Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 14

This copy is for personal use only. To order printed copies, contact reprints@rsna.

org
1131

Imaging Physics
Introduction to the Technical
Aspects of Computed Diffusion-
weighted Imaging for Radiologists
Toru Higaki, PhD
Yuko Nakamura, MD, PhD Diffusion-weighted (DW) imaging is a magnetic resonance (MR)
Fuminari Tatsugami, MD, PhD imaging method. It is an indispensable sequence for the diagnosis
Yoko Kaichi, MD, PhD of acute cerebral infarction and is recognized as a standard tool in
Motonori Akagi, MD oncologic imaging. Computed DW imaging refers to the synthesiz-
Yuij Akiyama, RT ing of arbitrary b-value DW images from a set of measured b-value
Yasutaka Baba, MD, PhD images by voxelwise fitting. Computed DW imaging is advanta-
Makoto Iida, MD, PhD geous because it generates DW images with a higher diffusion effect
Kazuo Awai, MD, PhD than that achievable by using the MR imaging units in use today.
Additionally, computed DW imaging can reduce imaging time
Abbreviations: ADC = apparent diffusion co- while producing images characterized by a higher signal-to-noise
efficient, CNR = contrast-to-noise ratio, DW =
diffusion-weighted, FDG = fluorodeoxyglucose, ratio than what the acquired DW images would display at the cor-
MPG = motion probing gradient, SNR = signal- responding b values. By fitting input images acquired at a lower b
to-noise ratio, TE = echo time
value and correspondingly a shorter echo time, the signal intensity
RadioGraphics 2018; 38:1131–1144 of the resulting computed DW image is closer to the ideal case.
https://doi.org/10.1148/rg.2018170115 Computed DW images are generated by employing mathematical
Content Codes: models that use mono-, bi-, or triexponential equations. To generate
accurate computed DW images, the appropriate model must be se-
From the Department of Diagnostic Radiology,
Hiroshima University, 1-2-3 Kasumi, Minami- lected, and the image parameters for the input data must be chosen
ku, Hiroshima 734-8551, Japan (T.H.,Y.N., F.T., accordingly. In addition, to reduce artifacts on computed DW im-
Y.K, M.A., Y.B., M.I., K.A.); and Department of
Clinical Radiology, Hiroshima University Hospi- ages, the misalignment of input data must be corrected with the aid
tal, Hiroshima, Japan (Y.A.). Presented as an ed- of image registration techniques.
ucation exhibit at the 2016 RSNA Annual Meet-
ing. Received April 28, 2017; revision requested ©
RSNA, 2018 • radiographics.rsna.org
September 8 and received October 6; accepted
October 17. For this journal-based SA-CME ac-
tivity, the author K.A. has provided disclosures
(see end of article); all other authors, the editor,
and the reviewers have disclosed no relevant re-
lationships. Address correspondence to T.H.
Introduction
(e-mail: higaki@hiroshima-u.ac.jp). Diffusion-weighted (DW) imaging is an established magnetic reso-
©
RSNA, 2018
nance (MR) imaging method for whole-body imaging and can be
used to diagnose a wide spectrum of diseases (1–6). For example,
DW imaging is a standard tool for diagnosing ischemic stroke, as dif-
SA-CME Learning Objectives
fusion changes can be observed on DW images and apparent diffu-
After completing this journal-based SA-CME sion coefficient (ADC) maps earlier than with other imaging modali-
activity, participants will be able to:
ties. Analogously, as malignant tumors tend to be characterized by
■■Define the principles of DW imaging.
increased cellularity and typically demonstrate impeded diffusion at
■■Describe the basic theory and advan-
tages of computed DW imaging.
imaging, the signal intensity of malignant lesions on DW images is
■■Identify the clinical uses and applica-
higher than that of the normal parenchyma (1).
tions of computed DW imaging. A crucial parameter used in DW imaging is the b value (7),
See rsna.org/learning-center-rg. which refers to the strength of the motion probing gradient (MPG)
pulse; the contrast ratio on DW images increases as the b value
increases. However, the absolute signal intensity of a DW image is
lower with higher b values, resulting in a decrease in the signal-to-
noise ratio (SNR). Consequently, it is generally difficult to obtain
DW images with ultra-high b values at lower magnetic fields (1).
1132 July-August 2018 radiographics.rsna.org

