Oup Supporting Refugees Author SP

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 30

Supporting

refugees
A PRIMER FOR LANGUAGE TEACHERS

Professor Hayo Reinders


Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

ABSTRACT
In recent years, many language teachers have
experienced having one or more refugee
learners in their classes. Such learners often
have specific educational, social, and affective
needs, which many teachers feel they are ill-
equipped to deal with. This position paper is
written with such teachers in mind, particularly
those who have not received specialized
training in teaching refugee learners.

The paper begins by summarizing what is necessary systems are in place to provide
known about the particular challenges these assistance to all relevant stakeholders,
learners face, the challenges their teachers including parents, the wider community,
experience, and the positive impact the funding and charitable organizations, and
presence of refugee learners can have on government agencies.
the classroom and the wider organization.
This position paper includes practical
Next, it presents a number of pedagogical
resources for teachers and their
practices that teachers can draw on to best
organizations to learn more about the topic
serve the needs of these learners. Finally,
and ‘prompt cards’ designed to encourage
the paper examines the organizational
reflection and discussion in the preparation
adjustments and preparations needed to
and support process.
ensure that teachers are supported and the
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

CONTENTS
Refugees in language education 02
Supporting refugees 06
Teaching refugees 12
Conclusion 18
Resources and references 24

Hayo Reinders (www.innovationinteaching.org) is TESOL Professor and Director of Research


at Anaheim University, USA, and Professor of Applied Linguistics at KMUTT in Thailand. He is
founder of the global Institute for Teacher Leadership and editor of Innovation in Language
Learning and Teaching. His interests are in out-of-class learning, technology, and language
teacher leadership. Hayo is the author of this paper.

01
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

REFUGEES IN
LANGUAGE EDUCATION
According to the United Nations Refugee
Agency (UNHCR; Batalova, 2022), 103 million
people worldwide have been forced to flee
their homes due to conflicts, violence, fear
of persecution, and human rights violations.
This is more than double the 42.7 million
people who were forcibly displaced a decade
ago and the most since World War II.

The largest numbers of people seeking refuge across borders come


from Venezuela, Syria, Afghanistan, and South Sudan, with recently
significant numbers from Ukraine. Asylum seekers and refugees
(those whose claim for asylum has been accepted by a host country1)
face a wide range of challenges and the development of host country
language proficiency has been identified as a key factor in successfully
adapting to and integrating into a new country (Bleakley & Chin, 2004).

Conversely, poor language skills ‘create a number of disadvantages’


and stand out ‘strongly as a barrier to progress’ in relation to
integration, economic success, and progression into further learning
(Casey, 2016, p. 94).

1. For a discussion on the range of terminology and its definitions, see https://www.amnesty.org/en/what-we-do/
refugees-asylum-seekers-and-migrants/#definitions. In this paper, we use the umbrella term ‘refugees’ to refer
to both refugees and asylum seekers.

02
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Beyond such practical outcomes, language (Martin, 1994; O’Toole et al., 2018), issues
development is linked with important with cultural adjustment (Constant et
psychological gains, such as an increased al., 2009, Yakushko, 2008), the effects of
or renewed sense of dignity and self-worth trauma, and lower motivation compared
and as such is strongly desired by refugees to voluntary migrants (Chiswick & Miller,
(Tip et al., 2019). 2001; Wehrle et al., 2018) play a major
role in the ability to access and benefit
This section of the paper focuses on the from education. These barriers lead to
specific challenges that refugees face when high levels of anxiety, depression, and
learning languages, the challenges teachers maladaptive outcomes (Baran et al., 2018;
face when supporting refugees, and the Baranik et al., 2018).
positive contributions the presence of
refugees brings to teachers, other learners, In addition, practical constraints such
and the wider educational system. as ‘lack of child care, caring for family
members, health issues, financial barriers,
Refugees’ challenges in attending paid employment, transport
language learning difficulties, gender barriers, living in isolated
areas, and understanding how “systems”
Refugees face many challenges that impact
work in order to access information
their ability to learn a new language. Of
and resources (Benseman, 2014, p. 94)
these, instability, pre- and post-settlement
significantly impact refugees.

Refugees also face particular challenges relating


to language acquisition. Perhaps the most
widely recognized of these is a lack of literacy
among many refugees in their first language
(Bigelow & Schwarz, 2010; Chamorro et al., may have Arabic as their first language
2021), which places a severe limitation on (Syrian Arabic as their spoken and Modern
learners’ ability to develop an additional Standard Arabic as their written language),
language, especially among older learners may have had some instruction in Syria in
and women (Morrice et al., 2019). Many French as a Foreign Language, moved to
require lengthy support to develop basic Denmark and enrolled in a school where
literacy skills, such as letter recognition Danish is the language of instruction, while
and formation.2 Another challenge is that also taking English as a Foreign Language
many refugees manage multiple languages classes as part of that schooling.
by necessity. For example, a Syrian child

2. A similar but opposite problem exists where highly qualified and often professionally
significantly accomplished refugees are ‘lumped in’ with those without such backgrounds.

