Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 21

Grades 3-4

GRADES 3-4
13213BEP

Critical Thinking
Test

The Critical Thinking Co.™


Empower the mind!
Grades 3-4 Critical Thinking Test
Table of Contents
Critical Thinking for Reading Comprehension - Inferential/Inductive & Deductive Reasoning. . . . . 1

Inference Jones Beginning 2 - Inferential/Inductive Reasoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-3

Mathematical Reasoning™ Level E - Deductive Reasoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4

Mind Benders® Level 3 - Deductive Reasoning. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5

Math Analogies Level 2 - Inferential/Inductive Reasoning. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

Balance Benders™ Level 1 - Deductive Reasoning. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7

Dr. DooRiddles B1 - Inferential/Inductive & Associative Reasoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8

Language Smarts™ Level D - Inferential/Inductive & Deductive Reasoning �������������������������������9-10

Building Thinking Skills® Level 2 - Deductive Reasoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11

Basics of Critical Thinking - Inferential/Inductive & Deductive Reasoning ������������������������������������ 12

Pattern Explorer Beginning - Deductive Reasoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13

Critical Thinking Detective™ Beginning - Deductive Reasoning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14-15

Answers. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16

The Critical Thinking Co.™


Empower the mind!

200+ Award-Winning PreK-12+ Books & eBooks!

For more than 60 years, our fun, award-winning critical thinking skills products have helped
students of all abilities achieve better grades and higher test scores with highly effective lessons
that sharpen the mind as they teach standards-based reading, writing, mathematics, science,
and social studies. We do not teach through drill and memorization nor teach to the tests; we
empower the mind!

Our products–written by teachers–are designed so students must carefully analyze what they
are learning. Deeper analysis produces deeper understanding, which results in better academic
performance. Over time, students who practice critical thinking learn to apply it throughout their
education and life.

© 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849 i


From: Critical Thinking for Reading Comprehension https://www.criticalthinking.com/critical-thinking-for-reading-comprehension.html

Fishing
Observation and Reading for Evidence – Deduction

1
Tom, his son, and his brother are fishing. Each of them caught one fish.
2

3
Tom’s brother caught the largest fish.

Answer each question and then explain the evidence for your answer.

1. The picture is Tom and his son. True False Unknown

2. Tom’s son did not catch a fish. True False Unknown

3. Tom’s son is in the picture. True False Unknown

4. Tom’s son’s fish is smaller than his brother’s. True False Unknown

5. Tom and his son both caught small fish. True False Unknown

© 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849 1


From: Inference Jones Beginning 2 https://www.criticalthinking.com/inference-jones-beginning-2.html

MY PET HUMAN

1
Wow, it sure is cold in this big house! I wonder
2

where my human went. Oh, there she is, tapping on


3

those buttons again. I think I’ll go and jump on them to


4

annoy her a bit. 5


It’s so fun to watch her reaction, plus
she usually feeds me after I distract her from staring at
that computer screen all day. 6
Click, Click. “HEY! GET
7

OFF THERE, SYLVESTER!” That’ll do it.


8
Now I’ll just hop off this chair, onto the floor,
9

and walk in circles until she comes around the corner. Here she comes.
10 11
I bet I
can beat her to the kitchen. Yup, every time.
12
It must be tough having only two
13

legs. 14
I’m starving; I wish she didn’t take so long fixing my food. 15
Finally! Yes!
16
Sardines and salmon are my favorite!
17
Mmmm … that was great. Now, if I can only get her to swing around that
18

plastic mouse for me to chase. 19


PRRR … PRRRR ….
20
“Syl, do you want to play with little mousy?” Yes, I knew I could keep her from
21

tapping those buttons again. 22


Oh, yea, swing it again and again! 23
I love the taste of
this little mousy. 24
Ok, I’m tired now. I think I’ll rest in her lap and snuggle until I
25

decide that I need something else from her. I love my pet human.
26

Circle T if you are certain this sentence is true. Circle F if you are certain it is
false. Circle U if it is unknown because you need more information. Add the
sentence number(s) on the line that best supports your true or false answer.

1. The human’s name is not Cindy. T ___, F ___, or U

2. The house is cold. T ___, F ___, or U

3. Sylvester does not consider himself a pet. T ___, F ___, or U

Write the answer on the lines given or circle the letter next to the correct answer(s).