Figure 1 shows DW images with b values of 0


Teaching Points and 1000 sec/mm2. To calculate the ADC from
■■ By selecting a logarithmic scale for the ordinate axis, Equation Equation 1, at least two DW images obtained at
1 defines a straight line, which is called the monoexponential
model of diffusion. The slope of the straight line corresponds
different b values are required. Typically, an im-
to the ADC. From this step onward, by drawing a straight age with b value equal to 0 and a DW image with
line between the signal intensities measured at two different b high b value are obtained and used as the input
values, it is possible to compute the signal intensity that would data. The ADC can then be calculated by solving
be observed at other arbitrary b values. Equation 1 for D, as shown in Equation 2:
■■ The logarithmic signal intensity curves measured from actual
DW images deviate from linearity at low b values. This phe- Sbi
nomenon is related to tissue microperfusion. Microperfusion ln . (2)
bi
refers to the movement of protons caused by microscopic
blood flow. This motion is macroscopically observed as an
isotropic random motion, and it is not distinguished from a Regarding the image with the b value of 0 (Fig
true diffusion phenomenon when a low b value is observed.
1a), the contrast is similar to that of a T2-
■■ By using input data from an image with a b value of 150 sec/ weighted MR image, with a signal intensity
mm2 or higher, the effect of microperfusion is eliminated, and
defined by Equation 3 (14):
computed DW images can be accurately generated using the
monoexponential model.
TE
■■ Computed DW imaging allows for the calculation of arbitrary , (3)
b-value images by postprocessing after completion of the im- T2
aging examination. This benefits diagnostic ability, as a high
b value results in high lesion contrast. Additionally, increasing where K represents a proportionality coefficient,
the b value through computation can reduce the T2 shine- p represents the proton density, and T2 represents
through effect.
the spin-spin relaxation time. All of those terms
■■ With the computed DW imaging technique, images can be
are constant characteristics of the target tissue.
generated at a short TE with the desired high b value, using a
short TE and low b-value images as the input data.
Echo time (TE) in Equation 3 is determined
by the MR imaging sequence. As TE increases,
the signal intensities on DW images decrease
exponentially owing to the effect of T2 relax-
Computed DW images are synthetic DW ation. As seen in Equation 3, a longer TE corre-
images, which are calculated from measured sponds to a lower SNR on DW images and thus
DW images acquired at arbitrarily selected low b a decrease in image quality (15). Furthermore,
values by voxelwise fitting (8,9). Computed DW the superimposed T2-weighted contrast mate-
imaging is advantageous because it generates rial contaminates the “pure” diffusion signal
DW images with a higher diffusion effect than because the T2 relaxation progresses as the TE
those obtained at MR imaging (10). In addition, is extended. This phenomenon is called the T2
computed DW imaging can reduce imaging time shine-through effect, and it requires special atten-
while producing images with a higher SNR than tion because it may produce false-positive high-
those of the measured DW images acquired at intensity areas (ie, a high diffusion signal that is
the corresponding b values (8,9,11–13). unrelated to diffusion restriction) (1,12,16,17).
In this article, we introduce the theoretical While a short TE is ideal, the duration of the
framework of DW imaging and computed DW MPG pulse required to obtain a high b value
imaging and the application of computed DW im- causes it to be prolonged.
aging in the clinical setting. We also present clinical
images obtained at computed DW imaging. Generating Computed DW Images
Understanding DW Imaging Monoexponential Diffusion Model
The basic mechanism underlying the relationship Figure 2 shows the results of Equation 1, where
between the signal intensity on DW images and Sb0 is defined as 1000 sec/mm2 and D as 2.0 ×
the b value is expressed in Equation 1 (7–10): 10−3 (teal line) and again where Sb0 is defined as
750 sec/mm2 and D as 0.5 × 10−3 (purple line).
Sbi bi , (1) By selecting a logarithmic scale for the or-
dinate axis, Equation 1 defines a straight line,
where bi represents the b value, Sb0 represents the which is called the monoexponential model of
signal intensity without diffusion weighting (b = diffusion (1,18,19). The slope of the straight line
0), Sbi represents the signal intensity at bi, and D corresponds to the ADC. From this step onward,
is the apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC). The by drawing a straight line between the signal
signal intensity on DW images decreases expo- intensities measured at two different b values, it
nentially as the b value increases. is possible to compute the signal intensity that
RG • Volume 38 Number 4 Higaki et al 1133

Figure 1. DW images of the brain. (a) Axial


DW image of the brain demonstrates a b value
of 0 sec/mm2, without an MPG pulse. (b) Axial
DW image of the brain demonstrates a b value of
1000 sec/mm2. (c) Axial ADC map demonstrates
the calculation of a pair of DW images. Typically,
an image with a b value of 0 is obtained with the
DW image with high b value to calculate the ADC.

would be observed at other arbitrary b values.


This is the fundamental theory behind computed
DW imaging (8,9,12,13,16,20).
Figure 3 shows a flow diagram illustrating
the computed DW imaging generation process.
First, the value of D is calculated from the signal
intensity measured at two b values (b0 = 0 and
600 sec/mm2) using Equation 2. Next, the signal
intensity of the computed DW image (Sbi) is
calculated using Equation 1, using as input data
the signal intensity measured at a b value of 0
(Sb0), the arbitrary target b value (bx), and the
Figure 2. Signal intensity curves of DW imaging. Equation ADC value calculated in the first step. By per-
1 defines a straight line on the graph, Sb0 corresponds to the forming these computational steps for all pixels,
intersection of the lines, and D corresponds to the slope of
computed DW images are generated. In Figure
the lines.
3, an example of a computed DW image gener-
ated with the target b value of 1000 sec/mm2 is
shown as the output image.
1134 July-August 2018 radiographics.rsna.org

Figure 3. Flow chart shows the generation process of an axial computed DW image. In Step 1 (teal line), the ADC values are calcu-
lated from signal intensities measured at two b values using Equation 2. In Step 2 (purple line), the signal intensity of the computed
DW image at the arbitrary target b value (bx) is calculated using Equation 1, using the measured signal intensity of b0 and the ADC
value calculated in step 1.

