Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

19981 BERNAL: PHYTELEPHAS SEEMANNII I J

P rinc ip es, 42(l), 1998, pp. 15-23

The growth form of Phytelephas


seemanni i-a potentially i mmortal
solitarypalm
RoonrcoBrRuer
Instituto d,eCiencias Naturales, Uniuersidad Nacional d,eColombia, Apartad,o 7495, Bogotti, Colonbia

AssrRecr Granville 1,992). Four of the 23 architectural


models describedby Hall6 et al. (1978) for trees
I studied the growth form of the vegetable ivory palm
Phytelephasseemanniion the Pacific coast of Choc6,Colom- are representedamongpalms: Corner'smodel (a
bia. The palm grows in the understory of riverine forests and solitary, unbranched,pleonanthic axis, as in the
has a large crown up to 16 m in diameter.The prostratestem coconut); Tomlinson's model (axis branched at
is erect for some distance at the apex and has abundant ad-
base, as in all clustering palms, individual axes
ventitious roots throughoutits length. The palm differs from
other plants having Corner's architectural model in that its
being either hapaxanthic or pleonanthic); Holt-
stem often rots at the older end. Crowing at the apex and tum's model (a solitary,unbranchedhapaxanthic
dying at the base,the palm has no mechanical constraintsto axiso as in Corypha); and Schoute'smodel (di-
indefinite growth, and individuals can be potentially immor- chotomously branched axes, as in Hyphaene).
tal. The creeping aspecto{ the stem is not due to plagiotropic
growth but is the result of oblique orthotropic growth com-
Although appropriate for describing the varia-
bined with gradual subsidence due to the crown's own tion in architecture, the models do not describe
weight, accumulatedlitter, or the impact of falling branches. aspectsrelevant to the ecologicalperformanceof
This growth form is considered as the adaptation of a palm palms, such as size, phyllotaxis, or. overall
with a large crown to the understory of a frequently flooded growth form. Dransfield (1978) recognizedfour
forest. The same growth form is noted for rhe palm Elaeis
oleifera and the cycad Zamia roezlii. basic growth forms for palms, accounting for
plant size: treeoshrub, acaulescent,and climb-
Rnsuunr,l ing palms. Thesecategories,however,can hardly
Se estudi6 la forma de crecimiento de la palma de tagua accommodatepalms with prostrate or creeping
Phytelephas seemannii en Ia costa Pacffica de Colombia. La stems. Uhl and Dransfield (1987) have briefly
palma crece en el sotobosque de selvas ribereflas y tiene una discussedthe caseof palms with prostratestems,
corona de hasta 16 m de dir4metro. El tallo es postrado, erecto
and Kahn and de Granville (7992) have treated
en el 5pice, y est6 provisto de abundantes raices adventicias
en toda su longitud. La palma difiere de otras plantas que
them as a separatelife form. In this paper, I de-
tienen el modelo arquitect6nico de Corner, en que el tallo a scribe the growth form of the vegetable ivory
menudo se pudre en el extremo basal. Creciendo en el 6pice y palm PhytelephasseemannttO. F. Cook, discuss
muriendo en la base, la palma no tiene limitaciones mec6ni- its ecological significance, and compare it to
cas para un crecimiento indefinido, y los individuos pueden
that of other specieswith prostratestems.
ser potencialmente inmortales. El aspecto rastrero del tallo
no se debe a crecimiento plagiotr6pico, sino que es el resulta- Phytelephasseema.nniiis a large, dioecious,
do de crecimiento ortotr6pico oblicuo, combinado con una solitar5 understorypalm with a thick stem up to
gradual reclinaci6n debida al propio peso de Ia corona, a la 2-6 (occasionallyup to 12) m long and 25 cm in
hojarasca acumulada o al impacto de ramas que caen. Se con-
diameter.Most of the stemlies on the ground,but
sidera esta forma de crecimiento como la adaptaci6n de una
palma con gran corona al sotobosque de selvas frecuente-
its apical part is erect and upto2-4 m tall. Leaf
mente inundadas. Se sef,ala el mismo hdbito de crecimiento scars are densely arranged, and those of the
para la palma Elaeis oleifera y la cicada Zamia roezlii. lower side are hidden by numerousadventitious
roots. The crown usually has 15-35 pinnate
Ieavesto B m long and ca. 4.5 kg in weight. Fe-
In spite of their overall architectural simplici- male palms bear up to 20 infructescencesin dif-
ty, palms exhibit a wide variety of growth forms ferent developmental stages. The mature in-
(Holttum 1955, Dransfield 1978, Uhl and Drans- fructescenceis spherical and compact,to 40 cm
field 1987, Tomlinson 1990, Kahn and de in diameterand weighsca.7 kg.
PRINCIPES fYor.42

