Critique Paper about the painting “Mona Lisa” by

Leonardo da Vinci

Name: Dan Gideon A. Deypalan Mrs. Joyce Gelio-Vacal

Grade 12-Musk (Academic Stem) EAPP Subject Teacher

1
 Leonardo da Vinci's Mona Lisa is a masterpiece of art that transcends the

realm of mere representation, captivating viewers for centuries with its stunning

realism, technical mastery, and enigmatic mystery, serving as a celebration of

human beauty and complexity, a reflection of Leonardo's own fascination with the

human body and the natural world, and a meditation on the nature of art and the

relationship between artist and subject.

The Mona Lisa is a portrait of a mysterious woman with a direct gaze and an

enigmatic smile. She is seated in a chair against a peaceful background landscape.

Painted in a muted color palette, with the sitter's skin and dress being the most

prominent colors, the painting creates a sense of unity and harmony in the

composition. Leonardo da Vinci used a variety of line types, shapes, textures, and

spaces to achieve this effect. Delicate curves define the sitter's features while the

geometric shapes create balance and harmony. Adding a thick impasto together with

the perspective creates the illusion of depth. The sitter is positioned in the center of

the canvas, creating a sense of balance and harmony in the composition. She is also

posed in a way that is both elegant and natural.

The Mona Lisa is a portrait of Lisa Gherardini, the wife of Francesco del

Giocondo, a wealthy Florentine merchant. The painting was commissioned by

Francesco sometime between 1503 and 1519, and it is believed to have been

completed in 1506. The Mona Lisa was originally in the possession of the Giocondo

family, but it was later acquired by the French royal family. The painting has been on

display at the Louvre Museum in Paris since 1797.

The Mona Lisa is a masterpiece of art for many reasons. First is its stunning

realism. Leonardo da Vinci was a master of anatomy and perspective, which allowed

2
him to create a lifelike depiction of the sitter's face and body. Her features are

delicate and realistic, and her body is well-proportioned. Da Vinci's attention to

anatomical detail is evident in the Mona Lisa's hands, which are particularly well-

rendered (Zöllner, 2017). Additionally, Da Vinci used perspective to create the

illusion of depth in the painting, with the sitter placed in the foreground and the

landscape in the background becoming gradually smaller. This creates the feeling

that the viewer is looking into a real space (Ackerman, 1951). Second, the painting is

full of mystery. The sitter's identity was unknown for centuries, and her enigmatic

smile has been the subject of much speculation and debate. This sense of mystery

adds to the painting's appeal and makes it even more fascinating. Third, Leonardo

da Vinci's Mona Lisa is a masterpiece of technical mastery. He used a variety of

techniques to create the painting's realism and depth, such as glazing and sfumato.

Using the glazing would create subtle effects of light and shadow on the sitter's face

and clothing, giving the painting a sense of realism and depth. Additionally, sfumato

creates a soft and blended effect, especially on the sitter's skin. This technique gives

the woman's skin a soft and luminous quality.

While the Mona Lisa is renowned for its realism, it is important to note that the

painting is not a completely accurate representation of reality. Da Vinci idealized the

sitter's features and pose, and he used several artistic techniques to create a more

pleasing and harmonious image. For example, the sitter's eyes are perfectly

symmetrical, and her smile is perfectly enigmatic. This suggests that Da Vinci was

more interested in creating a work of art than in providing a faithful depiction of his

subject.

3
 Leonardo da Vinci's Mona Lisa is a masterpiece of art that has captivated and

intrigued viewers for centuries. One of the most enduring questions about the

painting is what Leonardo was trying to communicate through it.

One possible interpretation is that the Mona Lisa is a celebration of human

beauty and complexity. Leonardo was a master of anatomy and perspective, and he

used his skills to create a portrait that was both lifelike and idealized. The sitter's

features are delicate and perfect, and her body is well-proportioned. However, her

enigmatic smile also suggests that she is a complex and mysterious individual

(Zöllner, 2017).

Another possible interpretation is that the Mona Lisa reflects Leonardo's own

fascination with the human body and the natural world. Leonardo was a scientist and

inventor as well as an artist, and he was deeply interested in the workings of the

human body and the laws of physics. The Mona Lisa's realism can be seen as a way

of capturing the essence of human beauty and complexity (Ackerman, 1951).