Figure 4. Graph shows the signal intensity curves


of multiple tissues obtained from an abdominal DW
image. The measured signal intensity curves devi-
ate from linearity at a low b value owing to the mi-
croperfusion of the tissues.

Equation 1 can be generalized using an arbi-


trary low b value data point in place of S0 (12) to
create Equation 4:

Sbi bi , (4)

where Sb1 is the signal intensity at the b value of b1.


This means that the calculation of a computed DW
image does not require an image with a b value of 0,
and any combination of two b values can be used as
input data for the computed DW imaging process.
At low b values, the effects of microperfusion
Biexponential Diffusion Model and true diffusion cannot be separated, and each
The graph seen in Figure 4 shows signal inten- impacts the signal intensity (1,18). At a b value of
sity plots, generated using the logarithmic scale about 150–250 sec/mm2 or higher, the effect of
described previously, of healthy abdominal or- microperfusion is eliminated, and only true diffu-
gans obtained from measured DW images. The sion contributes to the signal intensity (1,21–23).
key observation is that the logarithmic signal Curves modeling the effect of both microperfu-
intensity curves measured from actual DW im- sion and true diffusion can be generated with a
ages deviate from linearity at low b values. This combination of straight lines, as shown in Equa-
phenomenon is related to tissue microperfusion tion 5 and plotted in Figure 5:
(7,18,19). Microperfusion refers to the move-
ment of protons caused by microscopic blood Sbi 1 bi
flow. This motion is macroscopically observed bi , (5)
as an isotropic random motion, and it is not
distinguished from a true diffusion phenomenon where f is the diffusion fraction component and D*
when a low b value is observed (19). is the microperfusion-related diffusion coefficient.
RG • Volume 38 Number 4 Higaki et al 1135

require the input data from several acquired im-


ages. However, this problem can be more easily
solved by using data from a low b value input im-
age (b ≥ 150 sec/mm2). This strategy ensures that
the relationship between the b value and the signal
intensity remains linear (1,21–23). Therefore, by
using input data from an image with a b value of
150 sec/mm2 or higher, the effect of microperfu-
sion is eliminated, and computed DW images can
be accurately generated using the monoexponen-
tial model, described in Equation 4.
Figure 7 shows a comparison between com-
puted DW images, generated from input images
Figure 5. Graph shows the signal intensity curve of the biex- with b values of 0 and 150 sec/mm2. In a com-
ponential model of diffusion. The biexponential curve is dem-
puted DW image generated from the b values of
onstrated by the sum of two straight lines.
a 600 and 0 sec/mm2 input data pair, the signal
intensity of the normal liver parenchyma deviates
from that which is observed on the measured DW
image. Particularly in the right lobe of the liver,
the signal intensity of the normal liver paren-
chyma appears lower than on the measured DW
image. This is the result of the overestimation of
the ADC value because the image with a b valve
of 0 sec/mm2 was used as an input image.
On the computed DW image generated from
the 600 and 150 sec/mm2 b-value input pair, the
signal intensity appears to be similar to that of
the measured DW image. It is depicted as the
low signal intensity region on the color map
inset images (Fig 7).
Figure 6. Graph shows the effect of the microperfusion com-
ponent when b is defined as 0 sec/mm2 and is used as input
data. If the slope of the line (ADC) is calculated from b val-
Triexponential Diffusion Model
ues of 600 and 0 sec/mm2, it will be overestimated owing to The Figure 8 graph plots the signal intensity
microperfusion. curves of normal brain tissues measured on
actual DW images using the logarithmic scale.
Expanding the b-value range to 4000 sec/mm2
When b1 is defined as 0, Equation 5 can be adds an additional inflection point along the in-
rewritten to create Equation 6: tensity curve. This curve should be fitted by the
Sbi bi combination of three straight lines, as described
bi . (6) in Equation 7. This is called the triexponential
model of diffusion (28–31):
Equations 5 and 6 are generally referred to as
biexponential models of diffusion (24–27). The data Sbi fp bi Dp
from at least four input images are necessary to ff bi Df
solve these equations and generate the computed
DW image. fs bi Ds , (7)
With the monoexponential model, choosing a
DW image with a b value of 0 as one of the input where fp and Dp represent the perfusion-related
images may result in overestimation of the slope diffusion fraction and coefficient, ff and Df rep-
of the straight line D owing to the effect of the resent the fast-free diffusion fraction and coef-
microperfusion component (Fig 6) (1,22,23,25). ficient, and fs and Ds represent the slow-restricted
If the computed DW image is generated under diffusion fraction and coefficient. Equation 7 can
this condition, the signal intensity of the image be simplified to Equation 8 when choosing b1
will significantly deviate from the actual value. defined as 0:
Although this problem can be solved by gen-
Sbi fp bi Dp
erating a computed DW image using Equation 5,
this comes at the cost of a much more complicated ff bi D f
mathematical model and more importantly would fs bi D s . (8)
1136 July-August 2018 radiographics.rsna.org

Figure 7. Comparison of axial computed DW images gener-


ated from b-value pairs (600 and 0 sec/mm2; 600 and 150
sec/mm2) using the monoexponential model described in
Equation 4, with corresponding axial DW color map insets.
(a) Computed DW image (cDWI) demonstrates a b value of
1000 sec/mm2, generated from input images with b defined
as 600 and 0 sec/mm2. (b) Computed DW image demon-
strates a b value of 1000 sec/mm2, generated from input im-
ages with b values of 600 and 150 sec/mm2. (c) DW image
demonstrates a b value of 1000 sec/mm2. In the computed
DW images generated from the input image pair where b is
defined as 600 and 0 sec/mm2 (a), the signal intensity of the
normal liver parenchyma (red oval in a–c) deviates from that
of the actual DW image (c). This is the result of ADC value
overestimation owing to the use of the input image where
b is defined as 0 sec/mm2. DWI = diffusion-weighted image.