Phytelephas seemannii ranges from north- mate age of 24 yeats; at this point, the palm is
western Colombia to Central Panama. It forms still increasingthe number of leavesin the crown
large homogeneousstands (Fig. l) in the under- (Bernal, unpublished observations).The stem
story of riverine forests that are subject to brief initially grows orthotropically, either verticaliy
flooding (Bernal and Ervik 1996)with an average or slightly leaning (Fig. 4), and in no casedoesit
density of 352 adult palms per hectare (Bernal, creep from its initial stages.
unpublished observations).This specieswas one Totally vertical stems taller than I m are
of the former sourcesof vegetableivory (Barfod scarce. Only three individuals were observedin
1989, Bernal 7992), and it is the basis ofhandi- the study area with vertical stems 3-4 m tall;
craft production in Panama(Dalling et al. 1996) they all were males. As the palm growsoit oftef
and Colombia. rotatesthe whole crown toward"anarea ofhigher
light intensity, which is more evident near gaps
Materialsand Methods or forest edges.Stems ca. 1.5-2 m long often ex-
Stem length was measuredin all adult palms hibit a curved shape, the basal portion lying on
in two 0.I-ha plots and in a plotlesssite ca. 0.3 the tangential side of the curve (Fig. 5). Stems
ha (total n [number] : 201) at the Valle and ca.2-3 m long are also curved, but they usually
BoroboroRivers, in the Departmentof Choc6,on lie on the plane described by the curve (Fig. 6).
the Pacific coast of Colombia (5o34'-6o04'N, Longer stemsusually exhibit a rangeof patterns,
77"20'-30'W). Sex and state of the stem base from almost straight and creeping for most of
(whether complete or rotten above ground) were their length, to variously meanderingor describ-
recorded for 320 palms along the Boroboro ing a completecircle and with the apical portion
River. For palms having the base apparentlyun- erect (Fig. 7). Theselong stemsare often marked
damagedaboveground,undergroundrotting was at intervals by abrupt bends (Fig. B) that contrast
not checked, as this would have required poten- with their rather smooth curvature. Up to three
tially destructive excavation. Height of the such bends were found on the longest stems.
crown center from the ground was recorded for Thesebendswere closerto each other in females
120 palms along the sameriver. For 16 male and than in males(mean: 1.6 vs. 2.0 m, respective-
18 female palms, the number of abrupt bends on ly; o : 22 females,25 males; F : 4.3; P : 6.8
the stem (reflecting past falls) was counted and X l0-4). On average,males have longer stems
the distance betweenbends measured;for these than females(mean : 2.8 vs. 2.0 m; n : 105
and 30 other palms in the area, stem shape and ; : 2.5;P : 3.8 X 10-6),
m a l e s ,9 6 f e m a l e s F
growth direction of the adventitious roots were and the center of their crown is located higher
studied in detail, in order to reconstruct the than that of females (mean : 1.8 vs. I.4 m; n :
palm's past creeping history. Additionally, many 60 males,60 females;F : 2.8;P : 5.1 X l0 ).
casual observationswere made during several In SBVoof all palms studied (n : 320), the stem
years. Data from demographicplots (Bernal, un- was rotten at the base above ground. There was
published observations)were used to describe no significant difference betweenmales and fe-
the initial growth phaseof the palm. males in abovegroundrotting at the base (P :
0.39). The longest stem recorded was that of a
Results male 12.1 m long, the baseof which was rotten.
Phytelephasseemanniihas remoteligular ger- The stem of a 3-m-tall palm that was broken 1 m
mination (Fig. 2). The cotyledonaryaxis extends aboveground by a falling tree at the river Arusi,
geotropically for I0-I5 cm before the plumuie fell to the ground and resumedgrowth after a few
emerges. The seedling produces three scaie months, initially producing reduced leaves.
leaves(occasionallythe upper one with a few re- Many palms that were cut down in a pasture at
duced pinnae) before the plumule becomesevi- the Valle River were still growingseveralmonths
dent (Bernal, unpublished observations). The later, although someothersdied.
eophyll has 14-lB pinnae on each side of the
rachis,and successiveleavesincreasethe num- Discussion
ber ofpinnae. As the seedlinggrows,it produces Phytelephasseemanniifits Corner'sarchitec-
an obconical,oblique stem (Fig. 3). The palm be- tural model in having a single, unbranchedstem
gins to producean abovegroundstemwhen it has with axillary inflorescences. Although palms
alreadyreachedsexualmalurity. at an approxi- conforming to this model have indefinite apical
r99Bl B E R N A L : P H Y T E L E P H A SS E E M A NN I I I7

