Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gestalt
Gestalt
'Reich ultimately became best known for his unorthodox sex and energy theories and tragi-
cally died of a heart attack in Lewisburg Federal Penitentiary, Pennsylvania, where he was
serving a 2-year term for distributing his invention, the orgone energy accumulator, in violation of
a U.S. Food and Drug Administration injunction. This telephone-booth-size device purportedly
gathered energy from the atmosphere to cure common colds, cancer, and impotence while the
patient sat inside (Sharaf, 1983).
83
http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/12064-006
Becoming an Effective Psychotherapist: Adopting a Theory of Psychotherapy That's
Right for You and Your Client, by D. Truscott
Copyright © 2010 American Psychological Association. All rights reserved.
84 BECOMING AN EFFECTIVE PSYCHOTHERAPIST
Copyright American Psychological Association. Not for further distribution.
While working with Goldstein, Fritz met and later married Laura Perls
(nee Lore Posner; 1905-1990). Laura studied psychology at Frankfurt
University and received a doctorate in science. Among her teachers were
psychologists Kurt Goldstein and Max Wertheimer (one of the founders
of Gestalt psychology) and existential philosophers Paul Tillich and Mar-
tin Buber (see chap. 4). Fritz and Laura later fled Western Europe, just
ahead of the Nazis, to South Africa, where they established a psychoana-
lytic institute.
Fritz and Laura cowrote Ego, Hunger and Aggression: A Revision of Freud's
Theory and Method (Perls, 1947)—although Laura was not given author-
ship credit—during this period of upheaval, and the book presaged many
gestalt therapy concepts. In it they reevaluated the psychoanalytic concep-
tualization of aggression and suggested that Sigmund Freud had under-
estimated the importance of basic bodily functions like eating and diges-
tion. They also discussed holistic and existential perspectives, and described
therapeutic exercises designed to promote physical awareness rather than
cognitive insight.
In response to the rise of apartheid in South Africa, Fritz and Laura
immigrated to the United States and established the New York Institute
for Gestalt Therapy in 1952. Several years of collaboration with members
of this group resulted in a comprehensive formulation of the theory and
Gestalt 85
Finally, Gestalt psychology gave to gestalt therapy more than its name.
Although gestalt therapy is not directly an application or extension of it,
Gestalt psychology's focus on interaction and process, and many of its
important experimental observations and conclusions, informs gestalt
therapy. In particular, gestalt therapy incorporates the Gestalt psychol-
ogy concept of homeostasis. Needs are understood as disturbing of an
individual's homeostasis. A healthy person, when aware of a need, acts
to satisfy the need and thus returns to balance. Distress arises when a
person is unable to act to regain homeostasis. For example, where dis-
Copyright American Psychological Association. Not for further distribution.
Gestalt Rationale
Gestalt Goals
1970). If, instead, clients are encouraged to focus on the here and now of
their experience, they will find that any point of contact becomes a por-
tent of exciting new possibilities (Polster & Polster, 1973). Change then
occurs spontaneously and without effort through awareness of what and
how we are thinking, feeling, and doing—through awareness of the field
of our present moment. The ensuing process leads to changes in the en-
tire field that is the client's existence. It is this experience that is essential
for change—not thinking or talking about the experience. Most of us
tend to talk about ourselves, our past, our problems, our dreams, our
Copyright American Psychological Association. Not for further distribution.
ideas. The more aware we are of the full extent of our experience, the
more able we are to integrate and accept all aspects of our self. In addi-
tion, the more thorough the exploration, the more intense the reorgani-
zation, allowing us to accept responsibility for our actions and reactions
and thereby make choices that are based on a more authentic apprecia-
tion of environmental demands and of our true needs and desires.
expand awareness of the here and now. Ideally, each individualized ex-
periment grows out of the therapist's responsive interaction with the cli-
ent. Because the experience can be very emotional and unsettling, it is
best if clients are prepared for experiments (Greenwald, 1976) and a strong
therapeutic relationship is established beforehand (see the Therapeutic
Relationship section later in this chapter). The following paragraphs de-
scribe some of the games proposed by gestalt therapists.
Internal dialogue exercises are probably the most famous of the gestalt
experiments. They are intended to address internal conflicts caused by
Copyright American Psychological Association. Not for further distribution.
here and now. The therapist then uses what is revealed by the dream to
raise the client's awareness of self. This may mean the client acts out the
dream's different elements—be they people or objects. Alternatively,
dream analysis might involve finishing the dream in a different manner,
or the therapist might ask the client to do an internal dialogue exercise
with the dream to determine what it has to tell the person.
Using the language of responsibility involves encouraging clients to say
what they mean and mean what they say. In other words, clients use
language that injects real feeling into their words. The language of re-
Copyright American Psychological Association. Not for further distribution.
