Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Full Text 01
Full Text 01
K' > Mg’ >Na’
Effect of sugar concentration and different cosolutes
Sugar is the most commonly used cosolute in pectin gels. The presence of cosolutes reduces
the water activity and the interactions between pectin and water. It also influences the
hydrophobic bondings presumably by disrupting the cage of water molecules surrounding the
ester groups (May and Stainsby, 1985). The sugar content therefore affects the rheological
properties and the setting temperature of the gel. When the sugar concentration increases, the
setting temperature increases. In figure 4-13 the changes in 5 are shown for samples with
different sugar contents. During cooling the system changes from mainly viscous to mainly
elastic behaviour as the gelation proceeds,
298
3
Phase angled, «|
8
rr a ee) 2
Temperature, °C
Figure 4-13 Changes in phase angle during cooling of a slow set pectin gel in the presence of 65, 70, and 75%
soluble solids, analyzed by change in phase angle, 6. From Barford and Pedersen, 1990.
When sucrose is replaced by other sugars, the hydrophobic effects vary, since these sugars
interact with water in different ways. May and Stainsby found that the setting temperature of
HM-peetin gels increased when sucrose was partly replaced by maltose, lactose or glucose
syrup, respectively. When the whole amount of sucrose was replaced by maltose, the setting
temperature rose above 95°C. Dextrose and fructose affected the setting temperature in the
opposite way. When sucrose was partly replaced by dextrose and fructose, the setting
temperature fell.
4.2.2 Gelstrength
Internal gel strength is affected by several different factors such as type of pectin, molecular
weight, pH, soluble solids content and gel-forming conditions. The gel strength of pectin can
differ depending on the source and on the extraction method used (Crandall and Wicker,
1986). For HM pectins the gel strength increases with increased DM up to about 70 %. Any
further increase in DM will result in a decrease in gel strength. (Axelos et al, 1991). The
relation between gel strength, pH and DM is shown in figure 4-13.
DEGREE OF METHYLATION
63 73 at
GEL STRENGTH
GEL pH
Figure 4-14 Relationships between gel sirength, degree of methylation and pH. From Erlich, 1977.
Increased DM moves the optimal pH to higher values, Barford and Pedersen (1990) found a
similar relation between the content of soluble solids and pH on the internal gel strength.
Increased soluble solid content increases the gel strength and the pH optimum. When the
sugar content is increased, less acid is needed for gelation,
30The molecular weight affects the rupture strength of pectin gels. The rupture strength
increases continuously with increased molecular weight (Mitchell, 1980). The thermal
treatment of the pectin before gelation is also an important factor in the final gel strength. If
the pectin solutions are held for many hours at high temperatures, thermal breakdown of the
molecules can occur (Barford and Pedersen 1990). The cooling rate, time of ageing, stage of
acid addition, type of cosolute and the use of buffer salts also influences the gel strength
(Crandall and Wieker, 1986, Oakenfull and Scott, 1984a),
‘Test methods that measure the rupture strength of a gel may not be related to the elastic
‘modulus of the gel. Therefore, measurements of rupture strength will not necessarily rank a
series of gels in the same sequence as small deformation tests without rupture (Mitchell
1980).
Berth and Dahme (1991) used the shear modulus Gp as a normalised rigidity parameter to
evaluate the gel strength of high-methoxy! apple and citrus pectins. The pectins were
fractionated on size with GPC (gel permeation chromatography) and the different fractions
showed different behaviour. The results showed that raising the degree of polymerisation
increased the shear modulus. An increased amount of branched molecules or a greater degree
of branching was shown to reduce the shear modulus.
4.2.3 Gel strength measurements
‘The pectin gel strength can be measured with several different methods. Many methods
developed for the jelly manufacturer's needs are not easily correlated to each other. The need
for a standardised pectin gel strength measuring method was met in 1959 when the Institute
for Food Technologist’s presented the SAG method, described in detail below (IFT
Committee on Pectin Standardisation 1959). Gel strength measurements can briefly be
divided into two types, non-destructive and destructive methods. A non-destructive test
measures the clastic properties of the gel within the linear viscoelastic region. Destructive
tests have the advantage of being close to the consumer’s perception of a jelly. On the other
hand, large deformations are more difficult to interpret and are not reproducible to the same
extent as non-destructive methods. The description of gel strength methods given below
largely follows the review by Crandall and Wicker (1986).