4. Explain why the picture above does not work with the story.

_____________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________

2 © 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849


From: Inference Jones Beginning 2 https://www.criticalthinking.com/inference-jones-beginning-2.html

5. Describe Sylvester’s personality.


a. loving and kind
b. scared and fearful
c. brave and courageous
d. playful and spoiled

6. Which sentence(s) best supports the idea that Sylvester is not a dog?
a. 13
b. 19.
c. 4.
d. 26.

7. What is the main idea of this story?


a. Sylvester likes sardines and salmon.
b. The human and cat have changed roles.
c. Humans are smarter than cats.
d. Sylvester keeps his human from watching television.

8. What probably happened in-between these two sentences: “Oh, yea, swing it again
and again! I love the taste of this little mousy.”
a. The human swung the bowl.
b. The human was annoyed.
c. Sylvester caught the mouse and put it in his mouth.
d. Sylvester jumped on the computer mouse.

Circle PT for probably true or PF for probably false. Be sure to supply the best
evidence that supports your answer: sentence number(s) and/or personal knowledge.

9. Sylvester is a cat.

PT or PF Sentences ____ ____ ____

Personal knowledge: ____________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________

10. Sylvester distracts his human from the computer.

PT or PF Sentence ____

Personal knowledge: ____________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________

© 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849 3


From: Mathematical Reasoning™ Level E https://www.criticalthinking.com/mathematical-reasoning-level-e.html

Smarty Pants Puzzles ™

Mike told Kevin that he


City Park would give him a ride to
Entrance the movies if Kevin was
waiting in front of the
city park at 6 p.m. At Show Time
Starts at 6:15 p.m.
5:45 p.m., Kevin walked
directly to the city park
and then waited there in
front of the park until 6:15
p.m. when he walked di-
rectly home.

Read the problem and then write whether each sentence is


true, false, or unknown based on the information.

1. Kevin arrived at the park before 6 p.m.

2. Mike could not have kept his promise to Kevin.

3. If Kevin arrived at the front of the park at


5:59 p.m., then Mike did not keep his promise
to Kevin.

4. If Kevin arrived home at 6:30 p.m. and it took


him more time to walk home than it took him to
walk to the front of the park, Mike did not keep his
promise to Kevin.

4 © 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849


From: Mind Benders® Level 3 https://www.criticalthinking.com/mind-benders-level-3.html

NAME THE ANIMALS

A cat, a small dog, a goat, and a horse are named Angel, Beauty, King, and Rover.
Read the clues to find each animal’s name.

1. King is smaller than both the dog and Rover.


2. The horse is younger than Angel.
3. Beauty is the oldest and is a good friend of the dog.

Angel Beauty King Rover

cat

dog

goat

horse

© 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849 5


From: Math Analogies Level 2 https://www.criticalthinking.com/math-analogies-level-2.html

Complete Each Math Analogy


TH
MA

1)

26
13 : :: 11 :
39

2)

: :: :

3)

: :: :

4)

: :: :

6 © 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849


From: Balance Benders™ Level 1 https://www.criticalthinking.com/balance-benders-level-1.html

Balance
Benders™

?
Which answer can replace the question mark?

a. c.

b. d.

from both pans on 2nd balance. Hint: Remove

© 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849 7


From: Dr. DooRiddles B1 https://www.criticalthinking.com/dr-dooriddles-b1.html

I get confused with shrub,


And roses grow on me;
And, no, I'm not a vine,
Think words that start with B.

What am I?

___ ___ ___ ___

Most trains run on me,


I rhyme with sacks;
Both sides are parallel,
I was built by strong backs.

What am I?

___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___

I keep out all the flies,


But let in all the air;
Movies play upon me,
While you just sit and stare.

What am I?

___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___

The trees you often see,


On a Hawaiian shore;
Or look deep in your hand,
And see what lies in store.

What am I?

___ ___ ___ ___

8 © 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849


From: Language Smarts™ Level D https://www.criticalthinking.com/language-smarts.html

Subtitles
Subtitles are often found on JENNY AND
JOE
the covers of books. Subtitles The Story
of a Girl
and Her D
og
appear under titles and provide
additional information about
the book.