Therapeutic Relationship
Gestalt therapists strive to bring the full impact of their personality to the
therapeutic encounter (Levin & Shepherd, 1974). This is not to say that
the therapist dominates the session but rather that honesty, spontaneity,
and direct engagement are modeled and valued in the session. Therapy
is seen as an encounter between two people in which the conditions for
change are made possible, in part, by the presence of a therapist who is
committed to growth. The therapist therefore enters fully into the ses-
sion in an active, assertive, engaged, confident, and creative manner.
The therapeutic moment is prized as a precious, singular opportunity for
change. If the client is fully present and aware, then the therapist will
not interrupt their process. When the therapist observes withdrawal from
experiencing, however, the client's attention is drawn to the phenom-
enon and an opportunity for growth is seized.
The gestalt therapist recognizes that change does not happen through
coercion—it happens when a person is fully experiencing. Forced change
is an attempt to actualize an idea—which is impossible—rather than to
actualize the self. Awareness and self-acceptance are the conditions that
make growth possible. Forced intervention inhibits this process. The ge-
stalt therapist therefore tries to avoid speculation about what will emerge
Gestalt 91
in session or what direction the client will or should take. Rather, the
therapist pays close attention to the client's moment-by-moment experi-
ence and directs awareness toward truer expression of the client's real
needs. In this sense, the therapist is an expert—an expert on the change
process and skilled in removing obstacles to growth (Levin & Shepherd,
1974). Yet, the therapist cannot make discoveries for the client—
ultimately, the client is responsible for his or her own actions, reactions,
and decisions, and is the expert on his or her own life.
Copyright American Psychological Association. Not for further distribution.
Gestalt therapy suffered from the loss of the dominant (some would say
domineering) presence of Fritz Perls after his death. Yet, gestalt therapy
clearly is not dead yet; there are more than 60 gestalt therapy institutes
throughout the world, and more continue to be established. A number
of journals also continue to thrive: International Gestalt Journal (formerly
The Gestalt Journal), British Gestalt Journal, Gestalt Review, and Australian
Gestalt Journal are devoted primarily to articles on gestalt therapy. Gestalt
Theory also publishes articles on Gestalt psychology, including some on
therapy.
Earlier gestalt therapy practice tended to stress the clinical use of frus-
tration and an abrasive attitude if the therapist thought the client was
being manipulative. There has been a movement toward more interper-
sonal gentleness in gestalt therapy practice, largely influenced by the
overwhelming empirical evidence of the importance of the therapeutic
alliance (Wampold, 2001).
Emotion-focused—or process-experiential—therapy was developed by
Leslie S. Greenberg (1945-), who, beginning his graduate studies with
Laura Rice (Rice & Greenberg, 1984), has committed his career to under-
standing and testing gestalt therapy (Sloan, 2004). Emotion is under-
stood as the primary adaptive motivator in human experience. By acti-
vating clients' emotions, their cognitions and behaviors will follow as
their self-actualizing tendency is engaged (Elliot, Watson, Goldman, &
Greenberg, 2004). The emotion-focused therapist strives for empathic
attunement with the client to be able to propose change tasks that will
facilitate healthy emotional processing. Markers of problematic emotional
processing that occur in session, such as puzzling over an emotional re-
action, feeling torn between alternatives, self-criticism, or ambiguous feel-
ings toward a significant person, are used by the therapist as opportuni-
ties for introducing an experiential change task (L. S. Greenberg, 2002).
These change tasks are designed to help clients identify, experience, ex-
92 BECOMING AN EFFECTIVE PSYCHOTHERAPIST
plore, make sense of, transform, and flexibly manage their emotions in
the present moment. As a result, clients become better able to access the
important information and meanings about themselves and their place
in the world around them that healthy emotional processing affords. Cli-
ents are then freed to use this information to live a full and vital life (L. S.
Greenberg & Watson, 2006).
Body-oriented psychotherapy is currently quite a popular approach (e.g.,
R. Frank, 2001; Kepner, 1987; Kurtz, 1990). Originally developed pri-
marily from the work of Wilhelm Reich, body-oriented psychotherapy
Copyright American Psychological Association. Not for further distribution.
A Heart Divided
man she loved. Yet she felt that she was her "own worst enemy." She
wanted to work with a therapist who would help her "grow as a
person" and heard that Dr. Smith worked from a gestalt perspective.
Emma liked how Dr. Smith was kind yet forthright. He took time
to listen without interrupting, and he would then make penetrating
observations about what she said, as well as how she spoke and
behaved, inviting her to pay attention to these aspects as well.
Gradually, Emma became more aware of her body and tone of
voice, and as she did so, she found herself increasingly anxious in
session. Dr. Smith encouraged her to stay with this feeling.
"I can't. It's too painful."
"You mean you won't," replied Dr. Smith.
"That's so harsh. Can't you see I'm in pain?"
"You say you are in pain and yet you are smiling."
"Am I? I hadn't noticed."
"May I propose something? What do you notice around your
mouth, your eyes, and your face? Try telling me what your smile is
saying."
"You don't know pain. You don't know suffering. Don 'tyou dare cry.