03
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

The role of these languages shifts with the with the same L1 background increases the
L1 now becoming a ‘heritage language’ temptation to avoid the target language,
with important questions regarding if and and capped access to the internet further
how this should be further developed limits learners’ access to target language
and/or maintained (and often with limited resources.
resources available to support development
languages not commonly taught in the host Expectations about the future have a major
country; Erenay & Reinders, in press). Of impact on learners’ motivation to learn the
course, when learners are not in education, language. For example, Ukrainian refugees
access to the target language may be are mostly looking to return home as soon
limited. Refugees tend to be housed in as possible, Sudanese refugees in Egypt
asylum centres outside urban areas, with may be looking to move to Europe, and
few opportunities to interact with native often an application for asylum is denied,
speakers. Housing learners with others but the person is not deported.

I was speaking to a group of refugee women from Myanmar, none of whom


were literate or had any form of formal education, even in their own language.
Their dreams were very much centred on their children’s success, but they
struggled to fulfil the school’s expectations of home–school partnership:
It’s just the homework we get from the school. As parents we are expected to
support them and help them revise. But we are not literate. We cannot give them
that support. And I don’t know any mathematics – so how can I teach them? When
they do their homework and have questions, I can’t answer them.
Schools often have little understanding in this area and assume that parents
do not value education if their children are not completing their homework.
However, language barriers and unfamiliarity with systems mean that parents
may not interact with the school to the desired level and may therefore be seen
to lack engagement in their children’s education.
In the last year, a homework club has been started in the area, where students
of refugee background can get additional support after school, through
tutoring by qualified teachers. This has proven extremely popular and it assists
children and relieves some of the burden for the parents.
Hanna Svensson, ETC, New Zealand

103 million
people worldwide have been forced
to flee their homes due to conflicts,
violence, fear of persecution, and
human rights violations.

04
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Language teachers’ challenges in On the personal front, teachers sometimes


supporting refugees worry about causing offence when working
with refugee learners. The Star Network in the
Refugees have a wide range of educational United Kingdom offers some commonsense
backgrounds, languages, interests, and advice (see http://www.star-network.org.uk/)
needs that language teachers need to and warns against being overly concerned.
accommodate, which can differ quite Nonetheless, there are emotional and political
significantly from host country learners or components to the work which can be both
EFL students that teachers might be used exciting and challenging.
to teaching, using ready-made and readily-
available course books. Refugees often A positive perspective
arrive at different times throughout the
academic year, which is both challenging The next section introduces several
to the teacher and potentially disruptive pedagogical and support practices that have
to other learners (Farrelly, 2017). Some proved instrumental in dealing with the
only stay for short periods before moving challenges of teaching refugees. However,
to another city or country, which makes it is important not to assume a deficit view.
planning difficult, and many have faced Rodriguez (2015) talked, for example, about
significant disruption to their educational ‘the dangers of compassion’, stating that while
progress, with resulting gaps in their educators must be mindful of the traumatic
knowledge. However, the greatest challenge experiences refugees may have had, this
reported by language teachers is poor or should not lead to ‘position[ing] refugees
non-existing L1 literacy (Chamorro et al., like vulnerable problems to be fixed through
2021; Benseman, 2014). This, together education and other services’ (p. 112).
with the social, practical, and psychological
challenges introduced in the previous While recognizing the very real obstacles in
section, requires a complex and specialized the way of refugees and those who support
set of responses from individual teachers them, it is also true that the presence of
and their organizations. In practice, refugees has a number of benefits. First,
however, many teachers lack such the cultural and linguistic diversity and life
specialized skills and many organizations do experiences that refugees bring can be a
not have a systematic approach to teaching major source of interest to the language
refugees and supporting their teachers. classroom. Second, the qualities that many
Many teachers also report not having access refugees have developed, such as grit,
to sufficiently tailored teaching materials inventiveness, and flexibility, can act as a
(Miles & Bailey-McKenna, 2016), and many source of inspiration to other learners and
teachers of refugees are volunteers who their teachers alike. Furthermore, supporting
receive little professional training or support a new classmate can bring a group of learners
(Van Rensburg & Son, 2010), which impacts together in new ways. In other words,
learner participation and success (Stevenson the inclusion of refugees in the language
& Willott, 2007; Riggs et al., 2012). classroom offers both challenges and
opportunities.3

3. Funds of Knowledge and Funds of Identity are two theoretical lenses


that recognise the resources learners have available. These have been
fruitfully applied in studies of refugee learners (Esteban-Guitart &
Moll, 2014).

05
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

SUPPORTING REFUGEES
– A COLLABORATIVE
EFFORT
Successful support for refugees is
systematically organized, carefully
integrated across the school, and actively
connected to other relevant stakeholders.
As this support cannot be the responsibility
of an individual teacher, in this section,
we examine the relationships between the
classroom and the wider context.

While teachers can play an important


monitoring and advocacy role to encourage
their organization to better prepare for
supporting refugee learners, schools can
play a mediating role with other support
services, government agencies, NGOs,
community networks, and families.
Figure 1 illustrates this interrelationship.
Policies, support services (language and
other support), relevant communities, and
available resources are identified, adapted
and, where necessary, created by the
school in collaboration with its teachers and
learners. The experiences obtained by all
feed back into the ongoing development of
school policies and resources, which may
be shared with the wider community.