Circle the letter of the subtitle that fits each title best.

1. “Dogs Can Be the Best Pets”


a. What You See at the Zoo
b. Tips on How to Train Your Puppy
c. Photos of Strange Pets

2. “Spending Time With Grandparents”


a. Visits Don’t Have to be Boring
b. Six Ideas that Changed History Forever
c. Make the Best Use of Your Brain

3. “Exploring the Grand Canyon”


a. Maps and Tips to Guide Your Trip
b. Giving Advice can be Risky
c. Typing Notes in Half the Time

4. “You Can Be a Musician!”


a. Sharing Recipes Pays Off
b. Six Easy Piano Lessons
c. Birds and Cats Don’t Mix

© 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849 9


From: Language Smarts™ Level D https://www.criticalthinking.com/language-smarts.html

Capitalize
Titles: Doctor Wall
Abbreviations: Dr. Wall
Groups: Girl Scout
Book titles: Shiloh
Proper names: Kendall
Names of places: Oregon
Initials: J.P. Skinner
First word in sentence: Yesterday, Jim was sick.
Pronoun: I
First word in a quotation: She said, “Call me when the
game is over.”
Days of the week: Monday Tuesday Wednesday
Thursday Friday
Months and holidays: January March November
Easter Thanksgiving

Circle the words that should be capitalized


in the following story.

A Magical Moment

17 as darkness fell over disneyland, my brother and i saw mickey

mouse and cinderella leading a big parade. we stood for a long time

watching, even though it was december and it was a chilly day. our

friends, dr. jeremy smith and michelle elliott, were spending christmas in

california, but we were heading home on thursday.

10 © 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849


From: Building Thinking Skills® Level 2 https://www.criticalthinking.com/building-thinking-skills-level-2-color.html

COMBINING SHAPES

DIRECTIONS: If each square is cut into three parts, circle the figures that can be
formed by joining those parts.

B-21 a. b.

c. d.

B-22 a. b.

c. d.

a. b.
B-23

c. d.

© 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849 11


From: Basics of Critical Thinking https://www.criticalthinking.com/the-basics-of-critical-thinking.html

The Cort House


Read the story and look for evidence in the picture to answer the questions below.
All four members of the Cort family just returned to their house after a three-day
vacation visiting relatives. It started snowing last night, but stopped just before they
got home. Mr. and Mrs. Cort bought a new sled on their way home and parked the
car right in front of the house. All of the Cort family is in the house. The Cort family
are the only people in the house. None of the Corts were carried into the house.

1. Which Cort is not in the picture?

___________________

2. If you look at the tracks in the snow, how many people are in the house?

______

3. If there are four members of the Cort family in the house, how could the fourth
member of the family get into the house?

_________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________

12 © 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849


From: Pattern Explorer Beginning https://www.criticalthinking.com/pattern-explorer-beginning.html

4. Number
NumberNinja
Ninja 11
4.4.Number
Write
Write whole Number
4.numbers
Number
whole4.numbers
Number
Ninja
Ninja
Ninja1Ninja
in the
in the 1 empty
empty 1 1 boxes so
boxes sothat
thattheir product
their product
equals the number on the right for each
equals the number on the right for each row and the number row and the number 3 7 21
Write
on Write
theWrite
whole
whole
Write
bottomwhole
numbers
numbers
whole
for numbers
each in
numbers
in
the
the
column. in
empty
the
empty
in empty
the
boxes
boxes
empty
boxes
soso
boxes
that
that
sotheir
that
their
so product
that
their
product
their
product
product
on the equals
bottom
equals for
equals
the
the each
equals
number
the
number column.
number
theonnumber
onthethe
onright
the
right
onfor
right
the
for
each
right
each
for row
each
for
roweach
and
row
andthe
row
and
the
number
and
number
the number 21
the number3 3 737 3721 721 21
onon
For the
thethe
onbottom
bottom
the
on bottom
example theforfor
bottom
each
each
shown:for column.
each
for
3column.
xeach
7column.
= 21 column.
in the top row, 8 5 40
For the8 example shown: 3 x
x 5 = 40 in the bottom row, 3 x 8 = 24 7 = 21 in thein top row,
the left 40
8 8 58 5 8540 540 40
ForFor
8 x 5 =column,
40 the
inFor
theexample
the
andFor
the
example
7example
the
x 5shown:
bottom example
=shown:
shown:
in3the
row,
35 shown:
3
x3 7xx 7
=
38=
right21
x=721
3in=xin
24 the
21
7 in
column. the
=in
top
21the
top
thein
row,
row,
top
the row,
left top row, 24 35
8 8
x 5
x 5
=
8 =
40
x 5
40
8 in
=
x in
the
40
5 the
= in
bottom
40 the
bottom
in bottom
therow,
row,
bottom
3row,
3
x 8
xrow,
8
=
3 =
24
x 8
24
3 in
=
x in
the
24
8 the
= in
left
24 the
left
in left
the left 2424 35
243524
35 35
column, and 7 x 5 = 35 in the right column.
column,
column,column,
and
column,
and 7and
7
x 5x and
5
=
7= 35
x535
7in
=xin
the
35
5 the
=in right
35the
right
incolumn.
right
the
column.
right
column.
column.

