain plasticity
https://doi.org/10.1590/1516-3180.202 (Amsterdam, Netherlands), 2(2),
0.0706.r1.0802021 127–152.
Fisher, M. (November 10, 2020). “7 ways https://doi.org/10.3233/BPL-160040
exercise makes you happy—and how
9

Appendix A

Sample Research Tool

1. Please input your email address.


2. On a weekly basis, how often do you exercise?
a. I exercise frequently (4-7 times a week)
b. I exercise occasionally (1-3 times a week)
c. I do not exercise at all (0 times a week)
Perceived Stress Level Scale
3. Using the scale below, how stressed do you generally feel? (0 = lowest, 10 = highest)

No Stress Moderately Stressed Extremely


at All Stressed

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
10

Appendix B

Informed Consent Form

Greetings of peace and hope!

We are 1st year Bachelor of Arts in Psychology students taking the PSYCH 110 - Psychological Statistics
class from the University of the Philippines - Cebu. We are conducting a study with the title,

“The Relationship Between Weekly Exercise Frequency and Stress Levels.”

If you are reading this right now, we are here to formally request for your consent and participation in
our study.

–Participant Selection
Due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, questionnaires will be distributed online. The researchers will
be using the purposive sampling method in gathering the participants. There are no specific
requirements to be a participant in this survey.

–Voluntary Participation
Participation in this research is entirely voluntary. In case you would like to discontinue your participation
for any reason, please inform the researchers immediately. You are allowed to withdraw at any
point and will not face any consequences for doing so.

–Risks
Participation in this study will not do you any harm. This research entails no physical or emotional risk to
you beyond what you might experience in daily life. However, if you feel any discomfort upon
answering some of the questions, you may inform the researchers at any time. As with all other
research, there is a probability that the confidentiality of the information we collect from you
could be breached. However, we will take all precautionary measures and actions to minimize
this risk and protect the data gathered. Additionally, rest assured that all information will not be
used for malicious purposes.

–Benefits
Being a participant in this study is unlikely to provide you with any immediate benefits. While
participating in this research would not help you directly, your participation will help the
researchers with the fulfillment of their course requirement. Furthermore, it may also provide
additional information on the relationship between one's exercise frequency and stress levels.

–Sharing the results


The results gathered from this research may be included in publications and presentations. The gathered
data from your participation may be shared with other researchers for future research studies.
The researchers will share the study to you and ask for your consent before being widely
distributed. Any personal information that could identify you prior to the distribution of data will
be eradicated.
11

–Confidentiality
To avoid violations of confidentiality, the data obtained from this study, both hard copies and soft
copies, will be maintained in a safe environment to which only the researchers will have access.
Any soft copies of the data will be encrypted or password secured, while hard copies will be kept
for nearly two years before being discarded and shredded. Moreover, participants of the survey
are protected under the Republic Act No. 10173 or Data Privacy Act. Therefore, your
identification in this survey is protected.

–Questions and/or Concerns


If you have any questions, you may contact the assigned researcher:
Del Mar, Elian R. (erdelmar@up.edu.ph)

–Participant’s Consent
Yes, I understand the statements above and give my consent to participate.
No, I have chosen not to participate in this study.

ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS

In doing research, the protection of every participant’s rights and protection through all necessary and
appropriate ethical principles are important. Specifically, in this research paper, different ethical
considerations to appraise were made such as (a) voluntary participation, (b) Informed Consent
Form, and (c) confidentiality for gatekeeping.

Voluntary Participation. Firstly, in the process of participant selection, the researchers made sure that all
possible participants’ participation in the said survey and research process is voluntary and non
compulsory. Beforehand, all of the participants were first and foremost asked if they were willing
to answer relevant questions on the topic for research specifically on exercise frequency and
stress levels.

Informed Consent Form. All participants who agreed to join the research were given the Informed
Consent Form discussing all possible ethical concerns including the risks, benefits, and
confidentiality. They were made to read and understand the Informed Consent Form, and then
they were asked to provide their e-signatures so their full consent was indicated and appraised
by the researchers. The informed consent form was important since it contains everything that
the participants have to know about their rights and the reason for research as well as how the
data will be protected under any circumstances.

Gatekeeping. The confidentiality and full reliability of the data collected for the research are under the
researchers’ efforts for gatekeeping. In order to make sure that all of the information collected
won’t be disclosed in any unwanted nature, the researchers have applied a researcher-only folder
for their data collection and analysis procedure wherein only the researchers are able to access
the full and raw data provided by the respondents. Furthermore, the researchers also made sure
to inform the respondents that their information and answers will be used for the research
project the researchers are in compliance with their course requirements and will thus be shared
with their Professor on the subject through the Informed Consent Form. The respondents were
also made aware of the risks that they can get and are exposed to when they decide to
participate in the research. Furthermore, in a major effort to protect their personal information
12

and answers to the questionnaire, the researchers followed the ethical requirement for security
and confidentiality and stored the survey data in a secure centralized platform.
13

Appendix C

Data Tables Processed by SPSS

Table 1

Means, Standard Deviations, and One-Way Analyses of Variance stress levels according to weekly
exercise frequency

Frequent exercise Occasional exercise No exercise F(2,42)

M SD M SD M SD

stress levels 4.47 2.973 7.93 1.486 8.13 1.642 13.918**

**p<0.001

Table 2

Descriptive table of stress levels for the relationship between Weekly Exercise Frequency and Stress
Levels
95% Confidence
Interval for Mean
Std. lower upper
Exercise frequency N Mean Std. error minimum maximum
deviation bound bound
No exercise 15 8.13 1.642 0.424 7.22 9.04 4 10

Occasional exercise 15 7.93 1.486 0.384 7.11 8.76 5 10

Frequent exercise 15 4.47 2.973 0.768 2.82 6.11 0 10

Total 45 6.84 2.696 0.402 6.03 7.65 0 10

Table 3

One-way ANOVA

Sum of squares df Mean square F Sig

Between groups 127.511 2 63.756 13.918 0.000


Within groups 192.400 42 4.581
Total 319.911 44
14

Table 4

Post hoc tests - Multiple Comparisons

95% Confidence Interval for


Mean
(I) (J) Mean
Frequency of Frequency of difference Std. error Sig. lower bound upper bound
exercise exercise (I-J)

No exercise Occasional
0.200 0.782 1.000 -1.75 2.15
exercise
Frequent
3.667* 0.782 0.000 1.72 5.62
exercise
Occasional
No exercise -0.200 0.782 1.000 -2.15 1.75
exercise
Frequent
3.467* 0.782 0.000 1.52 5.42
exercise
Frequent
No exercise -3.667* 0.782 0.000 -5.62 -1.72
exercise
Occasional
-3.467* 0.782 0.000 -5.42 -1.52
exercise
*The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level

You might also like