There are plenty ofthings to cry about that are worse than what's happening to
you."
"Oh, God! I haven't thought about this in years."
"About what?"
"About how I always had to take care of my younger brothers and
I never had time to take care of myself. Argh! I just feel so angry!"
As Emma continued to talk about and pay attention to her feelings
about her upbringing, this led to her feelings about her job.
"I know there are things I should be doing, and I want to do them.
Yet, I put them off. I just can't seem to get around to them. I know! I
know! 7 don't do them. I won't do them.' But part of me just resents
doing them."
"May I propose something else? Try sitting over there {pointing to
another chair] and speaking from that part of you that resents doing
those things."
"Why should I have to clean up after them just because they're
incompetent? If I were as bad at my job as they are, no one would expect me to
do it. It's not fair."
"Good. Now move over to that chair and speak from the other
part of you."
"You 'll damn well do it and do it well. No one gets ahead by slacking off.
Those other nurses will never make anything of themselves with that attitude.
And neither will you ifyou don't smarten up."
94 BECOMING AN E F F E C T I V E PSYCHOTHERAPIST
Learning Task
Copyright American Psychological Association. Not for further distribution.
The past is history, the future's a mystery, and today is a gift—that's why
we call it the present. Take a few moments to pay attention to your imme-
diate experience. Are you feeling stressed, harried, calm, or curious? Does
this exercise seem silly to you? Does it seem meaningful, difficult, easy?
How do you think it would be received by most clients? What do you
notice about how you feel about gestalt therapy? What do your answers
Gestalt 95
to these questions tell you about your affinity for the approach? How do
you feel about it relative to the other approaches you have learned about
so far? Record your thoughts and feelings in your reflective journal.
Summary
Copyright American Psychological Association. Not for further distribution.
Gestalt therapy takes as its centerpiece the idea that the human condi-
tion is a unified whole different from the sum of its parts. Distress arises
when we withdraw from awareness of our experience of body, self,
and environment. If we focus on our experiential present moment, our
innate homeostatic tendency toward health is activated. Gestalt therapy
therefore focuses on the here and now of living in session and has as its
goal awareness of the contact between our physical bodies, our envi-
ronment, and our selves. Change is accepted as paradoxical in that the
more one tries to be who one is not, the more one stays the same. By
focusing on what is happening in the moment, change occurs sponta-
neously and without effort. Change is facilitated through the use of
experiments individually tailored to facilitate awareness. In order to
improve in this manner, the gestalt therapist must be active, assertive,
engaged, confident, and creative in session and in relation to the client.
Currently, gestalt therapy is enjoying a resurgence in popularity in the
form of process-experiential, body-oriented, and mindfulness-based
therapies.
Further Resources
CASE READINGS
Aylward, J., Bauer, R., Freedman, H., Harman, R., & Perls, L. (1986). A case
presentation in gestalt therapy. The Gestalt Journal, 9, 16-35.
Feder, B., & Ronall, R. (1997). A living legacy of Fritz and Lara Perls: Contempo-
rary case studies. New York: Feder.
Perls, E (1969). Gestalt therapy verbatim. Moab, UT: Real People Press.
RECOMMENDED READING
Greenberg, L. S. (2002). Emotion-focused therapy: Coaching clients to work through
their feelings. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
Perls, F., Hefferline, R. E., & Goodman, P. (1951). Gestalt therapy: Excitement
and growth in the human personality. New York: Dell.
Polster, E., & Polster, M. (1973). Gestalt therapy integrated. NewYork: Brunner/
Copyright American Psychological Association. Not for further distribution.
Mazel.
Woldt, A. J., & Tolman, S. M. (2005). Gestalt therapy: History, theory, and prac-
tice. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
RECOMMENDED VIEWING
American Psychological Association (Producer). (2004). Gestalt therapy with
Gordon Wheeler, PhD [Motion picture]. (Available from the American Psy-
chological Association, 750 First Street, NE, Washington, DC 20002-4242)
American Psychological Association (Producer). (2007). Emotion focused therapy
over time with Leslie S. Greenberg, PhD [Motion picture]. (Available from the
American Psychological Association, 750 First Street, NE, Washington, DC
20002-4242)
Milton H. Erickson Foundation (Producer). (1990). Erving Polster, PhD: Hu-
manization of technique [Motion Picture]. (Available from the Milton H.
Erickson Foundation, 3606 N. 24th Street, Phoenix, AZ 85016-6500)
Psychological & Educational Films (Producer) .(1965). Three approaches to Psy-
chotherapy I: Part II. Frederick Perls (gestalt therapy) [Motion picture]. (Avail-
able from Psychological & Educational Films, 3334 East Coast Highway,
#252, Corona del Mar, CA 92625-2328)
Psychological & Educational Films (Producer). (1973). Gestalt dream analysis
with Frederick Perls [Motion picture]. (Available from Psychological & Edu-
cational Films, 3334 East Coast Highway, #252, Corona del Mar, CA 92625-
2328)