i:::i::i::::tt:t::::l

1 . A s t a n d o f P h y t e L e p h a ss e e m a n n i i a t t h e A r u s i R i v e r , C h o c 6 , C o l o m b i a . 2 - 3 . E a r l y g r o w t h o f P s e e t n a , n n i i . 2 . A s e e t l l i n g
'Ihe
showing rernote ligular germination and first eophy11. il. subterranean slem o{ a juvenile ca. l5 years old, at the \ralle
River.
IB PRINCIPES [Yor.42

B. A Phytelephas seemannii with two straight stem segments and an abrupt bend (near the center of the photo)' revealing at
least two suddenfalls. The stemwas dusted with corn flour for contrast'

growth,there are mechanical constraintsassoci- in most cases, to trace the growth history of a
ated with stem size (Holttum 1955, Tomlinson particular individual. The process apparently
1990), and each particular palm speciescannot begins from the seedling stage. Seedlings re-
exceeda certain size. Individuals must eventu- quire forest gaps to grow into juveniles; thus,
ally die due to mechanicallimitations. In P see- when an individual reaches adulthood, it is
mannii, however,longevity is not conditioned by probably growingin or around an old gap. As the
stem size. By losing the older portions at the palm's stem grows obliquelR the crown rotates
base of the stem, the palm can keep within the toward the area of higher illumination. As the
mechanically functional limits of stem size. In lever arm on the rooting baseincreases,the palm
this way, an individual may be potentially im- gradually subsides. Becausethe palm apex al-
mortal becausenone of its tissues are ever too ways has orthotropic (although oblique) growth,
old. A similar pattern of growth is observed in the progressivesinking of the stem often results
the palm Elaeis oleifera (Jacq.) Cort6s (Fig. 9), in an open curvature (Fig. 11a). When this
which occupiessimilar habitats ro P. seemannii, processhas advancedfor a long time the base is
and in the cycad Zamia roezlii Linden (Zami- often slightly risen from the ground. Rather than
aceae),which growsin mangroveson the Pacific creeping (as a plagiotropic stem would do), the
coast of Colombia (Fig. f0). By growing at the palm is almost rolling. If the torque caqsed by
apex and dying behind, these plants virtually the crown is too strong, due either to its own
move through the forest, probably being able, at weight (numerous developing infructescences),
least partially, to oodiscover"better light condi- to litter accumulation, or to an impact by a
tions. This departurefrom Corner'sarchitectural falling branch, the crownwill probably fall to the
model is so unique structurally and ecologically, ground, and the stem will either uproot and rise
that it should perhapsbe recognizedas an archi- (Fig. llb) or break. Because uprooting (which
tectural model on its own. seemsto be more common)results in an unstable
The form and curvature of the stem allow one. balance,the stem ends up lying on its side (Fig.
r9eBl BERNAL:PHYTELEPHAS
SEEMANNII