In addition to these interpretations, the Mona Lisa can also be seen as a

reflection of the values and ideals of the Italian Renaissance. The sitter's idealized

beauty and serene expression reflect the Renaissance ideal of the perfect woman.

Additionally, the painting's harmonious composition and balanced use of light and

shadow reflect the Renaissance ideal of harmony and order.

Finally, the Mona Lisa can also be seen as a meditation on the nature of art

and the relationship between artist and subject. Leonardo was a master of illusion,

and in the Mona Lisa, he creates a portrait that is both realistic and enigmatic. The

sitter's smile is both inviting and elusive, and it seems to challenge the viewer to

know her truly. In this way, the Mona Lisa can be seen as a reflection of Leonardo's

4
own belief in the power of art to transcend reality and reveal the inner truths of

human existence.

In conclusion, the Mona Lisa is a masterpiece of art that has captivated

viewers for centuries. Its stunning realism, technical mastery, and enigmatic mystery

have made it one of the most famous and beloved paintings in the world. The Mona

Lisa is a testament to Leonardo da Vinci's genius and his ability to create works of

art that are both beautiful and thought-provoking.

The Mona Lisa is a reminder that art is not just about creating a

representation of reality; it is also about creating a work of beauty, mystery, and

intrigue. It is a reminder that art can inspire, challenge, and transform us. The Mona

Lisa is a truly iconic work of art, and it continues to be one of the most beloved and

admired paintings in the world.

5
RUBRICS:
artwork in a artwork and across the How the
thoughtful that caused artwork but author
manner. him to does not put selected the
consider it much effort artwork.
further. into explaining
what attracted
him to pursue
it.
Description Author Author Author Author does
thoughtfully answers the somewhat not answer the
answers the question What answers the question What
question What do see? question What do see? Make
do I see? Discusses do see? weak attempt
Discusses the most of the ff: Discusses to describe the
size, medium, size, medium, some of the ff: artwork,
process used process size, size, medium, describing
and subject. medium, used process size, very
Author shows and subject. medium, used few elements
strong Author and subject. in the work.
understanding discusses A few
of the most of the elements in
elements: line, elements: line, the work are
shape, space, shape, space, discussed.
color, texture, color, texture,
and value. and value.
Analysis Author Author Author Author does
answers the answers the somewhat not answer the
question: How question: Howanswers the question: How
is the work is the work
question: How is the work
organized? organized? is the work organized?
Thoroughly Discusses the organized? Make a weak
discusses the major Discusses a effort to
major principles offew of the mention the
principles of art in the work. major major
art in the work. principles of principles of
art in the work. art in the work.
Interpretation Author Author Author Author does
thoroughly and answers: What somewhat not answer:
thoughtfully is the artist answers: What What is the
answers: What trying to is the artist artist trying to
is the artist communicate? trying to communicate?
trying to The communicate? The
communicate? interpretation The interpretation

6
 The is based on interpretation is not
interpretation some visual is based on a supported by
is based on facts and few visual visual facts
visual facts clues facts and and clues
and clues collected. clues collected.
collected. collected.
Conclusion Author Author Author Author
concludes with concludes with concludes with concludes with
an engaging an interesting a somewhat a shallow
and interesting point about his interesting reaction to the
point about his reaction to the point about his artwork.
reaction to the artwork. reaction to the
artwork. artwork.
Mechanics No errors in A few minor A few minor Distracting
punctuation, errors in errors in and major
spelling, punctuation, punctuation, errors in
grammar, or spelling, spelling, spelling,
capitalization. grammar, or grammar, or grammar, or
Uses APA capitalization capitalization capitalization.
style, double- but they do not that while Header and
spacing and distract the distracting, the title format are
12-point font. overall meaning can not correct.
Header and meaning of the still be There are
title format are essay. Uses discerned. mistakes in
correct. Paper APA style, Some APA spacing and
is at least 3-4 double- style, double- font. Paper is
pages. spacing and spacing and less than 3
12-point font. 12-point font. pages.
Header and Header and
title format are title format
correct. Paper may not be
is at least 3-4 correct. Paper
pages. is not 3 pages.

Rated by: _____________________ Date:___________ Overall Score:_________

Feedbacks:__________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
________________________________