Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

VIEWPOINT

2023

E M B E D D E D I N V E S T M E N T,
E M B E D D E D W E A LT H

The evolution, interplay & future promise

AUTHORS
Embedded finance is transitioning from being a mere
concept to a force that could substantially influence
Arjun Vir Singh
our evolving financial services landscape. Among
embedded forms of payments, lending, and insurance, Philippe De Backer
both embedded investments and wealth are expected Dr. Mohammad Nikkar
to play pivotal roles, offering insights into future
developments in personal finance. This Viewpoint
examines the wider topic of embedded finance from
multiple lenses and delves into the origins, evolution,
and prospective trajectory of embedded investments
and wealth, highlighting the intertwined relationship
with embedded savings.
VIEWPOINT ARTHUR D. LITTLE

ORIGINS & RISE OF By providing streamlined wealth management

EMBEDDED FINANCE tools, this segment attracts not only seasoned


investors but also novices, expanding the
The foundation of embedded finance lies in market base.
the marriage between finance and technology.
Before the digital revolution, traditional banking INTERPL AY BE T WEEN
and finance were compartmentalized, usually
EMBEDDED SAVINGS &
operating in isolation. As technology moved into
EMBEDDED INVES TMENT S
every facet of our lives, these barriers began to
erode. Fintechs began offering banking services, In a world where finance is intertwined with daily
while banks started leveraging technology to digital experiences, embedded savings is the
expand their scope of service. This convergence silent gatherer, while embedded investments is
laid the foundation of evolving from standalone the astute grower, turning pennies into portfolios.
finance to integrated finance to embedded Within embedded finance, two facets are proving
finance (see Figure 1). particularly interesting: embedded savings

Embedded investments is where accumulated and embedded investments. Their interplay,

savings are intelligently channeled — not toward though subtle, has the potential to redesign how

spending in the future (we will cover the concept consumers approach money management, creating

of “save now, buy later” in an upcoming Viewpoint) a frictionless pathway from saving to investing:

but rather on creating wealth. Embedded - Embedded savings — the gateway to


investment platforms take saved funds and financial prudence. Often likened to digitally
direct them into investment avenues, offering enhanced piggy banks, embedded savings
returns and increasing wealth. This converts platforms give users a way to seamlessly
passive savings into active wealth growth, often integrate savings mechanisms into their
with minimal input or expertise from the user. routine digital transactions. The psychology
The potential for embedded wealth is vast. As behind it is straightforward: simplifying
of 2022, the global embedded finance market the act of saving by integrating it into daily
was estimated to reach US $385 billion by 2029. activities, reducing decision fatigue and
Figure 1. Maturity and
The subset of market
embedded potential
investments holds a of keymaking
embedded
savings almost involuntary.
finance offerings
considerable share of that market opportunity.

MATURITY AND MARKET POTENTIAL OF KEY EMBEDDED FINANCE


Figure 1. Maturity and market potential
OFFERINGSof (ILLUSTRATIVE
key embeddedVIEW)
finance offerings

Personalized Illustrative
& relevant
Embedded insurance Loan options & installment payments:
insurance options unsecured lending (e.g., “buy now,
Market potential

Embedded pay later” [BNPL]) & secured lending


lending (e.g., underwritten point-of-sale loan)

Payment & processing


services directly on the
Banking services like platform (e.g., e-wallets,
Embedded
Investment & debit/credit cards & cross-border payments,
Embedded payments
other wealth banking saving accounts B2B payments)
mgmt. services
Embedded
wealth mgmt. (e.g., stocks,
commodities)
Market maturity

Embedded finance can


Embedded insurance Embedded payments encompass any use case
Greater upside possible
& lending with huge are already de facto that facilitates delivery
in banking & wealth Embedded
potential, still early one-click checkouts of financial services, tax
mgmt. as it matures anything
in the journey (but BNPL) mgmt., accounting mgmt.,
invoices mgmt., etc.