06
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Figure 1. Refugee Support Network

Language Other
Support Support
Community

Policies Resources

Support
Policies Resources

School

Teaching & Learning

Planning for refugee support Such changes may include mandates for
in schools schools to enrol a minimum number of
refugees, the availability or withdrawal of
Ideally, one person or team is responsible funding, the provision of new resources
for planning support for refugees in for teaching refugees, and the availability
schools. Given the vital importance of specialist training for teachers. As these
of language development for refugee changes can come quickly, it is imperative
wellbeing, it is important that refugees that schools have as much time as possible
are involved in the delivery of language to react. Thus, it is important that this team
support. Especially in situations where little has a finger on the pulse of the political
or no dedicated support may be available landscape. Attitudes towards refugees can
within the school, some teachers have shift rapidly based on news stories and
reported great success in working with geopolitical events, which can influence
former, now-settled refugees. However this what requirements might be placed on
team is made up, it should stay up-to-date schools and what support is available.
on any changes in the national landscape
regarding refugees.

07
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Available support
Support for refugees is typically provided • Self-study materials, provided by the
by many providers, of which schools and government or NGOs, designed to
other language providers are only one. enable refugees to learn by themselves,
Other providers include: especially as they may be transitory and
not yet enrolled in a school.
• resettlement agencies that do anything
from finding accommodation to liaising It is important that the schools and
with healthcare providers institutions have knowledge of these other
• counselling services for trauma and providers. This will help them to refer
other mental health issues students where necessary and, especially
in the case of language providers, to know
•e
 mployment agencies what language instruction learners may
• legal services have received prior to enrolling in the
school, what materials learners are familiar
•N
 GOs
with, and what ongoing language support
Of particular interest in the context of this learners may receive outside of school.
paper are the language providers. Before
Parents play a tremendously important
enrolling in a school and often continuing
role in heritage language maintenance and
after, refugees may take language courses
in encouraging and supporting younger
from one or more of the following:
learners in learning a new language. Where
•S
 pecialized language providers, often possible, it is important to find out about
funded by the government, dedicated prior learning experiences from parents
to helping learners develop the ability to and explain how language learning is
navigate their environment as quickly as supported at school and what parents can
possible. Where necessary, these include do to help (For example by encouraging
a strong focus on developing initial extensive reading at home). This will
literacy skills. also help mitigate some of the common
concerns parents have about not being
•C
 ommunity/volunteer groups/clubs able to understand or navigate the new
offering (usually conversational) classes educational system, for example, due to
in churches/mosques, libraries and other language or literacy barriers and feeling
public places. left out.
•F
 amily learning classes, where (often
Identifying learner needs
volunteer) teachers visit a family in their
(temporary) home to help with everyday Staying in touch with local support
language issues, such as filling in forms providers may give teachers an early
and making appointments with a doctor. indication of how many refugees to
expect, when, and from which countries.
•H
 omework clubs, which, in addition
Regardless, it is important to try to answer
to school-oriented support, help with
the following questions as early as possible:
learning both the new and the heritage
language.

08
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Are they likely to be resettled soon?

What is the learners’ literacy level in their L1?

What language instruction have learners received prior to


enrolling in the school?

What is their proficiency in the L2 in listening, reading,


speaking and writing?

What (if any) continuing language support do they have


access to outside the school?

What materials do they have access to at home?

What is their family (language) situation?

What is their digital literacy level?

What is their (anticipated) level of motivation to study in


general and to study the language in particular?

Do we have other learners in our school who could provide


support, perhaps from a similar background?

Do we have teachers in our school who may have relevant


backgrounds or expertise that we can draw on?

Do they have major family or work commitments that


are likely to impact their participation?

What are their travel and childcare arrangements?

Do they have particular psychological needs and are these


being met through specialized support providers?

09
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

1. know that this is happening and who


is doing it,
2. receive the resulting information so
they can act on it and
3. inform the counsellor when psychological
issues arise in class.

Likewise, content teachers (for example, a


science or mathematics teacher) can work
with language teachers to ensure that the
topics covered in language classes relate
to what learners need and can benefit
from the most in their content class.
The literature on content and language
integrated learning (CLIL) offers many
Systematizing and integrating practical suggestions for how this can be
support achieved (see Coyle et al., 2012).

A key feature of successful support is that Professional development


it is systematic and integrated. Systematic and support
support is based on a clear set of goals.
Using a needs analysis (see page 9), a An important part of the bigger picture is
school may identify particular priorities the support that is available, both within
and design a learning plan that covers the and outside the school, for teachers and
amount of time refugee learners are, at a anyone else in the school involved in
minimum, likely to be enrolled. Such a plan supporting refugees. The government may
should be flexible enough to accommodate provide courses or tailored resources (for
learners arriving at different times and/or example sample teaching materials), but
leaving early (for example, by writing any where these are unavailable or unsuitable,
teaching materials in such a way that they they will have to be located or developed
can be used independently by learners). elsewhere. Baecher and her colleagues
(2019) developed and delivered a short
Integrated support requires that all training programme in the US, which may
stakeholders within the school know give you a ideas for developing your own.
about the goals the school has set and
who is responsible for realizing them.
It also involves actively communicating
and collaborating to ensure there are no
overlaps or gaps in duties. For example,
if the school counsellor is tasked
with finding out about new learners’
psychological needs, then teachers should