1. 1.1. 1. 1. 2. 2.2. 2. 2. 3.3. 3. 3.


3. 4.4. 4.
4. 4.

6 66 6 6 1414 14 14
14 9 9 99 9 5 5 5 55
2020 20 20 2020 20 20 1616 16 16 1010 10 10
20 20 16 10
8 8 815158 15 15 1010 10
2828
1028 28 1212 12 5 5105 5
1212 12 1010 10
1212
8 15 10 28 12 12 10 5
5.5. 5. 5. 6.6. 6. 6. 7.7. 7. 7. 8.8. 8. 8.

5. 6. 33 33
3333 7. 8.
2727 27 27 88 8 8 33 3 3
33 4 4 4 4 27
4242 42 42 2828828 28 4 4 4 34
1212 12 1211 11
1111 2121 21 2154 54
5454 8 8 828288 28 28
4 42 28 1212 121 12
1 1 1
4
129.9.11
9. 9. 10. 10. 10.
10.
21 54
11.
11. 11. 11.
8 28 12.
12. 12. 12.
12 1
2222 22 22 66 6 6 3030 30 30 1818 18 18
9. 10. 11. 12.
3535 35 35 22 2 2 3030 30 30 3232 32 32
1414 14
22
1455 55
5555 2 2 26 62 6 6
6 1818
5050 50 30 8 8 8 8
5018 18
18
7272 72 72

13. 35
13. 13. 13. 14.
14. 14. 14. 2 15.
15. 15. 15. 30
16.
16. 16. 16. 32
14 55 1515 15215 6 9 9 9 950 184040 40 40 8 100
100100100
72
4040 9 9 15.
9 9 1212 12 12 44 4 4
13. 14.40 40 16.
1212
5050 50 5012 12 3 3 32727
3 27 27 3030 30
1616
3016 16 2020 20
2020
2020 20
15 9 55 5 5 40 100
© 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849 13

40 9 12 4
From: Critical Thinking Detective™ Beginning https://www.criticalthinking.com/critical-thinking-detective-beginning.html

Read the case below to find evidence to identify the innocent and guilty suspects.
Remember, the story and witnesses’ statements are true.

The Candy Thief


1
On Monday at 1 p.m., one of the four boys below was seen stealing candy from a store.
2
The store is within walking distance from the thief’s home. 3When police arrived, they
talked to the store owner and two shoppers who were in the store at the time of the
theft. 4After listening to the witnesses’ statements below, police arrested one of their four
suspects at 1:30 p.m. 5The suspect later confessed to stealing the candy.

Jeff Richards: 6I saw all four of the suspects in the store. 7I know one of the boys with
the longest hair because his dad and I are close friends. 8His dad has never stolen
anything in his life. 9I watched one of the boys with the shortest hair very carefully, but I
never saw the other one with short hair.

Ramsey Collier: 10My brother is one of the suspects with short hair. 11His friend is the
other boy with dark short hair. 12I was always with my friend when he was in the store.
13
He is one of the two suspects with the longest hair. 14He didn’t steal the candy, but we
both know who did.

Store Owner: 15I was at the cash register across from the candy counter and saw all
four suspects looking at the candy from 12:30 p.m. to 1:30 p.m. 16Suspect B was always
by himself and never bought or stole anything. 17I kept watching Suspect C, but he never
stole anything.