Source: Arthur D. Little, Dealroom.co

Source: Arthur D. Little, Dealroom.co


EMBEDDED INVESTMENT, EMBEDDED WEALTH 2
VIEWPOINT ARTHUR D. LITTLE

(In the Viewpoint, “From Micro-Saving to Big from conservative bonds to mutual funds or
Impact,” we shared our perspective on this more aggressive stocks. The idea is not just
topic.) At its core, embedded savings is about to save, but to make the saved money work
integrating savings tools within nonfinancial for the user, compounding over time.
platforms. Imagine you’re purchasing a
The key is the seamless flow between embedded
coffee through a mobile app. The coffee
savings and embedded investments. The journey
costs $3.65, but you’re charged $4. The extra
from a user’s daily digital activity to saving
$0.35 is automatically diverted to a savings
and, subsequently, to investing is integrated,
account or fund. Such tools take advantage
eliminating the need for active financial planning
of daily transactions, transforming mundane
or management. It’s a passive, yet effective, way
activities into financial opportunities. This
to manage and grow one’s finances.
“spare change” strategy is an effortless
way to accumulate significant savings over
MAK ING MAGIC HAPPEN
time. Note that one of the pillars supporting
embedded savings is behavioral economics.
Embedded wealth: The next phase of
Research shows that the act of saving
fintech disruption
money, especially when done consciously,
can be mentally taxing for individuals. Embedded wealth services can be offered through
Decision fatigue, a phenomenon in which a wide range of platforms ranging from neobanks
making decisions becomes harder with the to super-apps (see Figure 2). Some of the players
sheer number of choices, comes into play growing their embedded wealth services rapidly
with traditional savings. Embedded savings include traditional and challenger banks, asset
eliminates the need for such decisions by managers, and super-apps.
automating the process. Regardless of the use case and/or the providers,

- Embedded investments — turning savings the embedded wealth management market is


into wealth. Embedded investments leverages growing and largely untapped. When facilitated
the funds you’ve accumulated for wealth by an established and trusted embedder, it is
generation. Once a savings threshold is quicker, easier, and cheaper to offer to an existing
reached, these platforms automatically invest customer base.
the accumulated amount into predefined or
ure 2. Embedded wealth potential
personalized embedders
investment portfolios, ranging From daily activities to wealth accumulation

The magic happens when embedded savings and

Figure 2. Embedded wealth potential embedders investments operate in tandem. This combination
transforms everyday transactions into wealth-

Retail & Consumer fintech &


accumulation opportunities. Platforms like
challenger banks wealthtech players Acorns exemplify this. In an example touched
on earlier, users spend on routine transactions,
Health insurance the platform rounds up the expenses, and the
Super-apps
providers
spare change is invested in diversified portfolios.
The user’s journey from spending to investing is
frictionless — a seamless financial continuum.
Pension & life
Asset managers
There are several embedded savings and
insurance providers
investments offerings, each looking to deliver
a direct path from daily activities to wealth
accumulation (see Figure 3).
Financial health platforms

Source: Arthur D. Little

EMBEDDED INVESTMENT, EMBEDDED WEALTH 3


VIEWPOINT ARTHUR D. LITTLE

Figure 3. Fintechs offering embedded savings and investment


products
Figure 3. Fintechs offering embedded savings and investment products
Non-exhaustive