The falls are probably not always instanta-


neous, as evidenced by the occurrence of many
stems lacking abrupt bends. In such cases,the
smoothcurvature of the stem is probably the re-
sult of gradual subsiding, combined with or-
thotropic growth of the stem and probably also
with the rotation of the crown toward changing
light conditions in the forest canopy.
For the American oil palm Elaeis olei,fera,
which has the same growth form, Tomlinsonn
(f990) consideredthat the gradualsubsidenceof
the stem may be only apparent, and that the re-
verse is what happens: the initially horizontal
apex becomes erect. My observations on this
species(Fig. 9) indicate that the processis iden-
tical to that of P. seemannii. and that gradual
subsidence occurs. Casual observationsof the
cycadZamia roezlii (Fig. I0) suggestthat it also
growsin the sameway.Other palms describedas
having creeping stems, e.g., tohannesteijsrnan-
nia ahifrons, Licuala spp. (Uhl and Dransfield
I9B7), Chelyocarpus repens (personal observa-
tions, Kahn and Mejia l9BB, Kahn and de
Granville 1992), Nypa fruticans (Tomlinson
1990) or Serenoarepens(personalobservations,
Fisher and Tomlinson 1973, Tomlinson 1990)
differ in having plagiotropic development,and
are thereforetrue creeping palms. Rotting of the
9- Elaeis oleifera near Jurad6, Colombia. Note the rotten
base ofthe stem.
older portions of the stem in these species has
been documented only for Licuala spp. (Saw
l1c). Evidence of this can often be seen by a Leng Guan, personal communication) and for
changeofdirection ofthe adventitiousroots.The very old plants of Serenoarepens(J. B. Fisher,
stem recovers upright growth, and the process personal communication),and it apparently oc-
starts again (Fig. Ild). If the stem has risen to a curs also in Johannesteijsmannia ahifrons (Uhl
height of I m or so when the crownfalls next time, and Dransfietd1987).
the older portion of curved stemthat was lying on The ability of P. seemanniito resume growth
the ground may have risen to some height (Fig. after its stem has been broken is rare in the palm
l1e), ifthe stemdoesnot breakin the process.In family, and it can be explained by the abundant
somecases,the falls are probably instantaneous, adventitiousroots present all along the stem. In
as evidencedby the more or less abrupt bends on most other palms, adventitious roots are con-
the stem (Fig. B), which mark the point wherethe fined to the basal portions of the sterir(Tomlinson
stem resumedapogeotropicgrowth.The fact that 1990).The occasionalfailure ofindividuals ofP
the bendsare significantly closerin femalesindi- seemanniito recoverfrom a stem rupture is prob-
cates that they have abrupt falls more often than ably associatedwith the seasonofthe event, and
males. This is probably due to the weight of the the length of the stem portion that remains at-
numerous developing infructescences usually tached to the crown (Bernal, unpublished obser-
presenton the crown,and it might explain why fe- vations). If a stem is broken during the dry sea-
male crownsreach a lower height on averagethan son or is cut very close to the crown, the
males. It probably accounts also for the shorter available roots probably will not be enough to
stemsin females:If female stemsfall more ofterr, cover the water stress.
they have a higher risk of breaking during an The growth form of P seemannii is not only
abrupt fall, and have more portions exposedto unusual in the palm family, but also within the
being coveredby flooding. genus Phytelephas. It probably represents the
20 PRINCIPES fYot.42

10. A young ind ividtal of Zamia roezlii at lhe Pacific coast of Colombia. Note the rotten stem base.

optimal growth form for a large palm (crown up to od,ora,is a palm of the sandy soils in the camp-
16 m in diameter)of the forest understory,in an inaranas north of the Rio Negro in Brazil, and
areawhere the high rainfall (5000-7000 mm per has a subterranean stem (Henderson 1986). Z.
year) doesnot favor the developmentof a subter- roezlii (Fig. l0) has perhapsthe largest crown of
raneanstemon river banks, due to the high water any SouthAmerican cycad,up to 6 m in diameter
table. This is supportedby the fact that in drier and with up to 30 leaves, abounds in mangrove
areas in Panama this species is often acaules- swamps (personal observations,Norstog 1986),
cent or has a stem up to I m tall (Dalling et al. and has many close relatives with subterranean
1996); also, its closest relative, P rnacrocarpa stems.The fact that the three speciesare domi-
ssp. schottii, of the Magdalena River basin in nant elementsof the understoryin their respec-
Colombia,usually has a subterraneanstemwhen tive areas bespeaks the ecological success of
it growson drier slopes(Barfod 1991), but popu- this growth form.
lations growing on the alluvial plains have the Phylogenetic analysis of the' subfamily
same growth form as P. seemannii(Cla6s 1925). Phytelephantoideae(Barfod 1991) has shownP
The fact that the two other plants reported here seemannii andP rnacrocarpaas the most derived
as having the samegrowth form as P. seemannii, speciesin the genus.P. macrocarpassp.schottii
viz. Elaeis oleifera and Zamia roezlii, both also is endemic to the Magdalena River valley in
have large crowns,grow in areaswith high water Colombia ando as mentioned above, it exhibits
table, and have relatives with subterranean both subterraneanand aerial, oblique, partially
stems growing in drier areas also supports this prostrate stemsdepending on the habitat. Thus,
view. E. oleifera has a crown as large as that of P I hypothesizethat migration of P. macrocarpa,(or
seerna.nnii(both palms are strikingly similar, of its acaulescent ancestor) from northwestern
Fig. 9), and growsin swampyor frequently flood- Amazoniainto the wetter areasof the Magdalena
ed areas (Vallejo Rosero 1976,Kahn and Mejia River valley before the upheaval of the Colom-
1986); its closest American relative, Barcella bian Eastern Cordillera, and further west into
ree8l BERNAL:PHYTELEPHAS
SEEMANNII