A B C D

Circle the Candy Thief.

14 © 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849


From: Critical Thinking Detective™ Beginning https://www.criticalthinking.com/critical-thinking-detective-beginning.html

The Innocent
Fill in the blanks, then use complete sentences and sentence numbers to describe the
best evidence for your conclusions.

Sentence _____ proves that Suspect C is innocent.

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

Sentence _____ proves that Suspect _____ is innocent.

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

Sentences _____, _____, and _____ prove that one of the two suspects with the longest
hair did not steal the candy. This evidence and sentence _____ prove that Suspect _____
is innocent.

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

The Candy Thief

______________________ is the candy thief. We can prove that Suspects _____, _____,
and _____ are all innocent, and sentences 4 and 5 tell us that one of the suspects was
arrested and confessed. This proves that Suspect _____ is the candy thief.

© 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849 15


Answers
Page 1 10. PT; 7; Sentence 5 tells us what usually
1. Unknown; The picture could also be happens when Sylvester distracts his
Tom’s brother and Tom’s son. pet human, but sentence 7 is the best
2. False; Sentence 2 states that each of evidence that he did distract her.
the people in the story caught a fish.
Page 4
1. Unknown We know that he started his
3. True; There are three people in the
walk to the park at 5:45 p.m., but we
story; Tom, his son, and his brother.
don’t know how long it took him to get
Since the man in the picture has some
there. We know he left the park at
grey hair and the boy in the picture is
6:15 p.m., but we don’t know when he
too young to be a father, the man in the
arrived so we also don’t know how long
picture is either Tom or his brother. The
he waited.
boy in the picture must be Tom’s son.
2. False If Kevin did not arrive in front
of the city park until after 6 p.m., then
4. True; Sentence 3 tells us that Tom’s Mike could have kept his promise to Kevin.
brother caught the largest fish, so Tom’s 3. True If Kevin arrived at 5:59 p.m. and
son’s fish must be smaller. the story tells us that he “waited there
in front of the park until 6:15 p.m.,” then
5. Unknown; Sentence 3 tells us that Tom’s we know that Mike did not keep his
brother caught the largest fish, but we promise to give him a ride to the movies.
do not know the size of the fish. For 4. True If it took Kevin 15 minutes to walk
example, all three fish could have been home and it took him less time to
small, but Tom’s brother’s fish could walk to the front of the park, then he
have been the largest of the three, small arrived at the front of the park before
fish. 6 p.m. and was there waiting for Mike at
6 p.m.
Pages 2-3
My Pet Human Page 5
1. U; There is no evidence in the story that ANIMAL NAME
tells us or suggests the name of the pet
human, so we don’t know if it is Cindy or cat King
something else. This means the answer
is definitely unknown. dog Angel
2. T; 1
3. T; 26; Sentence 26 tells us Sylvester views goat Beauty
his human as his pet and pets don’t have
horse Rover
pets, so the sentence is true.
4. The cat bowl has the wrong name on it,
and the mouse is a wind-up mouse. King is smaller than the small dog (1), so King isn’t
5. d the goat or the horse (or the dog). Then King is the
6. b cat. The dog is not Rover (1) or Beauty (3), so it is
7. b; Sentence 16 tells us that answer “a” is Angel. The horse is not the oldest (2), but Beauty is
true, but it isn’t the main idea of the story. the oldest (3), so Beauty is not the horse. Then the
Answer “c” might be true in the story, but horse is Rover, and Beauty is the goat.
the story is fiction and not trying to claim
this is true. Answer “d” is not supported
anywhere in the story. The main idea of
the story is that the human is Sylvester’s
pet, so they have changed roles which is
answer “b.”
8. c
9. PT; 13, 18, 19

16 © 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849


Page 6 Page 11
22
Building Thinking Skills® — Level 2 Figural Similarities and Differences

COMBINING SHAPES

1)
33
DIRECTIONS: If each square is cut into three parts, circle the figures that can be
formed by joining those parts.

B-21 a. b.

2) c. d.

3) B-22 a. b.

4) c. d.