1 2 3 4 5 6

Acorns rounds up Combines principles of Allows users to start Primarily a neobank; Provides mobile-based Cross-border payment
purchases to the behavioral economics investing with as little offers automatic savings platform that company turned digital
nearest dollar & saves with automation; users as $5; its Stock-Back savings feature where enables users to link bank introduced the
the difference; takes can set rules or use program is particularly a percentage of every bank accounts & “saving jar” concept in
those savings & invests roundups for savings; innovative: users earn paycheck can be auto- automatically invest 2020 to let users stash
them in diversified saved amounts can be stock pieces as rewards transferred to a savings spare change from excess cash; in 2023,
portfolios, embodying channeled into when they shop at account; although it each transaction in it introduced the
synergy between investment products certain brands, leans more toward gold; saving through concept of “interest”
embedded savings & offered by platform merging spending savings, integration gold investing is an in partnership with
embedded investments with saving/investing with other platforms attractive option for BlackRock: users can
paves the way to people looking to maximize their saving
embedded investments diversify investment returns through
portfolio & protect seamless investment
savings against market into a portfolio of
fluctuations short-term money-

Figure 4. Banks developing or acquiring wealthtech offerings


market instruments

Source: Arthur D. Little

Figure 4. Banks developing or acquiring wealthtech offerings


Non-exhaustive

1 D. Little
Source: Arthur 2 3 4 5

Santander & BlackRock Acquisition of Nutmeg, a Swiss bank partnered with Acquisition of E*Trade lets UAE-based bank launched
agreed to incorporate European robo-advisor, was SigFig to offer digital wealth Morgan Stanley clients take CBD Investr app, becoming
BlackRock’s Aladdin wealth an indication of JP Morgan’s mgmt. services to US-based advantage of E*Trade’s first bank in region to offer
mgmt. services into ambitions to bring digital clients; the two firms agreed digital offering; acquisition robo-advisory investment
Santander's platform; move wealth mgmt. services to to build a joint Advisor is in line with Morgan solution; developed in
expands range of investment clients; at the time of Technology Research and Stanley’s ambitions to partnership with InvestSuite,
solutions for Santander acquisition, JP Morgan Innovation Lab, where the expand wealth mgmt. a leading wealthtech
clients, using BlackRock’s indicated that Nutmeg companies will continually offering across different Belgium company
established capabilities products would complement collaborate on new wealth channels & segments,
those of Chase in the UK mgmt. technology tools expanding scale & breadth

Source: Arthur D. Little

These types of offerings are not limited to neo/ There are various paths, encouraging varied
digital banks and/or fintechs. Increasingly, thinking:
incumbent banks are either partnering with
1. Monetization opportunity. Embedders
wealthtech platforms and/or developing their
can harness new revenue streams, either
own embedded wealth proposition (some through
Source: Arthur D. Little through commissions, subscription fees, or
M&A). Also, this phenomenon is global in nature;
a percentage of assets under management.
prominent examples include Santander, JP
Morgan, UBS, Morgan Stanley, and CBD, among 2. Increased user engagement. Offering

others (see Figure 4). financial services can increase the time a
user spends on a platform, leading to higher
engagement and potentially more revenue
EMBEDDERS ’ OPP OR TUNIT Y
from other channels.

Most embedders (typically nonfinancial 3. Value addition. By providing financial tools,


institutions with direct access to customers and platforms can increase their value proposition,
the necessary level of trust among their target making them indispensable to users.
customers) have been focused on embedding
4. Cross-selling opportunities. Users who
payments, as well as lending and insurance.
adopt embedded wealth tools might be more
Few have genuinely focused on the opportunity
inclined to use other services offered by the
associated with embedded investments.
platform, increasing overall revenue.

EMBEDDED INVESTMENT, EMBEDDED WEALTH 4


VIEWPOINT ARTHUR D. LITTLE

5. User data insights. Access to financial THE GOAL IS TO BLEND


habits can provide invaluable insights into
FINANCIAL DECISIONS
user behavior, which can be leveraged for
personalized marketing or service offerings.
S E A M L E S S LY I N T O
E V E R Y D AY O N L I N E
6. Customer retention. Providing a suite of
services, including financial management,
AC TIVITIES
can create stickiness, reducing the likelihood
of users switching to competitors.

7. Competitive differentiation. In a crowded


- Fitness and health apps. Users reaching
fitness goals could be presented with options
digital marketplace, offering embedded
to “invest” in health insurance or related
wealth services can set a platform apart
financial products.
from competitors.