10
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

When I first started teaching refugees, every week – sometimes every day – opened my eyes
to their sufferings. Getting to know these wonderful people and then being told their stories
of torture, flight, abuse, starvation, and separation shocked me. The stories exhausted me,
and the trauma that my students shared often provoked strong reactions in me – a desire to
solve their problems, to find help for them and to, generally, turn everything upside down
until I knew they were OK. Fortunately, through our collaboration with the settlement
support agency we were able to refer students to experienced social workers, and these
social workers helped me see that many of my students’ struggles were not pathological
conditions but normal reactions to difficult situations and a normal part of the settlement
process. Now in a role supporting other teachers, I see similar patterns in every new teacher
– the fear, sense of inadequacy, and emotional exhaustion. My response to this is to become
the repository of their worries and the person they can send students to when they need to
talk. I have found that the most important way to support the teachers is by letting them
know that the problem is not theirs, that it has been assessed and referred to professionals
if needed and that not all problems are urgent. Personally, I still get affected by the stories
I hear, but I have learnt to take care of myself when this happens.
Laura Baecher, CUNY, USA

It is important to recognize that support for


staff needs to include not only technical or
pedagogical skills but also support for dealing
with the stresses that working with refugees can
cause. Some examples include hearing about
people’s traumas, not knowing how to respond
to mental health issues as they arise in class
and the need to engage in possible conflict
resolution. At the very least, a safe space should
be provided for staff to share their experiences.

11
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

TEACHING
REFUGEES

This section of the paper introduces some


actions language teachers can adopt to
better support refugees. Although the
primary focus is on language development,
the suggestions below cover both
pedagogical and broader support issues.

As Magro (2007) and others have argued,


‘resettlement issues cannot be separated from
language development and teachers should work
from a broad definition of literacy that includes
not only numeracy, problem solving, and the
ability to read, write, and speak English, but also
emotional and social literacies such as motivation,
interpersonal effectiveness, critical thinking, and
cultural awareness’ (p. 70).

12
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Pedagogical considerations
Although each context is unique and specific teaching practices will differ from one
classroom to the next, research studies and teachers’ experiences have given us good
insight into the fundamental pedagogical principles that are conducive to refugee learner
success. Figure 2 illustrates this. The following sections discuss each principle.

Figure 2. Pedagogical Considerations

Community

School

Relevant Empowering

Situated Scaffolded
Social Affective

Teaching & Learning

Immediate relevance to learners’ lives


One of the most important features of language instruction for refugees is that it is
applicable in the context of learners’ lives. This means including topics related to getting
to know the local environment, such as where to shop, how to use public transportation,
finding employment, and making doctor’s appointments. Even younger learners are
often involved in helping out their parents, so the language they need may be different
from what non-refugee learners normally receive in class. To find out more about your
learners and their specific language needs (in addition to the broader educational needs
analysis discussed in the preceding section of this paper), teachers can use a diagnostic
assessment or a screening tool such as the one developed by the Education & Training
Foundation. The Foundation also provides free teaching resources.

13
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Learning from media


An excellent source of local and cultural information is through
watching and listening to the news and other media; however, this
can be too challenging for many learners. Språkkraft, a Swedish NGO
(working internationally as Lingvis foundation), has developed a suite
of free language support and learning tools for up to 30 different
languages commonly spoken by refugees into a large number of
daily updated general media. These tools help learners to use freely
available online media, from music, social media posts, news articles,
videos, podcasts, and (audio)books. Using integrated dictionaries and
grammar analysis, the tools provide scaffolding in authentic media
and create a visual personal learning profile that highlights words to
be learned now or later depending on the learner’s proficiency. The
learner’s profile is updated through taking automatically generated
exercises. Sprakkraft is available online.

Situated
Situated learning involves learning from At a practical level, situated learning can be
and with others in the context of activities achieved through in-class tasks that mimic
that occur in learners’ daily lives or strongly out-of-class situations through role play or
resemble activities that do (Stein, 1998). As by using project-based or problem-based
the activities are contextual and social, they learning. Out-of-class tasks can involve
allow learners to learn by doing. Therefore, guided activities for learners to complete
learners develop knowledge and skills that on their own, such as using a checklist to
are meaningful to them. For example, on a interview a member of the community.
field trip to a museum, they may not only Work placements and internships are
learn new words, but they may also learn examples of situated learning suitable for
those words in the context of, for example, older learners.
figuring out how to buy an entrance ticket
or reading the explanations of the pieces.
They remember these in relation to what
they were doing (for example deciding with
their peers where to go next) and how they
were feeling at the time, who was present,
and what they said and did. Such situated
information is more likely to be retained.