Page 7 B-23
a. b.

c. Remove from both pans on 2nd balance


c. d.

so = . (Tip 3)
46 © 2022 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849

On 1st balance, divide both pans in half so =


Page 12
1. Mr. Cort. The problem tells us that there are four
. (Tip 6) Substitute for each so members of the Cort family and all of the Corts are
in the house. Mrs. Cort and two small children can
be seen in the house.
2. Three. We only see three sets of footprints and
= . (Tip 7)
three people in the windows, but we know Mr. Cort
is in the house, but not at a window.
Page 8
3. The other child was probably pulled on the sled.
bush
This would match the evidence since there are two
tracks sets of adult footprints and only one set of child
screen footprints.
palm

Page 9
1. b
2. a
3. a
4. b

Page 10
As darkness fell over Disneyland, my
brother and I saw Mickey Mouse and
Cinderella leading a big parade. We stood
for a long time watching, even though
it was December and it was a chilly
day. Our friends, Dr. Jeremy Smith and
Michelle Elliott, were spending Christmas
in California, but we were heading home
Thursday.

© 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849 17


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15

4. Number Ninja 1
Page 13
Some questions have more than 1 answer. You need to find only 1 answer.

1. 2. Two solutions: 3. 4. Two solutions: 5.


2 3 6 2 7 14 1 14 14 3 3 9 1 5 5 5 1 5 3 11 33
4 5 20 5 4 20 10 2 20 4 4 16 10 1 10 2 5 10 4 1 4
8 15 10 28 10 28 12 12 10 5 10 5 12 11

6. Two solutions: 7. Three solutions: 8. 9.


3 9 27 1 27 27 2 4 8 8 1 8 4 2 8 3 1 3 2 11 22
7 6 42 21 2 42 4 7 28 1 28 28 2 14 28 4 1 4 7 5 35
21 54 21 54 8 28 8 28 8 28 12 1 14 55

10. Two solutions: 11. Two solutions: 12. Two solutions: 13.
2 3 6 1 6 6 5 6 30 10 3 30 2 9 18 1 18 18 5 3 15
1 2 2 2 1 2 10 3 30 5 6 30 4 8 32 8 4 32 10 4 40
2 6 2 6 50 18 50 18 8 72 8 72 50 12

14. Two solutions: 15. Two solutions: 16. Three solutions:


3 3 9 1 9 9 5 8 40 10 4 40 10 10 100 5 20 100 20 5 100
1 9 9 3 3 9 6 2 12 3 4 12 2 2 4 4 1 4 1 4 4
3 27 3 27 30 16 30 16 20 20 20 20 20 20
3

Page 14
The Candy Thief

A B C D

The Innocent
Suspect C: Sentence 17 proves that Suspect C is innocent. In sentence 17, the store owner says Suspect C never
stole anything.
Suspect B: Sentence 16 proves that Suspect B is innocent. In sentence 16, the store owner says Suspect B never
bought or stole anything.
Suspect A: Sentences 12, 13, and 14 prove that one of the two suspects with the longest hair did not steal the
candy. This evidence and sentence 16 prove that Suspect A is innocent. Sentences 12 and 13 tell us that Ramsey
Collier was always with one of the suspects with long hair when he was in the store. Sentence 14 tells us that the
boy with long hair that Ramsey was with didn’t steal the candy. Sentence 16 tells us that Suspect B was always by
himself, so Suspect B is not the long haired boy that Ramsey Collier was with. This means that Ramsey was with
Suspect A and Suspect A is innocent.
The Candy Thief
Suspect D is the candy thief. We can prove that Suspects A, B, and C are all innocent and sentences 4 and 5
tell us that one of the suspects was arrested and confessed. This proves that Suspect D is the candy thief.

18 © 2023 The Critical Thinking Co.™ • www.CriticalThinking.com • 800-458-4849


Grades PreK-12+
200+ Award-Winning Books and Software!
Reading/Grammar/Punctuation
Math/Science Logical Thinking
Spelling/Vocabulary
Fun-Time Phonics!TM Mathematical Building Thinking Skills®
(Gr. PreK–2) ReasoningTM Series Series
This fun, easy-to-use comprehension (15 levels: Gr. PreK–9) (6 levels: Gr. PreK–12+)
program is based on the scientific Teaches students to generate different This award-winning series develops
findings of the National Reading strategies for solving a wide variety verbal and spatial reasoning skills
Commission. The game-like activities of math problems. Skills students necessary for success in reading,
engage students through listening, develop will improve their grades and mathematics, and science.
thinking, speaking, and reading. test scores and prepare them for upper- Books or Software
Books or Software level math challenges.