When generating an ultra-high b-value computed


DW image (b > 2000 sec/mm2), the triexponen-
tial model should be used (32,33).
The triexponential model requires at least six
input images to solve the equation; however, as
is the case with the biexponential model, one can
ignore the effect of microperfusion by using an im-
age with a b value of 150 sec/mm2 or higher as the
low b-value input. As a result, Equation 7 can be
further simplified to Equation 9:
Sbi ff bi Df
fs bi Ds . (9)
Figure 8. Graph shows the signal intensity curves of brain tis-
Equation 9 is a biexponential model and can be sues obtained from a DW image. An additional inflection point
appears along the curves around b value 1500–2500 sec/mm2.
solved with data from four input images. This CSF = cerebrospinal fluid, GM = gray matter, WM = white matter.
allows for the generation of ultra-high b-value
computed DW images.
sity curve is a straight line on the semilogarithmic
Optimal b-Value Selection graph (34). In the case of the multiexponential
models, the number of b values required is depen-
b Values and Input Images.—In the case of a dent on the explicit expression of the model for-
monoexponential model requiring two input im- mula being used. In general, the SNR of the DW
ages with different b values, it is necessary to select image obtained with a low b value is higher, as the
the two points in the region where the signal inten- TE can be shortened. It is also possible to reduce
RG • Volume 38 Number 4 Higaki et al 1137

the influence of noise when estimating the slope pixel value of Sbi or Sb0 approaches 0 asymptoti-
by increasing the interval between the b values. cally, the ADC value asymptotically approaches
negative infinity or positive infinity. When the
Target b Value.—A high b value enhances the ADC value is ± infinity, artifacts can be reduced
contrast of the lesion, whereas the SNR of the by setting the output pixel value to 0.
image decreases. The optimal b value is dependent
on the organ being imaged (8,9). In many cases, a Clinical Advantages of Computed
value that is slightly higher than that used during DW Imaging
the routine examination is selected (11,13,16,20). One of the advantages of using computed DW
imaging is that the b value can be changed arbi-
Misalignment between Input Images trarily. In particular, even at low magnetic fields,
When generating computed DW images, it is at which it is difficult to acquire high b-value
necessary to correct morphologic misalignment DW images, such images can be generated by
between the input images. Because computed computation.
DW images are calculated voxelwise from the sig- In general, computed DW imaging allows for
nal intensity of matching voxel positions in each the calculation of arbitrary b-value images by
input image, each voxel should be acquired from postprocessing after completion of the imag-
the same location in the patient’s body. ing examination (8,9). This benefits diagnostic
Among the several causes of misalignment dur- ability, as a high b value results in high lesion
ing imaging, one is gross motion during the exam- contrast. Additionally, increasing the b value
ination. Even if the patient’s body is stationary, the through computation can reduce the T2 shine-
position of the organ may shift during imaging ow- through effect. However, it is important to note
ing to the patient’s heartbeat or breathing (35–37). that the b value cannot be increased infinitely. As
The influence of cardiac pulsation is apparent on shown in Equation 1, signal intensity decreases
the arterial vasculature, and it has a nonnegligible as the b value increases; if the b value is set too
effect, especially on high b-value images, which are high, the SNR drops, resulting in considerable
sensitive to microscopic motion. image quality degradation.
Another cause of image misalignment is the Another benefit of computed DW imaging is
distortion associated with magnetic field inho- the use of a shorter TE. As described previously,
mogeneities, which can be caused by factors signal intensity decreases as the TE increases,
such as the patient’s magnetic susceptibility and causing the SNR on DW images to drop. In
the eddy current derived from the MPG pulses addition, extending TE elicits T2 shine-through
(37,38). The MPG pulse generates eddy currents effects, potentially causing false-positive high-in-
in various metallic components of the MR imag- tensity lesions to be diagnosed (16). TE elonga-
ing unit, resulting in unpredictable magnetic field tion is associated with the long duration of the
inhomogeneities that can distort DW images. MPG pulse required to obtain a high b-value
Image registration algorithms provide an effi- image. With the computed DW imaging tech-
cient tool to correct misalignments (39–43). Image nique, images can be generated at a short TE
registration is the process of transforming different with the desired high b value, using a short TE
images into the same coordinate system. Available and low b-value images as the input data.
image registration methods are rigid, affine, and
deformable registration. Such algorithms are clas- Improving Contrast-to-Noise Ratio
sified on the basis of the difference in the method There are two ways to improve the contrast-to-
applied for transforming the image (44,45). The noise ratio (CNR) on DW images, as described
registration algorithms can also be classified on the previously. The first is to shorten the TE to
basis of the method used to calculate the degree reduce image noise by inputting images with low
of alignment between images, including the sum b values. The second way to improve CNR is to
(mean) of squared difference (46), mutual infor- increase the b value of the generated computed
mation (42,43), and the correlation coefficient DW image to increase the contrast between
(40,41). Figure 9 shows computed DW images normal tissue and the lesion (48).
with and without misalignment correction. Figures 10–12 show cases in which the CNR
is improved by using computed DW imaging.
Removing Outlier Pixel Values Figure 10 shows a patient with acute isch-
During the computed DW imaging generation emic stroke; Figure 11 shows brain images of
process, outlier pixel values may appear. Such a healthy subject; and Figure 12 shows images
pixels arise from image noise or artifacts in the obtained in a patient with prostate cancer.
input images and result in artifacts on computed In the case of a patient with acute ischemic
DW images. For example, in Equation 2, if the stroke (Fig 10), it would have been desirable to
1138 July-August 2018 radiographics.rsna.org