14
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Social
The social aspect of learning is perhaps even 5. O
 pinion exchange tasks: Learners
more important for refugee learners than engage in discussion and exchange
for other learners. Within the classroom, ideas. They do not need to reach
this means involving learning in the daily agreement.
rhythm and activities of the group as soon
as possible, for example, by assigning them
some class duties or by pairing them up The social aspect of learning can also be
with a ‘buddy’. Common language learning usefully linked to the learner’s family and
tasks, such as those listed below, can be community context. For example, some
particularly helpful in getting learners to schools offer learning opportunities for
collaborate in activities where refugees’ children with their parents or caregivers,
backgrounds and knowledge can be used usually after school. Additionally, the parents
advantageously. For example, in jigsaw tasks, or community leaders may communicate
refugee learners may have information regularly (with the help of an interpreter
about their home country that other where necessary; see Sebben [2009] for
learners do not have. advice on working with an interpreter)
about the aims of the class and the work
1. Jigsaw tasks: Learners combine learners are asked to complete at home.
different pieces of information to form More broadly, helping learners develop
a whole (for example, three individuals the communicative skills to interact with
or groups may have three different people in the community is vital because it
parts of a story and have to piece the enhances opportunities for exposure to the
story together). target language and supports relationship
building, both major contributors to success
in language learning.
2. I nformation-gap tasks: One student
or group of students has one set of
information and another student or
group has a complementary set of
information. To complete an activity,
they must negotiate and find out the
other party’s information.

3. P
 roblem-solving tasks: Students
are given a problem and a set of
information. They must arrive at a
solution to the problem. There is
generally a single resolution.

4. D
 ecision-making tasks: Students are
given a problem for which there are a
number of possible outcomes and they
must choose one through negotiation
and discussion.

15
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Affective
Language learning is an emotional process. Examples of activities teachers can use
Language learning in a new environment include ‘Three Good Things’ (Seligman,
is emotionally challenging. Language 2011), which asks learners to write down
anxiety, lack of confidence, frustration at a three things that went well for them and
lack of progress, and many other negative the reasons why, or keeping a confidence-
emotions play a major role in language building diary (Kato & Mynard, 2016), where
learner motivation and eventual success. learners reflect on their language learning
This is compounded for many refugees emotions.
as they try to navigate a new and often
considerably alien environment in which While focusing on the emotional aspects
they experience constant disruption to their of learning is helpful, it is important for
daily lives as well as issues of prejudice, teachers not to overstep their boundaries.
or worse, often against the backdrop of Mental health issues and trauma should
previous traumatic experiences. be handled by professionals, such as
qualified counsellors. Cook et al. (2005)
The organization ‘Teaching Refugees’ recommended that teachers watch out
recommends establishing routines so that for seven warning signs: lack of reducing
learners experience a sense of normality. attachment and withholding emotions, poor
They recommend that teachers focus on or worsening self-concept (shame and guilt),
emotional skill development and self-care. inability to control behaviour, inability to
Of course, a focus on emotions does not to handle emotions (aggression or avoidance),
be exclusively negative. Positive psychology difficulty recognizing and describing one’s
emphasizes a focus on wellbeing, own emotions, and difficulty concentrating
contentment and satisfaction (in the past), or being ‘absent’ and forgetfulness. Teachers
hope and optimism (in the future), and should ask for support when they observe
flow and happiness (in the present). these warning signs.

Digital storytelling
One activity that brings together some of the pedagogical principles is
the use of digital storytelling. Digital stories combine text, audio, video,
music, and other forms of media and enable even learners with lower
levels of proficiency to express themselves (Reinders, 2010). Kendrick et al.
(2022) had refugee learners create a portfolio in which to reflect on their
emotional self-awareness, including noting stressors and developing coping
strategies. Next, the students created short videos on their experiences,
with music and/or voice-overs. After completing their digital stories,
students could participate in a public exhibition in the school.

The authors emphasized the value of drawing on lived experiences and


everyday meaning making, including using digital literacies to give learners
a voice. Sharing stories is a highly social activity that can provide learners
with a platform to express their emotions and experiences and help them
get to know each other better.

16
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Scaffolded Empowering
Refugee learners often struggle to cope Considering that many refugee learners
with the varying demands that language end up being resettled to other towns
classes place on them. In addition to the or countries, it is important to help them
usual challenges shared with other learners, develop the ability to regulate their own
they may struggle to understand the cultural learning. Self-regulation refers to ‘how
background to what is being discussed, they learners cognitively, motivationally, and
may still have L1 literacy issues and be slower behaviorally promote their own academic
at word recognition, or they may be more achievement’ (Zimmerman, 1989, p. ix).
self-conscious around their peers. The result
Oxford’s position paper on this topic,
is that such learners’ cognitive capacity is
launched in April 2023, includes a framework
quickly depleted. Cognitive load reduction
for gradually introducing learners to the
(Martin, 2016) involves using instructional
different skills involved in Self-Regulated
techniques that make the language easier
Learning. These skills include helping learners
for the learner to process and thus free up
to self-motivate, identify their own needs, set
cognitive resources. Such techniques, many
goals, plan and regulate their own learning,
of which have been used successfully with
and self-assess. The position paper includes
refugees, include:
example activities for developing these skills.
– using explicit instruction Refugee learners may come from educational
– simplifying instructional language backgrounds that have not prepared
them for taking responsibility for their own
– using gestures and body language
learning and it is therefore important to
– using written texts to support oral start slowly by raising awareness of the
instruction importance of self-regulation and what it
– using structure and routines involves. Guided practice can be introduced
gradually in class by, for example, asking
– slower pacing
learners to plan a language learning activity
– using repetition and paraphrasing in pairs and receiving feedback from the
– frequent revision teacher. Once they have developed some
confidence, the teacher may ask learners to
– varying teaching techniques
carry out an activity independently outside
– lowering expectations of the classroom and have them report their
– using guided discovery experiences in class. Eventually, learners can
– giving learners time for personal expression be given greater freedom over deciding what
to learn and how.
– using discussion and social bonding