Non-destructive test methods
In the SAG Method a mixture of a standardised amount of sugar is cooked with a test amount
of pectin. The mixture is poured into glasses of well-defined dimensions extended with tape at
the top. After 18 to 24 hours the gel is ready and the tape is removed from the top. A stretched
wire then cuts off the part of the gel held by the tape. After that the gel is turned upside down
on to a glass plate to rest on the base that was formed during cutting. The gel will sag under
its own weight and the loss in height is measured with a special micrometer called a
Ridgelimeter (IFT Committee on Pectin Standardisation 1959, Crandall and Wicker, 1986,
Rolin and de Vries 1990).
BAR and FIRA Jelly Tester: These instruments measure the apparent clastic modulus with a
torque on a blade immersed in the gel. The torque is applied by water flowing into a bucket
and the amount of water needed to obtain a 30° turn of the blade is measured. An improved
version of the instrument uses an electric motor connected to a torsion wire with a known
torsion moment instead of flowing water to turn the blade,
31Concentric Cylinder Instruments consist of two corrugated cylinders, one inner and one outer.
The pectin mixture is poured between the cylinders and will then set. A torsion wire twists the
inner cylinder, and the extent of torsion caused in the gel is measured. These types of
instruments can also be used for creep compliance and stress relaxation measurements,
Parallel Plate Instruments: The sample is placed between two parallel plates. Parallel plates
have been used for creep compliance measurements.
In Oscillatory Testing a small oscillatory stress is applied to the sample. The phase angle of
the responding strain is measured. Most gels show a phase difference of less than 90° between
stress and strain. Beveridge and Timbers (1989) carried out small amplitude oscillatory testing
with a “versatile food rheometer” at a constant cooling rate. The output amplitude was,
followed during the progress of gelation. During cooling of the pectin/sucrose solution, the
amplitude began to increase almost linearly at 70-80 °C. During reheating from 25 °C, the
amplitude decreased until the temperature passed 70 °C. After 70 °C the amplitude started to
increase again. See figure 4-15. Different pectin concentrations were investigated with the
oscillatory testing
‘Temperature ('c)
or Amplitude (g.cm)
Time nin)
Figure 4-15 Ampliude and temperature as a function of time of oscillatory input. The slow set pectin
concentration is 1 % and pH 2.82. From Beveridge and Timbers, 1989,
Destructive methods
‘The first destructive test method known is the Finger Test, A slice of the pectin gel is placed
between the thumb and the forefinger and squeezed until it breaks. The test gel is compared to
a reference gel. Trained analysts can detect differences of 5% between the test gel and the
reference,
Tarr-Baker Gelometer (Delaware Jelly Strength Tester): A force is applied to a pectin gel by
a piston powered by compression air. The method is sensitive to uneven application of the
pressure and “skin” formation on the surface of the gel. A modified version of the instrument
can be used for several elastic and breaking tests on the same gel.
Luers-Lochmuller Pektinometer measures the force required to pull a metal figure out after
being cast inside a pectin gel. The pectin mixture is poured into a special container with the
‘metal figure inside. The container sides are corrugated to avoid slip. See figure 4-16.
32Figure 4-16 The Luers and Lochmuller pektinometer. From Beach et al, 1986,
‘The Herbstreith-Pektinometer is an improvement on Luers-Lochmuller’s device. The
Herbstreith Pektinometer uses a special designed clear, corrugated cup with a plastic self-
centred figure. 100 gram pectin mixture is poured into the cup and held for 2 hours at 20°C,
‘The position of the cup is then locked and a hook is attached to the plastic figure. The force
required for an electric motor to pull the plastic figure is measured in Pektinometer units. One
advantage with the method is that the breaking strength is measured from the inside of the gel,
which thereby eliminates any problem with skin formation on the gel surface (Beach e al,
1986).
Instron: The Instron Universal Testing Machine can be used for compression and tension
measurements of samples loaded in a cell. The force is measured when the upper part of the
cell is moved a given distance or time, Fundamental characteristics of the gel such as
brittleness, hardness and elasticity can be quantitatively measured and related to sensory
properties such as chewiness and gumminess. Apparent gel strength and rupture strength were
measured by Oakenfull and Scott (1984a) using an Instron,
The Voland Stevens LFRA Texture Analyser (VSTA) measures the breaking strength of the
gel. A plunger is applied to the gel at a constant speed and the stress versus deformation graph
is recorded. A maximum corresponding to the point at which the elastic limit of the gel is
exceeded appears during the measurement (Rolin and de Vries, 1990).