e
11. Schematic representation of the growth form of P. seemannii. (a) Orthotropic growth combined with progressive sinking of
the stem often results in an open curvature. (b) A sudden fall uproots and raises the stem base. (c) Becausebalance of b is
unstable, the stem ends up lying on its side. (d) The stem resumesupright growth. (e) The crown falls again, and the older
portion ofcurved stem that was lying on the ground is raised slightly.

the Choc6, giving rise to P seemannii, entailed Colombia,for a leave of absence,DANIDA (f 04.
the ability to develop an aerial stem provided Dan.BL/20I) for a study fellowship, and The
with abundant adventitious roots. Frequent CharlesA. and Anne Morrow Lindbergh Founda-
flooding and strikes offalling branchesand trees tion, Conservation International, Fundaci6n
on the easy target offered by the large crown Ingued6, and The International Foundation for
must have acted as strongselectivepressuresfor Science(grantDl2254-1) for support during dif-
this growthform. ferent stagesof the research.I also thank F. Va-
lencia, members of ASPROVAL, the family of
Acknowledgments Arsenio, and that of Zulma and Oliverio for facil-
This researchis a part of my Ph.D. disserta- itating field work in the Choc6,The Montgomery
tion in the Departmentof SystematicBotany,Bi- Foundation for permission to study Serenoa
ological Institute, Aarhus University. I thank H. repenson their property in Miami, J. B. Fisher for
Balslev and other personnel of the Institute for enlightening discussion, Saw Leng Guan for in-
their support, the Universidad Nacional de formation on Licuala, and H. Balslev, J. Drans-
22 PRINCIPES fYor.42