Scaffolding plays an important role in

1. providing access to teacher or peer


support,
2. using the L1 where possible,
3. having learners of similar backgrounds
and languages work together, and
4. using visual aids.

In addition to having the immediate benefit of


helping learners understand and participate
in class, these techniques relieve stress and
increase motivation (Sevari et al., 2021).

17
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

CONCLUSION

Supporting refugee learners is taxing at


the best of times and may seem like an
insurmountable challenge, especially in
schools where teachers are given insufficient
preparation time, professional development,
and ongoing (emotional) support.

However, the suggestions in this paper show that individual teachers can have a
major impact by making straightforward adjustments to their instruction. For example,
cognitive load reduction techniques are likely to benefit all learners, and improving
communication across different departments in the school is likely to lead to a more
collaborative environment. In other words, making a (considerable) effort is likely to
prove to be a valuable investment. Most importantly, by supporting some of the most
vulnerable members of your community, teachers can make a genuine and lifelong
difference for learners. To start or continue the process, please consider using the
‘prompt cards’ available at the end of this paper.

18
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

19
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

These prompt cards will help you explore the various needs of your refugee learners, and how best to
support them. Discuss the prompts with your colleague to start the process.

Conversation Who is responsible for Our refugee


starters supporting refugees? population

• What is our experience with • What are our obligations • How many refugees do we
refugee populations? (including legal, regulatory have and how many do other,
[such as for accreditation], similar schools have?
• If we have little or no and moral)?
experience, what are our • What are their backgrounds?
expectations? • Is there a person or group
in our school who has • What are the expectations for
responsibility for refugee the coming months and years
support? If not, could there be? for our refugee population?

• Which teachers have a


particular interest in (learning
more about) teaching
refugees?

What support services What language support What support exists


exist in the community? exists in the community? for teachers?

• What services exist? Consider Teaching resources, such as:

• Do we know what they do • ESOL providers • Professional development


and how to reach them? training
• Community/ volunteer groups/
clubs • Organizations involved in
psychological support (e.g.
• Self-study materials understanding trauma
• Family learning classes • Practical services (e.g. visas,
• Libraries and other resource registering for employment
centres services)

20
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Is there a systematic How are content and


Identifying refugees language teachers
learning plan for different
(language) needs communicating about
groups of refugees? their learners’ needs?

• Are they likely to be resettled • If not, what would such a plan • For example, consider setting
soon? need to comprise? up an online document
for sharing ideas and
• What is the learners’ literacy level • Are there perhaps examples
in their L1?
experiences. A shared folder
available online or at other can be used to exchange
• What language instruction schools that may have more lesson plans and course
have learners received prior to experience in this area? outlines so everyone has
enrolling in the school? insight into the types of
• What is their proficiency in the
instruction learners have
L2 in listening, reading, speaking, received.
and writing?

• What (if any) continuing language


support do they have access to
outside the school?

• What materials do they have


access to in the home?

• What is their family (language)


situation?

• What is their digital literacy level?

• What is their (anticipated) level


of motivation to study in general
and to study the language in
particular?

• Do they have major family or


work commitments that are likely
to impact their participation?

• What are their travel and


chioldcare arrangements?

• Do they have particular


psychological needs and are
these being met through
specialized support providers?

21
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Can we help learners Can we help learners as What content would be


before they arrive? they transition to other most relevant for our
schools or countries? learners?

• In some cases, it is known • For example, schools can • What daily experiences are
when learners will arrive. (help learners) create a they most likely to have at this
Contacting them and portfolio that can inform the point in their lives?
connecting them with other new school or workplace
learners (both those in about their language learning • What realia could we (ask them
the school and other new progress and needs. Similarly, to) bring into the classroom?
refugees) can help create a certain materials (such as • What are their local and
sense of belonging and ease those created by teachers cultural orientation needs?
any potential anxiety. in-house) may be shared with
the new school to give the • What so we know about
• Although many in transit will new teachers insight into what their employment and social
have limited opportunities learners have covered up to integration needs?
to access or learn with that point.
educational resources, the
provision of certain informal • Maintaining connections
types of materials (e.g. videos with learners, especially in
in the target language on cases where they do not
YouTube, cartoons that (immediately) transition into
can be read online) can be another school or work, can What teaching materials
motivational. help learners stay engaged do we have access to that
in their studies and maintain are relevant to refugee
a sense of belonging and learners?
security at a time of change.
• Do we have other learners in
our school who could provide
support, perhaps from a
similar background?