‘The Bloom Gelometer is another plunger method, often used for classification of gelatines. It
measures the force required to press a plunger of specified dimensions 4 mm into the gel
(Rolin and de Vries, 1990).
The Boucher Electronic Jelly Tester is based on the same principle as the Bloom Gelometer.
The force required is measured by an electronic instrument (Rolin and de Vries, 1990).
The Penetrometer measures how deep a cone, which has been placed on the surface of a gel,
can penetrate the gel at a given time period. The driving force is only the gravitational force
(Rolin and de Vries, 1990).
‘The Chatillon consists of a stationary mechanical gauge attached to a test stand, The force-
sensitive gauche contains a calibrated spring, which is activated by moving a test sample cup
(Johnson and Breene, 1988).
3Comparison between different methods
Johnson and Breene (1988) compared the precision of the Pektinometer with that of the
Chatillon and Instron for gel strength measurement. Two different modes were tested, the pull
and the push mode. The Pektinometer and Instron showed similar precision; i.e. the variance
in the gel strength measurements was small for both modes. The simpler instrument,
Chatillon, showed higher variability in the gel strength measurements. However, the precision
of the Chatillon seemed to be high enough for routine gel strength measurements,
Beach et al (1986) compared five different pectins standardised to 150° SAG using different
test methods. The internal strength and breaking strength were measured with VSTA. The five
pectin sorts differed markedly in internal gel strength when the pectin concentration was
about 0.5 %. According to the SAG test, all five pectins were of the same quality. Further
investigations were made of other pectin samples. The breaking strength values measured
with the Herbstreith Pektinometer differed from results with the VSTA. Once again, the
pectin samples were standardised to 150° SAG and were supposed to have equal gel strength.
‘The VSTA was compared to the Tar-Baker gelometer for its suitability for measuring pectin
gel break strength. The results from the two methods were highly correlated and showed a
Tinear behaviour between gel break strength and pectin concentration (Angalet, 1986)
Rao et al (1989) compared the VSTA with an Instron in order to examine the feasibility of
determining texture parameters with the VSTA. The internal gel strength measured with
VSTA was also compared to results from SAG and Pektinometer measurements. Depending
on the plunger used with VSTA, high or low correlation with the Pektinometer was obtained.
High correlation was obtained for the VSTA and the SAG Ridgelimeter.
4.2.4 Structure development rate
The structure development (SD) rate during gelation is a usefull measure to provide
information about the time required to complete gelation or to obtain certain gel strength. The
SD rate can be defined either as dG'/dt, or as dn*/dt where n* is the complex viscosity:
nt=G*/o mts
© js the frequency and G* is the complex modulus consisting of an elastic par the storage
‘modulus (G’) and one viscous part, the loss modulus (G’’):
a= GY +@F aa
‘The magnitudes of SD rates can be used to examine the effect of different process variables,
such as temperature and polymer hydration (Lopes da Silva and Rao, 1995). Rao and Cooley
(1993) measured the incipient SD rate and the SD rate after 22 days of storing on
pectin/fructose gels, Both hydrated and unhydrated pectin were used. In the incipient SD rate
measurement, dispersions containing 65 % fructose and 0.5-1.0 % rapid set HM-pectin (DM =
49%) were cooled for 2 hours. The samples were placed in a cone and plate system of a Carri-
Med Rheometer. The SD rates were calculated from the time-n/* data recorded, Since pectin
gels are weak, the derivatives were calculated after careful interpolation of the data. SD rates
during the temperature sweep are shown in figure 4-17,
4Rate (poise/min)
‘Temperature (°C)
Figure 4-17 Structure development rates during a temperature sweep in 1 % pectin and 65 % fructose gel at pH
= 2.68, during cooling at 20 °C/h. From Rao and Cooley, 1993,
The negative and positive rates are suggested to correspond to breakage and reformation of
bonds during the cooling process. As can be seen in figure 4-17, the SD rates were higher in
the hydrated samples than in the unhydrated samples. In the long-term SD investigation,
samples were tested regularly during the storage period. The SD rates were strongly
dependent on the storage temperature and pH of the gels. The SD rates were, as expected,
highest in the beginning of the period. SD rates have also been measured during gelation by
Lopes da Silva et al (1995). An Arrhenius relationship was applied to describe the
temperature dependence of the SD rates.