Figure 9. Reduction of artifacts (arrowheads) in axial com-


puted DW images and ADC maps, with and without misalign-
ment correction. (a, b) Computed DW image (b = 1000 sec/
mm2) (a) and ADC map (b) generated without image registra-
tion show artifacts. (c, d) Computed DW image (b = 1000 sec/
mm2) (c) and ADC map (d) generated with image registration
show a reduction in the depiction of the artifacts. (e) DW im-
age (b =1000 sec/mm2) shows a reference standard DW image.
A b-spline based deformable image registration algorithm with
mutual information was applied using 3D Slicer (version 4.6.2,
www.slicer.org) software (47). By performing the deformable
image registration, the artifacts that appeared at the border of
the organs have been reduced.

use the triexponential model (Eq 7 or 9) to gen-


erate ultra-high b-value computed DW images,
but that was not possible because an insufficient
number of input images were obtained. Conse-
quently, on the computed DW image (Fig 10a),
the normal brain tissue appears atrophic. In Figure 11, the measured DW image ap-
Nonetheless, the area of infarction is shown pears noisy, but this effect is reduced on the
more clearly on the computed DW image than computed DW image. Because computed DW
on the measured DW image obtained on day 0. images are generated from low b-value images
The infarcted area shown on the computed DW and use a shorter TE compared with that of the
image obtained on day 0 (Fig 10a) matches that measured DW images, the noise of the computed
on the measured DW image obtained on day 2 DW image is suppressed, improving the SNR on
(Fig 10c), demonstrating that early lesions can the computed DW image. The signal intensity of
clearly be depicted on computed DW images. gray matter is higher on the computed DW image
RG • Volume 38 Number 4 Higaki et al 1139

Figure 10. Lesion (arrowhead) depiction on


axial computed DW and DW images in a 67-year-
old man with acute ischemic stroke. (a) Com-
puted DW image (cDWI) demonstrates a target b
value of 3000 sec/mm2, obtained on day 0 and
generated from input DW images with b values of
1000 and 0 sec/mm2, using the monoexponential
model. ms = msec. (b) DW image (DWI) demon-
strates a b value of 1000 sec/mm2, obtained on
day 0. (c) DW image demonstrates a b value of
1000 sec/mm2, obtained on day 2. The area of in-
farction is depicted more clearly on the computed
DW image (a) than on the actual DW image ob-
tained on day 0 (b). This observation corresponds
with the actual DW image obtained on day 2 (c).
Early lesions are clearly depicted on the computed
DW image.

Figure 11. Brain images of a healthy 34-year-old male subject. (a) Axial computed DW image shows the
brain, obtained with a target b value of 4000 sec/mm2 and a TE of 98 msec. This image was generated from
input images with b values of 250, 750, 1250, and 2000 sec/mm2, using the biexponential model described
in Equation 9. (b) Axial DW image shows the brain, obtained with a b value of 4000 sec/mm2 and a TE of
122 msec. The DW image appears noisy, but this effect is reduced on the computed DW image.
1140 July-August 2018 radiographics.rsna.org

Figure 12. Lesion depiction in a 77-year-old man with prostate cancer. (a) Axial T2-weighted MR image (T2WI) of the
prostate shows a lesion (arrowheads). (b) Axial DW image (DWI) obtained with a b value of 2000 sec/mm2 shows the
lesion (arrowheads). Dashed square = area of interest magnified in c. (c) Axial computed DW images (cDWI) with pro-
gressively increasing b value application show the lesion. The signal intensity of the lesion increases with the increasing b
values, resulting in clear lesion depiction (arrowhead) at 2000 sec/mm2. The images were generated from input images
with b values of 0 and 1000 sec/mm2, using the monoexponential model. The target b values for the computed DW im-
ages ranged from 200 to 2000 sec/mm2.