22
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Dealing with emotional


Teaching techniques Sensitive issues and psychological
for refugees issues

The text mentions the importance • The text quotes Rodriguez • What are our expectations
of cognitive load reduction and (2015), who talks about ‘the in dealing with students
suggests several good practices: dangers of compassion’. What, who experience emotional
– using explicit instructions in our view, are some of those challenges or have
dangers, and how could we psychological issues?
– simplifing instructional langauge
avoid them?
– using gestures and body • What approaches have
language • The text also mentions ‘positive worked?
psychology’ and includes one
– using written texts to support • What other support services
particular activity (‘Three Good
oral instruction can we call on, either in the
Things’). Can we think of other
– using structure and routines such activities that might work school or beyond?
– slower pacing in our context? • Could this person/group be
– using repetition and invited to come and speak to
paraphrasing the teachers to share some
general advice?
– frequent revision
– varying teaching techniques
– lower expectations Preparing for the possibility
that learners may have to
– guided discovery
leave at any moment
– giving learners time for personal
expression
– using discussion and social • Can we select or create our
bonding teaching materials so that, if
necessary, learners can use
– guided discovery
them independently?
•H
 ow confident are we in
each of these? For example, answer sheets
could be made available, along
•A
 re there colleagues who with general instructions on
could help us?
how to progress through the
•D
 o we have resources that materials at any given moment
could help us? during the term.

23
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

RESOURCES &
REFERENCES
https://epale.ec.europa.eu/en
Electronic Platform for Adult Learning in Europe

https://esol.excellencegateway.org.uk/content/teachers/lessons-and-activities/teaching-
beginners-refugees

ESOL for Refugees: Resources for new arrivals aim to help ESOL practitioners better
meet the early integration needs of refugees who are new to ESOL. The resources were
commissioned by the Education and Training Foundation and the Home Office and were
developed by Learning and Work Institute and Learning Unlimited in the UK. The 12 units
of teaching and learning materials, based around a simple dialogue in a relevant early
integration scenario, are each intended to support around six hours of delivery; offer
guidance to support practitioners with the approaches underpinning the resources, linking
to earlier practitioner resources and guidance on working with new to ESOL learners;
provide a screening tool to help identify learners who are new to ESOL and who may benefit
from additional early integration language support; and include learner profiles, illustrating
the early integration needs and longer-term learning and work aspirations of refugees.

http://www.star-network.org.uk/
Advice on what topics to avoid talking about with refugees.

https://www.teachingrefugees.com/
Does this English Language Learner (ELL) have specialised programming needs? The sample
documents in this package may assist staff in determining an ELL’s programming needs and
possible entitlement to individualized programming.

http://www.unhcr.org/pages/49c3646c4b2.html
This site provides background information about the refugee situation worldwide. It contains
feature stories and information about the UN’s work, a public domain photo bank and
searchable databases.

https://youtu.be/fLXyCTSQmRI
A video by the Center for Applied Linguistics (Canada) on ‘Reframing Literacies through the
eyes of Refugees and SLIFE students’.

https://sprakkraft.se/agenda-iin.html
https://sprakkraft.se/agenda-no.html
https://epub.sub.uni-hamburg.de/epub/volltexte/2023/155866/pdf/386371eng.pdf

These sites offer videos, slides and written reports from two conferences on Informal
Language Learning and Media for Migrants in the Nordic, co-hosted by Språkkraft and the
UNESCO Institute for Lifelong Learning with funding from the Nordic Council of Ministers.

24
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Al Janaideh, R., Gottardo, A., Tibi, S., Paradis, J., & Chen, X. (2020). The role of word reading
and oral language skills in reading comprehension in Syrian refugee children. Applied
Psycholinguistics, 41(6), 1283–1304.

Baran, B. E., Valcea, S., Porter, T. H., & Coleman Gallagher, V. (2018). Survival, expectations
and employment: An inquiry of refugees and immigrants to the United States. Journal of
Vocational Behavior, 105, 102–115. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvb.2017.10.011

Baranik, L. E., Hurst, C. S., & Eby, L. T. (2018). The stigma of being a refugee: A mixed-method
study of refugees’ experiences of vocational stress. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 105,
116–130.

Batalova, J. (2022). Top statistics on global migration and migrants. Migration Policy Institute.
https://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/top-statistics-global-migration-migrants

Benseman, J. (2014). Adult refugee learners with limited literacy: Needs and
effective responses. Refuge: Canada’s Journal on Refugees, 30(1), 93–103. https://doi.
org/10.25071/1920-7336.38606

Bigelow, M., & Schwarz, R. (2010). Adult English language learners with limited literacy.
National Institute for Literacy.