The SD rates during ageing at different temperatures were studied by Lopes da Silva er af
(1995). The samples were quenched to the different ageing temperatures. Figure 4-18 shows
the SD rates as a function of ageing time at different temperatures.
ous
0.0
00s
acai
0.00
-005 | -0.05
0010" 1010 20104 3.010 Aro L210 1:3 10°
time (5)
Figure 4-18 Structure development rates during ageing of a 1% HM pectin 160% sucrase dispersion at pH = 3.0
and isothermal conditions. (A) 5°C, (@) 15°C, (0) 20°C, (») 30°C, (+) 50°C. From Lopes da Silva et al, 1995.
35All structural modifications were assumed to occur isothermally, due to the rapid quenching
of the samples, An initial increase in the SD rates was observed during the ageing process.
‘The largest increase occurred in the sample at 30°C. Both higher and lower temperatures
showed lower initial SD rates. The rapid increase in SD rates corresponds to the rapid
formation of junction zones between pectin chains, according to Lopes da Silva et al (1995).
The increase was followed by a decrease in SD rates. The SD rates continued to decrease
during the whole ageing period. This behaviour was suggested to correspond to slow
reorganisation of the network.
The effect of ageing temperature on the SD rates can be quantified by calculating the average
SD rates, SDRav:
f(spryar ee
where t; and t corresponds to the time interval over which dG’/dt data are obtained (Rao and
Cooley, 1994, Lopes da Silva et al, 1995). When SDR. values are plotted against
temperature, a bell-shaped dependence of temperature will occur. Lopes da Silva et al (1995)
found a SDRy, maximum at 30°C for a 1 % HM pectin/60 % sucrose sample at pH = 3.0. The
same ageing temperature was found for maximum elastie modulus (G’). In a similar way to
the SDR, the average viscosity, n*, is defined by Rao and Cooley (1994):
nea mest
Di
where t; and tz are the time interval over which the complex viscosity data are obtained.
The SD rate is very sensitive to changes in pectin concentration (Rao and Cooley, 1994).
When the pectin concentration is increased, the SD rate increases. Lopes da Silva et al (1995)
reported a high power dependence of the SD rate versus concentration; dG’/dt « c*!, Rao and
Cooley compared the SD rates for gels with fructose and gels with glucose. The
pectin/glucose gels showed higher SD rates than the pectin/fructose gels. Hydrogen bonds and
hydrophobic interactions seemed to affect the glucose gels more than the fructose gels, since
the SD rate varied substantially during cooling from 50°C to 10°C.
42.5 Ageing process
The network structure of pectin gels is stabilised by hydrogen bonds and hydrophobic
interactions. During ageing at different temperatures the different interactions will change,
which gives a complex behaviour in G’ and G"’ (Lopes da Silva and Goncalves, 1994). 1 %
HM-pectin/60) % sucrose systems were studied at different ageing temperatures, The storage
modulus increased as a function of time for all studied temperatures; however, at 5°C only a
small increase was observed. See figure 4-19.
36sean
2500 ee
2000 awe
= 1x0 isc
1000 toe
2 rc
sc
tine 0)
Figure 4-19 Storage modulus as a function of ageing time for HM pectin/sucrose gels at pH = 3.0.
‘Measurements were performed at 0.5 Hz and 3 % strain. From Lopes da Silva and Goncalves, 1994.
At the end of the ageing process the G’-value at $°C is much less than G’ for other
temperatures. This could be an effect of the temperature dependence of the hydrophobic
interactions. At low temperatures hydrophobic interactions are weak. As a consequence of
stronger hydrophobic interactions at higher temperatures, G’ increases from 5°C to 30°C. At
higher temperatures hydrogen bonds are weakened, which gives a weaker gel and lower G’ at
50°C. The effect of ageing has been studied on 0.5 % pectin / 65 % fructose gels at different
pH by Rao and Cooley (1993). At pH = 2.7, the rheological properties G’, G”’ and n*
increased during storage for 22 days at temperatures above 18°C. Below 18°C the rheological
properties decreased with time. In contrast, at pH = 3.0 no changes in G’, G’” or y* occurred
during storage.
4.2.6 Mechanical spectra
The reciprocal of the angular frequency, «», defines the time scale during a dynamic
measurement. The mechanical properties of a material can be qualitatively determined as a
function of time by scanning the frequency. Lopes da Silva and Goncalves (1994) interrupted
the time sweep experiments to perform frequency sweeps (mechanical spectra) on the pectin
sucrose system described above. The purpose was to find a power law dependence for G’ and
G” on the frequency («) with the same exponent (n) as a possible measure of the gel point:
G@)xYou might also like