(Fig 11a) compared to that of the measured DW false-positive high-intensity lesion. Figures 13–15
image (Fig 11b) because the effect of the T2 demonstrate to what extent the T2 shine-through
relaxation is decreased by using a shorter TE. effect is reduced by using computed DW imaging.
In Figure 12, the signal intensity of the lesion in- Figure 13 shows images obtained in a patient with
creases with the application of progressively higher multiple hepatic cysts; Figure 14 shows images
b values, resulting in clearer lesion depiction. The obtained in a patient with hepatic metastasis from
diagnostic ability of computed DW imaging when colon cancer; and Figure 15 shows images ob-
applied to prostate cancer has been reported to tained in a patient with brain metastasis.
improve by increasing the b value (11,13,20). In Figure 13b, the hepatic cysts appear as
high-intensity lesions. However, the ADC map
Eliminating T2 Shine-Through Effect (Fig 13c) does not display diffusion restric-
The computed DW imaging technique makes it tion for these lesions, which is thought to be
possible to generate computed DW images with attributable to the T2 shine-through effect. By
a short TE and a high b value by relying on input generating a computed DW image with a b value
images meeting these requirements. A shorter of 1500 sec/mm2, the lesions can be correctly
TE and/or high b value eliminates the T2 shine- evaluated without referring to the ADC map.
through effect that may result in the depiction of a Nakamura et al (16) reported the usefulness of
RG • Volume 38 Number 4 Higaki et al 1141

Figure 13. Hepatic cysts in a 74-year-old woman. (a) Axial computed DW image (cDWI) shows the hepatic cysts (arrowheads),
imaged with a target b value of 1500 sec/mm2, generated from input DW images with b values of 600 and 150 sec/mm2, using the
monoexponential model. ms = msec. (b) Axial DW image (DWI) shows the hepatic cysts (arrowheads) as high-intensity lesions, imaged
with a b value of 1000 sec/mm2. (c) Axial ADC map shows the hepatic cysts. By generating a computed DW image with a b value of
1500 sec/mm2, the lesions can be correctly evaluated without referring to the ADC map.

computed DW imaging for imaging noncompli- Although the theory underlying computed DW
cated hepatic cysts. imaging is simple, there are several important key
In Figure 14b, the tumor appears as a uniform aspects that should be observed. Most notably,
lesion on the measured DW image with a b value when computed DW images with ultra-high b
of 600 sec/mm2. On the computed DW image, values are generated, accurate images can be ob-
only the edges of the lesion display high signal tained only by applying the triexponential model.
intensity, as the signal intensity in the necrotic Even for the generation of lower b-value com-
region decreases with reduced T2 shine-though puted DW images, the appropriate computation
effect. This matches the pattern of FDG PET models must be combined with carefully chosen
uptake (Fig 14d). b values for the input DW images. Computed
In Figure 15, on the measured DW image, the DW imaging falls in the category of synthetic
edematous region exhibits isointense signal com- MR imaging, which has had growing visibility
pared with that of the surrounding region; this is in recent years. For the widespread application
thought to be due to the T2 shine-through effect. of computed DW imaging, the framework of
Since the TE is short on the computed DW im- synthetic MR imaging may be helpful for the ef-
age, the T2 shine-through effect is reduced, and ficient acquisition of input images.
the signal intensity of the edema decreases.
Disclosures of Conflicts of Interest.—K.A. Activities related
Conclusion to the present article: disclosed no relevant interests. Activities
not related to the present article: research grants from Toshiba
Computed DW imaging allows for the genera- Medical Systems, Hitachi HealthCare, Fujitsu, Eisai, Daiichi
tion of new contrast images at postprocessing. Sankyo, Bayer Yakuhin, and Fuji Yakuhin; member of the
1142 July-August 2018 radiographics.rsna.org

Figure 14. Hepatic metastasis (arrowhead) in a 79-year-old woman. (a) Axial computed DW image (cDWI) shows the hepatic metas-
tasis with high signal intensity around the edges (b = 1500 sec/mm2). The image was generated from input DW images with b values
of 600 and 0 sec/mm2, using the monoexponential model. ms = msec. (b) Axial DW image (DWI) shows a uniform lesion, imaged with
a b value of 600 sec/mm2. (c) Axial gadolinium ethoxybenzyl–enhanced hepatobiliary phase MR image shows the hepatic metastasis.
(d) Axial fluorine 18 fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) positron emission tomography (PET) color-mapped fusion image shows the hepatic
metastasis. The signal intensity of the tumor on the computed DW image (a) matches the pattern of FDG PET uptake.

Figure 15. T2 shine-through effect in a 75-year-old woman with brain metastasis. (a) Axial computed DW image (cDWI) of the
brain shows edema with low signal intensity, obtained with a target b value of 4000 sec/mm2. The image was generated from input
images with b values of 250, 750, 1250, and 2000 sec/mm2, using the biexponential model (Eq 9). ms = msec. (b) Axial DW image
(DWI) (b = 4000 sec/mm2) shows the edema with iso–signal intensity compared with that of the surrounding region, thought to be
due to the T2 shine-through effect. (c) Axial ADC map of the brain shows the edema. Since the TE on the computed DW image (a)
is short, the T2 shine-through effect is reduced, and the signal intensity of the edema decreases.
RG • Volume 38 Number 4 Higaki et al 1143