Language SmartsTM Series Math Analogies Series Mind Benders® Series


(4 levels: Gr. 1–4) (5 levels: Gr. K–9) (9 levels: Gr. PreK–12+)
These books can serve as a core Understanding analogies and the ability Tricky logic puzzles develop superior
to reason analogically (reasoning used
curriculum for language arts or as a deductive thinking and reading
to identify, evaluate, and solve an
supplemental resource. Empower comprehension for higher grades,
analogy) are important problem-solving
your students’ minds as you skills. Problem-solving is an essential top test scores, and real-life
improve their vocabulary, grammar, part of mathematical development. problem-solving.
punctuation, reading, and writing skills. Books or Software Books or Software

Balance MathTM and More! Balance BendersTM Series


Editor in Chief ® Series
Series (4 levels: Gr. 2–12+)
(5 levels: Gr. 2–12+)
(4 levels: Gr. 2–12+) Move over Sudoku, here come
Students become world-class editors Balance Benders™! You can use
These activities sharpen computational
as they identify and correct errors skills and develop algebraic reasoning. these books as quick, fun, logic
in grammar, mechanics, usage, and Level 1 focuses on addition and problems or as stepping-stones to
content in short, high-interest stories. subtraction. Level 2 focuses on success in algebra. Students develop
Books or Software multiplication and division. Level 3 deductive thinking and pre-algebra
involves addition, subtraction, division, skills as they solve balance puzzles.
multiplication, fractions, and decimals. Books or Software

Word Roots Series Math Detective® Series Inference Jones Series


(3 levels: Gr. 3–8) (2 levels: Gr. 3–6)
(5 levels: Gr. 3–12+) Short stories include charts, tables,
Effective activities teach Latin or graphs that are used to answer Short, fun, easy-to-use activities
and Greek prefixes, roots, and questions to improve understanding that improve critical thinking by
suffixes. Improves spelling, reading of math concepts and develop critical developing students’ ability to draw
comprehension, and adds hundreds thinking skills. Topics and skills are inferences from written text as they
drawn from national math standards to identify and evaluate evidence.
of words to students’ vocabulary. prepare students for advanced math
Meets state standards. courses and assessments. Books or Software
Books or Software Books or Software
Reading Detective® Series Science Detective® Series Critical Thinking
(4 levels: Gr. 3–12+) (2 levels: Gr. 3–6) Detective Series
Standards-based, higher-order Topics and skills drawn from national (3 levels: Gr. 3–12+)
science standards prepare students These quick, fun, easy-to-use
thinking activities develop analysis,
for more advanced science courses detective cases develop critical
synthesis, and vocabulary skills for
and assessments that measure thinking skills by requiring students
exceptional reading comprehension. to identify clues and analyze and
Includes literature, math, history, reasoning, reading comprehension,
and writing in science. synthesize information to determine
and science. the innocence or guilt of each
Books or Software Books or Software
suspect.

Building Writing Skills Pattern Explorer Series The Basics of Critical


Series (3 levels: Gr. 3–9) Thinking
(3 levels: Gr. 3–12+) Rich and diverse collections of pattern (Gr. 4–9)
Teaches writing as a 5-step problems to explore, investigate, discover, Defines and teaches critical thinking
and create to provide a foundation for through simple explanations,
process: Prewriting, Drafting,
authentic learning and abstraction. diagrams, and short, engaging
Revising, Editing, and Publishing. Activities are independent, self-contained, activities. Students who successfully
Includes examples, practice, and and build on one another. complete this book will have a
scoring rubric for narrative, opinion, fundamental set of critical thinking
argumentative, informative writing. skills they can use their entire lives.

Better Grades & Higher Test Scores — Guaranteed!


Try any of our 200+ Critical Thinking products risk free—guaranteed or your money back!
Call 800-458-4849 or visit www.CriticalThinking.com for:
• Online Catalog • Discounts/Promotions • Sample Activities
• Product Info. & Guidance • Reseller Opportunities • Free Critical Thinking Tests

13213BEP

You might also like