Bleakley, H., & Chin, A. (2004). Language skills and earnings: Evidence from childhood
immigrants. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 86(2), 481–496. https://doi.
org/10.1162/003465304323031067

Casey, L. (2016). The Casey review: A review into opportunity and integration. https://www.
gov.uk/government/publications/the-casey-review-a-review-into-opportunity-and-integration

Chiswick, B. R., & Miller, P. W. (2001). A model of destination-language acquisition: Application


to male immigrants in Canada. Demography, 38(3), 391–409. https://doi.org/10.1353/
dem.2001.0025

Chamorro, G., Garrido-Hornos, M. D. C., & Vázquez-Amador, M. (2021). Exploring ESOL


teachers’ perspectives on the language learning experiences, challenges, and motivations of
refugees and asylum seekers in the UK. International Review of Applied Linguistics in Language
Teaching, 61(2). https://doi.org/10.1515/iral-2020-0155

Constant, A. F., Kahanec, M., & Zimmermann, K. F. (2009). Attitudes towards immigrants,
other integration barriers and their veracity. International Journal of Manpower, 30, 5–14.
https://doi.org/10.1108/01437720910948357

Cook, A., Spinazzola, J., Ford, J., Lanktree, C., Blaustein, M., Cloitre, M., & Van der Kolk, B.
(2005). Complex trauma. Psychiatric annals, 35(5), 390-398.

Coyle, D., Hood, P., & Marsh, D. (2012). CLIL: Content and language integrated learning.
Cambridge University Press.

Esteban-Guitart, M., & Moll, L. C. (2014). Funds of identity: A new concept based on the funds
of knowledge approach. Culture & Psychology, 20(1), 31–48.

25
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Frieze, S. (2015). How trauma affects student learning and behaviour. BU Journal of
Graduate Studies in Education, 7(2), 27–34.

Kato, S., & Mynard, J. (2015). Reflective dialogue: Advising in language learning. Routledge.

Magro, K. (2007). Overcoming the trauma of war: Literacy challenges of adult learners.
Education Canada, 47, 70–74.

Martin, A. J. (2016). Using load reduction instruction (LRI) to boost motivation and
engagement. British Psychological Society.

Martin, A. J., & Evans, P. (2018). Load reduction instruction: Exploring a framework that
assesses explicit instruction through to independent learning. Teaching and Teacher
Education, 73, 203–214. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2018.03.018

Martin, S. F. (1994). A policy perspective on the mental health and psychosocial needs
of refugees. In A. Marsella, T. J. H. Bornemann, S. Ekblad, & J. Orley (Eds.), Amidst peril
and pain: The mental health and well-being of the world’s refugees (pp. 69–80). American
Psychological Association. https://doi.org/10.1037/10147-002

Miles, J., & Bailey-McKenna, M. C. (2016). Giving refugee students a strong head start:
The LEAD Program. TESL Canada Journal, 33, 109–128.

Miller, J., Mitchell, J., & Brown, J. (2005). African refugees with interrupted schooling in
the high school mainstream: Dilemmas for teachers. Prospect, 20(2), 19–33.

Murphy, L. (2021). Understanding trauma to create effective trauma informed schools.


Curriculum and Instruction Undergraduate Honors Theses. Retrieved from https://
scholarworks.uark.edu/cieduht/23, 25/08/2023

O’Toole Thommessen, S. A., & Todd, B. K. (2018). How do refugee children experience
their new situation in England and Denmark? Implications for educational policy
and practice. Children and Youth Services Review Journal, 85, 228–238. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.childyouth.2017.12.025

Reinders, H. (2010). Digital storytelling in the foreign language classroom.

Rodriguez, S. (2015). The dangers of compassion: The positioning of refugee students


in policy and education research and implications for teacher education. Knowledge
Cultures, 3(2), 112–126.

Sebben, J. (2009). Guidelines for teachers working with interpreters. Accent, 16(1),
Alberta Teachers’ Association: ESLC.

26
Supporting Refugees: a primer for language teachers

Seligman, M. E. (2011). Flourish: A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-


being. Simon and Schuster.

Sevari, K., Mahmodi, M., Rahdari, R., & Nabhani, N. (2021). The effect of autonomy
support on academic stress: The mediating role of self-regulated learning and mastery
goal orientation. Annals of the Romanian Society for Cell Biology, 25(6), 21109–21116.

Stein, D. (1998). Situated learning in adult education (pp. 640-646). ERIC Clearinghouse
on Adult, Career, and Vocational Education, Center on Education and Training for
Employment, College of Education, Ohio State University.

Tip, L. K., Brown, R., Morrice, L., Collyer, M., & Easterbrook, M. J. (2019). Improving
refugee well-being with better language skills and more intergroup contact. Social
Psychological and Personality Science, 10(2), 144–151.

UNHCR. (2022). Figures at a glance. https://www.unhcr.org/en-us/figures-at-a-glance.


html

Wehrle, K., Klehe, U.-C., Kira, M., & Zikic, J. (2018). Can I come as I am? Refugees’
vocational identity threats, coping and growth. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 105,
83–101. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvb.2017.10.010

Yakushko, O., Backhaus, A., Watson, M., Ngaruiya, K., & González, J. (2008). Career
development concerns of recent immigrants and refugees. Journal of Career
Development, 34(4), 362–396. https://doi.org/10.1177/0894845308316292

Zheng, J., Jiang, N., & Dou, J. (2020). Autonomy support and academic stress: A
relationship mediated by self-regulated learning and mastery goal orientation. New
Waves-Educational Research and Development Journal, 23, 43–63.

Zimmerman, B. J. (1989). A social cognitive view of self-regulated academic learning.


Journal of Educational Psychology, 81(3), 329–339.

27

You might also like