Medical Advisory Board for GE Healthcare. Other activities: nance imaging for prostate cancer diagnosis. Eur Radiol
disclosed no relevant relationships. 2013;23(12):3509–3516.
21. Barral M, Taouli B, Guiu B, et al. Diffusion-weighted MR
imaging of the pancreas: current status and recommendations.
References Radiology 2015;274(1):45–63.
1. Koh DM, Collins DJ. Diffusion-weighted MRI in the body: 22. Kallehauge JF, Tanderup K, Haack S, et al. Apparent diffusion
applications and challenges in oncology. AJR Am J Roentgenol coefficient (ADC) as a quantitative parameter in diffusion
2007;188(6):1622–1635. weighted MR imaging in gynecologic cancer: dependence
2. Schaefer PW, Grant PE, Gonzalez RG. Diffusion-weighted on b-values used. Acta Oncol 2010;49(7):1017–1022.
MR imaging of the brain. Radiology 2000;217(2):331–345. 23. Karki K, Hugo GD, Ford JC, et al. Estimation of optimal
3. Hagmann P, Jonasson L, Maeder P, Thiran JP, Wedeen b-value sets for obtaining apparent diffusion coefficient free
VJ, Meuli R. Understanding diffusion MR imaging tech- from perfusion in non-small cell lung cancer. Phys Med Biol
niques: from scalar diffusion-weighted imaging to diffusion 2015;60(20):7877–7891.
tensor imaging and beyond. RadioGraphics 2006;26(suppl 24. Le Bihan D, Turner R, Moonen CT, Pekar J. Imaging of
1):S205–S223. diffusion and microcirculation with gradient sensitization:
4. González RG, Schaefer PW, Buonanno FS, et al. Diffusion- design, strategy, and significance. J Magn Reson Imaging
weighted MR imaging: diagnostic accuracy in patients 1991;1(1):7–28.
imaged within 6 hours of stroke symptom onset. Radiology 25. Dijkstra H, Baron P, Kappert P, Oudkerk M, Sijens PE. Ef-
1999;210(1):155–162. fects of microperfusion in hepatic diffusion weighted imaging.
5. Srinivasan A, Goyal M, Al Azri F, Lum C. State-of-the-art Eur Radiol 2012;22(4):891–899.
imaging of acute stroke. RadioGraphics 2006;26(suppl 26. Chandarana H, Lee VS, Hecht E, Taouli B, Sigmund EE.
1):S75–S95. Comparison of biexponential and monoexponential model
6. Rajeshkannan R, Moorthy S, Sreekumar KP, Rupa R, Prabhu of diffusion weighted imaging in evaluation of renal lesions:
NK. Clinical applications of diffusion weighted MR imaging: preliminary experience. Invest Radiol 2011;46(5):285–291.
a review. Indian J Radiol Imaging 2006;16(4):705–710. 27. Lin M, Yu X, Chen Y, et al. Contribution of mono-expo-
7. Le Bihan D, Breton E, Lallemand D, Grenier P, Cabanis nential, bi-exponential and stretched exponential model-
E, Laval-Jeantet M. MR imaging of intravoxel incoherent based diffusion-weighted MR imaging in the diagnosis and
motions: application to diffusion and perfusion in neurologic differentiation of uterine cervical carcinoma. Eur Radiol
disorders. Radiology 1986;161(2):401–407. 2017;27(6):2400–2410.
8. Blackledge MD, Leach MO, Collins DJ, Koh DM. Com- 28. Hayashi T, Miyati T, Takahashi J, et al. Diffusion analysis
puted diffusion-weighted MR imaging may improve tumor with triexponential function in liver cirrhosis. J Magn Reson
detection. Radiology 2011;261(2):573–581. Imaging 2013;38(1):148–153.
9. Blackledge MD, Wilton B, Messiou C, Koh DM, Leach MO, 29. Hayashi T, Miyati T, Takahashi J, et al. Diffusion analysis
Collins DJ. Computed diffusion weighted imaging (cDWI) with triexponential function in hepatic steatosis. Radiol Phys
for improving imaging contrast (abstr). In: Proceedings of the Technol 2014;7(1):89–94.
Seventeenth Meeting of the International Society for Magnetic 30. Ueda Y, Takahashi S, Ohno N, et al. Triexponential function
Resonance in Medicine. Berkeley, Calif: International Society analysis of diffusion-weighted MRI for diagnosing prostate
for Magnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2009; 4005. cancer. J Magn Reson Imaging 2016;43(1):138–148.
10. Kawahara S, Isoda H, Fujimoto K, et al. Additional benefit of 31. Cercueil JP, Petit JM, Nougaret S, et al. Intravoxel incoherent
computed diffusion-weighted imaging for detection of hepatic motion diffusion-weighted imaging in the liver: comparison
metastases at 1.5T. Clin Imaging 2016;40(3):481–485. of mono-, bi- and tri-exponential modelling at 3.0-T. Eur
11. Maas MC, Fütterer JJ, Scheenen TW. Quantitative Radiol 2015;25(6):1541–1550.
evaluation of computed high b value diffusion-weighted 32. Hu YC, Yan LF, Sun Q, et al. Comparison between ultra-
magnetic resonance imaging of the prostate. Invest Radiol high and conventional mono b-value DWI for preoperative
2013;48(11):779–786. glioma grading. Oncotarget 2017;8(23):37884–37895.
12. Gatidis S, Schmidt H, Martirosian P, Nikolaou K, Schwenzer 33. Xueying L, Zhongping Z, Zhoushe Z, et al. Investigation
NF. Apparent diffusion coefficient-dependent voxelwise com- of apparent diffusion coefficient from ultra-high b-values in
puted diffusion-weighted imaging: an approach for improving Parkinson’s disease. Eur Radiol 2015;25(9):2593–2600.
SNR and reducing T2 shine-through effects. J Magn Reson 34. Ogura A, Koyama D, Hayashi N, Hatano I, Osakabe K,
Imaging 2016;43(4):824–832. Yamaguchi N. Optimal b values for generation of com-
13. Yoshida R, Yoshizako T, Katsube T, Tamaki Y, Ishikawa puted high-b-value DW images. AJR Am J Roentgenol
N, Kitagaki H. Computed diffusion-weighted imaging us- 2016;206(4):713–718.
ing 1.5-T magnetic resonance imaging for prostate cancer 35. Pang Y, Yu B, Zhang X. Hepatic fat assessment using ad-
diagnosis. Clin Imaging 2017;41:78–82. vanced magnetic resonance imaging. Quant Imaging Med
14. Bammer R. Basic principles of diffusion-weighted imaging. Surg 2012;2(3):213–218.
Eur J Radiol 2003;45(3):169–184. 36. Kandpal H, Sharma R, Madhusudhan KS, Kapoor KS.
15. Holdsworth SJ, Yeom KW, Antonucci MU, et al. Diffusion- Respiratory-triggered versus breath-hold diffusion-weighted
weighted imaging with dual-echo echo-planar imaging for MRI of liver lesions: comparison of image quality and ap-
better sensitivity to acute stroke. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol parent diffusion coefficient values. AJR Am J Roentgenol
2014;35(7):1293–1302. 2009;192(4):915–922.
16. Nakamura Y, Higaki T, Akiyama Y, et al. Diffusion-weighted 37. Chilla GS, Tan CH, Xu C, Poh CL. Diffusion weighted
MR imaging of non-complicated hepatic cysts: value of 3T magnetic resonance imaging and its recent trend: a survey.
computed diffusion-weighted imaging. Eur J Radiol Open Quant Imaging Med Surg 2015;5(3):407–422.
2016;3:138–144. 38. Andre JB, Bammer R. Advanced diffusion-weighted magnetic
17. Feuerlein S, Pauls S, Juchems MS, et al. Pitfalls in abdomi- resonance imaging techniques of the human spinal cord. Top
nal diffusion-weighted imaging: how predictive is restricted Magn Reson Imaging 2010;21(6):367–378.
water diffusion for malignancy. AJR Am J Roentgenol 39. Arlinghaus LR, Welch EB, Chakravarthy AB, et al. Motion
2009;193(4):1070–1076. correction in diffusion-weighted MRI of the breast at 3T. J
18. Koh DM, Collins DJ, Orton MR. Intravoxel incoherent mo- Magn Reson Imaging 2011;33(5):1063–1070.
tion in body diffusion-weighted MRI: reality and challenges. 40. deSouza NM, Orton M, Downey K, et al. Distortion cor-
AJR Am J Roentgenol 2011;196(6):1351–1361. rection of echo-planar diffusion-weighted images of uterine
19. Le Bihan D, Breton E, Lallemand D, Aubin ML, Vignaud cervix. J Magn Reson Imaging 2016;43(5):1218–1223.
J, Laval-Jeantet M. Separation of diffusion and perfusion 41. Hancu I, Lee SK, Hulsey K, et al. Distortion correction
in intravoxel incoherent motion MR imaging. Radiology in diffusion-weighted imaging of the breast: performance
1988;168(2):497–505. assessment of prospective, retrospective, and combined
20. Ueno Y, Takahashi S, Kitajima K, et al. Computed (prospective + retrospective) approaches. Magn Reson Med
diffusion-weighted imaging using 3-T magnetic reso- 2017;78(1):247–253.
1144 July-August 2018 radiographics.rsna.org