field, J. Fischer, G. Galeano,A. Henderson,and trees as living systems. Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge,UK, pp. 263-27 3.
SawLeng Guan for commentson the manuscript. Frsurn, J. B. eNo P. B. ToMUNsoN.1973. Branch and inflo-
rescenceproduction in saw palmetto (Serenoarepens).
P r i n c i p e sl 7 : 1 0 - 1 9 .
LtrnReruRnCrrEn
HALLE,F., R. A. A. Oronueir, eNn P. B. ToMrjr,isoN.1978.
Benroo, A. S. 1989. The rise and fall of vegetable ivory. Tropical trees and forests: an architectural analysrs.
Principes 33: 181-190. . Springer,Berlin, Germany.
199f. A monographic study of the subfamily Heloeansou,A. f986. Barcella odora. Principes 30: 74-75.
Phytelephantoideae(Arecaceae).Opera Botanica 105: Horrrulr, R. E. f955. Growth-habits of monocotyledons
l-73. variations on a theme.Phytomorphology5: 399-413.
Brnuer., R. f 992. Colombianpalm products.lnr M. Plotkin K,qnr.l,F. exo J. J. oo GRetlvtrrn. 1992. Palms in foreh
and L. Famolare(eds.).Sustainableharvestand market- ecosystemsof Amazonia.Springer,Berlin, Germany.
ing of rainforest products. Isiand Press, Washington, - AND 1986. The American oil palm, Elaets
D . C . ,p p . l 5 B - 1 7 2 . oleifera,in Peruvian Amazonia.Principes 30: 182'
- ANDF. Envrr. 1996. Floral biology and pollination -AND K. Mrrie. 1988. Anewspeci.esof Chelyocarpus
ofthe dioecious palm Phytelephasseemanniiin Colom- (Palmae, Coryphoideae) from Peruvian Amazonia.
bia: an adaptationto staphylinid beetles.Biotropica 2B: Principes 32:69-72.
682-696. Nonsroc, K. 1986. Zamia chigua, a caseof mistaken iden-
"Phytele- tity? Fairchild Trop. Gard. Bull.4l: 6-13.
CleEs, F. 1925. Quelques donn6es utiles sur le
phas macrocarpa"Ruiz et Pav.Agronomie Coloniale96: Tour.tlson, P. B. 1990. The structural biology ofpalms. Ox-
29r-294. ford University Press,New York, New York, USA.
D e . L r r n cJ, . W . , K . E . H e n u s , J . R . E s n n u e n l , e r o I . C e w - UHr, N. W. eno J. DRensnrnr,o.1987. Cenera Palmarum.
DANEDo.1996. Natural history and uses of tagua Allen Press,Lawrence,Kansas,USA.
(Phytelephas seemannii) in Panama. Principes 40: Var,I-oJoRosnno, G. 1976. Estudio de poblaciones espon-
16-23. tdneasde la palma noli (Elaeisoleflera)(H.B.K.) Cort6s)
DRensrrrLo,J. 1978. Growth forms of rain forest palms. 12.' en Colombia. M.S. Thesis, Universidad Nacional de
P. B. Tomlinsonand M. H. Zimmermann (eds.).Tropical Colombia-ICA, BogotS.

(Continuedfrom p. 8)

Everywherethere were palms, many growing submergedin water along the river margins, others
growing in swampyupland conditions, but most were located on terra firme sandy loam soil. Climati-
cally it was hot but not oppressive.Fortunatelythere were few mosquitoeson the tannin-stainedwaters
of the Rio Negro,as its strongacidity apparentlyinhibits heavymosquitobreeding.Although the area
was sparsein population, we visited several villages and isolated thatched homes of the local Por-
tuguese-speakingcaboclos,severalofwhom guided us to palm-growingsites and sold us fish, includ-
ing piranhas,etc., which we later cookedon board.
Traveling northwestwardon the Rio Negro we cruised as far as the confluence of the smaller Rio
Padauariand the Rio Negro, almost the head of navigationfor a craft of our draft, as further upstream
rapids prohibit onwardnavigation.Altogether,we traveled up the Rio Negro eight days before revers-
ing coursedownstreamwhere after two days and two nights we were back in Manausfor a last day of
sightseeing.Throughoutour trip on the river we were accompaniedby the famed pink Amazoniandol-
phins, which continually swamand leaped around us in friendly curiosity.
Our final count of palms was lB generaand 55 species,the most outstandingof which were:Astro-
caryunxjauarl (clumping,fruits eaten by fish), Asr ocaryurLparatnacca(uncommonon the Rio Negro),
Attalea racemosa(trunkless), Bactris bidentula (a probable rheophyte),Bactris campestris(flat leaf
spines), Bactris riparia, Barcella odora (highlight, a rare sight), Desmoncuspolyacanthos,Euterpe
catinga (orange crownshaft), Geonomastricta (blue fruits), Leopoldinia major (clumping in deep
water), Leopoldiniapiassaba (rare, drooping fibers), Lepidocaryumtenue (tnd,erstory scaled fruit),
Manicaria saccifera (huge leaves, warty fruits), Mauritia carana, and Mauritiella aculeata. There
were of coursemany more, far too numerousto mention.
BIrl posro*
l 9eBl SS
B E R N A LP: H Y T E L E P H A E E M AN I I

\,{ft'"'
.'.f

.;.,':,
,l.,.;,trt::.
|
f ::.:"
i;
tt],:

4-7. Stem bending in Phytelephas seemannii. 4. A female palnr with leaning stent. 5. A stem resuming upright growth after
'lwo
falling to the ground. 6-7. p a l n r s w i t h d i f f e r e n t s t e m l e n g t h s . ' l ' h e s t e r n sw e r e d u s t e d w i t h c o r n f l o u r f o r c o n t r a s t .

You might also like