Most of the rationale listed above is similar


- Gaming platforms. Gamers could be presented
with real-world investment options based on
to reasons for embracing the wider topic of
virtual in-game earnings or achievements.
embedded finance, but the difference lies in the
customer journeys they power — allowing them - Freelance job portals. Platforms like Upwork
to unlock embedded wealth and investments and Fiverr could offer freelancers options
opportunities. Examples include: to invest part of their earnings directly into

-
diverse financial products.
Online shopping. Platforms like Amazon and
Noon could offer investment options based Almost every online interaction or transaction
on amounts saved through discounts or allow (and some offline ones) presents an opportunity
users to invest their cashback rewards. for embedded wealth services, given the right

-
context and a user-centric approach. The goal
Social media platforms. Users on sites
is to blend financial decisions seamlessly into
like Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, and even
everyday online activities, making wealth
Linkedin could be presented with investment
management intuitive and habitual.
options based on their likes, follows, or online
behavior.
CHALLENGES &
- Travel booking portals. Users booking flights
THE ROAD AHE AD
or hotels could invest amount saved from
deals or discounts. The synergy between embedded savings and

- Utility bill payments. Utilities could offer investments is compelling, but the path isn’t devoid

investment suggestions based on monthly of hurdles (see Figure 5). Among several challenges,

savings on utilities. a few showstoppers range from educating and


attracting customers, managing technology (data
- Online subscriptions. Media platforms like
security, scaling, and integration), and building
Netflix and Spotify could provide investment
a profitable business model (finding the right
options proportionate to subscription fees.
partners and designing the right revenue model).
- E-learning platforms. Users could be invited
This list may seem daunting, but a number of
to invest in educational savings plans or
successful players in the domain like Qapital
related financial products.
have navigated these challenges by combining
- Food delivery apps. Apps like Deliveroo, behavioral economics with technology to enable
Jahez, UberEats, and DoorDash could present goal-oriented savings and investments that
investment options based on savings from resonate with user aspirations. Qapital’s success
promotional deals. story should serve as an inspiration to new
companies entering this space.

EMBEDDED INVESTMENT, EMBEDDED WEALTH 5


VIEWPOINT ARTHUR D. LITTLE

Figure 5. Challenges and road ahead

Figure 5. Challenges and road ahead

Market maturity Embedder’s Regulatory compliance Building trust User education


& expectations commitment Global nature of digital Finances are intimate & Although automation is at
Mature markets may already Embedder provides user platforms & diverse users need assurance about heart of embedded finance,
have established financial interface; its commitment regulatory landscapes pose safety of data/money; users must be educated
service providers, making it to success of product significant challenges; transparent operations & about financial choices;
hard for embedded solutions is key ensuring compliance while robust security measures transparent reporting, user-
to find a foothold maintaining efficiency is are essential friendly dashboards &
delicate balancing act financial literacy initiatives
can bridge the gap

Building the “right” Integration complexity Data security & Scaling issues Revenue models
partnerships Integrating robust financial privacy concerns As platforms grow, ensuring Determining how to
Partnership will be long- tools within nonfinancial Users are increasingly same level of service quality, monetize embedded
lasting if it serves all platforms without concerned about data speed & security becomes investment solutions
members, including provider compromising user privacy, especially as it more challenging without alienating users
& embedder experience can be relates to financial can be tricky
technically demanding information