42. Mazaheri Y, Do RK, Shukla-Dave A, Deasy JO, Lu Y, Akin 46. Higaki T, Kaneda K, Tamaki T, Date N, Azemoto S. Non-
O. Motion correction of multi-b-value diffusion-weighted rigid image registration for medical diagnosis using free-form
imaging in the liver. Acad Radiol 2012;19(12):1573–1580. deformation with multiple grids. J Inst Image Electron Eng
43. Liu W, Liu X, Yang G, et al. Improving the correction of Japan 2007;37(3):286–292.
eddy current-induced distortion in diffusion-weighted images 47. Kapur T, Pieper S, Fedorov A, et al. Increasing the impact
by excluding signals from the cerebral spinal fluid. Comput of medical image computing using community-based open-
Med Imaging Graph 2012;36(7):542–551. access hackathons: the NA-MIC and 3D Slicer experience.
44. Maintz JB, Viergever MA. A survey of medical image registra- Med Image Anal 2016;33:176–180.
tion. Med Image Anal 1998;2(1):1–36. 48. Blackledge MD, Collins DJ, Koh DM, Leach MO. Signal
45. Zitová B, Flusser J. Image registration methods: a survey. to noise ratio of high b-value diffusion weighted images is
Image Vis Comput 2003;21(11):977–1000. improved using computed diffusion weighted imaging [abstr].
In: Proceedings of the Eighteenth Meeting of the International
Society for Magnetic Resonance in Medicine. Berkeley, Calif:
International Society for Magnetic Resonance in Medicine,
2010; 4707.

TM
This journal-based SA-CME activity has been approved for AMA PRA Category 1 Credit . See rsna.org/learning-center-rg.

You might also like