Source: Arthur D. Little

ROLE OF S TAK EHOLDERS 3. Enablers. As the technology backbone, these


companies must ensure robust, secure, and
Source: Arthur D. Little
The embedded finance ecosystem comprises a scalable solutions while staying abreast of
variety of stakeholders, each playing a distinctive financial trends and user behaviors. They are
and significant role (see Figure 6). To make the the glue that holds everything together.
magic happen, stakeholders across the value
4. Banks, traditional wealth managers, and
chain must do their part and do it in tandem:
other financial institutions. Their expertise,
1. Customers. End users stand to gain the most, established trust, and vast resources make
enjoying seamless financial management them invaluable. However, they need to adapt,
and potential wealth accumulation. Their innovate, and collaborate to remain relevant.
feedback, preferences, and trust shape the
5. Regulators. These entities must frame
industry.
guidelines that protect user interests while
2. Embedders. Platforms that integrate savings fostering innovation.
Figure 6. Embedded wealth
and investment participants
tools need to ensure user-
centric design, regulatory compliance, and
continuous innovation.

Figure 6. Embedded wealth participants


Non-exhaustive

Customers Embedders Enablers Providers Government

Non-FIs Fintech Banks Regulators

Govt.-backed
Banks1 Pure-play wealthtechs Wealth mgmt. players
eco developers
Banks Other FIs with
Big tech
(wealth mgmt. arms) wealth products

Other traditional FIs Other traditional FIs

Government Fintech/tech players

Magic makers Product Investors &


User touchpoints
BaaS, money movement, manufacturers alternative
Brand providing finance providers
APIs, verification, Actual financial Investors
products & services also play a role
insights, security, etc. services offering

Note: 1) Banks as embedders is a possibility if bank adopts the role of ecosystem provider and/or orchestrator (beyond banking/lifestyle super-app)
Source: Arthur D. Little

Note: 1) Banks as embedders is a possibility if bank adopts the role of ecosystem provider and/or orchestrator (beyond banking/lifestyle
super-app)
EMBEDDED INVESTMENT, EMBEDDED WEALTH 6
Source: Arthur D. Little
VIEWPOINT ARTHUR D. LITTLE

CONCLUSION

GLIMPSING THE FUTURE

T H E E M B E D D E D W E A LT H P H E N O M E N A
R E F L E C T H O W F U T U R E D I G I TA L I N V E S T M E N T
A N D W E A LT H S E R V I C E S W I L L B E C O N S U M E D

Embedded savings and embedded investments are the dual engines


powering the modern consumer’s financial journey — one accumulates,
the other multiplies, both seamlessly integrate into everyday digital
life. With technologies like artificial intelligence, machine learning,
and blockchain gaining momentum, we can expect hyper-personalized
financial solutions, more diversified investment avenues, and possibly a
convergence of embedded finance components into unified platforms.
As embedded finance permeates more sectors, we can see scenarios in
which smart devices not only facilitate savings but make investment
decisions based on behaviors, preferences, and financial goals.

The embedded wealth phenomena reflect how future digital investment


and wealth services will be consumed. With a market potential of
billions of young, digital-savvy consumers who use their mobile phones
for everyday digital financial services, including digital wealth, financial
institutions and embedders worldwide should not only take note, but
they should also take action.

The journey from the compartmentalized world of traditional finance


to the integrated realm of embedded investments and wealth is a
testament to the transformative power of rapidly emerging technology.
As embedded savings and investments continue to collaborate, they
pave the way for a future where financial growth is an integrated aspect
of our digital existence. For stakeholders, the message is clear: adapt,
collaborate, and innovate to get ready for entwined finance.

EMBEDDED INVESTMENT, EMBEDDED WEALTH 7


Arthur D. Little has been at the forefront of innovation since
1886. We are an acknowledged thought leader in linking
strategy, innovation and transformation in technology-
intensive and converging industries. We navigate our clients
through changing business ecosystems to uncover new growth
opportunities. We enable our clients to build innovation
capabilities and transform their organizations.

Our consultants have strong practical industry experience


combined with excellent knowledge of key trends and dynamics.
ADL is present in the most important business centers around the
world. We are proud to serve most of the Fortune 1000 companies, in
addition to other leading firms and public sector organizations.

For further information, please visit www.adlittle.com.


Copyright © Arthur D. Little – 2023. All rights reserved.

You might also like